Attaining Spectral Energy Distributions With Sub-Percent Uncertainties: All-Sky DA White Dwarf Spectrophotometric Standard Stars For Large Telescopes And Surveys. Facilities: HST (WFC3, STIS), SOAR , MMT , Gemini , Gaia , PaNSTARRS , SDSS , DES , DECaLS , Las Cumbres Observatory . Abhijit Saha, Edward W. Olszewski, Benjamin M. Boyd, Thomas Matheson, Tim Axelrod, Gautham Narayan, Annalisa Calamida, Jay B. Holberg, Ivan Hubeny, Ralph C. Bohlin, Susana Deustua, Armin Rest, Jenna Claver, Sean Points, Christopher W. Stubbs, Elena Sabbi, John W. Mackenty Abstract We present a synopsis of the project to establish thirty-two new faint ( 16.5 ≤ V ≤ 19.8 16.5\leq V\leq 19.8 ) DA white dwarfs as spectrophotometric standards distributed over the whole sky. Our results validate the use of fully radiative pure hydrogen model fluxes for hot DA white dwarfs to predict the observed broadband fluxes from near ultraviolet through the near infrared to accuracies of a few parts per thousand. After fitting the line of sight reddenings simultaneously with the model spectral energy distributions of these stars against spectroscopic and multi-band photometric observations, we have shown that residuals have an rms of typically 0.4 percent. This indicates that the complications from interstellar dust extinction have been adequately mitigated. Our stars supplement the three brighter DA white dwarfs that define the flux scale of CALSPEC. The consequent photometric accuracy, their all sky coverage, and their brightness range that matches the dynamic range of large telescopes, constitutes an unprecedented ensemble of standard stars for both ground as well as space based use. This paper targets readers who may wish to use these as standard stars, and provides for them the essential content to understand their strengths and limitations, without traversing the technical details of analysis that are already captured in a series of papers since 2016. The narrative here describes the motivation, justification, and evolution of the analysis methods; the input data that constrain the modeling; as well as the stability of our results in the face of future improvements in models. I Introduction In a decade-long series of papers, 38 , 16 , 39 , 15 , 3 , and culminating in 13 , we have documented the observations, methodology and results for selecting, testing, and calibrating a set of thirty five DA white dwarf (DAWDs) as spectrophotometric standard stars. To the three relatively bright DA white dwarfs that have anchored the CALSPEC fluxes for over two decades, we have added thirty-two DAWDs in the magnitude range 16.5\leq V\leq 19.8 (with the majority around V\approx 18 ), which places them in the optimal signal-to-noise ratio dynamic range for observations with the largest telescopes and space based facilities in use today. The full ensemble, including the three bright DAWDs is thus 35 stars. In the spectral range from \approx 275 nm in the ultraviolet (UV) through \approx 1600 nm (H-band) in the near infrared (IR), our ensemble of DAWDs are validated to be accurate for broadband photometry at the uncertainty level of a few \times 0.1%, when compared against space based broadband photometry obtained with the Wide Field Camera 3 (WFC3) instrument on board the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) using 5 filters in the UV/Visible (UVIS) channel ( F275W,F336W,F475W,F625W,F775W ) and the F160W filter in the near-infrared (IR) channel in 3 HST programs in Cycle 20 (Program 12967; 2012-2013), Cycle 22 (Program 13711; 2014-2016), and Cycle 25 (Program 15113; 2018). To our knowledge, this network of 35 stars constitutes one of the most accurate and coherently calibrated set of photometric standards. They are available over the entire sky and the thirty-two fainter stars present a “sweet spot” in terms of dynamic range and signal-to-noise, accessible to the largest aperture telescopes and modern space facilities. The co-analysis of HST Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph (STIS) UV spectra of 19 of these stars described by 13 leave the model fluxes in the near-UV through near-IR wavelengths essentially unchanged, which observationally validates the models as standard fluxes further into the UV to \approx 130 nm for the subset of our ensemble with available STIS spectra. Full confidence in this conclusion awaits the analysis and successful validation of all of our standard stars. For the UV and IR calibrations to attain the same reliability as that achieved here for the spectral coverage of WFC3, will require data in the UV and in the IR with the same demonstrable internal consistency across all objects, along with showing that the synthetic fluxes and interstellar extinction behavior continue to reproduce the observed fluxes at those outlying wavelengths. Subsets of our standard stars are embedded in the survey areas of existing and future programs such as the Panoramic Survey Telescope & Rapid Response System (PanSTARRS), the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS), the Dark Energy Survey (DES), Gaia, and Euclid, and in forthcoming future surveys, notably the NSF-DOE Vera C. Rubin Observatory’s Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST), the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope (Roman), and NASA’s projected Habitable Worlds Observatory. The above cited papers, and the results presented therein, cover all the relevant details of this decade-long effort. Anyone interested in the details of how the experiment was conducted as well as how the data were processed and analyzed (in various stages) can find full descriptions there. However, we recognize that many potential users of the standard stars will be interested in the strengths, caveats, and limitations of these DAWD standards, including the underlying assumptions inherent in defining them as spectrophotometric standard stars. The purpose of this paper is to lay out this information so that a potential user of these standard stars is able to decide whether they are suitable for the purpose they have in mind, without having to delve into the full details of the methods and analysis employed. We have made a conscious decision not to repeat figures and tables from earlier papers, but to cite them at their original locations. I.1 Why DA white dwarfs? The over-arching rationale for choosing DAWDs is that, by definition, these stars have pure hydrogen atmospheres. Moreover, hot ( T>15000\thinspace K ) DAWDs are fully radiative and not subject to pulsational instabilities. Their photospheres are completely characterized by two parameters: the effective temperature, T_{e} , and the surface gravity \log\thinspace g ( 28 , e.g.,) . This means that their atmospheres are stable and therefore not intrinsically variable in brightness. Being of pure hydrogen, they are the least complicated to model of any class of stellar atmospheres. Thus, of all the various kinds of stars, these appear to be the ideal candidates for which one can expect the best predicted spectral energy distributions (SEDs) from modeling. 11 demonstrated, with three DAWDs, that their spectroscopically determined respective values of T_{e} and \log\thinspace g predicted their relative SEDs to better than 1\% . The CALSPEC system, which provides flux standards for HST, and the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), is anchored on the model-predicted SEDs of these three stars ( 10 ) . Our experiment compares the detected flux above the terrestrial atmosphere using WFC3 on HST to the predicted SED as informed by ground-based spectra as described through the chain of papers cited above. We have sought to test just how well the model atmospheres predict the SEDs for a larger set of 35 DAWDs: 32 faint DAWDs plus the three DAWDs that anchor the CALSPEC system. As shown by 3 , within the wavelength range from \approx 270{\rm~nm~to~}\approx 900{\rm~nm} , non-local thermodynamical equilibrium (NLTE) white dwarf atmosphere models predict the wavelength dependence of the SEDs for these 35 stars to within an rms uncertainty of \approx 0.004 mag for broadband passbands. At 1600{\rm~nm} , where the IR channel of WFC3 is used, the count-rate non-linearity 1 1 1 https://hst-docs.stsci.edu/wfc3dhb/chapter-7-wfc3-ir-sources-of-error/7-7-count-rate-non-linearity must be accounted for. The error weighted rms for the sample is \approx 0.006 mag, but is biased by the brighter objects of the ensemble. The unweighted rms at 1600{\rm~nm} is \approx 0.008 mag and includes the three bright DAWDs. 13 (hereafter B25) represents the final analysis with the fully matured methodology, which uses updated DAWD model atmospheres and dust models for line-of-sight reddening, joint inference methods for both photometry and spectra to mitigate correlated errors, and incorporates modeling and comparison of observed STIS UV spectra where available (for 19 of the 35 DAWDs). This method produces a reduction of the rms residuals by up to 0.001 mag compared to those in A23. The results illustrate the robustness of the analysis to changes in the models and to extending the wavelength range, as described further in § III.3 and § IV . For calibrating existing optical surveys, our synthetic magnitudes for those surveys based on our derived SEDs (B25) and on published survey passbands are available on Zenodo (see § V.1 ) In § II we describe the motivation for our work, and the factors that guided our experimental design, while § III follows the evolution of both scope and methodology of our work and the reasons for them. The intercomparison of results from various stages of our work, as well as with results from alternative analyses (outside the confines of our methodology, but using data for this project) provides perspective about overall robustness and dependencies on models. This is covered in § IV . Future efforts that can test and expand the reach of these standards to other wavelengths (e.g., making them useful for JWST, and establishing standardization in the UV) is under development by our team and by others, with a general discussion and summary in § V . II Needs and Perspectives There has been a pressing need for a way to tie spectrophotometric measurements over the whole sky in absolute physical units linked to the SI International System of units (we use the cgs alternative, and the related AB magnitudes familiar to astronomers) to sub-percent uncertainties. Cosmological studies, such as those using faint Type Ia Supernovae as probes, or those relying on photometric redshifts (photo-z) require uncertainties smaller than a percent in colors (i.e. flux ratios). Specifically, the uncertainty in determining the equation of state for dark energy is dominated by measurement uncertainties in the photometry, as exemplified in 4 and 30 . System-wide consistency in calibration across ground and space observations, across wavelength ranges probed by different instrumentation, as well as assurance of linearity across all brightness levels of interest to astronomy depend on the mitigation of systematic errors in calibration. An astronomical point source illuminates a telescope’s pupil with a collimated beam. The telescope focuses such an object onto a detector as a point-like image, whose intensity can be recorded and measured (after adjusting, as best as possible, for instrumental signatures, such as bias corrections and flat fields). The problem at hand is to translate that measurement onto an absolute scale with physical units, i.e., in terms of, say, \rm ergs\thinspace cm^{-2}s^{-1}Hz^{-1} , and infer what that flux would be if received above the terrestrial atmosphere. There is a rich history of attempts to do so beginning with the pioneering work of 41 , 26 , 25 , and 40 . The seminal work of setting up the CALSPEC standards (e.g. 8 ) based on the SEDs of 3 bright (V \sim 12 mag) DAWDs has been the state of the art, with percent-level uncertainties relative to the models. However, a set of standard stars faint enough for modern day large-aperture telescopes with sub-percent systemic uncertainties has been elusive. Our work has been motivated by the need to address this shortcoming. SI-traceable spectrophotometric measurements at specific wavelengths exist for Vega in the visible (cf. the above cited papers). 37 ’s analysis of the published results of a half dozen spectroscopic experiments provided a value of the flux at 555.6 nm for Vega. 45 provides photometric fluxes for Sirius and Vega at wavelengths beyond 4 \mu m (microns). Vega is known to have circumstellar dust ( 51 ) , and is incompatible with Sirius at the mid-IR wavelengths where the latter has accurate absolute flux determinations. Thus, at this time, independent experimental validation of models for Vega and Sirius remain uncertain at the order of 1\% , but the absolute flux at certain specific wavelengths for Vega and for Sirius are known. In the absence of high accuracy direct measurements based on laboratory SI standards, absolute stellar fluxes have been inferred from modeling the observed features of certain types of stellar atmospheres. The modeling uses the resulting inferred physical parameters of the stellar photosphere to produce an SED which is normalized to bright stars such as Vega and Sirius. We are unaware of any independent observational validation of the SEDs spanning large wavelength baselines (UV through mid-infrared, panchromatic) of such models to better than \sim 1\% . We recognize that the problem can be partitioned into two independent parts: 1. The wavelength dependence of the SED, which need only be measured in a relative way for the same object at different wavelengths. This is sometimes referred to as the chromatic or color component. 2. The absolute received flux for at least one wavelength that is ultimately tied to absolute physical units. These two components together provide a complete specification, but, in practice, present very different complexities when we try to measure them. SEDs can be measured as the flux ratios at different wavelengths for an unvarying source, and, for a stable detector, can be calibrated against sources with known SEDs, such as standardized laboratory sources. Absolute brightness, however, requires knowledge of the actual rate of incidence of photons at the top of the atmosphere, which is beset by its own set of additional complications. Our experiments have shown that the wavelength dependence of SEDs (hereafter wSED) can be determined for astronomical sources to very high accuracies, achieving sub-percent uncertainties, whereas the achromatic normalization of the SED (nSED) leaves room for improvement, and is currently uncertain for astronomical applications at the 1\%~{\rm to}~2\% (1-sigma) level. Astrophysical applications, such as characterization of the host stars of exo-planets, will benefit from improvements in the accuracy of the absolute achromatic zero-point ( 52 , e.g.) , whereas sub-percent calibrations of ”colors” is, for example, the dominant term in the error budget for determining the dark-energy equation of state using galaxy photo-z’s. Our methods bring significant improvements to the accuracy of wSEDs, but rely on external constraints for nSED. The disambiguation of these two components in the calibration will recur in the discussion of our results later in this paper. II.1 Instrumental vs. Atmospheric Modulation Consider first a ground-based facility, with a pixelated imaging device at the focal plane of a telescope. The detected time integrated signal in counts (ADU) from incident flux F_{\lambda} at wavelength \lambda detected from a source at a location (x,y) on the detector can be written as: ADU~~=~~A~\int_{0}^{\Delta T}dt\int_{0}^{\infty}\lambda^{-1}~F_{\lambda}~S^{tot}(x,y,alt,az,t,\lambda)~d{\lambda} (1) where S^{tot} represents the system response that, in general, depends on the position on the detector ( x,y ), the direction the telescope is pointed ( alt,az , which accounts for atmospheric extinction), and temporal and wavelength dependent variations in the response ( t , and \lambda ). The factor A is a constant for the system, and includes the collecting area of the telescope and other invariants. It is reasonable to write S^{tot} as being composed of two mutually independent parts: S^{tot}(x,y,alt,az,t,\lambda)=S^{inst}(x,y,t,\lambda)\times S^{atm}({\rm alt,az},t,\lambda) (2) where S^{inst} captures the response from the top of the telescope through to the detector and S^{atm} accounts for the modulation suffered through the terrestrial atmosphere, which can depend on direction and time, as well as the wavelength. For a telescope in space, S^{atm} is effectively unity and invariant. It is possible to determine and monitor S^{inst} in ”laboratory” mode, e.g., with techniques described by 53 and demonstrated by the DECal Spectrophotometric calibration system 35 for calibrating the instrumental response of the Dark Energy Camera (DECam). Such a setup is specifically built into the Rubin observatory infrastructure, where flat fields illuminated by tuneable (wavelength) lasers can be used to map the ”monochromatic” response at all wavelengths across the face of the detector ( 33 ) . Care must be exercised to ascertain that the telescope pupil is uniformly illuminated, with a well-understood angular dependence, so that the system response for point sources as well as the surface brightness of extended sources can be quantified. Absolute energies entering the telescope pupil can be measured with NIST 2 2 2 National Institute of Standards and Technology detectors calibrated to exacting standards. It would seem difficult and perhaps prohibitive to outfit telescopes in space in the same way. A much-dreamed option is to ”fly” a standard source in space (or very high above most of the terrestrial atmosphere in a balloon) that can be accessed both from the ground and from space-based observatories. To date, such facilities have not come to fruition. At the time of this writing, several space- and balloon-borne experiments are under development. Direct determination and/or measurement informed modeling of S^{atm} is much more complex, but efforts are underway to measure and monitor the atmospheric extinction and other telluric effects in real time. For progress on this front, see for example: 42 ; 50 . Using real stars as calibrators has the practical advantage that they are observed in the same manner as other ”unknown” astronomical targets. This finesses the problem of ascertaining that the calibration source illuminates the telescope in the same way as the unknowns. Incidentally, this is also the argument for having standard stars within the dynamic range of the telescope and instrument system, as practices such as de-focusing the telescope to accommodate bright standards by spreading their light on the detector affects the illumination pattern through the optics and can introduce systematic differences in S^{tot} . The earliest experiments to bring astronomical flux measurements to an absolute scale calibrated the bright star Vega against physical laboratory standards ( 41 ; 26 ) , giving birth to spectrophotometry. The goal then, as now, is to set select stellar objects onto the physical absolute flux scale and to subsequently use the star(s) as standards. With our growth in the understanding of stellar atmospheres and our ability to model them, it soon became apparent that, for select kinds of stars, such models produced better predictions of the SEDs of such standard stars than the direct calibration from ground-based laboratory sources. 5 showed this in a definitive manner. It is safe to state that the most self-consistent calibrators in use today are from models of stellar atmospheres. However, we do not yet have the final word on nSED, the achromatic normalization. The fidelity of Vega, long used as a primary standard star, is questionable at the few percent level, since we now know that it has dust contamination around it ( 2 , 51 49 ). We are seeing progress in developing experiments by other teams who are using direct calibration methods with satellite and balloon experiments ( 43 ; 18 ) . We claim that our experiment succeeds in bringing down the uncertainties in wSED to \sim 0.4\% (1-sigma) in the visible, and to \sim 0.7\% (1-sigma) in the near-IR. To proceed using models of stellar atmospheres as predictors of wSEDs, we must choose wisely. With this in mind, and for reasons detailed below, we embarked on testing the efficacy of using the predicted SEDs of hot DAWDs from their atmospheric models. The various stages of our project are recounted by A23, which traces the evolution of our methods through 38 , 16 , 39 , and 15 . II.2 Methodology Keeping the above discussion in mind, we set our focus on testing the predictability of wavelength dependence of the SEDs, i.e, the wSED component, from DAWD models to greater accuracy. However, we must recognize that re-examining the achromatic absolute flux zero-point would require a very different experiment. At the time when we began our investigation, the demand clearly was for improving wSED, since it affects a variety of issues: (a) Accuracy in wSED limits the accuracy for photometric redshift determinations. (b) The availability of accurate wSEDs allows reliably accurate transformations across different photometric systems, if the transmission functions of the passbands are known. (c) Most physical processes under investigation require accurate wSED to sub-percent uncertainty levels. In contrast, a 1% or 2% uncertainty in setting an nSED zero-point is not as critical. This has changed since the time we designed our experiment, as, for instance, exoplanet work can demand sub-percent accuracies in nSED as well. Our experiment has three observational components: 1. Ground-based spectra from which we can derive the physical parameters T_{e} and \log g , which in turn predicts the SED emerging from the DAWD star. A variety of facilities were used to obtain these spectra as described further below. At a late stage of our effort, UV spectra of 19 of the faint DAWD stars were obtained with HST/STIS, to help test the validity of our inferred extinction/reddening, as described by B25. 2. Broadband photometry (over a wide wavelength range) of potential candidate DAWDs, obtained above the atmosphere to eliminate atmospheric effects, referred to an instrumental system that is internally standardized across all observations. 3. Ground-based monitoring of all candidates for variability on a variety of time-scales over a period of two years, to demonstrate that they are indeed non-variable. The evolution of how we have treated 1) above is described in § III . For item 2) above, internal standardization was achieved for the photometry with WFC3 on board the HST, by contemporaneous measurement of the 3 primary CALSPEC DAWD standard stars from 7 . These 3 stars can trace the sensitivity of the instrument over time spans when the remaining candidate DAWDs were observed. For item 3) we monitored the brightness of our target stars against neighboring objects in the field, using the Las Cumbres Observatory (LCO) Network of Telescopes. We sampled over a variety of time scales, over a total duration of \sim 2 years. This allowed us to ensure that our ensemble is free of objects showing any variability, such as from debris disks. For those interested, details of all observational aspects listed above can be found in C19 and C22. The notional procedure is to compare the SEDs predicted by the spectra (which give us T_{e} and \log g , the two parameters that completely specify the atmospheric model for DAWDs) to the internally standardized instrumental pan-chromatic photometry of the DAWD stars chosen as potential standards. There is a range of SEDs due to the range of T_{e} and \log g values derived for different DAWDs. How accurately are these reflected in the photometry? The answer to this question defines the accuracy to which DAWDs can be used as standards, as first done by 7 . We also immediately recognize that, since we aim to test DAWDs that are a hundred times fainter than the 3 bright CALSPEC DAWDs, this implies that they are \sim 10 times farther away, at several hundred parsecs, where the effects of reddening cannot be ignored. If the reddening is modest, the colors from panchromatic photometry leave enough degrees of freedom to fit a reddening term E(B-V) to resolve a discrepancy in matching the observed photometry to the predicted SEDs. The process to do so introduces several complications, and the best way to handle them drove the evolution of the analysis, as described in our series of past papers and discussed in § III III Project History III.1 Object Selection We began by finding suitable candidates along the celestial equator. DAWDs identified spectroscopically, with estimated T_{e}\geq 20,000K and T_{e}\leq 80,000K and V\geq 16.5 mag (with a preference for V\sim 18 mag) were selected from the Villanova Catalog ( 36 ) and from compilations from the SDSS survey ( 19 ; 34 , e.g.,) . The equatorial objects were supplemented with similar candidates at northern declinations, also from the same sources. For the interested reader, further details for the selection, photometry, and spectroscopy of the equatorial and northern DAWDs were presented in C19. At the time (before Gaia results were available), there were no equivalent faint white dwarf catalogs for southern declinations. A list of possible candidates was compiled from objects with high proper motion and blue colors in the desired brightness range, either from lists of probable white dwarfs compiled by ( 22 ; 46 , e.g.,) , or examining (by eye) the digital images from the southern sky survey of high proper motion stars identified in the SuperCosmos Sky Survey ( 24 ) . Since these did not (at the time) have any confirmatory spectra in the literature, 48 candidate objects in the resulting compiled list were then observed spectroscopically using the Goodman spectrograph ( 17 ) on the 4-meter SOAR telescope. The spectra were obtained with signal-to-noise to permit the detailed analysis necessary if the candidates passed the final selection. As described in C22, 19 objects were selected with an eye to keeping spatial uniformity across the southern sky. All objects, in the celestial north, near the equator, and in the south, were then monitored for variability using the LCO telescopes, over a range of timescales, spanning a total of 2 years. These were combined with time-domain observations available from other surveys. Details of the process are described in § 2 through § 4 of C22. The final set of 35 validated spectrophotometric standards is presented in Table 1 of C22, with the sky distribution illustrated in Fig. 1 therein. The information is also available in Table 1 and Fig. 1 of B25. III.2 Photometry and Spectroscopy The photometric data were extracted from images taken with the WFC3 camera of the HST in three separate programs. In HST Cycle-20 (GO-12967; PI A. Saha), 9 equatorial targets were observed in 5 passbands: F336W , F475 W, F625 W, F775 W with the UVIS channel, and F160 W with the IR channel. These observations were made with the full field of view (FOV) afforded by the respective detectors. Photometry of the targets was performed by multiple methods, as described in § 3 of N16, to ensure absence of systematic effects from the method used. From the scatter in measured fluxes from multiple exposures for each target, we learned, unsurprisingly for these critically sampled images, that best results came from the images that had not undergone any resampling (i.e individual exposures that had been bias-subtracted and flat-fielded but not altered geometrically). Accuracy characterized by rms uncertainties of a few ~\times~0.001 mag (the scatter from multiple exposures, as well as from the noise properties of the images themselves) were routinely attained. Spectra of five of the nine targets were obtained from the Gemini Multi-Object Spectrograph (GMOS) on the Gemini South telescope. The data are described in § 2.2 of N16, and the determination of T_{e} and \log g from the Balmer lines is discussed in § 4 therein. The subsequent analysis by N16, where the photometry is compared to the synthetic photometry from the model atmosphere (using parameters derived from the spectra) showed clearly that a scaling of the standard reddening law by one parameter, ( E(B-V) ), adequately accounts for the systematic chromatic discrepancy, and leaves residuals of a few \times 0.001 mag per passband that are fully consistent with the reported photometric errors. These results provided a general validation for our experiment. Nevertheless, this experiment also informed us of the need to make improvements and increase observational efficiency: 1. To control for systematic changes in the photometry (due to temporal drifts in the system response for whatever reason), so that all objects would be on a self consistent scale within each pass-band, we decided to contemporaneously observe the 3 bright DAWDs that define the CALSPEC scale. 2. Explicitly recognize the correlation between derived T_{e} and reddening parameter E(B-V) . To mitigate this, we would have to determine T_{e} , \log g and E(B-V) in one integrated process, rather than analyzing the spectra and photometry in separate sequential steps. Additionally, we could see that adding an additional passband farther in the UV would help to resolve the degeneracy. So, an additional observation in the F275W band was added to all observations after Cycle 20 (2016). 3. Fitting the Balmer line profiles suffers from uncertainties in knowing where the local continuum is. The data can suffer from positioning errors at the spectrograph aperture, possibly compounded by atmospheric dispersion, all despite reasonable precautions while observing. For those interested, a detailed discussion is given in § 2.2 of N19. Spectra from multiple telescopes and/or instruments help to estimate the magnitude of the problem. Gaussian process analysis of the residuals for a trial fit of the model SED to the observed flux calibrated spectrum (see § 6.7 of N19) can be used to mitigate flux calibration errors (and hence the continuum position) in the observations. 4. N16 presented two different approaches to matching the model SEDs to the observed photometry. The model parameters T_{e} and \log g and the resulting SEDs at the source were derived in the same way for both. In the first approach, the photometry was tied explicitly to the CALSPEC system, through identical measurements made on contemporaneous observations (e.g., F160W Program 13575; PI S. Deustua) of the three bright DAWD standards that define that system. The observed colors of the candidate DAWDs were then used to compare to the model SEDs. The second approach taken, described in § 5 of the N19 paper, explored the potential of decoupling from the CALSPEC system and improving the accuracy attained. The essential notion is that if we have self-consistent instrumental colors for all our target stars, the degree to which the instrumental colors correlate with synthetic colors (modulo fitting the reddening) is a measure of the predictability of the DAWD atmospheric models . The results were very encouraging and became a goal to be pursued in the longer term. The reader interested in probing into the details of the above issues, and how they were eventually dealt with, is referred to § 3 of N19. The Cycle-22 observations (program GO-13711; PI A. Saha) observed 23 fainter DAWD targets (including repeats of those observed in Cycle-20) distributed around the celestial equator and the northern celestial hemisphere. Observations in all 6 passbands (now including F275W ) of the 3 bright DAWDs (GD-153, G191B2B, and GD-71) that define the CALSPEC fluxes were interspersed over the total duration in time over which the 23 ‘unknowns’ were observed, so that any trends in the photometric behavior of the end-to-end system could be monitored. Also, all targets in Cycle 22 and thereafter were placed in the same location of the UVIS channel (the UVIS2-C512C-SUB aperture that provides a 512\times 512 pixel image) in the corner of the CCD nearest the readout) to minimize charge transfer efficiency (CTE) losses. Ground-based spectra were obtained by GMOS ( 29 ) on the Gemini telescopes, and also with the Blue Channel spectrograph on the MMT ( 1 ) . Several stars were observed by both GMOS and Blue Channel, providing an opportunity to cross-check the robustness of the derived atmospheric parameters. See § 3.7 of N19 for details. Cycle-25 HST observations (GO-15113; PI A. Saha) for the southern stars utilized the same observing strategy as for Cycle-22. The process for photometry was identical as well. However, the spectroscopy of those targets was done with the Goodman spectrograph ( 17 ) on the SOAR telescope. The acquisition and processing of the data are described in detail in C22. III.3 The Evolution of Analysis Methodology Here we trace how items 1) through 4) from the list of desired improvements mentioned above in § III.2 were progressively addressed and presented in subsequent analyses and papers. N19 presented results for 19 DAWDS with 16.5 mag