Inclination Bias in Techniques Used to Identify Be Star Candidates Astropy ( 6 ; 4 ; 5 ) , Bedisk ( 51 ) , Beray ( 53 ) , Violin Plots for Matlab (Bechtold 2016) B. D. Lailey, T. A. A. Sigut Abstract Several methods for identifying Be star candidates are reviewed for observational bias with respect to system inclination, that is the angle between the stellar/disk rotation axis and the observer’s line of sight, with focus on two photometric methods that leverage narrow-band filters centred on H α \alpha and a spectroscopic method using a H α \alpha peak-finding algorithm. Tests for bias were performed using a sample of 20,000 synthetic Be stars drawn from a Salpeter initial mass function and computed libraries of spectral energy distributions and H α \alpha profiles. The spectroscopic method showed substantial bias against high inclinations ( i > 80 ∘ i>80^{\circ} ). Both photometric methods were biased against low inclinations, with one also biased against inclinations above 80 ∘ 80^{\circ} , resulting in a surplus in the Be star candidate detection rate for moderate inclinations ( 50 ∘ < i < 80 ∘ 50^{\circ}0 represents net line emission. Figure 1 shows the visual V magnitude of a representative Be star as a function of stellar inclination. As V is clearly correlated with inclination, we have the potential conditions for classic Malmquist bias ( 62 ) . The basic trend with inclination is easily understood. Assuming both the star and disk radiate as black bodies and the disk’s temperature is 60% that of the star’s effective temperature, T_{d}=0.6\,T_{\rm eff} , the magnitude difference between the star+disk system and the star alone is approximately \Delta m_{V}\approx-2.5\log_{10}\left\{1+0.3\,(R_{c}^{2}-1)\,\cos i\right\}\;. (2) Here the disk is assumed to be optically thick in the continuum (perpendicular through the disk) to radius R_{c} (measured in stellar radii), and 0.3 is representative of ratio B_{\nu}(T_{d})/B_{\nu}(T_{\rm eff}) in the visible over the T_{\rm eff} range of the B stars. The factor of \cos i reflects the reduction in the disk’s emitting area with increasing inclination angle. Clearly, this expression is valid only for low-to-moderate inclinations where absorption of starlight by the disk is negligible. For large inclinations, absorption of starlight by the disk becomes a factor, and the system magnitude eventually returns to the star’s magnitude and then further increases due to absorption by the disk, reaching a maximum at i=90^{\circ} . As Be star disks are thin, with H/R\ll 1 , the system magnitude falling below the stellar magnitude occurs only for high-inclination systems. While the details vary with the general model for the disk density distribution, the overall picture remains the same. Figure 1: Change in the visual magnitude (star+disk minus star alone) of an M=7\,M_{\odot} Be star as the viewing inclination ranges from i=0^{\circ} (pole-on star, face-on disk) to i=90^{\circ} (equator-on star, edge-on disk). The solid lines with symbols are Bedisk / Beray calculations (see Section III for computational details). Here the star is surrounded by a disk with parameters \rho_{0}=2.35\times 10^{-11}\,\rm g\,cm^{-3} and n=2.25 , and several disk radii are considered (see legend). The red line is the prediction of Equation 2 with R_{c}=1.3 stellar radii. Figure 2 shows the H \alpha equivalent width for several representative Be star models (distinguished by the choice of power-law index n ; see Section III.1 ) as a function of inclination. Again there is a clear correlation with inclination. The basic trends are easily understood, although there is an interplay of several effects. For high inclinations, i\geq 80^{\circ} , there is a rapid reduction in the EW for most models. Here, the system is sufficiently edge-on that the star is seen through the plane of the (optically-thick) disk, and this leads to so-called shell absorption by the disk material. However, this is not seen for the lowest power-law index model shown, n=2.25 . Here, the densities in the outer disk are large enough that even viewed edge-on, the disk material not seen against the star contributes substantial emission. Observationally, the H \alpha profile of such objects has large V and R emission peaks separated by a narrow, deep absorption core (zeta \tau is a good example). Such Be stars are still classified as shell stars according to the criteria of 25 , but exhibit large emission equivalent widths. For the other models, the equivalent widths are usually smallest for low-to-moderate inclinations, i\leq 30^{\circ} , where the low projected disk rotation velocities result in a singly-peaked emission line for H \alpha . For increasing inclination, we transition to the classic, doubly-peaked H \alpha line and, therefore, larger equivalent widths. As, nominally, the inclinations follow the \sin i distribution, Be stars with doubly-peaked lines are most common. Finally, for the highest index n models, where the density is low over most of the disk, we see a more-or-less flat behavior until the onset of shell absorption at high inclination. Finally, it should always be kept in mind that the EW of H \alpha is defined relative to the local continuum which can include a contribution from the disk itself. In most cases, the optical depths in the continuum are quite small; however, for sufficiently dense disks, emission in the adjacent continuum will begin to grow as optical depths build. As the line emission has long since saturated, the H \alpha equivalent width will actually begin to decrease . Although not shown in Figure 2 for clarity, the EWs for the n=2.00 model actually lie below those shown for n=2.25 for most inclinations. Figure 2: Change in H \alpha equivalent width as a function of viewing inclination. Positive equivalent widths represent net emission. The same Be star model of Figure 1 was used, except that R_{d} was fixed at 25 and the power-law index was varied with the values given in the legend. I.4 Organization Section II discusses procedures for identifying Be star candidates using spectroscopy, single exposure photometry, and photometric time-series, using examples drawn from the literature. Section III describes the computation of the synthetic Be star H \alpha and SED libraries used to test whether methods for identifying Be star candidates are biased in terms of inclination. Section IV tests for inclination bias in spectroscopically determined Be star candidates using the peak-finding algorithm of 27 on the synthetic Be star spectra. Section V tests for inclination bias in photometrically determined Be star candidates using the methods of both 28 and 36 . A discussion of our conclusions follows in Section VI . II Methods for Identifying Be Star Candidates II.1 Spectroscopy Multi-fiber spectroscopic surveys, such as those produced by the Large Sky Area Multi-Object Fiber Spectroscopic Telescope (LAMOST) ( 12 ) and by the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment (APOGEE) ( 32 ) , can simultaneously observe entire fields of stars yielding large spectral catalogues. The LAMOST survey contains approximately 11 million spectra with resolution, \mathcal{R}\equiv\frac{\lambda}{\Delta\lambda} , 1,800 and spectral coverage between \rm 3700-9000\,\AA , with an additional six million spectra with \mathcal{R}=7,500 and spectral coverage between both \rm 4900-5400\,\AA and \rm 6000-6800\,\AA . The APOGEE survey contains approximately 600,000 spectra with \mathcal{R}=22,500 and spectral coverage between \rm 1.51-1.69\,\mu m ( 66 ) . Contemporary approaches ( 27 ; 64 , e.g.,) can extract thousands of Be star candidates from these large spectral catalogues often by leveraging machine learning techniques followed by tests to exclude confounding objects such as B[e] and Herbig stars. 27 found 9,752 early-type emission line star candidates while searching dr2 of the LAMOST survey ( 12 ) . A peak-finding routine was used near H \alpha line-centre to identify emission line stars. Once identified, each emission line star was then classified into one of six morphological types by cross-correlation with template line profiles, followed by visual inspection. Any emission line star found within an H ii region was removed due to the ambiguity of whether the \rm H\alpha emission is intrinsic or extrinsic to the star; Herbig Be stars were separated from classical Be stars using infrared excess measurements from the Two Micron All-Sky Survey (2MASS) ( 55 ) and the Wield-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE) ( 65 ) . 27 culminated in discovering 5,603 new classical Be stars. 49 found 3,339 early-type emission line star candidates while searching dr5 of the LAMOST survey ( 12 ) . Again a peak-finding routine was used near H \alpha line-centre to identify emission line stars. Once identified, a series of tests was used to identify confounding objects such as A[e], B[e], and Herbig Be stars in order to remove them. Forbidden emission lines characteristic of A[e] and B[e] stars were identified by fitting the LAMOST spectra to the empirical spectral library of 47 and pre-main-sequence Herbig stars were identified using infrared excess measurements from 2MASS ( 55 ) and WISE ( 65 ) . 49 culminated in identifying 1,089 classical Be stars. 64 found 1,162 Be star candidates by searching dr7 of the LAMOST survey for H \alpha emission in early type stars using the ResNet convolutional neural network ( 26 ) . The neural network was trained on a combination of Be star spectra (found by searching for local maxima within \rm 28\,\AA of H \alpha line-centre) and non-Be, B-type spectra from the LAMOST survey. Previously discovered Be stars were removed by cross-referencing the literature and confounding Herbig Be stars were removed using infrared excess measurements from the extended Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (ALLWISE) ( 13 ) . 64 culminated in the discovery of 183 new Be stars. II.2 Photometry Narrow-band H \alpha filters ( \rm\lambda_{centre}\approx 6563\,\AA,\Delta\lambda\approx 300\,\AA ) combined with single-exposure optical or infrared photometry allow for the the efficient detection of large numbers of Be star candidates ( 44 ) . Methods for identifying Be star candidates using single exposure photometry are particularly well suited to the LMC and SMC where large distances and high cluster densities make spectroscopy difficult ( 28 ) . Here, classical, rather than machine learning based, techniques are normally used, with Be star candidates typically determined by comparison to a threshold line in a colour-colour or colour-magnitude diagram. 28 found 96 Be star candidates by searching the Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment (OGLE) catalogue ( 39 ) for open clusters in the LMC and SMC with ages between 10 and 100 Myr. Photometric observations using a narrow-band H \alpha filter were compared with observations using Cousins V, R, and I band filters to produce an \rm R-H\alpha vs \rm V-I diagnostic plot. Be star candidates were identified as cluster stars lying above a threshold line in the diagnostic plot. Stars displaying Be characteristics with a V magnitude lower than that of a cluster’s main-sequence turnoff were considered to be supergiant B[e] stars and excluded. 36 found that the ratio of Be to early-type main-sequence stars varied between \approx 0.0 and 0.6 as a function of the relative magnitude to the main-sequence turnoff by searching Hubble Space Telescope Wide Field Camera 3 (WFC3) ( 30 ) photometry of 13 young open clusters in the LMC and SMC. Although the focus of this work was to search for evidence of an extended main-sequence consisting of fast rotators, rather than to catalogue Be stars, the method, which involved producing a diagnostic ( \rm F814_{wide} vs \rm F814_{wide}-F656_{narrow} ) colour-magnitude plot where Be star candidates are demarcated from main-sequence B-type stars by a threshold line, is essentially similar to that of 28 . II.3 Photometric Time-Series Gravitational microlensing surveys such as the MAssive Compact Halo Object project (MACHO) ( 3 ) and OGLE ( 39 ) allowed researchers to identify Be star candidates in the LMC and SMC using a combination of their colours and photometric variability. 35 found \sim 1,000 Be star candidates by searching the OGLE II catalogue ( 67 ) for stars in the SMC with V -band absolute magnitudes, B-V , and V-I colours corresponding to the ranges in which Galactic Be stars are usually found. The I -band light curves for each of these \sim 4,000 stars was then visibly inspected to remove spurious variable stars, Cepheids, and eclipsing binaries, resulting in \sim 1,000 Be star candidates that were categorized into four types based on their light curve behaviour. The light curves, which were attributed to disk ejection and dissipation, varied on timescales of tens to hundreds of days. The types were assigned based on whether the variation was abrupt or gradual and periodic or stochastic. 61 found 693 Be star candidates as a side effect of training neural networks to identify Galactic Herbig Be stars using photometric time series data from the Global Astrometric Interferometer for Astrophysics (GAIA) DR2 ( 18 ) , combined with near and mid-IR data from the 2MASS and WISE surveys, respectively, as well as H \alpha emission data from both the INT/WFC Photometric H \alpha Survey of the Northern Galactic Plane (IPHAS) ( 7 ) and the VST Photometric \rm H\alpha Survey of the Southern Galactic Plane (VPHAS+) ( 14 ) . III Creating the Synthetic Be Stars In order to test methods for identifying Be star candidates, such as those described in the previous section, for inclination bias, 13 large libraries of synthetic Be star SED+H \alpha profiles were generated. Each of the 13 libraries features a central B-type star that corresponds to one of the masses given in Table 1 . These stellar masses span most of the mass range of the main sequence B-type stars and are adopted from 16 assuming a mid-main sequence core hydrogen fraction of X=0.3 . Within a given library, the synthetic Be stars are differentiated on the basis of their disk density structure and inclination angle as described below. Mass Radius Luminosity T_{\rm eff} \log(g) ( \rm M_{\odot} ) \rm(R_{\odot}) ( \rm L_{\odot} ) (K) 3.00 2.9 1.10\times 10^{2} 11,000 4.0 3.25 3.0 1.46\times 10^{2} 11,600 4.0 3.50 3.2 2.03\times 10^{2} 12,200 4.0 3.75 3.3 2.62\times 10^{2} 12,800 4.0 4.25 3.6 4.46\times 10^{2} 14,000 4.0 4.75 3.8 6.55\times 10^{2} 15,000 4.0 5.50 4.1 1.09\times 10^{3} 16,400 4.0 6.00 4.3 1.52\times 10^{3} 17,400 3.9 8.00 5.1 4.23\times 10^{3} 20,600 3.9 9.00 5.4 6.28\times 10^{3} 22,000 3.9 10.0 5.7 8.88\times 10^{3} 23,400 3.9 12.0 6.4 1.58\times 10^{4} 25,600 3.9 14.0 7.0 2.51\times 10^{4} 27,400 3.9 Table 1: Stellar properties adopted from 16 corresponding to a core hydrogen fraction of X=0.3 . III.1 Creating the libraries of synthetic Be stars The SED+H \alpha libraries of synthetic Be stars were created using the Bedisk ( 51 ; 53 ) and Beray ( 53 ) suite of radiative transfer codes. A comprehensive account of using Bedisk and Beray to create libraries of synthetic Be stars can be found in 52 and 50 . The stellar parameters mass, radius, and luminosity (M_{*},R_{*},L_{*}) fix the star’s T_{\rm eff} and log(g) and, therefore, the star’s photoionizing radiation field, which is the principal heating source for the star’s equatorial disk. Bedisk is used to compute the temperature structure of the circumstellar disk, given the central star’s photoionizing radiation field. The circumstellar disk density structure uses a parameterized density model ( 51 ) . This model depends on H , the scale height of the disk, \rho_{0} , the equatorial disk density at the stellar radius, n , the power-law index fixing the radial drop-off in disk density, and r_{d} , the disk radius. With these values, the disk density model is \rho(R,Z)=\rho_{0}\,\left(\frac{R_{*}}{R}\right)^{n}e^{-\left(\frac{Z}{H}\right)^{2}}\, (3) Here, R is the distance from the central B-type star’s rotation axis, and Z is the distance above the equatorial plane. Equation 3 holds for R_{*}f_{\rm continuum}\,, (7) where f[n_{0}] is the flux at line centre, the sum is over pixel index i , and f_{\rm continuum} is the flux of the adjacent continuum. Due to the oversampling rate of LAMOST, these 11 pixels correspond to about 16.6\,\AA . This step is used to find H \alpha lines with emission above the continuum. To find weak emission in an absorption trough, the second step checks whether both the average flux of the three pixels centred on H \alpha is greater than the average flux of the five pixels centred on H \alpha C_{2}\colon~~~~~\frac{1}{3}\sum_{i=-1}^{1}f[n_{0}+i]>\frac{1}{5}\sum_{i=-2}^{2}f[n_{0}+i]\,, (8) and whether the maximum flux of the five pixels centred on H \alpha occurs within the central three pixels. C_{3}\colon\max(f[n_{0}-1:n_{0}+1])\geq\max(f[n_{0}-2:n_{0}+2])\,, (9) where f[n_{0}] and i are the same as in C_{1} , and the colons in C_{3} indicate a range over pixel indices. According to the method of 27 , a Be star candidate is a main sequence, B-type star that satisfies either C_{1} or both C_{2} and C_{3} . A possible complication in evaluating the inclination bias of methods for detecting Be star candidates from LAMOST spectra is the wide range of signal-to-noise ratios (S/N) present in the survey, which range from below \rm S/N=10 to above \rm S/N=500 . The analysis below assumes negligible noise, and therefore represents an idealized analysis of the method of 27 . Figure 8 shows the results of applying the method of 27 to the sample of synthetic Be stars of Section III.2 after profiles have been convolved down to the LAMOST resolution of \rm\mathcal{R}=1,800 . The vertical axis shows the fraction of Be stars in the sample rejected as Be star candidates, i.e. , those that don’t satisfy either C_{1} or both C_{2} and C_{3} , as a function of inclination. Although the sample is constructed such that every star is a Be star (with H \alpha differing from a purely photospheric profile by at least two percent in the mean flux deviation), 4,734 out of 19,891 stars ( \approx 24\% ) are rejected as Be star candidates. No sample Be stars are rejected for i\leq 10^{\circ} . However, the rejected fraction rises sharply between 20^{\circ} and 50^{\circ} , plateauing until 80^{\circ} , and then rises steeply again for i\geq 80^{\circ} . There is clear evidence of a selection bias against very high inclination objects: Be stars with inclinations of 90^{\circ} are more than twice as likely to be rejected as Be stars compared to inclination at or below 80^{\circ} . Furthermore, there is clear evidence of a selection bias in favour of low inclination objects, particularly for i\leq 20^{\circ} . Figure 8: The fraction of sample Be stars rejected by the method of 27 as a function of inclination. This fraction is seen to monotonically increase with inclination. Note the non-linear inclination bins. IV.1 Discussion The results of Section IV suggest that the method of 27 for identifying Be star candidates is significantly biased in favour of detecting low inclination angle Be stars and against very high inclination angle Be stars. We now turn to examining the factors that result in this inclination bias. Figure 9 shows the distribution of H \alpha equivalent widths for both the synthetic Be stars identified as Be star candidates (bottom panel) and those that were rejected (top panel). The two distributions are very different. Most notably, no Be star with a positive H \alpha equivalent width was rejected as a Be star candidate using the method of 27 as it would satisfy the requirements of C_{1} . However, while a negative equivalent width was a necessary condition to reject a synthetic Be star as a Be star candidate, Equations C_{2} and C_{3} ensured that many of the Be stars with negative H \alpha equivalent widths were correctly identified. Figure 9: Top : Histogram of the H \alpha EWs of the sample Be stars rejected by the method of 27 . Bottom : Histogram of the H \alpha EWs of the sample Be stars accepted by the method of 27 . Note the change in axis limits from the panel above. There are four sample Be stars with EW>60 Å. There are three ways for a synthetic Be star to be rejected as a Be star candidate using the method of 27 , namely (1) failure to satisfy C_{1} , C_{2} , and C_{3} , (2) failure to satisfy C_{1} and C_{2} , but not C_{3} , and (3) failure to satisfy C_{1} and C_{3} , but not C_{2} . In the analysis of the synthetic sample, only (1) and (3) were operative; furthermore, (3) was very rare, with only 66 out of 19,891 ( \approx 0.3\% ) rejected as Be star candidates this way. Turning from the effects of the H \alpha equivalent width to the profiles themselves, Figure 10 is a panel plot of 50 randomly chosen profiles from the synthetic Be star sample that were rejected by the method of 27 by failing to satisfy C_{1} , C_{2} , and C_{3} (top panel) and by failing to satisfy C_{1} and C_{3} , but not C_{2} (bottom panel). The top panel shows the typical condition for rejection with the H \alpha line featuring more absorption than emission, and there is no visible emission peak inside the absorption trough; this condition is strongly associated with high inclinations and low density disks. The bottom panel shows the rarer condition by which a Be star is rejected because the H \alpha line features more absorption than emission, combined with the separation between the peaks of the doubled-peaked emission structure being too small to satisfy C_{2} which only occurs at intermediate inclinations 30^{\circ}\leq i\leq 60^{\circ} . Figure 10: Top : H \alpha line profiles for 50 randomly selected Be stars rejected by the method of 27 for failing to satisfy each of the conditions C_{1} , C_{2} , and C_{3} . Bottom : H \alpha line profiles for 50 randomly selected Be star rejected by the method of 27 for failing to satisfy conditions C_{1} and C_{3} , but not C_{2} . Finally, Figure 11 shows the expected observed inclination bias of the method of 27 , expressed as both a probability density function (pdf, top panel) and as a cumulative distribution function (cdf, bottom panel). This pdf was created to model how an underlying inclination distribution (assumed to be the random \sin{i} distribution) is modified by the bias shown in Figure 8 . We defined an inclination bias function for the method of 27 on a uniform inclination distribution, b(i) , as a cubic spline fit to one minus the fraction of rejected Be stars as a function of inclination shown in Figure 8 . The pdf of the inclination distribution expected for a random, observed sample of Be stars is then {\rm pdf}=\frac{b(i)\,\sin\,\!i}{\int_{0}^{\frac{\pi}{2}}b(i)\,\sin\,\!i\,di}\;, (10) and is shown in the top panel of Figure 11 . Compared to the \sin{i} distribution, the method of 27 is modestly biased in favour of low inclinations i\lesssim 50^{\circ} and heavily biased against very high inclinations i>80^{\circ} . Figure 11: The inclination bias of the method of 27 determined on the sample of synthetic Be star spectra expressed as both a probability density function (top panel) and a cumulative distribution function (bottom panel). In both panels, the inclination bias of Hou16 is shown as a solid line with the \sin{i} probability distribution shown as a dotted line for comparison. Note the strong bias against inclination angles above 80^{\circ} . V Biases of Photometric Methods to Identify Be Star Candidates Although there are methods for identifying Be star candidates using both single exposure photometry and photometric time-series (see Sections II.2 & II.3 , respectively), this work will focus on methods using single exposure photometry because the synthetic Be stars described in Section III do not have evolving disks. This section will evaluate the methods of 28 and of 36 to determine if we should expect samples of Be star candidates found using single exposure photometry to be biased in inclination. V.1 Iqbal & Keller 2013 28 used observations from the Faulkes Telescope South (FTS) to search for Be stars in young, open clusters in the SMC and LMC. It leverages the fact that stars with strong hydrogen emission will have larger \rm R-H\alpha magnitudes than stars without hydrogen emission at a given \rm V-I . According to the method of 28 , a Be star candidate is a main-sequence, B-type star that lies above a threshold line on an \rm R-H\alpha vs \rm V-I colour-colour diagram. One complication that arises is that \rm R-H\alpha has an arbitrary zero point; 28 addressed this issue by calibrating such that main-sequence stars are tightly clustered around \rm R-H\alpha=0 . Be star candidates identified by this method represent a lower-bound to the the number of Be stars in a cluster because the method is inherently biased against small emission equivalent widths (in addition, of course, to those missed due to the transient nature of the Be phenomena). Recently, 38 expanded on the work of 28 using the Southern Astrophysical Research Telescope (SOAR) Adaptative Module Imager (SAMI), which provides high angular resolution, adaptive optics assisted photometry ( 58 ) . Unlike observations from the FTS, which are both seeing and flux limited, SAMI offers full photometric coverage up to the early A-type stars and is able to resolve stars in the densely packed cores of young open SMC clusters ( 38 ) . Owing to the high angular resolution of SAMI, 38 found approximately twice as many Be star candidates as 28 by replicating their method with a very slightly modified threshold line. Preliminary testing performed during the course of this work found that the effect of 38 ’s modification to the threshold line of 28 on the inclination bias was negligible; thus, the inclination bias determined in this section will also apply to 38 . Figure 12: Top : An (\rm R-H\alpha) vs (\rm V-I) colour-colour diagram used to identify Be star candidates based on the method of 28 . Shown as circles are 1,000 randomly selected sample Be stars, with inclination coded according to the colourbar on the right. The black line is the threshold above which stars are considered Be star candidates. Bottom : A histogram of the fraction of all sample Be stars that were rejected as Be star candidates as a function of inclination. The top panel of Figure 12 shows the method of 28 applied to the synthetic Be stars of the sample. The vertical axis shows the \rm R-H\alpha colour, where higher values are brighter in \rm H\alpha. Following 28 , we calibrated the \rm R-H\alpha colour of diskless main sequence stars to zero; this was done by shifting all the Be stars in the sample by +0.141 magnitudes in \rm R-H\alpha such that the weighted average (by mass according to the initial mass function ( 46 ) ) of the stars with purely photospheric H \alpha profiles has an \rm R-H\alpha colour of zero. The horizontal axis shows the \rm V-I colour. We calibrated the sample stars in \rm V-I according to the calibration standards of 15 ; this was done by shifting all the Be stars in the sample by +0.346 magnitudes. After calibration, none of the photospheric stars in the sample differed from their associated calibration standards by more than 0.01 magnitudes in \rm V-I . The black line is a threshold line ( \rm R-H\,\alpha=0.1(V-I)+0.15 ) above which any star is identified as a Be star candidate by the method of 28 . In 28 , both the slope and y-intercept of the threshold line are allowed to vary slightly depending on the star cluster being studied. Figure 12 uses the threshold line associated with the search for Be star candidates in NGC 330, which was chosen because the method of 28 has recently been reassessed on this cluster ( 38 ) . The bottom panel of Figure 12 shows the fraction of Be stars in the sample rejected as Be star candidates by the method of 28 , namely those that fall below the threshold line, as a function of inclination. Again, while every star in the sample is a Be star whose H \alpha profile differs from a purely photospheric profile, 8,594 out of 20,000 ( \approx 43 %) of the stars in the sample are rejected as Be star candidates, consistent with the method of 28 selecting only strong H \alpha emitters. The shape of the distribution of rejected Be star candidates by inclination is relatively flat between i=0^{\circ} and 40^{\circ} , falls slightly between 50^{\circ} and 70^{\circ} , and then rises steadily for i\geq 80^{\circ} . There is clear evidence of a selection bias against very high inclination objects: Be stars with an inclination of 90^{\circ} are the most likely to be rejected as candidates ( \approx 52\,\% are rejected) by the method of 28 and are about 20\,\% more likely to be rejected than the average across all inclinations. V.2 Milone et al. 2018 36 used observations from the Hubble Space Telescope’s WFC3 to search 13 young clusters in the LMC and SMC for evidence of a “split” main-sequence thought to represent stellar populations with differing rotation rates. 36 used a photometric method to search for the presence of Be stars, which are known to be fast rotating main-sequence stars ( 44 ) . The method of 36 leverages the fact that stars with strong H \alpha emission will have smaller \rm F656N-F814W magnitudes compared to stars without H \alpha emission at a given F814W . According to the method of 36 , a Be star candidate is a star that lies to the left of a threshold line on a F814W vs \rm F656N-F814W colour-magnitude diagram. The threshold line was created by a shifting a fiducial line by -0.15 magnitudes (brighter in H \alpha ); the fiducial line was created by fitting a cubic spline to the main-sequence stars of the cluster. As our sample of stars is synthetic, we recreated the fiducial line by fitting a cubic spline to the purely photospheric profiles only. Figure 13: Top: An \rm F814W vs \rm F656N-F814W colour-magnitude diagram used to identify Be star candidates based on the method of 36 . Shown as circles are 1,000 randomly selected sample Be stars, with inclination coded according to the colourbar on the right. The red line is a cubic spline fit to the purely H \alpha photospheric profiles, and the dashed black line is a threshold line created by shifting the red line by -0.15 magnitudes (see text). According to the method of 36 , stars left of this threshold line are Be star candidates. Bottom : A histogram of the fraction sample Be stars rejected as Be star candidates as a function of inclination. Note that low inclination Be stars are the most likely to be rejected, in contrast with Figure 12 . The top panel of Figure 13 shows the method of 36 applied to the Be stars of the sample. The vertical axis shows the \rm F814W magnitude and the horizontal axis shows the \rm F656N-F814W colour (lower values are brighter in \rm H\alpha ). The red line is the fiducial line created by fitting a cubic spline to the purely photospheric profiles. The black dashed line is the threshold line created by shifting the fiducial line by -0.15 magnitudes in \rm F656N-F814W . As the method of 36 ultimately depends only on the horizontal distance to a fiducial line derived from the purely photospheric profiles, it is unaffected by calibration shifts in \rm F814W . For this reason, the stars in Figure 13 have been left uncalibrated. The bottom panel of Figure 13 shows the fraction of Be stars in the sample rejected as Be star candidates by the method of 36 as a function of inclination. Again, although every star in the sample is a Be star by construction, 11,562 out of 20,000 stars ( \approx 58\,\% ) are rejected as Be star candidates. The shape of the distribution of rejected Be star candidates is flat and maximal between i=0^{\circ} and 30^{\circ} , then falls between 40^{\circ} and 80^{\circ} before rising for i\geq 80^{\circ} . Thus the method of 36 is most strongly biased against low inclination Be stars unlike the method of 28 , which was most strongly biased against very high inclination Be stars. Finally, a two-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnoff (KS) test ( 34 ) was used to compare the inclination distribution of rejected Be stars from the methods of 28 and 36 (that is, the bottom panels of Figures 12 and 13 multiplied by the number of stars in the sample at each inclination). The result rejects the null hypothesis that the two distributions come from the same underlying distribution with a a p-value of 0.031 . V.3 Discussion The results of Sections V.1 and V.2 show that relatively similar photometric methods for identifying Be star candidates can produce somewhat different inclination biases, and there is likely no simple inclination bias that will apply to every photometric method. This section explores the causes of these differences in inclination bias, i.e. why the methods of 28 and 36 produce their maximum bias at opposite ends of the inclination range. The primary differences between the methods of 28 and 36 are the colours used ( \rm R-H\,\alpha vs \rm F656N-F814W ), and the threshold line morphology (linear versus cubic spline of differing ‘slopes’ through a secondary axis \rm V-I vs F814W ). A consequence of these differences is that the two methods reject different proportions of Be stars in the sample as Be star candidates ( 43\,\% vs 58\,\% ). Figure 14: Top and Bottom : The same as Figure 13 except that the threshold was created by shifting the red line by 0.09715 magnitudes, instead of 0.15 , to give the same number of rejected sample Be stars as the method of 28 (see Section V.1 ). Figure 14 examines the influence of the proportion of Be stars in the sample rejected as Be star candidates by recreating the method of 36 with the modification that the threshold line is a shift of the fiducial line by -0.09715 magnitudes in \rm F656N-F814W rather than the original -0.15 magnitudes. This change in the location of the threshold line results in the same number of rejected Be star candidates ( 8,594\approx 43\,\% ) as the method of 28 . A two-sample KS test applied to the inclination distribution of rejected Be stars using both the method of 28 and this modified method of 36 accepts the null hypothesis that the two distributions come from the same underlying distribution with a p-value of 0.31 . Thus, the two photometric methods have inclination biases that are consistent with one another when the level of rejection is taken into account. However, the analysis is extended below to look at the impact of the two remaining differences between the methods of 28 and 36 : colour and threshold line morphology. Figure 15: Histograms in \rm H\alpha-R (top row) and \rm F656N-F814W (bottom row) for low ( i=10^{\circ} , left), medium ( i=50^{\circ} , middle), and very high ( i=90^{\circ} , right) inclination sample Be stars binned in colour increments of 0.05 magnitudes. Note that although the colour used in the method of 28 is \rm R-H\alpha , it has been reversed in this figure to make comparisons with the \rm F656N-F814W distributions easier. Moving on from the relationship between biases in inclination and the proportion of Be stars rejected as Be star candidates, we turn to the role of colour. Figure 15 is a panel plot of six histograms where the counts are over the synthetic Be stars in the sample with a given inclination and the bins are in colour increments of 0.05 magnitudes. Along the columns, each panel corresponds to low ( i=10^{\circ} , left), medium ( i=50^{\circ} , middle), and high ( i=90^{\circ} , right) inclinations. The top row shows the colour distribution of sample stars in \rm H\alpha-R , used by the method of 28 (reversed so that the stars brightest in H \alpha are on the left side of the distribution to make a visual comparison with the bottom row easier). The bottom row shows the colour distribution of sample stars in \rm F656N-F814W , used by the method of 36 . The purpose of these histograms is to remove the effects of threshold line morphology (namely the small positive slope in the method of 28 and the curved fiducial line in the method of 36 ) to focus on the differences that arise due to the two methods different choices of colour. i \mu \sigma Skew Kurt Q1 Med Q3 \rm H\,\alpha-R 10^{\circ} -0.07 0.13 -1.14 4.31 -0.14 -0.04 0.03 50^{\circ} -0.11 0.19 -1.40 5.14 -0.20 -0.05 0.04 90^{\circ} -0.10 0.24 -1.24 3.96 -0.23 0.00 0.09 \rm F656N-F814W 10^{\circ} -0.35 0.13 -1.33 5.56 -0.41 -0.33 -0.26 50^{\circ} -0.40 0.18 -1.52 6.08 -0.47 -0.35 -0.27 90^{\circ} -0.40 0.23 -1.36 4.74 -0.51 -0.32 -0.22 Table 3: Summary statistics for each of the six histograms shown in Figure 15 . The rows are organized by inclination ( i ) in two sets of three; the top set of three rows corresponds to the \rm H\,\alpha-R histograms (top row of Figure 15 ) and the bottom set of three rows corresponds to the \rm F656N-F814W histograms (bottom row of Figure 15 ). The included summary statistics are the mean ( \mu ), the standard deviation ( \sigma ), the skewness (Skew), the kurtosis (Kurt), the first quartile (Q1), the median (Med), and the third quartile (Q3). Table 3 shows summary statistics for each of the six histograms in Figure 15 . The means of the \rm H\alpha-R histograms are higher than those of their \rm F656N-F814W counterparts at all inclinations, which is expected because Be stars are typically brighter at red wavelengths than in the near infrared. The standard deviations increase with inclination and are nearly identical between the two colours. The histograms of both colours are very negatively skewed at all inclinations as can be seen in the long left tails of the distributions in Figure 15 . This is corroborated by the mean being more negative than the median for each of the six histograms. Kurtosis values above three imply that each of the six panels contains more profiles in the wings of the distribution than would be expected if they were normally distributed; that the kurtosis values of the \rm F656N-F814W histograms are higher than those of their \rm H\alpha-R counterparts at all inclinations shows that they have more counts in the tails. Of the summary statistics listed in Table 3 , the inclination dependent quartiles are especially important for understanding the relationship between a photometric identification method and the resulting bias in inclination. Figure 16: A plot of the fraction of all the Be stars in the sample that were rejected as Be star candidates versus inclination for five different threshold lines in \rm R-H\,\alpha . The threshold lines correspond to the first quartile (circles), median (squares), third quartile (diamonds), 42.97th percentile (triangles), and the unmodified results using the method of 28 (asterisks). The points have been fit with cubic splines to show the trends. Figure 16 shows the fraction of all the synthetic Be stars in the sample that were rejected as Be star candidates according to the method of 28 with the modification of using four different quartiles in \rm R-H\,\alpha as alternative threshold lines; the fraction of synthetic Be stars rejected using the unmodified method of 28 is also included for comparison. These threshold lines occur at the: \bullet First quartile (Q1) in \rm R-H\,\alpha ( \rm R-H\,\alpha\approx 0.075 , shown as circles). \bullet Median (Median) in \rm R-H\,\alpha ( \rm R-H\,\alpha\approx 0.160 , shown as squares). \bullet Third quartile (Q3) in \rm R-H\,\alpha ( \rm R-H\,\alpha\approx 0.295 , shown as diamonds). \bullet 42.97th percentile (P42.97) in \rm R-H\,\alpha ( \rm R-H\,\alpha\approx 0.133 , shown as triangles). \bullet Unmodified location of the method of 28 (IK13) ( \rm R-H\,\alpha=0.1(V-I)+0.15 , shown as asterisks). The threshold line corresponding to the 42.97th percentile in \rm R-H\,\alpha was chosen because this results in the same number of rejected Be stars (8,594) as the unmodified method of 28 (see Section V.1 ), allowing the relationship between line profile morphology and inclination bias to be explored when the fraction of rejected Be stars and the colours are held constant but the slope is set to zero. Finally, the unmodified method of 28 contains identical values to the bottom panel of Figure 12 ). Threshold line morphology turns out to be relatively unimportant to the method of 28 (the small slope through V-I was likely chosen to avoid the inclusion of cool red giant branch objects); a two-sample KS test between the P42.97 (triangles) and IK13 (asterisks) distributions of Figure 16 (multiplied by the number of stars in the sample at each inclination) strongly accepts the null hypothesis that the two distributions come from the same underlying distribution with a p-value of 0.97. While the effect is small, the threshold line used in the method of 28 rejects slightly more low inclination objects and slightly less high inclination objects than the threshold line at the 42.97th percentile in \rm R-H\,\alpha . At high inclinations, H \alpha line profiles can feature deep absorption troughs that sometimes result in a Be star having higher \rm R-H\,\alpha magnitudes than a purely photospheric star. This effect is especially prominent above i=80^{\circ} and manifests in the Q1 distribution of Figure 16 being the most biased against high inclinations because these high \rm R-H\,\alpha magnitude Be stars represent a greater proportion of the total number of rejected stars. The effect can also be seen in Figure 15 by noting that a far higher fraction of i=90^{\circ} Be stars are dim in \rm H\alpha (i.e., have higher counts between 0.1 and 0.2 on the top row) compared to their i=10^{\circ} or i=50^{\circ} counterparts. As we move to threshold lines that reject a higher fraction of the total number of Be stars in the sample as Be star candidates, the high \rm R-H\,\alpha magnitude Be stars that are disproportionately present at high inclinations become a smaller fraction of the total number of rejected Be stars; this, coupled with low inclination Be stars having fewer objects in the tail of their \rm R-H\,\alpha distribution results in the bias becoming strongest against low inclination Be stars in the Q3 distribution of Figure 16 . Another notable feature of Figure 16 is the dip in rejected Be stars that reaches a minimum between 60^{\circ} and 70^{\circ} . This can be understood in terms of the two previously mentioned effects: unlike i=90^{\circ} Be stars, moderate inclination Be stars do not feature an excess of high \rm R-H\,\alpha objects resulting from H \alpha line profiles that feature deep absorption troughs and while there are less moderate inclination Be stars in the tail of the H \alpha distribution compared to i=90^{\circ} Be stars, there are significantly more than for low inclination Be stars. The combination of these two effects results in the dip in rejected Be stars seen at moderate inclinations. The distribution of rejected Be stars obtained by the method of 28 is intermediate between the Q1 and Median distributions. Figure 17: A plot of the fraction of all the Be stars in the sample that were rejected as Be star candidates versus inclination for five different threshold lines in \rm F656N-F814W . The threshold lines correspond to the first quartile (diamonds), median (squares), third quartile (circles), 57.81th percentile (triangles), and the unmodified results using the method of 36 (asterisks). The points have been fit with cubic splines to show the trends. Note that compared to Figure 16 , the symbol used for the first and third quartiles have been swapped to aid comparison. Figure 17 shows a plot of the fraction of all the synthetic Be stars in the sample that were rejected as Be star candidates according to the method of 36 with the modification of using four different quantiles in \rm F656N-F814W as alternative threshold lines; the fraction of synthetic Be stars rejected using the unmodified method of 36 is also included for comparison. The threshold lines occur at the: \bullet Third quartile (Q3) in \rm F656N-F814W ( \rm F656N-F814W\approx-0.261 , shown as circles). \bullet Median (Median) in \rm F656N-F814W ( \rm F656N-F814W\approx-0.344 , shown as squares). \bullet First quartile (Q1) in \rm F656N-F814W ( \rm F656N-F814W\approx-0.462 , shown as diamonds). \bullet 57.81th percentile (P57.81) in \rm F656N-F814W ( \rm F656N-F814W\approx-0.373 , shown as triangles). \bullet Unmodified location of the method of 36 (Mil18) (see Figure 13 , shown as asterisks). The positions of the first and third quartiles have been swapped to make comparisons between the two sets of histograms easier ( i.e. the first quartile in \rm R-H\,\alpha rejects the same number of profiles, 5,000 out of 20,000 or 25%, as the third quartile in \rm F656N-F814W ). The threshold line corresponding to the 57.81th percentile in \rm F656N-F814W was chosen because it results in the same number of rejected Be stars (11,562) as the unmodified method of 36 (see Section V.2 ), allowing us to explore the relationship between line profile morphology and inclination bias when the fraction of rejected Be stars and the colour are held constant. Finally, the unmodified method of 36 (containing identical values to the bottom panel of Figure 13 ) is included for comparison. While more important than for the method of 28 , threshold line morphology remains relatively unimportant to the method of 36 ; a two-sample KS test between the P57.81 (blue) and Mil18 (turqoise) distributions of Figure 17 (multiplied by the number of stars in the sample at each inclination) accepts the null hypothesis that the two distributions come from the same underlying distribution with a p-value of 0.78. The threshold line used in the method of 36 rejects more low inclination objects and less high inclination objects than the threshold line at the 57.81th percentile in \rm F656N-F814W (an effect that was also observed with the method of 28 ; see Figure 16 ). As previously noted, H \alpha line profiles can feature deep absorption troughs at high inclinations that sometimes result in a Be star having higher \rm F656N-F814W magnitudes (dimmer in \rm H\alpha ) than a purely photospheric star. This effect manifests in the Q3 distribution of Figure 17 being the most biased against i=90^{\circ} Be stars and can also be seen in Figure 15 by noting that a far higher fraction of i=90^{\circ} Be stars are dim in H \alpha (with higher counts between -0.2 and -0.1 on the bottom row) compared to their i=10^{\circ} or i=50^{\circ} counterparts. Bias against low inclinations as the proportion of rejected Be stars increases is driven by the relative lack of Be stars in the (bright in H \alpha ) tail of their \rm F656N-F814W distribution (see the bottom row of Figure 15 ). This bias against low inclination angles is seen most clearly in the Q1 distribution of Figure 17 . There is a dip in the fraction of rejected Be stars that reaches a minimum between between 60^{\circ} and 70^{\circ} . This occurs because, unlike high inclination Be stars, these moderate inclination Be stars do not contain high \rm F656N-F814W values (dim in H \alpha ) resulting from H \alpha line profiles that feature deep absorption troughs while also containing more Be stars in the bright in H \alpha tail of their \rm F656N-F814W distribution compared to lower inclination Be stars. The distribution of rejected Be stars obtained by the method of 36 is intermediate between the Median and Q1 distributions. Comparing the biases produced by photometric methods based on \rm R-H\,\alpha (Figure 16 ) with those based on \rm F656N-F814W (Figure 17 ), the former is more biased against very high inclination Be stars when the proportion of Be stars in the sample rejected as Be star candidates is low (compare Q1 in Figure 16 to Q3 in Figure 17 ). Conversely, there is a stronger bias produced by photometric methods based on \rm F656N-F814W than by those based on \rm R-H\,\alpha against low inclinations when the proportion of rejected Be stars is high (compare Q3 in Figure 16 to Q1 in Figure 17 ). Both effects occur because the \rm F656N-F814W distribution has a heavier, bright in H \alpha , tail than the \rm R-H\,\alpha distribution (compare the top and bottom rows of Figure 15 and the kurtosis column of Table 3 ). Figure 18: The inclination biases of the methods of 28 and 36 determined on the sample of synthetic Be star spectra expressed as both probability density functions (top panel) and cumulative distribution functions (bottom panel). In both panels, the inclination bias of the method of 28 (IK13) is shown as a solid line, the inclination bias of the method of 36 (Mil18) is shown as a dashed line, and the \sin{i} probability distribution is shown as a dotted line for comparison. Figure 18 shows the observational inclination biases of the methods of both 28 and 36 expressed as probability density functions (top panel) and cumulative distribution functions (bottom panel). These pdfs were created in the same manner as Figure 11 using Eq. ( 10 ). Compared to the \sin{i} distribution, the methods of both 28 and 36 are biased against low ( i<50^{\circ} ) inclination Be stars, the latter significantly more so than the former. Both methods result in an excess of Be stars as Be star candidates at moderate inclinations ( 50^{\circ}80^{\circ} ). The photometric methods were both biased against low inclinations and one of the photometric methods was also biased against inclinations above 80^{\circ} , resulting in a surplus in the detection rate of moderate inclination ( 50^{\circ}