Random-effects meta-analysis via generalized linear mixed models: A Bartlett-corrected approach for few studies Keisuke Hanada, Tomoyuki Sugimoto Abstract Random-effects meta-analysis is widely used for synthesizing results across studies, but the implicit assumption of normality in study-specific aggregate data is often violated. Such violations can lead to biased estimates and misleading conclusions, especially in meta-analyses with small studies or rare events. A prominent example occurs with the log-odds ratio, which exhibits bias that depends on the within-study sample sizes. We first show that conventional methods assuming normality fail to eliminate such biases, even as the number of studies increases. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a generalized linear mixed-effects model that uses only aggregate data, accommodating a wide range of outcome types, including binomial, Poisson, gamma, and other members of the exponential family, without requiring individual participant data. To enable valid interval estimation when the number of studies is small, we further propose a simple Bartlett correction for the test statistics. The proposed method yields consistent point estimators without relying on the normality assumption and achieves accurate interval coverage across diverse outcome types. It is particularly applicable in clinical and epidemiological research where only summary data are available, making it a practical alternative to conventional approaches. Simulation studies and applications to three published meta-analyses with binary, Poisson, and gamma outcomes demonstrate that the method provides reliable inference and maintains nominal coverage, thereby supporting sound decision-making and guideline development when only aggregate data are available. Keywords Bartlett correction, few studies, generalized linear model, meta-analysis, random-effects model. 1 Introduction The random-effects model, commonly used to account for between-study heterogeneity when synthesizing results across studies, is often implemented using the method proposed by DerSimonian and Laird 1986 . This approach is simple and easy to implement, but it implicitly relies on three within-study normality assumptions: (A1) the estimated effect in each study is unbiased; (A2) the within-study variance is known; and (A3) the estimated effect follows a normal distribution ( Jackson and White 2018 ) . A well-known example, where these assumptions are violated, is meta-analysis using the log-odds ratio as the outcome. In particular, when rare events are involved, the log-odds ratio estimator exhibits bias that depends on the within-study sample sizes. To address the limitations of meta-analysis under the normality assumption for biased effect measures, previous studies have proposed generalized linear mixed models (GLMM) that assume binomial distributions for event counts or their extensions ( Stijnen et al. 2010 ; Bhaumik et al. 2012 ; Jackson et al. 2018 ) . For even rarer events, Poisson regression models have also been applied ( Böhning et al. 2015 ) . These approaches avoid assumptions (A1)-(A3) by explicitly modeling the outcome distribution. However, they are limited to specific outcome types, such as event counts. The present study generalizes these methods to accommodate outcomes from any distribution within the exponential family. This extension enables consistent and asymptotically normal inference without requiring large sample sizes within each study, relying instead on an increasing number of studies. The advantage justifies including studies with small sample sizes in a meta-analysis. Such situations often arise in rare disease research, early-phase clinical trials, and subgroup analyses, where the number of participants per study is inherently limited. Another important issue in meta-analysis is that, when the number of studies is small, the variance of the average treatment effect is often underestimated. The underestimation results in confidence intervals and prediction intervals with coverage probabilities falling below the nominal level ( Li et al. 1994 ; Viechtbauer 2005 ) . Empirical studies have shown that such undercoverage occurs in meta-analyses using odds ratios or risk ratios when the number of studies is small ( Seide et al. 2019 ) , and similar degradation in performance has been observed in the GLMM. Under the normality assumptions (A1)–(A3), several methods have been proposed to construct confidence and prediction intervals that achieve nominal levels ( Michael et al. 2019 ; Nagashima et al. 2019 ; Hanada and Sugimoto 2023 ) . Among these methods, the Bartlett correction for profile likelihood estimators is known to yield conservative intervals, regardless of the magnitude of heterogeneity ( Noma 2011 ) . However, when biased effect measures such as the log-odds ratio are used, the coverage probability can be further compromised due to the presence of bias. The Bartlett correction improves the approximation accuracy of the profile likelihood ratio statistic from O(K^{-1}) to O(K^{-2}) , and is especially effective when the number of studies K is small ( Barndorff-Nielsen and Hall 1988 ) . However, the Bartlett correction requires third- and fourth-order derivatives of the profile likelihood, which are often difficult to compute in GLMMs due to parameter transformations via link functions. To avoid the complex calculation of higher-order derivatives, bootstrap-based estimation of the Bartlett correction term has been proposed and applied to network meta-analysis ( Rocke 1989 ; Noma et al. 2018 ) . However, this approach involves repeated optimization of the profile likelihood across bootstrap samples, leading to a substantial computational burden. The present study shows that the Bartlett correction term derived under the normality assumptions by Noma 2011 can be effectively applied within the GLMM framework in many practical settings. This simple Bartlett correction requires only a single optimization of the profile likelihood and yields interval estimates with nominal coverage, even when the number of studies is small. The main contributions of the present study are as follows: (i) to mathematically clarify the limitations that arise under the normality assumptions (A1)–(A3); (ii) to establish that, when individual participant data follow a distribution in the exponential family, the corresponding aggregate data also follow a distribution in the exponential family, thereby allowing parameter estimation using only aggregate data; (iii) to propose a profile likelihood approach with simplified Bartlett correction (PLSBC), which applies the Bartlett correction originally developed under the normal-normal model, and to demonstrate its validity both theoretically and through simulations. The resulting confidence intervals achieve nominal coverage regardless of the number of studies or the magnitude of between-study heterogeneity. The proposed method is implemented in the R package metaGLMM , which is publicly available at https://github.com/keisuke-hanada/metaGLMM . The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents the methodology of meta-analysis under the normality assumptions (A1)–(A3) and shows that, violations of these assumptions can result in biased inference and lead to the rejection of incorrect null hypotheses. Section 3 introduces a GLMM in which individual outcomes follow a distribution in the exponential family. Based on this framework, we propose a maximum likelihood estimation procedure using only aggregate data, along with a profile likelihood-based interval estimation method incorporating a simplified Bartlett correction. Section 4 evaluates the performance of the proposed method through simulations under representative exponential family models and compares it with existing methods based on the normality assumptions. Section 5 applies the proposed method to reanalyze three published meta-analyses involving binary, Poisson, and gamma outcomes. Finally, Section 6 summarizes the findings and discusses directions for future research. 2 Meta-analysis under the normality assumption Let K denote the number of studies included in the meta-analysis, and n_{k} be the number of subjects in study k . Suppose that heterogeneity across the K studies is captured by random effects V_{1},\dots,V_{K} , which are assumed to have a probability density function f_{V}(\cdot;\tau^{2}) with zero mean and variance \tau^{2} , and v_{1},\dots,v_{K} are the realizations of V_{1},\dots,V_{K} . 2.1 Individual participant data under the normal assumption Let Y_{ki} denote the outcome of subject i (=1,\ldots,n_{k}) in study k (=1,\ldots,K) , and that Y_{k1},\dots,Y_{kn_{k}} are independently and identically distributed within the same study. For each subject i in study k , we assume that the outcome model \displaystyle\mu_{k} \displaystyle=E[Y_{ki}\mid V_{k}=v_{k}],\quad\theta_{k}=g(\mu_{k})={\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k}, (1) where the mean \mu_{k} of outcomes in study k is formulated by the conditional expectation given the study heterogeneity v_{k} , and {\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}=(x_{k1},\dots,x_{kp})^{T} is a p -dimensional covariate vector for study k . The function g(\cdot) is a link function for connecting the study mean \mu_{k} with the linear predictor \theta_{k} , which can be analyzed statistically via a regression model. The coefficient vector {\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}=(\beta_{1},\dots,\beta_{p})^{T} in the linear predictor specifies the effect of the study-level covariates. Although the canonical link function is often used due to its natural connection to the exponential family, any one-to-one link function is theoretically admissible. For example, the identity link g(\mu_{k})=\mu_{k} is canonical for normal outcomes; the logit link g(\mu_{k})=\mathrm{logit}(\mu_{k}) for binomial outcomes; and the inverse link g(\mu_{k})=1/\mu_{k} is canonical for gamma outcomes, although the log link g(\mu_{k})=\log\mu_{k} is commonly used in practice for numerical stability. In standard analyses using individual participant data, covariates are observed for each individual. In contrast, meta-analysis typically uses only aggregate data for each study. We assume that a common covariate vector {\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k} is available for each study k . Examples of such study-level covariates include the average age, gender ratio, and year of the study; specific cases are described in Section 5 . In this setting, given the study-level covariates {\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k} , individual-level observations (y_{k1},\dots,y_{kn_{k}}) are independently and identically sampled from the outcome model ( 1 ). At the meta-analysis stage, the available information typically includes the sample size n_{k} , the sample mean \bar{y}_{k}=n_{k}^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{k}}y_{ki} , the estimate \hat{\theta}_{k}=g(\bar{y}_{k}) of \theta_{k} , the variance estimate \hat{\sigma}_{k}^{2} of \hat{\theta}_{k} , and the study-level covariates {\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k} . In meta-analysis assuming normality, the following three conditions are implicitly required ( Jackson et al. 2018 ) : (A1) \hat{\theta}_{k} is an unbiased estimator: E[\hat{\theta}_{k}\mid V_{k}=v_{k}]=\theta_{k}={\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k} . (A2) The within-study variance \sigma_{k}^{2} is known. (A3) \hat{\theta}_{k} is normally distributed given V_{k}=v_{k} : \hat{\theta}_{k}\mid V_{k}=v_{k}\sim N(\theta_{k},\sigma_{k}^{2}) . Although these assumptions rarely hold exactly, they are often considered reasonable due to the asymptotic normality of \hat{\theta}_{k} ( DerSimonian and Laird 1986 ) . For example, when \hat{\theta}_{k} is the sample mean, i.e., \hat{\theta}_{k}=n_{k}^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{k}}y_{ki} , normality assumptions (A1)–(A3) are satisfied if all n_{1},\dots,n_{K} are sufficiently large. However, the assumption that all studies have sufficiently large sample sizes implicitly discourages the inclusion of those with small sample sizes in a meta-analysis. Therefore, it is necessary to have a meta-analysis whose theoretical validity is ensured solely by an increasing number of studies or by an increasing total sample size. 2.2 Random-effects meta-analysis with the normal assumption To simplify the discussion in this section, we consider the setting of univariate meta-analysis, where p=1 , {\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}=1 , and {\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}=\theta^{*} . Under assumptions (A1)–(A3), and assuming that the random effects are normally distributed as V_{k}\sim N(0,\tau^{2}) , ( 1 ) can be written as the marginal model of estimator \hat{\theta}_{k} : \displaystyle\hat{\theta}_{k} \displaystyle\sim N(\theta^{*},\sigma_{k}^{2}+\tau^{2}). (2) We refer to model ( 2 ) as the normal-normal model . Under the normal-normal model, the average treatment effect \theta^{*} can be estimated by the weighted mean \displaystyle\hat{\theta} \displaystyle=\frac{\sum_{k=1}^{K}w_{k}(\tau^{2})\hat{\theta}_{k}}{\sum_{k=1}^{K}w_{k}(\tau^{2})}, (3) where w_{k}(\tau^{2})=1/(\sigma_{k}^{2}+\tau^{2}) . Under the normal-normal model, ( 3 ) is unbiased and the maximum likelihood estimator. A Wald-type test statistic for testing the hypothesis H_{0}:\theta=\theta_{0} is given by \displaystyle T_{K}(\theta) \displaystyle=\frac{\sum_{k=1}^{K}w_{k}(\tau^{2})(\hat{\theta}_{k}-\theta_{0})}{\sqrt{\sum_{k=1}^{K}w_{k}(\tau^{2})}}\sim N\left((\theta^{*}-\theta_{0})\sqrt{\sum_{k=1}^{K}w_{k}(\tau^{2})},1\right). However, the estimator \hat{\theta}_{k} may be biased depending on how it is constructed. A representative example is the log odds ratio ( Bhaumik et al. 2012 ) . Example 1 (Bias of the log odds ratio) . Suppose Y_{j}\sim B(n_{j},p_{j}) with \mathrm{logit}(p_{j})=\mu+j\theta for j=0,1 . Then, the log odds ratio with continuity correction parameter a\in[0,1] is defined by \displaystyle\log\mathrm{OR}_{a} \displaystyle=\log\frac{Y_{1}+a}{n_{1}-Y_{1}+a}-\log\frac{Y_{0}+a}{n_{0}-Y_{0}+a}, and its expectation is given by \displaystyle E[\log\mathrm{OR}_{a}] \displaystyle=\theta+\left(\frac{\frac{1}{2}-a}{n_{1}}\right)(e^{\mu+\theta}-e^{-\mu-\theta})-\left(\frac{\frac{1}{2}-a}{n_{0}}\right)(e^{\mu}-e^{-\mu})+O(n^{-2}), where n=\min(n_{0},n_{1}) . When a=0 , the bias term b_{k} is given by \displaystyle b_{k}=\frac{e^{\mu+\theta}-e^{-\mu-\theta}}{2n_{1}}-\frac{e^{\mu}-e^{-\mu}}{2n_{0}}+O(n^{-2}). The result indicates that a nonlinear transformation of the outcome can induce bias in the expectation of the estimator. Taking the presence of bias into account, we reformulate model ( 2 ) as \displaystyle\hat{\theta}_{k}=\tilde{\theta}_{k}+b_{k},\quad\tilde{\theta}_{k}\sim N(\theta^{*},\sigma_{k}^{2}+\tau^{2}),\quad b_{k}=\frac{c_{k}}{n_{k}^{r}}=O(n^{-r}),~~~r>0, (4) where c_{k} is a constant, and n_{k}=na_{k} with \sum_{k=1}^{K}a_{k}=1 and a_{k}>0 . In the model ( 4 ), the bias b_{k} decreases as the within-study sample size n_{k} increases, but does not diminish with the number of studies K . Thus, even if only one study has a small n_{k} , the overall bias in \hat{\theta} does not vanish and cannot be corrected by increasing the number of studies. The following proposition highlights the necessity of assumption (A1) in meta-analysis under the normal-normal model. Proposition 1 . Assume model ( 4 ) holds for \hat{\theta}_{k} , \tilde{\theta}_{k} , and b_{k} . Then, the estimator \hat{\theta} defined in ( 3 ) satisfies \displaystyle\hat{\theta} \displaystyle=\theta^{*}+\frac{C_{K}}{n^{r}}+o_{p}(1)\quad\text{as }K\to\infty, and for the true null hypothesis H_{0}\!:\theta=\theta^{*} , the test statistic satisfies \displaystyle P\big(|T_{K}(\theta^{*})|>z_{a}\big)\to 1\quad\text{as }K\to\infty, where C_{K}=\left\{\sum_{k=1}^{K}w_{k}(\tau^{2})c_{k}/a_{k}^{-r}\right\}\left/\left\{\sum_{k=1}^{K}w_{k}(\tau^{2})\right\}\right. and z_{a} is the upper 100a\% quantile of the standard normal distribution. This proof is provided in Appendix A.1 . This result shows that when the study-specific summary statistics \hat{\theta}_{k} are biased (i.e., assumption (A1) is violated), such bias cannot be eliminated under the normal-normal model. As a practical implication, when including studies with limited sample sizes or effect measures subject to substantial bias, conventional random-effects meta-analysis may not guarantee valid inference and may instead promote the rejection of a true null hypothesis. 3 Random-effects meta-analysis under the generalized linear mixed model 3.1 Expansion to exponential family For outcomes involving nonlinear transformations, such as the log odds ratio, meta-analysis based on the normal-normal model may suffer from bias, as demonstrated in Proposition 1 . To reduce the bias, we consider a model that is consistent with the assumed outcome distribution in each study. When individual participant data are available, the likelihood function for study k is given by \displaystyle L_{k}({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2})=\int_{\Omega}\left\{\prod_{i=1}^{n_{k}}f_{Y}(y_{ki};{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},v_{k})\right\}f_{V}(v_{k};\tau^{2})\,dv_{k}, (5) where f_{Y}(\cdot) denotes the density (or probability mass) function of the outcome Y , and \Omega is the support of the random effect V_{k} . In general, we require access to the individual-level observations y_{ki} in estimation of \beta based on the likelihood ( 5 ). In aggregate data meta-analysis, the individual-level observations are unavailable, and thus the estimator in equation ( 3 ) is commonly used. As shown in Proposition 1 , however, this estimator cannot eliminate the bias in \hat{\theta}_{k} , even as the number of studies increases. We consider the case in which the outcome follows a generalized linear mixed model (GLMM). Assuming that the distribution of Y_{ki} belongs to the exponential family, its density function can be expressed as \displaystyle f_{Y}(y_{ki};{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},v_{k})=\exp\left(\frac{y_{ki}({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k})-b({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k})}{a(\varphi_{k})}+c(y_{ki},\varphi_{k})\right), (6) where \varphi_{k} is the dispersion parameter, a(\varphi_{k}) and b({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k}) are known functions specific to the distribution, and c(y_{ki},\varphi_{k}) is the normalizing function. Although individual outcomes y_{ki} are typically not available in practice, the study-level mean \bar{y}_{k} is usually reported. Since \bar{y}_{k} is a realization from an exponential family distribution conditional on V_{k}=v_{k} , and the density f_{V} of the random effect does not include y_{ki} and x_{k} , we have the following result: Lemma 1 . Suppose that Y_{ki} follows the exponential family distribution ( 6 ) and that V_{k} has the density f_{V}(\cdot;\tau^{2}) . Then, given ({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{1},\dots,{\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{K}) , the vector (\bar{y}_{1},\dots,\bar{y}_{K}) is a sufficient statistic for the parameters ({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2}) , and the likelihood function for study k can be written as \displaystyle L_{k}({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2};\bar{y}_{k},{\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k},\varphi_{k}) \displaystyle=\left(\prod_{i=1}^{n_{k}}e^{c(y_{ki},\varphi_{k})}\right)\int_{\Omega}\left\{\exp\left(\frac{n_{k}(\bar{y}_{k}({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k})-b({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k}))}{a(\varphi_{k})}\right)\right\}f_{V}(v_{k};\tau^{2})dv_{k}. (7) This proof is provided in Appendix A.2 . Lemma 1 implies that if Y_{ki} follows a distribution in the exponential family, then the parameters ({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2}) can be estimated using only the study-level means \bar{y}_{k} , even when the individual-level observations y_{ki} are unavailable. Under the normal-normal model, the likelihood function in equation ( 7 ) has a closed-form expression. In contrast, when the individual-level outcomes follow an exponential family distribution, the likelihood involves an intractable integral that must be approximated numerically. Common numerical integration techniques include the Laplace approximation, adaptive Gaussian-Hermite quadrature, and penalized quasi-likelihood ( Ju et al. 2020 ) . Among these techniques, Gaussian-Hermite quadrature and Laplace approximation allow fast computation. However, maintaining accuracy of the integration over the entire domain \Omega for arbitrary values of \tau^{2} requires adaptively adjusting the integration region, which can be computationally expensive if performed separately for each study. A simpler numerical approach is Monte Carlo integration. That is, \displaystyle\log L_{k}({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2};\bar{y}_{k},{\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k},\varphi_{k}) \displaystyle\propto\log\int_{\Omega}\exp\left(\frac{n_{k}\left(\bar{y}_{k}({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k})-b({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k})\right)}{a(\varphi_{k})}\right)f_{V}(v_{k};\tau^{2})\,dv_{k} \displaystyle\approx\log\frac{1}{B}\sum_{b=1}^{B}\exp\left(\frac{n_{k}\left(\bar{y}_{k}({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v^{(b)})-b({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v^{(b)})\right)}{a(\varphi_{k})}\right), (8) where the integration over v_{k} is independent across studies. A single set of samples v^{(1)},\dots,v^{(B)} can be independently drawn from f_{V}(\cdot;\tau^{2}) and shared across all K studies for numerical integration. Monte Carlo integration achieves a convergence rate of O(B^{-1/2}) , but the repeated likelihood evaluations required for profile likelihood estimation result in a substantial computational burden. To reduce the computational burden, we improve the convergence rate to O(B^{-1}\log B) by using quasi-Monte Carlo integration ( Sobol and Asotsky 2003 ) . In quasi-Monte Carlo methods, a low-discrepancy sequence (u_{1},\dots,u_{B})\in[0,1]^{B} is generated, and the samples of random effects are obtained as v^{(b)}=F_{V}^{-1}(u_{b}) , where F_{V}^{-1} denotes the quantile function of V . The parameters ({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2}) can be estimated by MLE (\hat{{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}},\hat{\tau}^{2}) based on the likelihood ( 3.1 ), where \displaystyle(\hat{{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}},\hat{\tau}^{2})=\mathop{\rm arg~max}\limits_{({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2})}\log L({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2}), (9) and L({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2})=\prod_{k=1}^{K}L_{k}({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2}) . Although this optimization does not admit a closed-form solution, it can be computed numerically using only the study-level data \{n_{k},\bar{y}_{k},x_{k},\varphi_{k}\}_{k=1,\dots,K} , without requiring access to individual-level data. Moreover, because the estimator ( 9 ) relies on the same likelihood as that based on the full individual participant data, the estimator inherits the consistency and asymptotic normality properties under standard regularity conditions ( Hoadley 1971 ; Philippou and Roussas 1975 ) . This approach retains the consistency and asymptotic normality properties of maximum likelihood estimation without requiring large sample sizes in individual studies. It therefore enables reliable inference even for studies with small sample sizes or effect measures involving nonlinear transformations, provided that the number of studies or the total sample size increases. 3.2 Profile likelihood interval estimation with simple Bartlett correction When the number of studies is small, it is well known that the between-study variance tends to be underestimated. In the normal-normal model, restricted maximum likelihood estimation is often used to mitigate this underestimation of \tau^{2} . However, for interval estimation of \beta , the variance of \hat{{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}} also tends to be underestimated. As a result, the confidence intervals based on normal approximation become overly narrow. A more reliable approach for constructing confidence intervals is the profile likelihood method. Let \beta_{\ell} denote the parameter of interest, and define the vector {\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}(b_{\ell})=(\beta_{0},\dots,\beta_{\ell-1},b_{\ell},\beta_{\ell+1},\dots,\beta_{p}) . The profile likelihood ratio statistic is asymptotically chi-squared distributed as follows: \displaystyle T(\beta_{\ell}^{0}) \displaystyle=-2\left\{\log L(\hat{{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}}(\beta_{\ell}^{0}),\tilde{\tau}^{2}(\beta_{\ell}^{0}))-\log L(\hat{{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}},\hat{\tau}^{2})\right\}\xrightarrow{d}\chi^{2}_{1}\quad(K\to\infty), where \chi^{2}_{1} denotes the chi-squared distribution with one degree of freedom, \xrightarrow{d} denotes convergence in distribution, and the constrained maximum likelihood (CML) estimates under the constraint \beta_{\ell}=\beta_{\ell}^{0} are obtained as \displaystyle(\hat{{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}}(\beta_{\ell}^{0}),\tilde{\tau}^{2}(\beta_{\ell}^{0})) \displaystyle=\mathop{\rm arg~max}\limits_{(\beta_{0},\dots,\beta_{\ell-1},\beta_{\ell+1},\dots,\beta_{p},\tau^{2})}\log L({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}(\beta_{\ell}^{0}),\tau^{2}). Using the asymptotic chi-squared approximation of the profile likelihood, the resulting confidence interval attains the nominal coverage level when the number of studies is sufficiently large. However, in small-sample settings, such as when K=5 , the nominal level may not be maintained. In such cases, conservative interval estimation based on the Bartlett correction, which improves the approximation error of the chi-squared distribution for T(\beta_{\ell}^{0}) from O(K^{-1}) to O(K^{-2}) , is useful ( Noma 2011 ) . Let T^{*}(\beta_{\ell}^{0}) denote the Bartlett-corrected version of T(\beta_{\ell}^{0}) , defined as \displaystyle T^{*}(\beta_{\ell}^{0})=\frac{T(\beta_{\ell}^{0})}{1+2C^{*}(\beta_{\ell}^{0})}. The correction term C^{*}(\beta_{\ell}^{0}) is given by (equation (4) in Lawley 1956 ) \displaystyle C^{*}(\beta_{\ell})=\frac{1}{2K}\left\{l_{2}^{-2}\left(\frac{1}{4}l_{4}-l_{31}+l_{22}\right)-l_{2}^{-3}\left(\frac{5}{12}l_{3}^{2}-2l_{3}l_{21}+2l_{21}^{2}\right)\right\}, where \displaystyle l_{r} \displaystyle=E\left[\frac{\partial^{r}l}{\partial\beta_{\ell}^{r}}\right],\quad l_{rs}=\frac{\partial^{s}l_{r}}{\partial\beta_{\ell}^{s}},\quad l(\beta_{\ell})=\sum_{k=1}^{K}\log L_{k}(\hat{{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}}(\beta_{\ell}),\tilde{\tau}^{2}),\quad r=1,2,3,4,\quad s=1,2. Since computing C^{*}(\beta_{\ell}) requires the third- and fourth-order derivatives of the log-likelihood function, it is difficult to evaluate analytically when L({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2}) involves an integral. Therefore, we consider an approximate Bartlett correction using the correction term C(\beta_{\ell}^{0}) derived under the normal-normal model ( Noma 2011 ) : \displaystyle C(\beta_{\ell}^{0})=\frac{\sum_{k=1}^{K}(\sigma_{k}^{2}+\tilde{\tau}^{2})^{-3}}{\left\{\sum_{k=1}^{K}(\sigma_{k}^{2}+\tilde{\tau}^{2})^{-1}\right\}\left\{\sum_{k=1}^{K}(\sigma_{k}^{2}+\tilde{\tau}^{2})^{-2}\right\}}. Using this expression, we define an approximate Bartlett-corrected likelihood ratio statistic as \displaystyle\tilde{T}(\beta_{\ell}^{0})=\frac{T(\beta_{\ell}^{0})}{1+2C(\beta_{\ell}^{0})}. Since C(\beta_{\ell}^{0})>0 , this correction yields more conservative interval estimates than those based directly on T(\beta_{\ell}^{0}) , and improves the asymptotic behavior with respect to the number of studies. However, this correction still relies on the asymptotic normality that results from increasing the within-study sample sizes. Accordingly, for the number of studies K and the within-study sample sizes n_{1},\dots,n_{K} , the following result holds: Theorem 1 . Suppose that Y_{ki} follows the exponential family distribution ( 6 ) and v_{1},\dots,v_{K}\sim N(0,\tau^{2}) . Then, for any \beta_{\ell}=\beta_{\ell}^{0} , \displaystyle\tilde{T}(\beta_{\ell}^{0}) \displaystyle=T^{*}(\beta_{\ell}^{0})+O_{p}(n^{-1/2})=\chi_{1}^{2}+O_{p}(n^{-1/2}+K^{-2}). This proof is provided in Appendix A.3 . Therefore, the 100(1-\alpha)\% confidence interval for \beta_{\ell} is defined as the region satisfying \displaystyle\tilde{T}(\beta_{\ell})\leq q_{\chi^{2}_{1},\alpha}, where q_{\chi^{2}_{1},a} denotes the upper 100a\% quantile of the chi-squared distribution with one degree of freedom. In the case of the normal-normal model, C^{*}(\beta_{\ell}^{0})=C(\beta_{\ell}^{0}) holds, and hence \tilde{T}(\beta_{\ell}^{0})=\chi^{2}_{1}+O(K^{-2}) . In this setting, the chi-squared approximation improves as the number of studies increases, regardless of the within-study sample sizes. Another advantage of using C(\beta_{\ell}^{0}) is that it always satisfies C(\beta_{\ell}^{0})>0 , which implies \tilde{T}(\beta_{\ell}^{0})0 , we have P(|T_{K}|>c\mid\theta^{*})\to 1\quad\text{as }K\to\infty. In particular, for c=z_{\alpha/2} , which is a finite constant, it follows that P(|T_{K}|>z_{\alpha/2}\mid\theta^{*})\to 1\quad\text{as }K\to\infty. ∎ A.2 Proof of Lemma 1 Proof. The likelihood function conditional on fixed V_{k}=v_{k} can be expanded as follows: \displaystyle L_{k}({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}};y_{k1},\dots,y_{kn_{k}},{\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k},v_{k},\varphi_{k}) \displaystyle=\prod_{i=1}^{n_{k}}f_{Y}(y_{ki};{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},v_{k}) \displaystyle=\prod_{i=1}^{n_{k}}\exp\left(\frac{y_{ki}({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k})-b({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k})}{a(\varphi_{k})}+c(y_{ki},\varphi_{k})\right) \displaystyle=\left(\prod_{i=1}^{n_{k}}e^{c(y_{ki},\varphi_{k})}\right)\exp\left(\sum_{i=1}^{n_{k}}\frac{y_{ki}({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k})-b({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k})}{a(\varphi_{k})}\right) \displaystyle=\left(\prod_{i=1}^{n_{k}}e^{c(y_{ki},\varphi_{k})}\right)\exp\left(\frac{n_{k}(\bar{y}_{k}({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k})-b({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k}))}{a(\varphi_{k})}\right). Next, the marginal likelihood with respect to the random effect v_{k} is given by: \displaystyle L_{k}({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2}) \displaystyle=E_{v_{k}}\left[L_{k}({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}};y_{k1},\dots,y_{kn_{k}},{\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k},v_{k},\varphi_{k})\right] \displaystyle=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}L_{k}({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}};y_{k1},\dots,y_{kn_{k}},{\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k},v_{k},\varphi_{k})f_{V}(v_{k};\tau^{2})dv_{k} \displaystyle=\left(\prod_{i=1}^{n_{k}}e^{c(y_{ki},\varphi_{k})}\right)\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\left\{\exp\left(\frac{n_{k}(\bar{y}_{k}({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k})-b({\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}+v_{k}))}{a(\varphi_{k})}\right)\right\}f_{V}(v_{k};\tau^{2})dv_{k}. Because the likelihood function L_{k} can be expressed solely in terms of (\bar{y}_{1},\dots,\bar{y}_{K}) , it follows that (\bar{y}_{1},\dots,\bar{y}_{K}) is a sufficient statistic for the parameters ({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2}) . ∎ A.3 Proof of Theorem 1 Proof. For the fixed \beta_{\ell} , we have \displaystyle|\tilde{T}(\beta_{\ell})-T^{*}(\beta_{\ell})| \displaystyle=\left|\frac{T(\beta_{\ell})}{1+2C(\beta_{\ell})}-\frac{T(\beta_{\ell})}{1+2C^{*}(\beta_{\ell})}\right| \displaystyle=\left|\frac{T(\beta_{\ell})}{1+2C^{*}(\beta_{\ell})}\frac{1+2C^{*}(\beta_{\ell})}{1+2C(\beta_{\ell})}-\frac{T(\beta_{\ell})}{1+2C^{*}(\beta_{\ell})}\right| \displaystyle\leq\left|\frac{2T(\beta_{\ell})}{(1+2C^{*}(\beta_{\ell}))(1+2C(\beta_{\ell}))}\right|\left|C^{*}(\beta_{\ell})-C(\beta_{\ell})\right| \displaystyle=M_{1}\left|C^{*}(\beta_{\ell})-C(\beta_{\ell})\right|, where \displaystyle M_{1} \displaystyle=\left|\frac{2T(\beta_{\ell})}{(1+2C^{*}(\beta_{\ell}))(1+2C(\beta_{\ell}))}\right|\leq 2|T(\beta_{\ell})|. From the theorem of Wilks 1938 , we have T(\beta_{\ell})=\chi_{1}^{2}+O_{p}(K^{-1/2}) . Then, we have M_{1}\leq 2|T(\beta_{\ell})|=2\chi_{1}^{2}+O_{p}(K^{-1/2})=O_{p}(1) . We next show \left|C^{*}(\beta_{\ell})-C(\beta_{\ell})\right|=O(n^{-1/2}) . The term of Bartlett correction is given as (equation (4) in Lawley 1956 ) \displaystyle C^{*}(\beta_{\ell}) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2K}\left\{l_{2}^{-2}\left(\frac{1}{4}l_{4}-l_{31}+l_{22}\right)-l_{2}^{-3}\left(\frac{5}{12}l_{3}^{2}-2l_{3}l_{21}+2l_{21}^{2}\right)\right\}, where \displaystyle l_{r} \displaystyle=E\left[\frac{\partial^{r}l}{\partial\beta_{\ell}^{r}}\right],~~~l_{rs}=\frac{\partial^{s}l_{r}}{\partial\beta_{\ell}^{s}},~~~r=1,2,3,4,~~s=1,2 and l(\beta_{\ell}) is the profile likelihood function for \beta_{\ell} , \displaystyle l(\beta_{\ell}) \displaystyle=\sum_{k=1}^{K}\log L_{k}(\hat{{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}}(\beta_{\ell}),\tilde{\tau}^{2}(\beta_{\ell})). Because Y is a random variable belonging to the exponential family, we have E[Y]<\infty , E[|Y|^{s}]<\infty,s=1,2,3 , and the distribution function of Y is smooth. Then, we can apply Theorem 2 in Bhattacharya et al. 1978 to L_{k} , and we have below uniform convergence as n_{k}\to\infty such that \displaystyle\log L_{k}({\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\tau^{2}) \displaystyle=\log\phi(g(\bar{y}_{k});{\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\sigma_{k}^{2}+\tau^{2})+O(n_{k}^{-1/2}), where \phi(\cdot;{\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}},\sigma_{k}^{2}+\tau^{2}) is the probability density function of normal distribution with mean {\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}} and variance \sigma_{k}^{2}+\tau^{2} . We can estimate the normal approximated log profile likelihood function of l(\beta_{\ell}) using \displaystyle\hat{l}(\beta_{\ell}) \displaystyle=\sum_{k=1}^{K}\log\phi(g(\bar{y}_{k});{\text{\boldmath$x$}}_{k}^{T}\tilde{{\text{\boldmath$\beta$}}}(\beta_{\ell}),\sigma_{k}^{2}+\tilde{\tau}^{2}(\beta_{\ell})). From the relationship between \log L_{k} and \log\phi , we have l(\beta_{\ell})=\hat{l}(\beta_{\ell})+O(n^{-1/2}) . Since l(\beta_{\ell}) and \hat{l}(\beta_{\ell}) are smooth, we have \displaystyle l_{r}^{m} \displaystyle=\hat{l}_{r}^{m}+O(n^{-1/2}),~~~l_{rs}^{m}=\hat{l}_{rs}^{m}+O(n^{-1/2}),~~~m=-3,-2,1, from the chain rule and Leibniz rule. Because C^{*} is the sum of l_{r}^{m} and l_{rs}^{m} , \displaystyle C^{*}(\beta_{\ell}) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2K}\left\{\hat{l}_{2}^{-2}\left(\frac{1}{4}\hat{l}_{4}-\hat{l}_{31}+\hat{l}_{22}\right)-\hat{l}_{2}^{-3}\left(\frac{5}{12}\hat{l}_{3}^{2}-2\hat{l}_{3}\hat{l}_{21}+2\hat{l}_{21}^{2}\right)\right\}+O(n^{-1/2}) \displaystyle=C(\beta_{\ell})+O(n^{-1/2}). Thus, for any \beta_{\ell} , there exist a constant M_{2}>0 such that \left|C^{*}(\beta_{\ell})-C(\beta_{\ell})\right|0 be the shape parameter and b>0 the scale parameter. The distribution can be reparameterized as a=1/\varphi_{k} , b=\varphi_{k}/\mu_{k} . The parameters in the density function of Y_{ki} given in ( 6 ) are specified as follows: \displaystyle\theta_{k} \displaystyle=-\frac{1}{\mu_{k}},\quad a(\varphi_{k})=\varphi_{k},\quad b(\theta_{k})=-\log(\theta_{k}),\quad c(y_{ki},\varphi_{k})=\left(\frac{1}{\varphi_{k}}-1\right)\log(y_{ki})-\frac{1}{\varphi_{k}}\log(\varphi_{k})-\log\Gamma\left(\frac{1}{\varphi_{k}}\right). With this specification, the density function is expressed as \displaystyle f_{Y}(y_{ki}) \displaystyle=\exp\left\{\frac{y_{ki}\theta_{k}+\log(\theta_{k})}{\varphi_{k}}+\left(\frac{1}{\varphi_{k}}-1\right)\log(y_{ki})-\frac{1}{\varphi_{k}}\log(\varphi_{k})-\log\Gamma\left(\frac{1}{\varphi_{k}}\right)\right\}. This corresponds to a model where the outcome follows a gamma distribution with a log link function. While the binomial and Poisson models used the canonical link, the canonical link for the gamma distribution is g(\mu_{k})=-1/\mu_{k} , which requires \mu_{k}>0 and is often numerically unstable. Therefore, we adopted the log link function. In the simulation, the dispersion parameter \varphi_{k} was set as \displaystyle\varphi_{k}=\frac{1}{3}\left(1+4\frac{k-1}{K}\right),\quad k=1,\dots,K. Since \varphi_{k} is unknown in real applications, we estimated it using the sample mean \bar{y}_{k} and variance \hat{\sigma}_{k}^{2} from each study as \hat{\varphi}_{k}=\hat{\sigma}_{k}^{2}/\bar{y}_{k}^{2} , and substituted the estimated value into f_{Y}(\cdot) .