Generation Order and Parallel Decoding in Masked Diffusion Models: An Information-Theoretic Perspective Shaorong Zhang, Longxuan Yu, Rob Brekelmans, Luhan Tang, Salman Asif, Greg Ver Steeg Abstract Masked Diffusion Models (MDMs) significantly accelerate inference by trading off sequential determinism. However, the theoretical mechanisms governing generation order and the risks inherent in parallelization remain under-explored. In this work, we provide a unified information-theoretic framework to decouple and analyze two fundamental sources of failure: order sensitivity and parallelization bias . Our analysis yields three key insights: (1) The benefits of Easy-First decoding (prioritizing low-entropy tokens) are magnified as model error increases; (2) factorized parallel decoding introduces intrinsic sampling errors that can lead to arbitrary large Reverse KL divergence, capturing “incoherence” failures that standard Forward KL metrics overlook; and (3) while verification can eliminate sampling error, it incurs an exponential cost governed by the total correlation within a block. Conversely, heuristics like remasking, though computationally efficient, cannot guarantee distributional correctness. Experiments on a controlled Block-HMM and large-scale MDMs (LLaDA) for arithmetic reasoning validate our theoretical framework. † † affiliationnotice: Equal contribution \dagger Equal advising. 1 Introduction Autoregressive (AR) models have established themselves as the dominant paradigm for discrete sequence generation, powering breakthroughs in natural language processing ( 1 ; 21 ) and biological sequence design ( 15 ) . By decomposing the joint probability of a sequence into a chain of conditional probabilities, these models allow for tractable training and high-fidelity generation. However, this factorization imposes a strict sequential constraint: standard decoding proceeds token-by-token from left to right, resulting in inference latency that scales linearly with sequence length. To dismantle this computational bottleneck, recent research has pivoted toward parallel generation strategies. An initial line of work focuses on Speculative Decoding ( 14 ; 5 ) . However, the efficiency of speculative methods is strictly capped by the draft acceptance rate , which often stagnates in complex reasoning tasks or when the draft-oracle gap is large ( 22 ) . To achieve more aggressive speedups, a more radical shift has emerged toward fully parallel and non-autoregressive frameworks, such as Masked Diffusion Models (MDMs) ( 18 ; 16 ) and Discrete Flow Matching ( 3 ) . While these models bypass the serial verification bottleneck of speculative decoding, they introduce two unaddressed theoretical risks: (1) Order Sensitivity : Due to model approximation errors, the magnitude of error accumulation becomes highly dependent on the generation order. (2) Parallelization Bias : parallelization itself introduces a structural error; even with a perfect model, the resulting decoding distribution diverges from the ground truth. This leads to the generation of individually likely but jointly impossible sequences, a phenomenon we term incoherence or hallucinations. A variety of heuristic solutions have been proposed, such as confidence-based masking ( 4 ) , entropy-based scheduling ( 17 ) , and margin-based methods ( 12 ) . These approaches typically rely on what we term the Easy-first principle —prioritizing the generation of tokens with low uncertainty. However, the field lacks a unified theoretical framework to separate and characterize the distinct sources of failure in these strategies, especially as they typically intertwine order scheduling with parallel decoding. In particular, two fundamental questions remain open: Can the widely-used “Easy-first” principle be justified theoretically? and To what extent can the errors induced by parallel decoding be mitigated or eliminated? . Contributions. This work provides an information-theoretic analysis of how generation order and parallelization affect distributional correctness in MDMs. Our main contributions are: • Generation order matters under model error. We show that under imperfect conditional models, the divergence between the induced and target joint distributions is explicitly order-dependent due to rollout-induced covariate shift. Our analysis indicates that Easy-First ordering yields greater benefits as model error increases, due to the amplified effect of early conditional inaccuracies under forward KL divergence. • Parallel decoding introduces intrinsic sampling error. We compare forward KL, reverse KL, and incoherence probability as metrics for evaluating parallel decoding. We show that sampling error in factorized parallel decoding is unavoidable: exact elimination requires verification with expected cost exponential in forward KL, while heuristic corrections, though computationally efficient, in general cannot guarantee distributional correctness and totally avoid incoherence. • Empirical validation . Experiments on a fully specified Block-HMM confirm that parallel mean-field decoding can exhibit high reverse KL and incoherence despite modest forward KL. Additional results on arithmetic reasoning and masked diffusion decoding demonstrate that Easy-First schedules substantially improve accuracy, especially in high-error regimes. 2 Background and Problem Setup 2.1 Autoregressive Models and Decoding We consider a length- T discrete sequence X_{1:T}=(X_{1},\ldots,X_{T}) over a finite alphabet \mathcal{V} , distributed according to an unknown data distribution p_{\mathrm{data}} . Autoregressive (AR) models provide a convenient reference point by parameterizing a joint distribution via the chain rule: p_{\theta}(x_{1:T})=\prod_{t=1}^{T}p_{\theta}(x_{t}\mid x_{0 captures the contribution of intrinsic uncertainty, \lambda\geq 0 models prefix-induced error propagation, and b\geq 0 absorbs residual mismatch. This assumption abstracts the empirically observed relationship between conditional entropy and approximation error, while allowing for mild prefix-dependent effects. In Appendix B , we provide empirical evidence that conditional entropy is a strong predictor of approximation error, and that prefix error exhibits a monotone but secondary influence. Substituting Equation 10 into Equation 9 yields an upper bound of the form \mathcal{J}(\pi)\;\leq\;\sum_{t=1}^{T}W_{t}\,H\!\big(X_{\pi(t)}\mid x_{\pi(