Conversions between kinetic and surface energy in periodically forced multiphase turbulence F. Thiesset, J. Vahé Abstract In multiphase flows, kinetic and interfacial energies coexist, and their mutual conversion can strongly influence the overall energy balance. However, in statistically steady flows these energy reservoirs remain constant, making such conversions undetectable. For them to be observed, a degree of unsteadiness must be introduced, here provided by the deliberate use of a fluctuating time-periodic input of kinetic energy into the system. The main focus of the present work is on the dynamical cycle connecting energy injection, conversion, and dissipation which we explore using numerical simulations of multiphase homogeneous isotropic turbulence, subjected to periodic forcing. The database includes various Reynolds and Weber numbers and volume fractions in the dense regime. To interpret and replicate the observed dynamics, we reformulate the Ka-Pi-bara model of 6 (an extension of the k k – ϵ \epsilon model) in terms of total energy (the sum of kinetic and surface energy), which we further enhance by adding equations for the surface energy and its destruction. This model accurately captures a key feature of turbulence: non-equilibrium effects, seen as the phase lag between kinetic energy and its rate of dissipation, which are found to operate also in multiphase flows. Linearizing the model highlights the various relevant time scales of the system and provides predictions of how different observables are coupled and respond to the energy input. In particular, the model predicts that fluctuations of surface energy and its destruction are in phase, in good agreement with numerical simulations. Therefore, unlike kinetic energy, surface energy remains in equilibrium, indicating the absence of a surface energy cascade. I Introduction Flows of immiscible fluids are common in both natural and industrial systems. In many cases, the interfacial surface area between the two phases is a critical parameter, controlling phenomena such as heat and mass transfer. Yet, predicting the interface surface area requires understanding the complex coupling between the flow and the interface which remains a major challenge. This interplay becomes clear when considering energy balances: the interface stores surface energy through surface tension, coexisting with kinetic energy 21 ; 14 ; 33 ; 7 . A key open question is how these different forms of energy interact. Recent studies 23 ; 17 ; 26 ; 13 ; 25 ; 9 ; 29 ; 24 ; 31 have gradually converged toward a coherent framework for describing energy exchanges in multiphase turbulence. In this picture, a portion of the kinetic energy injected at large scales cascades to smaller scales, much like in single-phase flows. Concurrently, when surface tension is present, part of the injected energy is also converted into interfacial or surface energy as interfaces become progressively distorted and fluid structures break up. At smaller scales, interfaces may relax, fluid structures could also coalesce, converting surface energy back into kinetic energy. Both the turbulent cascade and energy conversion processes continue down to the smallest scales, where kinetic energy is ultimately dissipated into heat. Multiphase flows are thus characterized by a complex interplay of energy injection, cascade, conversion, and dissipation. At steady state, both kinetic and surface energy remain constant, and energy conversions vanish, reflecting an equilibrium between the two reservoirs and between energy injection and dissipation, as in single-phase flows. In turbulent flows, however, steady state can only be defined statistically, after averaging over long times. Instantaneously, spatial averages remain non-stationary, making turbulence a textbook example of an “out-of-equilibrium” system, where the injected energy requires finite time to cascade across scales before being dissipated ( 27 ; 10 ; 19 , see e.g.) . Non-equilibrium effects are then manifested in particular in a time delay between fluctuations of kinetic energy and its rate of dissipation. Because in multiphase turbulence, energy conversion occurs alongside energy transfer, it can potentially lead to atypical out-of-equilibrium behaviours that remain largely unexplored. To date, only 23 have revealed an intriguing dynamical cycle linking kinetic energy injection, conversion into surface energy, and dissipation into heat. This study pursues three main objectives: (i) to analyse energy exchanges in unsteady multiphase flows, (ii) to examine the coupling and dissipation/destruction of kinetic and surface energies, and (iii) to clarify the out-of-equilibrium characteristics of multiphase turbulent flows for both forms of energy. Here, we deliberately keep the flow in a non-stationary regime while retaining the possibility of meaningful statistical analysis. This is achieved by considering periodically forced turbulence, for which phase averaging can be employed in place of classical time averaging. Such a configuration has been widely used, in particular to investigate non-equilibrium effects 34 ; 5 or to explore the role of intermittency of the large scales 11 ; 2 . They also provide a convenient benchmark for one-point and two-point closure models (see, e.g., 30 ; 35 ; 16 ; 6 , and references therein) . Periodically forced flows are known to exhibit two asymptotic responses. At very low forcing frequencies, the system has sufficient time to adjust to variations in energy input and therefore evolves through a sequence of locally steady states; this corresponds to the static limit. Conversely, at very high forcing frequencies, the turbulent cascade acts as a low-pass filter, so that dissipation does not respond to changes in the energy input, defining the frozen limit. While these extreme regimes are relatively straightforward to predict, more interesting dynamics arise at intermediate forcing frequencies, which is the regime of primary interest in the present study. We conduct numerical simulations of multiphase turbulence driven by harmonic forcing in a triply periodic domain using a standard Navier–Stokes solver coupled with an interface-capturing method. The resulting flow is homogeneous and isotropic. To interpret and reproduce the numerical observations, we propose a model that accounts for the coupling between kinetic and surface energies, as well as their respective dissipation or destruction mechanisms. This model builds upon a recent extension of the k – \epsilon framework, referred to as the Ka-Pi-bara model 6 , which was developed to capture non-equilibrium effects in single-phase flows. The extension to multiphase flows proceeds in two steps. First, we reformulate the model in terms of the total energy, defined as the sum of kinetic and surface energies, in order to incorporate the influence of interfaces on the kinetic energy dissipation rate. Second, we introduce additional evolution equations for the surface energy and its destruction, formulated in direct analogy with the equations governing kinetic energy and its dissipation rate in the k – \epsilon model. Linearising the model allows us to predict the gain and phase lag of the different observables with respect to changes in the energy input. The paper is organized as follows. First, the derivation of the model and the linearised solutions are presented in § II . Details about the numerical procedure and the explored parameters are provided in § III . Results are gathered and discussed in § IV . Section V summarizes the main conclusions. II Modelling II.1 Single-phase flows The standard k-\epsilon model 22 for single phase, homogeneous, forced turbulence writes: \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{k} \displaystyle= \displaystyle F-\epsilon (1a) \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{\epsilon} \displaystyle= \displaystyle C_{1}F\frac{\epsilon}{E_{k}}-C_{2}\frac{\epsilon^{2}}{E_{k}}, (1b) where E_{k}=\langle\rho|\bm{u}|^{2}\rangle is the kinetic energy, with the brackets denoting a volume average and \rho is the density. The kinetic energy dissipation rate is defined by \epsilon=\langle\mu~{\bm{\mathsf{S}}}:{\bm{\mathsf{S}}}\rangle where \mu=\nu/\rho is the dynamic viscosity, \nu the kinematic viscosity and {\bm{\mathsf{S}}} the strain rate tensor. Time derivatives of any quantity X is denoted \accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{X} . Equation ( 1a ) is exact while Eq. ( 1b ) is a model equation for the time variations of the kinetic energy dissipation rate \epsilon . The latter depends on some model parameters C_{1} and C_{2} which needs to be determined. The k-\epsilon model is a set of coupled but closed ordinary differential equations (ODE) which provides estimates for the kinetic energy and dissipation, where the forcing F is the input. The steady state solution of Eq. ( 1a ), is F^{0}=\epsilon^{0} (superscript 0 denote the steady state quantities). For Eq. ( 1b ) to be compatible with the steady state solution \accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{\epsilon}^{0}=0 , the model parameters C_{1} and C_{2} should be equal, i.e. C_{1} = C_{2}=C_{k} . The k-\epsilon model can thus be rewritten as: \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{k} \displaystyle= \displaystyle F-\epsilon (2a) \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{\epsilon} \displaystyle= \displaystyle C_{k}\frac{\epsilon}{E_{k}}\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{k} (2b) For turbulent flows with time-periodic forcing, the k-\epsilon model predicts a finite time delay between forcing and dissipation, which depends on the ratio between the forcing frequency and the inverse of eddy turn-over time C_{k}\epsilon^{0}/E_{k}^{0} . However, the model predicts that E_{k} and \epsilon are in phase, which is inconsistent with a wide range of observations supporting out-of-equilibrium dynamics. In recent works by 6 ; 4 , a modified k – \epsilon model was developed which properly reflects the time lag between E_{k} and \epsilon . For this purpose, they started from the spectral balance equation for forced homogeneous turbulence. They assume that the large-scales kinetic energy follows \accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{k}^{<}=F-\Pi while the small-scales kinetic energy evolves as \accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{k}^{>}=\Pi-\epsilon , where \Pi is the kinetic energy transfer across scales. Then, using a Taylor-like expression for the energy transfer, i.e. \Pi\sim{E_{k}^{<}}^{3/2}/L , they obtained the so-called Ka-Pi-bara model which writes (see eq. (59) of 6 ): \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{k} \displaystyle= \displaystyle F-\epsilon (3a) \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{\epsilon} \displaystyle= \displaystyle C_{k}\frac{\epsilon}{E_{k}}\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{k}\left(1+\gamma\frac{F}{\epsilon}\right)-\gamma\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{F} (3b) In the system Eq. ( 3 ), the symbol \gamma=E_{k}^{>}/E_{k}^{<} represents the small-scale to large-scale kinetic energy ratio. The Ka-Pi-bara assumes \gamma is constant in time and appears as a second model parameter which needs to be determined. When \gamma=0 , the model reduces to the original k – \epsilon formulation, showing that the delay between E_{k} and \epsilon is encoded into this constant \gamma . II.2 Multiphase flows Our purpose is now to extend this framework to multiphase flows where kinetic energy E_{k} coexists with surface energy E_{s} related to interfacial forces. For an interface with a constant surface tension coefficient \sigma , the surface energy is given by E_{s}=\sigma A 23 ; 33 ; 7 , where A is the surface area density of the interface between the two phases. For statistically homogeneous flows, in absence of mass and heat exchanges, the evolution equation for the kinetic energy then writes ( 33 ; 1 ; 7 ; 3 ; 20 ; 31 , e.g.) : \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{k}=F-\epsilon-\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{s} (4) where \accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{s}=\sigma\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{A} corresponds to the conversion of kinetic energy into surface energy 14 . This implies that the evolution of the total energy E_{t}=E_{k}+E_{s} is given by: \accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{t}=F-\epsilon. (5) Equation ( 5 ) indicates that the energy budget in multiphase turbulence is formally analogous to the one in single-phase turbulence, once the total energy E_{t} is used in place of the kinetic energy E_{k} . It means that the conversion between kinetic and surface energy is conservative: surface energy has no intrinsic dissipation. All irreversible process occurs via viscosity: the total energy dissipation rate is the kinetic energy dissipation rate. For modelling purposes, it thus seems natural to use E_{t} instead of E_{k} in the evolution equation for \epsilon in the k-\epsilon or Ka-Pi-bara model, viz: \accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{\epsilon}=C_{k}\frac{\epsilon}{E_{t}}\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{t}\left(1+\gamma\frac{F}{\epsilon}\right)-\gamma\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{F}. (6) This equation can be derived using the same procedure as in 4 ; 6 assuming that the total energy E_{t} can be used in place of the kinetic energy E_{k} in the spectral balance equation, viz. \gamma=E_{t}^{>}/E_{t}^{<} and assuming that \Pi reads as the non-linear transfer term plus the scale-by-scale contribution due to the conversion between kinetic and surface energy; an argument confirmed by the theory of 25 . Several studies (e.g. 14 ; 23 ; 31 , among others) have reported a relationship between kinetic energy dissipation and interfacial surface area. This effect enters via Equation ( 6 ) which formally couples the equations governing \epsilon and E_{s} . The evolution equation for the surface density A is known 28 ; 8 . For homogeneous flows, it can be formulated in terms of E_{s} as 33 ; 7 : \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{s}=KE_{s}, (7) where K is the rate of production/destruction of surface area (or here surface energy). By analogy with E_{k} , we will write K=P-\chi where P relates to a surface energy production term associated with stretch and breakup, while \chi is a surface energy destruction term due to compression and coalescence. This idea was already present in 32 and was reappraised in recent studies 23 ; 26 ; 33 ; 13 ; 31 . 32 suggested that P is proportional to the inverse of the Kolmogorov time-scale, a postulate that is robustly verified in a variety of different situations including material surfaces ( 36 , e.g.) , passive scalar iso-surfaces ( 18 , e.g.) , premixed flames ( 12 , e.g.) , etc. Hence, we here assume P=(\epsilon/\nu)^{1/2} . However, much less is known about the rate of destruction of surface energy \chi . In consequence, since \chi plays for E_{s} the same role as \epsilon for E_{k} , we add a fourth equation to model the evolution of \chi . The latter is written in analogy with the one of \epsilon in the original k-\epsilon model, by simply replacing \epsilon by \chi and E_{k} by E_{s} . The final system then writes \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{t} \displaystyle= \displaystyle F-\epsilon (8a) \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{\epsilon} \displaystyle= \displaystyle C_{k}\frac{\epsilon}{E_{t}}\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{t}\left(1+\gamma\frac{F}{\epsilon}\right)-\gamma\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{F} (8b) \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{s} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(\left(\frac{\epsilon}{\nu}\right)^{1/2}-\chi\right)E_{s} (8c) \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{\chi} \displaystyle= \displaystyle C_{s}\frac{\chi}{E_{s}}\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{s}, (8d) where C_{s} is a third model parameter to be determined. The system Eqs. ( 8 ) is one of the main result of the present paper. It consists of four coupled ODEs which allows the kinetic and surface energy to be predicted together with the kinetic and surface energy dissipation/destruction rates. II.3 Solutions for the linearized system Linearizing Eqs ( 8 ) allows the transfer function, i.e. the gain and phase of the different variables with respect to the gain and frequency of the forcing to be predicted. For this purpose, we first write every variable X\in\{E_{k},E_{s},E_{t},\epsilon,\chi,F\} as \displaystyle X=X^{0}+X^{\prime}=X^{0}\left[1+\alpha_{X}\sin\left(\omega t+\phi_{X}\right)\right] (9) where X^{0} is the steady state value and the prime denotes the perturbation around the base state. The forcing is periodic with a frequency \omega=2\pi/T_{f} where T_{f} is the forcing period. At steady state, in addition to F^{0}=\epsilon^{0} , we also have \chi^{0}=\sqrt{\epsilon^{0}/\nu} . The linearized system writes: \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E_{t}^{\prime}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle F^{\prime}-\epsilon^{\prime} (10a) \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E_{s}^{\prime}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle A_{s}^{-1}\left(\frac{1}{2}\chi^{0}\epsilon^{\prime}-\epsilon^{0}\chi^{\prime}\right)~~~~~~\textrm{where}~A_{s}=\frac{\epsilon^{0}}{E_{s}^{0}}=\tau_{s}^{-1}~~~[s^{-1}] (10b) \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{\epsilon^{\prime}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle A_{t}\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E_{t}^{\prime}}-\gamma\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{F^{\prime}}~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~\textrm{where}~A_{t}=\frac{C_{k}(1+\gamma)}{\tau_{k}+\tau_{s}}~~~[s^{-1}] (10c) \displaystyle\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{\chi^{\prime}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle A_{\chi}\frac{\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E_{s}^{\prime}}}{E_{s}^{0}}~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~\textrm{where}~A_{\chi}=C_{s}\chi^{0}=C_{s}{\tau_{\eta}}^{-1}~~~[s^{-1}] (10d) Note the appearance of three inverse time-scales, A_{t} , A_{s} and A_{\chi} which are related to the kinetic and surface energy time-scales \tau_{\{k,s\}}=E_{\{k,s\}}^{0}/\epsilon^{0} , and the Kolmogorov time scale \tau_{\eta}=(\nu/\epsilon^{0})^{1/2} . We now write perturbations in complex harmonic form X^{\prime}=\mathcal{R}\{\widehat{X}e^{i\omega t}\} . The real part is noted \mathcal{R} and the complex Fourier mode at frequency \omega is \widehat{X}e^{i\omega t} . The hat denotes the complex amplitude, viz \widehat{X}=|\widehat{X}|e^{i\phi_{X}} with \phi_{X} being the phase. The linearized system then writes \displaystyle i\omega\widehat{E_{t}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\widehat{F}-\widehat{\epsilon} (11a) \displaystyle i\omega\widehat{E_{s}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle A_{s}^{-1}\left(\frac{1}{2}\chi^{0}\widehat{\epsilon}-\epsilon^{0}\widehat{\chi}\right) (11b) \displaystyle\widehat{\epsilon} \displaystyle= \displaystyle A_{t}\widehat{E_{t}}-\gamma\widehat{F} (11c) \displaystyle\widehat{\chi} \displaystyle= \displaystyle A_{\chi}\frac{\widehat{E_{s}}}{E_{s}^{0}}, (11d) which can be solved to obtain \widehat{E_{t}},~\widehat{\epsilon},~\widehat{E_{s}} , \widehat{E_{k}} and \widehat{\chi} : \displaystyle\widehat{E_{t}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{1+\gamma}{A_{t}(1+i\omega^{*})}\widehat{F} (12a) \displaystyle\widehat{E_{s}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{1}{2A_{s}C_{s}}\frac{1-\gamma i\omega^{*}}{(1+i\omega^{\dagger})(1+i\omega^{*})}\widehat{F} (12b) \displaystyle\widehat{E_{k}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{\widehat{F}}{1+i\omega^{*}}\left(\frac{1+\gamma}{A_{t}}-\frac{1-\gamma i\omega^{*}}{2A_{s}C_{s}(1+i\omega^{\dagger})}\right) (12c) \displaystyle\widehat{\epsilon} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{1-\gamma i\omega^{*}}{1+i\omega^{*}}\widehat{F} (12d) \displaystyle\widehat{\chi} \displaystyle= \displaystyle A_{\chi}\frac{\widehat{E_{s}}}{E_{s}^{0}}, (12e) where \omega^{*}=\omega/A_{t} and \omega^{\dagger}=\omega/A_{\chi} . One can then derive the modulus \alpha_{X}=|\widehat{X}|/X^{0} : \displaystyle\alpha_{E_{t}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{\alpha_{F}}{C_{k}\sqrt{1+(\omega^{*})^{2}}} (13a) \displaystyle\alpha_{E_{s}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\alpha_{\epsilon}~\frac{1}{2C_{s}}\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+(\omega^{\dagger})^{2}}} (13b) \displaystyle\alpha_{E_{k}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{\alpha_{E_{t}}\alpha_{Es}}{\alpha_{\epsilon}}\frac{A_{k}C_{k}}{A_{s}A_{t}}\sqrt{\big(2A_{s}C_{s}(1+\gamma)-A_{t}\big)^{2}+\big(2A_{s}C_{s}(1+\gamma)\omega^{\dagger}+A_{t}\gamma\,\omega^{*}\big)^{2}} (13c) \displaystyle\alpha_{\epsilon} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\alpha_{E_{t}}~C_{k}\sqrt{1+(\gamma\omega^{*})^{2}} (13d) \displaystyle\alpha_{\chi} \displaystyle= \displaystyle C_{s}~\alpha_{E_{s}} (13e) together with the phase \phi_{X} \displaystyle\phi_{E_{t}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-\arctan(\omega^{*}) (14a) \displaystyle\phi_{E_{s}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\phi_{\epsilon}-\arctan(\omega^{\dagger}) (14b) \displaystyle\phi_{E_{k}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\phi_{E_{t}}+\arctan(Z) (14c) \displaystyle\phi_{\epsilon} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\phi_{E_{t}}-\arctan(\gamma\omega^{*}) (14d) \displaystyle\phi_{\chi} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\phi_{E_{s}}, (14e) where Z=\frac{\omega^{\dagger}+\gamma\,\omega^{*}}{2A_{s}C_{s}\frac{1+\gamma}{A_{t}}\big(1+(\omega^{\dagger})^{2}\big)-\big(1+\gamma\,\omega^{*}\,\omega^{\dagger}\big)}. (15) Eqs. ( 13 ) and ( 14 ) provide estimates for the transfer function between F and the other variables. It predicts that, in multiphase turbulence, the evolution of total energy E_{t}=E_{k}+E_{s} and the dissipation rate \epsilon is qualitatively similar to that in the original (single-phase) Ka-Pi-bara model 4 ; 6 . Note however that the parameters C_{k},\gamma and hence A_{t} can possibly differ between single and multiphase turbulence, resulting in quantitative differences in gain and phase shift. The model thus predicts that in multiphase turbulence, non-equilibrium effects translate into a time delay between the total energy E_{t} (and possibly E_{k} ) and the dissipation rate \epsilon . The model further shows that \phi_{E_{s}}=\phi_{\chi} , i.e. surface energy and its destruction are in phase. This is not surprising given that the surface energy is here modelled in analogy with the kinetic energy in the classic k-\epsilon model. It thus predicts that E_{s} and \chi are in equilibrium, indicating the absence of a surface energy cascade. Eqs. ( 14 ) also predicts the phase shift between the dissipation \epsilon and the surface energy E_{s} . The latter is related to \omega/A_{\chi}=\omega\tau_{\eta}/C_{s} . Since \tau_{\eta} is increasingly small with increasing Reynolds number, we expect \omega^{\dagger}\to 0 when the Reynolds is large. This framework then predicts that E_{s} and \epsilon tend to be synchronized ( \phi_{E_{s}}\to\phi_{\epsilon} ) and proportional to each other ( \alpha_{E_{s}}\to\alpha_{\epsilon}/2/C_{s} ) at sufficiently large Reynolds number. The amplitude of E_{s} is then inversely proportional to C_{s} . If E_{s} tends to be synchronized with \epsilon , then \chi should also be synchronized with \epsilon . Note that this is valid only asymptotically and in the linear regime, since if \chi and \epsilon were synchronized, then P-\chi=0 . For the kinetic energy, in the limit of large Reynolds numbers \omega^{\dagger}\to 0 , we obtain \lim_{\omega^{\dagger}\to 0}\phi_{E_{k}}=\phi_{E_{t}}+\arctan(\gamma\omega^{\ddagger})~~~~\textrm{where~}\omega^{\ddagger}=\frac{\omega}{2A_{s}C_{s}(1+\gamma)-1}, (16) which gives a slightly more compact formulation for the gain and phase shift of kinetic energy. III Numerical database Table 1: Description of the numerical database. To ease readability, it is organised in five distinct sets as described in the leftmost column. The case Re=1612,~We=12.5,~\alpha=25.0\%,~T_{f}=1.0 is repeated for clarity. Re We \alpha T_{f} N R_{\lambda} \tau_{k} \tau_{s} C_{k} \gamma C_{s} A_{t} A_{s} A_{\chi} single-phase 645 - - 1.0 128 43 0.65 - 0.66 0.19 - 1.20 - - Reynolds 1612 - - 1.0 256 72 0.70 - 0.31 0.23 - 0.54 - - number 4166 - - 1.0 512 120 0.72 - 0.10 0.35 - 0.19 - - multiphase 1612 8 \frac{1}{3} 25% 1.0 256 60 0.58 0.36 0.78 0.20 1.48 1.00 2.76 59.54 Weber 1612 12.5 25% 1.0 256 58 0.56 0.35 0.72 0.19 1.32 0.94 2.89 53.10 number 1612 25.0 25% 1.0 256 57 0.55 0.29 0.77 0.24 1.56 1.13 3.42 62.58 multiphase 1612 12.5 12.5% 1.0 256 64 0.62 0.22 0.62 0.23 2.13 0.91 4.51 85.53 volume 1612 12.5 25% 1.0 256 58 0.56 0.35 0.72 0.19 1.32 0.94 2.89 53.10 fraction 1612 12.5 50% 1.0 256 52 0.50 0.43 0.84 0.20 1.12 1.08 2.33 45.16 multiphase 645 12.5 25% 1.0 128 32 0.49 0.36 0.91 0.17 1.24 1.25 2.77 31.36 Reynolds 1612 12.5 25% 1.0 256 58 0.56 0.35 0.72 0.19 1.32 0.94 2.89 53.10 number 4166 12.5 25% 1.0 512 99 0.59 0.32 0.53 0.27 1.44 0.74 3.13 92.76 multiphase 1612 12.5 25% 0.75 256 57 0.55 0.34 0.43 0.12 1.26 0.54 2.93 50.58 forcing 1612 12.5 25% 1.0 256 58 0.56 0.35 0.72 0.19 1.32 0.94 2.89 53.10 period 1612 12.5 25% 1.5 256 57 0.55 0.35 1.26 0.36 1.58 1.92 2.88 63.39 The model is tested against numerical simulations of homogeneous isotropic turbulence in a cubic periodic domain. The code archer , the numerical procedure and configuration, have been detailed by 31 and references therein. We use the stochastic forcing of 15 as implemented by 31 , where the amplitude is adjusted at every time step in order to have F=F^{0}(1+\alpha_{F}\sin(\omega t)) (17) F_{0} is set to 1 and \alpha_{F} to 50%. No noticeable changes were observed for different \alpha_{F} (not shown). Note that the forcing of 15 comes with a correlation timescale. We found (not shown) that varying this timescale by a factor 20 did not change the results. The domain width is L=1 , which allows us to define a characteristic velocity U=(F^{0}L)^{1/3}=1 . We set the same density and same viscosity in both phase. The Reynolds is then defined by Re=UL/\nu\equiv 1/\nu and the Weber number is We=\rho U^{2}L/\sigma\equiv 1/\sigma . Assuming the same density in both phase is a rather valid assumption for liquid-liquid emulsions. In addition, it simplifies the analysis as it reduces the parameter space, and it avoids reopening the controversy over whether density jumps give rise to the so-called baropycnal work, which has been claimed to provide an additional contribution to kinetic energy transfer by 31 ; 24 . For all simulations, the viscosity \nu is prescribed in order to guarantee a resolution \eta/\Delta_{x}=(\nu^{3}/F^{0})^{1/4}=1 , where \eta is the Kolmogorov microscale. With F^{0}=\epsilon^{0}=1 and a domain of size L=1 discretized with N mesh cells in each direction, this yields \nu\equiv N^{-4/3} . The simulations are run for 40 forcing periods. Four periods are necessary to reach a quasi-limit cycle. We then gather statistics over the next 36 periods (only 30 periods for the two highest Reynolds number cases to be described below). All results are analysed using phase averages. Statistical convergence was within 5%. Here, we study the effect of the Reynolds and Weber numbers, together with the effect of volume fraction (the volume of a given phase with respect to the entire simulation volume) and of the forcing period. The database is described in Table 1 . It is organised in five subsets: 1. the first three cases correspond to single phase flows at different Reynolds numbers ( Re=645,~1612,~4166 ) varying \nu=\{15.5,~6.2,~2.4\}\times 10^{-4} . The forcing period is kept constant T_{f}=1.0 . 2. The next three cases are for multiphase flows at different Weber numbers, varying \sigma=0.04,~0.08,~0.12 ( We=25,~12.5,~8\frac{1}{3} ), at constant forcing period T_{f}=1.0 , volume fraction \alpha=25\% and Re=1612 . 3. The three next cases correspond to different volume fractions \alpha=12.5,~25,~50\% , at constant forcing period T_{f}=1.0 , We=12.5 and Re=1612 . 4. The next three cases correspond to different Reynolds numbers, varying \nu=\{15.5,~6.2,~2.4\}\times 10^{-4} ( Re=645,~1612,~4166 ), keeping the forcing period T_{f}=1.0 , the volume fraction \alpha=25\% and We=12.5 constant. 5. The last subset employs different forcing period ( T_{f}=0.75,~1.0,~1.5 ) at constant \alpha=25\% , We=12.5 and Re=1612 . Table 1 reports the values for \tau_{k}=E_{k}^{0}/\epsilon^{0} , \tau_{s}=E_{s}^{0}/\epsilon^{0} and R_{\lambda}=E_{k}^{0}\sqrt{20/3\nu\epsilon^{0}} (recall \epsilon^{0}=F^{0}=1.0 ). Note that we refer to C_{k},\gamma,C_{s} as “model parameter” rather than “model constant” since these values are very unlikely to be universal. This reflects the unavoidable trade-off when reducing the full set of multiscale, nonlinear partial differential equations to a simple system of ordinary equations. The objective here is solely to evaluate whether the proposed simplified model can replicate the observed dynamics and to extract qualitative understanding from it. Hence, the model parameters are systematically adjusted for each case using a simple least-square fitting method comparing the numerical data to the linearized solutions. The procedure minimizes a global residual constructed from the normalized errors in E_{k},~E_{s},~\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{k},~\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{s},~\epsilon and \chi . The values for the model parameters C_{k},\gamma,C_{s} together with A_{t},~A_{s},~A_{\chi} appearing in the linearized solutions are reported in Table 1 . Table 1 reveals that the values for C_{k},~\gamma,~C_{s} are clearly not constant. In contrast, some trends in their evolution with respect to the flow parameters are discernible. It appears that C_{k} systematically decreases when the Reynolds number increases. It is also larger in multiphase than in single phase flows, it increases with \alpha but does not seem to vary with We . The parameter \gamma increases with Re and is slightly smaller in multiphase turbulence compared to the single phase case. For the newly introduced parameter C_{s} which comes out from the evolution equation for \chi , it increases with Re and decreases with \alpha . From the linearized solution of the system, it follows that the relevant quantities for predicting the dynamics are A_{t},~A_{s},~A_{\chi} . Table 1 first indicates that for most cases, A_{\chi}\gg 1 suggesting that the assumption \omega^{\dagger}\to 0 is rather well justified. Hence, we expect \epsilon and E_{s} to be in phase or close to it. We then should have that \epsilon and \accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{s} are lagged by \pi/2 , i.e. the conversion is maximum when kinetic (or total) energy dissipation fluctuation is zero. The inverse of the characteristic timescale for the total energy A_{t} decreases quite substantially when Re increases but does not seem to vary much with the other flow parameter \alpha,~We . What is more surprising is the evolution of C_{k},\gamma together with A_{t} with the forcing period as we would have expected these values to be intrinsic quantities of the flow, but not of the forcing. An explanation for this trend is proposed at the end of the results section § IV . (a) (b) (c) (d) Figure 1: Predictions using the k – \epsilon model (top panel, (a, b)) and the Ka-Pi-bara model (bottom panel, (c, d)) in single phase flows. Symbols represent the numerical simulations while the lines corresponds to the model. Full lines represent solutions of the non-linear system while dashed lines correspond to solutions of the linearized system. The colours from dark to light represents an increasing Reynolds number R_{\lambda}=43,~72,~120 . The kinetic energy E_{k} is normalised by F^{0}\alpha_{F}T_{f} while the terms of its balance equation are normalised by F^{0}\alpha_{F} . IV Results IV.1 Single-phase flows We first analyse the results obtained with the k – \epsilon and Ka-Pi-bara models for single-phase flows. Figure 1 presents the results for Re=645,~1612,~4166 , corresponding to R_{\lambda}=43,~72,~120 . Panels (a, c) show the phase-averaged kinetic energy E_{k}^{\prime} , while panels (b, d) display the different terms of the phase-averaged kinetic energy budget, F^{\prime},~\accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}^{\prime}_{k},~\epsilon^{\prime} . The simulation results are indicated by symbols. The curves correspond to the solutions of the nonlinear system (solid lines) and of the linearized system (dashed lines), which are almost indistinguishable. This means that, within the investigated regimes, non-linearities have a limited impact. Numerical results indicate that E_{k}^{\prime} and \epsilon^{\prime} are increasingly lagged when Re increases. This behaviour, known as non-equilibrium effects cannot be reproduced by the k – \epsilon model (Figure 1 (a, b)) which predicts that both quantities are in phase. As a consequence, the departures between observations and the classical k – \epsilon model are quite significant and increase with Re . In particular, the predicted amplitude for the fluctuations of \epsilon are drastically underestimated. In contrast, the Ka-Pi-bara model accurately reproduces the phase lag between E_{k} and \epsilon which is encoded in the parameter \gamma . The latter increases with Re (see Table 1 ) consistently with observations. Irrespective of the Reynolds number, the predictions agree very nicely with numerical observations. Therefore, in what follows, only the results of the Ka-Pi-bara model will be discussed. IV.2 Multiphase flows IV.2.1 Effect of Weber number (a) (b) Figure 2: Effect of Weber number. From dark to light : We=8.33,~12.5,~25 . Panel (a) shows E_{k}^{\prime},~E_{s}^{\prime} (normalized by F^{0}\alpha_{F}T_{f} ) and panel (b) represents F^{\prime},~\dot{E}_{k}^{\prime},~\dot{E}_{s}^{\prime},~\epsilon (normalized by F^{0}\alpha_{F} ). Results for single-phase flow at same Re are displayed with filled symbols. We now proceed with the analysis of multiphase turbulence. We start by exploring the effect of Weber number in Fig. 2 . In the range of We investigated, the surface energy reservoir E_{s}^{0} represent about roughly 60% of the kinetic energy reservoir (see Table 1 ), i.e. nearly 35% of the total energy. Interestingly, this proportion does not vary much with the Weber number. Since E_{s}^{0}=\sigma A^{0} , this means that decreasing the surface tension is compensated by an increase of the surface area density A^{0} so that the surface energy is constant. Similarly, phase-averaged fluctuations of surface energy E_{s}^{\prime} and E_{k}^{\prime} (Fig. 2 (a)) do not seem to be influenced by the Weber number. All curves collapse rather nicely, and the same observation applies to the different terms of the energy balance (Fig. 2 (b)). The model accurately reproduces observations. In particular, we find that E_{s}^{\prime} and \epsilon^{\prime} are almost in phase as anticipated by the analysis of the linearized system for \omega^{\dagger}\to 0 . Overall, the results indicate that fluctuations of E_{k}^{\prime} precedes fluctuations of E_{s}^{\prime} which is more dynamically related to \epsilon^{\prime} . Comparing these results to single-phase flows at same Re indicates that the peak of kinetic energy and dissipation in multiphase flows appears earlier than in single-phase flows. This is a consequence of the kinetic energy being converted into the surface energy reservoir. It is often stated that the presence of an interface increases the amount of kinetic energy dissipation. Here, we note that the presence of the interface does not alter much the amplitude of the phase-averaged dissipation which appears to be roughly the same in single-phase or multiphase flows. This observation is likely to break down when the two phases have significantly different densities ( 14 ; 31 , see e.g.) . Again, one cannot distinguish between the non-linear and the linearized solutions. This suggests again that non-linearities do not play too much role. Both predictions show very good agreement with the numerical results as they correctly capture the dynamical behaviour of energy conversion in multiphase flows. Note again the advantage of using the Ka-Pi-Bara model compared to the classical k-\epsilon model. Indeed, without the introduction of the non-equilibrium constant \gamma , the phase shift between E_{k}^{\prime} and \epsilon^{\prime} would not have been captured and hence, the dynamics of E_{s}^{\prime} would not have been correctly represented. IV.2.2 Effect of volume fraction (a) (b) Figure 3: Effect of the volume fraction. From dark to light : \alpha=12.5,~25,~50\% . Panel (a) shows E_{k}^{\prime},~E_{s}^{\prime} (normalized by F^{0}\alpha_{F}T_{f} ) and panel (b) represents F^{\prime},~\dot{E}_{k}^{\prime},~\dot{E}_{s}^{\prime},~\epsilon (normalized by F^{0}\alpha_{F} ). Results for single-phase flow at same Re are displayed with filled symbols. In contrast with variations of the Weber number, changes in \alpha lead to different proportions between kinetic and surface energy in the system. Table 1 indicates that E_{s}^{0} is multiplied by roughly 2 between \alpha=12.5\% and \alpha=50\% while E_{k}^{0} is slightly decreasing. At \alpha=50\% , E_{k}^{0} and E_{s}^{0} appear in comparable proportion. Similarly, when \alpha increases, the amplitude of the phase-averaged surface energy E_{s}^{\prime} increases, while the amplitude of E_{k}^{\prime} decreases (Fig. 3 (a)). The amplitude of E_{s}^{\prime} is encoded in the parameter C_{s} whose value drives the amount of surface energy destruction \chi , with respect to surface energy production P=(\epsilon/\nu)^{1/2} . Table 1 indicates that the parameter C_{s} decreases by almost a factor 2 between \alpha=12.5 and 50% which corresponds to roughly the same ratio on the amplitude of E_{s}^{\prime} on Fig. 3 (a). Speculatively, C_{s} could exhibit greater universality when parameterized by \alpha or E_{s}^{0}/E_{k}^{0} . It is observed that the phase for the surface energy signals does not depend on \alpha (Fig. 3 (a)). This behaviour is anticipated by the model, which predicts that the peak should coincide with that of \epsilon^{\prime} (recall that A_{\chi}\gg 1 ). This is confirmed by observing the evolution of \epsilon^{\prime} (Fig. 3 (b)) which does not vary much, either in amplitude or in phase, with \alpha . However, the kinetic energy signals E_{k}^{\prime} are systematically shifted toward earlier times as the volume fraction increases. This indicates that when a larger amount of surface energy is present into the system, the conversion of kinetic energy into surface energy is obviously enhanced and as a consequence, kinetic energy reaches its peak earlier and with a lower amplitude. A contrario, the signals for small \alpha approaches the one corresponding to single phase flows. The influence of the interface and energy conversion processes on the energy balance might become negligible for \alpha<10\% . IV.2.3 Effect of Reynolds number We now explore the effect of Reynolds number, while the volume fraction \alpha , Weber number and forcing period are kept constant. Table 1 indicates that the Reynolds number does not influence much the proportion between E_{s}^{0} and E_{k}^{0} , their ratio remains roughly constant at a value of about 60%. As already observed in single-phase flows, non-equilibrium effects, i.e. the phase lag between E_{k}^{\prime} (fig. 4 (a)) and \epsilon^{\prime} (fig. 4 (b)) become more pronounced as Re increases. This is nicely reproduced by the Ka-Pi-bara model as the non-equilibrium parameter \gamma/A_{t} increases by almost a factor 3 between the two extreme Reynolds number values (see Table 1 ). A careful examination of Figure 4 indicates that a phase lag between E_{s}^{\prime} and \epsilon^{\prime} is perceptible. The latter is substantial at the lowest Reynolds number but becomes negligible as Re increases. This trend is nicely reproduced by the model through the parameter C_{\chi}\sim\tau_{\eta}^{-1} which increases in such a way that \omega^{\dagger}\to 0 when Re increases (see Table 1 ). With appropriate values for the parameters C_{k},\gamma,C_{s} , the model captures nicely the observed dynamics of the different variables. For instance, it reproduces the slight increase of kinetic energy E_{k}^{\prime} with Re , as was also observed in single-phase flows (see Fig. 1 ). It also predicts correctly that the amplitude of E_{s}^{\prime} does not vary much with Re and the same applies to \epsilon^{\prime} . (a) (b) Figure 4: Effect of the Reynolds number. From dark to light : Re=645,~1612,~4166 . Panel (a) shows E_{k}^{\prime},~E_{s}^{\prime} (normalized by F^{0}\alpha_{F}T_{f} ) and panel (b) represents F^{\prime},~\dot{E}_{k}^{\prime},~\dot{E}_{s}^{\prime},~\epsilon^{\prime} (normalized by F^{0}\alpha_{F} ). IV.2.4 Effect of forcing period (a) (b) Figure 5: Effect of the forcing period. From dark to light : T_{f}=0.75,~1.0,~1.5 . Panel (a) shows E_{k}^{\prime},~E_{s}^{\prime} (normalized by F^{0}\alpha_{F}T_{f} ) and panel (b) represents F^{\prime},~\dot{E}_{k}^{\prime},~\dot{E}_{s}^{\prime},~\epsilon^{\prime} (normalized by F^{0}\alpha_{F} ). We now vary the forcing period T_{f} . The other parameters are kept constant so that the proportion between surface and kinetic energy remains the same (see Table 1 ). Fig. 5 (a,b) indicates that when T_{f} decreases (increasing \omega ), the amplitude of \epsilon^{\prime} decreases. We can thus expect \accentset{\mbox{\large.}}{E}_{k}^{\prime}\to F^{\prime} in the limit of small T_{f} (large \omega ), i.e. in the frozen regime. A contrario, the amplitude of \epsilon^{\prime} continuously increases as T_{f} increases. Hence, the quasi steady-state limit \epsilon^{\prime}\to F^{\prime} is likely to be recovered for large T_{f} (small \omega ). In this respect, the dynamical behaviour of periodically multiphase turbulence is qualitatively similar to the single-phase case. The amplitude of E_{s}^{\prime} does not increase in same proportion as \epsilon^{\prime} . This translates in a substantial increase of the parameter C_{s} when T_{f} increases (see Table 1 ). Irrespective of T_{f} , the value of A_{\chi} remains sufficiently large for \epsilon^{\prime} and E_{s}^{\prime} to evolve almost in phase. Again, this shows that the dynamics of surface energy is coupled to the dynamics of the kinetic energy dissipation rate \epsilon . Once the parameters C_{k},~\gamma,~C_{s} adjusted, the model reproduces the dynamics of each variable fairly well. It is quite surprising however that these parameters change with the forcing frequency. It would have been much more natural to expect these parameters to be intrinsic to the flow with no relation with the properties of the external energy input. To explain this behaviour, we should recall that the Ka-Pi-bara model was derived from a two-scale decomposition, distinguishing, on the one hand, the large scales whose dynamics are driven by the forcing and energy transfer and, on the other hand, the small-scales where only the energy transfer and dissipation operates. This effectively results in the appearance of two characteristic timescales, i.e. A_{t}^{-1} , which appears in the expression for \widehat{E_{k}} (the large scales), and \gamma A_{t}^{-1} which appears in the expression for \widehat{\epsilon} (the small-scales). But clearly, these two timescales are not independent, i.e. the timescale of the small-scales is \gamma times the timescale of the large scales. This is likely to cause C_{k},\gamma (and eventually C_{s} ) to adapt in order to reproduce the correct dynamics. One could have anticipated this since the Ka-Pi-bara model was derived hypothesizing that the small-scales rapidly (=instantaneously) adapt to the large scales (see hypothesis (1) in 4 ), i.e. E_{k}^{>}=\gamma E_{k}^{<} . This suggests that the performance of the Ka-Pi-bara can be further improved by introducing a two-timescale decomposition alongside the two-scale decomposition. This will unfortunately result in additional ODEs and hence additional model parameters. V Conclusions This paper examines how conversions between kinetic and surface energy influence the overall energy balance of multiphase turbulence. A time-periodic forcing is imposed to assess the cycle connecting energy injection, conversion, and dissipation. We use phase-averages to analyse data from numerical simulations spanning different Reynolds and Weber numbers, volume fractions, and forcing frequencies. A model, viewed as a generalization of the k – \epsilon model to non-equilibrium multiphase turbulence, is proposed to reproduce and explain the observed dynamics. To derive this model, we first propose to reformulate the Ka-Pi-bara model in terms of E_{t}=E_{s}+E_{k} , exploiting the analogy between the balance equation for E_{t} in multiphase flows and the kinetic energy in single-phase flows. The evolution of surface energy is decomposed into a production term, related to the Kolmogorov strain rate, and a destruction term. Due to limited knowledge of the latter, we introduce an evolution equation, written in analogy with the kinetic energy dissipation rate in the standard k – \epsilon model. The proposed system then consists of four coupled ODEs for E_{t},~\epsilon,~E_{s},~\chi , respectively, featuring three parameters C_{k},~\gamma,~C_{s} . The proposed model is then linearized in order to highlight the relevant timescales of the system and to get predictions of how the different variables respond to the energy input. The present work yields some outcomes that are listed below. We find that solutions of the linearized and non-linear systems do not reveal substantial differences, suggesting that non-linearities are weak. Furthermore, once the model parameters adjusted, the predictions agree satisfactorily with the numerical observations. Trends in the evolution of optimal values for C_{k},~\gamma,~C_{s} with respect to the control parameters indicate their non-universality. Nonetheless, the dependence of C_{k} and \gamma to Re and \alpha appears potentially parametrisable, as does that of C_{s} with respect to \alpha . If such parametrizations were to be confirmed, some more general predictions for the energy balance in multiphase turbulence could be obtained, with potential applications in various engineering problems. The linearized solutions indicate that fluctuations of E_{s} and its destruction rate are synchronized. The surface energy is thus in equilibrium, underscoring the absence of a surface energy cascade. E_{s} and \chi further appear to be synchronized with the kinetic energy dissipation at sufficiently large Re . However, there is a substantial time lag between E_{k} (or E_{t} ) and its dissipation \epsilon , a key feature of non-equilibrium turbulence that is well captured by the Ka-Pi-Bara model. A systematic exploration of the parameter space shows that the Weber number does not significantly affect the base flow state or the fluctuations about it. This implies a compensation between surface tension and surface area. The effect of volume fraction is much more perceptible. When the two phases are in equal proportion \alpha=50\% , fluctuations associated with the surface energy are maximum. For iso-density fluid flows, the influence of an interface on the energy balance might become negligible for \alpha<10\% . An increase in Reynolds number leads to a larger phase lag between E_{k} and \epsilon , indicating a stronger influence of non-equilibrium effects due to the increased separation between large and small scales. The surface energy is much less influenced by the effect of Reynolds number, here again suggesting the absence of a cascade for the surface energy. Varying the forcing frequency reveals that the model can still adapt, albeit at the cost of adjusting the parameters C_{k},~\gamma,~C_{s} . This observation suggests that the model may lack a timescale decomposition, which reflects that the small scales do not instantaneously adapt to the large scales. Acknowledgements. The members of the archer team, viz. J-C. Brändle de Motta, B. Duret, T. Ménard, A. Poux, F.X. Demoulin are gratefully acknowledged. This work has also benefited from discussions with R. Zamansky and W. Bos. Calculations were performed using the computing resources of CRIANN (Normandy, France), under the project 2018002.