Controlling emergent dynamical behavior via phase-engineered strong symmetries Marc Nairn, Beatriz Olmos, Parvinder Solanki Abstract Symmetry constraints provide a powerful means to control the dynamics of open quantum systems. However, the set of accessible control parameters is often limited. Here, we show that a tunable phase in the collective light-matter coupling of a cavity QED system induces a phase-dependent strong symmetry of the Liouvillian, enabling dynamical control of the open quantum system evolution. We demonstrate that tuning this phase substantially reduces the critical driving strength for dissipative phase transitions between stationary and non-stationary phases. We illustrate this mechanism in two experimentally relevant cavity QED settings: a two-species ensemble of two-level atoms and a single-species ensemble of three-level atoms. Our results establish phase control as a versatile tool for engineering dissipative phase transitions, with implications for quantum state preparation. Introduction. – Symmetries play a central role in modern physics by constraining dynamics, enforcing conservation laws, and shaping phases of matter and their transitions Kosmann-Schwarzbach 2011 ; Strocchi 2005 . In open quantum systems Breuer and Petruccione 2002 ; Alicki and Lendi 2007 , where coherent and dissipative processes coexist, symmetries impose stringent constraints on both the structure of the dynamics and the stationary and non-stationary states that they support Buča and Prosen 2012 ; Albert and Jiang 2014 . In these systems, when present, so-called strong symmetries remain preserved under both coherent evolution and dissipation, enforcing microscopic conservation laws in contrast to the ensemble-averaged conservation laws associated with weak symmetries Baumgartner and Narnhofer 2008 . Such symmetries can give rise to decoherence-free subspaces Wu and Lidar 2002 ; Beige et al. 2000 ; Albert et al. 2016 ; Lidar and Birgitta Whaley 2003 ; Shabani and Lidar 2005 ; Bacon 2001 ; Vaecairn et al. 2025 and enable rich non-equilibrium phenomena, including non-stationary phases Iemini et al. 2018 ; Alaeian and Buča 2022 ; Buča et al. 2019a ; Kongkhambut et al. 2022 with applications in sensing Cabot et al. 2024a ; Gribben et al. 2025 , heat engines Carollo et al. 2020 ; Zaletel et al. 2023 , and energy storage Paulino et al. 2025 . A complementary route to controlling open-system dynamics exploits phase-engineered interference, achievable through geometric design Pleinert et al. 2017 or reservoir engineering Metelmann and Clerk 2015 . Such phases can be global, generating collective nonlinear effects protected by symmetries Young et al. 2025 , or appear as non-gaugeable relative phases that enable non-reciprocal behavior Fruchart et al. 2021 ; Clerk 2022 ; Barzanjeh et al. 2025 . These mechanisms underpin applications ranging from directional amplification Wanjura et al. 2023 ; Jing et al. 2021 ; Vega et al. 2025 to the emergence of novel dynamical phases Chiacchio et al. 2023 ; Nadolny et al. 2025 ; Lyu and Hwang ; Ho et al. 2025 . Despite these advances, the use of phase-dependent symmetries themselves as a resource for controlling open-system dynamics has remained largely unexplored. Figure 1: Schematic of the setups . (a) Two species of two-level atoms confined in a single-mode optical cavity with phase-dependent couplings g_{A}=g,g_{B}=ge^{-i\varphi} and (b) description of the effective spin interactions mediated by the cavity. (c) Atomic gas where each atom is modeled as a three-level system with state-dependent couplings g_{A}=g,g_{B}=ge^{-i\varphi} and (d) effective atom-only description. In this work, we show that the interplay between strong symmetries and tunable phases provides a powerful and systematic route to controlling dynamical phenomena in collective light-matter systems. We consider a driven-dissipative cavity QED platform that exhibits dissipative phase transitions between stationary and non-stationary states, also known as continuous-time crystals Iemini et al. 2018 ; Buča et al. 2019b ; Buča and Jaksch 2019 ; Pizzi et al. 2019 ; Hurtado-Gutiérrez et al. 2020 ; Carollo and Lesanovsky 2022 ; Hajdušek et al. 2022 ; Krishna et al. 2023 ; Nakanishi and Sasamoto 2023 ; Iemini et al. 2024 ; Solanki et al. 2024 ; Cabot et al. 2024b ; Mattes et al. 2023 ; Mukherjee et al. 2024 ; Carollo et al. 2024 ; Paulino et al. 2025 ; Paulino et al. 2023 ; Russo and Pohl 2025 ; Wang et al. 2025 ; Solanki et al. 2025 ; Schumann et al. 2026 . We demonstrate that a tunable phase in the collective light–matter coupling induces a phase-dependent strong symmetry that reshapes the onset and character of the non-stationary dynamics, enabling access to time-crystalline regimes at substantially reduced driving strengths. We establish the generality of this mechanism by analyzing two variants of the Tavis–Cummings model: a two-species ensemble of two-level atoms and a single-species three-level atomic gas in a single-mode cavity. Our results identify phase-controlled strong symmetries as a versatile tool for engineering non-stationary phases and controlling dissipative phase transitions in open quantum systems, with potential applications in quantum state preparation. Strong symmetries in open quantum systems. – Within the Born–Markov approximation, the time evolution of the density matrix \hat{\rho} of an open quantum system is governed by the Gorini-Kossakowski-Sudarshan-Lindblad master equation (GKSL), \dot{\hat{\rho}}=\mathcal{L}(\hat{\rho})\equiv-\dfrac{\mathrm{i}}{\hbar}[\hat{H},\hat{\rho}]+\sum_{k}\mathcal{D}[\hat{L}_{k}]\hat{\rho}, (1) where \hat{H} is the Hamiltonian, \hat{L}_{k} are the Lindblad jump operators, \mathcal{D}[\hat{L}_{k}]\hat{\rho}=\hat{L}_{k}\hat{\rho}\hat{L}_{k}^{\dagger}-\{\hat{L}_{k}^{\dagger}\hat{L}_{k},\hat{\rho}\}/2 denotes the dissipator and \mathcal{L} is the Liouvillian superoperator. A system exhibits a strong symmetry if there exists an operator \hat{A} that commutes with both the Hamiltonian and all Lindblad jump operators, i.e., [\hat{A},\hat{H}]=0 and [\hat{A},\hat{L}_{k}]=0\ \forall k Buča and Prosen 2012 ; Baumgartner and Narnhofer 2008 ; Albert and Jiang 2014 . This dual commutation relation partitions the Hilbert space into invariant symmetry sectors, \mathcal{H}=\bigoplus_{\lambda}\mathcal{H}_{\lambda} , corresponding to the eigenspaces of \hat{A} . As a result, the dynamics generated by \mathcal{L} is decoupled across sectors. Decomposing the initial state as \hat{\rho}(0)=\sum_{\lambda,\lambda^{\prime}}\hat{\rho}_{\lambda\lambda^{\prime}}(0) with \hat{\rho}_{\lambda\lambda^{\prime}}(0)=\hat{\Pi}_{\lambda}\,\hat{\rho}(0)\,\hat{\Pi}_{\lambda^{\prime}} and \hat{\Pi}_{\lambda} being the projector onto \mathcal{H}_{\lambda} , the coherences between different symmetry sectors ( \lambda\neq\lambda^{\prime} ) do not contribute to the long-time dynamics Iemini et al. 2024 . Consequently, the steady state of Eq. ( 1 ) assumes the block-diagonal form \hat{\rho}^{\mathrm{ss}}=\lim_{t\to\infty}e^{\mathcal{L}t}\hat{\rho}(0)=\sum_{\lambda}w_{\lambda}\,\hat{\rho}^{\mathrm{ss}}_{\lambda}, (2) where the conserved sector weights (or overlaps) w_{\lambda}=\Tr[\hat{\Pi}_{\lambda}\,\hat{\rho}(0)] are fixed by the initial state. In the following, we show that in collective cavity QED systems, a tunable phase in the light–matter coupling modifies the underlying strong symmetry, thereby reshaping the dynamical constraints imposed by Eq. ( 1 ) and controlling the onset of dissipative phase transitions. Two-species model. – We first consider an ensemble of N atoms interacting with a single-mode driven cavity. The atoms belong to two different species, A and B , each comprising N/2 two-level atoms with states \ket{\downarrow}_{A/B} and \ket{\uparrow}_{A/B} [see Fig. 1 (a)]. Each species couples collectively to the cavity field with coupling strength g_{A/B} and atomic detuning \Delta_{A/B} . As detailed in the Supplemental Material (SM) sup , both the magnitude and phase of the couplings, as well as the detunings, can be controlled experimentally using external Raman lasers. In the following, we focus on the situation in which the two species differ only by a controllable phase \varphi , i.e. g_{A}=g , g_{B}=ge^{-i\varphi} , and \Delta=\Delta_{A}=\Delta_{B} . In an appropriate rotating frame, the system dynamics is governed by the Hamiltonian \hat{H}_{2L}=\hat{H}_{\mathrm{cav}}+\hat{H}_{\mathrm{int}}+\hat{H}_{\mathrm{at}} (see SM sup for details of the derivation). The cavity contribution reads \hat{H}_{\mathrm{cav}}=\hbar\Delta_{c}\hat{a}^{\dagger}\hat{a}+i\hbar\eta\sqrt{N}\left(\hat{a}^{\dagger}-\hat{a}\right) , where \hat{a} ( \hat{a}^{\dagger} ) annihilates (creates) a cavity photon, \eta is the driving rate, and \Delta_{c} the cavity detuning. Throughout this work we set \Delta_{c}=0 ; qualitatively similar behavior persists for \Delta_{c}\neq 0 (see SM sup ). The atom-cavity interaction is \hat{H}_{\mathrm{int}}=\hbar g/\sqrt{N}\left(\hat{a}^{\dagger}\hat{S}_{\varphi}+\hat{a}\hat{S}^{\dagger}_{\varphi}\right) , where the phase-dependent spin operator \hat{S}_{\varphi}=\sum_{j=1}^{N/2}\left(\hat{\sigma}_{jA}+e^{-i\varphi}\hat{\sigma}_{jB}\right) encodes the relative phase between the two species, with \hat{\sigma}_{jm}=\ket{\downarrow}_{jm}\!\!\bra{\uparrow} . The free atomic Hamiltonian is given by \hat{H}_{\mathrm{at}}=\hbar\Delta\hat{S}_{\varphi}^{z} , with \hat{S}_{\varphi}^{z}=\frac{1}{2}\left(\hat{S}_{\varphi}^{\dagger}\hat{S}_{\varphi}-\hat{S}_{\varphi}\hat{S}_{\varphi}^{\dagger}\right) . Photon losses are described by a Lindblad term with decay rate \kappa . All terms are scaled with N to ensure a well-defined thermodynamic limit ( N\to\infty) . Figure 2: Phase enabled nonstationary states . (a) Mean-field phase diagram showcasing the effect of tunable phase \varphi on the transition between stationary ( SS ) and nonstationary states ( NSS ), and (b) the corresponding weight distribution in the Dicke subspace, w_{S^{2}_{\text{max}}}^{\varphi} and its complement \overline{w}^{\varphi} . Finite-size dynamics for highlighted points in (a) illustrating the usual time-crystalline behavior and the lowering of the threshold value, panels (c) and (d) , respectively. We consider system sizes N\in\left(10,20,\dots,60\right) (lines with increasing color intensity). The results are benchmarked against the mean-field values (dashed) with g/\kappa=0.1 and \Delta=0 . To understand the role of the phase \varphi , we first analyze the mean-field dynamics in terms of the cavity field \alpha=\langle\hat{a}\rangle and the rescaled collective spin components s_{A/B}^{\mu}=\langle\hat{S}_{A/B}^{\mu}\rangle/(N/2) with \hat{S}_{m}^{\mu}=\frac{1}{2}\sum_{j=1}^{N/2}\hat{\sigma}_{jm}^{\mu} and \hat{\sigma}_{jm}^{\mu=x,y,z} the Pauli matrices for m\in\{A,B\} . To distinguish stationary from non-stationary phases, we introduce the dominant frequency \tilde{\omega} extracted from the spectrum of the spin polarization \mathcal{F}_{A/B}(\omega)=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}s^{z}_{A/B}(t)e^{-i\omega t}dt . In all cases considered, the two species oscillate synchronously, so that \tilde{\omega}\equiv\tilde{\omega}_{A}=\tilde{\omega}_{B} . For \varphi=0 and \Delta=0 , the system undergoes a transition from a stationary state ( \tilde{\omega}=0 ) to a non-stationary state ( \tilde{\omega}>0 ) at a critical driving strength \eta_{c}=g , as shown in [Fig. 2 ](a). In contrast, for finite \varphi the critical driving strength becomes phase-dependent for any initial state with |s_{A/B}^{z}|<1 . This behavior is illustrated in [Fig. 2 (a)] for the initial state condition (\alpha,s^{x}_{A/B},s^{y}_{A/B},s^{z}_{A/B})=(0,1,0,0) . Remarkably, the threshold for the onset of non-stationarity is progressively reduced with increasing |\varphi| and vanishes in the limit \varphi\to\pm\pi . In the following section, we show that this phase-enabled reduction of the critical drive originates from a modification of an underlying strong symmetry, which reshapes the accessible dynamical sectors of the system. Symmetries and dynamical phases in the two-species model. – In the limit of strong dissipation \kappa\gg g,\eta,\Delta , the cavity field can be adiabatically eliminated, yielding an effective spin-only description (see SM sup ), [Fig. 1 (b)]. The reduced spin density matrix \hat{\mu}_{s} then evolves according to \dot{\hat{\mu}}_{s}=-\frac{\mathrm{i}}{\hbar}[\hat{H}_{S},\hat{\mu}_{s}]+\frac{\Gamma}{2S}\mathcal{D}[\hat{S}_{\varphi}]\hat{\mu}_{s}, (3) where S=N/2 , \Gamma=4g^{2}/\kappa , and the effective Hamiltonian reads \hat{H}_{S}=\hbar\Delta\hat{S}_{\varphi}^{z}+\hbar\Omega\left(\hat{S}_{\varphi}+\hat{S}^{\dagger}_{\varphi}\right) with \Omega=2\eta g/\kappa . For \Delta=0 and \varphi=0 , Eq. ( 3 ) reduces to the boundary time crystal (BTC) model Iemini et al. 2018 , which undergoes a transition from a stationary to a time crystalline phase at \Omega/(\Gamma/2)=1 . This directly accounts for the critical driving strength \eta_{c}=g observed in the full cavity-spin model and motivates our identification of the non-stationary phase as a continuous time crystal. To elucidate the role of the phase \varphi , we analyze the symmetries of the spin-only dynamics. The operators \hat{S}_{\varphi},\hat{S}_{\varphi}^{\dagger},\hat{S}_{\varphi}^{z} generate an \mathfrak{su}(2) algebra. The associated Casimir operator \hat{\mathbf{S}}_{\varphi}^{2}=\dfrac{1}{2}\left(\hat{S}_{\varphi}\hat{S}_{\varphi}^{\dagger}+\hat{S}_{\varphi}^{\dagger}\hat{S}_{\varphi}\right)+(\hat{S}_{\varphi}^{z})^{2} commutes with both the Hamiltonian \hat{H}_{S} and the jump operators \hat{S}_{\varphi} , and therefore constitutes a strong symmetry of the Liouvillian. This symmetry generalizes a total spin conservation in the \varphi=0 case to a phase-dependent setting. As a consequence, the dynamics decomposes into invariant sectors labeled by the eigenvalues S^{2}_{\varphi} of \hat{\mathbf{S}}_{\varphi}^{2} . The system can be thus described in a generalized, phase-dependent Dicke basis. For \varphi=0 , these sectors coincide with the standard Dicke manifolds; for \varphi\neq 0 , they correspond to rotated collective modes encoding the relative phase between the two subensembles. The weight of each sector is w_{S^{2}}^{\varphi}=\mathrm{Tr}[\hat{\Pi}^{\varphi}_{S^{2}}\hat{\mu}_{s}] , where \hat{\Pi}^{\varphi}_{S^{2}} projects onto the corresponding eigenspace. In practice, the dynamics is governed by the competition between the fully symmetric sector, w_{{S^{2}}_{\mathrm{max}}}^{\varphi} , and its complement, \overline{w}^{\varphi}=1-w_{{S^{2}}_{\mathrm{max}}}^{\varphi} , which collects all contributions outside the permutationally invariant Dicke manifold. We now connect this symmetry structure to the dynamical phase diagram shown in [Fig. 2 (a)]. We consider the initial product state \hat{\mu}_{s}(0)=\bigotimes_{m=A,B}\bigotimes_{j=1}^{N/2}\outerproduct{+_x}{+_x}_{jm} with \ket{+_x}=\left(\ket{\uparrow}+\ket{\downarrow}\right)/\sqrt{2} , which corresponds to the mean-field condition used in [Fig. 2 (a)]. While this choice is not unique, it is particularly instructive because its decomposition into symmetry sectors depends sensitively on \varphi . For \varphi=0 , the initial state lies entirely in the fully symmetric Dicke manifold, w_{{S^{2}}_{\mathrm{max}}}^{\varphi=0}=1 , and the critical driving strength reaches its maximal value, reproducing the BTC threshold Iemini et al. 2018 ; Carollo and Lesanovsky 2022 . As \varphi is tuned away from zero, weight is transferred into non symmetric sectors, as shown in [Fig. 2 (b)]. Since different symmetry sectors are dynamically decoupled, only the component within the fully symmetric manifold undergoes the collective instability responsible for time-crystalline dynamics. The effective evolution is therefore governed by a Dicke state with reduced effective spin length, leading to a corresponding reduction of the critical driving strength Solanki et al. 2024 ; Cabot et al. 2024c . In the limit of \varphi\to\pm\pi , the contribution of the fully symmetric Dicke manifold vanishes w_{{S^{2}}_{\mathrm{max}}}^{\varphi}\to 0 . In this regime, arbitrarily weak driving induces time-crystalline dynamics Iemini et al. 2024 ; Solanki et al. 2024 , consistent with the vanishing threshold observed in [Fig. 2 (a)]. At the exact antisymmetric point (exactly \varphi=\pm\pi ), the initial state becomes a dark state, remaining unaffected by the dissipative dynamics. Within the time-crystalline phase, both species exhibit frequency-locked oscillations that converge to the mean-field behavior as N increases [Fig. 2 (c,d)]. The oscillation frequency \tilde{\omega} increases with the weight \overline{w}^{\varphi} , reflecting the contribution of dressed modes originating outside the fully symmetric manifold Iemini et al. 2024 . Finally, we note that the physics of the system for finite detuning \Delta\neq 0 differs qualitatively. For \eta<\eta_{c} , the system does not relax to a stationary state but instead exhibits persistent oscillations at frequency \Delta , associated with decoherence-free subspaces corresponding to purely imaginary eigenvalues \pm i\Delta . For \eta>\eta_{c} , the oscillation frequencies are modified in a manner analogous to the resonant case; see sup for details. Figure 3: Three-level system frequency response . (a) Phase-dependent steady-state phase diagram showcasing frequency response for a chosen initial state with c_{\pm}=(1\pm\sqrt{2})/2\sqrt{2},\,c_{0}=\sqrt{1-c_{+}^{2}-c_{-}^{2}} , far from the eigenstates \ket{v_{\pm 1}^\varphi} . The order parameter \tilde{\omega}_{N_{B}} is the normalized dominant Fourier component of the excited state B . (b) Initial state visualization of threshold contours in (c_{+},c_{-}) parameter space for \varphi=0 . States are defined as nonstationary if \tilde{\omega}_{N_{B}}\geq 0.01 and shaded orange. On the \eta/g=0 plane we highlight the eigenstates of \hat{\tau}_{j}^{\varphi} mentioned in the main text. (c) Parameter space map taken at the \eta/g=0.5 slice from (b) . (d) Threshold contours for \varphi=2\pi/3 , and the equivalent parameter space map (e) . The white and green markers correspond to the initial state used in (a) , falling inside the nonstationary regime as \varphi is tuned. Other parameters used g/\kappa=0.1,\Delta=0 , for a simulation time of gt=2\times 10^{4} . Single-species three-level system and its symmetries. – To illustrate the generality of phase-controlled strong symmetries, we consider N atoms with a common ground state \ket{0} and two excited states \ket{A} and \ket{B} [Fig. 1 (c)]. Each atom is coupled to the cavity via Raman transitions with amplitudes g_{A} and g_{B} . A relative phase \varphi is imprinted by phase-shifting the Raman lasers such that g_{A}=g and g_{B}=ge^{-i\varphi} . After adiabatic elimination of the cavity, [Fig. 1 (d)], the atomic dynamics is governed by \dot{\hat{\mu}}_{\rm 3s}=-\frac{i}{\hbar}[\hat{H}_{\rm 3s},\hat{\mu}_{\rm 3s}]+\frac{\Gamma}{N}\mathcal{D}[\hat{\Lambda}_{\varphi}]\hat{\mu}_{\rm 3s}, (4) where \hat{\mu}_{\mathrm{3s}} is the reduced atomic density matrix, \Gamma=4g^{2}/\kappa , \hat{\Lambda}_{\varphi}=\hat{\Lambda}_{A}+e^{-i\varphi}\hat{\Lambda}_{B}, and \hat{\Lambda}_{k}=\sum_{j=1}^{N}\outerproduct{0}{k}_{j} with k\in\{A,B\} . The effective Hamiltonian reads \hat{H}_{\mathrm{3s}}=\hbar\sum_{k}\Delta_{k}\hat{\Lambda}_{k}^{\dagger}\hat{\Lambda}_{k}+\hbar\mathcal{E}\left(\hat{\Lambda}_{\varphi}+\hat{\Lambda}_{\varphi}^{\dagger}\right), where \mathcal{E}=2\eta g/\kappa . For equal detunings, \Delta_{A}=\Delta_{B}=\Delta , the dynamics admits a phase-dependent strong symmetry that can be written as a sum of single-atom operators, \hat{\mathcal{T}}^{\varphi}=\sum_{j=1}^{N}\hat{\tau}^{\varphi}_{j} , with \hat{\tau}^{\varphi}_{j}=\outerproduct{0}{0}_{j}+e^{-i\varphi}\outerproduct{A}{B}_{j}+e^{i\varphi}\outerproduct{B}{A}_{j} . To elucidate the structure of the dynamically invariant subspaces, we examine the eigenstates of the single-atom operators \hat{\tau}^{\varphi}_{j} , which split according to their eigenvalues \pm 1 : \ket{v_{+1}^\varphi}_{j}\equiv\big\{\ket{0}_{j},\ket{+}_{j}\big\},\;\ket{v_{-1}^\varphi}_{j}\equiv\ket{-}_{j}, (5) where \ket{\pm}_{j}=\left(\ket{B}_{j}\pm e^{-i\varphi}\ket{A}_{j}\right)/\sqrt{2} . For \Delta=0 , the states in \ket{v_{+1}^\varphi}_{j} form a doubly-degenerate subspace in which excitations can cycle between \ket{0}_{j} and \ket{+}_{j} under the combined action of Hamiltonian and dissipative dynamics. We therefore identify this as the bright subspace . In contrast, \ket{v_{-1} ^\varphi}_{j} is a dark state , decoupled from both coherent and dissipative dynamics. Extending this structure to N atoms suggests that the population of dark states strongly influences the long time dynamics. In particular, the fraction of atoms occupying the dark subspace, together with the driving rate \eta , determine whether the system evolves toward a stationary or non-stationary phase. We quantify this dependence in the following section. State-space dependent dynamics .– To illustrate the dynamical role of the bright and dark subspaces, we consider a family of pure initial states \hat{\mu}_{3s}(0)=\outerproduct{\psi_{3s}}{\psi_{3s}} with \ket{\psi_{3s}}=c_{+}\ket{+}^{\otimes N}+c_{-}\ket{-}^{\otimes N}+c_{0}\ket{0}^{\otimes N} , where c_{0}=\sqrt{1-c_{+}^{2}-c_{-}^{2}} and c_{\pm}\in[0,1] . We quantify the support of a state on the symmetry sectors via the weights w_{\pm}^{\varphi}=\mathrm{Tr}[\hat{\Pi}_{\pm}^{\varphi}\hat{\mu}_{3s}] , where the projectors onto the bright and dark subspaces are \hat{\Pi}_{\pm}^{\varphi}=\bigotimes_{j}^{N}\ket{v_{\pm 1}^\varphi}\bra{v_{\pm 1}^\varphi}_{j} . Non-stationary dynamics can arise either from sufficiently strong driving or from finite overlap with the freely evolving bright subspace ( w_{+}^{\varphi}>0 ). The competition between drive and sector weight determines the long-time behaviour, such that the critical driving strength \eta_{c} depends on the parameters of the initial state c_{\pm} as well as on the phase \varphi . To characterize the non-stationary phase, we analyze the mean-field dynamics with initial conditions determined by expectation values in \ket{\psi_{3s}} . As an order parameter we use the normalized dominant frequency \tilde{\omega}_{N_{B}} of the Fourier transform of the population of the excited-state B . The choice of observable is not essential, and other choices yield equivalent results Prazeres et al. 2021 . For initial states with 0