Fluctuating environments are sufficient to drive substantial variability in species abundance across locations James F. D. Henderson, Andreas Tiffeau-Mayer Abstract Species growing in environments that change in time and space will vary in their abundance across locations, even in the absence of persistent location preferences. Here we quantify this non-equilibrium effect by studying a minimal model of a spatially compartmentalised community with time-averaged-neutral competition but location-dependent environmental fluctuations. We analytically derive distributions of two-point inequality, defined as the log-ratio of a species’ abundance across a pair of locations. We characterise how the balance of relaxation via migration and fluctuation strength determine the bulk and extreme value statistics of these distributions in the two-patch and infinite-patch cases. We demonstrate the existence of a noise-induced transition to bimodal inequality, which depends on the correlation timescale of the environmental fluctuations. Finally, we discuss the evolutionary benefit of finite migration rates in environments with temporal correlations. That species fluctuate in their abundance across space and time is an ecological rule, not an exception Rosenzweig et al. 1996 , however identifying the key drivers of these fluctuations in high-dimensional ecosystems remains an open challenge Grilli 2020 ; Rogers et al. 2022 . Changing environmental conditions act as one source of such fluctuations, as they alter the availability of resources required for a species to prosper and reproduce Levin 1976 ; Ottino-Löffler and Kardar 2020 ; Asker et al. 2025 . Additionally, interactions between species in large communities can drive dramatic abundance changes and chaotic dynamics, acting as an effective stochastic driving on single-species growth rates Pearce et al. 2020 ; de Pirey 2025 . Previous work has thus considered how the interplay of spatial compartmentalisation and random growth affects extinction times Agranov and Bunin 2021 and has recently highlighted the ability of noise and space to fundamentally alter coexistence regimes Al-Hiyasat et al. 2026 . Here, we build on this work by focusing on the basic question at the core of this phenomenology: How much spatial variability in a species’ abundance should we expect from environmental fluctuations alone, in an otherwise neutral community? Metacommunity theory provides a framework to describe spatially compartmentalised communities consisting of S species migrating between N locations (patches) Leibold et al. 2004 ; Garcia Lorenzana et al. 2024 . In the general case, the population size, C_{k,i} , of species k in patch i evolves according to \begin{split}\frac{dC_{k,i}}{dt}=&\left[r_{k,i}\left(\vec{C}_{i}\right)+\eta_{k,i}(t)\right]C_{k,i}\\ &+\sum_{j\neq i}^{N-1}\left(M_{k,ij}C_{k,j}-M_{k,ji}C_{k,i}\right),\end{split} (1) for i=1,...,N and k=1,...,S . The terms r_{k,i}(\vec{C}_{i}) account for interactions between species. Each \eta_{k,i}(t) models the impact of temporal fluctuations in the environmental conditions within patch i on the growth rate of species k . For simplicity, we will neglect demographic noise which would introduce sub-leading terms \sim\sqrt{C_{k,i}}\xi_{k,i}(t) . M_{k,ij} defines the rate of migration of individuals of species k into patch i from patch j . This framework allows us to specify alternate explanations for spatial heterogeneity in species abundance: A species can vary in its abundance between locations because of persistent niche differences (modelled by r_{k,i}(\vec{C_{i}}) ), migratory preferences ( M_{k,ij} ), or alternatively as a non-equilibrium effect of transient fitness fluctuations ( \eta_{k,i}(t) ). We are interested here in this latter setting, in which species have no inherent preference for a particular location. We therefore assume symmetric migration with M_{k,ij}=M/N , where M is the overall coupling strength between patches, and consider time-averaged neutral competition where all species compete uniformly and are equally fit on average across locations Mallmin et al. 2026 . In the limit S\rightarrow\infty , such competition results in the decoupling of species dynamics, with r_{k,i}(\vec{C}_{i})\rightarrow r\leq 0 , allowing for the species index k to be dropped (see SI). Eq. ( 1 ) effectively reduces to the dynamics of a single species migrating between multiple locations (a metapopulation Levins 1969 ; Hanski 1998 ; Evans et al. 2013 ). We expect this setting to provide a useful null model for the study of spatial compartmentalisation in large ecological communities, as it represents the simplest extension of the time-averaged neutral theory of ecology Volkov et al. 2003 ; Desponds et al. 2016 ; Gaimann et al. 2020 ; Kessler and Shnerb 2024 ; Mallmin et al. 2026 ; Azaele et al. 2016 ; Hubbell 2011 to the spatial domain. For instance, in the adaptive immune system populations of lymphocytes circulate the body and undergo periods of rapid growth upon antigen encounter. Time-averaged neutral theory has previously been used to explain heavy-tailed species abundance distributions in this system Desponds et al. 2016 ; Gaimann et al. 2020 . However, it is unknown whether local expansion and migration might suffice to also explain observed variation in clonal lineage (species) abundance of immune cells across locations DeWolf et al. 2023 ; Sureshchandra et al. 2025 . Beyond the field of ecology, this setting provides a stylised model for how market fluctuations and wealth exchange drive inequality between economic agents Bouchaud and Mezard 2000 ; Bouchaud 2015 , and also relates to the KPZ equation of random surface growth Kardar et al. 1986 . Even in this simple setting, we will find a surprisingly rich phenomenology, depending on the dimensionality of the system N and the statistical structure of the noise \eta_{k,i}(t) . We restrict our study to spatially uncorrelated environmental fluctuations modelled as stochastic processes of zero mean and intensity of 2D , defined as the zero-frequency part of their stationary power spectra. Previous work studying a non-spatially compartmentalised species has shown that the correlation timescale of environmental noise, i.e. the colour of the noise, can significantly alter the risk of species extinction Spanio et al. 2017 ; Kamenev et al. 2008 . We therefore allow the noise to be temporally correlated and study how emerging species fluctuations depend on the environmental correlation time 1/\lambda . In the study of this system, the two-point inequality of species abundances x_{ij}=\ln\left(\frac{C_{i}}{C_{j}}\right), (2) provides a natural observable characterising the fluctuations in a single species’ abundance between a pair of locations. In the following we thus present analytical solutions for distributions of x_{ij} in the N=2 and N\rightarrow\infty cases for white and coloured environmental noise. Temporally uncorrelated environments– The simplest scenario in which this system can be studied considers temporally uncorrelated environmental fluctuations, \left<\eta_{i}(t)\eta_{i}(t^{\prime})\right>=2D_{i}\delta(t-t^{\prime}) . For N=2 , working in the Stratonovich convention, the log-ratio x=x_{12} evolves autonomously according to Agranov and Bunin 2021 \frac{dx}{dt}=-M\sinh x+\eta_{x}(t), (3) where \eta_{x}(t)=\eta_{1}(t)-\eta_{2}(t) and has intensity 4D . To obtain the steady state distribution of x , we recast Eq. ( 3 ) into its corresponding Fokker–Planck equation Gardiner 2009 \partial_{t}\rho(x,t)=-\partial_{x}\left[-M\sinh(x)\rho(x,t)-2D\partial_{x}\rho(x,t)\right]. (4) Solving for \partial_{t}\rho(x,t)=0 with zero flux boundary conditions shows that the system approaches a non-equilibrium steady-state, where two-point inequality is distributed according to Agranov and Bunin 2021 ; Bouchaud 2015 \rho(x)=\rho(x,\infty)=\frac{1}{2\mathcal{K}\left(0,\frac{M}{2D}\right)}e^{-\frac{M}{2D}\cosh x}, (5) where \mathcal{K}(\nu,z) , is a modified Bessel function of the second kind. Around the origin, this distribution is approximately Gaussian, with a double exponential suppression of large values of |x| with asymptotic scaling \rho(x)\sim e^{-M/(4D)e^{|x|}} . In the limit of weak coupling, M/D\ll 1 , this distribution is approximately uniform for small values of |x| (Fig. 1 a), indicating that many intermediate values of two-point inequality are similarly likely. The white-noise driven system may also be studied in the limit of N\rightarrow\infty by making use of a mean-field approximation (see SI). In such an approximation each site evolves independently and y_{i}=\ln(C_{i}/\bar{C}) , where \bar{C}=\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i}C_{i} is the average population size across all patches, approaches a steady-state density. This mean-field steady-state density is Bouchaud and Mezard 2000 ; Ottino-Löffler and Kardar 2020 \rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(y)=\frac{\left(\frac{M}{D}\right)^{(\frac{M}{D}+1)}}{\Gamma\left(\frac{M}{D}+1\right)}e^{-\frac{M}{D}e^{-y}-(\frac{M}{D}+1)y}, (6) where we have dropped the site-specific subscript. At large y , we recover the well-known power law scaling of w=e^{y} occurring in convergent multiplicative processes repelled from zero Sornette and Cont 1997 . Using \rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(y) , the density for x_{ij}=y_{i}-y_{j},i\neq j , may be obtained using the fact that y_{i},y_{j}\overset{i.i.d}{\sim}\rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(y) and hence \displaystyle\rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(x) \displaystyle=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(y)\rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(y+x)dy (7) \displaystyle=\frac{\Gamma\left(2\left(\frac{M}{D}+1\right)\right)}{\Gamma\left(\frac{M}{D}+1\right)^{2}}\left(1+e^{-x}\right)^{-2\left(\frac{M}{D}+1\right)}e^{-(\frac{M}{D}+1)x}, (8) where \Gamma(z) is the Gamma function. In contrast to the two patch case, this distribution has heavier tails which scale \rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(x)\sim e^{-(M/D+1)|x|} , and approaches a limiting density for weak coupling (Fig. 1 b and see SI). Taken together, these results reveal an interesting distinction for two-point inequality between the low and high dimensional regimes whose distributions differ in both bulk and tail behaviour. Figure 1: Analytical densities for the steady-state distribution of two-point inequality in the case of a) N=2 given by Eq. ( 5 ) and b) N\rightarrow\infty given by Eq. ( 8 ) for a range of migration rate to noise intensity ratios. Temporally correlated environments– As most real sources of environment variability will exhibit temporal correlations, we next turn to the study of Eq. ( 1 ) when driven by coloured noise with correlation timescale 1/\lambda . We adopt the simplest model for such temporal correlations, an Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process defined by \frac{d\eta_{i}}{dt}=-\lambda\eta_{i}(t)+\lambda\sqrt{2D}\xi_{i}(t), (9) where each \xi_{i}(t) is a zero-mean Gaussian white noise. Figure 2: a) Trajectories of Eq. ( 3 ) simulated via the Euler-Maruyama method for white environmental noise (dotted line) with M=0.1 , D=10 , and a coloured noise (solid line) with M=0.1 , D=10 and \lambda=1 . b) Histograms of trajectories obtained at Mt=20 over 2\times 10^{4} simulation runs. The analytic steady state densities are overlaid. Simulation runs are initialised as x(0)=0,\eta(0)=0 . c) ‘Phase’ diagram highlighting monostable and bistable parameter regimes. These regions are separated by a supercritical pitchfork bifurcation Strogatz 2024 shown by the dashed black line. For certain parameter values with N=2 , simulations reveal that x(t) unexpectedly switches between two typical values of two-point inequality, in contrast to simulations with white noise at equal noise intensity (Fig. 2 a). In line with this, histograms of x show that its steady state distribution is bimodal when driven by coloured noise, as opposed to the unimodal distribution observed for white noise (Fig. 2 b). The rare but rapid switches in the bimodal case are reminiscent of relaxation oscillations in non-linear oscillators such as the Van der Pol system Strogatz 2024 . These numerical results are suggestive of a noise-induced transition, a class of phenomena in which a system driven by noise can enter states not present in its deterministic dynamics Horsthemke and Lefever 1984 ; Coomer et al. 2022 . To analytically characterise this noise-induced transition, we made use of the Unified Coloured Noise Approximation Jung and Hänggi 1987 (see SI) to obtain an effective 1D stochastic differential equation for x \frac{dx}{dt}=\frac{-M\sinh x}{1+\frac{M}{\lambda}\cosh x}+\frac{\sqrt{4D}}{1+\frac{M}{\lambda}\cosh x}\xi_{x}(t), (10) where \xi_{x}(t) is a zero-mean Gaussian white noise taken with the Stratonovich prescription. As before, Eq. ( 10 ) may be converted into a Fokker–Planck equation whose steady state density can be written in terms of an effective potential U_{\mathrm{eff}}(x) \rho(x)=\frac{1}{Z}e^{-U_{\mathrm{eff}}(x)}, (11) where Z is a normalisation constant, and \displaystyle U_{\mathrm{eff}}\left(x\right)= \displaystyle\frac{M}{2D}\left(1+\frac{M}{2\lambda}\cosh x\right)\cosh x \displaystyle-\ln\left(1+\frac{M}{\lambda}\cosh x\right). (12) Analysis of the extrema of this effective potential allows us to derive a phase diagram for the bistable region of parameter space (Fig. 2 c). The transition happens above a critical noise intensity \tilde{D}>\tilde{D}_{c}=(\tilde{\lambda}+1)^{2}/(2\tilde{\lambda}) , which depends on the non-dimensional ratios \tilde{D}=D/M and \tilde{\lambda}=\lambda/M . Above this critical value the effective potential has a single maxima at the origin and two minima located at x^{*}_{\pm}=\pm\cosh^{-1}\left(\sqrt{2\tilde{D}\tilde{\lambda}}-\tilde{\lambda}\right) implying a bimodal steady-state density. The predictions by the unified coloured noise approximation agree closely with numerical simulations (see SI). In the limit of fast environmental decorrelation with respect to the rate of migration, \tilde{\lambda}\rightarrow\infty , we fully recover the white noise density as expected. In the opposite, ‘quenched’, limit of a highly persistent environment, \lambda\rightarrow 0 at finite D\lambda=\sigma^{2} , we find that the transition occurs at \sigma^{2}\geq M^{2}/2 . This is directly equivalent to an ensemble of two-patch systems with disordered basal growth rates, r_{i} , drawn from a zero-mean Gaussian distribution of variance \sigma^{2} (see SI). We now turn to N\rightarrow\infty for a temporally correlated environment. The dynamics of y_{i}=\ln(C_{i}/\bar{C}) are (see SI) \frac{dy_{i}}{dt}=M(e^{-y_{i}}-1)+\eta_{i}(t)-\zeta(t) (13) where \zeta(t)=\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i}\frac{C_{i}(t)}{\bar{C}(t)}\eta_{i}(t) . We assume self-averaging in the mean-field limit, \zeta(t)\rightarrow\zeta , which can be solved for by the self-consistency condition \left/\bar{C}=1 . We once again employ the Unified Coloured Noise Approximation and find the steady state density for y to be \rho(y)\propto\exp(-U_{\mathrm{eff,mf}}(y)) , where U_{\mathrm{eff,mf}}(y)=\frac{1}{D}(M+\zeta)y+\frac{M}{D}\left(1-\frac{1}{\lambda}(M+\zeta)\right)e^{-y}+\frac{M^{2}}{2\lambda D}e^{-2y}-\ln\left(1+\frac{M}{\lambda}e^{-y}\right). (14) Large positive fluctuations in y are controlled by the first term, which again implies power-law scaling for w=e^{y} for w\gg 1 . Following Eq. ( 7 ) to derive the steady-state density for x , we find that it inherits the large y scaling, with \rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(x)\sim e^{-|x|(M+\zeta)/D} (see SI). As \zeta defines the tail behaviour of the distributions, it dictates the extreme value of statistics of the system and controls the divergence of distribution moments. For any finite model parameters, the self-consistency condition holds, implying a finite mean for w (see SI). However, in the limit of ‘quenched’ disorder, \lambda\rightarrow 0 , self-consistent solutions only exist for D=\left=1 . The dashed line is the boundary predicted by a saddle-point approximation (see text). A second transition, referred to as the ‘condensation’ transition Ichinomiya 2012 , occurs when M+\zeta<2D which causes \left to diverge. For a white driving noise \zeta=D and so \left diverges for D>M Ottino-Löffler and Kardar 2020 . Solving for \zeta numerically we find that for coloured noise this transition can occur at a lower noise intensity (Fig. 3 ). In the weak-noise limit, D=r+\left<\zeta(t)\right>. (16) Our results thus far therefore relate to the stability and long-term evolutionary success of populations living in time-varying environments Kelly 1956 ; Rivoire and Leibler 2011 ; Al-Hiyasat et al. 2026 . We can naturally ask which rate of migration M optimises long-term growth in a fluctuating environment with fixed \lambda and D . For N\rightarrow\infty and finite \lambda , we find that \zeta monotonically decreases with M and hence the optimal strategy is to not migrate (see SI). Intuitively, in an infinite system we might always expect some patch to experience favourable environmental conditions that persist for some finite time and dispersal then merely acts to dilute this growth across space. In stark contrast, numerical evaluation of \zeta for N=2 shows that the growth rate peaks at a finite value of M which scales with the degree of environmental persistence \lambda (Fig. 4 ). We expect such an optimal migration rate to exist for any finite N and to emerge as a balance of exploiting temporally-correlated streaks of good luck while rebalancing the growing population to hedge against bad times. In the context of economics and finance, where \zeta is related to the geometric mean return, this result implies the existence of an optimal rate of portfolio rebalancing or wealth-taxation Bouchaud 2015 to exploit the empirically well-documented temporal correlations in real market returns Jegadeesh and Titman 1993 . Figure 4: Logarithmic growth rate for a species migrating between two time varying environments as a function of its migration rate. Each curve shows the numerically obtained growth rates for fluctuations with different correlation timescales 1/\lambda . Circles show the analytic solution for temporally uncorrelated environmental fluctuations. All rates have been rescaled by the intensity of the environmental fluctuations, D , and r set to 0 . Conclusion– We have provided a unified theory describing the extent to which environmental fluctuations drive spatial species variability in a simple time-averaged neutral setting. Our results extend previous work Ottino-Löffler and Kardar 2020 ; Agranov and Bunin 2021 ; Evans et al. 2013 ; Bouchaud and Mezard 2000 to show how the bulk and extreme values of spatial inequality are controlled by the interplay of system timescales and dimensionality. We find significant differences in the distribution of inequality for a small ( N=2 ) and large ( N\rightarrow\infty ) number of patches, with low dimensions allowing for broader bulk behaviour at weak couplings ( D=2D\delta_{kl}\delta_{ij}\delta(t-t^{\prime}) . This simplification is supported by the analyses from Ref. Mallmin et al. 2026 which show that for a fixed environmental noise variance ( D\lambda ), the correlation timescale only weakly impacts single patch community composition. To make progress, we convert the noise into the Itô form \eta_{k,i}(t)C_{k,i}dt=\sqrt{2D}C_{k,i}\circ dB_{k,i}=\sqrt{2D}C_{k,i}dB_{k,i}+DC_{k,i}dt, (13) and so \displaystyle\Xi(t)dt \displaystyle=\sum_{k=1}^{S}\left(\sqrt{2D}C_{k,i}dB_{k,i}+DC_{k,i}dt,\right) \displaystyle=DT_{i}dt+\sum_{k=1}^{S}\sqrt{2D}C_{k,i}dB_{k,i} \displaystyle=DT_{i}dt+\sqrt{2D\sum_{k=1}^{S}C_{k,i}^{2}(t)}dB_{i} (14) where dB_{i} is a new Brownian increment. Assuming no species holds a macroscopic fraction of the total biomass within the patch, then \sqrt{\sum_{k=1}^{S}C_{k,i}^{2}}dB_{i}=T_{i}\sqrt{\sum_{k=1}^{S}\left(\frac{C_{k,i}}{T_{i}}\right)^{2}}dB_{i}\;\xrightarrow[S\to\infty]{}\;0. (15) Under such an approximation, the total population size in a given patch evolves as \frac{dT_{i}}{dt}\approx sC_{0}+b+(D-d)T_{i}+\frac{M}{N}\sum_{j\neq i}^{N-1}(T_{j}-T_{i}). (16) We assume that there exists a steady state for the system such that dT_{i}/dt|_{T_{i}=T_{i}\star}=0 for all i and hence sC_{0}+b+(D-d)T^{\star}_{i}+\frac{M}{N}\sum_{j\neq i}^{N-1}(T^{\star}_{j}-T^{\star}_{i})=0, (17) where each T_{i}^{\star} is the steady state value of T_{i} . We now define P^{\star}=\sum_{i=1}^{N}T_{i}^{\star} to be the total number of individuals in the entire system such that Eq. ( 17 ) can be written as sC_{0}+b+(D-d-M)T^{\star}_{i}+\frac{M}{N}P^{\star}=0, (18) and so T^{\star}_{i}=T^{\star}=\frac{\frac{M}{N}P^{\star}+b+sC_{0}}{M+d-D}. (19) As P^{\star}=NT^{\star} , we finally find T^{\star}=\frac{b+sC_{0}}{d-D}, (20) to be the total population size per patch. At long times, when T_{i}\rightarrow T^{\star} , and assuming d>D , the effective growth rate experienced by each species is r_{k,i}^{\star}\approx-\frac{bD+dsC_{0}}{b+sC_{0}}. (21) As all of the parameters in the above equation are positive, r_{k,i}^{\star}\leq 0 . This is in agreement with prior work modelling neutral competition between immune cell populations Gaimann et al. 2020 . II.2 Metapopulation model Consider a single species migrating between N identically coupled spatial sites with independent fluctuating environments. The population size per patch obeys the following dynamics \displaystyle\frac{dC_{i}}{dt} \displaystyle=\left[r+\eta_{i}(t)\right]C_{i}+\frac{M}{N}\sum_{j\neq i}^{N-1}\left(C_{j}-C_{i}\right) \displaystyle=\left[r+\eta_{i}(t)\right]C_{i}+M\left(\bar{C}-C_{i}\right), (22) where \bar{C}(t)=\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}C_{i}(t) is the average population size over all patches. We change coordinates to the population size of a patch relative to the spatial average population w_{i}=C_{i}/\bar{C} which evolves via a replicator-like equation \displaystyle\frac{dw_{i}}{dt} \displaystyle=\left[r+\eta_{i}(t)\right]w_{i}+M\left(1-w_{i}\right)-w_{i}\left(\frac{1}{N}\sum_{j=1}^{N}rw_{j}+\frac{1}{N}\sum_{j=1}^{N}w_{j}(t)\eta_{j}(t)\right) \displaystyle=M\left(1-w_{i}\right)+w_{i}\left[\eta_{i}(t)-\zeta(t)\right], (23) where we have used the fact that by definition \frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}w_{i}=1 and defined \zeta(t)=\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}w_{i}(t)\eta_{i}(t). (24) To convert the multiplicative noise in Eq. ( II.2 ) to additive noise, we can shift coordinates to y_{i}=\ln w_{i} , to obtain \frac{dy_{i}}{dt}=M(e^{-y_{i}}-1)+\eta_{i}(t)-\zeta(t) (25) In the limit N\rightarrow\infty and with the \eta_{i} ’s as uncorrelated white-noises with intensity 2D , we may write \frac{1}{N}\sum_{j=1}^{N}w_{j}\eta_{j}(t)dt=\frac{1}{N}\sum_{j=1}^{N}\sqrt{2D}w_{j}dB_{j}+\left(\frac{D}{N}\sum_{j=1}^{N}w_{j}-\mathcal{O}\left(\frac{1}{N^{2}}\right)\right)dt\approx\left<\sqrt{2D}w_{j}dB_{j}\right>+Ddt=Ddt, (26) where we have shifted to the Itô form and assumed that the system is self averaging so that an average over patches may be replaced by a average over realisations of the noise, denoted by \left<\right> . If instead the \eta_{i} ’s have some degree of temporal correlation, we take \zeta(t)\rightarrow\zeta which must be found self consistently by enforcing \left=1 . III Coloured noise in the limit of N\rightarrow\infty III.1 Steady-state density for y Taking \zeta(t)\rightarrow\zeta and applying the unified coloured noise approximation to Eq. ( 25 ) and dropping the subscript gives \frac{dy}{dt}=\frac{M(e^{-y}-1)-\zeta}{1+\frac{M}{\lambda}e^{-y}}+\frac{\sqrt{2D}}{1+\frac{M}{\lambda}e^{-y}}\xi(t). (27) We convert this into a Fokker–Planck equation and solve for steady state, finding \rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(y)=\frac{1}{Z}\left(1+\frac{M}{\lambda}e^{-y}\right)e^{-\frac{M}{D}\left(1-\frac{1}{\lambda}(M+\zeta)\right)e^{-y}-\frac{M^{2}}{2\lambda D}e^{-2y}-\frac{1}{D}(M+\zeta)y}, (28) For large y , Eq. ( 28 ) scales like \rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(y)\sim e^{-y(M+\zeta)/D} , and hence \left diverges for large y if (M+\zeta)/D<1 . Therefore we require \zeta>D-M for a self consistent solution to exist and the mean-field approximation to hold. We find the normalisation constant to be Z=\mathcal{I}_{\nu}(\alpha,\beta)+\frac{M}{\lambda}\mathcal{I}_{\nu+1}(\alpha,\beta), (29) where \displaystyle\mathcal{I}_{\nu}(\alpha,\beta) \displaystyle=\int_{0}^{\infty}u^{\nu-1}e^{-\alpha u^{2}-\beta u}du=\left(2\alpha\right)^{-\nu/2}\Gamma(\nu)e^{\beta^{2}/(8\alpha)}\mathcal{D}_{-\nu}\left(\frac{\beta}{\sqrt{2\alpha}}\right), (30) where \mathcal{D}_{a}(z) is a parabolic cylinder function, \Gamma(z) is the Gamma function and we have defined \alpha=M^{2}/(2\lambda D) , \beta=(M/D)(1-(\zeta+M)/\lambda) and \nu=(M+\zeta)/D . III.2 Steady-state density for x The steady state density for x_{ij}=y_{i}-y_{j},i\neq j , may be obtained by using y_{i},y_{j}\overset{i.i.d}{\sim}\rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(y) . We find the density for x to be, \displaystyle\rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(x) \displaystyle=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(y)\rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(y+x)dy (31) \displaystyle=\frac{e^{-\nu x}}{Z^{2}}\left(\mathcal{I}_{2\nu}(A(x),B(x))+\frac{M}{\lambda}\left(1+e^{-x}\right)\mathcal{I}_{2\nu+1}(A(x),B(x))+\left(\left(\frac{M}{\lambda}\right)^{2}+e^{-x}\right)\mathcal{I}_{2\nu+2}(A(x),B(x))\right), (32) where A(x)=\alpha\left(1+e^{-2x}\right) and B(x)=\beta\left(1+e^{-x}\right) . The tails of this density scale like \rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(x)\sim e^{-|x|(M+\zeta)/D} . III.3 Solving for \zeta \zeta is solved for self consistently by requiring \left=\left=1 , which is equivalent to G(\nu,\alpha,\beta)=\mathcal{I}_{\nu-1}(\alpha,\beta)+\left(\frac{M}{\lambda}-1\right)\mathcal{I}_{\nu}(\alpha,\beta)-\frac{M}{\lambda}\mathcal{I}_{\nu+1}(\alpha,\beta)=0. (33) From the scaling of the tail of Eq. ( 28 ) we require \zeta>D-M , as \zeta=D\nu-M this condition is equivalent to \nu>1 . III.3.1 Existence of a solution for finite parameters For finite D>0,M>0,\lambda>0 we can consider G(\nu,\alpha,\beta) as \nu\rightarrow 1^{+} and \nu\rightarrow\infty . First, for \nu\rightarrow 1^{+} , we have \beta\rightarrow\frac{M}{D}-\frac{M}{\lambda}=\beta_{1} . We evaluate each term of Eq. ( 33 ) in turn \displaystyle\lim_{\nu\rightarrow 1^{+}}I_{\nu}(\alpha,\beta(\nu)) \displaystyle=\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-\alpha u^{2}-\beta_{1}u}du\rightarrow\text{finite} \displaystyle\lim_{\nu\rightarrow 1^{+}}I_{\nu+1}(\alpha,\beta(\nu)) \displaystyle=\int_{0}^{\infty}ue^{-\alpha u^{2}-\beta_{1}u}du\rightarrow\text{finite} \displaystyle\lim_{\nu\rightarrow 1^{+}}I_{\nu-1}(\alpha,\beta(\nu)) \displaystyle=\int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{1}{u}e^{-\alpha u^{2}-\beta_{1}u}du\rightarrow+\infty Therefore \lim_{\nu\rightarrow 1^{+}}G(\nu,\alpha,\beta(\nu))=+\infty . We next consider \nu\rightarrow+\infty , for which \beta=\frac{M}{D}-\frac{M}{\lambda}\nu=\beta_{0}-c\nu . We write \displaystyle I_{\nu+k}(\alpha,\beta(\nu)) \displaystyle=\int_{0}^{\infty}u^{(\nu+k)-1}e^{-\alpha u^{2}-(\beta_{0}-c\nu)u}du \displaystyle=\nu^{k}\nu^{\nu}\int_{0}^{\infty}t^{\nu+k-1}e^{-\alpha\nu^{2}t^{2}-\beta_{0}\nu t+c\nu^{2}t}dt (34) where we have changed coordinates to u=t\nu . We now make a saddlepoint approximation, defining \psi(t)=(\nu+k-1)\ln t-\alpha\nu^{2}t^{2}-\beta_{0}\nu t+c\nu^{2}t, (35) which has a critical point defined by \displaystyle\frac{d\psi}{dt}\Bigg|_{t=t^{*}} \displaystyle=\frac{\nu+k-1}{t}-2\alpha\nu^{2}t^{*}-\beta_{0}\nu+c\nu^{2}=0 \displaystyle\implies t^{*}\approx\frac{c}{2\alpha}, (36) where we have kept terms to leading-order in \nu . Evaluating at the saddle and only keeping terms to leading order \nu , we have I_{\nu+k}(\alpha,\beta(\nu))\approx\nu^{k}\nu^{\nu}e^{\psi(t^{*})}=\nu^{k}\nu^{\nu}e^{(\nu^{2}c^{2})/(4\alpha)}=\nu^{k}F(\nu), (37) where F(\nu)=\nu^{\nu}e^{(\nu^{2}c^{2})/(4\alpha)} . Therefore we may write G(\nu,\alpha,\beta) as \displaystyle G(\nu,\alpha,\beta) \displaystyle\approx\frac{1}{\nu}F(\nu)+\left(\frac{M}{\lambda}-1\right)F(\nu)-\frac{M}{\lambda}\nu F(\nu) \displaystyle=F(\nu)\left(\frac{1}{\nu}+\frac{M}{\lambda}-1-\frac{M}{\lambda}\nu\right) \displaystyle\approx-\frac{M}{\lambda}\nu F(\nu) (38) We now take the limit \nu\rightarrow+\infty , writing \displaystyle-\nu F(\nu)\;\xrightarrow[\nu\to+\infty]{}\;-\infty (39) Therefore \lim_{\nu\rightarrow+\infty}G(\nu,\alpha,\beta(\nu))=-\infty . As G(\nu,\alpha,\beta(\nu)) is continuous on the interval, at least one solution for G(\nu,\alpha,\beta(\nu))=0 always exists for finite M,D and \lambda . III.3.2 The quenched limit - \lambda\rightarrow 0 We now take the limit \lambda\rightarrow 0 , \lambda\ll M , of Eq. ( 28 ), writing \displaystyle\ln\rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(y) \displaystyle\sim{-\frac{M}{D}\left(1-\frac{1}{\lambda}(M+\zeta)\right)e^{-y}-\frac{M^{2}}{2\lambda D}e^{-2y}-\frac{1}{D}(M+\zeta)y}+\ln\left(1+\frac{M}{\lambda}e^{-y}\right) \displaystyle=-\frac{1}{\lambda}\left(\frac{M^{2}}{2D}e^{-2y}-\frac{M}{D}(M+\zeta)e^{-y}\right)+\mathcal{O}\left(\ln\left(\frac{1}{\lambda}\right)\right)+\mathcal{O}(1) (40) In the limit \lambda\rightarrow 0 , \rho_{\mathrm{mf}}(y)\rightarrow\delta(y-y^{*}) , where y^{*} is the critical point of S(y)=\frac{M^{2}}{2D}e^{-2y}-\frac{M}{D}(M+\zeta)e^{-y}. (41) Therefore \displaystyle\frac{dS}{dy}\Bigg|_{y=y^{*}} \displaystyle=-\frac{M^{2}}{D}e^{-2y^{*}}+\frac{M}{D}(M+\zeta)e^{-y^{*}}=0 \displaystyle\implies y^{*}=\ln\left(\frac{M}{M+\zeta}\right). (42) Enforcing the self consistency condition \left=1 , we find that \displaystyle\lim_{\lambda\rightarrow 0}\left \displaystyle=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\delta(y-y^{*})e^{y}dy=e^{y^{*}}=\frac{M}{M+\zeta}=1 \displaystyle\implies\zeta=0 (43) Therefore, in the limit of persistent environmental fluctuations, the condition \zeta>D-M , becomes D diverging for D\geq M and the mean-field approximation failing. If we take D\lambda=\sigma^{2}/(2\ln N) , and keep 2\lambda\ln N=M as N\rightarrow\infty and \lambda\rightarrow 0 , we find \left diverges for \sigma^{2}\geq M^{2} . This matches the condition found for the case of heterogenous random growth rates in Bernard et al. 2025 . III.3.3 Weak-noise approximation - D\tilde{D}-1 . Defining t=e^{-y} , the self consistency condition may be written as \frac{I_{2}}{I_{1}}=\frac{\int_{0}^{\infty}g_{2}(t)\,e^{\Phi(t)/\tilde{D}}\,dt}{\int_{0}^{\infty}g_{1}(t)\,e^{\Phi(t)/\tilde{D}}\,dt}=1 (44) where g_{\ell}(t)=t^{-\ell}\left(1+\frac{1}{\tilde{\lambda}}t\right), (45) and \Phi(t)=(1+\tilde{\zeta})\ln t-\left(1-\frac{1+\tilde{\zeta}}{\tilde{\lambda}}\right)t-\frac{1}{2\tilde{\lambda}}t^{2}. (46) For \tilde{D}\ll 1 , the integrals are dominated by their value around t^{*} , the critical point of \Phi(t) , such that \displaystyle\frac{d\Phi}{dt}\Bigg|_{t=t^{*}} \displaystyle=(1+\tilde{\zeta})\frac{1}{t^{*}}-\left(1-\frac{1+\tilde{\zeta}}{\tilde{\lambda}}\right)-\frac{1}{\tilde{\lambda}}t^{*}=0, (47) \displaystyle\implies t^{*}=1+\tilde{\zeta}. (48) Employing the saddlepoint approximation and keeping terms to \mathcal{O}(\tilde{D}) , each integral may be written as I_{\ell}\approx\sqrt{\frac{2\pi\tilde{D}}{-\Phi^{\prime\prime}(t^{*})}}e^{\Phi(t^{*})/\tilde{D}}\left[g_{\ell}(t^{*})+\tilde{D}\left(\frac{g^{\prime\prime}_{\ell}(t^{*})}{-2\Phi^{\prime\prime}(t^{*})}+\frac{g^{\prime}_{\ell}(t^{*})\Phi^{\prime\prime\prime}(t^{*})}{2(-\Phi^{\prime\prime}(t^{*}))^{2}}+\frac{g_{\ell}(t^{*})\Phi^{\prime\prime\prime\prime}(t^{*})}{8(\Phi^{\prime\prime}(t^{*}))^{2}}+\frac{5g_{\ell}(t^{*})(\Phi^{\prime\prime\prime}(t^{*}))^{2}}{24(-\Phi^{\prime\prime}(t^{*}))^{3}}\right)+\mathcal{O}\left(\tilde{D}^{2}\right)\right], (49) where prime denotes differentiation with respect to t . Computing I_{2}/I_{1} , the prefactor terms cancel and keeping only terms of \mathcal{O}(\tilde{D}) , we find \frac{I_{1}}{I_{2}}\approx\frac{1}{1+\tilde{\zeta}}+\tilde{D}\left(\frac{\tilde{\lambda}}{(1+\tilde{\zeta})^{2}(1+\tilde{\lambda}+\tilde{\zeta})}\right)+\mathcal{O}\left(\tilde{D}^{2}\right)=1. (50) This equation has three roots, which to \mathcal{O}(D) are \tilde{\zeta}_{(1)}=\tilde{D}\left(\frac{\tilde{\lambda}}{\tilde{\lambda}+1}\right),\quad\tilde{\zeta}_{(2)}=\frac{\tilde{D}-(\tilde{\lambda}+1)^{2}}{\tilde{\lambda}+1},\quad\tilde{\zeta}_{(3)}=-(\tilde{D}+1). (51) For \tilde{D}<1 , only the first root is greater than \tilde{D}-1 . Converting back to dimensional parameters, this root is \zeta_{(1)}=D\left(\frac{\lambda}{\lambda+M}\right). (52) III.4 The long-term population growth rate The long-term logarithmic growth rate of the population is \left<\frac{d\ln\bar{C}}{dt}\right>=r+\left<\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}w_{i}(t)\eta_{i}(t)\right>=r+\left<\zeta(t)\right>\rightarrow r+\zeta. (53) As migration is symmetric, the long-term growth rate may alternatively be computed by considering the growth of a single patch, for N=2 we have \left<\zeta\right>=\left<\frac{d\ln C_{1}}{dt}\right>-r=\frac{M}{2}\left(\left-1\right)=\frac{M}{2}\left(\left_{\rho(x)}-1\right), (54) where we have used the fact that \rho(x,t) approaches a steady state. For white noise, the expectation may be solved for analytically with Agranov and Bunin 2021 ; Bouchaud 2015 \left<\zeta\right>=\frac{M}{2}\left(\frac{\mathcal{K}\left(-1,\frac{M}{2D}\right)}{\mathcal{K}\left(0,\frac{M}{2D}\right)}-1\right), (55) where \mathcal{K}(\nu,z) is a modified Bessel function of the second kind. For coloured noise at N=2 we evaluate Eq. ( 54 ) numerically. Figure S1: Logarithmic growth rates for a species migrating between time varying environments in the limit of N\rightarrow\infty . Each curve shows the numerically obtained growth rates for environmental fluctuations with a correlation timescale of 1/\lambda . Circles are the analytic solution found in the case of temporally uncorrelated environmental fluctuations. The dashed line is the analytically obtained growth rate in the limit \lambda/D\rightarrow 0 , which is valid for D\sigma , the long term growth rate of the system is \zeta=0 , while for M<\sigma they find \zeta=\sigma-M . All rates have been rescaled by the intensity of the environmental fluctuations, D . IV Bimodality emerging from heterogeneous random growth rates for N=2 In the absence of environmental fluctuations ( D\rightarrow 0 ), the log-ratio coordinate for two patches with non-equal basal growth rates obeys the following differential equation \frac{dx}{dt}=s-M\sinh x, (56) where s=r_{1}-r_{2} . At long times x approaches an attractive fixed point, x^{\star} , given by x^{\star}=\sinh^{-1}\left(\frac{s}{M}\right). (57) Consider an ensemble of systems for which each r_{i} is drawn from a normal distribution of mean \mu_{r} and variance \sigma_{r}^{2} such that s\sim\mathcal{N}(0,2\sigma_{r}^{2}) . The distribution of fixed points over this ensemble, \rho(x^{\star}) , is then given by \displaystyle\rho(x^{\star}) \displaystyle=\rho\left(s(x^{\star})\right)\left|\frac{ds}{dx^{\star}}\right| \displaystyle=\frac{M}{\sqrt{4\pi\sigma_{r}^{2}}}e^{-\frac{M^{2}}{4\sigma_{r}^{2}}\sinh^{2}x^{\star}}\cosh x^{\star}. (58) The extrema of \rho(x^{\star}) may be identified as the extrema of -\log\rho(x^{\star})\propto\frac{M^{2}}{4\sigma_{r}^{2}}\sinh^{2}x^{\star}-\ln\left(\cosh x^{\star}\right). (59) Which has turning points at x^{\star}_{0}=0 and x^{\star}_{\pm}=\pm\cosh^{-1}\left(\sqrt{2}\frac{\sigma_{r}}{M}\right) . These last two extrema are maxima of \rho(x^{\star}) and only defined for 2\sigma_{r}^{2}/M^{2}\geq 1 . Therefore, \rho(x^{\star}) is bimodal for \sigma_{r}^{2}\geq M^{2}/2 (including the case of degenerate roots) in agreement with the quenched, \lambda\rightarrow 0 , limit of coloured noise. V Simulation scheme Numerical simulations of the stochastic differential equations presented in the main text were performed using the Euler-Maruyama method, with Ornstein-Uhlenbeck processes being simulated using exact discretisation. For N=2 driven by white noise, the update was x(t+\Delta t)=x(t)-M\sinh x(t)\Delta t+\sqrt{4D\Delta t}\xi, (60) with \xi\sim\mathcal{N}(0,1) . For N\rightarrow\infty , Eq. ( 25 ) was simulated with \zeta=D such that the update was y(t+\Delta t)=y(t)+\left(Me^{-y(t)}-M-D\right)\Delta t+\sqrt{2D\Delta t}\xi. (61) Trajectories of x were computed from y_{i}-y_{j} , where the index denotes independent simulation runs. For N=2 driven by coloured noise \displaystyle x(t+\Delta t) \displaystyle=x(t)+\left(-M\sinh x(t)+\eta_{x}(t)\right)\Delta t, \displaystyle\eta_{x}(t+\Delta t) \displaystyle=e^{-\lambda\Delta t}\eta_{x}(t)+\sqrt{2D\lambda\left(1-e^{-2\lambda\Delta t}\right)}\xi (62) For N\rightarrow\infty driven by coloured noise, we used the following update \displaystyle\zeta(t) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{n_{\text{runs}}}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{\text{runs}}}e^{y_{i}(t)}\eta_{i}(t) \displaystyle y_{i}(t+\Delta t) \displaystyle=y_{i}(t)+\left(Me^{-y_{i}(t)}-M-\zeta(t)+\eta_{i}(t)\right)\Delta t, \displaystyle\eta_{i}(t+\Delta t) \displaystyle=e^{-\lambda\Delta t}\eta_{i}(t)+\sqrt{D\lambda\left(1-e^{-2\lambda\Delta t}\right)}\xi_{i} (63) where i spans simulation runs updated in parallel. VI Additional figures Figure S2: Analytical densities for the steady-state distribution of two-point inequality in the limits of two patches and an infinite number of patches for a range of noise intensity, D , to migration rate, M , ratios. Plots highlight the differences in tail behaviour, with exponentially decaying tails in log space for N=2 and linear tails for N\rightarrow\infty . We anticipate that any system with finite N should feature exponentially decaying tails in log space for large |x| . Figure S3: Histograms of trajectories of x for a two patch system driven by white noise. Results obtained at Mt=20 over 2\times 10^{4} simulation runs. The analytic steady state densities are overlaid. Figure S4: Histograms of trajectories of x for an infinite patch system driven by white noise. Simulations were performed using stochastic differential equations obtained via a mean field approximation. Results obtained at Mt=20 over 2\times 10^{4} simulation runs. The analytic steady state densities are overlaid. Figure S5: Histograms of trajectories of x for a two patch system driven by coloured noise. Results obtained at Mt=20 over 2\times 10^{4} simulation runs. The analytic steady state densities are overlaid. Figure S6: Histograms of trajectories of x for an infinite patch system driven by coloured noise. Simulations were performed using stochastic differential equations obtained via a mean field approximation. Results obtained at Mt=20 over 2\times 10^{4} simulation runs. The analytic steady state densities are overlaid. Figure S7: Histograms of trajectories of x for an infinite patch system driven by coloured noise. Simulations were performed using stochastic differential equations obtained via a mean field approximation. Results obtained at Mt=20 over 2\times 10^{4} simulation runs. The analytic steady state densities are overlaid in addition to the analytic densities using an approximation obtained using a saddlepoint approximation for \zeta for weak noise ( D