On Lagrangians of Non-abelian Dijkgraaf-Witten Theories Yuan Xue, Eric Y. Yang Abstract Dijkgraaf-Witten theories have a wide range of applications in topological phases of matter and the study of generalized global symmetries. We develop a method to construct BF-type Lagrangians for Dijkgraaf-Witten theories with non-abelian gauge group by gauging H ( 0 ) H^{(0)} symmetries from a BF-Lagrangian of an abelian Dijkgraaf-Witten theory. When H H nontrivially permutes the operators of the original theory, the Lagrangian of the H H -gauged theory is constructed with cohomologies with local coefficients. We analyze the structure of the Lagrangians and their gauge transformations with homotopy theory. We also construct the operator spectrum and verify the Lagrangians by matching elementary linking invariants. I Introduction Discrete gauge theories 2 ; 31 ; 36 have a wide range of applications in condensed matter physics and high energy physics. An important class of examples are the topological discrete gauge theories as discussed by Dijkgraaf and Witten 15 in D=3 . We will here refer to such TQFT discrete gauge theories in D\geq 3 as “Dijkgraaf Witten” (DW) theories. In condensed matter physics, DW theories describe the long-wavelength limit of a wide class of D -dimensional bosonic topological orders for D\geq 3 33 ; 10 ; 11 ; 42 ; 32 , where D is the spacetime dimension. When the spacetime manifold M_{D} is given a triangulation, one can explicitly define the partition function of the DW theory. There also exist lattice Hamiltonian constructions of DW theories in (2+1)D 30 ; 24 and (3+1)D 41 . Recently, DW theories have also regained popularity in high-energy physics due to the modern perspective of generalized symmetries 19 . The central paradigm is that global symmetries of a quantum field theory, topological or not, are implemented by topological defects. The topological nature of the global symmetries of a theory \mathcal{T} on M_{D} motivates the definition of the symmetry topological field theory (SymTFT) 17 on a cylinder M_{D}\times I , which captures the symmetry data, defects, and anomalies of \mathcal{T} as topological operators and boundary conditions. See 6 ; 40 and the references therein for further details. The same construction also appears in the condensed matter theory literature as SymTO/topological holography 8 ; 7 . Mathematically, DW theories are extended TQFTs 1 ; 34 , and a proper mathematical investigation would require higher category theory. Given its relevance in both the condensed matter theory and the high energy theory community, it is helpful to formulate a purely field theoretic treatment of DW theory where operator fusion and linking can be studied from elementary operator algebra and path integral arguments familiar to physicists. If a DW theory contains only invertible operators, then in many cases it can be formulated as a BF theory 27 . Meanwhile, abelian DW theories with certain non-trivial DW twists can contain non-invertible operators. Lagrangian analysis of such theories has previously appeared in the context of linking invariant calculations in non-abelian topological orders 37 ; 21 , example studies of symTFT for categorical symmetries 25 ; 38 , as well as top-down derivation of symTFT from IIA/IIB/F-theory 44 ; 16 ; 5 ; 22 . However, a universal bottom-up Lagrangian construction with a non-abelian gauge group G is still lacking. This work aims to provide a Lagrangian treatment of DW theories with non-abelian gauge group G that fits into an abelian extension: 0\rightarrow A\rightarrow G\rightarrow H\rightarrow 0 (1) where A and H are both abelian. We would like to construct a BF-type Lagrangian for a G -DW theory from the BF-type Lagrangian of an A -DW theory. Coincidentally, the same construction also appeared in the previous studies of finite 0-form symmetry gaugings in DW theories 28 , where the extension class c_{2}\in H^{2}(BH,A) encodes the fractionalization of the H 0-form symmetry. In this work, we will construct G -DW theory Lagrangians by gauging an H 0-form symmetry in an A -DW theory. When H nontrivially acts on the group A , the new gauge group G is necessarily non-abelian, and the topological action of the resulting G -DW theory is described in terms of cohomologies with local coefficients. Partial progress has been made in our previous work 43 , where we proposed a mechanism for constructing G -Lagrangians from A -Lagrangians by gauging global symmetries via an effective Noether procedure. The Poincaré dual of the Noether currents are represented by higher gauging condensation defects 39 , whose classification in untwisted DW theories was examined in 13 ; 12 . As in our previous work, the guiding principle of the operator construction is operator world-volume gauge invariance, and we verify our constructions by showing that the linking invariant calculations can correctly reproduce the character table of G . This paper is summarized as follows. In Sec. II , we will give a brief review of DW theories and present the recipe for constructing the G -action. For simplicity, we take G to be the dihedral group of order 2k \mathbb{D}_{k}\simeq\mathbb{Z}_{k}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{2} in (3+1) D. In this case, the twist coincides with a \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{C} 0-form charge conjugation symmetry of the original \mathbb{Z}_{k} -DW theory without fractionalization. We will also carefully study the gauge transformation structure and explain its origin in terms of homotopy theory assuming a knowledge of the theory of smooth fiber bundles. We will postpone the technical homotopy-theoretic details to Appendix A . When gauging a finite symmetry in any theory, one necessarily needs to verify that the symmetry action is anomaly-free. We will address this in Sec. III . In Sec. IV , we will verify our Lagrangian construction by demonstrating how to extract the character table of G from Hopf links between Wilson lines and ’t Hooft surfaces and tabulate the full list of results in Appendix B . In Sec. V , we will summarize and point out possible future directions. Notes added : During the preparation of this draft, we became aware of 4 , which partially overlaps with our results. 4 decomposes a G -action in terms of A -gauge fields and H -gauge fields and the Lagrangian examples are mostly in (2+1)D . This work focuses on gauging a H -symmetry in an A -action in (3+1) D and has a new family of examples for G=\mathbb{D}_{k} , where \mathbb{D}_{k} is the dihedral group of order 2k for k -even. Our organization of the operator spectrum can be easily generalized to any spacetime dimension D\geq 3 . II Lagrangian Constructions and Gauge Transformations In this section, we construct the Lagrangians of \mathbb{D}_{k} -DW theories by gauging the \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{C} symmetry in an untwisted \mathbb{Z}_{k} -DW theory. In the spirit of 28 , these are candidate actions of some 0-form symmetry gauged actions that are possibly obstructed by ’t Hooft anomalies. We will postpone the ’t Hooft anomaly analysis to Sec. III . Central to our analysis is the typical BF-theory formulation of DW theory, which we will quickly review in Sec. II.1 . In Sec. II.2 , we will construct the BF theory action of untwisted \mathbb{D}_{k} -DW theories. Note that the group \mathbb{D}_{4} is rather special, as it fits in various central and split extensions. We will construct various versions of its Lagrangian in Sec. II.3 . II.1 BF Theory Formulation of Discrete Gauge Theories In this subsection, we quickly review the definition of DW theories and their BF-theory formulations. Instead of using the extended TQFT definition in the framework of 1 ; 34 , it is convenient to treat DW theories as an analog of Yang-Mills theories with a finite gauge group G 15 . In this subsection, we set the spacetime manifold to be a closed oriented D -dimensional manifold M_{D} with a triangulation. Just like ordinary Yang-Mills theory with a compact continuous gauge group, the structure of a DW theory can be described by principal G bundles P\rightarrow M_{D} . A “classical” DW theory is specified by a choice of gauge group G and a topological action \omega\in H^{D}(BG,U(1)) , which can be interpreted as the universal cocycle data of a G -SPT on M_{D} 9 . When \omega is the identity element, the theory is typically referred to as an untwisted G -DW theory. Here BG is the classifying space of G , which is a topological space whose only non-vanishing homotopy group is the fundamental group \pi_{1}(BG)=G . Quantization of the theory is physically described by gauging the G -symmetry in the G -SPT, which results in a nontrivial topological order with loop operators/ Wilson lines and codimension-2 surface operators/ ’t Hooft surfaces in spacetime. When the topological action \omega is trivial, the line operators are in one-to-one correspondences with the linear irreps of G , and the codimension-2 surface operators are in one-to-one correspondences with the conjugacy classes of G . Topologically, quantization is described by defining the partition function as a weighted sum over isomorphism classes of G -bundles over M_{D} . It is well known that these bundles are classified by the classifying maps f:M_{D}\rightarrow BG up to homotopy. Specifically, for any BG there exists a contractible space EG called the universal covering space which admits a free G action and the quotient EG/G is homotopic to BG . It is then a standard math fact that any principal G bundle P\rightarrow M_{D} is isomorphic to the pull-back bundle induced by the classifying map f:M_{D}\rightarrow BG : {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces P=f^{*}(EG)} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces EG} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces M_{D}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces BG} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces f^{*}} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces f} (2) The partition function is given by: Z_{\omega}(M_{D})=\frac{1}{|G|}\sum_{\phi\in\mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(M_{D}),G)}\left\langle\phi^{*}\omega,[M_{D}]\right\rangle. (3) After modding out gauge transformations on the path integral measure, using the isomorphism [M_{D},BG]\simeq\mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(M_{D}),G)/G 1 1 1 It is a highly nontrivial fact that [M_{D},BA] has the structure of a finite abelian group for a finite abelian A . A full explanation involves the definition of the based loop space \Omega X of X . We refer the readers to 20 for further details. where [M_{D},BG] denotes the homotopy classes of maps from M_{D} to BG , one can rewrite the partition function as: Z_{\omega}(M_{D})=\sum_{[\rho]\in[M_{D},BG]}\frac{1}{|C_{G}(\rho)|}\,\left\langle\rho^{*}\omega,[M_{D}]\right\rangle, (4) where C_{G}(\rho) denotes the centralizer of the image of \rho in G . Crucially, since the quantization procedure involves [M_{D},BG] , DW theories are also termed as topological sigma models in the literature 14 . When G=A is abelian, there is an alternative definition in terms of gauge fields. Using the isomorphism H^{n}(BA,U(1))\simeq H^{n+1}(BA,\mathbb{Z}) , one can rewrite the inner product \left\langle\rho^{*}\omega,[M_{D}]\right\rangle as a phase \exp(2\pi i\int_{[M_D]}\rho^*\omega) and replace the measure with the [M_{D},BA]\simeq H^{1}(M_{D},A) . For example, since H^{4}(B\mathbb{Z}_{k},U(1))=\mathbb{Z}_{1} , \mathbb{Z}_{k} -DW theories in (3+1) D can only be defined with respect to a trivial topological action, and its partition function reads: Z(M_{D})=\sum_{[\rho]\in H^{1}(M_{D},\mathbb{Z}_{k})}\frac{1}{\absolutevalue{C_A(\rho)}}=\frac{\absolutevalue{H^1(M_D,\mathbb{Z}_k)}}{\absolutevalue{Z_k}} (5) When M_{D} is simply connected, the partition function equals 1/\mathbb{Z}_{k} and when M_{D} is torsionless, the partition function equals k^{b_{1}(M_{D})-1} . The fact that the path integral measure is a sum over H^{1}(M_{D},A) is the main motivation for the BF-theory formulation. Suppose A=\mathbb{Z}_{k} for concreteness. A 1-form gauge field a_{1} is a \mathbb{Z}_{k} -valued 1-cocycle on M_{D} taking values in \{0,1,\dots,k-1\} . In Lagrangian formulations, it is convenient to work with integer lifts of \mathbb{Z}_{k} -valued gauge fields, where \mathbb{Z}_{k} fits in the following short exact sequence: 0\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}\xrightarrow{\times k}\mathbb{Z}\xrightarrow{\text{mod }k}\mathbb{Z}_{k}\rightarrow 0 (6) The BF-theory Lagrangian is defined by introducing a \widehat{\mathbb{Z}}_{k} Lagrange multiplier \tilde{b}_{D-2} 27 : I=\frac{2\pi}{k}\int_{M_{D}}\tilde{b}_{D-2}\cup\delta b_{1}+\int_{M_{D}}(\rho^{*}\omega)(b_{1}) (7) so that the flatness constraint of b_{1} is encoded in the equation of motion for \tilde{b}_{D-2} . Integrating out \tilde{b}_{D-2} recovers the original definition of DW action. BF-type actions are convenient for an explicit operator algebra analysis of the TQFT. On the other hand, the action obtained by integrating out the Lagrange multiplier fields are convenient for the purpose of ’t Hooft anomaly analysis 28 . Finally, we point out a crucial subtlety of the BF-theory/ Lagrangian formulation of DW theories. Notice that the group homomorphism f^{*}:H^{D}(Y,U(1))\rightarrow H^{D}(X,U(1)) induced by the map f:X\rightarrow Y in general can have a nontrivial kernel. In the case of DW theory, we simply replace X with a physical spacetime M_{D} and Y with the target space BG for any finite group G . Adopting the topological sigma model definition, this means that a nontrivial topological action \omega\in H^{D}(BG,U(1)) can be trivialized once pulled back to spacetime if \ker f^{*} is not trivial, where f^{*}:H^{D}(BG,U(1))\rightarrow H^{D}(M_{D},U(1)) (8) Namely, if \omega_{G}\in\ker f^{*} , then its action on spacetime f^{*}\omega_{G} is necessarily trivial. Since certain nontrivial topological actions \omega_{D}\in H^{D}(BG,U(1)) can be pulled back to the trivial cocycle on spacetime M_{D} , working with a BF-type Lagrangian on spacetime alone does not capture all the data of the DW theory, and the specification of the initial data \omega_{G}\in H^{D}(BG,U(1)) is necessary. II.2 Charge Conjugation Gauged Lagrangian In this subsection, we construct the BF-Lagrangians of charge conjugation gauged \mathbb{Z}_{k} DW theories in (3+1)D without symmetry fractionalization and study the structure of their gauge transformations. In particular, we combine the field theoretic on-shell and off-shell deformations and show how they can be reproduced from a canonical homotopy theory perspective 18 . Let a_{1} be a \mathbb{Z}_{k} valued cochain. We can gauge the charge conjugation by a two-step procedure. Since the charge conjugation symmetry non-trivially permutes the extended operators, the coupling of the background gauge fields necessarily changes the cohomological structure of the theory 26 and modifies the original untwisted action to 2 2 2 When the 1-cochain c_{1} is used only to indicate the twisting in the subscript, we will simply write c instead of c_{1} . Similarly, for the gauge transformation c_{1}\rightarrow c_{1}+\delta\epsilon_{0} , we shall only write \epsilon . I=\frac{2\pi}{k}\int\tilde{a}_{2}\cup_{c}\delta_{c}a_{1} (9) where c_{1} is a \mathbb{Z}_{2} -valued 1-cocycle. To complete the gauging, we promote c_{1} to dynamical gauge fields and allow off-shell fluctuations of the c_{1} gauge field: I_{\mathbb{D}_{k}}=\frac{2\pi}{k}\int_{M_{4}}\tilde{a}_{2}\cup_{c}\delta_{c}a_{1}+\pi\int_{M_{4}}\tilde{c}_{2}\cup\delta c_{1} (10) where \tilde{c}_{2} is a \widehat{\mathbb{Z}}_{2} -valued 2-cochain implementing the flatness constraint on c_{1} . The on-shell and off-shell physics of Eq. ( 10 ) admit an interesting hierarchy structure. Especially, we would like to study the on-shell and off-shell deformations that leave the action Eq. ( 10 ) invariant. For clarity, we note that on-shell deformations should not introduce new solutions or eliminate existing solutions to the equations of motion in a usual field theory sense. On the other hand, this requirement does not apply to off-shell deformations as they need not respect the equations of motion. Let us first examine the on-shell physics. For simplicity, we integrate out the Lagrange multipliers, which will be later restored. The relevant equations of motion are: \begin{split}\delta_{c}a_{1}=0\qquad\delta c_{1}=0\end{split} (11) which implies that a_{1}\in H^{1}_{c}(M_{D},\mathbb{Z}_{k}) where H^{\bullet}_{c}(M_{D},\mathbb{Z}_{k}) is a twisted cohomology theory defined with respect to a twisted coboundary operator \delta_{c} . In the language of 28 , the twisted flatness of a_{1} is a consequence of the vanishing of symmetry fractionalization. Now we run into an immediate problem. The flatness constraint \delta c_{1}=0 implies that the on-shell physics for c_{1} is invariant under a deformation by a coboundary c_{1}\mapsto c_{1}+\delta\epsilon_{0} , and the solution space modulo deformation is c_{1}\in H^{1}(M_{D},\mathbb{Z}_{2}) . However, the twisted flatness constraint for a_{1} implies that each particular closed profile of c_{1} defines a particular cohomology theory that allows for the definition of the action in Eq. ( 10 ). If we allow a deformation c_{1}\mapsto c_{1}+\delta\epsilon_{0} , then the twisted coboundary operator \delta_{c} will be deformed into \delta_{c+\delta\epsilon} . This deformation nontrivially maps the equation of motion \delta_{c}a_{1}=0 to \delta_{c+\delta\epsilon}a_{1}=0 . Accordingly, we will have a new solution space H^{1}_{c+\delta\epsilon}(M_{D},\mathbb{Z}_{k}) . However, since there is no canonical isomorphism between H_{c}^{\bullet}(M_{D},\mathbb{Z}_{k}) and H_{c+\delta\epsilon}^{\bullet}(M_{D},\mathbb{Z}_{k}) , it follows that a particular \delta_{c} -cocycle on spacetime M_{D} might not be a \delta_{c+\delta\epsilon} -cocycle. Therefore, a c_{1}\mapsto c_{1}+\delta\epsilon_{0} deformation on-shell does not preserve the on-shell physics. In fact, it does something worse — it changes the equations of motion themselves. In this sense, it is not a genuine on-shell deformation. Therefore, the allowed on-shell gauge transformation should be: a_{1}\mapsto a_{1}+\delta_{c}\alpha_{0}\qquad c_{1}\mapsto c_{1} (12) This leads to an interesting puzzle. From a field theory perspective, it is unphysical to demand that the solutions to a particular equation of motion \delta c_{1}=0 have no non-trivial deformations. On the other hand, nontrivial deformation on c_{1} is incompatible with the on-shell physics of a_{1} . Luckily, this puzzle can be resolved by going to the quantum theory, where we are no longer constrained by the equations of motion. Now we address the off-shell gauge transformations, which need not preserve the equations of motion, but they do need to leave the quantum theory invariant. For DW theories, this means that any off-shell gauge transformation must only deform the pulled back topological action \rho^{*}\omega by a spacetime coboundary. To fully understand the off-shell gauge transformations, it is convenient to invoke the topological sigma model definition of DW theory 18 , where the gauge transformations can be understood as deformations of maps from the physical spacetime M_{D} to the target space. Recall that a DW theory with gauge group \mathbb{D}_{k} is a topological sigma model from M_{D} to the classifying space B\mathbb{D}_{k} . Since \mathbb{D}_{k} sits in a split extension: 0\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{k}\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{k}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{2}\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{2}\rightarrow 0 (13) we can model the target space B\mathbb{D}_{k} as the total space of a Serre fibration of classifying spaces 3 3 3 Strictly speaking, only the map \pi:B\mathbb{D}_{k}\rightarrow B\mathbb{Z}_{2} is called a Serre fibration, and the entire Eq. ( 14 ) is called a fiber sequence. The topological spaces are presented in such a way that is reminiscent of the short exact sequences of the finite groups that induces this fiber sequence. : B\mathbb{Z}_{k}\rightarrow B\mathbb{D}_{k}\xrightarrow{\pi}B\mathbb{Z}_{2} (14) For clarity, let us first consider a simplified setup by replacing the fiber B\mathbb{Z}_{k} with an empty set, which reduces the target space to B\mathbb{Z}_{2} . The reduced theory has the following standard BF action: I_{\text{reduced}}=\pi\int_{M_{4}}\tilde{c}_{2}\cup\delta c_{1} (15) with equations of motion \delta c_{1}=0 and \delta\tilde{c}_{2}=0 . In this case, the on-shell and off-shell small gauge transformations coincide: c_{1}\mapsto c_{1}+\delta\epsilon_{0}\qquad\tilde{c}_{2}\mapsto\tilde{c}_{2}+\delta\tilde{\epsilon}_{1} (16) Especially, because of the isomorphism: H^{1}(M_{4},\mathbb{Z}_{2})\simeq[M_{4},B\mathbb{Z}_{2}] (17) the small gauge transformation is the cohomological analog of a null-homotopy of a particular map from M_{4} to B\mathbb{Z}_{2} . Now let us turn the homotopy fiber back on and consider the untwisted \mathbb{D}_{k} DW theory. Here we will give a homotopy-theoretic interpretation of the off-shell gauge transformations of an untwisted \mathbb{D}_{k} theory 4 4 4 The fact that one can find homotopy theory analogs of cohomological operation is a consequence of the representability of simplicial cohomology. We refer the readers to 20 for further details. . We will see that this picture naturally encodes the gauge transformation c_{1}\rightarrow c_{1}+\delta\epsilon_{0} , which is absent from the on-shell deformations. Similar to the case where we trivialized the fiber, the collection of gauge fields for untwisted \mathbb{D}_{k} DW theories are described in terms of homotopy classes of maps [M_{4},B\mathbb{D}_{k}] . However, since \mathbb{D}_{k} is non-abelian, we cannot naively define \mathbb{D}_{k} -valued 1-cocycles on M_{4} . Instead, one can try to use a pair of \mathbb{Z}_{k} and \mathbb{Z}_{2} gauge fields to collectively denote a “ \mathbb{D}_{k} gauge field”. To find a homotopy theory analog of this decomposition, let’s try to find inspirations by recalling certain features of smooth fiber bundles, which are a special class of homotopy fibrations. Recall that the total space of a smooth fiber bundle E\rightarrow B admits a local trivialization so that locally we can always describe the geometry of total space E in terms of the base B , the fiber F and a section s:B\rightarrow E . Going back to a generic Serre fibration E\rightarrow B with typical fiber F , one may ask if it is possible to describe the space E in terms of the space B and the F . The answer is somewhat positive, and extra care must be taken. For the readers unfamiliar with homotopy theory, in order to understand the intuition in the main text, it suffices to replace the word “fibration” with a “smooth fiber bundle”. We will address the homotopy-theoretic details in Appendix A . Consider any map f:M_{4}\rightarrow B\mathbb{D}_{k} , which physically describes a “mode” integrated over in the path integral measure of the \mathbb{D}_{k} DW theory. The map f can be trivially composed with the map \pi:B\mathbb{D}_{k}\rightarrow B\mathbb{Z}_{2} in Eq. ( 14 ) into \tilde{f}\equiv\pi\circ f so that we have a commutative triangle: {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces B\mathbb{D}_{k}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces M_{4}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces B\mathbb{Z}_{2}} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\pi} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces f} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\tilde{f}} (18) Namely, for any x\in M_{4} , we have \tilde{f}(x)=(\pi\circ f)(x) . The map \tilde{f}:M_{4}\rightarrow B\mathbb{Z}_{2} is a homotopy theory analog of the \mathbb{Z}_{2} sector of a “ \mathbb{D}_{k} gauge field”. To get the analog of the \mathbb{Z}_{k} sector gauge field, we temporarily suppress the map f:M_{4}\rightarrow B\mathbb{D}_{k} in the above diagram and consider the pull-back fibration by the map \tilde{f}:M_{4}\rightarrow B\mathbb{Z}_{2} . Note that a pull-back fibration is simply a homotopy-theoretic analog of a pullback smooth fiber bundle. Similar to a pullback smooth fiber bundle, a pullback fibration has the same typical fiber as the original fibration, so now we can expand this triangular diagram into: {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces B\mathbb{Z}_{k}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\tilde{f}^{*}B\mathbb{D}_{k}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces B\mathbb{D}_{k}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces M_{4}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces B\mathbb{Z}_{2}} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\tilde{\pi}} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\pi} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\tilde{f}} (19) One can define a section of the pull-back fibration B\mathbb{Z}_{k}\rightarrow\tilde{f}^{*}B\mathbb{D}_{k}\xrightarrow{\tilde{\pi}}M_{4} , which is a map s_{\tilde{\pi}}:M_{4}\rightarrow\tilde{f}^{*}B\mathbb{D}_{k} . The fiber direction of this section is the homotopy-theoretic analog of the \mathbb{Z}_{k} gauge field. To cleanly illustrate this construction, we restore the original effective “ \mathbb{D}_{k} ” gauge field as a blue arrow in the following diagram and identify the decomposition into the \mathbb{Z}_{k} and \mathbb{Z}_{2} components with blue arrows: {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces B\mathbb{Z}_{k}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\tilde{f}^{*}B\mathbb{D}_{k}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces B\mathbb{D}_{k}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces M_{4}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces B\mathbb{Z}_{2}} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\tilde{\pi}} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\pi} \scriptstyle{\color[rgb]{1,0,0}\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces f} \scriptstyle{\color[rgb]{0,0,1}\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces s_{\tilde{\pi}}} \scriptstyle{\color[rgb]{0,0,1}\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\tilde{f}} (20) In this language, both the on-shell and off-shell gauge transformations of the gauge fields are described by deformations of the maps in Eq. ( 20 ). We see that it makes sense to discuss a fiber-wise deformation while holding \tilde{f} fixed. This corresponds to an on-shell gauge transformation with respect to a fixed c_{1} profile in Eq. ( 12 ). In homotopy theory terms, such a deformation is simply a change of section s_{\tilde{\pi}} of the pull-back fibration. Since the path integral measure integrates over all possible maps from M_{4} to B\mathbb{Z}_{2} modulo homotopy, the off-shell gauge transformation necessarily includes a shift c_{1}\rightarrow c_{1}+\delta\epsilon_{0} as expected. From the homotopy-theoretic perspective, we see that the section s_{\tilde{\pi}}:M_{4}\rightarrow\tilde{f}^{*}B\mathbb{D}_{k} is determined by the map \tilde{f}:M_{4}\rightarrow B\mathbb{Z}_{2} . Namely, the \mathbb{Z}_{k} components of the \mathbb{D}_{k} can only be defined with respect to a particular \mathbb{Z}_{2} gauge field. Therefore, a deformation on the map \tilde{f} necessarily induces a change on the section s_{\tilde{\pi}} . In terms of gauge fields, this corresponds to the following off-shell gauge transformation: \begin{split}c_{1}&\mapsto c_{1}+\delta\epsilon_{0}\\ a_{1}&\mapsto a_{1}+\delta_{c+\delta\epsilon}\alpha_{0}\end{split} (21) Now we address the off-shell gauge transformations of the Lagrange multiplier fields. Since the c_{1} -twist acts on \mathbb{Z}_{k} as an automorphism, the off-shell gauge transformation of the \widehat{\mathbb{Z}}_{k} -valued gauge field \tilde{a}_{2} is dual to the gauge transformation of a_{1} : \tilde{a}_{2}\mapsto\tilde{a}_{2}+\delta_{-c-\delta\epsilon}\tilde{\alpha}_{1} (22) while the gauge transformation on \tilde{c}_{2} is given by: \tilde{c}_{2}\mapsto\tilde{c}_{2}+\delta\tilde{\epsilon}_{1} (23) Using a twisted Leibniz rule constructed in 3 , it is easy to verify that an off-shell deformation maps the action to: I_{\mathbb{D}_{k}}^{\prime}=\frac{2\pi}{k}\int_{M_{4}}\tilde{a}_{2}\cup_{c+\delta\epsilon}\delta_{c+\delta\epsilon}a_{1}+\pi\int_{M_{4}}\tilde{c}_{2}\cup\delta c_{1} (24) Finally, it is worth mentioning that such a hierarchy of gauge transformation also appears in higher group gauge theories, which is a more general class of topological sigma models. In fact, the (3+1)D untwisted \mathbb{D}_{k} -DW theory examples in this work are dualized 2-group gauge theories. We refer the readers to 18 ; 17 ; 29 for further details. II.3 \mathbb{D}_{4} Lagrangian In this section, we present various equivalent \mathbb{D}_{4} Lagrangians. It is known that \mathbb{D}_{4}=(\mathbb{Z}_{2}\times\mathbb{Z}_{2})\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{2} admits two different split extensions. By the construction introduced in Sec. II.2 , the action reads I_{\mathbb{D}_{4}}=\pi\int\tilde{a}_{2}\cup_{c}\delta_{c}a_{1}+\pi\int\tilde{b}_{2}\cup_{c}\delta_{c}b_{1}+\pi\int\tilde{c}_{2}\cup\delta c_{1}, (25) where a_{1} , b_{1} are \mathbb{Z}_{2} -valued 1-cochains describing the two components of the Klein-four subgroup V=\mathbb{Z}_{2}\times\mathbb{Z}_{2} , while c_{1} is the \mathbb{Z}_{2} -valued 1-cochain for the quotient sector in the split extension \displaystyle 1\rightarrow V\rightarrow\mathbb{D}_{4}\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{2}\rightarrow 1. (26) Let V=\mathbb{Z}_{2}\times\mathbb{Z}_{2} . There are two split extensions with kernel V , where the twists in the additive notation act on V as: \rho_{1}:(a,b)\mapsto(b,a),\quad\rho_{2}:(a,b)\mapsto(a,a+b). (27) \rho_{1} exchanges the two \mathbb{Z}_{2} factors, while \rho_{2} acts on V by a shift. These two choices enter the theory only through the twisted coboundary \delta_{c} and the associated gauge transformations. For simplicity here we only state the off-shell gauge transformation induced by a shift c_{1}\rightarrow c_{1}+\delta\epsilon_{0} . For the twist \rho_{1} , the gauge fields have the following off-shell deformations: \begin{split}a_{1}&\mapsto a_{1}+\delta_{c+\delta\epsilon}\alpha_{0}\\ b_{1}&\mapsto b_{1}+\delta_{c+\delta\epsilon}\beta_{0}\\ \tilde{a}_{2}&\mapsto\tilde{a}_{2}+\delta_{-c-\delta\epsilon}\tilde{\alpha}_{1}\\ \tilde{b}_{2}&\mapsto\tilde{b}_{2}+\delta_{-c-\delta\epsilon}\tilde{\beta}_{1}\end{split} (28) For the twist \rho_{2} , we have the following off-shell gauge transformations: \begin{split}a_{1}&\mapsto a_{1}+\delta_{c+\delta\epsilon}\alpha_{0}\\ b_{1}&\mapsto b_{1}+\delta\beta_{0}\\ \tilde{a}_{2}&\mapsto\tilde{a}_{2}+\delta\tilde{\alpha}_{1}\\ \tilde{b}_{2}&\mapsto\tilde{b}_{2}+\delta_{-c-\delta\epsilon}\tilde{\beta}_{1}\end{split} (29) Finally, we note that the Lagrangian of the untwisted \mathbb{D}_{4} -DW theory can also be constructed by gauging a \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{2} 0-form symmetry in an untwisted \mathbb{Z}_{2} -DW theory, where the symmetry does not permute the operators but carries nontrivial fractionalization data. The relevant action is a central extension: 0\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{2}\rightarrow\mathbb{D}_{4}\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{2}^{2}\rightarrow 0 (30) The \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{2} gauged action reads: I_{\mathbb{D}_{4}}=\pi\int\tilde{a}_{2}\cup\delta a_{1}+\pi\int\tilde{b}_{2}\cup\delta b_{1}+\pi\int\tilde{c}_{2}\cup\delta c_{1}+\pi\int\tilde{b}_{2}\cup a_{1}\cup c_{1} (31) where b_{1} is the gauge field of the original untwisted \mathbb{Z}_{2} -DW theory. Integrating out the Lagrange multipliers, the action becomes: I_{\mathbb{D}_{4}}=\pi\int\tilde{b}_{2}\cup a_{1}\cup c_{1} (32) where: a_{1}\cup c_{1}\in H^{2}(\mathbb{Z}_{2}^{2},\mathbb{Z}_{2}) (33) is the pullback of the extension class of Eq. ( 30 ) to spacetime. The Lagrangian itself defines a topological sigma model from M_{4} to the classifying space \mathbb{B}\mathbb{Z}_{2}^{3} with a nontrivial topological action. Similar to the previous split extensions, the central extension Eq. ( 30 ) also defines a fibration of classifying spaces: B\mathbb{Z}_{2}^{2}\rightarrow B\mathbb{Z}_{2}^{3}\rightarrow B\mathbb{Z}_{2} (34) However, it can be shown that the on-shell and off-shell gauge transformations of this theory in the BF formalism agree with each other. One can recover the hierarchy of gauge transformations by appropriately suppressing the small gauge transformation parameters. See 43 for further details. III Anomaly-Free Conditions In this section, we will work out the obstruction-free conditions for \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{C} gauging of \mathbb{Z}_{k} DW theories in (3+1)D without symmetry fractionalization by anomaly inflow. Especially, we show that all the symmetries we considered in the previous section are anomaly-free. As mentioned in Sec. II.1 , it is convenient to integrate out the Lagrange multipliers for ’t Hooft anomaly analysis. We can construct a new \mathbb{D}_{k} action \omega_{\mathbb{D}_{k}} in terms of the degrees of freedom of the original \mathbb{Z}_{k} DW theory as well as the \mathbb{Z}_{2} background gauge field. The \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{C} symmetry is anomaly free only when the background gauge field variation of \omega_{\mathbb{D}_{k}} can be canceled by (3+1) D local counterterms. Because of the ambiguities in (3+1) D counterterms, it is more convenient to extend \omega_{\mathbb{D}_{k}} to a 5D manifold M_{5} with boundary M_{4} and solve for certain conditions that allow the 4D action to be extended to a trivial 5-cocycle \omega_{5}=\delta\omega_{\mathbb{D}_{k}} . In particular, these conditions constrain the coupling of background gauge fields with the existing dynamical gauge fields. Because of the anomaly inflow assumption, this critical condition is equivalent to the anomaly-free condition of the \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{C} symmetry of the (3+1) D \mathbb{Z}_{k} DW theory. This framework was first introduced in 28 and it is applicable to all discrete symmetry gauging of DW theories with Lagrangian formulations. If the 0-form symmetry action is organized by a split extension: 0\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{k}\xrightarrow{\iota}\mathbb{Z}_{k}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{2}^{C}\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{2}^{C}\rightarrow 0 (35) then the anomaly free condition admits a much more elegant criterion 28 ; 35 . The \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{C} symmetry is anomaly free when there exists \omega_{\mathbb{D}_{k}}\in H^{4}(B\mathbb{D}_{k},U(1)) so that \iota^{*}\omega_{\mathbb{D}_{k}}=\omega_{\mathbb{Z}_{k}} . First we show that the charge-conjugation symmetry action that we considered above is anomaly free. After integrating out the Lagrange multiplier field, we see that the on-shell action of the original \mathbb{Z}_{k} DW theory and the proposed \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{C} gauged theory are both topologically trivial when pulled back to spacetime: \rho^{*}\omega_{\mathbb{D}_{k}}=[0] (36) Therefore, Eq. ( 10 ) is a good BF-Lagrangian for the untwisted \mathbb{D}_{k} DW theory. This immediately satisfies the pull-back definition of the anomaly-free condition, because the map \iota in the group extension naturally defines a map of the classifying space B\mathbb{Z}_{k} and B{\mathbb{D}_{k}} , hence a homomorphism of the cohomology groups \iota^{*}:H^{4}(B\mathbb{D}_{k},U(1))\rightarrow H^{4}(B\mathbb{Z}_{k},U(1)) . The two trivial topological actions are simply the identity elements of H^{4}(B\mathbb{D}_{k},U(1)) and H^{4}(B\mathbb{Z}_{k},U(1)) , which satisfies \iota^{*}[0]_{\mathbb{D}_{k}}=[0]_{\mathbb{Z}_{k}} by definition. We note that this observation can be directly generalized to an H^{(0)} symmetry acting on an untwisted DW theory in arbitrary spacetime dimension with a finite abelian gauge group A via the split extension: 0\rightarrow A\rightarrow A\rtimes H\rightarrow H\rightarrow 0 (37) The H^{(0)} symmetry is anomaly free and the H^{(0)} gauged theory is an untwisted A\rtimes H DW theory. Now we consider the symmetry action by central extension. In this case, the on-shell action is given by Eq. ( 32 ). Integrating out b_{1} implements the constraint \delta\tilde{b}_{2}=0 . Moreover, integrating out \tilde{a}_{2} and \tilde{c}_{2} implements the constraints \delta a_{1}=0 and \delta c_{1}=0 , respectively. Therefore, the extension of the 4-cocycle \pi\,\tilde{b}_{2}\cup a_{1}\cup c_{1} to 5D: \pi\,\delta(\tilde{b}_{2}\cup a_{1}\cup c_{1}) (38) is necessarily cohomologically trivial by Leibniz rule. Therefore, this symmetry is anomaly-free. IV Linking and Higher Gauging Condensation Defect Dressing In this section, we will work out the operator formalism of untwisted \mathbb{D}_{k} -DW theory. Given an action, one can derive a collection of gauge transformations in the G -DW theory and define gauge invariant objects on closed oriented submanifolds of spacetime. We will see that the requirement of gauge invariance of the operators naturally leads to the emergence of higher gauging condensation defects 39 ; 13 ; 12 . The idea of higher gauging condensation defects is to start from a parent gauge theory with an ordinary or higher-form symmetry and gauge the symmetry only along a submanifold rather than in the entire spacetime 39 . In finite-group gauge theories, this provides a concrete way to realize both invertible and non-invertible symmetry defects: one first writes a bare operator and then dresses it by suitable condensation factors so that it becomes gauge invariant and has the correct fusion and linking properties. In our construction below, we will repeatedly use condensation defects \mathcal{S}_{c} and \tilde{\mathcal{S}}_{c} by higher gauging a \mathbb{Z}_{2} 1-form symmetry. Similar to the constructions in our previous work 43 , the main higher gauging condensation defects involved are the diagonal electric condensation defects \mathcal{D}_{K} introduced in 13 ; 12 , where K\triangleleft G is a normal subgroup of the spacetime gauge group. These diagonal condensation defects are orientation reversal invariant with a trivial world-volume topological action, and we refer the readers to 13 ; 12 for their physical implications. In our work, we only need their self-fusion rules \mathcal{D}_{K}\times\mathcal{D}_{K}=\frac{\absolutevalue{G}}{\absolutevalue{K}}\mathcal{D}_{K} (39) We will see that the main role of the electric condensation is to ensure gauge invariance. A basic diagnostic of the operator spectrum in DW theory is the Hopf link between a Wilson line W_{\rho}(S^{1}) , labeled by an irreducible representation \rho , and a ’t Hooft surface T_{[g]}(S^{2}) , labeled by a conjugacy class [g] . The linking invariants contain representation-theoretic data of the gauge group. More precisely, the Hopf link equals 23 : \expectationvalue{W_{\rho}(S^1)T_{[g]}(S^2)}=\chi_{\rho}([g])\times\mathrm{size}([g]). (40) where an overall normalization factor of the DW theory partition function is suppressed. This is the basic relation that allows one to reconstruct the character table from the topological linking data. In the present higher-gauging-condensation-defect construction, the same relation emerges after dressing the bare electric and magnetic operators by the appropriate electric and magnetic condensation defects. The physical reason is also straightforward. A Wilson line inserts an electric probe charge transforming in the irrep \rho , while a linked ’t Hooft surface inserts a magnetic flux in the conjugacy class [g] . When the two operators are linked, the electric probe encircles the magnetic flux and picks up the corresponding Aharonov–Bohm phase, or more generally the action of the holonomy g in \rho . Taking the trace over the representation gives the character \chi_{\rho}(g) . Since a ’t Hooft operator associated with a non-central conjugacy class is represented by a sum over all elements in the class, the final answer is weighted by the size of conjugacy class. In fact, generic correlation functions of DW theories are evaluated similarly by unlinking all the operator insertions and then shrinking all the operators to a point. The Aharonov-Bohm phases can be understood as an obstruction to the unlinking process. Particularly, the one-point function of any operator on a sphere measures its quantum dimension up to an overall normalization factor of the partition function. See 43 for an extended discussion. In this section, we show how to extract the representation theory information of the gauge group \mathbb{D}_{k} from the linking invariant calculations. Recall that \mathbb{D}_{k} can be represented by the following relation: \mathbb{D}_{k}=\langle r,s\mid r^{k}=1,\ s^{2}=1,\ srs^{-1}=r^{-1}\rangle, (41) The representations for k -even and k -odd are slightly different, and we will discuss them separately in Sec. IV.1 and Sec. IV.2 . The case k=4 has more equivalent operator formalisms, which we present in Sec. IV.3 . IV.1 \mathbb{D}_{k} for k -odd Recall that \mathbb{D}_{k} for odd k has the following conjugacy classes: \{1\},\,\{r^{t},r^{-t}\,|\,1\leq t\leq(k-1)/2\},\,\{r^{p}s\,|\,0\leq p\leq k-1\} (42) \mathbb{D}_{k} has two 1D linear irreps 1 and \chi_{-} , and (k-1)/2 2D linear irreps \chi_{j} , labeled by j=1,\dots,(k-1)/2 . Similar to usual BF theory formulations, the operator spectrum is constructed by exponentiating the gauge fields. However, subtlety arises when twisted cohomologies are involved. Let us first consider the line operators. Gauging a \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{C} symmetry without fractionalization always leads to a nontrivial \mathbb{Z}_{2} Wilson line: U_{c}(M_{1})=e^{i\oint_{M_{1}}c_{1}} (43) where the flux integral is an abbreviation of the evaluation of a 1-cocycle c_{1} on a 1-cycle M_{1} . For example, when M_{1} is S^{1} as in Fig. 1 , the integral represents: \oint_{M_{1}}c_{1}=c_{1}([M_{1}])=c_{ij}+c_{jk}+c_{ki} (44) c_{ij} c_{jk} c_{ki} i j k Figure 1: A triangulation of S^{1} . One may attempt to define the object e^{i\oint_{M_{1}}a_{1}} , but it is not gauge invariant under the on-shell gauge transformation Eq. ( 12 ). To see this, let M_{1}=S^{1} . With the triangulation in Fig. 1 , an on-shell gauge transformation over an S^{1} with a nontrivial c_{1} background shifts the integral by: \oint_{S^{1}}\delta_{c}\alpha_{0}=\rho(c_{ij})\alpha_{j}-\alpha_{i}+\rho(c_{jk})\alpha_{k}-\alpha_{j}+\rho(c_{ki})\alpha_{i}-\alpha_{k} (45) This means that the sites i,j,k now host local gauge transformation parameters: \begin{split}\phi_{i}&=\rho(c_{ki})\alpha_{i}-\alpha_{i}\\ \phi_{j}&=\rho(c_{ij})\alpha_{j}-\alpha_{j}\\ \phi_{k}&=\rho(c_{jk})\alpha_{k}-\alpha_{k}\end{split} (46) See Fig. 2 for a demonstration. Gauge invariance requires the cancellation of these parameters, and this can only be achieved by trivializing c_{1} over the S^{1} . The same reasoning applies to off-shell gauge transformations, where on a link ij replace c_{ij} with: c_{ij}^{\prime}=(c_{1}+\delta\epsilon_{0})_{ij}=c_{ij}+\epsilon_{j}-\epsilon_{i} (47) Therefore, all we need is the trivialization of cohomology classes of c_{1} . ( c_{ij},a_{ij} ) ( c_{jk},a_{jk} ) ( c_{ki},a_{ki} ) 0_{i} 0_{j} 0_{k} ( c_{ij},a_{ij} ) ( c_{jk},a_{jk} ) ( c_{ki},a_{ki} ) \phi_{i} \phi_{j} \phi_{k} Figure 2: An on-shell gauge transformation of e^{i\oint_{S^{1}}a_{1}} on a loop with nontrivial c_{1} profile. 0_{i},0_{j},0_{k} means that there are no data associated to the sites i,j,k . A simple way to trivialize [c_{1}] on any loop is by stacking with the following delta function: \delta_{c}(M_{1})=\frac{1}{2}(1+e^{i\oint_{M_{1}}c_{1}}) (48) Moreover, since the \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{C} symmetry exchanges the gauge field a_{1} with -a_{1} , the true physical object should be the following orbit of the \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{C} action: \hat{U}_{a}^{(1)}=\left(e^{i\oint a_{1}}+e^{-i\oint a_{1}}\right)\delta_{c} (49) In fact, in the language of 13 ; 12 , one should formally rewrite the operator as: \hat{U}_{a}^{(1)}(M_{1})=\frac{e^{i\oint a_{1}}+e^{-i\oint a_{1}}}{2}\mathcal{S}_{c}(M_{1}) (50) where \mathcal{S}_{c}(M_{1})=2\delta_{c}(M_{1}) (51) is the electric condensation defect associated with the \mathbb{Z}_{k} normal subgroup of the spacetime gauge group \mathbb{D}_{k} . In this notation, the higher gauging condensation defect \mathcal{S}_{c} carries the quantum dimension of the operator: \expectationvalue{\hat{U}_a^{(1)}}=2 (52) \mathbb{D}_{k} has \frac{k-1}{2} such linear irrep in total, and they are similarly labeled by: \hat{U}_{a}^{(j)}=\frac{e^{i\oint ja_{1}}+e^{-i\oint ja_{1}}}{2}\mathcal{S}_{c} (53) where j\in\{1,2,\dots,\frac{k-1}{2}\} . Together with the trivial irrep, we have the 1+1+\frac{k-1}{2}=\frac{k+3}{2} irreps of \mathbb{D}_{k} in total. Now we consider the ’t Hooft operators. The only invertible surface operator is the trivial surface. We can attempt to define an object e^{i\oint_{M_{2}}\tilde{a}_{2}} , but the same gauge invariance consideration requires us to trivialize all cohomology classes of [c_{1}] on all possible 1-cycles of M_{2} , which is achieved by the stacking of the following operator: \Delta_{c}(M_{2})=\prod_{\gamma\in H_{1}(M_{2},\mathbb{Z}_{2})}\delta_{c}(\gamma)=\frac{1}{\absolutevalue{H_1(M_2,\mathbb{Z}_2)}}\sum_{\gamma\in H_{1}(M_{2},\mathbb{Z}_{2})}U_{c}(\gamma) (54) Now we can construct surface operators with quantum dimension 2, which can be understood as the size-2 conjugacy classes of the \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{C} orbits of \mathbb{Z}_{k}\triangleleft\mathbb{D}_{k} \hat{U}_{\tilde{a}}^{(t)}=\frac{e^{it\oint\tilde{a}_{2}}+e^{-it\oint\tilde{a}_{2}}}{2}\tilde{\mathcal{S}}_{c}=\left(e^{it\oint\tilde{a}_{2}}+e^{-it\oint\tilde{a}_{2}}\right)\Delta_{c} (55) where t\in\{1,2,\dots,\frac{k-1}{2}\} and \mathcal{S}_{c}=2\Delta_{c} is a codimension-2 electric condensation defect associated to \mathbb{Z}_{k}\triangleleft\mathbb{D}_{k} . Finally, consider the object e^{i\oint_{M_{2}}\tilde{c}_{2}} , which should correspond to the remaining size k conjugacy class. The quantum dimension can be provided by the operator: M_{\tilde{a}}(M_{2})=\sum_{l=0}^{k-1}e^{il\oint_{M_{2}}\tilde{a}_{2}} (56) which is not gauge invariant on its own. Therefore, we need a further stacking of \mathcal{S}_{c} , which leads us to the following representation of the conjugacy class [s] : \hat{U}_{\tilde{c}}=\frac{1}{2}e^{i\oint\tilde{c}}\tilde{\mathcal{S}}_{c}M_{\tilde{a}}, (57) Similar to the construction of non-invertible Wilson lines, the operator e^{i\oint_{M_{2}}\tilde{c}_{2}}M_{\tilde{a}} can be understood as a size k -orbit of \mathbb{D}_{k} under conjugation action, which needs to be dressed with \tilde{S}_{c} to ensure gauge invariance. Together, this gives 1+\frac{k-1}{2}+1=\frac{k+3}{2} conjugacy classes as expected. We end our discussion of untwisted \mathbb{D}_{k} by explicitly carrying out a few linking invariant calculations. Let’s consider the Hopf link between \hat{U}_{a}^{(j)}(S^{1}) and \hat{U}_{\tilde{a}}^{(t)}(S^{2}) . Since a_{1} serves as a source of \tilde{a}_{2} , integrating out a_{1} in the path integral converts the \tilde{a}_{2} monodromy into Aharonov-Bohm phases. Meanwhile, since nothing sources the c_{1} fields in the electric condensation \mathcal{S}_{c} , we are free to shrink \mathcal{S}_{c} to a point. Altogether: \displaystyle\expectationvalue{\hat{U}_a^{(j)}(S^1)\hat{U}_{\tilde a}^{(t)}(S^2)} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\expectationvalue{ e^{i\oint j a_1}(e^{it\oint\Tilde{a}_2} + e^{-it\oint\Tilde{a}_2})\frac{\mathcal{S}_c}{2}}+\mathrm{c.c.} \displaystyle= \displaystyle(e^{\frac{2\pi i}{k}jt}+e^{-\frac{2\pi i}{k}jt})+\mathrm{c.c.} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 4\cos\Big(\frac{2\pi i}{k}jt\Big) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\chi_{j}([r^{t}])\times\text{size}([r^{t}]) (58) Similarly, consider the Hopf link between \hat{U}_{a}^{(j)}(S^{1}) and \hat{U}_{\tilde{c}}(S^{2}) . In this case, the \tilde{c}_{2} field on \hat{U}_{\tilde{c}}(S^{2}) nontrivially sources the c_{1} fields, whose monodromies are condensed on S^{1} by the electric condensation \mathcal{S}_{c} . Therefore, we have \displaystyle\expectationvalue{\hat{U}_a^{(j)}(S^1) \hat{U}_{\tilde{c}}(S^2)} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{1}{2}\expectationvalue{(e^{i\oint_{S^1} j a_1} + e^{-i\oint_{S^1} j a_1})(1+U_c(S^1))e^{i\oint_{S^2}\tilde{c}_2} \mathcal{S}_c(S^2)} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\expectationvalue{(e^{i\oint_{S^1} j a_1} + e^{-i\oint_{S^1} j a_1})(1+e^{\frac{2\pi i}{2}}) } \displaystyle= \displaystyle 0 (59) as expected, where we shrunk \tilde{\mathcal{S}}_{c}(S^{2}) in the third line. The remaining entries of the character table can be reconstructed similarly and the results are recorded in Appendix B . IV.2 \mathbb{D}_{k} for k -even The k -even case contains more families of operators than the k -odd case, but the idea is the same. Let us set k=2m . The conjugacy classes are: \{1\},\,\{r^{m}\},\,\{r^{t},r^{-t}\},\,\{r^{p}s\,|\,p\text{-even}\},\,\{r^{p}s\,|\,p\text{-odd}\}, (60) where 1\leq t\leq m-1 and the last two are both size m conjugacy classes. \mathbb{D}_{2m} has four 1D irreps 1, \chi_{+-},\chi_{-+},\chi_{--} and m-1 2D irreps labeled by \chi_{j} , where 1\leq j\leq m-1 . Let us first work out the Wilson lines. First we have the trivial line \mathbf{1} and U_{c}=e^{i\oint c} , which can be identified with \mathbf{1} and \chi_{+-} . We also have the gauge invariant object: U_{a}(M_{1})=e^{i\oint_{M_{1}}ma_{1}} (61) This is because a gauge transformation: ma_{1}\mapsto ma_{1}+\delta_{c}(m\alpha_{0}) (62) on ma_{1} shifts it by an ordinary coboundary. In terms of the component form: \begin{split}\Big(\delta_{c}(m\alpha_{0})\Big)_{ij}=&\rho(c_{ij})(m\alpha_{0})_{j}-(m\alpha_{0})_{i}\\ =&(m\alpha_{0})_{j}-(m\alpha_{0})_{i}\\ =&\delta(m\alpha_{0})_{ij}\end{split} (63) where we have used the fact that the charge conjugation action represented by the twist \rho(c_{ij}) acts trivially on m\in\mathbb{Z}_{k} . Therefore, this operator does not need an \mathcal{S}_{c} dressing. Fusing U_{a} with U_{c} creates another invertible Wilson line: U_{a,c}=U_{a}\times U_{c} (64) which we identify as the irrep \chi_{--} . The non-invertible line construction is analogous to the k -odd case, so we directly state the result: \hat{U}_{a}^{(j)}=\frac{e^{i\oint ja_{1}}+e^{-i\oint ja_{1}}}{2}\mathcal{S}_{c}(M_{1}) (65) where 1\leq j\leq m-1 . The ’t Hooft surface construction is analogous to the k -odd case. The only difference is the dressing of the magnetic condensations responsible for the quantum dimensions of the operators. There are only two invertible surfaces: \mathds{1}\quad\text{and}\quad U_{\tilde{a}}=e^{im\oint\tilde{a}_{2}} (66) There are m-1 non-invertible surfaces of quantum dimension 2, corresponding to the m-1 size-2 conjugacy classes: \hat{U}_{\tilde{a}}^{(r)}=\frac{e^{i\oint r\tilde{a}}+e^{-i\oint r\tilde{a}}}{2}\tilde{\mathcal{S}}_{c} (67) where r\in\{1,2,\dots,m-1\} . The remaining two size m conjugacy classes are given by constructing gauge invariant objects with e^{i\oint_{M_{2}}\tilde{c}_{2}} . There are two natural non-gauge-invariant objects with quantum dimension m : \begin{split}M_{[s]}&=\sum_{l=0}^{m-1}e^{2i\oint l\tilde{a}_{2}}\\ M_{[rs]}&=\sum_{l=0}^{m-1}e^{i\oint(2l+1)\tilde{a}_{2}}\end{split} (68) They can be made gauge invariant by further dressing with the higher gauging condensation defect \Delta_{c}=\frac{1}{2}\tilde{S}_{c} , which is an electric condensation defect associated to the \mathbb{Z}_{k} normal subgroup of \mathbb{D}_{k} . Therefore, the correct operators are: \begin{split}\hat{U}_{\tilde{c}}^{[s]}&=\frac{1}{2}e^{i\oint_{M_{2}}\tilde{c}_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{S}}_{c}M_{[s]}\\ \hat{U}_{\tilde{c}}^{[rs]}&=\frac{1}{2}e^{i\oint_{M_{2}}\tilde{c}_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{S}}_{c}M_{[rs]}\end{split} (69) IV.3 Equivalent Formulations of Untwisted \mathbb{D}_{4} Gauge Theories Given the \mathbb{D}_{4} -DW theory (Eq. ( 31 )) in Sec. II.3 , in this section, we construct the corresponding Wilson and ’t Hooft operators using the higher gauging condensation defects. The bare \mathbb{Z}_{2}\times\mathbb{Z}_{2} variables and the dressing factors will depend on which split extension presentation we use as introduced in Sec. II.3 . For the operator content of the central extension, see 43 ; 37 ; 21 ; 38 ; 5 ; 4 for further details. We first consider the representative \rho_{1} , where \mathbb{D}_{4} is defined as \mathbb{D}_{4}=\braket{a,b,t\,|\,a^{2}=b^{2}=t^{2}=1,ab=ba,tat=b,tbt=a}. (70) The conjugacy classes are given as \{1\},\,\{ab\},\,\{a,b\},\,\{t,abt\},\,\{at,bt\}. (71) \mathbb{D}_{4} has four 1D irreps: 1, \chi_{+-} , \chi_{-+} , \chi_{--} , and one 2D irrep Following the same procedure in Sec. IV.1 and IV.2 , the four invertible Wilson lines are \displaystyle\mathds{1},\quad U_{c}(M_{1})=e^{i\oint c_{1}},\quad U_{a,b}(M_{1})=e^{i\oint a_{1}+b_{1}}, \displaystyle U_{a,b,c}(M_{1})=e^{i\oint a_{1}+b_{1}+c_{1}}, (72) and one non-invertible line is \hat{U}_{a}=\frac{1}{2}\left(e^{i\oint a_{1}}+e^{i\oint b_{1}}\right)\mathcal{S}_{c}, (73) where \mathcal{S}_{c} is defined by Eq. ( 51 ). Similarly, the ’t Hooft surfaces can be constructed as follows. The two invertible surfaces correspond to the size-1 conjugacy classes: \mathds{1},\quad U_{\tilde{a},\tilde{b}}=e^{i\oint\tilde{a}_{2}+\tilde{b}_{2}}. (74) The remaining surfaces are non-invertible \displaystyle\hat{U}_{\tilde{a}}= \displaystyle\frac{1}{2}e^{i\oint\tilde{a}_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{S}}_{c}M_{[ab]}, (75) \displaystyle\hat{U}_{\tilde{c}}= \displaystyle\frac{1}{2}e^{i\oint\tilde{c}_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{S}}_{c}M_{[ab]}, (76) \displaystyle\hat{U}_{\tilde{a},\tilde{c}}= \displaystyle\frac{1}{2}e^{i\oint\tilde{a}_{2}+\tilde{c}_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{S}}_{c}M_{[ab]}, (77) where M_{[ab]}=(1+e^{i\oint\tilde{a}_{2}+\tilde{b}_{2}})/2 . Now we consider another choice of split extension by replacing the twist conditions with tat^{-1}=a and tbt^{-1}=ab . Again, there are four 1D irreps labeled by the signs of b and t and one 2D irrep. The conjugacy classes are given as \{1\},\,\{a\},\,\{b,ab\},\,\{t,at\},\,\{bt,abt\}. (78) The four invertible Wilson lines are \displaystyle\mathbf{1},\quad U_{c}(M_{1})=e^{i\oint c_{1}},\quad U_{b}(M_{1})=e^{i\oint b_{1}}, \displaystyle U_{b,c}(M_{1})=e^{i\oint b_{1}+c_{1}}, (79) and one non-invertible line is \hat{U}_{a}=\frac{1}{2}\left(e^{i\oint a_{1}}+e^{i\oint a_{1}+b_{1}}\right)\mathcal{S}_{c}. (80) The ’t Hooft surfaces are listed as follows: \displaystyle\mathds{1},\quad U_{\tilde{a}}=e^{i\oint\tilde{a}_{2}},\quad\hat{U}_{\tilde{b}}=\frac{1}{2}e^{i\oint\tilde{b}_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{S}}_{c}M_{a}, \displaystyle\hat{U}_{\tilde{c}}=\frac{1}{2}e^{i\oint\tilde{c}_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{S}}_{c}M_{a},\quad\hat{U}_{\tilde{a},\tilde{c}}=\frac{1}{2}e^{i\oint\tilde{a}_{2}+\tilde{c}_{2}}\tilde{\mathcal{S}}_{c}M_{a}, (81) where M_{a}=(1+e^{i\oint\tilde{a}_{2}})/2 . Following the previous discussions in Sec. IV.1 and IV.2 , we can show that all these operators give the correct quantum dimensions and Hopf links, thus both of them reproduce the same untwisted \mathbb{D}_{4} DW theory. V Conclusion In this work, we outlined a procedure for constructing BF-Lagrangians for a G -DW theory by gauging an abelian H^{(0)} symmetry in abelian A -DW theory: 1\rightarrow A\rightarrow G\rightarrow H\rightarrow 1 (82) We explicitly constructed the operator spectrum with appropriate higher gauging condensation defects for G=\mathbb{D}_{k} and verified our Lagrangian construction by matching the linking invariant calculation with the character table of G . As advertised in 17 ; 18 , DW theories are a simple class of a broader class of topological sigma models M_{D}\rightarrow X , where X has a finite number of non-vanishing homotopy groups. When the only non-vanishing homotopy group of X is its fundamental group, we recover the ordinary DW theory. For a more general target space X with a finite number of non-vanishing higher homotopy group, the corresponding topological sigma models are typically called higher group gauge theories. If a BF formulation of the higher group gauge theory is available, it should be a rather straightforward exercise to construct gauge invariant objects from gauge transformations of the BF-action. However, a precise operator formalism of the theory would also require the identification of appropriate defects stacked on the extended operators to ensure gauge invariance. Similar to our previous work 43 , the stacked higher gauging condensation defects contain nontrivial information about the quantum dimensions of the operators. For future directions, it would be interesting to study the BF-type Lagrangians of more general higher group gauge theories and the corresponding operator formalism, which would provide a more physical approach to studying exotic bosonic topological orders as well as symTFT/symTO/topological holography for a wider class of non-invertible/ higher group global symmetries. Acknowledgements. We thank Ken Intriligator and John McGreevy for helpful discussions. E.Y.Y. is supported by Simons Foundation award 568420 (Simons Investigator) and award 888994 (The Simons Collaboration on Global Categorical Symmetries). Appendix A Homotopy Theory Basics In this appendix, we quickly review some concepts of homotopy theory involved in the main text. Homotopy theory is the study of spaces and structured objects up to continuous deformations. The main topic of concern is maps between topological spaces and oftentimes it is also convenient to present concepts in terms of commutative diagrams. Now consider a map p:E\rightarrow B and another map g:X\rightarrow E . As mentioned in the main text, we can always compose a third map g_{*}p=p\circ g so that the following diagram commutes. {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces E} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces X} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces B} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces p} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces g} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\tilde{g}_{*}p=p\circ g} (83) However, given a map f:X\rightarrow B and a map p:E\rightarrow B , it is not guaranteed that one can find a third map \tilde{f}:X\rightarrow E so that f=p\circ\tilde{f} and the following diagram commutes: {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces E} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces X} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces B} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces p} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\exists\,\tilde{f}\,?} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces f} (84) If one can find such an \tilde{f} , then it is called a lift of the map f:X\rightarrow B through p . For example, consider the group extension: 0\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{2}\xrightarrow{\iota}\mathbb{Z}_{4}\xrightarrow{p}\mathbb{Z}_{2}^{\prime}\rightarrow 0 (85) Let O be the trivial group homomorphism sending all elements of \mathbb{Z}_{2} to the identity element of \mathbb{Z}_{2}^{\prime} , then \iota:\mathbb{Z}_{2}\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{4} would be a lift of the homomorphism O through p . On the other hand, consider the identity map \text{id}:\mathbb{Z}_{2}\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{2}^{\prime} and p:\mathbb{Z}_{4}\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{2}^{\prime} , and there does not exist any homomorphism lifting id through p . Let’s consider a particular space X and a special map p:E\rightarrow B so that for any map f:X\rightarrow B there exists a lift \tilde{f} of f through p . If for any homotopy f_{t}:X\times I\rightarrow B of f , there exists a map \tilde{f}_{t}:X\times I\rightarrow E so that the following diagram commutes: {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces E} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces X\times I} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces B} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces p} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\tilde{f}_{t}} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces f_{t}} (86) and \tilde{f}_{0}=\tilde{f} , we say that p has the homotopy lifting property for X . Namely, we relaxed the triangle diagram for lifting by smearing f and \tilde{f} with homotopies up to compatibility conditions. Furthermore, if the map p:E\rightarrow B satisfies the homotopy lifting property for all spaces X , then p:E\rightarrow B is called a fibration , where E is the total space and B is the base space. Let b_{0}\in B be a basepoint, then the pre-image of the base point F=p^{-1}(b_{0}) in E is a typical fiber . In this context, the section of a fibration p:E\rightarrow B is simply a map s that partially inverts p in a sense that p\circ s=\text{id}_{B} . Finally, we introduce a method to construct new fibrations from maps onto the base space B . For any map f:X\rightarrow B , we can construct a space: f^{*}E=X\times_{B}E=\{(x,e)\in X\times E\,|\,f(x)=p(e)\} (87) The map f^{*}p:E\rightarrow X acts as a projection f^{*}p(x,e)=x called the pullback fibration . Concretely, we have the following commutative square diagram: {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces f^{*}E} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces E} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces X} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces B} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces f^{*}p} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces p} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces f} (88) To recover the familiar concepts of smooth fiber bundles, one needs to add additional constraints on homotopy fibrations. If we further require that E is locally a product space p^{-1}(U)\simeq U\times F , where U\subset B and F is the typical fiber, then a homotopy fibration becomes a fiber bundle. Further demanding smooth structures on E,F,B and extra compatibility conditions recovers the definition of smooth fiber bundles. Appendix B Linking Invariant Calculations In this appendix, we record the Hopf-link calculations in untwisted \mathbb{D}_{k} -DW theories from path integrals summarized in Table. 1 and 2 . The character table information can be extracted by matching with Eq. ( 40 ) Table 1: Linking invariants for k -odd. \begin{array}[]{c|ccc}\langle W_{\rho}(S^{1})\,T_{g}(S^{2})\rangle&\mathds{1}&U_{\hat{a}}^{(t)}&\hat{U}_{\hat{c}}\\ \hline\cr\mathbf{1}&1&2&2\\ \epsilon&1&2&-2\\ \chi_{j}&2&4\cos\!\left(\frac{2\pi jt}{k}\right)&0\end{array} Table 2: Linking invariants for k -even. \begin{array}[]{c|ccccc}\langle W_{\rho}(S^{1})\,T_{g}(S^{2})\rangle&\mathds{1}&U_{\hat{a}}&\hat{U}_{\hat{a}}^{(r)}&\hat{U}_{\tilde{c}}^{[s]}&\hat{U}_{\tilde{c}}^{[rs]}\\ \hline\cr\mathbf{1}&1&1&2&m&m\\ \chi_{+-}&1&1&2&-m&-m\\ \chi_{-+}&1&(-1)^{m}&2(-1)^{r}&m&-m\\ \chi_{--}&1&(-1)^{m}&2(-1)^{r}&-m&m\\ \chi_{j}&2&2(-1)^{j}&4\cos\!\left(\frac{2\pi jr}{k}\right)&0&0\end{array}