Late-time tails for linear waves on radially symmetric stationary spacetimes of two space dimensions Onyx Gautam Abstract . We show that the leading-order term in the late-time asymptotics of solutions to the linear wave equation on radially symmetric stationary perturbations of ( 2 + 1 ) (2+1) -dimensional Minkowski space is proportional to u − 1 / 2 v − 1 / 2 u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2} (which solves the wave equation on Minkowski space), where u u and v v are double null coordinates. Our proof adapts the physical space techniques in the work of Gajic [ Gaj23 ] on the wave equation with an inverse-square potential on the Schwarzschild spacetime. In particular, we extend the r p r^{p} -weighted energy estimates of Dafermos–Rodnianski [ DR09 ] to two space dimensions. 1. Introduction We are interested in solutions to the linear wave equation on spacetimes of two space dimensions: (1.1) \Box{}_{g}\varphi{}=0. Our main result determines the leading-order late-time asymptotics of solutions to eq. 1.1 when the metric g is a radially symmetric stationary perturbation of the Minkowski metric. Theorem 1.1 (Main theorem on leading-order late-time asymptotics, rough version) . Let g be a Lorentzian metric on \mathbf{R}^{2+1} that is a small, stationary, radially symmetric, and asymptotically flat perturbation of the Minkowski metric. Let (u,v,\theta{}) be a double null coordinate system on (\mathbf{R}^{2+1},g) normalized as in Minkowski space. Then there is \delta{}>0 such that for large values of u , solutions \varphi{} of eq. 1.1 arising from suitably regular and decaying initial data satisfy (1.2) \varphi{}(u,v,\theta{})=\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2}+O(u^{-1/2-\delta{}}v^{-1/2}). Here \mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}] is a linear functional of the initial data for \varphi{} , and the implicit constant in the big- O notation depends on a weighted Sobolev norm of the initial data. Moreover, the estimate eq. 1.2 is stable under differentiation by r\partial{}_{v} and uT , where r is the area-radius function associated to the orbits of radial symmetry and T is the Killing vector field associated to stationarity. See theorem 3.1 for a more precise statement. Remark 1.2 (The leading-order profile) . The explicit function u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2} that appears in theorem 1.1 solves the wave equation on exact Minkowski space (where u=t-r and v=t+r ). For this reason u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2} is a natural candidate for the leading-order profile of general solutions on spacetimes that are small perturbations of Minkowski space. Remark 1.3 (The representation formula on Minkowski space) . On exact Minkowski space, one could in principle deduce theorem 1.1 from the representation formula for solutions to the wave equation, but this method does not apply to the more general backgrounds we consider. Remark 1.4 (Contrast with the strong Huygens principle in odd space dimensions) . Solutions to the linear wave equation on (n+1) -dimensional Minkowski space for n\geq 3 odd obey the strong Huygens principle, and so exhibit no non-trivial late-time asymptotics when their Cauchy data is compactly supported. The setting of theorem 1.1 (specialized to Minkowski space) is therefore the simplest possible for a late-time tails result. Remark 1.5 (A comment on the assumptions) . We must assume that the perturbation is small to prevent trapping or bound states, which obstruct decay. The assumption of stationarity is natural for potential applications that involve the stability of steady states. In such problems, the background will be asymptotically stationary. The methods we use have been applied to spacetimes settling down appropriately to the stationary Schwarzschild spacetime in [ GK25 ] , and so our methods could be applied to backgrounds that are only asymptotically stationary. Finally, the assumption that the background metric is radially symmetric is a significant restriction of our proof. We use this assumption to split the scalar field into its radially symmetric part \varphi_{0} and non-radially symmetric part \varphi_{\geq 1} and construct the good scalar field \Psi_{0}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}\partial_{r}\varphi_{0} . On non-symmetric backgrounds, these quantities would satisfy suitable equations near infinity, but not in a compact set, where many of the difficulties lie. Remark 1.6 (A comment on the proof) . The main difficulties in this problem arise from an inverse-square potential of a bad sign in the equation for r^{1/2}\varphi{} . The inverse-square potential is scale-critical and moreover appears with the critical constant -1/4 . 1 1 1 Here “scale-critical” means that the inverse-square potential in the equation for r^{1/2}\varphi{} scales the same way as the derivative terms in the spatial part of the operator in the equation for r^{1/2}\varphi{} , namely \partial{}_{r}^{2}+r^{-2}\partial{}_{\theta}^{2} (on Minkowski space). Inverse-square potentials are also critical for the behaviour of the spectrum of the corresponding Schrödinger operator. See remarks 1.7 and 1.8 for further discussion. For this reason, techniques that are standard in (3+1) dimensions, such as integrated local energy decay estimates and r^{p} -weighted energy estimates, degenerate in (2+1) dimensions. The main new steps of our proof are: (i) an extension of the r^{p} -weighted energy method of Dafermos–Rodnianski [ DR09 ] and methods of Gajic [ Gaj23 ] to (2+1) dimensions, (ii) and a resolution of the difficulty caused by the inverse-square potential with critical constant -1/4 by introducing the commuted quantity \Psi{}_{0}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}\partial{}_{r}\varphi{}_{0} . Here \varphi_{0} is the radially symmetric part of \varphi{} and \partial_{r} is the coordinate derivative in (t,r) coordinates. The quantity \Psi_{0} is good because it solves a wave equation with inverse-square potential with the constant +3/4 . This means we can prove estimates for \Psi_{0} using standard techniques. We then prove estimates for \varphi_{0} by treating \Psi_{0} as a controlled source term. See section 1.2.1 for a more detailed summary of the proof. 1.1. Related results 1.1.1. Late-time tails for linear and nonlinear waves in three space dimensions There is a vast literature studying the late-time asymptotics of linear and nonlinear waves in three (and higher) space dimensions, including [ Hin23 , LO24 , GK25 ] , which treat general dynamical and nonlinear settings. We refer to [ LO24 , Sec. 1.3] for a more detailed overview of the literature, including upper bound results. Much of the literature studies the wave equation on black hole spacetimes. Heuristics for the sharp decay rate of linear waves on the Schwarzschild spacetime of three space dimensions go back to Price [ Pri72 ] . The sharp pointwise asymptotics on various black hole spacetimes, including the subextremal Kerr background, were proven mathematically in [ AAG18a , AAG23 , AAG23a ] and in [ Hin22 ] . A Price’s law result was established in a nonlinear and spherically symmetric setting in [ Gau24 ] . 1.1.2. Linear wave equations with an inverse-square potential in three space dimensions The first results, namely Strichartz and dispersive estimates, for wave equations with an inverse-square potential in three space dimensions are due to [ PST02 , BPST03 , BPST04 ] . The work of Gajic [ Gaj23 ] establishes late-time asymptotics for solutions to the wave equation with an inverse-square potential on the Schwarzschild spacetime (of three space dimensions). In [ Hin23 ] , similar results are obtained in all higher dimensions. Another proof is given in [ BGM25 ] , working in the framework of [ BVW15 ] (and relying on [ BM22 ] ), which establishes sharp decay rates for such equations (as well as for solutions of the massless Dirac–Coulomb system). We also mention the work [ GVdM24 ] , which uses the conformal embedding of (3+1) -dimensional Minkowski space into \mathrm{AdS}_{2}\times S^{2} to derive late-time asymptotics for such equations. See [ VdM25 ] for an extension of the r^{p} -weighted energy method to linear wave equations on spherically symmetric spacetimes with small inverse-square potentials (as well as small scale-critical first-order terms) that may oscillate in time. We also mention the works [ DS10 , CH14 ] , which study the sharp decay rates for the one-dimensional wave equation with a potential V satisfying \lvert V(x)\rvert\lesssim(1+x)^{-p} for p>2 , and the works [ CSST08 , DK13 ] which consider the case p=2 . The estimates in [ DK13 ] were used in [ DKSW16 ] to prove the codimension-one stability of the catenoid of two space dimensions as a stationary solution of the hyperbolic vanishing mean curvature equation to perturbations that are radially symmetric and satisfy an additional discrete symmetry. Finally, we refer to the survey article [ Sch21 ] for further references. 1.1.3. Linear wave equations in two space dimensions We first discuss results that use physical space methods, as we do here. The recent work [ Ike25 ] established that for a class of wave equations with variable coefficients (without a symmetry condition as we impose here), the local energy (namely the energy restricted to a compact region of space) of the solution decays like t^{-2}\log t , as long as the data is compactly supported; note that theorem 1.1 provides the sharp rate t^{-2} . In [ Won19 ] , Wong obtained the almost-sharp global decay rate u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2}\log^{2}(uv) for solutions to the wave equation on (2+1) -dimensional Minkowski space using the conformal (or Morawetz) multiplier u^{2}\partial_{u}+v^{2}\partial_{v} , again under a compact support assumption; the associated energy estimates are then used to study the global existence problem for wave maps. In [ HM23 ] , the authors use the multiplier r(\log r)^{q}\partial_{v} for q\in(0,1) to obtain an integrated energy estimate in the context of the Dirichlet problem for the wave equation outside an obstacle containing the origin in two space dimensions. There is also a large body of work using spectral methods to study linear wave equations with a potential on (2+1) -dimensional Minkowski space, namely (\Box{}_{m}-V)\varphi{}=0 . In this setting, when \lvert V\rvert\lesssim(1+r)^{-\beta{}} for some \beta{}>2 , the spectrum of the stationary (spatial) operator, namely the Hamiltonian -\Delta_{\mathbf{R}^{2}}+V , consists of finitely many non-negative eigenvalues and the absolutely continuous spectrum [0,\infty) . The negative eigenvalues lead to exponentially growing mode solutions, and the zero eigenvalues are obstructions to decay. For this reason, one first projects away the non-positive eigenvalues (thereby considering solutions orthogonal to the corresponding eigenfunctions), or demands that the zero be a “regular point” of the spectrum of H=-\Delta_{\mathbf{R}^{2}}+V . This means that H has no resonances or zero-energy eigenfunctions. 2 2 2 Let w\neq{}0 be a distributional solution of Hw=(-\Delta_{\mathbf{R}^{2}}+V)w=0 . We say w is an “s-wave” resonance if w\in L^{\infty} and w\notin L^{p} for any 1\leq p<\infty . If w\in L^{p} for all p>2 but w\notin L^{2} , then w is called a “p-wave” resonance. Finally, w is a zero-energy eigenfunction if w\in L^{2} . This assumption is not satisfied in the setting of theorem 1.1 , since the constant function 1 is an “s-wave” resonance H=-\Delta_{\mathbf{R}^{2}} . When this assumption is satisfied, one can obtain better decay results for linear wave equations with a potential: [ Kop10 , Gre14 ] (see also the high-frequency analysis of [ Mou09 ] ) show a pointwise decay rate \lvert\varphi{}\rvert\lesssim t^{-1}(\log t)^{-2} near \{r=0\} , which is faster than the rate given by theorem 1.1 by (\log t)^{2} . We also remark that [ Bec16 ] proves Strichartz estimates. The methods in these works are related to the study of zero-energy resolvent expansions for -\Delta_{\mathbf{R}^{2}}+V (see [ JN01 , EG13 ] ). Finally, we mention the work [ FZZ22 ] , which studies wave equations in two dimensions with an inverse-square electromagnetic potential. 1.2. Outline of the proof We now outline the proof of theorem 1.1 when the background is Minkowski space (and when N=M=0 ). Let \varphi{} be a solution to the wave equation \Box{}_{m}\varphi{}=0 . We will use the following notation for scalar fields associated to \varphi{} : Notation Meaning \varphi{} solution to \Box_{m}\varphi{}=0 \varphi_{0} and \varphi_{\geq 1} \varphi_{0} is the radially symmetric part of \varphi{} , and \varphi_{\geq 1}\coloneqq{}\varphi{}-\varphi_{0} \mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}] a linear functional of the initial data for \varphi{} defined in eq. 2.36 \varphi_{\textnormal{mink}} the leading-order profile u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2} , which solves the wave equation on Minkowski space \widehat{\varphi{}} \widehat{\varphi{}}\coloneqq{}\varphi{}-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}} is the renormalized solution \psi{} \psi{}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}\varphi{} achieves a finite non-zero limit at future null infinity \psi{}_{0} and \psi_{\geq 1} defined analogously to \varphi_{0} and \varphi_{\geq 1} \Psi_{0} \Psi_{0}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}\partial_{r}\varphi_{0} , where \partial_{r} is the coordinate derivative in (t,r,\theta{}) coordinates As we will explain, the scalar fields \psi_{\geq 1} and \Psi_{0} are “good,” while the radially symmetric scalar field \varphi_{0} is “bad.” The good quantities \psi_{\geq 1} and \Psi_{0} satisfy estimates that are standard in (3+1) dimensions and which fail for the bad quantity \varphi_{0} . We will also write \underline{L}=\partial_{u} and L=\partial_{v} for the coordinate derivatives in (u,v,\theta{}) coordinates. 1.2.1. A brief summary of the proof Our goal is to prove a late-time tails result for the linear wave equation in (2+1) dimensions. There are many such results in higher dimensions, even in nonlinear settings (see section 1.1.1 ). We highlight in particular the work of Gajic [ Gaj23 ] on wave equations with an inverse-square potential in (3+1) dimensions, which makes crucial use of the Dafermos–Rodnianski r^{p} -weighted estimates [ DR09 ] . However, the methods of [ DR09 , Gaj23 ] do not apply directly to our problem. The main challenge in two space dimensions appears at the level of the radially symmetric part of \varphi{} , which we call \varphi_{0} . The quantity r^{1/2}\varphi_{0} solves an equation with an inverse-square potential of a bad sign (with the critical constant -1/4 ), which obstructs standard Morawetz and r^{p} -weighted estimates. 3 3 3 In higher even spatial dimensions, the inverse-square potential has a good sign, and in higher odd spatial dimensions, the inverse-square potential does not appear. For this reason, one can establish Morawetz and r^{p} estimates in higher dimensions. The mechanism, which we identify in appendix A , is the scale invariance of the energy norm \dot{H}^{1}(\mathbf{R}^{2}) in two space dimensions. On Minkowski space, one can nevertheless prove r^{p} -weighted energy estimates for \varphi{}_{0} , due to an exact cancellation that arises when p=1 (see appendix B ). This cancellation does not persist on perturbations of Minkowski space. We overcome this difficulty by identifying two “good” quantities that solve wave equations with (effective) potentials of a favourable sign. The first is r^{1/2}\varphi{}_{\geq 1}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}(\varphi{}-\varphi{}_{0}) , and the second, more important one, is \Psi_{0}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}\partial_{r}\varphi_{0} . One can close energy estimates for these good quantities using standard techniques. Since we can decompose \varphi{}=\varphi_{0}+\varphi_{\geq 1} , it remains to estimate \varphi_{0} . We prove estimates for \varphi{}_{0} by coupling them to estimates for the good quantity \Psi_{0} . That is, once \Psi_{0} is estimated, we can treat it as an acceptable error term in estimates for \varphi_{0} . We use this strategy to derive novel integrated local energy decay and r -weighted estimates for \varphi_{0} . To turn our energy estimates into sharp pointwise decay results, we subtract from \varphi{} a suitable multiple of the desired leading-order profile \varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}\coloneqq{}u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2} (which solves the wave equation on (2+1) -dimensional Minkowski space) and consider instead the renormalized quantity \widehat{\varphi{}}\coloneqq{}\varphi{}-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}} . The suitable multiple \mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}] (introduced in theorem 1.1 ) is chosen so that one can construct a time integral of \widehat{\varphi{}} , namely a function T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}} such that TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}=\widehat{\varphi{}} . The reason we construct a time integral of \widehat{\varphi{}} , thereby expressing it as a time derivative of a solution to eq. 1.1 , is that time derivatives decay faster. The improved decay we therefore obtain for \widehat{\varphi{}}=\varphi{}-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}} means that the leading-order asymptotics of \varphi{} are indeed given by \mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}} . We construct the time integral by solving the wave equation from initial data obtained by solving an elliptic problem \mathcal{L}[T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}]=\mathcal{F}[\widehat{\varphi{}}] , where \mathcal{L} is the spatial part of the wave operator and \mathcal{F} is the first-order operator such that \mathcal{L}[\varphi{}]=\mathcal{F}[T\varphi{}] for solutions of eq. 1.1 . Working with the renormalized quantity \widehat{\varphi{}} (as opposed to the original solution \varphi{} ) is necessary because the image of \mathcal{L} (acting on radially symmetric functions) has codimension one; the quantity \mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}] is defined so that the source \mathcal{F}[\widehat{\varphi{}}] is in the image of \mathcal{L} . We then show that each time derivative gains two powers of u in energy decay (where we consider an energy defined along asymptotically null hypersurfaces). That is, while the T -energy E[\varphi{}] decays like u^{-1} , the T -energy E[T\varphi{}] decays like u^{-3} . It follows that the pointwise norm of a time derivative decays faster by one power in u . Since \widehat{\varphi{}}=TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}} is a time derivative, this shows that \widehat{\varphi{}} decays faster in u than \varphi_{\textnormal{mink}} , which means that \varphi{} itself is described at late times by a multiple of \varphi_{\textnormal{mink}} plus an error term that decays faster in u . These ideas are discussed in more detail in sections 1.2.2 , 1.2.3 , 1.2.8 , 1.2.6 , 1.2.7 , 1.2.4 , and 1.2.5 . 1.2.2. Difficulties associated to the zeroth-order term of a bad sign The main difficulty in (2+1) dimensions is the presence of zeroth-order terms of a bad sign that form an obstruction to integrated local energy decay (or Morawetz) and r -weighted energy estimates. By integrated local energy decay, we mean an estimate of the form (1.3) \int_{0}^{\infty}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq R\}}r(\partial{}\varphi{})^{2}+\varphi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim_{R}E[\varphi{}](0), where \tau{} is a time function with level sets \Sigma{}(\tau{}) (in our proof we take \tau{} to have hyperboloidal level sets, so that energies defined on the foliation \Sigma{}(\tau{}) will decay), R>0 is arbitrary, and E[\varphi{}](0) is the initial T -energy (where T=\partial_{t} is the stationary Killing vector field). By an r -weighted energy estimate, we mean an estimate roughly of the form (1.4) \int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{}_{2})}r^{p}(L\psi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}pr^{p-1}(L\psi{})^{2}+(2-p)r^{p-3}(\psi{}^{2}+(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\psi{})^{2})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{}_{1})}r^{p}(L\psi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{} for 0\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2} and 0\leq p\leq 2 . Here we have written \psi{}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}\varphi{} and L=\partial_{v} for the coordinate derivative in (u,v,\theta{}) coordinates, where u=\frac{1}{2}(t-r) and v=\frac{1}{2}(t+r) are the standard double null coordinates on Minkowski space. The bad zeroth-order term is manifest in the equation for \psi{}=r^{1/2}\varphi{} , which has an inverse-square potential with constant -1/4 : (1.5) r^{1/2}\Box{}\varphi{}=-\underline{L}L\psi{}-\alpha{}r^{-2}\psi{}+r^{-2}\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}\psi{}\quad\textnormal{for }\alpha{}=-\frac{1}{4}. Here we write \underline{L}=\partial_{u} and L=\partial_{v} for the coordinate derivatives in (u,v,\theta{}) coordinates. Previous works have studied wave equations with an inverse-square potential of the form \alpha{}r^{-2} for \alpha{}>-1/4 (see section 1.1.2 for further discussion), but eq. 1.5 corresponds to the case where the parameter \alpha{} takes the critical value -1/4 . Remark 1.7 (Criticality of inverse-square potentials of the form \alpha r^{-2} with \alpha=-1/4 ) . Inverse-square potentials are critical for the behaviour of the spectrum of the corresponding Schrödinger operator in the following sense. The operator -\Delta+V acting on L^{2}(\mathbf{R}^{3}) has an infinite discrete spectrum when V\sim\alpha{}r^{-p} as r\to\infty for p>2 , while the discrete spectrum is finite if p<2 . In the critical case p=2 , the spectral properties of this operator depend on the value of \alpha{} : when \alpha{}<-1/4 , the operator is unbounded from below and fails to be essentially self-adjoint, and when \alpha{}\geq-1/4 , the discrete spectrum is finite. See [ RS81 , Thm. XII.6] for further discussion. Remark 1.8 (Relation between Hardy’s inequality and the critical value \alpha{}=-1/4 ) . In 3 dimensions, 4 is the best constant in Hardy’s inequality, namely the estimate \lVert r^{-1}f\rVert_{L^{2}(\mathbf{R}^{3})}^{2}\leq 4\lVert\partial{}f\rVert_{L^{2}(\mathbf{R}^{3})}^{2} for f\in C_{c}^{\infty}(\mathbf{R}^{3}) . This means that, when \alpha{}>-1/4 , bad zeroth-order terms in estimates for solutions \varphi{} to (\Box{}-\alpha{}r^{-2})\varphi{}=0 can be absorbed by the remaining good derivative terms. Put another way, the operator -\Delta+\alpha{}r^{-2} acting on C_{c}^{\infty}(\mathbf{R}^{3}) is positive-definite when \alpha{}>-1/4 but fails to be positive-definite when \alpha{}=-1/4 . The analogue of Hardy’s inequality fails in two dimensions, due to the non-integrability of 1/r^{2} near the origin, but a logarithmically modified version holds. The obstruction caused by the bad zeroth-order term can be overcome when \varphi{}_{0}\equiv 0 , where \varphi{}_{0} is the radially symmetric part of \varphi{} (namely the average of \varphi{} over circles of constant \tau{} and r , where \tau{} is a time function). Indeed, for such functions, which satisfy \varphi{}=\varphi_{\geq 1} , where \varphi_{\geq 1}\coloneqq{}\varphi{}-\varphi_{0} is the projection of \varphi{} to non-zero angular modes, the following Poincaré inequality on S^{1} holds: (1.6) \int_{S^{1}}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\geq\int_{S^{1}}\varphi{}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\textnormal{ when }\varphi{}=\varphi{}_{\geq 1}. It follows that the angular derivative term can absorb the zeroth-order term of a bad sign, and so the effective potential in the equation for \psi_{\geq 1} is \alpha{}r^{-2} for \alpha{}=3/4 , which has a good sign. Since the effective value of \alpha{} is positive, one can establish integrated local energy decay estimates and r^{p} -weighted energy estimates in the full range 0\leq p<2 for \psi{}_{\geq 1} using the same proofs that work in (3+1) dimensions (see section 4.1 ). On the other hand, the integrated local energy decay estimate of eq. 1.3 , which controls in particular a zeroth-order term in the bulk by the T -energy, fails to hold for radially symmetric scalar fields in (2+1) dimensions, due to the scale invariance of the energy space \dot{H}^{1}(\mathbf{R}^{2}) (see appendix A ). 1.2.3. A quantity that solves an equation with a zeroth-order term of a good sign A key observation is that the quantity \Psi{}_{0}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}\partial_{r}\varphi{}_{0} , where \partial_{r}=\partial{}_{v}-\partial{}_{u} is the coordinate derivative in (t,r,\theta{}) coordinates, solves an equation with a zeroth-order term of a good sign , namely (1.7) 0=\underline{L}L\Psi{}_{0}+\frac{3}{4}r^{-2}\Psi{}_{0}. This is to be contrasted with the bad sign in the equation that \psi_{0}=r^{1/2}\varphi_{0} satisfies, namely (1.8) 0=\underline{L}L\psi{}_{0}-\frac{1}{4}r^{-2}\psi{}_{0}. In other words, commuting with r^{1/2}\partial_{r} converts the bad sign in front of the inverse-square potential to a favourable sign. For this reason, one can establish integrated local energy decay estimates, as well as r^{p} -weighted energy estimates in the full range 0
-1/4
) in the range
p\in(1-\beta{},1+\beta{})
for
\beta{}=\sqrt{1+4\alpha{}}
. The
case
\alpha{}=-1/4
arises in
(2+1)
dimensions, and in this case we
have
\beta{}=0
.
concretely we have
-rg^{\prime\prime}-g^{\prime}=-(p-1)^{2}r^{p-2}
when
g(r)=r^{p-1}
.
On perturbations of Minkowski space, the zeroth-order term in (the analogue of)
eq.
1.13
does not vanish, even when
g(r)\equiv 1
! Because a
Morawetz estimate controlling a zeroth-order term in the bulk is not available,
we treat this term as an error, so that
eq.
1.13
produces (for
f(r)\equiv r
) an estimate of the form
(1.14)
\begin{split}&\mathcal{E}_{1}[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2})+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}r(L\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\leq A\mathcal{E}_{1}[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1})+B\epsilon{}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}(1+r)^{-2}\varphi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}-C\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}2rL\psi{}r^{1/2}\Box{}_{m}\varphi{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
Here
A,B,C>0
are constants,
\epsilon{}
measures the size of the metric
perturbation, and we have written
(1.15)
\mathcal{E}_{1}[\varphi{}](\tau{})\coloneqq{}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}r(L\psi{})^{2}+h(r)\varphi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{},
where
h
is as in
section
1.2.3
. Because of the zeroth-order bulk term on the
right-hand side of
eq.
1.14
, we are not able to obtain
r
-weighted energy estimates for
\varphi{}
itself on a general background.
We now explain how to close the estimates for
T\varphi{}
and
(rL)\varphi{}
. First, we
apply
eq.
1.14
with
T\varphi{}
in place of
\varphi{}
. When
\Box{}\varphi{}=0
, we have
\Box{}T\varphi{}=0
, and so the final term
on the right-hand side of
eq.
1.14
vanishes. The bulk term with an
\epsilon{}
-factor (involving now
T\varphi{}
) can be controlled by the
T
-energy of
\varphi{}
and an
r^{p}
-weighted energy of
\Psi{}
, in
view of the discussion in
section
1.2.4
. In conclusion,
we obtain an estimate
(1.16)
\mathcal{E}_{1}[T\varphi{}](\tau_{2})+\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}r(LT\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim\mathcal{E}_{1}[T\varphi{}](\tau_{1})+E[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1})+\textnormal{terms involving }\Psi{}.
Next, we apply
eq.
1.14
with
(rL)\varphi{}
in place of
\varphi{}
. The
integrand of the final term on the right-hand side of
eq.
1.14
becomes
-2rL(r^{1/2}(rL)\varphi{})\Box_{m}(rL)\varphi{}
. Expanding this and
commuting
(rL)
with
\Box_{m}
produces bulk terms involving
L(rL)^{\leq 1}\varphi{}
of a favourable sign and terms involving
\Psi{}
. The good bulk
terms are enough to compensate for the term in
eq.
1.14
with an
\epsilon{}
-factor. After treating all terms involving
\Psi{}
as error,
we obtain the estimate
(1.17)
\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2})+\sum_{n=0}^{1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}r(L(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{})+\textnormal{terms involving }\Psi{}.
We have therefore proven
r
-weighted estimates for derivatives of
\varphi{}
, and
these estimates are sufficient to prove
theorem
1.1
.
Remark 1.9
(Estimates with stronger
r
-weights)
.
In order to derive pointwise estimates, one also needs control of
r^{p}
-weighted energies for
p=1+\delta{}
, where
\delta{}>0
is
small. Using
f(r)=r(1+r)^{\delta}{}
in
eq.
1.13
(where
\delta{}>0
) produces an additional zeroth-order error term in the bulk.
Since this term comes with a
\delta{}
-factor, it can be absorbed as above
when
\delta{}
is small.
These estimates are established in
section
4.2.2
.
1.2.6.
Improved energy decay for time derivatives
It is well-known since
[
DR09
]
that
r^{p}
-weighted energy estimates of the type proven in
section
1.2.5
(with
p=1
), lead to
\tau^{-1}
decay for
the
T
-energy, via what we will call in this section a “pigeonhole argument”.
However, the decay rate
\tau^{-1}
for the
T
-energy of
\varphi{}
is
too slow to prove
theorem
1.1
, since the best pointwise decay it can
imply for
\varphi{}
is
\tau^{-1/2}
, while
theorem
1.1
shows
that
\varphi{}
decays like
\tau^{-1}
near
\{r=0\}
. In
(3+1)
-dimensions, one could improve the decay in
\tau{}
for
\varphi{}
by
increasing the range of
p
for which one applies
r^{p}
-weighted estimates.
However, as discussed in
section
1.2.5
, such an increased range
is not available in
(2+1)
dimensions.
To obtain improved decay for
\varphi{}
, we first obtain improved decay for
T\varphi{}
, whose
T
-energy decays two powers faster, like
\tau^{-3}
.
This is helpful because we will eventually write a renormalized version of
\varphi{}
as a time derivative (see
section
1.2.7
).
We first discuss the improved decay of
T
-derivatives of the “good scalar
field”
\Psi_{0}
. The same argument works for
\psi{}_{\geq 1}
. The methods
in this case are standard (see
[
Gaj23
, Sec. 8]
). Improved decay for
T
-derivatives (after commuting with
(rL)
) goes back to
[
Sch13
,
Mos16
]
, and appears in
[
AAG18
,
AAG18a
,
AAG23
]
. First, the
r^{p}
-weighted energy estimate for
\Psi_{0}
with
p=1
(see
eq.
1.9
) implies the estimate
(1.18)
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1}[\Psi{}_{0}](\tau{}_{2})+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{0}[\Psi{}_{0}](\tau{})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1}[\Psi{}_{0}](\tau{}_{1})
for
\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
. A pigeonhole argument provides
\tau^{-1}
decay for
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{0}[\Psi_{0}](\tau{})
, which is at the level of the
T
-energy. Then, one uses the equation for
\Psi_{0}
(see
eq.
1.7
) together with the expression
T=L+\underline{L}
to estimate
(1.19)
r^{2}(LT\Psi{}_{0})^{2}\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{1}(L(rL)^{n}\Psi{}_{0})^{2}+r^{-2}\Psi{}_{0}^{2}.
When integrated in the bulk, the left-hand side of
eq.
1.19
corresponds to the
p=3
energy of
T\Psi_{0}
, while the terms on the right-hand side of
eq.
1.19
are controlled by the
p=1
energy of
\Psi_{0}
(see
eq.
1.9
). In this way, one can exchange time
derivatives in an energy norm for two powers of
r
, at the cost of one
commutation with
(rL)
. Heuristically, gaining two powers of
r
corresponds to “increasing the range of an
r^{p}
-weighted energy hierarchy by
two,” which corresponds to gaining two powers of decay in
\tau{}
. Indeed, we
obtain a
\tau^{-3}
decay rate for the
T
-energy of
T\Psi_{0}
(compared
to the
\tau^{-1}
decay rate for the
T
-energy of
\Psi_{0}
itself),
using only
r^{p}
-weighted energies with
p=1
.
We now discuss the estimates for radially symmetric scalar fields
\varphi{}=\varphi_{0}
, which do not appear in previous works. We want to show
that
E[T\varphi{}_{0}]
decays like
\tau^{-3}
. As a first step, we can show
that an analogue of
eq.
1.18
holds for
\varphi_{0}
:
(1.20)
E[(rL)^{\leq 1}\varphi{}_{0}](\tau{}_{2})+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}E[(rL)^{\leq 1}\varphi{}_{0}](\tau{})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim E[(rL)^{\leq 1}\varphi{}_{0}](\tau{}_{1})+\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)\varphi{}_{0}](\tau{}_{1})+\textnormal{terms involving }\Psi{}_{0}
for
\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
. A pigeonhole argument extracts a decay rate
\tau{}^{-1}
for the
T
-energy of
(rL)^{\leq 1}\varphi_{0}
. From here, we cannot directly apply
the strategy used for
\Psi_{0}
and write
(LT\psi{}_{0})^{2}\lesssim r^{-1}(L(rL)^{\leq 1}\psi{}_{0})^{2}+r^{-2}\psi{}_{0}^{2}
in analogy with
eq.
1.19
. This is because we do not control a bulk term
involving
L\psi_{0}
(only one involving
L\varphi{}
) or, more importantly,
a zeroth-order bulk term involving
\psi{}_{0}
. Instead, we estimate
(1.21)
r^{2}(LT\psi{}_{0})^{2}\lesssim r(L(rL)^{\leq 1}\varphi{}_{0})^{2}+r^{2}(L\Psi{}_{0})^{2}.
After integrating in the bulk, the first term on the right-hand side of
eq.
1.21
can be controlled by the
p=1
energy of
(rL)^{\leq 1}\varphi_{0}
(see
eq.
1.17
). Thus a gain in
r
-powers, and hence a gain in
\tau{}
-decay, after commuting with
T
holds for
\varphi_{0}
just as it does for
\Psi_{0}
, as long as we can control
the term
(1.22)
\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}r^{2}(L\Psi{}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.
This bulk term corresponds to the
p=3
energy of
\Psi_{0}
. However, we would
like to only use
p=1
energies, and even then, one can only control the
r^{p}
-weighted energy of
\Psi_{0}
with
p\in(0,2)
! To control this term,
we write
\Psi{}_{0}=TT^{-1}\Psi{}_{0}
, where
T^{-1}\Psi{}_{0}
is a
time
integral
of
\Psi{}_{0}
(see
section
1.2.7
), and exchange the time
derivative for two powers of
r
-decay by applying
eq.
1.19
with
T^{-1}\Psi_{0}
in place of
\Psi_{0}
. We
are then left with a term of the form
(1.23)
\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}(LT^{-1}\Psi{}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{},
which is controlled by the
p=1
energy of
T^{-1}\Psi_{0}
.
Remark 1.10
(Constructing two time integrals of
\Psi_{0}
)
.
When, after the discussion of
section
1.2.7
, we apply the analysis of
this section to
T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
in place of
\varphi{}
(where
\widehat{\varphi{}}
is a suitably renormalized version of
\varphi{}
), we
will need to construct
two
time integrals of the renormalized quantity
\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
. Although we cannot construct two time integrals of
\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
, this is possible for
\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
precisely
because this quantity solves an equation with an inverse-square potential of a
good sign.
In the end, we can show that
\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)T\varphi{}]
decays like
\tau^{-2}
(a gain in two powers over
\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)\varphi{}]
, which is merely
bounded). On the other hand, since the estimate for
\mathcal{E}_{1}[T\varphi{}]
sees
E[\varphi{}]
(which decays like
\tau^{-1}
) on the right-hand side, we do not obtain an estimate better than
\tau^{-1}
for
\mathcal{E}_{1}[T\varphi{}]
.
6
6
6
The
\mathcal{E}_{1}[T\varphi{}_{0}](\tau{})\lesssim\tau^{-1}
stands in contrast to the
estimate we obtain
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1}[T\Psi_{0}]
, which decays like
\tau^{-2}
. By
theorem
1.1
, our estimate for
\mathcal{E}_{1}[T\varphi_{0}]
is not sharp. Note that, on exact Minkowski space,
one can indeed prove that
\mathcal{E}_{1}[T\varphi{}_{0}]
decays like
\tau^{-2}
.
Nevertheless, we can
obtain the sharp rate
E[T\varphi{}]\lesssim\tau^{-3}
, since the estimate
eq.
1.20
applied to
T\varphi{}
in place of
\varphi{}
does
not see
\mathcal{E}_{1}[T\varphi{}]
, but only
\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)T\varphi{}]
, which indeed decays like
\tau^{-2}
.
We can also derive higher-order versions of the above estimates. In summary, we
obtain the following estimates for radially symmetric scalar fields (where
M\geq 0
):
(1.24)
E[\varphi{}](\tau{})\lesssim\tau^{-1},\quad\mathcal{E}_{1}[\varphi{}]\lesssim 1,\quad E[T^{M+1}\varphi{}]\lesssim\tau^{-3-2M},\quad\mathcal{E}_{1}[T^{M+1}\varphi{}]\lesssim\tau^{-1-2M},\quad\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)T^{M+1}\varphi{}]\lesssim\tau^{-2-2M}.
The crucial feature of the estimates in
eq.
1.24
is the gain
of two powers of
\tau{}
in energy decay for each time derivative.
This step is carried out in
section
5
.
1.2.7.
Time inversion and subtraction of the Minkowskian solution
The gain of two powers of decay for time derivatives
discussed in
section
1.2.6
motivates the construction of
time integrals
(“inverse time derivatives”) of the solution, as in
[
AAG18a
,
AAG23
,
Gaj23
]
, thereby converting
improved decay for time derivatives into improved decay for the solution itself.
That is,
\varphi{}
itself decays faster whenever one can construct its time
integral, namely a function
T^{-1}\varphi{}
such that
TT^{-1}\varphi{}=\varphi{}
, since then
\varphi{}
is a time derivative.
In
[
Gaj23
]
, the time integral
T^{-1}\varphi{}
is constructed by
inverting the spatial part of the wave operator. One also constructs
T^{-1}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
(where
\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}\coloneqq{}u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2}
is the desired leading-order profile) and
subtracts a suitable multiple of
T^{-1}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
from
T^{-1}\varphi{}
. In our case, we must work directly with the renormalized
quantity
\widehat{\varphi{}}\coloneqq{}\varphi{}-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
. This is because the
elliptic operator we invert to construct the time integral has a codimension one
image when acting on radially symmetric functions;
7
7
7
The obstruction is given by the s-wave resonance discussed in
section
1.1.3
.
the constant
\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]
is chosen precisely so that the source term
corresponding to
\widehat{\varphi{}}
that we seek to invert lies in this
image.
To construct a time integral of
\widehat{\varphi{}}
, we recast the wave
equation as an elliptic problem (coming from the spatial part of the wave
operator) with a source term (coming from the part of the wave operator
involving time derivatives). That is, we write
(1.25)
\mathcal{L}\psi{}=\mathcal{F}[T\psi{}]+r^{1/2}\Box{}_{m}\varphi{},
where
\mathcal{L}
is a second-order elliptic operator involving only spatial
derivatives and
\mathcal{F}
is a first-order operator. We first construct
the solution
\Phi{}
to the elliptic problem
(1.26)
\mathcal{L}\Phi{}=\mathcal{F}[\widehat{\psi{}}]|_{\Sigma{}(0)},
Here
\widehat{\psi{}}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}\widehat{\varphi{}}
has been constructed to lie in the
kernel of the functional determining the invertibility of
\mathcal{L}
. We
then solve the wave equation with initial data
(r^{-1/2}\Phi{},\widehat{\varphi{}})
prescribed on
\Sigma{}(0)
.
Remark 1.11
(Time integrals outside of Minkowski space)
.
Outside of Minkowski space,
\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}=u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2}
, and hence
\widehat{\varphi{}}
, is only
an approximate solution to the wave equation. Since
\widehat{\varphi{}}
is
not a solution to the wave equation, all the estimates in earlier sections must
accommodate for inhomogeneities. Furthermore, we must directly construct and
estimate the time integral
T^{-1}\Box{}_{g}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
and include
it as a source term in the wave equation used to construct
T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}
.
This step is carried out in
section
6
.
1.2.8.
Pointwise estimates
Since pointwise estimates for
\varphi_{\geq 1}
follow from
standard techniques, we focus this discussion on the novel estimates for
radially symmetric scalar fields and assume
\varphi{}=\varphi_{0}
.
The basic idea is to interpolate between
\tau{}
-decay in a finite-
r
region
with a loss depending on the size of the region with
r
-decay in a
large-
r
region. In order to control
\widehat{\varphi{}}
pointwise in a
finite-
r
region via Sobolev embedding, we need to control
\widehat{\varphi{}}
in
L^{2}
near the origin. However, the weakest (and
hence fastest decaying) energy with this control is
\mathcal{E}_{1}[\widehat{\varphi{}}]
, which decays like
\tau^{-1}
, by the
results discussed in
sections
1.2.6
and
1.2.7
. This would
lead to an estimate
\lvert\widehat{\varphi{}}\rvert|_{r=0}\lesssim\tau^{-1/2}
.
Near
r=0
, the Minkowskian solution
\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}=u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2}
decays like
\tau^{-1}
, and so we cannot show that
\widehat{\varphi{}}
decays faster in
u
than
\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
using this estimate.
To remedy this issue, we first derive an estimate for
(rL)\widehat{\varphi{}}
. We
then integrate this estimate in the
L
-direction to null infinity, where
\widehat{\varphi{}}=0
, to obtain an estimate in the region
\{r\geq 1\}
. To estimate
\widehat{\varphi{}}
in the region
\{r\leq 1\}
, we
integrate an estimate for
\widehat{\Psi{}}=r^{1/2}\partial_{r}\widehat{\varphi{}}
in the
\partial_{r}
-direction, which is
possible since
r^{-1/2}
is integrable near
\{r=0\}
.
We now elaborate on this procedure. First, we obtain the following estimate:
(1.27)
\lVert(rL)\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq R\})}^{2}\lesssim R^{C}(\mathcal{E}_{1}[T\varphi{}](\tau{})+E[(rL)^{\leq 1}T^{\leq 1}\varphi{}](\tau{}))\qquad(R\geq 1).
Here
C>0
is a constant determined by the foliation (specifically the
function
h
discussed in
section
1.2.3
). Applying this estimate to
\widehat{\varphi{}}=TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}
, we obtain, by
eq.
1.24
, the decay rate
(1.28)
\lVert(rL)\widehat{\varphi{}}\rVert_{L^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq R\})}^{2}\lesssim R^{C}\tau^{-3}.
On the other hand, a standard estimate using the
r^{p}
-weighted energy for
p=1+\delta{}
with
\delta{}>0
gives
(1.29)
\lvert\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\lesssim_{\delta}{}r^{-1}(\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[\varphi{}](\tau{})+E[\varphi{}](\tau{}))\qquad\textnormal{for }\delta{}>0\textnormal{ in }\{r\geq 1\}.
Applying this estimate to
(rL)\widehat{\varphi{}}=(rL)TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}
and recalling
eq.
1.24
, we obtain
(1.30)
\lvert(rL)\widehat{\varphi{}}\rvert^{2}\lesssim r^{-1}\tau^{-2}\qquad\textnormal{in }\{r\geq 1\}.
Interpolating between
eq.
1.28
in a small-
r
region and
eq.
1.30
in the large-
r
region, we obtain
(1.31)
\lvert(rL)\widehat{\varphi{}}\rvert\lesssim u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2}u^{-\delta{}}\quad\textnormal{ for some }\delta{}>0\textnormal{ depending on }C.
Integrating this estimate in the
L
-direction (that is, in the outgoing null
direction) to future null infinity, where
\widehat{\varphi{}}
vanishes, one
obtains
(1.32)
\lvert\widehat{\varphi{}}\rvert\lesssim u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2}u^{-\delta{}/2}\qquad\textnormal{in }\{r\geq 1\}.
To control
\widehat{\varphi{}}
in
\{r\leq 1\}
, we obtain a pointwise estimate
(1.33)
\lvert\widehat{\Psi{}}\rvert^{2}\lesssim\tau^{-5}\qquad\textnormal{in }\{r\leq 1\},
which is two powers better than
eq.
1.28
because we can
construct one more time integral of
\widehat{\Psi{}}
than of
\widehat{\varphi{}}
. We then recall the definition
\widehat{\Psi{}}=r^{1/2}\partial_{r}\widehat{\varphi{}}
and integrate in the
\partial_{r}
-direction (where
\partial{}_{r}
is the coordinate derivative
in
(t,r,\theta{})
coordinates) to
\{r=1\}
, using the integrability of
r^{-1/2}
near
\{r=0\}
. This extends the estimate
eq.
1.32
to all values of
r
.
These estimates are carried out in
section
7
.
1.2.9.
Diagrammatic overview of the proof
In
fig.
1
, we summarize the dependencies between the energy estimates and
pointwise estimates used to prove
theorem
1.1
for the radially
symmetric scalar field
\varphi_{0}
and record where each estimate is proved.
Since the estimates for the non-radially symmetric part
\varphi_{\geq 1}=\varphi{}-\varphi_{0}
are similar to the estimates for
\Psi_{0}=r^{1/2}\partial_{r}\varphi_{0}
, we suppress their role here.
Figure 1
.
A summary of the proof of the pointwise estimate for
\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
that, together with estimates for
\varphi_{\geq 1}
, implies that the late-time asymptotics of
\varphi{}
are described
by
\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
.
Acknowledgements
We thank Dejan Gajic, Georgios Moschidis, and Igor Rodnianski for helpful
discussions. We thank Jonathan Luk and Sung-Jin Oh for pointing out references.
We thank Dejan Gajic and Igor Rodnianski for comments on the manuscript.
2.
Preliminaries
2.1.
Notation and conventions for constants
For
x\in\mathbf{R}
, we write
\langle{}x\rangle{}\coloneqq{}\sqrt{2+x^{2}}
.
For
g:(0,\infty)\to\mathbf{R}_{\geq 0}
, we write
f(r)=O(g(r))
to mean that
f:(0,\infty)\to\mathbf{R}
is a smooth function such that there exists a constant
C>0
for which
\lvert f(r)\rvert\leq Cg(r)
. We write
f(r)=\mathcal{O}(g(r))
to
mean that
(r\partial_{r})^{k}f(r)=O(g(r))
for each
k\geq 0
. If
f
depends on additional parameters
\theta{}
, then we write
f(r,\theta{})=\mathcal{O}(g(r))
to mean that
f(\cdot,\theta{})=\mathcal{O}(g(r))
for each choice of parameters
\theta{}
, with the
implicit constants uniform in
\theta{}
. In practice,
f=f(r,\theta{})
will be a smooth function in polar coordinates. If the implicit constants do
depend on additional parameters, this will be indicated with the use of a
subscript (e.g.
f_{k}(r)=\mathcal{O}_{k}(1)
).
Fix constants
\eta_{0}>0
,
\epsilon{}>0
, and
a>1
. The constant
\eta_{0}
will be
used to limit the range of
p
for which we establish
r^{p}
-weighted energy
estimates (see
eq.
4.16
) and elliptic estimates (see
section
6.2.1
). The constant
\epsilon{}
will measure the size
of the metric perturbation, and
a
will quantify the asymptotic flatness of
the metric perturbation (see
section
2.2
). We will assume without
comment that
\epsilon{}
is much smaller than all other constants that appear
(including
\eta_{0}
).
We write
A\lesssim B
(or
B\gtrsim A
) when there is a constant
C
,
depending only on
\eta_{0}
,
a
, and the function
h
used to construct
the foliation
\Sigma_{\tau}{}
defined in
section
2.3
such that
A\leq CB
. We write
A\sim B
if
A\lesssim B
and
A\gtrsim B
.
2.2.
Assumptions on the metric
The Minkowski metric on
\mathbf{R}^{2+1}
, expressed in the global (Cartesian)
coordinate chart
(t,x^{1},x^{2})
, is
(2.1)
g_{\textnormal{mink}}\coloneqq{}-\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}t^{2}+(\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}x^{1})^{2}+(\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}x^{2})^{2}.
Define
r:\mathbf{R}^{2}\to\mathbf{R}_{\geq 0}
by
r(x^{1},x^{2})\coloneqq{}\sqrt{(x^{1})^{2}+(x^{2})^{2}}
. Write
\theta{}
for a coordinate on
S^{1}
(with range
(0,2\pi{})
). Then the
standard polar coordinates
(t,r,\theta{})
form a chart on
\mathbf{R}^{2+1}\setminus\{r=0\}
, in which the Minkowski metric takes the form
(2.2)
g_{\textnormal{mink}}=-\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}t^{2}+\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r^{2}+r^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta^{2}.
We consider metrics
g
that are asymptotically flat stationary perturbations
of the Minkowski metric, namely metrics that take the following form on
\mathbf{R}^{2+1}\setminus\{r=0\}
:
(2.3)
g=-A(r)^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}t^{2}+B(r)^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r^{2}+r^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta^{2},\qquad A(r),B(r)=1+\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{}\langle{}r\rangle^{-a}),\qquad A(0)=B(0).
Here
\epsilon{}>0
and
a{}>1
are the constants fixed in
section
2.1
.
We assume that
A(r)
and
B(r)
define smooth functions on
\mathbf{R}^{2}
, so that
the metric
g
is smooth on
\mathbf{R}^{2+1}
.
2.3.
The hyperboloidal foliation and spacetime regions
Let
h:[0,\infty)\to(0,2)
be a smooth function such that:
(i)
(regularity conditions at
0
)
h(0)=1
and
h^{(k)}(0)=0
for each
k\geq 1
,
(ii)
(decay conditions)
h(r)=\mathcal{O}(\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1-\eta{}_{h}})
for some
\eta{}_{h}>0
,
(iii)
(condition used in
lemma
6.6
)
h(r)+\lvert rh^{\prime}(r)\rvert\leq B_{h}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1-\eta{}_{h}}
for some
B_{h}>0
and
\lvert h^{\prime}(r)\rvert\leq\epsilon_{h}
for some
\epsilon_{h}>0
,
(iv)
(lower bound) and
h(r)\geq c\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-C_{h}}
for some
c>0
and
C_{h}\geq 2
.
Remark 2.1
(Comments on the assumptions on
h
)
.
The conditions in
item
(i)
are required to ensure that the level
sets of the function
\tau{}
, which will be defined using the function
h
in
eq.
2.6
, are smooth at
\{r=0\}
. In
item
(ii)
, we used the
\mathcal{O}
-notation introduced in
section
2.1
. The condition
item
(ii)
implies that the foliation determined by level sets of
\tau{}
are asymptotically null, while
item
(iv)
implies that the
foliation does not become null too quickly. We can assume that the constant
\eta_{h}
is sufficiently small, since if
item
(ii)
holds for a
particular value of
\eta_{h}>0
, it also holds for all smaller positive
values. The condition
item
(iii)
(where the existence of
B_{h}
is
implicit in
item
(ii)
) are used only
in the proof of
lemma
6.6
, to show that a certain quantity
associated to the foliation is non-zero, so that the quantity
\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]
introduced in
theorem
1.1
is
well-defined. To do this, we will need to choose
\epsilon_{h}
small depending
on
B_{h}
and
\eta_{h}
.
Define the coordinates
(2.4)
u\coloneqq{}\frac{1}{2}(t-\tilde{G}(r)),\qquad v\coloneqq{}\frac{1}{2}(t+\tilde{G}(r)),\qquad\tilde{G}(r)\coloneqq{}\int_{0}^{r}G(s)^{-1}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}s,\qquad G(r)\coloneqq{}\frac{A(r)}{B(r)}
Note that
G\circ r
is a smooth function on
\mathbf{R}^{2}
with
G(0)=1
. Then
(u,v,\theta{})
are smooth coordinates on
\mathbf{R}^{2+1}\setminus\{r=0\}
,
in which
g
takes the form
(2.5)
g=-4A^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}u\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}v+r^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta^{2}.
Evidently
g^{-1}(\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}u,\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}u)=g^{-1}(\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}v,\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}v)=0
, and so
u
and
v
are
double null coordinates. Define also
(2.6)
\tau{}\coloneqq{}u-1-\frac{1}{2}\int_{r}^{\infty}h(s)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}s.
Then
(\tau{},r,\theta{})
are smooth coordinates on
\mathbf{R}^{2+1}\setminus\{r=0\}
. Moreover,
\tau{}
and
h\circ r
define smooth functions on
\mathbf{R}^{2+1}
, in view
of
lemma
2.3
, the smoothness of
G
, and the conditions on
h
at
0
in
item
(i)
. The level sets of
\tau{}
, denoted
(2.7)
\Sigma{}(\tau{}^{\prime})\coloneqq{}\{\tau{}=\tau{}^{\prime}\},
are spacelike hypersurfaces, since
g^{-1}(\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{},\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{})=-\frac{1}{4}h(2-h)+\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{}\langle{}r\rangle^{-a})
is negative for
\epsilon{}
sufficiently small. For
v_{0}\geq 0
, define the cutoff hypersurface
(2.8)
\Sigma{}(\tau{},v_{0})\coloneqq{}\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{v\leq v_{0}\}.
We also introduce notation for the ingoing null cones
(2.9)
\underline{C}(v_{0})\coloneqq{}\{v=v_{0}\}
and the spacetime regions
(2.10)
\mathcal{R}(\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)=\bigcup_{\tau{}_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau{}_{2}}\Sigma{}(\tau{},v),\qquad\mathcal{R}(\tau{}_{1},\infty,v)\coloneqq{}\bigcup_{\tau{}\geq\tau{}_{1}}\mathcal{R}(\tau{}_{1},\tau{},v),\qquad\mathcal{R}\coloneqq{}\bigcup_{\tau{}\geq 0}\Sigma{}(\tau{}).
By construction, we have
u\geq 1
in
\mathcal{R}
. Finally, the spacetime volume form
\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\mathrm{vol}
satisfies
(2.11)
\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\mathrm{vol}=rA(r)^{2}G(r)^{-1}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}t\sim r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}t\sim r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}u\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}v\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\sim r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{},
where the equivalence up to constants of these expressions holds when
\epsilon{}
is
sufficiently small.
2.4.
Notation for vector fields
Define the vector field
T\coloneqq{}\partial{}_{t}|_{x^{1},x^{2}}
on
\mathbf{R}^{2+1}
. We introduce
the following notation for the coordinate derivatives in
(t,r,\theta{})
coordinates,
(u,v,\theta{})
coordinates, and
(\tau{},r,\theta{})
coordinates:
(2.12)
Z\coloneqq{}\partial{}_{r}|_{t,\theta{}},\qquad\underline{L}\coloneqq{}\partial{}_{u}|_{v,\theta{}},\qquad L\coloneqq{}\partial{}_{v}|_{u,\theta{}},\qquad X\coloneqq{}\partial{}_{r}|_{\tau{},\theta{}}.
One readily derives the following relations between these vector fields on
\mathbf{R}^{2+1}\setminus\{r=0\}
:
Lemma 2.2
(Relations between coordinate derivatives)
.
We have
(2.13)
\displaystyle\partial{}_{t}|_{r,\theta{}}=T,\quad\partial{}_{\tau}{}|_{r,\theta{}}=2T,
(2.14)
\displaystyle\underline{L}=T-GZ=(2-Gh)T-GX,
(2.15)
\displaystyle L=T+GZ=GhT+GX.
2.5.
Projection to angular modes
We recall the following elementary facts.
Lemma 2.3
(Facts about smooth radially symmetric functions)
.
Suppose
f:\mathbf{R}^{2}\to\mathbf{R}
is such that
f=F\circ r
for some even function
F:\mathbf{R}\to\mathbf{R}
. Then we say
f
is
radially symmetric
, and the following statements hold:
(i)
f
is smooth if and only if
F
is (if and only if
\tilde{F}\coloneqq{}F|_{[0,\infty)}
is
smooth and
\tilde{F}^{(k)}(0)=0
for all
k
odd),
(ii)
and in this case
F(x)=g(x^{2})
for some function
g:\mathbf{R}\to\mathbf{R}
that is smooth if and only if
F
is, and moreover depends smoothly
on a parameter when
f
does,
(iii)
and for each
k\geq 0
, when
f
is smooth,
r^{-1}\partial_{r}^{2k+1}f
and
\partial_{r}^{2k}f
, which are smooth on
\mathbf{R}^{2}\setminus\{0\}
, extend to smooth functions on
\mathbf{R}^{2}
, where we write
\partial_{r}
for
the radial derivative in polar coordinates
(r,\theta{})
.
Proof.
Part
item
(ii)
is a classical theorem of Whitney, established in the
(2-page!) paper
[
Whi43
]
(where the smooth dependence of
g
on
F
, hence on
f
, is evident from the proof). Part
item
(iii)
follows from
item
(ii)
and the chain rule.
∎
Lemma 2.4
(Vanishing at the origin for higher modes)
.
Let
f:\mathbf{R}^{2}\to\mathbf{R}
be smooth. Let
f_{0}=\frac{1}{2\pi{}}\int_{S^{1}}f\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}
denote the
radially symmetric part of
f
, and let
f_{\geq 1}\coloneqq{}f-f_{0}
be the projection of
f
to angular modes
\geq 1
. Then
r^{-1}f_{\geq 1}
is bounded as
r\to 0
.
Proof.
This follows from a Taylor expansion around the origin.
∎
2.6.
Notation for scalar fields and expressions for the wave equation
From now on, let
\varphi{}
denote a smooth function on the spacetime region
\mathcal{R}
defined in
eq.
2.10
. We introduce the following
important rescaled quantities:
(2.16)
\psi{}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}\varphi{},\qquad\Psi{}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}GZ\varphi{}=\frac{1}{2}r^{1/2}(L-\underline{L})\varphi{}.
The quantity
\psi{}
is natural since it attains a finite non-zero limit at null
infinity (the Friedlander radiation field). The quantity
\Psi{}
is important
because its radially symmetric part, which we call
\Psi_{0}
, satisfies a wave
equation with a favourable potential (see
eq.
2.26
).
We write
\varphi_{0}
for the radially symmetric part of
\varphi{}
, namely
(2.17)
\varphi{}_{0}(r)\coloneqq{}\frac{1}{2\pi{}}\int_{0}^{2\pi{}}\varphi{}(r,\theta{})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.
We write
\varphi_{\geq 1}
for the non-radially symmetric part of
\varphi{}
, namely
(2.18)
\varphi_{\geq 1}\coloneqq{}\varphi{}-\varphi_{0}.
Similarly, we write
\psi_{\geq 1}
,
\Psi_{0}
, and so on.
We will write
\Box{}\coloneqq{}A^{2}\Box_{g}
, where
\Box_{g}
is the wave operator associated to
the metric
g
, and will from now on refer to solutions of
(2.19)
\Box{}\varphi{}=0,
which are of course equivalent to solutions of
eq.
1.1
. We now
derive various expressions for the equations satisfied by
\varphi{}
,
\psi{}
,
and
\Psi{}
.
Lemma 2.5
(Expressions for the wave equation)
.
The wave equation for
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
can be written in the
following forms:
(2.20)
\displaystyle\Box{}\varphi{}
\displaystyle=-\underline{L}L\varphi{}+\frac{1}{2}r^{-1}G(L-\underline{L})\varphi{}+r^{-2}A^{2}\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}\varphi{},
\displaystyle G^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}
\displaystyle=-h(2-Gh)T^{2}-(2-2Gh)XT+((Gh)^{\prime}-r^{-1}(1-Gh))T
(2.21)
\displaystyle\qquad+GX^{2}+r^{-1}(G+rG^{\prime})X+A^{2}G^{-1}r^{-2}\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}.
Moreover,
\psi{}=r^{1/2}\varphi{}
satisfies
(2.22)
\displaystyle r^{1/2}\Box{}\varphi{}
\displaystyle=-\underline{L}L\psi{}+\frac{1}{4}r^{-2}G(G-2rG^{\prime})\psi{}+r^{-2}A^{2}\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}\psi{},
which can be rewritten as
(2.23)
\mathcal{L}(G^{1/2}\psi{})=\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}T\psi{}]+G^{-3/2}r^{1/2}\Box{}\varphi{},
where
(2.24)
\begin{split}\mathcal{L}&\coloneqq{}X^{2}+\frac{1}{4}r^{-2}(1-2G^{-1}rG^{\prime}+G^{-2}r^{2}G^{\prime 2}-2G^{-1}r^{2}G^{\prime\prime})+A^{2}G^{-2}r^{-2}\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}\end{split}
and
(2.25)
\mathcal{F}\coloneqq{}-G^{-1}h(2-Gh)T-2G^{-1}(1-Gh)X+G^{-1}(G^{-1}G^{\prime}(1-Gh)+(Gh)^{\prime}).
Finally,
\Psi{}_{0}=r^{1/2}GZ\varphi{}_{0}
satisfies
(2.26)
r^{1/2}GZ\Box{}\varphi{}_{0}=-\underline{L}L\Psi{}_{0}-\frac{3}{4}r^{-2}G\Bigl(G-\frac{2}{3}rG^{\prime}\Bigr)\Psi{}_{0}.
Remark 2.6
(The effective inverse-square potential for good scalar fields)
.
Observe from
eq.
2.26
that
\Psi{}_{0}
satisfies an
equation with a zeroth-order term of a good sign. To be precise, the
zeroth-order term in the equation for
\psi_{\geq 1}
has a bad sign, but it is
compensated for by the angular term of a good sign (via a Poincaré inequality on
S^{1}
).
Proof.
First,
eq.
2.20
is a direct computation (in
(u,v,\theta{})
coordinates) from
eq.
2.5
using
(2.27)
\Box_{g}\varphi{}=\lvert\Det g\rvert^{-1/2}\partial_{\alpha}{}(\lvert\Det g\rvert^{1/2}g^{\alpha{}\beta{}}\partial_{\beta}{}\varphi{}).
Then
eqs.
2.21
,
2.22
,
2.23
, and
2.26
can be derived from
eq.
2.20
using
lemma
2.2
. For
eq.
2.26
, we note that the
+\frac{3}{4}
arises from adding
-\frac{1}{4}
(coming from
r^{-1/2}\partial{}_{r}^{2}r^{1/2}=-\frac{1}{4}r^{-2}
) and
+1
(coming from
-\partial{}_{r}r^{-1}=r^{-2}
).
∎
2.7.
Norms
In this section, we introduce norms that measure energy of a scalar field along
\Sigma{}(\tau{})
, inhomogeneities in the bulk region
\mathcal{R}(\tau_{1},\tau_{2})
, and initial data on
\Sigma{}(0)
. Some norms
will appear with a tilde (for example
\tilde{E}[\Psi{}_{0}]
or
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{p,N}[\tilde{F}]
), while others (such as
E[\varphi{}]
or
\mathcal{A}_{p,N}[F]
) appear without a tilde. We will
use the tilded energies for quantities associated to the good quantities
\Psi{}_{0}=r^{1/2}GZ\varphi_{0}
and
\psi{}_{\geq 1}=r^{1/2}\varphi{}_{\geq 1}
, which carry an
r^{1/2}
-weight. We will use the unadorned energies for
radially symmetric scalar fields
\varphi_{0}
(without an
r^{1/2}
-weight).
The notation
\Phi{}
will always denote an abstract good scalar field, as
defined in
section
4.1.1
(we will later specialize to
\Psi_{0}
and
\psi{}_{\geq 1}
).
2.7.1.
Index of notation
We collect here notation for all the norms we use. We first
introduce the energy norms defined in
section
2.7.2
.
Notation
Meaning
E[\varphi{}]
T
-energy of a radially symmetric scalar field
\varphi{}
\tilde{E}[\Phi{}]
T
-energy of a good scalar field
\Phi{}
\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[\varphi{}]
r^{p}
-weighted energy of a radially symmetric field
\varphi{}
, with
p=1+\delta{}
for
\delta{}\geq 0
small
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p}[\Phi{}]
r^{p}
-weighted energy of a good scalar field
\Phi{}
, used for
p\in[0,2)
Energies with an additional subscript, such as
E_{N}[\varphi{}]
or
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1,N}[\Phi{}]
are higher-order variants of the above
energies with respect to commutation with
(rL)
and
\partial_{\theta}{}
(see
eq.
2.32
). These energies take as arguments a time
\tau{}
and a value
v
: for example,
E[\varphi{}](\tau{},v)
measures
the
T
-energy of
\varphi{}
on the truncated hyperboloidal surface
\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)
(see
eq.
2.8
). When we omit the parameter
v
,
it is to be interpreted as “
v=\infty
.”
Next, we introduce the norms for inhomogeneities defined in
section
2.7.3
.
Notation
Meaning
\mathcal{A}_{p,N}[F]
r^{p}
-weighted norm of
(rL)^{n}F
, with
p\geq 0
and
0\leq n\leq N
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{p,N}[\tilde{F}]
r^{p}
-weighted norm of
(rL)^{n_{1}}\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{2}}\tilde{F}
with
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N
In practice, we will take
F=\Box{}\varphi{}
and
\tilde{F}=r^{1/2}GZ\Box{}\varphi{}
to be the
inhomogeneities associated to
\varphi{}
and
\Psi{}
, respectively. These
will be non-zero when considering the renormalized quantities
\widehat{\varphi{}}
and
\widehat{\Psi{}}
, since the Minkowskian profile
\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
is not an exact solution to the wave equation on
the perturbed background metric.
Finally, we introduce notation for the initial data norms defined in
section
2.7.4
.
Notation
Meaning
\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]
the scalar needed to construct the renormalized solution
\widehat{\varphi{}}\coloneqq{}\varphi{}-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
\mathbf{D}_{N,\delta{}}[\varphi{}]
\leq N
derivatives of the data in
r
-weighted
L^{\infty}
and
L^{2}
norms, with corrections defined by
\delta{}>0
To capture the improved decay for
T
-derivatives, we also use the following
norms:
Notation
Meaning
\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}]
derivatives
(rL)^{\leq N}
and
T^{\leq M}
, with
\tau{}
-weights; defined in
eq.
5.20
\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\Phi{}]
analogous to
\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}
, used for good scalar fields; defined in
proposition
5.6
In practice, we will use the norm
\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}
with arguments
\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
and
T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
, as well as
T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
and
T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
.
2.7.2.
Energy norms
Define the
T
-energy
(2.28)
E[\varphi{}](\tau{},v)\coloneqq{}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\bigl[(L\varphi{})^{2}+h(r)(\underline{L}\varphi{})^{2}+r^{-2}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\varphi{})^{2}\bigr]r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\sim\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\bigl[(X\varphi{})^{2}+h(r)(T\varphi{})^{2}+r^{-2}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\varphi{})^{2}\bigr]r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.
We will also use the modified
T
-energy
(2.29)
\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau{},v)\coloneqq{}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}(L\Phi{})^{2}+h(r)(\underline{L}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{-2}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{-2}\Phi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.
The energy
\tilde{E}
differs from
E
in two ways: it lacks the factor of
r
in the volume form, on account of the
r^{1/2}
-weight already carried
by
\Phi{}
(which in practice is either
\Psi_{0}=r^{1/2}GZ\varphi_{0}
or
\psi_{\geq 1}=r^{1/2}\varphi_{\geq 1}
), and includes the zeroth-order term
r^{-2}\Phi{}
, which is present because
\Phi{}
is a good scalar field.
Next, we introduce the following
r
-weighted energy for
\delta{}\geq 0
:
(2.30)
\begin{split}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta}[\varphi{}](\tau{},v)&\coloneqq{}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle{}^{\delta}{}(L\psi{})^{2}+h(r)\langle{}r\rangle{}^{\delta{}}\varphi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.\end{split}
For
p\in\mathbf{R}
, we define a modified
r
-weighted energy:
(2.31)
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p}[\Phi{}](\tau{},v)\coloneqq{}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{p}(L\Phi{})^{2}+h(r)\langle{}r\rangle^{p}r^{-2}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}+h(r)\langle{}r\rangle^{p}r^{-2}\Phi{}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.
We also define higher-order variants of the above energies (suppressing here the
arguments
(\tau{},v)
):
(2.32)
\begin{split}E_{N}[\varphi{}]\coloneqq{}\sum_{n=0}^{N}E[(rL)^{n}\varphi{}],\qquad\mathcal{E}_{p,N}[\varphi{}]\coloneqq{}\sum_{n=0}^{N}\mathcal{E}_{p}[(rL)^{n}\varphi{}],\qquad\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[\Phi{}]\coloneqq{}\!\!\!\!\!\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p}[\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}\Phi{}].\end{split}
We will not use a higher-order version of the modified
T
-energy. We write
(2.33)
E[\varphi{}](\tau{})\coloneqq{}\sup_{v\geq 0}E[\varphi{}](\tau{},v),
and use similar notation for the other energies.
2.7.3.
Norms for inhomogeneities
For
p\geq 0
,
N\geq 0
, and
\tau{}\geq 0
, define the norm
(2.34)
\mathcal{A}_{p,N}[F](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)\coloneqq{}\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{p}\lvert(rL)^{n}F\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.
For
p\geq 0
,
N\geq 0
,
\tau_{0}\geq 0
, and
v\geq 0
, define the norm
(2.35)
\begin{split}\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{p,N}[\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)&\coloneqq{}\sum_{n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{p+1}(\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}\tilde{F})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N+1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{1+\eta{}_{0}}(\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}\tilde{F})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N}\sup_{\tau{}\in[\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2}]}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{1+\eta{}_{0}}(\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}\tilde{F})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N}\int_{\underline{C}(v)\cap\{\tau{}_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau{}_{2}\}}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{2+\eta{}_{0}}(\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}\tilde{F})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}u\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{},\end{split}
where
\eta_{0}
is the small constant fixed in
section
2.1
. We introduce the
constant
\eta_{0}
and the loss of derivatives in the second line (where
N+1
appears instead of
N
) in the inhomogeneous norm
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}
to avoid the anomalous degeneracy in the
r^{p}
estimates when
p=0
(see
the proof of
eq.
4.16
). In practice, we will only apply these estimates to
scalar fields that satisfy a known inhomogeneity, arising from the failure of
\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
to solve
eq.
2.19
. Since the
inhomogeneity is known, a loss of derivatives does not present an issue. If
there is extra
\tau{}
-decay available, one can remove the loss of derivatives.
2.7.4.
Initial data norm
Define the
L^{1}
-type quantity
(2.36)
\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]\coloneqq{}\Bigl(\int_{0}^{\infty}r^{1/2}G^{1/2}\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}\psi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}]|_{\Sigma{}(0)}+rG^{-1}T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\Bigr)^{-1}\int_{0}^{\infty}r^{1/2}G^{1/2}\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}\psi{}_{0}](r)|_{\Sigma{}(0)}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r,
where
\mathcal{F}
is as in
eq.
2.25
and
\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}=u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2}
. The well-definedness of the quantity
\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]
(in particular the existence of
T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
and the non-vanishing of the factor
that is inverted) is established in
section
6.1.2
.
For
N\geq 0
and
\delta{}\geq 0
, define the initial data norm
(2.37)
\begin{split}&\mathbf{D}_{N,\delta{}}[\varphi{}]\\
&\coloneqq{}\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]^{2}+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n,m\geq 0\\
n+m\leq N\end{subarray}}\lVert\langle{}r\rangle^{1/2}(rX)^{n}T^{m}\varphi{}_{0}\rVert_{L^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0))}^{2}+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2},n_{3}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}+n_{3}\leq N\end{subarray}}\lVert\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rX)^{n_{2}}T^{n_{3}}\psi{}_{\geq 1}\rVert_{L^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0))}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{m=0}^{N}(E_{N-m}[T^{m}\varphi{}_{0}](0)+\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N-m}[T^{m}\varphi{}_{0}](0)+\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N-m}[T^{m}\psi{}_{\geq 1}](0))+\sum_{m=0}^{N-2}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N-m}[T^{m}\Psi{}_{0}](0)\\
&\qquad+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n,m\geq 0\\
n+m\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}\langle{}r\rangle^{3-\delta{}}(X(rX)^{n}\psi{}_{0})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{2-\delta{}}(T(rX)^{n}\varphi{}_{0})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{2-\delta{}}((rX)^{n}\varphi{}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0,v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{2}(X(rX)^{n}\Psi{}_{0})^{2}+((rX)^{n}T\Psi{}_{0})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{1-2\delta{}}((rX)^{n}\Psi{}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}\langle{}r\rangle^{3-\delta{}}(X\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rX)^{n_{2}}\psi{}_{\geq 1})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{1-\delta{}}(T\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rX)^{n_{2}}\psi{}_{\geq 1})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{1-\delta{}}(\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rX)^{n_{2}}\psi{}_{\geq 1})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.\end{split}
We also note that the initial data norms
\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\Phi{}]
and
\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}]
, which are used in
section
5
to establish improved decay for
T
-derivatives, are
defined in
eqs.
5.20
and
5.6
, respectively.
3.
Precise statement of the main result
Given the notation introduced in
section
2
, we can state a
precise version of our main result.
Theorem 3.1
(Main theorem, precise version)
.
Let
h
be the function defined in
section
2.3
that
determines the hyperboloidal foliation
\Sigma{}(\tau{})
, and let
\delta{}_{h}\coloneqq{}\frac{1}{4}(C_{h}+1)^{-1}>0
, where
C_{h}\geq 2
(defined in
item
(iv)
of
section
2.3
) determines the
polynomial rate (in the radial coordinate
r
) at which the hyperboloidal
foliation becomes null.
Let
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
solve
eq.
2.19
, and let
\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}\coloneqq{}u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2}=(t^{2}-\tilde{G}(r)^{2})^{-1/2}
. If the constant
\epsilon{}>0
(which
measures the size of the deviation of the metric
g
from the Minkowski
metric) is sufficiently small, then the following estimate holds for each
N\geq 0
,
M\geq 0
,
\tau{}\geq 0
, and
\delta{}>0
sufficiently small (depending
on
h
):
(3.1)
\begin{split}&\lvert T^{M}(rL)^{N}(\varphi{}-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}})(\tau{},r,\theta{})\rvert\\
&\lesssim_{N,M,h,\delta{}}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}(\tau{},r,\theta{})\cdot(1+\tau{})^{-M-\delta{}_{h}}\cdot\Bigl(\mathbf{D}_{\min(1,N)+M+4,\delta{}}[\varphi{}]+\sum_{k=0}^{1}\mathbf{D}_{\min(1,N)+M+2,\delta{}}[\partial{}_{\theta}^{k}\varphi{}]\Bigr).\end{split}
Here the linear functional
\mathfrak{L}
and the data norm
\mathbf{D}
were defined in
section
2.7.4
.
Proof.
This follows from
eq.
7.57
.
∎
4.
Energy estimates
In this section, we prove energy estimates, namely energy boundedness estimates,
integrated energy estimates, and
r
-weighted energy estimates. The estimates
of
section
4.1
, for scalar fields satisfying an
equation with a good zeroth-order term, are derived using standard techniques.
The estimates in
section
4.2
, for radially symmetric
scalar fields, are new. There we establish estimates for
\varphi_{0}
which
include on the right-hand side quantities involving the good scalar field
\Psi_{0}
, which is estimated in
section
4.1
.
4.1.
Energy estimates for scalar fields that satisfy an equation with a good zeroth-order term
We first establish energy estimates for the quantities
\Psi{}_{0}=r^{1/2}Z\varphi{}_{0}
and
\psi_{\geq 1}=r^{1/2}\varphi_{\geq 1}
, which
satisfy equations with (effective) zeroth-order terms of a good sign.
4.1.1.
The class of scalar fields under consideration
To treat
\Psi_{0}
and
\psi_{\geq 1}
uniformly (although these quantities satisfy
different equations), we formulate the class of “good scalar fields” for which
we prove energy estimates.
Definition 4.1
(The class of good scalar fields)
.
We say that
\Phi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R}\setminus\{r=0\})
satisfies an equation with a good
(effective) zeroth-order term with inhomogeneity
\tilde{F}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R}\setminus\{r=0\})
if
\Phi{}
satisfies the boundary conditions
(4.1)
\begin{gathered}\textnormal{for each }N_{1},N_{2},N_{3}\geq 0,\,r^{-1}\partial_{\theta}^{N_{1}}(rL)^{N_{2}}T^{N_{3}}\Phi{}\textnormal{ extends continuously to }\mathcal{R}\cap\{r=0\}\textnormal{ and vanishes there},\end{gathered}
solves the equation
(4.2)
\underline{L}L\Phi{}+\alpha{}r^{-2}(1+f_{1}(r))\Phi{}-r^{-2}(1+f_{2}(r))\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}\Phi{}=\tilde{F}
for some
\alpha{}\in\mathbf{R}
and
f_{1},f_{2}=\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{}\langle{}r\rangle^{-a})
, and satisfies one of the
following conditions:
(i)
\alpha{}>0
,
(ii)
or
\alpha{}>-1
and
\Phi{}=\Phi{}_{\geq 1}
.
Remark 4.2
(A coercivity property for good scalar fields)
.
If
\Phi{}
satisfies the assumptions of
definition
4.1
, then we have
(4.3)
\int_{S^{1}}(1+f_{2}(r))(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}+\alpha{}(1+f_{1}(r))\Phi{}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\gtrsim_{\alpha}{}\int_{S^{1}}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}+\Phi{}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}
when
\epsilon{}
is sufficiently small. Indeed, this is clear when
item
(i)
holds, and if
item
(ii)
holds, then this follows from the Poincaré
inequality
(4.4)
\int_{S^{1}}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{}_{\geq 1})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\geq\int_{S^{1}}\Phi{}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.
Lemma 4.3
(The quantities
\psi_{\geq 1}
and
\Psi_{0}
are good scalar fields)
.
If
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
, then
\psi_{\geq 1}
and
\Psi_{0}
satisfy the assumptions
of
definition
4.1
with inhomogeneities given by the left-hand sides of
eq.
2.22
(projected to modes
\geq 1
) and
eq.
2.26
,
respectively.
Proof.
For
\Psi_{0}
, we have
\alpha{}=3/4
, and for
\psi_{\geq 1}
, we have
\alpha{}=-1/4
. The
relevant equations are satisfied by
eq.
2.26
and
eq.
2.22
. The boundary conditions are satisfied for any element of
r^{3/2}C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
, and we have
\Psi_{0}\in r^{3/2}C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
by
lemma
2.3
and
\psi_{\geq 1}\in r^{3/2}C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
by
lemma
2.4
.
∎
4.1.2.
Energy boundedness and integrated local energy decay
In this section, we prove an energy boundedness estimate and integrated energy
estimate (or Morawetz estimate) for good scalar fields using the standard
multipliers
T
and
f(r)Z
.
Proposition 4.4
(Energy boundedness and integrated local energy decay for good scalar fields)
.
Suppose
\Phi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R}\setminus\{r=0\})
satisfies the assumptions of
definition
4.1
with inhomogeneity
\tilde{F}
. Then for
0\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
,
v\geq 0
, and
\delta{}>0
, we have
(4.5)
\begin{split}&\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau_{2},v)+\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1-\delta{}}((L\Phi{})^{2}+(\underline{L}\Phi{})^{2})+r^{-2}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1}(\Phi^{2}+(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{\delta{}}\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{1+\delta{},0}[\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v).\end{split}
Moreover, we have
(4.6)
\begin{split}&\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau_{2},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1-\delta{}}(\underline{L}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{\delta}{}\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau_{1},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1-\delta{}}(L\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}\lvert T\Phi{}\rvert\lvert\tilde{F}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
Remark 4.5
(Higher-order estimates)
.
We only prove the estimates in
eq.
4.6
for the good scalar field
\Phi{}
itself, and do not prove higher-order analogues that include
commutation. Instead, we prove higher-order estimates for the
r^{p}
-weighted
energy in
section
4.1.3
. In most situations, we will use the
p=0
energy
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{0}[\Phi{}]
as a replacement for the
T
-energy
\tilde{E}[\Phi{}]
.
Remark 4.6
(Control of terms involving
\underline{L}\Phi{}
)
.
The importance of the estimates in
eq.
4.6
is their control of
flux terms on
\Sigma{}(\tau{})
as well as bulk terms that involve
\underline{L}\Phi{}
, since these quantities are not controlled by the
r^{p}
-weighted energy.
Proof.
Step 1: Energy boundedness.
In this step we will prove
eq.
4.6
and
also the statement that for
0\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
and
v\geq 0
, we have
(4.7)
\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau_{2},v)+\int_{\underline{C}(v)\cap\{\tau{}_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau{}_{2}\}}(\underline{L}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{-2}\Phi^{2}+r^{-2}(\partial{}_{\theta{}}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}u\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\lesssim\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau_{1},v)+\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}\lvert T\Phi{}\rvert\lvert\tilde{F}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.
In Step 2, we will use
eq.
4.7
to conclude
eq.
4.5
.
Let
f:(0,\infty)\to\mathbf{R}_{>0}
be a bounded non-increasing
C^{1}
function.
Multiply
eq.
4.2
by
4f(r)T\Phi{}
, and then use the Leibniz rule and
lemma
2.2
to get
(4.8)
\begin{split}4fT\Phi{}\tilde{F}&=T\bigl(f(r)[(2-Gh)(L\Phi{})^{2}+Gh(\underline{L}\Phi{})^{2}+2\alpha{}r^{-2}(1+f_{1}(r))\Phi^{2}+r^{-2}(1+f_{2}(r))(\partial{}_{\theta}\Phi{})^{2}]\bigr)\\
&\qquad+GX\bigl(f(r)[(\underline{L}\Phi{})^{2}-(L\Phi{})^{2}]\bigr)+\partial{}_{\theta}{}(\cdots{})+(-f^{\prime})[(\underline{L}\Phi{})^{2}-(L\Phi{})^{2}]\end{split}
Let
r_{0}>0
and
v_{0}>0
and integrate
eq.
4.8
over the
region
\{\tau_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau_{2}\}\cap\{v\leq v_{0}\}\cap\{r\geq r_{0}\}
with respect to the volume form
G^{-1}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}
.
The boundary term at
\{r=r_{0}\}
vanishes as
r_{0}\to 0
by the boundary
conditions in
eq.
4.1
. By
eq.
4.4
, the boundary
term at
\{v=v_{0}\}
, with integrand
(L\Phi{})^{2}+\alpha{}r^{-2}(1+f_{1}(r))\Phi^{2}+r^{-2}(1+f_{2}(r))(\partial{}_{\theta{}}\Phi{})^{2}
, has a good sign since
f(r)>0
, and it is comparable to the one in
eq.
4.7
when
f(r)\equiv 1
. The boundary terms at
\{\tau{}=\tau_{i}\}
(
i=1,2
)
are comparable to
\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau_{i},v)
when
f(r)\equiv 1
by
eq.
4.4
. Thus we obtain
eq.
4.7
by taking
f(r)\equiv 1
. To obtain
eq.
4.6
, take
f(r)=1+(1+r)^{-\delta{}}
.
Step 2: Integrated local energy decay.
Let
f:(0,\infty)\to\mathbf{R}_{>0}
be a bounded
non-decreasing
C^{1}
function. Multiply
eq.
4.2
by
2f(r)(L-\underline{L})\Phi{}
, and then use the Leibniz rule to get
(4.9)
\begin{split}2f(r)F(L-\underline{L})\Phi{}&=\underline{L}(f(L\Phi{})^{2}-\alpha{}fr^{-2}(1+f_{1}(r))\Phi^{2}-fr^{-2}(1+f_{2}(r))(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2})\\
&\qquad+L(-f(\underline{L}\Phi{})^{2}+\alpha{}fr^{-2}(1+f_{1}(r))\Phi^{2}+fr^{-2}(1+f_{2}(r))(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2})\\
&\qquad-2G\alpha{}(fr^{-2}(1+f_{1}(r)))^{\prime}\Phi^{2}-2G(fr^{-2}(1+f_{2}(r)))^{\prime}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}\\
&\qquad+Gf^{\prime}[(\underline{L}\Phi{})^{2}+(L\Phi{})^{2}]+\partial{}_{\theta}{}(\cdots{})\end{split}
Let
r_{0}>0
and
v_{0}>0
and integrate
eq.
4.9
over the
region
\{\tau_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau_{2}\}\cap\{v\leq v_{0}\}\cap\{r\geq r_{0}\}
with respect to the volume form
G^{-1}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}
.
The boundary term at
\{r=r_{0}\}
vanishes as
r_{0}\to 0
by the boundary
conditions in
eq.
4.1
. The boundary terms at
\{\tau{}=\tau_{i}\}
and
\{v=v_{0}\}
are controlled by the left-hand side of
eq.
4.7
. We now consider the bulk terms. Choose
f=1-(1+r)^{-\delta{}}
, so that
f^{\prime}\gtrsim_{\delta}{}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1-\delta{}}
and
-(fr^{-2})^{\prime}\gtrsim r^{-2}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1}
. Since
f_{i}(r)=\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{})
, we
conclude using
eq.
4.4
that
(4.10)
\begin{split}&\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau_{2},v)+\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1-\delta{}}((L\Phi{})^{2}+(\underline{L}\Phi{})^{2})+r^{-2}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1}(\Phi^{2}+(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}(\lvert L\Phi{}\rvert+\lvert\underline{L}\Phi{}\rvert)\lvert F\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
Using Young’s inequality and noting that
(4.11)
\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{1+\delta{}}\lvert F\rvert^{2}\lesssim\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{1+\delta{},0}[\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)
completes the proof of
eq.
4.5
.
∎
4.1.3.
r^{p}
-weighted energy estimates
In this section, we prove
r^{p}
-weighted estimates for good scalar fields.
Since these quantities satisfy equations with a zeroth-order term of a
favourable sign, these estimates follow from standard techniques.
We first derive the equation satisfied by the commuted quantities
(rL)^{N}\Phi{}
.
Lemma 4.7
(Equation satisfied by a good scalar field after commutation with
(rL)
)
.
Suppose
\Phi{}
solves
eq.
4.2
for some
\alpha{}\in\mathbf{R}
and
f_{1},f_{2}=\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{}\langle{}r\rangle^{-a})
. Then for
N\geq 0
, we have
(4.12)
\begin{split}0&=\underline{L}L(rL)^{N}\Phi{}+GNr^{-1}L(rL)^{N}\Phi{}+\alpha{}r^{-2}(1+f_{1}(r))(rL)^{N}\Phi{}-r^{-2}(1+f_{2}(r))\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}(rL)^{N}\Phi{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{O}(r^{-2})(rL)^{n}\Phi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{O}(r^{-2})\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}(rL)^{n}\Phi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N}C_{N,n}(rL)^{n}\tilde{F},\end{split}
for some constants
C_{N,n}\in\mathbf{R}
, where the implicit constants in the
\mathcal{O}
-notation depend on
\alpha{}
,
N
, and the functions
f_{1}
and
f_{2}
.
Proof.
We induct on
N
. The
N=0
case is immediate from
eq.
4.2
. Now
suppose
eq.
4.12
holds for some
N\geq 0
. Multiplying both
sides of the equation by
r
and using the Leibniz rule for the first term
gives
(4.13)
\begin{split}0&=\underline{L}(rL)^{N+1}\Phi{}+G(N+1)L(rL)^{N}\Phi{}+\alpha{}r^{-1}(1+f_{1}(r))(rL)^{N}\Phi{}-r^{-1}(1+f_{2}(r))\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}(rL)^{N}\Phi{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{O}(r^{-1})(rL)^{n}\Phi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{O}(r^{-1})\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}(rL)^{n}\Phi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N}C_{N,n}r(rL)^{n}\tilde{F},\end{split}
Act with
L
on both sides and rewrite
(4.14)
LL(rL)^{N}\Phi{}=r^{-1}L(rL)^{N+1}\Phi{}-r^{-1}L(rL)^{N}\Phi{}
to obtain
eq.
4.12
with
N+1
in place of
N
. In
particular, we use the fact that
f_{i}(r)=\mathcal{O}(\langle{}r\rangle^{-a})
for
i=1,2
to obtain
L(r^{-1}(1+f_{i}(r)))=\mathcal{O}(r^{-2})
.
∎
Proposition 4.8
(
r^{p}
-weighted energy estimates)
.
Suppose
\Phi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R}\setminus\{r=0\})
satisfies the assumptions of
definition
4.1
with inhomogeneity
\tilde{F}
. Let
p\in[0,2-\eta_{0}]
(where the small constant
\eta_{0}>0
was fixed in
section
2.1
). Then for
0\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
,
v\geq 0
, and
N\geq 0
, we have
(4.15)
\begin{split}&\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[\Phi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}(n_{2}+p)\langle{}r\rangle^{p}r^{-1}(L\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{p}r^{-3}(\partial{}_{\theta{}}\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}\Phi{})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{p}r^{-3}(\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{\alpha{},\eta{}_{0},N}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{p,N}[\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v),\end{split}
where the norm
\mathcal{\tilde{A}}_{p,N}
was defined in
section
2.7.3
. It follows that for
p\in(0,2-\eta{}_{0}]
, we have
(4.16)
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[\Phi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p-1,N}[\Phi{}](\tau{},v)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim_{\alpha{},p,\eta{}_{0},N}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{p,N}[\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v).
Proof.
Step 1: Preliminary reductions.
First, note that
eq.
4.16
follows immediately from
eq.
4.15
, since
h(r)
is bounded. To
establish
eq.
4.15
, it suffices to consider the case where
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[\Phi{}](\tau_{2},v)
is replaced by
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p}[(rL)^{N}\Phi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)
and
n_{1}=0
and
n_{2}=N
in the sum on the left-hand side. This is because
\partial_{\theta}{}\Phi{}
satisfies the assumptions of
definition
4.1
whenever
\Phi{}
does (in
particular since
\partial_{\theta}{}
commutes with equation
eq.
4.2
).
Moreover, it suffices to prove the estimates with
\langle{}r\rangle^{p}
in
the bulk term on the left-hand side of
eq.
4.15
replaced with
r^{p}
and with
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}
replaced with
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}^{\circ}
,
where
(4.17)
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p}^{\circ}[\Phi{}](\tau{},v)\coloneqq{}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{p}(L\Phi{})^{2}+h(r)r^{p-2}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}+h(r)r^{p-2}\Phi{}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}
and the higher-order version
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}^{\circ}
is defined as in
section
2.7.2
. This is because the estimate for
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}
can
obtained by summing the estimates for
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{0,N}^{\circ}
and
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{{p,N}}^{\circ}
.
Step 2: Zeroth-order estimate.
We first establish
eq.
4.15
(with
the appropriate reductions of Step 1) when
N=0
.
Multiply
eq.
4.2
by
2r^{p}L\Phi{}
and use the Leibniz rule to get
(4.18)
\begin{split}r^{p}L\Phi{}\cdot\tilde{F}&=\underline{L}(r^{p}(L\Phi{})^{2})+L(r^{p-2}(1+f_{2}(r))(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}+\alpha{}r^{p-2}(1+f_{1}(r))\Phi{}^{2})+\partial{}_{\theta}{}(\cdots{})+Gpr^{p-1}(L\Phi{})^{2}\\
&\qquad+G(2-p)r^{p-3}[\alpha{}(1+f_{1}(r)-(2-p)^{-1}rf_{1}^{\prime}(r))\Phi{}^{2}+(1+f_{2}(r)-(2-p)^{-1}rf_{2}^{\prime}(r))(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}].\end{split}
Fix
r_{0}>0
and
v_{0}>0
. We integrate
eq.
4.18
over the region
\{\tau_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau_{2}\}\cap\{v\leq v_{0}\}\cap\{r\geq r_{0}\}
with
respect to
G^{-1}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}
. The boundary term on
\{\tau{}=\tau_{i}\}
is proportional to
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p}^{\circ}[\Phi{}](\tau{}_{i},v)
by
eq.
4.4
. The bulk
term that arises is proportional to the bulk term in
eq.
4.15
(with the appropriate reductions of Step 1) when
N=0
by
eq.
4.4
, after one chooses
\epsilon{}\ll 2-p\leq\eta{}_{0}
, so that
(4.19)
1+f_{1}(r)-(2-p)^{-1}rf_{1}^{\prime}(r)=1+O(\epsilon{}\max(1,(2-p)^{-1}))\geq\frac{1}{2}.
The boundary
term at
\{r=r_{0}\}
is
r^{p}[(L\Phi{})^{2}-r^{-2}(1+f_{2}(r))(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}-\alpha{}r^{-2}(1+f_{1}(r))\Phi{}^{2}]
. By the boundary conditions
eq.
4.1
, this term vanishes as
r_{0}\to 0
. Applying
eq.
4.4
to the boundary term at
\{v=v_{0}\}
, we have
(4.20)
\begin{split}&\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p}^{\circ}[\Phi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}pr^{p-1}(L\Phi{})^{2}+r^{p-3}\Phi{}^{2}+r^{p-3}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}+\int_{\underline{C}(v)\cap\{\tau{}_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau{}_{2}\}}r^{p-2}\Phi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}u\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim_{\alpha{}}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p}^{\circ}[\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\Big\lvert\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{p}L\Phi{}\cdot\tilde{F}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\Big\rvert.\end{split}
To control the bulk term involving the inhomogeneity
F
, we can use Young’s
inequality directly when
p\geq\eta{}_{0}
:
(4.21)
\Big\lvert\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{p}L\Phi{}\cdot\tilde{F}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\Big\rvert\leq\delta{}p\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{p-1}(L\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}+\delta{}^{-1}\eta{}_{0}^{-1}\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{p+1}\tilde{F}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.
The first term on the right can be absorbed into the left-hand side of
eq.
4.20
(for
\delta{}>0
sufficiently small depending on
\alpha{}
), and the second term on the right is controlled by the norm
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{p,0}[F](\tau_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)
. If
p\leq\eta_{0}
, then we first
integrate the
L
-derivative by parts and then use Young’s inequality:
(4.22)
\begin{split}&\Big\lvert\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{p}L\Phi{}\cdot\tilde{F}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\Big\rvert\\
&\lesssim\delta{}\Bigl[\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{p-3}\Phi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}+\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{}_{2},v)}h(r)r^{p-2}\Phi{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}+\int_{\underline{C}(v_{0})\cap\{\tau{}_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau{}_{2}\}}r^{p-2}\Phi{}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}u\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\Bigr]\\
&\qquad+\delta{}^{-1}\Bigl[\sum_{n=0}^{1}\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{p+1}((rL)^{n}F)^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}+\sum_{i=1}^{2}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{}_{i},v)}h(r)r^{p+2}\tilde{F}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\qquad+\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{}_{1},v)}h(r)r^{p-2}\Phi{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}+\int_{\underline{C}(v)\cap\{\tau{}_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau{}_{2}\}}r^{p+2}\tilde{F}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}u\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\Bigr].\end{split}
The terms with
\delta{}
can be absorbed into the left-hand side of
eq.
4.20
, and the terms with
\delta^{-1}
make up the norm
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{p,0}[F](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)
(after noting that
h(r)\lesssim\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1}
). In either case, we obtain the
N=0
case of
eq.
4.15
.
Step 3: Higher-order estimates.
Now let
N\geq 1
and suppose
eq.
4.15
(with the appropriate reductions of Step 1) holds for
N-1
in place of
N
. Multiply
eq.
4.12
by
2r^{p}L(rL)^{N}\Phi{}
and use the Leibniz rule to get
(4.23)
\begin{split}0&=\underline{L}(r^{p}(L(rL)^{N}\Phi{})^{2})+L\bigl(\alpha{}r^{p-2}(1+f_{1}(r))((rL)^{N}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{p-2}(1+f_{2}(r))(\partial{}_{\theta}{}(rL)^{N}\Phi{})^{2}\bigr)+\partial{}_{\theta}{}(\cdots{})\\
&\qquad+2G(N+p)r^{p-1}(L(rL)^{N}\Phi{})^{2}+G\alpha{}(2-p)r^{p-3}(1+\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{}\max(1,(2-p)^{-1})))((rL)^{N}\Phi{})^{2}\\
&\qquad+G(2-p)r^{p-3}(1+\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{}\max(1,(2-p)^{-1})))(\partial{}_{\theta}{}(rL)^{N}\Phi{})^{2}\\
&\qquad+r^{(p-1)/2}L(rL)^{N}\Phi{}\cdot\Bigl[\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{O}(r^{(p-3)/2})(rL)^{n}\Phi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{O}(r^{(p-3)/2})(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\partial{}_{\theta}{}(rL)^{n}\Phi{})\Bigr]\\
&\qquad+r^{p}L(rL)^{N}\Phi{}\cdot\sum_{n=0}^{N}C_{N,n}(rL)^{n}\tilde{F},\end{split}
Fix
r_{0}>0
and
v_{0}>0
and integrate over
\{\tau_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau_{2}\}\cap\{v\leq v_{0}\}\cap\{r\geq r_{0}\}
. As in Step 2, the boundary term at
\{r=r_{0}\}
vanishes as
r_{0}\to 0
. After using
eq.
4.4
to show that the bulk term and the boundary terms at
\{\tau{}=\tau_{i}\}
and
\{v=v_{0}\}
are coercive, we get
(4.24)
\begin{split}&\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p}^{\circ}[(rL)^{N}\Phi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{p-1}(L(rL)^{N}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{p-3}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}(rL)^{N}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{p-3}((rL)^{N}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\int_{\underline{C}(v_{0})\cap\{\tau{}_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau{}_{2}\}}r^{p-2}((rL)^{N}\Phi)^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}u\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p}^{\circ}[(rL)^{N}\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)\\
&\qquad+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{(p-1)/2}L(rL)^{N}\Phi{}\cdot\Bigl[\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{O}(r^{(p-3)/2})(rL)^{n}\Phi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{O}(r^{(p-3)/2})(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\partial{}_{\theta}{}(rL)^{n}\Phi{})\Bigr]\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{p}L(rL)^{N}\Phi{}\cdot C_{N,n}{(rL)}^{n}\tilde{F}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
After using Young’s inequality and adding a suitable multiple of
eq.
4.15
(with the appropriate reductions of Step 1) with
N-1
in place of
N
(applied to both
u
and
\partial_{\theta}{}u
) to control
the terms on the second line of the right-hand side of
eq.
4.24
, we
obtain
(4.25)
\begin{split}\textup{{(LHS of }}\textup{\lx@cref{creftype\lx@tilde refnum}{rp-prelim-inequality}}\text{{)}}\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{1}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N-1}^{\circ}[\partial{}_{\theta}^{n}\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}r^{p}L(rL)^{N}\Phi{}\cdot{(rL)}^{n}\tilde{F}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
Controlling the bulk term on the right by integrating by parts as in Step 2
completes the proof of
eq.
4.15
, in view of Step 1.
∎
4.1.4.
An integrated estimate for the modified
T
-energy
The energy estimates of
sections
4.1.2
and
4.1.3
allow us to quickly
prove an estimate controlling the integral of the modified
T
-energy.
Proposition 4.9
(Integrated estimate for the modified
T
-energy)
.
Suppose
\Phi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R}\setminus\{r=0\})
satisfies the assumptions of
definition
4.1
with inhomogeneity
\tilde{F}
. Then for
0\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
,
v\geq 0
, and
\delta{}>0
, we have
(4.26)
\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau{},v)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim_{\delta}{}\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1}[\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{1+\delta{},0}[\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v).
Proof.
Since
h(r)\lesssim\langle{}r\rangle^{-1-\eta{}_{h}}
, we have
(4.27)
\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau{},v)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}(L\Phi{})^{2}+r^{-2}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{-2}\Phi^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{-1-\eta{}_{h}}(\underline{L}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.
To control the final term on the right-hand side, use
eq.
4.6
(with
\eta_{h}
in place of
\delta{}
there) to obtain
(4.28)
\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\tilde{E}[\Phi{}](\tau{},v)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}(L\Phi{})^{2}+r^{-2}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{-2}\Phi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\lvert T\Phi{}\rvert\lvert\tilde{F}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.
To control the first three terms on the right-hand side, use
eq.
4.16
with
p=1
. For the final term, use an
r
-weighted Young’s inequality together
with
eq.
4.5
.
∎
4.2.
Energy estimates for radially symmetric scalar fields
We now turn our attention to radially
symmetric scalar fields, for which proving energy estimates is more difficult,
as discussed in
section
1.2
.
4.2.1.
Energy boundedness and integrated energy estimates
We first record the standard
T
-energy estimate. For a higher-order version
of this estimate (controlling the energy
E_{N}[\varphi{}]
for
N\geq 1
), see
proposition
4.13
.
Proposition 4.10
(Boundedness of the
T
-energy)
.
Let
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
. For
0\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
and
v\geq 0
, we have
(4.29)
E[\varphi{}](\tau_{2},v)+\sup_{0\leq v^{\prime}\leq v}\int_{\underline{C}(v^{\prime})\cap\{\tau_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau_{2}\}}r(\underline{L}\varphi{})^{2}+r^{-1}(\partial_{\theta}{}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}u\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\lesssim E[\varphi{}](\tau_{1},v)+\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\lvert T\varphi{}\rvert\lvert r\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.
Moreover, for any
\delta{}>0
we have
(4.30)
\begin{split}&\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1-\delta{}}r(\underline{L}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{\delta}{}E[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1-\delta{}}r(L\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}+\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{-\delta{}}\lvert T\varphi{}\rvert\lvert r\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
Proof.
Let
f:(0,\infty)\to\mathbf{R}_{>0}
be a bounded non-increasing
C^{1}
function. Multiply
eq.
2.20
by
-4rf(r)T\varphi{}
, and then use the Leibniz rule and
lemma
2.2
to get
(4.31)
\begin{split}-4rfT\varphi{}\Box{}\varphi{}&=\underline{L}(fr(L\varphi{})^{2}+fr^{-1}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\varphi{})^{2})+L(fr(\underline{L}\varphi{})^{2}+fr^{-1}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\varphi{})^{2})\\
&\qquad-\partial{}_{\theta}{}(2fr^{-2}\partial{}_{\theta}{}\varphi{}T\varphi{})+G(-f^{\prime})r[(\underline{L}\varphi{})^{2}-(L\varphi{})^{2}]\\
&=T(fr(2-h)(L\varphi{})^{2}+frh(\underline{L}\varphi{})^{2}+fr^{-1}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\varphi{})^{2})+GX(-fr(L\varphi{})^{2}+fr(\underline{L}\varphi{})^{2})\\
&\qquad+\partial{}_{\theta}{}(\cdots{})+G(-f^{\prime})r[(\underline{L}\varphi{})^{2}-(L\varphi{})^{2}].\end{split}
Let
r_{0}>0
and
v_{0}>0
and integrate
eq.
4.31
over the region
\{\tau_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau_{2}\}\cap\{v\leq v_{0}\}\cap\{r\geq r_{0}\}
with respect to the volume form
G^{-1}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}
. The boundary term at
\{r=r_{0}\}
is
-fr(L\varphi{})^{2}+fr(\underline{L}\varphi{})^{2}
, which vanishes as
r_{0}\to 0
due to the
regularity of
\varphi{}
at
\{r=0\}
. To obtain
eq.
4.29
, take
f(r)\equiv 1
and take a supremum over
v_{0}\leq v
. To obtain
eq.
4.30
, take
f(r)=(1+r)^{-\delta{}}
.
∎
We now establish an estimate that controls a bulk term involving derivatives of
\varphi{}
by the
T
-energy of
\varphi{}
and a bulk term involving
\Psi{}
. We need this estimate to control terms arising from commutation (see
proposition
4.13
).
Proposition 4.11
(Integrated energy estimate; radially symmetric case)
.
Let
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
be radially symmetric. For
0\leq\tau{}_{1}\leq\tau{}_{2}
,
v\geq 0
, and
\delta{}\in(0,1)
, we have
(4.32)
\begin{split}&E[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}[(L\varphi{})^{2}+(\underline{L}\varphi{})^{2}]\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{\delta}{}E[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{-1}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}\Psi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}\lvert r\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{},\end{split}
Proof.
Take
f(r)=(1+r)^{-1+\delta{}}
, so that
f
is bounded and
(rf)^{\prime}\sim_{\delta}{}(1+r)^{-1+\delta{}}
. Rewrite
eq.
2.20
as
(4.33)
\underline{L}L\varphi{}=r^{-1}GZ\varphi{}-\Box{}\varphi{}=r^{-3/2}\Psi{}-\Box{}\varphi{}.
We have reinterpreted the first-order term
r^{-1}GZ\varphi{}
, which obstructs a
standard Morawetz estimate, as a source term involving
\Psi{}
, which we have
already controlled. Multiply
eq.
4.33
by
2rf(r)(L-\underline{L})\varphi{}=4f(r)r^{1/2}\Psi{}
and use the Leibniz rule and
Young’s inequality to get
(4.34)
\begin{split}\underline{L}(rf(L\varphi{})^{2})-L(rf(\underline{L}\varphi{})^{2})+G(rf)^{\prime}[(L\varphi{})^{2}+(\underline{L}\varphi{})^{2}]&=4r^{-1}f\Psi^{2}+4f\cdot r^{-1/2}\Psi{}\cdot r\Box{}\varphi{}\\
&\lesssim r^{-1}f\Psi^{2}+f\lvert r\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}.\end{split}
Fix
r_{0}>0
and
v_{0}>0
. The boundary term at
\{r=r_{0}\}
arising from
integrating
eq.
4.34
over the region
\{\tau_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau_{2}\}\cap\{v\leq v_{0}\}\cap\{r\geq r_{0}\}
is
rf(L\varphi{})^{2}-rf(\underline{L}\varphi{})^{2}
, which vanishes as
r_{0}\to 0
. The boundary
terms at
\{\tau{}=\tau{}_{i}\}
are controlled by the
T
-energy, since
f
and
G
are bounded. After adding a suitable multiple of
eq.
4.29
, we obtain
eq.
4.32
.
∎
Next, we turn to proving a higher-order version of
eqs.
4.30
and
4.32
. To this end, we compute the terms
that arise when commuting the above estimates with
(rL)^{N}
.
Lemma 4.12
(Commutation with
(rL)^{N}
)
.
Suppose
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
. Then for
N\geq 0
, we have
(4.35)
r^{1/2}GZ(rL)^{N}\varphi{}=\sum_{n=0}^{N}\mathcal{O}(1)(rL)^{n}\Psi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{O}(r^{1/2})L(rL)^{n}\varphi{}
and
(4.36)
L(r^{1/2}GZ(rL)^{N}\varphi{})=\sum_{n=0}^{N}\mathcal{O}(1)L(rL)^{n}\Psi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\mathcal{O}(r^{-1/2})L(rL)^{n}\varphi{}.
Moreover, if
\varphi{}
is radially symmetric, we have
(4.37)
[\Box{},(rL)^{N}]\varphi{}=\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\bigl[\mathcal{O}(r^{-1})L(rL)^{n}\varphi{}+\mathcal{O}(r^{-1/2})L(rL)^{n}\Psi{}+\mathcal{O}(r^{-1/2}\langle{}r\rangle^{-2})(rL)^{n}\Psi{}\bigr].
We interpret sums from
0
to
N-1
as being empty if
N=0
.
Proof.
First,
eq.
4.35
follows from the stronger statement that for each
N\geq 1
and
0\leq n\leq N
, there exist constants
C_{N,n}
such that
(4.38)
r^{1/2}GZ(rL)^{N}\varphi{}=\sum_{n=0}^{N}C_{N,n}(rL)^{n}\Psi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{O}(r^{1/2})L(rL)^{n}\varphi{}.
The
N=1
case of
eq.
4.38
follows from the computation
(4.39)
r^{1/2}GZ(rL)\varphi{}=(rL)\Psi{}-\frac{1}{2}\Psi{}+r^{1/2}GL\varphi{},
and the general case follows by induction on
N
after using
eq.
4.39
with
(rL)^{N}\varphi{}
in place of
\varphi{}
to write
(4.40)
\begin{split}r^{1/2}GZ(rL)^{N+1}\varphi{}&=r^{1/2}GZ(rL)(rL)^{N}\varphi{}=(rL)(r^{1/2}GZ(rL)^{N}\varphi{})-\frac{1}{2}r^{1/2}GZ(rL)^{N}\varphi{}+r^{1/2}GL(rL)^{N}\varphi{}.\end{split}
Now
eq.
4.36
is obtained by acting with
L
on both sides of
eq.
4.35
.
The
N=1
case of
eq.
4.37
follows from the computation
(4.41)
[\Box{},rL]\varphi{}=(G^{2}+GrG^{\prime})r^{-1}L\varphi{}+2r^{-1/2}GL\Psi{}-r^{-1/2}GG^{\prime}\Psi{},
which can be obtained from
eq.
2.20
, and the inequality
a\geq 1
(where
a
appears in
section
2.2
). The general case
follows by induction on
N
after writing
(4.42)
[\Box{},(rL)^{N+1}\varphi{}]=(rL)[\Box{},(rL)^{N}]\varphi{}+[\Box{},rL](rL)^{N}\varphi{}
and using the identities
eqs.
4.36
and
4.35
to compute the final term in
eq.
4.42
.
∎
Proposition 4.13
(Higher-order
T
-energy estimate and integrated energy estimate; radially symmetric case)
.
Suppose
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
is radially symmetric. Then for
0\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
,
v\geq 0
,
N\geq 0
, and
\delta{}>0
, we have
(4.43)
\begin{split}&E_{N}[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}[(L(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}+(\underline{L}(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}]\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}E_{N}[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[\Psi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{1+\delta{},N}[\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)+\mathcal{A}_{1+\delta{},N}[\Box{}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v),\end{split}
where
\tilde{F}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}GZ\Box{}\varphi{}
is the inhomogeneity in the equation
satisfied by
\Psi{}
(see
eq.
2.26
) and the inhomogeneous norms
\mathcal{A}
and
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}
were defined in
section
2.7.3
.
Proof.
First, the
N=0
case follows from
eqs.
4.32
and
4.16
. Now
suppose that
N\geq 1
and that we have established
eq.
4.43
with
N-1
in place of
N
. Apply
eq.
4.32
with
(rL)^{N}\varphi{}
in place of
\varphi{}
to obtain
(4.44)
\begin{split}&E[(rL)^{N}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}[(L(rL)^{N}\varphi{})^{2}+(\underline{L}(rL)^{N}\varphi{})^{2}]\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{\delta}{}E[(rL)^{N}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{-1}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}(r^{1/2}GZ(rL)^{N}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}\lvert r[\Box{},(rL)^{N}]\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}r^{2}\lvert(rL)^{N}\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
We now control the bulk terms on the right-hand side of
eq.
4.44
. Use
eq.
4.35
and
eq.
4.16
applied to
\Psi{}
(with
p=1+\delta{}
) to compute
(4.45)
\begin{split}&\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{-1}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}(r^{1/2}GZ(rL)^{N}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{-1}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}((rL)^{n}\Psi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}(L(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[\Psi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{1+\delta{},N}[\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}(L(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
Next, use
eq.
4.37
and
eq.
4.16
applied to
\Psi{}
(with
p=1+\delta{}
) to compute
(4.46)
\begin{split}&\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}\lvert r[\Box{},(rL)^{N}]\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}r(L(rL)^{n}\Psi{})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{-4+\delta{}}((rL)^{n}\Psi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}(L(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N-1}[\Psi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{1+\delta{},N-1}[\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}(L(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
To complete the proof of
eq.
4.43
, substitute
eqs.
4.45
and
4.46
into
eq.
4.44
and
add a suitable multiple of
eq.
4.43
with
N-1
in place of
N
.
∎
4.2.2.
r
-weighted energy estimates
We now establish
r
-weighted energy estimates for
radially symmetric scalar fields. We establish these estimates not for
\varphi{}
itself, but for
(rL)\varphi{}
(see
proposition
4.15
) and
T\varphi{}
(see
proposition
4.16
). That is, we must commute with one
derivative in order to obtain an
r
-weighted energy estimate.
We begin by deriving a general identity associated to multipliers of the form
f(r)L
.
Lemma 4.14
(Identity associated to the multiplier
f(r)L
)
.
Let
f(r)=rg(r)
for
g:[0,\infty)\to\mathbf{R}_{>0}
a
C^{2}
function. Then for any
v\geq 0
and
0\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
, an identity of the following form
holds for radially symmetric functions
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
:
(4.47)
\begin{split}&\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{}_{2},v)}(2-Gh)f(L\psi{})^{2}+\frac{1}{4}G^{2}h(2rg^{\prime}+(1+O(\epsilon{}))g)\varphi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\qquad+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}rf^{\prime}(L\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}+\int_{\underline{C}(v)\cap\{\tau{}_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau{}_{2}\}}\frac{1}{4}G^{2}(2rg^{\prime}+(1+O(\epsilon{}))g)\varphi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}u\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&=\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{}_{1},v)}(2-Gh)f(L\psi{})^{2}+\frac{1}{4}G^{2}h(2rg^{\prime}+(1+O(\epsilon{}))g)\varphi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\qquad+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\bigl(O(1)rg^{\prime\prime}+O(1)g^{\prime}+O(\epsilon{}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1-a})g\bigr)\varphi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad-\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}2G^{-1}fL\psi{}r^{1/2}\Box{}\varphi{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
Proof.
Multiply both sides of
eq.
2.22
by
-2f(r)L\psi{}
, use the expansions
(4.48)
L\psi{}=\frac{1}{2}Gr^{-1/2}\varphi{}+r^{1/2}L\varphi{},\qquad(L\psi{})^{2}=r(L\varphi{})^{2}+\frac{1}{2}GL(\varphi{}^{2})+\frac{1}{4}G^{2}r^{-1}\varphi^{2},
and use the Leibniz rule to obtain
(4.49)
\begin{split}-2fL\psi{}r^{1/2}\Box{}\varphi{}&=\underline{L}(f(L\psi{})^{2})+\frac{1}{4}L(-r^{-1}fG(G-2rG^{\prime})\varphi^{2})+Grf^{\prime}(L\varphi{})^{2}\\
&\qquad+\frac{1}{4}G\Bigl[r(r^{-2}fG(G-2rG^{\prime}))^{\prime}+G^{2}r^{-1}f^{\prime}\Bigr]\varphi^{2}+\frac{1}{2}G^{2}f^{\prime}L(\varphi^{2})\\
&=\underline{L}(f(L\psi{})^{2})+\frac{1}{4}L\bigl(G^{2}(2rg^{\prime}+g+2rgG^{-1}G^{\prime})\varphi^{2}\bigr)+Grf^{\prime}(L\varphi{})^{2}\\
&\qquad+\frac{1}{2}G^{3}\Bigl[-rg^{\prime\prime}-(1+3rG^{-1}G^{\prime})g^{\prime}-gG^{-1}(rG^{\prime\prime}+rG^{-1}(G^{\prime})^{2}+G^{\prime})\Bigr]\varphi{}^{2}\end{split}
In passing to the final line, we expressed
f=rg
and differentiated the
L(\varphi^{2})
term by parts, which produces a term
\frac{1}{2}(G^{2}f^{\prime})^{\prime}\varphi^{2}
and a total-
L
-derivative term. By the assumptions on
G
(and
lemma
2.3
), the zeroth-order term (in the last line of
eq.
4.49
) has the form
(4.50)
\bigl(O(1)rg^{\prime\prime}+O(1)g^{\prime}+O(\epsilon{}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1-a})g\bigr)\varphi^{2}.
Now let
r_{0}>0
and
v_{0}>0
. Use
eq.
4.48
and the identity
f=rg
to express the integrand of the boundary term at
\{r=r_{0}\}
that
arises from integrating
eq.
4.49
on
\{\tau{}_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau{}_{2}\}\cap\{v\leq v_{0}\}\cap\{r\geq r_{0}\}
with respect to the volume
form
G^{-1}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}
as follows:
(4.51)
f(L\psi{})^{2}-\frac{1}{4}G^{2}(2rg^{\prime}+g+2rgG^{-1}G^{\prime})\varphi^{2}=r^{2}g(L\varphi{})^{2}+Gf\varphi{}L\varphi{}-\frac{1}{4}G^{2}(2rg^{\prime}+2rgG^{-1}G^{\prime})\varphi^{2}.
This term vanishes as
r\to 0
since
g
and
G
are
C^{1}
functions of
r
(up to and including
r=0
). We therefore obtain the desired identity
upon integration.
∎
We now prove an estimate for
(rL)
-derivatives of the solution. We can close
the estimate because with
(rL)
will produce bulk terms involving
L(rL)^{\leq 1}\varphi{}
of a good sign as well as error terms involving
\Psi{}
.
Proposition 4.15
(
r
-weighted energy estimate for
(rL)
-derivatives; radially symmetric case)
.
Suppose
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
is radially symmetric. Then for
0\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
,
v\geq 0
, and
N\geq 0
, and
\delta{}\geq 0
sufficiently small, we have
(4.52)
\begin{split}&\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\sum_{n=0}^{N+1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{N}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[\Psi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{1+\delta{},N}[\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)+\mathcal{A}_{3+\delta{},N+1}[\Box{}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)\\
&\qquad+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{2}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{n}\Psi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{},\end{split}
where
\tilde{F}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}GZ\Box{}\varphi{}
is the inhomogeneity in the equation
satisfied by
\Psi{}
(see
eq.
2.26
) and the inhomogeneous norms
\mathcal{A}
and
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}
were defined in
section
2.7.3
.
Proof.
Step 1: The case
N=0
.
Set
f(r)=r(1+r)^{\delta}{}
(i.e.
g(r)=(1+r)^{\delta}{}
).
We explicitly compute
(4.53)
\begin{cases}2rg^{\prime}(r)+(1+\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{}))g(r)\sim\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{},\\
rf^{\prime}(r)\geq r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}\\
\lvert rg^{\prime\prime}\rvert+\lvert g^{\prime}\rvert+\epsilon{}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1-a}\lvert g\rvert\lesssim(\delta{}+\epsilon{})\langle{}r\rangle^{-1+\delta{}}.\end{cases}
It follows from
eq.
4.47
(after dropping the term on
\underline{C}(v)
, which has a good sign) that
(4.54)
\begin{split}&C^{-1}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+C^{-1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle{}^{\delta}{}(L\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\leq C\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+C(\delta{}+\epsilon{})\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1+\delta{}}\varphi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}-\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}2G^{-1}r(1+r)^{\delta}{}L\psi{}r^{1/2}\Box{}\varphi{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\end{split}
for some constant
C>0
. Applying
eq.
4.54
to
(rL)\varphi{}
in
place of
\varphi{}
, we obtain
(4.55)
\begin{split}&C^{-1}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+C^{-1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle{}^{\delta}{}(L(rL)\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\leq C\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+C(\delta{}+\epsilon{})\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad-\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}2G^{-1}r(1+r)^{\delta}{}L(r^{1/2}(rL)\varphi{})r^{1/2}\Box{}(rL)\varphi{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\end{split}
We now compute the final term on the right-hand side of
eq.
4.55
and observe that it produces a bulk term (of a good sign) that controls
\langle{}r\rangle^{-1+\delta{}}((rL)\varphi{})^{2}
. The commutation formula
eq.
4.41
and the
identity
(4.56)
L(r^{1/2}(rL)\varphi{})=r^{1/2}L(rL)\varphi{}+\frac{1}{2}r^{1/2}L\varphi{}
imply
(4.57)
\begin{split}&G^{-1}r(1+r)^{\delta}{}L(r^{1/2}(rL)\varphi{})r^{1/2}[\Box{},rL]\varphi{}\\
&=(1+r)^{\delta}{}\Bigl(r^{1/2}L(rL)\varphi{}+\frac{1}{2}r^{1/2}L\varphi{}\Bigr)((G+rG^{\prime})r^{1/2}L\varphi{}+2rL\Psi{}-rG^{\prime}\Psi{})\\
\end{split}
We now expand the parentheses, producing terms proportional to
(4.58)
\textnormal{(I)}\coloneqq{}r(1+r)^{\delta}{}(L\varphi{})^{2}\textnormal{ and }\textnormal{(II)}\coloneqq{}(1+r)^{\delta}{}\cdot r^{1/2}L(rL)\varphi{}\cdot r^{1/2}L\varphi{}=\frac{1}{2}(1+r)^{\delta}{}L(((rL)\varphi{})^{2}),
with proportionality constants independent of
\delta{}
. We also produce terms
multiplying
L^{\leq 1}\Psi{}
, which we treat as error. The key step is to
differentiate by parts term
(II)
,
producing a total-
L
-derivative term of a good sign and a bulk term of a bad
sign proportional to
\delta{}r(1+r)^{\delta}{}(L\varphi{})^{2}
, which is
compensated for by the pre-existing such term of a good sign that comes without
a
\delta{}
-factor, namely term
(I)
. We therefore obtain
(4.59)
\begin{split}&\textup{{(LHS of }}\textup{\lx@cref{creftype\lx@tilde refnum}{rL-phi-commuted-prep}}\text{{)}}\\
&=\frac{1}{2}L((1+r)^{\delta}{}(G+rG^{\prime})((rL)\varphi{})^{2})+\frac{1}{2}(G-rG^{\prime}-r^{2}G^{\prime\prime}-\delta{}(1+r)^{-1})r(1+r)^{\delta}{}(L\varphi{})^{2}\\
&\qquad+(1+r)^{\delta}{}\Bigl(r^{1/2}L(rL)\varphi{}+\frac{1}{2}r^{1/2}L\varphi{}\Bigr)(2rL\Psi{}-rG^{\prime}\Psi{})\\
&\geq\frac{1}{2}L((1+O(\epsilon{}))(1+r)^{\delta}{}((rL)\varphi{})^{2})+\frac{1}{4}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L\varphi{})^{2}-C\langle{}r\rangle{}^{\delta}{}(r^{1/2}\lvert L(rL)\varphi{}\rvert+r^{1/2}\lvert L\varphi{}\rvert)(r\lvert L\Psi{}\rvert+\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1}\lvert\Psi{}\rvert).\end{split}
for
\delta{}\geq 0
sufficiently small (say
\delta{}<1/8
). We used
\lvert rG^{\prime}\rvert\leq\langle{}r\rangle^{-1}
to pass to the final line. Substitute
eqs.
4.56
and
4.57
into
eq.
4.55
and rearrange terms to obtain
(4.60)
\begin{split}&C^{-1}\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+C^{-1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)\varphi{})^{2}+r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}L((1+\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{}))(1+r)^{\delta}{}((rL)\varphi{})^{2})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\leq C\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+C(\delta{}+\epsilon{})\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+C\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(r^{1/2}\lvert L(rL)\varphi{}\rvert+r^{1/2}\lvert L\varphi{}\rvert)(r\lvert L\Psi{}\rvert+\langle{}r\rangle^{-1}\lvert\Psi{}\rvert+r^{3/2}\lvert(rL)\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
The final term on the left-hand side produces a term at
\underline{C}(v)
with a
good sign (and no boundary term at
\{r=0\}
). After dropping this term,
absorbing the
(\delta{}+\epsilon{})
-term to the left-hand side (taking
\delta{}
sufficiently small), and applying Young’s inequality, we obtain
(4.61)
\begin{split}&\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)\varphi{})^{2}+r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{2}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L\Psi{})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{-2+\delta{}}\Psi^{2}+r^{3}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}\lvert(rL)\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
Apply
eq.
4.16
to
\Psi{}
(with
p=1+\delta{}
) to control the zeroth-order
term involving
\Psi{}
on the right-hand side of
eq.
4.61
and
obtain
eq.
4.52
when
N=0
.
Step 2: The case
N\geq 1
.
Suppose
N\geq 1
and
eq.
4.52
holds
with
N-1
in place of
N
. Apply
eq.
4.61
with
(rL)^{N}\varphi{}
in place of
\varphi{}
and use
lemma
4.12
to obtain
(4.62)
\begin{split}&\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)^{N}(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{N}(rL)\varphi{})^{2}+r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{N}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)^{N}(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)\\
&\qquad+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{2}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(r^{1/2}GZ(rL)^{N}\varphi{}))^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{-2+\delta{}}(r^{1/2}GZ(rL)^{N}\varphi{})^{2}+r^{3}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}\lvert(rL)\Box{}(rL)^{N}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\mathcal{E}_{1}[(rL)^{N}(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{2}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{n}\Psi{})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{-2+\delta{}}((rL)^{n}\Psi)^{2}+r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{3}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}\lvert(rL)^{N+1}\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\end{split}
To complete the proof of
eq.
4.52
with
N\geq 1
, add to
eq.
4.61
a multiple of
eq.
4.52
with
\delta{}=0
and
N-1
in place of
N
and a multiple of
eq.
4.15
applied to
\Psi{}
(with
p=1+\delta{}
).
∎
We now prove an estimate for a
(rL)^{N}T
-derivative of the solution. We can
close the estimate when
N=0
because replacing
\varphi{}
with
T\varphi{}
turns dangerous zeroth-order terms in the bulk into derivative
bulk terms that we can control using
proposition
4.13
. To prove the estimate
for
N\geq 1
, we argue as in the proof of
proposition
4.15
to commute with
(rL)
.
Proposition 4.16
(
r
-weighted energy estimate for a
T
-derivative; radially symmetric case)
.
Suppose
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
is radially symmetric. Then for
0\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
,
v\geq 0
,
N\geq 0
, and
\delta{}>0
sufficiently small, we have
(4.63)
\begin{split}&\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[T\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{n}T\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[T\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+E_{N}[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[\Psi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{1+\delta{},N}[\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)+\mathcal{A}_{3+\delta{},N}[T\Box{}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)\\
&\qquad+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{2}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{n}T\Psi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{},\end{split}
where
\tilde{F}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}GZ\Box{}\varphi{}
is the inhomogeneity in the equation
satisfied by
\Psi{}
(see
eq.
2.26
) and the inhomogeneous norms
\mathcal{A}
and
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}
were defined in
section
2.7.3
.
Proof.
Apply
eq.
4.54
with
T\varphi{}
in place of
\varphi{}
to obtain
(4.64)
\begin{split}&\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[T\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle{}^{\delta}{}(LT\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[T\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1+\delta{}}(T\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}-\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}\lvert LT\psi{}\rvert\lvert r^{1/2}T\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\end{split}
After estimating
\lvert LT\psi{}\rvert\lesssim r^{1/2}\lvert LT\varphi{}\rvert+r^{-1/2}\lvert T\varphi{}\rvert
and applying (an
r
-weighted)
Young’s inequality, we obtain
(4.65)
\begin{split}&\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[T\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(LT\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[T\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1+\delta{}}(T\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{1+\delta{}}\lvert r\Box{}T\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
Control the bulk term associated to
T\varphi{}
on the right-hand side of
eq.
4.65
using
proposition
4.13
to obtain
eq.
4.63
when
N=0
. The case
N\geq 1
follows as in the
proof of
proposition
4.13
.
∎
4.2.3.
An integrated estimate for the
T
-energy
We now use the energy estimates of
sections
4.2.1
and
4.2.2
to estimate the integral of the
higher-order
T
-energy, in preparation for an argument that establishes
energy decay using the pigeonhole principle (see
section
5
).
Proposition 4.17
(Integrated estimate for the higher-order
T
-energy; radially symmetric case)
.
Suppose
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
is radially symmetric. Then for
0\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
,
v\geq 0
,
N\geq 1
, and
\delta{}>0
sufficiently small, we have
(4.66)
\begin{split}&\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}E_{N}[\varphi{}](\tau{},v)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}E_{N}[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\mathcal{E}_{1,N-1}[(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[\Psi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{1,N}[\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)+\mathcal{A}_{3,N}[T\Box{}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)\\
&\qquad+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle{}(L(rL)^{n}\Psi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{},\end{split}
where
\tilde{F}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}GZ\Box{}\varphi{}
is the inhomogeneity in the equation
satisfied by
\Psi{}
(see
eq.
2.26
), the inhomogeneous norms
\mathcal{A}
and
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}
were defined in
section
2.7.3
, and
\eta_{h}
is a parameter associated to the
hyperboloidal foliation (see
section
2.3
).
Proof.
First, use
h(r)\lesssim\langle{}r\rangle^{-1-\eta_{h}}
, and then use
proposition
4.15
applied to
\varphi{}
and
eq.
4.30
(where
\eta_{h}
takes the
role of
\delta{}
) applied to
(rL)^{n}\varphi{}
for
0\leq n\leq N
in place of
\varphi{}
to obtain
(4.67)
\begin{split}&\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}E_{N}[\varphi{}](\tau{},v)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r(L(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{-1-\eta{}_{h}}r(\underline{L}(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r(L(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}+\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\lvert T(rL)^{n}\varphi{}\rvert\lvert r\Box{}(rL)^{n}\varphi{}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
We now control the final bulk term on the right-hand side of
eq.
4.67
. Now use an
r
-weighted Young’s inequality and then use
eq.
4.37
to estimate
(4.68)
\begin{split}&\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\lvert T(rL)^{n}\varphi{}\rvert\lvert r\Box{}(rL)^{n}\varphi{}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1+\delta{}}(T(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{1-\delta{}}\lvert r\Box{}(rL)^{n}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r(L(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{-1+\delta{}}[(L(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}+(\underline{L}(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}]\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\int_{\tau_{1}}^{\tau_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{1-\delta{}}(L(rL)^{n}\Psi{})^{2}+r\langle{}r\rangle^{-3-\delta{}}((rL)^{n}\Psi{})^{2}+r^{2}\langle{}r\rangle^{1-\delta{}}\lvert(rL)^{n}\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
To complete the proof, substitute
eq.
4.68
into
eq.
4.67
and use
propositions
4.13
,
4.15
, and
4.16
to
control the terms on the right.
∎
5.
Energy decay and improved energy decay for time derivatives
The goal of this section is to show that energies
associated to time derivatives decay faster in time. In
section
6
,
we will show that a suitably renormalized version of
\varphi{}
(namely
\widehat{\varphi{}}=\varphi{}-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
) can be written as a time
derivative. In this way we will obtain improved decay for
\varphi{}
itself.
In
section
5.1
, we prove an abstract interpolation lemma (a
version of
[
Gaj23
, Prop. 8.2]
). We then use this lemma to prove
improved decay for time derivatives of good scalar fields in
section
5.2
and for time derivatives of radially symmetric scalar
fields in
section
5.3
.
5.1.
An abstract interpolation lemma
We formulate an abstract version of the interpolation argument used in
[
Gaj23
, Prop. 8.2]
.
Lemma 5.1
(Abstract interpolation lemma)
.
Let
\alpha{},\beta{},\delta{},D\geq 0
, and let
f:[0,\infty)\to\mathbf{R}_{\geq 0}
be an integrable function satisfying the following assumptions:
(5.1)
\displaystyle f(0)
\displaystyle\lesssim D,
(5.2)
\displaystyle f(\tau{}^{\prime})
\displaystyle\lesssim f(\tau{})+(1+\tau{})^{-\beta{}}D\quad\textnormal{for }\tau{}^{\prime}\geq\tau{}\geq 0,
(5.3)
\displaystyle\int_{\tau{}}^{\infty}f(\tau{}^{\prime})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}^{\prime}
\displaystyle\lesssim R^{-\alpha{}}(1+\tau{})^{\delta}{}D+R(f(\tau{})+(1+\tau{})^{-\beta{}}D)\quad\textnormal{for }1\leq R\leq\tau{}.
Then for
\tau{}\geq 0
and
\eta{}>0
, we have
(5.4)
f(\tau{})\lesssim_{\alpha{},\beta{},\eta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-\min(\beta{},\alpha{}+1)+\delta{}+\eta{}}D.
Remark 5.2
.
In
sections
5.2
and
5.3
, we will apply
eq.
5.4
when
f(\tau{})
is an energy defined on
\Sigma{}(\tau{})
,
D
is an initial data norm,
eq.
5.1
is the boundedness of initial
data,
eq.
5.2
is an energy estimate, and
eq.
5.3
is an
integrated energy estimate obtained by splitting the spatial integral defining
the energy
f(\tau{})
into the regions
\{r\leq R\}
and
\{r\geq R\}
.
Proof.
By
eq.
5.2
and
eq.
5.1
, we have
(5.5)
f(\tau{})\lesssim f(0)+D\lesssim D\quad\textnormal{for }\tau{}\geq 0,
and so it suffices to prove
eq.
5.4
for
\tau{}\geq 1
.
Step 1: The iteration argument.
Suppose we
have shown that
(5.6)
f(\tau{})\lesssim\tau^{-\gamma{}+\delta{}}D\quad\textnormal{for }\tau{}\geq 1
for some
0\leq\gamma{}\leq\min(\beta{},\alpha{}+1)
. We will show that
eq.
5.6
holds with
\min(1+(1-\frac{1}{\alpha{}+1})\gamma{},\beta{})
in place of
\gamma{}
(with an implicit constant that is larger by a factor independent of
\gamma{}
). Note that the case
\gamma{}=0
of
eq.
5.6
follows
from
eq.
5.5
.
Let
\tau_{i}=2^{i}
be a dyadic sequence. Combine
eq.
5.6
with
eq.
5.3
to obtain
(5.7)
\int_{\tau_{i}}^{\tau_{i+1}}f(\tau{})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim R^{-\alpha{}}\tau_{i}^{\delta}{}D+R\tau_{i}^{-\gamma{}}D\quad\textnormal{for }1\leq R\leq\tau{}_{i}.
Since
\gamma{}\leq\alpha{}+1
, we can take
R=\tau_{i}^{\gamma{}/(\alpha{}+1)}
in
eq.
5.7
to obtain
(5.8)
\int_{\tau_{i}}^{\tau_{i+1}}f(\tau{})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim\tau{}_{i}^{-\gamma{}\alpha{}/(\alpha{}+1)+\delta{}}D.
By the pigeonhole principle, there is
\tau_{i}^{\prime}\in[\tau_{i},\tau_{i+1}]
such that
(5.9)
f(\tau{}_{i}^{\prime})\lesssim\tau{}_{i}^{-1-\gamma{}\alpha{}/(\alpha{}+1)+\delta{}}D.
By
eq.
5.2
and the dyadicity of the
\tau_{i}
, and hence of the
\tau_{i}^{\prime}
,
we can extend the estimate
eq.
5.9
to
(5.10)
f(\tau{})\lesssim\tau{}^{-\min(1+\gamma{}\alpha{}/(\alpha{}+1),\beta{})+\delta{}}D\quad\textnormal{for }\tau{}\geq 1,
as desired.
Step 2: Completing the proof.
Define a sequence
\gamma_{n}
for
n\geq 0
by
(5.11)
\gamma{}_{0}=0,\qquad\gamma{}_{n+1}=\min\Bigl(1+\Bigl(1-\frac{1}{\alpha{}+1}\Bigr)\gamma{}_{n},\beta{}\Bigr).
If
\gamma_{n}\leq\alpha{}+1
, then so is
\gamma_{n+1}
(since
\gamma_{n+1}\leq 1+(1-1/(\alpha{}+1))\gamma_{n}
). Since
\gamma_{0}=0
, it follows that
\gamma_{n}\leq\min(\beta{},\alpha{}+1)
for all
n\geq 0
. In particular, Step 1 shows that
(5.12)
f(\tau{})\lesssim_{n}\tau^{-\gamma{}_{n}+\delta{}}D\quad\textnormal{for }\tau{}\geq 1.
If
\beta{}\geq\alpha{}+1
, then by induction we have
(5.13)
\gamma{}_{n+1}=1+\Bigl(1-\frac{1}{\alpha{}+1}\Bigr)\gamma{}_{n}\implies\gamma{}_{n+1}=\sum_{k=0}^{n}\Bigl(1-\frac{1}{\alpha{}+1}\Bigr)^{k}=\alpha{}+1-\alpha{}\Bigl(1-\frac{1}{\alpha{}+1}\Bigr)^{n}.
If
\beta{}<\alpha{}+1
, then we have
(5.14)
\gamma{}_{n+1}=\min\Bigl(\alpha{}+1-\alpha{}\Bigl(1-\frac{1}{\alpha{}+1}\Bigr)^{n},\beta{}\Bigr),
and there is some
N\geq 0
such that
\gamma_{n}=\beta{}
for
n\geq N
. In either case, we
establish
eq.
5.4
by taking
n
sufficiently large that
\alpha{}(1-1/(\alpha{}+1))^{n}\leq\eta{}
.
∎
5.2.
Energy decay for scalar fields that satisfy an equation with a good zeroth-order term
In this section, we closely follow
[
Gaj23
, Sec. 8]
to show that energies of time derivatives of good
scalar fields decay faster in time. We first show that we can express
T
-derivatives in terms of
(rL)
-derivatives and
\partial_{\theta}{}
-derivatives.
Lemma 5.3
.
If
\Phi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R}\setminus\{r=0\})
solves
eq.
4.2
with
inhomogeneity
F\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R}\setminus\{r=0\})
, then for
N\geq 0
and
M\geq 1
, we have
(5.15)
\begin{split}&L(rL)^{N}T^{M}\Phi{}\\
&=\sum_{n=0}^{N+M}\mathcal{O}(r^{-M})L(rL)^{n}\Phi{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{m=0}^{M-1}\sum_{n=0}^{N+M-m-1}\Bigl(\mathcal{O}(r^{-1-M+m})(rL)^{n}T^{m}\Phi{}+\mathcal{O}(r^{-1-M+m})\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}(rL)^{n}T^{m}\Phi{}+\mathcal{O}(r^{1-M+m})(rL)^{n}T^{m}F\Bigr),\end{split}
where the implied constants in the
\mathcal{O}
-notation depend on
N
,
M
, and the parameters of
eq.
4.2
.
Proof.
Use
2T=L+\underline{L}
to write
(5.16)
\begin{split}2L(rL)^{N}T\Phi{}&=LL(rL)^{N}\Phi{}+\underline{L}L(rL)^{N}\Phi{}=r^{-1}L(rL)^{N+1}\Phi{}-r^{-1}L(rL)^{N}\Phi{}+\underline{L}L(rL)^{N}\Phi{}.\end{split}
Rewrite the final term on the right using
lemma
4.7
to obtain
the
M=1
case of
eq.
5.15
:
(5.17)
\begin{split}L(rL)^{N}T\Phi{}&=\sum_{n=0}^{N+1}\mathcal{O}(r^{-1})L(rL)^{n}\Phi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\mathcal{O}(r^{-2})(rL)^{n}\Phi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\mathcal{O}(r^{-2})\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}(rL)^{n}\Phi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\mathcal{O}(1)(rL)^{n}F.\end{split}
To complete the proof, induct on
M
and use
eq.
5.17
in the
induction step.
∎
Proposition 5.4
(Energy decay and improved energy decay for time derivatives)
.
Let
\Phi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R}\setminus\{r=0\})
satisfy the assumptions of
eq.
4.16
. For
p\in[0,2-\eta{}_{0}]
(where
\eta_{0}
was fixed in
eq.
4.16
),
N\geq 0
,
M\geq 0
, and
v\geq 0
, define
(5.18)
\begin{split}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N,M}[\Phi{}](v)&\coloneqq{}\sum_{m=0}^{M}\Bigl(\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N+M-m}[T^{m}\Phi{}](0,v)+\sup_{\tau{}\geq 0}(1+\tau{})^{2m}\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{p+1,N+M-m}[T^{m}F](\tau{},\infty,v)\Bigr),\end{split}
where
F\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R}\setminus\{r=0\})
is the inhomogeneity in the equation
solved by
\Phi{}
(see
definition
4.1
) and the norm
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{p,N}[F](\tau{})
was defined in
section
2.7.3
. For
p\in[0,2-\eta{}_{0}]
,
N\geq 0
,
\tau{}\geq 0
, and
v\geq 0
, we have the energy boundedness
estimate
(5.19)
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[\Phi{}]\lesssim_{N,M,\eta{}_{0}}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N,M}[\Phi{}](v),
as well as the following improved energy decay estimates for time derivatives,
where
\eta{}>0
is arbitrary:
(5.20)
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[T^{M}\Phi{}](\tau{},v)\lesssim_{N,M,\eta{}_{0},\eta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-2M+\eta{}}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N,M}[\Phi{}](v)\qquad(M\geq 1).
Proof.
First,
eq.
5.19
follows from
eq.
4.16
, so we can consider
M\geq 1
. By
eq.
4.16
, it suffices to consider
\tau{}\geq 1
.
Let
1\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
and let
R\geq 1
. Split into the regions
\{r\leq R\}
and
\{r\geq R\}
and use
h(r)\lesssim\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1}
to obtain
(5.21)
\begin{split}&\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[T^{M}\Phi{}](\tau{},v)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&=\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{p}(L\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}T^{M}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}h(r)r^{p-2}[(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}T^{M}\Phi{})^{2}+(\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}T^{M}\Phi{})^{2}]\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim R\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)\cap\{r\leq R\}}r^{p-1}(L\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}T^{M}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+R^{-1}\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)\cap\{r\geq R\}}r^{p+1}(L\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}T^{M}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{p-3}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}T^{M}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{p-3}(\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}T^{M}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim R(\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[T^{M}\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tau{}_{1}^{-2M}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N,M}[\Phi{}](v))+R^{-1}\cdot\textnormal{(I)}_{R,N,M},\end{split}
where
(5.22)
\textnormal{(I)}_{R,N,M}\coloneqq{}\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)\cap\{r\geq R\}}r^{p+1}(L\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n_{2}}T^{M}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.
To pass to the last line in
eq.
5.21
, we used
eq.
4.16
and
the estimate
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{p,N}[T^{M}F](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)\leq\tau{}_{1}^{-2M}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N,M}[\Phi{}](v)
(which follows from the
definition of the norm
\tilde{\mathcal{D}}
). To control the term
\textnormal{(I)}_{R,N,M}
, use
lemma
5.3
to estimate
(5.23)
\begin{split}&\textnormal{(I)}_{R,N,M}\\
&\lesssim\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)\cap\{r\geq R\}}r^{-2(M-1)}\sum_{n=0}^{n_{2}+M}r^{p-1}(L\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\sum_{m=0}^{M-1}r^{-2(M-m-1)}\sum_{n=0}^{n_{2}+M-m-1}\\
&\qquad\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)\cap\{r\geq R\}}\bigl(r^{p-3}(\partial{}_{\theta}\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}+1}(rL)^{n}T^{m}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{p-3}(\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n}T^{m}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{p+1}(\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rL)^{n}T^{m}F)^{2}\bigr)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
Using the
r^{p}
-weighted energy estimate of
eq.
4.16
to estimate the
right-hand side of
eq.
5.23
, we obtain
(5.24)
\begin{split}\textnormal{(I)}_{R,N,M}&\lesssim R^{-2(M-1)}\sum_{m=0}^{M-1}R^{2m}(\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N+M-m}[T^{m}\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tau{}_{1}^{-2m}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N,M}[\Phi{}](v)).\end{split}
In particular, when
M=1
, we have
(5.25)
\textnormal{(I)}_{R,N,1}\lesssim\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N,1}[\Phi{}](v).
Substitute
eq.
5.25
into
eq.
5.21
to obtain
(5.26)
\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[T\Phi{}](\tau{},v)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim R^{-1}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N,1}[\Phi{}](v)+R(\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[T\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tau{}_{1}^{-2}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N,1}[\Phi{}](v)).
Since
\tau_{2}\geq\tau{}_{1}
is arbitrary,
eq.
5.20
for
M=1
now follows
from
eq.
5.4
(where the assumptions
eqs.
5.1
and
5.2
of
eq.
5.4
follow from
eq.
4.16
and
eq.
5.26
plays
the role of
eq.
5.3
).
Now suppose that
M>1
and that we have established
eq.
5.20
for
M-1
in place of
M
. Then, returning to
eq.
5.24
and using
eq.
4.16
and the induction hypothesis (applied to
T^{m}\Phi{}
for
0\leq m\leq M-1
), we conclude that for any
\eta{}>0
and
1\leq R\leq\tau{}_{1}
, we have
(5.27)
\begin{split}\textnormal{(I)}_{R,N,M}\lesssim_{\eta}{}R^{-2(M-1)}\tau{}_{1}^{\eta}{}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N,M}[\Phi{}](v),\end{split}
where we have used the fact that (for
N\geq 0
,
M\geq 1
and
v\geq 0
)
(5.28)
\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N+1,M-1}[\Phi{}](v)\leq\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N,M}[\Phi{}](v).
Substitute
eq.
5.27
into
eq.
5.21
to
get
(5.29)
\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[T^{M}\Phi{}](\tau{},v)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim R^{-2M+1}\tau{}_{1}^{\eta}{}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N,M}[\Phi{}](v)+R(\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{p,N}[T^{M}\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tau{}_{1}^{-2M}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{p,N,M}[\Phi{}](v)).
for
1\leq R\leq\tau{}_{1}
. Now
eq.
5.20
follows from
eqs.
5.4
and
5.29
as in
the case
M=1
.
∎
5.3.
Energy decay for radially symmetric scalar fields
In this section, we partially extend the
results of
section
5.2
to radially symmetric scalar fields. We
first show that we can express
T
-derivatives of a radially symmetric scalar
field
\varphi{}
in terms of
(rL)
-derivatives of
\varphi{}
and of the
quantity
\Psi{}
.
Lemma 5.5
.
Suppose
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
. Then for
N\geq 0
and
M\geq 1
, we have
(5.30)
\begin{split}L(r^{1/2}(rL)^{N}T^{M}\varphi{})&=\mathcal{O}(r^{-M+1})\sum_{n=0}^{N+M}\mathcal{O}(r^{-1/2})L(rL)^{n}\varphi{}\\
&\qquad+\mathcal{O}(r^{-M+1})\sum_{m=0}^{M-1}\mathcal{O}(r^{m+1})\sum_{n=0}^{N+M-m-1}\bigl(\mathcal{O}(r^{-2})T^{m}\Psi{}+\mathcal{O}(r^{-1})L(rL)^{n}T^{m}\Psi{}\bigr).\end{split}
Proof.
The case
N=0
and
M=1
follows from the computation
(5.31)
LT\psi{}=L(r^{1/2}T\varphi{})=L(r^{1/2}L\varphi{})-L(r^{1/2}GZ\varphi{})=r^{-1/2}L(rL)\varphi{}-\frac{1}{2}r^{-1/2}GL\varphi{}-L\Psi{}.
Apply
eq.
5.31
to
(rL)^{N}\varphi{}
in place of
\varphi{}
and use
eq.
4.36
to conclude the case
M=1
:
(5.32)
\begin{split}L(r^{1/2}(rL)^{N}T\varphi{})&=r^{-1/2}L(rL)^{N+1}\varphi{}-\frac{1}{2}r^{-1/2}GL(rL)^{N}\varphi{}-L(r^{1/2}GZ(rL)^{N})\varphi{}\\
&=\sum_{n=0}^{N+1}\mathcal{O}(r^{-1/2})L(rL)^{n}\varphi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\mathcal{O}(1)L(rL)^{n}\Psi{}.\end{split}
Multiply
eq.
5.32
by
r^{1/2}
and
rearrange terms to obtain
(5.33)
L(rL)^{N}T\varphi{}=\sum_{n=0}^{N+1}\mathcal{O}(r^{-1})L(rL)^{n}\varphi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\mathcal{O}(r^{-1/2})L(rL)^{n}\Psi{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\mathcal{O}(r^{-3/2})(rL)^{n}\Psi{}.
The general formula
eq.
5.30
follows
by induction on
M
, where in the inductive step one uses
eqs.
5.32
and
5.33
applied to
T^{M-1}\varphi{}
in place of
\varphi{}
.
∎
Proposition 5.6
(Energy decay and improved energy decay for time derivatives; radially symmetric case)
.
Suppose
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
is radially symmetric. Suppose moreover that there
exists a function
\Phi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R}\setminus\{r=0\})
such that
(i)
T\Phi{}=\Psi{}=r^{1/2}GZ\varphi{}
,
(ii)
and
\Phi{}
satisfies the assumptions of
definition
4.1
with inhomogeneity
\tilde{F}
.
For
N\geq 1
,
M\geq 0
,
\delta{}\geq 0
, and
v\geq 0
, define the initial data norm
(5.34)
\begin{split}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)&\coloneqq{}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{1+\delta{},N,M+1}[\Phi{}](v)+\sum_{m=0}^{M}\bigl(E_{N+M-m}[T^{m}\varphi{}](0,v)+\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N+M-m}[T^{m}\varphi{}](0,v)\bigr)\\
&\qquad+\sum_{m=0}^{M}\bigl(\sup_{\tau{}\geq 0}(1+\tau{})^{2m+2}\mathcal{A}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{m}\Box{}\varphi{}](\tau{},\infty,v)+\sup_{\tau{}\geq 0}(1+\tau{})^{2m}\mathcal{A}_{3+\delta{},N}[T^{m}\Box{}\varphi{}](\tau{},\infty,v)\bigr),\\
\end{split}
where the data norm
\tilde{\mathcal{D}}
was defined in
eq.
5.20
and
the norm
\mathcal{A}
of the inhomogeneity was defined in
section
2.7.3
.
Then for all
N\geq 1
,
\tau{}\geq 0
, and
v\geq 0
, and
\delta{}>0
sufficiently small
(that the estimates of
section
4.2.2
hold),
we have the energy boundedness and decay estimates
(5.35)
\displaystyle E_{N}[\varphi{}](\tau{},v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-1}\mathcal{D}_{N,0,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v),
(5.36)
\displaystyle\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N-1}[(rL)\varphi{}](\tau{},v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,0,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v),
as well as the following improved energy decay estimates for time derivatives,
where
M\geq 1
and
\eta{}>0
:
(5.37)
\displaystyle E_{N}[T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{},v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{},\eta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-1-2M+\delta{}+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v),
(5.38)
\displaystyle\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta,N-1}[(rL)T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{},v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{},\eta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-2M+\delta{}+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v),
(5.39)
\displaystyle\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta,N}[T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{},v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{},\eta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-2M+1+\delta{}+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v).
Remark 5.7
(Sharpness of the decay rates)
.
Note that, although we do not obtain the sharp decay rate (on Minkowski or given
by
theorem
3.1
) for
\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[T\varphi{}]
(namely
\tau^{-2}
), we still obtain the sharp rate
\tau^{-3}
for
E_{N}[T\varphi{}]
. This is crucial for the sharp energy decay and pointwise
estimates proven in
section
7
.
Proof.
Fix
v\geq 0
and
\delta{}>0
sufficiently small, and let
\eta{}>0
.
Step 1: Preliminary estimates.
Let
0\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
. First, we claim that
(5.40)
\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{2}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{n}T^{M}\Psi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim_{\eta}{}(1+\tau{}_{1})^{-2M+\eta{}}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{1+\delta{},N,M+1}[\Phi{}](v).
when
N\geq 1
and
M\geq 0
.
We delay the proof to the end of this step. We now note several consequences of
eq.
5.40
and the energy-estimates of
section
4.2
. We have:
(5.41)
\begin{split}&E_{N}[T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{-1+\delta{}}(T(rL)^{n}T^{M}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{\eta}{}E_{N}[T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+(1+\tau{}_{1})^{-2M-2+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)\end{split}
when
N\geq 0
and
M\geq 0
, and
(5.42)
\begin{split}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}E_{N}[T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim_{\eta}{}E_{N}[T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\mathcal{E}_{1,N-1}[(rL)T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+(1+\tau{}_{1})^{-2M+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)\end{split}
when
N\geq 1
and
M\geq 0
, and
(5.43)
\begin{split}&\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\sum_{n=0}^{N+1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{n}T^{M}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{\eta}{}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+(1+\tau{}_{1})^{-2M+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N+1,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)\end{split}
when
N\geq 0
and
M\geq 0
, and
(5.44)
\begin{split}&\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{n}T^{M}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{\eta}{}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+E_{N}[T^{M-1}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+(1+\tau{}_{1})^{-2M+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)\end{split}
when
N\geq 0
and
M\geq 1
.
Indeed,
eqs.
5.41
,
5.42
,
5.43
, and
5.44
follow immediately from
propositions
4.13
,
4.17
,
4.15
, and
4.16
combined with
eq.
5.20
once
eq.
5.40
has been established.
We now establish
eq.
5.40
. Use
lemma
5.3
(applied to
T^{M}\Phi{}
),
eq.
4.16
(applied to
T^{M}\Phi{}
with
p=1+\delta{}
), and
eq.
5.20
:
(5.45)
\begin{split}&\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{2}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{n}T^{M}\Psi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}=\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r^{2}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{n}TT^{M}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{\delta{}}(L(rL)^{n}T^{M}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{-2}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}((rL)^{n}T^{M}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{2}\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}((rL)^{n}T^{M}\tilde{F})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{0,N}[T^{M}\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{M}\Phi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{2+\delta{},N}[T^{M}\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1},\tau{}_{2},v)\\
&\lesssim_{\eta}{}(1+\tau{}_{1})^{-2M+\eta{}}\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{1+\delta{},N,M}[\Phi{}](v).\end{split}
Step 2: Decay for the
T
-energy from decay for the
r
-weighted energy;
proof of
eq.
5.37
from
eq.
5.38
.
The point of this step is that the
integral of
E_{N}[T^{M}\varphi{}]
is controlled by
\mathcal{E}_{1,N-1}[(rL)T^{M}\varphi{}]
(see
eq.
5.42
), and so a pigeonhole argument can
obtain a decay rate
\tau^{-1}
faster for the former than for the latter.
Let
N\geq 1
and
M\geq 0
. In this step we will show that for
M\geq 0
,
the statement
(5.46)
\mathcal{E}_{1,N-1}[(rL)T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{},v)\lesssim(1+\tau{})^{-\beta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)\textnormal{ for all }\tau{}\geq 0
for some
\beta{}\leq 2M
implies the statement
(5.47)
E_{N}[T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{},v)\lesssim_{\eta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-1-\beta{}+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)\textnormal{ for all }\tau{}\geq 0.
In particular,
eq.
5.37
follows from
eq.
5.38
.
First,
eq.
5.41
implies that it suffices to
consider
\tau{}\geq 1
. Now suppose we have shown that for some
k\geq 0
and all
\tau{}\geq 1
, we have
(5.48)
E_{N}[T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{},v)\leq\tau{}^{-k}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v).
By
eq.
5.41
, the estimate
eq.
5.48
holds for
k=0
. Let
\tau_{i}=2^{i}
be a dyadic sequence. By
eq.
5.46
and
eq.
5.48
together with
eq.
5.42
, we have
(5.49)
\int_{\tau{}_{i}}^{\tau{}_{i+1}}E_{N}[T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{},v)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim_{\eta}{}\tau{}_{i}^{-\min(k,\beta{})+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v).
By the pigeonhole principle, there is
\tau{}_{i}^{\prime}\in[\tau{}_{i},\tau{}_{i+1}]
for which
(5.50)
E_{N}[T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{i}^{\prime},v)\lesssim_{\eta}{}\tau{}_{i}^{\prime-1-\min(k,\beta{})+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v).
By
eq.
5.42
,
eq.
5.46
, and the dyadicity of the
\tau_{i}
(and hence of the
\tau{}_{i}^{\prime}
), we
can extend this to
(5.51)
E_{N}[T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{},v)\lesssim_{\eta}{}\tau{}^{-1-\min(k,\beta{})+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)
for all
\tau{}\geq 1
. If
k+1\leq\beta{}
, then this implies
eq.
5.48
for
k+1-\eta{}
in
place of
k
. We can repeat this argument until
k\geq\beta{}
, in which
case
eq.
5.51
implies the desired
eq.
5.47
(with
2M\eta{}
in place of
\eta{}
).
Step 3: The interpolation argument.
Fix
j\in\{0,1\}
and
N\geq 0
such that
N+j\geq 1
, fix
M\geq 1
, and fix
1\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
. Let
1\leq R\leq\tau{}_{i}
. The
goal of this step is to show that
(5.52)
\begin{split}&\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)^{j}T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{},v)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{\eta}{}R^{-2M+1+\delta{}}\tau{}_{1}^{\eta}{}\mathcal{D}_{N+j,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)\\
&\qquad+R(\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)^{j}T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+(1-j)E_{N+j}[T^{M-1}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tau{}_{1}^{-2M+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N+j,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)).\end{split}
To produce this estimate, we will expand the integral and interpolate between
(i.e. split the region of integration into) a large-
r
region (which produces
the term on the first line) and a small-
r
region (which produces the terms
on the last line).
Split into the regions
\{r\leq R\}
and
\{r\geq R\}
and use
h(r)\lesssim\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1}
to obtain
(5.53)
\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)^{j}T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{},v)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim\textnormal{(I)}_{N,j,M,R}+R^{-1+\delta{}}\textnormal{(II)}_{N,j,M,R}
for
(5.54)
\begin{split}\textnormal{(I)}_{N,j,M,R}&\coloneqq{}\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\mathbf{1}_{r\leq R}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(r^{1/2}(rL)^{n+j}T^{M}\varphi{}))^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1+\delta{}}((rL)^{n+j}T^{M}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
\end{split}
and
(5.55)
\textnormal{(II)}_{N,j,M,R}\coloneqq{}\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)\cap\{r\geq R\}}r^{2}(L(r^{1/2}(rL)^{n+j}T^{M}\varphi{}))^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
We now control the terms on the right-hand side of
eq.
5.53
. By estimating
(L(r^{1/2}f))^{2}\lesssim r(Lf)^{2}+r^{-1}f^{2}
and using the fact that the
first term in
\textnormal{(I)}_{N,j,M,R}
is only integrated over
\{r\leq R\}
(and
R\geq 1
), we obtain
(5.56)
\begin{split}\textnormal{(I)}_{N,j,M,R}\lesssim R\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(rL)^{n+j}T^{M}\varphi{})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{-1+\delta{}}((rL)^{n+j}T^{M}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
When
j=0
, we have
N\geq 1
, and so we can estimate the first term on the
left-hand side of
eq.
5.56
using
eq.
5.43
(with
N-1
in place of
N
),
and since
M\geq 1
, we can estimate the second term on the left-hand side of
eq.
5.56
by writing
(rL)^{n+j}T^{M}\varphi{}=T(rL)^{n}T^{M-1}\varphi{}
and using
eq.
5.41
(with
M-1
in place of
M
):
(5.57)
\begin{split}\textnormal{(I)}_{N,0,M,R}&\lesssim_{\eta}{}R(\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N-1}[(rL)T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+E_{N}[T^{M-1}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tau{}_{1}^{-2M+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)).\\
\end{split}
When
j=1
, we estimate the the first term on the left-hand side of
eq.
5.56
using
eq.
5.43
, and we estimate the second term on the left-hand side of
eq.
5.56
by writing
((rL)^{n+j}T^{M}\varphi{})^{2}=r^{2}(L(rL)^{n}T^{M}\varphi{})^{2}
and using
eq.
5.43
:
(5.58)
\textnormal{(I)}_{N,1,M,R}\lesssim_{\eta}{}R(\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tau{}_{1}^{-2M+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)).
Combining
eqs.
5.57
and
5.58
, we obtain
(5.59)
\textnormal{(I)}_{N,1,M,R}\lesssim_{\eta}{}R(\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)^{j}T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+(1-j)E_{N+j}[T^{M-1}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tau{}_{1}^{-2M+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)).
Next, we estimate
\textnormal{(II)}_{N,j,M,R}
: the calculation in
eq.
5.30
, together with the fact that the
integral is over
\{r\geq R\}
, implies that for
R\leq\tau_{1}
, we have
(5.60)
\begin{split}\textnormal{(II)}_{N,j,M,R}&\lesssim R^{-2M+2}\Bigl[\sum_{n=0}^{N+M+j}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r(L(rL)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{m=0}^{M-1}R^{2m+2}\sum_{n=0}^{N+M+j-m-1}\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}(L(rL)^{n}T^{m+1}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{-2}(T^{m+1}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\Bigr]\\
&\lesssim R^{-2M+2}\Bigl[\mathcal{E}_{1,N+M+j-1}[(rL)\varphi{}](0,v)+\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{1,N+j,M+1}[\Phi{}](v)\\
&\qquad+\sum_{m=0}^{M-1}R^{2m+2}(\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1,N+j+M-m-1}[T^{m+1}\Phi{}]+\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{1,N+j+M-m-1}[T^{m+1}\tilde{F}](\tau{}_{1}))\Bigr]\\
&\lesssim_{\eta}{}R^{-2M+2}\tau{}_{1}^{\eta}{}\mathcal{D}_{N+j,M,0}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v).\end{split}
To pass to the second last line, we applied
proposition
4.15
(with
N+M+j-1
in place of
N
), estimating the terms that arise on the right-hand side using
eqs.
5.40
and
5.20
, and applied
eq.
4.16
(in which the norm
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}
was defined). To pass to the last line, we used
eq.
5.20
.
Combining
eqs.
5.59
,
5.60
, and
5.53
, we obtain
eq.
5.52
.
Step 4: The iteration argument: proof of
eqs.
5.39
and
5.38
.
By
Steps 1 and 2, it suffices to prove the estimates
eqs.
5.39
and
5.38
for
\tau{}\geq 1
. First, note that
eq.
5.38
holds for
M=0
by
eq.
5.43
. Now suppose that
M\geq 1
and we have established
eq.
5.38
for
M-1
. By Step 2,
for
\tau{}\geq 0
and
N\geq 0
we have
(5.61)
\begin{split}E_{N+1}[T^{M-1}\varphi{}](\tau{},v)&\lesssim_{\eta}{}(1+\tau{})^{-2M+1+\delta{}+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N+1,M-1,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)\lesssim(1+\tau{})^{-2M+1+\delta{}+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v).\end{split}
Now let
j\in\{0,1\}
and let
N\geq 0
satisfy
N+j\geq 1
. By Step 3 and
eq.
5.61
, we
have
(5.62)
\begin{split}&\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)^{j}T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{},v)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\\
&\lesssim_{\eta}{}R^{-2M+1+\delta{}}\tau{}_{1}^{\eta}{}\mathcal{D}_{N+j,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)+R(\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)^{j}T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\tau{}_{1}^{-2M+(1-j)+\delta{}+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N+j,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v)).\end{split}
By
eqs.
5.43
and
5.44
, we have
(5.63)
\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)^{j}T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)\lesssim_{\eta}{}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)^{j}T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+(1+\tau{}_{1})^{-2M+(1-j)+\delta{}+\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N+j,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v).
It now follows from
eqs.
5.4
,
5.62
, and
5.63
that
(5.64)
\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[(rL)^{j}T^{M}\varphi{}](\tau{},v)\lesssim_{\eta}{}(1+\tau{})^{-2M+(1-j)+\delta{}+2\eta{}}\mathcal{D}_{N+j,M,\delta{}}[\varphi{},\Phi{}](v),
which establishes
eqs.
5.39
and
5.38
(with
2\eta{}
in place of
\eta{}
).
∎
6.
Constructing time integrals
In view of the results of
section
5
, we would like to show that the
difference of
\varphi{}
and a suitable multiple of the claimed leading-order
profile can be written as a time derivative of a solution to
eq.
2.19
,
so that said difference decays faster than the leading-order profile itself.
That is, we aim to construct a “time integral” of a suitably renormalized
solution
\widehat{\varphi{}}
(see
section
6.1.1
). Recall from
eq.
2.26
that
(6.1)
\mathcal{L}(G^{1/2}\psi{})=\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}T\psi{}]+G^{-3/2}r^{1/2}\Box{}\varphi{},
where the operators
\mathcal{L}
and
\mathcal{F}
were defined in
eqs.
2.24
and
2.25
. We can therefore hope to construct a “time integral” of
the renormalized solution
\widehat{\varphi{}}
by constructing a solution
\zeta{}
to
the equation
\mathcal{L}\zeta{}=\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}\widehat{\psi{}}]|_{\Sigma{}_{0}}
on
\Sigma_{0}
and then
solving
eq.
2.19
with initial data
(r^{-1/2}G^{-1/2}\zeta{},\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{\Sigma{}_{0}})
.
In
section
6.1
, we introduce the Minkowskian solution
\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
and the renormalized solution
\widehat{\varphi{}}
. In
section
6.2
, we invert an elliptic operator to construct
functions which we use in
section
6.3
as initial data for wave
equations to construct time integrals.
6.1.
The Minkowskian solution and the renormalized solution
Define the Minkowskian solution
(6.2)
\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}\coloneqq{}u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2}=4(t^{2}-\tilde{G}(r)^{2})^{-1/2}.
Then
\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
is radially symmetric. An explicit computation
shows that on Minkowski space (where
\tilde{G}(r)\equiv r
), we have
\Box{}_{m}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}=0
, where
\Box_{m}
is the wave operator on Minkowski space of
(2+1)
dimensions.
6.1.1.
The renormalized solution
Let
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
. We recall from
eq.
2.36
the linear functional
\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]
of the (radially
symmetric part of the) initial data
(\varphi{}|_{\Sigma{}(0)},T\varphi{}|_{\Sigma{}(0)})
:
\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]\coloneqq{}\Bigl(\int_{0}^{\infty}r^{1/2}G^{1/2}\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}\psi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}]|_{\Sigma{}(0)}+rG^{-1}T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\Bigr)^{-1}\int_{0}^{\infty}r^{1/2}G^{1/2}\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}\psi{}_{0}](r)|_{\Sigma{}(0)}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r.
Here the linear operator
\mathcal{F}
was defined in
eq.
2.25
. When
\varphi{}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}
has sufficient decay
towards infinity, the final integral defining
\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]
converges. The quantity
T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
is defined
in
eq.
6.10
, and the well-definedness of the quantity
\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]
(in particular the non-vanishing of the factor
involving
\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
that is inverted) is established in
lemma
6.6
.
Definition 6.1
(The renormalized solution)
.
Given
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
, we define the renormalized quantity
(6.3)
\widehat{\varphi{}}\coloneqq{}\varphi{}-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}.
We write
(6.4)
\widehat{\psi{}}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}\widehat{\varphi{}},\qquad\widehat{\Psi{}}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}GZ\widehat{\varphi{}}.
Clearly, we have
(6.5)
\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}=\varphi_{0}-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}_{0}]\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}},\qquad\widehat{\varphi{}}_{\geq 1}=\varphi_{\geq 1},\qquad\Box{}\varphi{}=0\implies\Box{}\widehat{\varphi{}}=-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}.
6.1.2.
Estimates for the Minkowskian solution
In this section, we construct and estimate the
second time integral
T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
of the
inhomogeneity associated to
\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
. In particular, we
show that the quantity
\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]
defined in
eq.
2.36
is
well-defined (see
lemma
6.6
).
Lemma 6.2
(Estimating
\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
and
\Psi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
)
.
We have
(6.6)
\lvert(rL)^{N}T^{M}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}\rvert\lesssim_{N,M}u^{-1/2-M}v^{-1/2}
and
(6.7)
\lvert(rL)^{N}T^{M}\Psi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}\rvert\lesssim_{N,M}r^{3/2}u^{-3/2-M}v^{-3/2}.
Proof.
This is a straightforward calculation.
∎
Proposition 6.3
(Time integrals of inhomogneities associated to
\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
)
.
There exists a radially symmetric function
T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
such
that
T^{2}T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}=\Box{}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
. Moreover, the following estimates hold for
N\geq 0
and
M\geq 0
:
(6.8)
\displaystyle\lvert(rL)^{N}T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}\rvert
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1}(\tau{}+r)^{-1}
(6.9)
\displaystyle\lvert(rL)^{N}T^{M}T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}\rvert
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1}(1+\tau{})^{-1/2-M}(1+\tau{}+r)^{-3/2}.
Similarly, the quantity
\tilde{F}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}GZT^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
is radially symmetric, satisfies
r^{-3/2}\tilde{F}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
, and
satisfies the following estimates for
N\geq 0
and
M\geq 0
:
(6.10)
\lvert(rL)^{N}T^{M}\tilde{F}\rvert\lesssim_{N,M}\langle{}r\rangle^{-3/2}\tau{}^{-M}(\tau{}+r)^{-1}.
Remark 6.4
.
We write
T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}\coloneqq{}TT^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
.
Proof.
Define
(6.11)
T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}\coloneqq{}\frac{2}{\tilde{G}(r)^{2}}\Bigl(1-\frac{\tilde{G}(r)}{r}G(r)\Bigr)(t-(t^{2}-\tilde{G}(r)^{2})^{1/2}).
Using
eqs.
2.20
and
2.4
, we compute
(6.12)
\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}=\frac{1}{4}(1-(v-u)r^{-1}G)u^{-3/2}v^{-3/2}=\frac{1}{4}\Bigl(1-\frac{\tilde{G}(r)}{r}G(r)\Bigr)u^{-3/2}v^{-3/2}=2\Bigl(1-\frac{\tilde{G}(r)}{r}G(r)\Bigr)\frac{1}{(t^{2}-\tilde{G}(r)^{2})^{3/2}}.
A computation now verifies that
T^{2}T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}=TT^{-1}\Box{}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}=\Box{}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
.
The smoothness and radial symmetry of
G
(and
lemma
2.3
) imply
(6.13)
\frac{1}{\tilde{G}(r)^{2}}\Bigl(1-\frac{\tilde{G}(r)}{r}G(r)\Bigr)=\mathcal{O}(\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-3}).
Similar considerations show that
T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}\in r^{2}C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
. One obtains
eq.
6.8
by considering
separately the regions
\{r\leq u/2\}
and
\{r\geq u/2\}
. For example,
when
N=M=0
, we use the binomial expansion in
\{r\leq u/2\}
and a
trivial estimate in
\{r\geq u/2\}
to obtain
(6.14)
t(1-(1-\tilde{G}(r)^{2}/t^{2})^{1/2})\lesssim\begin{cases}r^{2}/t\sim r^{2}/v&\textnormal{in }\{r\leq u/2\}\\
t\sim r\sim r^{2}/v&\textnormal{in }\{r\geq u/2\}\\
\end{cases}\implies\lvert T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}\rvert\lesssim r^{2}\langle{}r\rangle^{-3}v^{-1},
and this estimate persists under differentiation by
(rL)
and
T
. Note
that
u\sim 1+\tau{}
and
v\sim 1+\tau{}+r
.
The smoothness of
r^{-3/2}\tilde{F}
and the estimates in
eq.
6.10
follow
from using
GZ=L-T
and
lemma
2.3
and the estimates for
T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
.
∎
Corollary 6.5
(Estimates for inhomogeneous norms associated to time integrals of
\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
)
.
Let
F\coloneqq{}T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
. For
N\geq 0
,
M\geq 0
,
\tau{}\geq 0
,
v\geq 0
, and
\eta{}>0
, we have
(6.15)
\displaystyle\mathcal{A}_{1,N}[T^{M}F](\tau{},\infty,v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\eta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-3-2M+\eta{}},
(6.16)
\displaystyle\mathcal{A}_{2-\eta{},N}[T^{M}F](\tau{},\infty,v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\eta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-2-2M},
(6.17)
\displaystyle\mathcal{A}_{4-\eta{},N}[T^{M}F](\tau{},\infty,v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\eta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-2M},
where the norm
\mathcal{A}
was defined in
section
2.7.3
.
Let
\tilde{F}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}GZT^{-2}\Box{}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
be as in
eq.
6.10
. For
p\in[0,2-\eta_{0}]
,
N\geq 0
,
M\geq 0
,
\tau{}\geq 0
, and
v\geq 0
,
(6.18)
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}_{p,N}[T^{M}\tilde{F}](\tau{},\infty,v)\lesssim_{N,M,\eta{}_{0}}(1+\tau{})^{-2M},
where the norm
\tilde{\mathcal{A}}
was defined in
section
2.7.3
.
Proof.
This is an immediate consequence of
eq.
6.10
and the definitions of the
norms.
∎
Lemma 6.6
(Well-definedness of the quantity
\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]
)
.
Let
\eta_{h}>0
,
B_{h}>0
, and
\epsilon_{h}>0
be the constants defined in
item
(ii)
and
item
(iii)
of
section
2.3
,
respectively. If
\epsilon_{h}
is sufficiently small depending on
B_{h}
and
\eta_{h}
,
then
(6.19)
\int_{0}^{\infty}r^{1/2}G^{1/2}\mathcal{F}[\psi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}]|_{\Sigma{}(0)}+rG^{-1}T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\neq{}0,
where the operator
\mathcal{F}
was defined in
eq.
2.25
and
T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
was defined in
eq.
6.10
. In
particular, the linear functional
\mathfrak{L}
introduced in
eq.
2.36
is well-defined.
Proof.
The value of the integral is continuous in the function
G
(near
G\equiv 1
, in the
C^{1}
topology), so it suffices to prove that the
integral has a sign when
G\equiv 1
. We will show that the integrand (when
G\equiv 1
), namely
(6.20)
\frac{1}{4}u^{-3/2}v^{-3/2}r^{-1/2}\textnormal{(I)},\qquad\textnormal{(I)}\coloneqq{}h(r)^{2}r(v+u)+4uvrh^{\prime}(r)+4u^{2}(1-h(r)),
is positive when
\epsilon_{h}
is small enough compared to
B_{h}
. By the definition
of
\tau{}
(see
eq.
2.6
), we have
1\leq u\leq C
on
\Sigma{}(0)
,
where
C
depends only on
B_{h}
. Since the first term in
(I)
is non-negative, the assumption
item
(ii)
of
section
2.3
implies that
(6.21)
\textnormal{(I)}\geq 4(1-B_{h}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1})-4C\langle{}r\rangle^{-\eta{}_{h}}.
It follows that there is
R=R(B_{h},\eta{}_{h})>0
such that in
\{r\geq R\}
, we
have
\textnormal{(I)}\geq 1
. Next, since
h(0)=1
, we have
(6.22)
\lvert 1-h(r)\rvert\leq\int_{0}^{r}\lvert h^{\prime}(s)\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}s\leq\epsilon{}_{h}r.
It follows from
eq.
6.22
, the assumption
item
(iii)
of
section
2.3
and the estimate
v=u+r\leq C\langle{}r\rangle{}
on
\Sigma{}(0)
(for
C
depending only on
B_{h}
) that in
\{r\leq R\}
, we have
(6.23)
\textnormal{(I)}\geq r(2(1-\epsilon{}_{h}r)-C\epsilon{}_{h}\langle{}r\rangle{}-C\epsilon{}_{h})\geq r(2-C\epsilon{}_{h}\langle{}R\rangle{}).
If
\epsilon_{h}\ll R
, then we obtain
\textnormal{(I)}\geq r
in
\{r\leq R\}
.
∎
6.2.
Constructing time integral initial data by inverting an elliptic operator
In this section, we invert an elliptic operator to
construct functions which will be used in
section
6.3
as
initial data for wave equations that define time integrals.
6.2.1.
Scalar fields that solve an equation with a good zeroth-order term
For
f_{1}(r),f_{2}(r)=\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{}r^{2}\langle{}r\rangle^{-2})
, define the operator
(6.24)
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}\Phi{}\coloneqq{}X^{2}\Phi{}-\alpha{}r^{-2}(1+f_{1}(r))\Phi{}+r^{-2}(1+f_{2}(r))\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}\Phi{}.
For
p\in\mathbf{R}
and
N\geq 0
, let
\mathbf{H}_{p,N}
be the closure of
C_{c}^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0)\setminus\{r=0\})
under the norm
(6.25)
\lVert\Phi{}\rVert_{p,N}^{2}\coloneqq{}\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r^{p}[(X\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rX)^{n_{2}}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{-2}(\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rX)^{n_{2}}\Phi{})^{2}+r^{-2}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rX)^{n_{2}}\Phi{})^{2}]\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.
Lemma 6.7
.
For
\Phi{}\in C_{c}^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0)\setminus\{r=0\})
,
p\in\mathbf{R}
, and
N\geq 0
, we have
(6.26)
\lVert\Phi{}\rVert_{p,N}\lesssim_{p,N}\lVert r^{p/2}\Phi{}\rVert_{0,N}.
Proof.
This is a straightforward calculation.
∎
Lemma 6.8
(Commutation of the operator
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}
with
(rX)
-derivatives)
.
For
N\geq 0
, there are constants
C_{N,n}\in\mathbf{R}
such that
(6.27)
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}(rX)^{N}=\sum_{n=0}^{N}C_{N,n}(rX)^{n}\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{O}(\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-2})(rX)^{n}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{O}(\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-2})\partial_{\theta}^{2}(rX)^{n},
where the implicit constants in the
\mathcal{O}
-notation depend on
\alpha{}
,
f_{1}
, and
f_{2}
.
Proof.
Induction on
N
.
∎
Lemma 6.9
(A priori estimate for the elliptic operator
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}
)
.
Suppose
\Phi{}\in\mathbf{H}_{p,N}
solves
(6.28)
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}\Phi{}=\tilde{\mathcal{F}}.
Suppose moreover that one of the following assumptions holds:
(i)
\alpha{}>0
,
(ii)
or
\alpha{}>-1
,
\alpha{}\neq{}0
, and
\Phi{}=\Phi_{\geq 1}
.
Define
\tilde{\alpha{}}=\alpha{}
if
item
(i)
holds and
\tilde{\alpha{}}=\alpha{}+1
if
item
(ii)
holds. Then for
\eta_{0}>0
such that
\epsilon{}\ll\eta_{0}
,
\lvert p\rvert\leq 2\sqrt{\tilde{\alpha{}}}-\eta{}_{0}
and
N\geq 0
, we have
(6.29)
\begin{split}\lVert\Phi{}\rVert_{p,N}^{2}\lesssim_{p,N,\alpha{},\eta{}_{0}}\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r^{p+2}(\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rX)^{n_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{F}})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.\end{split}
Proof.
By density, it suffices to consider
\Phi{}\in C_{c}^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0)\setminus\{r=0\})
.
Step 1: The case
N=0
.
Compute
(6.30)
\begin{split}-r^{p}\Phi{}\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}\Phi{}&=-X(r^{p}\Phi{}X\Phi{})-\partial{}_{\theta}{}((1+f_{2}(r))\Phi{}\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})+r^{p}(X\Phi{})^{2}+pr^{p-1}\Phi{}X\Phi{}\\
&\qquad+\alpha{}r^{p-2}(1+\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{}))\Phi^{2}+r^{p-2}(1+\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{}))(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}.\end{split}
After integrating on
\Sigma{}(0)
and applying an
r
-weighted Young’s inequality
for the last term on the first line, we obtain
(6.31)
\begin{split}&\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r^{p}\Bigl(1-\frac{1}{4}\delta{}^{-1}p^{2}\Bigr)(X\Phi{})^{2}+r^{p-2}(\alpha{}(1+\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{}))-\delta{})\Phi^{2}+r^{p-2}(1+\mathcal{O}(\epsilon{}))(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\leq\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r^{p}\lvert\Phi{}\rvert\lvert\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}\Phi{}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.\end{split}
If
item
(ii)
holds, then we use the Poincaré inequality on
S^{1}
:
(6.32)
\int_{S^{1}}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{}_{\geq 1})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\geq\int_{S^{1}}\Phi{}_{\geq 1}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.
In either case, the expression on the left-hand side of
eq.
6.31
is
coercive for
\delta{}=\alpha{}-\eta_{0}
and
\lvert p\rvert\leq 2\sqrt{\tilde{\alpha{}}}-\eta_{0}
, and so we obtain
(6.33)
\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r^{p}(X\Phi{})^{2}+r^{p-2}\Phi^{2}+r^{p-2}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\lesssim_{p,\alpha{},\eta{}_{0}}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r^{p}\lvert\Phi{}\rvert\lvert\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}\Phi{}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.
Using Young’s inequality completes the proof when
N=0
.
Step 2: The case
N\geq 1
.
Now assume
N\geq 1
and
eq.
6.29
holds with
N-1
in place of
N
. Applying the
N=0
case to
(rX)^{N}\Phi{}
in place
of
\Phi{}
and using
lemma
6.8
, we obtain
(6.34)
\begin{split}\lVert(rX)^{N}\Phi{}\rVert_{p,0}\lesssim\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r^{p+2}(\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}(rX)^{N}\Phi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r^{p+2}((rX)^{N}\tilde{\mathcal{F}})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\lVert(rX)^{n}\Phi{}\rVert_{p,0}.\end{split}
Adding a suitable multiple of the
N-1
case, we obtain
(6.35)
\sum_{n=0}^{N}\lVert(rX)^{n}\Phi{}\rVert_{p,0}\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r^{p+2}((rX)^{N}\tilde{\mathcal{F}})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.
Repeating this argument with
\partial_{\theta}^{n}\Phi{}
in place of
\Phi{}
completes the proof (since
\partial_{\theta}{}
commutes with
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}
).
∎
Proposition 6.10
(Inversion of the elliptic operator
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}
acting on good scalar fields)
.
Suppose that
\tilde{\mathcal{F}}\in C^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0)\setminus\{r=0\})
satisfies
(6.36)
\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r^{p+2}(\partial{}_{\theta}^{n_{1}}(rX)^{n_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{F}})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}<\infty
for some
N\geq 0
and
p\in\mathbf{R}
. Suppose moreover that either
\alpha{}=-1/4
and
\tilde{\mathcal{F}}=\tilde{\mathcal{F}}_{\geq 1}
, or
\alpha{}=3/4
and
\tilde{\mathcal{F}}
is radially symmetric. Let
\tilde{\alpha{}}
and
\eta_{0}
be as
in
eq.
6.29
, and let
\lvert p\rvert\leq 2\sqrt{\tilde{\alpha{}}}-\eta{}_{0}
. Then there is a unique
\Phi{}\in\mathbf{H}_{p,N}
solving
eq.
6.28
, which is radially symmetric (resp. supported on angular modes
\geq 1
) if
\tilde{\mathcal{F}}
is, and the following estimate holds:
(6.37)
\lVert\Phi{}\rVert_{p,N}^{2}\lesssim_{p,N,\alpha{}}\textup{{(LHS of }}\textup{\lx@cref{creftype\lx@tilde refnum}{F-norm}}\text{{)}}.
Moreover, if
\mathcal{F}\in r^{\beta}{}C^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0))
for
\beta{}\coloneqq{}\frac{1}{2}(1+\sqrt{1+4\alpha{}})
, then
\Phi{}\in r^{\beta}{}C^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0))
.
Remark 6.11
.
We could have formulated a version of
proposition
6.10
for
\alpha{}\notin\{-1/4,3/4\}
, but these are the only cases that we need in order to prove
theorem
3.1
.
Proof.
As in
[
Gaj23
, Sec. 9.1]
, define the twisted operator
(6.38)
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}^{(p)}\Phi{}\coloneqq{}r^{p/2}\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}(r^{-p/2}\Phi{}).
We also introduce the associated bilinear operator
B_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}^{(p)}:\mathbf{H}_{0,0}\times\mathbf{H}_{0,0}\to\mathbf{R}
:
(6.39)
B_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}^{(p)}[\Phi_{1},\Phi_{2}]\coloneqq{}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}X(r^{-p/2}\Phi{}_{1})X(r^{p/2}\Phi{}_{2})+\alpha{}r^{-2}(1+f_{1}(r))\Phi{}_{1}\Phi{}_{2}+r^{-2}(1+f_{2}(r))\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{}_{1}\partial{}_{\theta}{}\Phi{}_{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.
Note that
B^{(p)}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}[\Phi{}_{1},\Phi{}_{2}]=\langle{}\tilde{\mathcal{L}}^{(p)}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}\Phi{}_{1},\Phi{}_{2}\rangle{}_{L^{2}(\Sigma{}(0),\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{})}
.
One can check that for
\lvert p\rvert\leq 2\sqrt{\tilde{\alpha{}}}-\eta_{0}
, we have
(6.40)
\lvert B_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}^{(p)}[\Phi_{1},\Phi_{2}]\rvert\lesssim_{p,\alpha{}}\lVert\Phi{}_{1}\rVert_{0,0}\lVert\Phi{}_{2}\rVert_{0,0},\qquad\lvert B_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}^{(p)}[\Phi,\Phi]\rvert\gtrsim_{p,\alpha{}}\lVert\Phi{}\rVert_{0,0}^{2}.
By
eq.
6.36
, the functional
\langle{}r^{p/2}\tilde{\mathcal{F}},\cdot\rangle{}_{L^{2}(\Sigma{}(0),\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{})}
is continuous on
\mathbf{H}_{0,0}
. By the Lax–Milgram lemma, there exists a unique
\Phi{}\in\mathbf{H}_{0,0}
solving
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}^{(p)}\Phi{}=r^{p/2}\tilde{\mathcal{F}}
weakly, equivalently
\tilde{\Phi{}}=r^{p/2}\Phi{}\in\mathbf{H}_{0,0}
solving
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}\tilde{\Phi{}}=\tilde{\mathcal{F}}
and, by
eq.
6.29
, satisfying the estimate
\lVert\tilde{\Phi{}}\rVert_{0,0}^{2}\lesssim\textup{{(LHS of }}\textup{\lx@cref{creftype\lx@tilde refnum}{F-norm}}\text{{)}}
. Now suppose
N=1
. Since
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}\partial{}_{\theta}{}\tilde{\Phi{}}=\partial{}_{\theta}{}\tilde{\mathcal{F}}
, the uniqueness part of the
Lax–Milgram lemma ensures that
\partial_{\theta}{}\tilde{\Phi{}}\in\mathbf{H}_{0,0}
. By
lemma
6.8
and the fact that
\tilde{\Phi{}},\partial_{\theta}{}\tilde{\Phi{}}\in\mathbf{H}_{0,0}
, we
conclude that
(rX)\tilde{\Phi{}}
satisfies
r^{p/2+1}\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}(rX)\tilde{\Phi{}}\in L^{2}(\Sigma{}(0),\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{})
. Then a Lax–Milgram argument shows that
(rX)\tilde{\Phi{}}\in\mathbf{H}_{0,0}
(with an estimate). This shows that
\tilde{\Phi{}}\in\mathbf{H}_{0,1}
. In this way one can inductively show
that
\tilde{\Phi{}}\in\mathbf{H}_{0,N}
and
\lVert\tilde{\Phi{}}\rVert_{0,N}^{2}\lesssim\textup{{(LHS of }}\textup{\lx@cref{creftype\lx@tilde refnum}{F-norm}}\text{{)}}
. By
eq.
6.26
, we conclude that
\Phi{}=r^{-p/2}\tilde{\Phi{}}\in\mathbf{H}_{p,N}
and
eq.
6.37
holds.
We now deduce a smoothness property of
\Phi{}
by considering the equation solved by
\tilde{\Phi{}}\coloneqq{}r^{-\beta{}}\Phi{}
,
namely
(6.41)
\begin{split}X^{2}\tilde{\Phi{}}+\frac{2\beta{}}{r}X\tilde{\Phi{}}-\alpha{}r^{-2}f_{1}(r)\tilde{\Phi{}}+r^{-2}(1+f_{2}(r))\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}\tilde{\Phi{}}=r^{-\beta{}}\tilde{\mathcal{F}}.\end{split}
If
\alpha{}=-1/4
, then
\beta{}=1/2
, and so we have
(6.42)
(\Delta_{\mathbf{R}^{2}}+r^{-2}f_{2}(r)\partial{}_{\theta{}}^{2})\tilde{\Phi{}}+\alpha{}r^{-2}f_{1}(r)\tilde{\Phi{}}=r^{-\beta{}}\tilde{\mathcal{F}},
where we have written
\Delta_{\mathbf{R}^{2}}=X^{2}+r^{-1}X+r^{-2}\partial_{\theta}^{2}
. The
principal part of the operator on the left is a small and smooth perturbation of
the Laplacian in two dimensions with small and smooth potential (by the
assumptions on
f_{1}
and
f_{2}
), and the source on the right-hand side is smooth
by assumption. We conclude by standard interior elliptic regularity results that
\tilde{\Phi{}}\in C^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0))
. If instead
\alpha{}=3/4
and
\mathcal{F}
is radially symmetric, then
\Phi{}
is radially symmetric by uniqueness.
Moreover,
\beta{}=3/2
, and the equation becomes
(6.43)
\Delta_{\mathbf{R}^{4}}\tilde{\Phi{}}-\alpha{}r^{-2}f_{1}(r)\tilde{\Phi{}}=r^{-\beta{}}\tilde{\mathcal{F}},
where we have written
\Delta_{\mathbf{R}^{4}}=X^{2}+3r^{-1}X+\Delta_{S^{3}}
, and now interpret
\tilde{\Phi{}}
as a spherically symmetric function on
\mathbf{R}^{4}
. Again, elliptic
regularity for this equation is standard.
∎
6.2.2.
Radially symmetric scalar fields
Although the elliptic theory of
section
6.2.1
fails for radially
symmetric functions (because the critical value
-1/4
in the coefficient of
the inverse-square potential in the equation for
\psi{}_{0}
makes the operator
only degenerate elliptic rather than elliptic), for such scalar fields the
operator
\mathcal{L}
reduces to an ODE which we can solve via direct
integration.
8
8
8
In
[
GK25
]
, which
studies late-time tails for linear and nonlinear waves on the Schwarzschild
spacetime of three space dimensions, an elliptic operator similar to
\mathcal{L}
is inverted for
low angular modes via direct integration, while elliptic theory is used to
invert the operator acting on high angular modes.
Proposition 6.12
(Inverting the operator
\mathcal{L}
via direct integration; radially symmetric case)
.
Let
\mathcal{F}\in C^{\infty}((0,\infty))
. Suppose that there are constants
B_{N,\delta{}}>0
such that the following estimate holds for each
N\geq 0
and
\delta{}>0
:
(6.44)
\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{0}^{\infty}r^{-1}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{4-\delta{}}((rX)^{n}\mathcal{F})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\leq B_{N,\delta{}}^{2}.
Suppose moreover that we have the vanishing property
(6.45)
\int_{0}^{\infty}r^{1/2}G(r)^{1/2}\mathcal{F}(r)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r=0.
Then the function
\zeta{}:(0,\infty)\to\mathbf{R}
defined formally by
(6.46)
\zeta{}(r)\coloneqq{}-r^{1/2}G(r)^{1/2}\int_{r}^{\infty}\rho{}^{-1}G(\rho{})^{-1}\int_{0}^{\rho}{}s^{1/2}G(s)^{1/2}\mathcal{F}(s)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}s\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\rho{}
(i)
is well-defined and smooth, with
r^{-1/2}\zeta{}
bounded as
r\to 0
,
(ii)
determines an element of
r^{1/2}C^{\infty}(\Sigma{}_{0})
if
\mathcal{F}
does, which is moreover radially symmetric,
(iii)
solves
\mathcal{L}\zeta{}=\mathcal{F}
,
(iv)
and satisfies the following estimate for each
N\geq 0
and
\delta{}>0
:
(6.47)
\begin{split}&\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{0}^{\infty}r(X(rX)^{n}(r^{-1/2}G^{-1/2}\zeta{}))^{2}+r\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-2\delta{}}(X(r^{1/2}(rX)^{n}(r^{-1/2}G^{-1/2}\zeta{})))^{2}\\
&\qquad+\langle{}r\rangle^{-2\delta{}}((rX)^{n}(r^{-1/2}G^{-1/2}\zeta{}))^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\\
&\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}B_{N,\delta{}}^{2}.\end{split}
Remark 6.13
(Purpose of the vanishing condition
eq.
6.45
)
.
Without the vanishing property
eq.
6.45
, the
\rho{}
-integral in
eq.
6.46
would not converge.
Proof.
We first establish
item
(i)
. We claim that
(6.48)
\Big\lvert\int_{0}^{r}s^{1/2}G(s)^{1/2}\mathcal{F}(s)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}s\Big\rvert\lesssim_{\delta}{}B_{0,\delta{}}r^{3/2}\langle{}r\rangle^{-2+\delta{}/2}.
Indeed, using Cauchy–Schwarz and
\lvert G(s)\rvert\lesssim 1
, we obtain
(6.49)
\Big\lvert\int_{0}^{r}s^{1/2}G(s)^{1/2}\mathcal{F}(s)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}s\Big\rvert\lesssim B_{0,\delta{}}\Bigl(\int_{0}^{r}s^{2}\langle{}s\rangle{}^{-4+\delta{}}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}s\Bigr)^{1/2}\lesssim B_{0,\delta{}}r^{3/2}\langle{}r\rangle^{-3/2}.
This implies
eq.
6.48
as
r\to 0
. To also obtain
eq.
6.48
as
r\to\infty
,
we use the vanishing condition
eq.
6.45
to write
(6.50)
\Big\lvert\int_{0}^{r}s^{1/2}G(s)^{1/2}\mathcal{F}(s)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}s\Big\rvert=\Big\lvert\int_{r}^{\infty}s^{1/2}G(s)^{1/2}\mathcal{F}(s)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}s\Big\rvert\lesssim B_{0,\delta{}}\Bigl(\int_{r}^{\infty}s^{2}\langle{}s\rangle{}^{-4+\delta{}}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}s\Bigr)^{1/2}\lesssim B_{0,\delta{}}\langle{}s\rangle^{-1/2+\delta{}/2}.
It follows that
\zeta{}
is well-defined. Moreover,
\zeta{}
inherits the smoothness
of
\mathcal{F}
on
(0,\infty)
by the fundamental theorem of calculus. Next, we establish
item
(ii)
. By assumption,
r^{-1/2}\mathcal{F}
determines a smooth radially symmetric function on
\Sigma_{0}
, and so
r^{1/2}\mathcal{F}\in rC^{\infty}(\Sigma{}_{0})
. In view of
item
(i)
of
lemma
2.3
, a Taylor expansion shows that
(6.51)
r^{-1}\int_{0}^{r}s^{1/2}G(s)^{1/2}\mathcal{F}(s)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}s\in{}rC^{\infty}(\Sigma{}_{0}),
and so
r^{-1/2}\zeta{}
determines an element of
C^{\infty}(\Sigma{}_{0})
, being the difference
of a constant and an element of
r^{2}C^{\infty}(\Sigma_{0})\subset C^{\infty}(\Sigma_{0}).
Next,
item
(iii)
follows from the fundamental theorem of calculus and the
representation
(6.52)
\mathcal{L}\zeta{}=r^{-1/2}G^{-1/2}X(rFX(r^{-1/2}G^{-1/2}\zeta{})).
Finally, we turn to
item
(iv)
. Write
(6.53)
\textnormal{(I)}\coloneqq{}\int_{r}^{\infty}\rho{}^{-1}G(\rho{})^{-1}\int_{0}^{\rho}{}s^{1/2}G(s)^{1/2}\mathcal{F}(s)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}s\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\rho{},\qquad\textnormal{(II)}\coloneqq{}\int_{0}^{r}s^{1/2}G(s)^{1/2}\mathcal{F}(s)\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}s,
so that
(6.54)
\lvert\textnormal{(I)}\rvert=\lvert r^{-1/2}G^{-1/2}\zeta{}\rvert\lesssim\langle{}r\rangle^{-1/2+\delta{}/2},\qquad\lvert\textnormal{(II)}\rvert\lesssim_{\delta}{}B_{0,\delta{}}r^{3/2}\langle{}r\rangle^{-2+\delta{}/2},
by
eq.
6.48
. By differentiating
eq.
6.46
and using
G=\mathcal{O}(1)
and
G^{\prime}=\mathcal{O}(\langle{}r\rangle^{-1})
, we obtain
(6.55)
\displaystyle(rX)^{N}(r^{-1/2}G^{-1/2}\zeta{})
\displaystyle=\mathbf{1}_{N=0}\textnormal{(I)}+\mathcal{O}(1)\textnormal{(II)}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-2}\mathcal{O}(r^{3/2})(rX)^{n}\mathcal{F},
(6.56)
\displaystyle X(rX)^{N}(r^{-1/2}G^{-1/2}\zeta{})
\displaystyle=\mathcal{O}(r^{-1})\textnormal{(II)}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{O}(r^{1/2})(rX)^{n}\mathcal{F},
(6.57)
\displaystyle X(r^{1/2}(rX)^{N}(r^{-1/2}G^{-1/2}\zeta{}))
\displaystyle=\mathcal{O}(r^{-1/2})\textnormal{(I)}+\mathcal{O}(r^{-1/2})\textnormal{(II)}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-2}\mathcal{O}(r)(rX)^{n}\mathcal{F}.
Now
item
(iv)
follows from
eqs.
6.54
,
6.55
,
6.56
,
6.57
, and
6.44
.
∎
6.3.
Constructing time integrals from initial data by solving a wave equation
In this section, we build time integrals of the
renormalized quantity
\widehat{\varphi{}}
(and of
\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
)
using the functions constructed in
section
6.2
as initial data
for wave equations. In view of the results of
section
5
, it is
important that we can construct
two
time integrals of
\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
;
this is possible because
\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
solves an equation with a good
zeroth-order term. We first provide a formula comparing
(rL)
-derivatives
with
(rX)
-derivatives.
Lemma 6.14
(Comparing
(rL)
-derivatives with
(rX)
-derivatives)
.
For
N\geq 1
, we have
(6.58)
(rX)^{N}=\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N-1\end{subarray}}((1+\mathcal{O}(r\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1}))(rL)(rL)^{n_{1}}T^{n_{2}}+\mathcal{O}(r\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1})T(rL)^{n_{1}}T^{n_{2}}),
and the same formula holds with
X
and
L
swapped.
Proof.
The case
N=1
follows from the explicit formula
rX=G^{-1}rL+rhT
and
the fact that
G^{-1}=\mathcal{O}(1)
and
rh=\mathcal{O}(1)
(by
item
(ii)
of
section
2.3
). The general case follows by
induction on
N
. The case when
X
and
L
are swapped is analogous.
∎
Proposition 6.15
(Constructing the first time integral of
\widehat{\varphi{}}
)
.
Suppose
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
solves
eq.
2.19
. There exists
T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
solving
(6.59)
\Box{}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}=-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
such that
TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}=\widehat{\varphi{}}
and the following estimates hold
for each
N\geq 0
and
\delta{}>0
:
(6.60)
E_{N}[T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](0,v)+\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](0,v)+\tilde{E}[T^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}}_{\geq 1}](0,v)+\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}}_{\geq 1}](0,v)\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}v^{3\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N,\delta{}}[\varphi{}],
where the initial data norm
\mathbf{D}_{N,\delta{}}[\varphi{}]
was defined in
section
2.7.4
.
Proof.
Step 1: Construction.
Let
\zeta{}_{0}\in r^{1/2}C^{\infty}(\Sigma(0))
be the solution to
(6.61)
\mathcal{L}\zeta{}_{0}=\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}\widehat{\psi{}}_{0}]|_{\Sigma{}(0)}-G^{-3/2}r^{1/2}\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}
constructed in
eq.
6.47
. Note that the right
side of
eq.
6.61
is an element of
r^{1/2}C^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0))
and satisfies the
vanishing condition
eq.
6.45
by the definition of
\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]
.
Let
\zeta{}_{\geq 1}\in r^{1/2}C^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0))
be the solution to
(6.62)
\mathcal{L}\zeta{}_{\geq 1}=\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}\widehat{\psi{}}_{\geq 1}]|_{\Sigma{}(0)}
constructed in
proposition
6.10
(noting that the operator
\mathcal{L}
is of the type considered in the proposition). Then
\zeta{}\coloneqq{}\zeta{}_{0}+\zeta{}_{\geq 1}
is a solution
\zeta{}\in r^{1/2}C^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0))
to
(6.63)
\mathcal{L}\zeta{}=\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}\widehat{\psi{}}]|_{\Sigma{}(0)}-G^{-3/2}r^{1/2}\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}.
Let
T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
be the unique solution to
(6.64)
\Box{}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}=-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}},\qquad(T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)},TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)})=(G^{-1/2}r^{-1/2}\zeta{},\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}),
where
T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
was defined in
eq.
6.10
.
We now show that
TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}=\widehat{\varphi{}}
. Since
(6.65)
\Box{}TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}=T\Box{}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}=\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]TT^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}=\Box{}\widehat{\varphi{}},
it suffices to show that
(\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)},T\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)})=(TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)},TTT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)})
,
by the uniqueness of solutions to
eq.
2.19
. The equality
TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}=\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}
holds by construction. To see that
TTT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}=T\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}
, note that, by
eqs.
2.26
and
6.64
we have
(6.66)
\mathcal{L}(G^{1/2}T^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}})=\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}TT^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}}]-G^{-3/2}r^{1/2}\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
Restricting to
\Sigma{}(0)
, using the prescription
G^{1/2}r^{1/2}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}=\zeta{}
, and
recalling
eq.
6.63
, we obtain
(6.67)
\mathcal{L}(G^{1/2}T^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}})|_{\Sigma{}(0)}=\mathcal{L}\zeta{}=\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}\widehat{\psi{}}]|_{\Sigma{}(0)}-G^{-3/2}r^{1/2}\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}.
It follows from
eqs.
6.66
and
6.67
that
(6.68)
\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}TT^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}}]|_{\Sigma{}(0)}=\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}\widehat{\psi{}}]|_{\Sigma{}(0)}.
Recalling the definition of
\mathcal{F}
(see
eq.
2.25
), we obtain the desired equality
TTT^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}=\widehat{\psi{}}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}
.
Step 2: Estimates.
We want to control energies of
T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}
that
involve
(rL)
-derivatives. We first use
lemma
6.14
to replace
(rL)
-derivatives by
(rX)
-derivatives and
T
-derivatives. We also use
the relation
TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}=\widehat{\varphi{}}
so that we
only estimate
T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}
for
M=0
and
T^{M}\widehat{\varphi{}}
for
M>0
. This is done in
eqs.
6.69
and
6.70
. We then estimate the
(rX)
-derivatives
using the results of
section
6.2
, which in turn requires bounding
the source term on the right-hand side of
eq.
6.63
using
eq.
6.10
; this is done in
eq.
6.71
.
First, by
lemma
6.14
and
TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}=\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
, we have
(6.69)
\begin{split}&E_{N}[T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](0,v)\\
&\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r(X(rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1}((rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n\geq 0,m\geq 1\\
n+m\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}((rX)^{n}T^{m-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})^{2}+r(X(rX)^{n}T^{m-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})^{2}+h(r)r(T(rX)^{n}T^{m-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n\geq 0,m\geq 0\\
n+m\leq N\end{subarray}}\lVert\langle{}r\rangle^{1/2}(rX)^{n}T^{m}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}\rVert_{L^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0))}^{2}+\sum_{m=0}^{N-1}E_{N-1-m}[T^{m}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](0,v)\\
&\qquad+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r(X(rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1}((rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.\end{split}
Similarly, we have
(6.70)
\begin{split}&\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](0,v)\\
&\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0,v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(X(r^{1/2}(rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}))^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}((rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\qquad+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n\geq 0,m\geq 1\\
n+m\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\Sigma{}(0,v)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L(r^{1/2}(rL)^{n}T^{m-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}))^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta{}}((rX)^{n}T^{m-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim\sum_{m=0}^{N}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N-m}[T^{m}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](0,v)+v^{3\delta{}}\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n\geq 0,m\geq 0\\
n+m\leq N\end{subarray}}\lVert\langle{}r\rangle^{1/2}(rX)^{n}T^{m}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}\rVert_{L^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0))}^{2}\\
&\qquad+v^{3\delta{}}\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{-2\delta{}}(X(r^{1/2}(rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}))^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{-2\delta{}}((rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{},\end{split}
where we have used
v\sim\langle{}r\rangle{}
on
\Sigma{}(0)
. By
eq.
6.47
, we have
(6.71)
\begin{split}&\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{0}^{\infty}r(X(rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})^{2}+r\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-2\delta{}}(X(r^{1/2}(rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}))^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{-2\delta{}}((rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\\
&\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r^{-1}\langle{}r\rangle^{4-\delta{}}((rX)^{n}\textup{{(RHS of }}\textup{\lx@cref{creftype\lx@tilde refnum}{Tinv-phi-prep-0}}\text{{)}})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\end{split}
By estimating the right-hand side using
eq.
6.10
, combining with
eqs.
6.69
and
6.70
, and using
eq.
6.7
to replace
\widehat{\varphi{}}
with
\varphi{}
in energy and pointwise norms, we obtain
(6.72)
E_{N}[T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](0,v)+\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](0,v)\lesssim v^{3\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N,\delta{}}[\varphi{}].
The estimates for the norms involving
\psi_{\geq 1}
are similar, but we use
proposition
6.10
with
p=0
and
p=1-\delta{}
(noting that
\mathcal{L}
is an operator of the form
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}_{\alpha{},f_{1},f_{2}}
considered there, with
\alpha{}=-1/4
) in place of
eq.
6.47
.
∎
We will construct time integrals of
\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
not by solving the wave
equation that
\widehat{\varphi{}}
solves, but by solving the equation that
\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
itself solves (see
eq.
2.26
).
Lemma 6.16
(Solvability theory for the equation solved by
\Psi_{0}
)
.
Suppose
\Phi{}_{0}
,
\Phi{}_{1}
, and
F
are radially symmetric elements of
r^{3/2}C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
. Then there exists a
unique solution
\Phi{}\in r^{3/2}C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
to the equation
(6.73)
-\underline{L}L\Phi{}-\frac{3}{4}r^{-2}G\Bigl(G-\frac{2}{3}rG^{\prime}\Bigr)\Phi{}=F
that is radially symmetric and achieves the initial data
(\Phi{}|_{\Sigma{}_{0}},T\Phi{}|_{\Sigma{}_{0}})=(\Phi{}_{0},\Phi{}_{1})
.
Proof.
Observe that a radially symmetric scalar field
\Phi{}
solves
eq.
6.73
if and only if
\tilde{\Phi{}}\coloneqq{}r^{-3/2}\Phi{}
solves
(6.74)
-T^{2}\tilde{\Phi{}}+G^{2}Z^{2}\tilde{\Phi{}}+G^{2}\frac{3}{r}Z\tilde{\Phi{}}+GG^{\prime}Z\tilde{\Phi{}}+2Gr^{-1}G^{\prime}\tilde{f}=r^{-3/2}F.
This is the equation for a spherically symmetric solution to a wave equation
associated to an asymptotically flat metric in
(4+1)
-dimensions with smooth
potential and source, for which existence and uniqueness for solutions arising
from smooth data is standard. Namely,
\Phi{}
solves
eq.
6.73
if and only if
\tilde{\Phi{}}\coloneqq{}r^{-3/2}\Phi{}
solves
(6.75)
\Box{}_{\tilde{g}}\tilde{\Phi{}}+2A^{-2}Gr^{-1}G^{\prime}\tilde{\Phi{}}=r^{-3/2}F,
where
\tilde{g}
is the spherically symmetric metric
(6.76)
\tilde{g}=-A(r)^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}t^{2}+A(r)^{2}G(r)^{-2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r^{2}+r^{2}g_{S^{3}}.
The reduction to
eq.
6.75
is motivated by the fact that the
r^{3}
volume form present in four space dimensions absorbs the
r^{-3/2}\Phi{}
term that would otherwise introduce a term that is too
singular at the origin to apply standard existence and uniqueness results.
∎
Proposition 6.17
(Constructing the first two time integrals of
\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
)
.
There exists a radially symmetric function
T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}\in r^{3/2}C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
solving
(6.77)
\underline{L}LT^{-2}\Psi{}_{0}+\frac{3}{4}r^{-2}G\Bigl(G-\frac{2}{3}rG^{\prime}\Bigr)T^{-2}\Psi{}_{0}=\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]GZ(r^{1/2}T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}})
such that
T^{2}T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}=\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
and
T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}\coloneqq{}-TT^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}=r^{1/2}GZT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
, where
T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
was constructed in
proposition
6.15
. Moreover, the following estimate holds for
each
N\geq 0
and
\delta{}>0
:
(6.78)
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}](0,v)\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}v^{3\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+1,\delta{}}{}[\varphi{}],
where the initial data norm
\mathbf{D}_{N,\delta{}}[\varphi{}]
was defined in
section
2.7.4
.
Proof.
Step 1: Construction.
Note that if a radially symmetric field
\Phi{}
solves
(6.79)
\underline{L}L\Phi{}+\frac{3}{4}r^{-2}G\Bigl(G-\frac{2}{3}rG^{\prime}\Bigr)\Phi{}=\tilde{F},
then we have
(6.80)
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}(G^{1/2}\Phi{})=\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}T\Phi{}]-G^{-3/2}\tilde{F},
where
(6.81)
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}\Phi{}\coloneqq{}X^{2}\Phi{}-\frac{3}{4}r^{-2}\Bigl(1-\frac{2}{r}G^{-1}rG^{\prime}+\frac{2}{3}G^{-1}r^{2}G^{\prime\prime}-\frac{1}{3}G^{-2}(rG^{\prime})^{2}\Bigr)\Phi{}+r^{-2}A^{2}G^{-2}\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}\Phi{}.
In particular,
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}
is of the form considered in
section
6.2.1
(with
\alpha{}=3/4
).
Let
\Phi^{(1)}
be the solution to
(6.82)
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}\Phi^{(1)}=\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}]+\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]T(GZ(r^{1/2}T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}))
constructed by
proposition
6.10
. By the uniqueness of such solutions
in the Hilbert space
\mathbf{H}_{0,N}
considered in
proposition
6.10
, we have
\Phi^{(1)}=r^{1/2}GZT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}|_{\Sigma{}(0)}
, where
T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
was constructed in
proposition
6.15
. Moreover,
\Phi^{(1)}
is a radially symmetric element of
r^{3/2}C^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0))
.
Define
T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
to be the unique solution to
eq.
6.73
with initial data
(G^{-1/2}\Phi^{(1)},\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}|_{\Sigma{}(0)})
and inhomogeneity
F=-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]T(GZ(r^{1/2}T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}))
constructed in
lemma
6.16
(where the equation is satisfied by
eq.
2.26
applied to
\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
). Since
T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
and
r^{1/2}GZT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
solve
eq.
6.79
with the same initial data, they are equal by the
uniqueness statement of
lemma
6.16
.
Next, let
\Phi^{(2)}
be the solution to
(6.83)
\tilde{\mathcal{L}}\Phi^{(2)}=\mathcal{F}[G^{1/2}T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}]+\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]GZ(r^{1/2}T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}})
constructed by
proposition
6.10
. Then
\Phi{}
is a radially symmetric element
of
r^{3/2}C^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(0))
. We now let
T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
be
the unique solution to
eq.
6.73
with initial data
(G^{-1/2}\Phi^{(2)},T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}|_{\Sigma{}(0)})
and
inhomogeneity
F=-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]GZ(r^{1/2}T^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}})
constructed in
lemma
6.16
(where the equation is satisfied by
eq.
2.26
applied to
T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
). We argue as in
Step 1 of the proof of
proposition
6.15
to show that
TT^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}=T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
.
Step 2: Estimates.
Arguing as in the proof of Step 2 of
proposition
6.15
(using now
the estimates of
proposition
6.10
with
p=1-2\delta{}
in place of
those of
eq.
6.47
and the right-hand side of
eq.
6.83
in place
of that of
eq.
6.63
, as well as
eq.
6.10
to estimate the
inhomogeneity associated to
\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
), we obtain
(6.84)
\begin{split}&\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}](0,v)\\
&\lesssim\sum_{m=0}^{N-2}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N-m}[T^{m}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}](0,v)+v^{3\delta{}}\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0,v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{3-2\delta{}}(X(rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{1-2\delta{}}((rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\qquad+v^{3\delta{}}\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0,v)}\langle{}r\rangle^{1-2\delta{}}((rX)^{n}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}+v^{3\delta{}}\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]^{2}\\
\end{split}
By
eq.
6.7
, we can replace
\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
by
\Psi_{0}
(at the cost
of gaining
\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]^{2}
, which is already present) to see that all the
terms but the one involving
T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
are present in the data norm
\mathbf{D}_{N,\delta{}}[\varphi{}]
. On one hand, by expanding
(6.85)
\sum_{n=0}^{N}X(rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}=\sum_{n=0}^{N}X(rX)^{n}(r^{1/2}GZT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})=\sum_{n=0}^{N+1}\mathcal{O}(r^{-1})X(r^{1/2}(rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\mathcal{O}(1)X(rX)^{n}\widehat{\psi{}}_{0},
we have
(6.86)
\begin{split}&\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0,v)\cap\{r\geq 1\}}\langle{}r\rangle^{3-2\delta{}}(X(rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{1-2\delta{}}((rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N+1}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r\langle{}r\rangle^{-2\delta{}}(X(r^{1/2}(rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}))^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{-2\delta{}}((rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}\langle{}r\rangle^{3-2\delta{}}(X(rX)^{n}\widehat{\psi{}}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim\mathbf{D}_{N,\delta{}}[\varphi{}]+\sum_{n=0}^{N+1}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}r^{-1}\langle{}r\rangle^{4-\delta{}}((rX)^{n}\textup{{(RHS of }}\textup{\lx@cref{creftype\lx@tilde refnum}{Tinv-phi-prep-0}}\text{{)}})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{},\end{split}
We can estimate the final term on the right-hand side by
\mathbf{D}_{N+1,\delta{}}[\varphi{}]
as
in Step 2 of the proof of
proposition
6.15
. On the other hand, by Step 1, we
can use
proposition
6.10
with
p=0
to estimate
(6.87)
\begin{split}&\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0,v)\cap\{r\leq 1\}}\langle{}r\rangle^{3-2\delta{}}(X(rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{1-2\delta{}}((rX)^{n}T^{-1}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}\langle{}r\rangle^{2}((rX)^{n}\textup{{(RHS of }}\textup{\lx@cref{creftype\lx@tilde refnum}{Phi-1-construction}}\text{{)}})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]^{2}+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(0)}\langle{}r\rangle^{2}(X(rX)^{n}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0})^{2}+((rX)^{n}T\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0})^{2}+((rX)^{n}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\lesssim\mathbf{D}_{N,\delta{}}[\varphi{}].\end{split}
Combining
eqs.
6.86
and
6.87
and replacing
\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
with
\Psi_{0}
using
eq.
6.7
, we obtain
eq.
6.78
.
∎
7.
Late-time asymptotics
In this section, we combine the results of
sections
5
and
6
to derive pointwise decay for the
renormalized quantity
\widehat{\varphi{}}
, and hence precise late-time
asymptotics for
\varphi{}
itself. In
section
7.1
, we derive energy
decay estimates, and in
section
7.2
, we derive pointwise decay
estimates.
7.1.
Energy decay for the renormalized solution
In this section, we prove energy decay estimates for the renormalized solution
\widehat{\varphi{}}
. To do this, we write
\widehat{\varphi{}}=TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}
using the time integral construction of
section
6
, and then apply
the improved decay results for time derivatives obtained in
section
5
. A caveat is that the time integral
T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}
does not have a finite
p=1
energy, and so we are forced to work with a small
loss in
v
for the energy defined on the truncated hypersurface
\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)
.
In
lemma
7.2
, we show that this loss in
v
can be exchanged
for a loss in
\tau{}
-decay for the energy defined on the full hypersurface
\Sigma{}(\tau{})
. The main result of this section is
proposition
7.3
,
where we prove energy decay estimates for all the solution variables associated
to
\widehat{\varphi{}}
.
Lemma 7.1
(Estimate for the initial data of time integrals of the renormalized solution)
.
Let
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
. For
N\geq 0
,
M\geq 0
,
\delta{}>0
, and
v\geq 0
, we have
(7.1)
\displaystyle\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{1+\delta{},N,M}[T^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}}_{\geq 1}](v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}v^{3\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M,\delta{}}{}[\varphi{}],
(7.2)
\displaystyle\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{1+\delta{},N,M}[T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}](v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}v^{3\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+1,\delta{}}{}[\varphi{}],
(7.3)
\displaystyle\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}{}[T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0},T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}](v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}v^{3\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+2,\delta{}}[\varphi{}]\qquad(N\geq 1).
Proof.
We first establish
eq.
7.1
by considering
T^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}}_{\geq 1}
, which satisfies the assumptions of
definition
4.1
(see
lemmas
4.3
and
2.22
) with vanishing
inhomogeneity (since
\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
is radially symmetric). It
follows from the estimates in
proposition
6.15
and the definition of the norm
\tilde{\mathcal{D}}
(see
eq.
5.20
) that
(7.4)
\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{1+\delta{},N,M}[\widehat{\psi{}}_{\geq 1}](v)\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}v^{3\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M,\delta{}}{}[\varphi{}]+\sum_{m=0}^{M-1}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N+M-m}[T^{m}\widehat{\psi{}}_{\geq 1}](0,v).
Next, we consider
T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
, which satisfies the assumptions of
definition
4.1
(see
lemmas
4.3
and
6.77
) with
inhomogeneity
F\coloneqq{}-r^{1/2}\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]GZT^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
.
It follows from
corollary
6.5
and the estimates in
proposition
6.17
that
(7.5)
\tilde{\mathcal{D}}_{1+\delta{},N,M}[T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}]\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}v^{3\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+1,\delta{}}{}[\varphi{}]+\sum_{m=0}^{M}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N+M-m}[T^{m}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}](0,v).
Finally, we establish
eq.
7.3
by considering
T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
, which solves
\Box{}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}=F=-\mathfrak{L}[\varphi{}]T^{-1}\Box{}\varphi_{\textnormal{mink}}
. It follows
from
corollary
6.5
,
eq.
7.5
, and the definition of the
norm
\mathcal{D}
(given in
proposition
5.6
) that
(7.6)
\begin{split}\mathcal{D}_{N,M,\delta{}}[T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0},T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}](v)&\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}v^{3\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+2,\delta{}}{}[\varphi{}]+\sum_{m=0}^{M}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N+M-m}[T^{m}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}](0,v)\\
&\qquad+\sum_{m=0}^{M-1}(E_{N+M-m}[T^{m}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](0,v)+\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N+M-m}[T^{m}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}]).\end{split}
∎
Lemma 7.2
(Exchanging growth in
v
of the truncated energy for a loss in
\tau{}
-decay of the full energy)
.
Let
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
. Suppose that for all
\delta{}>0
small, there exists
a constant
D_{\delta}{}>0
such that
(7.7)
\displaystyle\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[\varphi{}](\tau{},v)
\displaystyle\leq D_{\delta}{}v^{\eta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-\beta{}}
for some
\eta{}>0
and
\beta{}\in\mathbf{R}
(independent of
\delta{}
). Suppose moreover that
D_{\delta}{}\leq D_{\delta{}^{\prime}}
whenever
\delta{}\leq\delta{}^{\prime}
. Then for
\delta{}<\eta{}
, we have
(7.8)
\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[\varphi{}](\tau{})\lesssim D_{2\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-\beta{}+\eta{}}.
The same result holds with
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[\psi{}](\tau{},v)
in place of
\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[\varphi{}](\tau{},v)
.
Proof.
We use the interpolation argument of
[
Gaj23
, Prop. 10.6]
. First,
choose
A>0
large enough (independently of
\tau{}
) that
\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq R\}\subset\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{v\leq AR\}
for all
R\geq 1+\tau{}
. Now let
r_{i}
be a dyadic sequence with
r_{0}=1+\tau{}
, and split
(7.9)
\begin{split}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[\varphi{}](\tau{})&=\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}\underbrace{r(1+r)^{\delta}{}(L\psi{})^{2}+h(r)(1+r)^{\delta}{}\varphi{}^{2}}_{\coloneqq{}(\ast{})}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&=\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq r_{0}\}}(\ast{})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}+\sum_{i\geq 0}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r_{i}\leq r\leq r_{i+1}\}}(\ast{})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.\end{split}
By assumption, we can estimate
(7.10)
\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq r_{0}\}}(\ast{})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\leq\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{v\leq A(1+\tau{})\}}(\ast{})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}=\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[\varphi{}](\tau{},A(1+\tau{}))\lesssim D_{\delta}{}(1+\tau{})^{-\beta{}+\eta{}}.
Using the dyadicity of the
r_{i}
, we estimate
(7.11)
\begin{split}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r_{i}\leq r\leq r_{i+1}\}}(\ast{})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}&\leq(1+r_{i})^{-\delta{}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{v\leq Ar_{i+1}\}}r(1+r)^{2\delta{}}(L\psi{})^{2}+h(r)(1+r)^{2\delta{}}\varphi{}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&=(1+r_{i})^{-\delta{}}\mathcal{E}_{1+2\delta{}}[\varphi{}](\tau{},Ar_{i+1})\lesssim(1+r_{i})^{-\delta{}+\eta{}}D_{2\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-\beta{}}.\end{split}
Returning to
eq.
7.9
(and summing the geometric series
in
eq.
7.11
), and repeating this argument for
(rL)^{n}\varphi{}
in place of
\varphi{}
, we obtain the desired result. The
argument for
\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[\psi{}](\tau{},v)
is similar.
∎
Proposition 7.3
(Energy estimates for the renormalized solution)
.
Suppose
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
solves
eq.
2.19
. For
N\geq 0
,
M\geq 0
,
\tau{}\geq 0
,
v\geq 0
, and
\delta{}>0
sufficiently small, we have
(7.12)
\displaystyle\tilde{E}[T^{M}T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}](\tau{})+\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{0,N}[T^{M}T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}](\tau{})
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-1-2M+4\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+1,2\delta{}}[\varphi{}],
(7.13)
\displaystyle\tilde{E}[T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}}_{\geq 1}](\tau{})+\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{0,N}[T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}}_{\geq 1}](\tau{})
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-1-2M+4\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M,2\delta{}}[\varphi{}],
(7.14)
\displaystyle\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}}_{\geq 1}](\tau{})
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-2M+4\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+2,2\delta{}}[\varphi{}],
(7.15)
\displaystyle E_{N}[T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](\tau{})
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-1-2M+5\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+2,2\delta{}}[\varphi{}],
(7.16)
\displaystyle\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](\tau{})
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{1-2M+5\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+2,2\delta{}}[\varphi{}]\qquad(M\geq 1).
Proof.
We first claim that
(7.17)
\displaystyle\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}}_{\geq 1}](\tau{},v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}v^{3\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-2M+\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M,\delta{}}[\varphi{}],
(7.18)
\displaystyle\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{M}T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}](\tau{},v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}v^{3\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-2M+\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+1,\delta{}}[\varphi{}],
(7.19)
\displaystyle\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N-1}[(rL)T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](\tau{},v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}v^{3\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-2M+2\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+2,\delta{}}[\varphi{}]\qquad(N\geq 1),
(7.20)
\displaystyle\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](\tau{},v)
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}v^{3\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{1-2M+2\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+2,\delta{}}[\varphi{}]\qquad(M\geq 1).
Indeed, these are immediate consequences of
eq.
5.20
applied to
T^{-1}\widehat{\psi{}}_{\geq 1}
and
T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
(which
satisfy the relevant assumptions by
lemma
4.3
),
proposition
5.6
applied to
T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
(where
T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}
plays the role of
\Phi{}
in the theorem), and
lemma
7.1
. Now
eqs.
7.14
and
7.16
follow from
lemma
7.2
together with
eqs.
7.17
and
7.20
, and
eq.
7.13
follows from
eq.
7.14
and a standard pigeonhole argument
using
eqs.
4.6
and
4.26
. Similarly,
eqs.
7.19
and
7.18
and
lemma
7.2
imply
(7.21)
\displaystyle\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[T^{M}T^{-2}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}](\tau{})
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-2M+4\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+1,2\delta{}}[\varphi{}],
(7.22)
\displaystyle\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{},N-1}[(rL)T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](\tau{})
\displaystyle\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}(1+\tau{})^{-2M+5\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+2,2\delta{}}[\varphi{}]\qquad(N\geq 1).
Note that
eq.
7.12
follows from
eq.
7.21
and a standard pigeonhole
argument using
eq.
4.16
(see
eq.
4.16
).
It now remains to establish
eq.
7.15
. By
proposition
4.13
,
eq.
7.21
, and
corollary
6.5
, we have
(7.23)
E_{N}[T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](\tau{}_{2})\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}E_{N}[T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](\tau{}_{1})+(1+\tau{})^{-2-2M+4\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M,2\delta{}}[\varphi{}].
By
proposition
4.17
,
eq.
7.21
,
eq.
7.22
,
corollary
6.5
, and an argument as in the proof of
eq.
5.40
, we have
(7.24)
\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}E_{N}[T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](\tau{})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}E_{N}[T^{M}T^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}](\tau{}_{1},v)+(1+\tau{})^{-2M+5\delta{}}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+1,2\delta{}}[\varphi{}].
A pigeonhole argument using
eqs.
7.23
and
7.24
(as in Step 2 of the proof
of
proposition
5.6
) proves
eq.
7.15
.
∎
7.2.
Pointwise decay for the renormalized solution
In this section, we complete the proof of
theorem
3.1
by proving sharp pointwise estimates for
\varphi{}
, which
come from improved decay estimates for
\widehat{\varphi{}}=TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}
. We do not prove pointwise estimates for
\widehat{\varphi{}}
directly. As usual, the obstruction comes at the level
of the radially symmetric part
\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
. To get around this
obstruction, we first prove an estimate for
(rL)\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
by
interpolating between the estimates of
eq.
7.29
applied in
appropriate large-
r
and small-
r
regions. We then integrate this estimate
in the
L
-direction to future null infinity (where we pick up no boundary
term). This yields an estimate in the region
\{r\geq 1\}
. To extend the
estimate to
\{r\leq 1\}
, we integrate the estimate we have for
\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}\sim r^{1/2}Z\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
in the
Z
-direction
to
\{r=1\}
, using the integrability of
r^{-1/2}
near
\{r=0\}
. We
pursue this argument in
eq.
7.57
, completing the proof of
theorem
3.1
.
Proposition 7.4
(Pointwise estimates for general scalar fields)
.
Let
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
and let
\eta_{h}>0
and
C_{h}\geq 2
be the constants
defined in
item
(ii)
and
item
(iv)
of
section
2.3
. Recall the norm
\mathcal{A}
defined in
section
2.7.3
. Then for
R\geq 1
,
N\geq 0
, and
\tau{}\geq 0
, we have
(7.25)
\begin{split}&\lVert(rL)^{N}\varphi{}_{0}\rVert_{L^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq R\})}^{2}\lesssim_{N}R^{C_{h}}\Bigl(\mathcal{E}_{1}[T^{N}\varphi{}_{0}](\tau{})+\!\!\!\!\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}0\leq m\leq N\\
0\leq k\leq 1\end{subarray}}E_{N-m}[T^{m+k}\varphi{}_{0}](\tau{})+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n,m\geq 0\\
n+m\leq N\end{subarray}}\mathcal{A}_{1,N-m}[T^{m}\Box{}\varphi{}](\tau{})\Bigr)\end{split}
and
(7.26)
\begin{split}&\lVert(rL)^{N}\varphi{}_{\geq 1}\rVert_{L^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq R\})}\lesssim_{N}R^{C_{h}}\sum_{k=0}^{1}\Bigl(\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{0,N}[\partial{}_{\theta}^{k}\psi{}_{\geq 1}](\tau{})+\tilde{E}[\partial{}_{\theta}^{k}\psi{}_{\geq 1}](\tau{})+\mathcal{A}_{1,N-1}[\partial{}_{\theta}^{k}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\geq 1}]\Bigr)\end{split}
and
(7.27)
\lVert\Psi{}_{0}\rVert_{L^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq R\})}^{2}\lesssim R^{C_{h}+2}(\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{0}[\Psi{}_{0}](\tau{})+\tilde{E}[\Psi{}_{0}](\tau{})).
For
N\geq 0
,
\tau{}\geq 0
,
0<\delta{}\leq\eta_{h}
, and
r\geq 1
, we have
(7.28)
\lvert r^{1/2}(rL)^{N}\varphi{}_{0}(\tau{},r,\theta{})\rvert^{2}\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[(rL)^{N}\varphi{}_{0}](\tau{})+E[(rL)^{N}\varphi{}_{0}](\tau{})
and
(7.29)
\begin{split}&\lvert r^{1/2}(rL)^{N}\varphi{}_{\geq 1}(\tau{},r,\theta{})\rvert^{2}\lesssim_{N,\delta{}}\sum_{k=0}^{1}\Bigl(\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[\partial{}_{\theta}^{k}\psi{}_{\geq 1}](\tau{})+\tilde{E}[\partial{}_{\theta}^{k}\psi{}_{\geq 1}](\tau{})+\mathcal{A}_{2,N-1}[\partial{}_{\theta}^{k}\Box{}\varphi{}_{\geq 1}]\Bigr).\end{split}
Remark 7.5
.
We could of course formulate an
(rL)
-commuted version of
eq.
7.27
(or an analogue for general scalar fields satisfying
eq.
4.2
), as
well as a corresponding version of
eq.
7.29
, but we do not need
such estimates for the proof of
theorem
3.1
.
Proof.
Step 1: Proof of
eq.
7.25
.
Recall the following estimate for
f\in C_{c}^{\infty}(\mathbf{R}^{2})
:
(7.30)
\lVert f\rVert_{L^{\infty}(\mathbf{R}^{2})}^{2}\lesssim\lVert f\rVert_{L^{2}(\mathbf{R}^{2})}\lVert\Delta f\rVert_{L^{2}(\mathbf{R}^{2})}.
Let
\chi{}(r)
be a cutoff function that is supported on
\{r\leq 2R\}
,
is identically
1
on
\{r\leq R\}
, and satisfies
r\lvert\chi{}^{\prime}(r)\rvert+r^{2}\lvert\chi{}^{\prime\prime}(r)\rvert\lesssim 1
. By applying
eq.
7.30
with
\chi{}\varphi{}
(considered as a function on
\Sigma{}(\tau{})
) in place of
f
and using the expression
\Delta=X^{2}+r^{-1}X+r^{-2}\partial_{\theta}^{2}
and the identity
(7.31)
\Delta(\chi{}\varphi{})=\chi{}\Delta\varphi{}+(\Delta\chi{})\varphi{}+2\chi{}^{\prime}X\varphi{}\implies\lvert\Delta(\chi{}\varphi{})\rvert\lesssim\lvert\Delta\varphi{}\rvert+R^{-2}\lvert\varphi{}\rvert+R^{-1}\lvert X\varphi{}\rvert,
we obtain
(7.32)
\begin{split}&\lVert\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq R\})}^{2}\\
&\lesssim R^{-2}\lVert\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{2}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\})}^{2}+\lVert X\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{2}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\})}^{2}+\lVert\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{2}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\})}\lVert\Delta\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{2}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\})}.\end{split}
where the
L^{2}
norms are with respect to the volume form
r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}
.
Step 1a: Proof of
eq.
7.25
when
N=0
.
In this step we will show that
(7.33)
\begin{split}\lVert\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq R\})}^{2}&\lesssim R^{C_{h}}(\mathcal{E}_{1}[\varphi{}](\tau{})+E[\varphi{}](\tau{})+E[T\varphi{}](\tau{})+E[\partial{}_{\theta}{}\varphi{}](\tau{}))+\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\}}r\lvert\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.\end{split}
First, we have
(7.34)
\begin{split}\lVert\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{2}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\})}^{2}+\lVert X\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{2}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\})}^{2}&=\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\}}\varphi^{2}r+r(X\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim R^{C_{h}+1}\mathcal{E}_{1}[\varphi{}](\tau{},v_{R}(\tau{}))+E[\varphi{}](\tau{},v_{R}(\tau{})).\end{split}
We now estimate the Laplacian by the spatial part of the wave operator in
(\tau{},r)
coordinates, namely
(7.35)
\mathcal{P}\coloneqq{}X^{2}+r^{-1}(1+rG^{-1}G^{\prime})X+A^{2}G^{-2}r^{-2}\partial{}_{\theta}^{2},
which satisfies
(7.36)
G^{-2}\Box{}\varphi{}=\mathcal{P}\varphi{}-hG^{-1}(2-Gh)T^{2}\varphi{}-G^{-1}(2-2Gh)XT\varphi{}+G^{-1}((Gh)^{\prime}-r^{-1}(1-Gh))T\varphi{},
by
eq.
2.21
. In view of the assumptions on
h
and
G
and the
expression
\Delta=X^{2}+r^{-1}X+r^{-2}\partial_{\theta}^{2}
in
(r,\theta{})
coordinates, we have
(7.37)
\Delta=\mathcal{O}(1)\Box{}+\mathcal{O}(1)XT\varphi{}+\mathcal{O}(1)X\varphi{}+\mathcal{O}(1)\partial{}_{\theta}^{2}+\mathcal{O}(1)hT^{2}\varphi{}+\mathcal{O}(\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1})T\varphi{}.
It follows that
(7.38)
\begin{split}&\lVert\Delta\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{2}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\})}^{2}\lesssim R^{C_{h}-2}(E[\varphi{}](\tau{})+E[T\varphi{}](\tau{})+E[\partial{}_{\theta}{}\varphi{}](\tau{}))+\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\}}r\lvert\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.\end{split}
Combining
eqs.
7.34
,
7.38
, and
7.32
we get
eq.
7.33
.
Step 1b: Applying
eq.
7.32
with
(rX)^{N}\varphi{}
for
N\geq 1
in
place of
\varphi{}
.
Let
N\geq 1
. The goal of this step is to show that
(7.39)
\begin{split}&\lVert(rX)^{N}\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{\infty}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq R\})}^{2}\lesssim R^{C_{h}}\!\!\!\!\!\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}0\leq m\leq N\\
k_{1},k_{2}\geq 0\\
k_{1}+k_{2}\leq 1\end{subarray}}E_{N-m}[T^{k_{1}}\partial{}_{\theta}^{k_{2}}T^{m}\varphi{}](\tau{})+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n,m\geq 0\\
n+m\leq N\end{subarray}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\}}r\lvert(rL)^{n}T^{m}\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.\end{split}
We first use
lemma
6.14
and the definition of the constant
C_{h}\geq 2
to estimate
(7.40)
\begin{split}\lVert(rX)^{N}\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{2}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\})}^{2}&\lesssim\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N-1\end{subarray}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\}}[r^{2}(L(rL)^{n_{1}}T^{n_{2}}\varphi{})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{C_{h}}h(T(rL)^{n_{1}}T^{n_{2}}\varphi{})^{2}]r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim R^{C_{h}}\sum_{m=0}^{N-1}E_{N-m-1}[T^{m}\varphi{}](\tau{}).\end{split}
Next, we use
lemma
6.14
to obtain
(7.41)
\begin{split}\lVert X(rX)^{N}\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{2}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\})}^{2}&\lesssim\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1},n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N-1\end{subarray}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\}}[(X(rL)^{n_{1}+1}T^{n_{2}}\varphi{})^{2}+(X(rL)^{n_{1}}T^{n_{2}+1}\varphi{})^{2}]r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim\sum_{m=0}^{N}E_{N-m}[T^{m}\varphi{}](\tau{}).\end{split}
From the commutation formula
[\Delta,rX]=2\Delta
, we obtain
(7.42)
\Delta(rX)^{N}\varphi{}=\sum_{n=0}^{N}C_{n}(rX)^{n}\Delta\varphi{}
for some integers
C_{n}
. It follows from
eqs.
7.42
,
7.37
, and
6.14
that
(7.43)
\begin{split}\lVert\Delta(rX)^{N}\varphi{}\rVert_{L^{2}(\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\})}^{2}&\lesssim\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\}}[(X(rX)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}+(X(rX)^{n}T\varphi{})^{2}+(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\partial{}_{\theta}{}(rX)^{n}\varphi{})^{2}\\
&\qquad+\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-2}(T(rX)^{n}T\varphi{})^{2}+\lvert(rX)^{n}\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}]r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim R^{C_{h}-2}\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}0\leq k_{1},k_{2}\leq 1\\
k_{1}+k_{2}\leq 1\end{subarray}}E_{N}[T^{k_{1}}\partial{}_{\theta}^{k_{2}}\varphi{}](\tau{})+\sum_{n=0}^{N}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\}}r\lvert(rX)^{n}\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
\end{split}
Substituting
eqs.
7.40
,
7.41
, and
7.43
into
eq.
7.32
, we obtain
eq.
7.39
.
Step 1c: Completing the proof.
We established
eq.
7.25
when
N=0
in Step 1a. Let
N\geq 1
.
Lemma
6.14
gives
(7.44)
\begin{split}\lvert(rL)^{N}\varphi{}\rvert&\lesssim\lvert T^{N}\varphi{}\rvert+\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n_{1}\geq 1,n_{2}\geq 0\\
n_{1}+n_{2}\leq N\end{subarray}}\lvert(rX)^{n_{1}}T^{n_{2}}\varphi{}\rvert.\end{split}
Combining this estimate with
eq.
7.39
and
eq.
7.33
applied to
T^{N}\varphi{}
in place of
\varphi{}
, we obtain
eq.
7.25
when
N\geq 1
.
Step 2: Proof of
eq.
7.26
.
Let
\chi{}
be as in Step 1. First, estimate
(7.45)
\begin{split}\lvert X((\chi{}\varphi{})^{2})\rvert&\leq 2\chi^{2}\lvert\varphi{}X\varphi{}\rvert+2\lvert\chi{}\chi{}^{\prime}\rvert\varphi^{2}\lesssim r(X\varphi{})^{2}+r^{-1}\varphi^{2}\lesssim(X\psi{})^{2}+r^{-2}\psi{}^{2}\lesssim(X\psi{})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{C_{h}}h(r)r^{-2}\psi^{2}\\
&\lesssim(L\psi{})^{2}+h^{2}(\underline{L}\psi{})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{C_{h}}h(r)r^{-2}\psi^{2}.\end{split}
Since there are constants
C_{N,n}
such that
(7.46)
r^{1/2}(rL)^{N}\varphi{}=\sum_{n=0}^{N}C_{N,n}(rL)^{n}\psi{},
we obtain from
eq.
7.45
(applied to
(rL)^{N}\varphi{}
in place of
\varphi{}
) the estimate
(7.47)
X((\chi{}(rL)^{N}\varphi{})^{2})\lesssim_{N}\sum_{n=0}^{N}[(L(rL)^{n}\psi{})^{2}+h(r)^{2}(\underline{L}(rL)^{n}\psi{})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{C_{h}}h(r)r^{-2}((rL)^{n}\psi{})^{2}].
Use
eqs.
4.13
,
2.22
, and
7.45
to estimate
(7.48)
\sum_{n=0}^{N}(\underline{L}(rL)^{n}\psi)^{2}\lesssim(\underline{L}\psi{})^{2}+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}[(L(rL)^{n}\psi{})^{2}+r^{-2}((rL)^{n}\psi{})^{2}+r^{-2}(\partial{}_{\theta}{}\partial{}_{\theta}{}(rL)^{n}\psi{})+r^{3}\lvert(rL)^{n}\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}].
Using the fundamental theorem of calculus in the
X
-direction together with
eqs.
7.47
and
7.48
, we find that for
r\leq R
, we
have
(7.49)
\begin{split}\int_{S^{1}}((rL)^{N}\varphi{})^{2}(\tau{},r,\theta{})\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}&\leq\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\}}\lvert X((\chi{}\varphi{})^{2})\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim R^{C_{h}}\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{0,N}[\psi{}](\tau{})+\tilde{E}[\psi{}](\tau{})+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{r\leq 2R\}}r^{3}\lvert(rL)^{n}\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\end{split}
Sobolev embedding on the circle (and
C_{h}\geq 2
) completes the proof of
eq.
7.26
.
Step 3: Proof of
eq.
7.27
.
Let
\chi{}
be as in Step 1. As in Step
2, we estimate
(7.50)
\lvert X((\chi{}\Psi{}_{0})^{2})\rvert\lesssim(L\Psi{}_{0})^{2}+h(r)(\underline{L}\Psi{}_{0})^{2}+\langle{}r\rangle^{C_{h}+2}h(r)r^{-2}\Psi{}_{0}^{2}.
Using the fundamental theorem of calculus in the
X
-direction together with
eq.
7.50
(and the
radial symmetry of
\Psi_{0}
), we obtain
eq.
7.27
.
Step 4: Proof of
eq.
7.28
.
Let
r_{0}\in[1/2,1]
. For
R\geq 1
, the
fundamental theorem of calculus in the
X
-direction gives
(7.51)
\begin{split}\int_{S^{1}}\lvert\psi{}(\tau{},R,\theta{})\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}&\leq\int_{S^{1}}\lvert\psi{}(\tau{},r_{0},\theta{})\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}+\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{1/2\leq r\leq R\}}\lvert X\psi{}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.\end{split}
Since
r
and
h(r)
are comparable to
1
in
\{1/2\leq r\leq 1\}
,
Cauchy–Schwarz gives
(7.52)
\Bigl(\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{1/2\leq r\leq 1\}}\lvert\psi{}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\Bigr)^{2}\lesssim\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{1/2\leq r\leq 1\}}r\langle{}r\rangle^{C_{h}}h\varphi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\lesssim\mathcal{E}_{1}[\varphi{}](\tau{}),
since
R\geq 1
. Use Cauchy–Schwarz, the integrability of
r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}
on
[r_{0},\infty)
for
\delta{}>0
, and
the identity
X=G^{-1}L-hT
to estimate
(7.53)
\begin{split}\Bigl(\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{1/2\leq r\leq R\}}\lvert X\psi{}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\Bigr)^{2}&\leq\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})\cap\{1/2\leq r\leq R\}}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(X\psi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L\psi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}+\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}h(r)r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}\cdot h(r)(T\varphi{})^{2}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[\varphi{}](\tau{})+E[\varphi{}](\tau{}),\end{split}
where in the last line we used
\delta{}\leq\eta_{h}
. Averaging
eq.
7.51
over
r_{0}\in[1/2,1]
and substituting
eqs.
7.52
and
7.53
, we obtain
(7.54)
\Bigl(\int_{S^{1}}\lvert\psi{}(\tau{},r,\theta{})\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\Bigr)^{2}\lesssim\mathcal{E}_{1+\delta{}}[\varphi{}](\tau{})+E[\varphi{}](\tau{}).
The Sobolev embedding
W^{1,1}(S^{1})\hookrightarrow{}L^{\infty}(S^{1})
(which follows from the
fundamental theorem of calculus) combined with
eq.
7.54
applied
to
(rL)^{N}\varphi{}
in place of
\varphi{}
completes the proof.
Step 5: Proof of
eq.
7.29
.
Let
R\geq 1
. Arguing as in Step 3, we
obtain the estimate
(7.55)
\begin{split}\Bigl(\int_{S^{1}}\lvert\psi{}(\tau{},R,\theta{})\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\Bigr)^{2}&\lesssim\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}r\langle{}r\rangle^{\delta}{}(L\psi{})^{2}+h(r)(\underline{L}\psi{})^{2}+h(r)r^{-2}\psi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{}}[\psi{}](\tau{})+\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}h(r)(\underline{L}\psi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\end{split}
Combining this estimate with
eq.
7.48
, we find that for
N\geq 0
, we have
(7.56)
\Bigl(\int_{S^{1}}\lvert(rL)^{N}\psi{}(\tau{},R,\theta{})\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\Bigr)^{2}\lesssim\tilde{\mathcal{E}}_{1+\delta{},N}[\psi{}](\tau{})+\tilde{E}[\psi{}](\tau{})+\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{})}r^{3}\langle{}r\rangle{}^{-1}\lvert(rL)^{n}\Box{}\varphi{}\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}.
To complete the proof, commute the
(rL)^{N}
on the left inside the
r^{1/2}
-weight and use the Sobolev embedding
W^{1,1}(S^{1})\hookrightarrow{}L^{\infty}(S^{1})
(which follows from the
fundamental theorem of calculus).
∎
Proposition 7.6
(Pointwise estimates for the renormalized solution)
.
Let
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
solve
eq.
2.19
, and let
\widehat{\varphi{}}
be
the corresponding renormalized solution defined in
section
6.1.1
.
Let
\gamma{}\coloneqq{}(C_{h}+1)^{-1}
, where
C_{h}\geq 2
(defined in
item
(iv)
of
section
2.3
) determines the polynomial rate
(in the radial coordinate
r
) at which the hyperboloidal foliation
\Sigma{}(\tau{})
becomes null. For
N\geq 0
and
M\geq 0
and
\delta{}>0
sufficiently small, we have
(7.57)
\lvert(rL)^{N}T^{M}\widehat{\varphi{}}(\tau{},r,\theta{})\rvert\lesssim\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}(\tau{},r,\theta{})\cdot(1+\tau{})^{-M-\gamma{}/4}\Bigl(\mathbf{D}_{\min(1,N)+M+4,\delta{}}[\varphi{}]+\sum_{k=0}^{1}\mathbf{D}_{\min(1,N)+M+2,\delta{}}[\partial{}_{\theta}^{k}\varphi{}]\Bigr).
Proof.
Let
R\geq 1
, and let
\delta{}>0
be sufficiently small. Fix
N\geq 0
and
M\geq 0
and write
(7.58)
\mathbf{D}\coloneqq{}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+4,\delta{}}[\varphi{}]+\sum_{k=0}^{1}\mathbf{D}_{N+M+2,\delta{}}[\partial{}_{\theta}^{k}\varphi{}].
Step 1: The case
N\geq 1
.
Writing
\widehat{\varphi{}}=TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}+TT^{-1}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{\geq 1}
and applying
the estimates in
eq.
7.29
(with
\delta{}/5
in place of
\delta{}
) and
proposition
7.3
and estimating the inhomogeneous
terms that arise using
corollary
6.5
, we obtain
(7.59)
\lvert(rL)^{N}T^{M}\widehat{\varphi{}}(\tau{},r,\theta{})\rvert^{2}\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}\begin{cases}R^{C_{h}}(1+\tau{})^{-\min(3,2N+1)-2M+\delta{}}\mathbf{D}&\{r\leq R\},\\
r^{-1}(1+\tau{})^{-2-2M+\delta{}}\mathbf{D}&\{r\geq 1\}.\end{cases}
Taking
R=(1+\tau{})^{\gamma}{}
for
\gamma{}\coloneqq{}(C_{h}+1)^{-1}<1
and using the first
estimate in
\{r\leq R\}
and the second estimate in
\{r\geq R\}
, we
obtain the estimate
(7.60)
\lvert(rL)^{N}T^{M}\widehat{\varphi{}}(\tau{},r,\theta{})\rvert^{2}\lesssim_{N,M,\delta{}}u^{-1}v^{-1}(1+\tau)^{-\gamma{}-2M+\delta{}}\mathbf{D}\quad(N\geq 1),
which proves
eq.
7.57
when
N\geq 1
(after taking
\delta{}<\gamma{}/2
).
Step 2: The case
N=0
.
We now consider the case
N=0
. There are two
reasons we do not argue directly as in the case
N\geq 1
. First, the
right-hand sides of the estimates in
eq.
7.29
do not have
enough
\tau{}
-decay. For example,
eq.
7.25
includes
E[\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}]
when
N=0
, which decays like
\tau^{-2}
,
and so this estimate concludes
\tau^{-1}
decay for
\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
near the origin. However, we need to prove that
\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
decays
faster than
\varphi{}_{\textnormal{mink}}
, which itself decays like
\tau^{-1}
near the origin. More seriously, the right-hand side of
eq.
7.25
when
N=0
includes
\mathcal{E}_{1}[\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}]
, which we do not even control (recall
that we only control
(rL)
-derivatives and
T
-derivatives of the scalar
field in the
\mathcal{E}_{1}
norm, but not the scalar field itself). For this
reason, we use the case
N=0
to control
\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
in the
region
\{r\geq 1\}
by integrating the estimate for
(rL)\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
in the
L
-direction to null infinity, and
integrate an estimate for
\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}\sim r^{1/2}Z\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}
in the
Z
-direction to obtain control in
\{r\leq 1\}
.
From
eq.
7.60
, we have
(7.61)
\lvert LT^{M}\widehat{\varphi{}}(\tau{},r,\theta{})\rvert\lesssim_{M,\delta{}}r^{-1}u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2}(1+\tau)^{-\gamma{}/2-M+\delta{}/2}\mathbf{D}|_{N=1}.
From
eq.
7.59
, we know
T^{M}\widehat{\varphi{}}|_{r=\infty}=0
,
and so we can integrate
eq.
7.61
in the
L
-direction to
null infinity (and use
1+\tau{}\sim u
and
v\sim u+r
) to obtain (in
(u,v)
coordinates)
(7.62)
\lvert T^{M}\widehat{\varphi{}}(u_{0},v_{0},\theta{})\rvert\lesssim_{M,\delta{}}u_{0}^{-1/2-\gamma{}/2-M+\delta{}/2}\mathbf{D}|_{N=1}\cdot\int_{r_{0}}^{\infty}r^{-1}v^{-1/2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r,
where the integral is over a curve of constant
u_{0}
. Let
r_{0}\coloneqq{}r(u_{0},v_{0})\geq 1
. We split the integral into the regions
\{r_{0}\leq r\leq v_{0}/2\}
(where
v\sim u
) and
\{r\geq v_{0}/2\}
(where
v\sim r
). When the first piece exists, we have
u_{0}\sim v_{0}
, and so this
piece contributes logarithmically only in
u_{0}
. The second piece always
contributes like
v_{0}^{-1/2}
. Thus we have
(7.63)
\begin{split}\int_{r_{0}}^{\infty}r^{-1}v^{-1/2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r&\lesssim\mathbf{1}_{r_{0}\leq v_{0}/2}u_{0}^{-1/2}\int_{r_{0}}^{v_{0}/2}r^{-1}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r+\int_{v_{0}/2}^{\infty}r^{-3/2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\lesssim v_{0}^{-1/2}\log u_{0}.\end{split}
Combining
eqs.
7.62
and
7.63
we
obtain
(7.64)
\lvert T^{M}\widehat{\varphi{}}(u,v,\theta{})\rvert\lesssim_{\eta}{}u^{-1/2}v^{-1/2}\cdot u^{-\gamma{}/2-M+\delta{}/2+\eta{}}\mathbf{D}|_{N=1}\quad(r(u,v)\geq 1)
for any
\eta{}>0
, which implies
eq.
7.57
in the region
\{r\geq 1\}
.
We now consider the region
\{r\leq 1\}
. From
eq.
7.27
in
eq.
7.29
(with
R=1
) and
eq.
7.12
, we obtain
(7.65)
\lvert T^{M}\widehat{\Psi{}}_{0}\rvert\lesssim(1+\tau{})^{-5+4\delta{}}\mathbf{D}|_{N=0}\implies\lvert ZT^{M}\widehat{\varphi{}}_{0}\rvert\lesssim r^{-1/2}(1+\tau{})^{-5+4\delta{}}\quad\textnormal{in }\{r\leq 1\}.
Since
r^{-1/2}
is integrable near
\{r=0\}
, we can integrate
eq.
7.65
in the
Z
-direction to
\{r\leq 1\}
(which is
possible when
\tau{}\gg 1
) and use
eq.
7.57
for
N=0
in the region
\{r\geq 1\}
(which we have already obtained) to obtain
eq.
7.57
for
N=0
in the region
\{r\leq 1\}\cap\{\tau{}\gg 1\}
. The result in the region
\{\tau{}\lesssim 1\}
follows
from
eq.
7.59
.
∎
Appendix A
Failure of integrated local energy decay for radially symmetric scalar fields
In this section, we explain why, unlike in
(3+1)
dimensions, in two space dimensions, one cannot control a
zeroth-order bulk term by the
T
-energy. For this reason, the standard
strategy for proving Morawetz estimates in
(3+1)
dimensions, which
provides control of a zeroth-order bulk term, must fail in
(2+1)
dimensions. In particular, in
(2+1)
dimensions one cannot hope to directly
apply the method of Dafermos–Rodnianski
[
DR09
]
to prove
r^{p}
-weighted estimates, since this strategy requires as input an integrated
local energy decay estimate.
The obstruction lies at the level of the radially symmetric part of the scalar
field. The mechanism is the scale invariance of the energy norm in two space
dimensions (namely
k=1
and
p=0
in
proposition
A.1
). As a
consequence, one can only hope to control a zeroth-order term in the bulk if one
allows on the right-hand side an energy with an
r^{p}
-weight with
p\geq 1
(as we do in
section
4.2.2
).
Due to the necessary restriction
p\geq 1
, one can only hope to prove
r^{p}
-weighted estimates on their own, without invoking an integrated local
energy decay statement that controls
\varphi{}
itself by the
T
-energy.
However, as we show in
eq.
4.32
, we can establish an
integrated estimate for
derivatives of
\varphi{}
, provided that one is
willing to include an
r^{p}
-weighted energy of
\Psi{}\coloneqq{}r^{1/2}\partial_{r}\varphi{}
on the right-hand side. This is
the reason that our estimates for radially symmetric scalar fields
\varphi{}
are coupled to the estimates for
\Psi{}
, which is the main innovation in our
argument (see
section
1.2
and in particular
section
1.2.5
for further discussion).
To illustrate the argument, it is convenient to use energies defined on surfaces
of constant
t
.
Proposition A.1
.
For each
T\geq 1
, there exists a radially symmetric function
\varphi_{T}\in C^{\infty}(\mathbf{R}^{2+1})
solving the linear wave equation on Minkowski space
(\mathbf{R}^{2+1},m)
and
arising from compactly supported data on
\{t=0\}
such that for any
p\in[0,1)
and
k\geq 1
, the following estimate holds:
(A.1)
\int_{0}^{T}\int_{\Sigma{}_{t}\cap\{r\leq 1\}}\varphi{}_{T}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}t\gtrsim_{k}T^{2k-1-p}\int_{\mathbf{R}^{2}}(1+r)^{p}(\partial^{k}\varphi{}_{T})^{2}|_{\{t=0\}}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{},
where we write
\Sigma_{t_{0}}\coloneqq{}\{t=t_{0}\}
and
\partial^{k}\varphi_{T}\coloneqq{}\sum_{j=0}^{k}\partial_{t}^{j}\partial_{r}^{k-j}\varphi_{T}
. In particular, there is no uniform
estimate of the form
(A.2)
\int_{0}^{\infty}\int_{\Sigma{}_{t}\cap\{r\leq 1\}}\varphi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}t\lesssim\int_{\Sigma{}_{0}}(\partial{}\varphi{})^{2}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}
for solutions
\varphi{}
to the wave equation on
(\mathbf{R}^{2+1},m)
.
Remark A.2
.
This proposition says that no uniform integrated local energy decay statement
can hold for radially symmetric scalar fields in two space dimensions, even if
one allows small growing weights in time and/or a loss of derivatives on the
right-hand side. As we use in
section
4.1
, this
obstruction does not occur for scalar fields with vanishing radial part, because
there is additional coercivity available from the angular term in the energy, by
way of a Poincaré inequality on
S^{1}
.
Proof.
The proof of this proposition was communicated to the author by Georgios
Moschidis
[
Mos
]
. Fix
\chi{}:[0,\infty)\to[0,1]
such that
\chi{}\equiv 1
on
[0,1]
and
\chi{}\equiv 0
on
[2,\infty)
. Let
\varphi_{T}
be the solution to the wave equation arising
from initial data
(\varphi{}_{T}|_{\{t=0\}},\partial{}_{t}\varphi{}_{T}|_{\{t=0\}})=(\chi{}(r/2T),0)
. Since
\chi{}(r/2T)\equiv 1
on
\{r\leq 2T\}
, the
domain of dependence property for solutions to the wave equation implies that
\varphi_{T}\equiv 1
on
\{r\leq 1\}\cap\{0\leq t\leq T\}\subset\{r\leq 2T-\lvert t\rvert\}
, and so
(A.3)
\int_{0}^{T}\int_{\Sigma{}_{t}\cap\{r\leq 1\}}\varphi{}_{T}^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}t\sim T.
On the other hand, we can compute (using the wave equation
(-\partial_{t}^{2}+\partial_{r}^{2}+r^{-1}\partial_{r})\varphi_{T}=0
to express
\partial_{t}^{2}\varphi_{T}|_{\{t=0\}}
in terms of
\partial_{r}^{2}\varphi_{T}|_{\{t=0\}}
and
r^{-1}\partial_{r}\varphi_{T}|_{\{t=0\}}
, noting that
\partial_{t}\varphi_{T}|_{\{t=0\}}=0
, and using
\Supp\chi{}^{\prime}\subset[1,2]
):
(A.4)
\begin{split}\sum_{j=0}^{k}\int_{\mathbf{R}^{2}}(1+r)^{p}(\partial_{t}^{j}\partial_{r}^{k-j}\varphi_{T})^{2}|_{\{t=0\}}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}&\lesssim_{k}\sum_{j=0}^{k-1}\int_{\mathbf{R}^{2}}(1+r)^{p}r^{-2j}(\partial_{r}^{k-j}\varphi_{T}|_{\{t=0\}})^{2}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim_{k}\sum_{j=0}^{k-1}\int_{2T}^{4T}(1+r)^{p}r^{-2j}(\partial{}_{r}^{k-j}(\chi{}(r/2T)))^{2}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\\
&\lesssim_{k}T^{-2k+2}\sum_{j=0}^{k-1}\int_{1}^{2}(1+2Tx)^{p}\lvert\chi^{(k-j)}(x)\rvert^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}x\\
&\lesssim_{k}T^{-2k+2+p}.\end{split}
In passing from the second line to the third line, we have used the fact that
r\sim T
in the region of integration and that each
r
-derivative of
\chi{}(r/2T)
produces a power of
T^{-1}
.
∎
Appendix B
An exceptional cancellation on Minkowski space and control of a zeroth-order bulk term
In this section, we derive estimates that control a zeroth-order
bulk term associated to a radially symmetric scalar field on exact Minkowski
space
(\mathbf{R}^{2+1},m)
. We do not use these estimates in the proof of
theorem
3.1
, which concerns perturbations of Minkowski space; we aim here
to highlight the special structure in the estimates present on exact Minkowski
space.
As discussed in
appendix
A
, an estimate controlling a
zeroth-order bulk term on Minkowski space must include an
r^{p}
-weighted
energy on the right hand side with
p\geq 1
. The starting point is to prove a
p=1
estimate (see
eq.
B.1
). This is possible on Minkowski space due
to a crucial cancellation in the zeroth-order bulk term, which contributes with
a bad sign for all
p\in(0,2)\setminus\{1\}
. The
p=1
estimate
controls a flux term along ingoing null cones, which we then use to extend the
r^{p}
-weighted estimates to the full range
p\in[1,2)
, albeit with growing
weights in time on the right-hand side for
p>1
(see
eq.
B.17
).
On perturbations of Minkowski space, the cancellation that occurs on Minkowski
space for
p=1
is broken, and so we must treat the zeroth-order term in the
bulk as an error term on the right-hand side. For this reason, we do not prove
r^{p}
-weighted estimates for
\varphi{}
itself. However, we can prove
r^{p}
-weighted estimates for derivatives of
\varphi{}
, and this is enough
to close the argument. See
section
1.2.5
for further
discussion.
Proposition B.1
(
r^{p}
-weighted energy estimate for
p=1
on Minkowski space)
.
Let
f(r)=rg(r)
for
g:[0,\infty)\to\mathbf{R}_{>0}
a
C^{2}
function. Then for any
v\geq 0
and
0\leq\tau_{1}\leq\tau_{2}
, an identity of the following form
holds for radially symmetric functions
\varphi{}\in C^{\infty}(\mathcal{R})
:
(B.1)
\begin{split}&\mathcal{E}_{1}[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{2},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}r(L\varphi{})^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}+\int_{\underline{C}(v)\cap\{\tau{}_{1}\leq\tau{}\leq\tau{}_{2}\}}\varphi^{2}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}u\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\\
&\lesssim\mathcal{E}_{1}[\varphi{}](\tau{}_{1},v)+\int_{\tau{}_{1}}^{\tau{}_{2}}\int_{\Sigma{}(\tau{},v)}\lvert rL\psi{}\rvert\lvert r^{1/2}\Box{}_{m}\varphi{}\rvert\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}r\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\theta{}\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}{}\tau{}.\end{split}
Proof.
This follows immediately from the multiplier identity in
eq.
4.47
with
f(r)\equiv r
(so that
g(r)\equiv 1
). On exact Minkowski space, we
have
G(r)\equiv 1
, and so the zeroth-order term in
eq.
4.47
vanishes.
∎
We now use Hardy’s inequality to prove an estimate that controls a zeroth-order
term in the bulk by the
p=1
energy, using in particular the control of the
flux term on ingoing null cones in
eq.
B.1
. However, this estimate includes
a logarithmic loss in time.
Lemma B.2
(1D Hardy inequality)
.
Fix
a,b\in\mathbf{R}
with
a0
. However, our proof
strategy cannot avoid the “loss in
r
-weights.”
Proof.
Let
0