Computing with many encoded logical qubits beyond break-even Shival Dasu, Matthew DeCross, Andrew Y. Guo, Ali Lavasani, Jan Behrends, Asmae Benhemou, Yi-Hsiang Chen, Karl Mayer, Chris N. Self, Selwyn Simsek, Basudha Srivastava, M.S. Allman, Jake Arkinstall, Justin G. Bohnet, Nathaniel Q. Burdick, J.P. Campora III, Alex Chernoguzov, Samuel F. Cooper, Robert D. Delaney, Joan M. Dreiling, Brian Estey, Caroline Figgatt, Cameron Foltz, John P. Gaebler, Alex Hall, Craig A. Holliman, Ali A. Husain, Akhil Isanaka, Colin J. Kennedy, Yuga Kodama, Nikhil Kotibhaskar, Nathan K. Lysne, Ivaylo S. Madjarov, Michael Mills, Alistair R. Milne, Brian Neyenhuis, Annie J. Park, Anthony Ransford, Adam P. Reed, Steven J. Sanders, Charles H. Baldwin, David Hayes, Ben Criger, Andrew C. Potter, David Amaro Abstract High-rate quantum error correcting (QEC) codes encode many logical qubits in a given number of physical qubits, making them promising candidates for quantum computation. Implementing high-rate codes at a scale that both frustrates classical computing and improves performance by encoding requires both high fidelity gates and long-range qubit connectivity—both of which are offered by trapped-ion quantum computers. Here, we demonstrate computations that outperform their unencoded counterparts in the high-rate ⟦ k + 2 , k , 2 ⟧ \left\llbracket k+2,\,k,\,2\right\rrbracket iceberg quantum error detecting (QED) and ⟦ ( k 2 + 2 ) ( k 1 + 2 ) , k 2 k 1 , 4 ⟧ \left\llbracket(k_{2}+2)(k_{1}+2),\,k_{2}k_{1},\,4\right\rrbracket two-level concatenated iceberg QEC codes, using the 98-qubit Quantinuum Helios trapped-ion quantum processor. Utilizing new gadgets for encoded operations, we realize this “beyond break-even” performance with reasonable postselection rates across a range of fault-tolerant (FT) and partially-fault-tolerant (pFT) component and application benchmarks with between 48 48 and 94 94 logical qubits. These benchmarks include FT state preparation and measurement, QEC cycle benchmarking, logical gate benchmarking, GHZ state preparation, and a pFT quantum simulation of the three-dimensional X ​ Y XY model of quantum magnetism. Additionally, we illustrate that postselection rates can be suppressed by increasing the code distance via concatenation. Our results represent state-of-the-art logical component and state fidelities and provide evidence that high-rate QED/QEC codes are viable on contemporary quantum computers for near-term beyond-classical-scale computation. Achieving high fidelity in lengthy quantum computations necessary for most practical applications requires encoding logical qubits into a larger number of physical qubits in a quantum code to suppress errors. Computation and error correction with encoded logical qubits adds space (memory) and time (circuit complexity) overheads, that, so far, have limited experimental implementations on existing quantum hardware to modest numbers of logical qubits that do not yet challenge the limits of classical computation. The arbitrary qubit connectivity available in trapped-ion and neutral atom devices enables a variety of geometrically non-local codes with substantially reduced overheads Yoder et al. 2025 ; Yoshida et al. 2025 ; Berthusen and Durso-Sabina 2025 . As an extreme example, iceberg quantum error-detection (QED) codes Gottesman 1997 ; Chao and Reichardt 2018 ; Self et al. 2024 require only two additional physical qubits to encode an arbitrary number of logical qubits capable of detecting any single-qubit error. In this work, we introduce a family of concatenated iceberg codes that generalize many-hypercubes codes Goto 2024 to variable code block sizes to achieve asymptotically high encoding rates and code distances Yoshida et al. 2025 . Using the 98-qubit Quantinuum Helios trapped-ion quantum processor Ransford et al. 2025 (see Methods .1 for hardware details), we implement iceberg codes at the first and second levels of concatenation, respectively forming QED and quantum error correction (QEC) codes of distances d=2 and 4 . While arbitrary error suppression ultimately requires fully fault-tolerant (FT) operation, there is a significant leap in complexity and scale of computation before FT algorithms can outperform unencoded ones. To bridge this gap, partially fault-tolerant (pFT) techniques Akahoshi et al. 2024 ; Ibe et al. 2025 that can immediately improve upon unencoded performance and extend the practical reach of quantum computers can be useful, even if these techniques do not scale efficiently to asymptotically large circuits. In Quantinuum trapped-ion quantum processors, a practical pFT scheme consists in implementing arbitrary-angle logical Pauli rotations via continuously-parameterized native two-qubit Pauli rotations to avoid the sizable cost of FT non-Clifford gate synthesis Jin et al. ; Yamamoto et al. 2025 . This work reports encoded (“logical”) vs. unencoded (“physical”) performance results across a range of FT and pFT techniques, including experiments with up to 94 logical qubits in iceberg QED codes, and up to 48 logical qubits in concatenated iceberg QEC codes. For iceberg QED codes, we introduce improved FT initialization, syndrome extraction, and readout gadgets, as well as new FT and pFT gates, that develop iceberg codes as a practical tool for beyond-classical-scale quantum computation. We show that encoded algorithms can outperform their unencoded counterparts, that is, demonstrate beyond break-even performance, on a variety of logical benchmarks including state preparation-and-measurement (SPAM) experiments, cycle benchmarking of logical gates, preparation of GHZ states, and the dynamics of the three-dimensional XY model relevant to simulation of magnetic materials. For concatenated iceberg QEC codes, we similarly introduce improvements to initialization, QEC, and entangling gadgets, demonstrating beyond break-even performance on SPAM experiments and the preparation of GHZ states. We benchmark the performance of the newly introduced QEC cycle and find below pseudo-threshold performance for the \left\llbracket 80,\,48,\,4\right\rrbracket code. Additionally, we find improved QEC acceptance rates for the \left\llbracket 16,\,4,\,4\right\rrbracket code compared to analogous QED acceptance rates for the \left\llbracket 4,\,2,\,2\right\rrbracket code at comparable fidelity, allowing for longer FT computations to be performed at higher levels of concatenation. Postselecting out detectable, but not correctable, weight- d/2 faults in even-distance codes should not be misconstrued as a non-scalable technique, since, below threshold, both the error rate and the postselection overheads are exponentially suppressed with increasing code distance. Figure 1: Iceberg codes and their concatenation (a) Grid layout depicting stabilizers and logical operators of the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} code. (b) SPAM infidelity per logical qubit across experiments, some using leakage-heralded measurement and/or non-destructive extraction of S_{X} . Note that the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} SPAM experiment recorded no logical errors, bounding the infidelity as indicated in the rightmost column. (c) Acceptance rates across each SPAM experiment. When leakage-heralded measurement is used, the leakage acceptance rate is outlined (black, dashed). (d) The QEC cycle for the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} code; Z stabilizer syndrome extraction is shown, and is followed by extraction of the X stabilizers. EDZ denotes d=2 Bell-pair syndrome extraction. (e) Fidelity and acceptance rate (AR) as a function of number of QEC/SE cycles for (concatenated) iceberg codes for different logical basis input states. All uncertainties reported through this work denote 68% Wilson confidence intervals unless otherwise noted, with point estimates corresponding to empirical observations. Acceptance and fidelity curves are obtained from fitting the data to exponential decays using maximum likelihood estimation. Fit values are given in Methods .2 . Concatenated Iceberg Codes: Iceberg codes, \mathcal{I}_{k} , are low-overhead quantum error-detecting (QED) codes that encode an even number, k , of logical qubits at code distance d=2 using only two additional qubits for a total of n=k+2 physical qubits Gottesman 1997 ; Chao and Reichardt 2018 ; Self et al. 2024 . The stabilizer generators S_{X} and S_{Z} of an iceberg code are global Pauli products: S_{X/Z}=\prod_{j=0}^{n-1}(X/Z)_{j} . Any Pauli operator containing an even number of X ’s and Z ’s is a logical operator. These can be generated by \overline{X}^{j}=X_{0}X_{j} and \overline{Z}^{j}=Z_{j}Z_{k+1} for 1\leq j\leq k . Here we index physical qubit operators by subscripts with range [n]\equiv\{0,1,\dots n-1\} , and logical operators with an overline and superscripts with range \{1,2,\dots k\} , and use index-raising to denote encoding qubits into the logical qubits of a code. Iceberg QED codes can be promoted to QEC codes using concatenation (see, e.g. Ref. Goto 2024 ), which takes as input two iceberg codes, \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}} and \mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} , and outputs a code, \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}}\circ\mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} , with parameters \left\llbracket n_{2}n_{1},\,k_{2}k_{1},\,d_{2}d_{1}\right\rrbracket . This procedure can be visualized as in Fig. 1 a by arranging the physical qubits into an n_{1}\times n_{2} grid with Pauli- X and Z operators labeled X_{i,j} and Z_{i,j} ( i\in[n_{1}],j\in[n_{2}] ) respectively. The qubits in each row are encoded into \mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} codes and then \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}} codes are encoded on each of the k_{1} logical qubit columns. The X and Z stabilizers of the concatenated code consist of Pauli X or Z products along rows (the stabilizers of the \mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} codes) and pairs of columns (the stabilizers of the encoded \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}} codes), and the \overline{X} and \overline{Z} logical operators are rectangles of physical X or Z operators (see Fig. 1 a). This concatenation procedure can be straightforwardly iterated to higher levels to achieve larger distances. In the following, we implement only the first two concatenation levels for iceberg codes, exploring a variety of iceberg QED codes with up to 94 logical qubits and concatenated iceberg QEC codes with up to 48 logical qubits (the largest for which a full QEC cycle can be executed on Helios). Encoding and readout: Encoding physical qubits into logical qubits is an essential first step for FT computation. To this end, we introduce and benchmark improved encoding circuits and logical readout protocols for iceberg codes with and without concatenation. The logical zero state of the iceberg code \mathcal{I}_{k} , |\overline{0}\rangle^{\otimes k} , is a GHZ state |\text{GHZ}_{n}\rangle on all physical qubits Self et al. 2024 . In the d=4 concatenated iceberg code, the logical zero state |\overline{0}\rangle^{\otimes k_{1}k_{2}} is the tensor product of the logical GHZ states over each \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}} logical qubit column: |\overline{\text{GHZ}}_{k_{2}}\rangle^{\otimes k_{1}}. To prepare the d=2 logical zero state, a physical GHZ state preparation circuit can be used, which starts with a |+\rangle state and subsequently incorporates more qubits via a tree of CX gates. To prepare the d=4 logical zero state, we follow a similar procedure replacing physical qubits with iceberg codes. Starting with a |\bar{+}\rangle^{\otimes k_{1}} \mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} block, other blocks are incorporated via a tree of transversal logical CX gates. In both cases, X errors during the circuit can cascade through the CX gates, causing a high-weight error on the output. To ensure fault-tolerance, we catch these errors by measuring ZZ operators at the ends of certain pairs of tree branches Goto 2024 . In the d=2 case, we introduce a FT state preparation and measurement (SPAM) circuit using a log-depth tree, which uses up to n/4 ancilla qubits and up to n/2 additional CX gates. In the d=4 case, we introduce a two-branch circuit, with a modified tree structure and additional error-checking to catch additional errors which cannot occur in the d=2 case. We use repeat-until-success (RUS), decoherence free subspace (DFS) techniques, and dynamical decoupling (DD) to increase acceptance rates and suppress errors in some d=2 encoding and QED gadgets throughout this work (the third only for XY model simulations as well as SPAM experiments extracting S_{X} ); for additional details, see Supplementary Information (SI) Sec. I . In some SPAM experiments, we only extract one syndrome destructively ( S_{Z} ), in contrast to the final syndrome measurement proposed in Refs. Self et al. 2024 ; Jin et al. . We benchmark the performance of fault-tolerantly preparing 48 logical qubits in the d=2 and d=4 cases in the \mathcal{I}_{48} and \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} codes, respectively (see Fig. 1 b, c, SI. Sec. II ). Both the d=2 case and d=4 case achieve beyond-break-even performance compared to the physical SPAM error on Helios Ransford et al. 2025 by at least an order of magnitude, with d=4 exhibiting improved fidelities and acceptance rates compared to d=2 , demonstrating the additional error-correction power of the concatenated QEC codes compared to their QED counterparts. In some experiments, we use the leakage-heralded measurement available on Helios (Methods .1 ) and compare to the physical leakage-heralded measurement error correspondingly. Syndrome Extraction and QEC: Once encoded, quantum error detection and/or correction are required to prevent physical errors from spreading into logical ones. Here, we introduce new methods for performing (QEC) QED on (concatenated) iceberg codes, which are optimized to Helios. For the d=2 case, both mid-circuit syndrome extraction (SE) and readout of the logical state are performed by extending the protocol Jin et al. to use GHZ states in the X or Z basis to improve parallelization of gates (shown later in Fig. 3 b; see also SI Sec. III ). We use four-qubit GHZ states that allow syndrome extraction gates to be parallelized in groups of 8 , matching the number of gate zones in Helios Ransford et al. 2025 . For concatenated iceberg codes, previous work on closely-related many-hypercubes codes Goto 2024 ; Goto 2025 proposed using Knill-style QEC that involves preparing two ancillary logical code blocks per QEC cycle, incurring significant spacetime overhead to the QEC cycle. Here, we instead introduce a lower-overhead scheme that generalizes the d=2 QEC protocol (with a Bell pair of ancilla) by replacing the physical ancilla qubits in that scheme with lower-concatenation-level d=2 iceberg code blocks, followed by regular d=2 syndrome extraction on each of the lower-level \mathcal{I}_{6} blocks. For the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} code, the resulting circuit, shown in Fig. 1 d, uses only 18 physical ancilla qubits, and has depth 18 , representing a substantial reduction in the spacetime overhead compared to Knill-Style QEC. The QEC cycle in this work is similar to the improvement proposed in Ref. Nakai and Goto 2026 , a follow-up to Ref. Goto 2024 which appeared during the writing of this manuscript for a subsystem version of concatenated iceberg codes. The physical qubit overhead in Ref. Nakai and Goto 2026 for the subsystem code would be the same, with the additional advantage of not requiring the lower-level ancilla to be encoded for the extraction of either high- or low- level stabilizers. Conversely, the QEC cycle and decoder introduced here is fault-tolerant for circuit-level noise as discussed in SI Sec. IV , whereas the QEC cycle in Ref. Nakai and Goto 2026 was introduced only for phenomenological noise. Implementing this procedure for the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} concatenated iceberg code with 48 logical qubits, we observe an average QEC-cycle infidelity per logical qubit (see Methods .2 ) upper-bounded by 4\times 10^{-5} with no logical errors recorded in five thousand shots in each basis, and an acceptance rate (AR) of 0.62(2) when postselecting out uncorrectable errors. Because leakage-heralded measure as well as DD were used in all logical memory experiments, a natural point of comparison for this encoded logical memory experiment is the (non-leakage component of the) physical linear memory error accrued over a depth-1 time: 1.1(3)\times 10^{-4} ( Ransford et al. 2025 , Methods .2 ). By this comparison, QEC improves the memory error over that for unencoded physical qubits, indicating that the hardware is below the pseudo-threshold for this d=4 concatenated iceberg code. Next, we examine the effect of increasing the code distance on the logical memory performance. To this end, we shift our focus to smaller (concatenated) iceberg codes with 4 logical qubits: \mathcal{I}_{2}\circ\mathcal{I}_{2} or two copies of \mathcal{I}_{2} . The higher AR per QEC cycle of these smaller codes allow us to explore sequences with many repeated rounds of QEC (Fig. 1 e) without a prohibitively high shot overhead. We observe that increasing the distance from 2 to 4 by concatenation significantly boosts the AR (averaged over both initial states) from 0.945(2) to 0.972_{-2}^{+1} . The infidelities, <4\times 10^{-5} and 2^{+8}_{-2}\times 10^{-5} for distances 2 and 4 respectively, are indistinguishable up to statistical uncertainty. As the discard rate is several orders of magnitude higher than the logical error rate, this demonstrates that the length of a FT computation can be scaled up by increasing the code distance through concatenation. Figure 2: Logical gate benchmarking and GHZ state preparation (a) Circuit gadgets for an inter-block U_{ZZ} gate and the FANOUT gate. Here t=q_{0} is the “top” qubit and b=q_{n-1} is the “bottom” qubit on each code block with indices labeling the code block. (b) Infidelity per logical gate for each gate considered in the main text, reported alongside the physical U_{ZZ}(\pi/2) fidelity from Ransford et al. 2025 , both including ( \tilde{\epsilon}_{2Q} ) and excluding (2QRB) transport overheads. (c) Preparing a GHZ state distributed over many \mathcal{I}_{4} code blocks using the log-depth FANOUT tree, represented in shorthand by controlled gates with stars, followed by extraction of the \prod_{i}\overline{X}^{i} GHZ stabilizer where red (purple) gates couple to qubit q_{0} ( q_{5} ) alone on each block. (d) GHZ state preparation in the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} code as described in the text. (e) GHZ infidelity and acceptances across the various experiments. Note that the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} ( k=48 ) and leakage-heralded 15\times\mathcal{I}_{4} ( k=60 ) experiments both recorded no errors. Benchmarking a universal logical gate set: Unlike physical benchmarking, logical gate benchmarking must incorporate the effects of syndrome extraction, state preparation, and readout at the encoded level. Here, we perform logical gate benchmarking to estimate the average fidelity of a universal logical gate set that entangles logical qubits within or between \mathcal{I}_{4} code block(s), demonstrating break-even performance over physical gates. We employ a logical version of cycle benchmarking (CB) Combes et al. 2017 ; Erhard et al. 2019 (see Methods .3 , SI Sec. V ), which involves interleaving repeated layers of a chosen multi-qubit Clifford operation (“cycle”) with random Pauli gates. Fitting the (exponential) decay of the expectation value of a randomly sampled Pauli observable vs. depth—after postselecting via syndrome extraction rounds interspersed every 8 logical gates (chosen to roughly optimize gate performance)—extracts an estimate of the Pauli fidelity, which can be used to compute the fidelity of the logical gate. Using this approach, we benchmark the following universal pFT gate set (Fig. 2 a, see also SI Sec. VI ) consisting of: non-FT intra- and inter-code block U_{ZZ}(\theta)=e^{-i\frac{\theta}{2}\overline{ZZ}} 1 1 1 We benchmark the gate at \theta=\pi/2 ; in general Helios can implement either gate with arbitrary \theta and we expect that logical error decreases with \theta similar to the physical gate, since the probability of a single fault causing a logical error is correspondingly scaled down. , as well as a FT logical FANOUT gate. The latter implements a global logical parity flip \prod_{i}\overline{X}^{i} on all logical qubits in one code block, controlled by a logical qubit in another code block. The resulting average logical gate infidelities, all between (1.0-1.2)\times 10^{-4} , are summarized in Fig. 2 b. Crucially, these logical fidelities significantly outperform the bare physical two-qubit gate errors of \sim 8\times 10^{-4} on Helios Ransford et al. 2025 , not to mention the implied two-qubit gate fidelities \tilde{\epsilon}_{2Q}\sim 2\times 10^{-3} obtained from full-circuit benchmarks that include other substantial overheads. Preparing large logical entangled states: We now benchmark the high-fidelity preparation of entangled resource states of many logical qubits, specifically, GHZ states, in various sizes and combinations of iceberg codes. Details of the unencoded GHZ state fidelity protocol can be found in SI Sec. VII . The logical GHZ state for a single \mathcal{I}_{k} code block factorizes into a physical GHZ state on physical qubits 1,\dots k and a Bell pair on qubits 0,k+1 , which can be directly prepared by a small modification of the usual encoding circuit (SI Sec. VIII ). To prepare logical GHZ states spanning multiple iceberg code blocks, we initialize a single code block in a logical GHZ state, and apply a log-depth tree of logical FANOUT gates (Fig. 2 c) to extend the GHZ state across other code blocks that were initialized to \ket{\bar{0}}^{\otimes k} . This approach saves many physical 2Q gates compared to the standard implementation using transversal CX gates. To benchmark the resulting GHZ state fidelity in both cases, we perform simultaneous (single-shot) FT measurements of the logical GHZ stabilizers ( \bar{Z}^{i}\bar{Z}^{i+1} and \prod_{i}\bar{X}^{i} ) (see Methods .4 ). To explore the effects of code concatenation, we develop a FT GHZ state preparation protocol on a concatenated iceberg code block that generalizes more straightforwardly to higher concatenation levels. The protocol (Fig. 2 d) uses level-1 \mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} ancilla prepared in a logical GHZ state as described above, to fault-tolerantly measure the level-2 logical GHZ stabilizer \prod_{i,j}\overline{X}^{i,j} (defined in Methods .4 ). To ensure robustness to up to two measurement errors the logical GHZ stabilizer measurement is performed twice. Additionally, the X,Z stabilizers and \overline{Z} observables of the level-1 GHZ state are extracted, which allows us to correct one error occurring anywhere in the full d=4 protocol (see Methods .4 for further details). SI Sec. IX contains simulations of fault tolerance and a more detailed analysis. Results for logical GHZ state (in)fidelity and acceptance rates are displayed in Fig. 2 e and reported in SI Sec. VIII for \mathcal{I}_{48} , \mathcal{I}_{60} , and \mathcal{I}_{94} codes, the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} code, and for k=48,\,60 logical qubits distributed among \mathcal{I}_{4} code blocks. Across the board, encoding yields large improvements to logical GHZ state fidelity with greater gains coming from the improved fault-tolerance of the \mathcal{I}_{4} code blocks and the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} code. In particular, we measure \sim\!95\% fidelity in the \mathcal{I}_{94} code and recorded no logical errors in the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} and leakage-heralded k=60 , \mathcal{I}_{4} codes over several thousand shots. Figure 3: Mirror benchmarking of encoded Hamiltonian simulation (a) The natural edge- 6 -coloring of the 4\times 4\times 4 periodic cubic lattice. Edges connecting the periodic boundaries are omitted for visual clarity, but the corresponding gates are included in the circuits executed. (b) Logical mirror benchmarking circuits used to assess the fidelity of Hamiltonian simulation. For the purposes of illustration, the circuit shown uses an \mathcal{I}_{10} code with dynamics governed by a 6-regular graph on 10 vertices. (c) Logical gates implementing the first-order Trotter circuit depicted in (b). In the “reverse” half of the circuit, the inverse gates (dashed) are used in the opposite order. (d) Fidelity estimate and acceptance rate as a function of total Trotter steps in the full mirrored circuit. The fidelity estimate inset displays the last three points on a log scale for clarity. Each heuristic depolarizing error model (dashed) is labeled with its corresponding effective 2Q error rate \tilde{\epsilon}_{2Q} (see Methods .1 , SI Sec. XI ). Computing: Finally, we put these ingredients together for an application-level benchmark of the pFT operation of an iceberg code, inspired by magnetic materials simulation. The iceberg code is particularly well-tailored to the simulation of quantum magnetism with Hamiltonians of the form H=\sum_{\alpha\in x,y,z}\sum_{i,j}J^{\alpha}_{i,j}\sigma^{\alpha}_{i}\sigma^{\alpha}_{j} , whose terms are each logical operators that are simple to implement in a pFT manner. Trotterized evolution under such Hamiltonians can be implemented with no extra overhead in an \mathcal{I}_{k} code using Helios’ native physical gate set. This direct implementation of logical gates is not FT—a single 2Q gate error with Pauli components XX , YY , or ZZ leads to a logical error. However, due to bias in the native 2Q gate errors, these dangerous errors occur with probability \sim\!10\times lower than other detectable errors Moses et al. 2023 ; Haghshenas et al. 2025 . This pFT computation scheme mixing FT state preparation, syndrome extraction, and measurement with non-FT Hamiltonian simulation gates enables a significant fidelity improvement over unencoded simulations of quantum computations at a scale that challenges classical simulation. To benchmark this pFT scheme, we implement a logical version of the standard mirror-benchmarking (MB) protocol Proctor et al. 2022a ; Proctor et al. 2022b ; Mayer et al. 2023 , that measures the survival probability P(t)=|\langle\psi_{0}|U(\frac{t}{2})^{\dagger}U(\frac{t}{2})|\psi_{0}\rangle|^{2} , where U(\frac{t}{2})=e^{-iHt/2} is implemented by s/2 Trotter steps with size \Delta t=t/s approximating the magnetic dynamics, and |\psi_{0}\rangle is a reference state. This protocol provides a sample-efficient way to estimate the global fidelity of time evolution for time t , without comparing to non-scalable classical simulations. Specifically, we implement logical MB for a three-dimensional ( 3 D) antiferromagnet with an easy-plane anisotropy to the spin-exchange, described by the paradigmatic XY -model Hamiltonian: H_{xz}=\sum_{\langle ij\rangle}h_{ij}=\sum_{\langle ij\rangle}J(X_{i}X_{j}+Z_{i}Z_{j}). where \langle ij\rangle denote nearest neighbors on a 3 D cubic lattice with dimensions 4\times 4\times 4 , and periodic boundary conditions. Here, we have chosen the easy-plane anisotropy to lie in the xz plane (rather than the conventional xy plane) for convenience of implementation in the iceberg code. We choose to study a 3 D model to connect to realistic bulk materials, showcase the flexible programmability of Helios’ QCCD architecture in implementing models of arbitrary dimension, and because this high-dimensional geometry offers a stronger challenge to competing classical simulation methods for forward time evolution circuits. We encode this system into a single \mathcal{I}_{64} iceberg code block, choosing a ferromagnetically polarized initial state |\psi_{0}\rangle=|\bar{0}\rangle^{\otimes 64} . The forward dynamics is implemented via s/2 first-order Trotter steps: U(s\Delta t/2)\approx U_{1}(\Delta t)^{s/2} , where U_{1}(\Delta t)=\prod_{C}\prod_{\langle ij\rangle\in C}e^{-ih_{ij}\Delta t} and C labels the 6 different sets of non-overlapping bonds indicated by the colorings shown in Fig. 3 a. We choose a step size J\Delta t=\pi/8 that is large enough to rapidly generate entanglement in a small number of Trotter steps, but small enough to be far from the Clifford limit of the system. Gates are Pauli-twirled using real-time random number generation Koch et al. to avoid coherent cancellation of errors. A single SE round is inserted between the forward ( U ) and backward ( U^{\dagger} ) time evolutions. The MB protocol concludes with Z -basis measurements of all physical qubits, from which we reconstruct both the survival probability and Z -stabilizers. The data is postselected on detecting no errors in the mid-circuit SE or final measurement. The resulting survival probability and acceptance rates for MB sequences of up to s=10 total Trotter steps are shown in Fig. 3 d for both unencoded and iceberg QED encoded, with and without postselection on detecting leakage outside of the qubit subspace of any of the k+2 data qubits. From exponential-decay fits to the survival probability versus logical gate number, we also extract an effective per-gate error \tilde{\epsilon}_{2Q} , which reflects a combination of gate errors and memory errors (see Methods .1 for details and SI Sec. X , XI for preliminary experimental results and more data). We observe that the effective error rate \tilde{\epsilon}_{2Q} is reduced \approx 30\% by encoding in the iceberg code, at the expense of a reasonable increase in shot count incurred by postselecting out detected errors. We note that obtaining high global state fidelity may be an overly conservative standard for quantum simulation applications that typically require the less stringent task of approximating local correlation functions. While the MB protocol itself is trivial to simulate classically, for chaotic many-body Hamiltonians such as H_{xz} , it serves as a proxy for the global state fidelity for simulating a purely forward-time-evolved initial state: U(s\Delta t)|0\rangle . We anticipate that the pure forward time evolution may be difficult—if at all possible—to simulate classically, due to the large number of logical qubits (which renders direct state-vector simulation infeasible), high dimensionality, periodic boundary conditions, and rapid entanglement spreading (all of which challenge tensor-network methods). Outlook: We demonstrate computations below break-even on many logical qubits encoded in iceberg codes and their concatenations on Quantinuum Helios. In particular, the favorable performance and overhead of the pFT simulation of the XY model with 64 logical qubits at distance-2 motivates extending this approach to more demanding condensed-matter models, such as the Fermi–Hubbard or Kitaev models, of both academic and industrial relevance. When higher algorithmic fidelity or acceptance rates are required, fully FT, below-threshold protocols on higher-distance codes become necessary Acharya et al. 2025 . We observe in this work that increasing the distance via concatenation already enhances acceptance rates without degrading fidelity. We further present alternative fault-tolerant resource-state preparation schemes (SI Sec. XII ) based on repeated stabilizer measurements, flag-at-origin Forlivesi and Amaro 2025 , and an automatically generated flag circuit—the latter outperforming the gadgets of Goto 2024 in depolarizing simulations. Decoding with look-up tables derived from circuit-level simulations is explored in SI Sec. XIII . They can provide a first layer of a hierarchical decoding pipeline, with other layers potentially leveraging the concatenated structure of iceberg codes Kakizaki 2026 . These codes additionally offer a low-overhead, naturally global logical gate set—including Clifford gates via automorphisms Liu et al. 2025a and global magic-state preparation Dasu et al. 2025 (as an alternative to distillation Sales Rodriguez et al. 2025 )—that warrants further investigation. These creative developments, together with advances in quantum architectures that offer arbitrary connectivity, including neutral-atom Bluvstein et al. 2024 and trapped-ion Ransford et al. 2025 platforms, are rapidly bringing fault-tolerant quantum computation with many logical qubits within reach. Author Contributions S.D., M.D., C.H.B., D.H., B.C., A.C.P., and D.A. devised the project and the protocol implementations. S.D. devised the distance-4 QEC cycle, with improvements from B.C., and decoder as well as distance-4 GHZ preparation protocol and developed code for and executed all distance-4 experiments and distance-2 syndrome extraction experiments. M.D. devised the GHZ-based distance-2 syndrome extraction as well as the FT FANOUT gate and its use in the GHZ experiments, and developed code for and executed distance-2 SPAM, GHZ state preparation, and XY model experiments. A.Y.G. developed code for and executed the logical gate benchmarking experiments. Y.-H. C. developed code for and executed the unencoded GHZ state preparation experiments. A.L., J.B., A.B., C.N.S., S.S., and B.S. performed additional simulations, QEC algorithm design, and circuit code development. A.Y.G., Y.-H. C., K.M., and C.H.B. developed the logical gate benchmarking analysis. M.S.A., J.A., J.G.B., N.Q.B., J.P.C. III, A.C., S.F.C., R.D.D., J.M.D., B.E., Car.F., Cam.F., J.P.G., A.H., C.A.H., A.A.H., A.I., C.J.K., Y.K., N.K., N.K.L., I.S.M., M.M., A.R.M., B.N., A.J.P., A.R., A.P.R., and S.J.S. designed, optimized, operated, and maintained the Helios hardware and software stack. D.A. directed the overall project as lead principal investigator. S.D., M.D., A.Y.G., A.L., J.B., A.B., Y.-H. C., S.S., N.Q.B., A.R., C.H.B., D.H., B.C., A.C.P., and D.A. contributed to the writing and editing of the manuscript. Competing Interests The authors declare no competing interests. Additional Information Supplementary Information is available for this paper. Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to David Amaro, david.amaro@quantinuum.com . Methods .1 Hardware specifications Helios is a 98-qubit trapped-ion quantum processor with {}^{137}\text{Ba}^{+} hyperfine qubits that implements the quantum charge-coupled device (QCCD) architecture introduced in Refs. Wineland et al. 1998 ; Kielpinski et al. 2002 , first realized in Ref. Pino et al. 2021 with {}^{171}\text{Yb}^{+} qubits. Here we present an abbreviated summary of the technical specifications of the processor presented in Ref. Ransford et al. 2025 . Qubit ions, along with their associated sympathetic coolant ions, are confined by the electromagnetic field generated by RF electrodes and physically transported around the ion trap by additional DC electrodes. The Helios architecture stores qubits in a large ring, sorts them by transport around the ring and through an X-junction Burton et al. 2023 into an intermediate “cache” region, and subsequently further transports the qubits into one of two “legs” for cooling, quantum logic operations and temporary storage (see Ref. Ransford et al. 2025 , Figs. 1 and 2). Enabled by a new classical control system and software stack, Helios implements real-time compilation of program operations (using the Guppy programming language Koch et al. ) into physical hardware commands on the device. This permits realization of many new algorithmic primitives, including dynamic allocation of qubits, classical control flow such as conditional statements and loops, early conditional termination of programs, and remote procedure calls to an external server that can perform arbitrary classical computations and return information needed for on-the-fly decisions about quantum logic (“gate streaming”, demonstrated in Refs. Niroula et al. 2025 , Liu et al. 2025b ). All primitive quantum logic operations (measurements, resets, and gates) on Helios are performed via interactions that are mediated by several lasers of different frequencies delivered to the QPU via free space; we refer the reader to Sec. IIB of Ref. Ransford et al. 2025 for further details. Qubits on Helios are initialized into the |0\rangle state. Arbitrary one-qubit (1Q) gating operations are decomposed by the compiler into U_{1Q}(\theta,\phi)=\exp\left(-i\frac{\theta}{2}(\cos(\phi)X+\sin(\phi)Y)\right) physical gates and R_{Z}(\theta)=\exp\left(-i\frac{\theta}{2}Z\right) gates that are implemented fully in software as phase updates. The two-qubit (2Q) gate is mediated by the Mølmer-Sørensen interaction made phase-insensitive via wrapper pulses and implements U_{ZZ}(\theta)=\exp\left(-i\frac{\theta}{2}ZZ\right) Lee et al. 2005 ; Pino et al. 2021 , where \theta is a user-specified angle and the gate error scales linearly with angle up to the maximal entangler \theta=\pi/2 Moses et al. 2023 . Several types of measurements are available on Helios; in addition to the standard (possibly mid-circuit) measurement of isolated qubits, requests for simultaneous measurement of batches of qubits can trigger compilation into a “protected” measurement operation that reduces crosstalk. Furthermore, users can request a ternary-valued measurement that may return 2 to herald that the measured qubit has leaked outside the qubit subspace, at the expense of extra measurement error since this scheme requires several additional optical pulses. The leakage-heralded measurement may similarly be protected if ternary measurements are requested on batches of qubits simultaneously. The infidelities associated to each of these quantum logic operations are reported in Table II of Ref. Ransford et al. 2025 . For self-contained comparisons to the logical benchmarks in this work, we note in particular that the SPAM error associated to the standard measurement was measured at p_{\text{SPAM}}=4.8(6)\times 10^{-4} per qubit, and the 2Q gate error was measured to be \epsilon_{2Q}=8(2)\times 10^{-4} at the maximum gate angle. In the full-circuit benchmarks studied in that work, including random Clifford and mirror circuits, several heuristic formulas for circuit fidelity were used to extract an “effective” 2Q gate infidelity \tilde{\epsilon}_{2Q} roughly following a depolarizing-channel model. These estimates include additional overheads such as memory errors incurred during qubit idling and predict an effective 2Q gate infidelity at the maximum angle of \tilde{\epsilon}_{2Q}=20(2)\times 10^{-4} . For comparison, in Fig. 3 we report \tilde{\epsilon}_{2Q} for XY model simulation experiments using partially -entangling gates ranging from \tilde{\epsilon}_{2Q}=10.7(5)\times 10^{-4} (unencoded) to \tilde{\epsilon}_{2Q}=7.1(6)\times 10^{-4} (encoded in \mathcal{I}_{64} , leakage-heralded). Here, and similarly to Ref. Ransford et al. 2025 , these values are extracted from a simple depolarizing model F(N_{\text{gates}})=A(1-\frac{5}{4}\tilde{\epsilon}_{2Q})^{N_{\text{gates}}} with N_{\text{gates}} the number of two-qubit gates in the circuit, so that \tilde{\epsilon}_{2Q} is an effective average fidelity and A is an overall normalization capturing SPAM errors. .2 QEC benchmarking For all k>1 QEC/QED experiments, due to the application of one or more rounds of QEC/QED, we assume that the logical memory channel on all k can be written as a stochastic logical Pauli channel Beale et al. 2018 . Therefore, we can write this channel in the form of \mathcal{E}(\rho)=\sum_{i}p_{i}P_{i}\rho P_{i}, (1) where the sum is over all k qubit Paulis. For the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} experiments, in which a single round of QEC was performed on \ket{\overline{0}}^{\otimes 48} and \ket{\bar{+}}^{\otimes 48} , we apply a union bound to the process fidelity. Let us denote by p_{\ket{\overline{0}}^{\otimes 48}} and p_{\ket{\bar{+}}^{\otimes 48}} the probability of any logical error occurring to the \ket{\overline{0}}^{\otimes 48} and \ket{\bar{+}}^{\otimes 48} states. The process infidelity is I=\sum p_{i} , where the p_{i} are the non-identity Pauli error probabilities in Eq. ( 1 ). Since any P_{i} containing an X or a Y will cause a logical error on \ket{\overline{0}}^{\otimes 48} and any P_{i} containing a Y or a Z will cause a logical error on \ket{\bar{+}}^{\otimes 48} , we have that \frac{1}{2}(p_{\ket{\overline{0}}^{\otimes 48}}+p_{\ket{\bar{+}}^{\otimes 48}})\leq I\leq p_{\ket{\overline{0}}^{\otimes 48}}+p_{\ket{\bar{+}}^{\otimes 48}}. (2) The average infidelity for this 48 -qubit process is essentially identical to the process infidelity in this case, differing by a factor of \frac{2^{48}}{2^{48}+1} , and we report the upper bound on the average infidelity divided by the number of logical qubits as the average infidelity of a QEC cycle per logical qubit for these experiments. For the k=4 experiments, repeated Pauli errors which may occur on a single qubit due to repeated applications of QEC/QED will cancel, so the above analysis does not apply directly. To deal with these cancellations, we restrict our attention to single-qubit logical memory channels by marginalizing over all but one qubit. For logical qubit j , the reduced channel for \tilde{\rho}=\tr_{[k]\backslash j}\rho is \mathcal{E}(\tilde{\rho})=\tilde{p}_{I}\tilde{\rho}+\tilde{p}_{X}X\tilde{\rho}X+\tilde{p}_{Y}Y\tilde{\rho}Y+\tilde{p}_{Z}Z\tilde{\rho}Z where \tilde{p}_{P} is the probability of the single qubit Pauli P being applied to \tilde{\rho} , which can be obtained by summing over the terms p_{i} in the full channel which apply a P operator to logical qubit j . The process infidelity \tilde{I_{j}} of the reduced channel is \tilde{p}_{X}+\tilde{p}_{Y}+\tilde{p}_{Z} . To estimate the \tilde{p}_{P} , we can make use of a formula which takes into account possible cancellations of Pauli errors for the survival probability of a single logical qubit under repeated rounds of QEC Ryan-Anderson et al. 2021 given by p_{\psi}(c)=\frac{1}{2}+\left(s_{\psi}-\frac{1}{2}\right)\left(1-2q_{\psi}\right)^{c}. (3) where p_{\psi}(c) is the survival probability of an initial state \ket{\overline{\psi}} after c rounds of QEC. The logical SPAM error of producing state \ket{\overline{\psi}} is s_{\psi} , and q_{\psi} is the probability of introducing a logical error to \ket{\overline{\psi}} after one round of QEC. Since both logical X and Y operators will flip \ket{\overline{0}} , we have that p_{\ket{\overline{0}}}=\tilde{p_{X}}+\tilde{p_{Y}} and, similarly, p_{\ket{\bar{+}}}=\tilde{p_{Y}}+\tilde{p_{Z}}. Therefore, we can estimate \tilde{I} from the survival probabilities of the input states over repeated rounds of QEC by again applying a union bound, \frac{1}{2}(p_{\ket{\overline{0}}}+p_{\ket{\bar{+}}})\leq\tilde{I}\leq p_{\ket{\overline{0}}}+p_{\ket{\bar{+}}}. (4) We obtain estimates for the p_{\psi} by fitting experimental data to the curve in Eq. ( 3 ) through maximum likelihood estimation to take into account non-normality of the sample distributions due to rare events. Uncertainties were derived from Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling of the curve-fitting parameters. For both k=4 experiments, we report the average of the upper bounds for these single-qubit infidelities as the infidelity of a QEC cycle per logical qubit. This quantity is the analog of the depth-1 memory error infidelity reported in Ransford et al. 2025 , which does not capture correlations in the noise between different qubits and instead treats the memory error as a single-qubit process. We note that when taking the average of the infidelity over the reduced channels, we add the statistical uncertainties of the infidelities linearly and not in quadrature, since the estimators for the different logical qubits are not independent. For all experiments, confidence intervals were obtained by adding the 1\sigma statistical uncertainty (68%) of all estimators to the lower and upper bounds in Eq. ( 2 ) and Eq. ( 4 ). The average infidelity 1.1(3)\times 10^{-4} corresponding to non-leakage component of the depth-1 linear memory error reported in the main text is obtained from the transport-1QRB benchmarking data from Ransford et al. 2025 . We fit the non-leakage-heralded memory error to the quadratic curve ax^{2}+bx-c where x is the number of transport rounds and b is the depth-1 linear memory error and a is the quadratic memory error. For those experiments, a=6(3)\times 10^{-5} , b=1.1(3)\times 10^{-4} , and c=2(5)\times 10^{-5} . We compare to the linear memory error because a limited amount of dynamical decoupling (DD) is used in all QEC/QED memory experiments in the second half of each cycle when the Z syndromes are extracted, since Z -type noise on the data qubits commutes with the gates therein and can therefore build coherently. In the d=4 case, X pulses are inserted before, at the midpoint of, and after the high-level syndromes are extracted, while in the d=2 case, X pulses are applied to the qubits that are gated in the second half of the Z syndrome extraction circuit, then to all the qubits at midpoint of Z syndrome extraction, and then to the qubits gated in the first half of syndrome extraction at the end of the QED cycle. This ensures that X pulses are applied opportunistically in a way that does not induce additional transport while commuting with the extracted stabilizers. In the first half of each cycle, no DD is used since X syndrome extraction should convert Z -type noise into incoherent errors. For all k=4 experiments, the QED/QEC cycle rejection rates over c\in\{1,2,4,8\} cycles were fitted to the exponential (1-r)^{c} , where r is the rejection rate per cycle. In the X basis, r=.060^{+2}_{-2} and r=.027_{-1}^{+2} , for d=2 and d=4 respectively. In the Z basis, r=.070_{-3}^{+2} , and r=.030_{-2}^{+2} , for d=2,4 respectively. For all d=2 and d=4 experiments, leakage-heralded measurement is used to postselect on any leakage, since leakage at certain locations can potentially violate fault-tolerance in the absence of gadgets which introduce additional overheads Brown et al. 2020 . An alternative solution is leakage repump Hayes et al. 2020 , which converts leakage into depolarizing noise that can be fault-tolerantly handled by QEC/QED without additional circuit gadgets. All QEC/QED acceptance rates reported are conditioned on the absence of leakage and successfully preparing the data and ancilla qubit code blocks. Leakage acceptance rates, and preacceptance rates for state preparation, are given in SI Sec. IV . .3 Logical gate benchmarking To perform logical cycle benchmarking on gates in/between \mathcal{I}_{4} code blocks, we sample a random logical Pauli string P over all logical qubits and initialize the system in one of its corresponding logical eigenstates. For inter-block gates between two \mathcal{I}_{4} blocks, Pauli strings of length 8 are used, reflecting the fact that faults can propagate across all logical qubits in both code blocks due to the nonlocal structure of syndrome-extraction gadgets. We repeat the Pauli-twirled logical gate (cycle) L times, perform syndrome extraction at a fixed frequency, and then measure in the P basis to obtain an estimate of the expectation value of P . We choose a maximum cycle depth of L=64 for intra-block gates and L=48 for inter-block gates. Syndrome-extraction gadgets are interleaved at a fixed cadence of one round per eight logical cycles, enabling detection of single-qubit faults and two-qubit Pauli errors not in the set \{XX,YY,ZZ\} that occur during gate execution or syndrome extraction. Any shot with a detected error is discarded, and the remaining shots are used for estimating the logical observable. Pauli twirling is implemented using shot-level randomness via the real-time random number generation implemented in the Guppy programming language. The Pauli twirling allows the aggregate error channel on the input state \rho to be written as a stochastic Pauli channel \mathcal{E}(\rho)=\sum_{i}p_{i}P_{i}\rho P_{i}, where the sum is over all Pauli operators (modulo an overall phase) and the Pauli error probabilities p_{i}\in[0,1] sum to 1. Taking a Walsh-Hadamard transform of these error probabilities, we obtain the Pauli fidelities , f_{j} , which are equivalent to the eigenvalues of the Pauli error channel. Specifically, f_{j}=\sum_{i}(-1)^{\langle i,j\rangle}p_{i}, where the symbol \langle i,j\rangle is 0 or 1 depending on whether the Paulis P_{i} and P_{j} commute or anti-commute. Denoting a noisy circuit of length L as C_{j} , the output of the Pauli-basis measurement is \mathbb{E}_{L}[P_{j}]=\text{Tr}({P_{j}C_{j}(P_{j})}) . We estimate the Pauli fidelity by fitting the expectation value decay with increasing L to an exponential model, i.e. \mathbb{E}_{L}[P_{i}]=A_{j}f_{j}^{L} . The fit is performed using maximum likelihood estimation (see SI Sec. V for more details). We then average the Pauli fidelities to obtain an estimate of the process fidelity F_{\mathrm{pro}} of the logical cycle, which, for the case of a single logical 2Q gate per cycle, can be converted to the gate-averaged fidelity via F_{\mathrm{avg}}=(4F_{\mathrm{pro}}+1)/5 . The F_{\text{avg}} for each of the three experiments are reported in Fig. 2 , along with error bars representing the 1\sigma (68%) confidence intervals obtained via standard parametric bootstrap. We discuss the details of the statistical analysis along with the postselection rates from error detection in SI Sec. V . .4 Logical GHZ state preparation We estimate the GHZ state preparation fidelity in the d=2 codes via a single-shot protocol, making use of the fact that the GHZ state is uniquely identified by its stabilizers \prod_{i}\overline{X}^{i} and \overline{Z}^{i}\overline{Z}^{i+1} . The former can be measured in a quantum non-destructive (QND) fashion while the latter can be obtained by destructive readout of all qubits in the Z basis. In contrast to other recent large-scale GHZ state experiments Javadi-Abhari et al. 2025 , we do not postselect on any of the GHZ stabilizers. The logical GHZ state in a single global \mathcal{I}_{k} code is particularly simple; as described in the main text, it factorizes into a physical GHZ state on n-2 qubits and a Bell pair. As such, it can be directly prepared fault-tolerantly by a circuit similar to the code initialization circuit (see SI Sec. VIII for an illustration). The GHZ stabilizer \prod_{i}\overline{X}^{i} can be measured efficiently since it is stabilizer-equivalent to X_{0}X_{n-1} . We measure X_{0}X_{n-1} twice to ensure robustness against measurement errors by coupling to a single ancilla each time that is dynamically allocated before reading out the parity. Break-even is relatively easy to achieve for logical GHZ state preparation on a global \mathcal{I}_{k} code block, since the protocol prepares a physical GHZ state of essentially comparable size and then enhances the logical fidelity via postselection. By contrast, preparing a logical GHZ state across many small iceberg code blocks is significantly more general and nontrivial, corresponding to a complicated entangled state of all physical qubits. We describe here the case of many \mathcal{I}_{4} iceberg code blocks, which uses the same FANOUT gate and code structure as in our logical gate benchmarking protocol. However, the preparation for any number and size of code blocks follows a similar structure. This protocol is displayed in Fig. 2 c and begins with preparation of one code block in the |\overline{\text{GHZ}}_{4}\rangle state by the procedure described above while all other code blocks are initialized in the |\overline{0}\rangle^{\otimes 4} state. We then extend the logical GHZ state on the first code block to the full logical GHZ state using the logical FANOUT gate described above. This gate maps the state |\overline{\text{GHZ}}_{k_{1}}\rangle\otimes|\overline{0}\rangle^{\otimes k_{2}} to the state |\overline{\text{GHZ}}_{k_{1}+k_{2}}\rangle when controlled on any logical qubit in the \mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} code. One then proceeds analogously to the usual GHZ state preparation (in which the |+\rangle state on one qubit is extended to the |\text{GHZ}\rangle state on all qubits by means of a tree of CX gates), by applying the logical FANOUT gate in a log-depth tree spanning iceberg code blocks. Each application of the logical FANOUT only requires four two-qubit gates compared to n when instead applying transversal CX gates between each pair of code blocks, and straightforwardly applies to the case that the code blocks are of incommensurate size. Subsequently, the GHZ stabilizer \prod_{i}\overline{X}^{i} can still be measured relatively efficiently using the product of X_{0}X_{n-1} across all code blocks. We order the gates so that first all top qubits q_{0} in each block are coupled to the ancilla followed by all bottom qubits q_{n-1} in the opposite order, c.f. Fig. 2 c, so that X hook errors are almost always detected on at least one code block. We again repeat the measurement of \prod_{i}\overline{X}^{i} to be FT to measurement errors on the ancilla. We note that although many applications of the \mathcal{I}_{k} codes use the pFT continuously-parameterized two-qubit Pauli rotation gates, both GHZ state preparation protocols detailed above are actually fully FT to single weight-2 faults. The logical operators of \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}}\circ\mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} are rectangles and we denote them by \overline{X}^{i,j}=X_{0,0}X_{i,0}X_{0,j}X_{i,j} , \overline{Z}^{i,j}=Z_{i,j}Z_{n_{1}-1,j}Z_{i,n_{2}-1}Z_{n_{1}-1,n_{2}-1} . To prepare a global GHZ state on the 48 logical qubits of the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} code, we begin by initializing a code block in the \ket{\overline{0}}^{\otimes 48} state. The stabilizers of this state already contain the Z-type GHZ stabilizers \overline{Z}^{i_{1},j_{1}}\overline{Z}^{i_{2},j_{2}} for 1\leq i_{1},i_{2}\leq 6,1\leq j_{1},j_{2},\leq 8 . To enforce the condition that \prod_{i=1,j=1}^{6,8}\overline{X}^{i,j} stabilizes the state, we measure this operator using an \mathcal{I}_{6} ancilla. We observe that the operator X_{0,0}X_{7,0}X_{0,9}X_{7,9} commutes with all the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} stabilizers and anticommutes with all \overline{Z}^{i,j} . Therefore, this operator is equal to \prod_{i=1,j=1}^{6,8}\overline{X}^{i,j} up to stabilizers. We can measure this operator by initializing an \mathcal{I}_{6} ancilla with stabilizer X_{0}X_{7} , performing transversal CX gates from this ancilla to the top and bottom blocks of the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} code, and then measuring this ancilla in the X basis, see Fig. 2 d. This will cause the state to collapse to a \pm 1 eigenvalue of \prod_{i=0,j=0}^{5,7}\overline{X}^{i,j} with random sign. We flip the sign of this eigenvalue in software to +1 by updating the Pauli frame. Since we are preparing the GHZ state in a d=4 code, we must measure the eigenvalue of \prod_{i=1,j=1}^{6,8}\overline{X}^{i,j} a second time to protect against two measurement/gate errors which could have caused a logical error in the first \mathcal{I}_{6} measurement. If the two \mathcal{I}_{6} measurements differ by a logical operator, we postselect. By postselecting in the presence of two faults, we will prepare the state with logical error rate of O(p^{3}) , and, by correcting a single error anywhere in the preparation procedure, the postselection probability will be O(p^{2}) . See SI Sec. IX for simulations demonstrating these scalings with the error rate. Supplementary Information for: Computing with many encoded logical qubits beyond break-even I State preparation and error mitigation techniques In the \mathcal{I}_{k} codes, we prepare the logical zero state |\overline{0}\rangle^{\otimes k}=|\text{GHZ}_{k}\rangle via a tree of CX gates that originate at a |+\rangle state with target qubits initialized in the |0\rangle state. This tree can be extended to contain up to n/2 branches where n=k+2 , in which case the state preparation proceeds in log depth. Pairs of branches are coupled to an ancilla qubit that reads out the ZZ operator of the qubits at the end of each branch; therefore, up to n/4 ancilla qubits and n/2 additional CX gates are required, although the ancilla qubits may be reused at the expense of reduced circuit parallelization. The simplest such case is the two-branch preparation presented in Ref. Jin et al. and for which the corresponding gate connectivity graph is displayed in Fig. S1 . Figure S1: Two-branch state preparation gadget in the \mathcal{I}_{k} codes. (a) Two-branch tree specifying preparation of the logical zero state of the \mathcal{I}_{48} code. Nodes are labeled with the index i corresponding to qubit q_{i} in the code. Qubit q_{0} is initialized in the |+\rangle state while all other qubits are initialized in the |0\rangle state; directed arrows indicate the control and target of CX gates between the qubits and all arrows terminating on nodes at the same vertical height are performed in parallel. The red bracket connecting the terminal nodes indicates that the corresponding operator Z_{48}Z_{49} will be read out by coupling to an ancilla. (b) The circuit gadget instantiating the two-branch tree in the \mathcal{I}_{10} code for illustration. This gadget is fault-tolerant: all single faults are detectable or do not act on the logical state, as we now explain. First, a weight-1 Z error does not propagate down the CX tree at all, so it will be detected by the X stabilizer later. A weight-1 X error does propagate down the tree; however, it either occurs on q_{0} in which case it applies the code stabilizer \prod_{i}X_{i} to the physical state, or it flips the value of the ZZ operator measured at the end of the branches, since it can only spread down one branch. Gate errors may also cause single weight-2 faults. Any Pauli error on a single gate that does not involve q_{0} either flips the ZZ operator at the end of the branches (if it applies an X or Y to the target), causes a detectable syndrome, or applies a ZZ operator that acts as the identity on a physical GHZ state. The situation is similar for gates that do involve q_{0} ; although these can cause Pauli errors to potentially propagate down both tree branches if they apply an X or Y to q_{0} , either this results in an overall detectable Y error, or it applies the \prod_{i}X_{i} code stabilizer. In Fig. S2 we illustrate the log-depth version of this state preparation protocol. The key observation is that the same arguments above for fault-tolerance apply as long as we specify the tree such that the ZZ operators measured always correspond to two qubits whose only common ancestor is the root of the tree q_{0} . Conceptually, one builds up such a tree iteratively by separating nodes into two sets: those with q_{1} as an ancestor, and those without. Each time a new successive node is added to the tree, it is either added to the descendants of q_{1} or to the side of the tree that does not descend from q_{1} depending on which set is larger, to maintain a balance between the size of the two sets. Following this procedure, one obtains a log-depth tree in which half of the terminal nodes descend from q_{1} and half do not; pairing off nodes in each set obtains the ZZ operators that should be checked for fault-tolerance. It is possible, depending on the desired depth of the state preparation protocol, for the tree generated in this fashion to be imbalanced by at most one surplus/deficit qubit descending from q_{1} ; the leftover qubit may be paired with q_{0} in checking ZZ operators of the pairs of terminal nodes. Figure S2: Log-depth state preparation gadget for \mathcal{I}_{k} codes. (a) The balanced tree structure specifying preparation of the logical zero state in the \mathcal{I}_{48} code. As before, red brackets indicate pairs of qubits whose ZZ operator will be read out by coupling to an ancilla (note that in this particular case, the qubit with index m on the left connects to the qubit with index m-1 on the right). (b) Circuit instantiation of the log-depth tree in the \mathcal{I}_{10} code, as also depicted in Fig. 3 . Pauli X gates in the circuit implement the DFS-based error mitigation discussed below; note that this flips the noiseless value of the ancilla measurements that is checked as part of the repeat-until-success protocol. Rather than postselect on errors detected on the ancilla measurements that record the various ZZ operators, we instead use a repeat-until-success (RUS) protocol in which any detected errors trigger a reset of all qubits followed by a new attempt at initializing the code. In Fig. S3 we report statistics on the number of loop iterations for RUS to pass, across all experiments in which it was utilized. Even for the largest code studied, \mathcal{I}_{94} , initialization succeeds with exceptionally high probability in only one or two loop iterations, with a maximum of six loop iterations required across all experiments of any size in this work. We group the results in Fig. S3 for each experiment type (SPAM, GHZ, XY model simulation) and aggregate results within each category across experiments using the same-size codes since other differences do not affect the state preparation. For GHZ state preparation experiments using many \mathcal{I}_{4} code blocks we report the success with which we can prepare each individual \mathcal{I}_{4} code block and aggregate the statistics across all \mathcal{I}_{4} code blocks in a given shot. However, we separate the results reported by total number of code blocks since, e.g., the memory error experienced by the qubits may depend on the total number of qubits involved in the experiment. Figure S3: Repeat-until-success statistics for distance-2 experiments. We report the fraction of the time that a code block required each number of RUS iterations before no error was detected, corresponding to the fraction of total shots for experiments using a single \mathcal{I}_{k} code block, or fraction of total initializations = (total shots times number of code blocks) for experiments using multiple code blocks. Experiments of the same type (i.e., SPAM, GHZ state preparation, or XY model simulation) are aggregated on the plots above when they only differ in aspects that do not affect state preparation. Shot counts for each experiment are reported in the relevant SI sections below. Although the log-depth initialization gadget substantially reduces the circuit depth of state preparation, qubit idling remains a concern due to the potential for the buildup of coherent dephasing errors (for instance, due to spatial and temporal variance in magnetic fields) which can grow quadratically at small idle times. Below, we discuss additional error mitigation techniques that were employed only in the log-depth gadget to further reduce coherent memory errors. To the extent that coherent memory errors are spatially uniform across the device, motivated by decoherence-free subspace (DFS) codes Lidar et al. 1998 ; Kielpinski et al. 2002 we insert a Pauli X operator into the log-depth tree so that after each full layer of the tree is applied, the qubits are in a “decoherence-free state” that is a superposition of computational basis states with an equal mixture of 0s and 1s. The net effect at the end of state preparation is equivalent to the application of X_{i} operators on half of the physical qubits, so one can simply flip the relevant bits in postprocessing with the understanding that in the case that n=2j with j odd, the code space throughout the circuit is now defined by the S_{Z}=-1 subspace. In Fig. S2 we show the inserted Pauli X operator along with two additional Pauli X operators that we insert at the end of initialization so that q_{0} and q_{n-1} are in opposite states; since these two qubits correspond to the pivot qubits, they may idle for long periods during computations in a single \mathcal{I}_{k} code. Consequently, this may provide additional protection against coherent dephasing on those two qubits in particular. In deep circuits, we expect that the code does not remain in a DFS state; however, at the beginning and end of the circuit, and in particular during any terminal syndrome extraction, we might expect the state to remain approximately DFS, so this technique provides a low-overhead way to mitigate some coherent error both during the initialization gadget and potentially during an encoded circuit. To the extent that coherent memory errors may be spatially varying but relatively temporally uniform, we insert two dynamical decoupling (DD) X pulses on the qubits idling for the longest period during state preparation. As in Ref. Haghshenas et al. 2025 , we alternate the sign of the DD pulses on each qubit between +X and -X (which have physically distinct implementations on Helios) so as to cancel any potential coherent over-rotation on the single-qubit gate itself in the positive vs. negative directions. We do not depict these gates in Fig. S2 but they are arranged to occur during the long idle period on half the system qubits on the right-hand side of the gadget, with roughly equal temporal spacing. Figure S4: Two-branch state preparation gadget in the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} code. All wires are logical, representing \mathcal{I}_{6} blocks and all CX gates are transversal. The “init L1” gadgets initialize the \mathcal{I}_{6} using the d=2 two-branch state preparation circuit of Fig. S1 . Finally, we introduce a new, FT two-branch \ket{0}^{\otimes k_{1}k_{2}} state preparation gadget for concatenated iceberg codes \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}}\circ\mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} which generalizes the d=2 circuit in Fig. S1 . This circuit is shown for the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} code in Fig. S4 . First, we initialize the lower-level \mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} blocks using the d=2 two-branch circuit in Fig. S1 . Then, we perform a two-branch circuit comprised of transversal CX gates with a logical ancilla which measures the logical ZZ operators of two \mathcal{I}_{6} blocks to catch all cascading logical X errors, analogous to the d=2 case. The main difference is that we arrange the CX gates so that they have only two controls, so that any weight-two Z error resulting from a single failure will be caught by the d=2 EDZ gadgets, which extract X syndromes of the \mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} code using a Bell-pair syndrome extraction circuit similar to the non-destructive part of Fig. S5 b. Similarly, the EDX gadget will extract d=2 Z syndrome of the third \mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} block to catch high weight X errors which may result from an XX error on one of the CX gates in the first transversal CX between the top two code blocks. We postselect on any non-trivial measurements in these EDZ/EDX gadgets as well as in the bottom transversal Z measurement of the \mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} ancilla. If the \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}}\circ\mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} code passes these checks, a single failure will lead to at most a weight-one error on the code block. Pairs of gate failures can lead to columns of errors on the output code block of weight possibly larger than two. However, since these error strings intersect the support of any weight-four logical operator on at most two qubits, we shall show in Sec. IV that such error are “generalized weight-two,” in the sense that they can be treated as weight-two errors and the usual proofs that computations are FT to distance four will still apply. II Data from SPAM experiments In Table 1 we report explicitly all distance-2 data appearing in Fig. 1 b and Fig. 1 c. We report separately the distance-4 data, which does not use RUS in its state preparation protocol, so that we can distinguish the pre-acceptance and post-acceptance rates of the experiment, where the pre-acceptance rate corresponds to the fraction of leakage-postselected shots that pass state preparation and the post-acceptance rate refers to the fraction of remaining shots that are not postselected due to a weight-two error. In the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} SPAM experiment the leakage acceptance rate was 0.775^{+7}_{-6} , the pre-acceptance rate was 0.654(8) , and the post-acceptance rate was 0.987(2) . No logical errors were recorded after performing 4000 shots of the experiment, which is consistent with an upper bound (Wilson 68% confidence interval) on the SPAM infidelity per logical qubit of 8.3\times 10^{-6} . Experiment Infidelity ( \times 10^{-5} ) Total shots Leakage accept rate Overall accept rate Unencoded 48(6) 4000 – – \mathcal{I}_{48} , two-branch 6^{+3}_{-2} 2000 – .942(5) \mathcal{I}_{48} , log-depth 3^{+3}_{-1} 2000 – .943(5) \mathcal{I}_{48} , two-branch, S_{X} extraction 31^{+9}_{-7} 2000 – .47(1) \mathcal{I}_{48} , log-depth, S_{X} extraction 13^{+6}_{-4} 2000 – .49(1) Unencoded, LH 170(10) 4000 .82(3) .82(3) \mathcal{I}_{48} , log-depth, LH 12^{+3}_{-2} 4000 .916(4) .829(6) \mathcal{I}_{48} , log-depth, LH, S_{X} extraction 21(4) 4000 .907^{+4}_{-5} .695(7) Table 1: Logical distance-2 and unencoded SPAM experiment results. Here, and elsewhere, LH refers to the leakage-heralded measurement available on Helios (Methods .1 ). Infidelity is reported per logical qubit as in Fig. 1 as the fraction of total shots with no logical error, divided by number of logical qubits, and (leakage) acceptance rate is computed as the probability of preparing 48 qubits with no detected (leakage) error in both the encoded and unencoded case. Uncertainties for all encoded experiments in this work are obtained from Wilson 68% confidence intervals unless otherwise indicated, and are reported with parenthetical notation when symmetric and \mbox{}^{+}_{-} notation where asymmetric, with values referring to the trailing significant digits. III GHZ-state based syndrome extraction and readout in \mathcal{I}_{k} codes The standard gadgets for d=2 syndrome extraction presented in Refs. Self et al. 2024 ; Jin et al. use two ancilla qubits to extract the S_{Z} and S_{X} syndromes non-destructively in the middle of the circuit. These gadgets are made FT by careful ordering of the SE gates so that each ancilla serves as a flag for errors that may occur in extracting the syndrome measured by the other ancilla. This assumes that any nontrivial measurement of the corresponding ancilla qubit results in that circuit’s results being discarded via postselection, and it is not possible to distinguish errors that occurred during the rest of the circuit that resulted in a nontrivial syndrome from flagged errors that occurred during the SE gadget itself. More importantly, the gates involved in these gadgets are highly serial, with at most two performed simultaneously throughout the gadget. This presents a challenge for efficient qubit transport on Helios, both because it can parallelize batches of up to 8 two-qubit gates at a time in its gate zones and because this type of “two-to-all” circuit structure requires repeatedly moving the same ancilla qubits back and forth from the ring storage to the quantum logic regions, which may result in large time overheads. Figure S5: Syndrome extraction and readout gadgets in the \mathcal{I}_{k} codes (a) GHZ-based syndrome extraction illustrated on an \mathcal{I}_{10} code. Both four-qubit ancillary GHZ states read in parities across all qubits; the lower ladder of CX gates wraps around to include the top four physical qubits as well. (b) Readout gadget used in \mathcal{I}_{94} GHZ state preparation experiments. The information encoding the measured syndromes is described in the text below. These standard gadgets are designed with efficiency of qubit number required in mind. However, for nearly all d=2 experiments in this work, there is a surplus of qubits in the device that we may employ for mitigation of errors. The parallelization of the standard gadgets can already be improved simply by assigning a flag qubit for each ancilla rather than using them as flags for each other. This allows twice as many gates to be implemented in parallel, since each ancilla and its corresponding flag are prepared in a Bell pair and syndrome extraction gates can be broadcast over both qubits in the Bell pair. In this work we take this idea further, noting that we can achieve further parallelization of SE gates by entangling ancillas into GHZ states in the appropriate basis; gates can then be broadcast over all qubits in the ancillary GHZ states and one qubit detects the syndrome while the remaining qubits flag any potential error that may occur during the gadget. In Fig. S5 a we illustrate this scheme on an \mathcal{I}_{10} code. Using four-qubit GHZ states takes full advantage of the gate-zone parallelization on Helios while introducing minimal delays for encoding and decoding of the ancillary states themselves. We expect this is close to the optimal size GHZ state for performing SE on Helios, because larger states will introduce larger encoding/decoding delays, will be more sensitive to coherent dephasing errors on the ancillas, and the gate zones are already being fully utilized in parallel when 8 gates are performed simultaneously (larger states will require additional transport rounds to perform more gates). However, one can take the GHZ states to be of any intermediate size up to potentially n (the Steane-style syndrome extraction limit Steane 1997 ) which may be useful on future devices. To be explicit, we use an X -basis GHZ state to detect X errors (detected by S_{Z} ) and vice versa with a Z -basis GHZ state as shown in Fig. S5 a. We arrange the gates that encode/decode the GHZ states in a careful order as shown, so that all errors which can flip the syndrome propagate back to the same ancilla (i.e., the qubit initialized in |0\rangle for the X -basis GHZ state and vice versa), whose measured value records the relevant syndrome. All other qubits flag any hook errors that might occur (i.e., a Z error on the X -basis GHZ state from gates or memory errors that could propagate back onto the system), and we correspondingly discard any shot where any qubit in either GHZ state records a nontrivial measurement. We note that when the DFS-based error mitigation discussed in Sec. I is used, the code space is defined by the S_{Z}=-1 subspace so the expected noiseless value of the relevant ancilla measurement is flipped. Readout proceeds similarly to syndrome extraction, but the S_{Z} syndrome does not need to be extracted non-destructively; it can be reconstructed by the destructive measurement of each qubit in the Z basis. As a result, we only extract S_{X} non-destructively during readout, using a four-qubit Z -basis GHZ state. In general, it is not clear that extracting S_{X} at the end of a circuit is always desirable, as the gadget itself can introduce coherent idling errors in the Z basis that do not affect the destructive measurements of the qubits but suppress the acceptance rate since they are detected by S_{X} (and potentially introduce extra logical errors). For the state preparation and measurement (SPAM) experiments that are described in the main text and reported in Fig. 1 b and Fig. 1 c, we report the fidelity of the distance-2 experiments both with and without terminal S_{X} extraction. It is clear from the results reported there that terminal S_{X} extraction appears to typically increase both discard rates and logical error. For this reason, we do not extract S_{X} at the end of the circuit in our XY model experiments. The results reported in Fig. 1 b and Fig. 1 c also include some experiments that used the leakage-heralded measurement available on Helios (Methods .1 ). As expected, those experiments also show slightly larger logical error rates and discard rates, while the leakage-heralded measurement substantially improves the results presented in Fig. 3 . This is primarily due to the fact that the leakage-heralded measurement has larger associated physical SPAM error but the SPAM experiments, being relatively short circuits, do not result in much qubit leakage. Consequently, we expect leakage-heralding not to enhance logical error in these very short circuits. During both syndrome extraction and readout, we employ additional dynamical decoupling pulses following the same method as discussed for state preparation in Sec. I , applying \pm X pulses of alternating sign to idling qubits during the gadget, with an even parity of pulses applied on any given qubit before and after SE gates to avoid affecting the code stabilizers. In the SPAM experiments of Fig. 1 b,c, these pulses are only applied to the experiments that extracted S_{X} . The full impact of these DD pulses is not clearly resolved and may require further study to refine pulse timing. In the \mathcal{I}_{94} GHZ state preparation experiments, there are not sufficiently many qubits on the device to use the log-depth initialization gadget and the GHZ-based readout protocol. For this reason, we default to the two-branch initialization presented in Fig. S1 , and we use the readout gadget shown in Fig. S5 b, which further improves on the gadget of Ref. Jin et al. and requires only one ancilla qubit. In terms of the physical operators measured at the end of this gadget, we still have \overline{Z}^{i}=Z_{i}Z_{n-1} ; however, the stabilizers are now encoded into the operators S_{X}=Z_{0} and S_{Z}=\prod_{i=1}^{n-1}Z_{i}=Z_{1}Z_{2}\ldots Z_{k}Z_{n-1} . Any nontrivial measurement of the ancilla flags errors that occur during the gadget. IV Concatenated iceberg QEC cycle details In this section, we give fault-tolerance proofs, decoding algorithms, and experimental data from Helios for the QEC cycle for d=4 concatenated iceberg codes introduced in the main text. Recall that in the \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}}\circ\mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} code, stabilizers consist of rows and pairs of columns, see Fig. 1 a. We call the former low-level stabilizers, denoted by S_{X/Z,i}=\prod_{j=0}^{n_{1}}(X_{ij}/Z_{ij}) for i\in\{0,...,n_{2}-1\} , since they are stabilizers of the d=2 \mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} codes and the latter, high-level stabilizers, denoted by S_{X/Z}^{i}=\prod_{j=0}^{n_{2}}(X_{0,j}X_{i,j}/Z_{i,j}Z_{n_{1}-1,j}) for i\in\{1,...,n_{1}-2\} since they are the stabilizers of the encoded \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}}. The full QEC cycle for \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}}\circ\mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} is given in Fig. S6 . To summarize, a \ket{\bar{+}}^{\otimes k_{1}} state encoded in an \mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} ancilla is used to extract the high-level X stabilizers, S_{X}^{i} . The qubits used to flag this ancilla are unencoded, initialized in the \ket{0}^{\otimes n_{1}} state. Then the lower-level stabilizers S_{X,j} are extracted using Bell pair d=2 syndrome extraction (denoted as EDZ in Figs. S6 and 1 d), the circuit for which is shown in Fig. S5 b. The second half of the QEC cycle is conjugate to the first via the Hadamard gate and extracts the S_{Z}^{i} and S_{Z,j} syndromes. Before discussing decoding the QEC cycle under circuit-level noise, we give a decoding algorithm in the case of correcting input errors with a noiseless QEC cycle. In this case, we must correct a single input error and halt if uncorrectable errors of weight >1 occur. The intuition behind decoding in this case is that the high-level stabilizers, corresponding to pairs of columns, will give information about the x coordinates of errors, and the low-level stabilizers will give information about the y coordinates. If a weight-one error occurs, we can deduce the x and y coordinates of the error from the stabilizers and correct it. If a detectable error occurs, we can deduce from the stabilizers that there will either be multiple x coordinates, or multiple y coordinates, or both. Pseudocode for correcting Z errors given the X stabilizers is shown in Fig. S7 . Correcting X errors given the Z stabilizers is analogous. We see that strings of vertical and horizontal errors can be differentiated from correctable errors by the presence of multiple y coordinates or multiple x coordinates in Algorithm 1. We will refer to such errors as “generalized weight-two,” due to both their detectability as well as to the size of their common support with any of the weight-four logical operators being \leq 2 (because lines intersect rectangles on at most two vertices). Definition 1 . We call X error strings of the form \prod_{j\in S}X_{x,j} and \prod_{i\in S}X_{i,y} generalized weight-two. Similarly, we call Z error strings of the form \prod_{j\in S}Z_{x,j} and \prod_{i\in S}Z_{i,y} generalized weight-two. A product of a generalized weight-two X error and a generalized weight-two Z error is also generalized weight-two, due to independent correction of X and Z errors. Additionally, suppose we know that a vertical or horizontal string of errors has occurred, and, moreover, we know the common x or y coordinate of the string. Algorithm 1 will then compute the y or x locations of the string respectively, and this error can be corrected. Therefore, we call such strings for which the common coordinate is known “generalized weight-one” errors. There is one additional X error which is “generalized weight-one:” an X error on all the qubits of a column. Since pairs of columns are stabilizers, these are all equivalent up to a stabilizer: \prod_{j\in[n_{2}]}X_{x_{1},j}\sim\prod_{j\in[n_{2}]}X_{x_{1},j} . Therefore, if in Algorithm 1, the length of the array ‘Ycoords’ is n_{2} , we may apply \prod_{j\in[n_{2}]}X_{0,j} and this will correct an error string on any column. Definition 2 . We call the tuple (\prod_{j\in S}X_{x,j},\,x) , representing a vertical error string with a known x coordinate generalized weight-one. Similarly, we call the tuple (\prod_{i\in S}X_{i,y},y) , representing a horizontal error string with a known y coordinate generalized weight-one. Finally, we also denote the vertical error string \prod_{j\in[n_{2}]}X_{x_{1},j} with x_{1} arbitrary generalized weight-one. Similarly, (\prod_{j\in S}Z_{x,j},x) , (\prod_{i\in S}Z_{i,y},y) , and \prod_{j\in[n_{2}]}Z_{x_{1},j} are generalized weight-one. A product of a generalized weight-one X error and a generalized weight-one Z error is also generalized weight-one, due to independent correction of X and Z errors. Figure S6: The QEC cycle for \mathbf{\mathcal{I}_{k_{2}}\circ\mathcal{I}_{k_{1}}} . The first half of the QEC cycle extracts X stabilizers and the second half extracts Z stabilizers. EDZ refers to d=2 X syndrome and EDX to d=2 Z syndrome extraction respectively. All CX gates shown are transversal, including the ones between the bottom two ancilla wires. The top ancilla is an \mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} code block and the bottom is n_{1} physical qubits, so they have the same size, and “transversal” in this case still means n_{1} physical CX gates. We will prove versions of the fault-tolerance criteria in Prabhu and Reichardt 2024 for d=4 codes, broadened to take into account the notions of generalized weight-1 and -2 errors, as well as the handling of measurement errors, which are natural for this QEC cycle. As a consequence, the conditions we prove are weaker in the sense of allowing more general output errors, but stronger in that the QEC cycle must correct more general input errors. To demonstrate that these conditions are sufficient for fault-tolerance, we will show that they imply the desired d=3 QEC and d=4 QED ExRec conditions (an ExRec or “extended rectangle” is a region of a circuit containing two adjacent QEC cycles; see Definition 3). Namely, for d=3 , we show that an encoded computation using an \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}}\circ\mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} code will succeed so long as there is at most one fault per ExRec. Furthermore, we show for d=4 , that if there are at most two faults per ExRec, the computation will either succeed or halt, but will not result in an undetectable logical error. Proposition 1 . The QEC cycle for two-level concatenated iceberg codes satisfies the following properties: 1. If the QEC cycle contains no fault, it will take an input with a generalized weight-1 (or weight-0) error to an error-free output, and will halt the computation in the case of a generalized weight-2 input. 2. Suppose the QEC cycle contains a single internal fault. Then it will take an input with no errors to an output with error of generalized weight at most 1. Also, it will take an input with a generalized weight-1 error to a generalized weight-1 output, or if it does not do so, it will pass flags to the next QEC cycle which will cause it to halt. 3. If the QEC cycle contains at two internal faults, it will take an error-free input to an output of at most generalized weight-2, or it will halt. Proof. Let us discuss the correction of Z errors as correcting X errors is analogous. The proof of 1. follows from Algorithm 1 since, in this case, the extraction of the stabilizers is noiseless. Also, it is clear that, in the absence of noise, Algorithm 1 will correct a weight-one Z error. In order to proceed further, we must analyze and correct circuit-level noise in terms of generalized weight-one and weight-two errors. Z hook errors can only occur in the second half of the QEC cycle. Z errors on the iceberg ancilla for extracting the S_{Z}^{i} or its flags will lead to vertical Z strings. An example is shown in Fig. S8 , where an error on the flag for the first qubit of the iceberg ancilla will lead to a vertical string of Z errors with x coordinate 0. In the absence of further errors, the 0 th flag will have a non-trivial measurement, and this x coordinate is known, making the error generalized weight-one. This information can be passed to the next QEC cycle, which can then correct this error (this is the “HighZFlags” measurement register in Algorithms 2 and 3, shown in Figs. S9 and S10 ). Any single internal error, for it to be a hook error of Z type, must affect an ancilla in the second half of the QEC cycle and will therefore cause a non-trivial flag measurement, and lead to an error of at most generalized weight-1 if the input is error-free, proving the first half of 2. To prove the second half, we must discuss what happens in the case of measurement errors in the X stabilizer registers (“HighX” and “LowX”) which, ideally, will correct generalized weight-1 input errors. If the error is strictly weight-1, in the absence of measurement errors, Algorithm 2 would deduce the x and y coordinate of such an error and be able to correct it. If a single measurement error occurs, then one of these two coordinates may be missing. In this case, we allow the error to pass through to the next QEC cycle, but, in Algorithm 3, we also pass the flags “CurrInternalFaults”’ and “NextInputErrorAllowed” to the next QEC cycle and postselect if there are subsequent internal faults or input errors respectively. If the error is generalized weight-1 with a flagged x or y coordinate from the previous QEC cycle, and a single internal-fault in the current QEC cycle introduces any uncertainty in any of the y or x coordinates of the string respectively, we can postselect, as we know two errors in this ExRec have occurred (the hook error from the previous QEC cycle and the current internal fault). We can tell if such an internal fault has occurred by looking at, in the case of a vertical hook error, the parity of the number of detected y coordinates, which should be accompanied by a detected x error coordinate in the case that this parity is odd, or no detected x error coordinate, in the case that this parity is even (see the comments “Halt if there is another error in addition to the hook error” in Algorithm 3). We computationally enumerate all single internal-faults and all generalized weight-1 inputs in the case of the \mathcal{I}_{2}\circ\mathcal{I}_{2}=\left\llbracket 16,\,4,\,4\right\rrbracket QEC cycle, and verify that, in all cases, if a generalized weight-1 input is turned into a higher weight output, the subsequent QEC cycle will halt, completing the proof of 2, as the decoding for other sizes of iceberg layers is entirely analogous. Finally, if a hook error occurs, a subsequent internal fault, such as a measurement error in the measurement of flag 0 in Fig. S8 can turn a generalized weight-1 vertical error, for instance, into an error where the x coordinate of this error string is not detected. In this case, the error becomes generalized weight-two. We can verify 3. through an exhaustive enumeration of all two s internal faults for r+s=2 in the case of the \mathcal{I}_{2}\circ\mathcal{I}_{2}=\left\llbracket 16,\,4,\,4\right\rrbracket QEC cycle. ∎ Note that Prop. 1 implies that the scaling in Fig. S11 for circuit-level simulations of the \mathcal{I}_{2}\circ\mathcal{I}_{2} QEC cycle should have an O(p^{3}) infidelity and O(p^{2}) rejection rate, consistent with the numerically fitted slopes. Now, we prove that Prop. 1 implies the d=3 and d=4 ExRec conditions. Definition 3 . In a memory experiment with repeated QEC cycles, we define an ExRec to be any pair of consecutive cycles. An ExRec is good to distance 3 if it contains \leq 1 errors. Proposition 2 . Suppose \ket{\overline{\psi}} is in the code space of \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}}\circ\mathcal{I}_{k_{1}} and is input to m rounds of QEC. If all ExRecs are good to distance 3, then the computation will not halt and the output will have an error of generalized weight at most one. Proof. First, suppose that all ExRecs are good to distance three. Then the success of the computation follows from Prop. 1 since QEC cycles with errors are interleaved with perfect QEC cycles, which will correct any generalized weight-one errors produced by the faulty QEC cycles. ∎ Now, we prove the d=4 ExRec condition for Z errors (the proof for X errors is analogous). Again, suppose the computation is m rounds of QEC and the input is in the code space of \mathcal{I}_{k_{2}}\circ\mathcal{I}_{k_{1}}. Definition 4 . An ExRec is good to distance 4 if it contains \leq 2 errors. Proposition 3 . If all ExRecs are good to distance 4, then the computation will either halt or the output will have an X error of generalized weight at most two. Proof. If all ExRecs are good to distance 4, then we examine the first ExRec where after the first QEC gadget, there is an error of generalized weight-two. There are two ways in which this can occur (by Prop. 1 ). The first is that the input to the ExRec was error-free and there were two errors in the first QEC cycle. In this case, the second QEC cycle must be error-free for the ExRec to be good, and the computation will halt because this noiseless QEC cycle has a weight-two input error. The second possibility is that the input to the ExRec had a generalized weight-one error and there was a single internal fault in the first QEC cycle. In this case, since after the first QEC cycle of the ExRec, the error is no longer generalized weight \leq 1 , by Prop. 1 , the second QEC cycle will halt, completing the proof. ∎ We note that while we prove the ExRec conditions here for memory experiments, we believe they could be straightforwardly generalized to, for example, a transversal CX gate, by looking at all the flags in both inputs to the CX gate and halting if their combined non-trivial measurements are too numerous (for instance, if both had a “CurrFailures” value of 1 in Algorithm 3). For the \mathcal{I}_{2}\circ\mathcal{I}_{2} and 2\times\mathcal{I}_{2} codes, we performed memory experiments on Helios where c cycles of QEC/QED were performed for c\in\{1,2,4,8\} . Leakage heralding was used and the leakage acceptance, preacceptance, and QEC/QED acceptance rates are given in Table 2 . We decode over multiple ExRecs using Algorithm 3 (and analogous decoding for X errors) with the extra postselection condition that correctable hook errors must occur on every other x or y coordinate due to the fact that the ancillas in syndrome extraction interact with every other qubit. We note that the preacceptance rate, which denotes the fraction of all unleaked shots for which all the state preparations in the protocol succeed, could be made arbitrarily close to 1 through repeat-until-success, and leakage postselection could be solved through the conversion of leakage noise to depolarizing noise in hardware using the technique of Ref. Hayes et al. 2020 . Therefore, it is the QEC acceptance rate, which should scale as O(p^{2}) , which is fundamentally the limiting factor and must be increased by scaling the code distance, as we demonstrate. For the single \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} QEC cycle experiment, the decoding problem over a single ExRec is significantly easier, as we can simply iterate over all possible single failures and apply corrections whenever the flags and syndromes are compatible with such failures, and postselect otherwise. The results for this experiment are given in Table 3 . Experiment Cycles Leakage acceptance Preacceptance QEC/QED acceptance \mathcal{I}_{2}\circ\mathcal{I}_{2} (X Basis) [ 1 , 2 , 4 , 8 ] [ .930_{-9}^{+8} , .89(1) , .81(1) , .67_{-2}^{+1} ] [ .88_{-2}^{+1},.83_{-2}^{+1},.88(1),.84_{-2}^{+1} ] [ .989^{+3}_{-4},.970^{+6}_{-7},.90(1),.75(2) ] \mathcal{I}_{2}\circ\mathcal{I}_{2} (Z Basis) [ 1 , 2 , 4 , 8 ] [ .917_{-9}^{+8} , .89(1) , .77(1) , .64_{-2}^{+1} ] [ .87(1),.84(1),.80^{+1}_{-2},.82_{-1}^{+2} ] [ .991^{+3}_{-4},.952^{+7}_{-8},.88_{-3}^{+1},.76(2) ] 2\times\mathcal{I}_{2} (X Basis) [ 1 , 2 , 4 , 8 ] [ .983_{-5}^{+4},.984(4),.967_{-6}^{+5},.937_{-8}^{+7} ] [ .993^{+2}_{-3} , .991_{-4}^{+2} , .993_{-4}^{+2} , .996_{-3}^{+1} ] [ .960^{+6}_{-7},.912_{-10}^{+8},.71_{-2}^{+1},.64(2) ] 2\times\mathcal{I}_{2} (Z Basis) [ 1 , 2 , 4 , 8 ] [ .983_{-5}^{+4},.984(4),.967_{-6}^{+5},.937_{-8}^{+7} ] [ .993_{-3}^{+2},.990_{-4}^{+3},.981_{-5}^{+4},.994_{-4}^{+2} ] [ .960_{-7}^{+6},.917_{-9}^{+8},.74_{-2}^{+1},.50_{-2}^{+1} ] Table 2: Acceptance rates for k=4 memory experiments over 1,2,4, and 8 cycles of QEC or QED. 1000 shots were submitted for each cycle length, for the \ket{\overline{0}}^{\otimes 4} and \ket{\bar{+}}^{\otimes 4} states for the \mathcal{I}_{2}\circ\mathcal{I}_{2} and 2\times\mathcal{I}_{2} codes. In all experiments, leakage heralding was used and shots with detected leakage events were discarded. Leakage acceptance is the fraction of shots for which no detected leakage errors occurred. The preacceptance is the fraction of leakage postselected shots for which all state preparations (both for the input states and, in the case of the concatenated code, the lower-level ancilla used in QEC) succeeded. The QEC/QED acceptance rates are computed as the fraction of unleaked, preaccepted shots for which the QEC/QED cycles do not halt due to uncorrectable configurations of d/2 circuit failures. In the accepted shots, one error occurred in the 4 -cycle \mathcal{I}_{2}\circ\mathcal{I}_{2} X basis experiment which induced an error on one of the logical qubits. No errors were found in any of the other k=4 memory experiments. Experiment Leakage acceptance Preacceptance QEC acceptance Accepted shots Errors \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} (X Basis) .431(7) .57(1) .58_{-2}^{+1} 708 0 \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} (Z Basis) .453(7) .64(1) .66(1) 958 0 Table 3: Experimental data for the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} QEC cycle experiments. 5000 shots were submitted in each basis. Leakage, preacceptance and QEC acceptance rates are as before. Of the 708 accepted shots in the X basis and 958 accepted shots in the Z basis, no errors occurred. Figure S7: Noiseless decoding of X stabilizer measurements. Given two arrays of noiseless X stabilizer measurements S_{X}^{i} and S_{X,i} , in the presence of non-trivial syndromes, this algorithm will either return a compatible weight-one Z correction or determine that an uncorrectable error has occurred. Figure S8: Error propagation during high-level Z syndrome extraction. An example of a Z_{0} error on the ancilla during high-level Z syndrome extraction spreading to a vertical string of Z_{0} errors on the data iceberg code blocks. Figure S9: Helper Function for decoding circuit-level Z errors from QEC Cycle Measurements. Given the four relevant (possibly faulty) measurement registers from the current and previous QEC cycle, this algorithm computes the possible hook error locations as well as non-trivial x and y coordinates of Z errors. The HighX and LowX measurement registers are from the transversal X measurement of \ket{\bar{+}}^{\otimes k_{1}} and the stabilizer measurements of the EDZ gadgets in the first half of the QEC cycle respectively. The HighZFlags and LowZFlags are the flags for the \ket{\bar{0}}^{\otimes k_{1}} ancilla and the flags from the EDX gadgets in the second half of the previous QEC cycle, which record the locations of the vertical and horizontal Z hook errors that the current QEC cycle must correct. Figure S10: Circuit-level decoding for the d=4 concatenated iceberg QEC cycle. The decoder for Z errors which satisfies Prop. 1 . ‘PrevFailures’ and ‘InputErrorAllowed’ are passed from the previous QEC cycle, and the current QEC cycle will return the analogous quantities ‘NextInputErrorAllowed’ and ‘Curr Failures’ to pass to the next QEC cycle, as well as ‘Zcorr’, the Z corrections for this QEC cycle. Figure S11: Simulated QEC infidelity and reject rate as a function of physical noise rate p . Circuit-level Stim Gidney 2021 simulations with two-qubit gate errors and measurement errors of a single round of QEC on the \ket{+}^{\otimes 4} input state. The properties in Prop. 1 imply that the QEC rejection rate should scale as O(p^{2}) and the infidelity as O(p^{3}) . Also shown are the rejection rates and infidelities for two copies of the \mathcal{I}_{2} code. We can see that for an effective two-qubit infidelity of \leq 4\times 10^{-3} , the fidelity and acceptance rate for d=4 are improved relative to d=2 . V Logical gate benchmarking analysis and statistical procedure Here, we provide more details about the logical cycle-benchmarking protocol described in the main text and in Methods .3 and discuss the methods used for fitting and statistical analysis. Figure S12: Circuit diagrams for logical cycle-benchmarking experiments of \mathcal{I}_{4} code blocks. Both (a) intra-block and (b) inter-block experiments are displayed with cycles consisting of Pauli-twirled 2Q-gate layers and syndrome extraction rounds inserted every 8 cycles. The general protocol operates as follows: suppose we have k logical qubits distributed among one or more code blocks on which the logical gates act (i.e., k=8 for two \mathcal{I}_{4} code blocks, even if the gates only couple one logical qubit in each block). First, sample a set of logical Pauli observables \mathcal{P}_{\text{samp}} from the uniform distribution over k -qubit Paulis, and choose a set of cycle depths \mathcal{L}_{\text{cyc}} with which to perform the experiment. For each corresponding fixed cycle depth L\in\mathcal{L}_{\text{cyc}} , initialize in a random eigenstate \ket{\psi}_{P} of P\in\mathcal{P}_{\text{samp}} and apply L Pauli-twirled gates along with periodic syndrome extraction before measuring in the eigenbasis of P . From the parity of the resulting bitstring, extract an estimate of the expectation value of the output state with respect to the basis of P . We view the constituent logical cycle of this experiment as being the Pauli-twirled logical gates, with the syndrome extraction essentially just a mechanism for detecting errors that occur during the cycle. However, note that the syndrome extraction can cause up to k -qubit logical errors, which is why we sample over Pauli observables of size k correspondingly. The circuit diagrams for the experiments are displayed in Fig. S12 . For the inter-block experiments, we use two \mathcal{I}_{4} iceberg code blocks with a single 2Q gate across the blocks ( U_{ZZ}(\pi/2) or FANOUT) as the cycle. For the intra-block experiments, we used a single \mathcal{I}_{4} code block and perform two U_{ZZ}(\pi/2) on both pairs of logical qubits per cycle. For each set of experiments, we randomly sample 20 Pauli observables across all 4 or 8 logical qubits (for intra-block or inter-block respectively). Each shot includes mid-circuit syndrome extraction round after every eight gate cycles and concludes with a terminal SE round. This frequency of syndrome extraction was chosen as a rough optimization for logical gate fidelity considering the competing factors of (a) very-frequent syndrome extraction introducing extra memory and gate errors versus (b) infrequent syndrome extraction leading to combinatorially more opportunities for faults to occur per detector region. In order to obtain an estimate of the Pauli fidelity f_{P} from the measured Pauli expectation values, we employ a maximum-likelihood based approach. For each depth L\in\mathcal{L}_{\text{cyc}} and Pauli observable P , we perform N repetitions of the corresponding logical CB circuit with Pauli layers randomized per shot. After postselecting on outcomes without detected errors, we accept N_{L} shots. For each accepted shot, we record the parity of the final measured bits to obtain the Pauli eigenvalue outcome X_{P,s}(L)\in\{+1,-1\},\qquad s=1,\dots,N_{L}. In order to extract the Pauli fidelity, we fit the distribution of X_{P,s} to a Bernoulli model. First, define a “match” event as when X_{P,s}(L) is equal to the eigenvalue of the initial Pauli eigenstate, \lambda_{\ket{\psi}} , and let K_{P}(L) be the total number of such events across the N_{L} retained shots. For fixed P and L , we model the observed outcomes as i.i.d. Bernoulli trials with probability q_{P}(L)=\Pr\!\big(X_{P,s}(L)=\lambda_{\ket{\psi}}\big). Equivalently, K_{P}(L) is a binomial random variable with mean N_{L} and variance q_{P}(L) . We then relate the Pauli expectation value \mu_{P}(L) to the “match” probability by \mu_{P}(L)=\mathbb{E}[X_{P,s}(L)]=(+1)\cdot q_{P}(L)+(-1)\cdot[1-q_{P}(L)]=2q_{P}(L)-1. In cycle benchmarking, the expectation value of each Pauli decays exponentially with the number of cycles L (assuming the probability of each cycle introducing an error is approximately i.i.d.) Erhard et al. 2019 , that is, \mu_{P}(L)=A_{P}f_{P}^{L}, where f_{P}\in[0,1] represents the Pauli fidelity associated with the effective logical Pauli channel of one cycle, and A_{P}\in[0,1] is the amplitude parameter that captures the SPAM error for preparing an eigenstate of P . Since q_{P}(L)=(1+\mu_{P}(L))/2 , this gives the binomial success probability q_{P}(L)=\frac{1+A_{P}f_{P}^{L}}{2}. We fit each Pauli individually with its own amplitude parameter A_{P} and Pauli fidelity f_{P} . Given observed match counts \{K_{P}(L)\}_{L\in\mathcal{L}_{\text{cyc}}} and accepted shot counts \{N_{L}\}_{L\in\mathcal{L}_{\text{cyc}}} , define the likelihood function for parameters (A_{P},f_{P}) by \mathcal{L}(A_{P},f_{P})=\prod_{L\in\mathcal{L}_{\text{cyc}}}\binom{N_{L}}{K_{L}{(P)}}\left(\frac{1+A_{P}f_{P}^{L}}{2}\right)^{K_{P}(L)}\left(\frac{1-A_{P}f_{P}^{L}}{2}\right)^{N_{L}-K_{P}(L)}. Dropping binomial coefficient terms that do not depend on the fit parameters, the negative log-likelihood is \begin{split}-\log\mathcal{L}(A_{P},f_{P})=-&\sum_{L\in\mathcal{L}_{\text{cyc}}}\Bigg[K_{P}(L)\log\!\left(\frac{1+A_{P}f_{P}^{L}}{2}\right)+(N_{L}-K_{P}(L))\log\!\left(\frac{1-A_{P}f_{P}^{L}}{2}\right)\Bigg].\end{split} We obtain the maximum-likelihood estimates (\hat{A}_{P},\hat{f}_{P})=\text{argmin}_{A_{P},f_{P}}\big[-\log\mathcal{L}(A_{P},f_{P})\big], subject to constraints that ensure that 02 errors on the data qubits are flagged and discarded. This is sub-optimal since an ideal decoder for the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} code discards any shot with w\geq 2 errors on data qubits anyway. Therefore we only flag a fault pair if it propagates to an error that the ideal decoder mistakenly corrects instead of discards, i.e. if it propagates to an error with the same syndrome as a single-qubit error. • Ideally, one would apply the gates in C_{\text{FT}} in parallel. However, doing so requires more qubits than what is available on the Helios trapped-ion quantum processor. Therefore we have to run flag gadgets serially. Different choices of which flag gadgets to run first may then result in different total number of simultaneously allocated qubits. In Forlivesi and Amaro 2025 , it was suggested to start by running the gadgets attached to qubits in Q_{X} and run the gadgets in Q_{Z} accordingly. However, for states with |Q_{Z}|\gg|Q_{X}| , such as the logical all-zero state |\bar{0}\rangle^{\otimes 48} , it is better to start with gadgets attached to qubits in Q_{Z} and build the gadgets for qubits in Q_{X} accordingly. Moreover, within the qubits in Q_{Z} , we begin with the flag gadget of the qubit with the largest number of CX gates attached to it in C , followed by the one with the second-to-largest, and so on. This ensures that we are done with flag gadgets which potentially need more flag qubits first, when we have more qubits available, before we entangle more data qubits to the state we are building. • The circuits in Ref. Forlivesi and Amaro 2025 were found by first finding a circuit C which has the lowest number of CX gates (among some fixed number of randomly built C ) and then, using the fact that all CX gates in C commute with each other, finding the CX ordering which results in a C_{\text{FT}} with the lowest number of required qubits. Since the required number of qubits in C_{\text{FT}} is not simply a function of the number of CX gates in C , we combine these two steps together; we find a large number of C (of the order of 10^{3} ) with relatively small number of CX gates, and build C_{\text{FT}} for each of them and choose the one with the smallest number of required simultaneous qubits. 3 Flag-based \ket{\overline{0}}^{\otimes 48} state preparation Using the insight that all operations required for \ket{\overline{0}}^{48} state preparation in the iceberg code are themselves transversal in the iceberg code, a non-FT state preparation circuit for the two-layer concatenated iceberg code can easily be created, see Figure S25 . 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z X X X Z X X X X Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Figure S25: Depth- 9 non-FT circuit preparing \ket{\overline{0}}^{\otimes 48} in the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} code. The circuit contains 142 CX gates. Given the limited error propagation in this circuit, flag-based fault tolerance Chao and Reichardt 2018 is an effective method for deriving an equivalent FT circuit. We produce a preparation circuit using an automated method for producing flag FT circuits for CSS codes Criger et al. 2026 , see Figure S26 . 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 X X Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z X X X Z X X X X X Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z X Z Z X Z X X X Z X Z X Z X X X X X X Z Z Z Z X Z X Z Z X Z Z Z Z X Z Z X Z Z Z Z X Z Z X Z Z Z Z X Z Z X Z Z Z Z Z Z X X Z X Z X X X X Z X X X X Z X Z X X X X Z X X Z X X X X Z Z Z X Z X Z X X X X Z X Z Z X Z X Z X Z X Z X Z X Z X Z X Z X Z X Figure S26: Flag FT circuit preparing \ket{\overline{0}}^{\otimes 48} in the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} code. The circuit contains 344 CX gates and 67 measurements. XIII Decoding Goto’s state preparation Here we discuss more details on the decoding of the state preparation circuit for the \mathcal{I}_{8}\circ\mathcal{I}_{6} concatenated code that was introduced in Ref. Goto 2024 . First note that products of four operators X_{i,j}X_{k,j}X_{k,l}X_{i,l} (and Z_{i,j}Z_{k,j}Z_{k,l}Z_{i,l} ) that are, using the conventions from Fig. 1 a, arranged in a rectangle, commute with all stabilizers, thus, they must be products of logical operators and stabilizers. Since all minimum-weight stabilizers have at least weight \min(n_{1},2n_{2})=8 , the products X_{i,j}X_{k,j}X_{k,l}X_{i,l} (and Z_{i,j}Z_{k,j}Z_{k,l}Z_{i,l} ) must contain at least one logical operator. Hence, each two-qubit X error is connected to at least one other two-qubit error by some combination of logical operators, i.e., for each syndrome corresponding to a two-qubit error there are at least two same-weight errors in different equivalence classes. We thus do not attempt to correct any two-qubit errors. Similar arguments hold for three-qubit errors: for each three-qubit error, we can find at least another three-qubit error with the same syndrome, but in a different equivalence class; additionally, some three-qubit errors share the same syndrome with one-qubit errors in a different equivalence class. Hence, we do not attempt to correct any syndrome corresponding to weight-two-or-higher errors. We simulate the quantum circuit using Stim Gidney 2021 for two-qubit depolarizing noise of strength p after each two-qubit gate. The error rates for qubit initialization and measurement (bit flip or phase flip errors) also equal p . We measure each final state in its Z basis to reconstruct its S^{Z} syndrome s and logical equivalence class q . Since the code has 16 S^{Z} stabilizers and 48 logical qubits, we consider 2^{16} different syndromes s and 2^{48} equivalence classes q . Figure S27: Sampled syndrome probabilities for different error rates p . The syndrome may be caused by errors of different weights; the vertical dashed lines separate regimes whose lowest-weight errors are of weight zero to four. The syndromes are ordered by P(s) in descending order. For each p , we take 10^{10} samples. We show the distribution of syndromes in Fig. S27 . For each p , we sample 10^{10} different circuits and use the results to estimate the syndrome probability P(s) . We categorize all syndromes by their minimum-weight error; note that higher-weight errors (connected via logicals and stabilizers) may cause the same syndrome. The gray dashed lines in Fig. S27 separate syndromes with minimum-weight zero-, one-, two-, and higher-qubit errors. P(s) is not constant in each regime since (i) errors are not caused by code capacity noise, but circuit-level noise, and (ii) some two-weight error syndromes can be caused by two inequivalent weight-two errors, while others can be caused by eight or ten inequivalent weight-two errors (and the latter thus occur with higher probability). Figure S28: Probability P_{q,s} that an error is characterized by an equivalence class q and syndrome s , divided by probability of the syndrome P(s)=\sum_{q}P_{q,s} . Dots denote data points, and the red shaded area the 95 % Wilson confidence interval. For most two-qubit errors, P_{q_{\text{max}},s}/P(s)\lesssim 1/2 (black dashed line denotes 1/2 ). As argued before, we do not attempt to correct any syndrome caused by weight-two errors. In Fig. S28 , we provide numerical evidence that supports our arguments. We show the ratio of the (numerically sampled) maximum-likelihood equivalence class P_{q_{\text{max}},s} and the total syndrome probability P(s)=\sum_{q}P_{q,s} . This ratio is a measure for the confidence in the chosen correction: when the ratio approaches one, we have a high confidence that the syndrome s was caused by an error in class q ; if another equivalence class is more likely, the ratio will drop below 1/2 . We show 1-P_{q_{\text{max}},s}/P(s) in Fig. S28 , which for the trivial syndrome grows as p^{4} , and for syndromes caused by weight-one errors increases as p^{2} . For syndromes caused by two-qubit errors, as argued before, there are at least two same-weight errors in different equivalence classes, hence, assuming that for circuit-level noise both errors have similar probabilities, P_{q_{\text{max}},s}/P(s)\lesssim 1/2 , as evident from Fig. S28 , where the black dashed line denotes P_{q_{\text{max}},s}/P(s)=1/2 . Figure S29: Error rates for the state preparation protocol described in Sec. XIII . The error rates are obtained via Stim Gidney 2021 simulations, where p is the strength of the depolarizing noise. (a) Rate of flagged circuit runs, P_{\text{flag}} , (b) discard rate of syndromes that are not compatible with weight-zero or weight-one errors, P_{\text{post}} , and (c) final logical error rate P_{\text{L}} . The black dots represent the data, the red shaded region the 95 % Wilson confidence interval, and the gray dashed line a power law as a guide for the eyes. In Fig. S29 , we show three different resulting error rates: in Fig. S29 a, we show P_{\text{flag}} , the sampled rate of flagged circuit runs that are discarded. Only the postselected fraction 1-P_{\text{flag}} of runs will be used for state preparation. Since single-qubit errors can cause flags to fire, we expect that P_{\text{flag}} grows linearly with p for small error rates. We show a gray dashed line \propto p as a guide for the eye. We then discard all syndromes compatible with weight-two-and-higher errors. We show the discard rate P_{\text{post}} in panel (b), and include \propto p^{2} as a guide for the eye since two-qubit errors are the dominant contribution to P_{\text{post}} , which occur with probability \propto p^{2} . Finally, we show the resulting logical error rate P_{\text{L}} in panel (c): logical errors occur with probability p^{3} as they correspond to three-qubit errors causing the same syndrome as one-qubit errors in a different equivalence class.