The interplay of cation/anion and monovalent/divalent selectivity in negatively charged nanopores: local charge inversion and anion leakage Eszter Lakics, Mónika Valiskó, Dirk Gillespie, Dezső Boda Abstract The anomalous mole fraction effect (AMFE) is widely regarded as a hallmark of calcium versus monovalent ion selectivity in negatively charged pores. While AMFE is well understood in highly cation-selective narrow ion channels, its microscopic origin in wide synthetic nanopores, where anions may also contribute to transport, remains less clear. Here, we use a reduced Nernst-Planck + Local Equilibrium Monte Carlo framework to study ionic transport in a negatively charged PET nanopore, with particular emphasis on how the modeling of surface carboxyl (COO - ) groups influences charge inversion, ionic currents, and AMFE. We systematically compare fixed point-charge models and explicit-particle representations of surface oxygens and identify two controlling parameters: the distance of closest approach (DCA) between ionic charges and pore charges and grid spacing that modulates localization (while keeping average surface charge constant). By fitting pore diffusion coefficients to three experimental conductance points, we reproduce the entire experimental AMFE curve as well as anion leakage in CaCl 2 seen in experiments and molecular dynamics simulations. Remarkably, vastly different microscopic models of the surface groups yield indistinguishable device-level conductance curves when the DCA is matched, despite substantial differences in local Ca 2+ concentration profiles. Our results demonstrate that AMFE in wide nanopores is governed by a delicate interplay between charge inversion, anion leakage, and ionic mobility, underlying that in wide pores monovalent vs. divalent cation selectivity is modulated by cations vs. anion selecivity. I Introduction The anomalous mole fraction effect (AMFE) is widely regarded as a defining signature of calcium (divalent) versus monovalent ion selectivity in negatively charged pores, including both biological ion channels 1 ; 2 ; 17 ; 18 ; 16 and synthetic nanopores 14 . Because these pores are overall cation-selective, the AMFE indicates a “preferential selectivity” between cations, defining which is more preferred 16 . In AMFE experiments, the mole fraction of Ca 2+ in a mixed electrolyte is gradually increased while the total ionic current through the pore is monitored as a function of composition. The effect is termed anomalous because the resulting current-composition curve is non-monotonic, exhibiting a pronounced minimum at an intermediate Ca 2+ mole fraction. The lower the Ca 2+ mole fraction at which this minimum occurs, the more strongly Ca 2+ -selective the pore is considered to be. AMFE was first reported for the L-type calcium channel 1 ; 2 , later for the ryanodine receptor (RyR) calcium release channel 17 ; 18 ; 16 , and subsequently for a synthetic biconical polyethylene terephthalate (PET) nanopore whose diameter is much larger than that of typical ion channels 14 (see Fig. 1 ). Our earlier modeling efforts 15 ; 10 ; 22 ; 5 ; 7 ; 12 replaced the original single-file interpretation 21 with a more general physical picture: the current minimum arises because monovalent cations are expelled from the pore by Ca 2+ (depressing monovalent current), while Ca 2+ itself carries little current at low mole fraction due to its low bulk concentration. This explanation is particularly clear for narrow biological ion channels, where anions (Cl - ) are effectively excluded and the competition occurs solely between cations in a highly charged environment that strongly prefers divalents. In contrast, the situation is more complex in wide nanopores (radius \sim 2.7 nm at the narrowest part , versus <0.3 nm for ion channels), where anion leakage occurs and can significantly contribute to the total current. In this work, we advance this picture by proposing that the nanopore not only allows anion leakage in pure CaCl 2 solutions, but that the Cl - current may even exceed the Ca 2+ current. We demonstrate that this scenario is consistent with experimental observations 20 , recent molecular dynamics simulations 24 , and the experimentally measured AMFE curves of Gillespie et al. 14 . The reduced model employed here closely follows that used in our previous work 12 , but is extended with a more detailed representation of the deprotonated carboxyl (COO - ) groups decorating the PET nanopore wall. Proper modeling of these charged surface groups is essential because the central mechanism underlying AMFE in nanopores is charge inversion: Ca 2+ ions adsorb strongly to the carboxyl groups and locally overcompensate the surface charge 9 . In the context here, charge inversion is an interplay of all the three ionic species. Ca 2+ ionsoutcompete K + ions and are tightly bound to the surface groups, which limits their mobility. Cl - ions, on the other hand, may form a layer of inverted charge where their mobility may exceed that of Ca 2+ . K + ions are electrostatically repelled by the overcharged pore wall, which decreases their conductance even at low Ca 2+ mole fractions. The magnitude of each mechanism depends on the strength of the charge inversion. In simulations, this is in large part is controlled by how the surface groups are modeled. This is because charge inversion is a local phenomenon that depends sensitively on the microscopic structure of the charged surface groups. While our earlier work 12 already demonstrated the importance of representing surface charge in a localized manner (individual charges on a grid rather than a uniform surface charge), the present study identifies another control parameter, beyond the degree of localization, of the reduced model: the distance of closest approach (DCA) between the central charge of Ca 2+ ions and the pore charge. Here, we systematically investigate different representations of the COO - groups, ranging from fixed point charges to flexible oxygen atoms modeled as charged hard spheres confined by harmonic potentials. This work follows our usual modeling strategy, in which complexity is introduced incrementally, progressing from simple to increasingly realistic descriptions to define which complexity is truly required in a model 3 ; 6 ; 8 ; 4 ; 7 ; 12 ; 24 . II Model and method We employ a reduced model in which the number of degrees of freedom is deliberately small by treating selected components implicitly rather than explicitly. Most notably, water is modeled as a continuum medium instead of as explicit molecules, interacting with ions through effective response functions that account for dielectric screening and friction (the dielectric constant \epsilon and position-dependent diffusion coefficients D_{i}(\mathbf{r}) , respectively). The guiding principle of this approach is to explicitly retain the degrees of freedom essential for nanopore current conduction, while incorporating less critical ones implicitly through physically self-consistent averaging procedures 9 . Reduced models are computationally efficient, enabling simulations across a broad range of state points, and they facilitate the sampling of millimolar and sub-millimolar concentrations, which is notoriously challenging in explicit-solvent MD. II.1 Model of the nanopore and electrolyte In the experiments of Gillespie et al. 14 , a long (12 \mu m) and narrow ( 2.7-79 nm) biconical nanopore was used. The scanning electron micrograph of the cross section is seen in Fig. 1 A. It is not feasible to handle a system of this size explicitly in a computer simulation even without reduced models. In this work, however, we are interested in the selectivity properties of the pore, and not necessarily in the detailed conduction properties of each segment of the pore. Therefore, we assume that the narrowest (2.7 nm radius) part of the pore (the red frame in Fig. 1 B) governs selectivity (its role is similar to that of the selectivity filter of an ion channel). We also assume that it is sufficient to model this central part of the pore explicitly, while the rest of the pore can be taken into account by adjusting the diffusion coefficients to experimental data. Since the whole pore is 1000 times longer than our model pore ( 12 \mu m vs. 12 nm), 2-3 orders of magnitude reduction of the diffusion coefficient will be needed to match the conductance values. Note that the real nanopore shown in Fig. 1 A is not perfectly biconical and its walls are not perfectly smooth 30 . The effect of these features, however, can be included in the fitted diffusion coefficients. The model is composed of two parts: a cylindrical nanopore (length H=12 nm and radius R=2.7 nm) embedded in a membrane and two bulk phases on either side of the membrane (bottom panel of Fig. 1 B). The walls of the pore and the membrane are hard, so ion overlap with the walls is forbidden. Figure 1: (A) Scanning electron micrograph of a cross section of a biconical PET nanopore from the paper of Gillespie et al. 14 . The length of the pore (width of the PET membrane) is 12 \mu m. The large radii at the entrances are 79 nm, while the small radius at the center is 2.7 nm. (B) The top panel shows the whole nanopore (axes aspect ratio is not to scale). The middle panel zooms on the blue rectangle of the top panel (axes aspect ratio is not to scale). The bottom panel zooms on the red rectangle of the middle panel (aspect ratio is correct). We explicitly simulate the central H=12 nm long portion (red rectangle), while the effect of the rest of the pore is taken into account by tuning the diffusion coefficients in the pore, D_{i}^{\mathrm{p}} . In our specific simulation cell, we have two baths on the two sides of the membrane (bottom panel) with their own diffusion coefficients. We impose boundary conditions for the electrochemical potential at the boundary of the finite simulation cell, which is a cylinder containing the membrane, the pore, and the bulk regions. In this work, we keep the concentrations of all the ionic species the same on the two sides of the membrane, while we impose different electrical potentials on the two sides to create the driving force of ionic transport (the voltage, U ). The ions of the electrolyte are modeled explicitly as hard spheres with point charges in their centers. The spheres cannot overlap, either with the membrane wall or with each other. The interaction between ions is u(r)=\left\{\begin{array}[]{ll}\infty&\quad\mathrm{for}\quad rR_{\mathrm{loc}},\\[6.0pt] -\dfrac{k_{\mathrm{loc}}}{R^{2}_{\mathrm{loc}}}\,\bigl|\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_{0}\bigr|^{2},&\text{for }|\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_{0}|\leq R_{\mathrm{loc}},\end{cases} (2) with effective spring constant k_{\mathrm{loc}}/R_{\mathrm{loc}}^{2} . The value k_{\mathrm{loc}}=4.5kT was used in this work; using other value for k_{\mathrm{loc}} does not influence the final result. Here, R_{\mathrm{loc}} is the maximum allowable distance of the atom from \mathbf{r}_{0} ; the oxygen atoms’ centers are constrained by the harmonic potential to move only within a sphere of this radius and cannot overlap with each other. Finnerty et al. 13 developed this model as a reduced representation of amino-acid side chains in ion channels, based on the scheme proposed by Yu et al. 31 . Thus, the surface groups modeled this way are not rigid; some movement of oxygen atoms mimicking vibration is allowed. Various models regarding the number of oxygen atoms, their locations ( r_{0} ), and the value of R_{\mathrm{loc}} are shown in Fig. 3 and will be investigated in this study. We also use a “behind the wall” model (Fig. 2 b), where the surface point charge -e is placed behind the hard surface at distance r_{0} . A special case of this model is when we place the charges on the surface ( r_{0}=0 , Fig. 2 a). II.3 NP+LEMC method The driving force for drift and diffusion is the gradient of the electrochemical potential in the Nernst-Planck (NP) equation: \mathbf{j}_{i}(\mathbf{r})=-\frac{1}{kT}D_{i}(\mathbf{r})c_{i}(\mathbf{r})\nabla\mu_{i}(\mathbf{r}). (3) In this equation, i is the ion species, k is the Boltzmann constant, T is the temperature ( T=298.15 K), \mathbf{j}_{i}(\mathbf{r}) is the particle current density, D_{i}(\mathbf{r}) is the diffusion coefficient profile, c_{i}(\mathbf{r}) is the concentration profile, and \mu_{i}(\mathbf{r}) is the electrochemical potential profile. The diffusion constant profile is constructed as a step function, where its value for a given ion species is a constant outside the pore ( D_{i}^{\mathrm{b}} , see Table 1 ) and a different constant ( D_{i}^{\mathrm{p}} ) inside the pore: D_{i}(z)=\left\{\begin{array}[]{ll}D_{i}^{\mathrm{p}}&\quad\mathrm{for}\quad|z|\>= \displaystyle\>\>D_{\mathrm{Cl}^{-}}^{\mathrm{p}}G^{\prime}_{\mathrm{Cl}^{-}}(0) \displaystyle+ \displaystyle\>\>D_{\mathrm{K}^{+}}^{\mathrm{p}}G^{\prime}_{\mathrm{K}^{+}}(0) \displaystyle G^{\mathrm{exp}}(0.2)\>\>= \displaystyle\>\>D_{\mathrm{Ca}^{2+}}^{\mathrm{p}}G^{\prime}_{\mathrm{Ca}^{2+}}(0.2)\>\> \displaystyle+ \displaystyle\>\>D_{\mathrm{Cl}^{-}}^{\mathrm{p}}G^{\prime}_{\mathrm{Cl}^{-}}(0.2)\>\> \displaystyle+ \displaystyle\>\>D_{\mathrm{K}^{+}}^{\mathrm{p}}G^{\prime}_{\mathrm{K}^{+}}(0.2) \displaystyle G^{\mathrm{exp}}(1)\>\>= \displaystyle\>\>D_{\mathrm{Ca}^{2+}}^{\mathrm{p}}G^{\prime}_{\mathrm{Ca}^{2+}}(1) \displaystyle+ \displaystyle\>\>D_{\mathrm{Cl}^{-}}^{\mathrm{p}}G^{\prime}_{\mathrm{Cl}^{-}}(1) (8) where G^{\mathrm{exp}}(\eta) is the experimental value for the total conductance. Although now we are fitting to three points, as we will see, there is space for the G(\eta) curves to behave quite differently between the fitting points. The questions that we now seek the answers to are: 1. How do the G(\eta) curves behave in between the three fitting points ( 0<\eta<0.2 and 0.2<\eta<1 )? 2. How do the simulations agree with experimental and MD findings that the Cl - conductance is larger than Ca 2+ conductance ( G_{\mathrm{Cl}^{-}}(1)>G_{\mathrm{Ca}^{2+}}(1) ) for pure CaCl 2 (bulk-like behavior)? 3. How do the models of the carboxyl groups change the G(\eta) curves? III Results and Discussion We begin with the simplest model in which fixed point charges Q are placed on a \Delta x\ \times\Delta x grid behind the pore wall at a distance r_{0} from the surface (Fig. 1 b). III.1 Changing localization First, we revisit the effect of varying \Delta x (and, simultaneously, Q , to keep the average surface charge constant) using the three-point fitting procedure defined in Eq. 8 , with the surface charges located at the pore wall ( r_{0}=0 ). Our previous work showed that the minimum in the total conductance (obtained from Eq. 7 ) deepens as \Delta x increases; however, the overall shape of the resulting curve did not quantitatively match the experimental data (see Fig. 11 of Ref. 12 ). Since the parameter \Delta x controls the strength of charge inversion through the degree of charge localization, it is natural to ask how the application of the three-point fitting procedure (Eq. 8 ) affects the resulting conductance curves in the present analysis. Figure 4 shows he ionic conductances, G_{i} , as functions of \lg(\eta) for different values of \Delta x with various line styles ( r_{0}=0 ) as obtained from Eq. 8 . Arrows indicate increasing \Delta x . The total conductance increases with increasing \Delta x (black curves) in the 0<\eta<0.2 region, and becomes increasingly similar to the experimental data (large gray spheres). Figure 4: Conductances of ionic species (Ca 2+ , K + , and Cl - ) and total conductance as functions of Ca 2+ mole fraction, \eta , for different models of carboxyl groups. Lines refer to fixed-charge models with the point charge being “on the wall” ( r_{0}=0 ) with \Delta x grid spacing and reduced point charges Q to maintain \sigma=-1 e /nm 2 . The arrows show the direction of increasing \Delta x . The small open triangles show the results obtained for modeling the carboxyl groups point charges at r_{0}=0.14 nm distance “behind the wall” using \Delta x=1 nm spacing and Q=-e . The large gray circles denote experimental results 14 . Total concentration is fixed at 0.1 M. For localization \Delta x=0.6 nm, the curve (thick line in Fig. 4 ) practically becomes identical with the curve for \Delta x=1 nm, Q=-e , r_{0}=1.4 nm (small open triangles). This latter model (discussed in the next subsection) decreases charge inversion in a different way: placing the -e point charges “behind the wall” at distance r_{0} , as compared to reducing Q . This result implies that the strength of charge inversion can be manipulated in two distinct ways: (1) changing localization (characterized by the \Delta x control parameter) and (2) changing the DCA (characterized by the r_{0} control parameter). The G_{i}(\eta) curves for the individual ions show similar behavior as functions of the control parameters: as functions of \Delta x in Fig. 4 and as functions of r_{0} in Fig. 5 . Therefore, we refer the detailed analyses of this behavior to the next subsection where we discuss that model. Here, we just note that charge inversion is so strong in the \Delta x=1 nm, r_{0}=0 nm case that fitting on the basis of Eq. 8 provides unphysical results: too large Ca 2+ conductance and negative Cl - conductance. III.2 Changing distance of closest approach We continue with the model in which fixed -e point charges are placed on a 1\;\mathrm{nm}\times 1\;\mathrm{nm} grid ( \Delta x=1 nm, Q=-e ) behind the pore wall at a distance r_{0} from the surface (Fig. 1 b). The case r_{0}=0 (the charge is on the wall, Fig. 1 a) is the point where our previous work 12 and the previous subsection concluded. The value r_{0}=R_{\mathrm{f}}=0.14 nm (triangles in Fig. 4 ), on the other hand, represents the case where the DCA between the ionic charge centers and the surface charges coincides with that obtained when carboxyl groups are modeled explicitly by oxygen atoms (Figs. 1 c-d and Fig. 2 ). In addition to these two limiting cases, we investigate intermediate cases with 0\leq r_{0}\leq R_{\mathrm{f}} . Figure 5 shows the ionic conductances, G_{i} , (as obtained from Eq. 8 ) as functions of \lg(\eta) for different values of r_{0} , with arrows indicating increasing r_{0} . As r_{0} increases, the Ca 2+ conductance decreases, while the Cl - and K + conductances increase. The total conductance, G=\sum_{i}G_{i} , for which experimental data are available, likewise increases in the 0<\eta<0.2 region and approaches the experimental curve as r_{0}\rightarrow R_{\mathrm{f}}=0.14 nm. Figure 5: Conductances of ionic species (Ca 2+ , K + , and Cl - ) and total conductance as functions of Ca 2+ mole fraction, \eta , for different models of carboxyl groups. Lines refer to fixed-charge models with the point charge being “behind the wall” at distance r_{0} from the wall. The arrows show the direction of increasing r_{0} . The small open squares show the results obtained for modeling the carboxyl groups with two oxygen atoms (charged hard spheres with radius R_{\mathrm{f}}=0.14 nm) each carrying -0.5e charge ( r_{0}=0.14 nm, R_{\mathrm{loc}}=0.2 nm). The large gray circles denote experimental results 14 . Total concentration is fixed at 0.1 M. This behavior arises from the simultaneous change of both G_{i}^{\prime} and D_{i}^{\mathrm{p}} (Figs. 6 and 7 A). G_{i}^{\prime} is determined by the LEMC simulation only, so it depends on the state point (determined by \eta ) and on the local interactions (tuned by r_{0} ) as shown in Fig. 6 . The conductances, on the other hand, change because the changing G_{i}^{\prime}(\eta) coefficients in Eq. 8 lead to different D_{i}^{\mathrm{p}} solutions (Fig. 7 A), and, therefore, different G_{i}(\eta) values between the fitting points (Fig. 5 and 7 B). Varying r_{0} tunes the strength of charge inversion, so it changes the concentration profiles (Figs. 8 and 9 ), and, consequently, the G_{i}^{\prime} variables (Fig. 6 ). Figure 6: The G_{i}^{\prime} normalized conductances for ionic species Ca 2+ , K + , and Cl - as functions of Ca 2+ mole fraction, \eta , for different models of carboxyl groups. Lines refer to fixed-charge models with the point charge being “behind the wall” at distance r_{0} from the wall. The arrows show the direction of increasing r_{0} . The G_{i}^{\prime} values are obtained by dividing the conductances ( G_{i} ) of Fig. 5 with the diffusion constants ( D_{i}^{\mathrm{p}} ) of Fig. 7 A. The values of G_{i} are not shown; we focus on the trends. The behavior of Ca 2+ is strongly affected by charge inversion (see the peaks and depletion zones in Figs. 8 and bottom panel of 9 ) so the G_{\mathrm{Ca}}^{\prime}(\eta) function depends sensitively on r_{0} : Ca 2+ ions become more mobilized with increasing r_{0} ( G_{\mathrm{Ca}}^{\prime} increases, see blue curves in Fig. 6 ). The conductance of Ca 2+ , on the other hand, decreases with increasing r_{0} (blue curves in Fig. 5 ). The G_{\mathrm{Cl}}^{\prime}(\eta) function, on the other hand, is small and decreases with increasing r_{0} (red curves in Fig. 6 ). G_{\mathrm{Cl}}^{\prime} is small because Cl - concentrations are smaller in the pore compared to cations (see the Cl - concentration profiles in the top panel of Fig. 9 ); it is a negatively charged pore after all. G_{\mathrm{Cl}}^{\prime} decreases due to decreasing Cl - concentration with increasing r_{0} due to lessened charge inversion (less overcharged pore wall draws less co-ions). The conductance of Cl - increases with increasing r_{0} (red curves in Fig. 5 ) despite this concentration decrease because a Cl - conductance is required to reproduce the data. The G_{\mathrm{K}}^{\prime}(\eta) function shows an increasing trend with increasing r_{0} (orange curves in Fig. 6 ) because the quantity of K + increases in the pore as charge inversion weakens (see the K + concentration profiles in the middle panel of Fig. 9 ). The conductance profiles show the same trend (orange curves in Fig. 5 ). The above discussion can readily be applied to the \Delta x -dependence in the previous subsection by replacing “increasing r_{0} ” with “decreasing \Delta x ” since both weaken charge inversion. Axial concentration profiles for different values of \Delta x are found in Fig. 10 of Ref. 12 . Detailed discussion about the role of localization is found in Ref. 9 . This complex behavior is the outcome of (1) simulations to get G_{i}^{\prime} and (2) fitting on the basis of Eq. 8 to get D_{i}^{\mathrm{p}} and G_{i} . The question now is which model of the surface charge (which r_{0} ) produces results that are in agreement with the experimental G_{i}(\eta) profiles between the fitting points and which model is in agreement with other considerations such as experiment for pure CaCl 2 20 , MD simulations for pure CaCl 2 24 , and physical intuition. The opposite r_{0} -dependence of G_{i} and G_{i}^{\prime} for Ca 2+ and Cl - is the result of the D_{\mathrm{Ca}}^{\mathrm{p}} and D_{\mathrm{Cl}}^{\mathrm{p}} values showing opposite trends as functions of r_{0} (Fig. 7 A). The case of r_{0}=0 (charge on the wall) is physically not meaningful first of all because D_{\mathrm{Cl}}^{\mathrm{p}} is negative, and because D_{\mathrm{Ca}}^{\mathrm{p}} is larger than D_{\mathrm{K}}^{\mathrm{p}} , which is unlikely given that D_{\mathrm{Ca}}^{\mathrm{b}}