A proof of Esterle’s conjecture on negative powers of Hilbert-space contractions Thanks: Research supported by NSERC Discovery Grant RGPIN-2026-04565 Thomas Ransford Abstract . We establish the following result, confirming a conjecture of Jean Esterle. For each closed subset E E of the unit circle of Lebesgue measure zero, there exists a positive sequence u n → ∞ u_{n}\to\infty with the following property: if T T is a contraction on a Hilbert space such that σ ⁡ ( T ) ⊂ E \sigma(T)\subset E and ‖ T − n ‖ = O ⁡ ( u n ) \|T^{-n}\|=O(u_{n}) as n → ∞ n\to\infty , then T T is a unitary operator. A key tool used in the proof is a result generalizing the well-known fact that closed subsets E E of the real axis of Lebesgue measure zero are removable for bounded holomorphic functions. We show that such sets remain removable even for certain unbounded holomorphic functions of moderate growth near E E , where the notion of ‘moderate’ depends on E E . 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 30J05, 47A45, 47A56 1. Introduction and statement of main results Let T be a bounded linear operator on a complex Hilbert space. We denote the operator norm and spectrum of T by \|T\| and \sigma(T) respectively. We say T is a contraction if \|T\|\leq 1 . Our goal in this article is to establish the following theorem, which confirms a conjecture of Jean Esterle [ 4 , Conjecture 1.3] . Theorem 1.1 . For each closed subset E of the unit circle \mathbb{T} of Lebesgue measure zero, there exists a positive sequence u_{n}\to\infty with the following property: if T is a contraction on a Hilbert space such that \sigma(T)\subset E and \|T^{-n}\|=O(u_{n}) as n\to\infty , then T is a unitary operator. Versions of this result have long been known for specific sets E : for example countable compact sets [ 5 ] , certain Cantor sets [ 1 ] , and Carleson sets [ 2 , 3 ] . In each case, the corresponding sequence (u_{n}) was explicitly identified. It is also known that no single sequence (u_{n}) can work simultaneously for all compact sets E of measure zero [ 3 ] . Also the condition that E have measure zero is optimal: Theorem 1.1 breaks down for every closed set E of positive measure [ 4 ] . Finally, the result also breaks down if ‘Hilbert space’ is replaced by ‘Banach space’ [ 2 ] . For a detailed account of the background to Esterle’s conjecture, we refer to [ 4 ] . In [ 4 , Theorem 1.5] it was shown that Theorem 1.1 holds under the additional assumption that \rank(I-T^{*}T)<\infty . In this note, we prove the full version, following a method suggested to the author by Fedja Nazarov. The new ingredient is a removable singularity theorem, which we believe to be of interest in its own right. It is a generalization of the well-known fact that a closed subset E of the real line \mathbb{R} of Lebesgue measure zero is removable for bounded holomorphic functions. The new result shows that this remains true even for certain unbounded holomorphic functions of moderate growth near E , where what ‘moderate’ means depends on E . We denote by |\cdot| Lebesgue measure on \mathbb{R} . Also, given E\subset\mathbb{C} and t>0 , we write E_{t}:=\{z\in\mathbb{C}:\dist(z,E)\leq t\} . Theorem 1.2 . Let E be a compact subset of \mathbb{R} such that |E|=0 . (i) There exists a decreasing continuous function \omega:(0,\infty)\to(1,\infty) such that \lim_{t\to 0^{+}}\omega(t)=\infty\quad\text{and}\quad\liminf_{t\to 0^{+}}\frac{|E_{t}\cap\mathbb{R}|}{t}\int_{0}^{t}\omega(s)\,ds=0. (1) (ii) Every \omega satisfying the conditions in (i) has the following property: if \Omega is an open subset of \mathbb{C} containing E , and if f is a holomorphic function on \Omega\setminus E such that |f(x+iy)|\leq\omega(|y|) for all x+iy\in\Omega\setminus\mathbb{R} , then f has a holomorphic extension to the whole of \Omega . 2. Proof of Theorem 1.2 The proof uses two lemmas. In the first of these, m denotes planar Lebesgue measure. Lemma 2.1 . Let \Omega be an open subset of \mathbb{C} , and let F be a compact subset of \mathbb{C} such that m(F)=0 . Then every holomorphic function f:\Omega\setminus F\to\mathbb{C} such that \liminf_{\eta\to 0}\frac{1}{\eta}\int_{F_{\eta}}|f(z)|\,dm(z)=0 (2) has a holomorphic extension to the whole of \Omega . The idea for the proof that follows was suggested by Fedja Nazarov. Proof. Fix \psi\in C^{\infty}(\mathbb{C}) with \supp\psi\subset\mathbb{D} and \int_{\mathbb{C}}\psi\,dm=1 . For each \eta>0 , define \phi_{\eta}:\mathbb{C}\to\mathbb{R} by \phi_{\eta}(z):=1-\frac{1}{(\eta/4)^{2}}\int_{F_{\eta/2}}\psi\Bigl(\frac{z-w}{\eta/4}\Bigr)\,dm(w). Then \phi_{\eta}\in C^{\infty}(\mathbb{C}) and it satisfies \phi_{\eta}=1 on \mathbb{C}\setminus F_{\eta} and \phi_{\eta}=0 on F_{\eta/4} . Also |\partial\phi_{\eta}/\partial\overline{z}|\leq C_{\psi}/\eta on \mathbb{C} , where C_{\psi} is a constant depending just on \psi . Let f:\Omega\setminus E\to\mathbb{C} be a holomorphic function such that ( 2 ) holds. Define f_{\eta}:\Omega\to\mathbb{C} by f_{\eta}(z):=\begin{cases}f(z)\phi_{\eta}(z),&z\in\Omega\setminus F,\\ 0,&z\in F_{\eta/4}.\end{cases} Then f_{\eta}\in C^{\infty}(\Omega) , and it satisfies f_{\eta}=f on \Omega\setminus F_{\eta} and \partial f_{\eta}/\partial\overline{z}=f\partial\phi_{\eta}/\partial\overline{z} on \Omega\setminus F . Fix \Gamma , a finite union of closed contours in \Omega\setminus F such that n(\Gamma,w)=\begin{cases}0\text{~or~}1,&\forall w\in\mathbb{C}\setminus\Gamma,\\ 1,&\forall w\in F,\\ 0,&\forall w\in\mathbb{C}\setminus\Omega.\end{cases} Set U:=\{w\in\Omega\setminus\Gamma:n(\Gamma,w)=1\} , a open neighbourhood of F . By the Cauchy–Pompeiu formula, f_{\eta}(\zeta)=\frac{1}{2\pi i}\int_{\Gamma}\frac{f_{\eta}(z)}{z-\zeta}\,dz-\frac{1}{\pi}\int_{U}\frac{\partial f_{\eta}}{\partial\overline{z}}(z)\frac{1}{z-\zeta}\,dm(z)\quad(\zeta\in U). In particular, if \eta<\dist(\Gamma,F) , then f(\zeta)=\frac{1}{2\pi i}\int_{\Gamma}\frac{f(z)}{z-\zeta}\,dz-\frac{1}{\pi}\int_{F_{\eta}}f(z)\frac{\partial\phi_{\eta}}{\partial\overline{z}}(z)\frac{1}{z-\zeta}\,dm(z)\quad(\zeta\in U\setminus F_{\eta}). For each \zeta\in U\setminus F_{\eta} , we have \Bigl|\frac{1}{\pi}\int_{F_{\eta}}f(z)\frac{\partial\phi_{\eta}}{\partial\overline{z}}(z)\frac{1}{z-\zeta}\,dm(z)\Bigr|\leq\frac{C_{\psi}}{\pi\dist(\zeta,F_{\eta})}\frac{1}{\eta}\int_{F_{\eta}}|f(z)|\,dm(z). Taking \liminf_{\eta\to 0} and using ( 2 ), we deduce that f(\zeta)=\frac{1}{2\pi i}\int_{\Gamma}\frac{f(z)}{z-\zeta}\,dz\quad(\zeta\in U\setminus F). As a function of \zeta , the right-hand is holomorphic on U , so it provides the required holomorphic extension of f . ∎ Lemma 2.2 . Let \rho:(0,\infty)\to(0,\infty) be a continuous increasing function such that \lim_{t\to 0^{+}}\rho(t)/t=\infty . Then there exists a continuous decreasing function \omega:(0,\infty)\to(1,\infty) such that \lim_{t\to 0^{+}}\omega(t)=\infty\quad\text{and}\quad\liminf_{t\to 0^{+}}\frac{1}{\rho(t)}\int_{0}^{t}\omega(s)\,ds=0. Proof. Define \rho_{1}:(0,\infty)\to(0,\infty) by \rho_{1}(t):=\sqrt{t\rho(t)} . Then \lim_{t\to 0+}\frac{\rho_{1}(t)}{t}=\lim_{t\to 0^{+}}\sqrt{\frac{\rho(t)}{t}}=\infty, so we may recursively choose a decreasing sequence (t_{n}) tending to zero such that, if we set d_{n}:=\frac{\rho_{1}(t_{n-1})-\rho_{1}(t_{n})}{t_{n-1}-t_{n}}, then (d_{n}) is an increasing sequence that tends to infinity as n\to\infty . Fix n_{0} such that d_{n_{0}}>1 , and define \omega:(0,\infty)\to(1,\infty) by stipulating that \omega(t_{n})=d_{n} for all n\geq n_{0} , that \omega is linear on each interval [t_{n+1},t_{n}] for n\geq n_{0} and constant on [t_{n_{0}},\infty) . Clearly \omega is a continuous decreasing function such that \lim_{t\to 0^{+}}\omega(t)=\infty . Also, for each n\geq n_{0} , we have \displaystyle\int_{0}^{t_{n}}\omega(s)\,ds \displaystyle\leq\sum_{k\geq n}\int_{t_{k+1}}^{t_{k}}\omega(s)\,ds\leq\sum_{k\geq n}\omega(t_{k+1})(t_{k}-t_{k+1}) \displaystyle=\sum_{k\geq n}(\rho_{1}(t_{k})-\rho_{1}(t_{k+1}))\leq\rho_{1}(t_{n}), and hence \frac{1}{\rho(t_{n})}\int_{0}^{t_{n}}\omega(s)\,ds=\frac{t_{n}}{\rho_{1}(t_{n})^{2}}\int_{0}^{t_{n}}\omega(s)\,ds\leq\frac{t_{n}}{\rho_{1}(t_{n})}. Since t_{n}/\rho_{1}(t_{n})\to 0 , it follows that \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{1}{\rho(t_{n})}\int_{0}^{t_{n}}\omega(s)\,ds=0, which establishes the result. ∎ Proof of Theorem 1.2 . (i) Define \rho:(0,\infty)\to(0,\infty) by \rho(t):=\frac{t}{|E_{t}\cap\mathbb{R}|}\quad(t>0). Then \rho is a continuous increasing function such that \lim_{t\to 0^{+}}\rho(t)/t=\infty . By Lemma 2.2 , there exists a continuous decreasing function \omega:(0,\infty)\to(1,\infty) such that ( 1 ) holds. (ii) Let \omega be a function satisfying the conclusions of (i), let \Omega be an open subset of \mathbb{C} containing E , and let f be a holomorphic function on \Omega\setminus E such that |f(x+iy)|\leq\omega(|y|) for all x+iy\in\Omega\setminus\mathbb{R} . For each \eta>0 , we have E_{\eta}\subset(E_{\eta}\cap\mathbb{R})\times[-\eta,\eta], so, if \eta is small enough so that (E_{\eta}\cap\mathbb{R})\times[-\eta,\eta]\subset\Omega , then \int_{E_{\eta}}|f|\,dm\leq\int_{E_{\eta}\cap\mathbb{R}}\int_{-\eta}^{\eta}|f(x+iy)|\,dy\,dx\leq 2|E_{\eta}\cap\mathbb{R}|\int_{0}^{\eta}\omega(y)\,dy. Hence \liminf_{\eta\to 0^{+}}\frac{1}{\eta}\int_{E_{\eta}}|f|\,dm\leq\liminf_{\eta\to 0^{+}}\frac{2|E_{\eta}\cap\mathbb{R}|}{\eta}\int_{0}^{\eta}\omega(y)\,dy=0, the last equality by ( 1 ). By Lemma 2.1 , the function f has a holomorphic extension to the whole of \Omega . This shows that \omega has the required property, and completes the proof of the theorem. ∎ 3. Proof of Theorem 1.1 Given Hilbert spaces \mathcal{F},\mathcal{F}^{\prime} , we write \mathcal{L}(\mathcal{F},\mathcal{F}^{\prime}) for the space of bounded linear operators from \mathcal{F} into \mathcal{F}^{\prime} . Also we say that T\in\mathcal{L}(\mathcal{F},\mathcal{F}^{\prime}) is purely contractive if \|Tx\|<\|x\| for all x\in\mathcal{F}\setminus\{0\} . The following result is a key step in the proof of Theorem 1.1 . Theorem 3.1 . For each closed subset E of \mathbb{T} of Lebesgue measure zero, there exists a positive sequence u_{n}\to\infty with the following property: if \mathcal{F},\mathcal{F}^{\prime} are Hilbert spaces and if \Theta:(\mathbb{C}_{\infty}\setminus E)\to\mathcal{L}(\mathcal{F},\mathcal{F}^{\prime}) is a holomorphic function such that \Theta(\lambda) is purely contractive for all \lambda\in\mathbb{D} and unitary for all \lambda\in\mathbb{T}\setminus E , then \liminf_{n\to\infty}u_{n}\delta_{n}(\Theta)=0, where \delta_{n}(\Theta):=\inf_{\lambda\in\mathbb{D}}\max\bigl\{|\lambda|^{n},\|\Theta(\lambda)^{-1}\|^{-1}\bigr\}. (3) In [ 4 , Theorem 5.7] it was shown that Theorem 3.1 holds in the special case where \dim\mathcal{F}=\dim\mathcal{F}^{\prime}<\infty (leading to the version of Theorem 1.1 where \rank(I-T^{*}T)<\infty ). The technique used was to reduce to the scalar case \dim_{\mathcal{F}}=\dim\mathcal{F}^{\prime}=1 by taking determinants, and then to exploit the fact that, in that case, \Theta is a singular inner function, so has a representation in terms of a singular measure on E . In the case where \dim\mathcal{F}=\dim\mathcal{F}^{\prime}=\infty , we know of no such representation, and so the problem of proving Theorem 3.1 was left open [ 4 , Conjecture 7.1] . Using the removable singularity result Theorem 1.2 , we can now solve this problem. Before embarking upon on the proof of Theorem 3.1 , it will be convenient to establish an alternative formula for \delta_{n}(\Theta) . Lemma 3.2 . Let E,\mathcal{F},\mathcal{F}^{\prime},\Theta,\delta_{n}(\Theta) be as in the statement of Theorem 3.1 . Then 1/\delta_{n}(\Theta)=\sup_{|\lambda|>1}\min\bigl\{|\lambda|^{n},\|\Theta(\lambda)\|\bigr\}. (4) Proof. The function \lambda\mapsto\Theta(\lambda)\Theta(1/\overline{\lambda})^{*} is holomorphic on \mathbb{C}_{\infty}\setminus E and equal to the identity I when \lambda\in\mathbb{T}\setminus E . By the identity principle, it follows that \Theta(\lambda)\Theta(1/\overline{\lambda})^{*}=I for all \lambda\in\mathbb{C}_{\infty}\setminus E . The formula ( 4 ) follows easily. ∎ Proof of Theorem 3.1 . Let E be a closed subset of \mathbb{T} of Lebesgue measure zero. By Theorem 1.2 and a simple conformal-mapping argument, there exists a decreasing continuous function \omega:(0,\infty)\to(1,\infty) satisfying \lim_{t\to 0^{+}}\omega(t)=\infty with the following property: if \Omega is an open subset of \mathbb{C} containing E , and if f:\Omega\setminus E\to\mathbb{C} is a holomorphic function such that |f(re^{i\theta})|\leq\omega(|r-1|) for all re^{i\theta}\in\Omega\setminus\mathbb{T} , then f has a holomorphic extension to the whole of \Omega . For n\geq 1 , the function t\mapsto\omega(t)-(1+t)^{n}:(0,\infty)\to\mathbb{R} is continuous, strictly decreasing, tends to +\infty as t\to 0^{+} and to -\infty as t\to\infty . Therefore there exists a unique t_{n}\in(0,\infty) such that \omega(t_{n})=(1+t_{n})^{n} . Clearly the sequence (t_{n}) is strictly decreasing and t_{n}\to 0 as n\to\infty . Set u_{n}:=(1+t_{n+1})^{n/2}\quad(n\geq 1). Note that u_{n}=\omega(t_{n+1})^{n/(2n+2)}\quad(n\geq 1), which implies that u_{n}\to\infty . We shall show that this sequence (u_{n}) has the property prescribed in the statement of the theorem. Let \mathcal{F},\mathcal{F}^{\prime} be Hilbert spaces, and let \Theta:(\mathbb{C}_{\infty}\setminus E)\to\mathcal{L}(\mathcal{F},\mathcal{F}^{\prime}) be a holomorphic function such that \Theta(\lambda) is purely contractive for all \lambda\in\mathbb{D} and unitary for all \lambda\in\mathbb{T}\setminus E . Fix any \zeta_{0}\in\mathbb{T}\setminus E . Since \Theta(\zeta_{0}) is unitary, there exist unit vectors v\in\mathcal{F} and v^{\prime}\in\mathcal{F}^{\prime} such that \langle\Theta(\zeta_{0})v,v^{\prime}\rangle=1 . Define f:\mathbb{C}_{\infty}\setminus E\to\mathbb{C} by f(\lambda):=\langle\Theta(\lambda)v,v^{\prime}\rangle\quad(\lambda\in\mathbb{C}_{\infty}\setminus E). Clearly f is holomorphic on \mathbb{C}_{\infty}\setminus E and f(\zeta_{0})=1 . Also, as \Theta(\lambda) is purely contractive for each \lambda\in\mathbb{D} , we have |f(\lambda)|=|\langle\Theta(\lambda)v,v^{\prime}\rangle|\leq\|\Theta(\lambda)v\|<\|v\|=1\quad(\lambda\in\mathbb{D}). In particular, f is not constant. This implies that the set E is not a removable singularity for f . By the choice of \omega above, it follows that there exists a sequence (\lambda_{k}) in \mathbb{C}\setminus\mathbb{T} such that |\lambda_{k}|\to 1 and |f(\lambda_{k})|>\omega(||\lambda_{k}|-1|) for all k . As |f|\leq 1 on \mathbb{D} , all but finitely many (\lambda_{k}) lie outside \overline{\mathbb{D}} , so we may as well suppose that |\lambda_{k}|>1 for all k . For each k sufficiently large, there exists an n\geq 1 such that 1+t_{n+1}\leq|\lambda_{k}|\leq 1+t_{n} . Then, by the maximum principle applied on the exterior of |\lambda|=1+t_{n+1} , |f(\lambda_{k})|\leq\max_{|\lambda|=1+t_{n+1}}|f(\lambda)|\leq\max_{|\lambda|=1+t_{n+1}}\|\Theta(\lambda)\|, and hence 1<\frac{|f(\lambda_{k})|}{\omega(|\lambda_{k}|-1)}\leq\max_{|\lambda|=1+t_{n+1}}\frac{\|\Theta(\lambda)\|}{\omega(|\lambda_{k}|-1)}\leq\max_{|\lambda|=1+t_{n+1}}\frac{\|\Theta(\lambda)\|}{\omega(t_{n})}. By our choice of t_{n} , we have \omega(t_{n})=(1+t_{n})^{n} , and so 1<\max_{|\lambda|=1+t_{n+1}}\frac{\|\Theta(\lambda)\|}{(1+t_{n})^{n}}\leq\max_{|\lambda|=1+t_{n+1}}\frac{\|\Theta(\lambda)\|}{(1+t_{n+1})^{n}}=\max_{|\lambda|=1+t_{n+1}}\frac{\|\Theta(\lambda)\|}{|\lambda|^{n}}. Using ( 4 ), we deduce that \frac{1}{\delta_{n}(\Theta)}=\sup_{|\lambda|>1}\min\bigl\{|\lambda|^{n},\|\Theta(\lambda)\|\bigr\}\geq(1+t_{n+1})^{n}=u_{n}^{2}, the last equality by our choice of u_{n} . To summarize, we have shown that, for each n such that 1+t_{n+1}\leq|\lambda_{k}|\leq 1+t_{n} for some k , we have \delta_{n}(\Theta)\leq 1/u_{n}^{2} . Since |\lambda_{k}|\to 1 , there are infinitely many such n . Consequently \liminf_{n\to\infty}u_{n}\delta_{n}(\Theta)\leq\liminf_{n\to\infty}1/u_{n}=0. Thus the sequence (u_{n}) has the required property. ∎ It remains to show how Theorem 1.1 can be deduced using Theorem 3.1 . In fact this part of the argument was already explained in detail in [ 4 ] , so we shall just sketch the proof for the sake of completeness. Proof of Theorem 1.1 . Let E be a closed subset of \mathbb{T} of Lebesgue measure zero. Let (u_{n}) be a positive sequence tending to infinity and satisfying the conclusion of Theorem 3.1 . We shall show that, if T is a non-unitary Hilbert-space contraction such that \sigma(T)\subset E , then \limsup_{n\to\infty}\|T^{-n}\|/u_{n}=\infty , thereby proving Theorem 1.1 . Let T be a non-unitary Hilbert-space contraction such that \sigma(T)\subset E . By [ 4 , Lemma 6.1] , there is a completely non-unitary contraction T_{1} defined on a separable Hilbert space such that \sigma(T_{1})\subset\sigma(T) and \|T_{1}^{-n}\|\leq\|T^{-n}\| for all n . Thus, we may as well suppose from the outset that T is completely non-unitary and that it is defined on a separable Hilbert space. Together with the fact that \sigma(T) is a subset \mathbb{T} of Lebesgue measure zero, this implies that both T^{n} and T^{*n} converge strongly to zero as n\to\infty [ 4 , Lemma 6.2] . We now invoke a version of the Nagy–Foias model theorem for contractions [ 4 , Theorem 5.8] : since T is a contraction on a separable Hilbert space such that T^{*n} converges strongly to zero as n\to\infty , it is unitarily equivalent to S_{\Theta} , the compressed shift associated to an operator-valued inner function \Theta on \mathbb{D} . Thus \|T^{-n}\|=\|S_{\Theta}^{-n}\| for all n\geq 1 , and from [ 4 , Theorem 5.5] we have \|S_{\Theta}^{-n}\|\geq\frac{1}{2}\Bigl(\frac{1}{\delta_{n}(\Theta)}-1\Bigr)\quad(n\geq 1), where \delta_{n}(S_{\Theta}) is defined as in ( 3 ). Now by [ 4 , Theorem 5.9] , as T is non-unitary, \Theta can be chosen so that \Theta(\lambda) is purely contractive for each \lambda\in\mathbb{D} . Also, by [ 4 , Theorem 5.2] , since \sigma(T)\subset E , it follows that \Theta may be chosen so that it has a holomorphic extension to the whole of \mathbb{C}\setminus E and so that \Theta(\lambda) is unitary for all \lambda\in\mathbb{T}\setminus E . Thus \Theta satisfies all the hypotheses of Theorem 3.1 , and so by that theorem we deduce that \liminf_{n\to\infty}u_{n}\delta_{n}(\Theta)=0. Putting everything together, we obtain \limsup_{n\to\infty}\|T^{-n}\|/u_{n}=\limsup_{n\to\infty}\|S_{\Theta}^{-n}\|/u_{n}\geq(1/2)(\liminf_{n\to\infty}u_{n}\delta_{n}(\Theta))^{-1}=\infty, as was to be shown. ∎ Acknowledgements I am grateful to Fedja Nazarov for a valuable discussion on this topic, and in particular for suggesting the idea used in the proof of Lemma 2.1 . While this paper was being prepared, I learned from William Verreault that he too had (independently) found a proof of Theorem 3.1 . His proof, which is based on notions from potential theory and probability theory, is different from the one presented here. I thank him for sharing his ideas with me.