Hom-unitality and hom-associative structures Germán García Butenegro, Abdennour Kitouni, Sergei Silvestrov Abstract We study hom-associative structures on general, possibly non-associative algebras, focusing on one-sided and two-sided unital algebras. New characterizations and aspects of these structures, along with some important subclasses, are explored for non-associative algebras. By exploiting the observation that the twisting linear map in the hom-associativity axiom of one-sided unital hom-associative algebras is a left or right multiplication operator by an element of the algebra (obtained by the action of the twisting map on a corresponding one-sided unity), a new characterization of the multiplicative twisting operators (or, in other words, the multiplicative hom-associative algebras) is established for one-sided unital algebras. This demonstrates a strong connection between multiplicativity in hom-associative structures and the idempotents of the algebra, thereby further enhancing our understanding of the structure and special nature of multiplicative hom-associative algebra structures as a special subclass of arbitrary hom-associative structures with arbitrary linear twisting maps. Furthermore, new insights into subspaces and a subalgebra of hom-unities, algebra elements that induce hom-associativity by multiplication, are obtained. Moreover, since non-unital hom-associative algebras need not be twisted by a multiplication operator, a unitalization process is employed to describe a subalgebra of two-sided hom-unities that induce hom-associative structures on such algebras. This is formulated in terms of eigenspaces of multiplication operators within the algebra. Additionally, the obtained insights and general results about the structure and characterization of hom-algebra structures are applied to some important known general classes of non-associative algebras, such as commutative, possibly non-associative algebras, Cayley-Dickson algebras, Leibniz algebras, and hom-Leibniz algebras. Keywords : hom-associative algebras, unity, hom-unity MSC2020 : 17D30, 17B61, 17A30, 17A35 1 Introduction Hom-algebra structures provide a unified framework for the joint study of seemingly unrelated classes of algebraic structures by relating their defining axioms through linear twisting maps (unary operations) that deform these axioms in specific, non-trivial ways. Such deformations establish connections between the axioms of various related but distinct known and new classes of algebraic structures, enabling their simultaneous consideration and classification, and uncovering common or distinct properties and relationships between their substructures and morphisms. In particular, hom-algebra structures of a given type include their classical non-twisted counterparts for special choices of twisting maps in the defining identities, and they create additional opportunities for deformations, extensions of cohomological structures, and representations. Over the last two decades, following the pioneering works [ 10 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 17 , 18 ] , hom-algebra structures have evolved into a broad and fruitful area of mathematics, exhibiting numerous connections to fundamental non-commutative and non-associative structures and concepts in non-commutative geometry, as well as offering possibilities for a unified treatment and applications to models in mathematical physics based on various important non-commutative or potentially non-associative structures. The area of hom-algebra structures originated with the work of Hartwig, Larsson, and Silvestrov [ 10 ] in 2003, where general hom-Lie algebras and the more general quasi-hom-Lie algebras were introduced, together with a general method for constructing quasi-deformations of Witt and Virasoro algebras based on the discretization of vector fields via twisted derivations ( \sigma -derivations). This approach was motivated by discrete modifications of differential calculi and the q -deformed Jacobi identities observed for specific q -deformed algebras and their representations in physics, as well as in q -deformed differential calculi and homological algebra. Following [ 10 ] , Larsson and Silvestrov carried out a systematic study of central extensions of quasi-hom-Lie algebras in [ 12 ] , first appearing in 2004. At the same time, Larsson and Silvestrov introduced more general quasi-Lie algebras and quasi-Leibniz algebras in [ 13 ] (2004), and general color quasi-Lie algebras ( \Gamma -graded \epsilon -quasi-Lie algebras) in [ 14 ] (2005), including color quasi-hom-Lie algebras and color hom-Lie algebras, quasi-Lie superalgebras, quasi-hom-Lie superalgebras, hom-Lie superalgebras, and hom-Lie algebras. Sigurdsson and Silvestrov continued this work in [ 23 ] (2006) and [ 22 ] (2009), where color quasi-Lie algebras of Witt type and their central extensions were studied. In a further fundamental development, important hom-Lie admissible algebras were discovered by Makhlouf and Silvestrov in [ 17 ] (2006). In particular, [ 17 ] introduced hom-associative algebras and showed that they are hom-Lie admissible, meaning they yield hom-Lie algebras via the commutator map as a new product, thus constituting a natural generalization of associative algebras as Lie-admissible algebras leading to Lie algebras through the commutator map. Moreover, [ 17 ] described several other interesting classes of hom-Lie admissible algebras extending certain non-associative algebras to more general hom-algebra counterparts, as well as examples of finite-dimensional hom-Lie algebras. In [ 18 ] (2007), the study of formal deformations and cohomology of hom-algebras was initiated, giving rise to numerous significant developments in cohomology and formal deformation theory for various hom-algebra structures over the past two decades. Hom-associative algebras, introduced in [ 17 ] , are the first example of hom-Lie admissible algebras, where the commutator induces a hom-Lie algebra. They have been extensively studied, including deformations, extensions, and Hochschild cohomology in the multiplicative case [ 18 , 9 , 11 , 2 ] , as well as low-dimensional classifications [ 19 ] . The main construction method is twisting the product of an associative algebra by an algebra homomorphism [ 24 ] , a process applicable to various algebraic structures, including alternative and Jordan algebras [ 16 ] . While many hom-associative algebras arise from twists, non-twist examples exist even in dimension three [ 19 , 8 ] . Other notable constructions leading to many non-twist examples include hom-association process and hom-associative Ore extensions [ 3 , 4 ] . Hom-algebras in which the twisting map is an algebra homomorphism are called multiplicative . Hom-algebras from this special subclass possesses many additional cohomological and divisibility properties [ 24 , 1 , 2 , 16 , 7 ] , and the hom-associative ones are classified in low dimension [ 19 ] . Numerous examples of hom-algebras are multiplicative, as they can be constructed by twisting [ 24 ] or by employing algebra morphisms in other ways [ 3 , 4 ] . While not strictly necessary, multiplicativity often facilitates the study of cohomology and representations [ 1 , 2 , 16 ] . At the same time, multiplicative hom-algebras form a rather special subclass of hom-algebras, as in general multiplicativity turns out to be quite restrictive condition. Any insight into role and consequences of multiplicativity or non-multiplicativity of various classes of hom-algebra structures and the classifications or characterizations of multiplicative or non-multiplicative algebra structures is one of the important fundamental problems in investigation, classifications, constructions and applications of various hom-algebra structures. It is deeply concerned with the interplay of multiplicativity of the twisting maps with the defining axioms of the class of hom-algebra structures viewed as special type of deformations or mutations of axioms of the original (untwisted) class of algebras. Unitality in hom-associative algebras [ 5 , 6 ] can be seen as strengthening hom-associativity so that it implies, or nearly implies, classical associativity [ 5 ] . This observation motivates the introduction of hom-unities [ 6 ] , also referred to as weak unities [ 4 , 3 ] , which are elements \omega satisfying the hom-unitality condition \omega\cdot x=\alpha(x) . Hom-algebras equipped with a hom-unity have previously been called unital [ 17 , 19 ] or weakly unital [ 4 , 5 ] . For consistency with our previous work [ 8 ] , we adopt the terminology hom-unital , interpreting the prefix “hom-X” as indicating that the axiom X is modified by a twisting map. The notion of a hom-unity provides a weakened form of unitality adapted to the twisted setting of hom-algebras. While classical unitality ensures that multiplication interacts with the identity element in a strict way, hom-unitality relaxes this requirement by incorporating the twisting map, making it compatible with the hom-associative structure. Hom-unities play an important role in the structural analysis and construction of hom-associative algebras. They often arise naturally in deformation processes, where classical identities are replaced by twisted analogues to maintain consistency with the underlying hom-structure. For example, in Ore-type extensions and hom-analogues of Weyl algebras [ 4 , 3 ] , the existence of a hom-unity ensures that the extended algebra retains a generalized identity element compatible with the twisting map. Similarly, in classification results for hom-associative algebras [ 19 ] , hom-unities provide a useful criterion for distinguishing between strongly twisted and weakly twisted structures. Beyond theoretical interest, these constructions have applications in quantum deformations and non-commutative geometry, where hom-type identities model symmetries that are no longer strictly associative but remain coherent under twisting. The goal of this article is to study in-depth the connection between unitality and hom-unitality in arbitrary algebras and establish hom-associativity conditions in terms of one-sided (hom-)unities and multiplication operators within the algebra. The constructions and results of this article aim to approach this problem in full generality of arbitrary non-associative algebras. We generalize associativity conditions for hom-associative algebras established by Frégier, Gohr and Silvestrov [ 6 ] . In that paper, associativity conditions are derived from two-sided unitality. We provide conditions for left- and right-unital algebras which imply those in [ 6 ] in the two-sided unital case. Frégier and Gohr [ 5 ] use nucleus and ideals to describe a subalgebra of a given two-sided unital algebra which encodes all hom-associative structures of the algebra. We describe this subalgebra explicitly in terms of commutation, association and zero division relations, that is, via center, nucleus and annihilators. We extend their results to one-sided unital algebras by describing a subspace of one-sided multiplication operators which contains a subalgebra encoding all hom-associative structures of a given one-sided unital algebra. Furthermore, we examine the problem in non-unital algebras by describing a subspace encoding hom-associative structures given by multiplication operators, and use a unitalization process to describe a subalgebra encoding hom-associative structures given by multiplication by central elements. Section 2 introduces hom-associative and unital algebras, together with the notations and conventions assumed across this article. Section 3 studies properties of the twisting map that are extracted from the unitality axiom, including that it must be a multiplication operator; Section 3.1 studies the relation between associator and hom-associator of these algebras and establishes rules for invariance of relative nuclei in terms of the unity ( Proposition 15 ); in Section 3.2 we show that any appropriate (or compatible ) twisting map is multiplicative if and only if the multiplier (or hom-unity ) is idempotent ( Theorem 16 ). In two-sided unital algebras, Frégier and Gohr [ 5 ] prove that the multipliers of all compatible maps form a subalgebra; in Section 4 , we compute it explicitly in terms of center, nucleus and annihilators of the algebra ( Theorem 24 ). We illustrate this by computing hom-associative structures in the first Cayley-Dickson algebras. Section 5 explores characterization of hom-associative structures in one-sided unital algebras. We describe the multipliers of compatible maps as sum of an element commuting with the unity and a global zero divisor ( Theorem 34 ). We prove that the subspace of all multipliers contains a subalgebra ( Theorem 43 ) consisting of those multipliers commuting with the unity. This subalgebra is then shown to be in bijection with all compatible maps, and a subset is described, consisting of the idempotents of this subalgebra, which encodes those compatible maps that are also multiplicative ( Theorem 38 ). Relations between hom-unities are expressed in terms of commutation, association, and zero division ( Lemma 40 ) and used to prove that there are no unital hom-associative domains nor division algebras ( Theorem 47 ). In Section 5.3 we examine this construction in terms of the two-sided version by Frégier and Gohr [ 5 ] and explore hom-associative structures in one-sided unital hom-Leibniz algebras. In particular, it turns out that, in the presence of hom-associativity, a unity on one side is incompatible with the hom-Leibniz identity on the same side, but compatible with that on the other side ( Proposition 59 ). In Section 6 , we describe different subspaces of hom-unities for non-unital ( Proposition 60 ) and show that, under certain zero division relations, associative algebras are hom-associative with twisting map given by multiplication by central elements ( Proposition 64 ). In Section 6.1 , we use a standard unitalization process to describe a subspace of two-sided hom-unities in any non-unital algebra. We illustrate this idea on Leibniz algebras and find a subspace of hom-unities hidden within the nilpotents of the algebra ( Proposition 73 ); furthermore, we examine non-unital hom-Leibniz algebras, where we prove that a certain twist yields a hom-Lie algebra ( Proposition 75 ). 2 Basic notions, notations and conventions An algebra over a field \mathbb{F} is a linear space A over \mathbb{F} with a bilinear multiplication operation called a product or multiplication. The notations for the products, such as \mu\colon A\times A\rightarrow A , (x,y)\mapsto x\cdot y , often simplified to juxtaposition xy when no confusion arise. The algebra is associative if x\cdot(y\cdot z)=(x\cdot y)\cdot z for all x,y,z\in A , and it is commutative if x\cdot y=y\cdot x for all x,y\in A . If no confusion is possible, we identify the algebra with the associated linear space A . An element e\in A is idempotent if e\cdot e=e . The set of all idempotents is denoted E(A) . Commuting elements in non-commutative algebras are studied in terms of commutators. The commutator is the bilinear operator on an algebra A defined by [x,y]_{-}=x\cdot y-y\cdot x . Algebras where the commutator is always 0 are commutative . The zeroes of the commutator indicate how wide the commutativity relation is in an algebra or a certain subset of it: the center Z(A)=\{a\mid[a,x]_{-}=0\ \forall x\in A\} of an algebra A is the subspace of elements of A that commute with all its elements, and generally, the centralizer of a subset S\subseteq A is the subspace of elements of A that commute with all elements of S , that is, [a,s]_{-}=0 for all s\in S. In any algebra, the commutator map [,]_{-}:A\times A\rightarrow A is bilinear and skew-symmetric, [x,y]_{-}=-[x,y]_{-} , and hence the underlying linear space of any algebra is a skew-symmetric algebra with the commutator map as the new product. In general, for non-associative algebras, it is a rare and highly restrictive condition for the commutator operation to be associative on the whole algebra. For example, in any Lie algebra (A,[\cdot,\cdot]) , by skew-symmetry of [\cdot,\cdot] , the Jacobi identity can be rewritten as [[x,y],z]-[x,[y,z]]=[[x,z],y] , implying thus that (A,[\cdot,\cdot]) is associative if and only if [A,A]\subseteq Ann_{A}(A)=\{a\mid[a,x]=[x,a]=0\ \forall x\in A\} , that is, if and only if (A,[\cdot,\cdot]) is a nilpotent algebra of degree 3 meaning that the products of any three elements are zero, since [A,A]\subseteq Ann_{A}(A)\Leftrightarrow[[A,A],A]=0,\ [A,[A,A]]=0 by skew-symmetry of [\cdot,\cdot] . This shows that, for Lie algebras, as a class of not necessarily associative algebras, associativity is indeed a rare and highly restrictive condition. The annihilators of a subset S\subseteq A are the subspaces Ann_{A}^{l}(S)=\{a\in A\mid a\cdot s=0\ \forall s\in S\} (left annihilator) and Ann_{A}^{r}(S)=\{a\in A\mid s\cdot a=0\ \forall s\in S\} (right annihilator), and the subspace Ann_{A}(A) is known as annihilator of A . Note that in any skew-symmetric algebra (A,[\cdot,\cdot]) , [x,y]_{-}=[x,y]-[y,x]=[x,y]+[x,y]=2[x,y] by skew-symmetry, and hence [x,y]_{-}=0\Leftrightarrow[x,y]=0 , that is, Ann_{A}(A)=Z(A) in any skew-symmetric algebra over a field of characteristic different from 2 . The commutator is often seen as the simplest example of a not necessarily associative bilinear product on associative algebras. The commutator product on any associative algebra (A,\cdot) not only satisfies skew-symmetry but also obeys the Jacobi identity [x,[y,z]_{-}]_{-}+[y,[z,x]_{-}]_{-}+[z,[x,y]_{-}]_{-}=0 for all x,y,z\in A , yielding thus a Lie algebra (A,[\cdot,\cdot]_{-}) . This Lie algebra is associative if and only if it is nilpotent of degree 3 , meaning that [[A,A]_{-},A]_{-}=0,\ [A_{-},[A,A]_{-}]_{-}=0 , which is equivalent to [x,[y,z]_{-}]_{-}=x\cdot y\cdot z-y\cdot x\cdot z-z\cdot x\cdot y+z\cdot y\cdot x=0 holding for all x,y,z\in A . This identity holds for all commutative associative algebras, but is clearly quite a restrictive for non-commutative associative algebras, singling out a special subclass of non-commutative associative algebras which satisfy this special identity. The associator on an algebra A is the trilinear operator defined by [x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}=(x\cdot y)\cdot z-x\cdot(y\cdot z). The associator can be seen as the commutator of multiplication operators L_{x} and R_{z} in the following sense: [x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}=(x\cdot y)\cdot z-x\cdot(y\cdot z)\\ =R_{z}(x\cdot y)-L_{x}(y\cdot z)=R_{z}(L_{x}(y))-L_{x}(R_{z}(y))=[R_{z},L_{x}]_{-}(y). The zeroes of the associator correspond to associating elements of the algebra. Definition 1 . The relative nucleus of S\subseteq A is the subspace of A consisting of elements that associate with all elements in S , that is, \displaystyle N_{A}(S) \displaystyle=\{a\in A\mid[a,x,y]_{\mathrm{as}}=[x,a,y]_{\mathrm{as}}=[x,y,a]_{\mathrm{as}}=0\ \forall x,y\in S\} \displaystyle=\{a\in A\mid[a,S,S]_{\mathrm{as}}=[S,a,S]_{\mathrm{as}}=[S,S,a]_{\mathrm{as}}=0\}. The left, right and middle relative nuclei of S\subseteq A are the subspaces of A consisting of elements that associate with all S in the corresponding position: \displaystyle N_{A}^{l}(S) \displaystyle=\{a\in A\mid\left[a,s,t\right]=0\ \forall s,t\in S\} \displaystyle N_{A}^{m}(S) \displaystyle=\{a\in A\mid\left[s,a,t\right]=0\ \forall s,t\in S\} \displaystyle N_{A}^{r}(S) \displaystyle=\{a\in A\mid\left[s,t,a\right]=0\ \forall s,t\in S\} If S=A , we denote them N(A),N^{l}(A),N^{m}(A) and N^{r}(A) , respectively. Hom-algebras appear as natural deformations of usual algebras by the action of a linear map. A hom-algebra is an algebra equipped with a linear map \alpha\colon A\rightarrow A which deforms the fundamental identities of the algebra. Definition 2 (​​ [ 17 , Definition 1.1] ) . A hom-associative algebra is a triple (A,\mu,\alpha) where A is a linear space, \mu\colon A\times A\rightarrow A is a bilinear product operation denoted by dot or juxtaposition, and \alpha\colon A\rightarrow A is a linear map such that \alpha(x)\cdot(y\cdot z)=(x\cdot y)\cdot\alpha(z) for all x,y,z\in A. If no confusion is possible, we identify a hom-algebra with the pair (A,\alpha). The twisting map \alpha is called trivial if \alpha=\lambda\mathrm{id}_{A},\ \lambda\in\mathbb{F} , and non-trivial otherwise. A hom-associative algebra is multiplicative if \alpha(x\cdot y)=\alpha(x)\cdot\alpha(y) for all x,y\in A . A hom-associative algebra where \alpha=\mathrm{id}_{A} is associative. A common way to obtain hom-associative algebras is to twist an associative algebra by a homomorphism [ 24 , Theorem 2.3] : if (A,\mu) is associative, then (A,\alpha\circ\mu,\alpha) is hom-associative. Example 3 . Consider \mathbb{C} as a linear space over \mathbb{R} , x\ast y=\overline{x\cdot y} and \alpha\colon x\mapsto\bar{x} , where \bar{x} is the complex conjugate of x . The triple (\mathbb{C},\ast^{\prime},\alpha) is a hom-associative algebra. Indeed, for all x,y,z\in\mathbb{C}, \displaystyle\alpha(x)\ast^{\prime}(y\ast^{\prime}z) \displaystyle=\overline{\alpha(x)\cdot(y\ast^{\prime}z)}=\overline{\bar{x}\cdot\overline{{y\cdot z}}}=x\cdot y\cdot z \displaystyle=\overline{\overline{x\cdot y}\cdot{\bar{z}}}=\overline{(x\ast^{\prime}y)\cdot\alpha(z)}=(x\ast^{\prime}y)\ast^{\prime}\alpha(z). This procedure is compatible with more general algebras and linear maps: the hom-associator of a twisted algebra (A,\alpha\circ\mu,\alpha) can be expressed in terms of the original product as [x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}^{\alpha}=\alpha(\alpha(x\cdot y)\cdot\alpha(z)-\alpha(x)\cdot\alpha(y\cdot z)) . Theorem 4 . Let (A,\mu) be an algebra, \alpha\colon A\rightarrow A be a linear map. Then (A,\alpha\circ\mu,\alpha) is hom-associative if and only if, for all x,y,z\in A , \alpha(\alpha(x\cdot y)\cdot\alpha(z)-\alpha(x)\cdot\alpha(y\cdot z))=0 . Example 5 . Let (\mathbb{C}[t],\mu) denote complex polynomials in t with usual product and the multiplication operator L_{t}\colon p(t)\rightarrow tp(t) . For any three generators t^{n},\ t^{m},\ t^{l} , the hom-associator with respect to L_{t} is L_{t}(L_{t}(t^{n}\cdot t^{m})\cdot L_{t}(t^{l})-L_{t}(t^{n})L_{t}(t^{m}\cdot t^{l}))=L_{t}(t^{n+m+1}\cdot t^{l+1}-t^{n+1}\cdot t^{m+l+1})\\ =L_{t}(t^{n+m+l+2}-t^{n+m+l+2})=0. and thus (\mathbb{C}[t],L_{t}\circ\mu,L_{t}) is hom-associative. Similarly to the associator in associative algebras, an algebra will be hom-associative if the corresponding hom-associator is always zero. Definition 6 . The hom-associator [\cdot,\cdot,\cdot]_{\mathrm{as}}^{\alpha}\colon A\times A\times A\rightarrow A is the trilinear operator defined by [x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}^{\alpha}=(x\cdot y)\cdot\alpha(z)-\alpha(x)\cdot(y\cdot z). A unity of a (hom-)algebra (A,\alpha) is an element 1_{\star}\in A such that, for all x\in A , 1_{\star}\cdot x=x (left unity) or x\cdot 1_{\star}=x (right unity) or both (two-sided unity). A hom-algebra equipped with a unity is known as unital and denoted (A,\alpha,1_{\star}) . Two-sided unital hom-associative algebras are very close to being associative: it suffices that the twisting map is injective or surjective [ 6 ] . In particular, the quotient algebra A/\ker\alpha is associative. It is then necessary to introduce a generalized notion of unity for hom-algebras. Definition 7 . A hom-unity or weak unity of a hom-algebra (A,\alpha) is an element \omega_{\star}\in A such that, for all x\in A , \omega_{\star}\cdot x=\alpha(x) (left hom-unity), x\cdot\omega_{\star}=\alpha(x) (right hom-unity) or both (two-sided hom-unity). A hom-algebra with a hom-unity is known as hom-unital or weakly unital and denoted (A,\alpha,\omega_{\star}) . A hom-algebra being left or right hom-unital is equivalent to \alpha=L_{\omega_{\star}} or \alpha=R_{\omega_{\star}} respectively. Example 8 (​​ [ 5 ] ) . The twist (A,\alpha\circ\mu,\alpha,1_{\star}) of a two-sided unital algebra (A,\mu,1_{\star}) by a homomorphism \alpha is two-sided hom-unital. Indeed, for all x\in A , (\alpha\circ\mu)(1_{\star},x)=\alpha(1_{\star}\cdot x)=\alpha(x)=\alpha(x\cdot 1_{\star})=(\alpha\circ\mu)(x,1_{\star}). Across these pages, L_{a} and R_{a} represent, respectively, left and right multiplication by a\in A . Naming convention for these algebras is in Table 1 . Table 1: Naming convention for (hom-)unital (hom-)algebras. The term (hom-)unital refers to any of these algebras. With… On side… Is known as… (hom-)unity… Unity Left Left-unital 1_{l} Right Right-unital 1_{r} Both Two-sided unital 1_{lr} Unspecified One-sided unital 1_{\star} Hom-unity Left Left hom-unital \omega_{l} Right Right hom-unital \omega_{r} Both Two-sided hom-unital \omega_{lr} Unspecified One-sided hom-unital \omega_{\star} Definition 9 . A (one-sided) hom-ideal of a hom-algebra (A,\alpha) is a (one-sided) ideal I\subseteq A such that \alpha(I)\subseteq I . A hom-algebra is (one-sided) hom-simple if it does not contain any non-trivial (one-sided) hom-ideals. An essential aspect of the structure of algebras and hom-algebras is the presence of nonzero elements that multiply to 0 . Definition 10 . For any subset S\subseteq A of an algebra, the left annihilator of S is the subspace of elements of A that annihilate every element in S under left multiplication, \displaystyle Ann_{A}^{l}(S)=\{a\in A\mid\forall x\in S,\ a\cdot x=0\}=\bigcap\limits_{x\in S}\ker(R_{x}). (1) The right annihilator of S is the subspace of elements of A that annihilate every element in S under right multiplication, \displaystyle Ann_{A}^{r}(S)=\{a\in A\mid\forall x\in S,\ x\cdot a=0\}=\bigcap\limits_{x\in S}\ker(L_{x}). (2) An element a\in A is is left-regular if a\cdot x\neq 0\ \forall x\in A\backslash\{0\} , right-regular if x\cdot a\neq 0\ \forall x\in A\backslash\{0\} and two-sided regular if both hold. An associative algebra where all non-zero elements are two-sided regular is an associative domain , and one where all non-zero elements are invertible is a division algebra . A non-associative algebra where all multiplication operators are injective is a non-associative domain , and one where all multiplication operators are bijective is a non-associative division algebra . 3 One-sided unital hom-associative algebras From this section on, we mainly prove results for left-unital algebras, as the right-unital counterparts are analogous, and easily obtained by considering the opposite algebra A^{\mathrm{op}}=(A,\mu_{\mathrm{op}},1_{r}) of a given right-unital algebra A=(A,\mu,1_{r}) . The opposite product is given by \mu_{\mathrm{op}}(x,y)=y\cdot x . The opposite algebra (A^{\mathrm{op}},\mu,1_{r}) is left-unital if and only if (A,1_{r}) is right-unital. It then suffices to study left-unital algebras. Remark 11 . Observe that a left unital hom-associative algebra (A,\alpha,1_{l}) is hom-unital with hom-unity \alpha(1_{l}) – indeed, by hom-associativity, we have \alpha(x)=(1_{l}\cdot 1_{l})\cdot\alpha(x)=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot(1_{l}\cdot x)=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot x, which is the hom-unitality axiom. Lemma 12 . Let (A,\alpha,1_{l}) be a left-unital hom-associative algebra. Then, for all x,y,z\in A , (i) \alpha(x)\cdot z=(x\cdot 1_{l})\cdot\alpha(z) , (ii) \alpha(x)\cdot x=(x\cdot 1_{l})\cdot\alpha(x) , (iii) \alpha(x)\cdot 1_{l}=(x\cdot 1_{l})\cdot\alpha(1_{l}) , (iv) \alpha(1_{l})\cdot x=\alpha(x) , (v) 1_{l}\cdot\alpha(1_{l})=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot 1_{l} , (vi) \alpha(x\cdot y)=x\cdot\alpha(y) , (vii) \alpha=L_{\alpha(1_{l})} . Let (A,\alpha,1_{r}) be a right-unital hom-associative algebra. Then, for all x,y,z\in A , (viii) x\cdot\alpha(z)=\alpha(x)\cdot(1_{r}\cdot z) , (ix) x\cdot\alpha(x)=\alpha(x)\cdot(1_{r}\cdot x) , (x) 1_{r}\cdot\alpha(x)=\alpha(1_{r})\cdot(1_{r}\cdot x) , (xi) x\cdot\alpha(1_{r})=\alpha(x) , (xii) \alpha(1_{r})\cdot 1_{r}=1_{r}\cdot\alpha(1_{r}) , (xiii) \alpha(x\cdot y)=\alpha(x)\cdot y , (xiv) \alpha=R_{\alpha(1_{r})} . Proof. We apply hom-associativity and one-sided unitality conditions: (i) \colon (x\cdot 1_{l})\cdot\alpha(z)=\alpha(x)\cdot(1_{l}\cdot z)=\alpha(x)\cdot z , (ii) \colon (x\cdot 1_{l})\cdot\alpha(x)=\alpha(x)\cdot(1_{l}\cdot x)=\alpha(x)\cdot x , (iii) \colon (x\cdot 1_{l})\cdot\alpha(1_{l})=\alpha(x)\cdot(1_{l}\cdot 1_{l})=\alpha(x)\cdot 1_{l} , (iv) \colon (1_{l}\cdot 1_{l})\cdot\alpha(x)=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot(1_{l}\cdot x)=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot x , (v) \colon \alpha(1_{l})\cdot 1_{l}=\alpha(1_{l})=1_{l}\cdot\alpha(1_{l}) , (vi) \colon \alpha(x\cdot y)=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot(x\cdot y)=(1_{l}\cdot x)\cdot\alpha(y)=x\cdot\alpha(y) , (vii) \colon \alpha(x)=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot x\ \forall x\in A\Rightarrow\alpha=L_{\alpha(1_{l})} , (viii) \colon \alpha(x)\cdot(1_{r}\cdot z)=(x\cdot 1_{r})\cdot\alpha(z)=x\cdot\alpha(z) , (ix) \colon \alpha(x)\cdot(1_{r}\cdot x)=(x\cdot 1_{r})\cdot\alpha(x)=x\cdot\alpha(x) , (x) \colon \alpha(1_{r})\cdot(1_{r}\cdot x)=(1_{r}\cdot 1_{r})\cdot\alpha(x)=1_{r}\cdot\alpha(x) , (xi) \colon \alpha(x)\cdot(1_{r}\cdot 1_{r})=(x\cdot 1_{r})\cdot\alpha(1_{r})=x\cdot\alpha(1_{r}) , (xii) \colon 1_{r}\cdot\alpha(1_{r})=\alpha(1_{r})=\alpha(1_{r})\cdot 1_{r} , (xiii) \colon \alpha(x\cdot y)=(x\cdot y)\alpha(1_{r})=\alpha(x)\cdot(y\cdot 1_{r})=\alpha(x)\cdot y , (xiv) \colon \alpha(x)=x\cdot\alpha(1_{r})\ \forall x\in A\Rightarrow\alpha=R_{\alpha(1_{r})} . ∎ We represent these relations in a table to better compare them. Table 2: Product relations in one-sided unital hom-associative algebras. Left-unital Right-unital \alpha(x)\cdot y=(x\cdot 1_{l})\cdot\alpha(y) x\cdot\alpha(y)=\alpha(x)\cdot(1_{r}\cdot y) \alpha(x\cdot y)=x\cdot\alpha(y) \alpha(x\cdot y)=\alpha(x)\cdot y \alpha(x)\cdot 1_{l}=(x\cdot 1_{l})\cdot\alpha(1_{l}) 1_{r}\cdot\alpha(x)=\alpha(1_{r})\cdot(1_{r}\cdot x) \alpha(x)=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot x \alpha(x)=x\cdot\alpha(1_{r}) \alpha=L_{\alpha(1_{l})} \alpha=R_{\alpha(1_{r})} x\cdot y=1_{l}\Rightarrow x\cdot\alpha(y)=\alpha(1_{l}) x\cdot y=1_{r}\Rightarrow\alpha(x)\cdot y=1_{r} 1_{l}\cdot\alpha(1_{l})=\alpha(1_{l})=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot 1_{l} \alpha(1_{r})\cdot 1_{r}=\alpha(1_{r})=1_{r}\cdot\alpha(1_{r}) The two-sided unital analogues of relations in Table 2 are the opening result of [ 5 ] , and are naturally a combination of the two prior. Two-sided unitality also grants commutation between any element and its image by \alpha . Table 3: Product relations in two-sided unital hom-associative algebras. Two-sided unital x\cdot\alpha(y)=\alpha(x)\cdot y x\cdot\alpha(y)=\alpha(x\cdot y)=\alpha(x)\cdot y \alpha(1_{lr})\cdot x=\alpha(x)=x\cdot\alpha(1_{lr}) \alpha(1_{lr})\cdot x=\alpha(x)=x\cdot\alpha(1_{lr}) L_{\alpha(1_{lr})}=\alpha=R_{\alpha(1_{lr})} x\cdot y=1_{lr}\Rightarrow x\cdot\alpha(y)=\alpha(1_{lr})=\alpha(x)\cdot y x\cdot\alpha(x)=\alpha(x^{2})=\alpha(x)\cdot x The twisting map of any unital hom-associative algebra is a multiplication operator, but multiplication operators need not yield unital hom-associative algebras. Example 13 . Consider the ring t\cdot\mathbb{C}[t]=\{p(t)\in\mathbb{C}[t]\mid p(0)=0\} of polynomials in t with independent term equal to 0 and usual product. The multiplication operator L_{t}\colon p(t)\mapsto t\cdot p(t) defines a hom-associative algebra, since by multi-linearity of the hom-associator, the hom-associativity holds for any elements since it holds for the basis \{t^{n}\mid n\geq 1\} of t\cdot\mathbb{C}[t] : [t^{n},t^{m},t^{l}]_{\mathrm{as}}^{L_{t}}=(t^{n}\cdot t^{m})\cdot L_{t}(t^{l})-L_{t}(t^{n})\cdot(t^{m}\cdot t^{l})\\ =(t^{n}\cdot t^{m})\cdot t^{l+1}-t^{n+1}\cdot(t^{m}\cdot t^{l})=t^{n+m+l+1}-t^{n+1+m+l}=0. As a hom-algebra, (t\mathbb{C}[t],L_{t}) is hom-associative but not unital. Remark 14 . Observe that the hom-algebra in Example 13 is also associative. On the sequel (see Lemma 37 ) it will be shown that hom-associativity is due to centrality of t in \mathbb{C}[t,t^{-1}] . 3.1 Association relations One-sided unities need not be unique. Indeed, for any two different one-sided unities 1_{l} and 1_{l}^{\prime} we have 1_{l}\cdot x=x=1_{l}^{\prime}\cdot x , and thus (1_{l}^{\prime}-1_{l})\cdot x=0 , that is, 1_{l}^{\prime}-1_{l} is a universal left zero divisor of A or 1_{l}-1_{l}^{\prime}\in Ann_{A}^{l}(A) . Due to this, any unity in a domain is unique. The element 1_{l}^{\prime}-1_{l} is also nilpotent with order 2 , as (1_{l}^{\prime}-1_{l})\cdot(1_{l}^{\prime}-1_{l})=1_{l}^{\prime}\cdot 1_{l}^{\prime}-1_{l}^{\prime}\cdot 1_{l}-1_{l}\cdot 1_{l}^{\prime}+1_{l}\cdot 1_{l}=1_{l}^{\prime}-1_{l}-1_{l}^{\prime}+1_{l}=0 . If there are left and right unities, then the unity is two-sided and unique: for any two one-sided unities 1_{l} and 1_{r} , 1_{l}=1_{l}1_{r}=1_{r} . The twisting map \alpha of a unital hom-associative algebra (A,\alpha,1_{\star}) is multiplication by \alpha(1_{\star}) (see Lemma 12 ). This property applied to the hom-associators provides associativity conditions which extend those in [ 5 , Proposition 1.1] . Proposition 15 . Let (A,\alpha,1_{l}) be a left-unital hom-associative algebra. Then, for all x,y,z\in A , [x,y,\alpha(z)]_{\mathrm{as}}=\alpha([x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}). Moreover, if \alpha is injective, then, for all x,y,z\in A , [x,y,\alpha(z)]_{\mathrm{as}}=0\Leftrightarrow[x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}=0,\textnormal{ that is, }\alpha(z)\in N^{r}(A)\Leftrightarrow z\in N^{r}(A) Let (A,\alpha,1_{r}) be right-unital hom-associative algebra. Then, for all x,y,z\in A , [\alpha(x),y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}=\alpha([x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}). Moreover, if \alpha is injective, then, for all x,y,z\in A , [\alpha(x),y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}=0\Leftrightarrow[x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}=0,\textnormal{ that is, }\alpha(x)\in N^{l}(A)\Leftrightarrow x\in N^{l}(A) Proof. In left-unital hom-associative algebras, it follows from Lemma 12 that, for all x,y\in A , \alpha(x\cdot y)=x\cdot\alpha(y) . Apply this property to elements \{x\cdot y,z\} : (x\cdot y)\cdot\alpha(z)=\alpha((x\cdot y)\cdot z)\Rightarrow[x,y,\alpha(z)]_{\mathrm{as}}=(x\cdot y)\cdot\alpha(z)-x\cdot(y\cdot\alpha(z))\\ =\alpha((x\cdot y)\cdot z)-x\cdot\alpha(y\cdot z)=\alpha((x\cdot y)\cdot z)-\alpha(x\cdot(y\cdot z))=\alpha([x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}). If \alpha is injective, then [x,y,\alpha(z)]_{\mathrm{as}}=\alpha([x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}})=0\Leftrightarrow[x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}=0 . In right-unital hom-associative algebras, it follows from Lemma 12 that, for all x,y\in A , \alpha(x\cdot y)=\alpha(x)\cdot y . Apply this property to elements \{x,y\cdot z\} : \alpha(x)\cdot(y\cdot z)=\alpha(x\cdot(y\cdot z))\Rightarrow[\alpha(x),y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}=(\alpha(x)\cdot y)\cdot z-\alpha(x)\cdot(y\cdot z)\\ =\alpha(x\cdot y)\cdot z-\alpha(x\cdot(y\cdot z))=\alpha((x\cdot y)\cdot z)-\alpha(x\cdot(y\cdot z))=\alpha([x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}) If \alpha is injective, then [\alpha(x),y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}=\alpha([x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}})=0\Leftrightarrow[x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}=0. ∎ In the two-sided unital case, both statements of Proposition 15 hold. It follows that \alpha((x\cdot y)\cdot z)=\alpha(x\cdot(y\cdot z)) for all x,y,z\in A , that is, \alpha([x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}})=0 . Applying this property to Proposition 15 gives [ 5 , Proposition 1.1] , which can be used to prove the following identity: [\alpha(x),y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}=[x,\alpha(y),z]_{\mathrm{as}}=[x,y,\alpha(z)]_{\mathrm{as}}=\alpha([x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}})=0, and thus \alpha(A)\subseteq N(A) . This identity applied to a surjective \alpha implies that (A,1_{\star}) is associative. This is another proof to [ 5 , Corollary 1.1] . 3.2 Multiplicativity and associativity conditions In the literature, hom-algebras are often considered to be multiplicative [ 1 , 19 , 2 , 16 ] or constructed that way by twisting the product of an algebra by an algebra homomorphism [ 3 , 4 , 24 ] : doing so allows a very smooth generalization of many relevant algebraic properties including cohomology [ 1 ] and deformations [ 2 ] , and multiplicative hom-associative algebras are moreover classified in low dimension [ 19 ] . Multiplicativity in one-sided unital algebras behaves as follows: Theorem 16 . Let (A,\alpha,1_{\star}) be a unital hom-associative algebra. The following statements are equivalent: 1) \alpha is multiplicative, 2) \alpha is idempotent, 3) \alpha^{2}(1_{\star})=\alpha(1_{\star}) , 4) \alpha(1_{\star}) is idempotent. Proof. We prove 1 \Rightarrow 2 \Rightarrow 3 \Rightarrow 4 \Rightarrow 1 for a left-unital algebra (A,1_{l}) : 1 \Rightarrow 2 : If \alpha is multiplicative, then x\cdot\alpha(y)=\alpha(x\cdot y)=\alpha(x)\cdot\alpha(y) . It follows from here that x\cdot\alpha(y)=\alpha(x)\cdot\alpha(y) , and by contracting x\mapsto 1_{l} we obtain \alpha(y)=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot\alpha(y)=\alpha^{2}(y) and thus \alpha^{2}=\alpha. That is, \alpha is idempotent. 2 \Rightarrow 3 : If \alpha^{2}=\alpha , then \alpha(1_{l})^{2}=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot\alpha(1_{l})=\alpha^{2}(1_{l})=\alpha(1_{l}) . It follows that \alpha^{2}(1_{l})=\alpha(1_{l})^{2}=\alpha(1_{l}). That is, \alpha(1_{l}) is idempotent. 3 \Rightarrow 4 : From \alpha(1_{l})^{2}=\alpha^{2}(1_{l}) it follows that \alpha(1_{l})^{2}=\alpha(1_{l})\Leftrightarrow\alpha^{2}(1_{l})=\alpha(1_{l}) . 4 \Rightarrow 1 : If \alpha^{2}(1_{l})=\alpha(1_{l}) , then \alpha(x)\cdot\alpha(y)=(\alpha(1_{l})\cdot x)\cdot\alpha(y) . By hom-associativity, this is equal to \alpha^{2}(1_{l})\cdot(x\cdot y)=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot(x\cdot y)=\alpha(x\cdot y) . It follows that \alpha(x\cdot y)=\alpha(x)\cdot\alpha(y). That is, \alpha is multiplicative. The right-unital case is analogous. This completes the proof. ∎ We can visualize these relations using the following diagram: {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\alpha\textnormal{ multiplicative}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\alpha^{2}(1_{\star})=\alpha(1_{\star})} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\alpha\textnormal{ is idempotent}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\alpha(1_{\star})\textnormal{ idempotent}} The twisting map of any unital hom-associative algebra is a multiplication operator, and thus determined (albeit not always uniquely) by the factor \alpha(1_{\star}) . That is, there is a correspondence between multiplicative twisting maps and a certain subset of idempotents of the algebra (see Theorem 38 ). Remark 17 . Multiplicativity of \alpha can be determined by computing \alpha(1_{\star})^{2} . This allows a very streamlined classification of multiplicative hom-associative structures, as will be seen on the sequel, and can moreover be used to rule out hom-associative structures on certain algebras. Corollary 18 . The following equivalent statements hold: 1) No multiplicative hom-associative algebra (A,\alpha) with \alpha^{2}\neq\alpha is unital. 2) A unital multiplicative hom-associative algebra without non-trivial idempotents is either trivial or associative. Example 19 . The 3 -dimensional multiplicative hom-associative algebras A_{4}^{3} , A_{5}^{3} , A_{6}^{3} and A_{11}^{3} , classified in [ 19 ] , have non-idempotent twisting maps (see [ 8 ] ), and thus are non-unital. Example 20 . Any division algebra has no non-trivial idempotents, and thus it cannot be seen as multiplicative hom-associative unless \alpha(1_{\star})=1_{\star} , in which case it is associative. Example 21 (​​ [ 21 ] ) . Let R be a unital ring without non-trivial idempotents, G a finite group such that every prime divisor of the order of G is not invertible in R . The group ring RG has no non-trivial idempotents. As a unital R -algebra, (RG,1e_{G}) cannot be seen as multiplicative hom-associative unless \alpha(e_{G})=e_{G} , in which case it is associative. Corollary 22 . Let (A,\alpha,1_{\star}) be a unital hom-associative algebra. If any of the statements of Theorem 16 holds and \alpha is injective or 1_{\star}\in\alpha(A) (and in particular if \alpha is surjective), then (A,1_{l}) is associative. Proof. Let (A,\alpha,1_{\star}) be a one-sided unital hom-associative algebra. If any of the statements of Theorem 16 holds, then \alpha is idempotent. Moreover, (i) If \alpha is injective: From \alpha idempotent folows that \alpha(\alpha(x)-x)=0 . By injectivity of \alpha , \alpha(x)=x , and thus \alpha=\mathrm{id}_{A}. (ii) If 1_{\star}\in\alpha(A) : there is a\in A such that 1_{\star}=\alpha(a)=\alpha^{2}(a)=\alpha(1_{\star}) . It follows that \alpha=L_{1_{\star}}=\mathrm{id}_{A} or \alpha=R_{1_{\star}}=\mathrm{id}_{A} . (iii) If \alpha surjective: 1_{\star}\in\alpha(A) always holds, as \alpha(A)=A . By the twisting map being the identity, (A,1_{\star}) is associative. ∎ This result expands [ 5 , Corollary 1.3] to one-sided unital hom-associative algebras and illustrates how restrictive multiplicativity of \alpha is: multiplicative unital hom-associative algebras are oftentimes just associative, in which case it is much more interesting to study them with the machinery of associative algebras. 4 Hom-unities in two-sided unital algebras Definition 23 . Given an algebra A , a linear map \alpha\colon A\to A is HA-compatible or a hom-associative structure of A if (A,\alpha) is hom-associative. An element a\in A induces a hom-associative structure on A if the multiplication operator \alpha=L_{a} or \alpha=R_{a} is HA-compatible. If no nonzero map is HA-compatible, we say that A has no non-trivial hom-associative structures. The twisting map \alpha of a left-unital hom-associative algebra is a multiplication operator L_{a} , and thus a satisfies the hom-unitality axiom \alpha(x)=a\cdot x . The search for hom-associative structures is then one with the search of hom-unities of the algebra which induce hom-associative structures. In two-sided unital algebras, the subspace of HA-compatible maps consists of left multiplications by elements in the following subalgebra [ 5 , Proposition 1.1] : AC(A)=\{a\in Z(A)\mid Aa\subseteq N(A)\textnormal{ is a two-sided ideal}\}. Any a\in AC(A) is central, and thus speaking of left or right multiplication is up to preference. AC(A) is the subalgebra consisting of all hom-unities of (A,1_{lr}) which induce hom-associative structures. Theorem 24 . Let (A,1_{lr}) be a two-sided unital algebra. With the notations above, AC(A)=Z(A)\cap N(A)\cap Ann_{A}^{l}([A,A,A]_{\mathrm{as}}). (3) Proof. For any a\in AC(A) , it follows from Aa\subseteq N(A) that a\in N(A) , and thus AC(A)\subseteq Z(A)\cap N(A) . Moreover, Aa\subseteq N(A) is a two-sided ideal only if the following association relations hold for all x,y,z\in A : \displaystyle[ax,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}} \displaystyle=((ax)y)z-(ax)(yz)=(a(xy))z-a(x(yz)) \displaystyle\hskip 120.92421pt=a((xy)z)-a(x(yz))=a[x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}, \displaystyle[x,ay,z]_{\mathrm{as}} \displaystyle=(x(ay))z-x((ay)z)=((xa)y)z-x(a(yz)) \displaystyle\hskip 35.56593pt=((ax)y)z-(ax)(yz)=(a(xy))z-a(x(yz)) \displaystyle\hskip 120.92421pt=a((xy)z)-a(x(yz))=a[x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}, \displaystyle[x,y,za]_{\mathrm{as}} \displaystyle=(xy)(za)-x(y(za))=((xy)z)a-x((yz)a) \displaystyle\hskip 56.9055pt=((xy)z)a-(x(yz))a=[x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}a=a[x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}. These relations indicate that Aa\subseteq N(A) is a two-sided ideal if and only if a[x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}=0 for all x,y,z\in A , that is, a\in Ann_{A}^{l}([A,A,A]_{\mathrm{as}}) . Lastly, ideal conditions of Aa follow from a\in Z(A)\cap N(A) : \displaystyle\textbf{Left ideal: }\text{for all }b\in A,\ b(ax)=b(xa)=(bx)a\in Aa. \displaystyle\textbf{Right ideal: }\text{for all }b\in A,\ (xa)b=x(ab)=x(ba)=(xb)a\in Aa. This completes the proof. ∎ Since this subalgebra consists entirely of central elements, it can be rewritten in any of the following forms indistinctly: \displaystyle AC(A)=Z(A)\cap N(A)\cap Ann_{A}^{l}([A,A,A]_{\mathrm{as}}) \displaystyle=Z(A)\cap N(A)\cap Ann_{A}^{r}([A,A,A]_{\mathrm{as}}) \displaystyle=Z(A)\cap N(A)\cap Ann_{A}([A,A,A]_{\mathrm{as}}) . Example 25 . Any two-sided unital associative algebra (A,1_{lr}) satisfies N(A)=A and [A,A,A]_{\mathrm{as}}=\{0\} , and thus AC(A)=Z(A) . That is, (the product in) (A,\alpha,1_{lr}) is hom-associative if and only if the twisting map is \alpha=L_{\omega} for some \omega\in Z(A) . Then, (A,L_{\omega},\omega) is two-sided hom-unital hom-associative. The algebra in Example 13 is a case of this, with hom-unity \omega=t . Example 26 . Any two-sided unital simple algebra with non-trivial HA-compatible maps is associative. Indeed, if (A,1_{lr}) is two-sided unital simple and AC(A)\neq\{0\} , then Aa is a two-sided ideal for some a\neq 0 in AC(A) . This implies one of the following: \displaystyle Aa \displaystyle=\{0\}\overset{a\in Z(A)}{\Longrightarrow}L_{a}=0\Rightarrow Twist(A)=\{0\}\Rightarrow a=0, \displaystyle Aa \displaystyle=A\overset{Aa\subseteq N(A)}{\Longrightarrow}N(A)=A\Rightarrow(A,1_{lr})\textnormal{ is associative.} By associativity, as seen in Example 25 , we have AC(A)=Z(A) . Corollary 27 . No HA-compatible map of a two-sided unital non-associative algebra is injective. Moreover, if there exist x,y,z\in A such that [x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}} is one-sided regular, then AC(A)=\{0\} . Proof. Let a\in AC(A) . Then a\in Ann_{A}^{l}([A,A,A]_{\mathrm{as}}) . We can write this in the form a\cdot[A,A,A]_{\mathrm{as}}=\{0\} , or [A,A,A]_{\mathrm{as}}\subseteq\ker L_{a} . Since A is non-associative, \ker L_{a} is non-trivial. If, for some x,y,z\in A , [x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}} is (without loss of generality) right-regular, then there is no nonzero a\in A such that [x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}\in\ker L_{a} , that is, Ann_{A}^{l}([A,A,A]_{\mathrm{as}})=\{0\} . Conclusion follows. ∎ All hom-associative structures of a given two-sided unital algebra are given by multiplication with central elements, that is, the twisting maps are determined by two-sided hom-unities. This problem can be reversed in different ways, which leaves two interesting open questions: (i) Can a given hom-unital hom-associative algebra be interpreted as a hom-associative structure over another algebra? (ii) Given a linear map of A , when is it possible to find a product in A that makes it HA-compatible? Example 28 . The first Cayley-Dickson algebras over \mathbb{R} are the complex numbers \mathbb{C} , the quaternions \mathbb{H} , the octonions \mathbb{O} , the sedenions \mathbb{S} and more, each obtained by doubling the previous one, by adding a new generator and a new involution. \begin{array}[]{c|c|c|c}\textnormal{Algebra}&\textnormal{Construction}&\textnormal{Generators}&\textnormal{Properties}\\ \hline\cr\mathbb{C}&\mathbb{R}\oplus\mathbb{R}i&\{1,i\}&i^{2}=-1.\\ \mathbb{H}&\mathbb{C}\oplus\mathbb{C}j&\{1,i,j,k\}&ij=k,\ ijk=-1.\end{array} Using this process twice more we obtain \mathbb{O} with 8 generators and \mathbb{S} with 16. Each step of the Cayley-Dickson process doubles the dimension in exchange for certain algebraic properties: \mathbb{R} is commutative associative domain, \mathbb{H} is non-commutative associative domain, \mathbb{O} is non-commutative alternative domain, \mathbb{S} is non-commutative flexible and has zero divisors. All of these algebras are two-sided unital with unity 1 . The coefficient in 1 is called real part of these objects, and we identify the subalgebra of real elements (with only real part) with \mathbb{R} . The hom-unities inducing HA-compatible maps in \mathbb{C} , \mathbb{H} , \mathbb{O} and \mathbb{S} are: 1) \mathbb{C}\colon\ AC(\mathbb{C})=\mathbb{C} . 2) \mathbb{H}\colon\ AC(\mathbb{H})=Re(\mathbb{H})=\mathbb{R}\cdot 1 . 3) \mathbb{O}\colon\ AC(\mathbb{O})=\{0\} . 4) \mathbb{S}:\ AC(\mathbb{S})=\{0\} . We use the explicit formulation given by Theorem 24 , namely AC(A)=Z(A)\cap N(A)\cap Ann_{A}^{l}([A,A,A]_{\mathrm{as}}), given that \mathbb{C},\mathbb{H},\mathbb{O} and \mathbb{S} are two-sided unital. We can then see all HA-compatible maps as multiplication operators following Table 2 . \mathbb{C} is a commutative associative domain, and thus [\mathbb{C},\mathbb{C},\mathbb{C}]_{\mathrm{as}}=\{0\} . It follows that AC(\mathbb{C})=Z(\mathbb{C})\cap N(\mathbb{C})\cap Ann_{\mathbb{C}}^{l}(\{0\})=\mathbb{C} . \mathbb{H} is an associative domain, and thus [\mathbb{H},\mathbb{H},\mathbb{H}]_{\mathrm{as}}=\{0\} . It follows that AC(\mathbb{H})=Z(\mathbb{H})\cap N(\mathbb{H})\cap Ann_{\mathbb{H}}^{l}(\{0\})=Re(\mathbb{H})\cap\mathbb{H}\cap\mathbb{H}=Re(\mathbb{H})=\mathbb{R}1. \mathbb{O} is a domain, and then we have Ann_{\mathbb{O}}^{l}([\mathbb{O},\mathbb{O},\mathbb{O}]_{\mathrm{as}})=\{0\} . It follows that AC(\mathbb{O})=Z(\mathbb{O})\cap N(\mathbb{O})\cap\{0\}=\{0\}. Regarding \mathbb{S} , observe that Z(\mathbb{S})=N(\mathbb{S})=Re(\mathbb{S})\cong\mathbb{R} . From the definition of AC(\mathbb{S}) it follows that AC(A)\cong T\subseteq\mathbb{R} . Since \mathbb{S} is non-associative, there is a nonzero element z\in[\mathbb{S},\mathbb{S},\mathbb{S}]_{\mathrm{as}} . The real part e_{0} of any sedenion associates, N(\mathbb{S})=Re(\mathbb{S}) , and thus z has the form z=\sum\limits_{i=1}^{15}a_{i}e_{i} . For all \lambda\in\mathbb{R} , it holds that \lambda z=0\Leftrightarrow\lambda a_{i}=0 for all i\in\{1,\dots,15\} . Given that z\neq 0 , there is at least one a_{i}\neq 0 , and thus \lambda=0 . It follows that Ann_{\mathbb{S}}^{l}([\mathbb{S},\mathbb{S},\mathbb{S}]_{\mathrm{as}})\cap Re(\mathbb{S})=\{0\} , from which AC(\mathbb{S})=\{0\}. Remark 29 . AC(A) is a subalgebra of any two-sided unital algebra A . Then, 0 is the hom-unity corresponding to the zero map, which we can see as 0\mathrm{id}_{A} or multiplication by 0\cdot 1_{lr} . It is shown that all left multiplications in \mathbb{C} are HA-compatible, while \mathbb{H} , \mathbb{O} and \mathbb{S} admit no non-trivial hom-associative structures. Every HA-compatible map is either a real multiple of the identity (in the case of \mathbb{H} ) or the zero map, seen as multiplication by 0 . The Cayley-Dickson process removes association relations: from the associative algebra \mathbb{H} we obtain the alternative algebra \mathbb{O} and then the flexible algebra \mathbb{S} . The loss of hom-unities from \mathbb{H} to \mathbb{O} is due to losing associativity but maintaining domain property. 5 Hom-unities in one-sided unital algebras This section studies left-unital algebras, which we denote (A,1_{l}) . The right-unital versions of all results in this section follow by applying them to the opposite algebra A^{\mathrm{op}}=(A,\mu_{\mathrm{op}},1_{\star}) – as seen at the beginning of Section 3 , A^{\mathrm{op}} which is left-unital (right-unital) if and only if (A,\mu,1_{\star}) is right-unital (left-unital) with the same unity. Consider the maps \displaystyle\begin{array}[]{ccc}\phi:Twist(A)&\rightarrow&A\\ \beta&\mapsto&\beta(1_{l})\end{array}\quad\text{ and }\quad\begin{array}[]{ccc}\psi:AC(A)&\rightarrow&\mathcal{L}(A)\\ a&\mapsto&L_{a}:x\mapsto ax\end{array} If (A,1_{\star}) is two-sided unital, Frégier and Gohr [ 5 ] proved that these maps induce a bijection between all HA-compatible maps of A and the subalgebra AC(A) of hom-unities of the given product. The aim of this section is to describe the linear subspace of left hom-unities of a given left-unital algebra. The set of all left hom-unities with respect to all linear maps on any algebra form a linear subspace of A since for any linear maps \alpha and \beta on A and for any x\in A and \lambda,\mu\in\mathbb{F} , ax=\alpha(x),\ bx=\beta(x)\Rightarrow\begin{array}[]{l}(\lambda a+\mu b)x=\lambda(ax)+\mu(bx)\\ \quad=\lambda\alpha(x)+\mu\beta(x)=(\lambda\alpha+\mu\beta)(x)\end{array} and hence, in particular, if a is a hom-unity with respect to \alpha and b is a hom-unity with respect to \beta , then \lambda a+\mu b is a hom-unity with respect to the linear map \lambda\alpha+\mu\beta . In other words, if \alpha=L_{a} and \beta=L_{b} for some a,b\in A , then \lambda\alpha+\mu\beta=L_{\lambda a+\mu b} which means that for any algebra A , the set of all linear operators of multiplication from the left by elements of the algebra form a linear subspace of the space of all linear operators on the algebra A . In most algebras it is a proper subspace since the elements of this subspace are special linear transformations given by the multiplication operation of the algebra. In other words, in most algebras, the linear subspace of all left hom-unities with respect to all linear maps form a proper linear subspace of A . For given elements x,y,z\in A in an algebra A , the hom-associator [x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}^{\alpha}=(x\cdot y)\cdot\alpha(z)-\alpha(x)\cdot(y\cdot z) is a linear map \alpha\in{\cal L}(A)\to[x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}^{\alpha}\in A from the linear space of all linear transformations {\cal L}(A) of A to A . The kernel of this linear map is a linear subspace of {\cal L}(A) of all linear maps \alpha such that the elements x,y,z hom-associate with respect to twisting map \alpha , that is \alpha(x)\cdot(y\cdot z)=(x\cdot y)\cdot\alpha(z) . The intersection of these associator kernel subspaces is the linear subspace of {\cal L}(A) consisting of all hom-associative structures on A , that is, of all linear maps \alpha for which the hom-algebra (A,\alpha) is a hom-associative (such \alpha for which \alpha(x)(yz)=(xy)\alpha(z) for all x,y,z\in A ). To make this more explicit, if (A,\cdot,\alpha) and if (A,\cdot,\beta) are hom-associative, then for any \lambda,\mu\in\mathbb{F} , (\lambda\alpha+\mu\beta)(x)\cdot(y\cdot z)=\lambda\alpha(x)\cdot(y\cdot z)+\mu\beta(x)\cdot(y\cdot z)\\ =(x\cdot y)\cdot\lambda\alpha(z)+(x\cdot y)\cdot\mu\beta(z)=(x\cdot y)\cdot(\lambda\alpha+\mu\beta)(z). and thus \lambda\alpha+\mu\beta is a hom-associative structure on A . The intersection of the linear subspace in {\cal L}(A) of hom-associative structures on an algebra A with the linear subspace of linear maps of multiplication by elements of the algebra from the left is a linear subspace of {\cal L}(A) consisting of the left multiplication operators L_{a},a\in A such that (A,L_{a}) is hom-associative. In other words, \{L_{a}\mid a\text{ is left hom-unity of }A,\ (A,L_{a})\text{ is hom-associative}\} is a linear subspace of {\cal L}(A) . Since the map a\mapsto L_{a} from A to {\cal L}(A) is linear, the set \{a\in A\mid a\text{ is hom-unity of }A,\ (A,L_{a})\text{ is hom-associative}\}, is a linear subspace of A as the preimage of the linear subspace \{L_{a}\mid a\text{ is hom-unity of }A,\ (A,L_{a})\text{ is hom-associative}\} of {\cal L}(A) under this linear map. Any hom-unity a of a left-unital hom-associative algebra (A,L_{a},1_{l}) satisfies the following three properties, for all x,y,z\in A : 1) L_{ax}\circ L_{y}=L_{xy}\circ L_{a} , or (a\cdot x)\cdot(y\cdot z)=(x\cdot y)\cdot(a\cdot z). 2) L_{a}\circ L_{x}=L_{x}\circ L_{a} , or a\cdot(x\cdot z)=x\cdot(a\cdot z). 3) L_{ax}\circ L_{y}=L_{a}\circ L_{xy} , or (a\cdot x)\cdot(y\cdot z)=a\cdot((x\cdot y)\cdot z). The first property is hom-associativity; the second property results from applying hom-associativity to a triple of the form \{1_{l},x,z\} , as direct consequence of left unitality (see Table 2 ); the third property follows from the other two. Consider the linear subspace of elements of A satisfying, for all x,y,z\in A , the last two conditions above, that is: \displaystyle AC_{l}(A)=\{a\in A\mid L_{a}\circ L_{x}=L_{x}\circ L_{a},\ L_{ax}\circ L_{y}=L_{a}\circ L_{xy},\ \forall x,y\in A\} \displaystyle=\{a\in A\mid\underset{-\textnormal{Property \ref{item:ACL1}}-}{a\cdot(x\cdot z)=x\cdot(a\cdot z)},\ \underset{-\textnormal{Property \ref{item:ACL2} }-}{(a\cdot x)\cdot(y\cdot z)=a\cdot((x\cdot y)\cdot z)},\ \forall x,y,z\in A\} Remark 30 . Elements in AC_{l}(A) satisfy multiple properties, which are explored in Section 5.1 . and appear in Table 4 , also listed as and . This notation will be followed throughout the remainder of this paper. Given one-sided unitality, we can define the subspace AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l}=\{a\cdot 1_{l}\mid a\in AC_{l}(A)\}, (8) which interacts with AC_{l}(A) in the following way: Lemma 31 . Let (A,1_{l}) be a left-unital algebra. With the notations above, it holds that \{a\in AC_{l}(A)\mid a\cdot 1_{l}=a\}=AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l}\subseteq AC_{l}(A). Proof. We prove the content first. Let b\in AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} . There is a\in AC_{l}(A) such that b=a\cdot 1_{l} . We check properties and for b using those of a : \displaystyle\colon L_{a1_{l}}=L_{a}\overset{\ref{item:ACL1}_{a}}{\Rightarrow}L_{a1_{l}}\circ L_{x}=L_{x}\circ L_{a1_{l}} \displaystyle\colon(a\cdot 1_{l})\cdot((x\cdot y)\cdot z)=a\cdot((1_{l}\cdot(x\cdot y))\cdot z)=a\cdot((x\cdot y)\cdot z)=(a\cdot x)\cdot(y\cdot z) \displaystyle\hskip 263.18799pt\overset{\ref{item:ACL2}_{a}}{=}((a\cdot 1_{l})\cdot x)\cdot(y\cdot z). Lastly, by contracting x\mapsto 1_{l} in , we have (a\cdot 1_{l})\cdot(y\cdot z)=a\cdot((1_{l}\cdot y)\cdot z)=a\cdot(y\cdot z) . Now contract y\mapsto 1_{l} , we obtain (a\cdot 1_{l})\cdot z=a\cdot(1_{l}\cdot z)=a\cdot z . It follows that L_{a}=L_{a1_{l}} . To prove the equality: For every b\in AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} we have b\cdot 1_{l}=b , and for every a\in AC_{l}(A) commuting with 1_{l} we have a=a\cdot 1_{l}\Rightarrow a\in AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} . ∎ The equality AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l}=AC_{l}(A) is satisfied when Ann_{A}^{l}(A)=\{0\} . This is in fact an equivalence, which we prove in Theorem 34 . AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} is not straightforward to compute, there is no decomposition in center, nucleus and annihilators like in two-sided unital algebras ( 3 ). Nonetheless, a subspace of it admits such decomposition. Proposition 32 . Let (A,1_{l}) be a left-unital algebra. Consider the subspace HU_{n}^{l}(A)=Z(A\cdot A)\cap N^{l}(A)\cap N^{m}(A)\cap Ann_{A}^{l}([A,A,A]_{\mathrm{as}}). It holds that HU_{n}^{l}(A)\subseteq AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} . Proof. Let a\in HU_{n}^{l}(A) . We can express the hom-associator in (A,L_{a}) as \displaystyle(a\cdot x)\cdot(y\cdot z)=a\cdot(x\cdot(y\cdot z)), \displaystyle(x\cdot y)\cdot(a\cdot z)=((x\cdot y)\cdot a)\cdot z=(a\cdot(x\cdot y))\cdot z=a\cdot((x\cdot y)\cdot z) \displaystyle\hskip 51.21504pt\Rightarrow[x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}^{L_{a}}=a\cdot((x\cdot y)\cdot z)-a\cdot(x\cdot(y\cdot z))=a\cdot[x,y,z]_{\mathrm{as}}=0. It follows that a\in AC_{l}(A) . Commutation with 1_{l} follows from a\in Z(A\cdot A)=Z(A) , since A is left-unital. This completes the proof. ∎ Remark 33 . Observe that, since (A,1_{l}) is left-unital, Z(A\cdot A)\cap N^{l}(A)\cap N^{m}(A)=Z(A)\cap N(A) , and thus the subspace we call HU_{n}^{l}(A) is no other than AC(A) as defined in the previous section – all hom-unities in HU_{n}^{l}(A) are then two-sided. The equality HU_{n}^{l}(A)=AC(A) will be broken when exploring non-unital algebras. The equality AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l}=HU_{n}^{l}(A) is not a given. It holds in some associative algebras (see Lemma 37 ), and in all two-sided unital algebras. Theorem 34 . Let (A,1_{l}) be a left-unital algebra. It holds that AC_{l}(A)=AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l}\oplus Ann_{A}^{l}(A). (9) Moreover, AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l}=AC_{l}(A) if and only if Ann_{A}^{l}(A)=\{0\} . Proof. Firstly, both AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} and Ann_{A}^{l}(A) are subspaces of AC_{l}(A) , since any a\in Ann_{A}^{l}(A) trivially makes (A,L_{a},1_{l}) hom-associative. Next, observe that the property L_{a}=L_{a1_{l}} reads, for all a\in AC_{l}(A) , L_{a1_{l}-a}=0 , or equivalently, a\cdot 1_{l}-a\in Ann_{A}^{l}(A) . By linearity, a\cdot 1_{l}\in Ann_{A}^{l}(A) if and only if a\in Ann_{A}^{l}(A) . But then a\cdot 1_{l}=0 . If a\in AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} , then it commutes with 1_{l} , which implies a=1_{l}\cdot a=a\cdot 1_{l}=0 . That is, AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} and Ann_{A}^{l}(A) are disjoint subspaces. Finally, we can write every a\in AC_{l}(A) uniquely as a=a\cdot 1_{l}+(a-a\cdot 1_{l})\in AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l}\oplus Ann_{A}^{l}(A). The sum being direct completes the proof. ∎ Example 35 . The unity 1_{lr} of any two-sided unital algebra is two-sided regular. We then have Ann_{A}^{l}(A)=\{0\} , and thus AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{lr}=AC_{l}(A) . The two-sided unital AC(A) is a subalgebra of A . It is then highly desirable to find a subspace of AC_{l}(A) which is also one. Remark 36 . In Theorem 43 , it will be shown that AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} is indeed a subalgebra of A . This is key to many results in this section. Left-unital associative algebras can be seen as hom-unital hom-associative, with hom-unity 1_{l} . That is, 1_{l}\in AC_{l}(A) if and only if (A,1_{l}) is associative. Lemma 37 . Proof. This completes the proof. ∎ This proof is very transparent in regards to where left unitality is used. This fact will help prove the general case, where the lack of commutation of the unity with AC_{l}(A) creates additional difficulties. Theorem 38 . Let (A,1_{l}) be a left-unital algebra. The following statements hold: (B1): The subalgebra Twist(A) of all HA-compatible maps on (A,1_{l}) is in bijection with the commutative associative subalgebra AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l}=\{a\in AC_{l}(A)\mid a\cdot 1_{l}=a\}. Bijection is given by \phi and \psi|_{AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l}} , where: \displaystyle\begin{array}[]{ccc}\phi:Twist(A)&\to&A\\ \alpha&\mapsto&\alpha(1_{l})\end{array}\quad, \displaystyle\begin{array}[]{ccc}\psi:AC_{l}(A)&\to&\mathcal{L}(A)\\ a&\mapsto&L_{a}\colon x\mapsto a\cdot x.\end{array} (B2): For every a\in AC_{l}(A) , (A,L_{a},1_{l}) is hom-associative. (B3): Multiplicative HA-compatible maps on (A,1_{l}) are in bijection with the subset E(A)\cap AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} of idempotents in AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} . (B4): If (A,1_{l}) is moreover associative, then HA-compatible maps of (A,1_{l}) are in bijection with the commutative associative subalgebra AC_{l}(A)=\{a\in A\mid a\cdot x\cdot z=x\cdot a\cdot z\ \forall x,z\in A\}. (10) The bijection is given by a\leftrightarrow L_{a} . Moreover, AC_{l}(A) satisfies the following: 1) Z(A)\subseteq AC_{l}(A) . 2) If (A,1_{l}) is two-sided unital, a domain or commutative, then it holds that AC_{l}(A)=Z(A)=AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l}=HU_{n}^{l}(A) . Proof. In order to prove (B1) and (B2) , that is, the bijection between \phi and a restriction of \psi , we show that they are bijective and mutually inverse, that is: (i) (\psi\circ\phi)(\alpha)=\alpha for all \alpha\in Twist(A) . (ii) (\phi\circ\psi)(a)=a for all a\in AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} . And both of these fail if the corresponding map fails to be injective. Apply \psi to a\in AC_{l}(A) , it follows that: (i) (A,L_{a},1_{l}) is hom-associative. That is, \psi(a)=L_{a}\in Twist(A). (ii) (\phi\circ\psi)(a)=\phi(L_{a})=L_{a}(1_{l})=a\cdot 1_{l}\in AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} . (iii) The zero map is always HA-compatible, and thus \ker\psi=\{a\in AC_{l}(A)\mid L_{a}=0\}=Ann_{A}^{l}(A)\cap AC_{l}(A)=Ann_{A}^{l}(A). Using the last property in Table 2 , for a\in AC_{l}(A) we have L_{a1_{l}}=L_{a} , that is, \psi(a1_{l})=\psi(a) . By Theorem 34 , if we restrict \psi to AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} we obtain \ker\psi|_{AC_{l}(A)1_{l}}=\{a\in AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l}\mid L_{a}{=}0\}=AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l}\cap Ann_{A}^{l}(A)=\{0\}. That is, \psi|_{AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l}} is injective. Moreover, for any a\in AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} it holds that (\phi\circ\psi)(a)=\phi(L_{a})=a\cdot 1_{l}=a . Let \alpha\in\ker\phi . By hom-associativity of (A,\alpha,1_{l}) we have \alpha=L_{\alpha(1_{l})}=L_{0}=0 . It follows that \phi is injective. Now, let a\in\phi(Twist(A)) . Then, a=\alpha(1_{l}) for some \alpha such that (A,\alpha,1_{l}) is hom-associative. We have the following: (i) L_{xy}\circ L_{a}=L_{ax}\circ L_{y} (hom-associativity). (ii) x\cdot(a\cdot y)=x\cdot(\alpha(1_{l})\cdot y)=x\cdot\alpha(y)=\alpha(x\cdot y)=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot(x\cdot y){=}a\cdot(x\cdot y) that is, L_{x}\circ L_{a}=L_{a}\circ L_{x} (Property ). (iii) Putting the previous two together, L_{a}\circ L_{xy}=L_{ax}\circ L_{y} (Property ) . (iv) By left unitality (see Table 2 ), we have [a,1_{l}]=0 , that is, a\cdot 1_{l}=a . From these properties follows that a\in AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} . Now, by left unitality it holds that (\psi\circ\phi)(\alpha)=\psi(\alpha(1_{l}))=L_{\alpha(1_{l})}=L_{a} . We have that a\leftrightarrow L_{a} is indeed an isomorphism between Twist(A) and AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} . Lastly, that Twist(A) is a subalgebra of \mathcal{L}(A) follows by multiplicativity of \phi and \psi and AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} being itself a subalgebra of A . Indeed: Multiplicativity of \phi\colon \phi(\alpha\circ\alpha^{\prime})=(\alpha\circ\alpha^{\prime})(1_{l})=\alpha(\alpha^{\prime}(1_{l}))=\alpha(1_{l})\cdot\alpha^{\prime}(1_{l})=\phi(\alpha)\cdot\phi(\alpha^{\prime}). Multiplicativity of \psi\colon For all a,a^{\prime}\in AC_{l}(A) we have: \psi(a\cdot a^{\prime})(1_{l}\cdot x)=L_{aa^{\prime}}(1_{l}\cdot x)=(a\cdot a^{\prime})\cdot(1_{l}\cdot x)=(a^{\prime}\cdot 1_{l})\cdot(a\cdot x)\\ =(1_{l}\cdot a)\cdot(a^{\prime}\cdot x)=a\cdot(a^{\prime}\cdot x)=(L_{a}\circ L_{a^{\prime}})(x)=\left(\psi(a)\circ\psi(a^{\prime})\right)(x). In order to prove (B3) , observe firstly that Property is a consequence of Property . Indeed, (a\cdot x)\cdot(y\cdot z)=a\cdot x\cdot y\cdot z=a\cdot((x\cdot y)\cdot z) . It follows that AC_{l}(A)=\{a\in A\mid a\cdot x\cdot z=x\cdot a\cdot z,\ \forall x,z\in A\}. Let a\in AC_{l}(A) . Then, for all x,y,z\in A , we have L_{a}(x)\cdot(y\cdot z)=(a\cdot x)\cdot(y\cdot z)=a\cdot(x\cdot y)\cdot z=(x\cdot y)\cdot a\cdot z=(x\cdot y)\cdot L_{a}(z), and thus (A,L_{a},1_{l}) is hom-associative. Conversely, let \alpha be HA-compatible, that is, let (A,\alpha,1_{l}) be hom-associative. Then, (i) By left unitality (see Table 2 ), \alpha=L_{a} , where a=\alpha(1_{l}) . (ii) By hom-associativity, (a\cdot x)\cdot y\cdot z=x\cdot y\cdot(a\cdot z) . By contracting x\mapsto 1_{l} , we obtain a\cdot y\cdot z=y\cdot a\cdot z , that is, a\in AC_{l}(A) . Finally, let a\in Z(A) . For all x,z\in A , it satisfies: a\cdot x=x\cdot a\Rightarrow(a\cdot x-x\cdot a)\cdot z=0\Rightarrow a\cdot x\cdot z=x\cdot a\cdot z\Rightarrow a\in AC_{l}(A). If (A,1_{l}) is a domain, the reciprocal is also true. Conclusion follows. If (A,1_{l}) is two-sided unital, then from A\cdot A=A follows Z(A\cdot A)=Z(A) and thus AC(A)=HU_{n}^{l}(A) by construction. If (A,1_{l}) is commutative, then it is two-sided unital. Lastly, to prove (B4) , observe that an HA-compatible map is multiplication by an element a\in AC_{l}(A)\cdot 1_{l} . By Theorem 16 , such a map L_{a} is multiplicative if and only if a is idempotent. This completes the proof. ∎ Remark 39 . Observe that E(A) is not a linear subspace: for e_{1},\dots,e_{n}\in E(A) , we have (e_{1}+\dots+e_{n})^{2}=\sum\limits_{i=1}^{n}e_{i}+\sum\limits_{i\neq j}e_{i}e_{j}=\sum\limits_{i=1}^{n}e_{i}+\sum\limits_{i