Relativistic distorted-wave analysis of the missing-energy spectrum measured with monochromatic ν μ \nu_{\mu} – 12 C interactions at JSNS 2 J. M. Franco-Patino, J. García-Marcos, V. Belocchi, M. B. Barbaro, G. Co’, R. González-Jiménez Abstract Recently, the JSNS 2 collaboration measured for the first time the missing-energy distribution of 12 C using a monochromatic neutrino beam coming from kaon decays at rest. In this work we present the results of an analysis of this spectrum using the relativistic distorted-wave approach. A new parameterization of the spectral function for neutrons in 12 C, which incorporates detailed information from ( e , e ′ ​ p ) \left(e,e^{\prime}p\right) experiments with high missing-energy resolution has been used. The role of the recoil of the residual nucleus, final-state interactions, and neutrino event generators are discussed. I Introduction Motivated by the global effort to measure the neutrino-oscillation parameters, neutrino–nucleus interactions have been investigated with unprecedented intensity Alvarez-Ruso et al. 2018 . The interpretation of accelerator-based measurements requires accurate modeling of neutrino–nucleus cross sections over a wide range of energies. Since neutrino beams are commonly produced via charged-particle decays in flight, they exhibit a broad energy spectrum at the detector, which complicates the reconstruction of the incident neutrino energy on an event-by-event basis. Moreover, beyond the intrinsic uncertainties in energy reconstruction, determining the reaction mechanism underlying the measured observables remains a persistent and nontrivial challenge. Kaon decays at rest (KDAR) provide a unique opportunity to study neutrino–nucleus interactions while avoiding the complications associated with neutrinos produced by meson decays in flight. The resulting monoenergetic \nu_{\mu} beam, with E_{\nu}=235.5 MeV, constitutes an especially clean probe for the direct study of nuclear effects such as initial- and final-state interactions and correlations in the nuclear medium. More broadly, KDAR \nu_{\mu} offer the prospect of substantially reducing experimental and theoretical uncertainties and mitigating longstanding ambiguities. Although KDAR neutrinos were observed for the first time by the MiniBooNE collaboration Aguilar-Arevalo et al. 2018 , the JSNS 2 collaboration Marzec et al. 2025 has set a new paradigm in neutrino physics. For the first time, in a laboratory scattering experiment, the missing-energy spectrum of neutrons in 12 C using KDAR neutrinos was measured. Unfortunately, only the shape of the cross section versus the missing energy is available and not its normalization. Despite of this limitation, these first data represent an important step forward in the direction of understanding the low-energy neutrino-nucleus interaction. In this article, we present the results of an investigation aimed to study the role played by various nuclear effects related to the neutrino-nucleus interaction. We start by using the relativistic-mean field model Ring 1996 ; Walecka 1974 ; Serot and Walecka 1992 to describe the nucleus ground-state. We correct this basic model by adding effects beyond the mean-field approximation based on a parameterization of the 12 C spectral function given in Ankowski et al. 2024 . For the modeling of final-state interactions, we include proton distortion using the relativistic distorted-wave formalism Udías et al. 1993 ; Udías et al. 1995 ; Udías et al. 2001 ; González-Jiménez et al. 2022 ; Nikolakopoulos et al. 2022 ; Franco-Patino et al. 2022 ; Franco-Patino et al. 2024 and simulate the inelastic interactions using the neutrino event generator NuWro Golan et al. 2012 ; Niewczas and Sobczyk 2019 . In Sec. II we summarize the general kinematics of the interaction of a monochromatic neutrino with a nucleus in the impulse approximation. In Sec. III and Sec. IV we address the relativistic distorted-wave formalism, as well as the description of the ground-state nucleus within the relativistic-mean model with a parameterized spectral function. In Sec. V we present a comparison of the JSNS 2 measurement and the theoretical predictions. Finally, we draw our conclusions in Sec. VI . II Kinematics We present in this section the basic expressions of our description of the process studied by the JSNS 2 collaboration where muon neutrinos generated by the KDAR process impact on the 12 C target inducing a charge current (CC) reaction producing a \mu^{-} of energy E_{\mu} . We work under the assumption that, given the low energy of the incoming neutrino, the main interaction channel is the quasielastic (QE) scattering off a single bound neutron in 12 C. This means that the value of the energy transferred to the bound neutron \omega=E_{\nu}-E_{\mu} is above the nucleon emission threshold. Therefore, our final state will be characterized by a residual nucleus B and one proton emitted with energy E_{p} . The residual nucleus of mass M_{B} has total energy E_{B} which includes the recoil kinetic energy T_{B} and an eventual excitation energy \xi , such as E_{B}=M_{B}+T_{B}+\xi . In the laboratory frame, with the z axis aligned with the incoming neutrino momentum \mathbf{k_{\nu}} , and within the impulse approximation (IA), where the exchanged W boson is assumed to couple to a single bound nucleon that is subsequently ejected, the semi-inclusive \nu_{\mu}+A\rightarrow\mu+p+B cross section can be written as Franco-Patino et al. 2022 \frac{d\sigma(E_{\nu})}{dk_{\mu}d\Omega_{\mu}dp_{p}d\Omega_{p}dE_{m}}=\frac{G_{F}^{2}\cos^{2}{\theta_{c}}k_{\mu}^{2}p_{p}^{2}}{64\pi^{5}}L_{\mu\nu}H^{\mu\nu}\delta\left(\omega+M_{A}-E_{p}-E_{B}\right), (1) where \mathbf{k}_{\mu} and \mathbf{p}_{p} denote the momenta of the ejected muon and proton, respectively, and \Omega_{\mu} and \Omega_{p} represent their corresponding emission angles. We indicate with M_{A} is the mass of the target nucleus, with G_{F} the Fermi constant and with \theta_{c} the Cabibbo angle. The cross section is also a function of the contraction of the leptonic L_{\mu\nu} and the hadronic H^{\mu\nu} tensors. The observable measured by JSNS 2 , the missing energy E_{m} , is defined as follows E_{m}=E_{s}^{n}+\xi=M_{B}-M_{A}+m_{n}+\xi, (2) where E_{s}^{n}=M_{B}-M_{A}+m_{n} is the neutron separation energy. The energy conservation in Eq. ( 1 ) can be expressed as \omega+M_{A}=E_{p}+E_{B}\longrightarrow\omega+m_{n}=E_{m}+T_{p}+m_{p}+T_{B}, (3) where m_{p} is the mass of the emitted nucleon, T_{p} its kinetic energy, and T_{B} is the kinetic energy of the residual nucleus T_{B}=E_{B}-M_{B}-\xi=\sqrt{\mathbf{p}_{m}^{2}+(M_{B}+\xi)^{2}}-M_{B}-\xi. (4) We indicate with \mathbf{p}_{m}=\mathbf{p}_{p}-\mathbf{q} the missing momentum, which is fixed by momentum conservation and depends on the momentum of the ejected nucleon \mathbf{p}_{p} and on the transferred momentum \mathbf{q}=\mathbf{k_{\nu}}-\mathbf{k_{\mu}} . The recoil of the residual nucleus T_{B} in Eq. ( 3 ) introduces a complicated angular dependence in the energy-conservation delta function, making the integration over one of the variables in Eq. ( 1 ) non-trivial. For instance, if we solve the energy conservation to integrate on p_{p} we obtain a quadratic equation \left[A_{0}^{2}-\alpha^{2}\right]p_{p}^{2}-\alpha\Delta p_{p}+A_{0}^{2}m_{p}^{2}-\Delta^{2}/4=0, (5) where \displaystyle A_{0} \displaystyle=E_{\nu}-E_{\mu}+M_{A} (6) \displaystyle\Delta \displaystyle=A_{0}^{2}+m_{p}^{2}-q^{2}-(M_{B}+\xi)^{2} \displaystyle\alpha=E_{\nu}\cos{\theta_{p}}- \displaystyle k_{\mu}\left(\sin{\theta_{\mu}}\sin{\theta_{p}}\cos{\phi_{p}}+\cos{\theta_{\mu}}\cos{\theta_{p}}\right). Integrating over p_{p} using the delta function introduces a factor f_{\textnormal{rec}}^{-1}=\left|\frac{p_{p}}{E_{p}}+\frac{p_{p}-\alpha}{E_{B}}\right|^{-1}\;\;, in the expression of the cross section. Then, Eq. ( 1 ) becomes \frac{d\sigma(E_{\nu})}{dk_{\mu}d\Omega_{\mu}d\Omega_{p}dE_{m}}=\frac{G_{F}^{2}\cos^{2}{\theta_{c}}k_{\mu}^{2}p_{p}^{2}}{64\pi^{5}f_{\textnormal{rec}}}L_{\mu\nu}H^{\mu\nu}, (7) where p_{p} is the solution of Eq. ( 5 ). If the two solutions of Eq. ( 5 ) are valid, then the cross section is the incoherent sum of both solutions. As we will show later, retaining the recoil of the residual nucleus in Eq. ( 3 ) allows us to investigate its impact on the missing-energy spectrum measured by JSNS 2 . III The relativistic distorted-wave approach The kinematic region accessible to the JSNS 2 experiment requires a careful treatment of nuclear effects ( e.g. Pauli blocking, ground state correlations, re-interaction of the emitted nucleon with the residual nucleus, etc.) in order to accurately describe the experimental results Nikolakopoulos et al. 2021 . In this work we adopt the relativistic distorted-wave approach based on the energy dependent-relativistic mean field model (ED-RMF) González-Jiménez et al. 2019 ; González-Jiménez et al. 2020 . This model has been used to describe inclusive \left(e,e^{\prime}\right) data that overlap in phase-space with 235.5 MeV \nu_{\mu} scattering processes González-Jiménez et al. 2019 . In our description of the process we consider that \nu_{\mu} interacts with a bound neutron which becomes a proton because of the CC weak interaction. The proton is then emitted from the nucleus. In our model, the remaining nucleons act as inert spectators in the one-body process described above. In the relativistic distorted-wave impulse approximation (RDWIA) we can express the hadronic tensor H^{\mu\nu} of Eq. ( 7 ) as a sum over occupied initial-states identified by the quantum number \kappa H^{\mu\nu}=\sum_{\kappa}\mathcal{H}^{\mu\nu}_{\kappa}=\sum_{\kappa}\rho_{\kappa}(E_{m})\sum_{s_{p},m_{j}}J^{\mu}_{s_{p},\kappa,m_{j}}J^{\nu*}_{s_{p},\kappa,m_{j}}, (8) where the hadronic current is J_{s_{p},\kappa,m_{j}}^{\mu}=\int d\mathbf{r}e^{i\mathbf{r}\cdot\mathbf{q}}\bar{\Psi}^{s_{p}}(\mathbf{r},p_{p})\hat{J}^{\mu}\Phi_{\kappa}^{m_{j}}(\mathbf{r}), (9) and \rho_{\kappa}(E_{m}) indicates the missing energy profile. In the above expressions j=|\kappa|-1/2 is the total angular momentum of the bound neutron, m_{j} its third component and s_{p} is the spin projection of the ejected proton. The weak current one-body operator \hat{J}^{\mu} has the CC2 expression given in Ref. Franco-Patino et al. 2022 . The wave functions \Psi^{s_{p}} and \Phi_{\kappa}^{m_{j}} are four-dimensional spinors that describe, respectively, the scattered and bound nucleons. The 12 C ground state is described in terms of single particle wave functions \Phi_{\kappa}^{m_{j}}(\mathbf{r}) obtained within the independent-particle shell model, where the nucleons inside the nucleus occupy discrete energy states that are eigenvalues of a spherically symmetrical potential. For this work, we consider a fully relativistic framework where the bound states are solutions of the Dirac equation with scalar and vector potentials given by the relativistic mean field (RMF) approach Ring 1996 ; Walecka 1974 ; Serot and Walecka 1992 . The free parameters of the RMF potential are fitted to reproduce different properties of finite nuclei. In this work, we use the potential NLSH described in Sharma et al. 1993 . Table. 1 lists the model predictions for the neutron and proton separation energies in 12 C, while Fig. 1 shows the corresponding densities and root-mean-square charge radius. Figure 1: Charge and neutron radial density calculated with the RMF potential NLSH Sharma et al. 1993 , compared with a fit to elastic electron–nucleus scattering data De Vries et al. 1987 . The root-mean-square (rms) charge radius obtained with NLSH is 2.46811 fm, in agreement with the experimental value of 2.4701\pm 0.0022 fm Angeli and Marinova 2013 . protons neutrons th. exp. th. exp. 1p_{3/2} 14.46 15.96 17.81 18.72 1s_{1/2} 40.50 - 44.37 - Table 1: Energy levels of the 1p_{3/2} and 1s_{1/2} shells obtained with the NLSH parameterization Sharma et al. 1993 for protons and neutrons in 12 C compared with the empirical separation energies from Ref. Wang et al. 2021 . All the energies are in MeV. Within RDWIA, the wave function \Psi^{s_{p}}\left(\mathbf{r},p_{p}\right) describes the scattered proton with asymptotic momentum p_{p} and is given by \displaystyle\Psi^{s_{p}}\left(\mathbf{r},p_{p}\right)=4\pi\sqrt{\frac{E_{p}+m_{p}}{2E_{p}}}\sum_{\kappa,\mu,m^{\prime}}e^{i\delta_{\kappa}}i^{l}Y_{lm^{\prime}}^{*}(\Omega_{p})\psi_{\kappa}^{\mu}\left(\mathbf{r},p_{p}\right), (10) where Y_{lm}(\Omega_{p}) are the spherical harmonics that describe the direction of the emitted proton and \delta_{\kappa} is the phase shift obtained by matching the distorted wave-function to the Dirac-Coulomb wave-function. The orbital momentum l is fixed by \kappa and take the values l=\kappa if \kappa>0 and l=-\kappa-1 if \kappa<0 . The wave function \psi_{\kappa}^{\mu}\left(\mathbf{r},p_{p}\right) is a four-component spinor of the form \psi_{\kappa}^{\mu}\left(\mathbf{r},p_{p}\right)=\begin{pmatrix}g_{\kappa}\!\left(E_{p},r\right)\,\Phi_{\kappa}^{\mu}\!\left(\Omega_{r}\right)\\[4.0pt] i\,f_{\kappa}\!\left(E_{p},r\right)\,\Phi_{-\kappa}^{\mu}\!\left(\Omega_{r}\right)\end{pmatrix} (11) with the Pauli spin-spherical harmonics \Phi_{\kappa}^{\mu}(\Omega_{r})=\sum_{s_{p}}Y_{l}^{\mu}(\Omega_{r})\chi^{s_{p}}, (12) where \chi^{s_{p}} is a Pauli spinor of two components and g_{\kappa} and f_{\kappa} satisfy the following coupled-differential equations \displaystyle\frac{df_{\kappa}}{dr}= \displaystyle\frac{\kappa-1}{r}f_{\kappa}-\bigg(E_{p}-m_{p}-V(r)\bigg)g_{\kappa} (13) \displaystyle\frac{dg_{\kappa}}{dr}=- \displaystyle\frac{\kappa-1}{r}g_{\kappa}+\bigg(E_{p}+m_{p}-V(r)\bigg)f_{\kappa}. Our theoretical predictions for the QE channel correspond to two calculations based on the distorted-wave approach with two different potentials V(r) . One of the models is based on the ED-RMF potential González-Jiménez et al. 2019 ; González-Jiménez et al. 2020 , which is real and used to describe inclusive \left(e,e^{\prime}\right) and \left(\nu,l\right) data, and the other one is based on the relativistic optical potential (ROP) Cooper et al. 1993 , which is complex and can be used to describe \left(e,e^{\prime}p\right) data Udías et al. 1993 ; Udías et al. 1995 ; Udías et al. 2001 . More specifically, we use here the energy-dependent A-independent Carbon (EDAI-C) optical potential. Notice that there is a third option, which is not realistic for the kinematics involved in the process, that is the relativistic plane-wave model (RPWIA) where the coupled equations are solved with V(r)=0 González-Jiménez et al. 2019 . IV Missing energy profile parameterization In the pure shell model presented so far, the missing-energy distribution \rho_{\kappa}\left(E_{m}\right) is given by a sum of Dirac delta functions. These delta functions ensure that the missing energy can take only discrete values, corresponding to the energy eigenvalues of the fully occupied single-particle states given the RMF model. This model is relatively simple, and a meaningful comparison with the missing-energy distribution measured by JSNS 2 requires a more realistic description of the initial nuclear bound state that incorporates correlations, i.e. , effects beyond the pure mean-field approximation. There is an extensive body of literature addressing microscopic calculations of spectral functions, which lead to the missing-energy profile \rho_{\kappa}\left(E_{m}\right) Müther and Dickhoff 1994 ; Benhar et al. 1994 ; Benhar et al. 2005 ; Polls et al. 1997 ; Atkinson and Dickhoff 2019 ; Barbieri and Carbone 2017 ; Sartor 1976 ; Jeukenne et al. 1976 . Here, we adopt a phenomenological approach and, based on previous work González-Jiménez et al. 2022 ; Franco-Patino et al. 2022 , we introduce a new parameterization of the missing-energy profile \rho_{\kappa}\left(E_{m}\right) for neutrons in 12 C. The parameterization is based on the updated spectral function of Ref. Ankowski et al. 2024 which us optimized to improve the agreement with exclusive \left(e,e^{\prime}p\right) data Van Der Steenhoven et al. 1988 . The improvement is obtained by modeling the region dominated by the p -states with three Dirac deltas instead of only one narrow Gaussian. In our modeling of \rho_{\kappa}\left(E_{m}\right) , three distinct contributions are considered. The first contribution is associated with the occupancy of the p -states and corresponds to the energy region extending from the neutron emission threshold to about 22 MeV ( E_{m}\approx 18-22 MeV). In this region, the profile is represented by three Dirac delta functions as in Ref. Ankowski et al. 2024 . Those three p-states correspond to a 1p_{3/2} shell describing the ground state and two excited states, namely 1p_{1/2} and 1p_{3/2} , corresponding to 2.125 MeV and 5.020 MeV of excitation energy Van Der Steenhoven et al. 1988 . For both excited states we use the same wave-function predicted by the RMF model for the 1p_{3/2} ground-state. Figure 2: Missing energy profile of a neutron in a s -state of 12 C parameterized with \mu=37 MeV and \sigma=19 MeV using Gaussian and Maxwell-Boltzmann distributions (see Eq. ( 14 )). Both distributions are normalized to n_{1s1/2}= 1.74 nucleons. The second contribution is associated with the s -states, which (e,e^{\prime}p) experiments indicate to exhibit a large width. We abandoned the usual gaussian parameterization in favor of an asymmetric Maxwell-Boltzmann shape of the type \rho_{1s1/2}\left(E_{m}\right)=\frac{4{n_{1s1/2}}}{\sigma\,\sqrt{\pi}}\;\exp\!\left(-\frac{(E_{m}-\mu+\sigma)^{2}}{\sigma^{2}}\right)\;\frac{(E_{m}-\mu+\sigma)^{2}}{{\sigma}^{2}}; (14) with \mu=37.0 MeV and \sigma= 19 MeV. In Fig. 2 we compare the missing-energy profiles of a neutron in a s -state obtained using Gaussian and Maxwell-Boltzmann distributions. The two distributions are normalized at the same value, corresponding to n_{1s1/2}= 1.74 nucleons. The Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution avoids the unphysical contribution at E_{m} values below the nucleon emission threshold. Figure 3: Comparison of our missing energy profile \rho_{\kappa}\left(E_{m}\right) of neutrons with that of Ref. Ankowski et al. 2024 . A shift of +2.764 MeV has been applied to the results of Ankowski et al. to account for neutron, rather than proton, emission (see text for explanation). The third contribution in our modeling of \rho_{\kappa}\left(E_{m}\right) is related to the region of E_{m} and p_{m} where the effects of short-range correlations on the spectral function are significant Ankowski et al. 2024 . We refer to this contribution as the “background” and parametrize it as follows to reproduce the high-energy tail reported in Ankowski et al. 2024 : \rho_{\textnormal{backg}}\left(E_{m}\right)=n_{b}\exp(-x_{\textnormal{cut}}b)\exp\bigg(-w\big(E_{m}-x_{\textnormal{cut}}\big)\bigg) (15) for 2630 MeV in both cases presented in the figure, namely with and without including the recoil of the residual nucleus. However, predictions from intranuclear cascade models for protons in the kinetic-energy range relevant to KDAR neutrinos must be interpreted with great care. Investigations of hadronic final-state interactions in neutrino–nucleus reactions have found substantial differences among different cascade-model predictions, and they also point to limitations of the semiclassical treatment at such low nucleon energies, where the Compton wavelength becomes comparable to the nuclear size Dytman et al. 2021 ; Nikolakopoulos et al. 2024 . All theoretical cross sections shown in Fig. 5 vanish below the neutron emission threshold of 18.7 MeV, as expected within our RDWIA models. However, the experimental data exhibit nonzero values even at energies below this threshold. The presence of cross section below threshold may be attributed to nuclear structure effects, correlations, and also to the finite energy resolution of the detector. We simulate the detector smearing with a Gaussian distribution centered at E_{\textnormal{vis}} and with a width \sigma=0.025\times E_{\textnormal{vis}} . This 2.5\% energy smearing is quoted in Marzec et al. 2025 to be a plausible estimate of the minimum energy resolution of the JSNS 2 detector. The results obtained with this smearing procedure are shown in Fig. 6 . We observe that the region below the threshold is now populated by the theoretical cross sections, and the agreement with the experimental data is improved, especially for the case including the recoil. In the lower panel of Fig. 6 , the position of the peak is no longer visible around E_{m}\approx 18.7 MeV due to the combined effect of neglecting the recoil and the detector smearing. If the recoiling residual nucleus does not produce visible light in the detector, this combined effect could help explain the discrepancies observed between the data and the generator predictions, which does not account for recoil effects in the kinematics, in the region of the peak Marzec et al. 2025 . VI Summary and conclusions We analyzed the results of the JSNS 2 experiment Marzec et al. 2025 , which observes CC interactions of muon neutrinos produced via kaon decay at rest on a 12 C target. In our model, the \nu_{\mu} interacts with a neutron in 12 C, which is converted into a proton via a CC interaction and subsequently emitted from the nucleus together with the associated \mu^{-} . The 12 C ground state is described within a relativistic mean-field model. In this framework, the nucleons in 12 C fully occupy the lowest single-particle levels, obtained by solving a set of coupled Dirac equations that include a potential simulating the average interaction of a nucleon with the remaining nucleons Ring 1996 ; Sharma et al. 1993 . The missing energy, E_{m} , takes discrete values corresponding to the single-particle level energies. Consequently, the missing-energy distribution \rho_{\kappa}\left(E_{m}\right) consists of a sum of Dirac delta functions for all the occupied shells. We improve this model by constructing a \rho_{\kappa}(E_{m}) that reproduces the spectral function of Ankowski et al. Ankowski et al. 2024 . Our \rho_{\kappa}(E_{m}) parameterization consists of three contributions. The first is a sum of three delta functions accounting for the p -shell states. The second describes the s -shell contribution, modeled by a Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution. Finally, we include a background term that accounts for the effects of short-range correlations, which generate strength at large missing-energy values. The final nuclear state, consisting of the emitted proton and the residual 11 C nucleus, is treated using three different approaches. In the first approach (ED-RMF), the proton wave function is distorted by the same real potential employed to describe the 12 C ground state. In the second approach (ROP), the proton wave function is obtained by solving the Dirac equation with a complex optical potential. Finally, the ED-RMF wave function is used as input to the cascade model of NuWro, which simulates the re-scattering of the primary proton with the remaining nucleons within a semiclassical framework. This last modeling approach allows us to identify the role of neutron emission induced by re-scattering processes. The comparison with the data is affected by an ambiguity in the definition of the missing energy, depending on whether the recoil of the residual nucleus is taken into account. We therefore present our results for both scenarios, namely with and without nuclear recoil. We find that including the recoil effect in our calculations leads to improved agreement with the experimental data, especially in the region of the p -shell peak. However, if JSNS 2 detector does not collect the light produced by the recoil, the shifted distribution obtained without the recoil could explain the inconsistencies found between the data and the generator predictions, which do not take into account the recoil in the kinematics, in the region of the peak. The experimental data provide only the shape of the cross section as a function of the missing energy, not its absolute normalization. For this reason, all our results are normalized to the total strength of the empirical data. The ED-RMF and ROP calculations exhibit very similar profiles, although the overall strength of the ROP cross section is approximately 27% smaller than that of the ED-RMF result. The situation is quite different for the ED-RMF + NuWro results. The shape of the distribution is modified, as part of the strength is shifted from the main p -shell contribution to larger missing-energy values. This effect arises from neutron emission induced by the re-scattering of the primary proton. Since the neutron energy is not detected by the JSNS 2 detector, the visible energy E_{\rm vis} is reduced, consequently leading to a larger reconstructed missing energy (see Eqs. ( 17 ) and ( 18 )). Including this mechanism leads to poorer agreement with the data, unlike the ED-RMF result. Ref. Dytman et al. 2021 compares proton– 12 C reaction cross-section with the predictions of different neutrino event generators and finds sizable discrepancies among the generators for T_{p}<50 MeV, the kinematic region relevant for JSNS 2 . Nevertheless, even when a generator reproduces the low- T_{p} reaction cross-section, the observable is inclusive and does not ensure an accurate modeling of particular inelastic final states, such as channels involving neutron emission. Another effect we have considered is the presence of cross section below the neutron-emission threshold. In our mean-field model, such contributions are forbidden. This discrepancy may arise from nuclear-structure effects not included in mean-field approaches, such as collective nuclear states Nikolakopoulos et al. 2021 and discrete nuclear excitations leading to emission of photons Abe 2024 ; McKean et al. 2026 , and/or from the finite energy resolution of the JSNS 2 detector. We simulate an energy smearing of the measured quantity E_{\textnormal{vis}} with a Gaussian distribution centered at this value and width equal to 2.5 \% of E_{\textnormal{vis}} . This procedure leads to an improved agreement with the experimental data. The JSNS 2 experiment provides important insights into the nuclear-structure mechanisms underlying neutrino–nucleus interactions. Nevertheless, many questions remain open from both the experimental and theoretical viewpoints. From an experimental perspective, the treatment of nuclear recoil energy remains ambiguous. Our results indicate that including recoil yields better agreement with the data than neglecting it. Yet the unfolding procedure of the data relies on a Monte Carlo event generator whose kinematics do not incorporate recoil. If the kinetic energy of the residual nucleus is not effectively detected, the generator would fail to describe the right position of the peak. From the theoretical side, several issues remain to be addressed. For instance, the importance of low-energy collective excitations requires further investigation. In addition, low-energy p-^{12} C reaction cross-section data suggest that the semi-classical description of inelastic FSI in cascade models might be inadequate in this energy regime. The JSNS 2 experiment opens new opportunities in neutrino physics that deserve further investigation. In particular, measurements of absolute cross sections, beyond shape-only distributions, would be crucial to fully exploit the reach of these data. Acknowledgements. This work has been partially supported by INFN under Project NUCSYS. R.G.J. and J.G.-M. were supported by project PID2021-127098NA-I00 funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033/FEDER. In addition, R.G.J. was supported by project RYC2022-035203-I funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033/FSE+, UE; and by “Ayudas para Atracción de Investigadores con Alto Potencial–modalidad A” funded by VII PPIT-US. J.G.-M. was also supported by the Fund for Scientific Research Flanders (FWO). V.B. was supported by “Planes Complementarios de I+D+i” program (Grant No. ASFAE/2022/022) by MICIU with funding from the European Union NextGenerationEU and Generalitat Valenciana; by Grant No. PID2023-147458NB-C21 funded by MCIN/AEI/ 10.13039/501100011033 and by the European Union.