The Airy line ensemble at the rough-smooth boundary Sunil Chhita, Duncan Dauvergne, Thomas Finn Abstract . We study the rough-smooth boundary in the two-periodic Aztec diamond, a random domino tiling model exhibiting three types of macroscopic regions. We show that the height function at this boundary converges to an independent sum of an Airy surface and an i.i.d. noise field with fluctuations governed by the full-plane smooth phase. Going further, we prove convergence of a family of Temperleyan backbone paths to the Airy line ensemble. This gives the first convergence result for a family of undirected paths converging to the Airy line ensemble, as well as Airy convergence at a noisy boundary. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 60K35, 82B23, 82B20 Figure 1 . Temperleyan paths for the two-periodic Aztec diamond ( n=1200,a=0.5 ). 1. Introduction The two-periodic Aztec diamond with bias parameter a\in(0,1) is a domino tiling model of a certain diamond shaped region of the square grid, known as an Aztec diamond. Each domino ( 1\times 2 or 2\times 1 rectangle) has weight 1 or a which depends on its location in a doubly periodic fashion. Large two-periodic Aztec diamonds exhibit three types of macroscopic regions, as characterized for random tiling models in [ KOS06 ] . These regions are known as frozen , where tiles form a deterministic brickwork pattern; rough , where there is polynomial decay of correlations between tiles; and smooth , where there is exponential decay of correlations between tiles. In the simulation in Figure 2 , we can identify four frozen regions covering the corners of the Aztec diamond, a smooth region sitting in the center of the Aztec diamond (the region with no long structures), and a doubly-connected rough region which occupies the rest of the Aztec diamond. There are other random tiling models which exhibit all three types of macroscopic regions, such as the three-periodic lozenge tilings [ Kui25 ] , as well as other statistical mechanical models, such as the six vertex model with domain-wall boundary conditions and a certain choice of parameters [ AR05 ] . The two-periodic Aztec diamond is one of the simplest such models. Figure 2 . A simulation of a two-periodic Aztec diamond with n=200 and a=0.7 with the a -dominoes shaded darker than the b -dominoes. Note the underlying square grid is rotated by \pi/4 , as is our coordinate convention in this paper. One of the original motivations for studying the two-periodic Aztec diamond as articulated in [ CY14 , CJ16 ] was to understand the probabilistic behavior at the rough-smooth boundary and to compare to the known probabilistic behavior at the frozen-rough boundary. Indeed, universality at the frozen-rough boundary has been recently achieved for a large class of lozenge tilings [ AH25 ] , see also [ OR03 , FS03 , Joh05 , BKMM07 , Pet14 , DM18 ] for earlier tiling results and [ Gor21 ] for more references and background. In tiling models, there is usually a set of lattice paths that combinatorially defines the boundary between the frozen and rough regions. In the microscopic limit at the interface, these lattice paths converge to the Airy line ensemble , a random sequence of continuous functions \mathcal{A}=\{\mathcal{A}_{i}:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R},i\in\mathbb{N}\} with the ordering \mathcal{A}_{1}>\mathcal{A}_{2}>\cdots believed to govern edge fluctuations of many statistical mechanical models. The Airy line ensemble also appears as a scaling limit in random matrix theory [ Mac94 , FNH99 , AVM05 ] and for growth models in the Kardar-Parisi-Zhang universality class, e.g. see [ PS02 , IS07 , CH13 , DNV23 , Wu23 , ACH24 ] . The Airy line ensemble is also expected to govern the fluctuations at the rough-smooth boundary in random tilings. However, here the picture is much murkier than at the rough-smooth boundary. One of the main difficulties is that unlike at the frozen-rough boundary, the rough-smooth boundary features mixing between two non-deterministic regions. This makes the boundary noisy, and means that there is no local combinatorial description of a boundary or a canonical ensemble of paths. Moreover, when one does try to define natural families of paths they are undirected, i.e. they cannot be written as graphs of one-dimensional functions and may feature significant backtracking or winding. Our goal in this paper is to overcome these challenges and understand precisely what is happening at the rough-smooth boundary in the two-periodic Aztec diamond. Our first theorem shows convergence of the height function at the rough-smooth boundary. For this theorem, we define the Airy surface \mathcal{A}:\mathbb{R}^{2}\to\{0,1,\dots\} by \mathcal{A}(t,x)=\#\{i\in\mathbb{N}:\mathcal{A}_{i}(t)\geq x\}, which should be viewed as the height function for the Airy line ensemble. Theorem 1 (Informal version of 2.1 ) . Fix a\in(0,1) . Let \mathcal{H}_{n} be the height function of the two-periodic Aztec diamond of size n , and let H_{n} be the average of \mathcal{H}_{n} in the smooth region. Let [\cdot]_{n}:\mathbb{R}^{2}\to\mathbb{R}^{2} be a scaling map which takes limiting coordinates to an O(n^{2/3})\times O(n^{1/3}) -sized box where the rough-smooth boundary meets the antidiagonal in the two-periodic Aztec diamond of size n . Then, as n\to\infty , for any finite set S\subset\mathbb{R}^{2} , (H_{n}-\mathcal{H}_{n}[u]_{n},u\in S)\implies(4\mathcal{A}(u)+X_{u},u\in S) where \mathcal{A} is the Airy surface and X=(X_{u},u\in F) is an i.i.d. vector, independent of \mathcal{A} , whose individual entries are given by the height of a face in the full-plane smooth phase. 1 makes precise the idea that the rough-smooth boundary is given by an Airy line ensemble \mathcal{A} sitting on top of a smooth background, represented by the X . The central height H_{n} itself converges in the limit to a discrete Gaussian random variable, see the definition ( 3 ) and surrounding discussion. While 2.1 confirms the idea that the height profile at the rough-smooth boundary looks like an Airy surface sitting in a smooth background, it says nothing about the existence of a family of paths converging to the Airy line ensemble. Most of the paper is devoted to understanding such a family. In particular, we are able to identify a ‘top path’ which converges to the Airy process. The paths we consider are south and north backbone paths , introduced briefly in [ CJ16 ] , which arise from a version of Temperley’s bijection. See Section 2.3 for details and Figure 3 for an example. Let \{\mathcal{S}_{i}\}_{i=1}^{n/2} be the collection of south backbone paths starting on the bottom boundary and labelled from left to right. We let 1\leq I\leq n be the (random) index such that \mathcal{S}_{1},\dots,\mathcal{S}_{I} terminate on the left boundary and \mathcal{S}_{I+1},\dots,\mathcal{S}_{n} terminate on the right. We can now state our main theorem. Figure 3 . The same simulation as in Figure 2 , with an overlay of south ( \mathcal{S} ) and north ( \mathcal{N} ) backbone paths from the bottom and top of the Aztec diamond respectively. Theorem 2 (Informal version of 2.2 ) . Fix a\in(0,1) . Around the main anti-diagonal of the Aztec diamond, as n\to\infty , the collection \{\mathcal{S}_{I+1-i}\}_{i\in\mathbb{N}} converges after rescaling to the Airy line ensemble, in the sense of finite dimensional distributions (FDD). This convergence can be taken jointly with the convergence in 2 . Note that since the curves \mathcal{S}_{i} are general plane curves whereas the Airy line ensemble consists of one-dimensional functions, certain projections need to be taken to make sense of the FDD convergence above. Note that the splitting point I retains randomness even in the limit, and ends up corresponding with high probability to the central height H_{n} from 1 . To our knowledge, our results are the first to show Airy process or Airy line ensemble convergence for a model in a noisy background, or a model whose boundary is given by genuinely two-dimensional lattice paths. Indeed, without these difficulties the kind of FDD convergence in 1 and 2 would be immediate from the extended Airy kernel convergence established in [ BCJ18 ] , as is the case for other models. In our setting we need to worry about even the most basic properties of the model, such as establishing the presence of a last path at the boundary, controlling global or mesoscopic backtracks and path winding, and teasing out the differences between the local and global contributions to the height function. What saves us is that we are working with a highly integrable model which is amenable to refined computations, and we have a Temperley-type correspondence with certain biased spanning forest measures, which allows us to import probabilistic tools coming from Wilson’s algorithm and biased loop-erased random walks. We discuss our analysis in much greater detail below after the precise statement of results. 1.1. Previous work on the model Recent progress on the two-periodic Aztec diamond and its generalizations has hinged on an inherent algebraic structure. This algebraic structure yields exact expressions for the determinantal point process correlations associated to the two-periodic Aztec diamond in three different ways [ CY14 , DK21 , BD19 ] which rely on the same structure [ CD23 , KP25 ] . Moreover, this algebraic structure has also been exploited to introduce bias on the orientation of dominoes [ BD23 ] , consider higher periodicities where the model has multiple smooth regions [ Ber21 , BB25 ] , split weights where the model has two different adjacent smooth phases [ She25 ] , as well as completely general weights [ BdT24 ] . One feature of all of the aforementioned papers is that the correlation kernel associated to the determinantal process is amenable to precise asymptotic analysis, which gives access to limit shape curves and certain local statistics. Indeed, this has been exploited for the two-periodic Aztec diamond to find local limit laws [ CJ16 , DK21 ] , Airy kernel asymptotics at the rough-smooth boundary [ CJ16 , BCJ18 ] , sine-Gordon asymptotics in the a\to 1 regime [ Mas22 ] , precise dimer-dimer correlations at this boundary [ JM23b ] , and Gaussian free field fluctuations [ BN25 ] . This final result also holds for more general periodicities. More recently, this integrable structure has been to shown to hold for certain randomly weighted domino tilings of the Aztec diamond [ DP25 ] . An alternate way to try to define the rough-smooth boundary is to introduce contractions to certain faces, a process called squishing [ BCJ22 ] , which results in a set of lattice paths known as squished paths. From simulations, these squished paths seem to determine the rough-smooth boundary and it was shown there that the squished paths are responsible, in a certain sense, for producing the Airy kernel point process found in [ BCJ18 ] provided that 0I_{n} , the path \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} ends on the east boundary. To help parse the definitions, it may be illustrative to consider the third panel in Figure 5 where n=12 , and we have six south forest paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} and six north forest paths \mathcal{N}_{i}^{-} . In that example, I_{n}=3 . We similarly use notation \mathcal{S}_{i}^{+},\mathcal{N}_{i}^{+} for south and north backbone paths starting on the north boundary. By considering simulations (e.g. see Figure 3 ) we should expect that the path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}:=\mathcal{S}_{I_{n}}^{-} delineates the rough-smooth boundary. Now, the Airy paths are one-dimensional in the limit whereas the paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} are plane curves which may backtrack (e.g. see Figure 7 ). Therefore in order to consider the convergence of the paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} to the Airy line ensemble, we should consider the smallest and largest points where these curves intersect each vertical line. First, let R_{\theta} denote counterclockwise rotation by \theta , and define the set {\mathtt{Meso}}_{n}=n(\xi_{c},\xi_{c})+R_{-\pi/4}([-n^{3/4},n^{3/4}]\times[-n^{1/2},n^{1/2}]), which is a mesoscopic enlargement of the O(n^{2/3}\times n^{1/3}) scaling window at the rough-smooth boundary. Define paths \mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,\pm}:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R} by \displaystyle\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,+}(t) \displaystyle=\sup\{x\in\mathbb{R}:[t,x]_{n}\in\mathcal{S}_{I+1-i}\cap{\mathtt{Meso}}_{n}\}, \displaystyle\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,-}(t) \displaystyle=\inf\{x\in\mathbb{R}:[t,x]_{n}\in\mathcal{S}_{I+1-i}\cap{\mathtt{Meso}}_{n}\}. Theorem 2.2 . First, \mathbb{P}(H_{n}=4I_{n}-n-1)=1-o(1) as n\to\infty . In other words, with high probability the path split point is equal to the central height (after shifting the indexing appropriately). Next, the two line ensembles \{\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,\pm}:i\in\mathbb{N}\} converge to the parabolic Airy line ensemble \{\mathcal{A}_{i}:i\in\mathbb{N}\} in the sense of finite dimensional distributions (FDDs). That is, for any finite set T\subset\mathbb{R} we have (7) (\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,\pm}|_{T}:i\in\mathbb{N})\stackrel{{\scriptstyle d}}{{\to}}(\mathcal{A}_{i}|_{T}:i\in\mathbb{N}). Moreover, with all assumptions as in 2.1 and Remark 2.3 , we have the joint FDD convergence (8) \begin{split}(H_{n}-\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}[u]_{n},\;\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,\pm}(t))&\implies(-4\mathcal{A}(u),\;\mathcal{A}_{i}(t)).\end{split} Here the joint convergence is over u\in S,t\in T , and i\in\mathbb{N} , where S\subset\mathbb{R}^{2},T\subset\mathbb{R} are arbitrary finite or countable sets. Remark 2.4 . It is not particularly important that we intersect with the enlarged boundary region {\mathtt{Meso}}_{n} in the definitions \mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,\pm} . This could be removed with some extra asymptotic formula analysis, but we have not pursued this here for brevity. The exact scaling of n^{3/4}\times n^{1/2} in the definition of {\mathtt{Meso}}_{n} is essentially arbitrary, and only important in that it is larger than the n^{2/3}\times n^{1/3} Airy scale. Remark 2.5 . A version of 2.2 also holds using the north Temperleyan backbone paths, see 9.1 . Indeed, an important part of the proof is showing that the naturally paired north and south backbone paths stay close together as they move through the rough-smooth boundary region. Our exact estimate shows that the vertical distance between these paths is O(n^{1/4}\log^{2}n) , whereas the fluctuation scale is O(n^{1/3}) , see Corollary 8.2 for details. We expect that the true distance between these pairs of paths is of much lower order, i.e. logarithmic (or at least polylogarithmic) in n . We can also give a slight strengthening 2.2 by replacing the paths \mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,\pm}(t) with versions of the form t\mapsto\sup_{|u|\leq n^{-1/3-\varepsilon}}\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,\pm}(t+u),\qquad t\mapsto\inf_{|u|\leq n^{-1/3-\varepsilon}}\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,\pm}(t+u), where \varepsilon>0 is arbitrary, see 9.1 . Note that if n^{-1/3} is replaced by n^{-2/3} , then this result becomes essentially immediate from 2.2 . Of course, the optimal result in this direction would be to show that the paths \mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,\pm} actually converge uniformly to the Airy line ensemble. We state this as a conjecture. Conjecture 2.3 . The two line ensembles \{\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,\pm}:i\in\mathbb{N}\} converge in the uniform-on-compact topology to the Airy line ensemble \{\mathcal{A}_{i}:i\in\mathbb{N}\} . Almost all approaches towards understanding uniform convergence to the Airy line ensemble go through studying a Gibbs property in the prelimit that converges to the Brownian Gibbs property in the limit. This approach was pioneered by Corwin and Hammond [ CH13 ] in the setting of non-intersecting Brownian motions, and extended and refined to prove uniform tightness for a range of one-dimensional non-intersecting or softly non-intersecting path models, e.g. see [ CH16 , DNV23 , Wu23 , BCD23 , DFF+21 , CD18 , ACH24 , Ser23 , DS25a , DS25b ] . The Brownian Gibbs property for the Airy line ensemble also leads to a complete probabilistic characterization of the object, recently proven in [ AH26 ] (see also [ DM21 ] for an earlier result), which presents the tantalizing possibility of proving convergence to the Airy line ensemble without an appeal to formulas. In all of these papers, an underlying Gibbs property for non-intersecting paths is crucial for propagating pointwise path control to control on entire sets. In our setting, a natural Gibbs property for the backbone paths should exist. Indeed, because the backbone paths are non-crossing paths coming out of a weighted spanning forest, we expect that there is a tractable Gibbs property related to the study of non-crossing loop erased random walks, coming out of Fomin’s theory [ Fom01 ] . However, even given this property, we expect that proving uniform convergence of the paths \mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,\pm} would require a new suite of ideas, since in the present setting our paths are two-dimensional, whereas all of the prior Gibbsian line ensemble literature deals with one-dimensional paths. 3. Proof sketch and some auxiliary results As the paper is quite long, we have opted to give a detailed proof sketch in order to help guide the reader. Along the way, we will present two auxiliary results about the behaviour of the backbone paths in the two-periodic Aztec diamond. Two challenges and three tools As discussed previously, there are two central challenges in studying the rough-smooth boundary that are not present at the rough-frozen boundary in tiling models, or in other models where Airy line ensemble convergence has been previously established. I. The presence of a noise (in our case, from the smooth phase) which blurs the exact boundary. II. The natural collections of paths defining the boundary are undirected. There are many models where we expect Airy line ensemble convergence in the presence of effects I and II, see Section 1.2 for more details. Of these, the two-periodic Aztec diamond is particularly tractable, and we have many refined integrable and probabilistic tools available for understanding the rough-smooth boundary. In the present paper, the tools we use fit into three main categories: 1. Height function estimates. While we cannot understand absolutely everything about the height function directly from formulas, we can essentially compute the expectation of the height function throughout the Aztec diamond with precise asymptotics. We can also gain some control over how the height function concentrates and how it decorrelates. Finally, a more refined analysis at the rough-smooth boundary reveals that certain averages of the height function converge the Airy surface; this was established in [ BCJ18 ] . 2. Smooth phase couplings. The full-plane smooth phase measure \mathbb{P}_{a} with parameter a\in(0,1) is equivalent (through Temperley’s bijection) to a biased spanning forest on \mathbb{Z}^{2} , where edges pointing in the (1,1) and (1,-1) directions have weight a^{2} and edges pointing in the (-1,-1) and (-1,1) have weight 1 . In [ BCJ22 ] , the authors used the determinantal structure of the two-periodic Aztec diamond measure \mathbb{P}_{a,n} to prove the following smooth phase coupling result: for a box of with side length L at the rough-smooth boundary, the total variation distance between \mathbb{P}_{a} and \mathbb{P}_{a,n} is O(n^{-1/3}L^{8}) . We use both this estimate, and a couple of variants which give smooth phase couplings on larger sets as we move further away from the rough-smooth boundary and into the central smooth region. The smooth phase itself can be understood through Wilson’s algorithm for sampling spanning trees. 3. Spanning tree estimates and interlacing. If we condition on the backbone paths in one of the four Temperleyan forests, then we can fill in the remainder using Wilson’s algorithm. In particular, individual paths in any of the Temperleyan forests simply follow a biased loop-erased random walk path until they hit the backbone, and so remain in a certain parabola with high probability. This observation starts to give a lot of structure to the spanning forests when we combine it with the fact that the south and north forests are dual to each other. For example, in the corridor between two adjacent south backbone paths, the trajectory of the dual north backbone path cannot position itself in a way that blocks a south loop-erased random walk path from reaching either of the south backbone paths, see Figure 8 . Figure 8 . A low-likelihood configuration of backbone paths. The dual north backbone path \mathcal{N}_{i-1}^{-} is positioned relative to the south backbone paths \mathcal{S}_{i-1}^{-},\mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} in such a way that makes it very unlikely that a south-drifted random walk from any of the three blue sites will hit \mathcal{S}_{i-1}^{-} or \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} before hitting \mathcal{N}_{i-1}^{-} . Parabolic random walk range constraints are included for two of the blue sites. The first two categories above are highly reliant on the specific integrable structure of the two-periodic Aztec diamond, whereas the third is based on more a general probabilistic/combinatorial framework and holds for two-periodic tilings on more general domains. Beyond establishing the tools above, we do not use the exact formulas for the two-periodic Aztec diamond and all arguments are probabilistic or geometric in nature. Most of the tools described above have standard proofs and will not surprise readers familiar with the model. The only result we highlight here is the following symmetry, recorded again in the body of the text as 5.1 . Lemma 3.1 . Let a\in(0,1] , and let (i,j)\in{\mathtt{F}} be such that i,j\in 2\mathbb{Z} . Then \mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(i,j)=-\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(-i,j)=-\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(i,-j)=\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(-i,-j) In particular, \mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(2i,0)=\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(0,2i)=0 for all -n/2\leq i\leq n/2 . This lemma is an obvious symmetry when a=1 , but beyond this case we do not have a combinatorial explanation. We executed a by-hand verification of the equality \mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(0,0)=0 for small values of n , but could not discern a pattern. Note that the expected height at the origin is not an integer in the full-phase smooth phase, so even this symmetry is not coming from a simpler property of the infinite-volume model. The overview of proof of 2.1 2.1 is significantly easier than 2.2 , and in the context of the present paper can be viewed as a warm-up to the latter statement. Indeed, by analyzing convergence to the Airy surface rather than finding paths that converge to the Airy line ensemble, we circumvent effect II described above. Moreover, the framework of random surface convergence in 2.1 can easily incorporate the idea of an Airy line ensemble sitting in a background noise, whereas convergence of line ensembles struggles to capture this directly. 2.1 follows uses the main theorem of [ BCJ18 ] , together with a few of the auxiliary tools described in 1 and 2 above and some probabilistic understanding of the smooth phase. Translated into our language, the main theorem of [ BCJ18 ] essentially says the following; a stronger and more precise version is recorded as 6.1 . Consider a finite collection of times T\subset\mathbb{R} and a finite collection of disjoint intervals (x_{i},y_{i}),i\in I . Then for a particular choice of mollifying sequence \phi_{n} (see Remark 2.3 ), we have: (9) \begin{split}(\mathcal{H}^{\phi_{n}}_{n}[t,x_{i}]_{n}&-\mathcal{H}^{\phi_{n}}_{n}[t,y_{i}]_{n}\;;\;(i,t)\in I\times T)\\ &\implies(4\mathcal{A}(t,y_{i})-4\mathcal{A}(t,x_{i})\;;\;(i,t)\in I\times T).\end{split} There are two key differences between ( 9 ) and ( 6 ): the presence of the mollifying sequence in ( 9 ) versus the presence of the i.i.d. random variables X_{u} in ( 6 ), and the fact that ( 9 ) looks at differences of the height function, rather than the height function itself. Note that in 6.1 , the scaling of the plane with n differs slightly, but this is a minor effect and easily resolved. In [ BCJ18 ] , statement ( 9 ) is proven by asymptotic analysis of exact formulas. In that context, the mollifying sequence \phi_{n} is crucial since it renders the limiting object determinantal. The asymptotic analysis yields a limit result for height differences rather than for the heights themselves because the underlying exact formulas are for the dimer configuration, which is a discrete derivative of the height function. To remove the mollifiers \phi_{n} , we will use that locally around each point [t,x]_{n} , the dimer configuration is well-coupled to a smooth phase (tool 2 ). Fast decay of correlations in the smooth phase guarantees that the mollifying sequence must have had the effect of simply averaging out this smooth phase. It also guarantees that any noise we see from this smooth phase at a fixed point is independent of the limiting heights. By making this argument rigorous, we can replace ( 9 ) with a statement of the following form: (10) \begin{split}(\mathcal{H}^{\phi_{n}}_{n}[t,x_{i}]_{n}&-\mathcal{H}^{\phi_{n}}_{n}[t,y_{i}]_{n}\;;\;(i,t)\in I\times T)\\ &\implies(4\mathcal{A}(t,y_{i})+Y_{i,t}-4\mathcal{A}(t,x_{i})-X_{i,t}\;;\;(i,t)\in I\times T),\end{split} where the X_{i,t},Y_{i,t} are i.i.d. random variables, independent of \mathcal{A} , each equal in law to the height at any a -face in the full-plane smooth phase. Next we remove the height differences. First, it is not difficult to reduce this problem to the case when |I|=1 , and it will be easier to work in the mollified framework ( 9 ). If we take the point y_{1} in ( 10 ) to be very large then with high probability the right-hand side ( 9 ) is simply equal to \{\mathcal{A}(x_{1},t):t\in T) . This suggests that it will be useful to allow y_{1} to tend to \infty with n . In 6.7 , we extend the analysis of [ BCJ18 ] to prove a version of their main theorem that allow us to do this with y_{1}=\log^{3}n . Given this, it is enough to show that for fixed t , we have \lim_{n\to\infty}\mathbb{P}(\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}[t,\log^{3}n]_{n}=H_{n})=1. Heuristically, this follows from the fact that the two-periodic Aztec diamond should agree with the full-plane smooth phase on the entire smooth region if we are sufficiently far away from the boundary. In practice, we prove this by patching together a mesoscopic smooth phase coupling near the boundary of the smooth phase that deals with regions at least distance n^{1/3}\log^{2}n away from the rough-smooth boundary, and a macroscopic smooth phase coupling that kicks in the moment we are distance n^{6/7} away from the boundary. The overview of the proof of 2.2 2.2 is significantly more involved, and the bulk the paper is devoted to its proof. Before discussing the proof, recall that to recover the height at a vertex v along a path in one of the Temperleyan forests, we simply take the height at the source or sink vertex and add four times the winding number of the path connecting v to its source or sink. The upshot of this is that if paths do not typically wind (as is suggested by the simulations) then the height function should stay relatively stable as we move along a backbone path. Moreover, the different components of the Temperleyan forests can be viewed as essentially flat, decorated with local height fluctuations which come from small windings of the tree. Focusing now on the south Temperleyan forest, recall also that off the backbone paths, Wilson’s algorithm guarantees that the forest paths are simply south-biased loop-erased random walks. In summary, a simplistic picture of the components in the south forest near the rough-smooth boundary suggests that each component sits almost entirely above its corresponding backbone path (up to a logarithmic error) and has height function equal to a deterministic shift of the path index (again, up to a logarithmic error). To reconcile this picture with 2.1 , we expect that there is a sequence of south backbone paths indexed by J_{n},J_{n}-1,J_{n}-2,\dots with J_{n}:=\lceil H_{n}/4+n/2\rceil which follow the Airy lines. See Figure 9 for a cartoon, and Figure 7 for a simulation. Figure 9 . A cartoon of the rough-smooth boundary. The top three prelimiting Airy paths \mathcal{S}_{I_{n}-i}^{-} are pictured, with associated typical corridor heights. Two types of forest paths that can change heights within a corridor are highlighted: red whorls, which change height by winding, and green paths, which connect up to upper backbone path despite the southward random walk drift. Controlling global path behaviour To establish this picture rigorously, we need to gain a strong level of control over the backbone paths. The principal difficulties arise from the fact that we are working with undirected, rather than directed, paths. Before we can address the rough-smooth boundary, we must first rule out pathological global behaviour. For purposes of illustration, consider the single path \mathcal{S}_{J}^{-}=\mathcal{S}^{n}_{J_{n}} . In order to later conduct an analysis of the rough-smooth boundary, we will need to rule out the following four global phenomena: (i) \mathcal{S}_{J}^{-} travels macroscopically into the rough or frozen regions. (ii) \mathcal{S}_{J}^{-} travels macroscopically into the smooth region {\mathtt{Smooth}} , rather than staying confined to a small window around the rough-smooth boundary {\mathtt{RS}} . (iii) \mathcal{S}_{J}^{-} stays in a small window around the rough-smooth boundary, but winds around the smooth region or backtracks, rather than simply following the rough-smooth boundary from south to west. (iv) \mathcal{S}_{J}^{-} traces the rough-smooth boundary from south to west, but it is not the last path to do so. In other words, J_{n}\neq I_{n} , where I_{n} is the split point defined prior to 2.2 . See Figure 10(a) for a picture of the regions above. The tools 1 - 3 introduced above are sufficient to rule out each of these scenarios. (a) Regions in the two-periodic Aztec diamond. (b) A potentially bad trajectory for a path \mathcal{S}_{i} starting in the region {\mathtt{RS}} . We can address scenario (i) with expectation and concentration estimates on the height function (tool 1 ). Such estimates give that H_{n}=O(1) , and outside of a small, simply connected window around the central smooth region and the rough-smooth boundary {\mathtt{RS}} , the height deviates by more than O(1) away from 0 . Since the path \mathcal{S}_{J} starts out at a height of H_{n}+O(1) by definition, it cannot exit this window without winding. On the other hand, a path that starts on the boundary of a simply connected domain must have winding number zero upon first exit. This prevents \mathcal{S}_{J} from exiting this window, ruling out (i). We address (ii) and (iii) together. Consider a single path \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} , which starts on the part of the south boundary in the set {\mathtt{RS}} , and ends on the west boundary. First, if we can couple the whole smooth region with the full-plane smooth phase, then this path behaves as a south-drifted random walk whenever it is in the region {\mathtt{Smooth}} . At a global scale, this means that it can only move directly south while in this region. This greatly restricts the kind of trajectories that the path can have, see Figure 10(b) for an example. From here, the rough idea for proving (ii) and (iii) is that if the path \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} does not simply follow the rough-smooth boundary curve from south to west, then we can find vertices in the north forest from which a loop-erased random walk would have to behave atypically, i.e. breaking the parabolic bounds in Figure 8 . These points are easy to find if only a single path \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} has a bad trajectory. Two such points are shown in red in Figure 10(b) . If multiple paths have bad trajectories, then we can create nested onions of bad paths. 7.3 systematically extends the path-blocking idea in Figure 8 to give us quantitative control on onions in terms of their heights, widths, and number of layers. Together with the height estimates used in establishing (i), and the drift estimates in the smooth region, this gives sufficient control to eliminate (ii) and (iii). Once (i)–(iii) are ruled out for \mathcal{S}_{J}^{-} and its neighboring south backbone paths, we can conclude that there exists a topmost path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} tracing the rough-smooth boundary from south to west within the region \operatorname{RS} . By standard random walk estimates, all south forest paths that start above \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} within the smooth region \operatorname{Smooth} must eventually coalesce with \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} . By the smooth phase coupling, these south forest paths start at height H_{n} on average. Therefore the starting height of \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} must coincide with the central height H_{n} , unless \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} itself winds around the smooth region—a possibility ruled out by (i)–(iii). This forces I_{n}=J_{n} , resolving (iv). While a full implementation of the argument eliminating (i)–(iv) is possible using the techniques developed in this paper, doing so would require height function estimates on the whole Aztec diamond and smooth phase couplings that hold throughout the entire smooth region. To avoid some of these technicalities, we will instead prove a weaker statement which still suffices for our study of the rough-smooth boundary. The weak version replaces each region with a kind of topological skeleton and focuses on whether paths cross barriers imposed by this skeleton. A precise version is as follows. First, let \alpha>0 be the unique point such that (-\alpha,0) and (0,-\alpha) lie on the rough-smooth boundary curve. Let \xi_{0}:[-\alpha,\alpha]\to\mathbb{R}^{2} be the rough-smooth boundary curve in the third quadrant, parametrized so that for all a\in[-\alpha,\alpha] , the point \xi_{0}(a) is on the line \{{\bf v}\in\mathbb{R}^{2}:\mathbf{v}\cdot e_{2}=a\} (here recall that e_{1}=(1,1),e_{2}=(-1,1) ). Define the coordinate change \beta_{n}:[-\alpha n,\alpha n]\times\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R}^{2} by \beta_{n}(t,x)=n\xi_{0}(t/n)+e_{1}x. In words, \beta_{n}(t,x) gives a point at location t along the rough-smooth boundary curve, at distance x away from the boundary. Note that the spatial scaling in \beta_{n} does not change with n ; the scaling n\xi_{0}(\cdot/n) simply puts the limit curve back in unscaled coordinates. Next, define regions \displaystyle{\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} \displaystyle:=\beta_{n}([-2n^{3/4},2n^{3/4}]\times[-n^{1/2}\log^{3/2}n,2n^{1/3}\log^{2}n]), \displaystyle{\mathtt{PRS}}_{n}^{*} \displaystyle:=\beta_{n}([-2n^{3/4},2n^{3/4}]\times[-n^{1/2}\log^{2}n,n^{3/4}]), We view the set {\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} as an enlarged version of the region of the rough-smooth boundary where we will eventually see Airy fluctuations, and {\mathtt{PRS}}_{n}^{*} as a padded version. The exact exponents in the definitions of {\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*},{\mathtt{PRS}}_{n}^{*} are not so important. What is important is that the O(n^{2/3}\times n^{1/3}) -region where we are studying fluctuations is lower order compared to {\mathtt{RS}}_{n} , whose height is lower order compared to {\mathtt{PRS}}_{n} . Next, let {\mathtt{X}}=\{{\bf v}\in\mathbb{R}^{2}:v_{1}=\pm v_{2}\} . See Figure 11 for a sketch of these regions, and an illustration of the upcoming theorem. Theorem 3.2 . Recall that I_{n} is the label of the last south backbone path \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} to move from the south boundary to the west boundary. Then with probability 1-o(1) as n\to\infty , the following events hold: 1. (Boundary paths avoid the skeleton and are funnelled through the boundary) The paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} with I_{n}-n^{1/4}\leq i\leq I_{n} do not intersect the region ({\mathtt{X}}\cup{\mathtt{PRS}}_{n}^{*})\setminus{\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} . 2. ( \mathcal{S}_{I_{n}}^{-} is the top path) The path \mathcal{N}_{I_{n}}^{-} does not intersect the region {\mathtt{PRS}}_{n}^{*} . By interlacing, neither do any of the paths \mathcal{S}_{i},i>I_{n} . 3. (Height matching) H_{n}=4I_{n}-n-1 . Figure 11 . Theorem 3.2 gives global control of backbone paths. One of the main upshots of the theorem is that the path \mathcal{S}_{I_{n}}^{-} avoids the region ({\mathtt{X}}\cup{\mathtt{PRS}}_{n}^{*})\setminus{\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} , whereas the path \mathcal{N}_{I_{n}}^{-} avoids the region {\mathtt{PRS}}_{n}^{*} entirely before meeting a path started on the north side of the Aztec diamond. This establishes that \mathcal{S}_{I_{n}}^{-} is the top path moving through the rough-smooth boundary Point 1 in the above theorem should be viewed as a weak resolution to problems (i)-(iii) above, point 2 a resolution to problem (iv), and point 3 an upshot. Note that the precise powers of n in the definition of {\mathtt{RS}}_{n} are not particularly important, beyond the fact that n^{5/6}\gg n^{2/3} and n^{1/2}\gg n^{1/3} . 3.2 is restated with more detail in the sequel as 7.1 . Path regularity at the rough-smooth boundary. Given the weak global control in 3.2 , we have a starting point for understanding the paths \mathcal{S}_{i} at the rough-smooth boundary. If we can additionally prove a kind of weak path regularity locally, then we can deduce 2.2 . To this end, we will prove the following estimate as part of 8.1 . Theorem 3.3 . The following estimates holds simultaneously with probability 1-o(1) as n\to\infty . Let k\in\{0,\dots,\lfloor n^{1/4}\rfloor\} , and suppose that v=(v_{1},v_{2}),w=(w_{1},w_{2}) are two vertices in {\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*}\cap\mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-} where v occurs before w on the path \mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-} . Then (11) w_{1}-v_{1}<(2k+1)n^{1/4}\log^{2}n. 3.3 is a kind of backtrack estimate , which gives quantitative control on how far the undirected paths \mathcal{S}_{i} are from being directed as they move through the rough-smooth boundary. The estimate shows that for paths of index I-k with k=O(1) , the maximum size of a backtrack in the rough-smooth boundary region is of order O(n^{1/4}\log^{2}n) , which is lower order than the Airy scaling. 3.3 is not expected to be sharp, and indeed, the true backtrack bound above should be polylogarithmic. In order to illustrate how 3.3 feeds into 2.2 , let us temporarily assume we can show ( 11 ) with a stronger bound of size \alpha_{n}=o(n^{1/24}) . Fix x,t\in\mathbb{R} , and let v=[x,t]_{n} . Let \pi be the south forest path starting incident to v , and ending at a sink vertex s . Let w be the first vertex on a backbone path \mathcal{S}_{i} visited by the path \pi , and let w^{\prime} be the first vertex visited by \pi on \mathcal{S}_{i} whose height \mathcal{H}_{n}(w^{\prime}) equals the sink height \mathcal{H}_{n}(s) . The height \mathcal{H}_{n}(v) can be written as a sum of the sink height \mathcal{H}_{n}(s)=\mathcal{H}_{n}(w^{\prime}) , and the relative height \mathcal{H}_{n}(v)-\mathcal{H}_{n}(w^{\prime}) . Now, we can use a local smooth phase coupling around v (tool 2 ) to say that in a box B of width 4\alpha_{n} around v , the dimer configuration is close to the smooth phase (since n^{-1/3}\cdot\alpha_{n}^{8}=o(1) ). Because any south forest path entering a smooth region experiences a strong downward drift, this makes it highly unlikely that \mathcal{S}_{i} will enter a slightly smaller box B^{\prime} of width 2\alpha_{n} centered around v . In particular, we expect w^{\prime} to lie outside of B^{\prime} , and the height difference \mathcal{H}_{n}(v)-\mathcal{H}_{n}(w^{\prime}) should be given by the height of v in the smooth phase coupling on B^{\prime} , plus a contribution if the path \pi ever winds around the box B^{\prime} . By our backtrack estimate, winding cannot happen around boxes of width larger than \alpha_{n} , and so \pi cannot wind around the box B^{\prime} . This allows us to identify \mathcal{H}_{n}(v)-\mathcal{H}_{n}(w^{\prime}) as the smooth term X in 2.1 . The sink height \mathcal{H}_{n}(w^{\prime}) (equivalently, the path index i after a deterministic shift) then gives the Airy term. Applying this idea on a fine mesh of vertices v and using some of the weak global path control from 3.2 then translates 2.1 into 2.2 . Now, the above argument fails if we directly apply the estimate ( 11 ), since n^{1/4}\log^{2}n is much larger than the o(n^{1/24}) -scale on which we have a high-probability smooth phase coupling. In order to work around this issue, rather than executing the above argument with a single smooth phase coupling, we construct a ring of boxes of width \log^{3}n which will act as a path barrier. By tool 2 above, the smooth phase coupling succeeds each box with probability at least 1-O(n^{-1/3}\log^{24}n) , and so by a union bound, we can create a ring containing n^{1/3-\varepsilon} overlapping boxes, and couple each box to a different copy of the smooth phase so that all couplings simultaneously succeed with probability at least 1-n^{-\varepsilon/2} . Now, the box width we have chosen is large enough so that drift estimates on smooth phase imply that the probability of a backbone path passing through any box in this ring is smaller than any polynomial in n . Therefore with high probability, we will only have a winding contribution to \mathcal{H}_{n}(v)-\mathcal{H}_{n}(w^{\prime}) if one of the paths \mathcal{S}_{i} winds around the entire ring, which has width at least n^{1/3-\varepsilon} . For \varepsilon<1/12 , we have n^{1/3-\varepsilon}\gg n^{1/4}\log^{2}n , and so 3.3 can guarantee that this does not happen. The overview of the proof of 3.3 . We start with the bound on the top path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} . From 3.2 , \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} moves through the region {\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} without entering the region {\mathtt{X}}\cup{\mathtt{PRS}}_{n}^{*} , whereas \mathcal{N}_{I}^{-} never enters the region {\mathtt{PRS}}_{n}^{*} . In other words, the picture will resemble Figure 11 . Now consider a north forest path \pi starting just above \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} in the region {\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} . By Wilson’s algorithm, the path \pi is simply the loop-erasure of biased random walk, stopped when it hits \mathcal{N}_{I}^{-} . In particular, it will move as a biased loop-erased walk until it exits {\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} , and so with high probability, it will stay in a parabola opening up vertically while it sits in this region. Since the region {\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} has height O(n^{1/2}\log^{3/2}n) , the parabola has maximum width given by the square root of this: O(n^{1/4}\log^{3/4}n) . Now, if the path \mathcal{S}_{I} has backtracks which are much larger than this scale, it will trap some of these loop-erased walk paths, contradicting Wilson’s algorithm. Now, we can apply a similar idea to bound the backtrack size of the top north backbone path \mathcal{N}_{I-1}^{-} . Unlike the path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} , as this path moves through {\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} it in a corridor between \mathcal{S}_{I-1}^{-} and \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} , rather than in a region which is unbounded above. However, the backtrack estimate on \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} guarantees that the upper boundary of this corridor is still regular, and so a version of the argument still applies. We can continue moving through the lines \mathcal{S}_{I-1}^{-},\mathcal{N}_{I-2}^{-},\dots inductively, sacrificing only an additive factor with each successive line index. 4. Trees, forests, and Temperley’s bijection In this section, we describe and prove Temperley’s bijection for the Aztec diamond, and describe its relationships to the height function and dimer representations. Along the way, we will prove some basic combinatorial and probabilistic properties of these correspondences (e.g. symmetries, interlacing, Wilson’s algorithm). Before discussing Temperley’s bijection, we record three basic symmetries of the two-periodic Aztec diamond. Here we let f_{*}\mu denote the pushforward of a measure \mu under a map f . The following lemma is immediate. Lemma 4.1 . The measure \mathbb{P}_{a,n} is invariant under the following three operations sending the south vertex set {\mathtt{S}} to {\mathtt{E}},{\mathtt{W}} , and {\mathtt{N}} , respectively. • \mathbb{P}_{a,n}=(\rho_{\mathtt{E}})_{*}\mathbb{P}_{a,n} where \rho_{\mathtt{E}}(x,y)=(-y,-x) . The map \rho_{\mathtt{E}} sends {\mathtt{S}}\mapsto{\mathtt{E}},{\mathtt{E}}\mapsto{\mathtt{S}} and {\mathtt{N}}\mapsto{\mathtt{W}},{\mathtt{W}}\mapsto{\mathtt{N}} . • \mathbb{P}_{a,n}=(\rho_{\mathtt{W}})_{*}\mathbb{P}_{a,n} where \rho_{\mathtt{W}}(x,y)=(y,x) . The map \rho_{\mathtt{W}} sends {\mathtt{S}}\mapsto{\mathtt{W}},{\mathtt{W}}\mapsto{\mathtt{S}} and {\mathtt{N}}\mapsto{\mathtt{E}},{\mathtt{E}}\mapsto{\mathtt{N}} . • \mathbb{P}_{a,n}=(\rho_{\mathtt{N}})_{*}\mathbb{P}_{a,n} where \rho_{\mathtt{W}}(x,y)=(-x,-y) . The map \rho_{\mathtt{N}} sends {\mathtt{S}}\mapsto{\mathtt{N}},{\mathtt{N}}\mapsto{\mathtt{S}} and {\mathtt{W}}\mapsto{\mathtt{E}},{\mathtt{E}}\mapsto{\mathtt{W}} . 4.1. A generalization of Temperley’s bijection In this subsection, we prove the generalized Temperley’s bijection introduced in Section 2.3 , along with a handful of other combinatorial properties of this correspondence. First, recall from Section 2.3 the definition of the extended south-vertex set {\mathtt{\bar{S}}} , the south-vertex graph {\mathtt{G(S)}} , the source and sink boundaries \partial^{{\mathtt{o}}}{\mathtt{S}},\partial^{{\mathtt{x}}}{\mathtt{S}} , and the notion of a dimer-compatible forest F on {\mathtt{G(S)}} . We give similar definitions for the north vertices using the rotation \rho_{\mathtt{N}} is 4.1 . Define {\mathtt{\bar{N}}}=\rho_{\mathtt{N}}{\mathtt{\bar{S}}},{\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{N}})=\rho_{\mathtt{N}}({\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}})) and say that a spanning forest F of {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{N}}) is dimer-compatible if F=\rho_{\mathtt{N}}F^{\prime} for a dimer-compatible spanning forest F^{\prime} on {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}}) . We define \partial_{N}{\mathtt{N}},\partial_{S}{\mathtt{N}},\partial_{E}{\mathtt{N}},\partial_{W}{\mathtt{N}} exactly as in ( 2 ) but with {\mathtt{N}} in place of {\mathtt{S}} , and set \partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{N}}=\partial_{E}{\mathtt{N}}\cup\partial_{W}{\mathtt{N}},\partial^{\mathtt{o}}{\mathtt{N}}=\partial_{N}{\mathtt{N}}\cup\partial_{S}{\mathtt{N}} , and \partial N=\partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{N}}\cup\partial^{\mathtt{o}}{\mathtt{N}} . Note that we could give similar definitions for the east and west vertices using the other two symmetries in 4.1 , and develop Temperley’s bijection in these settings as well. We will not need these bijections in the present paper. The wiring structure for paths starting on the source boundary in a DCF is quite rigid. We specify this structure in the next lemma. We state it for DCFs on {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}}) , but a symmetric version holds for {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{N}}) by applying the map \rho_{\mathtt{N}} . See Figure 12 for an example of 4.2 . Figure 12 . A dimer configuration on an Aztec diamond with n=4 , together with the associated pair of north (red) and south (blue) Temperleyan forests. Boundary vertex labelling is as in 4.2 , 4.3 . Here I=2 . Lemma 4.2 . Label the vertices of \partial{\mathtt{S}} as follows, moving clockwise in a cycle around the boundary from the northeast corner (n+1,n) : v_{1}^{E},\dots,v_{n/2+1}^{E},v^{S}_{n/2},\dots,v^{S}_{1},v^{W}_{1},\dots,v^{W}_{n/2},v^{N}_{n/2},\dots,v^{N}_{1}. Now, consider a DCF F on {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}}) , and recall the map \theta_{F}:\partial^{\mathtt{o}}{\mathtt{S}}\to\partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{S}} from Definition 2.1 (iii). Then 1. There is a split point I=I(F)\in\{0,\dots,n/2\} such that for j\leq I we have \theta_{F}(v_{j}^{S})\in\partial_{W}{\mathtt{S}} , and for j>I we have \theta_{F}(v_{j}^{S})\in\partial_{E}{\mathtt{S}} . 2. Given I=I(F) , the map \theta_{F} satisfies: \theta_{F}(v_{j}^{S})=\begin{cases}v_{j}^{E},\quad&j>I\\ v_{j}^{W},\quad&j\leq I\end{cases},\qquad\theta_{F}(v_{j}^{N})=\begin{cases}v_{j+1}^{E},\quad&jI\end{cases} If I>0 , then \theta_{F}(v^{N}_{I})\in\{v^{W}_{I},v^{E}_{I+1}\} . Proof. Point 1 holds by planarity. For point 2 , observe that we can translate Definition 2.1 (iii) into the condition that for j\in\{1,\dots,n/2\} we have \theta_{F}(v^{S}_{j})\in\{v_{j}^{E},v^{W}_{j}\},\qquad\theta_{F}(v^{N}_{j})\in\{v_{j+1}^{E},v^{W}_{j}\}. The choice of \theta_{F} is determined as in point 2 by this constraint, the definition of I , and planarity. ∎ Remark 4.1 . The labelling on the boundary vertices match the height function, up to an affine shift. For example, for every south vertex v=v^{S}_{i}\in\partial_{S}{\mathtt{S}} , let f_{v}=v-(1,0) . The face f_{v} is always in \partial{\mathtt{F}} so it has a deterministic height, which satisfies h(f_{v_{i}^{*}})/4+n/4=i-1. Similar affine relationships hold for the vertices on the other three boundaries. Note the similarity between the relationship here and the relation between I_{n} and H_{n} in 2.2 . The takeaway in all settings is that path index equals height-over- 4 (up to shifting the labels). However, here the relationship is straightforward and deterministic, whereas in 2.2 the relationship only holds with high probability, and is a consequence of our global control on path behaviour. Now, the graphs {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}}),{\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{N}}) are duals of each other, in the following sense. Let E_{\mathtt{S}} and E_{\mathtt{N}} denote the edge sets of {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}}) and {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{N}}) , represented as line segments in the plane. Then the map taking every edge in E_{\mathtt{S}} and rotating by \pi/2 about its midpoint is a bijection from E_{\mathtt{S}} to E_{\mathtt{N}} . In particular, every edge in E_{\mathtt{S}} crosses exactly one edge in E_{\mathtt{N}} , and we refer to such edges as duals. This dual relationship extends to dimer-compatible forests. Lemma 4.3 . Consider a DCF F on {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}}) . Define the dual \check{F} of F to be the subgraph of {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{N}}) with vertex set {\mathtt{\bar{N}}} and edge set consisting of all edges in E_{\mathtt{N}} that do not cross an edge in F . Then \check{F} is a DCF on {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{N}}) . Moreover, if the split point I is given as in 4.2 , we have the following description for \theta_{\check{F}} . Extend the labelling of \partial{\mathtt{S}} in 4.2 to all vertices of \partial{\mathtt{N}}\cup\partial{\mathtt{S}} as follows, so that moving clockwise in a cycle around the boundary from the northeast corner (n+1,n) we have: \displaystyle v_{1}^{E},w_{1}^{E},v_{2}^{E},\dots,v^{E}_{n/2},w_{n/2}^{E},v_{n/2+1}^{E},w^{S}_{n/2},v^{S}_{n/2},\dots,w^{S}_{1},v^{S}_{1}, \displaystyle w^{W}_{1},v^{W}_{1},w^{W}_{2},\dots,w^{W}_{n/2},v^{W}_{n/2},w^{W}_{n/2+1},v^{N}_{n/2},w^{N}_{n/2},\dots,v^{N}_{1},w^{N}_{1}. Then \theta_{\check{F}}(w_{j}^{S})=\begin{cases}w_{j}^{E},\quad&j>I\\ w_{j+1}^{W},\quad&jI\end{cases} If I>0 , then \theta_{\check{F}}(w^{S}_{I})=w_{I}^{E} if \theta_{F}(v^{N}_{I})=v^{W}_{I} and \theta_{\check{F}}(w^{S}_{I})=w_{I+1}^{W} if \theta_{F}(v^{N}_{I})=v^{E}_{I+1} . Figure 12 may help with parsing the labelling in 4.3 . Proof. First observe that \check{F} cannot contain a cycle. Indeed, any cycle in \check{F} would surround a component in F . On the other hand, every component in F contains a vertex from \partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{S}} , and there are no cycles in {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{N}}) which surround a vertex in \partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{S}} . Hence \check{F} is a forest, giving Definition 2.1 (i). Next, |E_{\mathtt{N}}|=|{\mathtt{E}}|+|{\mathtt{W}}|=|{\mathtt{S}}|+|{\mathtt{N}}|. This follows since the edge set E_{\mathtt{N}} is in bijection with the east/west vertex set {\mathtt{E}}\cup{\mathtt{W}} under the map taking an edge e to its midpoint. Now, |E(F)|=|{\mathtt{S}}| , as F is a forest with |\partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{S}}| -many components and vertex set \partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{S}}\cup{\mathtt{S}} . Therefore |E(\check{F})|=|{\mathtt{N}}| since |E(F)|+|E(\check{F})|=|E_{\mathtt{N}}| by duality. Since \check{F} is a forest with vertex set {\mathtt{N}}\cup\partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{N}} , it contains |\partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{N}}| -many components. Suppose a component C of \check{F} contains no vertices in \partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{N}} . Then there must be two components D,D^{\prime} (possibly the same) of F that separate C from the east and west boundaries \partial_{E}{\mathtt{N}},\partial_{W}{\mathtt{N}} , respectively. Component D must contain vertices in \partial_{E}{\mathtt{S}},\partial_{S}{\mathtt{S}},\partial_{N}{\mathtt{S}} , whereas component D^{\prime} must contain vertices in \partial_{W}{\mathtt{S}},\partial_{S}{\mathtt{S}},\partial_{N}{\mathtt{S}} . Part 2 of 4.2 shows that it is not possible for both these components to exist. Together with the component count for \check{F} , this yields Part (ii) of 2.1 . Given Parts (i) and (ii) of 2.1 , we can define the map \theta_{\check{F}} mapping vertices in \partial^{\mathtt{o}}{\mathtt{N}}\to\partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{N}} . The planar dual relationship between F,\check{F} allows us to determine \theta_{\check{F}} from \theta_{F} (given by 4.2 ) as in the statement of the lemma. This also guarantees Part (iii) of 2.1 . ∎ Next, we state Temperley’s correspondence for the Aztec diamond. Given a dimer configuration D on {\mathtt{A}}_{n} , for any choice of {\mathtt{C}}\in\{{\mathtt{N}},{\mathtt{S}},{\mathtt{E}},{\mathtt{W}}\} we can construct a directed subgraph F_{{\mathtt{C}}}(D) of {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{C}}) as follows. For every vertex w\in{\mathtt{C}} , there is a unique dimer in D of the form \{w,w+e\} where e\in\{\pm e_{1},\pm e_{2}\} . Add the directed edge (w,w+2e) to the graph F_{{\mathtt{C}}}(D) . Proposition 4.4 . For every even value of n\in 4\mathbb{N} and {\mathtt{C}}\in\{{\mathtt{N}},{\mathtt{S}}\} , the map D\mapsto F_{{\mathtt{C}}}(D) is a bijection between dimer configurations on {\mathtt{A}}_{n} and dimer-compatible forests on {\mathtt{G}}(\mathtt{C}) , directed towards the sink boundary \partial^{\mathtt{x}}\mathtt{C} . The inverse map D_{\mathtt{C}} of F_{{\mathtt{C}}} is given as follows. Consider a DCF F on {\mathtt{G}}(\mathtt{C}) , and construct the dual forest \check{F} on {\mathtt{G}}(\mathtt{\check{C}}) , where {\mathtt{\check{S}}}={\mathtt{N}},{\mathtt{\check{N}}}={\mathtt{S}} by including an edge e in \check{F} if and only if e does not cross an edge in F . Then \check{F} is a DCF in {\mathtt{G}}(\mathtt{\check{C}}) . Orient F towards \partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{C}} and \check{F} towards \partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{\check{C}}} , and let D_{\mathtt{C}}(F)=\{(v,v+e):(v,v+2e)\text{ is a directed edge in }F\text{ or }\check{F}\}. Finally, for a dimer configuration D , the dual forest \check{F}_{{\mathtt{C}}}(D) to F_{{\mathtt{C}}}(D) is F_{{\mathtt{\check{C}}}}(D) . To prove 4.4 , we will need to track height changes along forest paths. This is taken care of by the next two results. Lemma 4.5 . Let D be a dimer configuration on {\mathtt{A}}_{n} and let P=(s_{0},s_{1},\dots,s_{k}) be a directed path of vertices in the graph F_{{\mathtt{S}}}(D) . For \varepsilon\in\{(0,\pm 1),(\pm 1,0)\} , define the face-path F^{\varepsilon}(P)=(f_{0}^{\varepsilon},\dots,f_{k}^{\varepsilon})=(s_{0}+\varepsilon,\dots,s_{k}+\varepsilon). Then the height function h for D evolves along F^{v}(P) as follows. Here for two points a,b\in\mathbb{R}^{2} we write [a,b] for the line segment from a to b , oriented in that way. • For i\in\{1,\dots,k-1\} , if [s_{i},s_{i+1}] does not cross [f_{i-1}^{\varepsilon},f^{\varepsilon}_{i}] , then h(f_{i-1}^{\varepsilon})=h(f_{i}^{\varepsilon}) . • For i\in\{1,\dots,k-1\} , if [s_{i},s_{i+1}] crosses [f_{i-1}^{\varepsilon},f^{\varepsilon}_{i}] from right-to-left, then h(f_{i-1}^{\varepsilon})+4=h(f_{i}^{\varepsilon}) . • For i\in\{1,\dots,k-1\} , if [s_{i},s_{i+1}] crosses [f_{i-1}^{\varepsilon},f^{\varepsilon}_{i}] from left-to-right, then h(f_{i-1}^{\varepsilon})-4=h(f_{i}^{\varepsilon}) . The same height evolution holds for F_{{\mathtt{N}}}(D) . 4.5 is readily verified from the definition of the height function. Corollary 4.6 . For a vertex v in a dimer configuration D , let its height h(v) be the average height of the four incident faces. Then in the south-forest setup of 4.5 , we have that h(s_{k-1})-h(s_{0})=L-R, where L is the number of left turns made by the path P , and R is the number of right turns. The same holds for a north-forest path. Remark 4.2 . We remark that h(v) as defined above uniquely specifies the dimer incident to v . For instance, if v\in\mathtt{S} and fix the a -face v+(0,1) to have height 1 . Then we have that h(v) is \frac{5}{2} , \frac{3}{2} , \frac{1}{2} , and -\frac{1}{2} for the dimers (v,v+e_{1}) , (v,v-e_{2}) , (v,v-e_{1}) , and (v,v+e_{2}) respectively. Moreover, it is not hard to see that given the average height function for all vertices of the Aztec diamond, we can recover the tiling. Proof of 4.6 . It suffices to prove the result when k=2 , as the general case follows by concatenation. The k=2 case follows from 4.5 and averaging out the height changes amongst all of the incident faces around two consecutive vertices on a path. ∎ Proof of Proposition 4.4 . We consider the case {\mathtt{C}}={\mathtt{S}} , as the {\mathtt{C}}={\mathtt{N}} case is symmetric. First we show that F_{{\mathtt{S}}}(D) contains no (undirected) cycles. Suppose that C=(s_{1},\dots,s_{k}=s_{1}) is a cycle in F_{{\mathtt{S}}}(D) . First, we necessarily have that C is also a directed cycle, since otherwise some vertex in C would have two outgoing edges. As a directed cycle, C either has four more left turns then right turns, or vice versa. By tracking height changes around C using Corollary 4.6 , this gives two different values for the height of s_{1} , which is not possible. Therefore F_{{\mathtt{S}}}(D) is a directed acyclic graph. By construction, the only sinks in F_{{\mathtt{S}}}(D) are the elements of \partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{S}} , so every component of F_{{\mathtt{S}}}(D) must contain at least one element of F_{{\mathtt{S}}}(D) . On the other hand, the number of edges in F_{{\mathtt{S}}}(D) in |{\mathtt{S}}| , whereas the number of vertices is |{\mathtt{S}}|+|\partial{\mathtt{S}}| and so F_{{\mathtt{S}}}(D) has exactly n+1=|\partial{\mathtt{S}}| components. Therefore each component has exactly one element of \partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{S}} , as desired. Now consider a vertex v=(i,-n)\in\partial_{S}{\mathtt{S}} , and let P=(v=v_{1},\dots,v_{k}=u) , where u\in\partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{S}} . First assume u\in\partial_{W}{\mathtt{S}} . Define an augmented path P^{\prime}=(v_{0},v_{1},\dots,v_{k+1}) by letting v_{0}=v_{1}+2e_{2}=(i-2,-n-2) and v_{k+1}=v_{k}-2e_{2} , adding in the dimers \{v_{0},v_{0}+e_{2}\},\{v_{k},v_{k}+e_{2}\} to the dimer configuration D and extending the height to include all incident faces to v_{0},v_{k+1} . The new path P^{\prime} does not wind around its initial vertex, and its initial and final edges have the same direction. Therefore it has an equal number of left and right turns, and so h(v_{0})=h(v_{k+1}) by Corollary 4.6 . On the other hand, we can compute h(v_{0}) using the deterministic boundary values for the heights near v=(i,n) . This gives h(v_{0})=i+1/2 . By similar reasoning, letting u=(-n-1,j) , we can compute that h(u)=j-1/2 . Therefore j=i+1 and so u=(-n-1,i+1) . By a symmetric argument, we can show that if u\in\partial_{E}{\mathtt{S}} , then u=(n+1,-i+1) . This gives Definition 2.1 (iii) when v\in\partial_{S}{\mathtt{S}} . A similar argument gives the same condition when v\in\partial_{N}{\mathtt{S}} , and so F_{\mathtt{S}}(D) is a dimer-compatible forest. Next, we show that given a DCF F on {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}}) , the set D_{{\mathtt{S}}}(F) is a dimer configuration. First, the dual forest \check{F} is a DCF on {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{N}}) by 4.3 , and so orienting both F,\check{F} towards the sink boundaries is well-defined. Next, D_{\mathtt{S}}(F) is a subgraph of {\mathtt{A}}_{n} where every white (i.e. {\mathtt{N}}/{\mathtt{S}} )-vertex has degree one, since in the oriented forest F,\check{F} , all vertices have out-degree one. Moreover, every black vertex also has degree one, since a black (i.e. {\mathtt{E}}/{\mathtt{W}} )-vertex is incident to an edge in D_{\mathtt{S}}(F) if that planar edge contained the black vertex at its midpoint in either F or \check{F} . Exactly one of these possibilities holds for each black vertex by the dual relationship between F and \check{F} . Hence D_{\mathtt{S}}(F) is a dimer configuration. It is straightforward to check that the maps D_{\mathtt{S}},F_{\mathtt{S}} are inverses. Finally, for a dimer configuration D , for every edge \{v,v+2e\} in the edge set E_{\mathtt{S}} for {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}}) , it is not possible that both \{v,v+2e\} and its dual are contained in both F_{\mathtt{S}}(D) and F_{\mathtt{N}}(D) since the black vertex v+e has degree 1 in D . Hence the planar embeddings of F_{\mathtt{S}}(D) and F_{\mathtt{N}}(D) do not cross, and so they must be duals. ∎ 4.2. Temperley’s bijection and the two-periodic Aztec diamond As discussed in the introduction, the bijection in 4.4 is important in our setting because the pushforward under F_{\mathtt{C}} of the two-periodic Aztec diamond measure \mathbb{P}_{a,n} is tractable. First, observe that D_{\mathtt{C}},F_{\mathtt{C}} interact well with path weights, as described in the next lemma. This is immediate from the definitions. Lemma 4.7 . Fix {\mathtt{C}}\in\{{\mathtt{N}},{\mathtt{S}}\} , and let {\mathtt{D}}_{\mathtt{C}}\subset{\mathtt{D}} be the set of all edges incident to a {\mathtt{C}} -vertex in the Aztec diamond graph {\mathtt{A}}_{n} . Let \operatorname{Dir}_{\mathtt{C}} be the set of directed edges in {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{C}}) and let \phi_{{\mathtt{C}}}:{\mathtt{D}}_{\mathtt{C}}\to\operatorname{Dir}_{\mathtt{C}} be the map sending the edge \{v,v+e\} to the directed edge (v,v+2e) , where v\in{\mathtt{C}} . Let w:{\mathtt{D}}\to[0,\infty) be any weight function which equals 1 on {\mathtt{D}}\setminus{\mathtt{D}}_{\mathtt{C}} , and let \tilde{w}=w\circ\phi^{-1} be the corresponding weight function on \operatorname{Dir}_{\mathtt{C}} . Extend w,\tilde{w} to subgraphs of {\mathtt{A}}_{n} and directed subgraphs of {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{C}}) , by letting the weight of a subgraph be the product of its edge weights. Then with F_{\mathtt{C}},D_{\mathtt{C}} as in 4.4 , for any dimer configuration D on {\mathtt{A}}_{n} or any DCF F on {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{C}}) we have \tilde{w}\circ F_{\mathtt{C}}(D)=w(D)\qquad\text{ and }\qquad w\circ D_{\mathtt{C}}(F)=\tilde{w}(F). 4.7 is relevant because we can produce the dimer measure \mathbb{P}_{a,n} by starting with a collection of edge weights that are 1 on {\mathtt{D}}\setminus{\mathtt{D_{C}}} , for any choice of {\mathtt{C}} , as per the next lemma. Lemma 4.8 (Proposition 8.2, [ BCJ22 ] ) . Fix a\in(0,1) , and consider the following collections of edge weights on {\mathtt{A}}_{n} . • {\mathtt{N}} -weights: edges of the form \{v,v-(\pm 1,1)\} , where v\in{\mathtt{N}} have weight a^{2} . All other edges have weight 1 . • {\mathtt{S}} -weights: edges of the form \{v,v+(\pm 1,1)\} , where v\in{\mathtt{S}} have weight a^{2} . All other edges have weight 1 . Then for either of the two edge weight choices above, the measure on dimer configurations on {\mathtt{A}}_{n} given by choosing configurations proportional to their edge weight is the two-periodic Aztec diamond measure \mathbb{P}_{a,n} . Figure 13 . The north and south edge weights on \mathtt{A}_{n} as considered in 4.8 , along with the original two-periodic weights and the face weights. The idea of 4.8 is that a dimer model is determined by its face weights, i.e. the alternating product of edge weights around each face. Two dimer models with the same face weights are called gauge equivalent , and produce the same measure, see Section 8 in [ BCJ22 ] for details. Combining Lemmas 4.8 and 4.7 , we have the following result. For this corollary, we call a directed edge of the form (v,v+2e) in {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{C}}) a northeast (NE) edge if e=(1,1) , a northwest (NW) edge if e=(1,-1) , a southeast (SE) edge if e=(-1,1) and a southwest (SW) edge if e=(-1,-1) . Corollary 4.9 . For {\mathtt{C}}\in\{{\mathtt{N}},{\mathtt{S}}\} and a\in(0,1) , let \mathbb{Q}_{\mathtt{C,a,n}} denote the pushforward measure of \mathbb{P}_{a,n} under the map F_{\mathtt{C}} . Then \mathbb{Q}_{\mathtt{C,a,n}} is a measure on dimer-compatible forests in {\mathtt{G(C)}} , where for a forest F (oriented towards \partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{C}} , \mathbb{Q}_{\mathtt{C,a,n}}(F) is proportional to the weight of F , where edge weights on \operatorname{Dir}_{\mathtt{C}} are given as follows: • {\mathtt{C}}={\mathtt{N}} : NE/NW edges have weight 1 and SE/SW edges weight a^{2} . • {\mathtt{C}}={\mathtt{S}} : SE/SW edges have weight 1 and NE/NW edges weight a^{2} . Figure 14 . The random walk weights from 4.9 . In other words, the pushforward of \mathbb{P}_{a,n} under the map F_{\mathtt{C}} is a measure on DCFs, where the weights bias towards edges that point in cardinal direction {\mathtt{C}} . Proof. By 4.8 , the measure \mathbb{P}_{a,n} assigns weights to dimer configurations based on the {\mathtt{C}} -weights in that lemma, which equal 1 off of {\mathtt{D_{C}}} . Therefore by 4.7 and the bijectivity of F_{\mathtt{C}} ( 4.4 ), the pushforward \mathbb{Q}_{{\mathtt{C}},a,n} assigns measure to DCFs with weights described above. ∎ One of the main advantages of moving from the dimer measure \mathbb{P}_{a,n} to the DCF measure \mathbb{Q}_{{\mathtt{C}},a,n} is the connection to loop-erased random walks via Wilson’s algorithm [ Wil96 ] . First, consider a finite weighted directed graph G=(V,E) , with a distinguished root vertex v , and suppose that for every w\in V there is a directed path from w to v . We can sample a spanning tree T on G , oriented towards v , with probability proportional to the weight of T , as follows: 1. Choose any enumeration v_{1},v_{2},v_{3},\dots v_{k} of V\setminus\{v\} , and set T_{0}=\{v\} . 2. At step i\in\{1,\dots,k\} , run a random walk X_{i} with step probabilities proportional to edge weights in G , until it hits a vertex in T_{i-1} . Set T_{i}=T_{i-1}\cup\operatorname{LE}(P_{i}) , where \operatorname{LE}(X_{i}) is the loop-erasure of X_{i} (i.e. we remove loops of X_{i} in the order in which they appear to get a simple path). 3. Set T=T_{k} . Wilson’s algorithm has the following obvious extension. Suppose that H is a subforest of G with vertex set W\subset V . Then if we run Wilson’s algorithm on V\backslash W with the whole subgraph H in place of T_{0} , the final graph F=T_{k} has law \mu given as follows: • \mu assigns positive measure to spanning forests F of G such that F|_{W}=H , and every component of F is oriented towards an element of W . Here we write F|_{W} for the subgraph of F induced by the vertex set W . • Subject to this constraint, the probability of F is proportional to its weight. To see why this holds, observe that running Wilson’s algorithm in this setting is equivalent to running Wilson’s algorithm on a graph \tilde{G} , whose vertex set is given by V together with an extra sink vertex w , where we remove all outgoing edges from G|_{W} except those in H , and where we connect vertices in H to the new sink vertex w . We refer to the measure described in the two bullets above as {\mathtt{Forest}}(G\mid H) . Now we examine the upshot of Wilson’s algorithm for the south forest in the two-periodic Aztec diamond. First, for a DCF F on {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}}) , define paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{\pm}=\mathcal{S}_{i}^{\pm}(F),i=1,\dots,n/2 where (with notation as in 4.2 ), the path \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} is the path starting at v_{i}^{S} and ending in \partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{S}} in F , and the path \mathcal{S}_{i}^{+} is the path starting at v_{i}^{N} and ending at a sink vertex in \partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{S}} . We let \mathcal{S}=\mathcal{S}(F)=\bigcup_{i=1}^{n/2}(\mathcal{S}_{i}^{+}\cup\mathcal{S}_{i}^{-}) . We call \mathcal{S} the backbone of the DCF F , and the paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{\pm} the backbone paths . Lemma 4.10 . In this lemma, {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}}) should be understood as a weighted directed graph, with south-biased weights given as in Corollary 4.9 , and F\sim\mathbb{Q}_{{\mathtt{S}},a,n} . 1. Conditional on \mathcal{S}=\mathcal{S}(F) , F\sim{\mathtt{Forest}}({\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}})\mid\mathcal{S}) . 2. Let v\in{\mathtt{S}} , and let \Pi^{\mathcal{S}}(v)=(v=v_{0},v_{1},v_{2},\dots,v_{T}) denote the path starting at v in F , stopped at the first vertex v_{T}\in\mathcal{S} . Then conditional on \mathcal{S} , (v_{0},\dots,v_{T})\sim\operatorname{LE}(X_{v}), where X_{v} is a random walk on {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}}) started at v , stopped when it hits \mathcal{S} . We can similarly define north backbone paths \mathcal{N}_{i}^{\pm} , and state a version of 4.10 in this setting. Proof. Conditional on \mathcal{S} , the only constraint on F required for Definition 2.1 is that F is a spanning forest of {\mathtt{G}}({\mathtt{S}}) where every component is oriented towards an element of \mathcal{S} . The first part of the lemma then follows from Corollary 4.9 . The second part follows from Wilson’s algorithm for sampling measures of the form {\mathtt{Forest}}(G\mid H) . ∎ 4.10 gives a precise framework for showing that paths in north/south Temperleyan forests tend to drift north/south, and gives us a probabilistic foothold for understanding the forest measures \mathbb{Q}_{{\mathtt{C}},a,n} . Remark 4.3 . 4.10 says nothing about how we sample the backbone paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{\pm} prior to filling in the remaining forest. This can again be understood through Wilson’s algorithm. While we will not state a precise correspondence here, one can show that the paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{\pm} are loop-erased random walk paths starting at \partial^{\mathtt{o}}{\mathtt{S}} , and conditioned to end at one of the prescribed points on \partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{S}} , and on non-intersection. The notion of non-intersecting loop-erased random walks, and hence the law of \mathcal{S} , can be understood through Fomin’s determinant formula [ Fom01 ] . Since the backbone paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{\pm} are coming from south-drifted random walks, by conditioning them to hit the east or west boundaries (which forces them to move against their drift), we should expect that they become essentially one-dimensional. Therefore we may loosely expect that the whole ensemble bears a resemblance to non-intersecting one-dimensional walks. This gives some intuition from the forest perspective for why we might expect to see Airy fluctuations. While this is an intriguing picture, it is not as tractable as models of one-dimensional non-intersecting random walks, and we were not to use this description to gain a foothold at the rough-smooth boundary. 4.3. The smooth phase. Near the center of the Aztec diamond, and in large regions within corridors, the Aztec diamond measure is close to a full-plane dimer measure called the smooth phase . The smooth phase is the local limit away from the boundary of a 2 -periodic dimer model with flat boundary conditions. It is easiest to first describe this measure from the point of view of Temperleyan forests, where we can sample it using Wilson’s algorithm rooted at \infty , see [ BLPS01 ] . For this algorithm, let {\mathtt{C}}\in\{{\mathtt{N}},{\mathtt{S}}\} . 1. Choose any enumeration v_{i},i\in\mathbb{N} of the full-plane vertex set {\mathtt{\tilde{C}}} . 2. Run a random walk X_{1} starting at v_{1} with {\mathtt{C}} -biased edge weights as in Corollary 4.9 . Let T_{1}=\operatorname{LE}(X_{1}) . Because of the drift, X_{1} is transient and so \operatorname{LE}(X_{1}) is well-defined. 3. At steps i=2,3,\dots , run a random walk X_{i} with {\mathtt{C}} -biased edge weights until it hits a vertex in X_{i-1} . Set T_{i}=T_{i-1}\cup\operatorname{LE}(X_{i}) . The random walk X_{i} hits T_{i-1} almost surely. 4. Set T=\bigcup_{i=1}^{\infty}T_{i} . It is easy to check that the resulting graph T is an infinite (spanning) tree on {\mathtt{\tilde{C}}} . We let \mathbb{Q}_{a,{\mathtt{C}}} be the law of T , and call T a smooth phase {\mathtt{C}} -spanning tree (with parameter a ). As with the finite version of Wilson’s algorithm, this law does not depend on the enumeration of {\mathtt{\tilde{C}}} . Now, the lattice {\mathtt{\tilde{S}}} with edges of the form \{v,v+2e\} is dual to the lattice {\mathtt{\tilde{N}}} with edges of the same form, and given T\sim\mathbb{Q}_{a,{\mathtt{S}}} , we can construct a dual tree \check{T} on {\mathtt{\tilde{N}}} by letting a dual edge \check{e}\in\check{T} if and only if the original edge e\notin T . The same duality relation holds between {\mathtt{\tilde{E}}},{\mathtt{\tilde{W}}} . The results of [ BLPS01 ] (i.e. Theorem 12.2 therein; the versions of these lattices with oriented edge weights as in Corollary 4.9 are dual networks in the sense of that theorem) imply that if T\sim\mathbb{Q}_{a,{\mathtt{C}}} , then \check{T}\sim\mathbb{Q}_{a,{\mathtt{\check{C}}}} , where {\mathtt{\check{C}}} denotes the dual direction. Together we can take the pair (T,\check{T}) and produce a dimer configuration using an infinite analogue of Temperley’s bijection. Orient both T,\check{T} towards \infty (i.e. so that there are no sink vertices), and define a perfect matching D_{{\mathtt{C}}}(T) of {\mathtt{\tilde{G}}}=({\mathtt{\tilde{V}}},{\mathtt{\tilde{D}}}) by letting D_{{\mathtt{C}}}(T)=\{\{v,v+e\}:v\in{\mathtt{C}}\cup{\mathtt{\check{C}}}:(v,v+2e)\text{ is a directed edge in }T\text{ or }\check{T}\}. Now, given a perfect matching D of {\mathtt{\tilde{G}}} , we can define an (oriented) spanning forest F_{\mathtt{C}}(D) on {\mathtt{\tilde{C}}} by letting F_{\mathtt{C}}(D)=\{(v,v+2e):v\in{\mathtt{C}},\{v,v+e\}\in D\}. The maps D_{{\mathtt{C}}} and F_{\mathtt{C}} are inverses. We let \mathbb{P}_{a}=(D_{\mathtt{S}})_{*}\mathbb{Q}_{a,{\mathtt{S}}}=(D_{\mathtt{N}})_{*}\mathbb{Q}_{a,{\mathtt{N}}} and call \mathbb{P}_{a} the smooth phase . Just as we can define heights in the Aztec diamond, we can also define heights in the smooth phase. As with the Aztec diamond, this requires an anchor point. The natural anchor point is \infty , which is the unique choice that guarantees that the height function is ergodic. To define the height function anchored at \infty , let D\sim\mathbb{P}_{a} and T=F_{\mathtt{S}}(D) . We first define the height function h^{f}_{D} anchored at an a -face f\in{\mathtt{\tilde{F}}} by using the rules in Section 2.2 , subject to the initial condition h^{f}_{D}(f)=0 . All these height functions are shifts of each other. Next, for a simple path \Pi=(v_{0},v_{1},\dots) satisfying (12) \lim_{n\to\infty}v_{n,2}=-\infty, we say that the (counterclockwise) winding number of \Pi is the number times the path \Pi crosses the line v_{0}+\{0\}\times(0,\infty) moving right-to-left minus the number of times it crosses moving left-to-right. The southward drift of the random walk and condition ( 12 ) ensures that each of these counts is finite. We write \operatorname{Wind}(\Pi) for the winding number of \Pi . For an a -face f , let \Pi_{f} be the path in T starting on the {\mathtt{S}} -vertex f-(0,1) . All paths \Pi_{f} satisfy ( 12 ) almost surely since T is built from south-biased random walks, and by this property, there are faces f with \operatorname{Wind}(\Pi_{f})=0 . Choose any such a -face f and set h_{D}=h_{D}^{f} . This is the height function of D , anchored at \infty . The next lemma shows that this procedure is well-defined and clarifies the connection between winding numbers and height functions. Lemma 4.11 . Suppose that D is a dimer configuration on \tilde{V} , and that T=F_{\mathtt{S}}D is an infinite tree such that the infinite path (v_{0}=(0,0),v_{1},\dots) in T starting at the origin satisfies ( 12 ). Then the function h_{D} is well-defined, and for any a -face f we have h_{D}(f)=-4\operatorname{Wind}(\Pi_{f}). Proof. Both claims in the lemma follow if we can show that h_{D}^{f}-h_{D}^{f^{\prime}}=4\operatorname{Wind}(\Pi_{f^{\prime}})-4\operatorname{Wind}(\Pi_{f}). For this, let v(f)=f-(0,1),v(f^{\prime})=f^{\prime}-(0,1) . Let (v,v^{\prime}) be consecutive vertices contained in \Pi_{f}\cap\Pi_{f^{\prime}} . By condition ( 12 ), we can choose v^{\prime} so that the paths \Pi_{f},\Pi_{f^{\prime}} stay below the line \mathbb{R}\times\{v_{2}^{\prime}\} after hitting v^{\prime} . By Corollary 4.6 , h_{D}^{f}(v)=h_{D}^{f}(v(f))+L(f)-R(f), where L is the number of left turns of \Pi_{f} prior to hitting v^{\prime} and R is the number of right turns. A case-by-case analysis starting from the fact that h_{D}^{f}(f)=0 shows that h_{D}^{f}(v(f))=(2/\pi)\theta_{f} , where \theta_{f}\in(-\pi,\pi) is the angle formed between the edge e leaving v(f) and the south-pointing vector (0,-1) . Since \Pi_{f} stays below the line \mathbb{R}\times\{v_{2}^{\prime}\} after hitting v^{\prime} , h_{D}^{f}(v)=(2/\pi)\theta_{f}+L(f)-R(f)=(2/\pi)\theta_{f}-4\operatorname{Wind}(\Pi_{f})-(2/\pi)\gamma_{f}, where \gamma_{f} is the angle formed by the edges e and (v,v^{\prime}) . A similar computation holds for h_{D}^{f^{\prime}}(v) , and the lemma follows since \theta_{f}-\gamma_{f}=\theta_{f^{\prime}}-\gamma_{f^{\prime}} is the angle formed by the edge (v,v^{\prime}) and the vector (0,-1) . ∎ We end this section with a symmetry of the smooth phase that falls out of 4.11 . Corollary 4.12 . If D\sim\mathbb{P}_{a} and f is any a -face or b -face, then h_{D}(f+(x,y))\stackrel{{\scriptstyle d}}{{=}}-h_{D}(f+(-x,y)), where the distributional equality is jointly over all (x,y)\in\hat{\mathbb{Z}}^{2} . Proof. Let L be any vertical line with x -coordinate x_{0}\in 2\mathbb{Z}+1 . Reflect the spanning tree T\sim\mathbb{Q}_{a,S} across L to get a new spanning tree T^{\prime} . The trees T,T^{\prime} are equal in law by the symmetry in Wilson’s algorithm, and moreover, letting D=D_{\mathtt{S}}T,D^{\prime}=D_{\mathtt{S}}T^{\prime} , by 4.11 we can see that h_{D}(x_{0}+x,y)=-h_{D^{\prime}}(x_{0}-x,y) for all (x,y)\in\hat{\mathbb{Z}}^{2} . Since a and b faces have x -coordinates in 2\mathbb{Z}+1 , the lemma follows. ∎ Remark 4.4 . Corollary 4.12 does not hold if f is not an a - or b -face, and this corollary is why we choose to anchor our height function to be 0 on an a -face, rather than at the origin, which will have height in 4\mathbb{Z}+1 . This convention differs from our convention for the finite Aztec diamond, where the origin has height in 4\mathbb{Z} and a -faces have heights in 4\mathbb{Z}-1 . We have chosen the latter convention for the Aztec diamond to accommodate the remarkable symmetry \mathbb{E}h_{D}(0,0)=0 , where D\sim\mathbb{P}_{a,n} , see 5.1 . In the smooth phase, no reasonable convention on the heights yields an integer value for \mathbb{E}h_{D}(0,0) , whereas our choice gives \mathbb{E}h_{D}(f)=0 for any a - or b -face f through Corollary 4.12 . 5. Basic tools In this section, we gather together the three sets of basic tools discussed at the beginning of Section 3 . Most of the height function and smooth phase coupling estimates (tools 1 and 2) in the upcoming Sections 5.1 and 5.2 have integrable proofs, and these are postponed until the latter sections of the paper. On the other hand, the straightforward probabilistic estimates on random walks and spanning trees in Section 5.3 are proven therein. A final section (Section 5.4 ) combines all three tools to produce a few new height function estimates. 5.1. Height function estimates Throughout this section we write \mathcal{H}_{n}:{\mathtt{\bar{F}}}\to\mathbb{Z} for the height function of a dimer configuration D\sim\mathbb{P}_{a,n} . In order to state some asymptotics it will also be convenient to extend \mathcal{H}_{n} to all of [-n,n]^{2} by letting \mathcal{H}_{n}(v)=\mathcal{H}_{n}([v]) , where [v] is the nearest face to the point v , breaking ties arbitrarily. We start with a remarkable symmetry of the two-periodic Aztec diamond. Lemma 5.1 . For any face F=(i,j)\in{\mathtt{F}} with i,j\in 2\mathbb{Z} , we have \mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(i,j)=-\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(-i,j)=-\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(i,-j)=\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(-i,-j) In particular, \mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(2i,0)=\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(0,2i)=0 for all -n/2\leq i\leq n/2 . The anti-symmetry \mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(i,j)=-\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(-i,j) in 5.1 is completely surprising and comes from a delicate formula comparison. We do not have a combinatorial explanation. It is equivalent to a surprising symmetry in height expectation after changing the a -face weights from a to 1/a . 5.1 is proven in Section 12.1 . We also need the following result from [ BN25 ] . Lemma 5.2 . [ BN25 , special case of Theorem 3.1] The central height \mathcal{H}_{n}(0,0) converges in law to a limiting random variable X as n\to\infty . Moreover, \mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(0,0)^{k}\to\mathbb{E}X^{k}\in\mathbb{R} as n\to\infty , for all fixed k\in\mathbb{N} . Remark 5.1 . The random variable X can be written as a sum of independent random variables H+Y , where H is the limit of the averaged central height H_{n} defined prior to 2.1 , and Y is the height at the origin (0,0) in the smooth phase. Theorem 1.1 in [ BN25 ] shows that H is a discrete Gaussian random variable (as with 5.2 , [ BN25 ] also prove this in much greater generality). The random variable Y , which is the winding number of a biased loop-erased random walk on \mathbb{Z}^{2} , should also be a discrete Gaussian random variable. We do not pursue this here. More remarkably, we believe that H\stackrel{{\scriptstyle d}}{{=}}-Y , though we do not have a proof. One upshot of 5.1 is that \mathbb{E}X=0 , and so \mathbb{E}H=-\mathbb{E}Y . We can also compute that \mathbb{E}H^{2}=\mathbb{E}Y^{2} and give explicit formulas for this second moment. This computation also gives an explicit evaluation for the right-hand side of [ BN25 , Equation (61)] for the special case of the two-periodic Aztec diamond. Since these formulas are not relevant to our argument, we omit this computation as it adds considerable length. In Section 5.4 , we will use global smooth phase couplings and estimates on the heights in the smooth phase to propagate the height estimates at the origin given by the previous two lemmas throughout the smooth region. For now, we will move into the rough-smooth boundary and the rough phase. We record two expectation computations, to be proven in Section 12.2 . To state the next lemma, recall from the preamble to 3.2 that \xi_{0}:[-\alpha,\alpha]\to\mathbb{R}^{2} is the rough-smooth boundary curve in the third quadrant, parametrized so that for all t\in[-\alpha,\alpha] , the point \xi_{0}(t) is on the line \{{\bf v}\in\mathbb{R}^{2}:\mathbf{v}\cdot e_{2}=t\} . Recall the coordinate change \beta_{n}:[-\alpha n,\alpha n]\times\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R}^{2} by \beta_{n}(t,x)=n\xi_{0}(t/n)+e_{1}x. In words, \beta_{n}(t,x) gives a point at location t along the rough-smooth boundary curve, at distance x away from the boundary. Note that the transformation \beta_{n} does not scale space; the scaling n\xi_{0}(\cdot/n) simply puts the limit curve back in unscaled coordinates. Lemma 5.3 . There exists \eta_{a}>0 such that the following holds for all large enough n . For all t\in[-n^{5/6},n^{5/6}] and x\in[-n^{8/15},2n^{1/3}\log^{2}n] , we have \displaystyle|\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(\beta_{n}(t,x))+\eta_{a}|x|^{3/2}n^{-1/2}| \displaystyle\leq n^{1/6}. Lemma 5.4 . There exists a constant \mu_{a}>0 such that the following holds for all large enough n . For all x\leq 2n^{1/3}\log^{2}n we have \mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(\beta_{n}(0,x))\leq-\mu_{a}|x|^{3/2}n^{-1/2}+n^{1/6} whenever \beta_{n}(0,x)\in[-n,n]^{2} . We can also establish concentration around the expectations in 5.3 and 5.4 . However, we defer this computation to Section 5.4 , since it requires a connection to the smooth region via a smooth phase coupling. 5.2. Smooth phase couplings In this section, we collect coupling results between the smooth phase and the Aztec diamond. We start with a local coupling result at the rough-smooth boundary from [ BCJ22 ] . Lemma 5.5 . (Local smooth coupling, Proposition 4.5, [ BCJ22 ] ) Fix L>0 , and consider a subset \Lambda\subset\beta_{n}([-Ln^{2/3},Ln^{2/3}]\times[-Ln^{1/3},Ln^{1/3}]). Then there exists a constant C=C(L)>0 such that d_{\operatorname{TV}}(\mathbb{P}_{a,n}|_{\Lambda},\mathbb{P}_{a}|_{\Lambda})\leq Cn^{-1/3}|\Lambda|^{4}. Here d_{\operatorname{TV}} denotes the total variation distance between the measures. In [ BCJ22 ] , this lemma is stated only for boxes. However, the proof goes through verbatim regardless of the geometry of the set \Lambda , see Section 7 in [ BCJ22 ] or the similar proofs of 5.6 and 5.7 in Section 11 . The set \beta_{n}([-Ln^{2/3},Ln^{2/3}]\times[-Ln^{1/3},Ln^{1/3}]) appearing in the lemma statement simply corresponds to a region of fixed size at the rough-smooth boundary after we pass to the limiting coordinates. We note that it is not difficult to use the Gibbs property for dimers and replace the factor |\Lambda|^{4} by |\partial\Lambda|^{4} in the above lemma, where \partial\Lambda is the inner boundary of \Lambda . However, this improvement does not help us so we have not included this strengthening here. If we move away from the rough-smooth boundary and into the smooth region, then we can improve the total variation bound in 5.5 and couple on larger sets. The next two lemmas give two couplings on specific larger sets. The choice of parameters in the sets are somewhat arbitrary, and chosen for ease of proof. Figure 15 . The coupling sets \Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1},\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2} depicted within the smooth region. The green box is the rough-smooth boundary where we will study Airy fluctuations, and where 5.5 holds. The figure is not to scale, e.g. the gap between \Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2} and the Airy region is of size n^{1/3}\log^{2}n , and the overlap between \Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1},\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2} is of order n^{6/7} . Lemma 5.6 . (Global smooth coupling) There exist a -dependent constants \gamma_{a},d_{a}>0 such that the following holds. First define \Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1}=\beta_{n}([-n^{5/6},n^{5/6}]\times[n^{6/7},n(|\xi_{0}(0)|+\gamma_{a})). Then d_{\operatorname{TV}}(\mathbb{P}_{a,n}|_{\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1}},\mathbb{P}_{a}|_{\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1}})\leq 3e^{-d_{a}n^{6/7}}. The same bound holds with \Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1} replaced by any of its rotations R_{\pi/2}\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1} , R_{\pi}\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1} , or R_{3\pi/2}\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1} , where R_{\theta} denotes counterclockwise rotation by \theta . Lemma 5.7 . (Mesoscopic smooth coupling) Define the region \Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2}=\beta_{n}([-n^{5/6},n^{5/6}]\times[n^{1/3}\log^{2}n,2n^{6/7}]). Then there exists an a -dependent constant d_{a}>0 such that d_{\operatorname{TV}}(\mathbb{P}_{a,n}|_{\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2}},\mathbb{P}_{a}|_{\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2}})\leq 3e^{-d_{a}\log^{2}n}. The same bound holds with \Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2} replaced by any of its rotations R_{\pi/2}\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2} , R_{\pi}\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2} , or R_{3\pi/2}\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2} . Remark 5.2 . Due asymptotics for K^{-1}_{a,1}(x,y) , the inverse Kasteleyn matrix entry evaluated at x and y (see Section 10 for definitions) given in [ BN25 , Lemma 5.3] for two vertices x and y in the interior of the smooth region, it is not hard to show by mirroring the same proofs as the ones given in 5.6 and 5.7 , that a smooth phase coupling for the entire smooth region as long as we are an appropriate mesoscopic distance away from the boundary. Indeed, such a result follows from the fact that the error between K^{-1}_{a,1}(x,y) and its smooth phase counterpart is exponentially small, as established in [ BN25 , Lemma 5.3] . An immediate consequence is that the mesoscopic average of the height function considered in our main theorems is equal with high probability to the macroscopic average height function considered in [ BN25 ] . The proof of these results can be found in Section 11 . Note that a smooth phase coupling with the same order of error as in 5.7 should hold on the union \Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1}\cup\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2} . The reason we prove couplings separately on \Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1} and \Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2} instead has to do with technical considerations around a choice of conjugation for the kernel for the determinantal measure \mathbb{P}_{a,n} . See Figure 15 for an illustration of Lemmas 5.5 , 5.6 , and 5.7 . 5.3. Random walk and spanning tree estimates Next, we record a few basic estimates coming from standard random walk bounds. Here and throughout the paper, we say that a random walk on {\mathtt{\tilde{S}}} is south-biased (or north-biased) if it moves according to the edge weights in Corollary 4.9 . We start with a straightforward estimate on the path of a biased random walk. For this lemma and through the section, for a path X=(X_{0},X_{1},X_{2},\dots) we write \operatorname{Range}(X) for the set of vertices visited by X . Lemma 5.8 . Let X=(X_{0},X_{1},X_{2},\dots) be a south-biased random walk on {\mathtt{\tilde{S}}} started at X_{0}=(1,0) . For \alpha\geq 2 , define the (roughly) parabolic region P^{\alpha}_{\mathtt{S}}=\{(x,y)\in\mathbb{R}^{2}:y\leq\alpha,|x|\leq(\alpha+\log(y^{-}+1))\sqrt{y^{-}+1}\}, where y^{-}=\max(-y,0) . Then for an a -dependent constant d_{a}>0 , we have \mathbb{P}(\operatorname{Range}(X)\not\subset P^{n}_{\mathtt{S}})\leq 2\exp(-d_{a}\alpha). Moving forward, we will also use the notation P^{\alpha}_{\mathtt{N}}=\rho_{\mathtt{N}}P^{\alpha}_{\mathtt{S}} . Proof. Write X_{i,1},X_{i,2} for the x - and y -coordinates of X . Then X_{\cdot,1} is a simple symmetric random walk on \mathbb{Z} , and X_{\cdot,2} is a biased random walk on \mathbb{Z} with step probabilities \mathbb{P}(X_{i,2}-X_{i-1,2}=1)=a^{2}/(1+a^{2}),\qquad\mathbb{P}(X_{i,2}-X_{i-1,2}=-1)=1/(1+a^{2}). Let \mu_{a}=\mathbb{E}(X_{i,2}-X_{i-1,2})=(a^{2}-1)/(1+a^{2}) . Then by Hoeffding’s inequality, \displaystyle\mathbb{P} \displaystyle(X_{\ell}\notin P^{\alpha}_{\mathtt{S}}) \displaystyle\leq\mathbb{P}\Big(|X_{\ell,1}|>(\alpha+\log(\ell|\mu_{a}|/2+1))\sqrt{\ell|\mu_{a}|/2+1}\Big)+\mathbb{P}(X_{\ell,2}>\ell\mu_{a}/2) \displaystyle\leq 2\exp(-|\mu_{a}|^{2}(\alpha+\log(\ell|\mu_{a}|/2+1))^{2}/16)+\exp(-\ell\mu_{a}^{2}/8). On the other hand, by a union bound \mathbb{P}(\exists i\in\mathbb{N}\text{ s.t. }X_{i}\notin P^{\alpha}_{\mathtt{S}})\leq\sum_{\ell=\lfloor\alpha\rfloor}^{\infty}\mathbb{P}(X_{\ell}\notin P^{\alpha}_{\mathtt{S}}), where the sum starts at \lfloor\alpha\rfloor , since prior to time \lfloor\alpha\rfloor , X_{\ell} is deterministically contained in P^{\alpha}_{\mathtt{S}} . Combining this with the previous bound gives the result. ∎ The above random walk estimate yields a simple bound for the behaviour of south forest paths in the Aztec diamond off of the backbone. Lemma 5.9 . Let F\sim\mathbb{Q}_{{\mathtt{S}},a,n} , let \mathcal{S}=\mathcal{S}(F) be the backbone of F , and let \Pi^{\mathcal{S}}(v) denote the path in F from a vertex v stopped when it first hits the backbone, as in 4.10 . Define the event \mathsf{Para}_{\mathtt{S}}(\alpha)=\{\operatorname{Range}(\Pi^{\mathcal{S}}(v))\subset P^{\alpha}_{\mathtt{S}}+v\text{ for all }v\in{\mathtt{S}}\}. Then \mathbb{P}(\mathsf{Para}_{\mathtt{S}}(\alpha)\mid\mathcal{S})\geq 1-2n^{2}\exp(-d_{a}\alpha). Here we are conditioning on the entire backbone of F , i.e. all south backbone paths. Proof. This follows from Part (2) of 4.10 , 5.8 , and a union bound. ∎ We end this section by establishing decorrelation and concentration estimates for heights in the smooth phase. Lemma 5.10 . Let D\sim\mathbb{P}_{a} and let f\in{\mathtt{\tilde{F}}} be any face. Then (13) \mathbb{P}(|h_{D}(f)|>m)\leq 2\exp(-d_{a}m^{2}) for all m>0 . Moreover, for any two faces f,f^{\prime} we have the covariance estimate \operatorname{Cov}(h_{D}(f),h_{D}(f^{\prime}))\leq c_{a}\exp(-d_{a}\|f-f^{\prime}\|_{\infty}). Proof. We first prove the lemma in the setting where all faces are a -faces. Let f be any a -face. We have h_{D}(f)=-4\operatorname{Wind}(\Pi_{f}) , with notation as in 4.11 . From Wilson’s algorithm, \Pi_{f}=\operatorname{LE}(X) , where X is a south-biased random walks started at v_{f}=f-(0,1) . For m\in\mathbb{N} , on the event \operatorname{Wind}(\Pi_{f})\geq m , the random walk X must satisfy X_{\ell,2}\geq(v_{f})_{2} for some \ell\geq m^{2}/4 . Using Hoeffding’s inequality and a union bound as in proof of 5.8 \mathbb{P}(\exists\ell\geq m^{2}/4\text{ s.t. }X_{\ell,2}\geq(v_{f})_{2})\leq\sum_{\ell=m^{2}/4}^{\infty}\exp(-\ell\mu_{a}^{2}/4)\leq 2\exp(-d_{a}m^{2}), giving ( 13 ). We move on to the covariance estimate, starting with the case when f,f^{\prime} are a -faces. We may assume f_{2}\leq f^{\prime}_{2} , and set \alpha=\|f-f^{\prime}\|_{\infty} and v:=f-(0,1),v^{\prime}:=f^{\prime}-(0,1) . We have that (14) [P^{\alpha/6}_{\mathtt{N}}+v^{\prime}]\cap[P^{\alpha/6}_{\mathtt{S}}+w]=\emptyset,\qquad\text{ for all }w\in\mathbb{Z}^{2},w\in P^{\alpha/6}_{\mathtt{S}}+v. Here recall that P^{\alpha/6}_{\mathtt{N}} is a north-facing parabola given by rotating P^{\alpha/6}_{\mathtt{S}} by \pi . Let X,X^{\prime} be independent south-biased walks starting at v,v^{\prime} . Then by Wilson’s algorithm, we have (\Pi_{f},\Pi_{f^{\prime}})\stackrel{{\scriptstyle d}}{{=}}(\operatorname{LE}(X),Y) where Y is given by \operatorname{LE}(X^{\prime}|_{[0,T]}) , where T is the first time X^{\prime} hits \operatorname{LE}(X) , concatenated with the remainder of the path to infinity in \operatorname{LE}(X) at the hitting location of X^{\prime} . To prove the estimate in the lemma, we will show that (15) \mathbb{P}(\operatorname{Wind}(Y)\neq\operatorname{Wind}(\operatorname{LE}(X^{\prime})))\leq 4\exp(-d_{a}\alpha). To see how this proves the covariance bound, observe that gives a coupling between the independent pair (\frac{1}{4}(\operatorname{Wind}(\operatorname{LE}(X)),\frac{1}{4}(\operatorname{Wind}(\operatorname{LE}(X^{\prime}))) and the height vector (h_{D}(f),h_{D}(f^{\prime})) such that the two disagree with probability at most c_{a}\exp(-d_{a}\alpha) . The covariance estimate follows by using this coupling together with the tail bound in ( 13 ). To prove ( 15 ), observe that by 5.8 , (16) \operatorname{LE}(X)\subset P^{\alpha/6}_{\mathtt{S}}+v with probability at least 1-2\exp(-d_{a}\alpha) . Now, let w be the final vertex of Y that is contained in P_{{\mathtt{N}}}^{\alpha/6}+v^{\prime} , and let \bar{Y} be the segment of Y ending at w . Similarly, let w^{\prime} be the final vertex on \operatorname{LE}(X^{\prime}) that is in P_{{\mathtt{N}}}^{\alpha/6}+v^{\prime} , and let \bar{X}^{\prime} be the segment of \operatorname{LE}(X^{\prime}) ending at w^{\prime} . If \bar{X}^{\prime}=\bar{Y} , then Y and \operatorname{LE}(X^{\prime}) have the same winding number, so it suffices to estimate the probability that \bar{X}^{\prime}\neq\bar{Y} . In order for \bar{X}^{\prime} and \bar{Y} to disagree on the event ( 16 ), the path X^{\prime} would have to re-enter P_{{\mathtt{N}}}^{\alpha/6}+v^{\prime} after entering the set P^{\alpha/6}_{\mathtt{S}}+v . By the relation ( 14 ), if T denotes the time when X^{\prime} hits \operatorname{LE}(X) , then this would require that X^{\prime}|_{[T,\infty)}-X^{\prime}(T)\not\subset P_{{\mathtt{S}}}^{\alpha/6}, which has probability bounded above by 2\exp(-d_{a}\alpha) by another application of 5.8 (and the fact that T is a stopping time, so X^{\prime}|_{[T,\infty)}-X^{\prime}(T) is another south-biased random walk). This completes the proof of the coupling. The general case of the lemma when some faces are not a -faces follows from a similar argument, this time decomposing the height of a face as a winding number plus a term coming from the initial direction of the loop-erased random walk. ∎ 5.4. Compound estimates We end Section 5 with two height estimates that combine results from the three sections above. The first estimate gives expectation and concentration estimates on the height function throughout the portion of the smooth region where we have smooth phase couplings. With notation as in 5.6 and 5.7 , define the cross-shaped set {\mathtt{Cross}}={\mathtt{Cross}}_{n}:=\bigcup_{\theta\in\{0,\pi/2,\pi,3\pi/2\}}R_{\theta}(\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1}\cup\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2}). For this lemma, a face f=(i,j)\in{\mathtt{F}} is a c -face if i,j\in 2\mathbb{Z} and i+j\in 4\mathbb{Z} . Corollary 5.11 . For all large enough n , for all c -faces f\in{\mathtt{Cross}} we have that |\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)|\leq 2\exp(-d_{a}n^{6/7}),\qquad\mathbb{E}|\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)|^{2}\leq c_{a} for constants c_{a},d_{a}>0 . Proof. We prove the lemma when f\in\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1}\cup\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2} , as the claim on the rest of {\mathtt{Cross}} follows by a symmetric argument. First assume f\in\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1} . By 5.6 we can couple the height function \mathcal{H}_{n} to the smooth phase height function \mathcal{H} so that with probability at least 1-3e^{-d_{a}n^{6/7}} we have (17) \mathcal{H}_{n}(f)-\mathcal{H}_{n}(0,0)=\mathcal{H}(f)-\mathcal{H}(0,0). Importantly, the coupling in 5.6 only couples the increments of the height function, since the anchor points for the two height functions are different. Therefore letting A be the event where ( 17 ) holds, and letting X=\mathcal{H}_{n}(0,0)+\mathcal{H}(v)-\mathcal{H}(0,0) , we have \mathcal{H}_{n}(f)=X+\mathbf{1}(A^{c})(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)-X) Now, \mathbb{E}X=0 since \mathcal{H}(f)\stackrel{{\scriptstyle d}}{{=}}\mathcal{H}(0,0) by the translation invariance of \mathbb{P}_{a} , and \mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(0,0)=0 by 5.1 . Moroever, by the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality, we have |\mathbb{E}\mathbf{1}(A^{c})(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)-X)|\leq\sqrt{\mathbb{P}(A^{c})}\sqrt{\mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)-X)^{2}}\leq c_{a}n\exp(-d_{a}n^{-6/7}), where the final inequality uses that \mathbb{P}(A^{c})\leq 3e^{-d_{a}n^{6/7}} , the tail bound on heights in the smooth phase ( 5.10 ), and the fact that |\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)|\leq 4n deterministically since \mathcal{H}_{n} has increments bounded by 4 on adjacent faces, and fixed boundary conditions. Combining these results gives the expectation bound, after changing d_{a} . The second moment bound follows similarly, this time using that \mathbb{E}X^{2}\leq c_{a} by 5.2 and 5.10 . Now, for a c -face f\in\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2} , consider any c -face f^{\prime}\in\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2}\cap\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1} . Then by 5.7 we can couple \mathcal{H}_{n} to the smooth phase height function \mathcal{H} such that \mathcal{H}_{n}(f)-\mathcal{H}_{n}(f^{\prime})=\mathcal{H}(f)-\mathcal{H}(f^{\prime}) with probability at least 1-2\exp(-d_{a}\log^{2}n) . We can then proceed similarly to bound \mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(f) and \mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)^{2} , this time using as input the estimates on the moments of \mathcal{H}_{n}(f^{\prime}) from this lemma, rather than those for \mathcal{H}_{n}(0,0) . ∎ Next, we aim to upgrade the expectation estimates in Lemmas 5.3 and 5.4 to concentration estimates. We will use the following standard concentration inequality. Lemma 5.12 . For any faces f,f^{\prime}\in{\mathtt{F}} and any r>0 we have \mathbb{P}(|\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)-\mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)\mid H_{n}(f^{\prime}))|\geq r\sqrt{\|f-f^{\prime}\|_{1}})\leq 2\exp(-r^{2}/18). Moreover, the function x\mapsto\mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)\mid H_{n}(f^{\prime})=x),\qquad x\in 4\mathbb{Z} is a non-decreasing 1 -Lipschitz function of x . Proof. The concentration bound follows from a martingale argument and Azuma’s inequality, see [ Gor21 , Theorem 5.8] for details. The fact that the function \mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)\mid H_{n}(f^{\prime})=x) is 1 -Lipschitz and non-decreasing follows from height monotonicity for random tilings. The details of the argument are again contained in the proof of [ Gor21 , Theorem 5.8] . ∎ Corollary 5.13 . Define the region {\mathtt{Cap}}=\beta_{n}([-n^{5/6},n^{5/6}]\times[-n^{1/2}\log^{2}n,2n^{1/3}\log^{2}n]). Let A_{n} be the event where for all v=\beta_{n}(t,x)\in{\mathtt{Cap}} we have \displaystyle|\mathcal{H}_{n}(R_{\theta}v)+\eta_{a}|x|^{3/2}n^{-1/2}| \displaystyle\leq n^{1/4}\log^{2}n,\quad\theta=0,\pi, \displaystyle|\mathcal{H}_{n}(R_{\theta}v)-\eta_{a}|x|^{3/2}n^{-1/2}| \displaystyle\leq n^{1/4}\log^{2}n,\quad\theta=\pm\pi/2. Here \eta_{a} is the constant from 5.3 . Then \mathbb{P}(A_{n})=1-o(n^{-1/6}) . Similarly, let B_{n} be the event where for all v=\beta_{n}(0,x)\in[-n,n]^{2} with x\leq 2n^{1/3}\log^{2}n we have \displaystyle\mathcal{H}_{n}(R_{\theta}v) \displaystyle\leq-\frac{\mu_{a}}{2}|x|^{3/2}n^{-1/2}+n^{1/4}\log^{2}n,\quad\theta=0,\pi. \displaystyle\mathcal{H}_{n}(R_{\theta}v) \displaystyle\geq\frac{\mu_{a}}{2}|x|^{3/2}n^{-1/2}+n^{1/4}\log^{2}n,\quad\theta=\pm\pi/2. Here \mu_{a} is as in 5.4 . Then \mathbb{P}(B_{n})=1-o(n^{-1/6}) . Proof. Let A_{n}^{0}\supset A_{n},B_{n}^{0}\supset B_{n} be the versions of these events where we only ask the inequalities to holds when \theta=0 . We first prove that \mathbb{P}(A_{n}^{0}),\mathbb{P}(B^{n}_{0})=1-o(n^{-1/6}) . Throughout the proof we focus on bounding heights on the face set {\mathtt{F}} . The extension to all general heights in \mathbb{R}^{2} follows by approximation through the nearest face. Bounding \mathbb{P}(A_{n}^{0}) . For i\in[-n^{1/3},n^{1/3}]\cap\mathbb{Z} , let f_{i} be the c -face closest to the point \beta_{n}(n^{1/2}i,n^{1/2}) . Then for every face f\in{\mathtt{Cap}} , we can find an index I(f)\in[-n^{1/3},n^{1/3}]\cap\mathbb{Z} with \|F-F_{I(f)}\|_{1}\leq 2n^{1/2}\log^{2}n . Therefore by applying 5.12 with r=\log n/2 , taking a union bound over the o(n^{2}) -many faces contained in {\mathtt{Cap}} , with probability at least 1-o(n^{2})\cdot\exp(-\log^{2}n/72) we have (18) |\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)-\mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)\mid\mathcal{H}_{n}(f_{I(f)}))|\leq n^{1/4}\log^{2}n/\sqrt{2}. Next, we claim that there exists a constant c_{a}>0 such that for all faces f,f_{i} and all j_{0}\in 4\mathbb{Z} we have (19) |\mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)\mid\mathcal{H}_{n}(f_{i})=j_{0})-\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)|\leq c_{a}+j_{0}. Indeed, we can write \displaystyle|\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)-\mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)\mid\mathcal{H}_{n}(f_{i})=j_{0})| \displaystyle\leq\sum_{j\in 4\mathbb{Z}}\Big|\mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)\mid\mathcal{H}_{n}(f_{i})=j)-\mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)\mid\mathcal{H}_{n}(f_{i})=j_{0})\Big|\mathbb{P}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f_{i})=j) \displaystyle\leq\sum_{j\in 4\mathbb{Z}}|j-j_{0}|\mathbb{P}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f_{i})=j) \displaystyle=\mathbb{E}|\mathcal{H}_{n}(f_{i})-j_{0}|\leq c_{a}+j_{0}. Here the second inequality uses that \mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)\mid\mathcal{H}_{n}(f_{i})=j) is a 1 -Lipschitz function of j ( 5.12 ), and the final inequality uses Corollary 5.11 . Finally, Corollary 5.11 , Chebyshev’s inequality, and a union bound give that (20) \begin{split}&\mathbb{P}(\text{ There exists }i\in[-n^{1/3},n^{1/3}]\cap\mathbb{Z}\text{ s.t. }|\mathcal{H}_{n}(F_{i})|\geq\tfrac{1}{4}n^{1/4}\log^{2}n)\\ &\leq c_{a}n^{-1/6}\log^{-4}n.\end{split} Together with ( 18 ), ( 19 ), and the estimate from 5.3 , this implies \mathbb{P}(A_{n}^{0})=1-o(n^{-1/6}) . Bounding \mathbb{P}(B_{n}^{0}) . This estimate is similar. Indeed, similarly to ( 18 ), with probability at least 1-2n^{2}\exp(-\log^{2}n/72) , for all faces of the form f=\beta_{n}(0,x) for some x\leq 2n^{1/3}\log^{2}n we have (21) |\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)-\mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)\mid\mathcal{H}_{n}(f_{0}))|\leq\frac{1}{2}(n^{1/2}-x)^{1/2}\log n, where f_{0}=\beta_{n}(0,n^{1/2}) as before. Moreover, from Corollary 5.11 and Chebyshev’s inequality we have \mathbb{P}(|\mathcal{H}_{n}(f_{0})|\geq n^{1/10})\leq c_{a}n^{-1/5}. Combining this bound, ( 19 ), ( 21 ), and 5.4 gives that with probability 1-o(n^{-1/6}) , for all faces f=\beta_{n}(0,x) with x\leq 2n^{1/3}\log^{2}n we have \displaystyle\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)\leq \displaystyle-\mu_{a}|x|^{3/2}n^{-1/2}+\frac{1}{2}(n^{1/2}-x)^{1/2}\log n+c_{a}+n^{1/10}+n^{1/6}. yields the desired estimate on \mathbb{P}(B_{n}^{0}) after simplification. Bounding \mathbb{P}(A_{n}),\mathbb{P}(B_{n}) . To extend the height estimates on \mathbb{P}(A_{n}^{0}),\mathbb{P}(B_{n}^{0}) to all of A_{n},B_{n} , observe that all steps go through verbatim, except we cannot apply Lemmas 5.3 and 5.4 directly since these lemmas do not pertain to points of the form R_{\theta}v where v\in{\mathtt{Cap}} or v=\beta_{n}(0,x)\in[-n,n]^{2} and \theta\neq 0 . Rather, we need to apply these lemmas in conjunction with the symmetries in expectation from 5.1 (in the case when \theta=\pi , we could also use the stronger symmetries from 4.1 , but this is not useful for \theta=\pm\pi/2 ). ∎ 6. An Airy surface in a smooth background In this section, we prove 2.1 , following the proof sketch outlined in Section 3 . We will also prove a few variants of this result which offer different perspectives on the idea that at the rough-smooth boundary we see an Airy surface sitting in a smooth background. As discussed there, our starting point is the main result of [ BCJ18 ] , which shows that Airy statistics arise after taking small averages of the height function around the rough-smooth boundary. 6.1. The Airy line ensemble, the Airy surface, and the main result of [ BCJ18 ] We start by giving a formal definition of the Airy line ensemble. Definition 6.1 . The (stationary) Airy line ensemble is a random sequence of continuous functions \mathcal{A}=(\mathcal{A}_{i}:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R},i\in\mathbb{N}) whose law is uniquely characterized by the following two properties: • For all x\in\mathbb{R} and i\in\mathbb{N} , \mathcal{A}_{i}(x)>\mathcal{A}_{i+1}(x) . • For any finite set of times T=\{t_{1},\dots,t_{k}\} , the point process \bigcup\{(t_{j},\mathcal{A}_{i}(t_{j})):i\in\mathbb{N},j\in\llbracket 1,k\rrbracket\} is a determinantal point process on T\times\mathbb{R} with kernel (22) {\mathcal{A}}(\tau_{1},\zeta_{1};\tau_{2},\zeta_{2})=\tilde{\mathcal{A}}(\tau_{1},\zeta_{1};\tau_{2},\zeta_{2})-\phi_{\tau_{1},\tau_{2}}(\zeta_{1},\zeta_{2}), where (23) \begin{split}\tilde{\mathcal{A}}(\tau_{1},\zeta_{1};\tau_{2},\zeta_{2})&=\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-\lambda(\tau_{1}-\tau_{2})}\mathrm{Ai}(\zeta_{1}+\lambda)\mathrm{Ai}(\zeta_{2}+\lambda)d\lambda\\ \end{split} and (24) \phi_{\tau_{1},\tau_{2}}(\zeta_{1},\zeta_{2})=\mathbbm{I}_{\tau_{1}<\tau_{2}}\frac{1}{\sqrt{4\pi(\tau_{2}-\tau_{1})}}e^{-\frac{(\zeta_{1}-\zeta_{2})^{2}}{4(\tau_{2}-\tau_{1})}-\frac{(\tau_{2}-\tau_{1})(\zeta_{1}+\zeta_{2})}{2}+\frac{(\tau_{2}-\tau_{1})^{3}}{12}}. The function \mathcal{A} is known as the extended Airy kernel . In the above definition and in the sequel we use the integer interval notation \llbracket a,b\rrbracket:=\{a,\dots,b\} . Next, as in the introduction we define the Airy surface \mathcal{A}:\mathbb{R}^{2}\to\{0,1,2,\dots\} by letting \mathcal{A}(x,t)=\#\{i\in\mathbb{N}:\mathcal{A}_{i}(t)\geq x\}. This function is well-defined since \mathcal{A}_{k}\to-\infty as k\to\infty , uniformly on compact sets. This follows, for example, from [ DV21 , Theorem 1.6] . The Airy surface is the analogue of the height function for random tilings, and so it is a natural object to introduce when studying height function convergence in the absence of a tractable family of non-intersecting paths. Next, we recast the main theorem of [ BCJ18 ] in terms of height function convergence to the Airy surface. To set up some notation, for a finite set \phi and a point v\in\mathbb{R}^{2} , define the mollified height function (25) \mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi}(v)=\frac{1}{|\phi|}\sum_{u\in\phi}\mathcal{H}_{n}(v+u), with ties broken using the lexicographic order. Also, define the scaling transformation \tilde{\beta}_{n}(t,x)=[\beta_{n}(2^{1/3}\lambda_{2}n^{2/3}t,2^{2/3}\lambda_{1}n^{1/3}x)]_{a}, where the constants \lambda_{1},\lambda_{2} are as in ( 5 ). Here the outer bracket [\cdot]_{a} maps a point in \mathbb{R}^{2} to the nearest a -face, where ties are broken with the lexicographic order. The transformation \tilde{\beta}_{n} maps limiting coordinates at the rough-smooth boundary to unscaled coordinates in the two-periodic Aztec diamond. This is the scaling transformation used in [ BCJ18 ] , and differs from the scaling transformations \gamma_{n},\hat{\gamma}_{n} we defined in the introduction by a shear that becomes negligible in the n\to\infty limit. For most of this section, we will work with the transformation \tilde{\beta}_{n} , in order to more easily work with the results of [ BCJ18 ] . We translate to the scaling \hat{\gamma}_{n} in a straightforward final step. Next, define (26) \tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}:=\mathcal{H}_{n}\circ\tilde{\beta}_{n},\qquad\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\phi}:=\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi}\circ\tilde{\beta}_{n} for the height function and mollified height function defined in the limiting coordinates. Theorem 6.1 (Theorem 1.1, [ BCJ18 ] ) . Suppose we have the following data: • A collection of times t_{1}\leq t_{2}\leq\cdots\leq t_{k} and spatial locations x_{1}\leq y_{1}\leq x_{2}\leq y_{2}\cdots\leq x_{k}\leq y_{k} . • Mollifiers \phi_{n},n\in\mathbb{N} of the form \phi_{n}=\{2\lfloor\ell\log^{2}n\rfloor e_{2}:\ell\in\{0,\dots,a_{n}\}\}, where the sequence a_{n}\to\infty as n\to\infty and satisfies a_{n}=o(n^{1/3}\log^{-2}n) as n\to\infty . • Sequences t_{i,n}\to t_{i},x_{i,n}\to x_{i},y_{i,n}\to y_{i} for all i=1,\dots,k such that for every i\in\{1,\dots,k-1\} we have that \displaystyle\lambda_{2}n^{2/3}t_{i,n}+2a_{n}\log^{2}n+4 \displaystyle<\lambda_{2}n^{2/3}t_{i+1,n}+2a_{n}\log^{2}n, \displaystyle\lambda_{1}n^{1/3}x_{i,n}+8<\lambda_{1}n^{1/3}y_{i,n}+4 \displaystyle<\lambda_{1}n^{1/3}x_{i+1,n}. Then we have the following Fourier transform convergence. There exists a constant \varepsilon_{0}>0 , such that for any \lambda=(\lambda_{i,j})\in\mathbb{C}^{k\times\ell},\|\lambda\|_{\infty}<\varepsilon_{0} we have (27) \begin{split}\lim_{n\to\infty}&\mathbb{E}\exp\left(\sum_{i,j=1}^{k}\lambda_{i,j}[\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(t_{j,n},y_{i,n})-\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(t_{j,n},x_{i,n})]\right)\\ =\;\;&\mathbb{E}\exp\left(-4\sum_{i,j=1}^{k}\lambda_{i,j}[\mathcal{A}(t_{j},y_{i})-\mathcal{A}(t_{j},x_{i})]\right).\end{split} This theorem is a stronger version of the statement ( 9 ) described in the introduction. Note that in the original statement in [ BCJ18 ] , the sequences t_{i,n},x_{i,n},y_{i,n} are fixed, equal to t_{i},x_{i},y_{i} , and the prelimiting inequalities in the third bullet point above are replaced with the stronger assumptions that t_{i}0 such that for all n , we have U_{n}\subset\beta_{n}([-Ln^{2/3},Ln^{2/3}\times[-Ln^{1/3},Ln^{1/3}]) . Therefore by 5.5 , we can couple the two-periodic Aztec diamond D_{n}\sim\mathbb{P}_{a,n} and the smooth phase D\sim\mathbb{P}_{a} so that (34) \mathbb{P}(D|_{U_{n}}=D_{n}|_{U_{n}})\geq 1-Cn^{-1/3}k^{8}b_{n}^{8}\geq 1-o(1). Let \mathcal{H} denote the height function in D . On the event where D|_{U_{n}}=D_{n}|_{U_{n}} , (35) \begin{split}\mathcal{H}^{\psi_{n}}(u_{i,j})-\mathcal{H}^{\phi_{n}}(u_{i,j})&=\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\psi_{n}}(u_{i,j})-\mathcal{H}^{\phi_{n}}_{n}(u_{i,j}).\end{split} Now, arguing as in the proof of 6.3 , as n\to\infty we have that (36) \mathcal{H}^{\psi_{n}}(u_{i,j})\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\mathbb{P}}}{{\to}}0,\qquad\mathcal{H}^{\phi_{n}}(u_{i,j})\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\mathbb{P}}}{{\to}}0. Putting this together with ( 34 ), ( 35 ), and 6.3 for the mollifiers \psi_{n} then gives (H_{i,n}-\mathcal{H}^{\phi_{n}}(u_{i,j}):i,j\in\llbracket 1,k\rrbracket)\implies(\mathcal{A}(t_{i},x_{j}):i,j\in\llbracket 1,k\rrbracket). where the random variables H_{i,n} are the same as in ( 28 ). This is the first claim in the lemma. We move on to the display ( 33 ). We will work in a version of the coupling above, but with b_{n}=\min\Big(n^{1/100},\inf_{(i,j)\neq(i^{\prime},j^{\prime})}\|\tilde{\beta}_{n}(t_{i,n},x_{j,n})-\tilde{\beta}_{n}(t_{i^{\prime},n},x_{j^{\prime},n})\|_{\infty}/3\Big). This ensures that the sets u_{i,j}+[-b_{n},b_{n}]^{2},i,j\in\llbracket 1,k\rrbracket are disjoint. We also set \phi_{n}:=(2\mathbb{Z})^{2}\cap([-b_{n},b_{n}]^{2}\setminus[-b_{n}/2,b_{n}/2]^{2}). The bound ( 34 ) still holds here, as does the second convergence in ( 36 ) and on the event where D|_{U_{n}}=D_{n}|_{U_{n}} , for any i,j and any point v\in u_{i,j}+[-b_{n},b_{n}]^{2} we have \mathcal{H}(v)-\mathcal{H}^{\phi_{n}}(u_{i,j})=\mathcal{H}_{n}(v)-\mathcal{H}^{\phi_{n}}_{n}(u_{i,j}). By this equality and the first part of the lemma, to prove ( 33 ) it suffices to show that (37) (H_{i,n}-\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(u_{i,j});\mathcal{H}(u_{i,j}+v))\implies(4\mathcal{A}(t_{i},x_{j});\mathcal{H}_{i,j}((1,1)+v)), where the convergence in law is joint over all i,j\in\llbracket 1,k\rrbracket and all v\in\hat{\mathbb{Z}}^{2} . To prove ( 37 ), define the set V_{n}={\mathtt{V}}\cap\bigcup_{i,j=1}^{k}([-b_{n}/2,b_{n}/2]^{2}+u_{i,j}). On the event in ( 34 ), given D|_{V_{n}^{c}} and D_{n}|_{V_{n}^{c}} , resample the dimer configuration D|_{V_{n}}=D_{n}|_{V_{n}} according to the 2 -periodic weights to give a new configuration D^{\prime}|_{V_{n}}=D_{n}^{\prime}|_{V_{n}} . Extend D^{\prime},D_{n}^{\prime} to equal D,D_{n} on V_{n}^{c} , and let \mathcal{J} , \mathcal{J}_{n} denote the height functions in these configurations on the full plane and the Aztec diamond, respectively. By the Gibbs property for the dimer laws \mathbb{P}_{a},\mathbb{P}_{a,n} , we have that (\mathcal{H},\mathcal{H}_{n})\stackrel{{\scriptstyle d}}{{=}}(\mathcal{J},\mathcal{J}_{n}) so it suffices to show that ( 37 ) holds for the pair (\mathcal{J},\mathcal{J}_{n}) . Observe that by the definition of V_{n},\phi_{n} , we have \mathcal{J}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(t_{i,n},x_{j,n})=\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(t_{i,n},x_{j,n}) for all i,j . Therefore to prove ( 37 ) it suffices to show that conditional on \mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}} (and the H_{i,n} , which can be taken as measurable functions of H_{n}^{\phi_{n}} ) we have (38) (\mathcal{J}(u_{i,j}+v))_{i,j\in\llbracket 1,k\rrbracket,v\in\hat{\mathbb{Z}}^{2}}\implies(\mathcal{H}_{i,j}((1,1)+v))_{i,j\in\llbracket 1,k\rrbracket,v\in\hat{\mathbb{Z}}^{2}}. For this, observe that if we let \mathcal{F}_{n} be the \sigma -algebra generated by D|_{V_{n}^{c}} and let \mathcal{G}_{n} be \sigma -algebra generated by both \mathcal{F}_{n} and \mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}} we have \mathbb{P}(D^{\prime}\in\cdot\mid\mathcal{F}_{n})=\mathbb{P}(D^{\prime}\in\cdot\mid\mathcal{G}_{n}). Now, the sets V_{n} fit the assumptions of 6.5 since b_{n}\to\infty with n . Therefore by that lemma, for any sets A_{i,j},i,j=1,\dots,k we have \mathbb{P}(\mathcal{J}(u_{i,j}+\cdot)\in A_{i,j}:i,j\in\llbracket 1,k\rrbracket\mid\mathcal{F}_{n})\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\mathbb{P}}}{{\to}}\prod_{i,j=1}^{k}\mathbb{P}(\mathcal{J}((1,1)+\cdot)\in A_{i,j}). Combining the previous two displays gives ( 38 ). ∎ Next, we recall the definition of the central height. Using the mollifier notation introduced above and letting \zeta_{n} be the set of all faces with \|f\|_{\infty}\leq n^{3/4} , the central height H_{n} is the unique integer in the interval (\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\zeta_{n}}(0,0)-1/2,\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\zeta_{n}}(0,0)+1/2]. To complete the proof of 2.1 , we need to show that all of the height shifts H_{i,n} can be replaced by H_{n} . Up to a coordinate change, this will immediately imply the theorem. Lemma 6.6 . In the setting of 6.4 , we can take H_{i,n}=H_{n} for all i , and the lemma still holds. To prove 6.6 , we require a strengthening of 6.1 in the k=\ell=1 case that allows the endpoint y_{1} to tend to \infty with n . The proof in this setting is a similar to the proof of 6.1 in [ BCJ18 ] with a few minor tweaks, and is included in Section 13 . Theorem 6.7 . Suppose we have: • Sequences t_{n}\to t and x_{n}\leq y_{n}=\log^{3}n with x_{n}\to x\in\mathbb{R}\cup\{\infty\} . • Mollifiers \phi_{n},n\in\mathbb{N} of the form \phi_{n}=\{2\lfloor k\log^{2}n\rfloor e_{2}:k\in\{0,\dots,a_{n}\}\}, where the sequence a_{n}\to\infty as n\to\infty and satisfies a_{n}=o(n^{1/3}\log^{-2}n) as n\to\infty . Then there exists a constant \varepsilon>0 such that for any \lambda\in[-\varepsilon,\varepsilon] we have (39) \begin{split}\lim_{n\to\infty}\mathbb{E}\exp\left(\lambda[\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(t_{n},y_{n})-\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(t_{n},x_{n})]\right)=\mathbb{E}\exp\left(4\lambda\mathcal{A}(x,t)\right),\end{split} where if x=\infty , we set \mathcal{A}(x,t)=0 . Proof of 6.6 . First, in the setting of 6.4 , we can extend the collection of points x_{i},i=1,\dots,k and sequences x_{i,n} to infinite collections x_{i},x_{i,n},i,n\in\mathbb{N} with x_{i}\to\infty with n . The convergences in law in the lemma continue to hold by Kolmogorov’s extension theorem. We claim that in this setting, any sequence of heights H_{i,n} realizing the convergence (40) (H_{i,n}-\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\psi_{n}}(t_{i,n},x_{j,n}):j\in\mathbb{N})\implies(4\mathcal{A}(t_{i},x_{j}):j\in\mathbb{N}) with the explicit choice of \psi_{n}=\{2\lfloor k\log^{2}n\rfloor e_{2}:k\in\{0,\dots,\lfloor n^{1/100}\rfloor\}\}, must satisfy (41) |H_{i,n}-H_{n}|\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\mathbb{P}}}{{\to}}0 as n\to\infty , which yields the desired result. To prove ( 41 ), first note that for any fixed i , we have \mathcal{A}(t_{i},x)\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\mathbb{P}}}{{\to}}0 as x\to\infty , since the Airy point process has a largest point almost surely. Therefore \lim_{j\to\infty}\lim_{n\to\infty}H_{i,n}-\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\psi_{n}}(t_{i,n},x_{j,n})=0, where the convergence is in probability. Similarly, by 6.7 , letting y_{n}=\log^{3}n as in that theorem, we have that in probability, \lim_{j\to\infty}\lim_{n\to\infty}\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\psi_{n}}(t_{j,n},y_{n})-\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\psi_{n}}(t_{i,n},x_{j,n})=0. Subtracting together these two equations gives that in probability, \lim_{j\to\infty}\lim_{n\to\infty}\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\psi_{n}}(t_{j,n},y_{n})-H_{i,n}=0. Given this, to prove the lemma we just need to show that (42) \tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\psi_{n}}(t_{j,n},y_{n})-H_{n}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\mathbb{P}}}{{\to}}0. Recall the sets \Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1},\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2} defined in the global smooth phase couplings, 5.6 and 5.7 . Then by applying these two lemmas, with probability 1-o(1) we can couple our dimer configuration D\sim\mathbb{P}_{a,n} with two other dimer configurations D_{1},D_{2}\sim\mathbb{P}_{a} such that (43) D|_{\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},i}}=D_{i}|_{\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},}i},\qquad\text{ for }i=1,2. Now, let f_{1} be an a -face chosen so that f_{1}+\psi_{n}\subset\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1}\cap\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},2} , and let f_{2}=\tilde{\beta}_{n}(t_{j,n},y_{n}) . Since y_{n}\to\infty much faster than \log^{2}n , we have that f_{2}+\psi_{n}\subset\Lambda_{\operatorname{sm},1} . Then letting h_{i} be the height function for D_{i} , in the above coupling we have (44) \begin{split}\mathcal{H}^{\psi_{n}}_{n}(f_{2})-\mathcal{H}^{\psi_{n}}_{n}(f_{1})&=h_{2}^{\psi_{n}}(f_{2})-h_{2}^{\psi_{n}}(f_{1}),\\ \mathcal{H}^{\psi_{n}}_{n}(f_{1})-\mathcal{H}^{\zeta_{n}}_{n}(0,0)&=h_{1}^{\psi_{n}}(f_{2})-h_{1}^{\zeta_{n}}(0,0).\end{split} Here \zeta_{n} is the set of all faces with \|f\|_{\infty}\leq n^{3/4} . Then arguing as in ( 36 ), all four terms on right-hand side above tend to 0 with n in probability. To handle the averaging in h_{1}^{\zeta_{n}}(0,0) , which also includes faces that are not a - or b -faces, we use the reflection symmetry \mathbb{E}h_{1}(x,y)=-\mathbb{E}h_{1}(1-x,1+y) from Corollary 4.12 to get that \mathbb{E}h_{1}^{\zeta_{n}}(0,0)=O(n^{-3/4}) . Therefore putting together the above discussion and the displays ( 43 ), ( 44 ), we have that \tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\psi_{n}}(f_{2})-\mathcal{H}^{\zeta_{n}}_{n}(0,0)=\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\psi_{n}}(t_{j,n},y_{n})-\mathcal{H}^{\zeta_{n}}_{n}(0,0)\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\mathbb{P}}}{{\to}}0. To complete the proof, observe that the height difference \mathcal{H}^{\zeta_{n}}_{n}(0,0)-h^{\zeta_{n}}_{n}(0,0) is always an integer. Since h^{\zeta_{n}}_{n}(0,0) converges to 0 in probability, this implies that \mathcal{H}^{\zeta_{n}}_{n}(0,0)-H_{n} also converges to 0 in probability, since H_{n} is the nearest integer to \mathcal{H}^{\zeta_{n}}_{n}(0,0) . Putting this together with the previous display gives ( 42 ). ∎ 2.1 is almost immediate from the previous few lemmas, and a minor change of coordinates. We restate a stronger version of that theorem here, together with the variants discussed in Remark 2.3 . Note that the upcoming 6.8 (along with all statements in the body of the paper) is stated in terms of coordinates centered around the rough-smooth limit curve whereas 2.1 is set up using the second order Taylor approximation to the limit curve. The two versions are equivalent since the limit curve is smooth in a neighbourhood \xi_{0}(0) and the lower order Taylor terms are negligible in our scaling. First, define the scaling transformation \gamma_{n}:\mathbb{R}^{2}\to\mathbb{R}^{2} given by (45) \gamma_{n}(t,x)=n\xi_{0}(t/n)+(x,0), and let \hat{\gamma}_{n}(t,x)=[\gamma_{n}(2^{1/3}\lambda_{2}n^{2/3}t,2^{5/3}\lambda_{1}n^{1/3}x)]_{a}-(1,1). Theorem 6.8 . Consider k (potentially equal) points u_{1},\dots,u_{k}\in\mathbb{R}^{2} , and sequences u_{i,n}\to u_{i},n\to\infty . Then for any mollifying sequence \phi_{n}\subset(2\mathbb{Z})^{2} satisfying |\phi_{n}|\to\infty as n\to\infty and \max_{x\in\phi_{n}}\|x\|_{\infty}=o(n^{1/24}) , we have that (46) (\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(\hat{\gamma}(u_{i,n}))-H_{n}:i\in\llbracket 1,k\rrbracket)\implies(-4\mathcal{A}(u_{i}):i\in\llbracket 1,k\rrbracket). Moreover, under the additional assumption that \lim_{n\to\infty}\inf_{1\leq iI , the path \mathcal{S}_{j}^{-} ends on the east boundary \partial_{E}{\mathtt{S}} . By the interlacing above (alternately, by 4.2 ), the paths \mathcal{N}_{i}^{-},iI end on the east boundary. The path \mathcal{N}_{I}^{-} may end on the east or west boundary. Next, recall that the transformation \beta_{n} maps the point n\xi_{0}(0) where the rough-smooth boundary intersects the line \{x=y\} to (0,0) . This transformation also flatten outs and rotates the rough-smooth boundary (without scaling) so that it becomes a horizontal line. Define the regions \displaystyle{\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} \displaystyle:=\beta_{n}([-2n^{3/4},2n^{3/4}]\times[-n^{1/2}\log^{3/2}n,2n^{1/3}\log^{2}n]), \displaystyle{\mathtt{PRS}}_{n}^{*} \displaystyle:=\beta_{n}([-2n^{3/4},2n^{3/4}]\times[-n^{1/2}\log^{2}n,n^{3/4}]), which surround the rough-smooth boundary, together with the set and the set {\mathtt{X}}=\{{\bf v}\in\mathbb{R}^{2}:v_{1}=\pm v_{2}\} . Finally, recall the event \mathsf{Para}_{\mathtt{S}}(\alpha) from 5.9 , which constrains south forest paths to parabolas away from the south backbone. We define \mathsf{Para}_{\mathtt{N}}(\alpha) as the analogous parabolic constraint event for north forest paths (with north-opening parabolas). More precisely, we let \mathsf{Para}_{\mathtt{N}}(\alpha) be the set of DCFs F on {\mathtt{G(N)}} such that \rho_{N}F\in\mathsf{Para}_{\mathtt{S}}(\alpha) , where \rho_{N}(x,y)=(-x,-y) , as in 4.1 . Theorem 7.1 . With probability 1-o(1) as n\to\infty , the following events hold for D_{n}\sim\mathbb{P}_{a,n} and the associated Temperleyan forests: 1. |H_{n}|\leq\log n . 2. The events \mathsf{Para}_{\mathtt{S}}(\log^{2}n),\mathsf{Para}_{\mathtt{N}}(\log^{2}n) hold. 3. The paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} with I-n^{1/4}\leq i\leq I do not intersect the region ({\mathtt{X}}\cup{\mathtt{PRS}}^{*}_{n})\setminus{\mathtt{RS}}^{*}_{n} . 4. The paths \mathcal{N}_{i}^{-},i\geq I and \mathcal{N}_{i}^{+},i\in\llbracket 1,n/2\rrbracket do not enter the region {\mathtt{PRS}}^{*}_{n} . 5. The paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-},i\leq I-n^{1/4}\log^{4}n do not intersect the region {\mathtt{PRS}}^{*}_{n} , and the path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+} does not enter the region {\mathtt{PRS}}^{*}_{n} prior to coalescing with another path. 6. H_{n}=4I-n-1 . Note that the proof of 7.1 will actually yield bounds on slightly larger regions, which we will define as we move through this section. We start with a simple lemma that converts height estimates from Section 5.4 to bounds on path locations. For this lemma, define three overlapping regions: \displaystyle{\mathtt{A}}_{SW} \displaystyle:=\beta_{n}([-n^{5/6},n^{5/6}]\times[n^{1/3}\log^{2}n,n(|\xi_{0}(0)|+\gamma_{a})) \displaystyle{\mathtt{B}}_{SW} \displaystyle:=\beta_{n}([-n^{5/6},n^{5/6}]\times[-n^{1/2}\log^{2}n,2n^{1/3}\log^{2}n]) \displaystyle{\mathtt{C}}_{SW} \displaystyle:={\mathtt{C1}}_{SW}\cup{\mathtt{C2}}_{SW},\quad\text{ where } \displaystyle{\mathtt{C1}}_{SW} \displaystyle:=\beta_{n}([-n^{5/6},n^{5/6}]\times[-n^{1/2}\log^{2}n/2,-n^{1/2}\log^{3/2}n]) \displaystyle{\mathtt{C2}}_{SW} \displaystyle:=\beta_{n}(\{0\}\times(-\infty,-n^{1/2}\log^{2}n]). Here \gamma_{a} is as in 5.6 . For S\in\{{\mathtt{A}},{\mathtt{B}},{\mathtt{C}},{\mathtt{C1}},{\mathtt{C2}}\} , we also define \displaystyle S_{NW} \displaystyle=R_{-\pi/2}S_{SW},\qquad S_{SE}=R_{\pi/2}S_{SW},\qquad S_{NE}=R_{\pi}S_{SW}, \displaystyle\qquad S_{\times} \displaystyle=S_{NW}\cup S_{SW}\cup S_{SE}\cup S_{NE}. where here recall that R_{\theta} denotes a counterclockwise rotation by \theta . See Figure 16 for an illustration of these regions. Figure 16 . Some of the important forbidden sets in 7.2 . Lemma 7.2 . The following events hold with probability 1-o(1) as n\to\infty . 1. The paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{\pm},\mathcal{N}_{i}^{\pm},i\geq n/4+n^{1/4}\log^{2}n do not enter the region {\mathtt{D^{-}}}:={\mathtt{C}}_{NE}\cup{\mathtt{C}}_{SW}\cup{\mathtt{B}}_{NE}\cup{\mathtt{B}}_{SW}\cup{\mathtt{A}}_{\times}. Similarly, the paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{\pm},\mathcal{N}_{i}^{\pm},i\leq n/4-n^{1/4}\log^{2}n do not enter {\mathtt{D}}^{+}:={\mathtt{C}}_{NW}\cup{\mathtt{C}}_{SE}\cup{\mathtt{B}}_{NW}\cup{\mathtt{B}}_{SE}\cup{\mathtt{A}}_{\times} . 2. The paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{\pm},\mathcal{N}_{i}^{\pm},|i-n/4|\leq 2n^{1/4}\log^{2}n do not enter the set {\mathtt{C}}_{\times} . 3. The paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{\pm},\mathcal{N}_{i}^{\pm},|i-n/4|\geq n^{1/4}\log^{4}n/2 do not enter the set {\mathtt{A}}_{\times}\cup{\mathtt{B}}_{\times} . 4. The split point I_{n} satisfies I_{n}-n/4\in[-n^{1/4}\log^{2}n-1,n^{1/4}\log^{2}n] . Proof. We first translate the height bounds from Corollaries 5.11 and 5.13 . These corollaries imply that with probability 1-o(1) , we have that • |\mathcal{H}_{n}(v)|\leq\log n for all v\in{\mathtt{A}}_{\times} by Corollary 5.11 . • \mathcal{H}_{n}(v)\leq n^{1/4}\log^{2}n for all v\in{\mathtt{B}}_{SW}\cup{\mathtt{B}}_{NE} and \mathcal{H}_{n}(v)\geq-n^{1/4}\log^{2}n for all v\in{\mathtt{B}}_{SE}\cup{\mathtt{B}}_{NW} by the first estimate in Corollary 5.13 . • |\mathcal{H}_{n}(v)|\leq n^{1/4}\log^{4}n for all v\in{\mathtt{B}}_{\times} by the first estimate in Corollary 5.13 . • \mathcal{H}_{n}(v)\leq-100n^{1/4}\log^{2}n for all v\in{\mathtt{C}}_{SW}\cup{\mathtt{C}}_{NE} and \mathcal{H}_{n}(v)\geq 100n^{1/4}\log^{2}n for all v\in{\mathtt{C}}_{SE}\cup{\mathtt{C}}_{NW} . This uses the first estimate in Corollary 5.13 on the {\mathtt{C1}} -pieces and the second estimate on the {\mathtt{C2}} -pieces. On the event where these four bounds hold, we will show that the four points in the lemma hold deterministically. For part 1 , by Remark 4.1 , the paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{\pm},\mathcal{N}_{i}^{\pm},i\geq n/4+n^{1/4}\log^{2}n all start at vertices of height at least 4n^{1/4}\log^{2}n+O(1) . They can only change their height by winding ( 4.5 ). On the other hand, the set {\mathtt{D}}^{-} is connected to the boundary of the Aztec diamond, so the first time any of these paths enters this set, its height would have to be within 4 of its initial height. Therefore by the second and third bullets above, none of these paths can enter {\mathtt{D}}^{-} . The second piece of part 1 follows similarly, as does part 2 . For part 3 , observe that the sets {\mathtt{A}}_{\times}\cup{\mathtt{B}}_{\times}\cup{\mathtt{D}}^{-} and {\mathtt{A}}_{\times}\cup{\mathtt{B}}_{\times}\cup{\mathtt{D}}^{+} are connected to the boundary of the Aztec diamond, and by the above bullet points, with probability 1-o(1) the heights on these sets are bounded above by n^{1/4}\log^{4}n/100 (for the first set) and below by -n^{1/4}\log^{4}n/100 (for the second set). Therefore by a similar argument as for parts 1 and 2 , any path whose initial height has absolute value at least n^{1/4}\log^{4}n/99 cannot enter at least one of these sets, and so it cannot enter {\mathtt{A}}_{\times}\cup{\mathtt{B}}_{\times} . Part 3 then follows by translating path indices to heights via Remark 4.1 . For part 4 , observe that {\mathtt{D}}^{-} cuts off the south and west boundaries of the Aztec diamond. Therefore by second part 1 , we have I_{n}-n/4\leq n^{1/4}\log^{2}n . Similarly, the set {\mathtt{D}}^{+} cuts off the south and east boundaries of the Aztec diamond, and so I_{n}-n/4\geq-n^{1/4}\log^{2}n-1 . ∎ To move beyond the height restrictions in 7.2 to get the full suite of restrictions in 7.1 , we will need to control the possibility that paths backtrack or create spirals, which will change their height via 4.5 . This is a particular challenge when paths do this in a nested fashion, creating a kind of onion . We can control the presence of onions by using the parabolic path estimates from the \mathsf{Para} events defined in 5.9 . The next lemma gives a precise statement. For this lemma, for r_{1},r_{2}>0 and \mathbf{v}\in\mathbb{R}^{2} define \displaystyle B_{r_{1},r_{2}}(\mathbf{v}) \displaystyle=\mathbf{v}+[-r_{1},r_{1}]\times[-r_{2},r_{2}],\qquad \displaystyle\partial^{\pm}B_{r_{1},r_{2}}(\mathbf{v}) \displaystyle=\mathbf{v}+\{\pm r_{1}\}\times[-r_{2},r_{2}]. Lemma 7.3 . For r_{1},r_{2}\geq 1 and \ell\in\mathbb{N} let \mathsf{Onion}(r_{1},r_{2},\ell) be the event where there exists a path \mathcal{C}_{i_{0}}^{*}:[0,t]\to\mathbb{R} for some i_{0}\in\{1,\dots,n/2\} , *\in\{+,-\},\mathcal{C}\in\{\mathcal{N},\mathcal{S}\} and path segments \pi_{1}=\mathcal{C}_{i_{0}}^{*}|_{[s_{1},t_{1}]},\pi_{2}=\mathcal{C}_{i_{0}}^{*}|_{[s_{2},t_{2}]} for some t_{1}\leq s_{2} satisfying the following two conditions: • There exists \mathbf{v}\in\mathbb{R}^{2} such that \pi_{1},\pi_{2}\subset B_{r_{1},r_{2}}(\mathbf{v}) . • The points \pi_{1}(s_{1}),\pi_{2}(t_{2}) sit on the same boundary \partial^{\pm}B_{r_{1},r_{2}}(\mathbf{v}) and the points \pi_{1}(s_{2}),\pi_{2}(t_{1}) sit on the opposite boundary \partial^{\mp}B_{r,R}(\mathbf{v}) . • Let M\subset B_{r_{1},r_{2}}(\mathbf{v}) be the union of \pi_{1},\pi_{2} and the region in B_{r_{1},r_{2}}(\mathbf{v}) bounded between these two paths. Then there are at most \ell paths of the form \mathcal{S}_{j}^{\pm} or \mathcal{N}_{j}^{\pm} that enter M . Informally, the event \mathsf{Onion}(r_{1},r_{2},\ell) says that there exists an onion of width r_{1} , height r_{2} , and \ell layers. Then assuming that r_{2}\geq 1 and r_{1}\geq 10\ell\sqrt{r_{2}}\log^{2}n , we have (48) \mathsf{Onion}(r_{1},r_{2},\ell)\cap\mathsf{Para}_{\mathtt{S}}(\log^{2}n)\cap\mathsf{Para}_{\mathtt{N}}(\log^{2}n)=\emptyset. See Figure 17 for an illustration of 7.3 , and a sketch of the proof. Figure 17 . An example of the event \mathsf{Onion}(r_{1},r_{2},3) . If \ell,r_{2} are too small relative to the width r_{1} , then in any onion configuration, we can find a north or south vertex w from which loop-erased random walk paths can only join the backbone by exiting the parabolic set w+P^{\log^{2}n}_{\cdot} . Two such vertices (one north vertex, one south vertex), are shown in the above figure. Proof. Throughout the proof, we assume we are on the event defined by the left-hand side of ( 48 ). Working from this starting point, we will derive the inequality between r_{1},r_{2} , and \ell . Without loss of generality, we assume that the path \mathcal{C}_{i_{0}}^{*} realizing the event \mathsf{Onion}(r_{1},r_{2},\ell) is of the form \mathcal{N}_{i_{0}}^{-}:[0,t]\to\mathbb{R} , and that \pi_{1}(s_{1}),\pi_{2}(t_{2})\in\partial^{+}B_{r_{1},r_{2}}(\mathbf{v}) . The other cases have symmetric arguments. We may also assume r_{1},r_{2}\leq n since the Aztec diamond has height and width 2n . This is the setting of Figure 17 . We proceed by induction on \ell , starting with the base case when \ell=1 . In this case, the only \mathcal{S} - or \mathcal{N} -path that enters the sets M is the path \mathcal{N}_{i_{0}}^{-} . In particular, no \mathcal{N} -path enters the set M . Now consider a vertex \mathbf{w}\in{\mathtt{S}} that lies in the set M , and satisfies |w_{1}-v_{1}|\leq 2 . The south forest path starting from \mathbf{w} must exit M at a vertex \mathbf{u} on the boundary set \mathbf{v}+\{-r_{1},r_{1}\}\times[-r_{2},r_{2}] . On the other hand, since we are on the event \mathsf{Para}_{\mathtt{S}}(\log^{2}n) , the exit point must satisfy \mathbf{u}\in\mathbf{w}+P^{\log^{2}n}_{\mathtt{S}}, which implies that r_{1}\leq|u_{1}-w_{1}|+2\leq(\log^{2}n+\log(|u_{2}-w_{2}|+1))\sqrt{|u_{2}-w_{2}|+1}+2. Using the bounds |u_{2}-w_{2}|\leq 2r_{2} , 1\leq r_{2}\leq n , and simplifying gives (49) r_{1}<10\log^{2}n\sqrt{r_{2}}, which implies the lemma for \ell=1 . Now, let r_{2}\geq\ell\geq 2 and assume that the lemma holds for \ell-1 . Consider the path \mathcal{N}_{i_{0}}^{-}:[0,t]\to\mathbb{R} . Let [a_{1},b_{1}],[a_{2},b_{2}],\dots,[a_{k},b_{k}]\subset[0,t] be an enumeration of all the intervals for which \mathcal{N}_{i_{0}}^{-}|_{[a_{i},b_{i}]}\subset B_{r_{1},r_{2}}(\mathbf{v}), and the points \mathcal{N}_{i_{0}}^{-}(a_{i}),\mathcal{N}_{i_{0}}^{-}(b_{i}) lie on opposite boundaries \partial^{\pm}B_{r_{1},r_{2}}(\mathbf{v}) and \partial^{\mp}B_{r_{1},r_{2}}(\mathbf{v}) . In other words, we have enumerated all left-to-right and right-to-left crossings of [-r_{1},r_{1}]\times[-r_{2},r_{2}] . Since we know \mathcal{S}_{i_{0}}^{-} has at least one left-to-right crossing and one right-to-left crossing of this box, we can find an index i\in\{1,\dots,k-1\} such that the intervals [a_{i},b_{i}] and [a_{i+1},b_{i+1}] represent opposite types of crossings. We may take these two intervals as the intervals [s_{1},t_{1}] and [s_{2},t_{2}] realizing the event {\mathtt{Onion}}(r_{1},r_{2},\ell) . Now, since the crossings are consecutive and we have assumed that \pi_{1}(s_{1}),\pi_{2}(t_{2})\in\partial^{+}B_{r_{1},r_{2}}(\mathbf{v}) , each of the \ell-1 other (\mathcal{S}\cup\mathcal{N}) -paths that enter the region M must enter through the boundary \partial^{+}B_{r_{1},r_{2}}(\mathbf{v}) , as in Figure 17 . At this point, there are two cases: • At least one of these paths entering M also enters the smaller box B:=\mathbf{v}+(r_{1}-20\log^{2}n\sqrt{r_{2}},r_{1}]\times[-r_{2},r_{2}]. In this case, this path crosses from left-to-right and then back from right-to-left across the set M\setminus B . Let M^{\prime}\subset M\setminus B be the region between these crossings. By the ordering/disjointness of the north and south backbone paths, \mathcal{S}_{i_{0}}^{-} does not enter M^{\prime} . Therefore the set M^{\prime} realizes the event {\mathtt{Onion}}(r_{1}-10\log^{2}n\sqrt{r_{2}},r_{2},\ell-1) , which implies the inequality in the lemma by the inductive hypothesis. • No paths enter the set M\cap B . In this case, the set M\cap B and the path \mathcal{S}_{i_{0}}^{-} realizes the event {\mathtt{Onion}}(10\log^{2}n\sqrt{r_{2}}-\varepsilon,r_{2},1) for every \varepsilon>0 , contradicting ( 49 ). ∎ We can combine the previous two lemmas to upgrade the path control in Part (1) of 7.2 to include all paths above (or below) the split point I=I_{n} . This will imply Part (3) of 7.1 . The caveat is that we need to slightly shrink the sets {\mathtt{D}}^{\pm} . For this next lemma, define \displaystyle{\mathtt{D}}^{+}_{0} \displaystyle=\{v\in{\mathtt{D}}^{+}:|v_{1}+v_{2}|\wedge|v_{1}-v_{2}|\leq n^{5/6}/2\}\setminus({\mathtt{B}}_{SW}\cup{\mathtt{B}}_{NE}), \displaystyle{\mathtt{D}}^{-}_{0} \displaystyle=\{v\in{\mathtt{D}}^{-}:|v_{1}+v_{2}|\wedge|v_{1}-v_{2}|\leq n^{5/6}/2\}\setminus({\mathtt{B}}_{SE}\cup{\mathtt{B}}_{NW}). Lemma 7.4 . With probability 1-o(1) , the paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-},i\leq I do not enter {\mathtt{D}}^{+}_{0} . Similarly, the paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-},i\geq I+1,\mathcal{N}_{i}^{+},i\geq I+1 do not enter {\mathtt{D}}^{-}_{0} , and the paths \mathcal{N}_{i}^{+},i\leq I do not enter {\mathtt{D}}^{+}_{0} . Proof. For the proof, we first define an event E of probability 1-o(1) , and then show that the lemma holds deterministically on E . We will only verify the lemma for the paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-},i\leq I , as the claim for the other three sets of paths follows by a symmetric argument. First, let E_{1} be the probability (1-o(1)) -event where the four points in 7.2 hold. Next, let E_{2} be the event where for any path segment \pi in the south forest F_{\mathtt{S}}(D) started at a vertex v and with \pi\subset{\mathtt{A}}_{\times} , we have (50) \pi\subset P_{\mathtt{S}}^{\log^{2}n}, and similarly for any path segment \gamma in the north forest F_{\mathtt{N}}(D) started at a vertex v and with \gamma\subset{\mathtt{A}}_{\times} , we have \gamma\subset P_{\mathtt{N}}^{\log^{2}n} . The event E_{2} has probability 1-o(1) in the smooth phase by the standard estimate in 5.8 and a union bound. Therefore it also has probability 1-o(1) in the Aztec diamond by the smooth phase couplings, 5.6 , 5.7 . We now define E=E_{1}\cap E_{2}\cap\mathsf{Para}_{\mathtt{S}}(\log^{2}n)\cap\mathsf{Para}_{\mathtt{N}}(\log^{2}n), which has probability 1-o(1) by 5.9 , 7.2 , and the above discussion regarding E_{2} . In the remainder of the proof, we work on E . We will only prove the claim for {\mathtt{D}}^{+}_{0} , as the proof for {\mathtt{D}}^{-}_{0} is symmetric. For the sake of contradiction, suppose that one of the paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-},i\leq I enters the set {\mathtt{D}}^{+}_{0} . By path ordering, the rightmost path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} must then also enter {\mathtt{D}}^{+}_{0} . Figure 18 . An illustration of the first part of the proof of 7.4 . For the the path {\mathtt{S}}_{I}^{-} to cross over the line L_{2} , it must either cross through the sets {\mathtt{A}}_{\times} , or else use one of the corridors between {\mathtt{A}}_{\times} and {\mathtt{C}}_{SE} or {\mathtt{C}}_{NW} . The former is essentially rules out since south paths {\mathtt{A}}_{\times} have a strong southward drift. The latter event is illustrated above, and results in an unfavourable {\mathtt{Onion}} event. We first split {\mathtt{D}}^{+}_{0} into two pieces, {\mathtt{D}}_{1}=\{v\in{\mathtt{D}}^{+}_{0}:v_{1}+v_{2}\geq-n^{5/6}/2\},\qquad{\mathtt{D}}_{2}={\mathtt{D}}^{+}_{0}\setminus{\mathtt{D}}_{1}. We first rule out that the paths \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} enter {\mathtt{D}}_{1} . The argument is sketched in Figure 18 . Setting up some notation, define the lines L_{i}=\{(x,y):x+y=-n^{5/6}/i\},\quad i=1,2. Let R denote the region bounded between the lines L_{1} and L_{2} , and the sets {\mathtt{C}}_{SE},{\mathtt{C}}_{NW} . For the sake of contradiction, suppose that one of the paths the paths \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-},i\leq I enters the set {\mathtt{E}}_{1} . By path ordering, the rightmost path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} must then also enter {\mathtt{E}}_{1} . By Part (4) of 7.2 , we have that |I-n/4|\leq n^{1/4}\log^{2}n+1 . Therefore by Part (2) of 7.2 , the path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} cannot enter the sets {\mathtt{C}}_{SE}\cup{\mathtt{C}}_{NW} , so the only way \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} can enter {\mathtt{D}}_{1} is if it crosses through the region R , first crossing the line L_{1} and then later crossing the line L_{2} . Let \pi_{1}=\mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}|_{[s,t]}\subset R denote the segment of \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} given by taking the first crossing of R from L_{1} to L_{2} . Let v=\mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(s),w=\mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(t) denote the first and last points on \pi_{1} . We claim that (51) w_{1}-v_{1}\geq n^{5/6}/100. Suppose that ( 51 ) fails. Then w_{2}-v_{2}\geq 0.4n^{5/6} , since L_{1} and L_{2} are line segments parallel to the line y=-x , vertically shifted by n^{5/6}/2 . On the other hand, the set {\mathtt{B}}_{NW}\cap R is a thin strip contained in a set of the form \{(x,y)+v_{NW}:|x-y|\leq n^{3/4},|x+y|\leq n^{5/6}/2\} for some v_{NW}\in\mathbb{R}^{2} . The same holds true of {\mathtt{B}}_{SE}\cap R (with the vertex v_{NW} replaced by a vertex v_{SE} ). In particular, for n large enough we have the estimate (52) \max\{|a_{2}-a_{2}^{\prime}|:a,a^{\prime}\in{\mathtt{B}}_{*}\cap R\}<0.39n^{5/6}\},\quad*\in\{\text{NE},\text{SW}\}. The negation of ( 51 ) together with ( 52 ) implies that there exists a path \pi^{\prime}\subset\pi_{1}\cap{\mathtt{A}}_{\times} starting and ending at vertices a,a^{\prime} and with a^{\prime}_{2}-a_{2}\geq n^{5/6}/100 . This contradicts the parabolic path estimate ( 50 ), and so ( 51 ) must hold. Figure 19 . The setup of the second part of the proof of 7.4 . Given that the path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} does not enter {\mathtt{D}}_{1} , for it to enter {\mathtt{D}}_{2} it must cross through the boundary strip M in a way that contradicts a parabolic drift estimate. One example of this is given above. Now, since the path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} started on the south side of the Aztec diamond and finishes on the west side, there must exist a path \pi_{2}\subset\mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} contained in the subset S^{\prime} of the strip [v_{1},w_{1}]\times\mathbb{R} which is bounded below by \pi_{1} : S^{\prime}=\{(x,y)\in[v_{1},w_{1}]\times\mathbb{R}:\text{ There exists }x\in\pi_{1},v_{2}\leq y\}, and which crosses S^{\prime} from right to left. Let S^{\prime\prime} be the region in S^{\prime} bounded between \pi_{1} and \pi_{2} . By the ordering on paths, the only paths of the form \mathcal{S}^{\pm}_{i} that can enter the region S^{\prime\prime} are the paths \mathcal{S}^{-}_{i},i\leq I . Additionally, only those paths with index i\geq n/4-n^{1/4}\log^{2}n can enter S^{\prime\prime} . Indeed, the region S^{\prime\prime} is contained in the union of the set {\mathtt{D}}^{+} together with the component of the Aztec diamond that is connected to the north boundary. Therefore any path \mathcal{S}^{-}_{i},i\leq I that enters S^{\prime} must enter the region {\mathtt{D}}^{+} , and therefore must have index i\geq n/4-n^{1/4}\log^{2}n by Part (1) of 7.2 . In summary, we have constructed a region in a strip [v_{1},w_{1}]\times\mathbb{R} of width at least n^{5/6}/100 , bounded between two \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-} paths crossing from left to right and right to left, which contains at most 2n^{1/4}\log^{2}n\leq 2n^{1/4}\log^{n} \mathcal{S}_{i} -paths. By \mathcal{S} - and \mathcal{N} -path interlacing, this region also contains at most 3n^{1/4}\log^{2}n \mathcal{N} -paths. That is, we are on the onion event \mathsf{Onion}(n,n^{5/6}/100,5n^{1/4}\log^{2}n). By 7.3 , this event cannot hold simultaneously with E . Having arrived at a contradiction, we can conclude that \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} does not enter the set {\mathtt{D}}_{1} . To finish the proof, we show that \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} does not enter {\mathtt{D}}_{2}={\mathtt{D}}^{+}_{0}\setminus{\mathtt{D}}_{1} . The argument is illustrated in Figure 19 . Let M be the closure of the set \{v\in\mathbb{R}^{2}\setminus{\mathtt{D}}^{+}:d(v,{\mathtt{D}}_{2})\leq n^{1/4}\}. Note that M\subset{\mathtt{A}}_{\times} , since when defining {\mathtt{D}}_{0}^{+} we removed a boundary strip around the perimeter of {\mathtt{A}}_{\times} in the region containing {\mathtt{D}}_{2} . Let \partial^{-}M be the portion of the boundary of M contained in {\mathtt{D}}_{2} , and let \partial^{+}M be the portion of the boundary not contained in {\mathtt{D}}_{0}^{-} . Since \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} does not hit any vertex in {\mathtt{D}}_{1} , for \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} to enter {\mathtt{D}}_{2} , there must be two disjoint path segments \pi_{1}=\mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}|_{[s_{1},t_{1}]},\pi_{2}=\mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}|_{[s_{2},t_{2}]} with t_{1}\leq s_{2} contained in M , such that: • \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(s_{1}),\mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(t_{2})\in\partial^{+}M and \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(s_{2}),\mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(t_{1})\in\partial^{-}M . • The vertex \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(t_{2}) has a smaller polar coordinate in (0,2\pi) than \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(s_{1}) . We can guarantee this path ordering by choosing [s_{1},t_{1}] minimally, [s_{2},t_{2}] maximally, and using that \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} moves from the south boundary to the west boundary of the Aztec diamond. We will use these two points to derive a contradiction, repeatedly using that M\subset{\mathtt{A}}_{\times} , so the estimate ( 50 ) is in effect. First, by ( 50 ) we must have \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(t_{1})\in P_{\mathtt{S}}^{\log^{2}n+4}+\mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(s_{1}) (the +4 here is to accommodate the fact that the points \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(s_{i}),\mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(t_{i}) may not be vertices in {\mathtt{S}} ). This forces the vertex \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(s_{1}) to lie on the portion of \partial^{+}M where y=x+n^{5/6}/2+n^{1/4} ; call this part of the boundary \partial^{++}M . By the ordering in the second bullet, the point \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(t_{2}) must also lie on \partial^{++}M . However, again appealing to condition ( 50 ), we have that \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(t_{2})\in P_{\mathtt{S}}^{\log^{2}n+4}+\mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(s_{2}) . Since \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-}(s_{2})\in\partial^{-}M , this is a contradiction. ∎ By 7.4 , every path \mathcal{S}_{i}^{\pm},\mathcal{N}_{i}^{\pm} is forbidden from entering either {\mathtt{D}}_{0}^{-} or {\mathtt{D}}_{0}^{+} , with the exception of the two paths \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+},\mathcal{N}_{I}^{-} . These are the free paths which appear in Figure 7 . While they will typically cross through the smooth region, we can still control the possibility that they approach the rough-smooth boundary. This is the goal of the next lemma, which will imply Part (4) of 7.1 . For this next lemma, we define one last region, \Theta , given as follows. First, let L denote the vertical line containing the point \beta_{n}(n^{5/6}/5,-n^{1/2}\log^{2}n) , and let L_{W}\subset L be the largest segment of L whose endpoints are contained in {\mathtt{C}}_{SW},{\mathtt{C}}_{NW} . Let L_{E}=R_{\pi}L_{W} , and let \Theta be the connected component of [-n-1,n+1]^{2}\setminus({\mathtt{C}}_{\times}\cup L_{W}\cup L_{E}) containing the origin, see Figure 20 . Figure 20 . A sketch of 7.5 . The region containing the origin is \Theta . It is well-separated by the red curves from the black region, where we will eventually study Airy fluctuation. Lemma 7.5 . The following holds with probability 1-o(1) as n\to\infty . Either \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+} coalesces with \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} and \mathcal{N}_{I}^{-} coalesces with \mathcal{N}_{I}^{+} , or else \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+} coalesces with \mathcal{S}_{I+1}^{-} and \mathcal{N}_{I}^{-} coalesces with \mathcal{N}_{I+1}^{+} . Prior to the coalescence points, the paths \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+},\mathcal{N}_{I}^{-} are contained in the set \Theta . Proof. The coalescence claims are deterministic given the definition of the split point I by 4.3 , and from this point forward in the proof we write \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+},\mathcal{N}_{I}^{-} for just the portion of these paths prior to the coalescence point with another \mathcal{S} - or \mathcal{N} -path. We must check that the paths \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+},\mathcal{N}_{I}^{-} are contained in the set \Theta . We may assume that \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+} eventually coalesces with \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} and \mathcal{N}_{I}^{-} coalesces with \mathcal{N}_{I}^{+} , as the other case follows a symmetric argument. Throughout, we work on the high probability event E defined in the proof of 7.4 . The lemma in this case is deterministic on this event. For i=3,4,5 , let L_{i} be the vertical line that crosses the boundary \partial^{-}{\mathtt{Cap}}_{SW} at the point \beta_{n}(n^{5/6}/i,-n^{1/2}\log^{2}n) . Let L_{i,W}\subset L_{i} be the largest line segment whose endpoints lie on {\mathtt{C}}_{SW},{\mathtt{C}}_{NW} , and let L_{i,E}=R_{\pi}L_{i,W} . We first rule out the possibility that \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+} crosses L_{4,E} . First, by Part (4) of 7.2 , we have that |I-n/4|\leq n^{1/4}\log^{2}n+1 , and so by Part (2) of 7.2 , the path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+} does not enter {\mathtt{C}}_{\times} . Therefore the only way for \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+} to cross L_{4,E} is if it first crosses L_{3,E} . Moreover, \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+} later coalesces with \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} , and \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} never crosses {\mathtt{C}}_{\times}\cup L_{3,E} , since this would require it to enter {\mathtt{D}}_{0}^{+} , contradicting 7.4 . Therefore \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+} must cross L_{3,E} again after crossing L_{4,E} prior to joining \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} . Now, we can find subpaths \pi_{1}=\mathcal{S}_{I}^{+}|_{[s_{1},t_{1}]},\pi_{2}=\mathcal{S}_{I}^{+}|_{[s_{2},t_{2}]},t_{1}\leq s_{2} that stay in the region R bounded by the four sets L_{3,E},\quad L_{4,E},\quad{\mathtt{C}}_{SE},\quad{\mathtt{C}}_{NE} such that \pi_{1} starts on L_{3,E} and ends on L_{4,E} and \pi_{2} starts on L_{4,E} and ends on L_{3,E} . Let R^{\prime}\subset R denote the subregion bounded between the paths \pi_{1},\pi_{2} . Again, the path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} cannot enter R^{\prime} by 7.4 , since it cannot cross {\mathtt{D}}_{0}^{+} . Similarly, the path \mathcal{N}_{I+1}^{+} cannot enter R^{\prime} by 7.4 since it cannot cross {\mathtt{D}}_{0}^{-} . Therefore by the ordering on the \mathcal{S} - and \mathcal{N} -paths, no path can enter the set R^{\prime} other than \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+} itself, and so since the width of R^{\prime} is n^{5/6}/12 we can conclude that we are on the event \mathsf{Onion}(n,n^{5/6}/12,1) . This event has an empty intersection with E by 7.3 . Now, we will use the fact that \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+} does not cross L_{4,E} to rule out the possibility that \mathcal{N}_{I}^{-} crosses L_{E}=L_{5,E} . Consider the region M of the Aztec diamond bounded between the three \mathcal{N} -paths \mathcal{N}_{I}^{-},\mathcal{N}_{I-1}^{-},\mathcal{N}_{I+1}^{+} (including the piece of \mathcal{N}_{I}^{-} after it coalesces with \mathcal{N}_{I}^{+} ). There are two \mathcal{S} -paths that lie within this region: \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+} and \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} , and for every point v\in\partial M , there is an {\mathtt{S}} -vertex in M that is within distance 4 of v . Since we are on the event {\mathtt{Para_{S}}}(\log^{2}n) , there must be a path of south vertices ending on \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+}\cup\mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} which is contained in the connected component of C of (v+P_{\mathtt{S}}^{\log^{2}n+4})\cap M containing v . In other words, C\cap(\mathcal{S}_{I}^{+}\cup\mathcal{S}_{I}^{-})\neq\emptyset . Now, if v\in L_{5,E} , then the only two ways that this can happen are if: • Either \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+} or \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} hits L_{4,E} , or • One of the three paths \mathcal{N}_{I}^{-},\mathcal{N}_{I-1}^{-},\mathcal{N}_{I+1}^{+} hits {\mathtt{C}}_{\times} . The first of these is ruled out by the previous argument, and the second by 7.2 . Therefore \partial M\cap L_{5,E}=\emptyset , and so \mathcal{N}_{I}^{-}\cap L_{5,E}=\emptyset . By a symmetric argument we can ensure that \mathcal{N}_{I}^{+} does not cross L_{4,W} and that \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} does not cross L_{5,W}=L_{W} . Putting these estimates together with the fact that \mathcal{S}_{I}^{+},\mathcal{N}_{I}^{-} do not enter {\mathtt{C}}_{\times} ( 7.2 ) gives the lemma. ∎ Given the path control above, we can confirm that the split point and the central height are related deterministically. This is the final piece of 7.1 . Corollary 7.6 . With probability 1-o(1) , we have H_{n}=4I_{n}-n-1 . Proof. Consider any a -face f , and let \pi=(v_{0},\dots,v_{k}),\qquad v_{k}\in\partial^{\mathtt{x}}{\mathtt{S}} be the path in F_{\mathtt{S}}(D) starting from the {\mathtt{S}} -vertex v_{0}:=f-(0,1) . By Corollary 4.6 , the height \mathcal{H}_{n}(v_{0}) is given by R-L+\mathcal{H}_{n}(v_{k-1}) , where R and L denote the number of right and left turns along the path \pi . We first translate this to a statement about face heights on the event where v_{k} joins the path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} . First, using that the boundary heights in the Aztec diamond are deterministic, we can compute that \mathcal{H}_{n}(v_{k-1})=4I-n-5/2+\mathbf{1}(v_{k}-v_{k-1}=(2,-2)). Also, \mathcal{H}_{n}(v_{0})=\mathcal{H}_{n}(f)+1+2\theta/\pi, where \theta\in(-3\pi/2,\pi/2) is the polar coordinate of the vector v_{1}-v_{0} . Finally, R-L=4\operatorname{Wind}(\pi)-\mathbf{1}(v_{k}-v_{k-1}=(2,-2))+2\theta/\pi+5/2. where \operatorname{Wind}(\pi) is the number of times that the path \pi crosses the vertical ray f+\{0\}\times[0,\infty) moving right-to-left minus the number of times it crosses moving left-to-right. Putting all this together gives that (53) \mathcal{H}_{n}(f)=4\operatorname{Wind}(\pi)+4I-n-1. Now, let f be the a -face closest to the point \beta_{n}(0,n^{3/4}) . To complete the proof, given ( 53 ) it is enough to show that with probability 1-o(1) , we have that • The south forest path \pi started at v_{0}:=m\beta_{n}(0,n^{3/4})-(0,1) joins the backbone path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} , and • \mathcal{H}_{n}(f)=4\operatorname{Wind}(\pi)+H_{n} . We show that the first bullet holds deterministically on the event E from 7.4 . Indeed, the path \pi starts in the set {\mathtt{D}}_{0}^{+} , so by 7.4 , it starts in a region which is above the path \mathcal{S}_{I}^{-} , and so by backbone path ordering, the path \pi cannot join any path \mathcal{S}_{i}^{-},i(2k-1)n^{1/4}\log^{2}n, We define points s_{1}0 , without affecting the result. Remark 9.1 . In the final mesoscopic strengthening of the theorem, the trivial estimate allows us to take suprema and infima over ranges of size \Delta n^{-2/3} , which is the scale on which we see the discrete lattice. Of course, the optimal result in this direction would be uniform convergence to the Airy line ensemble, as discussed in the introduction. Moreover, as with 6.8 , we can strengthen the above theorem to allow the finite sets S,T to vary with n . We could also give a version of the above theorem with \mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}} replaced by \mathcal{H}_{n} , where in the limit we also see i.i.d. copies of the full-plane smooth phase (as in ( 47 )). For brevity, we have omitted these versions. The main step in proving 9.1 is the following proposition. For this proposition and for the remainder of the section, fix a mollifying sequence \phi_{n} satisfying the conditions of 6.8 . For a fixed mesh size \delta>0 , a line index i\in\mathbb{N} and a time t\in\mathbb{R} , define random variables A_{n,\delta}(i,t)=\max\{x\in[-\delta^{-1},\delta^{-1}]\cap\delta\mathbb{Z}:[H_{n}-\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(\hat{\gamma}_{n}(x,t))]/4\geq i-\delta\}, where we set this \max to -\infty if [H_{n}-\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(\hat{\gamma}_{n}(x,t))]/40 , a time t\in\mathbb{R} , and i\in\mathbb{N} . Then \displaystyle\lim_{\delta\to 0}\lim_{n\to\infty}\mathbb{P}(|A_{n,\delta}(i,t)-\sup_{|u|\leq n^{-1/3-\varepsilon}}\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,+}(\cdot+u)|>\sqrt{\delta}) \displaystyle=0, \displaystyle\lim_{\delta\to 0}\lim_{n\to\infty}\mathbb{P}(|A_{n,\delta}(i,t)-\inf_{|u|\leq n^{-1/3-\varepsilon}}\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,-}(\cdot+u)|>\sqrt{\delta}) \displaystyle=0. Before proving 9.2 , we use it to establish 9.1 . Proof of 9.1 . We first note that by Corollary 8.2 , for any fixed i\in\mathbb{N} and t\in\mathbb{R} , we have that \mathbb{P}(|\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,+}(t)-\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,{\mathtt{N}}+}(t)|\geq n^{-1/12}\log^{3}n)\to 0 as n\to\infty , and similarly with +\mapsto- , {\mathtt{N}}+\mapsto{\mathtt{N}}- . Therefore it suffices to prove 9.1 only when *\in\{+,-\} . Next, write \mathcal{B}_{i}^{n,-}(t)=\inf_{|u|\leq n^{-1/3-\varepsilon}}\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,-}(\cdot+u),\qquad\mathcal{B}_{i}^{n,+}=\sup_{|u|\leq n^{-1/3-\varepsilon}}\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,+}(\cdot+u). It furthermore suffices to prove ( 63 ) with \mathcal{B}_{i}^{n,\pm} in place of \mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,\pm} . Now, fix a finite set T\subset\mathbb{R} and a countable dense set Q\subset\mathbb{R} . Using 6.8 and the Skorokhod representation theorem, we can consider a coupling of all of the Aztec diamond measures at each n\in 4\mathbb{N} with the Airy line ensemble so that for any t,q\in Q we have (65) \mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(\hat{\gamma}_{n}(q,t))-H_{n}\to-4\mathcal{A}(q,t) almost surely. It suffices to show that in this coupling, for any fixed i\in\mathbb{N},t\in Q , we have \mathcal{B}_{i}^{n,\pm}(t)\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\mathbb{P}}}{{\to}}\mathcal{A}_{i}(t) . The statement ( 63 ) then follows by taking Q so that S\cup T^{2}\subset Q^{2} . Observe that by ( 65 ), we have \limsup_{n\to\infty}\mathbf{1}(|\mathcal{A}_{i}(t)|\leq\delta^{-1}-1)|A_{n,\delta}(i,t)-\mathcal{A}_{i}(t)|\leq\delta, and so by 9.2 , \limsup_{n\to\infty}\mathbb{P}(|\mathcal{B}_{i}^{n,\pm}(t)-\mathcal{A}_{i}(t)|>\delta+\sqrt{\delta})\leq\mathbb{P}(|\mathcal{A}_{i}(t)|>\delta^{-1}). Since \delta>0 was arbitrary and the random variables \mathcal{A}_{i}(t) are all finite, this gives the desired result. ∎ In the remainder of the section we prove 9.2 . The main part of the proof involves showing that around any fixed point \hat{\gamma}_{n}(x,t) we can define a box O_{\varepsilon}(x,t) size n^{1/3-\varepsilon}\times n^{1/3-\varepsilon} such that with high probability: • No south backbone paths enter the box O_{\varepsilon}(x,t) • We have (66) O_{\varepsilon}(x,t)\subset U(\mathcal{S}_{I_{n}-J})\cap L(\mathcal{S}_{I_{n}-J+1}), where J\approx(H_{n}-\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(\hat{\gamma}_{n}(x,t)))/4. The dimensions of the box O_{\varepsilon}(x,t) are important here. The key point will be that the width of the box is larger than the size of the maximum backtrack of any south backbone path entering the region. The maximum backtrack size is O(n^{1/4}\log^{2}n) by 8.1 . The idea for constructing the box O_{\varepsilon}(x,t) is to use the local smooth phase coupling, 5.5 , to rule out the potential presence of backbone paths. The difficulty with that lemma is that it only provides a coupling on a rectangle of width o(n^{1/12}) , which is too small to make 8.1 effective. The workaround is to first build a ring of overlapping boxes of small size, each of which is individually coupled to the full-plane smooth phase. We build the rings in the next lemma, and then use that lemma together with the path regularity from Section 8 to verify that a box inside this ring satisfies the two bullet points above. Lemma 9.3 . Let D\sim\mathbb{P}_{a,n} , and fix \varepsilon>0,(x,t)\in\mathbb{R}^{2} . For ease of notation, set c_{n}=\log^{3}n . Define the set S_{\varepsilon}=\{v\in\mathbb{Z}^{2}:\|v\|_{1}=\lfloor n^{1/3-\varepsilon}\rfloor\}, and for v\in S_{\varepsilon} let B_{v}=\hat{\gamma}_{n}(x,t)+c_{n}(v+[-3/5,3/5]^{2}). Then with probability 1-o(1) , the following claims hold: (i) We can couple D with |S_{\varepsilon}| -many copies of the smooth phase D_{v}\sim\mathbb{P}_{a},v\in S_{\varepsilon} such D_{v}|_{B_{v}}=D|_{B_{v}},\qquad\text{ for all }v\in S_{\varepsilon}. (ii) In each of the smooth phases D_{v},v\in S_{\varepsilon} , any path \pi in the associated south forest, started at a point in D_{v} , satisfies \pi\subset P^{\log^{2}n}_{\mathtt{S}}. Similarly, any path \pi in the associated north forest, started at a point in D_{v} , satisfies \pi\subset P^{\log^{2}n}_{\mathtt{N}}. (iii) Let T=\bigcup_{v\in S_{\varepsilon}}B_{v} , let \partial^{-}T be the part of the boundary of T connected to the bounded component U^{-} of T^{c} , and let \partial^{+}T be the part of the boundary of T connected to the unbounded component U^{+} of T^{c} . Consider any north or south backbone path \pi , and let \pi_{0}:[s,t]\to\mathbb{R} be a segment of \pi with \pi_{0}|_{(s,t)} contained in the interior of T , and \pi_{0}(s),\pi_{0}(t) on the boundary of T . Then: • If \pi is a south backbone path, \pi_{0}(s)\in\partial T^{+} and \pi_{0}(t)\in\partial T^{-} , then \pi_{0}(s) is contained in a box B_{v} with v_{2}\geq 1 . • If \pi is a south backbone path, \pi_{0}(s)\in\partial T^{-} and \pi_{0}(t)\in\partial T^{+} , then \pi_{0}(s) is contained in a box B_{v} with v_{2}\leq-1 . • If \pi is a north backbone path, \pi_{0}(s)\in\partial T^{+} and \pi_{0}(t)\in\partial T^{-} , then \pi_{0}(s) is contained in a box B_{v} with v_{2}\leq-1 . • If \pi is a north backbone path, \pi_{0}(s)\in\partial T^{-} and \pi_{0}(t)\in\partial T^{+} , then \pi_{0}(s) is contained in a box B_{v} with v_{2}\geq 1 . Figure 23 . The setup of 9.3 , together with the proof of (iii) given (ii). Essentially, the smooth phase couplings in part (ii) force strong drifts through the ring of boxes \{B_{v},v\in S_{\varepsilon}\} . This means \mathcal{S} -paths can only enter through a box in the top half of the ring, and exit through a box in the bottom, whereas the opposite is true for \mathcal{N} -paths. Proof. By 5.5 and a union bound bound over |S_{\varepsilon}| -many boxes, we can achieve all of the couplings in part (i) simultaneously with probability at least 1-c|S_{\varepsilon}|n^{-1/3}\log^{24}n\geq 1-cn^{-\varepsilon/2}, where the constant c depends on x,t , and the inequality holds for large enough n . The parabolic path control in part (ii) follows from 5.8 and a union bound, using that paths in the smooth phase forests are loop-erased random walks. Part (iii) is deterministic given part (ii). See Figure 23 for an illustration. We only prove the claim about south backbone paths, as the claim about north backbone paths follows symmetrically. Consider a given path segment \pi_{0} , let B_{v} be a box that \pi_{0} intersects, and let \tau:[s^{\prime},t^{\prime}]\to\mathbb{R} be a segment of \pi_{0} contained in B_{v} . If we define \tilde{\tau}:[s^{\prime},t^{\prime}]\to[-1,1]^{2} by letting \displaystyle\tau(r)=\hat{\gamma}_{n}(x,t)+c_{n}(v+\tilde{\tau}(r)), then by part (ii), for large enough n we have that for any r0 and define a set O_{\varepsilon}=O_{\varepsilon}(x,t)=\hat{\gamma}_{n}(x,t)+[-n^{1/3-\varepsilon},n^{1/3-\varepsilon}]^{2}. Then with probability 1-o(1) , no backbone paths of the form \mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-},\mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-},k\in\{0,\dots,\lfloor\log^{50}n\rfloor\} enter the set O_{\varepsilon} . Figure 24 . The proof setup for 9.4 . Proof. Fix \varepsilon\in(0,1/12) , and consider the probability (1-o(1)) -event where points (i)-(iii) of 9.3 hold with \varepsilon and points 1,2 or Corollary 8.2 hold. On this event, we will show that deterministically, no backbone paths of the form \mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-},\mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-},k\in\{0,\dots,\lfloor\log^{50}n\rfloor\} enter the set O_{2\varepsilon} as long as n is sufficiently large. Fix k\in\{0,\dots,\lfloor\log^{50}n\rfloor-1\} and suppose that \mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-} enters the set O_{2\varepsilon} . Let T,\partial^{\pm}T,U^{\pm} be as in 9.3 . The set O_{2\varepsilon} is contained in U^{-} , and moreover, every point in T is L^{\infty} -distance at least n^{1/3-\varepsilon}>n^{1/4}\log^{100}n away from O_{2\varepsilon} . In particular, by Corollary 8.2 , the path \mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-} must also enter the set U^{-} . This path also stays in the set L(\mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-}) . Now, let R be a connected component of L(\mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-})\cap(T\cup U^{-}) such that R\cap U^{-}\neq\emptyset . We aim to show that \mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-} cannot enter R\cap U^{-} , which will complete the proof since R is arbitrary. The proof setup is illustrated in Figure 24 . The boundary of R can be decomposed into two pieces: • \partial_{1}R , which is given by a path segment \mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-}|_{[s,t]} , where \mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-}|_{(s,t)} is contained in the interior of T\cup U^{-} and \mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-}(s),\mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-}(t)\in\partial^{+}T . • \partial_{2}R , which is a closed connected subset of \partial^{+}T between the points \mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-}(s) and \mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-}(t) . We view \partial_{2}R as a parametrized simple curve \pi:[s,t]\to\mathbb{R} and choose the parametrization so that \mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-}(s)=\pi(s),\qquad\mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-}(t)=\pi(t), and so that \pi is one-to-one. Now at this point, suppose \mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-} intersects the set R\cap U^{-} , and let \mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-}|_{[s^{\prime},t^{\prime}]} be a segment of \mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-} such that: 1. \mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-}|_{[s^{\prime},t^{\prime}]} is contained in R , and intersects the set U^{-} . 2. \mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-}(s^{\prime}),\mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-}(t^{\prime}) are on the boundary \partial^{+}T . 3. t^{\prime} is chosen maximally among all choices of s^{\prime},t^{\prime} satisfying 1,2 . Now, by the first two bullet points in 9.3 (iii), there exists v,w\in S_{\varepsilon} such that \mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-}(s)\in B_{v},\qquad\mathcal{S}_{I-k}^{-}(t)\in B_{w},\;\;\;\text{ and }v_{1}\geq 1,\;\;w_{1}\leq-1, and by the third and fourth bullet points in 9.3 (iii), there exists v^{\prime},w^{\prime}\in S_{\varepsilon} such that \mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-}(s^{\prime})\in B_{v^{\prime}},\qquad\mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-}(t^{\prime})\in B_{w^{\prime}},\;\;\;\text{ and }v_{1}^{\prime}\leq-1,\;\;w_{1}^{\prime}\geq 1. Now let r_{1},r_{2}\in(s,t) be such that \mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-}(s^{\prime})=\pi(r_{1}) and \mathcal{N}_{I-k-1}^{-}(s^{\prime})=\pi(r_{2}) . From the previous two displays, we have that s0 was arbitrary, the lemma follows. ∎ Our next goal is to prove ( 66 ). To do so, we first need an estimate on the minimum index of a path that enters a region near O_{\varepsilon}(x,t) . For this lemma, we will need to work with the scaling map \tilde{\beta}_{n} used in 6.7 , introduced at the beginning of Section 6 . Lemma 9.5 . Fix L>0 , and consider the region {\mathtt{A}}_{L}=\tilde{\beta}_{n}([-L,L]\times[-L,\log^{3}n]). Define K(L)=\max\{i\in\mathbb{N}:\mathcal{S}_{I-i}^{-}\text{ or }\mathcal{N}_{I-i}^{-}\text{ enters the region }{\mathtt{A}}_{L}\}. Then \mathbb{P}(K(L)\leq\log^{4}n)=1-o(1). Proof. First, with notation as in 7.1 , let K denote the connected component of {\mathtt{A}}_{L}\cup[({\mathtt{X}}\cup{\mathtt{PRS}}^{*}_{n})\setminus{\mathtt{RS}}^{*}_{n}] containing {\mathtt{A}}_{L} . The set K is connected to the boundary of the Aztec diamond at the point (n+1,-n-1) . Therefore by path ordering, if a north or south backbone path with index I-i,i>\log^{4}n enters the region {\mathtt{A}}_{L} , then the same must be true of the path \mathcal{N}_{I-\lfloor\log^{4}n\rfloor}^{-} . By Part (3) of 7.1 , this path can only enter the region K through {\mathtt{A}}_{L} . Moreover, since K is connected to the Aztec diamond boundary, if it enters the region {\mathtt{A}}_{L} , it first enters without winding around that region, and so its entry height is within 4 of its initial height ( 4.5 ). Now, by parts 1 and 6 of 7.1 , we have that |I_{n}-n/4|\leq\log n with probability 1-o(1) , and so I_{n}-\lfloor\log^{4}n\rfloor\leq n/4-\log^{4}n/2 . By the relationship between path index and starting height, the starting height of the path \mathcal{N}_{I-\lfloor\log^{4}n\rfloor}^{-} is bounded above by -\log^{4}n . Therefore to complete the proof, it suffices to show that X=\min\{\mathcal{H}_{n}(x):x\in{\mathtt{A}}_{L}\} is bounded below by -\log^{4}n/2 with probability 1-o(1) . We have that X\geq X_{0}-X_{1}-X_{2} , where \displaystyle X_{0} \displaystyle=\mathcal{H}_{n}(0,0) \displaystyle X_{1} \displaystyle=\max\{|\mathcal{H}_{n}(0,0)-\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}(t,\log^{3}n)|:t\in[-L,L]\}, \displaystyle X_{2} \displaystyle=\max\{|\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}(t,\log^{3}n)-\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}(t,x)|:t\in[-L,L],x\in[-L,\log^{3}n]\}, and \tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}=\mathcal{H}_{n}\circ\tilde{\beta}_{n} . First, X_{0} converges in law as n\to\infty by 5.2 and so X_{0}\geq-\log^{4}n/6 with probability 1-o(1) . Next, as in the proof of 6.6 we can couple a dimer configuration D\sim\mathbb{P}_{a,n} with two copies of the smooth phase measure D_{1},D_{2}\sim\mathbb{P}_{a} using Lemmas 5.6 , 5.7 so that with probability 1-o(1) we have D_{i}|_{\Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},i}}=D|_{\Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},i}} for i=1,2 . On the event where this coupling succeeds, using bounds on heights in the smooth phase ( 5.10 ), we have that \max\{|\mathcal{H}_{n}(v)-\mathcal{H}_{n}(0,0)|:v\in\Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},1}\cup\Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},2}\}\leq\log n with probability 1-o(1) , and so X_{1}\leq\log^{4}n/6 with probability 1-o(1) . Finally, we show that X_{2}\leq\log^{4}n/6 with probability 1-o(1) . To prove this, by Markov’s inequality and a union bound over the O(n\log^{3}n) -many lattice points in {\mathtt{A}}_{L} , it is enough to show that we can find \lambda>0 such that (68) \sup_{(t,x)\in[-L,L]\times[-L,\log^{3}n]}\mathbb{E}\exp(\lambda|\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}(t,\log^{3}n)-\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}(t,x)|)\leq\exp(\log^{3}n) for all large enough n . Suppose that ( 68 ) fails. Then for all \lambda>0 , we can find sequences t_{n,\lambda}\in[-L,L],x_{n,\lambda}\in[-L,\log^{3}n] such that \mathbb{E}\exp(\lambda|\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}(t_{n,\lambda},\log^{3}n)-\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}(t_{n,\lambda},x_{n,\lambda})|)\geq\exp(\log^{3}n) for all n in some infinite set Y_{\lambda} . We can apply diagonalization argument here to find t_{n},x_{n},n\in Y that works simultaneously for all \lambda>0 , and then by passing to a further subsequence Y^{\prime}\subset Y we may assume that t_{n}\to t\in[-L,L] and that x_{n}\to x\in[-L,\infty] . Now, letting \phi_{n}=\{2\lfloor\ell\log^{2}n\rfloor e_{2}:\ell\in\{0,\dots,\lfloor\log^{1/2}n\rfloor\}\}, then \lim_{n\in Y^{\prime}}\mathbb{E}\exp(\lambda|\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(t_{n},\log^{3}n)-\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(t_{n},x_{n})|)=\infty. for all \lambda>0 . This contradicts 6.7 . ∎ We now precisely state and prove ( 66 ). Lemma 9.6 . Fix (x,t)\in\mathbb{R}^{2},\varepsilon>0 , and let O_{\varepsilon}(x,t) be as in 9.4 . Let \phi_{n} be any mollifying sequence satisfying the conditions of 6.8 . Then there exists a sequence \sigma_{n} which tends to 0 with n (and depends on \phi_{n},x,t ) such that with probability 1-o(1) , we have that (69) O_{\varepsilon}(x,t)\subset U(\mathcal{S}_{I_{n}-J})\cap L(\mathcal{S}_{I_{n}-J+1}), where |J-(H_{n}-\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(\hat{\gamma}_{n}(x,t)))/4|<\sigma_{n}. In the special case when this forces J=0 , we remove the intersection with L(\mathcal{S}_{I_{n}-J+1}) . Proof. All statements in the proof will hold with probability 1-o(1) , and we do not mention this further. We may also assume \varepsilon<1/12 , and for ease of notation we set u=\hat{\gamma}_{n}(x,t) . First, with notation as in 9.5 , the set {\mathtt{A}}_{|t|+1} has at most \log^{4}n south backbone paths that enter it: \mathcal{S}_{I-i}^{-} , i=0,\dots,\lfloor\log^{4}n\rfloor . Here the upper bound on i is from 9.5 , and the fact that no \mathcal{S}^{+} -paths and no paths of the form \mathcal{S}_{I+i},i>0 enter this region uses 7.1 , parts 4 and 5, along with north and south path interlacing. Next, by 9.4 , none of the paths \mathcal{S}|_{I-i}^{-} , i=0,\dots,\lfloor\log^{4}n\rfloor enter the sets O_{\varepsilon}=O_{\varepsilon}(x,t) . Therefore there exists some index J such that ( 69 ) holds (where again, we omit the intersection with L(\mathcal{S}_{I_{n}-J+1}) if J=0 ). It remains to show that J=(H_{n}-\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(u)/4 . For this, consider the south forest path \pi:[0,t]\to\mathbb{R}^{2} started at the south vertex adjacent to the a -face u , and let \pi(s)\in{\mathtt{S}} denote the location when \pi either first coalesces with a backbone path or exits the set {\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} . Note that \pi(0)\in U(\mathcal{S}_{I-\lfloor\log^{4}n\rfloor-1}^{-}) since \mathcal{S}_{I-\lfloor\log^{4}n\rfloor-1}^{-} does not enter the set {\mathtt{A}}_{|t|+1} or the set ({\mathtt{X}}\cup{\mathtt{PRS}}^{*}_{n})\setminus{\mathtt{RS}}^{*}_{n} (the latter uses Part (3) of 7.1 ). We first show that \pi(s) is a coalescence point. Indeed, by the parabolic path estimate in Part (2) of 7.1 , if \pi(s) were in {\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} , then it would be located on the lower boundary of {\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} , at a point in the interior of {\mathtt{PRS}}^{*}_{n} . In particular, in this case the set T=\pi|_{[0,s]}\cup[({\mathtt{X}}\cup{\mathtt{PRS}}^{*}_{n})\setminus{\mathtt{RS}}^{*}_{n}]\cup{\mathtt{A}}_{|t|+1} is connected, and [-n-1,n+1]^{2}\setminus T puts the south and west boundaries of the Aztec diamond in different components. As discussed above, the path \mathcal{S}_{I-\lfloor\log^{4}n\rfloor-1}^{-} does not enter T , which contradicts that this path moves from the south to the west boundary. Therefore \pi(s) is a coalescence point. Moreover, since south forest paths enter O_{\varepsilon} , \pi(s) is not located in O_{\varepsilon} , and again using the parabolic path estimate in Part (2) of 7.1 together with the fact that the height of {\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} is less than 2n^{1/2}\log^{3/2}n , we have that \pi(s)\in{\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*}\cap(u+[-n^{1/3-\varepsilon}/100,n^{1/3-\varepsilon}/100]\times(-\infty,-n^{1/3-\varepsilon}]). Here we have used that \varepsilon<1/12 to absorb the width of the parabola P^{\log^{2}n}_{\mathtt{S}} as it intersects {\mathtt{RS}}_{n}^{*} (this width is O(n^{1/4}\log^{3/4}n) ). Now, let \mathcal{S}_{I-K},K\in\{0,\dots,\lfloor\log^{4}n\rfloor+1\} be the path containing \pi(s) . Arguing deterministically as in the proof of ( 53 ) in Corollary 7.6 , we have that \mathcal{H}_{n}(u)=4\operatorname{Wind}(\pi)+4(I-K)-n-1, and so by Part (6) of 7.1 we have that H_{n}-\mathcal{H}_{n}(u)=-4\operatorname{Wind}(\pi)+4K. Now, by 5.5 we can couple our dimer configuration D_{n}\sim\mathbb{P}_{a,n} with a dimer configuration D\sim\mathbb{P}_{a} such that the two agree on the set u+[-b_{n},b_{n}]^{2} , where n^{1/100}\leq b_{n}=o(n^{1/24}) and \phi_{n}\subset[-b_{n},b_{n}]^{2} . Let \mathcal{H} be the height function for D , and let \pi_{0} be the south forest path in D started at \pi(0) . On the event where this coupling holds, we have that \mathcal{H}_{n}(u)-\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(u)=\mathcal{H}(u)-\mathcal{H}^{\phi_{n}}(u)=4\operatorname{Wind}(\pi_{0})+o(1). Here the final equality uses 4.11 , and the o(1) term goes to 0 in probability as n\to\infty (by Corollary 4.12 , 5.10 ). Therefore to complete the proof, we must show that \operatorname{Wind}(\pi_{0})=\operatorname{Wind}(\pi) with high probability. First, \pi_{0} will not cross vertical line V=u+\{0\}\times[0,\infty) after it first exits the box u+[-b_{n},b_{n}]^{2} with high probability by the parabolic path estimate in 5.8 . Up until this point, \pi_{0} and \pi agree. Similarly, \pi will not cross V after it exits this box and before it joins the backbone path \mathcal{S}_{I-K}^{-} . Next, if \mathcal{S}_{I-K}^{-} were to cross V within the set {\mathtt{RS}}_{n} , then it would have a backtrack of size at least n^{1/3-\varepsilon}/2 , since it cannot enter the set O_{\varepsilon} . Since \varepsilon<1/12 , this would contradict 8.1 . Therefore the barrier estimate in Part (3) of 7.1 guarantees that the number of left-to-right crossings of the line V by \mathcal{S}_{I-K}^{-} equals the number of right-to-left crossings, which finally implies that \operatorname{Wind}(\pi_{0})=\operatorname{Wind}(\pi) , as desired. ∎ At last, we are ready to prove 9.2 . Proof of 9.2 . Fix \varepsilon\in(0,1/12),\delta\in(0,1/2) , and let Z_{\delta}=[-\delta^{-1},\delta^{-1}]\cap\delta\mathbb{Z}. Define M:Z_{\delta}\to\mathbb{N} so that M(x) is the nearest integer to the point [H_{n}-\mathcal{H}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(\hat{\gamma}_{n}(x,t))]/4 , and define J^{\pm}:Z_{\delta}\to\mathbb{N} so that \displaystyle J^{-}(x)=\min\{i=0,1,\dots:O_{\varepsilon}(x,t)\subset U(\mathcal{S}_{I_{n}-i})\neq\emptyset\}, \displaystyle J^{+}(x)=\max\{i=1,\dots:O_{\varepsilon}(x,t)\subset L(\mathcal{S}_{I_{n}-i+1})\neq\emptyset\}, where in the definition of J^{+} , we set the maximum to 0 if the set above is empty. By 9.6 , J^{-}=J^{+} and |J^{-}-M|<\sigma_{n} with probability 1-o(1) for a sequence \sigma_{n}\to 0 with n . Now, by the backtrack estimate in 8.1 and the fact that the width of O_{\varepsilon}(x,t) is of order n^{1/3-\varepsilon},\varepsilon<1/12 , the following implications hold simultaneously with probability 1-o(1) for all i\in\{0,\dots,\log n\},x\in Z_{\delta} : \displaystyle O_{\varepsilon}(x,t) \displaystyle\subset U(\mathcal{S}_{I_{n}+1-i})\quad\implies\quad\sup_{|u|\leq n^{-1/3-2\varepsilon}}\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,+}(t+u)x. At this point, we fix i and work deterministically on the event where the above implications hold, J^{-}=J^{+} , and |J^{-}-M|<\sigma_{n} for \sigma_{n}<\delta . On this event, the two implications above give that (70) \displaystyle\sup_{|u|\leq n^{-1/3-2\varepsilon}}\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,+}(t+u) \displaystyle<\min\{x\in Z_{\delta}:J^{-}\leq i-1\}, (71) \displaystyle\inf_{|u|\leq n^{-1/3-2\varepsilon}}\mathcal{A}_{i}^{n,-}(t+u) \displaystyle>\max\{x\in Z_{\delta}:J^{+}\geq i\}, where the right-hand side of ( 70 ) equals -\infty if the set is empty, and the right-hand side of ( 71 ) equals -\infty if that set is empty. Using that J^{-}=J^{+} and |J^{-}-M|<\sigma_{n}<\delta then implies (72) A_{n,\delta}(i,t)=\max\{x\in Z_{\delta}:J^{+}\geq i\}=\min\{x\in Z_{\delta}:J^{-}\leq i-1\}-\delta on the event E=\{|A_{n,\delta}(i,t)|\leq\delta^{-1}-1\} . The final event E holds with probability 1-o(1) as we first take n\to\infty and then take \delta\to 0 , since in this double limit, A_{n,\delta}(i,t) converges in law to \mathcal{A}_{i}(t) , which is a finite almost surely. Combining ( 70 ), ( 71 ), and ( 72 ) gives the proposition. ∎ 10. Correlation Kernel and Estimates In this section, we introduce the Kasteleyn matrix as well as the relevance of its inverse. We give a formula for the entries of the inverse of the Kasteleyn matrix of the two-periodic Aztec diamond, as well as formulas which serve as a starting point for taking asymptotics of these entries. These results are refinements of the ones in [ CJ16 ] , and are proved in Section 14 . 10.1. Inverse Kasteleyn matrix for the two-periodic Aztec diamond Suppose that G is a planar weighted bipartite graph. Recall that the Kasteleyn matrix, K , of the graph G is a type of signed weighted adjacency matrix whose rows are indexed by the black vertices and whose columns are indexed by the white vertices of the graph, see [ Joh18 , Section 3] for more background. The importance of the Kasteleyn matrix is due to the following theorem. Here the underlying dimer measure assigns a dimer configurations a probability proportional to the product of edge weights. Theorem 10.1 ( [ Ken97 , Joh18 ] ) . Suppose that E=\{\mathtt{e}_{i}\}_{i=1}^{r} is a collection of distinct edges on G with \mathtt{e}_{i}=(\mathtt{b}_{i},\mathtt{w}_{i}) , where \mathtt{b}_{i} and \mathtt{w}_{i} denote black and white vertices. The dimer configuration forms a determinantal point process on the edges of G with correlation kernel L meaning that the probability of observing edges e_{1},\dots,e_{r} is given by \det L(\mathtt{e}_{i},\mathtt{e}_{j})_{1\leq i,j\leq r} where L(\mathtt{e}_{i},\mathtt{e}_{j})=K({\mathtt{b}_{i},\mathtt{w}_{i}})K^{-1}({\mathtt{w}_{j},\mathtt{b}_{i}}). More general versions of this theorem hold, but we do not need these here. The Kasteleyn matrix K_{a,b} for the two-periodic Aztec diamond where a -faces and b -faces have weight a,b>0 takes entries (73) \begin{split}&K_{a,b}(x,y)\\ &=\left\{\begin{array}[]{ll}(b(1-j)+aj)(1-k)\mathrm{i}+(bj+a(1-j))k&\mbox{if }y=x+(-1)^{j}e_{k+1},x\in\mathtt{E},\\ (b(1-j)+aj)k+(bj+a(1-j))(1-k)\mathrm{i}&\mbox{if }y=x+(-1)^{j}e_{k+1},x\in\mathtt{W},\\ 0&\mbox{if $(x,y)$ is not an edge.}\end{array}\right.\end{split} where \mathrm{i}^{2}=-1 and j,k\in\{0,1\} . Here we only need to consider K_{a,1} . For historical reasons, e.g. see [ CJ16 ] , we set n=4m for m\in\mathbb{N} , where n is the size of the Aztec diamond, and will use this convention throughout and interchange between n and m for convenience. We now proceed in stating formulas needed to give a suitable form for K^{-1}_{a,1} as well as its asymptotics. Let \tilde{c}(u_{1},u_{2})=2(1+a^{2})+a(u_{1}+u_{1}^{-1})(u_{2}+u_{2}^{-1}), which is related to the so-called characteristic polynomial for the dimer model [ KOS06 ] ; see [ CJ16 , (4.11)] for an explanation. Write (74) h(\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2})=\varepsilon_{1}(1-\varepsilon_{2})+\varepsilon_{2}(1-\varepsilon_{1}), and let \Gamma_{R} denote a positively oriented circle of radius R around the origin, where we adopt this notation for the rest of the paper. In what follows below, we set \mathtt{W}_{0}=\mathtt{S} , \mathtt{W}_{1}=\mathtt{N} , \mathtt{B}_{0}=\mathtt{W} , and \mathtt{B}_{1}=\mathtt{E} , along with the full-plane analogs using \tilde{\mathtt{W}}_{0} , etc. The full-plane smooth phase inverse Kasteleyn matrix is given by \mathbb{K}^{-1}_{1,1}(x,y)=-\frac{\mathrm{i}^{1+h(\varepsilon_{x},\varepsilon_{y})}}{(2\pi\mathrm{i})^{2}}\int_{\Gamma_{1}}\frac{du_{1}}{u_{1}}\int_{\Gamma_{1}}\frac{du_{2}}{u_{2}}\frac{a^{\varepsilon_{y}}u_{2}^{1-h(\varepsilon_{x},\varepsilon_{y})}+a^{1-\varepsilon_{y}}u_{1}u_{2}^{h(\varepsilon_{x},\varepsilon_{y})}}{\tilde{c}(u_{1},u_{2})u_{1}^{\frac{x_{1}-y_{1}+1}{2}}u_{2}^{\frac{x_{2}-y_{2}+1}{2}}}, where x=(x_{1},x_{2})\in\tilde{\mathtt{W}}_{\varepsilon_{x}} and y=(y_{1},y_{2})\in\tilde{\mathtt{B}}_{\varepsilon_{y}} with \varepsilon_{x},\varepsilon_{y}\in\{0,1\} ; see [ CJ16 , Section 4] for details and connections with [ KOS06 ] . Define \sqrt{\omega^{2}+2c}=e^{\frac{1}{2}\log(\omega+\mathrm{i}\sqrt{2c})+\frac{1}{2}\log(\omega-\mathrm{i}\sqrt{2c})} for \omega\in\mathbb{C}\backslash\mathrm{i}[-\sqrt{2c},\sqrt{2c}] , where the logarithm in the exponent has arguments in (-\pi/2,3\pi/2) . This is the same choice of branch cut given in [ CJ16 ] . For s\in\mathbb{Z} , define (75) F_{s}(w)=\frac{1}{2\pi\mathrm{i}}\int_{\Gamma_{1}}\frac{u^{s}}{1+a^{2}+aw(u+u^{-1})}\frac{\mathrm{d}u}{u}. Introduce (76) G(\omega)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2c}}(\omega-\sqrt{\omega^{2}+2c}) where c=a/(1+a^{2}) and let (77) \mu(u)=1-\sqrt{1+c^{2}(u-u^{-1})^{2}}\hskip 14.22636pt\mbox{ and }s(u)=1-\mu(u) with the sign chosen so that G(1/\omega)=-\mu(-u\mathrm{i})/(c(u+u^{-1}))\mathrm{i} if we set u\mathrm{i}=G(\omega) . With the choice of branch cut, we have \sqrt{(-w)^{2}+2c}=-\sqrt{w^{2}+2c} and so G(-\omega)=-G(\omega) and for t\in(\sqrt{2c},1/\sqrt{2c}) , \begin{split}\sqrt{(\mathrm{i}t)^{2}+2c}&=\mathrm{i}\sqrt{t^{2}-2c}\hskip 14.22636pt\mbox{and}\\ \hskip 14.22636pt\sqrt{\frac{1}{(\mathrm{i}t)^{2}}+2c}&=\sqrt{(-\mathrm{i}\frac{1}{t})^{2}+2c}=-\mathrm{i}\sqrt{t^{-2}-2c}.\end{split} With this in mind, we use the notation (78) \theta(t)=\frac{t}{\sqrt{t^{2}-2c}}\hskip 14.22636pt\mbox{for}\hskip 14.22636ptt\in(\sqrt{2c},1/\sqrt{2c}). We now bring forward the following theorem from [ CJ16 ] , which is the formula for K^{-1}_{a,1} for the two-periodic Aztec diamond. Theorem 10.2 (Theorem 2.3 in [ CJ16 ] ) . For n=4m , x=(x_{1},x_{2})\in\mathtt{W}_{\varepsilon_{1}} and y=(y_{1},y_{2})\in\mathtt{B}_{\varepsilon_{2}} with \varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}\in\{0,1\} , the entries of K^{-1}_{a,1} are given by \begin{split}&K_{a,1}^{-1}(x,y)=\mathbb{K}^{-1}_{1,1}(x,y)-\Big(\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})\\ &-\frac{\mathrm{i}}{a}(-1)^{\varepsilon_{1}+\varepsilon_{2}}\big(\mathcal{B}_{1-\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(1/a,n-x_{1},n+x_{2},n-y_{1},n+y_{2})\\ &+\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},1-\varepsilon_{2}}(1/a,n+x_{1},n-x_{2},n+y_{1},n-y_{2})\big)\\ &+\mathcal{B}_{1-\varepsilon_{1},1-\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n-x_{1},n-x_{2},n-y_{1},n-y_{2})\Big),\end{split} where for a0 an let \Gamma_{\omega_{c}} be the contour \Gamma_{\omega_{c}}\,:\,[\theta_{c},\pi-\theta_{c}]\cup[\pi+\theta_{c},2\pi-\theta_{c}]\ni\theta\to r_{c}e^{\mathrm{i}\theta}. For x=(x_{1},x_{2})\in\mathtt{W}_{\varepsilon_{1}} and y=(y_{1},y_{2})\in\mathtt{B}_{\varepsilon_{2}} we define (86) C_{\omega_{c}}(x,y)=\frac{\mathrm{i}^{(x_{2}-x_{1}+y_{1}-y_{2})/2}}{2\pi\mathrm{i}}\int_{\Gamma_{\omega_{c}}}V_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(\omega,\omega)G(\omega)^{\frac{y_{1}-x_{1}-1}{2}}G(\omega^{-1})^{\frac{x_{2}-y_{2}-1}{2}}\frac{\mathrm{d}\omega}{\omega}. The following lemma collects asymptotics for K^{-1}_{a,1}(x,y) when the points x,y are close to the diagonal in the third quadrant. It gives a starting point for the asymptotic analysis of K^{-1}_{a,1} given in this paper. It is pieced together from various statements in [ CJ16 ] , which we gather in a short proof in Section 14 . Note that we do not need an explicit form for S(x,y) given below, only what is listed below. We have kept the notation, up to a shift, similar to that used in [ CJ16 ] . Lemma 10.3 . For x=(x_{1},x_{2})=(\lfloor 4m\eta_{1}\rfloor+\overline{x}_{1},\lfloor 4m\eta_{1}\rfloor+\overline{x}_{2})\in\mathtt{W}_{\varepsilon_{1}} and y=(y_{1},y_{2})=(\lfloor 4m\eta_{2}\rfloor+\overline{y}_{1},\lfloor 4m\eta_{2}\rfloor+\overline{y}_{2})\in\mathtt{B}_{\varepsilon_{2}} with \varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}\in\{0,1\} where -1<\eta_{1},\eta_{2}<0 and |\overline{x}_{1}|,|\overline{x}_{2}|,|\overline{y}_{1}|,|\overline{y}_{2}|\leq Cm^{5/6} for some C>0 constant, we have for a constant \mathtt{c}>0 (87) K^{-1}_{a,1}(x,y)=\mathbb{K}^{-1}_{1,1}(x,y)-\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,x+(n,n),y+(n,n))+O(e^{-\mathtt{c}n}) where (88) \begin{split}&\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})=\frac{\mathrm{i}^{\frac{x_{2}-x_{1}+y_{1}-y_{2}}{2}}}{(2\pi\mathrm{i})^{2}}\int_{\Gamma_{p}}\frac{\mathrm{d}\omega_{1}}{\omega_{1}}\int_{\Gamma_{1/p}}\mathrm{d}\omega_{2}\\ &\times\frac{V_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(\omega_{1},\omega_{2})}{\omega_{2}-\omega_{1}}\frac{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{1})}{H_{y_{1},y_{2}+1}(\omega_{2})}\end{split} where V_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(\omega_{1},\omega_{2}) is given in ( 81 ). Moreover, we have (89) \mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,x+(n,n),y+(n,n))=C_{1}(x,y)+\tilde{\mathcal{B}}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,x+(n,n),y+(n,n)) where for \sqrt{2c}-1 or x_{2}-y_{2}>-1 . Also, if f\in\{\pm e_{1},\pm e_{2}\} and x\in\mathtt{W}_{\varepsilon_{1}} , then S(x,x+f)\not=0 only if f=e_{2} and then S(x,x+e_{2})=-\mathrm{i}a^{\varepsilon_{1}-1} . Finally, we need the following lemma, which contains versions of the asymptotic equation ( 87 ) when the points x,y are close to the anti-diagonal or close to the diagonal in quadrants 1 . It is again essentially contained in [ CJ16 ] , and we give a brief proof in Section 14 . Lemma 10.4 . For x=(x_{1},x_{2})=(-\lfloor 4m\eta_{1}\rfloor+\overline{x}_{1},\lfloor 4m\eta_{1}\rfloor+\overline{x}_{2})\in\mathtt{W}_{\varepsilon_{1}} and y=(y_{1},y_{2})=(-\lfloor 4m\eta_{2}\rfloor+\overline{y}_{1},\lfloor 4m\eta_{2}\rfloor+\overline{y}_{2})\in\mathtt{B}_{\varepsilon_{2}} with \varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}\in\{0,1\} where -1<\eta_{1},\eta_{2}<0 and |\overline{x}_{1}|,|\overline{x}_{2}|,|\overline{y}_{1}|,|\overline{y}_{2}|\leq Cm^{5/6} for some constant C>0 , we have for a constant \mathtt{c}>0 K^{-1}_{a,1}(x,y)=\mathbb{K}^{-1}_{1,1}(x,y)+\frac{\mathrm{i}}{a}(-1)^{\varepsilon_{1}+\varepsilon_{2}}\mathcal{B}_{1-\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n-x_{1},n+x_{2},n-y_{1},n+y_{2})+O(e^{-\mathtt{c}n}). For x=(x_{1},x_{2})=(\lfloor 4m\eta_{1}\rfloor+\overline{x}_{1},-\lfloor 4m\eta_{1}\rfloor+\overline{x}_{2})\in\mathtt{W}_{\varepsilon_{1}} and y=(y_{1},y_{2})=(\lfloor 4m\eta_{2}\rfloor+\overline{y}_{1},-\lfloor 4m\eta_{2}\rfloor+\overline{y}_{2})\in\mathtt{B}_{\varepsilon_{2}} with \varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}\in\{0,1\} where -1<\eta_{1},\eta_{2}<0 and |\overline{x}_{1}|,|\overline{x}_{2}|,|\overline{y}_{1}|,|\overline{y}_{2}|\leq Cm^{5/6} for some constant C>0 , we have for a constant \mathtt{c}>0 K^{-1}_{a,1}(x,y)=\mathbb{K}^{-1}_{1,1}(x,y)+\frac{\mathrm{i}}{a}(-1)^{\varepsilon_{1}+\varepsilon_{2}}\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},1-\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n-x_{2},n+y_{1},n-y_{2})+O(e^{-\mathtt{c}n}). For x=(x_{1},x_{2})=(-\lfloor 4m\eta_{1}\rfloor+\overline{x}_{1},-\lfloor 4m\eta_{1}\rfloor+\overline{x}_{2})\in\mathtt{W}_{\varepsilon_{1}} and y=(y_{1},y_{2})=(-\lfloor 4m\eta_{2}\rfloor+\overline{y}_{1},-\lfloor 4m\eta_{2}\rfloor+\overline{y}_{2})\in\mathtt{B}_{\varepsilon_{2}} with \varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}\in\{0,1\} where -1<\eta_{1},\eta_{2}<0 and |\overline{x}_{1}|,|\overline{x}_{2}|,|\overline{y}_{1}|,|\overline{y}_{2}|\leq Cm^{5/6} for some constant C>0 , we have for a constant \mathtt{c}>0 K^{-1}_{a,1}(x,y)=\mathbb{K}^{-1}_{1,1}(x,y)-\mathcal{B}_{1-\varepsilon_{1},1-\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n-x_{1},n-x_{2},n-y_{1},n-y_{2})+O(e^{-\mathtt{c}n}). 10.3. Scalings In this subsection, we give the scalings needed for asymptotic analysis. Recall that \xi_{c}=-\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{1-2c} . Let \xi=(\xi_{1},\xi_{2}) and (\tilde{\xi}_{1},\tilde{\xi}_{2}) be on the rough-smooth limit shape curve (given in ( 144 )) with |\xi_{1}-\xi_{2}|0 , 0<\delta<\frac{1}{12} and \gamma>0 . (Smooth region) (92) \displaystyle\hskip 85.35826ptm^{-\frac{1}{6}+\delta}\leq X,Y\leq-\xi_{c}+\gamma (Smooth region close to rough-smooth boundary) (93) \displaystyle\hskip 85.35826ptm^{-\frac{2}{3}}L\leq X,Y0 , 1\leq k_{x}\leq M where M=(\log m)^{2} . We have a similar scaling for y with \hat{\beta}_{y},f_{y},k_{y},\alpha_{y} . We always choose f_{x},f_{y} so that x and y indicate will always be white and black vertices respectively. 10.4. Asymptotics of the Correlation Kernel We now give the refined asymptotics for K^{-1}_{a,1} for the scalings given in the previous subsection. To state our results, we need some details on the saddle point functions, giving a brief description of their origins. In what follows below, we ignore integer parts since these are negligible. First, if we set x and y as given in ( 91 ) we have that (97) \log H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega)=2mg_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega)-\log G(\omega) and (98) \log H_{y_{1},y_{2}+1}(\omega)=2mg_{\tilde{\xi}_{1}+Y,\tilde{\xi}_{2}+Y}(\omega)+\log G(\omega^{-1}) where (99) g_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega)=\log\omega-\xi_{1}\log G(\omega)+\xi_{2}\log G(\omega^{-1}) and the function G is defined in ( 76 ). Recalling ( 88 ) and using ( 97 ) and ( 98 ), we have (100) \begin{split}&\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})=\frac{\mathrm{i}^{\frac{x_{2}-x_{1}+y_{1}-y_{2}}{2}}}{(2\pi\mathrm{i})^{2}}\int_{\Gamma_{p}}\frac{\mathrm{d}\omega_{1}}{\omega_{1}}\int_{\Gamma_{1/p}}\mathrm{d}\omega_{2}\\ &\times\frac{V_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(\omega_{1},\omega_{2})}{\omega_{2}-\omega_{1}}e^{2mg_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{1})-\log G(\omega_{1})}e^{-2mg_{\tilde{\xi}_{1}+Y,\tilde{\xi}_{2}+Y}(\omega_{2})-\log G(\omega_{2}^{-1})}.\end{split} To understand the asymptotic behvavior of this integral, we need to understand the saddle points of g_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}} . By differentiating ( 99 ) we arrive at (101) \omega g^{\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega)=1+\frac{\xi_{1}\omega}{\sqrt{\omega^{2}+2c}}+\frac{\xi_{2}}{\omega\sqrt{\omega^{-2}+2c}} and the equation \omega g^{\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega)=0 has at most four roots in \mathbb{C}\backslash(\mathrm{i}(-\infty,-1/\sqrt{2c}]\cup\mathrm{i}[-\sqrt{2c},\sqrt{2c}]\cup\mathrm{i}[1/\sqrt{2c},\infty)) ; see [ CJ16 , Lemma 3.7] . Note that the equation is symmetric under \omega\mapsto-\omega and \omega\mapsto\mathrm{i}\omega by the choice of square root. We denote \mathbb{H} to be the upper half-plane and set \mathbb{H}_{+}=\{x+y\mathrm{i}:x,y>0\} to be the first quadrant. The critical points of g_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}} determine the macroscopic region which (\xi_{1},\xi_{2}) belongs to. The analysis in [ CJ16 ] was performed for \xi_{1}=\xi_{2} to make the analysis explicit, showing that the four roots of ( 101 ) are given by \omega_{c},\omega^{-1}_{c},-\omega_{c} and -\omega_{c}^{-1} where \omega_{c}\in\mathbb{H}_{+}\cup\mathbb{R}_{\geq 1}\cup[-\sqrt{2c},1]\mathrm{i} . In this case, they found that (\xi_{1},\xi_{1}) depends continously on \omega_{c} with • if \omega_{c}\in(\sqrt{2c},1)\mathrm{i} , then (\xi_{1},\xi_{1}) is in the smooth region (single critical point), • if \omega_{c}=\mathrm{i} , then (\xi_{1},\xi_{1}) is at the smooth-rough boundary, • if \omega_{c}\in\mathbb{H}_{+} with |\omega_{c}|=1 , then (\xi_{1},\xi_{1}) is in the rough region (single critical point), • if \omega_{c}=1 , then (\xi_{1},\xi_{1}) is at the frozen-rough boundary, • if \omega_{c}>1 , the (\xi_{1},\xi_{1}) is in the frozen region. Since we work slightly away from the main diagonal in this paper, we adapt some of our notation accordingly. Moreover, we use the notation that (102) \begin{array}[]{lll}\omega_{c,X}\in\mathbb{H}_{+}\cup\partial\mathbb{H}_{+}&\mbox{such that}&g^{\prime}_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{c,X})=0\\ \tilde{\omega}_{c,Y}\in\mathbb{H}_{+}\cup\partial\mathbb{H}_{+}&\mbox{such that}&g^{\prime}_{\tilde{\xi}_{1}+Y,\tilde{\xi}_{2}+Y}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y})=0,\end{array} where X and Y are marking the distance from (\xi_{1},\xi_{2}) on the limit shape curve at the rough-smooth boundary with |\xi_{1}-\xi_{2}|0 depending only on a , such that (1) If x and y have scaling given by ( 92 ) and 0<\gamma<\mathtt{C}_{2} , then (103) |\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})|\leq\mathtt{C}_{1}e^{-\mathtt{C}_{2}m^{\frac{5}{6}+\delta}}. (2) If x and y have scaling given by ( 93 ), then (104) \begin{split}&|\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})|\\ &\leq\mathtt{C}_{1}\bigg|\frac{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{c,0})}{H_{y_{1},y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,0})}\bigg|e^{-m(\mathtt{C}_{2}X^{3/2}-\mathtt{C}_{3}Y^{3/2})}.\end{split} (3) If x and y both have scaling given by ( 94 ) and |\xi_{1}-\tilde{\xi}_{1}|1 constant, then (106) \mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})=C_{\omega_{c,X}}(x,y)+O(m^{-\frac{1}{2}}) where C_{\omega_{c,X}} is defined in ( 86 ) and \mathrm{Re}\,\omega_{c,X} is order \sqrt{X} . Remark 10.1 . If one of x and y have scaling ( 92 ), then we also have the bound given in ( 103 ). The proof of this follows by the same saddle point analysis for one of the variables in the proof of ( 103 ) (and another saddle point analysis for the other). We omit this computation. By relying on the analysis in [ CJ16 ] , we give a shortened proof of the above result in Section 14 . Using the notation from [ CJ16 ] , let \mathtt{g}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}=\left\{\begin{array}[]{ll}\frac{\mathrm{i}\left(\sqrt{a^{2}+1}+a\right)}{1-a}&\mbox{if }(\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2})=(0,0)\\ \frac{\sqrt{a^{2}+1}+a-1}{\sqrt{2a}(1-a)}&\mbox{if }(\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2})=(0,1)\\ -\frac{\sqrt{a^{2}+1}+a-1}{\sqrt{2a}(1-a)}&\mbox{if }(\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2})=(1,0)\\ \frac{\mathrm{i}\left(\sqrt{a^{2}+1}-1\right)}{(1-a)a}&\mbox{if }(\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2})=(1,1).\end{array}\right. The following theorem is an extension of [ CJ16 , Theorem 2.7] . The extension requires justification, which is done in Section 14.3 . Theorem 10.6 . If x and y have scaling defined by ( 96 ), then we have K_{a,1}^{-1}(x,y)=\mathbb{K}^{-1}_{1,1}(x,y)-\mathbb{K}_{A}(x,y) where \mathbb{K}_{A}(x,y)=\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})(1+o(1)) as n\to\infty . Moreover, we have that as n\to\infty \begin{split}&\mathbb{K}^{-1}_{1,1}(x,y)=\mathrm{i}^{y_{1}-x_{1}+1}|G(\mathrm{i})|^{\frac{-2-x_{1}+x_{2}+y_{1}-y_{2}}{2}}c_{0}\mathtt{g}_{\varepsilon_{x},\varepsilon_{y}}\\ &\times e^{\alpha_{y}\hat{\beta}_{y}-\alpha_{x}\hat{\beta}_{x}-\frac{2}{3}(\hat{\beta}_{x}^{3}-\hat{\beta}_{y}^{3})}(2m)^{-\frac{1}{3}}(\phi_{\hat{\beta}_{x},\hat{\beta}_{y}}(\alpha_{x}+\hat{\beta}_{x}^{2},\alpha_{y}+\hat{\beta}_{y}^{2})+o(1))\end{split} and \begin{split}&\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})=\mathrm{i}^{y_{1}-x_{1}+1}|G(\mathrm{i})|^{\frac{-2-x_{1}+x_{2}+y_{1}-y_{2}}{2}}c_{0}\mathtt{g}_{\varepsilon_{x},\varepsilon_{y}}\\ &\times e^{\alpha_{y}\hat{\beta}_{y}-\alpha_{x}\hat{\beta}_{x}-\frac{2}{3}(\hat{\beta}_{x}^{3}-\hat{\beta}_{y}^{3})}(2m)^{-\frac{1}{3}}(\tilde{\mathcal{A}}(\hat{\beta}_{x},\alpha_{x}+\hat{\beta}_{x}^{2};\hat{\beta}_{y},\alpha_{y}+\hat{\beta}_{y}^{2})+o(1)).\end{split} Here the notation \tilde{\mathcal{A}},\phi_{s,t} for the extended Airy kernel is as in ( 23 ), ( 24 ). Note that the above theorem is stated in a stronger form than needed since it considers different values of \hat{\beta}_{x} and \hat{\beta}_{y} whereas in the sequel, we only need the case \hat{\beta}_{x}=\hat{\beta}_{y} . 11. Proofs of Lemmas 5.6 and 5.7 In this section, we give the smooth phase coupling resuls, that is the proofs of 5.6 and 5.7 . To prove these results, we introduce notation similar to the one used in [ BCJ22 ] . Consider \Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},k} defined in 5.6 for k=1 and 5.7 for k=2 . We denote by \partial\Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},k} to be vertices which share edges that cross the boundary of the box \Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},k} . Letting \mathtt{W}(\Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},k}) denote all white vertices in \Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},k} , we write \mathtt{W}(\Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},k})=\{w_{1},\dots,w_{R}\} . Set f_{1}=e_{1},f_{2}=e_{2},f_{3}=-e_{1} , and f_{4}=-e_{2} and [N]=\{1,\dots,N\} for a positive integer N . A configuration in \Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},k} is a set of edges: (107) ({w}_{1},{w}_{1}+f_{s_{1}}),\dots,({w}_{R},{w}_{R}+f_{s_{R}}) where s_{j}\in[4],1\leq j\leq R . We can think of ( 107 ) as the event that all these edges are covered by dimers. For \overline{s}\in[4]^{R} , we let \overline{s} denote the configuration ( 107 ). Let A_{ij}(\overline{s})=K_{a,1}({w}_{i},{w}_{i})\mathbb{K}^{-1}_{1,1}({w}_{i},{w}_{j}+f_{s_{j}}) and C_{ij}(\overline{s})=-K_{a,1}({w}_{i},{w}_{i})\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})(1+o(1)); where w_{i}=(x_{1},x_{2})\in\mathtt{W}_{\varepsilon_{1}} and {w}_{j}+f_{s_{j}}=(y_{1},y_{2})\in\mathtt{B}_{\varepsilon_{2}} and \varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}\in\{0,1\} . Then, \mathbb{P}_{a,n} induces the following measure on [4]^{R} : (108) p^{a,n}_{\mathrm{Az}}\big(\overline{s}|\Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},k}\big)=\det\big(A_{ij}(\overline{s})+C_{ij}(\overline{s})\big)_{1\leq i,j\leq R} while \mathbb{P}_{a} induces the following measure on [4]^{R} (109) p_{a}\big(\overline{s}|\Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},k}\big)=\det(A_{ij}(\overline{s}))_{1\leq i,j\leq R}. Note that if w_{j}+f_{s_{j}}=w_{k}+f_{s_{k}} for j\not=k , then ( 108 ) and ( 109 ) both give zero, so configurations with overlaps have probability zero. Proof of 5.6 . The proof is the same as 5.5 given in [ BCJ22 , Proposition 4.5] but replacing the bound for |C_{ij}(\overline{s})| by the bound given in ( 103 ) for all i,j and for all \overline{s} such that all faces x in \Lambda_{\mathrm{sm},1} have scaling ( 92 ). The result can be equivalently seen as replacing n^{-1/3} in 5.5 by the bound given in ( 103 ) and accounting for the size of the box (which is o(n^{-1/2}) ) in the statement of 5.6 . The statement on the rotations follows from using 10.4 , the same asymptotic bounds given in ( 103 ), and the above argument. Indeed, these asymptotic bounds holds for any of the rotations considered here because the saddle point function from 10.4 has the same form as the one considered in Section 10.4 . ∎ Proof of 5.7 . Like in the proof of 5.6 we give a shortened proof by relying on the proof of 5.5 given in [ BCJ22 , Proposition 4.5] . The main difference to the proof this lemma compared with 5.6 is that we need to adjust for the additional factor seen in the estimate ( 104 ). We can remove this by showing this additional factor becomes a conjugation factor multiplied by another factor. Indeed, for x=(x_{1},x_{2})\in\mathtt{W}_{\varepsilon_{1}} and y=(y_{1},y_{2})\in\mathtt{B}_{\varepsilon_{2}} and \varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}\in\{0,1\} , we can write \begin{split}&K_{a,1}(x,x)(\mathbb{K}_{1,1}^{-1}(x,y)-\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})(1+o(1)))\\ &=\frac{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}+1}(\omega_{c,0})}{H_{y_{1}+1,y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,0})}\bigg(\frac{H_{y_{1}+1,y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,0})}{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}+1}(\omega_{c,0})}K_{a,1}(x,x)\mathbb{K}_{1,1}^{-1}(x,y)\\ &-\frac{H_{y_{1}+1,y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,0})}{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}+1}(\omega_{c,0})}K_{a,1}(x,x)\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})(1+o(1))\bigg).\end{split} We now proceed as before in the proof of 5.5 , with A_{ij}(\cdot) given by the first term on the right side of the above equation inside the parenthesis and with C_{ij}(\cdot) given by the second term on the right side of the above equation inside the parenthesis. The result follows by noting the additional factor \frac{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}+1}(\omega_{c,0})}{H_{y_{1}+1,y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,0})} outside the parenthesis becomes a conjugation factor, the bound from ( 104 ) which gives an exponential bound for C_{ij}(\cdot) , the fact that \frac{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}+1}(\omega_{c,0})}{H_{y_{1}+1,y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,0})}=G(\omega_{c,0})^{\frac{1}{2}}G(\tilde{\omega}_{c,0})^{-\frac{1}{2}}\frac{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{c,0})}{H_{y_{1},y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,0})} from ( 80 ),and that A_{ij}(\cdot) as chosen above, is the smooth phase correlation kernel with a conjugation factor of the form \frac{H_{y_{1}+1,y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,0})}{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}+1}(\omega_{c,0})} . Analogous to the proof of 5.6 , the exponential bound is given by ( 104 ) (after multiplying by \frac{H_{y_{1}+1,y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,0})}{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}+1}(\omega_{c,0})} ). ∎ 12. Proof of Expected Height Results In this section, we give the proofs of the expected height function results, namely, the proofs of 5.1 , 5.3 and 5.4 . 12.1. Proof of 5.1 To prove 5.1 , we need the following result that is a surprising consequence of the explicit formulas for K^{-1}_{a,1} . Once this result is established, 5.1 follows readily. Lemma 12.1 . Let k,\ell be non-negative integers with -n+2k+2\ell0 we have as m\to\infty \mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(J_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2},-R})=-\mathtt{C}_{1}R^{\frac{3}{2}}m+o(m^{2\delta}). Proof of 12.2 . First, without loss of generality we may assume that J_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2},-R} is a c -face, since the estimate for other faces can be built from the c -face estimate and the fact that height differences on adjacent faces are at most 4 . Next, let u\in[m^{5/6},m^{5/6}+2] be such that \mathtt{J}=J_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2},u} is also a c -face. Then, we have that \mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(J_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2},-R})=\mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(J_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2},-R})-\mathcal{H}_{n}(\mathtt{J}))-\mathbb{E}\mathcal{H}_{n}(\mathtt{J}), where we have an exponential bound on the last term by 5.11 . Note here that 5.11 does not rely on either 5.3 and 5.4 as an input, so this is not a circular argument. Using the relationship between dimer coverings and height functions as well as 10.1 , similarly to ( 110 ) we have that (119) \begin{split}&\mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(J_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2},-R})-\mathcal{H}_{n}(\mathtt{J}))\\ &=4\sum_{k=0}^{\mathtt{m}}\sum_{\varepsilon=0}^{1}(-1)^{\varepsilon}\mathbb{P}\big[\mbox{Dimer covers the edge }(x_{k,\varepsilon},y_{k,\varepsilon})\big]\\ &=-4a\mathrm{i}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathtt{m}}\sum_{\varepsilon=0}^{1}(-1)^{\varepsilon}K^{-1}_{a,1}(x_{k,\varepsilon},y_{k,\varepsilon}).\end{split} where \displaystyle x_{k,\varepsilon} \displaystyle=(\lfloor 4m\xi_{1}-4mR\rfloor+2k+1,\lfloor 4m\xi_{1}-4mR\rfloor+2k+2\varepsilon), \displaystyle y_{k,\varepsilon} \displaystyle=(\lfloor 4m\xi_{1}-4mR\rfloor+2k+2\varepsilon,\lfloor 4m\xi_{1}-4mR\rfloor+2k+1). and \mathtt{m}=2m^{5/6}+2Rm+O(1) . We use the formula K_{a,1}^{-1} given in 10.2 , noting that the smooth phase is flat in expectation, and the bounds given in the first equation of 10.3 , which gives that ( 119 ) equals \begin{split}-4a\mathrm{i}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathtt{m}}\sum_{\varepsilon=0}^{1}(-1)^{\varepsilon}\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon,\varepsilon}\big(a,&(n,n)+x_{k,\varepsilon},(n,n)+y_{k,\varepsilon}\big)+O(e^{-\mathtt{C}_{1}n})\end{split} for some positive constant \mathtt{C}_{1} . We split the above sum into three sums, namely (120) \begin{split}-4a\mathrm{i}\sum_{j=0}^{2}\sum_{k=\mathtt{m}_{j}}^{\mathtt{m_{j+1}}}\sum_{\varepsilon=0}^{1}(-1)^{\varepsilon}\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon,\varepsilon}\big(a,&(n,n)+x_{k,\varepsilon},(n,n)+y_{k,\varepsilon}\big)+O(e^{-\mathtt{C}_{1}n})\end{split} where \mathtt{m}_{3}=\mathtt{m} , \mathtt{m}_{2}=\lfloor 2(m^{1/3}\log^{2}m+Rm)\rfloor , \mathtt{m}_{1}=\lfloor 2(-m^{1/3}\log^{2}m+Rm)\rfloor and \mathtt{m}_{0}=0 . We consider the sum with respect to j separately. By statements 1 and 2 in 10.5 , we have that the summands when j=2 in the above equation are at most O(\exp(-c\log^{3}m)) for some constant c>0 , while the sum is over a polynomial in m , and so the j=2 sum above is O(e^{-\mathtt{C}_{2}\log^{3}n}) as m\to\infty . By statement 3 in 10.5 , we have that the summands when j=1 are of order m^{-\frac{1}{3}} and so the second sum is o(m^{\delta}) as m\to\infty . It remains to consider the sum j=0 in the above equation. Notice that we can apply Statement 4 in 10.5 and we get that the error term, when summed is o(m^{2\delta}) as m\to\infty . Putting everything together, we get that \begin{split}&\mathbb{E}(\mathcal{H}_{n}(J_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2},-R})-\mathcal{H}_{n}(\mathtt{J}))\\ &=-4a\mathrm{i}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathtt{m_{1}}}\sum_{\varepsilon=0}^{1}(-1)^{\varepsilon}\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon,\varepsilon}\big(a,(n,n)+x_{k,\varepsilon},(n,n)+y_{k,\varepsilon}\big)+o(m^{\delta})\\ &=-4a\mathrm{i}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathtt{m_{1}}}C_{\omega_{c,X(k)}}((1,0),(0,1))-C_{\omega_{c,X(k)}}((1,2),(2,1))+o(m^{2\delta})\end{split} where the error term is out of the sum, and \omega_{c,X(k)} is defined through ( 106 ) since X(k)=2k-4R . We have that \begin{split}&C_{\omega_{c,X(\ell)}}((1,2),(2,1))-C_{\omega_{c,X(\ell)}}((1,0),(0,1))\\ &=\frac{1}{2\pi\mathrm{i}}\int_{\Gamma_{\omega_{c,X(k)}}}\frac{\mathrm{d}\omega}{\omega}(\mathrm{i}V_{1,1}(\omega,\omega)-\mathrm{i}^{-1}V_{0,0}(\omega,\omega)(G(\omega)G(\omega^{-1}))^{-1})\\ &=\frac{\mathrm{i}}{2\pi\mathrm{i}}\int_{\Gamma_{\omega_{c,X(k)}}}\frac{\mathrm{d}\omega}{\omega}\frac{1}{2(1+a^{2})\sqrt{\omega^{2}+2c}\sqrt{\omega^{-2}+2c}}(G(\omega)G(\omega^{-1})-(G(\omega)G(\omega^{-1}))^{-1})\\ &=-\frac{\mathrm{i}a}{2\pi\mathrm{i}}\int_{\Gamma_{\omega_{c,X(k)}}}{\mathrm{d}\omega}\frac{1}{\omega^{2}\sqrt{\omega^{-2}+2c}}+\frac{1}{\sqrt{\omega^{2}+2c}}\end{split} where we have used the formula for C_{\omega_{c,X(k)}} given in ( 86 ) and the formula for V_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(\omega,\omega) given in ( 85 ). The above integral can be computed explicitly, is negative and is bounded below by -\mathtt{C}_{1}|\Gamma_{\omega_{c,X(k)}}| , the length of the contour which is approximately equal to 4\mathrm{Re}\,\omega_{c,X(k)} . The exact value is not important here. We have that |\Gamma_{\omega_{c,X(k)}}| is order \sqrt{X(k)} and since the sum contains approximately Rm terms, we get the desired expansion. ∎ Proof of 5.3 . Set \delta=1/30 and x=Rm in 12.2 and the result follows for x\in[-n^{8/15},-\mathtt{C}n^{1/3}(\log n)^{2}] for some constant \mathtt{C}>0 . For x\in[-\mathtt{C}n^{1/3}(\log n)^{2},2n^{1/3}(\log n)^{2}] , we can follow the proof of 12.2 and get an expected height bound of O(\log^{2}n) ; see the proof of 12.2 up to ( 120 ) along with the discussion in the following paragraph for the summands j=1 and j=2 . ∎ The next lemma is used in the proof of 5.4 . Lemma 12.3 . Recall that \xi_{c}=-\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{1-2c} and let -\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{1+2c}0 small, the bound follows from 12.3 along with a Taylor expansion (in x/n ), while for x\leq-\delta n , the bound follows immediately from 12.3 . ∎ 13. Proof of strengthened result of [ BCJ18 ] Here, we prove 6.7 . We adopt a similar notation and conventions used in [ BCJ18 ] to make later comparisons to that paper simpler. This helps to keep our exposition as brief as possible. We translate back to the coordinate system in the remainder of the paper only as necessary. 13.1. Particle System from [ BCJ18 ] We give a similar albeit slightly altered particle system to the one used in [ BCJ18 ] . Let \hat{\beta}_{m}\to\hat{\beta}\in\mathbb{R} , and introduce \hat{\beta}_{m}(k)=2\lfloor\hat{\beta}_{m}\lambda_{2}(2m)^{2/3}\rfloor+2\lfloor k\lambda_{2}\log^{2}m\rfloor. where 1\leq k\leq M with M\to\infty with n and M=o(m^{1/3}\log^{-2}m) . For \ell\in 2\mathbb{Z} , let \mathcal{L}_{m}^{\varepsilon}(\ell)=\{v=(2i-\varepsilon+\frac{1}{2})e_{1}-\ell e_{2}:i\in\mathbb{Z},v\in[-n,n]^{2}\}, let \mathcal{L}_{m}(\hat{\beta}_{m}(k))=\mathcal{L}_{m}^{0}(\hat{\beta}_{m}(k))\cup\mathcal{L}_{m}^{1}(\hat{\beta}_{m}(k)) and let \mathcal{L}_{m}=\bigcup_{k=1}^{M}\mathcal{L}_{m}(\hat{\beta}_{m}(k)). For z\in\mathcal{L}_{m}^{\varepsilon}(\hat{\beta}_{m}(k)) , write \varepsilon(z)=\varepsilon . If \varepsilon(z)=0 , then z has even parity and if \varepsilon(z)=1 , then z has odd parity. This relates to the sign of the height function when crossing the edges in the north-east direction along the diagonal of the Aztec diamond. For a particle z\in\mathcal{L}_{m}(\hat{\beta}_{m}(k)) , associate the vertex x(z)\in\mathtt{W}_{0}\cup\mathtt{W}_{1} and the vertex y(z)\in\mathtt{B}_{0}\cup\mathtt{B}_{1} and the edge (y(z),x(z)) between them, that is the dimer covering the two vertices y(z) and x(z) . Our convention means that (124) \begin{array}[]{ll}&x(z)=z-\frac{1}{2}(-1)^{\varepsilon(z)}e_{2},\\ &y(z)=z+\frac{1}{2}(-1)^{\varepsilon(z)}e_{2},\end{array} see Figure 25 . Figure 25 . The particles to edge mapping. This gives the particle to edge mapping: There is a particle at \displaystyle z\in\mathcal{L}_{m}\qquad \displaystyle\longleftrightarrow\qquad There is a dimer at \displaystyle(x(z),y(z))\in\mathtt{White}\times\mathtt{Black}. We have the following proposition. Proposition 13.1 . The particle process on \mathcal{L}_{m} defined above is a determinantal point process with correlation kernel \mathcal{K}_{m} given by (125) \tilde{\mathcal{K}}_{m}(z,z^{\prime})=a\mathrm{i}K_{a,1}^{-1}(x(z^{\prime}),y(z)) for z,z^{\prime}\in\mathcal{L}_{m} . This proposition follows immediately from the local statistics formula, see 10.1 , and the fact that K_{a,1}(y(z),x(z))=a\mathrm{i} for z\in\mathcal{L}_{m} . We let \mathbb{I}\subset\mathcal{L}_{m} denote the point process in 13.1 . The particle processes on \mathcal{L}_{m} can be used to reconstruct height differences between faces along each of the lines \mathcal{L}_{m}(\hat{\beta}_{m}(k)) . Indeed, for two distinct faces of the form f=ae_{1}-\hat{\beta}_{m}(k)e_{2} and f^{\prime}=be_{1}-\hat{\beta}_{m}(k)e_{2} with a0 and m\in\mathbb{N} , let \alpha_{1,m}<\alpha_{2,m}^{\prime}\leq\alpha_{2,m}<\alpha_{3,m}^{\prime}\leq\alpha_{4,m}<\dots\leq\alpha_{L,m}<\alpha_{L+1,m}^{\prime}=\log^{3}m be real numbers such that \alpha_{i,m},\alpha_{i,m}^{\prime}\to\alpha_{i} , where the limiting sequence satisfies \alpha_{1}<\alpha_{2}<\dots<\alpha_{L}\leq\alpha_{L+1}:=\infty. We allow \alpha_{L}\in\mathbb{R}\cup\{\infty\} , whereas all \alpha_{i},i\leq L-1 must be real. Now let A_{p}=[\alpha_{p},\alpha_{p+1}) for 1\leq p\leq L and define disjoint discrete intervals \tilde{A}_{p}=\{s\in\mathbb{Z}:2\lfloor\alpha_{p,m}\lambda_{1}(2m)^{1/3}\rfloor-1\leq s\leq 2\lfloor\alpha_{p+1,m}^{\prime}\lambda_{1}(2m)^{1/3}-4\rfloor+1\}. Here the separation by 2 is simply to guarantee that the intervals \tilde{A}_{p} are disjoint. The embedding of the interval \tilde{A}_{p} as a discrete interval in \mathcal{L}_{m}(k) is then given by I_{p,k}=\{z_{k}(s):s\in\tilde{A}_{p}\}. We write \mathbb{I}_{p,k}(z)=\mathbf{1}(z\in I_{p,k}) for the indicator function for I_{p,k} . Now, define the random measure \mu_{m} by the formula (128) \mu_{m}(\tilde{A}_{p})=\frac{1}{M}\sum_{k=1}^{M}\sum_{z\in\mathbb{I}}(-1)^{\varepsilon(z)}\mathbb{I}_{p,k}(z). With the mollifier \phi_{n} as above, and notation as in ( 25 ), ( 26 ), by ( 126 ) we have that \tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(\beta_{n},\alpha_{i+1,m}+o(1))-\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_{n}^{\phi_{n}}(\beta_{n},\alpha_{i,m}+o(1))=4\mu_{m}(\tilde{A}_{p}) where the o(1) terms are coming from scaling translation in ( 127 ). Through this translation, and since the approximating sequences \alpha_{i,m} were arbitrary, we can rewrite 6.7 as the L=1 case of the following theorem. Theorem 13.2 . In the above setup, there exists R>0 such that for all \omega\in\mathbb{C}^{L} with |\omega_{p}|0 and 1\leq k\leq M . 1. We have \mathcal{K}_{m,1}(z,z^{\prime})=\frac{1}{\lambda_{1}(2m)^{1/3}}\tilde{\mathcal{A}}\left(\frac{t^{\prime}}{\lambda_{1}(2m)^{1/3}};\frac{t}{\lambda_{1}(2m)^{1/3}}\right)(1+o(1)). where \tilde{\mathcal{A}}(x;y)=\tilde{\mathcal{A}}(0,x;0,y) is given in ( 23 ). 2. Assume that k>k^{\prime} . Then there are constants c_{1},c_{2},C_{1}>0 , so that: (a) If |t^{\prime}-t|\leq c_{2}((k-k^{\prime})(\log m)^{2})^{7/12} , then \begin{split}\mathcal{K}_{m,0}(z,z^{\prime})&=\frac{1}{\lambda_{1}(\log m)}\frac{1}{\sqrt{4\pi(k-k^{\prime})}}\\ &\times\exp\left(-\frac{1}{4(k-k^{\prime})}\left(\frac{t^{\prime}-t}{\lambda_{1}\log m}\right)^{2}\right)(1+o(1)).\end{split} (b) If c_{2}((k-k^{\prime})(\log m)^{2})^{7/12}\leq|t^{\prime}-t|\leq\lambda_{2}(k-k^{\prime})(\log m)^{2} , then |\mathcal{K}_{m,0}(z,z^{\prime})|\leq\frac{C}{(\log m)\sqrt{k-k^{\prime}}}\exp\left(-\frac{c_{1}}{(k-k^{\prime})}\left(\frac{t^{\prime}-t}{\lambda_{1}\log m}\right)^{2}\right). (c) If |t^{\prime}-t|\geq\lambda_{2}(k-k^{\prime})(\log m)^{2} , then |\mathcal{K}_{m,0}(z,z^{\prime})|\leq Ce^{-c_{1}(k-k^{\prime})(\log m)^{2}}. 3. Assume that k0 so that |\mathcal{K}_{m,0}(z,z^{\prime})|\leq Ce^{-c_{1}(k^{\prime}-k)(\log m)^{2}}. 4. Assume that k=k^{\prime} . Then there are constants c_{1},C>0 so that |\mathcal{K}_{m,0}(z,z^{\prime})|\leq Ce^{-c_{1}|t^{\prime}-t|}. Proof of 13.3 . 13.3 differs from [ BCJ18 , Proposition 3.1] in that it allows the parameters to enter the smooth region (by at most \log^{3}m amount). The asymptotics for statements 2, 3, 4 hold from statements 3, 4, 5 from [ BCJ18 , Proposition 3.1] . Statement 1 holds by 10.6 . ∎ 13.3. Proof of 13.2 We give a condensed proof of 13.2 by signposting, where appropriate, to the proof of [ BCJ18 , Theorem 1.1] . The main difference is that here, the support interval of \mu_{m} is no longer compact. For a set S , we write S^{r}=\{\overline{k}=(k_{1},\dots,k_{r}):k_{i}\in S\text{ for all }i=1,\dots,r\} . We adopt cyclic notation, that is, k_{r+1}=k_{1} . Let D_{r}=\{0,1\}^{r}\times[M]^{r}\times[L]^{r} where [N]=\{1,2,\dots,N\} . Similar to [ BCJ18 ] , define \displaystyle D_{r,0} \displaystyle=\{(\overline{\delta},\overline{k},\overline{p})\in D_{r};\delta_{i}=0,k_{i}=k_{i+1},p_{i}=p_{i+1}\mbox{ for }1\leq i\leq r\}, \displaystyle D_{r,1} \displaystyle=\{(\overline{\delta},\overline{k},\overline{p})\in D_{r};\delta_{i}=0\mbox{ for }1\leq i\leq r\mbox{ and }p_{i}\neq p_{i+1}\mbox{ for some $i$}\}, \displaystyle D_{r,2} \displaystyle=\{(\overline{\delta},\overline{k},\overline{p})\in D_{r};\delta_{i}=0,p_{i}=p_{i+1}\mbox{~for~}1\leq i\leq r\mbox{~and~}k_{i}\not=k_{i+1}\mbox{~for some~}i\}, \displaystyle D_{r,3} \displaystyle=\{(\overline{\delta},\overline{k},\overline{p})\in D_{r};\delta_{i}=1\mbox{~for some~}i\}. Then D_{r}=D_{r,0}\cup D_{r,1}\cup D_{r,2}\cup D_{r,3} . Introduce (132) \begin{split}T_{j}(m,r,\overline{\ell})=&\sum_{\overline{\varepsilon}\in\{0,1\}^{r}}\prod_{i=1}^{r}(-1)^{\ell_{i}\varepsilon_{i}}\sum_{(\overline{\delta},\overline{k},\overline{p})\in D_{r,j}}\prod_{i=1}^{r}\omega_{p_{i}}^{\ell_{i}}(-1)^{\delta_{i}}\\ &\times\sum_{\overline{z}\in(\mathcal{L}_{m})^{r}}\prod_{i=1}^{r}\mathbbm{I}_{p_{i},k_{i}}^{\varepsilon_{i}}(z_{i})\mathtt{K}_{m,\delta_{i}}(z_{i},z_{i+1}),\end{split} for j\in\{0,1,2,3\} where \mathbbm{I}_{p,k}^{\varepsilon} is the indicator on \mathcal{L}_{m} for the set (133) I_{p,k}^{\varepsilon}=\{z\in I_{p,k}:\varepsilon(z)=\varepsilon\}. By performing a cumulant expansion, see [ BCJ18 , Equations (4.1)-(4.6)] for details, we can write \log\det(\mathbbm{I}+(e^{\frac{1}{M}\psi}-1)\mathtt{K}_{m})=\sum_{j=0}^{3}U_{j}(m) where we define (134) U_{j}(m)=\sum_{s=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{M^{s}}\sum_{r=1}^{s}\frac{(-1)^{r+1}}{r}\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}\ell_{1}+\dots+\ell_{r}=s\\ \ell_{1},\dots,\ell_{r}\geq 1\end{subarray}}\frac{T_{j}(m,r,\overline{\ell})}{\ell_{1}!\dots\ell_{r}!}. We have that U_{0}(m) , U_{1}(m) , and U_{2}(m) all tend to zero as m\to\infty by [ BCJ18 , Lemma 4.1 and Lemma 4.2] , since the same proofs hold as the same estimates are present in 13.3 as [ BCJ18 , Proposition 3.1] for \mathcal{K}_{m,0} . It remains to consider U_{3}(m) . We introduce some additional notation similar to that of [ BCJ18 ] . Define z_{k}^{\varepsilon}(t)=(\lfloor 4m\xi_{c}\rfloor+2(t-\tau_{m})-\varepsilon+\frac{1}{2})e_{1}-\hat{\beta}_{m}(k)e_{2}, and set A_{p,m}=\{t\in\mathbb{Z}:\lfloor\alpha_{p}\lambda_{1}(2m)^{1/3}\rfloor\leq t\leq\lfloor\alpha_{p+1}\lambda_{1}(2m)^{1/3}-\log^{3}m\rfloor\}. We these definitions, we have that I_{p,k}^{\varepsilon}=\{z_{k}^{\varepsilon}(t):t\in A_{p,m}\}. Next, define S_{r}(\overline{\varepsilon},\overline{\delta},\overline{k},\overline{p})=\int_{\mathbb{R}^{r}}\mathrm{d}^{r}\overline{t}\prod_{i=1}^{r}\mathbbm{I}_{A_{p,m}}(\lfloor t_{i}\rfloor)\mathcal{K}^{(i)}_{m,\overline{\varepsilon},\overline{\delta},\overline{k}}(t_{i},t_{i+1}) where \mathcal{K}^{(i)}_{m,\overline{\varepsilon},\overline{\delta},\overline{k}}(t_{i},t_{i+1})=\mathcal{K}_{m,\delta_{i}}(z_{k_{i}}^{\varepsilon_{i}}(\lfloor t_{i}\rfloor),z_{k_{i+1}}^{\varepsilon_{i+1}}(\lfloor t_{i+1}\rfloor)). With this notation, following [ BCJ18 , (4.7)-(4.10)] we have T_{j}(m,r,\overline{\ell})=\sum_{\overline{\varepsilon}\in\{0,1\}^{r}}P(\overline{\varepsilon},\overline{\ell})\sum_{(\overline{\delta},\overline{k},\overline{p})\in D_{r,j}}\prod_{i=1}^{r}\omega_{p_{i}}^{\ell_{i}}(-1)^{\delta_{i}}S_{r}(\overline{\varepsilon},\overline{\delta},\overline{\ell},\overline{p}) with P(\overline{\varepsilon},\overline{\ell})=\prod_{i=1}^{r}\frac{a\mathrm{i}}{2}\sqrt{1-2c}(-1)^{(1+\ell_{i})\varepsilon_{i}}\mathtt{g}_{\varepsilon_{i},\varepsilon_{i+1}}|G(\mathrm{i})|^{\varepsilon_{i}+\varepsilon_{i+1}-2}. Introduce (135) d_{i}=\left\{\begin{array}[]{ll}\lambda_{1}(2m)^{1/3}&\mbox{if }\delta_{i}=1\\ (\log m)\lambda_{1}\sqrt{|k_{i+1}-k_{i}|}&\mbox{if }\delta_{i}=0,k_{i}\not=k_{i+1}\\ 1&\mbox{if }\delta_{i}=0,k_{i}=k_{i+1}\end{array}\right. and the change of variables \tau_{i}=t_{i}/d_{i} for 1\leq i\leq r . After this change of variables, we obtain S_{r}(\overline{\varepsilon},\overline{\delta},\overline{k},\overline{p})=\int_{\mathbb{R}^{r}}\mathrm{d}^{r}\overline{\tau}\prod_{i=1}^{r}\mathbbm{I}_{A_{m}}(\lfloor\tau_{i}d_{i}\rfloor)d_{i}\mathcal{K}^{(i)}_{m,\overline{\varepsilon},\overline{\delta},\overline{k}}(\tau_{i}d_{i},\tau_{i+1}d_{i+1}). We have the following bound. Lemma 13.4 . There is a constant C>0 such that |S_{r}(\overline{\varepsilon},\overline{\delta},\overline{k},\overline{p})|\leq C^{r} for all (\overline{\delta},\overline{k})\in D_{r,3} and \overline{\varepsilon}\in\{0,1\}^{r} . Proof. The proof of this lemma is the same as the one given in [ BCJ18 , Lemma 4.3] , noting the extended ranges given in 13.3 . ∎ Let D_{s,3}^{*}=\{(\overline{\delta},\overline{k},\overline{p})\in D_{s,3}:k_{i}\not=k_{j}\text{ for all }i\not=j\} and let Q(\overline{\varepsilon})=P(\overline{\varepsilon},(1,\dots,1)) . Then define U_{3}^{*}(m)=\sum_{s=1}^{\infty}\frac{(-1)^{s+1}}{sM^{s}}\sum_{\overline{\varepsilon}\in\{0,1\}^{r}}Q(\overline{\varepsilon})\sum_{(\overline{\delta},\overline{k},\overline{p})\in D_{s,3}^{*}}\prod_{i=1}^{s}(-1)^{\delta_{i}}\omega_{p_{i}}S_{s}(\overline{\varepsilon},\overline{\delta},\overline{k},\overline{p}) Lemma 13.5 . There is a constant C>0 such that for R sufficiently small and all |\omega_{p}|\leq R , U_{3}(m) is uniformly convergent and |U_{3}^{*}(m)-U_{3}(m)|k_{i+1}}\end{split} Next we have that on \lfloor d_{i}\tau_{i}\rfloor\in A_{p_{i},m} with i\in J , d_{i}\mathcal{K}^{(i)}_{m,\overline{\varepsilon},\overline{\delta},\overline{k}}(\tau_{i}d_{i},\tau_{i+1}d_{i+1})=\tilde{\mathcal{A}}(\tau_{i};\tau_{i+1})(1+o(1)) by Statement (1) in 13.3 . The fact that the Airy functions decay when \tau_{i}\to\infty means that we can write \begin{split}&\lim_{m\to\infty}S_{r}(\overline{\varepsilon},\overline{\delta},\overline{k},\overline{p})=\prod_{i\in J^{\prime}}\mathbbm{I}_{k_{i}>k_{i+1}}\int_{\mathbb{R}^{r}}\prod_{j\in J}\mathrm{d}\tau_{j}\times\prod_{i=1}^{r}\mathbbm{I}_{A_{p_{i}}}(\tau_{j_{i}})\tilde{\mathcal{A}}\big(\tau_{j_{i}},\tau_{j_{i+1}}\big)\end{split} where we have computed the Gaussian integral from ( 136 ) and used the indicator functions for the integral with respect to \tau_{i} for i\in J . The proof now proceeds exactly as in [ BCJ18 ] in that one has to use \lim_{m\to\infty}\frac{1}{M^{s}}\sum_{\overline{k}\in[M]^{s}}\prod_{i\in J^{\prime}}\mathbbm{I}_{k_{i}>k_{i+1}}=\frac{1}{\ell_{1}!\dots\ell_{r}!}. along with [ BCJ18 , Lemma 4.6] that states that \sum_{\overline{\varepsilon}\in\{0,1\}^{s}}Q(\overline{\varepsilon})=(-1)^{s} , and a resummation to get the right side of the statement of the theorem; we omit these details since they can be found in [ BCJ18 ] . 14. Proof of results from Section 10 We now give the proofs of the results given in Section 10 , including those relating to the refined asymptotic analysis of K^{-1}_{a,1} . 14.1. Proof of 10.3 The next lemma is a restatement of [ CJ16 , Lemma 3.6] and so will be stated without proof. Lemma 14.1 . Rescale and center the Aztec diamond so that x=([4m\eta_{1}]+\overline{x}_{1},[4m\eta_{1}]+\overline{x}_{2})\in\mathtt{W}_{\varepsilon_{1}} and y=([4m\eta_{2}]+\overline{y}_{1},[4m\eta_{2}]+\overline{y}_{2})\in\mathtt{B}_{\varepsilon_{2}} for \varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}\in\{0,1\} and -1<\eta_{1},\eta_{2}<0 where \overline{x}_{1},\overline{x}_{2},\overline{y}_{1},\overline{y}_{2} are at most order m^{5/6} , there are positive constants \mathtt{C}_{1} and \mathtt{C}_{2} so that \displaystyle\left|\frac{1}{a}\mathcal{B}_{1-\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a^{-1},n-x_{1},n+x_{2},n-y_{1},n+y_{2}\right| \displaystyle\leq\mathtt{C}_{1}e^{-\mathtt{C}_{2}n}, \displaystyle\left|\frac{1}{a}\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},1-\varepsilon_{2}}(a^{-1},n+x_{1},n-x_{2},n+y_{1},n-y_{2})\right| \displaystyle\leq\mathtt{C}_{1}e^{-\mathtt{C}_{2}n}, \displaystyle\left|\mathcal{B}_{1-\varepsilon_{1},1-\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n-x_{1},n-x_{2},n-y_{1},n-y_{2})\right| \displaystyle\leq\mathtt{C}_{1}e^{-\mathtt{C}_{2}n}. The statement in [ CJ16 , Lemma 3.6] differs slightly in that the vertices x and y are at the same asymptotic coordinate (that is, \eta_{1}=\eta_{2} ) and that \overline{x}_{1},\overline{x}_{2},\overline{y}_{1},\overline{y}_{2} is at most order m^{2/3} . However, it follows from the proof of the lemma given there that we can immediately extend to the conditions given in the above lemma. Next, set (137) \begin{split}&Q_{\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2}}^{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}\left(\omega_{1},\omega_{2}\right)=(-1)^{\varepsilon_{1}+\varepsilon_{2}+\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2}+\gamma_{1}(1+\varepsilon_{2})+\gamma_{2}(1+\varepsilon_{1})}\\ &\times s\left(G\left(\omega_{1}\right)\right)^{\gamma_{1}}s\left(G\left(\omega_{2}^{-1}\right)\right)^{\gamma_{2}}G\left(\omega_{1}\right)^{\varepsilon_{1}}G\left(\omega_{2}^{-1}\right)^{\varepsilon_{2}}\mathtt{x}^{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}_{\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2}}\left(a,\omega_{1},\omega_{2}^{-1}\right),\end{split} where notation is as in ( 82 ) and ( 83 ). The following corollary from [ CJ16 ] expresses the integrals in 10.2 in terms of the \omega -coordinates. Corollary 14.2 (Part of Corollary 2.4, [ CJ16 ] ) . For n=4m , let x=(x_{1},x_{2})\in\mathtt{W}_{\varepsilon_{1}} and y=(y_{1},y_{2})\in\mathtt{B}_{\varepsilon_{2}} with \varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}\in\{0,1\} . Suppose that -n0 , • g^{\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{c,X})<0 , • g^{\prime\prime}_{\tilde{\xi}_{1}+Y,\tilde{\xi}_{2}+Y}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y})>0 , • if X=Y and (\tilde{\xi}_{1},\tilde{\xi}_{2})=(\xi_{1},\xi_{2}) , then |\omega_{c,X}|<|\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y}| . The curve of steepest descent of \mathrm{Re}\,g_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X} goes from \omega_{c,X} , perpendicular to the imaginary axis, to 0 and a curve of steepest ascent of \mathrm{Re}\,g_{\tilde{\xi}_{1}+Y,\tilde{\xi}_{2}+Y} from \tilde{\omega}_{c,Y} , along the imaginary axis, to \infty . We assume the above lemma and proceed with the proof of ( 103 ). We follow the saddle point analysis in [ CJ16 , Proposition 3.12] and refer the reader there for more details. Our starting point is the formula given in ( 100 ). We deform the contours to the curves given in 14.4 , splitting the integral into a local contribution around the saddle points \omega_{c,X} and \tilde{\omega}_{c,Y} , and a remaining contribution which is exponentially small which can be ignored; see [ CJ16 , Proposition 3.12] . For the local contribution, we apply a change of variables \omega_{1}=\omega_{c,X}+(2m)^{-1/2}w_{1} and \omega_{2}=\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y}+(2m)^{-1/2}w_{2} . Applying a Taylor expansion, the term in the first exponential in ( 100 ) becomes \begin{split}&2mg_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{1})-\log G(\omega_{1})=2mg_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{c,X})-\log G(\omega_{c,X})\\ &+\frac{1}{2}g^{\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{c,X})w_{1}^{2}+O(w_{1}^{3}m^{-1/2})\\ &=\log H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{c,X})+\frac{1}{2}g^{\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{c,X})w_{1}^{2}+O(w_{1}^{3}m^{-1/2}).\end{split} We have a similar formula in the \omega_{2} variable for the term in the second exponential in ( 100 ). Collecting the error terms in the above expansion means that ( 100 ) becomes (139) \begin{split}&\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})\\ &=\frac{(1+O(m^{-1/2}))}{2m}\frac{\mathrm{i}^{\frac{x_{2}-x_{1}+y_{1}-y_{2}}{2}}}{(2\pi\mathrm{i})^{2}}\int\frac{\mathrm{d}w_{1}}{\omega_{c,X}}\int\mathrm{d}w_{2}\frac{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{c,X})}{H_{y_{1},y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y})}\\ &\times\frac{V_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(\omega_{c,X},\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y})e^{\frac{1}{2}g^{\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{c,X})w_{1}^{2}-\frac{1}{2}g^{\prime\prime}_{\tilde{\xi}_{1}+Y,\tilde{\xi}_{2}+Y}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y})w_{2}^{2}}}{\omega_{c,X}-\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y}+(2m)^{-\frac{1}{2}}(w_{1}-w_{2})}\end{split} where the contours are local contours around the origin (of length m^{-\epsilon} for some \epsilon>0 ) with the w_{1} and w_{2} contours are positively oriented along the real and imaginary axis respectively, which follows from 14.4 . If \omega_{c,X}=\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y} , the above singularity is integrable. In any case and noting the signs in the exponent from 14.4 , we extend the contours to infinity which gives a Gaussian integral and so we obtain a bound |\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})|\leq\frac{\mathtt{C}_{1}}{\sqrt{m}}\bigg|\frac{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{c,X})}{H_{y_{1},y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y})}\bigg| The result then follows by using the exponential form of H given in ( 97 ) and third and fourth statements in 14.4 , and noting that 2m\mathrm{Re}\,g_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{c,X}) is at most -m^{5/6+\delta} from the choice of scaling in ( 92 ), and that V is uniformly bounded on compact subsets. It remains to prove the assumed lemma stated above. Proof of 14.4 . The proof of this lemma uses the following two lemmas from [ CJ16 ] . Lemma 14.5 (Lemma 3.9 in [ CJ16 ] ) . The function g_{\xi,\xi}(\omega) for \omega\in\mathbb{H}_{+}\cup\partial\mathbb{H}_{+} has two distinct saddle points in the interval (\sqrt{2c},1/\sqrt{2c})\mathrm{i} (but not equal to \mathrm{i} ) if and only if -1/2\sqrt{1-2c}<\xi<0 . These saddle points are given by \omega_{c}\in(\sqrt{2c},1)\mathrm{i} and -\omega_{c}^{-1} . We also have \mathrm{Re}\,g_{\xi,\xi}(\omega_{c})<0 and \mathrm{Re}\,g_{\xi,\xi}(-\omega_{c}^{-1})>0 . Lemma 14.6 (Lemma 3.10 in [ CJ16 ] ) . For -\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{1-2c}<\xi<0 , choose \omega_{c} such that g_{\xi,\xi}^{\prime}(\omega_{c})=0 with \omega_{c}\in(\sqrt{2c},1)\mathrm{i} . Then g_{\xi,\xi}^{\prime}(-\omega_{c}^{-1})=0 , g_{\xi,\xi}^{\prime\prime}(\omega_{c})<0\hskip 14.22636pt\mbox{and}\hskip 14.22636ptg_{\xi,\xi}^{\prime\prime}(-\omega_{c}^{-1})>0. Turning to the proof of 14.4 , letting \omega=\mathrm{i}t and recalling \theta defined in ( 78 ), we have that 0=\mathrm{i}tg^{\prime}_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\mathrm{i}t)=1+(\xi_{1}+X)\theta(t)+(\xi_{2}+X)\theta(t^{-1}). When \xi_{1}=\xi_{2} , the right-hand side above has zeroes at points t\in(\sqrt{2c},1) and t^{-1} ; this is part of 14.5 . Since the function is continuous in \xi_{1},\xi_{2} , these two zeroes will move continuously as we vary these parameters in an O(m^{-1/6}) window. This produces the two critical points defined in ( 102 ), and verifies the fifth bullet point. Next, using the above two lemmas and the fact that |\xi_{1}-\xi_{2}||\omega_{c,X}| and \omega_{c,0}-\omega_{c,X}=O(\sqrt{X}) and |\tilde{\omega}_{c,0}|<|\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y}| and \tilde{\omega}_{c,0}-\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y}=O(\sqrt{Y}) . As in the proof of ( 103 ), we start with ( 100 ) and obtain ( 139 ) with the contours for the w_{1} and w_{2} as stated there. As given in the proof ( 103 ) we compute the Gaussian integrals and we obtain the bound (140) \begin{split}&|\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})\leq\bigg|\frac{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{c,X})}{H_{y_{1},y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y})}\bigg|\\ &\times\frac{\mathtt{C}_{1}}{\sqrt{-mg^{\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+Y}(\omega_{c,X})g^{\prime\prime}_{\tilde{\xi}_{1}+X,\tilde{\xi}_{2}+X}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y})}}\end{split} where \mathtt{C}_{1} is a positive constant. In the above equation, it suffices to estimate H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{c,X}) as the estimate for H_{y_{1},y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y}) follows by a similar computation. Taking the logarithms and using ( 97 ), we need to consider \begin{split}&g_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{c,X})=g_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega_{c,X})-X(\log G(\omega_{c,X})-\log G(\omega_{c,X}^{-1}))\\ &=g_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega_{c,0})-X(\log G(\omega_{c,0})-\log G(\omega_{c,0}^{-1}))\\ &+(\omega_{c,X}-\omega_{c,0})\frac{X}{\mathrm{i}t_{c,0}}(\theta(t_{c,0})+\theta(t_{c,0}^{-1}))+O(X(\omega_{c,X}-\omega_{c,0})^{2})\\ &=g_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{c,0})+(t_{c,X}-t_{c,0})\frac{X}{t_{c,0}}(\theta(t_{c,0})+\theta(t_{c,0}^{-1}))+O(X(\omega_{c,X}-\omega_{c,0})^{2})\end{split} where the second line follows by a Taylor series, setting \omega_{c,0}=\mathrm{i}t_{c,0} and \omega_{c,X}=\mathrm{i}t_{c,X} , using that \omega_{c,0} satisfies g^{\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega_{c,0})=g^{\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega_{c,0})=0 , and using the definition of \theta in ( 78 ). We then have |H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{c,X})|=|H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{c,0})|e^{(t_{c,X}-t_{c,0})\frac{X}{t_{c,0}}(\theta(t_{c,0})+\theta(t_{c,0}^{-1}))+O(X^{2})}. The result follows from using the bound on (\omega_{c,X}-\omega_{c,0}) in 14.7 , applying the same type of computation to {H_{y_{1},y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y})} and subsituting the estimates back into ( 140 ). Proof of 14.7 . We prove the lemma for X ; the assertions hold for Y by similar computations. Since (\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X) is not on the curve ( 144 ), we have that that g^{\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{c,X})\not=0 and so \omega_{c,X} satisfy the statements of 14.4 by analyticity. Let \omega_{c,0}=\mathrm{i}t_{c,0} , \omega_{c,X}=\mathrm{i}t_{c,X} and recall ( 78 ). Suppose that t_{c,X}-t_{c,0}=\epsilon . From ( 101 ) with \xi_{i}\mapsto\xi_{i}+X for i\in\{1,2\} , we get from a Taylor expansion (141) \begin{split}0&=1+(\xi_{1}+X)\theta(t_{c,X})+(\xi_{2}+X)\theta((t_{c,X})^{-1})\\ &=1+\xi_{1}\theta(t_{c,0})+\xi_{2}\theta(t_{c,0}^{-1})+\epsilon\big(\xi_{1}\theta^{\prime}(t_{c,0})+\xi_{2}\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}\theta(t^{-1})\big|_{t=t_{c,0}}\big)\\ &+\frac{\epsilon^{2}}{2}\big(\xi_{1}\theta^{\prime\prime}(t_{c,0})+\xi_{2}\frac{\mathrm{d}^{2}}{\mathrm{d}t^{2}}\theta(t^{-1})\big|_{t=t_{c,0}}\big)+X(\theta(t_{c,X})+\theta(t_{c,X}^{-1}))+O(\epsilon^{3})\\ &=\frac{\epsilon^{2}}{2}\big(\xi_{1}\theta^{\prime\prime}(t_{c,0})+\xi_{2}\frac{\mathrm{d}^{2}}{\mathrm{d}t^{2}}\theta(t^{-1})\big|_{t=t_{c,0}}\big)+X(\theta(t_{c,X})+\theta(t_{c,X}^{-1}))+O(\epsilon^{3})\end{split} where the last line follows since (\xi_{1},\xi_{2}) is a double zero of ( 101 ). The remaining terms in the above equation are non-zero and noting that \theta^{\prime\prime}(t_{c,0}),\theta(t_{c,0})>0 and \xi_{1},\xi_{2}<0 it follows \epsilon is real and is O(\sqrt{X}) . Finally, we get |\omega_{c,0}|>|\omega_{c,X}| which holds by the fifth statement of 14.4 and using analyticity. k ∎ ∎ Proof of ( 105 ) in 10.5 . We need the following lemma which we prove first before commencing with the proof of ( 105 ). Lemma 14.8 . For \omega_{c,0}=\mathrm{i}t_{c,0} , we have that t_{c,0}\in(\sqrt{2c},1/\sqrt{2c}) and that g^{\prime\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\mathrm{i}t_{c,0})=-\mathrm{i}\mathcal{G}_{c,t} with \omega_{c,0}=\mathrm{i}t_{c,0} and t\in(\sqrt{2c},1/\sqrt{2c}) where \mathcal{G}_{c,t}=\frac{2c(2c-t^{2}+8c^{2}t^{2}-4ct^{4}-3t^{6}+6ct^{8})}{t^{5}(2c-t^{2})(-1+2ct^{2})(-1+4ct^{2}-t^{4})}. In \mathbb{H}_{+}\cup\partial\mathbb{H}_{+} , there is a curve of steepest descent leaving \omega_{c,0} at angle -\pi/6 going to the origin and a curve of steepest ascent leaving \omega_{c,0} at angle \pi/6 going to \infty . Proof of 14.8 . We can differentiate ( 101 ) which gives (142) \omega g^{\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega)+g^{\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega)=\xi_{1}\frac{2c}{(\omega^{2}+2c)^{\frac{3}{2}}}-\xi_{2}\frac{2c}{(\omega^{-2}+2c)^{\frac{3}{2}}}. Asserting that g^{\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega_{c,0})=g^{\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega_{c,0})=0 in ( 101 ) and the above equation gives a matrix equation for (\xi_{1},\xi_{2}) which can be solved giving (143) \begin{split}(\xi_{1},\xi_{2})&=\bigg(\frac{-\omega_{c,0}(\omega_{c,0}^{2}+2c)^{\frac{3}{2}}}{1+4c\omega_{c,0}^{2}+\omega_{c,0}^{4}},\frac{-(\omega_{c,0}^{-2}+2c)^{\frac{3}{2}}}{\omega_{c,0}(1+4c\omega_{c,0}^{2}+\omega_{c,0}^{4})}\bigg)\\ &=\bigg(\frac{-t_{c,0}(t_{c,0}^{2}-2c)^{\frac{3}{2}}}{1-4ct_{c,0}^{2}+t_{c,0}^{4}},\frac{-(t_{c,0}^{-2}-2c)^{\frac{3}{2}}}{t_{c,0}(1-4ct_{c,0}^{2}+t_{c,0}^{4})}\bigg)\end{split} where \omega_{c,0}=\mathrm{i}t_{c,0} . The above equation solves ( 144 ) and we need to verify that it is on the rough-smooth boundary. To see this, notice that for t_{c,0}\in(\sqrt{2c},1/\sqrt{2c}) , we have that \xi_{1},\xi_{2}<0 and for t_{c,0}=1 , \xi_{1}=\xi_{2}=\xi_{c} as needed. We differentiate ( 142 ) which gives \omega g^{\prime\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega)+2g^{\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega)=-\frac{6c\omega}{(\omega^{2}+2c)^{\frac{5}{2}}}\xi_{1}+\frac{2c(-1+4c\omega^{2})}{\sqrt{2c+\omega^{-2}}(\omega+2c\omega^{3})^{2}}\xi_{2}. This gives g^{\prime\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\mathrm{i}t_{c,0})=-\frac{6c}{\mathrm{i}(t_{c,0}^{2}-2c)^{\frac{5}{2}}}+\frac{2c(-1-4ct_{c,0}^{2})}{\mathrm{i}t_{c,0}\sqrt{2c+t_{c,0}^{-2}}(t_{c,0}-2ct_{c,0}^{3})^{2}}\xi_{2}. Substituting the values of \xi_{1} and \xi_{2} found in ( 143 ) gives the result for g^{\prime\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}} after a computation. The local angles of the curves of steepest descent and ascent around the double critical point follows from the fact that \mathcal{G}_{c,t}>0 for t\in(\sqrt{2c},1/\sqrt{2c}) . The rest of the argument for the location of the curves of steepest descent and ascent is the same as the one in 14.4 . ∎ We now proceed with the proof of ( 105 ) in 10.5 . We follow the saddle point analysis in [ CJ16 , Proposition 3.17] and refer the reader there for more details. Our starting point is the formula given in ( 100 ). We deform the contours to those given in 14.8 , splitting the integral to a local contribution around the saddle points \omega_{c,0} and \tilde{\omega}_{c,0} defined through ( 102 ), and a remaining contribution which is exponentially small which can be ignored; see [ CJ16 , Proposition 3.17] . For the local contribution, we apply a change of variables \omega_{1}=\omega_{c,0}+(2m)^{-1/3}w_{1} and \omega_{2}=\tilde{\omega}_{c,0}+(2m)^{-1/3}w_{2} . Applying a Taylor series gives the terms in the exponent with respect to \omega_{1} becoming \begin{split}&2mg_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{1})-\log G(\omega_{1})\\ &=2mg_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega_{1})-(2mX+1)\log G(\omega_{1})+2mX\log G(\omega_{1}^{-1})\\ &=2mg_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{c,0})-\log G(\omega_{c,0})\\ &+\frac{1}{6}g^{\prime\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega_{c,0})w_{1}^{3}+(2m)^{\frac{2}{3}}Xw_{1}\bigg(\frac{1}{\sqrt{\omega_{c,0}^{2}+2c}}+\frac{1}{\omega_{c,0}^{2}\sqrt{\omega_{c,0}^{-2}+2c}}\bigg)\\ &+O(w_{1}^{3}m^{-1/3})=\log H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{c,0})+\frac{1}{6}g^{\prime\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega_{c,0})w_{1}^{2}\\ &+\frac{(2m)^{\frac{2}{3}}Xw_{1}}{\omega_{c,0}}(\theta(-\mathrm{i}\omega_{c,0})-\theta(\mathrm{i}\omega_{c,0}^{-1}))+O(w_{1}^{3}m^{-1/3}).\end{split} In the above display, we have rewrite g_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X}(\omega_{1}) in terms of g_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega_{1}) and an additional term from ( 99 ) in order to facilitate the Taylor series. We have also used -\mathrm{i}\omega_{c,0}\in(\sqrt{2c},1/\sqrt{2c}) to keep the notation compact. A similar expression holds for the \omega_{2} variable. Collecting the error terms and the above expansion means that ( 100 ) becomes \begin{split}&\mathcal{B}_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(a,n+x_{1},n+x_{2},n+y_{1},n+y_{2})=\frac{(1+O(m^{-1/3}))}{(2m)^{2/3}}\frac{\mathrm{i}^{\frac{x_{2}-x_{1}+y_{1}-y_{2}}{2}}}{(2\pi\mathrm{i})^{2}}\\ &\times\int\frac{\mathrm{d}w_{1}}{\omega_{c,X}}\int\mathrm{d}w_{2}\frac{V_{\varepsilon_{1},\varepsilon_{2}}(\omega_{c,0},\tilde{\omega}_{c,0})e^{\frac{1}{6}g^{\prime\prime\prime}_{\xi_{1},\xi_{2}}(\omega_{c,0})w_{1}^{3}-\frac{1}{6}g^{\prime\prime\prime}_{\tilde{\xi}_{1},\tilde{\xi}_{2}}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,0})w_{2}^{3}}}{\omega_{c,0}-\tilde{\omega}_{c,0}+(2m)^{-\frac{1}{3}}(w_{1}-w_{2})}\frac{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{c,X})}{H_{y_{1},y_{2}+1}(\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y})}\\ &\times e^{\frac{(2m)^{\frac{2}{3}}Xw_{1}}{\omega_{c,0}}(\theta(-\mathrm{i}\omega_{c,0})-\theta(\mathrm{i}\omega_{c,0}^{-1}))-\frac{(2m)^{\frac{2}{3}}Yw_{2}}{\tilde{\omega}_{c,0}}(\theta(-\mathrm{i}\tilde{\omega}_{c,0})-\theta(\mathrm{i}\tilde{\omega}_{c,0}^{-1}))}\end{split} where the contours are local contours around the origin (of length m^{-\epsilon} for some \epsilon>0 ) with the w_{1} contour leaving the origin at -\pi/6 and w_{2} contour leaving the origin at \pi/6 , which follows from 14.8 . From the choice |\xi_{1}-\tilde{\xi}_{1}|0,\theta^{\prime\prime}(t)<0 for t\in(\sqrt{2c},1/\sqrt{2c}) \xi_{1},\xi_{2}<0 we have that \epsilon is O(\sqrt{|X|}) and real and so \omega_{c,X}\in\mathbb{H}_{+} . Moreover, we can write \omega_{c,X}=r_{c,X}e^{\mathrm{i}\theta_{c,X}} with r_{c,X}>0 and 0<\theta_{c,X}<\pi/2 . Since both |X-Y|1 , we have that \omega_{c,X}=\tilde{\omega}_{c,Y} because g_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X} and g_{\tilde{\xi}_{1}+Y,\tilde{\xi}_{2}+Y} differ by O(m^{-1}) . We now choose the contours for the integral in ( 100 ) so that they pass through the four roots \omega_{c,X},-\omega_{c,X},\overline{\omega_{c,X}} and -\overline{\omega_{c,X}} and are given by the curves of steepest ascent and descent for \mathrm{Re}g_{\xi_{1}+X,\xi_{2}+X} . By analyticity and since |\xi_{1}-\xi_{2}|0 . We get from a Taylor series \begin{split}&\frac{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{1})}{H_{y_{1},y_{2}+1}(\omega_{2})}=\frac{H_{x_{1}+1,x_{2}}(\omega_{c,X})}{G(\mathrm{i}^{-1})^{\frac{y_{2}-y_{1}+1}{2}}}\exp\Bigg(g_{\xi_{c}+X,\xi_{c}+X}^{\prime\prime}(\omega_{c,X})c_{0}^{2}w^{2}\\ &-2\lfloor\hat{\beta}_{x}\lambda_{2}(2m)^{\frac{1}{6}}\rfloor\bigg(-\frac{1}{\sqrt{\omega_{c,X}^{2}+2c}}+\frac{1}{\omega_{c,X}^{2}\sqrt{\omega_{c,X}^{-2}+2c}}\bigg)c_{0}w\\ &+\frac{\mathrm{i}}{3}{z^{3}}+\hat{\beta}_{y}z^{2}-\mathrm{i}\alpha_{y}z+\mathrm{Err}\Bigg)\end{split} where \mathrm{Err} is equal to m^{-1/2}w^{3}R_{m}(w)+m^{-1/3}z^{4}S_{m}(z) and both R_{m}(w) and S_{m}(z) tend to constants as m tends to infinity for |z|,|w|