Recovery-Induced Erasure Attack on QKD Systems Hashir Kuniyil 1 , Asad Ali 1 , Syed M. Arslan 1 , Muhammad Talha Rahim 1 , Artur Czerwinski 2 , Saif Al Kuwari 1 Abstract Detector dead time is typically treated as a fixed parameter in quantum key distribution (QKD) security analyses. In practice, however, the effective recovery time of single-photon avalanche photodiodes (SPADs) depends on the incident count rate. In this work, we demonstrate that this count-rate–dependent recovery nonlinearity constitutes a distinct attack primitive. We experimentally characterize the dead-time shift of a free-running SPAD under controlled broadband loading and observe a substantial increase in effective recovery time as the detected rate rises into the high photon count regime. We show that recovery-induced availability reduction can be modeled as an adversarial erasure channel and derive a conservative bound on the signal detection probability under loading. Unlike previously studied detector-control or efficiency-mismatch attacks, the proposed mechanism does not rely on deterministic blinding or timing discrimination. Instead, count-rate–dependent recovery asymmetry induces basis-dependent suppression of detection probabilities ( p ⟂ < p ∥ p_{\perp}I(A;B) . But, for Eve tobe not detected she also need to reduce the QBER, e_{B}<0.11 (for BBM92)). Fig. 2 : Mutual information I(A;E) (Alice–Eve) and I(A;B) (Alice–Bob) as a function of basis ratio r . The shaded region indicates where Eve is detected, assuming detection if e_{B}>0.11 . The vertical dashed line is at the threshold r_{th}=0.282 . V Experiment To characterize the dependence of detector dead time on count rate, we injected broadband thermal light (Thorlabs SLS201L/M) into an Excelitas avalanche photodiode (APD, SPCM-AQRH-14-FC). The optical intensity was controlled using calibrated neutral density filters to vary the detected count rate over several orders of magnitude. The detector was operated in free-running mode, and timestamps were recorded using a time-tagging module with 8 ps resolution (We used swabian made time tagger ultra). The effective dead time was determined from the onset of the first non-zero bin in the inter-arrival-time histogram. The effective dead time was extracted from the histogram of adjacent photon arrival time differences, following the method described in Ref. [ 16 ] . As the incident photon flux increases, the probability of closely spaced detection events rises; however, events occurring within the detector recovery interval are suppressed due to dead time. Consequently, the short-time region of the inter-arrival-time histogram exhibits a depletion whose width corresponds to the effective recovery time of the detector. The minimum observable separation between consecutive detection events therefore provides a direct estimate of the dead time. By repeating this measurement at different count rates, we obtained the count-rate–dependent effective dead time t_{d}(\lambda) . Fig. 3 : The response of detector SPCM-AQRH-14-FC in various count rate. (a) Measured effective detector dead time t_{d} as a function of the observed count rate. The solid curve shows a fit to the recovery model presented in Ref [ 16 ] . (b) Detector busy fraction \lambda t_{d}(\lambda) as a function of the observed count rate \lambda , calculated from the measured dead time data. The busy fraction represents the proportion of time the detector is unavailable due to recovery. Fig 3 (a) shows the measured dependence of the effective detector dead time on the observed count rate. The dead time increases from its nominal manufacturer-specified value of 23.3 ns to approximately 31.5 ns at high count rates. In the low-noise regime (count rate < 4 Mcps), the measured dead time remains near 23–24 ns. However, as the count rate exceeds 4 Mcps, the dead time begins to increase and surpasses 30 ns above approximately 25 Mcps. This behavior indicates a clear count-rate–dependent recovery nonlinearity in the detector. Since the recovery-induced erasure model relies on temporary detector unavailability during the dead-time interval, it is necessary to estimate the fraction of time the detector is insensitive. In the low-count regime, where t_{d}=23.3 ns and the count rate is small, the detector is effectively available most of the time. To quantify the fraction of time the detector is unavailable, we introduce the dimensionless parameter \lambda t_{d}(\lambda) (27) referred to as the busy fraction. The busy fraction represents the proportion of time the detector resides within its recovery (dead-time) window. As the count rate increases, the busy fraction rises rapidly and exceeds 0.9 above approximately 25 Mcps. The experimentally estimated busy fraction is shown in Fig. 3 (b). To assess the feasibility of the Recovery-Induced Erasure Attack, we next estimate the ratio r=p_{\perp}/p_{\parallel} . Assuming Poisson arrival statistics for the noise photons and adopting a conservative non-paralyzable detector model, the signal detection probability under loading satisfies p(\lambda)\leq p_{0}(1-\lambda t_{d}(\lambda)). (28) Combining Eqs. ( 11 ) and ( 12 ), this yield a conservative bound: R_{\text{bound}}(\lambda_{\perp})=\frac{1-\lambda_{\parallel}\,t_{d}(\lambda_{\parallel})}{1-\lambda_{\perp}\,t_{d}(\lambda_{\perp})}. (29) For representative aligned-basis loading rates \lambda_{\parallel}= 1, 2, 5, 10 Mcps we evaluate this bound using interpolation of the measured t_{d} . The resulting stealth regime is shown in Fig. 4 . The dashed horizontal line at 0.282 corresponds to the QBER abort threshold of 11\% . Curves falling below this threshold indicate parameter regimes in which QBER suppression is achievable under the conservative availability model. Notably, this condition is satisfied only when \lambda_{\perp} enters the high-count regime (upper tens of Mcps), where detector recovery nonlinearity becomes pronounced. Fig. 4 : Conservative bound on the ratio R_{\text{bound}} as a function of the orthogonal-basis loading rate \lambda_{\perp} computed using the measured dead-time dependence t_{d}(\lambda) . VI discussion The RIE attack works when the dead time widening happen as a result of increased count rate. We tested the attacking with weaker Eve, non-deterministic pre-pulse model that provides a conservative bound. In the presence of deterministic pre-pulse timing, suppression of the signal detector can be stronger than predicted by the average busy-fraction model. In our attacking test, we used thermal light as a pre-pulse model which has random (Poisson) arrivals, steady-state statistics, and has no precise timing control. Therefore, it gives an average availability. If Eve sends a strong pre-pulse at time t=0 and a signal pulse at time t=\Delta , then detector behavior is not statistical — it is time conditioned. For a non-paralyzable detector, detector is unavailable if \Deltat_{d}.\end{cases} (30) This is a step-like suppression. Therefore, Eve does not require to elevate the count rate as in non-deterministic pre-pulse. Under deterministic pre-pulse model the suppression of desirable basis is maximum. Meaning, with deterministic model Eve can achieve p_{\perp}\rightarrow 0 while keeping p_{\parallel}\rightarrow p_{0} . If the pre-pulse is routed to the non-signal detector in the aligned case, this yields r=0 , which is much lower than in the case where a non-deterministic pulse is used as a pre-pulse, for which r=0.282 . Important distinction of RIE attack with well known attacks are counter measure based on measurement window enlargement does not help to deviate this attack. In detector-efficiency-mismatch and time-shift attacks, enlarging the coincidence window is a common countermeasure because it restores symmetry in timing-dependent detection efficiencies. In such attacks, detection events are present but temporally biased, and a wider coincidence window ensures that shifted clicks are not preferentially accepted or rejected. In contrast, the recovery-induced erasure mechanism analyzed here operates at the level of detector availability rather than timing discrimination. When a detector is within its recovery (dead-time) interval at the photon arrival time, no detection event is generated and consequently no timestamp exists to be evaluated by the coincidence logic. Therefore, increasing the coincidence window cannot recover suppressed detection events, as erasures correspond to physically missing clicks rather than timing shifts. Indeed, enlarging the coincidence window may increase the accidental coincidence rate, potentially raising the observed QBER without mitigating the underlying erasure asymmetry. This distinction highlights that countermeasures designed for efficiency-mismatch attacks do not directly address recovery-induced erasure mechanisms. Although the recovery-induced erasure mechanism has been formulated here in the context of active-basis BBM92 implementations, the underlying principle is not restricted to this specific architecture. The essential requirement of the attack is the presence of count-rate–dependent detector recovery nonlinearity that induces basis-dependent detection suppression p_{\perp}