How negative feedback from filamentous actin affects cell shapes and motility Jack M. Hughes, Jupiter Algorta, Leah Edelstein-Keshet Abstract The crawling motility of many eukaryotic cells is driven by filamentous actin (F-actin), and regulated by a network of signaling proteins and lipids (including small GTPases). The tangle of positive and negative feedback loops gives rise to various experimentally observed dynamic patterns (“actin waves”). Here we consider a recent prototypical model for actin waves in which F-actin exerts negative feedback onto a GTPase. Guided by recent numerical PDE bifurcation analysis in [ 25 , 27 ] , we explore cell shapes and motility associated with polar, oscillatory, and traveling waves solutions of a mass-conserved partial differential equation (PDE) model. We use Morpheus (cellular Potts) simulations to investigate the implications of such regimes of behavior on the shapes and motion of cells, and on transitions between modes of behavior. The model demonstrates various cell states, including resting (spatially uniform GTPase), polar cells (static “zones” of GTPase), and traveling waves along the cell edge. In some parameter regimes, such states can coexist, so that cells can transition from one behavior to another in response to noisy stimuli. 1 Introduction Understanding eukaryotic cell motility continues to be one of the grand challenges of modern cell biology, engendering both experimental and theoretical research. Experimentally, many complex cell motility modes have been observed in a wide variety of cell types [ 7 , 37 , 40 , 52 ] . Commonly, cells experience directed cell motion, which is key in many biological processes including cancer metastasis [ 47 ] and wound healing [ 55 , 58 ] . Other modes of motility can also occur such as random amoeboid-type motion, and cell turning and ruffling. Among the fundamental questions to be addressed, we ask how cell motility is regulated and what causes cells to change motility modes. While new mechanisms powering cell motility are continually being discovered, the leading role of filamantous actin (F-actin) is well-recognized in basic directed migration of neutrophils, keratocytes, social amoeba (Dictyostelum discoideum) and other cell types. F-actin is a key player in cell motility because the “barbed ends” of these filaments, at which actin monomers assemble, accumulate near the front edge of a cell and cause the edge to protrude outwards. However, it is not always clear what interactions between F-actin and its regulators are at the core of the complex motility machinery. Our interest here is in accounting for basic cell motility patterns such as directed motion, turning, ruffling, and random motility. We consider a small subset of the central signaling network, consisting of a small GTPase (such as Rho, Rac, or Cdc42) ( fig. 1 a) and the interaction with F-actin. GTPases act as molecular switches, with the active form bound to the membrane and the inactive in the cell interior (cytosol). The activation and inactivation of these GTPases are on the scale of seconds/minutes, while any loss or production is on a much longer scale [ 34 ] . This justifies the common modeling assumption that the total quantity of a given GTPase is conserved over the timescale of interest for motile cells (minutes). The conversion from inactive to active form is governed by GEFs (guanine nucleotide exchange factors) and the reverse by GAPs (GTPase-activating proteins). The patterns induced by these Rho-GTPases dictate the distribution of F-actin. Recent experimental evidence shows that F-actin is not only governed by Rho GTPases but, in certain cells, it can also affect the activity of the GTPase. Feedback between GTPases and F-actin results in a variety of experimentally observable dynamic patterns, commonly denoted “actin waves” [ 4 , 6 , 7 , 9 , 10 , 12 , 17 , 19 , 20 , 31 , 39 , 36 , 54 , 59 ] . For example, F-actin can promote GTPase inactivation by recruiting GAPs [ 8 ] ( fig. 1 b). This negative feedback loop leads to many interesting actin wave structures and forms the basis of the actin waves modeling in this paper. Experimental work shows a rich structure of waves along the cell edge, including oscillatory waves [ 20 ] , traveling waves along the cell front [ 7 ] and waves on the cell membrane [ 60 , 38 ] . Thus, these wave-like dynamics appear in many different settings, although the proposed mechanisms governing these patterns vary. A key motivation of our work is to explore how these actin waves affect cell motility. Models describing actin waves tend to be complex, often relying on numerical simulations alone to understand model behavior. Such studies favor model details over unraveling generic model structure. It can be challenging to fully understand the results. Using simulations alone can also miss important parameter regimes where there is coexistence of different behaviors or transitions from one behavior to another. In this work, we leverage a previous study that analyzed a simple reaction-diffusion (RD) model for actin waves [ 27 ] . There, numerical bifurcation analysis was used to identify a mathematical mechanism for coexistence of polar patterns (with a clear front and back) and multi-peak traveling waves suspected to lead to directed cell motion and cell ruffling, respectively. In particular, a parameter regime was identified where such patterns are stable and coexist. Other works in which numerical bifurcation analysis has been used to study actin waves models include [ 10 , 61 ] . Here, our key motivation is to then determine what types of cell shapes and motility occur based on the structures identified by [ 27 ] . The intracellular dynamics of actin waves only provides part of the picture at the cell-scale. To understand how actin waves affect cell shape and motility, the dynamics must be coupled to a model for cell deformations. Common techniques for capturing deformable cell domains include Lagrangian marker point, level set methods [ 43 ] , phase field methods [ 46 , 15 , 5 ] , finite elements [ 16 , 18 ] , and Metropolis-based methods including the cellular Potts model (CPM) [ 3 ] . Additional references using such methods can be found in the reviews by [ 1 , 11 , 13 , 14 , 24 , 48 , 50 ] . The goal of the present study is to provide a simple, reproducible connection between the reaction-diffusion dynamics and cell deformations so that cell-scale structures can be studied. Therefore, we use the CPM framework [ 22 ] , as this is arguably the simplest [ 2 ] and can be easily implemented using the open source software package Morpheus [ 49 ] . For the basics on the CPM framework, see appendix B . Many previous papers have described dynamic cell shapes using the CPM formalism, and many of those papers have included PDEs for the proteins that regulate F-actin and cell motion. Examples include [ 35 , 32 , 44 ] . These examples are more advanced in that they simulated PDEs inside fully 2D deforming cell domains. However, none of these works had accompanying PDE bifurcation analysis, nor did they attempt to map out the mechanisms for transitions between multiple observed cell behaviors. Also, since previous simulations were done with custom-made proprietary codes, reproducing previous results, or building upon them, remains challenging. To address these issues, we use the open source simulation platform Morpheus, together with the numerical bifurcation analysis by [ 25 , 27 ] . To investigate cell shape and motility, we construct initial conditions and choose parameter values near key locations along the solution branches. We depict cell shapes using CPM simulations, where outward protrusion updates are favored in areas with high F-actin concentration. Our results demonstrate transitions between directed cell motion, cell turning, and ruffling based on the intracellular dynamics of actin waves. 2 Methods 2.1 The signaling model The model of interest consists of two underlying subsystems. The first is the main regulatory unit (e.g. Rho GTPase) whose active ( u ) and inactive ( v ) forms satisfy overall mass conservation ( fig. 1 a). This subsystem, denoted “wave-pinning” was studied by [ 41 ] as a model for cell polarization: the PDE model supports a stable pattern with a zone of high Rho activity under appropriate conditions. The second subsystem, F-actin ( F ) is promoted by the GTPase, and provides negative feedback that enhances the inactivation of the GTPase ( fig. 1 b). Similar circuits have been modeled in both theoretical [ 23 , 32 ] and experiment-modeling papers [ 9 , 21 , 31 , 39 , 51 ] (see section A.3 for more details). We model the uvF system using the dimensionless set of partial differential equations \displaystyle\frac{\partial u}{\partial t} \displaystyle=(b+\gamma u^{2})v-(1+sF+u^{2})u+D_{u}u_{xx}, (1a) \displaystyle\frac{\partial v}{\partial t} \displaystyle=-(b+\gamma u^{2})v+(1+sF+u^{2})u+D_{v}v_{xx}, (1b) \displaystyle\frac{\partial F}{\partial t} \displaystyle=\omega(p_{0}+p_{1}u-F)+D_{F}F_{xx}, (1c) in one spatial dimension (1D) with periodic boundary conditions on the domain (0,1) to represent the edge of a cell (see fig. 1 c, and appendix A for derivation and nondimensionalization of the original model). The spatial domain is scaled by the cell perimeter, L , so that the domain is 0\leq x\leq 1 (see section A.2 ). Importantly, this model preserves the total mass of the GTPase, i.e., \displaystyle M:=\int_{0}^{1}[u(x,t)+v(x,t)]{\textrm{d}}x=\text{constant}. (2) A typical polar pattern throughout a thin, flat 2D cell shape ( fig. 1 c, left) is simplified to the corresponding pattern along the cell edge ( fig. 1 c, right). For example, a zone of active Rho corresponds, in this geometry, to a peak or plateau of u . The model includes terms for Rho activation (basal, b and self-amplifying, \gamma ) and inactivation (basal and GTPase dependent rate normalized to 1, F-actin dependent rate, s ). The GTPase diffusion rates satisfy D_{u}0 ) suggesting the emergence of traveling and standing waves [ 30 , 57 ] , long wavelengths (LWs, \sigma=0 for q\to 0 ), which have been shown to lead to the emergence of polar patterns after subsequent bifurcations [ 27 ] , and, for completeness, homogeneous Hopf bifurcations (HBs, \sigma=\pm i\omega for q=0 ) are shown. (Note that in this regime, no Turing bifurcations are found ( \sigma=0 for q=q_{\ast}>0 ).) Thus, this diagram provides a useful starting point for further analysis. It is important to note that this figure only shows where new spatiotemporal patterns emerge but not whether the solutions are stable or for which parameter values they exist. In particular, these curves do not represent boundaries where patterns exist only on one side. Instead, they denote parameter sets where spatiotemporal patterns emerge from the uniform steady states. Figure 2 : Two-parameter bifurcation diagram of uniform steady states: Parameters b,s were used to produce the two-parameter plane shown above. In [ 27 ] , two-parameter continuation was applied to eq. 1 to trace the onsets of bifurcations of the homogeneous steady states (HSSs). The bifurcations shown are finite wavenumber Hopfs (WB), long wavelengths (LW), homogeneous Hopfs (HB), and saddle-nodes (SN). The black-striped subset of the yellow region corresponds to the bistability region, where two HSSs out of three are stable. In the solely yellow-shaded region, there is at most one stable HSS. Note that the curves only indicate onsets of bifurcations, not regions of existence of a given pattern. The dashed lines denote b -value slices corresponding to values used in the parameter sweeps of the model eq. 1 given in figs. 3 and 19 . The curves shown in fig. 2 identify onsets where new types of spatiotemporal behaviors can emerge. Tuning the basal activation rate b (moving vertically on the diagram) or the negative feedback rate s (moving horizontally) can lead to identifying such onsets. Special points at the intersections of two curves (“codimension-2” bifurcations) denote parameter sets where both bifurcations occur simultaneously. Important in this work and previously identified in [ 27 ] is the codimension-2 bifurcation, where a long wavelength and finite wavenumber Hopf occur simultaneously. In [ 27 ] , we showed that solutions representing polar and traveling wave states emerge from such a bifurcation, as described in more detail below. Guided by the results of the numerical bifurcation analysis shown in fig. 2 a, we identified an interesting region of the sb parameter space to explore. We then varied s and b in a 7\times 4 grid of values close to the codimension-2 point, and plotted the space-time solutions of the PDE equations eq. 1 as kymographs. We used initial conditions of the form a+b\cos(2\pi x/L) for each component, which favors the formation of solutions symmetric about x=L/2 , i.e., stationary (polar) solutions. Results are shown in fig. 3 . In each sub-panel, the spatial component (vertical axis) represents position along the cell edge, and time t along the positive horizontal axis. The color map displays the intensity of GTPase activity, u(x,t) . Uniform color depicts a cell edge with no “GTPase zone”. A horizontal band of color denotes a plateau of elevated GTPase (consistent with a polarized cell), and slanted stripes describe traveling waves (TW) that move clockwise or anti-clockwise around the cell perimeter. In order to test for coexisting (bistable) behavior, we introduced random noise for a short time period to “scramble” the solution and permit a transition to another behavior that exists for the same parameter set. Several such transitions are evident in fig. 3 , from polar to wave-like solutions ( s\approx 0.5 and 0\leq b\leq 0.15 ), and from uniform to wave-like solutions ( 0.7\leq s\leq 0.9 and 0\leq b\leq 0.15 ). Note that initially the solutions are symmetric, e.g. polar and uniform patterns, because of the choice of initial condition. We also see cases where waves move in one direction, or in opposite directions. We found that if s is too high or too small, no wave-type solutions were possible. Figure 19 is another parameter sweep with L=2\lambda , showing that fewer types of transient dynamics are possible with smaller domain lengths but the overall “long run” dynamics are similar. These full PDE solutions confirm the predictions of the bifurcation study. We further plotted the profiles of all three variables, u,v,F at the final time point ( t=400 ) to demonstrate the relationship of the model components. As shown in fig. 4 , the inactive GTPase is nearly spatially uniform, while the dominant patterns reside in u,F . (This follows from the fact that v diffuses fastest, so that it rapidly redistributes along the domain.) Furthermore, we note that for the propagating solutions, such as the traveling waves, the peak of F trails after the peak of u (see the arrows in fig. 4 that denote the direction of propagation). This behavior arises from the diffusion coefficients, that is, D_{F}0 , then accept the new configuration with a probability e^{-\Delta H/T} , where T is the Boltzmann temperature parameter. While the canonical CPM selects sites randomly from the entire lattice, Morpheus [ 49 ] , the software package we use, optimizes this by selecting only sites at the boundaries between cell and medium where configuration changes can occur. In our implementation, we also apply the perimeter constraint using an “aspherity” parameter, which instead computes the perimeter relative to that of a circle with the same area as the CPM cell. The area constraint implies that cell protrusion along part of the edge is inherently balanced by a tendency to retract other parts of the cell and the perimeter constraint acts as an effective “membrane tension” or stiffness that governs overall cell shape. To capture the effects of F-actin on cell shape and motility, the PDEs eq. 1 are solved at each point on the CPM cell edge. Updates to the CPM simulation that protrude the cell edge at x , a location along the cell edge, are favored if the value of F-actin, F(x,t) , is high. This results in an additional term added to the Hamiltonian. For each simulation, the cell is initiated as a circle. Appendix C More bifurcation diagrams and parameter sweeps Here, we present additional bifurcation diagrams and another parameter sweep. Figure 17 shows all stationary solutions emerging from the HSSs when L=3\lambda and the traveling wave solutions with the same wavelength. We include this figure to demonstrate that traveling waves with different wavelengths also exist/coexist and only unipolar patterns are stable. In fig. 18 we show a similar structure when L=2\lambda . In fig. 19 , we show a parameter sweep as in fig. 3 , but with L=2\lambda . Polar, traveling wave, and time-periodic solutions resembling counter-propagating waves are still observed; however, unlike the L=3\lambda case, there are no transient interactions with these solutions. Figure 17 : Polar and traveling waves of various wavelength: As in fig. 5 but showcasing traveling waves (TWs) and polar patterns (PPs) with wavelengths \lambda , 3\lambda/2 and 3\lambda . The notation 3TW λ denotes TWs with wavelength \lambda and three spatial copies. This figure shows part of the bifurcation structure for simulations in figs. 7 , 9 and 8 . The traveling wave solutions represent cell turning (TW 3λ ) and ruffling (2TW 3λ/2 and 3TW λ ). The polar solutions PP 3λ , 2PP 3λ/2 , and 3PP λ represent polar, bipolar, and tripolar solutions, respectively. However, as before, only stable solutions (solid branches) are biologically observable. Figure 18 : Coexistence of polar and ruffling states in smaller cells: Single parameter bifurcation diagram as in fig. 17 but with L=2\lambda . This figure shows part of the bifurcation structure for simulations in figs. 10 and 11 . Here, we show unipolar (PP 2λ ) and bipolar (2PP λ ) solutions, and traveling waves with 1 peak (TW 2λ , “turning”) and 2 peaks (2TW λ , “ruffling”). The shaded regions denote various existence and coexistence regimes of nonlinear patterns: yellow - polarization (P), orange - polarization and ruffling (P&R), purple - ruffling (R), red - ruffling and turning (R&T), and brown - turning (T). Cell turning with a perimeter L=2\lambda is shown in the top panel of fig. 11 . Figure 19 : Parameter sweep with L=2\lambda : As in fig. 3 but with L=2\lambda . When L=2\lambda , time-periodic solutions resembling counter-propagating waves and coexistence of polar and traveling wave solutions are still observed. Other parameter values as in table I . Appendix D Simulation details Unless otherwise stated, we used parameter values given in table I with b=0.067 . Table I : Model parameter values: Dimensionless parameter values used in simulations Parameter Definition Value b GTPase basal activation rate varied \gamma GTPase feedback activation rate 3.557 s F-actin dependent inactivation rate varied \omega F-actin time scale parameter 0.6 p_{0} F-actin basal growth rate 0.8 p_{1} GTPase dependent F-actin growth rate 3.8 L Cell perimeter varied D_{u} Active GTPase diffusion rate 0.1 /L^{2} D_{v} Inactive GTPase diffusion rate 1 /L^{2} D_{F} F-actin diffusion rate 0.001 /L^{2} M Average GTPase density 2 Figure 7 : Domain length: L=3\lambda , where \lambda\approx 3.09 is the numerically solved for wavelength that leads to the WB of the codimension-2 LW/WB. The three simulations use the s values 0.376,0.475,0.519 . Initial conditions: \displaystyle u(x,0) \displaystyle=0.75-0.5\cos(x), (11a) \displaystyle v(x,0) \displaystyle=1.25+0.1\cos(x), (11b) \displaystyle F(x,0) \displaystyle=3.5-2\cos(x). (11c) Figure 8 : Domain length: L=3\lambda and s values 0.413,0.475,0.607 . Initial conditions: \displaystyle u(x,0) \displaystyle=1-0.5\cos(3x)-0.32\sin(3x), (12a) \displaystyle v(x,0) \displaystyle=1+0.028\cos(3x)+0.08\sin(3x), (12b) \displaystyle F(x,0) \displaystyle=4.6-2\cos(3x). (12c) Figure 9 : Same initial conditions, domain length, and parameters as for fig. 7 , but with s=0.54 . Figure 10 : Domain length: L=2\lambda and s=0.6 . Initial conditions: \displaystyle u(x,0) \displaystyle=0.75-0.5\cos(x), (13a) \displaystyle v(x,0) \displaystyle=1.25+0.1\cos(x), (13b) \displaystyle F(x,0) \displaystyle=3.5-2\cos(x). (13c) Figure 11 : Same initial conditions, domain length, and parameter values as for fig. 10 but with s=0.8 and noise added to the GTPase equations for 150\leq t\leq 200 . In particular, we added Noise: \xi(x,t)=4\mathcal{N}, where \mathcal{N} is a standard normal random number at each grid and time point. The noise was implemented as follows: \displaystyle\frac{du}{dt} \displaystyle=(b+\gamma u^{2})v-(1+sF+u^{2})u+D\triangle u+\xi(x,t), (14a) \displaystyle\frac{dv}{dt} \displaystyle=-(b+\gamma u^{2})v+(1+sF+u^{2})u+\triangle v-\xi(x,t). (14b) to maintain mass conservation. Figure 12 : Domain length: L=5 . Parameter values as in table I , but with a time-dependent F-actin dependent inactivation rate, with parameters s_{0}=0.475 and s_{f}=0.6 \displaystyle s(t)=\begin{cases}s_{0}&t<125,\\ s_{0}-(s_{0}-s_{f})(t-125)/250&125\leq t\leq 375,\\ s_{f}&t>375.\end{cases} (15) Initial conditions given by eq. 13 . Figure 13 : Same domain length and parameters as for fig. 12 but with the starting and ending values of s interchanged, i.e., s_{0}=0.6 and s_{f}=0.475 . Initial conditions: \displaystyle u(x,0) \displaystyle=0.07+2\text{sech}(3(x-L/2)), (16a) \displaystyle v(x,0) \displaystyle=M-u(x,0), (16b) \displaystyle F(x,0) \displaystyle=1.15+5\text{sech}(3(x-L/3)), (16c) where M=2 . Figure 14 : Same domain length, parameters, and initial conditions as for fig. 12 but with s changing randomly in time within the interval [0.475,0.6] (see the xml file for implementation details Dicty.xml ). Figure 16 : Domain length: L=4\lambda and s=0.8 . Initial conditions: \displaystyle u(x,0) \displaystyle=1-0.5\cos(x), (17a) \displaystyle v(x,0) \displaystyle=1+0.1\cos(x), (17b) \displaystyle F(x,0) \displaystyle=4.5-0.82\cos(x). (17c) Continual spatiotemporal noise was added similarly to fig. 11 but of the form \displaystyle\xi(x,t)=2[(1+\sin(x))((1-\cos(6.5t/100))^{2})+(1-\sin(x))(1+\cos(6.5t/100))^{2}]\mathcal{N}, (18) where \mathcal{N} is a standard normal random number at each grid and time point. The noise was then added and subtracted to the active and inactive GTPase equations as in eq. 14 .