Constraints on non-standard neutrino interactions from Borexino extended data-set V. Antonelli 1, D. Basilico 1, G. Bellini 1, J. Benziger 2, R. Biondi 3,a, B. Caccianiga 1, F. Calaprice 4, A. Caminata 5, A. Chepurnov 6, D. D’Angelo 1, A. Derbin 7, A. Di Giacinto 3, V. Di Marcello 3, X.F. Ding 4,b, A. Di Ludovico 3,4, L. Di Noto 5, I. Drachnev 7, D. Franco 8, C. Galbiati 4,9, C. Ghiano 3, M. Giammarchi 1, A. Goretti 4, M. Gromov 6,22, D. Guffanti 10,c, Aldo Ianni 3, Andrea Ianni 4, A. Jany 11, V. Kobychev 12, G. Korga 13,14, S. Kumaran 15,16,d, M. Laubenstein 3, E. Litvinovich 17,18, P. Lombardi 1, I. Lomskaya 7, L. Ludhova 15,16,e,10, I. Machulin 17,18, J. Martyn 10, E. Meroni 1, L. Miramonti 1, M. Misiaszek 11, V. Muratova 7, L. Oberauer 19, V. Orekhov 10, F. Ortica 20, M. Pallavicini 5, L. Pelicci 1, Ö. Penek 15,f, L. Pietrofaccia 3, N. Pilipenko 7, A. Pocar 21, G. Raikov 17, M.T. Ranalli 3, G. Ranucci 1, A. Razeto 3, A. Re 1, N. Rossi 3, S. Schönert 19, D. Semenov 7, G. Settanta 15,g, M. Skorokhvatov 17,18, A. Singhal 15,16,h, O. Smirnov 22, A. Sotnikov 22, G. Sun 25, R. Tartaglia 3, G. Testera 5, M.D.C. Torri 1, E. Unzhakov 7, A. Vishneva 22, R.B. Vogelaar 23, F. von Feilitzsch 19, M. Wojcik 11, M. Wurm 10, S. Zavatarelli 5, X. Zhou 25, K. Zuber 24, G. Zuzel 11, The BOREXINO collaboration – email: spokesperson-borex@lngs.infn.it Abstract Neutrino non-standard interactions (NSI) constitute an active research field, as they are closely related to potential new physics associated with dark matter searches and exotic interactions arising from fundamental symmetry violations. The Borexino’s unprecedented sensitivity to solar neutrinos, derived from its low background and precision spectral measurements, enables stringent constraints on potential deviations from the standard three-flavor neutrino oscillation paradigm. This work presents an update on the analysis of flavor-diagonal NSI using the full Borexino Phase-III data set, extending the study previously reported in Constraints on flavor-diagonal non-standard neutrino interactions from Borexino Phase-II (JHEP 2020, 38). The updated analysis incorporates the extended temporal and statistical coverage of Phase-III. The results indicate improved sensitivity to the diagonal NSI parameters, with constraints exceeding those obtained in Phase-II. Furthermore, a more general analysis that includes all possible off-diagonal NSI terms is presented for the first time, providing a comprehensive exploration of the NSI parameter space associated with the flavors of the incoming and outgoing neutrinos. This work once again underlines the Borexino’s critical role in probing new physics scenarios and reinforces its legacy in neutrino research. Detailed comparisons with Phase-II results are discussed, along with implications for theoretical models of NSI. Introduction Non-standard neutrino interactions (NSI) refer to hypothetical interactions between neutrinos and other particles that deviate from the predictions of the Standard Model (SM) of particle physics. Although the SM has been incredibly successful in describing the fundamental particles and their interactions, it does not account for all observed phenomena, such as gravity, dark matter, and dark energy. Besides those fundamental questions, the neutrino plays a special role as a unique portal on the physics beyond SM. In particular, NSI go exactly in this direction: investigating them could help us understand the nature of neutrino masses and mixing, provide insights into the origins of matter-antimatter asymmetry, and explore connections to dark matter and other exotic particles related to the possible violation of the axial/vector interaction. The Borexino experiment has made significant contributions to science with its discoveries and precise measurements of the nuclear processes that power the Sun and stars bib:bell . With its exceptional low background in the energy range of approximately 150 keV to 15 MeV, Borexino was the only experiment able to detect all the components of solar neutrino spectrum, and, therefore, it greatly contributed to advance our understanding of neutrino oscillations, by measuring simultaneously the survival probability in vacuum and in matter. In previous studies bib:bxnsi , exploiting data from the detector Phase-II, we analyzed flavor-diagonal NSI, paving the way for understanding how NSI could modify neutrino-electron elastic scattering and the survival probability of solar neutrinos. Starting from the previous result, we now extend our analysis to a more comprehensive data set including Phase-III, aiming to refine and improve our constraints on NSI. This larger data set offers higher statistics, allowing us to explore more in detail the potential existence of NSI and their implications for neutrino interactions. In Sec. I we review the main features of the Borexino detector and its most important results in neutrino physics. Furthermore, we review the basic analysis strategy and the characteristics of the extended dataset for the NSI analysis upgrade. In Sec. II we discuss the theoretical framework of NSI, highlighting the difference of the parameter choice between the old and the new analysis, consisting mainly in the inclusion of the off-diagonal terms. In Sec. III we discuss the analysis strategy, showing the new Monte Carlo based approach. Finally in Sec. IV we report the results of the new analysis, comparing and contrasting it with the old publication and discussing the implications of the results in a wider context including results from other experiments. This document is followed by a series of appendices, reporting the details of the formalism and calculations used in the main analysis. In order not to deviate the reader from the main content, all those technicalities are reported at the end and can be checked by the most curious readers. I The Borexino detector Borexino was mainly detecting neutrinos via the scattering off electrons given by the reaction \nu_{x}+e^{-}\rightarrow\nu_{x}+e^{-} , where \nu_{x} represents neutrinos of all types interacting with neutral and / or charged current, depending on the flavor according to SM. Borexino was reconstructing the energy, position, and other features of each event in real time. The detector was located in Hall C of the Laboratori Nazionali Gran Sasso (LNGS) of the Italian Institute of Nuclear Physics (INFN) bib:lngs . The detector had been taking data from mid-2007 to the end of 2021, and is currently under decommissioning. The detector is made of spherical concentric layers of increasing radiopurity (see bib:tech for details): the innermost core, called the Inner Vessel (IV), consists of about 280 tons of liquid scintillator ( pseudocumene mixed with 1.5 g/l of PPO as scintillating solute) contained inside an ultra-pure nylon vessel with a thickness of 125 \upmu m and a radius of 4.25 m. A Stainless Steel Sphere (SSS), filled with the remaining 1000 m 3 of buffer liquid ( pseudocumene mixed with dimethylphthalate quencher) is instrumented with 2212 PMTs to detect scintillation light inside the IV. Ultimately, the SSS is placed inside a water tank (WT) with a volume of 2400 m 3 , which functions as a Cerenkov veto system, equipped with 200 PMTs. Using results from the study of internal residual contaminations and from the 2010 calibration, it was found that the detector is capable of determining the event position with an accuracy of \sim 10 cm (at 1 MeV) and the event energy with a resolution following approximately the relation \sigma(E)/E\simeq 5\%/\sqrt{E/[MeV]} . The Borexino data set is divided into three different phases: Phase-I, from May 2007 to May 2010, ended with a calibration campaign, in which the first measurement of the 7 Be solar neutrino interaction rate bib:be7-1 ; bib:be7-2 ; bib:be7-3 and the first evidence of the pep solar neutrinos bib:pep were achieved; Phase-II, from December 2011 to May 2016, started after an intense purification campaign with unprecedented reduction of the scintillator radioactive contaminants, in which the first spectroscopic observation of the pp neutrinos with 10% precision was published bib:pp , and was later updated in the comprehensive analysis of all pp chain neutrino fluxes bib:global ; bib:nusol ; bib:b8 ; finally, Phase-III, from July 2016 to October 2021, started after a thermal stabilization program (consisting of detector insulation and temperature control aimed at stopping the scintillator convective motions) in which the first detection of the CNO neutrinos bib:cno and its subsequent improvements bib:PRLcno ; bib:CID were achieved. The most important solar neutrino results in terms of interaction rate and corresponding fluxes are summarized in Tab. 1 . Due to its unprecedented radio-purity, Borexino has also set a lot of limits on rare processes, such as potential electron decay bib:elec , NSI bib:bxnsi , low energy neutrinos correlated with astrophysical events bib:astro-nu , neutrino magnetic moment bib:magnet , sterile neutrino bib:sterile , and performed other studies, such as e.g. the determination of very stringent limits for possible violations of Pauli’s principle in nuclear systems Borexino-Pauli and geo-neutrino detection bib:geonu , which gives essential contributions to the testing and discrimination of possible geophysical models for the Earth. Species Rate [cpd/100 t ] Flux [cm -2 s -1 ] pp (134\pm 10)^{+6}_{-10} (6.1\pm 0.5)_{-0.5}^{+0.3}\times 10^{10} 7 Be (48.3\pm 1.1)^{+0.4}_{-0.7} (4.99\pm 0.11)_{-0.08}^{+0.06}\times 10^{9} pep (HZ) (2.7\pm 0.4)^{+0.1}_{-0.2} (1.3\pm 0.3)_{-0.1}^{+0.1}\times 10^{8} 8 B ( >3 MeV) 0.223_{-0.022}^{+0.021} 5.68_{-0.44}^{+0.42}\times 10^{6} hep <0.002 (90% CL) <1.8\times 10^{5} (90% CL) CNO 6.7_{-0.8}^{+1.2} 6.7_{-0.8}^{+1.2}\times 10^{8} Table 1 : Solar neutrino interaction rates in Borexino and extrapolated solar neutrino fluxes for the different components of the pp chain and CNO cycle. Rates are reported in cpd/100 t, while fluxes are reported in \text{cm}^{-2}\,\text{s}^{-1} . N.B.: HZ stands for high metallicity assumption. N.B.: cpd/100 t is the standard Borexino rate unit and stands for counts per day per 100 tonnes. I.1 Data selection For the most important analyses in Borexino, the fundamental event selection is based on the following criteria: internal only trigger (no muon veto coincidence), event time greater than 2 ms from a preceding muon (to remove cosmogenics), a single cluster in the acquisition window, and the position typically reconstructed in r<2.8 m and -1.8j}A^{E}_{ek}A^{E\dagger}_{ek}A^{S}_{ej}A^{S\dagger}_{ej}\cos\left({\frac{\Delta m_{kj}^{2}}{2E_{\nu}}L+\delta}\right)\end{split} (34) where \dagger is the hermitian adjoint operator and \delta is the usual CP violation phase. The convention that the index E indicates the term relative to the Earth and S indicates the term relative to the Sun is still valid. The last term of the previous equations can be neglected, in fact, the term oscillates rapidly and its contribution is null when averaged over realistic experimental energy bins with finite size. Hence the survival probability becomes: P_{ee}=|A_{ee}|^{2}=\sum_{k}|A^{E}_{ek}|^{2}|A^{S}_{ek}|^{2}=\sum_{k}P^{E}_{ek}P^{S}_{ek}. (35) Taking into account the explicit form of the transition amplitudes and neglecting the fast oscillation term for the same motivation introduced before, the survival probability can be written as: P_{ee}=\sum_{j}|U^{E}_{ej}|^{2}|U^{S}_{ej}|^{2} (36) The PMNS matrices used in the previous equality are obtained in the context of the NSI modified MSW effect. The propagation of neutrinos inside matter is ruled by the Hamiltonian 5 where the matter interaction operator is given by: \begin{split}&H=\;\frac{1}{2E_{\nu}}\bigg[U\left(\begin{array}[]{ccc}0&0&0\\ 0&\Delta m_{21}^{2}&0\\ 0&0&\Delta m_{32}^{2}\\ \end{array}\right)U^{\dagger}\\ &+V_{matt}\left(\begin{array}[]{ccc}1+\varepsilon_{ee}&\varepsilon_{e\mu}e^{i\phi_{e\mu}}&\varepsilon_{e\tau}e^{i\phi_{e\tau}}\\ \varepsilon_{e\mu}e^{-i\phi_{e\mu}}&\varepsilon_{\mu\mu}&\varepsilon_{\mu\tau}e^{i\phi_{\mu\tau}}\\ \varepsilon_{e\tau}e^{-i\phi_{e\tau}}&\varepsilon_{\mu\tau}e^{-i\phi_{\mu\tau}}&\varepsilon_{\tau\tau}\\ \end{array}\right)\bigg]\end{split} (37) where the matter potential is V_{matt}=2\sqrt{2}G_{F}N_{e}E_{\nu} . The electronic density inside the Sun and the Earth can be approximated as constant, resulting in a value for the matter potential given by: V_{matt}\simeq\begin{cases}(4\div 8)\times 10^{-5}\mathrm{eV}^{2}\left(\mathrm{\frac{E_{\nu}}{1MeV}}\right)\hskip 17.00024pt\mathrm{Solar\;matter\;density}\\ (1.5\div 2.5)\times 10^{-7}\mathrm{eV}^{2}\left(\mathrm{\frac{E_{\nu}}{1MeV}}\right)\;\,\mathrm{Earth\;matter\;density}.\end{cases} (38) To continue the study the change of the neutrino basis using the unitary matrix O=R_{23}R_{13} is useful. This approach allows for the flavor basis reintroduction, resulting in: \widetilde{H}=O^{\dagger}\,H\,O=(R_{23}R_{13})^{\dagger}\,H\,(R_{23}R_{13}). (39) The form of the obtained Hamiltonian operator can be simplified considering that the \theta_{13} mixing angle is negligible compared to the other ones. After subtracting a common phase term in the form of the diagonal matrix \varepsilon_{\tau\tau}V_{matt}\,\mathbb{I} , taking into account that \Delta m_{31}^{2}\gg V_{matt} for both the solar and terrestrial matter densities and considering \theta_{13}\simeq 0 , the Hamiltonian can be approximated in the form: \widetilde{H}=\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}\widetilde{H}_{2\times 2}&0\\ 0&\frac{1}{2E_{\nu}}\Delta m_{31}^{2}+O(\varepsilon\times V_{matt})\\ \end{array}\right). (40) The term O(\varepsilon\times V_{matt}) is negligible, as a consequence the third mass eigenstate decouples from the other two and propagate without interacting as in vacuum. Therefore, in the NSI scenario as well, the analysis of the MSW effect reduces to the two flavor eigenstates approximation. As a result, the obtained picture uses the solar neutrino flavor basis, with the third mass eigenstate decoupled. The reduced Hamiltonian can be written in the explicit form: \begin{split}&\widetilde{H}_{2\times 2}=\frac{\Delta m_{21}^{2}}{4E_{\nu}}\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}-\cos{2\theta_{12}}&\sin{2\theta_{12}}\\ \sin{2\theta_{12}}&\cos{2\theta_{12}}\end{array}\right)\\ &+\frac{V_{matt}}{2E_{\nu}}\left[\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}1&0\\ 0&0\end{array}\right)+\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}\widetilde{\varepsilon}_{1}&\widetilde{\varepsilon}_{2}\\ \widetilde{\varepsilon}_{2}&\widetilde{\varepsilon}_{1}\end{array}\right)\right].\end{split} (41) The terms \widetilde{\varepsilon} are the NSI introduced perturbations and are functions of the NSI parameters \varepsilon_{**} and of the mixing angles. After subtracting a common phase term, the 2\times 2 Hamiltonian can be written as: \widetilde{H}_{2\times 2}\simeq\frac{1}{2E_{\nu}}\widetilde{M} (42) with the matrix M defined as: \widetilde{M}=\left(\begin{pmatrix}-\Delta m_{21}^{2}\cos{(2\theta_{12})}+2\,V_{matt}\,(1+\varepsilon_{ee}-\varepsilon_{\tau\tau})&-\Delta m_{21}^{2}\sin{(2\theta_{12})}+2\,V_{matt}\cdot\varepsilon_{e\mu}\cdot\cos{\theta_{23}}\\ -\Delta m_{21}^{2}\sin{(2\theta_{12})}+2\,V_{matt}\cdot\varepsilon_{e\mu}\cdot\cos{\theta_{23}}&\Delta m_{21}^{2}\cos{(2\theta_{12})}+V_{matt}\cdot(\varepsilon_{\mu\mu}-\varepsilon_{\tau\tau})\,\cos^{2}{\theta_{23}}\end{pmatrix}\right) (43) Finally using the MSW standard analysis strategy it is possible to obtain the PMNS matrix that connects the flavor eigenstates with the matter mass ones: U_{M}=\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}\cos{\theta_{M}}&\sin{\theta_{M}}\\ -\sin{\theta_{M}}&\cos{\theta_{M}}\\ \end{array}\right) (44) with the matter mixing angle given by: \tan{(2\theta_{M})}=\frac{\Delta m_{21}^{2}\sin{(2\theta_{12})-2\,V_{matt}\cdot\varepsilon_{e\mu}\cdot\cos{\theta_{23}}}}{\Delta m_{21}^{2}\cos{(2\theta_{12})}-V_{matt}\,(1-\varepsilon^{\prime})} (45) and this result can be written in the final form 10 : \begin{split}\tan{(2\theta_{M})}=&\tan{(2\theta_{12})}\bigg[1-\frac{2\,V_{matt}\cdot\varepsilon_{e\mu}\cdot\cos{\theta_{23}}}{\Delta m_{12}^{2}\sin{(2\theta_{12})}}\bigg]\\ &\bigg[1-\frac{V_{matt}(1-\varepsilon^{\prime})}{\Delta m_{12}^{2}\cos{(2\theta_{12})}}\bigg]^{-1}\end{split} (46) where we have introduced the parameter \varepsilon^{\prime}=-\varepsilon_{ee}+\varepsilon_{\mu\mu}\cos^{2}{\theta_{23}}+\varepsilon_{\tau\tau}\sin^{2}{\theta_{23}} 11 . The Solar or Earth matter mixing angles with the related PMNS matrix can be obtained choosing the correct matter density for the interaction potential in the previous analysis framework. Matter-induced effects can be included considering the matter mixing angle and the related unitary matrix 44 . The oscillation probability 36 for day neutrinos is obtained neglecting the contribution of Earth matter: \displaystyle P_{ee}= \displaystyle\sum_{j}|U^{E}_{ej}|^{2}|U^{S}_{ej}|^{2}=\sin^{4}\theta_{13}+\cos^{4}\theta_{13}P_{ee}^{2\nu}(\theta_{M},\,\theta_{12}) \displaystyle P_{e\mu}= \displaystyle\sum_{j}|U^{E}_{\mu j}|^{2}|U^{S}_{ej}|^{2}=\cos^{2}\theta_{13}\sin^{2}\theta_{23}\left(1-P_{ee}^{2\nu}(\theta_{M},\,\theta_{12})\right) \displaystyle P_{e\tau}= \displaystyle\sum_{j}|U^{E}_{\tau j}|^{2}|U^{S}_{ej}|^{2}=\cos^{2}\theta_{13}\cos^{2}\theta_{23}\left(1-P_{ee}^{2\nu}(\theta_{M},\,\theta_{12})\right) (47) where \theta_{M} is the effective mixing angle in solar matter, and P_{ee}^{2\nu}(\theta_{M},\,\theta_{12}) is the adiabatic two-flavor survival probability for electronic neutrinos. Under the hypothesis of adiabatic MSW effect and in the solar neutrino energy range it can be approximated in the form: P_{ee}^{2\nu}(\theta_{M},\,\theta_{12})=\frac{1}{2}\left(1+\cos{(2\theta_{M})}\cos{(2\theta_{12})}\right). (48) The explicit form of the survival probability, for instance, can be written as: P_{ee}=\sin^{4}{\theta_{13}}+\frac{1}{2}\cos^{4}{\theta_{13}}\left(1+\cos{(2\theta_{M-S})}\cos{(2\theta_{12})}\right). (49) It is important to underline that the NSI modified survival probability, obtained before, differs from the standard one for perturbative terms: P_{ee}=\sin^{4}{\theta_{13}}+\frac{1}{2}\cos^{4}{\theta_{13}}\left(1+\cos^{2}{(2\theta_{12})}\right)+O(\varepsilon\times V_{matt}) (50) hence, the standard survival probability differs from the NSI-modified one by only a few percent.