Characterizing and Modeling the GitHub Security Advisories Review Pipeline Conference: 23rd International Conference on Mining Software Repositories; April 13–14, 2026; Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 23rd International Conference on Mining Software Repositories (MSR ’26), April 13–14, 2026, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil DOI: 10.1145/3793302.3793360 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2474-9/2026/04 Conference: 23rd International Conference on Mining Software Repositories; April 13–14, 2026; Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 23rd International Conference on Mining Software Repositories (MSR ’26), April 13–14, 2026, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil DOI: 10.1145/3793302.3793360 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2474-9/2026/04 Claudio Segal, Paulo Segal, Carlos Eduardo Banjar, Felipe Paixão, Hudson Silva Borges, Paulo Silveira, Eduardo Santana de Almeida, Joanna C. S. Santos, Anton Kocheturov, Gaurav Srivastava, Daniel S. Menasché Abstract . GitHub Security Advisories (GHSA) have become a central component of open-source vulnerability disclosure and are widely used by developers and security tools. A distinctive feature of GHSA is that only a fraction of advisories are reviewed by GitHub, while the mechanisms associated with this review process remain poorly understood. In this paper, we conduct a large-scale empirical study of GHSA review processes, analyzing over 288,000 advisories spanning 2019–2025. We characterize which advisories are more likely to be reviewed, quantify review delays, and identify two distinct review-latency regimes: a fast path dominated by GitHub Repository Advisories (GRAs) and a slow path dominated by NVD-first advisories. We further develop a queueing model that accounts for this dichotomy based on the structure of the advisory processing pipeline. † † cc-license: by † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction The security of modern software ecosystems depends on the timely identification, disclosure, and remediation of vulnerabilities in open-source components ( 9 ; 7 ; 8 ; 6 ) . The GitHub Security Advisories (GHSA) ( 21 ) database plays a central role in this process by providing structured vulnerability information and integrating with tools such as Dependabot ( 20 ; 25 ) , which automatically alerts developers when dependencies are affected by known vulnerabilities. Given the scale of open-source adoption, GHSA are directly relevant to millions of users worldwide ( 23 ; 14 ) . Within GHSA, some advisories undergo a formal GitHub review , which validates the report, enriches it with metadata, and increases its visibility in automated pipelines, while others remain unreviewed. Reviews can substantially influence how quickly and effectively vulnerabilities are triaged and patched ( 20 ; 25 ) . While previous studies have examined various facets of the security advisory publishing process, including disclosure practices ( 5 ) , automation ( 25 ) , and governance ( 8 ; 2 ) , little is known about the factors that drive the advisory reviews. How long do reviews take once advisories are published? And do review patterns reveal implicit prioritization strategies? This paper addresses these questions through a systematic analysis of 288,604 GHSA vulnerability reports, including 23,563 that received GitHub reviews as of August 21, 2025. We quantify the timing of reviews, propose models for predicting review outcomes, and discuss implications for vulnerability management. Understanding review timing has both academic and industry value: it enables organizations to align their triage strategies with ecosystem dynamics and to anticipate which vulnerabilities are more likely to receive timely attention ( 9 ; 20 ) . The contributions of this work are as follows: • We analyze the roles and maturity of users credited in GitHub-reviewed advisories, and study how these roles correlate with advisory review processes (Section 4 ), offering insights into the human factors that shape them. • We provide the first large-scale characterization of GHSA reviews, examining their frequency, distribution across ecosystems and severities, and time-to-review dynamics (Section 5 ). • We identify distinct fast and slow review paths in the advisory pipeline (Sections 5 – 6 ), showing that advisories originating as GRAs tend to be reviewed earlier than NVD-first advisories. However, our information flow analysis (Section 4 and Figure 4 ) reveals substantial room for improving how GRAs are currently leveraged, as most GHSAs still do not originate from GRAs. • We develop a simple analytical model of advisory review timing (Section 6 ), capturing the essence of the fast and slow paths observed in the GHSA pipeline, and enabling what-if analyses. • We discuss how these insights can inform vulnerability triage, policy considerations, and automated tooling (Section 7 ). • We release a curated dataset and scripts to enable replication and future research: https://github.com/cmsegal/ghsa-review . Outline. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 gives a background. Section 3 describes our mining methodology and dataset construction. Section 4 examines the roles, popularity, and engagement patterns of users involved in security advisories, Section 5 provides an empirical characterization of the review pipeline, and Section 6 develops a queueing-based model that captures key statistical properties of the review process, Section 7 discusses the practical implications of our findings, Section 8 situates our contributions within the broader literature, Section 9 lists threats to validity and Section 10 concludes this paper. 2. Background The GitHub Security Advisory Database (GHSA) is a comprehensive repository of known security vulnerabilities in open source software packages. The database categorizes advisories into two main groups: GitHub-reviewed advisories and unreviewed advisories ( 14 ) . GitHub-reviewed advisories are security vulnerabilities that have been manually validated and mapped to packages in supported ecosystems, ensuring they contain complete descriptions and accurate ecosystem information. Unreviewed advisories remain in this category either because they are pending review, do not affect supported packages, or do not describe valid vulnerabilities ( 23 ) . Reviewed advisories originate from multiple sources, with the two most significant being the National Vulnerability Database (NVD) ( 35 ) and the GitHub Repository Advisories (GRA) ( 14 ) . The NVD is the largest source, covering vulnerabilities across all software types, while GitHub reviews only those relevant to its supported ecosystems. GRAs constitute the second-largest source and provide maintainers with a collaborative workflow for responsible vulnerability disclosure ( 18 ) . Maintainers can create draft advisories to privately discuss security issues, develop fixes in temporary private forks, and publish them to alert their communities. Once published, GitHub reviews each advisory and incorporates it into the GHSA database. These advisories may trigger Dependabot alerts, notifying repository owners when dependencies contain known vulnerabilities ( 20 ) . 3. Mining Methodology and Goals Our study is based on the GHSA dataset as of August 21, 2025, which provides structured metadata for each advisory, including its identifier ( ghsa_id ), affected repositories ( source_code_location ), and a Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVE) identifier ( cve_id ), which is a unique identifier within NVD. Using GitHub’s global advisories API ( 22 ) , we extracted 288,604 advisories, of which 23,563 are GitHub-reviewed and the rest unreviewed. Temporal fields are central to our study: published_at marks the advisory’s first appearance in GHSA, nvd_published_at records the corresponding date in NVD, and github_reviewed_at indicates when GitHub completed its internal review process. Additional fields capture affected product ranges ( vulnerabilities ), supporting references ( references ), and user credits ( credits ), later analyzed to understand contributor roles. Table 1. GHSA dataset fields, including enrichment. Field Description ghsa_id GHSA identifier. source_code_location Link to reported GitHub repository ( 26 ) . repository_advisory_url URL of the originating GRA, if any. published_at Publication date of the GHSA. nvd_published_at Publication date in the NVD, if imported. github_reviewed_at GitHub review date (if reviewed). cve_id Associated Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVE) identifier. severity Severity of the advisory (low, medium, high, critical or unknown). references External references regarding the advisory. vulnerabilities Products and affected version ranges. credits List of users and their roles. gra_published_at Publication date of the originating GRA (when available). enrich_nvd_published_at NVD publication date obtained via CVE query (if missing in GHSA). ecosystem_published_at Dates from ecosystem DBs (RustSec, PyPA, RubySec, etc.). patched_at Date of first patched package version. user_profile Metadata of credited users (e.g., account age, #followers, #public repos). repo_metadata Characteristics of affected repositories (e.g., stars, forks, open issues). 3.1. Data enrichment While the GHSA database provides the temporal metrics aforementioned (e.g., published_at , nvd_published_at , etc.), not all entries in this database may include these metrics. Thus, we conduct an enrichment process, to fill in key missing values and include additional ones that are not originally present in GHSA. Table 1 summarizes the core fields and the enrichment features derived to trace advisory propagation and patch availability. Since this study focuses on the GHSA review process, the enrichment is applied only to the 23,563 GitHub-reviewed advisories. This enrichment step aims to provide complementary information on temporal metrics, as well as user and repository metadata. (a) Temporal enrichment: To obtain a more complete and consistent timeline of advisory disclosure events, we enrich the records with additional publication timestamps from multiple data sources. These timestamps allow measuring propagation across sources and delays between patch release and review. (i) If the repository_advisory_url field is nonempty, we query the GitHub API for the associated Repository Security Advisory (GRA) and record its publication timestamp as gra_published_at . (ii) If the nvd_published_at field is missing, we fill it with the NVD-provided publication timestamp, obtained by querying the NVD API using the advisory’s cve_id . (iii) We parse the references field of each advisory to detect links to RustSec, FriendsOfPHP, PyPA, RubySec, and GoVulnDB. For each, we approximate the publication date by retrieving the timestamp of the first commit that introduced the advisory into the corresponding repository. These dates are stored as rustsec_published_at , pypa_published_at , etc. (iv) For selected ecosystems (pip/PyPI, Go, RubyGems, npm, Maven, NuGet), we extract the first patched package version from the advisory’s vulnerabilities attribute. We then query the deps.dev API to retrieve the publishedAt timestamp of that version, denoted as patched_at . If multiple packages are affected, we sample the first one listed in the vulnerabilities array (see Section 5.4 ). (b) User and repository enrichment: To capture the social and technical context of reviews, we also enrich reviewed advisories with user and repository metadata. For each credited user, we query the GitHub API to retrieve profile metadata, including account creation date, followers, public repositories, and activity indicators, used in Section 4 . For repositories linked via source_code_location , we collected number of stars, open issues and OpenSSF scores as proxies for project popularity and activity, allowing us to analyze differences in maintenance and security practices. Together, the user and repository enrichment complement the temporal data, allowing us to view advisory reviews not as isolated events but as part of broader socio-technical ecosystems. The final dataset includes 5,984 unique GitHub repositories and 3,928 users. 3.2. Research Questions Using these data, we address the following research questions: RQ1 What are the roles of users involved with security advisories? RQ2 Do users tend to specialize in one role? RQ3 How does the popularity and engagement of actors (e.g., remediation developers) differ from that of critics (e.g., reviewers)? RQ4 What distinguishes GRA-originated advisories from non-GRA advisories in the characteristics of their linked repositories and reviewers? RQ5 What are the main sources of GitHub-reviewed advisories, and what is their relative contribution to the review process? RQ6 What factors influence the time to review an advisory once it is published in GitHub? RQ7 How long does it take for advisories to be reviewed after the corresponding patches are released? In the next sections (Sections 4 and 5 ), we present the methodology used to address these RQs along with the corresponding results. 4. RQ1–RQ4: Users Engagement and Repository Characteristics Understanding how advisories are handled requires examining both the individuals and the projects behind them. GHSA operates as a socio-technical system, in which user roles and repository characteristics influence the way in which vulnerabilities progress through the review pipeline. Thus, in this section, we analyze user engagement and repository characteristics to explain how social and technical factors influence review outcomes (RQ1–RQ4). 4.1. User Roles RQ1: What are the roles of users involved with security advisories? Security advisories involve multiple user roles, each responsible for specific tasks during the vulnerability lifecycle. By analyzing the credits field in GitHub Security Advisories, we identified 10 distinct roles. Table 2 summarizes these roles along with their frequencies and descriptions. This distribution highlights the collaborative and multifaceted nature of handling security vulnerabilities, with a strong emphasis on validation and reporting roles. These roles align with the standardized contributor categories defined in the CVE 5.0 schema, which formalizes how individuals are credited throughout the vulnerability lifecycle ( 18 ; 19 ) . Table 2. Roles observed in GitHub Security Advisories, with their total frequency of occurrence across advisories and their respective descriptions. Role # Occurr. Description Analyst 5,610 Validates the vulnerability to confirm its accuracy or severity. Reporter 2,086 Notifies the vendor or responsible party about the vulnerability. Finder 616 Identifies the vulnerability. Remediation Developer 602 Prepares code changes or remediation plans. Remediation Reviewer 349 Reviews fixes for effectiveness and completeness. Coordinator 236 Facilitates the coordination of the response process. Remediation Verifier 51 Tests and verifies that the vulnerability has been properly resolved. Other 31 Contributes in ways that do not fit into predefined roles. Sponsor 7 Supports the vulnerability identification or remediation process. Tool 3 Refers to tools used in the discovery or identification of vulnerabilities. Key finding for RQ1 The vulnerability management process on GitHub is dominated by Analysts and Reporters , while less frequent roles, such as Remediation Developers , Reviewers , and Coordinators , play crucial parts in later remediation stages, highlighting a clear separation between discovery and resolution. 4.2. Specialization RQ2: Do users tend to specialize in one role? Our analysis of 3,928 users with at least one role revealed that 3,521 (90%) acted in exactly one role, and 407 (10%) acted in multiple roles. Table 3 presents the top three most frequent role combinations for users with n distinct roles. Among multi-role users, 77% combined exactly two roles, with the most frequent combinations being Analyst and Reporter (98 users), Finder and Reporter (47 users), and Remediation Reviewer and Remediation Developer (37 users). Higher role diversity (3–5 roles) typically involved Analyst with remediation-related roles. While most users are specialists, a small group of generalists contribute across multiple roles, potentially bridging tasks across different responsibilities. Table 3. Number of users by count of distinct roles, and the top three most frequent role combinations. # Roles # Users Top Three Combinations (Role Sets with Counts) 1 3521 – 2 313 Analyst + Reporter (98); Finder + Reporter (47); Remediation Reviewer + Remediation Developer (37) 3 72 Finder + Reporter + Analyst (26); Remediation Reviewer + Remediation Developer + Analyst (9); Remediation Developer + Coordinator + Analyst (5) 4 19 Rem. Developer + Rem. Reviewer + Coordinator + Analyst (4); Reporter + Coordinator + Analyst + Remediation Reviewer (2); Remediation Developer + Reporter + Coordinator + Analyst (2) 5 3 Coordinator + Reporter + Rem. Reviewer + Rem. Developer + Analyst (2); Coordinator + Reporter + Finder + Rem. Developer + Analyst (1) Key finding for RQ2 Most participants in GHSAs are highly specialized, with few (10%) taking multiple, related roles such as Analyst , Reporter , and Remediation 4.3. An Actor-Critic Perspective towards Roles RQ3: How does the popularity and engagement of actors (e.g., remediation developers) differ from that of critics (e.g., reviewers)? Table 4 presents the distribution of popularity metrics (followers and stars) across contributor roles in security advisories, based on established platform engagement metrics ( 12 ; 10 ) . Statistics are computed at the credit type occurrence level, where each user contribution is counted independently. We report median values due to highly skewed distributions with substantial outliers. Table 4. Popularity and engagement metrics per role Role # Stars Followers Mean Med. Std Mean Med. Std Analyst 5610 596.16 18 3521.50 178.69 36 608.10 Reporter 2086 429.22 8 2230.90 136.42 16 760.14 Finder 616 391.76 11 1825.58 176.43 22 703.94 Remediation Developer 602 1882.82 59 7386.75 724.68 93.5 2853.51 Remediation Reviewer 349 620.65 30 1853.61 340.77 90 824.25 Coordinator 236 1097.08 34 3532.88 785.40 122 2089.26 Remediation Verifier 51 185.45 38 336.98 222.08 132 276.53 Other 31 431.65 43 973.56 208.23 58 358.67 Sponsor 7 7050.43 0 8793.43 568.71 18 701.85 Tool 3 43.33 13 64.13 52.33 15 72.60 The credit roles reveal a clear capability hierarchy between actors (who produce artifacts) and critics (who validate them). Discovery-phase actors, i.e., finders and reporters , require minimal platform visibility (median 8–22 followers, under 11 stars), suggesting low barriers to entry. In contrast, remediation developers exhibit markedly higher visibility (median 93.5 followers, 59 stars), reflecting the need for maintainer access and established trust to merge security-critical code. Among critics, analysts show modest visibility (median 36 followers, 18 stars) similar to discovery actors, while remediation reviewers and verifiers display substantially higher prominence (median 90–132 followers, 30–38 stars), approaching remediation developer levels. This pattern indicates that while vulnerability discovery and initial analysis are broadly accessible, contributing to remediation and review requires greater platform establishment. Coordinators combine high visibility (median 122 followers) with moderate frequency, indicating experienced community members orchestrate the disclosure process. Key finding for RQ3 Data on the users’ roles reveal a capability hierarchy in vulnerability management. Discovery-phase actors (finders, reporters) and early analysts have modest visibility requirements (median 16–36 followers), whereas remediation-phase actors (developers) and later-stage critics (reviewers, verifiers) require substantially greater platform establishment (median 90–132 followers), likely reflecting trust and access controls around security-critical code changes. 4.4. Repository Characteristics RQ4: What distinguishes GRA-originated advisories from non-GRA advisories in the characteristics of their linked repositories and reviewers? 4.4.1. Dataset To analyze the repositories referenced by GHSA, we used the source_code_location attribute. There are advisories where the same repository URL can appear in different ways; for example, both with the protocol ( https:// ) and without. To address this problem, we normalized the values of this field so that they conform to the format github.com/owner/repo . We also filtered out values that do not refer to a GitHub repository. After this normalization, we ended up with 5,984 distinct GitHub repositories, out of which we analyzed only the 3,779 for which advisories were published after June 2022. For these repositories, using the deps.dev API, we collected the number of stars and open issues, in addition to two security health metrics from the OpenSSF scorecard: the Security-Policy and Maintained scores ( 36 ) . Repositories were classified as GRA-linked if they were associated with at least one GRA; otherwise, they were classified as non-GRA-linked. Figure 1. Repository characteristics box plot. 4.4.2. Analysis Figure 1 compare GRA-linked and non-GRA-linked repositories. Across all metrics, GRA-linked repositories exhibit higher medians. Although variability is large in all dimensions, Mann–Whitney tests confirm that the differences are statistically significant ( p<0.0001 ) with small-to-moderate effect sizes ( |\mathrm{RBC}| up to 0.3). In particular, GRA-linked repositories are more likely to maintain explicit security policies ( \mathrm{RBC}=-0.3 ) and to be more actively maintained ( \mathrm{RBC}=-0.28 ). Complete test statistics for these comparisons are provided in the replication package. We also found that, among the repositories for which we collected the Security-Policy score, 69.3% of GRA-linked repositories have an explicit security policy (i.e., a Security-Policy score greater than zero) ( 36 ) , compared to 39.5% among non-GRA repositories. Key finding 1 for RQ4 Nearly 70% of repositories associated with GRAs include an explicit security policy, compared to only about 40% among non-GRA repositories. Furthermore, to search for additional repository differences, we examined the reviewer experience at review time for GRAs versus other advisories. For each credited reviewer–advisory event, we counted how many GHSA reviews that reviewer had completed before that event (experience). The resulting empirical cumulative distribution functions (ECDFs) are shown in Figure 2 . To ensure consistency with the stabilized advisory pipeline following GitHub’s automation and NVD backfill, we restrict outputs to reviews after June 2022, while experience counts include all prior history. Figure 2. Reviewer experience at review time (ECDF) for GRA vs. non-GRA advisories, and for all advisories combined. The distributions show a notable difference between the groups. For GRA advisories the median prior experience is 0 (at least half of GRA reviews are a reviewer’s first-ever credited GHSA review), and the 90th percentile is 11 . In contrast, non-GRA advisories have a median of 33 prior reviews and a 90th percentile of 379 . Means are likewise separated (GRA: 8.3 vs. non-GRA: 130 ) with higher maxima among non-GRA (297 vs. 622). Visually, the GRA ECDF rises sharply and saturates early, indicating that GRAs are predominantly handled by first-time or low-experience reviewers—consistent with the notion that GRAs are initiated and resolved by repository maintainers. The non-GRA ECDF increases more gradually, reflecting a heavy tail of experienced reviewers. Key finding 2 for RQ4 GRAs are mostly reviewed by low-experience contributors (median prior reviews = 0). 5. RQ5–RQ7: Empirical Characterization of Review Pipeline Understanding how advisories propagate through the GHSA review process requires a clear empirical picture of their distribution, sources, and timing. In this section, we characterize the advisory review pipeline at scale, examining which advisories are reviewed, where they come from, and how their flows evolve over time. This provides the foundation for identifying fast and slow review paths and for modeling the underlying dynamics in later sections. 5.1. Overview Table 5 provides an overview of both the reviewed and the unreviewed advisories, broken down by ecosystem, severity and source. Our dataset spans the period from 2019 to 2025, and includes a total of 288,604 advisories. Out of these, 23,563 advisories (8.2%) were reviewed by GitHub, while 265,041 (91.8%) remain unreviewed. Table 5. Ecosystem of GitHub Security Advisories: reviewed advisories (except for last row), categorized by source and CVSS severity (C = Critical, H = High, M = Medium, L = Low). Ecosystem Total Source Severity GRA NVD Other C H M L Maven 5866 781 5074 11 796 1924 2828 318 Composer 4838 1061 3355 422 514 1283 2761 280 Npm 4082 1080 2220 782 1010 1578 1284 210 Pip 3872 1378 2465 29 497 1490 1578 307 Go 2454 1181 1262 11 260 885 1119 190 Rust 1010 313 475 222 159 377 369 105 Rubygems 943 243 659 41 116 312 448 67 Nuget 723 214 504 5 49 436 211 27 Swift 39 23 16 0 2 21 14 2 Erlang 36 10 24 2 5 10 16 5 Actions 33 31 2 0 7 17 7 2 Pub 12 5 7 0 0 6 3 3 Reviewed 23563 6220 15825 1518 3391 8243 10418 1511 Unreviewed 265041 0 265041 0 23129 102005 124700 10775 Concerning ecosystems, among the reviewed advisories, the Maven, composer and npm ecosystems dominate the dataset. Regarding severities, as the table shows, the majority of advisories are classified in the GHSA database as Medium (M) or High (H), with Critical (C) and Low (L) severity advisories representing a smaller but non-negligible fraction. These severity levels correspond to the qualitative severity rating scale defined in the Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS) ( 21 ) . We also distinguish advisories by source. Among the reviewed advisories, 6,220 advisories (26.4%) originated as GRAs, while 17,343 (73.6%) did not. In addition, 15,825 reviewed advisories (67.2%) originated from the NVD. For the remainder of this work, we focus on reviewed advisories. The following subsections address our research questions about their timing and propagation dynamics (RQ5–RQ7). 5.2. Sources of Advisories RQ5: What are the main sources of GitHub-reviewed advisories, and what is their relative contribution to the review process? We examine the sources of reviewed advisories and their relative contribution to the review process. The platforms that we consider in this analysis are: GHSA, GRA, NVD, FriendsOfPHP, RustSec, PyPA, RubySec and GoVulnDB, with NVD and GRA being the two most prevalent ones ( 14 ) . This list constitutes all external databases listed by GitHub as sources of GHSAs. ( 21 ) 5.2.1. Longitudinal Analysis Figure 3 reports a longitudinal analysis of the advisories. Along with Table 5 , it illustrates that GRAs are both relevant and stable over time—a significant portion of GHSAs originate from GRAs. Yet, despite their prevalence, there is almost no literature dedicated to GRAs. Figure 3. Reviews per month by source Key finding 1 for RQ5 GRAs constitute a stable and persistent source of GHSAs, accounting for roughly one-third of all reviewed advisories. 5.2.2. Flow of Advisories The advisory flow, i.e. the sequence in which advisories appear across platforms, can be represented as a Sankey diagram (Fig. 4 ). We use a methodology similar to that described by Miranda et al. ( 31 ) . Figure 4. Flow of reviewed GHSA across platforms. For each advisory, we consider the sequence of platforms that published it, sorted by publish date. From the sequence, we determine tuples (x,y) where x and y are platforms with distinct consecutive publish dates. The Sankey diagram is generated from the multiset \mathcal{S} of all such tuples, constructed as follows. If platforms x , y and z publish the same advisory on three distinct dates, we add tuples (\mathrm{x},\mathrm{y}) and (\mathrm{y},\mathrm{z}) to \mathcal{S} . If two platforms x and y publish on the same date, they are treated as simultaneous and no tuple is added for that pair. However, if a third platform z publishes later, we add (x,z) and (y,z) to \mathcal{S} . Similarly, if a platform w publishes before x and y , we add (w,x) and (w,y) . The width of each link in Figure 4 is proportional to the frequency the tuples, and represents the intensity of advisory flow between the platforms. The diagram is organized into three levels: links from level 1 to 2 represent initial publication flows, while those from level 2 to 3 represent subsequent propagation steps. We consider only advisories published both in GHSA and in at least one other platform on a distinct date. Key finding 2 for RQ5 Approximately 95% ( 5230/(5230+268+8) ) of all advisory flows that traverse the GRA platform originate from it, following consistent propagation paths from GRA \rightarrow GHSA and from GRA \rightarrow NVD \rightarrow GHSA. 5.3. Time from Publication to Review RQ6: What factors influence the time to review an advisory once it is published in GitHub? 5.3.1. Definition We define time to review as the interval between an advisory’s publish date and its review date ( github_reviewed_at ). For advisories linked to a GRA, the publish date is taken from the GRA; otherwise, we use the GHSA published_at . 5.3.2. Data cleaning and filtering In about 3,500 cases, the recorded review date precedes the publish date, resulting in negative review times. An inspection of these cases shows that they occur exclusively before April 2022, prior to the NVD backfill into GitHub ( 17 ) . Among these negative-time cases, approximately one third were published within one day after review, and a majority of those within a few hours, suggesting coordination effects or timestamp granularity issues (e.g., time zone differences) rather than substantive review-before-publication behavior. Since negative review times are artifacts of metadata timing and are not observed after the backfill cutoff, we restrict our analysis to advisories whose review date is not earlier than the publish date. Table 6. Percentile distribution of time to review (measured in days) for GHSAs, by source. Source P25 P50 P75 P90 P95 P99 GRA (all) 0.22 0.64 2.07 7.09 40.33 747.58 NVD (all) 0.93 35.26 513.03 707.57 834.08 1074.36 GRA post-June 2022 0.18 0.45 1.14 2.95 4.5 59.25 NVD post-June 2022 0.21 0.84 3.86 13.55 146.32 637.98 All reviewed 0.35 2.65 320.74 657.86 715.44 1068.59 Table 7. Mann–Whitney statistical tests for time to review. Comparison RBC p -value GRA (5357) vs NVD (13048) 0.62 <0.0001 GRA (4350) vs NVD (6047) post-June 2022 0.202 <0.0001 5.3.3. Empirical distribution and statistical comparison Table 6 reports time-to-review percentiles. To assess whether the distributions differ across advisory sources, we test the null hypothesis H_{0} that the review lag distributions for GRA and NVD advisories are identical. The alternative hypothesis H_{1} is that they differ. Because review lag data are not normally distributed (D’Agostino’s K^{2} test, p<0.0001 ), we employ the non-parametric Mann–Whitney U test, complemented by the rank-biserial correlation (RBC) to estimate effect size. Table 7 reports the results for both the full dataset and the subset of advisories published after June 2022. Prior to testing, outliers were removed from each group (GRA and NVD) 1 1 1 Outliers are defined as values outside the range [Q_{1}-1.5\times\mathrm{IQR},;Q_{3}+1.5\times\mathrm{IQR}] , where Q_{1} and Q_{3} are the first and third quartiles, and \mathrm{IQR}=Q_{3}-Q_{1} . . The U statistic is computed using the first sample listed (e.g., GRA vs. NVD) as the reference group. Hence, a positive RBC indicates shorter lags for that group. The tests reject the null hypothesis ( p<0.0001 ). The positive \mathrm{RBC} 2 2 2 The \mathrm{RBC} is computed using the formula from Wendt (1972) ( 45 ) , r_{U}=1-2U/(n_{1}n_{2}) , where we set U as the Mann-Whitney statistic for the first sample. indicates that the differences favor faster reviews for GRAs. In the post–May 2022 comparison, for instance, \mathrm{RBC}=0.202 implies that P(X_{\mathrm{GRA}}