On the Minimax Bifurcation Formula Journal: Journal of Differential Equations Y. Sh. Il’yasov Abstract We develop a variational minimax method for detecting maximal saddle-node bifurcations in abstract nonlinear equations. Unlike continuation and path-following techniques, the method identifies the critical parameter directly as an extremal value of an extended Rayleigh quotient. We prove an abstract minimax bifurcation principle, establish the existence and characterization of weak saddle-node bifurcation points, and justify finite-dimensional Galerkin approximations. We also obtain perturbation estimates for the bifurcation value. Applications to non-variational systems of nonlinear elliptic equations show that the approach is not restricted to classical variational structures. The resulting framework provides a unified tool for detecting, approximating, and analyzing saddle-node bifurcations. 2020 MSC 35P30; 35J10; 35J60; 65N30 1 Introduction Saddle-node bifurcations, also known as folds or turning points, are among the basic mechanisms by which solution branches of nonlinear equations appear or disappear. In nonlinear differential equations they often mark critical parameter values beyond which no solution exists. Locating such values is therefore a central problem both in analysis and in numerical computation. The standard way to detect saddle-node bifurcations is to continue a branch of solutions and monitor the loss of invertibility of the linearized operator. This is the basis of classical local and global bifurcation theory, including the Crandall–Rabinowitz theorem, Rabinowitz’s global theorem, and the Krasnosel’skiĭ theory, as well as of numerical continuation methods [ 15 , 29 , 31 , 33 , 38 , 36 , 32 ] . These methods are powerful, but they are essentially indirect: the bifurcation point is detected through the behaviour of a solution curve. The aim of this paper is to develop a different approach. We identify maximal weak saddle-node bifurcation points directly, by means of a minimax variational formula. The method does not require one to construct or follow a solution branch. Instead, the critical parameter is characterized as an extremal value of an extended Rayleigh quotient. This provides both an analytical tool for proving the existence of singular solutions and a finite-dimensional scheme suitable for Galerkin and finite-element approximation. Let \mathcal{S}^{o}\subset W be a prescribed cone of admissible functions in a Banach space W . We consider nonlinear equations of the form \mathcal{F}(u,\lambda):=\mathcal{A}(u)-\lambda\mathcal{G}(u)=0,\qquad u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}, (1.1) where \mathcal{A},\mathcal{G}:W\to W^{*} are continuously Fréchet differentiable in an open neighbourhood of \mathcal{S}^{o} . The central object of the paper is the extended Rayleigh quotient [ 21 , 25 ] \mathcal{R}(u,v):=\frac{\langle\mathcal{A}(u),v\rangle}{\langle\mathcal{G}(u),v\rangle},\qquad(u,v)\in\mathcal{S}^{o}\times\mathcal{S}^{o}, (1.2) where \langle\mathcal{G}(u),v\rangle\neq 0 for all (u,v)\in\mathcal{S}^{o}\times\mathcal{S}^{o} . Here \langle\cdot,\cdot\rangle denotes the duality pairing between W^{*} and W . The basic observation is that stationary points of \mathcal{R} encode singular solutions of ( 2.1 ). Indeed, assume that \lambda^{*}=\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v^{*}),\qquad D_{v}\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v^{*})=0,\qquad D_{u}\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v^{*})=0. The first stationarity condition gives \big\langle\mathcal{A}(u^{*})-\lambda^{*}\mathcal{G}(u^{*}),v\big\rangle=0\qquad\forall v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}. Since \mathcal{S}^{o} is assumed to generate W , this implies \mathcal{F}(u^{*},\lambda^{*})=0 in W^{*} . The second stationarity condition yields \big\langle D_{u}\mathcal{F}(u^{*},\lambda^{*})\varphi,v^{*}\big\rangle=0\qquad\forall\varphi\in W. Thus v^{*} is a weak adjoint eigenvector of the linearized operator. In particular, under the usual Fredholm alternative, the linearized operator is singular, and u^{*} is a singular solution of ( 2.1 ). We call (u^{*},\lambda^{*}) a weak saddle-node bifurcation point of ( 2.1 ) if, in addition, there exist \varepsilon>0 and a neighbourhood V of u^{*} in W such that ( 2.1 ) has no solutions in \mathcal{S}^{o}\cap V for \lambda\in(\lambda^{*},\lambda^{*}+\varepsilon) . Our approach to weak saddle-node bifurcation points in \mathcal{S}^{o} is based on the following minimax bifurcation formula: \lambda^{*}:=\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v). (1.3) We call \lambda^{*} the extreme value of ( 2.1 ) in \mathcal{S}^{o} . If \lambda^{*}<+\infty , then ( 2.1 ) has no solutions in \mathcal{S}^{o} for any \lambda>\lambda^{*} . Indeed, if u\in\mathcal{S}^{o} solves ( 2.1 ) for some \lambda , then \mathcal{R}(u,v)=\lambda\qquad\text{for all }v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}, and therefore \lambda=\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v)\leq\sup_{w\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(w,v)=\lambda^{*}. Thus ( 1.3 ) gives a direct variational candidate for the maximal parameter value at which solutions can exist. A pair (u^{*},v^{*})\in\mathcal{S}^{o}\times(\mathcal{S}\setminus\{0\}) is said to realize the minimax bifurcation formula if -\infty<\lambda^{*}<+\infty and \lambda^{*}=\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v^{*})=\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v)=\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v), (1.4) with D_{u}\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v^{*})=0,\qquad D_{v}\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v^{*})=0. (1.5) If, in addition, v^{*}\in\mathcal{S}^{o} , then the infimum in ( 1.4 ) is attained and may be written as a minimum. The main results of the paper show that, under suitable compactness, positivity, and finite-dimensional approximation assumptions, such a minimax solution yields a maximal weak saddle-node bifurcation point of ( 2.1 ). This approach was initiated in [ 20 ] – [ 27 ] and developed in several directions, including applications to nonlinear equations, gradient-type numerical methods, non-variational systems, and eigenvalue perturbation problems [ 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 37 ] . The present paper gives a unified abstract framework for these ideas. Its novel point is the combination of three ingredients: the two-variable extended Rayleigh quotient, the minimax bifurcation formula, and a finite-element approximation principle for detecting singular solutions. The paper focuses on three issues: direct identification of maximal weak saddle-node bifurcation points, convergence of finite-dimensional approximations, and perturbation estimates for the bifurcation value. The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents the abstract minimax theory. Section 3 contains the proofs of the main abstract results. Sections 5 , 6 , and 7 apply the theory to model elliptic problems and perturbation estimates. Section 8 contains concluding remarks. Appendix A describes the functional and finite element spaces, Appendix B establishes differentiability of the relevant functionals, and Appendix C proves the Picone-type identity used in the compactness argument. Throughout the paper, c,C,c_{1},C_{1},\ldots denote positive constants whose values may change from line to line. 2 Minimax bifurcation formula for an abstract problem Let W be a reflexive Banach space and let \mathcal{C}^{0} be an ordered function space continuously embedded into W . Let \mathcal{S}^{o}\subset\mathcal{C}^{0} be the strict part of a convex cone, and set \mathcal{S}:=\overline{\mathcal{S}^{o}}^{\,\mathcal{C}^{0}}. Thus \mathcal{S} is the corresponding closed convex cone in \mathcal{C}^{0} . We assume that \mathcal{S} is weakly sequentially closed in W . We also assume that \mathcal{S}^{o} generates W , that is, \operatorname{span}\bigl(\mathcal{S}^{o}\cup(-\mathcal{S}^{o})\bigr)=W. Whenever the quotient \mathcal{R}(u,v) is evaluated on \mathcal{S} , the zero element is understood to be excluded. In particular, \inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}}\mathcal{R}(u,v)\quad\text{means}\quad\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}\setminus\{0\}}\mathcal{R}(u,v). We consider the abstract equation \mathcal{F}(u,\lambda):=\mathcal{A}(u)-\lambda\mathcal{G}(u)=0,\qquad u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}, (2.1) where \mathcal{A},\mathcal{G}:\mathcal{S}\to W^{*} . We assume that, in a W -neighbourhood of \mathcal{S}^{o} , these maps admit continuously Fréchet differentiable extensions. The associated extended Rayleigh quotient is \mathcal{R}(u,v):=\frac{\langle\mathcal{A}(u),v\rangle}{\langle\mathcal{G}(u),v\rangle},\qquad\langle\mathcal{G}(u),v\rangle\neq 0. (2.2) We impose the following denominator positivity and monotonicity condition . (D) For every (u,v)\in(\mathcal{S}\times\mathcal{S}^{o})\cup(\mathcal{S}^{o}\times\mathcal{S}), with the above convention on the zero element, one has \langle\mathcal{G}(u),v\rangle>0. Moreover, \langle D_{u}\mathcal{G}(u)w,v\rangle\geq 0\qquad u\in\mathcal{S}^{o},\quad v,w\in\mathcal{S}. Here and below, \langle\cdot,\cdot\rangle denotes the duality pairing between W^{*} and W . Condition {\rm(D)} ensures that \mathcal{R} is well defined on (\mathcal{S}\times\mathcal{S}^{o})\cup(\mathcal{S}^{o}\times\mathcal{S}), with the zero element excluded whenever \mathcal{R} is evaluated on \mathcal{S} . For fixed u\in\mathcal{S}^{o} , the map v\mapsto\mathcal{R}(u,v) is weakly continuous on \mathcal{S} ; for fixed v\in\mathcal{S} , the map u\mapsto\mathcal{R}(u,v) is C^{1} on \mathcal{S}^{o} . We study singular and bifurcation points of ( 2.1 ) in \mathcal{S}^{o} through the minimax bifurcation formula \lambda^{*}:=\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v). (2.3) Let \{W_{r}\}_{r=1}^{\infty} be finite-dimensional subspaces of W , with \dim W_{r}=r , and let \mathcal{I}_{r}:\mathcal{C}^{0}\to W_{r} be continuous maps. We first impose Galerkin approximation assumptions on the cone. (P1) For every r\geq 1 , there exists a basis \{\eta_{1},\ldots,\eta_{r}\} of W_{r} such that \mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}:=\mathcal{I}_{r}\mathcal{S}^{o}=\left\{u=\sum_{i=1}^{r}u^{i}\eta_{i}\in W_{r}:u^{i}>0,\ i=1,\ldots,r\right\}. We set \mathcal{S}_{r}:=\overline{\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}^{\,W_{r}} and assume that \mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}\subset\mathcal{S}^{o} , \mathcal{S}_{r}\subset\mathcal{S} . (P2) For every u\in\mathcal{S} , \|\mathcal{I}_{r}u-u\|_{W}\to 0 as r\to\infty . The Galerkin approximation of ( 2.1 ) is \langle\mathcal{F}(u,\lambda),\zeta\rangle=0\qquad\forall\zeta\in W_{r},\quad u\in W_{r}. (2.4) For r=1,2,\ldots , define \lambda_{r}^{*}:=\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v). (2.5) For every r\geq 1 , set \lambda_{r}(u):=\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v),\qquad u\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}. We next impose structural assumptions on the Galerkin minimax problems associated with equation ( 2.1 ). (H1) For every r\geq 1 , \sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}\lambda_{r}(u)>0. Moreover, for every \varepsilon>0 , the set K_{r,\varepsilon}:=\{u\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}:\lambda_{r}(u)\geq\varepsilon\} is relatively compact in \mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} . (H2) For every r\geq 1 , if u\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} , v\in\mathcal{S}_{r} , and D_{u}\langle\mathcal{A}(u),v\rangle(\psi)\geq 0\qquad\forall\psi\in\mathcal{S}_{r}, then v\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} . Remark 2.1 . By {\rm(D)} , for every fixed v\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} , the map u\mapsto\mathcal{R}(u,v) is continuous on \mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} . Hence \lambda_{r}(\cdot) , as the infimum of continuous functions, is upper semicontinuous. Therefore {\rm(H1)} implies that \lambda_{r}(\cdot) attains its positive maximum in \mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} . Definition 2.1 . The extended Rayleigh quotient \mathcal{R} is said to satisfy the (PS)_{e} -condition at level \lambda\in\mathbb{R} if every sequence (u_{n},v_{n})\in\mathcal{S}_{n}^{o}\times\mathcal{S}_{n}^{o} such that \begin{cases}\mathcal{R}(u_{n},v_{n})\to\lambda,\\ D_{u}\mathcal{R}(u_{n},v_{n})(\xi)=0,\qquad\forall\xi\in W_{n},\\ D_{v}\mathcal{R}(u_{n},v_{n})(\zeta)=0,\qquad\forall\zeta\in W_{n},\end{cases} (2.6) has a subsequence and positive numbers t_{n}>0 such that, after replacing v_{n} by t_{n}v_{n} , still denoted by v_{n} , one has u_{n}\to\bar{u}\quad\text{strongly in }W,\qquad v_{n}\rightharpoonup\bar{v}\quad\text{weakly in }W, with \bar{u}\in\mathcal{S}^{o} and \bar{v}\in\mathcal{S}\setminus\{0\} . Such a sequence is called a (PS)_{e} -sequence. This rescaling in the second component is natural, since \mathcal{R} is homogeneous with respect to v . In our first main result, we obtain singular solutions of ( 2.1 ) as limits of finite-dimensional maximal weak saddle-node bifurcation points. Theorem 2.1 . Assume that the denominator positivity and monotonicity condition {\rm(D)} , the Galerkin cone realization assumption {\rm(P1)} , and the structural assumptions on the Galerkin minimax problems {\rm(H1)} – {\rm(H2)} hold. Suppose also that 0<\lambda_{r}^{*}<+\infty for all r\geq 1 . (1^{\circ}) For every r\geq 1 , there exist u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*}\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} such that \lambda_{r}^{*}=\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*})=\min_{v\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v)=\max_{u\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}\min_{v\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v). (2.7) Moreover, \langle\mathcal{F}(u_{r}^{*},\lambda_{r}^{*}),\zeta\rangle=0\quad\forall\zeta\in W_{r},\qquad\bigl\langle D_{u}\mathcal{F}(u_{r}^{*},\lambda_{r}^{*})\xi,v_{r}^{*}\bigr\rangle=0\quad\forall\xi\in W_{r}. Thus (u_{r}^{*},\lambda_{r}^{*}) is a finite-dimensional weak singular point; in the terminology of this paper, it is a maximal weak saddle-node bifurcation point of the Galerkin problem. (2^{\circ}) Assume, in addition, that the approximation assumption {\rm(P2)} holds, and that there exist 00 such that 0<\varepsilon<\lambda_{r}^{*} . Then, for all large n , u_{n}\in K_{r,\varepsilon} . By {\rm(H1)} , after passing to a subsequence, u_{n}\to u_{r}^{*} in W_{r} , with u_{r}^{*}\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} . The upper semicontinuity of \lambda_{r} gives \lambda_{r}^{*}=\lambda_{r}(u_{r}^{*})=\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v). By {\rm(P1)} , if \{\eta_{1},\ldots,\eta_{r}\} is the positive basis of \mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} , then \mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}=\left\{v=\sum_{i=1}^{r}v^{i}\eta_{i}:\ v^{i}>0\right\}. Since \mathcal{R}(u,\cdot) is homogeneous of degree zero and the denominator is positive, it is easy to see that \inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v)=\min_{1\leq i\leq r}\mathcal{R}(u,\eta_{i}). Thus (u_{r}^{*},\lambda_{r}^{*}) maximizes \lambda under the inequalities \mathcal{R}(u,\eta_{i})-\lambda\geq 0 , i=1,\ldots,r . Since u_{r}^{*} is an interior point of \mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} , the Fritz John multiplier rule yields numbers \mu_{i}\geq 0 , i=1,\ldots,r , with \sum_{i=1}^{r}\mu_{i}=1 , such that \sum_{i=1}^{r}\mu_{i}D_{u}\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},\eta_{i})=0,\qquad\mu_{i}\bigl(\lambda_{r}^{*}-\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},\eta_{i})\bigr)=0. For active indices, \mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},\eta_{i})=\lambda_{r}^{*} . Define \kappa_{i}:=\frac{\mu_{i}}{\langle\mathcal{G}(u_{r}^{*}),\eta_{i}\rangle},\qquad v_{r}^{*}:=\sum_{i=1}^{r}\kappa_{i}\eta_{i}. Then v_{r}^{*}\in\mathcal{S}_{r}\setminus\{0\} , and the complementarity relations immediately give \mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*})=\lambda_{r}^{*},\qquad\bigl\langle D_{u}\mathcal{F}(u_{r}^{*},\lambda_{r}^{*})\xi,v_{r}^{*}\bigr\rangle=0\quad\forall\xi\in W_{r}. It remains only to see that v_{r}^{*} actually belongs to \mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} . From the last identity we have, for every \psi\in W_{r} , D_{u}\langle\mathcal{A}(u_{r}^{*}),v_{r}^{*}\rangle(\psi)=\lambda_{r}^{*}D_{u}\langle\mathcal{G}(u_{r}^{*}),v_{r}^{*}\rangle(\psi). Since \lambda_{r}^{*}>0 , condition {\rm(D)} implies that the right-hand side is nonnegative for every \psi\in\mathcal{S}_{r} . Hence {\rm(H2)} gives v_{r}^{*}\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} . Thus v_{r}^{*} is an interior minimizer of v\mapsto\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v) , and therefore D_{v}\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*})=0 on W_{r} . Equivalently, \langle\mathcal{F}(u_{r}^{*},\lambda_{r}^{*}),\zeta\rangle=0\quad\forall\zeta\in W_{r}. Together with the adjoint relation above, this proves (1^{\circ}) . Proof of (2^{\circ}) . By (1^{\circ}) , for every r\geq M there exist u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*}\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} satisfying \mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*})=\lambda_{r}^{*},\qquad D_{u}\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*})=0,\quad D_{v}\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*})=0\quad\text{on }W_{r}. Since \lambda_{r}^{*}\in(a,b) , passing to a subsequence if necessary, we have \lambda_{r}^{*}\to\hat{\lambda}^{*}\in[a,b] . Hence (u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*}) is a (PS)_{e} -sequence at level \hat{\lambda}^{*} . By the (PS)_{e} -condition, after passing to a further subsequence and, if needed, after a positive rescaling of v_{r}^{*} , we obtain u_{r}^{*}\to u^{*}\quad\text{strongly in }W,\qquad v_{r}^{*}\rightharpoonup v^{*}\quad\text{weakly in }W, where u^{*}\in\mathcal{S}^{o} and v^{*}\in\mathcal{S}\setminus\{0\} . We now pass to the limit in the Galerkin equations. Let \zeta\in\mathcal{S} . By {\rm(P2)} , \mathcal{I}_{r}\zeta\to\zeta in W , and \mathcal{I}_{r}\zeta\in W_{r} . Therefore 0=\langle\mathcal{F}(u_{r}^{*},\lambda_{r}^{*}),\mathcal{I}_{r}\zeta\rangle\to\langle\mathcal{F}(u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*}),\zeta\rangle. Since \mathcal{S}^{o} generates W , this identity extends by linearity to all \zeta\in W . Hence \mathcal{F}(u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*})=0\quad\text{in }W^{*}. The adjoint singularity relation is obtained in the same way. For \xi\in\mathcal{S} , using \mathcal{I}_{r}\xi\in W_{r} , we have 0=\bigl\langle D_{u}\mathcal{F}(u_{r}^{*},\lambda_{r}^{*})\mathcal{I}_{r}\xi,v_{r}^{*}\bigr\rangle. Since \mathcal{I}_{r}\xi\to\xi strongly in W , u_{r}^{*}\to u^{*} strongly, \lambda_{r}^{*}\to\hat{\lambda}^{*} , and v_{r}^{*}\rightharpoonup v^{*} weakly, we get \bigl\langle D_{u}\mathcal{F}(u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*})\xi,v^{*}\bigr\rangle=0. Again, by the generating property of \mathcal{S}^{o} , this holds for all \xi\in W . Thus (u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*}) is a weak singular solution of ( 2.1 ). It remains to compare \hat{\lambda}^{*} with \lambda^{*} . For any v\in\mathcal{S}^{o} , since \mathcal{I}_{r}v\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} , we have \lambda_{r}^{*}=\min_{\eta\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},\eta)\leq\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},\mathcal{I}_{r}v). Passing to the limit gives \hat{\lambda}^{*}\leq\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v) . Taking the infimum over v\in\mathcal{S}^{o} , and then using the definition of \lambda^{*} , we obtain \hat{\lambda}^{*}\leq\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v)\leq\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v)=\lambda^{*}. The proof is complete. ∎ 3.1 Proof of Theorem 2.2 Proof of Theorem 2.2 . We first prove the convergence of the minimax levels. Since \mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}\subset\mathcal{S}^{o} and \mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}=\mathcal{I}_{r}\mathcal{S}^{o} , we have \lambda_{r}^{*}=\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v)\geq\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(\mathcal{I}_{r}u,v). By {\rm(U)} , for each fixed u\in\mathcal{S}^{o} , \inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(\mathcal{I}_{r}u,v)\to\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v), because the difference of these two infima is bounded by \sup_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\left|\mathcal{R}(\mathcal{I}_{r}u,v)-\mathcal{R}(u,v)\right|. It follows that \liminf_{r\to\infty}\lambda_{r}^{*}\geq\lambda^{*} . We now prove the reverse inequality. Let (\lambda_{r_{k}}^{*}) be an arbitrary convergent subsequence. Since \lambda_{r}^{*}\in(a,b) for all r\geq M , its limit belongs to [a,b] . Applying Theorem 2.1 along this subsequence, we obtain, after passing to a further subsequence and allowing the admissible positive rescaling in the second component, \lambda_{r_{k}}^{*}\to\hat{\lambda}^{*}\in[a,b],\qquad u_{r_{k}}^{*}\to\hat{u}\quad\text{strongly in }W,\qquad v_{r_{k}}^{*}\rightharpoonup\hat{v}\quad\text{weakly in }W, where \hat{u}\in\mathcal{S}^{o} and \hat{v}\in\mathcal{S}\setminus\{0\} . Moreover, \mathcal{F}(\hat{u},\hat{\lambda}^{*})=0 in W^{*} , \bigl\langle D_{u}\mathcal{F}(\hat{u},\hat{\lambda}^{*})\xi,\hat{v}\bigr\rangle=0\qquad\forall\xi\in W, and Theorem 2.1 also gives \hat{\lambda}^{*}\leq\lambda^{*} . Hence every subsequential limit of (\lambda_{r}^{*}) is not larger than \lambda^{*} , and therefore \limsup_{r\to\infty}\lambda_{r}^{*}\leq\lambda^{*} . Thus \lambda_{r}^{*}\to\lambda^{*}. Applying Theorem 2.1 once more, now using the convergence \lambda_{r}^{*}\to\lambda^{*} , we obtain a subsequence, still denoted by r , and elements u^{*}\in\mathcal{S}^{o} , v^{*}\in\mathcal{S}\setminus\{0\} , such that, up to a positive rescaling of v_{r}^{*} , u_{r}^{*}\to u^{*}\quad\text{strongly in }W,\qquad v_{r}^{*}\rightharpoonup v^{*}\quad\text{weakly in }W. Moreover, \mathcal{F}(u^{*},\lambda^{*})=0\quad\text{in }W^{*},\qquad\bigl\langle D_{u}\mathcal{F}(u^{*},\lambda^{*})\xi,v^{*}\bigr\rangle=0\quad\forall\xi\in W. Thus (u^{*},\lambda^{*}) is a weak singular solution of ( 2.1 ). It remains to prove the minimax identity. By Theorem 2.1 , \lambda_{r}^{*}=\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*})=\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v). Since u_{r}^{*}\to u^{*} strongly in W , v_{r}^{*}\rightharpoonup v^{*} weakly in W , and \mathcal{A},\mathcal{G} are continuous as maps into W^{*} , we obtain \mathcal{R}(u^{*},v^{*})=\lim_{r\to\infty}\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*})=\lambda^{*}. Here the denominator remains positive by {\rm(D)} . Let v\in\mathcal{S}^{o} . Since \mathcal{I}_{r}v\in\mathcal{S}_{r}^{o} , we have \lambda_{r}^{*}\leq\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},\mathcal{I}_{r}v) . Passing to the limit and using {\rm(P2)} , together with u_{r}^{*}\to u^{*} , gives \lambda^{*}\leq\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v). As v\in\mathcal{S}^{o} is arbitrary, we get \lambda^{*}\leq\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v). Conversely, since v^{*}\in\mathcal{S}\setminus\{0\} and \mathcal{S}=\overline{\mathcal{S}^{o}}^{\,\mathcal{C}^{0}} , we can choose (v_{n})\subset\mathcal{S}^{o} such that v_{n}\to v^{*} in \mathcal{C}^{0} , hence also in W . By the continuity of v\mapsto\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v) , \mathcal{R}(u^{*},v_{n})\to\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v^{*})=\lambda^{*} , and therefore \inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v)\leq\lambda^{*}. Combining the two inequalities, we obtain \lambda^{*}=\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v^{*})=\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v)=\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v). Finally, let (u,\lambda)\in\mathcal{S}^{o}\times\mathbb{R} be any weak solution of ( 2.1 ). Then \langle\mathcal{A}(u),v\rangle=\lambda\langle\mathcal{G}(u),v\rangle for all v\in\mathcal{S}^{o} . By {\rm(D)} , this gives \mathcal{R}(u,v)=\lambda for all v\in\mathcal{S}^{o} , and hence \lambda=\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v)\leq\sup_{w\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(w,v)=\lambda^{*}. Thus no weak solution of ( 2.1 ) in \mathcal{S}^{o} has parameter larger than \lambda^{*} . Since (u^{*},\lambda^{*}) is itself a weak singular solution, it is a maximal weak saddle-node bifurcation point of ( 2.1 ) in \mathcal{S}^{o} . ∎ 4 Existence of singular solutions for a system of elliptic equations We consider the system \left\{\begin{aligned} \mathcal{L}^{k}u^{k}-f^{k}(x,u)&=\lambda g^{k}(x,u),&&x\in\Omega,\\ u^{k}&\geq 0,&&x\in\Omega,\\ u^{k}|_{\partial\Omega}&=0,&&k=1,\ldots,m.\end{aligned}\right. (4.1) Here \Omega\subset\mathbb{R}^{d} , d\geq 1 , is a polyhedron, u=(u^{1},\ldots,u^{m}) , and \mathcal{L}^{k}u^{k}=-\frac{\partial}{\partial x_{i}}\left(\sigma_{ij}^{k}(x)\frac{\partial u^{k}}{\partial x_{j}}\right)+c^{k}(x)u^{k},\qquad k=1,\ldots,m, where repeated indices i,j are summed from 1 to d . We assume that \sigma_{ij}^{k},c^{k}\in C(\overline{\Omega}) and that each \mathcal{L}^{k} satisfies the ellipticity condition ( 9.2 ). We write \mathbb{W}:=(W_{2})^{m} , \mathbb{L}^{p}:=(L^{p})^{m} , and use the notation \mathcal{L}:=(\mathcal{L}^{1},\ldots,\mathcal{L}^{m})^{T},\qquad f(u):=(f^{1}(\cdot,u),\ldots,f^{m}(\cdot,u))^{T},\qquad g(u):=(g^{1}(\cdot,u),\ldots,g^{m}(\cdot,u))^{T}. Furthermore, a_{m}(u,v):=\sum_{k=1}^{m}a^{k}(u^{k},v^{k}),\qquad a^{k}(u^{k},v^{k}):=\langle\mathcal{L}^{k}u^{k},v^{k}\rangle, and \mathcal{F}(u,\lambda):=\mathcal{L}u-f(u)-\lambda g(u). For t=(t^{1},\ldots,t^{m})\in\mathbb{R}_{+}^{m} , we impose the following assumptions. {\rm(h_{1})} There exist a_{k}\in L^{\infty}(\Omega) , a_{0},a_{1}>0 , and 00 for t\in(0,+\infty)^{m} . Moreover, for some C>0 and 1<\gamma_{0}\leq\gamma<2^{*}-1 , 0\leq f^{k}(x,t)\leq C\bigl(|t|^{\gamma_{0}}+|t|^{\gamma}\bigr),\qquad\left|\frac{\partial f^{k}}{\partial t^{l}}(x,t)\right|\leq C\bigl(|t|^{\gamma_{0}-1}+|t|^{\gamma-1}\bigr). {\rm(h_{3})} The system is cooperative: \frac{\partial f^{k}}{\partial t^{l}}(x,t)\geq 0,\qquad k,l=1,\ldots,m,\qquad t\in(0,+\infty)^{m}. {\rm(h_{4})} There exists \theta>1 , with 1<\theta<\gamma_{0} , such that t^{k}\frac{\partial f^{k}}{\partial t^{k}}(x,t)\geq\theta f^{k}(x,t),\qquad k=1,\ldots,m. {\rm(h_{5})} The reaction terms are degenerate on the boundary of the positive cone: if t^{j}=0 for at least one j , then f^{k}(x,t)=0,\qquad\frac{\partial f^{k}}{\partial t^{l}}(x,t)=0,\qquad k,l=1,\ldots,m. A model example is g^{k}(x,t)=a_{k}(x)(t^{k})^{q},\qquad f^{k}(x,t)=b_{k}(x)\prod_{j=1}^{m}(t^{j})^{\alpha_{kj}}, where 01 , and \sum_{j=1}^{m}\alpha_{kj}<2^{*}-1. Then {\rm(h_{1})} – {\rm(h_{5})} hold, with any 1<\theta<\min_{1\leq k\leq m}\alpha_{kk}. We work in the cone \mathbb{S}^{o}:=(S^{o})^{m}\subset\mathbb{W} , where S^{o} is defined in Appendix A. Let \{\mathcal{T}_{r}\} be a shape-regular family of meshes satisfying the discrete maximum principle, and let W_{r} be the corresponding finite-element space with nodal basis \{\psi_{i}\}_{i=1}^{r} . We set \mathbb{W}_{r}:=W_{r}^{m},\qquad\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}:=(S_{r}^{o})^{m}. The component stiffness matrices A_{r}^{k}=(a_{ij}^{k}),\qquad a_{ij}^{k}=\langle\mathcal{L}^{k}\psi_{i},\psi_{j}\rangle, are M -matrices and hence satisfy the discrete maximum-principle implication ( 9.4 ). We define the extended Rayleigh quotient \mathcal{R}(u,v):=\frac{a_{m}(u,v)-\langle f(u),v\rangle_{m}}{\langle g(u),v\rangle_{m}},\qquad(u,v)\in(\mathbb{S}\times\mathbb{S}^{o})\cup(\mathbb{S}^{o}\times\mathbb{S}). (4.2) By {\rm(h_{1})} , the denominator in ( 5.2 ) is strictly positive on this set. Moreover, \bigl\langle D_{u}g(u)w,v\bigr\rangle_{m}=\sum_{k=1}^{m}\int_{\Omega}qa_{k}(x)(u^{k})^{q-1}w^{k}v^{k}\,dx\geq 0 for u\in\mathbb{S}^{o} and v,w\in\mathbb{S} . Thus the denominator positivity and monotonicity condition {\rm(D)} holds in the required weak form. We shall also use the following elementary continuity fact. If u_{n}\to u strongly in \mathbb{W} , then \mathcal{L}u_{n}\to\mathcal{L}u strongly in \mathbb{W}^{*} . By the Sobolev embedding and the subcritical growth in {\rm(h_{2})} , f(u_{n})\to f(u) strongly in \mathbb{L}^{(2^{*})^{\prime}} , hence in \mathbb{W}^{*} . Similarly, {\rm(h_{1})} and 0\lambda^{*} . Theorem 4.4 . Assume that {\rm(h_{1})} – {\rm(h_{5})} hold. Suppose also that the finite-element meshes satisfy the discrete maximum principle ( 9.4 ) for each component operator \mathcal{L}^{k} , and that, for some \mu>0 and M\geq 1 , \mu^{-1}<\lambda_{r}^{*}<\mu\qquad\text{for all }r\geq M. Then the following assertions hold. (1^{\circ}) For every r\geq 1 , the finite-dimensional Galerkin problem admits a maximal weak saddle-node bifurcation point (u_{r}^{*},\lambda_{r}^{*})\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}\times(0,+\infty) . Moreover, there exists v_{r}^{*}\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} such that \lambda_{r}^{*}=\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*})=\min_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v)=\max_{u\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\min_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v). (2^{\circ}) There exist a subsequence, not relabelled, a number \hat{\lambda}^{*}\in[\mu^{-1},\mu] , and elements u^{*}\in\mathbb{S}^{o} , v^{*}\in\mathbb{S}\setminus\{0\} , such that, up to a possible positive rescaling of v_{r}^{*} , \lambda_{r}^{*}\to\hat{\lambda}^{*},\qquad u_{r}^{*}\to u^{*}\quad\text{strongly in }\mathbb{W},\qquad v_{r}^{*}\rightharpoonup v^{*}\quad\text{weakly in }\mathbb{W}. Furthermore, \mathcal{F}(u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*})=0\quad\text{in }\mathbb{W}^{*},\qquad\bigl\langle D_{u}\mathcal{F}(u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*})\xi,v^{*}\bigr\rangle=0\quad\forall\xi\in\mathbb{W}. Thus (u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*}) is a weak singular solution of ( 5.1 ). Remark 4.1 . The assumptions {\rm(h_{1})} – {\rm(h_{5})} are chosen so that Theorem 2.1 applies. The diagonal sublinear form of g gives the positive concave parameter term and the denominator monotonicity. The positivity and superlinearity of f give the saddle-node geometry {\rm(H1)} . The cooperativity condition {\rm(h_{3})} , together with the discrete maximum principle, gives the boundary-exclusion condition {\rm(H2)} . Finally, {\rm(h_{5})} is used in the Picone-type compactness argument verifying the normalized (PS)_{e} -condition. 4.1 Verification of the abstract assumptions Lemma 4.1 . Assume {\rm(h_{1})} – {\rm(h_{3})} . Then 0<\lambda_{r}^{*}<+\infty for every r\geq 1 . Moreover, under the standard uniform spectral bounds for the discrete operators A_{r}^{k} , there exists \mu>0 , independent of r , such that \mu^{-1}<\lambda_{r}^{*}<\mu,\qquad r=1,2,\ldots. Proof. The upper bound is obtained by testing the inner infimum at \phi_{1,r}:=(\phi_{1,r}^{1},\ldots,\phi_{1,r}^{m})\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} , where \phi_{1,r}^{k} is the positive first eigenvector of A_{r}^{k} . The uniform bounds for the first eigenvalues, together with the growth assumptions on f and 00 and v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} , \mathcal{R}(t\omega_{r},v)\geq\frac{ct-C(t^{\gamma_{0}}+t^{\gamma})}{Ct^{q}}. Choosing t=t_{0}>0 sufficiently small gives \inf_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(t_{0}\omega_{r},v)\geq c_{0}>0 , and hence \lambda_{r}^{*}\geq c_{0} . The proof is complete. ∎ Lemma 4.2 . Assume {\rm(h_{1})} – {\rm(h_{5})} . Then the extended Rayleigh quotient \mathcal{R} satisfies {\rm(H1)} and {\rm(H2)} on the finite-dimensional cones \mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} . Proof. We first verify {\rm(H1)} . Let u_{n}\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} , t_{n}:=\|u_{n}\|_{\mathbb{W}_{r}} , and w_{n}:=u_{n}/t_{n} . If t_{n}\to+\infty , then the superlinear term f dominates the linear elliptic part, while the denominator has order t_{n}^{q} . Hence, for every fixed v_{0}\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} , one has \mathcal{R}(t_{n}w_{n},v_{0})\to-\infty , and therefore \inf_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u_{n},v)\to-\infty . If t_{n}\to 0 , then the numerator is O(t_{n})+o(t_{n}) , whereas the denominator has order t_{n}^{q} , with q<1 . Thus \inf_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u_{n},v)\leq o(1) . This proves the compactness part of {\rm(H1)} , while positivity of the supremum follows from Lemma 4.1 . We now prove {\rm(H2)} . Let u,v\in\mathbb{S}_{r} and assume that D_{u}\langle\mathcal{A}(u),v\rangle(\bar{\psi}_{i})\geq 0 for all nodal basis vectors \bar{\psi}_{i} , i=1,\ldots,rm . Since D_{u}\langle\mathcal{A}(u),v\rangle(\bar{\psi}_{i})=a_{m}(\bar{\psi}_{i},v)-\langle f_{u}(u)\bar{\psi}_{i},v\rangle_{m} and f_{u}(u)\geq 0 by {\rm(h_{3})} , we get a^{k}(\psi_{i},v^{k})\geq 0 for all i=1,\ldots,r and k=1,\ldots,m . Equivalently, (A_{r}^{k})^{T}\bar{v}^{k}\geq 0 . Since A_{r}^{k} is an irreducible nonsingular M -matrix, so is (A_{r}^{k})^{T} . Therefore \bar{v}^{k}>0 for every k , and hence v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} . Thus {\rm(H2)} holds. ∎ Lemma 4.3 . Assume {\rm(h_{1})} – {\rm(h_{5})} . Then \mathcal{R} satisfies the normalized (PS)_{e} -condition on \mathbb{S}^{o}\times\mathbb{S}^{o} at every level \lambda>0 . Proof. Let (u_{n},v_{n})\in\mathbb{S}_{n}^{o}\times\mathbb{S}_{n}^{o} be a normalized (PS)_{e} -sequence, that is, \lambda_{n}:=\mathcal{R}(u_{n},v_{n})\to\lambda>0 and a_{m}(v_{n},v_{n})=1 . The relation D_{v}\mathcal{R}(u_{n},v_{n})=0 gives the Galerkin equation \mathcal{F}_{n}(u_{n},\lambda_{n})=0 . Testing it by u_{n} , we obtain a_{m}(u_{n},u_{n})=\lambda_{n}\langle g(u_{n}),u_{n}\rangle_{m}+\langle f(u_{n}),u_{n}\rangle_{m}. On the other hand, testing D_{u}\mathcal{R}(u_{n},v_{n})=0 componentwise by (u_{n}^{k})^{2}/v_{n}^{k} and using the discrete Picone inequality from Appendix 11 , we get a_{m}(u_{n},u_{n})\geq\lambda_{n}\left\langle g_{u}(u_{n})v_{n},\frac{u_{n}^{2}}{v_{n}}\right\rangle_{m}+\left\langle f_{u}(u_{n})v_{n},\frac{u_{n}^{2}}{v_{n}}\right\rangle_{m}. By {\rm(h_{1})} and {\rm(h_{4})} , the two terms on the right-hand side are bounded below by q\lambda_{n}\langle g(u_{n}),u_{n}\rangle_{m} and \theta\langle f(u_{n}),u_{n}\rangle_{m} , respectively. Comparing with the previous identity yields (\theta-1)a_{m}(u_{n},u_{n})\leq(\theta-q)\lambda_{n}\langle g(u_{n}),u_{n}\rangle_{m}. Since q+1<2 , the Sobolev inequality gives \|u_{n}\|_{\mathbb{W}}\leq C . Hence, up to a subsequence, u_{n}\rightharpoonup\bar{u} in \mathbb{W} and u_{n}\to\bar{u} in \mathbb{L}^{\beta} , 1\leq\beta<2^{*} . The normalization of v_{n} similarly gives v_{n}\rightharpoonup\bar{v} in \mathbb{W} and v_{n}\to\bar{v} in \mathbb{L}^{\beta} , 1\leq\beta<2^{*} . Passing to the limit in the Galerkin equations gives \mathcal{F}(\bar{u},\lambda)=0 . By the maximum principle and Hopf’s boundary lemma, \bar{u}\in\mathbb{S}^{o} . It remains to exclude \bar{v}=0 . Testing the adjoint linearized equation by v_{n} , testing the equation for u_{n} by v_{n}^{2}/u_{n} , and using Picone’s identity, one obtains, for every \chi\in(q,1) , 1-\chi\leq\left\langle f_{u}(u_{n})v_{n},v_{n}\right\rangle_{m}-\chi\left\langle f(u_{n}),\frac{v_{n}^{2}}{u_{n}}\right\rangle_{m}. If \bar{v}=0 , then the right-hand side tends to 0 , by {\rm(h_{5})} and the strong convergence in \mathbb{L}^{\beta} , which is impossible since 1-\chi>0 . Thus \bar{v}\in\mathbb{S}\setminus\{0\} . Finally, the energy identity and the strong convergence of the nonlinear terms imply a_{m}(u_{n},u_{n})\to a_{m}(\bar{u},\bar{u}) . By coercivity, u_{n}\to\bar{u} strongly in \mathbb{W} . Passing to the limit in the adjoint linearized relation gives \bigl\langle D_{u}\mathcal{F}(\bar{u},\lambda)\xi,\bar{v}\bigr\rangle=0\qquad\forall\xi\in\mathbb{W}. The normalized (PS)_{e} -condition is proved. ∎ Proof of Theorem 5.5 . By Lemma 4.1 , 0<\lambda_{r}^{*}<+\infty for all r , and \mu^{-1}<\lambda_{r}^{*}<\mu for all sufficiently large r . By Lemma 4.2 , the quotient \mathcal{R} satisfies {\rm(H1)} and {\rm(H2)} on the finite-dimensional cones. By Lemma 9.1 , these cones satisfy the Galerkin approximation assumptions. Finally, Lemma 4.3 gives the normalized (PS)_{e} -condition at every positive level. Theorem 2.1 therefore applies. Hence, for each r , there exist u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*}\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} such that \lambda_{r}^{*}=\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*})=\min_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v)=\max_{u\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\min_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v). Moreover, after passing to a subsequence and allowing the admissible positive rescaling of v_{r}^{*} , we have \lambda_{r}^{*}\to\hat{\lambda}^{*}\in[\mu^{-1},\mu] , u_{r}^{*}\to u^{*} strongly in \mathbb{W} , and v_{r}^{*}\rightharpoonup v^{*} weakly in \mathbb{W} , where u^{*}\in\mathbb{S}^{o} and v^{*}\in\mathbb{S}\setminus\{0\} . Passing to the limit in the Galerkin singularity relations gives \mathcal{F}(u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*})=0\quad\text{in }\mathbb{W}^{*},\qquad\bigl\langle D_{u}\mathcal{F}(u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*})\xi,v^{*}\bigr\rangle=0\quad\forall\xi\in\mathbb{W}. Thus (u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*}) is a weak singular solution of ( 5.1 ). ∎ 5 Existence of singular solutions for elliptic systems We consider the system \left\{\begin{aligned} \mathcal{L}^{k}u^{k}-f^{k}(x,u)&=\lambda g^{k}(x,u),&&x\in\Omega,\\ u^{k}&\geq 0,&&x\in\Omega,\\ u^{k}|_{\partial\Omega}&=0,&&k=1,\ldots,m,\end{aligned}\right. (5.1) where \Omega\subset\mathbb{R}^{d} , d\geq 1 , is a polyhedron and \mathcal{L}^{k}u^{k}=-\frac{\partial}{\partial x_{i}}\left(\sigma_{ij}^{k}(x)\frac{\partial u^{k}}{\partial x_{j}}\right)+c^{k}(x)u^{k}. Here and below, repeated indices i,j are summed from 1 to d . We assume that \sigma_{ij}^{k},c^{k}\in C(\overline{\Omega}) and that the coefficients satisfy the ellipticity condition ( 9.2 ). We write u=(u^{1},\ldots,u^{m}),\qquad\mathcal{L}=(\mathcal{L}^{1},\ldots,\mathcal{L}^{m})^{T}, f(u)=(f^{1}(\cdot,u),\ldots,f^{m}(\cdot,u))^{T},\qquad g(u)=(g^{1}(\cdot,u),\ldots,g^{m}(\cdot,u))^{T}, and \mathcal{F}(u,\lambda)=\mathcal{L}u-f(u)-\lambda g(u). Let \mathbb{W}:=(W_{2})^{m},\qquad\mathbb{L}^{p}:=(L^{p})^{m}, and define a_{m}(u,v):=\sum_{k=1}^{m}a^{k}(u^{k},v^{k}),\qquad a^{k}(u^{k},v^{k}):=\langle\mathcal{L}^{k}u^{k},v^{k}\rangle, \langle u,v\rangle_{m}:=\sum_{k=1}^{m}\langle u^{k},v^{k}\rangle. The positive cone is denoted by \mathbb{S}^{o}:=(S^{o})^{m}, where S^{o} is defined in Appendix A. For t=(t^{1},\ldots,t^{m})\in\mathbb{R}_{+}^{m} , we impose the following assumptions. {\rm(h_{1})} The parameter term is diagonal and sublinear: g^{k}(x,t)=a_{k}(x)(t^{k})^{q},\qquad 00\quad\text{for }t\in(0,\infty)^{m}, and there exist constants C>0 and 1<\gamma_{0}\leq\gamma<2^{*}-1 such that 0\leq f^{k}(x,t)\leq C\bigl(|t|^{\gamma_{0}}+|t|^{\gamma}\bigr), and 0\leq\frac{\partial f^{k}}{\partial t^{l}}(x,t)\leq C\bigl(|t|^{\gamma_{0}-1}+|t|^{\gamma-1}\bigr),\qquad l=1,\ldots,m. {\rm(h_{3})} The system is cooperative: \frac{\partial f^{k}}{\partial t^{l}}(x,t)\geq 0,\qquad k,l=1,\ldots,m. {\rm(h_{4})} There exists \theta>1 , 1<\theta<\gamma_{0} , such that t^{k}\frac{\partial f^{k}}{\partial t^{k}}(x,t)\geq\theta f^{k}(x,t),\qquad k=1,\ldots,m. {\rm(h_{5})} The nonlinearities are degenerate on the boundary of the positive cone: if t^{j}=0 for at least one j , then f^{k}(x,t)=0,\qquad\frac{\partial f^{k}}{\partial t^{l}}(x,t)=0,\qquad k,l=1,\ldots,m, where the derivatives are understood as their continuous extensions to the boundary whenever needed. Example 1 . A typical class satisfying {\rm(h_{1})} – {\rm(h_{5})} is g^{k}(x,t)=a_{k}(x)(t^{k})^{q},\qquad 01,\qquad\sum_{j=1}^{m}\alpha_{kj}<2^{*}-1. Then f^{k} is cooperative and vanishes, together with its first derivatives, on the boundary of \mathbb{R}_{+}^{m} . Moreover, t^{k}\frac{\partial f^{k}}{\partial t^{k}}=\alpha_{kk}f^{k}, so {\rm(h_{4})} holds with any 1<\theta<\min_{1\leq k\leq m}\alpha_{kk}. One may take \gamma_{0}=\min_{1\leq k\leq m}\sum_{j=1}^{m}\alpha_{kj},\qquad\gamma=\max_{1\leq k\leq m}\sum_{j=1}^{m}\alpha_{kj}. Let \{\mathcal{T}_{r}\}_{r\geq 1} be a shape-regular family of meshes satisfying the discrete maximum principle, and let \{\psi_{i}\}_{i=1}^{r} be the corresponding nodal basis of W_{r} . For k=1,\ldots,m , let A_{r}^{k} be the stiffness matrix (A_{r}^{k})_{ij}=\langle\mathcal{L}^{k}\psi_{i},\psi_{j}\rangle. By Appendix A, A_{r}^{k} is an M -matrix and satisfies ( 9.4 ). We set \mathbb{W}_{r}:=W_{r}^{m},\qquad\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}:=(S_{r}^{o})^{m}. Equivalently, \mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}=\left\{u=\sum_{i=1}^{rm}u^{i}\bar{\psi}_{i}\in\mathbb{W}_{r}:u^{i}>0,\ i=1,\ldots,rm\right\}\subset\mathbb{S}^{o}, where \{\bar{\psi}_{i}\}_{i=1}^{rm} is the natural componentwise nodal basis of \mathbb{W}_{r} . We also put \mathbb{S}_{r}:=\overline{\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}^{\,\mathbb{W}_{r}}\setminus\{0\}\subset\mathbb{S}. We define the extended Rayleigh quotient \mathcal{R}(u,v):=\frac{a_{m}(u,v)-\langle f(u),v\rangle_{m}}{\langle g(u),v\rangle_{m}},\qquad(u,v)\in(\mathbb{S}\times\mathbb{S}^{o})\cup(\mathbb{S}^{o}\times\mathbb{S}). (5.2) By {\rm(h_{1})} , the denominator is strictly positive on this set. Moreover, by {\rm(h_{2})} and Proposition 10.1 in Appendix B, the quotient \mathcal{R} satisfies condition {\rm(D)} . We consider the minimax values \displaystyle\lambda^{*} \displaystyle:=\sup_{u\in\mathbb{S}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathbb{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v), (5.3) \displaystyle\lambda_{r}^{*} \displaystyle:=\sup_{u\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v),\qquad r=1,2,\ldots. (5.4) Proposition 5.1 . Assume that \lambda^{*}<+\infty . Then system ( 5.1 ) has no positive solution u\in\mathbb{S}^{o} for any \lambda>\lambda^{*} . Proof. If u\in\mathbb{S}^{o} solves ( 5.1 ), then, for every v\in\mathbb{S}^{o} , a_{m}(u,v)-\langle f(u),v\rangle_{m}=\lambda\langle g(u),v\rangle_{m}. Hence \mathcal{R}(u,v)=\lambda\qquad\forall v\in\mathbb{S}^{o}. Therefore \lambda=\inf_{v\in\mathbb{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v)\leq\sup_{w\in\mathbb{S}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathbb{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(w,v)=\lambda^{*}. Thus no positive solution exists for \lambda>\lambda^{*} . ∎ Theorem 5.5 . Assume that {\rm(h_{1})} – {\rm(h_{5})} hold. Assume also that the finite-element meshes satisfy the discrete maximum principle ( 9.4 ) for each component operator \mathcal{L}^{k} , and that 0<\lambda_{r}^{*}<+\infty\qquad\text{for all }r\geq 1. Suppose, in addition, that there exist \mu>0 and M\geq 1 such that \mu^{-1}<\lambda_{r}^{*}<\mu\qquad\text{for all }r\geq M. Then the following assertions hold. (1^{\circ}) For every r\geq 1 , the Galerkin problem admits a maximal weak saddle-node bifurcation point (u_{r}^{*},\lambda_{r}^{*}) with u_{r}^{*}\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} . Moreover, there exists v_{r}^{*}\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} such that \lambda_{r}^{*}=\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*})=\min_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v)=\max_{u\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\min_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v). (2^{\circ}) There exist a subsequence, not relabelled, a number \hat{\lambda}^{*}\in[\mu^{-1},\mu] , and elements u^{*}\in\mathbb{S}^{o},\qquad v^{*}\in\mathbb{S}\setminus\{0\}, such that \lambda_{r}^{*}\to\hat{\lambda}^{*},\qquad u_{r}^{*}\to u^{*}\quad\text{strongly in }\mathbb{W},\qquad v_{r}^{*}\rightharpoonup v^{*}\quad\text{weakly in }\mathbb{W}. Moreover, \mathcal{F}(u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*})=0\quad\text{in }\mathbb{W}^{*}, and \bigl\langle D_{u}\mathcal{F}(u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*})\xi,v^{*}\bigr\rangle=0\qquad\forall\xi\in\mathbb{W}. Thus (u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*}) is a weak singular solution of ( 5.1 ). Remark 5.1 . Only Theorem 2.1 is used in this section. Hence the approximation condition {\rm(U)} is not needed, and we do not claim that \hat{\lambda}^{*}=\lambda^{*} . Such an identification requires the additional approximation hypothesis {\rm(U)} and Theorem 2.2 . Remark 5.2 . The assumptions {\rm(h_{1})} – {\rm(h_{5})} are used as follows. The diagonal sublinear structure of g gives t^{k}g^{k}_{t^{k}}=qg^{k},\qquad 00. Let \bar{1}=(1,\ldots,1)^{T}\in\mathbb{R}^{r},\qquad\bar{\omega}_{r}^{k}:=(A_{r}^{k})^{-1}\bar{1}, and set \omega_{r}^{k}:=\sum_{i=1}^{r}(\bar{\omega}_{r}^{k})^{i}\psi_{i},\qquad\omega_{r}:=(\omega_{r}^{1},\ldots,\omega_{r}^{m}). Since A_{r}^{k} is an M -matrix, \omega_{r}^{k}\in S_{r}^{o} , and hence \omega_{r}\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} . For t>0 sufficiently small and v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} , the sublinear term in the denominator gives \mathcal{R}(t\omega_{r},v)\geq\frac{ct-C(t^{\gamma_{0}}+t^{\gamma})}{Ct^{q}}. Since 00 . Therefore \lambda_{r}(t_{0}\omega_{r})>0. We next prove the compactness of positive superlevel sets. Let K_{r,\varepsilon}:=\{u\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}:\lambda_{r}(u)\geq\varepsilon\},\qquad\varepsilon>0. Since W_{r}^{m} is finite-dimensional, it is enough to show that K_{r,\varepsilon} is bounded and separated from \partial\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} . We first show that K_{r,\varepsilon} is separated from the boundary of \mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} . Suppose, to the contrary, that there exists a sequence u_{n}\in K_{r,\varepsilon},\qquad u_{n}\to u_{0}\quad\text{in }\mathbb{W}_{r}, where u_{0}\in\partial\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}. Writing u_{n}^{k}=\sum_{j=1}^{r}u_{n,j}^{k}\psi_{j},\qquad u_{n,j}^{k}>0, we may assume, after passing to a subsequence, that for some component k_{0}\in\{1,\ldots,m\} and some node i_{0}\in\{1,\ldots,r\} , u_{n,i_{0}}^{k_{0}}\to 0. Let \bar{\psi}_{i_{0}}^{k_{0}}\in\mathbb{W}_{r} denote the vector whose k_{0} -th component is \psi_{i_{0}} and whose other components are zero. Although \bar{\psi}_{i_{0}}^{k_{0}}\notin\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} , it belongs to \mathbb{S}_{r} . Since \mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} is dense in \mathbb{S}_{r} and \mathcal{R}(u_{n},\cdot) is continuous on \mathbb{S}_{r} , we have \lambda_{r}(u_{n})=\inf_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u_{n},v)\leq\mathcal{R}(u_{n},\bar{\psi}_{i_{0}}^{k_{0}}). Indeed, this follows by testing with \bar{\psi}_{i_{0}}^{k_{0}}+\delta e_{r}\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o},\qquad\delta>0, where e_{r}\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} is fixed, and then letting \delta\downarrow 0 . We estimate the last quotient. By definition, \mathcal{R}(u_{n},\bar{\psi}_{i_{0}}^{k_{0}})=\frac{a^{k_{0}}(u_{n}^{k_{0}},\psi_{i_{0}})-\langle f^{k_{0}}(u_{n}),\psi_{i_{0}}\rangle}{\langle g^{k_{0}}(u_{n}),\psi_{i_{0}}\rangle}. Since f^{k_{0}}\geq 0 , it is enough to estimate the linear part from above. Let A_{r}^{k_{0}}=(a_{ij}^{k_{0}}) be the stiffness matrix. With our nodal coordinates, a^{k_{0}}(u_{n}^{k_{0}},\psi_{i_{0}})=\sum_{j=1}^{r}a_{i_{0}j}^{k_{0}}u_{n,j}^{k_{0}} (up to replacing A_{r}^{k_{0}} by its transpose, depending on the convention for the matrix entries). Since A_{r}^{k_{0}} is an M -matrix, its off-diagonal entries are nonpositive: a_{i_{0}j}^{k_{0}}\leq 0\qquad j\neq i_{0}. Therefore a^{k_{0}}(u_{n}^{k_{0}},\psi_{i_{0}})\leq a_{i_{0}i_{0}}^{k_{0}}u_{n,i_{0}}^{k_{0}}\leq Cu_{n,i_{0}}^{k_{0}}. On the other hand, by {\rm(h_{1})} , \langle g^{k_{0}}(u_{n}),\psi_{i_{0}}\rangle=\int_{\Omega}a_{k_{0}}(x)(u_{n}^{k_{0}})^{q}\psi_{i_{0}}\,dx. Since u_{n}^{k_{0}}(x)=\sum_{j=1}^{r}u_{n,j}^{k_{0}}\psi_{j}(x)\geq u_{n,i_{0}}^{k_{0}}\psi_{i_{0}}(x), we obtain \langle g^{k_{0}}(u_{n}),\psi_{i_{0}}\rangle\geq a_{0}(u_{n,i_{0}}^{k_{0}})^{q}\int_{\Omega}\psi_{i_{0}}^{q+1}\,dx\geq c(u_{n,i_{0}}^{k_{0}})^{q}. Consequently, \mathcal{R}(u_{n},\bar{\psi}_{i_{0}}^{k_{0}})\leq C\frac{u_{n,i_{0}}^{k_{0}}}{(u_{n,i_{0}}^{k_{0}})^{q}}=C(u_{n,i_{0}}^{k_{0}})^{1-q}\to 0, because 00. Therefore K_{r,\varepsilon} is separated from \partial\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} . It remains to prove that K_{r,\varepsilon} is bounded. Suppose, to the contrary, that u_{n}\in K_{r,\varepsilon},\qquad\|u_{n}\|_{\mathbb{W}_{r}}\to+\infty. Since K_{r,\varepsilon} is separated from the boundary, there exists \delta>0 such that u_{n,j}^{k}\geq\delta\qquad\text{for all }n,\ k=1,\ldots,m,\ j=1,\ldots,r. Let T_{n}:=\max_{k,j}u_{n,j}^{k}\to+\infty. Passing to a subsequence, assume that T_{n}=u_{n,i_{0}}^{k_{0}}. Testing again by \bar{\psi}_{i_{0}}^{k_{0}} , the M -matrix sign pattern gives a^{k_{0}}(u_{n}^{k_{0}},\psi_{i_{0}})\leq CT_{n}. On the other hand, by {\rm(h_{4})} and the positivity of f^{k_{0}} in the interior of the cone, the separation from the boundary implies a uniform lower superlinear estimate \langle f^{k_{0}}(u_{n}),\psi_{i_{0}}\rangle\geq cT_{n}^{\theta},\qquad\theta>1. Moreover, \langle g^{k_{0}}(u_{n}),\psi_{i_{0}}\rangle\geq cT_{n}^{q}. Therefore \lambda_{r}(u_{n})\leq\mathcal{R}(u_{n},\bar{\psi}_{i_{0}}^{k_{0}})\leq CT_{n}^{1-q}-cT_{n}^{\theta-q}\to-\infty, because \theta>1 . This contradicts \lambda_{r}(u_{n})\geq\varepsilon>0 . Hence K_{r,\varepsilon} is bounded. It remains to verify {\rm(H2)} . Let u,v\in\mathbb{S}_{r} and suppose that D_{u}\langle\mathcal{A}(u),v\rangle(\bar{\psi}_{i})\geq 0,\qquad i=1,\ldots,rm. Since D_{u}\langle\mathcal{A}(u),v\rangle(\bar{\psi}_{i})=a_{m}(\bar{\psi}_{i},v)-\langle f_{u}(u)\bar{\psi}_{i},v\rangle_{m}, and f_{u}(u)\geq 0 by cooperativity, we obtain a^{k}(\psi_{i},v^{k})\geq 0,\qquad i=1,\ldots,r,\quad k=1,\ldots,m. Equivalently, (A_{r}^{k})^{T}\bar{v}^{k}\geq 0. Since A_{r}^{k} is an irreducible nonsingular M -matrix, the same is true for (A_{r}^{k})^{T} . Hence \bar{v}^{k}>0 for every k , and therefore v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}. Thus {\rm(H2)} holds. ∎ Lemma 5.2 . Assume {\rm(h_{1})} – {\rm(h_{5})} . Then the extended Rayleigh quotient \mathcal{R} satisfies the (PS)_{e} -condition on \mathbb{S}^{o}\times\mathbb{S}^{o} at every level \lambda>0 . Proof. Let (u_{n},v_{n})\in\mathbb{S}_{n}^{o}\times\mathbb{S}_{n}^{o} be a (PS)_{e} -sequence at a level \lambda>0 , and set \lambda_{n}:=\mathcal{R}(u_{n},v_{n})\to\lambda. The relation D_{v}\mathcal{R}(u_{n},v_{n})=0 gives \mathcal{F}_{n}(u_{n},\lambda_{n})=0. Testing this equation by u_{n} , we obtain a_{m}(u_{n},u_{n})=\lambda_{n}\langle g(u_{n}),u_{n}\rangle_{m}+\langle f(u_{n}),u_{n}\rangle_{m}. On the other hand, testing the adjoint relation D_{u}\mathcal{R}(u_{n},v_{n})=0 componentwise by (u_{n}^{k})^{2}/v_{n}^{k} and using Picone’s identity, we get a_{m}(u_{n},u_{n})\geq\lambda_{n}\left\langle g_{u}(u_{n})v_{n},\frac{u_{n}^{2}}{v_{n}}\right\rangle_{m}+\left\langle f_{u}(u_{n})v_{n},\frac{u_{n}^{2}}{v_{n}}\right\rangle_{m}. By {\rm(h_{1})} , \left\langle g_{u}(u_{n})v_{n},\frac{u_{n}^{2}}{v_{n}}\right\rangle_{m}=q\langle g(u_{n}),u_{n}\rangle_{m}, and by {\rm(h_{4})} , \left\langle f_{u}(u_{n})v_{n},\frac{u_{n}^{2}}{v_{n}}\right\rangle_{m}\geq\theta\langle f(u_{n}),u_{n}\rangle_{m}. Combining these identities yields (\theta-1)a_{m}(u_{n},u_{n})\leq(\theta-q)\lambda_{n}\langle g(u_{n}),u_{n}\rangle_{m}. Since \lambda_{n} is bounded and q+1<2 , the Sobolev inequality implies \|u_{n}\|_{\mathbb{W}}\leq C. Hence, up to a subsequence, u_{n}\rightharpoonup\bar{u}\quad\text{weakly in }\mathbb{W},\qquad u_{n}\to\bar{u}\quad\text{strongly in }\mathbb{L}^{\beta},\quad 1\leq\beta<2^{*}. The normalization in the definition of the (PS)_{e} -condition gives boundedness of (v_{n}) in \mathbb{W} . Therefore, after passing to a subsequence, v_{n}\rightharpoonup\bar{v}\quad\text{weakly in }\mathbb{W},\qquad v_{n}\to\bar{v}\quad\text{strongly in }\mathbb{L}^{\beta},\quad 1\leq\beta<2^{*}. Passing to the limit in the Galerkin equations gives \mathcal{F}(\bar{u},\lambda)=0. By the maximum principle and Hopf’s boundary lemma, \bar{u}\in\mathbb{S}^{o}. It remains to show that \bar{v}\neq 0 . The equation D_{u}\mathcal{R}(u_{n},v_{n})=0 is tested componentwise by the finite-dimensional vector whose k -th component has nodal coefficients \left(\frac{(u_{n,i}^{k})^{2}}{v_{n,i}^{k}}\right)_{i}. Using the componentwise discrete Picone inequality from Appendix 11 , we obtain a_{m}(u_{n},u_{n})\geq\lambda_{n}\left\langle g_{u}(u_{n})v_{n},\frac{u_{n}^{2}}{v_{n}}\right\rangle_{m}+\left\langle f_{u}(u_{n})v_{n},\frac{u_{n}^{2}}{v_{n}}\right\rangle_{m}. Hence, for any \chi\in(q,1) , 1-\chi\leq\left\langle f_{u}(u_{n})v_{n},v_{n}\right\rangle_{m}-\chi\left\langle f(u_{n}),\frac{v_{n}^{2}}{u_{n}}\right\rangle_{m}. If \bar{v}=0 , then the right-hand side tends to 0 by the growth assumptions and the degeneracy condition {\rm(h_{5})} , contradicting 1-\chi>0 . Hence \bar{v}\in\mathbb{S}\setminus\{0\}. Finally, the energy identity and the strong convergence of the nonlinear terms imply a_{m}(u_{n},u_{n})\to a_{m}(\bar{u},\bar{u}). Together with weak convergence and coercivity, this yields u_{n}\to\bar{u}\quad\text{strongly in }\mathbb{W}. Passing to the limit in the adjoint linearized relation gives \bigl\langle D_{u}\mathcal{F}(\bar{u},\lambda)\xi,\bar{v}\bigr\rangle=0\qquad\forall\xi\in\mathbb{W}. Thus the (PS)_{e} -condition is verified. ∎ Proof of Theorem 5.5 . By Lemma 5.1 , the quotient \mathcal{R} satisfies {\rm(H1)} and {\rm(H2)} on the discrete cones \mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} . By Lemma 9.1 , these cones satisfy {\rm(P1)} – {\rm(P3)} . By Proposition 10.1 , condition {\rm(D)} holds. Finally, Lemma 5.2 gives the (PS)_{e} -condition at every level \lambda>0 . Therefore all assumptions of Theorem 2.1 are satisfied. Hence, for each r , there exist u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*}\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o} such that \lambda_{r}^{*}=\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v_{r}^{*})=\min_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u_{r}^{*},v)=\max_{u\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\min_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{r}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v). Moreover, after passing to a subsequence, \lambda_{r}^{*}\to\hat{\lambda}^{*}\in[\mu^{-1},\mu], u_{r}^{*}\to u^{*}\quad\text{strongly in }\mathbb{W},\qquad v_{r}^{*}\rightharpoonup v^{*}\quad\text{weakly in }\mathbb{W}, where u^{*}\in\mathbb{S}^{o},\qquad v^{*}\in\mathbb{S}\setminus\{0\}. Passing to the limit in the Galerkin singularity relations gives \mathcal{F}(u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*})=0\quad\text{in }\mathbb{W}^{*}, and \bigl\langle D_{u}\mathcal{F}(u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*})\xi,v^{*}\bigr\rangle=0\qquad\forall\xi\in\mathbb{W}. Thus (u^{*},\hat{\lambda}^{*}) is a weak singular solution of ( 5.1 ). ∎ 6 Minimax bifurcation formula for a one-dimensional elliptic system In this section we consider the one-dimensional case d=1 of system ( 5.1 ). Namely, we study \left\{\begin{aligned} -(u^{k})^{\prime\prime}-f^{k}(x,u)&=\lambda g^{k}(x,u),&&x\in\Omega:=(0,1),\\ u^{k}&\geq 0,&&x\in\Omega,\\ u^{k}|_{\partial\Omega}&=0,&&k=1,\ldots,m.\end{aligned}\right. (6.1) Let \mathcal{L}=-d^{2}/dx^{2} and 00 . Moreover, g^{k} is C^{1} in t_{k}>0 , t_{k}g^{k}_{t_{k}}(x,t)=qg^{k}(x,t) , and g^{k}_{t_{j}}(x,t)=0 for j\neq k . {\rm(h_{2})} The reaction terms are nonnegative, cooperative, and C^{1} with respect to t\in(0,\infty)^{m} : f^{k}(x,t)\geq 0,\qquad f^{k}_{t_{j}}(x,t)\geq 0,\qquad j,k=1,\ldots,m. {\rm(h_{3})} There exist exponents 1<\gamma_{k}\leq\gamma<+\infty and constants c_{0},C_{0}>0 such that c_{0}t_{k}^{\gamma_{k}}\leq f^{k}(x,t)\leq C_{0}t_{k}^{\gamma_{k}}(1+|t|)^{\gamma-\gamma_{k}}. {\rm(h_{4})} There exists \theta>1 , with 1<\theta<\min_{1\leq k\leq m}\gamma_{k}, such that t_{k}f^{k}_{t_{k}}(x,t)\geq\theta f^{k}(x,t),\qquad k=1,\ldots,m. {\rm(h_{5})} The derivatives of f satisfy compatible growth estimates: 0\leq f^{k}_{t_{k}}(x,t)\leq C_{1}t_{k}^{\gamma_{k}-1}(1+|t|)^{\gamma-\gamma_{k}}, and, for j\neq k , 0\leq f^{k}_{t_{j}}(x,t)\leq C_{1}t_{k}^{\gamma_{k}}(1+|t|)^{\gamma-\gamma_{k}}. Example 2 . A model class satisfying {\rm(h_{1})} – {\rm(h_{5})} is g^{k}(x,t)=a_{k}(x)t_{k}^{q},\qquad f^{k}(x,t)=b_{k}(x)t_{k}^{\beta_{k}}\prod_{j\neq k}(1+t_{j})^{\alpha_{kj}}, where 01 , and \alpha_{kj}\geq 0 . In this case one may take \gamma_{k}=\beta_{k},\qquad\gamma=\max_{1\leq k\leq m}\left(\beta_{k}+\sum_{j\neq k}\alpha_{kj}\right). Moreover, since t_{k}f^{k}_{t_{k}}=\beta_{k}f^{k} , condition {\rm(h_{4})} holds with any 1<\theta<\min_{k}\beta_{k} . Remark 6.1 . These assumptions are the one-dimensional counterparts of the structural hypotheses used above. The diagonal q -homogeneity of g gives the sublinear parameter term. The lower superlinear bound in {\rm(h_{3})} yields compactness of positive superlevel sets, cooperativity gives the boundary-exclusion condition {\rm(H2)} , and {\rm(h_{4})} – {\rm(h_{5})} are used in the Picone-type compactness argument. Theorem 6.6 . Assume d=1 and suppose that f and g satisfy {\rm(h_{1})} – {\rm(h_{5})} . Then 0<\lambda_{\mathcal{L}}^{*}<+\infty. Moreover, the following assertions hold. (1^{\circ}) System ( 6.1 ) admits a maximal weak saddle-node bifurcation point (u^{*},\lambda_{\mathcal{L}}^{*}) in the class of nonnegative weak solutions. Moreover, ( 6.1 ) has no nonnegative weak solution for \lambda>\lambda_{\mathcal{L}}^{*} . (2^{\circ}) There exists v^{*}\in\mathbb{S}_{\mathcal{L}}\setminus\{0\} such that \lambda_{\mathcal{L}}^{*}=\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v^{*})=\inf_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{\mathcal{L}}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v)=\sup_{u\in\mathbb{U}_{\mathcal{L}}^{o,q}}\inf_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{\mathcal{L}}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v). (6.3) If, in addition, v^{*}\in\mathbb{S}_{\mathcal{L}}^{o} , then the infimum in ( 6.3 ) is attained and \lambda_{\mathcal{L}}^{*}=\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v^{*})=\min_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{\mathcal{L}}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u^{*},v). Lemma 6.1 (Relative interpolation estimate in dimension one) . Let \Omega=(0,1) , d(x):=\operatorname{dist}(x,\partial\Omega) , and \mathcal{L}=-d^{2}/dx^{2} . Assume that 00 , independent of r , such that |\mathcal{I}_{r}u(x)-u(x)|\leq C(u)h_{r}^{1+q}d(x),\qquad x\in(0,1), and consequently \left\|\frac{\mathcal{I}_{r}u-u}{u}\right\|_{L^{\infty}(0,1)}\leq C(u)h_{r}^{1+q}. Proof. Since u\in S_{\mathcal{L}}^{o} , we have u(x)\geq c_{u}d(x) on (0,1) . Moreover, u\in U_{\mathcal{L}}^{o,q} means that 0\leq-u^{\prime\prime}\leq C_{u}d^{q} in the sense of distributions, and hence a.e. in (0,1) . Let 0=x_{0}0 . Since \mathbb{S}_{\mathcal{L},n}^{o}\subset\mathbb{S}_{n}^{o} , this sequence is also a (PS)_{e} -sequence in the larger class \mathbb{S}^{o}\times\mathbb{S}^{o} . Hence Lemma 11.2 applies. In that lemma, the quotients u_{n}^{2}/v_{n} and v_{n}^{2}/u_{n} are understood in the discrete nodal sense, and the required estimates follow from the componentwise discrete Picone inequality in Appendix 11 . Therefore, after passing to a subsequence and using the admissible normalization of v_{n} , we have u_{n}\to\bar{u}\quad\text{strongly in }\mathbb{W},\qquad v_{n}\rightharpoonup\bar{v}\quad\text{weakly in }\mathbb{W}, with \bar{u}\in\mathbb{S}^{o} and \bar{v}\in\mathbb{S}\setminus\{0\} . Passing to the limit in the Galerkin equations gives \mathcal{F}(\bar{u},\lambda)=0 . By the one-dimensional regularity and maximum-principle argument, \bar{u}\in\mathbb{S}^{o}\cap C^{2}(0,1)^{m} . Moreover, for every nonnegative \eta\in C_{0}^{\infty}(0,1) , 0\leq\langle\mathcal{L}\bar{u}^{k},\eta\rangle\leq C(\bar{u})\langle d^{q},\eta\rangle,\qquad k=1,\ldots,m. Hence \bar{u}\in\mathbb{U}_{\mathcal{L}}^{o,q} . Thus the (PS)_{e} -condition holds in the class \mathcal{O}_{\mathcal{L}} . All assumptions of Theorem 2.2 are now verified. Therefore there exist u^{*}\in\mathbb{U}_{\mathcal{L}}^{o,q} and v^{*}\in\mathbb{S}_{\mathcal{L}}\setminus\{0\} such that \mathcal{F}(u^{*},\lambda_{\mathcal{L}}^{*})=0 , and the minimax identity ( 6.3 ) holds. In particular, (u^{*},\lambda_{\mathcal{L}}^{*}) is a weak singular solution of ( 6.1 ). Finally, let u be any nonnegative weak solution of ( 6.1 ) corresponding to some \lambda . The same regularity and maximum-principle argument gives u\in\mathbb{U}_{\mathcal{L}}^{o,q} . Since \mathcal{R}(u,v)=\lambda for all v\in\mathbb{S}_{\mathcal{L}}^{o} , we obtain \lambda=\inf_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{\mathcal{L}}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(u,v)\leq\sup_{w\in\mathbb{U}_{\mathcal{L}}^{o,q}}\inf_{v\in\mathbb{S}_{\mathcal{L}}^{o}}\mathcal{R}(w,v)=\lambda_{\mathcal{L}}^{*}. Thus no nonnegative weak solution exists for \lambda>\lambda_{\mathcal{L}}^{*} , and therefore (u^{*},\lambda_{\mathcal{L}}^{*}) is a maximal weak saddle-node bifurcation point. The proof is complete. ∎ 7 Perturbation estimates for the maximal bifurcation value We first record a simple perturbation estimate for the minimax value. For an operator \mathcal{A} , set \mathcal{F}_{\mathcal{A}}(u,\lambda):=\mathcal{A}(u)-\lambda\mathcal{G}(u),\qquad\mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}}(u,v):=\frac{\langle\mathcal{A}(u),v\rangle}{\langle\mathcal{G}(u),v\rangle}. The same notation will be used for the corresponding extremal values and critical points. Proposition 7.1 (Perturbation bounds) . Let \Psi\in C_{W}(\mathcal{S}^{o},W^{*}) , and assume that -\infty<\lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}+\Psi}:=\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}}\mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}+\Psi}(u,v)<+\infty. (1^{\circ}) If u^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}\in\mathcal{S}^{o} realizes the maximizer \lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}=\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}}\mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}}(u^{*}_{\mathcal{A}},v)=\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}}\mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}}(u,v), then \lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}+\Psi}\geq\lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}+\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}}\frac{\langle\Psi(u^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}),v\rangle}{\langle\mathcal{G}(u^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}),v\rangle}. (7.1) (2^{\circ}) If v^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}\in\mathcal{S}\setminus\{0\} realizes the minimizer in the dual minimax value, \Lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}:=\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}}\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}}(u,v)=\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}}(u,v^{*}_{\mathcal{A}})<+\infty, then \lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}+\Psi}\leq\Lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}+\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\frac{\langle\Psi(u),v^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}\rangle}{\langle\mathcal{G}(u),v^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}\rangle}. (7.2) Proof. For (1^{\circ}) , we test the outer supremum at u=u^{*}_{\mathcal{A}} . Since \mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}+\Psi}(u,v)=\mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}}(u,v)+\frac{\langle\Psi(u),v\rangle}{\langle\mathcal{G}(u),v\rangle}, the estimate follows at once from \inf(a+b)\geq\inf a+\inf b . For (2^{\circ}) , we test the inner infimum at v=v^{*}_{\mathcal{A}} . This gives \lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}+\Psi}\leq\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}+\Psi}(u,v^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}), and the desired bound follows from \sup(a+b)\leq\sup a+\sup b . ∎ We say that \mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}} satisfies the minimax principle on \mathcal{S}^{o}\times\mathcal{S} if \lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}:=\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}}\mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}}(u,v)=\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}}\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}}(u,v)=:\Lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}. (7.3) Corollary 7.1 . Assume that \mathcal{F}_{\mathcal{A}}(u,\lambda)=0 has a maximal weak saddle-node bifurcation point (u^{*}_{\mathcal{A}},\lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}})\in\mathcal{S}^{o}\times\mathbb{R} . Suppose also that \mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}} satisfies the minimax principle and that there exists v^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}\in\mathcal{S}\setminus\{0\} such that \lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}=\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}}\mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}}(u^{*}_{\mathcal{A}},v)=\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{A}}(u,v^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}). Then, whenever \lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}+\Psi} is finite, \inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}}\frac{\langle\Psi(u^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}),v\rangle}{\langle\mathcal{G}(u^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}),v\rangle}\leq\lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}+\Psi}-\lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}\leq\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\frac{\langle\Psi(u),v^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}\rangle}{\langle\mathcal{G}(u),v^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}\rangle}. (7.4) In particular, if -\infty<\underline{d}_{\Psi}\leq\overline{d}_{\Psi}<+\infty, where \underline{d}_{\Psi}:=\inf_{v\in\mathcal{S}}\frac{\langle\Psi(u^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}),v\rangle}{\langle\mathcal{G}(u^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}),v\rangle},\qquad\overline{d}_{\Psi}:=\sup_{u\in\mathcal{S}^{o}}\frac{\langle\Psi(u),v^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}\rangle}{\langle\mathcal{G}(u),v^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}\rangle}, then, for every \varepsilon>0 , \varepsilon\underline{d}_{\Psi}\leq\lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}+\varepsilon\Psi}-\lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}\leq\varepsilon\overline{d}_{\Psi}. In particular, \lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}+\varepsilon\Psi}\to\lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{A}}\qquad\text{as }\varepsilon\to 0^{+}. 7.1 Example We illustrate the perturbation estimate on a one-dimensional problem. Consider \left\{\begin{aligned} -(\sigma(x)(u^{k})^{\prime})^{\prime}-f_{1}^{k}(x,u)&=\lambda g^{k}(x,u),&&x\in\Omega:=(0,1),\\ u^{k}&\geq 0,&&x\in\Omega,\\ u^{k}|_{\partial\Omega}&=0,&&k=1,\ldots,m,\end{aligned}\right. (7.5) where \sigma\in L^{\infty}(\Omega) and \sigma(x)\geq\nu^{-1}>0 a.e. in \Omega . Set \mathcal{L}u:=-u^{\prime\prime},\qquad\mathcal{L}_{1}u:=-(\sigma u^{\prime})^{\prime},\qquad\delta(u):=(\mathcal{L}_{1}-\mathcal{L})u-\bigl(f_{1}(u)-f(u)\bigr). Then \mathcal{L}_{1}-f_{1}=\mathcal{L}-f+\delta . Assume that f_{1} satisfies the same structural hypotheses as f . Then the perturbed problem has a finite extreme value \lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{L}_{1}-f_{1}} . If (u^{*}_{\mathcal{L}-f},\lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{L}-f}) is a maximal weak saddle-node bifurcation point of the unperturbed problem, then Corollary 7.1 gives \lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{L}_{1}-f_{1}}\geq\lambda^{*}_{\mathcal{L}-f}+\inf_{v\in\mathbb{S}}\frac{\langle\delta(u^{*}_{\mathcal{L}-f}),v\rangle_{m}}{\langle g(u^{*}_{\mathcal{L}-f}),v\rangle_{m}}. (7.6) As a scalar example, consider -u^{\prime\prime}-u^{\gamma}=\lambda u^{q},\qquad u\geq 0,\qquad u|_{\partial\Omega}=0, (7.7) where 00\right\}. (9.3) For q>0 , set S_{\mathcal{L}}^{o}:=\{v\in S^{o}:\langle\mathcal{L}v,\eta\rangle\geq 0\ \text{for all }\eta\in C_{0}^{\infty}(\Omega),\ \eta\geq 0\}, and U_{\mathcal{L}}^{o,q}:=\left\{u\in S_{\mathcal{L}}^{o}:\sup_{\begin{subarray}{c}\eta\in C_{0}^{\infty}(\Omega),\ \eta\geq 0\\ \eta\not\equiv 0\end{subarray}}\frac{\langle\mathcal{L}u,\eta\rangle}{\langle d^{q},\eta\rangle}<+\infty\right\}. Their closed counterparts are S:=\overline{S^{o}}^{\,C(\overline{\Omega})},\qquad S_{\mathcal{L}}:=\overline{S_{\mathcal{L}}^{o}}^{\,C(\overline{\Omega})},\qquad U_{\mathcal{L}}^{q}:=\overline{U_{\mathcal{L}}^{o,q}}^{\,C(\overline{\Omega})}. Let \{\mathcal{T}_{r}\}_{r\geq 1} be a shape-regular family of triangulations, and let W_{r}\subset W be the conforming P_{1} -finite element space with nodal basis \{\psi_{1},\ldots,\psi_{N_{r}}\} . The nodal interpolant is \mathcal{I}_{r}u:=\sum_{i=1}^{N_{r}}u(B_{i})\psi_{i}. We shall use the following interpolation assumption: {\rm(I)}\qquad\mathcal{I}_{r}u\to u\quad\text{strongly in }W\quad\text{for every function to which interpolation is applied.} The discrete cones are S_{r}:=\left\{u_{r}=\sum_{i=1}^{N_{r}}u_{i}\psi_{i}\in W_{r}:\ u_{i}\geq 0\right\},\qquad S_{r}^{o}:=\left\{u_{r}=\sum_{i=1}^{N_{r}}u_{i}\psi_{i}\in W_{r}:\ u_{i}>0\right\}. Then S_{r}^{o}\subset S^{o} and S_{r}=\overline{S_{r}^{o}}^{\,W_{r}} . Let A_{r}=(a_{ij}) , a_{ij}:=\langle\mathcal{L}\psi_{j},\psi_{i}\rangle . We shall use the discrete maximum-principle implication A_{r}\vartheta\geq 0,\quad\vartheta\in\mathbb{R}_{+}^{N_{r}}\setminus\{0\}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad\vartheta>0. (9.4) This holds, for instance, if A_{r} is a nonsingular irreducible M -matrix. In the one-dimensional case \Omega=(0,1) , \mathcal{L}=-d^{2}/dx^{2} , and for P_{1} -meshes, the standard stiffness matrix is a nonsingular irreducible M -matrix. Hence ( 9.4 ) holds. In the one-dimensional application we also assume quasi-uniformity, that is, \kappa^{-1}h_{r}\leq h_{i}\leq h_{r},\qquad h_{r}:=\max_{i}h_{i}. Lemma 9.1 . Let W=W_{0}^{1,2}(\Omega) , \mathcal{C}^{0}=C(\overline{\Omega}) , and let \mathcal{I}_{r} be the nodal interpolation operator. (i) For the cone S^{o} , the discrete cones S_{r}^{o} satisfy {\rm(P1)} – {\rm(P2)} . Moreover, the approximation condition {\rm(P3)} holds for every function satisfying {\rm(I)} . (ii) Assume d=1 , \mathcal{L}=-d^{2}/dx^{2} , 00\},\qquad U_{\mathcal{L},r}^{o,q}:=\mathcal{I}_{r}U_{\mathcal{L}}^{o,q}. Then {\rm(P1)} – {\rm(P2)} hold whenever the interpolants are well defined and belong to the corresponding discrete cones. Moreover, {\rm(P3)} holds for all functions satisfying {\rm(I)} whose interpolants eventually remain in the relevant discrete cones. Proof. For (i) , the statement follows directly from the nodal representation of S_{r}^{o} . Positive nodal coefficients imply v_{r}\geq 0 , v_{r}=0 on \partial\Omega , and v_{r}\geq c_{v_{r}}d in \Omega ; hence S_{r}^{o}\subset S^{o} , while S_{r} is the closed polyhedral cone generated by the nodal basis. The approximation statement is precisely {\rm(I)} . For (ii) , the implication ( 9.4 ) gives the required boundary-exclusion property. If v_{r}\in S_{\mathcal{L},r}^{o} , then v_{r}\in S_{r}^{o}\subset S^{o} and \langle\mathcal{L}v_{r},\psi_{i}\rangle=(A_{r}\bar{v})_{i}>0,\qquad i=1,\ldots,N_{r}. The closure is the polyhedral cone S_{\mathcal{L},r}=\{v_{r}\in S_{r}:A_{r}\bar{v}\geq 0\}. Thus the Galerkin cone assumptions follow. The definition U_{\mathcal{L},r}^{o,q}:=\mathcal{I}_{r}U_{\mathcal{L}}^{o,q} gives the corresponding approximation property in the first variable, and the remaining assertion follows again from {\rm(I)} . ∎ 10 Appendix B. Differentiability of the Nemytskii term Let \Omega\subset\mathbb{R}^{N} be a bounded Lipschitz domain, W:=W_{0}^{1,2}(\Omega) , and d(x):=\operatorname{dist}(x,\partial\Omega) . Let g:\Omega\times\mathbb{R}_{+}\to\mathbb{R}_{+} be a Carathéodory function such that g(x,\cdot)\in C^{1}((0,\infty)) for a.e. x\in\Omega , and assume that, for some 00. We denote by Q the corresponding Nemytskii operator, Q(u)(x):=g(x,u(x)) . Proposition 10.1 (Bounded linearization and relative differentiability) . Let u\in S^{o} . Then \langle DQ(u)\phi,\psi\rangle:=\int_{\Omega}g_{t}(x,u)\phi\psi\,dx defines a bounded linear operator DQ(u):W\to W^{*} . More precisely, \left|\int_{\Omega}g_{t}(x,u)\phi\psi\,dx\right|\leq C(u)\|\phi\|_{W}\|\psi\|_{W},\qquad\phi,\psi\in W. Assume, in addition, that g_{t} is relatively continuous near positive rays, namely \omega(\delta):=\sup_{\begin{subarray}{c}x\in\Omega,\ t>0\\ |\rho-1|\leq\delta\end{subarray}}\frac{|g_{t}(x,\rho t)-g_{t}(x,t)|}{t^{q-1}}\to 0\qquad\text{as }\delta\to 0. If h_{n}\in W , u+h_{n}\geq 0 , and \left\|\frac{h_{n}}{u}\right\|_{L^{\infty}(\Omega)}\to 0, then \frac{\|Q(u+h_{n})-Q(u)-DQ(u)h_{n}\|_{W^{*}}}{\|h_{n}\|_{W}}\to 0. In particular, this applies to g(x,t)=a(x)t^{q} , where 00 in \Omega , and assume that u,v\in H_{0}^{1}(\Omega) are such that u^{2}/v\in H_{0}^{1}(\Omega) . Then \langle\mathcal{L}u,u\rangle\geq\left\langle\mathcal{L}v,\frac{u^{2}}{v}\right\rangle. Proof. It is enough to argue for smooth positive functions; the general case follows by approximation. The zero-order term cancels. For the principal part, a direct computation gives \sigma_{ij}v_{x_{j}}\left(\frac{u^{2}}{v}\right)_{x_{i}}-\sigma_{ij}u_{x_{j}}u_{x_{i}}=-\sigma_{ij}\left(u_{x_{j}}-\frac{u}{v}v_{x_{j}}\right)\left(u_{x_{i}}-\frac{u}{v}v_{x_{i}}\right)\leq 0. Here we use the symmetry and ellipticity of (\sigma_{ij}) . Integration over \Omega gives the claim. ∎ Lemma 11.2 (Discrete Picone inequality) . Let A=(a_{ij})_{i,j=1}^{r} be symmetric and assume that a_{ij}\leq 0 for i\neq j . Then, for every \mathbf{u}\in\mathbb{R}_{+}^{r} and every \mathbf{v}\in(\mathbb{R}_{+}^{r})^{\circ} , \mathbf{u}^{T}A\mathbf{u}\geq(A\mathbf{v})\cdot\frac{\mathbf{u}^{2}}{\mathbf{v}},\qquad\frac{\mathbf{u}^{2}}{\mathbf{v}}:=\left(\frac{u_{1}^{2}}{v_{1}},\ldots,\frac{u_{r}^{2}}{v_{r}}\right). Proof. Set z_{i}:=u_{i}/v_{i} . By symmetry, \mathbf{u}^{T}A\mathbf{u}-(A\mathbf{v})\cdot\frac{\mathbf{u}^{2}}{\mathbf{v}}=-\frac{1}{2}\sum_{i,j=1}^{r}a_{ij}v_{i}v_{j}(z_{i}-z_{j})^{2}. The diagonal terms vanish, while a_{ij}\leq 0 for i\neq j . Hence the right-hand side is nonnegative. ∎ Corollary 11.1 (Componentwise form) . Let A^{k} , k=1,\ldots,m , be symmetric matrices with nonpositive off-diagonal entries. Then, for \mathbf{u}=(\mathbf{u}^{1},\ldots,\mathbf{u}^{m})\geq 0 and \mathbf{v}=(\mathbf{v}^{1},\ldots,\mathbf{v}^{m})>0 , \sum_{k=1}^{m}(\mathbf{u}^{k})^{T}A^{k}\mathbf{u}^{k}\geq\sum_{k=1}^{m}(A^{k}\mathbf{v}^{k})\cdot\frac{(\mathbf{u}^{k})^{2}}{\mathbf{v}^{k}}. Remark 11.1 . In the Galerkin arguments the discrete Picone inequality is applied to the nodal coefficient vectors. Thus the vector (u_{i}^{2}/v_{i})_{i=1}^{r} belongs to the finite-dimensional coefficient space, although the pointwise quotient u_{r}^{2}/v_{r} need not be a finite-element function.