Irreducible objects in the Gaiotto category at roots of unity Aleksandr Popkovich Abstract . A theorem of R. Travkin and R. Yang, initially conjectured by D. Gaiotto, states that for a generic (not a root of unity) q q the category of q q -twisted D-modules on the affine Grassmannian G ​ r G ​ L N Gr_{GL_{N}} which are equivariant with respect to a certain subgroup (defined by a choice of 0 ≤ M < N 0\leq MM+1 then \theta_{M+2},...,\theta_{N} are “dummy” entries, unaffected by the algorithm. Also, below we formulate the algorithm completely in terms of operations with tuples of integers and only for the case of passing from the stndard to the “mixed” Borel - for more general discussion we refer to [ BK ] . Now consider (2.4) A:=\{(\lambda,\theta)\in\mathbb{Z}^{M}\times\mathbb{Z}^{M+1}\text{ such that }\lambda_{1}\geq\lambda_{2}\geq...\geq\lambda_{M}\ \text{ and }\theta_{1}\geq\theta_{2}...\geq\theta_{M+1}\} This is the set of dominant integral weights of GL(M|N) , i.e. the highest weights with respect to the standard Borel subgroup (see Section 4 of [ BK ] ). There is a map S:A\to\mathbb{Z}^{M}\times\mathbb{Z}^{M+1} given by applying to the elements of A the following algorithm. The algorithm (but not its result) will depend on a choice of a linear order on the set \{\alpha_{i}\}:=\Phi^{+}_{st}\backslash\Phi^{+}_{m} which refines the ”standard” partial order given by \alpha\preccurlyeq_{st}\beta\iff(\alpha-\beta\in\Phi_{st}^{+}) . There are two linear orders that we will use. Under the identification \Phi^{+}_{st}\backslash\Phi^{+}_{m}=\{(i,j)|1\leq i\leq M,1\leq j0 ). The two linear orderings described above lead to two slightly different versions of the algorithms (i) Version 1: we go through the set \Phi^{+}_{st}\backslash\Phi^{+}_{m} using the linear order <_{1} described above, or (ii) Version 2: we use the linear order <_{2} . (the result does not depend on the version used). In both versions, on the k -th step of the algorithm transform one of the following two actions is taken: if (i_{k},j_{k}) is the k -th element of \Phi^{+}_{st}\backslash\Phi^{+}_{m} with respect to the chosen order then (i) (Action 1) If \lambda^{(k)}_{i_{k}}+\theta^{(k)}_{j_{k}}\equiv 0\text{ mod }p , then we do nothing: \lambda^{(k+1)}=\lambda^{(k)} and \theta^{(k+1)}=\theta^{(k)} (ii) (Action 2) Otherwise, \lambda^{(k+1)}_{i_{k}}=\lambda^{(k)}_{i_{k}}-1 , \theta^{(k+1)}_{j_{k}}=\theta^{(k)}_{j_{k}}+1 and for all i\neq i_{k} and j\neq j_{k} we have \lambda^{(k+1)}_{i}=\lambda^{(k)}_{i_{k}} and \theta^{(k+1)}_{j}=\theta^{(k)}_{j} . . We are able to describe the image of the set A under the Serganova’s algorithm. Lemma 3 . Denote by M\subset A the subset consisting of pairs (\lambda,\theta) that satisfy the following conditions: (i) \lambda_{1}\geq\lambda_{2}\geq...\geq\lambda_{M} and \theta_{1}\geq\theta_{2}...\geq\theta_{M+1} (ii) if \lambda_{i-1}=\lambda_{i} then \lambda_{i}+\theta_{i}=0\text{ mod }p , and (iii) if \theta_{i}=\theta_{i+1} then \lambda_{i}+\theta_{i}=0\text{ mod }p . Then we have an equality of sets S(A)=M\subset\mathbb{Z}^{M}\times\mathbb{Z}^{M+1} . Proof. First, let us show that S(A)\subset M . We will use the fact that the linear ordering of \Phi^{+}_{st}\backslash\Phi^{+}_{m} can be chosen in any way which is consistent with the partial order on this set without affecting the result of the algorithm. • To show that any element (\tilde{\lambda},\tilde{\theta})=S\left((\lambda,\theta)\right) in the image of S has \tilde{\lambda}_{i}\geq\tilde{\lambda}_{i+1} for all i and the condition (i) of the Lemma is satisfied, we use Version 1 of the algorithm. First we show that \tilde{\lambda}_{i}\geq\tilde{\lambda}_{i+1} for all i , that is \tilde{\lambda} is a non-increasing sequence of integers. In fact, a stronger statement is true (and we will need it swiftly): the property of being non-increasing is preserved on every step of the algorithm. Indeed, for the sake of contradiction suppose that on k -th step of the algorithm this property is broken for the first time, that is \lambda^{(k)} was non-increasing but \lambda^{(k+1)} is not. Since only the i_{k} -th entry of \lambda could be affected on this step, it must have been changed (decreased) and we must have \lambda^{(k+1)}_{i_{k}}<\lambda^{(k+1)}_{i_{k}+1} . Since every time Action 2 is taken the entry is only decreased by one, and on the previous iteration \lambda^{(k)} was non-increasing, we must have had \lambda^{(k)}_{i_{k}}<\lambda^{(k)}_{i_{k}+1} , and on a previous (k-1) -th step with i_{k-1}=i_{k}+1 (since we are using the dirst ordering) Action 1 must have been taken. But then it also should have been taken on the k -th step. A contradiction. Now to prove that condidtion (i) is always satisfied for (\tilde{\lambda},\tilde{\theta}) , suppose that we have \tilde{\lambda}_{i-1}=\tilde{\lambda}_{i} for some i . Let k be the last step on which i_{k}=i so that \lambda^{(k+1)}_{i}=\tilde{\lambda}_{i} . Since this is the last step on which i_{k}=i and we are using the ordering <_{1} the following must be true: we must have j_{k}=i_{k} , and all of the remaining “m”-th steps have i_{m}>i_{k} and j_{m}>j_{k} . It follows that \lambda_{i_{k}-1}^{(k+1)}=\tilde{\lambda}_{i_{k}-1} , \lambda_{i_{k}}^{(k+1)}=\tilde{\lambda}_{i_{k}} and \theta_{i_{k}}^{(k+1)}=\tilde{\theta}_{i_{k}} . So due to our assumption we must have \lambda_{i-1}^{(k+1)}=\lambda_{i}^{(k+1)} . This, together with the fact (proven above) that \lambda^{(k)} was non-increasing implies that on k -th step Action 1 was taken, so \lambda_{i_{k}}^{(k+1)}=\theta_{i_{k}}^{(k+1)} and hence \tilde{\lambda}_{i_{k}}^{(k+1)}=\tilde{\theta}_{i_{k}}^{(k+1)} . • Analogous reasoning using Version 2 of the algorithm shows that any element (\tilde{\lambda},\tilde{\theta})=S\left((\lambda,\theta)\right) in the image of S has \tilde{\theta}_{i}\geq\tilde{\theta}_{i+1} for all i and the condition (ii) of the Lemma is satisfied. • Finally, let us show that any pair (\tilde{\lambda},\tilde{\theta})\in M can be obtained as S((\lambda,\theta)) for some (\lambda,\theta)\in A . It turns out one can describe an inverse map S^{-1}:M\to A . For this note that whichever of the two Actions of the algorithm is take on step k , we have \lambda^{(k)}_{i_{k}}+\theta^{(k)}_{j_{k}}\equiv\lambda^{(k+1)}_{i_{k}}+\theta^{(k+1)}_{j_{k}}\text{ mod }p ; so at every moment we ”remember” what Action we took on the previous step. Therefore, we can ”invert” the algorithm by going through the set \Phi^{+}_{st}\backslash\Phi^{+}_{m} in the order inverse to either <_{1} or <_{2} and performing the transformations inverse to the ones we did earlier. This defines a map S^{-1}:M\to\mathbb{Z}^{M}\times\mathbb{Z}^{M+1} ; we need to show that S^{-1}(M)\subset A , i.e. that for any element (\tilde{\lambda},\tilde{\theta})\in M and (\lambda,\theta):=S^{-1}((\tilde{\lambda},\tilde{\theta})) both \lambda and \theta are non-decreasing. Let us prove that \lambda is non-decreasing. For this we will use the inverse to the Version 1 of the Serganova algorithm and the condition (i) of the Lemma. Since \tilde{\lambda} is already non-decreasing, we just need to show that this property is preserved on each step of the procedure. Let k -th step of the reversed algorithm be the first one on which the property of being non-increasing is broken. Call the input of this step (\lambda^{(in)},\theta^{(in)}) and the output (\lambda^{(out)},\theta^{(out)}) . The property being broken means that there are indeces i and j (indeces of entries being considered on this step) such that \lambda^{(in)}_{i-1}=\lambda^{(in)}_{i} , but \lambda^{(out)}_{i}=\lambda^{(out)}_{i-1}+1 and \theta^{(out)}_{j}=\theta^{(in)}_{j}-1 , that is on this step the inverse of Action 2 was performed, increasing the i -th value of \lambda and decreasing the j -th values of \theta . Now consider two cases: either i=j or i>j . If i>j then the above could not happen: for the inverse of Action 2 to be taken we must have \lambda^{(in)}+\theta^{(in)}\neq 0\text{ mod }p , but to have \lambda^{(in)}_{i-1}=\lambda^{(in)}_{i} Action 1 must have been taken on the previous step - one easily sees a contradiction. If i=j then again the inverse to Action 2 could not have been performed on this step: due to how reverse to order <_{1} works, we must have \lambda^{(in)}_{i-1}=\tilde{\lambda}_{i-1} , \lambda^{(in)}_{i}=\tilde{\lambda}_{i} and \theta^{(in)}_{i}=\tilde{\theta}_{i} , and we know that any element (\tilde{\lambda},\tilde{\theta})\in S(A) satisfies condition (i) of the Lemma, so from \lambda^{(in)}_{i-1}=\lambda^{(in)}_{i} follows \lambda^{(in)}+\theta^{(in)}=0\text{ mod }p hence the inverse to Action 2 was not taken. Proof that \theta is non-decreasing is analogues, using the inverse to Version 2 of the algorithm and condition (ii) of the lemma. ∎ Corollary 4 . The set of highest weights of irreducible representations from the category Rep_{p}(GL(M|N)) with respect to the “mixed” Borel subgroup consists of tuples (\lambda,\theta)\in\mathbb{Z}^{M}\times\mathbb{Z}^{N} that satisfy the following conditions. (2.6) \begin{split}\textnormal{A}:\textnormal{A}:\lambda_{1}\geq\lambda_{2}\geq\cdots\geq\lambda_{M},\\ \theta_{1}\geq\theta_{2}\geq\cdots\geq\theta_{M+1}\geq\theta_{M+2}\geq\cdots\geq\theta_{N}\\ \textnormal{and B: if }\theta_{i}=\theta_{i+1},\textnormal{then }\theta_{i}+\lambda_{i}=0\text{ mod }p,\textnormal{for }i=1,2,...,M;\\ \textnormal{if }\lambda_{i-1}=\lambda_{i},\textnormal{then }\theta_{i}+\lambda_{i}=0\text{ mod }p,\textnormal{for }i=2,...,M.\end{split} 3. Relevant orbits Now let us discuss the irreducible objects in the Gaiotto category \mathrm{SD}_{q}^{\mathrm{GL}_{M}(\mathcal{O})\times U_{M,N}^{-}(\mathcal{K}),\chi}(\mathrm{Gr}_{N}) , i.e. in the left-hand side of the desired equivalence 1.1 . For standard reasons, they correspond to a subset of orbits of the action of \mathrm{GL}_{M}(\mathcal{O})\times U_{M,N}^{-}(\mathcal{K}) on \mathrm{Gr}_{N} . These are the orbits that support the (twisted) D -modules that satisfy the necessary equivariance conditions; we call such orbits relevant. 3.1. Results of Travkin and Yang A detailed study of relevant orbits for the case when q is not a root of unity is can be found in [ TY2 ] , and similar analyses were performed in [ BFT1 ] , [ BFT2 ] and [ TY1 ] . In this subsection we state the classification from [ TY2 ] with one modification (accounting for the condition q^{p}=1 ) and indicate where this modification is coming from. First, one sees that all GL_{M}(\mathbb{O})\ltimes U_{M,N}^{-}(\mathcal{K}) -orbits are enumerated by certain weights: Lemma 5 . (Lemma 3.3.3 in [ TY2 ] ) Any GL_{M}(\mathbb{O})\ltimes U_{M,N}^{-}(\mathcal{K}) -orbit in {\mathrm{Gr}}_{N} has a unique representative of the form \mathbb{L}_{(\lambda,(\theta,\theta^{\prime}))} , such that (\lambda,\theta) is a dominant weight of length (M,M+1) , and \theta^{\prime} is a sequence of length N-M-1 . Here, (3.1) \mathbb{L}_{(\lambda,(\theta,\theta^{\prime}))}=\begin{pmatrix}t^{-\lambda_{1}-\theta_{1}}&&&&&&\\ &\ddots&&&&&\\ &&t^{-\lambda_{M}-\theta_{M}}&&&&\\ t^{-\theta_{1}}&\dots&t^{-\theta_{M}}&t^{-\theta_{M+1}}&&&\\ &&&&t^{-\theta^{\prime}_{1}}&&\\ &&&&&\ddots&\\ &&&&&&t^{-\theta^{\prime}_{N-M-1}}\end{pmatrix}\in GL_{N}(\mathcal{K}). Then one can work out which of them are relevant (thus also classifying the irreducible objects in the Gaiotto category). Proposition 6 . (Proposition 3.3.4 in [ TY2 ] ) The GL_{M}(\mathbb{O})\ltimes U_{M,N}^{-}(\mathcal{K}) -orbit of \mathbb{L}_{(\lambda,(\theta,\theta^{\prime}))} is relevant if and only if (\lambda,(\theta,\theta^{\prime}))\in M , that is if and only if (3.2) \begin{split}\textnormal{A}:\lambda_{1}\leq\lambda_{2}\leq\cdots\leq\lambda_{M},\\ \theta_{1}\leq\theta_{2}\leq\cdots\leq\theta_{M+1}\leq\theta^{\prime}_{1}\leq\cdots\leq\theta^{\prime}_{N-M-1},\\ \textnormal{and B: if }\theta_{i}=\theta_{i+1},\textnormal{then }\theta_{i}+\lambda_{i}=0,\textnormal{for }i=1,2,...,M;\\ \textnormal{if }\lambda_{i-1}=\lambda_{i},\textnormal{then }\theta_{i}+\lambda_{i}=0,\textnormal{for }i=2,...,M.\end{split} For the case of q^{p}=1 we claim the following. Proposition 7 . Suppose q^{p}=1 . Then The GL_{M}(\mathbb{O})\ltimes U_{M,N}^{-}(\mathcal{K}) -orbit of \mathbb{L}_{(\lambda,(\theta,\theta^{\prime}))} is relevant if and only if (\lambda,(\theta,\theta^{\prime}))\in M , that is if and only if (3.3) \begin{split}\textnormal{A}:\textnormal{A}:\lambda_{1}\leq\lambda_{2}\leq\cdots\leq\lambda_{M},\\ \theta_{1}\leq\theta_{2}\leq\cdots\leq\theta_{M+1}\leq\theta^{\prime}_{1}\leq\cdots\leq\theta^{\prime}_{N-M-1}\\ \textnormal{and B: if }\theta_{i}=\theta_{i+1},\textnormal{then }\theta_{i}+\lambda_{i}=0\text{ mod }p,\textnormal{for }i=1,2,...,M;\\ \textnormal{if }\lambda_{i-1}=\lambda_{i},\textnormal{then }\theta_{i}+\lambda_{i}=0\text{ mod }p,\textnormal{for }i=2,...,M.\end{split} Proof. The proof is the same as the proof of Proposition 3.3.4 in [ TY2 ] with only a minor modification. Just as in loc. cit. we need to check that the condition stated above is equivalent to the condition that Stab_{GL_{M}(\mathbb{O})\ltimes U^{-}_{M,N}(\mathcal{K})}(\mathbb{L}_{(\lambda,(\theta,\theta^{\prime}))})\subset Ker\ \chi and that this stabilizer acts trivially on the fiber of \overset{\circ}{\mathcal{P}}_{\det,N} over \mathbb{L}_{(\lambda,(\theta,\theta^{\prime}))}\in Gr_{N} . The proof that Stab_{GL_{M}(\mathbb{O})\ltimes U^{-}_{M,N}(\mathcal{K})}(\mathbb{L}_{(\lambda,(\theta,\theta^{\prime}))})\subset Ker\ \chi iff \theta_{M+1}\leq\theta^{\prime}_{1}\leq\cdots\leq\theta^{\prime}_{N-M-1} is the same as in loc cit. The minor change should be introduced to the proof that the stabilizer group Stab_{GL_{M}(\mathcal{O})}(\mathbb{L}_{(\lambda,\theta)}) acts trivially on the fiber over \mathbb{L}_{(\lambda,\theta)} if and only if (\lambda,\theta) satisfies the condition B (since the condition B in loc.cit. does not feature any comparison mod p ). Namely, [ TY2 ] refers for the proof to Proposition 4.1.1 of [ BFT1 ] , which in turn is based on the computation of stabilizers made in [ BFT2 ] , Lemma 2.3.3. In this computation one encounters the action of some GL_{n} (a factor of Stab_{GL_{M}(\mathcal{O})}(\mathbb{L}_{(\lambda,\theta)}) ) acting on the fiber over \mathbb{L}_{(\lambda,\theta)} by det^{a} where a=\theta_{i}+\lambda_{i} for i such that either \theta_{i}=\theta_{i+1} or \lambda_{i-1}=\lambda_{i} . When q is not a root of unity, the condition that this action trivializes is that a=0 , hence the form of condition B of Proposition 4.1.1 of [ TY2 ] . In our case when q^{p}=1 , this action trivializes whenever a=0\text{ mod }p , which is the reason for the modification of condition B above. ∎ 3.2. Swithing the group It is time to make an important remark. Remark 8 . We want to note at this point that the choice of the unipotent subgroup U_{M,N}^{-}(\mathcal{K}) of GL_{N}(\mathcal{K}) made in [ TY2 ] is not the only possible one, and in fact is different from the choice in [ TY1 ] , where the authors define and use the group U_{M,N}(\mathcal{K}) which is “transposed” U_{M,N}^{-}(\mathcal{K}) (i.e. U_{M,N}(\mathcal{K}) is a subgroup of upper-triangular matrices, while U_{M,N}^{-}(\mathcal{K}) is in lower-triangular). Both choices in fact lead to equivalent categories of equivariant sheaves - see discussion in section 5 of [ TY1 ] . However, the descriptions of all orbits and of relevent orbits don’t change drastically: when one switches from U_{M,N}^{-}(\mathcal{K}) to U_{M,N}(\mathcal{K}) , all of the inequalities should be reversed (which is proved mutatis mutandis compared to the proof of Lemma 3.3.3 and Proposition 3.3.4 of [ TY2 ] ). Corollary 9 . Suppose q^{p}=1 . The set of all GL_{M}(\mathbb{O})\ltimes U_{M,N}(\mathcal{K}) -orbits is in bijection with integral weights of GL(M|N) , and the set of relevant orbits consists of those tuples (\lambda,(\theta,\theta^{\prime}))\in\mathbb{Z}^{M}\times\mathbb{Z}^{N} that satisfy the following conditions. (3.4) \begin{split}\textnormal{A}:\textnormal{A}:\lambda_{1}\geq\lambda_{2}\geq\cdots\geq\lambda_{M},\\ \theta_{1}\geq\theta_{2}\geq\cdots\geq\theta_{M+1}\geq\theta^{\prime}_{1}\geq\cdots\geq\theta^{\prime}_{N-M-1}\\ \textnormal{and B: if }\theta_{i}=\theta_{i+1},\textnormal{then }\theta_{i}+\lambda_{i}=0\text{ mod }p,\textnormal{for }i=1,2,...,M;\\ \textnormal{if }\lambda_{i-1}=\lambda_{i},\textnormal{then }\theta_{i}+\lambda_{i}=0\text{ mod }p,\textnormal{for }i=2,...,M.\end{split} We can now combine Corollary 4 and Corollary 4 and fomulate the main statement of this note. Theorem 10 . Let q^{p}=1 for prime p . Then the set of orbits that support irreducible objects of \mathrm{SD}_{q}^{\mathrm{GL}_{M}(\mathcal{O})\ltimes U_{M,N}(\mathcal{K}),\chi}(\mathrm{Gr}_{N}) is equal (as a subset of the lattice of integral weights of supergroup GL(m|n) ) to the set of highest weights of irreducible objects of \mathrm{Rep}_{p}(\mathrm{GL}(M|N)) with respect to the “mixed” Borel subalgebra.