Hadronic decay branching ratio measurements of the Higgs boson at future colliders using the Holistic Approach Jianfeng Jiang, Yongfeng Zhu, Manqi Ruan Abstract Accurately measuring the properties of the Higgs boson is one of the primary physics objectives of the high-energy frontier. Using a holistic approach that incorporates the inclusive information of reconstructed particles, we estimate the relative statistical uncertainty for the Higgs decay modes H → b ​ b ¯ H\to b\bar{b} , c ​ c ¯ c\bar{c} , g ​ g gg , W ​ W ∗ WW^{*} , and Z ​ Z ∗ ZZ^{*} at the Circular Electron–Positron Collider (CEPC) operating as a Higgs factory with an integrated luminosity of 20 ab -1 . In the Z ⁡ ( μ + ​ μ − ) ​ H Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})H and Z ⁡ ( ν ​ ν ¯ ) ​ H Z(\nu\overline{\nu})H channels, the relative statistical uncertainties for these decay modes are projected to range from 0.38% to 6.56% and 0.17% to 2.55%, respectively. Notably, the projected precisions for H → b ​ b ¯ H\to b\bar{b} , c ​ c ¯ c\bar{c} , g ​ g gg , and W ​ W ∗ WW^{*} closely approach the statistical limits, while the H → Z ​ Z ∗ H\to ZZ^{*} channel remains approximately a factor of two to four with respect to the statistical limits. Compared to the CEPC Snowmass results, the holistic approach boosts the measurement precision by a factor of two to three. The scaling behavior, specifically the dependence of the anticipated accuracy on the training dataset size, is also observed and analyzed. 1 Introduction After the discovery of the Higgs boson at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) in 2012 1 ; 11 , one of the primary objectives of the high-energy physics has been the precise measurement of its properties, in particular its couplings to Standard Model particles. The dominant decay modes of the Higgs boson, H\to b\bar{b},c\bar{c},gg,WW^{*}, and ZZ^{*} , are of paramount importance. Collectively, these channels not only account for the vast majority of the Higgs width but also provide crucial probes of the Yukawa couplings, gauge boson couplings, and the loop-induced coupling to gluons. Nevertheless, these measurements are intrinsically difficult at the LHC, as the hadronic signatures are often obscured by the complicated collision environment, characterized by significant pile-up events and overwhelming QCD backgrounds. On the other hand, an electron-positron Higgs factory, which has been identified as the highest priority for future collider facilities 22 ; 13 , offers a clean environment that is ideal for measuring these Higgs hadronic decay processes. Prominent proposals include the Circular Electron–Positron Collider (CEPC) 10 ; 16 ; 2 ; 3 , the Future Circular Collider (FCC-ee) 4 , the International Linear Collider (ILC) 7 , and the Compact LInear Collider (CLIC) 18 . Artificial intelligence (AI) has significantly advanced data analysis techniques in high-energy physics. Jet origin identification (JOI) 17 classifies jets according to their underlying parton flavor, while one-to-one reconstruction techniques associate detector hits with individual reconstructed particles to identify their species 24 . More recently, color-singlet identification algorithms have been developed to directly associate final-state particles with their parent bosons 27 . The holistic approach 27 , a novel method for signal-background separation, leverages the dimensionality of input information by nearly two orders of magnitude, and has been observed in toy models to enhance the physics reach by roughly a factor of two to six compared to conventional approaches. To improve the Higgs hadronic decay measurement precision and also to understand the performance of the holistic approach under more realistic conditions, we apply this strategy to the Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})H and Z(\nu\bar{\nu})H channels at the CEPC, focusing on the measurement of the five dominant hadronic Higgs decay processes: H\to b\bar{b} , c\bar{c} , gg , WW^{*} , and ZZ^{*} . Compared to the reported results in the CEPC Snowmass study 12 , the measurement precision is improved by up to a factor of two to three. In order to better understand the learning behavior and the data dependency of the model, we further analyze the scaling of measurement precision with respect to the training dataset size and assess its robustness against generator-level uncertainties. This paper is organized as follows: Section 2 introduces the detector model, software framework, AI algorithm, and simulated data samples used in this analysis. Section 3 presents the analyses in the Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})H and Z(\nu\bar{\nu})H channels and the combined results. Section 4 discusses the observed scaling behavior and the generator robustness of the holistic approach. Section 5 provides a summary and outlook. 2 Detector, Samples, and Holistic Approach This study is based on the CEPC operating as a Higgs factory at a center-of-mass energy of 240 GeV, using the AURORA detector model 24 . AURORA is a particle-flow–oriented detector design evolved from the CEPC Conceptual Design Report (CDR) baseline 16 . It features high-granularity electromagnetic and hadronic calorimeters (ECAL and HCAL), a high-precision tracking system with a low material budget, a high-resolution vertex detector, and a large solenoidal magnet enclosing the calorimeters. In addition, both ECAL and HCAL are assumed to provide a per-cell time resolution of 100 ps. A critical figure of merit for hadronic Higgs measurements is the Boson Mass Resolution (BMR). The AURORA detector is designed to achieve a BMR of 2.75%, as illustrated in the invariant mass distributions in the left panel of Figure 1 . Within the AURORA detector concept, near-universal particle identification is achieved, as summarized by the reconstruction confusion matrix in the right panel of Figure 1 . The results demonstrate efficiencies of 97%–100% for charged particles and photons, and 75%–80% for neutral hadrons. Fake particles—such as spurious clusters arising from incorrect calorimeter–track associations—are identified with an efficiency of about 77% and a purity of 97.5%. Figure 1: Overview of the AURORA detector performance. Left: The reconstructed invariant mass distributions for hadronic systems in WW\to\mu\nu q\bar{q} , ZZ\to\nu\nu q\bar{q} , and ZH\to\nu\nu gg processes at \sqrt{s}=240 GeV. Right: Confusion matrix for particle identification (PID) reconstruction, illustrating the identification efficiency for charged particles, photons, and neutral hadrons. The detector concept achieves near-universal particle identification performance. Channel Cross section ( \times BR) [fb] Expected yield ( 20\,\text{ab}^{-1} ) Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})H(b\bar{b}) 3.8 7.7\times 10^{4} Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})H(c\bar{c}) 0.19 3.9\times 10^{3} Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})H(gg) 0.57 1.1\times 10^{4} Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})H(WW^{*}) 0.65 1.3\times 10^{4} Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})H(ZZ^{*}) 0.086 1.7\times 10^{3} Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})Z(q\bar{q}) 51 1.0\times 10^{6} Z(\nu\bar{\nu})H(b\bar{b}) 23 4.5\times 10^{5} Z(\nu\bar{\nu})H(c\bar{c}) 1.2 2.3\times 10^{4} Z(\nu\bar{\nu})H(gg) 3.4 6.8\times 10^{4} Z(\nu\bar{\nu})H(WW^{*}) 3.8 7.7\times 10^{4} Z(\nu\bar{\nu})H(ZZ^{*}) 0.51 1.0\times 10^{4} W(l\nu)W(q\bar{q}) 1200 2.4\times 10^{7} Z(\nu\bar{\nu})Z(q\bar{q}) 150 3.0\times 10^{6} q\bar{q} 54000 1.1\times 10^{10} Table 1: Expected yields and cross section( \times\text{BR} ) for Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})H , Z(\nu\bar{\nu})H and main background processes at 240 GeV center-of-mass energy with an integrated luminosity of 20\,\text{ab}^{-1} . The samples used in this study are generated with MadGraph_aMC@NLO 5 and Pythia8 9 . Fast simulations are performed using Delphes 14 for the process e^{+}e^{-}\to ZH with Z\to\mu^{+}\mu^{-} or \nu\bar{\nu} , and with the Higgs boson decaying into the five dominant hadronic modes: H\to b\bar{b} , c\bar{c} , gg , WW^{*} , and ZZ^{*} . With this fast simulation, a BMR of approximately 3% is achieved. Standard Model background processes, including e^{+}e^{-}\to ZZ , WW , and q\bar{q} , are generated to estimate contamination in the signal regions. The cross sections and expected event yields for all signal and background processes, normalized to an integrated luminosity of 20~\mathrm{ab}^{-1} , are summarized in Table 1 . The holistic approach is implemented using the ParticleNet architecture 20 , a dynamic graph neural network that represents each collision event as a particle cloud. The core building block of ParticleNet is the EdgeConv operation, which aggregates features from each particle and its k nearest neighbors in the event. By stacking multiple EdgeConv blocks, the network performs message passing to learn local and global correlations, enabling the extraction of high-level representations directly from the particle cloud. The EdgeConv layers are followed by a channel-wise global average pooling layer and two fully connected layers, with a softmax activation used to produce event-level classification scores. The input features provided to the network encode comprehensive information from reconstructed particles, including: • Geometric coordinates : The angular variables \Delta\eta and \Delta\phi , defined relative to a reference axis. 1 1 1 To explicitly capture the global topology of the ZH process, a reference axis is introduced for coordinate transformation. For the Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})H channel, the reference axis is defined by the recoil system (the Higgs candidate), p_{\mathrm{recoil}}=p_{\mathrm{initial}}-p_{\mu\mu} . For the Z(\nu\bar{\nu})H channel, it is defined by the missing momentum vector (the Z boson candidate), p_{\mathrm{missing}}=p_{\mathrm{initial}}-p_{\mathrm{visible}} . These coordinates are used to construct the dynamic k -nearest-neighbor graph. • Kinematic variables : The transverse momentum ( p_{T} ) and energy ( E ), together with their normalized fractions ( p_{T}/p_{T,\mathrm{evt}} and E/E_{\mathrm{evt}} ). The angular distance \Delta R=\sqrt{\Delta\eta^{2}+\Delta\phi^{2}} and the particle charge are also included. • Impact parameters : The transverse ( d_{0} ) and longitudinal ( d_{z} ) impact parameters of the track, which are essential for resolving displaced vertices from heavy-flavor ( b and c ) decays. • Particle identification : One-hot encoded labels for the seven reconstructed particle species: \mu^{\pm},e^{\pm},\gamma,\pi^{\pm},K^{\pm},p^{\pm} , and neutral hadrons. To study the scaling behavior with respect to the size of the training dataset, independent training samples are generated with sizes logarithmically spaced between 10^{4} and 10^{6} events. A fixed validation dataset of 2\times 10^{5} events is used for hyperparameter tuning and model checkpointing to mitigate overfitting. The final performance, quantified in terms of efficiency, purity, and confusion matrices, is evaluated using an independent inference dataset of 8\times 10^{5} events, ensuring statistical robustness. 3 Higgs Hadronic Decay Measurements For the measurement of different Higgs decay processes in \mu^{+}\mu^{-}H and \nu\bar{\nu}H channels, we use the relative statistical uncertainty to evaluate the measurement performance. The relative statistical uncertainty is calculated as \Delta\mu/\mu=\sqrt{S+B}/S , where S and B denote the expected signal and background yields surviving the selection, respectively. 3.1 \mu^{+}\mu^{-}H Figure 2: Confusion matrix for the Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})H classification task using the holistic approach, trained on 1M events. Matrix elements are normalized to a unit in each row. In the Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})H channel, the presence of two isolated high-momentum muons provides an efficient trigger and allows for strong suppression of Standard Model backgrounds, except semileptonic ZZ production 19 . We therefore apply the holistic approach to directly discriminate among the different Higgs decay processes and the semileptonic ZZ background. A training dataset of 10^{6} events are used for each Higgs decay process and for the ZZ background in a multi-class classification setup. Figure 3: Score distributions and relative statistical uncertainties for H\to b\bar{b} , H\to c\bar{c} , H\to gg , H\to WW^{*} , and H\to ZZ^{*} processes in the Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})H analysis using holistic approach trained on 1M events. The purple curve denotes the signal, while the colored histograms show the backgrounds. The red solid curve gives the statistical uncertainty versus the score cut, and the vertical red dashed line marks the optimal score cut. Figure 2 shows the resulting confusion matrix, where each row represents the classification efficiency for a given process. A pronounced diagonal structure is observed, in which the dominant Standard Model background, Z(\mu^{+}\mu^{-})Z(q\bar{q}) , is strongly suppressed, achieving a classification efficiency of 99.25%. Among the Higgs decay processes, H\to b\bar{b} attains the highest classification efficiency. This is primarily due to the presence of multiple secondary vertices in b -jets and the more compact event topology compared to the broader topologies of H\to WW^{*} and H\to ZZ^{*} decays. The classification efficiencies for H\to c\bar{c} and H\to gg are 90.03% and 84.40%, respectively. The separation of H\to WW^{*} and H\to ZZ^{*} remains more challenging because of their similar decay topologies, and the observed asymmetric misidentification between these two channels warrants further investigation. Figure 3 presents the classifier score distributions for H\to b\bar{b} , H\to c\bar{c} , H\to gg , H\to WW^{*} , and H\to ZZ^{*} processes. For the H\to b\bar{b} process, characterized by distinct signatures and a relatively large cross-section, a loose selection threshold (score >0.11 ) is sufficient to achieve high precision. In contrast, the H\to c\bar{c} process demands a stringent threshold (score >0.90 ) to effectively suppress the significant gluon backgrounds. The optimized statistical uncertainties are 0.38% for H\to b\bar{b} , 2.23% for H\to c\bar{c} , 1.18% for H\to gg , 1.03% for H\to WW^{*} , and 6.56% for H\to ZZ^{*} . Notably, except for the H\to ZZ^{*} process, these projections closely approach the ultimate statistical limit ( 1/\sqrt{N_{sig}} ) of 0.36%, 1.61%, 0.94%, and 0.88% for H\to b\bar{b} , H\to c\bar{c} , H\to gg , and H\to WW^{*} , respectively. 3.2 \nu\bar{\nu}H For the Z(\nu\bar{\nu})H channel, the dominant background contributions arise from four-fermion processes (such as e^{+}e^{-}\to ZZ and e^{+}e^{-}\to W^{+}W^{-} ) and two-fermion ( e^{+}e^{-}\to q\bar{q} ) processes according to the studies in 23 . Therefore, a pre-selection based on kinematic variables is needed to suppress these backgrounds. These pre-selection criteria are optimized to maximize the product of signal efficiency and signal purity, including: p_{T,\text{evt}}>10 GeV, 6010 GeV 6010 GeV, 60