Identifying Host Galaxies of Binary Black Hole Mergers with Next-Generation Gravitational Wave Detector Networks 2025 Identifying Host Galaxies of Binary Black Hole Mergers with Next-Generation Gravitational Wave Detector Networks – A.4 Sumedha Biswas, Andrew Levan, Peter G. Jonker, Kendall Ackley, Gregory Ashton, Nikhil Sarin Abstract Identifying the host galaxy of a binary black hole (BBH) merger detected via gravitational waves (GWs) remains a challenge due to the absence of electromagnetic counterparts and the large localization volumes produced by current-generation detectors. A confident host association would provide stellar population properties to constrain BBH formation channels and enable measurements of cosmological parameters such as the Hubble constant, H 0 H_{0} . We simulate BBH mergers in nearby ( z < 0.25 z<0.25 ) host galaxies to evaluate the feasibility of host identification with future GW detector networks, including configurations with the planned LIGO-India detector and third-generation detectors such as the Einstein Telescope (ET) and Cosmic Explorer (CE). We construct two injection grids to explore variations in BBH mass, distance, and directional sensitivity, and infer localization volumes using the Fisher Information Matrix (FIM)-based parameter estimation implemented through BILBY . To assess the prospects for unique host identification, we introduce a set of diagnostics: theoretical comoving volume thresholds for galaxies of a given stellar mass, derived from galaxy stellar mass functions (GSMFs), a metallicity-based volume threshold motivated by progenitor environment models, stellar mass fractions to quantify candidate host prominence, and the probability of chance alignment ( p c p_{c} ). These metrics provide ways to evaluate host associations and constrain BBH formation channels. We find that future networks that include ET and CE localize BBH mergers to volumes smaller than those theoretical thresholds, implying potentially unique host identification, out to ∼ \sim 1000 Mpc at a rate of ∼ 100 ​ yr − 1 \sim 100\penalty\ {\rm yr^{-1}} . While associations for individual events may remain uncertain, our framework is well-suited to population-level analyses, enabling constraints on BBH formation scenarios in the era of next-generation GW detector networks. 1 Introduction The discovery of gravitational waves (GW) from a binary black hole (BBH) merger was made during the first observing run (O1) of the two LIGO detectors at Hanford and Livingston (USA) in 2015, marking the beginning of GW astrophysics ( 7 ) . Since then, the two LIGO detectors have undergone further upgrades in sensitivity ( 6 ; 56 ; 3 ) , and Advanced Virgo ( 17 ; 19 ; 18 ) in Italy and KAGRA ( 32 ; 114 ; 21 ) in Japan have been operational, since 2017 and 2020, respectively. With this combined GW detector network, many BBH mergers and other compact binary coalescences (CBCs) have been detected across successive observing runs. Combining data from the GW transient catalogues (GWTC-1.0: 8 , GWTC-2.0, 2.1: 12 ; 16 , GWTC-3.0: 14 , and GWTC-4.0: 2 ), there are 218 1 1 1 GW candidates with a probability of astrophysical origin \rm p_{astro}\geq 0.5 ; GW event candidates in total, comprising 210 BBH mergers, 2 binary neutron star (BNS) mergers, and 6 neutron star–black hole (NSBH) mergers. GW transients, involving at least one neutron star (NS), i.e. BNS and NSBH mergers, can produce a range of electromagnetic (EM) counterparts such as gamma-ray bursts ( 79 , e.g.) , kilonovae ( 124 ; 144 ; 195 ; 65 ; 183 ; 166 ; 199 ; 123 , e.g.) , and potentially fast X-ray transients ( 179 ; 180 ; 190 ; 191 ; 192 ; 165 ; 48 , e.g.) . These signatures are thought to arise from the accretion of a remnant disk onto the massive NS or BH remnant following the merger ( 147 , e.g.) , radioactive decay of heavy, neutron-rich, elements synthesised through the r -process in the expanding merger ejecta ( 125 ; 196 ) , or the spin-down energy of a milli-second magnetar (e.g. 126 ). In the case of NSBH mergers, the outcome depends on the binary parameters ( 70 ; 86 , e.g.) : the NS may be tidally disrupted outside the event horizon of the BH, leading to substantial mass ejection, or it may plunge directly into the BH with little or no ejecta. Since their GW signals are typically louder than those of BNS mergers, and tidal disruption can eject more material, giving rise to brighter kilonovae, NSBH mergers are regarded as especially promising targets for EM follow-up ( 101 ) . During O3, two NSBH mergers ( 11 ) were detected; however, neither yielded an EM counterpart. In contrast, BBH mergers, are generally not expected to produce EM emission, although possible EM bright scenarios do exist, for example if the merger occurs in a gas-rich environment such as the accretion disks of active galactic nuclei (AGN) ( 158 ; 140 ; 97 , e.g.) . Notably, the first detected BBH merger, GW150914 ( 7 ) , was temporally and spatially coincident with a weak gamma-ray burst detected by Fermi -GBM ( 20 ; 63 ) although no optical or radio emission was detected ( 173 ) , and this association remains debated ( 113 ; 62 , e.g.) . In another BBH merger, GW190521 ( 13 ) , a contemporaneous optical flare lasting several months from an active galactic nucleus within the GW localization volume was found, with 97 suggesting the possibility of it occurring inside the accretion disk of a central supermassive BH. However, these claims remain controversial, and are not generally accepted at the present time ( 154 ; 205 , e.g.) . Hence, at present there are no clear EM counterparts, or indeed precise localizations and host galaxy associations, for any BBH mergers. One of the primary challenges in GW astronomy is the precise localization of CBCs, as GW skymaps often span up to hundreds or thousands of square degrees on the sky ( 91 ; 9 ; 156 ) . The identification of an EM counterpart significantly improves the localization, as demonstrated in the case of GW170817 ( 10 ) , a BNS merger that occurred at a nearby distance of 40 Mpc and was associated with a range of EM counterparts across the spectrum ( 23 ; 29 ; 59 ; 65 ; 66 ; 67 ; 74 ; 115 ; 83 ; 127 ; 149 ; 160 ; 177 ; 182 ; 197 ; 200 ; 208 ; 203 ; 185 ) , and was subsequently successfully associated with its host, NGC 4993 ( 122 ; 112 ; 78 ; 116 ) . Conversely, in the case of BBH mergers, which are generally assumed to have no associated EM counterparts, GW localization and host identification become extremely challenging since they must be undertaken purely on the basis of GW information. However, it is astrophysically important. The properties of the BBH environment play a critical role in constraining both formation and merger pathways (see 137 for a detailed review). For instance, low-metallicity environments may favour the formation of more massive stellar-origin BBHs ( 121 , e.g.) , while dense stellar regions such as globular clusters may support hierarchical BH assembly through repeated dynamical interactions ( 24 ; 139 ; 210 , e.g.) . A uniquely identified host galaxy (or even location within the host galaxy) provides direct measurements of the underlying stellar population properties such as total stellar mass, age of the dominant population and metallicity that can be directly compared to the predictions of different formation channels. Beyond constraining these channels, host identification also has cosmological applications; for instance, it provides a method for an independent redshift measurement to be combined with the luminosity distance inferred from GW observations, enabling a direct measurement of the Hubble constant ( 1 , e.g.) . Since BBH mergers can be found at much larger distances than those containing NSs, they probe well into the Hubble flow and can, therefore, enable better constraints on expansion histories with fewer observations by, for example, minimising uncertainties due to peculiar motions that were substantial in the case of GW170817 ( 107 ; 55 ) . In the absence of host identification, several studies have utilized BBH mergers as statistical dark sirens to place constraints on the Hubble constant ( 129 ; 72 ; 98 ; 50 ; 92 , e.g.) , but even a small number of unique host identifications would provide great diagnostic power. Although localizing BBH mergers remains challenging with current detector sensitivities, it may be possible in some circumstances ( 152 ; 57 ; 109 ) , and this limitation may not persist in the coming decades. By the mid-2030s, a range of developments is expected to dramatically improve GW sky localization. Future detections of stellar-mass BBH mergers may be preceded by months to years of inspiral signals in the millihertz regime ( 84 ) , detectable by the space-based Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) detector ( 22 ; 61 ) , allowing advanced pre-merger localization. On the ground, localization prospects will improve with the planned addition of LIGO-India ( 201 ; 202 ; 178 ) to the existing network of advanced detectors. Crucially, third-generation (3G) detectors such as the Einstein Telescope (ET) ( 164 ; 106 ; 130 ; 4 ) and Cosmic Explorer (CE) ( 167 ; 81 ; 82 ) are predicted to have an order-of-magnitude improvement in sensitivity ( 51 ) . When operating in conjunction with 2G detectors, these facilities will potentially enable precise 3D localization for nearby, high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) BBH events, achieving sky areas \rm<1\penalty\ deg^{2} ( 51 ; 99 ; 145 ) . In this paper, we investigate the feasibility of identifying hosts of BBH mergers using future GW detector networks. We simulate BBH mergers injected into \mathrm{M}_{*} galaxies and construct two complementary injection grids, Grids I and II, to explore how localization performance depends on source properties (mass and distance) and directional sensitivity (Section 2.2 ). We first define three GW detector network configurations: HLV, HLVKIEC, and EC (Section 2.1 ); and then perform parameter estimation using the Fisher Information Matrix (FIM) formalism implemented in BILBY (Section 2.3 ). The resulting posteriors are used to compute 3D localization volumes for each injection (Section 2.4 ). We then compare these volumes to theoretical comoving volume thresholds derived from galaxy stellar mass functions, including versions weighted by assumptions about isolated and dynamical BBH formation scenarios (Section 2.5 ). To further assess the astrophysical utility of these volumes, we introduce a set of diagnostics: a metallicity-based threshold (Section 2.6.1 ), mass fractions (Section 3.1.3 ), and probability of chance alignment (Section 3.2 ). In Section 4 , we present detailed analyses of localization performance across both injection grids, using each of the proposed diagnostics. These analyses are used to compare detector network performance (Section 5.1 ) and to evaluate the extent to which hosts may be identified and BBH formation channels statistically constrained (Section 5.2 ). We summarize our findings and discuss future directions in Section 6 . In Appendix A , we explore how our assumptions about GW source parameters influence the analysis outcomes and compare our adopted values to those inferred from observed GW events. 2 Methods We adopt a flat \Lambda CDM cosmology with a matter density parameter \Omega_{m}=0.3 throughout this analysis. For sections of the study requiring observed galaxy information, we use the NED Local Volume Sample (NED-LVS; 64 ), a subset of \sim 2 million objects in NED with distances out to 1000 Mpc. For bright galaxies ( \geq L^{*} ), NED-LVS is \sim 100% complete out to \sim 400 Mpc ( 64 ) . The catalogue adopts H_{0}=69.6\penalty\ \rm km\penalty\ s^{-1}\penalty\ Mpc^{-1} , which we also use in relevant calculations to ensure consistency. 2.1 GW Detector Networks We consider the following GW detectors in our analysis: current-generation detectors — LIGO-Hanford (H), LIGO-Livingston (L) ( 5 ) , Virgo (V) ( 17 ) , and KAGRA (K) ( 114 ) ; and proposed third-generation detectors — Einstein Telescope (E) ( 164 ; 106 ; 130 ; 4 ) , Cosmic Explorer (C) ( 167 ; 81 ; 82 ) , and LIGO-India (I) ( 201 ; 202 ; 178 ) . The specifications of each detector, such as the location, frequency range, and orientation, are listed in Table 1 . Based on these, we define three GW detector networks that we use throughout this study: HLVKIEC, HLV, and EC. For each detector, we use publicly available power spectral density (PSD) data 2 2 2 Design Sensitivity curves have been downloaded from: LIGO-T2000012-v2 , CE-T2000017-v8 , and ET . Figure 1: Heatmap of the network optimal SNRs for the injected BBH mergers across masses and distances. Black vertical lines separate Grids I and II (maximum and minimum sensitivity), and the white vertical lines separate the GW detector networks. Each triplet of columns within a network corresponds to distances of 500, 750, and 1000 Mpc (left to right) , and rows correspond to mass configurations from 50+50 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} (top) to 5+5 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} (bottom) . The colourbar indicates the logarithm of the network optimal SNR, with lighter shades corresponding to higher SNR values. The network optimal SNR is calculated as \rho_{\rm network}=\sqrt{\sum_{j}\rho_{j}^{2}} , where \rho_{j} is the optimal matched-filter SNR in detector j . Table 1: GW detector network specifications. Detector Location (Lat, Lon) Frequency Range (Hz) Arms Orientation (Azimuths) LIGO Hanford (H) 46.45°N, 119.41°W 20–2000 2 36.8°, 126.8° LIGO Livingston (L) 30.56°N, 90.77°W 20–2000 2 108.0°, 198.0° Virgo (V) 43.63°N, 10.50°E 20–2000 2 19.4°, 109.4° KAGRA (K) 36.41°N, 137.30°E 20–2000 2 25°, 295° LIGO-India (I) 19.61°N, 77.02°E 20–2000 2 TBD Einstein Telescope (ET) 50.85°N, 5.70°E 1–10,000 3 0°, 120°, 240° Cosmic Explorer (CE) 46.45°N/30.56°N, 5–5,000 2 Site-dependent 119.41°W/90.77°W Notes: Orientation angles are azimuths measured clockwise from geographic north. L-shaped detectors have 90° arm separations. ET is planned to have three 10 km arms arranged in an equilateral triangle. CE’s final orientation depends on site selection (40 km arms). Frequency ranges represent approximate design goals. 2.2 Injection Grids With the detector networks established, we proceed to construct two complementary grids of GW injections to evaluate how both sky location and detector sensitivity affect localization performance. 1. Grid I: We select 3 \mathrm{M}_{*} galaxies—systems with typical total stellar masses near the characteristic “knee” of the double Schechter galaxy stellar mass function (Equation 1 ), marking the transition from the abundant low-mass population to the rarer massive galaxies—from the NED-LVS galaxy catalogue, located at distances of \sim 500 Mpc, \sim 750 Mpc, and \sim 1000 Mpc respectively (Table 2 ). These distances are similar to several of the BBH detections reported in GWTC 4.0 ( 8 ; 12 ; 16 ; 14 ; 2 ) and are sufficiently close that well-constrained skymaps maintain reasonably small comoving volume regions that can be realistically surveyed for galaxies with existing telescopes. In each galaxy, we simulate a BBH merger with one of the following component mass configurations: 50+50 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} , 40+40 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} , 30+30 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} , 20+20 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} , 10+10 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} , and 5+5 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} . This results in an injection grid with a total dimension of 3\times 3\times 6 for 3 GW detector networks. 2. Grid II: To explore the “best” and “worst” case scenarios for detector network performance and compare the performance of the HLVKIEC and EC detector networks, we incorporate directional sensitivity using the network antenna patterns. The response of a GW detector to a signal depends on its antenna pattern functions F_{+} and F_{\times} , which quantify the sensitivity of the detector to the two independent polarization states of a GW signal ( 85 ; 175 ) . To construct this grid, we select arbitrary sky locations within the most sensitive ("bright") and least sensitive ("dark") regions of each detector network’s (HLVKIEC and EC) antenna pattern (Figure 2 , Table 3 ). At each of these positions, we simulate BBH mergers at the same three distances and BBH mass configurations as in Grid I. This results in an injection grid with a total dimension of 2\times 2\times 3\times 6 for 2 GW detector networks. We exclude the HLV network from Grid II as the FIM-based parameter estimation (PE; discussed in Section 2.3 ) becomes unreliable due to low SNRs. Table 2: Properties of the injected \mathrm{M}_{*} hosts in Grid I, selected from the NED-LVS galaxy catalogue. For each injection distance, the corresponding characteristic stellar mass \mathrm{M}_{*} was determined using the corresponding Schechter function parameters (see Table 6 ). Galaxy Name RA, Dec [deg] Distance [Mpc] Redshift Stellar Mass [ \mathrm{M}_{\odot} ] WISEA J171543.62+291712.7 258.93177, 29.28687 499.922 \pm 0.145 0.12 6.16\times 10^{10} \mathrm{M}_{\odot} WISEA J142633.23+335512.5 216.63848, 33.92015 750.081 \pm 0.053 0.18 6.15\times 10^{10} \mathrm{M}_{\odot} WISEA J205335.01+010024.3 313.39591, 1.00678 999.938 \pm 0.326 0.23 4.93\times 10^{10} \mathrm{M}_{\odot} Figure 2: Antennae pattern maps for the three GW detector networks considered in this study: (A) HLVKIEC, (B) HLV, and (C) EC. Each panel shows the combined network antenna amplitude response, defined as \sqrt{\sum_{j}F_{+,j}^{2}+F_{\times,j}^{2}} ( 85 ; 175 ) , as a function of sky position in equatorial coordinates at time t. The red, green, and blue crosses mark the locations of the three injected \mathrm{M}_{*} galaxies at 1000 Mpc, 750 Mpc, and 500 Mpc (Table 2 ), respectively, used in Grid I. The lime green and white circles denote the “bright” (maximum sensitivity) and “dark” (minimum sensitivity) sky locations in panels (A) and (C) (Table 3 ), respectively, selected based on the network antenna pattern and used in Grid II. Table 3: Sky coordinates for Grid II, corresponding to the most and least sensitive points on the antenna response pattern for each detector network (HLVKIEC, HLV, and EC). The sensitivity is quantified by the combined antenna power \sum_{j}\sqrt{(F_{+,j}^{2}+F_{\times,j}^{2})} , computed over the full sky at a fixed geocentric time t_{c}=0.0 and polarization angle \psi=0 . The maximum sensitivity represent directions of peak network response to GWs, while the minimum sensitivity correspond to minima in directional sensitivity. Network Sensitivity RA (deg) Dec (deg) HLVKIEC Maximum 279.000 -48.923 Minimum 68.203 -12.025 EC Maximum 286.967 -44.202 Minimum 238.359 19.471 2.3 Parameter Estimation with BILBY To perform PE on our simulated GW injection grid, we use the Bayesian inference library BILBY ( 30 ) . All analyses are performed using the IMRPhenomXPHM waveform approximant ( 163 ) , a frequency-domain, precessing, phenomenological model well-suited to modeling the inspiral, merger, and ringdown of non-eccentric BBHs. For each injection, we use Grid I or Grid II values (Section 2.2 , Tables 2 , 3 ), while keeping all other parameters fixed across runs (Table 4 ). PE is performed using standard astrophysical priors (Table 5 ): we assume uniform priors on Right Ascension (RA), polarization angle \psi , and coalescence phase \phi_{c} ; sinusoidal priors on the inclination angle \theta_{\rm JN} ; and a cosine prior on Declination (Dec). The luminosity distance prior d_{L} between 1 and 10000 Mpc, is uniform in comoving volume and source frame time i.e. \propto\frac{1}{1+z}\frac{dV_{c}}{dz} where V_{c} is the comoving volume. The coalescence time is allowed to vary within a \pm 0.5 s window around the injection time. All other parameters, including masses and spins, are fixed to their injected values. Table 4: Fixed injection parameters in the BILBY runs. For each run, m_{1}=m_{2}=[50.0,40.0,30.0,20.0,10.0,5.0]M_{\odot} , and the sky position coordinates (RA, Dec) vary according to Tables 2 , 3 . Parameter Injected Value Units Spin magnitude 1, a_{1} 0.1 – Spin magnitude 2, a_{2} 0.1 – Tilt angle 1, \theta_{1} 0.0 rad Tilt angle 2, \theta_{2} 0.0 rad Azimuthal spin angle, \phi_{12} 0.0 rad Precession angle, \phi_{\rm JL} 0.0 rad Inclination angle, \theta_{\rm JN} 0.4 rad Polarization angle, \psi 0.0 rad Coalescence phase, \phi_{c} 0.0 rad Geocentric time, t_{c} 0.0 s Table 5: Priors and their ranges used in the BILBY runs. Parameters not listed here are fixed to their injected values (Table 4 ). Parameter Prior Range Units Right Ascension, RA [0, 2\pi ] rad Declination, Dec [ -\pi/2 , \pi/2 ] rad Geocentric time, t_{c} [–0.5, 0.5] s Luminosity distance, d_{L} [1, 10000] Mpc Inclination angle, \theta_{\rm JN} [0, \pi ] rad Polarization angle, \psi [0, \pi ] rad Coalescence phase, \phi_{c} [0, 2\pi ] rad Given the extremely high signal-to-noise ratios (Figure 1 ) and the long signal durations in some of our low-mass injections, nested samplers such as dynesty ( 186 ) or nestle face computational challenges in efficiently exploring the resulting sharply peaked posterior distributions. We therefore adopt the Fisher Information Matrix (FIM) approximation ( 204 ) , which approximates the log-likelihood around the maximum-likelihood point to produce an analytic Gaussian approximation to the posterior. This method is well-justified in the high-SNR limit. From this, we generate posterior samples that can be used to construct credible regions. 2.4 Localization Volumes For each simulated GW event, we compute the 3D localization volume by combining the sky localization area with luminosity distance constraints derived from the FIM-based posterior distributions. We begin by extracting the posterior samples for RA, Dec, and luminosity distance d_{L} . To estimate the sky localization area, we apply a 2D kernel density estimate (KDE) ( 170 ; 157 ) to the RA and Dec samples, evaluate the density on a HEALPix grid ( 95 ) with resolution parameter \texttt{nside}=2048 , and identify the smallest set of pixels enclosing 50% and 90% of the posterior probability. Figure 12 shows an example of the 2D localization areas of a 50 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} + 50 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} injection at 1000 Mpc. We extract the central credible interval from the d_{L} posterior distribution, convert the lower and upper bounds to redshift using the assumed cosmology, and compute the comoving shell volume between z_{\mathrm{min}} and z_{\mathrm{max}} . The final 3D localization volume is obtained by multiplying this shell volume by the fractional solid angle subtended by the sky localization region. The 50% ( V_{50} ) and 90% ( V_{90} ) localization volumes are then used for further analyses. 2.5 Galaxy Mass Weighting Across BBH Formation Channels Several formation channels have been proposed for BBHs (see 137 for a detailed review): BBH mergers can be the result of isolated binary evolution via common envelope ( 47 ; 161 ; 44 ; 45 ; 43 ; 77 ; 76 ; 80 ; 134 ; 135 ; 188 ; 119 ; 187 ; 46 ; 118 ; 153 ; 194 ) , stable mass transfer ( 93 ; 148 ; 41 ; 90 ; 176 ) , or chemically homogeneous evolution ( 71 ; 132 ; 138 ; 75 ; 168 ) . Alternatively, BBHs can form dynamically in triples ( 25 ; 181 ; 28 , e.g.) , multiples ( 88 ; 102 , e.g.) , young stellar clusters ( 37 ; 136 ; 38 ; 120 , e.g.) , globular clusters (GCs) ( 162 ; 193 ; 171 ; 169 ; 31 ; 87 ; 108 ; 58 ) , and nuclear star clusters ( 26 ; 89 , e.g.) . These disparate formation channels may result in markedly different formation environments; however, the delay time between the formation and merger also means that the formation environment and merger environment are not necessarily identical ( 137 , e.g.) . As a first-order approximation, we can assume that the likelihood of a galaxy hosting a BBH merger is proportional to its stellar mass. In the local Universe ( \lesssim 1000 Mpc), most of the stellar mass is concentrated around \mathrm{M}_{*} , the characteristic break in the galaxy stellar mass function (see below). However, given the strong relationship between the galaxy stellar mass and metallicity ( 198 ) , systems formed preferentially at low metallicity should also form in low mass galaxies. Alternatively, since the bulge mass and the number of GCs per unit stellar mass increases for more massive galaxies, those formed via dynamical interactions may be formed preferentially in more massive galaxies. We do not attempt to model this fully here, but consider characteristic (if simplistic) models that may capture the range of plausible behaviour. To implement this approach, we begin with the galaxy stellar mass function (GSMF) as described by the double Schechter function ( 174 ) : \displaystyle\Phi(M)\rm{d}M=\left[\phi_{1}\left(\frac{M}{M_{*}}\right)^{\alpha_{1}}+\phi_{2}\left(\frac{M}{M_{*}}\right)^{\alpha_{2}}\right]e^{-M/M_{*}}\frac{\rm{d}M}{M_{*}}, (1) where M is the stellar mass of the galaxy, \Phi(M)dM is the number density of galaxies per unit stellar mass in the range (M,M+dM) , \mathrm{M}_{*} is the characteristic stellar mass which represents the transition between the power-law and exponential regimes, \phi_{1} and \phi_{2} are the normalization constants for the high-mass and low-mass ends respectively, and \alpha_{1} and \alpha_{2} are the power law slopes of the high-mass and low-mass ends, respectively. To compute the number density of galaxies in a specific mass range (M_{1},M_{2}) , we integrate Equation 1 over those limits. Observational values for the Schechter parameters ( M_{*} , \phi_{1} , \phi_{2} , \alpha_{1} , \alpha_{2} ) are drawn from various galaxy surveys, including GAMA ( 36 ) , SDSS DR7 ( 207 ) , and high-redshift samples from the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) and other ground-based observatories ( 142 ) (see Table 6 ). Table 6: GSMF parameters for galaxies in various surveys over different redshifts. Ref. z \log(M_{*}/M_{\odot}) \phi_{1} \phi_{2} \alpha_{1} \alpha_{2} ( 10^{-3} Mpc -3 ) B12 < 0.06 10.66 3.96 0.79 -0.35 -1.47 W16 0.02 - 0.06 10.79 0.49 0.98 -1.69 -0.79 M21 0.25 - 0.75 10.64 2.34 0.78 0.25 -1.49 0.75 - 1.25 10.51 2.14 0.85 0.08 -1.49 1.25 - 1.75 10.54 1.48 0.48 -0.07 -1.60 1.75 - 2.25 10.56 0.89 0.31 -0.06 -1.63 2.25 - 2.75 10.55 0.53 0.32 0.02 -1.66 2.75 - 3.75 10.64 0.08 0.18 0.35 -1.76 • Ref.: B12 - 36 , W16 - 207 , M21 - 142 • Surveys: GAMA (B12), SDSS DR7 (W16), and HST combined with ground-based surveys ( 142 ) While the GSMF captures the overall stellar mass distribution of galaxies, different BBH formation channels weigh this distribution differently based on their host environment preferences. We first consider the isolated formation channel. 172 provide empirical fits for the BBH merger rate per galaxy per year, n_{\rm iso} 3 3 3 \rm log(n_{\rm iso}/Myr^{-1})=a+b\penalty\ log(M/M_{\odot}) , across a range of stellar masses and redshifts 4 4 4 We assume the model corresponding to common-envelope parameter \alpha =5 (see also 213 and 60 ); \alpha quantifies the efficiency with which orbital energy is used to expel the envelope of a star when the two stars in a binary interact closely. . These fits, based on population synthesis models, incorporate either the galaxy mass-metallicity relation (MZR) or the fundamental metallicity relation (FMR). As both yield similar BBH merger rate densities for z<1 , we adopt the MZR-based values for our analysis (see their table 2 and figure 13). We then normalize the BBH merger rate such that n_{\rm iso}\in[0,1] and define an efficiency-weighted GSMF: \displaystyle\Phi^{\rm iso}(M,z)=n_{\rm iso}(M)\penalty\ \Phi(M,z). (2) To model the dynamical channel, we assume that BBHs originate from interactions in GCs. In this case, the BBH formation efficiency would follow an empirical power-law relation between the galaxy stellar mass and the number of GCs. To account for this, we adopt a stellar mass–GC scaling relation to weigh the GSMF, thereby constructing a dynamical efficiency-weighted GSMF. The number of GCs per galaxy with M>10^{10} \mathrm{M}_{\odot} is well described by a power-law scaling relation ( 104 ; 105 ; 212 ) : \displaystyle n_{\rm GC}(M)=N_{0}\left(\frac{M}{M_{0}}\right)^{\delta}, (3) where M is the stellar mass of a galaxy, M_{0} is a reference mass, N_{0} is a normalization constant, and \delta is the power-law slope. For M>10^{10}\penalty\ \rm{M_{\odot}} , we adopt \log N_{0}=2.924 , \log(M_{0}/\rm{M_{\odot}})=11.2 , and \delta\approx 1 ( 104 ) . For lower-mass galaxies ( 10^{8}\leq M/\rm{M_{\odot}}\leq 10^{10} ), the relation flattens, with \delta=0.365 , \log N_{0}=1.274 , and \log(M_{0}/\rm{M_{\odot}})=9.2 . As before, we normalize n_{\rm GC}(M) such that n_{\rm GC}(M)\in[0,1] and define the dynamical efficiency-weighted GSMF: \displaystyle\Phi^{\rm dyn}(M,z)=n_{\rm GC}(M)\penalty\ \Phi(M,z). (4) Figure 3 illustrates the original GSMF \rm\Phi(M) , and the weighted GSMFs: \rm\Phi^{iso}(M) and \rm\Phi^{dyn}(M) at z=0.2 . The isolated BBH formation channel yields a broad and uniform distribution across galaxy stellar masses, whereas the dynamical channel shows a relative preference for higher-mass galaxies, reflecting the scaling of the number of GCs with galaxy mass. Figure 3: Weighted and unweighted GSMFs at z=0.2 ; The black curve shows the original GSMF \Phi(M) (Equation 1 ), modeled using a redshift-interpolated double Schechter function. The blue curve, \Phi^{\rm iso}(M) (Equation 2 ), represents the mass function weighted by a BBH merger efficiency model for the isolated formation channel, normalized over stellar mass. The red curve, \Phi^{\rm dyn}(M) (Equation 4 ), is weighted by a globular cluster (GC) scaling relation to represent dynamical BBH formation. 2.6 Theoretical Localization Volumes To evaluate the prospects for uniquely identifying the host of a BBH merger, we compare the simulated GW localization volume to the expected number density of galaxies within that same volume. In particular, we evaluate the minimum comoving volume that must be achieved in order to uniquely associate a galaxy of stellar mass \mathrm{M}_{*} with the BBH merger. This provides a theoretical upper bound on the localization volume necessary for host identification, under the assumption of a specific BBH formation channel. We assume that galaxies are distributed homogeneously and isotropically in space, following the cosmological principle. While true on large scales and a standard approximation ( 73 , e.g.) , we note that on small scales, this approximation necessarily breaks down. True localization volumes are likely not within this limit (at least not when they are sufficiently small to yield host identifications); hence, this approach is necessarily an approximation. Given a GSMF, \Phi(M,z) (Equation 1 ), we compute the expected number of galaxies with stellar masses \geq M contained within a comoving volume V by assuming Poisson statistics. The minimum comoving volume required to contain, on average, \lambda such galaxies is then V_{\min}(\geq M,z)=\frac{\lambda}{\displaystyle\int_{\log_{10}M}^{\infty}\Phi(M^{\prime},z)\penalty\ d\log_{10}M^{\prime}}, (5) where the denominator represents the cumulative comoving number density of all galaxies with stellar masses \geq M . This cumulative form reflects the fact that we do not know a priori which galaxy within a localization volume is the true host. A localization volume equal to V_{\min}(\lambda=1) corresponds to an expectation value of, on average, one galaxy of mass M_{*} ; volumes smaller than this may still contain such a galaxy, but the average number falls below unity (Figure 4 ). Figure 4: Minimum comoving volumes V_{\min} required to contain, on average, one galaxy of mass M as a function of galaxy stellar mass and redshift. Each panel corresponds to a different injected host at distances of 500 Mpc, 750 Mpc, and 1000 Mpc. Coloured curves show V_{\min}(M) (Equation 5 ) scaled by different values of \lambda . The black dashed line denotes the fiducial case of \lambda=1 . The vertical blue dashed line marks the mass of the injected \mathrm{M}_{*} galaxy (Grid I, Table 2 ), while the horizontal blue dashed line indicates the corresponding V_{\min} value at that mass. All three curves assume the redshift-dependent GSMF \Phi(M,z) (Equation 1 ). To account for different astrophysical channels of BBH formation, we compute analogous minimum comoving volumes using the modified GSMFs introduced earlier in Section 2.5 . For the isolated and dynamical channels, Equation 5 is evaluated using \Phi^{\rm iso}(M,z) (Equation 2 ) and \Phi^{\rm dyn}(M,z) (Equation 4 ), resulting in corresponding minimum localization volumes, V^{\rm iso}_{\min}(M,z) and V^{\rm dyn}_{\min}(M,z) , respectively. Each of these volumes - V_{\min} , V^{\rm iso}_{\min} , and V^{\rm dyn}_{\min} - can be interpreted as the minimum localization volume required to statistically isolate, on average, a single galaxy of stellar mass \mathrm{M}_{*} ( \lambda=1 ) under the assumption of the corresponding BBH formation channel. We note, importantly, that \lambda=1 is the point at which we expect one galaxy within the localization volume at random. Hence, it is not a volume at which we can realistically claim (at least not with high confidence) to be able to identify the host. We consider this further in Section 3 . Table 7: Minimum volume required to observe, on average, at least 1 galaxy of mass M (equal to the injected host masses at each corresponding redshift, see Table 2 ) ( V_{\min} ) for each BBH formation channel. Units are in Mpc 3 . Channel 500 Mpc 750 Mpc 1000 Mpc V_{\min} 2.7\times 10^{3} 2.1\times 10^{3} 1.2\times 10^{3} V_{\min}^{\mathrm{iso}} 3.6\times 10^{3} 2.7\times 10^{3} 1.5\times 10^{3} V_{\min}^{\mathrm{dyn}} 4.1\times 10^{3} 3.2\times 10^{3} 1.8\times 10^{3} 2.6.1 Metallicity Dependence Several binary population synthesis models predict that BBH formation via isolated binary evolution is strongly dependent on progenitor metallicity ( 42 ; 80 , e.g.) , with lower-metallicity environments favouring the formation of more massive BHs and higher merger rates ( 93 ; 187 , e.g.) . In contrast, dynamical formation channels are largely insensitive to metallicity ( 133 , e.g.) . This distinction presents a potential way to distinguish BBH formation channels. Analysis by 213 (see also 52 ) indicates that no single formation pathway accounts for more than \sim 70% of the BBHs detected in GWTC-2.0 and GWTC-2.1 ( 12 ; 16 ) . Recent population synthesis studies suggest that the isolated channel may contribute a larger fraction than the dynamical channel ( 39 ) . To explore how metallicity may influence our analysis, we adopt a representative metallicity threshold of 12+\rm{log(O/H)}=8.3 , commonly found as a threshold for the occurrence of long gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs) ( 96 , e.g.) . The relation between galaxy stellar mass and metallicity is captured by the MZR relation of 211 , valid for z\lesssim 1.6 and parameterized as: \displaystyle\rm 12+log(O/H)=Z_{0}+log\left[1-exp\left(-\left[\frac{M_{*}}{M_{0}}\right]^{\gamma}\right)\right], (6) where Z_{0} is the saturation metallicity ( 146 , e.g.) ; M_{0} is the characteristic turnover galaxy mass above which the metallicity asymptotically approaches the upper metallicity limit Z_{0}=9.102 and \gamma=0.513 is the power-law index (values taken from table 2 in 211 ). The MZR flattens at high galaxy stellar masses at z=0.2 . Using this relation, we find that this threshold corresponds to a galaxy stellar mass of log(M/ \mathrm{M}_{\odot} ) =\rm M_{Z} = 7.97. We then treat this mass as a lower threshold and compute the number density of galaxies with stellar mass \geq\rm M_{Z} , using a method analogous to that described in Section 2.6 . This yields \Phi^{Z}=1.84\times 10^{-2}\penalty\ \rm{Mpc^{-3}} , and an associated minimum localization volume of V^{Z}_{\min}=54.42\penalty\ \rm{Mpc^{3}} . 3 Prescriptions for Host Galaxy identification for BBH mergers 3.1 Masses within the GW Localization Volumes We compare the injected host to the total stellar mass in galaxies within the GW localization volume. We compute the total stellar mass enclosed in two ways: a theoretical estimate based on the GSMF, and an observational estimate obtained by summing the stellar masses of galaxies in galaxy catalogues within the localization region, although we note that, at least at the current time, the latter approach is of very limited value because of galaxy catalogue incompleteness. 3.1.1 Theoretical Galaxy Stellar Mass To estimate the total stellar mass theoretically enclosed within a GW localization region, we proceed as follows. We compute the stellar mass density, \rm\rho_{\star}(z) [ \rm{M_{\odot}\penalty\ Mpc^{-3}} ] by computing the mass-weighted integral of the GSMF, \Phi(M) , over a stellar mass range of ( M_{\min},M_{\max}=10^{8} \mathrm{M}_{\odot} , 10^{12} \mathrm{M}_{\odot} ): \displaystyle\rho_{\star}(z)=\int_{M_{\text{min}}}^{M_{\text{max}}}M\penalty\ \Phi(M)\penalty\ \mathrm{d}M. (7) The total expected stellar mass enclosed within the GW localization region is \rm M_{\Phi}(z)=\rho_{\star}\penalty\ V_{\text{comoving}} . This formalism enables the computation of the theoretical stellar mass contained within the V_{50} and V_{90} credible regions of each injection. 3.1.2 Observed Galaxy Stellar Mass We determine the total observed mass enclosed within the GW localization volume by first performing a 3D crossmatch of the GW localization volumes with the NED-LVS galaxy catalogue, and then defining: \rm M_{\text{obs}}=\sum_{i=1}^{N}M_{\mathrm{candidate},i}, (8) where M_{\mathrm{candidate},i} denotes the stellar mass of the \rm i^{th} galaxy identified within the localization volume, and N is the total number of crossmatched candidates from the NED-LVS galaxy catalogue. 3.1.3 Mass Fractions To quantify the significance of the injected \mathrm{M}_{*} host relative to the total galaxy stellar mass within the GW localization volume, we define two complementary dimensionless mass fractions: 1. \rm\mathbb{M}_{*,\Phi} : We compare the stellar mass of the injected \mathrm{M}_{*} host to the total theoretical mass enclosed within the GW localization volume by computing the theoretical mass fraction, \rm\mathbb{M}_{*,\Phi}=M_{*}/{M_{\Phi}} . 2. \rm\mathbb{M}_{*,obs} : Similarly, we compute an observed mass fraction, \rm\mathbb{M}_{*,obs}=M_{*}/{M_{obs}} , where M_{\rm obs} is the total stellar mass of all candidate hosts identified within the GW localization volume. 3.2 Probability of Chance Alignment A common way to assess the significance of a candidate host association is the probability of chance alignment, p_{c} . This quantifies the likelihood that a galaxy of a certain brightness falls at a certain proximity to the source location at random. It is calculated through a combination of the offset and magnitude of the putative host based on the 2D distribution of galaxies on the sky. In particular, 49 define P_{c}=1-\exp{(-\eta_{i})} . Here \eta_{i} is the expected number of galaxies as bright as or brighter than the candidate host within a certain search region. In the traditional 2D case, this is given by \eta_{i}=\pi r^{2}\sigma_{i} , where r is the angular separation from the transient and \sigma_{i} is the surface density of galaxies as bright as or brighter than the host. In the context of GW follow-up, the projected 2D density of galaxies across the sky becomes extremely high due to the large localization areas. However, as the measurement of the luminosity distance is also available, this information should be used as well. The total number of galaxies within the 3D localization volume (i.e., within the luminosity distance and sky position uncertainty) may be tractable. We therefore define \eta_{i} to account for the number of galaxies with stellar mass equal to or greater than that of the candidate host, M_{\rm host} , within a comoving volume V : \displaystyle\eta_{i}(\geq M_{\rm host})=V\int_{M_{\rm host}}^{\infty}\Phi(M)dM (9) where \Phi(M) is the GSMF (Equation 1 ). Here, we consider both the V_{50} and V_{90} credible volumes for V , and also the weighted GSMFs corresponding to the different BBH formation channels, \Phi^{\rm iso}_{\min} (Equation 2 ) and \Phi^{\rm dyn}_{\min} (Equation 4 ). Alternatively, a luminosity-based formulation can be used: \displaystyle\eta_{i}(\geq L_{\rm host})=V\int_{L_{\rm host}}^{\infty}\Phi(L)\,dL, (10) where \Phi(L) is the galaxy luminosity function and L_{\rm host} is the luminosity of the candidate host. 4 Results 4.1 Grid I: Galaxy Catalogue Injections 4.1.1 Localization Volumes Figure 5 presents the 3D localization volumes, quantified by the V_{50} and V_{90} credible regions, for each BBH injection in Grid I (Table 2 ), as inferred for the three GW detector networks we consider: HLVKIEC, HLV, and EC. Consistent with expectations, the HLVKIEC and EC networks yield significantly smaller localization volumes than HLV, due to their enhanced detector sensitivity and correspondingly higher SNR values for the CBCs. At fixed network and distance, localization volumes increase with decreasing total mass of the binary due to the correlation between SNR and CBC masses (Figure 1 ). For high-mass binaries, such as 50+50 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} , V_{90}^{\rm HLVKIEC}\sim V_{90}^{\rm EC}\sim 10^{-1}\penalty\ \rm{Mpc}^{3} at 500 Mpc, and V_{90}^{\rm HLVKIEC}\sim V_{90}^{\rm EC}\sim 10\penalty\ \rm{Mpc}^{3} at 1000 Mpc. In contrast, the HLV network yields much poorer localization, with V_{90}^{\rm HLV}>10^{2}\penalty\ \rm{Mpc}^{3} across all the distances and mass configurations. The horizontal shaded bands in Figure 5 indicate the theoretical minimum comoving volumes required to contain, on average, one galaxy of mass M_{*} or higher, under the assumption of different BBH formation channels as defined in Section 2.6 , along with the metallicity-based threshold V^{Z}_{\min} that we defined in Section 2.6.1 . Across both 50% and 90% credible volumes, the EC and HLVKIEC networks demonstrate strong localization performance relative to the threshold volumes, with localization volumes consistently lower than the thresholds across all mass configurations and distances; only at the lowest mass configuration at 1000 Mpc, \rm V^{HLVKIEC}_{90} and \rm V^{EC}_{90} are above V^{Z}_{\min} . Figure 5: Localization volumes for simulated BBH mergers in Grid I, at luminosity distances of 500, 750, and 1000 Mpc (Panels a–c) . For each mass configuration and network: HLVKIEC (red) , HLV (blue) , EC (green) , we plot V_{50} (hollow marker) and V_{90} (filled marker) , with a vertical line connecting the two. Horizontal shaded bands indicate the minimum comoving volume required to contain, on average, one galaxy of mass \mathrm{M}_{*} or higher under three different BBH formation channel assumptions: V_{\min} ( gray , Equation 5 ), V_{\min}^{\mathrm{iso}} ( blue ), and V_{\min}^{\mathrm{dyn}} ( red ). These threshold comoving volumes were computed within a redshift range of z=0.12 and z=0.23 , corresponding to the injected \mathrm{M}_{*} hosts (Table 7 ). The dashed purple horizontal line corresponds to the metallicity-dependent minimum comoving volume, V^{Z}_{\min} = 370.70 \rm Mpc^{3} , as calculated in Section 2.6.1 . 4.1.2 Mass Fractions Figure 6 shows the theoretical mass fractions, \rm\mathbb{M}_{*,\Phi} , for each BBH injection in Grid I. Both HLVKIEC and EC networks yield values of \sim 1 - 10^{4} at all three distances, for values evaluated with both V_{90} and V_{50} , with a systematic decline towards 1000 Mpc and towards low-mass BBHs; for HLV, \rm\mathbb{M}_{*,\Phi} is a few orders of magnitudes smaller ( \sim 10^{-3}-10 ), reflecting the larger localization volumes in those cases. The corresponding observed mass fractions, \rm\mathbb{M}_{*,obs} , are discussed in Section 5.2.3 . Figure 6: Theoretical ( \rm\mathbb{M}_{host,\Phi} ) mass fractions (Section 3.1 ) for simulated BBH mergers in Grid I at 500 Mpc, 750 Mpc and 1000 Mpc (Panels a - c) . \rm\mathbb{M}_{host,\Phi} is the ratio between the mass of the injected \mathrm{M}_{*} galaxy and the total theoretical mass enclosed within the GW localization volumes V_{50} and V_{90} .Colours denote the GW detector networks: HLVKIEC (red) , HLV (blue) , EC (green) . The hollow markers correspond to values evaluated within the V_{50} region and the filled markers correspond to values evaluated within the V_{90} region. 4.1.3 Chance Alignment We evaluate the probability of change alignment, p_{c} (Section 3.2 ), as a diagnostic of host identification for the BBH injections in Grid I in Figure 7 . At 500 Mpc, both EC and HLVKIEC consistently yield low chance alignment values, with p_{c}<0.01 for all mass configurations and GSMFs. In contrast, HLV shows higher values, with p_{c}(V_{90})>0.8 for the 5+5 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} injection. At 750 Mpc, the difference between the detector networks becomes more distinct. Both EC and HLVKIEC maintain p_{c}<0.01 for all mass configurations. The HLV-only configuration performs comparatively poorly, with p_{c}(V_{90})>0.2 for the 50+50 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} injection and p_{c}(V_{90})\sim 1 at 5+5 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} . At 1000 Mpc, p_{c}(V_{90})\lesssim 0.01 for all the HLVKIEC and EC injections up to 10+10 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} , and increases to \sim 0.1 at 5+5 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} . HLV returns p_{c}\approx 1 across all injections at 1000 Mpc. Figure 7: Probability of chance alignment, p_{c} , for Grid I BBH injections at 500 Mpc, 750 Mpc, and 1000 Mpc (Panels a-c) . Colours denote the GW detector networks: HLVKIEC (red) , HLV (blue) , EC (green) . The line style/marker encodes the different GSMFs across BBH formation channels used in Equation 9 : \Phi(M) ( solid/circle , Equation 1 ), \Phi^{\rm iso}(M) ( dashed/triangle , Equation 2 ), \Phi^{\rm dyn}(M) ( dotted/square , Equation 4 ). For each injection, the vertical segment spans the value at V_{50} (hollow marker) to the value at V_{90} (filled marker) . 4.2 Grid II: Maximum & Minimum Sky Sensitivity Injections 4.2.1 Localization Volumes Figure 8 illustrates the impact of network directional sensitivity on localization performance by comparing the credible volumes, V_{50} and V_{90} , for HLVKIEC and EC, at sky locations corresponding to maximum and minimum antenna responses (Table 3 ). As discussed in Section 2.2 , these sky positions were determined from the "bright" and "dark" regions of the antenna patterns of each detector network, and they approximately represent the most and least favourable configurations for network sensitivity, enabling us to probe the full range of localization outcomes for a fixed set of intrinsic source parameters. Panels (a-c) in Figure 8 show the localization volumes for the injected sources at the maximum sensitivity points of each network (lime green circles in Figure 2 , also see Table 3 ). In this best-case scenario, both networks localize all the injections across all the distances to volumes similar to or less than the threshold comoving volumes ( V_{\min} , V_{\min}^{\mathrm{iso}} , V_{\min}^{\mathrm{dyn}} ). For instance, a 50+50 \mathrm{M}_{\odot} BBH merger at 500 Mpc has V_{50}^{\rm HLVKIEC}\sim V_{50}^{\rm EC} \rm\sim 10^{-1}\penalty\ Mpc^{3} . Across the distances, HLVKIEC shows slightly better localization performance than EC. At 500 Mpc, both networks have localization volumes