The Carathéodory metric on Teichmüller space of genus two surface Kejie Lin and Weixu Su Abstract . Let 𝒯 g , n \mathcal{T}_{g,n} be the Teichmüller space of Riemann surfaces of genus g g with n n punctures. It is conjectured that the Teichmüller and Carathéodory metrics agree on a Teichmüller disk if and only if all the zeros of the corresponding holomorphic quadratic differential are of even order. The conjecture was proved by Gekhtman and Markovic for 𝒯 0 , 5 ≅ 𝒯 1 , 2 \mathcal{T}_{0,5}\cong\mathcal{T}_{1,2} . We confirm the conjecture for 𝒯 2 , 0 ≅ 𝒯 0 , 6 \mathcal{T}_{2,0}\cong\mathcal{T}_{0,6} . 1. Introduction Let \mathcal{T}_{g,n} be the Teichmüller space of Riemann surfaces of genus g with n marked points. Throughout this paper, we assume that 3g-3+n\geq 2 . The Teichmüller space \mathcal{T}_{g,n} is the (orbifold) universal cover of the moduli space of Riemann surfaces \mathcal{M}_{g,n} and is naturally a complex manifold of dimension 3g-3+n . It is known that \mathcal{T}_{g,n} can be realized as a bounded domain in \mathbb{C}^{3g-3+n} , by the Bers embedding [ 3 ] . Let \mathbb{H} be the upper half-plane, equipped with the Poincaré metric d_{\mathbb{H}}=\frac{|dz|}{2\operatorname{Im}z}. The Kobayashi metric d_{\mathcal{K}} on \mathcal{T}_{g,n} is the largest metric so that every holomorphic map f:\mathbb{H}\rightarrow\mathcal{T}_{g,n} is nonexpanding. Royden [ 13 ] proved that the Kobayashi metric on \mathcal{T}_{g,n} coincides with the Teichmüller metric d_{\mathcal{T}} . Furthermore, the Teichmüller metric is not homogeneous at any point and its isometry group is essentially the mapping class group. Another natural metric on \mathcal{T}_{g,n} satisfying the Schwarz-Pick inequality is the Carathéodory metric , which can be defined as the smallest metric so that every holomorphic map F:\mathcal{T}_{g,n}\rightarrow\mathbb{H} is nonexpanding. Let d_{\mathcal{C}} denote the Carathéodory metric on \mathcal{T}_{g,n} . By the Schwarz Lemma, the inequality d_{\mathcal{C}}\leq d_{\mathcal{T}} holds on \mathcal{T}_{g,n} . A longstanding open problem is whether the two metrics d_{\mathcal{T}} and d_{\mathcal{C}} agree on \mathcal{T}_{g,n} . Recently, Markovic [ 11 ] solved the problem. Teichmüller disks, also known as complex geodesics, are holomorphic isometric embeddings of the hyperbolic plane into Teichmüller space. There is a unique Teichmüller disc through any pair of distinct points in \mathcal{T}_{g,n} . Every Teichmüller disk is generated by a non-zero holomorphic quadratic differential \phi , with at most simple poles at the marked points. Let \tau^{\phi}:\mathbb{H}\rightarrow\mathcal{T}_{g,n} be a Teichmüller disk. Kra [ 10 ] proved that the two metrics d_{\mathcal{T}} and d_{\mathcal{C}} agree on \tau^{\phi} if all the zeros of \phi are of even order, see also McMullen [ 12 , Theorem 4.1] . Remark 1 . Note that if a holomorphic quadratic differential \phi vanishes at a marked point (puncture), then it is not necessary to require that it vanish of even order. Markovic [ 11 ] established a criterion that says when the two metrics d_{\mathcal{T}} and d_{\mathcal{C}} agree on a Teichmüller disk. Then he used this criterion to show that d_{\mathcal{T}} and d_{\mathcal{C}} disagree on certain Teichmüller disk in \mathcal{T}_{0,5} . Since there exists a holomorphic and isometric embedding of \mathcal{T}_{0,5} into \mathcal{T}_{g,n} , we have d_{\mathcal{T}}\neq d_{\mathcal{C}} on \mathcal{T}_{g,n} . An application of Markovic’s result is to prove a folklore conjecture of Siu that the Teichmüller space is not biholomorphic to any bounded convex domain in \mathbb{C}^{3g-3+n} . Note that Gupta and Seshadri [ 7 , Theorem 1.1.] proved a related result that the Teichmüller space is not biholomorphically equivalent to any bounded domain in \mathbb{C}^{3g-3+n} which is strictly locally convex at one boundary point. A remaining problem is to classify Teichmüller disks for which d_{\mathcal{T}}=d_{\mathcal{C}} . This is equivalent to classifying Teichmüller disks that are holomorphic retracts of the Teichmüller space. Gekhtman and Markovic [ 6 ] made the following conjecture. Conjecture 1.1 . A Teichmüller disk is a holomorphic retract if and only if it is generated by a holomorphic quadratic differential all of whose zeros are of even order. Gekhtman and Markovic [ 6 , Theorem 1.2] proved the above conjecture for \mathcal{T}_{0,5}\cong\mathcal{T}_{1,2} . In this paper, we confirm the conjecture for \mathcal{T}_{0,6}\cong\mathcal{T}_{2,0} , which is of complex dimension 3 . Theorem 1.2 . Let \tau^{\phi} be a Teichmüller disk in \mathcal{T}_{2,0} . The Teichmüller metric and Carathéodory metric agree on \tau^{\phi} if and only if \phi is a quadratic differential all of whose zeros are of even order. Equivalently, we show Theorem 1.3 . Let \tau^{\phi} be a Teichmüller disk in \mathcal{T}_{0,6} . The Teichmüller metric and Carathéodory metric agree on \tau^{\phi} if and only if either \phi is a quadratic differential with no odd-order zeros, or \phi is a quadratic differential with a simple zero located at a marked point. The proof of Theorem 1.3 follows the strategy developed by Gekhtman and Markovic [ 11 , 6 ] . Due to Markovic’s criterion, it suffices to classify Jenkins-Strebel differentials with at least one odd-order zero. In Section 3 , by applying cylinder deformations or by interchanging the vertical and horizontal foliations if necessary, we prove that Theorem 1.3 can be reduced to the case when \phi is a staircase. Assume that \phi is a staircase surface and that the corresponding Teichmüller disk \tau^{\phi} admits a holomoprhic retraction, say F:\mathcal{T}_{0,6}\to\mathbb{H} . In Section 4 , we use the Schwarz-Christoffel formula to compute F on certain smooth paths of \mathcal{T}_{0,6} . The computation is explicit and it shows that F fails to be C^{2} -smooth, which leads to a contradiction. Our computational method generalizes Markovic’s previous work on L -shaped pillowcases [ 11 ] . Remark 2 . By a result of Apisa and Wright [ 1 , Corollary 1.3] , Conjecture 1.1 can be reduced to checking strata (and full loci of covers) of genus zero quadratic differentials. 2. Teichmüller disks and Orbit closures In this section, we introduce the notion of Teichmüller disk. Then we recall the method of Gekhtman and Markovic [ 6 ] , which reduces the classification of Teichmüller disks to the case of Jenkins-Strebel differentials. Most of the relevant materials can be found in [ 6 ] . See Gupta [ 8 ] for a survey on complex analytic aspect of Teichmüller space. For general background on Teichmüller theory and quadratic differentials, we refer to Hubbard [ 9 ] and Strebel [ 15 ] . 2.1. Teichmüller disks and holomorphic retracts Let S_{g,n} be an oriented surface of genus g with n marked points (punctures), where 3g-3+n\geq 2 . Let \mathcal{T}_{g,n} be the Teichmüller space of Riemann surfaces marked by S_{g,n} . Let \operatorname{Mod}_{g,n} be the mapping class group of S_{g,n} . The quotient \mathcal{M}_{g,n}=\mathcal{T}_{g,n}/\operatorname{Mod}_{g,n} is the moduli space of Riemann surfaces. Let \pi:\mathcal{T}_{g,n}\rightarrow\mathcal{M}_{g,n} be the natural projection. Given X\in\mathcal{T}_{g,n} , a holomorphic quadratic differential \phi on X is a (2,0) tensor locally given by \phi=\phi(z)dz^{2}, where \phi(z) is a holomorphic function. Let Q(X) be the space of holomorphic quadratic differentials \phi on X such that the L^{1} -norm \|\phi\|=\int_{X}|\phi| is finite. Note that \|\phi\|<\infty if and only if \phi has at most simple poles at the punctures. Any \phi\in Q(X) induces a flat metric of finite area, which is also called a half-translation surface . It is known that the cotangent space of \mathcal{T}_{g,n} at X can be naturally identified with Q(X) and the L^{1} -norm is dual to the Teichmüller norm. We denote the cotangent bundle by Q\mathcal{T}_{g,n} . A pair (X,\phi)\in Q\mathcal{T}_{g,n} with \phi\in Q(X) and \phi\neq 0 generates a holomorphic embedding \tau^{\phi}:\mathbb{H}\rightarrow\mathcal{T}_{g,n}, which is an isometry from the Poincaré metric on \mathbb{H} to the Teichmüller metric on \mathcal{T}_{g,n} . For each \lambda\in\mathbb{H} , the Riemann surface X_{\lambda}=\tau^{\phi}(\lambda) is characterized by the property that the extremal quasiconformal map between X and X_{\lambda} has Beltrami differential \mu_{\lambda}=\left(\frac{i-\lambda}{i+\lambda}\right)\frac{|\phi|}{\phi}. In the natural coordinates associated with \phi , the extremal quasiconformal map is an affine map of the form z=x+iy\mapsto x+\lambda y. By abuse of notation, we write \tau^{\phi}(\lambda)=\left(\frac{i-\lambda}{i+\lambda}\right)\frac{|\phi|}{\phi}. We call \tau^{\phi} the Teichmüller disk generated by \phi . Note that \tau^{\phi}\left(i\cdot\mathbb{R}_{+}\right) is the Teichmüller geodesic in the direction of \phi . Definition 2.1 (Holomorphic retract) . Let \tau^{\phi}:\mathbb{H}\rightarrow\mathcal{T}_{g,n} be a Teichmüller disk. We say that \tau^{\phi} is a holomorphic retract of \mathcal{T}_{g,n} if there exists a holomorphic map F:\mathcal{T}_{g,n}\to\mathbb{H} such that F\circ\tau^{\phi}=\mathrm{id}_{\mathbb{H}}. Any holomorphic map F:\mathcal{T}_{g,n}\to\mathbb{H} satisfies the above property is called a holomorphic retraction of \tau^{\phi} . The following lemma states that classifying Teichmüller disks for which d_{\mathcal{T}}=d_{\mathcal{C}} is equivalent to classifying holomorphic retracts of \mathcal{T}_{g,n} . See [ 6 , Lemma 1.3] . Lemma 2.2 . The Kobayashi and Carathéodory metrics agree on a Teichmüller disk \tau^{\phi} if and only if \tau^{\phi} is a holomorphic retract of \mathcal{T}_{g,n} . 2.2. Orbit closures There is a natural \operatorname{GL}_{2}^{+}(\mathbb{R}) -action on Q\mathcal{T}_{g,n} that commutes with the action of \operatorname{Mod}_{g,n} . One can define a quadratic differential \phi by gluing a polygon P along sides in pairs, in a way that each side of P belongs to exactly one pair and the two sides in each pair are parallel and of the same length. If A\in\operatorname{GL}_{2}^{+}(\mathbb{R}) , then A acts on P as an affine transformation. By definition, A\cdot\phi is the quadratic differential obtained by gluing A\cdot P in the same pattern as that for P . Let p:Q\mathcal{T}_{g,n}\to\mathcal{T}_{g,n} be the natural projection. For any (X,\phi)\in Q\mathcal{T}_{g,n} , the image of A\cdot(X,\phi) under p remains the same if and only if we multiply A by \mathbb{C}^{*}=\mathbb{C}\setminus\{0\} . Note that \mathbb{H}\cong\mathbb{C}^{*}\backslash\operatorname{GL}_{2}^{+}(\mathbb{R}) . In fact, we can identify \mathbb{H} as a subgroup of \operatorname{GL}_{2}^{+}(\mathbb{R}) : \mathbb{H}\cong\left\{\begin{pmatrix}1&\operatorname{Re}\lambda\\ 0&\operatorname{Im}\lambda\end{pmatrix}\ :\ \lambda\in\mathbb{H}\right\}. In complex coordinates, the action of \begin{pmatrix}1&\operatorname{Re}\lambda\\ 0&\operatorname{Im}\lambda\end{pmatrix} is given by x+iy\mapsto x+\lambda y. So the Beltrami differential is \left(\frac{i-\lambda}{i+\lambda}\right)\frac{|\phi|}{\phi}, which coincides with \tau^{\phi}(\lambda) defined before. Let Q\mathcal{M}_{g,n}=Q\mathcal{T}_{g,n}/\operatorname{Mod}_{g,n} be the moduli space of holomorphic quadratic differentials. We also use \pi to denote the natural projection Q\mathcal{T}_{g,n}\to Q\mathcal{M}_{g,n} . The \operatorname{GL}_{2}^{+}(\mathbb{R}) -action on Q\mathcal{T}_{g,n} induces an action of \operatorname{GL}_{2}^{+}(\mathbb{R}) on Q\mathcal{M}_{g,n} . Given (X,\phi)\in Q\mathcal{M}_{g,n} , we denote by \operatorname{GL}_{2}^{+}(\mathbb{R})\cdot\phi the \operatorname{GL}_{2}^{+}(\mathbb{R}) orbit of (X,\phi) . Let \overline{\operatorname{GL}_{2}^{+}(\mathbb{R})\cdot\phi} be the orbit closure in a stratum of Q\mathcal{M}_{g,n} . The next result is very useful, proved by Gekhtman and Markovic [ 6 , Lemma 2.2] . Proposition 2.3 . Let \phi be a quadratic differential. If \phi generates a Teichmüller disk \tau^{\phi} that is a holomorphic retract of \mathcal{T}_{g,n} , so does every element in the orbit closure \overline{\operatorname{GL}_{2}^{+}(\mathbb{R})\cdot\phi} . Let \kappa=(\kappa_{1},\cdots,\kappa_{m}) be an integral vector where \kappa_{i}\geq-1 , i=1,...,m , and satisfy \sum\limits_{i=1}^{m}\kappa_{i}=4g-4. Denote by \mathcal{Q}(\kappa) the stratum of quadratic differentials (X,\phi) in Q\mathcal{M}_{g,n} consisting of \phi with m distinct zeros or poles of multiplicities \kappa_{1},\cdots,\kappa_{m} . The horocycle flow action h_{t}:\mathcal{Q}(\kappa)\rightarrow\mathcal{Q}(\kappa) is defined as the restriction of the \operatorname{GL}_{2}^{+}(\mathbb{R}) -action to the subgroup H=\left\{\begin{pmatrix}1&t\\ 0&1\end{pmatrix}\ :\ t\in\mathbb{R}\right\}. We refer to [ 5 ] for a comprehensive survey of the dynamics of the horocycle flow. Let \phi be a non-zero Jenkins-Strebel differential in Q\mathcal{M}_{0,6} with k cylinders. A saddle connection of \phi is a geodesic segment connecting singularities (zeros or poles) of \phi , and which does not contain any singularities in its interior. Let \mathcal{F}(\phi) be the horizontal foliation of \phi , whose leaves are tangent to the directions such that \phi(z)dz^{2}>0 . Denote the horizontal critical graph of \phi by \Gamma=\Gamma(\phi) . We say that \phi or \mathcal{F}(\phi) is Jenkins-Strebel if \Gamma(\phi) is compact and the complement X\setminus\Gamma(\phi) is a union of disjoint flat cylinders foliated by horizontal closed leaves. Smillie and Weiss [ 14 , Theorem 5] proved the following theorem. Theorem 2.4 . Let (X,\phi)\in\mathcal{Q}(\kappa) . Then (1) The closure \overline{H\cdot\phi} contains a Jenkins-Strebel differential \psi\in\mathcal{Q}(\kappa) . (2) If \phi has k horizontal cylinders whose union is not dense in S_{g,n} , then there exists a Jenkins-Strebel differential \psi in \overline{H\cdot\phi} that has at least k+1 horizontal cylinders. See [ 6 , §2.4] for details. By Proposition 2.3 and Theorem 2.4 , Conjecture 1.1 can be reduced to the classification of Jenkins-Strebel differentials. 2.3. Markovic’s criterion Suppose that \phi is a Jenkins-Strebel differential on X that decomposes the surface into a finite number of horizontal cylinders \Pi_{j},j=1,\cdots,k . Let \mathbb{H}^{k} be the k -fold product of the upper half-plane \mathbb{H} . Following [ 11 , Section 4] , we define the Teichmüller polydisk \mathcal{E}^{\phi}:\mathbb{H}^{k}\rightarrow\mathcal{T}_{g,n} by associating each {\lambda}=(\lambda_{1},\cdots,\lambda_{k}) a Riemann surface X_{\lambda}\in\mathcal{T}_{g,n} determined by the Beltrami differential \mu_{\lambda}=\left(\frac{i-\lambda_{j}}{i+\lambda_{j}}\right)\frac{|\phi|}{\phi} on each \Pi_{j} . Remark 3 . It is known that (see [ 11 , Section 4] ) \mathcal{E}^{\phi} is a holomorphic embedding, but not proper. Denote by h_{j} the height of \Pi_{j} . Note that each \Pi_{j} is deformed into a new horizontal cylinder \Pi_{j}(\lambda) . The circumference is preserved, while the height is scaled by a factor \operatorname{Im}\lambda_{j} . By gluing \Pi_{j}(\lambda),i=1,\cdots,k , we obtain a new Jenkins-Strebel differential \phi_{\lambda} on X_{\lambda} . The following beautiful and important theorem provides a criterion to characterize Jenkins-Strebel differentials which generate Teichmüller disks that admit holomorphic retractions. See [ 6 , Theorem 4.1] . Theorem 2.5 (Markovic’s criterion) . Let \phi\in Q(X) be a non-zero Jenkins-Strebel differential. Denote the area of the j -th cylinder of \phi by a_{j} . Let \mathcal{E}^{\phi}:\mathbb{H}^{k}\rightarrow\mathcal{T}_{g,n} be the Teichmüller polydisk associated with \phi . Then the Teichmüller disk \tau^{\phi} admits a holomorphic retraction if and only if there exists a holomorphic map \Phi:\mathcal{T}_{g,n}\rightarrow\mathbb{H} satisfying (1) \left(\Phi\circ\mathcal{E}^{\phi}\right)(\lambda)=\sum\limits_{j=1}^{k}a_{j}\lambda_{j}. As a corollary of Theorem 2.5 , if \phi is a Jenkins-Strebel differential with k cylinders and if \phi generates a Teichmüller disk that admits a holomorphic retraction, then so does every quadratic differential in its \mathbb{H}^{k} orbit. Based on Theorem 2.5 , Gekhtman and Markovic proposed the program to solve Conjecture 1.1 by showing that for any quadratic differential \phi with an odd-order zero (not lie at a marked point), the orbit closure of \phi contains a Jenkins-Strebel differential that does not satisfy the criterion ( 1 ). They carried out the program for \mathcal{T}_{0,5} in [ 6 ] . In the remainder of this paper, we focus on \mathcal{T}_{0,6} . 3. Classification of Jenkins-Strebel differentials on S_{0,6} We adopt the following notation. Let \mathcal{Q}(\kappa) be a stratum of Q\mathcal{M}_{0,6} , where \kappa=(\kappa_{1},\cdots,\kappa_{m}) . If there are j multiplicities say \kappa_{1},\cdots,\kappa_{j} that are equal to some n\in\mathbb{Z} , then we denote n^{j} instead of (\kappa_{1},\cdots,\kappa_{j}) . For instance, \mathcal{Q}(-1^{4}) denotes the stratum of quadratic differentials with four simple poles (without zeros), and \mathcal{Q}(2,-1^{6}) denotes the stratum of quadratic differentials with a single zero of order 2 and six simple poles. There are four strata in Q\mathcal{M}_{0,6} , as illustrated in the following table: Case (I) (II) (III) (IV) Stratum \mathcal{Q}(1^{2},-1^{6}) \mathcal{Q}(2,-1^{6}) \mathcal{Q}(1,-1^{5}) \mathcal{Q}(-1^{4}) A Jenkins-Strebel differential that is obtained by taking the double of a rectilinear polygon (whose sides are parallel to the coordinate axes) is called a pillowcase . A staircase (surface) on S_{0,6} is the double of a staircase-shaped polygon illustrated in Figure 1 . It is a Jenkins-Strebel differential with two simple zeros and six simple poles. This concept can be extended to flat surfaces on S_{0,n} for any n\geq 5 . Figure 1 . The double of the polygon is called a staircase. The first step to prove Theorem 1.3 is to classify Jenkins-Strebel differentials on S_{0,6} . In this section, we show that the problem can be reduced to staircase surfaces. Remark 4 . Staircase surfaces on S_{0,7} are used by Bourque and Rafi [ 4 ] to construct non-convex Teichmüller geodesic balls. Staircase surfaces on S_{0,n} (and the moduli space) are studied by Weber and Wolf [ 16 ] for finding minimal surfaces. If \phi is a Jenkins-Strebel differential with k horizontal cylinders, then \mathbb{H}^{k} acts on \phi through the Teichmüller polydisk associated with \phi . Throughout what follows, we denote by \mathbf{J}=\begin{pmatrix}0&-1\\ 1&0\end{pmatrix} the rotation matrix of the plane by angle \frac{\pi}{2} . The matrix \mathbf{J} acts on \phi by interchanging the horizontal and vertical foliations. This section contains many figures that serve to illustrate the proofs. We usually plot the trajectories of a quadratic differential on the plane, with the assumption that the point at infinity is a regular point. 3.1. Case (I): \phi\in\mathcal{Q}(1^{2},-1^{6}) . In this case, \phi has two simple zeros and six simple poles. Most of this section will be devoted to this case. We shall classify \phi according to the topological type of its critical graph \Gamma . Denote the zeros of \phi by z_{1} and z_{2} . Denote the poles by p_{1},\cdots,p_{5} and p_{6} . Jenkins-Strebel differentials with three cylinders. Case (I-1): Each zero z_{i} of \phi is connected to itself by a horizontal saddle connection, and there is a horizontal saddle connection joining z_{i} and a pole. There are three possibilities as shown in Figure 2 , which are referred to as type (a), (b) and (c), respectively. The surface is decomposed by \Gamma into three cylinders, \Pi_{1},\Pi_{2} and \Pi_{3} , which are arranged sequentially such that \Pi_{2} separates \Pi_{1} from \Pi_{3} . Denote their circumferences by \ell_{1},\ell_{2} and \ell_{3} . z_{1} \times p_{2} z_{2} p_{3} \times \times \times p_{4} \times \times p_{1} (a) z_{1} z_{2} \times \times \times \times \times \times (b) z_{1} z_{2} \times \times \times \times \times \times (c) Figure 2 . Case (I-1): The crosses stand for simple poles and the black dots stand for zeros. The Jenkins-Strebel differential \phi is decomposed by the critical graph into three cylinders. (I-1-a): \phi is of type (a). The circumferences of the cylinders satisfy \ell_{3}<\ell_{2}<\ell_{1} . Now \mathbb{H}^{3} acts on \phi through the Teichmüller polydisk \mathcal{E}^{\phi} . We shear \Pi_{1} appropriately so that there exists a vertical saddle connection ending at the poles p_{1} and p_{2} . See Figure 2 (a) for the notation. More precisely, we take a saddle connection in the cylinder \Pi_{1} connecting p_{1} and p_{2} , which may not be vertical. However, we can use the horocycle flow action on \Pi_{1} to shear the cylinder so that saddle connection is vertical. Similarly, we shear \Pi_{2} appropriately so that there is a vertical saddle connection connecting z_{1} to the pole p_{3} . Finally, we shear \Pi_{3} appropriately so that there exists a vertical saddle connection joining z_{2} and the pole p_{4} . We obtain a quadratic differential \psi that lies within the \mathbb{H}^{3} -orbit of \phi . Moreover, \psi is a staircase, obtained by doubling the polygon as illustrated in the first case of Figure 3 . (a) (b) (c) Figure 3 . The three types of polygon corresponding to types (a), (b) and (c). The one of type (a) is a staircase-shaped polygon. The other two types can be handled in much the same way. By applying the \mathbb{H}^{3} -action, we can transform them into pillowcases. There is a correspondence between Figure 2 and Figure 3 . In Type (b), we have \ell_{1}>\ell_{2} and \ell_{3}>\ell_{2} . In Type (c), we have \ell_{1}<\ell_{2} and \ell_{3}<\ell_{2} . Remark 5 . If \psi is a pillowcase, then the vertical foliation of \psi is also Jenkins-Strebel. In other words, rotating \psi by \mathbf{J} gives a new Jenkins-Strebel differential. We will show that every Jenkins-Strebel differential \phi\in\mathcal{Q}(1^{2},-1^{6}) can be replaced by a new \psi , which is a pillowcase of type (a), (b) or (c). Next, we show that any pillowcase surface \phi of type (I-1-b) or (I-1-c) can be deformed into a staircase, i.e., a Jenkins-Strebel differential of type (I-1-a). (I-1-b): \phi is of type (I-1-b). We can apply the \mathbb{H}^{3} -action on \phi using the following steps (as illustrated in Figure 4 ): (i) As a first step, we shear the cylinder \Pi_{2} (the one in the middle) appropriately so that the surface becomes the double of a Z -shaped polygon. (ii) Secondly, we use the \mathbb{H}^{3} -action on the horizontal cylinders to adjust their heights, denoted by h_{1},h_{2} and h_{3} , to satisfy the inequality h_{1}|\gamma_{2}| . By appropriately shearing the horizontal cylinders, we can assume that z_{1} is connected to p_{1} by a vertical saddle connection and z_{2} is connected to p_{4} by a vertical saddle connection. Denote by \widetilde{p_{1}p_{2}} the horizontal saddle connection between p_{1} and p_{2} , and denote by \widetilde{p_{3}p_{4}} the horizontal saddle connection between p_{3} and p_{4} . Note that |\widetilde{p_{3}p_{4}}|>|\gamma_{2}| . There is a vertical leaf \delta_{1} which emanates from z_{1} and intersects with the interior of \widetilde{p_{3}p_{4}} . We extend the leaf until it meets with \gamma_{3} . Similarly, there is a vertical leaf \delta_{2} which emanates from z_{2} and intersects with the interior of \widetilde{p_{1}p_{2}} . We extend \delta_{2} until it meets with \gamma_{1} . See Figure 13 for an illustration. Figure 13 . Case (I-3-b). Thick lines denote vertical saddle connections. The grey domain is a rectangle bounded by vertical and horizontal saddle connections. Denote by \widehat{z_{1}p_{1}} the vertical saddle connection between z_{1} and p_{1} , and denote by \widehat{z_{1}p_{4}} the vertical saddle connection between z_{2} and p_{4} . As shown in Figure 13 , the vertical leaves \delta_{1},\widehat{z_{1}p_{1}},\delta_{2},\widehat{z_{2}p_{4}} together bound a vertical strip of width |\gamma_{2}| . The top and the bottom of the strip are two horizontal segments, one contained in \gamma_{1} and the other contained in \gamma_{3} . Let \widetilde{p_{5}p_{6}} the horizontal saddle connection between p_{5} and p_{6} . Note that 2|\widetilde{p_{5}p_{6}}|=|\gamma_{1}|+|\gamma_{3}| and then |\widetilde{p_{5}p_{6}}|>|\gamma_{2}| . By appropriately shearing the horizontal cylinder with the slit \widetilde{p_{5}p_{6}} , we can obtain a new surface so that the vertical strip can be enlarge to a vertical cylinder across \widetilde{p_{5}p_{6}} . Denote such a vertical cylinder by \Theta . Consider the new surface (still denoted by \phi ). The complement of \Theta consists of two disjoint Jordan domains. Each such domain is bounded by a vertical closed leaf passing through a zero, and the interior of each domain contains two poles. It turns out that, in each domain, the two poles are connected by a vertical saddle connection. See Figure 14 for an illustration. As a result, up to a rotation by \mathbf{J} , \phi is a Jenkins-Strebel differential with three horizontal cylinders, and each zero is connected to itself by a horizontal saddle connection. Thus we can reduce this case to Case (I-1). \times \times \Omega Figure 14 . The Jordan domain is bounded by a closed vertical saddle connection passing through a zero, with two poles in the interior. (I-3-c): Assume that |\gamma_{1}|=|\gamma_{2}|<|\gamma_{3}| . Note that |\widetilde{p_{1}p_{2}}|=|\gamma_{1}|=|\gamma_{2}| , which is strictly less than |\widehat{p_{3}p_{4}}|=|\widehat{p_{5}p_{6}}| . By appropriately shearing the horizontal cylinders, we can assume that there is a vertical cylinder \Theta containing the interior of \widetilde{p_{1}p_{2}},\gamma_{1} and \gamma_{2} , which crosses \widetilde{p_{3}p_{4}},\widetilde{p_{5}p_{6}} and \gamma_{3} . See Figure 15 for an illustration. Now the complement of \overline{\Theta} has two connected components, each of which is a Jordan domain with two poles in the interior. As a result, up to a rotation by \mathbf{J} , \phi is a Jenkins-Strebel differential with three horizontal cylinders, and each zero is connected to itself by a horizontal saddle connection. Thus we can reduce this case to Case (I-1) again. Figure 15 . Case (I-3-c). Thick lines denote vertical saddle connections. The grey domains are the complement of the vertical cylinder \Theta . (I-3-d): Assume that |\gamma_{2}|<|\gamma_{3}|<|\gamma_{1}| . The proof for Case (I-3-b) applies to this case. We omit the details. Jenkins-Strebel differentials with two cylinders. Case (I-4): The two zeros z_{1} and z_{2} of \phi are connected by a pair of horizontal saddle connections, and each zero is connected to a pole by a horizontal saddle connection. Denote by \gamma_{1} and \gamma_{2} , respectively, the two horizontal saddle connections ending at z_{1} and z_{2} . There are two horizontal saddle connections, each of which connects a pair of poles, denoted by \alpha and \beta . There are several subcases. (I-4-a): The first subcase is illustrated in Figure 16 . We assume that |\beta|>|\alpha| and |\gamma_{1}|=|\gamma_{2}| . The union \gamma_{1}\cup\gamma_{2} bounds a Jordan domain with \alpha as a slit. Up to an \mathbb{H}^{2} -action, we can assume that p_{1} is connected to p_{5} by a vertical saddle connection, and p_{3} is connected to z_{1} by a vertical saddle connection. Since |\gamma_{1}|=|\gamma_{2}| , \phi is the double of the polygon shown in Figure 17 . Rotating \phi by \mathbf{J} , we can reduce this case to a pillowcase of type (I-1-c). \times p_{2} \times p_{1} \gamma_{2} \gamma_{1} \times p_{4} \times p_{3} \times \times p_{5} p_{6} \alpha \beta z_{1} z_{2} Figure 16 . Jenkins-Strebel differential in Case (I-4-a) or Case (I-4-b). Figure 17 . Polygon in Case (I-4-a). (I-4-b): The second subcase is the same as (I-4-a), except that in this case we don’t have |\gamma_{1}|=|\gamma_{2}| . Without loss of generality, we may assume that |\gamma_{1}|>|\gamma_{2}| . As before, up to an \mathbb{H}^{2} -action, we can assume that the pole p_{1} is connected to p_{5} by a vertical saddle connection, and p_{3} is connected to z_{1} by a vertical saddle connection. In this case, \phi has two vertical cylinders, denoted by \Theta_{1} and \Theta_{2} . See Figure 18 for an illustration. The first cylinder, denoted by \Theta_{1} , contains the interior of \gamma_{2} , and it crosses \alpha and \beta . The second cylinder, denoted by \Theta_{2} , is bounded by a vertical closed saddle connection passing through z_{1} and the vertical saddle connection connecting p_{1} to p_{5} . \times \times \times \times \times \times \times \times \times \times \gamma_{1} \gamma_{2} \gamma_{1} \gamma_{2} \alpha \beta Figure 18 . Case (I-4-b): The surface is obtained by gluing the three rectangles along the sizes with the same arrow. The green shadow domain stands for the first vertical cylinder and the blue shadow domain stands for the second vertical cylinder. Note that the complement of \overline{\Theta_{1}}\cup\overline{\Theta_{2}} is a Jordan domain \Omega , which contains three poles in the interior. The boundary \partial\Omega is a closed vertical saddle connection passing through z_{2} . There is a unique vertical critical leaf called \delta emanating from z_{2} . See Figure 19 for an illustration. \times \times \times \Omega Figure 19 . The Jordan domain is bounded by a closed vertical saddle connection passing through z_{2} . If \delta terminates at a pole, then the vertical foliation of \phi is Jenkins-Strebel. In this case, we can reduce \phi to Case (I-1) using the \mathbf{J} -action. If \delta does not terminate at a pole, then it is minimal in \Omega (This case is similar to a minimal foliation in a four-punctured sphere). Replace \phi by \mathbf{J}\cdot\phi . By Theorem 2.4 , there is a new Jenkins-Strebel differential \psi in \overline{H\cdot\phi} which has at least three horizontal cylinders. Since any Jenkins-Strebel differential on S_{0,6} has at most three cylinders, \psi has exactly three horizontal cylinders. Thus we can reduce \phi to the case of Jenkins-Strebel differential with three cylinders. (I-4-c): The third subcase is illustrated in Figure 20 , where the union \gamma_{1}\cup\gamma_{2} separates the surface into two components, each containing three poles. We assume that |\gamma_{1}|=|\gamma_{2}| . Up to an \mathbb{H}^{2} -action, we can assume p_{5} is connected to p_{1} by a vertical saddle connection, and p_{3} is connected to z_{1} by a vertical saddle connection. In this case \phi is the double of the polygon illustrated in Figure 21 . Rotate \phi by \mathbf{J} . Then the resulting Jenkins-Strebel differential has three horizontal cylinders, with each zero connected to itself by a horizontal saddle connection. This is exactly the one described in Case (I-1-c). \times \times p_{1} p_{2} \gamma_{2} \gamma_{1} \times \times p_{4} p_{3} \times \times p_{5} p_{6} \alpha \beta z_{2} z_{1} Figure 20 . Case (I-4-c). Figure 21 . Polygon in Case (I-4-c). (I-4-d): The remaining subcase is the same as (I-4-c), except that we don’t have |\gamma_{1}|=|\gamma_{2}| . Without loss of generality, we may assume that |\gamma_{1}|>|\gamma_{2}| . We can shear the horizontal cylinders appropriately to transform \phi into the one as shown in Figure 22 . There are two vertical cylinders \Theta_{1} and \Theta_{2} such that the complement of \overline{\Theta_{1}}\cup\overline{\Theta_{2}} is a Jordan domain containing three poles. Replace \phi by \mathbf{J}\cdot\phi . Similar to our discussion in Case (I-4-b), either \phi has three or two horizontal cylinders. In the later case, we can apply Theorem 2.4 to produce a new Jenkins-Strebel differential \psi with three horizontal cylinders. \times \times \times \times \times \gamma_{1} \gamma_{2} \times \times \times \times \times \gamma_{1} \gamma_{2} Figure 22 . Case (I-4-d) : The green shadow domain stands for the first vertical cylinder and the blue shadow domain stands for the second vertical cylinder. Case (I-5): The two zeros of \phi are connected by a unique horizontal saddle connection, and one of the zeros is connected to itself by a horizontal saddle connection, see Figure 23 . \times \times \times \times \times \times Figure 23 . Case (I-5). By appropriately shearing the horizontal cylinders, we can assume that each zero is connected to itself by a vertical saddle connection. These two vertical saddle connections bounds a cylinder, whose complement is two disjoint Jordan domains. Each such Jordan domain contains three poles in its interior. Rotating \phi by \mathbf{J} , the resulting quadratic differential (still denoted by \phi ) may be Jenkins-Strebel or not. If it is Jenkins-Strebel, then it must have three horizontal cylinders. Then we can reduce \phi to Case (I-1). If it is not Jenkins-Strebel, then we apply Theorem 2.4 to produce a new Jenkins-Strebel differential \psi in \overline{H\cdot\phi} with three horizontal cylinders. Case (I-6): In this case, one of the zeros say z_{1} is connected to itself by a horizontal saddle connection, denoted by \beta . The other zero z_{2} is connected to three poles by horizontal saddle connections. \times \times \times \times \times \times (a) z_{2} z_{1} p_{2} p_{1} p_{5} p_{6} p_{3} p_{4} \beta \alpha Figure 24 . Case (I-6-a). (I-6-a): See Figure 24 for an illustration. Denote by \gamma_{1} the horizontal saddle connections connecting z_{1} to p_{1} . Denote by \gamma_{i} the horizontal saddle connection connecting z_{2} to p_{i} by \gamma_{i} , where i=2,3,4 . Without loss of generality, we may assume that |\gamma_{2}|=\max\{|\gamma_{2}|,|\gamma_{3}|,|\gamma_{4}|\}. Denote by \alpha the horizontal saddle connections connecting p_{5} to p_{6} . We have the equation (2) |\gamma_{2}|+|\gamma_{3}|+|\gamma_{4}|=|\gamma_{1}|+|\alpha|. There are several subcases. We first consider the subcase that |\gamma_{1}|<|\gamma_{2}| . By appropriately shearing the two horizontal cylinders, we may assume that z_{1} is connected to p_{5} by a vertical saddle connection, and p_{1} is connected to p_{2} by a vertical saddle connection. Denote the above vertical saddle connections by \widehat{z_{1}p_{5}} and \widehat{p_{1}p_{2}} , respectively. There is a vertical cylinder with leaves surrounding \widehat{p_{1}p_{2}} , denoted by \Theta_{1} . Since |\gamma_{1}|<|\gamma_{2}| , \Theta_{1} must be bounded by a vertical closed saddle connection through z_{1} . Now, we examine the vertical leaves near the boundary of \overline{\Theta_{1}} . Any vertical leaf sufficiently close to \partial\overline{\Theta_{1}} travels along \partial\overline{\Theta_{1}} , and when it gets close to z_{1} , it turns right (or left) and follows the direction of \widehat{z_{1}p_{5}} until it is close to p_{5} . Then it turns around and returns to z_{1} . If it keeps going, it will return to the starting point. We conclude that there is a vertical cylinder \Theta_{2} adjoint to \Theta_{1} . Since |\gamma_{2}|-|\gamma_{1}|<|\alpha| , the zero z_{2} must lie on the boundary of \Theta_{2} . This is illustrated in Figure 25 . The complement of \overline{\Theta_{1}}\cup\overline{\Theta_{2}} , denoted by \Omega , is a Jordan domain containing three poles. Therefore, either \Omega corresponds to the third vertical cylinder \Theta_{3} or the vertical leaf in \Omega emanating from z_{2} is minimal. Replace \phi by \mathbf{J}\cdot\phi . In the later case, we apply Theorem 2.4 to produce a new Jenkins-Strebel differential \psi in \overline{H\cdot\phi} with three horizontal cylinders. \times \times \times \Theta_{1} \Theta_{2} z_{1} p_{5} z_{2} Figure 25 . Case (I-6-a): The vertical cylinders \Theta_{1} and \Theta_{2} . Next, we consider the subcase that |\gamma_{1}|=|\gamma_{2}| . We can appropriately shearing the horizontal cylinders so that p_{1} is connected to p_{2} by a vertical saddle connection. Now we shear the horizontal cylinder bounded by \alpha and \beta so that p_{4} is connected to p_{6} by a vertical saddle connection. Denote the above vertical saddle connections by \widehat{p_{1}p_{2}} and \widehat{p_{4}p_{6}} , respectively. \times \times \times \times \times \times z_{2} z_{1} p_{2} p_{1} p_{5} p_{6} p_{3} p_{4} Figure 26 . Thick lines denote vertical leaves. There are two vertical cylinders, with closed leaves surrounding \widehat{p_{1}p_{2}} and \widehat{p_{4}p_{6}} , respectively. Similar to the subcase before, we have a vertical cylinder \Theta_{1} with close leaves surrounding \widehat{p_{1}p_{2}} . Since |\gamma_{1}|=|\gamma_{2}| , both z_{1} and z_{2} lie on the boundary of \Theta_{1} . On the other hand, there is a vertical cylinder \Theta_{2} with close leaves surrounding \widehat{p_{4}p_{6}} . Since |\gamma_{4}|<|\alpha| , the boundary of \Theta_{2} must meets z_{2} . So \Theta_{2} must be bounded by a union of two vertical saddle connections, each of which connects z_{1} and z_{2} . This is illustrated in Figure 24 . Now the complement of \overline{\Theta_{1}}\cup\overline{\Theta_{2}} is a Jordan domain \Omega , which contains the two poles p_{3} and p_{5} . Thus the vertical foliation of \phi is Jenkins-Strebel. By applying the \mathbf{J} -action on \phi , we can reduce \phi to the Case (I-2). The remaining subcase is that |\gamma_{1}|>|\gamma_{2}| . First we assume that |\gamma_{2}|>|\alpha| . By appropriately shearing \phi along the horizontal cylinders we can assume that p_{2} and p_{6} is connected by a vertical saddle connection, and z_{1} is connected by a vertical saddle connection to p_{5} . Denote the above vertical saddle connections by \widehat{p_{2}p_{6}} and \widehat{z_{1}p_{5}} , respectively. This is illustrated in Figure 27 . Figure 27 . Thick lines denote vertical leaves. There is a vertical cylinder with close leaves surrounding \widehat{p_{2}p_{6}} and bounded by \delta . Consider the vertical cylinder \Theta_{1} with leaves surrounding \widehat{p_{2}p_{6}} . Since |\gamma_{2}|>|\alpha| , z_{1} is contained in the boundary of \Theta_{1} . Moreover, \overline{\Theta_{1}} is bounded by a vertical closed saddle connection passing through z_{1} , denoted by \delta . Since z_{1} is a simple zero, the remaining angle at z_{1} outside \Theta_{1} is \pi . As a result, there must be another vertical cylinder \Theta_{2} adjoint to \Theta_{1} . The cylinder \Theta_{2} is bounded by \delta and another vertical closed saddle connection passing through z_{2} . The complement of \overline{\Theta_{1}}\cup\overline{\Theta_{2}} is a Jordan domain containing at most three poles. Replace \phi by \mathbf{J}\cdot\phi . Either \Omega corresponds to the third horizontal cylinder or we can apply Theorem 2.4 to produce a new Jenkins-Strebel differential \psi in \overline{H\cdot\phi} with three horizontal cylinders. Now we assume that |\alpha|\geq|\gamma_{2}| . By our assumption, |\alpha|\geq|\gamma_{2}|\geq|\gamma_{3}|\geq|\gamma_{4}. The inequality together with Equation 2 implies |\gamma_{3}|+|\gamma_{4}|\geq|\gamma_{1}| or, equivalently, |\gamma_{1}|-|\gamma_{3}|\leq|\gamma_{4}| . By appropriately shearing \phi along the horizontal cylinders, we can assume that p_{3} and p_{1} is connected by a vertical saddle connection, and z_{2} is connected by a vertical saddle connection to p_{6} . Denote the above vertical saddle connections by \widehat{p_{1}p_{2}} and \widehat{z_{2}p_{6}} , respectively. Let \Theta_{1} be the vertical cylinder with closed leaves surrounding \widehat{p_{1}p_{2}} , which is bounded by a vertical closed saddle connection passing through z_{2} . Now we examine the neighborhood of \overline{\Theta_{1}}\cup\widehat{z_{2}p_{6}} . Since |\gamma_{1}|-|\gamma_{3}|\leq|\gamma_{4}|\leq|\gamma_{2}|\leq|\alpha| , there must be a vertical cylinder \Theta_{2} adjoint to \Theta_{1} , which is illustrated in Figure 28 . The width of \Theta_{2} is |\gamma_{1}|-|\gamma_{3}| . It crosses \gamma_{2} , \gamma_{4} and \alpha . Note that the complement of \overline{\Theta_{1}}\cup\widehat{\Theta_{2}} is non-empty. For otherwise, |\gamma_{2}|=|\gamma_{3}|=|\gamma_{4}|=|\alpha| , which implies |\gamma_{1}|=|\gamma_{2}| , which is contradicted to our assumption that |\gamma_{1}|>|\gamma_{2}| . Replace \phi by \mathbf{J}\cdot\phi . Now either the complement of \overline{\Theta_{1}}\cup\overline{\Theta_{2}} corresponds to the third horizontal cylinder or we can apply Theorem 2.4 to produce a new Jenkins-Strebel differential \psi in \overline{H\cdot\phi} with three horizontal cylinders. Figure 28 . Thick lines denote vertical leaves. The grey cylinder is \Theta_{2} . (I-6-b): See Figure 29 for an illustration. In this case we have the equation |\alpha|=\sum\limits_{i=1}^{4}|\gamma_{i}| . By appropriately shearing the horizontal cylinders, we may assume that p_{1} is connected to p_{5} by a vertical saddle connection, z_{1} is connected to p_{4} by a vertical saddle connection. Now, there exists a vertical cylinder \Theta_{1} with closed leaves surrounding the vertical saddle connection \widehat{p_{1}p_{5}} . The domain \overline{\Theta_{1}} is bounded by a vertical closed saddle connection passing through z_{1} . Denote such a vertical closed saddle connection by \delta . Since |\alpha|-|\gamma_{1}|\geq|\gamma_{4}| and |\gamma_{2}|\geq|\gamma_{3}|\geq|\gamma_{4}| , there exists a second vertical cylinder \Theta_{2} adjoint to \Theta_{1} with width |\gamma_{4}| , which crosses \gamma_{2},\gamma_{3} and \alpha . Replace \phi by \mathbf{J}\cdot\phi . Now either the complement of \overline{\Theta_{1}}\cup\overline{\Theta_{2}} corresponds to the third horizontal cylinder or we can apply Theorem 2.4 to produce a new Jenkins-Strebel differential \psi in \overline{H\cdot\phi} with three horizontal cylinders. \times \times \times \times \times \times (b) z_{1} z_{2} z_{1} p_{1} \alpha p_{5} p_{6} \beta p_{4} p_{3} p_{2} Figure 29 . Case (I-6-b). Jenkins-Strebel differentials with a single cylinder. Case (I-7): The two zeros of \phi are connected by a unique horizontal saddle connection, and each zero is connected to two poles by horizontal saddle connection, see Figure 30 . Denote the saddle connection between the two zeros by \alpha . There is a horizontal connection ending at two poles, denoted by \beta . \times \times \alpha \beta \times \times \times \times Figure 30 . Case (I-7). In this case, \phi is a Jenkins-Strebel differential with a single horizontal cylinder. Note that |\alpha|<|\beta| . By appropriately shearing the horizontal cylinder, we may assume that each zero is connected to itself by a vertical saddle connection. The two vertical saddle connections together bound a vertical cylinder \Theta , and the complement of \overline{\Theta} consists of two Jordan domains. In each such Jordan domain, there are three poles. Replace \phi by \mathbf{J}\cdot\phi . Now either each complement component of \overline{\Theta} corresponds to a horizontal cylinder or we can apply Theorem 2.4 to produce a new Jenkins-Strebel differential \psi in \overline{H\cdot\phi} with three horizontal cylinders. Case (I-8): This is the final case, illustrated in Figure 31 . Each zero is connected to three poles by horizontal saddle connections. By appropriately shearing this horizontal cylinder, we can assume that p_{1} and p_{4} are connected by a vertical saddle connection. Denote by \gamma_{1},\gamma_{2} and \gamma_{3} the horizontal saddle connections joining z_{1} to p_{1},p_{2} and p_{3} , respectively. Denote by \gamma_{4},\gamma_{5} and \gamma_{6} the horizontal saddle connections joining z_{2} to p_{4},p_{5} and p_{6} , respectively. Then we have the equation |\gamma_{1}|+|\gamma_{2}|+|\gamma_{3}|=|\gamma_{4}|+|\gamma_{5}|+|\gamma_{6}|. If all \gamma_{i} have equal length, then by using the \mathbf{J} -action the resulting quadratic differential is exactly the same as the one in Case (I-3). As a result, by abuse of notation, we can assume that |\gamma_{1}|>|\gamma_{4}| . Since p_{1} and p_{4} are connected by a vertical saddle connection, there exists a vertical cylinder \Theta with closed leaves surrounding the vertical saddle connection \widehat{p_{1}p_{4}} . Replace \phi by \mathbf{J}\cdot\phi . Now either the horizontal foliation of \phi is Jenkins-Strebel or we can apply Theorem 2.4 to produce a new Jenkins-Strebel differential \psi in \overline{H\cdot\phi} with two or three horizontal cylinders. Thus, we can reduce \phi to the previous cases. \times \times \times \times \times \times p_{1} p_{2} p_{3} p_{4} p_{5} p_{6} z_{1} z_{2} Figure 31 . Case (I-8). We conclude from the above discussion that Proposition 3.1 . Let \phi\in\mathcal{Q}(1^{2},-1^{6}) . There exists a Jenkins-Strebel differential \psi\in\mathcal{Q}(1^{2},-1^{6}) such that • \psi is a staircase. • If \tau^{\phi} admits a holomorphic retraction, so does \tau^{\psi} . 3.2. Case (II): \mathcal{Q}(2,-1^{6}) . There is a canonical double cover \eta:S_{2,0}\to S_{0,6} branched over the marked points. By pulling back Riemann surface structures, \eta induces a holomorphic isometry of Teichmüller spaces (with respect to the Teichmüller metric) \eta^{*}:\mathcal{T}_{0,6}\cong\mathcal{T}_{2,0}. Moreover, any quadratic differential on X\in\mathcal{T}_{0,6} is pulled back to a quadratic differential \psi on Y=\eta^{*}(X) . f \times \times \times \times \times \times Figure 32 . The canonical double cover \eta:S_{2,0}\to S_{0,6} . If (X,\phi)\in\mathcal{Q}(2,-1^{6}) , then (Y,\psi) be a holomorphic quadratic differential in Q\mathcal{T}_{2,0} , which has two zeros of even order. According to Kra’s theorem, there exists a holomorphic retraction F:\mathcal{T}_{2,0}\to\mathbb{H},\ F\circ\tau^{\psi}=\operatorname{id}_{\mathbb{H}}. As a consequence, \tau^{\phi} admits a holomorphic retraction. 3.3. Case (III): \mathcal{Q}(1,-1^{5}) . There are two subcases. Case (III-1): The zero of \phi does not lie at a marked point. In this case, \phi is a Jenkins-Strebel differential with a simple zero. There are two possibilities, see Figure 33 for an illustration. The right one can be transform into the left one. \times \times \times \times \times \times \times \times \times \times Figure 33 . Case (III-1). Let us assume that \phi is the one on the left of Figure 33 . In this situation, we shall consider the regular marked point on S_{0,6} as a singularity of order 0 . That is, \phi is a quadratic differential in the stratum \mathcal{Q}(1,-1^{5},0) . There is a horizontal closed saddle connection \gamma joining the zero to itself, which separates the surface into two horizontal cylinders \Pi_{1} and \Pi_{2} . We can use the \mathbb{H}^{2} -action to shear \phi appropriately along the horizontal cylinders so that \phi is a L -shaped pillowcase with an extra marked point. See Figure 34 for an illustration, where we denote the zero by z , the poles by p_{1},\cdots,p_{5} and the extra marked point by p . Without loss of generality, we may assume that p lies in the closure of \Pi_{2} . \times \times \times \times \times \gamma p \Pi_{2} \Pi_{1} z p_{1} p_{2} p_{5} p_{4} p_{3} Figure 34 . The Jenkins-Strebel differential in Case (III-1), which can be deformed into a L-shaped pillowcase with an extra marked point (the blue bullet) lying at the bottom. If p lies in the interior of \Pi_{2} , then we can take the horizontal closed trajectory of \phi passing through p , which together with \gamma separate the surface into three horizontal cylinders. By using the action of \mathbb{H}^{3} on the horizontal cylinders, we can move the marked point p such that it lies at the left side of the L -shaped polygon. Rotating \phi by \mathbf{J} , we can transform \phi into a L -shaped pillowcase such that the marked point p lies at the bottom of the polygon. If p lies at the saddle connection between z and p_{5} (but not at the saddle connection between p_{3} and p_{4} ), then we add the vertical closed trajectory of \phi passing through p and consider \phi as a Jenkins-Strebel differential with three vertical cylinders. Rotate \phi by \mathbf{J} and apply the \mathbb{H}^{3} -action to \mathbf{J}\cdot\phi we can move p to the bottom of \phi . Finally, assume that the marked point p lies at \gamma (but not at the saddle connection between p_{2} and p_{3} ). We take the vertical closed leaf passing through p and consider \phi as a Jenkins-Strebel differential with three vertical cylinders. Up to the \mathbf{J} -action, we can again transform \phi into a L -shaped pillowcase such that the marked point p lies at the bottom of the polygon. As a result, we can always assume that \phi is the double of a L -shaped polygon with an extra marked point lying at the bottom. We can deal with this case using Markovic’s computation for the L -shaped polygon [ 11 ] . This is the same as for the proof of [ 11 , Theorem 1.1] , which shows that \tau^{\phi} does not admit a holomorphic retraction. We omit the details. Case (III-2): The zero of \phi is a marked point. In this case, the pullback of \phi under \eta^{*} gives a quadratic differential \psi with a single zero of order 4 on S_{2,0} . By Kra’s theorem, \tau^{\phi} admits a holomorphic retraction. 3.4. Case (IV): \mathcal{Q}(-1^{4}) . In this case, the pullback of \phi under \eta^{*} produces a quadratic differential \psi with two zeros of order 2 on S_{2,0} . By Kra’s theorem, \tau^{\phi} admits a holomorphic retraction. 3.5. Conclusion From the above discussion, to prove Theorem 1.3 , it suffices to show that the equation ( 1 ) does not hold for staircase Jenkins-Strebel differentials. This will be addressed in Section 4 . To prove Theorem 1.2 , we can identify any quadratic differential \psi on a genus two surface as the pullback of some \phi\in Q\mathcal{T}_{0,6} . Note that if \psi has a zero of odd order, then either \phi\in\mathcal{Q}(1^{2},-1^{6}) or \phi\in\mathcal{Q}(1,-1^{5}) . In the latter case, the zero of \phi could not be located at a marked point. Thus Theorem 1.2 follows directly from Theorem 1.3 . 4. Staircase surfaces We have already shown in Section 3 that the proof of Theorem 1.3 can be reduced to staircase surfaces. In this section, we show that for any given staircase on S_{0,6} , the associated Teichmüller disk does not admit a holomorphic retraction. Our result generalizes Markovic’s previous work on L -shaped pillowcases [ 11 ] . Remark 6 . Markovic’s computation shows that extremal length is not C^{2} along certain smooth paths in the space of measured foliations, see also Azemar [ 2 , Theorem 1.9] . 4.1. Holomorphic retraction Let us begin with some notation. Assume that a,b,c>0 and p,q>0,p+q<1 . Let L(a,b,c,p,q) be a staircase-shaped polygon as shown in Figure 35 . There are six vertices, denoted by P_{k},k=1,\cdots,6 , at which the interior angles are \frac{\pi}{2} . And there are another two vertices, denoted by Q_{1} and Q_{2} , at which the interior angles are \frac{3\pi}{2} . Let S(a,b,c,p,q) be the double of L(a,b,c,p,q) , which is regarded as a Riemann sphere with marked points P_{1},\cdots,P_{6} . Let \phi(a,b,c,p,q) denote the quadratic differential on S(a,b,c,p,q) obtained by gluing the two copies of dz^{2} on L(a,b,c,p,q) . It is evident that \phi(a,b,c,p,q) is a Jenkins-Strebel differential, with two simple zeros corresponding to Q_{1} and Q_{2} . The surface S(a,b,c,p,q) is decomposed by the horizontal critical graph of \phi into three annuli \Pi_{1},\Pi_{2} and \Pi_{3} , each of which is swept out by horizontal closed trajectories of \phi(a,b,c,p,q) . P_{6} P_{1} P_{2} P_{3} P_{4} P_{5} Q_{1} Q_{2} 1 1-p-q q p \Pi_{1} \Pi_{2} \Pi_{3} a b c Figure 35 . The polygon L(a,b,c,p,q) . Fix (a_{0},b_{0},c_{0},p_{0},q_{0}) . We denote S=S(a_{0},b_{0},c_{0},p_{0},q_{0}) and \phi=\phi(a_{0},b_{0},c_{0},p_{0},q_{0}) . The main result in this section is Theorem 4.1 . The Teichmüller disk \tau^{\phi}:\mathbb{H}\to\mathcal{T}_{0,6} does not admit a holomorphic retraction. To derive a contradiction, we assume that there exists a holomorphic retraction \Phi:\mathcal{T}_{0,6}\to\mathbb{H} of the Teichmüller disk \tau^{\phi} . Let \mathcal{E}:\mathbb{H}^{3}\rightarrow\mathcal{T}_{0,6} be the Teichmüller polydisk associated with \phi . Define a_{1}=\frac{1}{{\|\phi\|}}\int_{\Pi_{1}}|\phi|=\frac{a_{0}}{a_{0}+b_{0}(p_{0}+q_{0})+c_{0}p_{0}}, a_{2}=\frac{1}{{\|\phi\|}}\int_{\Pi_{2}}|\phi|=\frac{b_{0}(p_{0}+q_{0})}{a_{0}+b_{0}(p_{0}+q_{0})+c_{0}p_{0}}, and a_{3}=\frac{1}{{\|\phi\|}}\int_{\Pi_{3}}|\phi|=\frac{c_{0}p_{0}}{a_{0}+b_{0}(p_{0}+q_{0})+cp_{0}}. By Theorem 2.5 , we can assume that \Phi satisfies \left(\Phi\circ\mathcal{E}\right)(\lambda_{1},\lambda_{2},\lambda_{3})=a_{1}\lambda_{1}+a_{2}\lambda_{2}+a_{3}\lambda_{3} for all (\lambda_{1},\lambda_{2},\lambda_{3})\in\mathbb{H}^{3} . Note that for any a,b,c>0 , we have \mathcal{E}\left(\frac{a}{a_{0}}i,\frac{b}{b_{0}}i,\frac{c}{c_{0}}i\right)=S(a,b,c,p_{0},q_{0}). Thus we have the following equality (3) \Phi(S(a,b,c,p_{0},q_{0}))=\frac{a+b(p_{0}+q_{0})+cp_{0}}{a_{0}+b_{0}(p_{0}+q_{0})+c_{0}p_{0}}i. Lemma 4.2 . Assume that the Teichmüller disk \tau^{\phi}:\mathbb{H}\to\mathcal{T}_{0,6} admits a holomorphic retraction. Then there exists a holomorphic function F on \mathcal{T}_{0,6} such that F\left(S(a,b,c,p_{0},q_{0})\right)=a+b(p_{0}+q_{0})+cp_{0} for every a>0 and b,c\geq 0 . Proof. We take F=\left(a_{0}+b_{0}(p_{0}+q_{0})+c_{0}p_{0}\right)\frac{\Phi}{i}, which is a holomorphic function on \mathcal{T}_{0,6} . By ( 3 ), we have F(S(a,b,c,p_{0},q_{0}))=a+b(p_{0}+q_{0})+cp_{0} for any a,b,c>0 . By continuity, the above equality holds for every a>0 and b,c\geq 0 . ∎ Note that the function F(S(a,b,c,p_{0},q_{0})) , for fixed (p_{0},q_{0}) , is the area of L(a,b,c,p_{0},q_{0}) . 4.2. Computation of area. Let f:\mathbb{H}\to L(a,b,c,p,q) be the Riemann mapping such that f(\infty)=P_{1},f(-1)=P_{2},f(1)=P_{6} . Assume that f(\xi_{1})=P_{3},f(\xi_{2})=P_{4},f(\xi_{3})=P_{5} , where -1<\xi_{1}<\xi_{2}<\xi_{3}<1 . Assume that f(\eta_{1})=Q_{1},f(\eta_{2})=Q_{2} , where -1<\eta_{1}\leq\xi_{1}<\eta_{2}\leq\xi_{2} (we allow b,c to be 0 ). By the Schwarz-Christoffel formula, f is given by f(z)=J\int_{1}^{z}\frac{\sqrt{w-\eta_{1}}\sqrt{w-\eta_{2}}}{\sqrt{w-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{w-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{w-\xi_{3}}\sqrt{w-1}\sqrt{w+1}}dw. Since |P_{6}P_{1}|=1 , we have \frac{1}{J}=\int_{1}^{\infty}\frac{\sqrt{x-\eta_{1}}\sqrt{x-\eta_{2}}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}}dx. Since S(a,b,c,p,q) is the double of L(a,b,c,p,q) , we can extend f to a conformal mapping f:\mathbb{C}\setminus\{-1,\xi_{1},\xi_{2},\xi_{3},1\}\rightarrow S(a,b,c,p,q). Computing the Schwarz-Christoffel maps. Consider the case that -1<\eta_{1}=\xi_{1}<\eta_{2}=\xi_{2}<\xi_{3}<1 . Under the Schwarz-Christoffel map, the corresponding polygon is L(a,0,0,p,q) , which is a rectangle with two additional marked points P_{3} and P_{4} on the top side. Let s>0 and t>0 be sufficiently small. We deform L(a,0,0,p,q) into a new polygon \mathbf{L}(s,t)=L\left(a(s,t),b(s,t),c(s,t),p(s,t),q(s,t)\right) in a way that the Schwarz-Christoffel map sends (\xi_{1},\xi_{2},\xi_{3}) into (P_{3},P_{4},P_{5}) and (\xi_{1}-s,\xi_{2}-t) into (Q_{1},Q_{2}) . In other words, we have \eta_{1}=\xi_{1}-s,\eta_{2}=\xi_{2}-t . Let \mathbf{S}(s,t)=S\left(a(s,t),b(s,t),c(s,t),p(s,t),q(s,t)\right) be the double of \mathbf{L}(s,t) , with the natural Jenkins-Strebel differential \phi(s,t)=\phi\left(a(s,t),b(s,t),c(s,t),p(s,t),q(s,t)\right) induced by the flat metric on \mathbf{L}(s,t) . Note that the Riemann surface structure induced by \mathbf{S}(s,t) is equivalent to \mathbb{C}\setminus\{-1,\xi_{1},\xi_{2},\xi_{3},1\} . So we obtain a two-parameter family of Jenkins-Strebel differentials that represent the same point in \mathcal{T}_{0,6} . To compute a(s,t),b(s,t),c(s,t),p(s,t),q(s,t) , we let \displaystyle A(s,t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\int_{-\infty}^{-1}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}dx, \displaystyle B(s,t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\int_{\xi_{1}-s}^{\xi_{1}}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}dx, \displaystyle C(s,t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\int_{\xi_{2}-t}^{\xi_{2}}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}dx, \displaystyle P(s,t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-\int_{\xi_{2}}^{\xi_{3}}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}dx, \displaystyle Q(s,t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-\int_{\xi_{1}}^{\xi_{2}-t}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}dx, \displaystyle\frac{1}{J(s,t)} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{1}^{+\infty}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}dx. It follows by definition that \displaystyle a(s,t)={J(s,t)}{A(s,t)}, \displaystyle b(s,t)={J(s,t)}{B(s,t)},\ \ \ \ c(s,t)={J(s,t)}{C(s,t)}, \displaystyle p(s,t)={J(s,t)}{P(s,t)}, \displaystyle q(s,t)={J(s,t)}{Q(s,t)}. Both J(s,t) and A(s,t) are real analytic with respect to (s,t) , since their integrals depend analytically on (s,t) . Convention We adopt the following convention. If two functions h(s,t) and g(s,t) satisfy \frac{h(s,t)}{g(s,t)}\to 0 as (s,t)\to(0,0) , then we denote h(s,t)=o\left(g(s,t)\right) . If there is a constant C such that \left|\frac{h(s,t)}{g(s,t)}\right|0 sufficiently small B(s,t)=\frac{\pi s}{2\sqrt{1-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{1+\xi_{1}}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{1}}}+O(s^{2})+O(st), C(s,t)=\frac{\pi t}{2\sqrt{1-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{1+\xi_{2}}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{2}}}+O(st)+O(t^{2}). Proof. For s,t>0 sufficiently small, we have for x\in[\xi_{1}-s,\xi_{1}] \displaystyle\frac{-i}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{i}{\sqrt{1-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{1+\xi_{1}}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{1}}}+O(s), \displaystyle\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 1+O(t). So we can write \displaystyle B(s,t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(\frac{i}{\sqrt{1-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{\xi_{1}+1}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{1}}}+O(s)\right)\int_{\xi_{1}-s}^{\xi_{1}}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}dx \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(\frac{i}{\sqrt{1-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{\xi_{1}+1}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{1}}}+O(s)\right)\left(1+O(t)\right)\int_{\xi_{1}-s}^{\xi_{1}}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}}dx. It remains to compute the integral \int_{\xi_{1}-s}^{\xi_{1}}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}}dx. Note that \int_{\xi_{1}-s}^{\xi_{1}}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}}dx=-i\int_{\xi_{1}-s}^{\xi_{1}}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}}{\sqrt{\xi_{1}-x}}dx, Substituting \xi_{1}-x=y then yields \displaystyle-i\int_{\xi_{1}-s}^{\xi_{1}}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}}{\sqrt{\xi_{1}-x}}dx \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\int_{0}^{s}\frac{\sqrt{s-y}}{\sqrt{y}}dy \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\left[\sqrt{s-y}\sqrt{y}+s\arctan\left(\frac{\sqrt{y}}{\sqrt{s-y}}\right)\right]\bigg|_{0}^{s} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\frac{\pi s}{2}. We conclude that \displaystyle B(s,t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{\xi_{1}+1}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{1}}}+O(s)\right)\left(1+O(t)\right)\frac{\pi s}{2} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{\pi s}{2\sqrt{1-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{1+\xi_{1}}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{1}}}+O(s^{2})+O(st). The proof for C(s,t) is similar. ∎ Recall that \displaystyle P(0,0) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-\int_{\xi_{2}}^{\xi_{3}}\frac{1}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}dx, \displaystyle Q(0,0) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-\int_{\xi_{1}}^{\xi_{2}}\frac{1}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}dx. Proposition 4.4 . With the about notation, we have P(s,t)-P(0,0)=\frac{1}{2\sqrt{1-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{1+\xi_{2}}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{2}}}\ t\ln\frac{1}{t}+o\left(t\ln\frac{1}{t}\right)+O(s). Proof. By definition, \displaystyle P(s,t)-P(0,0)=\int_{\xi_{2}}^{\xi_{3}}\frac{1}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx. Let \epsilon=\epsilon(t) be a function (to be explicitly determined later) such that \epsilon(t)\to 0\quad and\quad\frac{t}{\epsilon(t)}\to 0 as t\to 0 . Write the above integral as the sum \displaystyle I_{1}+I_{2} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{2}}^{\xi_{2}+\epsilon}\frac{1}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx \displaystyle+\int_{\xi_{2}+\epsilon}^{\xi_{3}}\frac{1}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx. For the first intergal I_{1} , we have (4) \displaystyle\frac{1}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}=\frac{-1}{\sqrt{1-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{1+\xi_{2}}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{2}}}+O(\epsilon). for \xi_{2}\leq x\leq\xi_{2}+\epsilon . On the other hand, (5) \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{2}}^{\xi_{2}+\epsilon}\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx \displaystyle= \displaystyle\epsilon-\left(1+O(s)\right)\int_{\xi_{2}}^{\xi_{2}+\epsilon}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}dx. Substituting x-\xi_{2}=y yields (6) \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{2}}^{\xi_{2}+\epsilon}\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}dx \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{0}^{\epsilon}\frac{\sqrt{y+t}}{\sqrt{y}}dy \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(\sqrt{y}\sqrt{y+t}+t\ln(\sqrt{y}+\sqrt{y+t})\right)\mid_{0}^{\epsilon} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sqrt{\epsilon}\sqrt{\epsilon+t}+t\ln\frac{(\sqrt{\epsilon}+\sqrt{\epsilon+t})}{\sqrt{t}}. Combining ( 4 ),( 5 ) and ( 6 ), the first integral satisfies \displaystyle I_{1} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{2}}^{\xi_{2}+\epsilon}\frac{1}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{1+\xi_{2}}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{2}}}+O(\epsilon)\right)\left(\sqrt{\epsilon}\sqrt{\epsilon+t}-\epsilon+t\ln\frac{(\sqrt{\epsilon}+\sqrt{\epsilon+t})}{\sqrt{t}}\right) \displaystyle+O(s)\left(\sqrt{\epsilon}\sqrt{\epsilon+t}+t\ln\frac{(\sqrt{\epsilon}+\sqrt{\epsilon+t})}{\sqrt{t}}\right). Note that \displaystyle\sqrt{\epsilon}\sqrt{\epsilon+t} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\epsilon+o(\epsilon), \displaystyle\sqrt{\epsilon}\sqrt{\epsilon+t}-\epsilon \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{t}{1+\sqrt{1+t/\epsilon}}=\frac{t}{2}+o(t), \displaystyle t\ln\frac{(\sqrt{\epsilon}+\sqrt{\epsilon+t})}{\sqrt{t}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle t\ln\left(\frac{\sqrt{\epsilon}}{\sqrt{t}}\left(1+\sqrt{1+\frac{t}{\epsilon}}\right)\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{1}{2}t\ln\frac{1}{t}-\frac{1}{2}t\ln\frac{1}{\epsilon}+O\left(\frac{t^{2}}{\epsilon}\right)+t\ln 2. Therefore, we obtain (7) \displaystyle I_{1} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{1}{2\sqrt{1-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{1+\xi_{2}}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{2}}}t\left(\ln\frac{1}{t}-\ln\frac{1}{\epsilon}\right)+o\left(t\ln\frac{1}{t}\right)+O(s). For the second integral I_{2} , we note that when x\geq\xi_{2}+\epsilon , \displaystyle 1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 1-\left(1+O(s)\right)\left(1+O\left(\frac{t}{\epsilon}\right)\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle O(s)+O\left(\frac{t}{\epsilon}\right). Thus, we have (8) \displaystyle I_{2} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{2}+\epsilon}^{\xi_{3}}\frac{1}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx \displaystyle= \displaystyle O\left(s\right)+O\left(\frac{t}{\epsilon}\right). To conclude our result, we take \epsilon=\frac{1}{\sqrt{\ln\frac{1}{t}}}. Then by ( 7 ) and ( 8 ), we have P(s,t)-P(0,0)=\frac{1}{2\sqrt{1-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{1+\xi_{2}}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{2}}}t\ln\frac{1}{t}+o\left(t\ln\frac{1}{t}\right)+O(s). ∎ Proposition 4.5 . With the about notation, we have for s,t>0 sufficiently small \displaystyle Q(s,t)-Q(0,0) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{-1}{2\sqrt{1-\xi_{2}}\sqrt{1+\xi_{2}}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{2}}}t\ln\frac{1}{t}+\frac{1}{2\sqrt{1-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{1+\xi_{1}}\sqrt{\xi_{3}-\xi_{1}}}s\ln\frac{1}{s} \displaystyle+o\left(s\ln\frac{1}{s}\right)+o\left(t\ln\frac{1}{t}\right)+O(t)s\ln\frac{1}{s}+O\left(\frac{1}{\ln\frac{1}{s}}\right)t\ln\frac{1}{t}. Proof. By the formula of Q(s,t) , we have (9) \displaystyle Q(s,t)-Q(0,0) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{1}}^{\xi_{2}-t}\frac{1}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx \displaystyle+\int_{\xi_{2}-t}^{\xi_{2}}\frac{1}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}dx Obviously, the second integral \int_{\xi_{2}-t}^{\xi_{2}}\frac{1}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}dx=O(t)=o\left(t\ln\frac{1}{t}\right). It remains to study the first integral in ( 9 ). Denote h(x)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{x-1}\sqrt{x+1}\sqrt{x-\xi_{3}}}, which is negative when \xi_{1}\leq x\leq\xi_{2}-t . Let N=\ln\frac{1}{s} . We write the first integral in ( 9 ) as (10) \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{1}}^{\xi_{2}-t}h(x)\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx \displaystyle= \displaystyle I_{3}+I_{4} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{1}}^{\xi_{1}+Ns}h(x)\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx \displaystyle+\int_{\xi_{1}+Ns}^{\xi_{2}-t}h(x)\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx. For the integral I_{3} in ( 10 ), we have \displaystyle I_{3} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{1}}^{\xi_{1}+Ns}h(x)\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{1}}^{\xi_{1}+Ns}h(x)\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx \displaystyle+\int_{\xi_{1}}^{\xi_{1}+Ns}h(x)\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}}\right)dx \displaystyle= \displaystyle O(t)\left(s\ln\frac{1}{s}\right)+\left(1+O(t)\right)\int_{\xi_{1}}^{\xi_{1}+Ns}h(x)\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}}\right)dx. Substituting x-\xi_{1}=y , we have \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{1}}^{\xi_{1}+Ns}h(x)\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}}\right)dx \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(h(\xi_{1})+O\left(s\ln\frac{1}{s}\right)\right)\left(Ns-\int_{0}^{Ns}\frac{\sqrt{y+s}}{\sqrt{y}}dy\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(h(\xi_{1})+O\left(s\ln\frac{1}{s}\right)\right)\left(Ns-\left[\sqrt{y}\sqrt{y+s}+s\ln(\sqrt{y}+\sqrt{y+s})\right]|_{0}^{Ns}\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(h(\xi_{1})+O\left(s\ln\frac{1}{s}\right)\right)\left(Ns-\sqrt{Ns}\sqrt{Ns+s}-s\ln\frac{(\sqrt{Ns}+\sqrt{Ns+s})}{\sqrt{s}}\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(h(\xi_{1})+O\left(s\ln\frac{1}{s}\right)\right)\left(N-\sqrt{N(N+1)}-\ln(\sqrt{N}+\sqrt{N+1})\right)s. Since N-\sqrt{N(N+1)} is bounded and \ln(\sqrt{N}+\sqrt{N+1}) is approximately \frac{1}{2}\ln\left(\ln\frac{1}{s}\right) , we conclude that I_{3}=o\left(s\ln\frac{1}{s}\right)+O(t)s\ln\frac{1}{s}. For the integral I_{4} in ( 10 ), we write \displaystyle I_{4} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{1}+Ns}^{\xi_{2}-t}h(x)\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx \displaystyle= \displaystyle I_{5}+I_{6}, where \displaystyle I_{5} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{1}+Ns}^{\xi_{2}-t}h(x)\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}}\right)dx, \displaystyle I_{6} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{1}+Ns}^{\xi_{2}-t}h(x)\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}}\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx. Substituting x-\xi_{1}=y , we have \displaystyle I_{5} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{\xi_{1}+Ns}^{\xi_{2}-t}h(x)\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}}\right)dx \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{Ns}^{\xi_{2}-\xi_{1}-t}h(\xi_{1}+y)\left(1-\sqrt{1+\frac{s}{y}}\right)dy \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{-1}{2}\int_{Ns}^{\xi_{2}-\xi_{1}-t}h(\xi_{1}+y)\left(\frac{s}{y}+O\left(\frac{s^{2}}{y^{2}}\right)\right)dy \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{-h(\xi_{1})}{2}s\ln\frac{1}{s}+o\left(s\ln\frac{1}{s}\right), where the last equality follows with the aid of an integration by parts. It remains to estimate I_{6}=\int_{\xi_{1}+Ns}^{\xi_{2}-t}h(x)\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}}\left(1-\frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}+t}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{2}}}\right)dx. Note that \frac{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}+s}}{\sqrt{x-\xi_{1}}}>0 when \xi_{1}+Ns0 . Assume for contradiction that the Teichmüller disk \tau^{\phi} admits a holomorphic retraction. Let F be the holomorphic function in Lemma 4.2 . 1 a p q 1-p-q \Pi_{1,1} \Pi_{1,2} \Pi_{1,3} Figure 36 . Consider the surface S(a_{0},0,0,p_{0},q_{0}) . For small x,y>0 , we let \mathbf{R}(x,y)=S(a_{0},0,0,p_{0}-x,q_{0}-y)\in\mathcal{T}_{0,6}. Lemma 4.7 . The family of Riemann surfaces \{\mathbf{R}(x,y)\} is real analytic with respect to the parameters x and y . Proof. We can obtain each \mathbf{R}(x,y) by a quasiconformal deformation of S(a,0,0,p_{0},q_{0}) , with Beltrami differential \mu(x,y) given by \mu_{j}(x,y) on the annulus \Pi_{1,j} (see Figure 36 ), satisfying \mu_{1}(x,y)=\frac{-x}{2p_{0}-x},\mu_{2}(x,y)=\frac{-y}{2q_{0}-y},\mu_{3}(x,y)=\frac{x+y}{2(1-p_{0}-q_{0})+x+y}. It is obvious that the family of Beltrami differentials \{\mu(x,y)\} depends real-analytically on x and y , so the lemma follows. ∎ As we have shown, \mathbf{R}(x,y) depends smoothly on x and y , thus F(\mathbf{R}(x,y)) defines a smooth function of x and y . Now we claim that each \mathbf{R}(x,y) can be identified with a certain surface \mathbf{S}(s,t)=S\left(a(s,t),b(s,t),c(s,t),p(s,t),q(s,t)\right), which arises from the deformation constructed in Section 4.2 . We set p=p_{0}-x,q=q_{0}-y . Lemma 4.8 . For x,y sufficiently small, we can locate (s,t) such that the surface \mathbf{S}(s,t)=S\left(a(s,t),b(s,t),c(s,t),p(s,t),q(s,t)\right), which is the deformation of the base surface \mathbf{S}(0,0)=\mathbf{R}(x,y) , satisfying p(s,t)=p_{0},q(s,t)=q_{0}. Proof. By our previous computation, there are positive coefficients P and Q (depending on the base surface \mathbf{R}(x,y) ) such that \displaystyle\begin{cases}p(s,t)-p=\left(P+o(1)\right)t\ln{\frac{1}{t}}+O(s),\\ q(s,t)-q=\left(-P+o(1)\right)t\ln{\frac{1}{t}}+\left(Q+o(1)\right)s\ln{\frac{1}{s}}.\end{cases} We set \displaystyle\begin{cases}u=s\ln{\frac{1}{s}},\\ v=t\ln{\frac{1}{t}}.\end{cases} Then the value of \left(p(s,t)-p,q(s,t)-q\right) is approximately \left(Pv,-Pv+Qu\right) . Note that the inverse of the matrix \left[{\begin{array}[]{cc}0&P\\ Q&-P\\ \end{array}}\right] is \left[{\begin{array}[]{cc}\frac{1}{Q}&\frac{1}{Q}\\ \frac{1}{P}&0\\ \end{array}}\right] , which is positive. Thus for x,y>0 that are sufficiently small, there exist u>0,v>0 (and then s>0,t>0 ) such that p(s,t)-p=x,\quad q(s,t)-q=y. This gives p(s,t)=p_{0},q(s,t)=q_{0} . ∎ Now we are able to prove Theorem 4.1 . Using the same notation as in Lemma 4.8 , we have \displaystyle\left[{\begin{array}[]{cc}x\\ y\\ \end{array}}\right]=\left[{\begin{array}[]{cc}o(1)&P+o(1)\\ Q+o(1)&-P+o(1)\\ \end{array}}\right]\left[{\begin{array}[]{cc}u\\ v\\ \end{array}}\right] This gives \displaystyle\left[{\begin{array}[]{cc}u\\ v\\ \end{array}}\right]=\left[{\begin{array}[]{cc}\frac{1}{Q}+o(1)&\frac{1}{Q}+o(1)\\ \frac{1}{P}+o(1)&o(1)\\ \end{array}}\right]\left[{\begin{array}[]{cc}x\\ y\\ \end{array}}\right] Recall that u=s\ln\frac{1}{s},v=t\ln\frac{1}{t} . Thus s=\frac{u}{\ln\frac{1}{s}},t=\frac{v}{\ln\frac{1}{t}} . Since \ln{\frac{1}{s}}=(1+o(1))\ln{\frac{1}{u}},\ln{\frac{1}{t}}=(1+o(1))\ln{\frac{1}{v}}, we have s=\frac{u}{(1+o(1))\ln{\frac{1}{u}}},t=\frac{v}{(1+o(1))\ln{\frac{1}{v}}}. As a consequence, we obtain \displaystyle s \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{\left(\frac{1}{Q}+o(1)\right)x+\left(\frac{1}{Q}+o(1)\right)y}{\left(1+o(1)\right)\ln\left(\frac{1}{\left(\frac{1}{Q}+o(1)\right)x+\left(\frac{1}{Q}+o(1)\right)y}\right)} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{\frac{x}{Q}+\frac{y}{Q}+o(x)+o(y)}{\ln\left(\frac{Q}{x+y}\right)} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{x+y+o(x)+o(y)}{Q\ln\frac{1}{x+y}}, where the last equality holds since \lim_{x+y\to 0}\frac{\ln\frac{Q}{x+y}}{\ln\frac{1}{x+y}}=1. Similarly, we have \displaystyle t \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{x+o(x)+o(y)}{P\ln\frac{1}{x}}. By Proposition 4.6 , substituting s and t with x and y , we find that (13) \displaystyle\operatorname{Area}(L(a(s,t),b(s,t),c(s,t),p_{0},q_{0})) \displaystyle= \displaystyle a(0,0)+\beta_{1}t+\beta_{2}s+\beta_{11}t^{2}\ln\frac{1}{t}+\beta_{22}s^{2}\ln\frac{1}{s} \displaystyle+o(st\ln\frac{1}{t})+o(t^{2}\ln\frac{1}{t})+o(s^{2}\ln\frac{1}{s}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle a(0,0)+\frac{\beta_{1}}{P}\frac{x+o(x)+o(y)}{\ln\frac{1}{x}}+\frac{\beta_{2}}{Q}\frac{x+y+o(x)+o(y)}{\ln\left(\frac{1}{x+y}\right)} \displaystyle+\pi\frac{x^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{x}}+\pi\frac{\left(x+y\right)^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{x+y}}+o\left(\frac{x^{2}+xy+y^{2}}{\ln\left(\frac{1}{x+y}\right)}\right)+o\left(\frac{x^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{x}}\right). Here we use \beta_{11}=\pi P^{2} and \beta_{22}=\pi Q^{2} . On the other hand, we have \mathbf{R}(x,y)\cong S(a(s,t),b(s,t),c(s,t),p_{0},q_{0}) in \mathcal{T}_{0,6} . By Lemma 4.2 , F(\mathbf{R}(x,y)) is the area of L\left(a(s,t),b(s,t),c(s,t),p_{0},q_{0})\right) . Note that a_{0}=a(0,0) and so F(S(a_{0},0,0,p_{0},q_{0}))=a(0,0) . It turns out that ( 13 ) is exactly the value of the function F(\mathbf{R}(x,y)) . Since F(\mathbf{R}(x,y)) is smooth, so is ( 13 ) . Thus, we have (14) \displaystyle\frac{\beta_{1}}{P}\frac{x+o(x)+o(y)}{\ln\frac{1}{x}}+\frac{\beta_{2}}{Q}\frac{x+y+o(x)+o(y)}{\ln\left(\frac{1}{x+y}\right)} \displaystyle+\pi\frac{x^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{x}}+\pi\frac{\left(x+y\right)^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{x+y}}+o\left(\frac{x^{2}+xy+y^{2}}{\ln\left(\frac{1}{x+y}\right)}\right)+o\left(\frac{x^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{x}}\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\delta_{1}x+\delta_{2}y+\delta_{11}x^{2}+\delta_{12}xy+\delta_{22}y^{2}+O\left((x+y)^{3}\right) If we take x\to 0 , then we get \frac{\beta_{2}}{Q}\frac{y+o(y)}{\ln\frac{1}{y}}=\delta_{2}y+\delta_{22}y^{2}+O\left(y^{3}\right). Divide both sides by y and take y\to 0 , we obtain \delta_{2}=0 . So we have \frac{\beta_{2}}{Q}\frac{y+o(y)}{\ln\frac{1}{y}}=\delta_{22}y^{2}+O\left(y^{3}\right). Now we divide both sides by y^{2} and take y\to 0 to conclude that \beta_{2}=0 . As a consequence, the equation ( 14 ) becomes (15) \displaystyle\frac{\beta_{1}}{P}\frac{x+o(x)+o(y)}{\ln\frac{1}{x}}+\pi\frac{x^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{x}}+\pi\frac{\left(x+y\right)^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{x+y}} \displaystyle+o\left(\frac{x^{2}+xy+y^{2}}{\ln\left(\frac{1}{x+y}\right)}\right)+o\left(\frac{x^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{x}}\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\delta_{1}x+\delta_{11}x^{2}+\delta_{12}xy+\delta_{22}y^{2}+O\left((x+y)^{3}\right) If we take y\to 0 , then we get \displaystyle\frac{\beta_{1}}{P}\frac{x+o(x)}{\ln\frac{1}{x}}+2\pi\frac{x^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{x}}+o\left(\frac{x^{2}}{\ln\left(\frac{1}{x}\right)}\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\delta_{1}x+\delta_{11}x^{2}+O\left(x^{3}\right). The same analysis as above shows \delta_{1}=\beta_{1}=0 . So the equation ( 15 ) becomes \displaystyle\pi\frac{x^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{x}}+\pi\frac{\left(x+y\right)^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{x+y}} \displaystyle+o\left(\frac{x^{2}+xy+y^{2}}{\ln\left(\frac{1}{x+y}\right)}\right)+o\left(\frac{x^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{x}}\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\delta_{11}x^{2}+\delta_{12}xy+\delta_{22}y^{2}+O\left((x+y)^{3}\right) By taking x\to 0 , we deduce that \displaystyle\pi\frac{y^{2}}{\ln\frac{1}{y}}+o\left(\frac{y^{2}}{\ln\left(\frac{1}{y}\right)}\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\delta_{22}y^{2}+O\left(y^{3}\right). If we divide both sides by y^{2}/\ln\frac{1}{y} , then we obtain \delta_{22}=0 , which is impossible. This completes the proof of Theorem 4.1 .