States of 2D Yang-Mills and Large-Volume Entanglement Dmitry Melnikov, Jefferson T. Oliveira, Valmir Peixoto, Marcia Tenser Abstract We study entanglement in two-dimensional Yang-Mills theory, viewed as a quasi-topological model of emergent space. The most familiar class of states in this theory are states defined by Euclidean path integrals over Riemann surfaces. Bipartite states of this class have thermofield double structure, with entanglement consistently reducing with total area and the number of topological defects, turning separable in the infinite-area limit. In contrast, Wilson lines and loops generate rich non-monotonic behavior of the entanglement entropy. Most notably, we find that for a certain discrete set of configurations, entanglement remains finite at infinite area. The reduced density matrices, in such configurations, take the form of finite-dimensional projectors onto non-trivial vacuum sectors. We also discuss the implications of the large-volume effects for confinement and find that special asymptotic configurations are related to transitions in the confining force. International Institute of Physics, Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte, Campus Universitário, Lagoa Nova, Natal-RN 59078-970, Brazil Department of Theoretical and Experimental Physics, Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte, Campus Universitário, Lagoa Nova, Natal-RN 59078-970, Brazil 1 Introduction The discovery of the geometrization of quantum entanglement [ 26 ] , in the context of a more general description of properties of quantum field theories by the holographic correspondence [ 35 , 27 , 18 , 16 , 32 ] , contributed to the development of the concept of space emerging from entanglement and quantum correlations [ 28 ] . In this concept, the higher dimensional space attached to an ordinary nongeometric (nongravitating) system emerges as a convenient resource to encode the system’s quantum correlations. A very similar holographic feature was somewhat known and used, before the advent of holography, in the axiomatic approach to topological quantum field theories (TQFT) [ 1 ] , but received a revived and more focused interest after the appearance of its geometric analog. TQFT axioms propose to view states in abstract Hilbert spaces as topological spaces attached to codimension-one boundaries, with boundaries themselves being invariants, representing the Hilbert space itself. The necessary properties of the quantum states can then be engineered by the choice of the topological details of the attached spaces. Similarly, gravitational systems, such as black holes, can encode quantum states living in flat asymptotic boundaries of curved spaces [ 33 , 19 ] . In other words, both topology and geometry can be viewed as a quantum resource. Different aspects of the geometric presentation of quantumness were extensively studied in the holographic literature (see [ 29 ] for a review). One popular slogan – “ER = EPR” – comparing the Einstein-Rosen bridge (a wormhole) with a pair of entangled particles [ 20 ] , summarizes the broader efforts to understand black holes as ordinary quantum systems. In a more specific form, relevant for the later discussion, a double-sided black hole is understood as a thermofield double (TFD) state \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle|{\rm TFD}\rangle\ =\ \sum_{n}e^{-\beta E_{n}}|n\rangle|n\rangle\,.\end{array} (1.1) Some other studies, focused on the general features of geometries and the properties of the multipartite states they describe include [ 4 , 7 , 6 ] . Most studies of the geometric quantification of entanglement are naturally limited by classical gravity backgrounds, which have only restricted access to possible forms of entanglement. This is particularly apparent in multipartite systems [ 5 ] . It seems that, to fully reflect the power of quantum correlations, the space also needs to be quantum. The topological encoding of entanglement is better placed in this respect, as TQFTs are usually integrable and one can easily reach the quantum regime. Some studies relevant to the present discussion can be found in [ 3 , 2 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] . However, even in this case, it is not precisely known how topology can access arbitrary forms of entanglement. In this work we take further steps in the development of the emerging space paradigm by looking at an intermediate example provided by the states of two-dimensional Yang-Mills theory (2D YM). This theory is quasi-topological since it has a very mild dependence on the geometry of the emerging spaces, via areas of their basic domains. Yet it remains integrable and, in principle, allows for the computation of arbitrary correlation functions [ 24 , 31 ] . States of 2D YM can be constructed as Euclidean path integrals over Riemann surfaces with circular boundaries. This approach defines states of the pure gauge theory on a collection of disjoint circles. On top of these, there is the possibility of adding particles, represented by endpoints of Wilson lines that cut the Riemann surfaces into domains. One may also consider adding closed Wilson lines (loops) as an additional feature to be added to the “emerging spaces”. In this paper, we will consider such configurations, beyond the well-studied cases of the pure YM states. Our primary goal is to develop general intuition about entanglement properties of the states encoded in each setup. We will start by reviewing the bipartite states defined on Riemann surfaces of different genus [ 31 , 10 ] . Entanglement properties of such states have already been discussed in the literature [ 13 , 12 , 11 ] . Our expectation, stemming from the study of TQFT states, is that topological defects should, in general, decrease the amount of entanglement because the defects consistently decrease the space’s connectedness. Calculating the von Neumann entropy, we will see that this is indeed the case for this class of states. Moreover, we will recover the known exponential decrease of entanglement with the total area of the Riemann surface. In the bipartite case (cylinder) the state has the structure of the TFD state ( 1.1 ), with the length of the cylinder playing the role of the inverse temperature. Consequently, the states are separable in the zero-temperature limit. Next, we will introduce Wilson loops and Wilson lines in the Riemann surface background. To our knowledge, such states have been much less explored (recent works where such states appear include [ 8 ] ). We analyze a wide range of examples, including bipartite states and states with a single boundary. In the former case, we consider Wilson lines connecting the same or opposite boundaries, as well as loops with trivial and nontrivial homotopy, and intersecting loops. The main observations of our studies can be summarized as follows: • Defects in the form of contractible nonnested Wilson loops, in general, affect the bipartite entanglement in a nonmonotonous fashion. However, there is a special regime in which such defects consistently decrease entanglement; • In general, contractible loops have optimal sizes for the purpose of the entanglement. That is, the latter may have a (local) maximum for certain ratios of the areas inside and outside the loops; • Though intuitively one expects entanglement to vanish in the large area limit, there are bipartite states for which entanglement asymptotes to a positive value. These are precisely the infinite volume 1 1 1 Since the theory is two-dimensional, “volume” and “area” refer to the same geometric characteristic. limits of the optimal ratio values; • Reduced density matrices of the bipartite states with contractible Wilson loops are of TFD type. In the large area limit, they take the form of projectors on finite-dimensional subspaces of the Hilbert space. More precisely, they are equivalent to finite-dimensional thermal density matrices; • In the large area limit, the proliferation of contractible loops consistently decreases entanglement entropy; • Bipartite states with noncontractible loops, in general, are not of the TFD type. However, they asymptote to TFD states in the infinite volume limit. Local maxima and finite entropy values for infinite volumes also occur for certain ratios of the areas of the domains separated by the loops. Reduced density matrices of such states also take the form of finite-dimensional thermal density matrices, consistently decreasing the entropy; • Similar behavior is observed for bipartite states with Wilson lines connecting the same or the opposite boundaries. For certain ratios of the areas of the domains cut by the Wilson lines, the entanglement entropy has nonzero limit for infinite areas. Although the density matrices have a more complex structure in the presence of Wilson line endpoints, they take a very similar asymptotic form in the large volume limit; • Reduced density matrices of the Wilson lines themselves, that is, density matrices with traced out gauge degrees of freedom, reduce to simple separable maximally mixed density matrices of the endpoints. This form of the density matrices is gauge invariant, despite the noninvariance of the original states and the Hilbert space. We believe that the existence of finite results for the entanglement entropy in the infinite volume limit is the most interesting outcome of our studies. It seems to indicate the existence of a special sector of the theory in this limit, which is equivalent to zero temperature or strong coupling. As a slightly complementary line, we also review the properties of some states from the point of view of confinement. We note that, despite the fact that the endpoints of Wilson lines must be interpreted as being in a separable mixed state, this doesn’t affect their ability to exhibit confining behavior. Since confinement in 2D YM has been studied extensively, we focus on a few complementary points: large volume effects on the confining force and on the hadronic force between meson-like configurations of Wilson lines. The existence of optimal area ratios with finite, locally maximal entropy values results in a series of crossover transitions in the confining force. In the infinite volume limit, these should become sharp phase transitions. Note that this limit is also the zero-temperature limit of the theory. Meanwhile, for the analog of the hadron force between meson-like configurations, no large-area effects occur. The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 we briefly review the basics of the calculation of Euclidean partition functions in 2D Yang-Mills. We consider a few standard examples of partition functions in the pure gauge theory and review the entanglement properties of two examples of bipartite states: on Riemann surfaces with two S^{1} boundaries and on a disk with a partition of a single boundary. In Section 3 we introduce Wilson loops. We start in Section 3.1 with the case of a single contractible Wilson loop on a cylinder and make a detailed investigation of the behavior of the entanglement entropy in different regimes. Our method, in this and the following sections, is based on the numerical observation of the entropy, followed by analytical arguments that explain special features of the numerical results. In most cases, we do not provide full analytical proofs of the numerical results. We believe that such proofs are straightforward, at least in the SU(2) case. For general SU(N) , proofs may be complicated due to the lack of general formulas for group-theoretic quantities and, especially, the multiplicities in the tensor products of representations. Besides the single contractible loop, Section 3 also includes subsections with configurations of multiple loops (Section 3.1.2 ), intersecting loops (Section 3.2 ), and noncontractible loops (Section 3.3 ). In Section 4 we connect the boundaries of a cylinder with Wilson lines and study the entanglement present in either of the boundaries. We investigate the cases of lines ending at the same (Section 4.1 ) or at opposite boundaries (Section 4.2 ). In the last case, an example of entropy enhancement due to a nontrivial multiplicity effect is demonstrated. Section 5 also studies Wilson lines on a cylinder and on a disk, but focuses on the entanglement of the Wilson lines with the gauge degrees of freedom. In Section 5.1 we consider a single line connecting two endpoints on a single boundary. On a cylinder, we mark a pair of points on each boundary and consider three most natural ways of connecting them with lines: \cup\cap -configuration (Section 5.2.1 ), {\rm II} -configuration (Section 5.2.2 ) and {\rm X} -configuration (Section 5.2.3 ). We show that in either case the reduced density matrix has the structure of a separable maximally mixed state. Section 6 reviews the confining behavior of particles (quarks) represented by the endpoints of Wilson lines. We compute the free energy associated with several examples of partition functions and check its behavior at different quark separations. In Section 6.2 we discuss the effects of large volume and the presence of the optimal area fractions on the confining force. In Section 6.3 we discuss the analog of the hadronic force between meson-like configurations of quarks. In Section 7 we draw our conclusions and discuss possible follow-up questions. Appendix A contains an additional list of group-theoretic formulae useful for calculations. 2 States in pure 2D Yang-Mills theory We will consider Yang-Mills theory defined on a 2D Riemannian manifold \mathcal{M} , with a compact simple Lie group G and its Lie algebra \mathfrak{g} . The theory is said to be quasi-topological and its partition function Z depends on the metric solely via the surface area \varrho of the manifold \mathcal{M} . In particular, on a compact orientable manifold of genus g , the partition function has the form of the following sum over irreducible representations \alpha of G : Z(\varrho)=\sum_{\alpha}(d_{\alpha})^{2-2g}e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho/2}\,. (2.1) Here d_{\alpha} is the dimension of \alpha – its exponent is the Euler characteristic of \mathcal{M} – and C_{2}(\alpha) is the quadratic Casimir of \alpha . 2 2 2 In this work we will adopt the convention for the quadratic Casimir given by equation ( A.2 ). In practice, for manifolds of g>0 , one computes the partition function ( 2.1 ) using a cell decomposition technique [ 31 , 10 ] . By decomposing a genus- g Riemannian manifold in 2D in terms of p plaquettes (these will be polygons of 4 g edges), one arrives at a set L_{p} of l links or edges composing each plaquette. Around them, the holonomy is U_{p}=\prod_{l\in L_{p}}U_{l} . One may then compute Z integrating over the elements dU_{l} – the Haar measure on the gauge group G – as follows: Z(\varrho)=\int\prod_{l}dU_{l}\prod_{p}\Gamma(U_{p},\varrho_{p})\,,\qquad\Gamma(U_{p},\varrho_{p})\equiv\sum_{\alpha}d_{\alpha}\,\chi_{\alpha}(U_{p})\,e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho/2}\,. (2.2) The quantities \chi_{\alpha}(U_{p}) are the characters of the group element U_{p} in the irreducible representations \alpha of G . According to the Peter-Weyl theorem, characters form an orthonormal basis for the conjugacy class functions. In particular, they satisfy \displaystyle\int dU\,\chi_{\alpha}(VU)\chi_{\beta}(U^{-1}W) \displaystyle=\delta_{\alpha\beta}\,(d_{\alpha})^{-1}\,\chi_{\alpha}(VW)\,, (2.3) \displaystyle\int dU\,\chi_{\alpha}(VUWU^{-1}) \displaystyle=(d_{\alpha})^{-1}\chi_{\alpha}(V)\chi_{\alpha}(W)\,. (2.4) Moreover, for unitary representations, it follows that \chi_{\alpha}(U^{-1})=\overline{\chi_{\alpha}(U)} . In the following sections we will make extensive use of these properties. When the manifold \mathcal{M} has n_{b} boundaries, the prescription is to consider holonomies W_{i} in representation \alpha_{i} along them. The partition function will depend on these boundary data and, in particular, Z(\varrho;W_{i})=\int\prod_{l}dU_{l}\prod_{p}\Gamma(W_{i},U_{p},\varrho_{p})\,. (2.5) Note that there will be plaquettes containing holonomies at the boundary, but these are not integrated over. Equivalently, provided that \Gamma(W_{i}) is a class function, one may write the partition function in the representation basis. This is implemented by projection on the character basis \chi_{\alpha_{i}}(W_{j}^{-1}) , via integration over dW_{j} : Z(\varrho;\alpha_{i})=\int\prod_{j}^{n_{b}}dW_{j}\,\chi_{\alpha_{i}}(W_{j}^{-1})\int\prod_{l}dU_{l}\prod_{p}\Gamma(W_{k},U_{p},\varrho_{p})\,. (2.6) One may also glue manifolds M_{i} along their boundaries, such that the resulting manifold \mathcal{M} has fewer boundaries: \mathcal{M}=\cup\mathcal{M}_{i} . Considering that the boundaries of \mathcal{M}_{i} contain holonomies W_{i_{j}} in representation \alpha_{i_{j}} , the gluing is done by i) taking the product of the partition functions, ii) identifying the representations living on coincident boundaries and iii) summing over all boundary representations: Z_{\mathcal{M}}(\varrho)=\prod_{i}\sum_{\alpha_{i_{j}}}Z_{\mathcal{M}_{i}}(\varrho_{i},\{\alpha_{i_{j}}\})\,. (2.7) Suppose we consider a 2D manifold with one boundary and we associate a holonomy U to it. We refer to such a manifold as \mathcal{M}_{U} . A wavefunction \psi may then be prepared by path integrating over \mathcal{M}_{U} with U as a boundary condition: \psi(U)=\int\prod_{p}dV_{p}\ \Gamma(U,V_{p},\varrho_{p})\,, (2.8) where the integration is performed over all holonomies except the one on the boundary where the wavefunction is evaluated. By definition, \psi(U) will be a class function. Naturally, the Hilbert space may be equipped with a positive inner product by means of the Haar measure on G , \langle\psi_{1}|\psi_{2}\rangle=\int_{G}dU\,\overline{\psi_{1}(U)}\psi_{2}(U)\,. (2.9) So the Hilbert space \mathcal{H} consists of square-integrable class functions with respect to the Haar measure. We will apply the cutting and gluing techniques described for the computation of partition functions for construction of wavefunctions and density matrices. The corresponding amplitudes will also often be referred to as partition functions, with some abuse of terminology. In the rest of this section we will apply these techniques to discuss the entanglement properties of typical states of pure 2D Yang-Mills theory, focusing on the bipartite entanglement. 2.1 The disk The entanglement entropy associated with a single interval on the boundary of a disk may be computed using the replica trick as follows. The disk’s partition function is given by the contribution of a single plaquette with holonomy U at the boundary, Z(\varrho,U)=\sum_{\alpha}d_{\alpha}\,\chi_{\alpha}(U)\,e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho/2}\,. (2.10) So we start by partitioning the system in terms of two plaquettes, of area \varrho_{1} and \varrho_{2} . Their sum equals the total area of the disk \varrho . The decomposition is depicted in Figure 1 . We may write Z(\varrho_{1},\varrho_{2};U_{1},U_{2})=\int dV\left(\sum_{\alpha}d_{\alpha}\,\chi_{\alpha}(U_{1}V)\,e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{1}/2}\right)\left(\sum_{\beta}d_{\beta}\,\chi_{\beta}(V^{-1}U_{2})\,e^{-C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{2}/2}\right)\,. (2.11) Naturally, if one performs the integration over V , one recovers ( 2.10 ), given that U=U_{1}U_{2} and \varrho=\varrho_{1}+\varrho_{2} . U \varrho \varrho_{1} \varrho_{2} V U_{1} U_{2} i j Figure 1 : Cell decomposition of the disk. The partition can also be thought as the insertion of a Wilson line, with the corresponding group representation indices shown. The empty disk partition function is recovered when the representation of the Wilson line is considered to be trivial. The partition function ( 2.11 ) may be seen as a state with two labels, U_{1} and U_{2} , \psi(U_{1},U_{2}) , to which one can associate a density matrix. A (unnormalized) reduced density matrix \rho may then be obtained via \displaystyle\begin{split}\rho(U_{1},U_{3}^{-1})&=\int dU_{2}\,Z(U_{1},U_{2})\overline{Z(U_{2},U_{3})}=\sum_{\alpha}d_{\alpha}\,\chi_{\alpha}(U_{1}U_{3}^{-1})e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho}\end{split} (2.12) The normalization factor is simply Z_{1}\ =\ {\rm Tr}\,\rho(U_{1},U_{3}^{-1})\ =\ \int dU\,\rho(U,U^{-1})=\sum_{\alpha}(d_{\alpha})^{2}e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho/2}\,, (2.13) which is nothing but the partition function of a sphere S^{2} , cf. equation ( 2.1 ). To use the replica trick, we need to compute Z_{n}={\rm Tr}\left(\rho^{n}(U_{1},U_{3}^{-1})\right) , and it is not difficult to show that Z_{n}=\sum_{\alpha}(d_{\alpha})^{2}e^{-nC_{2}(\alpha)\varrho}\,. (2.14) The entanglement entropy is then given by S=-\lim_{n\to 1}\frac{d}{dn}\frac{Z_{n}}{Z_{1}^{n}}\,. (2.15) Introducing the notation p(\alpha)\equiv\frac{(d_{\alpha})^{2}\exp\left(-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho\right)}{Z_{1}}\,, (2.16) we may write the resulting entanglement entropy as S=-\sum_{\alpha}p(\alpha)\log p(\alpha)+2\sum_{\alpha}p(\alpha)\log d_{\alpha}\,. (2.17) This basic example reproduces the results of [ 12 ] via the replica trick applied to the cell decomposition approach. In particular, the second term appearing on the right-hand side originates from additional degrees of freedom living on the entangling surface, the so-called edge modes. They appear due to the impossibility of gauge invariant factorization of the Hilbert space of the gauge theory. The replica trick derives their contribution in a gauge invariant way. As explained in [ 12 ] , if one requires gauge invariance of the reduced density matrix \rho(U_{1},U_{3}^{-1}) , it must commute with gauge transformations acting at both boundaries. It then follows from Schur’s lemma that, for each irreducible representation \alpha , the boundary degrees of freedom must form a maximally mixed state of dimension d_{\alpha} . This, in turn, leads to a contribution 2\log d_{\alpha} to the entropy, where the factor of two accounts for the two boundaries. In Section 5 we will see how gauge invariant reduced density matrices explicitly appear after integration over the gauge modes. 2.2 The cylinder In the case of a cylinder, we have the set-up shown in Figure 2 . Following the prescription outlined in ( 2.6 ), we compute the partition function by i) identifying the edges by gluing along W and ii) introducing holonomies U_{1} and U_{2} at the boundaries. The resulting partition function will depend on the area and on the representation of the holonomies, say \alpha_{1} and \alpha_{2} . In the representation basis we have \displaystyle\begin{split}Z(\varrho;\alpha_{1},\alpha_{2})&=\int dU_{1}dU_{2}dW\,\sum_{\beta}d_{\beta}\,\chi_{\beta}(U_{1}W^{-1}U_{2}W)e^{-C_{2}(\beta)\varrho/2}\overline{\chi_{\alpha_{1}}(U_{1})}\,\overline{\chi_{\alpha_{2}}(U_{2})}\\ &=\int dU_{1}dU_{2}\,\sum_{\beta}\chi_{\beta}(U_{1})\chi_{\beta}(U_{2})e^{-C_{2}(\beta)\varrho/2}\chi_{\alpha_{1}}(U_{1}^{-1})\,\chi_{\alpha_{2}}(U_{2}^{-1})\\ &=\delta_{\alpha_{1}\alpha_{2}}\exp\left(-\frac{\varrho}{2}C_{2}(\alpha_{1})\right).\end{split} (2.18) Equivalently, in the holonomy basis, \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle Z(\varrho;U_{1},U_{2})=\sum_{\alpha}\chi_{\alpha}(U_{1})\chi_{\alpha}(U_{2})\,e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho/2}\,.\end{array} (2.19) Note that one can obtain this result immediately by using a refined cell decomposition that sums over cells with given Euler characteristic, zero in this case, which amounts to omitting the dimension d_{\alpha} factor from ( 2.2 ) and inserting a character for each boundary. U_{1} U_{2} U_{1} W^{-1} W U_{2} \varrho_{i} \varrho_{e} Figure 2 : Cell decomposition of the cylinder. For later use we show the setup with one contractible Wilson loop. The two-boundary partition function may be seen as coefficients of a state decomposed in the character basis as follows |\psi\rangle=\sum_{\alpha_{1},\alpha_{2}}\psi_{\alpha_{1}\alpha_{2}}|\chi_{\alpha_{1}}\chi_{\alpha_{2}}\rangle\,. (2.20) So ( 2.18 ) makes it evident that the state is a TFD state (for now unnormalized): |\psi\rangle=\sum_{\alpha}e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho/2}|\chi_{\alpha}\chi_{\alpha}\rangle\,. (2.21) We may then consider the pure state with density matrix given by \rho=|\psi\rangle\langle\psi|=\sum_{\alpha,\beta}e^{-\left(C_{2}(\alpha)+C_{2}(\beta)\right)\varrho/2}|\chi_{\alpha}\chi_{\alpha}\rangle\langle\chi_{\beta}\chi_{\beta}|\,. (2.22) The reduced density matrix obtained by tracing out the U_{1} boundary, for instance, is \rho_{2}=\frac{1}{\mathcal{N}}\sum_{\alpha}e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho}|\chi_{\alpha}\rangle\langle\chi_{\alpha}|\,,\qquad\mathcal{N}\equiv\sum_{\alpha}e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho}\,. (2.23) It is instructive to visualize how the von Neumann entropy is obtained from the replica trick, S=-\lim_{n\to 1}\frac{d}{dn}{\rm Tr}(\rho_{2}^{n})=\left(1-\varrho\frac{d}{d\varrho}\right)\log\mathcal{N}\,, (2.24) where \rho_{2}^{n} is the same partition function as \rho , but computed on a longer cylinder. Otherwise, the entropy is directly computed for the diagonal matrix via \boxed{\quad S=-\sum_{\alpha}h_{\alpha}\log h_{\alpha}\,,\quad\quad h_{\alpha}=\dfrac{e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho}}{\mathcal{N}}\,.\quad} (2.25) When G=SU(2) , for example, C_{2}(j)=j(j/2+1) with j=0,1,2,3,\dots and one has \mathcal{N}=\frac{e^{\varrho/2}}{2}\left(\vartheta_{3}(0,e^{-\varrho/2})-1\right)\,,\qquad\vartheta_{3}(z,q)=\sum_{n=-\infty}^{\infty}q^{n^{2}}\exp(2n iz)\,, (2.26) where \vartheta_{3}(z,q) are Jacobi theta functions on the torus. 2.3 Higher genera Building on the intuition gained from considering the cylindrical case, we go a step further and introduce holes in such a topology. This will lead to two-boundary states defined on Riemann surfaces of genus g . A hole may be introduced by gluing together two pairs of pants, as depicted in Figure 3(a) . Each pair of pants, on the other hand, may be cut open and represented in terms of a plaquette with identified edges. In Figure 3(b) we choose to cut the left pair of pants along the curves X and Y . V U W X Y T U^{-1} W^{-1} (a) U X^{-1} Y W Y^{-1} V X \varrho (b) Figure 3 : A genus-1 cell may be built by gluing two pairs of pants as depicted in ( 3(a) ). Each pair of pants may be cut open and represented as a heptagon. In ( 3(b) ) we depict the plaquette obtained by cutting the left pair of pants along X and Y . Each pair of pants may be seen as a three-boundary state. Focusing on the pair of pants on the left, we may read off its representation in the holonomy basis directly from Figure 3(b) . We have \displaystyle\begin{split}\psi_{l}(V,U,W)&=\int dXdY\sum_{\alpha}d_{\alpha}\,\chi_{\alpha}(VXUX^{-1}YWY^{-1})\,e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho/2}\\ &=\int dX\sum_{\alpha}d_{\alpha}\,\frac{\chi_{\alpha}(VXUX^{-1})\chi_{\alpha}(W)}{d_{\alpha}}\,e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho/2}\\ &=\sum_{\alpha}\frac{1}{d_{\alpha}}\,\chi_{\alpha}(V)\chi_{\alpha}(U)\chi_{\alpha}(W)\,e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho/2}\,.\end{split} (2.27) Analogously, the state associated with the pair of pants on the right is \displaystyle\begin{split}\psi_{r}(T,U^{-1},W^{-1})&=\sum_{\alpha}\frac{1}{d_{\alpha}}\,\chi_{\alpha}(T)\chi_{\alpha}(U^{-1})\chi_{\alpha}(W^{-1})\,e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho/2}\,.\end{split} (2.28) The genus-one cell of Figure 3(a) is the two-boundary state obtained by gluing \psi_{l} and \psi_{r} above along U and W : \displaystyle\begin{split}\psi_{1}(V,T)&\equiv\int dUdW\psi_{l}(V,U,W)\psi_{r}(T,U^{-1},W^{-1})\\ &=\sum_{\alpha}\frac{1}{(d_{\alpha})^{2}}\chi_{\alpha}(V)\chi_{\alpha}(T)\,e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho}\,.\end{split} (2.29) Successively gluing copies of states of the form ( 2.29 ), we build two boundary states of genus g . For instance, gluing two of them gives 3 3 3 From now on, and until the end of this section, instead of keeping track of how many factors of the area of a single pair of pants we have, we choose to write the area dependence in terms of the total area of the state under consideration. We keep the notation \varrho nevertheless. \psi_{2}(V,R)=\int dT\,\psi_{1}(V,T)\,\psi_{1}(T^{-1},R)=\sum_{\alpha}\frac{1}{(d_{\alpha})^{4}}\,\chi_{\alpha}(V)\chi_{\alpha}(R)\,e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho/2}\,. (2.30) It is easy to see that, in general, a bipartite genus- g state will be described by 4 4 4 This agrees with the well-known results cited in [ 31 , 10 ] . \psi_{g}(V,S)=\sum_{\alpha}\frac{1}{(d_{\alpha})^{2g}}\,\chi_{\alpha}(V)\chi_{\alpha}(R)\,e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho/2}\,. (2.31) Equivalently, in the character basis, we have |\psi_{g}\rangle=\sum_{\alpha}\frac{e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho/2}}{(d_{\alpha})^{2g}}|\chi_{\alpha}\chi_{\alpha}\rangle\,, (2.32) which is the genus g version of ( 2.21 ). We see that such states of pure Yang-Mills preserve the TFD structure, as seen in the cylinder case, for higher genera as well. The von Neumann entropy is given by a generalization of ( 2.25 ). In particular, we have \boxed{\quad S=-\sum_{\alpha}h_{\alpha}\log h_{\alpha}\,,\quad h_{\alpha}=\frac{e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho}(d_{\alpha})^{-4g}}{\mathcal{N}}\,,\qquad\mathcal{N}=\sum_{\alpha}e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho}(d_{\alpha})^{-4g}\,.\quad} (2.33) 2.3.1 Entanglement entropy analysis It is clear from ( 2.33 ) that the entropy decreases exponentially with the area \varrho . We also see that the addition of holes increases the hierarchy among different eigenvalues of the density matrix, thereby further reducing the entropy. For SU(2) this result is readily proven. All representations \alpha are unequivocally labeled by only one number, the spin j , and we assume them to be related via \alpha=2j . The eigenvalues h_{\alpha} of the reduced density matrix can be ordered by the value of \alpha . The ratio of two consecutive eigenvalues is \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle\frac{h_{\alpha+1}}{h_{\alpha}}\ =\ \left(\frac{2\alpha+3}{2\alpha+1}\right)^{-4g}e^{-4(\alpha+1)\varrho}\,,\end{array} (2.34) confirming that the hierarchy among eigenvalues increases. For other groups, there is no unique way to label and order the representations, and we demonstrate the effect of entropy decay with genus numerically in Figure 4 . Figure 4 : Logarithm of the entropy as a function of genus for different gauge groups. The total area is fixed, \varrho=20 . The reduction of the amount of entanglement with genus is expected in the space-emerging-from-entanglement paradigm discussed in the introduction. According to the paradigm, topological defects reduce the connectedness of the space emerging between the parties, which results in the loss of their correlation. In the limit of an infinite number of holes, the space essentially disconnects, breaking the correlations. 3 Configurations with Wilson loops Now we would like to turn on additional effects on the two-dimensional surfaces. In this section, we will focus on the example of the bipartite system of genus zero (cylinder) and study the effect of introducing basic Wilson loops to these states. We will consider contractible loops, with and without intersections, as well as non-contractible loops. 3.1 Contractible loops without intersections Let us add a contractible closed loop with no self-intersections on the surface of the cylinder; see Figure 2 . In this case, the procedure outlined in Section 2 leads to a partition function written in terms of two boundary holonomies, U_{1} and U_{2} , and the Wilson loop’s representation \gamma . In particular, it has the form \displaystyle\begin{split}Z(\varrho_{i},\varrho_{e};\gamma,U_{1},U_{2})\ &=\int dV\ \sum\limits_{\alpha,\beta}\frac{d_{\beta}}{d_{\alpha}}\chi_{\alpha}(U_{1})\chi_{\alpha}(U_{2})\chi_{\alpha}(V^{-1})\chi_{\beta}(V)\chi_{\gamma}(V)\ e^{-\left(C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{e}+C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{i}\right)/2}\\ &=\ \sum\limits_{\alpha,\beta}\frac{d_{\beta}}{d_{\alpha}}N_{\beta\gamma}^{\alpha}\chi_{\alpha}(U_{1})\chi_{\alpha}(U_{2})\ e^{-\left(C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{e}+C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{i}\right)/2}\,,\end{split} (3.1) where \varrho_{i} and \varrho_{e} denote the internal and external areas bounded by the loop, respectively. Coefficients N_{\beta\gamma}^{\alpha} are the Littlewood-Richardson coefficients, or multiplicities of irreducible representation \alpha appearing in the expansion of the tensor product of representations \beta and \gamma : \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle\beta\otimes\gamma\ =\ \bigoplus_{\alpha}N_{\beta\gamma}^{\alpha}\,\alpha\,.\end{array} (3.2) In equation ( 3.1 ) we used equation ( A.8 ), which expresses these coefficients in terms of a character integral. Note that for trivial \gamma , N_{\beta 0}^{\alpha}=\delta_{\beta}^{\alpha} , and one recovers the cylinder partition function ( 2.19 ). We find it convenient to define the coefficients \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle\mathcal{D}_{\alpha}(\gamma,\varrho)\ \equiv\ \sum\limits_{\beta}\frac{d_{\beta}}{d_{\alpha}}N_{\beta\gamma}^{\alpha}\,e^{-C_{2}(\beta)\varrho/2},\end{array} (3.3) which allow us to write the partition function as \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle Z(\varrho_{i},\varrho_{e};\gamma,U_{1},U_{2})\ =\ \sum\limits_{\alpha}\mathcal{D}_{\alpha}(\gamma,\varrho_{i})e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{e}/2}\chi_{\alpha}(U_{1})\chi_{\alpha}(U_{2})\,.\end{array} (3.4) This makes it more evident that the state has a similar diagonal (TFD) structure as the cylinder, but with renormalized coefficients. Moreover, note that \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle\mathcal{D}_{\alpha}(\gamma,0)\ =\ \sum\limits_{\beta}\frac{d_{\beta}}{d_{\alpha}}N_{\beta\gamma}^{\alpha}\ =\ d_{\gamma}\,,\end{array} (3.5) so that \mathcal{D}_{\alpha}(\gamma,\varrho) may be interpreted as a “deformation” of the dimension of the representation \gamma . This deformation preserves the reality of the dimension. For n nonintersecting loops, expression ( 3.4 ) is generalized by adding a \mathcal{D}_{\alpha}(\gamma_{k},\varrho_{k}) factor for each loop labeled by k , k=1,\dots,n : \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle Z(\varrho_{e},\{\varrho_{k}\};\{\gamma_{k}\},U_{1},U_{2})\ =\ \sum\limits_{\alpha}\left(\prod\limits_{k=1}^{n}\mathcal{D}_{\alpha}(\gamma_{k},\varrho_{k})\right)e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{e}/2}\chi_{\alpha}(U_{1})\chi_{\alpha}(U_{2})\,.\end{array} (3.6) This pattern is similar to that of adding a topologically trivial Wilson loop in Chern-Simons partition functions, which amounts to inserting a factor of the “quantum” dimension [ 30 , 23 ] . In the representation basis ( 2.20 ), such an amplitude has coefficients \psi_{\alpha\beta}=\delta_{\alpha\beta}\left(\prod\limits_{k=1}^{n}\mathcal{D}_{\alpha}(\gamma_{k},\varrho_{k})\right)e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{e}/2}\,. (3.7) Then the reduced density matrix is \rho_{1}=\mathcal{N}^{-1}\sum_{\alpha}\left(\prod^{n}_{k=1}\mathcal{D}_{\alpha}(\gamma_{k},\varrho_{k})^{2}\right)e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{e}}\,\ket{\chi_\alpha}\bra{\chi_\alpha}\,, (3.8) where the normalization factor is given by \mathcal{N}=\sum_{\alpha}\left(\prod^{n}_{k=1}\mathcal{D}_{\alpha}(\gamma_{k},\varrho_{k})^{2}\right)e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{e}}\ =\ Z(T^{2},\{\gamma_{k}\},\{\gamma_{k^{\prime}}\})\,, (3.9) which is equivalent to the partition function of a torus with 2n Wilson loops in their respective representations. Consequently, the entropy takes the form \boxed{\quad S=-\sum_{\alpha}h_{\alpha}\log h_{\alpha}\,,\quad\quad h_{\alpha}=\dfrac{e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{e}}}{\mathcal{N}}\prod^{n}_{k=1}\mathcal{D}_{\alpha}(\gamma_{k},\varrho_{k})^{2}\,.\quad} (3.10) 3.1.1 Entanglement entropy analysis for a contractible loop The qualitative behavior of the entropy in ( 3.10 ) can be understood with the help of numerical analysis. We start with the case of a single loop and investigate how its presence affects the entropy. The first lesson learned is that entropy is not a monotonic function of the loop parameters. Let us look at the behavior of the entropy of a fixed-area state with a single loop as a function of the loop size. When the total area is sufficiently large in units set by the inverse of the Casimir of the loop’s representation, a typical entropy plot reveals a series of peaks (local maxima) at specific values of the ratio between the area enclosed by the loop and the total area of the cylinder. The number of peaks is controlled by the loop representation; for instance, in the case of SU(2) , it coincides with its Dynkin label. 5 5 5 In the rest of the paper we will label the irreps of SU(N) by Young diagrams, either drawing the diagram, or listing the corresponding N -integer box partition, e.g \scalebox{0.3}{\hbox{}\hskip 0.0pt{\vbox{\vbox{\hrule height=0.3pt\hbox{\vrule height=8.74669pt,width=0.3pt,depth=2.18663pt\hbox to10.93333pt{\hfil}\vrule height=8.74669pt,width=0.3pt,depth=2.18663pt\hbox to10.93333pt{\hfil}\vrule height=8.74669pt,width=0.3pt,depth=2.18663pt}\hrule height=0.3pt}\vskip-0.3pt\vbox{\hrule height=0.3pt\hbox{\vrule height=8.74669pt,width=0.3pt,depth=2.18663pt\hbox to10.93333pt{\hfil}\vrule height=8.74669pt,width=0.3pt,depth=2.18663pt}\hrule height=0.3pt}\vskip-0.3pt}}\hskip 0.0pt}\equiv[2,1,0] is the adjoint representation of SU(3) . A representative example is shown in Figure 5 . In particular, Figures ( 5(a) ) and ( 5(b) ) correspond to different values of the total area \varrho_{t} . They show that, as the total area increases, the peaks become sharply localized around certain “optimal” values of the area fraction. For example, the single blue peak associated with the fundamental representation localizes sharply at 50\% of \varrho_{t} as its value increases. (a) (b) Figure 5 : Entropy ( 3.10 ) for varying area fraction for the loop in some SU(2) representations calculated for intermediate ( 5(a) ) and large ( 5(b) ) total area \varrho_{t} . The vertical dashed lines correspond to the same fraction of the loop area and the total area on both plots. The exact position of each peak is a function of the total area, and their heights are approximately equal to \log 2 . Globally, the entropy is unbounded: It is divergent in the limit of vanishing total area, so the regime where this particular structure of the peaks is present corresponds to total areas above a threshold, as can be clearly seen from Figure 6 . The figure displays a collection of entropy curves for the fundamental representation, plotted as functions of the total area \varrho_{t}=\varrho_{i}+\varrho_{e} . Each curve corresponds to a fixed value of the area fraction r=\varrho_{i}/\varrho_{t} , with a few representative choices shown explicitly. Figure 6 : Entropy ( 3.10 ) as a function of the total area \varrho_{t} for the loop in the fundamental representation of SU(2) for different fractions r=\varrho_{i}/\varrho_{t} of the loop area and the total area. For fractions 0.50.5 , the optimal inner area fraction becomes constant and equal to 1. That is, the entropy will be finite in the large area limit only when the intersecting loops entirely cover the cylinder. In particular, its asymptotic value is S\simeq 0.33 , which corresponds to the entropy derived from ( 3.25 ). That is, in this regime, the system behaves like a single spin- 1 contractible loop at optimal ratio. (a) (b) Figure 13 : ( 13(a) ) Entropy ( 3.33 ) as a function of the total area \varrho_{t} for two crossing loops, both in the fundamental representation of SU(2) , for different fractions of the loop area and the total area as well as for different overlap fractions between the two loops areas. ( 13(b) ) Asymptotic values for the entropy for different combinations of overlap and total inner area fractions. 3.3 Non-contractible loops Now let us add a non-contractible loop, that is, a loop wrapping around the cylinder; see Figure 14 . In this case, the cylinder is split into left and right regions of areas \varrho_{l} and \varrho_{r} , respectively. The amplitude, or partition function, depends on the boundary holonomies, U_{1} and U_{2} , and on the representation \gamma of the loop: \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle Z(\varrho_{l},\varrho_{r};\gamma,U_{1},U_{2})\ =\ \sum\limits_{\alpha,\beta}N_{\alpha\gamma}^{\beta}e^{-\left(C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{l}+C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{r}\right)/2}\chi_{\alpha}(U_{1})\chi_{\beta}(U_{2})\,.\end{array} (3.36) In the representation basis, the components of the state are \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle C_{\alpha\beta}\ =\ N_{\alpha\gamma}^{\beta}e^{-\left(C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{l}+C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{r}\right)/2}.\end{array} (3.37) We see that, although the coefficient matrix of such a state is not diagonal, in general, its components are located at a finite distance from the diagonal, controlled by \gamma . As expected, for trivial \gamma , one returns to the diagonal result of the empty cylinder ( 2.19 ). U_{1} U_{2} \varrho_{l} \varrho_{r} Figure 14 : Cylinder with non-contractible loop separating left and right regions with areas \varrho_{l} and \varrho_{r} . In order to compute the entropy, we write the reduced density operator, say, of the left subsystem. In the representation basis, we find \rho_{l}=\mathcal{N}^{-1}\sum_{\alpha,\alpha^{\prime},\beta}N_{\alpha\gamma}^{\beta}\,N_{\beta\gamma^{\ast}}^{\alpha^{\prime}}\,e^{-(C_{2}(\alpha)+C_{2}(\alpha^{\prime}))\varrho_{l}/2-C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{r}}\ket{\chi_\alpha}\bra{\chi_{\alpha'}}\,. (3.38) Here \mathcal{N} is the normalization factor, given by \mathcal{N}=\sum_{\alpha,\beta}(N_{\alpha\gamma}^{\beta})^{2}\,e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{l}-C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{r}}\,, (3.39) where we used that N_{\beta\gamma^{\ast}}^{\alpha}=N_{\alpha^{\ast}\gamma^{\ast}}^{\beta^{\ast}}=N_{\alpha\gamma}^{\beta} . Computation of the entropy using the replica trick requires analytical expression for the contraction of 2n multiplicity coefficients, weighted by exponential factors, which is probably unknown. Instead, a valid approximation can be obtained using the standard von Neumman formula, S=-{\rm Tr}\,(\rho_{l}\ln\rho_{l})=-{\rm Tr}\,(\rho_{r}\ln\rho_{r})\,, (3.40) at least for sufficiently large values of the total area. The presence of exponential factors allows truncating the representation basis in order to obtain a finite matrix that can be diagonalized numerically. This enables us to perform a consistent numerical analysis, as presented below. 3.3.1 Entanglement entropy analysis for one non-contractible loop For a Wilson loop wrapping the cylinder, we find some similarities compared to the contractible case analyzed in Section 3.1.1 . Using the ratio between left and total areas \varrho_{l}/(\varrho_{l}+\varrho_{r}) to characterize the system, when the gauge group is SU(2) , we find that: • there are ratios for which the entropy asymptotes to a non-zero value in the large area limit; • for a loop colored with irrep \gamma , there are \gamma of such fractions, determined by ( 3.13 ); Now, in contrast to the state containing a contractible loop, • the exchange between the two areas involved, \varrho_{l} and \varrho_{r} , represents a symmetry of the system and, therefore, also of the entropy; • for the optimal ratios, the entropy asymptotes to \log 2 in the large area limit, regardless of the representation of the loop. Let us further explain these statements. First, note that the normalization factor ( 3.39 ) has a structure that is similar to that of ( 3.9 ). The first difference between them is the presence of a single sum over \beta in the former, while the latter includes two sums, over \beta_{1} and \beta_{2} . This difference, however, does not change the analysis of the “optimal” ratios. Note that the analysis for ( 3.9 ) involves choosing representations with the lightest Casimirs, such that the minimization of C_{2}(\beta_{1}) automatically minimizes C_{2}(\beta_{2}) . This implies that, in the end of the day, relevant contributions arise only for \beta_{1}=\beta_{2} . For this reason, the analysis outlined for ( 3.9 ) extends entirely to the ( 3.39 ) case. Thus, ( 3.13 ) appropriately captures the optimal ratios of the current setup. Moreover, note that the procedure of choosing the lightest of the Casimirs also renders \rho_{l} ( 3.38 ) diagonal in the large area limit: for a fixed \beta , minimization of C_{2}(\alpha) automatically minimizes C_{2}(\alpha^{\prime}) and selects \alpha^{\prime}=\alpha . This allows us to repeat the analysis of entropy in the large area limit along the lines of Section 3.1.1 . We find that, while the ratios are the same, the value of the entropy in the asymptotic limits differs. This happens due to the second difference between ( 3.39 ) and ( 3.9 ): the absence of factors of dimension in the former. Due to this fact, whenever we reach an optimal ratio, two elements will contribute to the entropy, but this time h_{n}(\gamma) , which in the contractible case was given by ( 3.15 ), will simply be equal to 1/2 . Therefore, the entropy will always asymptote to \log 2 for such states. In Figure 15(a) we present the case of \gamma=[7,0] as an example. The asymptotic limit is equal to \log 2 for all of them, as claimed. We choose dashed curves to illustrate fractions that are greater than 1/2 in order to highlight the ( \varrho_{l}\leftrightarrow\varrho_{r} )-symmetry of the entropy. (a) (b) Figure 15 : Entropy as a function of the total area using different fractions between left and right areas ( 15(a) ), and entropy as a function of the left area holding the total area \varrho_{l}+\rho_{r}=20 fixed for different Wilson loop SU(3) representations ( 15(b) ). Finally, since there is a direct parallel between the analysis of peaks (or, equivalently, of the optimal ratios) in the present setup and that of the contractible loop, it is natural to examine the case in which the gauge group is SU(3) . For the representation [2,1,0] , we expect two central peaks located at \varrho_{l}/(\varrho_{l}+\varrho_{r})=4/9 and 5/9 , corresponding to the two central maxima of the [2,1,0] curve shown in Figure 9(b) . In Figure 15(b) , we display the entropy as a function of the total area for this representation, considering ratios in the interval between these two values. At 4/9\simeq 0.44 , the entropy approaches the asymptotic value \log 3 . As the ratio increases, the asymptotic limit of the curves descends toward \log 2 , with the 0.5 curve reaching \log 2 faster than the others. For ratios between 0.5 and 5/9\simeq 0.56 , the curves ascend eventually changing the asymptotic value to \log 3 at the 5/9 fraction. Thus, the lower and upper bounds coincide with those in Figure 10(b) ; however, in the present case they attain the exact value \log 3 at the 4/9 and 5/9 fractions. 4 Configurations with Wilson lines In this section we will enrich the spatial topology including open Wilson lines ending on the boundaries. In the cell decomposition framework, the inclusion of Wilson line operators is accomplished via the insertion of the respective representation matrices along appropriate links of the lattice [ 31 ] , instead of closed loop characters. For instance, suppose V is an edge of the cell decomposition of \mathcal{M} along which a Wilson line is supported. We shall denote it as \gamma(V)_{ij}\,, (4.1) where \gamma stands for its representation and indices i and j are representation indices. Wilson lines are natural partition cuts and the partition function integrates the inserted operator over the holonomy V associated with the cut. The addition of Wilson line endpoints to the boundaries enhances the corresponding Hilbert spaces. They are no longer spanned by the gauge invariant basis of representations |\chi_{\gamma}\rangle , but by a more general basis of matrix elements |\gamma;i,j\rangle , so that \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle\gamma(V)_{ij}\ =\ \langle\gamma;i,j|V\rangle\,.\end{array} (4.2) In the following, we shall apply this framework by considering configurations with several Wilson lines anchored on the same or opposite boundaries of a cylinder. We will see that, as in the case of Wilson loops, configurations with open lines can also lead to nonvanishing entropies in the infinite area limit. 4.1 Wilson lines anchored on the same boundary of a cylinder Let us insert a pair of Wilson lines, each anchored on a different boundary in the cylinder topology. The corresponding cell decomposition consists of three plaquettes; see Figure 16 . We denote the inner areas enclosed by each line as \varrho_{1} and \varrho_{2} , while the area external to the lines is \varrho_{e} . U_{1} U_{2} i i^{\prime} j^{\prime} j U_{1i} W^{-1} W U_{2i} U_{2o} V_{1} V_{2} i i^{\prime} j^{\prime} j U_{1o} \varrho_{1} \varrho_{e} \varrho_{2} Figure 16 : Cell decomposition of the cylinder with two Wilson lines, each anchored on a boundary. The wavefunction, in this case, will depend not only on the boundary holonomies, which the line insertion splits into U_{1i} , U_{1o} and U_{2i} , U_{2o} , but also on \gamma_{1}(V_{1})_{ii^{\prime}} and \gamma_{2}(V_{2})_{jj^{\prime}} , with indices i,i^{\prime} and j,j^{\prime} labeling the internal state of two pairs of particles on a circle in the Euclidean preparation picture. The density matrix will be a function of the full set of data: 8 8 8 In this and the following sections, pairs of indices separated by a semicolon label the endpoints of the same Wilson line. \displaystyle\begin{split}\psi(U_{1i},U_{2i},U_{1o},U_{2o};\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2})_{ii^{\prime};jj^{\prime}}=\int&dV_{1}dV_{2}dW\Bigg[\bigg(\sum_{\alpha}d_{\alpha}\,e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{1}/2}\,\chi_{\alpha}(U_{1i}V_{1})\bigg)\\ &\times\bigg(\sum_{\beta}d_{\beta}\,e^{-C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{e}/2}\,\chi_{\beta}(U_{1o}V_{1}^{-1}W^{-1}V_{2}^{-1}U_{2o}W)\bigg)\\ &\times\bigg(\sum_{\sigma}d_{\sigma}\,e^{-C_{2}(\sigma)\varrho_{2}/2}\,\chi_{\sigma}(U_{2i}V_{2})\bigg)\,\gamma_{1}(V_{1})_{ii^{\prime}}\,\gamma_{2}(V_{2})_{jj^{\prime}}\Bigg]\end{split} (4.3) Identifying the edges to form the cylinder, that is, integrating over W , gives \displaystyle\begin{split}\psi(U_{1i},U_{2i},U_{1o},U_{2o}&;\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2})_{ii^{\prime};jj^{\prime}}=\sum_{\alpha,\beta,\sigma}d_{\alpha}d_{\sigma}\,e^{-(C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{1}+C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{e}+C_{2}(\sigma)\varrho_{2})/2}\\ &\times\int dV_{1}\ dV_{2}\ \chi_{\alpha}(U_{1i}V_{1})\chi_{\beta}(U_{1o}V_{1}^{-1})\chi_{\beta}(V_{2}^{-1}U_{2o})\chi_{\sigma}(U_{2i}V_{2})\gamma_{1}(V_{1})_{ii^{\prime}}\,\gamma_{2}(V_{2})_{jj^{\prime}}\,\end{split} (4.4) Let us trace out one half of the system ( 4.3 ). For the reduced density matrix of the left subsystem, labeled by holonomy U_{1} and Wilson line with indices i and i^{\prime} , one obtains \displaystyle\begin{split}\rho(U_{1i},U_{3i},U_{1o},U_{3o};\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2})_{ii^{\prime};kk^{\prime}}\ =\ \mathcal{N}^{-1}\sum_{\alpha,\beta,\alpha^{\prime}}d_{\alpha}d_{\alpha^{\prime}}\,e^{-C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{e}-(C_{2}(\alpha)+C_{2}(\alpha^{\prime}))\varrho_{1}/2}\mathcal{D}_{\beta}(\gamma_{2},2\varrho_{2}&)\\ \times\int dV\ dW\ \chi_{\alpha}(VU_{1i})\chi_{\beta}(V^{-1}U_{1o})\chi_{\beta}(U_{3o}^{-1}W)\chi_{\alpha^{\prime}}(U_{3i}^{-1}W^{-1})\gamma_{1}(V)_{ii^{\prime}}\,\gamma_{1}(W^{-1})_{k^{\prime}k}&\,,\end{split} (4.5) where the normalization factor is the partition function of a torus with a pair of closed Wilson loops, cf. ( 3.9 ): \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle\mathcal{N}\ =\ {\rm Tr}\,\rho(\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2})\ =\ \sum_{\beta}\mathcal{D}_{\beta}(\gamma_{1},2\varrho_{1})\mathcal{D}_{\beta}(\gamma_{2},2\varrho_{2})\,e^{-C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{e}}\,.\end{array} (4.6) Expression ( 4.5 ) has a straightforward generalization to \rho^{n} : \displaystyle\begin{split}\rho^{n}(U_{1i},U_{3i},U_{1o},U_{3o};\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2})_{ii^{\prime},kk^{\prime}}=\mathcal{N}^{-n}\sum_{\alpha,\beta,\alpha^{\prime}}d_{\alpha}d_{\alpha^{\prime}}\,e^{-nC_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{e}-(C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{1}+C_{2}(\alpha^{\prime})\varrho_{1}/2}\left(\mathcal{D}_{\beta}(\gamma_{2},2\varrho_{2})\right)^{n}\\ \times\left(\mathcal{D}_{\beta}(\gamma_{1},2\varrho_{1})\right)^{n-1}\int dV\ dW\ \chi_{\alpha}(VU_{1i})\chi_{\beta}(V^{-1}U_{1o})\chi_{\beta}(U_{3o}^{-1}W)\chi_{\alpha^{\prime}}(U_{3i}^{-1}W^{-1})\gamma_{1}(V)_{ii^{\prime}}\,\gamma_{1}(W^{-1})_{k^{\prime}k}&\,,\end{split} (4.7) Note that just by comparison with ( 4.6 ) the trace of the above can be cast as \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle{\rm Tr}\,\rho^{n}(\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2})\ =\ \sum_{\beta}h_{\beta}(\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2};\varrho_{1},\varrho_{2},\varrho_{e})^{n}\,,\end{array} (4.8) so that the entanglement entropy of the left half of the system is \boxed{S=-\sum_{\beta}h_{\beta}\log h_{\beta}\,,\qquad h_{\beta}(\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2},\varrho_{1},\varrho_{2},\varrho_{e})=\dfrac{1}{\mathcal{N}}\,{\mathcal{D}_{\beta}(\gamma_{1},2\varrho_{1})\mathcal{D}_{\beta}(\gamma_{2},2\varrho_{2})e^{-C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{e}}}\,,} (4.9) where \mathcal{N} is the same as in ( 4.6 ). Finally, we can also consider a somewhat intermediate scenario between lines and loops. Namely, let us assume that only one cylinder boundary has a line attached. Although the entropy is independent of which side is traced out, if we trace out the side with the line, the reduced density matrix will essentially be the state shown in Figure 2 . The entropy may then be obtained by taking one of the lines above to be in the trivial representation: \boxed{S=-\sum_{\beta}h_{\beta}\log h_{\beta}\,,\quad h_{\beta}(\gamma,\varrho_{i},\varrho_{e})=\dfrac{1}{\mathcal{N}}\,{\mathcal{D}_{\beta}(\gamma,2\varrho_{1})e^{-C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{e}}}\,,\quad\mathcal{N}=\sum_{\alpha}{\mathcal{D}_{\alpha}(\gamma,2\varrho_{1})e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{e}}}\,.} (4.10) 4.1.1 Entanglement entropy analysis Note that the formula for the coefficients in the expression ( 4.9 ) is a variation of formula ( 3.10 ), which looks like a “square root” of the configuration with two loops in representations \gamma_{1} and \gamma_{2} , so the analysis is very similar to the case of a cylinder with contractible loops. To compare, we quote here the normalization factor ( 3.9 ), which had the structure \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle\mathcal{N}=\sum_{\alpha}\left(\prod^{n}_{k=1}\mathcal{D}_{\alpha}(\gamma_{k},\varrho_{k})^{2}\right)e^{-C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{e}}\,.\end{array} (4.11) In the large area limit, this fact implies the same hierarchy of the exponential terms and the same optimal ratios as in the case of a single loop. What will change are the values of the entropy because the factors of dimensions in h_{\beta} will not be squared. For SU(2) this results in the following values, cf. ( 3.15 ): \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle h_{n}(\gamma)=\frac{1}{1+\frac{d_{n}d_{\gamma-n+1}}{d_{\gamma-n}d_{n-1}}}\,.\end{array} (4.12) To illustrate the similarity and the difference between the two cases, we plot the entropies ( 4.10 ) and ( 3.10 ) for Wilson lines and Wilson loops with compatible representations and areas in Figure 17 . For Wilson lines, Figure 17(a) and similar plots show that the entropy profiles have similar shapes, but there is a consistent shift of the entropy peaks towards smaller area fractions. In the infinite area limit, the entropy peaks occur at the same area fractions, as illustrated in Figure 17(b) . The entropy of a single Wilson line is higher in the infinite area limit, as expected from the perspective that the line is only half of the loop. (a) (b) Figure 17 : Entropy ( 4.10 ) of Wilson lines anchored on one of the cylinder’s boundaries as a function of the area fraction for irreps [5,0,0] and [2,1,0] of SU(3) ( 17(a) ) and as a function of the total area \varrho_{t} in irrep [3,0] of SU(2) ( 17(b) ). Dashed curves show similar qualitative results for the case of Wilson loops. 4.2 Wilson lines anchored on opposite boundaries of a cylinder If one inserts two nonintersecting lines stretched between the opposite boundaries of the cylinder, the following cell decomposition can be employed. We denote the respective cell areas as \varrho_{1} and \varrho_{2} , see Figure 18 . The corresponding wavefunction in the holonomy basis is written as: \displaystyle\begin{split}\psi(U_{1t},U_{2t},U_{1b},U_{2b}&;\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2})_{ii^{\prime},jj^{\prime}}=\sum_{\alpha,\beta}d_{\alpha}d_{\beta}\,e^{-(C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{1}+C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{2})/2}\\ &\times\int dW_{1}\ dW_{2}\ \chi_{\alpha}(U_{1t}W_{2}U_{2t}W_{1}^{-1})\,\chi_{\beta}(U_{1b}W_{1}U_{2b}W_{2}^{-1})\,\gamma_{1}(W_{1})_{ii^{\prime}}\,\gamma_{2}(W_{2})_{jj^{\prime}}\end{split} (4.13) It’s not hard to see that by making another copy of the cylinder and gluing both together to form a density operator, one obtains the same result, except for doubled area factors in the exponential. U_{1} U_{2} i i^{\prime} j j^{\prime} W_{1}^{-1} W_{2}^{-1} W_{2} W_{1} \varrho_{1} \varrho_{2} U_{1t} i U_{2t} i^{\prime} U_{1b} j U_{2b} j^{\prime} Figure 18 : Cylinder with a pair of parallel Wilson lines and its cell decomposition. As before, we compute the entropy associated with the left/right subsystems. By the symmetry of the state matrix ( 4.13 ), the left/right reduced density matrix and all its powers are given by essentially the same expression, with the only difference being the amount of area covered by the cylinder. Similarly to the calculation in Section 4.1 , one can find the trace of the n -th power of the reduced density matrix of the left subsystem as a sum over weighted “probabilities”: {\rm Tr}\,\rho^{n}\ =\ \sum\limits_{\alpha,\beta}N^{\alpha}_{\gamma_{1}\beta}N^{\beta}_{\alpha\gamma_{2}}\,p_{\alpha\beta}^{n}\,,\qquad p_{\alpha\beta}\ =\ \frac{1}{\cal{N}}\,e^{-(C_{2}(\alpha)\varrho_{1}+C_{2}(\beta)\varrho_{2})}\,, (4.14) where the normalization factor {\cal N} is the partition of the torus T^{2} with a pair of Wilson loops along the longitude of the torus: 9 9 9 This partition function does not distinguish between the longitude and the meridian and can be compared with the expression previously encountered in ( 3.39 ). \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle{\cal N}\ =\ Z(T^{2};\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2})\ =\ \sum_{\lambda,\sigma}N^{\lambda}_{\gamma_{1}\sigma}N^{\sigma}_{\lambda\gamma_{2}}e^{-(C_{2}(\lambda)\varrho_{1}+C_{2}(\sigma)\varrho_{2})}\,.\end{array} (4.15) The entropy is then \boxed{\quad S=-\sum_{\alpha,\beta}N^{\alpha}_{\gamma_{1}\beta}N^{\beta}_{\alpha\gamma_{2}}\,p_{\alpha,\beta}\log p_{\alpha,\beta}\,.\quad} (4.16) 4.2.1 Entanglement entropy analysis As in previous examples, we find particular configurations for which the entropy does not vanish in the large area limit, which we characterize by the ratio between \varrho_{1} and the total area \rho_{t}=\varrho_{1}+\varrho_{2} : r\equiv\varrho_{1}/(\varrho_{1}+\varrho_{2}) . Specializing to the case of SU(2) , we see that representations \gamma_{1} and \gamma_{2} are compatible if and only if they sum to an even number. Assuming, for simplicity, that \gamma_{2}\geq\gamma_{1} , we see that the leading contribution to the partition function ( 4.15 ) is dominated by \displaystyle\begin{split}Z&\simeq\sum_{n=0}^{\gamma_{1}}\exp\left\{-\left[C_{2}\left(\frac{\gamma_{2}+\gamma_{1}}{2}-n\right)\varrho_{1}+C_{2}\left(\frac{\gamma_{2}-\gamma_{1}}{2}+n\right)\varrho_{2}\right]\right\}.\end{split} (4.17) In particular, the lowest values of the Casimirs are attained on the following representations: \lambda=\frac{\gamma_{2}+\gamma_{1}}{2}-n and \sigma=\frac{\gamma_{2}-\gamma_{1}}{2}+n for n=0,\dots,\gamma_{1} . Writing \varrho_{2}=x\varrho_{1} , we see that optimal ratios appear when exactly two terms in Z simultaneously dominate. In particular, whenever there are two dominating terms, they are neighbors in n . That is, they satisfy \begin{array}[]{rcl}\displaystyle C_{2}\left(\frac{\gamma_{2}-\gamma_{1}}{2}+n\right)x+C_{2}\left(\frac{\gamma_{2}+\gamma_{1}}{2}-n\right)=C_{2}\left(\frac{\gamma_{2}-\gamma_{1}}{2}+n+1\right)x+C_{2}\left(\frac{\gamma_{2}+\gamma_{1}}{2}+\gamma_{1}-n-1\right)\,.\end{array} (4.18) Therefore, optimal fractions r=x/(1+x) are given by \displaystyle\begin{split}r_{n}(\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2})&=\frac{C_{2}(\frac{\gamma_{2}-\gamma_{1}}{2}+n-1)-C_{2}(\frac{\gamma_{2}-\gamma_{1}}{2}+n)}{C_{2}(\frac{\gamma_{2}+\gamma_{1}}{2}-n)-C_{2}(\frac{\gamma_{2}+\gamma_{1}}{2}-n+1)+C_{2}(\frac{\gamma_{2}-\gamma_{1}}{2}+n-1)-C_{2}(\frac{\gamma_{2}-\gamma_{1}}{2}+n)}\\ &=\frac{1+2n+\gamma_{2}-\gamma_{1}}{2\gamma_{2}+4}\,,\end{split} (4.19) for n=1,\dots,\gamma_{1} . Note that these correspond to \gamma_{1} -many central peaks of the loop case ( 3.13 ) for representation \gamma_{2} . Moreover, for \gamma_{1}=\gamma_{2} the result matches precisely ( 3.13 ). As in that case, there is a reflection symmetry in the distribution of ratios between [0,1] . At a particular fraction r_{n} , there are two asymptoticaly non-zero contributions p_{\alpha\beta} : one with \alpha=\frac{\gamma_{2}+\gamma_{1}}{2}-n , \beta=\frac{\gamma_{2}-\gamma_{1}}{2}+n and another with \alpha=\frac{\gamma_{2}+\gamma_{1}}{2}-n+1 , \beta=\frac{\gamma_{2}-\gamma_{1}}{2}+n-1 . Each of them is equal to 1/2 , since there will be two contributing exponential terms from the normalization factor {\cal N} in the denominator. Therefore, the entropy asymptotes to that of a Bell pair in the large area limit, \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle S=\log 2\,.\end{array} (4.20) Note that the set of asymptotic density matrices constructed with parallel Wilson lines is different from the case of states with Wilson loops. These density matrices have much more complicated structure, cf. ( 4.13 ), defined in a larger basis of representation matrices. To illustrate our results, in Figure 19(a) we consider the case \gamma_{1}=[3,0] and \gamma_{2}=[5,0] . For this choice, ( 4.19 ) yields three ratios with non-vanishing entropy in the large area limit, namely 5/14 , 1/2 and 9/14 . As expected, the entropy associated with each of these fractions asymptotes to \log 2 . These values precisely correspond to the three central peaks predicted by ( 3.13 ) for the representation [5,0] . The remaining candidate fractions, 3/14 and 11/14 , are excluded once the second line in the irrep [3,0] is introduced. This exclusion is visible in the plot. Moreover, complementary ratios produce coincident entropy curves, indicating that the entropy is insensitive to the direction from which the two lines approach each other. (a) (b) Figure 19 : ( 19(a) ) Entropy versus total area for a cylinder with two parallel lines in irreps \gamma_{1}=[3,0] and \gamma_{2}=[5,0] of SU(2) . Colored lines are obtained numerically while the gray horizontal line is the analytical result to the asymptotic limit. ( 19(b) ) Peaks of the entropy function for some choices of SU(3) irreps. For SU(3) we restrict ourselves to examples giving \log 3 and higher entropy in the infinite area limit. In this case, for \gamma_{1} and \gamma_{2} to be compatible representations, they should satisfy the ‘‘triality’’ condition; that is, the sum of the number of boxes of the corresponding diagrams must be a multiple of three. 10 10 10 For SU(N) this is the N -ality condition that requires the sum of the number of boxes of the Young diagrams of \gamma_{1} and \gamma_{2} is an integer mutliple of N . In order to reach the \log 3 value, both representations must be genuine SU(3) ones, so the minimal choice is \gamma_{1}=\gamma_{2}=[2,1,0] . In this case, one has the following dominant contribution to the partition function ( 4.15 ): \begin{array}[]{c}\displaystyle Z\ \simeq\ e^{-C_{2}(\scalebox{0.2}{\hbox{}\hskip 0.0pt{\vbox{\vbox{\hrule height=0.3pt\hbox{\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt\hbox to7.65337pt{\hfil}\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt\hbox to7.65337pt{\hfil}\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt}\hrule height=0.3pt}\vskip-0.3pt\vbox{\hrule height=0.3pt\hbox{\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt\hbox to7.65337pt{\hfil}\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt}\hrule height=0.3pt}\vskip-0.3pt}}\hskip 0.0pt})\varrho_{2}}+e^{-C_{2}(\scalebox{0.2}{\hbox{}\hskip 0.0pt{\vbox{\vbox{\hrule height=0.3pt\hbox{\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt\hbox to7.65337pt{\hfil}\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt}\hrule height=0.3pt}\vskip-0.3pt}}\hskip 0.0pt})\varrho_{1}-C_{2}(\scalebox{0.2}{\hbox{}\hskip 0.0pt{\vbox{\vbox{\hrule height=0.3pt\hbox{\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt\hbox to7.65337pt{\hfil}\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt}\hrule height=0.3pt}\vskip-0.3pt}}\hskip 0.0pt})\varrho_{2}}+e^{-C_{2}(\scalebox{0.2}{\hbox{}\hskip 0.0pt{\vbox{\vbox{\hrule height=0.3pt\hbox{\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt\hbox to7.65337pt{\hfil}\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt}\hrule height=0.3pt}\vskip-0.3pt\vbox{\hrule height=0.3pt\hbox{\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt\hbox to7.65337pt{\hfil}\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt}\hrule height=0.3pt}\vskip-0.3pt}}\hskip 0.0pt})\varrho_{1}-C_{2}(\scalebox{0.2}{\hbox{}\hskip 0.0pt{\vbox{\vbox{\hrule height=0.3pt\hbox{\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt\hbox to7.65337pt{\hfil}\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt}\hrule height=0.3pt}\vskip-0.3pt\vbox{\hrule height=0.3pt\hbox{\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt\hbox to7.65337pt{\hfil}\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt}\hrule height=0.3pt}\vskip-0.3pt}}\hskip 0.0pt})\varrho_{2}}+e^{-C_{2}(\scalebox{0.2}{\hbox{}\hskip 0.0pt{\vbox{\vbox{\hrule height=0.3pt\hbox{\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt\hbox to7.65337pt{\hfil}\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt\hbox to7.65337pt{\hfil}\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt}\hrule height=0.3pt}\vskip-0.3pt\vbox{\hrule height=0.3pt\hbox{\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt\hbox to7.65337pt{\hfil}\vrule height=6.12271pt,width=0.3pt,depth=1.53064pt}\hrule height=0.3pt}\vskip-0.3pt}}\hskip 0.0pt})\varrho_{1}}\,.\end{array} (4.21) As one can see, the two central terms are degenerate, which corresponds to a situation similar to the one described in ( 3.20 ) for a contractible Wilson loop in the same representation. The optimal fractions are again r_{-}=4/9 and r_{+}=5/9 . At these fractions, exactly three terms of the above expression contribute, and the entropy is \log 3 . For r_{-}