From cubic norm pairs to 𝐆 𝟐 \mathbf{G_{2}} - and 𝐅 𝟒 \mathbf{F_{4}} -graded groups and Lie algebras Tom De Medts, Torben Wiedemann Abstract . We construct Lie algebras arising from cubic norm pairs over arbitrary commutative base rings. Such Lie algebras admit a grading by a root system of type G 2 G_{2} , and when the cubic norm pair is a cubic Jordan matrix algebra, the G 2 G_{2} -grading can be further refined to an F 4 F_{4} -grading. We then use these Lie algebras and their gradings to construct corresponding root graded groups. Along the way, we produce many results providing detailed information about the structure of these Lie algebras and groups. Introduction The study of Lie algebras graded by root systems goes back to the influential work of Stephen Berman and Robert V. Moody from 1992 [ 6 ] . More precisely, Berman and Moody classified all Lie algebras over a base field k of characteristic 0 graded by simply-laced finite root systems of rank \geq 2 , up to central isogeny. Over the following decade, this result was extended to the types A_{1} , B_{n} , C_{n} , BC_{r} , F_{4} and G_{2} for n\geq 2 , r\geq 1 and strengthened to a classification up to isomorphism by the combined work of Bruce Allison, Georgia Benkart, Yun Gao, Oleg Smirnov and Efim Zel’manov [ 4 , 1 , 2 , 3 ] . A different, uniform approach to the classification for 3 -graded root systems (an assumption which excludes exactly the types E_{8} , F_{4} and G_{2} ) which avoids case-by-case considerations was given by Erhard Neher [ 22 ] . A different approach for G_{2} -graded Lie algebras, now over arbitrary fields k (including fields of characteristic 2 and 3 ) was taken in [ 10 ] , based on the theory of extremal elements in Lie algebras and intersecting two different 5 -gradings on the Lie algebra. The goals of the current paper are the following. (1) Construct and investigate G_{2} - and F_{4} -graded Lie algebras over arbitrary commutative base rings k . (2) Develop the theory of cubic norm pairs over arbitrary base rings k , required for (1). (3) Construct and investigate G_{2} - and F_{4} -graded groups. Our description of the Lie algebras is similar as in [ 10 ] in the sense that we coordinatize each “piece” of the grading separately and explicitly describe the Lie bracket in terms of this coordinatization. For G_{2} -graded Lie algebras, we encounter the same sort of algebraic structures as the ones that play a key role in [ 10 ] , namely cubic norm pairs , a twin version of the more common cubic norm structures. When k is a field, such a cubic norm pair either has trivial norm or it arises from a genuine cubic norm structure, but this dichotomy fails to hold over base rings. At the same time, the occurrence of such a twin structure is no surprise and is simply the correct analogue of a cubic norm structure, very much like Jordan pairs form a twin version of Jordan algebras. Nevertheless, not much has been written in the existing literature about these cubic norm pairs, and our only traces back are John Faulkner’s paper [ 15 ] and Michiel Smet’s recent preprint [ 25 ] . We use the opportunity to spell out the basic theory of cubic norm pairs. We follow a similar setup as in the recent excellent monograph [ 17 ] , which develops the theory of cubic norm structures over arbitrary commutative rings. The results from [ 17 ] will play a crucial role throughout the whole paper. A purely combinatorial construction, which relies on a certain Tits index and an associated surjection F_{4}\to G_{2}\cup\{0\} of root systems, makes it possible to regard any F_{4} -graded Lie algebra as a G_{2} -graded Lie algebra. For G_{2} -graded Lie algebras defined by a specific kind of cubic norm pairs, namely cubic Jordan matrix algebras , we can reverse this procedure: that is, we refine the G_{2} -grading to obtain an F_{4} -graded Lie algebra. Again, we will be able to give a precise description of each “piece” of the grading. This turns out to be rather delicate for the “middle piece” of the original G_{2} -grading. In the next step, we pass from root graded Lie algebras to root graded groups. These are groups equipped with a family of subgroups (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in\Phi} for a finite root system \Phi such that certain commutator relations [U_{\alpha},U_{\beta}]\subseteq U_{\mathord{]\alpha,\beta[}} for non-proportional \alpha,\beta\in\Phi are satisfied and such that so-called Weyl elements , whose conjugation action permutes the root groups, exist for all roots. The terminology of groups graded by root systems appears for the first time in [ 24 ] , where Zhiyong Shi proves coordinatization results for root graded groups of simply-laced type with rank at least 3. These results are similar in spirit to the recognition theorems for root graded Lie algebras. Partial progress towards a comparable result for type C_{n} with n\geq 3 was made by Zezhou Zhang in [ 33 ] . Complete coordinatization results for root graded groups of the remaining types B_{n} , C_{n} , F_{4} and BC_{n} for n\geq 3 were proven in [ 31 ] , and they were extended to the types H_{3} and H_{4} in [ 5 ] (with a slightly different axiomatic setup to account for the non-crystallographicness of these root systems). We will follow the terminology introduced in [ 31 ] for root graded groups (of crystallographic types), and point to its preface for further historical details. It should also be noted that Jacques Tits’ notion of RGD-systems, introduced in [ 30 ] , is a special case of root graded groups. For these objects, a geometrical interpretation in terms of thick spherical Moufang buildings is available. In particular, Tits’ classification of thick spherical Moufang buildings of rank at least 3 [ 29 ] provides a classification of RGD-systems of rank at least 3. This classification was extended to the rank 2 case—the so-called Moufang polygons—by Jacques Tits and Richard Weiss [ 28 ] . The main structure theorem for F_{4} -graded groups is [ 31 , 10.7.8] : Every F_{4} -graded group is parametrized by what is called in [ 17 ] a multiplicative conic alternative algebra C over a commutative ring k , which means that the structure of the group is largely determined by C and k (though not up to isomorphism). Multiplicative conic alternative algebras should be thought of as a suitable generalization of composition algebras—such as octonions or quaternions—over rings, and they are precisely the kind of algebras over which the aforementioned cubic Jordan matrix algebras are defined. Our main goal in the setting of root graded groups—which was, in fact, our original motivation to undertake this project—is to prove a converse existence result: For every multiplicative conic alternative algebra C over any commutative ring k , there actually exists an F_{4} -graded group which is coordinatized by C . Along we way, we will also show that there exists a G_{2} -graded group for every cubic norm structure (while the group defined by a cubic norm pair may lack Weyl elements for the short roots). We remark that a similar existence question is answered positively in [ 34 ] , where Zezhou Zhang constructs a C_{3} -graded group that is coordinatized by an arbitrary alternative ring with a nuclear involution. We construct the desired G_{2} -graded group as a subgroup of the automorphism group of our G_{2} -graded Lie algebra. In principle, this amounts to “exponentiating” the appropriate adjoint maps in the Lie algebra, but since we are dealing with arbitrary commutative base rings (where 2 and 3 are not necessarily invertible), this is not straightforward at all, and simply defining the exponential maps along with the required verifications will occupy us for some time. This can be compared with the definition of exponential maps over arbitrary base fields introduced in [ 10 , Theorem A] , but we cannot simply extend the ideas of loc. cit. to commutative base rings. One new technical tool that we use is the explicit formulation of what we call “higher Leibniz rules”. The exponential maps in the F_{4} -graded group may be defined by specializing the exponential maps in the G_{2} -grading, but only for those roots that do not “map to zero under the surjection F_{4}\to G_{2}\cup\{0\} ” . The exponential maps defined in this way allow us to define automorphisms of the Lie algebra that will later be proven to be Weyl elements, and the exponential maps for the “problematic” roots in F_{4} may be defined as conjugates of other exponential maps by a suitable choice of these automorphisms. The Weyl elements in the G_{2} -grading can be defined in a more straightforward way as certain reflections in the Lie algebra , which are given by explicit formulas inspired by [ 10 ] . Once we have the exponential maps at our disposal, we can define root groups as U_{\alpha}\coloneq\exp_{\alpha}(L_{\alpha}) . It then remains to show that these satisfy the desired commutator relations and that our candidates for the Weyl elements permute the root groups, which is a straightforward but long computation. For the F_{4} -grading in particular, we have to show that each Weyl element permutes the 48 root groups in the desired way, for which we use computer assistance. Outline of the paper. We start by recalling the required background on root graded Lie algebras and root graded groups in Section 1 . In Section 2 , we develop the theory of cubic norm pairs, following a similar approach as in [ 17 ] . In the process, we collect many identities that we will need later. We start the construction of the G_{2} -graded Lie algebra from a cubic norm pair in Section 3 by first producing the “classical” Tits–Kantor–Koecher Lie algebra of the cubic norm pair. In Section 4 , we make this TKK Lie algebra into a larger, G_{2} -graded, Lie algebra. This involves an important subtlety where we first have to modify the 0 -graded part of the TKK construction. It requires some computational effort to explicitly write down the Lie bracket and verify that it satisfies the Jacobi identity, but this pays off, since we will later have to refine the construction to produce an F_{4} -graded Lie algebra. We take an intermezzo in Sections 5 and 6 . First, in Section 5 , we show that surjective homotopies between cubic norm pairs give rise to surjective homomorphism between the corresponding Lie algebras, and we introduce reflections \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} , \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} , \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} and \varphi_{\updownarrow} of the Lie algebra. Then, in Section 6 , we investigate the ideal structure of the Lie algebra. The main results up to this point can be summarized as follows: Theorem A ( 4.30 , 5.15 , 6.25 ) . Let (J,J^{\prime}) be a cubic norm pair over a commutative ring k . Then there exists a G_{2} -graded Lie algebra L=L(J,J^{\prime}) whose root spaces L_{\alpha} for \alpha\in G_{2} are isomorphic to k , J or J^{\prime} . Further, the construction of L is functorial in (J,J^{\prime}) (with respect to surjective homotopies), and L is simple if and only if k is a field and the trace of (J,J^{\prime}) is non-degenerate. We are then ready to pass from Lie algebras to groups. In Section 7 , we introduce the notion of \alpha -parametrizations and \alpha -exponential automorphisms (where \alpha is a root). We then proceed to explicitly define such maps for the G_{2} -graded Lie algebras arising from any cubic norm pair. The precise verification that these maps define automorphisms of the Lie algebra is rather computational, and we have decided to extract it from this section into a separate Appendix A . In addition, some verifications involving Weyl elements have been moved into a second Appendix B . As a final result of Section 7 , we obtain: Theorem B ( 7.24 ) . Let J be a cubic norm structure over a commutative ring k and let L\coloneq L(J,J) be as in A . Then \Aut(L) contains a G_{2} -graded group G(J) with root groups U_{\alpha}\cong L_{\alpha} for all \alpha\in G_{2} . We then move on to F_{4} -gradings. We begin by laying out the combinatorics of the Tits index that relates F_{4} -gradings to G_{2} -gradings in Section 8 . In a short Section 9 , we collect the required background on cubic Jordan matrix algebras, following [ 17 ] , expressed in our setting of cubic norm pairs (rather than cubic norm structures). Next, in Section 10 , we show that for this specific class of cubic norm pairs, the G_{2} -grading can be refined to an F_{4} -grading, which we obtain by introducing three new 5 -gradings that we then intersect. Finally, in Section 11 , we show that also the G_{2} -grading in the automorphism group of the Lie algebra can be refined to an F_{4} -grading, leading to our final result. Theorem C ( 10.23 , 11.15 ) . Let C be a multiplicative conic alternative algebra (e.g., a composition algebra) over a commutative ring k , let \Gamma=\operatorname{diag}(\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2},\gamma_{3})\in\Mat_{3}(k) be invertible and let J=\Her(C,\Gamma) be the associated cubic Jordan matrix algebra. Let L\coloneq L(J,J) be as in A and G\coloneq G(J) be as in B . Then L is F_{4} -graded with root spaces L_{\alpha}\cong k for all long \alpha\in F_{4} and L_{\alpha}\cong C for all short \alpha\in F_{4} . Further, G is an F_{4} -graded group with root groups U_{\alpha}\cong L_{\alpha} for all \alpha\in F_{4} . Acknowledgments. We are grateful to Holger Petersson for pointing out the reference [ 15 ] to us and to Bernhard Mühlherr for several insightful discussions about Tits indices. The work of the second author was partially supported by a DAAD postdoctoral research scholarship and by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation), Project-ID 286237555, TRR 195. 1. Root graded Lie algebras and groups Convention 1.1 . Throughout this paper, we will use the terminology of [ 18 ] for root systems. In other words, all root systems are finite, reduced and crystallographic. Further, for any root system \Phi , we put \Phi^{0}\coloneq\Phi\cup\{0\} . 1.1. Root gradings We first introduce the central objects that we intend to construct in this paper: Root gradings of Lie algebras and groups. Definition 1.2 . Let k be a commutative ring and let L be a Lie algebra over k . For an abelian group (A,+) , an A -grading of L is a family (L_{a})_{a\in A} of k -submodules of L such that L=\bigoplus_{a\in A}L_{a} and [L_{a},L_{b}]\leq L_{a+b} for all a,b\in A . For n\in\mathbb{N} , a (2n+1) -grading of L is a family (L_{i})_{-n\leq i\leq n} such that (L_{i})_{i\in\mathbb{Z}} is a \mathbb{Z} -grading of L where L_{i}\coloneq 0 for \lvert i\rvert>n . For a root system \Phi , a \Phi -grading of L is a family (L_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in\Phi^{0}} such that (L_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in\langle\Phi\rangle_{\mathbb{Z}}} is a \langle\Phi\rangle_{\mathbb{Z}} -grading where L_{\alpha}\coloneq 0 for all \alpha\in\langle\Phi\rangle_{\mathbb{Z}}\setminus\Phi^{0} . Remark 1.3 . Our notion of root graded Lie algebras is more general than the one in [ 6 ] . A \Phi -graded Lie algebra L=\bigoplus_{\alpha\in\Phi^{0}}L_{\alpha} in our sense is \Phi -graded in the sense of [ 6 , 1.1] if it contains a copy \bar{L} of the split Lie algebra of type \Phi such that the root spaces (\bar{L})_{\alpha\in\Phi^{0}} of \bar{L} with respect to some split Cartan subalgebra satisfy \bar{L}_{\alpha}\subseteq L_{\alpha} for all \alpha\in\Phi^{0} . (Actually, root graded Lie algebras in the sense of [ 6 ] are usually only considered over base fields and not rings, but since the split Chevalley Lie algebras are defined over \mathbb{Z} (see [ 18 , Section 25] ), the notion makes sense over rings as well.) The Lie algebras that we construct in this paper are often root graded in this stronger sense, and they are “close to being so” in some other cases. We will discuss this in more detail in Remark 10.34 . Convention 1.4 . For x,y in an arbitrary group G , we define their commutator to be [x,y]\coloneq x^{-1}y^{-1}xy . Definition 1.5 ( [ 31 , 2.5.2] ) . Let \Phi be a root system and let G be a group. A \Phi -grading of G is a family (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in\Phi} of subgroups of G with the following properties, where we write U_{A}\coloneq\langle U_{\alpha}\mid\alpha\in A\rangle for any subset A of \Phi . (1) G is generated by (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in\Phi} and U_{\alpha}\neq 1 for all \alpha\in\Phi . (2) For all non-proportional \alpha,\beta\in\Phi , we have [U_{\alpha},U_{\beta}]\subseteq U_{\mathord{]\alpha,\beta[}} where \mathord{]\alpha,\beta[}\coloneq\Phi\cap\{i\alpha+j\beta\mid i,j\in\mathbb{Z}_{>0}\} . (3) For all \alpha\in\Phi , the set of so-called \alpha -Weyl elements M_{\alpha}\coloneq\{w\in U_{-\alpha}U_{\alpha}U_{-\alpha}\mid U_{\beta}^{w}=U_{\beta^{\sigma(\alpha)}}\text{ for all }\beta\in\Phi\} is not empty. Here \sigma_{\alpha}\colon\Phi\to\Phi denotes the reflection along \alpha^{\perp} , which we let act on \Phi from the right-hand side. (4) If \Pi is a positive system in \Phi , then U_{-\alpha}\cap U_{\Pi}=1 for all \alpha\in\Pi . Remark 1.6 . What we call a \Phi -grading here is actually called a crystallographic \Phi -grading in [ 31 ] . However, in the context of \Phi -graded groups arising from \Phi -graded Lie algebras, only crystallographic \Phi -graded groups are of interest, and hence we will always drop the word “crystallographic” in this paper. Remark 1.7 . It is a non-trivial but elementary observation that root groups in A_{2} -graded groups are necessarily abelian (see [ 31 , 5.4.9] ). Since G_{2} and F_{4} have the property that every root is contained in a subsystem of type A_{2} , it follows that all root groups in root graded groups of these types are abelian as well. Remark 1.8 ( [ 31 , 2.2.6] ) . Let \Phi be a root system, let G be a group with a family of subgroups (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in\Phi} and let \alpha,\beta\in\Phi . Then M_{\alpha}=M_{\alpha}^{-1}=M_{-\alpha} and M_{\alpha}^{w_{\beta}}=M_{\alpha^{\sigma(\beta)}} for all w_{\beta}\in M_{\beta} . It follows from the second property that if M_{\delta}\neq\emptyset for all \delta in a system of simple roots of \Phi , then M_{\alpha}\neq\emptyset for all \alpha\in\Phi . 1.2. F_{4} -graded groups We now turn to the special case of F_{4} -graded groups. One of the main results of [ 31 ] is that every such group is “coordinatized” by what is called a multiplicative conic alternative algebra ( Theorem 1.15 ). One of our main results in this paper is that for every multiplicative conic alternative algebra, there exists an F_{4} -graded groups coordinatized by this algebra ( Theorem 11.15 ). In the following, we develop the necessary terminology to make these two statements precise. For this we will freely use the terminology of multiplicative conic alternative algebras that we will only later introduce in Section 9 . For the moment, it suffices to know that a multiplicative conic alternative algebra is an algebra C over some commutative ring k which is equipped with a conjugation \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mu\>\cdot\>\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\colon C\to C , a norm n\colon C\to k (which has a linearization n\colon C\times C\to k ) and a trace t\colon C\to k . However, the reader who wishes to do so may safely skip ahead to Section 9 to read the precise definitions. Definition 1.9 . A standard system of simple roots in F_{4} is a tuple (\delta_{1},\delta_{2},\delta_{3},\delta_{4}) such that \{\delta_{1},\delta_{2},\delta_{3},\delta_{4}\} is a simple system of roots, \delta_{1},\delta_{2} are longer that \delta_{3},\delta_{4} and the subsystems spanned by \{\delta_{1},\delta_{2}\} , \{\delta_{2},\delta_{3}\} , \{\delta_{3},\delta_{4}\} are of type A_{2} , B_{2} , A_{2} , respectively. Definition 1.10 ( [ 31 , 4.3.2, 10.1.17] ) . Let C be a multiplicative conic alternative algebra over a commutative ring k . The twisting group (of (k,C) ) is the group T\coloneq\{\pm 1\}\times\{\pm 1\} together with the actions on (the sets) k and C defined by \displaystyle(-1,1).t \displaystyle\coloneq-t,\quad(1,-1).t\coloneq t,\quad(-1,1).c\coloneq-c,\quad(1,-1).c\coloneq\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu for all t\in k , c\in C . Definition 1.11 ( [ 31 , 4.2.4] ) . Let \Delta be a system of simple roots in F_{4} and let T be any abelian group. A \Delta -parity map with values in T is any map \eta\colon F_{4}\times\Delta\to T\colon(\alpha,\delta)\mapsto\eta_{\alpha,\delta} . For any sequence \delta_{1},\ldots,\delta_{\ell}\in\Delta with \ell\geq 2 , we put \eta_{\alpha,\delta_{1}\cdots\delta_{\ell}}\coloneq\prod_{i=1}^{\ell}\eta_{\alpha^{\sigma(\delta_{1})\cdots\sigma(\delta_{i-1})},\delta_{i}}. Definition 1.12 ( [ 31 , 4.3.4] ) . Let C be a multiplicative conic alternative algebra over a commutative ring k , let T be the twisting group of (k,C) , let \Delta be a system of simple roots in F_{4} and let \eta be a \Delta -parity map with values in T . Further, let G be a group with an F_{4} -grading (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} and let w_{\delta} be a \delta -Weyl element for all \delta\in\Delta . Put P_{\alpha}\coloneq k for all long \alpha\in F_{4} and P_{\alpha}\coloneq C for all short \alpha\in F_{4} . Then a parametrization of (G,(U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}}) by (k,C) with respect to (w_{\delta})_{\delta\in\Delta} and \eta is a family of isomorphisms (\theta_{\alpha}\colon P_{\alpha}\to U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} such that \theta_{\alpha}(p)^{w_{\delta}}=\theta_{\alpha^{\sigma(\delta)}}(\eta_{\alpha,\delta}.p)\quad\text{for all }p\in P_{\alpha}. Remark 1.13 . A parametrization automatically satisfies \theta_{\alpha}(p)^{w_{\delta_{1}}\cdots w_{\delta_{\ell}}}=\theta_{\alpha^{\sigma(\delta_{1})\cdots\sigma(\delta_{\ell})}}(\eta_{\alpha,\delta}.p)\quad\text{for all }p\in P_{\alpha}. Remark 1.14 . Let \Delta be a system of simple roots in F_{4} . Not every parity map (with values in the twisting group of some pair (k,C) ) is reasonable in the sense that it may arise in a parametrization of an F_{4} -graded group: For example, it is known that for many possible choices of \alpha\in F_{4} , \delta\in\Delta , the action of the square of any \delta -Weyl element on U_{\alpha} must be the inversion map (see [ 31 , 10.5.5] ), and hence any reasonable parity map \eta should satisfy \eta_{\alpha,\delta\delta}=(-1,1) . An example of a reasonable parity map \eta^{\text{c}}\colon F_{4}\times\Delta\to\{\pm 1\}^{2} is given in [ 31 , Figure 10.4] . Here the letter “c” stands for the fact that this is the parity map that is used in the Coordinatization Theorem 1.15 for F_{4} -graded groups. Theorem 1.15 ( [ 31 , 10.7.8] ) . Let G be a group with an F_{4} -grading (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} . Choose a standard system \Delta=(\delta_{1},\delta_{2},\delta_{3},\delta_{4}) of simple roots in F_{4} and a \delta -Weyl element w_{\delta} for all \delta\in\Delta . Then there exist a commutative ring k , a multiplicative conic alternative algebra C over k and a parametrization (\theta_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} of (G,(U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}}) by (k,C) with respect to (w_{\delta})_{\delta\in\Delta} and the standard parity map \eta^{\text{c}} from Remark 1.14 (whose codomain we identify with the twisting group T of (k,C) ) such that the following commutator relations hold for all s,t\in k and all c,d\in C : \displaystyle[\theta_{\delta_{1}}(s),\theta_{\delta_{2}}(t)] \displaystyle=\theta_{\delta_{1}+\delta_{2}}(-st), \displaystyle[\theta_{\delta_{2}}(s),\theta_{\delta_{3}}(c)] \displaystyle=\theta_{\delta_{2}+\delta_{3}}(-sc)\theta_{\delta_{2}+2\delta_{3}}\big(-sn(c)\big), \displaystyle[\theta_{\delta_{2}+\delta_{3}}(c),\theta_{\delta_{3}}(d)] \displaystyle=\theta_{\delta_{2}+2\delta_{3}}\big(n(c,d)\big)=\theta_{\delta_{2}+2\delta_{3}}\big(t(c\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mud\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)\big), \displaystyle[\theta_{\delta_{4}}(c),\theta_{\delta_{3}}(d)] \displaystyle=\theta_{\delta_{3}+\delta_{4}}(cd). Remark 1.16 . Keep the notation of Theorem 1.15 and put X\coloneq\{(\delta_{1},\delta_{2}),(\delta_{2},\delta_{3}),(\delta_{2}+\delta_{3},\delta_{3}),(\delta_{2},\delta_{2}+2\delta_{3}),(\delta_{3},\delta_{4})\}. For all (\alpha,\beta)\in X , Theorem 1.15 provides an explicit commutator formula for [U_{\alpha},U_{\beta}] . Now let \alpha,\beta\in F_{4} be arbitrary non-proportional roots. Then by the transitivity properties of the Weyl group, there exists u in the Weyl group of F_{4} such that (\alpha^{u},\beta^{u})\in X . Thus we have a commutator formula for [U_{\alpha^{u}},U_{\beta^{u}}] . Conjugating this formula by a sequence w_{\delta_{i_{\ell}}},\ldots,w_{\delta_{i_{1}}} of Weyl elements where u=\sigma_{\delta_{i_{1}}}\cdots\sigma_{\delta_{i_{\ell}}} , we obtain a commutator formula for [U_{\alpha},U_{\beta}] . For example, it follows from the formula [\theta_{\delta_{3}}(c),\theta_{\delta_{3}}(d)]=\theta_{\delta_{3}+\delta_{4}}(cd) that [\theta_{\delta_{4}^{\sigma(\delta)}}(\eta^{\text{c}}_{\delta_{4},\delta}.c),\theta_{\delta_{3}^{\sigma(\delta)}}(\eta^{\text{c}}_{\delta_{3},\delta}.d)]=\theta_{\delta_{3}^{\sigma(\delta)}+\delta_{4}^{\sigma(\delta)}}(\eta^{\text{c}}_{\delta_{3}+\delta_{4},\delta}.cd) for all \delta\in\Delta and all c,d\in C . Thus explicit knowledge of \eta^{\text{c}} grants explicit knowledge of all commutator relations. Remark 1.17 . We refer to the family (\theta_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} in Theorem 1.15 as a coordinatization , meaning that it is a parametrization for which explicit commutator formulas (involving the structural maps of (k,C) ) are known. In [ 31 , 10.4.14, 10.4.15] , the parity map \eta^{\text{c}} and (\theta_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} are called the “standard parity map” and a “coordinatization with standard signs” , respectively. However, we avoid the terminology of “standard signs” in this paper because there is nothing canonical about the parity map \eta^{\text{c}} . For example, the F_{4} -graded group in our Existence Theorem 11.15 will, a priori, be coordinatized with respect to a different parity map \eta^{\text{e}} , and the commutator relations in this group (see Proposition 11.13 ) will be the same as in Theorem 1.15 only “up to twisting” , that is, “up to signs and conjugation” . However, we will show in Remark 11.16 how a coordinatization of one type can be modified to obtain a coordinatization of the other type, which illustrates that this difference in the choice of signs is not meaningful. 2. Cubic norm pairs 2.1. Definition and identities Let k be an arbitrary commutative ring. To define cubic norm pairs, we first need to clarify the notion of a cubic form. Definition 2.1 ( [ 14 ] , [ 17 , 12.43] ) . Let M,N be k -modules. A cubic map from M to N (over k ) is a pair (f,g) of maps f\colon M\to N\quad\text{and}\quad g\colon M\times M\to N with the following properties. (1) f(\lambda x)=\lambda^{3}f(x) for all x\in M , \lambda\in k . (2) g is quadratic in the first component and linear in the second component. (3) f(x+y)=f(x)+g(x,y)+g(y,x)+f(y) for all x,y\in M . (4) Euler’s differential equation: g(x,x)=3f(x) for all x\in M . We will also write (f,g)\colon M\to N . If N=k , we also call (f,g) a cubic form on M . The reason to include the “ (2,1) -linearization g of f ” in the definition of a cubic map is to ensure the existence and uniqueness of scalar extensions in the following sense. Lemma 2.2 ( [ 14 , Theorem 35] , [ 17 , 12.43] ) . Let M,N be k -modules, let R be a k -algebra and let (f,g)\colon M\to N be a cubic map. Then there exists a unique cubic map (f,g)_{R}=(f_{R},g_{R})\colon M_{R}=M\otimes_{k}R\to N_{R}=N\otimes R , called the R -cubic extension of (f,g) , such that the following diagrams commute: {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces M} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces N} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces M_{R}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces N_{R},} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces f} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces m\mapsto m\otimes 1} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces n\mapsto n\otimes 1} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces f_{R}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces M\times M} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces N} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces M_{R}\times N_{R}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces N_{R}.} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces g} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces(u,v)\mapsto(u\otimes 1,v\otimes 1)} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces n\mapsto n\times 1} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces g_{R}} We are now ready to define cubic norm pairs. Definition 2.3 . A cubic norm pair (over k ) is a pair (J,J^{\prime}) of k -modules which are equipped with maps \displaystyle\times \displaystyle\colon J\times J\to J^{\prime}, \displaystyle\times^{\prime} \displaystyle\colon J^{\prime}\times J^{\prime}\to J, \displaystyle T \displaystyle\colon J\times J^{\prime}\to k, \displaystyle T^{\prime} \displaystyle\colon J^{\prime}\times J\to k, \displaystyle N \displaystyle\colon J\to k, \displaystyle N^{\prime} \displaystyle\colon J^{\prime}\to k, \displaystyle\sharp \displaystyle\colon J\to J^{\prime}, \displaystyle\sharp^{\prime} \displaystyle\colon J^{\prime}\to J such that the following conditions are satisfied. (1) \times and T are k -bilinear maps, \times is symmetric, and T^{\prime}(a^{\prime},a)=T(a,a^{\prime}) for all a\in J , a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . (2) \sharp is a quadratic map with linearization \times . That is, (\lambda a)^{\sharp}=\lambda^{2}a^{\sharp} and (a+b)^{\sharp}=a^{\sharp}+b^{\sharp}+a\times b for all a,b\in J and \lambda\in k . (3) Put g\colon J\times J\to k\colon(a,b)\mapsto T^{\prime}(a^{\sharp},b) . Then (N,g) is a cubic form on M . Explicitly, N(\lambda a)=\lambda^{3}N(a) , T^{\prime}(a^{\sharp},a)=3N(a) and the gradient identity N(a+b)=N(a)+T^{\prime}(a^{\sharp},b)+T^{\prime}(b^{\sharp},a)+N(b) hold for all a,b\in J and \lambda\in k . (4) The adjoint identity (a^{\sharp})^{\sharp^{\prime}}=N(a)a holds strictly. That is, (a^{\sharp})^{\sharp^{\prime}}=\tilde{N}_{R}(a)a for all k -algebras R and all a\in J_{R} . (5) N^{\prime}(a^{\sharp})=N(a)^{2} holds strictly. That is, N_{R}^{\prime}(a^{\sharp})=N_{R}(a)^{2} for all k -algebras R and all a\in J_{R} where N_{R} , N_{R}^{\prime} are as in Lemma 2.2 . (6) a\times(a^{\sharp}\times^{\prime}b^{\prime})=N(a)b^{\prime}+T(a,b^{\prime})a^{\sharp} holds strictly. That is, a\times(a^{\sharp}\times^{\prime}b^{\prime})=\tilde{N}_{R}(a)b^{\prime}+T(a,b^{\prime})a^{\sharp} for all k -algebras R and all a\in J_{R} , b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime}_{R} . (7) All the previous conditions are still satisfied if we interchange the roles of (J,\times,T,N,\sharp) and (J^{\prime},\times^{\prime},T^{\prime},N^{\prime},\sharp^{\prime}) . We will usually simply write \times , T , N , \sharp for the maps \times^{\prime} , T^{\prime} , N^{\prime} , \sharp^{\prime} . We will refer to T as the (bilinear) trace and to N as the norm . Definition 2.4 ( [ 17 , 33.4] ) . A cubic norm structure is a k -module J which is equipped with maps \displaystyle\times \displaystyle\colon J\times J\to J,\quad T\colon J\times J\to k,\quad N\colon J\to k,\quad\sharp\colon J\to J and a distinguished element 1_{J}\in J , called the base point , such that the following conditions are satisfied. (1) (J,J) is a cubic norm pair with structural maps \times , T , N , \sharp and \times^{\prime}\coloneq\times , T^{\prime}\coloneq T , N^{\prime}\coloneq N , \sharp^{\prime}\coloneq\sharp . It is called the cubic norm pair associated to (or induced by) J . (2) The base point satisfies 1_{J}^{\sharp}=1_{J} , N(1_{J})=1_{k} and 1_{J}\times a=T(1_{J},a)1_{J}-a for all a\in J . We will also sometimes refer to the cubic norm pair (J,J) induced by J as a cubic norm structure. Remark 2.5 . For the curious reader, we compare our definition of cubic norm pairs to some related ones that appear in the literature, and comment on the necessity of Axioms Items 5 and 6 in Definition 2.3 . These facts will not be used in the sequel. (1) If there exist a,b\in J such that N(a) is invertible and kb is free, then Axioms Items 5 and 6 follow from the remaining ones. Namely, by similar arguments as in [ 17 , 33.7] , the existence of b implies that kc is free for all c\in J for which N(c) is invertible, and with this observation, Items 5 and 6 can be derived as in [ 17 , (33a.18), (33a.19)] . (2) The condition in 1 on the existence of a,b is satisfied if there exists a base point 1_{J} that is unimodular , meaning that k1_{J} is a free direct summand of J . The unimodularity of the base point is required in the definition of cubic norm structures in [ 17 , 33.1, 33.4] , and hence Axioms Items 5 and 6 are absent from loc. cit. . The condition in 1 is also satisfied if k is a field and N\neq 0 , which is how Item 5 is proven in [ 15 , (ADJ3’)] . (3) Axiom Item 6 does not appear in [ 15 ] , but follows from Item 5 if k is a field. Further, it is shown in [ 15 , p. 4644] that Item 5 holds if T is non-degenerate in the sense that T(a,J^{\prime})=0 implies a=0_{J} . (4) In [ 25 , 2.1.5] , the identity in Lemma 2.8 Item 21 is required as an axiom in place of our Axiom Item 5 . In particular, it follows from Lemma 2.8 Item 21 that a cubic norm pair in our sense is a cubic norm pair in the sense of [ 25 , 2.1.5] . Remark 2.6 (Linearizations) . By [ 17 , 12.10, 12.11] , Axiom 2.3 Item 4 is equivalent to the requirement that the identity (a^{\sharp})^{\sharp}=N(a)a and its formal linearizations (1) \displaystyle a^{\sharp}\times(a\times b) \displaystyle=N(a)b+T(a^{\sharp},b)a\quad\text{and} (2) \displaystyle\quad a^{\sharp}\times b^{\sharp}+(a\times b)^{\sharp} \displaystyle=T(a^{\sharp},b)b+T(a,b^{\sharp})a hold for all a,b\in J . (See also [ 17 , 33.14] .) Further, by linearizing with respect to b , it follows from ( 2 ) that a^{\sharp}\times(b\times c)+(a\times b)\times(a\times c)=T(a^{\sharp},b)c+T(a^{\sharp},c)b+T(a,b\times c)a for all a,b,c\in J , which is also the linearization of ( 1 ) with respect to a . Similarly, Axiom 2.3 Item 6 is equivalent to the requirement that a\times(a^{\sharp}\times b^{\prime})=N(a)b^{\prime}+T(a,b^{\prime})a^{\sharp} and the formal linearization \displaystyle a\times\big((a\times c)\times b^{\prime}\big)+c\times(a^{\sharp}\times b^{\prime}) \displaystyle=T(a^{\sharp},c)b+T(a,b^{\prime})a\times c+T(c,b^{\prime})a^{\sharp} hold for all a,c\in J , b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Finally, the formal linearizations of Axiom 2.3 Item 5 of respective multi-degrees (5,1) , (4,2) , (3,3) in (a,b)\in J^{2} are the identities \displaystyle T\big((a^{\sharp})^{\sharp},a\times b\big) \displaystyle=2T(a^{\sharp},b)N(a), \displaystyle T\big((a^{\sharp})^{\sharp},b^{\sharp}\big)+T\big(a^{\sharp},(a\times b)^{\sharp}\big) \displaystyle=2N(a)T(a,b^{\sharp})+T(a^{\sharp},b)^{2}, \displaystyle N(a)T(b,b^{\sharp})+T(a^{\sharp},b)T(a,b^{\sharp})+N(a\times b) \displaystyle=2N(a)N(b)+2T(a^{\sharp},b)T(a,b^{\sharp}). These formulas are obtained by computing D^{i}(N\circ\sharp) and D^{i}(N\cdot N) for i\in\{1,2,3\} with the chain and product rules [ 17 , 12.17, 12.42] , and equating the resulting expressions. The first two of these identities are consequences of Lemma 2.8 Items 7 and 10 , whose proof is independent of Axiom 2.3 Item 5 , while the third one is equivalent to (3) N(a\times b)=T(a^{\sharp},b)T(a,b^{\sharp})-N(a)N(b) because T(b,b^{\sharp})=3N(b) . Further, the formal linearization of ( 3 ) of multi-degree (3,2,1) in (a,b,c)\in J^{3} is \displaystyle T\big((a\times b)^{\sharp},a\times c\big) \displaystyle=T(a^{\sharp},b)T(a,b\times c)-N(a)T(b^{\sharp},c)+T(a^{\sharp},c)T(a,b^{\sharp}), which is also a consequence of Lemma 2.8 Item 10 . We conclude that we could replace Axiom 2.3 Item 5 by the requirement that N(a^{\sharp})=N(a)^{2} and ( 3 ) hold for all a,b\in J . For the rest of this section, we assume that (J,J^{\prime}) is a cubic norm pair. Definition 2.7 . The U-operators U_{a}\colon J^{\prime}\to J are given by U_{a}(a^{\prime})\coloneq T(a,a^{\prime})a-a^{\sharp}\times a^{\prime}, for all a\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} , with linearization U_{a,b}(a^{\prime})=T(a,a^{\prime})b+T(b,a^{\prime})a-(a\times b)\times a^{\prime} for all a,b\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . We also write D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b):=\{a,a^{\prime},b\}\coloneq U_{a,b}(a^{\prime}). In particular, for each a\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} , this defines an endomorphism D_{a,a^{\prime}} of J . Similarly, we have endomorphisms D_{a^{\prime},a} of J^{\prime} . (There is no danger of confusion in notation, because a\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} .) We will see in Lemma 2.9 that the U -operators equip (J,J^{\prime}) with the structure of a Jordan pair. We will sometimes write D(a,a^{\prime}) for D_{a,a^{\prime}} . The following lemma says that all identities which are proven in [ 17 , 33.8] for cubic norm structures and which do not refer to the distinguished base point remain valid. We keep the same numbering as in loc. cit. . Lemma 2.8 . The following identities hold for all a,b,c,d\in J , b^{\prime},c^{\prime},d^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} and also for all a,b,c,d\in J^{\prime} , b^{\prime},c^{\prime},d^{\prime}\in J : (7) T(a\times b,c)=T(a,b\times c) . (8) a^{\sharp}\times(a\times b)=N(a)b+T(a^{\sharp},b)a . (9) (a\times b)\times(a\times c)+a^{\sharp}\times(b\times c)=T(a^{\sharp},b)c+T(a^{\sharp},c)b+T(a\times b,c)a . (10) a^{\sharp}\times b^{\sharp}+(a\times b)^{\sharp}=T(a^{\sharp},b)b+T(a,b^{\sharp})a . (16) U_{a}(a\times b)=T(a^{\sharp},b)a-N(a)b . (17) \{a,a^{\sharp},b\}=2N(a)b . (20) (U_{a}b^{\prime})^{\sharp}=U_{a^{\sharp}}((b^{\prime})^{\sharp}) . (21) N(U_{a}b^{\prime})=N(a)^{2}N(b^{\prime}) . (25) \begin{aligned} &(a\times b)\times(c\times d)+(b\times c)\times(a\times d)+(c\times a)\times(b\times d)\\ &\qquad=T(a\times b,c)d+T(b\times c,d)a+T(c\times d,a)b+T(d\times a,b)c.\end{aligned} (26) \begin{aligned} &a\times(b^{\prime}\times(a\times c))=T(a,b^{\prime})a\times c+T(a^{\sharp},c)b^{\prime}+T(b^{\prime},c)a^{\sharp}-(a^{\sharp}\times b^{\prime})\times c\\ &\qquad=(U_{a}b^{\prime})\times c+T(a^{\sharp},c)b^{\prime}+T(b^{\prime},c)a^{\sharp}\end{aligned} (27) \begin{aligned} &a\times(b^{\prime}\times(c\times d))+c\times(b^{\prime}\times(d\times a))+d\times(b^{\prime}\times(a\times c))\\ &\qquad=T(a,b^{\prime})c\times d+T(c,b^{\prime})d\times a+T(d,b^{\prime})a\times c+T(a\times c,d)b^{\prime}.\end{aligned} (29) N(a\times b)=T(a^{\sharp},b)T(a,b^{\sharp})-N(a)N(b) . (30) T(U_{a}b^{\prime},c^{\prime})=T(b^{\prime},U_{a}c^{\prime}) . (31) T(\{a,b^{\prime},c\},d^{\prime})=T(c,\{b^{\prime},a,d^{\prime}\}) . Proof. The same arguments and computations as in [ 17 , 33.8] for cubic norm structures work in our more general setting. Note that, unlike in [ 17 , 33.8] , we cannot use the Zariski-density argument [ 17 , 12.24] to restrict our attention to elements with invertible norm because it is not guaranteed that the set \mathbf{D}(N)(k)\coloneq\{a\in J\mid N(a)\text{ invertible}\} is non-empty. Note also that we have already seen Items 8 , 9 , 10 , 26 and 29 in Remark 2.6 . ∎ Lemma 2.9 ( [ 15 , Proposition 1] ) . The U -operators from Definition 2.7 equip (J,J^{\prime}) with the structure of a Jordan pair. In other words, the identities \displaystyle\{a,b^{\prime},U_{a}c^{\prime}\}=U_{a}(\{b^{\prime},a,c^{\prime}\}), \displaystyle\{U_{a}b^{\prime},b^{\prime},c\}=\{a,U_{b^{\prime}}a,c\}\quad\text{and}\quad U_{U_{a}b^{\prime}}c^{\prime}=U_{a}U_{b^{\prime}}U_{a}c^{\prime} hold for all a,c\in J , b^{\prime},c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Proof. This holds by the computations in [ 15 , Proposition 1] . Alternatively, we may cite [ 25 , 1.2.9] . The first and third identity also follow from the computations in [ 17 , 33.9] . All identities required in the proof hold by Lemma 2.8 . ∎ We briefly summarize the relationship between cubic norm pairs and cubic norm structures, which naturally leads to the notion of homotopies. Definition 2.10 . Let (J_{1},J_{1}^{\prime}) , (J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) be two cubic norm pairs, let \varphi\colon J_{1}\to J_{2} , \varphi^{\prime}\colon J_{1}^{\prime}\to J_{2}^{\prime} be two homomorphisms of k -modules and let t\in k be invertible. Then the pair (\varphi,\varphi^{\prime}) is called a t -homotopy of cubic norm pairs if \displaystyle N_{2}\bigl(\varphi(a)\bigr) \displaystyle=tN_{1}(a), \displaystyle\varphi(a)^{\sharp_{2}} \displaystyle=t\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\sharp_{1}}), \displaystyle T_{2}\big(\varphi(a),\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime})\big) \displaystyle=T_{1}(a,a^{\prime}), \displaystyle N_{2}\bigl(\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime})\bigr) \displaystyle=t^{-1}N_{1}(a^{\prime}), \displaystyle\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime})^{\sharp_{2}} \displaystyle=t^{-1}\varphi\bigl((a^{\prime})^{\sharp_{1}}\bigr) for all a\in J_{1} , a^{\prime}\in J_{1}^{\prime} . A homotopy is a t -homotopy for some invertible t\in k , and a homomorphism is a 1 -homotopy. We say that (\varphi,\varphi^{\prime}) is surjective, injective or bijective if both \varphi and \varphi^{\prime} have the respective property. Bijective homotopies are also called isotopies and bijective homomorphisms are also called isomorphisms. Remark 2.11 . A t -homotopy (\varphi,\varphi^{\prime})\colon(J_{1},J_{1}^{\prime})\to(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) of cubic norm pairs automatically satisfies \displaystyle\varphi^{\prime}(a\times_{1}b) \displaystyle=\varphi^{\prime}\big((a+b)^{\sharp}-a^{\sharp}-b^{\sharp}\big)=t^{-1}\big((\varphi(a)+\varphi(b))^{\sharp}-\varphi(a)^{\sharp}-\varphi(b)^{\sharp}\big) \displaystyle=t^{-1}\varphi(a)\times_{2}\varphi(a) and similarly \varphi(a^{\prime}\times_{1}b^{\prime})=t\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime})\times_{2}\varphi^{\prime}(b^{\prime}) for all a,b\in J_{1} , a^{\prime},b^{\prime}\in J_{1}^{\prime} . Further, if (\varphi,\varphi^{\prime}) is a bijective t -homotopy, then (\varphi^{-1},(\varphi^{\prime})^{-1}) is a bijective t^{-1} -homotopy, and the composition of a t_{1} -homotopy with a t_{2} -homotopy is a t_{1}t_{2} -homotopy. Example 2.12 . Let t,s\in k be invertible. Then (t\id_{J},t^{-1}\id_{J^{\prime}})\colon(J,J^{\prime})\to(J,J^{\prime}) is a t^{3} -isotopy. It follows that for any s -isotopy (\phi,\phi^{\prime}) , the pair (t\phi,t^{-1}\phi^{\prime})=(\phi,\phi^{\prime})\circ(t\id_{J},t^{-1}\id_{J^{\prime}}) is a t^{3}s -isotopy. Remark 2.13 . Any homomotopy (\varphi,\varphi^{\prime})\colon(J_{1},J_{1}^{\prime})\to(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) of cubic norm pairs is also a homomorphism of Jordan pairs: If (\varphi,\varphi^{\prime}) is a t -homotopy for t\in k invertible, we have \displaystyle\varphi^{\prime}\big(U_{a}(a^{\prime})\big) \displaystyle=T(a,a^{\prime})\varphi(a)-\varphi(a^{\sharp}\times a^{\prime})=T\big(\varphi(a),\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime})\big)\varphi(a)-t\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\sharp})\times\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime}) \displaystyle=T\big(\varphi(a),\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime})\big)\varphi(a)-\varphi(a)^{\sharp}\times\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime})=U_{\varphi(a)}\big(\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime})\big) for all a\in J_{1} , a^{\prime}\in J_{1}^{\prime} , and similarly, \varphi(U_{a^{\prime}}(a))=U_{\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime})}\varphi(a) . It follows that \varphi(\{a,a^{\prime},b\})=\{\varphi(a),\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime}),\varphi(b)\} and \varphi^{\prime}(\{a^{\prime},a,b^{\prime}\})=\{\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime}),\varphi(a),\varphi^{\prime}(b^{\prime})\} for all a,b\in J_{1} , a^{\prime},b^{\prime}\in J_{1}^{\prime} . We conclude that we have an implication chain “homomorphism of cubic norm pairs” \implies “homotopy of cubic norm pairs” \implies “homomorphism of Jordan pairs” . Remark 2.14 . Let (\varphi,\varphi^{\prime})\colon(J_{1},J_{1})\to(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) be a t -homotopy of cubic norm pairs (for some invertible t\in k ) where (J_{1},J_{1}) is the cubic norm pair induced by a cubic norm structure J_{1} . Then (\varphi^{\prime},\varphi)\colon(J_{1},J_{1})\to(J_{2}^{\prime},J_{2}) is a t^{-1} -homotopy. Definition 2.15 . Let t\in k be invertible. A t -involution of a cubic norm pair (J,J^{\prime}) is a t -isotopy (\varphi,\varphi^{\prime})\colon(J,J^{\prime})\to(J^{\prime},J) of cubic norm pairs such that \varphi^{\prime}=\varphi^{-1} . An involution is a 1 -involution. Remark 2.16 . Any cubic norm pair that is induced by a cubic norm structure has an involution. However, a cubic norm pair with an involution is not necessarily induced by a cubic norm structure because it need not have a base point in the sense of Definition 2.4 . Remark 2.17 . Assume that there exists p\in J such that N(p) is invertible, and put p^{\prime}\coloneq N(p)^{-1}p^{\sharp} . Then by [ 25 , 1.1.10] or by the same computations as in [ 17 , 33.10] , p is invertible in the sense of Jordan pairs with inverse p^{\prime} (meaning that U_{p}\colon J^{\prime}\to J is invertible with inverse U_{p^{\prime}} ). Moreover, we may define a cubic norm structure with base point p on the k -module J^{(p)}\coloneq J by the formulas in [ 25 , 1.1.10] or [ 17 , 33.11] . It is called the p -isotope of (J,J^{\prime}) and its structural maps are given by \displaystyle N^{(p)}\colon J\to k \displaystyle\colon a\mapsto N(p^{\prime})N(a)=N(p^{\prime})^{-1}N(U_{p^{\prime}}a), \displaystyle\sharp^{(p)}\colon J\to J \displaystyle\colon a\mapsto N(p^{\prime})^{-1}U_{p^{\prime}}(a)^{\sharp}=N(p^{\prime})U_{p^{\prime}}^{-1}(a^{\sharp}), \displaystyle T^{(p)}\colon J\times J\to k \displaystyle\colon(a,b)\mapsto T\big(U_{p^{\prime}}a,b\big)=T\big(a,U_{p^{\prime}}b\big), \displaystyle\times^{(p)}\colon J\times J\to k \displaystyle\colon(a,b)\mapsto N(p^{\prime})U_{p^{\prime}}^{-1}(a\times b)=N(p^{\prime})^{-1}\big(U_{p^{\prime}}(a)\times U_{p^{\prime}}(b)\big). In this setup, a straightforward computation shows that the pair (\id_{J},U_{p}^{-1})=(\id_{J},U_{p^{\prime}})\colon(J^{(p)},J^{(p)})\to(J,J^{\prime}) is an N(p) -isotopy. By Remark 2.14 , this implies that (U_{p}^{-1},\id_{J})=(U_{p^{\prime}},\id_{J})\colon(J^{(p)},J^{(p)})\to(J^{\prime},J) is an N(p)^{-1} -isotopy. In particular, the composition (U_{p}^{-1},U_{p})=(U_{p}^{-1},\id_{J})\circ(\id_{J},U_{p}^{-1})^{-1}\colon(J,J^{\prime})\to(J^{\prime},J) is an N(p)^{-2} -involution, and hence (N(p)U_{p}^{-1},N(p)^{-1}U_{p})\colon(J,J^{\prime})\to(J^{\prime},J) is an N(p) -involution. We conclude that a cubic norm pair (J,J^{\prime}) is isotopic to the cubic norm pair induced by a cubic norm structure if and only if there exists p\in J such that N(p) is invertible. Further, for a second cubic norm pair (J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) and a pair (\varphi,\varphi^{\prime})\colon(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime})\to(J,J^{\prime}) of k -linear maps, another straightforward computation shows that (\varphi,\varphi^{\prime}) is an N(p) -homomoty if and only if the composition (\id_{J},U_{p})\circ(\varphi,\varphi^{\prime}) is a homomorphism of cubic norm pairs (from (J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) to (J^{(p)},J^{(p)}) ). Thus the notion “ t -homotopy to (J,J^{\prime}) for some invertible t\in k\cap\im(N) ” coincides with the notion “homomorphism to an isotope of (J,J^{\prime}) ” . The second notion is precisely the definition of homotopies in the theory of Jordan algebras (see [ 17 , 31.17] ). We conclude this section with some identities that will be needed later. Lemma 2.18 . For all a,b,c\in J , the following identities hold. (1) D_{a,a^{\sharp}}=2N(a)\id_{J} . (2) D_{a^{\sharp},a}=2N(a)\id_{J^{\prime}} . (3) D_{a,b^{\sharp}}+D_{b,a\times b}=2T(a,b^{\sharp})\id_{J} . (4) D_{a^{\sharp},b}+D_{a\times b,a}=2T(a^{\sharp},b)\id_{J^{\prime}} . (5) D_{a,b\times c}+D_{b,c\times a}+D_{c,a\times b}=2T(a,b\times c)\id_{J} . (6) D_{a\times b,c}+D_{b\times c,a}+D_{c\times a,b}=2T(a\times b,c)\id_{J^{\prime}} . The same identities hold for all a,b,c\in J^{\prime} if the roles of \id_{J} and \id_{J^{\prime}} are interchanged. Proof. Let a,b,c,d\in J . By Definition 2.3 Item 3 and Lemma 2.8 Item 8 , we have D_{a,a^{\sharp}}(c)=T(a,a^{\sharp})c+T(c,a^{\sharp})a-(a\times c)\times a^{\sharp}=2N(a)c, proving Item 1 . Next, by Lemma 2.8 Items 7 and 9 , we have \displaystyle D_{a,b^{\sharp}}(c)+D_{b,a\times b}(c) \displaystyle=T(a,b^{\sharp})c+T(c,b^{\sharp})a-(a\times c)\times b^{\sharp} \displaystyle\hskip 34.44434pt+T(b,a\times b)c+T(c,a\times b)b-(b\times a)\times(b\times c) \displaystyle=2T(a,b^{\sharp})c, proving Item 3 . Now Item 5 follows immediately from Item 3 by linearizing in b . The proofs of Item 2 , Item 4 and Item 6 are completely similar. ∎ Lemma 2.19 . For all a,b\in J and c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} , the following identities hold. (1) U_{a}(a^{\sharp})=N(a)a . (2) T(U_{a}(c^{\prime}),a^{\sharp})=N(a)T(a,c^{\prime}) . (3) U_{a}(c^{\prime})\times a=T(a,c^{\prime})a^{\sharp}-N(a)c^{\prime} . (4) T\bigl((a\times b)\times c^{\prime},a^{\sharp}\bigr)=N(a)T(b,c^{\prime})+T(b,a^{\sharp})T(a,c^{\prime}) . (5) T\bigl((a\times b)^{\sharp},a^{\sharp}\bigr)=N(a)T(a,b^{\sharp})+T(b,a^{\sharp})^{2} . (6) (a\times b)^{\sharp}\times a=T(a,b^{\sharp})a^{\sharp}+T(b,a^{\sharp})a\times b-N(a)b^{\sharp} . Proof. Let a,b\in J and c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . (1) Using Definition 2.3 Items 3 and 4 , we have U_{a}(a^{\sharp})=T(a,a^{\sharp})a-a^{\sharp}\times a^{\sharp}=3N(a)a-2(a^{\sharp})^{\sharp}=N(a)a . (2) Again using Definition 2.3 Items 3 and 4 , we get \displaystyle T(U_{a}(c^{\prime}),a^{\sharp}) \displaystyle=T(a,c^{\prime})T(a,a^{\sharp})-T(a^{\sharp}\times c^{\prime},a^{\sharp}) \displaystyle=3N(a)T(a,c^{\prime})-T(a^{\sharp}\times a^{\sharp},c^{\prime})=N(a)T(a,c^{\prime}). (3) By Definition 2.3 Item 6 , we have U_{a}(c^{\prime})\times a=T(a,c^{\prime})a\times a-(a^{\sharp}\times c^{\prime})\times a=T(a,c^{\prime})a^{\sharp}-N(a)c^{\prime} . (4) Using Lemma 2.8 Item 8 , we get T\bigl((a\times b)\times c^{\prime},a^{\sharp}\bigr)=T\bigl((a\times b)\times a^{\sharp},c^{\prime}\bigr)=N(a)T(b,c^{\prime})+T(b,a^{\sharp})T(a,c^{\prime}) . (5) Using Definition 2.3 Items 3 and 4 and Lemma 2.8 Item 10 , we get \displaystyle T\bigl((a\times b)^{\sharp},a^{\sharp}\bigr) \displaystyle=T(b,a^{\sharp})T(b,a^{\sharp})+T(a,b^{\sharp})T(a,a^{\sharp})-T(a^{\sharp}\times b^{\sharp},a^{\sharp}) \displaystyle=T(b,a^{\sharp})^{2}+3N(a)T(a,b^{\sharp})-T(a^{\sharp}\times a^{\sharp},b^{\sharp}) \displaystyle=N(a)T(a,b^{\sharp})+T(b,a^{\sharp})^{2}. (6) Using Definition 2.3 Item 6 and Lemma 2.8 Item 10 , we get \displaystyle(a\times b)^{\sharp}\times a \displaystyle=T(b,a^{\sharp})b\times a+T(a,b^{\sharp})a\times a-(a^{\sharp}\times b^{\sharp})\times a \displaystyle=T(b,a^{\sharp})a\times b+2T(a,b^{\sharp})a^{\sharp}-N(a)b^{\sharp}-T(a,b^{\sharp})a^{\sharp} \displaystyle=T(a,b^{\sharp})a^{\sharp}+T(b,a^{\sharp})a\times b-N(a)b^{\sharp}.\qed 2.2. Linear cubic norm pairs One of our main goals, which will be accomplished in Section 4 , is to construct a G_{2} -graded Lie algebra L=L(J,J^{\prime}) from an arbitrary cubic norm pair (J,J^{\prime}) . Since a Lie algebra is a “linear object” , it is not surprising that L depends only on the ring k , the modules J , J^{\prime} and the bilinear maps \times and T . In other words, the maps N and \sharp of higher degree will appear neither in the definition of the module L nor in its multiplication table ( Table 1 ). This observation, which may seem like a mere curiosity at first glance, will be needed explicitly in Section 6 (specifically, in Remark 6.17 ). The purpose of this section is to make the aforementioned observation more precise by introducing the notion of linear cubic norm pairs , which capture the linear structure of (and hence generalize) cubic norm pairs. It is only this linear structure that will be needed in Sections 3 , 4 , 5 and 6 . In contrast, the definition of exponential maps on the Lie algebra L in Section 7 involves the maps \sharp and N . Hence our construction of G_{2} -graded groups works only for cubic norm pairs but not for arbitrary linear cubic norm pairs. The reader who is enthusiastic to get to our main results may want to skip this somewhat technical section until later. Definition 2.20 . A linear cubic norm pair (over k ) is a pair (J,J^{\prime}) of k -modules which are equipped with maps \displaystyle\times \displaystyle\colon J\times J\to J^{\prime}, \displaystyle\times^{\prime} \displaystyle\colon J^{\prime}\times J^{\prime}\to J, \displaystyle T \displaystyle\colon J\times J^{\prime}\to k, \displaystyle T^{\prime} \displaystyle\colon J^{\prime}\times J\to k such that the following conditions are satisfied. (1) \times and T are k -bilinear maps, \times is symmetric, and T^{\prime}(a^{\prime},a)=T(a,a^{\prime}) for all a\in J , a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . (2) The identities in Lemma 2.8 Items 7 , 25 , 27 and 31 hold: \displaystyle T^{\prime}(a\times b,c)=T(a,b\times c), \displaystyle a\times(b^{\prime}\times^{\prime}(a\times c))=T(a,b^{\prime})a\times c+T^{\prime}(a^{\sharp},c)b^{\prime}+T^{\prime}(b^{\prime},c)a^{\sharp}-(a^{\sharp}\times^{\prime}b^{\prime})\times c \displaystyle\qquad=(U_{a}b^{\prime})\times c+T^{\prime}(a^{\sharp},c)b^{\prime}+T^{\prime}(b^{\prime},c)a^{\sharp}, \displaystyle a\times(b^{\prime}\times^{\prime}(c\times d))+c\times(b^{\prime}\times^{\prime}(d\times a))+d\times(b^{\prime}\times^{\prime}(a\times c)) \displaystyle\qquad=T(a,b^{\prime})c\times d+T(c,b^{\prime})d\times a+T(d,b^{\prime})a\times c+T^{\prime}(a\times c,d)b^{\prime}, \displaystyle T(\{a,b^{\prime},c\},d^{\prime})=T(c,\{b^{\prime},a,d^{\prime}\}) for all a,b,c\in J and b^{\prime},d^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . (3) All the previous conditions are still satisfied if we interchange the roles of (J,\times,T) and (J^{\prime},\times^{\prime},T^{\prime}) . We will usually simply write \times , T , N , \sharp for the maps \times^{\prime} , T^{\prime} , N^{\prime} , \sharp^{\prime} . We will sometimes refer to cubic norm pairs as proper cubic norm pairs to emphasize the distinction from linear cubic norm pairs. Example 2.21 . Any proper cubic norm pair (J,J^{\prime}) with maps \times , \times^{\prime} , T , T^{\prime} , N , N^{\prime} , \sharp , \sharp^{\prime} induces a linear cubic norm pair (J,J^{\prime}) with maps \times , \times^{\prime} , T , T^{\prime} . Certain quotients of cubic norm pairs, which we will encounter in Remark 6.17 , provide examples of linear cubic norm pairs that are not (proven to be) proper cubic norm pairs. For the rest of this section, (J,J^{\prime}) denotes a linear cubic norm pair over k . Definition 2.22 . For all a,b\in J , we define a U -operator U_{a,b}\colon J^{\prime}\to J by U_{a,b}(a^{\prime})\coloneq T(a,a^{\prime})b+T(b,a^{\prime})a-(a\times b)\times a^{\prime} for all a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . We also write D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b):=\{a,a^{\prime},b\}\coloneq U_{a,b}(a^{\prime}). Remark 2.23 . The set of axioms in Definition 2.20 is adequate for our purposes, but it might not be sufficient to build a satisfying theory of linear cubic norm pairs (which we have no interest in doing). For example, we do not claim that the U -operators equip (J,J^{\prime}) with the structure of a linear Jordan pair, and this seems cumbersome to prove (if it is even true). Definition 2.24 . Let (J_{1},J_{1}^{\prime}) , (J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) be two linear cubic norm pairs, let \varphi\colon J_{1}\to J_{2} , \varphi^{\prime}\colon J_{1}^{\prime}\to J_{2}^{\prime} be two homomorphisms of k -modules and let t\in k be invertible. Then the pair (\varphi,\varphi^{\prime}) is called a t -homotopy of linear cubic norm pairs if \displaystyle T_{2}\big(\varphi(a),\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime})\big)=T_{1}(a,a^{\prime}), \displaystyle\varphi^{\prime}(a\times_{1}b)=t^{-1}\varphi(a)\times_{2}\varphi(a),\quad\varphi(a^{\prime}\times_{1}b^{\prime})=t\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime})\times_{2}\varphi^{\prime}(b^{\prime}) for all a,b\in J_{1} , a^{\prime},b^{\prime}\in J_{1}^{\prime} . A homotopy is a t -homotopy for some invertible t\in k , and a homomorphism is a 1 -homotopy. We say that (\varphi,\varphi^{\prime}) is surjective, injective or bijective if both \varphi and \varphi^{\prime} have the respective property. Bijective homotopies are also called isotopies and bijective homomorphisms are also called isomorphisms. Remark 2.25 . Any homotopy of linear cubic norm pairs satisfies \varphi(\{a,a^{\prime},b\})=\{\varphi(a),\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime}),\varphi(b)\}\quad\text{and}\quad\varphi^{\prime}(\{a^{\prime},a,b^{\prime}\})=\{\varphi^{\prime}(a^{\prime}),\varphi(a),\varphi^{\prime}(b^{\prime})\} for all a,b\in J_{1} , a^{\prime},b^{\prime}\in J_{1}^{\prime} . Remark 2.26 . The identities \displaystyle D_{a,b\times c}+D_{b,c\times a}+D_{c,a\times b} \displaystyle=2T(a,b\times c)\id_{J}, \displaystyle D_{a\times b,c}+D_{b\times c,a}+D_{c\times a,b} \displaystyle=2T(a\times b,c)\id_{J^{\prime}} from Lemma 2.18 remain valid for linear cubic norm pairs because they can be proven using only Lemma 2.8 Items 7 , 25 and 27 . 3. The Tits–Kantor–Koecher Lie algebra for cubic norm pairs Throughout this section, we assume that (J,J^{\prime}) is a cubic norm pair (or, more generally, a linear cubic norm pair) over the commutative ring k . We first introduce derivations and inner derivations. (We have not seen this notion before in the literature.) Definition 3.1 . (1) A derivation of (J,J^{\prime}) is a pair of k -linear maps \delta=(\delta_{+},\delta_{-}) where \delta_{+}\colon J\to J and \delta_{-}\colon J^{\prime}\to J^{\prime} such that there is a constant \lambda\in k for which (4) \displaystyle\delta_{-}(a\times b) \displaystyle=\delta_{+}(a)\times b \displaystyle+a\times\delta_{+}(b) \displaystyle-\lambda(a\times b), (5) \displaystyle\delta_{+}(a^{\prime}\times b^{\prime}) \displaystyle=\delta_{-}(a^{\prime})\times b^{\prime} \displaystyle+a^{\prime}\times\delta_{-}(b^{\prime}) \displaystyle+\lambda(a^{\prime}\times b^{\prime}), (6) \displaystyle 0 \displaystyle=T(\delta_{+}(a),a^{\prime}) \displaystyle+T(a,\delta_{-}(a^{\prime})) , for all a,b\in J and a^{\prime},b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . (2) The collection of all derivations of (J,J^{\prime}) forms a Lie algebra that we denote by \Der(J,J^{\prime}) . (3) Let a\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Then the pair \delta_{a,a^{\prime}}:=(D_{a,a^{\prime}},-D_{a^{\prime},a}) defines an inner derivation of the cubic norm pair. We will show in Lemma 3.3 below that \delta_{a,a^{\prime}} is indeed a derivation of (J,J^{\prime}) , with \lambda=2T(a,a^{\prime}) . (4) We define the grading derivation \gamma:=(\id_{J},-\id_{J^{\prime}}). This is indeed a derivation of (J,J^{\prime}) , with \lambda=3 . Remark 3.2 . If \delta=(\delta_{+},\delta_{-}) is a derivation, then \delta_{+}\bigl((a\times b)\times a^{\prime}\bigr)=\bigl(\delta_{+}(a)\times b\bigr)\times a^{\prime}+\bigl(a\times\delta_{+}(b)\bigr)\times a^{\prime}+(a\times b)\times\delta_{-}(a^{\prime}) for all a,b\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Together with Eq. 6 , it follows that \delta_{+}\{a,a^{\prime},b\}=\{\delta_{+}(a),a^{\prime},b\}+\{a,\delta_{-}(a^{\prime}),b\}+\{a,a^{\prime},\delta_{+}(b)\} for all a,b\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . In the language of Jordan pairs , this tells exactly that \delta=(\delta_{+},\delta_{-}) is a derivation of the Jordan pair (J,J^{\prime}) . See, for instance, [ 19 , §6.8] . Lemma 3.3 . The pair \delta_{a,a^{\prime}}:=(D_{a,a^{\prime}},-D_{a^{\prime},a}) is a derivation of (J,J^{\prime}) . More precisely, it satisfies Eqs. 4 , 5 and 6 with \lambda=2T(a,a^{\prime}) . Proof. By Lemma 2.8 Item 27 (or Definition 2.20 ), \bigl((a\times b)\times a^{\prime}\bigr)\times c+\bigl((b\times c)\times a^{\prime}\bigr)\times a+\bigl((c\times a)\times a^{\prime}\bigr)\times b\\ =T(a,b\times c)a^{\prime}+T(a,b^{\prime})b\times c+T(b,b^{\prime})c\times a+T(c,b^{\prime})a\times b for all a,b,c\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Using this identity, it is easy to verify that (7) D_{a^{\prime},a}(b\times c)+D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b)\times c+b\times D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)=2T(a,a^{\prime})b\times c, proving Eq. 4 with \lambda=2T(a,a^{\prime}) . The proof of Eq. 5 is similar, and Eq. 6 holds by Lemma 2.8 Item 31 (or Definition 2.20 ). ∎ We can now define the Tits–Kantor–Koecher Lie algebra \TKK(J,J^{\prime}) of the cubic norm pair (J,J^{\prime}) . First, let I\coloneq\TKK_{0}(J,J^{\prime})\coloneq\langle\delta_{a,a^{\prime}}\mid a\in J,a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime}\rangle+k\gamma\leq\Der(J,J^{\prime}). We then define the TKK Lie algebra \TKK(J,J^{\prime}):=J^{\prime}\oplus I\oplus J, equipped with the usual Lie bracket on I inherited from \Der(J,J^{\prime}) extended by the rules (8) [J,J]=0,\quad[J^{\prime},J^{\prime}]=0,\quad[\delta,a]=\delta_{+}(a),\quad[\delta,a^{\prime}]=\delta_{-}(a^{\prime}),\quad[a^{\prime},a]=\delta_{a,a^{\prime}} for all a\in J , a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} and \delta\in I . To show that this defines a 3 -graded Lie algebra, we could make a detour via Jordan pairs (see [ 21 ] ), but we believe that it is interesting to provide a (short and easy) direct proof of this fact. Proposition 3.4 . The algebra \TKK(J,J^{\prime})=J^{\prime}\oplus I\oplus J defined above is a 3 -graded Lie algebra, with J^{\prime} of degree -1 , I of degree 0 and J of degree 1 . Proof. We first observe that I is, in fact, an ideal of \Der(J,J^{\prime}) . Indeed, let \delta=(\delta_{+},\delta_{-})\in\Der(J,J^{\prime}) and let a\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Then using Eqs. 6 and 3.2 , we compute that (9) [\delta,\delta_{a,a^{\prime}}]=\delta_{\delta_{+}(a),a^{\prime}}+\delta_{a,\delta_{-}(a^{\prime})}. Moreover, \gamma is central in \Der(J,J^{\prime}) , so indeed I=\langle\delta_{a,a^{\prime}}\mid a\in J,a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime}\rangle+k\gamma is an ideal of \Der(J,J^{\prime}) . In particular, I is itself a Lie algebra. Next, we claim that the identities Eq. 8 make J (and similarly, J^{\prime} ) into a module for the Lie algebra I . In fact, if we allow \delta\in\Der(J,J^{\prime}) in these identities (rather than \delta\in I ), then J becomes a module for the full Lie algebra \Der(J,J^{\prime}) . Indeed, let \delta=(\delta_{+},\delta_{-}) and \epsilon=(\epsilon_{+},\epsilon_{-}) be two elements of \Der(J,J^{\prime}) and a\in J , then we have to verify that [[\delta,\epsilon],a]=[\delta,[\epsilon,a]]-[\epsilon,[\delta,a]] , but since [\delta,\epsilon]=(\delta_{+}\epsilon_{+}-\epsilon_{+}\delta_{+},\delta_{-}\epsilon_{-}-\epsilon_{-}\delta_{-}) , this is obvious from the identities Eq. 8 . Finally, we have to check that the Jacobi identity holds. There are only two remaining non-trivial cases to consider. We first consider triples of the form (a,b,a^{\prime})\in J\times J\times J^{\prime} . Then [a,b]=0 and \displaystyle[[a^{\prime},a],b]=[\delta_{a,a^{\prime}},b]=D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b) \displaystyle[[a^{\prime},b],a]=[\delta_{b,a^{\prime}},a]=D_{b,a^{\prime}}(a), and by definition, both expressions are equal to U_{a,b}(a^{\prime}) . The case of triples in J^{\prime}\times J^{\prime}\times J is, of course, completely similar. Next, we consider triples of the form (a,a^{\prime},\delta)\in J\times J^{\prime}\times\Der(J,J^{\prime}) . By Eq. 9 , we have [\delta,[a^{\prime},a]]=[\delta,\delta_{a,a^{\prime}}]=\delta_{\delta_{+}(a),a^{\prime}}+\delta_{a,\delta_{-}(a^{\prime})}. On the other hand, we have \displaystyle[[\delta,a^{\prime}],a]=[\delta_{-}(a^{\prime}),a]=\delta_{a,\delta_{-}(a^{\prime})}\quad\text{and} \displaystyle[[\delta,a],a^{\prime}]=[\delta_{+}(a),a^{\prime}]=-\delta_{\delta_{+}(a),a^{\prime}}, and we see that indeed the Jacobi identity holds also in this case. ∎ Remark 3.5 . In fact, we have shown that also the larger algebra \widetilde{\TKK}(J,J^{\prime}):=J^{\prime}\oplus\Der(J,J^{\prime})\oplus J is a 3 -graded Lie algebra, but we will not need this. 4. Constructing the Lie algebra 4.1. Constructing the bracket We continue to assume that (J,J^{\prime}) is a cubic norm pair (or, more generally, a linear cubic norm pair) over the commutative ring k . Our aim is to extend \widetilde{L}_{0}:=\TKK(J,J^{\prime}) to a larger 5 -graded Lie algebra L_{-2}\oplus L_{-1}\oplus\widetilde{L}_{0}\oplus L_{1}\oplus L_{2} with L_{-2}\cong L_{2}\cong k\quad\text{and}\quad L_{-1}\cong L_{1}\cong k\oplus J\oplus J^{\prime}\oplus k, with a finer 5\times 5 -grading as in Fig. 1 . This Lie algebra will be denoted by L , or (in later sections) by L(J,J^{\prime}) to emphasize its dependence on (J,J^{\prime}) . \langle x\rangle \langle f_{-}\rangle J^{\prime}_{-1} J_{-1} \langle e_{-}\rangle J Z J^{\prime} \langle f_{+}\rangle J^{\prime}_{1} J_{1} \langle e_{+}\rangle \langle y\rangle L_{-2} L_{-1} L_{0} L_{1} L_{2} L^{\prime}_{2} L^{\prime}_{1} L^{\prime}_{0} L^{\prime}_{-1} L^{\prime}_{-2} L^{\prime\prime}_{2} L^{\prime\prime}_{1} L^{\prime\prime}_{0} L^{\prime\prime}_{-1} L^{\prime\prime}_{-2} Figure 1. Construction of a 5\times 5 -graded Lie algebra This involves an important subtlety, as we now explain, and in particular, we will only be able to construct such a Lie algebra after modifying \widetilde{L}_{0} (which is also why the middle part in Fig. 1 is called Z rather than I ). We will first need to ensure the presence of a grading derivation \xi for this new grading, which we can do, in principle, by defining \overline{L}_{0}:=\TKK(J,J^{\prime})\oplus k\xi , a central extension of \TKK(J,J^{\prime}) by a free k -module spanned by a new element \xi of degree 0 . However, in the resulting Lie algebra that we will construct, the element \xi is not necessarily linearly independent from \TKK(J,J^{\prime}) , so we will replace \overline{L}_{0} by the Lie algebra L_{0} consisting of the corresponding inner derivations acting on \bigoplus_{i\neq 0}L_{i} , following a typical idea that has been worked out in detail in [ 7 , Construction 4.1.2] . In addition, this will also solve any problems that we might have if we would try to directly define an action of \TKK(J,J^{\prime}) on the L_{i} . (See also Remark 4.18 below.) We start by setting up the notation for the k -modules L_{i} for i\neq 0 . Definition 4.1 . (1) We define four k -modules \displaystyle L_{-2} \displaystyle:=kx, \displaystyle L_{-1} \displaystyle:=\{(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}\mid\lambda,\mu\in k,b\in J,b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime}\}, \displaystyle L_{1} \displaystyle:=\{(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}\mid\lambda,\mu\in k,b\in J,b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime}\}, \displaystyle L_{2} \displaystyle:=ky. (2) We will further decompose \displaystyle L_{-1} \displaystyle=L_{-1,-2} \displaystyle\oplus L_{-1,-1} \displaystyle\oplus L_{-1,0} \displaystyle\oplus L_{-1,1}, \displaystyle L_{1} \displaystyle=L_{1,-1} \displaystyle\oplus L_{1,0} \displaystyle\oplus L_{1,1} \displaystyle\oplus L_{1,2}, where \displaystyle L_{-1,-2} \displaystyle:=\{(\lambda,0,0,0)_{-}\mid\lambda\in k\}, \displaystyle L_{1,-1} \displaystyle:=\{(\lambda,0,0,0)_{+}\mid\lambda\in k\}, \displaystyle L_{-1,-1} \displaystyle:=\{(0,b,0,0)_{-}\mid b\in J\}, \displaystyle L_{1,0} \displaystyle:=\{(0,b,0,0)_{+}\mid b\in J\}, \displaystyle L_{-1,0} \displaystyle:=\{(0,0,b^{\prime},0)_{-}\mid b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime}\}, \displaystyle L_{1,1} \displaystyle:=\{(0,0,b^{\prime},0)_{+}\mid b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime}\}, \displaystyle L_{-1,1} \displaystyle:=\{(0,0,0,\mu)_{-}\mid\mu\in k\}, \displaystyle L_{1,2} \displaystyle:=\{(0,0,0,\mu)_{+}\mid\mu\in k\}. We also write L_{-2,-1}:=L_{-2} and L_{2,1}:=L_{2} . We call elements of L_{i,j} , whenever L_{i,j} is defined, homogeneous of \xi -degree i and \zeta -degree j . (3) We define the Lie algebra M:=\bigoplus_{i\neq 0}\mathfrak{gl}(L_{i}) . In Definition 4.9 , we will be able to define the Lie algebra L_{0} as a subalgebra of M , an idea that also appears in [ 7 , Construction 4.1.2] . Notice that trivially, each L_{i} is a module for the Lie algebra M . (4) We define two specific elements \zeta and \xi in M by setting \xi(l)=il\quad\text{and}\quad\zeta(l)=jl\quad\text{whenever }l\in L_{i,j}. Explicitly, \displaystyle\zeta(x) \displaystyle:=-x, \displaystyle\zeta\bigl((\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}\bigr) \displaystyle:=(-2\lambda,-b,0,\mu)_{-}, \displaystyle\zeta\bigl((\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}\bigr) \displaystyle:=(-\lambda,0,b^{\prime},2\mu)_{+}, \displaystyle\zeta(y) \displaystyle:=y, \displaystyle\xi(l_{i}) \displaystyle:=il_{i}\quad\text{for all }l_{i}\in L_{i},i\neq 0. (5) Let \varphi=(\varphi_{i})_{i\neq 0}\in M . We say that \varphi has \zeta -degree j if each \varphi_{i} maps all elements of \zeta -degree i to elements of \zeta -degree i+j . (Visually, this means that \varphi shifts the parts in Fig. 1 down by j .) In particular, \zeta and \xi have \zeta -degree 0 . (6) Since our goal is to construct a Lie algebra L_{-2}\oplus L_{-1}\oplus L_{0}\oplus L_{1}\oplus L_{2} with L_{0}\leq M , we will already denote actions of elements of M on each L_{i} using a Lie bracket, i.e., we will write 1 1 1 In principle, each \varphi\in M is a 4 -tuple \varphi=(\varphi_{i})_{i\neq 0} , so [\varphi,l_{i}]:=\varphi_{i}(l_{i}) , but we will omit the subscript i and simply write \varphi(l_{i}) without danger of confusion. [\varphi,l_{i}]:=\varphi(l_{i}) for all \varphi\in M and l_{i}\in L_{i} , i\neq 0 . Remark 4.2 . Whenever we define a Lie bracket between certain elements, it is silently understood that it is skew-symmetric. In other words, once we define an element [l,m] , we silently assume that we also define [m,l]:=-[l,m] . Remark 4.3 . A graphical depiction of the subspaces of L defined in Definition 4.1 is given in Fig. 1 (where Z is a certain subspace of M that will be defined in Definition 4.9 ). Our goal is to define a Lie bracket on L such that these subspaces constitute a 5\times 5 -grading on L , meaning that [L_{ij},L_{pq}]\subseteq L_{i+p,j+q} for all i,j,p,q\in\mathbb{Z} where L_{st}\coloneq 0 for all s,t\in\mathbb{Z} for which no such space L_{st} has been defined previously. In particular, the “vertical lines” (L_{i})_{-2\leq i\leq 2} , the “horizontal lines” (L_{i}^{\prime})_{-2\leq i\leq 2} and the “diagonal lines” (L_{i}^{\prime\prime})_{-2\leq i\leq 2} that can be read off from Fig. 1 will each constitute a 5-grading of L . When k is a field, these 5-gradings correspond to the so-called “hyperbolic pairs” (x,y) , (e_{-},f_{+}) and (-f_{-},e_{+}) in L , respectively; see [ 10 , §4, page 28] . Note that L_{i,j}=L_{i}\cap L_{j}^{\prime} for all i,j\in\{-2,\ldots,2\} . Further, we have a 7 -grading (L^{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}_{i})_{-3\leq i\leq 3} of L defined by L^{{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}}_{i}\coloneq\sum_{p\in\mathbb{Z}}L_{p,i-p} for all i\in\{-3,\ldots,3\} . (This grading, however, does not correspond to a hyperbolic pair.) Remark 4.4 . Let \{\gamma,\delta\} be a choice of simple roots for the root system G_{2} , where \gamma is long and \delta is short. Then there is a unique group homomorphism \omega from \mathbb{Z}G_{2} to \mathbb{Z}^{2} mapping \gamma to (-2,-1) and \delta to (1,0) . Now a straightforward computation shows that \omega(G_{2}) is precisely the set of indices (i,j)\in\mathbb{Z}^{2} for which we defined a module L_{i,j} in Definition 4.1 . Hence \omega(G_{2}^{0}) is precisely the set of indices for which a non-trivial submodule of L is depicted in Fig. 1 . We conclude that any 5\times 5 -grading of the form in Fig. 1 may equivalently be regarded as a G_{2} -grading. For this reason, we will sometimes identify G_{2}^{0} with the set \omega(G_{2}^{0})\subseteq\mathbb{Z}^{2} , so that we have a decomposition L=\bigoplus_{\alpha\in G_{2}^{0}}L_{\alpha}. (This means that we implictly choose a system of simple roots \{\gamma,\delta\} in G_{2} in such situations.) Remark 4.5 . Let W be the subgroup of the Weyl group of G_{2} which is generated by the reflections corresponding to long roots. Then there are three orbits of G_{2} under W : One orbit consisting of all six long roots and two orbits consisting of three short roots in each. The first one corresponds to the root spaces of L parametrized by k while the other two correspond to the root spaces canonically parametrized by J or J^{\prime} , respectively. (For the last statement to be true, we have to consider J and J^{\prime} as distinct parametrizing spaces even if J=J^{\prime} , which we underline by saying “canonically parametrized” .) Remark 4.6 . The element 2\zeta-\xi will appear at several points. It is the unique element \varphi\in L_{0} that satisfies \varphi(L_{\pm 2})=0\quad\text{and}\quad\varphi\big((\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm}\big)=(-3\lambda,-b,b^{\prime},3\mu)_{\pm} for all (\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm}\in L_{\pm 1} . Intuitively, our next goal is to make each of the four parts L_{-2} , L_{-1} , L_{1} and L_{2} into a module for the Lie algebra \TKK(J,J^{\prime}) . This is not quite possible, so instead, we first make them into a module for the abelian Lie algebras J^{\prime} and J . Definition 4.7 . (1) We define L_{-2} and L_{2} as trivial J - and J^{\prime} -modules, i.e., we set [a,x]=[a,y]=0 and [a^{\prime},x]=[a^{\prime},y]=0 for all a\in J , a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . (2) To define the action of J and J^{\prime} on L_{-1} and L_{1} , we set \displaystyle\bigl[a,(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm}\bigr] \displaystyle:=\bigl(0,\ \lambda a,\ a\times b,\ T(a,b^{\prime})\bigr)_{\pm}\ , \displaystyle\bigl[a^{\prime},(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm}\bigr] \displaystyle:=-\bigl(T(b,a^{\prime}),\ a^{\prime}\times b^{\prime},\ \mu a^{\prime},\ 0\bigr)_{\pm}\ , for all a,b\in J , a^{\prime},b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} and \lambda,\mu\in k . (3) Together, this associates to each a\in J and to each a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} an element of M , which we will denote by \ad_{a} and \ad_{a^{\prime}} , respectively. Since the map J\to M\colon a\mapsto\ad_{a} is clearly injective, we can safely identify a and \ad_{a} (and similarly for J^{\prime} ). Notice that the elements \ad_{a^{\prime}} with a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} have \zeta -degree -1 and that the elements \ad_{a} with a\in J have \zeta -degree 1 . Proposition 4.8 . Definition 4.7 makes each L_{i}\ (i\neq 0) into a module for the abelian Lie algebras J and J^{\prime} . Proof. This is obvious for the trivial modules L_{-2} and L_{2} . We will now verify that L_{1} is a J -module; the remaining three cases are completely similar. So let a,c\in J and z=(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}\in L_{1} . We compute \displaystyle[a,[c,z]] \displaystyle=\bigl[a,\bigl(0,\ \lambda c,\ c\times b,\ T(c,b^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\bigr] \displaystyle=\bigl(0,\ 0,\ \lambda a\times c,\ T(a,c\times b)\bigr)_{+}, and since T(a,c\times b)=T(c,a\times b) by Lemma 2.8 Item 7 , we get [a,[c,z]]=[c,[a,z]] as required. ∎ We can rephrase Proposition 4.8 as the fact that the maps J\to M\colon a\mapsto\ad_{a} and J^{\prime}\to M\colon a^{\prime}\mapsto\ad_{a^{\prime}} are homomorphisms of Lie algebras. (As in Definition 4.7 Item 3 , this now implies that we may view J and J^{\prime} as Lie subalgebras of M .) Interestingly, this does not extend to a Lie algebra homomorphism \TKK(J,J^{\prime})\to M . Instead, we do the following. Definition 4.9 . For each a\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} , we define \mathbf{d}(a,a^{\prime})\coloneq\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}\coloneq[\ad_{a^{\prime}},\ad_{a}]\in M. We also set Z:=L_{0,0}:=\langle\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}\mid a\in J,a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime}\rangle+k\zeta+k\xi\leq M and finally also L_{0}:=J^{\prime}\oplus Z\oplus J\leq M. Further, we denote by L_{0,-1} , L_{0,0} and L_{0,1} the subspaces J^{\prime} , Z and J of L_{0} , respectively. Remark 4.10 . Notice that the sum in the definition of L_{0} is indeed a direct sum. Indeed, as we observed in Definition 4.7 Item 3 , the elements of J^{\prime} have \zeta -degree -1 and the elements of J have \zeta -degree 1 . On the other hand, the elements of Z all have \zeta -degree 0 . However, the sum \langle\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}\mid a\in J,a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime}\rangle+k\zeta+k\xi is never a direct sum (cf. Lemma 4.19 ). Remark 4.11 . Observe that \xi centralizes M and that \zeta centralizes Z . Further, since elements of J have \zeta -degree 1 , we have [\zeta,\ad_{a}]=\ad_{a} for all a\in J . Similarly, [\zeta,\ad_{a^{\prime}}]=-\ad_{a^{\prime}} for all a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . We first explicitly compute the action of \mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}} on each L_{i} . Proposition 4.12 . Let a\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Then \mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}(L_{\pm 2})=0 and \bigl[\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm}\bigr]\\ =\bigl(-\lambda T(a,a^{\prime}),\ D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b)-T(a,a^{\prime})b,\ -D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})b^{\prime},\ \mu T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{\pm} for all \lambda,\mu\in k , b\in J , b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Proof. Let z=(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm} . Since \mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}=\ad_{a^{\prime}}\ad_{a}-\ad_{a}\ad_{a^{\prime}} , we can use Definition 4.7 to get \displaystyle[\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},z] \displaystyle=[a^{\prime},[a,z]]-[a,[a^{\prime},z]] \displaystyle=\begin{multlined}-\bigl(\lambda T(a,a^{\prime}),\ a^{\prime}\times(a\times b),\ T(a,b^{\prime})a^{\prime},\ 0\bigr)_{\pm}\\ +\bigl(0,\ T(b,a^{\prime})a,\ a\times(a^{\prime}\times b^{\prime}),\ \mu T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{\pm},\end{multlined} and using the definition of D_{a,a^{\prime}} and D_{a^{\prime},a} , we get the required formula. ∎ Corollary 4.13 . Let a,b\in J and a^{\prime},b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Then (10) [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\mathbf{d}_{b,b^{\prime}}]=\mathbf{d}_{D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b),b^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{b,D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime})}. In particular, Z is a Lie subalgebra of M . Proof. First observe that by Eq. 9 , we have [\delta_{a,a^{\prime}},\delta_{b,b^{\prime}}]=\delta_{D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b),b^{\prime}}-\delta_{b,D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime})}, so in particular, [D_{a,a^{\prime}},D_{b,b^{\prime}}]=D_{D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b),b^{\prime}}-D_{b,D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime})}. By Proposition 4.12 , on the other hand, we have \bigl[[\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\mathbf{d}_{b,b^{\prime}}],(\lambda,c,c^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm}\bigr]=\bigl(0,\ [D_{a,a^{\prime}},D_{b,b^{\prime}}](c),\ -[D_{a^{\prime},a},D_{b^{\prime},b}](c^{\prime}),\ 0\bigr)_{\pm}. Since (11) T(D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b),b^{\prime})-T(b,D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime}))=0 by Eq. 6 , we conclude that both sides of Eq. 10 have the same action on L_{\pm 1} . Since they both act trivially on L_{\pm 2} , they have the same action on each L_{i} ( i\neq 0 ), and hence they represent the same element of M . This proves Eq. 10 and shows, in particular, that \langle\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}\mid a\in J,a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime}\rangle is a Lie subalgebra of M . Together with Remark 4.11 , it follows that Z is indeed a Lie subalgebra of M . ∎ Proposition 4.14 . Let a,c\in J and a^{\prime},c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Then [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\ad_{c}]=\ad_{D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)}\quad\text{and}\quad[\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\ad_{c^{\prime}}]=-\ad_{D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})}. Proof. We compute the action of [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\ad_{c}] on an arbitrary element (\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm}\in L_{\pm 1} : \displaystyle\big[\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},[c,(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm}]] \displaystyle=\big[\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\big(0,\lambda c,c\times b,T(c,b^{\prime})\big)_{\pm}\big] \displaystyle=\big(0,\lambda\big(D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c\big),-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c\times b)+T(a,a^{\prime})(c\times b),T(c,b^{\prime})T(a,a^{\prime})\big)_{\pm}, \displaystyle\big[c,[\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm}]] \displaystyle=\big[c,\big(-\lambda T(a,a^{\prime}),D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b)-T(a,a^{\prime})b,-D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})b^{\prime},\mu T(a,a^{\prime})\big)_{\pm}\big] \displaystyle=\big(0,-\lambda T(a,a^{\prime})c,c\times\big(D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b)-T(a,a^{\prime})b\big),T\big(c,-D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})b^{\prime}\big)\big)_{\pm}. Using Eqs. 7 and 11 , we conclude that \displaystyle\big[[\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\ad_{c}],\ (\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm}] \displaystyle=\big(0,\ \lambda D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c),\ D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)\times b,\ T(D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c),b^{\prime})) \displaystyle=\big[D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c),(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm}\big]. This shows that [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\ad_{c}] and \ad_{D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)} have the same action on L_{1} and L_{-1} . Since both elements also act trivially on L_{2} and L_{-2} , they represent the same element of M , i.e., they coincide. The proof of the second assertion is completely similar. ∎ Proposition 4.15 . L_{0} is a Lie subalgebra of M . Proof. By Corollary 4.13 , we already know that Z is a Lie subalgebra of M . Further, [J,k\zeta+k\xi]\subseteq L_{0} and [J^{\prime},k\zeta+k\xi]\subseteq L_{0} by Remark 4.11 . Finally, by Proposition 4.14 , [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},J]\subseteq L_{0} and [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},J^{\prime}]\subseteq L_{0} for all a\in J , a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . ∎ Remark 4.16 . Notice that since each L_{i} is an M -module, it is automatically also an L_{0} -module, now that we know that L_{0} is a Lie subalgebra of M . We will need the following lemma in the proof of Proposition 4.27 below. At the same time, it may serve as a good example to explain the subtle difference between the \delta_{a,a^{\prime}}\in\TKK(J,J^{\prime}) and the \mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}\in M that we have just defined. Lemma 4.17 . Let a,b,c\in J and a^{\prime},b^{\prime},c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Then the following hold. (1) \mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\sharp}}=N(a)\cdot(2\zeta-\xi) . (2) \mathbf{d}_{(a^{\prime})^{\sharp},a}=N(a^{\prime})\cdot(2\zeta-\xi) . (3) \mathbf{d}_{a,b^{\sharp}}+\mathbf{d}_{b,a\times b}=T(a,b^{\sharp})\cdot(2\zeta-\xi) . (4) \mathbf{d}_{(a^{\prime})^{\sharp},b}+\mathbf{d}_{a^{\prime}\times b^{\prime},a^{\prime}}=T((a^{\prime})^{\sharp},b)\cdot(2\zeta-\xi) (5) \mathbf{d}_{a,b\times c}+\mathbf{d}_{b,c\times a}+\mathbf{d}_{c,a\times b}=T(c,a\times b)\cdot(2\zeta-\xi) . (6) \mathbf{d}_{a^{\prime}\times b^{\prime},c^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime},a^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{c^{\prime}\times a^{\prime},b^{\prime}}=T(c^{\prime},a^{\prime}\times b^{\prime})\cdot(2\zeta-\xi) . Proof. Notice that these are identities in L_{0} , and by construction, two such elements coincide if and only if they have the same action on L_{i} for all i\neq 0 . Since each \mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}} acts trivially on L_{2} and L_{-2} and the grading derivation 2\zeta-\xi\in M kills both L_{2} and L_{-2} , it suffices to verify this for i=\pm 1 . Recall from Lemma 2.18 Item 1 that D_{a,a^{\sharp}}(d)=2N(a)d. Together with Proposition 4.12 , this yields, using T(a,a^{\sharp})=3N(a) , that [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\sharp}},\ (\lambda,d,d^{\prime},\mu)_{+}]=\bigl(-3\lambda N(a),\ -N(a)d,\ N(a)d^{\prime},\ 3\mu N(a)\bigr)_{+}. Using Remark 4.6 , we conclude that both sides of Item 1 have the same action on L_{1} . The verification for L_{-1} is similar, so Item 1 holds. The proofs of the remaining identities follow in a completely similar way from the other identities in Lemma 2.18 . ∎ Remark 4.18 . In contrast, notice that in \TKK(J,J^{\prime}) , we have \delta_{a,a^{\sharp}}=2N(a)\cdot\gamma, by Lemma 2.18 Items 1 and 2 . (See Definition 3.1 Item 4 and Lemma 3.3 .) Comparing this with Lemma 4.17 shows, in particular, that the action introduced in Definition 4.7 does not extend to an action of \TKK(J,J^{\prime}) on L_{i} , as we mentioned just before Definition 4.9 . See, however, Corollary 4.20 below. The appearance of a multiple of 2\zeta-\xi in Lemma 4.17 is not a coincidence. In the following lemma and its proof, all summations are understood to run over a\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Lemma 4.19 . Let f\in L_{0,0} be arbitrary and write (12) f=\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}+\lambda_{\zeta}\zeta+\lambda_{\xi}\xi for certain scalars \lambda_{a,a^{\prime}},\lambda_{\zeta},\lambda_{\xi}\in k . Then f=0 if and only if the following assertions are satisfied. (1) \lambda_{\zeta}+2\lambda_{\xi}=0 . (2) \textstyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}T(a,a^{\prime})=3\lambda_{\xi} . (3) \textstyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a,a^{\prime}}=2\lambda_{\xi}\id_{J} and \textstyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a^{\prime},a}=2\lambda_{\xi}\id_{J^{\prime}} . In this situation, we have \sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}=\lambda_{\xi}\cdot(2\zeta-\xi)\quad\text{and}\quad\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\delta_{a,a^{\prime}}=\lambda_{\xi}\cdot 2\gamma. Proof. Let t:=\textstyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}T(a,a^{\prime}) . Then \displaystyle[f,(1,0,0,0)_{+}] \displaystyle=(-t+\lambda_{\xi}-\lambda_{\zeta},0,0,0)_{+}, \displaystyle[f,(1,0,0,0)_{-}] \displaystyle=(-t-\lambda_{\xi}-2\lambda_{\zeta}), \displaystyle[f,(0,b,0,0)_{+}] \displaystyle=\left(0,\textstyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b)+(-t+\lambda_{\xi})b,0,0\right)_{+}, \displaystyle[f,(0,b,0,0)_{-}] \displaystyle=\left(0,\textstyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b)+(-t-\lambda_{\xi}-\lambda_{\zeta})b\right)_{-}, \displaystyle[f,(0,0,b^{\prime},0)_{+}] \displaystyle=\left(-\textstyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime})+(t+\lambda_{\xi}+\lambda_{\zeta})b^{\prime},0\right)_{+}, \displaystyle[f,(0,0,b^{\prime},0)_{-}] \displaystyle=\left(-\textstyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime})+(t-\lambda_{\xi})b^{\prime},0\right)_{-}, \displaystyle[f,(0,0,0,1)_{+}] \displaystyle=(0,0,0,t+\lambda_{\xi}+2\lambda_{\zeta}), \displaystyle[f,(0,0,0,1)_{-}] \displaystyle=(0,0,0,t-\lambda_{\xi}+\lambda_{\zeta}), \displaystyle[f,x] \displaystyle=(-2\lambda_{\xi}-\lambda_{\zeta})x, \displaystyle[f,y] \displaystyle=(2\lambda_{\xi}+\lambda_{\zeta})y. Since f=0 if and only if all these expressions are zero, the equivalence in the assertion follows. The remaining equations are then a straightforward consequence, using that \gamma=(\id_{J},-\id_{J^{\prime}}) and \delta_{a,a^{\prime}}=(D_{a,a^{\prime}},-D_{a^{\prime},a}) . ∎ Corollary 4.20 . The linear map \pi\colon Z\to\TKK_{0}(J,J^{\prime})\colon\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}+\lambda_{\zeta}\zeta+\lambda_{\xi}\xi\mapsto\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\delta_{a,a^{\prime}}+\lambda_{\zeta}\gamma is well-defined. It is an epimorphism of Lie algebras, which extends to an epimorphism L_{0}\to\TKK(J,J^{\prime}) . In particular, L_{0} is a central extension of \TKK(J,J^{\prime}) . Proof. If \sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}+\lambda_{\zeta}\zeta+\lambda_{\xi}\xi=0 , then also \sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\delta_{a,a^{\prime}}+\lambda_{\zeta}\gamma=0 by Lemma 4.19 , so \pi is well-defined. Further, since \xi,\zeta are central in Z and \gamma is central in \TKK_{0}(J,J^{\prime}) , it follows from the comparison of Eqs. 9 and 4.13 that \pi is a homomorphism of Lie algebras. Clearly, \pi is surjective. Since L_{0}=J\oplus Z\oplus J^{\prime} and \TKK(J,J^{\prime})=J\oplus\TKK_{0}(J,J^{\prime})\oplus J^{\prime} , we can extend \pi to an epimorphism L_{0}\to\TKK(J,J^{\prime}) of k -modules in a natural way. This defines an epimorphism of Lie algebras because for all a,b\in J , a^{\prime},b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} , we have [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},b]=D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b) and [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},b^{\prime}]=-D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime}) in L_{0} by Proposition 4.14 and [\delta_{a,a^{\prime}},b]=(\delta_{a,a^{\prime}})_{+}(b)=D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b) and [\delta_{a,a^{\prime}},b^{\prime}]=(\delta_{a,a^{\prime}})_{-}(b^{\prime})=-D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime}) in \TKK(J,J^{\prime}) by Eq. 8 . It remains to show that the kernel of \pi is central. Let f=\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}+\lambda_{\xi}\xi+\lambda_{\zeta}\zeta denote an arbitrary element of the kernel and let c\in J , c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} be arbitrary. Then \displaystyle[f,\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}}] \displaystyle=\left[\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}}\right]=\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\big(\mathbf{d}(D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c),c^{\prime})-\mathbf{d}(c,D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime}))\big) \displaystyle=\mathbf{d}\big(\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c),c^{\prime}\big)-\mathbf{d}\big(c,\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})\big). Since f lies in the kernel of \pi , we have \sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\delta_{a,a^{\prime}}+\lambda_{\zeta}\gamma=0 or, in other words, \sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a,a^{\prime}}=-\lambda_{\zeta}\id_{J}\quad\text{and}\quad\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a^{\prime},a}=-\lambda_{\zeta}\id_{J^{\prime}}. Hence \displaystyle[f,\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}}]=\mathbf{d}(-\lambda_{\zeta}c,c^{\prime})-\mathbf{d}(c,-\lambda_{\zeta}c^{\prime})=0. Further, [f,\xi]=0=[f,\zeta] . Thus the kernel of \pi is indeed central. ∎ We are now ready to make the k -module (13) L:=L_{-2}\oplus L_{-1}\oplus L_{0}\oplus L_{1}\oplus L_{2} into a Lie algebra. It remains to describe the Lie bracket between elements of L_{i} and L_{j} for i,j\neq 0 , followed by a somewhat lengthy verification that this does indeed define a Lie algebra. Before we proceed, we also fix the second grading on L that was long visible on Fig. 1 . Definition 4.21 . For each j\in\mathbb{Z} , we define L^{\prime}_{j}:=\bigoplus_{i}L_{i,j}, where the L_{i,j} are as in Definitions 4.1 and 4.9 , with the convention that L_{i,j}=0 if it has not been defined. In particular, L now admits two decompositions \displaystyle L \displaystyle=L_{-2}\oplus L_{-1}\oplus L_{0}\oplus L_{1}\oplus L_{2}\quad\text{and} \displaystyle L \displaystyle=L^{\prime}_{-2}\oplus L^{\prime}_{-1}\oplus L^{\prime}_{0}\oplus L^{\prime}_{1}\oplus L^{\prime}_{2}. (Observe that both L_{i}=0 and L^{\prime}_{i}=0 whenever |i|>2 .) Notice that [\xi,l]=il for all l\in L_{i} and [\zeta,l]=jl for all l\in L^{\prime}_{j} . However, we cannot use these identities to define L_{i} and L^{\prime}_{j} in general because our base ring k is arbitrary (so e.g. we might have 2=0 in k ). Definition 4.22 . Let \displaystyle[x,(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}] \displaystyle:=-(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}\,, \displaystyle[y,(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}] \displaystyle:=(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}\,, \displaystyle[x,y] \displaystyle:=\xi, \displaystyle\bigl[(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-},\ (\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}\bigr] \displaystyle:=\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)x, \displaystyle\bigl[(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+},\ (\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}\bigr] \displaystyle:=\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)y, for all \lambda,\mu,\nu,\rho\in k , a,b\in J and a^{\prime},b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Of course, we define [L_{i},L_{j}]:=0 whenever |i+j|>2 . It only remains to define [L_{-1},L_{1}] , which is the most complicated case: (14) \bigl[(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-},\ (\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}\bigr]\\ \quad:=\bigl(-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime}\bigr)\\ +\bigl((\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot\zeta+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot(\xi-\zeta)+\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\bigr)\\ +\bigl(-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c\bigr). We first observe that all these definitions respect both gradings. Lemma 4.23 . Let l\in L_{i}\cap L^{\prime}_{i^{\prime}} and m\in L_{j}\cap L^{\prime}_{j^{\prime}} . Then [l,m]\in L_{i+j}\cap L^{\prime}_{i^{\prime}+j^{\prime}} . Proof. This is a straightforward verification, going through the different cases, using Definitions 4.7 , 4.9 and 4.22 . ∎ We have summarized the complete definition of the Lie bracket on L=L_{-2}\oplus L_{-1}\oplus L_{0}\oplus L_{1}\oplus L_{2} in Table 1 . \begin{array}[]{c||c|c|ccccc|c|c|}[\,\downarrow\,,\rightarrow\,]&x&(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}&c^{\prime}&\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}}&\xi&\zeta&c&(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}&y\\ \hline\cr\hline\cr x&0&0&0&0&2x&x&0&-(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}&\xi\\ \hline\cr(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}&0&\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)x&\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime}),\ c^{\prime}\times b^{\prime},\ \mu c^{\prime},\ 0\bigr)_{-}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),\\[1.29167pt] \quad-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b,\\[1.29167pt] \quad D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})-T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 51.6665pt-\mu T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),\\[1.29167pt] \quad-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b,\\[1.29167pt] \quad D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})-T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 51.6665pt-\mu T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447pt-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b,\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447ptD_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})-T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 36.16663pt-\mu T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612pt-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b,\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612ptD_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})-T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 25.83325pt-\mu T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}&(2\lambda,b,0,-\mu)_{-}&-\bigl(0,\ \lambda c,\ c\times b,\ T(c,b^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\ \bigl(-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime}\bigr)\\[3.44444pt] \quad{}+(\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot\zeta\\ \quad{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot(\xi-\zeta)\\ \quad{}+\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[2.58334pt] \hskip 38.74988pt{}+\bigl(-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c\bigr)\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\ \bigl(-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime}\bigr)\\[3.44444pt] \quad{}+(\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot\zeta\\ \quad{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot(\xi-\zeta)\\ \quad{}+\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[2.58334pt] \hskip 38.74988pt{}+\bigl(-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c\bigr)\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\ \bigl(-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime}\bigr)\\[2.41112pt] \hskip 8.19447pt{}+(\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot\zeta\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot(\xi-\zeta)\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}+\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[1.80835pt] \hskip 27.12497pt{}+\bigl(-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c\bigr)\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\ \bigl(-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime}\bigr)\\[1.72221pt] \hskip 7.3612pt{}+(\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot\zeta\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot(\xi-\zeta)\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}+\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 19.37494pt{}+\bigl(-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c\bigr)\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&-(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}\\ \hline\cr b^{\prime}&0&-\bigl(T(c,b^{\prime}),\ b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime},\ \rho b^{\prime},\ 0\bigr)_{-}&0&D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})&0&b^{\prime}&\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}&-\bigl(T(c,b^{\prime}),\ b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime},\ \rho b^{\prime},\ 0\bigr)_{+}&0\\ \mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}&0&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\nu T(a,a^{\prime}),\\[1.29167pt] \quad D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\\[1.29167pt] \quad-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime},\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 64.58313pt\rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\nu T(a,a^{\prime}),\\[1.29167pt] \quad D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\\[1.29167pt] \quad-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime},\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 64.58313pt\rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\nu T(a,a^{\prime}),\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447ptD_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447pt-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime},\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 45.20828pt\rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\nu T(a,a^{\prime}),\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612ptD_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612pt-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime},\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 32.29156pt\rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})&\mathbf{d}_{D_{a,a^{\prime}}(e),e^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{e,D_{a^{\prime},a}(e^{\prime})}&0&0&D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\nu T(a,a^{\prime}),\\[1.29167pt] \quad D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\\[1.29167pt] \quad-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime},\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 64.58313pt\rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\nu T(a,a^{\prime}),\\[1.29167pt] \quad D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\\[1.29167pt] \quad-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime},\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 64.58313pt\rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\nu T(a,a^{\prime}),\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447ptD_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447pt-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime},\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 45.20828pt\rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\nu T(a,a^{\prime}),\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612ptD_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612pt-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime},\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 32.29156pt\rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&0\\ \xi&-2x&-(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}&0&0&0&0&0&(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}&2y\\ \zeta&-x&(-2\nu,-c,0,\rho)_{-}&-c^{\prime}&0&0&0&c&(-\nu,0,c^{\prime},2\rho)_{+}&y\\ b&0&\bigl(0,\ \nu b,\ b\times c,\ T(b,c^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}&-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}&-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)&0&-b&0&\bigl(0,\ \nu b,\ b\times c,\ T(b,c^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}&0\\ \hline\cr(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}&(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\ \bigl(\lambda c^{\prime}-b\times c+\nu b^{\prime}\bigr)\\[3.44444pt] \quad{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot\zeta\\ \quad{}+(\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot(\xi-\zeta)\\ \quad{}-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[2.58334pt] \hskip 38.74988pt{}+\bigl(\rho b-b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}+\mu c\bigr)\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\ \bigl(\lambda c^{\prime}-b\times c+\nu b^{\prime}\bigr)\\[3.44444pt] \quad{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot\zeta\\ \quad{}+(\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot(\xi-\zeta)\\ \quad{}-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[2.58334pt] \hskip 38.74988pt{}+\bigl(\rho b-b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}+\mu c\bigr)\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\ \bigl(\lambda c^{\prime}-b\times c+\nu b^{\prime}\bigr)\\[2.41112pt] \hskip 8.19447pt{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot\zeta\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}+(\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot(\xi-\zeta)\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[1.80835pt] \hskip 27.12497pt{}+\bigl(\rho b-b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}+\mu c\bigr)\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\ \bigl(\lambda c^{\prime}-b\times c+\nu b^{\prime}\bigr)\\[1.72221pt] \hskip 7.3612pt{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot\zeta\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}+(\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot(\xi-\zeta)\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 19.37494pt{}+\bigl(\rho b-b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}+\mu c\bigr)\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime}),\ c^{\prime}\times b^{\prime},\ \mu c^{\prime},\ 0\bigr)_{+}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),\\[1.29167pt] \quad-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b,\\[1.29167pt] \quad D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})-T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 51.6665pt-\mu T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),\\[1.29167pt] \quad-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b,\\[1.29167pt] \quad D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})-T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 51.6665pt-\mu T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447pt-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b,\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447ptD_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})-T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 36.16663pt-\mu T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612pt-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b,\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612ptD_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})-T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 25.83325pt-\mu T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}\par&-(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}&(\lambda,0,-b^{\prime},-2\mu)_{+}&-\bigl(0,\ \lambda c,\ c\times b,\ T(c,b^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}&\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)y&0\\ \hline\cr y&-\xi&(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}&0&0&-2y&-y&0&0&0\\ \hline\cr\end{array} Table 1. The Lie bracket on L=L_{-2}\oplus L_{-1}\oplus L_{0}\oplus L_{1}\oplus L_{2} 4.2. Verification of the Jacobi identity To verify the Jacobi identity on L , we use a little trick to simplify some computations. The following auxiliary definition is a useful shorthand. Definition 4.24 . Let a,b,c\in L , where L is a k -module equipped with a k -bilinear skew-symmetric operation [\cdot,\cdot] . We write \Jac(a,b,c) if the Jacobi identity holds for the triple (a,b,c) , i.e., [[a,b],c]+[[b,c],a]+[[c,a],b]=0. Notice that by the skew-symmetry, \Jac(a,b,c) implies \Jac(x,y,z) for any permutation (x,y,z) of (a,b,c) . Similarly, if A , B and C are subsets (usually subspaces) of L , we write \Jac(A,B,C) if \Jac(a,b,c) for all a\in A , b\in B and c\in C . We also write, for example, \Jac(a,B,C) as a shorthand for \Jac(\{a\},B,C) when a\in L and B and C are subsets of L . Lemma 4.25 . Let L be a k -algebra with a \mathbb{Z} -grading L=\oplus_{i\in\mathbb{Z}}L_{i} , denote the multiplication in L by [\cdot,\cdot] and assume that it is skew-symmetric. Fix i,j\in\mathbb{Z} and l,m\in L_{0} . Assume that \Jac(l,L_{i},L_{j}) , \Jac(m,L_{i},L_{j}) and \Jac(l,m,L_{i}\cup L_{j}\cup L_{i+j}) . Then also \Jac([l,m],L_{i},L_{j}) . Proof. This is a straighforward verification, using the fact that when z\in L_{i} , then also [l,z],[m,z]\in L_{i} , because of the grading. ∎ Remark 4.26 . By Definition 4.21 , we have [\xi,\ell]=i\ell\quad\text{and}\quad[\zeta,\ell]=j\ell\quad\text{whenever }\ell\in L_{i}\cap L^{\prime}_{j}. As a consequence, the Jacobi identity will be automatically satisfied for triples involving \xi or \zeta . More precisely, if \ell\in L_{i}\cap L^{\prime}_{j} and \ell^{\prime}\in L_{i^{\prime}}\cap L^{\prime}_{j^{\prime}} , then by Lemma 4.23 , we have [\ell,\ell^{\prime}]\in L_{i+i^{\prime}}\cap L^{\prime}_{j+j^{\prime}} , so we have \displaystyle[[\zeta,\ell],\ell^{\prime}]+[[\ell,\ell^{\prime}],\zeta]+[[\ell^{\prime},\zeta],\ell] \displaystyle=[j\ell,\ell^{\prime}]-[\zeta,[\ell,\ell^{\prime}]]+[\ell,j^{\prime}\ell^{\prime}] \displaystyle=j[\ell,\ell^{\prime}]-(j+j^{\prime})[\ell,\ell^{\prime}]+j^{\prime}[\ell,\ell^{\prime}]=0, and similarly for \xi . Proposition 4.27 . The algebra L=L_{-2}\oplus L_{-1}\oplus L_{0}\oplus L_{1}\oplus L_{2} equipped with the Lie brackets from Definitions 4.7 , 4.9 and 4.22 is a (5-graded) Lie algebra. Proof. We have to check the Jacobi identity for all triples of elements in L . By linearity, we may of course assume that each of these elements is homogeneous, i.e., belongs to some L_{i} . It is clear from our definitions that the proof for triples in L_{i} , L_{i^{\prime}} , L_{i^{\prime\prime}} can be translated mutatis mutandis to a proof for triples in L_{-i} , L_{-i^{\prime}} , L_{-i^{\prime\prime}} . In addition, the Jacobi identity is trivially satisfied if |i+i^{\prime}+i^{\prime\prime}|>2 , and by Remark 4.16 , we already know that it is satisfied if at least two of the three indices are 0 . Recall also that by Remark 4.2 , the Lie bracket is skew-symmetric. That leaves us with the following nine cases for (i,i^{\prime},i^{\prime\prime}) : \displaystyle(0,1,1), \displaystyle(0,1,-1), \displaystyle(0,1,-2), \displaystyle(0,2,-2), \displaystyle(1,1,-1), \displaystyle(1,1,-2), \displaystyle(1,2,-1), \displaystyle(1,2,-2), \displaystyle(2,2,-2). Unavoidably, we will deal with these different cases one by one. In each case, we will assume that \ell\in L_{i} , \ell^{\prime}\in L_{i^{\prime}} and \ell^{\prime\prime}\in L_{i^{\prime\prime}} and our goal is to show the Jacobi identity for the triple (\ell,\ell^{\prime},\ell^{\prime\prime}) . Before we proceed with our case-by-case analysis, we point out that whenever we want to check the Jacobi identity for all triples (\ell,\ell^{\prime},\ell^{\prime\prime}) with \ell\in L_{0} , it suffices to consider \ell\in J\cup J^{\prime} . Indeed, the case \ell=\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}} then follows from Lemma 4.25 , and the cases \ell=\zeta and \ell=\xi are automatically satisfied by Remark 4.26 . In addition, since the cases \ell\in J and \ell\in J^{\prime} are completely similar in each case, we will always assume that \ell=a\in J whenever i=0 . Case (0,1,1) : Write \ell=a , \ell^{\prime}=(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+} and \ell^{\prime\prime}=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} . Notice that [\ell^{\prime},\ell^{\prime\prime}]\in L_{2} , so [a,[\ell^{\prime},\ell^{\prime\prime}]]=0 . We have to show that [[a,\ell^{\prime}],\ell^{\prime\prime}]=[[a,\ell^{\prime\prime}],\ell^{\prime}] . We compute \displaystyle[[a,\ell^{\prime}],\ell^{\prime\prime}] \displaystyle=\bigl[[a,(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}],(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}\bigr] \displaystyle=\bigl[\bigl(0,\ \lambda a,\ a\times b,\ T(a,b^{\prime})\bigr)_{+},(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}\bigr] \displaystyle=\bigl(\lambda T(a,c^{\prime})-T(c,a\times b)+\nu T(a,b^{\prime})\bigr)\cdot y, and since T(c,a\times b)=T(b,a\times c) , this is indeed symmetric in \ell^{\prime} and \ell^{\prime\prime} . Case (0,1,-1) : This is the most interesting case. Write \ell=a , \ell^{\prime}=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} and \ell^{\prime\prime}=(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-} . We compute \displaystyle[[a,\ell^{\prime\prime}],\ell^{\prime}]=\bigl[[a,(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}],(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}\bigr] \displaystyle=\bigl[\bigl(0,\ \lambda a,\ a\times b,\ T(a,b^{\prime})\bigr)_{-},(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}\bigr] \displaystyle=(\lambda a\times c-\nu a\times b) \displaystyle\hskip 25.83325pt+\bigl(-\lambda T(a,c^{\prime})\cdot\zeta+(T(c,a\times b)-\nu T(a,b^{\prime}))\cdot(\xi-\zeta)+\lambda\mathbf{d}_{a,c^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{c,a\times b}\bigr) \displaystyle\hskip 25.83325pt+\bigl(-\lambda\rho a+(a\times b)\times c^{\prime}-T(a,b^{\prime})c\bigr); \displaystyle[[\ell^{\prime},a],\ell^{\prime\prime}]=[\ell^{\prime\prime},[a,\ell^{\prime}]]=\bigl[(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-},[a,(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}]\bigr] \displaystyle=\bigl[(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-},\bigl(0,\ \nu a,\ a\times c,\ T(a,c^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\bigr] \displaystyle=(-\lambda a\times c+\nu a\times b) \displaystyle\hskip 25.83325pt+\bigl((\lambda T(a,c^{\prime})-T(b,a\times c))\cdot\zeta+\nu T(a,b^{\prime})\cdot(\xi-\zeta)+\mathbf{d}_{b,a\times c}+\nu\mathbf{d}_{a,b^{\prime}}\bigr) \displaystyle\hskip 25.83325pt+\bigl(-T(a,c^{\prime})b+(a\times c)\times b^{\prime}-\mu\nu a\bigr); \displaystyle[[\ell^{\prime\prime},\ell^{\prime}],a]=\Bigl[\bigl(-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime}\bigr) \displaystyle\hskip 68.88867pt+\bigl((\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot\zeta+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot(\xi-\zeta)+\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\bigr) \displaystyle\hskip 68.88867pt+\bigl(-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c\bigr),\ a\Bigr] \displaystyle=(-\lambda\mathbf{d}_{a,c^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{a,b\times c}-\nu\mathbf{d}_{a,b^{\prime}}) \displaystyle\hskip 25.83325pt+\bigl((\lambda\rho+\mu\nu-T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime}))a+D_{b,c^{\prime}}(a)+D_{c,b^{\prime}}(a)\bigr) \displaystyle=(-\lambda\mathbf{d}_{a,c^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{a,b\times c}-\nu\mathbf{d}_{a,b^{\prime}}) \displaystyle\hskip 25.83325pt+\bigl((\lambda\rho+\mu\nu)a+T(a,c^{\prime})b+T(a,b^{\prime})c-(a\times b)\times c^{\prime}-(a\times c)\times b^{\prime}\bigr). The Jacobi identity [[a,\ell^{\prime\prime}],\ell^{\prime}]+[[\ell^{\prime},a],\ell^{\prime\prime}]+[[\ell^{\prime\prime},\ell^{\prime}],a]=0 now follows from Lemma 4.17 . Case (0,1,-2) : Write \ell=a , \ell^{\prime}=(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+} . Without loss of generality, \ell^{\prime\prime}=x . Notice that [a,x]=0 , and we quickly verify that \displaystyle[a,[x,(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}]]-[x,[a,(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}]] \displaystyle=-[a,(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}]-[x,\bigl(0,\ \lambda a,\ a\times b,\ T(a,b^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}] \displaystyle=-\bigl(0,\ \lambda a,\ a\times b,\ T(a,b^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}+\bigl(0,\ \lambda a,\ a\times b,\ T(a,b^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}=0. Case (0,2,-2) : Write \ell=a . Without loss of generality, \ell^{\prime}=y and \ell^{\prime\prime}=x . We have [a,x]=0 and [a,y]=0 . Moreover, [[x,y],a]=[\xi,a]=0 . Case (1,1,-1) : This is the lengthiest computation, but there are no surprises. Write \ell=(\nu_{1},c_{1},c_{1}^{\prime},\rho_{1})_{+} , \ell^{\prime}=(\nu_{2},c_{2},c_{2}^{\prime},\rho_{2})_{+} and \ell^{\prime\prime}=(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-} . First, we have \displaystyle[\ell^{\prime\prime},[\ell,\ell^{\prime}]] \displaystyle=\bigl[(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-},\bigl(T(c_{1},c_{2}^{\prime})-T(c_{2},c_{1}^{\prime})+\rho_{1}\nu_{2}-\nu_{1}\rho_{2}\bigr)\cdot y\bigr] \displaystyle=\bigl(-T(c_{1},c_{2}^{\prime})+T(c_{2},c_{1}^{\prime})-\rho_{1}\nu_{2}+\nu_{1}\rho_{2}\bigr)\cdot(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}. To compute [[\ell^{\prime\prime},\ell],\ell^{\prime}] , we use Eqs. 14 and 4.7 , and after working out all the different terms, we get \displaystyle[[\ell^{\prime\prime},\ell],\ell^{\prime}] \displaystyle=\Bigl(\begin{multlined}\lambda T(c_{2},c_{1}^{\prime})-\lambda T(c_{2},b\times c_{1})+\nu_{1}T(c_{2},b^{\prime})-\lambda\rho_{1}\nu_{2}+\nu_{2}T(c_{1},b^{\prime})-2\mu\nu_{1}\nu_{2},\\[4.30554pt] \lambda c_{1}^{\prime}\times c_{2}^{\prime}-(b\times c_{1})\times c_{2}^{\prime}+\nu_{1}b^{\prime}\times c_{2}^{\prime}-\nu_{2}\rho_{1}b+\nu_{2}b^{\prime}\times c_{1}^{\prime}-\nu_{2}\mu c_{1}+T(c_{1},b^{\prime})c_{2}\\ -\mu\nu_{1}c_{2}-c_{1}^{\prime}\times(b\times c_{2})+T(c_{2},c_{1}^{\prime})b-(c_{1}\times c_{2})\times b^{\prime}+T(c_{2},b^{\prime})c_{1},\\[4.30554pt] \lambda\rho_{2}c_{1}^{\prime}-\rho_{2}b\times c_{1}+\nu_{1}\rho_{2}b^{\prime}-\rho_{1}b\times c_{2}+(b^{\prime}\times c_{1}^{\prime})\times c_{2}-\mu c_{1}\times c_{2}+\lambda\rho_{1}c_{2}^{\prime}\\ -T(b,c_{1}^{\prime})c_{2}^{\prime}-T(b,c_{2}^{\prime})c_{1}^{\prime}+b\times(c_{1}^{\prime}\times c_{2}^{\prime})-T(c_{1},c_{2}^{\prime})b^{\prime}+c_{1}\times(b^{\prime}\times c_{2}^{\prime}),\\[0.0pt] -\rho_{1}T(b,c_{2}^{\prime})+T(b^{\prime}\times c_{1}^{\prime},c_{2}^{\prime})-\mu T(c_{1},c_{2}^{\prime})+2\rho_{1}\rho_{2}-T(b,c_{1}^{\prime})\rho_{2}+\mu\nu_{1}\rho_{2}\Bigr)_{+}\,.\end{multlined} The expression for [[\ell^{\prime\prime},\ell^{\prime}],\ell] is, of course, exactly the same but with all subscripts 1 and 2 interchanged. It is now pleasant to observe that when we compute the difference [[\ell^{\prime\prime},\ell],\ell^{\prime}]-[[\ell^{\prime\prime},\ell^{\prime}],\ell] , many terms cancel out, and what is left is precisely the expression for [\ell^{\prime\prime},[\ell,\ell^{\prime}]] that we have computed above. Case (1,1,-2) : Write \ell=(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+} and \ell^{\prime}=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} , and assume without loss of generality that \ell^{\prime\prime}=x . We have \displaystyle[[x,\ell],\ell^{\prime}] \displaystyle=\bigl[[x,(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}],(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}\bigr] \displaystyle=-\bigl[(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-},(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}\bigr], so we deduce from Eq. 14 that \displaystyle[[x,\ell],\ell^{\prime}]-[[x,\ell^{\prime}],\ell] \displaystyle=\bigl[(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-},(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}\bigr]-\bigl[(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-},(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}\bigr] \displaystyle=\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)\cdot\xi. On the other hand, \displaystyle[x,[\ell,\ell^{\prime}]] \displaystyle=\bigl[x,\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)y\bigr] \displaystyle=\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)\cdot[x,y], and we conclude that indeed [x,[\ell,\ell^{\prime}]]=[[x,\ell],\ell^{\prime}]-[[x,\ell^{\prime}],\ell] . Case (1,2,-1) : Write \ell=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} and \ell^{\prime\prime}=(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , and assume without loss of generality that \ell^{\prime}=y . Notice that [\ell,y]=0 . Since [y,J]=[y,J^{\prime}]=[y,[J^{\prime},J]]=0 , we have \displaystyle[y,[\ell^{\prime\prime},\ell]] \displaystyle=\bigl[y,(\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot\zeta+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot(\xi-\zeta)\bigr] \displaystyle=\bigl(-\lambda\rho+T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu\bigr)\cdot y. On the other hand, we also have [[y,\ell^{\prime\prime}],\ell]=\bigl[(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+},(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}\bigr]=\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)y. Case (1,2,-2) : Write \ell=(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+} and assume without loss of generality that \ell^{\prime}=y and \ell^{\prime\prime}=x . Notice that [\ell,y]=0 and that [x,y]=\xi . The result now follows from the facts that [\xi,\ell]=\ell and [y,[x,\ell]]=-\ell . Case (2,2,-2) : Without loss of generality, \ell=\ell^{\prime}=y and \ell^{\prime\prime}=x , so the Jacobi identity is trivially satisfied. ∎ Proposition 4.28 . The decomposition L=\bigoplus_{\alpha\in G_{2}^{0}}L_{\alpha} from Remark 4.4 is a G_{2} -grading of the Lie algebra L . Proof. We can read off from Table 1 that [L_{\alpha},L_{\beta}]\leq L_{\alpha+\beta} for all \alpha,\beta\in G_{2}^{0} . ∎ Remark 4.29 . In the case that J=0=J^{\prime} , there are only six non-trivial root spaces in L , and they constitute an A_{2} -grading of L . Theorem 4.30 . Let (J,J^{\prime}) be a cubic norm pair over a commutative ring k . Then there exists a G_{2} -graded Lie algebra L such that L_{\alpha}\cong(k,+) for all long roots \alpha\in G_{2} , L_{\beta}\cong(J,+) for three short roots \beta\in G_{2} which lie in the same of the three orbits of G_{2} in Remark 4.5 and L_{\gamma}\cong(J^{\prime},+) for the remaining three short roots \gamma . Proof. As a module, L was constructed in Definitions 4.1 , 4.9 and 13 , and its root spaces have the desired isomorphism type. The Lie bracket was constructed in Definitions 4.1 , 4.7 and 4.22 and is summarized in Table 1 . We showed in Propositions 4.27 and 4.28 that L is a G_{2} -graded Lie algebra. ∎ Remark 4.31 . In [ 12 ] , John Faulkner constructs Lie algebras from “ternary algebras” over arbitrary commutative base rings. Cubic norm structures provide examples of those, and the resulting Lie algebras are probably isomorphic to the Lie algebras that we have constructed (but we have not explicitly carried out this verification). In any case, we need our more “refined” description to obtain the G_{2} -grading (and we want to refine it even further to an F_{4} -grading later). In fact, our approach is more direct for cubic norm structures, because Faulkner uses the triple product—see [ 12 , (1.6) on p. 399] —which in itself is already quite complicated. On the other hand, we recognize his bilinear form (1.5) directly in our formulas in Definition 4.22 . 5. Functoriality and reflections In the previous section, we have constructed a Lie algebra L=L(J,J^{\prime}) for every cubic norm pair (J,J^{\prime}) (in fact, for every linear cubic norm pair). The current section is devoted to the construction of several interesting Lie algebra homomorphisms that are defined on L(J,J^{\prime}) . We begin by establishing that L(J,J^{\prime}) is functorial in (J,J^{\prime}) : For any surjective homomorphism (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})\colon(J,J^{\prime})\to(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) of cubic norm pairs, we construct a surjective homomorphism L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})\colon L(J,J^{\prime})\to L(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) of Lie algebras that is bijective if and only if (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}) is ( Lemma 5.15 ). Here the surjectivity of (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}) is a subtle requirement which ensures that L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}) is well-defined (see Remark 5.3 ), and which is also present in the construction of (the functorial homomorphisms defined on) the Tits-Kantor-Koecher algebra of a Jordan pair (see [ 19 , §7.1] ). We can even phrase our construction in a slightly more general way: Every surjective t -homotopy (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}) between cubic norm pairs induces a surjective homomorphism L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t) of Lie algebras. A corollary of this observation is that the isomorphism type of L(J,J^{\prime}) depends only on the isotopy type of (J,J^{\prime}) . Another application of the functoriality of L(J,J^{\prime}) will be given in Section 6 (in particular, Remark 6.17 ), where we investigate quotients of L(J,J^{\prime}) that are induced by “ideals of (k,J,J^{\prime}) ” . We also define automorphisms \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} , \varphi_{\updownarrow} , \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} of L that we call “reflections” because they permute the root spaces of L(J,J^{\prime}) in a way that is prescribed by a reflection of the root system G_{2} . Each of these automorphisms corresponds to one of the 5 -gradings of L(J,J^{\prime}) described in Remark 4.3 in the sense that it reverses the grading: It maps the i -graded part to the (-i) -graded part. We can also define a fourth reflection \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} which reverses the 7 -grading of L(J,J^{\prime}) , but only under the assumption that we are given an isomorphism (or, more generally, a t -isotopy) (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})\colon(J,J^{\prime})\to(J^{\prime},J) . This assumption is certainly necessary because a reflection that reverses the 7 -grading necessarily maps root spaces parametrized by J isomorphically to root spaces parametrized by J^{\prime} , and vice versa. In the general situation, we can only construct an isomorphism \psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}\colon L(J,J^{\prime})\to L(J^{\prime},J) , and \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} is simply the composition of \psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} with L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t) . In Section 7 , we will construct root groups (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}} in \Aut(L) . This would, if done naively, involve a large number of lengthy computations. The reflections described in the previous paragraph allow us to reduce the number of computations significantly by exploiting the symmetries of L . For details, see Proposition B.14 . Moreover, we will show in Propositions B.15 and B.24 that \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} and \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} are Weyl elements with respect to (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}} (under suitable assumptions in the case of \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} ). This is one important step in proving that (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}} is a G_{2} -grading of a subgroup of \Aut(L) . Notation 5.1 . For any linear cubic norm pair (J,J^{\prime}) , we denote by L(J,J^{\prime}) the corresponding Lie algebra constructed in Proposition 4.27 . If no linear cubic norm pair is specified, we assume that (J,J^{\prime}) is a fixed linear cubic norm pair and that L\coloneq L(J,J^{\prime}) is the corresponding Lie algebra. Further, we will occasionally use the convention from Remark 4.4 to identify G_{2}^{0} with a subset of \mathbb{Z}^{2} . Convention 5.2 . We will always let automorphism of L act on L from the left. Remark 5.3 . We will define all homomorphisms on L by describing their action on all components. Since it is in general not true that the sum \langle\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}\mid a\in J,a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime}\rangle+k\zeta+k\xi is direct, it is a priori not clear that these maps are well-defined on L_{0,0} . This will be verified in Lemma 5.14 . We begin with the functoriality of L(J,J^{\prime}) with respect to surjective homotopies. Definition 5.4 . Let (J_{1},J_{1}^{\prime}) and (J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) be two linear cubic norm pairs (over the same ring k ), let t\in k be invertible and let (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})\colon(J_{1},J_{1}^{\prime})\to(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) be a surjective t -homotopy of linear cubic norm pairs. Then we define a map L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t)\colon L(J_{1},J_{1}^{\prime})\to L(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}), denoted by \psi in the following set of equations, by setting \displaystyle\psi(x) \displaystyle\coloneq t^{-1}x, \displaystyle\psi((\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}) \displaystyle\coloneq(t^{-1}\nu,t^{-1}c^{\iota},(c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},\rho)_{-}, \displaystyle\psi(c^{\prime}) \displaystyle\coloneq(c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}, \displaystyle\psi(\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}}) \displaystyle\coloneq\mathbf{d}_{c^{\iota},(c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}},\quad\psi(\xi)\coloneq\xi,\quad\psi(\zeta)\coloneq\zeta, \displaystyle\psi(c) \displaystyle\coloneq c^{\iota}, \displaystyle\psi((\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}) \displaystyle\coloneq(\nu,c^{\iota},t(c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t\rho)_{+} \displaystyle\psi(y) \displaystyle\coloneq ty for all \nu,\rho\in k , c\in J , c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . If (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}) is a homomorphism (i.e., if t=1 ), we simply put L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})\coloneq L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},1) . Remark 5.5 . If (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})\colon(J,J^{\prime})\to(J^{\prime},J) is a t -involution for some invertible t\in k , then L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t)^{-1}=L({\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},\iota,t^{-1}) . Remark 5.6 . The definition of L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t) is not canonical: We made a choice “where to put t and t^{-1} ” . Our choice corresponds to the 5 -grading (L^{\prime\prime}_{i})_{-2\leq i\leq 2} from Remark 4.3 in the sense that exactly the blocks of type J , J^{\prime} that lie in L_{0}^{\prime\prime} and the blocks of type k that lie in L_{-1}^{\prime\prime}+L_{1}^{\prime\prime} are multiplied by t or t^{-1} . In a similar way, we could for example define a map \psi\coloneq L^{\prime}(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t)\colon L(J_{1},J_{1}^{\prime})\to L(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) that corresponds to the 5 -grading (L_{i})_{-2\leq i\leq 2} by \displaystyle\psi(x) \displaystyle\coloneq x, \displaystyle\psi((\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{\pm}) \displaystyle\coloneq(t\nu,c^{\iota},(c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t^{-1}\rho)_{\pm}, \displaystyle\psi(c^{\prime}) \displaystyle\coloneq t(c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}, \displaystyle\psi(\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}}) \displaystyle\coloneq\mathbf{d}_{c^{\iota},(c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}},\quad\psi(\xi)\coloneq\xi,\quad\psi(\zeta)\coloneq\zeta, \displaystyle\psi(c) \displaystyle\coloneq t^{-1}c^{\iota}, \displaystyle\psi(y) \displaystyle\coloneq y for all \nu,\rho\in k , c\in J , c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Note that L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t)=L^{\prime}(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t) if t=1 , that is, if (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}) is a homomorphism. Further, the two maps agree on L_{0,0} for arbitrary t . The latter fact implies that the proof of well-definedness in Lemma 5.14 is also valid for L^{\prime}(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t) . Before we define the automorphism \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} , \varphi_{\updownarrow} , \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} , \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} , we formalize what we mean by “reflections” . Definition 5.7 . Let \Phi be a root system, let \alpha\in\Phi and let \bar{L}=\bigoplus_{\beta\in\Phi^{0}}\bar{L}_{\beta}\quad\text{and}\quad\bar{L}^{\prime}=\bigoplus_{\beta\in\Phi^{0}}\bar{L}_{\beta}^{\prime} be two \Phi -graded Lie algebras. An \alpha -reflection from \bar{L} to \bar{L}^{\prime} is an isomorphism \varphi\colon\bar{L}\to\bar{L}^{\prime} such that \varphi(\bar{L}_{\beta})=\bar{L}^{\prime}_{\beta^{\sigma(\alpha)}} for all \beta\in\Phi^{0} where \sigma_{\alpha}\colon\Phi^{0}\to\Phi^{0} is the reflection along \alpha^{\perp} . The root \alpha will also sometimes be called the type of \varphi . If \bar{L}^{\prime}=\bar{L} , we will simply call \varphi a \alpha -reflection on \bar{L} . The defining formulas for the following reflections on L have been obtained by applying the formulas in [ 10 , Lemma 2.8] to an “extremal element” with respect to the grading that should be reversed. Definition 5.8 . We define endomorphisms \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} and \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} of the k -module L by \displaystyle\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}(x) \displaystyle\coloneq y, \displaystyle\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}((\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}) \displaystyle\coloneq(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}, \displaystyle\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}(c^{\prime}) \displaystyle\coloneq c^{\prime}, \displaystyle\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}(\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}}) \displaystyle\coloneq\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}},\quad\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}(\xi)\coloneq-\xi,\quad\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}(\zeta)\coloneq\zeta-\xi, \displaystyle\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}(c) \displaystyle\coloneq c, \displaystyle\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}((\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}) \displaystyle\coloneq-(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}, \displaystyle\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}(y) \displaystyle\coloneq x, and \displaystyle\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(x) \displaystyle\coloneq(1,0,0,0)_{-}, \displaystyle\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}((\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}) \displaystyle\coloneq-\nu x+(0,c,0,0)_{-}+c^{\prime}-(\rho,0,0,0)_{+}, \displaystyle\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(c^{\prime}) \displaystyle\coloneq-(0,0,c^{\prime},0)_{-}, \displaystyle\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}}) \displaystyle\coloneq\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}}+T(c,c^{\prime})(\xi-\zeta),\quad\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(\xi)\coloneq\zeta,\quad\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(\zeta)\coloneq\xi, \displaystyle\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(c) \displaystyle\coloneq-(0,c,0,0)_{+}, \displaystyle\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}((\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}) \displaystyle\coloneq-(0,0,0,\nu)_{-}+c+(0,0,c^{\prime},0)_{+}-\rho y, \displaystyle\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(y) \displaystyle\coloneq(0,0,0,1)_{+}. for all \nu,\rho\in k , c\in J and c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Remark 5.9 . In a similar way, we can define a third map \varphi_{\updownarrow} by \displaystyle\varphi_{\updownarrow}(x) \displaystyle\coloneq(0,0,0,1)_{-}, \displaystyle\varphi_{\updownarrow}((\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}) \displaystyle\coloneq-\rho x+(0,0,c^{\prime},0)_{-}+c+(0,0,0,\nu)_{+}, \displaystyle\varphi_{\updownarrow}(c^{\prime}) \displaystyle\coloneq(0,0,c^{\prime},0)_{+}, \displaystyle\varphi_{\updownarrow}(\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}}) \displaystyle\coloneq\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}}-T(c,c^{\prime})\zeta,\quad\varphi_{\updownarrow}(\xi)\coloneq\xi-\zeta,\quad\varphi_{\updownarrow}(\zeta)\coloneq-\zeta, \displaystyle\varphi_{\updownarrow}(c) \displaystyle\coloneq-(0,c,0,0)_{-}, \displaystyle\varphi_{\updownarrow}((\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}) \displaystyle\coloneq(0,0,0,\rho)_{-}-c^{\prime}+(0,c,0,0)_{+}+\nu y, \displaystyle\varphi_{\updownarrow}(y) \displaystyle\coloneq(-1,0,0,0)_{+}. We introduce it here for completeness, but we will never use it in our arguments in a meaningful way. For this reason, we will not verify in detail that it is indeed compatible with the Lie bracket, as we do for \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} and \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} in Lemma 5.15 . We will also need the following reflection from L(J,J^{\prime}) to L(J^{\prime},J) in Definitions 5.18 and B.13 . Definition 5.10 . We define a map \psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}\coloneq\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{(J,J^{\prime})}\colon L(J,J^{\prime})\to L(J^{\prime},J) by setting \displaystyle\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(x) \displaystyle\coloneq(0,0,0,1)_{+}, \displaystyle\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}((\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}) \displaystyle\coloneq-\nu y+(0,0,-c,0)_{+}+c^{\prime}+(0,0,0,\rho)_{-}, \displaystyle\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(c^{\prime}) \displaystyle\coloneq\big(0,-c^{\prime},0,0\big)_{+}, \displaystyle\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}}) \displaystyle\coloneq-\mathbf{d}_{c^{\prime},c}+T(c,c^{\prime})(\zeta-\xi),\quad\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(\xi)\coloneq-\zeta,\quad\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(\zeta)\coloneq-\xi, \displaystyle\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(c) \displaystyle\coloneq(0,0,-c,0)_{-}, \displaystyle(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} \displaystyle\coloneq(\nu,0,0,0)_{+}+c+\big(0,-c^{\prime},0,0\big)_{-}-\rho x, \displaystyle\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(y) \displaystyle\coloneq(1,0,0,0)_{-} for all \nu,\rho\in k , c\in J , c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Remark 5.11 . It is immediate from Definitions 5.10 , 5.8 and 5.9 that \displaystyle\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}(L_{\alpha})=L_{\alpha^{\sigma((2,1))}},\quad\varphi_{\updownarrow}(L_{\alpha}) \displaystyle=L_{\alpha^{\sigma((1,2))}},\quad\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(L_{\alpha})=L_{\alpha^{\sigma((-1,1))}}, \displaystyle\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{(J,J^{\prime})}\big(L(J,J^{\prime})_{\alpha}\big) \displaystyle=L(J^{\prime},J)_{\alpha^{\sigma((1,1))}} for all \alpha\in G_{2}^{0} . Thus to show that these maps are reflections, it only remains to show that they are isomorphisms of Lie algebras. Remark 5.12 . It follows from Remark 5.11 that \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}(L_{i})=L_{-i},\qquad\varphi_{\updownarrow}(L_{i}^{\prime})=L_{-i}^{\prime},\qquad\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(L_{i}^{\prime\prime})=L_{-i}^{\prime\prime} for all i\in\{-2,\ldots,2\} . This means that the reflections \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} , \varphi_{\updownarrow} and \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} correspond to the 5 -gradings (L_{i})_{-2\leq i\leq 2} , (L_{i}^{\prime})_{-2\leq i\leq 2} and (L_{i}^{\prime\prime})_{-2\leq i\leq 2} defined in Remark 4.3 , respectively. Similarly, for the 7 -gradings (L(J,J^{\prime})^{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}_{i})_{-3\leq i\leq 3} of L(J,J^{\prime}) and (L(J^{\prime},J)^{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}_{i})_{-3\leq i\leq 3} of L(J^{\prime},J) from Remark 4.3 , we have \psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{(J,J^{\prime})}\big(L(J,J^{\prime})^{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}_{i}\big)=L(J^{\prime},J)^{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}_{-i} for all i\in\{-3,\ldots,3\} . Remark 5.13 . For all \varphi\in\{\varphi_{\leftrightarrow},\varphi_{\updownarrow},\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}},\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}\} , the map \varphi^{2} is the parity automorphism of the grading to which \varphi corresponds. In particular, \varphi_{\leftrightarrow},\varphi_{\updownarrow},\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} have order 4 if 2\neq 0 in k and order 2 if 2=0 in k . We can now prove that all maps above are actually well-defined and homomorphisms of Lie algebras. Lemma 5.14 . (1) For any linear cubic norm pair (J,J^{\prime}) , the reflections \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} , \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} , \varphi_{\updownarrow} on L(J,J^{\prime}) and the map \psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}\colon L(J,J^{\prime})\to L(J^{\prime},J) are well-defined. (2) For any invertible t\in k and any surjective t -homotopy (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})\colon(J,J^{\prime})\to(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) of linear cubic norm pairs, the map L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t)\colon L(J,J^{\prime})\to L(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) is well-defined. Proof. In this proof, all summations are understood to run over a\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Suppose that \sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}+\lambda_{\zeta}\zeta+\lambda_{\xi}\xi=0 for certain, finitely many scalars \lambda_{a,a^{\prime}},\lambda_{\zeta},\lambda_{\xi}\in k . We have to show this sum evaluates to zero under the respective assignments in Definitions 5.4 , 5.10 , 5.8 and 5.9 . We know from Lemma 4.19 that (15) \displaystyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}} \displaystyle=\lambda_{\xi}\cdot(2\zeta-\xi), (16) \displaystyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}T(a,a^{\prime}) \displaystyle=3\lambda_{\xi}, (17) \displaystyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a,a^{\prime}} \displaystyle=2\lambda_{\xi}\id_{J},\qquad\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a^{\prime},a}=2\lambda_{\xi}\id_{J^{\prime}}. Both sides of ( 15 ) are fixed by the assignments defining \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} , so \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} is well-defined. Under the assignments defining \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} , they evaluate to \displaystyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}+\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}T(a,a^{\prime})(\xi-\zeta)\quad\text{and} \displaystyle\lambda_{\xi}\cdot(2\xi-\zeta)=\lambda_{\xi}(2\zeta-\xi)+3\lambda_{\xi}(\xi-\zeta). By ( 16 ), we infer that \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} is well-defined. Similarly, the two sides of ( 15 ) are mapped to \displaystyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}-\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}T(a,a^{\prime})\zeta=\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}-3\lambda_{\xi}\zeta\quad\text{and} \displaystyle\lambda_{\xi}\cdot(-2\zeta-\xi+\zeta)=\lambda_{\xi}\cdot(2\zeta-\xi)-3\lambda_{\xi}\zeta under the assignments defining \varphi_{\updownarrow} , respectively. We infer that \varphi_{\updownarrow} is also well-defined. For the proof that \psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} is well-defined, we have to distinguish between the elements \xi,\zeta,\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}} of L(J,J^{\prime}) and the elements \xi^{\prime},\zeta^{\prime},\mathbf{d}_{a^{\prime},a} of L(J^{\prime},J) . The two sides of ( 15 ) are mapped to \displaystyle-\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a^{\prime},a}+\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}T(a,a^{\prime})(\zeta^{\prime}-\xi^{\prime})=-\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a^{\prime},a}+3\lambda_{\xi}(\zeta^{\prime}-\xi^{\prime}), \displaystyle\lambda_{\xi}\cdot(-2\xi^{\prime}+\zeta^{\prime})=-\lambda_{\xi}\cdot(2\zeta^{\prime}-\xi^{\prime})+3\lambda_{\xi}(\zeta^{\prime}-\xi^{\prime}) under the assignments defining \psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} . By Proposition 4.12 , ( 16 ) and ( 17 ), we have \sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}[\mathbf{d}_{a^{\prime},a},(\lambda,b^{\prime},b,\mu)_{\pm}]=\lambda_{\xi}(-3\lambda,-b^{\prime},b,3\mu)_{\pm} for all (\lambda,b^{\prime},b,\mu)_{\pm}\in L(J^{\prime},J)_{\pm 1} and \mathbf{d}_{a^{\prime},a}(L(J^{\prime},J)_{\pm 2})=0 , so it follows from Remark 4.6 that \sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a^{\prime},a}=\lambda_{\xi}(2\zeta^{\prime}-\xi^{\prime}) . We infer that \psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} is well-defined. Now assume that (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})\colon(J,J^{\prime})\to(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) is a surjective t -homotopy of linear cubic norm pairs for some invertible t\in k . Similarly as in the previous paragraph, we have to distinguish between the elements \xi,\zeta,\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}} of L(J,J^{\prime}) and the elements \xi_{2},\zeta_{2},\mathbf{d}_{a^{\iota},(a^{\prime})^{{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}}} of L(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) . Now the two sides of ( 15 ) are mapped to \displaystyle\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a^{\iota},(a^{\prime})^{{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}}}\quad\text{and}\quad\lambda_{\xi}(2\zeta_{2}-\xi_{2}) under the assignments defining L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t) . It follows from ( 17 ) and Remark 2.13 that \displaystyle\left(\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a^{\iota},(a^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}}\right)(b^{\iota}) \displaystyle=\left(\sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b)\right)^{\iota}=2\lambda_{\xi}b^{\iota} for all b\in J . Since \iota is surjective, we infer that \sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{a^{\iota},(a^{\prime})^{{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}}}=2\lambda_{\xi}\id_{J_{2}} . By a similar computation, \sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}D_{(a^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},a^{\iota}}=2\lambda_{\xi}\id_{J_{2}^{\prime}} . Further, ( 16 ) implies that \sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}T(a^{\iota},(a^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})=3\lambda_{\xi} . Thus by similar arguments as in the previous paragraph, it follows from Propositions 4.12 and 4.6 that \sum\lambda_{a,a^{\prime}}\mathbf{d}_{a^{\iota},(a^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}}=\lambda_{\xi}(2\zeta_{2}-\xi_{2}) . Hence L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t) is well-defined. ∎ Lemma 5.15 . (1) For any linear cubic norm pair (J,J^{\prime}) , the maps \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} , \varphi_{\updownarrow} , \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} on L(J,J^{\prime}) and the map \psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}\colon L(J,J^{\prime})\to L(J^{\prime},J) are isomorphisms of Lie algebras. In particular, \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} , \varphi_{\updownarrow} and \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} are reflections of type (-2,-1) , (-1,-2) and (-1,1) , respectively. (2) For any invertible t\in k and any surjective t -homotopy (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})\colon(J,J^{\prime})\to(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) of linear cubic norm pairs, the map L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t)\colon L(J,J^{\prime})\to L(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) is a surjective homomorphism of Lie algebras. It is bijective if and only if (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}) is bijective. Proof. Let \varphi\in\{\varphi_{\leftrightarrow},\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}},\varphi_{\updownarrow},\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}\} or \varphi=L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t) for a surjective t -homotopy (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})\colon(J,J^{\prime})\to(J_{2},J_{2}^{\prime}) of linear cubic norm pairs and some invertible t\in k . The assertion about the surjectivity or bijectivity of \varphi are clear (see also Remark 5.11 ), so it remains to show that it is also compatible with the Lie bracket. For this it suffices to show that \varphi([a,b])=[\varphi(a),\varphi(b)] for all a,b in a generating set of the k -module L . By the anti-symmetry of the Lie bracket, we only have to check this for all a\lVert\gamma+\delta\rVert\quad\text{ for all }\gamma,\delta\in\Phi. When \Phi=G_{2} there are only 3 possible configurations for adjacent roots (up to symmetry), namely either both \alpha and \beta are long and make an angle of 60^{\circ} , or one is short and the other is long, making an angle of either 30^{\circ} or 90^{\circ} . In any case, we have \lVert\alpha+\beta\rVert>2 . Since roots have length at most \sqrt{3} , we have \lVert\gamma+\delta\rVert\leq 2\sqrt{3} , and ( 19 ) follows. Now assume \Phi\neq G_{2} , so that all roots have length at most \sqrt{2} . In particular, (20) \lVert\gamma+\delta\rVert\leq 2\sqrt{2}. On the other hand, since \alpha and \beta make an angle of at most 90^{\circ} , we have (21) 2\lVert\alpha+\beta\rVert\geq 2\sqrt{\lVert\alpha\rVert^{2}+\lVert\beta\rVert^{2}}. Assume now that ( 19 ) is false. Then \sqrt{\lVert\alpha\rVert^{2}+\lVert\beta\rVert^{2}}\leq\sqrt{2} , from which we get \lVert\alpha\rVert=\lVert\beta\rVert=1 , i.e., both \alpha and \beta are short roots; moreover, both inequalities ( 20 ) and ( 21 ) are equalities. This implies that on the one hand, \gamma=\delta is long, and on the other hand, \alpha and \beta make an angle of 90^{\circ} . The fact that we have ( 19 ) with an equality rather than an inequality also implies that i=j=2 , so 2\alpha+2\beta=\gamma+\delta . However, since \gamma=\delta , we now see that \alpha+\beta=\gamma , contradicting the fact that \alpha and \beta are adjacent. ∎ Lemma 7.6 . Let \alpha,\beta\in\Phi be adjacent and let \exp_{\alpha}\colon\bar{L}_{\alpha}\to\Aut(\bar{L})\colon a\mapsto\sum_{i\geq 0}\theta^{[i,\alpha]}_{a}\quad\text{and}\quad\exp_{\beta}\colon\bar{L}_{\beta}\to\Aut(\bar{L})\colon b\mapsto\sum_{i\geq 0}\theta^{[i,\beta]}_{b} be an \alpha -parametrization and a \beta -parametrization, respectively. Then for all x_{\alpha}\in\bar{L}_{\alpha} and x_{\beta}\in\bar{L}_{\beta} , the automorphisms \exp_{\alpha}(x_{\alpha}) and \exp_{\beta}(x_{\beta}) commute. Proof. Let x_{\alpha}\in\bar{L}_{\alpha} and x_{\beta}\in\bar{L}_{\beta} . For each i\in\mathbb{N} and \zeta\in\{\alpha,\beta\} and y\coloneq x_{\zeta} , put \delta^{i}_{\zeta}\coloneq\theta^{[i,\zeta]}_{y} . Since \exp_{\alpha}(x_{\alpha})\circ\exp_{\beta}(x_{\beta})=\left(\sum_{i\geq 0}\delta^{i}_{\alpha}\right)\circ\left(\sum_{j\geq 0}\delta^{j}_{\beta}\right)=\sum_{i\geq 0}\sum_{j\geq 0}\delta_{\alpha}^{i}\circ\delta_{\beta}^{j}, it suffices to show that \delta_{\alpha}^{i} and \delta_{\beta}^{j} commute for all i,j\geq 0 . If i,j\geq 2 , then it follows from Lemma 7.5 that \delta_{\alpha}^{i}\circ\delta_{\beta}^{j} and \delta_{\beta}^{j}\circ\delta_{\alpha}^{i} are both zero on L_{\gamma} for all \gamma\in\Phi . If i=0 or j=0 , then either \delta_{\alpha}^{i} or \delta_{\beta}^{j} is the identity map. It remains to consider the case that i=1 or j=1 , say i=1 . Then \delta_{\alpha}^{i}=\ad_{x_{\alpha}} . By Lemma A.2 , the endomorphisms \delta_{\beta}^{0},\delta_{\beta}^{1},\ldots satisfy the higher Leibniz rules ( ∗ ) ℓ . Hence for all \gamma\in\Phi , all j\geq 0 and all x_{\gamma}\in L_{\gamma} , we have \displaystyle\delta_{\beta}^{j}\circ\delta_{\alpha}^{i}(x_{\gamma}) \displaystyle=\delta_{\beta}^{j}([x_{\alpha},x_{\gamma}])=\sum_{\ell=0}^{j}[\delta_{\beta}^{\ell}(x_{\alpha}),\delta_{\beta}^{j-\ell}(x_{\gamma})]. Since \delta_{\beta}^{\ell}(x_{\alpha})\in L_{\alpha+\ell\beta} for all \ell\geq 0 and \alpha , \beta are adjacent, all summands are zero except for \ell=0 . Hence \delta_{\beta}^{j}\circ\delta_{\alpha}^{i}(x_{\gamma})=[x_{\alpha},\delta_{\beta}^{j}(x_{\gamma})]=\delta_{\alpha}^{i}\circ\delta_{\beta}^{j}(x_{\gamma}) . We conclude that \delta_{\alpha}^{i} and \delta_{\beta}^{j} commute in all cases, and hence \exp_{\alpha}(x_{\alpha}) and \exp_{\beta}(x_{\beta}) commute. ∎ In Appendix B , we will show that the reflections \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} and \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} from Definitions 5.8 and 5.18 are Weyl elements. For this we have to check that their conjugation action permutes the root groups accordingly. Since \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{2} and \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{2} are the parity automorphisms of certain gradings by Remarks 5.13 and 5.19 , the following result allows us to deduce from U_{\alpha}^{\varphi}=U_{\sigma(\alpha)} that U_{\sigma(\alpha)}^{\varphi}=U_{\alpha}^{\varphi^{2}}=U_{\alpha} , where \alpha\in G_{2} , \varphi\in\{\varphi_{\leftrightarrow},\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}\} and \sigma\colon G_{2}\to G_{2} the reflection induced by \varphi . This cuts the amount of necessary computations by half. Explicitly, see Lemmas B.4 , B.10 , B.18 , B.19 , B.20 , B.22 and B.23 . Lemma 7.7 . Let p\in\mathbb{N} and assume that \Phi has a (2p+1) -grading, that is, a decomposition \Phi=\bigsqcup_{i=-p}^{p}\Phi_{i} such that (\Phi_{i}+\Phi_{j})\cap\Phi\subseteq\Phi_{i+j} for all i,j\in\mathbb{Z} (where \Phi_{i}\coloneq\emptyset if \lvert i\rvert>p ) and \Phi_{-i}=-\Phi_{i} for all i\in\mathbb{Z} . Put \bar{L}_{i}\coloneq\bigoplus_{\alpha\in\Phi_{i}}\bar{L}_{\alpha} for all i\in\mathbb{Z} , so that (\bar{L}_{i})_{-p\leq i\leq p} is a (2p+1) -grading of \bar{L} . Let \exp_{\alpha}\colon L_{\alpha}\to\Aut(\bar{L}) be an \alpha -parametrization for some \alpha\in\Phi and let \varphi\colon\bar{L}\to\bar{L} denote the parity automorphism of L with respect to the (2p+1) -grading, so that \varphi(x_{i})=(-1)^{i}x_{i} for all i\in\mathbb{Z} and x_{i}\in\bar{L}_{i} . Then for all a\in\bar{L}_{\alpha} , we have \varphi^{-1}\circ\exp_{\alpha}(a)\circ\varphi=\exp_{\alpha}\big(\varphi(a)\big). Proof. For all i\in\mathbb{Z} and \beta\in\Phi_{i} , we put \epsilon_{\beta}\coloneq(-1)^{i} , and also \epsilon_{0}\coloneq 1 . Then for all \beta,\gamma\in\Phi with \beta+\gamma\in\Phi , we have \epsilon_{\beta+\gamma}=\epsilon_{\beta}\epsilon_{\gamma} . Since root strings in \Phi are unbroken, it follows that \epsilon_{\beta+i\gamma}=\epsilon_{\beta}\epsilon_{\gamma}^{i} for all \beta,\gamma\in\Phi^{0} and i\in\mathbb{Z} with \beta+i\gamma\in\Phi^{0} . Now let \beta\in\Phi^{0} and b\in\bar{L}_{\beta} be arbitrary. Then \displaystyle\varphi^{-1}\circ\exp_{\alpha}(a)\circ\varphi(b) \displaystyle=\epsilon_{\beta}\sum_{i\geq 0}\epsilon_{\beta+i\alpha}\theta_{a}^{[i]}(b)\quad\text{and} \displaystyle\exp_{\alpha}\big(\varphi(a)\big)(b) \displaystyle=\exp_{\alpha}(\epsilon_{\alpha}a)(b)=\sum_{i\geq 0}\theta_{\epsilon_{\alpha}a}^{[i]}(b)=\sum_{i\geq 0}\epsilon_{\alpha}^{i}\theta_{a}^{[i]}(b). Since \epsilon_{\beta}\epsilon_{\beta+i\alpha}=\epsilon_{\beta}^{2}\epsilon_{\alpha}^{i}=\epsilon_{\alpha}^{i} for all i\in\mathbb{Z} , the assertion follows. ∎ The following general result will allow us to establish Axiom 1.5 Item 4 of \Phi -graded groups for both \Phi=G_{2} and \Phi=F_{4} . The argument is the same as in the context of Chevalley groups (see, for instance, Corollary 3 of Lemma 18 in [ 26 ] ) Proposition 7.8 . For each \alpha\in\Phi , let \exp_{\alpha}\colon\bar{L}_{\alpha}\to\Aut(\bar{L}) be an \alpha -parametrisation and let U_{\alpha} denote the corresponding root group. Further, let \Pi be any positive system of roots in \Phi and denote by U_{+} and U_{-} the groups generated by (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in\Pi} and (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in-\Pi} , respectively. Then U_{+}\cap U_{-}=1 . In particular, the root groups (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in\Phi} satisfy Axiom 1.5 Item 4 . Proof. Denote by \rootht\colon\Phi\to\mathbb{Z} the height function with respect to \Pi , which we extend to a function on \Phi^{0}\coloneq\Phi\cup\{0\} by setting \rootht(0)\coloneq 0 . Put \ell\coloneq\lvert\Phi^{0}\rvert and choose an ordering (\alpha_{1},\ldots,\alpha_{\ell}) of the elements of \Phi^{0} such \rootht(\alpha_{i})<\rootht(\alpha_{j}) implies i0 : There exists a k -linear map \phi^{\prime}\colon\bar{L}\to\bar{L} such that \phi=\id_{\bar{L}}+\phi^{\prime} and \phi^{\prime}(\bar{L}_{\alpha_{m}})\subseteq\sum_{m W = weyl_group(:C, 3); f2,f3,f4 = W[3],W[2],W[1]; ¯¯julia> longest_element(W) == f2*(f3*f2*f3)*(f4*f3*f2*f3*f4) ¯ in the computer algebra system OSCAR [ 23 , 11 ] . Note that \displaystyle w_{\{2,3,4\}} \displaystyle=\sigma_{f_{2}}\sigma_{f_{2}}^{\sigma(f_{3})}\sigma_{f_{2}}^{\sigma(f_{3})\sigma(f_{4})}=\sigma_{f_{2}}\sigma_{f_{2}+2f_{3}}\sigma_{f_{2}+2f_{3}+2f_{4}}. Lemma 8.6 . The following hold, where U\coloneq\langle\sigma(f_{3}),\sigma(f_{4})\rangle\leq\Weyl(F_{4}) . (1) There exists a unique homomorphism u\colon\Weyl(G_{2})\to\Weyl(F_{4}) such that, in the notation of Remark 8.5 , u(\sigma_{g_{1}})=w_{\{2,3,4\}}w_{\{3,4\}},\qquad u(\sigma_{g_{2}})=w_{\{1\}}=\sigma(f_{1}). Further, u is injective and its image centralizes w_{\{3,4\}} . (2) For all w\in\Weyl(G_{2}) , all \tilde{w}\in u(w)U and all \gamma\in F_{4} , we have \pi\big(\gamma^{\tilde{w}}\big)=\pi(\gamma)^{w}. Proof. Put S\coloneq\{w_{\{2,3,4\}}w_{\{3,4\}},w_{\{1\}}\} . By [ 20 , 20.32] , (\langle S\rangle,S) is a Coxeter system. Is is a straightforward computation to show that the order of the product w_{\{2,3,4\}}w_{\{3,4\}}w_{\{1\}} is 6 , so this Coxeter system is of type G_{2} . Further, u(\sigma_{g_{1}}) and u(\sigma_{g_{2}}) commute with w_{\{3,4\}} by [ 20 , 20.11(i)] . Assertion 1 follows. It suffices to prove 2 for the case that w\in\{\sigma(g_{1}),\sigma(g_{2})\} and \gamma\in\Delta_{F} . Further, for all \beta\in F_{4} and u\in U , we have \beta^{u}-\beta\in\langle f_{3},f_{4}\rangle_{\mathbb{R}} and hence \pi(\beta^{u})=\pi(\beta) . Thus we may also assume that \tilde{w}=u(w) . We conclude that there are only eight cases to consider, and each of them is covered by a short computation. ∎ We can now describe the fibers of \pi , which will be crucial for our construction of G_{2} -gradings from F_{4} -gradings, and give an alternative description of u in terms of these fibers. For \beta\in G_{2}^{0} , we will always write \pi^{-1}(\beta) for \{\alpha\in F_{4}^{0}\mid\pi(\alpha)=\beta\} . Lemma 8.7 . The following hold. (1) For all \beta\in G_{2} and w\in\Weyl(G_{2}) , we have \pi^{-1}(\beta^{w})=\pi^{-1}(\beta)^{u(w)} . (2) \pi^{-1}(0)=F_{4}^{0}\cap\langle f_{3},f_{4}\rangle_{\mathbb{Z}}=\{\pm f_{3},\pm f_{4},\pm(f_{3}+f_{3})\}\cong A_{2}^{0} . (3) For every long root \beta\in G_{2} , the fiber \pi^{-1}(\beta) contains exactly one element, and this element is long in F_{4} . (4) For every short root \beta\in G_{2} , the fiber \pi^{-1}(\beta) contains exactly three long roots in F_{4} and three short roots in F_{4} , and the subsystem \langle\pi^{-1}(\beta)\rangle_{\mathbb{R}}\cap F_{4} spanned by this fiber is of type C_{3} . If we denote the three long roots by 2e_{1} , 2e_{2} , 2e_{3} , then (e_{1},e_{2},e_{3}) is an orthogonal basis of \langle\pi^{-1}(\beta)\rangle_{\mathbb{R}} and the three short roots in \pi^{-1}(\beta) are e_{1}+e_{2} , e_{2}+e_{3} , e_{1}+e_{3} . (5) Let \beta\in G_{2} and denote by L(\beta) the set of long roots in \pi^{-1}(\beta) . Then u(\sigma(\beta))=\begin{cases}\prod_{\alpha\in L(\beta)}\sigma_{\alpha}&\text{if }\beta\text{ is long},\\ (\prod_{\alpha\in L(\beta)}\sigma_{\alpha})\sigma_{f_{3}}\sigma_{f_{4}}\sigma_{f_{3}}&\text{if }\beta\text{ is short}\end{cases} where the product over L(\beta) may be taken in any order. Proof. Assertions 1 and 2 follow from Lemma 8.6 Item 2 and Lemma 8.4 Item 1 , respectively. Using Remark 8.2 , we can compute that \displaystyle\pi^{-1}(g_{1}) \displaystyle=\{f_{2}+f_{3},f_{2}+f_{3}+f_{4},f_{2}+2f_{3}+f_{4},f_{2},f_{2}+2f_{3},f_{2}+2f_{3}+2f_{4}\}, \displaystyle\pi^{-1}(g_{2}) \displaystyle=\{f_{1}\}. By a short computation, the long roots in \pi^{-1}(g_{1}) are f_{2},f_{2}+2f_{3},f_{2}+2f_{3}+2f_{4} and their pairwise sums are precisely the remaining roots in \pi^{-1}(g_{1}) multiplied by 2 . We infer that assertions 3 and 4 hold for \beta\in\{g_{1},g_{2}\} . By 1 , it follows that they hold for all \beta\in G_{2} . Assertion 5 is satisfied for the long root \beta=g_{2} because L(g_{2})=\{f_{1}\} . Since L(g_{1})=\{f_{2},f_{2}+2f_{3},f_{2}+2f_{3}+2f_{4}\} , it follows from Remark 8.5 that w_{\{2,3,4\}}=\prod_{\alpha\in L(g_{1})}\sigma_{\alpha} and hence 5 holds for \beta=g_{1} as well. Since all roots in G_{2} are conjugate to g_{1} or g_{2} and since the image of u centralizes w_{\{3,4\}}=\sigma_{f_{3}}\sigma_{f_{4}}\sigma_{f_{3}} by Lemma 8.6 Item 1 , the general assertion follows by an application of 1 . ∎ Remark 8.8 . A 3 -grading of a root system \Phi is a decomposition \Phi=\Phi_{-1}\sqcup\Phi_{0}\sqcup\Phi_{1} such that (\Phi_{i}+\Phi_{j})\cap\Phi\subseteq\Phi_{i+j} for all i,j\in\{-1,0,1\} and some other properties are satisfied (see [ 19 , 14.1] for details). The root system C_{3} has the following 3 -grading [ 19 , 14.5(c)] : \displaystyle(C_{3})_{\pm 1} \displaystyle=\{\pm 2e_{i}\mid i\in\{1,2,3\}\}\cup\{\pm(e_{i}+e_{j})\mid i\neq j\in\{1,2,3\}\}, \displaystyle(C_{3})_{0} \displaystyle=\{e_{i}-e_{j}\mid i\neq j\in\{1,2,3\}\}. Note that the set \pi^{-1}(\beta) in Lemma 8.7 Item 4 is precisely the set (C_{3})_{1} of 1 -graded roots while \pi^{-1}(-\beta)=-\pi^{-1}(\beta) is the set (C_{3})_{-1} of (-1) -graded roots. Remark 8.9 . It follows from Lemma 8.7 Item 5 that \prod_{\alpha\in L(\beta)}\sigma_{\alpha}\in u(\sigma_{\beta})U for all \beta\in G_{2} where U\coloneq\langle\sigma_{f_{3}},\sigma_{f_{4}}\rangle . Hence we may always choose \tilde{w}=\prod_{\alpha\in L(\beta)}\sigma_{\alpha} for w=\sigma_{\beta} in Lemma 8.6 Item 2 . We can now apply our observations to construct G_{2} -gradings. For Lie algebras, the distributive law makes this fairly straightforward. Proposition 8.10 . Let L=\bigoplus_{\alpha\in F_{4}^{0}}L_{\alpha} be an F_{4} -graded Lie algebra over a commutative ring k . For all \beta\in G_{2}^{0} , we define L_{\beta}^{\prime}\coloneq\langle L_{\alpha}\mid\alpha\in\pi^{-1}(\{\beta\})\rangle_{k}. Then (L_{\beta}^{\prime})_{\beta\in G_{2}^{0}} is a G_{2} -grading of L . Proof. Since L_{\beta}^{\prime}=\bigoplus_{\alpha\in\pi^{-1}(\beta)}L_{\alpha} for all \beta\in G_{2}^{0} , we have L=\bigoplus_{\beta\in G_{2}^{0}}L_{\beta}^{\prime} . Now let \beta,\bar{\beta}\in G_{2}^{0} and let x_{\beta}\in L_{\beta}^{\prime} , y_{\bar{\beta}}\in L_{\bar{\beta}}^{\prime} . Write x_{\beta}=\sum_{\alpha\in\pi^{-1}(\beta)}x_{\alpha}\quad\text{and}\quad y_{\bar{\beta}}=\sum_{\bar{\alpha}\in\pi^{-1}(\bar{\beta})}y_{\bar{\alpha}} where x_{\alpha}\in L_{\alpha} and y_{\bar{\alpha}}\in L_{\bar{\alpha}} . Thus [x_{\beta},y_{\bar{\beta}}]=\sum_{\alpha\in\pi^{-1}(\beta)}\sum_{\bar{\alpha}\in\pi^{-1}(\bar{\beta})}[x_{\alpha},y_{\bar{\alpha}}]. For all \alpha\in\pi^{-1}(\beta) , \bar{\alpha}\in\pi^{-1}(\bar{\beta}) , there are two possibilities: (1) If \alpha+\bar{\alpha}\notin F_{4} , then [x_{\alpha},y_{\bar{\alpha}}]=0 . (2) If \alpha+\bar{\alpha}\in F_{4} , then \pi(\alpha+\bar{\alpha})=\pi(\alpha)+\pi(\bar{\alpha})=\beta+\bar{\beta} by Lemma 8.4 Item 1 . Hence \beta+\bar{\beta}\in G_{2}^{0} and \alpha+\bar{\alpha}\in\pi^{-1}(\beta+\bar{\beta}) in this case, which implies that [x_{\alpha},y_{\bar{\alpha}}]\in L_{\alpha+\bar{\alpha}}\leq L^{\prime}_{\beta+\bar{\beta}} . We infer that [x_{\beta},y_{\bar{\beta}}]=0 if \beta+\bar{\beta}\notin G_{2}^{0} and [x_{\beta},y_{\bar{\beta}}]\in L^{\prime}_{\beta+\bar{\beta}} otherwise. It follows that (L_{\beta}^{\prime})_{\beta\in G_{2}^{0}} is a G_{2} -grading of L . ∎ The proof of G_{2} -commutator relations in F_{4} -graded groups is more difficult due to the non-linear nature of groups. We can use the criterion [ 31 , 2.1.29] (which is an application of [ 19 , 3.9] ), but for this we first need to establish Lemma 8.12 . Lemma 8.11 . Let \Delta_{G}^{\prime}=(g_{1}^{\prime},g_{2}^{\prime}) be a system of simple roots in G_{2} such that g_{1} is short and let \Pi_{G}^{\prime} be the corresponding positive system in G_{2} . Then there exists a standard system \Delta_{F}^{\prime}=(f_{1}^{\prime},f_{2}^{\prime},f_{3}^{\prime},f_{4}^{\prime}) of simple roots in F_{4} with corresponding positive system \Pi_{F}^{\prime} such that \pi(\Pi_{F}^{\prime})=\Pi_{G}^{\prime}\cup\{0\} and \pi(\Delta_{F}^{\prime})=(g_{2}^{\prime},g_{1}^{\prime},0,0) . Proof. If \Delta_{G}^{\prime}=\Delta_{G} , then we can choose \Delta_{F}\coloneq\Delta_{F}^{\prime} by Lemma 8.4 . In the general case, there exists w\in\Weyl(G_{2}) such that \Delta_{G}^{\prime}=\Delta_{G}^{w} . Put \Delta_{F}^{\prime}\coloneq\Delta_{F}^{u(w)} . Then it follows from Lemma 8.6 Item 2 that \displaystyle\pi(\Delta_{F}^{\prime}) \displaystyle=\pi\big(\Delta_{F}^{u(w)}\big)=\pi(\Delta_{F})^{w}=(g_{2},g_{1},0,0)^{w}=(g_{2}^{\prime},g_{1}^{\prime},0,0). A similar computation shows that \pi(\Pi_{F}^{\prime})=\Pi_{G}^{\prime}\cup\{0\} . ∎ Lemma 8.12 . For all non-proportional \alpha,\beta\in G_{2} , there exists a positive system \Pi_{F}^{\prime} in F_{4} which contains \pi^{-1}(\{\alpha,\beta\}) . Proof. Choose a system \Delta_{G}^{\prime}=\{g_{1}^{\prime},g_{2}^{\prime}\} of simple roots in G_{2} such that g_{1} is short and such that \alpha,\beta lie in the positive system \Pi_{G} corresponding to \Delta_{G}^{\prime} . Let \Delta_{F}^{\prime}=(f_{1},f_{2},f_{3},f_{4}) be a standard system of simple roots in F_{4} chosen as in Lemma 8.11 . We show that the corresponding positive system \Pi_{F}^{\prime} contains \pi^{-1}(\{\alpha^{\prime},\beta^{\prime}\}) . It suffices to show that \pi^{-1}(\{\alpha,\beta\}) contains no root in F_{4}\setminus\Pi_{F}^{\prime}=-\Pi_{F}^{\prime} . This is satisfied because \pi(-\Pi_{F}^{\prime})=-\Pi_{G}^{\prime}\cup\{0\} , a set which contains neither \alpha nor \beta . ∎ Proposition 8.13 . Let G be a group with an F_{4} -grading (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} . For all \beta\in G_{2}^{0} , we define U_{\beta}^{\prime}\coloneq\langle U_{\alpha}\mid\alpha\in\pi^{-1}(\beta)\rangle. Then (G,(U_{\beta}^{\prime})_{\beta\in G_{2}}) satisfies Axioms 1.5 Items 1 , 2 and 3 , and hence it is a G_{2} -graded group if it satisfies Axiom 1.5 Item 4 . Proof. For Axiom 1.5 Item 1 , we show that the group generated by (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in\pi^{-1}(0)} is contained in the group generated by (U_{\beta}^{\prime})_{\beta\in G_{2}} . Recall from Lemma 8.7 Item 2 that \pi^{-1}(0)=\{\pm f_{3},\pm f_{4},\pm(f_{3}+f_{3})\}. Observe that f_{3}=\delta_{1}+\delta_{2} and f_{4}=\delta_{3}+\delta_{4} where \displaystyle\delta_{1}\coloneq f_{2}+2f_{3}+f_{4},\qquad\delta_{2}\coloneq-(f_{2}+f_{3}+f_{4}), \displaystyle\delta_{3}\coloneq f_{1}+f_{2}+f_{3}+f_{4},\qquad\delta_{4}\coloneq-(f_{1}+f_{2}+f_{3}). Here \{\delta_{1},\delta_{2}\} and \{\delta_{3},\delta_{4}\} span subsystems of type A_{2} . By [ 31 , 5.4.7] , which is an elementary observation in the study of A_{2} -graded groups, it follows that U_{\varepsilon f_{3}}=[U_{\varepsilon\delta_{1}},U_{\varepsilon\delta_{2}}] , U_{\varepsilon f_{4}}=[U_{\varepsilon\delta_{3}},U_{\varepsilon\delta_{4}}] and U_{\varepsilon(f_{3}+f_{4})}=[U_{\varepsilon f_{3}},U_{\varepsilon f_{4}}] for all \varepsilon\in\{\pm 1\} . Hence the root groups (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in\pi^{-1}(0)} are contained in the group generated by (U_{\delta_{i}})_{i\in\{1,2,3,4\}} . Since \delta_{1},\delta_{2},\delta_{3},\delta_{4} lie in \pi^{-1}(G_{2}) , we infer that G is generated by (U_{\beta}^{\prime})_{\beta\in G_{2}} . For the existence of Weyl elements, let \beta\in G_{2} be arbitrary and let \alpha_{1},\ldots,\alpha_{m} denote the pairwise distinct long roots in \pi^{-1}(\beta) . For each i\in\{1,\ldots,m\} , choose an \alpha_{i} -Weyl element w_{i}=a_{-\alpha_{i}}b_{\alpha_{i}}c_{-\alpha_{i}} where a_{-\alpha_{i}},c_{-\alpha_{i}}\in U_{-\alpha_{i}} and b_{\alpha_{i}}\in U_{\alpha_{i}} . By Lemma 8.7 Items 4 and 3 , we have \mathord{]\alpha_{i},\alpha_{j}[}=\emptyset=\mathord{]\alpha_{i},-\alpha_{j}[} and hence [U_{\alpha_{i}},U_{\pm\alpha_{j}}]=1 for all distinct i,j\in\{1,\ldots,m\} . Together with Remark 1.7 , this implies that w_{\beta}\coloneq\prod_{i=1}^{m}w_{i} may be written as w_{\beta}=\prod_{i=1}^{m}a_{-\alpha_{i}}\prod_{i=1}^{m}b_{\alpha_{i}}\prod_{i=1}^{m}c_{-\alpha_{i}}\in U_{-\beta}^{\prime}U_{\beta}^{\prime}U_{-\beta}^{\prime}. Further, by Lemma 8.6 Item 2 , Remark 8.9 and because \sigma_{\alpha_{1}},\ldots,\sigma_{\alpha_{m}} commute pairwise, we have U_{\gamma}^{w_{\beta}}=U_{\gamma^{\sigma(\alpha_{1})\cdots\sigma(\alpha_{m})}}\subseteq U_{\pi(\gamma)^{\sigma(\beta)}}^{\prime}\quad\text{and}\quad U_{\gamma}^{w_{\beta}^{-1}}=U_{\gamma^{\sigma(\alpha_{m})\cdots\sigma(\alpha_{1})}}\subseteq U_{\pi(\gamma)^{\sigma(\beta)}} for all \gamma\in F_{4} . This implies that (U_{\delta}^{\prime})^{w_{\beta}}\subseteq U_{\delta^{\sigma(\beta)}}^{\prime}\subseteq(U_{\delta}^{\prime})^{w_{\beta}} for all \delta\in G_{2} . We conclude that w_{\beta} is a \beta -Weyl element. The commutator relations with respect to (U_{\beta}^{\prime})_{\beta\in G_{2}} follow from [ 31 , 2.1.29] , whose assumptions are satisfied by Lemma 8.12 . (More precisely, loc. cit. is formulated only for maps \pi\colon\Phi\to\Phi^{\prime} between root systems, but the same proof remains valid if the image of \pi lies in \Phi^{\prime}\cup\{0\} .) ∎ 9. Cubic Jordan matrix algebras Now and for the rest of this paper, we move on to F_{4} -gradings. We do so by specializing to a specific kind of cubic norm pairs (in fact, cubic norm structures ), which are known as cubic Jordan matrix algebras . In this section, we briefly introduce these objects and the so-called multiplicative conic alternative algebras over which they are defined, and collect all the properties that we will need later. We closely follow the exposition in [ 17 , Sections 36, 37] . Convention 9.1 . For a commutative ring k , all k -algebras are understood to be unital but not necessarily associative or commutative. We recall that a k -algebra A is called alternative if (aa)b=a(ab) and (ab)b=a(bb) for all a,b\in A , which by Artin’s Theorem implies that the subalgebra generated by any two elements (and their inverses, if they exist) is associative (see, for example, [ 17 , 14.5] ). 9.1. Notation and setup Notation 9.2 . From now on (and for the rest of this paper), we denote by k a commutative ring and by (C,n) a multiplicative conic alternative k -algebra in the sense of [ 17 , 16.1, 17.1] . This means that C is an alternative k -algebra equipped with a quadratic form n\colon C\to k , called the norm of C , such that n(1_{C})=1_{k} , n(ab)=n(a)n(b) for all a,b\in C and a^{2}-n(1_{C},a)a+n(a)1_{C}=0_{C} for all a\in C . Here n(a,b)\coloneq n(a+b)-n(a)-n(b) denotes the linearization of n for a,b\in C . Further, we denote by \displaystyle t \displaystyle\colon C\to k\colon a\mapsto n(1_{C},a), \displaystyle t \displaystyle\colon C\times C\to k\colon(a,b)\mapsto t(ab), \displaystyle\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mu\>\cdot\>\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu \displaystyle\colon C\to C\colon a\mapsto\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\coloneq t(a)1_{C}-a the (linear) trace, the bilinear trace and the conjugation of C , respectively. On a purely typographical level, we point out that the expression \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muac\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu for a,c\in C will always stand for \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mu(ac)\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu and not for \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu . We will usually refer to C as a multiplicative conic alternative algebra, dropping n from the notation. Example 9.3 . Composition algebras over rings (in the sense of [ 17 , 19.5] ), such as octonion or quaternion algebras, are the most prominent examples of multiplicative conic alternative algebras. Further, by [ 17 , 16.4] any k -algebra that is projective of rank 2 as a k -module is a multiplicative conic algebra that is commutative and associative. This provides examples of multiplicative conic alternative algebras that are not composition algebras, such as the dual numbers k[\epsilon]\coloneq k[t]/(t^{2}) . The crucial difference between composition algebras and multiplicative conic alternative algebras is that the latter need not be finitely generated projective as a k -module and that their norm need not satisfy any “regularity assumption” (such as non-degeneracy). For a detailed characterization of composition algebras in terms of conic alternative algebras, see [ 17 , 19.13] . For a discussion of the subtleties involving different “regularity assumptions” that coincide for finite-dimensional vector spaces over fields of characteristic not 2 but not over base rings, see [ 17 , 11.9, 11.11] . Remark 9.4 . For all a,b,c\in C , the following identities hold. (1) The conjugation is an involution: \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua+b\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu=\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu+\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu , \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muab\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu=\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu and \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mu\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu=a . [ 17 , 17.2] (2) The conjugation involution is scalar: a\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu=\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mua=n(a)1_{C} and a+\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu=t(a)1_{C} . [ 17 , (16.5.6)] (3) n and t are invariant under conjugation: n(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)=n(a) and t(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)=t(a) . [ 17 , (16.5.7)] (4) Kirmse’s identities : a(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mub)=n(a)b=(b\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)a and, thus, the linearization a(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mub)+\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu(cb)=n(a,c)b=(b\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)c+(b\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)a . [ 17 , (17.4.1)] (5) t(a^{2})=t(a)^{2}-2n(a) . [ 17 , (16.5.8)] (6) n(a,\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)=t(a)t(b)-n(a,b) . [ 17 , (16.5.10)] (7) C is norm-associative: n(a,ba)=t(b)n(a) , n(a,ab)=t(b)n(a) , n(ab,c)=n(a,c\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)=n(b,\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5muc) , t(a,b)=n(a,\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu) . [ 17 , 16.12, 17.2] (8) t is an associative linear form (in the sense of [ 17 , 7.9] ): t(ab)=t(ba) and t((ab)c)=t(a(bc))\eqcolon t(abc) . [ 17 , (16.13.1)] Notation 9.5 ( [ 17 , 36.1] ) . We will often say that “a sum is taken over all cyclic permutations (i\,j\,l) of (1\,2\,3) ” to mean that an expression \sum x_{ijl} stands for x_{123}+x_{231}+x_{312} . Notation 9.6 . We fix a (not necessarily invertible) diagonal matrix \Gamma=(\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2},\gamma_{3}) in \Mat_{3}(k) and we denote by J the cubic Jordan matrix algebra \Her_{3}(C,\Gamma) , as in [ 17 , 36.4] . For the reader’s convenience, we spell out what this means. As a k -module, J is isomorphic to k^{3}\oplus C^{3} and consists of all formal expressions \sum\bigl(\xi_{i}e_{ii}+u_{i}[jl]\bigr) with \xi_{i}\in k , u_{i}\in C , where the sum is taken over all cyclic permutations (i\,j\,l) of (1\,2\,3) . We will write \displaystyle e_{i}\coloneq e_{ii}\in J,\quad u[lj]\coloneq\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muu\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[jl],\quad 1_{J}\coloneq e_{1}+e_{2}+e_{3}, \displaystyle J_{ii}\coloneq ke_{i},\quad J_{jl}\coloneq J_{lj}\coloneq C[jl] for any cyclic permutation (i\,j\,l) of (1\,2\,3) and all \xi\in k , u\in C . Thus we have a decomposition \displaystyle J \displaystyle=J_{11}\oplus J_{22}\oplus J_{33}\oplus J_{23}\oplus J_{31}\oplus J_{12}. For arbitrary elements x=\sum\big(\xi_{i}e_{i}+u_{i}[jl]\big)\quad\text{and}\quad y=\sum\big(\eta_{i}e_{i}+v_{i}[jl]\big) of J , we define \displaystyle x^{\sharp} \displaystyle\coloneq\sum\Big(\big(\xi_{j}\xi_{l}-\gamma_{j}\gamma_{l}n(u_{i})\big)e_{i}+(-\xi_{i}u_{i}+\gamma_{i}\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mu(u_{j}u_{l})\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)[jl]\big), \displaystyle N(x) \displaystyle\coloneq\xi_{1}\xi_{2}\xi_{3}-\sum\gamma_{j}\gamma_{l}\xi_{i}n(u_{i})+\gamma_{1}\gamma_{2}\gamma_{3}t(u_{1}u_{2}u_{3}), \displaystyle x\times y \displaystyle\coloneq\sum\Bigl(\big(\xi_{j}\eta_{l}+\eta_{j}\xi_{l}-\gamma_{j}\gamma_{l}n(u_{i},v_{i})\big)e_{i} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad+\big(-\xi_{i}v_{i}-\eta_{i}u_{i}+\gamma_{i}\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mu(u_{j}v_{l}+v_{j}u_{l})\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\big)[jl]\Bigr), \displaystyle T(x,y) \displaystyle\coloneq\sum\big(\xi_{i}\eta_{i}+\gamma_{j}\gamma_{l}n(u_{i},v_{i})\big) where all sums are taken over all cyclic permutations (i\,j\,l) of (1\,2\,3) . This defines maps \sharp , N , \times , T that, by [ 17 , 36.5] , equip J with the structure of a cubic norm structure with base point 1_{J} . Notation 9.7 . Being a cubic norm structure, J induces a cubic norm pair that we denote by (J,J^{\prime}) . Thus J^{\prime} is an isomorphic copy of J and we let \iota\colon J\to J^{\prime}\colon a\mapsto a^{\iota} be a fixed isomorphism between J and J^{\prime} , with inverse {\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}\colon J^{\prime}\to J\colon a\mapsto a^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}. Hence (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})\colon(J,J^{\prime})\to(J^{\prime},J) is an involution of (J,J^{\prime}) . Further, we denote by e_{ii}^{\prime}=e_{i}^{\prime} , 1_{J^{\prime}} , J_{ii}^{\prime} and J_{jl}^{\prime} the images of the corresponding elements and subspaces of J under \iota . Remark 9.8 . Assume that \gamma_{1},\gamma_{2},\gamma_{3} are invertible, put p\coloneq\sum_{i=1}^{3}\gamma_{i}e_{i}\in J and denote by \Her_{3}(C) the cubic Jordan matrix algebra defined with respect to the diagonal matrix \bar{\Gamma}=(1_{k},1_{k},1_{k}) . Then by [ 17 , 37.23] , the p -isotope of J (in the sense of Remark 2.17 ) is isomorphic to \Her_{3}(C) . In particular, if we restrict to the case that \Gamma is invertible, then the isotopy type of (J,J^{\prime}) (and hence, by Proposition 5.16 , the isomorphism type of the Lie algebra L(J,J^{\prime}) ) does not depend on the choice of \Gamma . Remark 9.9 . It follows from the formula defining T that T is non-degenerate (in the sense that the radical defined in Example 6.15 is zero, i.e., T(a,J)=\{0\} implies a=0 ) if and only if the linearization of n is non-degenerate (in a similar sense). Thus if k is a field and the linearization of n is non-degenerate, then L(J,J^{\prime}) is simple by Theorem 6.25 . In particular, these conditions are satisfied if k is field and C is a composition algebra in the sense of [ 17 , 19.5] . Under these assumptions, J is a Freudenthal algebra by [ 17 , 39.9(d)] . If, in addition, C is an octonion algebra, then J is an Albert algebra by [ 17 , 39.19(a)] . Remark 9.10 . By [ 17 , 37.8, 37.9] , the triple (e_{1},e_{2},e_{3}) is an elementary frame in the sense of [ 17 , 37.5] , and it is connected if and only if \Gamma is invertible. With this setup, we may apply the results of [ 17 , Section 37] to J (with the additional assumption that \Gamma is invertible if a co-ordinate system is required). 9.2. Identities in cubic Jordan matrix algebras We begin by collecting some results which break down the long formulas in 9.6 into more succinct identities. For the next lemma, recall the Jordan pair structure on (J,J^{\prime}) from Definition 2.7 . Lemma 9.11 (Multiple Peirce decomposition) . The following assertions hold for all i,j,l,m,p,q\in\{1,2,3\} . (1) \{J_{ij},J_{jl}^{\prime},J_{lm}\}\subseteq J_{im} and U_{J_{ij}}(J_{ij}^{\prime})\subseteq J_{ij} . (2) \{J_{ij},J_{lm}^{\prime},J_{pq}\}=0 and U_{J_{ij}}(J_{lm}^{\prime})=0 if the indices i,j,l,m,p,q (respectively, i,j,l,m ) cannot be pairwise reordered in the above form. By this we mean that, in the sense of [ 17 , 32.14] , the Peirce triple (ij,lm,pq) (respectively, (ij,lm,ij) ) is not connected. Similar statements hold if the roles of J and J^{\prime} are interchanged. Proof. By [ 17 , 37.8] , the spaces J_{ij} for i,j\in\{1,2,3\} are precisely the Peirce components of the cubic norm structure J . Hence the assertion follows from the Peirce decomposition in Jordan algebras, see [ 17 , 32.15] . ∎ Lemma 9.12 . Let a\in J and write a=\xi_{1}e_{1}+\xi_{2}e_{2}+\xi_{3}e_{3}+c_{1}[23]+c_{2}[31]+c_{3}[12] with each \xi_{i}\in k and each c_{i}\in C . Let (i\,j\,l) be any (not necessarily cyclic) permutation of (1\,2\,3) . Then the following formulas (and their analogues for T^{\prime} in place of T ) hold. (1) T(a,e_{i}^{\prime})=\xi_{i} . (2) T(a,d_{l}[ij]^{\iota})=T(c_{l}[ij],d_{l}[ij]^{\iota})=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}t(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc_{l}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mud_{l}) for all d_{l}\in C . (3) The Peirce decomposition of (J,J^{\prime}) is orthogonal with respect to T in the sense that T(b_{pq},b^{\prime}_{rs})=0 for all b_{pq}\in J_{pq} , b^{\prime}_{rs}\in J_{rs}^{\prime} with \{p,q\}\neq\{r,s\} . Proof. These are special cases of the formulas defining and T in 9.6 . Note that we may assume that (i\,j\,l) is a cyclic permutation, the general case being a consequence of this case (because t(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc_{l}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mud_{l})=t(c_{l}\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mud_{l}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu) by Remark 9.4 Items 3 and 8 ). Alternatively, we may cite [ 17 , (37.13.5)] for Item 1 and the first equation in Item 2 and [ 17 , 37.4(c)] for Item 3 . ∎ Lemma 9.13 . Let a\in J and write a=\xi_{1}e_{1}+\xi_{2}e_{2}+\xi_{3}e_{3}+c_{1}[23]+c_{2}[31]+c_{3}[12] with each \xi_{i}\in k and each c_{i}\in C . Put c_{ij}\coloneq c_{l}[ij] for all cyclic permutations (i\,j\,l) of (1\,2\,3) . Let (i\,j\,l) and (i^{\prime}\,j^{\prime}\,l^{\prime}) be permutations of (1\,2\,3) such that (i\,j\,l) is cyclic. Then the following formulas (and their analogues for T^{\prime},\mathord{\times}^{\prime} in place of T,\times ) hold. (1) a\times e_{i}=\xi_{l}e_{j}^{\prime}+\xi_{j}e_{l}^{\prime}-c_{i}[jl]^{\iota} . In particular, e_{i^{\prime}}\times e_{j^{\prime}}=e_{l^{\prime}}^{\prime} and c_{i^{\prime}}[j^{\prime}l^{\prime}]\times e_{i^{\prime}}=-c_{i^{\prime}}[j^{\prime}l^{\prime}]^{\iota} . (2) c_{l^{\prime}}[i^{\prime}j^{\prime}]\times d_{i^{\prime}}[j^{\prime}l^{\prime}]=\gamma_{j^{\prime}}c_{l^{\prime}}d_{i^{\prime}}[il] for all d_{i^{\prime}}\in C . (3) a\times d_{ij}=-T(c_{ij},d_{ij})e_{l}^{\prime}-\xi_{l}d_{ij}^{\iota}+c_{li}\times d_{ij}+d_{ij}\times c_{jl} for all d_{ij}\in J_{ij} . Proof. These are special cases of the formulas defining \times and T in 9.6 . Again, the general case follows from the cyclic one because \displaystyle e_{l}\times e_{j} \displaystyle=e_{j}\times e_{l}=e_{i}, \displaystyle c_{l}[ji]\times e_{l} \displaystyle=\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc_{l}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[ij]\times e_{l}=-\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc_{l}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[ij]^{\iota}=-c_{l}[ji]^{\iota}\quad\text{and} \displaystyle c_{i}[lj]\times d_{l}[ji] \displaystyle=\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mud_{l}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[ij]\times\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc_{i}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[jl]=\gamma_{j}\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mud_{l}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc_{i}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[il]=\gamma_{j}c_{i}d_{l}[li]. Alternatively, we may cite [ 17 , (37.13.4)] for Items 1 and 3 . ∎ Lemma 9.14 . For all pairwise distinct i,j,l\in\{1,2,3\} , the following hold: (1) J_{ij}\times J_{jl}\subseteq J_{il}^{\prime} . (2) J_{ij}\times J_{ij}\subseteq J_{ll}^{\prime} and J_{ij}\times J_{ll}\subseteq J_{ij}^{\prime} . (3) J_{ij}\times J_{jj}=0=J_{jj}\times J_{jj} . Proof. If (i\,j\,l) is a cyclic permutation of (1\,2\,3) , then by Lemma 9.13 , all assertions hold by Lemma 9.13 . The general case follows because \times is symmetric and J_{ij}=J_{ji} . Further, Item 1 is [ 17 , (37.13.1)] . ∎ We can also compute explicit formulas for the operators D_{a,a^{\prime}}=D(a,a^{\prime}) from Definition 2.7 , which together with Lemma 9.11 characterize these operators. In practice, we will only need a few of these formulas, but we state them all for completeness. We can already see at this point that for many (though not all) possible choices of i,j,p,q , the operator D(a[ij],b[pq]) depends only on the product ab . This will later lead to the similar statements in Lemmas 10.9 and 10.10 about \mathbf{d}(a[ij],b[pq]) . However, only Lemma 10.9 will be proven by using the explicit formulas in Lemma 9.15 , while we derive Lemma 10.10 from Lemma 4.17 by specializing to cubic Jordan matrix algebras. Lemma 9.15 . Let i,j,l\in\{1,2,3\} be pairwise distinct, let a_{1},a_{2},a_{3}\in C and let s_{1},s_{2},s_{3}\in k . Then the following hold: (1) The operator D(a_{1}[jl],a_{2}[li]^{\iota}) satisfies \displaystyle\{a_{1}[jl],a_{2}[li]^{\iota},a_{3}[ij]\} \displaystyle=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}\gamma_{l}t(a_{1}a_{2}a_{3})e_{j}, \displaystyle\{a_{1}[jl],a_{2}[li]^{\iota},a_{3}[il]\} \displaystyle=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{l}(a_{1}a_{2})a_{3}[jl], \displaystyle\{a_{1}[jl],a_{2}[li]^{\iota},s_{3}e_{i}\} \displaystyle=\gamma_{l}s_{3}a_{1}a_{2}[ji]. (2) The operator D(s_{1}e_{j},a_{2}[ji]^{\iota}) satisfies \displaystyle\{s_{1}e_{j},a_{2}[ji]^{\iota},a_{3}[ij]\} \displaystyle=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}s_{1}t(a_{2}a_{3})e_{j}, \displaystyle\{s_{1}e_{j},a_{2}[ji]^{\iota},a_{3}[il]\} \displaystyle=\gamma_{i}s_{1}a_{2}a_{3}[jl] \displaystyle\{s_{1}e_{j},a_{2}[ji]^{\iota},s_{3}e_{i}\} \displaystyle=s_{1}s_{3}a_{2}[ji]. (3) The operator D(a_{1}[ji],s_{2}e_{i}^{\prime}) satisfies \displaystyle\{a_{1}[ji],s_{2}e_{i}^{\prime},a_{3}[ij]\} \displaystyle=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}s_{2}t(a_{1}a_{3})e_{j}, \displaystyle\{a_{1}[ji],s_{2}e_{i}^{\prime},a_{3}[il]\} \displaystyle=\gamma_{i}s_{2}a_{1}a_{3}[jl], \displaystyle\{a_{1}[ji],s_{2}e_{i}^{\prime},s_{3}e_{i}\} \displaystyle=s_{2}s_{3}a_{1}[ji]. (4) The operator D(s_{1}e_{i},s_{2}e_{i}) satisfies \displaystyle\{s_{1}e_{i},s_{2}e_{i}^{\prime},s_{3}e_{i}\} \displaystyle=2s_{1}s_{2}s_{3}e_{i}, \displaystyle\{s_{1}e_{i},s_{2}e_{i}^{\prime},a_{3}[ij]\} \displaystyle=s_{1}s_{2}a_{3}[ij]. (5) The operator D(a_{1}[ij],a_{2}[ji]) satisfies \displaystyle\{a_{1}[ij],a_{2}[ji]^{\iota},s_{3}e_{i}\} \displaystyle=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}s_{3}t(a_{1}a_{2})e_{i}, \displaystyle\{a_{1}[ij],a_{2}[ji]^{\iota},a_{3}[ij]\} \displaystyle=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}\big(t(a_{2}a_{3})a_{1}+t(a_{1}a_{2})a_{3}-t(a_{1}\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{3}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{2}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\big)[ij], \displaystyle\{a_{1}[ij],a_{2}[ji]^{\iota},a_{3}[il]\} \displaystyle=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}a_{1}(a_{2}a_{3})[il]. Further, the same statements hold if all elements b\in J and c\in J^{\prime} are replaced by b^{\iota}\in J^{\prime} and c^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}\in J , respectively. Proof. This is a straightforward computation, see Section 9.3 for details. Note that, since \{a,b^{\prime},c\}=\{c,b^{\prime},a\} for a,c\in J , b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} and a[ij]=\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[ji] for a\in C and i\neq j , some of the formulas are redundant. For the second formula in Item 1 , we first prove by a straightforward computation that \{a_{1}[jl],a_{2}[li]^{\iota},a_{3}[il]\}=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{l}\big(t(a_{2}a_{3})a_{1}-(a_{1}\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{3}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{2}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\big), and then the desired formula follows by an application of Remark 9.4 Item 4 . ∎ 9.3. Computations in cubic Jordan matrix algebras The computations in J that are required in the proof of Lemma 9.15 , and similar computations in L and \Aut(L) that we will need later, boil down to the following two steps: First, we unravel the definition of all involved operators (such as D , U , N , \sharp , \times , T and the Lie bracket) to see that the desired assertion is equivalent to a set of equations in C and k . Second, we show that these equations follow from known identities on multiplicative conic alternative algebras, such as the ones in Remark 9.4 . While this procedure is straightforward in principle, the required computations can be rather long. In particular, the verification that certain elements in \Aut(L) are Weyl elements ( Proposition 11.11 ) seems too extensive to be manageable by hand. For this reason, we have performed these computations with the computer algebra system GAP [ 16 ] . Our code is available at [ 32 ] . In the following, we provide a few details on how these computations are performed. The key problem consists in working with an arbitrary multiplicative conic alternative algebra. In other words, we have to work in a free multiplicative conic algebra, whose generators we may think of as indeterminates. Say that we want to prove identities involving at most p elements in the conic algebra and at most q elements in the commutative ring. We introduce corresponding indeterminates (that is, abstract symbols) a_{1},\ldots,a_{p} and t_{1},\ldots,t_{q} . For each i\in\{1,\ldots,p\} , we also introduce abstract symbols \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{i}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu and n(a_{i})=n(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{i}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu) , which do not (yet) have any relation to the symbol a_{i} . Similarly, we define an abstract symbol t(a) for each a in the free magma A^{*} generated by the symbols in A\coloneq\{a_{1},\ldots,a_{p},\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{1}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu,\ldots,\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{p}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\} . Using all the symbols above, we define \tilde{k} to be the polynomial ring over \mathbb{Z} in indeterminates t_{1},\ldots,t_{q},n(a_{1}),\ldots,n(a_{p}) and t(a) for a\in A . Similarly, we define \tilde{C} to be the free nonassociative algebra over \tilde{k} generated by the symbols a_{1},\ldots,a_{p},\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{1}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu,\ldots,\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{p}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu . We can now give meaning to the symbol names introduced earlier: Define t\colon\tilde{C}\to\tilde{k} to be the unique \tilde{k} -linear map which sends a\in A^{*}\subseteq\tilde{C} to t(a)\in\tilde{k} and define \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mu\>\cdot\>\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\colon\tilde{C}\to\tilde{C} to be the unique k -linear map which sends a_{i} to \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{i}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu and \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{i}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu to a_{i} for all i\in\{1,\ldots,p\} and such that \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muab\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu=\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu for all a,b\in A^{*}\subseteq\tilde{C} . We also define n\colon A^{*}\to\tilde{k} to be the unique homomorphism of magmas that maps a\in A to the abstract symbol n(a) . Choosing an arbitrary total order < on A^{*} (for example, the lexicographic order), we can extend n to a map n\colon\tilde{C}\to\tilde{k} (which depends on the choice of < ) by putting (27) n\Bigl(\sum_{a\in A^{*}}\lambda_{a}a\Bigr)\coloneq\sum_{a\in A^{*}}\lambda_{a}^{2}n(a)+\sum_{a\cdot\>\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu are straightforward to implement in GAP. Hence we can also implement the maps N , T , \times and \sharp defined on \tilde{J}\coloneq\tilde{C}^{3}\oplus\tilde{k}^{3} . By construction, \tilde{k} and \tilde{C} satisfy the following universal property: For arbitrary b_{1},\ldots,b_{p}\in C and s_{1},\ldots,s_{q}\in k , there exist unique homomorphisms \pi_{k}\colon\tilde{k}\to k and \pi_{C}\colon\tilde{C}\to C such that \pi_{k}(t_{i})=s_{i} for all i\in\{1,\ldots,q\} , \pi_{C}(a_{j})=b_{j} for all j\in\{1,\ldots,p\} and \displaystyle\pi_{k}(t(c))=t_{C}\big(\pi_{C}(c)\big),\quad\pi_{k}(n(c))=n_{C}\big(\pi_{C}(c)\big),\quad\pi_{C}(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)=\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mu\pi_{C}(c)\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu for all c\in\tilde{C} where n_{C} , t_{C} denote the norm and trace on C . In particular, while n\colon\tilde{C}\to\tilde{k} depends on the choice of the total order < on A^{*} , the map \pi_{k}\circ n\colon\tilde{C}\to k is independent of this choice because it equals n_{C}\circ\pi_{C} . We say that a simplification map is a map \alpha\colon\tilde{C}\to\tilde{C} (or \alpha\colon\tilde{k}\to\tilde{k} ) such that for all possible choices of k , C , b_{1},\ldots,b_{m}\in C and s_{1},\ldots,s_{n}\in k , we have \alpha(c)-c\in\ker(\pi_{C}) for all c\in\tilde{C} (or \alpha(s)-s\in\ker(\pi_{k}) for all s\in\tilde{k} ). For example, for any total order \prec on A=\{a_{1},\ldots,a_{p},\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{1}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu,\ldots,\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{p}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\} , the map which replaces all occurrences of t(bc) for c\prec b\in A by t(cb) is a simplification map by Remark 9.4 Item 8 . In order to prove identities \ell=r such as those in Lemma 9.15 , we compute both sides \ell , r “in \tilde{J} ” (using one of the indeterminates a_{1},\ldots,a_{p} for each variable in C that occurs, and similarly using t_{1},\ldots,t_{q} for variables in k ) and apply a certain (fixed) sequence of simplification maps to the difference \ell-r . If the result is 0 , then we have proven that the identity holds for arbitrary C and k . If not, we obtain no information. The main challenge now lies in finding and implementing simplification maps that are computationally feasible but still “sufficiently powerful” to cover all identities that we want to prove. The correctness of these simplification maps relies on the identities in Remark 9.4 . From this point, the implementation of a suitable object \tilde{L} is straightforward except for the zero component \tilde{L}_{0,0} . Again, we use (linear combinations of) abstract symbols \zeta , \xi and \mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}} for a,a^{\prime}\in\tilde{J} to represent elements of \tilde{L}_{0,0} and suitable “simplification maps” to (try to) prove equality of terms. These simplification maps rely on the identities in Lemmas 10.10 , 10.9 and 10.13 . Finally, we may define exponential automorphisms by the formulas in Section 7 and prove equality of products of such automorphisms by evaluating them on \tilde{L}_{-2}\cup\tilde{L}_{1} , whose image in L is a generating set of the Lie algebra. In a few cases, the simplification maps do not reduce an element of \tilde{C} to 0 but instead to a rather short expression. In such cases, we simply prove by hand that the “simplified” expression lies in \ker(\pi_{C}) for all possible choices of C (instead of implementing a potentially complicated simplification map which would prove this automatically). Note that the strategy described in this section applies only to cubic Jordan matrix algebras and not to arbitrary cubic norm pairs. While a similar strategy could certainly work for cubic norm pairs, it would be more complicated to implement due to the higher number of maps that are part of the structure of a cubic norm pair. Moreover, the fact that the norm N is cubic and not merely quadratic would complicate this endeavor even further. At the same time, there is less need for computer assistance because the number of root spaces in G_{2} is more manageable. We have also considered an approach using “normal forms” of elements of \tilde{k} , \tilde{C} and \tilde{L}_{0,0} instead of using simplification maps. To some extent, the simplification maps that we use transform elements “of short (product) length” to something close to a normal form, but the task of finding a normal form for arbitrary elements seems much more challenging. 10. Refining the G_{2} -grading of the Lie algebra We keep up the notation from 9.2 , 9.6 and 9.7 and denote by L\coloneq L(J,J^{\prime}) the Lie algebra from Section 4 with respect to the cubic norm pair (J,J^{\prime}) coming from a cubic Jordan matrix algebra. Our goal is to further refine the G_{2} -grading of L from Proposition 4.28 to an F_{4} -grading. 10.1. Construction of the refinement In order to construct this refinement of the grading, we will first construct three new gradings. They arise from the “hyperbolic pairs” (e_{i},e^{\prime}_{i}) , where the e_{i} and e^{\prime}_{i} are as in Section 9 . When k is a field, we can indeed directly follow the approach from [ 10 ] and construct the gradings from these hyperbolic pairs, but in our setting, we will reverse the process by first describing the different pieces of the grading ( Definition 10.15 ), and then verifying that this does indeed define a 5 -grading ( Proposition 10.21 ). The hardest part to control is the “middle” subspace Z (see Definition 4.9 ). We rely on the multiple Peirce decomposition to introduce certain subspaces Z_{i\to j} of Z and we examine how these subspaces interact with various components in Lemmas 10.5 , 10.6 and 10.7 . In Proposition 10.14 , we will shows that Z_{i\to j} is isomorphic to the conic algebra C . Definition 10.1 . (1) For each subspace A\leq J and each subspace A^{\prime}\leq J^{\prime} , we write Z(A,A^{\prime}):=\left\langle\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}\mid a\in A,a^{\prime}\in A^{\prime}\right\rangle\leq Z. (2) Using the Peirce subspaces J_{ij} from Lemma 9.11 , we write Z_{ij,lm}:=Z(J_{ij},J_{lm}^{\prime}), for all i,j,l,m\in\{1,2,3\} . (We allow i=j or l=m .) (3) Finally, for all i,j\in\{1,2,3\} , not necessarily distinct, we write Z_{i\to j}:=Z_{i1,1j}+Z_{i2,2j}+Z_{i3,3j}. Remark 10.2 . Note that by Lemma 9.11 and Proposition 4.14 , Z_{ij,lm}=0 if (and only if) \{i,j\}\cap\{l,m\}=\emptyset . The following notation will be useful to avoid some case distinctions. Definition 10.3 . Let I be a subspace of J , J^{\prime} or Z and let P be a logical statement. We define I^{P}\coloneq I if P is true and I^{P}\coloneq 0 if P is false. Lemma 10.4 . Let i,j,l,p,q\in\{1,2,3\} be arbitrary. Let a\in J_{il} and a^{\prime}\in J_{lj}^{\prime} . Then: (1) If i\neq j , then D_{a,a^{\prime}}(J_{pq})\subseteq J_{iq}^{p=j}+J_{ip}^{q=j}. (2) If i=j , then D_{a,a^{\prime}}(J_{pq})\subseteq J_{pq}^{\{p,q\}\cap\{i,l\}\neq\emptyset}. The same assertions hold if we interchange the roles of J and J^{\prime} . Proof. This is an immediate corollary of Lemma 9.11 . ∎ Lemma 10.5 . Let i,j,p,q\in\{1,2,3\} with i\neq j . Then the following hold: (1) [Z_{i\to j},J_{pq}]\subseteq J_{iq}^{p=j}+J_{ip}^{q=j} and [Z_{i\to j},J_{pq}^{\prime}]\subseteq(J_{jq}^{\prime})^{p=i}+(J_{jp}^{\prime})^{q=i} . (2) [Z_{i\to i},J_{pq}]\subseteq J_{pq} and [Z_{i\to i},J_{pq}^{\prime}]\subseteq J_{pq}^{\prime} . Proof. Let i,j,p,q,l\in\{1,2,3\} . (We do not assume that i\neq j .) Let a\in J_{il} , a^{\prime}\in J_{lj} , c_{pq}\in J_{pq} and c_{pq}^{\prime}\in J_{pq}^{\prime} . By Proposition 4.14 , [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},c_{pq}]=D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c_{pq})\quad\text{and}\quad[\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},c_{pq}^{\prime}]=-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c_{pq}^{\prime}). The assertion now follows from Lemma 10.4 . ∎ Lemma 10.6 . Let i,j,p,q\in\{1,2,3\} with i\neq j . Then the actions of Z_{i\to j} and Z_{i\to i} on L_{\pm 1} respect the following formulas: (1) [Z_{i\to j},(k,J_{pq},J_{pq}^{\prime},k)_{\pm}]\subseteq(0,J_{iq}^{p=j}+J_{ip}^{q=j},(J_{jq}^{\prime})^{p=i}+(J_{jp}^{\prime})^{q=i},0)_{\pm} . (2) [Z_{i\to i},(0,J_{pq},J_{pq}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}]\subseteq(0,J_{pq},J_{pq}^{\prime},0)_{\pm} . Proof. This follows from Propositions 4.12 and 10.5 . For the first assertion, we also use that for all a\in J_{il} , a^{\prime}\in J_{lj} with l\in\{1,2,3\} (i.e., for the set of (a,a^{\prime}) for which the corresponding \mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}} generate Z_{i\to j} ), we have T(a,a^{\prime})=0 by Lemma 9.12 Item 3 . ∎ Lemma 10.7 . Let i,j,l\in\{1,2,3\} be arbitrary. (1) Z_{i\to j} is a Lie subalgebra of Z , which is abelian if i\neq j . (2) [Z_{i\to j},Z_{j\to i}]\subseteq Z_{i\to i}+Z_{j\to j} . (3) The Lie algebra Z_{i\to i} normalizes Z_{j\to l} , i.e., [Z_{i\to i},Z_{j\to l}]\subseteq Z_{j\to l} . (4) [Z_{i\to j},Z_{j\to l}]\subseteq Z_{i\to l} when i,j,l are pairwise distinct. (5) [Z_{i\to j},Z_{i\to l}]=0 and [Z_{i\to j},Z_{l\to j}]=0 when i,j,l are pairwise distinct. Proof. Recall from Corollary 4.13 that (28) [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\mathbf{d}_{b,b^{\prime}}]=\mathbf{d}_{D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b),b^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{b,D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime})}. Throughout this proof, we will assume that i,j,l,p,q\in\{1,2,3\} are arbitrary. We first observe that by Lemma 10.4 Item 2 and Eq. 28 , Z_{i\to i} normalizes each Z_{jl,pq} , so in particular, (29) [Z_{i\to i},Z_{p\to q}]\subseteq Z_{p\to q}. (1) Assume first that i=j . Then by Eq. 29 with p=q=i , Z_{i\to i} is indeed a Lie subalgebra of Z . Assume next that i\neq j . We have to show that, for all a\in J_{ip} , a^{\prime}\in J_{pj}^{\prime} , b\in J_{iq} , b^{\prime}\in J_{qj}^{\prime} , we have [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\mathbf{d}_{b,b^{\prime}}]=0 . By Lemma 10.4 Item 1 , we have D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b)\in J_{ii}^{q=j}\quad\text{and}\quad D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime})\in{J_{jj}^{\prime}}^{q=i}. By Lemma 9.11 , however, we have Z_{ii,jj}=0 , which implies that \mathbf{d}_{D_{a,a^{\prime}}(b),b^{\prime}} and \mathbf{d}_{b,D_{a^{\prime},a}(b^{\prime})} are trivial also when q=j or q=i . (2) We may assume that i\neq j . Let a\in J_{ip} , a^{\prime}\in J_{pj}^{\prime} , b\in J_{jq} , b^{\prime}\in J_{qi}^{\prime} . Then by Lemma 10.4 Item 1 and Eq. 28 , we have [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\mathbf{d}_{b,b^{\prime}}]\in Z_{iq,qi}+Z_{jq,qj}\subseteq Z_{i\to i}+Z_{j\to j}. (3) This is Eq. 29 . (4) Let a\in J_{ip} , a^{\prime}\in J_{pj}^{\prime} , b\in J_{jq} , b^{\prime}\in J_{ql}^{\prime} . Then by Lemma 10.4 Item 1 and Eq. 28 , we have [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\mathbf{d}_{b,b^{\prime}}]\in Z_{iq,ql}+Z_{qj,jl}^{q=i}\subseteq Z_{i\to l}. (5) Let a\in J_{ip} , a^{\prime}\in J_{pj}^{\prime} , b\in J_{iq} , b^{\prime}\in J_{ql}^{\prime} . Then by Lemma 10.4 Item 1 and Eq. 28 , we have [\mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}},\mathbf{d}_{b,b^{\prime}}]\in Z_{ii,ql}^{q=j}+Z_{iq,jl}^{q=i}\subseteq Z_{ii,jl}=0. The proof of the other identity is completely similar. ∎ Our next goal is to show that each of the spaces Z_{i\to j} is isomorphic to the conic algebra C for i\neq j ( Proposition 10.14 ). Clearly, we have a surjective homomorphism C\to Z_{ii,ij}\colon a\mapsto\mathbf{d}_{e_{i},a[ij]^{\iota}} (using that i\neq j ), so the main property to show is that Z_{ii,ij}=Z_{i\to j} . Lemma 10.8 . Let i,j\in\{1,2,3\} be distinct and let a\in C . Then D(a[ij],1_{C}[ji]^{\iota})=D(1_{C}[ij],a[ji]^{\iota})\quad\text{and}\quad D(a[ij]^{\iota},1_{C}[ji])=D(1_{C}[ij]^{\iota},a[ji]). Proof. We only prove the first statement, the proof of the second one being similar. It is immediate from Lemma 9.11 and Lemma 9.15 Item 5 that both operators act in the same way on all components of J except possibly on J_{ij} . For the action on J_{ij} , we compute for arbitrary b\in C : \displaystyle\{a[ij],1_{C}[ji]^{\iota},b[ij]\} \displaystyle=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}\big(t(b)a+t(a)b-t(a\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)1_{C}\big)[ij], \displaystyle\{1_{C}[ij],a[ji]^{\iota},b[ij]\} \displaystyle=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}\big(t(ab)1_{C}+t(a)b-t(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\big)[ij]. Recall from Remark 9.4 Items 3 , 6 and 7 that t(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)=t(b) and t(a\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)=n(a,b)=t(a)t(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)-n(a,\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)=t(a)t(b)-t(ab). Hence the difference between the two expressions above is \displaystyle t(b)a-t(a)t(b)1_{C}+t(b)\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu, which is zero because t(a)1_{C}=a+\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu . ∎ Lemma 10.9 . Let i,j\in\{1,2,3\} be distinct and let a\in C . Then \mathbf{d}(a[ij],1_{C}[ji]^{\iota})=\mathbf{d}(1_{C}[ij],a[ji]^{\iota}) . Proof. Since T(a[ij],1_{C}[ji]^{\iota})=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}t(a)=T(1_{C}[ij],a[ji]^{\iota}) , this follows from Propositions 4.12 and 10.8 . ∎ Lemma 10.10 . Let i,j,l\in\{1,2,3\} be pairwise distinct and let a,b\in C . Then the following hold. (1) \mathbf{d}_{e_{1},e_{1}^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{e_{2},e_{2}^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{e_{3},e_{3}^{\prime}}=2\zeta-\xi . (2) \mathbf{d}(e_{j},a[ji]^{\iota})=\mathbf{d}(a[ji],e_{i}^{\prime}) . (3) \begin{aligned} \mathbf{d}(a[jl],b[li]^{\iota})&=\mathbf{d}(1_{C}[jl],ab[li]^{\iota})=\mathbf{d}(ab[jl],1_{C}[li]^{\iota})\\ &=\gamma_{l}\mathbf{d}(e_{j},ab[ji]^{\iota})=\gamma_{l}\mathbf{d}(ab[ji],e_{i}^{\prime}).\end{aligned} (4) \mathbf{d}(a[ij],\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[ji]^{\iota})=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}n(a)\big(\mathbf{d}_{e_{i},e_{i}^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{e_{j},e_{j}^{\prime}}\big) . (5) \mathbf{d}(a[ij],\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[ji]^{\iota})+\mathbf{d}(b[ij],\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[ji]^{\iota})=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}t(a\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mub\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)\big(\mathbf{d}_{e_{i},e_{i}^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{e_{j},e_{j}^{\prime}}\big) . Proof. Recall from Lemma 4.17 Item 5 that for all p^{\prime},q^{\prime},r^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} , we have \displaystyle\mathbf{d}_{p^{\prime}\times q^{\prime},r^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{q^{\prime}\times r^{\prime},p^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{r^{\prime}\times p^{\prime},q^{\prime}}=T(r^{\prime},p^{\prime}\times q^{\prime})\cdot(2\zeta-\xi). We will denote this term by \varphi(p^{\prime},q^{\prime},r^{\prime}) and prove the assertions by specializing to well-chosen values of p^{\prime} , q^{\prime} , r^{\prime} . We will also use Lemmas 9.13 and 9.12 to compute terms such as p^{\prime}\times\tilde{b^{\prime}} or T(r^{\prime},p^{\prime}\times q^{\prime}) . For p^{\prime}\coloneq e_{1}^{\prime} , q^{\prime}\coloneq e_{2}^{\prime} , and r^{\prime}\coloneq e_{3}^{\prime} , we obtain \displaystyle\varphi(p^{\prime},q^{\prime},r^{\prime}) \displaystyle=\mathbf{d}(e_{1}^{\prime}\times e_{2}^{\prime},e_{3}^{\prime})+\mathbf{d}(e_{2}^{\prime}\times e_{3}^{\prime},e_{1}^{\prime})+\mathbf{d}(e_{3}^{\prime}\times e_{1}^{\prime},e_{2}^{\prime}) \displaystyle=\mathbf{d}_{e_{1},e_{1}^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{e_{2},e_{2}^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{e_{3},e_{3}^{\prime}}\quad\text{and} \displaystyle\varphi(p^{\prime},q^{\prime},r^{\prime}) \displaystyle=T(e_{3}^{\prime},e_{1}^{\prime}\times e_{2}^{\prime})(2\zeta-\xi)=T(e_{3}^{\prime},e_{3}^{\prime})(2\zeta-\xi)=2\zeta-\xi. This implies Item 1 . For p^{\prime}\coloneq e_{l}^{\prime} , q^{\prime}\coloneq e_{i}^{\prime} and r^{\prime}\coloneq a[ji]^{\iota} , we obtain \displaystyle\varphi(p^{\prime},q^{\prime},r^{\prime}) \displaystyle=\mathbf{d}(e_{l}^{\prime}\times e_{i}^{\prime},a[ji]^{\iota})+\mathbf{d}(e_{i}^{\prime}\times a[ji]^{\iota},e_{l}^{\prime})+\mathbf{d}(a[ji]^{\iota}\times e_{l}^{\prime},e_{i}^{\prime}) \displaystyle=\mathbf{d}(e_{j},a[ji]^{\iota})+\mathbf{d}(0,e_{l}^{\prime})-\mathbf{d}(a[ji]^{\iota},e_{i}^{\prime})\quad\text{and} \displaystyle\varphi(p^{\prime},q^{\prime},r^{\prime}) \displaystyle=T(a[ji]^{\iota},e_{l}^{\prime}\times e_{i}^{\prime})(2\zeta-\xi)=T(a[ji]^{\iota},e_{j})(2\zeta-\xi)=0. Identity Item 2 follows, which also implies the final equality sign in Item 3 . For p^{\prime}\coloneq e_{i}^{\prime} , q^{\prime}\coloneq 1[jl]^{\iota} , r^{\prime}\coloneq ab[li]^{\iota} , we obtain \displaystyle\varphi(p^{\prime},q^{\prime},r^{\prime}) \displaystyle=\mathbf{d}(e_{i}^{\prime}\times 1[jl]^{\iota},ab[li]^{\iota})+\mathbf{d}(1[jl]^{\iota}\times ab[li]^{\iota},e_{i}^{\prime})+\mathbf{d}(ab[li]^{\iota}\times e_{i}^{\prime},1[jl]^{\iota}) \displaystyle=-\mathbf{d}(1[jl],ab[li]^{\iota})+\mathbf{d}(\gamma_{l}ab[ji],e_{i}^{\prime})+\mathbf{d}(0,1[jl]^{\iota})\quad\text{and} \displaystyle\varphi(p^{\prime},q^{\prime},r^{\prime}) \displaystyle=T(ab[li]^{\iota},e_{i}^{\prime}\times 1[jl]^{\iota})(2\zeta-\xi)=T(ab[li]^{\iota},-1[jl])(2\zeta-\xi)=0. It follows that \mathbf{d}(1[jl],ab[li]^{\iota})=\gamma_{l}\mathbf{d}(ab[ji],e_{i}^{\prime}) . For p^{\prime}\coloneq e_{i}^{\prime} , q^{\prime}\coloneq ab[jl]^{\iota} , r^{\prime}\coloneq 1[li]^{\iota} , we obtain \displaystyle\varphi(p^{\prime},q^{\prime},r^{\prime}) \displaystyle=\mathbf{d}(e_{i}^{\prime}\times ab[jl]^{\iota},1[li]^{\iota})+\mathbf{d}(ab[jl]^{\iota}\times 1[li]^{\iota},e_{i}^{\prime})+\mathbf{d}(1[li]^{\iota}\times e_{i}^{\prime},ab[jl]^{\iota}) \displaystyle=-\mathbf{d}(ab[jl]^{\iota},1[li])+\mathbf{d}(\gamma_{l}ab[ji],e_{i}^{\prime})+\mathbf{d}(0,ab[jl])\quad\text{and} \displaystyle\varphi(p^{\prime},q^{\prime},r^{\prime}) \displaystyle=T(1[li]^{\iota},e_{i}^{\prime}\times ab[jl])(2\zeta-\xi)=T(1[li]^{\iota},-ab[jl]^{\iota})(2\zeta-\xi)=0. It follows that \mathbf{d}(ab[jl],1[li])=\gamma_{l}\mathbf{d}(ab[ji],e_{i}^{\prime}) . For p\coloneq a[jl] , q\coloneq b[li] , r\coloneq e_{j}\in J , we have \displaystyle\mathbf{d}_{p,q\times r}+\mathbf{d}_{q,r\times p}+\mathbf{d}_{r,p\times q} \displaystyle=-\mathbf{d}(a[jl],b[li]^{\iota})+\mathbf{d}(b[li],0)+\mathbf{d}(e_{j},\gamma_{l}ab[ji]), \displaystyle T(r,p\times q)(2\zeta-\xi) \displaystyle=T(e_{j},a[jl]\times b[li])(2\zeta-\xi)=T(e_{j},\gamma_{l}ab[ji])(2\zeta-\xi)=0. Thus it follows from Lemma 4.17 Item 6 that \mathbf{d}(a[jl],b[li]^{\iota})=\gamma_{l}\mathbf{d}(e_{j},ab[ji]) , which finishes the proof of Item 3 . For Item 4 , we put p\coloneq e_{l} and q\coloneq a[ij] . Then \displaystyle\mathbf{d}_{p,q^{\sharp}}+\mathbf{d}_{q,p\times q} \displaystyle=\mathbf{d}(e_{l},-\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}n(a)e_{l}^{\prime})+\mathbf{d}(a[ij],-a[ij]^{\iota}), \displaystyle T(p,q^{\sharp})(2\zeta-\xi) \displaystyle=T(e_{l},-\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}n(a)e_{l})(2\zeta-\xi)=-\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}n(a)(2\zeta-\xi) \displaystyle=-\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}n(a)(\mathbf{d}_{e_{1},e_{1}}+\mathbf{d}_{e_{2},e_{2}}+\mathbf{d}_{e_{3},e_{3}}) by Item 1 . Now Item 4 follows from Lemma 4.17 Item 3 . Finally, Item 5 is the linearization of Item 4 . ∎ Remark 10.11 . The identities in Lemma 10.10 also hold with D in place of \mathbf{d} (and then as identities in J or J^{\prime} ), except that Item 1 should be read as \sum_{i=1}^{3}D(e_{i},e_{i}^{\prime})=2\id_{J}\quad\text{and}\quad\sum_{i=1}^{3}D(e_{i}^{\prime},e_{i})=2\id_{J^{\prime}}. Remark 10.12 . Let i,j,l\in\{1,2,3\} be pairwise distinct. We want to show that we do not have \mathbf{d}(a[il],b[li]^{\iota})=\mathbf{d}(1[il],ab[li]^{\iota}) in general. Suppose for a contradiction that \mathbf{d}(a[il],b[li])=\mathbf{d}(1[il],ab[li]^{\iota}) for all a,b\in C , and let a,b,c\in C be arbitrary. Since \displaystyle T(a[il],b[li])=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}t(ab)=T(ab[il],1[li]) by Lemma 9.12 Item 2 , it follows from Proposition 4.12 that D(a[il],b[li])=D(1[il],ab[li]). Thus \displaystyle\{a[jl],b[li]^{\iota},c[il]\} \displaystyle=\{c[il],b[li]^{\iota},a[jl]\}=\{1[il],cb[li]^{\iota},a[jl]\} \displaystyle=\{a[jl],cb[li]^{\iota},1[il]\}=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{l}a(cb)[jl]. by Lemma 9.15 Item 1 . On the other hand, \displaystyle\{a[jl],b[li]^{\iota},c[il]\}=\gamma_{i}\gamma_{l}(ab)c[jl] Assuming additionally that \gamma_{i} , \gamma_{j} are invertible, it follows that (ab)c=a(cb) for all a,b,c\in C . In other words, C is commutative and associative, which is not the case for arbitrary multiplicative conic alternative algebras. Lemma 10.13 . Let a_{1},a_{2},a_{3}\in C . Then \sum\gamma_{i}\mathbf{d}_{a_{i}[jl],\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{l}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{j}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[jl]}=\gamma_{1}\gamma_{2}\gamma_{3}t(a_{1}a_{2}a_{3})\cdot(2\zeta-\xi) where the sum runs over all cyclic permutations (i\,j\,l) of (1\,2\,3) . Proof. By Lemma 4.17 , we have \sum\mathbf{d}_{a_{i}[jl],a_{j}[li]\times a_{l}[ij]}=T(a_{2}[31],a_{3}[12]\times a_{1}[23])\cdot(2\zeta-\xi). Recall from Lemma 9.14 Item 1 that \displaystyle a_{i}[jl]\times a_{j}[li]=\gamma_{l}\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{j}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{i}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[ij] for all cyclic permutations (i\,j\,l) of (1\,2\,3) . Hence \sum\mathbf{d}_{a_{i}[jl],a_{j}[li]\times a_{l}[ij]}=\sum\gamma_{i}\mathbf{d}_{a_{i}[jl],\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{l}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{j}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[jl]}. Further, \displaystyle T(a_{2}[31],a_{3}[12]\times a_{1}[23]) \displaystyle=T(a_{2}[31],\gamma_{2}\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{1}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mua_{3}\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu[31])=\gamma_{1}\gamma_{2}\gamma_{3}t(a_{2}a_{3}a_{1}) \displaystyle=\gamma_{1}\gamma_{2}\gamma_{3}t(a_{1}a_{2}a_{3}) by Lemma 9.14 Item 1 and Lemma 9.12 Item 2 . The assertion follows. ∎ Proposition 10.14 . Let i\neq j\in\{1,2,3\} . Then the map \theta\colon C\to Z_{i\to j},a\mapsto\mathbf{d}_{e_{i},a[ij]^{\iota}} is an isomorphism of k -modules. Proof. The map is clearly a homomorphism and surjective by Lemma 10.10 Items 2 and 3 . Now let a\in C with \theta(a)=0 . Then by Proposition 4.12 , \displaystyle 0 \displaystyle=[\theta(a),(0,e_{j},0,0)_{+}]=\big(0,D_{e_{i},a[ij]^{\iota}}(e_{j}),0,0\big)_{+}. Since D_{e_{i},a[ij]^{\iota}}(e_{j})=a[ij] by Lemma 9.15 Item 2 , we infer that a=0 . Thus \theta is injective. ∎ We are now ready to define three new gradings on our Lie algebra L . The verification that these are, in fact, gradings, will occupy us until Proposition 10.21 . Definition 10.15 . Let i\in\{1,2,3\} and let (i\,j\,l) be the unique cyclic permutation of (1\,2\,3) . We will define a decomposition L=L^{(i)}_{-2}\oplus L^{(i)}_{-1}\oplus L^{(i)}_{0}\oplus L^{(i)}_{1}\oplus L^{(i)}_{2} with L^{(i)}_{-2}=ke^{\prime}_{i} and L^{(i)}_{2}=ke_{i} . We set \displaystyle L^{(i)}_{-1} \displaystyle:=\begin{multlined}0\ \oplus\ (k,\ ke_{j}+ke_{l}+J_{jl},\ ke_{i}^{\prime},\ 0)_{-}\\ \oplus\ \Bigl((J_{ij}^{\prime}+J_{li}^{\prime})\oplus Z^{(i)}_{-1}\oplus 0\Bigr)\\ \oplus\ (k,\ ke_{j}+ke_{l}+J_{jl},\ ke_{i}^{\prime},\ 0)_{+}\ \oplus\ 0\,,\end{multlined} \displaystyle L^{(i)}_{0} \displaystyle:=\begin{multlined}kx\ \oplus\ (0,\ J_{ij}+J_{li},\ J_{ij}^{\prime}+J_{li}^{\prime},\ 0)_{-}\\ \oplus\ \Bigl((ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime})\oplus Z^{(i)}_{0}\oplus(ke_{j}+ke_{l}+J_{jl})\Bigr)\\ \oplus\ (0,\ J_{ij}+J_{li},\ J_{ij}^{\prime}+J_{li}^{\prime},\ 0)_{+}\ \oplus\ ky\,,\end{multlined} \displaystyle L^{(i)}_{1} \displaystyle:=\begin{multlined}0\ \oplus\ (0,\ ke_{i},\ ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime},\ k)_{-}\\ \oplus\ \Bigl(0\oplus Z^{(i)}_{1}\oplus(J_{ij}+J_{li})\Bigr)\\ \oplus\ (0,\ ke_{i},\ ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime},\ k)_{+}\ \oplus\ 0\,,\end{multlined} where \displaystyle Z^{(i)}_{-1} \displaystyle:=Z_{j\to i}+Z_{l\to i}\,, \displaystyle Z^{(i)}_{0} \displaystyle:=Z_{i\to i}+Z_{j\to j}+Z_{l\to l}+Z_{j\to l}+Z_{l\to j}+k\xi+k\zeta, \displaystyle Z^{(i)}_{1} \displaystyle:=Z_{i\to j}+Z_{i\to l}. 10.2. Verification of the grading property Proposition 10.16 . Let i\in\{1,2,3\} . Then: (1) We have Z=Z_{-1}^{(i)}\oplus Z_{0}^{(i)}\oplus Z_{1}^{(i)} as k -modules. (2) The decomposition from Item 1 defines a 3 -grading on Z . Proof. Let (i\,j\,l) denote the unique cyclic permutation of (1\,2\,3) starting from i . By Definition 4.9 , we have Z=Z_{-1}^{(i)}+Z_{0}^{(i)}+Z_{1}^{(i)} . Now let d_{-1}\in Z_{-1}^{(i)} , d_{0}\in Z_{0}^{(i)} and d_{1}\in Z_{1}^{(i)} such that d_{-1}+d_{0}+d_{1}=0 ; we have to show that d_{-1}=d_{0}=d_{1}=0 . Recall from Definition 4.1 that an element of M is zero if and only if it acts trivially on \bigoplus_{m\neq 0}L_{m} . By Proposition 4.12 , d_{-1} and d_{1} act trivially on L_{\pm 2} , so d_{0}=-d_{-1}-d_{1} does the same. Similarly, d_{-1} and d_{1} act trivially on the subspace (k,0,0,k)_{\pm} of L_{\pm 1} by Lemma 10.6 Item 1 , so the same holds for d_{0} . It remains to show that for all p,q\in\{1,2,3\} , d_{-1} , d_{1} and d_{0} act trivially on the subspaces (0,J_{pq},J_{pq}^{\prime},0)_{\pm} of L_{\pm 1} . It follows from Lemma 10.6 and Definition 4.1 Item 4 that d_{-1} , d_{1} and d_{0} map (0,J_{ii},J_{ii}^{\prime},0)_{\pm} to (0,J_{ij}+J_{il},0,0)_{\pm},\qquad(0,0,J_{ij}^{\prime}+J_{il}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}\quad\text{and}\quad(0,J_{ii},J_{ii}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}, respectively. Since the sum of these three spaces is direct and d_{-1}+d_{0}+d_{1}=0 , we deduce that d_{-1} , d_{1} and d_{0} all act trivially on (0,J_{ii},J_{ii}^{\prime},0)_{\pm} . Similarly, d_{-1} , d_{1} and d_{0} map the spaces (0,J_{pp},J_{pp}^{\prime},0)_{\pm} , (0,J_{ip},J_{ip}^{\prime},0)_{\pm} and (0,J_{pq},J_{pq}^{\prime},0)_{\pm} (for any (p,q)\in\{(j,l),(l,j)\} ) to \displaystyle(0,0,J_{pi}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}, \displaystyle(0,J_{pi},0,0)_{\pm}, \displaystyle(0,J_{pp}+J_{pq},J_{pp}^{\prime}+J_{pq}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}, \displaystyle(0,J_{pp}+J_{pq},J_{ii}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}, \displaystyle(0,J_{ii},J_{pp}^{\prime}+J_{pq}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}, \displaystyle(0,J_{ip}+J_{iq},J_{ip}^{\prime}+J_{iq}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}, \displaystyle(0,0,J_{iq}^{\prime}+J_{pi}^{\prime},0), \displaystyle(0,J_{iq}+J_{pi},0,0), \displaystyle(0,J_{pq},J_{pq}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}, respectively. Again, the three subspaces in each row form a direct sum, and we conclude that d_{-1} , d_{1} and d_{0} act trivially on each of the subspaces of the form (0,J_{pq},J_{pq}^{\prime},0)_{\pm} with p,q\in\{1,2,3\} . It follows that indeed d_{-1}=d_{0}=d_{1}=0 , and this proves Item 1 . Now Item 2 follows immediately from Lemmas 10.7 and 4.11 . ∎ Lemma 10.17 . Let i\in\{1,2,3\} and let (i\,j\,l) be the unique cyclic permutation of (1\,2\,3) starting from i . Consider the k -module homomorphisms \theta^{(i)}_{\pm}\colon L_{\pm 1}\to L_{\pm 1}\colon z\mapsto[e_{i},z]. Let z=(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm}\in L_{\pm 1} and write \displaystyle b \displaystyle=\xi_{1}e_{1}+\xi_{2}e_{2}+\xi_{3}e_{3}+c_{23}+c_{31}+c_{12}\in J, \displaystyle b^{\prime} \displaystyle=\xi_{1}^{\prime}e_{1}^{\prime}+\xi_{2}^{\prime}e_{2}^{\prime}+\xi_{3}^{\prime}e_{3}^{\prime}+c_{23}^{\prime}+c_{31}^{\prime}+c_{12}^{\prime}\in J^{\prime}, with each \xi_{i},\xi_{i}^{\prime}\in k and each c_{jl}\in J_{jl} , c_{jl}^{\prime}\in J_{jl}^{\prime} . Then [e_{i},z]=\bigl(0,\ \lambda e_{i},\ \xi_{l}e_{j}^{\prime}+\xi_{j}e_{l}^{\prime}-c_{jl}^{\iota},\ \xi_{i}^{\prime}\bigr)_{\pm}. In particular, the image and kernel of \theta^{(i)}_{\pm} are given by \displaystyle\im\theta^{(i)}_{\pm} \displaystyle=\bigl(0,\ ke_{i},\ ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime},\ k\bigr)_{\pm}\leq L_{1}^{(i)}, \displaystyle\ker\theta^{(i)}_{\pm} \displaystyle=\bigl(0,\ ke_{i}+J_{ij}+J_{li},\ ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{ij}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime}+J_{li}^{\prime},\ k\bigr)_{\pm}\leq L_{0}^{(i)}+L_{1}^{(i)}, respectively. Proof. By Lemma 9.12 , we have e_{i}\times b=\xi_{l}e_{j}^{\prime}+\xi_{j}e_{l}^{\prime}-c_{jl}^{\iota}\quad\text{and}\quad T(e_{i},b^{\prime})=\xi_{i}^{\prime}. Therefore, by Definition 4.7 , we have \displaystyle[e_{i},z] \displaystyle=\bigl(0,\ \lambda e_{i},\ e_{i}\times b,\ T(e_{i},b^{\prime})\bigr)_{\pm} \displaystyle=\bigl(0,\ \lambda e_{i},\ \xi_{l}e_{j}^{\prime}+\xi_{j}e_{l}^{\prime}-c_{jl}^{\iota},\ \xi_{i}^{\prime}\bigr)_{\pm}, and the result follows. ∎ We now arrive at a sequence of lemmas dealing with some of the more involved cases required to check that Definition 10.15 gives rise to 5 -gradings of L . We advise the reader to have a copy of Definition 10.15 ready, to be able to follow our computations. The different cases and subcases in our proofs correspond to the different L_{i} -components for each of the three subspaces occuring in Definition 10.15 . Lemma 10.18 . Let i\in\{1,2,3\} . Then [L_{-1}^{(i)},L_{1}^{(i)}]\subseteq L_{0}^{(i)} . Proof. Let (i\,j\,l) denote the unique cyclic permutation of (1\,2\,3) starting from i . Let z_{1}\in L_{-1}^{(i)} and z_{2}\in L_{1}^{(i)} . We will write z_{1}=(\lambda,b,\lambda_{i}^{\prime}e_{i}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}\quad\text{or}\quad z_{2}=(0,\mu_{i}e_{i},c^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm} if z_{1} or z_{2} , respectively, lies in L_{\pm 1} , where \lambda,\lambda_{i}^{\prime},\mu_{i},\mu\in k , b\in ke_{j}+ke_{l}+J_{jl} and c^{\prime}\in ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime} . First, we consider the case that z_{1}\in L_{\pm 1} . As the first subcase, we assume that z_{2}\in L_{\pm 1} as well. If z_{1} and z_{2} are both in L_{1} or both in L_{-1} , then [z_{1},z_{2}]\in ky\subseteq L_{0}^{(i)} or [z_{1},z_{2}]\in kx\subseteq L_{0}^{(i)} , respectively. If z_{1}\in L_{-1} and z_{2}\in L_{1} , then by Definition 4.22 , [z_{1},z_{2}]=\big(-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times\mu_{i}e_{i}\big)\\ \begin{aligned} &+\big((\lambda\mu-T(b,c^{\prime}))\zeta+T(\mu_{i}e_{i},\lambda_{i}^{\prime}e_{i}^{\prime})(\xi-\zeta)+\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{\mu_{i}e_{i},\lambda_{i}^{\prime}e_{i}^{\prime}}\big)\\ &+\big(-\mu b+\lambda_{i}^{\prime}e_{i}^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}\big).\end{aligned} Now \displaystyle b\times\mu_{i}e_{i}\in ke_{l}^{\prime}+ke_{j}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime}\quad \displaystyle\text{and}\quad\lambda_{i}^{\prime}e_{i}^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}\in ke_{l}+ke_{j}+J_{jl}, \displaystyle\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}\in Z_{j\to j}+Z_{j\to l}+Z_{l\to l}+Z_{l\to j}\quad \displaystyle\text{and}\quad\mathbf{d}_{\mu_{i}e_{i},\lambda_{i}^{\prime}e_{i}^{\prime}}\in Z_{i\to i}, by Lemma 9.13 Item 1 and Definition 10.1 , respectively. Hence [z_{1},z_{2}]\in L_{0}^{(i)} in this subcase. The subcase z_{1}\in L_{1} , z_{2}\in L_{-1} is completely similar. We now turn to the subcase z_{2}\in L_{0} . If z_{2}\in J_{ij}+J_{li} , then by Definition 4.7 , \displaystyle[z_{1},z_{2}] \displaystyle=-[z_{2},z_{1}]=-\big(0,\lambda z_{2},z_{2}\times b,T(z_{2},\lambda_{i}^{\prime}e_{i}^{\prime})\big) where z_{2}\times b\in J_{ij}^{\prime}+J_{il}^{\prime} by Lemma 9.14 and T(z_{2},\lambda_{i}^{\prime}e_{i}^{\prime})=0 by Lemma 9.12 Item 3 . Hence [z_{1},z_{2}]\in L_{0}^{(i)} in this subcase. In the final subcase z_{2}\in Z_{1}^{(i)} , we have [z_{1},z_{2}]\in(0,J_{ij}+J_{il},J_{ij}^{\prime}+J_{il}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}\subseteq L_{0}^{(i)} by Lemma 10.6 Item 1 . Second, we consider the case that z_{1}\in J_{ij}^{\prime}+J_{li}^{\prime} . If z_{2}\in L_{\pm 1} , then Definition 4.7 yields \displaystyle[z_{1},z_{2}] \displaystyle=-\big(T(\mu_{i}e_{i},z_{1}),z_{1}\times c^{\prime},\mu z_{1},0\big)_{\pm} where T(\mu_{i}e_{i},z_{1})=0 by Lemma 9.12 Item 3 and z_{1}\times c^{\prime}\in J_{ij}+J_{li} by Lemma 9.14 . If z_{2}\in J_{ij}+J_{li} , then \displaystyle[z_{1},z_{2}] \displaystyle=\mathbf{d}_{z_{2},z_{1}}\in Z_{i\to i}+Z_{j\to l}+Z_{l\to j}\subseteq L_{0}^{(i)}. If z_{2}\in Z_{1}^{(i)} , then by Lemma 10.5 Item 1 , [z_{1},z_{2}]\in J_{jj}^{\prime}+J_{ll}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime}\subseteq L_{0}^{(i)} , which finishes the case z_{1}\in J_{ij}^{\prime}+J_{li}^{\prime} . Finally, we assume that z_{1}\in Z_{-1}^{(i)} . If z_{2}\in L_{\pm 1} , then we infer from Lemma 10.6 Item 1 that [z_{1},z_{2}]\in(0,J_{ji}+J_{li},J_{ji}^{\prime}+J_{li}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}\subseteq L_{0}^{(i)}. If z_{2}\in J_{ij}+J_{li} , then [z_{1},z_{2}]\in J_{jj}+J_{ll}+J_{lj} by Lemma 10.5 Item 1 . If finally z_{2}\in Z_{1}^{(i)} , then [z_{1},z_{2}]\in Z_{i\to i}+Z_{j\to j}+Z_{j\to l}+Z_{l\to j}+Z_{l\to l}\subseteq L_{0}^{(i)} by Lemma 10.7 (as we already observed in Proposition 10.16 Item 2 ). ∎ Lemma 10.19 . Let i\in\{1,2,3\} . Then [L_{0}^{(i)},L_{1}^{(i)}]\subseteq L_{1}^{(i)} . Proof. Let (i\,j\,l) denote the unique cyclic permutation of (1\,2\,3) starting from i . Let z_{1}\in L_{0}^{(i)} and z_{2}\in L_{1}^{(i)} . We will write z_{1}=(0,b_{ij}+b_{li},b_{ij}^{\prime}+b_{li}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}\quad\text{or}\quad z_{2}=(0,\mu_{i}e_{i},c^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm} if z_{1} or z_{2} , respectively, lies in L_{\pm 1} , where \mu_{i},\mu\in k , b_{ij}\in J_{ij} , b_{li}\in J_{li} , b_{ij}^{\prime}\in J_{ij}^{\prime} , b_{li}^{\prime}\in J_{li}^{\prime} and c^{\prime}\in ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime} . First assume that z_{1}\in\{x,y\} . If z_{2}=(0,\mu_{i}e_{i},c^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm}\in L_{\pm 1} , then [z_{1},z_{2}]\in\{0,(0,\mu_{i}e_{i},c^{\prime},\mu)_{\mp},-(0,\mu_{i}e_{i},c^{\prime},\mu)_{\mp}\}\subseteq L_{1}^{(i)} by Definition 4.22 . If z_{2}\in J_{ij}+J_{li} or z_{2}\in Z_{1}^{(i)} , we have [z_{1},z_{2}]=0 by Definition 4.7 or Proposition 4.12 , respectively. Second, we consider the case z_{1}\in L_{\pm 1} . We begin with the subcase z_{2}\in L_{\pm 1} . If z_{1} and z_{2} both lie in L_{1} , then by Definition 4.22 and Lemma 9.12 Item 3 , [z_{1},z_{2}]=\big(T(b_{ij}+b_{li},c^{\prime})-T(\mu_{i}e_{i},b_{ij}^{\prime}+b_{li}^{\prime})\big)x=(0-0)x=0. The same holds if z_{1},z_{2} both lie in L_{-1} . If z_{1}\in L_{-1} and z_{2}\in L_{1} , then Definition 4.22 gives us [z_{1},z_{2}]=(b_{ij}+b_{li})\times\mu_{i}e_{i}\\ \begin{aligned} &+\big(-T(b_{ij}+b_{li},c^{\prime})\zeta+T(\mu_{i}e_{i},b_{ij}^{\prime}+b_{li}^{\prime})(\xi-\zeta)+\mathbf{d}_{b_{ij}+b_{li},c^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{\mu_{i}e_{i},b_{ij}^{\prime}+b_{li}^{\prime}}\big)\\ &+\big(-\mu(b_{ij}+b_{li})+(b_{ij}^{\prime}+b_{li}^{\prime})\times c^{\prime}\big).\end{aligned} Now \displaystyle(b_{ij}+b_{li})\times\mu_{i}e_{i}=0\quad \displaystyle\text{and}\quad(b_{ij}^{\prime}+b_{li}^{\prime})\times c^{\prime}\in J_{ij}+J_{il}, \displaystyle T(b_{ij}+b_{li},c^{\prime})=0\quad \displaystyle\text{and}\quad T(\mu_{i}e_{i},b_{ij}^{\prime}+b_{li}^{\prime})=0, \displaystyle\mathbf{d}_{b_{ij}+b_{li},c^{\prime}}\in Z_{i\to j}+Z_{i\to l}\quad \displaystyle\text{and}\quad\mathbf{d}_{\mu_{i}e_{i},b_{ij}^{\prime}+b_{li}^{\prime}}\in Z_{i\to j}+Z_{i\to l}, by Lemma 9.14 , Lemma 9.12 Item 3 and Definition 10.1 , respectively, so [z_{1},z_{2}]\in L_{1}^{(i)} . The case z_{1}\in L_{1} and z_{2}\in L_{-1} is similar. We continue with the subcase z_{2}\in J_{ij}+J_{li} . By Definition 4.7 , \displaystyle[z_{1},z_{2}] \displaystyle=-[z_{2},(0,b_{ij}+b_{li},b_{ij}^{\prime}+b_{li}^{\prime},0)]=-\big(0,0,z_{2}\times(b_{ij}+b_{li}),T(z_{2},b_{ij}^{\prime}+b_{li}^{\prime})\big)_{\pm}, which is an element of L_{1}^{(i)} because z_{2}\times(b_{ij}+b_{li})\in J_{ll}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime}+J_{jj}^{\prime} by Lemma 9.14 . In the last subcase z_{2}\in Z_{1}^{(i)} , we have [z_{1},z_{2}]\in(0,J_{ii},J_{jj}^{\prime}+J_{ll}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime},0)_{\pm}\subseteq L_{1}^{(i)} by Lemma 10.6 Item 1 . Third, we turn to the case z_{1}\in ke_{j}+ke_{l}+J_{jl} , and we simultaneously consider the opposite case of an element z_{1}^{\prime}\in ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{jl} . If z_{2}\in L_{\pm 1} , then Definition 4.7 yields \displaystyle[z_{1},z_{2}] \displaystyle=\big(0,0,z_{1}\times\mu_{i}e_{i},T(z_{1},c^{\prime})\big)_{\pm},\quad[z_{1}^{\prime},z_{2}]=-\big(T(\mu_{i}e_{i},z_{1}^{\prime}),z_{1}^{\prime}\times c^{\prime},\mu z_{1}^{\prime},0\big)_{\pm} where z_{1}\times\mu_{i}e_{i}\in J_{ll}^{\prime}+J_{jj}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime} and z_{1}^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}\in J_{ii} by Lemma 9.14 and T(\mu_{i}e_{i},z_{1}^{\prime})=0 by Lemma 9.12 Item 3 . Hence [z_{1},z_{2}],[z_{1}^{\prime},z_{2}]\in L_{1}^{(i)} in this subcase. If z_{2}\in J_{ij}+J_{li} , then [z_{1},z_{2}]=0 because J is abelian and [z_{1}^{\prime},z_{2}]=\mathbf{d}_{z_{2},z_{1}^{\prime}}\in Z_{i\to j}+Z_{i\to l}\in L_{1}^{(i)} . If z_{2}\in Z_{1}^{(i)} , then it follows from Lemma 10.5 that [z_{1},z_{2}]\in J_{ij}+J_{il} and [z_{1}^{\prime},z_{2}]=0 . Finally, we assume that z_{1}\in Z_{0}^{(i)} . By Definition 4.1 Item 4 and Remark 4.11 , the assertion is satisfied for z_{1}\in\{\xi,\zeta\} , so we may assume that z_{1}\in Z_{i\to i}+Z_{j\to j}+Z_{l\to l}+Z_{j\to l}+Z_{l\to j}. If z_{2}\in L_{\pm 1} , then [z_{1},z_{2}]\in(0,ke_{i},ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime},k)_{\pm}\subseteq L_{1}^{(i)} by Lemma 10.6 . If z_{2}\in J_{ij}+J_{li} , then [z_{1},z_{2}]\in J_{ij}+J_{li} by Lemma 10.5 . In the final subcase z_{2}\in Z_{1}^{(i)} , we have [z_{1},z_{2}]\in Z_{1}^{(i)} by Lemma 10.7 (as we already observed in Proposition 10.16 Item 2 ). ∎ Lemma 10.20 . Let i\in\{1,2,3\} . Then [L_{0}^{(i)},L_{0}^{(i)}]\subseteq L_{0}^{(i)} . Proof. Let (i\,j\,l) denote the unique cyclic permutation of (1\,2\,3) starting from i . Let z_{1},z_{2}\in L_{0}^{(i)} . We will write z_{1}=(0,b,b^{\prime},0)_{\pm}\quad\text{or}\quad z_{2}=(0,c,c^{\prime},0)_{\pm} if z_{1} or z_{2} , respectively, lies in L_{\pm 1} , where b,c\in J_{ij}+J_{li} and b^{\prime},c^{\prime}\in J_{ij}^{\prime}+J_{li}^{\prime} . First, we consider the case z_{1}\in\{x,y\} . We have [x,x]=0=[y,y] and [x,y]=\xi by Definition 4.22 . By Definition 4.1 Item 4 and Definition 4.7 , we have [x,L_{0}]\leq kx and [y,L_{0}]\leq ky . This already covers the subcases z_{2}\in\{x,y\} and z_{2}\in L_{0} . For z_{2}\in L_{1} , we have [y,z_{2}]=0 and [x,z_{2}]=-(0,c,c^{\prime},0)_{-}\in L_{0}^{(i)} by Definition 4.22 . The subcase z_{2}\in L_{-1} is completely similar. Second, we assume that z_{1}\in L_{\pm 1} . We begin with the subcase z_{2}\in L_{\pm 1} . Definition 4.22 yields that [z_{1},z_{2}] lies in kx or ky if z_{1} , z_{2} are both in L_{1} or both in L_{-1} , and that \displaystyle[z_{1},z_{2}] \displaystyle=b\times c+\big(-T(b,c^{\prime})\zeta+T(c,b^{\prime})(\xi-\zeta)+\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}+\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\big)+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime} if z_{1}\in L_{-1} and z_{2}\in L_{1} . Now b\times c\in J_{jj}^{\prime}+J_{ll}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime} and b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}\in J_{jj}+J_{ll}+J_{jl} by Lemma 9.14 and \mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}},\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\in Z_{i\to i}+Z_{j\to l}+Z_{l\to j} by Definition 10.1 , so [z_{1},z_{2}]\in L_{0}^{(i)} . We now turn to the subcase z_{2}\in ke_{j}+ke_{l}+J_{jl} and we simultaneously consider the subcase z_{2}^{\prime}\in ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime} . By Definition 4.7 , \displaystyle[z_{1},z_{2}] \displaystyle=-\big(0,0,z_{2}\times b,T(z_{2},b^{\prime})\big)_{\pm},\quad[z_{1},z_{2}^{\prime}]=\big(T(b,z_{2}^{\prime}),z_{2}^{\prime}\times b^{\prime},0,0\big)_{\pm} where T(z_{2},b^{\prime})=0 , T(b,z_{2}^{\prime})=0 by Lemma 9.12 and z_{2}\times b\in J_{ij}^{\prime}+J_{il}^{\prime} , z_{2}^{\prime}\times b^{\prime}\in J_{ij}+J_{il} by Lemma 9.14 . Hence [z_{1},z_{2}]\in L_{0}^{(i)} . Finally, if z_{2}\in Z_{0}^{(i)} , then \ad_{z_{2}} leaves (0,J_{ij}+J_{li},J_{ij}^{\prime}+J_{li}^{\prime},0)_{\pm} invariant by Definitions 4.1 and 10.6 , so that [z_{1},z_{2}]\in L_{0}^{(i)} . Third, we consider the cases z_{1}\in ke_{j}+ke_{l}+J_{jl} and z_{1}^{\prime}\in ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime} . For z_{2}\in ke_{j}+ke_{l}+J_{jl} , we have [z_{1},z_{2}]=0 because J is abelian and [z_{1}^{\prime},z_{2}]=\mathbf{d}_{z_{2},z_{1}^{\prime}}\in Z_{j\to j}+Z_{j\to l}+Z_{l\to j}+Z_{l\to l}\subseteq L_{0}^{(i)}. If z_{2}\in Z_{0}^{(i)} , then \ad_{z_{2}} leaves ke_{j}+ke_{l}+J_{jl} and ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime} invariant by Remarks 4.11 and 10.5 , which implies [z_{1},z_{2}]\in L_{0}^{(i)} . Fourth, in the case z_{1}\in\{\xi,\zeta\} and z_{2}\in Z_{0}^{(i)} , we have [z_{1},z_{2}]=0 by Remark 4.11 . Finally, Z_{i\to i}+Z_{j\to j}+Z_{l\to l}+Z_{j\to l}+Z_{l\to j} is a Lie subalgebra of L by Lemma 10.7 , so [z_{1},z_{2}]\in L_{0}^{(i)} in each possible case. ∎ Proposition 10.21 . For each i\in\{1,2,3\} , the decomposition L=\bigoplus_{p=-2}^{2}L^{(i)}_{p} defines a 5 -grading of L . Proof. Denote the cyclic permutation of (1\,2\,3) starting with i by (i\,j\,l) . We have to check that [L^{(i)}_{p},L^{(i)}_{q}]\subseteq L^{(i)}_{p+q} for all possible pairs (p,q) with -2\leq p\leq q\leq 2 . This will, of course, require a case distinction. There is some obvious symmetry in the definitions, and the cases (-1,1) , (0,1) and (0,0) are already covered by Lemmas 10.18 , 10.19 and 10.20 , leaving us with the following 6 cases for (p,q) to check: \displaystyle(2,2), \displaystyle(1,2), \displaystyle(0,2), \displaystyle(-1,2), \displaystyle(-2,2) \displaystyle(1,1). Case (2,2) : This case is trivial because [e_{i},e_{i}]=0 . Case (1,2) : Let z\in L^{(i)}_{1} . We have to check that [z,e_{i}]=0 . If z\in L_{\pm 1} , this holds by Lemma 10.17 . If z\in J_{ij}+J_{li} , it holds because [J,J]=0 . Finally, if z\in Z_{i\to j}+Z_{i\to l} , it holds by Lemma 10.5 Item 1 with p=q=i . Case (0,2) : Let z\in L^{(i)}_{0} . In most cases, we have [z,e_{i}]=0 : By Definition 4.7 if z\in kx+ky ; by Lemma 10.17 if z\in L_{\pm 1} ; by Remark 10.2 if z\in ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime} ; by Remark 4.11 if z=\xi ; and finally, because of [J,J]=0 if z\in ke_{j}+ke_{l}+J_{jl} . If z\in Z_{i\to i}+Z_{j\to j}+Z_{l\to l}+Z_{j\to l}+Z_{l\to j} , then [z,e_{i}]\in ke_{i} by Lemma 10.5 . Finally, [\zeta,e_{i}]=e_{i} by Remark 4.11 , so [z,e_{i}]\in ke_{i}=L^{(i)}_{2} in all cases. Case (-1,2) : Let z\in L^{(i)}_{-1} . If z\in L_{\pm 1} , then [z,e_{i}]\in L_{1}^{(i)} by Lemma 10.17 . If z\in J_{ij}^{\prime}+J_{li}^{\prime} , then [z,e_{i}]=\mathbf{d}_{e_{i},z}\in Z_{ii,ij}+Z_{ii,il}\subseteq Z_{i\to j}+Z_{i\to l}=Z_{1}^{(i)}. Finally, in the case z\in Z^{(i)}_{-1}=Z_{j\to i}+Z_{l\to i} , we have [z,e_{i}]\in J_{ij}+J_{li}\subseteq L^{(i)}_{1} by Lemma 10.5 Item 1 . Case (-2,2) : This follows from the fact that [e_{i}^{\prime},e_{i}]=\mathbf{d}_{e_{i},e_{i}^{\prime}}\in Z_{i\to i}\leq L^{(i)}_{0} . Case (1,1) : Let z_{1},z_{2}\in L_{1}^{(i)} . We will write z_{1}=(0,\lambda_{i}e_{i},b^{\prime},\lambda)_{\pm}\quad\text{or}\quad z_{2}=(0,\mu_{i}e_{i},c^{\prime},\mu)_{\pm} if z_{1} or z_{2} , respectively, lies in L_{\pm 1} , where \lambda_{i},\lambda,\mu_{i},\mu\in k and b^{\prime},c^{\prime}\in ke_{j}^{\prime}+ke_{l}^{\prime}+J_{jl}^{\prime} . In the case z_{1},z_{2}\in L_{1} , we have [z_{1},z_{2}]=\big(T(\lambda_{i}e_{i},c^{\prime})-T(\mu_{i}e_{i},b^{\prime})\big)x=0 by Definition 4.22 and Lemma 9.12 Item 3 . The case z_{1},z_{2}\in L_{-1} is completely similar. If z_{1}\in J_{ij}+J_{li} and z_{2}\in L_{\pm 1} , then [z_{1},z_{2}]=\big(0,0,z_{1}\times\mu_{i}e_{i},T(z_{1},c^{\prime})\big)_{\pm}=0 by Definition 4.7 , Lemma 9.14 and Lemma 9.12 Item 3 . In the case z_{1}\in Z_{1}^{(i)} , z_{2}\in L_{\pm 1} , we have [z_{1},z_{2}]=0 by Lemma 10.6 Item 1 . Finally, assume that z_{1},z_{2}\in L_{0} . Since J and Z_{1}^{(i)} are abelian, the latter by Lemma 10.7 Item 1 , we may assume that z_{1}\in Z_{1}^{(i)} and z_{2}\in J_{ij}+J_{li} . Then [z_{1},z_{2}]\in J_{ii}=L_{2}^{(i)} by Lemma 10.5 Item 1 . ∎ We now obtain our promised F_{4} -grading. Remark 10.22 . Let e_{1},e_{2},e_{3},e_{4} denote the standard basis of \mathbb{Z}^{4} and put \displaystyle\Phi \displaystyle\coloneq\{\pm 2e_{i}\mid i\in\{1,2,3,4\}\}\sqcup\{\epsilon_{1}e_{i}+\epsilon_{2}e_{j}\mid i\neq j\in\{1,2,3,4\},\epsilon_{1},\epsilon_{2}\in\{\pm 1\}\} \displaystyle\qquad{}\sqcup\{\epsilon_{1}e_{1}+\epsilon_{2}e_{2}+\epsilon_{3}e_{3}+\epsilon_{4}e_{4}\mid\epsilon_{1},\ldots,\epsilon_{4}\in\{\pm 1\}\} and \Phi^{0}\coloneq\Phi\cup\{(0,0,0,0)\} . Further, let (\delta_{1},\ldots,\delta_{4}) be a standard system of simple roots in F_{4} (in the sense of Definition 1.9 ). Then there exists a unique group homomorphism \omega\colon\mathbb{Z}F_{4}\to\mathbb{Z}^{4} mapping \delta_{1}\mapsto(1,1,-1,-1),\quad\delta_{2}\mapsto(-2,0,0,0),\quad\delta_{3}\mapsto(1,-1,0,0),\quad\delta_{4}\mapsto(0,1,1,0). A straightforward computation shows that \omega(\Phi)=F_{4} . As we will now see in Theorem 10.23 , the set \Phi is the natural description of the root system F_{4} in our context. Notice that this description is dual to the one in [ 8 , VI.4.9] , but since F_{4} is a self-dual root system, this difference is irrelevant. We will occasionally identify F_{4}^{0} with the set \Phi^{0}\subseteq\mathbb{Z}^{4} to simplify notation, similarly as we did for G_{2} (see Remark 4.4 ). Theorem 10.23 . Let k be a commutative ring, let C be a multiplicative conic alternative algebra, let \Gamma\in k^{3} and let (J,J^{\prime}) be the cubic norm pair induced by the cubic Jordan matrix algebra \Her_{3}(C,\Gamma) . Let L=L(J,J^{\prime}) be the Lie algebra constructed in Section 4 , let \Phi,\Phi^{0}\subseteq\mathbb{Z}^{4} be as in Remark 10.22 and define L_{p}^{(i)} for all i\in\{1,2,3\} and p\in\{-2,-1,0,1,2\} as in Definition 10.15 . For all p,i,j,l\in\{-2,-1,0,1,2\} (in particular, for all (p,i,j,l)\in\Phi^{0} ), we put L_{pijl}\coloneq L_{p}\cap L_{i}^{(1)}\cap L_{j}^{(2)}\cap L_{l}^{(3)}. Then (L_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in\Phi^{0}} is an F_{4} -grading of L with L_{\alpha}\cong\begin{cases}(k,+)&\text{if }\alpha\text{ is long,}\\ (C,+)&\text{if }\alpha\text{ is short}\end{cases} for all \alpha\in F_{4} . Further, if J\neq 0\neq J^{\prime} , then \Phi^{0}=\{(p,i,j,l)\in\{-2,-1,0,1,2\}^{4}\mid L_{pijl}\neq 0\}. Proof. By examining the gradings introduced in Definition 10.15 , it is not difficult to compute their intersections. We have summarized the result in Fig. 3 , where we have written \overline{2}:=-2 and \overline{1}:=-1 to save some space, and where we have written J and J^{\prime} in their “matrix form” J=\begin{pmatrix}ke_{1}&J_{12}&J_{13}\\ &ke_{2}&J_{23}\\ &&ke_{3}\end{pmatrix},\qquad J^{\prime}=\begin{pmatrix}ke_{1}^{\prime}&J_{12}^{\prime}&J_{13}^{\prime}\\ &ke_{2}^{\prime}&J_{23}^{\prime}\\ &&ke_{3}^{\prime}\end{pmatrix}. The middle component Z decomposes into 7 parts: there are 6 components of the form Z_{i\to j} , which we denote as Z_{0p_{1}p_{2}p_{3}} with p_{i}=1 , p_{j}=-1 and the remaining p_{l}=0 ; the seventh component is Z_{0000}=Z_{1\to 1}+Z_{2\to 2}+Z_{3\to 3}+k\xi+k\zeta . It is now a simple observation that \Phi^{0} coincides with the set of index tuples (p,i,j,l) for which L_{pijl} is “generically non-trivial” , that is, non-zero except possibly in the degenerate case that J=0 or J^{\prime}=0 . Since each of the four gradings that we have used for the labelling is indeed a grading (by Propositions 4.27 and 10.21 ), this automatically implies that the resulting decomposition of the whole Lie algebra L is a \Phi -grading and hence an F_{4} -grading. ∎ \bar{2}000 \bar{1}111 \begin{matrix}\bar{1}\bar{1}11&\bar{1}001&\bar{1}010\\[2.15277pt] &\bar{1}1\bar{1}1&\bar{1}100\\[2.15277pt] &&\bar{1}11\bar{1}\end{matrix} \begin{matrix}\bar{1}1\bar{1}\bar{1}&\bar{1}00\bar{1}&\bar{1}0\bar{1}0\\[2.15277pt] &\bar{1}\bar{1}1\bar{1}&\bar{1}\bar{1}00\\[2.15277pt] &&\bar{1}\bar{1}\bar{1}1\end{matrix} \bar{1}\bar{1}\bar{1}\bar{1} \begin{matrix}0200&0110&0101\\[2.15277pt] &0020&0011\\[2.15277pt] &&0002\end{matrix} \begin{matrix}&01\bar{1}0&010\bar{1}\\[2.15277pt] 0\bar{1}10&\boxed{\mathbf{0000}}&001\bar{1}\\[2.15277pt] 0\bar{1}01&00\bar{1}1&\end{matrix} \begin{matrix}0\bar{2}00&0\bar{1}\bar{1}0&0\bar{1}0\bar{1}\\[2.15277pt] &00\bar{2}0&00\bar{1}\bar{1}\\[2.15277pt] &&000\bar{2}\end{matrix} 1111 \begin{matrix}1\bar{1}11&1001&1010\\[2.15277pt] &11\bar{1}1&1100\\[2.15277pt] &&111\bar{1}\end{matrix} \begin{matrix}11\bar{1}\bar{1}&100\bar{1}&10\bar{1}0\\[2.15277pt] &1\bar{1}1\bar{1}&1\bar{1}00\\[2.15277pt] &&1\bar{1}\bar{1}1\end{matrix} 1\bar{1}\bar{1}\bar{1} 2000 Figure 3. Intersecting the four gradings Remark 10.24 . As in Remarks 4.4 and 10.22 , we identify G_{2}^{0} and F_{4}^{0} with subsets of \mathbb{Z}^{2} and \mathbb{Z}^{4} , respectively, and we consider the systems of simple roots \displaystyle g_{1}=(1,0),\qquad g_{2}=(-2,-1)\in G_{2}, \displaystyle f_{1}=(1,1,-1,-1),\quad f_{2}=(-2,0,0,0),\quad f_{3}=(1,-1,0,0),\quad f_{4}=(0,1,1,0)\in F_{4}. Then the map \pi\colon F_{4}^{0}\to G_{2}^{0} from Lemma 8.4 (defined with respect to the systems (f_{1},f_{2},f_{3},f_{4}) and (g_{1},g_{2}) of simple roots) is described by Fig. 3 : For any \alpha\in F_{4}^{0} , \pi(\alpha) is given by the coordinates in the \mathbb{Z}^{2} -grid of the rectangular block in which \alpha is contained. This implies that the G_{2} -graded constructed from the F_{4} -grading (L_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}^{0}} as in Proposition 8.10 is precisely the G_{2} -grading (L_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}^{0}} from Proposition 4.28 . Note that we can also describe \pi by the formula \pi\big((p,i,j,l)\big)=\left(p,\,\frac{p+i+j+l}{2}\right) for all (p,i,j,l)\in F_{4} . Remark 10.25 (cf. 8.8 ) . Keep the notation of Remark 10.24 and let \beta\in G_{2} be short. Then by Lemma 8.7 Item 4 , the preimage C_{\beta}\coloneq\pi^{-1}(\{\beta,-\beta,0\})=C_{-\beta} is a subsystem of F_{4} of type C_{3} . Thus L^{\prime}\coloneq\bigoplus_{\alpha\in C_{\beta}}L_{\alpha} is a C_{3} -graded subalgebra of L . Specifically, the three possibilities for L^{\prime} are L_{-1,0}\oplus L_{0,0}\oplus L_{1,0},\quad L_{-1,-1}\oplus L_{0,0}\oplus L_{1,1},\quad L_{0,-1}\oplus L_{0,0}\oplus L_{0,1}. 10.3. A Chevalley-type basis of the Lie algebra By specializing the commutator formulas in Table 1 to the case that J is a cubic Jordan matrix algebra, we obtain commutator formulas for the F_{4} -graded Lie algebra from Theorem 10.23 . For example, [(0,c[12],0,0)_{-},(0,0,d[12]^{\iota},0)_{-}]=T(c[12],d[12]^{\iota})x=\gamma_{1}\gamma_{2}t(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mud) for all c,d\in C by Lemma 9.12 Item 2 . It is not surprising that the constants \gamma_{1} , \gamma_{2} , \gamma_{3} may appear in these formulas because the structural maps of (J,J^{\prime}) depend on them. However, we have already observed in Remark 9.8 that the isomorphism type of the Lie algebra L(J,J^{\prime}) does not depend on \gamma_{1},\gamma_{2},\gamma_{3} as long as they are assumed to be invertible. Hence one should expect that, under this assumption, there exists a family (\vartheta_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} of root homomorphisms (each with domain k or C and codomain L_{\alpha} ) such that the commutator relations with respect to this family do not involve \gamma_{1} , \gamma_{2} , \gamma_{3} . The goal of this subsection is precisely to find such a family of root homomorphisms. We construct this family by multiplying the “natural” root homomorphisms in L by appropriate products of \gamma_{1} , \gamma_{2} , \gamma_{3} and their inverses. We will also observe that the elements (\vartheta_{\alpha}(1))_{\alpha\in F_{4}} defined by our root homomorphisms share several crucial properties with Chevalley bases of complex semisimple Lie algebras. To achieve this, some root homomorphisms will have to be multiplied not only with a product of \gamma_{1} , \gamma_{2} , \gamma_{3} and their inverses, but with -1 as well. An immediate consequence of the existence of a “Chevalley-type basis” is that if C is faithful as a k -algebra, then L contains a copy of the split Chevalley Lie algebra of type F_{4} over k as a subalgebra, which implies that L is F_{4} -graded in the stronger sense of [ 6 ] . See Remarks 1.3 and 10.34 for details. In Section 11 , we will “exponentiate” the root homomorphisms from this subsection to obtain root homomorphisms in the corresponding group of automorphisms of L(J,J^{\prime}) (which will then proven to be F_{4} -graded as well). Consequently, the commutator formulas in this F_{4} -graded group will not involve \gamma_{1},\gamma_{2},\gamma_{3} either (see Proposition 11.13 ). This aligns with the fact that in the coordinatization theorem for arbitrary F_{4} -graded groups ( Theorem 1.15 ), the algebraic data coordinatising the group involves only a commutative ring and a multiplicative conic alternative algebra but no choice of constants in the commutative ring. Further, using a Chevalley-type basis has benefits concerning the description of Weyl elements in the automorphism group, which will become apparent in Remark 11.6 . Notation 10.26 . From now on, we assume that \gamma_{1},\gamma_{2},\gamma_{3} are invertible. In the following, we will always use the convention from Remarks 4.4 and 10.22 to identify G_{2}^{0} and F_{4}^{0} with subsets of \mathbb{Z}^{2} and \mathbb{Z}^{4} , respectively. We will sometimes use the convention from Fig. 3 to write, e.g., 11\bar{1}\bar{1} as an abbreviation of (1,1,-1,-1) . Further, we denote by \pi\colon F_{4}^{0}\to G_{2}^{0} the map defined in Remark 10.24 , so that L_{\alpha}\leq L_{\pi(\alpha)_{1}}\cap L_{\pi(\alpha)_{2}} for all \alpha\in F_{4}^{0} . Finally, for all \alpha\in F_{4} , we put P_{\alpha}\coloneq k if \alpha is long and P_{\alpha}\coloneq C if \alpha is short, so that L_{\alpha}\cong P_{\alpha} as k -modules. We begin by defining the root homomorphisms (\vartheta_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} . It turns out that they can be constructed step by step: We first define root homomorphisms in J and J^{\prime} , then root homomorphisms in (k,J,J^{\prime})\cong L_{\pm 1} and then root homomorphisms in L . Note that the root homomorphisms in J^{\prime} are defined in a different way than those in J even though J\cong J^{\prime} . Definition 10.27 (Root homomorphisms in J and J^{\prime} ) . For any cyclic permutation (i\,j\,l) of (1\,2\,3) , we define homomorphisms \displaystyle\vartheta_{l}^{+}\colon(k,+)\to J \displaystyle\colon t\mapsto\gamma_{i}^{-1}\gamma_{j}te_{l}, \displaystyle\vartheta_{l}^{-}\colon(k,+)\to J^{\prime} \displaystyle\colon t\mapsto\gamma_{i}\gamma_{j}^{-1}te_{l}^{\prime}, \displaystyle\vartheta_{l}^{+}\colon(C,+)\to J \displaystyle\colon a\mapsto\gamma_{j}^{-1}a[ij], \displaystyle\vartheta_{l}^{-}\colon(C,+)\to J^{\prime} \displaystyle\colon a\mapsto\gamma_{i}^{-1}a[ij]. Note that we use the same name for the maps defined on k as for the maps defined on C , but there will be no danger of confusion in the sequel. Definition 10.28 (Root homomorphisms in (k,J,J^{\prime},k) ) . Let p_{1},p_{2},p_{3}\in\{-1,0,1\} with (1,p_{1},p_{2},p_{3})\in F_{4} (or equivalently, (-1,p_{1},p_{2},p_{3})\in F_{4} ) and put s\coloneq p_{1}+p_{2}+p_{3} . We define a homomorphism \vartheta_{p_{1}p_{2}p_{3}} as follows: (1) If s=-3 , define \vartheta_{p_{1}p_{2}p_{3}}\colon k\to(k,J,J^{\prime},k)\colon t\mapsto(t,0,0,0) . (2) If s=-1 , then there is a unique cyclic permutation (i\,j\,l) of (1\,2\,3) with p_{l}\neq p_{i}=p_{j} , and we define \vartheta_{p_{1}p_{2}p_{3}}\colon P_{(1,p_{1},p_{2},p_{3})}=P_{(-1,p_{1},p_{2},p_{3})}\to(k,J,J^{\prime},k)\colon a\mapsto(0,\vartheta_{l}^{+}(a),0,0) (3) If s=1 , then there is a unique cyclic permutation (i\,j\,l) of (1\,2\,3) with p_{l}\neq p_{i}=p_{j} , and we define \vartheta_{p_{1}p_{2}p_{3}}\colon P_{(1,p_{1},p_{2},p_{3})}=P_{(-1,p_{1},p_{2},p_{3})}\to(k,J,J^{\prime},k)\colon a\mapsto(0,0,\vartheta_{l}^{-}(a),0) (4) If s=3 , define \vartheta_{p_{1}p_{2}p_{3}}\colon k\to(k,J,J^{\prime},k)\colon t\mapsto(0,0,0,t) . Definition 10.29 (Root homomorphisms in L ) . Let \alpha=(p_{0},p_{1},p_{2},p_{3})\in F_{4} and put \mathcal{S}\coloneq\mathcal{S}^{\text{sh}}\cup\mathcal{S}^{\text{lo}} where \displaystyle\mathcal{S}^{\text{lo}} \displaystyle\coloneq\{\alpha\in F_{4}\mid\alpha\text{ is long}\}\setminus\{\bar{1}\bar{1}\bar{1}1,11\bar{1}1,1\bar{1}11,\bar{1}111\} \displaystyle\mathcal{S}^{\text{sh}} \displaystyle\coloneq\{10\bar{1}0,0101,0011,0\bar{1}\bar{1}0,\bar{1}100,\bar{1}001\}. We first define an auxiliary map \bar{\vartheta}_{\alpha}\colon P_{\alpha}\to L as follows. (1) If \pi(\alpha)_{1}=-2 , define \bar{\vartheta}_{\alpha}\colon k\to L\colon t\mapsto tx . (2) If \pi(\alpha)_{1}=\varepsilon 1 for \varepsilon\in\{\mathord{+},\mathord{-}\} , define \bar{\vartheta}_{\alpha}\colon P_{\alpha}\to L\colon a\mapsto\vartheta_{p_{1}p_{2}p_{3}}(a)_{\varepsilon} . (3) If \pi(\alpha)=(0,\varepsilon 1) for \varepsilon\in\{\mathord{+},\mathord{-1}\} , define \bar{\vartheta}_{\alpha}\colon P_{\alpha}\to L\colon a\mapsto\vartheta_{l}^{\varepsilon}(a)\in J+J^{\prime}\leq L_{0} where l\in\{1,2,3\} is the unique index with |p_{l}|=2 if \alpha is long and p_{l}=0 if \alpha is short. (4) If \pi(\alpha)=(0,0) , then there exist unique i,j,l\in\{1,2,3\} with p_{i}=1 , p_{j}=-1 , p_{l}=0 and we define (30) \bar{\vartheta}_{\alpha}\colon C\to L\colon a\mapsto\begin{cases}\lambda_{ij}\mathbf{d}_{e_{i},a[ij]}&\text{if }ij\end{cases} where \displaystyle\lambda_{12} \displaystyle\coloneq\gamma_{1}^{-1}\gamma_{2}^{-1}\gamma_{3}, \displaystyle\lambda_{13} \displaystyle\coloneq\gamma_{2}^{-1}, \displaystyle\lambda_{23} \displaystyle\coloneq\gamma_{1}\gamma_{2}^{-1}\gamma_{3}^{-1}, \displaystyle\lambda_{21} \displaystyle\coloneq\gamma_{3}^{-1}, \displaystyle\lambda_{31} \displaystyle\coloneq\gamma_{1}^{-1}\gamma_{2}\gamma_{3}^{-1}, \displaystyle\lambda_{32} \displaystyle\coloneq\gamma_{1}^{-1}. (5) If \pi(\alpha)_{1}=2 , define \bar{\vartheta}_{\alpha}\colon k\to L\colon t\mapsto ty . Further, the root homomorphism in L with respect to \alpha is \vartheta_{\alpha}\colon P_{\alpha}\to L\colon a\mapsto\begin{cases}\bar{\vartheta}_{\alpha}(a)&\text{if }\alpha\notin\mathcal{S},\\ \bar{\vartheta}_{\alpha}(-a)&\text{if }\alpha\in\mathcal{S}.\end{cases} The reason to use the case distinction in Eq. 30 will only become apparent at a later point, see Remark 11.12 . The following definition is motivated by the classical notion of Chevalley bases in complex semisimple Lie algebras. See, for example, [ 18 , 25.2] . Definition 10.30 . (1) Recall from Definition 4.1 that M denotes the Lie algebra \bigoplus_{i\neq 0}\mathfrak{gl}(L_{i}) which contains L_{0} . For all \alpha\in F_{4} , we denote by h_{\alpha} the element of M which is defined by [h_{\alpha},y_{\beta}]=\langle\beta|\alpha\rangle y_{\beta} for all y_{\beta}\in L_{\beta} and all \beta\in F_{4} with \pi(\beta)_{1}\neq 0 . Here \langle\beta|\alpha\rangle\coloneq 2\frac{\beta\cdot\alpha}{\alpha\cdot\alpha} denotes the Cartan integer. (2) A Chevalley-type basis of L is a family (x_{\alpha}\in L_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} with the following properties: (a) For all \alpha\in F_{4} , we have [x_{\alpha},x_{-\alpha}]=h_{\alpha} . (b) For all \alpha,\beta\in F_{4} with \alpha+\beta\in F_{4} , there exists c_{\alpha,\beta}\in\mathbb{Z} such that [x_{\alpha},x_{\beta}]=c_{\alpha,\beta}x_{\alpha+\beta} . (c) It is possible to choose the constants c_{\alpha,\beta} above so that for all \alpha,\beta\in F_{4} with \alpha+\beta\in F_{4} , we have c_{\alpha,\beta}=-c_{-\alpha,-\beta} . A family of integers c_{\alpha,\beta} for \alpha,\beta\in F_{4} with \alpha+\beta\in F_{4} which satisfies the properties above is said to be conforming to (x_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} . Remark 10.31 . (1) Note that a Chevalley-type basis (x_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} of L is not actually a basis of the k -module L : Its k -linear span intersects L_{0000} trivially and for any short root \alpha\in F_{4} , the k -span of x_{\alpha} is, in general, a proper submodule of L_{\alpha}\cong C . (2) Let L^{\prime} be a complex semisimple Lie algebra, let H denote a maximal toral subalgebra of L^{\prime} , let \kappa denote the Killing form on L^{\prime} , let \Phi\subseteq H^{*} denote the root system of L^{\prime} and let h_{\alpha},t_{\alpha}\in L^{\prime} for \alpha\in\Phi be defined as in [ 18 , 8.2, 8.3] . Then for all \alpha,\beta\in\Phi and all y_{\beta} in the \beta -root space L^{\prime}_{\beta} , we have [h_{\alpha},y_{\beta}]=\frac{2}{\kappa(t_{\alpha},t_{\alpha})}[t_{\alpha},y_{\beta}]=\frac{2}{\kappa(t_{\alpha},t_{\alpha})}\beta(t_{\alpha})y_{\beta}=2\frac{\kappa(t_{\beta},t_{\alpha})}{\kappa(t_{\alpha},t_{\alpha})}y_{\beta}=\langle\beta|\alpha\rangle y_{\beta}. Hence the elements h_{\alpha} in the classical theory have the same property as in Definition 10.30 Item 1 . In fact, they are the unique elements of H with this property because H acts faithfully on L^{\prime} . (3) The numbers c_{\alpha,\beta} in Definition 10.30 Item 2 are not uniquely determined in general because L may not be faithful as a \mathbb{Z} -module. For example, this is the case if k is a field of positive characteristic. Even the image of c_{\alpha,\beta} in k need not be uniquely determined because C (and hence L_{\gamma} for all short \gamma\in F_{4} ) need not be faithful as a k -module. Remark 10.32 . Let \alpha,\beta\in F_{4} such that \alpha+\beta\in F_{4} . If \beta and \alpha+\beta are long, then \alpha is long as well. If \beta is long and \alpha+\beta is short, then \alpha must be short. It follows that, unless \alpha,\beta are short and \alpha+\beta is long, we always have a multiplication map P_{\alpha}\times P_{\beta}\to P_{\alpha+\beta} which is one of the maps k\times k\to k , C\times C\to C , k\times C\to C . In the situation that \alpha,\beta are short and \alpha+\beta is long (so that P_{\alpha}=P_{\beta}=C and P_{\alpha+\beta}=k ), however, the multiplication defined on P_{\alpha}\times P_{\beta}=C\times C has image in C and not in k=P_{\alpha+\beta} . We can now state the crucial property of the root homomorphisms (\vartheta_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} . We find not only that the commutator formulas in L are independent of \gamma_{1},\gamma_{2},\gamma_{3} but also that all commutator formulas look the same up to possibly “twisting” the short root spaces by the conjugation \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mu\>\cdot\>\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu of C . This is the same kind of “twisting” that we have already seen in Definition 1.10 . Proposition 10.33 . There exists a unique family c=(c_{\alpha,\beta})_{\alpha,\beta\in F_{4},\alpha+\beta\in F_{4}} of integers in \{-2,\ldots,2\} such that for all commutative rings k , all multiplicative conic alternative k -algebras C and all invertible \Gamma=(\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2},\gamma_{3})\in\Mat_{3}(k) , the following hold: (1) Let \alpha,\beta\in F_{4} such that \alpha+\beta\in F_{4} . For each \gamma\in F_{4} , put T_{\gamma}\coloneq\{\id_{C},\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mu\>\cdot\>\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\}\leq\Aut(P_{\gamma}) if \gamma is short and T_{\gamma}\coloneq\{\id_{k}\}\leq\Aut(P_{\gamma}) if \gamma is long. If \alpha,\beta are short and \alpha+\beta is long, then c_{\alpha,\beta} is even and there exists \mathord{*}\in T_{\alpha}=\{\id_{C},\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mu\>\cdot\>\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\} such that the following commutator relation is satisfied for all c,d\in C : \bigl[\vartheta_{\alpha}(c),\vartheta_{\beta}(d)\bigr]=\vartheta_{\alpha+\beta}\big(c_{\alpha,\beta}/2\cdot t(c^{*}d)\big). Otherwise, there exist \mathord{*}\in T_{\alpha} , \mathord{\star}\in T_{\beta} and \sigma\in T_{\alpha+\beta} such that the following commutator relation is satisfied for all c\in P_{\alpha} , d\in P_{\beta} : \bigl[\vartheta_{\alpha}(c),\vartheta_{\beta}(d)\bigr]=\vartheta_{\alpha+\beta}\big(c_{\alpha,\beta}(c^{*}\cdot d^{\star})^{\sigma}\big). (Here c\cdot d\in P_{\alpha+\beta} by Remark 10.32 .) (2) The family (\vartheta_{\alpha}(1))_{\alpha\in F_{4}} (where “ 1 ” should be read as 1_{k} or as 1_{C} , depending on \alpha ) is a Chevalley-type basis of L to which c conforms. Further, for all \alpha\in F_{4} , the element h_{\alpha} lies in L_{0} and satisfies [h_{\alpha},y_{\beta}]=\langle\beta|\alpha\rangle y_{\beta} for all y_{\beta}\in L_{\beta} and all \beta\in F_{4} . Proof. A computer calculation (see Section 9.3 ) shows that for all \alpha,\beta\in F_{4} such that \alpha+\beta\in F_{4} , there exists c_{\alpha,\beta}\in\{-2,\ldots,2\} such that [\vartheta_{\alpha}(1),\vartheta_{\beta}(1)]=\vartheta_{\alpha+\beta}(c_{\alpha,\beta}) for all possible choices of k , C , \Gamma . In particular, the validity of this equation for k=C=\mathbb{C} (or any field of characteristic 0 ) shows that the family c is uniquely determined by this property (because then L is free as a \mathbb{Z} -module). A further computation shows that [[x_{\alpha},x_{-\alpha}],y_{\beta}]=\langle\beta|\alpha\rangle y_{\beta} for all \alpha,\beta\in F_{4} and y_{\beta}\in L_{\beta} . This implies that h_{\alpha}=[x_{\alpha},x_{-\alpha}]\in[L_{\alpha},L_{-\alpha}]\subseteq L_{0} for all \alpha\in L . The remaining assertions also follow from a computation. ∎ Remark 10.34 . Recall from Remark 1.3 the stronger notion of root graded Lie algebras from [ 6 ] . It follows from the existence of a Chevalley-type basis in L that L is F_{4} -graded in this stronger sense if C is faithful as a k -algebra. This additional condition, which by [ 17 , 11.14] is always satisfied if 2 is invertible in k , is need to ensure that the k -submodule kx_{\alpha} for a short root \alpha\in F_{4} is isomorphic to k and not to a quotient of k . Since an arbitrary cubic norm pair (\bar{J},\bar{J}^{\prime}) need not contain a distinguished base point, there is no evident way to define a Chevalley-type basis (in the sense of Definition 10.30 , but with F_{4} replaced by G_{2} ) of the corresponding Lie algebra L(\bar{J},\bar{J}^{\prime}) . Hence there is no reason to think that L(\bar{J},\bar{J}^{\prime}) is always G_{2} -graded in the stronger sense. However, assume now that (\bar{J},\bar{J}) is (induced by) a cubic norm structure and that its distinguished base point 1_{\bar{J}} is unimodular (see Remark 2.5 Item 2 ). Denote by (\vartheta_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}} the root homomorphisms in L(\bar{J},\bar{J}) from Definition 6.4 . For all roots \alpha,\beta\in G_{2} where \alpha is long and \beta is short, put \displaystyle\mathcal{S}_{1} \displaystyle\coloneq\{(-2,-1),(-1,-2)\}, \displaystyle\mathcal{S}_{2} \displaystyle\coloneq\{(-1,0),(0,-1)\}, \displaystyle x_{\alpha} \displaystyle\coloneq\begin{cases}\vartheta_{\alpha}(-1_{k})&\text{if }\alpha\in\mathcal{S}_{1},\\ \vartheta_{\alpha}(1_{k})&\text{otherwise,}\end{cases} \displaystyle x_{\beta} \displaystyle\coloneq\begin{cases}\vartheta_{\beta}(-1_{\bar{J}})&\text{if }\alpha\in\mathcal{S}_{2},\\ \vartheta_{\beta}(1_{\bar{J}})&\text{otherwise,}\end{cases} Using that T(1_{\bar{J}},1_{\bar{J}})=3_{k} and D(1_{\bar{J}},1_{\bar{J}})=2\id_{\bar{J}} , one can show that (x_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}} is a Chevalley-type basis of L(\bar{J},\bar{J}) of type G_{2} . Indeed, it is straightforward to see that there exist unique integers c_{\alpha,\beta} for all \alpha,\beta\in G_{2} with \alpha+\beta\in G_{2} and unique integers d_{\alpha,\beta} for all \alpha,\beta\in G_{2} such that for all cubic norm structures (\bar{J},\bar{J}) , we have [x_{\alpha},x_{\beta}]=c_{\alpha,\beta}x_{\alpha+\beta} and [[x_{\alpha},x_{-\alpha}],y_{\beta}]=d_{\alpha,\beta}y_{\beta} . Proving that (x_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}} is a Chevalley-type basis reduces to proving that these integers satisfy certain properties, so it suffices to show that it is a Chevalley-type basis for some cubic norm structure that is free as a \mathbb{Z} -module. This can be done for cubic Jordan matrix algebras with the strategy outlined in Section 9.3 . 11. Refining the G_{2} -grading of the automorphism group We keep up the notation from Section 10 , including 10.26 . By Theorem 7.24 , we have a G_{2} -grading (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}} in the automorphism group of the Lie algebra L=L(J,J^{\prime}) where J=J^{\prime}=\Her_{3}(C,\Gamma) is a cubic Jordan matrix algebra over the conic k -algebra (C,n) . We put G\coloneq\langle U_{\alpha}\mid\alpha\in G_{2}\rangle\leq\Aut(L) . Our goal is to refine (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}} to an F_{4} -grading (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} of G , using the F_{4} -grading of L(J,J^{\prime}) constructed in Section 10 . The system (f_{1},f_{2},f_{3},f_{4}) of simple roots in F_{4} that induces the map \pi\colon F_{4}^{0}\to G_{2}^{0} (see Remark 10.24 ) is impractical to work with because it contains two simple roots that map to zero. Instead, we will consider the following system of simple roots, which in addition has the property that three of its elements map to the positive system in G_{2} for which we have determined the commutator relations in Proposition 7.23 . Notation 11.1 . We denote by \Delta_{F}=(\delta_{1},\delta_{2},\delta_{3},\delta_{4}) the standard system of simple roots in F_{4} given by \delta_{1}=11\bar{1}\bar{1},\quad\delta_{2}=\bar{2}000,\quad\delta_{3}\coloneq 1\bar{1}00,\quad\delta_{4}\coloneq 0110. Further, we denote by T\coloneq\{\pm 1\}\times\{\pm 1\} the twisting group of (k,C) , which acts on k and C (see Definition 1.10 ). For roots \alpha\in F_{4} with \pi(\alpha)\neq(0,0) , we can define root homomorphisms in \Aut(L) by exponentiating the root homomorphisms in L from Section 10.3 . Definition 11.2 . Let \alpha\in F_{4} such that \pi(\alpha)\neq(0,0) and let \vartheta_{\alpha}\colon P_{\alpha}\to L_{\alpha}\leq L_{\pi(\alpha)} denote the root homomorphism from Definition 10.29 . Then the root homomorphism in G with respect to \alpha is \theta_{\alpha}\colon P_{\alpha}\to G\colon a\mapsto\exp_{\pi(\alpha)}\big(\vartheta_{\alpha}(a)\big) where \exp_{\pi(\alpha)}\colon L_{\pi(\alpha)}\to\Aut(L) is the \pi(\alpha) -parametrization (in the G_{2} -graded Lie algebra L ) from Proposition 7.20 . Further, the root group associated to \alpha is U_{\alpha}\coloneq\theta_{\alpha}(P_{\alpha}) . For the remaining six roots that map to 0 in G_{2} , we define the corresponding root homomorphisms by conjugating root homomorphisms from Definition 11.2 by appropriate reflections. Definition 11.3 . For all \alpha\in F_{4} such that \pi(\alpha)\neq(0,0) , we define w_{\alpha}\coloneq\theta_{-\alpha}(-1_{\alpha})\theta_{\alpha}(1_{\alpha})\theta_{-\alpha}(-1_{\alpha})\in G\leq\Aut(L) where 1_{\alpha}=1_{k} if \alpha is long and 1_{\alpha}=1_{C} if \alpha is short. Lemma 11.4 . For all \alpha\in F_{4} such that \pi(\alpha)\neq(0,0) , the element w_{\alpha}\in\Aut(L) is an \alpha -reflection. Proof. For all \alpha,\beta\in F_{4} , we have to show that w_{\alpha}(L_{\beta})=L_{\beta^{\sigma(\alpha)}} . We have verified these 48\cdot 48 assertions on a computer. See Section 9.3 for details. ∎ Remark 11.5 . We will only need the statement of Lemma 11.4 for \alpha\in\{\delta_{1},\delta_{4}\} . Remark 11.6 . Let \alpha\in F_{4} with \pi(\alpha)\neq(0,0) . While the root group U_{\alpha}=\exp_{\pi(\alpha)}(L_{\alpha}) does not depend on the choice of the root homomorphism \vartheta_{\alpha}\colon P_{\alpha}\to L_{\alpha} in L , the root homomorphism \theta_{\alpha}\colon P_{\alpha}\to U_{\alpha} in G does. In fact, the “twisting” of the \vartheta_{\alpha} by products of \gamma_{1} , \gamma_{2} , \gamma_{3} , -1 in Definition 10.29 is precisely what ensures that w_{\alpha} is indeed a reflection. If we had chosen a different map \tilde{\vartheta}_{\alpha}\colon P_{\alpha}\to L_{\alpha} and defined \tilde{\theta}_{\alpha}\colon P_{\alpha}\to G\colon a\mapsto\exp_{\pi(\alpha)}(\tilde{\vartheta}_{\alpha}(a)) accordingly, then the desired reflections might, for example, have the form w_{\alpha}=\tilde{\theta}_{-\alpha}(1_{\alpha})\tilde{\theta}_{\alpha}(1_{\alpha})\tilde{\theta}_{-\alpha}(1_{\alpha}) (as in Lemma B.6 for the G_{2} -grading). Even worse, their expression in terms of \tilde{\theta}_{\alpha} , \tilde{\theta}_{-\alpha} may involve the structure constants \gamma_{1},\gamma_{2},\gamma_{3} . It is this obstruction that originally prompted our search for a Chevalley-type basis of L . Remark 11.7 . Each of the six roots \alpha\in F_{4} with \pi(\alpha)=(0,0) can be expressed as \alpha=\beta^{\sigma(\delta_{i})} for some i\in\{1,4\} and some \beta\in F_{4} with \pi(\alpha)\neq(0,0) . Explicitly, we may choose \beta and i as in Table 2 . \alpha 01\bar{1}0 0\bar{1}10 010\bar{1} 0\bar{1}01 001\bar{1} 00\bar{1}1 \beta \bar{1}001 100\bar{1} \bar{1}010 10\bar{1}0 0\bar{1}0\bar{1} 0101 i 1 1 1 1 4 4 \eta_{\alpha} (-1,1) (-1,1) (1,-1) (1,-1) (1,-1) (1,-1) Table 2. The choice of \beta and i in Remark 11.7 , in dependence of \alpha Hence for each such \alpha , it follows from Lemmas 7.3 and 11.4 that \exp_{\alpha}\colon L_{\alpha}\to\Aut(L)\colon b\mapsto w_{i}^{-1}\circ\exp_{\beta}\big(w_{i}(b)\big)\circ w_{i} is an \alpha -parametrization where \beta\in F_{4} and i\in\{1,4\} are chosen as in Table 2 (in dependence of \alpha ) and w_{i}\coloneq w_{\delta_{i}} . Hence we may define \theta_{\alpha}\colon C\to\Aut(L)\colon a\mapsto\exp_{\alpha}\big(\vartheta_{\alpha}(a)\big)=w_{i}^{-1}\circ\exp_{\beta}\big(w_{i}(\vartheta_{\alpha}(a))\big)\circ w_{i}. Further, a computer calculation (see Section 9.3 ) shows that w_{i}(\vartheta_{\alpha}(a))=\vartheta_{\beta}(\eta_{\alpha}.a) for all a\in C where \eta_{\alpha}\in T is given by the last row in Table 2 . Definition 11.8 . Let \alpha\in F_{4} with \pi(\alpha)=(0,0) . Then the map \theta_{\alpha}\colon C\to\Aut(L) from Remark 11.7 (with \beta and i chosen as in Table 2 ) is called the root homomorphism with respect to \alpha , and its image U_{\alpha} is called the root group associated to \alpha . Remark 11.9 . For all \alpha\in F_{4} with \pi(\alpha)=(0,0) , we have that w_{i} and U_{\beta} are contained in G , the group generated by (U_{\gamma})_{\gamma\in G_{2}} . Hence the group generated by (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} is exactly G (and not a bigger group). Having defined all root homomorphisms (\theta_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} , we now verify that (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} satisfies the axioms of an F_{4} -grading of G . We begin with the existence of Weyl elements. Notation 11.10 (cf. 1.14 ) . We denote by \eta^{\text{e}}\colon F_{4}\times\Delta_{F}\to T the \Delta_{F} -parity map with values in T (in the sense of Definition 1.11 ) that is given by the values in Table 3 . Note that the definition of \eta^{\text{e}} does not involve the actions of T on k and C , so \eta^{\text{e}} is independent of k , C and \Gamma . Proposition 11.11 . For all \delta\in\Delta_{F} , \alpha\in F_{4} and a\in P_{\alpha} , we have (31) w_{\delta}^{-1}\circ\theta_{\alpha}(a)\circ w_{\delta}=\theta_{\alpha^{\sigma(\delta)}}(\eta^{\text{e}}_{\alpha,\delta}.a). In particular, w_{\delta} is a \delta -Weyl element with respect to (U_{\beta})_{\beta\in F_{4}} , (\theta_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} is a parametrization of (U_{\beta})_{\beta\in F_{4}} by (k,C) with respect to (w_{\delta})_{\delta\in\Delta_{F}} and \eta^{\text{e}} (in the sense of Definition 1.12 ) and (U_{\beta})_{\beta\in F_{4}} satisfies Axiom 1.5 Item 3 . Proof. The first assertion is a straightforward computation, but a very long one: For all \alpha\in F_{4} and for arbitrary a\in P_{\alpha} , we have to compute the action of w_{\delta}^{-1}\circ\theta_{\alpha}(a)\circ w_{\delta} and \theta_{\alpha^{\sigma(\delta)}}(\eta^{\text{e}}_{\alpha,\delta}.a) on a generating set of L (such as L_{-2}\cup L_{1} , which is spanned by 15 F_{4} -root spaces) and show that the resulting expressions are identical. (This procedure is precisely how we obtained the values of \eta^{\text{e}} .) We have performed these calculations on a computer (see Section 9.3 for details). By the definition of the root groups, we infer that w_{\delta} is a \delta -Weyl element. Since \Delta_{F} is a system of simple roots, it follows from Remark 1.8 that Axiom 1.5 Item 3 is satisfied. ∎ \alpha \eta^{\text{e}}(\alpha,\delta_{1}) \eta^{\text{e}}(\alpha,\delta_{2}) \eta^{\text{e}}(\alpha,\delta_{3}) \eta^{\text{e}}(\alpha,\delta_{4}) 1000 (-1,1) (1,1) (1,1) (1,1) 0100 (-1,1) (-1,1) (1,1) (1,1) 0010 (1,1) (1,1) (-1,-1) (-1,-1) 0001 (1,1) (1,1) (1,-1) (-1,-1) 1100 (1,1) (-1,1) (1,1) (1,1) 0110 (-1,1) (-1,1) (-1,-1) (-1,-1) 0011 (1,1) (1,1) (-1,-1) (1,-1) 1110 (1,1) (1,1) (-1,-1) (1,1) 0120 (-1,1) (1,1) (1,1) (1,1) 0111 (1,-1) (-1,1) (1,-1) (1,-1) 1120 (1,1) (1,1) (1,1) (-1,1) 1111 (-1,-1) (1,1) (1,1) (-1,1) 0121 (1,1) (1,1) (-1,-1) (-1,-1) 1220 (1,1) (-1,1) (1,1) (-1,1) 1121 (-1,1) (1,1) (-1,1) (-1,-1) 0122 (1,1) (1,1) (1,1) (1,1) 1221 (1,1) (-1,1) (1,-1) (-1,-1) 1122 (-1,1) (1,1) (1,1) (-1,1) 1231 (1,1) (1,1) (-1,-1) (1,-1) 1222 (1,1) (-1,1) (1,1) (-1,1) 1232 (1,1) (1,1) (-1,-1) (-1,-1) 1242 (1,1) (1,1) (1,1) (1,1) 1342 (1,1) (-1,1) (1,1) (1,1) 2342 (-1,1) (1,1) (1,1) (1,1) Table 3. The values of \eta^{\text{e}}\colon F_{4}\times\Delta\to T in Proposition 11.11 . In the first column, a sequence a_{1}a_{2}a_{3}a_{4} represents \sum_{i=1}^{4}a_{i}\delta_{i} . Further, \eta^{\text{e}}(\alpha,\delta)=\eta^{\text{e}}(-\alpha,\delta) for all \alpha\in F_{4} and \delta\in\Delta . Remark 11.12 . The map \eta^{\text{e}} in Proposition 11.11 has the property that \eta^{\text{e}}(\alpha,\delta)=\eta^{\text{e}}(-\alpha,\delta) for all \alpha\in F_{4} and \delta\in\Delta . As in Remark 11.6 , this property relies on our careful choice of the root homomorphisms (\theta_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} in Definition 10.29 . In particular, the validity of this property for \alpha\in F_{4} with \pi(\alpha)=(0,0) relies on the case distinction in Eq. 30 . Proposition 11.13 . The following commutator relations hold for all t,s\in k and c,d\in C : \displaystyle[\theta_{\delta_{1}}(t),\theta_{\delta_{2}}(s)] \displaystyle=\theta_{\delta_{1}+\delta_{2}}(ts), \displaystyle[\theta_{\delta_{2}}(t),\theta_{\delta_{3}}(c)] \displaystyle=\theta_{\delta_{2}+\delta_{3}}(-tc)\theta_{\delta_{2}+2\delta_{3}}\big(tn(c)\big), \displaystyle[\theta_{\delta_{2}+\delta_{3}}(c),\theta_{\delta_{3}}(d)] \displaystyle=\theta_{\delta_{2}+2\delta_{3}}\big(-t(c\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mud\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)\big), \displaystyle[\theta_{\delta_{2}}(t),\theta_{\delta_{2}+2\delta_{3}}(s)] \displaystyle=1_{G}, \displaystyle[\theta_{\delta_{4}}(c),\theta_{\delta_{3}}(d)] \displaystyle=\theta_{\delta_{3}+\delta_{4}}(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mud\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu). In particular, Axiom 1.5 Item 2 is satisfied. Proof. The first four commutator formulas follow from the ones established in Proposition 7.23 for arbitrary cubic norm pairs. For example, for t,s\in k : \displaystyle[\theta_{\delta_{1}}(t),\theta_{\delta_{2}}(s)] \displaystyle=\bigl[\exp_{1,0}\big(\vartheta_{11\bar{1}\bar{1}}(s)\big),\exp_{-2,-1}\big(\vartheta_{\bar{2}000}(t)\big)\bigr] \displaystyle=\bigl[\exp_{1,0}\big((0,-\gamma_{2}^{-1}\gamma_{3}se_{1},0,0)_{+}\big),\exp_{-2,-1}(tx)\bigr] \displaystyle=\bigl[x_{1}\big(-\gamma_{2}^{-1}\gamma_{3}se_{1}\big),x_{6}(t)\bigr]=x_{5}\big(-t\gamma_{2}^{-1}\gamma_{3}se_{1}\big). Here we have used that b\coloneq-\gamma_{2}^{-1}\gamma_{3}se_{1} satisfies N(b)=0 and b^{\sharp}=0 . This yields the desired commutator relation because \displaystyle\theta_{\delta_{1}+\delta_{2}}(ts) \displaystyle=\exp_{-1,-1}\big(\vartheta_{\bar{1}1\bar{1}\bar{1}}(ts)\big)=x_{5}\big(-t\gamma_{2}^{-1}\gamma_{3}se_{1}\big). Alternatively, the commutator formulas follow from a direct computer calculation (see Section 9.3 for details), and this is also how establish the last formula. It follows from the above that the commutator relation [U_{\alpha},U_{\beta}]\subseteq U_{\mathord{]\alpha,\beta[}} is satisfied for all (\alpha,\beta)\in X\coloneq\{(\delta_{1},\delta_{2}),(\delta_{2},\delta_{3}),(\delta_{2}+\delta_{3},\delta_{3}),(\delta_{2},\delta_{2}+2\delta_{3}),(\delta_{3},\delta_{4})\}. By similar arguments as in Remark 1.16 , we infer that [U_{\alpha},U_{\beta}]\subseteq U_{\mathord{]\alpha,\beta[}} holds for all non-proportional \alpha,\beta\in F_{4} . Hence Axiom 1.5 Item 2 is satisfied. ∎ Proposition 11.14 . Let \Pi be any positive system of roots in F_{4} and denote by U_{+} and U_{-} the groups generated by (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in\Pi} and (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in-\Pi} , respectively. Then U_{+}\cap U_{-}=1 . In particular, the root groups (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}} satisfy Axiom 1.5 Item 4 Proof. This follows from Proposition 7.8 . ∎ We conclude with our final main result. Theorem 11.15 . Let k be a commutative ring and let C be a multiplicative conic alternative algebra over k . Let \Gamma=\operatorname{diag}(\gamma_{1},\gamma_{2},\gamma_{3})\in\Mat_{3}(k) be invertible, let J\coloneq\Her_{3}(C,\Gamma) denote the associated cubic Jordan matrix algebra (see 9.6 ) and let L\coloneq L(J,J) denote the Lie algebra constructed in Section 4 . Then the root groups (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} from Definitions 11.8 and 11.2 constitute an F_{4} -grading of the group G\leq\Aut(L) that they generate. Further, (\theta_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} is a parametrization of (G,(U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}}) by (k,C) with respect to (w_{\delta})_{\delta\in\Delta_{F}} and \eta^{\text{e}} which satisfies the commutator formulas in Proposition 11.13 . Proof. This is a consequence of Propositions 11.13 , 11.11 , 11.14 and 11.9 . ∎ Remark 11.16 (cf. 1.17 ) . The commutator formulas in Proposition 11.13 are the same as in Theorem 1.15 only “up to twisting” , that is, “up to signs and conjugation” . Similarly, the parity map \eta^{\text{e}} in this section is not the same as the parity map \eta^{\text{c}} from Remark 1.14 that arises in Theorem 1.15 . In this remark, we illustrate how to modify the root homomorphisms (\theta_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} to obtain a parametrization of G which looks just like the one in Theorem 1.15 . Put \Delta\coloneq\Delta_{F} . Since we have shown in Theorem 11.15 that (G,(U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}}) is an F_{4} -graded group, we can apply Theorem 1.15 . Hence there exist a commutative ring k^{\prime} , a multiplicative conic alternative k^{\prime} -algebra (C^{\prime},n^{\prime}) and a parametrization (\theta_{\alpha}^{\prime})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} of (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} by (k^{\prime},C^{\prime}) with respect to (w_{\delta})_{\delta\in\Delta} (the Weyl elements from Definition 11.3 ) and \eta^{\text{c}} . We aim to show that k=k^{\prime} (as rings) and (C,n)=(C^{\prime},n^{\prime}) (as conic algebras). By [ 31 , 4.5.17] , we can achieve that k=k^{\prime} , C=C^{\prime} as additive groups and \theta_{\delta_{i}}^{\prime}=\theta_{\delta_{i}} for i\in\{2,3\} . Our main tool is the following observation: For all i\in\{2,3\} , \delta_{1},\ldots,\delta_{\ell}\in\Delta , p\in P_{\delta_{i}} and \alpha\coloneq\delta_{i}^{\sigma(\delta_{1})\cdots\sigma(\delta_{\ell})} , we have (in the notation of Definitions 1.11 and 1.13 ): (32) \theta_{\alpha}(\eta^{\text{e}}_{\delta_{i},\delta_{1}\cdots\delta_{\ell}}.p)=\theta_{\delta_{i}}(p)^{w_{\delta_{1}}\cdots w_{\delta_{\ell}}}=\theta_{\delta_{i}}^{\prime}(p)^{w_{\delta_{1}}\cdots w_{\delta_{\ell}}}=\theta_{\alpha}^{\prime}(\eta^{\text{c}}_{\delta_{i},\delta_{1}\cdots\delta_{\ell}}.p). Note that, while the twistings groups T and T^{\prime} of (k,C) and (k^{\prime},C^{\prime}) are the same as abstracts groups and act on the same sets k=k^{\prime} and C=C^{\prime} , their actions on C=C^{\prime} are not (yet proven to be) the same because they involve the conjugation of C and of C^{\prime} , respectively. It is the action of T that appears on the left side of Eq. 32 while the action of T^{\prime} appears on the right side. In the following, we will write \mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mu\>\cdot\>\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu for the conjugation of C and never (need to) refer to the conjugation of C^{\prime} . We first show that k=k^{\prime} as rings. We will frequently use some explicit values of \eta^{\text{c}} , such as \displaystyle\eta^{\text{e}}_{\delta_{2},\delta_{1}}=(-1,1)=\eta^{\text{e}}_{\delta_{1}+\delta_{2},\delta_{2}}\quad\text{and}\quad\eta^{\text{c}}_{\delta_{2},\delta_{1}}=(1,1)=\eta^{\text{c}}_{\delta_{1}+\delta_{2},\delta_{2}}, which can be read of from Table 3 and [ 31 , Figure 10.4] , respectively. Using these values and Definition 1.11 , we compute that \eta^{\text{e}}_{\delta_{2},\delta_{1}\delta_{2}}=(1,1)=\eta^{\text{c}}_{\delta_{2},\delta_{1}\delta_{2}} . Hence by Eq. 32 , we have \theta_{\delta_{1}+\delta_{2}}(t)=\theta_{\delta_{1}+\delta_{2}}^{\prime}(-t)\quad\text{and}\quad\theta_{\delta_{1}}(t)=\theta_{\delta_{1}}(t) for all t\in k . This implies that \displaystyle\theta_{\delta_{1}+\delta_{2}}(t\cdot_{k}s) \displaystyle=[\theta_{\delta_{1}}(t),\theta_{\delta_{2}}(s)]=[\theta_{\delta_{1}}^{\prime}(t),\theta_{\delta_{2}}^{\prime}(s)]=\theta_{\delta_{1}+\delta_{2}}^{\prime}(-t\cdot_{k^{\prime}}s)=\theta_{\delta_{1}+\delta_{2}}(t\cdot_{k^{\prime}}s) for all t,s\in k . Hence k^{\prime}=k . Similarly, to show that C=C^{\prime} as (nonassociative) rings, we observe that \eta^{\text{e}}_{\delta_{3},\delta_{4}}=(-1,-1)=\eta^{\text{e}}_{\delta_{3}+\delta_{4},\delta_{3}}\quad\text{and}\quad\eta^{\text{c}}_{\delta_{3},\delta_{4}}=(-1,1)=\eta^{\text{c}}_{\delta_{3}+\delta_{4},\delta_{3}}. This implies that \eta^{\text{e}}_{\delta_{3},\delta_{4}\delta_{3}}=(1,1)=\eta^{\text{c}}_{\delta_{3},\delta_{4}\delta_{3}} and, by Eq. 32 , \theta_{\delta_{3}+\delta_{4}}(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)=\theta_{\delta_{3}+\delta_{4}}^{\prime}(c)\quad\text{and}\quad\theta_{\delta_{4}}(c)=\theta_{\delta_{4}}^{\prime}(c) for all c\in C . Thus \displaystyle\theta_{\delta_{3}+\delta_{4}}^{\prime}(c\cdot_{C}d) \displaystyle=[\theta_{\delta_{4}}^{\prime}(c),\theta_{\delta_{3}}^{\prime}(d)]=[\theta_{\delta_{4}}(c),\theta_{\delta_{3}}(d)]=\theta_{\delta_{3}+\delta_{4}}(\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5mud\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu\cdot_{C}\mkern 1.5mu\overline{\mkern-1.5muc\mkern-1.5mu}\mkern 1.5mu)=\theta_{\delta_{3}+\delta_{4}}^{\prime}(c\cdot_{C}d) for all c,d\in C , so C=C^{\prime} as (nonassociative) rings. Finally, we have \eta^{\text{e}}_{\delta_{2},\delta_{3}}=(1,1) , \eta^{\text{c}}_{\delta_{2},\delta_{3}}=(-1,1) , \eta^{\text{c}}_{\delta_{3},\delta_{2}}=(1,1)=\eta^{\text{e}}_{\delta_{3},\delta_{2}} and thus \theta_{\delta_{2}+2\delta_{3}}(t)=\theta_{\delta_{2}+2\delta_{3}}^{\prime}(-t)\quad\text{and}\quad\theta_{\delta_{2}+\delta_{3}}(c)=\theta_{\delta_{2}+\delta_{3}}^{\prime}(c) for all t\in k , c\in C , which implies that \displaystyle\theta_{\delta_{2}+\delta_{3}}(-t\cdot_{C}c)\theta_{\delta_{2}+2\delta_{3}}\big(tn(c)\big) \displaystyle=[\theta_{\delta_{2}}(t),\theta_{\delta_{3}}(c)]=[\theta_{\delta_{2}}^{\prime}(t),\theta_{\delta_{3}}^{\prime}(c)] \displaystyle=\theta_{\delta_{2}+\delta_{3}}^{\prime}(-t\cdot_{C^{\prime}}c)\theta_{\delta_{2}+2\delta_{3}}^{\prime}\big(-tn^{\prime}(c)\big) \displaystyle=\theta_{\delta_{2}+\delta_{3}}(-t\cdot_{C^{\prime}}c)\theta_{\delta_{2}+2\delta_{3}}\big(tn^{\prime}(c)\big) for all t\in k , c\in C . Hence n=n^{\prime} and the k -algebra structures on C and on C^{\prime} coincide. Altogether, we conclude the following: Starting from an arbitrary multiplicative conic alternative algebra C over a commutative ring k , we can construct an F_{4} -graded group with a parametrization (\theta_{\alpha}^{\prime})_{\alpha\in F_{4}} that behaves exactly like the one in Theorem 1.15 . Appendix A Higher Leibniz rules In this appendix, we develop the machinery needed to verify that certain “exponential endomorphisms” preserve the Lie bracket, over arbitrary rings. We will apply this machinery to show that the maps e_{(0,b,0,0)_{+}} for b\in J and e_{\rho x} for \rho\in k from Definitions 7.12 and 7.11 are endomorphisms of the Lie algebra L . Lemma A.1 . Let L be a Lie algebra over an arbitrary commutative ring k . Assume that \delta_{0},\delta_{1},\dots,\delta_{s} are k -linear endomorphisms of L such that (*)_{\ell} \delta_{\ell}([v,w])=\sum_{i+j=\ell}[\delta_{i}(v),\delta_{j}(w)] for all v,w\in L and all \ell\in\mathbb{N} , where \delta_{\ell}=0 for all \ell>s . Then the map \varphi\coloneq\sum_{\ell=0}^{s}\delta_{\ell} is a Lie algebra endomorphism, i.e., \varphi([v,w])=[\varphi(v),\varphi(w)] for all v,w\in L . Proof. We have \varphi([v,w])=\sum_{\ell}\delta_{\ell}([v,w]) , so by invoking ( ∗ ) ℓ for each \ell , we get \varphi([v,w])=\sum_{\ell}\sum_{i+j=\ell}[\delta_{i}(v),\delta_{j}(w)]=\Bigl[\sum_{i}\delta_{i}(v),\sum_{j}\delta_{j}(w)\Bigr]=[\varphi(v),\varphi(w)].\qed In the case that the maps \delta_{0},\ldots,\delta_{s} are related to a grading of L (an assumption that will always be satisfied in our situation), we have the following converse of Lemma A.1 . Lemma A.2 . Let (A,+) be an abelian group and let L=\bigoplus_{a\in A}L_{a} be an A -graded Lie algebra over a commutative ring k . Assume that \delta_{0},\delta_{1},\ldots,\delta_{s} are k -linear endomorphisms of L such that the map \varphi\coloneq\sum_{\ell=0}^{s}\delta_{\ell} is a Lie algebra endomorphism and put \delta_{\ell}\coloneq 0 for all \ell>s . Assume further that there exists a\in A such that \delta_{\ell}(L_{b})\subseteq L_{b+\ell a} for all b\in A and \ell\in\mathbb{N} . Then ( ∗ ) ℓ holds for all v,w\in L and all \ell\in\mathbb{N} . Proof. It suffices to prove ( ∗ ) ℓ for homogeneous elements u,v , so let b,c\in A and let v\in L_{b} , w\in L_{c} . Since \varphi is an endomorphism of L , a slight rearrangement of the computation in Lemma A.1 yields that \displaystyle\sum_{\ell=0}^{s}\delta_{\ell}([v,w])=\varphi([v,w])=[\varphi(v),\varphi(w)]=\sum_{\ell}\sum_{i+j=\ell}[\delta_{i}(v),\delta_{j}(w)]. Note that \delta_{\ell}([v,w]) and \sum_{i+j=\ell}[\delta_{i}(v),\delta_{j}(w)] both lie in L_{b+c+\ell a} for all \ell\in\mathbb{N} . Since L=\bigoplus_{d\in A}L_{d} , it follows that \delta_{\ell}([v,w])=\sum_{i+j=\ell}[\delta_{i}(v),\delta_{j}(w)] for all \ell\in\mathbb{N} . ∎ The guiding example we have in mind, is the case where \delta is a derivation of L with \delta^{s+1}=0 for some s\in\mathbb{N}_{0} , and where \delta_{\ell}\coloneq\frac{1}{\ell!}\delta^{\ell} for each \ell , provided each \ell! is invertible in k . Notice that \varphi=\sum_{\ell=0}^{s}\delta_{\ell}=\sum_{\ell=0}^{s}\frac{1}{\ell!}\delta^{\ell} is then the usual exponential map corresponding to \delta . In this case, (*)_{0} is trivially satisfied (since \delta_{0}=\id ) and (*)_{1} is simply the Leibniz rule that defines derivations. By applying the Leibniz rule \ell times, we get that \ell!\cdot\delta_{\ell}([v,w])=\ell!\cdot\sum_{i+j=\ell}[\delta_{i}(v),\delta_{j}(w)] for all \ell , so if each \ell! is invertible in k , then ( ∗ ) ℓ follows for each \ell . The key point now is that the maps we care about, are exponential maps of derivations defined over arbitrary rings. We will still have that \delta_{0}=\id and \delta_{1}=\delta is a derivation, but we cannot deduce the “higher Leibniz rules” ( ∗ ) ℓ from the fact that \delta is a derivation. Proving each of these ( ∗ ) ℓ is a computational and rather elaborate process, that we will describe below, providing enough details so that the courageous reader can reconstruct the full proof without too much effort. Remark A.3 . We have been wondering whether there is some general principle that would allow us to pass from \mathbb{Z} to an arbitrary ring k (e.g. by tensoring), so that we would be able to omit the lengthy proofs that follow. However, the fact that we need a lot of additional identities and lemmas in the process indicates that this seems unlikely. A related example from the literature is that in the appendix of [ 13 ] , Faulkner constructs an A_{2} -graded Lie algebra and an A_{2} -graded group from an alternative ring. He faces the same problems as we do in [ 13 , (A.7)] (except that his grading is a 3-grading, so only the invertibility of 2 is a problem). He proceeds precisely by proving the identities ( ∗ ) ℓ by hand, so apparently he did not see a way around this. A.1. The exponential maps e_{(0,b,0,0)_{+}} We now proceed to show that the maps e_{(0,b,0,0)_{+}} from Definition 7.12 are indeed endomorphisms of the Lie algebra L . So fix b\in J , let \varphi\coloneq e_{(0,b,0,0)_{+}} and decompose \varphi=\sum_{\ell=0}^{3}\delta_{\ell} according to the degree. In particular, \delta_{0}\coloneq\id and \delta_{1}\coloneq\ad_{(0,b,0,0)_{+}} . Explicitly, the maps \delta_{1} , \delta_{2} and \delta_{3} are as follows. (33) \displaystyle\delta_{1} \displaystyle\colon\begin{cases}x&\mapsto(0,b,0,0)_{-}\\ (\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}&\mapsto-b\times c+T(b,c^{\prime})(\zeta-\xi)-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}+\rho b\\ c^{\prime}&\mapsto\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime}),0,0,0\bigr)_{+}\\ \mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}}&\mapsto\bigl(0,-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b,0,0\bigr)_{+}\\ \xi&\mapsto(0,-b,0,0)_{+}\\ \zeta&\mapsto 0\\ c&\mapsto(0,0,-b\times c,0)_{+}\\ (\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}&\mapsto T(b,c^{\prime})y\\ y&\mapsto 0\end{cases} (34) \displaystyle\delta_{2} \displaystyle\colon\begin{cases}x&\mapsto-b^{\sharp}\\ (\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}&\mapsto\bigl(-T(c,b^{\sharp}),\ T(b,c^{\prime})b-b^{\sharp}\times c^{\prime},\ -\rho b^{\sharp},\ 0\bigr)_{+}\\ c^{\prime}&\mapsto 0\\ \mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}}&\mapsto 0\\ \xi&\mapsto 0\\ \zeta&\mapsto 0\\ c&\mapsto-T(c,b^{\sharp})y\\ (\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}&\mapsto 0\\ y&\mapsto 0\end{cases} (35) \displaystyle\delta_{3} \displaystyle\colon\begin{cases}x&\mapsto\bigl(-N(b),0,0,0\bigr)_{+}\\ (\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}&\mapsto-\rho N(b)y\\ c^{\prime}&\mapsto 0\\ \mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}}&\mapsto 0\\ \xi&\mapsto 0\\ \zeta&\mapsto 0\\ c&\mapsto 0\\ (\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}&\mapsto 0\\ y&\mapsto 0\end{cases} Remark A.4 . (1) To make the expressions more readable, we will usually omit parentheses and write \delta_{i}v in place of \delta_{i}(v) . (2) Observe that \delta_{\ell}(L_{i,j})\subseteq L_{i+\ell,j} for all i,j,\ell . In particular, ( ∗ ) ℓ is trivially valid if v\in L_{ij} and w\in L_{rs} when L_{i+r+\ell,j+s}=0 . This will greatly reduce the number of cases we have to verify. The following little trick will severely reduce the required computations. Lemma A.5 . Let n\geq 2 and let a,b,c\in L . Assume that ( ∗ ) ℓ holds for all \ell\leq n for each of the following five pairs: (1) v=a and w=b ; (2) v=a and w=c ; (3) v=b and w=c ; (4) v=b and w=[a,c] ; (5) v=c and w=[a,b] . Then ( ∗ ) ℓ also holds for v=a and w=[b,c] , for all \ell\leq n . Proof. By the Jacobi identity, both sides of ( ∗ ) ℓ for v=a and w=[b,c] can be simplified to the same expression \sum_{i+j+m=\ell}\bigl[[\delta_{i}a,\delta_{j}b],\delta_{m}c\bigr]-\sum_{i+j+m=\ell}\bigl[[\delta_{i}a,\delta_{m}c],\delta_{j}b\bigr].\qed Here is one specific instance that we will use several times. Corollary A.6 . Let r\in\{-2,-1,0,1,2\} , let n\geq 2 , let e\in J and e^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Assume that ( ∗ ) ℓ holds for all \ell\leq n in each of the following situations: (1) v\in L_{r} and w=e ; (2) v\in L_{r} and w=e^{\prime} . Then ( ∗ ) ℓ also holds for all v\in L_{r} and w=\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}} , for all \ell\leq n . Proof. By definition, we have \mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}}=[e^{\prime},e] . Observe that for each v\in L_{r} , the elements [v,e^{\prime}] and [v,e] also belong to L_{r} . Moreover, ( ∗ ) ℓ also holds for v=e and w=e^{\prime} : it holds trivially for \ell=0 and \ell=1 , and once \ell\geq 2 , it holds by Remark A.4 because L_{\ell,0}=0 . The result now follows from Lemma A.5 . ∎ We are now ready to prove ( ∗ ) ℓ for each \ell , starting with \ell=2 . (Recall that (*)_{1} is just the Jacobi identity since \delta_{0}=\id and \delta_{1} is an inner derivation.) For each \ell , this will require a large number of case distinctions depending on v and w , where we will go over each of the different cases as in Table 1 . The case \ell=2 . We have to show that (*)_{2} \delta_{2}[v,w]=[\delta_{2}v,w]+[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w]+[v,\delta_{2}w] for all v,w\in L . We first list the different cases we have to consider. (1) v=x , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} , (2) v=x , w=\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}} , (3) v=x , w=\xi , (4) v=x , w=\zeta , (5) v=x , w=c\in J , (6) v=x , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} , (7) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} , (8) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} , (9) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}} , (10) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=\xi , (11) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=\zeta , (12) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=c\in J , (13) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} , (14) v=\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}} , w=c\in J , (15) v=\xi , w=c\in J , (16) v=\zeta , w=c\in J . Observe that several cases have been omitted because of Remark A.4 . For example, when v=x and w=c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} , we have v\in L_{-2,-1} and w\in L_{0,-1} , but L_{-2+0+2,-1-1}=L_{0,-2}=0 . As another example, note that when v\in L_{0,i} and w\in L_{0,j} , then we end up in L_{2,i+j} , which is 0 unless i+j=1 ; this implies that only cases Items 14 , 15 and 16 arise (up to symmetry) for v,w\in L_{0} . We will now deal with each of these cases separately. In each case, we will simply give the result of the computation of each of the four terms involved in ( ∗ ) 2 and mention if the computation or the verification of ( ∗ ) 2 involves additional identities. (1) v=x , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} . Then \displaystyle\delta_{2}[v,w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(T(c,b^{\sharp}),\ b^{\sharp}\times c^{\prime},\ \rho b^{\sharp},\ 0\bigr)_{-} \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=\bigl(-2T(c,b^{\sharp}),\ T(b,c^{\prime})b-2b^{\sharp}\times c^{\prime},\ -2\rho b^{\sharp},\ 0\bigr)_{-} \displaystyle[v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=\bigl(T(c,b^{\sharp}),\ -T(b,c^{\prime})b+b^{\sharp}\times c^{\prime},\ \rho b^{\sharp},\ 0\bigr)_{-}. (2) v=x , w=\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}} . By Corollary A.6 , we can skip this case, as it will follow from Item 5 . (Notice that the case v=x , w=e^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} holds by Remark A.4 .) (3) v=x , w=\xi . Then \displaystyle\delta_{2}[v,w] \displaystyle=-2b^{\sharp} \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=-2b^{\sharp} \displaystyle[v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=0. (4) v=x , w=\zeta . Then \displaystyle\delta_{2}[v,w] \displaystyle=-b^{\sharp} \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,w] \displaystyle=-b^{\sharp} \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=0. (5) v=x , w=c\in J . Then \displaystyle\delta_{2}[v,w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,w] \displaystyle=-\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\sharp}} \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=2T(c,b^{\sharp})\zeta-\mathbf{d}_{b,b\times c} \displaystyle[v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=-T(c,b^{\sharp})\xi. For the computation of [\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] , we used the fact that T(b,b\times c)=T(c,b\times b)=2T(c,b^{\sharp}) . Moreover, to verify ( ∗ ) 2 , we require Lemma 4.17 Item 3 . (6) v=x , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} . Then \displaystyle\delta_{2}[v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(T(c,b^{\sharp}),\ b^{\sharp}\times c^{\prime}-T(b,c^{\prime})b,\ \rho b^{\sharp},\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(T(c,b^{\sharp}),\ b^{\sharp}\times c^{\prime},\ \rho b^{\sharp},\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=\bigl(0,\ -T(b,c^{\prime})b,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=0. (7) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} . A direct computation is possible but quite involved, and it is much more efficient to invoke Lemma A.5 . So write w=[z,x] with z=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} . Then ( ∗ ) 2 for the given pair (v,w) will follow once we know it for each of the five pairs (v,z) , (v,x) , (z,x) , (x,[v,z]) and (z,[v,x]) . For (v,z) , this is case Item 13 below. For (v,x) and (z,x) , this has been dealt with in the respective cases Items 1 and 6 above. Since [v,z]\in L_{0} , the case (x,[v,z]) follows from Items 2 , 3 , 4 and 5 above. The case (z,[v,x]) , finally, is trivial because [v,x]=0 . (8) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Then \displaystyle\delta_{2}[v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(-T(c^{\prime}\times a^{\prime},b^{\sharp}),\ \mu T(b,c^{\prime})b-\mu b^{\sharp}\times c^{\prime},\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(T(b,a^{\prime})T(b,c^{\prime})-T(b^{\sharp}\times a^{\prime},c^{\prime}),\ -\mu c^{\prime}\times b^{\sharp},\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=\bigl(-T(b,a^{\prime})T(b,c^{\prime}),\ \mu T(b,c^{\prime})b,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=0. (9) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}} . By Corollary A.6 , we can skip this case, as it will follow from Items 8 and 12 . (10) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=\xi . Then \displaystyle\delta_{2}[v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(-T(a,b^{\sharp}),\ T(b,a^{\prime})b-b^{\sharp}\times a^{\prime},\ -\mu b^{\sharp},\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(T(a,b^{\sharp}),\ -T(b,a^{\prime})b+b^{\sharp}\times a^{\prime},\ \mu b^{\sharp},\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=\bigl(-2T(a,b^{\sharp}),\ D_{b,a^{\prime}}(b),\ -2\mu b^{\sharp},\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=0. By definition, D_{b,a^{\prime}}(b)=2T(b,a^{\prime})b-2b^{\sharp}\times a^{\prime} . (11) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=\zeta . Then \displaystyle\delta_{2}[v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(-T(a,b^{\sharp}),\ 0,\ \mu b^{\sharp},\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(-T(a,b^{\sharp}),\ 0,\ \mu b^{\sharp},\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=0. (12) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=c\in J . We can again invoke Lemma A.5 to avoid computations. Indeed, again write v=[z,x] with z=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{+} . Then ( ∗ ) 2 for the given pair (v,w) will follow once we know it for each of the five pairs (x,z) , (c,z) , (x,c) , (z,[x,c]) and (x,[z,c]) . For (x,c) , this is case Item 5 above. For (x,z) and (x,[z,c]) , this is case Item 6 above. For (c,z) , this is trivial because of Remark A.4 . The case (z,[x,c]) , finally, is trivial because [x,c]=0 . (13) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} . Then \displaystyle\delta_{2}[v,w] \displaystyle=T(\rho a-a^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}+\mu c,\ b^{\sharp})y \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,w] \displaystyle=\rho T(a,b^{\sharp})y+T(b,a^{\prime})T(b,c^{\prime})y-T(b^{\sharp}\times a^{\prime},c^{\prime})y+\mu T(c,b^{\sharp})y \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=-T(b,a^{\prime})T(b,c^{\prime})y \displaystyle[v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=0. (14) v=\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}} , w=c\in J . Then \displaystyle\delta_{2}[v,w] \displaystyle=-T\bigl(D_{e,e^{\prime}}(c),b^{\sharp}\bigr)y \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=T\bigl(D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)-T(e,e^{\prime})b,b\times c\bigr)y \displaystyle[v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=0. To prove equality of the two non-zero right hand sides, we expand \displaystyle-T\bigl(D_{e,e^{\prime}}(c),b^{\sharp}\bigr)=-T(e,e^{\prime})T(c,b^{\sharp})-T(c,e^{\prime})T(e,b^{\sharp})+T\bigl((c\times e)\times e^{\prime},b^{\sharp}\bigr), \displaystyle T\bigl(D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)-T(e,e^{\prime})b,b\times c\bigr)=T(b,e^{\prime})T(e,b\times c)-T\bigl((b\times e)\times e^{\prime},b\times c\bigr). Now invoke Lemma 2.8 Item 9 to rewrite \displaystyle T\bigl((b\times e)\times e^{\prime},b\times c\bigr)=T\bigl((b\times e)\times(b\times c),e^{\prime}\bigr) \displaystyle=T(c,b\times e)T(b,e^{\prime})+T(c,b^{\sharp})T(e,e^{\prime})+T(e,b^{\sharp})T(c,e^{\prime})-T\bigl((c\times e)\times b^{\sharp},e^{\prime}\bigr) and the result follows. (Notice that we could not apply Lemma A.5 or Corollary A.6 since we would run into a circular argument.) (15) v=\xi , w=c\in J . Then \displaystyle\delta_{2}[v,w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=2T(c,b^{\sharp})y \displaystyle[v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=-2T(c,b^{\sharp})y. (16) v=\zeta , w=c\in J . Then \displaystyle\delta_{2}[v,w] \displaystyle=-T(c,b^{\sharp})y \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=-T(c,b^{\sharp})y. The case \ell=3 . We have to show that (*)_{3} \delta_{3}[v,w]=[\delta_{3}v,w]+[\delta_{2}v,\delta_{1}w]+[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{2}w]+[v,\delta_{3}w] for all v,w\in L . Again, we first list the different cases we have to consider. (1) v=x , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} , (2) v=x , w=\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}} , (3) v=x , w=\xi , (4) v=x , w=\zeta , (5) v=x , w=c\in J , (6) v=x , w=(0,0,0,\rho)_{+} , (7) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} , (8) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}} , (9) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=\xi , (10) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=\zeta , (11) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=c\in J . Of course, we have again applied Remark A.4 . In particular, notice that for case Item 6 , where v=x\in L_{-2,-1} and w\in L_{1} , ( ∗ ) 3 is trivial when w\in L_{1j} with j\neq 1 , which is why we can restrict to the case w=(0,0,0,\rho)_{+} . (1) v=x , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} . Then \displaystyle\delta_{3}[v,w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[\delta_{3}v,w] \displaystyle=-N(b)c^{\prime}-\rho N(b)(\xi-\zeta) \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=-T(b,c^{\prime})b^{\sharp}+D_{c^{\prime},b}(b^{\sharp})-\rho\mathbf{d}_{b,b^{\sharp}} \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=T(b,c^{\prime})b^{\sharp}-N(b)c^{\prime}+3\rho N(b)\zeta-\rho\mathbf{d}_{b,b^{\sharp}} \displaystyle[v,\delta_{3}w] \displaystyle=-\rho N(b)\xi, where we have used Definition 2.3 Items 3 and 6 in the computation of [\delta_{1}v,\delta_{2}w] . Now these two identities also imply that D_{c^{\prime},b}(b^{\sharp})=2N(b)c^{\prime} . Together with the fact that \mathbf{d}_{b,b^{\sharp}}=N(b)(2\zeta-\xi) by Lemma 4.17 Item 1 , ( ∗ ) 3 follows. (2) v=x , w=\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}} . By Corollary A.6 , we can skip this case, as it will follow from Item 5 . (Notice that the case v=x , w=e^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} holds by Remark A.4 .) (3) v=x , w=\xi . Then \displaystyle\delta_{3}[v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(-2N(b),\ 0,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{3}v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(N(b),\ 0,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=\bigl(-3N(b),\ 0,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[v,\delta_{3}w] \displaystyle=0. (4) v=x , w=\zeta . Then \displaystyle\delta_{3}[v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(-N(b),\ 0,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{3}v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(-N(b),\ 0,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[v,\delta_{3}w] \displaystyle=0. (5) v=x , w=c\in J . Then \displaystyle\delta_{3}[v,w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[\delta_{3}v,w] \displaystyle=\bigl(0,\ N(b)c,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=\bigl(0,\ -b^{\sharp}\times(b\times c),\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=\bigl(0,\ T(c,b^{\sharp})b,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[v,\delta_{3}w] \displaystyle=0. The result now follows from Lemma 2.8 Item 8 . (6) v=x , w=(0,0,0,\rho)_{+} . Then \displaystyle\delta_{3}[v,w] \displaystyle=\rho N(b)y \displaystyle[\delta_{3}v,w] \displaystyle=\rho N(b)y \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[v,\delta_{3}w] \displaystyle=0. (7) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} . Again, we will invoke Lemma A.5 , writing w=[z,x] with z=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} . Then ( ∗ ) 3 for the given pair (v,w) will follow once we know it for each of the five pairs (v,z) , (v,x) , (z,x) , (x,[v,z]) and (z,[v,x]) . For (v,z) , this is trivial by Remark A.4 . For (v,x) and (z,x) , this has been dealt with in the respective cases Items 1 and 6 above. Since [v,z]\in L_{0} , the case (x,[v,z]) follows from Items 2 , 3 , 4 and 5 above. The case (z,[v,x]) , finally, is trivial because [v,x]=0 . (8) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}} . By Corollary A.6 , we can skip this case, as it will follow from Item 11 . (Notice that the case v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=e^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} holds by Remark A.4 .) (9) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=\xi . Then \displaystyle\delta_{3}[v,w] \displaystyle=-\mu N(b)y \displaystyle[\delta_{3}v,w] \displaystyle=2\mu N(b)y \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=-3\mu N(b)y \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[v,\delta_{3}w] \displaystyle=0. (10) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=\zeta . Then \displaystyle\delta_{3}[v,w] \displaystyle=\mu N(b)y \displaystyle[\delta_{3}v,w] \displaystyle=\mu N(b)y \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[v,\delta_{3}w] \displaystyle=0. (11) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=c\in J . Then \displaystyle\delta_{3}[v,w] \displaystyle=T(c,a^{\prime})N(b)y \displaystyle[\delta_{3}v,w] \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=T(c,a^{\prime})N(b)y-T(b,a^{\prime})T(c,b^{\sharp})y \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=T(b,a^{\prime})T(c,b^{\sharp})y \displaystyle[v,\delta_{3}w] \displaystyle=0, where we have used Lemma 2.8 Item 8 in the computation of [\delta_{2}v,\delta_{1}w] . The case \ell=4 . Notice that \delta_{4}=0 , so we have to show that (*)_{4} 0=[\delta_{3}v,\delta_{1}w]+[\delta_{2}v,\delta_{2}w]+[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{3}w] for all v,w\in L . By Remark A.4 , there are not many cases to consider. (1) v=x , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} , (2) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} . Notice that when v=x\in L_{-2,-1} and w\in L_{0j} , Remark A.4 always applies because L_{2,-1+j}=0 unless j=2 , but then L_{0j}=L_{02}=0 . (1) v=x , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} . Then \displaystyle[\delta_{3}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=\bigl(-N(b)T(b,c^{\prime}),\ \rho N(b)b,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{2}v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})T(b,b^{\sharp})-T(b^{\sharp}\times c,b^{\sharp}),\ -\rho b^{\sharp}\times b^{\sharp},\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+} \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{3}w] \displaystyle=\bigl(0,\ \rho N(b)b,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+}. The result now follows since b^{\sharp}\times b^{\sharp}=2b^{\sharp\sharp}=2N(b)b and T(b,b^{\sharp})=3N(b) . (2) v=(\lambda,a,a^{\prime},\mu)_{-} , w=(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} . We could, of course, directly compute that ( ∗ ) 4 holds, but this is not necessary by the same argument as before, invoking Lemma A.5 . The case \ell\geq 5 . Since \delta_{j}=0 for all j\geq 4 , the identities ( ∗ ) ℓ become trivial as soon as \ell\geq 7 . For \ell=5 and \ell=6 , they simplify to (*)_{5} \displaystyle 0 \displaystyle=[\delta_{3}v,\delta_{2}w]+[\delta_{2}v,\delta_{3}w]\quad\text{and} (*)_{6} \displaystyle 0 \displaystyle=[\delta_{3}v,\delta_{3}w], respectively. By Remark A.4 , however, they are trivially satisfied if v\in L_{i} and w\in L_{j} with i+j>-3 . So the only remaining case is v=x and w\in L_{-1} , but since L_{-1,2}=0 , this is again dealt with by the same Remark A.4 . This finishes the proof that the maps e_{(0,b,0,0)_{+}} are automorphisms of the Lie algebra L . A.2. The exponential maps e_{\rho x} We now show that the maps e_{\rho x} from Definition 7.11 are automorphisms of the Lie algebra L . This works in the same way as for the maps e_{(0,b,0,0)_{+}} , but the number of cases we have to verify will be much lower. We fix \rho\in k , put \varphi\coloneq e_{\rho x} and decompose \varphi=\sum_{\ell=0}^{2}\delta_{\ell} . Here \delta_{0}=\id , \delta_{1}=\ad_{\rho x} and \delta_{2} is defined by \delta_{2}(y)=\rho^{2}x and \delta_{2}(L_{ij})=0 for all (i,j)\neq(2,1) . Further, \delta_{1} is trivial on all L_{ij} except for the following cases: \displaystyle\delta_{1}(\xi)=2\rho x,\quad\delta_{1}(\zeta)=\rho x,\quad\delta_{1}\big((\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}\big)=-\rho(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{,}\quad\delta_{1}(y)=\rho\xi. Remark A.7 . Similarly to Remark A.4 , we have \delta_{\ell}(L_{i,j})=L_{i-2\ell,j-\ell} for all i,j,\ell . Hence ( ∗ ) ℓ is trivially satisfied for all v\in L_{ij} , w\in L_{rs} with L_{i+r-2\ell,j+s-\ell}=0 . In order to verify (*)_{2} \delta_{2}[v,w]=[\delta_{2}v,w]+[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w]+[v,\delta_{2}w], only the following cases have to be considered by Remark A.7 . (1) v\in L_{0} , w=y . (2) v=(0,0,0,\mu)_{+} , w=y . (3) v=(0,0,a^{\prime},0)_{+} , w=(0,0,b^{\prime},0)_{+} . (4) v=(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+} , w=y . (5) v=y , w=y . In case Item 4 , we compute that \displaystyle[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] \displaystyle=[-\rho(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-},\rho\xi]=-\rho^{2}(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}, \displaystyle[v,\delta_{2}w] \displaystyle=[(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+},\rho^{2}x]=\rho^{2}(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-} and \delta_{2}[v,w]=[\delta_{2}v,w]=[v,\delta_{2}w]=0 . In case Item 5 , we have \delta_{2}[v,w]=0=[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w] and [\delta_{2}v,w]=-[v,\delta_{2}w] because v=w . In all remaining cases, \delta_{2}[v,w]=[\delta_{2}v,w]=[\delta_{1}v,\delta_{1}w]=[v,\delta_{2}w]=0. Thus (*)_{2} is satisfied. We now turn to (*)_{3} . Using Remark A.7 , we can omit all cases except for v=y=w , and this case is trivial by the same arguments as for (*)_{2} . The relations (*)_{\ell} for \ell\geq 4 hold by Remark A.7 as well. We conclude that e_{\rho x} is indeed an automorphism of L . Appendix B Weyl elements in the G_{2} -grading We can summarize the results of Appendix A as follows. Lemma B.1 . We have e_{\lambda x}\in\End(L) for all \lambda\in k . Lemma B.2 . We have e_{(0,b,0,0)_{+}}\in\End(L) for all b\in J . The goal of this appendix is to show that all the remaining maps defined in Definitions 7.11 , 7.12 , 7.13 and 7.14 can be expressed as the conjugate of e_{\lambda x} or e_{(0,b,0,0)_{+}} by a suitable product of the reflections defined in Section 5 . In particular, we infer that all these maps are compatible with the Lie bracket, and hence lie in \End(L) . Once this is done, only a few additional computations are required to show that the reflections are actually Weyl elements in the sense of Definition 1.5 Item 3 . Lemma B.3 . For all \lambda\in k , we have \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda x}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=e_{\lambda y} . In particular, e_{\lambda y}\in\End(L) . Proof. Let \lambda\in k . Using the formulas in Definitions 5.8 , 5.17 and 7.11 , we can compute that \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda x}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow} acts as the identity on L_{1}+L_{2} and on \mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}} for all c\in J , c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} , and that it acts on the remaining generators of the k -modules L as follows: \displaystyle x \displaystyle\mapsto x-\lambda\xi+\lambda^{2}y, \displaystyle(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} \displaystyle\mapsto(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}+\lambda(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}, \displaystyle\xi \displaystyle\mapsto\xi-2\lambda y, \displaystyle\zeta \displaystyle\mapsto\zeta-\lambda y. Comparing the results of our computation to the definition of e_{\lambda y} , we conclude that \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda x}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=e_{\lambda y} . By Lemmas B.1 and 5.15 , it follows that e_{\lambda y}\in\End(L) . ∎ Lemma B.4 . For all \lambda\in k , we have \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda y}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=e_{\lambda x} . Proof. Let \lambda\in k . It follows from Lemma B.3 that \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda y}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{-2}\circ e_{\lambda x}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{2} . Since \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{2} is the parity automorphism of the grading (L_{i})_{-2\leq i\leq 2} by Remark 5.12 , the assertion follows from Lemma 7.7 . ∎ Lemma B.5 . For all a\in J and a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} , we have \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{-1}\circ e_{a}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=e_{a} and \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{-1}\circ e_{a^{\prime}}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=e_{a^{\prime}} . Proof. It suffices to check that e_{a}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}\circ e_{a} and e_{a^{\prime}}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}\circ e_{a^{\prime}} , which is straightforward. The main argument is the observation that the formulas for the action of e_{a} on L_{1} and L_{-1} are identical, and similarly for e_{a^{\prime}} . ∎ Lemma B.6 . We have \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=e_{y}\circ e_{x}\circ e_{y}=e_{x}\circ e_{y}\circ e_{x} . Proof. As in Lemma B.3 , we can compute that \displaystyle e_{y}\circ e_{x}\circ e_{y}(x) \displaystyle=y,\qquad e_{y}\circ e_{x}\circ e_{y}\big((\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}\big)=-(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} for all \nu,\rho\in k , c\in J and c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Since all the maps \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} , e_{x} and e_{y} lie in \End(L) , it follows from Remark 7.19 that \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=e_{y}\circ e_{x}\circ e_{y} . This implies that \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}}=e_{y}^{\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}}\circ e_{x}^{\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}}\circ e_{y}^{\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}}=e_{x}\circ e_{y}\circ e_{x} by Lemmas B.3 and B.4 . ∎ Lemma B.7 . For all \lambda\in k , we have \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda x}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{(-\lambda,0,0,0)_{-}} . In particular, e_{(\lambda,0,0,0)_{-}}\in\End(L) . Proof. Let \lambda\in k . Similarly as in the proof of Lemma B.3 , we can compute that \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda x}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} acts on the generators of the k -module L as follows: \displaystyle y \displaystyle\mapsto y+(\lambda,0,0,0)_{-},\qquad x\mapsto x, \displaystyle c^{\prime} \displaystyle\mapsto c^{\prime}, \displaystyle(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} \displaystyle\mapsto(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}+\lambda\rho x, \displaystyle\xi \displaystyle\mapsto\xi+(-\lambda,0,0,0)_{-}, \displaystyle\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}} \displaystyle\mapsto\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}}+\big(-T(c,c^{\prime})\lambda,0,0,0\big)_{-}, \displaystyle\zeta \displaystyle\mapsto\zeta+(-2\lambda,0,0,0)_{-}, \displaystyle(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} \displaystyle\mapsto(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}+\lambda c^{\prime}-\lambda\rho\zeta+(\lambda^{2}\rho,0,0,0)_{-}, \displaystyle c \displaystyle\mapsto c+(0,\lambda c,0,0)_{-} for all \nu,\rho\in k , c\in J , c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . We conclude that \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda x}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{(-\lambda,0,0,0)_{-}} . By Lemmas B.1 and 5.15 , it follows that e_{(\lambda,0,0,0)_{-}}\in\End(L) . ∎ Lemma B.8 . For all \lambda\in k , we have \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda y}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{(0,0,0,-\lambda)_{+}} . In particular, e_{(0,0,0,\lambda)_{+}}\in\End(L) . Proof. Let \lambda\in k . Then \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda y}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{(0,0,0,-\lambda)_{+}} acts on L as follows: \displaystyle x \displaystyle\mapsto x+(0,0,0,-\lambda)_{-}, \displaystyle(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-} \displaystyle\mapsto(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}+\lambda\nu\zeta+(0,0,0,\lambda^{2}\nu)_{+}-\lambda c, \displaystyle c^{\prime} \displaystyle\mapsto c^{\prime}+(0,0,-\lambda c^{\prime},0)_{+}, \displaystyle(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} \displaystyle\mapsto(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}-\lambda\nu y, \displaystyle\xi \displaystyle\mapsto\xi+(0,0,0,\lambda)_{+}, \displaystyle\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}} \displaystyle\mapsto\mathbf{d}_{c,c^{\prime}}+\big(0,0,0,T(c,c^{\prime})\lambda\big)_{+}, \displaystyle\zeta \displaystyle\mapsto\zeta+(0,0,0,2\lambda)_{+}, \displaystyle c \displaystyle\mapsto c,\qquad y\mapsto y for all \nu,\rho\in k , c\in J , c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . We conclude that \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda y}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{(0,0,0,-\lambda)_{+}} . By Lemmas B.3 and 5.15 , it follows that e_{(0,0,0,\lambda)_{+}}\in\End(L) . ∎ Lemma B.9 . (1) Let \lambda,\mu\in k , b\in J , b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} such that at most one of \lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu is non-zero. Then \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{-1}\circ e_{(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=e_{(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}} . (2) We have e_{(\lambda,0,0,0)_{\varepsilon}},e_{(0,b,0,0)_{\varepsilon}},e_{(0,0,0,\lambda)_{\varepsilon}}\in\End(L) for all \lambda\in k , b\in J and \varepsilon\in\{\mathord{\pm}\} . Proof. Let \lambda,\mu\in k , b\in J , b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} such that at most one of \lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu is non-zero. Then a similar computation as before shows that \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{-1}\circ e_{(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow} agrees with e_{(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}} on the usual set of generators of the k -module L . The final assertion follows from Lemmas B.1 , B.2 , B.7 and B.8 . ∎ Lemma B.10 . Let \lambda,\mu\in k , b\in J , b^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} such that at most one of \lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu is non-zero. Then \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{-1}\circ e_{(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=e_{-(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}} . Proof. We have \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{-1}\circ e_{(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}=\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{-2}\circ e_{(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{2} by Lemma B.9 . Thus the assertion follows from Remarks 5.13 and 7.7 . ∎ The following Lemmas B.11 and B.12 follow from the same kind of computations as before. Lemma B.11 . For all a\in J , we have \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(0,a,0,0)_{+}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{-a} . In particular, e_{a}\in\End(L) . Lemma B.12 . For all a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} , we have \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(0,0,a^{\prime},0)_{-}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{-a^{\prime}} . Lemma B.13 . Using the notation from Remark 7.16 , we have (\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{(J^{\prime},J)})^{-1}\circ e_{(0,a,0,0)_{+}}^{(J,J^{\prime})}\circ\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{(J^{\prime},J)}=e_{-a}^{(J^{\prime},J)} for all a\in J . In particular, e_{a^{\prime}}^{(J,J^{\prime})}\in\End(L(J,J^{\prime})) for all a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Proof. The first assertion follows from the same kind of computation as before. By Lemmas B.2 and 5.15 , it follows that for all cubic norm pairs (J,J^{\prime}) and all a\in J , the map e_{a}^{(J^{\prime},J)} is an endomorphism of L(J^{\prime},J) . Applying this observation to the cubic norm pair (J^{\prime},J) , the second assertion follows. ∎ The results in this section up to this point can be summarized as follows. Proposition B.14 . (1) Let \lambda\in k and e\in\{e_{\lambda x},e_{(\lambda,0,0,0)_{\pm}},e_{(0,0,0,\lambda)_{\pm}},e_{\lambda y}\}. Then there exist n\in\{0,1,2,3\} , \epsilon\in\{\pm 1\} and \varphi_{1},\ldots,\varphi_{n}\in\{\varphi_{\leftrightarrow},\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}\} such that e=\varphi^{-1}\circ e_{\epsilon\lambda x}\circ\varphi where \varphi\coloneq\varphi_{1}\cdots\varphi_{n} (which should be interpreted as \id_{L} if n=0 ). In particular, e\in\End(L) . (2) Let a\in J and e\in\{e_{a},e_{(0,a,0,0)_{\pm}}\} . Then there exist \varphi\in\{\varphi_{\leftrightarrow},\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}},\id_{L}\} and \epsilon\in\{\pm 1\} such that e=\varphi^{-1}\circ e_{(0,\epsilon a,0,0)_{+}}\circ\varphi . In particular, e\in\End(L) . (3) Let a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} and e\in\{e_{a^{\prime}}^{(J,J^{\prime})},e_{(0,0,a^{\prime},0)_{\pm}}^{(J,J^{\prime})}\}. Then there exist \varphi^{(J^{\prime},J)}\in\{\id_{L},\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{(J,J^{\prime})}\circ\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}^{(J,J^{\prime})}\} and \epsilon\in\{\pm 1\} such that (\varphi^{(J,J^{\prime})})^{-1}\circ e\circ\varphi^{(J,J^{\prime})}=(\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{(J,J^{\prime})})^{-1}\circ e_{(0,\epsilon a^{\prime},0,0)}^{(J^{\prime},J)}\circ\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{(J,J^{\prime})}. In particular, e\in\End(L) . Proof. The first assertion follows from Lemmas B.1 , B.3 , B.7 , B.8 , B.9 and B.10 . The second assertion follows from Lemmas B.2 , B.9 and B.11 . Finally, note that (\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{(J,J^{\prime})})^{-1}\circ e_{(0,\epsilon a^{\prime},0,0)}^{(J^{\prime},J)}\circ\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{(J,J^{\prime})}=e_{-\epsilon a^{\prime}}^{(J,J^{\prime})} by Lemma B.13 and that the left-hand map lies in \End(L) by the second assertion. Thus the third assertion follows from Lemmas B.12 and B.9 . ∎ With Proposition B.14 established, it now follows from Proposition 7.20 that \exp_{\alpha}\colon L_{\alpha}\to\Aut(L)\colon a\mapsto e_{a} is a well-defined \alpha -parametrization in L , and we can define root groups (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}} in \Aut(L) as in Definition 7.21 . In the remaining part of this appendix, we will show that these root groups have Weyl elements in the sense of Definition 1.5 Item 3 . In fact, one half of the work is already done. Proposition B.15 . \varphi_{\leftrightarrow} is a (2,1) -Weyl element with respect to (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}} . Proof. This follows from Lemmas B.6 , B.3 , B.4 , B.9 and B.10 . ∎ By Remark 1.8 , it remains to find a \delta -Weyl element for a root \delta such that \{(2,1),\delta\} is a system of simple roots in G_{2} . We opt to find a (-1,-1) -Weyl element. Convention B.16 . From now on, we assume that there exists b\in J for which N(b) is invertible. We fix such a b and put b^{\prime}\coloneq N(b)^{-1}b^{\sharp} . By Remark 2.17 , the pair (N(b)U_{b^{\prime}},N(b)^{-1}U_{b}) is then a t -involution of (J,J^{\prime}) for t\coloneq N(b) , which we denote by (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}) . We aim to show that the reflection \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}\coloneq\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t)}=\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{(J^{\prime},J)}\circ L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t) from Definition 5.18 is a (-1,-1) -Weyl element. We begin by showing that it has the desired product decomposition. Lemma B.17 . We have \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}=e_{(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}}\circ e_{(0,b,0,0)_{-}}\circ e_{(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}} . Proof. We compute the action of g\coloneq e_{(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}}\circ e_{(0,b,0,0)_{-}}\circ e_{(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}} on the generating set \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(kx+L_{1})=kx+(0,0,J^{\prime},0)_{-}+J+(k,0,0,k)_{+} of L . Since this computation relies on several identities, we perform it in full detail, with each arrow “ \mapsto ” denoting the application of the next consecutive factor of g . We will frequently use that T(b,b^{\sharp})=3N(b)=3t by Axiom 2.3 Item 3 , that (b^{\prime})^{\sharp}=t^{-1}b and N(b^{\prime})=-t^{-1} and that b\times b=2b^{\sharp} because \times is the linearization of \sharp . We will also apply Lemma 2.8 Items 7 and 8 and Axioms 2.3 Items 5 and 6 in many cases. Each factor of g fixes (k,0,0,0)_{+} pointwise. The action of g on x is given by \displaystyle x \displaystyle\mapsto x+(0,0,-t^{-1}b^{\sharp},0)_{-}-t^{-1}b+(0,0,0,-t^{-1})_{+} \displaystyle\mapsto x+(0,0,-t^{-1}b^{\sharp},0)_{-}-t^{-1}T(b,b^{\sharp})x-t^{-1}b+(0,0,t^{-1}b\times b,0)_{-} \displaystyle\qquad{}+t^{-1}T(b,b^{\sharp})x+(0,0,0,-t^{-1})_{+}+t^{-1}b+(0,0,-t^{-1}b^{\sharp},0)_{-}-t^{-1}N(b)x \displaystyle=(0,0,0,-t^{-1})_{+}\mapsto(0,0,0,-t^{-1})_{+}. The action of g on (0,0,c^{\prime},0)_{-} for an arbitrary c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} is given by \displaystyle(0,0,c^{\prime},0)_{-} \displaystyle\mapsto(0,0,c^{\prime},0)_{-}+t^{-1}c^{\prime}\times b^{\sharp}+\big(0,0,0,t^{-1}T(b,c^{\prime})\big)_{+} \displaystyle\mapsto(0,0,c^{\prime},0)_{-}+T(b,c^{\prime})x+t^{-1}c^{\prime}\times b^{\sharp}+\big(0,0,-t^{-1}(c^{\prime}\times b^{\sharp})\times b,0\big)_{-} \displaystyle\qquad{}-t^{-1}T(c^{\prime}\times b^{\sharp},b^{\sharp})x+\big(0,0,0,t^{-1}T(b,c^{\prime})\big)_{+}-t^{-1}T(b,c^{\prime})b \displaystyle\qquad{}+\big(0,0,t^{-1}T(b,c^{\prime})b^{\sharp},0\big)_{-}+T(b,c^{\prime})x \displaystyle=t^{-1}c^{\prime}\times b^{\sharp}-t^{-1}T(b,c^{\prime})b+\big(0,0,0,t^{-1}T(b,c^{\prime})\big)_{+} \displaystyle\mapsto t^{-1}c^{\prime}\times b^{\sharp}+\big(0,0,0,t^{-2}T(c^{\prime}\times b^{\sharp},b^{\sharp})\big)_{+}-t^{-1}T(b,c^{\prime})b \displaystyle\qquad{}+\big(0,0,0,-t^{-2}T(b,c^{\prime})T(b,b^{\sharp})\big)_{+}+\big(0,0,0,t^{-1}T(b,c^{\prime})\big)_{+} \displaystyle=-t^{-1}\big(T(b,c^{\prime})b-c^{\prime}\times b^{\sharp}\big)=-t^{-1}U_{b}c^{\prime} Here we have used twice that T(c^{\prime}\times b^{\sharp},b^{\sharp})=T(c^{\prime},b^{\sharp}\times b^{\sharp})=2tT(c^{\prime},b) , and also that -t^{-1}(c^{\prime}\times b^{\sharp})\times b=-c^{\prime}-t^{-1}T(b,c^{\prime})b^{\sharp} by Axiom 2.3 Item 6 . For arbitrary c\in J , the action of g on c is given by \displaystyle c \displaystyle\mapsto c+\big(0,0,0,t^{-1}T(c,b^{\sharp})\big)_{+} \displaystyle\mapsto c+(0,0,-c\times b,0)_{-}-T(c,b^{\sharp})x+\big(0,0,0,t^{-1}T(c,b^{\sharp})\big)_{+}-t^{-1}T(c,b^{\sharp})b \displaystyle\qquad{}+\big(0,0,t^{-1}T(c,b^{\sharp})b^{\sharp},0\big)_{-}+T(c,b^{\sharp})x \displaystyle=\big(0,0,t^{-1}U_{b^{\sharp}}c,0\big)_{-}+c-t^{-1}T(c,b^{\sharp})b+\big(0,0,0,t^{-1}T(c,b^{\sharp})\big)_{+} \displaystyle\mapsto\big(0,0,t^{-1}U_{b^{\sharp}}c,0\big)_{-}+t^{-2}U_{b^{\sharp}}(c)\times b^{\sharp}+\big(0,0,0,t^{-2}T(b,U_{b^{\sharp}}c)\big)_{+}+c \displaystyle\qquad{}+\big(0,0,0,t^{-1}T(c,b^{\sharp})\big)_{+}-t^{-1}T(c,b^{\sharp})b+\big(0,0,0,-t^{-2}T(c,b^{\sharp})T(b,b^{\sharp})\big)_{+} \displaystyle\qquad{}+\big(0,0,0,t^{-1}T(c,b^{\sharp})\big)_{+} \displaystyle=(0,0,t^{-1}U_{b^{\sharp}}c,0)_{-}. Here we have used that U_{b^{\sharp}}(c)\times b^{\sharp}=T(b^{\sharp},c)b^{\sharp\sharp}-N(b^{\sharp})c=tT(b^{\sharp},c)b-t^{2}c by ( 3 ) in Lemma 2.19 and T(b,U_{b^{\sharp}}c)=tT(b^{\sharp},c) by ( 2 ) in Lemma 2.19 (applied to b^{\sharp} , c in place of b , c^{\prime} and using that t=N(b) is invertible). Finally, the action of g on (0,0,0,1)_{+} is given by \displaystyle(0,0,0,1)_{+} \displaystyle\mapsto(0,0,0,1)_{+}\mapsto(0,0,0,1)_{+}-b+(0,0,b^{\sharp},0)_{-}+tx \displaystyle\mapsto(0,0,0,1)_{+}-b+\big(0,0,0,-t^{-1}T(b,b^{\sharp})\big)_{+}+(0,0,b^{\sharp},0)_{-}+t^{-1}b^{\sharp}\times b^{\sharp} \displaystyle\qquad{}+\big(0,0,0,t^{-1}T(b,b^{\sharp})\big)_{+}+tx+(0,0,-b^{\sharp},0)_{-}-b+(0,0,0,-1)_{+} \displaystyle=tx. By Remark 5.19 , we conclude that \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}=e_{(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}}\circ e_{(0,b,0,0)_{-}}\circ e_{(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}} . ∎ It remains to show that conjugation by \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} induces the desired permutation of the root groups. We first verify this on the short root groups. Lemma B.18 . We have \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(0,a,0,0)_{+}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{-a^{\iota}} for all a\in J and \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{a^{\prime}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{(0,(a^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},0,0)_{+}} for all a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Proof. It follows from Lemma B.13 that \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(0,a,0,0)_{+}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t)^{-1}\circ e_{-a}^{(J^{\prime},J)}\circ L(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t). The map on the right-hand side fixes x and maps (\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+} to \displaystyle\bigl(\nu+T(c^{\iota},a)+tT(a^{\sharp},(c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})+t\rho N(a),c+a^{\iota}\times c^{\prime}+t\rho(a^{\sharp})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},\,c^{\prime}+\rho a^{\iota},\,\rho\bigr) Here, since (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}) is a t -involution, \displaystyle T(c^{\iota},a)=T(c,a^{\iota}),\qquad tT\big(a^{\sharp},(c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}\big)=T\big((a^{\iota})^{\sharp},c^{\prime}\big), \displaystyle t\rho N(a)=\rho N(a^{\iota}),\qquad t\rho(a^{\sharp})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}=\rho(a^{\iota})^{\sharp}. The first assertion follows. This implies that \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{a^{\prime}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-2}\circ e_{(0,-(a^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},0,0)_{+}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{2} for all a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} , so the second assertion follows from Remarks 5.19 and 7.7 . ∎ Lemma B.19 . We have \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(0,0,a^{\prime},0)_{+}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{(0,-t(a^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},0,0)_{-}} for all a^{\prime}\in J and \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(0,a,0,0)_{-}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{(0,0,-t^{-1}a^{\iota},0)_{+}} for all a\in J . Proof. Let a^{\prime}\in J . We compute the action of \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(0,0.a^{\prime},0)_{-}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} on the generating set \varphi_{\updownarrow}(kx+L_{1})=(k,0,0,k)_{-}+J^{\prime}+(0,J,0,0)_{+}+ky of L . The module (0,0,0,k)_{-} is fixed pointwise and the action on the remaining generators is given as follows, where the final equality for each generator holds because (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}) is a t -homotopy: \displaystyle(1,0,0,0)_{-} \displaystyle\mapsto(1,0,0,0)_{-}, \displaystyle c^{\prime} \displaystyle\mapsto c^{\prime}+\big(-T((c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},a^{\prime})t,0,0,0\big)_{-}=c^{\prime}+\big(T((-ta^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},c^{\prime}),0,0,0\big)_{-}, \displaystyle(0,c,0,0)_{+} \displaystyle\mapsto(0,c,0,0)_{+}-(c^{\iota}\times a^{\prime})^{\iota}+\big(tT((a^{\prime})^{\sharp},c^{\iota}),0,0,0\big)_{-} \displaystyle\qquad\text{where}\quad tT\big((a^{\prime})^{\sharp},c^{\iota}\big)=T\big(((-ta^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})^{\sharp},c\big), \displaystyle y \displaystyle\mapsto y+\big(0,t(a^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},0,0\big)_{+}-t\big((a^{\prime})^{\sharp}\big)^{\iota}+\big(t^{2}N(a^{\prime}),0,0,0\big)_{-} \displaystyle\qquad\text{where}\quad-t\big((a^{\prime})^{\sharp}\big)^{\iota}=-\big((-ta^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}\big)^{\sharp},\quad t^{2}N(a^{\prime})=-N\big((-ta^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}\big). where c\in J and c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . The first assertion follows. This implies that \displaystyle\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(0,a,0,0)_{-}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-2}\circ e_{(0,0,-t^{-1}a^{\iota},0)_{+}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{2} for all a\in J , so the second assertion follows from Remarks 5.19 and 7.7 . ∎ Lemma B.20 . We have \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{a}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{(0,0,a^{\iota},0)_{-}} for all a\in J and \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(0,0,a^{\prime},0)_{-}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{-(a^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}} for all a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Proof. Let a\in J . We compute the action of \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{a}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} on the generating set \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(kx+L_{1})=(k,0,0,k)_{-}+kx+(0,J,0,0)_{-}+J^{\prime} of L . The module (0,0,0,k)_{+} is fixed pointwise. The action on the remaining part is given by \displaystyle\rho x+(0,c,0,0)_{-}+c^{\prime}+(\nu,0,0,0)_{+} \displaystyle\qquad{}\mapsto(\nu,0,0,0)_{+}+\big(c^{\prime}-\nu a^{\iota}\big)+\big(0,c+t(a\times(c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}})^{\iota}-t\nu(a^{\sharp})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},0,0\big)_{-} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad{}+\big(\rho-T(a,c^{\iota})-tT\big((c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},a^{\sharp}\big)+t\nu N(a)\big) for all \rho,\nu\in k , c\in J and c^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} . Here, since (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}) is a t -homotopy, \displaystyle t\big(a\times(c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}\big)^{\iota}=a^{\iota}\times c^{\prime},\qquad-t\nu(a^{\sharp})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}=-\nu(a^{\iota})^{\sharp}, \displaystyle-T(a,c^{\iota})=-T(a^{\iota},c),\quad-tT\big((c^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},a^{\sharp}\big)=-T\big((a^{\iota})^{\sharp},c^{\prime}\big),\quad t\nu N(a)=\nu N(a^{\iota}). The first assertion follows. Hence \displaystyle\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(0,0,a^{\prime},0)}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-2}\circ e_{(a^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{2}=e_{-(a^{\prime})^{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}}} for all a^{\prime}\in J^{\prime} by Remarks 5.19 and 7.7 . ∎ On the long root groups, the required computations are much shorter. Lemma B.21 . For all \nu,\rho\in k , we have \displaystyle\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(0,0,0,\rho)_{-}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{(0,0,0,\rho)_{-}}\quad\text{and}\quad\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(\nu,0,0,0)_{+}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{(\nu,0,0,0)_{+}}. Proof. This follows from Lemmas B.17 and 7.6 because the roots (-1,1) and (1,-1) are adjacent to (1,1) and (-1,-1) . ∎ Lemma B.22 . We have \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda x}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{(0,0,0,-t^{-1}\lambda)_{+}} and \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(0,0,0,\lambda)_{+}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{t\lambda x} for all \lambda\in k . Proof. Let \lambda\in k . Since e_{\lambda x} is the identity on L_{-1} , \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda x}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} is the identity on \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}(L_{-1}) . Further, \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda x}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} acts on (k,0,0,0)_{-}=\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}(ky) by \displaystyle(1,0,0,0)_{-} \displaystyle\mapsto(1,0,0,0)_{-}+t^{-1}\lambda\zeta+(0,0,0,t^{-2}\lambda^{2})_{+}. Since \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}(ky+L_{-1}) generates L , the first assertion follows. Hence \displaystyle\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(0,0,0,\lambda)_{+}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} \displaystyle=\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-2}\circ e_{-t\lambda x}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{2}=e_{t\lambda x}. by Remarks 5.19 and 7.7 . ∎ Lemma B.23 . We have \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda y}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{(-t\lambda,0,0,0)_{-}} and \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(\lambda,0,0,0)_{-}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}=e_{t^{-1}\lambda y} for all \lambda\in k . Proof. Let \lambda\in k . Since e_{\lambda y} is the identity on L_{1} , \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda y}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} is the identity on \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}(L_{1}) . Further, \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{\lambda y}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} acts on (0,0,0,k)=\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}(kx) by \displaystyle(0,0,0,1)_{+} \displaystyle\mapsto(0,0,0,1)-t\lambda\zeta+(t^{2}\lambda^{2},0,0,0)_{-}. Since \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}(ky+L_{-1}) generates L , the first assertion follows. Thus \displaystyle\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-1}\circ e_{(\lambda,0,0,0)_{-}}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}} \displaystyle=\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{-2}\circ e_{-t^{-1}\lambda y}\circ\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{2}=e_{t^{-1}\lambda y} by Remarks 5.19 and 7.7 . ∎ Proposition B.24 . Assume that there exists b\in J such that N(b) is invertible and define (\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t) as in B.16 . Then \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}^{(\iota,{\mathord{\mathchoice{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\displaystyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\textstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptstyle\iota$}}}{\reflectbox{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\iota$}}}}},t)} is a (-1,-1) -Weyl element with respect to (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}} . Proof. This follows from Lemmas B.17 , B.21 , B.22 , B.23 , B.18 , B.19 and B.20 . ∎ Proposition B.25 . Assume that there exists p\in J such that N(p) is invertible. Then for all \alpha\in G_{2} , there exists an \alpha -Weyl element with respect to (U_{\alpha})_{\alpha\in G_{2}} . Proof. By Propositions B.24 and B.15 , there exist Weyl elements for the system \{(2,1),(-1,-1)\} of simple roots in G_{2} . The assertion now follows from Remark 1.8 . ∎ \begin{array}[]{c||c|c|ccccc|c|c|}\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}&x&(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}&c^{\prime}&\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}}&\xi&\zeta&c&(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}&y\\ \hline\cr\hline\cr x&0&&&&&&&&\\ \hline\cr(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}&0&\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)y&&&&&&&\\ \hline\cr b^{\prime}&0&-\bigl(T(c,b^{\prime}),\ b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime},\ \rho b^{\prime},\ 0\bigr)_{+}&0&&&&&&\\ \mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}&0&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\nu T(a,a^{\prime}),\\[1.29167pt] \quad D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\\[1.29167pt] \quad-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime},\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 64.58313pt\rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\nu T(a,a^{\prime}),\\[1.29167pt] \quad D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\\[1.29167pt] \quad-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime},\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 64.58313pt\rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\nu T(a,a^{\prime}),\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447ptD_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447pt-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime},\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 45.20828pt\rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\nu T(a,a^{\prime}),\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612ptD_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612pt-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime},\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 32.29156pt\rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})&\mathbf{d}_{D_{a,a^{\prime}}(e),e^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{e,D_{a^{\prime},a}(e^{\prime})}&&&&&\\ \xi&-2y&-(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}&0&0&0&&&&\\ \zeta&-y&(-2\nu,-c,0,\rho)_{+}&-c^{\prime}&0&0&0&&&\\ b&0&\bigl(0,\ \nu b,\ b\times c,\ T(b,c^{\prime})\bigr)_{+}&-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}&-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)&0&-b&0&&\\ \hline\cr(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}&(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\ \bigl(\lambda c^{\prime}-b\times c+\nu b^{\prime}\bigr)\\[3.44444pt] \quad{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot(\zeta-\xi)\\ \quad{}+(\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot\zeta\\ \quad{}-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[2.58334pt] \hskip 38.74988pt{}+\bigl(\rho b-b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}+\mu c\bigr)\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\ \bigl(\lambda c^{\prime}-b\times c+\nu b^{\prime}\bigr)\\[3.44444pt] \quad{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot(\zeta-\xi)\\ \quad{}+(\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot\zeta\\ \quad{}-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[2.58334pt] \hskip 38.74988pt{}+\bigl(\rho b-b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}+\mu c\bigr)\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\ \bigl(\lambda c^{\prime}-b\times c+\nu b^{\prime}\bigr)\\[2.41112pt] \hskip 8.19447pt{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot(\zeta-\xi)\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}+(\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot\zeta\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[1.80835pt] \hskip 27.12497pt{}+\bigl(\rho b-b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}+\mu c\bigr)\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\ \bigl(\lambda c^{\prime}-b\times c+\nu b^{\prime}\bigr)\\[1.72221pt] \hskip 7.3612pt{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot(\zeta-\xi)\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}+(\lambda\rho-T(b,c^{\prime}))\cdot\zeta\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 19.37494pt{}+\bigl(\rho b-b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}+\mu c\bigr)\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\bigl(-T(b,c^{\prime}),\ -c^{\prime}\times b^{\prime},\ -\mu c^{\prime},\ 0\bigr)_{-}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),\\[1.29167pt] \quad D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)-T(e,e^{\prime})b,\\[1.29167pt] \quad-D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})+T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 51.6665pt\mu T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),\\[1.29167pt] \quad D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)-T(e,e^{\prime})b,\\[1.29167pt] \quad-D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})+T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 51.6665pt\mu T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447ptD_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)-T(e,e^{\prime})b,\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447pt-D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})+T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 36.16663pt\mu T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(-\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612ptD_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)-T(e,e^{\prime})b,\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612pt-D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})+T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 25.83325pt\mu T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}\par&(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}&(-\lambda,0,b^{\prime},2\mu)_{-}&\bigl(0,\ \lambda c,\ c\times b,\ T(c,b^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}&\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)x&\\ \hline\cr y&\xi&-(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}&0&0&-2x&-x&0&0&0\\ \hline\cr\end{array} Table 4. Computation in Lemma 5.15 : The entry at row a and column b shows \varphi_{\leftrightarrow}([a,b])=[\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}(a),\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}(b)] \begin{array}[]{c||c|c|ccccc|c|c|}\varphi_{\leftrightarrow}&x&(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}&c^{\prime}&\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}}&\xi&\zeta&c&(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}&y\\ \hline\cr\hline\cr x&0&&&&&&&&\\ \hline\cr(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}&0&\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho,0,0,0\bigr)_{-}&&&&&&&\\ \hline\cr b^{\prime}&0&T(c,b^{\prime})x+\bigl(0,\ -b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime},\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{-}-\rho b^{\prime}&0&&&&&&\\ \mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}&0&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\nu T(a,a^{\prime})x\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(0,\ D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{-}\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime}\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(-\rho T(a,a^{\prime}),\ 0,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\nu T(a,a^{\prime})x\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(0,\ D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{-}\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime}\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(-\rho T(a,a^{\prime}),\ 0,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\nu T(a,a^{\prime})x\\[0.90417pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(0,\ D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{-}\\[0.90417pt] \mathord{}-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime}\\[0.90417pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(-\rho T(a,a^{\prime}),\ 0,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\nu T(a,a^{\prime})x\\[0.64583pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(0,\ D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)-T(a,a^{\prime})c,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{-}\\[0.64583pt] \mathord{}-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime}\\[0.64583pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(-\rho T(a,a^{\prime}),\ 0,\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\bigl(0,\ 0,\ D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime}),\ 0\bigr)_{-}&\noindent\hbox{}\hfill{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}c@{}}\mathbf{d}_{D_{a,a^{\prime}}(e),e^{\prime}}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}-\mathbf{d}_{e,D_{a^{\prime},a}(e^{\prime})}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}c@{}}\mathbf{d}_{D_{a,a^{\prime}}(e),e^{\prime}}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}-\mathbf{d}_{e,D_{a^{\prime},a}(e^{\prime})}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}c@{}}\mathbf{d}_{D_{a,a^{\prime}}(e),e^{\prime}}\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447pt{}-\mathbf{d}_{e,D_{a^{\prime},a}(e^{\prime})}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}c@{}}\mathbf{d}_{D_{a,a^{\prime}}(e),e^{\prime}}\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612pt{}-\mathbf{d}_{e,D_{a^{\prime},a}(e^{\prime})}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&&&&&\\ \xi&(-2,0,0,0)_{-}&\nu x-(0,c,0,0)_{-}-c^{\prime}+(\rho,0,0,0)_{+}&0&0&0&&&&\\ \zeta&(-1,0,0,0)_{-}&2\nu x-(0,c,0,0)_{-}-(\rho,0,0,0)_{+}&(0,0,c^{\prime},0)_{-}&0&0&0&&&\\ b&0&(0,\nu b,0,0)_{-}+b\times c-\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime}),0,0,0\bigr)_{+}&-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}+T(b,c^{\prime})(\zeta-\xi)&\bigl(0,-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b),0,0\bigr)_{+}&0&(0,b,0,0)_{+}&0&&\\ \hline\cr(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}-\lambda x+(0,b,0,0)_{-}\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}+b^{\prime}-(\mu,0,0,0)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}-\lambda x+(0,b,0,0)_{-}\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}+b^{\prime}-(\mu,0,0,0)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}-\lambda x+(0,b,0,0)_{-}\\[0.90417pt] \mathord{}+b^{\prime}-(\mu,0,0,0)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}-\lambda x+(0,b,0,0)_{-}\\[0.64583pt] \mathord{}+b^{\prime}-(\mu,0,0,0)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime},0\bigr)_{-}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot\xi\\ \quad{}+(\lambda\rho+T(c,b^{\prime}))\cdot(\zeta-\xi)\\ \quad{}-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[2.58334pt] \quad{}+\bigl(0,-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c,0,0\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime},0\bigr)_{-}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot\xi\\ \quad{}+(\lambda\rho+T(c,b^{\prime}))\cdot(\zeta-\xi)\\ \quad{}-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[2.58334pt] \quad{}+\bigl(0,-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c,0,0\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime},0\bigr)_{-}\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447pt{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot\xi\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}+(\lambda\rho+T(c,b^{\prime}))\cdot(\zeta-\xi)\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[1.80835pt] \hskip 8.19447pt{}+\bigl(0,-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c,0,0\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime},0\bigr)_{-}\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612pt{}+(T(c,b^{\prime})-\mu\nu)\cdot\xi\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}+(\lambda\rho+T(c,b^{\prime}))\cdot(\zeta-\xi)\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}-\mathbf{d}_{b,c^{\prime}}-\mathbf{d}_{c,b^{\prime}}\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 7.3612pt{}+\bigl(0,-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c,0,0\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,0,-T(b,c^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}+c^{\prime}\times b^{\prime}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}+(0,0,\mu c^{\prime},0)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,0,-T(b,c^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}+c^{\prime}\times b^{\prime}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}+(0,0,\mu c^{\prime},0)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,0,-T(b,c^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447pt{}+c^{\prime}\times b^{\prime}\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447pt{}+(0,0,\mu c^{\prime},0)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,0,-T(b,c^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612pt{}+c^{\prime}\times b^{\prime}\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612pt{}+(0,0,\mu c^{\prime},0)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,0,-\lambda T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\\ \quad{}-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b\\ \quad{}+\bigl(0,0,D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})-T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},0\bigr)_{+}\\ \quad{}+\mu T(e,e^{\prime})y\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,0,-\lambda T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\\ \quad{}-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b\\ \quad{}+\bigl(0,0,D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})-T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},0\bigr)_{+}\\ \quad{}+\mu T(e,e^{\prime})y\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,0,-\lambda T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}+\bigl(0,0,D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})-T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},0\bigr)_{+}\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}+\mu T(e,e^{\prime})y\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,0,-\lambda T(e,e^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}+\bigl(0,0,D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})-T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},0\bigr)_{+}\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}+\mu T(e,e^{\prime})y\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(0,0,0,\lambda)_{-}\\ \;{}-b\\ \;{}+(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}\\ \;{}+\mu y\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(0,0,0,\lambda)_{-}\\ \;{}-b\\ \;{}+(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}\\ \;{}+\mu y\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(0,0,0,\lambda)_{-}\\ \;{}-b\\ \;{}+(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}\\ \;{}+\mu y\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(0,0,0,\lambda)_{-}\\ \;{}-b\\ \;{}+(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}\\ \;{}+\mu y\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(0,0,0,-\lambda)_{-}\\ \;{}+(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}\\ \;{}+2\mu y\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(0,0,0,-\lambda)_{-}\\ \;{}+(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}\\ \;{}+2\mu y\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(0,0,0,-\lambda)_{-}\\ \;{}+(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}\\ \;{}+2\mu y\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(0,0,0,-\lambda)_{-}\\ \;{}+(0,0,-b^{\prime},0)_{+}\\ \;{}+2\mu y\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(0,0,-c\times b,0)_{+}\\ \;{}-\lambda c\\ \;{}-T(c,b^{\prime})y\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(0,0,-c\times b,0)_{+}\\ \;{}-\lambda c\\ \;{}-T(c,b^{\prime})y\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(0,0,-c\times b,0)_{+}\\ \;{}-\lambda c\\ \;{}-T(c,b^{\prime})y\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(0,0,-c\times b,0)_{+}\\ \;{}-\lambda c\\ \;{}-T(c,b^{\prime})y\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,0,\\ \quad T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})\\ \quad{}+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,0,\\ \quad T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})\\ \quad{}+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,0,\\ \hskip 8.19447ptT(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,0,0,\\ \hskip 7.3612ptT(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)_{+}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\\ \hline\cr y&-\zeta&-(0,0,0,\nu)_{-}+c+(0,0,c^{\prime},0)_{+}-\rho y&0&0&(0,0,0,-2)_{+}&(0,0,0,-1)_{+}&0&0&0\\ \hline\cr\end{array} Table 5. Computation in Lemma 5.15 : The entry at row a and column b shows \varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}([a,b])=[\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(a),\varphi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{45.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(b)] \begin{array}[]{c||c|c|ccccc|c|c|}\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}&x&(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{-}&c^{\prime}&\mathbf{d}_{e,e^{\prime}}&\xi&\zeta&c&(\nu,c,c^{\prime},\rho)_{+}&y\\ \hline\cr\hline\cr x&0&&&&&&&&\\ \hline\cr(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{-}&0&\bigl(0,0,0,T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho\bigr)_{+}&&&&&&&\\ \hline\cr b^{\prime}&0&T(c,b^{\prime})y+\bigl(0,\ 0,\ b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime},\ 0\bigr)_{+}-\rho b^{\prime}&0&&&&&&\\ \mathbf{d}_{a,a^{\prime}}&0&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\nu T(a,a^{\prime})y\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(0,\ 0,\ -D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)+T(a,a^{\prime})c,\ 0\bigr)_{+}\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime}\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(0,\ 0,\ 0,\ \rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\nu T(a,a^{\prime})y\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(0,\ 0,\ -D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)+T(a,a^{\prime})c,\ 0\bigr)_{+}\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime}\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(0,\ 0,\ 0,\ \rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\nu T(a,a^{\prime})y\\[0.90417pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(0,\ 0,\ -D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)+T(a,a^{\prime})c,\ 0\bigr)_{+}\\[0.90417pt] \mathord{}-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime}\\[0.90417pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(0,\ 0,\ 0,\ \rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\nu T(a,a^{\prime})y\\[0.64583pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(0,\ 0,\ -D_{a,a^{\prime}}(c)+T(a,a^{\prime})c,\ 0\bigr)_{+}\\[0.64583pt] \mathord{}-D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime})+T(a,a^{\prime})c^{\prime}\\[0.64583pt] \mathord{}+\bigl(0,\ 0,\ 0,\ \rho T(a,a^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\bigl(0,\ D_{a^{\prime},a}(c^{\prime}),\ 0,\ 0\bigr)_{-}&-\mathbf{d}_{e^{\prime},D_{a,a^{\prime}}(e)}+\mathbf{d}_{D_{a^{\prime},a}(e^{\prime}),e}&&&&&\\ \xi&(0,0,0,-2)_{+}&\nu y+(0,0,-c,0)_{+}-c^{\prime}+(0,0,0,-\rho)_{-}&0&0&0&&&&\\ \zeta&(0,0,0,-1)_{+}&2\nu y+(0,0,-c,0)_{+}+(0,0,0,\rho)_{-}&(0,c^{\prime},0,0)_{+}&0&0&0&&&\\ b&0&(0,0,-\nu b,0)_{+}+b\times c+\bigl(0,0,0,T(b,c^{\prime})\bigr)_{-}&\mathbf{d}_{c^{\prime},b}-T(b,c^{\prime})(\zeta-\xi)&\bigl(0,0,D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b),0\bigr)_{-}&0&(0,0,b,0)_{-}&0&&\\ \hline\cr(\lambda,b,b^{\prime},\mu)_{+}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}-\lambda y+(0,0,-b,0)_{+}\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}+b^{\prime}+(0,0,0,\mu)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}-\lambda y+(0,0,-b,0)_{+}\\[1.29167pt] \mathord{}+b^{\prime}+(0,0,0,\mu)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}-\lambda y+(0,0,-b,0)_{+}\\[0.90417pt] \mathord{}+b^{\prime}+(0,0,0,\mu)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}-\lambda y+(0,0,-b,0)_{+}\\[0.64583pt] \mathord{}+b^{\prime}+(0,0,0,\mu)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime},0,0\bigr)_{+}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}+(-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu)\cdot\xi\\ \quad{}+(\lambda\rho+T(c,b^{\prime}))\cdot(\xi-\zeta)\\ \quad{}+\mathbf{d}_{c^{\prime},b}+\mathbf{d}_{b^{\prime},c}\\[2.58334pt] \quad{}+\bigl(0,0,-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c,0\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime},0,0\bigr)_{+}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}+(-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu)\cdot\xi\\ \quad{}+(\lambda\rho+T(c,b^{\prime}))\cdot(\xi-\zeta)\\ \quad{}+\mathbf{d}_{c^{\prime},b}+\mathbf{d}_{b^{\prime},c}\\[2.58334pt] \quad{}+\bigl(0,0,-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c,0\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime},0,0\bigr)_{+}\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447pt{}+(-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu)\cdot\xi\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}+(\lambda\rho+T(c,b^{\prime}))\cdot(\xi-\zeta)\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}+\mathbf{d}_{c^{\prime},b}+\mathbf{d}_{b^{\prime},c}\\[1.80835pt] \hskip 8.19447pt{}+\bigl(0,0,-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c,0\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,-\lambda c^{\prime}+b\times c-\nu b^{\prime},0,0\bigr)_{+}\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612pt{}+(-T(c,b^{\prime})+\mu\nu)\cdot\xi\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}+(\lambda\rho+T(c,b^{\prime}))\cdot(\xi-\zeta)\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}+\mathbf{d}_{c^{\prime},b}+\mathbf{d}_{b^{\prime},c}\\[1.29167pt] \hskip 7.3612pt{}+\bigl(0,0,-\rho b+b^{\prime}\times c^{\prime}-\mu c,0\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime}),0,0,0\bigr)_{+}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}+c^{\prime}\times b^{\prime}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}+(0,-\mu c^{\prime},0,0)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime}),0,0,0\bigr)_{+}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}+c^{\prime}\times b^{\prime}\\[1.29167pt] \quad{}+(0,-\mu c^{\prime},0,0)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime}),0,0,0\bigr)_{+}\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447pt{}+c^{\prime}\times b^{\prime}\\[0.90417pt] \hskip 8.19447pt{}+(0,-\mu c^{\prime},0,0)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime}),0,0,0\bigr)_{+}\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612pt{}+c^{\prime}\times b^{\prime}\\[0.64583pt] \hskip 7.3612pt{}+(0,-\mu c^{\prime},0,0)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),0,0,0\bigr)_{+}\\ \quad{}-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b\\ \quad{}+\bigl(0,-D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})+T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},0,0\bigr)_{-}\\ \quad{}+\mu T(e,e^{\prime})x\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),0,0,0\bigr)_{+}\\ \quad{}-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b\\ \quad{}+\bigl(0,-D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})+T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},0,0\bigr)_{-}\\ \quad{}+\mu T(e,e^{\prime})x\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),0,0,0\bigr)_{+}\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}+\bigl(0,-D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})+T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},0,0\bigr)_{-}\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}+\mu T(e,e^{\prime})x\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(\lambda T(e,e^{\prime}),0,0,0\bigr)_{+}\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}-D_{e,e^{\prime}}(b)+T(e,e^{\prime})b\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}+\bigl(0,-D_{e^{\prime},e}(b^{\prime})+T(e,e^{\prime})b^{\prime},0,0\bigr)_{-}\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}+\mu T(e,e^{\prime})x\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(-\lambda,0,0,0,)_{+}\\ \;{}-b\\ \;{}+(0,b^{\prime},0,0)_{-}\\ \;{}+\mu x\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(-\lambda,0,0,0,)_{+}\\ \;{}-b\\ \;{}+(0,b^{\prime},0,0)_{-}\\ \;{}+\mu x\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(-\lambda,0,0,0,)_{+}\\ \;{}-b\\ \;{}+(0,b^{\prime},0,0)_{-}\\ \;{}+\mu x\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(-\lambda,0,0,0,)_{+}\\ \;{}-b\\ \;{}+(0,b^{\prime},0,0)_{-}\\ \;{}+\mu x\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(\lambda,0,0,0)_{+}\\ \;{}+(0,b^{\prime},0,0)_{-}\\ \;{}+2\mu x\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(\lambda,0,0,0)_{+}\\ \;{}+(0,b^{\prime},0,0)_{-}\\ \;{}+2\mu x\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(\lambda,0,0,0)_{+}\\ \;{}+(0,b^{\prime},0,0)_{-}\\ \;{}+2\mu x\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}(\lambda,0,0,0)_{+}\\ \;{}+(0,b^{\prime},0,0)_{-}\\ \;{}+2\mu x\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,c\times b,0,0\bigr)_{-}\\ \;{}-\lambda c\\ \;{}+T(c,b^{\prime})x\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,c\times b,0,0\bigr)_{-}\\ \;{}-\lambda c\\ \;{}+T(c,b^{\prime})x\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,c\times b,0,0\bigr)_{-}\\ \;{}-\lambda c\\ \;{}+T(c,b^{\prime})x\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(0,c\times b,0,0\bigr)_{-}\\ \;{}-\lambda c\\ \;{}+T(c,b^{\prime})x\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\noindent\hbox{}{\mathchoice{\hbox{$\displaystyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})\\ \quad{}+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho,\\ \qquad 0,0,0\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\textstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})\\ \quad{}+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho,\\ \qquad 0,0,0\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})\\ \hskip 8.19447pt{}+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho,\\ \hskip 16.38895pt0,0,0\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}{\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\hbox{$\begin{array}[c]{@{}l@{}}\bigl(T(b,c^{\prime})-T(c,b^{\prime})\\ \hskip 7.3612pt{}+\mu\nu-\lambda\rho,\\ \hskip 14.72241pt0,0,0\bigr)_{-}\end{array}$}}$}}}\hfill\hbox{}&\\ \hline\cr y&\zeta&(\nu,0,0,0)_{+}+c+\bigl(0,-c^{\prime},0,0\bigr)_{-}-\rho x&0&0&(-2,0,0,0)_{-}&(-1,0,0,0)_{-}&0&0&0\\ \hline\cr\end{array} Table 6. Computation in Lemma 5.15 : The entry at row a and column b shows \psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}([a,b])=[\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(a),\psi_{\operatorname{\rotatebox{120.0}{\!${}_{\leftrightarrow}$}}}(b)]