Intermittency of geometric Brownian motion on SL (n) Sefika Kuzgun, Felix Otto, Christian Wagner Abstract . This short note is motivated by a recently discovered connection between a drift-diffusion process in n n -dimensional Euclidean space with a divergence-free drift sampled from a stationary and isotropic Gaussian ensemble of critical scaling on the one hand, and a geometric Brownian motion on SL ​ ( n ) \textbf{SL}(n) on the other hand. This can be seen as a tensorial form of a stochastic exponential; it thus is naturally intermittent, which transfers to the pair distance of the drift-diffusion process. In this note, we quantify the intermittency of the geometric Brownian motion { F τ } τ ≥ 0 \{F_{\tau}\}_{\tau\geq 0} on SL ​ ( n ) \textbf{SL}(n) also in dimensions n > 2 n>2 . We do so in two (related) ways: 1) by identifying the exponential growth rate for the 2 ​ p 2p -th stochastic moment 𝔼 ​ | F τ | 2 ​ p \mathbb{E}|F_{\tau}|^{2p} with its anomalous dependence on p p (and n n ), and 2) by quantifying a non-tightness of | F τ | 2 / 𝔼 ​ | F τ | 2 |F_{\tau}|^{2}/\mathbb{E}|F_{\tau}|^{2} as τ ↑ ∞ \tau\uparrow\infty . It is the second property that transmits to the drift-diffusion process. The arguments rely on stochastic analysis: We write { F τ } τ ≥ 0 \{F_{\tau}\}_{\tau\geq 0} as the solution of d ​ F = F τ ∘ d ​ B dF=F_{\tau}\circ dB with { B τ } τ ≥ 0 \{B_{\tau}\}_{\tau\geq 0} a Brownian motion on the Lie algebra 𝔰 ​ 𝔩 ​ ( n ) \mathfrak{sl}(n) . The arguments leverage isotropy: The diffusion projects onto the spectrum of the Gram matrix G = F ∗ ​ F G=F^{*}F , as captured by tr ​ G p {\rm tr}G^{p} . 1. Introduction We are interested in the process \{F_{\tau}\}_{\tau\geq 0} that solves the Stratonovich stochastic differential equation (SDE) (1) \displaystyle dF=F_{\tau}\circ dB,\quad F_{\tau=0}=id, where \{B_{\tau}\}_{\tau\geq 0} is a Brownian motion on {\mathfrak{sl}}(n):=\{{\rm tr}B=0\} that satisfies the following three assumptions: (B1) OBO^{-1}=_{\text{law}}B for all O\in\textbf{O}(n):=\{O^{*}O=id\} , (B2) \mathbb{E}[B_{\tau}B_{\tau}]=0 , and (B3) \mathbb{E}[B_{\tau}^{*}B_{\tau}]=\tau\text{id} . Since the chain rule holds for Stratonovich SDEs, F\in\textbf{SL}(n):=\{\text{det}F=1\} . In [ 4 ] , it is proved that for n\geq 2 , there is a unique Brownian motion on \mathfrak{sl}(n) that satisfies the Assumption (B1) - (B3) . We are interested in exploring the intermittent behavior of F in ( 1 ). Our first result is on the moments: Proposition 1 (Intermittency) . For any p\geq 1 integer, we have \displaystyle n\exp\left((p+\frac{2p(p-1)}{n+2})\tau\right)\leq\mathbb{E}|F_{\tau}|^{2p}\leq n^{p}\exp\left((p+\frac{2p(p-1)}{n+2})\tau\right), where |F|^{2}:={\rm tr}F^{*}F denotes the square of the Frobenius norm. Proposition 1 implies that (2) \displaystyle\mathbb{E}|F_{\tau}|^{2p}\sim_{n,p}\left(\mathbb{E}^{p}|F_{\tau}|^{2}\right)^{1+\frac{2(p-1)}{n+2}}. The fact that 2p -th moment scales with a rate much larger than the p -th power of the second moment amounts to strongly non-Gaussian and intermittent behavior. Proposition 1 generalizes [ 4 , Lemma 2] for n=2 to general n\geq 2 . The interest in studying the geometric Brownian motion comes from its intriguing relation to the drift-diffusion process (3) \displaystyle dX=b(X_{t})dt+\sqrt{2}dW with b being a divergence-free and time-independent vector field. One is interested in the case where b is sampled from a stationary and isotropic Gaussian ensemble with the scaling (4) \displaystyle b(\mu\cdot)=\frac{1}{\mu}b\text{ in law for all }\mu>0, in which convection and diffusion balance at every scale. After implementing an ultraviolet cutoff, w.l.o.g. at scale 1, b is fixed up to a single constant which we describe in terms of \mathbb{E}|b|^{2}=\epsilon^{2}\frac{n}{4} , where \epsilon\ll 1 can be interpreted as the Péclet number. It is now well-known that the mean-square displacement displays super-diffusive behavior \frac{1}{2t}\mathbb{E}|X_{t}|^{2}\approx\lambda(t) for t\gg 1 , where \displaystyle\lambda(t):=\sqrt{1+\frac{\epsilon^{2}}{2}\ln(1+t)}. This behavior was rigorously established with increasing precision in [ 6 , 2 , 3 , 1 , 4 ] . The relationship between the geometric Brownian motion process F in ( 1 ) and the drift-diffusion process in ( 3 ) was discovered in [ 4 ] on the level of the expected position, u(x,t) , (w.r.t. W_{t} ) of the process \{X_{t}\}_{t\geq 0} starting from X_{t=0}=x . More precisely, one obtains \nabla u(0,t)\approx F_{\tau(T)} in law on average over t\in(0,T) , where \tau(T):=\ln\lambda(T), see [ 4 , Theorem 2 & (19)] . Our result shows that the intermittency of the drift-diffusion equation depends less on topology (stream lines of the divergence-free b are closed iff n=2 ) and more on geometry ( \textbf{SL}(n) has less curvature as n increases). While Proposition 1 clearly expresses intermittency at the level of F , we are not able to transfer this higher-moment information to \nabla u . This is because we can capture the proximity of \nabla u and F only on the second moments. Hence we need to capture the shadow of the intermittency on the level of the second moment. In fact, it comes as a non-tightness result in the second moment in the sense that the extreme tails contain a substantial fraction of the second moment. Proposition 2 (Non-tightness) . For \tau\gg_{n}1 2 2 2 Here \tau\gg_{n}1 means that there is a possibly large constant C(n) depending only on n such that the statement is true for any \tau with \tau\geq C(n) . , we have (5) \displaystyle\mathbb{E}|F_{\tau}|^{2}I\Big({\textstyle\frac{1}{n}}|F_{\tau}|^{2}\leq{\textstyle\frac{1}{e}}\big({\textstyle\mathbb{E}\frac{1}{n}}|F_{\tau}|^{2}\big)^{\frac{n+4}{n+2}}\Big)\leq\Big(\frac{1}{2}+\frac{C(n)}{\sqrt{\tau}}\Big)\mathbb{E}|F_{\tau}|^{2}. where I(A) is the indicator function of the event A . Remark 3 . The information in Proposition 2 can easily be upgraded to the lower bound as is done in [ 4 , Theorem 3 & (118)] \displaystyle\mathbb{E}|F_{\tau}|^{2p}\gtrsim_{n,p}\mathbb{E}^{1+\frac{n+4}{n+2}(p-1)}|F_{\tau}|^{2}, which is weaker than ( 2 ) but not completely unrelated. This exponent is precisely the linearization of the quadratic exponent p+\frac{2p(p-1)}{n+2} around p=1 . The results in Propositions 1 and 2 were previously proven in the case n=2 (see [ 4 , Lemma 2, Lemma 4] ). The argument relied on the fact that the law of R=\frac{1}{2}{\rm tr}F^{*}F can be identified as the Itô evolution \displaystyle dR=R_{\tau}d\tau+\sqrt{R_{\tau}^{2}-1}dw,\quad R_{\tau=0}=1, where \{w_{\tau}\}_{\tau\geq 0} is a one-dimensional Brownian motion. In any dimension n , as a consequence of the \textbf{O}(n) -invariance, it is not difficult to see that one obtains an evolution for the (n-1) quantities {\rm tr}F^{*}F,{\rm tr}(F^{*}F)^{2},\dots,{\rm tr}(F^{*}F)^{n-1} . However, we are unable to leverage this evolution in order to characterize the evolution of R . In this paper, we take a different route: Relying on the observation that the quantities \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}(F^{*}F)^{2} and \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{2}F^{*}F satisfy a linear system of ODEs which is closed in any dimension n and can be solved explicitly, we learn that \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}(F^{*}F)^{2} can be well approximated by \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{2}F^{*}F . This in turn allows us to approximately close the equation for R in dimensions n>2 . Note that |F_{\tau}|^{2} is close to a stochastic exponential, which is consistent with Proposition 1 and 2 , namely \ln|F_{\tau}|^{2} behaves like a Gaussian random variable with mean (1-\frac{2}{n+2})\tau and variance \frac{4\tau}{n+2} . 2. Strategy of Proof Assumptions (B1) - (B3) on the Brownian motion B can be equivalently expressed in terms of the geometric Brownian motion F as follows: Lemma 4 ( [ 4 ] , Lemma 1) . Let \{F_{\tau}\}_{\tau\geq 0} be the solution to SDE ( 1 ) where \{B_{\tau}\}_{\tau\geq 0} satisfies Assumptions (B1) - (B3) . Then (F1) Isotropy: OFO^{-1}=_{\text{law}}F for all O\in\textbf{O}(n) , (F2) Itô=Stratonovich: F_{\tau}\circ dB=F_{\tau}dB , (F3) Normalization: \mathbb{E}[|F_{\tau}|^{2}]=ne^{\tau} . Observe that (F3) is nothing but Proposition 1 for p=1 in which case the upper and lower bounds coincide. It turns out to be convenient to work with the Gram matrix (6) \displaystyle G:=F^{*}F\quad\text{ so that }\quad|F|^{2}={\rm tr}G. Note that G is symmetric and positive definite; its square root appears in the polar factorization of F . Hence passing from F to G amounts to work with the quotient space \textbf{SL}(n)/\textbf{SO}(n) of the Lie group \textbf{SL}(n) by its maximal compact subgroup \textbf{SO}(n) as advocated by differential geometers. Since in particular G is diagonalizable with nonnegative eigenvalues, we have the inequality (7) \displaystyle{\rm tr}G^{p}\leq{\rm tr}^{p}G\quad\text{for }p\geq 1. It turns out to be convenient to monitor {\rm tr}G^{p} next to {\rm tr}^{p}G=|F|^{2p} . The Stratonovich evolution for G , G^{2} are easily derived: (8) \displaystyle dG \displaystyle=G_{\tau}\circ dB+\circ dB^{*}G_{\tau}, (9) \displaystyle dG^{2} \displaystyle=G_{\tau}\circ dBG_{\tau}+G^{2}_{\tau}\circ dB+\circ dB^{*}G^{2}_{\tau}+G_{\tau}\circ dB^{*}G_{\tau}. Taking the trace in ( 8 ) and ( 9 ) and using the cyclic property {\rm tr}GB={\rm tr}BG for any matrices G and B , makes the symmetric part of B appear (10) \displaystyle d{\rm tr}G \displaystyle={\rm tr}G_{\tau}(\circ dB+\circ dB^{*})=2{\rm tr}G_{\tau}\circ dB_{sym}, (11) \displaystyle d{\rm tr}G^{2} \displaystyle=2{\rm tr}G^{2}_{\tau}(\circ dB+\circ dB^{*})=4{\rm tr}G^{2}_{\tau}\circ dB_{sym}. Using the chain rule for Stratonovich integral, we also have (12) \displaystyle d{\rm tr}^{2}G \displaystyle=4{\rm tr}G_{\tau}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}\circ dB_{sym}. The following lemma characterizes B_{sym} . Lemma 5 ( [ 4 ] ,(74)) . Let \{B_{\tau}\}_{\tau\geq 0} be a Brownian motion on \mathfrak{sl}(n) satisfying Assumptions (B1) - (B3) . Then the symmetric part B_{sym}:=\frac{B+B^{*}}{2} and skew-symmetric part B_{skew}:=\frac{B-B^{*}}{2} are independent Brownian motions with the property that (13) \displaystyle\mathbb{E}[B_{sym,\tau}^{2}]=-\mathbb{E}[B_{skew,\tau}^{2}]=\frac{\tau id}{2}. In order to pass from the Stratonovich to the Itô formulation, we need to compute Itô-Stratonovich correction terms and quadratic variations. Let us start with ( 10 ), which using ( 8 ) has the correction: 3 3 3 For brevity and ease of notation, we purposefully avoid using d[{\rm tr}\int_{0}^{\cdot}G_{\tau}dB\,B_{sym}] in favor of d[{\rm tr}GBB_{sym}] . This is justified by the following computational rule for Itô integrals: Given a linear form f , we can define the quadratic variation [f(\cdot\,BB_{sym})] as the linear map G\mapsto[f(G\,BB_{sym})] . Equipped with this definition we have \displaystyle\Big[f\big(\int_{0}^{\cdot}G_{\tau}dB\,B_{sym}\big)\Big]=\int_{0}^{\cdot}G_{\tau}.d[f(\cdot\,BB_{sym})]. In words: to compute the variation [{\rm tr}\int_{0}^{\cdot}GdB\,B_{sym}] , we replace G by a deterministic objects, and integrate the result against the process G . (14) \displaystyle\begin{aligned} d[{\rm tr}GB_{sym}]&=d[{\rm tr}G(BB_{sym}+B_{sym}B^{*})]\\ &=d[{\rm tr}G(B_{sym}^{2}+B_{skew}B_{sym}+B_{sym}^{2}-B_{sym}B_{skew})]\\ &=2d[{\rm tr}GB^{2}_{sym}]\overset{\eqref{Bsymvar}}{=}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}d\tau.\end{aligned} Hence the Itô formulation of the equation ( 10 ) becomes (15) \displaystyle d{\rm tr}G \displaystyle=2{\rm tr}G_{\tau}dB_{sym}+{\rm tr}G_{\tau}d\tau. The quadratic variation of the martingale part is 4d[{\rm tr}GB_{sym}{\rm tr}GB_{sym}] . The following lemma will be used to characterize this quadratic variation as well as the variations coming from equations ( 11 ), ( 12 ). The nontrivial dependence on dimension n arises from this lemma the proof of which relies on combinatorial arguments. Lemma 6 . For any symmetric matrices G,\tilde{G} , we have (16) \displaystyle d\left[{\rm tr}GB_{sym}{\rm tr}\tilde{G}B_{sym}\right] \displaystyle=\frac{d\tau}{\alpha_{n}}\left(n{\rm tr}G\tilde{G}-{\rm tr}G{\rm tr}\tilde{G}\right), (17) \displaystyle d\left[{\rm tr}GB_{sym}\tilde{G}B_{sym}\right] \displaystyle=\frac{d\tau}{2\alpha_{n}}\left((n-2){\rm tr}G\tilde{G}+n{\rm tr}G{\rm tr}\tilde{G}\right), where (18) \displaystyle\alpha_{n}:=(n-1)(n+2). Using Lemma 6 , the quadratic variation of the martingale part of the equation ( 15 ) becomes (19) \displaystyle d[{\rm tr}GB_{sym}{\rm tr}GB_{sym}]=\frac{1}{\alpha_{n}}(n{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}-{\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau})d\tau. Moreover, the Itô form of the equation ( 11 ) becomes (20) \displaystyle d{\rm tr}G^{2}=4{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}dB_{sym}+\frac{2n}{\alpha_{n}}{\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}d\tau+\left(2+\frac{2(n-2)}{\alpha_{n}}\right){\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}d\tau. More details on the computation of the correction is given after ( 45 ). Note that this is not closed because of the presence of {\rm tr}^{2}G . Similarly, using the Itô formula, one sees (21) \displaystyle\begin{aligned} d{\rm tr}^{2}G&=4{\rm tr}G_{\tau}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}dB_{\text{sym}}+2{\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}d\tau+\frac{4}{\alpha_{n}}(n{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}-{\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau})d\tau\\ &=4{\rm tr}G_{\tau}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}dB_{\text{sym}}+\left(2-\frac{4}{\alpha_{n}}\right){\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}d\tau+\frac{4n}{\alpha_{n}}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}d\tau.\end{aligned} Doing similar computations on integer powers leads to the following differential equations on the level of expectations: Lemma 7 . Let \{F_{\tau}\}_{\tau\geq 0} be the process satisfying ( 1 ) and recall that G=F^{*}F . Then we have (22) \displaystyle\frac{d\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{p}G}{d\tau} \displaystyle=(p-\frac{2p(p-1)}{\alpha_{n}})\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{p}G_{\tau}+\frac{2p(p-1)n}{\alpha_{n}}\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{p-2}G_{\tau}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2} for any p>0 and (23) \displaystyle\frac{d\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G^{p}}{d\tau}=(p+\frac{p(p-1)(n-2)}{\alpha_{n}})\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}+\frac{pn}{\alpha_{n}}\sum_{j=1}^{p-1}\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{j}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p-j} for p\geq 1 integer. With these equations at hand, we are practically done by using inequality ( 7 ) or variants of it to get (24) \displaystyle ne^{(p+\frac{2p(p-1)}{n+2})\tau}\leq\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}\leq\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{p}G_{\tau}\leq n^{p}e^{(p+\frac{2p(p-1)}{n+2})\tau}, which transfers to F , yielding Proposition 1 . Now let us discuss the proof of Proposition 2 . The observation to implement the proof established in [ 5 ] in case n>2 is delicate. A priori, the Itô evolutions satisfied by observables of {\rm tr}G , say \zeta(\tau,R) for R={\rm tr}G are not closed similarly to ( 20 ). However only in n=2 , this system reduces to a single evolution of R={\rm tr}G because {\rm tr}G^{2}=4({\rm tr}^{2}G-\det G) , and only then were we able to deduce intermittency using R , see [ 4 , Section 3] . Instead, we take a different road: It is based on the observation that the expectations, \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau} , \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2} satisfy a closed linear system of ODEs which can be solved explicitly. Lemma 8 . It holds \displaystyle\frac{d}{d\tau}\begin{bmatrix}\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{2}G\\ \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G^{2}\end{bmatrix}=A\begin{bmatrix}\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}\\ \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}\end{bmatrix},\quad\quad\begin{bmatrix}\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau=0}\\ \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G_{\tau=0}^{2}\end{bmatrix}=\begin{bmatrix}n^{2}\\ n\end{bmatrix} where \displaystyle A=(2-\frac{4}{\alpha_{n}})\begin{bmatrix}1&0\\ 0&1\end{bmatrix}+\frac{2n}{\alpha_{n}}\begin{bmatrix}0&2\\ 1&1\end{bmatrix}. The matrix A has the eigenvalues \lambda_{1}=2+\frac{4}{n+2}>\lambda_{2}=2-\frac{2}{n-1} with left eigenvectors v_{1}=\begin{bmatrix}1\\ 2\end{bmatrix} and v_{2}=\begin{bmatrix}1\\ -1\end{bmatrix} . As a consequence, for all \tau>0 , (25) \displaystyle\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}-\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}=n(n-1)e^{\lambda_{2}\tau}. The identity ( 25 ) reveals that the difference \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}-\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G^{2}_{\tau} grows at a slower exponential rate than either \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau} or \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G^{2}_{\tau} both of which grows like e^{\lambda_{1}\tau} . This observation enables us to write an approximate Itô evolution for (26) \displaystyle R_{\tau}:={\rm tr}G_{\tau}. Indeed, recall from ( 15 ) and ( 19 ) that R satisfies (27) \displaystyle dR=2{\rm tr}G_{\tau}dB_{sym}+R_{\tau}d\tau,\quad\quad R_{\tau=0}=n, with quadratic variation \displaystyle d[RR] \displaystyle=\frac{4}{\alpha_{n}}(n{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}-R^{2}_{\tau})d\tau. By definition of \alpha_{n} , see ( 18 ), this can be rewritten as (28) \displaystyle d[RR] \displaystyle=\frac{4}{n+2}R_{\tau}^{2}d\tau+\frac{4n}{\alpha_{n}}({\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}-{\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau})d\tau. By the above lemma it is legitimate to neglect the last term in ( 28 ) to obtain the approximate SDE (29) \displaystyle dR\approx\frac{2}{\sqrt{n+2}}R_{\tau}dw+R_{\tau}d\tau,\quad\quad R_{\tau=0}=n, where w is a one-dimensional Brownian motion. Hence, R is approximately a geometric Brownian motion ne^{(1-\frac{2}{n+2})\tau+\frac{2}{\sqrt{n+2}}w_{\tau}} , which is consistent with the observation that \ln R=\ln|F|^{2} is close to being normal with mean (1-\frac{2}{n+2})\tau and variance \frac{4\tau}{n+2} as claimed in the introduction. This motivates us to consider the following change of variables (30) \displaystyle R=ne^{\tau}\hat{R}, under which ( 29 ) turns into (31) \displaystyle d\hat{R}\approx\frac{2}{\sqrt{n+2}}\hat{R}_{\tau}dw,\quad\quad\hat{R}_{\tau=0}=1. To capture the above approximation more quantitatively, we consider an observable \zeta=\zeta(\tau,r) solving the Kolmogorov backward PDE ( 29 ) for R (when treating ( 29 ) as an exact equality) (32) \displaystyle\frac{\partial\zeta}{\partial\tau}+r\frac{\partial\zeta}{\partial r}+\frac{2}{n+2}r^{2}\frac{\partial^{2}\zeta}{\partial r^{2}}=0. Using the change of variables ( 30 ) on the level of the variables r , \hat{r} (i.e. r=ne^{\tau}\hat{r} ) the PDE ( 32 ) transforms into 4 4 4 We will detail the upcoming computations in the proof of Lemma 9 . (33) \displaystyle\frac{\partial\zeta}{\partial\tau}+\frac{2}{n+2}\hat{r}^{2}\frac{\partial^{2}\zeta}{\partial\hat{r}^{2}}=0, which is the Kolmogorov equation for ( 31 ). The form of the observable in Proposition 2 also motivates us to make the ansatz that (34) \displaystyle\zeta(\tau,\hat{r})=\hat{r}\hat{\zeta}(\tau,\hat{r}) with \hat{\zeta} that solves (35) \displaystyle\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\tau}+2\hat{r}\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{r}}+\frac{2}{n+2}\hat{r}^{2}\frac{\partial^{2}\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{r}^{2}}=0. Finally, due to the structure of ( 35 ) it is natural to introduce the variable (36) \displaystyle\hat{\sigma}=\ln\hat{r}, w.r.t. which ( 35 ) takes form ( 37 ) below. Lemma 9 . Suppose \hat{\zeta}=\hat{\zeta}(\tau,\hat{\sigma}) solves (37) \displaystyle\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\tau}+\frac{2}{n+2}\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}}+\frac{2}{n+2}\frac{\partial^{2}\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}^{2}}=0, then (38) \displaystyle\mathbb{E}\hat{R}\hat{\zeta}(\tau,\hat{R})-\hat{\zeta}(\tau=0,\hat{r}=1)\lesssim_{n}\int_{0}^{\tau}d\tau^{\prime}e^{-(1-\frac{\lambda_{2}}{2})\tau^{\prime}}\sup_{\hat{\sigma}}\left|\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}}+\frac{\partial^{2}\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}^{2}}\right|, where \lambda_{2} is defined in Lemma 8 . Note that \lambda_{2}<2 is important to leverage ( 38 ) in the proof of Proposition 2 . 3. Proofs 3.1. Proofs of Lemmas Proof of Lemma 6 . Recall that the space of symmetric bilinear forms on \{G:G^{*}=G\} that are invariant under conjugation by \textbf{O}(n) is two dimensional and spanned by {\rm tr}G\tilde{G} and {\rm tr}G{\rm tr}\tilde{G} , see for example [ 4 , Lemma 16] for a proof. Note that (G,\tilde{G})\mapsto\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}GB_{sym,\tau}{\rm tr}\tilde{G}B_{sym,\tau} is such a symmetric bilinear form thanks to the \textbf{O}(n) invariance in law of B in (B1) , which transmits to B_{sym} . Since B_{sym} is a Brownian motion, its tensorial quadratic covariation agrees with its second moment, which grow linearly in \tau ; hence for non-random G,\tilde{G} , [{\rm tr}GB_{sym}{\rm tr}\tilde{G}B_{sym}]_{\tau}=\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}GB_{sym,\tau}{\rm tr}\tilde{G}B_{sym,\tau}=\text{const}\,\tau. As a consequence, we have (39) \displaystyle d[{\rm tr}GB_{sym}{\rm tr}\tilde{G}B_{sym}]=(a_{n}{\rm tr}G\tilde{G}+b_{n}{\rm tr}G{\rm tr}\tilde{G})d\tau for some constants a_{n},b_{n} only depending on n . In order to find a_{n},b_{n} , we start with the choice G=\tilde{G}=id . On the one hand, we have d[{\rm tr}B_{sym}{\rm tr}B_{sym}]=0 and on the other hand na_{n} and n^{2}b_{n} which this leads to (40) \displaystyle 0=na_{n}+n^{2}b_{n}. Second, we test with G=\tilde{G}=e_{i}\otimes e^{j}+e_{j}\otimes e^{i} (without implicit sum), where e^{i}=e_{i}^{*} denotes the dual basis. On one hand, (41) \displaystyle B_{sym}G \displaystyle=e_{i}\otimes B_{sym}e^{j}+e_{j}\otimes B_{sym}e^{i} and by the cyclic property of the trace and the symmetry of B_{sym} , we have \displaystyle{\rm tr}GB_{sym} \displaystyle={\rm tr}B_{sym}G=B_{sym}e^{j}.e_{i}+B_{sym}e^{i}.e_{j}=2B_{sym}e^{i}.e_{j} which leads to \displaystyle d[{\rm tr}GB_{sym}{\rm tr}\tilde{G}B_{sym}]=4d[(B_{sym}e^{i}.e_{j})(B_{sym}e^{i}.e_{j})]. Summing i,j over \{1,\dots,n\} , the left-hand side of the equation ( 39 ) becomes 4d[{\rm tr}B_{sym}^{2}] which is equal to 2nd\tau by (42) \displaystyle[{\rm tr}B^{2}_{sym}]_{\tau}=\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}B_{sym,\tau}^{2}=\frac{n\tau}{2}. On the other hand, we have \displaystyle{\rm tr}G \displaystyle=e^{j}.e_{i}+e^{i}.e_{j}=2\delta_{i}^{j},\quad\quad\text{ and thus}, \displaystyle{\rm tr}^{2}G \displaystyle=4\delta_{i}^{j}, \displaystyle G^{2} \displaystyle=\delta_{i}^{j}(e_{i}\otimes e^{j}+e_{j}\otimes e^{i})+e_{i}\otimes e^{i}+e_{j}\otimes e^{j},\text{ and thus}, \displaystyle{\rm tr}G^{2} \displaystyle=2\delta_{i}^{j}+2. Again summing over i,j for {\rm tr}^{2}G and {\rm tr}G^{2} , and then plugging in ( 39 ) we get that (43) \displaystyle 2n=2n(n+1)a_{n}+4nb_{n}. The system ( 40 ), ( 43 ) has the solution \displaystyle a_{n}=\frac{n}{\alpha_{n}}\quad\text{and}\quad b_{n}=-\frac{1}{\alpha_{n}} where \alpha_{n} is as defined in ( 18 ). Hence, finally using ( 13 ) leads to ( 16 ) in Lemma 8 . Similarly, the bilinear form \displaystyle(G,\tilde{G})\mapsto\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}GB_{sym,\tau}\tilde{G}B_{sym,\tau} is \textbf{O}(n) invariant by \textbf{O}(n) invariance in law of B in (B1) . Moreover, it is symmetric thanks to the cyclic property of the trace. So, by the same argument as above, we can write \displaystyle d[{\rm tr}GB_{sym}\tilde{G}B_{sym}]=(a_{n}{\rm tr}G\tilde{G}+b_{n}{\rm tr}G{\rm tr}\tilde{G})d\tau for some constants a_{n} , and b_{n} depending only on n . In order to find them, we will test on the same pair of matrices. This in turn implies that the right-hand sides of the equations stay the same. Let us compute the left-hand sides: For G=\tilde{G}=id , we have d[{\rm tr}GB_{sym}\tilde{G}B_{sym}]=\frac{n}{2}d\tau by ( 42 ) and for G=\tilde{G}=e_{i}\otimes e^{j}+e_{j}\otimes e^{i} , using ( 41 ) we have \displaystyle B_{sym}GB_{sym}G \displaystyle=B_{sym}e^{j}.e_{i}e_{i}\otimes B_{sym}e^{j}+B_{sym}e^{i}.e_{j}e_{j}\otimes B_{sym}e^{i} \displaystyle+B_{sym}e^{j}.e_{j}e_{i}\otimes B_{sym}e^{i}+B_{sym}e^{i}.e_{i}e_{j}\otimes B_{sym}e^{j} and taking the trace and using the symmetry of B_{sym} , we get \displaystyle{\rm tr}B_{sym}GB_{sym}\tilde{G}={\rm tr}GB_{sym}\tilde{G}B_{sym}=2B_{sym}e^{j}.e_{i}B_{sym}e^{j}.e_{i}+2B_{sym}e^{i}.e_{i}B_{sym}e^{j}.e_{j}. Finally summing over i,j , the left-hand side of the equation becomes \displaystyle\sum_{i,j=1}^{n}d[{\rm tr}GB_{sym}GB_{sym}]=2d[{\rm tr}B_{sym}^{2}]+\underbrace{2d[{\rm tr}B_{sym}{\rm tr}B_{sym}}_{=0}]=2d[{\rm tr}B_{sym}^{2}]=nd\tau where we have used ( 42 ) again. Hence we obtain the following system for a_{n} and b_{n} \displaystyle\frac{n}{2} \displaystyle=na_{n}+n^{2}b_{n}, \displaystyle n \displaystyle=2n(n+1)a_{n}+4nb_{n}, which has the solution \displaystyle a_{n}=\frac{n-2}{2\alpha_{n}},\quad\text{and}\quad b_{n}=\frac{n}{2\alpha_{n}} and we obtain the second claim ( 17 ) in Lemma 8 . \Box Proof of Lemma 7 . Note that G_{\tau} and G^{2}_{\tau} satisfy ( 8 ), ( 9 ) and more generally for p\geq 1 integer, G_{\tau}^{p} satisfies (44) \displaystyle dG^{p} \displaystyle=\sum_{j=1}^{p}G_{\tau}^{j-1}dGG_{\tau}^{p-j}=\sum_{j=1}^{p}G_{\tau}^{j}\circ dBG_{\tau}^{p-j}+\sum_{j=1}^{p}G_{\tau}^{j-1}\circ dB^{*}G_{\tau}^{p-j+1}. Taking the trace in ( 44 ), and using cyclic property of the trace, we get the following Stratonovich SDE: \displaystyle d{\rm tr}G^{p}={\rm tr}dG^{p}=p{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}(\circ dB+\circ dB^{*})=2p{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}\circ dB_{{sym}}. Now, we want to switch to the Itô formulation which can be done using the Itô-Stratonovich correction term as follows: (45) \displaystyle d{\rm tr}G^{p}=2p{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}\circ dB_{{sym}}=2p{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}dB_{{sym}}+pd[{\rm tr}G^{p}B_{{sym}}] where using ( 44 ) we see \displaystyle\begin{aligned} d[{\rm tr}G^{p}B_{sym}]&=d[{\rm tr}\left(\sum_{j=1}^{p}G^{j}BG^{p-j}+G^{j-1}B^{*}G^{p-j+1}\right)B_{sym}]\\ &=d[{\rm tr}(G^{p}BB_{sym}+B^{*}G^{p}B_{sym})+\sum_{j=1}^{p-1}{\rm tr}G^{j}(B+B^{*})G^{p-j}B_{sym}].\end{aligned} Together with the cyclic property of the trace, we rewrite it as (46) \displaystyle\begin{aligned} d[{\rm tr}G^{p}B_{sym}]=d[{\rm tr}G^{p}(BB_{sym}+B_{sym}B^{*})+2\sum_{j=1}^{p-1}{\rm tr}G^{j}B_{sym}G^{p-j}B_{sym}].\end{aligned} We can also replace B , B^{*} in the first two terms using B_{sym},B_{skew} and thanks to their independence, see Lemma 5 , we obtain (47) \displaystyle\begin{aligned} &d[{\rm tr}G^{p}(BB_{sym}+B_{sym}B^{*})]\\ &=d[{\rm tr}G^{p}(B_{sym}^{2}+B_{skew}B_{sym}+B_{sym}^{2}-B_{sym}B_{skew})]\\ &=2d[{\rm tr}G^{p}B^{2}_{sym}]\overset{\eqref{Bsymvar}}{=}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}d\tau.\end{aligned} Inserting ( 47 ) and ( 17 ) in ( 46 ), we finally get (48) \displaystyle\begin{aligned} d[{\rm tr}G^{p}B_{sym}]&={\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}d\tau+\frac{1}{\alpha_{n}}\sum_{j=1}^{p-1}\left((n-2){\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}+n{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{j}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p-j}\right)d\tau\\ &=(1+\frac{(p-1)(n-2)}{\alpha_{n}}){\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}d\tau+\frac{n}{\alpha_{n}}\sum_{j=1}^{p-1}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{j}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p-j}d\tau.\end{aligned} Plugging ( 48 ) into ( 45 ), we get the Itô-SDE for {\rm tr}G^{p} : (49) \displaystyle d{\rm tr}G^{p}=2p{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}dB_{sym}+(p+\frac{p(p-1)(n-2)}{\alpha_{n}}){\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}d\tau+\frac{pn}{\alpha_{n}}\sum_{j=1}^{p-1}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{j}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p-j}d\tau. Using the Itô formula with the function f(x)=x^{p} in ( 15 ) and the quadratic variation ( 19 ), we have (50) \displaystyle\begin{aligned} d{\rm tr}^{p}G=2p{\rm tr}^{p-1}\;G_{\tau}{\rm tr}\;G_{\tau}dB_{\text{sym}}+\left(p-\frac{2p(p-1)}{\alpha_{n}}\right){\rm tr}^{p}\;G_{\tau}d\tau+\frac{2np(p-1)}{\alpha_{n}}{\rm tr}^{p-2}\;G_{\tau}{\rm tr}\;G_{\tau}^{2}d\tau.\end{aligned} Finally, taking the expectations in ( 50 ) and ( 49 ) concludes the proof. \Box Proof of Lemma 9 . We start from ( 27 ) and ( 28 ) that imply for \zeta=\zeta(\tau,R_{\tau}) \displaystyle d\zeta \displaystyle=\text{martingale}+\Big(\frac{\partial\zeta}{\partial\tau}+R_{\tau}\frac{\partial\zeta}{\partial r}\Big)d\tau+\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial^{2}\zeta}{\partial r^{2}}d[R\,R] (51) \displaystyle=\text{martingale}+\Big(\frac{\partial\zeta}{\partial\tau}+R_{\tau}\frac{\partial\zeta}{\partial r}+\frac{2}{n+2}R_{\tau}^{2}\frac{\partial^{2}\zeta}{\partial r^{2}}\Big)d\tau+\frac{2n}{\alpha_{n}}\Big({\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}-{\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}\Big)\frac{\partial^{2}\zeta}{\partial r^{2}}d\tau. Due to the term {\rm tr}G^{2} , this differential equation ( 3.1 ) even on the level of expectation is not closed. To overcome this, we will invoke Lemma 8 , more specifically identity ( 25 ). Choosing our observable \zeta in ( 3.1 ) according to ( 32 ) as we argued to be equivalent to ( 37 ) the sum in the first parenthesis vanishes. Indeed, recall from ( 30 ), ( 34 ) and ( 36 ) that we change variables according to \displaystyle r=ne^{\tau}\hat{r},\quad\zeta=\hat{r}\,\hat{\zeta},\quad\hat{\sigma}=\ln\hat{r}, so that \frac{\partial}{\partial r}=e^{-\tau}\frac{1}{n}\frac{\partial}{\partial\hat{r}} , \frac{\partial}{\partial\hat{r}}=\frac{1}{\hat{r}}\frac{\partial}{\partial\hat{\sigma}} and readily (52) \displaystyle\frac{\partial\zeta}{\partial\tau}=\hat{r}\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\tau}-\hat{r}\Big(\hat{\zeta}+\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}}\Big),\quad r\frac{\partial\zeta}{\partial r}=\hat{r}\Big(1+\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}}\Big),\quad r^{2}\frac{\partial^{2}\zeta}{\partial r^{2}}=\hat{r}\Big(\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}}+\frac{\partial^{2}\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}^{2}}\Big). Thus, for the term of our interest \displaystyle\frac{\partial\zeta}{\partial\tau}+r\frac{\partial\zeta}{\partial r}+\frac{2}{n+2}r^{2}\frac{\partial^{2}\zeta}{\partial r^{2}}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle(\ref{Trafo})}}{{=}}\hat{r}\Big(\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\tau}+\frac{2}{n+2}\Big(\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}}+\frac{\partial^{2}\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}^{2}}\Big)\Big), which makes the operator in ( 37 ) appear, and ( 3.1 ) implies the preliminary (53) \displaystyle\frac{d\mathbb{E}\zeta}{d\tau}\lesssim_{n}\sup_{\hat{\sigma}}\Big|r\frac{\partial^{2}\zeta}{\partial r^{2}}\,\Big|\,\mathbb{E}\frac{1}{R_{\tau}}\big({\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}-{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}\big)\stackrel{{\scriptstyle(\ref{Trafo})}}{{\approx_{n}}}\sup_{\hat{\sigma}}e^{-\tau}\Big|\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}}+\frac{\partial^{2}\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}^{2}}\Big|\,\mathbb{E}\frac{1}{R_{\tau}}\big({\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}-{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}\big). On the remaining expectation we use the elementary inequality \displaystyle 0\leq\frac{1}{R_{\tau}}\big({\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}-{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}\big)\stackrel{{\scriptstyle(\ref{R})}}{{=}}\frac{1}{{\rm tr}G_{\tau}}\big({\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}-{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}\big)\leq\sqrt{{\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}-{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2}}, so that by Jensen’s inequality and Lemma 8 \displaystyle\mathbb{E}\frac{1}{R_{\tau}}\big({\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}-{\rm tr}G^{2}_{\tau}\big)\leq\sqrt{\mathbb{E}({\rm tr}^{2}G_{\tau}-{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2})}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle(\ref{difference})}}{{\lesssim_{n}}}e^{\frac{\lambda_{2}}{2}\tau}. Hence ( 53 ) turns into: \displaystyle\frac{d\mathbb{E}\hat{R}\hat{\zeta}}{d\tau}\lesssim_{n}e^{-(1-\frac{\lambda_{2}}{2})\tau}\sup_{\hat{\sigma}}\Big|\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}}+\frac{\partial^{2}\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}^{2}}\Big|. Integrating the estimate and using the second item in ( 31 ) yields the claim in ( 38 ). \Box 3.2. Proof of Proposition 1 Recall from Lemma 7 , we have for p\geq 1 integer \displaystyle\frac{d\mathbb{E}[{\rm tr}G^{p}]}{d\tau}=(p+\frac{p(p-1)(n-2)}{\alpha_{n}})\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}+\frac{pn}{\alpha_{n}}\sum_{j=1}^{p-1}\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{j}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p-j} with initial condition {\rm tr}G_{\tau=0}={\rm tr}id=n . Using {\rm tr}G^{j}{\rm tr}G^{p-j}\geq{\rm tr}G^{p} for 0\leq j\leq p , we can bound the second term \displaystyle\sum_{j=1}^{p-1}\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{j}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p-j}\geq(p-1)\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p} which leads to the differential inequality \displaystyle\frac{d\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G^{p}}{d\tau}\geq(p+\frac{p(p-1)(2n-2)}{\alpha_{n}})\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p} where \alpha_{n} is as defined ( 18 ). Hence we get \displaystyle\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{p}\geq ne^{(p+\frac{2p(p-1)}{n+2})\tau}. On the other hand, recall again from Lemma 7 , \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{p}G_{\tau} satisfies \displaystyle\frac{d\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{p}G}{d\tau} \displaystyle=(p-\frac{2p(p-1)}{\alpha_{n}})\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{p}G_{\tau}+\frac{2p(p-1)n}{\alpha_{n}}\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{p-2}G_{\tau}{\rm tr}G_{\tau}^{2} with initial condition \mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{p}G_{\tau=0}=n^{p} . This time using {\rm tr}G^{2}\leq{\rm tr}^{2}G , we get the differential inequality \displaystyle\frac{d\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{p}G}{d\tau} \displaystyle\leq(p+\frac{p(p-1)(2n-2)}{\alpha_{n}})\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{p}G_{\tau} which leads to \displaystyle\mathbb{E}{\rm tr}^{p}G_{\tau}\leq n^{p}e^{(p+\frac{2p(p-1)}{n+2})\tau}. Hence we obtain ( 24 ) which is a restatement of Proposition 1 . ∎ 3.3. Proof of Proposition 2 For parameters \tau^{*}\geq 0 and \hat{\sigma}^{*} that we will choose later we consider the terminal condition (54) \displaystyle\hat{\zeta}(\tau^{*},\hat{\sigma})\begin{cases}=1,\text{ if }\hat{\sigma}\leq\hat{\sigma}^{*},\\ \in[0,1]\text{ for all }\hat{\sigma},\\ =0,\text{ if }\hat{\sigma}\geq\hat{\sigma}^{*}+1,\end{cases}\text{ with }\left|\frac{\partial^{2}\hat{\zeta}(\tau^{*},\hat{\sigma})}{\partial\hat{\sigma}^{2}}\right|\lesssim 1 for the equation ( 37 ) in Lemma 9 . It is readily seen from ( 54 ) that we have (55) \displaystyle\mathbb{E}\hat{R}_{\tau^{*}}\hat{\zeta}(\tau^{*},\hat{R}_{\tau^{*}})\stackrel{{\scriptstyle(\ref{tc})}}{{\geq}}\mathbb{E}\hat{R}_{\tau^{*}}I(\hat{R}_{\tau^{*}}\leq\hat{R}^{*})\quad\text{provided}\quad\hat{\sigma}^{*}=:\ln\hat{R}^{*}. Our goal is to choose \hat{\sigma}^{*} large enough so that at initial time \tau=0 it holds (56) \displaystyle\hat{\zeta}(\tau=0,\hat{\sigma}=0)\leq\frac{1}{2}, so that Lemma 9 implies (57) \displaystyle\mathbb{E}\hat{R}_{\tau^{*}}I(\hat{R}_{\tau^{*}}\leq\hat{R}^{*})-\frac{1}{2}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle(\ref{ononehand})}}{{\leq}}\mathbb{E}\hat{R}_{\tau^{*}}\hat{\zeta}(\tau^{*},\hat{R}_{\tau^{*}})-\frac{1}{2}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\eqref{zetahatineq}\&(\ref{initial})}}{{\lesssim_{n}}}\int_{0}^{\tau^{*}}d\tau\,e^{-(1-\frac{\lambda_{2}}{2})\tau}\sup_{\hat{\sigma}}\left|\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}}+\frac{\partial^{2}\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}^{2}}\right|. To obtain ( 56 ) let us note that the heat kernel for ( 37 ) with terminal data at \tau^{*} is a Gaussian with mean -\frac{2}{n+2}(\tau^{*}-\tau) and variance \frac{4}{n+2}(\tau^{*}-\tau) . Moreover, by ( 54 ) we know \hat{\zeta}(\tau^{*},\hat{\sigma})\leq I(\hat{\sigma}\leq\hat{\sigma}^{*}+1) so that by the comparison principle we have \displaystyle\hat{\zeta}(\tau,\hat{\sigma})\leq\Phi\Big(\frac{-\hat{\sigma}+\hat{\sigma}^{*}+1-\frac{2}{n+2}(\tau^{*}-\tau)}{\sqrt{\frac{4}{n+2}(\tau^{*}-\tau)}}\Big)\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\text{at}\,\tau=0,\hat{\sigma}=0}}{{=}}\Phi\Big(\frac{\hat{\sigma}^{*}+1-\frac{2}{n+2}\tau^{*}}{\sqrt{\frac{4}{n+2}\tau^{*}}}\Big), where \Phi is the cumulative distribution function of a standard normal random variable. This turns into ( 56 ) provided we choose \hat{\sigma}^{*}\leq\frac{2}{n+2}\tau^{*}-1 , or equivalently, (58) \displaystyle\hat{R}^{*}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle(\ref{ononehand})}}{{=}}e^{\hat{\sigma}^{*}}\leq e^{\frac{2}{n+2}\tau^{*}-1}. To conclude the proof, it is left to show that the integral in ( 57 ) is small. To this end, note that using the estimates for the terminal data \displaystyle\sup_{\hat{\sigma}}\left|\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}(\tau^{*},\hat{\sigma})}{\partial{\hat{\sigma}}}\right|+\left|\frac{\partial^{2}\hat{\zeta}(\tau^{*},\hat{\sigma})}{\partial^{2}{\hat{\sigma}}}\right|\lesssim 1\quad\text{and}\quad\int d{\hat{\sigma}}\left|\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}(\tau^{*},\hat{\sigma})}{\partial{\hat{\sigma}}}\right|\lesssim 1 we learn (by convolution with the heat kernel) that \displaystyle\sup_{\hat{\sigma}}\left|\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}(\tau^{*},\hat{\sigma})}{\partial\hat{\sigma}}\right|\lesssim_{n}\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+\tau^{*}-\tau}},\quad\sup_{\hat{\sigma}}\left|\frac{\partial^{2}\hat{\zeta}(\tau^{*},\hat{\sigma})}{\partial\hat{\sigma}^{2}}\right|\lesssim_{n}\frac{1}{1+\tau^{*}-\tau}. Hence, the integral term in ( 57 ) is bounded by \displaystyle\int_{0}^{\tau*}d\tau e^{-(1-\frac{\lambda_{2}}{2})\tau}\sup_{\hat{\sigma}}\left|\frac{\partial\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}}+\frac{\partial^{2}\hat{\zeta}}{\partial\hat{\sigma}^{2}}\right|\lesssim_{n}\int_{0}^{\tau^{*}}d\tau e^{-\frac{4}{n-1}\tau}\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+\tau^{*}-\tau}}\lesssim_{n}\frac{1}{\sqrt{\tau^{*}}}, and with some constant C=C(n) estimate ( 57 ) turns into (59) \displaystyle\mathbb{E}\hat{R}_{\tau^{*}}I(\hat{R}_{\tau^{*}}\leq\hat{R}^{*})\leq\frac{1}{2}+\frac{C(n)}{\sqrt{\tau^{*}}}. Finally, undoing the change of variables we have \displaystyle\hat{R}_{\tau^{*}}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\eqref{Rhat}}}{{=}}e^{-\tau^{*}}{\textstyle\frac{1}{n}}R_{\tau^{*}}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\ref{F3},(\ref{R})\&(\ref{:G})}}{{=}}\frac{|F_{\tau^{*}}|^{2}}{\mathbb{E}|F_{\tau^{*}}|^{2}},\quad\hat{R}^{*}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle(\ref{eqnHatRStar})}}{{\leq}}e^{\frac{2}{n+2}\tau^{*}-1}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\ref{F3}}}{{=}}\frac{1}{e}\Big(\frac{\mathbb{E}|F_{\tau^{*}}|^{2}}{n}\Big)^{\frac{2}{n+2}}, so that since \frac{2}{n+2}+1=\frac{n+4}{n+2} \displaystyle\hat{R}_{\tau^{*}}I(\hat{R}_{\tau^{*}}\leq\hat{R}^{*})=\frac{|F_{\tau^{*}}|^{2}}{\mathbb{E}|F_{\tau^{*}}|^{2}}I\Big({\textstyle\frac{1}{n}}|F_{\tau^{*}}|^{2}\leq{\textstyle\frac{1}{e}}\big({\textstyle\frac{\mathbb{E}|F_{\tau^{*}}|^{2}}{n}}\big)^{\frac{n+4}{n+2}}\Big). Thus ( 59 ) turns into ( 5 ). ∎