DeepDive: Tracing the early quenching pathways of massive quiescent galaxies at z > 3 z>3 from their star-formation histories and chemical abundances Massissilia L. Hamadouche, Katherine E. Whitaker, Francesco Valentino, Jacqueline Antwi-Danso, Kei Ito, Aliza Beverage, Pengpei Zhu (朱芃佩), Gabriel Brammer, Vasily Kokorev, Gabriella de Lucia, William M. Baker, Marion Farcy, Anna Gallazzi, Steven Gillman, Rashmi Gottumukkala, Michaela Hirschmann, Christian Kragh Jespersen, Takumi Kakimoto, Minju M. Lee, Masato Onodera, Rhythm Shimakawa, Masayuki Tanaka, John R. Weaver, Po-Feng Wu Abstract We investigate the chemical abundances and star-formation histories (SFH) of ten massive ( log 10 ​ ( M ⋆ / M ⊙ ) > 10.5 \mathrm{log}_{10}(M_{\star}/\mathrm{M}_{\odot})>10.5 ) quiescent galaxies at 3 < z < 4 3 3 z>3 . I Introduction In the past few years, JWST has confirmed the existence of a high number of massive quiescent galaxies (MQGs) at z>3 ( 109 ; 23 ; 83 ; 82 ; 100 ) . Given the high quality of the data coupled with the access to near-infrared wavelengths afforded by JWST , these galaxies are excellent laboratories to explore the star-formation and chemical-enrichment histories of galaxies. Specifically, the abundance of key elements from spectral absorption features (at \lambda_{\mathrm{rest}}>4000 Å, e.g., Mg b ) can provide effective empirical determinations of the star-formation timescales of massive galaxies. Robust measurements of SFH timescales therefore allow us to place strong constraints on the conditions of the early Universe ( 11 , e.g. see ) . Over the past decade, significant effort has been expended into recovering accurate star-formation histories from spectro-photometric fitting of quiescent galaxies at intermediate redshift (using Bagpipes and Prospector , e.g. 21 ; 73 ; 101 ; 48 ; 10 ; 96 , z<2.5 ) , extending to z>3 with even greater accuracy since the launch of JWST ( 19 ; 83 ; 4 ) . Additionally, analyses using large spectroscopic samples of massive quiescent galaxies at z\sim 1 from ground-based observations have allowed statistical constraints on the formation times of massive galaxies from star-formation histories and chemical enrichment ( 20 ; 8 ; 49 ; 22 ; 48 ; 64 ; 84 ; 44 , see e.g.) . However, detecting absorption features — vital for robust metallicity measurements — at z>1 from the ground is difficult, and modeling galaxies with young stellar population ages is equally as hard due to the lack of models. Adding further complexity, as age and metallicity indicators trace the average effective SFH — which includes in-situ and ex-situ star formation — a galaxy’s merger history can make it challenging to interpret formation and quenching timescales. At high redshift, stellar population ages are easier to measure as evolutionary timescales are shorter, and late-stage merger effects (in bringing in ex-situ stars) are minimized, therefore imposing stronger constraints on theoretical models. Extending studies to higher redshifts is therefore crucial to our understanding of galaxy formation histories and evolution. That said, the degeneracy between metallicity, age, and dust poses a significant problem when trying to understand the properties of these galaxies at high redshift. Reliably differentiating between different star-formation histories is difficult, and inferring the incorrect metallicity for stellar populations with varying chemical abundance patterns can strongly affect their inferred formation times; for example, low inferred metallicities result in higher inferred stellar population ages and star-formation efficiencies at early times ( 23 ; 19 ; 31 ; 11 , see e.g.) . This raises significant arguments regarding our understanding of \Lambda -CDM cosmology and baryon physics at early times ( 45 ; 60 ; 61 , see also) . It is therefore crucial to reliably measure the true chemical abundance patterns of massive quiescent galaxies at high redshift. Locally, the most massive galaxies appear to be rich in elements that are produced in core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe, or Type II SNe) explosions. The abundances of these elements relative to iron are vital in aiding our understanding of a galaxy’s formation history, due to the relative timescales on which \alpha -elements and iron-peak elements are produced. For example, O is produced on the order of 10 Myr from the onset of star formation, in contrast to Fe-peak elements from SNe Ia, which are also produced on delayed timescales of 1 Gyr from the onset of star formation ( 114 ; 105 ; 67 , see e.g.) . This trend also appears to hold out to higher redshifts; a small body of literature exists on chemical abundances (from ground-based measurements) for massive quiescent galaxies at z\sim 1-2 , including single object studies or measurements from stacking ( 76 ; 86 ; 69 ; 8 ; 9 , see) . At z\sim 3.5 , massive star-forming galaxies are found to be \alpha -enhanced, with oxygen abundances measured from deep ground-based spectroscopy ( 98 , from NIRVANDELS) yielding \mathrm{[O/Fe]}=0.425\pm 0.026 . This is consistent with values derived for massive quiescent galaxies at z>3 ( 19 , e.g., z\simeq 3.2 ;) , suggesting that quenching may have little impact on chemical abundance ratios. At high redshift, findings suggest that abundance measurements (specifically [Mg/Fe]) are higher for massive quiescent galaxies that formed earlier in time, consistent with the ‘downsizing’ scenario ( 70 ; 58 ; 11 ) . Unfortunately, spectral modeling of galaxies at higher redshifts based on SSP models — particularly those with stellar-population ages <1 Gyr — is extremely difficult; in addition to the chemical abundance features being weaker for these young stellar populations and requiring high SNRs, current versions of stellar population models are tuned towards low-redshift galaxies with stellar population ages of >1 Gyr ( 105 ; 111 ; 28 ) . These models thus do not span the parameter space required for the much younger ( <1 Gyr) quiescent galaxy populations that exist at z>2.5 ( \sim 3 Gyr after the Big Bang). Moreover, current stellar population synthesis models integrated into popular SED fitting codes such as Prospector and Bagpipes (e.g. BPASS, BC03 and FSPS, 99 ; 13 ; 27 , respectively) are based on locally-observed solar abundance ratios, which have been proven to not accurately describe the population of quiescent galaxies ( 105 ; 11 ; 88 ; 59 , even at low redshift, see) . Fortunately, much effort has been exerted into developing \alpha -enhanced models that cover a wider range of stellar-population ages (see e.g. 66 ; 88 ; 16 , for sMILES, \alpha -MC and the single-star \alpha -enhanced BPASS models, respectively) . These models are integrated into codes such as Prospector and alf \alpha to obtain more robust ages and metallicities for young, early quiescent galaxies. Motivated by these recent observational and technical developments, we leverage the statistical capabilities afforded by DeepDive , a JWST Cycle 2 spectroscopic program (ID: 3567, PI: F. Valentino) targeting ten quiescent galaxies to obtain deep, high signal-to-noise, high-quality, medium-resolution spectroscopy between 33 . The structure of this paper is as follows: we discuss the DeepDive observations in Section II and the details of our Bagpipes and alf \alpha fitting in Section III . Our main spectro-photometric fitting results are presented in Section IV and the results obtained from our alf \alpha fitting are presented in IV.2 . We discuss these combined results in Section V and provide comparisons to relevant literature. Finally, we summarize our conclusions in Section VI . Throughout this paper, we quote all magnitudes in AB magnitudes ( 85 ) , and use a 71 initial mass function for all fitting. We assume a \Lambda- CDM cosmology with cosmological parameters of H {}_{0}=70 km s -1 Mpc -1 , \Omega_{m}=0.3 and \Omega_{\Lambda}=0.7 . The 66 SSP models employed in our alf \alpha fitting use the 47 Solar abundance scale of Z_{\odot}=0.0198 . Although this abundance scale is now regarded as obsolete, the isochrones ( 90 ; 91 ) were implemented using this value, and so the SSP models are bound to this value ( 66 ) . For our Bagpipes fitting we assume a the 3 Solar abundance of Z_{\odot}=0.0142 . Table 1: Details of the free parameter ranges and priors adopted for our Bagpipes fitting of the DeepDive photometry and spectroscopy (see Section III ). Priors listed as logarithmic are uniform in log-base-ten of the parameter. Component Parameter Symbol / Unit Range Prior Hyper-parameters Global Redshift z z_{\mathrm{spec}} Gaussian \mu=z_{\mathrm{spec}} , \sigma=0.1 SFH (continuity) Total stellar mass formed M_{\star}/\mathrm{M_{\odot}} (10 6 , 10 13 ) log \cdots Stellar metallicity Z_{\star}/\mathrm{Z_{\odot}} (0.1, 5) log \cdots SFR change ( i\rightarrow i+1 ) i(\log_{10}\mathrm{SFR}) ( -10 , 10) Student- t Default as in 73 Dust Attenuation at 5500 Å A_{V} /mag (0, 4) uniform \cdots Deviation from Calzetti slope \delta ( -0.3 , 0.3) Gaussian \mu=0.0 , \sigma=0.1 2175 Å bump strength B (0, 5) uniform \cdots Calibration Zeroth order P_{0} (0.5, 1.5) Gaussian \mu=1.0 , \sigma=0.25 First order P_{1} ( -0.5 , 0.5) Gaussian \mu=0.0 , \sigma=0.25 Second order P_{2} ( -0.5 , 0.5) Gaussian \mu=0.0 , \sigma=0.25 Third order P_{3} ( -0.5 , 0.5) Gaussian \mu=0.0 , \sigma=0.25 Fourth order P_{4} ( -0.5 , 0.5) Gaussian \mu=0.0 , \sigma=0.25 Noise White-noise scaling a (0.1, 10) log \cdots Correlated noise amplitude b/f_{\mathrm{max}} (0.0001, 1) log \cdots Correlation length l/\Delta\lambda (0.01, 1) log \cdots II The DeepDive Program Data were taken from the JWST Cycle 2 GO Program (ID: 3567, PI: F. Valentino) targeting massive quiescent galaxies at z>3 using the NIRCam and NIRSpec instruments. The main targets for this program are eleven UVJ -selected sources with spectroscopic redshifts determined from previous ground-based observations ( 93 ; 102 ; valentino_2020 ; 40 ) . Due to a guide star failure, one target was not observed and is therefore excluded from our analysis. The DeepDive survey selection, observations and reduction are described in detail in 54 . II.1 Spectroscopic observations Here we briefly summarize the DeepDive spectroscopic observations, whereas we refer the reader to 54 for a complete overview. Of the ten galaxies targeted in DeepDive , two (ID 80 and 111) were observed as part of EXCELS ( 19 , ID: 3543, PIs: Carnall, Cullen,) . Each spectroscopic target received approximately one to three hours of integration time per mask, using the NIRSpec multi-shutter array (MSA) F170LP/G235M medium-resolution grating. Targets are located in the Ultra-Deep Survey (UDS), Cosmological Evolution Survey (COSMOS), Subaru/XMM-Newton Deep Survey (SXDS), XMM-VIDEO and Extended Groth Strip (EGS) fields. All spectra were reduced using MSA Exp ( 12 ; 52 ; 31 ) . For Version 4 of the reduction, see 108 . II.2 Imaging Imaging was taken for five targets without existing JWST observations in four filters (F150W, F200W, F356W and F444W) with the JWST NIRCam instrument. The rest of the targets benefit from existing ancillary HST and JWST imaging from the CEERS, PRIMER and COSMOS-WEB surveys, all of which are publicly available on the DAWN JWST archive ( 109 , DJA, ) . We extract robust photometry for our sources from the imaging using aperpy 1 1 1 https://github.com/astrowhit/aperpy ( 113 ) , following the method described in 113 . We refer the reader to 54 for a detailed description of the photometric extraction and PSF-matched catalogs. Briefly, total fluxes are extracted by flux-correcting photometric measurements made from five circular apertures using a Kron-like ellipse fit to the PSF-matched images. These are then further corrected by adding light in the PSF outside the circularized radius of the ellipse. III Methodology Figure 1: Spectra for the three highest redshift galaxies in the DeepDive sample (the rest of the galaxies are shown in the Appendix). The fiducial Bagpipes model is over-plotted in purple, and the observed photometry along with the model SED is shown in the inset panel. The shaded gray bands correspond to wavelength regions that were masked during fitting owing to strong emission lines or absorption features indicative of out-flowing gas (e.g., Na D). The top panel shows the fit to DD-78, for which we also include an AGN component, which fits a Gaussian to the broad H \alpha emission (see Section III ), while the narrow emission feature is masked due to potential SF contamination. The lower panels show the residuals for each galaxy (where the residuals are \Delta f_{\lambda}/ errors). III.1 Spectro-photometric fitting We use Bagpipes ( 21 ) to simultaneously fit the available photometry and flux-calibrated spectroscopy for our ten main DeepDive galaxies using a similar method to that described in 48 , with some improvements to the star-formation history model. We use the 2016 version of the 13 stellar population models ( 25 , see) and we assume a 71 initial mass function (IMF). Importantly, the BC03 models assume solar abundance ratios based on the 3 values. In later sections, we describe our independent analysis using alf \alpha ( 11 ) to obtain the chemical abundances of our galaxies using \alpha -enhanced simple stellar population models from 66 to infer empirical star-formation timescales from \alpha -element abundances. The stellar metallicity is varied from Z_{*}=0.1-5\ \mathrm{Z}_{\odot} using a logarithmic prior. Solar metallicity is assumed to be Z_{\odot}=0.0142 ( 3 , see) . We use the 92 dust attenuation law, which parametrizes the dust-curve shape through a power-law deviation, \delta , from the 17 law. We use a nebular ionization parameter of \mathrm{log(}U\mathrm{)=-3} , which has been shown to be a suitable value for massive quiescent galaxies. We performed additional tests using a uniform prior on \mathrm{log(}U\mathrm{)} between (-4,-1) and find that our final choice does not impact our results with most galaxies having \mathrm{log}(U)\sim-3 . Additionally, we employ a 4th order spectral calibration polynomial in our fitting to account for issues with flux calibration. However, our results are not dependent on the choice of polynomial order ( 21 , based on fits with a higher order polynomial calibration, see e.g.) . Nebular continuum and emission lines (for H ii regions only, and not including AGN contribution) are modelled using the Cloudy photo-ionization code ( 38 ) , using a method based on that of 15 . The nebular metallicity component and corresponding prior was set to the same range as the stellar metallicity component. Full details of the free parameters and priors used in our fitting are provided in Table 1 . Additionally, as reported in 54 , three galaxies (DD IDs: 78, 170 and 111) appear to possess strong narrow emission in [O III], broad H \alpha emission (DD-78 and DD-111), and broad [He i ] (only object DD-111). During our Bagpipes fitting, we mask the wavelength regions corresponding to these common AGN emission lines for these objects. A significant fraction (7/23, 30%, including secondary targets) of the DeepDive galaxies also show evidence for neutral gas outflows via blue-shifted Na i D absorption (P. Zhu et al. in prep.) Recent studies have examined the origin of these features ( 7 ; 30 ; 35 ; 75 ; 108 , e.g.) in the context of neutral outflows driven by AGN within massive quiescent galaxies; future work will explore this with the DeepDive galaxies presented in this paper (P. Zhu et al., in prep.). Following 58 , and given the ubiquitous presence of neutral sodium outflows in the DeepDive sample, we also mask the neutral sodium absorption feature to avoid complications with metallicity measurements during our fitting. III.1.1 Galaxies with strong AGN emission features A large fraction of the massive quiescent galaxies observed at z>3 show evidence of AGN activity in their spectra ( 100 ; 4 ; 14 , see e.g.) These particular targets can provide important information on the co-evolution of black holes and quiescent galaxies in the early Universe. However, though interesting, the strong emission features that accompany the presence of an AGN make modeling galaxy SFHs and obtaining robust ages, star-formation rates and metallicities difficult. We point out that two galaxies in our sample (DD-78 and DD-111) possess strong, narrow and broad-line AGN emission features and are X-ray detected. We find that these features have a significant effect on our SED modeling; even while masking the regions of strong emission (including wide regions surrounding the features), Bagpipes produces extremely high values for the current star-formation rate for both objects ( >300 M {}_{\mathrm{\odot}}/\mathrm{yr^{-1}} ) – unrealistic for these quiescent galaxies at these early times. For DD-78, we mask the narrow emission lines in the spectrum caused by the AGN (e.g. [O iii ] and [O ii ], narrow H \alpha , [N ii ]) and test the addition of the AGN component. This fits Gaussians to the broadened H \alpha and H \beta lines – as well as a simple power law fit to the continuum – to account for the AGN contribution (as described in 23 ). This results in a SFR for the galaxy that is well within our expected values for quiescent galaxies at z>4 and in good agreement with the SFR derived from photometry only in 54 . We use this additional AGN component in our final fitting for DD-78 only. This highlights the issues of accurately modeling galaxies with strong AGN without a robust AGN model incorporated into our SED fitting methods ( 59 ) . We also opt to remove these two galaxies in our alf \alpha modeling, as these issues may have a strong affect on the robustness of our metallicity measurements. III.1.2 Fiducial SFH: the continuity prior We use a non-parametric (smooth) continuity prior ( 73 ) on the star-formation history which consists of 14 SFR( t ) bins. This SFH is similar to that used in 31 , with a slight modification; we adopt the following for the first five time bins (in look-back time) in order to finely sample the most recent star-formation history for each galaxy: \displaystyle\begin{split}0&1 . The gray contours represent the massive quiescent galaxies from the VANDELS survey at 1t_{\mathrm{Universe}} ). III.2 Priors for other SFH models In Section IV.1.3 , we also show comparisons of our galaxies to three other SFH models commonly employed in the literature – the parametric double-power law ( 21 ; 48 , e.g.) , a flexible continuity SFH with a bursty prior ( 101 , see) to account for more variable star formation at early times, and the non-parametric DenseBasis ( 56 ) star-formation history. During the three other SFH runs, we use the same priors for redshift, dust, calibration and noise models as our fiducial continuity model. For the bursty SFH prior, we implement the model described in 101 by increasing the Student- t SFR prior from \sigma=0.3 to \sigma=1 . This effectively allows for more extreme variation in SFR between neighboring bins compared to our fiducial model. The DenseBasis ( 56 ) SFH model is incorporated into Bagpipes fully and is separate from the FSPS-based SFH model that DenseBasis implements. We use 4 SFR( t ) bins for this SFH model for better comparison with the literature; additionally, in 56 , the authors find that higher numbers of time bins produce weaker constraints on the SFH. Interestingly, when we set the Dirichlet prior to \alpha=3 for all bins, we find that it produces a tail of early SFR (also seen when increasing the number of bins). Setting the Dirichlet parameter to the same value for all bins causes equal amounts of stellar mass to be produced in each of the time bins, possibly contributing to this early tail of SFR in our galaxies. We therefore set the Dirichlet parameter for the SFH model to \alpha=30 for the most recent time bin — in a similar manner as the fine binning we employ for our fiducial model. We find this approach to be suitable in not producing overly sharp star-formation histories ( 51 , see also) , and reducing the amount of stellar mass produced early in time, and bringing the formation times and timescales more in line with the other SFH parameterizations used. Finally, we use a double-power law star-formation history that incorporates two separate power law slopes, where \alpha is the rising slope and \beta is the falling slope, and \tau is the turnover time. Figure 3: The star-formation and cumulative stellar-mass histories for the primary DeepDive targets. Horizontal dashed lines are extrapolated values in order to compare the stellar masses to the SUSPENSE galaxies, shown as the unfilled triangles in the cumulative mass history subplots ( 96 ; 11 , see) . For each column, the blue and red dashed lines correspond to the formation and quenching times obtained from our fiducial Bagpipes run (see Section III for information), respectively. Some galaxies do not have lines corresponding to quenching time, due to the definition of quenched in Bagpipes ; this is explained in further detail in Section IV . The shaded region in each subplot corresponds to the age of the Universe at the observed redshift. IV Results Figure 4: We show a comparison between different star-formation histories with Bagpipes for all of the galaxies in DeepDive (with our fiducial SFH model in black, as in Fig. 3 ). Dashed vertical lines represent t_{\mathrm{form}} values for each of the SFHs and solid lines represent the t_{\mathrm{quench}} value (for galaxies that have quenching times from Bagpipes ). The different SFH parameterizations are mostly in good agreement with each other, with only the DenseBasis ( 56 ) tending to produce earlier formation times for some galaxies than the double-power law, bursty or fiducial SFHs. Figure 5: Example corner plots for two of the galaxies in the DeepDive sample (DD-96 and DD-80), demonstrating the differences between the sample distributions of each star-formation history prescription for stellar mass, metallicity and formation time. We see that there is very good agreement between SFH models for stellar mass; however, formation times for the double-power law, bursty and DenseBasis SFHs are slightly offset to later times than our fiducial SFH model. IV.1 Results from Bagpipes fitting We fit our the combined spectroscopy and photometry for the ten DeepDive galaxies using Bagpipes and obtain measurements for stellar mass, star-formation rate, metallicity and formation ( t_{\mathrm{form}} ) and quenching times ( t_{\mathrm{quench}} ). The best-fitting results are presented in Table 4 . The stellar masses obtained from our Bagpipes fitting are in excellent agreement (consistent with 1 \sigma ) with those reported in 54 from photometric fitting only. In Fig. 1 , we present spectra for three of our DeepDive galaxies, over-plotted with the best-fitting Bagpipes model in pink and common absorption/emission lines. In each panel, the inset figure displays the photometric data points and the best-fitting SED model. The presence of deep, higher-order Balmer absorption lines in our spectra, combined with the shallow Ca K absorption feature (except for those galaxies with evidence of excess absorption from neutral gas), point to the young, post-starburst nature of quiescent galaxies in the early Universe. IV.1.1 Formation and quenching times of massive galaxies In the left-hand panel of Fig. 2 , we show the formation times versus stellar mass for the ten galaxies in our DeepDive sample. The formation time, t_{\mathrm{form}} is defined as the age of the Universe at which fifty percent of the final stellar mass is formed, equivalent to t_{50} in other work ( 101 ) . Over-plotted in Fig. 2 are recent spectroscopic results of massive quiescent galaxies at z>1 ( 69 ; 22 ; 48 ; 2 ; 63 ; 96 ; 83 ; 31 ) . The gray contour shows data from the large, ultra-deep, ground-based spectroscopic program VANDELS ( 48 , for 114 massive quiescent galaxies at 1500\ \mathrm{M_{\odot}}/\mathrm{yr}^{-1} ) before quenching, in line with the idea that these may be possible descendants of extremely dust-obscured star-forming galaxies observed at high redshift ( 110 ) , consistent with number densities of DSFGs at z>4 ( 78 , e.g.) . IV.1.4 Formation and quenching timescales from Bagpipes We report values for ages and star-formation timescales for each of the SFH model parameterizations in Table 3 . Overall, we find good agreement for t_{\mathrm{form}} between SFH models. A significant difference between all SFH prescriptions is the star-formation timescale. We define this as \tau_{SF}=t_{80}-t_{20} , the time it takes to increase the stellar mass from 20% to 80% of the total stellar mass formed. We find that, although the four SFH parameterizations perform well in reproducing similar formation times (see Table 3 ), \tau_{\mathrm{SF}} varies widely; the double-power law SFH has the shortest formation timescales, with a median of \tau=67 Myr, and DenseBasis ( 56 ) produces a longer median timescale of \tau=214 Myr, due to the early peak in star-formation for some of the galaxies. The fiducial SFH model has a median star-formation timescale of \tau=155 Myr, shorter than the DenseBasis SF timescales, but longer than the DPL and bursty SFH models. We additionally consider quenching timescales for all galaxies in the DeepDive sample. The quenching time is defined as the age of the Universe at which the galaxy’s normalized SFR falls below 0.1 derived from Bagpipes . The quenching timescale is therefore the difference between the quenching time and the formation time. We show our derived quenching times and timescales along with the formation times and timescales for our fiducial Bagpipes results in the left and center panels of Fig. 6 . The quenching timescales derived for our sample similarly reflect the diverse formation and quenching pathways – the DeepDive galaxies quenched on timescales of <300 Myr with a median quenching timescale of \simeq 252 Myr for our fiducial run (bursty \simeq 214 Myr, DenseBasis \simeq 270 Myr, double-power law \simeq 278 Myr). The quenching timescales derived for all SFH parameterizations are therefore in good agreement, with the bursty SFH producing somewhat shorter quenching timescales than the rest of the parameterizations. Finally, when considering the correlation between \alpha -enhancement and star-formation timescale, there is a tentative trend towards galaxies with higher [ \alpha /Fe] having shorter star-formation timescales, though we find this is not statistically significant ( p-\mathrm{value}=0.96 ), due to the low numbers and narrow redshift range probed by our sample. Similarly, we find no statistically significant correlation in our sample between [ \alpha /Fe] and quenching timescale ( p-\mathrm{value}=0.56 ). Figure 6: Left and center: Star-formation and quenching timescales versus stellar mass for our DeepDive sample from our fiducial Bagpipes fitting. The star-formation timescale is defined as the time it takes for a galaxy’s stellar mass to rise from 20% to 80%, whereas the quenching timescale is the time between the formation ( t_{\mathrm{form}} ) and quenching ( t_{\mathrm{quench}} ) of a galaxy. t_{\mathrm{quench}} is the time at which the galaxy’s normalized SFR (nSFR) drops below 0.1. The two galaxies DD-78 and DD-111 do not have quenching timescales, most likely due to the effect of the AGN on their SFHs. Right: [ \alpha /Fe] versus formation timescale. No strong correlation is visible between formation timescale and \alpha -enhancement in our DeepDive sample, demonstrating the varied formation and quenching pathways of massive quiescent galaxies at z>3 . Reassuringly, we find that our results for formation and quenching timescales agree well with recent works at similar early times. 4 and 88 show that massive quiescent galaxies at z>2 have both long and short SFHs; galaxies that formed and quenched early and rapidly, those that formed and quenched on more extended timescales, as well as those that formed in very short starbursts ( 19 , as in ) . In our sample, we see evidence of galaxies with extended formation timescales (e.g., DD-170, DD-80) as well as galaxies that formed extremely fast in rapid bursts (e.g., DD-78, DD-115). The observed rapid timescales may indicate quenching via AGN feedback, in line with the duty cycles measured for AGN activity (see Section V.2 ). Table 3: Formation times ( t_{\mathrm{form}} , age of the Universe at which 50% of a galaxy’s stellar mass is formed) and star-formation timescales ( \tau_{SF}=t_{80}-t_{20} , where t_{20} [ t_{80} ] is the age of the Universe at which 20% [80%] of a galaxy’s stellar mass formed) for the different SFH prescriptions used in Bagpipes described in Section IV.1.3 . Uncertainties given are the 16th and 84th percentiles on the posterior. DenseBasis Double-power Law Bursty Fiducial DD-ID t_{\mathrm{form}} /Gyr \tau_{\mathrm{SF}} /Myr t_{\mathrm{form}} /Gyr \tau_{\mathrm{SF}} /Myr t_{\mathrm{form}} /Gyr \tau_{\mathrm{SF}} /Gyr t_{\mathrm{form}} /Gyr \tau_{\mathrm{SF}} /Myr 78 1.27^{+0.03}_{-0.02} 335 {}^{+45}_{-49} 1.33^{+0.01}_{-0.02} 51.3^{+7.0}_{-4.8} 1.42^{+0.01}_{-0.01} 15.4^{+1.4}_{-0.9} 1.41^{+0.01}_{-0.02} 57.2^{+13.1}_{-19.1} 80 1.06^{+0.06}_{-0.08} 225^{+470}_{-55} 1.13^{+0.03}_{-0.03} 85.3^{+54.4}_{-11.6} 1.11^{+0.02}_{-0.02} 113^{+50}_{-33} 1.08^{+0.04}_{-0.04} 200^{+88}_{-61} 96 1.10 {}^{+0.06}_{-0.07} 203^{+17}_{-50} 1.06^{+0.03}_{-0.03} 20.0^{+44.2}_{-6.3} 1.01^{+0.01}_{-0.01} 104^{+13.7}_{-3.7} 1.00^{+0.04}_{-0.07} 168^{+121}_{-55} 106 1.18^{+0.03}_{-0.04} 178^{+35}_{-50} 1.20^{+0.03}_{-0.06} 84.3^{+10.1}_{-6.2} 1.17^{+0.03}_{-0.01} 81.4^{+39.0}_{-5.8} 1.21^{+0.01}_{-0.03} 130^{+8.0}_{-22.0} 111 1.25^{+0.03}_{-0.04} 353^{+58}_{-49} 1.26^{+0.07}_{-0.17} 241^{+326}_{-148} 1.32^{+0.04}_{-0.07} 117^{+87}_{-48} 1.09^{+0.09}_{-0.08} 556^{+251}_{-204} 115 1.42^{+0.02}_{-0.06} 233^{+50}_{-53} 1.47^{+0.00}_{-0.01} 36.2^{+4.8}_{-2.6} 1.46^{+0.01}_{-0.01} 43.9^{+15.3}_{-8.2} 1.46^{+0.01}_{-0.01} 59.3^{+2.8}_{-7.8} 134 1.27^{+0.02}_{-0.02} 153^{+44}_{-50} 1.28^{+0.04}_{-0.04} 25.1^{+24.0}_{-17.1} 1.32^{+0.01}_{-0.02} 64.8^{+36.6}_{-7.8} 1.29^{+0.03}_{-0.02} 118^{+17}_{-52} 170 1.30^{+0.05}_{-0.05} 264^{+46}_{-30} 1.24^{+0.06}_{-0.08} 425^{+110}_{-101} 1.27^{+0.05}_{-0.06} 290^{+90}_{-96} 1.17^{+0.07}_{-0.11} 467^{+186}_{-150} 179 1.37^{+0.03}_{-0.08} 203^{+47}_{-64} 1.34^{+0.07}_{-0.04} 81.7^{+67.3}_{-11.1} 1.35^{+0.01}_{-0.02} 88.6^{+17.2}_{-4.2} 1.36^{+0.04}_{-0.08} 170^{+79}_{-30} 196 1.36^{+0.03}_{-0.03} 204^{+38}_{-66} 1.41^{+0.02}_{-0.02} 17.3^{+23.6}_{-10.0} 1.37^{+0.02}_{-0.01} 88.6^{+32.4}_{-6.2} 1.40^{+0.02}_{-0.03} 140^{+7}_{-34} IV.2 Metallicities of the DeepDive sample In general, studies have shown that massive quiescent galaxies demonstrate evidence for enhanced \alpha -element abundances (e.g, O, Mg, Si, Ca, S, Na, Ti); at higher redshifts, these abundance patterns are tightly correlated with the star-formation history of a galaxy, due to the timescales on which \alpha elements are produced in CCSNe relative to iron or iron-peak elements (from Type Ia SNe), which, in turn, are also dependent on the initial mass function. To obtain independent empirical estimates on the chemical enrichment history, and therefore formation and quenching histories of the DeepDive galaxies, we measure metallicity and \alpha -enhancement using the Pythonic element abundance fitting code, alf \alpha 2 2 2 https://github.com/alizabeverage/alfalpha ( 11 , for more details, see) . This code is based on the fortran Absorption Line Fitter ( 28 , see) with the MILES+IRTF+MIST SSP models, suitable for measuring elemental abundances for older ( >1 Gyr) stellar populations. Importantly, these models also use theoretical response functions to vary individual elemental abundances. Given the young galaxies analyzed in this paper, alf \alpha also has functionality to enable extending the modeling to younger stellar populations with the semi-empirical MILES models ( 66 , sMILES, see) . These models make use of the empirical MILES stellar library to provide spectra with varying \alpha -enhancements over a large range of stellar ages, metallicities and [ \alpha /Fe] computed for five initial mass functions. That said, these models do not include individual theoretical response functions as in the 28 models, so we are only able to measure total [ \alpha /Fe] values rather than the commonly used [Mg/Fe] value. The appeal of using alf \alpha with sMILES lies in the ability to model abundance measurements for SSPs down to 30 Myr, currently unavailable for the 28 models and response functions. However, as alf \alpha only assumes a single burst of star-formation, the stellar population age is also the time at which the burst occurred. Future work implementing improved stellar population models – such as the soon-to-be publicly-available \alpha -MC models ( 89 ) – in SED fitting codes will provide more sophisticated modeling for a range of star-formation histories. This will enable us to finally break the degeneracy between ages, metallicities and star-formation histories when fitting galaxies with non-solar abundance patterns, allowing for more reliable and less biased results from SED fitting. As the sMILES models only return total solar-scaled metallicities ([Z/H]), we first must convert to non-solar abundances (to retrieve [Fe/H]) using Eq. 2 below, (see Eq. 6 in 66 ): \mathrm{[Fe/H]}=[Z/\mathrm{H}]-a[\alpha/\mathrm{Fe}]-b[\alpha/\mathrm{Fe}]^{2}, (2) where the coefficients a=0.66154 and b=0.20465 . The values we obtain for [ \alpha/\mathrm{Fe} ], [Fe/H], age and velocity dispersion ( \sigma/\mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} ) derived from alf \alpha are presented in Table 4 . The sMILES models provide a rest-frame wavelength coverage of 3540.5-7409.6 Å, however, we fit our individual spectra within the region 3700-6400 Å for consistency with 11 . Although the models are computed for five initial mass function types, for consistency with the literature and our Bagpipes results, we default to a universal 71 IMF. Similar to our Bagpipes fitting procedure, we also mask AGN emission lines and the Na I doublet feature at \sim 5895 Å, due to the additional ISM dependence of the latter. Table 4: Derived properties from the alf \alpha (using the sMILES models, see 66 ) fits for the DeepDive galaxies, in order of increasing spectroscopic redshift. Galaxies 78 and 111 are not shown due to significant AGN emission features in their spectra affecting the alf \alpha fitting. The third column displays the ages of each galaxy derived from alf \alpha , not the formation times (age of Universe - age from alf \alpha ). Uncertainties given are the 16th and 84th percentiles on the posterior. DD-ID z_{\mathrm{spec}} Age / Gyr [ \alpha /Fe] [Fe/H] [Z/H] \sigma /km s -1 196 3.4332 0.36^{+0.06}_{-0.05} 0.11_{-0.19}^{+0.23} 0.04_{-0.21}^{+0.25} 0.15_{-0.18}^{+0.08} 273.20_{+23.19}^{+23.79} 179 3.4472 0.49_{-0.05}^{+0.06} 0.11_{-0.13}^{+0.15} 0.05_{-0.13}^{+0.10} 0.15_{-0.13}^{+0.08} 319.67_{-24.90}^{+26.92} 170 3.4894 0.51_{-0.06}^{+0.10} 0.44_{-0.23}^{+0.11} -0.49_{-0.18}^{+0.23} -0.18_{-0.13}^{+0.21} 382.58_{-27.83}^{+28.51} 134 3.7130 0.39_{-0.03}^{+0.03} 0.50_{-0.10}^{+0.07} -0.20_{-0.07}^{+0.08} 0.18_{-0.06}^{+0.06} 271.80_{-15.57}^{+16.43} 115 3.7766 0.15_{-0.01}^{+0.02} 0.04_{-0.10}^{+0.11} 0.10_{-0.09}^{+0.08} 0.13_{-0.08}^{+0.07} 289.53_{-8.79}^{+8.71} 106 3.8307 0.43_{-0.04}^{+0.06} 0.32_{-0.10}^{+0.09} -0.07_{-0.09}^{+0.06} 0.17_{-0.10}^{+0.07} 332.05_{-18.16}^{+18.44} 96 3.8676 0.65_{-0.07}^{+0.06} 0.01_{-0.07}^{+0.07} -0.09_{-0.09}^{+0.11} -0.09_{-0.10}^{+0.14} 359.45_{-15.68}^{+15.66} 80 3.9879 0.44_{-0.02}^{+0.03} 0.42_{-0.05}^{+0.06} -0.10_{-0.07}^{+0.05} 0.22_{-0.05}^{+0.03} 406.46_{-13.65}^{+14.18} Figure 7: [ \alpha /Fe] and [Fe/H] versus stellar mass and formation time for the DeepDive galaxies colored by mass-weighted age from Bagpipes , excluding the two galaxies with strong AGN emission lines (see Section III.1.1 ). The pink star is the median value (of the points) for the DeepDive galaxies. For consistency, the formation time shown is the difference between the age of the Universe at the observed galaxy redshift and the age of the galaxy from alf \alpha . Triangles with the solid outline represent the SUSPENSE [ \alpha /Fe] and [Fe/H] values measured in this work using alf \alpha . We also over-plot the LEGA-C DR3 [ \alpha /Fe] measurements (solid-line gray contour). The [ \alpha /Fe] values for the DeepDive sample shows strong diversity, though in good agreement with lower redshift studies (i.e. with results from the LEGA-C sample at z\sim 0.7 ). We find overall lower [Fe/H] values on average for our sample than z\sim 0.7 and z\sim 0 studies, consistent with 11 . Mass uncertainties are not shown for clarity (see Table 2 ). IV.2.1 \alpha -enhancement in massive galaxies at z>3 In Fig. 7 , we present our [ \alpha /Fe] and [Fe/H] measurements versus stellar mass and formation time ( t_{\mathrm{form}} ) for the DeepDive sample, alongside several literature measurements for massive quiescent galaxies. Our results demonstrate that MQGs at high redshift are \alpha -enhanced, as expected given the shorter formation and quenching timescales at early times. On average, the DeepDive galaxies display a range of [ \alpha /Fe] values (see Table 4 ), with a median [ \alpha /Fe] = 0.22^{+0.22}_{-0.17} . [ \alpha /Fe] values obtained from our fitting are lower than those found in current literature studies using the same approach ( 70 ) and code ( 11 ; 80 , using alf \alpha ,) , with different models. However, we emphasize that we are measuring total \alpha -enhancement rather than the [Mg/Fe] abundance ratio that is commonly quoted. In massive quiescent galaxies at high redshifts, Ca and Si are typically (less than) solar values, meaning that [Mg/Fe] will always be higher than the combined average of all \alpha -elements ( 11 , see e.g.) . We discuss this in more depth in Section V . To provide a self-consistent comparison of the \alpha -enhancements of massive quiescent galaxies, we fit the SUSPENSE spectra (reduced by the SUSPENSE team, 96 ) by applying the same method to the SUSPENSE galaxies with alf \alpha as used for our DeepDive analysis. In the bottom panels of Fig. 7 , we show the [Fe/H] values derived for the DeepDive galaxies, finding mostly sub-solar [Fe/H] values, with a median [Fe/H] = -0.08^{+0.13}_{-0.11} , in agreement with single object determinations at z\simeq 3.2 ( 19 ) and results at 13 are \alpha -enhanced is robust, even though the absolute values may be different due to the choice of models and/or definitions (including the different solar-abundance scales used between different models). We discuss this in more detail in Section V . When considering the DeepDive sample alone, we find no strong statistical evidence for correlations between stellar mass and abundances or formation time. In Fig. 7 , our galaxies appear to populate a narrow stellar-mass range of <1 dex. However, when placed in the context of lower-redshift results, we can see that our DeepDive galaxies are consistent with having higher [ \alpha /Fe] values due to having formed at earlier times than MQGs at lower stellar masses with later formation times. Overall, this suggests evidence for more massive galaxies having higher values for \alpha -enhancement, potentially an effect of downsizing (see 29 ; 39 ; 44 ), implying downsizing may already be in place at these early times. We observe a negative trend with formation time (t f,burst = age of the Universe – age from alf \alpha ), such that galaxies that formed earlier also have higher \alpha -enhancements (when comparing results at all redshifts). Interestingly, this negative trend holds with the formation times obtained from our Bagpipes fitting; galaxies with lower [ \alpha /Fe] formed more slowly, and thus later, in the Universe than those with higher values, due to the long, delayed timescales on which Type Ia SNe enrich the ISM with Fe (see Section V.2 ). These trends are also visible in the SUSPENSE sample; the similarities between the distributions of both datasets are clear and additionally suggest that there is little evolution between z\sim 4 to z\sim 1 . We additionally compare our results to the [ \alpha /Fe] values measured for the LEGA-C DR3 galaxies ( 9 , using the 28 models, ) , shown as the gray contour in Fig. 7 . We find that our DeepDive measurements are in good agreement with the LEGA-C and SUSPENSE galaxies, with strong overlap between all three samples. To quantify the overlapping distributions, we perform a 2-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) test to investigate whether the DeepDive [ \alpha /Fe] values are drawn from the same distributions as LEGA-C and SUSPENSE. We find p-\mathrm{value}=0.69 and p-\mathrm{value}=0.86 for the two-sample KS tests between the LEGA-C and SUSPENSE samples, respectively, allowing us to confirm the null hypothesis that the DeepDive galaxies are drawn from the same distributions as the the 0.63 and in agreement with the values found for the SUSPENSE galaxies from 11 . Although there is large uncertainty on our best-fit relation, this is understandable given the smaller size and narrow stellar-mass range of our sample compared to lower redshift studies. Larger combined archival samples from multiple programs, such as those presented in 54 will allow us to provide improved measurements of the MZR in the future. However, as a whole, our results place important constraints on the mass-metallicity evolution of high-redshift quiescent galaxies. V Discussion In this section, we discuss the results of our Bagpipes and alf \alpha fitting to the DeepDive galaxies. Specifically, we explore timescales and potential quenching mechanisms for the DeepDive sample. We also discuss the caveats associated with the models used in this work. V.1 Star-formation timescales inferred from \alpha -enhancements In the previous section, we showed that the DeepDive sample spans a diverse range of formation and quenching timescales, independent of the SFH parametrization chosen, within 1 \sigma . This therefore has strong implications on the various formation and quenching mechanisms that galaxies at z\sim 3-4 undergo. In addition, the chemical abundance patterns of galaxies at high redshift have strong implications on the evolution of galaxies; \alpha -enhancement correlates with star-formation timescale, allowing us to constrain the onset and cessation of their star formation. In Fig. 7 we present the distribution of our DeepDive sample for [ \alpha /Fe] and [Fe/H] versus stellar mass and formation time (the age of the Universe at the galaxy’s observed spectroscopic redshift minus the burst age obtained from alf \alpha ). Although in general, higher redshift galaxies are more massive and appear to have on average higher [ \alpha /Fe] than lower redshift samples ( 39 ; 44 ) , we find no evidence of this when considering the DeepDive sample alone , most likely due to the narrow range of ages and stellar masses probed by our sample at these high redshifts. However, we do find that the median [Fe/H] for our sample is almost \sim 0.1 dex lower than [Fe/H] from LEGA-C (at z\sim 0.7 ) and \gtrsim 0.2 -dex lower than z\sim 0 results (from SDSS), suggesting there is some evolution in the [Fe/H]. Our results are not inconsistent with results from analyses at lower redshifts; although we find that, overall, the majority of the DeepDive galaxies are \alpha -enhanced (see also Table 4 ), the range of [ \alpha /Fe] values for the sample is large. The large scatter in [ \alpha /Fe] for the DeepDive and SUSPENSE results presented in this paper may be partly explained by the expected spread due to [ \alpha /Fe] being an average over all \alpha elements. 11 demonstrates that not all \alpha elements have the same abundances, possibly contributing to the observed scatter in both the DeepDive and SUSPENSE samples. Moreover, this scatter in [ \alpha /Fe] may be an effect of the varying star-formation histories exhibited by these galaxies. At lower redshifts ( z\sim 1-3 ), massive quiescent galaxies are found to have a range of star-formation and quenching timescales ( 20 ; 48 ; 96 ) , and indeed, the galaxies at z>3 presented in this paper show a range of star-formation timescales and quenching timescales (see Section IV.1.4 and Fig. 6 ). The broad range of [ \alpha /Fe] values found for the DeepDive sample may therefore reflect the multiple formation and quenching mechanisms and timescales apparent at high redshifts. Similarly, the [O/Fe] of simulated massive quenched galaxies spans a range of \sim 0.25 dex ( 34 , e.g. GAEA,) , with a median \mathrm{[O/Fe]}=0.33 . Interestingly, massive quenched galaxies in Magneticum ( 65 ) have lower average \alpha -enhancement with a mean of \mathrm{[O/Fe]}=0.14 . This diversity may suggest either a range of formation and quenching timescales for galaxies at 30.2 , we find that the SF timescales derived from our [ \alpha/ Fe] values are also much shorter than those derived from Bagpipes consistent with findings in 11 . On average, the SF timescale derived for the median [ \alpha /Fe] ( \simeq 0.22 ) is \tau\simeq 750 Myr, longer than the median timescale determined with Bagpipes ( \tau\simeq 170 Myr). However, it is important to note that this is an oversimplified model, and does not reflect the complex star-formation histories and evolutionary pathways (e.g., previous bursts of star-formation) seen at early times. The timescales inferred from our [ \alpha /Fe] measurements are short, and much shorter than the timescales obtained from Bagpipes . Our results suggest that [ \alpha /Fe] alone cannot be used as an indicator of star-formation timescales within massive quiescent galaxies at high redshift; the influence of a variable IMF ( 106 , e.g.) , and merger/accretion events may contribute greatly to the observed trends ( 39 ; 32 ) . Specifically, a variable IMF can change the ratio of CCSNe to SNIa in distant quiescent galaxies which can affect the abundances of \alpha to iron-peak elements produced ( 39 ) . Additionally, the inclusion of different feedback modes in theoretical models is needed to understand in more detail the diversity of physical properties of early massive quiescent galaxies. Future work will explore more complex formation scenarios to understand their detailed chemical evolution. Figure 10: \alpha -enhancement, iron abundance ([Fe/H)] and total metallicity ([Z/H]) versus stellar velocity dispersion determined from alf \alpha . The pink star in each subplot represents the median [ \alpha /Fe], [Fe/H] and [Z/H] of the DeepDive sample, as in Fig. 7 . For comparison, we also show the values we derive for the SUSPENSE galaxies at 13 MQGs ( 34 ) . At z\sim 0.1 , the [ \alpha /Fe] of massive quiescent galaxies is relatively unchanged between different galaxy environments, though environment does affect the stellar mass and total metallicity ( 43 ) . A number of galaxies in the DeepDive sample have been reported to reside in over-dense environments as part of larger galaxy groups. One of the galaxies in our DeepDive sample with low [ \alpha /Fe] (DD-196) resides in the Cosmic Vine , ( 62 ; 55 , see also) , a dense structure at z=3.44 , which may have a potential impact on its formation and quenching mechanisms, though this is hard to quantify without simulations. Another galaxy in our sample (DD-134) is part of the Jekyll and Hyde galaxy pair ( 93 , see) , which has been identified to be in a larger group of MQGs from filler targets of DeepDive (Kakimoto et al., in prep.). By contrast, this galaxy has high [ \alpha /Fe], suggesting that the effects of large-scale environment on galaxy chemical enrichment and star-formation histories are complicated and require further observational and theoretical analysis. V.4 Modeling challenges & caveats In this work, we have obtained star-formation histories, stellar masses, ages, metallicities from sophisticated spectro-photometric fitting using SED code Bagpipes as well as [ \alpha /Fe] and [Fe/H] abundances from chemical abundance modeling using alf \alpha . We find that galaxies at high-redshift formed early and fast, and demonstrate evidence for \alpha -enhancement. Our galaxies display strong scatter in total metallicity and [ \alpha /Fe] abundances, possibly explained by quenching processes that generate strong outflows causing efficient gas removal at early times. Although our results are in good agreement with expected trends for massive quiescent galaxies at z>3 – and with those from lower-redshift studies – it is important to acknowledge that the stellar population models currently being used to describe the early quiescent galaxy population are a significant bottle-neck to our understanding of massive galaxy evolution; most do not cover the young stellar population ages required at these early time, and do not account for their varying star-formation histories. As discussed, it is difficult to compare and draw robust conclusions between individual galaxy abundance measurements due to the methodological and model differences across studies, although qualitatively, results are in agreement. Our [ \alpha /Fe] values should trace [Mg/Fe] ( 66 , see) , and broadly, our values for [ \alpha /Fe] in SUSPENSE and [Mg/Fe] ( 11 ) appear to be in good agreement, though with large uncertainties on both measurements. Considering that both measurements are derived using different sets of models which employ different isochrones, stellar spectra, solar abundance references ( 66 , see Table 2 in ) and the 28 models incorporating individual element response functions (so each element abundance is allowed to vary freely, unlike 66 models where all \alpha elements are tied to [Mg/Fe]), these results are reassuring and suggest that our higher redshift results are robust against our model uncertainties. Previous versions of \alpha -enhanced models demonstrate large differences between [Mg/Fe], [ \alpha /Fe] and [Fe/H] values across models; 57 find \sim 0.3 dex between [ \alpha /Fe] from 111 and [Mg/Fe] from 28 , with the same difference in [Fe/H] between both models. In this paper, we find that although there are large uncertainties on individual galaxy values, our derived [ \alpha /Fe] values for the SUSPENSE galaxies follow the [Mg/Fe] values derived by 11 . More recently, \alpha -enhanced stellar population synthesis models such as \alpha -MC based on the \alpha -enhanced MIST isochrones and C3K spectral libraries have been developed for smooth integration into FSPS for use in SED codes such as Prospector and Bagpipes . These models will have substantial impacts on SED fitting of young, high-redshift quiescent galaxies, allowing us to derive more robust stellar masses, ages and star-formation histories as well as more accurate chemical abundances. Future work employing these different sets of models on the DeepDive galaxies will also highlight the model dependencies on chemical abundance and timescale measurements. VI Summary In this work, we use deep, medium-resolution spectroscopy from the JWST Cycle 2 DeepDive program to investigate the star-formation histories of ten massive quiescent galaxies at 3200 Myr) and short ( <100 Myr) timescales, consistent with recent literature results for massive quiescent galaxies at 24 Gyr) at these early times. This may point to an earlier onset of Type Ia SNe enrichment (earlier DTD), or metals preferentially removed early in outflows from strong winds driven by Type II SNe or AGN. Future work accounting for these scenarios will shed light on the distribution of [ \alpha /Fe] values at z>3 . In this paper, we find that although we have shown that massive galaxies at high redshift are \alpha -enhanced, alone, [ \alpha /Fe] obtained from SSP models traces the formation timescales weakly at these early times. Future work must combine individual element abundance measurements with star-formation histories using \alpha -enhanced stellar population models integrated into SED fitting codes. In addition to \alpha -enhancement, the physics of later stellar evolutionary stages (a.g. from AGB stars) must be better incorporated into our models as we obtain better data from JWST probing longer wavelengths ( >7500 Å) previously unavailable with HST and ground-based studies ( 77 , see e.g.,) , as these can have significant impact on the initial mass function of massive galaxies at high redshift. Similarly, the contribution of AGN contamination in most high-redshift massive quiescent galaxies detected so far calls for better integration of AGN models in SED fitting codes. Overall the DeepDive galaxies represent a unique sample to study an important time in cosmic evolutionary history. Expanding this dataset with the addition of lower and higher redshift quiescent samples (as done with the SUSPENSE galaxies in this work) will allow us to trace the evolution of \alpha -enhancement, total stellar metallicities and star-formation histories over a wide range of cosmic time. Access to models with younger stellar populations such as those used in this paper ( 66 ) , and those which will be used in future work ( 89 , e.g. \alpha -MC in FSPS,) , which can accurately model the diversity in metallicities, ages, and star-formation histories of massive quiescent galaxies at earlier times. This has afforded us the capability to explore parameter spaces previously unavailable with solar-scaled models in SED fitting codes. MLH would like to thank a number of colleagues for insightful discussions that helped improve the quality of this paper: L. Barrufet, S. Berek, R. Cochrane, K. Iyer, S. Manning, M. de los Reyes and T. M. Stanton. This work is based in part on observations made with the NASA/ESA/CSA James Webb Space Telescope and the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope obtained from the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under NASA contract NAS 5–26555. The data were obtained from the Mikulski Archive for Space Telescopes at the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under NASA contract NAS 5-03127 for JWST. KEW and MLH gratefully acknowledge financial support for program JWST-GO-03567, provided by NASA through grants from the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Associations of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Incorporated, under NASA contract NAS 5-03127. Some of the data products presented herein were retrieved from the Dawn JWST Archive (DJA). DJA is an initiative of the Cosmic Dawn Center, which is funded by the Danish National Research Foundation under grant No. 140. The Dunlap Institute is funded through an endowment established by the David Dunlap family and the University of Toronto. TK acknowledges support from JSPS grant 25KJ1331. FV, KI, and PZ acknowledge support from the Independent Research Fund Denmark (DFF) under grant 3120-00043B. The Cosmic Dawn Center (DAWN) is funded by the Danish National Research Foundation under grant DNRF140. WMB gratefully acknowledges support from DARK via the DARK fellowship. This work was supported by a research grant (VIL54489) from VILLUM FONDEN. JRW acknowledges that support for this work was provided by The Brinson Foundation through a Brinson Prize Fellowship grant. Figure 11: The same as Fig. 1 for the rest of the galaxies in our main DeepDive sample.