Comparison of inviscid and viscous vortex shedding from translating and rotating plates Yu Jun Loo, Silas Alben Abstract We compare an inviscid vortex sheet model with continuous leading-edge shedding with direct Navier-Stokes simulations over a wide range of unsteady plate motions at moderate Reynolds number ( Re ≈ 1000 \mathrm{Re}\approx 1000 ). Approximately 70 70 distinct kinematic configurations are examined, spanning both body-dominated and flow-dominated regimes. In body-dominated motions, where the fluid dynamics are primarily driven by prescribed plate accelerations, the inviscid model accurately reproduces normal force histories and the qualitative structure of the induced vorticity field. In flow-dominated configurations, with quasi-periodic vortex shedding, agreement with force predictions is good but reduced at low angles of attack, reflecting the greater sensitivity of vortex shedding dynamics to physical and computational parameters. The ability of the present formulation to accommodate stable, continuous leading-edge vortex shedding enables uniform comparisons across diverse motions and clarifies the regimes in which inviscid vortex sheet models can be used reliably for force prediction and physical interpretation. 1 Introduction The remarkable efficiency of insect and bird flight has inspired a plethora of recent studies investigating propulsion by both rigid and flexible flapping plates [ 50 , 42 , 23 , 6 , 7 , 22 , 32 ] . These studies are motivated in part by their implications for the control and design of bio-inspired robots and micro air vehicles. In the same spirit, many authors have employed computational and experimental techniques to study the aerodynamic forces experienced by plates undergoing highly unsteady aerial maneuvers such as a complex pitch–ramp motion [ 12 , 67 , 46 ] . The relevant Reynolds numbers ( \mathrm{Re} ) of such maneuvers are typically \sim 10^{2} – 10^{4} [ 12 ] . Exploring large parameter spaces at these Reynolds numbers quickly becomes computationally prohibitive. As a result, many authors have turned to inviscid vortex sheet models as a computationally efficient alternative that can model and explain the aerodynamic mechanisms behind force generation during these maneuvers [ 51 , 2 , 23 ] . The physics of force generation on a body can often be explained by relating the unsteady forces to the vortex shedding patterns induced by the body [ 6 ] . Hence, by distilling the entire fluid–body system into a simplified vortex structure, vortex sheet models offer a promising route to both explaining and accurately predicting the aerodynamic forces experienced by plates and foils in terms of their vortex shedding patterns. Several studies have compared inviscid vortex sheet models with direct Navier–Stokes simulations and/or experiments, in terms of the forces and vortex structures induced by solid bodies in flows [ 41 , 11 , 63 , 47 , 56 , 51 , 25 , 16 ] . In [ 47 ] , excellent agreement was obtained between the time-averaged thrust forces measured for a flapping airfoil in experiment and an inviscid vortex sheet model. A key caveat, however, is that good agreement was found only when leading-edge vortex shedding was included in the inviscid model. In both [ 47 ] and [ 56 ] , omitting leading-edge shedding from the inviscid model led to relatively poor agreement with the forces computed by a direct Navier–Stokes simulation. These observations motivate a closer examination of leading-edge vortex shedding in vortex sheet simulations, which remains a central difficulty for such models. When leading-edge shedding occurs, free vorticity released from the body often remains very close to the body surface; by contrast, vorticity released at the trailing edge is quickly advected away. As a result, computing the velocity of vorticity released at the leading edge often involves a so-called “near-singular integral,” which can introduce severe numerical error [ 43 ] that persists in the inviscid setting due to the absence of viscous dissipation. Aside from these numerical issues, there is also a physical ambiguity. In inviscid flow, the boundary condition enforces no-penetration but not no-slip, so newly-shed vorticity must leave the body tangent to its edges. Hence, when the flow at a plate edge is directed onto the edge, it may not be clear to which side of the plate newly-shed vortex particles should be advected. Many vortex sheet models therefore deliberately halt the shedding of vorticity at the leading edge when the flow is directed onto it [ 3 , 59 , 24 , 42 ] . This is done especially frequently in coupled simulations, where the motion of the body is driven by the fluid forces and can become unstable in the presence of leading-edge shedding. When the motion of the body is prescribed (i.e., not coupled to the fluid forces), there is a related body of work surrounding the so-called “leading-edge suction parameter” (LESP): an experimentally determined quantity used in vortex sheet simulations to determine when leading-edge shedding should occur for bodies with rounded edges [ 51 , 38 , 52 ] . This parameter depends on both the prescribed motion and the geometry of the body, and can be viewed as a modeling choice that allows one to fit vortex sheet simulations to experiments or direct Navier–Stokes simulations. In [ 16 ] , for example, the critical LESP value was chosen based on the body geometry and the desired \mathrm{Re} . In practice, both special quadrature rules [ 43 , 59 ] and smoothing techniques [ 4 , 1 ] are often necessary to resolve the near-leading-edge flow accurately and robustly in vortex sheet models. Recently, a vortex sheet model has been proposed by the present authors that allows for stable, continuous leading-edge vortex shedding in vortex sheet simulations with strong flow-body coupling [ 33 ] . This model was used to simulate freely falling plates undergoing both side-to-side fluttering and end-over-end tumbling. Its predicted value of the plate density parameter where fluttering transitions to tumbling was consistent with both experiments and direct Navier–Stokes simulation [ 33 ] . Here, we build on that approach with an improved formulation and address a complementary but distinct question: to what extent can an inviscid vortex sheet model with continuous leading-edge shedding quantitatively reproduce forces and vortex dynamics from direct Navier–Stokes simulations? Previous comparisons between vortex sheet models and viscous simulations have typically focused on a small number of representative kinematics, chosen to illustrate specific flow features or the capabilities of a given formulation. These studies have played an important role in establishing the physical relevance of inviscid formulations. At the same time, because treatments of leading-edge shedding were often sensitive to kinematics or relied on model-specific assumptions, extending such comparisons in a uniform way across a broad range of unsteady motions has remained challenging. The continuous leading-edge shedding framework introduced in [ 33 ] reduces these sensitivities and allows us to conduct a more systematic assessment. In the present study, we use a single vortex sheet model to compare force predictions with direct Navier–Stokes simulations for \approx 70 distinct plate maneuvers, providing a broad evaluation of model performance across a wide range of conditions. A meaningful comparison requires that the viscous simulations accurately represent the same zero-thickness geometry assumed by the vortex sheet model. Indeed, the flows induced by plates of zero and small but nonzero thickness can be quite different. In [ 45 ] , for instance, the relative error between the time-averaged pressure drag on an oscillating plate with zero and nonzero thickness ( 5\% of the plate length) at \mathrm{Re}=1000 is as large as \approx 15\% . The pressure jump across a zero-thickness plate is greater at all times, consistent with the classical result that the normal force on the plate increases with decreasing thickness in an unbounded domain [ 49 ] . A similar effect arises when the leading edge of a flat plate is rounded, which can change the normal force coefficient by about 25\% , possibly by altering both the separation point and circulation intensity at the leading edge [ 53 ] . In many of the aforementioned studies comparing inviscid models with direct Navier–Stokes simulations, the zero-thickness plate is instead approximated by a plate of small but nonzero thickness ( \approx 2 – 6\% of the plate length). At the same time, accurate Navier–Stokes simulation of a plate of exactly zero thickness presents well-known numerical challenges. The pressure and vorticity fields exhibit inverse-square-root singularities at the plate tips [ 6 , 26 ] , and resolving these requires specialized numerical treatment. Prior studies have addressed these difficulties using approaches such as grid clustering near the tips [ 6 , 60 , 37 ] , viscous particle methods that integrate vorticity to remove singular behavior [ 26 ] , and discrete kernel methods suitable for high-Reynolds-number immersed-plate problems [ 54 ] . Even with high-order methods and fine resolution, the computed forces can differ significantly depending on how the singular region is treated [ 37 , 64 ] . Following [ 6 , 60 , 37 ] , we therefore cluster the grid near the plate tips to mitigate these singularities. In this study, we consider plates of exactly zero thickness and validate our viscous solver against the benchmark results of [ 26 ] . We then compare the aerodynamic forces and resulting vorticity fields for several unsteady plate maneuvers using both direct Navier–Stokes simulations and an improved vortex sheet model with continuous leading-edge shedding. This comparison will help elucidate which vortex-dynamical features of unsteady high-Re flows can be approximated well by inviscid models. Because inviscid vortex sheet simulations are both orders of magnitude faster and less expensive than corresponding viscous simulations, the present results also indicate where such models can be reliably used for rapid exploration of large kinematic parameter spaces or control. The structure of the paper is as follows. In section 2 we describe our viscous (section 2.1 ) and inviscid (section 2.2 ) models. Section 3 compares the forces and induced vorticity fields in five scenarios, namely plate oscillation (section 3.1 ), heaving and pitching (section 3.2 ), pitch-up (section 3.3 ), uniform rotation (section 3.4 ) and steady translation (section 3.5 ). In section 4 we summarize our findings before we conclude in section 5 . 2 Methodology and validation Here we describe both the viscous and inviscid numerical models of the zero-thickness plate. In both models, we assume 2D flow, and the plate is represented by a line segment of unit length. The motion of the plate is completely characterized by two quantities, the position of its center of mass and its orientation angle (i.e. the oriented angle a line tangent to the plate makes with the x -axis) denoted \displaystyle\boldsymbol{X}_{G}(t) \displaystyle:\text{plate center of mass} \displaystyle\beta(t) \displaystyle:\text{plate orientation angle} 2.1 Viscous numerical model We consider a plate with zero thickness and unit length occupying the interval [-1/2,1/2] on the x -axis and solve the 2D Navier-Stokes equations in the body frame of the plate [ 30 ] given by \begin{cases}\partial_{t}\boldsymbol{u}+\boldsymbol{u}\cdot\nabla\boldsymbol{u}-\frac{1}{\mathrm{Re}}\Delta\boldsymbol{u}=-\nabla p-2\boldsymbol{\Omega}\times\boldsymbol{u}-\boldsymbol{\Omega}\times(\boldsymbol{\Omega}\times\boldsymbol{r})-\dot{\boldsymbol{\Omega}}\times\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{A}(t)\\ \nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{u}=0\end{cases} (1) A complete derivation of equation ( 1 ) is given in appendix A . Here, \boldsymbol{r}=[x,y,0]^{T} , \boldsymbol{u}=[u,v,0]^{T} is the fluid velocity, and \boldsymbol{A}(t)=[A_{x}(t),A_{y}(t),0]^{T} is the acceleration of the plate center of mass (expressed in body-frame coordinates). \boldsymbol{\Omega}(t)=[0,\ 0,\ \Omega(t)]^{T} is the vector of angular velocity of the plate about its center of mass, and \dot{\boldsymbol{\Omega}}(t)=[0,\ 0,\ \dot{\Omega}(t)]^{T} is its angular acceleration vector. By definition, we have that \frac{d}{dt}\beta(t)=\Omega(t) . We nondimensionalize distances by the plate length L and velocities by a characteristic velocity U defined separately for each problem in section 3 . Then \mathrm{Re}=UL/\nu is a dimensionless inverse viscosity that we set to 1000. These equations can be simplified in terms of the variables u,v,p yielding: \begin{cases}\partial_{t}u+u\partial_{x}u+v\partial_{y}u-\frac{1}{\mathrm{Re}}\Delta u=-\partial_{x}p+2\Omega v+\dot{\Omega}y+\Omega^{2}x-A_{x},\\ \partial_{t}v+u\partial_{x}v+v\partial_{y}v-\frac{1}{\mathrm{Re}}\Delta v=-\partial_{y}p-2\Omega u-\dot{\Omega}x+\Omega^{2}y-A_{y},\\ \partial_{x}u+\partial_{y}v=0.\end{cases} (2) Henceforth we let \boldsymbol{r}=[x,y]^{T} , \boldsymbol{u}=[u,v]^{T} and \boldsymbol{A}(t)=[A_{x}(t),A_{y}(t)]^{T} . Since the centrifugal force [\Omega(t)^{2}x,\Omega(t)^{2}y]^{T} and the inertial force [-A_{x}(t),-A_{y}(t)]^{T} are conservative, we may write them as the gradient of a potential: [\Omega(t)^{2}x-A_{x}(t),\Omega(t)^{2}y-A_{y}(t)]^{T}=\nabla(\frac{1}{2}\Omega(t)^{2}(x^{2}+y^{2})-A_{x}(t)x-A_{y}(t)y). (3) Hence, as the pressure is unique only up to the addition of a potential, we may absorb these forces into the pressure to form the simplified equations: \begin{cases}\partial_{t}u+u\partial_{x}u+v\partial_{y}u-\frac{1}{\mathrm{Re}}\Delta u=-\partial_{x}p+2\Omega v+\dot{\Omega}y,\\ \partial_{t}v+u\partial_{x}v+v\partial_{y}v-\frac{1}{\mathrm{Re}}\Delta v=-\partial_{y}p-2\Omega u-\dot{\Omega}x,\\ \partial_{x}u+\partial_{y}v=0.\end{cases} (4) Note that only the Coriolis force [2\Omega v,-2\Omega u]^{T} and the Euler force [\dot{\Omega}y,-\dot{\Omega}x]^{T} remain, as these forces are non-conservative. Having presented the equations, we now briefly describe how we solve them numerically. Our viscous model for the flat plate is based on the method described in [ 6 ] with a few modifications. A similar model was also employed to study heat transfer from a flapping plate in [ 62 ] and validated at \mathrm{Re}\sim 150 . Here we briefly review some of the essential details. The system of equations ( 4 ) is solved on a rectangular grid with length \ell_{x} and width \ell_{y} in the x and y directions respectively. x and y are discretized with m and n points respectively. It is a finite-difference method, using a second-order stencil to compute spatial derivatives on a staggered MAC (marker-and-cell) grid aligned with the plate. The grid is non-uniform, and clustered near both the sides and edges of the plate. More precisely, assume we have (piecewise) uniformly spaced grids on X and Y such that -l_{x}/20$}.\end{cases} (9) To suppress any spurious vorticity that may be generated at the walls of the computational domain, we supplement our boundary conditions with an absorbing sponge layer using Rayleigh damping near the computational boundaries [ 58 ] . This approach has been used successfully to suppress boundary reflections in both incompressible [ 48 , 58 ] and compressible [ 20 , 21 ] vortex-dominated flows in an unbounded domain. The application of this sponge boundary condition consists of adding a damping term -\sigma(x,y)(\boldsymbol{u}-\boldsymbol{U}_{f}) (10) to the right-hand side of ( 4 ) in a thin region (sponge layer) containing the boundary. Here we take the damping function to be \sigma(x,y)=\begin{cases}0.5((x^{2}+y^{2})^{1/2}-R)^{3}\ \text{ if }\ x^{2}+y^{2}>R^{2}\ \\ 0\text{\ otherwise}\end{cases} (11) \sigma(x,y) controls the strength and spatial distribution of the absorbing layer [ 20 ] , where R=8 defines the radius of our computational domain, so that our sponge layer has a minimum thickness of \epsilon=3 . Note that outside this circle, the true Navier-Stokes equations are not being solved, and hence we think of the region outside the circle as part of the boundary, not the computational domain. 2.1.2 Validation To validate our viscous solver, we consider an impulsively started flat plate moving normal itself with unit speed at \mathrm{Re}=1000 . In figure 2 we compare the computed forces between our viscous solver with the numerical results of [ 26 ] . The results are in good agreement. Figure 2: (a) The drag coefficient F_{D} and (b) the length of the recirculation bubble S over time for an impulsively started flat plate moving normal to itself with unit speed at \mathrm{Re}=1000 , compared with data obtained from figure 13 in [ 26 ] . In figure 3 we reproduce the vorticity contours shown in figure 20 of [ 26 ] . The circulation bubble is outlined in black, and our vorticity is presented on a bi-directional logarithmic scale, with contour levels ranging from \pm 2^{-4} to \pm 2^{10} . Here, the vorticity contours are visualized with the perceptually uniform color map “balance” described in [ 61 ] (i.e. each doubling of vorticity magnitude corresponds to a fixed decrease in color brightness). Each panel is overlaid with the corresponding streamlines (top half) and vorticity contours (bottom half) in figure 20 in [ 26 ] . In the top half of each panel the streamlines from [ 26 ] inside are given as red dotted lines, while in the bottom half of each panel, the vorticity contours are given as dark blue lines. The circulation bubble in the top half of the figure in [ 26 ] overlaps with the present viscous model. Figure 3: Vorticity fields (labeled by color bar) for an impulsively started plate at times t = 0.5, 2.5, 6, and 10, with circulation bubble outlined in black and \mathrm{Re}=1000 . The streamlines (top half) and vorticity contours (bottom half) from figure 20 in [ 26 ] are overlaid on each panel. 2.2 Inviscid numerical model We now describe the inviscid model. The model is essentially the same as that in [ 33 ] , but with a few improvements which we will highlight. The discussion presented here is similar to [ 33 ] but we use vector notation instead of complex variables. In the limit of zero viscosity, the two boundary layers along the two sides of the plate shrink to a zero-thickness vortex sheet along the body surface. In the limit of zero body thickness, these two vortex sheets merge into a single vortex sheet called the “bound” vortex sheet, and the fluid velocity tangent to the body surface jumps discontinuously across the vortex sheet [ 14 ] . In our zero-viscosity model there is no diffusion of vorticity from the vortex sheets, only advection from the separation points, which we assume to occur at the two edges of the plate only. Consequently, two “free” vortex sheets emanate from the body, one from each edge. The bound vortex sheet along the body and the free vortex sheets form one continuous vortex sheet that we compute at each time step. As the body is accelerated into motion, there is a corresponding fluid motion that can be computed from the strengths and positions of the bound and free vortex sheets. As time increases, the lengths of the free vortex sheets increase at each edge, starting from zero. The bound vortex sheet coincides with the flat plate, given by \boldsymbol{X}(s,t)=[X(s,t),Y(s,t)]^{T},-1/2\leq s\leq 1/2 . Note that \boldsymbol{X}(s,0)=[s,0]^{T},\ -1/2\leq s\leq 1/2 (12) \boldsymbol{X}(s,t)=\boldsymbol{X}_{G}(t)+{R}_{\beta(t)}\boldsymbol{X}(s,0) (13) In this work, \boldsymbol{X}_{G}(t) and \beta(t) are prescribed, which determines \boldsymbol{X}(s,t) . The free vortex sheets emanating from the s=\pm 1/2 edges are denoted \boldsymbol{X}_{+}(s,t)=[X_{+}(s,t),Y_{+}(s,t)]^{T},\ s\in[1/2,s_{+}+1/2] and \boldsymbol{X}_{-}(s,t)=[X_{-}(s,t),Y_{-}(s,t)],\ s\in[-s_{-}-1/2,-1/2] , respectively. Here, s_{\pm} are the lengths of the positive and negative vortex sheets respectively, and the vortex sheet strengths \gamma_{\pm}(s,t) are defined on the same intervals. The strength of the entire (bound and free) vortex sheet is denoted \gamma(s,t) , with s\in[-1/2-s_{-},1/2+s_{+}] . We denote the restriction of \gamma(s,t) to the negative, positive, and bound vortex sheets as \gamma_{-}(s,t) , \gamma_{+}(s,t) , and \gamma_{b}(s,t) respectively. Convolving the vortex sheet strengths \gamma_{b} , and \gamma_{\pm} with the Biot-Savart kernel \boldsymbol{K}(\boldsymbol{r})=\frac{1}{2\pi}\frac{[-y,x]^{T}}{|\boldsymbol{r}|^{2}} along the vortex sheet results in the following equation for the fluid velocity \boldsymbol{u} : \boldsymbol{u}(\boldsymbol{r},t)=\int_{-1/2}^{1/2}{\boldsymbol{K}(\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X}(s,t))\gamma_{b}(s,t)ds}\\ +\int_{-s_{-}-1/2}^{-1/2}\boldsymbol{K}(\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X_{-}}(s,t))\gamma_{-}(s,t)ds+\int_{1/2}^{s_{+}+1/2}\boldsymbol{K}(\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X}_{+}(s,t))\gamma_{+}(s,t)ds. (14) Let \Gamma(s,t) denote the arc length integral of \gamma along the positive and negative vortex sheets, defined piecewise, \displaystyle\Gamma(s,t)=\begin{cases}\int_{-s_{-}-1/2}^{s}\gamma(s^{\prime},t)\,ds^{\prime},\quad s\in[-s_{-}-1/2,-1/2]\\ \int_{1/2}^{s}\gamma_{+}(s^{\prime},t)\,ds^{\prime},\quad s\in[1/2,1/2+s_{+}]\end{cases} (15) and \Gamma_{\pm}(t) denote the total circulations in the positive and negative vortex sheets, i.e. \displaystyle\Gamma_{+}(t)\equiv\int_{1/2}^{1/2+s_{+}}\gamma_{+}(s,t)\,ds\quad;\quad\Gamma_{-}(t)\equiv\int_{-s_{-}-1/2}^{-1/2}\gamma_{-}(s,t)\,ds. (16) Then, by reparameterizing the positions of the free vortex sheets in terms of \Gamma , we may rewrite the equation for the fluid velocity as \boldsymbol{u}(\boldsymbol{r},t)=\int_{-1/2}^{1/2}{\boldsymbol{K}(\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X}(s,t))\gamma_{b}(s,t)ds}\\ +\int_{0}^{\Gamma_{-}(t)}\boldsymbol{K}(\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X_{-}}(\Gamma,t))d\Gamma+\int_{0}^{\Gamma_{+}(t)}\boldsymbol{K}(\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X}_{+}(\Gamma,t))d\Gamma. (17) The first term on the right-hand side is the contribution of the bound vortex sheet, while the last two terms are the contributions of the negative and positive free vortex sheets respectively. Hence we see that the fluid velocity \boldsymbol{u} can be determined from the unknown functions \Gamma_{\pm}(t),\ \boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(\Gamma,t) , and \gamma_{b}(s,t) . We now discuss how we solve for these functions. At each time step, \Gamma_{\pm}(t) are chosen such that the Kutta conditions \gamma_{b}(\pm 1/2)=\gamma_{\pm}(\pm 1/2) are satisfied. In appendix B we discuss how this is done numerically. This condition ensures that the vortex sheet strength is finite and continuous across the edges of the plate. At each time step, \boldsymbol{X_{\pm}}(t) is determined by solving the Birkhoff-Rott equations, which asks that the free sheets move with the average of the fluid velocity on the two sides of the vortex sheet. Hence from ( 17 ) we obtain the classical Birkhoff-Rott equations: \partial_{t}\boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(\Gamma,t)=\int_{-1/2}^{1/2}{\boldsymbol{K}\big(\boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(\Gamma,t)-\boldsymbol{X}(s,t)\big)\gamma_{b}(s,t)ds}\\ +\int_{0}^{\Gamma_{-}(t)}\boldsymbol{K}\big(\boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(\Gamma,t)-\boldsymbol{X_{-}}(\Gamma^{\prime},t)\big)d\Gamma^{\prime}+\int_{0}^{\Gamma_{+}(t)}\boldsymbol{K}\big(\boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(\Gamma,t)-\boldsymbol{X}_{+}(\Gamma^{\prime},t)\big)d\Gamma^{\prime}. (18) The classical Birkhoff-Rott equations (with principal valued integrals for the free sheets) are in fact ill-posed, and develop a curvature singularity at a finite critical time [ 34 , 27 , 55 ] . Krasny showed that the Birkhoff-Rott equations can be evolved numerically past this critical time by introducing a smoothing parameter \delta to “desingularize” the equations [ 28 ] . This regularization consists of replacing the kernel \boldsymbol{K}(\boldsymbol{r}) with \boldsymbol{K}_{\delta}(\boldsymbol{r})=\boldsymbol{K}(\boldsymbol{r})\frac{|\boldsymbol{r}|^{2}}{\boldsymbol{|r|^{2}+\delta^{2}}} in the free-vortex-sheet terms, eliminating the integrand singularity. This smoothing parameter inhibits the growth of small spatial features and prevents the formation of curvature singularities on free vortex sheets. However, the smoothing parameter jumps discontinuously from \delta on the free vortex sheets to 0 on the bound vortex sheet, which creates logarithmic singularities at the edges of the plate in the resulting flow velocity. Following the method described in [ 33 ] , it is possible to remove these logarithmic singularities by regularizing the contribution of the bound vortex sheet, i.e. by replacing the kernel \boldsymbol{K}(\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X}) with \tilde{\boldsymbol{K}}_{\delta}(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{X}(\cdot),s)=B_{\delta}(\min_{s^{\prime}}|\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X}(s^{\prime})|)\boldsymbol{K}(\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X}(s))+(1-B_{\delta}(\min_{s^{\prime}}|\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X}(s^{\prime})|))\boldsymbol{K}_{\delta}(\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X}(s)) where B_{\delta}(l)=\begin{cases}0\text{,\ if }l=0,\\ \frac{\exp(-\delta/l)}{\exp(-\delta/l)+\exp(-\delta/(\delta-l))}\text{,\ if }00 , however small; as the inverse of C_{\delta} is discontinuous, any small numerical error in the no-penetration condition would be magnified in \gamma_{b} and prohibit any guarantee of accuracy or stability. By contrast, ( 20 ) can be solved by inverting the singular integral operator C[\gamma_{b}](\boldsymbol{r})=\int_{-1/2}^{1/2}\hat{\boldsymbol{n}}\cdot\boldsymbol{K}(\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X}(s,t))\gamma_{b}(s,t)ds in the no-penetration condition. This determines \gamma_{b}(s,t) to lie within a one-dimensional space of functions, each corresponding to a different amount of circulation around the plate. The particular value of circulation is set by Kelvin’s circulation theorem, which requires that the total circulation in the flow is conserved. Since the plate is accelerated from rest, the initial circulation in the flow is zero. Hence Kelvin’s circulation theorem dictates that \int_{-1/2}^{1/2}\gamma_{b}(s,t)ds+\Gamma_{+}(t)+\Gamma_{-}(t)=0. (21) With this additional constraint, we may invert the operator C[\cdot] to obtain a unique \gamma_{b}(s,t) . This is discussed in detail in appendix B . The second important aspect of ( 20 ) that we now highlight is that the smoothing parameter on the free sheets varies with s^{\prime}=s^{\prime}(\Gamma^{\prime}) , the arc length parameter on the free sheet. I.e. \delta=\tilde{\delta}(s^{\prime}) . More specifically, on the free vortex sheet connected the \pm 1/2 edge of the plate, we take \tilde{\delta}(s)=\delta_{0}+(\delta-\delta_{0})(1-e^{-((\pm 1/2-s)/\delta)^{2}}). (22) Here we take \delta_{0}=\delta/1000 , a much smaller amount of regularization than \delta . Note that s^{\prime}=s^{\prime}(\Gamma^{\prime}) is a function of the circulation. This aspect of the model is different from that of [ 33 ] , where a uniform regularization parameter was used. With \tilde{\delta} tapered to a smaller value near the edge of the plate, the computed \gamma_{b} more closely approximates the unregularized version [ 4 , 33 ] . We also find that it reduces the sensitivity of the model to the far-field value of the smoothing parameter \delta , since near the edges of the plate \tilde{\delta}(s)\approx 0 regardless of the value of \delta . In summary, in order to remove the logarithmic singularities on the edges of the plate, we use both mismatched kernels ( \tilde{\boldsymbol{K}}_{\delta} and \boldsymbol{K} ), and mismatched smoothing parameters ( \delta and \tilde{\delta}(s^{\prime}) ) in the Birkhoff-Rott equation ( 19 ) and the no-penetration condition ( 20 ). As a result, when the free sheets are evolved, they are advected with a fluid velocity different from that which satisfies the no-penetration condition. This mismatch introduces an O(\delta) error into the no-penetration condition that can cause the free sheets to penetrate the plate when solving for \boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(s,t) . As shown in [ 33 ] , this error can be controlled by fencing: clipping the displacements of points normal to the plate to prevent them from passing through the plate at each sub-step of a time step. Fencing suppresses the error incurred from the mismatched velocities, resulting in a numerical scheme that was shown to be at least first order in time for the dynamics of falling plates with different densities computed in [ 33 ] . In general, the fluid dynamics are less complicated in the present work because the plate motion is fully prescribed. In table we list the coupled system of equations we solve in the first column, with the corresponding unknown variables in the second column. Table 1: Table showing the equations and unknown variables we solve for at each time t . Equation Unknown variable \hat{\boldsymbol{n}}\cdot\partial_{t}\boldsymbol{X}=\hat{\boldsymbol{n}}\cdot\bigg(\int_{-1/2}^{1/2}{\boldsymbol{K}\big(\boldsymbol{X}(s,t)-\boldsymbol{X}(s^{\prime},t)\big)\gamma_{b}(s^{\prime},t)ds^{\prime}}\\ +\int_{0}^{\Gamma_{-}(t)}\boldsymbol{K}_{\tilde{\delta}(s^{\prime})}\big(\boldsymbol{X}(s,t)-\boldsymbol{X_{-}}(\Gamma^{\prime},t)\big)d\Gamma^{\prime}+\\ \int_{0}^{\Gamma_{+}(t)}\boldsymbol{K}_{\tilde{\delta}(s^{\prime})}\big(\boldsymbol{X}(s,t)-\boldsymbol{X}_{+}(\Gamma^{\prime},t)\big)d\Gamma^{\prime}\bigg) (23) \Gamma_{+}(t)+\Gamma_{-}(t)+\int_{-1/2}^{1/2}\gamma_{b}(s,t)ds=0 (24) \gamma_{b}(s,t) \gamma_{b}(\pm 1/2)=\gamma_{\pm}(\pm 1/2) (25) \Gamma_{\pm}(t) \partial_{t}\boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(\Gamma,t)=\int_{-1/2}^{1/2}{\tilde{\boldsymbol{K}}_{\delta}\big(\boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(\Gamma,t),\boldsymbol{X}(\cdot,t),s\big)\gamma_{b}(s,t)ds}\\ +\int_{0}^{\Gamma_{-}(t)}\boldsymbol{K}_{\delta}\big(\boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(\Gamma,t)-\boldsymbol{X_{-}}(\Gamma^{\prime},t)\big)d\Gamma^{\prime}\\ +\int_{0}^{\Gamma_{+}(t)}\boldsymbol{K}_{\delta}\big(\boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(\Gamma,t)-\boldsymbol{X}_{+}(\Gamma^{\prime},t)\big)d\Gamma^{\prime} (26) \boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(s,t) The fluid velocity can then be obtained from the following formula: \boldsymbol{u}(\boldsymbol{r},t)=\int_{-1/2}^{1/2}{\tilde{\boldsymbol{K}}_{\delta}(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{X}(\cdot,t),s)\gamma_{b}(s,t)ds}\\ +\int_{0}^{\Gamma_{-}(t)}\boldsymbol{K}_{\delta}(\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X_{-}}(\Gamma,t))d\Gamma+\int_{0}^{\Gamma_{+}(t)}\boldsymbol{K}_{\delta}(\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{X}_{+}(\Gamma,t))d\Gamma. (27) 2.2.1 Inviscid algorithm In the algorithm block below we summarize the numerical procedure that we use to solve for \boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(s,t),\ \Gamma_{\pm}(t),\ \gamma_{b}(s,t) simultaneously at each time step. Algorithm 1 Inviscid vortex shedding algorithm when the motion of the body \boldsymbol{X}(s,t) is known for each time step k=1,2,\ldots do Step 1: Solve for the free-sheet positions \boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(s,t) explicitly \bullet Use the velocity-smoothed Birkhoff-Rott equations ( 1 ) to compute \boldsymbol{X}_{\pm}(s,t) at the current time step t=dt\cdot k using 3rd-order Adams-Bashforth. Step 2: Sub-step fence for the free sheets. \bullet Project all crossing free-sheet points normally to the plate surface to eliminate crossing. Step 3: Create new points on the free sheets \bullet Update \boldsymbol{X}(s,t) with the known value, and again project any crossing free-sheet points normal to the plate to eliminate crossing. Add a new point to each of the free sheets, with positions exactly at the edges of the plate. These new points are labeled with the new total circulation \Gamma_{\pm}(t) of their respective sheets, which we solve for in the next step. Step 4: Solve for the new free-sheet circulations \Gamma_{\pm}(t) implicitly. \bullet Construct the helper function F(\Gamma_{+},\Gamma_{-})=[\gamma_{b}(1/2)-\gamma_{+}(1/2),\ \gamma_{b}(-1/2)-\gamma_{-}(-1/2)]^{T} . F obtains \gamma_{b}(\pm 1/2) by inverting the singular integral in the no-penetration condition ( ) with Kelvin’s circulation theorem ( ) to fix the gauge. In appendix B we discuss how this is done. Solve F(\Gamma_{+},\Gamma_{-})=\boldsymbol{0} with Broyden’s method to obtain \Gamma_{\pm} and \gamma_{b}(s,t) simultaneously. The initial guess is obtained with second-order extrapolation in time. end for 2.2.2 Computing aerodynamic forces By considering the Bernoulli equation in the reference frame of the moving body, and taking its difference when evaluated on both sides of the body, the following pressure-jump equation can be obtained [ 14 , 85] [ 5 ] : [p]^{+}_{-}(s,t)=\partial_{t}\big(\Gamma_{-}(t)+\Gamma_{b}(s,t)\big)+\gamma_{b}(s,t)(\boldsymbol{u}(\boldsymbol{X}(s,t),t)-\partial_{t}\boldsymbol{X}(s,t))\cdot\hat{\boldsymbol{s}}. (28) Here, [p]^{+}_{-}(s,t) is the pressure jump across the plate and \Gamma_{b}(s,t)=\int_{-1/2}^{s}\gamma_{b}(s,t)\,ds . The net normal force on the (inviscid) plate is therefore C_{N}(t)=\int_{-1/2}^{1/2}[p]_{-}^{+}(s,t)ds. (29) 2.2.3 Computing the vorticity The Biot-Savart law states that the velocity induced by a blob-regularized point vortex with circulation \Gamma_{0} situated at position \boldsymbol{x}_{0} is given by \frac{1}{2\pi}\frac{(\boldsymbol{x}-\boldsymbol{x}_{0})^{\perp}\Gamma_{0}}{|\boldsymbol{x}-\boldsymbol{x}_{0}|^{2}+\delta^{2}}. (30) Following [ 19 ] , the blob-regularized vorticity induced by this point vortex is \omega_{\delta}(\boldsymbol{x})=\boldsymbol{\nabla}\times\frac{1}{2\pi}\frac{(\boldsymbol{x}-\boldsymbol{x}_{0})^{\perp}\Gamma_{0}}{|\boldsymbol{x}-\boldsymbol{x}_{0}|^{2}+\delta^{2}}=\frac{\delta^{2}\Gamma_{0}}{\pi(|\boldsymbol{x}-\boldsymbol{x}_{0}|^{2}+\delta^{2})^{2}} (31) For the case of a vortex sheet with length L and cumulative circulation \Gamma(s),\ 0