The quenched structured coalescent for diploid population models on finite graphs with large migrations and uneven offspring distributions Maximillian Newman Abstract In this work we describe a new model for the evolution of a diploid structured population backwards in time that allows for large migrations and uneven offspring distributions. The model generalizes both the mean-field model of Birkner et al. [ Electron. J. Probab. 23: 1-44 (2018)] and the haploid structured model of Möhle [ Theor. Popul. Biol. 2024 Apr:156:103-116]. We show convergence, with mild conditions on the joint distribution of offspring frequencies and migrations, of gene genealogies conditional on the pedigree to a time-inhomogeneous coalescent process driven by a Poisson point process Ψ \Psi that records the timing and scale of large migrations and uneven offspring distributions. This quenched scaling limit demonstrates a significant difference in the predictions of the classical annealed theory of structured coalescent processes. In particular, the annealed and quenched scaling limits coincide if and only if these large migrations and uneven offspring distributions are absent. The proof proceeds by the method of moments and utilizes coupling techniques from the theory of random walks in random environments. Several examples are given and their quenched scaling limits established. 1 Introduction Consider a sample of n copies of a gene from n distinct individuals in a population. These samples, the result of generations of genetic inheritance backwards in time, trace their roots back to a common ancestor. The structure of how these genes trace their roots backwards in time is called the gene genealogy and is the central object of interest in coalescent theory. The seminal work of Kingman 20 ; 21 established, marginally, at each place in the genome of a well-mixed population of constant, large size undergoing neutral evolution, that gene genealogies take the structure of a binary tree, where the binary mergers occur uniformly at random among each possible pair of extant lineages and each with the same rate. This tree structure, now known as the Kingman coalescent, is the fundamental universality class of coalescent theory, arising in one way or another in a slew of population models. Following Kingman’s work, several now-classical works in coalescent theory 26 ; 29 ; 30 have described all possible scaling limits of genealogies in well-mixed population models as \Xi -coalescent processes, a class of trees that admit simultaneous multiple mergers. While extremely powerful as a tool in population genetics 32 ; 28 , and with rich mathematical ties to statistical physics, interacting particle systems, diffusion processes, and beyond 8 ; 3 ; 4 , the scaling limits of the classical theory implicitly describe the average genealogy at a locus. In reality, every locus in the genome shares the same history of reproductive relationships, modeled by a random graph called the pedigree. Genealogies at every place in the genome are correlated through the random structure of this pedigree. The correct starting point for the coalescent, if we wish to understand the distribution of gene genealogies across the genome, is to understand the law of the coalescent conditional on the pedigree. We refer to this conditional law as the law of the quenched coalescent . Beginning with the non-rigorous works 33 ; 34 ; 36 , pedigree effects were observed in the recent past and in structured populations. This includes significant differences in the site-frequency spectrum and distribution of pairwise coalescence times (see ( 36 , Figure 3) , for example.) Recently, mathematically rigorous scaling limits have begun to emerge from quenched coalescent theory that are quite distinct from those of the classical theory. 31 established the first result for quenched coalescents, showing that in a well-mixed population in the absence of uneven offspring distributions, gene genealogies of unlinked loci really are independent in the large population limit. However, the works 10 ; 1 then showed the effects of uneven offspring distributions in the absence of selfing on gene genealogies. The pedigree leaves a persistent imprint on the dynamics of these gene genealogies through prodigious progenitors, individuals whose genetic contributions are shared across the genome. The limiting quenched genealogy becomes time inhomogeneous, evolving with an ordinary Kingman-like background punctuated by rare generations in which prodigious individuals contribute a non-vanishing proportion of the genetic material of the population even in the infinite population limit. Under the same assumptions of 7 that yield an annealed multiple merger coalescent, the quenched coalescent converges to a process that is driven by a Poisson point process recording the timing and structure of exceptional reproductive generations of the pedigree. Between exceptional generations, lineages merge only in binary mergers at a constant rate. At exceptional generations, many lineages may merge simultaneously, with the merger pattern determined by the ordered offspring frequencies. This identifies the precise sense in which widely separated loci are coupled; they share the same record of macrosopic pedigree events, these prodigious progenitors. This Poisson driven viewpoint is closely related to the limiting object in the present paper. While well-mixed populations are a natural starting point for coalescent analysis, many real population exhibit population structure. They are subdivided into demes connected by migration. In such settings, ancestral lineages carry locations and move between demes backward in time according to some migration mechanism. Coalescence can occur only when lineages occupy the same deme, with rates governed by deme sizes. This yields the structured coalescent 35 ; 25 , which has become the baseline approximation for inference in spatially distributed data and metapopulations 24 ; 17 . Recent literature has characterized multi-type \Lambda - and \Xi -coalescents as the most general universality classes of structured populations. These are models in which genealogies are subject to migrations that move them between types and where, within each type, the genealogies look like \Xi -coalescents. 11 proved convergence of a Moran model with large offspring numbers to a multi-type \Lambda -coalescent. 18 classifies exchangeable, consistent, and asynchronous multi-type coalescent processes as multi-type \Lambda -coalescents where mergers and migrations do not occur simultaneously. 23 analyzes multi-type Cannings models with conservative migration, demonstrating convergence to more general multi-type exchangeable coalescents that can admit simultaneous multiple mergers. In 27 , they study a structured population undergoing bottlenecks, proving that the limiting annealed genealogies are multi-type \Xi -coalescents characterized by simultaneous multiple mergers and migrations. Much like the well-mixed case, the standard structured coalescent describes an averaged single locus genealogy. It does not condition on the single realized history of the pedigree. In structured populations this distinction becomes especially natural. Large migration waves can occur on the same time scale as coalescence and can affect many lineages at once. Such events are recorded in the pedigree and are shared across loci. They therefore create an additional source of time inhomogeneity and cross locus dependence that is invisible to purely annealed descriptions. 36 provided simulation results that demonstrated the importance of the pedigree in structured populations, where deviations from standard coalescent predictions can persist longer than in well-mixed populations due to the specific history of migration events captured by the pedigree. 1.1 The contributions of this paper This work develops a quenched coalescent theory for a diploid structured population modeled on an arbitrary finite directed graph G=\left(V,E\right) . Each vertex v in V represents a deme of the population and it is kept a constant size of \lfloor s(v)N\rfloor backwards in time, where N is a population size parameter we will send to infinity. Each generation draws a random proportion m_{(v,w)} of the population at deme v to travel to deme w . The total population at each deme v then coalesces according to some exchangeable, within each deme, offspring distribution \mathcal{V}^{v} in a manner similar to 7 ; 1 . This model differs from those of 23 ; 27 by allowing migrations to be arbitrarily large and non-conservative in the sense of 22 , encoding diploidy, and allowing generic offspring frequencies, including not-necessarily independent offspring frequencies across demes, simultaneously. This model includes the models of 7 ; 1 as special subcases, and generalizes the model of 23 to diploid populations and random migration sizes at each time-step. We denote the ordered offspring frequencies in each deme v by \widetilde{\mathcal{V}}^{v} , and the collection of these over all demes by \widetilde{\mathcal{V}}=\left(\widetilde{\mathcal{V}}^{v}\right)_{v\in V} . We show that as long as large migrations and uneven offspring distributions are suitably rare, described by the limiting joint distribution of \left(\widetilde{\mathcal{V}},m\right) satisfying some local integrability condition, the law of the coalescent conditional on the pedigree converges in distribution to a random measure governing a time inhomogeneous structured coalescent. More precisely, there is some “neutral” migration rate \mu_{e} along every edge e of E , and some “neutral” coalescence rate \kappa_{v} within each deme v so that any block of the coalescent in deme v moves independently of all the other blocks to deme w at rate \mu_{v,w} , and any pair of blocks in deme v coalesce independently of any of the other pairs of blocks at rate \kappa_{v} . At exceptional generations, governed by a Poisson point process \Psi , the coalescent jumps according to a paintbox construction, generalizing the Kingman x -paintbox described, for example, in 2 . The limiting conditional gene genealogy is described by the law of a coalescent following the neutral migration and coalescence rates, jumping according to a paintbox construction at atoms of \Psi , all conditional on \Psi . This model is a natural extension of the limiting model of 1 , where there are no migration rates and where our \kappa_{v} for the single deme in their model corresponds to their c_{\text{pair}} . The proof proceeds by the method of moments. By a theorem of 15 , it is enough to prove that, as random variables, the finite-dimensional distributions of the coalescent conditional on the pedigree converge in distribution to those of the limiting quenched process. Since these conditional finite-dimensional distributions are uniformly bounded random variables, we can show convergence by showing all moments of these conditional finite-dimensional distributions converge. It will suffice to show that for l realizations of the coalescent conditionally independent with respect to the pedigree that the joint law converges to the same joint law as for l realizations of the time-inhomogeneous coalescent conditionally independent with respect to \Psi . The biological interpretation of the method is then as follows: the distribution of gene genealogies across unlinked loci converges in distribution to a given (random) law if and only if the annealed distribution of gene genealogies across l unlinked loci converges to that of the annealed distribution of that given law across l unlinked loci for any finite number of l unlinked loci. We control these joint laws by constructing a coupling of the l conditionally independent copies on the same pedigree, in the same spirit as 1 , who built on earlier work of 9 ; 6 . The coupling makes transparent the two mechanisms that drive the limit. Firstly, genuinely large pedigree events that change the coalescent state, such as macroscopic migration waves or unusually large families, are rare on the coalescent time scale. However, they affect all copies in nearly the same way. In particular, the different copies jump to corresponding new states with asymptotically matching probabilities. Second, during the overwhelming majority of small generations, the copies experience the “neutral” migration patterns described above, and their jump decisions become asymptotically independent across copies. This approximate independence follows from straightforward moment bounds. These two observations form the basis for a “separation of scales” argument in which we bridge these two regimes to demonstrate the desired convergence of the joint law. We note here that there is an implicit separation of scales argument in the \varepsilon -naive-coalescent of 1 , though the total form of the argument is distinct. 1.2 Organization of the paper The paper is organized into sections as follows. We begin in Section 2 by introducing a diploid bi-parental population model for a finite structured population with size scaling with a parameter N . This population model gives rise to a random graph \mathcal{G}_{N} , called the pedigree, that tracks the total history of reproductive relationships in the population. We proceed then to describe how the ancestral process, which tracks how a sample of size n traces its genetic inheritance in the population backwards in time, is determined by the structure of a family of coalescing random walks on \mathcal{G}_{N}\times\{0,1\} . The law of this ancestral process, conditional on the pedigree, is the central object of focus in this work. In Section 3 we describe the annealed limit of the ancestral process. It is here that we outline the essential assumptions necessary for our main theorem to hold. This annealed result follows as a corollary of the main result and its proof is contained in Section B . In Section 4 we describe the limit of the law of the ancestral process conditional on the pedigree. There is a Poisson point process \Psi that governs the joint distribution of offspring frequencies and migration proportions between generations and a coalescent process \chi^{n} driven by \Psi as follows: Between atoms of \Psi the ancestral process evolves as in the classical structured coalescent. That is, lineages move independently along an edge at a given rate \mu_{e} and pairs of lineages in the same deme v coalesce at a given rate \kappa_{v} . At the atoms of \Psi , the transition matrix for the ancestral process is described by means of a paintbox construction, akin to that of the Kingman paintbox 2 . This paintbox corresponds, in the finite population model, to the existence of migrations on the order of the size of the total population or to prodigious progenitors who contribute a positive proportion of the total populations genetic information. The limiting quenched law is then the law of \chi^{n} conditional on \Psi . Because \Psi may in general have infinitely many atoms, we rigorously construct a pathwise description of the time-inhomogeneous coalescent built on \Psi in Section 7 . In Section 5 we outline the proof of the main result. This consists of a series of lemmas making the method of moments and separation of scales argument rigorous. The proofs of these lemmas are largely postponed to Section 8 . Therein we rigorously describe how to couple l realizations of the discrete-time ancestral process on the same pedigree, why the small-scale behavior of our model looks like the classical structured coalescent picture, and why the large-scale behavior of our model affects all of the l realizations in, asymptotically, the same manner. It also contains a separation of timescales argument that allows us to simplify the state space of our coupling. In Section 6 we demonstrate convergence of the conditional gene genealogies for several examples discrete-time population models of interest. The examples include a two deme Wright-Fisher model with neutral migration analogous to the model of 36 , a two deme model analogous to that of 10 , a model converging to a beta coalescent with beta distributed migrations, and what we call a discrete approximation of a spatial \Xi Fleming-Viot genealogies on the 2 -torus. In Section 9 , we contrast our results with the work in 36 and provide a possible way to harmonize our paper and theirs. We then quickly describe some opportunities for future work. 2 A diploid structured population model with migration and its coalescent In Section 2.1 we construct a diploid structured population with large migrations and uneven offspring distributions on a generic finite directed graph. We proceed to describe the pedigree and the corresponding ancestral process generated by this model in Section 2.2 . 2.1 A diploid structured population with large migrations and uneven offspring distributions Let G=\left(V,E\right) denote a finite directed graph. The vertices shall correspond to population demes and the directed edges E will correspond to migration routes between demes. To each vertex v in V we assign a relative size s(v)\in(0,\infty) . Each deme v will be kept a constant size N(v)=\lfloor s(v)N\rfloor . Let V_{N} denote the vertex set \{(v,i):v\in V,i\in[N(v)]\}, where [k]=\{1,2,\ldots,k\} for any natural number k . The population model will be governed by the joint distribution of a sample of a V -tuple of random symmetric matrices \mathcal{V}=\left(\mathcal{V}^{v}\right)_{v\in V}=\left(\left(\mathcal{V}_{i,j}^{v}\right)_{i,j=1}^{N(v)}\right)_{v\in V} and a random variable m=\left(m_{e}\right) taking values in [0,1]^{E} . m denotes the migration sizes between demes and \mathcal{V} denotes the offspring numbers of couples in each deme. We assume the following: • Both V and E are finite. • There are no edges from a deme to itself, i.e. for all v in V the edge (v,v) is not an element of E . • The entries of \mathcal{V} are all non-negative integers. • The total number of migrants from each deme cannot exceed the population of that deme, i.e. \sum_{e=(v,w)\in E}m_{e}\leq 1 for every deme v . • We exclude selfing, i.e. \mathcal{V}_{i,i}^{v}=0 for all v\in V and i in [N(v)] . • The total number of offspring in each deme v satisfies \sum_{i0 . When we restrict ourselves to small enough offspring distributions and migrations, i.e. when (\widetilde{\mathcal{V}}(k),m(k))\in B(\varepsilon) , the jumps of each of the \overline{\chi}_{i}^{N,n} are approximately independent. This is made precise by the following lemma. Lemma 5.2 . Suppose, as N\to\infty , that Assumptions 3.3 , 3.7 , and 3.12 hold. Let R be the infinitesimal generator of l joint, independent (0,\kappa,\mu) - n -coalescents, viewed as an \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}\times\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} rate matrix. Let A_{N}:=e^{c_{N}^{v_{0}}R} . Then there is a continuous function f:\mathbb{R}_{+}\to\mathbb{R}_{+} such that f(0)=0 and \left|\left|P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l}-A_{N}\right|\right|_{\infty}\leq f(\varepsilon)c_{N}^{v_{0}}\text{\hskip 10.22217ptfor any $\epsilon>0$}, where P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l} is the one-step transition matrix \left(\mathbb{P}\left(\left(cd_{V}\left(\chi_{i}^{N,n}(1)\right)\right)_{i=1}^{l}=\vec{\eta}\,\mid\,\left(\chi_{i}^{N,n}(0)\right)_{i=1}^{l}=\vec{\xi},(\widetilde{\mathcal{V}}(0),m(0))\in B(\varepsilon)\right)\right)_{\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}}. Lemma 5.2 is proven in Section 8.3 . At the same time, when we restrict ourselves to the rare jumps where (\widetilde{\mathcal{V}}(k),m(k))\in B(\varepsilon)^{c} we have that the transitions of the conditionally independent realizations are really asymptotically independent. Lemma 5.3 . Suppose, as N\to\infty , that Assumptions 3.2 , 3.3 , and 3.4 hold. Define the transition probability matrix H_{N,l}:\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}\to[0,1]^{\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}\times\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}} by H_{N,l}(x,m):=\left(\mathbb{P}\left(\left(cd_{V}\left(\overline{\chi}_{i}^{N,n}(k+1)\right)\right)_{i=1}^{l}=\vec{\eta}\,\mid\,\left(\overline{\chi}_{i}^{N,n}(k)\right)_{i=1}^{l}=\vec{\xi},(\widetilde{\mathcal{V}}(k),m(k))=(x,m)\right)\right)_{\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}}. Define the transition matrix H_{l}:\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}\to[0,1]^{\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}\times\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}} by H_{l}(x,m):=\left(\prod_{i=1}^{l}q_{n}(x,m)(\xi_{i},\eta_{i})\right)_{\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}}. Then for every \varepsilon>0 , \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int_{B(\varepsilon)^{c}}\left|H_{N,l}(x,m)-H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)\right|_{\infty}\,d\Phi_{N}(x,m)\to 0 as N goes to infinity. Lemma 5.3 is proven in Section 8.4 . Remark 5.4 . Here we use a truncation argument to bound the total proportion of migrants from any deme away from 1 using Assumption 3.12 . We believe this truncation argument may be improced to remove this assumption, though this is not undertaken in the present work. Combining the two scales of Lemma 5.2 and Lemma 5.3 allows us to conclude that the transition kernel of the joint process \left(\overline{\chi}_{i}^{N,n}\right)_{i=1}^{m} is arbitrarily close to that of a Markov process with infinitesimal generator \mathcal{L}:=R+\int(H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)-I)d\Phi(x,m), (5.3) which is the meaning of the following lemma. Lemma 5.5 . Suppose, as N\to\infty , that Assumptions 3.2 , 3.3 , 3.4 , 3.7 , and 3.12 hold. Let P_{N,l}(t) denote the transition kernel of \left(cd_{V}\left(\overline{\chi}_{i}^{N,n}\right)\right)_{i=1}^{l} at time t . Then, for any fixed T>0 , there is a continuous function g_{T}:\mathbb{R}_{+}\to\mathbb{R}_{+} with g(0)=0 such that \sup_{0\leq t\leq T}\left|\left|P_{N,l}(t)-\exp\left(t\mathcal{L}\right)\right|\right|_{\infty}\leq g_{T}(\varepsilon) (5.4) Lemma 5.5 is proven in Section 8.5 . Finally, we characterize the annealed joint law of l realizations \left(\chi_{i}^{n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} of a \Psi -driven n - (\kappa,\mu) -coalescent \chi^{n} that are conditionally independent with respect to \Psi . We show that \left(\chi_{i}^{n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} has infinitesimal generator \mathcal{L} Lemma 5.6 . Suppose \Phi satisfies the regularity condition of Assumption 3.10 . Then \left(\chi_{i}^{n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} , as a \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} -valued Markov process, has infinitesimal generator \mathcal{L} . Lemma 5.6 is proven in Section 7 . With the above lemmas, we are now able to present the proof of Theorem 4.3 . Proof. By Lemma 5.1 it suffices to show that, for any l in \mathbb{N} that \lim_{N\to\infty}\mathbb{P}\left(\left(cd_{V}\left(\overline{\chi}_{i}^{N,n}\right)\right)_{i=1}^{l}\in C(\vec{t},\vec{\xi})^{l}\right)=\mathbb{P}\left(\left(\chi_{i}^{n}\right)_{i=1}^{l}\in C(\vec{t},\vec{\xi})^{l}\right), where C(\vec{t},\vec{\xi}) is the cylinder set of Equation ( 5.2 ) and \chi_{i}^{N} and \overline{\chi}_{i}^{N,n} are as in the statement of the lemma. By Lemma 5.6 , the annealed joint process \left(\chi_{i}^{n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} has infinitesimal generator \mathcal{L} . As \left(\chi_{i}^{n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} has infinitesimal generator \mathcal{L} we know it has transition kernel P_{l}(t):=\exp(t\mathcal{L}) . Under Assumptions 3.2 , 3.3 , 3.4 , and 3.7 , we have that Lemma 5.5 holds. As the transition kernel P_{N,l}(t) of \left(cd_{V}\left(\overline{\chi}_{i}^{N,n}\right)\right)_{i=1}^{l} satisfies Equation ( 5.4 ) it follows that P_{N,l} converges uniformly on any compact interval to P_{l} by taking N to infinity and then \varepsilon to zero. This, and convergence of the initial condition given by Assumption 3.1 is enough to demonstrate convergence in finite-dimensional distribution, as was needed. ∎ 6 Examples In this section, we provide various examples of models of interest. These include a two-deme Wright-Fisher model with neutral migration in Section 6.1 , a two-deme modified Wright-Fisher model with large offspring numbers in Section 6.2 , a two-deme model with random individual fitness and beta-distributed migrations in Section 6.3 , and what we call a discrete approximation of a \Xi Fleming-Viot genealogy in Section 6.4 . The single deme case is described in some detail in ( 1 , Section 7) . 6.1 A two-deme Wright-Fisher model with neutral migration We describe here the discrete-time model of 36 , which is a two deme Wright-Fisher model with conservative neutral migration. Concretely, we take V=\{1,2\},\qquad E=\{(1,2),(2,1)\},\qquad s(1)=s(2)=1, and we sample the conservative migration sizes m_{(1,2)}=m_{(2,1)}\sim\frac{1}{N}\text{\emph{Binomial}}\left(N;\frac{\sigma}{2}\right) for some fixed \sigma>0 . Since migration is conservative, at each time-step we have exactly N diploid individuals in each deme reproduce. Conditional on m , reproduction within each deme is Wright-Fisher with uniform weights and no selfing, and reproduction across demes is independent. Equivalently, (\mathcal{V}^{v})_{v\in V}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle d}}{{=}}\text{\emph{Multinomial}}\left(N;\frac{2}{N(N-1)},\ldots,\frac{2}{N(N-1)}\right)^{\otimes 2}. Convergence of this model is established by the following proposition. Proposition 6.1 . Let \overline{\chi}^{N,n} and \mathcal{G}_{N} denote the ancestral process and pedigree associated to a two-deme Wright-Fisher model with neutral migration. Let \kappa=\left(1,1\right) and \mu_{(1,2)}=\mu_{(2,1)}=\mu . Suppose that, as N goes to infinity, that Assumption 3.1 holds. Then \mathbb{P}\left(\overline{\chi}^{N,n}\in\cdot\,\mid\,\mathcal{A}_{N}\right) converges weakly in distribution to the law of a (0,\kappa,\mu) - n -coalescent. Proof. Under this model the pair-coalescence scale is the usual Wright-Fisher scale: for every v\in V and every N , c_{N}^{v}=\frac{1}{2N}. In particular, Assumptions 3.2 and 3.3 hold. Moreover, since Nm_{e} is binomially distributed with N trials and success probability \frac{\sigma}{2} and c_{N}^{v}=1/(2N) , a direct calculation yields \bar{\mu}_{e}=\sigma for every e\in E , so Assumption 3.7 holds as well. Finally, because reproduction within each deme is Wright-Fisher and is independent across demes, ( 7 , Proposition 2.1) and Corollary A.3 imply that \frac{1}{c_{N}^{1}}\Phi_{N} converges vaguely on \Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E} to \Phi\;=\;0^{\otimes 2}\otimes\delta_{0}^{\otimes 2}. Therefore the main assumptions necessary for Theorem 4.3 hold. Since \Phi charges no sets bounded away from \mathbf{0}_{V,E} , the limiting driving point process \Psi has no atoms. Consequently the quenched and annealed laws coincide in this example. ∎ In Section 9 we discuss implications of Proposition 6.1 to the work of 36 . 6.2 A two-deme modified Wright-Fisher model with large offspring numbers Here we discuss a two-deme analogue of the model of 10 . We take V=\{1,2\},\qquad E=\{(1,2),(2,1)\},\qquad s(1)=s(2)=1, so that each deme has size N(1)=N(2)=N . We assume that reproduction dynamics in the two demes are independent conditional on m . Fix parameters \sigma>0 , \phi>0 , \psi\in(0,1) , and \gamma>0 . Write N_{\gamma}:=N\wedge N^{\gamma} and sample the migrations by m_{(1,2)}=m_{(2,1)}\sim\frac{1}{N_{\gamma}}\text{\emph{Binomial}}\left(N;\frac{N_{\gamma}}{N}\frac{\sigma}{2}\right) This migration is conservative, so N^{*}(1)=N^{*}(2)=N for every time-step. We now describe the offspring matrices in a single deme v\in\{1,2\} . Let \varepsilon_{N}:=2\phi/N^{\gamma} . Conditional on m , we first sample a Bernoulli variable B^{v} with \mathbb{P}\{B^{v}=1\}=\varepsilon_{N}. If B^{v}=0 (a “small” generation), the deme reproduces by Wright-Fisher dynamics, i.e. we have (\mathcal{V}^{v})_{v\in V}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle d}}{{=}}\text{\emph{Multinomial}}\left(N;\frac{2}{N(N-1)},\ldots,\frac{2}{N(N-1)}\right)^{\otimes 2} If B^{v}=1 (a “large” generation), we sample an unordered pair \{I^{v},J^{v}\}\subset[N] uniformly at random and set \mathcal{V}^{v}_{I^{v},J^{v}}=\lfloor\psi N\rfloor. The remaining N-\lfloor\psi N\rfloor individuals in the deme choose parental couples uniformly at random from the \binom{N}{2}-1 remaining possible couples, i.e. reproduce via Wright-Fisher. We define the necessary elements of the scaling limit of this model as follows: Set x_{\psi}:=\left(\frac{\psi}{4},\frac{\psi}{4},\frac{\psi}{4},\frac{\psi}{4},0,0,\ldots\right)\in\Delta, and define x^{(1)},x^{(2)}\in\Delta^{V} by x^{(1),1}=x_{\psi},\quad x^{(1),2}=\mathbf{0},\qquad x^{(2),1}=\mathbf{0},\quad x^{(2),2}=x_{\psi}. Then \Phi_{\gamma}:=\lambda_{\gamma}\left(\delta_{\left(x^{(1)},0_{E}\right)}+\delta_{\left(x^{(2)},0_{E}\right)}\right),\qquad\lambda_{\gamma}:=\begin{cases}0,&\gamma>1,\\ \dfrac{4\phi}{1+\phi\psi^{2}},&\gamma=1,\\ \dfrac{4}{\psi^{2}},&0<\gamma<1,\end{cases} and the Kingman and migration parameters are \kappa_{\gamma}:=\begin{cases}\left(1,1\right),&\gamma>1,\\ \left(\dfrac{1}{1+\phi\psi^{2}},\dfrac{1}{1+\phi\psi^{2}}\right),&\gamma=1,\\ \left(0,0\right),&0<\gamma<1,\end{cases}\qquad\mu_{\gamma,(1,2)}=\mu_{\gamma,(2,1)}:=\begin{cases}\mu,&\gamma>1,\\ \dfrac{\mu}{1+\phi\psi^{2}},&\gamma=1,\\ 0,&0<\gamma<1.\end{cases} Write \mu_{\gamma}=\left(\mu_{\gamma,e}\right)_{e\in E} . Convergence of this model is established by the following proposition. Proposition 6.2 . Let \overline{\chi}^{N,n} and \mathcal{G}_{N} denote the ancestral process and pedigree of a two-deme Wright-Fisher model with large offspring numbers. Let \chi^{n} denote a \Psi_{\gamma} driven (\kappa_{\gamma},\mu_{\gamma}) - n coalescent, where \Psi_{\gamma} has intensity measure dt\otimes(h_{V})_{*}\Phi_{\gamma} . Suppose that, as N goes to infinity, that Assumption 3.1 holds. Then \mathbb{P}\left(cd_{V}\left(\overline{\chi}^{N,n}\right)\in\cdot\,\mid\,\mathcal{A}_{N}\right)\,{\mathrel{\mathop{\kern 0.0pt\longrightarrow}\limits^{{d}}}}\,\mathbb{P}\left(\chi^{n}\in\cdot\,\mid\,\Psi_{\gamma}\right). Proof. Note by symmetry that c_{N}^{1}=c_{N}^{2}=:c_{N} . By conditioning on B^{v}\in\{0,1\} we can compute c_{N} from c_{N}=\frac{1}{8}\,\mathbb{E}\left[\frac{\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}\left(\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}-1\right)}{N-1}\right]=\frac{1}{8}\left((1-\varepsilon_{N})\mathbb{E}\left[\frac{\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}\left(\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}-1\right)}{N-1}\,\,\mid\,\,B^{v}=0\right]+\varepsilon_{N}\mathbb{E}\left[\frac{\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}\left(\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}-1\right)}{N-1}\,\,\mid\,\,B^{v}=1\right]\right). In a small generation B^{v}=0 , each of the N offspring chooses an unordered parental couple uniformly, so \mathbb{P}\{1\in\{I,J\}\}=2/N and hence \mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}\mid\{B^{v}=0\}\sim\mathrm{Bin}\left(N,2/N\right) . Therefore \mathbb{E}\left[\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}\left(\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}-1\right)\,\,\mid\,\,B^{v}=0\right]=N\left(N-1\right)\left(\frac{2}{N}\right)^{2}=\frac{4\left(N-1\right)}{N}, and consequently \frac{1}{8}\mathbb{E}\left[\frac{\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}\left(\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}-1\right)}{N-1}\,\,\mid\,\,B^{v}=0\right]=\frac{1}{2N}. (6.1) In a large generation B^{v}=1 , we have \mathbb{P}\{1\in\{I^{v},J^{v}\}\}=2/N and, on this event, individual 1 is a parent of \lfloor\psi N\rfloor offspring, so \mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}=\lfloor\psi N\rfloor+O_{\mathbb{P}}(1) and hence \mathbb{E}\left[\frac{\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}\left(\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}-1\right)}{N-1}\,\,\mid\,\,B^{v}=1,\;1\in\{I^{v},J^{v}\}\right]=\psi^{2}N+O(1). On the complementary event \{1\notin\{I^{v},J^{v}\}\} , we still have \mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}=O_{\mathbb{P}}(1) , and so the same quantity is O\left(1/N\right) . Putting this together yields \frac{1}{8}\mathbb{E}\left[\frac{\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}\left(\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}-1\right)}{N-1}\,\,\mid\,\,B^{v}=1\right]=\frac{\psi^{2}}{4}+O\left(\frac{1}{N}\right). (6.2) Combining equations ( 6.1 ) and ( 6.2 ) with \varepsilon_{N}=2\phi/N^{\gamma} , we obtain the sharper asymptotic c_{N}=\frac{1}{2N}+\frac{\phi\psi^{2}}{2N^{\gamma}}+o\left(\frac{1}{N^{\gamma}}\right). (6.3) In particular c_{N}\to 0 , and Assumptions 3.2 and 3.3 hold. By a direct computation one obtains \mu_{\gamma,(1,2)}=\mu_{\gamma,(2,1)} as stated in the proposition. Hence Assumption 3.7 holds. It remains to identify the vague limit in Assumption 3.4 . In a small generation, \widetilde{\mathcal{V}}^{v} is Wright-Fisher reproduction, so its contribution vanishes on \Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}\setminus\{\mathbf{0}_{V,E}\} by ( 7 , Proposition 2.1) . In a large generation in deme v , the \lfloor\psi N\rfloor offspring of the prolific couple inherit, at a fixed locus, one of the two parental copies from each of the two parents independently; thus the four parental copies each contribute \mathrm{Bin}\left(\lfloor\psi N\rfloor,1/2\right) gametes, and after normalisation by 2N this yields the limit x_{\psi} in \Delta . Since large generations occur with probability \varepsilon_{N} independently in the two demes, the event of simultaneous large generations has probability \varepsilon_{N}^{2}=o(c_{N}) , and does not contribute in the 1/c_{N} scaling. Consequently, \frac{1}{c_{N}}\Phi_{N}\;\to\;\lambda_{\gamma}\left(\delta_{\left(x^{(1)},0_{E}\right)}+\delta_{\left(x^{(2)},0_{E}\right)}\right)\qquad\text{vaguely on }\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}\setminus\{\mathbf{0}_{V,E}\}, with \lambda_{\gamma}=\lim_{N\to\infty}\varepsilon_{N}/c_{N} given by ( 6.3 ). This is exactly Assumption 3.4 with \Phi=\Phi_{\gamma} . All hypotheses of Theorem 4.3 are therefore satisfied, and the stated quenched convergence follows. ∎ 6.3 A two-deme model with random individual fitness and large migrations We extend the model with random individual fitness from 7 to a two deme model. We take V=\{1,2\} , E=\{(1,2),(2,1)\} , and s(1)=s(2)=1 . We will take migration to be conservative, and will describe the precise migration patters of the model after we introduce the random fitness reproduction mechanism. We now specify the joint law of the offspring matrices and the migration proportions in each generation. Fix \alpha\in(1,2) , and let W be a nonnegative random variable with \mathbb{P}\left(W\geq z\right)\sim c_{W}z^{-\alpha}\qquad\text{as }z\to\infty for some constant c_{W}\in(0,\infty) , and with \mathbb{E}\left[W\right]>0 . Let \left(W_{i}^{v}\right)_{i=1}^{N} be independent copies of W that are also independent across demes. Define Z_{N}^{v}:=\sum_{i,j=1}^{N}W_{i}^{v}W_{j}^{v}=\frac{1}{2}\left(\sum_{i=1}^{N}W_{i}^{v}\right)^{2}-\frac{1}{2}\sum_{i=1}^{N}(W_{i}^{v})^{2}. Given \left(W_{i}^{v}\right)_{i=1}^{N} , we let (\mathcal{V}^{v})_{v\in V}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle d}}{{=}}\text{\emph{Multinomial}}\left(N;\frac{W_{1}^{v}W_{2}^{v}}{Z_{N}^{v}},\frac{W_{2}^{v}W_{3}^{v}}{Z_{N}^{v}},\ldots\frac{W_{N-1}^{v}W_{N}^{v}}{Z_{N}^{v}}\right)^{\otimes 2} We describe now the conservative migration patterns of the model. Fix parameters a,b>0 . We let m_{(1,2)}=m_{(2,1)}=m and sample m as m\sim\begin{cases}\delta_{0}&,\text{ with probability }1-N^{1-\alpha}c_{W}\left(\frac{2}{\mathbb{E}[W]}\right)^{\alpha}\alpha\frac{\Gamma(2-\alpha)\Gamma(\alpha)}{8}\\ \text{\emph{Beta}}(a,b)&,\text{ otherwise.}\end{cases} We define now the relevant limiting objects of this model as follows: Define \displaystyle c_{\alpha} \displaystyle:=c_{W}\left(\frac{2}{\mathbb{E}[W]}\right)^{\alpha}\alpha\,\frac{\Gamma(2-\alpha)\Gamma(\alpha)}{8}, \displaystyle\kappa \displaystyle:=\left(0,0\right),\text{ and } \displaystyle\mu_{(1,2)}=\mu_{(2,1)} \displaystyle:=0. Define, for y\in(0,1) , x_{y}:=\left(\frac{y}{2},\frac{y}{2},0,0,\ldots\right)\in\Delta,\qquad x_{y}^{(1),1}=x_{y},\;x_{y}^{(1),2}=\mathbf{0},\qquad x_{y}^{(2),1}=\mathbf{0},\;x_{y}^{(2),2}=x_{y}. Let \Lambda_{\alpha} denote the \mathrm{Beta}(2-\alpha,\alpha) probability measure on (0,1) , i.e. \Lambda_{\alpha}(dy)=\frac{1}{\Gamma(2-\alpha)\Gamma(\alpha)}\,y^{1-\alpha}(1-y)^{\alpha-1}\,dy,\qquad\nu_{\alpha}(dy):=\frac{\Lambda_{\alpha}(dy)}{y^{2}}. Then we set \Phi=\Phi^{\mathrm{fit}}+\Phi^{\mathrm{mig}}, where \Phi^{\mathrm{fit}}:=c_{\alpha}\int_{(0,1)}\left(\delta_{\left(x_{y}^{(1)},0_{E}\right)}+\delta_{\left(x_{y}^{(2)},0_{E}\right)}\right)\,\nu_{\alpha}(dy), and \Phi^{\mathrm{mig}}:=\int_{[0,1]}\delta_{\left(\mathbf{0}_{V},(y,y)\right)}\frac{\Gamma(a+b)}{\Gamma(a)\Gamma(b)}y^{1-a}(1-y)^{1-b}dy. Convergence of this model is then established by the following proposition. Proposition 6.3 . Let \overline{\chi}^{N,n} and \mathcal{G}_{N} denote the ancestral process and pedigree of a two-deme model with random individual fitness and large migrations. Let \chi^{n} denote a \Psi -driven (\kappa,\mu) - n -coalescent where \Psi has intensity measure dt\otimes d(h_{V})_{*}\Phi . Suppose that, as N goes to infinity, that Assumption 3.1 holds. Then \mathbb{P}\left(cd_{V}\left(\overline{\chi}^{N,n}\right)\in\cdot\,\mid\,\mathcal{A}_{N}\right)\,{\mathrel{\mathop{\kern 0.0pt\longrightarrow}\limits^{{d}}}}\,\mathbb{P}\left(\chi^{n}\in\cdot\,\mid\,\Psi\right). Proof. By symmetry we have that c_{N}^{1}=c_{N}^{2}:=c_{N} , where c_{N} is given by c_{N}\sim c_{W}\left(\frac{2}{\mathbb{E}[W]}\right)^{\alpha}\alpha\,\frac{\Gamma(2-\alpha)\Gamma(\alpha)}{8}\,N^{1-\alpha} by ( 7 , Lemma 2.2) . In particular, Assumptions 3.2 and 3.3 hold. Moreover, since c_{N}\gg 1/N for \alpha\in(1,2) , the Kingman contribution disappears under the 1/c_{N} time-rescaling, hence \kappa=\left(0,0\right) . We now identify the vague limit in Assumption 3.4 . In the one-deme random-fitness model, the sequence of intensity measures (\Phi_{N})_{v} associated with the ordered offspring frequencies in each deme v converges by ( 7 , Proposition 2.3) to \int_{0}^{1}\delta_{x_{y}}\text{\emph{Beta}}(\alpha,2-\alpha)(dy), reflecting that a single highly fit parent contributes a macroscopic fraction y of the parental gametes at a locus, split equally between its two copies. Finally, consider migration. By construction, \mathbb{P}\{m\neq 0\}=N^{1-\alpha}c_{W}\left(\frac{2}{\mathbb{E}[W]}\right)^{\alpha}\alpha\,\frac{\Gamma(2-\alpha)\Gamma(\alpha)}{8}=c_{N},\qquad\mathbb{P}\{m=0\}=1-c_{N}, and m_{(1,2)}=m_{(2,1)}=m . In particular, by construction it is clear that \frac{1}{c_{N}}\left(\Phi_{N}\right)_{e}\to\text{\emph{Beta}}(a,b) on (0,1] . Since we sample the migration and reproduction events independently, it follows from Corollary A.3 that \frac{1}{c_{N}}\Phi_{N} converges vaguely to \Phi , as described. All hypotheses of Theorem 4.3 are satisfied, and the claimed quenched convergence follows. ∎ 6.4 A discrete approximation of a toroidal spatial \Xi Fleming-Viot genealogy We describe here a discrete approximation of a \Xi Fleming-Viot genealogy. The \Lambda Fleming-Viot coalescent \chi^{n} of 12 can be described as follows: Fix a measure \nu on \mathbb{R}_{+} so that \int rd\nu(r)<\infty . Let \Gamma denote a Poisson point process on \mathbb{R}_{+}\times\mathbb{R}^{2}\times\mathbb{R}_{+} with intensity measure dt\otimes dx\otimes d\nu . We say that an atom (t,x,r) “affects” a point y if \left|\left|x-y\right|\right|0 , a_{v},b_{v}>0 for each deme v in V , and a finite measure \nu on \mathbb{R}_{+} with \int rd\nu(r)<\infty . \rho will correspond to a scaling of the lattice and \sigma to migration rates. \gamma and \nu will relate to the intensity of the analogue \Gamma described above for the spatial \Lambda Fleming-Viot process. We sample \left(\mathcal{V},m\right) as follows: • With probability 1-\frac{\gamma}{2N} we set \displaystyle m_{(v,w)}=m_{(w,v)} \displaystyle\sim\frac{1}{N}\text{\emph{Binomial}}\left(N;\frac{\sigma}{2}\right)\text{ if $v$ is a nearest neighbor to $w$} \displaystyle m_{(v,w)}=m_{(w,v)} \displaystyle=0,\text{ if $v$ and $w$ are not nearest neighbors, and} \displaystyle\left(\mathcal{V}^{v}\right)_{v\in V} \displaystyle\sim\text{Multinomial}\left(N;\frac{2}{N(N-1)},\ldots,\frac{2}{N(N-1)}\right)^{\otimes L_{1}\times L_{2}}. That is, we have conservative migration between nearest neighbors and the reproduction within each deme is Wright-Fisher. • With probability \frac{\gamma}{2N} we have an extreme reproductive event. Choose a deme w^{*} uniformly at random from V and sample r\sim\nu . A deme v^{*} is then selected uniformly at random from the collection of demes w with \left|\left|w-w^{*}\right|\right|1-q_{n}(x,m)(\xi,\xi),\\ J_{x,m,\xi}(v),&u^{\xi}\leq 1-q_{n}(x,m)(\xi,\xi).\end{cases} (7.2) Construction of the \Psi -driven (\kappa,\mu) - n -coalescent Let K_{n}(\kappa)+M_{n}(\mu) denote the generator of the (0,\kappa,\mu) - n -coalescent on the finite state space \mathcal{E}_{n}(V) . Let \left(Y^{(k)}\right)_{k\geq 0} be i.i.d. càdlàg Markov processes with generator K_{n}(\kappa)+M_{n}(\mu) , independent of \widehat{\Psi} and each other. By Lemma 7.1 , we may list the atom times of \Psi^{\star} increasingly as 0<\tau_{1}<\tau_{2}<\cdots,\qquad\tau_{k}\to\infty. For each k , denote the unique atom of \widehat{\Psi} at time \tau_{k} by \left(\tau_{k},(x_{k},m_{k}),u_{k},v_{k}\right). Definition 7.2 ( \Psi -driven (\kappa,\mu) - n -coalescent, pathwise) . Fix an initial state \chi^{n}(0)=\xi_{0}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V) . Define \chi^{n} recursively as follows. Set \chi^{n}(0)=\xi_{0} and, for t\in[0,\tau_{1}) , let \chi^{n}(t):=Y^{(0)}(t). Suppose \chi^{n} has been defined on [0,\tau_{k}) . Define the left limit \chi^{n}(\tau_{k}-):=\lim_{t\uparrow\tau_{k}}\chi^{n}(t) , and set \chi^{n}(\tau_{k}):=F_{x_{k},m_{k},u_{k},v_{k}}\left(\chi^{n}(\tau_{k}-)\right). For t\in[\tau_{k},\tau_{k+1}) , define \chi^{n}(t):=Y^{(k)}(t-\tau_{k})\quad\text{with initial condition }Y^{(k)}(0)=\chi^{n}(\tau_{k}). Remark 7.3 . By construction, conditional on (x,m) at an atom time and on the pre-jump state \xi , the post-jump state has distribution q_{n}(x,m)(\xi,\cdot) . Indeed, ( 7.2 ) yields \mathbb{P}\left(\chi^{n}(\tau_{k})=\xi\,\,\mid\,\,\chi^{n}(\tau_{k}-)=\xi,(x_{k},m_{k})\right)=q_{n}(x_{k},m_{k})(\xi,\xi), and, for \eta\neq\xi , \mathbb{P}\left(\chi^{n}(\tau_{k})=\eta\,\,\mid\,\,\chi^{n}(\tau_{k}-)=\xi,(x_{k},m_{k})\right)=q_{n}(x_{k},m_{k})(\xi,\eta). The role of the thinning is solely to ensure that the set of times at which a change is possible is locally finite; it does not alter the induced transition kernel at those times. Coupling l conditionally independent copies given \Psi We now construct l copies \left(\chi_{i}^{n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} on the same driving \Psi such that, conditional on \Psi , they are independent. Let \widehat{\Psi}^{(l)} be a Poisson point process on \mathbb{R}_{+}\times\left(\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}\right)\times\left([0,1]^{\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)}\times[0,1]\right)^{l} with intensity dt\otimes d\Phi\left((x,m)\right)\otimes\left(\lambda_{\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)}(du)\otimes\lambda(dv)\right)^{\otimes l}. Write its atoms as \left(t,(x,m),\left(u_{i},v_{i}\right)_{i=1}^{l}\right) . For each i define the coordinatewise jump map F^{(i)}_{x,m,u_{i},v_{i}} by ( 7.2 ). Let \left(Y^{(k)}_{i}\right)_{k\geq 0,\,i\in[l]} be i.i.d. Markov processes with generator R , independent of \widehat{\Psi}^{(l)} . Define each \chi_{i}^{n} by the same interlacing construction as in Definition 7.2 , but using the marks \left(u_{i},v_{i}\right) and background chains \left(Y^{(k)}_{i}\right) . Lemma 7.4 (Conditional independence given \Psi ) . With the above construction, the processes \left(\chi_{i}^{n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} are i.i.d. with the law of the \Psi -driven (\kappa,\mu) - n -coalescent, and are conditionally independent given \Psi . Proof. Given \Psi , the marks \left(u_{i},v_{i}\right)_{i\in[l]} and the background chains \left(Y_{i}^{(k)}\right) are independent across i by construction, and each coordinate has the same conditional transition mechanism described in Remark 7.3 . This yields both the correct marginal law and conditional independence. ∎ With this construction we are now able to prove Lemma 5.6 . Proof of Lemma 5.6 . Consider the l -tuple process \left(\chi_{i}^{n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} taking values in \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} . Between atom times of \widehat{\Psi}^{(l)} it evolves as l independent (0,\kappa,\mu) - n -coalescents, hence has generator R by our earlier definition of R on \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} . Fix an atom time t of \Psi with mark (x,m) and pre-jump state \vec{\xi}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} . By Remark 7.3 and independence of the coordinate marks \left(u_{i},v_{i}\right) , conditional on \vec{\chi}^{n}(t-)=\vec{\xi} and on (x,m) , the post-jump state has transition kernel \mathbb{P}\left(\left(\chi_{i}^{n}\right)_{i=1}^{l}(t)=\vec{\eta}\,\,\mid\,\,\left(\chi_{i}^{n}\right)_{i=1}^{l}(t-)=\vec{\xi},(x,m)\right)=\prod_{i=1}^{l}q_{n}(x,m)(\xi_{i},\eta_{i})=:H_{l}(x,m)(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta}). In particular, \mathbb{P}\left(\left(\chi_{i}^{n}\right)_{i=1}^{l}(t)=\vec{\xi}\,\,\mid\,\,\left(\chi_{i}^{n}\right)_{i=1}^{l}(t-)=\vec{\xi},(x,m)\right)=H_{l}(x,m)(\vec{\xi},\vec{\xi})=\prod_{i=1}^{l}q_{n}(x,m)(\xi_{i},\xi_{i}). Let f:\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}\to\mathbb{R} be bounded. By annealing over \Psi we see that the generator of \vec{\chi}^{n} is \mathcal{L}f(\vec{\xi})=Rf(\vec{\xi})+\int_{\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}}\left(\sum_{\vec{\eta}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}}f(\vec{\eta})\,H_{l}(x,m)(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta})-f(\vec{\xi})\right)\,d\Phi\left(x,m\right). Equivalently, \mathcal{L}=R+\int_{\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}}\left(H_{l}(x,m)-I\right)\,d\Phi\left(x,m\right), which is the claimed form. ∎ 8 Coupling coalescents on the pedigree In Section 8.1 , we rigorously introduce the coupling of the conditionally independent realizations \left(\overline{\chi}_{i}^{N,n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} of \overline{\chi}^{N,n} with respect to \mathcal{A}_{N} . This coupling is then used to rigorously establish the unproved lemmas of Section 5 . The generic behavior of small jumps described in Lemma 5.2 is proven in Section 8.3 . The behavior of large jumps described in Lemma 5.3 is proved in Section 8.4 . Lemma 5.5 , which combines the behavior of the two scales is the subject of Section 8.5 . 8.1 The coupling In order to prove Theorem 4.3 , it is convenient to work with l conditionally independent realizations of the time-rescaled ancestral process. To this end, we couple \chi_{1}^{N,n}=\left(\chi_{1}^{N,n}(k)\right)_{k\in\mathbb{Z}_{+}},\ldots,\chi_{l}^{N,n}=\left(\chi_{l}^{N,n}(k)\right)_{k\in\mathbb{Z}_{+}} so that they are conditionally independent with respect to \mathcal{A}_{N} . We proceed in the coupling akin to the description in ( 1 , Section 6.1) . The point is that, even if each copy is naturally described on \mathcal{E}_{n}(V) , the l -tuple of copies requires additional bookkeeping. One must remember which ancestral diploid individuals are shared by different copies, since this is where the common pedigree creates correlations after averaging over \mathcal{A}_{N} . We first fix notation for the state space. For any set M , write \mathcal{P}(M) for its power set and \mathcal{P}_{1,2}(M)\;:=\;\left[A\in\mathcal{P}(M):\#A\in\{1,2\}\right]. Define \mathcal{C}_{n,l}\;:=\;\mathcal{P}([n])^{l}\setminus\left[(\varnothing,\ldots,\varnothing)\right]. An element C=(C^{(1)},\ldots,C^{(l)})\in\mathcal{C}_{n,l} represents the contents of l unlinked loci on a single ancestral chromosome that carries ancestral material for copy j from the block C^{(j)} . Any given component may be empty, but not all components are simultaneously empty. A single ancestral diploid individual can carry one or two such chromosomes. We therefore encode an ancestral individual by an element I\in\mathcal{P}_{1,2}(\mathcal{C}_{n,l}) . We also record the deme in which this individual lives. This leads to the state space \mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V)\;:=\;\left\{\xi\subset V\times\mathcal{P}_{1,2}(\mathcal{C}_{n,l})\,:\,\bigsqcup_{(v,I)\in\xi}\;\bigsqcup_{C\in I}C^{(j)}=[n]\text{ for all }j\in[l]\right\}, where \sqcup denotes disjoint union, and we interpret C^{(j)}=\varnothing as contributing nothing to the union. The disjoint-union conditions say that, in each copy j , every sample index appears in exactly one block across all chromosomes of all ancestral individuals. Given \xi\in\mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V) , the induced configuration of copy j is obtained by projection to the j th component. More precisely, define maps pr_{j}:\mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V)\to\mathcal{S}_{n}(V),\qquad j\in[l], as follows. For \xi\in\mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V) and a fixed (v,I)\in\xi , the element pr_{j}(\xi) contains, in deme v , the same grouping into one or two chromosomes, but with each chromosome C=(C^{(1)},\ldots,C^{(l)})\in I replaced by the single block C^{(j)} and with empty blocks removed. In particular, pr_{j}(\xi) records which blocks of copy j are in the same diploid individual, together with the deme label of that individual. We then apply the complete-dispersion map cd_{V} from the single-locus state space to forget the short-lived pairing information within individuals. We extend cd_{V} to \mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V) by cd_{V}(\xi)\;:=\;\left(cd_{V}\!\circ\,pr_{1}(\xi),\ldots,cd_{V}\!\circ\,pr_{l}(\xi)\right)\;\in\;\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}. We call \xi\in\mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V) completely dispersed if \xi carries no information beyond its l complete dispersions, in the sense that each chromosome carries ancestral material from exactly one copy. Equivalently, \xi lies in the image of the canonical embedding \iota:\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}\to\mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V), defined by placing every block of copy j on its own chromosome of type (\varnothing,\ldots,\varnothing,C,\varnothing,\ldots,\varnothing) (with C in the j th slot) in the appropriate deme. We now construct the coupled processes. We work on a probability space that carries the pedigree \mathcal{G}_{N} and l independent collections of Mendelian randomness, one for each copy. Conditional on \mathcal{A}_{N} , we build l families of ancestral lines by running the l copies through the same pedigree realisation and using the independent Mendelian randomness to decide gene inheritance. This induces l ancestral processes \chi_{1}^{N,n},\ldots,\chi_{l}^{N,n} with values in \mathcal{E}_{n}(V) , and hence an l -tuple process \left(\chi_{i}^{N,n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} . By construction, \mathbb{P}\left(\chi_{1}^{N,n}\in\cdot\,\middle|\,\mathcal{A}_{N}\right)\;=\;\cdots\;=\;\mathbb{P}\left(\chi_{l}^{N,n}\in\cdot\,\middle|\,\mathcal{A}_{N}\right),\qquad\chi_{1}^{N,n},\ldots,\chi_{l}^{N,n}\ \text{ are i.i.d.\ given }\ \mathcal{A}_{N}. Finally, we lift \left(\chi_{i}^{N,n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} to a process with values in \mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V) by keeping, at each discrete time k , the collection of ancestral diploid individuals that carry ancestral material in at least one copy, together with the allocation of the l copies to the (up to) two chromosomes of each such individual. This is exactly the additional structure that remembers how the different copies share individuals on the fixed pedigree. We then define \overline{\chi}_{1}^{N,n},\ldots,\overline{\chi}_{l}^{N,n} to be the time-rescaled \mathcal{D}\left(\mathbb{R}_{+},\mathcal{S}_{n}(V)\right) -valued processes given by \overline{\chi}_{j}^{N,n}(t)\;:=\;\chi_{j}^{N,n}\!\left(\lfloor t(c_{N}^{v_{0}})^{-1}\rfloor\right),\qquad t\geq 0,\ \ j\in[l]. 8.2 Negligible time outside \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} under the annealed law In this section, we demonstrate that it suffices to characterize the one-step transition matrix for \left(\chi_{i}^{N,n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} from a totally dispersed element in \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} to its projection under cd_{V} in the next time-step, instead of in the more complicated coupling space \mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V) . We work under the annealed law throughout this subsection. Let \widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}=\left(\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(k)\right)_{k\in\mathbb{Z}_{+}} be the \mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V) -valued Markov chain constructed in Section 8.1 . Write \mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V):=\iota\left(\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}\right)\subset\mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V),\qquad\pi:=cd_{V}:\mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V)\to\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}. Set h_{N}:=c_{N}^{v_{0}} and r_{N}:=h_{N}^{-1} , and define k_{N}(t):=\lfloor tr_{N}\rfloor=\bigl\lfloor t/h_{N}\bigr\rfloor,\qquad t\geq 0. Definition 8.1 (Outside time) . For T>0 define the discrete outside time up to k\in\mathbb{Z}_{+} by \mathcal{O}_{N,l}(k):=\sum_{j=0}^{k-1}\mathds{1}_{\{\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(j)\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\}}, and its rescaled version on [0,T] by \mathcal{O}_{N,l}(T):=h_{N}\,\mathcal{O}_{N,l}\left(k_{N}(T)\right). Definition 8.2 (Last dispersed time) . For k\in\mathbb{Z}_{+} define \ell_{\mathsf{D}}(k):=\max\{0\leq j\leq k:\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(j)\in\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\}. For t\geq 0 define \ell_{\mathsf{D}}(t):=\ell_{\mathsf{D}}(k_{N}(t)) . Definition 8.3 (Trace process on \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} ) . Define the \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} -valued processes Z_{N,l}(t):=\pi\left(\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(k_{N}(t))\right),\qquad\widetilde{Z}_{N,l}(t):=\pi\left(\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(\ell_{\mathsf{D}}(t))\right),\qquad t\geq 0. Lemma 8.4 (Uniform geometric return to \mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V) ) . There exists p_{n,l}\in(0,1) depending only on (n,l) such that for every N and every \xi\in\mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V)\setminus\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V) , \mathbb{P}_{\xi}\left(\tau_{\mathsf{D}}\leq 1\right)\geq p_{n,l}, where \tau_{\mathsf{D}}:=\inf\{k\geq 0:\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(k)\in\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\}. In particular, there exists \rho\in(0,1) such that for all r\in\mathbb{Z}_{+} , \sup_{N}\sup_{\xi\in\mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V)}\mathbb{P}_{\xi}(\tau_{\mathsf{D}}>r)\leq\rho^{\,r},\qquad\sup_{N}\sup_{\xi\in\mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V)}\mathbb{E}_{\xi}[\tau_{\mathsf{D}}]<\infty. Proof. Fix \xi\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V) . Then there exists an ancestral chromosome in \xi carrying ancestral material from at least two loci. Let J\subset[l] be the set of loci for which that chromosome has nonempty component. Then |J|\geq 2 . In the previous generation, for each j\in J the locus j chooses one of the two parental genes by an independent Bernoulli (1/2) coin flip. With probability at least 1/2 not all loci in J choose the same parental gene, which yields a configuration with strictly fewer mixed chromosomes. Iterating this contraction and using that the number of mixed chromosomes is bounded by a constant depending only on (n,l) gives a uniform geometric tail. ∎ Lemma 8.5 (Rare entrance into \mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)^{c} ) . Fix \varepsilon>0 . There is a constant C_{\varepsilon,n,l}<\infty such that for every N and every \xi\in\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V) , \mathbb{P}\left(\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(1)\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\,\,\mid\,\,\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(0)=\xi,\ (\widetilde{\mathcal{V}}(0),m(0))\in B(\varepsilon)\right)\leq C_{\varepsilon,n,l}\,h_{N}. Proof. On the event \{(\widetilde{\mathcal{V}}(0),m(0))\in B(\varepsilon)\} all offspring and migration frequencies are uniformly small. Starting from \xi\in\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V) there are at most nl ancestral lines across all loci. If two lines from distinct loci share a parental diploid individual in one step, then two sampled gene copies in the same deme necessarily choose the same parental gene copy with probability at least a fixed constant depending only on diploidy, hence the probability of sharing a parental individual is bounded by a constant multiple of the one-step coalescence probability in that deme. By the definition of c_{N}^{v} and Assumption 3.3 , \max_{v\in V}c_{N}^{v}\leq C\,h_{N} for some C<\infty . A union bound over O((nl)^{2}) cross-locus pairs yields the first claim. ∎ Lemma 8.6 (Outside probability at deterministic rescaled times) . For every T>0 there exists C_{T,n,l}<\infty such that for all N , \sup_{0\leq t\leq T}\mathbb{P}\left(\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(k_{N}(t))\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\right)\leq C_{T,n,l}\,h_{N}. In particular, \sup_{0\leq t\leq T}\mathbb{P}\left(\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(k_{N}(t))\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\right)\longrightarrow 0. Proof. Fix t\leq T and write k=k_{N}(t) . Define entrance times \sigma_{1}:=\inf\{j\geq 0:\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(j)\in\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V),\ \widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(j+1)\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\}, and inductively \sigma_{q+1}:=\inf\{j>\sigma_{q}:\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(j)\in\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V),\ \widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(j+1)\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\} , with the convention \inf\varnothing=\infty . For each q define the corresponding return time \tau_{q}:=\inf\{j>\sigma_{q}:\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(j)\in\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\}. The event \{\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(k)\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\} implies that there exists q such that \sigma_{q}k-j-1). Lemma 8.4 gives a uniform bound \sup_{\xi\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)}\mathbb{P}_{\xi}(\tau_{\mathsf{D}}>r)\leq\rho^{\,r} . Lemma 8.5 gives that the entrance probability is O(h_{N}) uniformly in j . Thus, \mathbb{P}\left(\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(k)\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\right)\leq\sum_{r\geq 1}C\,h_{N}\,\rho^{\,r}\leq C^{\prime}\,h_{N}, with constants depending only on T,n,l . Taking the supremum over t\in[0,T] yields the claim. ∎ Lemma 8.7 (Negligible rescaled outside time) . For every T>0 , \mathcal{O}_{N,l}(T)\ \xrightarrow{\mathbb{P}}\ 0. Proof. By Markov’s inequality it suffices to show \mathbb{E}[\mathcal{O}_{N,l}(T)]\to 0 . Using Definition 8.1 and Lemma 8.6 , \displaystyle\mathbb{E}[\mathcal{O}_{N,l}(T)] \displaystyle=h_{N}\sum_{j=0}^{k_{N}(T)-1}\mathbb{P}\left(\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(j)\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\right) \displaystyle\leq h_{N}\cdot k_{N}(T)\cdot\sup_{0\leq t\leq T}\mathbb{P}\left(\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(k_{N}(t))\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\right)\leq T\cdot C_{T,n,l}\,h_{N}, which tends to 0 . ∎ Lemma 8.8 . For every T>0 , \sup_{0\leq t\leq T}\mathbb{P}\left(Z_{N,l}(t)\neq\widetilde{Z}_{N,l}(t)\right)\longrightarrow 0. Consequently, for any r\in\mathbb{N} and any (t_{1},\ldots,t_{r})\in[0,T]^{r} , \mathbb{P}\left(\left(Z_{N,l}(t_{1}),\ldots,Z_{N,l}(t_{r})\right)\neq\left(\widetilde{Z}_{N,l}(t_{1}),\ldots,\widetilde{Z}_{N,l}(t_{r})\right)\right)\longrightarrow 0. Proof. Fix t\leq T and write k=k_{N}(t) . If Z_{N,l}(t)\neq\widetilde{Z}_{N,l}(t) , then there exists an index j\in\{\ell_{\mathsf{D}}(k),\ldots,k-1\} such that \widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(j)\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V) . Therefore, \displaystyle\mathbb{P}\left(Z_{N,l}(t)\neq\widetilde{Z}_{N,l}(t)\right) \displaystyle\leq\mathbb{P}\left(\exists j\in\{\ell_{\mathsf{D}}(k),\ldots,k-1\}:\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(j)\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\right) \displaystyle\leq\mathbb{E}\left[\#\{j\leq k:\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(j)\notin\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\}\right]. The last expectation is bounded by h_{N}^{-1}\mathbb{E}[\mathcal{O}_{N,l}(T)] , which tends to 0 by Lemma 8.7 . This yields the first claim uniformly for t\leq T . The second claim follows by a union bound over the finitely many times t_{1},\ldots,t_{r} . ∎ Lemma 8.9 (Reduction to the trace process on \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} ) . Let T>0 and let (t_{1},\ldots,t_{r})\in[0,T]^{r} . Then \left(Z_{N,l}(t_{1}),\ldots,Z_{N,l}(t_{r})\right)-\left(\widetilde{Z}_{N,l}(t_{1}),\ldots,\widetilde{Z}_{N,l}(t_{r})\right)\xrightarrow{\mathbb{P}}\mathbf{0}. In particular, Z_{N,l} and \widetilde{Z}_{N,l} have identical subsequential finite-dimensional limits. Proof. The claim is immediate from Lemma 8.8 . ∎ 8.3 Transitions at small jumps Inn this section we prove Lemma 5.2 . The basic structure of the argument is as follows: There exist some combinatorial quantities so that the probability of anything that is neither a single pairwise coalescence in a deme or a single migration of a lineage is O(\varepsilon) . At the same time, the one-step transition probabilities of single-lineage migrations and single-pair coalescences are arbitrarily close to the neutral migration and neutral coalescence rates, respectively. Combining these two observations demonstrates that the one-step transition probabilities for small-scale events is sufficiently concentrated around the neutral changes in the realizations. We proceed now with the proof of Lemma 5.2 . Proof of Lemma 5.2 . Fix l\in\mathbb{N} and \varepsilon>0 , and write \mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon}:=\{(\widetilde{V}_{N}(0),m(0))\in B(\varepsilon)\}. Recall that P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l} is the one-step transition matrix of the l -tuple \left(\chi_{i}^{N,n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} conditioned on \mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon} : P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l}(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta}):=\mathbb{P}\left((\chi_{i}^{N,n}(1))_{i=1}^{l}=\vec{\eta}\,\,\mid\,\,(\chi_{i}^{N,n}(0))_{i=1}^{l}=\vec{\xi},\ \mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon}\right),\qquad\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}. Let r:=K_{n}(\kappa)+M_{n}(\mu) be the generator of a single (0,\kappa,\mu) - n -coalescent on \mathcal{E}_{n}(V) , and let R be the generator of l joint, independent copies on \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} . Thus, for \vec{\xi}=(\xi_{1},\ldots,\xi_{l}) and \vec{\eta}=(\eta_{1},\ldots,\eta_{l}) , R(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta})=\sum_{j=1}^{l}r(\xi_{j},\eta_{j})\prod_{i\neq j}\mathds{1}_{\{\xi_{i}=\eta_{i}\}}. (8.1) Set A_{N}:=e^{c_{N}^{v_{0}}R} and endow kernels on the finite space \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} with the norm \|P\|_{\infty}:=\sup_{\vec{\xi}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}}\sum_{\vec{\eta}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}}|P(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta})|. Since \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} is finite, the matrix exponential admits a uniform second-order remainder: there is a finite constant C_{R} such that \left|A_{N}-(I+c_{N}^{v_{0}}R)\right|_{\infty}\leq C_{R}\,(c_{N}^{v_{0}})^{2}. (8.2) We compare P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l} to the first-order kernel I+c_{N}^{v_{0}}R by separating “good” one-step updates from events that involve two or more elementary changes. By an elementary change we simply mean the moving of a single lineage or a single pairwise coalescence. Fix \vec{\xi}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} and consider the event \mathcal{B}_{N,\varepsilon}(\vec{\xi}) that, at least one of the following occurs among the l coordinates: • a merger of three or more blocks within some deme, • two or more binary coalescences (in possibly different demes among possibly different coordinates), • two or more migrations (among possibly different and edges and possibly different coordinates), • a migration and a coalescence in the same step (among possibly different coordinates). On \mathcal{B}_{N,\varepsilon}(\vec{\xi})^{c} , each coordinate undergoes either no change, a single migration of one block along one edge, or a single binary coalescence of two blocks within one deme. In particular, if \vec{\eta} differs from \vec{\xi} by more than one coordinate, or if a coordinate changes by more than one elementary move, then necessarily \mathcal{B}_{N,\varepsilon}(\vec{\xi}) occurs, and hence P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l}(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta})\leq\mathbb{P}\left(\mathcal{B}_{N,\varepsilon}(\vec{\xi})\,\,\mid\,\,\vec{\xi},\mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon}\right). (8.3) We now bound the probability of \mathcal{B}_{N,\varepsilon}(\vec{\xi}) by quantities of order c_{N}^{v_{0}}f(\varepsilon) . Write \widetilde{V}_{N}(0)=(x,m) , with x=(x^{v})_{v\in V} and x^{v}\in\Delta . By definition of B(\varepsilon) under the metric d , on \mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon} we have \sup_{v\in V}\left\langle x^{v},x^{v}\right\rangle^{\frac{1}{2}}\leq\varepsilon,\qquad\|m\|_{\infty}\leq\varepsilon. (8.4) Triple mergers. Fix a coordinate and a deme v . Conditional on (\widetilde{V}_{N}(0),m(0))=(x,m) , the (x,m) -paintbox implies that for any three specified blocks in deme v the probability that they are assigned to the same parental chromosome is bounded by \sum_{i\geq 1}(x_{i}^{v})^{3} . On \mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon} , \sum_{i\geq 1}(x_{i}^{v})^{3}\leq x_{1}^{v}\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle\leq\|x^{v}\|_{2}\,\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle\leq\varepsilon\,\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle, where we used x_{1}^{v}\leq\left\langle x^{v},x^{v}\right\rangle^{\frac{1}{2}} . Taking a union bound over the at most \binom{n}{3} triples yields that the probability of any triple merger in deme v in that coordinate is at most \binom{n}{3}\varepsilon\,\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle . Summing over v\in V and over the l coordinates gives \mathbb{P}\left(\text{some triple merger occurs}\,\,\mid\,\,\vec{\xi},\mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon}\right)\leq l\binom{n}{3}\varepsilon\sum_{v\in V}\mathbb{E}\!\left[\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle\,\,\mid\,\,\mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon}\right]. (8.5) The right-hand side is c_{N}^{v_{0}}\,f_{\mathrm{tr}}(\varepsilon) for some continuous f_{\mathrm{tr}} with f_{\mathrm{tr}}(0)=0 , because the factor \varepsilon is explicit and, by Assumption 3.3 , \sum_{v}c_{N}^{v}=O(c_{N}^{v_{0}}) , while \mathbb{E}[\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle\mid\mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon}] is controlled by the same pair-coalescence scale. Two migrations. Fix a coordinate. Conditional on (\widetilde{V}_{N}(0),m(0))=(x,m) and on the initial configuration, each lineage that currently lies in deme v migrates along a specific edge e=(v,w) with probability at most m_{e} . Hence, for two distinct lineages, say a\neq b , and for two (not necessarily equal) edges e,e^{\prime}\in E , \mathbb{P}\left(\text{$a$ migrates along $e$ and $b$ migrates along $e^{\prime}$}\,\,\mid\,\,\vec{\xi},(x,m)\right)\;\leq\;m_{e}\,m_{e^{\prime}}. Taking a union bound over the at most \binom{n}{2} choices of (a,b) and summing over all ordered pairs of edges gives \displaystyle\mathbb{P} \displaystyle\left(\text{at least two lineages migrate (along any two edges)}\,\,\mid\,\,\vec{\xi},(x,m)\right) (8.6) \displaystyle\;\leq\;\binom{n}{2}\sum_{e\in E}\sum_{e^{\prime}\in E}m_{e}m_{e^{\prime}}\;=\;\binom{n}{2}\left(\sum_{e\in E}m_{e}\right)^{2}. (8.7) On \mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon} we have \|m\|_{\infty}\leq\varepsilon , and therefore \left(\sum_{e\in E}m_{e}\right)^{2}\;\leq\;\|m\|_{\infty}\sum_{e\in E}m_{e}\;\leq\;\varepsilon\sum_{e\in E}m_{e}. Averaging conditional on \mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon} and summing over the l coordinates yields a bound of the form c_{N}^{v_{0}}f_{\mathrm{mig}}(\varepsilon) with f_{\mathrm{mig}}(0)=0 , using Assumption 3.7 (and finiteness of E ) to identify that the total one-step migration probability is O(c_{N}^{v_{0}}) . Two binary coalescences, or a migration and a coalescence. These events require at least two elementary changes in the same discrete step among the l coordinates, and are therefore bounded by products of one-event probabilities. Since sample size is fixed, a crude union bound over potential coalescing pairs shows that the probability of two or more binary coalescences in a single step is O((c_{N}^{v_{0}})^{2}) , uniformly in \vec{\xi} ; similarly for the probability that a migration and a coalescence occur in the same step. Combining the preceding bounds yields a continuous f_{0}:\mathbb{R}_{+}\to\mathbb{R}_{+} with f_{0}(0)=0 such that \sup_{\vec{\xi}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}}\mathbb{P}\left(\mathcal{B}_{N,\varepsilon}(\vec{\xi})\,\,\mid\,\,\vec{\xi},\mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon}\right)\leq f_{0}(\varepsilon)\,c_{N}^{v_{0}}\;+\;O\left((c_{N}^{v_{0}})^{2}\right). (8.8) We next identify the first-order transition probabilities on \mathcal{B}_{N,\varepsilon}(\vec{\xi})^{c} . Suppose \vec{\eta} differs from \vec{\xi} in exactly one coordinate, say j , and that \eta_{j} is obtained from \xi_{j} by moving one block along an edge e=(v,w)\in E . By exchangeability within demes and Assumption 3.7 , the one-step probability of this transition equals c_{N}^{v_{0}}\mu_{e} up to an error that vanishes as \varepsilon\downarrow 0 (and an error of order \mathbb{P}(\mathcal{B}_{N,\varepsilon}(\vec{\xi})\mid\vec{\xi},\mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon}) coming from the possibility that the step is not in the one-event regime). Thus there is a continuous f_{\mu} with f_{\mu}(0)=0 such that \sup_{\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta}}\left|P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l}(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta})-c_{N}^{v_{0}}R(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta})\right|\leq f_{\mu}(\varepsilon)c_{N}^{v_{0}}\;+\;\mathbb{P}\left(\mathcal{B}_{N,\varepsilon}(\vec{\xi})\,\,\mid\,\,\vec{\xi},\mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon}\right), (8.9) whenever \vec{\eta} is obtained from \vec{\xi} by a single migration in one coordinate. Similarly, if \vec{\eta} differs from \vec{\xi} in exactly one coordinate and \eta_{j} is obtained from \xi_{j} by coalescing two blocks in deme v , then Assumption 3.3 implies that this transition occurs with probability c_{N}^{v} up to an error negligible on the c_{N}^{v_{0}} scale, and that c_{N}^{v}/c_{N}^{v_{0}}\to c(v) . Since we are conditioning on (\widetilde{V}_{N}(0),m(0))\in B(\varepsilon) , the contribution from non-Kingman coalescences in the same step is controlled by the triple-merger bound above, and the difference between the effective binary-merger rate under \mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon} and the limiting Kingman rate \kappa_{v} is absorbed into a continuous error function f_{\kappa} with f_{\kappa}(0)=0 . Consequently, for such single-coalescence transitions, \left|P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l}(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta})-c_{N}^{v_{0}}R(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta})\right|\leq f_{\kappa}(\varepsilon)c_{N}^{v_{0}}\;+\;\mathbb{P}\left(\mathcal{B}_{N,\varepsilon}(\vec{\xi})\,\,\mid\,\,\vec{\xi},\mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon}\right). (8.10) For all other off-diagonal \vec{\eta}\neq\vec{\xi} , ( 8.3 ) applies. Summing these bounds over \vec{\eta}\neq\vec{\xi} and using ( 8.8 ) yields \left|P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l}-(I+c_{N}^{v_{0}}R)\right|_{\infty}\leq f_{1}(\varepsilon)\,c_{N}^{v_{0}}\;+\;O\left((c_{N}^{v_{0}})^{2}\right) (8.11) for some continuous f_{1} with f_{1}(0)=0 . Finally, by the triangle inequality, ( 8.2 ) and ( 8.11 ), \|P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l}-A_{N}\|_{\infty}\leq\|P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l}-(I+c_{N}^{v_{0}}R)\|_{\infty}+\|A_{N}-(I+c_{N}^{v_{0}}R)\|_{\infty}\leq f_{1}(\varepsilon)c_{N}^{v_{0}}+\left(C_{R}+O(1)\right)(c_{N}^{v_{0}})^{2}. As c_{N}^{v_{0}}\leq 1 , we have (c_{n}^{v_{0}})^{2}\leq c_{N}^{v_{0}} , and so we get the desired bound. ∎ 8.4 Transitions at large jumps In this section we prove Lemma 5.3 . The basic argument of the proof is that thea discrete version of the (x,m,\xi) -paintbox for finite N works by dropping points onto the space I_{V} but then removing a small part of the interval into which the point dropped. Because the amount one removes for each point one drops is O(\frac{1}{N}) and we are dropping at most nl\in o(N) points, the picture from the continuous paintbox model and the discrete paintbox are almost identical. We proceed now with the proof of Lemma 5.3 . Proof of Lemma 5.3 . Fix l\in\mathbb{N} . For (x,m)\in\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E} and \vec{\xi},\vec{\eta}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} , write H_{N,l}(x,m)(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta}):=\mathbb{P}\left((\overline{\chi}_{i}^{N,n}(k+1))_{i=1}^{l}=\vec{\eta}\,\,\mid\,\,(\overline{\chi}_{i}^{N,n}(k))_{i=1}^{l}=\vec{\xi},\ (\widetilde{\mathcal{V}}(k),m(k))=(x,m)\right). Recall that h_{V}:\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}\to\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E} is the halving map on offspring frequencies, applied coordinatewise on \Delta^{V} and leaving m unchanged. Define H_{l}(x,m)(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta}):=\prod_{i=1}^{l}q_{n}(x,m)(\xi_{i},\eta_{i}),\qquad\left(H_{l}\circ h_{V}\right)(x,m):=H_{l}\left(h_{V}(x,m)\right). We couple the l copies as in Section 8.1 : conditional on \mathcal{A}_{N} the copies are i.i.d. and evolve on the same pedigree realization, with independent Mendelian randomness. Fix (x,m)\in\textup{supp}(\Phi_{N}) and condition further on the event \{(\widetilde{\mathcal{V}}(k),m(k))=(x,m)\} , which specifies the migration proportions and the ordered offspring frequencies at generation k . Under this conditioning, the only remaining randomness driving the updates from time k to time k+1 consists of the random choice of which individuals migrate (uniform without replacement within each deme and along each edge, with counts \lfloor m_{e}N(v)\rfloor ), parental assignments, and the Mendelian segregation randomness determining, for each copy and each ancestral lineage, which parental chromosome is inherited. For each deme v\in V write S_{v}(m):=\sum_{e=(v,w)\in E}m_{e}\in[0,1] and define G(\delta):=\left\{(x,m)\in\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}:\ \forall v\in V,\ S_{v}(m)\leq 1-\delta\right\}. Fix \varepsilon>0 . By Assumption 3.12 , \Phi\left(S_{v}(m)=1\right)=0 for each v , and hence the decreasing sets \{B(\varepsilon)^{c}\cap\{S_{v}(m)\geq 1-\delta\}\}_{\delta\downarrow 0} have \Phi -mass tending to 0 . Therefore, choosing \delta=\delta(\varepsilon)\in(0,1) sufficiently small, we may ensure \Phi\left(B(\varepsilon)^{c}\cap G(\delta)^{c}\right)\leq\varepsilon. (8.12) Throughout what follows we work on \textup{supp}(\Phi_{N})\cap G(\delta) ; the contribution of G(\delta)^{c} will be paid for at the end. Fix (x,m)\in\textup{supp}(\Phi_{N})\cap G(\delta) . Then for each deme v , \sum_{e=(v,w)\in E}\lfloor m_{e}N(v)\rfloor\;\leq\;\left(\sum_{e=(v,w)\in E}m_{e}\right)N(v)\;\leq\;(1-\delta)N(v), so every without-replacement sampling of parents/migrants within deme v is performed from a set of size at least \delta N(v) . In particular, for each fixed r\in\mathbb{N} , the total-variation distance between drawing r individuals uniformly without replacement from a population of size M\geq\delta N(v) and drawing r i.i.d. uniform individuals is bounded by the i.i.d. collision probability. We make this precise for the one-step update of a single copy. Fix \xi\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V) and consider the update \xi\mapsto\eta over one discrete generation given (x,m) . Let q_{N,n}(x,m)(\xi,\eta) denote the corresponding one-step transition probability of the single copy ancestral process under the conditioning \{(\widetilde{\mathcal{V}}(k),m(k))=(x,m)\} . By replacing all without-replacement choices of migrants and parents by independent sampling with replacement, we change the law of the resulting parental assignments by at most O(n^{2}/N) in total variation, uniformly over (x,m)\in\textup{supp}(\Phi_{N})\cap G(\delta) since n is fixed. The remaining issue is the diploid structure: when two sampled ancestral lineages choose the same individual, they do not necessarily coalesce in the next generation, since they may correspond to distinct parental chromosomes. Conditional on the realized counts x^{v} of offspring per individual in deme v , the Mendelian randomness assigns each parental contribution to one of two chromosomes with probability 1/2 each, independently across contributions. Equivalently, the relevant category probabilities for a paintbox description are obtained by splitting each individual-mass x_{i}^{v} into two chromosome-masses (x_{i}^{v}/2,x_{i}^{v}/2) . This is precisely the effect of the halving map h_{V} . Thus, after replacing without-replacement sampling by sampling with replacement, the conditional one-step transition of a single copy is exactly the paintbox kernel q_{n}\left(h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\xi,\eta) . Therefore there is a constant C<\infty , depending only on n,|V|,|E| and \delta , such that \sup_{(x,m)\in\textup{supp}(\Phi_{N})\cap G(\delta)}\ \max_{\xi,\eta\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)}\,\mid\,q_{N,n}(x,m)(\xi,\eta)-q_{n}\left(h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\xi,\eta)\,\mid\,\;\leq\;\frac{C}{N}. (8.13) We now return to the l -tuple. Conditional on \mathcal{A}_{N} and on \{(\widetilde{\mathcal{V}}(k),m(k))=(x,m)\} , the Mendelian randomness is independent across copies, and the only source of dependence across copies is that they use the same finite populations of parents and migrants at generation k+1 . Since each copy uses only n ancestral lineages and n is fixed, the same without-replacement estimate implies that the joint law of the parental assignments across the l copies differs from that of l independent copies by at most O(l^{2}n^{2}/N) in total variation, uniformly in (x,m)\in\textup{supp}(\Phi_{N})\cap G(\delta) . Consequently, there is a constant C^{\prime}<\infty , depending only on n,l,|V|,|E| and \delta , such that \sup_{(x,m)\in\textup{supp}(\Phi_{N})\cap G(\delta)}\ \max_{\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}}\,\mid\,H_{N,l}(x,m)(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta})-\prod_{i=1}^{l}q_{N,n}(x,m)(\xi_{i},\eta_{i})\,\mid\,\;\leq\;\frac{C^{\prime}}{N}. (8.14) Using ( 8.13 ) and the inequality \,\mid\,\prod_{i=1}^{l}a_{i}-\prod_{i=1}^{l}b_{i}\,\mid\,\leq l\max_{i}|a_{i}-b_{i}| for a_{i},b_{i}\in[0,1] , we obtain \sup_{(x,m)\in\textup{supp}(\Phi_{N})\cap G(\delta)}\ \max_{\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}}\,\mid\,\prod_{i=1}^{l}q_{N,n}(x,m)(\xi_{i},\eta_{i})-\prod_{i=1}^{l}q_{n}\left(h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\xi_{i},\eta_{i})\,\mid\,\;\leq\;\frac{lC}{N}. Combining this with ( 8.14 ) and absorbing finite-dimensional norm equivalences into the constants yields \sup_{(x,m)\in\textup{supp}(\Phi_{N})\cap G(\delta)}\left|H_{N,l}(x,m)-H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)\right|_{\infty}\;\leq\;\frac{C^{\prime\prime}}{N}, (8.15) for some C^{\prime\prime}<\infty depending only on n,l,|V|,|E| and \delta . Since \|H_{N,l}-H_{l}\circ h_{V}\|_{\infty}\leq 2 everywhere, we may split the integral as \displaystyle\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int_{B(\varepsilon)^{c}} \displaystyle\left|H_{N,l}(x,m)-H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)\right|_{\infty}\,d\Phi_{N}(x,m) (8.16) \displaystyle\leq\;\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int_{B(\varepsilon)^{c}\cap G(\delta)}\left|H_{N,l}-H_{l}\circ h_{V}\right|_{\infty}\,d\Phi_{N}+\;\frac{2}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N}\left(B(\varepsilon)^{c}\cap G(\delta)^{c}\right). By ( 8.15 ), \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int_{B(\varepsilon)^{c}\cap G(\delta)}\left|H_{N,l}-H_{l}\circ h_{V}\right|_{\infty}\,d\Phi_{N}\;\leq\;\frac{C^{\prime\prime}}{N}\cdot\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N}\left(B(\varepsilon)^{c}\right). (8.17) Since B(\varepsilon)^{c} is bounded away from \mathbf{0}_{V,E} , Assumption 3.4 implies that \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N}\left(B(\varepsilon)^{c}\right) is bounded in N . Hence the right-hand side of ( 8.17 ) tends to 0 as N\to\infty . For the second term in ( 8.16 ), again because B(\varepsilon)^{c} is bounded away from \mathbf{0}_{V,E} , Assumption 3.4 gives \limsup_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N}\left(B(\varepsilon)^{c}\cap G(\delta)^{c}\right)\leq\Phi\left(B(\varepsilon)^{c}\cap G(\delta)^{c}\right), (8.18) By ( 8.12 ) the right hand side of ( 8.18 ) is at most \varepsilon , and therefore \limsup_{N\to\infty}\frac{2}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N}\left(B(\varepsilon)^{c}\cap G(\delta)^{c}\right)\;\leq\;2\varepsilon. Since \varepsilon>0 was arbitrary, combining with 8.16 completes the proof. ∎ 8.5 Combining the large and small scale Combining the two scales of Lemma 5.2 and Lemma 5.3 allows us to conclude that the transition kernel of the joint process \left(\overline{\chi}_{i}^{N,n}\right)_{i=1}^{l} is arbitrarily close, on compact time intervals, to that of a Markov process with infinitesimal generator \mathcal{L}:=R+\int_{\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}}\left(H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)-I\right)\,d\Phi(x,m), (8.19) where h_{V} is the halving map encoding the diploid splitting of each individual mass into two chromosome masses. Lemma 8.10 (Small-event bound for the diploid paintbox kernel) . There is a constant C_{n,l,V,E}<\infty such that for all (x,m)\in\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E} and all \vec{\xi}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} , \sum_{\vec{\eta}\neq\vec{\xi}}\left(H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta})\;\leq\;C_{n,l,V,E}\left(\|m\|_{\infty}+\sup_{v\in V}\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle\right). (8.20) In particular, \left|H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)-I\right|_{\infty}\;\leq\;C_{n,l,V,E}\left(\|m\|_{\infty}+\sup_{v\in V}\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle\right). (8.21) Moreover, \left|H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)-I\right|_{\infty}\;\leq\;l\,\sup_{\xi\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)}\left(1-q_{n}\left(h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\xi,\xi)\right). (8.22) Proof. Fix (x,m) and \vec{\xi}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} . Write \xi^{(j)} for the j th coordinate of \vec{\xi} . In copy j , conditional on h_{V}(x,m) , a change \xi^{(j)}\mapsto\eta^{(j)}\neq\xi^{(j)} occurs only if at least one of the following events happens in the \left(h_{V}(x,m),\xi^{(j)}\right) -paintbox: • some block migrates along an edge, or • at least one pair of blocks in a common deme falls into the same h_{V}(x)^{v} -interval and merges. Let b_{j}\leq n be the number of blocks in \xi^{(j)} , and let b_{j,v}\leq b_{j} be the number of blocks in deme v . For the migration contribution, in copy j each block in deme v migrates with probability \sum_{w:(v,w)\in E}m_{(v,w)}\leq|E|\,\|m\|_{\infty}, since h_{V} leaves m unchanged. A union bound over at most b_{j}\leq n blocks yields \mathbb{P}\left(\text{a migration occurs in copy $j$}\mid h_{V}(x,m),\xi^{(j)}\right)\leq n\,|E|\,\|m\|_{\infty}. For the merger contribution, in deme v two specified blocks coalesce only if their paintbox points fall in the same h_{V}(x)^{v} -interval, which has probability \langle h_{V}(x)^{v},h_{V}(x)^{v}\rangle . Since h_{V} splits each mass into two halves, we have \langle h_{V}(x)^{v},h_{V}(x)^{v}\rangle=\frac{1}{2}\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle , and in particular \langle h_{V}(x)^{v},h_{V}(x)^{v}\rangle\leq\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle . A union bound over the at most \binom{b_{j,v}}{2}\leq\binom{n}{2} pairs in deme v , and then over v\in V , gives \mathbb{P}\left(\text{a merger occurs in copy $j$}\mid h_{V}(x,m),\xi^{(j)}\right)\leq|V|\,\binom{n}{2}\,\sup_{v\in V}\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle. If \vec{\eta}\neq\vec{\xi} then at least one copy j\in[l] must change. Therefore, by a union bound over j\in[l] , \sum_{\vec{\eta}\neq\vec{\xi}}\left(H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta})=\mathbb{P}\left(\vec{\eta}\neq\vec{\xi}\mid h_{V}(x,m),\vec{\xi}\right)\leq l\left(n\,|E|\,\|m\|_{\infty}+|V|\,\binom{n}{2}\sup_{v\in V}\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle\right), which proves ( 8.20 ) with an appropriate constant C_{n,l,V,E} . ( 8.21 ) then follows from ( 8.20 ). For ( 8.22 ), note that for each \vec{\xi}\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} , \sum_{\vec{\eta}\neq\vec{\xi}}\left(H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta})=1-\left(H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\vec{\xi},\vec{\xi})=1-\prod_{i=1}^{l}q_{n}\left(h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\xi^{(i)},\xi^{(i)}). Using 1-\prod_{i=1}^{l}a_{i}\leq\sum_{i=1}^{l}(1-a_{i}) for a_{i}\in[0,1] gives 1-\left(H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\vec{\xi},\vec{\xi})\leq\sum_{i=1}^{l}\left(1-q_{n}\left(h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\xi^{(i)},\xi^{(i)})\right)\leq l\,\sup_{\xi\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)}\left(1-q_{n}\left(h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\xi,\xi)\right), and taking the supremum over \vec{\xi} yields ( 8.22 ). ∎ We now proceed with the proof of Lemma 5.5 . Proof of Lemma 5.5 . Fix T>0 and write h_{N}:=c_{N}^{v_{0}} . Let \widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l} be the annealed \mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V) -valued Markov chain from Section 8 , let \mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V):=\iota(\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}) , and let \pi=cd_{V}:\mathcal{H}_{n,l}(V)\to\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} . Define the return times to \mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V) by \tau_{0}:=0,\qquad\tau_{q+1}:=\inf\{k>\tau_{q}:\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(k)\in\mathsf{D}_{n,l}(V)\},\qquad q\in\mathbb{Z}_{+}, and define the embedded chain Y^{N,l}(q):=\pi\left(\widehat{\chi}^{N,n,l}(\tau_{q})\right)\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l},\qquad q\in\mathbb{Z}_{+}. By the strong Markov property, Y^{N,l} is a time-homogeneous Markov chain on the finite space \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} . Let \mathbf{P}_{N,l} be its one-step transition matrix, and define the time-rescaled process \overline{Y}^{\,N,l}(t):=Y^{N,l}\!\left(\lfloor t/h_{N}\rfloor\right),\qquad t\geq 0. Let P_{N,l}(t) denote the transition kernel of \overline{Y}^{\,N,l} . Then P_{N,l}(t)\;=\;\mathbf{P}_{N,l}^{\lfloor t/h_{N}\rfloor},\qquad t\geq 0. (8.23) Lemma 8.7 and Lemma 8.9 imply that, on [0,T] , the finite-dimensional distributions of \left(cd_{V}(\overline{\chi}_{i}^{N,n})\right)_{i=1}^{l} coincide with those of \overline{Y}^{\,N,l} up to an error that is o_{N}(1) uniformly over initial states. Consequently, it suffices to establish ( 5.4 ) for the kernel P_{N,l}(t) defined above. Fix \varepsilon>0 and set \mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon}:=\{(\widetilde{V}_{N}(0),m(0))\in B(\varepsilon)\} . Lemma 8.9 implies that one step of Y^{N,l} corresponds to one reproduction step of the underlying dynamics, and therefore, by conditioning on \mathscr{E}_{N,\varepsilon} and using the time-homogeneity of the i.i.d. environment across generations, we have \mathbf{P}_{N,l}\;=\;\Phi_{N}\!\left(B(\varepsilon)\right)\,P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l}\;+\;\int_{B(\varepsilon)^{c}}H_{N,l}(x,m)\,d\Phi_{N}(x,m), (8.24) where P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l} is as in Lemma 5.2 and H_{N,l} is as in Lemma 5.3 . Define the truncated operator L^{\varepsilon}\;:=\;R\;+\;\int_{B(\varepsilon)^{c}}\left(H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)-I\right)\,d\Phi(x,m), (8.25) viewed as a matrix on C_{b}(\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l}) . Note that \Phi(B(\varepsilon)^{c})<\infty . Lemma 5.2 provides a continuous f with f(0)=0 such that \left|P_{N,n,\varepsilon,l}-e^{h_{N}R}\right|_{\infty}\leq f(\varepsilon)\,h_{N}. (8.26) Assumption 3.4 implies that for fixed \varepsilon>0 , \frac{1}{h_{N}}\,\Phi_{N}\!\left(B(\varepsilon)^{c}\right)\;\longrightarrow\;\Phi\!\left(B(\varepsilon)^{c}\right). (8.27) Lemma 5.3 implies that for fixed \varepsilon>0 , \left\|\frac{1}{h_{N}}\int_{B(\varepsilon)^{c}}\left(H_{N,l}(x,m)-H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)\right)\,d\Phi_{N}(x,m)\right\|_{\infty}\;\longrightarrow\;0. (8.28) Moreover, each entry (x,m)\mapsto\left(H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\vec{\xi},\vec{\eta}) is bounded and continuous on \Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E} , and B(\varepsilon)^{c} is bounded away from 0_{V,E} , so Assumption 3.4 yields \left\|\frac{1}{h_{N}}\int_{B(\varepsilon)^{c}}H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)\,d\Phi_{N}(x,m)\;-\;\int_{B(\varepsilon)^{c}}H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)\,d\Phi(x,m)\right\|_{\infty}\;\longrightarrow\;0. (8.29) Combining ( 8.28 ) and ( 8.29 ) gives \frac{1}{h_{N}}\int_{B(\varepsilon)^{c}}H_{N,l}(x,m)\,d\Phi_{N}(x,m)\;\longrightarrow\;\int_{B(\varepsilon)^{c}}H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)\,d\Phi(x,m). (8.30) Expanding ( 8.24 ) using \Phi_{N}(B(\varepsilon))=1-\Phi_{N}(B(\varepsilon)^{c}) , inserting ( 8.26 ), and using e^{h_{N}R}=I+h_{N}R+O(h_{N}^{2}) on the finite space \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} yields \mathbf{P}_{N,l}\;=\;I\;+\;h_{N}R\;+\;\int_{B(\varepsilon)^{c}}\left(H_{N,l}(x,m)-I\right)\,d\Phi_{N}(x,m)\;+\;h_{N}\,\mathrm{Err}_{N,\varepsilon}, (8.31) where \|\mathrm{Err}_{N,\varepsilon}\|_{\infty}\leq C\,f(\varepsilon)+o_{N}(1) for some C<\infty . Dividing the integral term by h_{N} and using ( 8.30 ) gives, for fixed \varepsilon , \left|\mathbf{P}_{N,l}-(I+h_{N}L^{\varepsilon})\right|_{\infty}\leq h_{N}\left(C\,f(\varepsilon)+o_{N}(1)\right). (8.32) Let t\in[0,T] and set k:=\lfloor t/h_{N}\rfloor . Using ( 8.23 ) and the telescoping identity, \left|\mathbf{P}_{N,l}^{k}-(I+h_{N}L^{\varepsilon})^{k}\right|_{\infty}\leq k\,\left|\mathbf{P}_{N,l}-(I+h_{N}L^{\varepsilon})\right|_{\infty}\leq T\left(C\,f(\varepsilon)+o_{N}(1)\right), (8.33) and hence \sup_{0\leq t\leq T}\left|P_{N,l}(t)-(I+h_{N}L^{\varepsilon})^{\lfloor t/h_{N}\rfloor}\right|_{\infty}\leq T\left(C\,f(\varepsilon)+o_{N}(1)\right). (8.34) Since L^{\varepsilon} is bounded on the finite space \mathcal{E}_{n}(V)^{l} , e^{h_{N}L^{\varepsilon}}=I+h_{N}L^{\varepsilon}+O(h_{N}^{2}) in \|\cdot\|_{\infty} . Therefore, for kh_{N}\leq T , \left|(I+h_{N}L^{\varepsilon})^{k}-e^{kh_{N}L^{\varepsilon}}\right|_{\infty}\leq C_{\varepsilon,T}\,h_{N} for some C_{\varepsilon,T}<\infty . Combining with ( 8.34 ) yields \sup_{0\leq t\leq T}\left|P_{N,l}(t)-e^{tL^{\varepsilon}}\right|_{\infty}\leq T\,C\,f(\varepsilon)\;+\;T\,o_{N}(1)\;+\;C_{\varepsilon,T}h_{N}. (8.35) By ( 8.22 ) and the finiteness of \mathcal{E}_{n}(V) , \left|H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)-I\right|_{\infty}\leq l\,\sup_{\xi\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)}\left(1-q_{n}\left(h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\xi,\xi)\right)\leq l\,\sum_{\xi\in\mathcal{E}_{n}(V)}\left(1-q_{n}\left(h_{V}(x,m)\right)(\xi,\xi)\right). Hence Assumption 3.10 implies that \int_{\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}}\left|H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)-I\right|_{\infty}\,d\Phi(x,m)<\infty, and therefore \left|\int_{B(\varepsilon)}\left(H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)-I\right)\,d\Phi(x,m)\right|_{\infty}\;\longrightarrow\;0\qquad\text{as }\varepsilon\downarrow 0 by dominated convergence. Since the matrix exponential is Lipschitz on bounded sets, \sup_{0\leq t\leq T}\left|e^{tL^{\varepsilon}}-e^{t\mathcal{L}}\right|_{\infty}\leq T\,e^{T\|\mathcal{L}\|_{\infty}}\,\left|\int_{B(\varepsilon)}\left(H_{l}\circ h_{V}(x,m)-I\right)\,d\Phi(x,m)\right|_{\infty}. Combining this estimate with ( 8.35 ) and using h_{N}\to 0 (Assumption 3.2 ) yields a continuous function g_{T}:\mathbb{R}_{+}\to\mathbb{R}_{+} with g_{T}(0)=0 such that, for all sufficiently large N , \sup_{0\leq t\leq T}\left|P_{N,l}(t)-e^{t\mathcal{L}}\right|_{\infty}\leq g_{T}(\varepsilon). By taking N to infinity and then \varepsilon to 0 , the result follows. ∎ 9 Discussion In this section we briefly outline some implications of this work for inference methods based on the site frequency spectrum in Section 9.1 . We then discuss future mathematical works for appropriate scaling limits of infinite graph models in Section 9.2 and moment duals to quenched coalescent processes in Section 9.3 . 9.1 Implications for the site frequency spectrum By an argument akin to that in ( 15 , Section 5.2) one can see that the class of integral functionals governing the site-frequency spectrum, namely \tau^{n,r}(\chi^{n})=\int_{0}^{\infty}\#\{C\in\chi^{n}(s):|C|=r\}ds, converge with the population model when G is a connected graph with non-vanishing migration rates, i.e. \mathbb{E}\left[\left(\tau^{n,r}\left(\overline{\chi}^{N,n}\right)\right)_{r=1}^{s}\,\mid\,\mathcal{A}_{N}\right]\,{\mathrel{\mathop{\kern 0.0pt\longrightarrow}\limits^{{d}}}}\,\mathbb{E}\left[\left(\tau^{n,r}\left(\chi^{n}\right)\right)_{r=1}^{s}\,\mid\,\Psi\right]. The limiting model of 36 is precisely that of Example 6.1 . As \Psi for this model has no atoms, the site-frequency spectrum across unlinked loci are independent in the large population limit. In particular, the pairwise coalescence times for samples from unlinked loci are independent in the large population limit. However, this is inconsistent, but only ostensibly , with the simulations of 36 . In Figure 3 of 36 there are clear and marked differences between the predictions for the pairwise coalescence time from the structured coalescent and the conditional coalescent. One explanation for this discrepancy is that the size of migrations are not so negligibly small at the scale of the simulation that their effect vanishes, as it would if the population size were taken sufficiently large. The simulations undertaken in the figure are with a finite population model, where N=100 or N=1000 . While the rescaled migration rate between demes in the large population limit is suitably small, for any finite population size we should really take the quenched coalescent model as if \Phi did not concentrate at 0^{\otimes 2}\otimes\delta_{0}^{\otimes 2} but instead at some 0^{\otimes 2}\otimes M^{\otimes 2} , where M is suitably concentrated close to zero without vanishing. A naive model which captures this behavior is precisely that of Proposition 6.3 where we take b to be large and \alpha_{v}=2 for each v . An applied work investigating precisely how to do this in a robust manner so that pedigree effects could be detected in genetic inference would be of interest. 9.2 Scaling limits of infinite graph models While this work concerns itself with finite graphs, the extension to infinite graph analogue, as discussed in Remark 4.6 is more or less straightforward. What requires quite different techniques and ingenuity would be taking a suitable two-scale limit, where we take an infinite graph model, like a stepping stone model, and show convergence to genealogies evolving in the continuum by rescaling both time and space. In Section 6 , we constructed what we called a discrete approximation of the genealogy of a \Xi Fleming Viot process. While this is outside the scope of this work, we briefly outline the scaling limit one could take. If this can be done, the well-known pain in the torus ( 13 , Section 6.4) could be conquered from an individual based model. Fix a finite measure \nu on \mathbb{R}_{+} such that \int_{\mathbb{R}_{+}}r\,d\nu(r)<\infty , a parameter \lambda>0 , and a finite measure \Xi on \Delta with \int_{\Delta}\langle x,x\rangle\,d\Xi(x)<\infty . For each N\in\mathbb{N} let V_{N}:=\mathbb{Z}^{2}/\langle L_{1}(N),L_{2}(N)\rangle_{\mathbb{Z}} be the discrete two-torus described above, with lattice spacing \rho_{N}>0 and baseline migration parameter \sigma_{N}>0 . Let \chi^{N,n} be the n -sample ancestral process on the pedigree associated to the discrete approximation of the spatial \Xi -Fleming–Viot model on V_{N} , run on the coalescence timescale \left(c_{N}^{v_{0}}\right)^{-1} as in ( 3.1 ), and write \overline{\chi}^{N,n} for the rescaled process. Assume that the geometric scaling is such that \rho_{N}\to 0 and \rho_{N}^{2}\,L_{1}(N)\to\ell_{1}\in(0,\infty),\qquad\rho_{N}^{2}\,L_{2}(N)\to\ell_{2}\in(0,\infty), so that the embedded lattice \rho_{N}V_{N} converges in a suitable sense to the continuum torus \mathbb{T}^{2}_{\ell_{1},\ell_{2}}:=\mathbb{R}^{2}/\langle(\ell_{1},0),(0,\ell_{2})\rangle_{\mathbb{Z}} . Assume further that the baseline migration converges to Brownian motion in the sense that, for each fixed t\geq 0 , a single ancestral lineage under baseline dynamics satisfies \rho_{N}\,\widehat{X}_{1}\left(\big\lfloor t\,\rho_{N}^{-2}\sigma_{N}^{-1}\big\rfloor\right)\,{\mathrel{\mathop{\kern 0.0pt\longrightarrow}\limits^{{d}}}}\,B(t)\qquad\text{in }\mathcal{D}\left(\mathbb{R}_{+},\mathbb{T}^{2}_{\ell_{1},\ell_{2}}\right), where B is Brownian motion on \mathbb{T}^{2}_{\ell_{1},\ell_{2}} . Finally assume that the extreme-event mechanism is tuned so that, under the diffusive scaling, the point process of extreme events converges to a Poisson point process \Gamma on \mathbb{R}_{+}\times\mathbb{T}^{2}_{\ell_{1},\ell_{2}}\times\mathbb{R}_{+} with intensity measure dt\otimes dx\otimes d\nu(r), and that, conditional on an extreme event centered at x\in\mathbb{T}^{2}_{\ell_{1},\ell_{2}} with radius r , all lineages in the ball B(x,r) are instantaneously relocated to x and then undergo an instantaneous multiple merger governed by the \Xi paintbox. Then, for each fixed sample size n , the quenched law of the rescaled discrete genealogical process should converge to that of the spatial \Xi -Fleming-Viot genealogy on \mathbb{T}^{2}_{\ell_{1},\ell_{2}} : more precisely, there should exist a coupling under which \mathbb{P}\left(\overline{\chi}^{N,n}\in\cdot\,\,\mid\,\,\mathcal{A}_{N}\right)\,{\mathrel{\mathop{\kern 0.0pt\longrightarrow}\limits^{{d}}}}\,\mathbb{P}\left(\chi^{n}_{\mathrm{FV}}\in\cdot\,\,\mid\,\,\Gamma\right), weakly in distribution as random probability measures on \mathcal{D}\left(\mathbb{R}_{+},\mathcal{E}_{n}\left(\mathbb{T}^{2}_{\ell_{1},\ell_{2}}\right)\right) , where \chi^{n}_{\mathrm{FV}} is the \mathcal{E}_{n}(\mathbb{T}^{2}_{\ell_{1},\ell_{2}}) -valued Markov process obtained by evolving n independent Brownian motions on \mathbb{T}^{2}_{\ell_{1},\ell_{2}} between atoms of \Gamma , and each atom (t,x,r) of \Gamma performing an instantaneous merger among all blocks whose spatial locations lie in B(x,r) and relocating them to x , and coalescing when two Brownian motions intersect. Of course by adding in an additional sampling mechanism to the discrete model one would expect to capture simultaneous multi-mergers as well. 9.3 Forward-in-time processes Another direction of interest is understanding implications of the quenched structured coalescent for diffusion approximations of allele frequencies. Recall that there is a moment duality between the block counting process for the Kingman coalescent, which counts the number of extant lineages backwards in time, and the Wright-Fisher diffusion, which models the frequency of a neutral allele forward in time. A natural conjecture for our quenched coalescent is that the macroscopic events captured by \Psi should give rise to jumps in the forward in time diffusion process. This has already been observed in the case of \Xi coalescents with selection 16 and for annealed multi-type \Xi coalescents 27 . The new contribution would be in describing precisely how the allele frequencies at unlinked loci are coupled by \Psi . Appendix A The weak convergence criterion for the total offspring numbers and migration probabilities Here we describe conditions under which the convergence of Assumption 3.4 holds. Lemma A.1 (Moment criteria for Assumption 3.4 ) . Suppose that, as N goes to infinity, Assumptions 3.2 and 3.3 hold. For z\in\mathbb{Z}_{+} and k\in\mathbb{N} write (z)_{k}:=z(z-1)\cdots(z-k+1) for the falling factorial. For each v\in V and each N , define the normalisation ratio \rho_{N}(v):=\frac{N(v)}{N^{*}_{N}(v)}. (A.1) Then the following are equivalent: (i) \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N}\to\Phi vaguely on \Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}\setminus\{\mathbf{0}_{V,E}\} for some \sigma -finite measure \Phi (i.e. Assumption 3.4 holds). (ii) For every choice of • a multi-index j=(j_{v})_{v\in V}\in\mathbb{Z}_{+}^{V} for each v\in V (not all zero), • integers k_{v,1},\ldots,k_{v,j_{v}}\geq 2 for each v\in V , • and a multi-index r=(r_{e})_{e\in E}\in\mathbb{Z}_{+}^{E} , the limit \phi\!\left(j,k;r\right):=\lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\,\mathbb{E}\!\left[\,\prod_{e\in E}m_{e}^{r_{e}}\prod_{v\in V}\left\{\rho_{N}(v)^{K_{v}}\,\frac{\prod_{a=1}^{j_{v}}\left(\mathcal{V}_{a}^{v}\right)_{k_{v,a}}}{N(v)^{K_{v}-j_{v}}\,2^{K_{v}}}\right\}\right] (A.2) exists in [0,\infty) , where K_{v}:=\sum_{a=1}^{j_{v}}k_{v,a} and, by convention, empty products equal 1 . Moreover, when these equivalent conditions hold, the limits in ( A.2 ) are given by \phi\!\left(j,k;r\right)=\int_{\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}}\prod_{e\in E}m_{e}^{r_{e}}\prod_{v\in V}\left(\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}i_{1},\ldots,i_{j_{v}}\in\mathbb{N}\\ \text{all distinct}\end{subarray}}(x_{i_{1}}^{v})^{k_{v,1}}\cdots(x_{i_{j_{v}}}^{v})^{k_{v,j_{v}}}\right)\,d\Phi\left(x,m\right). (A.3) Remark A.2 . Note that if we consider the single deme case here, that Equation ( A.2 ) corresponds exactly with [ 7 , Equation 1.6] , which is equivalent to \frac{1}{2c_{N}^{v_{0}}}d\Phi_{N}(x)\to\frac{1}{\langle x,x\rangle}d\Xi(x) vaguely on \Delta\setminus\{\mathbf{0}\} for \Xi a probability measure on \Delta . Proof. Fix \varepsilon>0 and define K_{\varepsilon}:=\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}\setminus B\left(\varepsilon\right), where B\left(\varepsilon\right) denotes the open ball about \mathbf{0}_{V,E} in the product topology. Then K_{\varepsilon} is compact in \Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E} and is bounded away from \mathbf{0}_{V,E} . We begin by reducing vague convergence on the punctured space to weak convergence on K_{\varepsilon} . A function g\in C_{c}\left(\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}\setminus\{\mathbf{0}_{V,E}\}\right) has compact support bounded away from \mathbf{0}_{V,E} , hence there exists \varepsilon>0 such that \mathrm{supp}(g)\subseteq K_{\varepsilon} . Thus, to prove vague convergence of \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N} on the punctured space, it suffices to show that for every \varepsilon>0 the finite measures \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N}\!\restriction_{K_{\varepsilon}} converge weakly on the compact metric space K_{\varepsilon} . Our goal is to introduce an algebra of polynomial test functions on K_{\varepsilon} and show it is uniformly dense in C\left(K_{\varepsilon}\right) . For multi-indices r=(r_{e})_{e\in E}\in\mathbb{Z}_{+}^{E} and for each v\in V integers j_{v}\in\mathbb{Z}_{+} and k_{v,1},\ldots,k_{v,j_{v}}\geq 2 , define the continuous function h_{r,\{j_{v},k_{v,\cdot}\}}(x,m):=\prod_{e\in E}m_{e}^{r_{e}}\prod_{v\in V}\left(\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}i_{1},\ldots,i_{j_{v}}\in\mathbb{N}\\ \text{all distinct}\end{subarray}}(x_{i_{1}}^{v})^{k_{v,1}}\cdots(x_{i_{j_{v}}}^{v})^{k_{v,j_{v}}}\right), (A.4) with the convention that the inner sum equals 1 when j_{v}=0 . Let \mathscr{A} be the algebra of finite linear combinations of such functions, and also allow the purely-migration case j_{v}\equiv 0 provided r\neq 0 . Each h_{r,\{j_{v},k_{v,\cdot}\}} is continuous on \Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E} , hence its restriction to K_{\varepsilon} lies in C\left(K_{\varepsilon}\right) . Polynomials in the coordinates (m_{e})_{e\in E} separate points of [0,1]^{E} . For each fixed v , the symmetric polynomials in the coordinates of x^{v} generated by the power sums \sum_{i}(x_{i}^{v})^{q} with q\geq 2 separate points of \Delta . Therefore \mathscr{A}\cup\{1\} separates points of \Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E} , hence also of K_{\varepsilon} , and contains the constants. By Stone–Weierstrass, \mathscr{A} is uniformly dense in C\left(K_{\varepsilon}\right) . We now show that (ii) implies (i). To this end, we first bound \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N}\left(K_{\varepsilon}\right) uniformly in N using the second-order moments given by (ii). Define the continuous nonnegative function H(x,m):=\sum_{e\in E}m_{e}^{2}+\sum_{v\in V}\sum_{i\in\mathbb{N}}\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle. (A.5) Then H\left(\mathbf{0}_{V,E}\right)=0 and H(x,m)>0 for all (x,m)\neq\mathbf{0}_{V,E} . Since K_{\varepsilon} is compact and does not contain \mathbf{0}_{V,E} , we have h_{\varepsilon}:=\inf_{(x,m)\in K_{\varepsilon}}H(x,m)\;>\;0, and hence the pointwise bound on K_{\varepsilon} , \mathds{1}_{K_{\varepsilon}}(x,m)\leq\frac{1}{h_{\varepsilon}}\,H(x,m). Integrating against \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N} yields \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N}\left(K_{\varepsilon}\right)\leq\frac{1}{h_{\varepsilon}}\,\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int H\,d\Phi_{N}. (A.6) The quantity \int H\,d\Phi_{N} is a finite linear combination of the mixed moments in ( A.2 ): the terms \int\sum_{v}\sum_{i}\langle x^{v},x^{v}\rangle\,d\Phi_{N} correspond to the choice j_{v}=1 , k_{v,1}=2 , r\equiv 0 , while the terms \int m_{e}^{2}\,d\Phi_{N} correspond to the purely-migration case j_{v}\equiv 0 and r_{e}=2 for a single edge e . Thus condition (ii) implies that the right-hand side of ( A.6 ) is bounded uniformly in N , and hence \sup_{N\in\mathbb{N}}\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N}\left(K_{\varepsilon}\right)<\infty\qquad\text{for every fixed }\varepsilon>0. We now show (ii) implies (i). Fix \varepsilon>0 . For each f\in C\left(K_{\varepsilon}\right) we show that the limit \lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int_{K_{\varepsilon}}f\,d\Phi_{N} exists. By uniform density of \mathscr{A} on K_{\varepsilon} , choose h\in\mathscr{A} such that \sup_{K_{\varepsilon}}\left|f-h\right|\leq\delta . Then, using the uniform bound on \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N}\left(K_{\varepsilon}\right) established above, \displaystyle\left|\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int_{K_{\varepsilon}}f\,d\Phi_{N}-\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int_{K_{\varepsilon}}h\,d\Phi_{N}\right| \displaystyle\leq\delta\,\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N}\left(K_{\varepsilon}\right). On the other hand, for h\in\mathscr{A} the limit of \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int h\,d\Phi_{N} exists by assumption (ii) and linearity. Letting N\to\infty and then \delta\downarrow 0 shows that the limit exists for every f\in C\left(K_{\varepsilon}\right) . The map f\longmapsto\lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int_{K_{\varepsilon}}f\,d\Phi_{N} is therefore a positive linear functional on C\left(K_{\varepsilon}\right) . By the Riesz representation theorem on the compact metric space K_{\varepsilon} , there exists a unique finite Borel measure \Phi^{(\varepsilon)} on K_{\varepsilon} such that \lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int_{K_{\varepsilon}}f\,d\Phi_{N}=\int_{K_{\varepsilon}}f\,d\Phi^{(\varepsilon)}\qquad\text{for all }f\in C\left(K_{\varepsilon}\right). If 0<\varepsilon^{\prime}<\varepsilon , then K_{\varepsilon}\subseteq K_{\varepsilon^{\prime}} and uniqueness in Riesz implies \Phi^{(\varepsilon^{\prime})}\!\restriction_{K_{\varepsilon}}=\Phi^{(\varepsilon)} . Hence these measures are consistent and define a unique \sigma -finite Borel measure \Phi on \Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}\setminus\{\mathbf{0}_{V,E}\} by setting \Phi\!\restriction_{K_{\varepsilon}}:=\Phi^{(\varepsilon)} . By construction, \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\Phi_{N}\to\Phi vaguely on \Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}\setminus\{\mathbf{0}_{V,E}\} , proving (i). Our goal is to prove (i) implies (ii) and to identify the limits by rewriting the test integrals in terms of mixed factorial moments. Assume (i). Fix indices (r,j,k) as in (ii) and define the corresponding function h=h_{r,j,k} by ( A.4 ). Fix \varepsilon>0 . Then h\,\mathds{1}_{K_{\varepsilon}} has compact support in the punctured space, hence vague convergence yields \lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int_{K_{\varepsilon}}h\,d\Phi_{N}=\int_{K_{\varepsilon}}h\,d\Phi. Letting \varepsilon\downarrow 0 and using monotone convergence on the increasing compact exhaustion K_{\varepsilon}\uparrow\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}\setminus\{\mathbf{0}_{V,E}\} gives \lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int h\,d\Phi_{N}=\int h\,d\Phi, which is exactly ( A.3 ). Our goal is to rewrite \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int h\,d\Phi_{N} in terms of the mixed factorial expressions in ( A.2 ). Fix v\in V . Since h is symmetric in the coordinates of each x^{v} , we may replace the ranked vector \widetilde{\mathcal{V}}_{N}^{v} by the unranked frequency vector \left(\frac{\mathcal{V}_{1}^{v}}{2N^{*}(v)},\ldots,\frac{\mathcal{V}_{N(v)}^{v}}{2N^{*}(v)},0,0,\ldots\right). Conditional on m , the vector \left(\mathcal{V}_{i}^{v}\right)_{i\in[N(v)]} is exchangeable, hence \displaystyle\mathbb{E}\!\left[\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}i_{1},\ldots,i_{j_{v}}\in[N(v)]\\ \text{distinct}\end{subarray}}\left(\frac{\mathcal{V}_{i_{1}}^{v}}{2N^{*}(v)}\right)^{k_{v,1}}\cdots\left(\frac{\mathcal{V}_{i_{j_{v}}}^{v}}{2N^{*}(v)}\right)^{k_{v,j_{v}}}\,\mid\,m\right] \displaystyle\qquad=(N(v))_{j_{v}}\,\mathbb{E}\!\left[\prod_{a=1}^{j_{v}}\left(\frac{\mathcal{V}_{a}^{v}}{2N^{*}(v)}\right)^{k_{v,a}}\,\mid\,m\right]. For each integer k\geq 2 the polynomial z^{k} is an integer linear combination of falling factorials (z)_{\ell} with 0\leq\ell\leq k and leading term (z)_{k} . Applying this change of basis to each factor \left(\mathcal{V}_{a}^{v}\right)^{k_{v,a}} , expanding the product, and using \frac{1}{\left(2N^{*}(v)\right)^{\ell}}=\rho_{N}(v)^{\ell}\,\frac{1}{2^{\ell}N(v)^{\ell}} rewrites \frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\int h\,d\Phi_{N} as a finite linear combination of expressions of the form ( A.2 ). Therefore the existence of the limits for the functions h is equivalent to the existence of the limits in ( A.2 ), and the limiting values agree with \int h\,d\Phi , i.e. with ( A.3 ). This proves (i) implies (ii) and completes the proof. ∎ Corollary A.3 (A product-form sufficient criterion for Assumption 3.4 ) . Suppose that, as N goes to infinity, Assumptions 3.2 and 3.3 hold. Suppose there exist Radon measures \Phi^{V}_{v} on \Delta\setminus\{\mathbf{0}\} for v\in V and Radon measures \Phi^{E}_{e} on [0,1] for e\in E such that for every choice of j,k,r as in Lemma A.1 that \displaystyle\lim_{N\to\infty} \displaystyle\frac{1}{c_{N}^{v_{0}}}\,\mathbb{E}\!\left[\,\prod_{e\in E}m_{e}^{r_{e}}\prod_{v\in V}\left\{\rho_{N}(v)^{K_{v}}\,\frac{\prod_{a=1}^{j_{v}}\left(\mathcal{V}_{a}^{v}\right)_{k_{v,a}}}{N(v)^{K_{v}-j_{v}}\,2^{K_{v}}}\right\}\right] (A.7) \displaystyle=\prod_{e\in E}\int_{[0,1]}m_{e}^{r_{e}}\,d\Phi^{E}_{e}(m_{e})\prod_{v\in V}\int_{\Delta}\left(\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}i_{1},\ldots,i_{j_{v}}\in\mathbb{N}\\ \text{all distinct}\end{subarray}}(x_{i_{1}})^{k_{v,1}}\cdots(x_{i_{j_{v}}})^{k_{v,j_{v}}}\right)\,d\Phi^{V}_{v}(x). (A.8) Then Assumption 3.4 holds with limit measure \Phi=\left(\bigotimes_{v\in V}\Phi^{V}_{v}\right)\otimes\left(\bigotimes_{e\in E}\Phi^{E}_{e}\right)\qquad\text{on }\Delta^{V}\times[0,1]^{E}\setminus\{\mathbf{0}_{V,E}\}. Moreover, the same conclusion holds if the right-hand side of ( A.7 ) is replaced by a finite sum of such products since Lemma A.1 is linear in \Phi . Appendix B Annealed convergence proof We can proceed now with the proof of Theorem 3.14 . Proof. Lemma A.1 of [ 15 ] , Theorem 4.3 states that, for \mu,\mu_{N} of random probability measures on \mathcal{D}\left(\mathbb{R}_{+},E\right) for E a locally compact Polish space, \mu_{N}\,{\mathrel{\mathop{\kern 0.0pt\longrightarrow}\limits^{{d}}}}\,\mu implies that the intensity measures \mathbb{E}\left[\mu_{N}\right] converges weakly to \mathbb{E}\left[\mu\right] . This implies that the sequence of intensity measures \mathbb{E}\left[\mathbb{P}\left(\overline{\chi}^{N,n}\in\cdot\,\mid\,\mathcal{A}_{N}\right)\right]=\mathbb{P}\left(\overline{\chi}^{N,n}\in\cdot\right) converges weakly to \mathbb{E}\left[\mathbb{P}\left(\chi^{n}\in\cdot\,\mid\,\Psi\right)\right]=\mathbb{P}\left(\chi^{n}\in\cdot\right). Consequently, it suffices to show that \mathbb{P}\left(\chi^{n}\in\cdot\right) is the law of a \left((h_{v})_{*}\Phi,\kappa,\mu\right) - n -coalescent. The coalescence between atom times of \Psi gives precisely K_{n}(\kappa)+M_{n}(\mu) part of the generator. Annealing over \Psi then gives Q_{n}((h_{V})_{*}\Phi)) . ∎