Understanding Pure Textual Reasoning for Blind Image Quality Assessment Yuan Li, Shin’ya Nishida Abstract Textual reasoning has recently been widely adopted in Blind Image Quality Assessment (BIQA). However, it remains unclear how textual information contributes to quality prediction and to what extent text can represent the score-related image contents. This work addresses these questions from an information-flow perspective by comparing existing BIQA models with three paradigms designed to learn the image–text–score relationship: Chain-of-Thought, Self-Consistency, and Autoencoder. Our experiments show that the score prediction performance of the existing model significantly drops when only textual information is used for prediction. Whereas the Chain-of-Thought paradigm introduces little improvement in BIQA performance, the Self-Consistency paradigm significantly reduces the gap between image- and text-conditioned predictions, narrowing the PLCC/SRCC difference to 0.02/0.03. The Autoencoder-like paradigm is less effective in closing the image–text gap, yet it reveals a direction for further optimization. These findings provide insights into how to improve the textual reasoning for BIQA and high-level vision tasks. I Introduction Early research [ 20 , 21 , 10 , 4 , 29 , 25 ] in Blind Image Quality Assessment (BIQA) focused mainly on score prediction, extracting visual features and mapping them to quality scores through classification or regression. Although these models achieved reasonable accuracy, their limited ability to capture higher-level cues (e.g., semantics) restricted their interpretability and generalization. With the rise of multimodal large language models (MLLMs) [ 1 , 18 , 26 , 2 ] , recent approaches [ 30 , 28 , 23 , 5 , 13 , 3 ] have begun to incorporate textual representations into BIQA. Works such as Q-Instruct [ 23 ] , DepictQA [ 28 ] , and Q-Ground [ 5 ] constructed extensive text-annotated datasets, laying a foundation for multimodal BIQA. Q-insight [ 13 ] and Q-Ponder [ 3 ] take a different direction by avoiding costly human annotations and instead leveraging pretrained knowledge, using reinforcement learning to optimize solely for the final quality score. Fig. 1: Image-Text Gap. Traditional BIQA relies on visual features and lacks interpretability. Although MLLM-based BIQA generates both captions and scores, their relationship remains unclear. We examine the performance gap between image-based and text-based score prediction to reveal how textual reasoning contributes to interpretable BIQA. However, previous work on MLLM models has not clearly established the role of textural captions in BIQA apart from providing explanations. Briqa [ 14 ] has shown that, under supervised fine-tuning, models may bypass the intermediate text altogether when predicting scores. Q-Align [ 24 ] even removes the textual reasoning step entirely and directly fits MLLMs for score regression, achieving state-of-the-art (sota) performance. These observations raise an important question: how much do the generated text captions truly contribute to quality prediction, and to what extent does the model actually engage in textual reasoning rather than merely producing superficial explanations? Motivated by these questions, we adopt an information-flow perspective to examine how effectively text alone can convey quality-related information and how different learning paradigms influence the image–text gap. To this end, we systematically study three training paradigms: (1) a Chain-of-Thought paradigm, (2) a Self-Consistency paradigm, and (3) an Autoencoder-like paradigm. We analyze the differences among the three paradigms from three perspectives. First, in terms of score prediction performance, the CoT paradigm provides almost no benefit, whereas both the Self-Consistency and Autoencoder-like paradigms reduce the image–text performance gap, with Self-Consistency showing the most notable improvement. Second, we examine token-level attention patterns during reasoning. The CoT paradigm behaves similarly to the baseline model, focusing on terms such as “focus” and “clear.” In contrast, the Self-Consistency paradigm shifts attention toward score-related words like “good” and “moderate,” while the Autoencoder-like paradigm highlights cues like “blurry” and “focus.” Finally, to assess whether the score-related words introduce shortcuts, we remove such score-related terms. The resulting performance drop is negligible, indicating that the models rely on additional implicit quality cues and possess stronger reasoning ability. These findings clarify how training paradigms shape internal reasoning and provide insights for developing more reliable BIQA systems. Our contributions are two-fold: • From an information-flow perspective, we systematically evaluate three training paradigms for learning textual representations of image quality. Our analysis provides a structured baseline for studying textual reasoning in BIQA and clarifies how different paradigms shape text-conditioned performance. • Our framework is general and can be applied to other downstream tasks that lack intermediate reasoning annotations. It offers a mechanism to induce task-specific and interpretable textual explanations, enabling broader use in multimodal and vision-centric applications. II Related Works II-A MLLM-based BIQA Systems With the rapid progress of MLLMs, which demonstrate strong capabilities in textual description and reasoning, recent researches [ 28 , 23 , 5 , 13 , 3 ] have begun to explore training MLLMs for BIQA through supervised fine-tuning (SFT) or reinforcement learning (RL). These approaches aim to construct a more interpretable assessment system. Representative works such as DepictQA [ 28 ] , Q-Instruct [ 23 ] , Q-Insight [ 13 ] , and Q-Ponder [ 3 ] are all devoted to building text-based interpretable systems for BIQA. Despite the presence of textual reasoning processes, these methods generally lack explicit evaluation of the quality or validity of the generated explanations. HumanIqa [ 15 ] supervises the reasoning and compares prediction performance under image- and text-conditioned settings. However, it relies on additional human-annotated reasoning data and provides limited analysis of how text-conditioned learning itself emerges or contributes to BIQA performance. Motivated by these observations, we aim to investigate how textual tokens contribute to BIQA and how the gap between image- and text-conditioned performance can be effectively bridged, thus providing deeper insight into the role of language in MLLM-based BIQA systems. II-B Interpretable Visual Reasoning Visual reasoning is a fundamental task of visual question answering (VQA) and MLLMs. Its primary goal is to infer answers by analyzing visual content and following a structured reasoning process. In many standard visual reasoning tasks, models benefit from abundant supervision such as question–answer pairs, attribute annotations, or annotated explanations that explicitly guide the intermediate steps of reasoning. However, for more complex perceptual tasks such as BIQA, effective supervision for intermediate reasoning is largely unavailable. To address the broader challenge of missing reasoning supervision, recent general-purpose reasoning systems have explored self-improving or self-rewarding strategies. MM-CoT [ 31 ] demonstrates how modality-specific CoT learning in both image and text domains enhances the reasoning capabilities of MLLMs, while Vision-SR1 [ 16 ] shows that such models can further improve by generating and evaluating their own reasoning processes without relying on external annotations. Inspired by these, we propose a related self-consistency strategy tailored for BIQA. Our method leverages the model’s pre-trained image captioning capability as a form of self-supervised signal, encouraging the model to refine its internal reasoning pathway and learn a more coherent quality projection, even in the absence of explicit CoT labels. III Methods Fig. 2: Training Paradigms. All models share the same MLLM backbone and perform two forward passes, where “1st” and “2nd” denote the first and second forward inferences of the same model. The 1st pass is always conditioned on the image. (a) Chain-of-Thought: The model first generates N caption candidates from the image; each caption then produces M score predictions through an independent second-stage inference. (b) Self-Consistency: The first pass outputs N (caption, score) pairs, and each caption undergoes an additional inference step for score regression, receiving a self-consistency reward. (c) Autoencoder-like: The model takes the image and the ground-truth MOS during the first pass to generate reasoning text; the second pass regresses the score solely from this reasoning text. III-A Overview of Information-Flows In this work, we investigate the information flow among image, text, and score in BIQA. We first consider a sequential formulation in which information flows from image to reasoning and then to score, denoted as \boldsymbol{I\rightarrow R\rightarrow\hat{S}} , where each stage is treated independently in a Markov-style manner. We refer to this paradigm as Chain-of-Thought (CoT) , assuming that the generated text R can fully represent image quality information and directly support score prediction. We also introduce a Self-Consistency paradigm that relaxes the strict separation between modalities. In this setting, the model performs score prediction in two stages: the first pass follows \boldsymbol{I\rightarrow(R,\hat{S})} with visual information preserved, while the second pass relies solely on textual reasoning, following \boldsymbol{R\rightarrow\hat{S}} . This design encourages the model to acquire text-based reasoning ability while maintaining consistency with image-conditioned predictions. Finally, we move beyond the forward formulation by reversing the information flow. In this Autoencoder-like paradigm, the model is explicitly provided with the ground-truth score and trained to generate explanations that justify it, following \boldsymbol{(I,S^{\ast})\rightarrow R\rightarrow\hat{S}} . This formulation explores how quality-aware supervision shapes textual explanations. III-B Chain-of-Thought Reasoning Learning As illustrated in Fig. 2 (a), the model generates N reasoning traces. The i -th reasoning trace produces M score predictions, denoted as s_{i,j} for i=1,\dots,N and j=1,\dots,M . As in ( 1 ), each score prediction s_{i,j} receives a reward r_{i,j} , where x is the absolute difference between the predicted score and ground-truth MOS, and t controls the tolerance margin. The reward for the i -th reasoning trace is then obtained by averaging the rewards of its M predictions as in ( 2 ). Higher values of R_{i} increase the generation probability of the corresponding sentence by strengthening the loss term defined in ( 3 ). In ( 3 ), \mathcal{L} denotes the cross-entropy loss, I , R , and S denote the image, reasoning (text), and quality score, respectively, while \alpha and \beta are hyper-parameters that enable or disable the loss terms associated with different training stages. r_{i,j}=\begin{cases}0.5\big(1+\cos(\pi x/t)\big),&\text{if }x