Joint calibration of the volatility surface and variance term structure Jiwook Yoo Abstract This article proposes a calibration framework for complex option pricing models that jointly fits market option prices and the term structure of variance. Calibrated models under the conventional objective function, the sum of squared errors in Black–Scholes implied volatilities, can produce model-implied variance term structures with large errors relative to those observed in the market and implied by option prices. I show that this can occur even when the model-implied volatility surface closely matches the volatility surface observed in the market. The proposed joint calibration addresses this issue by augmenting the conventional objective function with a penalty term for large deviations from the observed variance term structure. This augmented objective function features a hyperparameter that governs the relative weight placed on the volatility surface and the variance term structure. I test this framework on a jump-diffusion model with stochastic volatility in two calibration exercises: the first using volatility surfaces generated under a Bates model, and the second using a panel of S&P 500 equity index options covering the 1996–2023 period. I demonstrate that the proposed method is able to fit observed option prices well while delivering realistic term structures of variance. Finally, I provide guidance on the choice of hyperparameters based on the results of these numerical exercises. Keywords: Model calibration, volatility surface, variance term structure JEL Codes: C52, G13, G17 1 Introduction Parametric option pricing models are workhorses of contemporary academic research and industry practice. At a high level, the selection of a particular model is to specify the stochastic process for the underlying asset’s price as well as for any other relevant state variables, with the parameters of these processes often calibrated to closely match observed market prices. The distribution implied by these processes in turn informs a risk-neutral measure from which derivative prices and hedge ratios are derived. This workflow has its roots in the classic works of Black & Scholes (1973) and Black (1976) who model an underlying asset as a geometric Brownian motion (GBM) and calibrate the GBM diffusive variance to fit option prices. However, a large body of evidence suggests that asset prices exhibit time series properties that differ from a simple GBM. Asset prices can jump ( Carr et al. (2002) ; Bollerslev & Todorov (2011) ) , possess time-varying volatility ( Shephard (2005) ) , exhibit a leverage effect ( Carr & Wu (2017) ) , and deviate in a myriad of other ways not captured by a simple drift-diffusion process. In response, researchers and industry practitioners alike have considered more complex models that aim to shore up deficiencies by more faithfully modeling these underlying processes (e.g. adding jumps, stochastic volatility, etc). However, these more sophisticated models are more difficult to calibrate and can produce models with unrealistic implications ( Cont & Tankov (2004) ) . One of these implications which are at odds with the data is the economically unrealistic term structure of variance these models imply. The purpose of this article is to propose a general model calibration framework which can calibrate complex models that produce realistic term structures of variance while still closely matching observed option prices. Broadly speaking, the calibration of an option pricing model involves minimizing some function of the model fitting error to search for the a set of parameters which minimizes this error, thereby producing the best fit. Generally, the function being minimized is a weighted sum of squared errors, either in terms of prices or implied volatilities. Particularly for complex models, it is well-known that the problem of minimizing such an objective function can be ill-posed, resulting in a range of issues related to numerical implementation ( Cont & Tankov (2003) ) . For instance, the objective function may not be globally convex or might possess very flat regions. In such cases, the numerical optimization procedure used to minimize the objective function may fail to converge to a minimum. Even when this procedure does converge, the resulting set of parameters can imply economically unreasonable implications such as large derivations from the variance term structure observed in the market. This can pose a significant problem for academic work that relies on the calibration of such models to study the pricing of variance and its associated risk premia. At the core of my framework is the variance term structure implied by option prices. It is well-known that the term structure of variance is pinned down by option prices although this identification is complicated in the case that the underlying can jump. If the underlying price process is continuous, Neuberger (1994) and Dupire et al. (1994) provide a model-free construction of the risk-neutral expected variance of the underlying asset S_{t} over any time horizon [t,t+\tau] . This expected variance can be identified provided there are European-style options on the underlying expiring at time t+\tau . If the underlying can jump, the pricing of variance is more subtle. Recent work by Carr et al. (2021) and Carr et al. (2021) shows how to precisely recover the risk-neutral expected variance under very general settings. However, unlike in the continuous case, this replication is no longer model-independent; rather, it depends on the higher-order moments of the jump distribution. My proposed calibration procedure uses the information in the variance term structure to directly augment a standard objective function used for calibrating option pricing models, the sum of squared errors in option implied volatilities. To fix ideas, let \sigma^{mkt}(K_{i,j},\tau_{j}) be the Black-Scholes implied volatility (BSIV) of an out-of-the-money (OTM) European-style option with strike price K_{i,j} and maturity \tau_{j} obtained by inverting the option’s observed price. 1 1 1 For this article, I consider a strike price K and to be out-of-the-money if K\geq S for call options and K2 . The "correct" multiplier Q on the log contract is the one which recovers the expected quadratic variation and thus must satisfy: QE_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left(-\log\dfrac{S_{\tau}}{S_{0}}\right)=E_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left(\int_{0}^{\tau}V_{t}dt\right)+\lambda E_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left(\int_{0}^{\tau}\int_{\mathbb{R}}J^{2}\,v(dt,dx)\right) (18) Carr et al. (2012) derive an expression for the correct multiplier in equation ( 18 ): Q=\dfrac{E_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left(\int_{0}^{\tau}V_{t}dt\right)+\lambda E_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left(\int_{0}^{\tau}\int_{\mathbb{R}}J^{2}\,v(dt,dx)\right)}{\frac{1}{2}E_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left(\int_{0}^{\tau}V_{t}dt\right)-\lambda E_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left(\int_{0}^{\tau}\int_{\mathbb{R}}[1+J-e^{J}]\,v(dt,dx)\right)} (19) To gain intuition on the relation between the higher-order moments of the jump distribution and the value of the multiplier, one can substitute e^{J} by its third-order Taylor polynomial 1+J+J^{2}/2+J^{3}/6 in ( 18 ). Doing so and simplifying delivers an approximation of the multiplier: Q\approx\dfrac{E_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left(\int_{0}^{\tau}V_{t}dt\right)+\lambda E_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left(\int_{0}^{\tau}\int_{\mathbb{R}}J^{2}\,v(dt,dx)\right)}{\frac{1}{2}\left[E_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left(\int_{0}^{\tau}V_{t}dt\right)+\lambda E_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left(\int_{0}^{\tau}\int_{\mathbb{R}}J^{2}\,v(dt,dx)+\frac{1}{3}\int_{0}^{\tau}\int_{\mathbb{R}}J^{3}\,v(dt,dx)\right)\right]} (20) It is clear from the above approximation that whether or not Q is greater than or less than 2 depends on the third moment of the jump distribution. If the jump distribution is negatively skewed, the double integral over J^{3} in the denominator of ( 20 ) will be made smaller, raising the value of the multiplier above 2. If the jump distribution has positive skewness, the multiplier will be smaller than 2. Carr et al. (2012) examine the multiplier empirically, computing the ratio between market rates on variance swaps written on the S&P 500 and the price of the log contract. The authors find find that a multiplier greater than 2 is required to match variance swap rates observed in the market for nearly all of the jump-diffusion models fitted on SPX option prices they consider. 12 12 12 The models used to fit the data were drift diffusion models which varied in their jump distributions’ Levy densities. This is consistent with a large body of work which infers the presence of a negatively skewed jump process from the time series dynamics of equity indices and option prices ( Bates (2000) , Pan (2002) , Eraker et al. (2003) , Bollerslev & Todorov (2011) , Andersen et al. (2015) , among many others). In this more general setting, a quantity of related interest is the gap between the V^{mkt}(\tau) and VIX^{2}(\tau) : {}VS^{mkt}(\tau)-VIX^{2}(\tau)=Q\mathbb{E}^{\mathbb{Q}}_{0}\left[-\dfrac{1}{\tau}\log\dfrac{S_{\tau}}{S_{0}}\right]-2\mathbb{E}_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left[-\dfrac{1}{\tau}\log\dfrac{S_{\tau}}{S_{0}}\right]=2\lambda\mathbb{E}_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left(1+J+J^{2}/2-e^{J}\right) (21) where Q is the multiplier from ( 18 ). Using the same Taylor approximation as before delivers an expression in terms of the third moment of the jump distribution: VS^{mkt}(\tau)-VIX^{2}(\tau)\approx-\lambda\mathbb{E}_{0}^{\mathbb{Q}}\left(J^{3}/3\right) In the context of equity indices, the spread between the price of a variance swap and the VIX^{2} is generally positive and is driven by the negative skewness of the jump distribution. Aıt-Sahalia et al. (2020) explicitly document the time series properties of the VIX and the variance market quotes at the 2, 3, and 6 month maturity to quantify the degree to which jump risk is priced. On average, the difference between variance swap rates and the VIX is positive across all maturities, which the authors interpret as evidence of a significant, time-varying jump component embedded in variance swap prices. In particular, the average sign of this difference suggests that the jump process being priced in to swap rates is a negatively skewed one. 2.3 Calibration framework With the theoretical results detailed in section 2.2 in hand, I can now present my calibration framework and associated theoretical results. In section 2.3.1 , I first motivate my framework in the context of toy model, a Simple Jump Diffusion (SJD). An SJD process is a jump diffusion process with constant diffusive variance, jump size and jump intensity. 13 13 13 One can view this model as a special case of the Merton jump-diffusion model where the variance of the jump size is zero. Despite the simplicity of the setting, it is rich enough to demonstrate the benefit of incorporating information from the variance term structure for model calibration. In section 2.3.2 , I describe my proposed framework for a more general class of option pricing models which feature stochastic volatility and jumps in the underlying price process. 2.3.1 Identification in a Simple Jump Diffusion I show how the variance term structure can help simplify the identification of the parameters of a SJD process given option prices. Consider an underlying asset with price process S_{t} following the SJD in ( 22 ) with known diffusive volatility \sigma and true, unobserved jump parameters \lambda^{*} and J^{*} : 14 14 14 For ease of exposition, I assume the value of \sigma is known to the econometrician, a fairly benign assumption in this continuous time context. Barndorff-Nielsen & Shephard (2004) show, if prices are observed with high frequency, \sigma can be readily identified. \frac{dS_{t}}{S_{t^{-}}}=\sigma\,dW_{t}+\left(e^{J^{*}}-1\right)dN_{t}\qquad\qquad\mathbb{P}(dN_{t}=1)=\lambda^{*}dt (22) W_{t} is a Brownian motion and N_{t} is a Poisson arrival process with intensity \lambda^{*} . The jump process is simple - when a jump arrives it always has fixed size J^{*} . Suppose an econometrician is faced with the problem of recovering the unknown jump parameters of the SJD model. For what follows, I assume a non-degenerate jump process; that is, neither J nor \lambda is 0. She observes two frictionless, arbitrage-free markets at time 0: (1) a market for European-style call and put options with a single maturity T featuring a continuum of strike prices and (2) a variance swap market also of maturity T . 15 15 15 The markets she observes are frictionless in the sense that there are no transition costs. The spot price of the underlying is S_{0} and both the risk-free rate and the underlying’s dividend yield is zero. How should she proceed? A straightforward way to recover the model parameters is minimizing a sum of squared errors objective function, computed by sampling a large number N of OTM options. The calibration problem with this objective function amounts to solving: \min\limits_{\lambda,J}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}\left[\sigma^{SJD}(K_{i},T;\lambda,J)-\sigma^{mkt}(K_{i},T)\right]^{2} (23) \sigma^{SJD}(K_{i},T;\lambda,J) is the Black-Scholes implied volatility for an OTM option i with strike K_{i} with maturity T under SJD model with jump intensity \lambda and jump size J . 16 16 16 Specifically, I compute the option price under the SJD model with jump intensity \lambda and jump size J and invert this price via the Black-Scholes formula. The observed Black-Scholes implied volatilities from the market are \sigma^{mkt}(K,T)=\sigma^{SJD}(K_{i},T;\lambda^{*},J^{*}) . Since the variance swap price is observed, our econometrician can simplify her problem by incorporating this information. Let VS(T;\lambda,J) denote the price of the variance swap under the SJD model with parameters \lambda and J . By no-arbitrage: VS(T;\lambda,J)=\sigma^{2}+\lambda J^{2} (24) The variance swap rate observed in the market, VS^{mkt}(T) , is priced under the true parameters so the econometrician observes VS^{mkt}(T)=VS(T;\lambda^{*},J^{*}) . In this simple context, equation ( 24 ) allows the econometrician relate one of the true parameters, say \lambda^{*} , in terms of the other, J^{*} using the price of the observed variance swap. This simplifies her calibration procedure to a univariate optimization: \min\limits_{J}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}\left[\sigma^{SJD}(K_{i},T;\lambda(J),J)-\sigma^{mkt}(K,T)\right]^{2} (25) where \lambda(J) is derived from the variance swap pricing equation. The observation is summarized in proposition 1 . Proposition 1 . S_{t} obeys the SDE in ( 22 ) with unknown true parameters \lambda^{*} and J^{*} and known diffusive variance \sigma^{2} . If there is a frictionless, arbitrage-free market of European-style options and variance swaps with maturity T , then the optimization problem in ( 26 ) that recovers the unknown parameters is equivalent to the univariate problem in ( 27 ): \min\limits_{\lambda,J}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}\left[\sigma^{SJD}(K_{i},T;\lambda,J)-\sigma^{mkt}(K_{i},T)\right]^{2} (26) \min\limits_{J}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}\left[\sigma^{SJD}(K_{i},T;\lambda(J),J)-\sigma^{mkt}(K_{i},T)\right]^{2} (27) where \lambda(J)=J^{-2}\left[VS^{mkt}(T)-\sigma^{2}\right] . Proof provided in appendix. ∎ Even in the absence of a market for variance swaps, our econometrician can replicate a useful alternative: the squared VIX. Denote by P^{SJD}(K;\lambda,J) and C^{SJD}(K;\lambda,J) the put and call prices with strike K under the SJD model with jump parameters \lambda and J maturing at T . Since the options she observes are European-style, she can always replicate VIX^{2}(T;\lambda,J) , which only requires European-style option prices, by: VIX^{2}(T;\lambda,J)=\dfrac{2}{T}\left[\int_{0}^{S_{0}}\dfrac{P^{SJD}(K;\lambda,J)}{K^{2}}\,dK+\int_{S_{0}}^{\infty}\dfrac{C^{SJD}(K;\lambda,J)}{K^{2}}\,dK\right] (28) Replicating the VIX^{2} from observed option prices identifies VIX^{2}(T;\lambda^{*},J^{*}) . I can exploit the variance swap no-arbitrage relation and, combined with the expression in equation ( 21 ), yields a closed-form expression of the VIX in the SJD model. Equation ( 29 ) expresses the squared VIX in terms of the jump parameters: VIX^{2}(T;\lambda,J)=\sigma^{2}-2\lambda\left(1+J-e^{J}\right)\approx\sigma^{2}+2\lambda\left(J^{2}/2!+J^{3}/3!\right) (29) This again provides with an expression for \lambda in terms of J and, this time, the squared VIX obtained from observed option prices. Using a Taylor approximation for e^{J} shows that the squared VIX can be close to the theoretical variance swap price, with the difference having a leading order relationship in J^{3} . Like before, we may write an equation relating \lambda to J using the observed VIX^{2} which again allows the econometrician to substitute out \lambda in the optimization problem in ( 23 ) and reduce the problem to one of univariate minimization. This exercise in the SJD model illustrates the usefulness of the variance swap and VIX term structures with regards to calibration. Proposition 2 summarizes the results in the case only option prices are observed. Figure 1 : Surface (left) of the objective function in ( 30 ) computed with option prices computed under an SJD process with \lambda^{*}=1,J^{*}=-0.05 and \sigma=0.16 . Plot of objective function (right/dashed line on left) for parameter values consistent with market observed VIX . Proposition 2 . S_{t} obeys the SDE in ( 22 ) with unknown true parameters \lambda^{*} and J^{*} and known diffusive variance \sigma^{2} . If there is a frictionless, arbitrage-free market of European-style options with maturity T , then VIX^{2}(T;\lambda^{*},J^{*}) is identified from option prices and the optimization problem in ( 30 ) that recovers the unknown parameters can be converted to the univariate problem in ( 31 ): \min\limits_{\lambda,J}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}\left[\sigma^{SJD}(K_{i},T;\lambda,J)-\sigma^{mkt}(K_{i},T)\right]^{2} (30) \min\limits_{J}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N}\left[\sigma^{SJD}(K_{i},T;\lambda(J),J)-\sigma^{mkt}(K_{i},T)\right]^{2} (31) \lambda(J) in ( 31 ) is the function: \dfrac{VIX^{2}(T;\lambda^{*},J^{*})-\sigma^{2}}{2(1+J-e^{J})} Proof provided in appendix. ∎ To see how propositions 1 and 2 can be useful for calibration, I compute option prices under an SJD models with diffusive variance \sigma=0.16 and jump parameters in a grid centered at \lambda^{*}=1 and J^{*}=-0.05 . The time to maturity T is set to 1/12 (one month). Figure 1 plots the values of the objective function in ( 30 ) for option prices computed under various candidate jump parameters \lambda and J with true parameters \lambda^{*}=1 and J^{*}=-0.05 . 17 17 17 To compute the error term in equation ( 30 ), I sum the squared difference in BSIVs between the prices of OTM options generated under the true parameters and candidate parameters. The strike prices of the OTM options are 90,91,\ldots,110 and the spot price is 100. From the plot we see that, in the neighborhood of the true parameters, the objective function is very flat. As noted by Cont & Tankov (2004) , this can be challenging for optimization routines, particularly gradient-based methods, to handle. Since the VIX is observable, we can narrow our parameter search to the locus of points L consistent with the observed level of the VIX: L=\Bigg\{(\lambda,J)\text{ such that }\lambda=\dfrac{VIX^{2}(T;\lambda^{*},J^{*})-\sigma^{2}}{2(1+J-e^{J})}\Bigg\} In the left plot, the dashed line on the surface are the values of the objective function for the set of points in L . The right plot displays the values attained by the objective function restricted to just the set of points that lie in L . This reduces the problem to searching a flat region of the objective function to a simple univariate line search on L . 2.3.2 Identification under general processes Now I consider calibration in the context of a more general price process featuring jumps and stochastic volatility, two salient characteristics represented in modern option pricing models. Suppose the underlying process S_{t} obeys the following stochastic differential equation (SDE): \dfrac{dS_{t}}{S_{t}}=\sqrt{V_{t}}dW_{t}+[\exp(J_{t})-1]dN_{t}-\lambda_{t}\mu_{J}dt (32) where \mu_{J}=\mathbb{E}[\exp(J_{t})-1] . The above process is quite general, allowing for a separate variance process and general Levy densities for the jump process. N_{t} is the usual counting jump process with stochastic jump intensity \lambda_{t} . Denote the vector of model parameters for the SDE in ( 32 ) by \Theta and define \mathbb{Q}_{\Theta} to be the pricing measure implied by the process in ( 32 ) given \Theta . Recycling some notation from before, denote the prices of European-style call and put options with strike K and maturity \tau priced under \mathbb{Q}_{\Theta} by C(K,\tau;\Theta) and P(K,\tau;\Theta) . I assume frictionless markets, the absence of arbitrage, a continuum of observed strike prices, no dividend yield and a risk-free rate of zero. Unlike in the prior section, I assume there are M observed option maturities, \{\tau_{1},\tau_{2}\ldots,\tau_{M}\} , rather than a single maturity. I consider the inverse problem of recovering the true parameter vector \Theta^{*} given option prices implied by the SDE in ( 32 ). Like in the prior section, I tackle two cases, one where variance swap prices co-terminal with the option maturities are observed and the other where only the option prices are observed. Suppose variance swap prices with the same maturities as the options are observed by the econometrician. By no-arbitrage, the variance swap price VS(\tau;\Theta) with maturity \tau under the general model with parameters \Theta is given by: VS(\tau;\Theta)=\dfrac{1}{\tau}\mathbb{E}\left[QV(\tau)|\Theta\right]=\dfrac{1}{\tau}\mathbb{E}\left[\int_{0}^{\tau}V_{t}dt+\int_{0}^{\tau}\int_{\mathbb{R}}J^{2}\nu(ds,dx)\Big|\Theta\right] (33) where \mathbb{E}(\cdot|\Theta) is the expectation operator computed using pricing measure \mathbb{Q}_{\Theta} . The variance swaps the econometrician observes in the market, VS^{mkt}(\tau) , are priced under the pricing measure associated with the true parameter vector \Theta^{*} , thus VS^{mkt}(\tau)=VS(\tau;\Theta^{*}) . As before, the econometrician can solve the following optimization problem to recover the parameter \Theta : \min\limits_{\Theta}\sum\limits_{j=1}^{M}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N_{j}}w_{i,j}\left[\sigma(K_{i,j},\tau_{j};\Theta)-\sigma^{mkt}(K_{i,j},\tau_{j})\right]^{2} (34) where N_{j} is the number of OTM options of maturity \tau_{j} and \sigma(K_{i,j},\tau_{j};\Theta) denotes the BSIV of an OTM option with strike K_{i,j} and maturity \tau_{j} priced under the measure \mathbb{Q}_{\Theta} . w_{i,j} are non-negative constants which act as weights. \sigma^{mkt}(K_{i,j},\tau_{j}) denotes the BSIV of an OTM option priced under the true measure \mathbb{Q}_{\Theta^{*}} , the BSIV observed in the market. Therefore, we have \sigma^{mkt}(K_{i,j},\tau_{j})=\sigma(K_{i,j},\tau_{j};\Theta^{*}) . To be of practical use, an option pricing model should fit the observed volatility surface well. In addition to this first-order priority, for a variety of research and applied use cases, another desirable property is consistency between this fitted volatility surface and the observed term structure of variance. An obvious application where this property would be important is the hedging variance derivatives (e.g variance swaps, VIX futures) which are often hedged using a portfolio of vanilla options. Other use cases include academic studies which examine variance risk premia through the lens of an option pricing model. To quantify this risk premium in a coherent way, the model-implied level of variance should match what is implied by option prices. To this end, I augment the objective function in ( 34 ) using the regularization terms g^{VIX}(\Theta) and g^{VS}(\Theta) which penalize deviations from the observed term structure of the VIX and variance swap rates respectively: g^{VIX}(\Theta)=\sum\limits_{j=1}^{M}w^{v}_{j}\left[VIX(\tau_{j};\Theta)-VIX^{mkt}(\tau_{j})\right]^{2} (35) g^{VS}(\Theta)=\sum\limits_{j=1}^{M}w^{v}_{j}\left[\sqrt{VS(\tau_{j};\Theta)}-\sqrt{VS^{mkt}(\tau_{j})}\right]^{2} (36) where w^{v}_{j} are non-negative constants. The augmented objective function is given in the statement of Proposition 3 . The proposition shows that for the SDE in ( 32 ), \Theta^{*} minimizes this augmented objective function and that this augmented objective function is observable. Proposition 3 . S_{t} obeys the SDE in ( 32 ) with unknown true parameter vector \Theta^{*} . If there is a frictionless, arbitrage-free market of European-style options then \Theta^{*} solves the minimization problem in ( 37 ) for any non-negative constants w_{i,j} and w^{v}_{j} : \min\limits_{\Theta}\Bigg\{\sum\limits_{j=1}^{M}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N(\tau_{j})}w_{i,j}\left[\sigma(K_{i},\tau_{j};\Theta)-\sigma^{mkt}(K_{i},\tau_{j})\right]^{2}+g(\Theta)\Bigg\} (37) where g(\Theta)=g^{VIX}(\Theta) . The objective minimized in ( 37 ) is observable solely from option prices. If variance swaps with maturities \{\tau_{j}\}_{j=1}^{M} are observed, then g(\Theta)=g^{VS}(\Theta) also produces an observable objective function in ( 37 ). In either case, ( 37 ) is observable even if the stochastic process for S_{t} is mis-specified. Proof provided in appendix. ∎ Proposition 3 provides an observable objective function in the case where only option prices are observed and where option prices and the variance swap rates are jointly observed. The objective minimized in ( 37 ) is observable even when the SDE in ( 32 ) is mis-specified, that is, market prices are generated under a different pricing measure altogether. In the case of model mis-specification, the parameter vector that minimizes the objective is no longer the true parameter vector, but the set of parameters which delivers the model with the closest fit to market option prices and the variance term structure. The fact that the objective function is observable regardless of the correct stochastic process being specified makes it implementable in model calibration. In addition, the functional form, specifically, the non-negative constants w_{i,j} and w_{j}^{v} , allow for more targeted calibration based on the user’s needs. A practitioner needing a tight fit on ATM options could appropriately weight the constants associated with the error in ATM options more heavily. Similarly, a researcher wanting to fit the term structure of the variance swap curve can up-weight the w_{j}^{v} constants. The choice of these constants govern the relative importance of certain parts of the volatility surface and variance term structure in model calibration. One can employ the summations ( 35 ) and ( 36 ) as informative moment conditions for a generalized method of moments (GMM) framework, reminiscent of the pioneering work of Chernov & Ghysels (2000) and Pan (2002) . These works incorporate moment conditions under the physical and risk-neutral distributions of the underlying compared to the solely risk-neutral moments used here. The first summation in ( 37 ) can be seen as a moment condition for the implied volatility surface and the second summation as a moment condition for the term structure of variance. The particularly useful case of proposition 3 is the one where only option prices are observed. Typically, assets which have options written on them do not have a corresponding variance swap market. 18 18 18 Popular equity indices, such as the S&P 500 or DAX, are notable exceptions as underlyings with actively traded variance swap markets. Fortunately, while the term structure of the variance swap curve is not observed, one can still recover the VIX term structure which is identical to the variance swap term structure in the case of continuous prices and an approximation in the general case when the underlying can jump. 19 19 19 The error in this approximation is proportional to the product of the third moment of the jump distribution and the expectation of the jump intensity over the swap’s life. Even if the data generating process is not known, the minimization problem is still conceptually valid as a means of obtaining the best fitting parameters. The "best" model obtained in this context is the one that minimizes the objective function. A potential issue is that while the resulting model might match option prices and implied volatilities closely, the model-implied term structure of variance (measured by variance swap prices or the squared VIX) can have substantial error when compared to the term structure observed in the market. Surprisingly, as I show in section 4 , this can be true even for the VIX term structure, quantities directly computed from option prices themselves. In general, fitting the options well in a mean squared error sense does not guarantee fitting the term structure of the VIX or variance swaps well. Unfortunately, in nearly all applied contexts, the data generating price process is not known. Indeed, in practice, researchers and practitioners first posit a credible model then calibrate the parameters to minimize some function of model error. Intuitively, a desirable feature for a well-calibrated model is for the quantity below, the error in the calibrated volatility surface, to be small: \sum\limits_{j=1}^{N_{\tau}}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N(\tau_{j})}\left[\sigma(K_{i,j},\tau_{j};\Theta)-\sigma^{mkt}(K_{i,j},\tau_{j})\right]^{2} Like in a GMM approach to calibration, I minimize a function of the moment conditions rather that require that they hold exactly. Another sensible feature for a well-calibrated model is to fit the term structure of the VIX and/or variance swap quotes furnishing consistency between option and variance swap prices. As in proposition 3 , I can incorporate the term structure of variance or the VIX depending on the observed market instruments. These two considerations motivate a special case of my proposed objective function: \sum\limits_{j=1}^{M}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N_{\tau_{j}}}\left[\sigma(K_{i,j},\tau_{j};\Theta)-\sigma^{mkt}(K_{i,j},\tau_{j})\right]^{2}+\sum\limits_{j=1}^{M}N(\tau_{j})\left[\sqrt{V(\tau_{j};\Theta)}-\sqrt{V^{mkt}(\tau_{j}})\right]^{2} (38) where V(\tau_{j};\Theta) is the model-implied variance swap, when variance swap term structures are observed and is the model-implied VIX term structure otherwise. V^{mkt}(\cdot) denotes the comparable market observed term structure. The first sum in ( 38 ) is identical to the sums in ( 26 ) and ( 30 ), being simply the sum of squared errors in BSIV space with equal weight on each contract. The second sum is a special case of ( 35 ) or ( 36 ), scaling the error in the variance swap or VIX term structure by N_{\tau_{j}} , the number of OTM options of maturity \tau_{j} . This scaling makes errors in fitting V^{mkt}(\tau_{j}) contribute just as much to the objective function as errors over the entire volatility smile at maturity \tau_{j} . Intuitively, a 1% error in the variance is "as bad" at maturity \tau_{j} , according to the objective function, as a 1% error across all contracts with maturity \tau_{j} . Finally, I include a hyperparameter, \alpha\in[0,1] , which governs the relative importance between fitting the variance swap/VIX term structure and the option implied volatilities, yielding my proposed objective function below: \alpha\sum\limits_{j=1}^{M}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N_{\tau_{j}}}\left[\sigma(K_{i,j},\tau_{j};\Theta^{*})+\sigma^{mkt}(K_{i,j},\tau_{j})\right]^{2}+(1-\alpha)\sum\limits_{j=1}^{M}N(\tau_{j})\left[V(\tau_{j}|\Theta)-V^{mkt}(\tau_{j})\right]^{2} (39) Section 4 is devoted to studying model calibration with the objective function above. I calibrate volatility surfaces using ( 39 ) first in a simulation study, then using the SPX volatility surface implied by traded contracts. I also provide guidance for the choice of hyperparameter \alpha which, in empirical settings, can greatly affect quality of calibration. One might wonder of what additional benefit can be had by using the information from the variance swap or VIX term structures; after all, the term structure of VIX is itself identified from option prices with the variance swap rate and VIX being highly correlated. However, as I explore further in section 4 , fitting the observed option implied volatilities well does not guarantee a reasonable fit for the VIX term structure when calibrating to market option quotes. In the case the price process is continuous, such in the Heston (1993) or Heath et al. (1992) models, the variance swap term structure itself can be subject to the same criticisms as, in the continuous case, this term structure is also identified from option prices. For applied use, I find there are two main benefits from using ( 39 ) as the objective function. The first is that introducing an error in term structures regularizes the resulting parameters to match the observed term structure. I find that a simple sum of squared errors objective function, equivalent to \alpha=0 in ( 39 ), produces large errors in both the VIX and variance swap term structures. The introduction of a regularization term based on these term structures, by the appropriate choice of \alpha>0 , can produce calibrated models that closely match observed term structures while maintaining a quality fit on the volatility surface. 3 SPX Option panel and variance term structure I use the quotes provided by OptionMetrics for European-style call and put options on S&P 500 Index (SPX). Data coverage begins in January 1996 and ends in August 2023. Quotes are end-of-day 4pm bid and ask prices. For the purposes of calibrating option pricing models, I use the mid-price as the option’s price computed from the bid and ask quotes for OTM options. I consider only OTM options for inclusion in the panel as it suffices to price OTM options to be able to price a vanilla option of any strike. 20 20 20 Since the options are European-style, one can recover the price of in-the-money option from out-of-the-money option prices via a put-call parity relation. From an estimation perspective, OTM options also have the advantage that they generally more liquid compared to the ITM option of the same strike. Other data include risk-free rates from T-bill rates and dividend yield obtained from Bloomberg. I exclude options from the panel with maturity greater than 1 year. I impose standard filters on the option data following the literature (e.g. Constantinides et al. (2013) , Goyal & Saretto (2022) , etc). These filters eliminate contracts with prices which are either obviously erroneous, violate no-arbitrage conditions, or are so deeply out-of-the-money that their extrinsic value is close to zero. Specifically, I eliminate contracts which have a bid price greater than its ask price, have a ask price less than or equal to 10 cents, imply put-call parity violations, or have a standardized moneyness greater than 6 in absolute value. I compute the standardized moneyness k_{i,j} of an OTM option with time to maturity \tau_{j} and strike price K_{i,j} as: k_{i,j}=\dfrac{\ln\left(K_{i,j}/S_{t}\right)}{\text{VIX}(\tau_{j})\sqrt{\tau_{j}}} where \text{VIX}(\tau_{j}) is the VIX computed using the methodology of Jiang & Tian (2005) using options with time to maturity \tau_{j} . S_{t} is the spot price of the index. After filters are applied, the option panel consists of 2,968,199 call options and 6,182,584 put options. Moneyness Maturity BSIV (%) Std. Moneyness Option price (%) DTE N Obs. Panel A: Call options ATM 0-9 DTE 19.2 0.497 0.48 6.26 102,308 (12.4) (0.288) (0.463) (2.15) OTM 0-9 DTE 17.8 1.44 0.0447 6.11 82,033 (10.7) (0.274) (0.0511) (2.19) DOTM 0-9 DTE 18.6 2.26 0.0116 5.91 10,938 (12.2) (0.299) (0.0111) (2.27) ATM 10-30 DTE 16.5 0.474 0.758 20.4 461,003 (8.99) (0.286) (0.7) (5.89) OTM 10-30 DTE 14.8 1.39 0.0541 19.5 247,084 (7.86) (0.26) (0.0601) (5.99) DOTM 10-30 DTE 15.8 2.22 0.016 17.7 16,670 (9.44) (0.214) (0.012) (5.76) ATM 30+ DTE 16.2 0.455 1.86 130 1,549,052 (6.27) (0.28) (1.73) (90.5) OTM 30+ DTE 14.7 1.32 0.134 117 492,123 (5.64) (0.235) (0.176) (90) DOTM 30+ DTE 18.3 2.13 0.0426 115 7,988 (7.56) (0.123) (0.0314) (101) Panel B: Put options ATM 0-9 DTE 22.7 -0.499 0.602 6.26 102,728 (14.3) (0.289) (0.481) (2.15) OTM 0-9 DTE 25.6 -1.49 0.156 6.23 97,635 (14.6) (0.288) (0.119) (2.16) DOTM 0-9 DTE 29.6 -3.24 0.0357 6.23 184,172 (13.3) (0.891) (0.0267) (2.16) ATM 10-30 DTE 21.1 -0.489 1.02 20.6 495,907 (10.4) (0.287) (0.68) (5.87) OTM 10-30 DTE 24.4 -1.48 0.295 20.2 393,474 (10.8) (0.288) (0.168) (5.94) DOTM 10-30 DTE 29.2 -3.18 0.0739 19.7 620,642 (10.3) (0.841) (0.0458) (6.01) ATM 30+ DTE 22.7 -0.489 2.55 134 1,759,255 (7.59) (0.287) (1.58) (90.8) OTM 30+ DTE 28.1 -1.46 0.716 129 1,315,187 (8.73) (0.287) (0.386) (91.2) DOTM 30+ DTE 32.2 -2.81 0.17 98.4 1,213,584 (9.22) (0.619) (0.0971) (76.2) Table 1 : Summary statistics of S&P 500 Index option panel. BSIV and option prices (normalized by index spot price) are expressed as percentages. The N Obs. (number of observations) column reports the number of option contracts observed in each category. Table 1 presents summary statistics of the option panel, separated into call and put options. These contracts are further divided by their standardized moneyness and maturity. An option i is in the ATM (at-the-money), OTM (out-of-the-money), or DOTM (deep OTM) bucket if the absolute value of its standardized moneyness |k_{i,t}| is in [0,1),[1,2),\text{ or }[2,\infty) respectively. Options are sorted into different maturity categories based on the number of days to expiration (DTE): 1-9 DTE, 10-30 DTE, or 30+ (31-365) DTE. For both put and call options, I pick up the presence of a volatility smile. On average, the ATM options possess the lowest BSIV while the DOTM are the highest within their respective maturity categories for both puts and calls. This is most pronounced for put options with DOTM options having the highest BSIVs across both panels reflecting the relatively high cost of hedging large negative jumps ( Bollerslev & Todorov (2011) ) . The largest categories of options are the 30+ DTE categories consisting mostly of standard expiration index options. 21 21 21 Standard expiration options are AM-settled and expire on the third Friday of each month. The shorter maturities, which mostly consist of non-standard weekly expirations, are less represented in the full sample, despite their contemporary popularity. Across all maturity categories, we observe a volatility skew: OTM put options have greater BSIV on average than OTM call options of similar maturity. This skew in implied volatility units is largest at maturities greater than 30 days. For these maturities, an average OTM put option is nearly twice as expensive as the average OTM call option in implied volatility terms. These observations are consistent with empirical work documenting the properties of volatility surfaces generated by index options ( Gatheral (2011) ) . Figure 2 : Mean (blue dots) with standard error bars of the VIX at the 9 day and 1 to 12 month horizon computed from option prices of the appropriate maturity. Turning to the term structure of variance, I compute the VIX Index at a number of horizons using the VIX formula in ( 7 ). To get a sense of a typical term structure for the SPX, I calculate VIX across several horizons and compute its unconditional mean and standard deviation for each horizon. I compute the VIX for each monthly horizon between 1 and 12 months using the closest option maturity to the given horizon. I also replicate CBOE’s 9-day VIX, choosing the closest option maturity between 8 and 10 days as the inputs for the VIX formula. 22 22 22 CBOE interpolates the VIX on days when the exact target maturity is not listed using nearby maturities. The resulting quantities are nearly identical to the ones I compute here. I plot the mean and standard deviation of these VIX indices in figure 2 . Consistent with observations made by prior studies (e.g. Dew-Becker et al. (2017) , Johnson (2017) ), the term structure of the VIX is typically upward-sloping, flattening out around the intermediate horizons. The error bars around the unconditional averages shows substantial variability in the VIX at all horizons, with the short end of the term structure exhibiting higher volatility as compared to the long end. 4 Empirical results In this section, I apply my calibration framework to two contexts: a simulation study and a calibration exercise on SPX options. To work with a model sufficiently complex for the calibration to be challenging, I consider the calibration of the Bates (1996) model in both setups. The Bates model combines the stochastic volatility process of Heston (1993) with the jump process from Merton (1976) , effectively nesting both models. In section 4.1 , I demonstrate the ability of the framework to recover model parameters given the option prices generated under the Bates model. In section 4.2 , I calibrate a Bates model to the SPX equity index options panel constructed in section 3 . Lastly, in section 4.3 , I show how the calibrated parameters can shed light on the role of jumps in the overall price fluctuations of the S&P 500. Before proceeding with my empirical exercises, I define Bates model here and provide some useful closed-form expressions for the VIX and variance swap term structure. Denote underlying’s price by S_{t} and the latent variance process by V_{t} . S_{t-} denotes the price level at time t prior to a jump. I suppress time subscripts whenever an expression’s meaning is unambiguous. The Bates model assigns these processes the following dynamics: \displaystyle dS_{t-}=\left(r-q-\lambda\mu_{J}\right)S_{t-}dt+\sqrt{V_{t}}S_{-t}dW_{t}+(e^{J_{t}}-1)S_{t-}dN_{t} (40) \displaystyle dV_{t}=\kappa\left(\theta-V_{t}\right)dt+\sigma_{V}\sqrt{V_{t}}dW_{t}^{v} \displaystyle\mathbb{E}\left[dW_{t}dW_{t}^{v}\right]=\rho dt \displaystyle\mathbb{P}\left(dN_{t}=1\right)=\lambda dt \displaystyle J_{t}\sim Normal\left(\log\left(1+\mu_{J}\right)-\frac{\sigma_{J}^{2}}{2},\sigma_{J}^{2}\right) For the Bates model, the parameter vector is \Theta=[V_{t},\kappa,\theta,\sigma_{v},\rho,\lambda,\mu_{J},\sigma_{J}] . V_{t} is the latent level of variance, driven by a Brownian motion with variance proportional to its own level, \sigma_{V}^{2}V_{t} , and is a mean-reverting process with long term variance \theta and speed of adjustment \kappa . \rho is the instantaneous correlation between the two Brownian motions. The jump process J_{t} is drawn from a Gaussian distribution with mean \log(1+\mu_{J})-\sigma^{2}_{J}/2 and variance \sigma_{J}^{2} and has arrival intensity \lambda . On arrival, the underlying price instantly changes by S_{t-}[\exp(J_{t})-1] . Broadie & Jain (2008) derive the variance swap term structure in closed form for the Bates model, allowing for straight-forward computation as a function of the model parameters. The variance swap rate VS(\tau;\Theta) implied by the model is given by: VS(\tau;\Theta)=\theta+\frac{V_{0}-\theta}{\kappa\tau}\left(1-e^{-\kappa\tau}\right)+\lambda\left[(\log(1+\mu_{J})-\sigma^{2}_{J}/2)^{2}+\sigma_{J}^{2}\right] (41) Combining ( 41 ) with equation ( 21 ) allows us to compute a closed form expression for the squared VIX term structure: VIX^{2}(\tau;\Theta)=VS(\tau|\Theta)-2\lambda\mathbb{E}(1+J+J^{2}/2-e^{J}|\Theta) where expectation \mathbb{E}(\cdot|\Theta) is taken over the risk-neutral distribution under the Bates model with parameter vector \Theta . Computing the relevant moments of the jump distribution and \mathbb{E}(e^{J}) , we have: \mathbb{E}(e^{J})=\exp(\log(1+\mu_{J})-\sigma^{2}_{J}/2+\sigma^{2}_{J}/2)=1+\mu_{J} \mathbb{E}(J)=\log(1+\mu_{J})-\sigma^{2}_{J}/2 \mathbb{E}(J^{2})=\left[\log(1+\mu_{J})-\sigma^{2}_{J}/2\right]^{2}+\sigma^{2}_{J} Substituting moments and simplifying, I derive a closed-form formula for the VIX term structure implied by the Bates model: VIX^{2}(\tau;\Theta)=VS(\tau;\Theta)-2\lambda\left(\log(1+\mu_{J})-\mu_{J}+\frac{1}{2}[\log(1+\mu_{J})-\sigma_{J}^{2}/2]^{2}\right) (42) For the purposes of pricing options in the Bates model, I use the PROJ method of Kirkby (2015) , a Fourier-based pricing method that employs series truncation, allowing for computationally efficient computation of option prices. 23 23 23 For obtaining option prices under the Bates model, I use the python implementation of the PROJ method from the fyfy library. The Github repository can be found here: fypy Github repo . Parameter: V_{0} \kappa \theta \sigma_{v} \rho \lambda \mu_{J} \sigma_{J} Initial value (\Theta_{0}) 0.0576 2.03 0.04 0.38 -0.7 0.59 -0.05 0.07 Uniform distribution lower bound (a) 0.01 0.01 1 0.1 -1 0 -0.1 0.0 Uniform distribution upper bound (b) 0.1 0.1 5 0.5 1 5 0.1 0.1 Table 2 : Initial parameters \Theta_{0} used by Lindström et al. (2008) in their simulation study of the Bates model. Parameters are based on the analysis by Bakshi et al. (1997) of calibrated Bates models fitted to S&P 500 Index options. Lower and upper bounds of uniform noise in equation ( 43 ). 4.1 Simulation study As a proof of concept, I simulate option prices from the Bates model, using a broad range of parameter values and attempt to recover the model parameters. Specifically, I first form a set \mathcal{P} of parameter vectors as follows. Table 2 displays the parameter values from a simulation study on the Bates model conducted by Lindström et al. (2008) . I stack these parameters into the vector \Theta_{0} . I generate 1,000 parameter vectors in \mathcal{P} by adding uniformly distributed random variables pointwise to \Theta_{0} , where the lower and upper bound of the uniform distribution for each parameter: \Theta_{i}=\Theta_{0}+\begin{pmatrix}Uniform[a_{v},b_{v}]\\ Uniform[a_{\kappa},b_{\kappa}]\\ Uniform[a_{\theta},b_{\theta}]\\ Uniform[a_{\sigma}^{v},b_{\sigma}^{v}]\\ Uniform[a_{\rho},b_{\rho}]\\ Uniform[a_{\lambda},b_{\lambda}]\\ Uniform[a_{\mu},b_{\mu}]\\ Uniform[a_{\sigma}^{J},b_{\sigma}^{J}]\\ \end{pmatrix}\quad\quad\text{ for }i\in\{1,\ldots,1000\} (43) The bounds of the uniform distribution were chosen to obtain a diverse range of model parameters and to exclude the possibility non-nonsensical parameters being drawn, such as drawing a value greater than 1 for the correlation parameter \rho . For each of the 1,000 parameter vectors in \mathcal{P} , I calibrate the model using the objective function in ( 38 ) using \Theta_{0} as the initial guess for the optimization routine. To explore the effect of the hyperparameter \alpha on calibration, I show estimation results for a grid of values for \alpha\in[0,1] . Table 3 summarizes the results from this calibration exercise. Each of the 1,000 parameter vectors in \mathcal{P} , corresponds to a simulated volatility surface. For each run of the simulation, the spot price of the underlying is 100 and its dividend yield is 3%. The risk-free rate is set to 2%. I compute option prices under the model for the 1 week (7 days), 1 month (30 days), 3 month (91 days), 6 month (182 days) and 1 year (365 days) maturities with strike prices ranging from 75 to 125, spaced apart by $1. For the calibration step, I use only OTM options with price greater than or equal to 10 cents. I minimize objective function in ( 38 ), using the simulated volatility surface and the VIX for each available maturity using the relation derived earlier in equation ( 42 ). \text{Hyperparameter }(\alpha): 0.00 0.10 0.25 0.50 0.75 0.90 1.00 Panel A - Average errors in model-implied BSIVs with VIX Contract Moneyness: ATM (0\leq|k_{i,t}|<1) 2.05% 0.12% 0.13% 0.13% 0.14% 0.15% 0.16% OTM (1\leq|k_{i,t}|<2) 3.77% 0.21% 0.23% 0.25% 0.26% 0.26% 0.28% DOTM (2\leq|k_{i,t}|) 7.74% 0.35% 0.37% 0.41% 0.41% 0.42% 0.44% Panel B - Average errors in model-implied BSIVs with variance swap approximation Contract Moneyness: ATM (0\leq|k_{i,t}|<1) 1.98% 0.19% 0.19% 0.17% 0.17% 0.16% 0.16% OTM (1\leq|k_{i,t}|<2) 3.75% 0.28% 0.29% 0.29% 0.28% 0.27% 0.28% DOTM (2\leq|k_{i,t}|) 7.78% 0.45% 0.44% 0.45% 0.45% 0.42% 0.44% Panel C - Proportion of simulations where parameter vector was exactly recovered Calibration type: Exact VIX 0% 56.8% 56.6% 55.9% 56.3% 55.7% 55.4% Approximated VIX 0% 1.4% 1.5% 1.5% 2.2% 3.3% 55.4% Table 3 : Average errors for simulated contract prices across for different buckets of standardized moneyness (Panel A and B). Errors broken down by the absolute value of standardized moneyness |k_{i,t}| . Range given in parentheses. Percentage of simulations where parameter vector was exactly recovered (Panel C). Panel A of table 3 records the average error in terms of BSIVs across simulations for models calibrated using different values of the hyperparameter \alpha , broken down by different levels of standardized moneyness. Higher values of \alpha correspond to objective functions placing greater weight on the option BSIV surface. At the lower extreme, \alpha=0 corresponds to the case where only information from the VIX term structure is used to calibrate the surface. The errors are much higher compared to average errors under other values of \alpha . At the other end, a value of \alpha=1 , corresponds to the case where only information from the option BSIVs are used in calibration. The average errors in this case are substantially lower than those under the \alpha=0 case. Figure 3 show the average model error of the 1 month and 1 year VIX across the 1,000 simulations in percentages. All values of \alpha produce small errors with the fit becoming perfect as \alpha\to 0 . For \alpha=0.5 , which places equal weight on the VIX term structure and the volatility surface, the error is around 10 basis points for both the 1 month and 1 year VIX. The errors in the VIX term structure are comparable to what we see in the volatility surface fits. Overall, intermediate values of \alpha show similarly low errors suggesting the viability of using an objective function which jointly considers the fit in volatility surface and the variance term structure. These observations suggest a fairly benign trade-off between fitting the volatility surface and VIX term structure at higher values in the unit interval. As discussed in section 2 , the VIX is based on the pricing formula of a variance swap under the assumption that the underlying price process is continuous. In the presence of jumps, the VIX formula does not necessarily recover the variance swap price, which under no-arbitrage is the risk-neutral expectation of the quadratic variation. However, a number of studies do not make this distinction, treating the square of the VIX as the expected risk-neutral variance or, equivalently under no-arbitrage, as the fair strike of a variance swap. 24 24 24 Martin (2017) points out that the VIX, rather than measuring variance, is more accurately categorized as a measure of statistical entropy. Bondarenko (2014) documents the discrepancy between the VIX construction and the payoff of traded variance swaps. As pointed out by Carr et al. (2012) and Aıt-Sahalia et al. (2020) , the gap between the squared VIX and the expected quadratic variation is time-varying and at times can be substantial. Despite this, the VIX is widely used as a measure of expected volatility. I consider calibration in this commonly mis-specified case where the VIX is used as an approximation for the variance swap rate. I again calibrate models across different values of \alpha ; this time using the option BSIV surface and the variance swap curve as inputs for the objective function in ( 38 ). Specifically, the variance term structure errors in my objective function are replaced by the following approximation: \sum\limits_{j}\left[\sqrt{VS(\tau_{j};\Theta)}-\sqrt{VS^{mkt}(\tau_{j})}\right]^{2}\approx\sum\limits_{j}\left[\sqrt{VIX^{2}(\tau_{j};\Theta)}-\sqrt{VS^{mkt}(\tau_{j})}\right]^{2} (44) Figure 3 : Average fitting error (expressed as a percentage) for the 1 month and 12 month VIX over 1,000 simulations. Orange bars show fitting errors for calibration using the exact VIX term structure. Blue bars show fitting errors when using the VIX as an approximation of the variance swap rate. Panel B of table 3 displays the results from using the common VIX-variance swap expected quadratic variation approximation. For many moneyness categories, the errors are higher when calibrating using the variance swap approximation compared to using the VIX term structure exactly. Although the errors are not substantially higher, the real difference is observed in panel C. Panel C reports the percentage of the 1,000 simulations which recovered the exact true parameters across a range of hyperparameter values. When \alpha=0 , we see that under either calibration the exact parameters are never recovered. This is due to the flexibility of the Bates model, as there are multiple parameter vectors consistent with the variance term structure generated in each simulation. From the remaining values of \alpha , two salient details stand out; first, using the approximated term structure is substantially worse when it comes to exact recovery of the model parameters. This exercise suggests caution should be applied when using the squared VIX as the expected quadratic variation when it comes to model calibration. Using the exact VIX term structure recovers the parameters more than half of the time exactly and when the exact parameters are not recovered the fitting error across the term structure and volatility surface is low. Second, when using the exact VIX term structure for calibration as in panel A instead of using VIX as an approximation the exact parameters are recovered at nearly identical rates (\approx 56\%) across different values of \alpha , excluding the case where \alpha=0 . This provides further evidence that the trade-off in goodness-of-fit between the variance term structures and the volatility surface is mild for intermediate values of \alpha . 4.2 Model calibration to SPX Index options In this section, I calibrate the Bates model to the SPX Index options data for each day of observations in my option panel using the objective function in ( 38 ). The data starts in January of 1996 and ends in August of 2023. To get a sense of the effect the hyperparameter \alpha has on calibration, I calibrate the Bates model for each of the values of \alpha : 0, 0.1, 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 0.9, 1.0. To assess the model fit across the volatility surface and VIX term structure, I compute the average absolute fitting error across different groupings of maturities in table 4 for call options, put options, and the VIX term structure. The averages are taken over all fitted option prices and values computed from the VIX formula in ( 7 ) across all trading days in the panel. Examining the panels of table 4 by maturity grouping, we see that the most challenging components of the VIX term structure and the volatility surface are located at the shortest maturities. The errors for call and put options with 1 - 9 days to maturity have the highest errors in implied volatility space relative to other maturities. The calibration results on the SPX equity index options are most directly comparable with Broadie et al. (2007) study of S&P 500 futures options data ranging from 1987 to 2003. The authors estimate the Bates (1996) model using options between 10 and 180 days to expiration and obtain authors report an average error of 0.6% in BSIV terms. I obtain similar results for comparable maturities in my panel for call and put options with 10-30 DTE and 30+ DTE. This is notable even in light of the fact the volatility surfaces in my panel are more challenging from an calibration perspective due to the proliferation of short maturity, weekly expirations which the models need to fit jointly with longer maturities. These very short maturity options have populated contemporary volatility surfaces with many more near-term maturities which been known to be difficult to fit ( F.M. Bandi & Renò (2024) ; F. Bandi et al. (2024) ) . Turning to the short maturity options (1-9 DTE), I observe unsurprisingly higher errors relative to longer maturities. The shortest maturity segment of the volatility surface is notoriously difficult to fit. Andersen et al. (2017) studies options with less than 10 days to maturity and finds that many parametric option pricing models use jump processes at odds with the thickness and time-variation of the jump tails. Using a Bates model-like approach they obtain an average error of 1.24% on models fitted on only their short maturity sample. The results here are comparable despite having to fit the entire surface out to the 1 year maturity. For values of \alpha>0 , the errors for the (1-9 DTE) category are all between 1.47\% and 1.58\% for call options and 1.53\% to 1.67\% for put options. Hyperparameter ( \alpha ) 0.0 0.1 0.25 0.5 0.75 0.9 1.0 Panel A: Calls Call (1–9 DTE) 4.21% 1.58% 1.56% 1.52% 1.49% 1.47% 1.48% Call (10–30 DTE) 4.65% 0.68% 0.66% 0.62% 0.59% 0.57% 0.57% Call (30+ DTE) 6.13% 1.04% 0.96% 0.88% 0.83% 0.79% 0.74% Panel B: Puts Put (1–9 DTE) 5.57% 1.67% 1.62% 1.58% 1.55% 1.54% 1.53% Put (10–30 DTE) 5.06% 0.82% 0.75% 0.71% 0.67% 0.66% 0.65% Put (30+ DTE) 5.06% 0.75% 0.72% 0.68% 0.65% 0.62% 0.58% Panel C: VIX term structure 1–9 DTE 1.17% 1.18% 1.21% 1.27% 1.37% 1.53% 3.98% 10–30 DTE 0.45% 0.46% 0.47% 0.51% 0.60% 0.77% 3.14% 30+ DTE 0.30% 0.31% 0.32% 0.36% 0.42% 0.50% 1.85% Table 4 : Mean absolute errors of in model implied volatilities for OTM options (panel A and B) and VIX term structure (panel C) across maturities. Maturities/option maturities used in replication given in round parentheses. Panel C of table 4 , presents the mean absolute fitting errors for the VIX term structure. As expected, the lowest average error for all maturities occurs at \alpha=0 . When \alpha is zero, the entire error in contract implied volatilities drops out of the objective function, leaving only information from the term structure to guide calibration. Indeed, without the error in contract BSIVs term, the fit in the implied volatility surface is sharply poorer for every maturity relative to all other values of \alpha . In contrast, a value of \alpha=1 results in the poorest fit to the VIX term structure. Despite poor fit in option BSIVs and therefore prices, the objective function with \alpha=0 delivers a quality fit for the VIX term structure. This illustrates a familiar phenomenon with flexible option pricing models such as the Bates model and is consistent with we was observed with the simulations in section 4.1 : there are a number of pricing measures that can produce nearly identical variance term structures. At the other extreme, \alpha=1 represents an important special case since it is equivalent to the conventional mean squared error objective used in a wide range of academic and industry applications. As noted above, the volatility surface fits when \alpha=1 are comparable to literature standards; however, average errors in the model-implied VIX term structures are the highest across the grid of \alpha hyperparameters examined here. Relative to historical averages, the model-implied VIX term structures have average percentage errors across maturities range from between 10% to 20% of their average levels. As we calibrate the objective function with values of \alpha less than to 1, the calibrated models imply VIX term structures with substantially smaller errors. For example, in the 10-30 DTE category, the average error of models calibrated with \alpha=0.9 is reduced by 75\% compared to models calibrated with \alpha=1 . Figure 4 : Fitted volatility smiles for OTM options on 15th of February 2023. 1 week, 2 week, 1 month, 3 month, 6 month and 12 month maturities plotted in top and middle panels. Fitted and observed VIX term structure plotted on the bottom panel. Fitted quantities are in blue and observed market implied volatilities and options market-implied VIX in green. Figure 4 shows the fit of the Bates model on February 15, 2023, a day with a typical level of spot and implied volatilities using the objective function in ( 39 ) with \alpha=0.9 . The figure plots the fitted implied volatility smiles for select maturities in panel for that day: 7 days, 14 days, 1 month, 3 months, 6 months, and 12 months to maturity. The model-implied smiles for OTM options are plotted in blue and the corresponding market implied volatility smiles are plotted in green. The 7 day model-implied smile highlights some of the weaknesses of the Bates model, namely the inability to fit the steeper volatility smiles observed in very shortest maturities. For intermediate and longer term options, the implied volatility smile fits are reasonable. In the bottom panel, I plot the model-implied VIX (blue curve) and option market-implied VIX (green points). Overall, the results from this numerical exercise suggest a relatively high value of \alpha is best for jointly calibrating the volatility surface and the term structure of the VIX. I find minimal trade-offs between fitting the observed VIX term structure and the volatility surface when calibrating the model with values of \alpha close to 1. Table 3 shows that choosing a value of \alpha close to but strictly less than 1, can calibrate complex option pricing models that simultaneously produce a quality fit to the variance term structure and option volatility surface jointly. Combining the results on the SPX panel with the results from the simulation exercise suggests a value of \alpha=0.75 or \alpha=0.9 for applied use. This is quantitatively similar to a conclusion arrived at by Andersen et al. (2015) who use an objective function that uses a regularization term penalizing deviations from spot variance and place a similarly low weight on their variance penalty term and most of the weight on errors in contract-level BSIVs. Figure 5 : One-month moving average of absolute errors between model-implied one-month VIX from Bates models calibrated using \alpha\in[0.75,0.9,1.0] and the VIX time series from CBOE. Errors for models calibrated using \alpha hyperparameters equal to 0.75, 0.9, and 1.0 are in blue, orange, and green respectively. The presence of a term penalizing deviations from a variance term structure is useful even when the model is mis-specified. This is because for values of \alpha greater than zero, the error term for the variance term structure has a regularizing effect on calibrated model’s implied variances. Figure 5 plots the absolute errors in the one-month VIX for \alpha\in\{0.75,0.9,1\} implied by Bates models calibrated on my SPX panel relative to CBOE’s published VIX. I find that the error is large in crises and becomes very large towards the end of my sample where the short-maturity segment of the SPX volatility surfaces is densely packed with short maturity weekly options. Using a value of \alpha less than but close to 1, produces a time series of substantially lower errors. 4.3 Exploring the significance of jumps Since the model can reproduce the term structure of the VIX with reasonable accuracy, I use it to examine the impact of jumps on expected variance, or equivalently the pricing of variance swaps. As discussed in section 2 , the payoff of a variance swap is the realized variance of the underlying process with the fair value of this payoff being equal to the variance swap rate. Aıt-Sahalia et al. (2020) use the gap between the VIX and the variance swap rate to examine the role of jumps in the overall price fluctuations of the S&P 500. Recall from section 2 that the magnitude of the spread reflects the skewness of the jump distribution. A positive spread indicates that the jump distribution is negatively skewed. On the right, figure 6 plots the one-month moving average of difference between the square root of the one-month maturity variance swap rate and the CBOE VIX implied by calibrated Bates models on SPX. The models were calibrated with the objective function from ( 38 ) with hyperparameter \alpha=0.9 . Note the spread is always positive, reflecting the well-known negatively skewed jump distribution of equity indices, with the spread widening during times of crisis. In figure 6 , the spread is particularly wide during the 2008-2009 financial crisis and the COVID pandemic era. A related quantity is the log contract multiplier of Carr et al. (2012) and Carr et al. (2021) computed in ( 18 ). A multiplier greater than 2 imply a negatively skewed jump distribution, with the difference between two quantifying the extent to which the jump distribution is skewed. On the left panel of figure 6 , I plot the one-month moving average time series of the log contract multiplier. The multiplier is persistently above 2, again consistent with the negatively skewed jump distribution of equity indices. In addition, how skewed the jump distribution appears to be time-varying consistent with the findings of Aıt-Sahalia et al. (2020) , peaking around the crises associated with the onset of the second Iraq war, the 2008-2009 financial crisis, and the COVID pandemic. Overall, the calibration methodology produces a model which fits the term structure of variance well, facilitating analysis of the role of jumps in the expected volatility of the market. Both the variance swap spread relative to VIX and the log contract multiplier show persistent evidence of a negatively skewed jump distribution, with spreads and multipliers widening during crises. These measures highlight that the degree of skewness is time-varying, peaking during periods of high market stress. Figure 6 : One-month moving average of log contract multiplier (left) computed using equation ( 18 ) and variance swap/VIX spread in implied volatility units (right). Quantities computed from for Bates models calibrated on the SPX volatility surface and VIX term structure with \alpha=0.9 . 5 Conclusion The calibration of option pricing models is a routine procedure across both industry practice and academic research. This article offers a calibration procedure based on an objective function which jointly considers errors in the implied volatility surface and errors in the term structure of variance. My objective function can use either the term structure of variance swap rates or the VIX as an input. The ability to use the VIX is useful for a variety of underlying assets as many underlying assets with options do not have a corresponding variance swaps market and the VIX can be readily replicated from observed option prices. The error in the variance term structure is used as a regularization term for the objective function, akin to Tikhonov regularization penalty employed in ill-posed linear regression models. As I show in an empirical exercise, this discourages parameter values which imply unreasonable levels of future volatility. The hyperparameter \alpha in this objective function governs the relative importance between fitting the variance term structure and the volatility surface. \alpha ranges from 0 to 1, with higher values placing greater emphasis on fitting the volatility surface. To provide guidance on the choice of \alpha , I conduct calibration exercises using the S&P 500 equity index option data and run simulations to examine the potential trade-offs between fit quality in the volatility surface and in the variance term structure. In practice, I find that a value around \alpha=0.9 produces parameters which fit the volatility surface well and simultaneously implies option prices which can be reconciled with the variance term structure implied by the market. While there exists a trade-off between fitting the term structure of variance and the volatility surface, the numerical exercises in section 4 suggest this trade-off is minimal for certain ranges for \alpha . For this reason, a value of \alpha between 0.5 and 0.9 is recommended as in empirical settings provided an option pricing model of reasonable flexibility is chosen for calibration. 6 Appendix: Proofs Proof of proposition 1: Since the market is free of arbitrage, the price of a time T maturity swap, VS(T;\lambda,J) , for an underlying following a SJD process with jump size J and jump intensity \lambda is pinned down by the expectation of the quadratic variation as in ( 4 ) under the pricing measure. That is, VS(T;\lambda,J)=\mathbb{E}\left[QV(\tau)|\lambda,J\right]=\mathbb{E}\left[\int_{0}^{\tau}\left(d\log S_{t}\right)^{2}=\int_{0}^{\tau}V_{t}dt+\int_{0}^{\tau}\int_{\mathbb{R}}J^{2}\nu(ds,dx)\Big|\lambda,J\right] where \mathbb{E}(\cdot|\lambda,J) is the expectation taken over the pricing measure induced by the jump parameters and the known diffusive volatility \sigma . The computation of the expectation of each integral in the sum is straightforward yielding: VS(T;\lambda,J)=\sigma^{2}+\lambda J^{2} Both \lambda\neq 0 and J\neq 0 by assumption, permitting rearrangement of the variance swap price which defines a relationship that must hold between the jump parameters: \lambda=\dfrac{VS(T;\lambda,J)-\sigma^{2}}{J^{2}} Since the variance swap is priced under the true parameters \lambda^{*} and J^{*} , the function \lambda(J) is observable: \lambda(J)=\dfrac{VS(T;\lambda^{*},J^{*})-\sigma^{2}}{J^{2}} Therefore, we can substitute for \lambda the expression above in the summation being minimized in ( 26 ), converting the bivariate problem in ( 26 ) into the univariate problem in ( 27 ). ∎ Proof of proposition 2: Since the market is free of arbitrage and OTM option prices are observed, VIX^{2}(T;\lambda^{*},J^{*}) is observable via static replication: VIX^{2}(T;\lambda^{*},J^{*})=\dfrac{2}{T}\left[\int_{0}^{S_{0}}\dfrac{P^{SJD}(K;\lambda^{*},J^{*})}{K^{2}}\,dK+\int_{S_{0}}^{\infty}\dfrac{C^{SJD}(K;\lambda^{*},J^{*})}{K^{2}}\,dK\right] Equation ( 21 ) relates VIX^{2}(T) to the variance swap price VS(T) under the true parameters: VS(T;\lambda^{*},J^{*})-VIX^{2}(T;\lambda^{*},J^{*})=2\lambda^{*}(1+J^{*}-e^{J^{*}}) Although we do not observe the variance swap price, we may write its no arbitrage price in terms of the unobserved jump parameters. Substituting the variance swap price from the proof of proposition 1, we have: \sigma^{2}+\lambda J^{2}-VIX^{2}(T;\lambda^{*},J^{*})=2\lambda(1+J-e^{J}) Rearranging yields an observable function \lambda(J) which must hold in the absence of arbitrage: \lambda=\dfrac{VIX^{2}(T;\lambda^{*},J^{*})-\sigma^{2}}{2(1+J-e^{J})} Therefore, we can substitute for \lambda the expression above in the summation being minimized in ( 30 ), converting the bivariate problem in ( 30 ) into the univariate problem in ( 31 ). ∎ Proof of proposition 3: If the model is correctly specified, that is, the underlying price process follows the stochastic process in ( 32 ), it is clear that \Theta^{*} solves the minimization problem in ( 34 ). This is holds as the minimum of any linear combination of squared terms with non-negative coefficients is attained at zero when \Theta=\Theta^{*} . For each term in the sum of ( 34 ) with non-negative weight w_{i,j} , we have: w_{i,j}\left[\sigma(K_{i},\tau_{j};\Theta)-\sigma^{mkt}(K_{i},\tau_{j})\right]^{2}=0 for all i,j when evaluated at \Theta=\Theta^{*} . Likewise, at \Theta=\Theta^{*} , g^{VS}(\Theta)=0 and g^{VIX}(\Theta)=0 for any non-negative constants w^{v}_{j} by similar reasoning. To show that the objective function is observable, first consider the objective in ( 37 ) when g(\Theta)=g^{VS}(\Theta) and variance swap rates are observed. It is clear that the sum of squared errors in contract implied volatilities is observable. The model-implied variance swap rates are observable given the parameter vector \Theta by computing the following expectation of the quadratic variation: VS(\tau_{j};\Theta)=\mathbb{E}\left[QV(\tau_{j})|\Theta\right]=\dfrac{1}{\tau}\mathbb{E}\left[\int_{0}^{\tau}V_{t}dt+\int_{0}^{\tau}\int_{\mathbb{R}}J^{2}\nu(ds,dx)\Big|\Theta\right] where \mathbb{E}\left(\cdot|\Theta\right) is the expectation over the pricing measure induced by the parameter vector \Theta . Since market variance swap rates VS^{mkt}(\tau_{j}) are observable, each term in the sum of g^{VS}(\Theta) is observable: w_{j}^{v}\left[VS(\tau_{j};\Theta)-VS^{mkt}(\tau_{j})\right]^{2} Thus, both summations in the objective function below are observable and do not require the S_{t} to be the true data generating process:. \sum\limits_{j=1}^{M}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N(\tau_{j})}w_{i,j}\left[\sigma(K_{i},\tau_{j};\Theta)-\sigma^{mkt}(K_{i},\tau_{j})\right]^{2}+g^{VS}(\Theta) To show that the objective function is observable when only option prices are observable, it suffices to show g^{VIX}(\Theta) is observable since, as before, the sum of squared errors in contract implied volatilities is observable. Let C^{mkt}(K,\tau) and P^{mkt}(K,\tau) denote the market prices of put and call options with strike K and time to maturity \tau . Since the market is free of arbitrage and OTM option prices are observed, VIX^{mkt}(\tau_{j}) is recovered from market option prices via static replication: \left[VIX^{mkt}(\tau_{j})\right]^{2}=\dfrac{2}{\tau_{j}}\left[\int_{0}^{S_{0}}\dfrac{P^{mkt}(K,\tau_{j})}{K^{2}}\,dK+\int_{S_{0}}^{\infty}\dfrac{C^{mkt}(K,\tau_{j})}{K^{2}}\,dK\right] for each \tau_{j}\in\{\tau_{1},\ldots,\tau_{M}\} . Given the model parameter \Theta , which in turn specifies the product jump measure and variance process, the quantity VIX^{2}(\tau_{j};\Theta) can be computed from the stochastic differential equation of the underlying. As shown by Aıt-Sahalia et al. (2020) , we can write the difference between the model-implied variance swap price and the model-implied VIX as follows: VS(\tau_{j};\Theta)-VIX^{2}(\tau_{j};\Theta)=2\lambda\mathbb{E}(1+J+J^{2}/2-e^{J}|\Theta) where \lambda=\mathbb{E}\left[\int_{0}^{\tau_{j}}\lambda_{t}\,dt|\Theta\right]/\tau_{j} . Since both \mathbb{E}\left[QV(\tau_{j})|\Theta\right] and 2\lambda\mathbb{E}(1+J+J^{2}/2-e^{J}|\Theta) are computable from the model, VIX^{2}(\tau_{j};\Theta) is observable. Therefore, g^{VIX}(\Theta) is observable as each term in the summation in ( 35 ): w^{v}_{j}\left[VIX(\tau_{j};\Theta)-VIX^{mkt}(\tau_{j})\right]^{2} is observable to the econometrician. Thus, the objective function below is observable whenever option prices are observed with the objective function being observable whether or not the variance swap term structure is observed. \sum\limits_{j=1}^{M}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{N(\tau_{j})}w_{i,j}\left[\sigma(K_{i},\tau_{j};\Theta)-\sigma^{mkt}(K_{i},\tau_{j})\right]^{2}+g^{VIX}(\Theta) ∎