Finite-temperature Sp(4) Yang-Mills theory: towards the continuum Davide Vadacchino Abstract (on behalf of the TELOS collaboration) We present numerical results obtained in a finite-temperature study of the Sp(4) Yang-Mills theory on the lattice. We study its first-order confinement/deconfinement phase transition, by reconstructing the density of states via the Logarithmic Linear Relaxation (LLR) algorithm. We perform our measurements on lattices with different extents of space and time (and aspect ratios). We estimate the size of discretisation and finite-volume artefacts. We find clear signatures of a first-order transition. We determine the critical coupling, the specific heat, and the surface tension, for finite extents of the thermal circle, and use the results to set bounds for the continuum theory. [a,b,c]Fabian Zierler TUM-EFT 207/26 1 Introduction Non-Abelian, confining gauge theories, possibly coupled to new fermion matter field content, are promising candidates for the short-distance completion of proposals for Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics with composite dynamical origin. Their properties can be used to address a broad range of open phenomenological questions, ranging from the origin of dark matter, to electroweak and Higgs physics, and to the generation of mass of SM fermions—see for instance the reviews in Refs. [ 28 , 8 , 10 , 1 ] and references therein. One of the exciting aspects of some of these theories is that they lead to a relic stochastic background of gravitational waves (GWs), if the new physics underwent a phase transition in the early universe [ 33 ] . This signal is potentially detectable by the next generation of ground and space based experiments [ 24 , 9 ] . Yet, computing a precise prediction of the gravitational wave power spectrum is not straightforward. To determine the gravitational wave spectrum within the thin-wall approximation, one requires knowledge of the latent heat and the confined-deconfined surface tension [ 17 , 15 , 18 ] , which are the subjects of the SU(N) lattice studies in Refs. [ 23 , 7 , 32 ] . Alternative approaches based on models involving the Polyakov loop have also been proposed—see for instance Refs. [ 17 , 31 , 29 ] . The strongly coupled nature of non-Abelian gauge theories requires non-perturbative tools in order to make theoretical predictions. The methods of lattice field theory provide a first-principles, systematically improvable approach to determine numerically the non-perturbative properties of these theories. They rely on sampling the space of possible gauge field configurations, \{U\} , to determine the expectation value, or ensemble average, of operators of interest, O , defined as \displaystyle\langle O\rangle= \displaystyle\frac{1}{Z}\int D[U]\mathcal{O}[U]\exp\left(-\beta S[U]\right)\,, (1) where the normalisation of the ensemble average is given by \displaystyle Z= \displaystyle\int D[U]\exp\left(-\beta S[U]\right). (2) The existence of first-order phase transitions in Yang-Mills theories has been established numerically for gauge theories with SU(N>2) [ 23 , 27 , 22 , 32 ] , Sp(2N>2) [ 16 ] , and G_{2} [ 11 , 30 ] gauge group. It is challenging to achieve the required precision with standard lattice algorithms based on importance sampling, as their effectiveness is limited in the presence of a first-order phase transition. Due to the phenomenon of phase coexistence, the distribution in Eqs. ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) has a bimodal character in the proximity of the transition, and standard importance sampling algorithms struggle to sample the path integral efficiently, because the Markov chains tend to get stuck in one phase. The Logarithmic Linear Relaxation (LLR) algorithm [ 20 , 19 ] provides an alternative algorithm to describe Yang-Mills theories in proximity of a first-order phase transition. Building on our earlier work on SU(3) on a fixed lattice volume [ 21 ] , and on the thermodynamic limit Sp(4) for fixed thermal circle, N_{t}=4 [ 5 ] , in this contribution we present new results for Sp(4) with N_{t}=5 . This research is a necessary step towards the continuum limit. More details can be found in Ref. [ 4 ] . 2 Density-of-states & Logarithmic Linear Relaxation We circumvent the limitations of importance sampling methods by using an approach based on the density of states, \rho(E) . For operators that depend only on the energy, \mathcal{O}(S[U]=E) , we rewrite Eqs. ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) as a one dimensional integral over the energy \displaystyle\langle O\rangle \displaystyle=\frac{1}{Z}\int{\rm d}E\rho(E)\mathcal{O}(E)\exp\left(-\beta S[E]\right)\,, (3) \displaystyle Z \displaystyle=\int{\rm d}E\rho(E)\exp\left(-\beta S[U]\right)\,, (4) where we have defined the density of states as \displaystyle\rho(E) \displaystyle=\int D[U]\delta\left(S[U]-E\right)\,. (5) In order to determine the density of states precisely and reliably, we follow the process outlined in Ref. [ 20 , 19 ] , and employ a linear logarithmic approximation of the density of states. We write \displaystyle\rho(E)=\rho(0)\exp\left[-\int_{0}^{E}{\rm d}\bar{E}a(\bar{E})\right]\,, (6) where a(E) is a piecewise-linear function, defined by splitting the energy into small intervals. The coefficients a_{n} and c_{n} determine the density of states as \displaystyle\log\rho(E)\simeq a_{n}\left(E^{0}_{n}-E\right)+c_{n}\,, (7) in a given interval centred around E^{0}_{n} . The coefficients c_{n} are determined from requiring continuity—up to the first coefficient, c_{0} , which corresponds to \rho(0) and drops out of the ensemble averages. The remaining coefficients, a_{n} , are determined by considering the following expectation value, which we denote with double brackets: \displaystyle\langle\kern-1.69998pt\langle O\rangle\kern-1.69998pt\rangle(\hat{a}) \displaystyle=\int D[A]O[A]W\!(E_{n},\delta)\exp\left[\left(S[A]-E_{n}\right)\hat{a}\right]\,, (8) and where we introduced the function \displaystyle W(x,\delta) \displaystyle=\begin{cases}1&\text{if }x\in\left[-\delta/2,+\delta/2\right]\\ 0&\text{else}\end{cases}\,, (9) in which \hat{a} is for now an arbitrary parameter. The purpose of W is to restrict the energy range to a finite interval. We compute a_{n} by setting O=S[A]-E_{n} and requiring its vanishing \displaystyle\langle\kern-1.69998pt\langle O=S[A]-E_{n}\rangle\kern-1.69998pt\rangle(\hat{a}=a_{n})=0\,. (10) To find the (unique) root of Eq. ( 10 ), and hence a_{n} , we define a stochastic, non-linear, iterative process, with the following prescription for the (i+1) -th iteration step \displaystyle a_{n}^{(i+1)}=a_{n}^{(i)}-b^{(i)}\langle\kern-1.69998pt\langle S[A]-E_{n}\rangle\kern-1.69998pt\rangle(a_{n}^{(i)}). (11) Initially, we start with several Newton-Raphson update steps, for which b_{i}\equiv 1 . Then we adopt the simple choice b_{i}=1/i for the Robbins-Monro prescription, that satisfy the relations \displaystyle\sum_{i}b_{i}\to\infty\,,\quad\quad\quad\quad\sum_{i}b_{i}^{2}=\text{finite}\,. (12) This procedure may be affected by a potential ergodicity problem. By constraining every Markov chain to a single energy interval when calculating \langle\kern-1.69998pt\langle O\rangle\kern-1.69998pt\rangle , we might miss gauge configurations with energies in the same interval that are only connected via intermediate energies outside the selected interval. To circumvent this potential issue, we implement additionally a parallel tempering approach. We consider energies in the range \left[E_{\min},E_{\max}\right] and choose N_{\rm rep} evenly-spaced, overlapping intervals and start a Markov chain for every energy interval. After every update we swap the Markov chains of two neighbouring intervals, n and n+1 , with a probability of \displaystyle P_{\rm swap}=\min\left(1,e^{\left(S[A^{(n)}]-S[A^{(n+1)}]\right)\left(a^{(n)}-a^{(n+1)}\right)}\right). (13) We allow the first and last interval to probe energies below E_{\min} and above E_{\max} , respectively. 3 Lattice Setup We express the Wilson gauge action in terms of the plaquette, U=U_{\mu\nu} , as \displaystyle S[U]=\frac{1}{N_{c}}\sum_{x}\sum_{\mu<\nu}{\rm Re}~{\rm Tr}\left[1-U_{\mu\nu}(x)\right]\equiv 6N_{t}N_{s}^{3}\left(1-u_{p}[U]\right)\,, (14) where N_{c}=2N=4 for Sp(4) . The hypercubic lattice has lattice spacing a and N_{t} lattice sites in the temporal (thermal) direction and N_{s} lattice sites in the space directions. The averaged plaquette, u_{p} , will be later used as a proxy for the energy, E . We impose periodic boundary conditions, and interpret the temporal lattice extent (with N_{t}