The Output Convergence Debate Revisited: Lessons from recent developments in the analysis of panel data models Thanks: This paper was presented as a keynote talk at 19 th International Joint Conference on Computational and Financial Econometrics (CFE) and Computational and Methodological Statistics (CMStatistics), at Birkbeck, University of London, 13-15 December 2025. We are grateful to the conference participants, Daron Acemoglu, Alexander Chudik, Jan Ditzen, and Oscar Jorda for helpful comments, and to Jingshu Chen, a PhD candidate at USC, for excellent research assistance. M. Hashem Pesaran, Ron P. Smith Abstract This paper provides a critical examination of the empirical basis of the output convergence debate in the light of recent developments in the analysis of dynamic heterogeneous panels with interactive effects. It shows that popular tools such as Barro’s cross-country regressions and two-way fixed effects (TWFE) estimators that assume parallel trends and homogeneous dynamics lead to substantial under-estimation of the speed of convergence and misleading inference. Instead, dynamic common correlated effects (DCCE) estimators due to Chudik and Pesaran (2015a) provide consistent estimates and valid inference that are robust to nonparallel trends and correlated heterogeneity and apply even if there are breaks, trends and/or unit roots in the latent technology factor. It also suggests a way to estimate the effect of slowly moving determinants of growth. The theoretical findings are augmented with empirical evidence using Penn World Tables data, finding little evidence of per capita output convergence across countries, very slow evidence of cross country growth convergence, and reasonably fast within country convergence. Capital accumulation is found to be the most important single determinant of cross-country differences in output while slow moving indicators such as potential for conflict and protection of property rights proved to be statistically significant determinants of the steady state levels of output per capita. We are also able to replicate a positive evidence of democratization on output, but we find that the statistical significance of this effect to fall as we allow for nonparallel trends and dynamic heterogeneity. Keywords: Output growth, output convergence, Barro regression, panel data estimators, TWFE and DCCEP, heterogeneity bias, nonparallel trends. JEL Classification: C1, C33, E10, F43, O4 1 Introduction There is an extensive econometric literature on whether log output per capita ( y_{it}) of different countries i=1,2,...,n converges over time t=1,2,...,T and what may determine the level and growth in y_{it} . This paper provides a critical examination of the empirical basis of the output convergence literature in the light of recent developments in the analysis of dynamic heterogeneous panels with interactive effects, which provides the methodology needed to analyse output determination across countries. The paper provides a taxonomy of models of the speed of convergence and potential determinants of growth, time-varying and time-invariant, when the parallel trend and dynamic homogeneity assumptions that are prevalent in this literature are relaxed. It revisits the asymptotic biases of the estimators obtained from Barro (1991) type cross-country regressions of growth on initial output and from two-way fixed effect (TWFE) panel models. The estimate of the speed of convergence obtained from Barro type regressions will be biased towards zero if there are any random differences between countries even if the parallel trend assumption is maintained. The TWFE estimators are robust to random or fixed effects, but continue to result in biased estimates if the parallel trends assumption is relaxed even if dynamic homogeneity is maintained. By adhering to the parallel trends assumption, cross-country regressions as well as TWFE panel estimators require that all countries are affected similarly by the global factors, implying that all countries have the same steady state growth rate. To allow the average growth rate to differ between countries requires interactive time effects, where the loadings on the latent global factor(s) differ across countries and can depend on time-invariant or slowly moving variables like institutions that influence the degree of openness to new ideas. 1 1 1 In this paper, we focus on a single factor that we label technology for exposition, though models with interactive time effects can accomodate multiple factors, including climate. We do not pursue the role of climate change because of the measurement issues involved. Furthermore, to generate the observed pattern of global growth the latent technology factor must be trended. As well as considering time-varying covariates, we distinguish between time-invariant covariates that influence the intercepts, which can only have a one-off impact on growth, and those that influence the loadings on the global factor, which give rise to sustained growth. Nonparallel trends arise naturally if countries are differently placed to benefit from technological progress, due to historical, political or institutional factors. In the presence of nonparallel trends, the TWFE estimator of the speed of convergence is biased downward and this bias does not vanish even if T\rightarrow\infty . More importantly, this paper is the first to show that the TWFE estimator of the speed of convergence tends to zero, irrespective of its true value, if the technology factor is trended, which is required for the world economy to exhibit non-zero output growth. Relaxing the assumption of dynamic homogeneity is another source of the bias when the TWFE estimator is employed; similar to the ones documented by Pesaran and Smith (1995) in the context of fixed effects dynamic panel data models. The empirical importance of dynamic heterogeneity in output convergence regressions was demonstrated by Lee, Pesaran and Smith (1997, 1998) and more recently by, for instance, Ong (2024). The focus of this paper is to provide a systematic methodological investigation of the implications of relaxing the assumptions of parallel trends and dynamic homogeneity that are commonly made in the empirical growth literature. To relax these assumptions we propose the use of correlated common effect (CCE) type estimators instead of the TWFE estimates. The CCE estimator was first advanced by Pesaran (2006) for panels with strictly exogenous regressors, and has since been extended by Kapetanios, Pesaran and Yamagata (2011) to allow for unit roots in the latent factors, and further by Westerlund (2018) to account for deterministic trends amongst the latent factors. The analysis of dynamic panels with latent factors has received less attention. Chudik and Pesaran (2015a) propose dynamic CCE estimators for panels with interactive effects and heterogeneous dynamics. A related paper by Moon and Weidner (2017) proposes least squares estimators that allow for predetermined regressors (including lagged dependent variables), assuming homogeneous slopes and stationary latent factors. Everaert and De Groote (2016) have also considered CCE type estimators for panels with homogeneous dynamics. However, all these papers that allow for dynamics assume the latent factors are stationary, which is restrictive for the analysis of convergence in the case of growing economies. Assuming dynamic homogeneity, we show that the CCE estimator for the speed of convergence is consistent irrespective of whether the global technological factor is stationary or trended. The trend could be stochastic, with or without a drift, or could even be subject to a number of breaks. We refer to this estimator as DCCEP, to highlight the dynamics and the pooled nature of the underlying panel data model. We also consider a mean group version of DCCE, which we denote by DCCEMG, that allows for heterogeneous slopes, which applies generally to dynamics and the effects of time-varying covariates such as capital stocks across countries. 2 2 2 Chudik and Pesaran (2015b) provide a survey of CCE type estimators, more recently, in a special issue of The Journal of Econometrics on panel data analysis introduced by Sarafidis and Wansbeek (2021) there are a number of CCE related papers including Juodis, Karabiyik and Westerlund (2021) on the robustness of the pooled CCE estimator. In comparing Barro, TWFE, and DCCE type estimates, it is important to be clear that while all these methods aim to estimate the same “cross-country average speed of convergence”, they differ in their treatment of parameter heterogeneity across countries. Barro regressions provide an estimate of it under the assumption of full parameter homogeneity. Were it true that there was full parameter homogeneity, convergence would be to a single level of output for all countries. Were it not true, the estimate of the average speed of convergence will be biased towards zero. Similarly, TWFE regressions provide an estimate of it under the assumption that all countries have the same steady state growth rates. Were this true, convergence, would be to country specific parallel trends for output. Were this not true, the estimated average speed of convergence will again be biased towards zero. The Barro or TWFE biases are asymptotic, not reduced by more information. In contrast, DCCE type estimates, with or without the assumption of dynamic homogeneity, focus on the average speed of convergence to country-specific output paths, and do not impose that countries converge in either per capita outputs or growth rates. With this in mind, we quantify the size of the biases of Barro and TWFE estimates of the speed of convergence using Penn World Table data on log output per capita (and per employee) covering 157 countries over seventy years, 1950-2019. Both unconditional and conditional Barro regressions have speeds of convergence that range between 0.3 and 0.5 per cent implying mean lags that fall between 171 and 316 years, suggesting that there is little evidence of cross country output convergence. TWFE estimates of the speed of convergence, that relate to an assumed common growth path across countries, are around 3 per cent with implied mean lags of around 25 years. In contrast, the DCCEMG estimates of speed of convergence that relate to country-specific output paths are much higher, around 14 per cent with mean lags of around 6 years, corresponding to business cycle frequencies documented in the time series literature. For example, according to NBER (National Bureau of Economic Research) the average duration of business cycle in the U.S. over the period 1945-2020 has been around 75 months or 6.25 years. 3 3 3 See https://www.nber.org/research/data/us-business-cycle-expansions-and-contractions Similar results are also found for G7 and OECD countries. See, for example, Chuavet and Yu (2006) who also show that there exists a significant degree of synchronization of business cycles across countries driven partly by globalization and common shocks like total factor productivity shifts. 4 4 4 Chuavet and Yu (2006, Table 2) report average expansion and recession durations for OECD and G7 countries over the period 1960Q1-2000Q1. For OECD their estimate of average business cycle duration is 7 years. The rise in the estimated average speed of convergence as we relax parallel trends and dynamic homogeneity is in line with our theoretical findings, and highlight the important differences across the models that underlie them. For determinants of growth in the long run, we focus on capital stock as the primary time-varying covariate. We argue that the DCCEMG estimators of the long run effect of capital on output is reliable, despite endogeneity concerns, since CCE type estimators allow global latent factors to simultaneously drive both capital and output variables and thus filter out the common sources of dependence between capital and output. Focussing on DCCEMG, the long run estimate of capital coefficient is around 0.48 , which is quite close to the average share of capital at 0.46 , obtained from PWT data. As an example of slowly moving variables we considered years of schooling as a proxy for human capital. We found that education variable was only statistically significant when the capital stock variable was excluded, and the panel was estimated by DCCEP. Trying other variations, such as adding lagged values of the education variable or interacting it with global output did not made any difference. It is likely that years of schooling is not a satisfactory measure of human capital and further investigation is needed before a definite conclusion can be reached. We also consider the effects of democracy on output using Acemoglu, Naidu, Restrepo, and Robinson, (2019) replication data and their specification. This is an important example where the democracy variable is time-varying only for half of the countries in the panel. In our empirical investigation of the effects of democracy we also exclude countries with less than 20 time series data points for estimation, otherwise it would not be possible to relax the parallel trends assumption. This gives a sample of 148 rather than 175 countries used by Acemoglu et al. (2019). We find the TWFE estimates of the long run effect of democracy on output to be very similar in size and significance to the ones they report. However, when the parallel trend assumption is relaxed, the DCCEP estimate of the long run effect of democracy is reduced in size and becomes statistically insignificant. We apply our suggested procedure for time-invariant variables after removing the time-varying effects using either TWFE or DCCEP estimates. From the large number of suggested determinants of the level or growth of output we choose: an indicator of geography, absolute latitude; an indicator of the potential for conflict, namely ethnolinguistic fractionalization, and an indicator of property rights, protection from expropriation . Whether TWFE or DCCEP estimates are used to filter out the effects of the time-varying covariates, we find ethnolinguistic fractionalization and protection from expropriation to be statistically significant with the expected signs. Latitude was not statistically significant for both filtering procedures. Related Literature: In the vast literature on economic growth, there are many strands. A quantitative literature initiated by Baumol (1986) and Barro (1991), and more recently Kremer, Willis, and You (2022) is concerned with modelling convergence in per-capita output across countries. Another quantitative strand associated with Acemoglu and coauthors has emphasised the role of institutions and methods of identifying causality. A third strand is concerned with understanding sustained economic growth propelled by technological progress implemented through a process of learning and innovation. This strand involved theoretical work by Aghion and Howitt (1992) on how the new technology surpasses the old through a process of creative destruction. In terms of the econometric methods, the early contribution by Baumol (1986) opened the debate. It used a cross-country regression of country growth rates on initial income and interpreted the coefficient on initial income, beta, as a measure of ”unconditional” or absolute convergence. Barro (1991), Mankiw Romer and Weil (1992) and Barro and Sala-i-Martin (1992) added initial covariates and interpreted the coefficient on initial income as a measure of ”conditional” convergence to country specific steady states. Nerlove (1998, 1999) labelled such cross-country regressions Baumol-Barro regressions, but we will follow the common usage and call them Barro regressions. Before allowing for convergence using a Barro type model, Mankiw, Romer and Weil (1991) estimated a cross-country regression that did not include initial income, which explained log GDP per working age person in 1985 by corresponding values of Solow variables like investment and population growth. Similarly, Acemoglu, Johnson and Robinson (2001) estimate a cross-country regression explaining log per capita output in 1995 as a function of a measure of institutions and time-invariant variables like latitude, but not initial income. Such regressions are not informative about convergence and it is not clear how one chooses a particular year. Maseland (2021) examines the movement over time in the coefficients of 43 such ”deep” determinants used by Acemoglu et al. (2001) finding the effect of many of them, including latitude, increasing from around 1960 until about 2000, around when the paper was published, and then declining. Barro regressions were criticised on a number of counts. It was argued that such cross section snapshots were not be informative about time series processes and that, so called, ”beta convergence”, a negative coefficient on initial income in this regression, does not imply ”sigma convergence” a falling variance of incomes across countries. In Barro regressions any intercept heterogeneity is inherently correlated because it is inherited by the regressor, namely initial income. As a result, the estimated speed of convergence is downward biased unless the country specific intercepts are identical. This bias is present even if the intercepts are randomly distributed independently of all errors. To the extent that including covariates reduces the variance of the intercepts, making them more similar, the bias is reduced. Thus estimates of the speed of convergence in what are called conditional convergence regressions are less biased towards zero than in unconditional ones. Similar issues arise with dynamic heterogeneity in the coefficients of lagged dependent variables which are inherently correlated with the regressors. The title of Nerlove (1998) posed a central question: ”growth rate convergence, fact or artifact?” Like him we will argue that such regressions are badly biased. However, repeated criticisms of Barro regressions, including that by Friedman (1992) who asked ”Do old fallacies ever die?”, did not kill them and they have been recently resurrected by Kremer et al. (2022). But we hope the econometric analysis that we provide will put one last nail in the coffin. Subsequent literature, such as Islam (1995), used panels with country and time effects. These widely used two-way fixed effects panel data models, also known as fixed-effect, time-effect, imposed a parallel trend assumption, which we will relax. After a rapid growth in the literature, interest waned because there seemed little evidence for ”unconditional” convergence and while there was evidence for ”conditional” convergence, specification of the appropriate covariates was problematic. An early survey is Temple (1999). Durlauf (2009) documents ”The rise and fall of cross-country growth regressions”. Subsequent papers such as Barro (2015) and Acemoglu et al. (2019) have argued for the importance of institutions, such as democracy, in panel studies of conditional convergence. After an extensive survey, Johnson and Papageorgiou (2020) concluded that ”there is a broad consensus of no evidence supporting absolute convergence in cross-country per capita incomes — that is poor countries do not seem to be unconditionally catching up to rich ones.” However, that consensus was challenged in papers by Kremer et al. (2022), and Patel, Sandefur and Subramanian (2021). Kremer et al. (2022) resurrected Barro regressions and claimed that these provided evidence for unconditional convergence since 2000, if not from earlier dates, and argued that while conditional convergence held throughout the period, absolute convergence did not hold initially, but as human capital and policies improved in poorer countries, the difference in institutions across countries has shrunk, leading to unconditional convergence, a conclusion we challenge. Smith (2024) provides a recent review of some of the econometric methods used in the convergence literature. Outline of the paper: The rest of the paper is set out as follows: Section 2 provides an overview of the models of output convergence. Section 3 onwards considers estimation methods. Section 3 investigates the bias of the Barro cross-country regression when there is intercept heterogeneity with and without conditioning on time-invariant covariates. Section 4 , examines the bias of the TWFE estimator when the assumption of parallel trends is relaxed. Section 5 considers estimation of models with nonparallel trends and homogeneous dynamics using the DCCEP estimator. Section 6 considers estimation of models with nonparallel trends and heterogeneous dynamics using the DCCEMG estimator. Section 7 considers time-varying covariates, like capital. Section 8 considers the identification and estimation of the coefficients of time-invariant variables, like geography, or slowly moving ones like climate or institutions. Section 9 examines the quantitative importance of the theoretical results using data from the Penn World Tables and the replication files of Acemoglu et al. (2019) and Kremer et al. (2022). Section 10 contains some concluding remarks. 2 An overview of models of output convergence This section provides an overview of the models that will be examined to provide context for the subsequent discussion of estimation methods. To simplify the exposition here we assume balanced panels, but use both balanced and unbalanced panels in our empirical analysis, depending on the estimation procedure under consideration. Much of the literature can be related to the widely used TWFE autoregressive (AR) panel data model. Assuming a linear specification with first-order dynamics, the baseline panel model is: y_{it}=\alpha_{i}+f_{t}+\rho y_{i,t-1}+u_{it}, (1) where y_{it} is the logarithm of per capita output in countries i=1,2,...,n, at time periods t=1,2,...,T, with \left|\rho\right|<1 . The \alpha_{i} are heterogeneous country-specific intercepts. The time effect, f_{t} , can be viewed as a latent global factor, such as technology, assumed here to have the same effects on y_{it} across all i. Thus without loss of generality the TWFE specification ( 1 ) can be written equivalently in deviation form as y_{it}-g_{t}=\alpha_{i}+\rho\left(y_{i,t-1}-g_{t-1}\right)+u_{it}, (2) where f_{t}=g_{t}-\rho g_{t-1} and g_{t}=\sum_{s=0}^{\infty}\rho^{s}f_{t-s} (3) In this representation, and given that \left|\rho\right|<1 , then for each i=1,2,...,n E\left(y_{it}-g_{t}\right)=\frac{\alpha_{i}}{1-\rho},\text{ and }E\left(\Delta y_{it}\right)=E\left(\Delta g_{t}\right). Thus under the TWFE specification, unless \alpha_{i}=\alpha all i, there is no unconditional convergence. Log output paths will be parallel to one another, with all countries having the same mean output growth, the so called ”parallel trend” assumption. The parallel trend assumption can be relaxed by allowing heterogeneous loadings on the global factor giving a more general, interactive time effects, specification where f_{t} is replaced by \gamma_{i}f_{t} , with \gamma_{i} representing the factor loading for country i . 5 5 5 As noted above, given the growth context for exposition we treat there as being a single global factor. But it easily generalises to a multi-factor model: \boldsymbol{\gamma}_{i}^{\prime}\mathbf{f}_{t} , with \mathbf{f}_{t} representing a vector of latent variables, and \boldsymbol{\gamma}_{i} the associated vector of factor loadings. With the parallel trend assumption relaxed, mean output growth will no longer be equal across countries and we have E\left(\Delta y_{it}\right)=\gamma_{i}\sum_{s=0}^{\infty}\rho^{s}E\left(\Delta f_{t-s}\right), which simplifies to E\left(\Delta y_{it}\right)=(1-\rho)^{-1}\gamma_{i}E\left(\Delta f_{t}\right), if \Delta f_{t} is stationary. Equivalently, relaxing the parallel trend assumption using the deviation form, ( 2 ), we have E\left(\Delta y_{it}\right)=\gamma_{i}E\left(\Delta g_{t}\right) . The two representations of the cross-country mean growth rates are equivalent given ( 3 ). Differences in factor loadings across countries could be due to differences in trade, capital and immigration policies across countries due to geopolitical and other considerations. We discuss the implications of differences in factor loadings in Section 4 . In practice, these loadings could also vary over time, thus introducing another degree of complexity in the analysis of output convergence. Assuming that \rho lies in the range (-1,+1) , the parameter of interest is \phi=1-\rho>0 , which measures the speed of convergence of y_{it}-\gamma_{i}g_{t} to its steady state value of E\left(y_{it}-\gamma_{i}g_{t}\right)=\left(1-\rho\right)^{-1}\alpha_{i} . For estimation, or when there are higher order lags, it is more convenient to work with the error correction representations of ( 1 ) or ( 2 ) given by \Delta y_{it}=\alpha_{i}+\gamma_{i}f_{t}-\phi y_{i,t-1}+u_{it},\text{ or }\Delta\left(y_{it}-\gamma_{i}g_{t}\right)=\alpha_{i}-\phi\left(y_{i,t-1}-\gamma_{i}g_{t-1}\right)+u_{it}. (4) In these specifications it is assumed that country-specific error terms, u_{it} , are serially uncorrelated and cross-sectionally independent with mean zero and variances \sigma_{iu}^{2} , for i=1,2,...,n that vary across countries but are fixed over time. Assuming u_{it} are cross-sectionally independent could be problematic even if interactive time effects are included in the panel, since there may be spatial or spill-over effects that cannot be eliminated by use of factors. See Pesaran and Xie (2026). Higher order dynamics might be required to allow for possible serial correlation in u_{it} . In practice, this is achieved by adding lagged values of the output growth variables to the error correction representations, ( 4 ). Assuming a p^{th} order panel AR for log output y_{it}=\alpha_{i}+\gamma_{i}f_{t}+{\textstyle\sum_{\ell=1}^{p}}\rho_{\ell}y_{i,t-\ell}+u_{it} (5) yields the following p-1 order panel error correction specification \Delta y_{it}=\alpha_{i}+\gamma_{i}f_{t}-\phi y_{i,t-1}+\sum_{\ell=1}^{p-1}\psi_{\ell}\Delta y_{i,t-\ell}+u_{it}, (6) where \phi=1-{\textstyle\sum_{\ell=1}^{p}}\rho_{\ell} . As we shall see the choice of the lag order, p , plays an important role for the empirical validity of some of the estimation procedures. One prominent example arises when Barro regressions are used to estimate \phi , which requires that there is only a single lag, in addition to a number of other assumptions that will be discussed below in some detail. The TWFE specification, ( 1 ), and its extension in ( 6 ) imposes that all countries converge to their steady state per capita output levels at the same speed, \phi , which is a rather strong assumption. Countries differ in their political institutions and climatic conditions which affect the speed with which they adapt to shocks. We discuss the implications of these assumptions in Section 6 . Accordingly, we also consider a fully heterogeneous version of ( 6 ) that allows for \phi and \psi_{\ell} to differ across i , namely \Delta y_{it}=\alpha_{i}+\gamma_{i}f_{t}-\phi_{i}y_{i,t-1}+\sum_{\ell=1}^{p-1}\psi_{i,\ell}\Delta y_{i,t-\ell}+u_{it}. (7) The parameter of interest is the average speed of convergence across countries, defined by E(\phi_{i}) . Adding a vector of time-varying covariates, \mathbf{x}_{it} , is straightforward giving an error correction model of the form: \displaystyle\Delta y_{it} \displaystyle=\alpha_{i}+\gamma_{i}f_{t}-\phi_{y,i}y_{i,t-1}+\sum_{\ell=1}^{p-1}\psi_{y,i,\ell}\Delta y_{i,t-\ell} (8) \displaystyle+\boldsymbol{\phi}_{x,i}^{\prime}\mathbf{x}_{it}+\sum_{\ell=1}^{p-1}\boldsymbol{\psi}_{x,i,\ell}^{\prime}\Delta\mathbf{x}_{i,t-\ell}+u_{it}. In addition to the time-varying \mathbf{x}_{it}, the literature has emphasised the importance of covariates that do not vary over time or vary very slowly. These may influence the intercepts \alpha_{i}, which under the parallel trends assumption are the main source of differences in steady state output levels. Once the parallel trend assumption is relaxed, it is the differences in output growth paths, \gamma_{i}f_{t}, that will matter, since countries that are on different growth paths will diverge and differences in \alpha_{i} will be of secondary importance. It is the differences in \gamma_{i} across i\ that determine the changing dispersion of output per capita across countries. In our empirical analysis we consider the following models for the determination of \alpha_{i} and \gamma_{i}: \displaystyle\alpha_{i} \displaystyle=\alpha_{\alpha}+\boldsymbol{\theta}_{\alpha}^{\prime}\mathbf{z}_{i\alpha}+\eta_{i\alpha,} (9) \displaystyle\gamma_{i} \displaystyle=\alpha_{\gamma}+\boldsymbol{\theta}_{\gamma}^{\prime}\mathbf{z}_{i\gamma}+\eta_{i\gamma}, (10) where \mathbf{z}_{i\alpha} and \mathbf{z}_{i\gamma} are likely to include climatic, institutional or policy variables; \eta_{i\alpha} and \eta_{i\gamma} are random errors, representing the unexplained parts of \alpha_{i} and \gamma_{i}; and \alpha_{a},\alpha_{\gamma}, \mathbf{\theta}_{\alpha} and \mathbf{\theta}_{\gamma} are fixed coefficients. There is an important difference between the two types of variables, \mathbf{z}_{i\alpha} and \mathbf{z}_{i\gamma} . Changes in the latter could induce growth effects that are sustained, whilst the effects of changing \mathbf{z}_{i\alpha} , could at best result in a once and for all change in the level of output, without generating sustained growth effects. Thus policies that change the value of \gamma_{i} are likely to have more fundamental impacts on output. Abstracting from time-varying effects, and for simplicity assuming that \mathbf{z}_{i\alpha} and \mathbf{z}_{i\gamma} have no variables in common, then using ( 9 ) and ( 10 ) in ( 7 ) and averaging over t we have a_{iT}=\bar{y}_{i\circ}-{\textstyle\sum_{\ell=1}^{p}}\rho_{i,\ell}\bar{y}_{i,-\ell}=\alpha_{T}+\boldsymbol{\theta}_{T}^{\prime}\mathbf{z}_{i}+\eta_{iT}+\bar{u}_{i\circ}, (11) where \bar{y}_{i,-\ell}=T^{-1}\sum_{t=1}^{T}y_{i,t-\ell} , \alpha_{T}=\alpha_{\alpha}+\alpha_{\gamma}\bar{f}_{T} , \boldsymbol{\theta}_{T}=(\boldsymbol{\theta}_{\alpha}^{\prime},\boldsymbol{\theta}_{\gamma}^{\prime}\bar{f}_{T})^{\prime} , \mathbf{z}_{i}= \left(\mathbf{z}_{i\alpha}^{\prime},\mathbf{z}_{i\gamma}^{\prime}\right)^{\prime} , \eta_{iT}=\eta_{i\alpha}+\eta_{i\gamma}\bar{f}_{T} , and \bar{u}_{i\circ}=T^{-1}\sum_{t=1}^{T}u_{it} . Equation ( 8 ) could also be used to filter the dynamics. Therefore, in principle the time-invariant effects, \boldsymbol{\theta}_{T} , can be identified using cross-country regressions where the dynamics have been filtered out, and \mathbf{z}_{i} are distributed independently of the composite errors, \eta_{iT}+\bar{u}_{i\circ} . We shall return to the problem of identification and estimation of time-invariant effects in Section 8 . 3 Estimation of the speed of convergence by Barro regressions We begin with the Barro regression. This can be interpreted in terms of the panel AR(1) model given by ( 1 ) assuming u_{it} are serially uncorrelated and cross-sectionally independent, and the fixed effects, \alpha_{i} , follow a random coefficient specification. The unconditional Barro regression involves running a cross-country regression of y_{iT}-y_{i0} on an intercept and y_{i0} . The estimate of \phi=1-\rho is then recovered from the least squares estimate of the coefficient of y_{i0} . Specifically, the unconditional Barro regression can be written as y_{iT}-y_{i0}=a_{T}-(1-\rho^{T})y_{i0}+v_{iT}, (12) where it is assumed that the panel is balanced in the sense that y_{i0} and y_{iT} are available for all i . In addition to assuming homogeneous dynamics, the Barro regression also requires y_{i0} and v_{iT} are independently distributed. To investigate the relationship of Barro regressions to the TWFE panel data model, we assume 6 6 6 Recall that under parallel trends, assumed when using Barro regressions, \gamma_{i}=\gamma and only \alpha_{i} is affected by time-invariant variables, \mathbf{z}_{i} \alpha_{i}=\alpha+\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\prime}\mathbf{z}_{i}+\eta_{i}, (13) and eliminate the latent factor, f_{t} , from ( 1 ) by use of cross section averages. Averaging y_{it} given by ( 1 ), and augmented by ( 13 ) over i we have \bar{y}_{\circ t}=\alpha+\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\prime}\mathbf{\bar{z}}+\bar{\eta}+f_{t}+\rho\bar{y}_{\circ,t-1}+\bar{u}_{\circ t}, (14) where \bar{y}_{\circ t}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}y_{it} , \bar{u}_{\circ t}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}u_{it} , \mathbf{\bar{z}}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\mathbf{z}_{i}, and \bar{\eta}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\eta_{i} . Then f_{t} can be eliminated by subtracting ( 14 ) from ( 1 ) to obtain y_{it}-\bar{y}_{\circ t}=\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\prime}(\mathbf{z}_{i}-\mathbf{\bar{z}})+\rho\left(y_{i,t-1}-\bar{y}_{\circ,t-1}\right)+u_{it}-\bar{u}_{\circ t}+\left(\eta_{i}-\bar{\eta}\right). (15) Now solving forward from the initial values y_{i0}-\bar{y}_{0} , where \bar{y}_{0}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}y_{i0} , we have \displaystyle y_{iT}-\bar{y}_{\circ T} \displaystyle=\rho^{T}\left(y_{i0}-\bar{y}_{0}\right)+\left(\frac{1-\rho^{T}}{1-\rho}\right)\left[\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\prime}(\mathbf{z}_{i}-\mathbf{\bar{z}})+\left(\eta_{i}-\bar{\eta}\right)\right] (16) \displaystyle+\sum_{s=0}^{T-1}\rho^{s}\left(u_{i,T-s}-\bar{u}_{\circ,T-s}\right), After some rearrangements, ( 16 ) can be written equivalently as y_{iT}-y_{i0}=a_{T}+b_{T}y_{i0}+\mathbf{c}_{T}^{\prime}\mathbf{z}_{i}+\zeta_{iT}, (17) where a_{T}=\bar{y}_{\circ T}-\rho^{T}\bar{y}_{0}-\left(\frac{1-\rho^{T}}{1-\rho}\right)\left(\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\prime}\mathbf{\mathbf{\bar{z}}+}\bar{\eta}\right)-\sum_{s=0}^{T-1}\rho^{s}\bar{u}_{\circ,T-s}, (18) b_{T}=-(1-\rho^{T}),\text{ \ \ }\mathbf{c}_{T}=\left(\frac{1-\rho^{T}}{1-\rho}\right)\boldsymbol{\theta}\mathbf{,} (19) and \zeta_{iT}=\left(\frac{1-\rho^{T}}{1-\rho}\right)\eta_{i}+\sum_{s=0}^{T-1}\rho^{s}u_{i,T-s}. (20) Comparing this representation with the Barro regression given by ( 12 ), we note that ( 17 ) coincides with what is known as conditional Barro regression and reduces to unconditional Barro regression when \boldsymbol{\theta}=\mathbf{0} . The parameters of Barro regressions are b_{T} and \mathbf{c}_{T} , and \rho and \boldsymbol{\theta} are not directly estimated when one runs a standard conditional Barro regression. However, \phi and \boldsymbol{\theta} can be estimated using (recalling that \left|\rho\right|<1 , by assumption) \displaystyle\phi \displaystyle=1-\rho=1-\left(1+b_{T}\right)^{1/T} \displaystyle\boldsymbol{\theta} \displaystyle\mathbf{=}\left(\frac{1-\rho}{1-\rho^{T}}\right)\mathbf{c}_{T}=-\left[\frac{1-\left(1+b_{T}\right)^{1/T}}{b_{T}}\right]\mathbf{c}_{T}. Clearly, a_{T} and \mathbf{c}_{T} varies with T but not \phi and \mathbf{\theta} . For comparability with pooled panel estimates of \mathbf{\theta} when reporting Barro’s estimates one needs to report estimates of \boldsymbol{\theta} , in addition to the estimates of b_{T} and \mathbf{c}_{T} that are routinely reported in the literature. It is also clear that estimates of \phi and \boldsymbol{\theta} based on Barro’s regression estimates of b_{T} and \mathbf{c}_{T} will be biased, due to the non-zero correlations between y_{i0} and \zeta_{iT} , and between y_{i0} and \mathbf{z}_{i}, as established below. Considering ( 16 ), there are a number of distinct possible sources of bias which come from the correlation between either of the regressors y_{i0} and \mathbf{z}_{i} and any of the three elements of the composite error term of the Barro regression, namely \left(\frac{1-\rho^{T}}{1-\rho}\right)\eta_{i}, \sum_{s=0}^{T-1}\rho^{s}u_{i,T-s} and \sum_{s=0}^{T-1}\rho^{s}\bar{u}_{T-s}. Below we show that as long as \sigma_{\eta}^{2}\neq 0, then any heterogeneity in the \alpha_{i} , even if it is random, will cause bias because of the inevitable correlation between initial output y_{i0} and \eta_{i}, the random component of \alpha_{i} . In addition, serial correlation in the u_{it} will cause y_{i0} to become correlated with cross section averages of u_{iT},u_{i,T-1},.... In the case of \mathbf{z}_{i}, while the shocks - pandemics, revolutions and the like - may be exogenous, many of the elements of \mathbf{z}_{i} are likely to be adaptive to past shocks, causing them to be correlated with them. 3.1 Asymptotic bias of the Barro estimator For the OLS estimator of b_{T} from ( 17 ) to be consistent it is required that E\left(y_{i0}\zeta_{iT}\right)=0 , for i=1,2,...,n; irrespective of whether we consider unconditional or conditional Barro regressions. When conditioning variables are added to the regression it is also required that E(\mathbf{z}_{i}\zeta_{iT})=0 . Both of these conditions involve restrictions on the way initial values, y_{i0}, are generated. Since the random component of \alpha_{i} , namely \eta_{i} , is specific to country i it is likely that y_{i0} will also depend on \eta_{i} . Such a dependence arises irrespective of whether the \left\{y_{it}\right\} processes have started from a finite past prior to the initial date t=0 , or from a very distant past. It also does not matter if the countries differ in their start dates, say at time t=-M_{i} , where M_{i} is a positive integer. In this general set up, supposing country i was established (started) with y_{i,-M_{i}} at time t=-M_{i} , then iterating ( 1 ) forward from y_{i,-M_{i}} , (similar to the way equation ( 16 ) was derived) we obtain \displaystyle y_{i0}-\bar{y}_{0} \displaystyle=\rho^{M_{i}}(y_{i,-M_{i}}-\bar{y}_{\circ,-M_{i}})+\left(\frac{1-\rho^{M_{i}}}{1-\rho}\right)\left[\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\prime}(\mathbf{z}_{i}-\mathbf{\bar{z}})+\left(\eta_{i}-\bar{\eta}\right)\right] (21) \displaystyle+\sum_{s=0}^{M_{i}-1}\rho^{s}(u_{i,-s}-u_{\circ,-s}). Under the panel AR(1) model ( 1 ) u_{it} are serially uncorrelated. As a first order approximation it is also plausible to assume that u_{it} is distributed independently of f_{t} , \eta_{i} and \mathbf{z}_{i} . Even under these assumptions, using ( 20 ), we have a non-zero correlation between y_{i0} and \zeta_{iT} . Specifically, E\left(y_{i0}\zeta_{iT}\right)=\left(\frac{1-\rho^{T}}{1-\rho}\right)\left(\frac{1-\rho^{M_{i}}}{1-\rho}\right)\sigma_{\eta}^{2}, (22) where \sigma_{\eta}^{2}=var(\eta_{i}) , and renders Barro regression estimators of \phi and \boldsymbol{\theta} inconsistent if \sigma_{\eta}^{2}>0 , irrespective of whether the regression is estimated unconditionally or conditional on \mathbf{z}_{i} . The magnitude of the bias could depend on the conditioning variables used and whether they are uncorrelated with u_{it} . 7 7 7 The endogeneity of the conditioning variables, which has been widely discussed in the literature, is not essential for the bias which arises if \sigma_{\eta}^{2}>0, which can be allowed for by using TWFE in a model with parallel trends. We now derive the asymptotic bias of the unconditional Barro estimator of \rho_{0} the true value of \rho, which is obtained as the least squares estimator of b_{T}=-(1-\rho_{0}^{T}) from the OLS regression of y_{iT}-y_{i0} on y_{i0}-\bar{y}_{0} , namely \hat{b}_{T}=\frac{\sum_{i=1}^{n}\left(y_{i0}-\bar{y}_{0}\right)\left(y_{iT}-y_{i0}\right)}{\sum_{i=1}^{n}\left(y_{i0}-\bar{y}_{0}\right)^{2}}, recalling that \bar{y}_{\circ 0}= n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}y_{i0} . Then using ( 17 ) \displaystyle\hat{b}_{T}-b_{T} \displaystyle=\frac{n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\left(y_{i0}-\bar{y}_{0}\right)\left(\mathbf{c}_{T}^{\prime}\mathbf{z}_{i}+\zeta_{iT}\right)}{n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\left(y_{i0}-\bar{y}_{0}\right)^{2}} \displaystyle\rightarrow_{p}\frac{\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}E\left[\left(y_{i0}-\bar{y}_{0}\right)\left(\mathbf{c}_{T}^{\prime}\mathbf{z}_{i}+\zeta_{iT}\right)\right]}{\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}E\left(y_{i0}-\bar{y}_{0}\right)^{2}}. To simplify the derivations we assume that M_{i}\rightarrow\infty for all i (all processes have started in a distant past with \left|\rho\right|<1 ) and note that in this case, using ( 21 ), we have y_{i0}-\bar{y}_{0}=\left(\frac{1}{1-\rho_{0}}\right)\left[\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\prime}\left(\mathbf{z}_{i}-\mathbf{\bar{z}}\right)+\eta_{i}-\bar{\eta}\right]+\sum_{s=0}^{\infty}\rho_{0}^{s}\left(u_{i,-s}-\bar{u}_{\circ,-s}\right). Using this result together with ( 20 ) and noting that u_{it} and \eta_{i} are assumed to be cross-sectionally independent we obtain E\left[\left(y_{i0}-\bar{y}_{0}\right)\left(\mathbf{c}_{T}^{\prime}\mathbf{z}_{i}+\zeta_{iT}\right)\right]=\frac{\left(1-\rho_{0}^{T}\right)}{\left(1-\rho_{0}\right)^{2}}\left[\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\prime}Var\left(\mathbf{z}_{i}\right)\boldsymbol{\theta}\mathbf{+}\sigma_{\eta}^{2}-E\left(\eta_{i}\bar{\eta}\right)\right]. (23) But since \eta_{i} are independently distributed then E\left(\eta_{i}\bar{\eta}\right)=n^{-1}\sigma_{\eta}^{2} . Similarly E\left(y_{i0}-\bar{y}_{0}\right)^{2}=\frac{1-\rho_{0}^{T}}{\left(1-\rho_{0}\right)^{2}}\left[\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\prime}Var\left(\mathbf{z}_{i}\right)\boldsymbol{\theta}\mathbf{+}\sigma_{\eta}^{2}\right]+\frac{\sigma_{iu}^{2}}{1-\rho_{0}^{2}}+O(n^{-1}). Hence, as n\rightarrow\infty \hat{b}_{T}-b_{T}=\hat{\rho}^{T}-\rho_{0}^{T}\rightarrow_{p}\frac{\frac{\left(1-\rho_{0}^{T}\right)\left(1+\rho_{0}\right)}{1-\rho}\left(\frac{\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\prime}\boldsymbol{\Omega}_{z}\boldsymbol{\theta}\mathbf{+}\sigma_{\eta}^{2}}{\bar{\sigma}_{u}^{2}}\right)}{1+\left(\frac{1+\rho_{0}}{1-\rho_{0}}\right)\left(\frac{\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\prime}\boldsymbol{\Omega}_{z}\boldsymbol{\theta}\mathbf{+}\sigma_{\eta}^{2}}{\bar{\sigma}_{u}^{2}}\right)}>0, (24) where \mathbf{\Omega}_{z}=\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}Var\left(\mathbf{z}_{i}\right)\text{, and }\bar{\sigma}_{u}^{2}=\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\sigma_{iu}^{2} The magnitude of the bias, \hat{\rho}^{T}-\rho_{0}^{T}, depends on \rho_{0}, T and the ratio \left(\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\prime}\boldsymbol{\Omega}_{z}\boldsymbol{\theta}\mathbf{+}\sigma_{\eta}^{2}\right)/\bar{\sigma}_{u}^{2} , which represent the size of cross section dispersions relative to the average of the time series dispersions. If we set this ratio to unity, the bias of the Barro estimator is (1-\rho_{0}^{T})(1+\rho_{0})/2 , which could be substantial considering that \rho_{0} is likely to be close to 1 . For instance, if \rho_{0}=0.8, and T=10 , then the asymptotic bias of estimating \rho_{0}^{T} is given by (1-\rho_{0}^{T})(1+\rho_{0})/2=0.803, which implies \hat{\rho}\rightarrow_{p}0.99, namely a convergence rate of 1\% instead of the actual value of 20\% . 8 8 8 Since \hat{\rho}^{T}-\rho^{T}\rightarrow_{p}0.803, \hat{\rho}^{T}\rightarrow_{p}0.803+\rho^{10}=0.803+0.1074=0.9103. \hat{\rho}^{T}=0.9103 implies \hat{\rho}\rightarrow_{p}0.9883. Also the bias in \hat{b}_{T} is upward for any T , and rises with T since \left|\rho\right|<1 . The longer the time series data the more pronounced the bias of the Barro estimator will become. 9 9 9 Kremer et al. (2022, p338) using T=10 found divergence in income per capita at a rate of 0.5\% annually for 1985 to 1995 then convergence at rate 0.7\% from 2005-2015. By conditioning on the observed characteristics, it is possible to reduce the heterogeneity bias of the Barro estimator if the conditioning variables, \mathbf{z}_{i} , are independently distributed of the shocks, u_{it} . The larger the size of \boldsymbol{\theta}^{\prime}\boldsymbol{\Omega}_{z}\boldsymbol{\theta}/\bar{\sigma}_{u}^{2} the greater the scope for bias reduction by means of conditioning. In short, the Barro regression can only deliver consistent estimates of the speed of convergence of output across countries, if \alpha_{i} is a known deterministic function of \mathbf{z}_{i} , the errors of the underlying panel AR(1) model are serially uncorrelated, and the idiosyncratic errors are unrelated to all time-invariant regressors such as climate, latitude, demographic and institutional factors, for example. These are very strong assumptions and are unlikely to hold. Even if it is argued that \alpha_{i} is a deterministic function of a known vector of time-invariant variables \mathbf{z}_{i} and consequently \sigma_{\eta}^{2}=0, the Barro estimator could still be inconsistent due possible correlations between \mathbf{z}_{i} and current and past values of the idiosyncratic errors, \left\{u_{i,T+1},u_{i,T},....,u_{i0},...\right\} , as well as error serial correlation. Derivation of the Barro cross-country regression requires the underlying panel data model to follow an AR(1) specification and cannot accommodate higher order dynamics. As a result if such higher order dynamics are ignored, the errors in ( 1 ), u_{it} , will become serially correlated and the assumption that y_{i0} and \zeta_{iT} in ( 17 ) are uncorrelated will not hold any longer. The non-zero correlation between y_{i0} and \zeta_{iT} also renders the least squares estimates of the time-invariant effects, \boldsymbol{\theta} inconsistent if \sigma_{\eta}^{2}>0 and/or higher order dynamics are required. Whilst random coefficient models are good at dealing with parameter heterogeneity in the context of static panels, assuming random effects (intercepts and/or slopes) in dynamic panels invariably lead to inconsistent estimates when heterogeneity is ignored. The Barro regression basically fails because it cannot allow for random differences across countries. All randomness must be taken into account by assuming an exact relationship between \alpha_{i} and \mathbf{z}_{i} . 4 Asymptotic bias of TWFE estimator in presence of nonparallel trends To avoid the bias of Barro regressions we need to turn to panel data techniques, the most popular of which is TWFE specification, given by ( 1 ). But, as is widely acknowledged, an important limitation of the TWFE estimator is the parallel trends assumption that requires the time effects, f_{t} , have the same impact on all countries. 10 10 10 The parallel trends is also a core assumption in causal inference, particularly in the Difference-in-Difference (DiD) analysis where it is assumed that the trend components of the outcomes for treated and control groups are the same. In the case of current application, the analysis is further complicated due to the dynamics, often abstracted from in DiD analysis. This imposes identical steady state growth rates across all countries, irrespective of their differences in geography, endowments, and climatic conditions. Countries also differ in degree of openness to flows of goods, capital, people and ideas and these factors will influence the extent to which technology diffuses across countries. The obstacles to such flows may come from domestic institutions or from external constraints. Sanctions for instance are designed to cut countries off. Any similarities in the effects of latent factors across countries should be empirically investigated rather than assumed, a priori . Starting from ( 1 ), we relax the parallel trends assumption but for now retain the slope homogeneity assumption, \rho_{i}=\rho_{0}, where \rho_{0} is the true value of \rho . Specifically, we suppose that y_{it}=\alpha_{i}+\gamma_{i}f_{t}+\rho_{0}y_{i,t-1}+u_{it}, (25) where \left|\rho_{0}\right|<1 . We first consider the implications of assuming parallel trends when in reality the effects of the global factor, f_{t} , on country outputs are heterogeneous, namely Var\left(\gamma_{i}\right)=\sigma_{\gamma}^{2}>0 . We also assume that f_{t} is strong in the sense that its effects is pervasive across countries and E\left(\gamma_{i}\right)=\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\gamma_{i}>0 . This condition is necessary for the global output to have a non-zero mean growth rate defined by \bar{g}_{t}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\Delta y_{it} . The TWFE estimator of \rho_{0} is given by \hat{\rho}_{{}_{TWFE}}=\frac{(\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1})^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}(\mathbf{y}_{i\circ}-\mathbf{\bar{y}})}{\sum_{i=1}^{n}(\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1})^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}(\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1})}, (26) where \mathbf{M}_{T}=\mathbf{I}_{T}-T^{-1}\mathbf{\tau}_{T}\mathbf{\tau}_{T}^{\prime}, \mathbf{\tau}_{T} is a T\times 1 vector of ones, \mathbf{y}_{i\circ}=(y_{i1},y_{i2},...,y_{iT})^{\prime} , \mathbf{y}_{i,-1}=(y_{i0},y_{i1},...,y_{i,T-1})^{\prime} , \mathbf{\bar{y}=}(\bar{y}_{\circ 1},\bar{y}_{\circ 2},...,\bar{y}_{\circ T})^{\prime} , \mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1}\mathbf{=}(\bar{y}_{\circ 0},\bar{y}_{\circ 1},...,\bar{y}_{\circ,T-1})^{\prime} , and \bar{y}_{\circ t}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}y_{it} . To derive an expression for the bias of \hat{\rho}_{TWFE} we assume that f_{t} that u_{it} are independently distributed, u_{it} are cross-sectionally independent. Under ( 25 ) \mathbf{y}_{i\circ}-\mathbf{\bar{y}=}\left(\alpha_{i}-\bar{\alpha}\right)\mathbf{\tau}_{T}+\left(\gamma_{i}-\bar{\gamma}\right)\mathbf{f+}\rho_{0}(\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1})+\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}-\mathbf{\bar{u}} (27) where \mathbf{f=(}f_{1},f_{2},...,f_{T})^{\prime} , \mathbf{\bar{u}=(}\bar{u}_{\circ 1},\bar{u}_{\circ 2},...,\bar{u}_{\circ T})^{\prime} , with \bar{u}_{\circ t}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}u_{it} , Using it in ( 26 ) \hat{\rho}_{TWFE}-\rho_{0}=\frac{T^{-1}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}(\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1})^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\left[\left(\gamma_{i}-\bar{\gamma}\right)\mathbf{f}+\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}-\mathbf{\bar{u}}\right]}{T^{-1}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}(\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1})^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}(\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1})}. (28) Also solving ( 25 ) forward, from an initial value in a distant past, we have y_{it}=\alpha_{i}/(1-\rho)+\gamma_{i}g_{t}+v_{it}, (29) where g_{t}={\displaystyle\sum\limits_{j=0}^{\infty}}\rho^{j}f_{t-j},\text{ and }v_{it}={\displaystyle\sum\limits_{j=0}^{\infty}}\rho^{j}u_{i,t-j}, (30) which in turn gives \mathbf{y}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1}=\left(\gamma_{i}-\bar{\gamma}_{n}\right)\mathbf{g}_{-1}+\mathbf{v}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{v}}_{-1}, (31) where \bar{\gamma}_{n}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\gamma_{i} , \mathbf{g}_{-1}\mathbf{=(}g_{0},g_{1},...,g_{T-1})^{\prime} , and \mathbf{v}_{i,-1} and \mathbf{\bar{v}}_{-1} are defined analogously to \mathbf{y}_{i,-1} and \mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1} . Using this result, the numerator of ( 28 ) becomes \displaystyle Num_{TWFE}=\left(n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\left(\gamma_{i}-\bar{\gamma}_{n}\right)^{2}\right)\left(T^{-1}\mathbf{g}_{-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\mathbf{f}\right) \displaystyle\mathbf{+}T^{-1}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\mathbf{\tilde{v}}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\left(\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}-\mathbf{\bar{u}}\right) \displaystyle+T^{-1}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\left(\gamma_{i}-\bar{\gamma}\right)\mathbf{g}_{-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\left(\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}-\mathbf{\bar{u}}\right)\mathbf{.} where \mathbf{\tilde{v}}_{i,-1}=\mathbf{v}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{v}}_{-1} . Since by assumption u_{it} and f_{t} (and hence g_{t}) are independently distributed, and u_{it} are cross-sectionally independent, then for a fixed T we have Num_{TWFE}=\sigma_{\gamma}^{2}\left(T^{-1}\mathbf{g}_{-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\mathbf{f}\right)+T^{-1}\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}E\left[\mathbf{\tilde{v}}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\left(\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}-\mathbf{\bar{u}}\right)\right]+O_{p}\left(n^{-1/2}\right), (32) where \sigma_{\gamma}^{2}=\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}E\left(\gamma_{i}-\bar{\gamma}_{n}\right)^{2} . Consider now the denominator of ( 28 ) and using ( 31 ) note that \displaystyle Den_{TWFE} \displaystyle=T^{-1}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}(\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1})^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}(\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1}) (33) \displaystyle=\sigma_{\gamma}^{2}\left(T^{-1}\mathbf{g}_{-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\mathbf{g}_{-1}\right)+T^{-1}\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}E\left(\mathbf{\tilde{v}}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\mathbf{\tilde{v}}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\right)+O_{p}\left(n^{-1/2}\right) Using ( 32 ) and ( 33 ) in ( 28 ) now yields (for a fixed T ) p\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}\left(\hat{\rho}_{TWFE}-\rho_{0}\right)=\frac{\sigma_{\gamma}^{2}\left(T^{-1}\mathbf{g}_{-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\mathbf{f}\right)+\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}\left(nT\right)^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}E\left[\mathbf{\tilde{v}}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\left(\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}-\mathbf{\bar{u}}\right)\right]}{\sigma_{\gamma}^{2}\left(T^{-1}\mathbf{g}_{-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\mathbf{g}_{-1}\right)+\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}\left(nT\right)^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}E\left(\mathbf{\tilde{v}}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\mathbf{\tilde{v}}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\right)} (34) When the parallel trend assumption does not hold \sigma_{\gamma}^{2}>0 and in general the TWFE estimator of \rho_{0} will be biased. The second term in the numerator of ( 34 ) is similar to the Nickell (1981) bias and is of order T^{-1} , and vanishes as T\rightarrow\infty . It is present whether there is a factor or not. The first term arises from the presence of the factor and the magnitude of the asymptotic bias of the TWFE estimator critically depends on the time series properties of f_{t} . To highlight this point we consider two cases: (a) when f_{t} is covariance stationary, (b) when f_{t} is trended or follows a random walk with a non-zero drift, namely f_{t}=\mu t+s_{t} ( \mu\neq 0 ). The latter specification is particularly relevant to the growth convergence literature where it is important to allow for the possibility of a non-zero steady state output growth for the global economy. 4.1 The bias of the TWFE estimator under nonparallel trends with a stationary latent factor Under the assumption of a stationary factor, without loss of generality, we assume that f_{t} has mean zero with the autocovariance function, \gamma_{f}(\left|s-s^{\prime}\right|)=E(f_{t-s}f_{t-s^{\prime}}) . In this case, using ( 30 ) we have \displaystyle T^{-1}\mathbf{g}_{-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\mathbf{f} \displaystyle=T^{-1}\sum_{t=1}^{T}f_{t}g_{t-1}-\bar{f}\bar{g}_{-1}\rightarrow_{p}\sum_{s=0}^{\infty}\rho^{s}\gamma_{f}(s+1), \displaystyle T^{-1}\mathbf{g}_{-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\mathbf{g}_{-1} \displaystyle=T^{-1}\sum_{t=1}^{T}g_{t-1}^{2}-\bar{g}_{-1}^{2}\rightarrow_{p}\sum_{s=0}^{\infty}\sum_{s^{\prime}=0}^{\infty}\rho^{s+s^{\prime}}\gamma_{f}(\left|s-s^{\prime}\right|)>0. Therefore, when the parallel trends assumption does not hold ( \bar{\sigma}_{\gamma}^{2}>0) and f_{t} is covariance stationary, the asymptotic bias of \hat{\rho}_{TWFE} for both n and T large is given p\lim_{n,T\rightarrow\infty}\left(\hat{\rho}_{TWFE}-\rho_{0}\right)=\frac{\left(\frac{\sigma_{\gamma}^{2}}{\omega^{2}}\right)\sum_{s=0}^{\infty}\rho_{0}^{s}\gamma_{f}(s+1)}{1+\left(\frac{\sigma_{\gamma}^{2}}{\omega^{2}}\right)\sum_{s=0}^{\infty}\sum_{s^{\prime}=0}^{\infty}\rho_{0}^{s+s^{\prime}}\gamma_{f}(\left|s-s^{\prime}\right|)}, (35) where \omega^{2}=\lim_{n,T\rightarrow\infty}T^{-1}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}E\left[\left(\mathbf{v}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{v}}_{-1}\right)^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\left(\mathbf{v}_{i,-1}-\mathbf{\bar{v}}_{-1}\right)\right]>0. The sign of this bias depends on the sign of \sum_{s=0}^{\infty}\rho_{0}^{s}\gamma_{f}(s+1) , which is likely to be positive since \rho_{0}>0, and one would expect f_{t} to be positively autocorrelated. The magnitude of the bias depends on the relative importance of the heterogeneity of \gamma_{i} , given by \kappa^{2}=\sigma_{\gamma}^{2}/\omega^{2} , and the degree of persistence of the time effects, given by \sum_{s=0}^{\infty}\rho_{0}^{s}\gamma_{f}(s+1) . The TWFE estimator is asymptotically unbiased (as n and T\rightarrow\infty ) only if f_{t} is serially independent. Everaert and De Groote (2016) derive expressions for the inconsistency of TWFE estimators under ( 25 ) assuming that f_{t} follows a stationary AR(1) process. 4.2 The bias of the TWFE estimator under non parallel trends with a trended latent factor Consider now the case where f_{t} is trended, and suppose that f_{t}=\mu t+s_{t} , which is decomposed into a linear trend, \mu t , and a stochastic component s_{t} . The latter could be stationary or a unit root process. In either case s_{t} will be dominated by the trend component, so long as the drift term \mu\neq 0 . Then it is easily seen that g_{t-1}-\bar{g}_{-1}=\frac{\mu}{1-\rho_{0}}\left(t-\frac{T+1}{2}\right)+\left(q_{t-1}-\bar{q}_{-1}\right), where q_{t}=\rho_{0}q_{t-1}+s_{t} . Since \left|\rho_{0}\right|<1, then q_{t} will have the same order of integration as s_{t}, namely q_{t} could be stationary or a unit root process. In either case the linear trend in g_{t-1}-\bar{g}_{-1} will dominate \left(q_{t-1}-\bar{q}_{-1}\right) and we have \displaystyle T^{-3}\mathbf{g}_{-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\mathbf{f} \displaystyle=\frac{\mu^{2}}{12(1-\rho_{0})}+O_{p}(T^{-1}), \displaystyle T^{-3}\mathbf{g}_{-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{T}\mathbf{g}_{-1} \displaystyle=\frac{\mu^{2}}{12(1-\rho_{0})^{2}}+O_{p}(T^{-1}). Hence, scaling down the terms in ( 34 ) by T^{-3} , and using the above results it follows that p\lim_{n,T\rightarrow\infty}\left(\hat{\rho}_{TWFE}-\rho_{0}\right)=1-\rho_{0} , or p\lim_{n,T\rightarrow\infty}\left(\hat{\rho}_{TWFE}\right)=1\text{. } (36) This is a striking result that follows from the deterministic trend component of f_{t} , and holds irrespective of whether the stochastic component, s_{t} , is stationary or a unit root process. In short, the TWFE estimator of \rho_{0} is biased upward under nonparallel trends and the bias becomes highly pronounced when f_{t} is trended. In the latter case even a small degree of heterogeneity in \gamma_{i} can lead to substantial upward bias in estimation of \rho_{0} . In the context of growth regressions, the random walk model with drift is likely to be the most relevant case, and largely explains the very small estimates obtained in the literature for the speed of convergence, \phi_{0}=1-\rho_{0}, when TWFE estimators are used. 4.3 Panel data models with group-specific time effects The restrictive nature of the parallel trend assumption is becoming increasing recognized in the empirical growth literature. For example in addition to using TWFE, Acemoglu et al. (2019) let the time effect vary over groups. For instance, in column 8 of Table 4, they interact the time effects with the product of 7 regional dummies and the initial regime (democratic or non democratic). Having 14 groups in each year leaves very small numbers in some groups. In general, the panel data model with group-specific interactive effects can be written as y_{it}=\alpha_{i}+\gamma_{g}f_{t}\left(\sum_{g=1}^{G}d_{ig}\right)+\rho_{0}y_{i,t-1}+u_{it}, where d_{ig}=1 if country i belongs to group (region) g=1,2,...,G , and zero otherwise. The number of groups, G , and the group membership is typically assumed known. 11 11 11 For large n and T panels, machine learning techniques, such as cluster analysis, can be used to estimate the number of groups and the group membership. Such grouping is particularly relevant if the aim is to identify convergence clubs that are based on geographical proximity and political and historical similarities. As before, f_{t} is the common latent factor. This model can be written more compactly as y_{ig,t}=\alpha_{i,g}+\gamma_{g}f_{t}+\rho_{0}y_{i,g,t-1}+u_{i,g,t} (37) for country \left(i,g\right) , that denotes country i in group g, with i=1,2,...,n_{g}, g=1,2,...,G , and n={\textstyle\sum_{g=1}^{G}}n_{g} . The fixed effects, \alpha_{i,g} , and the group-specific time effects can be eliminated using the group-specific filtering, with \rho_{0} estimated by \hat{\rho}_{FE-GTE}=\frac{\sum_{t=1}^{T}\sum_{g=1}^{G}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{g}}\tilde{y}_{ig,t-1}\tilde{y}_{ig,t}}{\sum_{t=1}^{T}\sum_{g=1}^{G}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{g}}\tilde{y}_{ig,t-1}^{2}} (38) where \tilde{y}_{ig,t}=\left(y_{ig,t}-\bar{y}_{ig,\circ}\right)-(\bar{y}_{\circ,gt}-\bar{y}_{\circ g\circ}) and \tilde{y}_{ig,t-1}=\left(y_{ig,t-1}-\bar{y}_{ig,-1}\right)-(\bar{y}_{\circ,gt}-\bar{y}_{\circ g,-1}), where \bar{y}_{ig,-s}=T^{-1}\sum_{t=1}^{T}y_{ig,t-s} , \bar{y}_{\circ,gt}=n_{g}^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{g}}y_{ig,t} , and \bar{y}_{\circ g,-s}=n_{g}^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{g}}y_{ig,t-s} for s=0 and 1 . As an estimator of \rho_{0} , \hat{\rho}_{FE-GTE} is subject to the Nickell bias as well as the group-size bias. For a fixed G , \hat{\rho}_{FE-GTE} is a consistent estimator of \rho_{0} if \left(T,n_{1},n_{2},...,n_{G}\right)\rightarrow\infty . Under this condition group-specific time effects, \gamma_{g}, can be consistently estimated and hence eliminated form the analysis. The key condition on n_{g} , namely n_{g}\rightarrow\infty , for g=1,2,...,G is likely to be restrictive in the case of cross country analysis and arises due to the dynamic nature of the panel data model and will not be required in the case of static panel data models with strictly exogenous regressors. 5 The DCCEP estimator: nonparallel trends with homogeneous dynamics The use of group-specific time effects can be avoided by following the common correlated effects (CCE) approach introduced in Pesaran (2006) and later implemented for dynamic panels by Chudik and Pesaran (2015a), referred to as dynamic CCE (DCCE). The basic idea behind DCCE is to proxy the latent factor, f_{t} , by current and lagged cross country averages of log output, namely \bar{y}_{\circ t} and \bar{y}_{\circ,t-1} . The case with a homogeneous, \rho is referred to as DCCEP. Averaging ( 25 ) over i , we have \bar{y}_{\circ t}=\bar{\alpha}+\bar{\gamma}f_{t}+\rho\bar{y}_{\circ,t-1}+\bar{u}_{\circ t} , and assuming \bar{\gamma}\neq 0 , then f_{t}=\bar{\gamma}^{-1}\left(\bar{y}_{\circ t}-\rho\bar{y}_{\circ,t-1}-\bar{\alpha}-\bar{u}_{\circ t}\right) . Using this result back in ( 25 ) now yields y_{it}=\left(\alpha_{i}-\delta_{i0}\bar{\alpha}\right)+\delta_{i0}\bar{y}_{\circ t}+\delta_{i1}\bar{y}_{\circ,t-1}+\rho y_{i,t-1}+u_{it}-\delta_{i0}\bar{u}_{\circ t}, (39) where \delta_{i0}=\bar{\gamma}^{-1}\gamma_{i} , \delta_{i1}=-\delta_{i0}\rho , and \bar{u}_{\circ t}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}u_{it} . Running the above panel AR(1) regression in y_{it} , augmented with the cross section averages, \bar{y}_{\circ t} and \bar{y}_{\circ,t-1} , we obtain the following pooled DCCE estimator \hat{\rho}_{DCCEP}=\frac{n^{-1}T^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{\bar{h}}\mathbf{y}_{i\circ}}{n^{-1}T^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{\bar{h}}\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}}, (40) where \mathbf{M}_{\bar{h}}=\mathbf{I}_{T}-\mathbf{\bar{H}}\left(\mathbf{\bar{H}}^{\prime}\mathbf{\bar{H}}\right)^{-}\mathbf{\bar{H}}^{\prime} , \mathbf{\bar{H}=}\left(\mathbf{\tau}_{T},\mathbf{\bar{y},\bar{y}}_{-1}\right) , and \mathbf{A}^{-} denotes the generalized inverse of the square matrix \mathbf{A} . Note that \mathbf{M}_{\bar{h}}\mathbf{y}_{i\circ} and \mathbf{M}_{\bar{h}}\mathbf{y}_{i,-1} are residuals from the least squares regressions of \mathbf{y}_{i\circ} and \mathbf{y}_{i,-1} on \mathbf{\bar{H}} and are invariant to the choice of the generalized inverse. The use of generalized inverse allows for possible perfect collinearity that arise between \bar{y}_{\circ t} and \bar{y}_{\circ,t-1} when f_{t} is trended, as discussed below. To establish the consistency of \hat{\rho}_{DCCEP} for \rho_{0} , writing ( 39 ) in vector notations gives \mathbf{y}_{i\circ}=\mathbf{\bar{H}}\boldsymbol{\pi}_{i}+\rho_{0}\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}+\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}-\delta_{i0}\mathbf{\bar{u},} where \boldsymbol{\pi}_{i}=(\alpha_{i}-\delta_{i0}\bar{\alpha},\delta_{i0},\delta_{i1})^{\prime} . Then \hat{\rho}_{DCCEP}-\rho_{0}=\frac{n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{\bar{h}}\left(\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}-\delta_{i0}\mathbf{\bar{u}}\right)}{n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{\bar{h}}\mathbf{y}_{i,-1}}. Also, from ( 29 ) we obtain \ \mathbf{y}_{i,-1}=\alpha_{i}/(1-\rho)\mathbf{\tau}_{T}+\gamma_{i}\mathbf{g}_{-1}+\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}, and by cross section averaging, \mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1}=\bar{\alpha}/(1-\rho)\mathbf{\tau}_{T}+\bar{\gamma}\mathbf{g}_{-1}+\mathbf{\bar{v}}_{-1} , which in turn yields \mathbf{y}_{i,-1}=\left(\frac{\alpha_{i}-\delta_{i0}\bar{\alpha}}{1-\rho_{0}}\right)\mathbf{\tau}_{T}+\delta_{i0}\mathbf{\bar{y}}_{-1}+\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}-\delta_{i0}\mathbf{\bar{v}}_{-1}. Recall that \boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}=(v_{i0},v_{i1},...,v_{i,T-1}), \mathbf{\bar{v}}_{-1}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1} , where v_{it}={\displaystyle\sum\limits_{j=0}^{\infty}}\rho^{j}u_{i,t-j} . Hence \hat{\rho}_{DCCEP}-\rho_{0}=\frac{\sum_{i=1}^{n}\left(\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}-\delta_{i0}\mathbf{\bar{v}}_{-1}\right)^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{\bar{h}}\left(\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}-\delta_{i0}\mathbf{\bar{u}}\right)}{\sum_{i=1}^{n}\left(\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}-\delta_{i0}\mathbf{\bar{v}}_{-1}\right)^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{\bar{h}}\left(\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}-\delta_{i0}\mathbf{\bar{v}}_{-1}\right)}. Let \mathbf{M}_{g}=\mathbf{I}_{T}-\mathbf{P}_{g}, \mathbf{P}_{g}=\mathbf{G}\left(\mathbf{G}^{\prime}\mathbf{G}\right)^{-}\mathbf{G}^{\prime} , and \mathbf{G=}\left(\begin{array}[c]{ccc}\mathbf{\tau}_{T}&\mathbf{g}&\mathbf{g}_{-1}\end{array}\right) . Also \mathbf{\bar{H}}=\left(\mathbf{\tau}_{T},\mathbf{\bar{y},\bar{y}}_{-1}\right)=\left(\mathbf{\tau}_{T},\text{ }\bar{\alpha}/(1-\rho)\mathbf{\tau}_{T}+\bar{\gamma}\mathbf{g+\bar{v}}\text{, }\bar{\alpha}/(1-\rho)\mathbf{\tau}_{T}+\bar{\gamma}\mathbf{g}_{-1}+\mathbf{\bar{v}}_{-1}\right). Then \mathbf{\bar{H}}=\mathbf{G\bar{Q}}+\mathbf{\bar{V}} , where \mathbf{\bar{Q}} is a non-singular matrix (by assumption \bar{\gamma}\neq 0 ) given by \mathbf{\bar{Q}=}\left(\begin{array}[c]{ccc}1&\bar{\alpha}/(1-\rho_{0})&\bar{\alpha}/(1-\rho_{0})\\ 0&\bar{\gamma}&0\\ 0&0&\bar{\gamma}\end{array}\right), and \mathbf{\bar{V}=}\left(\mathbf{0},\mathbf{\bar{v},\bar{v}}_{-1}\right) . Since u_{it} (and hence v_{it} ) are cross-sectionally independent, then \mathbf{\bar{u}=}O_{p}(n^{-1/2}) , \mathbf{\bar{v}}=O_{p}(n^{-1/2}) , and \mathbf{\bar{v}}_{-1}=O_{p}(n^{-1/2}) . It is then easily established that for any fixed T>3 , and as n\rightarrow\infty, we have \mathbf{M}_{\bar{h}}-\mathbf{M}_{g}=\mathbf{G}\left(\mathbf{G}^{\prime}\mathbf{G}\right)^{-}\mathbf{G}^{\prime}-\left(\mathbf{G\bar{Q}}+\mathbf{\bar{V}}\right)\left[\left(\mathbf{G\bar{Q}}+\mathbf{\bar{V}}\right)^{\prime}\left(\mathbf{G\bar{Q}}+\mathbf{\bar{V}}\right)\right]^{-}\left(\mathbf{G\bar{Q}}+\mathbf{\bar{V}}\right)^{\prime}=O_{p}(n^{-1/2}) This follows since \mathbf{\bar{V}=}O_{p}\left(n^{-1/2}\right) and \mathbf{G}\left(\mathbf{G}^{\prime}\mathbf{G}\right)^{-}\mathbf{G}^{\prime}=\mathbf{G\bar{Q}}\left[\left(\mathbf{G\bar{Q}}\right)^{\prime}\left(\mathbf{G\bar{Q}}\right)\right]^{-}\mathbf{\bar{Q}}^{\prime}\mathbf{G}^{\prime} . Using this result, for a fixed T and conditional on \mathbf{f} , or \mathbf{G} , we now have \hat{\rho}_{DCCEP}-\rho_{0}\rightarrow_{p}\frac{lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}E\left(T^{-1}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{g}\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}\left|\mathbf{f}\right.\right)}{lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}\text{ }n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}E\left(T^{-1}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{g}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}\left|\mathbf{f}\right.\right)}. (41) For the denominator of ( 41 ) we have E\left(T^{-1}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{g}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}\left|\mathbf{f}\right.\right)=Tr\left[\mathbf{M}_{g}E\left(\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\right)\right] , and E\left(\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\right)=\frac{\sigma_{i}^{2}}{1-\rho_{0}^{2}}\left(\begin{array}[c]{cccc}1&\rho_{0}&\cdots&\rho_{0}^{T-1}\\ \rho_{0}&1&\cdots&\rho_{0}^{T-2}\\ \vdots&\vdots&\ddots&\vdots\\ \rho_{0}^{T-1}&\rho_{0}^{T-2}&\cdots&1\end{array}\right)=\sigma_{i}^{2}\mathbf{V}_{0}, where \lambda_{\max}\left(\mathbf{V}_{{}_{0}}\right) is bounded noting that \left|\rho_{0}\right|<1 . Hence, lim_{n\rightarrow\infty} n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}E\left(T^{-1}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{g}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}\left|\mathbf{f}\right.\right)=\bar{\sigma}^{2}Tr\left(T^{-1}\mathbf{M}_{g}\mathbf{V}_{0}\right) , where \bar{\sigma}^{2}=\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\sigma_{i}^{2} . Also, Tr\left(T^{-1}\mathbf{M}_{g}\mathbf{V}_{0}\right)=Tr\left(T^{-1}\mathbf{M}_{g}\mathbf{V}_{0}\mathbf{M}_{g}\right)\leq T^{-1}\lambda_{\max}\left(\mathbf{V}_{0}\right)Tr\left(\mathbf{M}_{g}\right)=\left[(T-3)/T\right]\lambda_{\max}\left(\mathbf{V}_{0}\right) which is bounded in T , irrespective of whether f_{t} is trended or not. Now consider the numerator of ( 41 ) and note that E\left(T^{-1}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{g}\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}\left|\mathbf{f}\right.\right)=T^{-1}\sum_{t=1}^{T}E\left(v_{i,t-1}u_{it}\right)-T^{-1}E\left(\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{P}_{g}\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}\left|\mathbf{f}\right.\right). (42) Since v_{it}={\displaystyle\sum\limits_{s=0}^{\infty}}\rho^{s}u_{i,t-s} and u_{it} is serially uncorrelated, then E\left(v_{i,t-1}u_{it}\right)=0 , and E\left(T^{-1}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{g}\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}\left|\mathbf{f}\right.\right)=-T^{-1}E\left(\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{P}_{g}\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}\left|\mathbf{f}\right.\right) . Further, since f_{t} (and g_{t} ) is independently distributed of u_{it} (and v_{it} ) then conditional on \mathbf{f} , we have T^{-1}E\left(\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{P}_{g}\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}\right)=Tr\left[\mathbf{P}_{g}E\left(T^{-1}\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\right)\right] . It is also easily seen that E\left(\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\right)=\sigma_{i}^{2}\mathbf{W}_{\rho} , where \mathbf{W}_{\rho}=\left(\begin{array}[c]{cccccc}0&1&\rho_{0}&\rho_{0}^{2}&\cdots&\rho_{0}^{T-2}\\ 0&0&1&\rho_{0}&\cdots&\rho_{0}^{T-3}\\ \vdots&\vdots&\vdots&&\cdots&\vdots\\ 0&0&\ddots&0&\cdots&1\\ 0&0&\cdots&0&0&0\end{array}\right)=(w_{tt^{\prime}}). Then \displaystyle E\left(T^{-1}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{g}\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}\left|\mathbf{f}\right.\right) \displaystyle=-T^{-1}E\left(\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{P}_{g}\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}\left|\mathbf{f}\right.\right) \displaystyle=T^{-2}\sigma_{i}^{2}Tr\left(\mathbf{AW}_{\rho}\right)=T^{-2}\sigma_{i}^{2}\sum_{t=1}^{T}\sum_{t=1}^{T}a_{tt^{\prime}}w_{tt^{\prime}} where a_{tt^{\prime}} is the (t,t^{\prime}) element of \mathbf{A=}T\mathbf{G}\left(\mathbf{G}^{\prime}\mathbf{G}\right)^{-1}\mathbf{G}^{\prime} . Hence \displaystyle\left|E\left(T^{-1}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{g}\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}\left|\mathbf{f}\right.\right)\right| \displaystyle\leq T^{-2}\sigma_{i}^{2}\sup_{t,t^{\prime}}\left|a_{tt^{\prime}}\right|\sum_{t=1}^{T}\sum_{t=1}^{T}\left|w_{tt^{\prime}}\right| \displaystyle\leq T^{-1}\sup_{t,t^{\prime}}\left|a_{tt^{\prime}}\right|\sigma_{i}^{2}\sum_{s=1}^{T-1}\left(1-\frac{s}{T}\right)\left|\rho\right|^{s-1}, and lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}E\left(T^{-1}\boldsymbol{v}_{i,-1}^{\prime}\mathbf{M}_{g}\mathbf{u}_{i\circ}\left|\mathbf{f}\right.\right)\leq T^{-1}\sup_{t,t^{\prime}}\left|a_{tt^{\prime}}\right|\bar{\sigma}^{2}\sum_{s=1}^{T-1}\left(1-\frac{s}{T}\right)\left|\rho\right|^{s-1}. Since \bar{\sigma}^{2}\sum_{s=1}^{T-1}\left(1-\frac{s}{T}\right)\left|\rho_{0}\right|^{s-1} is bounded in T , then conditional on \mathbf{G} , the order of the numerator of ( 41 ) is determined by the order of T^{-1}\sup_{t,t^{\prime}}\left|a_{tt^{\prime}}\right| . It is interesting that the probability order of this term does depend on whether f_{t} is stationary or trended, which is in contrast to the order of the bias of the TWFE estimator that crucially depended on whether f_{t} is stationary or trended. When f_{t} is stationary then g_{t}=O_{p}(1) and T^{-1}\mathbf{G}^{\prime}\mathbf{G=}O_{p}(1) and since \mathbf{A=G}\left(T^{-1}\mathbf{G}^{\prime}\mathbf{G}\right)^{-1}\mathbf{G} , then \sup_{t,t^{\prime}}\left|a_{tt^{\prime}}\right|=O_{p}(1) . In the case where f_{t} is trended we first write \mathbf{A} as \mathbf{A}=\left(\sqrt{T}\mathbf{GD}_{T}\right)\left(\mathbf{D}_{T}\mathbf{G}^{\prime}\mathbf{GD}_{T}\right)^{-1}\left(\sqrt{T}\mathbf{D}_{T}\mathbf{G}^{\prime}\right), where \mathbf{D}_{T}=diag(T^{-1/2},T^{-3/2},T^{-3/2}) . Then it is easily established that \mathbf{D}_{T}\mathbf{G}^{\prime}\mathbf{GD}_{T}=O_{p}(1) and \sqrt{T}\mathbf{GD}_{T}=O_{p}(1) . Hence, irrespective of whether f_{t} is stationary or trended, \sup_{t,t^{\prime}}\left|a_{tt^{\prime}}\right|=O_{p}(1) and numerator of ( 41 ) is O_{p}(T^{-1}) , and overall we have \hat{\rho}_{DCCEP}-\rho_{0}\rightarrow_{p}O_{p}\left(T^{-1}\right)\text{, as }n\rightarrow\infty. (43) Namely, the DCCEP estimator of \rho_{0} is consistent when n\, and T are both large, and applies irrespective of whether f_{t} is stationary or trended. The trend in f_{t} could be stochastic and subject to breaks. However, not surprisingly, DCCEP suffers from the small T bias analogous to the Nickell bias of the TWFE estimator. De Vos and Everaert (2021) derive the fixed T bias under the assumption of a stationary factor. This small T bias will be present irrespective of whether the panel data model includes a latent factor or not. It is simply due to dynamic nature of the panel regression under consideration. To avoid the small T bias of DCCEP estimator, Hayakawa, Pesaran and Smith (2023) allow for interactive time effects through a multi-factor error structure \boldsymbol{\gamma}_{i}^{\prime}\mathbf{f} in dynamic fixed effects panel data models in addition to the standard fixed and time effects, but assume that \boldsymbol{\gamma}_{i} are cross-sectionally independent. They apply maximum likelihood estimation after first-differencing the data to remove the fixed effects. This transformed quasi maximum likelihood estimator is shown to be robust to the heterogeneity of the initial values and common unobserved effects, and is applicable to both stationary and unit root cases. They also propose a procedure for selection of the number of latent factors. They apply the estimator to the Acemoglu et al. (2019) growth data using averages taken over five yearly intervals. 6 The DCCEMG estimator: nonparallel trends with heterogeneous dynamics In this case the output equations with heterogeneous dynamics as well as nonparallel trends are given by y_{it}=\alpha_{i}+\gamma_{i}f_{t}+\rho_{i}y_{i,t-1}+u_{it},\,\ \text{for }i=1,2,...,n. (44) This model is investigated in detail by Chudik and Pesaran (2015a), who show that once we allow for \rho_{i} to differ across i , the identification and estimation of f_{t} become much more complicated due to the heterogeneity in the dependence of y_{it} on f_{t} , and its lagged values. To identify f_{t} it is assumed that \rho_{i} lies in the range (-1,1) , such that E\left|\rho_{i}\right|^{s}\leq\bar{\rho}^{s} , where \bar{\rho}<1 . This ensures that E\left(\frac{1}{1-\rho_{i}^{2}}\right) exists which is required for identification of f_{t} from the macro outcomes, \bar{y}_{\circ t} . This assumption rules out the possibility of long memory processes. 12 12 12 On this see Robinson (1978) and Granger (1980). A more general treatment is provided in Pesaran and Chudik (2014). 6.1 DCCEMG with stationary latent factors Chudik and Pesaran (2015a) further assume that f_{t} is covariance stationary which is rather restrictive as noted above. Here we provide a sketch of the proof to highlight the way nonparallel trends and dynamic heterogeneity interact. Solving ( 44 ) from a distant past we have y_{it}=\mu_{i}+\gamma_{i}{\displaystyle\sum\limits_{s=0}^{\infty}}\rho_{i}^{s}f_{t-s}+{\displaystyle\sum\limits_{s=0}^{\infty}}\rho_{i}^{s}u_{i,t-s}, with \mu_{i}=\alpha_{i}/(1-\rho_{i}) , \theta_{is}=\gamma_{i}\rho_{i}^{s} and v_{it}= \sum_{s=0}^{\infty}\rho_{i}^{s}u_{i,t-s} , which if averaged over i yields \bar{y}_{\circ t}=\bar{\mu}_{n}+{\displaystyle\sum\limits_{s=0}^{\infty}}\bar{\theta}_{ns}f_{t-s}+\bar{v}_{\circ t}, (45) where \bar{\mu}_{n}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\mu_{i}, \bar{\theta}_{ns}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\theta_{is}, and \bar{v}_{\circ t}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}v_{it}. It is clear that conditional on \rho_{i} , v_{it}\,^{\prime}s continue to be cross-sectionally independent, and Var\left(\bar{v}_{\circ t}\right)=n^{-2}\sum_{i=1}^{n}Var\left(v_{it}\right) . Also Var\left(v_{it}\right)=Var\left[E\left(v_{it}\left|\rho_{i}\right.\right)\right]+E\left[Var\left(v_{it}\left|\rho_{i}\right.\right)\right]=E\left(\frac{\sigma_{i}^{2}}{1-\rho_{i}^{2}}\right), and it is easily seen that E\left(\frac{\sigma_{i}^{2}}{1-\rho_{i}^{2}}\right)p_{T}=3 , in the case of heterogeneous dynamics. 15 15 15 T_{ave} is the average time dimension of the panel computed as n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}T_{i} , where T_{i} is the number of years of available data for country i and n is the total number of countries in the panel. The use of TWFE estimators in the case of panels with heterogeneous dynamics results in terms like (\phi_{i}-\phi_{0})y_{i,t-1} to be included in the error term, which in turn could result in error serial correlation leading to more lagged terms being erroneously statistically significant. One might expect heterogeneous models to require fewer lags. This is in fact the case, with the statistical significance of \Delta y_{i,t-2} falling as one moves from TWFE to the CCE type estimators. Furthermore, since f_{t} is likely to be trended in the present application, and as explained earlier, fewer lags of cross section averages are needed to adequately proxy the latent factor. The estimates of the speed of convergence reported in Table 3 are in accordance with the theory which shows that relaxing the homogeneity restrictions reduces the downward bias in the estimated speed of convergence. For the case of output per capita, the estimates of the speed of convergence increases from 3 per cent per annum when TWFE is used, to 5 per cent if nonparallel trends are allowed by using DCCEP, and to 11 per cent when both the parallel trends and slope homogeneity restrictions are relaxed if estimation is carried out using the DCCEMG procedure. For output per employee the speeds are slightly higher. The mean number of years to convergence falls from 24-27 estimated using TWFE, to 14-18 using DCCEP, and to 5-6 years when using DCCEMG estimates (Table 3 ). Only the DCCEMG estimates correspond to the business cycle frequencies. Table 3: Alternative estimates of speed of convergence based on unbalanced panel regressions of order three using PWT data covering 157 countries over the period 1950-2019 Output per capita Output per employee TWFE DCCEP DCCEMG TWFE DCEEP CEEMG Regressors (estimates ) y_{i,t-1} \left({\footnotesize-}\hat{\phi}\right) \underset{(0.004)}{{\footnotesize-0.027}} \underset{(0.012)}{{\footnotesize-0.046}} \underset{(0.012)}{{\footnotesize-0.113}} \underset{(0.005)}{{\footnotesize-0.031}} \underset{(0.014)}{{\footnotesize-0.058}} \underset{(0.015)}{{\footnotesize-0.144}} {\footnotesize\Delta y}_{i,t-1} (\hat{\psi}_{1}) \underset{(0.030)}{{\footnotesize 0.206}} \underset{\left(0.029\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.141}} \underset{\left(0.018\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.210}} \underset{(0.034)}{{\footnotesize 0.185}} \underset{(0.0323)}{{\footnotesize 0.122}} \underset{(0.016)}{{\footnotesize 0.130}} {\footnotesize\Delta y}_{i,t-2} (\hat{\psi}_{2}) \underset{(0.027)}{{\footnotesize 0.034}} \underset{\left(0.030\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.015}} \underset{\left(0.014\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.012}} \underset{(0.029)}{{\footnotesize 0.035}} \underset{(0.031)}{{\footnotesize-0.019}} \underset{(0.014)}{{\footnotesize 0.001}} Mean lag in years \underset{\left(3.82\right)}{{\footnotesize 27.1}} \underset{(4.87)}{{\footnotesize 18.2}} \underset{(0.83)}{{\footnotesize 6.1}} \underset{\left(3.98\right)}{{\footnotesize 23.81}} \underset{\left(3.70\right)}{{\footnotesize 14.4}} \underset{\left(0.69\right)}{{\footnotesize 5.1}} Number of countries (n) {\footnotesize 157} {\footnotesize 157} {\footnotesize 157} {\footnotesize 157} {\footnotesize 157} {\footnotesize 157} T {}_{\min}\, (years) {\footnotesize 27} {\footnotesize 27} {\footnotesize 26} {\footnotesize 27} {\footnotesize 27} {\footnotesize 26} T ave {\footnotesize 55.2} 55.2 {\footnotesize 54.2} {\footnotesize 52} {\footnotesize 52} {\footnotesize 51} T max {\footnotesize 67} {\footnotesize 67} 66 {\footnotesize 67} {\footnotesize 67} {\footnotesize 66} Notes 1. The dependent variable is \Delta y_{it} , the change in log output per capita and log output per employee measured respectively using logarithms of ”rgdpna/pop” and ”rgdpna/emp” from PWT 10.01 . Average speed of convergence, measured by {\footnotesize\phi=1-\rho}_{1}{\footnotesize-\rho}_{2}{\footnotesize-\rho}_{3} , is estimated as the coefficient of the lagged output variable. The mean lag is computed as {\footnotesize(1-\hat{\phi}-\hat{\psi}}_{1}{\footnotesize-\hat{\psi}}_{2}{\footnotesize)/\hat{\phi}} , where {\footnotesize\psi}_{1}{\footnotesize=-(\rho}_{2}{\footnotesize+\rho}_{3}{\footnotesize)} , {\footnotesize\psi}_{2}{\footnotesize=-\rho}_{3} and {\footnotesize\rho}_{s} , {\footnotesize s=1,2,3} are the (average) autoregressive coefficients. See also equation ( 62 ). Notes 2. TWFE is the two way fixed effect estimator, DCCEP is the dynamic correlated common effect pooled estimator, and DCCEMG is the dynamic correlated common effect mean group estimator. See Sections ( 5 ) and ( 6 ) of the paper for further details. Heteroskedasticity robust standard errors are in parentheses, Huber-White for TWFE, the DCCE standard errors are heteroskedasticity robust. To filter out the nonparallel trends, DCCEP augments the panel regressions with the cross country averages \bar{y}_{\circ,t-s}, {\footnotesize s=0,1,2,3} , and the DCCEMG augments the panel regressions with {\footnotesize\bar{y}}_{\circ,t-s}, {\footnotesize s=0,1,2,3,4}; the additional lagged cross section average, \bar{y}_{\circ,t-4} , is added to account for dynamic heterogeneity. Stata routine xtdcce2 was used for estimation. 9.3 Panel regressions with time-varying covariates We now consider panel regressions that include time-varying covariates which we denote by the k_{x}\times 1 vector \mathbf{x}_{it} . Augmenting ( 62 ) with time-varying covariates and their lagged values we have \displaystyle\Delta y_{it} \displaystyle=\alpha_{i}-\phi_{i}y_{i,t-1}+{\textstyle\sum_{s=1}^{p_{T}-1}}\delta_{is}\Delta y_{i,t-s}+\boldsymbol{\beta}_{i}^{\prime}\mathbf{x}_{it}+{\textstyle\sum_{s=0}^{p_{T}-1}}\boldsymbol{\lambda}_{is}^{{}^{\prime}}\Delta\mathbf{x}_{i,t-s} (63) \displaystyle+\mathbf{\psi}_{i0}^{\prime}\mathbf{\bar{z}}_{t}+{\textstyle\sum_{s=1}^{q_{T}-1}}\mathbf{\psi}_{is}^{\prime}\Delta\mathbf{\bar{z}}_{t-s}+u_{it}, where \mathbf{\bar{z}}_{t}=(\bar{y}_{\circ t},\mathbf{\bar{x}}_{\circ t}^{\prime})^{\prime} , \mathbf{\bar{x}}_{\circ t} is the cross section average of \mathbf{x}_{it} , and \boldsymbol{\pi}_{i}=-\boldsymbol{\beta}_{i}/\phi_{i} is the long run elasticity of output with respect to \mathbf{x}_{it} . A large number of covariates have been considered in the literature as possible elements of \mathbf{x}_{it} . Here we focus on three of such variables only, namely physical capital, education as a proxy for human capital, and, a prominent institutional measure, democracy. The problem of how best to select a sub-set from a large number of potential covariates poses new methodological challenges and involves application of penalized regression techniques to dynamic panels with latent factors which is beyond the scope of the present application, primarily intended to illustrate the methodological issues discussed in this paper. Our choice of capital and education variables is based on production function approaches to growth theories that postulate output in the long run to be a function of inputs of capital and labour as in a constant returns Cobb-Douglas production function, with the technology regarded as a latent factor. 16 16 16 Constant returns was not rejected using the DCCE estimators but was using TWFE. For the capital variable we use log capital per-capita, k_{it}=\log(K_{it}/POP_{it}) to explain y_{it}=\log(Y_{it}/POP_{it}) , and use log capital per-employee, \tilde{k}_{it}=\log(K_{it}/EMP_{it}) to explain \tilde{y}_{it}=\log(Y_{it}/EMP_{it}) . 17 17 17 The capital measure K_{it} labelled rnna in PWT is capital stock at constant 2017 national prices (in millions 2017US$). The impact effect of the capital input on growth is likely to be subject to simultaneity bias since cyclical demand and supply factors will complicate the identification of the short-run effects of capital accumulation. However, the long run effects (that we focus on) are more likely to be consistently estimated, particularly when we use CCE type estimators that allow capital and output to be jointly determined by the same set of latent factors representing tastes, technology, and demography. 18 18 18 Here we use a regression explaining output to estimate the long run coefficients. An alternative approach which does not involve specifying the dynamics or a direction of causation is described in Chudik, Pesaran and Smith (2025). The panel data used for estimation is unbalanced and includes countries with at least 30 years of data, rendering a panel with 157 countries and a minimum of 26 data points, noting that the maximum lag order of the panel is set to p_{T}=q_{T}=4 . The estimation results are reported in Table 4 for the same set of specifications as in Table 3 . As before, allowing for heterogeneity and nonparallel trends results in larger estimates for the speed of convergence, while at the same time reducing the required lag orders. We also see further increases in the estimated speed of convergence (irrespective of the estimation method or the choice of output and capital variables) once we condition on the capital variable. This is in line with the literature that finds conditional convergence to be faster than unconditional convergence. We also report estimates of \pi_{k}=E\left(\pi_{ik}\right), the average long run elasticity of output with respect to capital, across the three estimation methods and the two measures of output and capital variables. Under some assumptions \pi_{k} should also measure the share of capital. Pesaran and Yang (2021) discuss the various estimates of the US share of capital used in the literature, which tend to be in the range 0.3-0.4. The estimates we obtain for \pi_{k} are somewhat higher, ranging from 0.48 to 0.64, with the DCCEMG estimates at 0.484 (0.122) (using output per capita) and 0.481 (0.084) (using output per employee) falling at the lower end. However, our estimates refer to an average across a wide range of countries. Over the 126 countries with available data, the average labour share in the PWT data is 0.54, that would suggest a coefficient on capital of around 0.46 . It is interesting that the DCCEMG estimates, that fully allow for heterogeneity across countries, are close to this. As discussed above allowing for a latent factor that simultaneously drives capital accumulation and the output process reduces endogeneity bias (if any) for estimation of long run coefficients. Our second time-varying covariate is the Barro-Lee measure of years of education. Table 5 reports the estimates with average years of education added to the panel regressions on its own and jointly with the capital variable. The number of countries in the panel is now reduced from 157 to 114, since not all countries in our baseline panel have time series data on the education variable, but allows us to increase the minimum number years of data available per country from 27 to 43 and 33 , for per capita and per employee measures, respectively. Also, since in Table 4 the second lagged changes were not statistically significant, the estimates in Table 5 are based only on one lagged changes. For each of the three estimators (TWFE, DCCEP and DCCEMG), we report estimates for models with just capital, just education, and both. The six estimates of the long run coefficient of capital are very close to each other, between 0.53 and 0.57 for per capita measures, and between 0.47 and 0.52 for per employee measures. These are within the range of the estimates in Table 4 . Education is only statistically significant when the capital stock variable is excluded and the panel is estimated by DCCEP using per capita measures. In this case the education variable has a t ratio of 2.12 for the impact effect and 2.24 for the long run effect. The TWFE estimates of the effect of education are negative, but statistically insignificant. Two robustness checks, not reported, were carried out. Firstly, lagged education was added and proved statistically significant only in 3 out of the 12 cases, and in no case was the long run effect of education significant. Second, we experimented with interacting the education variable with \bar{y}_{\circ t} , to see if, \gamma_{i} , the loading of the global factor, varies with education. Again the outcome was not significant. Table 4: Alternative estimates of regressions explaining the change in log output by log capital based on unbalanced panel ARDL regressions of order three using PWT data covering 157 countries over the period 1950-2019. Output per capita Output per employee TWFE DCCEP DCCEMG TWFE DCCEP DCCEMG AR Coefficients y_{i,t-1} (output) \underset{\left(0.007\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.051}} \underset{\left(0.031\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.131}} \underset{\left(0.025\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.349}} \underset{\left(0.009\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.057}} \underset{\left(0.030\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.183}} \underset{\left(0.029\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.375}} {\footnotesize\Delta y}_{i,t-1} \underset{\left(0.030\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.163}} \underset{\left(0.023\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.061}} \underset{\left(0.020\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.118}} \underset{\left(0.031\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.178}} \underset{\left(0.029\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.118}} \underset{\left(0.021\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.132}} {\footnotesize\Delta y}_{i,t-2} \underset{\left(0.027\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.028}} \underset{\left(0.028\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.050}} \underset{\left(0.016\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.005}} \underset{\left({\footnotesize 0.030}\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.028}} \underset{\left(0.044\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.013}} \underset{\left(0.018\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.027}} DL Coefficients k_{it} (Capital) \underset{\left(0.005\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.027}} \underset{\left(0.026\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.084}} \underset{\left(0.045\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.169}} \underset{\left(0.005\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.027}} \underset{\left(0.025\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.115}} \underset{\left(0.034\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.180}} {\footnotesize\Delta k}_{it} \underset{\left(0.110\right)}{{\footnotesize 1.146}} \underset{\left(0.187\right)}{{\footnotesize 1.141}} \underset{\left(0.156\right)}{{\footnotesize 1.757}} \underset{\left(0.043\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.794}} \underset{\left(0.058\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.769}} \underset{\left(0.156\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.724}} {\footnotesize\Delta k}_{i,t-1} \underset{\left(0.112\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.705}} \underset{\left(0.165\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.516}} \underset{\left(0.137\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.815}} \underset{\left(0.050\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.352}} \underset{\left(0.043\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.279}} \underset{\left(0.044\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.285}} {\footnotesize\Delta k}_{i,t-2} \underset{\left(0.066\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.069}} \underset{\left(0.085\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.074}} \underset{\left(0.121\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.043}} \underset{\left(0.038\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.010}} \underset{\left(0.050\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.050}} \underset{\left(0.043\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.029}} Long run effect of capital \underset{\left(0.043\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.524}} \underset{\left(0.105\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.640}} \underset{\left(0.122\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.484}} \underset{\left(0.044\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.470}} \underset{\left(0.068\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.627}} \underset{(0.084)}{{\footnotesize 0.481}} Sample sizes Number of Countries (n) {\footnotesize 157} {\footnotesize 157} {\footnotesize 157} {\footnotesize 157} {\footnotesize 157} {\footnotesize 157} Year T min {\footnotesize 27} {\footnotesize 27} {\footnotesize 26} {\footnotesize 27} {\footnotesize 27} {\footnotesize 26} T ave {\footnotesize 55.2} {\footnotesize 55.2} {\footnotesize 54.2} {\footnotesize 52.0} {\footnotesize 52.0} {\footnotesize 51.0} T max {\footnotesize 67} {\footnotesize 67} {\footnotesize 66} {\footnotesize 67} {\footnotesize 67} {\footnotesize 66} Notes. k_{it} is either the logarithm of capital per capita ”rnna/pop” or per employee ”rnna/emp” from PWT 10.01 , matching the way the output variable is scaled. To filter out the nonparallel trends, DCCEP augments the panel regressions with the cross country averages \mathbf{\bar{z}}_{t-s}, {\footnotesize s=0,1,2,3} , where \mathbf{\bar{z}}_{t}=(\bar{y}_{\circ t},\bar{k}_{\circ t})^{\prime} , and the DCCEMG augments the panel regressions with the additional lagged cross section average, \mathbf{\bar{z}}_{t-4} to account for dynamic heterogeneity. Speed of convergence, \phi=1-\rho_{1}-\rho_{2}-\rho_{3} , is estimated as the coefficient of the lagged output variable, {\footnotesize y}_{i,t-1} . See also Note 2 to Table 3 Table 5: Alternative estimates of regressions explaining the change in log output per capita or per employee by log capital per capita or per employee and education based on unbalanced dynamic panel regressions of order two. Panel A: Output per capita TWFE DCCEP DCCEMG (1) (2) (3) (1) (2) (3) (1) (2) (3) y_{i,t-1} \underset{\left(0.009\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.049}} \underset{\left(0.004\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.022}} \underset{\left(0.009\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.049}} \underset{\left(0.025\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.151}} \underset{\left(0.013\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.094}} \underset{\left(0.029\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.176}} \underset{\left(0.018\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.263}} \underset{\left(0.014\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.140}} \underset{\left(0.022\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.329}} {\footnotesize\Delta y}_{i,t-1} \underset{\left(0.022\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.141}} \underset{\left(0.026\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.204}} \underset{\left(0.022\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.141}} \underset{\left(0.025\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.117}} \underset{\left(0.026\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.169}} \underset{\left(0.026\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.117}} \underset{\left(0.018\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.124}} \underset{\left(0.018\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.207}} \underset{\left(0.017\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.125}} k_{it} \underset{\left(0.006\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.027}} ... \underset{\left(0.006\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.027}} \underset{\left(0.023\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.085}} ... \underset{\left(0.029\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.094}} \underset{\left(0.019\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.151}} ... \underset{\left(0.022\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.174}} {\footnotesize\Delta k}_{it} \underset{\left(0.104\right)}{{\footnotesize 1.172}} ... \underset{\left(0.104\right)}{{\footnotesize 1.171}} \underset{\left(0.151\right)}{{\footnotesize 1.176}} ... \underset{\left(0.145\right)}{{\footnotesize 1.157}} \underset{\left(0.110\right)}{{\footnotesize 1.735}} ... \underset{\left(0.115\right)}{{\footnotesize 1.701}} {\footnotesize\Delta k}_{i,t-1} \underset{\left(0.099\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.731}} ... \underset{\left(0.100\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.731}} \underset{\left(0.128\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.630}} ... \underset{\left(0.118\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.605}} \underset{\left(0.106\right)}{{\footnotesize-1.008}} ... \underset{\left(0.106\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.892}} {\footnotesize ed}_{it}/100 ... -\underset{\left(0.153\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.172}} \underset{\left(0.134\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.032}} ... \underset{\left(0.338\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.719}} \underset{\left(0.424\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.715}} ... \underset{\left(0.657\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.868}} \underset{\left(0.902\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.283}} L.R. k_{it} \underset{\left(0.052\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.542}} ... \underset{\left(0.054\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.544}} \underset{\left(0.088\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.564}} ... \underset{\left(0.103\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.535}} \underset{\left(0.064\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.574}} ... \underset{\left(0.064\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.530}} L.R. ed_{it} ... \underset{\left(7.292\right)}{{\footnotesize-7.630}} \underset{\left(2.773\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.648}} ... \underset{\left(3.395\right)}{{\footnotesize 7.610}} \underset{\left(2.417\right)}{{\footnotesize 4.062}} ... \underset{\left(4.691\right)}{{\footnotesize 6.216}} \underset{\left(2.752\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.861}} Panel B: Output per employee TWFE DCCEP DCCEMG (1) (2) (3) (1) (2) (3) (1) (2) (3) y_{i,t-1} \underset{\left(0.009\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.052}} \underset{\left(0.005\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.027}} \underset{\left(0.009\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.052}} \underset{\left(0.039\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.155}} \underset{\left(0.015\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.108}} \underset{\left(0.030\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.198}} \underset{\left(0.022\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.292}} \underset{\left(0.016\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.154}} \underset{\left(0.024\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.343}} {\footnotesize\Delta y}_{i,t-1} \underset{\left(0.022\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.146}} \underset{\left(0.027\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.160}} \underset{\left(0.022\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.145}} \underset{\left(0.028\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.112}} \underset{\left(0.027\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.116}} \underset{\left(0.025\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.120}} \underset{\left(0.018\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.119}} \underset{\left(0.019\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.106}} \underset{\left(0.019\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.120}} k_{it} \underset{\left(0.006\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.025}} ... \underset{\left(0.006\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.025}} \underset{\left(0.030\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.079}} ... \underset{\left(0.027\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.096}} \underset{\left(0.023\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.149}} ... \underset{\left(0.026\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.180}} {\footnotesize\Delta k}_{it} \underset{\left(0.041\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.840}} ... \underset{\left(0.041\right)}{0.838} \underset{\left(0.048\right)}{0{\footnotesize.826}} ... \underset{\left(0.046\right)}{0{\footnotesize.797}} \underset{\left(0.077\right)}{0{\footnotesize.776}} ... \underset{\left(0.078\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.741}} {\footnotesize\Delta k}_{i,t-1} \underset{\left(0.042\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.384}} ... \underset{\left(0.042\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.385}} \underset{\left(0.046\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.288}} ... \underset{\left(0.047\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.278}} \underset{\left(0.049\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.243}} ... \underset{\left(0.049\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.237}} {\footnotesize ed}_{it}/100 ... -\underset{\left(0.165\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.329}} \underset{\left(0.142\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.158}} ... \underset{\left(0.356\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.380}} \underset{\left(0.408\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.449}} ... \underset{\left(0.796\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.978}} \underset{\left(1.060\right)}{{\footnotesize 1.162}} L.R. k_{it} \underset{\left(0.059\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.474}} ... \underset{\left(0.061\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.481}} \underset{\left(0.094\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.511}} ... \underset{\left(0.082\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.488}} \underset{\left(0.071\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.510}} ... \underset{\left(0.067\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.524}} L.R. ed_{it} ... \underset{\left(7.220\right)}{{\footnotesize-12.332}} \underset{\left(2.870\right)}{{\footnotesize-3.062}} ... \underset{\left(3.128\right)}{3{\footnotesize.510}} \underset{\left(2.019\right)}{{\footnotesize 2.268}} ... \underset{\left(5.203\right)}{{\footnotesize 6.333}} \underset{\left(3.104\right)}{3{\footnotesize.387}} Notes. e{\footnotesize d}_{it} is the Barro Lee 20-60 measure of average years of education taken from the Kremer et al. (2022) replication file. {\footnotesize n=114} , minimum {\footnotesize T}_{i} is 43 for per capita, 33 for per employee, the maximum {\footnotesize T}_{i} is 55 for both, the average is 52.7 for per capita and 50 for per employee. L.R. indicates the long run coefficient of the variable. See also Notes 2 to Table 3 . There has been extensive research on the economic impact of democratization, most prominently by Acemoglu et al. (2019), and it is of interest to investigate the extent to which Acemoglu et al.’s estimates are robust to relaxing the assumptions of dynamic homogeneity and parallel trends. To focus on this problem we use their replication data set which is publicly available. Acemoglu et al. (2019, p.50) argue that existing measures of democracy suffer from measurement error and they develop a dichotomous democracy indicator, zero for non-democracy one for democracy, which combines several indices to purge spurious changes in each. They estimate a dynamic TWFE panel data model using four lags of log output per capita. This corresponds to our error correction specification with three lagged output changes. Their estimates are based on n=175 countries for the years 1960-2010, but some countries only have six years of data, which is too few to relax the parallel trends assumption using CCE estimators. Accordingly, we consider a subset of n=148 countries, that had at least 24 years of data, leaving a minimum of 20 time series observations per country for estimation, after allowing for lags. Their democracy indicator shows time series variation in 73 of the 148 countries; in 75 countries it does not change. This lack of time series variation does not cause any problems when using pooled estimators such as TWFE and DCCEP, since these estimation methods assume the democracy variable to have the same effect across all countries, irrespective of whether their democracy indicator varies over time or not. This is a strong assumption which is difficult to test. We report estimates for two versions of DCCEMG that differ depending on whether homogeneity of the coefficient of the democracy variable is imposed or not. The first version, denoted by DCCEMG*, imposes the same coefficient on the democracy variable across all countries, thus including all the 148 countries, but differs from TWFE or DCCEP since it allows for dynamic heterogeneity. The second version, denoted by DCCEMG, allows for full parameter heterogeneity and uses the smaller sample of 73 countries whose democracy indicator varies over time. The estimation results are reported in Table 6 . The first column gives the Acemoglu et al.’s TWFE estimates based on their full sample of 175 countries and match their estimate of the long run effect of democracy, namely 21.240 (7.215) , given in column 3 of their Table 2. 19 19 19 The bracketed figures give standard errors clustered by country. The subsequent columns give our TWFE estimates using the n=148 sample, which is also used to produce the estimates in the columns under DCCEP and DCCEMG* that impose a homogeneous democracy coefficient. The final column gives the DCCEMG estimates using the n=73 sample of countries with a time-varying democracy indicator, but using \bar{y}_{\circ t} and \bar{d}_{\circ t} computed as cross section averages of y_{it} and d_{it} corresponding to the n=148 sample. While the point estimates of the long run effects for the three DCCE estimators are similar, the n=73 estimate in the final column is not comparable to the other two DCCE estimates. It is an average treatment effect on the treated, where the treatment is a change in the democracy indicator. Table 6: Alternative estimates of equations explaining the change in log output per capita using the dichotomous democracy indicator in unbalanced panel regressions using Acemoglu et al. (2019) data 1960-2010. Output per capita TWFE Dynamic CCE Acemoglu et al. This paper DCCEP DCCEMG ∗ DCCEMG y_{i,t-1} (Lagged log output) \underset{\left(0.005\right)}{-{\footnotesize 0.037}} \underset{(0.005)}{{\footnotesize-0.036}} \underset{(0.020)}{{\footnotesize-0.164}} \underset{\left(0.022\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.218}} \underset{\left(0.035\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.348}} {\footnotesize\Delta y}_{i,t-1} \underset{\left(0.036\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.275}} \underset{(0.035)}{{\footnotesize 0.287}} \underset{\left(0.043\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.210}} \underset{\left(0.025\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.186}} \underset{\left(0.034\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.207}} {\footnotesize\Delta y}_{i,t-2} \underset{\left(0.023\right)}{\emph{0.069}} \underset{(0.025)}{{\footnotesize 0.058}} \underset{\left(0.034\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.018}} \underset{\left(0.018\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.054}} \underset{\left(0.027\right)}{{\footnotesize-0.016}} {\footnotesize\Delta y}_{i,t-3} \underset{\left(0.017\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.042}} \underset{(0.020)}{{\footnotesize 0.047}} \underset{\left(0.028\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.057}} \underset{\left(0.015\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.030}} \underset{\left(0.021\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.086}} d_{it} (Democracy indicator) \underset{\left(0.226\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.787}} \underset{(0.226)}{{\footnotesize 0.769}} \underset{\left(0.574\right)}{{\footnotesize 0.947}} \underset{\left(0.654\right)}{{\footnotesize 1.285}} \underset{\left(1.034\right)}{{\footnotesize 1.499}} Long run effect of Democracy \underset{\left(7.21\right)}{{\footnotesize 21.24}} \underset{(7.47)}{{\footnotesize 21.53}} \underset{(3.59)}{{\footnotesize 5.78}} \underset{(3.06)}{{\footnotesize 5.90}} \underset{\left(3.01\right)}{{\footnotesize 4.30}} Sample Sizes Number of countries n {\footnotesize 175} {\footnotesize 148} {\footnotesize 148} {\footnotesize 148} {\footnotesize 73} Years T_{\min} {\footnotesize 6} {\footnotesize 20} {\footnotesize 20} {\footnotesize 20} {\footnotesize 20} T_{ave} {\footnotesize 36.2} {\footnotesize 40} {\footnotesize 40} {\footnotesize 40} {\footnotesize 41.3} T_{\max} {\footnotesize 47} {\footnotesize 47} {\footnotesize 47} {\footnotesize 47} {\footnotesize 47} Notes. The dependent variable, {\footnotesize\Delta y}_{it} , the change in log output per capita, and {\footnotesize d}_{it} , the dichotomous democracy indicator, are both from the replication data set provided by Acemoglu et al. (2019). The first column, headed Acemoglu et al., replicates their results, subsequent columns exclude countries where the minimum {\footnotesize T}_{i} used for estimation was less that 20. To filter out the nonparallel trends, DCCEP and DCCEMG use cross section averages {\footnotesize\bar{y}}_{\circ,t-s}, {\footnotesize s=0,1,2,3} and {\footnotesize\bar{d}}_{\circ,t}. DCCEMG* imposes that the coefficient of democracy is the same across all {\footnotesize 148} countries, whilst  DCCEMG allows for full heterogeneity across the 73 countries in the panel with time-varying democracy indicators . See also the notes to Table 3 . A comparison of the first two columns of Table 6 shows that dropping countries with less than 24 years of data makes virtually no difference to the TWFE estimates. Looking across the first row of the table shows that, as in the preceding tables, relaxing parallel trends and dynamic homogeneity result in increased estimates of the average speed of convergence across countries, as predicted by the theory. Also, whereas all three lagged output changes are statistically significant when using TWFE, the lagged changes are less significant in the case of the other estimates that relax the homogeneity restrictions. Turning to the impact effect of democracy, the point estimates are very similar to those obtained by Acemoglu et al. (2019), though their statistical significance falls as we allow for a greater degree of heterogeneity, and become statistically insignificant if we condition on countries where the democracy indicator varies. A similar pattern can be observed if we consider the long run estimates. The estimates of the long run coefficient of the democracy variable fall as we relax the parallel trends and dynamic homogeneity assumptions. The statistically significant estimate reported by Acemoglu et al. (2019) become either insignificant or only marginally significant, although all the estimates have the expected positive sign. This loss of statistical significance is not due to multicollinearity between the country-specific democracy indicator, d_{it} , and the cross section average, \bar{d}_{\circ t} . 20 20 20 We are grateful to Daron Acemoglu for suggesting this possibility. When the latter is dropped, democracy is less significant. For instance the DCCEP estimate falls from 0.947 with a t -ratio of 1.65 when \bar{d}_{\circ t} is included, to 0.748 with a \ t -ratio of 1.27 when \bar{d}_{\circ t} is excluded from the panel regression. 9.4 Regressions with time-invariant covariates Finally, we turn to the effects of time invariant covariates on \alpha_{i} and \gamma_{i}, following the procedure set out in subsection 8 . From the large number of time-invariant variables considered in the literature and recently documented by Kremer et al. (2022), we consider an indicator of geography, absolute lattitude ; an indicator that has often been associated with conflict, ethnolinguistic fractionalization ; and an indicator of property rights, protection from expropriation . To these we add our PPP indicator, y_{i,1990}-y_{i,1990}^{PPP} to control for possible systematic differences in the national accounts and PPP measures of output in the initial year of the sample. There are also many other variables that one could consider, such as alternative measures of climate change, technological adaptation, governance approaches, and institutional features. However, due to the challenging new methodological issues that surround the problem of variable selection in the context of high dimensional heterogeneous dynamic panel data models, we confine our empirical analysis to a few variables highlighted as potentially important in the literature. An extension of our empirical analysis to selection from a large set of covariates is beyond the scope of the present paper and must be the subject of a separate investigation. The estimation of the time-invariant effects follows two steps: in the first step we estimate the coefficients of the time-varying effects used to estimate a_{iT} in ( 56 ). To avoid the small T bias of these estimates we only consider their pooled estimates, namely TWFE and DCCEP, denoted by \boldsymbol{\hat{\psi}}_{TWFE} and \boldsymbol{\hat{\psi}}_{DCCEP} , estimated using panel ARDL(2,2) regressions in log output and log capital (either per capita or per employee). We also increase the minimum number of observations used for these first stage panel regressions, so that the average number of time periods used is over 60 years. In the second stage, we run cross-country regressions of \hat{a}_{iT}=\bar{y}_{i\circ}-\mathbf{\bar{q}}_{i\circ}^{\prime}\boldsymbol{\hat{\psi}} , with \boldsymbol{\hat{\psi}=\hat{\psi}}_{TWFE} or \boldsymbol{\hat{\psi}}_{DCCEP} , on an intercept and \mathbf{z}_{i} which is an 4\times 1 vector of time-invariant regressors, with n=100 countries. The estimation results are summarized in Table 7 . The estimated coefficient of absolute latitude is not statistically significant. In contrast, the variables ethnolinguistic fractionalization and protection from expropriation are both statistically significant with the expected signs: a higher probability of conflict or weaker protection of property rights both have negative output effects. The PPP correction coefficient is positive and significant. These outcomes are robust to the choice of the first stage estimates \boldsymbol{\psi} . Table 7: Cross-country regressions estimating the coefficients (standard errors) of time-invariant regressors using different procedures to filter the time-varying effects. Output per capita Output per employee TWFE DCCEP TWFE DCCEP Dependent variable, \hat{a}_{i} absolute latitude ( z_{i1} ) \underset{(1.289)}{0.383} \underset{(2.568)}{0.832} \underset{\left(1.283\right)}{0.747} \underset{\left(3.390\right)}{1.353} ethnolinguistic fractionalization ( z_{i2} ) \underset{(0.608)}{-1.71} \underset{(1.341)}{-3.062} \underset{\left(0.658\right)}{-1.643} \underset{\left(1.831\right)}{-4.554} protection from expropriation ( z_{i3} ) \underset{(0.122)}{0.699} \underset{(0.236)}{0.952} \underset{\left(0.135\right)}{0.627} \underset{\left(0.336\right)}{1.219} y_{i,1990}-y_{i,1990}^{PPP} ( z_{i4} ) \underset{(0.272)}{0.704} \underset{(0.709)}{1.374} \underset{\left(0.328\right)}{0.883} \underset{\left(0.984\right)}{2.675} Notes. The reported estimates are computed by least squares regressions of \hat{a}_{i}=\bar{y}_{i\circ}-\mathbf{\bar{q}}_{i\circ}^{\prime}\boldsymbol{\hat{\psi}} , on an intercept and \mathbf{z}_{i}=(z_{i1},z_{i2},z_{i3},z_{i4})^{\prime} , for i=1,2,...,{\footnotesize n=100} , where \mathbf{\bar{q}}_{i\circ} is the time averages of lagged output and capital variables for country i , \boldsymbol{\hat{\psi}}=\boldsymbol{\hat{\psi}}_{TWFE} or \boldsymbol{\hat{\psi}}_{DCCEP} are  TWFE and DCCEP estimators obtained using ARDL(2,2) panel regressions in log output and log capital (either per capita or per employee). Data on \mathbf{z}_{i} are from Kremer et al. (2022) and are all divided by 100 to scale up the estimates provided. Standard errors are heteroskedasticity robust. The maximum time period used for estimation of \boldsymbol{\hat{\psi}}\ was 68 years. {\footnotesize T}_{\min}{\footnotesize=48} and {\footnotesize T}_{ave}{\footnotesize=63} years for regressions based per capita measures, and {\footnotesize T}_{\min}{\footnotesize=38} and {\footnotesize T}_{ave}{\footnotesize=61} years for regressions based on per employee measures. 10 Concluding remarks The empirical results presented in the previous section are in line with the theory and show that large biases can result from wrongly assuming parallel trends and/or homogeneous dynamics. Barro or pooled regression estimates of the speed of convergence are biased towards zero unless all slope coefficients in the panel are homogeneous and the heterogeneity of the fixed effects can be modelled perfectly: an impossible undertaking. TWFE estimates allow for intercept heterogeneity, but continue to be substantially biased if its two main assumptions of parallel trends and dynamic homogeneity are invalidated. Most crucially, when the latent factor is trended (deterministic or stochastic) and its effects differ across countries, the TWFE estimate of the speed of convergence tends to zero, no matter what is its true value. To deal with nonparallel trends and dynamic heterogeneity we consider DCCEP and DCCEMG estimators that are the dynamic versions of the CCE estimator originally proposed by Pesaran (2006). DCCEP relaxes the parallel trends assumption but maintains dynamic homogeneity, whilst DCCEMG allows for both. We show that DCCEP produces consistent estimates even if the latent factors driving the growth process are trended, with or without unit roots. In the empirical applications and in line we our theoretical results, we find that the mean convergence time of output to its steady state trend falls from hundreds of years if one uses Barro estimates, to 27 years if one uses TWFE, and to 6 years if one uses DCCEMG estimates, which closely match the business cycle frequency in OECD countries. We have relatively quick convergence to a country specific steady state trend, but there is no evidence of global cross-country convergence. When capital is added it has a sensible long run coefficient. Relaxing the parallel trends assumption reduces the endogeneity problem, since the introduction of a latent global factor with a country specific effect reduces the omitted variable problem arising from common factors driving both output and capital. We also investigated the effects of time-invariant variables on average deviations of output from its steady state trend, and found statistically significant positive effects from higher levels of protection from expropriation and statistically significant negative effects from high levels of ethnolinguistic fractionalization . There remain a number of areas for further research both in the econometric methods and in the determinants of the differences in output across countries. These include • The high dimensional selection problem in panels for a more comprehensive empirical analysis of the determinants of output from the large number of fast and slow moving variables suggested in the literature. • Inference on the role of time-invariant effects and how to separate their effects on the level of output ( \alpha_{i} ) and the trend output growth ( \gamma_{i} ). • How to distinguish between time-varying and time-invariant effects of climate. The time-varying effects have been extensively investigated in the literature. See, for example, Kahn, Mohaddes, Ng, Pesaran, Raissi, and Yang (2021), and references cited therein. • Convergence between countries, perhaps within clubs, can be investigated by looking at pairwise convergence, as in Pesaran (2007). Although this paper has focussed on economic growth similar issues come up in other research areas. For example, Westerlund, Karabiyik, Narayan and Narayan (2022) consider similar econometric issues in the context of applications to corporate finance.