Competition of small targets in planar domains: from Dirichlet to Robin and Steklov boundary condition D. \ns S. \ns G \ls R \ls E \ls B \ls E \ls N \ls K \ls O \ls V, \ns M. \ns J. \ns W \ls A \ls R \ls D Abstract We consider steady-state diffusion in a bounded planar domain with multiple small targets on a smooth boundary. Using the method of matched asymptotic expansions, we investigate the competition of these targets for a diffusing particle and the crucial role of surface reactions on the targets. We start from the classical problem of splitting probabilities for perfectly reactive targets with Dirichlet boundary condition and improve some earlier results. We discuss how this approach can be generalized to partially reactive targets characterized by a Robin boundary condition. In particular, we show how partial reactivity reduces the effective size of the target. In addition, we consider more intricate surface reactions modeled by mixed Steklov-Neumann or Steklov-Neumann-Dirichlet problems. We provide the first derivation of the asymptotic behavior of the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions for these spectral problems in the small-target limit. Finally, we show how our asymptotic approach can be extended to interior targets in the bulk and to exterior problems where diffusion occurs in an unbounded planar domain outside a compact set. Direct applications of these results to diffusion-controlled reactions are discussed. Keywords: diffusion, matched asymptotics, narrow escape problem, Steklov problem, mixed boundary conditions, diffusion-controlled reactions, first-passage time, Green’s functions, Dirichlet-to-Neumann operator. 1 Introduction Diffusive search for hidden targets is critically important for various physical, chemical and biological systems [ 67 , 73 , 62 , 60 , 58 , 20 ] . In the most basic setting, a point-like particle (e.g., a molecule, an ion, a protein, a virus, a bacterium, etc.) undergoes diffusive motion inside a confining environment and searches for an immobile target (e.g., a catalytic site on a solid surface, a channel on a plasma membrane, a specific site on the DNA, a cell, etc.). If the target is hidden in the bulk, it is often called an interior trap or a sink, whereas a target on the boundary is referred to as a reactive patch or an escape window. In both cases, if the target is small, one usually speaks about the narrow escape problem [ 47 , 48 ] , bearing in mind the picture of an open window, through which the particle can leave the domain and never return. Most former works were dedicated to finding and even optimizing the mean first-passage time (FPT) to a single target or to a given arrangement of multiple targets [ 75 , 74 , 65 , 15 , 11 , 29 , 59 , 41 , 49 , 43 ] . Other relevant characteristics of the diffusive search such as the whole distribution of the FPT [ 1 , 28 , 39 , 40 , 12 ] and Laplacian eigenvalues [ 51 , 19 , 14 ] , were also studied. A common limitation of most former works is their emphasis either on a single target, or on multiple targets of the same type. In turn, many biochemical applications involve targets of different types. For instance, signal transduction between neurons relies on diffusive search by calcium ions of a sensor protein on the vesicle with neurotransmitters inside the presynaptic bouton [ 70 , 63 , 47 , 44 , 68 ] . While the sensor protein is the primary target, calcium ions can reversibly bind to buffer molecules inside the confining domain or leave it through calcium channels on its boundary. Both buffer molecules and channels play the role of auxiliary targets that compete for calcium ions and thus allow to control the signal transduction. More generally, the successful reaction of a diffusing particle on a “primary” target may fail due to its eventual capture by other targets, or its escape. When all targets are perfect (i.e., the reaction occurs instantly upon the first arrival), the competition between targets for a diffusing particle is characterized via diffusive fluxes, splitting probabilities and conditional first-passage times [ 76 , 77 , 24 , 13 , 2 , 21 , 54 , 42 , 4 , 31 ] . In particular, the asymptotic behavior of these quantities for small interior traps or absorbing patches on the boundary and the dependence on their spatial arrangement have been studied in depth. However, as the targets are not perfectly reactive in most applications [ 18 , 71 , 72 , 23 , 55 , 26 , 30 , 31 , 64 , 5 , 34 ] , their competition also depends on their reactivities. The role of partially reactive traps, as modeled by a Robin condition condition, is not nearly as well understood, especially in the two-dimensional case. The problem becomes even more challenging for more intricate surface reactions, which cannot be described by the conventional Robin boundary condition on targets. We will refer to such targets as imperfect . For instance, the target reactivity can be progressively increased or decreased by encounters with a diffusing particle. Such activation or passivation processes are described within the encounter-based approach [ 33 , 32 , 35 , 6 , 7 ] . In probabilistic terms, the reaction event occurs when the number of reaction attempts upon each arrival onto the target exceeds some random threshold. The probability distribution of the threshold characterizes the reaction mechanism (see details in [ 33 ] ). For instance, the particular case of the exponential distribution corresponds to a partially reactive target with a constant reactivity, and its probabilistic description is equivalent to solving the diffusion equation with the Robin boundary condition. In turn, other distributions of the threshold describe more intricate surface reactions and involve integral-type boundary conditions. As shown in [ 33 ] , such PDE problems can be solved by employing spectral expansions based on the Steklov problem (see Sec. 4 and 5 for its formulation and basic properties). In particular, the Steklov eigenfunctions turn out to be particularly suitable for dealing with diffusive motion in the confining domain between successive arrivals onto an imperfect target. The peculiar feature of the Steklov problem that distinguishes it from common spectral problems for the Laplacian, is that the spectral parameter appears in the boundary condition. Various properties of the Steklov problem have been thoroughly investigated (see [ 56 , 50 , 45 , 27 , 17 ] and references therein). When imperfect targets are located on the inert impenetrable boundary, one needs to combine Steklov and Neumann boundary conditions. Such a mixed Steklov-Neumann problem was already known in hydrodynamics, where it is referred to as the sloshing problem [ 46 , 25 , 53 , 57 ] . In the case of a single target, the asymptotic behavior of its eigenvalues and eigenfunctions in the small-target limit was recently studied [ 37 ] . However, the scaling arguments and related analysis from [ 37 ] are not directly applicable to the case of multiple targets. The asymptotic behavior of the spectrum of the mixed Steklov-Neumann problem is thus unknown, despite the importance of its potential applications. Yet another unstudied setting concerns a single imperfect target with Steklov condition in the presence of multiple escape windows with Dirichlet condition. A mathematical framework for studying such an escape problem relies on the mixed Steklov-Neumann-Dirichlet problem [ 36 ] . To our knowledge, the asymptotic behavior of its eigenvalues and eigenfunctions in the small-target limit has not been studied previously. In this paper, we progressively fill the gap between perfect and imperfect targets. In Sec. 2 , we start with the conventional setting of N absorbing sinks and study their splitting probabilities, i.e., the probability of hitting one sink before any other. This relatively simple setting allows us to introduce in a didactic way many notions and tools that will be employed throughout the manuscript. Even though this problem was studied in the past (see [ 13 , 4 ] and references therein), we succeed in improving and generalizing some earlier results. Section 3 presents an extension to partially reactive targets, in which the Dirichlet boundary condition is replaced by a Robin condition. We show how partial reactivity effectively reduces the target size. The major contributions of the paper are presented in Secs. 4 and 5 . In Sec. 4 , we consider the mixed Steklov-Neumann problem for N imperfect targets. For this novel problem, we obtain the asymptotic behavior of its eigenvalues and eigenfunctions in the small-target limit. In turn, Sec. 5 focuses on the mixed Steklov-Neumann-Dirichlet problem, in which one target is imperfect (with Steklov condition), whereas the other targets are perfect (with Dirichlet condition). We apply matched asymptotic expansion techniques to investigate the asymptotic behavior in the small-target limit. For all considered cases, the accuracy of the derived asymptotic formulas is illustrated on two examples: the case of two patches in an arbitrary domain and the case of N equally-spaced patches on the boundary of a disk. Our analytical results are compared with numerical solutions obtained by a finite-element method in Matlab (its home-made implementation for Steklov problems is described in [ 10 ] ). In Sec. 6 , we discuss two further extensions of the present analysis: the case of interior targets (or traps), and exterior problems for which diffusion occurs outside a compact set. In this way, we cover a broad variety of settings, in which multiple small targets of different types compete for diffusing particles in planar domains. We summarize our main results in Section 7 . 2 Splitting probabilities on Dirichlet patches To introduce the theoretical framework and tools, we begin by revisiting the classical problem of splitting probabilities, which are commonly used to characterize competition between multiple perfectly reactive targets for a diffusing particle. Although this problem has been studied previously (see [ 13 , 4 ] and references therein), we will improve and generalize some earlier results. Figure 1: Illustration of a bounded domain \Omega\subset{\mathbb{R}}^{2} with a smooth boundary \partial\Omega split into three absorbing patches \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{i}} of length 2\varepsilon_{i} (in red and blue), and the remaining reflecting part \partial\Omega_{0} (gray dashed line). For a particle starting from a point \bm{x}\in\Omega , the splitting probability S_{1}(\bm{x}) is the probability of hitting the blue patch \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}} first. Let \Omega\subset{\mathbb{R}}^{2} be a bounded planar domain with a smooth boundary \partial\Omega . Let \{\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}},\ldots,\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{N}}\} be N disjoint subsets of the boundary \partial\Omega that represent multiple patches of lengths 2\varepsilon_{1},\ldots,2\varepsilon_{N} that are centered at boundary points \bm{x}_{1},\ldots,\bm{x}_{N} (each patch \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{j}} is connected). The remaining part of the boundary, denoted as \partial\Omega_{0}=\partial\Omega\backslash(\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}\cup\cdots\cup\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{N}}) , is reflecting (Fig. 1 ). We are interested in the small-target limit when all patches are small and comparable (i.e., \varepsilon_{1}\sim o(1) and \varepsilon_{j}/\varepsilon_{1}\sim{\mathcal{O}}(1) ). We assume that the patches are well-separated in the sense that |\bm{x}_{i}-\bm{x}_{j}|={\mathcal{O}}(1) for all i\neq j . In this section, we consider that all patches \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{j}} are absorbing sinks (i.e., perfectly reactive targets). For a particle started from a point \bm{x}\in\Omega , we aim at determining the splitting probability S_{k}(\bm{x}) ( k=1,\ldots,N ), i.e., the probability of the arrival onto the Dirichlet patch \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{k}} before hitting any other patch. This probability satisfies the boundary value problem (BVP) \displaystyle\Delta S_{k} \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{in}~\Omega\,, (1a) \displaystyle S_{k} \displaystyle=\delta_{j,k}\quad\textrm{on}~\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{j}}\,,\quad j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}}\,, (1b) \displaystyle\partial_{n}S_{k} \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{on}~\partial\Omega_{0}\,, (1c) where \Delta is the Laplacian, \partial_{n} is the normal derivative oriented outward to the domain \Omega , and \delta_{j,k} is the Kronecker symbol. In the analysis below, k\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}} is fixed. In the small-target limit \varepsilon_{j}\to 0 for each j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}} , we will use the method of matched asymptotic expansions for problems with logarithmic interactions [ 78 ] to approximate solutions to ( 1 ) that are accurate to all powers of {1/\ln(\varepsilon_{j})} . 2.1 Inner solutions The inner solution near each Dirichlet patch \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{j}} can be found by introducing the local coordinates \bm{y}=\varepsilon_{j}^{-1}{\bf Q}_{j}(\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{j}) , where {\bf Q}_{j} is an appropriate rotation matrix to restrict \bm{y}=(y_{1},y_{2}) to the upper half-plane {\mathbb{H}}_{2}={\mathbb{R}}\times{\mathbb{R}}_{+} (the matrix {\bf Q}_{j} plays no role since {\bf Q}_{j}^{\dagger}{\bf Q}_{j}={\bf I} and |\bm{y}|=\varepsilon_{j}^{-1}|\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{j}| ). We look for an inner solution near the patch \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{j}} in the form S_{k}(\bm{x}_{j}+\varepsilon_{j}{\bf Q}_{j}^{\dagger}\bm{y})=\delta_{j,k}+A_{j}g_{\infty}(\bm{y})\,,\quad j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}}\,, (2) where A_{j} is an unknown constant, and g_{\infty}(\bm{y}) is the Green’s function satisfying the canonical BVP given by \displaystyle\Delta g_{\infty} \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{in}~{\mathbb{H}}_{2}\,, (3a) \displaystyle\partial_{n}g_{\infty} \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{on}~y_{2}=0\,,~|y_{1}|\geq 1\,;\qquad g_{\infty}=0\quad\textrm{on}~y_{2}=0\,,~|y_{1}|<1\,, (3b) \displaystyle g_{\infty} \displaystyle\sim\ln|\bm{y}|+{\mathcal{O}}(1)\quad\textrm{as}~|\bm{y}|\to\infty\,, (3c) (the subscript \infty highlights infinite reactivity of the perfect patch, see below). The exact solution of this classical problem is given in Appendix A for completeness. The analysis below will require only the knowledge of the asymptotic behavior of g_{\infty}(\bm{y}) at infinity. We recall that the constant term in this behavior, g_{\infty}(\bm{y})\sim\ln|\bm{y}|-\ln(d)+o(1)\quad\textrm{as}~|\bm{y}|\to\infty\,, (4) is determined by the logarithmic capacity d of the interval (-1,1) , which is simply d={1/2} . Now putting \bm{y}=\varepsilon_{j}^{-1}{\bf Q}_{j}(\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{j}) , we get that the far-field behavior of the inner solution is S_{k}\sim\delta_{j,k}+A_{j}\biggl[\ln|\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{j}|-\ln(\varepsilon_{j}d)+o(1)\biggr]\quad\textrm{as}~\bm{x}\to\bm{x}_{j}\,. (5) Setting \nu_{j}=-\frac{1}{\ln(\varepsilon_{j}d)}\,,\quad\mbox{with}\quad d=\frac{1}{2}\,, (6) we rewrite this far-field behavior, for each j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}} , as S_{k}\sim\delta_{j,k}+A_{j}\biggl[\ln|\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{j}|+1/\nu_{j}+o(1)\biggr]\quad\textrm{as}\,\,\bm{x}\to\bm{x}_{j}\,. (7) 2.2 Outer solution and matching conditions Now we consider the outer problem for S_{k}(\bm{x}) given by \displaystyle\Delta S_{k} \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{in}~\Omega\,, (8a) \displaystyle S_{k} \displaystyle\sim\delta_{j,k}+A_{j}\bigl[\ln|\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{j}|+1/\nu_{j}\bigr]\quad\textrm{as}~\bm{x}\to\bm{x}_{j}\in\partial\Omega\,,\quad j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}}\,, (8b) \displaystyle\partial_{n}S_{k} \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{on}~\partial\Omega\backslash\{\bm{x}_{1},\ldots,\bm{x}_{N}\}\,. (8c) To find this solution, we introduce the surface Neumann Green’s function G(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) , which satisfies \displaystyle\Delta G \displaystyle=\frac{1}{|\Omega|}\quad\textrm{in}~\Omega\,;\quad\partial_{n}G=0\quad\textrm{on}~\partial\Omega\backslash\{{\bm{\xi}}\}\,;\quad\int\limits_{\Omega}G(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})\,d\bm{x}=0\,, (9a) \displaystyle G(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) \displaystyle\sim-\frac{1}{\pi}\ln|\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}|+R({\bm{\xi}})+o(1)\quad\textrm{as}~\bm{x}\to{\bm{\xi}}\in\partial\Omega\,, (9b) where |\Omega| is the area of \Omega , and R({\bm{\xi}}) is the regular part of G(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) , defined by R({\bm{\xi}})=\lim\limits_{\bm{x}\to{\bm{\xi}}}\biggl(G(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})+\frac{1}{\pi}\ln|\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}|\biggr)\,. (10) Remark 1 For a disk, G and R are known analytically from [ 51 ] and [ 65 ] (see ( 28 ) below). For a square domain, they can be represented in terms of rapidly converging infinite series representations (see Sec. 3.3 of [ 65 ] ). Similar representations can be obtained for rectangles and ellipses from the results for the interior Neumann Green’s function in Sec. 4.2 of [ 52 ] and in Sec. 5 of [ 49 ] , respectively, by allowing the interior source point to tend to the domain boundary (see Sec. F.2 for this derivation for an ellipse and Table 3 ). A numerical method to compute G and R in arbitrary planar domains is described in Sec. 3.3 of [ 65 ] . The divergence theorem applied to Eqs. ( 8 ) yields \sum\limits_{j=1}^{N}A_{j}=0\,. (11) Under this condition, the solution to Eqs. ( 8 ) can be written as the linear combination S_{k}(\bm{x})=\chi_{k}-\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}\pi A_{i}G(\bm{x},\bm{x}_{i})\,, (12) where \chi_{k} is a constant to be found. Matching the inner and outer asymptotic expansions as \bm{x}\to\bm{x}_{j} gives A_{j}+\nu_{j}\biggl[A_{j}R_{j}+\sum\limits_{i=1\atop i\neq j}^{N}G_{j,i}A_{i}\biggr]=\chi_{k}\nu_{j}-\nu_{k}\delta_{j,k}\,, (13) for j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}} , where we have defined G_{j,i}=\pi G(\bm{x}_{j},\bm{x}_{i})\quad(i\neq j)\,,\qquad R_{j}=\pi R(\bm{x}_{j})\,. (14) Together with the compatibility condition ( 11 ), we obtain a system of N+1 linear equations that determine the unknown coefficients A_{1},\ldots,A_{N} and \chi_{k} . 2.3 Matrix reformulation and general solution To proceed, we introduce the following vectors and matrices of sizes N\times 1 and N\times N : {\bf e}=\left(\begin{array}[]{c}1\\ 1\\ \cdots\\ 1\\ \end{array}\right),\quad{\bm{\nu}}=\left(\begin{array}[]{c c c c}\nu_{1}&0&\cdots&0\\ 0&\nu_{2}&\cdots&0\\ \cdots&\cdots&\cdots&\cdots\\ 0&0&\cdots&\nu_{N}\\ \end{array}\right)\,,\quad{\bf G}=\left(\begin{array}[]{c c c c}R_{1}&G_{1,2}&\cdots&G_{1,N}\\ G_{2,1}&R_{2}&\cdots&G_{2,N}\\ \cdots&\cdots&\cdots&\cdots\\ G_{N,1}&G_{N,2}&\cdots&R_{N}\\ \end{array}\right)\,\quad{\bf e}_{k}=\left(\begin{array}[]{c}0\\ 1\\ \cdots\\ 0\\ \end{array}\right)\,, (15) where 1 stands on the k -th row of the vector {\bf e}_{k} . In terms of this notation, the system ( 13 ) is written in matrix form as {\bf A}+{\bm{\nu}}{\bf G}{\bf A}=\chi_{k}{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}-{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}_{k}\,. (16) Applying {\bf e}^{\dagger} on the left, we isolate \chi_{k} as \chi_{k}=\frac{{\bf e}^{\dagger}{\bm{\nu}}{\bf G}{\bf A}}{\bar{\nu}}+\frac{\nu_{k}}{\bar{\nu}}\,, (17) where we used {\bf e}^{\dagger}{\bf A}=0 due to Eq. ( 11 ), and defined \bar{\nu}={\bf e}^{\dagger}{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}=\sum\limits_{j=1}^{N}\nu_{j}\,. (18) Eliminating \chi_{k} from Eq. ( 16 ), we get a matrix equation for {\bf A} given by ({\bf I}+{\bm{\nu}}{\bf G}){\bf A}-{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}\,\frac{{\bf e}^{\dagger}{\bm{\nu}}{\bf G}{\bf A}}{\bar{\nu}}=\frac{\nu_{k}}{\bar{\nu}}{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}-\nu_{k}{\bf e}_{k}\,. (19) By introducing the matrices {\bf M}_{0} and {\bf E} by {\bf M}_{0}={\bf I}+\biggl({\bf I}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf E}}{\bar{\nu}}\biggr){\bm{\nu}}{\bf G}\,,\qquad{\bf E}={\bf e}{\bf e}^{\dagger}\,, (20) the solution to Eq. ( 19 ) is {\bf A}=\frac{\nu_{k}}{\bar{\nu}}{\bf M}_{0}^{-1}\bigl({\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}-\bar{\nu}{\bf e}_{k}\bigr)\,, (21) where {\bf M}_{0}^{-1} is the inverse of {\bf M}_{0} . In fact, in the small-target limit, all \nu_{j}\ll 1 so that {\bf M}_{0} is a small perturbation of the identity matrix {\bf I} and is thus invertible. Once the coefficients A_{i} are found, the constant \chi_{k} follows from Eq. ( 17 ). As a consequence, the splitting probability S_{k}(\bm{x}) is fully determined via the representation ( 12 ). This is the main result of this section. The shape of the confining domain \Omega and the arrangement of Dirichlet patches are captured by the matrix {\bf G} , whereas the sizes of patches are accounted for via the matrix {\bm{\nu}} . When the surface Neumann Green’s function is known analytically, a numerical computation of the coefficients A_{i} and \chi_{k} is fast, at least if the number of targets is not too large. We emphasize that the solution {\bf A} in ( 21 ) to the linear system ( 19 ) has accounted for all logarithmic correction terms in the asymptotic expansion of the splitting probability. This technique for effectively summing what otherwise would be an infinite logarithmic expansion in powers of \nu_{k} was developed in [ 78 ] , and has been used in other contexts (see [ 19 ] , [ 54 ] , [ 65 ] ). We further emphasize that Eq. ( 12 ) is only applicable in the outer region, i.e., when |\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{j}|\gg{\mathcal{O}}(\varepsilon_{j}) for all j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}} . In turn, if the starting point \bm{x} is too close to \bm{x}_{j} , this asymptotic formula may give wrong values (e.g., negative or exceeding 1 ). In practice, the outer solution can be capped by 0 and 1 to avoid such invalid values, i.e., one can use \max\{0,\min\{1,S_{k}(\bm{x})\}\} instead of S_{k}(\bm{x}) . We remark that if an accurate approximation of the splitting probability is needed near the patch, one has to use the corresponding inner solution. We also note that the constant \chi_{k} can be interpreted as the volume-averaged splitting probability. In fact, if the starting point \bm{x} is not fixed but uniformly distributed in \Omega , the average over the starting point yields \overline{S}_{k}=\frac{1}{|\Omega|}\int\limits_{\Omega}S_{k}(\bm{x})\,d\bm{x}=\chi_{k}\,, (22) where we used \int_{\Omega}G(\bm{x},\bm{x}_{i})\,d\bm{x}=0 . 2.4 Example of two patches In the case of two targets ( N=2 ), the matrix {\bf M}_{0} from Eq. ( 20 ) reads {\bf M}_{0}={\bf I}+\gamma\left(\begin{array}[]{c c}R_{1}-G_{1,2}&G_{1,2}-R_{2}\\ G_{1,2}-R_{1}&R_{2}-G_{1,2}\\ \end{array}\right), (23) where \gamma=\nu_{1}\nu_{2}/(\nu_{1}+\nu_{2}) . The inverse of this matrix is {\bf M}_{0}^{-1}=\frac{1}{1+\gamma(R_{1}+R_{2}-2G_{1,2})}\left({\bf I}+\gamma\left(\begin{array}[]{c c}R_{2}-G_{1,2}&R_{2}-G_{1,2}\\ R_{1}-G_{1,2}&R_{1}-G_{1,2}\\ \end{array}\right)\right)\,. (24) Substituting this expression into Eq. ( 21 ), we find for k=1 that -A_{1}=A_{2}=\biggl(\frac{1}{\nu_{1}}+\frac{1}{\nu_{2}}+\bigl[R_{1}+R_{2}-2G_{1,2}\bigr]\biggr)^{-1}\,. (25) Then, by using Eq. ( 17 ) we determine \chi_{1} as \chi_{1}=\frac{\nu_{1}-A_{2}\nu_{1}(R_{1}-G_{1,2})+A_{2}\nu_{2}(R_{2}-G_{1,2})}{\nu_{1}+\nu_{2}}\,, (26) which can be further simplified as \chi_{1}=\frac{1/\nu_{2}+(R_{2}-G_{1,2})}{1/\nu_{1}+1/\nu_{2}+(R_{1}+R_{2}-2G_{1,2})}\,. (27) For instance, if \Omega is the unit disk, the surface Neumann Green’s function is well known [ 65 ] : G(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})=-\frac{1}{\pi}\ln|\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}|+\frac{|\bm{x}|^{2}}{4\pi}-\frac{1}{8\pi}\,,\quad R({\bm{\xi}})=\frac{1}{8\pi}\,. (28) Substitution of these expressions into Eqs. ( 25 , 27 ) yields \displaystyle-A_{1}=A_{2} \displaystyle=\biggl(-\ln(\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2})+2\ln(2)+2\ln|\bm{x}_{1}-\bm{x}_{2}|\biggr)^{-1}\,, (29a) \displaystyle\chi_{1} \displaystyle=\frac{-\ln(\varepsilon_{2}/2)+\ln|\bm{x}_{1}-\bm{x}_{2}|}{-\ln(\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2}/4)+2\ln|\bm{x}_{1}-\bm{x}_{2}|}\,, (29b) and we conclude that S_{1}(\bm{x})=\chi_{1}+A_{2}\ln\biggl(\frac{|\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{2}|}{|\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{1}|}\biggr)\,. (30) We can easily check that S_{1}(\bm{x}) approaches 0 [resp., 1 ] as \varepsilon_{1}\to 0 [resp., \varepsilon_{2}\to 0 ], as expected. In the special case of two identical targets, \nu_{1}=\nu_{2}=\nu , one has \chi_{1}=1/2 and A_{2}=1/(2/\nu+2\ln|\bm{x}_{1}-\bm{x}_{2}|) so that S_{1}(\bm{x})=\frac{1}{2}\biggl[1+\frac{\nu}{1+\nu\ln|\bm{x}_{1}-\bm{x}_{2}|}\ln\biggl(\frac{|\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{2}|}{|\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{1}|}\biggr)\biggr]\,. (31) We remark that if we were to expand the denominator of the second term into a Taylor series in powers of \nu\ll 1 up to {\mathcal{O}}(\nu^{2}) , we would recover the truncated approximation given in Eq. (98) from [ 13 ] . However, as \nu=-1/\ln(\varepsilon/2) is not necessarily small enough, our new result Eq. ( 31 ) that incorporates all logarithmic terms is preferable than using the previous truncated approximation from [ 13 ] . Figure 2 illustrates the splitting probability S_{1}(\bm{x}) from Eq. ( 30 ). As explained earlier, we plot the capped version of this quantity, \max\{0,\min\{1,S_{1}(\bm{x})\}\} , to avoid invalid values near two patches. Expectedly, S_{1}(\bm{x}) increases as \bm{x} gets closer to the first patch (red arc) and decreases as \bm{x} gets closer to the second patch (blue arc). However, as the outer solution ( 30 ) is not applicable in the vicinity of these patches, we can observe some discrepancy, e.g., S_{1}(\bm{x}) does not vanish on the second patch, as it should. To amend this discrepancy, we can use the inner solution when |\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{j}|\lesssim\varepsilon_{j} . Figure 2: Splitting probability S_{1}(\bm{x}) , given by Eq. ( 30 ), for the unit disk with two Dirichlet patches of length 2\varepsilon_{1}=0.2 (red) and 2\varepsilon_{2}=0.4 (blue). Note that S_{1}(\bm{x}) was capped by 0 and 1 , i.e., we plotted \max\{0,\min\{1,S_{1}(\bm{x})\}\} . 2.5 Example of equally-spaced identical patches on the boundary of the unit disk If there are N identical targets, one has \nu_{j}=\nu so that {\bm{\nu}}=\nu{\bf I} , \bar{\nu}=N\nu , and thus {\bf M}_{0}={\bf I}+\nu({\bf I}-{\bf E}/N){\bf G} from Eq. ( 20 ). Moreover, if the patches are equally-spaced on the boundary of the unit circle, the matrix {\bf G} defined in Eq. ( 15 ) is circulant and symmetric. As a consequence, its eigenvectors can be written as {\bf q}_{j}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{N}}\bigl(\omega^{-j},\omega^{-2j},\ldots,\omega^{-Nj}\bigr)^{\dagger}\,,\qquad j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}}\,, (32) where \omega=e^{2\pi i/N} , and the transposition \dagger now denotes the Hermitian conjugate. Upon taking the real and imaginary parts of {\bf q}_{j} , the resulting real-valued eigenvectors form an orthonormal basis in {\mathbb{R}}^{N} since {\bf G} is symmetric. Let us denote by \kappa_{j} the associated eigenvalues of {\bf G} : \kappa_{j}=R_{1}+\sum\limits_{m=1}^{N-1}\omega^{mj}\,G_{1,1+m}\,,\qquad j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}}\,. (33) For any j\in\{{1,\ldots,N-1\}} , we get {\bf M}_{0}{\bf q}_{j}=\bigl({\bf I}+\nu[{\bf I}-{\bf E}/N]\bigr)\kappa_{j}{\bf q}_{j}=(1+\nu\kappa_{j}){\bf q}_{j}\,, (34) because {\bf E}{\bf q}_{j}={\bf e}{\bf e}^{\dagger}{\bf q}_{j}=0 for any 1\leq j\leq N-1 due to orthogonality of {\bf q}_{j} to {\bf q}_{N}={\bf e}/\sqrt{N} . As a consequence, each {\bf q}_{j} with j\in\{{1,\ldots,N-1\}} is also the eigenvector of {\bf M}_{0} , associated to the eigenvalue 1+\nu\kappa_{j} . In addition, we have {\bf M}_{0}{\bf q}_{N}=\bigl({\bf I}+\nu[{\bf I}-{\bf E}/N]\bigr)\kappa_{N}{\bf q}_{N}={\bf q}_{N}\,, (35) since {\bf E}{\bf q}_{N}/N={\bf q}_{N} . Therefore, {\bf q}_{N} is the eigenvector of {\bf M}_{0} associated with the eigenvalue 1 . We use this spectral information to invert the matrix {\bf M}_{0} as {\bf M}_{0}^{-1}={\bf q}_{N}{\bf q}_{N}^{\dagger}+\sum\limits_{j=1}^{N-1}{\bf q}_{j}(1+\nu\kappa_{j})^{-1}{\bf q}_{j}^{\dagger}\,. (36) Substituting this spectral representation into Eq. ( 21 ), we get {\bf A}=-\nu\sum\limits_{j=1}^{N-1}{\bf q}_{j}(1+\nu\kappa_{j})^{-1}{\bf q}_{j}^{\dagger}{\bf e}_{k}\,, (37) where we used the orthogonality of the eigenvectors {\bf q}_{j} . Substitution of this expression into Eq. ( 17 ) yields \chi_{k}=1/N . This is consistent with the interpretation of \chi_{k} as the volume-averaged splitting probability: when all patches are identical and equally-spaced on the boundary of the unit disk, they are equivalent from the uniformly distributed starting point, so that \overline{S}_{k}=1/N from Eq. ( 22 ). To complete this example, we will simplify Eq. ( 33 ) by using the explicit form ( 28 ) of the surface Neumann Green’s function for the unit disk. Since the centers of the patches \bm{x}_{j} are equally-spaced on the domain boundary, we have \bm{x}_{j}=e^{2\pi i(j-1)/N}=\omega^{j-1} for j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}} . In this way, substituting Eq. ( 28 ) into Eq. ( 33 ), we get \kappa_{j}=\frac{1}{8}\sum_{m=0}^{N-1}\omega^{jm}-\sum\limits_{m=1}^{N-1}\omega^{mj}\ln|1-\omega^{m}|\,,\qquad j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}}\,, (38) where we interpret points as complex numbers and |z| as the modulus of z . For j=N , for which \omega^{Nm}=1 , we get \kappa_{N}=\frac{N}{8}-\ln\left|\prod_{m=1}^{N-1}(1-\omega^{m})\right|=\frac{N}{8}-\ln{N}\,, (39) where the product in Eq. ( 39 ) was evaluated by using the roots of unity together with L’Hopital’s rule to get \lim_{z\to 1}{(z^{N}-1)/(z-1)}=N=\prod_{m=1}^{N-1}(1-\omega^{m}) . For j0 can still be treated as the perfect ones but with the reduced effective length, defined by \varepsilon_{j}^{\rm eff}=\varepsilon_{j}\exp\bigl(\ln(2)-{\mathcal{C}}(\varepsilon_{j}q_{j})\bigr)\,. (54) Together with the spectral expansion ( 48 ), this is the main result of this section. From Eq. ( 48 ), the function {\mathcal{C}}(\mu) decreases monotonically from +\infty to \ln(2) on the range \mu>0 (see Fig. 3 ). As a consequence, \nu_{j} in Eq. ( 53 ) decreases monotonically from {-1/\ln(\varepsilon_{j}/2)} (this is the former definition of \nu_{j} for the Dirichlet patch) to 0 , whereas \varepsilon_{j}^{\rm eff} decreases from \varepsilon_{j} to 0 as the reactivity q_{j} drops from infinity to 0 . This shows that a target with a smaller reactivity has less chance to capture the diffusing particle. When q_{j}\sim{\mathcal{O}}(1) , one has \varepsilon_{j}q_{j}\ll 1 , so that the approximation ( 51 ) is applicable. This yields, that \nu_{j}\approx 2\varepsilon_{j}q_{j}/\pi\ll 1 and so to leading order \varepsilon_{j}^{\rm eff}\approx\varepsilon_{j}e^{-\pi/(2q_{j}\varepsilon_{j})}\qquad(\varepsilon_{j}q_{j}\ll 1)\,. (55) For weakly reactive targets (i.e., if q_{j}\varepsilon_{j}\ll 1 for all j=1,\ldots,N ), we get \nu_{j}\approx 2\varepsilon_{j}q_{j}/\pi\ll 1 . According to Eq. ( 21 ), all the coefficients A_{i} are small (of the order of \varepsilon ) so that the first term in Eq. ( 17 ) can be neglected, yielding \chi_{k}\approx\frac{\nu_{k}}{\nu_{1}+\ldots+\nu_{N}}\,, (56) and thus \overline{S}_{k}\approx\frac{\varepsilon_{k}q_{k}}{\varepsilon_{1}q_{1}+\ldots+\varepsilon_{N}q_{N}}\,, (57) independently of the location of the patches. We emphasize that the approximation ( 56 ) is generally not accurate for perfect targets: even if \varepsilon_{j} are very small, the gauge function \nu_{j}=-1/\ln(\varepsilon_{j}/2) may not be small enough to neglect higher-order terms in powers of \nu_{j} . For the case of two partially reactive patches on the boundary of the unit disk, substitution of the effective lengths \varepsilon_{j}^{\rm eff} from Eq. ( 54 ) into Eqs. ( 29 ) yields \displaystyle A_{2} \displaystyle=\biggl(-\ln(\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2})+{\mathcal{C}}(q_{1}\varepsilon_{1})+{\mathcal{C}}(q_{2}\varepsilon_{2})+2\ln|\bm{x}_{1}-\bm{x}_{2}|\biggr)^{-1}\,, (58a) \displaystyle\chi_{1} \displaystyle=\frac{-\ln(\varepsilon_{2})+{\mathcal{C}}(q_{2}\varepsilon_{2})+\ln|\bm{x}_{1}-\bm{x}_{2}|}{-\ln(\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2})+{\mathcal{C}}(q_{1}\varepsilon_{1})+{\mathcal{C}}(q_{2}\varepsilon_{2})+2\ln|\bm{x}_{1}-\bm{x}_{2}|}\,. (58b) Figure 5 shows the behavior of \chi_{1} for two patches of equal length. In this figure, the high accuracy of our asymptotic solution ( 58b ) is confirmed by comparison with a numerical solution of the BVP ( 1b ) with Robin boundary condition ( 42 ) by a finite-element method. Figure 5: Volume-averaged splitting probability \overline{S}_{1}=\chi_{1} for the unit disk, calculated from ( 58b ), with two patches of equal length 2\varepsilon=0.2 located at boundary points (\pm 1,0) . Three curves correspond to three values of the reactivity parameter q_{2} of the second patch. Symbols present the numerical solution of the BVP ( 1b ) with Robin boundary condition ( 42 ) by a finite-element method in Matlab PDEtool, with the maximal meshsize 0.02 . 3.1 The mean first-reaction time Although our asymptotic analysis has focused on calculating splitting probabilities it can be easily modified to calculate the mean first-reaction time (MFRT). The dimensionless MFRT u(\bm{x}) satisfies a Poisson equation with mixed Neumann-Robin boundary conditions: \displaystyle\Delta u \displaystyle=-1\,,\quad\bm{x}\in\Omega\,, (59a) \displaystyle\partial_{n}u+q_{i}u \displaystyle=0\,,\quad\bm{x}\in\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{i}}\,,\quad i\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}}\,, (59b) \displaystyle\partial_{n}u \displaystyle=0\,,\quad\bm{x}\in\partial\Omega_{0}=\partial\Omega\backslash(\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}\cup\cdots\cup\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{N}})\,. (59c) As previously, each reactive boundary patch \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{i}} has length 2\varepsilon_{i} , reactivity parameter q_{i} , and is centered at \bm{x}_{i}\in\partial\Omega . The matched asymptotic analysis of Eq. ( 59 ) in the small-target limit \varepsilon_{i}\ll 1 is very similar to that for analyzing the splitting probability. The inner solution near the j -th patch in terms of an unknown coefficient A_{j} is V_{j}(\bm{y})=u(\bm{x}_{j}+\varepsilon_{j}{\bf Q}_{j}^{\dagger}\bm{y})=A_{j}g_{\mu_{j}}(\bm{y})\,,\qquad j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}}, (60) where \mu_{j}\equiv\varepsilon_{j}q_{j} and g_{\mu}(\bm{y}) is the Robin Green’s satisfying Eq. ( 44 ) with far-field behavior Eq. ( 47 ). Upon matching the far-field behavior of V_{j}(\bm{y}) to the outer solution, we find that to within all logarithmic terms the outer solution satisfies \displaystyle\Delta u \displaystyle=-1\quad\textrm{in}~\Omega\,, (61a) \displaystyle u \displaystyle\sim A_{j}\bigl[\ln|\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{j}|+1/\nu_{j}\bigr]\quad\textrm{as}~\bm{x}\to\bm{x}_{j}\in\partial\Omega\,,\quad j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}}\,, (61b) \displaystyle\partial_{n}u \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{on}~\partial\Omega\backslash\{\bm{x}_{1},\ldots,\bm{x}_{N}\}\,, (61c) where \nu_{j} is defined by ( 53 ). The solvability condition for ( 61 ) is that \sum_{j=1}^{N}A_{j}={|\Omega|/\pi} . We then represent u in terms of the surface Neumann Green’s function and the volume average \overline{u}_{0}=|\Omega|^{-1}\int_{\Omega}u(\bm{x})\,d\bm{x} as u(\bm{x})=\overline{u}_{0}-\pi\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}A_{i}G(\bm{x},\bm{x}_{i})\,. (62) Imposing the singularity behavior in Eq. ( 61b ), we obtain an (N+1) -dimensional linear algebraic system for \overline{u}_{0} and A_{1},\ldots,A_{N} given by A_{j}+\nu_{j}\biggl[A_{j}R_{j}+\sum\limits_{i=1\atop i\neq j}^{N}G_{j,i}A_{i}\biggr]=\overline{u}_{0}\nu_{j}\,,\quad j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}}\,;\qquad\sum_{j=1}^{N}A_{j}=\frac{|\Omega|}{\pi}\,, (63) where G_{j,i} and R_{i} were defined in ( 14 ). In matrix form Eq. ( 63 ) is written for {\bf A}\equiv(A_{1},\ldots,A_{N})^{\dagger} as {\bf A}+{\bm{\nu}}{\bf G}{\bf A}=\overline{u}_{0}{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}\,,\quad{\bf e}^{T}{\bf A}=\frac{|\Omega|}{\pi}\,, (64) where {\bf e} , {\bm{\nu}} and the Green’s matrix {\bf G} were defined in Eq. ( 15 ). By eliminating \overline{u}_{0} in Eq. ( 64 ), we conclude that \overline{u}_{0}=\frac{|\Omega|}{\pi\bar{\nu}}+\frac{{\bf e}^{\dagger}{\bm{\nu}}{\bf G}{\bf A}}{\bar{\nu}}\,, (65) where \bar{\nu}\equiv\sum\limits_{j=1}^{N}\nu_{j} , while {\bf A} is the solution to {\bf M}_{0}{\bf A}=\frac{|\Omega|}{\pi\bar{\nu}}{\bm{\nu}}\,, (66) with {\bf M}_{0} and {\bf E} being defined in Eq. ( 20 ). By using Eq. ( 53 ) for \nu_{j} , which involves the local reactivity parameter q_{j} on the patch, one can invert {\bf M}_{0} in Eq. ( 66 ) to get the coefficients A_{j} . As a consequence, Eq. ( 65 ) gives access to the volume-averaged MFRT \overline{u}_{0} , whereas Eq. ( 62 ) determines the MFRT u(\bm{x}) for any well-separated spatial configuration of partially reactive patches. This result generalizes that in [ 65 ] , where perfect reactivities ( q_{j}=\infty ) were assumed. 4 Steklov-Neumann problem As discussed in Sec. 1 , the Robin boundary condition describes targets with a constant reactivity. In turn, more sophisticated surface reactions can be incorporated by using the encounter-based approach [ 33 , 32 , 35 ] , which relies on the mixed Steklov-Neumann problem. In this section, we apply the tools described above to derive the asymptotic properties of this spectral problem in the small-target limit. As before, we consider a bounded planar domain \Omega with a smooth boundary \partial\Omega , which has N small well-separated patches \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{j}} , and \partial\Omega_{0}=\partial\Omega\backslash(\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}\cup\ldots\cup\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{N}}) . We study the mixed Steklov-Neumann spectral problem: \displaystyle\Delta V \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{in}~\Omega\,, (67a) \displaystyle\partial_{n}V \displaystyle=\sigma V\quad\textrm{on}~\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}\cup\cdots\cup\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{N}}\,, (67b) \displaystyle\partial_{n}V \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{on}~\partial\Omega_{0}\,. (67c) This spectral problem is known to have a discrete positive spectrum [ 56 ] , i.e., infinitely many eigenpairs \{\sigma_{k},V_{k}\} that are enumerated by k=0,1,\ldots to form an increasing sequence of eigenvalues: 0=\sigma_{0}<\sigma_{1}\leq\sigma_{2}\leq\ldots\nearrow\infty . Note that the Steklov boundary condition ( 67b ) with a nonnegative \sigma differs from the previous Robin condition by the opposite sign. We aim at determining the asymptotic behavior of the eigenvalues \sigma_{k} and the associated eigenfunctions V_{k} in the small-target limit. In the case of a single Steklov patch ( N=1 ), the small- \varepsilon_{1} asymptotic behavior of the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions was analyzed in [ 37 ] . In fact, a simple scaling argument suggests that \sigma_{j}\approx\mu_{j}/\varepsilon_{1} ( j=1,2,\ldots ) to leading order, where \mu_{j} are the eigenvalues of the mixed Steklov-Neumann problem ( 46 ) for the interval in the upper half-plane (see also Appendix C ). If there are two well-separated Steklov patches, it is tempting to apply the same scaling argument in the vicinity of each patch. In this way, we can expect that the spectrum of the problem ( 67 ) with N=2 is composed of two sequences of eigenvalues: \{\mu_{j}/\varepsilon_{1}\} from the first patch of length 2\varepsilon_{1} , and \{\mu_{j}/\varepsilon_{2}\} from the second patch of length 2\varepsilon_{2} . In other words, the two patches might be expected to not interact with each other in the small-target limit as \varepsilon_{j}\to 0 . This intuitive argument turns out to be correct for all the eigenvalues, except for the first nontrivial eigenvalue \sigma_{1} . Indeed, if two patches could be treated as independent, the eigenvalue \sigma_{1} would have to be zero, as \sigma_{0} . However, the zero eigenvalue can only correspond to a constant eigenfunction, so that if \sigma_{1} was zero, one would have V_{1}=const=V_{0} , which is impossible. We conclude that even if the patches are extremely small, the eigenvalue \sigma_{1} must be strictly positive, and its asymptotic behavior must result from long-range interactions between two patches. In this section, we adapt the analysis from Sec. 3 to the case of N Steklov patches and determine the asymptotic behavior of the first N-1 eigenvalues \sigma_{j} , for j\in\{{1,\ldots,N-1\}} , in this setting. 4.1 Matched asymptotic analysis As before, we look at the inner solution near each Steklov patch \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{j}} . Upon comparing the Robin and Steklov conditions ( 42 , 67b ), we notice two differences: (i) q_{j} is replaced by -\sigma , and (ii) there is no inhomogeneous term q_{j}\delta_{j,k} in the right-hand side. Apart from these two points, the boundary value problems for S_{k}(\bm{x}) and V(\bm{x}) are identical. As a consequence, we can immediately rewrite the asymptotic behavior ( 52 ) for each j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}} as V\sim A_{j}\biggl[\ln|\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{j}|+1/\nu_{j}+{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{j})+o(1)\biggr]\quad\textrm{as}~\bm{x}\to\bm{x}_{j}\,, (68) where we now redefine \nu_{j} as \nu_{j}=-{1/\ln(\varepsilon_{j})}\,, (69) and where A_{j} is an unknown coefficient. Note that the constant term {\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{j}) is not incorporated into the new definition of \nu_{j} , as we did earlier in the Robin case. As before, the outer solution is represented as V=\chi-\pi\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}A_{i}G(\bm{x},\bm{x}_{i})\,, (70) with an unknown constant \chi . The divergence theorem still ensures the compatibility condition ( 11 ). Upon enforcing the singularity behavior ( 68 ) for the solution in Eq. ( 70 ), we get \chi-({\bf G}{\bf A})_{j}=A_{j}(1/\nu_{j}+{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{j}))\,,\quad j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}}\,, (71) where we used the matrix notations introduced in Eq. ( 15 ) of Sec. 2.3 . Multiplying this equation by \nu_{j} and introducing the diagonal matrix {\bf C} formed by \{{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1}),\ldots,{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{N})\} , we rewrite Eq. ( 71 ) as \bigl({\bf I}+{\bm{\nu}}{\bf G}+{\bm{\nu}}{\bf C}\bigr){\bf A}=\chi{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}\,. (72) Left-multiplying this equation by {\bf e}^{\dagger} , and using {\bf e}^{\dagger}{\bf A}=0 , we isolate \chi as \chi=\frac{1}{\bar{\nu}}\bigl({\bf e}^{\dagger}{\bm{\nu}}{\bf G}+{\bf e}^{\dagger}{\bm{\nu}}{\bf C}\bigr){\bf A}\,, (73) where \bar{\nu} was defined by Eq. ( 18 ). Substituting this expression back into Eq. ( 72 ), we obtain that \biggl({\bf I}+\biggl({\bf I}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf E}}{\bar{\nu}}\biggr){\bm{\nu}}\left({\bf G}+{\bf C}\right)\biggr){\bf A}={\bf 0}\,. (74) The necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of a nontrivial solution to this matrix equation is \mathrm{det}\biggl({\bf I}+\biggl({\bf I}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf E}}{\bar{\nu}}\biggr){\bm{\nu}}({\bf G}+{\bf C})\biggr)={\bf 0}\,. (75) The matrices {\bm{\nu}} and {\bf G} are determined by the sizes and arrangement of the Steklov patches, while the matrix {\bf C} is formed by \{{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1}),\ldots,{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{N})\} , with the function {\mathcal{C}}(\mu) given by Eq. ( 48 ). As a consequence, Eq. ( 75 ) determines the unknown parameter \sigma . Moreover, the functional form ( 48 ) implies that there are infinitely many negative solutions, denoted as -\sigma_{j} , which are actually small-target approximations of the Steklov eigenvalues. Let us first provide qualitative insights on these solutions. If the matrix {\bf C} was fixed in the small-target limit, the condition \nu_{j}\ll 1 would imply the smallness of the second matrix term in Eq. ( 75 ) as compared to the identity matrix {\bf I} , thus ensuring the positivity of the determinant. To compensate the smallness of the matrix {\bm{\nu}} , the matrix {\bf C} must therefore be large in the small-target limit. This is possible when at least one \sigma\varepsilon_{i} is close to -\mu_{2k} for some k . In other words, one can expect that a solution -\sigma_{j} of Eq. ( 75 ) is close to \mu_{2k}/\varepsilon_{i} for some i and k . This intuitive picture suggests that an eigenvalue \sigma_{j} of the mixed Steklov-Neumann problem with N patches can be approximated by that on a single patch (say, \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{i}} ), as if there were no other patches and the associated eigenfunction was localized on \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{i}} . The situation is, however, more subtle in the vicinity of \mu_{0}=0 . In the analysis below, we focus on the asymptotic behavior of the first N eigenvalues \sigma_{j} . 4.2 First N eigenvalues Let us assume that -\mu=\sigma\varepsilon_{j}\ll 1 for all j=1,\ldots,N , so that we can apply the approximate relation ( 51 ) for the function {\mathcal{C}}(\mu) . Introducing the diagonal matrix {\bm{\eta}} formed by \{{\pi/(2\varepsilon_{1})},\ldots,{\pi/(2\varepsilon_{N})}\} , we get {\bf C}\approx-{\bm{\eta}}/\sigma+C_{1}{\bf I} . Its substitution into Eq. ( 75 ) yields \mathrm{det}\biggl({\bf I}+\biggl({\bf I}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf E}}{\bar{\nu}}\biggr){\bm{\nu}}\bigl[{\bf G}-{\bm{\eta}}/\sigma+C_{1}{\bf I}\bigr]\biggr)={\bf 0}\,. (76) Upon defining {\bf M}_{1} and {\bf B}_{1} by {\bf M}_{1}={\bf I}+\biggl({\bf I}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf E}}{\bar{\nu}}\biggr){\bm{\nu}}\bigl({\bf G}+C_{1}{\bf I}\bigr)\,,\qquad{\bf B}_{1}=\biggl({\bf I}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf E}}{\bar{\nu}}\biggr){\bm{\nu}}{\bm{\eta}}\,, (77) we can rewrite Eq. ( 76 ) in a more compact form as \mathrm{det}(\sigma{\bf M}_{1}-{\bf B}_{1})=0\,. (78) In the small-target limit, one has \nu_{j}\ll 1 so that {\bf M}_{1} is invertible since it is a small perturbation of the identity matrix. As a consequence, we get that \mathrm{det}(\sigma{\bf I}-{\bf M}_{1}^{-1}{\bf B}_{1})=0\,. (79) We now prove that the eigenvalues \hat{\sigma}_{j} for j=0,\ldots,N-1 of the matrix {\bf M}_{1}^{-1}{\bf B}_{1} are real. To do so, we first write {\bf M}_{1} in Eq. ( 77 ) as {\bf M}_{1}={\bf I}-\hat{{\bf B}}_{1}\hat{{\bf G}}\,,\,\, (80) where we define the symmetric matrices \hat{{\bf B}}_{1} and \hat{{\bf G}} by \hat{{\bf B}}_{1}={\bf B}_{1}{\bm{\eta}}^{-1}=\left({\bf I}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf E}}{\bar{\nu}}\right){\bm{\nu}}\,,\qquad\hat{{\bf G}}=-{\bf G}-C_{1}{\bf I}\,. (81) By using the Neumann series to calculate {\bf M}_{1}^{-1} , which converges since \nu_{j}\ll 1 , we obtain that {\bf M}_{1}^{-1}\hat{{\bf B}}_{1}=\hat{{\bf B}}_{1}+\hat{{\bf B}}_{1}\left(\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}{\bf K}_{n}\right)\hat{{\bf B}}_{1}\,,\qquad{\bf K}_{n}=\left(\hat{{\bf G}}\hat{{\bf B}}_{1}\right)^{n-1}\hat{{\bf G}}\,. (82) Since {\bf K}_{n} is symmetric for each n=1,2,\ldots , it follows that {\bf M}_{1}^{-1}\hat{{\bf B}}_{1} is symmetric. Finally, we denote {\bf D}={\bf M}_{1}^{-1}{\bf B}_{1}={\bf M}_{1}^{-1}\hat{{\bf B}}_{1}{\bm{\eta}} and introduce \hat{{\bf D}}={\bm{\eta}}^{\frac{1}{2}}{\bf D}{\bm{\eta}}^{-\frac{1}{2}}={\bm{\eta}}^{\frac{1}{2}}{\bf M}_{1}^{-1}\hat{{\bf B}}_{1}{\bm{\eta}}^{\frac{1}{2}} , which is symmetric, so that its eigenvalues are real. Since {\bm{\eta}} is positive definite, \hat{{\bf D}} is related to {\bf D} by a similarity transformation so that the latter must also have real eigenvalues \hat{\sigma}_{j} for j=0,\ldots,N-1 . Moreover, we note that \hat{\sigma}_{0}=0 . This follows since {\bf B}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf e}=0 , so that {\bf e} is an eigenvector of {\bf B}_{1}^{\dagger} and thus of [{\bf M}_{1}^{\dagger}]^{-1}{\bf B}_{1}^{\dagger} . The associated eigenvalue 0 is thus an eigenvalue of {\bf B}_{1}{\bf M}_{1}^{-1} as well as of {\bf M}_{1}^{-1}{\bf B}_{1} . In summary, the eigenvalues of the matrix {\bf M}_{1}^{-1}{\bf B}_{1} provide the leading terms in the asymptotic behavior of the first N eigenvalues \sigma_{j} of the Steklov-Neumann problem: \sigma_{j}\approx\hat{\sigma}_{j}\,,\qquad j\in\{{1,\ldots,N-1\}}\,. (83) This is the main result of this section. We observe that \sigma_{0}=\hat{\sigma}_{0}=0 , as expected. 4.3 Associated eigenfunctions In addition, we construct the associated eigenfunctions of the first N eigenvalues. For this purpose, let us rewrite Eq. ( 74 ) as (\sigma{\bf I}-{\bf M}_{1}^{-1}{\bf B}_{1}){\bf A}={\bf 0}\,. (84) While each eigenvalue \hat{\sigma}_{j} of the matrix {\bf M}_{1}^{-1}{\bf B}_{1} approximates the j -th eigenvalue of the mixed Steklov-Neumann problem, the corresponding eigenvector of this matrix is the vector of coefficients A_{i} determining the associated eigenfunction V_{j} via Eq. ( 70 ), up to a multiplicative factor; we recall that \chi is given by Eq. ( 73 ). The missing multiplicative factor can be fixed by imposing an appropriate normalization of eigenfunctions. For the Steklov problem, the natural normalization is \int\limits_{\Gamma}V^{2}\,ds=1\,, (85) where \Gamma=\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}\cup\cdots\cup\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{N}} . For the trivial eigenvalue \sigma_{0}=0 , one has a constant eigenfunction V_{0} , whose normalization yields: V_{0}^{2}=1/|\Gamma| . In the following, we assume that \sigma>0 . To proceed, we recall that the inner solution near the i -th patch reads in local coordinates is V(\bm{x}_{i}+\varepsilon_{i}{\bf Q}_{i}^{\dagger}\bm{y})\approx A_{i}g_{-\sigma\varepsilon_{i}}(\bm{y})\,. (86) Using the representation ( 45 ) of the Green’s function g_{\mu}(\bm{y}) , the restriction of V onto \Gamma_{i} becomes V|_{\Gamma_{i}}(y_{1})=V(\bm{x}_{i}+\varepsilon_{i}{\bf Q}_{i}^{\dagger}(y_{1},0)^{\dagger})\approx\pi A_{i}\sum\limits_{k=0}^{\infty}\frac{\Psi_{2k}(\infty)\Psi_{2k}(y_{1},0)}{\mu_{2k}-\sigma\varepsilon_{i}}\,. (87) This equation helps to deduce the required condition on the coefficients A_{i} : \displaystyle 1 \displaystyle=\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}\int\limits_{\Gamma_{i}}V^{2}\,ds=\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}\varepsilon_{i}\pi^{2}A_{i}^{2}\sum\limits_{k=0}^{\infty}\frac{[\Psi_{2k}(\infty)]^{2}}{(\mu_{2k}-\sigma\varepsilon_{i})^{2}}\,, where we used the orthogonality of the eigenfunctions \Psi_{k} (see Appendix C ). The last sum can be re-written as the derivative of {\mathcal{C}}(\mu) , denoted as {\mathcal{C}}^{\prime}(\mu) : 1=-\pi\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}\varepsilon_{i}A_{i}^{2}{\mathcal{C}}^{\prime}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{i})\,. (88) When 0<\sigma\varepsilon_{i}\ll 1 , the Taylor expansion ( 49 ) implies {\mathcal{C}}^{\prime}(\mu)\approx-\pi/(2\mu^{2}) and thus \frac{2\sigma^{2}}{\pi^{2}}\approx\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}\frac{A_{i}^{2}}{\varepsilon_{i}}\,. (89) To complete this section, let us briefly discuss the positivity of Steklov eigenfunctions on patches \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{j}} . For a single patch, all Steklov eigenfunctions V_{j} must change sign on the patch due to their orthogonality to V_{0}=1/\sqrt{|\Gamma|} . When there are N Steklov patches, the orthogonality still holds so that any eigenfunction V_{j} with j>0 must change sign on the union of patches \Gamma=\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}\cup\cdots\cup\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{N}} . However, it is generally unknown whether V_{j} changes the sign or not on each patch \Gamma_{i} . Looking at Eq. ( 87 ), one can expect that if \sigma\varepsilon_{i} is small enough, the eigenfunction V does not change sign on the patch \Gamma_{i} (i.e., it is either positive, or negative on it). Indeed, the term 1/(-2\sigma\varepsilon_{i}) of the sum in Eq. ( 87 ) that corresponds to k=0 , is expected to provide the dominant contribution as compared to the remaining terms. This property follows from the conjectured inequality ( 194 ). In other words, if the patches are small enough, the first N eigenfunctions do not change their signs on each patch. This conjecture is confirmed by several numerical examples (not shown). 4.4 Example of two patches When N=2 , we calculate that ({\bf I}-{\bm{\nu}}{\bf E}/\bar{\nu}){\bm{\nu}}=\gamma\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}1&-1\\ -1&1\\ \end{array}\right), (90) where we label \gamma=\nu_{1}\nu_{2}/(\nu_{1}+\nu_{2}) . Then, from Eq. ( 77 ), we get {\bf M}_{1}={\bf I}+\gamma\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}(R_{1}-G_{1,2})+C_{1}&(G_{1,2}-R_{2})-C_{1}\\ (G_{1,2}-R_{1})-C_{1}&(R_{2}-G_{1,2})+C_{1}\\ \end{array}\right)\,,\qquad{\bf B}_{1}=\frac{\pi}{2}\gamma\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}1/\varepsilon_{1}&-1/\varepsilon_{2}\\ -1/\varepsilon_{1}&1/\varepsilon_{2}\\ \end{array}\right)\,. Since {\bf e} is a left-eigenvector of {\bf M}_{1} with eigenvalue one, the second eigenvalue of {\bf M}_{1} is simply \mathrm{trace}({\bf M}_{1})-1 . As a consequence, we find \mathrm{det}({\bf M}_{1})=\mathrm{trace}({\bf M}_{1})-1=1+\gamma[(R_{1}+R_{2}-2G_{1,2})+2C_{1}]\,, (91) and {\bf M}_{1}^{-1}=\frac{1}{\mathrm{det}({\bf M}_{1})}\biggl[{\bf I}+\gamma C_{1}{\bf E}+\gamma\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}R_{2}-G_{1,2}&R_{2}-G_{1,2}\\ R_{1}-G_{1,2}&R_{1}-G_{1,2}\\ \end{array}\right)\biggr]\,, (92) from which we calculate {\bf M}_{1}^{-1}{\bf B}_{1}=\frac{\pi\gamma/2}{\mathrm{det}({\bf M}_{1})}\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}1/\varepsilon_{1}&-1/\varepsilon_{2}\\ -1/\varepsilon_{1}&1/\varepsilon_{2}\\ \end{array}\right)\,. (93) The two eigenvalues of this matrix are \hat{\sigma}_{0}=0 and \hat{\sigma}_{1}=\frac{\pi\gamma(1/\varepsilon_{1}+1/\varepsilon_{2})}{2\,\mathrm{det}({\bf M}_{1})}\,, (94) so that upon solving for \hat{\sigma}_{1}^{-1} , we get \frac{1}{\hat{\sigma}_{1}}=\frac{2\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2}}{\pi(\varepsilon_{1}+\varepsilon_{2})}\biggl[\frac{1}{\gamma}+(R_{1}+R_{2}-2G_{1,2})+2C_{1}\biggr]\,. (95) To simplify this expression, we use \gamma=\frac{1}{1/\nu_{1}+1/\nu_{2}}=\frac{1}{-\ln(\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2})}\,. (96) This yields the following asymptotic behavior for the Steklov eigenvalue: \displaystyle\frac{1}{\sigma_{1}}\approx\frac{2\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2}}{\pi(\varepsilon_{1}+\varepsilon_{2})}\biggl[-\ln(\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2})+2C_{1}+(R_{1}+R_{2}-2G_{1,2})\biggr]\,. (97) For instance, if \Omega is the unit disk, Eq. ( 28 ) yields \displaystyle\frac{1}{\sigma_{1}}\approx\frac{2\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2}}{\pi(\varepsilon_{1}+\varepsilon_{2})}\biggl(-\ln(\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2})+2C_{1}+2\ln|\bm{x}_{1}-\bm{x}_{2}|\biggr)\,. (98) Moreover, the corresponding eigenfunction V_{1} can be easily found by noting that A_{1}=-A_{2} from Eq. ( 11 ), whereas Eq. ( 89 ) implies A_{1}=-A_{2}\approx\frac{\sqrt{2}\sigma_{1}}{\pi\sqrt{1/\varepsilon_{1}+1/\varepsilon_{2}}}\,. (99) These coefficients determine (V_{1})|_{\Gamma_{i}} via Eq. ( 87 ). 4.5 Example of identical equally-spaced patches on the boundary of the unit disk When all patches are of the same size, \varepsilon_{j}=\varepsilon , we have {\bm{\nu}}=\nu{\bf I} and {\bm{\eta}}={\bf I}\pi/(2\varepsilon) , so that {\bf M}_{1}={\bf I}+\nu\biggl({\bf I}-\frac{{\bf E}}{N}\biggr)({\bf G}+C_{1}{\bf I})\,,\qquad{\bf B}_{1}=\frac{\pi\nu}{2\varepsilon}\biggl({\bf I}-\frac{{\bf E}}{N}\biggr)\,. (100) If the patches are equally-spaced on the boundary of the unit disk, {\bf G} is circulant and symmetric, and its eigenvectors and eigenvalues were given in Eqs. ( 32 , 33 ). As shown earlier in Sec. 2.5 , one has ({\bf I}-{\bf E}/N){\bf q}_{j}={\bf q}_{j} for any j=1,2,\ldots,N-1 , and ({\bf I}-{\bf E}/N){\bf q}_{N}=0 . As a consequence, {\bf M}_{1}{\bf q}_{N}={\bf q}_{N} and {\bf M}_{1}{\bf q}_{j}=(1+\nu(\kappa_{j}+C_{1})){\bf q}_{j} , where \kappa_{j} are given explicitly by Eq. ( 40 ). Upon calculating {\bf M}_{1}^{-1}{\bf q}_{j} , we readily find that {\bf B}_{1}{\bf M}_{1}^{-1}{\bf q}_{N}=0\,,\qquad{\bf B}_{1}{\bf M}_{1}^{-1}{\bf q}_{j}=\frac{\pi\nu}{2\varepsilon}\bigl(1+\nu(\kappa_{j}+C_{1})\bigr)^{-1}{\bf q}_{j}\,. Since the eigenvalues of the matrices {\bf B}_{1}{\bf M}_{1}^{-1} and {\bf M}_{1}^{-1}{\bf B}_{1} are identical, we have from Eq. ( 79 ) that \hat{\sigma}_{0}=0 and \hat{\sigma}_{j}=\frac{\pi\nu}{2\varepsilon[1+\nu(\kappa_{j}+C_{1})]}\,,\qquad j\in\{{1,\ldots,N-1\}}\,. (101) Substituting C_{1}={3/2}-\ln{2} from Eq. ( 50 ) and \nu={-1/\ln\varepsilon} into Eq. ( 101 ), we obtain the following small- \varepsilon asymptotic result for the first N-1 eigenvalues of the mixed Steklov-Neumann problem: \frac{1}{\varepsilon\sigma_{j}}\approx\frac{2}{\pi}\biggl(-\ln(\varepsilon)+\frac{3}{2}-\ln(2)+\kappa_{j}\biggr)\,, (102) for j=1,2,\ldots,N-1 . When the number of patches is large, i.e. N\gg 1 , while still enforcing the well-separated patch assumption \varepsilon N\ll\pi , we can use the asymptotic relation ( 184 ) for \kappa_{j} , valid for j\ll N , to conclude that \frac{1}{\varepsilon\sigma_{j}}\approx\frac{2}{\pi}\biggl(\frac{N}{2j}-\ln\left(\frac{N\varepsilon}{\pi}\right)-\frac{1}{3}\biggr)\,. (103) If N\varepsilon is not too small, the logarithmic and constant terms can be neglected to yield to a first approximation \sigma_{j}\approx\frac{\pi j}{N\varepsilon}\quad\mbox{for}\quad j\ll N\,, (104) when N\gg 1 . It is instructive to compare this approximation to the case of a single Steklov patch of half-length \varepsilon_{1}=N\varepsilon , for which \sigma_{j}\approx\mu_{j}/\varepsilon_{1}\approx(\pi j/2)/(N\varepsilon) , where we used the asymptotic relation ( 196 ). As a consequence, the configuration with a single patch of half-length N\varepsilon yields approximately twice smaller eigenvalues. This suggests that the fragmentation of a patch will increase the eigenvalues. 5 Steklov-Neumann-Dirichlet problem In this section, we consider the last setting of a single Steklov patch \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}} and N-1 Dirichlet patches \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{j}} ( j=2,\ldots,N ). This is a typical situation when the diffusing particle needs to react on \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}} before escaping the domain \Omega through multiple opening windows \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{2}},\ldots,\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{N}} . A formal solution of such an escape problem was provided in [ 36 ] on the basis of the mixed Steklov-Neumann-Dirichlet spectral problem, formulated as \displaystyle\Delta V \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{in}~\Omega\,, (105a) \displaystyle\partial_{n}V \displaystyle=\sigma V\quad\textrm{on}~\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}\,;\qquad V=0\quad\textrm{on}~\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{2}}\cup\cdots\cup\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{N}}\,, (105b) \displaystyle\partial_{n}V \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{on}~\partial\Omega_{0}. (105c) As previously, this spectral problem is known to have a discrete positive spectrum [ 56 ] , i.e., infinitely many eigenpairs \{\sigma_{k},V_{k}\} that are enumerated by k=0,1,\ldots to form an increasing sequence of eigenvalues: 0<\sigma_{0}\leq\sigma_{1}\leq\ldots\nearrow\infty . The presence of Dirichlet patches implies that the principal eigenvalue \sigma_{0} is strictly positive. We aim at determining the asymptotic behavior of the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of this spectral problem in the small-target limit \varepsilon_{j}\to 0 . In the analysis below, we treat separately two cases depending on the integral of the Steklov eigenfunction on the Steklov patch \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}} . In particular, if \int_{\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}}\partial_{n}V\,ds=\sigma\int_{\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}}V\,ds\neq 0, (106) then, from the divergence theorem, the Steklov patch produces a logarithmic contribution to the far field. We will mainly focus on this generic case. However, if the integral in Eq. ( 106 ) is zero (e.g., if V|_{\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}} is antisymmetric, see below), there is no logarithmic contribution, and such an eigenfunction vanishes in the far field. This situation is actually simpler because the decay of V away from the Steklov patch is compatible with Dirichlet patches. In other words, we can restrict the analysis to the inner solution near the Steklov patch as if there were no Dirichlet patches. We will illustrate this situation in Sec. 5.4 . 5.1 Matched asymptotic analysis Expectedly, we can combine formerly derived inner solutions for Dirichlet and Steklov patches, whereas the outer solution is still written as the linear combination ( 70 ). As a consequence, we must enforce the singularity behavior V\sim A_{j}\biggl[\ln|\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{j}|+1/\nu_{j}+\delta_{j,1}{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})+o(1)\biggr]\,, (107) as \bm{x}\to\bm{x}_{j} for all patches j\in\{{1,\ldots,N\}} . Here we have used the former definition \nu_{j}=-1/\ln(\varepsilon_{j}/2) for Dirichlet patches and \nu_{1}=-1/\ln(\varepsilon_{1}) for the Steklov patch. By ensuring that V in Eq. ( 70 ) satisfies Eq. ( 107 ) we obtain that A_{j}+\nu_{j}\biggl[A_{j}R_{j}+\sum\limits_{i=1\atop i\neq j}^{N}G_{j,i}A_{i}\biggr]=\chi\nu_{j}-\nu_{1}A_{1}{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})\delta_{j,1}\,. (108) Together with Eq. ( 11 ), they form a system of N+1 linear equations for the unknowns A_{i} and \chi . Using the former matrix notation in Eqs. ( 15 ), Eq. ( 108 ) becomes \bigl({\bf I}+{\bm{\nu}}{\bf G}\bigr){\bf A}=\chi{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}-\nu_{1}{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1}){\bf e}_{1}{\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf A}\,, (109) with {\bf e}^{\dagger}{\bf A}=0 . Upon left-multiplying by {\bf e}^{\dagger} , we get \chi=\frac{1}{\bar{\nu}}\biggl[{\bf e}^{\dagger}{\bm{\nu}}{\bf G}{\bf A}+{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})\nu_{1}{\bf e}^{\dagger}{\bf E}_{1}{\bf A}\biggr]\,, (110) where \bar{\nu} was defined in Eq. ( 18 ), and we introduced the matrix {\bf E}_{1}={\bf e}_{1}{\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger} for a shorter notation. Eliminating \chi from Eq. ( 109 ), we obtain that \biggl({\bf I}+{\bm{\nu}}\biggl({\bf I}-\frac{{\bf E}{\bm{\nu}}}{\bar{\nu}}\biggr){\bf G}\biggr){\bf A}+{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})\nu_{1}\biggl({\bf I}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf E}}{\bar{\nu}}\biggr){\bf E}_{1}{\bf A}={\bf 0}\,, (111) where we recall that {\bf E}={\bf e}{\bf e}^{\dagger} . Upon introducing {\bf B} by {\bf B}=\biggl({\bf I}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf E}}{\bar{\nu}}\biggr){\bf E}_{1}\,, (112) and using the matrix {\bf M}_{0} from Eq. ( 20 ), we rewrite the matrix system in Eq. ( 111 ) as \bigl({\bf M}_{0}+{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})\nu_{1}{\bf B}\bigr){\bf A}={\bf 0}\,. (113) The condition, under which this matrix equation admits a nontrivial solution is \mathrm{det}\bigl({\bf M}_{0}+{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})\nu_{1}{\bf B}\bigr)=0\,, (114) which is a scalar problem that determines \sigma . To rewrite this problem in a more explicit form, we first observe that \mathrm{rank}({\bf B})=1 since {\bf E}_{1}{\bf q}=0 for any vector {\bf q}\in{\mathbb{R}}^{N} such that {\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf q}=0 . Since {\bf e}^{\dagger}{\bf e}_{1}=1 , we can rewrite {\bf B} in a more convenient rank-one form as {\bf B}=\biggl({\bf e}_{1}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}}{\bar{\nu}}\biggr){\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}={\bf a}{\bf b}^{\dagger}\,,\quad\mbox{where}\quad{\bf a}={\bf e}_{1}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}}{\bar{\nu}}\,,\qquad{\bf b}={\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})\nu_{1}{\bf e}_{1}\,. (115) To proceed, we need the matrix determinant lemma [ 22 ] . Lemma : Let {\bf M}={\bf M}_{0}+{\bf a}{\bf b}^{\dagger} be a perturbation of an invertible matrix {\bf M}_{0}\in{\mathbb{R}}^{N,N} by a rank-one matrix {\bf a}{\bf b}^{\dagger} . Then \mathrm{det}({\bf M}_{0}+{\bf a}{\bf b}^{\dagger})=(1+{\bf b}^{\dagger}{\bf M}_{0}^{-1}{\bf a})\,\mathrm{det}({\bf M}_{0})\,. (116) It follows that \mathrm{det}({\bf M})=0 if and only if {\bf b}^{\dagger}{\bf M}_{0}^{-1}{\bf a}=-1 . In the small-target limit, all \nu_{j}\ll 1 so that the matrix {\bf M}_{0} is invertible since it is a small perturbation of the identity matrix in Eq. ( 20 ). Applying the lemma above to our setting, we determine the condition on \sigma as {\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})=C\,, (117) where C=-\frac{1}{\nu_{1}}\biggl({\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf M}_{0}^{-1}\biggl[{\bf e}_{1}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}}{\bar{\nu}}\biggr]\biggr)^{-1}\,, (118) with the vectors and matrices {\bf e} , {\bf e}_{1} , {\bm{\nu}} , and {\bf M}_{0} being defined in Eqs. ( 15 , 20 ). This is the main result of this section that will allow us to determine the asymptotic behavior of the Steklov eigenvalues and their dependence on the configuration and sizes of all patches that are captured via the constant C in Eq. ( 118 ). We further emphasize that the homogeneous matrix equation ( 113 ) cannot uniquely determine the coefficients A_{i} . In fact, an eigenfunction V can be found up to a multiplicative factor that has to be fixed by normalization (see below). As stated above, the matrix {\bf M}_{0} is a small perturbation of the identity matrix in the small-target limit, so that {\bf M}_{0}^{-1}\sim{\bf I} to leading order, which implies that {\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf M}_{0}^{-1}[{\bf e}_{1}-{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}/\bar{\nu}]\sim 1-\nu_{1}/\bar{\nu}>0 . Since 0<\nu_{1}\ll 1 , we conclude that the constant C in Eq. ( 118 ) is negative and large: C<0\,,\qquad|C|\gg 1\,. (119) 5.2 Asymptotic behavior of eigenvalues and eigenfunctions Denoting \mu=-\sigma\varepsilon_{1} , we recast Eq. ( 117 ) as {\mathcal{C}}(\mu)=C\,. (120) The spectral expansion ( 48 ) of the function {\mathcal{C}}(\mu) allows one to solve this equation numerically for any fixed negative value C given by Eq. ( 118 ). Since the derivative {\mathcal{C}}^{\prime}(\mu)=d{\mathcal{C}}(\mu)/d\mu is negative, {\mathcal{C}}(\mu) is a continuous and monotonically decreasing function on each interval (-\mu_{2j+2},-\mu_{2j}) , with j=0,1,\ldots . Moreover, it ranges from +\infty to -\infty on each interval. As a consequence, for any fixed value C , there exist infinitely many negative solutions of Eq. ( 120 ), denoted as -\hat{\mu}_{2j} , such that \mu_{2j}\leq\hat{\mu}_{2j}\leq\mu_{2j+2}\quad\mbox{for}~j=0,1,\ldots\,. (121) This property facilitates the numerical solution, as a single zero has to be searched on each interval. Moreover, as the coefficients [\Psi_{2k}(\infty)]^{2} are small (see Table 2 ) and decrease with k , whereas C is negative and large, one has \hat{\mu}_{2j}\approx\mu_{2j} for j>0 . This is consistent with the intuitive picture that large Steklov eigenvalues become insensitive to Dirichlet patches in the small-target limit, and one retrieves the asymptotic behavior for a single Steklov patch [ 37 ] . The solutions \hat{\mu}_{2j}\approx\mu_{2j} determine the leading-order term in the asymptotic behavior of the eigenvalues \sigma_{2j} : \sigma_{2j}\approx\frac{\mu_{2j}}{\varepsilon_{1}}\qquad\mbox{for}~j=1,2,\ldots\,. (122) In contrast, the smallest eigenvalue \sigma_{0} involves the solution \hat{\mu}_{0} , which may actually be small in the small-target limit. We discuss this case separately in Sec. 5.3 . We also mention that the analysis above provides the leading-order approximation to the associated Steklov eigenfunction, restricted to \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}} . We recall that the inner solution near the Steklov patch is V_{2j}\sim A_{1}g_{-\sigma_{2j}\varepsilon_{1}}(\bm{y}) , with the Green’s function g_{\mu}(\bm{y}) given by Eq. ( 45 ). As a consequence, its restriction onto the patch reads V_{2j}\biggr|_{\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}}\approx a_{2j}\sum\limits_{k=0}^{\infty}\frac{\Psi_{2k}(\infty)}{\mu_{2k}-\varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{2j}}\Psi_{2k}(\bm{y})\,, (123) where the proportionality coefficient a_{2j} is fixed by the conventional normalization of the Steklov eigenfunction: 1=\int\limits_{\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}}V_{2j}^{2}\,ds\approx\varepsilon_{1}a_{2j}^{2}\sum\limits_{k=0}^{\infty}\frac{[\Psi_{2k}(\infty)]^{2}}{(\mu_{2k}-\varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{2j})^{2}}\,, (124) where the orthogonality of \Psi_{2k} was used. Since \varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{2j}\approx\mu_{2j} , the eigenfunction \Psi_{2j} provides the dominant contribution, and one gets for each j\in\{{1,2,\ldots\}} that V_{2j}(\bm{x}_{1}+\varepsilon_{1}{\bf Q}_{1}^{\dagger}(y_{1},0)^{\dagger})\approx\frac{1}{\sqrt{\varepsilon_{1}}}\Psi_{2j}(y_{1},0) (125) on the Steklov patch (i.e., for |y_{1}|\leq 1 ). We emphasize that the analysis above allowed us to access only half of eigenvalues with even indices 2j that correspond to symmetric eigenmodes. In turn, the eigenvalues with odd indices correspond to antisymmetric eigenmodes, for which the integral over the Steklov patch is zero. As discussed at the beginning of Sec. 5 , such eigenfunctions vanish away from the Steklov patch so that their asymptotic behavior can be determined directly from the local solution. As a consequence, we get a leading-order approximation \sigma_{2j+1}\approx\frac{\mu_{2j+1}}{\varepsilon_{1}}\qquad\mbox{for}~j=0,1,\ldots\,, (126) and on the Steklov patch we have V_{2j+1}(\bm{x}_{1}+\varepsilon_{1}{\bf Q}_{1}^{\dagger}(y_{1},0)^{\dagger})\approx\frac{1}{\sqrt{\varepsilon_{1}}}\Psi_{2j+1}(y_{1},0)\,. (127) In summary, our analysis justifies theoretically the intuitively appealing scaling argument that the eigenvalues \sigma_{j} and eigenfunctions (V_{j})|_{\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}} (on the Steklov patch) can be approximated by the eigenvalues \mu_{j} and eigenfunctions \Psi_{j} of the auxiliary problem ( 46 ), as if there were no Dirichlet patches. Regardless of the symmetry of eigenfunctions (and parity of its index), we can combine the former leading-order approximations as \displaystyle\sigma_{j} \displaystyle\approx\frac{\mu_{j}}{\varepsilon_{1}}\quad\mbox{for}~j=1,2,\ldots\,, (128a) \displaystyle V_{j}(\bm{x}_{1}+\varepsilon_{1}{\bf Q}_{1}^{\dagger}(y_{1},0)^{\dagger}) \displaystyle\approx\frac{1}{\sqrt{\varepsilon_{1}}}\Psi_{j}(y_{1},0)\,. (128b) In contrast, the presence of Dirichlet patches must affect the principal eigenvalue \sigma_{0} and the associated eigenfunction V_{0} , as explained below. 5.3 The principal eigenvalue Since \mu_{0}=0 , the smallest solution of Eq. ( 120 ), \hat{\mu}_{0} , is close to 0 . Indeed, as the constant C is large and negative, one needs to have |\mu|\ll 1 to ensure that {\mathcal{C}}(\mu) is also large and negative. Under the condition |\mu|\ll 1 , we can use the approximation ( 51 ), which can be easily inverted to get the explicit result \frac{1}{\mu}\approx\frac{2}{\pi}\bigl[{\mathcal{C}}(\mu)-C_{1}\bigr]=\frac{2}{\pi}\bigl[C-C_{1}\bigr]\,. (129) As a consequence, substitution of Eq. ( 118 ) here yields the asymptotic behavior of the principal eigenvalue \sigma_{0} : \frac{1}{\varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{0}}\approx-\frac{2}{\pi}\biggl[\ln(\varepsilon_{1})\biggl({\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf M}_{0}^{-1}\biggl[{\bf e}_{1}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}}{\bar{\nu}}\biggr]\biggr)^{-1}-C_{1}\biggr]\,. (130) In sharp contrast to Eq. ( 122 ) for \sigma_{j} with j\geq 1 , the principal eigenvalue \sigma_{0} exhibits a slower divergence {\mathcal{O}}(1/(\varepsilon_{1}\ln(\varepsilon_{1}))) . This is one of the main results of this section. The associated eigenfunction V_{0} is given by Eq. ( 123 ) with the normalization condition ( 124 ). We stress that Eq. ( 123 ) cannot be reduced to the approximation ( 125 ) in this case. 5.4 Example of two patches When there are two patches ( N=2 ), Eqs. ( 118 , 130 ) can be readily solved. Substituting {\bf M}_{0}^{-1} from Eq. ( 24 ) and {\bf e}_{1}-\frac{{\bm{\nu}}{\bf e}}{\bar{\nu}}=\frac{\nu_{2}}{\nu_{1}+\nu_{2}}\left(1,-1\right)^{\dagger} (131) into Eq. ( 118 ), we get after simplifications that C=\ln(\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2}/2)-(R_{1}+R_{2}-2G_{1,2})\,. (132) Using Eq. ( 129 ) with C_{1}={3/2}-\ln{2} from Eq. ( 50 ), the asymptotic behavior of the principal eigenvalue is \frac{1}{\varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{0}}\approx\frac{2}{\pi}\biggl(-\ln(\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2})+\frac{3}{2}+(R_{1}+R_{2}-2G_{1,2})\biggr)\,. (133) Figure 6: Illustration for the unit disk with Steklov and Dirichlet patches. (a) One Steklov patch of length 2\varepsilon_{1}=0.4 at \bm{x}_{1}=(1,0) (blue) and one Dirichlet patch of length 2\varepsilon_{2}=0.6 (red), whose center \bm{x}_{2} is at angle \theta=2\pi/3 . (b) One Steklov patch of length 2\varepsilon_{1}=2\varepsilon=0.2 at \bm{x}_{1}=(1,0) (blue) and three Dirichlet patches of length 2\varepsilon_{j}=0.4 (red), whose centers \bm{x}_{j} are equally-spaced on the boundary of the unit disk. For instance, when \Omega is the unit disk, one can substitute Eq. ( 28 ) into Eq. ( 133 ) to get \frac{1}{\varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{0}}\approx\frac{2}{\pi}\biggl(-\ln(\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2})+\frac{3}{2}+2\ln|\bm{x}_{1}-\bm{x}_{2}|\biggr)\,. (134) Figure 7 illustrates the remarkable accuracy of this asymptotic relation. Figure 7: Dependence of 1/(\varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{0}) on \varepsilon_{2} for the unit disk with a Steklov patch of length 2\varepsilon_{1} (located at \bm{x}_{1}=(1,0) ), and one Dirichlet patch of length 2\varepsilon_{2} , located at \bm{x}_{2} . Symbols present the numerical solution by a FEM with the maximal meshsize h_{\rm max}=0.005 and lines show Eq. ( 134 ). (a) \bm{x}_{2}=(0,1) and three values of \varepsilon_{1} : \varepsilon_{1}=\pi/6 (circles), \varepsilon_{1}=\pi/12 (squares), and \varepsilon_{1}=\pi/24 (triangles). (b) \varepsilon_{1}=\pi/12 and two locations of the Dirichlet patch: \bm{x}_{2}=(-1,0) (circles, \theta=\pi ), and \bm{x}_{2}=(0,1) (squares, angle \theta=\pi/2 ). Figure 8 shows the behavior of the Steklov eigenfunctions V_{j} restricted onto the Steklov patch. For the principal eigenmode with j=0 , this restriction is positive, as expected. The asymptotic formula ( 123 ) yields an accurate approximation. Let us now look at other eigenmodes with j=1,2,3 , for which \sigma_{j}\approx\mu_{j}/\varepsilon_{1} . We see that the restriction of V_{j} and its approximation ( 128 ) are in excellent agreement, for both symmetric and antisymmetric eigenfunctions, even though both considered patches are not small. Figure 8: The eigenfunctions V_{j} restricted on the Steklov patch \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}} , for the unit disk with a Steklov patch of length 2\varepsilon_{1}=\pi/12\approx 0.26 (located at \bm{x}_{1}=(1,0) ), and one Dirichlet patch of length 2\varepsilon_{2}=\pi/6\approx 0.52 , located at \bm{x}_{2}=(-1,0) . Filled circles present the numerical solution by a FEM with the maximal meshsize h_{\rm max}=0.005 , while solid lines show Eq. ( 123 ) for j=0 and Eq. ( 128 ) for j>0 . Four panels present the cases j=0,1,2,3 . 5.5 Example of equally-spaced patches on the unit disk We now consider another setting where the general formulas ( 117 ) and ( 118 ) can be simplified. We suppose that all Dirichlet patches with j=2,\ldots,N are of the same length, so that \varepsilon_{j}=\varepsilon for j\in\{{2,\ldots,N\}} , whereas for the Steklov patch we have \varepsilon_{1}=\ell_{1}\varepsilon/2 , for some \ell_{1}>0 . To treat this case, we can impose in our general formula ( 118 ) for C that \nu=\nu_{1}=\ldots=\nu_{N}=-{1/\ln(\varepsilon/2)},\qquad{\bm{\nu}}=\nu{\bf I}, (135) provided that we shift {\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1}) appropriately in the relation ( 117 ). To determine this shift, we write the singularity condition ( 107 ) as \bm{x}\to\bm{x}_{1} associated with the Steklov patch j=1 as \displaystyle V \displaystyle\sim A_{1}\biggl[\ln|\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{1}|-\ln\varepsilon_{1}+{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})+o(1)\biggr] \displaystyle\sim A_{1}\biggl[\ln|\bm{x}-\bm{x}_{1}|+1/\nu+\tilde{{\mathcal{C}}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})+o(1)\biggr]\,, where we have defined \tilde{{\mathcal{C}}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1}) by \tilde{{\mathcal{C}}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})={\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})-\ln\left(\frac{2\varepsilon_{1}}{\varepsilon}\right)\,. (136) As a result, by repeating the steps of Sec. 5.1 , we need only replace Eq. ( 117 ) by {\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})-\ln\left(\frac{2\varepsilon_{1}}{\varepsilon}\right)=C\,, (137) where C is given by Eq. ( 118 ) with {\bm{\nu}}=\nu{\bf I} , \bar{\nu}=N\nu , and \nu={-1/\ln\left({\varepsilon/2}\right)} , which yields C=\frac{1}{\nu}\biggl(\frac{{\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf M}_{0}^{-1}{\bf e}}{N}-{\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf M}_{0}^{-1}{\bf e}_{1}\biggr)^{-1}\,. (138) If all \bm{x}_{j} are equally-spaced on the boundary of the unit disk (such as shown in Fig. 6 (b)), then the matrix {\bf G} is circulant and symmetric, so that its eigenvectors and eigenvalues are known exactly (see Sec. 2.5 ). Moreover, the matrix {\bf M}_{0} admits a spectral representation and thus can be inverted explicitly. Using Eq. ( 36 ), we get {\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf M}_{0}^{-1}{\bf e}=1\,,\qquad{\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf M}_{0}^{-1}{\bf e}_{1}=({\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf q}_{N})({\bf q}_{N}^{\dagger}{\bf e}_{1})+\sum\limits_{j=1}^{N-1}\frac{({\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf q}_{j})\,({\bf q}_{j}^{\dagger}{\bf e}_{1})}{1+\nu\kappa_{j}}\,, (139) where {\bf q}_{j} and \kappa_{j} were defined by Eqs. ( 32 , 40 ). However, since ({\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf q}_{j})=\omega^{j}/\sqrt{N} and ({\bf q}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf e}_{1})=\omega^{-j}/\sqrt{N} , we get {\bf e}_{1}^{\dagger}{\bf M}_{0}^{-1}{\bf e}_{1}=\frac{1}{N}\biggl[1+\sum\limits_{j=1}^{N-1}(1+\nu\kappa_{j})^{-1}\biggr]\,. (140) Substituting this expression together with Eq. ( 139 ) into Eq. ( 138 ), we find C=-\frac{N}{\nu}\biggl(\sum\limits_{j=1}^{N-1}\frac{1}{1+\nu\kappa_{j}}\biggr)^{-1}\,. (141) As a result, Eqs. ( 129 , 137 ) with C_{1}={3/2}-\ln{2} imply \displaystyle\frac{1}{\varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{0}} \displaystyle\approx-\frac{2}{\pi}\bigl[{\mathcal{C}}(-\sigma\varepsilon_{1})-C_{1}\bigr]=-\frac{2}{\pi}\bigl[C+\ln\left(\frac{2\varepsilon_{1}}{\varepsilon}\right)-C_{1}\bigr] \displaystyle\approx\frac{2}{\pi}\biggl[\frac{N}{\sum\nolimits_{j=1}^{N-1}\bigl(\ln(2/\varepsilon)+\kappa_{j}\bigr)^{-1}}+C_{1}-\ln\left(\frac{2\varepsilon_{1}}{\varepsilon}\right)\biggr]\,. (142) Figure 9 illustrates the behavior of 1/(\varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{0}) as a function of \ln(\varepsilon) for the unit disk with one Steklov patch of length 2\varepsilon , and several Dirichlet patches of length 4\varepsilon , which are equally-spaced on the boundary of the unit disk. We observe an excellent agreement between the asymptotic formula ( 142 ) and numerical results. Figure 9: Dependence of 1/(\varepsilon\sigma_{0}) on \varepsilon for the unit disk with one Steklov patch of length 2\varepsilon (located at \bm{x}_{0}=(1,0) ), and N-1 Dirichlet patches of length 4\varepsilon , equally-spaced on the boundary of the unit disk. Symbols present the numerical solution by a FEM with the maximal meshsize h_{\rm max}=0.005 and lines show Eq. ( 142 ). Although the eigenvalues \kappa_{j} are known explicitly via Eq. ( 40 ), it is instructive to inspect their asymptotic behavior for large N (see Appendix B ). We aim at approximating the sum in the denominator of Eq. ( 142 ): S=\frac{1}{N}\sum\limits_{j=1}^{N-1}\frac{1}{\ln(2/\varepsilon)+\kappa_{j}}\,. (143) The degeneracy \kappa_{N-j}=\kappa_{j} allows us to limit this sum to j\leq{N/2} when N is even. By using the asymptotic result in Eq. ( 185 ) for \kappa_{j} when N\gg 1 , we find that \ln\left({2/\varepsilon}\right)+\kappa_{j}\approx\frac{1}{2\xi}+\zeta+a\frac{\pi^{2}\xi^{2}}{9}\,, (144) where we have defined \xi={j/N} , \zeta=-\ln\left(\frac{N\varepsilon}{b}\right)\,,\quad\mbox{and}\quad b=4\pi e^{-11/6}\approx 2.009\,. (145) Here the coefficient a=1.25 was empirically introduced to improve the accuracy of the approximation of \kappa_{j} (see Appendix B for details). In terms of \zeta , and substituting {j/N}=\xi , we view S as a Riemannian approximation of the integral defined by S\approx S(\zeta)=4\int\limits_{0}^{1/2}\frac{\xi\,d\xi}{1+2\xi\left(\zeta+a\pi^{2}\xi^{2}/9\right)}\,. (146) As a result, Eq. ( 142 ) is approximated for N\gg 1 by \displaystyle\frac{1}{\varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{0}} \displaystyle\approx\frac{2}{\pi}\biggl[\frac{1}{S(\zeta)}+C_{1}-\ln\left(\frac{2\varepsilon_{1}}{\varepsilon}\right)\biggr], (147) where \zeta is defined in Eq. ( 145 ). In this way, we have reduced the problem of estimating {1/(\varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{0})} to a simple numerical quadrature of the function S(\zeta) in Eq. ( 146 ). To obtain a more explicit, but less accurate, approximation, we neglect the {a\pi^{2}\xi^{2}/9} term in Eq. ( 146 ), which corresponds to using the result ( 184 ) for \kappa_{j} , and then evaluate the resulting integral to get S={\left(\zeta-\ln(1+\zeta)\right)/\zeta^{2}} . In this way, Eq. ( 142 ) can be approximated more explicitly as \frac{1}{\varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{0}}\approx\frac{2}{\pi}\left[\frac{\zeta^{2}}{\zeta-\ln(1+\zeta)}+C_{1}-\ln\left(\frac{2\varepsilon_{1}}{\varepsilon}\right)\right]\,. (148) For 63 Dirichlet patches (i.e. N=64 ) and with \varepsilon_{1}=0.1 , Fig. 10 compares the asymptotic results obtained by using the discrete sum ( 142 ) with its large- N approximation ( 147 ) and with the simpler, more explicit, result ( 148 ). We observe that Eq. ( 147 ) provides an excellent approximation, while Eq. ( 148 ) has a small systematic underestimate. Figure 10: Dependence of 1/(\varepsilon_{1}\sigma) on \varepsilon for the unit disk with the Steklov patch of length 2\varepsilon_{1}=0.2 and 63 Dirichlet patches (each of length 2\varepsilon ) that are equally-spaced on the boundary of the unit disk. Filled circles correspond to \kappa_{j} obtained via the discrete sum ( 142 ), the solid line indicates its large- N approximation ( 147 ), and the dashed line is the low-order approximation ( 148 ). 6 Further extensions In the previous four sections, we progressively increased the complexity of the problem: (i) N perfectly reactive (Dirichlet) patches; (ii) N partially reactive (Robin) patches; (iii) N imperfect (Steklov) patches; and (iv) one imperfect patch with N-1 Dirichlet patches. We showed that the asymptotic analysis required to study these settings is similar, although the resulting formulas became progressively more intricate. In the same vein, we can treat any combination of perfectly reactive, partially reactive and imperfect patches. In this section, we briefly discuss two other extensions that are relevant for applications: the case of interior targets (Sec. 6.1 ) and the exterior problem (Sec. 6.2 ). 6.1 Interior targets Throughout this paper, we focused on reactive patches on the boundary of a bounded domain. In many applications, however, absorbing sinks, traps and/or reactive targets can be hidden inside a bounded domain \Omega_{0} , surrounded by a reflecting boundary \partial\Omega_{0} . Let us consider the problem with N interior targets, where each target is a compact set \Omega_{\varepsilon_{j}}\subset\Omega_{0} of size \varepsilon_{j} , centered at a point \bm{x}_{j} (Fig. 11 ). Since the targets are impenetrable for a diffusing particle, we still consider surface reactions on their boundaries, denoted as \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{j}}=\partial\Omega_{\varepsilon_{j}} . As before, the targets are small ( \varepsilon_{j}\sim o(1) ), comparable in size, and well-separated from each other: |\bm{x}_{j}-\bm{x}_{k}|\sim{\mathcal{O}}(1) for j\neq k , and from the domain boundary \partial\Omega_{0} : |\bm{x}_{j}-\bm{x}|\sim{\mathcal{O}}(1) for any \bm{x}\in\partial\Omega_{0} . This setting represents diffusion in a perforated domain \Omega=\Omega_{0}\backslash(\Omega_{\varepsilon_{1}}\cup\cdots\cup\Omega_{\varepsilon_{N}}) with the boundary \partial\Omega=\partial\Omega_{0}\cup\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}}\cup\cdots\cup\Gamma_{\varepsilon_{N}} . These notations allow us to make an equivalence with the earlier setting introduced at the beginning of Sec. 2 . In particular, we can retain the same formulations of the four considered problems. As expected, their solutions can be constructed analogously, but with some modifications in the “building blocks”. In this section, we briefly describe these modifications and illustrate a few results. Figure 11: Illustration of a bounded domain \Omega\subset{\mathbb{R}}^{2} with a smooth reflecting boundary \partial\Omega_{0} (gray dashed line) and three interior targets \Omega_{\varepsilon_{j}} (filled in gray), centered at \bm{x}_{j} , with reactive boundaries \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{j}} (in red and blue). For a particle started from a point \bm{x}\in\Omega , the splitting probability S_{1}(\bm{x}) is the probability of hitting the boundary \Gamma_{\varepsilon_{1}} first. Perfectly reactive targets: Dirichlet boundary condition If the j -th target is perfectly reactive (with Dirichlet condition), the inner solution around this target is proportional to the exterior Dirichlet Green’s function \Delta g_{\infty}=0\quad\textrm{in}~{\mathbb{R}}^{2}\backslash\Omega_{j}\,;\qquad g_{\infty}=0\quad\textrm{on}~\partial\Omega_{j}\,;\qquad g_{\infty}\sim\ln|\bm{y}|+{\mathcal{O}}(1)\quad\textrm{as}~|\bm{y}|\to\infty\,, (149) where \Omega_{j}=\varepsilon_{j}^{-1}\Omega_{\varepsilon_{j}} is the rescaled target \Omega_{\varepsilon_{j}} . In contrast to the earlier studied case of a Dirichlet patch, the Green’s function g_{\infty}(\bm{y}) depends on the shape of the target \Omega_{j} and thus is not universal. In particular, its asymptotic behavior is g_{\infty}(\bm{y})\sim\ln|\bm{y}|-\ln(d_{j})+o(1) as |\bm{y}|\to\infty , where d_{j} is the logarithmic capacity of \Omega_{j} . For instance, if \Omega_{j} is the unit disk, its logarithmic capacity is 1 . Numerical values for d_{j} for various shapes of \Omega_{j} are given in Table 1 of [ 54 ] . In addition, the outer solution involves the Neumann Green’s function G_{\rm b}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) (also known as pseudo-Green’s function) that satisfies \displaystyle\Delta G_{\rm b} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{|\Omega_{0}|}-\delta(\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}})\quad\textrm{in}~\Omega_{0}\,;\qquad\partial_{n}G_{\rm b}=0\quad\textrm{on}~\partial\Omega_{0}\,;\qquad\int\limits_{\Omega_{0}}G_{\rm b}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})\,d\bm{x}=0\,, (150a) \displaystyle G_{\rm b}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) \displaystyle\sim-\frac{1}{2\pi}\ln|\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}|+R_{\rm b}({\bm{\xi}})+o(1)\quad\textrm{as}~\bm{x}\to{\bm{\xi}}\in\Omega_{0}\,, (150b) where we added the subscript b to distinguish it from the surface Neumann Green’s function G(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) . The main difference between this Green’s function and the surface Neumann Green’s function defined by Eqs. ( 9 ) is that the singularity at {\bm{\xi}} is located in the bulk and not on the boundary (accordingly, there is the factor 1/(2\pi) in Eq. ( 150b ) instead of 1/\pi ). For instance, when \Omega_{0} is the unit disk, the Neumann Green’s function is well-known [ 51 ] : \displaystyle G_{\rm b}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) \displaystyle=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\ln|\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}|-\frac{1}{4\pi}\ln\left(|\bm{x}|^{2}|{\bm{\xi}}|^{2}+1-2\bm{x}{\bf\cdot}{\bm{\xi}}\right)+\frac{|\bm{x}|^{2}+|{\bm{\xi}}|^{2}}{4\pi}-\frac{3}{8\pi}\,, (151a) \displaystyle R_{\rm b}({\bm{\xi}}) \displaystyle=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\ln\left(1-|{\bm{\xi}}|^{2}\right)+\frac{|{\bm{\xi}}|^{2}}{2\pi}-\frac{3}{8\pi}\,. (151b) We remark that rapidly converging infinite series representations for G_{\rm b} and R_{\rm b} are also known explicitly for ellipses (see Eqs. (4.6, 4.7) from [ 49 ] ) and for rectangles (see Eq. (4.13) of Section 4.2 of [ 52 ] , as well as [ 61 ] ). With these minor changes in the “building blocks”, we can repeat the steps in Secs. 2.2 and 2.3 to obtain that the splitting probability S_{k}(\bm{x}) is S_{k}(\bm{x})=\chi_{k}-\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}2\pi A_{i}G_{\rm b}(\bm{x},\bm{x}_{i})\,, (152) where the coefficients \chi_{k} and A_{i} are still determined via Eqs. ( 17 , 21 ), but now with \nu_{j}=-1/\ln(\varepsilon_{j}d_{j}) . Note also that the matrix {\bf G} from Eq. ( 15 ) is now based on the Neumann Green’s function G_{\rm b}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) from Eqs. ( 150 ) and its regular part R_{\rm b}({\bm{\xi}}) . In addition, the factor \pi in the definition ( 14 ) of the elements of the matrix {\bf G} should be replaced by 2\pi . The example of two targets can be worked out explicitly. Moreover, equally-spaced targets located on a circular ring that is concentric within a unit disk can also be treated explicitly. Partially reactive targets: Robin boundary condition If the j -th target is partially reactive , we should replace the Dirichlet boundary condition by a Robin condition with the reactivity parameter q_{j} . In the same vein, the former Robin Green’s function g_{\mu}(\bm{y}) now satisfies \Delta g_{\mu}=0\quad\textrm{in}~{\mathbb{R}}^{2}\backslash\Omega_{j}\,;\qquad\partial_{n}g_{\mu}+\mu g_{\mu}=0\quad\textrm{on}~\partial\Omega_{j}\,;\qquad g_{\mu}\sim\ln|\bm{y}|+{\mathcal{C}}_{j}(\varepsilon_{j}q_{j})+o(1)\quad\textrm{as}~|\bm{y}|\to\infty\,, (153) with \mu=\varepsilon_{j}q_{j} . In particular, the constant term {\mathcal{C}}_{j}(\mu) of its asymptotic behavior at infinity is not universal and depends on the shape of \Omega_{j} . We can still employ the eigenmodes of the exterior Steklov problem in {\mathbb{R}}^{2}\backslash\Omega_{j} to construct g_{\mu}(\bm{y}) and to determine the spectral expansion for {\mathcal{C}}_{j}(\mu) : {\mathcal{C}}_{j}(\mu)=-\ln(d_{j})+\frac{2\pi}{\mu|\partial\Omega_{j}|}+2\pi\sum\limits_{k=1}^{\infty}\frac{[\Psi_{k}^{j}(\infty)]^{2}}{\mu_{k}^{j}+\mu}\,, (154) where \mu_{k}^{j} and \Psi_{k}^{j} are the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of the auxiliary exterior Steklov problem, \Delta\Psi_{k}^{j}=0\quad\textrm{in}~{\mathbb{R}}^{2}\backslash\Omega_{j}\,;\qquad\partial_{n}\Psi_{k}^{j}=\mu_{k}^{j}\Psi_{k}^{j}\quad\textrm{on}~\partial\Omega_{j}\,;\qquad\Psi_{k}^{j}\sim{\mathcal{O}}(1)\quad\textrm{as}~|\bm{y}|\to\infty\,. (155) We also used the normalization \Psi_{0}^{j}=1/\sqrt{|\partial\Omega_{j}|} of the principal eigenfunction associated to \mu_{0}^{j}=0 . As earlier, a partially reactive target can be treated a perfect one, but with the reduced size: \varepsilon_{j}^{\rm eff}=\varepsilon_{j}\,\exp\bigl(-\ln(d_{j})-{\mathcal{C}}_{j}(\varepsilon_{j}q_{j})\bigr)\,, (156) (see further discussion and examples in Sec. 3 ). For the target \Omega_{j} of an arbitrary shape, the computation of the Steklov eigenmodes \mu_{k}^{j} and \Psi_{k}^{j} requires numerical techniques (e.g., a finite-element method, see [ 10 , 38 ] and references therein). However, if the rescaled target \Omega_{j} is the unit disk, the eigenmodes are known explicitly and they all vanish at infinity, except \Psi_{0}^{j} . As the logarithmic capacity of the unit disk is equal to 1 , we get a particularly simple exact expression: {\mathcal{C}}_{\rm disk}(\mu)=\frac{1}{\mu}\,. (157) This is not surprising given that the exterior Green’s function for the unit disk is simply g_{\mu}(\bm{y})=1/\mu+\ln|\bm{y}| . Imperfect targets In a similar way, we can easily reproduce the derivations of Secs. 4 and 5 for the mixed Steklov-Neumann and Steklov-Neumann-Dirichlet problems. For an imperfect target \Omega_{\varepsilon_{j}} of arbitrary shape, the main difficulty is the lack of knowledge of the function {\mathcal{C}}_{j}(\mu) , which is formally accessible via the spectral expansion ( 154 ) but its “ingredients” require numerical computations. Moreover, as the coefficients of the Taylor expansion of {\mathcal{C}}_{j}(\mu) are unknown, we cannot rely on the approximation ( 51 ). As a consequence, many numerical steps would be involved, and the analytical, almost explicit form of the asymptotic results would in general be lost. An interesting extension of this work consists of a systematic study of the function {\mathcal{C}}_{j}(\mu) for targets of various shapes. A drastic simplification appears when the imperfect targets are disks due the explicit form ( 157 ) of the function {\mathcal{C}}(\mu) . In this case, the analysis of Secs. 4 and 5 can be reproduced and will actually be even simpler. For instance, for the mixed Steklov-Neumann-Dirichlet problem with a single disk-shaped target \Omega_{\varepsilon_{1}} and one perfectly reactive target \Omega_{\varepsilon_{2}} (of arbitrary shape), one can rewrite Eq. ( 132 ) as C=\ln(d_{2}\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2})-2\pi\bigl[R_{\rm b}(\bm{x}_{1})+R_{\rm b}(\bm{x}_{2})-2G_{\rm b}(\bm{x}_{1},\bm{x}_{2})\bigr]\,, (158) from which the principal eigenvalue reads \frac{1}{\varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{0}}\approx-\ln(d_{2}\varepsilon_{1}\varepsilon_{2})+2\pi\bigl[R_{\rm b}(\bm{x}_{1})+R_{\rm b}(\bm{x}_{2})-2G_{\rm b}(\bm{x}_{1},\bm{x}_{2})\bigr]\,. (159) Figure 12 illustrates the accuracy of the asymptotic relation ( 159 ) for the unit disk with two interior circular targets. We observe a close agreement between a numerical solution and the asymptotic formula. One can notice a small deviation between two lines that slightly increases as the target radius \varepsilon_{2} decreases. This minor discrepancy seems to be a numerical artefact due to the available meshsize 0.005 , which becomes comparable to the target at small \varepsilon_{2} . To check this point, we computed the eigenvalue of the mixed Steklov-Dirichlet problem for a circular annulus with radii \varepsilon_{2} and R=1 , with Steklov condition on the outer circle and Dirichlet condition on the inner circle. As the exact solution of this problem is known, \sigma_{0}=1/(R\ln(R/\varepsilon_{2})) , we could compare it with the numerical results, and found the same minor discrepancy. Figure 12: The asymptotic behavior of the principal eigenvalue of the mixed Steklov-Neumann-Dirichlet problem, plotted as 1/(\varepsilon_{1}\sigma_{0}) versus \varepsilon_{2} , for the unit disk with two interior circular targets of radii \varepsilon_{1}=0.05 and \varepsilon_{2} (variable from 0.01 to 0.1 ), located at \bm{x}_{1}=(-0.5,0) and \bm{x}_{2}=(0.5,0) . Filled circles present the numerical solution by a FEM with the maximal meshsize of 0.005 , solid line indicates Eq. ( 159 ). In summary, we conclude that interior targets can be handled in essentially the same way as boundary patches, even though the asymptotic analysis becomes sensitive to the shapes of the targets. Moreover, one can combine interior targets with boundary patches that opens a way to access a broad variety of various geometric settings. 6.2 Exterior problems Another extension of the present approach is related to exterior problems in \Omega={\mathbb{R}}^{2}\backslash\Omega_{0} , where \Omega_{0} is a simply-connected compact domain. While the inner solutions remain unchanged, the outer solution is now constructed using the exterior surface Neumann Green’s function, labeled by G_{\rm e} , which satisfies \displaystyle\Delta G_{\rm e} \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{in}~{\mathbb{R}}^{2}\backslash\Omega_{0}\,, (160a) \displaystyle G_{\rm e}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) \displaystyle\sim-\frac{1}{\pi}\ln|\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}|+R_{\rm e}({\bm{\xi}})+o(1)\quad\textrm{as}~\bm{x}\to{\bm{\xi}}\in\partial\Omega_{0}\,;\qquad\partial_{n}G_{\rm e}=0\quad\textrm{on}~\partial\Omega_{0}\backslash\{{\bm{\xi}}\}\,, (160b) \displaystyle G_{\rm e}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) \displaystyle\sim-\frac{1}{2\pi}\ln|\bm{x}|+o(1)\quad\textrm{as}~|\bm{x}|\to\infty\,, (160c) where R_{\rm e}({\bm{\xi}}) is the regular part of G_{\rm e}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) at {\bm{\xi}} . The condition that G_{\rm e}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})+(2\pi)^{-1}\ln|\bm{x}|\to 0 as |\bm{x}|\to\infty determines G_{\rm e} uniquely. In the case when \Omega_{0} is the unit disk and |{\bm{\xi}}|=1 , we claim that G_{\rm e}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})=-\frac{1}{\pi}\ln|\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}|+\frac{1}{2\pi}\ln|\bm{x}|\,,\qquad R_{\rm e}({\bm{\xi}})=0\,. (161) Clearly Eq. ( 161 ) satisfies the behavior ( 160c ) as |\bm{x}|\to\infty as well as Eq. ( 160b ) as \bm{x}\to{\bm{\xi}} , where we identify that R_{\rm e}({\bm{\xi}})=0 (see more details in Appendix F.1 ). For instance, if there are two patches on the unit circle, the solution of any of four earlier considered problems involves R_{\rm e}(\bm{x}_{1})+R_{\rm e}(\bm{x}_{2})-2G_{\rm e}(\bm{x}_{1},\bm{x}_{2})=\frac{2}{\pi}\ln|\bm{x}_{1}-\bm{x}_{2}|\,, (162) which is identical for both interior and exterior domains. This property is consistent with the fact that the eigenvalues of interior and exterior mixed Steklov problems for the unit disk are identical. In contrast, the associated eigenfunctions behave differently. 7 Discussion In this paper, we have established a general mathematical framework for studying the competition of small targets for a diffusing particle in planar domains. Using the method of matched asymptotic expansions, as tailored for problems with localized defects [ 79 ] and with logarithmic gauge functions [ 78 ] , we solved four different problems of increasing complexity in the boundary conditions: (i) splitting probabilities for perfectly reactive patches with Dirichlet condition; (ii) their extension to partially reactive patches with Robin condition; (iii) mixed Steklov-Neumann problem describing imperfect patches; and (iv) mixed Steklov-Neumann-Dirichlet problem describing the escape of a particle through Dirichlet patches in the presence of an imperfect patch. Although the first problem was thoroughly studied in the past, we have improved some former results. To our knowledge, the asymptotic behavior for the three other problems in the small-target limit has not been reported previously. Moreover, we discussed two further extensions of our results to the case of interior targets and to exterior problems. The established asymptotic formalism in our 2-D setting can be applied to a broad variety of natural and industrial phenomena such as diffusion-controlled reactions in chemistry and biology. It would be worthwhile to extend our analytical framework to determine high-order asymptotic expansions to treat analogous 3-D problems with many either partially reactive or imperfect (Steklov) patches on the domain boundary. For a locally circular partially reactive patch on the boundary of a 3-D domain, a leading-order asymptotic theory was derived in [ 9 ] to determine the mean first-passage time for small, intermediate, and large patch reactivities. In [ 43 ] , the large reactivity limit was analyzed in detail. However, it is an open problem to derive high-order asymptotic expansions allowing for multiple partially reactive or imperfect patches, as the local geometry of the domain boundary will play a key role in the analysis. Acknowledgements. The authors thank professors I. Polterovich and M. Levitin for fruitful discussions, and A. Chaigneau for his implementation of the FEM code. D.S.G. acknowledges the Simons Foundation for supporting his sabbatical sojourn in 2024 at the CRM, University of Montréal, Canada, and the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation for support within a Bessel Prize award. M.J.W. was supported by the NSERC Discovery grant program. Competing interests declaration Competing interests: The author(s) declare none Appendix A Green’s function for the Dirichlet patch in the half-plane The Green’s function satisfying Eq. ( 3 ) can be found exactly. Even though this solution is classical [ 69 ] we reproduce it here for completeness. For this purpose, we use the elliptic coordinates for an ellipse with semi-axes a>b : y_{1}=a_{E}\cosh\alpha\cos\theta\,,\qquad y_{2}=a_{E}\sinh\alpha\sin\theta\,, (163) where a_{E}=\sqrt{a^{2}-b^{2}} , \alpha\geq 0 and -\pi<\theta\leq\pi . It is worth noting that all points on the horizontal interval (-a_{E},a_{E})\times\{0\} correspond to \alpha=\theta=0 and are thus indistinguishable. In our setting, we fix a=1 and b=0 . We search for g_{\infty}(\bm{y}) in the form g_{\infty}(\bm{y})=\ln|\bm{y}|-\ln(d)-\sum\limits_{n=1}^{\infty}c_{n}\cos(n\theta)e^{-n\alpha}\,, (164) with unknown coefficients c_{n} . This is a general form of a harmonic function, which behaves as \ln|\bm{y}|-\ln(d) at infinity and satisfies the condition \partial_{n}g_{\infty}=0 on |y_{1}|>1 , y_{2}=0 . The coefficients c_{n} are determined by the condition g_{\infty}=0 on |y_{1}|\leq 1 , y_{2}=0 , which yields 0=\ln|\cos\theta|-\ln(d)-\sum\limits_{n=1}^{\infty}c_{n}\cos(n\theta)\,,\qquad(0\leq\theta\leq\pi) (165) (here we restrict the analysis to the upper half-plane, with \theta\geq 0 ). Using the expansion \ln(2|z-z_{0}|)=-\sum\limits_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{2}{n}T_{n}(z)T_{n}(z_{0})\,, (166) where T_{n}(\cos z)=\cos(nz) are the Chebyshev polynomials and z_{0}=0 , we immediately see that the boundary condition ( 165 ) implies \ln(d)=-\ln(2)\,,\qquad c_{n}=\frac{2}{n}\,. (167) The solution then reads g_{\infty}(\bm{y})=\ln|\bm{y}|+\ln(2)-\sum\limits_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{2}{n}\cos(n\theta)e^{-n\alpha}\,. (168) By summing this series in terms of the logarithm we get g_{\infty}(\bm{y})=\ln|\bm{y}|+\ln(2)-\ln\bigl(1-2\cos\theta e^{-\alpha}+e^{-2\alpha}\bigr)\,. (169) Note that the elliptic coordinates \alpha and \theta can be easily expressed in terms of \bm{y}=(y_{1},y_{2}) by setting r_{\pm}=\sqrt{(y_{1}\pm a_{E})^{2}+y_{2}^{2}}=a_{E}(\cosh\alpha\pm\cos\theta)\,, (170) from which \cosh\alpha=\frac{r_{+}+r_{-}}{2a_{E}}\,,\qquad\cos\theta=\frac{r_{+}-r_{-}}{2a_{E}}\,. (171) Using Eq. ( 168 ), we calculate that -\partial_{n}g_{\infty}|_{(-1,1)}=\biggl(\frac{1}{h_{\alpha}}\partial_{\alpha}g_{\infty}\biggr)_{\alpha=0}=\frac{1}{|\sin\theta|}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-y_{1}^{2}}}\,, (172) where we used h_{\alpha}=a_{E}\sqrt{\cosh^{2}\alpha-\cos^{2}\theta}=|\sin\theta| at \alpha=0 for the scale factor. In particular, the integral of this expression over the interval (-1,1) is equal to \pi , as expected from the divergence theorem. Appendix B Limit of many small targets In this Appendix, we study the large- N behavior of the eigenvalues \kappa_{j} , given in Eq. ( 41 ), of the matrix {\bf G} for N identical equally-spaced patches on the boundary of the unit disk. Since the \kappa_{j} are the eigenvalues of the symmetric and circulant matrix {\bf G} , we have \kappa_{j}=\kappa_{N-j} for j=1,\ldots,{N/2} when N is even. As such, we need only estimate \kappa_{j} for j=1,\ldots,{N/2} when N\gg 1 is even. To do so, we use the Euler-Maclaurin expansion for a C^{\infty} function f(\theta) on 1\leq\theta\leq N-1 , which is given by \sum_{m=1}^{N-1}f(m)=\int_{1}^{N-1}f(\theta)\,d\theta+\frac{1}{2}\left[f(N-1)+f(1)\right]+\frac{1}{12}\left[f^{\prime}(N-1)-f^{\prime}(1)\right]+\cdots\,, (173) where from Eq. ( 41 ) we define f(\theta) by f(\theta)=\cos(2ja\theta)\ln\left[\sin(a\theta)\right]\,,\quad a=\frac{\pi}{N}\,. (174) From Eq. ( 41 ) we identify \kappa_{j}=\ln{2}-\sum_{m=1}^{N-1}f(m)\,,\quad j\in\{{1,\ldots,{N/2}\}}. (175) We first estimate the integral in Eq. ( 173 ), labeled by I=\int_{1}^{N-1}f(\theta)\,d\theta . Upon substituting x=a\theta , we get I=\frac{N}{\pi}\int_{0}^{\pi}\cos(2jx)\ln(\sin{x})\,dx-\frac{2N}{\pi}\int_{0}^{\pi/N}\cos(2jx)\ln(\sin{x})\,dx\,. (176) The first integral on the right-side of Eq. ( 176 ) can be evaluated explicitly as {-\pi/(2j)} , whereas in the second integral we use \sin(x)\approx x on the range 00 [ 3 , Chapter V.1] . Moreover, we observed numerically the following property: there exists \hat{\mu}<0 such that, for any \hat{\mu}<\mu<0 , the restriction of g_{\mu}(\bm{y}) onto the interval (-1,1) is negative: g_{\mu}(y_{1},0)<0\quad\textrm{for any}~-1\leq y_{1}\leq 1\,. (194) We obtained numerically that \hat{\mu}\approx-2.006 , which is very close to and possibly identical with -\mu_{1} . Qualitatively, when \mu is negative but small, the first term of the sum, \pi/(2\mu) , provides the dominant (negative) contribution to g_{\mu}(y_{1},0) , as compared to the remaining terms whose sum is expected to be bounded by a constant. However, we are not aware of the proof of this statement. According to the spectral expansion ( 193 ), the constant term {\mathcal{C}}(\mu) of the Robin Green’s function g_{\mu}(\bm{y}) at infinity, as defined in Eq. ( 47 ), is {\mathcal{C}}(\mu)=\ln(2)+\frac{\pi}{2\mu}+\pi\sum\limits_{k=1}^{\infty}\frac{[\Psi_{2k}(\infty)]^{2}}{\mu_{2k}+\mu}\,, (195) where we used Eq. ( 4 ) with d=1/2 and wrote explicitly the term with k=0 , for which \mu_{0}=0 and \Psi_{0}=1/\sqrt{2} that yielded \pi/(2\mu) . The numerical eigenvalues \mu_{2k} and the coefficients [\Psi_{2k}(\infty)]^{2} for the first ten terms are reported in Table 2 . The asymptotic behavior of the eigenvalues is well known (see [ 37 , 66 ] and references therein): \mu_{k}\sim\frac{\pi}{2}k\qquad(k\gg 1)\,. (196) In turn, the oscillating eigenfunction \Psi_{2k}(y_{1}) can be roughly approximated as \cos(\pi ky_{1}) at large k (see Appendix D ). As a consequence, we get \Psi_{2k}(\infty)=\frac{1}{\pi}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}\frac{\Psi_{2k}(y_{1})}{\sqrt{1-y_{1}^{2}}}\,dy_{1}\approx\frac{1}{\pi}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}\frac{\cos(k\pi y_{1})}{\sqrt{1-y_{1}^{2}}}\,dy_{1}=J_{0}(\pi k)\simeq\frac{(-1)^{k}}{\pi\sqrt{k}}\,,\qquad(k\gg 1)\,. (197) The decay of [\Psi_{2k}(\infty)]^{2}/\mu_{2k}\propto 1/k^{2} is rapid enough to ensure that the reported ten coefficients are sufficient for an accurate approximation of {\mathcal{C}}(\mu) , at least for small \mu . To get the small- \mu approximation, we expand the last term of Eq. ( 195 ) into a Taylor series in powers of \mu as {\mathcal{C}}(\mu)=\frac{\pi}{2\mu}+\sum\limits_{n=0}^{\infty}(-\mu)^{n}C_{n+1}\,, (198) with C_{n}=\delta_{n,1}\ln 2+\pi\sum\limits_{k=1}^{\infty}\frac{[\Psi_{2k}(\infty)]^{2}}{[\mu_{2k}]^{n}}\,,\qquad(n=1,2,\ldots)\,. (199) Substituting the first ten contributing terms from Table 2 , we get C_{1}\approx 0.7976 and C_{2}\approx 0.0222 . In Appendix E , we provide an exact computation of these coefficients that yields C_{1}=3/2-\ln 2\approx 0.8069\,,\qquad C_{2}=\frac{21-2\pi^{2}}{18\pi}\approx 0.0223\,. (200) One sees that the numerically computed values are very close to the exact ones. Most importantly, the coefficient C_{2} , as well as higher-order coefficients, are small and can thus be neglected when \mu\ll 1 . k 1 2 3 4 5 \mu_{2k-1} 2.0061 5.1253 8.2600 11.3982 14.5378 \mu_{2k} 3.4533 6.6286 9.7839 12.9330 16.0794 \pi k 3.1416 6.2832 9.4248 12.5664 15.7080 [\Psi_{2k}(\infty)]^{2} 0.0664 0.0391 0.0279 0.0218 0.0178 1/(\pi^{2}k) 0.1013 0.0507 0.0338 0.0253 0.0203 k 6 7 8 9 10 \mu_{2k-1} 17.6780 20.8187 23.9596 27.1006 30.2418 \mu_{2k} 19.2242 22.3682 25.5116 28.6547 31.7974 \pi k 18.8496 21.9911 25.1327 28.2743 31.4159 [\Psi_{2k}(\infty)]^{2} 0.0151 0.0131 0.0116 0.0104 0.0094 1/(\pi^{2}k) 0.0169 0.0145 0.0127 0.0113 0.0101 Table 2: List of eigenvalues \mu_{2k} and coefficients [\Psi_{2k}(\infty)]^{2} of the first 10 contributing terms in the spectral expansion ( 195 ) for {\mathcal{C}}(\mu) (in addition, one has \mu_{0}=0 and \Psi_{0}(\infty)=1/\sqrt{2} ). The reported values were obtained numerically by using a matrix representation of the Steklov problem in elliptic coordinates (see Appendix D ). The matrix was truncated to the size 100\times 100 and then diagonalized numerically. The shown values did not change when the truncation order was increased to 500\times 500 . For comparison, the large- k asymptotic approximations of \mu_{2k} and [\Psi_{2k}(\infty)]^{2} from Eqs. ( 196 , 197 ) are also present. For completeness, we also present the first ten eigenvalues \mu_{2k-1} that correspond to antisymmetric eigenfunctions \Psi_{2k-1} that vanish at infinity. Appendix D Steklov eigenmodes In this Appendix, we recall a numerical computation of the Steklov eigenfunctions \Psi_{k} satisfying Eqs. ( 46 ). The details of this computation are provided in Appendix D of Ref. [ 37 ] . Since \Psi_{0}=1/\sqrt{2} is known, we focus on the other eigenfunctions with k=1,2,\ldots . In elliptic coordinates (\alpha,\theta) , one has y_{1}=\cosh\alpha\cos\theta\,,\qquad y_{2}=\sinh\alpha\sin\theta\,, (201) with 0\leq\alpha<+\infty and 0\leq\theta\leq\pi . Note that Eqs. ( 170 , 171 ) with a_{E}=1 allow one to express \alpha and \theta in terms of y_{1} and y_{2} . The Steklov eigenfunctions can be written as \Psi_{k}(\alpha,\theta)=\sum\limits_{n=0}^{\infty}c_{k,n}\cos(n\theta)e^{-n\alpha}\,, (202) with unknown coefficients c_{k,n} . Imposing the Steklov condition yields the infinite system of linear equations: \sum\limits_{n=1}^{\infty}c_{k,n}{\bf M}_{n,m}=\frac{1}{\mu_{k}}c_{k,m}\,\quad\mbox{for}\,\,m=1,2,\ldots\,, (203) where {\bf M}_{n,m}=\frac{1}{m}\biggl[{\bf A}_{n,m}-\frac{{\bf A}_{n,0}{\bf A}_{0,m}}{{\bf A}_{0,0}}\biggr]\,, (204) and {\bf A}_{n,m}=\frac{1+(-1)^{m+n}}{\pi}\biggl(\frac{1}{1-(m-n)^{2}}+\frac{1}{1-(m+n)^{2}}\biggr)\,. This matrix equation determines the coefficients c_{k,n} up to a multiplicative factor that has to be fixed by the normalization ( 187 ) of Steklov eigenfunctions. Using the following relation derived in [ 37 ] for k=1,2,\ldots 1=\int\limits_{-1}^{1}|\Psi_{k}(y_{1},0)|^{2}\,dy_{1}=\frac{\pi}{2\mu_{k}}\sum\limits_{m=1}^{\infty}m|c_{k,m}|^{2}\,, (205) one can ensure the required normalization to the coefficients c_{k,m} . Once the coefficients c_{k,n} with n=1,2,\ldots are found, one also gets c_{k,0}=-\frac{1}{{\bf A}_{0,0}}\sum\limits_{n=1}^{\infty}c_{k,n}{\bf A}_{n,0}\,. (206) Note that c_{k,0} is actually the value of \Psi_{k} at infinity. In practice, one can truncate the infinite-dimensional matrix {\bf M} to a finite size M\times M and then diagonalize it numerically. Its eigenvalues and eigenvectors approximate 1/\mu_{k} and c_{k,n} , respectively. We checked numerically that these approximations converge very rapidly as M increases. We used this technique to obtain the numerical values reported in Table 2 . Figure 14 shows several eigenfunctions \Psi_{2k}(y_{1},0) and their approximations by \cos(\pi ky_{1}) . Figure 14: The Steklov eigenfunctions \Psi_{2k}(y_{1},0) , restricted onto the interval (-1,1) , are shown by thick lines. These eigenfunctions are obtained by truncating the series in Eq. ( 202 ) to n\leq 100 , with the coefficients c_{k,n} found by diagonalizing the truncated matrix {\bf M} from Eq. ( 204 ). For comparison, functions \cos(\pi ky_{1}) are plotted by thin lines. Appendix E Asymptotic behavior of {\mathcal{C}}(\mu) In this Appendix, we derive the exact values of the coefficients C_{1} and C_{2} of the Taylor expansion ( 49 ) of {\mathcal{C}}(\mu)-\pi/(2\mu) as \mu\to 0 . From the divergence theorem, there is no solution to Eq. ( 44 ) for \mu=0 . As such, for \mu\ll 1 , the solution should bifurcate from infinity, so that {\mathcal{C}}(\mu) is expected to be large in this limit. For this reason, we expand the solution for 0<\mu\ll 1 as g_{\mu}(\bm{y})=-\frac{C_{0}}{\mu}+v_{1}(\bm{y})-\mu v_{2}(\bm{y})+\mu^{2}v_{3}(\bm{y})+\ldots (207) Inserting this expansion into Eq. ( 44 ), we obtain three BVPs: \displaystyle\Delta v_{1} \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{in}~{\mathbb{H}}_{2}\,, (208a) \displaystyle\partial_{n}v_{1} \displaystyle=C_{0}\quad\textrm{on}~y_{2}=0\,,~|y_{1}|<1\,;\qquad\partial_{n}v_{1}=0\quad\textrm{on}~y_{2}=0\,,~|y_{1}|\geq 1\,, (208b) \displaystyle v_{1} \displaystyle\sim\ln|\bm{y}|+{\mathcal{O}}(1)\quad\textrm{as}~|\bm{y}|\to\infty\,, (208c) for v_{1}(\bm{y}) , \displaystyle\Delta v_{2} \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{in}~{\mathbb{H}}_{2}\,, (209a) \displaystyle\partial_{n}v_{2} \displaystyle=v_{1}\quad\textrm{on}~y_{2}=0\,,~|y_{1}|<1\,;\qquad\partial_{n}v_{2}=0\quad\textrm{on}~y_{2}=0\,,~|y_{1}|\geq 1\,, (209b) \displaystyle v_{2} \displaystyle\sim{\mathcal{O}}(1)\quad\textrm{as}~|\bm{y}|\to\infty\,, (209c) for v_{2}(\bm{y}) , and \displaystyle\Delta v_{3} \displaystyle=0\quad\textrm{in}~{\mathbb{H}}_{2}\,, (210a) \displaystyle\partial_{n}v_{3} \displaystyle=v_{2}\quad\textrm{on}~y_{2}=0\,,~|y_{1}|<1\,;\qquad\partial_{n}v_{3}=0\quad\textrm{on}~y_{2}=0\,,~|y_{1}|\geq 1\,, (210b) \displaystyle v_{3} \displaystyle\sim{\mathcal{O}}(1)\quad\textrm{as}~|\bm{y}|\to\infty\,, (210c) for v_{3}(\bm{y}) . Note that the solutions v_{1} , v_{2} and v_{3} are known only up to additive constants. These constants are needed for ensuring that Eqs. ( 208 , 209 , 210 ) have solutions. In particular, by the divergence theorem, there exists a solution to ( 208 ) provided that 0=\int\limits_{-1}^{1}\partial_{n}v_{1}|_{y_{2}=0}\,dy_{1}+\lim\limits_{R\to\infty}\int\limits_{B_{R}\cap{\mathbb{H}}_{2}}\partial_{n}v_{1}\,ds=2C_{0}+\pi, (211) where B_{R} is a large disk of radius R . This yields C_{0}=-\frac{\pi}{2}\,. (212) To get the next-order terms, we will use the following lemma, which follows by using the method of images. Lemma : For a given function f(\xi) such that \left|\int\limits_{-\infty}^{\infty}f(\xi)d\xi\right|<\infty , the solution w(\bm{y}) to the boundary value problem \Delta w=0\quad\textrm{in}~{\mathbb{H}}_{2}\,,\qquad\partial_{n}w=f(y_{1})\quad\textrm{on}~y_{2}=0\,, (213) is w(\bm{y})=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\int\limits_{-\infty}^{\infty}\ln[(\xi-y_{1})^{2}+y_{2}^{2}]f(\xi)\,d\xi\,. (214) In particular, one has w(\bm{y})\sim\left(-\frac{1}{\pi}\int\limits_{-\infty}^{\infty}f(\xi)\,d\xi\right)\ln|\bm{y}|+o(1)\qquad\mbox{as}\,\,\,|\bm{y}|\to\infty\,. (215) To apply this lemma, we decompose the solution v_{1} as v_{1}(\bm{y})=u_{1}(\bm{y})+C_{1} , where u_{1}(\bm{y}) is a solution for which u_{1}(\bm{y})\sim\ln|\bm{y}|+o(1) as |\bm{y}|\to\infty . In this way, using Eq. ( 212 ) and setting f(\xi)=-(\pi/2)\Theta(1-|\xi|)\,, (216) where \Theta(z) is the Heaviside step function ( \Theta(z)=1 for z>0 and 0 otherwise), we get u_{1}(\bm{y})=\frac{1}{4}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}\ln[(\xi-y_{1})^{2}+y_{2}^{2}]\,d\xi\,, (217) which satisfies the required condition u_{1}(\bm{y})\sim\ln|\bm{y}|+o(1) as |\bm{y}|\to\infty . Now we turn to the next-order term v_{2} satisfying Eq. ( 209 ), in which v_{1}|_{y_{2}=0}=C_{1}+u_{1}|_{y_{2}=0} . The divergence theorem yields that the necessary and sufficient condition for v_{2} to be bounded (i.e., v_{2}\sim{\mathcal{O}}(1) as |\bm{y}|\to\infty )is \int\limits_{-1}^{1}v_{1}(y_{1},0)\,dy_{1}=0\,, (218) from which C_{1}=-\frac{1}{2}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}u_{1}(y_{1},0)\,dy_{1}\,, (219) where from an integration of Eq. ( 217 ) with y_{2}=0 we get u_{1}(y_{1},0)=\frac{1}{2}\biggl[-2+y_{1}\ln\biggl(\frac{1+y_{1}}{1-y_{1}}\biggr)+\ln(1-y_{1}^{2})\biggr]\,. (220) Substituting this expression into Eq. ( 219 ), we get C_{1}=\frac{3}{2}-\ln 2\,. (221) Similarly, we write v_{2}=u_{2}+C_{2} such that u_{2}(\bm{y})\sim o(1) as |\bm{y}|\to\infty . Using again the above lemma with f(\xi)=u_{1}(\xi,0)+C_{1} , we conclude that u_{2}(\bm{y})=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}\ln[(\xi-y_{1})^{2}+y_{2}^{2}](u_{1}(\xi,0)+C_{1})\,d\xi\,. (222) In particular, we find u_{2}(y_{1},0)=-\frac{1}{\pi}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}\ln|\xi-y_{1}|\left(u_{1}(\xi,0)+C_{1}\right)\,d\xi=-\frac{2C_{1}}{\pi}u_{1}(y_{1},0)-\frac{1}{\pi}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}\ln|\xi-y_{1}|u_{1}(\xi,0)\,d\xi\,, where we used Eq. ( 217 ) with y_{2}=0 for the first term. Rewriting Eq. ( 220 ) as u_{1}(y_{1},0)=-1+\frac{1}{2}w(y_{1}) (223) with w(y_{1})=y_{1}\ln\biggl(\frac{1+y_{1}}{1-y_{1}}\biggr)+\ln(1-y_{1}^{2}), (224) we get \displaystyle u_{2}(y_{1},0) \displaystyle=\frac{2(1-C_{1})}{\pi}u_{1}(y_{1},0)-\frac{1}{2\pi}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}\ln|\xi-y_{1}|w(\xi)\,d\xi\,. (225) The divergence theorem applied to Eq. ( 210 ) yields \int\limits_{-1}^{1}v_{2}(y_{1},0)\,dy_{1}=0, (226) from which C_{2}=-\frac{1}{2}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}u_{2}(y_{1},0)\,dy_{1}=\frac{-(1-C_{1})}{\pi}\underbrace{\int\limits_{-1}^{1}u_{1}(y_{1},0)\,dy_{1}}_{=-2C_{1}}+\frac{1}{4\pi}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}\biggl\{\int\limits_{-1}^{1}\ln|\xi-y_{1}|w(\xi)\,d\xi\biggr\}\,dy_{1}\,. Exchanging the order of integrals in the second term and using ( 217 ) with y_{2}=0 , we get \displaystyle C_{2} \displaystyle=\frac{2(1-C_{1})C_{1}}{\pi}+\frac{1}{2\pi}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}w(\xi)u_{1}(\xi,0)\,d\xi=\frac{2(1-C_{1})C_{1}}{\pi}+\frac{1}{2\pi}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}w(\xi)\biggl[-1+\frac{1}{2}w(\xi)\biggr]\,d\xi \displaystyle=\frac{2(1-C_{1})C_{1}}{\pi}-\frac{2(1-C_{1})}{\pi}+\frac{1}{4\pi}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}\left[w(\xi)\right]^{2}\,d\xi=-\frac{2(1-C_{1})^{2}}{\pi}+\frac{1}{4\pi}\int\limits_{-1}^{1}\left[w(\xi)\right]^{2}\,d\xi. Substituting w(\xi) from Eq. ( 224 ) and C_{1} from Eq. ( 221 ), we get after some simplifications that C_{2}=\frac{21-2\pi^{2}}{18\pi}\,. (227) Appendix F Neumann Green’s functions In this Appendix, we summarize the available results on various Neumann Green’s for both interior and exterior settings when the singularity is either on the boundary and in the bulk. Table 3 collects their definitions and formulas for three shapes: the unit disk, ellipses, and rectangles (some derivations are provided below). Even though the exterior (bulk) Neumann Green’s function G_{\rm eb}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) is not discussed in the main text, we provide its definition for completeness. For a fixed point {\bm{\xi}}\in\Omega_{0}={\mathbb{R}}^{2}\backslash C in the exterior of a compact set C , G_{\rm eb}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) satisfies \displaystyle\Delta_{\bm{x}}G_{\rm eb} \displaystyle=-\delta(\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}})\quad\textrm{in}~\Omega_{0}\,,\qquad\qquad\partial_{n}G_{\rm eb}=0\quad\textrm{on}~\partial\Omega_{0}\,, (228a) \displaystyle G_{\rm eb}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) \displaystyle\sim-\frac{1}{2\pi}\ln|\bm{x}|+o(1)\quad\textrm{as}~|\bm{x}|\to\infty\,, (228b) whereas the regular part R_{\rm eb}({\bm{\xi}}) characterizes its singular behavior near {\bm{\xi}} : R_{\rm eb}({\bm{\xi}})=\lim\limits_{\bm{x}\to{\bm{\xi}}}\bigl(G_{\rm eb}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})+\frac{1}{2\pi}\ln|\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}|\bigr)\,. (229) Note that the o(1) condition in the asymptotic behavior ( 228b ) determines this function uniquely. For instance, for the exterior of the unit disk, we can readily derive by summing an eigenfunction expansion that G_{\rm eb}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\biggl(\ln|\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}|+\ln\bigl|\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}/|{\bm{\xi}}|^{2}\bigr|-\ln|\bm{x}|\biggr)\,, (230) from which R_{\rm eb}({\bm{\xi}})=-\ln(1-1/|{\bm{\xi}}|^{2})/(2\pi) . Interior problem Exterior problem surface bulk surface bulk Definition ( 9 ) ( 150 ) ( 160 ) ( 228 ) Disk ( 28 ) ( 151 ) ( 161 ), see Sec. F.1 ( 230 ) Ellipse ( 238 , 240 ) ( 236 ) ( 250 , 251 ) ( 248 , 249 ) Rectangle accessible Eq. (4.13) from [ 52 ] , and [ 61 ] unavailable unavailable Table 3: Summary of available formulas for various Neumann Green’s functions. Note that the surface Neumann Green’s function for rectangles can be derived from the results in [ 52 , 61 ] . In turn, its extension to the exterior problem is not available. F.1 Surface Neumann Green’s function for the exterior of the unit disk In this Appendix, we provide a rigorous derivation of Eq. ( 161 ) for the surface Neumann Green’s function G_{\rm e}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) for the exterior of the unit disk. To establish the result in Eq. ( 161 ), we let r=|\bm{x}| and we decompose G_{\rm e} as G_{\rm e}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})=-(2\pi)^{-1}\ln|\bm{x}|+H_{\rm e}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) , to obtain that H_{\rm e}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) satisfies \displaystyle\Delta_{\bm{x}}H_{\rm e}=0\quad\mbox{in}\quad|\bm{x}|>1\,;\qquad\partial_{r}H_{\rm e}=\frac{1}{2\pi}\quad\mbox{on}\,\,\,|\bm{x}|=1\,,\,\,\bm{x}\neq{\bm{\xi}}\,, (231a) \displaystyle H_{\rm e}\sim-\frac{1}{\pi}\ln|\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}|\quad\mbox{as}\quad\bm{x}\to{\bm{\xi}}\,;\qquad H_{\rm e}\to 0\quad\mbox{as}\quad|\bm{x}|\to\infty\,, (231b) where \Delta_{\bm{x}} is the Laplacian in the \bm{x} -variable. Consider now the interior surface Neumann Green’s function inside the disk |\bm{y}|\leq 1 satisfying Eq. ( 9 ), which we decompose as G(\bm{y};{\bm{\xi}})={|\bm{y}|^{2}/(4\pi)}+H_{\rm i}(\bm{y},{\bm{\xi}}) , where H_{\rm i}(\bm{y},{\bm{\xi}}) satisfies \displaystyle\Delta_{\bm{y}}H_{\rm i}=0\quad\mbox{in}\quad|\bm{y}|<1\,;\qquad\partial_{\rho}H_{\rm i}=\frac{-1}{2\pi}\quad\mbox{on}\quad|\bm{y}|=1\,,\,\,\,\bm{y}\neq{\bm{\xi}}\,, (232a) \displaystyle H_{\rm i}\sim-\frac{1}{\pi}\ln|\bm{y}-{\bm{\xi}}|\quad\mbox{as}\quad\bm{y}\to{\bm{\xi}}\,;\qquad H_{\rm i}\quad\mbox{bounded as}\quad\bm{y}\to{\bm{0}}\,. (232b) Here \rho=|\bm{y}| and \Delta_{\bm{y}} denotes the Laplacian in the \bm{y} variable. From Eq. ( 28 ) it follows that H_{\rm i}(\bm{y},{\bm{\xi}})=-\frac{1}{\pi}\ln|\bm{y}-{\bm{\xi}}|+C\,, (233) where C is a constant. By using conformal invariance under Kelvin’s transformation \bm{y}={\bm{x}/|\bm{x}|^{2}} in the unit disk, and noting that \partial_{r}=-\partial_{\rho} on r=\rho=1 , it follows that H_{\rm e} is given by H_{\rm e}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})=H_{\rm i}\left(\frac{\bm{x}}{|\bm{x}|^{2}},{\bm{\xi}}\right)=-\frac{1}{\pi}\ln{\biggl|}\frac{\bm{x}}{|\bm{x}|^{2}}-{\bm{\xi}}{\biggr|}\,, (234) where we observe that H_{\rm e}\to 0 as |\bm{x}|\to\infty . Finally, if |{\bm{\xi}}|=1 , we can readily calculate that {\biggl|}\frac{\bm{x}}{|\bm{x}|^{2}}-{\bm{\xi}}{\biggr|}=\frac{|\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}|}{|\bm{x}|}\,. (235) Upon subsituting Eq. ( 235 ) into Eq. ( 234 ) and using G_{\rm e}=-(2\pi)^{-1}\ln|\bm{x}|+H_{\rm e} , we obtain the result in Eq. ( 161 ). F.2 Neumann Green’s functions for an ellipse For an ellipse with semiaxes a and b ( a>b ), \Omega_{0}=\{\bm{x}=(x_{1},x_{2})\in{\mathbb{R}}^{2}~:~(x_{1}/a)^{2}+(x_{2}/b)^{2}<1\} , a rapidly converging representation for the “bulk” Neumann Green’s function was derived in [ 49 ] . In the elliptic coordinates introduced in Eq. ( 163 ), Eq. (5.21a) from [ 49 ] reads G_{b}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})=\frac{|\bm{x}|^{2}+|{\bm{\xi}}|^{2}}{4\pi ab}-\frac{3(a^{2}+b^{2})}{16\pi ab}+\frac{\alpha_{b}-\alpha_{>}}{2\pi}+S(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})\,, (236) where \bm{x}=(\alpha,\theta) , {\bm{\xi}}=(\alpha_{0},\theta_{0}) , \alpha_{>}=\max\{\alpha,\alpha_{0}\} , \beta=(a-b)/(a+b) , \alpha_{b}=\mathrm{atanh}(b/a)=\tfrac{1}{2}\ln(1/\beta) describes the boundary \partial\Omega_{0} , S(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\sum\limits_{n=0}^{\infty}\sum\limits_{j=1}^{8}\ln|1-\beta^{2n}z_{j}|\,, (237) and \displaystyle z_{1} \displaystyle=e^{-|\alpha-\alpha_{0}|+i(\theta-\theta_{0})},\qquad z_{2}=e^{-4\alpha_{b}+|\alpha-\alpha_{0}|+i(\theta-\theta_{0})},\qquad z_{3}=e^{-2\alpha_{b}-\alpha-\alpha_{0}+i(\theta-\theta_{0})},\qquad z_{4}=e^{-2\alpha_{b}+\alpha+\alpha_{0}+i(\theta-\theta_{0})}, \displaystyle z_{5} \displaystyle=e^{-4\alpha_{b}+\alpha+\alpha_{0}+i(\theta+\theta_{0})},\qquad z_{6}=e^{-\alpha-\alpha_{0}+i(\theta+\theta_{0})},\qquad z_{7}=e^{-2\alpha_{b}+|\alpha-\alpha_{0}|+i(\theta+\theta_{0})},\qquad z_{8}=e^{-2\alpha_{b}-|\alpha-\alpha_{0}|+i(\theta+\theta_{0})}\,. Setting {\bm{\xi}} to the boundary \partial\Omega_{0} , we get some simplifications. In particular, we have \alpha\leq\alpha_{0}=\alpha_{b} that implies \displaystyle z_{1} \displaystyle=z_{4}=e^{-\alpha_{b}+\alpha+i(\theta-\theta_{0})}\,,\qquad z_{3}=z_{2}=e^{-3\alpha_{b}-\alpha+i(\theta-\theta_{0})}\,, \displaystyle z_{5} \displaystyle=z_{8}=e^{-3\alpha_{b}+\alpha+i(\theta+\theta_{0})}\,,\qquad z_{7}=z_{6}=e^{-\alpha_{b}-\alpha+i(\theta+\theta_{0})}\,. As a consequence, we obtain a rapidly converging representation for the surface Neumann Green’s function: \displaystyle G(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) \displaystyle=\frac{|\bm{x}|^{2}+|{\bm{\xi}}|^{2}}{4\pi ab}-\frac{3(a^{2}+b^{2})}{16\pi ab}-\frac{1}{\pi}\sum\limits_{n=0}^{\infty}\sum\limits_{j=1}^{4}\ln|1-\beta^{2n}z_{2j-1}|\,. (238) The regular part of this function can be deduced as \bm{x}\to{\bm{\xi}} . Setting \theta=\theta_{0} and \alpha=\alpha_{0}-\epsilon , we find as \epsilon\to 0 : \displaystyle G(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})\approx\frac{|\bm{x}|^{2}+|{\bm{\xi}}|^{2}}{4\pi ab}-\frac{3(a^{2}+b^{2})}{16\pi ab}-\frac{1}{\pi}\ln(1-e^{-\epsilon})-\frac{1}{\pi}\sum\limits_{n=1}^{\infty}\ln(1-\beta^{2n})-\frac{1}{\pi}\sum\limits_{n=0}^{\infty}\sum\limits_{j=2}^{4}\ln|1-\beta^{2n}z_{2j-1}|\,, where \displaystyle z_{3} \displaystyle=e^{-4\alpha_{b}}=\beta^{2}\,,\qquad z_{5}=z_{7}=e^{-2\alpha_{b}+2i\theta_{0}}=\beta e^{2i\theta_{0}}\,. On the other hand, we have for \theta=\theta_{0} that \displaystyle|\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}|^{2} \displaystyle=a_{E}^{2}\bigl[(\cosh\alpha\cos\theta-\cosh\alpha_{0}\cos\theta_{0})^{2}+(\sinh\alpha\sin\theta-\sinh\alpha_{0}\sin\theta_{0})^{2}\bigr] \displaystyle\approx a_{E}^{2}\epsilon^{2}(\sinh^{2}\alpha_{0}+\sin^{2}\theta_{0})\qquad\mbox{as}\quad\epsilon\to 0\,, so that |\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}|\approx\epsilon a_{E}\sqrt{\sinh^{2}\alpha_{0}+\sin^{2}\theta_{0}}\qquad\mbox{as}\quad\epsilon\to 0\,. (239) We can thus express \epsilon in terms of |\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}| to obtain the following infinite series representation for the regular part in terms of the aspect ratio \beta={(a-b)/(a+b)} : \displaystyle R({\bm{\xi}}) \displaystyle=\frac{|{\bm{\xi}}|^{2}}{2\pi ab}-\frac{3(a^{2}+b^{2})}{16\pi ab}+\frac{1}{\pi}\ln\biggl(a_{E}\sqrt{\sinh^{2}\alpha_{0}+\sin^{2}\theta_{0}}\biggr)-\frac{2}{\pi}\sum\limits_{n=1}^{\infty}\biggl(\ln(1-\beta^{2n})+\ln\bigl|1-\beta^{2n-1}e^{2i\theta_{0}}\bigr|\biggr)\,. (240) F.3 Neumann Green’s functions for the exterior of an ellipse Finally, we consider the exterior of an ellipse with semiaxes a>b : \Omega_{0}=\{(x_{1},x_{2})\in{\mathbb{R}}^{2}~:~(x_{1}/a)^{2}+(x_{2}/b)^{2}>1\} . We first derive the “bulk” Neumann Green’s function G_{\rm eb}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) for this domain and then let the singularity point {\bm{\xi}} tend to the boundary to get G_{\rm e}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) and its regular part R_{\rm e}({\bm{\xi}}) . Bulk Neumann Green’s function In elliptic coordinates introduced in Eq. ( 163 ), we search the bulk Neumann Green’s function as the unique solution of Eqs. ( 228 ) in the form G_{\rm eb}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})=\sum\limits_{k=-\infty}^{\infty}A_{k}(\alpha)e^{ik(\theta-\theta_{0})}\,, (241) with unknown functions A_{k}(\alpha) . Substitution of this form into the equation for the Green’s function yields \displaystyle-\Delta_{\bm{x}}G(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) \displaystyle=-\frac{1}{h_{\alpha}^{2}}(\partial_{\alpha}^{2}+\partial_{\theta}^{2})\sum\limits_{k=-\infty}^{\infty}A_{k}(\alpha)e^{ik(\theta-\theta_{0})}=\frac{1}{h_{\alpha}^{2}}\delta(\alpha-\alpha_{0})\delta(\theta-\theta_{0})\,, where h_{\alpha}=a_{E}\sqrt{\cosh^{2}\alpha-\cos^{2}\theta} is the scale factor, and a_{E}=\sqrt{a^{2}-b^{2}} . Multiplying by e^{ik^{\prime}\theta} and integrating over \theta from -\pi to \pi , we obtain a set of equations for A_{k}(\alpha) : (-\partial_{\alpha}^{2}+k^{2})A_{k}(\alpha)=\frac{1}{2\pi}\delta(\alpha-\alpha_{0}). (242) Note that A_{k}(\alpha) should satisfy A^{\prime}_{k}(\alpha_{b})=0 , where \alpha_{b} is the location of the elliptic boundary (i.e., \tanh\alpha_{b}=b/a ). As a consequence, we can search for solutions separately on \alpha_{b}<\alpha<\alpha_{0} and \alpha>\alpha_{0} : A_{k}(\alpha)=\begin{cases}a_{k}\cosh(k(\alpha-\alpha_{b}))\,,\quad\alpha_{b}<\alpha<\alpha_{0}\,,\cr b_{k}e^{-k\alpha}\,,\hskip 85.35826pt\alpha>\alpha_{0}\,,\end{cases} (243) where we assumed that k>0 . The unknown coefficients a_{k} and b_{k} are obtained by requiring the continuity of A_{k}(\alpha) together with the jump condition for the derivative at \alpha=\alpha_{0} . This yields that \displaystyle b_{k}e^{-k\alpha_{0}} \displaystyle=a_{k}\cosh(k(\alpha_{0}-\alpha_{b})),\qquad-kb_{k}e^{-k\alpha_{0}}-ka_{k}\sinh(k(\alpha_{0}-\alpha_{b}))=-1/(2\pi)\,, (244) from which we determine \displaystyle a_{k} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2\pi k}e^{-k(\alpha_{0}-\alpha_{b})}\,,\qquad b_{k}=\frac{1}{2\pi k}e^{k\alpha_{b}}\cosh(k(\alpha_{0}-\alpha_{b}))\,. (245) We conclude that A_{k}=\frac{1}{2\pi k}e^{-k(\alpha_{>}-\alpha_{b})}\cosh(k(\alpha_{<}-\alpha_{b}))\,, (246) where \alpha_{<}=\min\{\alpha,\alpha_{0}\} and \alpha_{>}=\max\{\alpha,\alpha_{0}\} . We can further simplify this expression to A_{k}=\frac{1}{4\pi k}\left[e^{-k|\alpha-\alpha_{0}|}+e^{-k(\alpha+\alpha_{0}-2\alpha_{b})}\right]\,. (247) We recall that this solution holds for k>0 . By symmetry, it also holds for k<0 , if k is replaced by |k| . For k=0 , a general solution of the Laplace equation on the interval \alpha_{b}<\alpha<\alpha_{0} is A_{0}=a_{0}+c_{0}\alpha , where we must set c_{0}=0 to ensure that the Neumann condition at \alpha_{b} is satisfied. In turn, we have A_{0}=d_{0}+b_{0}\alpha for \alpha>\alpha_{0} . We set a_{0}=d_{0}+b_{0}\alpha_{0} to ensure the continuity of A_{0} at \alpha_{0} . The coefficient b_{0} is determined by the jump of the derivative, which yields b_{0}=-1/(2\pi) . We conclude that, in terms of a constant d_{0} to be fixed, A_{0} has the form A_{0}=d_{0}-\frac{1}{2\pi}\alpha_{>}\,. Combining these results, we get \displaystyle G(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) \displaystyle=d_{0}-\frac{\alpha_{>}}{2\pi}+\frac{1}{4\pi}\sum\limits_{k\neq 0}\frac{e^{ik(\theta-\theta_{0})}}{|k|}\bigl(e^{-|k||\alpha-\alpha_{0}|}+e^{-|k|(\alpha+\alpha_{0}-2\alpha_{b})}\bigr)\,, \displaystyle=d_{0}-\frac{\alpha_{>}}{2\pi}-\frac{1}{4\pi}\biggl[\ln(1-e^{-|\alpha-\alpha_{0}|+i(\theta-\theta_{0})})+\ln(1-e^{-|\alpha-\alpha_{0}|-i(\theta-\theta_{0})}) \displaystyle\qquad+\ln(1-e^{-(\alpha+\alpha_{0}-2\alpha_{b})+i(\theta-\theta_{0})})+\ln(1-e^{-(\alpha+\alpha_{0}-2\alpha_{b})-i(\theta-\theta_{0})})\biggr]. Since |\bm{x}|^{2}=a_{E}^{2}(\cosh^{2}\alpha-\sin^{2}\theta)\approx a_{E}^{2}\cosh^{2}\alpha when |\bm{x}|\gg a_{E} , we have \alpha_{>}=\alpha\approx\ln(2|\bm{x}|/a_{E}) as |\bm{x}|\to\infty , where we used that \cosh^{-1}(z)=\ln(z+\sqrt{z^{2}-1}) . Since the Neumann Green’s function behaves at infinity according to Eq. ( 228b ), the constant term d_{0} must compensate the constant contribution from \alpha_{>} . This condition yields d_{0}=\ln\left({2/a_{E}}\right)/(2\pi) , and so we conclude that that \displaystyle G_{\rm eb}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) \displaystyle=\frac{\ln(2/a_{E})-\alpha_{>}}{2\pi}-\frac{1}{4\pi}\biggl[\ln\bigl(1-2\cos(\theta-\theta_{0})e^{-|\alpha-\alpha_{0}|}+e^{-2|\alpha-\alpha_{0}|}\bigr) (248) \displaystyle\qquad+\ln\bigl(1-2\cos(\theta-\theta_{0})e^{-(\alpha+\alpha_{0}-2\alpha_{b})}+e^{-2(\alpha+\alpha_{0}-2\alpha_{b})}\bigr)\biggr]\,. To evaluate the regular part, we set \theta=\theta_{0} and \alpha=\alpha_{0}+\epsilon , so that \displaystyle G_{\rm eb}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}}) \displaystyle\approx\frac{1}{2\pi}\left[\ln(2/a_{E})-\alpha_{0}-\ln(1-e^{-\epsilon})-\ln\bigl(1-e^{-2(\alpha_{0}-\alpha_{b})}\bigr)\right]\,. Using again Eq. ( 239 ) to express \epsilon in terms of |\bm{x}-{\bm{\xi}}| , we conclude that R_{\rm eb}({\bm{\xi}})=\frac{1}{2\pi}\left[\frac{1}{2}\ln(\sinh^{2}\alpha_{0}+\sin^{2}\theta_{0})+\ln(2)-\alpha_{0}-\ln\bigl(1-e^{-2(\alpha_{0}-\alpha_{b})}\bigr)\right]\,. (249) Surface Neumann Green’s function Setting {\bm{\xi}}\in\partial\Omega in Eq. ( 248 ), we get a simplification for the surface Neumann Green’s function: G_{\rm e}(\bm{x},{\bm{\xi}})=\frac{\ln(2/a_{E})-\alpha}{2\pi}-\frac{1}{2\pi}\ln\bigl(1-2\cos(\theta-\theta_{0})e^{-(\alpha-\alpha_{b})}+e^{-2(\alpha-\alpha_{b})}\bigr)\,. (250) In turn, setting \theta=\theta_{0} and \alpha=\alpha_{b}+\epsilon , and using Eq. ( 239 ), we find that R_{\rm e}({\bm{\xi}})=\frac{1}{2\pi}\left[\ln(2a_{E})-\alpha_{0}+\ln(\sinh^{2}\alpha_{0}+\sin^{2}\theta_{0})\right]\,. (251)