Bending, entropy and proper affine actions of surface groups Martin Bridgeman, Richard Canary, Andres Sambarino Abstract . We show that for any closed surface S S there is an explict neighborhood V V of the fuchsian locus in quasifuchsian space QF ⁡ ( S ) \operatorname{QF}(S) such that for every representation ρ ∈ V \rho\in V which is not fuchsian, there is a proper affine action on 𝔰 ​ 𝔩 ​ ( 2 , ℂ ) \mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C}) with linear part Ad ⁡ ( ρ ) \operatorname{Ad}(\rho) . We further show that there is a larger neighborhood U U of the Fuchsian locus so that every critical point of the entropy function in U U lies on the Fuchsian locus. 1. Introduction Quasifuchsian hyperbolic 3-manifolds are a central object of study in low-dimensional topology and dynamics. One classical theme is the relationship between the geometry of the convex core and dynamical quantities like the topological entropy of the geodesic flow. More recently, connections have emerged between quasifuchsian manifolds and proper affine actions of surface groups on \mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C})\cong\mathbb{R}^{6} . In this paper, we investigate bending deformations on the space QF(S) of all (marked) quasifuchsian hyperbolic 3-manifolds. We introduce the notion of a moderately bent Jordan domain and obtain applications to both the variation of the entropy function on QF(S) and to proper affine actions of surface groups. We begin our investigation by using work Kourouniotis [ 46 , 47 ] to establish a general formula for the variation of the complex length function of an element of \pi_{1}(S) during a bending deformation. If a boundary component of the convex core is moderately bent, we obtain control on the real part of the variation as we bend along the associated bending lamination. Our first application of this work is to show that if one component of the boundary of the convex core of a quasifuchsian hyperbolic 3-manifold (which is not fuchsian) is moderately bent, then it is not a critcal point of the entropy function on QF(S) . Recall that the topological entropy of the geodesic flow of a quasifuchsian hyperbolic 3-manifold is the exponential growth rate of the number of closed geodesics of length at most T . The topological entropy is an analytic function on \operatorname{QF}(S) (see Ruelle [ 57 ] ) and it achieves its minimum value, which is 1, exactly along the locus of fuchsian groups (see Bowen [ 11 ] ). Previous work of Bridgeman [ 12 ] provided some evidence that every critical point of the entropy function lies on the Fuchsian locus. Our second application is to show that if \rho:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) is the holonomy representation of a quasifuchsian hyperbolic 3-manifold (which is not fuchsian) and both components of the boundary of the convex core are moderately bent, then \operatorname{Ad}\rho is the linear part of a proper affine action of \pi_{1}(S) on \mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C}) . Danciger, Guéritaud and Kassel [ 22 ] previously exhibited specific quasifuchsian hyperbolic 3-manifolds with this property. We extend our results to find proper affine actions of surface groups on any simple complex Lie group. We also give applications to proper actions of surface groups on the group manifold of a complex simple Lie group. Finally, we use work of Bridgeman, Canary and Yarmola [ 15 ] to find explicit bounds on the “roundness” of the bending lamination which guarantee that the associated boundary component of the convex core is moderately bent. We can then describe an explicit open neighborhood U of the Fuchsian locus in QF(S) so that every manifold in U which is not fuchsian is not a critical point of the entropy function. Similarly, we describe an explicit open neighborhood V of the Fuchsian locus in QF(S) so that if \rho is the holonomy representation of manifold in V which is not fuchsian, then \operatorname{Ad}\rho is the linear part of a proper affine action of \pi_{1}(S) on \mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C}) . We next develop the language to state our results more concretely. We follow this with a more in-depth discussion of the history of proper affine actions. Statement of results: A quasifuchsian representation is a discrete faithful representation \rho:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) , where S is a closed oriented surface of genus at least two, such that the limit set \Lambda(\rho) of \rho(\pi_{1}(S)) is a Jordan curve. Quasifuchsian space \operatorname{QF}(S) is the space of conjugacy classes of quasifuchsian representations. We may regard \operatorname{QF}(S) as an open subset of the character variety \mathfrak{X}(S)=\mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(S),\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}))//\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}). Since every point in QF(S) is a smooth point of \mathfrak{X}(S) (see [ 36 ] ), QF(S) has the structure of a complex manifold. If \rho is quasifuchsian then the complement of the limit set \Lambda(\rho) is two Jordan domains \Omega_{+}(\rho) and \Omega_{-}(\rho) . The group \rho(\pi_{1}(S)) acts properly discontinuously on \hat{\mathbb{C}}-\Lambda(\rho) , so one obtains two marked Riemann surfaces X_{+}(\rho)=\Omega_{+}(\rho)/\rho(\pi_{1}(S)) and X_{-}(\rho)=\Omega_{-}(\rho)/\rho(\pi_{1}(S)) where we choose the labels on the components of \hat{\mathbb{C}}-\Lambda(\rho) so that there is an orientation-preserving homeomorphism from S\cup\bar{S}\to X_{+}(\rho)\cup X_{-}(\rho) in the homotopy class determined by \rho (where \bar{S} is S with the opposite orientation). Bers showed that the resulting map from \operatorname{QF}(S) to \mathcal{T}(S)\times\mathcal{T}(\bar{S}) is a real analytic diffeomorphism, where \mathcal{T}(S) is the Teichmüller space of S . A representation \rho\in\operatorname{QF}(S) is fuchsian if it is conjugate to a representation with image in \mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{R}) . The Fuchsian locus \mathrm{F}(S)\subset\operatorname{QF}(S) of fuchsian representations is identified with the diagonal in this parametrization. If \Omega is a Jordan domain whose boundary is a Jordan curve C , we say a pair (x,y) of distinct points in C is a bending pair for \Omega if there is a maximal round open disk D in \Omega such that x,y\in\partial D . We say that \Omega is moderately bent if for every bending pair (x,y) there exists a circle L transverse to C such that L\cap C=\{x,y\} . We define the entropy function h:\operatorname{QF}(S)\to[1,2) by letting h([\rho]) be the topological entropy of the geodesic flow on N_{\rho}=\mathbb{H}^{3}/\rho(\pi_{1}(S)) , i.e. the exponential growth rate of the number of closed geodesics in N_{\rho} of length at most T . Sullivan [ 62 ] proved that h([\rho]) is the Hausdorff dimension of the limit set \Lambda(\rho) of \rho(\pi_{1}(S)) . One may also define h([\rho]) to be the critical exponent of the Poincaré series P_{\rho}(s)=\sum_{\gamma\in\pi_{1}(S)}e^{-sd(x_{0},\gamma(x_{0}))}, for any x_{0}\in\mathbb{H}^{3} , i.e. P_{\rho}(s) converges if s>h([\rho]) and diverges if s0 such that {\mathrm{d}}\ell_{\gamma}(w)\leq-K\ell_{\gamma}(\rho) for all \gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) . We now outline how Theorem 1.4 is used to prove Theorem 1.2 . If \rho:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) is quasifuchsian, then {\mathsf{u}}:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C}) is a cocycle for \operatorname{Ad}\rho if {\mathsf{u}}(\gamma\eta)={\mathsf{u}}(\gamma)+\operatorname{Ad}\rho(\gamma){\mathsf{u}}(\eta)\quad\text{for all}\quad\gamma,\eta\in\pi_{1}(S). Cocycles for \operatorname{Ad}\rho are in one-to-one correspondence with Affine representations with linear part \operatorname{Ad}\rho . Specifically, for {\mathsf{u}}:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C}) , the map F_{\rho,{\mathsf{u}}}:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathrm{Aff}(\mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C})) given by F_{(\rho,{\mathsf{u}})}(\gamma)=(\operatorname{Ad}\rho(\gamma),{\mathsf{u}}(\gamma))\quad\mbox{for all}\quad\gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) is an affine representation if and only if u is a cocycle for \operatorname{Ad}\rho . Suppose that [\rho]\in QF(S) and v\in{\mathsf{T}}_{[\rho]}QF(S) , then we choose a vector \tilde{v}\in{\mathsf{T}}_{\rho}\mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(S),\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C})) which projects to v\in{\mathsf{T}}_{[\rho]}QF(S) . If \gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) , then the function A_{\gamma}:\mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(S),\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}))\to\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) given by A_{\gamma}(\rho)=\rho(\gamma) is a complex analytic map. We define {\mathsf{u}}_{\tilde{v}}:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C})\quad\text{by letting}\quad{\mathsf{u}}_{\tilde{v}}(\gamma)=dA_{\gamma}(\tilde{v})A_{\gamma}(\tilde{\rho})^{-1} for all \gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) , which is a cocycle for \operatorname{Ad}\rho . Cocycles for \operatorname{Ad}\rho are in one-to-one correspondence with tangent vectors in {\mathsf{T}}_{\rho}\mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(S),\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C})) . Different choices of representatives of [\rho] and/or \tilde{v} will produce representations conjugate to F_{(\rho,{\mathsf{u}}_{\tilde{v}})} . Kassel and Smilga [ 42 ] , see also Ghosh [ 32 ] , developed a properness criterion for affine actions which is expressed in terms of the Margulis invariant spectrum, see Proposition 6.6 . Theorem 1.4 will allow us to control the Margulis invariant spectrum of (\rho,{\mathsf{u}}_{w}) when \rho and w satisfy the assumptions of the theorem. See Section 6 for details. In order to obtain the explicit neighborhoods of the Fuchsian locus that we promised earlier we recall a numerical invariant which we can use to guarantee that \Omega_{\pm} is moderately bent. If \beta_{\nu} is a bending lamination and L>0 , we let \|\beta_{\nu}\|_{L} be the supremum of the measure of any half-open arc of length less than L . The invariant \|\beta_{\nu}\|_{L} is sometimes called the L -roundness of \beta and was originally introduced by Epstein, Marden and Markovic [ 28 ] . We use the techniques of Bridgeman-Canary-Yarmola [ 15 ] to show that there exist bounds on the L -roundness of \beta_{\nu} which guarantee that \Omega_{\nu} is moderately bent. We define a threshold function r:\mathbb{R}_{+}\rightarrow\mathbb{R}_{+} such that if \|\beta_{\nu}\|_{L}1 , r(x)=x{\mathrm{sech}}(x) . A simple analysis of the function x{\mathrm{sech}}(x) shows that r(x)\geq x{\mathrm{sech}}(x) for all x . Theorem 1.5 . Let \rho\in\operatorname{QF}(S) have bending laminations \beta_{+} and \beta_{-} . If \|\beta_{\nu}\|_{L}0, then \Omega_{\nu}(\rho) is moderately bent. Our promised neighborhoods now have the following concrete form. Corollary 1.6 . Let U(S)=\{[\rho]\in\operatorname{QF}(S):\|\beta_{+}\|_{L_{1}}0\ \ \text{or}\quad\|\beta_{-}\|_{L_{2}}0\}. and V(S)=\{[\rho]\in\operatorname{QF}(S):\|\beta_{+}\|_{L_{1}}0\ \ \text{and}\quad\|\beta_{-}\|_{L_{2}}0\}. (1) U(S) is an open neighborhood of the Fuchsian locus, so that if [\rho]\in U(S) is not fuchsian, then [\rho] is not a critical point of the entropy function h . (2) V(S) is an open neighborhood of the Fuchsian locus, so that if [\rho]\in V(S) is not fuchsian, then \operatorname{Ad}\rho is the linear part of a proper affine action of \pi_{1}(S) on \mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C}) . We now discuss the explicit constants we obtain. For example, r(1)\approx.739 For comparison, it follows from [ 15 , Thm. 4.1] that for any \rho\in\operatorname{QF}(S) one has \|\beta_{\pm}\|_{L}\leq 2\cos^{-1}\left(-\sinh(L/2)\right). In particular, \|\beta_{\pm}\|_{1}\leq 2\cos^{-1}(-\sinh(1/2))\approx 4.2379. To consider how close r(L) is to being maximal, we describe the following elementary example. Take a horocycle H in a hyperbolic plane P\subseteq{{\mathbb{H}}^{3}} and let \gamma:\mathbb{R}\rightarrow P be a piecewise geodesic with vertices on H and each edge of length L . We then let C be the convex pleated plane containing \gamma and perpendicular to P . Then a simple calculation gives that C has bending lamination \beta with \|\beta\|_{L}=2\sin^{-1}\left(\tanh(L/2)\right). It follows that there are non-embedded convex pleated planes with \|\beta\|_{1} arbitrarily close to 2\sin^{-1}\left(\tanh(1/2)\right)\simeq.9607. In Section 9 we discuss other bounds guaranteeing that our domains of discontinuity are moderately bent. These bounds are in terms of the Schwarzian derivative, the Teichmüller distance between the two boundary components and the quasiconformal distortion of \Lambda(\rho) . One may also obtain the following applications to more general complex Lie groups. If {\mathsf{G}} is a complex simple Lie group and \Gamma is a finitely generated group, let \mathcal{C}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) be the space of pairs (\rho,{\mathsf{u}}) where \rho:\Gamma\to{\mathsf{G}} is a representation and {\mathsf{u}} is a cocycle for \operatorname{Ad}\rho . We give \mathcal{C}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) the compact-open topology. If \rho is a smooth point of \mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(S),{\mathsf{G}}) , then the space of cocycles for \operatorname{Ad}\rho is canonically identified with {\mathsf{T}}_{\rho}\mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(S),{\mathsf{G}}) . In general, the space of cocycles for \operatorname{Ad}\rho is identified with Zariski tangent space of \mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(S),{\mathsf{G}}) at \rho (see [ 36 ] ). Corollary 1.7 . Let {\mathsf{G}} be a complex simple Lie group with Lie algebra \mathfrak{g} . i) The subset of \mathcal{C}(\pi_{1}(S),{\mathsf{G}}) consisting of pairs (\rho,{\mathsf{u}}) such that F_{(\rho,{\mathsf{u}})}(\pi_{1}(S)) acts properly discontinuously on \mathfrak{g} has non-empty interior. ii) The set of representations of \pi_{1}(S) into {\mathsf{G}}\times{\mathsf{G}} that are discrete and faithful in each factor, and whose action on {\mathsf{G}} via left/right multiplication is proper, has non-empty interior. Moreover, its closure contains product representations \rho\times\rho where \rho is totally Anosov. The key tool in the proof of (i) is the fact that the normalized Margulis spectrum varies continuously (see Sambarino [ 59 , Lemma 2.34] ). The proof of (ii) makes crucial use of a properness criterion of Benoist [ 3 ] and Kobayashi [ 44 ] . Danciger, Guéritaud and Kassel [ 22 , Prop. 1.8] previously established part (ii) of Corollary 1.7 in the case when {\mathsf{G}}=\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) . Historical background: Auslander [ 2 ] conjectured that if \Gamma acts properly discontinuously and cocompactly on \mathbb{R}^{n} by affine transformations, then \Gamma is virtually solvable. The conjecture remains open, but has been established when n=3 by Fried-Goldman [ 30 ] , when n=4 and n=5 by Tomanov [ 64 ] and when n=6 by Abels, Margulis, and Soifer [ 1 ] . Milnor [ 54 ] asked whether, in analogy with the Bieberbach theorems, something similar might be true for actions which are not cocompact. Margulis [ 51 , 52 ] produced the first examples of proper affine actions by non-abelian free groups on \mathbb{R}^{3} , which are now called Margulis space-times. Drumm [ 24 ] , Charette-Drumm-Goldman [ 18 ] , and Drumm-Goldman [ 25 ] introduced a geometric viewpoint on Margulis’ construction and produced large classes of new examples. Goldman, Labourie and Margulis [ 38 ] gave an exact criterion for when affine actions of free groups on \mathbb{R}^{3} are proper (see Ghosh-Treib [ 34 ] for extensions to \mathbb{R}^{2n+1} ). Danciger, Guéritaud and Kassel [ 20 , 21 ] gave a complete classification of Margulis space-times with convex cocompact linear part and showed that their quotients are all homeomorphic to the interior of a handlebody. Smilga [ 61 ] extended Goldman, Labourie and Margulis’ properness criterion to any real semisimple Lie group \mathsf{G} of the non-compact type. He constructed a proper affine action of a non-abelian free group on the Lie algebra \mathfrak{g} whose linear part is Zariski dense in \operatorname{Ad}(\mathsf{G}) . Burelle and Zager Korenjak [ 16 , 66 ] further analyzed higher-dimensional Margulis space times. It is natural to ask which other groups admit proper affine actions. Mess [ 53 ] showed that a closed surface group cannot have a proper affine action on \mathbb{R}^{3} (see [ 53 ] ). Danciger and Zhang [ 23 ] showed that a proper affine action of a surface group on \mathbb{R}^{d} cannot have a linear part which is a Hitchin representation into \mathsf{SL}(d,\mathbb{R}) . (see also Labourie [ 49 ] ). In a major breakthrough, Danciger, Guéritaud and Kassel [ 22 ] proved that any right-angled Coxeter group on k generators admits a proper affine actions on \mathbb{R}^{k(k-1)/2} . They also show that every hyperbolic surface group admits a proper affine action on \mathbb{R}^{6} . We briefly describe the construction of Danciger, Guéritaud and Kassel in [ 22 ] for producing proper affine actions of hyperbolic surface groups on \mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C})=\mathbb{R}^{6} whose linear part is the adjoint action of the a quasifuchsian group. A surface group of genus g is an index 4 subgroup of the fuchsian Coxeter group which is the reflection group of a (2g+2) -gon all of whose internal angles are \frac{\pi}{2} . They describe an explicit path in the deformation space of the Coxeter group within \mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) and show that the nonfuchsian points on this path give rise to proper affine actions. Acknowledgements: The authors would like to thank Sourav Ghosh, Fanny Kassel and Curt McMullen for helpful comments or conversations. 2. Background 2.1. Geodesic currents and measured laminations Bonahon [ 9 ] introduced the space \mathcal{C}(X) of geodesic currents on a closed hyperbolic surface X as a natural closure of the space of weighted collections of closed geodesics on X . Let G({\mathbb{H}}^{2}) be the space of unoriented geodesics in {\mathbb{H}}^{2} . If X={\mathbb{H}}^{2}/\Gamma is a hyperbolic surface, a geodesic current on X is a locally finite \Gamma -invariant measure on G({\mathbb{H}}^{2}) . We endow the space \mathcal{C}(X) of geodesic currents on X with the weak ∗ topology. Any closed geodesic \alpha (with weight one) on X gives rise to a geodesic current by considering the measure which has an atom of weight one on each geodesic in \mathbb{H}^{2} which covers \alpha . Bonahon [ 9 ] showed that one may continuously extend the length function on geodesics to a length function L_{X}:\mathcal{C}(X)\to[0,\infty). We give a brief description of his construction. Let {\mathsf{PT}}({\mathbb{H}}^{2}) denote the projective tangent bundle of {\mathbb{H}}^{2} and consider the trivial fiber bundle \pi:{\mathsf{PT}}({\mathbb{H}}^{2})\rightarrow G({\mathbb{H}}^{2}) mapping a project tangent vector a point to the associated unoriented geodesic through the point. The fiber above a geodesic g can be identified with g and given its length measure \ell . So, if \mu\in\mathcal{C}(X) , then we obtain a \Gamma -invariant measure on {\mathsf{PT}}({\mathbb{H}}^{2}) which is locally \mu\times\ell . This measure descends to a measure \widehat{\mu\times\ell} on {\mathsf{PT}}(X) . Bonahon defines L_{X}(\mu) to be the total mass of \widehat{\mu\times\ell} . Given homotopy classes \alpha and \beta of closed geodesics on X , one defines their geometric intersection number i(\alpha,\beta) to be the number of transverse intersection points of \alpha and \beta . Bonahon also showed that one may continuously extend the intersection number to a continuous function on \mathcal{C}(X)\times\mathcal{C}(X) . If \mu,\nu\in\mathcal{C}(X) , then then \mu\times\nu gives a measure on G({\mathbb{H}}^{2})\times G({\mathbb{H}}^{2}) invariant under the diagonal action of \Gamma . Letting D({\mathbb{H}}^{2})=\{(\vec{u},\vec{v})\in{\mathsf{PT}}_{x}({\mathbb{H}}^{2})\times{\mathsf{PT}}_{x}({\mathbb{H}}^{2})\ |\ x\in\mathbb{H}^{2}\text{ and }\vec{u}\neq\vec{v}\} we can identify D({\mathbb{H}}^{2}) with a subset of G({\mathbb{H}}^{2})\times G({\mathbb{H}}^{2}) by mapping (\vec{u},\vec{v}) to the pair of geodesics tangent to them. Then D(X)=D({\mathbb{H}}^{2})/\Gamma=\{(\vec{u},\vec{v})\in{\mathsf{PT}}_{x}(X)\times{\mathsf{PT}}_{x}(X)\ |\ x\in X\text{ and }\vec{u}\neq\vec{v}\}. Since the pullback of the measure \mu\times\nu to D({\mathbb{H}}^{2}) is invariant under the action of \Gamma it projects to a measure \widehat{\mu\times\nu} on D(X) . Bonahon defines i_{X}(\mu,\nu) to be the total mass of \widehat{\mu\times\nu} on D(X) . If S is a closed topological surface of genus at least 2 , we may define the space \mathcal{C}(S) as the space of \pi_{1}(S) -invariant locally finite measures on the space of unordered pairs of distinct points in the Gromov boundary \partial_{\infty}\pi_{1}(S) of \pi_{1}(S) . Given (X,h)\in\mathcal{T}(S) , there is a well-defined h_{*} -equivariant homeomorphism \xi:\partial_{\infty}:\pi_{1}(S)\to\partial\mathbb{H}^{2} , which gives rise to a canonical identification of \mathcal{C}(S) to \mathcal{C}(X) . We notice that L_{X} does not induce a well-defined function on \mathcal{C}(S) , since the length function depends on the underlying hyperbolic structure. However, the definition of intersection number does not depend on the choice of hyperbolic structure so we have a well-defined continuous function i:\mathcal{C}(S)\times\mathcal{C}(S)\to[0,\infty) where for any (X,h)\in\mathcal{T}(S) , we take i(\mu,\nu)=i_{X}(\xi_{*}(\mu),\xi_{*}(\nu)) . Notice that a closed geodesic \alpha on X is simple if and only if i(\alpha,\alpha)=0 . More generally, we may consider the space \mathcal{ML}(X) of measured geodesic laminations on X to be the set of geodesic currents of self-intersection zero. If \mu\in\mathcal{ML}(X) then its support {\operatorname{supp}}(\mu) is a closed set foliated by disjoint complete geodesics, i.e. a geodesic lamination. Any interval \alpha transverse to the support, inherits a measure by taking the \mu -measure of all the geodesics transverse to \alpha . This gives the transverse measure associated to \mu . Since intersection number is independent of the hyperbolic structure, \mathcal{ML}(S) is also well-defined. 2.2. The convex core and bending laminations If \rho is quasifuchsian, but not fuchsian, there exists an orientation-preserving homeomorphism j_{\rho}:S\times[0,1]\to C(\rho) in the homotopy class of \rho . Thurston [ 63 ] showed that the intrinsic metric on each component of \partial C(\rho) is hyperbolic. Moreover, there exist measured laminations \beta_{+} and \beta_{-} on \partial C_{+}(\rho)=j_{\rho}(S\times\{1\}) and \partial C_{-}(\rho)=j_{\rho}(S\times\{0\}) so that \partial C_{\pm}(\rho) is totally geodesic on the complement of the support {\operatorname{supp}}(\beta_{\pm}) of \beta_{\pm} and each leaf of {\operatorname{supp}}(\beta_{\pm}) is mapped to a geodesic. (See Epstein-Marden [ 27 ] for complete proofs.) We now briefly describe the transverse bending measures given by \beta_{\nu} for \nu\in\{\pm\} . For a complete description see Epstein-Marden [ 27 ] . It will be easiest to work in the universal cover. Let \tilde{\partial}C_{\nu}(\rho) denote the pre-image of \partial C_{\nu}(\rho) in \partial CH(\rho) . A support half-space to \tilde{\partial}C_{\nu}(\rho) at x\in\partial C_{\nu}(\rho) is a half-space H such that the interior of H is disjoint from the convex hull CH(\rho) and x\in\partial H . The boundary \partial H of a support half-plane, is called a support plane . If \alpha:[0,1]\rightarrow\tilde{\partial}C_{\nu}(\rho) is an arc transverse to \beta_{\nu} (so that \alpha(0),\alpha(1)\notin{\operatorname{supp}}(\beta_{\nu}) ), \mathcal{P}=\{0=t_{0}0 and N so that if n\geq N and (\vec{u},\vec{v}) is in the support of \widehat{\gamma\times\mu_{n}} , then the (un-oriented) angle \angle\vec{u},\vec{v} between \vec{u} and \vec{v} lies between \theta and \pi-\theta . If not, then \gamma lies in the Hausdorff limit of a subsequence of \{{\operatorname{supp}}(\mu_{n})\} . Since the support of \mu is contained in the Hausdorff limit of any subsequence of \{{\operatorname{supp}}(\mu_{n})\} , this would imply that i(\gamma,\mu)=0 . Let \mathcal{L}_{\gamma}^{n}(z)=\mathcal{L}(\rho_{z\mu_{n}}(\gamma)) and \mathcal{L}_{\gamma}(z)=\mathcal{L}(\rho_{z\mu}(\gamma)) . Each \mathcal{L}_{\gamma}^{n} is holomorphic in z (by Theorem 2.1 ) and \{\mathcal{L}_{\gamma}^{n}\} converges uniformly on compact sets to \mathcal{L}_{\gamma} . Thus, \mathcal{L}_{\gamma}^{\prime}(0)=\lim(\mathcal{L}_{\gamma}^{n})^{\prime}(0). Moreover, Theorem 3.1 implies that (\mathcal{L}_{\gamma}^{n})^{\prime}(0)=\int_{D_{\gamma}(X)}\cosh\sigma_{\sigma,\rho}\ d\widehat{(\gamma\times\mu_{n})} for all n . Let D_{\gamma,\theta}(X)=\{(\vec{u},\vec{v})\in D_{\gamma}(X):\pi-\theta\geq\angle\vec{u},\vec{v}\,\geq\theta\}. For all n\geq N , (\mathcal{L}_{\gamma}^{n})^{\prime}(0)=\int_{D_{\gamma,\theta}(X)}\cosh\sigma_{\sigma,\rho}\ d\widehat{(\gamma\times\mu_{n})} Since, D_{\gamma,\theta}(X) is compact and \{\gamma\times\mu_{n}\} converges to \gamma\times\mu in the weak ∗ -topology, we see that \lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}(\mathcal{L}_{\gamma}^{n})^{\prime}(0)=\int_{D_{\gamma,\theta}(X)}\cosh\sigma_{\sigma,\rho}\ d\widehat{(\gamma\times\mu)}=\int_{D_{\gamma}(X)}\cosh\sigma_{\sigma,\rho}\ d\widehat{(\gamma\times\mu)} which completes the proof. ∎ 4. Critical points of the entropy function In this section we show that if one of the components of the domain of discontinuity of a nonfuchsian quasifuchsian group is moderately bent, then it is not a critical point of the entropy function Work of Sambarino [ 59 ] provides a criterion guaranteeing that \rho is not a critical point. If we consider [\rho]\in\operatorname{QF}(S) and a non-zero variation \vec{v}\in T_{[\rho]}\operatorname{QF}(S) , then the link between variation of entropy and variation of lengths is given by the set of normalized variations \mathbb{V}_{\vec{v}}=\overline{\left\{\frac{{\mathrm{d}}\ell_{\gamma}(\vec{v})}{\ell_{\gamma}}:\gamma\in\pi_{1}(S)\right\}}\subset\mathbb{R}. This is a closed interval and if \rho is not fuchsian it has non-empty interior. Moreover, in this case -{\mathrm{d}}h(\vec{v})/h(\rho)\in\mathrm{int}(\mathbb{V}_{\vec{v}}) (see [ 59 , Lemma 2.32] ). The following criterion follows immediately. Proposition 4.1 . (Sambarino [ 59 ] ) Suppose that [\rho]\in\operatorname{QF}(S) is not fuchsian and \vec{v}\in T_{[\rho]}\operatorname{QF}(S) is not zero. If {\mathrm{d}}\ell_{\gamma}(\vec{v})\leq 0 for all \gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) , then {\mathrm{d}}h(\vec{v})\neq 0, in particular h is not critical at [\rho]. We can use our formula for the derivative of complex length and our angle bounds to produce such vectors. Theorem 1.3 . Suppose that [\rho]\in QF(S) is not fuchsian, \Omega_{\nu}(\rho) is moderately bent (for some \nu\in\{\pm\} ) and w=w_{\nu}(\rho) is the infinitesmal bending deformation for -i\beta_{\nu} . If \gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) , then d\ell_{\gamma}(w)\leq 0 and d\ell_{\gamma}(w)<0 if \gamma intersects \beta_{\nu} essentially. Notice that Theorem 1.1 follows immediately from Theorem 1.3 and Proposition 4.1 . Proof. By Theorem 3.2 , d\ell_{\gamma}(w)=\Re(d\mathcal{L}_{\gamma}(w))=\Re\left(\int_{D_{\gamma}(X)}\cosh\sigma_{\rho,\gamma}\ d\widehat{(\gamma\times-i\beta_{\nu})}\right)=\int_{D_{\gamma}(X)}\Im\Big(\cosh\sigma_{\rho,\gamma}\Big)\ d\widehat{(\gamma\times\beta_{\nu})}. In particular, d\ell_{\gamma}(w)=0 if \gamma does not intersect \beta_{\nu} essentially. Recall that given (\vec{u},\vec{v})\in D_{\gamma}(X) , we lift (\vec{u},\vec{v}) to a pair of projective tangent vectors (\vec{U},\vec{V})\in{\mathsf{PT}}{\mathbb{H}}^{2} which are tangent to geodesics a_{U}(\gamma) and g_{V} . Then \sigma_{\rho,\gamma}(\vec{u},\vec{v})\ =\sigma((\xi_{\rho})_{*}(a_{U}(\gamma)),(\xi_{\rho})_{*}(g_{V})). Denoting the geodesics as an oriented pair of endpoints, we let (u_{-},u_{+})=(\xi_{\rho})_{*}(a_{U}(\gamma)) and (v_{-},v_{+})=(\xi_{\rho})_{*}(g_{V}) . By Equation ( 1 ) \Im\Big(\cosh\sigma_{\rho,\gamma}\Big)(\vec{u},\vec{v})\ =\frac{-2\Im\Big([u_{-},v_{-},v_{+},u_{+}]\Big)}{\left|[u_{-},v_{-},v_{+},u_{+}]-1\right|^{2}}. Thus it suffices to show that \Im\Big([u_{-},v_{-},v_{+},u_{+}]\Big)>0 for all (\vec{u},\vec{v})\in{\operatorname{supp}}(\widehat{\gamma\times\beta_{\nu}}) . Notice that, since g_{V} crosses a_{U}(\gamma) from left to right, the vertices occur in the order u_{-},v_{-},u_{+},v_{+} on \Lambda(\rho) . For a bending line with endpoints the bending pair (v_{-},v_{+}) , we can choose a support plane P which intersects \Lambda(\rho) only at v_{-} and v_{+} . (If the bending line has a unique support plane it has this property, while if not we can take any support plane which is not left-most or right-most.) We may assume that (v_{-},v_{+})=(0,\infty) that the plane P lying above the real axis \mathbb{R} is a support plane for CH(\Lambda(\rho)) , and the upper half-plane is the boundary disk of the support half-space bounded by P . It follows that \Omega_{\nu} contains the upper half-plane and that u_{-} and u_{+} are in the lower half-plane. Since \Omega_{\nu} is moderately bent, there exists a line L through 0 and \infty which intersects \Lambda(\rho) transversely and only at 0 and \infty . With our conventions u_{-} lies to the left of L (i.e. the side containing the negative real axis) and u_{+} lies to the right of L (see Figure 1 ). As the cross-ratio is invariant under rotation, we apply a clockwise rotation r about 0 so that z_{+}=r(u_{+}) lies on the positive real axis and let z_{-}=r(u_{-}) . The angle of rotation is less than the angle the portion of L below the real axis makes with the positive real axis, so \Im(z_{-})<0 . Figure 1. Domain \Omega_{\nu} So, [u_{-},v_{-},v_{+},u_{+}]=[z_{-},0,\infty,z_{+}]=\frac{z_{+}}{z_{-}}=\frac{z_{+}\overline{z_{-}}}{|z_{-}|^{2}}. Moreover, \Im\Big(z_{+}\overline{z_{-}}\Big)=-z_{+}\Im(z_{-})>0,\quad\text{so}\quad\Im\Big([u_{-},v_{-},v_{+},u_{+}]\Big)>0, which completes the proof. ∎ 5. Binding pairs of laminations and \delta -intersection number In this section we prove Theorem 1.4 which shows that lengths of curves decrease uniformly in the direction w(\rho)=w_{+}(\rho)+w_{-}(\rho)\in{\mathsf{T}}_{[\rho]}QF(S) . We say that a pair (\alpha,\beta) of measured laminations on S is binding if i(\alpha,\mu)+i(\beta,\mu)>0 whenever \mu is a non-trivial geodesic current on S . If (\vec{u},\vec{v})\in D(X) , let \angle\vec{u},\vec{v} is the unoriented angle between \vec{u} and \vec{v} . In particular, (\vec{u},\vec{v})\in(0,\pi)) . If \delta\in\left(0,\frac{\pi}{2}\right) , we define D_{\delta}(X)=\{(\vec{u},\vec{v})\in D(X):\pi-\delta\geq\,\angle\vec{u},\vec{v}\,\geq\delta\} If \alpha,\mu\in\mathcal{C}(X) and \delta>0 , we define i_{\delta}(\alpha,\mu) to be the total mass of the points in D_{\delta}(X) with respect to the quotient measure of \alpha\times\mu . Notice that while intersection number is independent of the base hyperbolic structure, the \delta -intersection number depends crucially on the underlying structure. Lemma 5.1 . Let (\alpha,\beta) be a binding pair of measured laminations on a closed hyperbolic surface X . There exists a \delta>0 and C>0 so that if \mu\in\mathcal{C}(X) , then i_{\delta}(\alpha,\mu)+i_{\delta}(\beta,\mu)\geq C\ell_{X}(\mu). Proof. Suppose no such \delta and C exist. Then, since \ell_{X} and intersection number both scale linearly, there exist a sequence \{\mu_{n}\} of unit length geodesic currents so that i_{\frac{1}{n}}(\alpha,\mu_{n})+i_{\frac{1}{n}}(\beta,\mu_{n})\to 0. Since the space \mathcal{C}_{1}(X) of unit length geodesic currents is homeomorphic to the space of projective geodesic currents \mathcal{PC}(S) , \mathcal{C}_{1}(X) is compact (see [ 9 ] ). We may assume that \mu_{n}\to\mu\in\mathcal{C}_{1}(X) . Since (\alpha,\beta) is binding, i(\alpha,\mu)+i(\beta,\mu)>0. Since D(X)=\bigcup_{n\in\mathbb{N}}D_{\frac{1}{n}}(X) , we see that there exists N\in\mathbb{N} so that i_{\frac{1}{N}}(\alpha,\mu)+i_{\frac{1}{N}}(\beta,\mu)>0. By considering a continuous bump function supported on D_{\frac{1}{2N}}(X) and equal to 1 on D_{\frac{1}{N}}(X) , we see that \liminf_{n\rightarrow\infty}\left(i_{\frac{1}{2N}}(\alpha,\mu_{n})+i_{\frac{1}{2N}}(\beta,\mu_{n})\right)\geq i_{\frac{1}{N}}(\alpha,\mu)+i_{\frac{1}{N}}(\beta,\mu)>0 which produces a contradiction as \liminf_{n\rightarrow\infty}\left(i_{\frac{1}{2N}}(\alpha,\mu_{n})+i_{\frac{1}{2N}}(\beta,\mu_{n})\right)\leq\liminf_{n\rightarrow\infty}\left(i_{\frac{1}{n}}(\alpha,\mu_{n})+i_{\frac{1}{n}}(\beta,\mu_{n})\right)=0. ∎ We can now return to our bounds on derivatives and observe that they can be made uniform with respect to \delta -intersection number. Lemma 5.2 . Suppose that [\rho]\in\operatorname{QF}(S) is not fuchsian, \Omega_{\nu} is moderately bent for some \nu\in\{\pm\} and w=w_{\nu}(\rho)\in{\mathsf{T}}_{[\rho]}QF(S) . If \delta\in\left(0,\frac{\pi}{2}\right) , then there exists D=D(\delta,\rho_{0}) so that {\mathrm{d}}\ell_{\gamma}(w_{\nu}(\rho))\leq-Ci_{\delta}(\gamma,\beta_{+}) for all \gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) . Proof. Recall that if \mu\in\mathcal{C}(X) , then i_{\delta}(\mu,\beta_{\nu})=\mu\times\beta_{\nu}\big(D_{\delta}(X)\big) and that D_{\delta}(X) is compact. If (u,v)\in D_{\delta}(X) lies in the support of \mu\times\beta_{\nu} , then u is a tangent vector to a leaf m of \mu and v is a tangent vector to a leaf a of \beta_{\nu} . Since \Omega_{\nu} is moderately bent, we saw in the proof of Theorem 1.3 that \Im\cosh\sigma(a,m)<0 . Since the intersection of the support of \mu\times\beta_{\nu} with D_{\delta}(X) is compact and complex length varies continuously, there exists C>0 so that if (u,v)\in D_{\delta}(X) lies in the support of \mu\times\beta_{\nu} , then \Im\left(\cosh\sigma(a,m)\right)\leq-C . Our formula for d\ell_{\gamma}(w_{\nu}(\rho)) , from Theorem 3.2 , immediately gives that d\ell_{\gamma}(w_{\nu}(\rho))\leq-Ci_{\delta}(\gamma,\beta_{+}) for all \gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) . ∎ We are now ready to prove Theorem 1.4 . Theorem 1.4 . Suppose that \rho\in\operatorname{QF}(S) is not fuchsian and that w=w_{+}(\rho)+w_{-}(\rho) . If both \Omega_{+}(\rho) and \Omega_{-}(\rho) are moderately bent, then there exists K>0 such that {\mathrm{d}}\ell_{\gamma}(w)\leq-K\ell_{\gamma}(\rho) for all \gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) . Proof. Recall that the bending laminations of a quasifuchsian group which is not fuchsian always bind (see, for example Bonahon-Otal [ 10 , Proposition 4] ). Fix a hyperbolic structure X on S . Lemma 5.1 implies that there exists a \delta>0 and C>0 so that if \mu\in\mathcal{C}(X) , then i_{\delta}(\beta_{+},\mu)+i_{\delta}(\beta_{-},\mu)\geq C\ell_{\mu}(X). Lemma 5.2 implies that there exists D>0 so that {\mathrm{d}}\ell_{\gamma}(w_{\pm}(\rho))\leq-Di_{\delta}(\gamma,\beta_{\pm}) for all \gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) and \nu\in\{\pm\} . Therefore, {\mathrm{d}}\ell_{\gamma}(w)\leq-D\Big(i_{\delta}(\gamma,\beta_{+})+i_{\delta}(\gamma,\beta_{-})\Big)\leq-CD\ell_{\gamma}(X) for all \gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) . Since \rho is quasifuchsian, there exists B>1 so that \frac{\ell_{\gamma}(\rho)}{B}\leq\ell_{\gamma}(X)\leq B\ell_{\gamma}(\rho) for all \gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) . Therefore, {\mathrm{d}}\ell_{\gamma}(w)\leq-\frac{CD}{B}\ell_{\gamma}(\rho) for all \gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) . ∎ 6. Proper affine actions with quasifuchsian holonomy In this section, we show that if both components of the domain of discontinuity of a nonfuchsian quasifuchsian representation \rho are moderately bent, then \operatorname{Ad}\rho arises as the linear part of a proper affine action of the surface group on \mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C}) . In Section 6.1 , we introduce the Margulis invariant of a loxodromic element in \mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) and an element of the Lie algebra \mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C}) . We see that the Margulis invariant provides a bound on the displacement of the associated action on \mathrm{Aff}(\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C})) . The reader who is only interested in the quasifuchsian case can always assume that d=2 which simplifes the discussion. In Section 6.2 , we recall the theory of totally Anosov (a.k.a. Borel Anosov) representations into \mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) . This is a natural setting for our work, since if a representation is totally Anosov then all infinite order elements have loxodromic image. A representation into \mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) is totally Anosov if and only if it is convex cocompact. In Section 6.3 , we develop a criterion guaranteeing that a totally Anosov representation into \mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) and an associated cocycle with image in \mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C}) give rise to a proper affine action on \mathrm{Aff}(\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C})) . In Section 6.4 we use our criterion to prove Theorem 1.2 . In section 6.5 we obtain generalizations of Theorem 1.2 in other complex Lie groups. 6.1. The Margulis invariant The fact that we are working in \mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) means that the eigenvalues of a matrix are only well-defined up to mulitplication by a d^{\rm th} root of unity. However, the moduli of the eigenvalues and their associated eigenspaces are still well-defined. We first develop language which makes this concrete. If g\in\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) , we may choose a lift \tilde{g}\in\mathsf{SL}(d,\mathbb{C}) . Let \big(\lambda_{i}(\tilde{g})\big)_{i=1}^{d} denote the (generalized) eigenvalues of \tilde{g} ordered so that |\lambda_{i}(\tilde{g})|\geq|\lambda_{i+1}(\tilde{g})| for all i . Notice that the center Z_{d} of \mathsf{SL}(d,\mathbb{C}) consists of matrices of the form r\rm{I} where r is a d^{\rm th} root of unity. If \tilde{g}^{\prime} is another lift of g , then there exists c\in Z_{d} , so that \tilde{g}=c\tilde{g}^{\prime} . In particular, there exists a d^{\rm th} root of unity r , so that \lambda_{i}(\tilde{g})=r\lambda_{i}(\tilde{g}^{\prime}) for all i . So we may define the Jordan projection \mu:\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C})\to\mathfrak{a}^{+} where \mathfrak{a}^{+}=\left\{\mathrm{diag}(a_{1},\ldots,a_{d}):\ a_{1},\ldots,a_{d}\in\mathbb{R},\ a_{i}\geq a_{i+1}\forall\ i\text{ and }\sum_{i=1}^{d}a_{i}=0\right\}\ \ \text{and}\ \ \mu(g)=(\log|\lambda_{1}(\tilde{g})|,\ldots,\log|\lambda_{d}(\tilde{g})|). We say that g is loxodromic if any (hence every) lift \tilde{g} is loxodromic, i.e. is diagonalizable over \mathbb{C} and its eigenvalues have distinct moduli. If g is loxodromic, then there exists \tilde{\psi}\in\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) that conjugates \tilde{g} to a diagonal matrix \mathrm{diag}(b_{1},\ldots,b_{d}) with decreasing in modulus entries, i.e. |b_{i}|>|b_{i+1}| for all i . Then \tilde{\psi} projects to \psi\in\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) and we will say that \psi conjugates g into standard form. If g is loxodromic, let L_{i}(g) denote the one-dimensional eigenspace of \tilde{g} with eigenvalue \lambda_{i}(\tilde{g}) . The eigenspace L_{i}(g) is well-defined since any two lifts differ by an element of Z_{d} and Z_{d} acts trivially on \mathbb{P}(\mathbb{C}^{d}) . Let E_{i}(g) be the i -dimensional space spanned by the first i eigenspaces, i.e. E_{i}(g)=\langle L_{1}(g),\ldots,L_{i}(g)\rangle . The flag E(g)=\big(E_{i}(g)\big)_{i=1}^{d-1} is the attracting flag of g . Notice that if \psi is an element conjugating g into standard form and E^{0}=\{\langle e_{1}\rangle,\langle e_{1},e_{2},\rangle,\ldots,\langle e_{1},\ldots,e_{d-1}\rangle\} then E(g)=\psi(E^{0}) . The repelling flag of g is given by F(g)=\big(F_{i}(g)\big)_{i=1}^{d-1} where F_{i}(g)=\langle L_{d-i+1},\ldots,L_{d}(g)\rangle . Notice that E(g)=F(g^{-1}) . The Lie algebra \mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C}) of \mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) contains a subalgebra {\mathfrak{h}} consisting of traceless diagonal matrices (over \mathbb{C} ). More precisely, {\mathfrak{h}}=\big\{{\operatorname{diag}}(z_{1},\ldots,z_{d}):\sum z_{i}=0\big\}. The adjoint action \operatorname{Ad}(g):\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C})\to\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C}) is given \operatorname{Ad}(g)(v)=\tilde{g}v\tilde{g}^{-1} . (Notice that again the choice of lift is irrelevant since any two lifts differ by an element of Z_{d} and \operatorname{Ad}(c) is the identity map for any c\in Z_{d} .) If g is loxodromic, \operatorname{Ad}(g) is also diagonalizable (although it may have eigenvalue coincidences). If \psi conjugates g into standard form, then its 1 -eigenspace is given by V^{0}(g):=\mathrm{Fix}\,(\operatorname{Ad}(g))=\operatorname{Ad}(\psi^{-1}){\mathfrak{h}}. We can consider the projection \pi^{0}_{g}:\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C})\to V^{0}(g) whose kernel W(g) is \operatorname{Ad}(g) -invariant. More explicitly W(g) is the sum of the eigenspaces associated to all the eigenvalues but 1 . Margulis [ 51 ] originally defined the Margulis invariant for pairs in \mathrm{SO}(1,2)\ltimes\mathbb{R}^{3} . The following generalization is due to Smilga [ 61 ] . Definition 6.1 . If g\in\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) and x\in\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C}) the Margulis invariant of (g,x) is {\mathsf{m}}(g,x):=\operatorname{Ad}(\psi)\big(\pi^{0}_{g}(x)\big)\in{\mathfrak{h}}, i.e. we project x onto the fixed set V^{0}(g) of \operatorname{Ad}(g) and move it into {\mathfrak{h}} via \operatorname{Ad}(\psi). Since any two elements \psi and \psi^{\prime} which conjugate g into standard form satisfy \psi^{\prime}\psi^{-1}\in\exp{\mathfrak{h}} and \operatorname{Ad}(\exp{\mathfrak{h}}) acts trivially on {\mathfrak{h}}, the Margulis invariant {\mathsf{m}}(g,x) is independent of the choice of \psi . Moreover, - {\mathsf{m}}(g,x) is invariant under conjugation by an element of \mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C})\ltimes\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C}), and - {\mathsf{m}}\big((g,x)^{-1}\big)=\mathrm{i}\big({\mathsf{m}}(g,x)\big), where \mathrm{i} is the opposition involution of {\mathfrak{h}}. In our proof it will be useful to choose \psi efficiently. Lemma 6.2 . (Bochi-Potrie-Sambarino [ 8 , Proposition 7.2] ) Given d\in\mathbb{N} , there exists K>1 so that if g\in\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) is loxodromic, one may choose an element \psi which conjugates g into standard form so that \|\psi\|\min_{i\in\llbracket 1,d-1\rrbracket}\angle(E_{i}(g),F_{d-i}(g))\in(1/K,K) where \|\psi\| is the standard operator norm of \psi . Remark 6.3 (When d=2 ) . If g\in\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) is loxodromic, then there exists \psi\in\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) so that \psi g\psi^{-1}=\pm\begin{bmatrix}\lambda&0\\ 0&\lambda^{-1}\end{bmatrix} where |\lambda|>1 . So, V^{0}(g):=\mathrm{Fix}\,(\operatorname{Ad}(g))=\operatorname{Ad}(\psi^{-1}){\mathfrak{h}}=\left\langle\psi^{-1}\begin{bmatrix}1&0\\ 0&{-1}\end{bmatrix}\psi\right\rangle. The other two eigenspaces of \operatorname{Ad}(g) are \left\langle\psi^{-1}\begin{bmatrix}0&1\\ 0&0\end{bmatrix}\psi\right\rangle\quad\text{and}\quad\left\langle\psi^{-1}\begin{bmatrix}0&0\\ 1&0\end{bmatrix}\psi\right\rangle with eigenvalues \lambda^{2} and \lambda^{-2} respectively. Moreover, E(g) is the attracting eigenline of g and F(g) is the repelling eigenline. Notice that the opposition involution is the identity map when d=2 , so {\mathsf{m}}\big((g,x)^{-1}\big)={\mathsf{m}}(g,x). An element (g,x)\in\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C})\ltimes\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C}) induces an affine transformation {\mathsf{F}}_{(g,x)}:\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C})\to\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C})\quad\text{by}\quad{\mathsf{F}}_{(g,x)}v=\operatorname{Ad}(g)v+x. When the angles between the attracting/repelling flags of g are uniformly bounded below, then the displacement of {\mathsf{F}}_{(g,x)} is controlled by the Margulis invariant: Lemma 6.4 (Margulis invariant as least displacement) . Given C>0 and d\in\mathbb{N} , there exists c>0 such that if g\in\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) is loxodromic and \min_{i\in\llbracket 1,d-1\rrbracket}\angle(E_{i}(g),F_{d-i}(g))\geq C, then \big\|{\mathsf{F}}_{(g,x)}v-v\big\|\geq c\|{\mathsf{m}}(g,x)\|. for any x,v\in\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C}) . Proof. Since the angles of the attracting/repelling flags of g are bounded below by C, the angles between the spaces in the decomposition \mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C})=V^{0}(g)\oplus W(g) are uniformly bounded below. Thus there exists k>0 (depending only on C and d ) such that \|u\|\geq\|\pi^{0}_{g}(u)\| for every u\in\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C}) . In particular, if u={\mathsf{F}}_{(g,x)}v-v we obtain (2) \|{\mathsf{F}}_{(g,x)}v-v\|\geq k\big\|\pi^{0}_{g}({\mathsf{F}}_{(g,x)}v-v)\big\|. Now observe that, since \operatorname{Ad}(g)|_{V^{0}(g)}=\mathrm{id} , we have \pi^{0}_{g}\big({\mathsf{F}}_{(g,x)}v-v\big)=\pi^{0}_{g}\big(\operatorname{Ad}(g)v+x-v)=\pi^{0}_{g}(x), It follows from the definition of {\mathsf{m}} that \operatorname{Ad}(\psi)\big(\pi^{0}_{g}\big({\mathsf{F}}_{(g,x)}v-v)\big)={\mathsf{m}}(g,x). for all v\in\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C}) , where \psi is an element conjugating g into standard form. By Lemma 6.2 we can chose \psi so that \|\psi\|0 and d\in\mathbb{N} , there exists b>0 such that if g\in\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) is loxodromic and \min_{i\in\llbracket 1,d-1\rrbracket}\angle(E_{i}(g),F_{d-i}(g))\geq C, then \big|\omega_{1}(\mu(g))-\log\sigma_{1}(g)\big|1 , which depends only on C and d , so that \psi g\psi^{-1} is in standard form and ||\psi||0 so that \|m(\rho(\gamma),{\mathsf{u}}(\gamma))\|\geq a\omega_{1}(\mu(\rho(\gamma))) for all \gamma\in\Gamma . Guichard and Wienhard [ 31 , Thm. 5.10] used work of Abels, Margulis and Soifer [ 1 ] to show that if \rho is totally Anosov, then there exists a finite subset A\subset\Gamma and C>0 so that if \gamma\in\Gamma , then there exists \alpha\in A so that \rho(\alpha\gamma) is loxodromic and (3) \min_{i\in\llbracket 1,d-1\rrbracket}\angle(E_{i}(\alpha\gamma),F_{d-i}(\alpha\gamma))\geq C. Lemmas 6.4 and 6.5 then imply that there exists b,c>0 so that for all \gamma\in\Gamma there exists \alpha\in A so that (4) \|{\mathsf{F}}(\alpha\gamma)v-v\|\geq c\big\|{\mathsf{m}}\big(\rho(\alpha\gamma),{\mathsf{u}}(\alpha\gamma)\big)\big\|\text{ for all }v\in\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C})\quad\text{and}\quad|\omega_{1}(\mu(\rho(\alpha\gamma))-\log\sigma_{1}(\rho(\alpha\gamma)|0 so that {\mathrm{d}}\ell_{\gamma}(w)\leq-K\ell_{\gamma}(\rho) for all \gamma\in\pi_{1}(S) . Since \ell_{\rho}(\gamma)=2\log(\mu_{1}(\gamma)) , Proposition 6.7 implies that \Re\Big({\mathsf{m}}(\rho(g),{\mathsf{u}}(g))\Big)=\Big({\mathrm{d}}\ell_{\gamma}({\mathsf{u}}),-{\mathrm{d}}\ell_{\gamma}({\mathsf{u}})\Big) and so the first coordinate of \frac{\Re\big({\mathsf{m}}(\rho(g){\mathsf{u}}(g))\big)}{\omega_{1}(\rho(g))} is always less than -K . Therefore, 0\notin\mathrm{MS}(\rho,{\mathsf{u}}) , so our Properness Criterion, Proposition 6.6 , implies that the action F_{\rho,{\mathsf{u}}} is proper. ∎ 6.5. Proper affine actions on other complex Lie groups We first observe that one may generalize the proof of Theorem 1.2 into the setting of totally Anosov representations into \mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) . Let \mathfrak{a} denote the real part of {\mathfrak{h}} (i.e. the matrices in {\mathfrak{h}} with real entries) and let \mathfrak{a}^{*} be its dual space. Suppose that \Gamma is a finitely generated group. If \varphi\in\mathfrak{a}^{*} and \gamma\in\Gamma , consider the function \varphi^{\gamma}:\mathrm{Hom}\big(\Gamma,\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C})\big)\to\mathfrak{a}\quad\text{given by}\quad\varphi^{\gamma}:\rho\mapsto\varphi\big(\mu\big(\rho(\gamma)\big)\big). If (\rho_{t})_{t\in(-\varepsilon,\varepsilon)}:\Gamma\to\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) is a smooth curve in \mathfrak{X}\big(\Gamma,\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C})\big) so that \rho_{0} is totally Anosov, then \varphi^{\gamma} is differentiable at 0, whenever \gamma\in\Gamma has infinite order. Corollary 6.8 . Let (\rho_{t})_{t\in(-\varepsilon,\varepsilon)} be a smooth curve in \mathrm{Hom}\big(\Gamma,\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C})\big) such that \rho=\rho_{0} is totally Anosov and let {\mathsf{u}}:\Gamma\to\mathfrak{g} be the cocycle given by {\mathsf{u}}(g)=\frac{d}{dt}\Big|_{t=0}\rho_{t}(g)\rho_{0}(g)^{-1}. If there exists \varphi\in\mathfrak{a}^{*} such that {\mathrm{d}}\varphi^{\gamma}({\mathsf{u}})\geq\omega_{1}(\mu(\rho(\gamma))) for all \gamma\in\Gamma , then {\mathsf{F}}_{(\rho,{\mathsf{u}})}(\Gamma) acts properly discontinuously on \mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C}) is proper. Proof. By Proposition 6.6 it suffices to show that 0\notin\mathrm{MS}(\rho,{\mathsf{u}}). For \gamma\in\Gamma we have, by Proposition 6.7 and our assumption imply that \varphi\big(\Re\big({\mathsf{m}}(\rho(\gamma),{\mathsf{u}}(\gamma))\big)\big)={\mathrm{d}}\varphi^{\gamma}({\mathsf{u}})\geq\omega_{1}(\mu(\rho(\gamma))). Thus \varphi\Big(\Re\big(\mathrm{MS}(\rho,{\mathsf{u}})\big)\Big)\subset[1,\infty), which implies that 0\notin\mathrm{MS}(\rho,{\mathsf{u}}). ∎ We now consider other complex simple Lie groups. If {\mathsf{G}} is a complex simple Lie group with Lie algebra \mathfrak{g} , the concepts from the previous sections, such as the Cartan algebra \mathfrak{h} , the Jordan projection \mu:{\mathsf{G}}\to\mathfrak{a}=\Re({\mathfrak{h}}), and the Cartan projection \kappa:{\mathsf{G}}\to\mathfrak{a}=\Re({\mathfrak{h}}) extend to this setting. Finally the Margulis invariant {\mathsf{m}}(g,x)\in{\mathfrak{h}} of (g,x)\in{\mathsf{G}}\ltimes\mathfrak{g}, can be extended to this more general setting. It will suffice for our purposes to recall that (after identifying {\mathsf{G}}\ltimes\mathfrak{g} with {\mathsf{T}}{\mathsf{G}} ) for (g,x)=\dot{g}\in{\mathsf{T}}_{g}{\mathsf{G}} , \Re\big({\mathsf{m}}(g,x)\big)={\mathrm{d}}\mu(\dot{g}) (see [ 59 , Corollary 8.3] ). We refer the reader to the book of Benoist and Quint [ 5 ] for the standard Lie algebra and Lie group concepts and to Smilga [ 61 ] for a discussion of the Margulis invariant in this more general context. In this setting it is convenient to consider the first fundamental restricted weight \varpi_{1}\in\mathfrak{a}^{*} of {\mathsf{G}}. The number \varpi_{1}(\mu(g)) replaces \omega_{1}(\mu(g)) (and coincides with it when {\mathsf{G}}=\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) ). We say that a representation \rho:\Gamma\rightarrow{\mathsf{G}} is totally Anosov if it is Anosov with respect to a minimal parabolic subgroup of {\mathsf{G}} (see [ 31 ] ). Let \mathfrak{A}_{{\mathsf{\Delta}}}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) be the subspace of the character variety \mathfrak{X}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) consisting of totally Anosov representations. For a homomorphism (\rho,u):\Gamma\to{\mathsf{G}}\ltimes\mathfrak{g} the normalized Margulis spectrum is the subset of {\mathfrak{h}} , \mathrm{MS}(\rho,{\mathsf{u}})=\overline{\Big\{\frac{{\mathsf{m}}(\rho(\gamma),{\mathsf{u}}(\gamma))}{\varpi_{1}\big(\mu(\rho(\gamma))\big)}:\gamma\in\Gamma\text{ has infinite order }\Big\}}. We recall that the Margulis spectrum varies continuously. Proposition 6.9 (Sambarino [ 59 , Lemma 2.34] ) . The map (\rho,{\mathsf{u}})\mapsto\mathrm{MS}(\rho,{\mathsf{u}}) is continuous on the open subset of \mathcal{C}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) where \rho\in\mathfrak{A}_{{\mathsf{\Delta}}}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) (where the image lies in the space of compact subsets of {\mathfrak{h}} with the Hausdorff topology). We are now ready to prove part (1) of Corollary 1.7 . Recall that \mathcal{C}(S,{\mathsf{G}}) is the space of pairs (\rho,{\mathsf{u}}) where \rho:\pi_{1}(S)\to{\mathsf{G}} is a representation and {\mathsf{u}} is a cocycle for \operatorname{Ad}\rho . Theorem 6.10 . Let {\mathsf{G}} be a complex simple Lie group with Lie algebra \mathfrak{g} , then the subset of \mathcal{C}(S,{\mathsf{G}}) consisting of pairs (\rho,{\mathsf{u}}) so that F_{\rho,{\mathsf{u}}}(\pi_{1}(S)) act properly on \mathfrak{g} has non-empty interior. Proof. We first give the proof in the case that {\mathsf{G}}=\mathrm{Inn}(\mathfrak{g}) is the group of inner autmorphisms of \mathfrak{g} . Theorem 1.2 implies there exists \rho\in\operatorname{QF}(S) and a cocycle {\mathsf{u}} for \operatorname{Ad}\rho such that 0\notin\Re(\mathrm{MS}(\rho,{\mathsf{u}})). Kostant defined an embedding \tau:\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C})\to\mathrm{Inn}(\mathfrak{g}) , called the principal embedding, which is unique up to conjugation. If {\mathsf{G}}=\mathsf{PSL}(d,\mathbb{C}) , the principle embedding is the irreducible embedding (see Kostant [ 45 ] ). The principal embedding \tau:\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C})\to\mathrm{Inn}(\mathfrak{g}) has the property that \varpi_{1}(\mu(\tau(g)))=c_{\mathfrak{g}}\omega_{1}(\mu(g)) for all g\in\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) , where c_{\mathfrak{g}}>0 is an explicit constant ( c_{\mathfrak{g}}=d-1 when \mathfrak{g}=\mathfrak{sl}(d,\mathbb{C}) ). The principal embedding \tau induces an embedding \mathrm{d}\tau:\mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C})\to\mathfrak{g}\quad\text{so that}\quad\varpi_{1}\big(\Re(\mathrm{MS}(\tau(\rho),{\mathrm{d}}\tau\circ{\mathsf{u}})\big)=\omega_{1}(\Re(\mathrm{MS}(\rho,{\mathsf{u}}))), so 0\notin\Re(\mathrm{MS}(\tau(\rho),{\mathrm{d}}\tau({\mathsf{u}}))). Since the map (\eta,{\vec{v}})\mapsto\mathrm{MS}(\eta,{\vec{v}}) is continuous when \eta is totally Anosov and 0\notin\varpi_{1}(\Re(\mathrm{MS}(\tau(\rho),{\mathrm{d}}\tau({\mathsf{u}})))) , we conclude that the same holds for nearby (\eta,{\vec{v}}). In particular, 0\notin\mathrm{MS}(\eta,{\vec{v}}) and thus the analogue of Proposition 6.8 (see [ 42 ] or [ 59 , Prop. 7.2] ) shows that {\mathsf{F}}_{(\eta,\vec{v})}(\pi_{1}(S)) acts properly discontinuously on \mathfrak{g} . If {\mathsf{G}} is not \mathrm{Inn}(\mathfrak{g}) , then there is a covering map p:{\mathsf{G}}\to\mathrm{Inn}(\mathfrak{g}) and \tau lifts to a homomorphism \tilde{\tau}:\mathsf{SL}(2,\mathbb{C})\to{\mathsf{G}} such that \varpi_{1}(\mu(\tilde{\tau}(g)))=c_{\mathfrak{g}}\omega_{1}(\mu(g)) . Recall that every quasifuchsian representation \rho:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) lifts to a representation \tilde{\rho}:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathsf{SL}(2,\mathbb{C}) (see Culler [ 19 ] ). Since \operatorname{Ad}\tilde{\rho}=\operatorname{Ad}\rho and \mathrm{d}\tilde{\tau}\circ u=\mathrm{d}\tau\circ u , we may complete the proof in this case using the same argument. ∎ 7. Proper actions on the group manifold In this section, we study actions on the group manifold of a Lie group via left and right multiplication. The final goal of the section is to establish part (2) of Corollary 1.7 . The action of {\mathsf{G}}\times{\mathsf{G}} on {\mathsf{G}} via (g,h)x=gxh^{-1} is transitive and the stabilizer of e\in{\mathsf{G}} is the diagonal embedding {\rm{Diag}}({\mathsf{G}})=\{(g,g):g\in{\mathsf{G}}\}\subset{\mathsf{G}}\times{\mathsf{G}}. The group manifold of {\mathsf{G}} is the quotient {\mathsf{G}}\times{\mathsf{G}}/\rm{Diag}({\mathsf{G}}). The quotient may be identified with {\mathsf{G}} . The group manifold inherits a pseudo-Riemannian metric from the Killing form on \mathfrak{g} which is invariant under right and left multiplication by {\mathsf{G}} . The most classical situation occurs when {\mathsf{G}}=\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{R}) , in which case the group manifold is three-dimensional anti-de Sitter space. Let \Gamma be a finitely generated group. Given two representations \rho,\eta:\Gamma\to{\mathsf{G}} , we let \rho\times\eta:\Gamma\to{\mathsf{G}}\times{\mathsf{G}} be the product representation defined by \gamma\mapsto(\rho(\gamma),\eta(\gamma)). The quotient action of \Gamma on the group manifold is simply the action given by right multiplication by \rho(\gamma) and left multiplication by \eta(\gamma)^{-1} . 7.1. Properness criteria Benoist [ 3 ] and Kobayashi [ 44 ] developed a general criterion to determine when an action on reductive homogeneous spaces are proper. When restricted to our situation we get the following criterion. Theorem 7.1 (Benoist-Kobayashi properness criterion) . Let \rho,\eta:\Gamma\to{\mathsf{G}} be two representations and assume that \rho\times\eta has discrete image and finite kernel. If for every K>0 , the set \big\{\gamma\in\Gamma:\|\kappa(\rho(\gamma))-\kappa(\eta(\gamma))\|\leq K\big\} is finite, then \rho\times\eta(\Gamma) acts properly on the group manifold {\mathsf{G}}\times{\mathsf{G}}/\rm{Diag}({\mathsf{G}}) . Their properness criterion is most commonly used in the following form. Corollary 7.2 . Let \rho,\eta:\Gamma\to{\mathsf{G}} be two representations of a finitely generated group and assume that \rho\times\eta has discrete image and finite kernel. If there exists b>1 and c\geq 0 such that \varpi_{1}(\kappa(\rho\gamma))-b\varpi_{1}(\kappa(\eta\gamma))\geq-c, for every \gamma\in\Gamma , then \rho\times\eta(\Gamma) acts properly on the group manifold {\mathsf{G}}\times{\mathsf{G}}/\rm{Diag}({\mathsf{G}}) . Proof. We consider the functional \varphi_{\mu}:\mathfrak{a}\times\mathfrak{a}\to\mathbb{R} defined by \varphi_{\mu}(x,y)=\varpi_{1}(x)-b\varpi_{1}(y) and an arbitrary K>0. Since \mu>1 and c\geq 0, the set \{\varphi_{\mu}\geq-c\}\cap\rm{Diag}(\mathfrak{a}^{+}) is compact and thus also is its intersection with the tubular neighborhood \big\{(x,y)\in\mathfrak{a}^{+}\times\mathfrak{a}^{+}:\|x-y\|\leq K\big\}. Since \rho\times\eta is a proper map (by assumption) and a is also proper, we conclude that the set \{\gamma\in\Gamma:\|\kappa(\rho(\gamma))-\kappa(\eta(\gamma))\|\leq K\} is finite and thus Benoist-Kobayashi’s criterion applies and we may conclude that \rho\times\eta(\Gamma) acts properly. ∎ 7.2. Ledrappier potentials for Anosov representations We now develop some more structure theory for Anosov representations, see Bridgeman-Canary-Labourie-Sambarino [ 13 ] . Given a totally Anosov representation \rho:\Gamma\to{\mathsf{G}} there exists a compact metric space {\mathsf{U}}_{\rho}\Gamma equipped with a flow \phi^{\rho}=(\phi^{\rho}_{t}:{\mathsf{U}}_{\rho}\Gamma\to{\mathsf{U}}_{\rho}\Gamma)_{t\in\mathbb{R}} whose periodic orbits, if \Gamma is torsion-free, are in one-to-one correspondence with conjugacy classes of infinite order elements of \Gamma such that the period of [\gamma] is \varpi_{1}(\mu(\rho\gamma)) . If \Gamma has torsion the correspondence is finite-to-one (see Blayac [ 7 ] and Carvajales [ 17 , Appendix] for more information). If \eta:\Gamma\to{\mathsf{G}} is also totally Anosov, there exists a Hölder-continuous function f_{\rho\eta}:{\mathsf{U}}_{\rho}\Gamma\to\mathbb{R}_{+} such that for every conjugacy class [\gamma] the integral of f_{\rho\eta} over the associated periodic orbit is \int_{[\gamma]}f_{\rho\eta}=\varpi_{1}(\mu(\eta\gamma)). The function f_{\rho\eta} is called the Ledrappier potential of \eta (seen from \rho ) and the map \eta\mapsto f_{\rho\eta}, well defined up to Livšic-cohomology, is called the thermodynamic mapping . For \alpha\in(0,1) , let \textrm{H\"{o}l}^{\alpha}({\mathsf{U}}_{\rho}\Gamma,\mathbb{R}) be the space of Hölder-continuous maps with exponent less than \alpha, equipped with the standard norm that makes it a Banach space. If \eta\in\mathfrak{A}_{{\mathsf{\Delta}}}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) is a smooth point of \mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(S),{\mathsf{G}}) , then there exists a neighborhood \cal U_{\eta} of \eta and \alpha\in(0,1) such that the thermodynamic mapping sends \cal U_{\eta} into \textrm{H\"{o}l}^{\alpha}({\mathsf{U}}_{\rho}\Gamma,\mathbb{R}) and it is an analytic map when restricted to \cal U_{\eta} (see [ 13 , Proposition 6.2] ). 7.3. Proper affine actions on the group manifold We are now ready to establish a weaker version of a recent result due to Ghosh-Kobayashi [ 35 ] , which suffices for our purposes. We include a proof for completeness. If U is a smooth open set in \mathrm{Hom}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) , then one can identify {\mathsf{T}}U with an open set in \mathcal{C}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) and there exists a smooth map \Psi:{\mathsf{T}}U\to\mathrm{Hom}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) with the property that \frac{d}{dt}\Big|_{t=0}\Psi(\rho,tv)=v for all v\in{\mathsf{T}}_{\rho}\mathrm{Hom}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) with \rho\in U . We will use the notation (\rho,v) to denote a tangent vector v\in{\mathsf{T}}_{\rho}\mathrm{Hom}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) . Proposition 7.3 . Suppose \rho_{0}\in\mathfrak{A}_{{\mathsf{\Delta}}}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) is a smooth point of \mathrm{Hom}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) , v_{0}\in{\mathsf{T}}_{\rho_{0}}\mathrm{Hom}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) and {\mathsf{u}}_{v_{0}}\in\mathcal{C}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) is the cocycle for \operatorname{Ad}\rho associated to v_{0} . If \rho_{0} is semi-simple and 0\notin\varpi_{1}\big(\Re(\mathrm{MS}(\rho_{0},{\mathsf{u}}_{v_{0}}))\big) , then there exists an open neighborhood V of (\rho_{0},v_{0}) in {\mathsf{T}}U and \delta>0 so that if (\rho,v)\in V and t\in(0,\delta) , the group \rho\times\Psi(\rho,tv) acts properly on {\mathsf{G}}\times{\mathsf{G}}/\rm{Diag}({\mathsf{G}}). Proof. Since \mathfrak{A}_{{\mathsf{\Delta}}}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) is open, we may assume that \rho is totally Anosov for all (\rho,v)\in V . We may also assume that the set V_{0}=\{(\rho,v)\in V\text{ for some }v\in{\mathsf{T}}_{\rho}\mathrm{Hom}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}})\} is a smooth open set in \mathrm{Hom}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) . We then consider the Ledrappier potential f_{t}(\rho,v):=f_{\rho\Psi(\rho,tv)}:{\mathsf{U}}_{\rho}\Gamma\to\mathbb{R} from § 7.2 , with respect to the base representation \rho. Since the map (\rho,\eta)\mapsto f_{\rho\eta} is analytic on an open neighborhood of (\rho,\rho) (which may assume contains V_{0}\times\Psi(V) ), we may find K>0 and \delta>0 such that, after possibly further shrinking V one has \|f_{t}(\rho,v)-f_{0}-t\frac{d}{dt}\Big|_{t=0}f_{\rho\Psi(\rho,tv)}\|_{\infty}\leq Kt^{2} for every (\rho,v)\in V and t\in[0,\delta] . By integrating the Ledrappier potential over periodic orbits of the geodesic flow, one observes that \big|\varpi_{1}(\mu(\Psi(\rho,tv)(\gamma)))-\varpi_{1}(\mu(\rho(\gamma)))-t{\mathrm{d}}\varpi_{1}^{\gamma}(v)\big|\leq Kt^{2}\varpi_{1}(\mu(\rho(\gamma))) for every (\rho,v)\in V , t\in[0,\delta] and infinite order element \gamma\in\Gamma . Since \varpi_{1}\big(\Re(\mathrm{MS}(\rho,{\mathsf{u}}_{v})) varies continuously, we may assume that there exists c>0 so that \varpi_{1}\big(\Re(\mathrm{MS}(\rho,{\mathsf{u}}_{v}))\big)\leq-c<0 for all (\rho,v)\in V , so (1-ct+Kt^{2})\varpi_{1}(\mu(\rho(\gamma)))\geq\varpi_{1}(\mu(\Psi(\rho,tv)(\gamma))). for every (\rho,v)\in V , t\in[0,\delta] and infinite order element \gamma\in\Gamma . If we assume that \delta\leq\frac{c}{2K} , then \varpi_{1}(\mu(\rho(\gamma)))\geq b_{t}\varpi_{1}(\mu(\Psi(\rho,tv)(\gamma))) for all t\in(0,\delta] and \gamma\in\Gamma with b_{t}=\frac{1}{1-ct+Kt^{2}}>1. Benoist [ 4 , §4.5] showed there exists a finite set A\subset\Gamma so that for all \gamma\in\Gamma , there exists \alpha\in A so that \rho_{0}(\alpha\gamma) is (\Delta,2\epsilon) -proximal. (Recall that g\subset{\mathsf{G}} is (\Delta,\delta) -proximal if it is loxodromic, if g^{-} and g^{-} are its attracting and repelling flags, then d(g^{+},g^{-})>\delta , g(B_{\delta}(g^{-}))\subset b_{\delta}(g^{+}) and g is \delta -Lipschitz on b_{\delta}(g^{+}) where B_{\delta}(g^{-}) is the complement of the open neighborhood of g^{-} of radius \delta and b_{\delta}(g^{+}) is the closed neighborhood of g^{+} of radius \delta .) After possibly shrinking V and \delta , one may assume that if \gamma\in\Gamma , then there exists \alpha\in A so that if (\rho,v)\in V and t\in[0,\delta) , then \Psi(\rho,tv)(\alpha\gamma) is (\Delta,\epsilon) -proximal. Benoist [ 4 , §4.5] also showed that there exists a compact subset N of \mathfrak{a} , depending only on \epsilon , so that g\in{\mathsf{G}} is (\Delta,\epsilon) -proximal, then \mu(g)-\kappa(g)\in N . Therefore, there exists E>0 so that if g\in{\mathsf{G}} is (\Delta,\epsilon) -proximal, then \Big|\varpi_{1}\big(\mu(g)\big)-\varpi_{1}\big(\kappa(g)\big)\Big|1 if t\in(0,\delta) , Corollary 7.2 implies that \rho\times\Psi(\rho,tv)\,(\Gamma) acts properly on {\mathsf{G}}\times{\mathsf{G}}/\rm{Diag}({\mathsf{G}}) for all (\rho,v)\in V and t\in(0,\delta). ∎ Let {{{\mathsf{Pr}}}}(S,{\mathsf{G}})\subset\mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(S),{\mathsf{G}}) be the set of totally Anosov representations \rho:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathsf{G} so that there exists a cocycle {\mathsf{u}} for \operatorname{Ad}\rho so that 0 does not lie in \varpi_{1}\big(\Re(\mathrm{MS}(\eta,{\mathsf{u}}))\big). Let {{{\mathsf{Pr}}}}_{sm}(S,{\mathsf{G}}) denote the set of semisimple representations \rho\in{{{\mathsf{Pr}}}}(S,{\mathsf{G}}) which are smooth points of \mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(S),{\mathsf{G}}) . We first observe that {{{\mathsf{Pr}}}}_{sm}(S,{\mathsf{G}}) is non-empty. Lemma 7.4 . Let {\mathsf{G}} be a complex simple Lie group and \tilde{\tau}:\mathsf{SL}(2,\mathbb{C})\to{\mathsf{G}} be the lift of a principal embedding \tau:\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C})\to\mathrm{Inn}(\mathfrak{g}) . If \rho:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathsf{SL}(2,\mathbb{C}) is a lift of a quasifuchsian representation which is not fuchsian, then \tilde{\tau}\circ\rho is a smooth point of \mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(S),{\mathsf{G}}). In particular, {{{\mathsf{Pr}}}}_{sm}(S,{\mathsf{G}}) is non-empty. Proof. Goldman [ 36 , §1.2 & 1.3] showed that \tilde{\tau}\circ\rho is a smooth point if the Lie algebra of its centralizer is zero-dimensional. Since lying in the centralizer is an algebraic condition, it suffices to show the Lie algebra of its Zariski closure is zero-dimensional. If \rho:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) is quasifuchsian, but not fuchsian, the Lie algebra of the Zariski closure of \tilde{\tau}\rho(\pi_{1}(S)) is \mathfrak{s}=d\tau(\mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C})) . Suppose that x lies in the centralizer of \mathfrak{s} . By Kostant (see [ 45 , Lemma 5.2] ), \mathfrak{s} is an \mathfrak{\mathfrak{sl}}(2,\mathbb{C}) triple \{h,e,f\} where h is in the interior of a Weyl chamber with Cartan subalgebra \mathfrak{h} and simple roots \Delta such that e=\sum_{\alpha\in\Delta}e_{\alpha}\qquad e_{\alpha}\in\mathfrak{g}_{\alpha},\ e_{\alpha}\neq 0. Thus the centralizer of h is \mathfrak{h} and therefore x\in\mathfrak{h} . As x is also in the centralizer of e , 0=\operatorname{ad}(x)(e)=\sum_{\alpha\in\Delta}\operatorname{ad}(x)(e_{\alpha})=\sum\alpha(x)e_{\alpha}. It follows that \alpha(x)=0 for all \alpha\in\Delta and as \Delta is a basis for \mathfrak{h}^{*} then x=0 . Therefore, \tilde{\tau}\circ\rho is a smooth point of \mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(S),{\mathsf{G}}). Theorem 1.4 implies that there exists a quasifuchsian representation \sigma:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathsf{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) which admit a cocycle {\mathsf{u}} so that 0\notin\varpi_{1}\big(\Re(\mathrm{MS}(\rho,{\mathsf{u}}))\big) . Let \rho:\pi_{1}(S)\to\mathsf{SL}(2,\mathbb{C}) be a lift of \sigma , then the proof of Corollary 6.10 implies that \tilde{\tau}\circ\rho\in{{{\mathsf{Pr}}}}(S,{\mathsf{G}}) . The representation \tilde{\tau}\circ\rho is semi-simple, since its Zariski closure is simple and we have just shown it is a smooth point of \mathrm{Hom}(\pi_{1}(S),{\mathsf{G}}) , so \tilde{\tau}\circ\rho\in{{{\mathsf{Pr}}}}_{sm}(S,{\mathsf{G}}) . ∎ We now establish the following more precise version of part ii) of Corollary 1.7 . Corollary 7.5 . Suppose that {\mathsf{G}} is a complex simple Lie group. The space of representations of \pi_{1}(S) into {\mathsf{G}}\times{\mathsf{G}} such that the action on {\mathsf{G}}\times{\mathsf{G}}/\rm{Diag}({\mathsf{G}}) is proper has non-empty interior and its closure contains the set \{\rho\times\rho:\rho\in{{\mathsf{Pr}}}_{sm}(S,{\mathsf{G}})\}. Proof. For each \rho_{0}\in{{\mathsf{Pr}}}_{sm}(S,{\mathsf{G}}) , there exists a cocycle {\mathsf{u}}_{0} for \operatorname{Ad}\rho_{0} so that 0\notin\varpi_{1}\big(\Re(\mathrm{MS}(\rho_{0},{\mathsf{u}}_{0})\big) . Proposition 7.3 produces \delta_{\rho_{0}}>0 and a neighborhood V_{\rho_{0}} of (\rho_{0},{\mathsf{u}}_{0}) in \mathcal{C}(\Gamma,{\mathsf{G}}) so that if (\sigma,v)\in V_{\rho_{0}} and t\in(0,\delta_{\rho_{0}}] , then \sigma\times\Psi(\sigma,tv) yields a proper action of \pi_{1}(S) on {\mathsf{G}}\times{\mathsf{G}}/\rm{Diag}({\mathsf{G}}) . The set \{\sigma\times\Psi(\sigma,tv):(\sigma,v)\in V_{\rho}\text{ and }t\in(0,\delta_{\rho})\ \text{for some}\ \ \rho\in{{\mathsf{Pr}}}_{sm}(S,{\mathsf{G}})\} is a non-empty open set that verifies the desired conditions. ∎ 8. Angle and bending bounds In order to show that a Jordan domain is moderately bent, it suffices to have a bound on the angle between geodesics in the intrinsic metric on the boundary of the convex hull and geodesics in \mathbb{H}^{3} joining points on the boundary. Our final goal is to prove Theorem 1.5 which shows that if ||\beta_{\mu}||_{L}0 , we let \gamma_{t}:[0,\infty)\to\mathbb{H}^{3} such that \gamma_{t}(0)=\alpha(0) and \gamma_{t}(r_{t})=\beta(t) where r_{t}=d(\beta(0),\beta(t)) . We then define \theta^{\pm}_{\mu}(t) to be the angle at \beta(t) between the tangent vectors \gamma_{t}^{\prime}(r_{t}) and \beta_{\pm}^{\prime}(t) at the point \beta(t) . If \beta(t) does not lie on an isolated leaf of \mu , then \theta_{\alpha}^{-}(t)=\theta^{+}_{\alpha}(t) . Furthermore \theta_{\mu}^{-} is continuous from the left and \theta^{+}_{\mu} is continuous from the right. Given p\neq q\in{\mathbb{H}}^{2} , let \alpha:\mathbb{R}\to{\mathbb{H}}^{2} be the unique unit speed geodesic ray with \alpha(0)=p and \alpha(d(p,q))=q . We define \theta_{\mu}(p,q)=\theta^{+}_{\mu}(p,q)=\theta^{+}_{\alpha}(d(p,q))\qquad\theta^{-}_{\mu}(p,q)=\theta^{-}_{\alpha}(d(p,q)). If q is not on an isolated leaf of \mu , then \theta^{-}_{\mu}(p,q)=\theta^{+}_{\mu}(p,q)=\theta_{\mu}(p,q) . Given \theta\in[0,\pi) we define \mu to be \theta -bounded if \theta_{\mu}(p,q)\leq\theta for all p\neq q\in{\mathbb{H}}^{2} . Notice that continuity properties of \theta_{\mu}^{\pm} imply that \mu is \theta -bounded if and only if \theta^{-}_{\mu}(p,q)\leq\theta for all p\neq q\in{\mathbb{H}}^{2} . We first observe that if \mu is \theta -bounded for some \theta<\frac{\pi}{2} , then f_{\mu} is a bilipschitz embedding. Lemma 8.1 . If \mu\in\mathcal{ML}({\mathbb{H}}^{2}) is \theta -bounded for some \theta<\frac{\pi}{2} , then f_{\mu}:\mathbb{H}^{2}\rightarrow\mathbb{H}^{3} is a (\sec\theta) -bilipschitz embedding. In particular f_{\mu} extends continuously to an embedding \bar{f}_{\mu}:\partial\mathbb{H}^{2}\to\partial\mathbb{H}^{3} . Proof. By definition f_{\mu} is 1 -Lipschitz so we only need to establish the lower bound. We assume first that \mu has locally finite support. Let x,y\in\mathbb{H}^{2} and \alpha:[0,T]\rightarrow\mathbb{H}^{2} be a geodesic parametrized by arc length with x=\alpha(0) and y=\alpha(T) . We let s(t)=d(f_{\mu}(x),f_{\mu}(\alpha(t)) and let t_{i} be values of t such that f_{\mu}(\alpha(t)) is on a bending line. If f_{\mu}\circ\alpha does not intersect \mu transversely, then it is a geodesic and f_{\mu} is an isometry on \alpha . Otherwise, there is a finite collection \{t_{i}\}\subset[0,T] so that f_{\mu}\circ\alpha is geodesic on [t_{i},t_{i}+1] . If t\neq t_{i} we define \theta(t)=\theta_{\mu}(x,\alpha(t)) . Then a simple calculation gives that s^{\prime}(t)=\cos(\theta(t))\geq\cos(\theta). It follows that s(t)\geq\cos(\theta)t , so d(f_{\mu}(x),f_{\mu}(y))=s(T)\geq\cos(\theta)T=\cos(\theta)d(x,y). For a general \theta -bounded lamination \mu , we consider the path \gamma(t)=f_{\mu}(\alpha(t)) . Then \gamma is a \theta -bounded curve. Let \mathcal{P}_{n} be an evenly spaced partition of [0,T] with n vertices and let \gamma_{n}:[0,T]\rightarrow\mathbb{H}^{3} be the piecewise geodesic path with vertices f_{\mu}(\alpha(\mathcal{P}_{n})) . Then, \gamma_{n} is a \theta_{n} bounded curve and \theta_{n}\rightarrow\theta , so by taking limits we see that d(f_{\mu}(x),f_{\mu}(y))\geq\cos(\theta)d(x,y). ∎ We now prove that \theta -bounded Jordan domains are moderately bent when \theta<\frac{\pi}{2} . Proposition 8.2 . If \mu\in\mathcal{ML}({\mathbb{H}}^{2}) is \theta -bounded for some \theta<\frac{\pi}{2} , then \Omega_{\mu} is moderately bent. Proof. Let (x,y) be a bending pair for \Omega_{\mu} . We may assume that (x,y)=(0,\infty) and that the plane Q lying above the real axis \mathbb{R} is a support plane for the pleated plane P_{\mu} . We can assume that \Omega_{\mu} contains the upper half-plane. Let P_{-} and P_{+} be the left and right half-planes for the geodesic \overline{0\infty} . (Notice that if g is not an atom for the measure, then Q=P_{-}=P_{+} .) Suppose that u\in\partial\Omega_{\mu}\setminus\{0,\infty\} lies to the right of 0 . Let \eta:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{H}^{3} be the unique geodesic ray so that \eta(0)=p=(0,0,|u|)\in\overline{0\infty} and \lim_{t\to+\infty}\eta(t)=u . Notice that \eta(\mathbb{R}) is perpendicular to \overline{0\infty} . Let \gamma:\mathbb{R}\to P_{\mu} be a geodesic in the intrinsic metric on P_{\mu} so that p=\gamma(0) and \lim_{t\to+\infty}\gamma(t)=u . Let \alpha_{t}:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{H}^{3} be a geodesic in \mathbb{H}^{3} so that p=\alpha_{t}(0) and \alpha_{t}(d(p,\gamma(t)))=\gamma(t) . Since \mu is \theta -bounded, the angle \theta_{\mu}(\gamma(t),\gamma(0)) is at most \theta . By definition, \theta_{\mu}(\gamma(t),\gamma(0)) is the angle between -\alpha_{t}^{\prime}(0) and -\gamma_{-}^{\prime}(0) , or equivalently, the angle between \alpha_{t}^{\prime}(0) and \gamma_{-}^{\prime}(0) . Since f_{\mu} extends continuously to an embedding \bar{f}_{\mu}:\partial\mathbb{H}^{2}\to\partial\mathbb{H}^{3} , we see that \alpha_{t} converges to \eta , so \alpha_{t}^{\prime}(0) converges to \eta^{\prime}(0) . Therefore, the angle between \eta^{\prime}(0) and \gamma_{-}^{\prime}(0) is at most \theta . Notice that \gamma_{-}^{\prime}(0) lies in the portion of P_{-} which is to the right of \overline{0\infty} . We see, by projecting \eta onto the plane that the Euclidean line segment R_{u} joining 0 to u makes an angle of at most \theta with portion R_{-} of \partial P_{-} which lies to the right of 0 . Notice that R_{-} must be a line segment with positive slope, since otherwise the bending at \overline{0\infty} would be at least \frac{\pi}{2} , which would contradict the fact that \mu is \theta -bounded. Since R_{u} lies in the lower half plane and makes an angle less than \frac{\pi}{2} with R_{-} it must have negative slope. Therefore, \Re(u)>0 (see Figure 2 ). We may similarly show that if u\in\partial\Omega_{\mu} lies to the left of 0 , then \Re(u)<0 . Therefore, if L is the imaginary axis, then L is a round circle in \hat{\mathbb{C}} which intersects \partial\Omega_{\mu} transversely at the points 0 and \infty and intersects no other point of \partial\Omega_{\mu} . Figure 2. Plane L ∎ 8.2. Bending bounds We now give explicit bounds on \|\mu\|_{L} such that the associated pleated plane is \theta -bounded and therefore the associated Jordan domain is moderately bounded. In earlier work [ 15 ] the first two authors and Yarmola produced an explicit upper bound on \|\mu\|_{L} which guarantees that f_{\mu} is a bilipschitz embedding. Theorem 8.3 . (Bridgeman-Canary-Yarmola [ 15 ] ) There exists an explicit function G:\mathbb{R}_{+}\rightarrow\mathbb{R}_{+} such that if \mu is a uniformly bounded measured lamination on \mathbb{H}^{2} and \|\mu\|_{L}1 , we define r_{L}(\theta)=-Lh^{\prime}(L+h^{-1}(\theta))=L{\mathrm{sech}}(L+\tanh^{-1}(\cos(\theta)). In all cases, we define r(L)=r_{L}(\pi/2) . We will give a more explicit description of these functions at the end of this section. Figure 3. Functions a_{L}(\theta) and r_{L}(\theta) for L\leq 1 We obtain the following strengthening of Theorem 8.3 . Theorem 8.4 . ( \theta -bounded criterion) Let \theta\in[0,\pi/2] and L>0 . If \mu\in\mathcal{ML}({\mathbb{H}}^{2}) and \|\mu\|_{L}\frac{\pi}{2}\geq\theta=u_{L}(a_{L}(\theta)). Since u_{L} is strictly decreasing, a_{L}(\theta)>x_{0} . Since h^{\prime} is increasing on (0,\infty) (but negative), r_{L}(\theta)=-Lh^{\prime}(a_{L}(\theta))<-Lh^{\prime}(x_{0})=G(L). If L>1 , we simply observe that since x_{0}\in(0,L) and h^{\prime} is increasing on [0,\infty) , we have r_{\theta}(L)\leq r_{\pi/2}(L)=-Lh^{\prime}(L)<-Lh^{\prime}(x_{0})=G(L). We also recall, see [ 15 , Lemma 4.3] , that if \|\mu\|_{L}t_{i} for all i . For all t>0 , we define \theta(t)=\theta^{+}(t)=\theta_{\mu}(\alpha(0),\alpha(t))\quad\text{and let}\quad\theta^{-}(t)=\theta^{-}_{\mu}(\alpha(0),\alpha(t)). Notice that if t\neq t_{i} (for some i ), then \theta^{-}(t)=\theta(t) and observe that u_{i}=|\theta^{+}(t_{i})-\theta^{-}(t_{i})|\leq\phi_{i}=\mu(m(\alpha(t_{i}))) where \mu(m(\alpha(t_{i}))) is the measure of the leaf of \mu passing through \alpha(t_{i}) . One may calculate (see [ 28 , Lemma 4.4] ) that if s(t)=d(\alpha(0),\alpha(t)) and t\neq t_{i} for any i , then s^{\prime}(t)=\cos(\theta(t))\qquad\theta^{\prime}(t)=\frac{-\sin(\theta(t))}{\tanh(s(t))}\leq-\sin(\theta(t)). Thus on the intervals (t_{i},t_{i+1}) , the angle \theta(t) is monotonically decreasing from \theta^{+}(t_{i}) to \theta^{-}(t_{i+1}) . We define a function g:(t_{1},\infty)\setminus\{t_{i}\}_{i=1}^{r}\to\mathbb{R} by the property that h(g(t))=\theta(t) . This is well-defined and continuous since h is strictly monotone, continuous and has image (0,\pi) . Similarly we define g^{\pm}(t_{i}) so that h(g^{\pm}(t_{i}))=\theta^{\pm}(t_{i}) . This definition guarantees that H(t)=(g(t),\theta(t)) and H^{\pm}(t_{i})=(g^{\pm}(t_{i}),\theta^{\pm}(t_{i})) all lie on the graph of the hill function. On (t_{i},t_{i+1}) the image of H(t) slides downward and to the right. Notice that if t\in(t_{i},t_{i+1}) and \theta(t)\in\left(0,\frac{\pi}{2}\right) , then h^{\prime}(g(t))g^{\prime}(t)=\theta^{\prime}(t)<-\sin(\theta(t))=-\sin(h(g(t))=h^{\prime}(g(t)), so g^{\prime}(t)>1 . In particular, if \theta(t_{i})<\frac{\pi}{2} , then g^{+}(t_{i+1})-g^{-}(t_{i})>t_{i+1}-t_{i}. At each t_{i} , the function transitions from (g^{-}(t_{i}),\theta^{-}(t_{i})) to (g^{+}(t_{i}),\theta^{+}(t_{i})) , so it jumps upward by u_{i}\leq\phi_{i} and to the left by g^{-}(t_{i})-g^{+}(t_{i}) . First, suppose that L\leq 1 and \theta\leq\frac{\pi}{2} . Let a=a_{L}(\theta) and notice that, since h(a)-Lh^{\prime}(a)=\theta , we must have h(a)<\theta . Assume that \theta(t)\geq\theta for some t and let T_{1}=\inf\{t\in(t_{1},\infty)\ |\ \theta(t)\geq\theta\}\quad\text{and}\quad T_{0}=\sup\{t\in(t_{1},T_{1})\ |\ \theta^{-}(t)\leq h(a)\}. Notice that since \theta^{-} is continuous from the left, \theta^{-}(T_{0})\leq h(a) . Since there is a total upward shift less than r_{L}(\theta) in the interval [T_{0},T_{0}+L) , we see that \theta(s)1 if t\neq t_{i} and \theta(t)\leq\frac{\pi}{2} , there is a horizontal shift right of at least L on the interval [T_{0},T_{0}+L) . Since h^{\prime} is decreasing in [0,a] , the total downward shift (associated with the horizontal shift) is greater than h^{\prime}(a)L . Since the total upward shift is less than r_{L}(\theta)=-Lh^{\prime}(a) , we conclude that \theta^{-}(T_{0}+L)\leq h(a) giving us our contradiction. Using the notation above, we can again make this more concrete. Consider the interval [t_{\ell},t_{\ell+1}) for some \ell\in\{t_{j-1},\ldots,t_{k}\} . Since h(g^{\pm}(t_{i}))=\theta^{\pm}(t_{i}) then by definition of T_{0} the interval [g^{+}(t_{\ell}),g^{-}(t_{\ell+1})] is contained in [0,a] . Since h^{\prime} is decreasing on [0,\infty) and g^{\prime}(t)>1 on (t_{\ell},t_{\ell+1}) , the mean value theorem implies that \theta^{-}(t_{\ell+1})-\theta^{+}(t_{\ell})\leq h^{\prime}(a)(g^{-}(t_{\ell+1})-g^{+}(t_{\ell}))1 and \theta\leq\frac{\pi}{2} . We define b=L+h^{-1}(\theta) , or equivalently, by the equation h(b-L)=\theta , so r_{L}(\theta)=-Lh^{\prime}(b) . As h is decreasing and concave on [0,\infty) h(b)<\theta\quad\text{and}\quad h(b)-Lh^{\prime}(b)1 . If \mu is any measured lamination on {\mathbb{H}}^{2} with \|\mu\|_{L}1 works for all L . However, if L\leq 1 and \theta\leq\frac{\pi}{2} , then 01 , r_{L}(\theta)=-Lh^{\prime}(L+h^{-1}(\theta))=L{\mathrm{sech}}(L+\tanh^{-1}(\cos(\theta)). It follows that r(L)=r_{L}(\pi/2)=L{\mathrm{sech}}(L). For L\leq 1 r_{L}(\theta)=-Lh^{\prime}(a_{L}(\theta))=L{\mathrm{sech}}(a_{L}(\theta)) then a_{L}(\theta)=\cosh^{-1}\left(\frac{L}{r_{L}(\theta)}\right). As a_{L}(\theta) is defined by the equation \theta=u_{L}(a_{L}(\theta)) and u_{L}(x)=h(x)-Lh^{\prime}(x)=\cos^{-1}(\tanh(x))+L{\mathrm{sech}}(x) then \theta=u_{L}\left(\cosh^{-1}\left(\frac{L}{r_{L}(\theta)}\right)\right)=\cos^{-1}\left(\sqrt{1-\frac{r_{L}(\theta)^{2}}{L^{2}}}\right)+r_{L}(\theta). Equivalently \theta=\sin^{-1}\left(\frac{r_{L}(\theta)}{L}\right)+r_{L}(\theta). Figure 4. Plot of r_{1}(\theta) on [0,\frac{\pi}{2}] Thus r_{L} is the inverse function of y=\sin^{-1}(x/L)+x . Therefore r_{L}(\theta) is the solution to the equation x=L\sin(\theta-x). As r(L)=r_{L}(\pi/2) , it follows that r is the inverse function of the function L(x)=x\sec(x). In particular for L=1 , r(1)=r_{1}(\pi/2)\simeq 0.739085. 8.4. Proof of Corollary 1.6 Theorems 1.1 and 1.5 together imply that if \rho\in U(S) is not fuchsian, then \rho is not a critical point of the entropy function. Theorems 1.2 and 1.5 together imply that if \rho\in V(S) is not fuchsian, then \operatorname{Ad}\rho is the linear part of a proper affine action of \pi_{1}(S) on \mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C}) . It remains to show that US) and V(S) are open. We first observe that if \alpha:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{H}^{2} is a geodesic and \mu is a geodesic lamination on \mathbb{H}^{2} , then \mu\left(\alpha([a,b))\right)=\lim_{\epsilon\to 0^{+}}\mu\left(\alpha((a-\epsilon,b-\epsilon))\right). It follows that ||\mu||_{L} can also be defined to be the supremum of the transverse measure of any open geodesic arc of length L . One can then easily check that ||\cdot||_{L} is a continuous function on \mathcal{T}(S)\times\mathcal{ML}(S) . Keen and Series [ 43 ] showed that the map from QF(S) to \mathcal{T}(S)\times\mathcal{ML}(S) which takes \rho to (X^{\nu}(\rho),\beta_{\nu}) is continuous for both \nu\in\{\pm\} . It follows that U(S) and V(S) are open subsets of QF(S) . ∎ 9. Teichmüller distance, Schwarzian derivatives and quasicircles In this section, we obtain versions of our main results in terms of more classical invariants. Our first description is expressed in terms of the Schwarzian derivative. Given a locally univalent map f:\Delta\rightarrow\hat{\mathbb{C}} and z\in\Delta , let M_{f,z} be the Möbius transformation with the same 2-jet as f at z . It follows that M_{f,z}^{-1}\circ f has the same two-jet as the identity at z and the Schwarzian derivative S(f) of f at z is then given by S(f)(z)=(M_{f,z}^{-1}\circ f)^{\prime\prime\prime}(z). In particular, if f is a Möbius transformation, then S(f)=0 . In general the Schwarzian derivative measures of how close f is to being Möbius. The Schwarzian derivative is also given by the equation S(f)=\left(\frac{f^{\prime\prime}}{f^{\prime}}\right)^{\prime}-\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{f^{\prime\prime}}{f^{\prime}}\right)^{2}. The Schwarzian derivative is a quadratic differential on \Delta . Denoting the space of quadratic differentials on a Riemann surface X by Q(X) we define the norm on Q(X) by \|\phi\|_{\infty}=\sup_{z\in X}\frac{|\phi(z)|}{\rho_{X}(z)} where \rho_{X}(z)|dz|^{2} is the hyperbolic metric on X . Classical results of Nehari [ 55 ] show that if f:\Delta\rightarrow\hat{\mathbb{C}} is univalent then \|S(f)\|\leq 3/2 and if f:\Delta\rightarrow\hat{\mathbb{C}} is locally univalent and \|S(f)\|\leq 1/2 , then f is univalent. Let \rho\in\operatorname{QF}(S) with limit set \Lambda(\rho) and complementary Jordan domains \Omega_{+}(\rho) and \Omega_{-}(\rho) . We let f_{\nu}(\rho):\Delta\rightarrow\Omega_{\nu} be the maps uniformizing \Omega_{\nu}(\rho),\nu\in\{\pm\} and define quadratic differentials \tilde{\phi}_{\nu}(\rho)=S(f_{\nu}(\rho)) in Q(\Delta) . Letting X_{\nu}(\rho)=\Omega_{\nu}/\rho(\pi_{1}(S)) , then \tilde{\phi}_{\nu}(\rho) descends to a quadratic differential \phi_{\nu}(\rho)\in Q(X_{\nu}(\rho)) . By Bers simultaneous uniformization the map QF(S)\rightarrow\mathcal{T}(S)\times\mathcal{T}(\bar{S}) given by \rho\rightarrow(X_{+}(\rho),X_{-}(\rho)) is a diffeomorphism (see [ 6 ] ). We let (X,Y)\rightarrow\rho(X,Y) be the inverse of this map. For X\in\mathcal{T}(S) the Bers embedding is the map B_{X}:\mathcal{T}(\overline{S})\rightarrow Q(X) given by B_{X}(Y)=\phi_{+}(\rho(X,Y)). Nehari’s bounds imply that the image of the Bers embedding B_{X} in the Banach space (Q(X),\|\cdot\|_{\infty}) is contained in the ball of radius 3/2 about 0 and contains the ball of radius 1/2 about 0 . We first show that for a smaller ball about zero, we obtain our criterion. Theorem 9.1 . If \rho\in\operatorname{QF}(S) and 0<\|\phi_{\nu}(\rho)\|<.0739 for some \nu\in\{\pm\} , then \rho is not a critical point of h and there is a proper affine action of \pi_{1}(S) on \mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb{C}) with linear part \operatorname{Ad}(\rho) . Proof. Let \beta_{\nu} be the bending laminations of \rho . Bridgeman and Tee [ 14 ] show that if \|\phi_{\nu}(\rho)\|_{\infty}<\frac{1}{2}\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+e^{2L}}} , then \|\beta_{\nu}\|_{L}\leq 2\tan^{-1}\left(\frac{2\|\phi_{\nu}(\rho)\|_{\infty}e^{L}}{\sqrt{1-4\|\phi_{\nu}(\rho)\|_{\infty}^{2}}}\right)=F_{L}(\|\phi_{\nu}(\rho)\|_{\infty}). If we choose \epsilon>0 so that \epsilon