Exploring the ultra-faint dwarf Boötes I using JWST and HST: Metallicity distribution and binaries F. Muratore, M. V. Legnardi, A. P. Milone, A. Mastrobuono-Battisti, G. Cordoni, L. N. Gorza, E. P. Lagioia, E. Bortolan, E. Dondoglio, A. F. Marino, T. Ziliotto Abstract Ultra-faint dwarf galaxies (UFDs) are among the oldest and most metal-poor stellar systems in the Universe. Their metallicity distribution encodes the fossil record of the earliest star formation, feedback, and chemical enrichment, providing crucial tests of models of the first stars, galaxy assembly, and dark matter halos. However, due to their faint luminosities and the limited number of bright giants, spectroscopic studies of UFDs typically probe only small stellar samples. Here, we present an analysis of multi-epoch Hubble Space Telescope and James Webb Space Telescope observations of the UFD Boötes I. Using deep color–magnitude diagram in the F606W and F322W2 bands, extending from the subgiant branch to the M-dwarfs, and stellar proper motions to identify likely members, we obtained an unprecedentedly clean census of the system. The exquisite quality of the diagram, combined with the sensitivity of M-dwarf colors to metallicity, allowed us to constrain the metallicity distribution in a large stellar sample. As a first step, we derived the binary fraction in Boötes I. This is crucial, since binaries can bias kinematic mass estimates, affect stellar population analyses, and shape the photometric signatures used to infer metallicity. We find that 20 ± 2 \pm 2 % of stellar systems in Boötes I are binaries with mass ratios larger than 0.4, corresponding to a total binary fraction of ∼ \sim 30%. This value is comparable to the binary fractions observed in globular clusters of similar stellar mass, suggesting that the presence of dark matter does not significantly affect the binary properties of Boötes I. We then exploited the metallicity sensitivity of M-dwarf colors to derive the metallicity distribution function. We find that most of the stars ∼ \sim 85% have [Fe/H] < − 2 <-2 , and that roughly ∼ \sim 17% have [Fe/H] < − 3 <-3 . 1 Introduction Ultra-faint dwarf galaxies (UFDs) are among the oldest and most chemically primitive stellar systems known, typically defined as having total luminosities below 10 5 L ⊙ (e.g. 44 , and references therein) . Over the past two decades, numerous UFDs have been identified through wide-field imaging surveys ( 7 ; 47 ; 16 , e.g.) . Although they may superficially resemble globular clusters (GCs), UFDs display distinctive structural and dynamical properties that clearly distinguish them as separate systems. One of the most intriguing features of UFDs is their extreme dark matter content: their total dynamical masses exceed the stellar mass by factors of 10 2 –10 4 , corresponding to mass-to-light ratios of similar magnitude ( 43 ; 27 ; 4 , e.g.) . Owing to their relative proximity, UFDs represent unique laboratories for probing the nature and distribution of dark matter on the smallest galactic scales. Moreover, owing to their extremely low baryonic content and their residence in low-mass, dark-matter–dominated halos, UFDs represent ideal laboratories for constraining the nature of dark matter and for testing models proposed to explain the missing satellite problem ( 44 ) . Furthermore, deep Hubble Space Telescope (HST) observations have shown that the stellar populations of UFDs are predominantly ancient, supporting the view that they are “fossil” galaxies—systems that formed most of their stars before reionization and subsequently ceased forming stars ( 9 ) . Reliable estimates of the dark matter content in UFDs are currently obtained from measurements of the radial–velocity dispersion of their member stars. Early studies already indicated that UFDs contain a large amount of dark matter based on their unexpectedly high velocity dispersions. For example, pioneering work on Boötes I and Ursa Major I reported dispersions of 9.3^{+11.7}_{-1.2}\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}} and 11.9^{+3.5}_{-2.3}\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}} , respectively, values far larger than the \sim 0.1\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}} expected from their stellar mass alone ( 33 ; 18 ) . However, unresolved binary systems can artificially inflate the observed velocity dispersion, leading to overestimates of the inferred dark matter mass ( 45 ; 40 ) . Consequently, constraining the binary fraction and the properties of binary stars is essential for obtaining robust dynamical measurements ( 13 ; 45 ; 46 ; 26 ) . Another intriguing characteristic of UFDs is the considerable variation in iron (Fe) and \alpha -element abundances observed among their stars, interpreted as the result of extended star formation episodes and internal chemical enrichment ( 43 ; 17 ) . These chemical patterns contrast sharply with those seen in GCs, which generally display much smaller star-to-star metallicity variations ( 21 ; 24 , e.g.) , resembling those observed in brighter dwarf galaxies. At the same time, UFDs are less complex than massive galaxies, making them ideal laboratories for studying the fundamental mechanisms that govern chemical evolution in low-mass galaxies. However, metallicity determinations mostly rely on spectroscopy of red giant branch (RGB) stars, which are typically few in number ( 20 ; 36 ; 11 ) . This limitation arises from the sensitivity of current telescopes, which cannot obtain high-resolution spectra for faint stars, combined with the sparsely populated RGBs characteristic of most UFDs. In this paper, we take advantage of imaging data collected with the HST and the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) to study Boötes I, one of the most extensively investigated UFDs. The resulting high-precision photometry enables us to pursue two main goals: (i) the determination of the metallicity distribution, and (ii) the characterization of the binary fraction along the main sequence (MS). Discovered by 8 , Boötes,I has since been the subject of numerous investigations of its stellar populations and chemical composition. With a luminosity of L_{V}=2.8\times 10^{4},L_{\odot} , Boötes I is among the brightest known UFDs. Using the Ca ii K line–strength index, 35 reported a mean [Fe/H] of -2.51\pm 0.13 for a sample of 16 stars. Further high-resolution spectroscopic studies have confirmed a mean value of \langle\mathrm{[Fe/H]}\rangle\simeq-2.6 , a wide iron range of \sim 2 dex, and very metal-poor stars with [Fe/H] <-3.5 ( 37 ; 20 ; 41 ) . As noted above, Boötes I exhibits a relatively large line-of-sight velocity dispersion, implying a high mass-to-light ratio and a significant dark-matter component. Boötes I is composed of old stellar populations and hosts a conspicuous fraction of binaries. From an analysis of the color-magnitude diagram (CMD) based on HST data, 9 inferred an age of about 13 Gyr, while 12 used the same data to constrain a binary fraction of \sim 0.28 to characterize the mass function. The main structural and physical properties of Bo”otes I are summarized in Table 1 . The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 describes the dataset and the methods for deriving high-precision photometry and astrometry. In Sect. 3 , we present the CMD of Boötes I. Section 4 describes the methods to infer the metallicity distribution of stars in Boötes I by using photometry of M-dwarfs, while Sect. 5 is dedicated to the determination of the binary fraction and the investigation of the binary stars in Boötes I. Finally, Sect. 6 provides a summary and a discussion of the results. Table 1: Main observational and physical parameters of Boötes I. Parameter Value Reference RA(J2000) 14^{h}00^{m}06^{s} 1 Dec.(J2000) + 14^{\circ}30^{\prime}00^{\prime\prime} 1 M_{V} -5.92 \pm 0.2 mag 2 D 65 \pm 3 kpc 2 r_{h} 12.5 \pm 0.3 arcmin 2 r_{t} 33.1 \pm 4.0 arcmin 3 [Fe/H] -2.55 \pm 0.11 3 M_{*} 3.4\pm 0.3\times 10^{4}M_{\odot} 4 M_{dyn} 4.9^{+1.3}_{-1.2}\times 10^{6}M_{\odot} 5 References:(1) 8 , (2) 39 , (3) 19 , (4) 25 , (5) 15 2 Data The data for this study were obtained from HST GO 12549 (PI: Brown), GO 15317 (PI: Platais), and JWST GO 3849 (PI: Gennaro). Table 2: Summary of the HST and JWST imaging data used in this study. Since the three observed fields share the same number of exposures and exposure times, we report these values only once. Filter Instrument Camera N x Exposure time Date Program PI F606W HST WFC/ACS 2 x 500 + 2 x 670 s May 25 - June 13 2012 12549 Brown F814W HST WFC/ACS 2 x 430 + 2 x 670 s May 25 - June 13 2012 12549 Brown F606W HST WFC/ACS 8 x 1224 s June 10 - 29 2019 15317 Platais F814W HST WFC/ACS 8 x 1258 s June 10 - 29 2019 15317 Platais F322W2 JWST NIRCam 20 x 945 s July 6 2024 3849 Gennaro F150W JWST NIRCam 20 x 945 s July 6 2024 3849 Gennaro To investigate the binaries and low-mass stars of Boötes I, we used F606W images from the Wide Field Channel of the Advanced Camera for Surveys (ACS/WFC) on board the HST, together with F322W2 images from the Near-Infrared Camera (NIRCam) on board the JWST. As discussed in detail in Sects. 4 and 5 , the CMD based on these filters maximizes the separation between single and binary stars and is highly sensitive to the chemical composition of M dwarfs. In addition, we used data collected with the ACS/WFC F814W filter and the NIRCam F150W filter to derive stellar proper motions and to separate Boötes I members from field stars. Because our analysis focuses on precise photometry of faint stars, we considered only the three fields observed in F606W during both GO programs 12549 and 15317. Figure 1 illustrates the footprints of the images used for photometry, and Table 2 summarizes the main properties of the full dataset. Figure 1: Footprints of the HST and JWST images used in this work are shown in red and green, respectively, in the top-left panel. The bottom-left panel displays the stacked NIRCam/F322W2 image used in our analysis. The right panel shows a three-colour composite image of the region marked with a red square in the bottom-left panel, where the blue, green, and red channels correspond to the stacked F606W, F814W, and F322W2 images, respectively. Stellar photometry and astrometry was carried out using Jay Anderson’s KS2 software package, an advanced evolution of the ACS/WFC reduction code presented by 2 . KS2 processes all exposures simultaneously and implements three complementary photometric strategies, each optimized for a different stellar brightness regime ( 42 ; 6 ; 28 , e.g. ) . Method I detects sources that produce a significant peak within a 5 \times 5 pixel region after neighbor subtraction. For each star, KS2 measures flux and position in every exposure by fitting an effective point-spread function (ePSF; 1 ) tailored to the star’s detector location. The sky background is estimated in an annulus spanning 4 to 8 pixels, and final measurements are obtained by averaging results from all images. Methods II and III are designed for stars too faint for robust PSF fitting. Both begin by subtracting neighboring stars and then derive fluxes from aperture photometry. Method II performs weighted aperture photometry in a 5 \times 5 pixel box, reducing the contribution of pixels affected by crowding and adopting the same sky estimate as Method I. Method III is optimized for very crowded regions and for faint stars with numerous exposures available. It uses a circular aperture of radius 0.75 pixels and determines the local background from an annulus between 2 and 4 pixels from the stellar position. KS2 also offers a suite of diagnostics to assess photometric quality. To ensure high-precision results, we retained only isolated stars that are well fitted by the ePSF model (see Section 2.4 of 28 ). The photometry was calibrated to the Vega magnitude system following the procedure described in 28 , using the appropriate encircled-energy corrections and zero points provided by STScI. 1 1 1 STScI calibration resources are available at: ACS: www.stsci.edu/hst/instrumentation/acs/data-analysis/photometric-calibration ; NIRCam: https://jwst-docs.stsci.edu/jwst-near-infrared-camera/nircam-calibrations . We accounted for pixel–area variations and corrected the coordinates for geometric distortion using the solutions of 3 for ACS/WFC, and those provided by Jay Anderson for NIRCam data. 2 2 2 https://www.stsci.edu/stsci-research/research-directory/jay-anderson . Finally, we derived proper motions by comparing stellar positions at multiple epochs, and used them to select the bulk of Boötes members employed in the analysis presented in this paper (see 28 , for details) . We conducted artificial-star (AS) tests to estimate photometric errors and to generate the simulated CMD. Following the method outlined by 2 , we created a list of 10^{6} ASs. These ASs were designed to mimic the radial distribution and luminosity function of the observed stars, and were placed along the fiducial line from the base of the RGB to the bottom of the MS. To derive magnitudes and positions for the ASs, we employed the KS2 program, using the same procedures applied to the real stars. Our analysis focused exclusively on relatively isolated ASs that exhibited good PSF fits and satisfied the same selection criteria adopted for the real stars. Figure 2: m_{\rm F322W2} vs. m_{\rm F606W}-m_{\rm F322W2} CMD of Boötes I. The red bars indicate the average photometric errors. 3 The color-magnitude diagram of Boötes I Figure 2 shows the m_{\mathrm{F322W2}} versus m_{\mathrm{F606W}}-m_{\mathrm{F322W2}} CMD of Boötes I, together with the average error bars, derived from ASs. The CMD is predominantly populated by MS stars, which define a well-visible sequence extending for approximately four F322W2 magnitudes below the turn-off ( m_{\mathrm{F322W2}}=25.5 mag). A significant population of MS–MS binary systems is clearly visible on the red side of the MS, while the sub-giant branch (SGB) and RGB are sparsely populated in the upper part of the diagram. There is no evidence for a large magnitude spread among SGB stars. The MS color broadening varies noticeably with magnitude: it is approximately 0.03 mag around the turn-off, increases to 0.08 mag at m_{\mathrm{F322W2}}\sim 23.3 mag, where it becomes comparable to that expected from observational uncertainties alone, and then suddenly increases for m_{\mathrm{F322W2}}\gtrsim 24.0 mag. Section 4 exploits the faint MS stars to constrain the metallicity distribution of stars in Boötes I, taking advantage of the fact that their color is strongly correlated with the chemical composition of this UFD. In Sect. 5 , we take advantage of the narrow and well-defined upper MS to estimate the binary fraction. 4 Metallicity distribution To better understand the CMD of Boötes I, we compare in the left panel of Fig. the observed CMD with isochrones. The adopted metallicity values range from [Fe/H] = -3.4 to -1.55 , whereas the corresponding values of [ \alpha /Fe] for each isochrone are derived from the relation between [ \alpha /Fe] and [Fe/H] inferred from 11 : (1) (2) Theisochroneswith[Fe/H] ≥-3.2 aretakenfromtheBaSTIdatabase\cite[citep]{(\@@bibref{AuthorsPhrase1Year}{hidalgo2018a}{\@@citephrase{, }}{})},whilethoseformoremetal-poorpopulationswerederivedbylinearlyinterpolatingthecolorsandmagnitudesbetweenthe[Fe/H]\penalty\ =\penalty\ 3 3 3 http://basti-iac.oa-abruzzo.inaf.it/isocs.html - 3.0and - 3.2BaSTIisochrones.Weobtainthebestfitbyassumingadistancemodulusof (m-M)_0=18.86 ,aforegroundreddeningof E(B-V)=0.10 \penalty\ mag,andagesof14--11\penalty\ Gyr.\par Notably,theseisochronesencompassthebulkofstarsalongtheentireMSandindicatethattheobservedvariationinMSwidthasafunctionofmagnitudeisconsistentwithstellarpopulationscharacterizedbydifferentmetallicities.Inparticular,theisochronesrevealthatthecolorbroadeningofthelowerMS( m_F322W2 ≳24.4 )stronglydependsonchemicalcomposition,whereasthecoloroftheMSsegmentbetween m_F322W2 ∼22.5 and24.4islessaffectedbymetallicityvariations,astheisochronesplottedinFig.\penalty\ \ref{cmd}reducetheircolorseparationandevenoverlapwithinthismagnitudeinterval.\par\begin{figure*}\centering\includegraphics[width]{figs/cmd_vert2.png} \@@toccaption{{\lx@tag[ ]{{3}}{ $m_{\rm F322W2}$ vs.\,$m_{\rm F606W}-m_{\rm F322W2}$ CMD of Bo\"{o}tes\,I (left panel) and $m_{\rm F322W2}$ vs.\,$\Delta_{\rm F606W,F322W2}$ verticalized diagram of the lower MS (right panel). We superimpose on the CMD nine isochrones with varying [Fe/H] and [$\alpha$/Fe], as indicated in the inset. The isochrones used to verticalize the diagram are shown with continuous lines. }}}\@@caption{{\lx@tag[: ]{{Figure 3}}{ $m_{\rm F322W2}$ vs.\,$m_{\rm F606W}-m_{\rm F322W2}$ CMD of Bo\"{o}tes\,I (left panel) and $m_{\rm F322W2}$ vs.\,$\Delta_{\rm F606W,F322W2}$ verticalized diagram of the lower MS (right panel). We superimpose on the CMD nine isochrones with varying [Fe/H] and [$\alpha$/Fe], as indicated in the inset. The isochrones used to verticalize the diagram are shown with continuous lines. }}}\par\@add@centering\end{figure*}\par ToinvestigatethemetallicitydistributionofBo\"{o}tes\,Istars,weselectedMSstarswithintheCMDregiondefinedby 24.5 ¡ m_F322W2 ¡ 25.5 \penalty\ mag,wherestellarcolorsarestronglyaffectedbymetallicity.Followingtheproceduredescribedin\cite[citet]{\@@bibref{Authors Phrase1YearPhrase2}{milone2017}{\@@citephrase{(}}{\@@citephrase{)}}},weverticalizedtheselectedstarssuchthattheisochroneswith[Fe/H]\penalty\ =-3.2 and[Fe/H]\penalty\ =-1.7 (blueandredsolidlinesinFig.\penalty\ \ref{cmd})aremappedontoverticallineswithabscissaeequalto0and1,respectively.Foreachstar,wecomputedthepseudo-colorparameter\begin{equation}\Delta_{\mathrm{F606W,F322W2}}=\frac{X-X_{\mathrm{red\,isochrone}}}{X_{\mathrm{red\,isochrone}}-X_{\mathrm{blue\,isochrone}}},\end{equation}where X representsthecolorofthestarintheCMD.\par TheresultingverticalizeddiagramisshownintherightpanelofFig.\penalty\ \ref{cmd}.Theparameter Δ_F606W,F322W2 servesasaproxyforthemetallicitydistribution.Figure\penalty\ \ref{kde_cdf}displaysthekernel( ϕ ),evaluatedusingaGaussiankernelwithabandwidthof0.1,andthecumulative( ρ )distributionsof Δ_F606W,F322W2 assolidblacklines.Thesedistributionsareapproximatelysymmetric,withthemajorityofMSstarsexhibitingintermediatevaluesof Δ_F606W,F322W2 .\par\par\begin{figure}\centering\includegraphics[width]{figs/KDE_CDF_simulations.png} \@@toccaption{{\lx@tag[ ]{{4}}{ Kernel (top) and cumulative (bottom) distributions of $\Delta_{\rm F606W,F322W2}$ for faint MS stars. The black curves are derived from the observed Bo\"{o}tes\,I members, while the coloured curves are obtained from the simulated CMDs. }}}\@@caption{{\lx@tag[: ]{{Figure 4}}{ Kernel (top) and cumulative (bottom) distributions of $\Delta_{\rm F606W,F322W2}$ for faint MS stars. The black curves are derived from the observed Bo\"{o}tes\,I members, while the coloured curves are obtained from the simulated CMDs. }}} \@add@centering\end{figure}\par Togatherinformationonmetallicity,wecomparedtheobservedphotometrywithsimulateddiagrams.WeusedASstogenerateseventeensimulatedCMDscorrespondingtosimplestellarpopulationswithmetallicitiesrangingfrom[Fe/H]= - 1.7to - 3.2instepsof0.1\penalty\ dex,assumingtherelationbetween[ α /Fe]and[Fe/H](Eq.\ref{eq1})inferredfrom\cite[cite]{\@@bibref{Authors Phrase1YearPhrase2}{frebel2016}{\@@citephrase{(}}{\@@citephrase{)}}}.Inaddition,weproducedtwolimitingsimulatedCMDcorrespondingtostellarpopulationswith[Fe/H]= - 3.4and - 1.55.Abinaryfractionof0.30wasadopted,withaflatmass--ratiodistribution.TheinputcolorsandmagnitudesoftheASswereobtainedfromtheBaSTIisochrones.Wederivedthe Δ_F606W,F322W2 pseudo-colorforstarsineachsimulateddiagrambyapplyingthesamemethodologyandadoptingthesamemagnituderangeasfortheobservedstars.InFig.\,\ref{kde_cdf},wecomparethekernel-densityandcumulativedistributionsoftheobservedstars(blacklines)withthosederivedfromthesimulatedCMDs.\par ToestimatethemetallicitydistributionofBo\"{o}tes\,I,weadaptedtothesampleofMSstarsidentifiedinFig.\,\ref{cmd}themethodintroducedby\cite[citet]{\@@bibref{Authors Phrase1YearPhrase2}{stauffer1980}{\@@citephrase{(}}{\@@citephrase{)}}}andwidelyadoptedforstudyingstellarpopulations\cite[citep]{(\@@bibref{AuthorsPhrase1Year}{cignoni2010a, cordoni2022a, legnardi2022}{\@@citephrase{, }}{}, e.g.)}.Inessence,wecomparedthecumulative Δ_F606W,F322W2 distributionoflargenumbersofsimulatedstellarpopulationswiththeobservedone.\par Weconstructedacompositesimulatedpopulationbysummingtheindividualmodelpopulations,assigningtoeachpopulation$j$aweightingfactor$c_{j}$thatdefinesitsfractionalcontributiontothetotalnumberofstarsintheresulting Δ_F606W,F322W2 cumulativedistribution.Thecoefficient$c_{j}$rangesbetween0and1.Thecompositecumulativedistributionwasthenquantitativelycomparedwiththeobserveddistributionthroughaclassical$\chi^{2}$minimizationprocedure.Thisoptimizationwasperformedusingtheopen-source\texttt{pyGAD}package,whichprovidesthearrayofcoefficients$c_{j}$describingtherelativecontributionofeachmodelpopulationtothebest-fittingcumulativedistributionoftheBo\"{o}tes\,Istars.\par Thebottom-leftpanelofFig.\penalty\ \ref{met}comparestheobservedcumulativedistributionwiththebest-fitmodel.Forcompleteness,theupper-leftpanelofthesamefigureshowsthecomparisonbetweentheobservedkernel-densitydistributionandthatderivedfromthebest-fitsimulation.AsshowninTable\,\ref{tab2},thebest-fittingsimulateddistributiongivesameanironabundanceof[Fe/H]\penalty\ 4 4 4 We used pyGAD ( https://pygad.readthedocs.io/ ), a genetic algorithm Python library that reduces the likelihood of convergence to a local rather than a global minimum. The coefficients were normalized using a softmax function, ensuring that their sum equals unity and can be interpreted as fractional contributions resulting from the minimization. =-2.53±0.05 andadispersionof 0.41±0.03 \penalty\ dex.Thesevaluesareconsistentwithspectroscopicmeasurements,[Fe/H]\penalty\ =-2.59±0.06 ,withadispersionof 0.38±0.05 \penalty\ dex\cite[citep]{(\@@bibref{AuthorsPhrase1Year}{lai2011}{\@@citephrase{, }}{})}.ThecorrespondingmetallicityhistogramisshownintherightandmiddlepanelsofFig.\penalty\ \ref{met},revealingamainpeakneartheaveragemetallicityvalue.Themostmetal-poorstarshave[Fe/H]\penalty\ ∼-3.4 ,andtheirnumbergraduallyincreasesuptothemaximumaroundthemeanmetallicity.Thenumberofstarsthendecreasestowardhighermetallicities,withatailofstarshaving[Fe/H]\penalty\ ≳-2 .Finally,therightpanelsofFig.\penalty\ \ref{met}comparetheobserved(top)andsimulated(bottom)CMDs,zoomedinonthefaintendoftheMS,highlightingthestrongsimilaritybetweenthetwodiagrams.\par\begin{figure*}\centering\includegraphics[width]{figs/met_dis_kde.png} \@@toccaption{{\lx@tag[ ]{{5}}{ {Left:} Comparison between the observed (black) and best-fit simulated (green) kernel (top) and cumulative (bottom) distributions of $\Delta_{\rm F606W,F322W2}$. {Middle:} [Fe/H] histogram that best reproduces the observations of Bo\"{o}tes\,I. The dashed black distribution is from a spectroscopic survey from \cite[cite]{\@@bibref{Authors Phrase1YearPhrase2}{lai2011}{\@@citephrase{(}}{\@@citephrase{)}}}. {Right:} Comparison between the observed (top) and simulated (bottom) CMDs, zoomed in on the MS region used to infer the metallicity distribution. The colors of the simulated stars indicate their iron abundance, as shown in the middle panel. }}}\@@caption{{\lx@tag[: ]{{Figure 5}}{ {Left:} Comparison between the observed (black) and best-fit simulated (green) kernel (top) and cumulative (bottom) distributions of $\Delta_{\rm F606W,F322W2}$. {Middle:} [Fe/H] histogram that best reproduces the observations of Bo\"{o}tes\,I. The dashed black distribution is from a spectroscopic survey from \cite[cite]{\@@bibref{Authors Phrase1YearPhrase2}{lai2011}{\@@citephrase{(}}{\@@citephrase{)}}}. {Right:} Comparison between the observed (top) and simulated (bottom) CMDs, zoomed in on the MS region used to infer the metallicity distribution. The colors of the simulated stars indicate their iron abundance, as shown in the middle panel. }}}\par\@add@centering\end{figure*}\par\par\par 5 The Binary Map To investigate the population of binaries along the MS of Boötes I, we introduce a Binary Map , a new diagnostic tool analogous to the chromosome map of GCs, designed to distinguish binaries with different mass ratios. This diagram is based on the well-known photometric properties of unresolved binary systems composed of two MS stars, which appear as single point-like sources with a total magnitude m_{\mathrm{bin}}=m_{1}-2.5\log\left(1+\frac{F_{2}}{F_{1}}\right), (5) where m_{1} is the magnitude of the primary (brightest) star, and F_{1} and F_{2} are the fluxes of the primary and secondary components, respectively. In a simple stellar population, the flux of MS stars depends on their mass, following a specific mass-luminosity relation. As a consequence, the total magnitude of a binary system composed of two MS stars can be uniquely determined by the mass of the primary component and the mass ratio, q=M_{2}/M_{1} , where M_{1} and M_{2} are the masses of the primary and secondary stars. To construct the Binary Map , we used the setup illustrated in Fig. 6 , where the shaded area superimposed on the CMD of Boötes I highlights the region, hereafter referred to as region A, used to study the binary systems. This region includes single stars with 22.50.4}=0.20\pm 0.02 . Assuming this mass-ratio distribution, we infer an overall binary fraction of f_{\mathrm{bin}}^{\mathrm{TOT}}=0.30\pm 0.03 , taking into account a minimum mass of 0.075 M_{\odot} for the secondary star. The derived parameters are summarized in Table 3 . Figure 8 shows a comparison between the observed Boötes I and the simulated CMDs with the derived binary fraction, metallicity distribution, and ages from 11 to 14 Gyr. Figure 8: Comparison of the observed (left) and simulated (right) CMD of Boötes I. 5.2 Comparison with clusters and field stars The binary fraction measured in Boötes I is comparable to that typically observed in Galactic open clusters ( 10 ) , and in Magellanic Cloud clusters ( 32 ) , and significantly higher than that found in most GCs ( 31 ; 29 ) . This comparison is illustrated in the left and central panels of Fig. 9 . The left panel shows the anticorrelation between the binary fraction in GCs ( 31 ; 29 ) and the mass of the host cluster ( 5 ) . Remarkably, when considering only the stellar mass ( 15 ) , Boötes I exhibits a binary fraction similar to that of GCs with comparable masses. In contrast, when the dynamical mass ( 25 ) is adopted, Boötes I deviates from the relation followed by the bulk of GCs. Noticeably, a large binary fraction is comparable to that typically observed in Galactic open clusters ( 10 ) , and in Magellanic Cloud clusters ( 32 ) . For completeness, the middle panel of Fig. 9 shows the relation between the binary fraction and the concentration parameter, defined as the ratio between the half-light radius and the tidal radius of the stellar system. The concentration parameter is often used to distinguish GCs from UFDs. We adopted GC structural parameters from the 2010 edition of the 14 catalog, and those for Boötes I from 39 and 19 . As expected, Boötes I exhibits a larger r_{\rm h}/r_{\rm t} ratio than that typically observed in GCs. There is no clear evidence for a strong correlation between the concentration and the binary fraction, although stellar systems (both Boötes I and GCs) with r_{\rm h}/r_{\rm t}\gtrsim 0.15 tend to have, on average, higher binary fractions than the remaining GCs. Nevertheless, the large scatter in binary fraction among systems with similar r_{\rm h}/r_{\rm t} values prevents us from drawing firm conclusions about any relation between concentration and binary fraction. Finally, as shown in the right panel of Fig. 9 , where we plot the binary fraction against the mass of the primary stars, Boötes I follows the same trend defined by Milky Way and Small Magellanic Cloud field stars ( 38 ; 23 ) . Figure 9: Comparison between Boötes I, Galactic GCs, and field stars. Left: fraction of binaries with mass ratio q>0.5 in the cores of GCs ( 31 ; 29 ) compared with that in Boötes I. The red and yellow diamonds represent Boötes I, corresponding to the dynamical and stellar masses, respectively, from 25 and 15 . GC masses are adopted from 5 . Middle: binary fraction plotted against the concentration parameter, r_{h}/r_{t} . Radii are taken from the 2010 edition of the 14 catalog for GCs, and from 39 and 8 for Boötes I. Right: total binary fraction as a function of the primary-component mass. Gray dots correspond to Galactic field stars compiled in the review by 38 , and the green diamond indicates the binary fraction measured for the SMC field by 23 . Table 3: Binary fraction with mass ratio larger than 0.4, total binary fraction, slope of the mass ratio distribution, average iron abundance and dispersion of Boötes I. Parameter Value \langle\rm[Fe/H]\rangle -2.53\pm 0.05 \sigma_{\rm[Fe/H]} 0.41\pm 0.03 f_{bin}^{q>0.4} 0.20\pm 0.02 f_{bin}^{\mathrm{TOT}} 0.30\pm 0.03 q slope -0.30\pm 0.15 6 Summary and discussion We derived high-precision HST and JWST photometry for stars in the core of the UFD galaxy Boötes I, using the F606W band of ACS/WFC and the F322W2 band of NIRCam. The resulting exquisite CMD reveals a remarkably narrow and bright MS, where the observed color spread is comparable with that expected from photometric uncertainties alone over the F322W2 magnitude range \sim 22.5–24.5. At fainter magnitudes, however, the MS color broadening increases sharply, reaching \sim 0.4 mag around m_{\rm F322W2}\sim 25.0 . A significant color broadening is also evident near the MS turnoff, which transitions into a narrow and sparsely populated SGB. Comparison with isochrones indicates that this behavior is consistent with the presence of stellar populations spanning a range of metallicities. Notably, the CMD also displays a prominent binary sequence, formed by pairs of MS stars, located on the red side of the single-star MS. We used this data to infer the metallicity distribution and to investigate the population of binaries. • The wide color broadening of stars fainter than m_{\rm F322W2}\sim 24 provides an opportunity to constrain the chemical composition of stars in Boötes I. After accounting for the [ \alpha /Fe]–[Fe/H] relation inferred from high-resolution spectroscopy ( 11 ) , the color distribution of faint stars allows for an accurate determination of the metallicity distribution (see also 21 ; 22 , for similar determinations in GCs) . Based on a sample of 265 stars, we infer an average iron abundance of [Fe/H] =-2.53\pm 0.05 , with a dispersion of 0.41\pm 0.03 . The metallicity distribution spans a wide range, from [Fe/H] \sim-3.4 up to [Fe/H] \sim-1.55 , indicating that approximately \sim 17% of the sample has \rm[Fe/H]<-3.00 , while about \sim 14% have \rm[Fe/H]>-2.00 . These findings are consistent and confirm previous high-resolution spectroscopic studies based on smaller samples of RGB stars ( 20 ; 11 ; 35 ) . This approach, applied here for the first time to a UFD, combines photometric and spectroscopic information to overcome the main limitations of purely spectroscopic analyses, enabling metallicity estimates for a much larger stellar sample. • We take advantage of the high-quality CMD, where the binary sequence is visible with unprecedented clarity, to infer the fraction of binary systems composed of MS stars. To this end, we introduced a new pseudo-CMD, which we dubbed Binary map , in which the pseudo-color serves as an indicator of the mass ratio. From this analysis, we derived a binary fraction of f_{\rm bin}^{q>0.4}=0.20\pm 0.02 for systems with mass ratio q>0.4 , and inferred an approximately flat mass-ratio distribution with a slope of -0.30\pm 0.15 . By assuming a flat mass-ratio distribution, we extrapolated a total binary fraction of 0.30 \pm 0.03, comparable to what was inferred by 12 to characterize the initial mass function of Boötes I using ACS/WFC data ( \sim 0.28). The binary fraction is a crucial parameter for constraining the dynamical mass of UFDs, and hence their dark matter content. Indeed, in UFDs, which exhibit relatively small velocity dispersions ( 43 , e.g.,) , the contribution from binary stars can reach a few km s -1 , comparable to the observed dispersions in these ancient stellar systems ( 45 ; 40 , e.g.,) . A relatively large binary fraction of \sim 30\% , as derived for Boötes I, can artificially broaden the measured velocity distribution and thus lead to an incorrect estimate of the dark matter content, as recently demonstrated by studies based on analytic method ( 13 ) . The binary fraction observed in Boötes I is comparable to that typically found in stellar systems with similar stellar mass, such as Galactic and Magellanic Cloud open clusters ( 10 ; 32 ) , as well as in the Galactic and Small Magellanic Cloud field for stars of similar masses ( 38 ; 23 ) . When compared with GCs, Boötes I follows the well-known anticorrelation between the binary fraction and the mass of the host stellar system. Using the stellar mass ( 25 ) , the dwarf galaxy aligns remarkably well with this relation; however, this agreement breaks down when the dynamical mass is considered ( 15 ) . Although caution must be exercised when comparing GCs and UFDs, given their different structural properties, the fact that Boötes I follows the GC trend indicates that dark matter, consistent with its collisionless nature, shapes the global gravitational potential but does not engage in local dynamical interactions that would alter binary fractions. Acknowledgements. This work has been funded by the European Union – NextGenerationEU RRF M4C2 1.1 (PRIN 2022 2022MMEB9W: ”Understanding the formation of globular clusters with their multiple stellar generations”, CUP C53D23001200006), and from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie Grant Agreement No. 101034319 and from the European Union – NextGenerationEU (beneficiary: T. Ziliotto). This research is based on observations made with the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope obtained from the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under NASA contract NAS 5–26555. These observations are associated with programs 12549,15317. This work is based [in part] on observations made with the NASA/ESA/CSA James Webb Space Telescope. The data were obtained from the Mikulski Archive for Space Telescopes at the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under NASA contract NAS 5-03127 for JWST. These observations are associated with program 3849. Appendix A On the age of Boötes I A visual inspection of the CMD shown in Fig. 2 reveals that the sparsely populated SGB of Boötes I appears remarkably narrow and well defined. Since the SGB is highly sensitive to stellar age, in this Appendix we examine whether the current dataset allows us to place meaningful constraints on the ages of the stellar populations in Boötes I. In addition, we assess how the choice of isochrone ages adopted throughout this paper affects the derived binary fractions and the inferred metallicity distribution. The left panels of Fig. 10 reproduce the CMD shown in Fig. 2 , zoomed in around the SGB region, with two BaSTI isochrones overplotted, corresponding to the extreme metallicity values ([Fe/H]= -3.2 and -1.7 ). The bottom panel displays the isochrones with different ages (14 and 11 Gyr), introduced in Sect., 4 , and adopted in this work. These two isochrones nearly overlap along the SGB. The top panel, instead, shows isochrones of the same age (13 Gyr), which are widely separated in color along the SGB. The middle panels of Fig. 10 present two simulated CMDs. In both cases, we adopted the same luminosity function and binary fraction as in the observed CMD, but with a total number of stars increased by a factor of ten to reduce statistical noise. We also assumed the same metallicity distribution inferred in this study. The two simulated CMDs differ only in the age distribution of stellar populations with different metallicities. The bottom-middle panel corresponds to the age distribution adopted in Sect., 4 , whereas the top-middle panel assumes all populations are coeval. The right panels show the same simulated CMDs as in the middle panels, but rescaled to match the number of stars in the observed CMD. Although the observed stars are distributed along a relatively narrow SGB—suggesting, at first glance, a prolonged star formation—the limited number of SGB stars prevents us from drawing firm conclusions about the ages of the Boötes I stellar populations. To assess the robustness of our results on the binary fraction and metallicity distribution, we repeated the analyses presented in Sects. 4 and 5 using coeval isochrones. We verified that the results remain unchanged. This outcome is expected, since the determination of the binary fraction and metallicity distribution is based on MS stars, whose position in the CMD is largely insensitive to age. Figure 10: m_{\rm F322W2} vs. m_{\rm F606W}-m_{\rm F322W2} CMDs zoomed in around the SGB. The left panels show the observed CMDs of Boötes I, where the red and blue lines are isochrones with different [Fe/H], [ \alpha /Fe], and ages, as indicated in the insets. The middle panels show simulated CMDs composed of coeval stellar populations (top) and of stellar populations with different ages (bottom). The right panels are the same as the middle panels, but include approximately the same number of stars as in the observed CMDs.