The Role of Ab Initio Beta-Decay Calculations in Light Nuclei for Probes of Physics Beyond the Standard Model Journal: Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics Grigor H. Sargsyan, Garrett B. King, Ayala Glick-Magid, Chien-Yeah Seng Abstract Precision beta decay experiments serve as powerful probes of physics beyond the Standard Model, enabling stringent tests of fundamental symmetries of nature. In particular, these experiments primarily focus on precise determinations of the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix element V u ​ d V_{ud} and the search for exotic weak currents, both of which depend critically on theoretical calculations of radiative, recoil-order, and isospin-breaking corrections with quantified uncertainties. In recent years, ab initio nuclear many-body methods—grounded in realistic nucleon-nucleon interactions and systematically improvable approximations—have advanced considerably in their ability to compute these higher-order corrections for various nuclei. This review provides a comprehensive overview of state-of-the-art ab initio calculations of beta-decay corrections, encompassing both radiative corrections and recoil-order terms, and examines their significance for precision tests of the Standard Model. We discuss the theoretical formalisms employed, including the integration of effective field theory frameworks with many-body approaches. Particular attention is given to recent results for superallowed Fermi decays (e.g., 10 C → \rightarrow 10 B and 14 O → \rightarrow 14 C) and allowed Gamow-Teller transitions (e.g., 6 He → \rightarrow 6 Li, 8 Li → \rightarrow 8 Be, 8 B → \rightarrow 8 Be), where ab initio calculations have achieved unprecedented precision. We also highlight emerging calculations for unique forbidden decays, which offer complementary sensitivity to BSM physics. Finally, we outline future directions aimed at extending the reach of ab initio calculations to heavier nuclei and additional decay modes, thereby strengthening the synergy between theory and experiment in the ongoing search for new physics. 1  Introduction The search for beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics is one of the most pressing open questions in modern particle physics. This area of research is vital for our understanding of the universe, from the origin of matter and the universe’s matter-antimatter asymmetry to the properties of dark matter and the behavior of fundamental forces at high energies. Searches of BSM physics have been central topics for some of the largest high-energy particle accelerators in the world, such as the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). On the other hand, low-energy nuclear beta decays have emerged as a powerful and complementary probe of BSM physics that can rival the sensitivity of large-scale particle accelerator experiments. The precise measurements of beta decay spectra and transition rates, often obtained with high accuracy in experiments involving radioactive nuclei, have already produced some of the most stringent constraints on BSM physics, and hold promise for further advances in our understanding of the universe’s fundamental laws. Within the broader landscape of precision physics programs [ 43 , 137 , 180 , 63 , 18 ] , the study of beta decay processes stands out as a particularly vibrant and significant area. In the Standard Model (SM), these decays are fundamentally driven by the exchange of a W boson, connecting light quark and lepton currents. Crucially, the strength of the interaction between the W boson and quarks within the SM is governed by the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix [ 23 , 111 ] . Consequently, beta decays offer a unique opportunity to precisely extract V_{ud} , the upper left element of this fundamental matrix. Indeed, this method currently represents the most precise means of determining V_{ud} , by a substantial margin [ 83 ] . Deviations from the unitarity of the CKM matrix would indicate the existence of BSM physics, and a renewed interest in this topic has followed the recent suggestion of a CKM unitarity violation at \sim 3\sigma [ 34 ] , which favors non-zero right-handed quark couplings (see, e.g. [ 38 ] and references therein). Furthermore, searches for BSM physics in beta decay test the left-handed vector minus axial-vector ( V-A ) structure of the weak interaction by looking for minuscule admixtures of non-SM currents. In an effective low-energy description, possible contributions from right-handed vector, scalar, and tensor currents–potentially arising from new heavy mediators–would modify decay observables relative to SM expectations. Precision measurements of beta-decay correlation coefficients (for example, electron–antineutrino correlations and angular/momentum correlations) and the beta-spectrum shape provide sensitivity to these exotic couplings [ 180 , 63 , 162 , 79 ] . Together with radiative and recoil-order corrections, the results place stringent constraints on new physics scenarios such as exotic scalar or tensor interactions. The extraction of fundamental parameters from precision beta-decay data depends on theoretical inputs for radiative corrections, isospin-breaking effects, and recoil-order terms. Given the precision that current measurements achieve, it is vital to have an accurate description of these higher-order corrections with quantified uncertainties to be able to distinguish between new physics and conventional nuclear physics effects. Nuclear ab initio methods–based on realistic nucleon-nucleon interactions–have made substantial progress in computing corrections to the beta decay for an expanding set of nuclei [ 74 , 153 , 108 , 124 , 72 , 36 , 35 , 109 ] . Ab initio models are able to provide first-principles descriptions of nuclei and beta decay corrections with quantified uncertainties. The calculations from ab initio methods are systematically improvable as the nucleon-nucleon interactions and many-body truncations are refined [ 93 , 55 ] . These advances strengthen the reliability of beta-decay observables used to test the SM and constrain BSM physics. This review gives an overview of recent ab initio calculations of beta decay radiative and recoil-order corrections and discusses their significance to the precision measurements that probe physics beyond the Standard Model. In the following sections, we detail the many-body methods that have been employed to perform ab initio calculations of these corrections and briefly discuss their application span for future studies. Moreover, we outline the formalism essential for deriving radiative corrections necessary for the precise extraction of the V_{ud} matrix element of the CKM matrix, highlighting some of the most recent results. Furthermore, we examine advancements in computing nuclear recoil-order corrections to beta decays that need to be accounted for in high-precision experiments that probe BSM physics. We conclude with a summary and an outlook to future studies hence aiming to illuminate the path toward more accurate tests of fundamental theories. 2  Many-body methods The landscape of ab initio nuclear theory [ 93 ] , which has increasingly come to define many-body calculations that describe nuclei at the finest resolution scale possible and are systematically improvable [ 55 ] , has grown steadily over the last decade. While the fundamental theory of the strong interaction is QCD, and there has been progress in describing nuclei with lattice approaches [ 11 ] , the finest degrees of freedom to describe most few-body nuclei are protons and neutrons (collectively, nucleons). While there are a number of ab initio approaches in the literature, we will limit the scope of this section to methods based on the no-core configuration interaction (NCCI) and quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) approaches as they are the ones relevant for our subsequent discussion. Generically, one would like to solve the A -body Schrödinger equation with a nuclear Hamiltonian that can be schematically represented as, H=\sum_{i}T_{i}+V_{\mathrm{Coul}}+\sum_{i\mathbf{\sigma}^{(k)}\cdot\mathbf{P}_{j}+(j\leftrightarrow k)\right]~. For future purpose, we can split the “recoil” potential into two pieces: \mathcal{V}_{0}^{\text{rec}}=\mathcal{V}_{0}^{\text{rec,1}}+\mathcal{V}_{0}^{\text{rec,2}} (3.23) which are linear and quadratic to g_{A} , respectively. There are also \mathcal{O}(\alpha^{2}) terms in the potential which we do not display here. Renormalization analysis shows that the nuclear matrix element of \mathcal{V}_{0}^{\text{mag}} depends logarithmically on the ultraviolet (UV) cutoff. This signals sensitivity to the UV physics which must be absorbed by an extra “counterterm” potential coming from Fig. 3.2 (d1): \mathcal{V}_{0}^{\text{CT}}=e^{2}(g_{V1}^{NN}O_{1}+g_{V2}^{NN}O_{2})~, (3.24) where O_{1}=\sum_{j\neq k}\tau^{+(j)}\mathbbm{1}^{(k)}~,~O_{2}=\sum_{j}~, (3.29) where the superscripts “<” and “>” denote the contribution from the loop integral below and above Q^{2}=2 GeV 2 . For Q^{2}>2 GeV 2 , the integral is related to a sum rule of the parity-odd structure function F_{3} , similar to the well-know Gross-Llewellyn Smith (GLS) sum rule [ 82 ] ; the latter is experimentally demonstrated to hold even for heavy nuclei [ 122 , 105 ] after including higher-order perturbative QCD effects, so one may assume that this part is not modified. Meanwhile, the nuclear modification to (\Box_{n}^{\text{inel}})^{<} can be inferred from the experimental knowledge of the ratio R between the nucleon and nuclear structure function F_{2} . Depending on the value of the Bjorken variable x_{\text{B}} , R may deviate positively or negatively from 1 due to different physical mechanisms, such as nuclear shadowing, anti-shadowing, EMC effect and Fermi motion. For A\approx 10 , the maximum deviation of R from 1 is about 20% [ 112 ] . So, one may simply multiply (\Box_{n}^{\text{inel}})^{<} by 20%, and take it as a conservative estimation of the absolute size of \delta(\Box_{n}^{\text{inel}})_{\text{shad}} which will be included as an error. The full result of \delta_{\text{NS}} for 10 C \rightarrow{}^{10} B obtained in Ref. [ 72 ] reads 3 3 3 We do not include the uncertainty due to the subtraction of the single-nucleon box diagram which was displayed in Fig. 3.4 , because it goes away upon combining \delta_{\text{NS}} and \Delta_{R}^{V} . : \delta_{\text{NS}}=-0.422(14)_{\text{PME}}(4)_{\Omega}(9)_{\chi}(24)_{\text{sh}}\%~, (3.30) where the sources of (nucleus-dependent) theoretical errors are: (i) PME: The “partial model error”, due to many-body basis truncation, multipole expansion truncation, and single-nucleon dipole form factors; (ii) \Omega : The choice of oscillator frequency; (iii) \chi : The chiral expansion truncation; and (iv) sh: The nuclear shadowing effect. It is informative to track the “evolution” of this number over time: \displaystyle\delta_{\text{NS}}(\%) \displaystyle: \displaystyle-0.345(35)~~,~~\text{Shell model} (3.31) \displaystyle\rightarrow \displaystyle-0.400(50)~~,~~\text{DR + Fermi gas model} \displaystyle\rightarrow \displaystyle-0.422(29)~~,~~\text{{Ab initio} NCSM} The first calculation with shell model was based on the type-A/type-B picture. This was later discovered in the dispersive analysis to contain a large theory systematic, which was estimated using a crude Fermi gas model [ 157 , 81 ] ; this resulted in a shift to \delta_{\text{NS}} to the more negative side, accompanied by an inflated theory uncertainty. This result is then confirmed by the ab initio calculation in Ref. [ 72 ] but with a substantially reduced uncertainty. 3.4 {}^{10}\text{C}\rightarrow{}^{10}\text{B} and {}^{14}\text{O}\rightarrow{}^{14}\text{N} with Quantum Monte Carlo Figure 3.5: Nuclear matrix element densities of various potentials contributing to \overline{\delta_{\rm NS}} in 14 O \rightarrow{}^{14} N computed with VMC plotted as a function of interparticle spacing r . The integrated curves correspond to the matrix elements in the legend of the plot. Model Method \delta_{\rm NS}^{(0)} \overline{\delta_{\rm NS}^{E}} NV2+3-Ia VMC -\left(4.03+0.25\pm 0.69\right)\cdot 10^{-3} 1.01\cdot 10^{-3} GFMC -\left(4.43+0.21\pm 0.77\right)\cdot 10^{-3} 0.97\cdot 10^{-3} NV2+3-Ia * VMC -\left(4.18+0.31\pm 0.62\right)\cdot 10^{-3} 1.06\cdot 10^{-3} GFMC -\left(4.25+0.31\pm 0.66\right)\cdot 10^{-3} 1.08\cdot 10^{-3} AV18+UX VMC -\left(4.48+0.27\pm 0.67\right)\cdot 10^{-3} 1.02\cdot 10^{-3} GFMC -\left(4.06+0.40\pm 0.48\right)\cdot 10^{-3} 1.17\cdot 10^{-3} AV18+IL7 VMC -\left(4.55+0.26\pm 0.61\right)\cdot 10^{-3} 1.01\cdot 10^{-3} GFMC -\left(4.32+0.29\pm 0.64\right)\cdot 10^{-3} 1.06\cdot 10^{-3} Table 3.1: Summary of the results for \bar{\delta}_{\rm NS} . For the energy-independent component, \delta_{\rm NS}^{(0)} , the first term encodes the contribution of the magnetic and spin-orbit two-body operators. The second term is the \mathcal{O}(\alpha^{2}) correction arising from M_{\text{F},p}^{+} . The last contribution arises from the contact interactions, with LECs set to the arbitrary values g_{V1}^{NN}\pm g^{NN}_{V2}=\pm\frac{1}{m_{N}}\frac{1}{(2F_{\pi})^{2}} . The last column shows the energy dependent part, \overline{\delta_{\rm NS}^{\rm E}} . Next, we report the pioneering studies of \delta_{\text{NS}} based on the EFT approach, by computing the matrix elements for the potentials defined in Section 3.2.2 with many-body methods. Recently, such evaluations have been performed using quantum Monte Carlo methods; namely, VMC and GFMC for 10 C [ 109 ] , and VMC and AFDMC for 14 O [ 35 ] . As an example, the VMC calculation of the nuclear matrix elements of various potentials is shown in Fig. 3.5 . To make connections with experimental data, for \beta^{+} decay, one combines the matrix elements of the potentials to give both the energy-independent part (see Eq.( 3.21 ), including the \mathcal{O}(\alpha^{2}) contribution not displayed), \delta^{(0)}_{\rm NS}=\frac{2}{g_{V}(\mu_{\pi})M_{F}^{(0)}}\sum_{N=n,p}\left[\alpha\left(M_{{\rm GT},N}^{\rm mag}+M_{{\rm T},N}^{\rm mag}+M_{{\rm GT},N}^{\rm CT}+M_{{\rm LS},N}\right)+\alpha^{2}M^{+}_{{\rm F},N}\right]\,, (3.32) and the energy-dependent part (see Eq.( 3.16 )), \overline{\delta^{E}_{\rm NS}}=-\frac{2}{g_{V}(\mu_{\pi})M_{F}^{(0)}}\left[M^{0}_{E}E_{0}+\frac{m_{e}^{2}}{E_{e}}M_{m_{e}}\right]\,, (3.33) where the vector coupling constant g_{V} is evaluated at a scale \mu_{\pi}=m_{\pi} giving g_{V}(m_{\pi})=1.01494(12) [ 39 ] , and the electron energy E_{e} is averaged over phase-space. The matrix element M^{X}_{i,N} denotes M^{X}_{i,N}=\matrixelement{f}{V^X_{i,N}}{i}\, (3.34) for a given potential V^{X}_{i,N} defined in Ref. [ 35 ] . These potentials are obtained by Fourier-transforming the momentum-space potentials \mathcal{V}(\mathbf{q},\mathbf{P}) in Section 3.2.2 into coordinate space, and scaling out appropriate powers of \alpha . The nuclear initial and final states are denoted as \ket{i} and \ket{f} , respectively. The values of these contributions sum to give the overall correction, \overline{\delta_{\rm NS}}=\delta_{\text{NS}}^{(0)}+\overline{\delta_{\text{NS}}^{E}}~. (3.35) For {}^{10}\text{C} , the GFMC results were obtained for four different models of the nuclear interaction. Namely, two phenomenological models– the Argonne v_{18} [ 188 ] plus either the Illinois-7 (IL7) [ 145 ] or Urbana X (UX) [ 185 ] three nucleon forces– and two Norfolk chiral potential models [ 144 , 143 , 8 ] . Norfolk potential models are denoted as NV2+3-Ia and NV2+3-Ia* in the literature. The main results are summarized for VMC and GFMC calculations in 10 C in Table 3.1 . For VMC calculations of 14 O using the interaction of Refs. [ 73 , 125 ] , the results are 4 4 4 Results for \delta_{\text{NS}}^{(0)} and V_{ud} were corrected for the re-evaluation of \mathcal{V}^{\text{rec}}_{0} matrix element. Private communication with Emanauele Mereghetti and Wouter Dekens. : \delta_{\text{NS}}^{(0)}=-2.84(88)\cdot 10^{-3}~~,~~\overline{\delta_{\text{NS}}^{E}}=2.06(41)\cdot 10^{-3}~. (3.36) The comparison with traditional approach (i.e. Ref. [ 87 ] ) is most conveniently done in terms of the full V_{ud} [ 86 ] . The GFMC values of |V_{ud}(^{10}C)| are compared with the traditional extraction below, NV2+3-Ia \displaystyle\left.V_{ud}\right|_{{}^{10}\rm C} \displaystyle=0.97355(66)_{\rm exp}(12)_{g_{V}}(17)_{\mu}(9)_{\delta_{C}}(38)_{g_{V}^{\rm NN}}, (3.37) NV2+3-Ia* \displaystyle\left.V_{ud}\right|_{{}^{10}\rm C} \displaystyle=0.97345(66)_{\rm exp}(12)_{g_{V}}(17)_{\mu}(9)_{\delta_{C}}(32)_{g_{V}^{\rm NN}}, (3.38) AV18+UX \displaystyle\left.V_{ud}\right|_{{}^{10}\rm C} \displaystyle=0.97336(66)_{\rm exp}(12)_{g_{V}}(17)_{\mu}(9)_{\delta_{C}}(23)_{g_{V}^{\rm NN}}, (3.39) AV18+IL7 \displaystyle\left.V_{ud}\right|_{{}^{10}\rm C} \displaystyle=0.97349(66)_{\rm exp}(12)_{g_{V}}(17)_{\mu}(9)_{\delta_{C}}(31)_{g_{V}^{\rm NN}}, (3.40) Traditional \displaystyle\left.V_{ud}\right|_{{}^{10}\rm C} \displaystyle=0.97318(66)_{\rm exp}(9)_{\Delta_{R}^{V}}(24)_{\delta_{\rm NS}}(9)_{\delta_{C}}\,. (3.41) For 14 O, the comparison gives, EFT \displaystyle\left.V_{ud}\right|_{{}^{14}\rm O} \displaystyle=0.97411(10)_{\rm exp}(12)_{g_{V}}(22)_{\mu}(12)_{\delta_{C}}(43)_{g_{V}^{\rm NN}}(20)_{\delta_{\text{NS}}^{E}}, (3.42) Traditional \displaystyle\left.V_{ud}\right|_{{}^{14}\rm O} \displaystyle=0.97405(13)_{\rm exp}(9)_{\Delta_{R}^{V}}(31)_{\delta_{\rm NS}}(12)_{\delta_{C}}\,. (3.43) The main theoretical uncertainty in the EFT approach is due to two undetermined LECs, namely, g_{V1}^{NN} and g_{V2}^{NN} . The magnitudes of these two LECs can only be estimated using chiral power counting. Reducing this uncertainty in the future may involve lattice calculations of two-nucleon matrix elements, which can be quite challenging in practice. An alternative approach suggested in Ref. [ 35 ] is to take these LECs as free fitting parameters, and perform a global fit, together with V_{ud} to different superallowed transition rates. In this review we point out the possibility to pin down the LECs through the matching procedure outlined in Section 2 . Other uncertainties include variations in the matching scales of the EFT ( \mu ), the value of the coupling g_{V}(\mu) at the matching scales, the uncertainty in the isospin breaking corrections taken from [ 86 ] ( \delta_{C} ), and missing higher order energy-dependent terms in the chiral expansion denoted by \delta^{E}_{\rm NS} . In comparison, the traditional extraction has uncertainties from its approach to computing \delta_{\rm NS} , as well as for the transition independent radiative corrections \Delta_{R}^{V} ; the latter is included in g_{V}(\mu) in the EFT approach. 4  Recoil-order corrections to allowed beta decays In-depth investigations of angular correlations in nuclear \beta decay have historically been instrumental in uncovering the “vector-minus-axial vector” (V - A) nature of the charged current in the electroweak interaction [ 120 , 98 ] . Presently, research in nuclear \beta decay continues to be at the forefront of probing for potential deviations from the Standard Model, particularly in the search for additional scalar (S) and tensor (T) Lorentz-invariant interactions that can naturally emerge in extensions beyond the Standard Model. Precise measurements of the \beta – \nu angular correlation, the \beta asymmetry, and the Fierz interference term serve as critical tests constraining possible new physics. Ongoing and upcoming experiments aim to enhance the precision of these measurements further [ 79 , 18 ] . Recoil-order terms are generally omitted in \beta -decay theory because they are proportional to q/m_{N} or higher, where q represents the momentum transfer–typically a few MeV/c–and m_{N} is the nucleon mass [ 94 ] . Consequently, in most \beta decays, recoil effects contribute less than one percent of the dominant Fermi and Gamow-Teller (GT) amplitudes. Nonetheless, when measurements reach very high precision, these recoil-order terms become significant and must be incorporated into the analyses of the experiments, particularly in cases where the primary contributions are suppressed or the recoil effects are unexpectedly large. The study of recoil-order corrections in allowed \beta decays provides a sensitive theoretical handle on sub-percent effects that can obscure or imitate signatures of BSM interactions. These corrections arise from higher-order terms in the nuclear weak current–such as weak magnetism, induced tensor, and higher-multipole axial components–which modify the \beta spectrum shape and angular correlations at the 10^{-3} level. Quantifying these effects within ab initio many-body approaches is therefore essential to distinguish genuine BSM contributions from Standard-Model nuclear structure effects. In this section, we review three complementary calculations that address this challenge: (i) the 6 He \!\to\!^{6} Li decay computed with the NCSM, providing the first consistent evaluation of recoil and shape corrections with quantified uncertainties; (ii) the same transition studied using GFMC, incorporating explicit two-body weak currents and full spectral reconstruction; and (iii) the 8 Li and 8 B \beta decays analyzed with the SA-NCSM, where correlations between recoil-order form factors and nuclear deformation help reduce uncertainties on the ab initio predictions. 4.1 6 He \to^{6} Li beta decay corrections with NCSM The \beta -decay of 6 He offers a particularly clean probe of BSM tensor currents thanks to its pure GT character, and its light nuclear mass which makes it computationally tractable within ab initio many-body frameworks, allowing high-precision theoretical predictions. Several experimental programs are currently pursuing precision studies of this decay. At the Laboratoire de Physique Corpusculaire de CAEN [ 41 ] , and the University of Washington CENPA through the He6-CRES Collaboration [ 4 ] , efforts focus on measuring the \beta -electron energy spectrum, while at SARAF, SNRC [ 140 ] the emphasis is on the angular correlation between the emitted \beta particle and neutrino. As these measurements strive for per-mil level accuracy, precise Standard Model calculations are essential to fully exploit their potential for constraining new physics. For a pure GT transition, the differential decay rate can be written as d\Gamma\propto 1+a\vec{\beta}\cdot\hat{\nu}+b\frac{m_{e}}{E_{e}} , where \vec{\beta}=\frac{\vec{k}}{E_{e}} is the emitted electron direction, \vec{k}_{e} , E_{e} and m_{e} are its momentum, energy, and mass, respectively, \hat{\nu} is the unit vector in the direction of the neutrino momentum \vec{\nu} . The coefficients a and b encode the leading angular correlation and spectral observables and are particularly sensitive to BSM tensor interactions. Specifically, the \beta – \nu angular-correlation coefficient a is quadratically sensitive to the tensor coupling \epsilon_{T} , while the Fierz interference term b depends linearly on \epsilon_{T} [ 96 , 63 ] . In the Standard Model limit, one has a=-1/3 and b=0 , and current experiments aim to detect per-mil-level deviations from these values as possible signatures of BSM physics. However, at the same level of experimental precision, nuclear-structure small effects become relevant. Recoil and shape corrections arise at next-to-leading order (NLO) in several small expansion parameters, namely the non-relativistic p_{\mathrm{F}}/m_{N}\approx 0.2 ( P_{\mathrm{Fermi}} is Fermi momentum and m_{N} is the nucleon mass), the momentum transfer qr\approx 0.05 ( \vec{q}=\vec{\nu}+\vec{k}_{e} and r is the nuclear radius), and the nucleon recoil q/m_{N}\approx 0.004 . These Standard-Model corrections modify the effective values of a and b and, if not properly accounted for, can mimic the effects of BSM tensor couplings. Following Ref. [ 76 ] , the fully differential decay rate including these recoil and shape corrections can be written as, \frac{d\Gamma}{dE_{e}d\Omega_{e}d\Omega_{\nu}}\propto\left(E_{0}-E_{e}\right)^{2}k_{e}E_{e}F^{-}\!\left(Z_{f},E_{e}\right)C_{\text{corr}}3\left(1+\delta_{1}\right)\left[1-\frac{1}{3}\left(1+\tilde{\delta}_{a}\right)\vec{\beta}\cdot\hat{\nu}+\delta_{b}\frac{m_{e}}{E_{e}}\right]\left\lvert\braket{\|\hat{L}_{1}^{A}\|}\right\rvert^{2}, (4.1) where E_{0} is the maximum electron energy, F^{-}(Z_{f},E_{e}) is the Fermi function accounting for Coulomb distortion of the electron wave function, and C_{\text{corr}} represents other corrections which do not affect the observables. Lastly, \braket{\|\hat{L}_{1}^{A}\|} corresponds to the reduced matrix element of the leading GT multipole operator between the initial and final wave functions, while \delta_{1} , \tilde{\delta}_{a} , and \delta_{b} parameterize recoil and shape corrections arising from subleading multipole contributions. These corrections depend on reduced matrix elements of rank-1 multipole operators of the weak current and can be expressed as \begin{split}\delta_{1}&\equiv\frac{2}{3}\mathfrak{Re}\left[-E_{0}\frac{\braket{\|\hat{C}_{1}^{A}/q\|}}{\braket{\|\hat{L}_{1}^{A}\|}}+\sqrt{2}\left(E_{0}-2E_{e}\right)\frac{\braket{\|\hat{M}_{1}^{V}/q\|}}{\braket{\|\hat{L}_{1}^{A}\|}}\right],\\ \tilde{\delta}_{a}&\equiv\frac{4}{3}\mathfrak{Re}\left[2E_{0}\frac{\braket{\|\hat{C}_{1}^{A}/q\|}}{\braket{\|\hat{L}_{1}^{A}\|}}+\sqrt{2}\left(E_{0}-2E_{e}\right)\frac{\braket{\|\hat{M}_{1}^{V}/q\|}}{\braket{\|\hat{L}_{1}^{A}\|}}\right],\\ \delta_{b}&\equiv\frac{2}{3}m_{e}\mathfrak{Re}\left[\frac{\braket{\|\hat{C}_{1}^{A}/q\|}}{\braket{\|\hat{L}_{1}^{A}\|}}+\sqrt{2}\frac{\braket{\|\hat{M}_{1}^{V}/q\|}}{\braket{\|\hat{L}_{1}^{A}\|}}\right],\end{split} (4.2) where \hat{C}_{1}^{A} , \hat{M}_{1}^{V} , and \hat{L}_{1}^{A} denote the axial-charge, vector-magnetic, and axial-longitudinal multipole operators, respectively. Ref. [ 74 ] carried out the first fully consistent ab initio calculation of recoil and shape corrections including uncertainty quantification essential for precision searches. Nuclear wave functions were obtained using the NCSM with \chi EFT interactions [ 61 , 127 , 138 , 10 ] . Two Hamiltonians were employed: NNLO opt (two-nucleon forces only) and NNLO sat (including three-nucleon forces) [ 54 , 56 ] . Matrix elements were computed in the impulse approximation, with one-body axial and vector operators constructed as in Ref. [ 50 ] : \begin{split}\hat{L}_{JM_{J}}^{A}&=\sum_{j=1}^{A}i\left(g_{A}+\frac{\tilde{g}_{P}}{\left(2m_{N}\right)^{2}}q^{2}\right)\hat{\Sigma}_{JM_{J}}^{\prime\prime}(q\vec{r}_{j})\,\tau^{+}_{j},\\ \hat{C}_{JM_{J}}^{A}&=\sum_{j=1}^{A}\frac{iq}{m_{N}}\left[g_{A}\hat{\Omega}^{\prime}_{JM_{J}}(q\vec{r}_{j})-\frac{1}{2}\frac{\tilde{g}_{P}}{2m_{N}}\left(E_{0}+\Delta E_{c}\right)\hat{\Sigma}_{JM_{J}}^{\prime\prime}(q\vec{r}_{j})\right]\tau^{+}_{j},\\ \hat{M}_{JM_{J}}^{V}&=\sum_{j=1}^{A}\frac{-iq}{m_{N}}\left[g_{V}\hat{\Delta}_{JM_{J}}(q\vec{r}_{j})-\frac{1}{2}\mu\hat{\Sigma}^{\prime}_{JM_{J}}(q\vec{r}_{j})\right]\tau^{+}_{j},\end{split} (4.3) with additional electromagnetic contributions from Coulomb energy shift \Delta E_{c}\approx 0.85 MeV following Refs. [ 15 , 76 ] and evaluated using Refs. [ 147 , 2 ] , as well as from Coulomb relevant order corrections from Refs. [ 89 , 90 ] . Translational invariance was ensured by using one-body densities in Jacobi coordinates [ 139 ] , thus eliminating spurious center-of-mass motion. The NCSM calculations were performed using model spaces up to N_{\max}=12 and with varying HO parameter \hbar\Omega=16 –24 MeV to assess convergence. Method and parametric uncertainties from the many-body solver were quantified by varying model spaces and comparing the two chiral interactions. Uncertainties due to the omission of two-body weak currents were estimated from EFT power counting ( \epsilon_{\mathrm{EFT}}\lesssim 0.15 ) and from comparisons with experimental observables such as the 6 Li magnetic moment and B(M1) transition, and the {}^{6}\text{He} half-life [ 141 , 66 , 176 ] . The subleading multipoles and higher-order terms omitted from the nonrelativistic expansion were estimated following the controlled formalism of Ref. [ 76 ] . Figure 4.1: (a) Calculated energy dependence of the spectrum of 6 He \beta -decay, in arbitrary units. Dashed line is the pure GT spectrum, while the filled bands include nuclear-structure dependent corrections. (b) The residual nuclear structure correction \delta_{1} compared to the pure GT spectrum (Eq. ( 4.2 )). (c) Energy dependence of the angular correlation a_{\beta\nu} . Dashed line corresponds to the SM value, a_{\beta\nu}=-1/3 . (d) Relative size of the \tilde{\delta}_{a} correction from ( 4.2 ). The width of the dark filled bands shows the variation with the employed nuclear Hamiltonian and NCSM model space parameters for HO frequency \hbar\Omega=16,20,24 MeV, N_{\mathrm{max}}=8,10,12 ( 10,12,14 ) using the NNLO sat (NNLO opt ) interaction, using translationally-invariant one-body densities. The width of the light filled band shows the total estimated theory error. Reprinted figure from [ 74 ] . Table 4.1: Calculated nuclear-structure corrections for the 6 He \!\rightarrow\!^{6} Li \beta decay obtained in Ref. [ 74 ] using the ab initio NCSM with chiral EFT interactions. Quoted NCSM uncertainties include methodological and parametric uncertainties of the many-body solver, as well as contributions from omitted two-body weak currents (EFT truncation), subleading multipoles, and higher-order terms. Angle brackets \langle\cdot\rangle denote averaging over the \beta -energy spectrum. Observable Symbol Value Uncertainty Fierz-like term \delta_{b} -1.52\times 10^{-3} 1.8\times 10^{-4} Angular-correlation correction \langle\tilde{\delta}_{a}\rangle -2.54\times 10^{-3} 6.8\times 10^{-4} Total extracted angular-correlation a -0.3331 0.0032 Multipole Operator Symbol Value Uncertainty Longitudinal \langle\hat{L}_{1}^{A}/i\rangle 0.464 0.016 Electric \langle\hat{E}_{1}^{A}/i\rangle 0.657 0.023 Magnetic \langle\hat{M}_{1}^{V}/iq\rangle -1.36\times 10^{-3} 1.5\times 10^{-4} Coulomb \langle\hat{C}_{1}^{A}/iq\rangle -1.39\times 10^{-4} 1.8\times 10^{-5} Holstein’s Form Factor Symbol Shell Model [ 25 ] NCSM [ 74 ] Extracted from Exp. [ 25 ] Gamow–Teller |c| 2.85(14) 2.75(3) Weak magnetism |b_{\mathrm{WM}}| 66.7(8.3) 69.0(1.0) Induced tensor |d^{I}| 2.4 7.73(59) Induced tensor to GT ratio |d^{I}/(Ac)| 0.12 0.45(4) 2.0(1.5) The resulted calculations, presented in Fig. 4.1 and summarized in Table 4.1 , revealed that nuclear-structure corrections produce measurable modifications to the GT observables. After averaging over the \beta -energy spectrum, the correction to the angular correlation was found to be \langle\tilde{\delta}_{a}\rangle=-2.54(68)\cdot 10^{-3} , which corresponds to a 0.7% modification of the GT angular correlation a=-1/3 . The extracted angular-correlation coefficient from available experimental data [ 101 ] , after including radiative, atomic, and the newly calculated structure effects, becomes a=-0.3331(32) , slightly shifted from the naive GT value but consistent with the standard model. Additionally, a nonzero Fierz-like contribution \delta_{b}=-1.52(18)\cdot 10^{-3} arises entirely due to nuclear structure effects. These value implies an energy-dependent distortion of the spectrum at the 10^{-3} level, comparable to the target precision of current experiments. The results were also benchmarked against the 1975 calculation by Calaprice [ 25 ] , which expressed the transition in terms of the Gamow–Teller ( c ), weak magnetism ( b_{\mathrm{WM}} ), and induced tensor ( d ) form factors. The NCSM values for the Gamow–Teller and weak-magnetism form factors, c=2.85(14) and b_{\mathrm{WM}}=66.7(8.3) , agree well with Calaprice’s values ( c=2.75(3) , b_{\mathrm{WM}}=69.0(1.0) ) extracted from measurements of half-life and M1 transition, respectively. For the induced tensor component, however, the NCSM result d^{I}\approx 7.73(59) is significantly larger than the value obtained in the shell-model calculation reported by Calaprice ( d^{I}\approx 2.4 ). Nonetheless, when expressed as a ratio d^{I}/(Ac)\approx 0.45(4) , the NCSM prediction lies closer to the value 2.0(1.5) inferred from the angular-correlation measurements analysis, which assumes all other recoil corrections and other effects are well known (which, of course, is not the case). A key outcome of these calculations is their quantified theoretical uncertainties, achieved for the first time. The resulting accuracy of order 10^{-4} places future measurements within the discovery window for BSM physics, as illustrated in Fig. 4.2 . Experiments observing additional per-mil deviations from these SM predictions would imply nonzero BSM tensor couplings. Furthermore, the indirect dependence of the measured angular correlation on the Fierz term b transforms its naive quadratic sensitivity to \epsilon_{T} into an effective linear one, significantly enhancing experimental reach for tensor interactions within angular correlation measurements. Overall, these NCSM results establish a high-precision Standard Model benchmark for the 6 He \rightarrow{}^{6} Li decay. Figure 4.2: Ratio of possible BSM-induced signals to SM nuclear-structure corrections for the 6 He \beta decay [ 74 ] . The solid green, dash-dotted purple, and dashed blue lines correspond to the Fierz term b , angular correlation a , and experimentally measured a^{\text{measured}} , respectively. If the ratio is of the order of 1 , the corrections should be calculated explicitly. The limit of theoretical uncertainty consequently occurs when the ratio is about the size of the theoretical uncertainty in calculating the SM corrections. The white region indicates where the theoretical uncertainty of the SM corrections (below 10^{-4} ) allows clean separation between SM and BSM effects. In the other domains, separation is limited by theoretical uncertainties. Reprinted figure with permission from [ 77 ] . Copyright 2023 by the American Physical Society. 4.2 6 He \rightarrow{}^{6} Li beta decay spectrum with QMC Figure 4.3: The Standard Model (SM) spectrum for 6 He \beta decay relative to the zero recoil approximation computed with GFMC (blue band), compared to results including BSM tensor (red band) and pseudoscalar (green band) contributions. The width of the band represents variations in the model Hamiltonian. Figure reprinted with permission from Ref. [ 108 ] . Interference between BSM currents with the V-A structure of the SM would induce a distinctive dependence in the \beta -decay spectrum on the ratio of the electron mass to the outgoing electron energy, m_{e}/E_{e} . This term, known as the Fierz interference term [ 99 ] , is usually denoted by b . The first constraint on its value -0.018