Resolving the Tachocline using Inversion of Rotational Splitting Derived from Fitting Very Long and Long Time Series Sylvain G. Korzennik, Antonio Eff-Darwich Abstract We use rotation splittings derived from very long and long time series, namely 25.2, 12.6 and 6.3 year long, computed by Korzennik 2023 independent methodology to characterize the solar tachocline and its variation with latitude and time. We use two different inversion methodologies and a model of the tachocline to derive its position, width and the amplitude of the radial shear. To validate our methodology we present results from simulated rotational splittings, whether including or not random noise commensurable with the current observational precision. We also describe how we leverage the fact that one of our methodologies uses an initial guess that can be chosen to include a priori information. In order to try to resolve the tachocline, we increased the radial density of the inversion grid and showed how it affect the inferences. We also show how the trade off between smoothing and noise magnification affects these, as well as the effectiveness of using an informed initial guess. Results derived from high-precision rotational splittings show clearly that the location of the tachocline at low latitudes is different for its position at high latitudes. The latitudinal variation of its width is not significantly constrained, but our results agree with estimates based on forward modeling. When using splittings derived from somewhat shorter time series, we find temporal variations that are neither definitive nor significant, since we see systematic differences when using different methodologies. show]skorzennik@cfa.harvard.edu show]adarwich@ull.edu.es I Introduction The solar tachocline, a term introduced by Spiegel and Zahn 1992 , is the shear layer where the solar rotation transitions from a nearly rigid-body rotation in the radiative interior to a differential rotation in the convection zone, i.e., where the rotation varies with depth and latitude. This transition layer is located near the base of the convective envelope, i.e., approximately at 0.7\,R_{\odot} , and is believed to be the seat of the solar dynamo, the mechanism responsible for generating the Sun’s magnetic field. It is also believed to be responsible for the solar activity cycles and to play a vital role in angular momentum transport and chemical mixing within the Sun ( Strugarek et al. 2023 ) . Over the past three decades, helioseismic analyses of the internal solar rotation rate ( Thompson et al. 2003 ) , based on p-mode oscillation frequencies and employing both global and local inversion techniques, have provided increasingly precise estimates of the tachocline’s location, thickness, and temporal variability (see Table 1 ). These studies rely on observations from instruments such as BBSO ( Libbrecht 1989 ) , SDO-HMI ( Schou et al. 2012 ) , SOI-MDI ( Scherrer et al. 1995 ) , GONG ( Harvey et al. 1996 ) , and LOWL ( Tomczyk et al. 1995 ) , which have provided frequency measurements of acoustic modes whose internal turning points are distributed both above and below the tachocline, thereby enabling sensitive diagnostics of this rotational shear layer. Helioseismic results place the tachocline between 0.69 and 0.72\,R_{\odot} , with estimates of its thickness at the equator ranging from 0.006 to 0.05\,R_{\odot} (see Table 2 ). Despite general agreement on its location, substantial variation persists across studies, particularly regarding the tachocline’s latitudinal profile and temporal evolution. Some studies suggest a prolate geometry, i.e., thicker and deeper at higher latitudes, while others suggest a more spherical or indeterminate structure. Similarly, while several analyses detect temporal changes in the amplitude of the shear with respect to time, hence the solar activity level, others find no significant variation. These discrepancies arise not only from the limited spatial resolution of helioseismic inversions, particularly near the tachocline, but also from differences in the length and quality of the input data sets, the inversion methodologies, and the parameterizations used to define the tachocline properties. In any case, it is clear that the tachocline is a dynamic, spatially complex region whose precise characterization remains challenging. Hence, it is necessary to implement inversion techniques capable of resolving sharp gradients and fine-scale features while minimizing smoothing, typically used to alleviate the intrinsic singular nature of the rotation inverse problem, while limiting noise magnification. Moreover, applying such techniques consistently across diverse data sets derived from different instruments is essential for building a coherent and physically meaningful picture of the tachocline. Instrument Location Width Observed Variation Reference BBSO 0.692 \pm 0.005 0.096 \pm 0.04 Kosovichev (1996) Mean GONG+BBSO 0.7050 \pm 0.0027 0.0098 \pm 0.0026 Basu (1997) GONG 0.675 – 0.695 0.001 – 0.013 Hints of latitude dependence, not statistically significant. Dependence on the analysis technique Antia, Basu & Chitre (1998) LOWL 0.695 \pm 0.005 0.05 \pm 0.03 (half-width) Corbard et al. (1998) LOWL 0.701 \pm 0.004 < 0.05 Corbard et al. (1999) LOWL 0.693 \pm 0.002 0.039 \pm 0.013 Prolate profile: radius increases by \sim 0.024 \pm 0.004 R_{\odot} from equator to 60^{\circ} . No significant variation of thickness with latitude Charbonneau et al. (1999) MDI 0.697 \pm 0.002 0.019 \pm 0.001 Based on inversions of the sound speed Elliott & Gough (1999) Not specified Not specified Rotation rate increases with depth at low/mid latitudes, 1.3-year oscillations near equator, \sim 1 year at high latitudes Howe et al. (2000) Mean GONG+MDI 0.6893 \pm 0.0023 0.0061 \pm 0.0012 Clear latitudinal variation in depth. No significant temporal variations Basu & Antia (2001) Mean GONG+MDI 0.6916 \pm 0.0019 0.0065 \pm 0.0013 Clear latitudinal variation in depth and width. No significant temporal variations Basu & Antia (2003) GONG 0.6945 \pm 0.0013 0.0037 \pm 0.0011 Center is prolate and thickness increases with latitude. MDI 0.6915 \pm 0.0016 0.0028 \pm 0.0017 Clear temporal variation of \delta\Omega with solar activity Antia & Basu (2011) GONG 0.7067 –- 0.7187 0.0067–0.0198 MDI 0.708 –- 0.7181 0.003 –- 0.0188 Clear temporal variation across solar cycles 23–25, HMI 0.7058 –- 0.7166 0.0077 –- 0.0182 changes in depth and \delta\Omega Basu et al. (2024) Table 1: Summary of tachocline properties from various helioseismic studies. Observed variations include only latitudinal or temporal effects when reported. Instrument Position Width MDI 0.692 – 0.718 0.003 -– 0.072 GONG 0.689 – 0.719 0.006 – 0.096 LOWL 0.690 – 0.700 0.026 – 0.080 BBSO 0.690 – 0.696 0.031 – 0.080 HMI 0.706 – 0.717 0.008 – 0.018 Table 2: Summary of the position and width of the tachocline at the equator as estimated from each instrument. Although the present work focuses primarily on the internal rotation rate of the Sun, complementary and essential insights are provided by helioseismic inferences of the Sun’s internal structure, particularly those deriving the difference in sound speed between observations and the standard solar model in the vicinity of the tachocline. Structural inversions of helioseismic data reveal a distinct bump in the sound speed profile near 0.65\,R_{\odot} , coinciding with the location of the tachocline, where observed values exceed predictions from the standard solar model. This anomaly is generally attributed to compositional differences in the tachocline, particularly the helium mixing that reduces the local mean molecular weight and thereby increases the sound speed ( Gough and McIntyre 1998 ) . These structural signatures provide independent constraints on the depth, composition, and mixing processes within the tachocline, and therefore offer valuable complementary results to those derived from rotation inversions ( Elliott and Gough 1999 ; Takata and Shibahashi 2003 ) . A number of theoretical models have been developed to explain the formation, stability, and confinement of the tachocline — i.e., its remarkable thinness — each emphasizing different physical mechanisms (see a sample of them in Table 3 ). Hydrodynamic models (e.g., Spiegel and Zahn 1992 ) propose viscous shear spreading, constrained by anisotropic turbulence, as such mechanism, whereas magnetic confinement models rely on either fossil fields resisting differential shear ( Gough and McIntyre 1998 ) or dynamo-generated oscillatory fields ( Forgács-Dajka and Petrovay 2001 ). Additional models highlight the role of thermal wind balance, meridional circulation, and baroclinic forcing in shaping the tachocline’s structure ( Rempel 2005 ; Balbus and Weiss 2010 ). Predictions for the tachocline’s location typically place it near the base of the convection zone (around 0.69\,R_{\odot} ), with model-dependent thicknesses ranging from very thin ( \sim 0.02\,R_{\odot} ) to more extended ( \sim 0.1\,R_{\odot} ). Several models account for latitudinal variation, often predicting a prolate shape (thicker at higher latitudes), and some suggest temporal modulations tied to the solar magnetic cycle or internal dynamo dynamics. While steady-state structures are assumed in some cases, others predict cyclic or irregular variability, reflecting the dynamic interplay between rotational shear, magnetic fields, and turbulent mixing. Hence, it is essential to improve the observational constraints provided by helioseismic inversions, including isorotation contours, detailed latitudinal and radial shear gradients, confirming the nearly uniform rotation of the radiative interior, and measuring the tachocline’s position and thickness as well as their latitudinal variation. These characteristics are essential for understanding its long-term stability against radiative spreading. They are also vital for constraining the underlying angular momentum transport mechanism, like the nature of turbulent anisotropy (e.g., horizontal vs. radial efficiency) and the effectiveness of magnetic confinement by either fossil or dynamo-generated oscillatory fields. Finally, long-term, continuous helioseismic observations with high spatial resolution are required to detect subtle temporal variations of the tachocline potentially linked to the solar cycle or internal dynamo dynamics. Table 3: Summary of some theoretical tachocline confinement models and their predictions. Confinement Mechanism Properties, if given Reference Confinement due to highly anisotropic turbulent viscosity Width \sim 0.13 to 0.1\,R_{\odot} Spiegel and Zahn 1992 with a large horizontal component Elliott 1997 Magnetic field quenches shear in RZ Thin implied; thickness increases towards the poles Rudiger and Kitchatinov 1997 Fossil magnetic field suppresses shear in RZ Thin Gough and McIntyre 1998 explains rigid interior rotation (i.e., below helioseismic inversion spatial resolution) Garaud and Garaud 2008 Turbulent tachocline pervaded and Thin confined by a dynamo-generated field Forgács-Dajka and Petrovay 2001 Anisotropy in momentum transport Implied thinness due to large horizontal turbulent viscosity Leprovost and Kim 2006 Global dynamical model, Base convection zone but is not able to avoid tachocline spreading with time Brun et al. 2011 Baroclinic radiative equilibrium Thin and sharp layer with no significant meridional circulation for stable confined tachocline Caleo et al. 2015 This model does not explain tachocline confinement Much thicker above 50^{\circ} to avoid hydrodynamic instability Gilman 2018 Persistent nonaxisymmetric dynamo field Width <0.05\,R_{\odot} regulates tachocline shear via Maxwell stresses Matilsky et al. 2024 In summary, we need to move beyond broad qualitative descriptions and toward a quantitatively constrained characterization of the tachocline’s structure and its role in solar dynamics. This requires not only enhanced spatial resolution, sensitivity, and temporal coverage, but also the systematic application of consistent and robust inversion techniques across multiple data sets and instruments. II Data Sets In order to best characterize the solar tachocline using rotation inversions we want to use rotational splittings with the lowest possible uncertainties, hence values estimated using the longest available time series. In contrast to the instruments’ respective reduction pipe-lines, observations taken by MDI, HMI and GONG have been fitted by Korzennik 2023 using time series of various lengths. Namely, sets as short as 36 days, but also sets of 72, 144, 288, etc, up to 2,304 days and 4,608 days (i.e., 32\times and 64\times 72 days, or 6.3 and 12.6 years respectively) for all 3 instruments, and up to 9,216 days (i.e., 128\times 72 days, or 25.2 years) for GONG. For time series longer than 72 days, the fitted epochs overlap by 50%, while their starting time is offset by an integer multiple of 72 days with respect to 1996.05.01 (i.e., the fist day MDI produced science quality data). To attempt resolving the tachocline, we opted to use rotational splittings resulting from fitting a very long (i.e., 128\times 72 day) and long (i.e., 32\times and 64\times 72 day) time series. The temporal coverage of these time series, compared with that of the three instruments, as well as the solar activity, represented by the sunspot number, are plotted in Fig. 1 . Figure 1: Temporal coverage of the time series used in the work presented here (filled boxes), compared the temporal coverage of the observations (open boxes) for the MDI, HMI and GONG instruments, and to the solar activity illustrated by the monthly averaged sunspot number. III Methodology and Inverse Techniques III.1 Variable Radial Gridding Since we try to resolve the tachocline, we decided to break from tradition and use a model grid – i.e., the set of target locations – with a high resolution in the radial direction, especially around the tachocline. The resolution in latitude was in all cases left uniform. Since our inversion techniques (see below) allow for a variable grid spacing, we experiment with various grids. Of course, the simplest grid is a uniformly spaced grid, but in order to reach a high resolution at the tachocline (i.e., well below 0.5% in the radial direction) the grid size becomes large, hence the size of the problem (i.e., the sizes of the matrices to handle) gets very large, requiring large amounts of memory and quite long computation time. With these constraints in mind, we defined such a grid using 256 radial points and 54 latitudinal points, or 13,824 target locations. The radial resolution of this grid is 0.39%. Alternatively, one can change the grid spacing to be large in the radiative zone (i.e., below the tachocline), where one knows from past experience that the radial resolution of rotation inversions is low while the solar rotation rate does not appear to vary much with respect to radius. One can also set the spacing above the tachocline (i.e., in the convection zone) to a value small enough to resolve the known radial variation on that region, while using, in a radial range centered around the tachocline, a much smaller spacing. To avoid edge effects, we realized through trial and error, that it is best if the second derivative of the radial grid remains smooth. Following these guidelines, we defined what we call an aggressive grid, a grid that reaches at the tachocline a resolution of 0.09% while remaining a set of 97 by 56, or only 5,432 target locations. Finally, we also defined what we call progressive grids, where the radial spacing was set to vary more smoothly, i.e., using a polynomial in r , with two target resolutions at the tachocline of 0.25% and 0.18%, hence a set of 142 by 56 or 7,952 target points and a set of 171 by 56 or 9,576 target points. These 4 grids are illustrated in Fig. 2 where the positions of the target locations are shown in Cartesian coordinates, as well as the corresponding grid radial spacing as a function of radius. Figure 2: Positions of the target locations, shown in Cartesian coordinates (top panels) and the grids’ radial spacing as a function of radius (bottom panels) for the four grids we used. Shown, from left to right, are the uniform radial spacing grid, two progressive radial spacing grids and the so-called aggressive radial spacing grid. The lowest radial resolution, occurring around the tachocline, is indicated as well. III.2 Inversion Techniques We use two different inversion methods: a variant of the classical regularized least squares technique ( Eff-Darwich and Pérez Hernández 1997 , RLS, see) and a newly developed iterative technique based on the simultaneous algebraic reconstruction technique ( Korzennik and Eff-Darwich 2024 , SART,) . The SART technique was originally implemented to solve linear systems in image reconstruction ( Anderson and Kak 1984 ; van der Sluis and van der Vorst 1990 ) and was proposed as an inversion technique for the solar internal rotation rate by Eff-Darwich et al. 2010 . Both methods use a piecewise constant discretization of the two-dimensional rotation inverse problem, and their implementation allows for a non-uniform discretization grid (aka target locations). Both are coded to allow the computation of the averaging kernels, K^{(a)}_{i,j}(r,\theta) . Indeed, the two-dimensional rotation inverse problem can be written as \frac{\delta\nu_{n,\ell,m}}{2\,m}=\iint K^{(r)}_{n,\ell,m}(r,\theta)\,\Omega(r,\theta)\,dr\,d\theta (1) where \delta\nu_{n,\ell,m}=\nu_{n,\ell,m}-\nu_{n,\ell,-m} are the individual rotation splittings, \nu_{n,\ell,m} the frequency for the mode with radial order n , spherical harmonic degree \ell , and azimuthal order m . K^{(r)}_{n,\ell,m} is the corresponding rotation kernel ( Hansen, Cox and van Horn 1977 ; Eff-Darwich and Pérez Hernández 1997 ; Korzennik and Eff-Darwich 2024 , see) , \Omega the rotation rate, r the radius, and \theta the co-latitude. Notice that we use the individual rotation splittings, not expansion coefficients of these splittings as a function of m , since (i) the tables resulting from the fitting by Korzennik 2023 provide these individual frequencies from which we compute the splittings; and (ii) using individual splittings results in better angular resolution since the observables are not pre-smoothed to an arbitrary number of expansion coefficients. When that inverse problem is solved as a linear combination of the splittings, the resulting estimate of the rotation rate, \tilde{\Omega} , is a convolution of the true underlying rotation rate, \Omega , by a linear combination of the rotational kernels. That linear combination is the averaging kernel, namely: \displaystyle\tilde{\Omega}(r_{i},\theta_{j}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{n,\ell,m}c^{(i,j)}_{n,\ell,m}\frac{\delta\nu_{n,\ell,m}}{2\,m} (2) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\iint\sum_{n,\ell.m}c^{(i,j)}_{n,\ell,m}K^{(r)}_{n,\ell,m}(r,\theta)\,\Omega(r,\theta)\,dr\,d\theta (3) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\iint K^{(a)}_{(i,j)}(r,\theta)\,\Omega(r,\theta)\,dr\,d\theta (4) hence K^{(a)}_{(i,j)}(r,\theta)=\sum_{n,\ell.m}c^{(i,j)}_{n,\ell,m}K^{(r)}_{n,\ell,m}(r,\theta) (5) Our RLS technique is computationally fast, and we implemented it with a single trade-off parameter (aka Lagrangian multiplier) that controls the amount of smoothing on the solution by minimizing its second derivative. In contrast, the SART technique is slow, since it is an iterative method, and we implemented it using either a global or local smoothing. The local smoothing is a parametrized function of depth and latitude (see Korzennik and Eff-Darwich 2024 , for additional details) . Since there is some commonality in the pre-processing of both methods, i.e., the discretization of matrices on the model grid, that common first step is coded as a separate computation, and is parallelized using the message passing interface (MPI) to speed it up. The second step of the SART inversion is also parallelized using MPI, while the second step of the RLS is not since it is relatively fast. Finally, since the SART technique starts with an initial guess, it gives us the option to use either a simple starting value, like a constant close to the mean rotation rate, or an informed initial guess, like a two-dimensional approximation of the anticipated solution. III.3 SART Initial Guess The simplest way to define the SART initial value is to start with a constant value at each grid point, picking a value close to the mean rotation. Hence we selected a starting value of 470 nHz. We also checked that we run enough iterations for the technique to converge, by saving the solution at intermediate number of iterations and confirming that the changes of the solution become negligible. We also investigated whether we can exploit the need for a starting value by using an informed guess. If we assume that the solution obtained with the RLS technique is a smoothed version of the true rotation, we should be able to use it to produce such informed initial guess. Since we are interested in the properties of the tachocline, and specifically its width, let us assume that the RLS solution is a good initial guess, but should be sharpened, since the RLS regularization is smoothing of the true solution, while the inferred position of the tachocline does not need any adjustment. Our current implementation of such sharpening is to fit a sigmoid to the tachocline, assume that its location is correct, but that its width is overestimated. Therefore we replace a portion of the RLS solution by a more narrow sigmoid, typically reducing its width by a factor two, and using this narrow profile as an initial guess for the SART technique. As presented in the next section, we used simulated splittings computed from model rotation profiles to not only test how well our techniques recover the tachocline, but also to validate our SART initial guess approach. IV Results from Simulations We present results from simulated splittings computed from simple but realistic rotational models. Namely a solid body rotation below the tachocline, a differential rotation above the tachocline, although constant on cylinder (to use a simple parametrization) and a tachocline whose width is different for different models. From these models, we compute the individual rotational splittings and assign to each an uncertainty corresponding to the error bar for that mode derived from fitting a 32\times 72 day long time series. Assigning a realistic relative uncertainty is key to replicating adequately the resolution potential of observations, even when inverting noiseless splittings. These three models are illustrated in Fig. 3 , for a so-called wide , nominal , and narrow tachocline. Figure 3: Three models used for our simulation. The top panels show the simulated rotation rate in Cartesian coordinates, while the bottom panels show the rotation profile at the equator, with a zoomed view around the tachocline in the lower left panel. Of course, to estimate the effect of observational noise, we also added random noise to each splitting. This noise is scaled by the mode’s uncertainty and an arbitrary factor. We used the values 0.1, 0.5 and 1.0 for that extra factor, simulating random errors corresponding to fitting a 100\times,4\times, or 1\times ( 32\times 72 -day) long time series. IV.1 Noiseless Simulations The effect of radial gridding on solutions derived from noiseless simulations is shown in Fig. 4 for the RLS method and in Fig. 5 for the SART method, whether using as an initial guess a constant value, or the exact solution. These figures show clearly how the RLS solution with a very high radial resolution resolves the tachocline, when using a very low smoothing trade-off. It also hints at a Gibbs-like phenomenon in the case of the narrow tachocline. Figure 4: RLS solutions for noiseless simulations (solid lines with dots) superimposed over the true solutions (dashed lines) for the three models of the tachocline, shown using different colors (red for narrow , green for nominal , and blue for wide ). Top to bottom panels correspond to different inversion grids ( aggressive , progressive I , and progressive II ), while left to right panels correspond to increasing smoothing (as per the trade-off coefficient \Lambda ). For the SART method, the solutions computed using the very high radial resolution display numerical noise that we trace to the rate of change of the radial grid. Indeed, this noise is absent from the solutions for the the progressive grids. Not surprisingly, the solutions for noiseless simulations, when starting with the exact solution and when using very little smoothing, recover the narrow tachocline. Yet adding more radial points to reach a lower minimum resolution, using a progressive grid, recovers the solution even better. And, not surprisingly either, adding some smoothing, in all cases, leads to a set of solutions that no longer resolves the model with the most narrow tachocline. Figure 5: SART solutions for noiseless simulations (solid lines with dots) superimposed over the true solutions (dashed lines) for the three models of tachocline, shown using different colors (red for narrow , green for nominal , and blue for wide ). Top to bottom panels correspond to different inversion grids ( aggressive , progressive I and progressive II ), while leftmost panel shows solutions when initial guess is set to a constant, while the middle and rightmost panels correspond to solutions when setting the initial to the true solutions and varying the smoothing factor \alpha (i.e., smoothing increases with lower \alpha values). The unique combination of the progressive II grid, exact initial solution and low smoothing (in the lowest middle panel) recovers almost perfectly the three models. We also need to check the effect of the choice of the initial guess, since except for simulations, the exact solution is unknown. Henceforth we inverted noiseless simulated data sets starting with a narrow, nominal or wide initial guess for all 3 simulations (i.e., models with narrow, nominal, and wide tachocline). The resulting solutions when using almost no smoothing are presented in Fig. 6 , while solutions when using what we consider typical smoothing are shown in Fig. 7 . These plots indicate that in the absence of noise and with almost no smoothing, the SART method with a too narrow initial guess will not properly recover the wider tachoclines, yet this becomes less of a problem when including typical smoothing. Figure 6: SART solutions for noiseless simulations (solid lines with dots) superimposed over the true solutions (dashed lines) for the three models (shown with different colors) and almost no smoothing. Top to bottom panels correspond to different inversion grids ( aggressive , progressive I and progressive II ), while left to right panels correspond to using different initial guesses (narrow, exact and wide respectively). Figure 7: SART solutions for noiseless simulations (solid lines with dots) superimposed over the true solutions (dashed lines) for the three models (shown with different colors) and “typical” smoothing. Top to bottom panels correspond to different inversion grids ( aggressive , progressive I and progressive II ), while left to right panels correspond to using different initial guesses (narrow, exact and wide respectively). IV.2 More Realistic Simulations Since in practice actual observations have some level of noise, it is a lot more instructive to invert simulations with random noise. Solutions for noisy simulations using the RLS method are presented in Fig. 8 and when using the SART method, and two levels of smoothing, in Fig. 9 . Figure 8: RLS solutions for noisy simulations (solid lines with dots) superimposed over the true solutions (dashed lines) for the three models (shown with different colors). Top to bottom panels correspond to increasing smoothing (as per the trade-off coefficient \Lambda ), while left to right panels correspond to increasing levels of noise, with respect to the uncertainties resulting from fitting a 32\times 72 d time series. Figure 9: SART solutions for noisy simulations (solid lines with dots) superimposed over the true solutions (dashed lines) for the three models (shown with different colors), using the progressive I grid. The top two rows correspond to almost no smoothing, while the bottom two rows to “typical” smoothing (as per value of \alpha ). Rows alternate cases with constant or exact initial guess, while columns correspond to increasing levels of noise, with respect to the uncertainties resulting from fitting a 32\times 72 d time series (from left to right). What these figures show is that in the presence of noise, the RLS and SART solutions display a strong Gibbs-like effect. While RLS solutions using the so-called aggressive grid looked great when using noiseless splittings, adding any level of noise results in large excursions that gets damped with additional smoothing. The challenge when using actual observations remains the optimal and objective selection of the trade-off between smoothing and noise amplification. Yet, with these caveats in mind, using the aggressive radial grid remains a viable strategy. In contrast, the SART method behaves a lot better when using the progressive grid, but remains affected by Gibbs-like excursions without appropriate smoothing. Yet, using an informed initial guess, while tricky and misleading in noiseless cases, offers limited improvement in the noisy cases. V Results from Observations From the tables of individual modes, \nu_{n,\ell,m} , we compute the scaled rotational splittings, s_{n,\ell,m} , and perform an outliers rejection. The scaled rotational splittings are defined as s_{n,\ell,m}=\frac{\delta\nu_{n,\ell,m}}{2m} (6) The uncertainties of the scaled splittings, \sigma_{s_{n,\ell,m}} , are derived from the individual modes uncertainties. The outliers rejection consists in fitting a straight line to the scaled splittings, s_{n,\ell,m} , with respect to the ratio {m}/{\ell} , using a 3- \sigma rejection when performing this fit. Scaled splittings that depart from that straight line by some value, r_{s} , are rejected, i.e., when |s_{n,\ell,m}-f(\frac{m}{\ell})|>r_{s} (7) as well as values whose reduced differences magnitude, i.e., the difference divided by the uncertainty, exceed some threshold, t_{s} , i.e., when \left|\frac{s_{n,\ell,m}-f(\frac{m}{\ell})}{\sigma_{s_{n,\ell,m}}}\right|>t_{s} (8) We tested several combinations of these two thresholds and settled on r_{s}=200 nHz and t_{s}=1.5 as a good trade-off between limiting the amount of rejection and yet eliminating most of the outliers. The resulting rotational rates, for four data sets and both inversion methods, are shown in an overall two-dimensional representation in Cartesian coordinates in Fig. 10 . The main features of the resulting rotation rate are the well-established near solid body rotation in the radiative interior, the differential rotation nearly constant on cones in the convection zone, a narrow tachocline near the base of the convection zone and a near-surface shear layer. Figure 10: Inverted rotation rate derived from splittings resulting from fitting very long time series, i.e., 25.2 years of GONG observations (leftmost panel) and long time series, i.e., 12.6 years of GONG, MDI or HMI observations (rightmost 3 columns), using either RLS or SART inversion methodology (top versus bottom row). V.1 Results Using Very Long Time Series A different representation of the inverted rotation rate derived from fitting a very long time series is shown in Fig. 11 , when using in both cases the lower resolution progressive grid. The tachocline and the near-surface shear are clearly visible. Figure 11: Inverted rotation rate derived from splittings resulting from fitting a very long time series, i.e., 25.2 years of GONG observations, plotted as a function of radius for a set of latitudes, using either the RLS or SART inversion methodology (left versus right panels). In order to characterize the tachocline, we followed the methodology used in Basu et al. 2024 where the tachocline is parametrized as a sigmoid. Hence, at each latitude, we fit a sigmoid, complemented by two slopes and a constant, to the inverted profiles as a function of radius, namely \tilde{\Omega}(r,\phi)=\Omega_{o,\phi}+\frac{\Delta\Omega_{\phi}}{1+e^{\frac{r-r_{d,\phi}}{w_{d,\phi}}}}+\left\{\begin{array}[]{lr}s_{-,\phi}\,(r-r_{d,\phi})&\mbox{~~~~~ for $rr_{d,\phi}$}\end{array}\right. (9) where \tilde{\Omega} is the inverted rotation rate, r the radius, \phi=\pi/2-\theta the latitude, r_{d,\phi} the location of the sigmoid discontinuity, w_{d,\phi} the width of the sigmoid, \Delta\Omega_{\phi} the amplitude of the sigmoid jump, \Omega_{o,\phi}+\frac{\Delta\Omega_{\phi}}{2} is the rotation at r=r_{d} and ( s_{-,\phi} , s_{+,\phi} ) the slopes below or above r_{d,\phi} . We use the limited radial range 0.43