Covert Signaling for Communication and Sensing over the Bosonic Channels Tianrui Tan, Evan J. D. Anderson, Michael S. Bullock, Boulat A. Bash Abstract Preventing signal detection in communication and active sensing requires careful control of transmission power. In fact, the square-root laws (SRL) for covert classical and quantum communication and sensing prescribe that the average output power per channel use scales as 1 / n 1/\sqrt{n} for n n channel uses. Two strategies for achieving this are diffuse and sparse signaling. The former transmits signals with power decaying as 1 / n 1/\sqrt{n} on all n n channel uses, which is convenient for mathematical analysis. The latter transmits constant-power signals rarely, on approximately n \sqrt{n} out of n n channel uses, while remaining silent on the others. This offers significant practical advantages in compatibility with modern digital transmitters. Here, we study sparse signaling over lossy thermal-noise bosonic channels, which describe quantumly many practical channels (including optical, microwave, and radio-frequency). We characterize the input signal state that minimizes detectability. We find an unintuitive optimal quantum state structure: a mixture of just two consecutive photon-number states. In particular, in the low-brightness regime, the optimal signal state is a mixture of vacuum and a single photon. Since these states are generally suboptimal for both communication and active sensing, we explore the resulting trade-off and identify input-power thresholds for transitions between optimizing for covertness vs. performance in communication and sensing tasks. I Introduction Covert, or low-probability-of-detection/intercept (LPD/LPI), signaling addresses a security requirement that is distinct from encryption and secrecy: Alice must hide the existence of her transmission, not merely protect the information carried by it. An adversarial warden Willie observes the physical channel and attempts to decide whether Alice is silent or active. Alice must therefore communicate, or probe a target region, while keeping Willie’s received quantum state nearly indistinguishable from the state produced when Alice does not transmit. A fundamental feature of covert communication is the square-root law. Over n channel uses, and in the absence of additional uncertainty at Willie, Alice can transmit only O(\sqrt{n}) bits reliably while remaining covert; attempting to transmit more either makes the transmission detectable or prevents reliable decoding at Bob [ 1 , 2 ] . Equivalently, the asymptotic rate in bits per channel use is zero, even though a non-vanishing \sqrt{n} -scale amount of information can still be sent. The square-root law and its refinements have since been developed for additive white Gaussian noise channels, discrete memoryless channels, classical-quantum channels, and networked covert communication settings [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . For optical, microwave, and radio-frequency (RF) systems, the lossy thermal-noise bosonic channel provides the natural quantum-mechanical model of propagation loss and background noise. Each channel use corresponds to an electromagnetic-field mode, Alice’s inputs are quantum states of this mode, and Willie may in principle perform arbitrary quantum measurements on his received systems. Thus, even when coherent-state modulation and coherent detection reduce the problem to a classical Gaussian model, the ultimate covert limits require a quantum information-theoretic treatment. Prior work established the square-root law for quantum-secure covert communication over bosonic channels and characterized covert communication constants and capacities under classical-secret and entanglement-assisted resources [ 5 , 7 , 8 ] . These results show that thermal noise inaccessible to Willie is the resource that enables covert communication against a quantum-powerful warden. Covert active sensing imposes a closely related Willie-side constraint. Instead of transmitting a message to Bob, Alice probes a target region and tries to discriminate between target absence and target presence while remaining undetected. This setting is motivated by quantum illumination, where signal-idler correlations can improve target detection in noisy and lossy regimes. In the covert setting, Alice’s probing signal must also be hidden from Willie. Previous work studied signaling strategies for covert quantum sensing over lossy noisy bosonic channels and compared diffuse signaling, which spreads a small number of photons over many modes, with sparse signaling, which transmits actively in only a small fraction of modes [ 9 ] . The common feature in both covert communication and covert sensing is that Alice’s operational goal is limited by the distinguishability of Willie’s state from the innocent thermal state. The characterization of signaling schemes are central to this paper. Diffuse signaling is asymptotically natural: Alice uses nearly all modes but with vanishingly small energy in each mode. Sparse signaling instead keeps most modes silent and transmits only with a small activity probability. Although diffuse signaling is mathematically convenient, sparse signaling is practically important. In realistic radio-frequency implementations, finite converter resolutions, synchronization constraints, pulse-shaping requirements, and nonzero amplitude floors can prevent Alice from making every transmitted symbol arbitrarily weak. Recent software-defined-radio experiments therefore motivate sparse signaling as a physically relevant route to covert communication [ 10 ] . This paper asks the following structural question: under sparse signaling over a lossy thermal-noise bosonic channel, which active input state minimizes the covertness criteria under a mean photon number constraint? Existing covert-capacity results identify the \sqrt{n} -scaling and, for communication, characterize optimal throughput constants for particular resources and coding models. Existing covert-sensing work compares diffuse and sparse probing strategies. In contrast, our focus is the state-optimization problem inside sparse signaling itself: for a fixed per-mode brightness \bar{n}_{S} , how should the active state distribute its photon number so that Willie sees the smallest perturbation away from the innocent thermal state? Our main contribution is a structural characterization of the sparse-signaling state that minimizes Willie’s leading quantum relative entropy (QRE) coefficient. First, we show that the minimizer may be chosen Fock-diagonal. This reduces the optimization over quantum states to an optimization over photon-number distributions. Second, we derive the corresponding Willie-side QRE coefficient explicitly and express it using an orthogonal representation. This representation exposes the dependence of Willie’s detectability on the factorial moments of the input photon-number distribution. Finally, using a convexity argument, we show that an optimizer is supported on at most two consecutive Fock states. In the low-brightness regime relevant to covert operations this reduces to a vacuum single-photon mixture. We then relate this optimal sparse structure to covert communication and covert sensing performance. For communication, the low-brightness optimizer attains the Willie-side quadratic coefficient appearing in the bosonic covert-communication converse [ 7 ] . For sensing, the same optimizer matches the leading Willie-side quadratic coefficient of the diffuse scheme under matched transmitted mean photon number [ 9 ] . The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section II introduces the bosonic channel model, the communication and sensing settings, the covertness criterion, and the sparse-signaling model. Section III proves the optimal sparse input structure. Section IV specializes the result to the low-brightness covert regime and connects it to known covert communication and sensing results. Section V compares the resulting communication and sensing performance under the same Willie-side covertness constraint. Section VI concludes the paper. II Preliminaries Fig. 1 : The lossy thermal-noise bosonic channel \mathcal{E}_{A\to BC}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{\mathrm{B}}} is characterized by transmissivity \eta and thermal photon number \bar{n}_{\rm B} , with input subsystem A and output subsystems B and C . Environment is in a thermal state \hat{\rho}_{\rm th}(\bar{n}_{\mathrm{B}}) . The modal annihilation operators \hat{a} , \hat{b} , \hat{c} and \hat{e} are used to describe the input-output relationships in this channel. II-A System Model We first review the necessary bosonic systems and quantum optics background, deferring the details to a survey [ 11 ] and textbooks [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] . In our analysis of covert signaling we employ a lossy thermal-noise bosonic channel modeled by a beam splitter with environment mean photon number \bar{n}_{\textrm{B}} and transmittance \eta denoted by \mathcal{E}_{A\to BC}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}} . Fig. 1 depicts it. An electromagnetic-field mode at the transmitter’s center frequency is the fundamental unit of information transmission in our work, akin to a channel use in classical information theory. System A describes the input mode, while system E is the input from the environment in a thermal state \hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right) . Systems B and C describe the outputs. These are related to the inputs using the bosonic modal annihilation operators \hat{a} (input), \hat{e} (environment), \hat{b} , and \hat{c} (outputs). For a beamsplitter these are \hat{b}=\sqrt{\eta}\,\hat{a}+\sqrt{1-\eta}\,\hat{e} and \hat{c}=\sqrt{1-\eta}\,\hat{a}-\sqrt{\eta}\,\hat{e} . One of the output modes corresponds to the intended receiver while the other to loss of signal to the environment and/or the adversary. This describes quantum mechanically many practical channels, including optical, microwave, and radio-frequency (RF) [ 11 ] . For a single bosonic mode, the Fock state (or photon-number state) \ket{i} describes the state containing exactly i photons. Equivalently, \ket{i} is an eigenbasis of the photon-number operator \hat{N}=\hat{a}^{\dagger}\hat{a} , satisfying \hat{N}\ket{i}=i\ket{i} , where \hat{a} and \hat{a}^{\dagger} are the annihilation and creation operators, respectively. Set \{\ket{i}\}_{i\geq 0} forms an orthonormal basis for the Hilbert space of the single bosonic mode, with \sum_{i=0}^{\infty}\ket{i}\bra{i}=\mathbb{I} [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] . Any quantum state of a bosonic mode can therefore be represented in the Fock basis: \hat{\rho}=\sum_{i,i^{\prime}=0}^{\infty}\rho_{ii^{\prime}}\,|i\rangle\langle i^{\prime}| , where the diagonal elements \rho_{ii} specify the photon-number distribution, and the off-diagonal elements \rho_{i,i^{\prime}\neq i} encode phase relations. For example, the thermal state with mean photon number \bar{n}_{\textrm{B}} describing the environment of a bosonic channel \mathcal{E}_{A\to BC}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}} is \hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right)=\sum_{i=0}\lambda_{i}\,\ket{i}\bra{i}, with \lambda_{i}=\frac{(\bar{n}_{B})^{i}}{(1+\bar{n}_{B})^{i+1}} . Note that \hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(0\right)=\ket{0}\bra{0} is a vacuum state [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] . As in our earlier works [ 5 , 16 , 8 , 17 , 18 ] , our system employs n=2TW orthogonal modes, which is the product of time T available for transmission, bandwidth W around the transmitter’s center frequency, and the factor two corresponding to the use of both orthogonal polarizations. Thus, we consider covert communication and active sensing settings where Alice’s transmission is an n -mode quantum state \hat{\rho}_{A}^{n} . (a) Covert communication (b) Covert sensing Fig. 2 : Systems models for covert communication and sensing. In both models, adversary Willie has to decide whether Alice transmits based on his observed state. When she does not transmit he receives thermal state. 1 Communication Model We model communication by a single thermal-loss bosonic channel \mathcal{E}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{\text{B}}}_{A\to BW} depicted in Fig. 2(a) . Denote the Alice-to-Bob message set by \mathcal{M} and suppose that each message m\in\mathcal{M} is equiprobable. Alice encodes m in an n -mode state \hat{\rho}_{A}^{n}(m) and transmits it to Bob via n independent uses of \mathcal{E}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{\text{B}}}_{A\to BW} . Bob receives the n -mode output state \hat{\rho}_{B}^{n}(m)=\tr_{W}\!\left[\left(\mathcal{E}_{A\to BW}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{B}}\right)^{\otimes n}\!\left(\hat{\rho}_{A}^{n}(m)\right)\right], and attempts to decode using a positive operator-valued measure (POVM) \left\{{\Lambda}_{m}^{n}\right\}_{m\in\mathcal{M}},~\sum_{m\in\mathcal{M}}{\Lambda}_{m}^{n}=\mathbb{I}_{B}^{\otimes n} , to produce an estimate \check{m} of the transmitted message. Accordingly, Bob’s decoding task is to infer m from \hat{\rho}_{B}^{n}(m) with vanishing error probability [ 8 ] . Formally, the average decoding error probability is P_{\text{e}}^{\text{(b)}}=\frac{1}{|\mathcal{M}|}\sum_{m\in\mathcal{M}}\Pr\!\left\{\check{M}\neq m\,\big|M=m\right\}=\frac{1}{|\mathcal{M}|}\sum_{m\in\mathcal{M}}\left(\tr\!\left[(\mathbb{I}-{\Lambda}_{m})\,\hat{\rho}_{B}^{n}(m)\right]\right), where M and \check{M} are the random variables describing the transmitted message m and its estimate \check{m} . Reliability requires that P_{\text{e}}^{\text{(b)}}\to 0 as n\to\infty . In covert communication, one may additionally allow Alice and Bob to share a resource that is not accessible by the adversary. This can be a source of either classical randomness or quantum entanglement. Here, we focus on the former, that it, on covert communication that uses a pre-shared classical secret key k\in\mathcal{K} to randomize the encoder and, hence, the ensemble observed by the Willie [ 5 , 7 , 8 ] . Thus, in fact, Alice transmits \hat{\rho}_{A}^{n}(m,k) and Bob uses POVM \left\{{\Lambda}_{m,k}^{n}\right\}_{m\in\mathcal{M}} . However, we defer the analyses of the key size and the entanglement-assisted covert communication to future work. 2 Sensing Model We study the covert version [ 9 ] of quantum-illumination-based binary target detection [ 19 ] , depicted in Fig. 2(b) . Alice prepares an n -mode signal-reference state \hat{\rho}_{IS}^{n} . Alice retains reference (“idler”) modes I . Signal modes S interrogate the target, modeled by a pure-loss bosonic channel \mathcal{E}^{\gamma^{(h)},0}_{S\to R^{\prime}W^{\prime}} , where transmittance to Willie \gamma^{(h)} depends on whether the target is absent ( h=0 , \gamma^{(0)}=1 ) or present ( h=1 , \gamma^{(1)}<1 ). Lossy thermal-noise bosonic channels \mathcal{E}^{\tau_{A},\bar{n}_{A}}_{R^{\prime}\to R} and \mathcal{E}^{\tau_{W},\bar{n}_{W}}_{W^{\prime}\to W} corrupt the light that the target reflects to Alice (modes R^{\prime} ) and transmits to Willie (modes W^{\prime} ), respectively. Note that one of the output modes in both channels is lost to the environment. Alice detects the presence of the target by performing a hypothesis test on the reference and returned modes I and R in the following quantum state: \displaystyle\hat{\rho}_{IR}^{n}(h) \displaystyle=\left(\mathcal{I}_{I\to I}\otimes\mathcal{E}^{(1-\gamma^{(h)})\tau_{A},(1-\tau_{A})\bar{n}_{A}}_{S\to R}\right)^{\otimes n}\!\left(\hat{\rho}_{IS}^{n}\right), (1) where \mathcal{I}_{I\to I} is an identity channel and \displaystyle\mathcal{E}^{(1-\gamma^{(h)})\tau_{A},(1-\tau_{A})\bar{n}_{A}}_{S\to R} \displaystyle=\mathcal{E}^{\tau_{A},\bar{n}_{A}}_{R^{\prime}\to R}\left(\tr_{W^{\prime}}\left[\mathcal{E}^{\gamma^{(h)},0}_{S\to R^{\prime}W^{\prime}}(\hat{\rho}_{S})\right]\right). (2) Note that, since probes are not returned when target is absent ( h=0 ), \hat{\rho}_{IR}^{n}(h)=\tr_{S}\!\left[\hat{\rho}_{I^{n}S^{n}}\right]\otimes\hat{\rho}_{\mathrm{th}}\!\left((1-\tau_{A})\bar{n}_{A}\right)^{\otimes n} , i.e., a product of reference and thermal states. Denote by H_{0} and H_{1} the respective hypotheses that the target is absent and present. For equal prior probabilities, \Pr(H_{0}\text{ true})=\Pr(H_{1}\text{ true})=1/2 , Alice’s detection performance is quantified by the error probability P_{e}^{(s)}=\frac{P_{\text{FA}}+P_{\text{MD}}}{2}, where P_{\text{FA}}=\Pr\!\left(\text{choose }H_{1}\mid H_{0}\text{ true}\right) , and P_{\text{MD}}=\Pr\!\left(\text{choose }H_{0}\mid H_{1}\text{ true}\right) , and her task is to find a binary measurement and corresponding decision rule that minimizes P_{\mathrm{e}}^{\mathrm{(s)}} . The minimum achievable value is given by the Helstrom limit [ 20 ] [ 21 , Sec. 9.1.4] , \displaystyle P_{\mathrm{e},\min}^{(\mathrm{s})}=\frac{1}{2}\left(1-\frac{1}{2}\left\|\hat{\rho}_{IR}^{n}(1)-\hat{\rho}_{IR}^{n}(0)\right\|_{1}\right), (3) where \left\|\hat{A}\right\|_{1}=\tr\left[\sqrt{\hat{A}^{\dagger}\hat{A}}\right] is the trace norm. In both communication and active sensing, Alice’s objective is to carry out her transmission while remaining undetected by the adversarial warden Willie. This requirement motivates the covertness criteria introduced next. II-B Covertness criteria Covertness is defined through Willie’s ability to distinguish whether Alice is transmitting or not. When silent, she inputs innocent vacuum state \hat{\rho}^{n}_{A}=\ket{0}\bra{0}^{\otimes n} , which yields an n -mode thermal state at Willie, \hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}^{\otimes n}(\eta\bar{n}_{B}) for communication and \hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}^{\otimes n}\left(\left(1-\tau_{W}\right)\bar{n}_{W}\right) for sensing. Consider Alice transmitting in the communication setting. The n -mode state \hat{\rho}_{W}^{n}=\frac{1}{|\mathcal{M}|}\frac{1}{|\mathcal{K}|}\sum_{m,k}\tr_{W}\left[\left[\mathcal{E}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{\text{B}}}_{A\to BW}\right]^{\otimes n}\left(\hat{\rho}_{A}^{n}(m,k)\right)\right] is Willie’s output of channel \mathcal{E}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{\text{B}}}_{A\to BW} averaged over messages in \mathcal{M} and the secret from \mathcal{K} inaccessible by Willie. In the sensing setting, Willie’s received state depends on the target: \hat{\rho}_{W,h}^{n}=\left(\mathcal{E}^{\tau_{W},\bar{n}_{W}}_{W^{\prime}\to W}\right)^{\otimes n}\left(\tr_{IR^{\prime}}\left[\left(\mathcal{I}_{I\to I}\otimes\mathcal{E}^{\gamma^{(h)},0}_{S\to R^{\prime}W^{\prime}}\right)^{\otimes n}\!\left(\hat{\rho}_{IS}^{n}\right)\right]\right) , where h\in\{0,1\} indicates target’s presence. As in [ 1 , 2 ] , we call a system covert if Willie’s average detection error probability P_{\rm e}^{\text{(w)}}\geq\frac{1}{2}-\delta for small \delta>0 . Like P_{\rm e}^{\text{(s)}} in ( 3 ), it is bounded by expressions involving the trace distance. For communication it is: \displaystyle P_{\rm e}^{\text{(w)}} \displaystyle\geq\frac{1}{2}\left(1-\frac{1}{2}\left\|\hat{\rho}_{W}^{n}-\hat{\rho}_{\mathrm{th}}^{\otimes n}(\eta\bar{n}_{B})\right\|_{1}\right), (4) whereas for sensing it is: \displaystyle P_{\rm e}^{\text{(w)}} \displaystyle\geq\frac{1}{2}\left(1-\max_{h\in\{0,1\}}\frac{1}{2}\left\|\hat{\rho}_{W,h}^{n}-\hat{\rho}_{\mathrm{th}}^{\otimes n}\left(\left(1-\tau_{W}\right)\bar{n}_{W}\right)\right\|_{1}\right). (5) Numerical evaluation suggests that the target-absent case ( h=0 ) minimizes the lower bound in ( 5 ); we defer confirming this analytically to future work. The trace distance is often mathematically inconvenient, however the quantum relative entropy (QRE) upper bounds it via the quantum Pinsker’s inequality [ 21 , Th. 11.9.1] : \frac{1}{2}\left\|\hat{\rho}-\hat{\sigma}\right\|_{1}\leq\sqrt{\frac{1}{2}D\!\left(\hat{\rho}\middle\|\hat{\sigma}\right)} . QRE is also additive over the product states. Therefore, as is common practice in the covertness literature [ 5 , 7 , 22 , 9 , 23 ] , we use it to define our covertness constraint directly: the communication and sensing systems are covert if: \displaystyle D\left(\hat{\rho}_{W}^{n}\middle\|\hat{\rho}_{\mathrm{th}}^{\otimes n}(\eta\bar{n}_{B})\right) \displaystyle\leq\delta_{\text{QRE}} \displaystyle\max_{h\in\{0,1\}}D\left(\hat{\rho}_{W,h}^{n}\middle\|\hat{\rho}_{\mathrm{th}}^{\otimes n}\left(\left(1-\tau_{W}\right)\bar{n}_{W}\right)\right) \displaystyle\leq\delta_{\text{QRE}}. (6) Setting \delta_{\text{QRE}}=8\delta^{2} meets the constraints in ( 4 ) and ( 5 ). II-C Signaling Scheme This covertness criterion requires the average transmitted energy per mode to scale as \frac{1}{\sqrt{n}} [ 1 , 2 ] . In the sparse signaling scheme considered next, this scaling is achieved by letting the fraction of active modes \alpha to vanish as n\to\infty . As previous research studied, in covert communication and sensing, signaling schemes are classified according to how transmission activity is distributed across channel uses. Under a covertness constraint, Alice must ensure that the induced change at Willie is sufficiently small. Broadly speaking, Alice may either distribute a weak signal over essentially all channel uses, or instead transmit only rarely while keeping most uses identical to vacuum. These two schemes are called diffuse signaling and sparse signaling, respectively. In diffuse signaling, the Alice employs nearly every channel use, but with very low per-use energy. Covertness is then maintained by ensuring that each individual use produces only a slight difference relative to the innocent background. This signaling regime was studied heavily in [ 9 ] . However, in radio frequency covert communication, finite data converter resolution and synchronization constraints make sparse signaling experimentally important and practical [ 10 ] . Therefore, our focus is on sparse signaling. In this scheme, the transmitter remains silent for most channel uses and only occasionally sends a nontrivial signal state. We can describe the ensemble-averaged single-mode input state by assigning a vanishing probability \alpha to the active input signal state \hat{\rho}_{A} and probability 1-\alpha to the innocent input vacuum state \ket{0}\bra{0} , with 0<\alpha<1 . \displaystyle\hat{\rho}_{\text{sp}}=(1-\alpha)\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(0\right)+\alpha\hat{\rho}_{A}, (7) After \hat{\rho}_{\text{sp}} goes through the lossy thermal-noise channel \mathcal{E}_{A\to BC}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}} described earlier, the ensemble-averaged single-mode output state Willie observed is a sparse state of the form \displaystyle\hat{\rho}_{\alpha}=(1-\alpha)\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right)+\alpha\hat{\rho}_{W}, (8) where \displaystyle\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right)=\sum_{\ell=0}^{\infty}\lambda_{\ell}\ket{\ell}\bra{\ell},\quad\lambda_{\ell}=\frac{(\eta\bar{n}_{B})^{\ell}}{(1+\eta\bar{n}_{B})^{\ell+1}}, (9) is the attenuated thermal output state and \hat{\rho}_{W} is the output state induced by the active input, and over n i.i.d modes his average state is \hat{\rho}_{W_{\alpha}}^{n}=\hat{\rho}_{\alpha}^{\otimes n} . Over n modes, the sparse signaling model describes transmission on a vanishing fraction of modes \alpha with fixed input mean photon number \bar{n}_{S} , while the remaining modes are kept in the vacuum state. This sparse-mixture is the structure is the foundation for our optimization of covert signaling states. III Characterization Of Sparse Signaling In sparse signaling the input state mean photon number \bar{n}_{S} is fixed and covertness is achieved through the vanishing transmission probability \alpha . Now, because the state seen by Willie is a convex mixture of the innocent and active states, so the QRE-covert criteria is governed by its behavior in \alpha rather than by the signal energy or a physical channel parameter. Inspired by the QRE perturbation framework of [ 24 ] , we proceed through a data-processing argument that is well suited to the infinite-dimensional bosonic setting. We apply the data-processing inequality for QRE to the sparse output state \hat{\rho}_{\alpha} in ( 8 ) to show that the covertness minimizer may be chosen to be diagonal in the Fock basis under mean photon number constraint \tr(\hat{\rho}_{A}\hat{N})=\bar{n}_{S} . The main result shows that the minimizer is supported on at most two consecutive Fock states. III-A Optimal Input State under Sparse Signaling Definition III.1 . (Phase rotation unitary). With number operator \hat{N}=a^{\dagger}a , where a is the complex amplitude of input mode function. The phase-rotation unitary \displaystyle U_{\phi}=e^{-i\phi\hat{N}},\qquad\phi\in[0,2\pi). (10) Definition III.2 (Dephasing channel) . \displaystyle\Delta(\hat{\rho})=\sum_{\ell=0}^{\infty}|\ell\rangle\langle\ell|\hat{\rho}|\ell\rangle\langle\ell|. (11) Equivalently, \displaystyle\Delta(\hat{\rho})=\int_{0}^{2\pi}e^{i\phi\hat{N}}\hat{\rho}e^{-i\phi\hat{N}}\frac{d\phi}{2\pi}. (12) Thus the dephasing channel removes the off-diagonal entries of \hat{\rho} in the Fock basis and resulting an Fock-diagonal state. Since \hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right) is diagonal in the Fock basis, \Delta(\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right))=\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right) . Also, dephasing preserves the mean photon number: \tr[\Delta(\hat{\rho}_{A})\hat{N}]=\tr[\hat{\rho}_{A}\hat{N}]. Definition III.3 . (Phase covariant channel) A channel \mathcal{N}_{A\to B} is phase-covariant if, \displaystyle\mathcal{N}_{A\to B}(U_{\phi}\hat{\rho}U_{\phi}^{\dagger})=U_{\phi}\,\mathcal{N}_{A\to B}(\hat{\rho})U_{\phi}^{\dagger}\quad\forall\phi. (13) where \mathcal{N}_{A\to B} is a linear, completely positive, and trace-preserving (CPTP) map. The thermal-lossy channel are the dephasing channel are phase covariant [ 25 , 26 ] . The arguments are that lossy thermal-noise channel commutes with phase rotations and because the channel loss interaction and the thermal noise are phase-insensitive, Similarly, the Fock-basis dephasing channel is phase covariant because it is defined by photon-number basis \ket{\ell}\bra{\ell} , which are invariant under phase rotations. We now state the primary result of this section. Theorem 1 (Optimal sparse input state structure) . For any single-mode quantum input state with mean photon number \bar{n}_{S} , the sparse QRE second-order coefficient is minimized by an Fock-diagonal state supported on at most two consecutive Fock states. Specifically, let \kappa=\lfloor\bar{n}_{S}\rfloor , then there exists an optimizer of the form \hat{\rho}_{A,{\text{opt}}}=\sum_{i\geq 0}\rho_{i}|i\rangle\langle i| , with \rho_{\kappa}=\kappa+1-\bar{n}_{S},~\rho_{\kappa+1}=\bar{n}_{S}-\kappa , and \rho_{i}=0 for all i\notin\{\kappa,\kappa+1\} . More explicitly, \displaystyle\hat{\rho}_{A,{\text{opt}}}=(\kappa+1-\bar{n}_{S})\,|\kappa\rangle\langle\kappa|+(\bar{n}_{S}-\kappa)\,|\kappa+1\rangle\langle\kappa+1|. (14) Proof: Construction: The proof is developed through the sequence of results below. We first show that, after data processing under dephasing, the optimization may be restricted to Fock-diagonal input states. Then, we derive the corresponding Willie-side perturbation coefficient C_{P} explicitly. Hence, the sparse-covertness problem reduces to minimizing C_{P} over the input distribution \rho_{i} . Next, We exploit orthogonal structure of C_{P} which exposes its dependence on the input factorial moments. Finally, combining this representation with a discrete-convexity argument yields an optimizer supported on at most two consecutive Fock states. The detailed steps are given in sec III-B , lemmas 1 – 4 and the resulting corollary 1 . III-B Dephasing reduction For sparse signaling, the QRE-covert criteria is \displaystyle D(\hat{\rho}_{\alpha}\|\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right)) (15) The goal is to minimize this quantity and find a potential minimizer input state under the mean photon constraint. Note that, since lossy thermal-noise channel and dephasing channel are both phase covariant, dephasing before thermal loss at Alice’s sparse input state \hat{\rho}_{\text{sp}} is equivalent to dephasing after the channel at Willie’s sparse output state \hat{\rho}_{\alpha} , \displaystyle\Delta(\hat{\rho}_{\alpha}) \displaystyle=(1-\alpha)\Delta\left(\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}})\right)+\alpha\Delta(\hat{\rho}_{W}) \displaystyle=\Delta\left(\mathcal{E}_{A\to BC}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}}\left(\hat{\rho}_{\text{sp}}\right)\right) \displaystyle=(1-\alpha)\mathcal{E}_{A\to BC}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}}\left(\Delta(\ket{0}\bra{0})\right)+\alpha\mathcal{E}_{A\to BC}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}}\left(\Delta(\hat{\rho}_{A})\right). (16) and using the fact that \hat{\rho}_{\mathrm{th}} is diagonal in the Fock basis, so it is dephasing invariant, \Delta\left(\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\right)=\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}} . Now, by the data-processing inequality for QRE, \displaystyle D\left(\hat{\rho}_{\alpha}\|\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right)\right)\geq D\left(\Delta\left(\hat{\rho}_{\alpha}\right)\|\Delta\left(\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right)\right)\right). (17) Substitute ( III-B ) into ( 17 ) Concluding, \displaystyle D\left(\hat{\rho}_{\alpha}\|\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right)\right)\geq D\left(\mathcal{E}_{A\to BC}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}}\left(\Delta\left(\hat{\rho}_{\text{sp}}\right)\right)\|\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right)\right), (18) Thus, for every feasible input state \hat{\rho}_{A} , the Fock-diagonal input \Delta(\hat{\rho}_{A}) is also feasible and gives Willie a QRE no larger than the original one. Therefore, there is no loss of optimality in restricting the covertness minimization under mean photon constraint \tr[\hat{\rho}_{A}\hat{N}] to Fock-diagonal inputs. III-C QRE diagonal perturbation expansion We now consider a single bosonic mode A at the channel input, prepared in a diagonal state supported on the truncated Fock subspace \mathcal{H}_{j}=\mathrm{span}\{\ket{0},\ket{1},\ldots,\ket{j}\} . The mode A propagates through a thermal lossy bosonic channel that mix the input with an environment mode E in a thermal state. We derive the output state seen by Willie in the Fock diagonal basis by producing the characteristic function inversion. Lemma 1 (Willie’s active output photon-number distribution) . Let \hat{\rho}_{A}=\sum_{i=0}^{j}\rho_{i}\ket{i}\!\bra{i} , with \rho_{i}\geq 0 and \sum_{i=0}^{j}\rho_{i}=1 . Suppose that the input state passes through a thermal lossy bosonic channel, \mathcal{E}_{A\to BC}^{\eta,\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}} . Then Willie’s output state is diagonal in the Fock basis and can be written as \displaystyle\hat{\rho}_{W}=\sum_{\ell=0}^{\infty}p_{\ell}\ket{\ell}\!\bra{\ell}. (19) Moreover, for every \ell\geq 0, the output photon-number probability p_{\ell} admits the integral representation \displaystyle p_{\ell}=\sum_{i=0}^{j}\rho_{i}\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-(1+\eta\bar{n}_{B})x}L_{\ell}(x)\,L_{i}\!\bigl((1-\eta)x\bigr)\,dx, (20) where L_{n}(\cdot) denotes the Laguerre polynomial of degree n . Equivalently, p_{\ell} admit the explicit finite-sum representation \displaystyle p_{\ell} \displaystyle=\sum_{i=0}^{j}\rho_{i}\sum_{t=0}^{i}\sum_{u=0}^{\ell} \displaystyle(-1)^{t+u}\binom{i}{t}\binom{\ell}{u} \displaystyle(1-\eta)^{t}\frac{(t+u)!}{t!\,u!}\frac{1}{(1+\eta\bar{n}_{b})^{t+u+1}}. (21) The proof relies on the characteristic-function description of the lossy thermal-noise channel. Specifically, we first express Willie’s output characteristic function through the beam-splitter input–environment decomposition and show that, for a Fock-diagonal truncated input, the input dependence is captured by Laguerre polynomials. We then invert the characteristic function in the Fock basis; after converting to polar coordinates, the angular integration forces the off-diagonal matrix elements to vanish, which establishes the diagonal form of Willie’s output and yields the integral formula for its photon-number distribution. Finally, a term-by-term expansion of the Laguerre polynomials leads directly to the closed-form finite-sum representation. The full proof is given in Appendix A . As a consequence of the diagonal form of Willie’s active output, the Willie-side sparse QRE admits the following explicit second-order expression. Lemma 2 (Second-order expansion of sparse QRE) . Let the sparse state ( 8 ) be \hat{\rho}_{\alpha}=(1-\alpha)\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right)+\alpha\hat{\rho}_{W}, where \hat{\rho}_{W} the active Willie’s output state is diagonal in the Fock basis (Lemma 1 ), \hat{\rho}_{W}=\sum_{\ell=0}^{\infty}p_{\ell}\ket{\ell}\bra{\ell}. Then, the Willie-side QRE admits the expansion \displaystyle D(\hat{\rho}_{\alpha}\|\hat{\rho}_{\text{th}\left(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right)})=\frac{\alpha^{2}}{2}C_{W}+o(\alpha^{2}), (22) Where C_{W} is the QRE coefficient for corresponding general input states. For the state in ( 19 ) C_{W} is the perturbation coeffeicent C_{P} \displaystyle C_{P}=\sum_{\ell=0}^{\infty}\frac{(p_{\ell}-\lambda_{\ell})^{2}}{\lambda_{\ell}}, (23) and p_{\ell} is expressed in ( 20 ) and ( 1 ). The proof of lemma 2 is straightforward. Since \hat{\rho}_{\alpha} and \hat{\rho}_{\text{th}}\left(\eta\bar{n}_{\textrm{B}}\right) commutes, the QRE reduces to a classical Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence. Hence, the problem becomes a scalar second order Taylor expansion. The detailed derivation is in Appendix B III-D Orthogonal Structural Optimization The representation of the perturbation coefficient C_{P} in lemma 2 is explicit, but it is not yet for clear structural analysis or optimization. Indeed, in ( 23 ), C_{P} is expressed through the output photon number probabilities p_{\ell} , and each p_{\ell} depends on the entire input distribution through the lossy thermal channel. As a result, the contribution of a given input Fock component is spread across all output photon numbers, and the dependence of C_{P} on \rho_{i} is hidden inside a complicated expression, which makes it difficult to identify which features of the input state increase detectability at Willie. To obtain a more informative characterization, we next derive an orthogonal representation of C_{P} . This representation rewrites the same perturbation coefficient as a weighted sum of squares of input-dependent moment quantities. In particular, it exposes how the photon number structure is penalized, and provides the key tool for proving the sparse optimal-input structure established in Theorem 1 . Definition III.4 (Meixner polynomials) . (See [ 27 , Section 1.1.9] ) For 01, (112) yields \displaystyle\sum_{i=0}^{\infty}R_{i}(\ell)s^{i}=\frac{G_{\ell}(s)}{\lambda_{\ell}}=\bigl(1+(\theta/q-1)s\bigr)^{\ell}\bigl(1+(\theta-1)s\bigr)^{-\ell-1}. (113) On the other hand, using ( 107 ) with \nu=-\frac{\theta~s}{1-s} , together with the binomial-series identity \displaystyle\sum_{i=y}^{\infty}\binom{i}{y}s^{i}=\frac{s^{y}}{(1-s)^{y+1}},\qquad y=0,1,2,\dots, (114) one checks that \displaystyle\sum_{i=0}^{\infty}\left(\sum_{y=0}^{i}\binom{i}{y}(-\theta)^{y}M_{y}(\ell;q)\right)s^{i} \displaystyle=\bigl(1+(\theta/q-1)s\bigr)^{\ell}\bigl(1+(\theta-1)s\bigr)^{-\ell-1}. (115) Comparing ( 113 ) and ( 115 ) shows that, for every i\geq 0 , \displaystyle R_{i}(\ell)=\sum_{y=0}^{i}\binom{i}{y}(-\theta)^{y}M_{y}(\ell;q). (116) Since R_{0}(\ell)=1 , it follows from ( 103 ) and ( 116 ) that \displaystyle S(\ell)-1 \displaystyle=\sum_{i=1}^{j}\rho_{i}\bigl(R_{i}(\ell)-1\bigr) \displaystyle=\sum_{i=1}^{j}\rho_{i}\sum_{y=1}^{i}\binom{i}{y}(-\theta)^{y}M_{y}(\ell;q) \displaystyle=\sum_{y=1}^{j}\left[(-\theta)^{y}\sum_{i=y}^{j}\rho_{i}\binom{i}{y}\right]M_{y}(\ell;q). (117) Define \displaystyle\mu_{y}=\sum_{i=y}^{j}\rho_{i}\binom{i}{y},\qquad y=1,2,\dots,j. (118) Then ( 117 ) becomes \displaystyle S(\ell)-1=\sum_{y=1}^{j}b_{y}M_{y}(\ell;q),\qquad b_{y}=(-\theta)^{y}\mu_{y}. (119) Finally, substituting ( 119 ) into ( 104 ) gives \displaystyle C_{P} \displaystyle=\sum_{\ell=0}^{\infty}\lambda_{\ell}\left(\sum_{y=1}^{j}b_{y}M_{y}(\ell;q)\right)^{2} \displaystyle=\sum_{y=1}^{j}\sum_{y^{\prime}=1}^{j}b_{y}b_{y^{\prime}}\sum_{\ell=0}^{\infty}\lambda_{\ell}M_{y}(\ell;q)M_{y^{\prime}}(\ell;q). (120) Applying the orthogonality relation ( 108 ), all cross terms vanish and we obtain \displaystyle C=\sum_{y=1}^{j}q^{-y}b_{y}^{2}=\sum_{y=1}^{j}q^{-y}\theta^{2y}\mu_{y}^{2},\quad\mu_{y}=\sum_{i=y}^{j}\rho_{i}\binom{i}{y}. (121) which is precisely the claimed orthogonal representation. This completes the proof. ∎ Appendix D Proof: Let \mathbb{E}[\mathrm{I}]=\kappa+\beta , where \kappa=\lfloor\mathbb{E}[\mathrm{I}]\rfloor and \beta\in[0,1) . Define \displaystyle g=\varphi(\tau+1)-\varphi(\tau). (122) Since \varphi is discrete convex, the increments \varphi(i+1)-\varphi(i) are nondecreasing in i . We claim that \displaystyle\varphi(i)\geq\varphi(\kappa)+g(i-\kappa),\qquad i\in\mathbb{Z}_{\geq 0}. (123) For i\geq\kappa , \displaystyle\varphi(i)-\varphi(\kappa)=\sum_{\kappa^{\prime}=\kappa}^{i-1}\bigl(\varphi(\kappa^{\prime}+1)-\varphi(\kappa^{\prime})\bigr)\geq\sum_{\kappa^{\prime}=\kappa}^{i-1}g=g(i-\kappa), (124) because each increment in the sum is at least g . For i\leq\kappa , \displaystyle\varphi(\kappa)-\varphi(i)=\sum_{\kappa^{\prime}=i}^{\kappa-1}\bigl(\varphi(\kappa^{\prime}+1)-\varphi(\kappa^{\prime})\bigr)\leq\sum_{\kappa^{\prime}=i}^{\kappa-1}g=g(\kappa-i), (125) because each increment in the sum is at most g . Rearranging again gives ( 123 ). Thus ( 123 ) holds for all i\geq 0 . Taking expectation with respect to \mathrm{I} yields \displaystyle\mathbb{E}[\varphi(\mathrm{I})]\geq\mathbb{E}\!\left[\varphi(\kappa)+g(\mathrm{I}-\kappa)\right] \displaystyle=\varphi(\kappa)+g\bigl(\mathbb{E}[\mathrm{I}]-\kappa\bigr) \displaystyle=\varphi(\kappa)+g\beta. (126) Substituting g=\varphi(\kappa+1)-\varphi(\kappa) , we obtain \displaystyle\mathbb{E}[\varphi(\mathrm{I})]\geq(1-\beta)\varphi(\kappa)+\beta\varphi(\kappa+1), (127) which proves ( 31 ). Finally, if \Pr[\mathrm{I}=\kappa]=1-\beta and \Pr[\mathrm{I}=\kappa+1]=\beta , then \mathbb{E}[\mathrm{I}]=\kappa+\beta and \displaystyle\mathbb{E}[\varphi(\mathrm{I})]=(1-\beta)\varphi(\kappa)+\beta\varphi(\kappa+1), (128) so equality holds. This completes the proof. ∎