How Sensor Attacks Transfer Across Lie Groups Rijad Alisic, Saurabh Amin* Abstract Sensor spoofing analysis in cyber-physical systems is predominantly confined to linear state spaces, where attack transferability is trivial. On Lie groups, however, the noncommutativity of the dynamics can distort certain sensor attacks, exposing nominally stealthy attacks during complex maneuvers. We present a geometric framework characterizing when a sensor attack can transfer across operating conditions, preserving both its physical impact and stealthiness. We prove that successful transfer requires the attack to commute with the nominal dynamics (a Lie bracket condition), which isolates transferable attacks to an invariant subspace, while attacks outside this subspace identifiably alter residuals. For small deviations from ideal transferable attacks, our decomposition theorem reveals a fundamental asymmetry: the flow’s Adjoint action amplifies the physical impact of the bracket-violating component. Furthermore, although the attack perturbs the innovation linearly, the accumulated error drift undergoes distortion via the Adjoint action. Finally, we demonstrate how turning maneuvers on a Dubins unicycle collapse the transferable subspace to a single direction, verifying that imperfect attacks remain within theoretical detection bounds. I Introduction Sensor spoofing is a well-documented threat to cyber-physical systems, increasingly exacerbated by their reliance on shared communication infrastructure. Documented incidents range from GPS spoofing of autonomous vehicles and drones [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] , to false data injection disrupting vehicle platoon kinematics [ 5 ] and the dynamical stability of critical infrastructure such as water distribution networks [ 6 ] . The theoretical foundations for such attacks in linear systems have been thoroughly developed [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] . Because additive sensor offsets transfer trivially across operating conditions in geometrically flat Euclidean spaces, existing literature predominantly focuses on detectability and stealthiness [ 11 ] , treating transferability as a non-issue. Many safety-critical systems, however, have nontrivial geometric state spaces: vehicle poses on SE(2) or SE(3) , robot orientations on SO(3) , and nonholonomic vehicles on the Heisenberg group [ 12 ] . While stealthy attack generation has been recently extended to general nonlinear systems using geometric control [ 13 ] , these approaches do not capture the specific algebraic symmetries of Lie groups. Because group operations do not commute, the system’s nonlinear motion can cause the attack to rotate relative to its position: an attack that is stealthy during straight-line driving may become detectable during a turn. Transferability becomes a geometric constraint that must be satisfied jointly with stealthiness. To analyze this, we model the system on a Lie group with left-invariant dynamics [ 14 , 15 ] . This algebraic structure, exploited by the invariant extended Kalman filter (IEKF) and equivariant observers [ 16 , 17 ] for robust filtering, is exploited here by an attacker. Concurrently, behavioral frameworks like DeePC [ 18 , 19 ] demonstrate that observed trajectories can bypass explicit modeling for control, inspiring a data-driven attack perspective [ 20 , 21 , 22 ] . In this paper, we implicitly assume an attacker who can generate such data-driven replay attacks. While somewhat trivial in linear spaces, extending these replay frameworks to non-Euclidean spaces remains fundamentally unexplored, because on general nonlinear systems, injection attacks can be distorted by the dynamics. This paper develops a unified algebraic framework to characterize attack predictability on Lie groups. We answer a fundamental question: what algebraic conditions guarantee that an attack learned in one operating condition retains identical dynamical impact in another? We call such attacks transferable ; if they furthermore evade detection, they are stealthily transferable . By reducing trajectory-level security to finite-dimensional algebraic checks, our contributions are: 1. A formalization of attack equivalence, defining transferability across the state space alongside a new notion of stealth on general manifolds. 2. A Lie-algebraic characterization of transferability, showing both the attack signal and detector deviation must independently reside in the invariant subspace \Delta_{f_{e}}=\ker([f_{e},\,\cdot]) . 3. A decomposition theorem quantifying how bracket-violating residuals alter dynamical impact and stealth through the adjoint action. This decomposition reveals that dynamical impact and stealth both depend on \Delta_{f_{e}} , but are structurally different. When attacks misalign with this subspace, the change in dynamical impact is warped by the adjoint action of the flow acting as a kinematic lever-arm. The change in stealth, conversely, alters the detector state linearly, totally isolated from dynamic amplification; only the accumulated state error is amplified by the adjoint action at the timestep after. This structural duality dictates that small errors made by the attacker may impact the dynamics severely, yet retain bounded stealth deterioration. Furthermore, complex maneuvers collapse this invariant subspace, giving defenders a principled lever to force attacks into detectable directions. The paper is structured as follows. Section II defines the problem setup. Section III derives the Lie algebraic subspace determining invariant transfer. Section IV analyzes deviations from these nominal settings using our decomposition theorem. Section V demonstrates the theory on a Dubins unicycle model, and Section VI concludes the paper. II Problem Setup The state of a general dynamical system naturally evolves on a manifold . To analyze continuous dynamics, we require smooth manifolds, which allow us to define derivatives and tangent velocities. In this work, we focus on a subclass of smooth manifolds with an algebraic structure: Lie groups . II-A Lie Groups Let us introduce some important tools for our analysis. Formally, we define: Definition 1 A Lie group \mathcal{G} is a smooth manifold equipped with smooth group operations: multiplication \mu(g,h)=g\cdot h , identity e\in\mathcal{G} , and inverse g^{-1} . On any smooth manifold, one can define a smooth curve \gamma:\mathbb{R}\to\mathcal{G} . For a curve passing through point g\in\mathcal{G} such that \gamma(0)=g , we define the tangent space at g , denoted \mathcal{T}_{g}\mathcal{G} , as the space of all possible velocity vectors: \mathcal{T}_{g}\mathcal{G}=\{\dot{\gamma}(0)\mid\text{for all }\gamma\text{ where }\gamma(0)=g\} . Example 1 The tangent space \mathcal{T}_{g}\mathcal{G} is a vector space of differential operators . Given a local coordinate chart with coordinates \{x^{i}\}_{i=1}^{n} , the basis vectors of \mathcal{T}_{g}\mathcal{G} are the partial derivatives \{\partial_{x^{i}}\}_{i=1}^{n} . General manifolds rely on local operations like following the flow of a vector field to define movement across the space. Lie groups, however, use a global algebraic rule to define a translation operator T_{g}:\mathcal{G}\to\mathcal{G} , shifting any h\in\mathcal{G} by g\in\mathcal{G} via group multiplication. Example 2 On Lie Groups, the multiplication operator can be used as a translation operator. In particular, for any g\in\mathcal{G} , we can define the • left translation L_{g}:\mathcal{G}\to\mathcal{G} as \mu(g,\cdot) , or the • right translation R_{g}:\mathcal{G}\to\mathcal{G} as \mu(\cdot,g) . Depending on the system, one or the other are used to appropriately model the dynamics. Applying the differential to these translations yields the induced mapping (or pushforward) T_{g*}:\mathcal{T}_{h}\mathcal{G}\to\mathcal{T}_{T_{g}h}\mathcal{G} , which maps tangent vectors from one point to another. Crucially, a tangent vector \dot{\gamma}(0) only strictly lives in the local space \mathcal{T}_{g}\mathcal{G} , which makes comparing dynamics at different points on the manifold mathematically difficult. To compare vectors globally, we push them to the identity e by translating the underlying curve prior to differentiation: T_{g^{-1}*}\dot{\gamma}(0)=\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}\bigg|_{t=0}\bigl(T_{g^{-1}}\gamma(t)\bigr)\in\mathcal{T}_{e}\mathcal{G}. We denote this tangent space at the identity as \mathfrak{g}=\mathcal{T}_{e}\mathcal{G} . By equipping this vector space with the Lie bracket [\cdot,\cdot]:\mathfrak{g}\times\mathfrak{g}\to\mathfrak{g} we form the Lie algebra , which we equip with a norm \|\cdot\|_{\mathfrak{g}} . The Lie algebra is useful thanks to the existence and uniqueness of its one-parameter subgroup. In particular, for a \xi\in\mathfrak{g} , the ordinary differential equation \dot{\gamma}(t)=T_{\gamma(t)*}\xi,\quad\gamma(0)=e, has a unique solution which we denote as \gamma(t)=\exp(t\xi) . We can then define the unit displacement of \xi as this curve evaluated at t=1 , namely \gamma(1)=\exp(\xi) . These curves in the one-parameter subgroup can then be translated to g through T_{g}\exp(t\xi)\in\mathcal{G} . To understand how this translation affects the curve, we use the conjugate map c^{T}_{g}:\mathcal{G}\to\mathcal{G} , defined for any h\in\mathcal{G} by c^{T}_{g}(h)=T_{g}T_{h}T_{g^{-1}}e . The adjoint action \mathrm{Ad}^{T}_{g}:\mathfrak{g}\to\mathfrak{g} is then \mathrm{Ad}^{T}_{g}\,\xi\;:=\;\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}\bigg|_{t=0}c^{T}_{g}\bigl(\exp(t\xi)\bigr)\;\in\;\mathfrak{g}, (1) which computes how \xi is transformed under conjugation. Furthermore, we define the induced operator norm as \|\mathrm{Ad}^{T}_{g}\|:=\sup_{\|\xi\|_{\mathfrak{g}}=1}\|\mathrm{Ad}^{T}_{g}\xi\|_{\mathfrak{g}} . II-B Dynamical Systems on Lie Groups Consider a curve x(t)\in\mathcal{G} arising from the dynamics \dot{x}(t)=f(x,u),\quad x(0)=x_{0}. (2) We assume the dynamics are T -invariant, meaning f(x,u)=T_{x*}f(e,u) . Under zero-order hold conditions where the input u is held constant , we define f_{e}(u)\coloneqq f(e,u)\in\mathfrak{g} . We write the exact solution over this interval as x(t)=T_{\exp\bigl(f_{e}(u)\,t\bigr)}x(0). (3) This integration forms the basis of our discrete-time model, x_{k}=x(t_{k}) , which naturally arises because the system we consider is sampled at discrete intervals. Specifically, we consider a deterministic observation map h\colon\mathcal{G}\to\mathbb{R}^{m} : z_{k}=h(x_{k}). (4) These measurements z_{k} are subsequently used to determine the next control input u_{k} , or fed into a detector to maintain a state estimate \hat{x}_{k} . The measurements are the attacker’s point of entry. In particular, the attacker modifies the measurements through the following mechanism. Definition 2 For a\in\mathcal{G} , the map \tilde{T}_{g}\colon\mathbb{R}^{m}\to\mathbb{R}^{m} defined by \tilde{T}_{a}h(x)\;=\;h(T_{a}x), (5) is called an observation action . While the spoofing operator \tilde{T}_{a} may be simple to apply in isolation, for instance by adding fixed biases to sensor readings, it is only physically consistent spoofing operators that are observation actions, as shown in the next example. Example 3 The induced map \tilde{T}_{g} models changes to sensor measurements. While isolated GPS spoofing ( x,y translations) or isolated LIDAR spoofing (forward f , lateral l translations) are trivially observation actions, mixed sensor suites require geometric coordination. For h(x)=\begin{bmatrix}x&y&f&l\end{bmatrix}^{\top} , a spoofing attack \tilde{T}_{a}h(x)=h(x)+\begin{bmatrix}a_{x}&a_{y}&a_{f}&a_{l}\end{bmatrix}^{\top} is only a valid observation action if a_{x}=a_{f}\cos\theta-a_{l}\sin\theta and a_{y}=a_{f}\sin\theta+a_{l}\cos\theta , ensuring \tilde{T}_{a}h(x)=h(T_{a}x) . As demonstrated, physically realizing an observation action requires state-dependent knowledge. Analytically computing these modifications is prohibitive in modern systems featuring thousands of sensors with disparate modalities, as they create hard-to-model implicit dependencies. Analytically computing these modifications is prohibitive in systems with complex sensor interdependencies. To keep matters general, we simply assume that an approximate observation action is learned from data. Specifically, let \{x^{D}_{k}\}_{k=0}^{N-1} be a nominal trajectory starting at x^{D}_{0}\in\mathcal{G} . We define the attack dataset as a collection of M experiments \mathcal{D}^{a}_{x_{0}^{D}}\;=\;\Bigl\{\!\bigl\{(z^{D}_{k},\;z_{k}^{a,(i)})\bigr\}_{k=0}^{N-1}\!\Bigr\}_{i=1}^{M}, (6) where z^{D}_{k}=h(x^{D}_{k}) and z_{k}^{a,(i)}=h(T_{\exp(\xi_{k}^{a,(i)})}x^{D}_{k}) . Here, attacks are modeled via one-parameter subgroups \xi_{k}^{a,(i)}\in\mathfrak{g} . The attacker leverages this dataset to construct an approximation of the observation action \tilde{T}_{a} , which can then be deployed to manipulate a victim’s sensor stream. The attacker’s goal is to use \mathcal{D}^{a}_{x_{0}^{D}} to synthesize attacks \tilde{T}_{a} that induce a predictable change (preserving dynamical impact ) while evading detection (remaining stealthy ). We now define both properties. Definition 3 Consider a nominal trajectory x_{0},x_{1},\dots with x_{k+1}=T_{\exp(f_{e}(u_{k}))}x_{k} , and an attacked trajectory x_{k}^{a}=T_{\exp(\xi_{k})}x_{k} for displacements \xi_{k}\in\mathfrak{g} . The local change induced by the attack is d_{k}^{local}=c^{T}_{x_{k-1}}c^{T}_{\exp(f_{e}(u_{k}))}\exp(\xi_{k})\in\mathcal{G}, where c^{T}_{g} is the conjugation operator from ( 1 ). Since d_{k}^{local} depends on the specific trajectory via the state x_{k-1} , we define the dynamical impact as the state-independent part of d_{k}^{local} : d_{k}:=c^{T}_{\exp(f_{e}(u_{k}))}\exp(\xi_{k})\in\mathcal{G}. (7) Two attack sequences \{\xi_{k}^{1}\} and \{\xi_{k}^{2}\} have the same dynamical impact if d_{k}^{1}=d_{k}^{2} for all k . An attack displacement \xi\in\mathfrak{g} is transferable if the attack synthesized from the nominal trajectory has the same dynamical impact when applied to the victim’s trajectory. To model detection, we define the observation displacement \eta_{k}\in\mathfrak{g} between the true state x_{k} and the detector’s estimate \hat{x}_{k} as: \hat{x}_{k}=T_{\exp(\eta_{k})}x_{k}. To preserve the geometric structure, this displacement updates multiplicatively: \exp(\eta_{k})=T_{\exp\big(K(I_{k})\big)}\exp\bigl(\mathrm{Ad}_{\exp(f_{e}(u_{k-1}))}^{T}\eta_{k-1}\bigr) where K:\mathbb{R}^{m}\to\mathfrak{g} is an update function on the innovation I_{k} . Under an equivariant observer framework, the innovation uses a geometrically invariant state error. Given the predicted state \hat{x}_{k|k-1}=T_{\exp(f_{e}(u_{k-1}))}\hat{x}_{k-1} and the attacked measurement \tilde{T}_{a_{k}}h(x_{k})=h(T_{a_{k}}x_{k}) , the invariant innovation is: I_{k}\coloneqq h\bigl(T_{\hat{x}_{k|k-1}^{-1}}T_{a_{k}}x_{k}\bigr)-h(e). This construction inherently cancels the global reference frame. Trajectories differing only by a shared transformation yield the exact same sequence of innovations, entirely avoiding restrictive linear assumptions on h . Since the attack enters the detector solely through I_{k} , detection is triggered evaluating its magnitude, \|I_{k}\| . We can now define stealth formally. Definition 4 Let a_{k}\in\mathcal{G} be an attack translation at time k . Under the equivariant observer framework, the attack a_{k} is: 1. undetectable if h\bigl(T_{\hat{x}_{k|k-1}^{-1}}T_{a_{k}}x_{k}\bigr)=h(e) . 2. \tau -stealthy if \bigl\|h\bigl(T_{\hat{x}_{k|k-1}^{-1}}T_{a_{k}}x_{k}\bigr)-h(e)\bigr\|\leq\tau . Given these definitions, we are ready to state the problem. Problem 1 Suppose an attacker learns a \tau -stealthy observation action \tilde{T}_{a} from a dataset \mathcal{D}^{a}_{x_{0}^{D}} . Under what conditions can this sensor injection \tilde{T}_{a} be transferred to an arbitrary victim state x\neq x_{0}^{D} while preserving its dynamical impact and \tau -stealth? To address Problem 1 , the remainder of this paper assumes left-invariant dynamics and models attacks as right translations , T_{\exp(\xi)}x=R_{\exp(\xi)}x=x\exp(\xi) . We adopt this convention because it naturally captures body-frame sensor displacements in standard robotics models (e.g., SE(2) and SE(3) ). Equivalent results for right-invariant dynamics or left-translation attacks follow directly by symmetry and are omitted for brevity. III Transfer Conditions Because the attacker’s primary mechanism requires the sensor to convincingly spoof the system state to a different pose, we first analyze how this right-translation spoofing alters the apparent state. III-A Invariant State Transfer The immediate question is to determine the conditions under which attacks that displace the state apply consistently across a range of scenarios. The next proposition applies a classic Lie group equivalence to answer this question. Proposition 1 Let a_{k}=\exp(\xi_{k})\in\mathcal{G} denote the state displacement induced by the sensor attack \tilde{R}_{a_{k}}h(x_{k})=h(x_{k}a_{k}) , and let g_{k-1}:=\exp(f_{e}(u_{k-1})) . The dynamical impact of \xi_{k} is the same for all g_{k-1} if and only if [f_{e}(u_{k-1}),\,\xi_{k}]=0. (8) Proof: Let f:=f_{e}(u_{k-1}) for brevity. The dynamical impact from ( 7 ) is d_{k}=g_{k-1}^{-1}\exp(\xi_{k})g_{k-1}=\exp(\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\xi_{k}) . Thus, d_{k} is independent of g_{k-1} if and only if \mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\xi_{k}=\xi_{k} . Consider the curve \phi(s):=\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{\exp(sf)}\xi_{k} . Its derivative is the linear ODE \dot{\phi}(s)=-[f,\phi(s)] with \phi(0)=\xi_{k} [ 23 ] . Since [f,\cdot] is a bounded linear operator on the finite-dimensional space \mathfrak{g} , the Picard-Lindelöf theorem guarantees a unique global solution. Because [f,\xi_{k}]=0 , the curve \phi(s)=\xi_{k} satisfies the ODE, yielding \mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\xi_{k}=\phi(1)=\xi_{k} . Conversely, if \mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\xi_{k}=\xi_{k} , the curve is constant, and the derivative at s=0 directly yields [f,\xi_{k}]=0 . ∎ Essentially, an attack parametrized by \xi_{k}\in\mathfrak{g} need only commute with the zero-order hold dynamics f_{e}(u_{k-1}) . This contrasts starkly with linear systems, where operations intrinsically commute, yielding trivially zero Lie brackets ( [f_{e},\xi]\equiv 0 ) and universally state-invariant attacks. On general Lie groups, however, operations do not commute, meaning attacks are only invariant across specific steady maneuvers generated by u_{k-1} . Furthermore, Proposition 1 extends naturally to attacks that are compositions of one-parameter subgroup elements: Corollary 1 Let a_{k}=\prod_{i}\exp(\xi_{k}^{i})\in\mathcal{G} . The dynamical impact of a_{k} is the same for all g_{k-1} if [f_{e}(u_{k-1}),\xi_{k}^{i}]=0,\,\forall i . Remark 1 Condition ( 8 ) requires that conjugations for the nominal and victim dynamics agree: \exp(\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}^{N}}\xi_{k})=\exp(\xi_{k})=\exp(\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}^{V}}\xi_{k}), since [f_{e}(u_{k-1}),\xi_{k}]=0 implies \mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\xi_{k}=\xi_{k} . III-B Invariance The attack displacements \exp(\xi) admit a degree of generalizability: there is a family of one-parameter maneuvers, characterized via the Lie bracket, that commute with any one-parameter subgroup attack. Conversely, each maneuver generated by f_{e} admits a family of transferable attacks with the same dynamical impact, defined as follows. The set of attacks satisfying ( 8 ) forms the invariant subset for a given f_{e}:=f_{e}(u_{k})\in\mathfrak{g} , defined as \Delta_{f_{e}}=\ker([f_{e},\cdot])=\{\xi\in\mathfrak{g}\mid[f_{e},\xi]=0\}\subset\mathfrak{g}. (9) By Proposition 1 , every \xi\in\Delta_{f_{e}} transfers invariantly to every x\in\mathcal{G} . Crucially, \Delta_{f_{e}} depends only on the dynamics f_{e}(u_{k-1}) , not on the state x\in\mathcal{G} . An attacker wishing to learn transferable attacks need not know where on the state manifold the system currently is, nor know the exact input u_{k-1} that was applied, but only whether the chosen \xi lies in \Delta_{f_{e}} for the input the system may currently be applying. Example 4 Consider a Dubins car with f_{e}=ve_{f}+\omega e_{\theta} , where e_{f},e_{l} , and e_{\theta} are the forward, lateral, and heading generators of SE(2) . For a displacement attack \xi=ae_{f}+be_{l}+ce_{\theta} , the condition [f_{e},\xi]=0 expands to: [ve_{f}+\omega e_{\theta},\;ae_{f}+be_{l}+ce_{\theta}]=-\omega be_{f}+(\omega a-vc)e_{l}=0. For straight motion ( \omega=0,v\neq 0 ), this requires c=0 , leaving a and b free. Thus, \Delta_{f_{e}}=\mathrm{span}(e_{f},e_{l}) , as illustrated by the purely lateral spoof in the top plot of Figure 1 . Conversely, for curved motion ( \omega\neq 0 ), the condition yields b=0 and a=\frac{v}{\omega}c , meaning \xi=c(\frac{v}{\omega}e_{f}+e_{\theta}) . The only transferable attacks are displacements strictly along the trajectory as seen in the purple arrows in the bottom plot of Figure 1 . Purely body-consistent (red) or world-consistent (green) offsets fail to commute ( \notin\Delta_{f_{e}} ) and distort the observed kinematics. Fig. 1 : Visualization of the commuting subspace \Delta_{f_{e}} . (Top) A constant lateral attack perfectly commutes during straight-line motion. (Bottom) During turns, only spoofing along the nominal trajectory (purple) remains in \Delta_{f_{e}} . Inconsistent attacks, such as purely body-frame (red) or global (green) offsets, fail to commute and cause observable distortions. Note that \Delta_{f_{e}} is a Lie subalgebra , meaning that [\xi,\eta]\in\Delta_{f_{e}} for all \xi,\eta\in\Delta_{f_{e}} , which follows from the Jacobi identity: [f_{e},\,[\xi,\eta]]=-[\xi,\,[\eta,f_{e}]]-[\eta,\,[f_{e},\xi]]=-[\xi,\,0]-[\eta,\,0]=0. (10) As an involutive distribution, the Frobenius theorem guarantees it generates a unique, connected integral manifold (or leaf) through each x\in\mathcal{G} . Provided the subgroup H=\exp(\Delta_{f_{e}}) is closed in \mathcal{G} , the group is partitioned into disjoint cosets H_{x}=x\cdot H . Corollary 2 For all \xi_{0}\in\Delta_{f_{e}} , the attacked state x\cdot\exp(\xi_{0}) remains within the leaf H_{x} passing through x . Proof: Involutivity ( 10 ) ensures the flow of \xi_{0} stays tangent to the manifold H_{x} . Thus, \exp(\xi_{0}) restricts the state to the local leaf H_{x} , which coincides with the global coset xH if H is a closed subgroup. ∎ Conceptually, Corollary 2 reveals that invariant transferability fundamentally restricts reachability. To guarantee identical dynamical impacts across all absolute states, the attacker is restricted to commuting perturbations. This eliminates \dim(\mathfrak{g})-\dim(\Delta_{f_{e}}) degrees of freedom, inherently confining the spoofed state to H_{x} . Since H_{x} is entirely parameterized by the control input f_{e}(u_{k}) , the defender can implement a moving target defense. By actively sequencing u_{k} to collapse the dimension of \Delta_{f_{e}} , the system structurally neutralizes the attacker’s ability to arbitrarily manipulate the state with transferable attacks. III-C Observational Transfer To reliably anticipate the detector’s reaction across varying trajectories, an attack must consistently induce a similar sequence of innovations I_{k} and accumulated detector drift \eta_{k}\in\Delta_{f_{e}} as it did on the nominal trajectory. Recall from Definition 4 that the equivariant observer framework natively respects the state space geometry by deriving innovations from the invariant error E_{k} . Leveraging this structure, the exact algebraic conditions for stealthy transfer are established below. Proposition 2 Let a_{k}=\exp(\xi_{k})\in\mathcal{G} be the attack-induced state displacement, yielding measurements \tilde{R}_{a_{k}}h(x_{k})=h(x_{k}a_{k}) . Let g_{k-1}=\exp(f_{e}) denote the victim’s one-step dynamics. If the victim dynamics commute with the historical detector drift, [\eta_{k-1},f_{e}]=0, (11) then the innovation sequence I_{k} remains identical to that of the nominal trajectory. Consequently, an attack engineered to be stealthy on the nominal trajectory remains stealthy under any such commuting dynamics. Proof: In an equivariant observer the innovation is evaluated on the invariant state error E_{k}=\hat{x}_{k}^{-1}x_{k} . Let the attacked state be x_{k}=x_{k-1}g_{k-1}a_{k} and the estimated state be \hat{x}_{k|k-1}=x_{k-1}\exp(\eta_{k-1})g_{k-1} , where \eta_{k-1}\in\mathfrak{g} encodes the detector drift. We first establish that the bracket condition ( 11 ) implies group-level commutativity. Let f:=f_{e} for brevity. The curve \psi(s):=\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{\exp(sf)}\eta_{k-1} satisfies the linear ODE \dot{\psi}(s)=-[f,\,\psi(s)] , with initial condition \psi(0)=\eta_{k-1}. Since [f,\eta_{k-1}]=0 by hypothesis ( 11 ), the unique solution guaranteed by Picard-Lindelöf is the constant curve \psi(s)\equiv\eta_{k-1} . Evaluating at s=1 gives \mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\eta_{k-1}=\eta_{k-1} , which expands to g_{k-1}^{-1}\exp(\eta_{k-1})g_{k-1}=\exp(\eta_{k-1}) , or equivalently, \exp(\eta_{k-1})\,g_{k-1}=g_{k-1}\,\exp(\eta_{k-1}). Substituting this into the error equation gives E k = ( x k-1 exp( η k-1 )g k-1 ) -1 (x k-1 g k-1 a k ) = g k-1 -1 exp(- η k-1 )g k-1 a k = exp(- η k-1 ) a k . The resulting innovation I_{k}=h(E_{k})-h(e)=h(\exp(-\eta_{k-1})a_{k})-h(e) is completely independent of the victim dynamics g_{k-1} , preserving stealth for any dynamics satisfying ( 11 ). ∎ Predictable stealth requires that the observer’s state drift due to the attack \eta_{k}\in\Delta_{f_{e}} . Because nominal unattacked drift is typically negligible, \eta_{k-1} is overwhelmingly driven by the attacker’s past injections. This reveals that stealth is not an instantaneous property: the attacker’s historical footprint must continuously commute with the system’s subsequent dynamics. While an attacker cannot realistically verify [\eta_{k-1},f_{e}]=0 online, Condition ( 11 ) establishes the fundamental geometric boundary for transferability. IV Main Results The previous section characterized ideal transfer conditions. In practice, the attacker faces informational and physical limitations: the true motion g_{k-1} is never perfectly known, meaning the invariant subspace \Delta_{f_{e}} cannot be explicitly computed. Rather than modeling the attacker’s specific data-driven estimation errors individually, we analytically absorb these limitations into a single geometric decomposition. We separate the empirically realized attack \hat{\xi}_{k} and detector drift \hat{\eta}_{k} onto the true, unknown subspaces: \hat{\xi}_{k}=\underbrace{\xi_{k}}_{\in\Delta_{f_{e}}}+\underbrace{\rho^{\xi}_{k}}_{\not\in\Delta_{f_{e}}}, (12) and similarly for the detector drift, \hat{\eta}_{k}=\underbrace{\eta_{k}}_{\in\Delta_{f_{e}}}+\underbrace{\rho^{\eta}_{k}}_{\not\in\Delta_{f_{e}}}, (13) Here, \xi_{k},\eta_{k}\in\Delta_{f_{e}} are the ideal invariantly transferable components. The bracket-violating residuals \rho^{\xi}_{k},\rho^{\eta}_{k} mathematically capture the attacker’s fundamental ignorance of the true dynamics, alongside sensor noise and trajectory mismatches. Definition 5 An attack dataset \mathcal{D}^{a}_{x_{0}^{D}} is \epsilon -rich with respect to \Delta_{f_{e}} if its empirical samples yield components such that: 1. The ideal components \{\xi_{k}^{a,(i)}\}_{i=1}^{M} span \Delta_{f_{e}}\subset\mathfrak{g} , and 2. The residual errors satisfy \|\rho^{\xi,(i)}_{k}\|\leq\epsilon for all i,k . Intuitively, an \epsilon -rich dataset guarantees that the attacker has empirically collected a sufficiently diverse set of noisy base attacks to implicitly span the required geometric degrees of freedom, while ensuring that the worst-case leakage caused by their ignorance of \Delta_{f_{e}} is strictly bounded by \epsilon . With these bounded residual errors defined, we now evaluate the change in impact and sensory footprint of transferring an attack. Theorem 1 Let \mathcal{D}^{a}_{x_{0}^{D}} be an \epsilon -rich attack dataset. Suppose an attacker extracts a sensor attack \tilde{T}_{a_{k}} where a_{k}=\exp(\hat{\xi}_{k}) , and applies it to the victim’s measurements such that \tilde{y}_{k}=\tilde{T}_{a_{k}}h(x_{k})=h(x_{k}a_{k}) . Then, the transferred attack exhibits the following properties: 1. Dynamical impact. The dynamical impact of the realized attack \hat{\xi}_{k} satisfies d_{k}=\exp(\xi_{k}+\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\rho^{\xi}_{k}), (14) with deviation bounded by \|\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\rho^{\xi}_{k}\|\leq\epsilon\|\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\| . 2. Stealth deviation. Under an equivariant observer, the realized invariant state error E_{k} evaluates to: E_{k}=\exp\bigl(-(\eta_{k-1}+\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\rho^{\eta}_{k-1})\bigr)\exp(\xi_{k}+\rho^{\xi}_{k}), (15) yielding the realized innovation I_{k}=h(E_{k})-h(e) . Proof: 1) Dynamical impact: Recall the dynamical impact d_{k}=g_{k-1}^{-1}\exp(\hat{\xi}_{k})g_{k-1} . Applying the Adjoint mapping property gives d_{k}=\exp(\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\hat{\xi}_{k}) . Substituting the decomposition \hat{\xi}_{k}=\xi_{k}+\rho^{\xi}_{k} and using linearity of \mathrm{Ad} yields d_{k}=\exp(\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\xi_{k}+\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\rho^{\xi}_{k}) . Since \xi_{k}\in\Delta_{f_{e}} , it commutes with the nominal flow, so \mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\xi_{k}=\xi_{k} , and ( 14 ) follows. 2) Stealth deviation: In an equivariant observer, the innovation is evaluated on the invariant state error E_{k}=\hat{x}_{k|k-1}^{-1}x_{k} , such that I_{k}=h(E_{k})-h(e) . Substituting the attacked state x_{k}=x_{k-1}g_{k-1}\exp(\hat{\xi}_{k}) and the estimated state \hat{x}_{k|k-1}=x_{k-1}\exp(\hat{\eta}_{k-1})g_{k-1} yields: E_{k}=\bigl(x_{k-1}\exp(\hat{\eta}_{k-1})g_{k-1}\bigr)^{-1}\bigl(x_{k-1}g_{k-1}\exp(\hat{\xi}_{k})\bigr). Expanding the inverse and grouping the g_{k-1} terms allows us to apply the Adjoint action: \displaystyle E_{k} \displaystyle=g_{k-1}^{-1}\exp(-\hat{\eta}_{k-1})g_{k-1}\exp(\hat{\xi}_{k}) \displaystyle=\exp(-\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\hat{\eta}_{k-1})\exp(\hat{\xi}_{k}). Applying the decompositions \hat{\xi}_{k}=\xi_{k}+\rho^{\xi}_{k} and \hat{\eta}_{k-1}=\eta_{k-1}+\rho^{\eta}_{k-1} , and noting that \mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\eta_{k-1}=\eta_{k-1} since \eta_{k-1}\in\Delta_{f_{e}} , we directly obtain the realized state error ( 15 ). ∎ Equations ( 14 ) and ( 15 ) show that without residuals, the attack transfers perfectly. Otherwise, dynamical deviation is bounded by \epsilon\|\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\| and stealth deviation gains drift via \mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\rho^{\eta}_{k-1} . Equation ( 15 ) also reveals a loophole: an unpredictable attack can stay stealthy if h(E_{k})=h(\tilde{E}_{k}) , where \tilde{E}_{k}\coloneqq\exp(-\eta_{k-1})\exp(\xi_{k}) is the ideal error. This mimics the linear case where residual errors in E_{k} map to the same sensory footprint as the ideal error. Remark 2 Theorem 1 exposes a fundamental asymmetry. While dynamical impact scales with the system’s absolute configuration due to \mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\rho^{\xi}_{k} , stealth deviation benefits from the equivariant framework. The dynamics g_{k-1} are absorbed into the Adjoint conjugation of the drift, keeping the detector’s innovation frame-independent. V Numerical Example Consider a Dubins car with state z=(x,y,\theta)\in SE(2) , whose continuous-time dynamics in global coordinates are \dot{x}=v\cos\theta,\quad\dot{y}=v\sin\theta,\quad\dot{\theta}=\omega, (16) or equivalently in the body frame, \dot{z}=z(ve_{f}+\omega e_{\theta}) , so f_{e}=ve_{f}+\omega e_{\theta}\in\mathfrak{se}(2) . The vehicle measures its position via a GPS-like sensor and a LIDAR-like odometry sensor, yielding the mixed sensor suite h(z)=[x,y,f_{s},l_{s}]^{\top} . Let the nominal training trajectory move straight along the global x -axis ( \theta=0 , \omega=0 ), expanding the commuting subspace to \Delta_{f_{e}}=\mathrm{span}(e_{f},e_{l}) (Example 4 ). Starting at t=60 s, the attacker observes a multi-modal lateral deviation \Delta h=[0,10,0,10]^{\top} . Because the global and body frames align when \theta=0 , this combined sensor drift maps directly to the right-invariant local displacement \xi_{k}=[0,10,0]^{\top}\in\mathfrak{se}(2) for k\geq 60 . To deploy this learned displacement against a victim on an arbitrary trajectory, simply replaying the constant bias \Delta h would violate physical consistency between the global and local sensors. Instead, the attacker dynamically coordinates the spoofing vector using their heading estimate \hat{\theta} : h(z^{V}_{\text{attacked}})=h(z^{V})+\begin{bmatrix}-10\sin\hat{\theta}&10\cos\hat{\theta}&0&10\end{bmatrix}^{\top}. (17) This orientation-dependent update successfully realizes the multi-sensor observation action \tilde{T}_{a}h(z^{V})=h(z^{V}T_{\exp(\xi_{k})}) . Proposition 1 and Theorem 1 state that attack transferability and impact are governed by \Delta_{f_{e}} and the Adjoint operator \mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}} of the one-step flow g_{k-1}=\exp(f_{e}\Delta t) . For any Dubins maneuver, along-trajectory displacements inherently lie in the commuting subspace \Delta_{f_{e}} . As Figure 2 illustrates, this invariant attack smoothly “drags” the detector bias forward along the predicted path. In practice, synthesized attacks may introduce out-of-subspace residuals \rho^{\xi}_{k}\notin\Delta_{f_{e}} . Their amplification is dictated by the Adjoint operator of the local flow g_{k-1}=(p_{f},p_{l},p_{\theta})\in SE(2) : \mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}=\begin{bmatrix}\cos p_{\theta}&-\sin p_{\theta}&p_{l}\\ \sin p_{\theta}&\cos p_{\theta}&-p_{f}\\ 0&0&1\end{bmatrix}, (18) with the induced 2-operator norm yielding \|\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\|_{2}=\frac{1}{2}\left(r+\sqrt{r^{2}+4}\right) , where r=\sqrt{p_{f}^{2}+p_{l}^{2}} is the translational magnitude. This directly provides the dynamical impact bound \|\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\rho^{\xi}_{k}\|_{2}\leq\epsilon\|\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\|_{2} from Theorem 1 . Mismatches in the heading direction excite the last column, which is scaled by the potentially large spatial displacements p_{f} and p_{l} . The visual result is that the actual noisy spatial deviation is guaranteed to stay within the theoretical Adjoint bound, plotted as the dashed blue circles in Figure 2 . Crucially, for a lateral residual \rho^{\xi}_{k}=[0,\epsilon,0]^{\top} , the last column is not excited: \mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\rho^{\xi}_{k}=\begin{bmatrix}-\epsilon\sin p_{\theta}\\ \epsilon\cos p_{\theta}\\ 0\end{bmatrix}. (19) These zero entries bypass the translational parameters p_{f} and p_{l} entirely. The residual merely rotates, preserving its exact magnitude \epsilon and shielding the attack from amplification. Consider the simulated victim at t=20.0 s, where v=13.96 m/s and \omega=-1.02 rad/s over \Delta t=0.5 s, yielding local integration parameters p_{f}=3.316 m, p_{l}=-0.408 m, p_{\theta}=-0.245 rad and \|\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\|_{2}=3.618 . The attacker targets \xi_{\text{ideal}}=\alpha f_{e}=[3.350,\,0,\,-0.245]^{\top}\in\Delta_{f_{e}} with \alpha=0.3 , and injects a lateral residual \rho^{\xi}_{k}=[0,\epsilon,0]^{\top} with \epsilon=0.44 . By ( 19 ), the residual merely rotates under the Adjoint, giving \|\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\rho^{\xi}_{k}\|_{2}=\epsilon=0.44 , well within the conservative bound \epsilon\|\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\|_{2}=1.59 . The effective displacement is \xi_{\text{eff}}=\xi_{\text{ideal}}+\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k-1}}\rho^{\xi}_{k}=\begin{bmatrix}3.350\\ 0\\ -0.245\end{bmatrix}+\begin{bmatrix}0.107\\ 0.427\\ 0\end{bmatrix}=\begin{bmatrix}3.457\\ 0.427\\ -0.245\end{bmatrix}, (20) remaining close to \exp(\xi_{\text{ideal}}) and confirming that a lateral residual incurs no Adjoint amplification despite the large translational parameters p_{f} and p_{l} . The realized deviations (orange) in Figure 2 remain strictly within the total bound (dashed blue) at every time step, never breaching the detection threshold \tau=5.0 m (dashed green). Fig. 2 : Estimator drift under the spoofed attack over a curved trajectory. The true path (blue) diverges from the spoofed measurement (red dashed) by the injected attack vectors (arrows), while the detector prediction (brown dots) is dragged along the spoofed signal. Realized spoofing deviations (orange) remain within the total theoretical bound (dashed blue) at all times. The steady-state tracking error stays below the detection threshold \tau=5.0 m (dashed green), confirming \tau -stealthiness. The zoomed inset highlights that lateral residuals preserve their magnitude under the Adjoint, preventing amplification regardless of vehicle velocity. Figure 3 isolates the structural design from noise over time. During training (dotted lines), the detector innovation remains strictly below the dynamical impact: the equivariant estimator tracks the spoofed signal so faithfully that its residual understates the true spatial displacement, justifying dynamical impact as the primary stealth metric. Upon transfer with residual \epsilon=0.44 , the innovation (solid brown) transiently exceeds the physical impact (solid orange) as accumulated noise disrupts tracking. Despite this, both quantities remain within the total bound \|\xi_{\text{ideal}}\|+\epsilon\|\text{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k}}\|_{2} (dashed blue), which peaks at \tau=5.0 m, confirming that the training margin is sufficient to maintain \tau -stealthiness throughout deployment at the victim. Fig. 3 : Nominal dynamical impact and detector innovation (dotted, training phase) stay near zero. Upon erroneous transfer with \epsilon=0.44 , both quantities (solid lines) grow with translational displacement but remain within the total bound \|\xi_{\text{ideal}}\|+\epsilon\|\mathrm{Ad}^{R}_{g_{k}}\|_{2} (dashed blue), which peaks at the detection threshold \tau=5.0 m, confirming that the margin established during training is sufficient to maintain \tau -stealthiness. VI Conclusions This paper introduces a geometric framework for analyzing sensor spoofing transferability on Lie groups. The central and perhaps surprising finding is that transferability reduces entirely to a single algebraic object: the centralizer \Delta_{f_{e}}=\ker([f_{e},\cdot]) of the nominal flow. Unlike linear systems where every attack transfers trivially, non-commutative dynamics confine transferable attacks to this invariant subspace. By formalizing the error mechanics of imperfect attacks, we further exposed a structural asymmetry: physical trajectory deviations are amplified by the Adjoint action, whereas detector innovations remain shielded by the observation map’s invariance. As validated on the SE(2) Dubins unicycle, this geometric loophole allows attackers to hijack estimators undetected. Ultimately, \Delta_{f_{e}} reframes attack transferability as a kinematic constraint intrinsic to the system’s symmetry. Future work will focus on several key extensions of this geometric framework: • Analyzing closed-loop systems under potentially coordinated actuator-sensor spoofing. • Tightening bounds on the Adjoint operator ( \operatorname{Ad} ) and formalizing \epsilon -conditions for \tau -stealth. • Generalizing the invariance assumptions to accommodate both direct-measurement observers and time-varying inter-sample inputs, which requires bounding the geometric divergence of compounding flows.