First-Exit Time Analysis for Truncated Heavy-Tailed Dynamical Systems Xingyu Wang, Chang-Han Rhee Abstract In this paper, we study the first-exit time of stochastic difference equation X j + 1 η ​ ( x ) = X j η ​ ( x ) + η ​ a ​ ( X j η ​ ( x ) ) + η ​ σ ​ ( X j η ​ ( x ) ) ​ Z j + 1 X^{\eta}_{j+1}(x)=X^{\eta}_{j}(x)+\eta a\big(X^{\eta}_{j}(x)\big)+\eta\sigma\big(X^{\eta}_{j}(x)\big)Z_{j+1} and its truncated variant X j + 1 η | b ​ ( x ) = X j η | b ​ ( x ) + φ b ​ ( η ​ a ​ ( X j η | b ​ ( x ) ) + η ​ σ ​ ( X j η | b ​ ( x ) ) ​ Z j + 1 ) X^{\eta|b}_{j+1}(x)=X^{\eta|b}_{j}(x)+\varphi_{b}\big(\eta a\big(X^{\eta|b}_{j}(x)\big)+\eta\sigma\big(X^{\eta|b}_{j}(x)\big)Z_{j+1}\big) , where φ b ​ ( x ) = ( x / ‖ x ‖ ) ​ min ⁡ { ‖ x ‖ , b } \varphi_{b}(x)=(x/\left\lVert x\right\rVert)\min\{\left\lVert x\right\rVert,b\} and the law of the noise Z t Z_{t} is multivariate regularly varying. The truncation operator φ b ​ ( ⋅ ) \varphi_{b}(\cdot) is often introduced as a modulation mechanism in heavy-tailed systems, such as stochastic gradient descent algorithms in deep learning. By developing a framework that connects large deviations with metastability, we leverage the locally uniform sample-path large deviations for both processes in [ 56 ] to obtain precise characterizations of the joint distributions of the first exit times and exit locations. The resulting limit theorem unveils a discrete hierarchy of phase transitions (i.e., exit times) as the truncation threshold b b varies, and manifests the catastrophe principle, whereby key events or metastable behaviors in heavy-tailed systems are driven by catastrophic behavior in a few components while the rest of the system behaves nominally. These developments lead to a comprehensive heavy-tailed counterpart of the classical Freidlin-Wentzell theory. 1 Introduction Metastability analysis in stochastic dynamical systems has a rich history in probability theory and related fields. Since the foundational works of Kramers and Eyring [ 13 , 34 , 21 ] , which analyzed phase transitions in stochastic dynamical systems in the context of chemical reaction-rate theory, extensive theoretical advancements have been made. One of the most notable breakthroughs is the now-classical Freidlin-Wentzell theory [ 17 , 18 , 19 ] , which introduced large deviations machinery to the analysis of exit times and global behaviors of small random perturbations of dynamical systems. Further extensions of this approach in the context of statistical physics were pioneered in [ 10 ] and described in detail in [ 42 ] . One of the key advantages of this approach—often called the pathwise approach —is its ability to describe in detail the scenarios that lead to phase transitions. In particular, the large deviations formalism at the sample-path level enables precise identification of the most likely paths out of the metastability sets. This ensures that, asymptotically, whenever the dynamical system escapes from the metastability set, the escape routes almost always closely resemble these most likely paths. However, the sample-path-level large deviations are typically available only in the form of logarithmic asymptotics, and hence, the asymptotic scale of the exit time can be determined only up to its exponential rate, requiring different approaches to identify the prefactor. Another breakthrough is the potential-theoretic approach initiated in [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] and later summarized in [ 6 ] . Instead of relying on large deviations machinery, this approach leverages potential-theoretic tools: the scale of exit times for Markov processes can be expressed in terms of capacity, which, in turn, can be bounded using variational principles. The key advantage of this approach, compared to the pathwise approach, is that it is often possible to find test functions that tightly bound the capacity of the Markov chains, thereby yielding precise asymptotics—rather than merely logarithmic asymptotics as in the pathwise approach—of the scales of exit times. Although the potential theoretic approach does not provide as much information (such as the most likely paths) as the pathwise approach beyond the asymptotics of the exit times, its sharpness has inspired extensive research activity. The early works in the potential theoretic approach were focused on reversible Markov processes. However, recent developments have extended the scope of the approach to enable the analysis of non-reversible Markov processes; see, for example, [ 53 , 35 , 20 , 36 ] . While these developments provide powerful means to understand metastability of light-tailed systems, heavy-tailed systems exhibit a fundamentally different metastable behaviors and call for a different set of technical tools for successful analysis. For example, early foundational works in heavy-tailed context [ 26 , 27 , 31 , 28 ] proved that the exit times of the stochastic processes driven by heavy-tailed noises scale polynomially with respect to the scaling parameter. These papers also reveal that the exit events are almost always driven by a single disproportionately large jump, while the rest of the system’s behavior remains close to its nominal behavior. By nominal behavior, we refer to the functional law of large numbers limit. This is in sharp contrast to the light-tailed cases, where the exit times scale exponentially, and the exit events are driven by smooth tilting of the entire system from its nominal behavior. One can view this as a manifestation of the principle of a single big jump , a well-known folklore in extreme value theory. However, across machine learning, finance, operations research, and other disciplines, many impactful key events or metastable behaviors cannot be driven by a single big jump (e.g. [ 1 , 54 , 16 , 15 , 55 ] ). For example, in the context of deep learning, stochastic gradient descent (SGD) and its variants are the powerhouse behind the training of deep neural networks (DNNs), and SGD’s ability to find flat local minima are believed to be associated with the generalization performance of DNNs on test data (see, e.g., [ 32 ] ). Nevertheless, the commonly used gradient clipping technique (see, e.g., [ 12 , 43 ] ) modifies the step size of SGD to prevent drastic changes of model weights in a single iteration, which prevents the escape from a wide, flat local minima using a single big jump in SGD. In such cases, we observe the more general catastrophe principle , where key events or metastable behaviors are driven by multiple big jumps under heavy tails. A rigorous mathematical characterization of the catastrophe principle for Lévy processes and random walks was established in the form of heavy-tailed sample-path large deviations [ 50 ] , leveraging the \mathbb{M} -convergence theory originally introduced in [ 38 ] . More recently, [ 56 ] considered a uniform extension of the \mathbb{M} -convergence theory and characterized the catastrophe principle for a much broader class of processes, including SGD-type stochastic difference equations under multivariate regularly varying dynamics. The results in [ 50 , 56 ] can be viewed as the heavy-tailed counterpart of the Mogulskii’s theorem [ 39 , 40 ] and Freidlin-Wentzell theory [ 19 ] , and such a formulation of large deviations provides precise asymptotics for heavy-tailed processes, in contrast to the logarithmic asymptotics of the classical large deviation principle. This raises the hope that, for heavy-tailed dynamical systems, it may be possible to simultaneously obtain both detailed descriptions of the scenarios leading to phase transitions (as in the pathwise approach [ 19 , 42 ] ) and sharp asymptotics for the exit time (as in the potential-theoretic approach [ 6 ] ). In this paper, we successfully implemented this strategy and obtained metastability analyses for heavy-tailed dynamical systems with transition dynamics potentially modulated by truncation. Specifically, the main contributions of this paper are as follows: • We establish a scaling limit of the exit-time and exit-location for stochastic difference equations. We accomplish this by developing a machinery for local stability analysis of general (heavy-tailed) Markov processes. Central to the development is the concept of asymptotic atoms, where the process recurrently enters and asymptotically regenerates. Leveraging the recent developments of locally uniform version of sample-path large deviations in [ 56 ] over these asymptotic atoms, we derive sharp asymptotics for the joint distribution of (scaled) exit-times and exit-locations for heavy-tailed processes, as detailed in Theorem 3.1 and Corollary 3.2 . Notably, the scaling rate parameter reflects an intricate interplay between the truncation threshold and the geometry of the drift, which is a feature absent in both the principle of a single big jump regime (heavy-tailed systems without truncation) and the conspiracy principle regime (light-tailed systems). Below, we give a more detailed account of related literature and overview of the main results. Let (\bm{Z}_{i})_{i\geq 1} be a sequence of independent copies of a random vector \bm{Z} in \mathbb{R}^{d} such that \mathbf{E}\bm{Z}=\bm{0} . For any \eta>0 and \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} , let \big(\bm{X}^{\eta}_{t}(\bm{x})\big)_{t\geq 0} be the solution to \displaystyle\bm{X}^{\eta}_{0}(\bm{x})=\bm{x};\qquad\bm{X}^{\eta}_{t}(\bm{x})=\bm{X}^{\eta}_{t-1}(\bm{x})+\eta\bm{a}\big(\bm{X}^{\eta}_{t-1}(\bm{x})\big)+\eta\bm{\sigma}\big(\bm{X}^{\eta}_{t-1}(\bm{x})\big)\bm{Z}_{t},\quad\forall t\geq 1. (1.1) Here, the vector-valued function \bm{a}:\mathbb{R}^{m}\to\mathbb{R}^{m} and the matrix-valued function \bm{\sigma}:\mathbb{R}^{m}\to\mathbb{R}^{m\times d} are the drift coefficient and diffusion coefficients, and \eta denotes the step length parameter. The equivalent scalar form is \displaystyle X^{\eta}_{t,i}(\bm{x})=X^{\eta}_{t-1,i}(\bm{x})+\eta a_{i}\big(\bm{X}^{\eta}_{t-1}(\bm{x})\big)+\eta\sum_{j\in[d]}\sigma_{i,j}\big(\bm{X}^{\eta}_{t-1}(\bm{x})\big)Z_{t,j},\quad\forall t\geq 1,\ i\in[m], with \bm{a}(\cdot)=\big(a_{1}(\cdot),\ldots,a_{m}(\cdot)\big)^{\top}, \bm{\sigma}(\cdot)=\big(\sigma_{i,j}(\ldots)\big)_{i\in[m],j\in[d]}, and \bm{X}^{\eta}_{t}(\bm{x})=\big(X^{\eta}_{t,1}(\bm{x}),\ldots,X^{\eta}_{t,m}(\bm{x})\big)^{\top}, \bm{Z}_{t}=(Z_{t,1},\ldots,Z_{t,d})^{\top}. Of particular interest is a truncated variant of ( 1.1 ) under the operator \displaystyle\varphi_{b}(\bm{w})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}{}(b\wedge\left\lVert\bm{w}\right\rVert)\cdot\frac{\bm{w}}{\left\lVert\bm{w}\right\rVert}\ \ \ \forall\bm{w}\neq\bm{0},\qquad{\varphi_{b}}(\bm{0})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\bm{0}. (1.2) Here, u\wedge v=\min\{u,v\} and u\vee v=\max\{u,v\} , and throughout this paper we interpret \left\lVert\cdot\right\rVert over \mathbb{R}^{d} as the L_{2} norm. That is, \varphi_{b} is the projection operator onto the closed L_{2} ball centered at the origin with radius b . Given \eta,b\in(0,\infty) and \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} , let \displaystyle\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{0}(\bm{x})=\bm{x};\qquad{\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x})}=\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t-1}(\bm{x})+\varphi_{b}\Big(\eta\bm{a}\big(\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t-1}(\bm{x})\big)+\eta\bm{\sigma}\big(\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t-1}(\bm{x})\big)\bm{Z}_{t}\Big),\quad\forall t\geq 1. (1.3) That is, \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x}) is a variation of \bm{X}^{\eta}_{t}(\bm{x}) where the update at each step is bounded by b . In the context of modern machine learning, ( 1.1 ) and ( 1.3 ) can be viewed as models for the dynamics of SGD and the variant under gradient clipping ( [ 12 , 43 , 58 , 33 ] ), respectively. In particular, if \bm{a} is the negative gradient of the training loss U , then the argument of \varphi_{b}(\cdot) in ( 1.3 ), \eta\bm{a}\big(\bm{X}_{t}^{\eta}(\bm{x})\big)+\eta\bm{\sigma}\big(\bm{X}_{t}^{\eta}(\bm{x})\big)\bm{Z}_{t+1}=-\eta\big(\nabla U\big(\bm{X}_{t}^{\eta}(\bm{x})\big)-\bm{\sigma}\big(\bm{X}_{t}^{\eta}(\bm{x})\big)\bm{Z}_{t+1}\big) , represents the state-dependent stochastic gradient of U at \bm{X}_{t}^{\eta}(\bm{x}) , scaled by the negative learning rate -\eta , which corresponds to the one-step displacement of SGD. As noted earlier, two modern approaches to the analysis of exit times for light-tailed stochastic dynamical systems are the Freidlin-Wentzell theory (or pathwise approach) detailed in the monographs [ 19 , 42 ] and the potential theoretic approach summarized in the monograph [ 6 ] . Despite their success in the light-tailed contexts, neither the pathwise approach nor the potential theoretic approach readily extends to heavy-tailed contexts. In particular, for truncated heavy-tailed dynamics such as \bm{X}_{t}^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}) , the explicit formula for the stationary distribution is rarely available, and its generator lacks the simplicity of the Brownian case, making the adaptation of potential theoretic approach to our context challenging. Meanwhile, the pathwise approach hinges on the large deviation principles at the sample-path level. Historically, however, the heavy-tailed large deviations at the sample-path level have been unavailable and considered to be out of reach until recently. See, for instance, [ 24 ] for a functional level characterization of the principle of a single big jump, and [ 50 , 3 , 56 ] for sample-path-level characterizations of the catastrophe principle. See also for an alternative formulation of the catastrophe principle in terms of the extended LDP in [ 5 ] providing log asymptotics. Successful results in metastability analyses for heavy-tailed systems are relatively recent. For one-dimensional Lévy driven SDEs, [ 26 , 31 ] proved that the exit times from metastability sets scale at a polynomial rate and the prefactor of the of the scale depend on the width of the potential wells rather than the height of the potential barrier. Similar results have been established in more general settings, such as the multi-dimensional analog in [ 28 ] , exit times for a global attractor instead of a stable point [ 22 ] (see also [ 23 ] for its application in characterizing the limiting Markov chain of hyperbolic dynamical systems driven by heavy-tailed perturbations), exit times under multiplicative noises in \mathbb{R}^{d} [ 45 ] , extensions to infinite-dimensional spaces [ 11 ] , and the (discretized) stochastic difference equations driven by \alpha -stable noises [ 41 ] , to name a few. Such metastability analyses were applied in [ 52 ] to study the generaliztion performance of DNNs trained by SGDs with heavy-tailed dynamics and, more recently, in [ 2 ] to analyze the sample efficiency of policy gradient algorithms in reinforcement learning. We note that these results focus on events associated with the principle of a single big jump. In contrast, this paper develops a systematic tool for analyzing the exit times and locations, even in cases where the principle of a single big jump fails to account for the exit events, and more complex patterns arise during the exit process. The process \bm{X}_{t}^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}) exemplifies such a scenario, as the truncation operator \varphi_{b}(\cdot) may prevent exits driven by a single big jump. We reveal phase transitions in the first exit times of \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x}) , which depend on a notion of the “discretized widths” of the attraction fields. Specifically, consider ( 1.3 ) with drift coefficients \bm{a}(\cdot)=-\nabla U(\cdot) for some potential function U\in\mathcal{C}^{1}(\mathbb{R}^{m}) . Without loss of generality, let I\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{m} be some open and bounded set containing the origin. Suppose that the entire domain I falls within the attraction field of the origin, and the gradient field -\nabla U(\cdot) is locally contractive around the origin (see Section 3.1.1 for details). In other words, when initialized within I , the deterministic gradient flow d\bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x})/dt=-\nabla U(\bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x})) (under the initial condition \bm{y}_{0}(\bm{x})=\bm{x} ) will be attracted to and remain trapped near the origin. However, due to the presence of random perturbations, \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x}) will eventually escape from I after a sufficiently long time. Of particular interest are the asymptotic scale of the first exit times as \eta\downarrow 0 . Theorem 3.1 proves that the joint law of the first exit time \tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})=\min\{t\geq 0:\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x})\notin I\} and the exit location \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau}(\bm{x})\triangleq\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x}) admits the limit (uniformly for all \bm{x} bounded away from I^{c} ): \displaystyle\Big(\lambda^{I}_{b}(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}),\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau}(\bm{x})\Big)\Rightarrow(E,V_{b})\qquad\text{ as }\eta\downarrow 0 (1.4) with some (deterministic) time-scaling function \lambda^{I}_{b}(\eta) . Here, E is an exponential random variable with the rate parameter 1, V_{b} is some random element independent of E and supported on I^{c} , and the scaling function \lambda_{b}^{I}(\eta) is regularly varying with index -[1+\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}(\alpha-1)] as \eta\downarrow 0 , where \mathcal{J}^{I}_{b} is the aforementioned discretized width of domain I relative to the truncation threshold b . The precise definition of \mathcal{J}_{b}^{I} is provided in ( 3.7 ) in Section 3.1.1 . However, we note that in the special case b=\infty , one can immediately verify that \mathcal{J}_{b}^{I}=1 , regardless of the geometry of U . Consequently, ( 1.4 ) reduces to the principle of a single big jump, as expected. When the drift is contractive so that \nabla U(\bm{x})\cdot\bm{x}\geq 0 for all \bm{x}\in I , it is also straightforward to see that \mathcal{J}_{b}^{I}=\lceil r/b\rceil where r is the distance between \bm{0} and I^{c} , and hence, \mathcal{J}_{b}^{I} is indeed precisely the discretized width of the attraction field I relative to b . In particular, note that the drift is contractive within any attraction field in the one-dimensional cases. However, in general multi-dimensional spaces, \mathcal{J}_{b}^{I} reflects a much more intricate interplay between the geometry of the drift \bm{a}(\cdot) (or the potential U(\cdot) ) and the truncation threshold b . (i) (ii) Figure 1.1: Numerical examples of the metastability analysis. (i) The univariate potential U(\cdot) defined in ( 3.15 ). (ii) First exit times \tau^{\eta|b}(m) from I under different truncation thresholds b and scale parameters \eta . Dashed lines are predictions from our results in Section 3.1 , whereas the dots are the exit times estimated using 20 samples. Non-solid dot represents an underestimation due to early termination after long runtime ( 5\times 10^{7} steps). Figure 1.1 illustrates the key role of the relative width \mathcal{J}_{b}^{I} in one dimension. Figure 1.1 illustrates the catastrophe principle in the first exit behaviors of \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x}) by considering a univariate example. Specifically, consider a potential function U:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R} depicted in Figure 1.1 (i), where I=(s_{1},s_{2}) is the attraction field of the local minimum m . Since m is closer to the left boundary s_{1} , the minimal number of steps required to exit I when starting from m is \mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}=\lceil|s-m_{1}|/b\rceil where b\in(0,\infty) . In the untruncated case ( 1.1 ) (i.e., with b=\infty ), we simply have \mathcal{J}^{\mathcal{I}}_{\infty}=1 . Figure 1.1 (ii) illustrates the discrete structure of phase transitions in ( 1.4 ), where the first exit time \tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}) is (roughly) of order 1/\eta^{1+\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}\cdot(\alpha-1)} for small \eta , with \alpha=1.2 being the index of \bm{Z}_{i} ’s regular variation. This means that the order of the first exit time \tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}) does not vary continuously with respect to the truncation threshold b . Instead, it exhibits a discrete dependence on b through the integer-valued quantity \mathcal{J}^{I}_{b} . Consequently, the wider the domain I , the asymptotically longer the exit time \tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}) will be. See Section 3.2 for details of the numerical experiments presented in Figure 1.1 . Our approach to the metastability analysis hinges on the concept of asymptotic atoms, a general machinery we develop in Section 3.1.2 . Asymptotic atoms are nested regions of recurrence at which the process asymptotically regenerates upon each visit. Our locally uniform sample-path large deviations then prove to be the right tool in this framework, empowering us to characterize the behavior of the stochastic processes uniformly for all initial values over the asymptotic atoms. It should be noted that [ 29 ] also investigated the exit events driven by multiple truncated jumps. However, in their context, the mechanism through which multiple jumps arise is due to a different tail behavior of the increment distribution that is lighter than any polynomial rate—more precisely, a Weibull tail—and it is fundamentally different from that of the regularly varying case. (See also [ 30 ] for the summary of the hierarchy in the asymptotics of the first exit times for heavy-tailed dynamics.) Our results complement the picture and provide a missing piece of the puzzle by unveiling the phase transitions in the exit times under truncated regularly varying perturbations. A culmination of metastability analysis is the sharp characterization of the global dynamics of heavy-tailed processes, often established in the form of process-level convergence of scaled processes to simpler ones, such as Markov jump processes on a discrete state space; see, for example, [ 42 , 6 , 27 , 31 , 37 , 49 ] . For the SDE counterpart of the unregulated processes such as ( 1.1 ), it is well known that the exit events are governed by the principle of a single big jump, and the scaling limit is a Markov jump process with a state space consisting of the local minima of the potential function; see e.g., [ 23 , 27 , 31 ] . In a companion paper [ 57 ] , we demonstrate that the framework developed in this paper is strong enough to extend the above-mentioned results to the systems not governed by the principle of a single big jump over a multi-well potential, by identifying scaling limits and characterizing their global behavior at the process level. In particular, the scaling limit for the truncated heavy-tailed dynamics is a Markov jump process that only visits the widest minima of the potential . This is in sharp contrast to the untruncated cases [ 23 , 27 , 31 ] where the limiting Markov jump process visits all the local minima with certain fractions. As a result, the fraction of time such processes spend in narrow attraction fields converges to zero as the scaling parameter (often called learning rate in the machine learning literature) tends to zero. Precise characterization of such phenomena is of fundamental importance in understanding and further leveraging the curious effectiveness of the stochastic gradient descent (SGD) algorithms in training deep neural networks. Some of the the metastability analysis in Section 3.1 of this paper have been presented in a preliminary univariate form at a conference [ 55 ] . The main focus of [ 55 ] was the connection between the metastability analysis of stochastic gradient descent (SGD) and its generalization performance in the context of training deep neural networks. Compared to the brute force approach in [ 55 ] , the current paper provides a systematic framework to characterize the global dynamics for significantly more general class of heavy-tailed dynamical systems. We also note that first-exit analysis of the form ( 1.4 ) can be extended to stochastic difference equations akin to ( 1.1 ) and ( 1.3 ) but under different scaling w.r.t. \eta , or Lévy-driven stochastic differential equations. We state those results in Sections A and B in the Appendix. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 reviews the uniform sample path large deviations developed in [ 56 ] . Section 3 carries out the first-exit analysis and presents the main results of this paper, with numerical examples collected in Section 3.2 . Sections 4 , 5 , and 6 provides the proofs. Results for stochastic difference equations under more general scaling regimes are presented in Appendix A . Results for SDEs driven by Lévy processes with regularly varying increments are collected in Appendix B . 2 Preliminaries In Section 2.1 , we collect frequently used notations. In Section 2.2 , we review the sample-path large deviations developed in [ 56 ] for heavy-tailed dynamical systems. 2.1 Notations Let [n]\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\{1,2,\cdots,n\} for any positive integer n . Let \mathbb{N}=\{0,1,2,\cdots\} be the set of non-negative integers. Let (\mathbb{S},\bm{d}) be a metric space with \mathscr{S}_{\mathbb{S}} being the corresponding Borel \sigma -algebra. For any E\subseteq\mathbb{S} , let E^{\circ} and E^{-} be the interior and closure of E , respectively. For any r>0 , let E^{r}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\{y\in\mathbb{S}:\ \bm{d}(E,y)\leq r\} be the r -enlargement of a set E . Here for any set A\subseteq\mathbb{S} and any x\in\mathbb{S} , we define \bm{d}(A,x)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\inf\{\bm{d}(y,x):\ y\in A\} . Also, let E_{r}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}((E^{c})^{r})^{c} be the r -shrinkage of E . Note that for any E , the enlargement E^{r} of E is closed, and the shrinkage E_{r} of E is open. We say that set A\subseteq\mathbb{S} is bounded away from another set B\subseteq\mathbb{S} if \inf_{x\in A,y\in B}\bm{d}(x,y)>0 . For any Borel measure \mu on (\mathbb{S},\mathscr{S}_{\mathbb{S}}) , let the support of \mu (denoted as \text{supp}(\mu) ) be the smallest closed set C such that \mu(\mathbb{S}\setminus C)=0 . For any function g:\mathbb{S}\to\mathbb{R} , let \text{supp}(g)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\big(\{x\in\mathbb{S}:\ g(x)\neq 0\}\big)^{-}. Given two sequences of positive real numbers (x_{n})_{n\geq 1} and (y_{n})_{n\geq 1} , we say that x_{n}=\mathcal{O}(y_{n}) (as n\to\infty ) if there exists some C\in[0,\infty) such that x_{n}\leq Cy_{n}\ \forall n\geq 1 . Besides, we say that x_{n}=\mathit{o}(y_{n}) if \lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}x_{n}/y_{n}=0 . 2.2 Heavy-Tailed Large Deviations We review the sample path large deviations for the truncated dynamics \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x}) in ( 1.3 ) under i.i.d. \bm{Z}_{t} ’s whose heavy tails are characterized via multivariate regular variation. A measurable function \phi:(0,\infty)\to(0,\infty) is regularly varying as x\rightarrow\infty with index \beta (denoted as \phi(x)\in\mathcal{RV}_{\beta}(x) as x\to\infty ) if \lim_{x\rightarrow\infty}\phi(tx)/\phi(x)=t^{\beta} for all t>0 . See also [ 4 , 47 , 14 ] for a more detailed treatment to regularly varying functions. We also say that a measurable function \phi(\eta) is regularly varying as \eta\downarrow 0 with index \beta if \lim_{\eta\downarrow 0}\phi(t\eta)/\phi(\eta)=t^{\beta} for any t>0 , denoted by \phi(\eta)\in\mathcal{RV}_{\beta}(\eta) as \eta\downarrow 0 . Let \displaystyle H(x)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\mathbf{P}(\left\lVert\bm{Z}\right\rVert>x). (2.1) Given \alpha>0 , let \nu_{\alpha} be the Borel measure on (0,\infty) with \displaystyle\nu_{\alpha}[x,\infty)=x^{-\alpha}. (2.2) Let \mathfrak{N}_{d}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\{\bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{d}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert=1\} be the unit sphere of \mathbb{R}^{d} . Let \Phi:\mathbb{R}^{d}\setminus\{\bm{0}\}\to[0,\infty)\times\mathfrak{N}_{d} be the polar transform, i.e., \displaystyle\Phi(\bm{x})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\Big(\left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert,\frac{\bm{x}}{\left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert}\Big). (2.3) Throughout this paper, we impose the following multivariate regular variation (MRV) assumption on \bm{Z} . Assumption 1 (Regularly Varying Noise) . \mathbf{E}\bm{Z}=\bm{0} . Besides, there exist some \alpha>1 and a probability measure \mathbf{S}(\cdot) on the unit sphere \mathfrak{N}_{d} such that • H(x)\in\mathcal{RV}_{-\alpha}(x) as x\to\infty , • for the polar coordinates (R,\bm{\Theta})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\Psi(\bm{Z}) (when \bm{Z}\neq\bm{0} ), we have (as x\to\infty ) \displaystyle\frac{\mathbf{P}\Big((x^{-1}R,\bm{\Theta})\in\ \cdot\ \Big)}{H(x)}\xrightarrow{v}\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S}, (2.4) where \xrightarrow{v} denotes vague convergence on (0,\infty]\times\mathfrak{N}_{d} . As noted in [ 56 ] , the classical vague convergence approach to the characterization of MRV (see, e.g., [ 48 , 25 ] ) is equivalent to the \mathbb{M} -convergence approach adopted in [ 56 ] . Throughout, we fix m and d to denote the dimensionality of \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x}) and \bm{Z}_{t} , respectively. We consider the L_{2} vector norm induced matrix norm \left\lVert\textbf{A}\right\rVert=\sup_{\bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{q}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert=1}\left\lVert\textbf{A}\bm{x}\right\rVert for any \textbf{A}\in\mathbb{R}^{p\times q} , and impose the following conditions on the drift coefficient \bm{a}(\cdot)=\big(a_{1}(\cdot),\cdots,a_{m}(\cdot)\big)^{\top} and the diffusion coefficient \bm{\sigma}(\cdot)=\big(\sigma_{i,j}(\cdot)\big)_{i\in[m],j\in[d]} in ( 1.3 ). Assumption 2 (Lipschitz Continuity) . There exists D\in(0,\infty) such that \left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{x})-\bm{\sigma}(\bm{y})\right\rVert\vee\left\lVert\bm{a}(\bm{x})-\bm{a}(\bm{y})\right\rVert\leq D\left\lVert\bm{x}-\bm{y}\right\rVert,\qquad\forall\bm{x},\ \bm{y}\in\mathbb{R}^{m}. We introduce a few notations required for presenting the precise asymptotics in the sample path large deviations results. Let (\mathbb{D}{[0,T]},\bm{d}_{J_{1}}^{{}_{[0,T]}}) be the metric space where \mathbb{D}[0,{T}]=\mathbb{D}\big([0,T],\mathbb{R}^{m}\big) is the space of all càdlàg functions with domain [0,{T}] and codomain \mathbb{R}^{m} , and \bm{d}_{J_{1}}^{{}_{[0,T]}} is the Skorodkhod J_{1} metric \displaystyle\bm{d}_{J_{1}}^{{}_{[0,T]}}(x,y)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\inf_{\lambda\in\Lambda_{T}}\sup_{t\in[0,T]}|\lambda(t)-t|\vee\left\lVert x(\lambda(t))-y(t)\right\rVert. (2.5) Here, \Lambda_{T} is the set of all homeomorphism on [0,T] . Throughout this paper, we fix some m and d and consider \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x}) taking values in \mathbb{R}^{m} driven by \bm{Z}_{t} ’s in \mathbb{R}^{d} . Given A\subseteq\mathbb{R} , let A^{k\uparrow}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\{(t_{1},\cdots,t_{k})\in A^{k}:\ t_{1}0 and \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} , let \bar{B}_{r}(\bm{x})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\{\bm{y}\in\mathbb{R}^{m}:\ \left\lVert\bm{y}-\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq r\} be the closed ball with radius r centered at \bm{x} . Given b,T\in(0,\infty) , \epsilon\geq 0 , A\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{m} and k\in\mathbb{N} , let \displaystyle\mathbb{D}_{A}^{(k)|b}{[0,T]}(\epsilon)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\bar{h}^{(k)|b}_{[0,T]}\Big(A,\ \mathbb{R}^{m\times k},\ \big(\bar{B}_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})\big)^{k},\ (0,T]^{k\uparrow}\Big) (2.10) be the set that contains all the ODE path with k jumps by time T , i.e., the image of the mapping \bar{h}^{(k)|b}_{[0,T]} defined in ( 2.6 )–( 2.8 ), under small perturbations \left\lVert\bm{v}_{j}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon for all j\in[k] . For k=-1 , we adopt the convention that \mathbb{D}_{A}^{(-1)|b}[0,T](\epsilon)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\emptyset . For any t>0 , let \mathcal{L}_{t} be the Lebesgue measure restricted on (0,t) and \mathcal{L}^{k\uparrow}_{t} be the Lebesgue measure restricted on (0,t)^{k\uparrow} . Given \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} , k\in\mathbb{N} and b,T\in(0,\infty) , define the Borel measure \displaystyle{\mathbf{C}}^{(k)|b}_{{[0,T]}}(\ \cdot\ ;\bm{x})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}} \displaystyle\int\mathbbm{I}\Big\{h^{(k)|b}_{{[0,T]}}\big(\bm{x},\textbf{W},\bm{t}\big)\in\ \cdot\ \Big\}\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{k}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{k\uparrow}_{{T}}(d\bm{t}), (2.11) where \mathbf{S} is the probability measure on the unit sphere \mathfrak{N}_{d} characterized in Assumption 1 , \nu_{\alpha} is specified in ( 2.2 ), (\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi is the composition of the product measure \nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S} with the polar transform \Phi , i.e., \displaystyle\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)(B)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}(\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\big(\Phi(B)\big),\qquad\forall\text{Borel set }B\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{d}\setminus\{\bm{0}\}, (2.12) and \big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{k} is the k -fold product of (\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi . Next, define the rate function \displaystyle\lambda(\eta)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\eta^{-1}H(\eta^{-1}) (2.13) with H(x)=\mathbf{P}(\left\lVert\bm{Z}\right\rVert>x) in ( 2.1 ). By Assumption 1 , \lambda(\eta)\in\mathcal{RV}_{\alpha-1}(\eta) as \eta\downarrow 0 . We write \lambda^{k}(\eta)=\big(\lambda(\eta)\big)^{k} . For any T,\ \eta,\ b\in(0,\infty) , and \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} , let {\bm{X}}^{\eta|b}_{[0,T]}(\bm{x})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\{\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\lfloor t/\eta\rfloor}(\bm{x}):\ t\in[0,T]\} be the time-scaled version of the sample path of \bm{X}_{t}^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}) embedded in \mathbb{D}[0,T] , with \lfloor t\rfloor\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\max\{n\in\mathbb{Z}:\ n\leq t\} and \lceil t\rceil\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\min\{n\in\mathbb{Z}:\ n\geq t\} . The next result is established in [ 56 ] , and our extension from domain [0,1] to [0,T] follows directly from the change of variable \eta^{\prime}=\eta/T . Theorem 2.1 (Theorem 2.5 of [ 56 ] ) . Let Assumptions 1 and 2 hold. Let k\in\mathbb{N} , b,T,\epsilon\in(0,\infty) , and A\subset\mathbb{R}^{m} be compact. Given B\in\mathscr{S}_{\mathbb{D}[0,T]} that is bounded away from {\mathbb{D}}_{A}^{(k-1)|b}[0,T](\epsilon) for some (and hence all) \epsilon>0 small enough, \begin{split}\inf_{\bm{x}\in A}\mathbf{C}^{(k)|b}_{[0,T]}\big(B^{\circ};\bm{x}\big)&\leq\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\frac{\inf_{\bm{x}\in A}\mathbf{P}\big({\bm{X}}^{\eta|b}_{[0,T]}(\bm{x})\in B\big)}{\lambda^{k}(\eta)}\\ &\leq\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\frac{\sup_{\bm{x}\in A}\mathbf{P}\big({\bm{X}}^{\eta|b}_{[0,T]}(\bm{x})\in B\big)}{\lambda^{k}(\eta)}\leq\sup_{\bm{x}\in A}\mathbf{C}^{(k)|b}_{[0,T]}\big(B^{-};\bm{x}\big)<\infty.\end{split} (2.14) 3 Main Results This section presents the main results of this paper. Section 3.1 carries out the metastability analysis. Section 3.2 presents details for numerical example in Figure 1.1 . 3.1 Metastability Analysis This section analyzes the metastability of \bm{X}_{t}^{\eta}(\bm{x}) and \bm{X}_{t}^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}) defined in ( 1.1 ) and ( 1.3 ). Section 3.1.1 establishes the scaling limits of their exit times. Section 3.1.2 introduces a framework that facilitates such analysis for general Markov chains. The results for stochastic differential equations and/or under more general scaling regimes are collected in the Appendix. 3.1.1 First Exit Times and Locations In this section, we analyze the first exit times and locations of \bm{X}^{\eta}_{t}(\bm{x}) and \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x}) from an attraction field of some potential with a unique local minimum at the origin. Specifically, throughout Section 3.1.1 , we fix an open set I\subset\mathbb{R}^{m} that is bounded and contains the origin, i.e., \sup_{\bm{x}\in I}\left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert<\infty and \bm{0}\in I . Let \bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x}) be the solution of ODE \displaystyle\bm{y}_{0}(\bm{x})=\bm{x},\qquad\frac{d\bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x})}{dt}=\bm{a}\big(\bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x})\big)\ \ \forall t\geq 0. (3.1) We impose the following assumption on the gradient field \bm{a}:\ \mathbb{R}^{m}\to\mathbb{R}^{m} . Assumption 3 . \bm{a}(\bm{0})=\bm{0} . The open set I\subset\mathbb{R}^{m} contains the origin and is bounded, i.e., \sup_{\bm{x}\in I}\left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert<\infty and \bm{0}\in I . For all \bm{x}\in I\setminus\{\bm{0}\} , \displaystyle\bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x})\in I\ \ \forall t\geq 0,\qquad\lim_{t\to\infty}\bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x})=\bm{0}. Besides, it holds for all \epsilon>0 small enough that \bm{a}(\bm{x})\bm{x}<0\ \forall\bm{x}\in\bar{B}_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})\setminus\{\bm{0}\}. An immediate consequence of the condition \lim_{t\to\infty}\bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x})=\bm{0}\ \forall\bm{x}\in I\setminus\{\bm{0}\} is that \bm{a}(\bm{x})\neq\bm{0} for all \bm{x}\in I\setminus\{\bm{0}\} . Of particular interest is the case where \bm{a}(\cdot)=-\nabla U(\cdot) for some potential U\in\mathcal{C}^{1}(\mathbb{R}^{m}) that has a unique local minimum at \bm{x}=0 over the domain {I} . In particular, Assumption 3 holds if U is also locally \mathcal{C}^{2} around the origin, and the Hessian of U(\cdot) at the origin \bm{x}=\bm{0} is positive definite. We note that Assumption 3 is a standard one in existing literature; see e.g. [ 44 , 28 ] . Define \displaystyle\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\min\big\{j\geq 0:\ \bm{X}^{\eta}_{j}(\bm{x})\notin I\big\},\qquad\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\min\big\{j\geq 0:\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x})\notin I\big\}, (3.2) as the first exit time of \bm{X}^{\eta}_{j}(\bm{x}) and \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x}) from I , respectively. To facilitate the presentation of the main results, we introduce a few concepts. Define the mapping \bar{g}^{(k)|b}:\mathbb{R}^{m}\times\mathbb{R}^{d\times k}\times\mathbb{R}^{m\times k}\times(0,\infty)^{k\uparrow}\to\mathbb{R}^{m} as the location of the (perturbed) ODE with k jumps at the last jump time: \displaystyle\bar{g}^{(k)|b}\big(\bm{x},\textbf{W},\textbf{V},(t_{1},\cdots,t_{k})\big)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\bar{h}^{(k)|b}_{[0,t_{k}+1]}\Big(\bm{x},\textbf{W},\textbf{V},(t_{1},\cdots,t_{k})\Big)(t_{k}), (3.3) where \bar{h}^{(k)|b}_{[0,T]} is the perturbed ODE mapping defined in ( 2.6 )–( 2.8 ). Note that the definition remains the same if, in ( 3.3 ), we use mapping \bar{h}^{(k)|b}_{[0,T]} with any T\in[t_{k},\infty) instead of \bar{h}^{(k)|b}_{[0,t_{k}+1]} . We include a +1 offset only to extend the time range of the mapping and simplify some arguments in our proofs. Besides, define \widecheck{g}^{(k)|b}:\mathbb{R}^{m}\times\mathbb{R}^{d\times k}\times(0,\infty)^{k\uparrow}\to\mathbb{R}^{m} by \displaystyle\widecheck{g}^{(k)|b}(\bm{x},\textbf{W},\bm{t})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\bar{g}^{(k)|b}\big(\bm{x},\textbf{W},(\bm{0},\cdots,\bm{0}),\bm{t}\big)=h^{(k)|b}_{[0,t_{k}+1]}(\bm{x},\textbf{W},\bm{t})(t_{k}), (3.4) where \bm{t}=(t_{1},\ldots,t_{k})\in(0,\infty)^{k\uparrow} , and the mapping h^{(k)|b}_{[0,T]} is defined in ( 2.9 ). For k=0 , we adopt the convention that \bar{g}^{(0)|b}(\bm{x})=\bm{x} . With mappings \bar{g}^{(k)|b} defined, we are able to introduce (for any k\geq 1 , b>0 , and \epsilon\geq 0 ) \displaystyle\mathcal{G}^{(k)|b}(\epsilon) \displaystyle\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\bigg\{\bar{g}^{(k-1)|b}\Big(\bm{v}_{1}+\varphi_{b}\big(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{v}_{1})\bm{w}_{1}\big),(\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{k}),(\bm{v}_{2},\cdots,\bm{v}_{k}),\bm{t}\Big): \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\textbf{W}=(\bm{w}_{1},\cdots,\bm{w}_{k})\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times k},\textbf{V}=(\bm{v}_{1},\cdots,\bm{v}_{k})\in\Big(\bar{B}_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})\Big)^{k},\bm{t}\in(0,\infty)^{k-1\uparrow}\bigg\} (3.5) as the set covered by the k^{\text{th}} jump of along ODE path initialized at the origin, with each jump modulated by \bm{\sigma}(\cdot) and truncated under b (and an \epsilon perturbation right before each jump). Here, the truncation operator \varphi_{b} is defined in ( 1.2 ), and \bar{B}_{r}(\bm{0}) is the closed ball with radius r centered at the origin. Under \epsilon=0 , we write \displaystyle\mathcal{G}^{(k)|b}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\mathcal{G}^{(k)|b}(0)=\bigg\{\widecheck{g}^{(k-1)|b}\Big(\varphi_{b}\big(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}_{1}\big),(\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{k}),\bm{t}\Big):\ \textbf{W}=(\bm{w}_{1},\cdots,\bm{w}_{k})\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times k},\bm{t}\in(0,\infty)^{k-1\uparrow}\bigg\}. Furthermore, as a convention for the case with k=0 , we set \displaystyle\mathcal{G}^{(0)|b}(\epsilon)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\bar{B}_{\epsilon}(\bm{0}). (3.6) We note that \mathcal{G}^{(k)|b}(\epsilon) is monotone in \epsilon , k , and b , in the sense that \mathcal{G}^{(k)|b}(\epsilon)\subseteq\mathcal{G}^{(k)|b}(\epsilon^{\prime}) for all 0\leq\epsilon\leq\epsilon^{\prime} , \mathcal{G}^{(k)|b}(\epsilon)\subseteq\mathcal{G}^{(k+1)|b}(\epsilon), and \mathcal{G}^{(k)|b}(\epsilon)\subseteq\mathcal{G}^{(k)|b^{\prime}}(\epsilon) for all 01 is the heavy-tail index in Assumption 1 , \textbf{W}=(\bm{w}_{1},\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{k})\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times k} , \big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{k} is the k -fold of (\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi defined in ( 2.12 ), and \mathcal{L}^{k\uparrow}_{\infty} is the Lebesgue measure restricted on \{(t_{1},\cdots,t_{k})\in(0,\infty)^{k}:\ 0\cdot) , \lambda(\eta)=\eta^{-1}H(\eta^{-1}) , and for any k\geq 1 we write \lambda^{k}(\eta)=\big(\lambda(\eta)\big)^{k} . Recall that I_{\epsilon}=\{\bm{y}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}-\bm{y}\right\rVert<\epsilon\ \Longrightarrow\ \bm{x}\in I\} is the \epsilon -shrinkage of I . As the main result of this section, Theorem 3.1 provides sharp asymptotics for the joint law of first exit times and exit locations of \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x}) and \bm{X}^{\eta}_{t}(\bm{x}) . The proof of Theorem 3.1 is deferred to Section 5 , and the proof is based on a general framework that will be developed in Section 3.1.2 . Theorem 3.1 . (First Exit Times and Locations: Truncated Case) Let Assumptions 1 , 2 , and 3 hold. Let b>0 . Suppose that \mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}<\infty , I^{c} is bounded away from \mathcal{G}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\epsilon) for some (and hence all) \epsilon>0 small enough, and \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(\partial I)=0. Then C^{I}_{b}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(I^{c})<\infty . Furthermore, if C^{I}_{b}\in(0,\infty) , then for any \epsilon>0 , t\geq 0 , and measurable set B\subseteq I^{c} , \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{b}\eta\cdot\lambda^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(\eta)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})>t;\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle\leq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B^{-})}{C^{I}_{b}}\cdot\exp(-t), \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{b}\eta\cdot\lambda^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(\eta)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})>t;\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle\geq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B^{\circ})}{C^{I}_{b}}\cdot\exp(-t). Otherwise, we have C^{I}_{b}=0 , and \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(\eta\cdot\lambda^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(\eta)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})\leq t\bigg)=0\qquad\forall\epsilon>0,\ t\geq 0. Remark 1 . Regarding the regularity conditions in Theorem 3.1 , conditions of form \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(\partial I)=0 are standard even for metastability analyses of untruncated dynamics; see e.g. [ 23 , 22 ] . Remark 2 . As will be confirmed in Corollary 3.2 below, \mathcal{J}_{b}^{I}=1 when b=\infty , regardless of the geometry of \bm{a}(\cdot) . In this case, Theorem 3.1 reduces to the manifestation of the principle of a single big jump. For b\neq\infty and a contractive drift—i.e., a(\bm{x})\cdot\bm{x}\leq 0 for all \bm{x}\in I —note that \mathcal{J}_{b}^{I}=\lceil r/b\rceil , where r\triangleq\inf\{\|\bm{x}-\bm{0}\|:\bm{x}\in I^{c}\} . This is because gradient flow will not bring \bm{X}_{j}^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}) closer to I^{c} , and hence, the most efficient way to escape from I is through \lceil r/b\rceil consecutive jumps in the direction where I^{c} is closest. In the general case, however, \mathcal{J}_{b}^{I} is determined as the solution to the discrete optimization problem in ( 3.7 ), where the geometry of \bm{a}(\cdot) —in particular, gradient flows and their distances from I^{c} —plays a more sophisticated role. We conclude this section by noting that the first exit analysis for untruncated process \bm{X}_{j}^{\eta}(\bm{x}) (see e.g. [ 26 , 31 , 27 ] for analogous results for continuous processes) follows directly from Theorem 3.1 . Let \displaystyle\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(\ \cdot\ )\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\int\mathbbm{I}\Big\{\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}\in\ \cdot\ \Big\}\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)(d\bm{w}). (3.9) The asymptotic analysis for exit times and locations of the untruncated dynamics \bm{X}^{\eta}_{j}(\bm{x}) follows from the result for \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x}) by sending b to \infty , and the limiting laws of the exit location \bm{X}^{\eta}_{\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x}) is characterized by \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(\ \cdot\ ) , as presented in Corollary 3.2 . The proof is straightforward and we collect it in Section 6 for the sake of completeness. Corollary 3.2 . (First Exit Times and Locations: Untruncated Case) Let Assumptions 1 , 2 , and 3 hold. Suppose that \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(\partial I)=0 and \left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\right\rVert>0 . Then C^{I}_{\infty}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(I^{c})<\infty . Furthermore, if C^{I}_{\infty}>0 , then for any t\geq 0 , \epsilon>0 , and measurable set B\subseteq I^{c} , \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})>t;\ \bm{X}^{\eta}_{\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle\leq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(B^{-})}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\exp(-t), \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})>t;\ \bm{X}^{\eta}_{\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle\geq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(B^{\circ})}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\exp(-t). Otherwise, we have C^{I}_{\infty}=0 , and \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(H(\eta^{-1})\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})\leq t\bigg)=0\qquad\forall\epsilon>0,\ t\geq 0. 3.1.2 General Framework: Asymptotic Atoms This section proposes a general framework that enables sharp characterization of exit times and exit locations of Markov chains. The new heavy-tailed large deviations formulation introduced in Section 2.2 is conducive to this framework. Consider a general metric space (\mathbb{S},\bm{d}) and a family of \mathbb{S} -valued Markov chains \big\{\{V_{j}^{\eta}(x):j\geq 0\}:\eta>0\big\} parameterized by \eta , where x\in\mathbb{S} denotes the initial state and j denotes the time index. We use \bm{V}_{[0,T]}^{\eta}(x)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\{V^{\eta}_{\lfloor t/\eta\rfloor}(x):t\in[0,T]\} to denote the scaled version of \{V_{j}^{\eta}(x):j\geq 0\} as a \mathbb{D}[0,T] -valued random element. For a given set E , let \tau^{\eta}_{E}(x)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\min\{j\geq 0:V_{j}^{\eta}(x)\in E\} denote \{V_{j}^{\eta}(s):j\geq 0\} ’s first hitting time of E . We consider an asymptotic domain of attraction I\subseteq\mathbb{S} , within which \bm{V}_{[0,T]}^{\eta}(x) typically (i.e., as \eta\downarrow 0 ) stays within I throughout any fixed time horizon [0,T] as far as the initial state x is in I . However, if one considers an infinite time horizon, V_{\bm{\cdot}}^{\eta}(x) is typically bound to escape I eventually due to the stochasticity. The goal of this section is to establish an asymptotic limit of the joint distribution of the exit time \tau^{\eta}_{I^{c}}(x) and the exit location V^{\eta}_{\tau^{\eta}_{I^{c}}(x)}(x) . Throughout this section, we will denote V^{\eta}_{\tau^{\eta}_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}(x)}(x) and V^{\eta}_{\tau^{\eta}_{I^{c}}(x)}(x) with V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x) and V^{\eta}_{\tau}(x) , respectively, for notation simplicity. We introduce the notion of asymptotic atoms to facilitate the analyses. Let \{I(\epsilon)\subseteq I:\epsilon>0\} and \{A(\epsilon)\subseteq\mathbb{S}:\epsilon>0\} be collections of subsets of I such that \bigcup_{\epsilon>0}I(\epsilon)=I and \bigcap_{\epsilon>0}A(\epsilon)\neq\emptyset . Let C(\cdot) is a Borel measure on \mathbb{S}\setminus I satisfying C(\partial I)=0 that characterizes the (asymptotics limit of the) exit location of V^{\eta}_{\cdot}(x) . Specifically, we consider two different cases for the location measure C(\cdot) : 1. C(I^{c})\in(0,\infty) : by incorporating the normalizing constant C(I^{c}) into the scale function \gamma(\eta) , we can assume w.l.o.g. that C(\cdot) is a probability measure , and C(B) dictates the limiting probability that \mathbf{P}(V^{\eta}_{\tau}(x)\in B) as shown in Theorem 3.4 ; 2. C(I^{c})=0 : as a result, C(B)=0 for any Borel set B\subseteq I^{c} , and it is equivalent to stating that C(\cdot) is trivially zero . Definition 3.3 . \big\{\{V_{j}^{\eta}(x):j\geq 0\}:\eta>0\big\} possesses an asymptotic atom \{A(\epsilon)\subseteq\mathbb{S}:\epsilon>0\} associated with the domain I , location measure C(\cdot) , scale \gamma:(0,\infty)\to(0,\infty) , and covering \{I(\epsilon)\subseteq I:\epsilon>0\} if the following holds: For each measurable set B\subseteq\mathbb{S} , there exist \delta_{B}:(0,\infty)\times(0,\infty)\to(0,\infty) , \epsilon_{B}>0 , and T_{B}:(0,\infty)\to(0,\infty) such that \displaystyle C(B^{\circ})-\delta_{B}(\epsilon,T)\leq\, \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\frac{\ \inf_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\tau^{\eta}_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}(x)\leq T/\eta;\;V_{\tau_{\epsilon}}^{\eta}(x)\in B\big)}{\gamma(\eta)T/\eta} (3.10) \displaystyle\leq\, \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\frac{\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\tau^{\eta}_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}(x)\leq T/\eta;\;V_{\tau_{\epsilon}}^{\eta}(x)\in B\big)}{\gamma(\eta)T/\eta}\leq C(B^{-})+\delta_{B}(\epsilon,T) (3.11) \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\frac{\sup_{x\in I(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\tau^{\eta}_{(I(\epsilon)\setminus A(\epsilon))^{c}}(x)>T/\eta\big)}{\gamma(\eta)T/\eta}=0 (3.12) \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\ \inf_{x\in I(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\tau^{\eta}_{A(\epsilon)}(x)\leq T/{\eta}\big)=1 (3.13) for any \epsilon\leq\epsilon_{B} and T\geq T_{B}(\epsilon) , where \gamma(\eta)/\eta\to 0 as \eta\downarrow 0 and \delta_{B} ’s are such that \lim_{\epsilon\downarrow 0}\lim_{T\to\infty}{\delta_{B}(\epsilon,T)}=0. To see how Definition 3.3 asymptotically characterize the atoms in V^{\eta}_{\bm{\cdot}}(x) for the first exit analysis from domain I , note that the condition ( 3.13 ) requires the process to efficiently return to the asymptotic atoms A(\epsilon) . The conditions ( 3.10 ) and ( 3.11 ) then state that, upon hitting the asymptotic atoms A(\epsilon) , the process almost regenerates in terms of the law of the exit time \tau^{\eta}_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}(x) and exit locations V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x) . Furthermore, the condition ( 3.12 ) prevents the process V^{\eta}_{\bm{\cdot}}(x) from spending a long time without either returning to the asymptotic atoms A(\epsilon) or exiting from I(\epsilon) , which covers the domain I as \epsilon tends to 0 . The existence of an asymptotic atom is a sufficient condition for characterization of exit time and location asymptotics as in Theorem 3.1 . To minimize repetition, we refer to the existence of an asymptotic atom—with specific domain, location measure, scale, and covering—Condition 1 throughout the paper. Condition 1 . A family \big\{\{V_{j}^{\eta}(x):j\geq 0\}:\eta>0\big\} of Markov chains possesses an asymptotic atom \{A(\epsilon)\subseteq\mathbb{S}:\epsilon>0\} associated with the domain I , location measure C(\cdot) , scale \gamma:(0,\infty)\to(0,\infty) , and covering \{I(\epsilon)\subseteq I:\epsilon>0\} . Recall that, right before Definition 3.3 , we state that for the location measure C(\cdot) we consider two cases that (i) C(I^{c})=1 (more generally, C(\cdot) is a finite measure), and (ii) C(I^{c})=0 . The following theorem is the key result of this section. See Section 4 for the proof of the theorem. Theorem 3.4 . If Condition 1 holds, then the first exit time \tau_{I^{c}}^{\eta}(x) scales as 1/\gamma(\eta) , and the distribution of the location V_{\tau}^{\eta}(x) at the first exit time converges to C(\cdot) . Moreover, the convergence is uniform over I(\epsilon) for any \epsilon>0 . That is, 1. If C(I^{c})=1 , then for each \epsilon>0 , measurable B\subseteq I^{c} , and t\geq 0 , \displaystyle C(B^{\circ})\cdot e^{-t} \displaystyle\leq\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{x\in I(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\gamma(\eta)\tau_{I^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t,\,V_{\tau}^{\eta}(x)\in B\big) \displaystyle\leq\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{x\in I(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\gamma(\eta)\tau_{I^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t,\,V_{\tau}^{\eta}(x)\in B\big)\leq C(B^{-})\cdot e^{-t}; 2. If C(I^{c})=0 , then for each \epsilon,t>0 , \displaystyle\lim_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{x\in I(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\gamma(\eta)\tau_{I^{c}}^{\eta}(x)\leq t\big)=0. 3.2 Numerical Examples In this section, we provide the details for numerical samples illustrated in Figure 1.1 . We consider iterates in \mathbb{R}^{1} : \displaystyle\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{0}(\bm{x})=\bm{x},\qquad\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x})=\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j-1}(\bm{x})+\varphi_{b}\big(-\eta U^{\prime}\big(\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j-1}(\bm{x})\big)+\eta\bm{Z}_{j}\big)\quad\forall j\geq 1, (3.14) under the potential function \displaystyle U(x)=(x+1.6)(x+1.3)^{2}(x-0.2)^{2}(x-0.7)^{2}(x-1.6)\big(0.05|1.65-x|\big)^{0.6} (3.15) \displaystyle\cdot\Big(1+\frac{1}{0.01+4(x-0.5)^{2}}\Big)\Big(1+\frac{1}{0.1+4(x+1.5)^{2}}\Big)\Big(1-\frac{1}{4}\exp(-5(x+0.8)(x+0.8))\Big). See Fig 1.1 (i) for an illustration. Specifically, we consider the case where the law of (Z_{j})_{j\geq 1} is of form \displaystyle c_{\text{pareto}}\cdot W_{\alpha}+c_{\text{normal}}\cdot N(0,1) (3.16) with c_{\text{pareto}}=0.1 , c_{\text{normal}}=0 , and \alpha=1.2 , and focus on the local minimum m=-0.66 and its attraction field I=(-1.3,0.2) . We initialize the process at \bm{x}=m and are interested in first exit times \tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}) from I ; see ( 3.2 ). In this case, the index \mathcal{J}^{I}_{b} defined in ( 3.7 ) reduces to \mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}=\lceil 0.64/b\rceil for any b\in(0,\infty) , and the regularity conditions in Theorem 3.1 hold for (Lebesgue) almost all b>0 ; see Remark 1 . Therefore, for Lebesgue almost all b>0 , the stopping times \tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}) is roughly of order 1/\eta^{1+\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}(\alpha-1)}=1/\eta^{1+\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}*0.2} as \eta\downarrow 0 . This characterizes the phase transitions in the order of first exit times depending on the (discretized) relative width \mathcal{J}^{I}_{b} . In case that b=\infty , we apply Corollary 3.2 and obtain that the exit times \tau^{\eta}(\bm{x}) in the untruncated case (see ( 3.2 )) is roughly of order 1/\eta^{\alpha}=1/\eta^{1.2} for small \eta . We confirm these asymptotics through Monte-Carlo simulation and present the results in Fig 1.1 (ii). This is a log-log scale plot, where each dot represents an average of 20 samples, and the dashed lines indicate the asymptotics provided by our metastability analysis. To prevent the experiment from running too long, a stopping criterion of 5\times 10^{7} steps is employed. This stopping criterion was reached only in the case where b=0.28 and \eta=0.001 , which is indicated in the plot by the only non-solid dot, highlighting that it is an underestimation. The plot confirms the asymptotic law of first exit times established in our metastability analysis, as well as the phase transition in first exit times w.r.t. \mathcal{J}^{I}_{b} . 4 Proof of Theorem 3.4 Our proof of Theorem 3.4 hinges on the following proposition. Proposition 4.1 . Suppose that Condition 1 holds. 1. If C(\cdot) is a probability measure supported on I^{c} (i.e., C(I^{c})=1 ), then for each measurable set B\subseteq\mathbb{S} and t\geq 0 , there exists \delta_{t,B}(\epsilon) such that \displaystyle C(B^{\circ})\cdot e^{-t}-\delta_{t,B}(\epsilon) \displaystyle\leq\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\gamma(\eta)\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t;\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\big) \displaystyle\leq\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\gamma(\eta)\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t;\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\big)\leq C(B^{-})\cdot e^{-t}+\delta_{t,B}(\epsilon) for all sufficiently small \epsilon>0 , where \delta_{t,B}(\epsilon)\to 0 as \epsilon\to 0 . 2. If C(I^{c})=0 (i.e., C(\cdot) is trivially zero), then for each t>0 , there exists \delta_{t}(\epsilon) such that \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\gamma(\eta)\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)\leq t\big)\leq\delta_{t}(\epsilon) for all \epsilon>0 sufficiently small, where \delta_{t}(\epsilon)\to 0 as \epsilon\to 0 . Proof. Fix some measurable B\subseteq\mathbb{S} and t\geq 0 . Henceforth in the proof, given any choice of 0RT/\eta\Big) \displaystyle\leq\mathbf{P}\Big(V_{j}^{\eta}(y)\in I(\epsilon)\setminus A(\epsilon)\quad\forall j\in\big[\lfloor rT/\eta\rfloor,\,RT/\eta\big]\Big) \displaystyle\leq\sup_{z\in I(\epsilon)\setminus A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau^{\eta}_{(I(\epsilon)\setminus A(\epsilon))^{c}}(z)>\frac{R-r}{2}T/\eta\Big) \displaystyle=\gamma(\eta)T/\eta\cdot\mathit{o}(1), (4.1) where the last equality is from ( 3.12 ) of Condition 1 , and \displaystyle\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(V_{\tau_{\epsilon}}^{\eta}(y)\in B;\;\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq\rho_{1}^{\eta}(y)\Big) \displaystyle\leq\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(V_{\tau_{\epsilon}}^{\eta}(y)\in B;\;\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq RT/\eta\Big)+\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\in\big(RT/\eta,\,\rho_{1}^{\eta}(y)\big]\Big) \displaystyle\leq\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(V_{\tau_{\epsilon}}^{\eta}(y)\in B;\;\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq RT/\eta\Big)+\gamma(\eta)T/\eta\cdot\mathit{o}(1) \displaystyle\leq\big(C(B^{-})+\delta_{B}(\epsilon,RT)+\mathit{o}(1)\big)\cdot\gamma(\eta)RT/\eta, (4.2) where the second inequaility is from ( 4.1 ) and the last equality is from ( 3.11 ) of Condition 1 . Proof of Case (i) . We work with different choices of R and r for the lower and upper bounds. For the lower bound, we work with R>r>1 and set K=\left\lceil\frac{t/\gamma(\eta)}{T/\eta}\right\rceil . Note that for \eta\in\big(0,(r-1)T\big) , we have \lfloor rT/\eta\rfloor\geq T/\eta and hence \rho_{K}^{\eta}(x)\geq K\lfloor rT/\eta\rfloor\geq t/\gamma(\eta) . Note also that from the Markov property conditioning on \mathcal{F}_{\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)} , \displaystyle\inf_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\gamma(\eta)\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t;\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\big) \displaystyle\geq\inf_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>\rho_{K}^{\eta}(x);\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B)=\inf_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\sum_{j=K}^{\infty}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)\in\big(\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x),\,\rho_{j+1}^{\eta}(x)\big];\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\Big) \displaystyle\geq\inf_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\sum_{j=K}^{\infty}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)\in\big(\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x),\,\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)+T/\eta\big];\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\Big) \displaystyle\geq\inf_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\sum_{j=K}^{\infty}\inf_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq T/\eta;\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(y)\in B\Big)\cdot\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)\Big). \displaystyle\geq\inf_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq T/\eta;\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(y)\in B\Big)\cdot\sum_{j=K}^{\infty}\inf_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)\Big). (4.3) From the Markov property conditioning on \mathcal{F}_{\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)} , the second term can be bounded as follows: \displaystyle\sum_{j=K}^{\infty}\inf_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)\Big) \displaystyle\geq\sum_{j=0}^{\infty}\bigg(\inf_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)>\rho_{1}^{\eta}(y)\Big)\bigg)^{K+j}=\sum_{j=0}^{\infty}\bigg(1-\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq\rho_{1}^{\eta}(y)\Big)\bigg)^{K+j} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq\rho_{1}^{\eta}(y)\Big)}\cdot\bigg(1-\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq\rho_{1}^{\eta}(y)\Big)\bigg)^{\lceil\frac{t/\gamma(\eta)}{T/\eta}\rceil} \displaystyle\geq\frac{1}{\big(1+\delta_{\mathbb{S}}(\epsilon,RT)+\mathit{o}(1)\big)\cdot\gamma(\eta)RT/\eta}\cdot\bigg(1-\big(1+\delta_{\mathbb{S}}(\epsilon,RT)+\mathit{o}(1)\big)\cdot\gamma(\eta)RT/\eta\bigg)^{\frac{t/\gamma(\eta)}{T/\eta}+1}. (4.4) where the last inequality is from ( 4.2 ) with B=\mathbb{S} . From ( 4.3 ), ( 4.4 ), and ( 3.10 ) of Condition 1 , we have \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\gamma(\eta)\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t;\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\big) \displaystyle\geq\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\frac{C(B^{\circ})-\delta_{B}(\epsilon,T)+\mathit{o}(1)}{\big(1+\delta_{\mathbb{S}}(\epsilon,RT)+\mathit{o}(1)\big)\cdot R}\cdot\bigg(1-\big(1+\delta_{\mathbb{S}}(\epsilon,RT)+\mathit{o}(1)\big)\cdot\gamma(\eta)RT/\eta\bigg)^{\frac{R\cdot t}{\gamma(\eta)RT/\eta}+1}. \displaystyle\geq\frac{C(B^{\circ})-\delta_{B}(\epsilon,T)}{1+\delta_{\mathbb{S}}(\epsilon,RT)}\cdot\exp\Big(-\big(1+\delta_{\mathbb{S}}(\epsilon,RT)\big)\cdot R\cdot t\Big). By taking limit T\to\infty and then considering an R arbitrarily close to 1, it is straightforward to check that the desired lower bound holds. Moving on to the upper bound, we set R=1 and fix an arbitrary r\in(0,1) . Set k=\left\lfloor\frac{t/\gamma(\eta)}{T/\eta}\right\rfloor and note that \displaystyle\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\gamma(\eta)\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t;\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\big) \displaystyle=\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t/\gamma(\eta);\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\big) \displaystyle=\underbrace{\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t/\gamma(\eta)\geq\rho_{k}^{\eta}(x);\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\big)}_{\mathrm{(I)}} \displaystyle\quad+\underbrace{\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t/\gamma(\eta);\;\rho_{k}^{\eta}(x)>t/\gamma(\eta);\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\big)}_{\mathrm{(II)}} We first show that (II) vanishes as \eta\to 0 . Our proof hinges on the following claim: \displaystyle\big\{\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t/\gamma(\eta);\;\rho_{k}^{\eta}(x)>t/\gamma(\eta)\big\}\ \subseteq\ \bigcup_{j=1}^{k}\big\{\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)\wedge\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)-\rho_{j-1}^{\eta}(x)\geq T/\eta\big\} Proof of the claim: Suppose that \tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t/\gamma(\eta) and \rho_{k}^{\eta}(x)>t/\gamma(\eta) . Let k^{*}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\max\{j\geq 1:\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)\leq t/\gamma(\eta)\} . Note that k^{*}(t/\gamma(\eta)-T/\eta)/k^{*} and (ii) \rho_{k^{*}}^{\eta}(x)\leq t/\gamma(\eta)-T/\eta. In case of (i), since \rho_{k^{*}}^{\eta}(x)/k^{*} is the average of \{\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)-\rho_{j-1}^{\eta}(x):j=1,\ldots,k^{*}\} , there exists j^{*}\leq k^{*} such that \rho_{j^{*}}^{\eta}(x)-\rho_{j^{*}-1}^{\eta}(x)>\frac{t/\gamma(\eta)-T/\eta}{k^{*}}\geq\frac{kT/\eta-T/\eta}{k-1}=T/\eta Note that since \rho_{j^{*}}^{\eta}(x)\leq\rho_{k^{*}}^{\eta}(x)\leq t/\gamma(\eta)\leq\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x) , this proves the claim for case (i). For case (ii), note that \rho_{k^{*}+1}^{\eta}(x)\wedge\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)-\rho_{k^{*}}^{\eta}(x)\geq t/\gamma(\eta)-(t/\gamma(\eta)-T/\eta)=T/\eta, which proves the claim. Now, with the claim in hand, we have that (II) \displaystyle\leq\sum_{j=1}^{k}\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)\wedge\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)-\rho_{j-1}^{\eta}(x)\geq T/\eta\big) \displaystyle=\sum_{j=1}^{k}\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{E}\Big[\mathbf{P}\big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)\wedge\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)-\rho_{j-1}^{\eta}(x)\geq T/\eta\big|\mathcal{F}_{\rho_{j-1}^{\eta}(x)}\big)\Big] \displaystyle\leq\sum_{j=1}^{k}\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\wedge\rho_{1}^{\eta}(y)\geq T/\eta\big) \displaystyle\leq\frac{t}{\gamma(\eta)T/\eta}\cdot\gamma(\eta)T/\eta\cdot\mathit{o}(1)=\mathit{o}(1) for sufficiently large T ’s, where the last inequality is from the definition of k and ( 4.1 ). We are now left with bounding (I) from above. \displaystyle\mathrm{(I)} \displaystyle=\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t/\gamma(\eta)\geq\rho_{K}^{\eta}(x);\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\big)\leq\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>\rho_{K}^{\eta}(x);\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\big) \displaystyle=\sum_{j=k}^{\infty}\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)\in\big(\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x),\,\rho_{j+1}^{\eta}(x)\big];\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\Big) \displaystyle=\sum_{j=k}^{\infty}\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{E}\bigg[\mathbf{E}\Big[\mathbbm{I}\big\{V_{\tau_{\epsilon}}^{\eta}(x)\in B\big\}\cdot\mathbbm{I}\big\{\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)\leq\rho_{j+1}^{\eta}(x)\big\}\Big|\mathcal{F}_{\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)}\Big]\cdot\mathbbm{I}\big\{\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)\big\}\bigg] \displaystyle\leq\sum_{j=k}^{\infty}\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{E}\bigg[\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(V_{\tau_{\epsilon}}^{\eta}(y)\in B;\;\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq\rho_{1}^{\eta}(y)\Big)\cdot\mathbbm{I}\big\{\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)\big\}\bigg] \displaystyle=\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(V_{\tau_{\epsilon}}^{\eta}(y)\in B;\;\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq\rho_{1}^{\eta}(y)\Big)\cdot\sum_{j=k}^{\infty}\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)\Big) The first term can be bounded via ( 4.2 ) with R=1 : \displaystyle\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(V_{\tau_{\epsilon}}^{\eta}(y)\in B;\;\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq\rho_{1}^{\eta}(y)\Big) \displaystyle\leq\big(C(B^{-})+\delta_{B}(\epsilon,T)+\mathit{o}(1)\big)\cdot\gamma(\eta)T/\eta+\frac{1-r}{2}\cdot\gamma(\eta)T/\eta\cdot\mathit{o}(1) whereas the second term is bounded via ( 3.10 ) of Condition 1 as follows: \displaystyle\sum_{j=k}^{\infty}\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)\Big) \displaystyle\leq\sum_{j=0}^{\infty}\bigg(\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)>\lfloor rT/\eta\rfloor\Big)\bigg)^{k+j}=\sum_{j=0}^{\infty}\bigg(1-\inf_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq rT/\eta\Big)\bigg)^{k+j} \displaystyle\leq\frac{1}{\inf_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq rT/\eta\Big)}\cdot\bigg(1-\inf_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq rT/\eta\Big)\bigg)^{\frac{t/\gamma(\eta)}{T/\eta}-1} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{r\cdot\big(1-\delta_{B}(\epsilon,rT)+\mathit{o}(1)\big)\cdot\gamma(\eta)T/\eta}\cdot\Big(1-r\cdot\big(1-\delta_{B}(\epsilon,rT)+\mathit{o}(1)\big)\cdot\gamma(\eta)T/\eta\Big)^{\frac{t}{\gamma(\eta)T/\eta}-1} Therefore, \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\gamma(\eta)\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t;\;V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\big) \displaystyle\leq\frac{C(B^{-})+\delta_{B}(\epsilon,T)}{r\cdot(1-\delta_{B}(\epsilon,rT))}\cdot\exp\Big(-r\cdot\big(1-\delta_{B}(\epsilon,rT)\big)\cdot t\Big). Again, taking T\to\infty and considering r arbitrarily close to 1, we can check that the desired upper bound holds. Proof of Case (ii) . We work with R=1 and set K=\left\lceil\frac{t/\gamma(\eta)}{T/\eta}\right\rceil . Again, for \eta\in\big(0,(r-1)T\big) , we have \lfloor rT/\eta\rfloor\geq T/\eta and hence \rho_{K}^{\eta}(x)\geq K\lfloor rT/\eta\rfloor\geq t/\gamma(\eta) . By the Markov property conditioning on \mathcal{F}_{\rho_{j}^{\eta}(x)} , \displaystyle\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\big(\gamma(\eta)\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)\leq t\big) \displaystyle\leq\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)\leq\rho^{\eta}_{K}(x)\Big)=\sup_{x\in A(\epsilon)}\sum_{j=1}^{K}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)\in\big(\rho^{\eta}_{j-1}(x),\rho^{\eta}_{j}(x)\big]\Big) \displaystyle\leq\sum_{j=1}^{K}\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\bigg(1-\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq\rho_{1}^{\eta}(y)\Big)\bigg)^{j-1}\cdot\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq\rho_{1}^{\eta}(y)\Big) \displaystyle\leq K\cdot\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(y)\leq\rho_{1}^{\eta}(y)\Big)\leq K\cdot\big(\delta_{I^{c}}(\epsilon,T)+\mathit{o}(1)\big)\cdot\gamma(\eta)T/\eta by ( 4.2 ) (with B=I^{c} ) and the running assumption of Case (ii) that C(\cdot)\equiv 0 \displaystyle\leq\frac{2t/\gamma(\eta)}{T/\eta}\cdot\big(\delta_{I^{c}}(\epsilon,T)+\mathit{o}(1)\big)\cdot\gamma(\eta)T/\eta\qquad\text{ for all $\eta$ small enough under }K=\lceil\frac{t/\gamma(\eta)}{T/\eta}\rceil \displaystyle=2t\cdot\big(\delta_{I^{c}}(\epsilon,T)+\mathit{o}(1)\big). Lastly, by Condition 1 (specifically, \lim_{\epsilon\downarrow 0}\lim_{T\uparrow\infty}\delta_{I^{c}}(\epsilon,T)=0 in Definition 3.3 ), we verify the upper bounds in Case (ii) and conclude the proof. ∎ Now, we are ready to prove Theorem 3.4 . Proof of Theorem 3.4 . We focus on the proof of Case (i) since the proof of Case (ii) is almost identical, with the only key difference being that we apply part (ii) of Proposition 4.1 instead of part (i) . We first claim that for any \epsilon,\epsilon^{\prime}>0 , t\geq 0 , and measurable B\subseteq\mathbb{S} , \displaystyle C(B^{\circ})\cdot e^{-t}-\delta_{t,B}(\epsilon) \displaystyle\leq\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{x\in I(\epsilon^{\prime})}\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t,\,V_{\tau_{\epsilon}}^{\eta}(x)\in B\Big) (4.5) \displaystyle\leq\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{x\in I(\epsilon^{\prime})}\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau_{I(\epsilon)^{c}}^{\eta}(x)>t,\,V_{\tau_{\epsilon}}^{\eta}(x)\in B\Big)\leq C(B^{-})\cdot e^{-t}+\delta_{t,B}(\epsilon) where \delta_{t,B}(\epsilon) is characterized in part (i) of Proposition 4.1 such that \delta_{t,B}(\epsilon)\to 0 as \epsilon\to 0 . Now, note that for any measurable B\subseteq I^{c} , \displaystyle\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{I^{c}}(x)>t,\,V_{\tau}^{\eta}(x)\in B\Big) \displaystyle=\underbrace{\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{I^{c}}(x)>t,\,V_{\tau}^{\eta}(x)\in B,\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in I\Big)}_{\mathrm{\text{(I)}}}+\underbrace{\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{I^{c}}(x)>t,\,V_{\tau}^{\eta}(x)\in B,\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\notin I\Big)}_{\mathrm{\text{(II)}}} and since \mathrm{\text{(I)}}\leq\mathbf{P}\Big(V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in I\Big)\qquad\text{and}\qquad\mathrm{\text{(II)}}=\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{\epsilon}(x)>t,\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\setminus I\Big), we have that \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{x\in I(\epsilon^{\prime})}\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{I^{c}}(x)>t,\,V_{\tau}^{\eta}(x)\in B\Big) \displaystyle\geq\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{x\in I(\epsilon^{\prime})}\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{\epsilon}(x)>t,\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\setminus I\Big) \displaystyle\geq C\big((B\setminus I)^{\circ}\big)\cdot e^{-t}-\delta_{t,B\setminus I}(\epsilon) \displaystyle=C(B^{\circ})\cdot e^{-t}-\delta_{t,B\setminus I}(\epsilon) due to B\subseteq I^{c} , and \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{x\in I(\epsilon^{\prime})}\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{I^{c}}(x)>t,\,V_{\tau}^{\eta}(x)\in B\Big) \displaystyle\leq\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{x\in I(\epsilon^{\prime})}\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{\epsilon}(x)>t,\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\setminus I\Big)+\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{x\in I(\epsilon^{\prime})}\mathbf{P}\Big(V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in I\Big) \displaystyle\leq C\big((B\setminus I)^{-}\big)\cdot e^{-t}+\delta_{t,B\setminus I}(\epsilon)+C(I^{-})+\delta_{0,I}(\epsilon) \displaystyle=C(B^{-})\cdot e^{-t}+\delta_{t,B\setminus I}(\epsilon)+\delta_{0,I}(\epsilon). Taking \epsilon\to 0 , we arrive at the desired lower and upper bounds of the theorem. Now we are left with the proof of the claim ( 4.5 ) is true. Note that for any x\in I , \displaystyle\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{\epsilon}(x)>t,\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\Big) \displaystyle=\mathbf{E}\bigg[\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{\epsilon}(x)>t,\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\Big|\mathcal{F}_{\tau_{A(\epsilon)}^{\eta}(x)}\Big)\cdot\Big(\mathbbm{I}\big\{\tau_{A(\epsilon)}^{\eta}(x)\leq T/\eta\big\}+\mathbbm{I}\big\{\tau_{A(\epsilon)}^{\eta}(x)>T/\eta\big\}\Big)\bigg] (4.6) Fix an arbitrary s>0 , and note that from the Markov property, \displaystyle\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{\epsilon}(x)>t,\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\Big) \displaystyle\leq\mathbf{E}\bigg[\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau^{\eta}_{\epsilon}(y)>t/\gamma(\eta)-T/\eta,\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(y)\in B\Big)\cdot\mathbbm{I}\big\{\tau_{A(\epsilon)}^{\eta}(x)\leq T/\eta\big\}\bigg]+\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{A(\epsilon)}^{\eta}(x)>T/\eta\Big) \displaystyle\leq\sup_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{\epsilon}(y)>t-s,\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(y)\in B\Big)+\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau_{A(\epsilon)}^{\eta}(x)>T/\eta\Big) for sufficiently small \eta ’s; here, we applied \gamma(\eta)/\eta\to 0 as \eta\downarrow 0 in the last inequality. In light of part (i) of Proposition 4.1 , by taking T\to\infty we yield \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{x\in I(\epsilon^{\prime})}\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{\epsilon}(x)>t,\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\Big) \displaystyle\leq C(B^{-})\cdot e^{-(t-s)}+\delta_{t,B}(\epsilon) Considering an arbitrarily small s>0 , we get the upper bound of the claim ( 4.5 ). For the lower bound, again from ( 4.6 ) and the Markov property, \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{x\in I(\epsilon^{\prime})}\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{\epsilon}(x)>t,\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(x)\in B\Big) \displaystyle\geq\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{x\in I(\epsilon^{\prime})}\mathbf{E}\bigg[\inf_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau^{\eta}_{\epsilon}(y)>t/\gamma(\eta),\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(y)\in B\Big)\cdot\mathbbm{I}\big\{\tau_{A(\epsilon)}^{\eta}(x)\leq T/\eta\big\}\bigg] \displaystyle\geq\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{y\in A(\epsilon)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\gamma(\eta)\cdot\tau^{\eta}_{\epsilon}(y)>t,\,V^{\eta}_{\tau_{\epsilon}}(y)\in B\Big)\cdot\inf_{x\in I(\epsilon^{\prime})}\mathbf{P}\big(\tau_{A(\epsilon)}^{\eta}(x)\leq T/\eta\big) \displaystyle\geq C(B^{\circ})-\delta_{t,B}(\epsilon), which is the desired lower bound of the claim ( 4.5 ). This concludes the proof. ∎ 5 Proof of Theorem 3.1 In this section, we apply the framework developed in Section 3.1.2 and prove Theorem 3.1 . Throughout this section, we impose Assumptions 1 , 2 , and 3 . We start by fixing a few constants. Recall the definition of the discretized width metric \mathcal{J}^{I}_{b} defined in ( 3.7 ). To prove Theorem 3.1 , in this section we fix some b>0 such that the conditions in Theorem 3.1 hold. This allows us to fix some \widecheck{\epsilon}>0 small enough such that \displaystyle\bar{B}_{\widecheck{\epsilon}}(\bm{0})\subseteq I_{\widecheck{\epsilon}},\qquad\bm{a}(\bm{x})\bm{x}<0\ \forall\bm{x}\in\bar{B}_{\widecheck{\epsilon}}(\bm{0})\setminus\{\bm{0}\},\quad\inf\Big\{\left\lVert\bm{x}-\bm{y}\right\rVert:\ \bm{x}\in I^{c},\ \bm{y}\in\mathcal{G}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\widecheck{\epsilon})\Big\}>0. (5.1) Here, \bar{B}_{r}(\bm{x})=\{\bm{x}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq r\} is the closed ball with radius r centered at \bm{x} . An implication of the first condition in ( 5.1 ) is the following positive invariance property under the gradient field \bm{a}(\cdot) : for any r\in(0,\widecheck{\epsilon}] , \displaystyle\bm{x}\in\bar{B}_{r}(\bm{0})\quad\Longrightarrow\quad\bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x})\in\bar{B}_{r}(\bm{0})\ \forall t\geq 0, (5.2) with the ODE \bm{y}_{t}(x) defined in ( 3.1 ). Next, for any \epsilon\in(0,\widecheck{\epsilon}) , let \displaystyle\widecheck{I}(\epsilon)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\Big\{\bm{x}\in I:\ \left\lVert\bm{y}_{1/\epsilon}(\bm{x})\right\rVert<\widecheck{\epsilon}\Big\} (5.3) By Gronwall’s inequality, it is easy to see that \widecheck{I}(\epsilon) is an open set. Meanwhile, by Assumption 3 , given \bm{x}\in I we must have \bm{x}\in\widecheck{I}(\epsilon) for any \epsilon>0 small enough. As a result, the collection of open sets \{\widecheck{I}(\epsilon):\ \epsilon\in(0,\widecheck{\epsilon})\} provides a covering for I : \displaystyle\bigcup_{\epsilon\in(0,\widecheck{\epsilon})}\widecheck{I}(\epsilon)=I. Next, recall that we use {I_{\epsilon}}=\{\bm{y}\in\mathbb{R}^{n}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}-\bm{y}\right\rVert<\epsilon\ \Longrightarrow\ \bm{x}\in I\} to denote the \epsilon -shrinkage of the set I . Given any \epsilon>0 , note that I_{\epsilon} is an open set and, by definition, its closure (I_{\epsilon})^{-} is still bounded away from I^{c} , i.e., \left\lVert\bm{x}-\bm{y}\right\rVert\geq\epsilon for all \bm{x}\in(I_{\epsilon})^{-} , \bm{y}\in I^{c} . Besides, the continuity of \bm{a}(\cdot) (see Assumption 2 ) implies the continuity (w.r.t. \bm{x} ) of \bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x}) ’s hitting time to \bar{B}_{\widecheck{\epsilon}}(\bm{0}) . Then, by the boundedness of set I and hence (I_{\epsilon})^{-}\subseteq I , as well as property ( 5.2 ), we know that given any \epsilon>0 , the claim \displaystyle\left\lVert\bm{y}_{T}(\bm{x})\right\rVert<\widecheck{\epsilon}\qquad\forall\bm{x}\in(I_{\epsilon})^{-} holds for any T>0 large enough. This confirms that given \epsilon>0 , it holds for any \epsilon^{\prime}>0 small enough that \displaystyle(I_{\epsilon})^{-}\subseteq\widecheck{I}(\epsilon^{\prime}). (5.4) As a direct consequence of the discussion above, we highlight another important property of the sets \mathcal{G}^{(k)|b}(\epsilon) defined in ( 3.5 ). For any k\in\mathbb{N} , b>0 , and \epsilon\geq 0 , let \displaystyle\bar{\mathcal{G}}^{(k)|b}(\epsilon)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\Big\{\bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x}):\ \bm{x}\in\mathcal{G}^{(k)|b}(\epsilon),\ t\geq 0\Big\}, (5.5) where \bm{y}_{\cdot}(\bm{x}) is the ODE defined in ( 3.1 ). First, due to ( 5.4 ) and the fact that \mathcal{G}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\widecheck{\epsilon}) is bounded away from I^{c} (see ( 5.1 )), given any \epsilon\in(0,\widecheck{\epsilon}] , it holds for all \epsilon^{\prime}>0 small enough that \mathcal{G}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\epsilon)\subseteq\widecheck{I}(\epsilon^{\prime}). Furthermore, we claim that \bar{\mathcal{G}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\widecheck{\epsilon}) is also bounded away from I^{c} , i.e., \displaystyle\inf\Big\{\left\lVert\bm{x}-\bm{z}\right\rVert:\ \bm{x}\in\bar{\mathcal{G}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\widecheck{\epsilon}),\ \bm{z}\in I^{c}\Big\}>0. (5.6) This can be argued with a proof by contradiction. Suppose that there exist sequences \bm{x}_{n}^{\prime}\in\bar{\mathcal{G}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\widecheck{\epsilon}) and \bm{z}_{n}\notin I such that \left\lVert\bm{x}_{n}^{\prime}-\bm{z}_{n}\right\rVert\leq 1/n . By definition of \bar{\mathcal{G}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\widecheck{\epsilon}) , there exist sequences \bm{x}_{n}\in{\mathcal{G}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\widecheck{\epsilon}) and t_{n}\geq 0 such that \bm{x}^{\prime}_{n}=\bm{y}_{t_{n}}(\bm{x}_{n}) for each n\geq 1 . Besides, we have shown that \mathcal{G}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\widecheck{\epsilon})\subseteq\widecheck{I}(\epsilon) holds for any \epsilon>0 small enough. Then under such \epsilon>0 , by ( 5.2 )( 5.3 ), we must have t_{n}\leq 1/\epsilon for each n ; otherwise, we will have \bm{x}^{\prime}_{n}=\bm{y}_{t_{n}}(\bm{x}_{n})\in\bar{B}_{\widecheck{\epsilon}}(\bm{0}) , which prevents \left\lVert\bm{x}_{n}^{\prime}-\bm{z}_{n}\right\rVert\leq 1/n to hold for the sequence \bm{z}_{n}\in I^{c} due to \bar{B}_{\widecheck{\epsilon}}(\bm{0})\subseteq I_{\widecheck{\epsilon}} ; see ( 5.1 ). Now, in light of the boundedness for the sequence \bm{x}_{n}\in\bar{\mathcal{G}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\widecheck{\epsilon})\subset I (due to the boundedness of I ) and the boundedness of the sequence t_{n} , by picking a sub-sequence if necessary, we can w.l.o.g. assume that \bm{x}_{n}\to\bm{x}_{*} for some \bm{x}_{*}\in\big(\mathcal{G}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\widecheck{\epsilon})\big)^{-}\subset I and t_{n}\to t_{*} for some t_{*}\in[0,\infty) . Let \bm{x}^{\prime}_{*}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\bm{y}_{t_{*}}(\bm{x}_{*}) . Since \bm{x}_{*}\in I , by Assumption 3 we must have \bm{x}^{\prime}_{*}\in I . However, the continuity of the flow (specifically, using Gronwall’s inequality) implies \bm{x}^{\prime}_{n}\to\bm{x}^{\prime}_{*} . Under the condition \left\lVert\bm{x}_{n}^{\prime}-\bm{z}_{n}\right\rVert\leq 1/n and \bm{z}_{n}\in I^{c} for each n , we arrive at the contradiction that \bm{z}_{n}\to\bm{x}^{\prime}_{*}\in I^{c} due to I being an open set and I^{c} being closed. This verifies ( 5.6 ). Summarizing ( 5.1 ), ( 5.2 ), and ( 5.6 ), we can fix some \bar{\epsilon}>0 small enough such that the following claims hold: \displaystyle\bar{B}_{\bar{\epsilon}}(\bm{0})\subseteq I_{\bar{\epsilon}}, (5.7) \displaystyle r\in(0,\bar{\epsilon}],\ \bm{x}\in\bar{B}_{r}(\bm{0})\quad\Longrightarrow\quad\bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x})\in\bar{B}_{r}(\bm{0})\ \forall t\geq 0, (5.8) \displaystyle\inf\Big\{\left\lVert\bm{x}-\bm{z}\right\rVert:\ \bm{x}\in\bar{\mathcal{G}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(2\bar{\epsilon}),\ \bm{z}\notin I_{\bar{\epsilon}}\Big\}>\bar{\epsilon}. (5.9) Moving on, let \bm{t}_{\bm{x}}(\epsilon)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\inf\Big\{t\geq 0:\ \bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x})\in\bar{B}_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})\Big\} be the hitting time to the closed ball \bar{B}_{\epsilon}(\bm{0}) for the ODE \bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x}) , and let \displaystyle\bm{t}(\epsilon)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\sup\Big\{\bm{t}_{\bm{x}}(\epsilon):\ \bm{x}\in(I_{\epsilon})^{-}\Big\} (5.10) be the upper bound for the hitting times \bm{t}_{\bm{x}}(\epsilon) over \bm{x}\in(I_{\epsilon})^{-} . By the continuity of \bm{a}(\cdot) (and hence \bm{t}_{\bm{x}}(\epsilon) w.r.t. \epsilon ), the contraction of \bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x}) around the origin (see Assumption 3 and its implication ( 5.8 )), and the boundedness of (I_{\epsilon})^{-} , we have \bm{t}(\epsilon)<\infty for any \epsilon>0 . Besides, by the definition of \bm{t}(\cdot) , we have (for any \epsilon\in(0,\bar{\epsilon}) ) \displaystyle\bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x})\in\bar{B}_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})\qquad\forall\bm{x}\in(I_{\epsilon})^{-},\ t\geq\bm{t}(\epsilon). (5.11) Furthermore, by repeating the arguments for ( 5.6 ), one can show that (for any \epsilon>0 ) \displaystyle\inf\Big\{\left\lVert\bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x})-\bm{z}\right\rVert:\ \bm{x}\in(I_{\epsilon})^{-},\ t\geq 0,\ \bm{z}\notin I\Big\}>0. (5.12) Specifically, as a direct consequence of ( 5.12 ), there is some \bar{c}\in(0,1) such that \displaystyle\Big\{\bm{y}_{t}(\bm{x}):\ \bm{x}\in(I_{\bar{\epsilon}})^{-},\ t\geq 0\Big\}\subseteq I_{\bar{c}\bar{\epsilon}}, (5.13) where \bar{\epsilon}>0 is the constant fixed in ( 5.7 )–( 5.9 ). 5.1 Technical Lemmas for \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(k)|b} Recall that {I_{\epsilon}}=\{\bm{y}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}-\bm{y}\right\rVert<\epsilon\ \Longrightarrow\ \bm{x}\in I\} is the \epsilon -shrinkage of the domain I , and that I^{-}_{\epsilon} is the closure of I_{\epsilon} . We first study the mapping {\widecheck{g}^{(k)|b}} in ( 3.4 ), which is defined based on \bar{h}^{(k)|b}_{[0,T]} and h^{(k)|b}_{[0,T]} defined in ( 2.6 )–( 2.9 ). Some of the results below will impose the following boundedness assumption on \bm{a} and \bm{\sigma} . Assumption 4 (Boundedness) . There exists C>0 such that \displaystyle\left\lVert\bm{a}(\bm{x})\right\rVert\vee\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{x})\right\rVert\leq C,\qquad\forall\bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m}. Lemma 5.1 . Let Assumptions 2 and 3 hold. Let \bar{\epsilon}>0 be the constant in ( 5.7 )–( 5.9 ). Let C\in[1,\infty) be such that \sup_{\bm{x}\in I^{-}}\left\lVert\bm{a}(\bm{x})\right\rVert\vee\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{x})\right\rVert\leq C . (Below, we adopt the convention that t_{0}=0 .) 1. Given any T>0 , the claim \xi(t)\in I^{-}_{2\bar{\epsilon}}\ \forall t\in[0,T] holds for all \xi\in\mathbb{D}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{\bar{B}_{\bar{\epsilon}}}[0,T](\bar{\epsilon}). 2. Let \bar{c}\in(0,1) be the constant fixed in ( 5.13 ). There exist \bar{\delta}>0 and \bar{t}>0 such that the following claim holds: Given any T>0 and \bm{x}_{0}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} with \left\lVert\bm{x}_{0}\right\rVert\leq\bar{\epsilon} , if \displaystyle\xi(t)\notin I_{\bar{c}\bar{\epsilon}}\qquad\text{ for some }\xi=h^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{[0,T]}\Big(\bm{x}_{0}+\varphi_{b}\big(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{x}_{0})\bm{w}_{0}\big),\textbf{W},(t_{1},\cdots,t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1})\Big),\ t\in[0,T], (5.14) where \textbf{W}=(\bm{w}_{1},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1})\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1} , and (t_{1},\cdots,t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1})\in(0,T]^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1\uparrow} , then (a) \xi(t)\in I_{2\bar{\epsilon}}^{-} for all t\in[0,t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1}) ; (b) \xi(t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1})\notin I_{\bar{\epsilon}} ; (c) \left\lVert\xi(t)\right\rVert\geq\bar{\epsilon} for all t\leq t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1} ; (d) t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1}<\bar{t} ; (e) \left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert>\bar{\delta} for all j=0,1,\cdots,\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1 . 3. Let T>0 , \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m},\ \textbf{W}=(\bm{w}_{1},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}},\ (t_{1},\cdots,t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\in(0,T]^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}\uparrow} , and \epsilon\in(0,\bar{\epsilon}) . Let \displaystyle\xi \displaystyle=h^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}_{[0,T]}\big(\bm{x},\textbf{W},(t_{1},\cdots,t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\big), \displaystyle=h^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{[0,T]}\Big(\varphi_{b}\big(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}_{1}\big),(\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}),(t_{2}-t_{1},t_{3}-t_{1},\cdots,t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}-t_{1})\Big). If \left\lVert\xi(t_{1}-)\right\rVert<\epsilon and \left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon^{-\frac{1}{2\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}}\ \forall j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}], then \displaystyle\sup_{t\in[t_{1},t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}]}\left\lVert\xi(t)-\widecheck{\xi}(t-t_{1})\right\rVert\leq\Big(2\exp\big(D(t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}-t_{1})\big)\cdot D\Big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}+1}\cdot\epsilon, where D\geq 1 is the constant in Assumption 2 . 4. Let \bar{c}\in(0,1) be the constant fixed in ( 5.13 ). Given \Delta>0 , there exists \epsilon_{0}=\epsilon_{0}(\Delta)\in(0,\bar{\epsilon}) such that the following claim holds: given T>0 , \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} , \textbf{W}=(\bm{w}_{1},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}},\ (t_{1},\cdots,t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\in(0,T]^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}\uparrow} , if \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon_{0} and \max_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon_{0}^{-\frac{1}{2\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}}, then \displaystyle\xi(t)\notin I_{\bar{c}\bar{\epsilon}}\text{ or }\widecheck{\xi}(t)\notin I_{\bar{c}\bar{\epsilon}}\text{ for some }t\in[t_{1},T-t_{1}]\qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad\sup_{t\in[t_{1},t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}]}\left\lVert\widecheck{\xi}(t-t_{1})-\xi(t)\right\rVert<\Delta, where \xi and \widecheck{\xi} are defined as in part (c) . Proof. Before the proof of the claims, we highlight two facts. First, Assumption 2 and I being a bounded set (so I^{-} is compact) imply the existence of C\in(0,\infty) such that \sup_{\bm{x}\in I^{-}}\left\lVert\bm{a}(\bm{x})\right\rVert\vee\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{x})\right\rVert\leq C . Without loss of generality, in the statement of Lemma 5.1 we pick some C\geq 1 . Next, one can see that the validity of all claims do not depend on the values of \bm{\sigma}(\cdot) and \bm{a}(\cdot) outside of I^{-} . Therefore, throughout this proof below we w.l.o.g. assume that \displaystyle\left\lVert\bm{a}(\bm{x})\right\rVert\vee\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{x})\right\rVert\leq C\qquad\forall\bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m}. (5.15) for some C\in[1,\infty) . That is, we impose the boundedness condition in Assumption 4 . (a) Arbitrarily pick some T>0 and \xi\in\mathbb{D}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{\bar{B}_{\bar{\epsilon}}}[0,T](\bar{\epsilon}) . To lighten notations, in the proof of part (a) we write k=J^{I}_{b} . By the definition of \mathbb{D}^{(k-1)|b}_{A}(\epsilon) in ( 2.10 ), there are some \bm{x} with \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\bar{\epsilon} , some (\bm{w}_{1},\cdots,\bm{w}_{k-1})\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times k-1} , some (\bm{v}_{1},\cdots,\bm{v}_{k-1})\in\mathbb{R}^{m\times k-1} with \max_{j\in[k-1]}\left\lVert\bm{v}_{j}\right\rVert\leq\bar{\epsilon} , and 00 small enough such that \displaystyle\exp(D\bar{t})\cdot C\bar{\delta}<\bar{\epsilon},\qquad C\bar{\delta}0 be such that the conditions in ( 5.7 )–( 5.9 ) hold. Let \bar{t} and \bar{\delta} be the constants characterized in Lemma 5.1 . Observe that (we write \textbf{W}=(\bm{w}_{1},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}) ) \displaystyle\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\big(I^{c}\big) \displaystyle=\int\mathbbm{I}\bigg\{\widecheck{g}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}\big(\varphi_{b}(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}_{1}),(\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}),(t_{1},\cdots,t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1})\big)\notin I\bigg\} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1\uparrow}_{\infty}(dt_{1},\cdots,dt_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1}) \displaystyle=\int\mathbbm{I}\bigg\{h^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{[0,1+t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1}]}\big(\varphi_{b}(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}_{1}),(\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}),(t_{1},\cdots,t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1})\big)(t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1})\notin I\bigg\} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1\uparrow}_{\infty}(dt_{1},\cdots,dt_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1}) \displaystyle\leq\int\mathbbm{I}\Big\{\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert>\bar{\delta}\ \forall j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}];\ t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1}<\bar{t}\ \Big\}\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1\uparrow}_{\infty}(dt_{1},\cdots,dt_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1}) by part (b) of Lemma 5.1 \displaystyle\leq\bar{t}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1}\big/\bar{\delta}^{\alpha\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}<\infty. This concludes the proof. ∎ Recall that we use E^{-} and E^{\circ} to denote the closure and interior of any Borel set E . In our analysis below, we make use of the following inequality in Lemma 5.3 . Lemma 5.3 . Let \bar{t},\bar{\delta}\in(0,\infty) be the constants characterized in part (b) of Lemma 5.1 . Given \Delta\in(0,{\bar{\epsilon}}) , there exists \epsilon_{0}=\epsilon_{0}(\Delta)>0 such that for any \epsilon\in(0,\epsilon_{0}] , T\geq\bar{t} , and Borel measurable B\subseteq(I_{\epsilon})^{c} , \displaystyle\inf_{\bm{x}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon}\mathbf{C}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}_{[0,T]}\bigg(\Big(\widecheck{E}(\epsilon,B,T)\Big)^{\circ};\ \bm{x}\bigg) \displaystyle\geq(T-\bar{t})\cdot\Big(\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B_{\Delta})-\widecheck{\bm{c}}(\epsilon_{0})\Big), \displaystyle\sup_{\bm{x}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon}\mathbf{C}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}_{[0,T]}\bigg(\Big(\widecheck{E}(\epsilon,B,T)\Big)^{-};\ \bm{x}\bigg) \displaystyle\leq T\cdot\Big(\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B^{\Delta})+\widecheck{\bm{c}}(\epsilon_{0})\Big), where \mathbf{C}^{(k)|b}_{[0,T]} is defined in ( 2.11 ), \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(k)|b} is defined in ( 3.8 ), \mathcal{J}_{b}^{I} is defined in ( 3.7 ), \displaystyle\widecheck{E}(\epsilon,B,T) \displaystyle\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\Big\{\xi\in\mathbb{D}[0,T]:\ \exists t\leq T\ s.t.\ \xi_{t}\in B\text{ and }\xi_{s}\in I_{\epsilon}\ \forall s\in[0,t)\Big\}, (5.18) \displaystyle\widecheck{\bm{c}}(\epsilon) \displaystyle\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}\cdot(\bar{t})^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1}\cdot(\bar{\delta})^{-\alpha\cdot(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)}\cdot\epsilon^{\frac{\alpha}{2\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}}. (5.19) Proof. Let \bar{c}\in(0,1) be the constant fixed in ( 5.13 ). By part (e) of Lemma 5.1 , for the fixed \Delta\in(0,\bar{\epsilon}) , we are able to fix some \epsilon_{0}\in(0,\frac{\Delta}{2}\wedge\bar{c}\bar{\epsilon}) such that the following claim holds: given T>0 , \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} , \textbf{W}=(\bm{w}_{1},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}},\ (t_{1},\cdots,t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\in(0,T]^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}\uparrow} , if \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon_{0} and \max_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon_{0}^{-\frac{1}{2\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}}, then \displaystyle\xi(t)\notin I_{\bar{c}\bar{\epsilon}}\text{ or }\widecheck{\xi}(t)\notin I_{\bar{c}\bar{\epsilon}}\text{ for some }t\in[t_{1},T-t_{1}]\quad\Longrightarrow\quad\sup_{t\in[t_{1},t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}]}\left\lVert\widecheck{\xi}(t-t_{1})-\xi(t)\right\rVert<\Delta, (5.20) where \displaystyle\xi \displaystyle=h^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}_{[0,T]}\big(\bm{x},\textbf{W},(t_{1},\cdots,t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\big), \displaystyle=h^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{[0,T]}\Big(\varphi_{b}\big(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}_{1}\big),(\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}),(t_{2}-t_{1},t_{3}-t_{1},\cdots,t_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}-t_{1})\Big). Henceforth in the proof, we fix some \epsilon\in(0,\epsilon_{0}] and B\subseteq(I_{\epsilon})^{c} . Due to our choice of \epsilon\leq\epsilon_{0}<\bar{c}\bar{\epsilon} , we have B\subseteq(I_{\bar{c}\bar{\epsilon}})^{c} . To prove the lower bound, let \widetilde{E}=\Big\{\xi\in\mathbb{D}[0,T]:\ \exists t\in[0,T]\text{ s.t. }\xi(t)\in B_{\Delta/2},\ \xi(s)\in I_{2\epsilon}\ \forall s\in[0,t)\Big\}. For any \xi\in\widetilde{E} and any \xi^{\prime} with \bm{d}_{J_{1}}^{{}_{[0,T]}}(\xi,\xi^{\prime})<\epsilon , due to \epsilon\leq\epsilon_{0}<\Delta/2 , there must be some t^{\prime}\in[0,T] such that \xi^{\prime}(t^{\prime})\in B and \xi^{\prime}(s)\in I_{\epsilon}\ \forall s\in[0,t^{\prime}). This implies that \xi^{\prime}\in\widecheck{E}(\epsilon,B,T) , and hence \displaystyle\widetilde{E}\subseteq\Big(\widecheck{E}(\epsilon,B,T)\Big)_{\epsilon}\subseteq\Big(\widecheck{E}(\epsilon,B,T)\Big)^{\circ}. Therefore, for any \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} with \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon\leq\epsilon_{0} , \displaystyle\mathbf{C}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}_{[0,T]}\bigg(\Big(\widecheck{E}(\epsilon,B,T)\Big)^{\circ};\ \bm{x}\bigg) \displaystyle\geq\int\mathbbm{I}\Big\{h^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}_{[0,T]}(\bm{x},\textbf{W},\bm{t})\in\widetilde{E}\Big\}\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}\uparrow}_{T}(d\bm{t}) \displaystyle=\int\widetilde{\phi}_{B}(t_{1},\bm{x})\mathcal{L}_{T}(dt_{1}), (5.21) where \mathcal{L}_{T} is the Lebesgue measure on (0,T) , \mathcal{L}_{T}^{k\uparrow} is the k -fold ofq Lebesgue measure restricted on \{(t_{1},\cdots,t_{k})\in(0,T)^{k}:\ t_{1}\bar{\delta}\bigg\} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1\uparrow}_{T-t_{1}}(du_{2},\cdots,du_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}) by claims (i) , (ii) , and (v) in part (b) of Lemma 5.1 \displaystyle\geq\inf_{\bm{x}_{0}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}_{0}\right\rVert\leq\frac{\Delta}{2}}\int\mathbbm{I}\bigg\{h^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{[0,T-t_{1}]}\Big(\bm{x}_{0}+\varphi_{b}(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{x}_{0})\bm{w}_{1}),(\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}),(u_{2},\cdots,u_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\Big)(u_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\in B_{\Delta/2}; \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\min_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert>\bar{\delta},\ \max_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon_{0}^{-\frac{1}{2\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}}\bigg\} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1\uparrow}_{T-t_{1}}(du_{2},\cdots,du_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}) \displaystyle\geq\int\mathbbm{I}\bigg\{h^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{[0,T-t_{1}]}\Big(\varphi_{b}(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}_{1}),(\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}),(u_{2},\cdots,u_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\Big)(u_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\in B_{\Delta}; \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\min_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert>\bar{\delta},\ \max_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon_{0}^{-\frac{1}{2\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}}\bigg\} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1\uparrow}_{T-t_{1}}(du_{2},\cdots,du_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}) by property ( 5.20 ) \displaystyle=\int\mathbbm{I}\bigg\{\widecheck{g}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{[0,T-t_{1}]}\Big(\varphi_{b}(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}_{1}),(\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}),(u_{2},\cdots,u_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\Big)\in B_{\Delta}; \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\min_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert>\bar{\delta},\ \max_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon_{0}^{-\frac{1}{2\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}}\bigg\} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1\uparrow}_{T-t_{1}}(du_{2},\cdots,du_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}) by the definition of \widecheck{g}^{(k)|b} in ( 3.4 ) \displaystyle=\int\mathbbm{I}\bigg\{\widecheck{g}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{[0,T-t_{1}]}\Big(\varphi_{b}(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}_{1}),(\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}),(u_{2},\cdots,u_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\Big)\in B_{\Delta}; \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\min_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert>\bar{\delta},\ \max_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon_{0}^{-\frac{1}{2\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}}\bigg\} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1\uparrow}_{\bar{t}}(du_{2},\cdots,du_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}) by claim (v) in part (b) of Lemma 5.1 \displaystyle\geq\int\mathbbm{I}\bigg\{\widecheck{g}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{[0,T-t_{1}]}\Big(\varphi_{b}(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}_{1}),(\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}),(u_{2},\cdots,u_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\Big)\in B_{\Delta};\ \min_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert>\bar{\delta}\bigg\} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1\uparrow}_{\bar{t}}(du_{2},\cdots,du_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}) \displaystyle\qquad-\int\mathbbm{I}\bigg\{\min_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert>\bar{\delta},\ \max_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert>\epsilon_{0}^{-\frac{1}{2\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}}\bigg\}\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1\uparrow}_{\bar{t}}(du_{2},\cdots,du_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}). We focus on the two integrals one the RHS of the last inequality in the display above. It is easy to see that the latter is upper bounded by \displaystyle\widecheck{\bm{c}}(\epsilon_{0})=\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}\cdot(\bar{t})^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1}\cdot(\bar{\delta})^{-\alpha\cdot(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)}\cdot\epsilon_{0}^{\frac{\alpha}{2\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}}. As for the former, using part (b) of Lemma 5.1 and the fact that B_{\Delta}\subseteq B\subseteq(I_{\bar{c}\bar{\epsilon}})^{c} again, we yield \displaystyle\int\mathbbm{I}\bigg\{\widecheck{g}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{[0,T-t_{1}]}\Big(\varphi_{b}(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}_{1}),(\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}),(u_{2},\cdots,u_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\Big)\in B_{\Delta};\ \min_{j\in[\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}]}\left\lVert\bm{w}_{j}\right\rVert>\bar{\delta}\bigg\} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1\uparrow}_{\bar{t}}(du_{2},\cdots,du_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}) \displaystyle=\int\mathbbm{I}\bigg\{\widecheck{g}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{[0,T-t_{1}]}\Big(\varphi_{b}(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}_{1}),(\bm{w}_{2},\cdots,\bm{w}_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}),(u_{2},\cdots,u_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}})\Big)\in B_{\Delta}\} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(d\textbf{W})\times\mathcal{L}^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1\uparrow}_{\infty}(du_{2},\cdots,du_{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}) \displaystyle=\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B_{\Delta}). In summary, for any \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} with \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon and t_{1}\in[0,T-\bar{t}] , we have shown that \widetilde{\phi}_{B}(t_{1},\bm{x})\geq\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B_{\Delta})-\widecheck{\bm{c}}(\epsilon_{0}). Together with the trivial bound that \widetilde{\phi}_{B}(t_{1},\bm{x})\geq 0 for all t_{1}>T-\bar{t} , we have in ( 5.21 ) that \mathbf{C}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}_{[0,T]}\bigg(\Big(\widecheck{E}(\epsilon,B,T)\Big)^{\circ};\ \bm{x}\bigg)\geq(T-\bar{t})\cdot\Big(\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B_{\Delta})-\widecheck{\bm{c}}(\epsilon_{0})\Big) for all \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} with \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon . This concludes the proof of the lower bound. The proof to the upper bound is almost identical, so we omit the details here. ∎ 5.2 Proof of Theorem 3.1 via Asymptotic Atoms To see how we apply the framework developed in Section 3.1.2 , let us specialize Condition 1 to a setting where \mathbb{S}=\mathbb{R} , A(\epsilon)=B_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})=\{\bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert<\epsilon\} , and the covering I(\epsilon)=I_{\epsilon} . Let V^{\eta}_{j}(x)=\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x}) . Meanwhile, for C^{I}_{b}=\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\big(I^{c}\big), it is shown in Lemma 5.2 that C^{I}_{b}<\infty . Now, recall that H(\cdot)=\mathbf{P}(\left\lVert\bm{Z}_{1}\right\rVert>\cdot) and \lambda(\eta)=\eta^{-1}H(\eta^{-1}) . Recall that in Theorem 3.1 , we consider two cases: (i) C^{I}_{b}\in(0,\infty) , and (ii) C^{I}_{b}=0 . We first discuss our choices in Case (i) . When C^{I}_{b}>0 , we set the location measure and scale as \displaystyle C(\ \cdot\ )\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(\ \cdot\ \setminus I)}\big/{C^{I}_{b}},\qquad\gamma(\eta)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}C^{I}_{b}\cdot\eta\cdot\big(\lambda(\eta)\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}. (5.22) The regularity conditions in Theorem 3.1 dictate that \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(\partial I)=0, and hence C(\partial I)=0 . Besides, note that C(\cdot) is a probability measure and \gamma(\eta)T/\eta=C^{I}_{b}T\cdot\big(\lambda(\eta)\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}. The application of the framework developed in Section 3.1.2 (specifically, Theorem 3.4 ) hinges on the verification of ( 3.10 )–( 3.13 ). We start by verifying ( 3.10 ) and ( 3.11 ). First, given any Borel measurable B\subseteq\mathbb{R} , we specify the choice of function \delta_{B}(\epsilon,T) in Condition 1 . From the continuity of measures, we get \lim_{\Delta\downarrow 0}\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B^{\Delta}\cap I^{c})\setminus(B^{-}\cap I^{c})\Big)=0 and \lim_{\Delta\downarrow 0}\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B^{\circ}\cap I^{c})\setminus(B_{\Delta}\cap I^{c})\Big)=0 . This allows us to fix a sequence (\Delta^{(n)})_{n\geq 1} such that \Delta^{(n+1)}\in(0,\Delta^{(n)}/2) and \displaystyle\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B^{\Delta^{(n)}}\cap I^{c})\setminus(B^{-}\cap I^{c})\Big)\vee\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B^{\circ}\cap I^{c})\setminus(B_{\Delta^{(n)}}\cap I^{c})\Big)\leq 1/2^{n} (5.23) for each n\geq 1 . Next, recall the definition of set \widecheck{E}(\epsilon,B,T) in Lemma 5.3 , and let \widetilde{B}(\epsilon)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}B\setminus I_{\epsilon} . Using Lemma 5.3 , we are able to fix another sequence (\epsilon^{(n)})_{n\geq 1} with \epsilon^{(n+1)}\in(0,\epsilon^{(n)}/2) and \epsilon^{(n)}\in(0,\bar{\epsilon}]\ \forall n\geq 1 , such that for any n\geq 1 , \epsilon\in(0,\epsilon^{(n)}] , \displaystyle\sup_{\bm{x}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon}\mathbf{C}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}_{[0,T]}\bigg(\Big(\widecheck{E}\big(\epsilon,\widetilde{B}(\epsilon),T\big)\Big)^{-};\ \bm{x}\bigg) \displaystyle\leq T\cdot\bigg(\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(\big(B\setminus I_{\epsilon}\big)^{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big)+\widecheck{\bm{c}}(\epsilon^{(n)})\bigg), (5.24) \displaystyle\inf_{\bm{x}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon}\mathbf{C}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}_{[0,T]}\bigg(\Big(\widecheck{E}\big(\epsilon,\widetilde{B}(\epsilon),T\big)\Big)^{\circ};\ \bm{x}\bigg) \displaystyle\geq(T-\bar{t})\cdot\bigg(\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(\big(B\setminus I_{\epsilon}\big)_{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big)-\widecheck{\bm{c}}(\epsilon^{(n)})\bigg). (5.25) Besides, note that given any \epsilon\in(0,\epsilon^{(1)}] , there uniquely exists some n=n_{\epsilon}\geq 1 such that \epsilon\in(\epsilon^{(n+1)},\epsilon^{(n)}] . This allows us to set (under n=n_{\epsilon} ) \displaystyle\widecheck{\delta}_{B}(\epsilon,T) (5.26) \displaystyle=T\cdot\Bigg[\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B^{\Delta^{(n)}}\cap I^{c})\char 92\relax(B^{-}\cap I^{c})\Big) \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\vee\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B^{\circ}\cap I^{c})\char 92\relax(B_{\Delta^{(n)}}\cap I^{c})\Big)\vee\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((\partial I)^{\epsilon+\Delta^{(n)}}\Big)\Bigg] \displaystyle\qquad+T\cdot\widecheck{\bm{c}}(\epsilon^{(n)})+\bar{t}\cdot\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\big(B^{\circ}\setminus I\big), where \widecheck{\bm{c}}(\cdot) is defined in ( 5.19 ). Also, let \delta_{B}(\epsilon,T)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}{\widecheck{\delta}_{B}(\epsilon,T)}/({C^{I}_{b}\cdot T}). By ( 5.23 ) and \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B\setminus I)\leq\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(I^{c})<\infty , we get \displaystyle\lim_{T\to\infty}\delta_{B}(\epsilon,T)\leq\big({C^{I}_{b}}\big)^{-1}\cdot\Big[\widecheck{\bm{c}}(\epsilon^{(n)})+\frac{1}{2^{n}}\vee\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((\partial I)^{\epsilon+\Delta^{(n)}}\Big)\Big], where n=n_{\epsilon} is the unique positive integer satisfying \epsilon\in(\epsilon^{(n+1)},\epsilon^{(n)}] . Moreover, as \epsilon\downarrow 0 we get n_{\epsilon}\to\infty . Since \partial I is closed, we get \cap_{r>0}(\partial I)^{r}=\partial I , which implies \lim_{r\downarrow 0}\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((\partial I)^{r}\Big)=\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(\partial I)=0. Also, by definition of \widecheck{\bm{c}} in ( 5.19 ), we have \lim_{\epsilon\downarrow 0}\widecheck{\bm{c}}(\epsilon)=0 . In summary, we have verified that \lim_{\epsilon\downarrow 0}\lim_{T\to\infty}\delta_{B}(\epsilon,T)=0 . Next, in Case (ii) (i.e., C^{I}_{b}=0 ), we set \displaystyle C(\cdot)\equiv 0,\qquad\gamma(\eta)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\eta\cdot\big(\lambda(\eta)\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}},\qquad\delta_{B}(\epsilon,T)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\widecheck{\delta}_{B}(\epsilon,T)/T. The same calculations above verify that \lim_{\epsilon\downarrow 0}\lim_{T\to\infty}\delta_{B}(\epsilon,T)=0 . Now, we are ready to verify conditions ( 3.10 ) and ( 3.11 ). Specifically, we introduce stopping time \displaystyle\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x}) \displaystyle\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\min\big\{j\geq 0:\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x})\notin I_{\epsilon}\big\}. (5.27) Lemma 5.4 (Verifying conditions ( 3.10 ) and ( 3.11 )) . Let \bar{t} be characterized as in Lemma 5.3 . Given any measurable B\subseteq\mathbb{R} , any \epsilon\in(0,\bar{\epsilon}] small enough, and any T>\bar{t} , \displaystyle C(B^{\circ})-\delta_{B}(\epsilon,T) \displaystyle\leq\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{\bm{x}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon}\frac{\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})\leq T/\eta;\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\Big)}{\gamma(\eta)T/\eta} \displaystyle\leq\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon}\frac{\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})\leq T/\eta;\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\Big)}{\gamma(\eta)T/\eta}\leq C(B^{-})+\delta_{B}(\epsilon,T). Proof. Recall that 1. in case that C^{I}_{b}\in(0,\infty) , we have \gamma(\eta)T/\eta=C^{I}_{b}T\cdot\big(\lambda(\eta)\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}, C(\cdot)=\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(\ \cdot\ \setminus I)/C^{I}_{b}, and \delta_{B}(\epsilon,T)={\widecheck{\delta}_{B}(\epsilon,T)}/({C^{I}_{b}\cdot T}) ; 2. in case that C^{I}_{b}=0 , we have \gamma(\eta)T/\eta=T\cdot\big(\lambda(\eta)\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}, C(\cdot)\equiv 0, and \delta_{B}(\epsilon,T)={\widecheck{\delta}_{B}(\epsilon,T)}/T . In both cases, by rearranging the terms, it suffices to show that \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon}\frac{\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})\leq T/\eta;\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\Big)}{\big(\lambda(\eta)\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}} \displaystyle\leq T\cdot\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B^{-}\setminus I)+\widecheck{\delta}_{B}(\epsilon,T), (5.28) \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{\bm{x}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon}\frac{\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})\leq T/\eta;\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\Big)}{\big(\lambda(\eta)\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}} \displaystyle\geq T\cdot\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B^{\circ}\setminus I)-\widecheck{\delta}_{B}(\epsilon,T). (5.29) Recall the definition of set \widecheck{E}(\epsilon,\cdot,T) in ( 5.18 ). Let \widetilde{B}(\epsilon)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}B\setminus I_{\epsilon} . Note that \displaystyle\Big\{\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})\leq T/\eta;\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\Big\} \displaystyle=\Big\{\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})\leq T/\eta;\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in\widetilde{B}(\epsilon)\Big\} \displaystyle=\Big\{\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{[0,T]}(\bm{x})\in\widecheck{E}\big(\epsilon,\widetilde{B}(\epsilon),T\big)\Big\}. For any \epsilon\in(0,\bar{\epsilon}) and \xi\in\widecheck{E}(\epsilon,\widetilde{B}(\epsilon),T) , there exists t\in[0,T] such that \xi_{t}\notin I_{\epsilon} . On the other hand, recall that we use \bar{B}_{\epsilon}(\bm{0}) to denote the closed ball with radius \epsilon centered at the origin. By part (a) of Lemma 5.1 , given \epsilon\in(0,\bar{\epsilon}] , it holds for any \xi\in\mathbb{D}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{\bar{B}_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})}[0,T](\epsilon) that \xi_{t}\in(I_{2\bar{\epsilon}})^{-}\ \forall t\in[0,T] . Therefore, the claim \displaystyle\bm{d}_{J_{1}}^{{}_{[0,T]}}\bigg(\widecheck{E}\big(\epsilon,\widetilde{B}(\epsilon),T\big),\ \mathbb{D}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}_{\bar{B}_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})}[0,T](\epsilon)\bigg)\geq\bar{\epsilon} holds for any \epsilon\in(0,\bar{\epsilon}] . Next, recall the sequence (\epsilon^{(n)})_{n\geq 1} specified in ( 5.24 )–( 5.25 ). For any \epsilon>0 small enough we have \epsilon\in(0,\epsilon^{(1)}] , and for such \epsilon we set n=n_{\epsilon} as the unique positive integer such that \epsilon\in(\epsilon^{(n+1)},\epsilon^{(n)}] . It then follows from Theorem 2.1 that \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon}\frac{\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})\leq T/\eta;\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\Big)}{\big(\lambda(\eta)\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}} (5.30) \displaystyle\leq\sup_{\bm{x}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon}\mathbf{C}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}_{[0,T]}\bigg(\Big(\widecheck{E}\big(\epsilon,\widetilde{B}(\epsilon),T\big)\Big)^{-};\bm{x}\bigg)\leq T\cdot\bigg(\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B\setminus I_{\epsilon})^{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big)+\widecheck{\bm{c}}(\epsilon^{(n)})\bigg), where we applied property ( 5.24 ) in the last inequality. Furthermore, \displaystyle\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B\setminus I_{\epsilon})^{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big) \displaystyle\leq\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(B^{\Delta^{(n)}}\cup((I_{\epsilon})^{c})^{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big)\qquad\text{due to }(E\cup F)^{\Delta}\subseteq E^{\Delta}\cup F^{\Delta} \displaystyle=\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(B^{\Delta^{(n)}}\cup((I_{\epsilon})^{c})^{\Delta^{(n)}}\cap I^{c}\Big)+\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(B^{\Delta^{(n)}}\cup((I_{\epsilon})^{c})^{\Delta^{(n)}}\cap I\Big) \displaystyle\leq\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(B^{\Delta^{(n)}}\setminus I\Big)+\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(((I_{\epsilon})^{c})^{\Delta^{(n)}}\cap I\Big) \displaystyle\leq\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(B^{\Delta^{(n)}}\setminus I\Big)+\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((\partial I)^{\epsilon+\Delta^{(n)}}\Big) \displaystyle\leq\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(B^{-}\setminus I\Big)+\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B^{\Delta^{(n)}}\cap I^{c})\setminus(B^{-}\cap I^{c})\Big)+\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((\partial I)^{\epsilon+\Delta^{(n)}}\Big) Plugging this bound back into ( 5.30 ), the upper bound in the claim ( 5.28 ) then follows from the definition of \widecheck{\delta}_{B} in ( 5.26 ) and our choice of C(\cdot) in ( 5.22 ). Similarly, by Theorem 2.1 and the property ( 5.25 ), we obtain (for any \epsilon>0 small enough) \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{\bm{x}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon}\frac{\mathbf{P}\Big(\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})\leq T/\eta;\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\Big)}{\big(\lambda(\eta)\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}} (5.31) \displaystyle\geq\inf_{\bm{x}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq\epsilon}\mathbf{C}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}_{[0,T]}\bigg(\Big(\widecheck{E}\big(\epsilon,\widetilde{B}(\epsilon),T\big)\Big)^{\circ};\bm{x}\bigg)\geq(T-\bar{t})\cdot\bigg(\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B\setminus I_{\epsilon})_{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big)-\widecheck{\bm{c}}(\epsilon^{(n)})\bigg), where n=n_{\epsilon} is the unique positive integer such that \epsilon\in(\epsilon^{(n+1)},\epsilon^{(n)}] . Furthermore, by the preliminary bound (E\cap F)_{\Delta}\supseteq E_{\Delta}\cap F_{\Delta} , \displaystyle\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B\setminus I_{\epsilon})_{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big) \displaystyle\geq\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B\setminus I)_{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big)\geq\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(B_{\Delta^{(n)}}\cap(I^{c})_{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big). Together with the fact that B_{\Delta}\setminus I=B_{\Delta}\cap I^{c}\subseteq\Big(B_{\Delta}\cap(I^{c})_{\Delta}\Big)\cup\Big(I^{c}\setminus(I^{c})_{\Delta}\Big), we yield \displaystyle\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B\setminus I_{\epsilon})_{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big)\geq\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(B_{\Delta^{(n)}}\cap(I^{c})_{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big) \displaystyle\geq\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(B_{\Delta^{(n)}}\setminus I\Big)-\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(I^{c}\setminus(I^{c})_{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big) \displaystyle\geq\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(B_{\Delta^{(n)}}\setminus I\Big)-\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((\partial I)^{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big) \displaystyle=\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big(B^{\circ}\setminus I\Big)-\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((B^{\circ}\cap I^{c})\setminus(B_{\Delta^{(n)}}\cap I^{c})\Big)-\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}\Big((\partial I)^{\Delta^{(n)}}\Big). Plugging this back into ( 5.31 ), we conclude the proof for the lower bound ( 5.29 ). ∎ The next result verifies condition ( 3.12 ). Under our choice of A(\epsilon)=\{\bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert<\epsilon\} and I(\epsilon)=I_{\epsilon} , the event \{\tau^{\eta}_{(I(\epsilon)\setminus A(\epsilon))^{c}}(x)>T/\eta\} in condition ( 3.12 ) means that \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x})\in I_{\epsilon}\char 92\relax\{\bm{x}:\left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert<\epsilon\} for all j\leq T/\eta . Also, recall our choice of \gamma(\eta)T/\eta=C^{I}_{b}T\cdot\big(\lambda(\eta)\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}} if C^{I}_{b}>0 , or \gamma(\eta)T/\eta=T\cdot\big(\lambda(\eta)\big)^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}} if C^{I}_{b}=0 . To verify condition ( 3.12 ), it suffices to prove the following result. Lemma 5.5 (Verifying condition ( 3.12 )) . Let \bar{\epsilon}>0 be the constant in ( 5.7 )–( 5.9 ), and \bm{t}(\cdot) be defined as in ( 5.10 ). Given k\geq 1 and \epsilon\in(0,\bar{\epsilon}) , it holds for any T\geq k\cdot\bm{t}(\epsilon/2) that \displaystyle\lim_{\eta\downarrow 0}\ \sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\ \,\frac{1}{\lambda^{k-1}(\eta)}\mathbf{P}\Big(\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x})\in I_{\epsilon}\setminus\{\bm{x}:\left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert<\epsilon\}\ \ \forall j\leq T/\eta\Big)=0. Proof. In this proof, we write \xi(t)=\xi_{t} for any \xi\in\mathbb{D}[0,T] , and write B_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})=\{\bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert<\epsilon\} . Note that \big\{\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x})\in I_{\epsilon}\setminus B_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})\ \ \forall j\leq T/\eta\big\}=\big\{\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{[0,T]}(x)\in E(\epsilon)\big\} where \displaystyle E(\epsilon)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\Big\{\xi\in\mathbb{D}[0,T]:\ \xi(t)\in I_{\epsilon}\setminus B_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})\ \ \forall t\in[0,T]\Big\}. Recall the definition of \mathbb{D}^{(k)|b}_{A}[0,T](\epsilon) in ( 2.10 ). We claim that E(\epsilon) is bounded away from \mathbb{D}^{(k-1)|b}_{(I_{\epsilon})^{-}}[0,T](\epsilon) . This allows us to apply Theorem 2.1 and conclude that \displaystyle\sup_{x\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\Big(\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{[0,T]}(\bm{x})\in E(\epsilon)\Big)=\bm{O}\big(\lambda^{k}(\eta)\big)=\bm{o}\big(\lambda^{k-1}(\eta)\big)\ \ \ \text{as }\eta\downarrow 0. Now, it only remains to verify that E(\epsilon) is bounded away from \mathbb{D}^{(k-1)|b}_{(I_{\epsilon})^{-}}[0,T](\epsilon) , which follows if we show the existence of some \delta>0 such that \displaystyle\bm{d}_{J_{1}}^{{}_{[0,T]}}(\xi,\xi^{\prime})\geq\delta>0\qquad\forall\xi\in\mathbb{D}^{(k-1)|b}_{(I_{\epsilon})^{-}}[0,T](\epsilon),\ \xi^{\prime}\in E(\epsilon). (5.32) First, by definition of E(\epsilon) , we have \xi^{\prime}(t)\in I_{\epsilon}\ \forall t\in[0,T] for any \xi^{\prime}\in E(\epsilon) . Also, note that \inf\{\left\lVert\bm{x}-\bm{y}\right\rVert:\ \bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon},\ \bm{y}\notin I_{\epsilon/2}\}\geq\epsilon/2. Therefore, for any \xi\in\mathbb{D}^{(k-1)|b}_{(I_{\epsilon})^{-}}[0,T](\epsilon) , if \xi(t)\notin I_{\epsilon/2} for some t\in[0,T] , then \bm{d}_{J_{1}}^{{}_{[0,T]}}(\xi,\xi^{\prime})\geq\epsilon/2>0. Next, given \xi\in\mathbb{D}^{(k-1)|b}_{(I_{\epsilon})^{-}}[0,T](\epsilon) , we consider the case where \xi(t)\in I_{\epsilon/2} for any t\in[0,T] . By definition of \mathbb{D}^{(k-1)|b}_{(I_{\epsilon})^{-}}[0,T](\epsilon), there is some \bm{x}\in(I_{\epsilon})^{-} , \textbf{W}\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times(k-1)} , \textbf{V}\in\big(\bar{B}_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})\big)^{k-1} , and (t_{1},\cdots,t_{k-1})\in(0,T]^{k-1\uparrow} such that \xi=\bar{h}^{(k-1)|b}_{[0,T]}\big(\bm{x},\textbf{W},\textbf{V},(t_{1},\cdots,t_{k-1})\big). Under the convention that t_{0}=0 and t_{k}=T , we have (for each j\in[k] ) \displaystyle\xi(t)=\bm{y}_{t-t_{j-1}}\big(\xi(t_{j-1})\big)\qquad\forall t\in[t_{j-1},t_{j}). (5.33) Here, \bm{y}_{\cdot}(x) is the ODE defined in ( 3.1 ). By the running assumption in this lemma that T\geq k\cdot\bm{t}(\epsilon/2) , there must be some j\in[k] such that t_{j}-t_{j-1}\geq\bm{t}({\epsilon}/{2}) . Since \xi(t)\in I_{\epsilon/2}\ \forall t\in[0,T] , we have \xi(t_{j-1})\in I_{\epsilon/2} . Combining ( 5.33 ) and the property ( 5.11 ), we get \lim_{t\uparrow t_{j}}\xi(t)\in\bar{B}_{\epsilon/2}(\bm{0})\subset B_{\epsilon}(\bm{0}). On the other hand, by definition of E(\epsilon) , we have \xi^{\prime}(t)\notin B_{\epsilon}(\bm{0}) for all t\in[0,T] , which implies \bm{d}_{J_{1}}^{{}_{[0,T]}}(\xi,\xi^{\prime})\geq\frac{\epsilon}{2}. This concludes the proof. ∎ Let \displaystyle R^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x}) \displaystyle\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\min\bigg\{j\geq 0:\ \left\lVert\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x})\right\rVert<\epsilon\bigg\} (5.34) be the first time \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x}) returns to the \epsilon -neighborhood of the origin. Lastly, we establish condition ( 3.13 ) under our choice of A(\epsilon)=\{\bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert<\epsilon\} . Note that the first visit time \tau^{\eta}_{A(\epsilon)}(x) therein coincides with R^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(x) . Lemma 5.6 (Verifying condition ( 3.13 )) . Let \bm{t}(\cdot) be defined as in ( 5.10 ) and \displaystyle E(\eta,\epsilon,\bm{x})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\Bigg\{R^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})\leq\frac{\bm{t}(\epsilon/2)}{\eta};\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x})\in I\ \forall j\leq R^{\eta|b}_{\epsilon}(\bm{x})\Bigg\}. For any \epsilon\in(0,\bar{\epsilon}) , \lim_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in(I_{\epsilon})^{-}}\mathbf{P}\Big(\big(E(\eta,\epsilon,\bm{x})\big)^{c}\Big)=0. Proof. In this proof, we write B_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})=\{\bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m}:\ \left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert<\epsilon\} . Note that \big(E(\eta,\epsilon,\bm{x})\big)^{c}\subseteq\big\{\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{[0,\bm{t}(\epsilon/2)]}(\bm{x})\in E^{*}_{1}(\epsilon)\cup E^{*}_{2}(\epsilon)\big\}, where \displaystyle E^{*}_{1}(\epsilon) \displaystyle\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\bigg\{\xi\in\mathbb{D}[0,\bm{t}(\epsilon/2)]:\ \xi(t)\notin B_{\epsilon}(\bm{0})\ \forall t\in[0,\bm{t}(\epsilon/2)]\bigg\}, \displaystyle E^{*}_{2}(\epsilon) \displaystyle\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\bigg\{\xi\in\mathbb{D}[0,\bm{t}(\epsilon/2)]:\ \exists 0\leq s0, (5.35) Meanwhile, by property ( 5.12 ), \displaystyle\bm{d}_{J_{1}}^{{}_{[0,\bm{t}(\epsilon/2)]}}\bigg(\mathbb{D}^{(0)|b}_{(I(\epsilon))^{-}}[0,\bm{t}(\epsilon/2)],\ E^{*}_{2}(\epsilon)\bigg) \displaystyle>0. (5.36) This allows us to apply Theorem 2.1 and obtain \sup_{\bm{x}\in(I_{\epsilon})^{-}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(\big(E(\eta,\epsilon,\bm{x})\big)^{c}\bigg)\leq\sup_{\bm{x}\in(I_{\epsilon})^{-}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{[0,\bm{t}(\epsilon/2)]}(\bm{x})\in E^{*}_{1}(\epsilon)\cup E^{*}_{2}(\epsilon)\bigg)=\bm{O}\big(\lambda(\eta)\big) as \eta\downarrow 0 . To conclude the proof, one only needs to note that \lambda(\eta)\in\mathcal{RV}_{\alpha-1}(\eta) (with \alpha>1 ) and hence \lim_{\eta\downarrow 0}\lambda(\eta)=0 . ∎ We conclude this section with the proof of Theorem 3.1 . Proof of Theorem 3.1 . As noted above, the claim C^{I}_{b}<\infty is verified by Lemma 5.2 . Next, since Lemmas 5.4 – 5.6 verify Condition 1 , Theorem 3.1 follows immediately from Theorem 3.4 . ∎ 6 Proof of Corollary 3.2 This section collects the proof of Corollary 3.2 . We first give a straightforward bound for the law of geometric random variables. Lemma 6.1 . Let a:(0,\infty)\to(0,\infty) , b:(0,\infty)\to(0,\infty) be two functions such that \lim_{\epsilon\downarrow 0}a(\epsilon)=0,\lim_{\epsilon\downarrow 0}b(\epsilon)=0 . Let \{U(\epsilon):\epsilon>0\} be a family of geometric RVs with success rate a(\epsilon) , i.e. \mathbf{P}(U(\epsilon)>k)=(1-a(\epsilon))^{k} for k\in\mathbb{N} . For any c>1 , there exists \epsilon_{0}>0 such that \exp\Big(-\frac{c\cdot a(\epsilon)}{b(\epsilon)}\Big)\leq\mathbf{P}\Big(U(\epsilon)>\frac{1}{b(\epsilon)}\Big)\leq\exp\Big(-\frac{a(\epsilon)}{c\cdot b(\epsilon)}\Big)\ \ \ \forall\epsilon\in(0,\epsilon_{0}). Proof. Note that \mathbf{P}(U(\epsilon)>\frac{1}{b(\epsilon)})=\big(1-a(\epsilon)\big)^{\lfloor 1/b(\epsilon)\rfloor}. By taking logarithm on both sides, we have \displaystyle\ln\mathbf{P}\Big(U(\epsilon)>\frac{1}{b(\epsilon)}\Big) \displaystyle=\lfloor 1/b(\epsilon)\rfloor\ln\Big(1-a(\epsilon)\Big)=\frac{\lfloor 1/b(\epsilon)\rfloor}{1/b(\epsilon)}\frac{\ln\Big(1-a(\epsilon)\Big)}{-a(\epsilon)}\frac{-a(\epsilon)}{b(\epsilon)}. Since \lim_{x\rightarrow 0}\frac{\ln(1+x)}{x}=1 , we know that for \epsilon sufficiently small, we will have -c\frac{a(\epsilon)}{b(\epsilon)}\leq\ln\mathbf{P}\Big(U(\epsilon)>\frac{1}{b(\epsilon)}\Big)\leq-\frac{a(\epsilon)}{c\cdot b(\epsilon)}. By taking exponential on both sides, we conclude the proof. ∎ Proof of Corollary 3.2 . Note that the value of \bm{\sigma}(\cdot) and \bm{a}(\cdot) outside of the domain I has no impact on the first exit analysis. Therefore, by modifying the value of \bm{\sigma}(\cdot) and \bm{a}(\cdot) outside of I , we can assume w.l.o.g. that \displaystyle\left\lVert\bm{a}(\bm{x})\right\rVert\vee\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{x})\right\rVert\leq C\qquad\forall\bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m}. (6.1) for some C\in(0,\infty) . That is, we can impose the boundedness condition in Assumption 4 w.l.o.g. We start with a few observations. First, under any \eta\in(0,\frac{b}{2C}) , on the event \{\eta\left\lVert\bm{Z}_{j}\right\rVert\leq\frac{b}{2C}\ \forall j\leq t\} the norm of the step-size (before truncation) \eta\bm{a}\big(\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j-1}(\bm{x})\big)+\eta\bm{\sigma}\big(\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j-1}(\bm{x})\big)\bm{Z}_{j} of \bm{X}_{j}^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}) is less than b for each j\leq t . Therefore, \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x}) and \bm{X}^{\eta}_{j}(\bm{x}) coincide for such j ’s. In other words, for any \eta\in(0,\frac{b}{2C}) , on event \big\{\eta\left\lVert\bm{Z}_{j}\right\rVert\leq\frac{b}{2C}\ \forall j\leq t\big\} we have \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x})=\bm{X}^{\eta}_{j}(\bm{x})\qquad\forall j\leq t. (6.2) Next, recall that I is a bounded under Assumption 3 . Therefore, under b>\sup_{\bm{x}\in I}\left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert , it holds for \bm{w}\in\mathbb{R}^{d} that \displaystyle\varphi_{b}\big(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}\big)\notin I\qquad\Longleftrightarrow\qquad\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}\notin I. As a result, for all b large enough, we have \displaystyle C^{I}_{b}=\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(1)|b}(I^{c}) \displaystyle=\int\mathbbm{I}\Big\{\varphi_{b}\big(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}\big)\notin I\Big\}\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)(d\bm{w}) \displaystyle=\int\mathbbm{I}\Big\{\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}\notin I\Big\}\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)(d\bm{w})=\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(I^{c})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}C^{I}_{\infty}. (6.3) Similarly, one can show that for all b large enough, \displaystyle\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(1)|b}(\partial I)=\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(1)}(\partial I). (6.4) Moreover, given any measurable A\subseteq\mathbb{R} such that r_{A}=\inf\{\left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert:\ \bm{x}\in A\}>0 , we claim that \displaystyle\lim_{b\to\infty}\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(1)|b}(A)=\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(A). (6.5) This claim follows from a simple application of the dominated convergence theorem. Indeed, by definition, we have \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(1)|b}(A)=\int\mathbbm{I}\big\{\varphi_{b}\big(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}\big)\in A\big\}\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)(d\bm{w}). For f_{b}(\bm{w})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\mathbbm{I}\big\{\varphi_{b}\big(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}\big)\in A\big\} , we first note that given \bm{w}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} , we have f_{b}(\bm{w})=f(\bm{w})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\mathbbm{I}\big\{\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}\in A\big\} for all b>\left\lVert\bm{w}\right\rVert\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\right\rVert . Therefore, the point-wise convergence \lim_{b\to\infty}f_{b}(\bm{w})=f(\bm{w}) holds for all \bm{w}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} . Next, observe that \displaystyle\big\{\varphi_{b}\big(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}\big)\in A\big\} \displaystyle\subseteq\big\{\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}\right\rVert\geq r_{A}\big\}\subseteq\big\{\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\right\rVert\cdot\left\lVert\bm{w}\right\rVert\geq r_{A}\big\}=\big\{\left\lVert\bm{w}\right\rVert\geq r_{A}/\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\right\rVert\big\}. This implies f_{b}(\bm{w})\leq\mathbbm{I}\big\{\left\lVert\bm{w}\right\rVert\geq r_{A}/\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\right\rVert\big\} for all b>0 and \bm{w}\in\mathbb{R}^{d} . Also, by definition of the measure \nu_{\alpha} in ( 2.2 ), \displaystyle\int\mathbbm{I}\big\{\left\lVert\bm{w}\right\rVert\geq r_{A}/\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\right\rVert\big\}\big((\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S})\circ\Phi\big)(d\bm{w})=(\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\right\rVert/r_{A})^{\alpha}<\infty. (6.6) The last inequality follows from r_{A}>0 . This allows us to apply dominated convergence theorem and establish ( 6.5 ). Moving on, we verify a few regularity conditions. By repeating the calculations in ( 6.6 ) with A=I^{c} , we are able to verify the condition {C^{I}_{\infty}}=\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(I^{c})<\infty in Corollary 3.2 . Next, by the convention in ( 3.6 ), we have that \mathcal{G}^{(0)|b}(\epsilon) is bounded away from I^{c} for all \epsilon>0 small enough and all b>0 . In the meantime, recall the definition of \mathcal{G}^{(1)|b}=\big\{\varphi_{b}\big(\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}\big):\ \bm{w}\in\mathbb{R}^{d}\big\}. Due to \left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\right\rVert>0 , there exists \bm{w}^{*} such that \left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}^{*}\right\rVert>\sup_{\bm{x}\in I}\left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert, and hence \bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}^{*}\notin I . As a result, for all b>\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}(\bm{0})\bm{w}^{*}\right\rVert we have \mathcal{G}^{(1)|b}\cap I^{c}\neq\emptyset. That is, we have shown that \displaystyle\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}=1\qquad\text{for all $b>0$ large enough}; see ( 3.7 ) for the definition. Together with ( 6.4 ) and the running assumption \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(\partial I)=0 in Corollary 3.2 , we have \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(1)|b}(\partial I)=0 for all b large enough. These conditions will allow us to apply Theorem 3.1 , with b>0 large enough, in the remainder of this proof. Now, we fix t\geq 0 and B\subseteq I^{c} , and recall that our goal is to study the probability of the event A(\eta,\bm{x})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\big\{C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})>t,\ \bm{X}^{\eta}_{\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\big\}. Here, note that \lambda(\eta)=\eta^{-1}H(\eta^{-1}) and hence \eta\cdot\lambda(\eta)=H(\eta^{-1}) . Also, henceforth in the proof we only consider b large enough such that C^{I}_{\infty}=C^{I}_{b}; see ( 6.3 ). We focus on the case where C^{I}_{\infty}>0 , but we stress that the proof for the case with C^{I}_{\infty}=0 is almost identical. First, we arbitrarily pick some T>t and observe that \displaystyle A(\eta,\bm{x}) \displaystyle=\underbrace{\Big\{C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})\in(t,T],\ \bm{X}^{\eta}_{\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\Big\}}_{\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.06946pt\hskip-3.06946pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.06946pt\hskip-1.45833pt\raisebox{3.68855pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-1.45833pt\hskip 3.06946pt}}A_{1}(\eta,\bm{x},T)}\cup\underbrace{\Big\{C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})>T,\ \bm{X}^{\eta}_{\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\Big\}}_{\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.06946pt\hskip-3.06946pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.06946pt\hskip-1.45833pt\raisebox{3.68855pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-1.45833pt\hskip 3.06946pt}}A_{2}(\eta,\bm{x},T)}. (6.7) Let E_{b}(\eta,T)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\big\{\eta\left\lVert\bm{Z}_{j}\right\rVert\leq\frac{b}{2C}\ \forall j\leq\frac{T}{C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})}\big\} and note that A_{1}(\eta,\bm{x},T)=\Big(A_{1}(\eta,\bm{x},T)\cap E_{b}(\eta,T)\Big)\cup\Big(A_{1}(\eta,\bm{x},T)\setminus E_{b}(\eta,T)\Big). Moreover, for all \eta\in(0,\frac{b}{2C}) , \displaystyle\mathbf{P}\Big(A_{1}(\eta,\bm{x},T)\cap E_{b}(\eta,T)\Big) \displaystyle=\mathbf{P}\bigg(\Big\{C^{I}_{b}\eta\cdot\lambda(\eta)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})\in(t,T],\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\Big\}\cap E_{b}(\eta,T)\bigg)\qquad\text{due to \eqref{proof, observation 1, theorem: first exit time, unclipped} and \eqref{proof, observation 2, theorem: first exit time, unclipped}} \displaystyle\leq\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{b}\eta\cdot\lambda(\eta)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})\in(t,T],\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle=\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{b}\eta\cdot\lambda(\eta)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})>t,\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg)-\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{b}\eta\cdot\lambda(\eta)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})>T,\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg). By Theorem 3.1 and claim ( 6.3 ), we get \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\Big(A_{1}(\eta,\bm{x},T)\cap E_{b}(\eta,T)\Big)\leq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(1)|b}(B^{-})}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\exp(-t)-\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(1)|b}(B^{\circ})}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\exp(-T). (6.8) Meanwhile, \sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\big(A_{1}(\eta,\bm{x},T)\setminus E_{b}(\eta,T)\big)\leq\mathbf{P}\big((E_{b}(\eta,T))^{c}\big)=\mathbf{P}\bigg(\eta\left\lVert\bm{Z}_{j}\right\rVert>\frac{b}{2C}\text{ for some }j\leq\frac{T}{C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})}\bigg). Applying Lemma 6.1 , we get (recall that H(\cdot)=\mathbf{P}(\left\lVert\bm{Z}_{j}\right\rVert>\cdot) and H(x)\in\mathcal{RV}_{-\alpha}(x) as x\to\infty ) \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\mathbf{P}\bigg(\eta\left\lVert\bm{Z}_{j}\right\rVert>\frac{b}{2C}\text{ for some }j\leq\frac{T}{C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})}\bigg) \displaystyle=1-\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\mathbf{P}\bigg(\text{Geom}\Big(H\big(\frac{b}{\eta\cdot 2C}\big)\Big)>\frac{T}{C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})}\bigg) \displaystyle\leq 1-\lim_{\eta\downarrow 0}\exp\bigg(-\frac{T\cdot H(\eta^{-1}\cdot\frac{b}{2C})}{C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})}\bigg) \displaystyle=1-\exp\bigg(-\frac{T}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\Big(\frac{2C}{b}\Big)^{\alpha}\bigg). (6.9) Similarly, \displaystyle A_{2}(\eta,\bm{x},T) \displaystyle\subseteq\Big\{C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})>T\Big\} \displaystyle=\bigg(\Big\{C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})>T\Big\}\cap E_{b}(\eta,T)\bigg)\cup\bigg(\Big\{C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})>T\Big\}\setminus E_{b}(\eta,T)\bigg). On \{C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})>T\}\cap E_{b}(\eta,T) , we have \tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})=\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}) again due to ( 6.2 ). By Theorem 3.1 and ( 6.3 ), we get \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(\Big\{C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})>T\Big\}\cap E_{b}(\eta,T)\bigg) \displaystyle\leq\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\Big(C^{I}_{b}\eta\cdot\lambda(\eta)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})>T\Big)\leq\exp(-T). (6.10) Meanwhile, the limit of \sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\big(C^{I}_{\infty}H(\eta^{-1})\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})>T\}\setminus E_{b}(\eta,T)\big) as \eta\downarrow 0 is again bounded by ( 6.9 ). Collecting ( 6.8 ), ( 6.9 ), and ( 6.10 ), we yield that for all b>0 large enough and all T>t , \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\big(A(\eta,\bm{x})\big) \displaystyle\leq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(1)|b}(B^{-})}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\exp(-t)-\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(1)|b}(B^{\circ})}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\exp(-T)+\exp(-T)+2\cdot\bigg[1-\exp\bigg(-\frac{T}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\Big(\frac{2C}{b}\Big)^{\alpha}\bigg)\bigg]. In light of claim ( 6.5 ), we send b\to\infty and T\to\infty to conclude the proof of the upper bound. The lower bound can be established analogously. By the decomposition of events in ( 6.7 ), \displaystyle\inf_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\big(A(\eta,\bm{x})\big) \displaystyle\geq\inf_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\big(A_{1}(\eta,\bm{x},T)\big)\geq\inf_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\big(A_{1}(\eta,\bm{x},T)\cap E_{b}(\eta,T)\big) \displaystyle=\inf_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(\Big\{C^{I}_{b}\eta\cdot\lambda(\eta)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})\in(t,T],\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\Big\}\cap E_{b}(\eta,T)\bigg)\qquad\text{due to \eqref{proof, observation 1, theorem: first exit time, unclipped} and \eqref{proof, observation 2, theorem: first exit time, unclipped}} \displaystyle\geq\inf_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{b}\eta\cdot\lambda(\eta)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})\in(t,T],\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg)-\mathbf{P}\Big(\big(E_{b}(\eta,T)\big)^{c}\Big) \displaystyle\geq\inf_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{b}\eta\cdot\lambda(\eta)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})>t,\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg)-\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{b}\eta\cdot\lambda(\eta)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})>T,\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle\qquad\qquad-\mathbf{P}\Big(\big(E_{b}(\eta,T)\big)^{c}\Big). By Theorem 3.1 and the limit in ( 6.9 ), we yield (for all b>0 large enough and all T>t ) \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\Big(A(\eta,\bm{x})\Big) \displaystyle\leq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(1)|b}(B^{\circ})}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\exp(-t)-\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(1)|b}(B^{-})}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\exp(-T)-\bigg[1-\exp\bigg(-\frac{T}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\Big(\frac{2C}{b}\Big)^{\alpha}\bigg)\bigg]. By claim ( 6.5 ), we send b\to\infty and T\to\infty to conclude the proof of the lower bound. ∎ To conclude, we provide the proof of Lemma 5.3 . Appendix A Results under General Scaling Below, we present results analogous to those in Section 3 under a general scaling. Specifically, throughout this section we define \displaystyle\bm{X}^{\eta}_{t}(\bm{x})=\bm{X}^{\eta}_{t-1}(\bm{x})+\eta\bm{a}\big(\bm{X}^{\eta}_{t-1}(\bm{x})\big)+\eta^{\gamma}\bm{\sigma}\big(\bm{X}^{\eta}_{t-1}(\bm{x})\big)\bm{Z}_{t},\quad\forall t\geq 1, (A.1) \displaystyle{\displaystyle\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x})}=\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t-1}(\bm{x})+\varphi_{b}\Big(\eta\bm{a}\big(\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t-1}(\bm{x})\big)+\eta^{\gamma}\bm{\sigma}\big(\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{t-1}(\bm{x})\big)\bm{Z}_{t}\Big),\quad\forall t\geq 1, with \gamma\in(\frac{1}{2\wedge\alpha},\infty) , where \alpha>1 is the heavy-tailed index in Assumption 1 . Let \displaystyle\lambda(\eta;\gamma)=\eta^{-1}H(\eta^{-\gamma}). We adopt the notations \mathbf{C}^{(k)|b}_{[0,T]}, \mathbb{D}^{(k)|b}_{A}[0,T](\epsilon), {\bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{[0,T]}(\bm{x})}, etc., introduced in the main paper. Let I\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{m} be an open set such that \bm{0}\in\bm{I} and Assumption 3 holds. Let the first exit times \tau^{\eta}(\bm{x}) and \tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x}) be defined as in ( 3.2 ). We adopt the notations \mathcal{J}^{I}_{b} , \mathcal{G}^{(k)|b}(\epsilon) , \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{k|b} , etc., introduced in Section 3.1 . Theorem A.1 . Let Assumptions 1 , 2 , and 3 hold. Let \gamma\in(\frac{1}{2\wedge\alpha},\infty) . 1. Let b>0 . Suppose that \mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}<\infty , I^{c} is bounded away from \mathcal{G}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\epsilon) for some (and hence all) \epsilon>0 small enough, and \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(\partial I)=0. Then {C^{I}_{b}}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(I^{c})<\infty . Furthermore, if C^{I}_{b}\in(0,\infty) , then for any \epsilon>0 , t\geq 0 , and measurable set B\subseteq I^{c} , \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{b}\eta\cdot\lambda^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(\eta;\gamma)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})>t;\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle\leq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B^{-})}{C^{I}_{b}}\cdot\exp(-t), \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{b}\eta\cdot\lambda^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(\eta;\gamma)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})>t;\ \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle\geq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B^{\circ})}{C^{I}_{b}}\cdot\exp(-t). Otherwise, we have C^{I}_{b}=0 , and \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(\eta\cdot\lambda^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}(\eta;\gamma)\tau^{\eta|b}(\bm{x})\leq t\bigg)=0\qquad\forall\epsilon>0,\ t\geq 0. 2. Suppose that \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(\partial I)=0 . Then {C^{I}_{\infty}}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(I^{c})<\infty . Furthermore, if C^{I}_{\infty}>0 , then for any t\geq 0 and measurable set B\subseteq I^{c} , \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{\infty}\eta\cdot\lambda(\eta;\gamma)\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})>t;\ \bm{X}^{\eta}_{\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle\leq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(B^{-})}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\exp(-t), \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{\infty}\eta\cdot\lambda(\eta;\gamma)\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})>t;\ \bm{X}^{\eta}_{\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle\geq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(B^{\circ})}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\exp(-t). Otherwise, we have C^{I}_{\infty}=0 , and \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(\eta\cdot\lambda(\eta;\gamma)\tau^{\eta}(\bm{x})\leq t\bigg)=0\qquad\forall\epsilon>0,\ t\geq 0. The proofs for results in this section will be almost identical to those presented in the main paper. We omit the details to avoid repetition. Appendix B Results for Lévy-Driven Stochastic Differential Equations In this section, we collect the results for stochastic differential equations driven by Lévy processes with regularly varying increments. Specifically, any multidimensional Lévy process \bm{L}=\{\bm{L}_{t}:\ t\geq 0\} can be characterized by its generating triplet (\bm{c}_{\bm{L}},\bm{\Sigma}_{\bm{L}},\nu) where \bm{c}_{\bm{L}}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} is the drift parameter, the positive semi-definite matrix \bm{\Sigma}_{\bm{L}}\in\mathbb{R}^{m\times m} is the magnitude of the Brownian motion term in \bm{L}_{t} , and \nu is the Lévy measure characterizing the intensity of jumps in \bm{L}_{t} . More precisely, we have the following Lévy–Itô decomposition \displaystyle\bm{L}_{t}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.08144pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle d$}}\hskip-2.08144pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\bm{c}_{\bm{L}}t+\bm{\Sigma}_{\bm{L}}^{1/2}\bm{B}_{t}+\int_{\left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert\leq 1}\bm{x}\big[N([0,t]\times d\bm{x})-t\nu(dx)\big]+\int_{\left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert>1}\bm{x}N([0,t]\times d\bm{x}) (B.1) where \bm{B}_{t} is a standard Brownian motion in \mathbb{R}^{m} , the measure \nu satisfies \int(\left\lVert\bm{x}\right\rVert^{2}\wedge 1)\nu(d\bm{x})<\infty , and N is a Poisson random measure independent of \bm{B}_{t} with intensity measure \mathcal{L}_{\infty}\times\nu . See Chapter 4 of [ 51 ] for details. We impose the following heavy-tailed assumption on the increments of \bm{L}_{t} . Assumption 5 . \mathbf{E}\bm{L}_{1}=\bm{0} . Besides, there exist \alpha>1 and a probability measure \mathbf{S}(\cdot) on the unit sphere of \mathbb{R}^{d} such that • H_{L}(x)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\nu\Big(\big\{\bm{y}\in\mathbb{R}^{d}:\ \left\lVert\bm{y}\right\rVert>x\big\}\Big)\in\mathcal{RV}_{-\alpha}(x) as x\to\infty , • As r\to\infty , \displaystyle\frac{\big(\nu\circ\Phi^{-1}_{r}\big)(\cdot)}{H_{L}(r)}\xrightarrow{v}\nu_{\alpha}\times\mathbf{S}, where \mathfrak{N}_{d} is the unit sphere of \mathbb{R}^{d} , the measure \nu_{\alpha} is defined in ( 2.2 ), and \displaystyle\big(\nu\circ\Phi^{-1}_{r}\big)(\cdot)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\nu\Big(\Phi^{-1}(r\cdot\ ,\ \cdot)\Big), i.e. \big(\nu\circ\Phi^{-1}_{r}\big)(A\times B)=\nu\big(\Phi^{-1}(rA,B)\big) for all Borel sets A\subseteq(0,\infty) and B\subseteq\mathfrak{N}_{d} . Consider a filtered probability space \big(\Omega,\mathcal{F},\mathbb{F}=(\mathcal{F}_{t})_{t\geq 0},\mathbf{P}\big) satisfying the usual hypotheses stated in Chapter I, [ 46 ] and supporting the Lévy process \bm{L} , where \mathcal{F}_{0}=\{\emptyset,\Omega\} and \mathcal{F}_{t} is the \sigma -algebra generated by \{\bm{L}_{s}:s\in[0,t]\} . For \eta\in(0,1] and \beta\geq 0 , define the scaled process \displaystyle{\bar{\bm{L}}^{\eta}}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\big\{\bar{\bm{L}}^{\eta}_{t}=\eta\bm{L}_{t/\eta^{\beta}}:\ t\geq 0\big\}, (B.2) and let \bm{Y}^{\eta}_{t}(\bm{x}) be the solution to SDE \displaystyle\bm{Y}^{\eta}_{0}(\bm{x})=\bm{x},\qquad d\bm{Y}^{\eta}_{t}(\bm{x})=\bm{a}\big(\bm{Y}^{\eta}_{t-}(\bm{x})\big)dt+\bm{\sigma}\big(\bm{Y}^{\eta}_{t-}(\bm{x})\big)d\bar{\bm{L}}^{\eta}_{t}. (B.3) Henceforth in Section B , we consider \beta\in[0,2\wedge\alpha) where \alpha>1 is the tail index in Assumption 5 . Let \displaystyle\lambda_{L}(\eta;\beta)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\eta^{-\beta}H_{L}(\eta^{-1}) and \lambda^{k}_{L}(\eta;\beta)=\big(\lambda_{L}(\eta;\beta)\big)^{k}, where \beta\in[0,2\wedge\alpha) determines the time scaling in ( B.2 ). Analogous to the truncated dynamics \bm{X}^{\eta|b}_{j}(\bm{x}) , we introduce a truncated variation {\bm{Y}}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x}) where all jumps are truncated under the threshold value b . More generally, we consider a sequence of stochastic processes \big(\bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(k)}_{t}(\bm{x})\big)_{k\geq 0} . First, for any \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} and t\geq 0 , let \displaystyle d{\bm{Y}}^{\eta|b;(0)}_{t}(\bm{x})=\bm{a}\big({\bm{Y}}^{\eta|b;(0)}_{t-}(\bm{x})\big)dt+\bm{\sigma}\big(\bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(0)}_{t-}(\bm{x})\big)d\bar{\bm{L}}_{t} (B.4) under initial condition {\bm{Y}}^{\eta|b;(0)}_{0}(\bm{x})=\bm{x} . Next, we define \displaystyle\tau^{\eta|b;(1)}_{Y}(\bm{x}) \displaystyle\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\inf\Big\{t>0:\left\lVert\bm{\sigma}\big(\bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(0)}_{t-}(\bm{x})\big)\Delta\bar{\bm{L}}^{\eta}_{t}\right\rVert>b\Big\}, (B.5) \displaystyle\bm{W}^{\eta|b;(1)}_{Y}(\bm{x}) \displaystyle\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\Delta\bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(0)}_{\tau^{\eta|b;(1)}_{Y}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x}) (B.6) as the arrival time and size of the first jump in \bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(0)}_{t}(\bm{x}) with L_{2} norm larger than b . Furthermore, we define (for any k\geq 1 ) \displaystyle{\bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(k)}_{\tau^{\eta|b;(k)}_{Y}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})} \displaystyle\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(k)}_{\tau^{\eta|b;(k)}_{Y}(\bm{x})-}(\bm{x})+\varphi_{b}\Big(\bm{W}^{\eta|b;(k)}_{Y}(\bm{x})\Big), (B.7) \displaystyle d{\bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(k)}_{t}(\bm{x})} \displaystyle\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\bm{a}\big(\bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(k)}_{t-}(\bm{x})\big)dt+\bm{\sigma}\big(\bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(k)}_{t-}(\bm{x})\big)d\bar{\bm{L}}^{\eta}_{t}\qquad\forall t>\tau^{\eta|b;(k)}_{Y}(\bm{x}), (B.8) \displaystyle{\tau^{\eta|b;(k+1)}_{Y}(\bm{x})} \displaystyle\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\min\Big\{t>\tau^{\eta|b;(k)}_{Y}(\bm{x}):\left\lVert\sigma\big(\bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(k)}_{t-}(\bm{x})\big)\Delta{\bar{\bm{L}}}^{\eta}_{t}\right\rVert>b\Big\}, (B.9) \displaystyle{\bm{W}^{\eta|b;(k+1)}_{Y}(\bm{x})} \displaystyle\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\Delta\bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(k)}_{\tau^{\eta|b;(k+1)}_{Y}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x}) (B.10) Lastly, for any t\geq 0,\ b>0,\ k\in\mathbb{N} and \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} , we define (under convention \tau^{\eta|b;(0)}_{Y}(\bm{x})=0 ) \displaystyle\bm{Y}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x})\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\sum_{k\geq 0}\bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(k)}_{t}(\bm{x})\cdot\mathbbm{I}\Big\{t\in\Big[\tau^{\eta|b;(k)}_{Y}(\bm{x}),\tau^{\eta|b;(k+1)}_{Y}(\bm{x})\Big)\Big\} (B.11) and let \bm{Y}^{\eta|b}_{[0,T]}(x)\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\big\{\bm{Y}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x}):\ t\in[0,T]\big\} . By definition, for any t\geq 0,\ b>0,\ k\in\mathbb{N} and \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{m} , \displaystyle{\bm{Y}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x})}=\bm{Y}^{\eta|b;(k)}_{t}(\bm{x})\qquad\Longleftrightarrow\qquad t\in\Big[\tau^{\eta|b;(k)}_{Y}(\bm{x}),\tau^{\eta|b;(k+1)}_{Y}(\bm{x})\Big). (B.12) Consider an open set I\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{m} such that \bm{0}\in\bm{I} and Assumption 3 holds. Define stopping times \displaystyle{\tau^{\eta}_{Y}(\bm{x})}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\inf\big\{t\geq 0:\ \bm{Y}^{\eta}_{t}(\bm{x})\notin I\big\},\qquad{\tau^{\eta|b}_{Y}(\bm{x})}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\inf\big\{t\geq 0:\ \bm{Y}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x})\notin I\big\} as the first exit times of \bm{Y}^{\eta}_{t}(\bm{x}) and \bm{Y}^{\eta|b}_{t}(\bm{x}) from I , respectively. The following result characterizes the asymptotic law of the first exit times and exit locations, using the measures {\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(k)|b}(\cdot)} defined in ( 3.8 ) and {\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(\cdot)} defined in ( 3.9 ). We omit the proof due to its similarity to that of Theorem 3.1 . Theorem B.1 . Let Assumptions 2 , 3 , and 5 hold. Let \beta\in[0,2\wedge\alpha) . 1. Let b>0 . Suppose that \mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}<\infty , I^{c} is bounded away from \mathcal{G}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}-1)|b}(\epsilon) for some (and hence all) \epsilon>0 small enough, and \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(\partial I)=0. Then {C^{I}_{b}}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(I^{c})<\infty . Furthermore, if C^{I}_{b}\in(0,\infty) , then for any \epsilon>0 , t\geq 0 , and measurable set B\subseteq I^{c} , \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{b}\lambda^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}_{L}(\eta;\beta)\tau^{\eta|b}_{Y}(\bm{x})>t;\ \bm{Y}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}_{Y}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle\leq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B^{-})}{C^{I}_{b}}\cdot\exp(-t), \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{b}\lambda^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}_{L}(\eta;\beta)\tau^{\eta|b}_{Y}(\bm{x})>t;\ \bm{Y}^{\eta|b}_{\tau^{\eta|b}_{Y}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle\geq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}^{(\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b})|b}(B^{\circ})}{C^{I}_{b}}\cdot\exp(-t). Otherwise, we have C^{I}_{b}=0 , and \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(\lambda^{\mathcal{J}^{I}_{b}}_{L}(\eta;\gamma)\tau^{\eta|b}_{Y}(\bm{x})\leq t\bigg)=0\qquad\forall\epsilon>0,\ t\geq 0. 2. Suppose that \widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(\partial I)=0 . Then {C^{I}_{\infty}}\mathrel{\hbox{\hskip 3.8889pt\hskip-3.8889pt\hbox{$=$}\hskip-3.8889pt\hskip-2.7431pt\raisebox{4.66875pt}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\Delta$}}\hskip-2.7431pt\hskip 3.8889pt}}\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(I^{c})<\infty . Furthermore, if C^{I}_{\infty}>0 , then for any t\geq 0 and measurable set B\subseteq I^{c} , \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{\infty}\lambda_{L}(\eta;\beta)\tau^{\eta}_{Y}(\bm{x})>t;\ \bm{Y}^{\eta}_{\tau^{\eta}_{Y}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle\leq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(B^{-})}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\exp(-t), \displaystyle\liminf_{\eta\downarrow 0}\inf_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(C^{I}_{\infty}\lambda_{L}(\eta;\beta)\tau^{\eta}_{Y}(\bm{x})>t;\ \bm{Y}^{\eta}_{\tau^{\eta}_{Y}(\bm{x})}(\bm{x})\in B\bigg) \displaystyle\geq\frac{\widecheck{\mathbf{C}}(B^{\circ})}{C^{I}_{\infty}}\cdot\exp(-t). Otherwise, we have C^{I}_{\infty}=0 , and \displaystyle\limsup_{\eta\downarrow 0}\sup_{\bm{x}\in I_{\epsilon}}\mathbf{P}\bigg(\lambda(_{L}\eta;\gamma)\tau^{\eta}_{Y}(\bm{x})\leq t\bigg)=0\qquad\forall\epsilon>0,\ t\geq 0.