RUBIES spectroscopically confirms the high number density of quiescent galaxies from 𝟐 < 𝐳 < 𝟓 \mathbf{2 10.3 \mathrm{log(M_{*}/M_{\odot})>10.3} ) quiescent galaxies at 2 < z < 5 2 3 z>3 , most simulations fail to produce enough massive quiescent galaxies, suggesting the treatment of feedback and/or the channels for early efficient formation are incomplete in most galaxy evolution models. I Introduction How the most massive galaxies stopped forming stars (“quenched”) remains one of the most important but mysterious questions in galaxy evolution. Evidence suggests that massive quiescent galaxies ( \mathrm{M_{*}>10^{11}M_{\odot}} ) are already in place in the first \mathrm{\sim 1\,Gyr} after the Big Bang ( Carnall et al. 2024 ; Weibel et al. 2025 ; de Graaff et al. 2025a , e.g.,) . The efficient formation channel for these early galaxies is heavily debated ( Liu & Bromm 2022 ; Dekel et al. 2023 ; Ferrara et al. 2023 , e.g.,) . Certain mechanisms must be triggered in these quiescent systems to rapidly shut down their previously efficient star formation, despite the fact that cosmic star formation density is rising in this epoch ( Madau & Dickinson 2014 , e.g.,) . Common speculations of these mechanisms include feedback from compact star formation ( Diamond-Stanic et al. 2012 ; Sell et al. 2014 , e.g.,) or from active galactic nuclei (AGN; e.g., Croton et al. 2006 ; Fabian 2012 ). These processes are capable of exhausting the central cool gas reservoir that fuels the star formation in galaxies, by either removing them mechanically through outflow, heating them to disrupt gravitational collapse, or preventing further gas accretion from the cosmic environment ( Bezanson et al. 2019 ; Whitaker et al. 2021 ; Williams et al. 2021 ; D’Eugenio et al. 2024 ; Belli et al. 2024 , e.g.,) . Historically, these mechanisms are incorporated into simulations to recreate the observed galaxy populations ( Croton et al. 2006 ; Bower et al. 2006 ; Sijacki et al. 2007 ; Lagos et al. 2008 ; Somerville et al. 2008 , e.g.,) . Since the launch of the JWST ( Gardner et al. 2006 ; Gardner et al. 2023 ) , tremendous progress has been made in selecting candidates of high redshift ( z>3 ) massive quiescent galaxies ( Carnall et al. 2023a ; Valentino et al. 2023 , e.g.,) as well as in confirming them spectroscopically ( Carnall et al. 2024 ; Nanayakkara et al. 2024 ; de Graaff et al. 2025a , e.g.,) . As these quenched objects are dominated by older stellar populations of high mass-to-light ratios, we can mitigate systematic bias in stellar mass estimation due to outshining from young ( \mathrm{<100\,Myr} old) stellar populations ( Giménez-Arteaga et al. 2023 ; Papovich et al. 2023 , e.g.,) . Moreover, the number densities of these massive quiescent systems in the early universe can place valuable constraints on our models of galaxy evolution ( De Lucia et al. 2024 ; Lagos et al. 2024 , e.g.,) , which are mostly calibrated to observations at later times ( Somerville & Davé 2015 , e.g.,) . Constrained by the age of the universe when these early massive quiescent galaxies are observed, their inferred star formation histories (SFHs) implies high or even close-to-theoretical-limit ( Carnall et al. 2024 ; Glazebrook et al. 2024 ; de Graaff et al. 2025a ; Turner et al. 2025 ) baryon conversion efficiency in the early dark matter halos, implying extreme formation efficiency. Alternatively, studies have explored how modifying inference assumptions — such as the initial mass function (IMF; e.g., van Dokkum & Conroy 2024 ) and abundance patterns ( Park et al. 2024a ; Beverage et al. 2025 , e.g.,) — can mitigate the inferred extreme stellar masses and reconstructed SFHs. Several studies have attempted to probe the number densities of the quiescent population at the earliest possible time, using photometrically selected candidates from the early JWST imaging fields ( Carnall et al. 2023a ; Valentino et al. 2023 ; Alberts et al. 2024 ; Long et al. 2024 ; Baker et al. 2025a , e.g.,) . However, the classical photometric rest-frame color selection techniques utilized successfully at z<2 ( Williams et al. 2009 ; Whitaker et al. 2011 , e.g.,) face various issues at z>3 . Firstly, photometry alone is not sufficient to break the age-dust degeneracy, which compromises the purity of color-selected quiescent samples, especially when the wavelength coverage is limited to NIRCam filters ( \lambda<4.4\mu m) ( Antwi-Danso et al. 2023 , e.g.,) . Secondly, early color selections miss the youngest (mean stellar age \mathrm{<300\,Myr} ) quiescent galaxies, which become more common at z>3 ( Belli et al. 2019 ; Baker et al. 2025b ; Park et al. 2024b , e.g.,) . Expanded color selections have been motivated to include younger quiescent galaxies ( Belli et al. 2019 ; Baker et al. 2025b , e.g.,) . Nevertheless, the range of these new photometric criteria and the available wavelength sampling create a patchwork of poorly understood selection effects and interloper populations, which could be driving the high variance in abundances measured between different surveys. Finally, photometric rest-frame colors will always be sensitive to systematic uncertainties due to photometric redshifts, which depend on the nature of the photometry. Deep near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy can more robustly confirm the quiescent nature of these high-redshift candidates. But most studies thus far have been limited to single objects or targeted follow-up of small samples ( Carnall et al. 2023b ; Carnall et al. 2024 ; Glazebrook et al. 2024 ; Onoue et al. 2024 ; Weibel et al. 2025 ; de Graaff et al. 2025a , e.g.,) . To date, only a few sizable spectroscopic samples have attempted to constrain the number density of quiescent galaxies, finding largely consistent statistics as photometric studies. Baker et al. 2025b assembled a spectroscopic sample by combining multiple early JWST observing programs. However, fully characterizing the selection function of such a sample is challenging due to the wide range of selection criteria that saw these sources placed on slits. Spectroscopic follow-up can be used to assess the purity of photometric samples; Nanayakkara et al. 2025 estimated \sim 80\% purity of their photometric parent sample, which could then be used to update initial number density estimates ( Schreiber et al. 2018 ) . However, given that the photometric sample utilizes the classical rest-frame UVJ color selection, this is likely an underestimate at z>3 ( Antwi-Danso et al. 2023 ; Long et al. 2024 , e.g.,) . Park et al. 2024b attempted a less direct but complementary method and measured the number density of quiescent galaxies at z>3 by reconstructing the formation histories of a spectroscopic sample of quiescent galaxies observed at lower redshifts z\sim 2 ( Park et al. 2024b ) . However, this approach is sensitive to the choice of model assumptions ( Carnall et al. 2019 ; Leja et al. 2019a ; Suess et al. 2022 ; Park et al. 2024a ) and will likely underestimate the true number densities due to progenitor bias. Finally, all early estimates of high redshift galaxy number densities are limited by the relatively small field of view of JWST. Therefore, cosmic variance sets a floor on the precision of this measurement (e.g., \sim 20\% , for a combined area of \mathrm{145\,arcmin^{2}} ; Valentino et al. 2023 ). These early studies of quiescent galaxy number densities at face value indicate an overabundance of quiescent galaxies at z>3 compared to predicted values from six state-of-the-art cosmological galaxy formation simulations ( Lagos et al. 2025 , e.g.,) . Given that tension exists relative to all models despite the wide variation in the implementation of the AGN feedback needed to quench massive galaxies, additional model development may be needed. However, given the known limitations in the observational measurements (e.g., due to sample purity, contamination, or cosmic variance), we must also demonstrate that this discrepancy is not caused by imprecise observational results. Thus, as we make this comparison between observed and predicted number densities, all observational studies must strive to identify quiescent galaxies that are fully representative of the full population over the largest possible area. In this paper, we present a spectroscopic census of massive quiescent galaxies at 22} ), bright ( \mathrm{F444W<27} ), or have high photometric redshifts ( \mathrm{z_{phot}>6.5} ), which were computed with EAZY ( Brammer et al. 2008 ) . The parent photometric catalog of RUBIES was derived by merging public catalogs that are available on the DAWN JWST Archive (DJA) and was visually inspected to remove invalid entries due to artifacts or pipeline errors. This catalog is used for the completeness correction described in Section IV.3 . All RUBIES spectra used in this work were reduced with msaexp 1 1 1 https://github.com/gbrammer/msaexp ( Brammer 2023a ) , corresponding to version 3 of NIRSpec data (described in detail in de Graaff et al. 2025b ) released on DJA 2 2 2 https://s3.amazonaws.com/msaexp-nirspec/extractions/nirspec_rubies_graded_v3.html ( de Graaff et al. 2024 ; Heintz et al. 2025 ) . In brief, uncalibrated exposures were taken from the Mikulski Archive for Space Telescopes (MAST) 3 3 3 All the JWST data used in this paper can be found in MAST: http://dx.doi.org/10.17909/sjsj-8p46 (catalog 10.17909/sjsj-8p46) . and processed through the Detector1Pipeline steps of the standard JWST pipeline, where a mask was inserted for large cosmic-ray snowball events ( Rigby et al. 2023 ) calculated with snowblind ( Davies 2024 ) and a 1/f correction was applied. After individual slits are identified, the 2D unrectified spectra are flat-fielded and flux-calibrated. Generally, RUBIES spectra are reduced with two different background subtraction strategies. However, not all RUBIES spectra have robust spectroscopic redshift quality (grade 3 as defined in de Graaff et al. 2025b ) in both reduction versions. In one version, the sky background is removed “locally” by taking image differences of the 2D spectra taken at the three spacecraft nod offset positions. Additionally, a second version of RUBIES spectrum reduction was implemented with a global sky subtraction, which is recommended for bright extended sources. The massive quiescent galaxies that this project aims to search for are bright and expected to be resolved. For any RUBIES spectra included in this analysis (see Section III.1 for selection criteria), we adopt the global subtraction where available (535 sources), defaulting to local background subtraction for 8 sources. Once background-subtracted, 1D spectra were optimally extracted ( Horne 1986 ) from the rectified 2D spectra (detailed description is available in Heintz et al. 2025 ). Finally, using the a priori source position within the shutter and assuming an azimuthally symmetric Gaussian profile, an effective extended-source path-loss correction for light outside the slitlet for each source is derived and applied to the spectrum. Although this work focuses on the NIRSpec/PRISM spectra as they provide homogeneous coverage of spectral information that constrains the stellar population modeling at 23 , early JWST surveys have uncovered novel extragalactic sources that are difficult to constrain by traditional spectral synthesis models, such as “Little Red Dots” (LRD) ( Greene et al. 2024 ; Matthee et al. 2024 , e.g.,) . In addition, the classical color selection of quiescent galaxies at this epoch is shown to be incomplete and impure ( Belli et al. 2019 ; Antwi-Danso et al. 2023 ; Baker et al. 2025b ; Park et al. 2024b , e.g.,) . Despite efforts to modify these color criteria, their selection effects are yet poorly understood. PCA provides a data-driven and model-independent approach for selecting and studying the properties of these sources. In this section, we explore the classification of RUBIES SEDs at 24 , each reconstructed spectrum accounts for a higher fraction of flux in the original spectrum, although this improvement becomes marginally better as n grows. At the same time, a higher number of SCs complicates the interpretation of these sources. Therefore, we choose n=4 for our subsequent analysis. The choice of SparsePCA is intended to identify eigen components corresponding to orthogonal features of the spectral continuum. In total, we identify four eigenspectra that correspond to the UV continuum slope, Balmer/ \mathrm{4000\AA} break strength, red optical continuum slope, and IR continuum slope (see Figure 1 for details). This choice allows us to intuitively connect the distribution of the galaxy population in SC space to their physical properties. Thus, we can draw empirical cuts in the SC space to separate galaxies of different spectral types. In Figure 1 , we showcase our ability to select objects of different spectral types based on their location in the SC space. The vast majority of the galaxies targeted by early public JWST/NIRSpec programs, and therefore in our PCA analysis, are star-forming galaxies (blue and purple). These sources have positive SC 0 , indicating that they possess excessive rest-frame UV flux on top of the mean spectrum. A fraction of them have a notable Balmer/ \mathrm{4000\AA} break (blue), as suggested by their slightly negative SC 2 . These galaxies have relatively evolved stellar populations and likely had stochastic SFHs ( Strait et al. 2023 ; Looser et al. 2024 ; Covelo-Paz et al. 2025 ; G. Khullar et al. in preparation). The LRDs (yellow), whose physical nature is hotly debated, reside in an isolated regime in the SC space. Since they are typically characterized by their unique “V-shaped” continua that turn over at the Balmer limit ( Setton et al. 2024a ; Hviding et al. 2025 , e.g.,) , these sources tend to have both positive SC 0 and SC 1 . However, the UV colors of faint LRDs are not uniform and consequently, LRDs can shift towards lower SC 0 ( Williams et al. 2024 ) . The quiescent galaxies (green and red) have the strongest Balmer/ \mathrm{4000\AA} break strengths and almost no rest-frame UV emission, residing in the lower-left corner of both SC 0 -SC 1 and SC 2 -SC 3 SC space. Older quiescent galaxies (time since quenching \mathrm{>0.8\,Gyr} ; red) tend to have flatter optical-near-IR continuum slopes and therefore have slightly higher SC 3 and SC 1 than the young quiescent galaxies (or recently quenched/post-starburst galaxies; green). They are also characterized by a \mathrm{4000\AA} break instead of the Balmer breaks characteristic of younger quiescent galaxies, which is reflected by their lower SC 2 . However, the exact boundary between dusty star-forming galaxies (maroon) and old quiescent galaxies (red) is difficult to determine in the SC space. As the PCA analysis is essentially an operation that lowers the dimension of the dataset, the subtle difference in the spectral shape required to break the dust-age degeneracy becomes hard to map to the SC location. Using the visualization of spectral types in Figure 1 , we can immediately eliminate sources that are unlikely to be quiescent galaxies without having to perform computationally expensive stellar population synthesis modeling on the entire RUBIES dataset. In order to ensure a complete selection of quiescent galaxies in RUBIES, we adopt generous initial SC cuts, outlined by light red dashed lines in Figure 1 . These cuts effectively remove any sources with spectral features that are mutually exclusive with quiescence. The cut in SC 0 removes sources with significant UV flux, which still host massive stars and therefore recent star formation. The cut in SC 2 removes sources without a prominent Balmer/ \mathrm{4000\AA} break, which lack evolved stellar populations. The cuts in SC 1 or SC 3 remove sources with continuum slope at red optical or NIR wavelengths corresponding to significant dust reddening, which is rare in quiescent galaxies ( Setton et al. 2024b ; Siegel et al. 2025 ) . Using this preselection, we identify an initial sample of 41 unique \mathrm{m_{F444W}<24} sources at 210\,Myr} ) stars fit in the range \tau\in[0,2.5] and a free dust index \delta\in[-1,0.4] that describes the deviation from the Calzetti et al. 2000 dust law and includes a UV bump that depends on the slope parameterized as in Noll et al. 2009 . We fix the attenuation around young ( \mathrm{t<10\,Myr} ) stars to be twice that of the older populations. The stellar metallicity is set as a free parameter with a logarithmically sampled uniform prior in the range \mathrm{log(Z/Z_{\odot})\in\,[-2,0.2]} . We mask all wavelengths shorter than rest-frame \mathrm{1200\AA} to avoid contributions from intergalactic medium absorption. We marginalize over the emission lines (specifically, \mathrm{[NeV]\,\lambda 3426} , \mathrm{[OII]\,\lambda\lambda 3726,3729} , \mathrm{[OIII]\,\lambda\lambda 4959,5007} , \mathrm{[NII]\,\lambda\lambda 6548,6584} , \mathrm{[SII]\,\lambda\lambda 6716,6731} , \mathrm{[SIII]\,\lambda\lambda 9069,9532} , \mathrm{H\alpha} , \mathrm{H\beta} , \mathrm{H\gamma} , and \mathrm{H\delta} ) by fitting flexible Gaussians. The line spread function curves in the original JWST User Documentation (JDox) are broader than those measured in practice, depending on the exact source morphology ( de Graaff et al. 2024 ) . Before fitting, all models are convolved with a line spread function that is a factor of 1.3 narrower than the JDox curves to account for instrumental dispersion, following de Graaff et al. 2025a . We additionally include two free velocity dispersions that smooth the stellar continuum and ionized gas emission, which we allow to vary in the range \mathrm{[0,1000]\,km/s} to marginalize over the uncertainty in the line spread function in addition to the intrinsic dispersion of the galaxy. As described in Section II.2 , physical properties inferred from SED fitting, such as stellar mass, have to be corrected because the customized photometry does not capture the total light from each galaxy due to the small aperture sizes. We derive an aperture to total flux correction from the ratio of F444W flux within the rectangular MSA apertures to the PSF-matched total in the same band. We apply this correction factor to the derived stellar mass and SFH for each galaxy. Following typical conventions, all masses are reported as surviving stellar mass. We note that this modeling assumes solar-scaled stellar population models. Given that these massive galaxies are probably alpha-enhanced ( Beverage et al. 2025 , e.g.,) and this will slightly overestimate mass and age ( Park et al. 2024b ) . Figure 2: Example spectro-photometric fits of a z\sim 4 post-starburst galaxy (ID: RUBIES-UDS-12594) and an old quiescent galaxy (ID: RUBIES-EGS-42328). For each row, the upper left panel shows the SED of observed NIRCam photometry and uncertainty (orange circle and error bar), observed NIRSpec PRISM spectrum and uncertainty (red solid line and pink bands), best-fit model photometry and its 68% confidence interval (black square and errorbar), and best-fit model spectrum and its 68% confidence interval (black solid line and grey band). The bottom left panel shows the residuals of our fits to the observed photometry (orange squares) and spectrum (red solid line). The inset shows the NIRCam/F444W image of the target galaxy. The red rectangle traces the central MSA micro-shutter used to compute slit-like aperture photometry, and the red circle traces the circular photometric catalog aperture. The right panels show the median (lines) and 16-84\% intervals (bands) for the inferred SFHs and t_{9}0 measurements. These fits allow us to robustly determine the physical properties of these galaxies. In Figure 2 , we show two examples of our spectro-photometric fits: a young quiescent (post-starburst) galaxy at z\sim 4 (top) and an old quiescent galaxy at z\sim 2.7 (bottom). In the upper left panels, the observed spectrum and its uncertainties are shown in red, and the observed photometry with error is shown in orange. The best-fitting model spectrum and photometry are shown in black. Both observed and model spectra have been scaled by the polynomial calibration vector to match the photometry. The insets show the NIRCam/F444W cutout ( 2.4^{\prime\prime} in width) of the target galaxy. The red rectangle traces the central MSA micro-shutter (for slit-like aperture photometry), and the red circle traces the circular aperture from which the catalog photometry was extracted. The bottom left panels show the residuals of the fits ( \chi values). The right panels show the median and 68\% confidence interval SFHs for these galaxies as solid black curves and grey regions. We show the median and 68\% confidence interval of t_{90} in the same panels as dashed red lines and light red regions. Overall, these fits are excellent and enable the characterization of SFHs and the physical properties of these galaxies. The SED fits and SFHs of the remaining galaxies in this sample are shown in Figure 8 and Figure 9 in the Appendix. IV The Selection of Quiescent Galaxies IV.1 The Selection and Classification of the RUBIES Quiescent Galaxy Sample Figure 3: Left panel: Stellar mass versus sSFR for SC-selected quiescent galaxy candidates. Robust quiescent galaxies (Criterion 1) are shown in red, and marginally quiescent cases (Criterion 2) are shown in pink. Galaxies with the 50th percentile \mathrm{sSFR}<10^{-10}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} are shown as upper limits. One galaxy (ID: RUBIES-EGS-61168) is not in the range of this plot due to its extremely low sSFR. Middle panel: stellar mass versus \mathrm{t}_{90} for all galaxies. We additionally divide our sample into young quiescent galaxies ( \mathrm{t}_{90}<0.8 Gyr, red or pink) and old quiescent galaxies ( \mathrm{t}_{90}>0.8 Gyr, black). Right panel: Stellar mass versus spectroscopic redshift of the finalized sample galaxies. The old quiescent population emerges at z\sim 3 . Based on our initial PCA selection, we find that that the majority ( \sim 90\% ) of the bright ( \mathrm{F444W<24}\,\cup\,\mathrm{SNR>5} ) RUBIES sources at 20.8\,Gyr} ) sources (black symbols) are found at the lowest redshifts ( 25 in the left panel and their rest-frame u_{s} g_{s} i_{s} colors ( Antwi-Danso et al. 2023 ) in the middle panel. The galaxies in RUBIES that are selected by our refined SC cuts are shown as hexagon symbols, whose color coding follows previous convention. Other galaxies in RUBIES that are excluded by the refined SC cuts are shown as black dots. All the remaining field galaxies not surveyed by RUBIES are binned into 2D histograms, where the darker color indicates the higher density of objects. The conventional rest-frame UVJ selection criteria with a horizontal U-V cut ( Williams et al. 2009 ; Whitaker et al. 2011 ; Schreiber et al. 2015 , e.g.,) misses some of the youngest quiescent galaxies in our sample, as expected ( Baker et al. 2025b , e.g.,) . Extending to bluer U-V colors ( Belli et al. 2019 ; Baker et al. 2025b ) (diagonal dashed lines) captures many excluded galaxies, for this quiescent sample ( \mathrm{sSFR_{50th}}<10^{-10}\,yr^{-1} ) \sim 30\% have {\it U-V}<1.23 . We find contamination fractions of \sim 35\% in both the classical and extended UVJ criteria, which is high but largely consistent with the \sim 10\%-30\% reported in Leja et al. 2019b , Antwi-Danso et al. 2023 , or Nanayakkara et al. 2025 . We return to discuss the impact of false positivity on number densities from UVJ color selections in Section 6 . Alternatively, the u_{s} g_{s} i_{s} criteria select almost all ( \sim 95\% ) quiescent galaxies in this sample at the cost of much higher contamination rates ( \sim 60\% ). Even though the photometric redshifts of these bright quiescent galaxies agree well with the spectroscopic redshifts (see right panel of Figure 4 ), the substantial uncertainties in photometric redshifts can contribute significant systematic uncertainties to the rest-frame color estimations and scatter in color-color space. The typical uncertainties in these color estimations are shown in the left and middle panels of Figure 4 . We emphasize that this scatter is not included in our purity and completeness fractions quoted above. Both the impostors and true quiescent galaxies located near these selection boundaries can shift into or out of these color selection criteria if perturbed within the confidence interval of their rest-frame colors. These uncertainties and the nuance in the definition of true quiescence (Criterion 1 versus Criterion 2) complicate the determination of systematic impurity or incompleteness in these rest-frame color selections. Another caveat is that the completeness or purity fraction reported in this section only considers the EGS and UDS galaxies surveyed by RUBIES and is not corrected for the selection bias introduced by the RUBIES selection function. Without this correction, the purity fraction of the extended UVJ criteria is likely prone to underestimation. These criteria include younger quiescent galaxies but also bluer impostors ( Whitaker et al. 2012 ; Spitler et al. 2014 ; Straatman et al. 2015 ) . Since RUBIES preferentially targeted redder sources, which we discuss in detail in the following section, RUBIES could miss more blue impostors and underestimate the total number of sources present in the extended color region. IV.3 Correcting for Targeting Incompleteness with the RUBIES Selection Function Figure 5: The parent catalog F444W magnitude versus F150W-F444W color of this quiescent sample, RUBIES surveyed sources, and all parent catalog sources in PRIMER/UDS and CEERS/EGS in three redshift bins. These panels illustrate the survey completeness of RUBIES as a function of magnitude, color, and redshift. The boxes outlined by grey dashed lines represent the area in color-magnitude space in which we perform the completeness calculation in each redshift bin. The survey completeness is close to 100\% for sources under the footprint in the color-magnitude space occupied by massive quiescent galaxies at z>4 . Spectroscopy reliably prevents the contamination of dusty star-forming galaxies in the selection of quiescent galaxies, which is unavoidable with only photometry. However, these spectroscopic surveys cannot comprehensively target every eligible source in the field. The number densities derived from this kind of spectroscopic selection must be statistically corrected for sample incompleteness. For the RUBIES massive quiescent galaxy sample, the overall sample incompleteness is a net product of three selection steps. Firstly, we consider the fraction of field sources that are eligible to be included as survey candidates ( \mathrm{S_{el}} ). This is a function of the apparent photometric properties of the source \vec{m}\mathrm{=(m_{F444W},m_{F150W}-m_{F444W})} , which depends on their intrinsic physical properties such as stellar mass ( \mathrm{M_{*}} ), sSFR, redshift ( \mathrm{z} ), and dust reddening ( \mathrm{A_{V}} ). Secondly, we define a variable, \mathrm{S_{slit}} , to be the fraction of potential sources for which suitable spectra were obtained. This fraction includes whether a source is assigned an MSA slit, whether a spectrum was successfully obtained and reduced, and whether the spectroscopic wavelength coverage, redshift quality grade, and SNR meet the PCA requirements described in Section III.1 . This is similarly a function of the photometric properties of the source \vec{m} . Thirdly, we consider the fraction of sources included in our super color cuts among all potential quiescent sources for which a successful spectrum is obtained( \mathrm{S_{PCA}} ). This term is a function of the source spectrum \mathrm{f_{\lambda}} and accounts for missing potential quiescent galaxies with unusual SCs. In summary, we express these terms as: • \mathrm{S_{el}}(\vec{m}\mathrm{(M_{*},sSFR,z,A_{V})}) • \mathrm{S_{slit}}(\vec{m}\mathrm{(M_{*},sSFR,z,A_{V})}) • \mathrm{S_{PCA}}(f_{\lambda}\mathrm{(M_{*},sSFR,z,A_{V})}) Therefore, the total sample incompleteness is given by: \mathrm{S_{tot}(M_{*},sSFR,z,A_{V})=S_{el}\cdot S_{slit}\cdot S_{PCA}}. (2) We simplify some of the terms in the selection function as follows. Since RUBIES considers any field source with \mathrm{F444W<28.5} to be eligible and we have enforced all sources in this sample to have \mathrm{m_{F444W}<24} , we assume \mathrm{S_{el}}=1 for all galaxies in this sample. Furthermore, \mathrm{S_{PCA}} has no dependency on stellar mass or redshift, since our PCA analysis is conducted on normalized, rest-frame spectra. As we have shown, the SC selection of quiescent galaxies has an effective limit in dust attenuation of \mathrm{A}_{V}<0.7 , we assume \mathrm{S_{PCA}}\sim 1 at \mathrm{A_{V}}<0.7 and \mathrm{sSFR<10^{-10}\,yr^{-1}} . With these simplifications, we show that \mathrm{S_{tot}} only depends on \mathrm{S_{slit}} for the quiescent galaxies in our selection. RUBIES selects spectroscopic targets from eligible sources in CEERS/EGS and PRIMER/UDS according to their photometric redshifts, F444W magnitudes, and \mathrm{F150W-F444W} colors ( de Graaff et al. 2025b ) . To estimate \mathrm{S_{slit}} , we divide the finalized quiescent galaxies, RUBIES sources with successful spectra, and eligible parent sources into three redshift bins: [2,3],[3,4], and [4,5] . In Figure 5 , we show the color-magnitude distribution of finalized quiescent galaxies (using the same color coding as in previous figures), RUBIES sources with successful spectra (black dots), and the parent photometric catalog sources (grey dots) in each redshift bin. We select the approximate color-magnitude space occupied by the quiescent galaxies in this sample in each redshift bin (thick grey dashed line) and divide these color-magnitude spaces into smaller boxes that are \mathrm{1\,mag} in width (thin grey dashed line). We mask out the faint regime ( \mathrm{m_{F444W}>24} ), which is excluded by the quiescent galaxy selection in this sample. In each color-magnitude box ( \mathbf{m} ), we count the total number of quiescent galaxies in this sample \mathrm{N_{QG,surveyed,\mathbf{m}}} , the number of RUBIES targets with a successful spectrum ( \mathrm{N_{surveyed,\mathbf{m}}} ), and the number of eligible parent sources ( \mathrm{N_{total,\mathbf{m}}} ). The fraction of eligible sources which yield successful spectra varies smoothly in the color-magnitude space ( de Graaff et al. 2025b ) . This allows us to approximate this fraction as a constant per color-magnitude box: \mathrm{S_{slit}}(\vec{m})\mathrm{\sim N_{surveyed,\mathbf{m}}/N_{total,\mathbf{m}}} , when \vec{m}\in\mathbf{m} . A few sources selected by RUBIES to be assigned an MSA slit fail to produce a spectrum that meets the PCA pre-requisite in wavelength coverage, redshift quality grade, or SNR. However, we find that this failure rate does not have a significant dependence on color, magnitude, or redshift within the relevant parameter space. Generally, the spectroscopic redshifts recovered by RUBIES in the entire survey agree well with photometric redshifts (the normalized median absolute deviation between the two is small: \sigma(\Delta z/(1+z))=0.033 ) ( de Graaff et al. 2025b ) . For the bright quiescent galaxies in this sample, the match between photometric and spectroscopic redshifts is excellent, as shown in the right panel of Figure 4 . We assume that any remaining unsurveyed quiescent galaxies should also have reliable photometric redshifts. Therefore, the approximation described above is likely not affected by any catastrophic errors in photometric redshifts or biased by any potential correlation between spectrum acquisition failure and source color, magnitude, or redshift. For a population of RUBIES massive quiescent galaxies in a narrow redshift bin, which have \mathrm{sSFRM_{*,min}} , and \mathrm{A_{V}M_{*,min},sSFR10^{10.3}M_{\odot}} ) quiescent ( \mathrm{sSFR<10^{-10}yr^{-1}} ) galaxies without significant dust reddening ( \mathrm{A_{V}<0.7} ). We essentially estimate how the selection of quiescent galaxies in RUBIES depends on their intrinsic source properties, given that we know how the selection of RUBIES sources depends on their observed source properties. V Quiescent Galaxy Number Densities V.1 The Number Density of Massive Quiescent Galaxies in the RUBIES Figure 6: Left panel: Different flavors of total quiescent galaxy number density binned by redshifts from this sample. We show the number density derived from the entire extended quiescent sample (pink hexagons), the entire strict quiescent sample (red hexagons), and the strict quiescent sample but using parent catalog sources from the entire field rather than just the survey footprints for completeness calculation (orange hexagons). Neither our quiescence criteria nor any potential survey targeting bias has a significant impact on the resulting number density. Middle panel: Our fiducial quiescent galaxy number density compared to literature values using JWST data. Our result is in agreement with previous JWST measurements overall. Right panel: Number densities of old ( t_{90}>0.8\,Gyr ) and young ( t_{90}<0.8\,Gyr ) quiescent galaxies in this work compared to (non-JWST) literature values. This work finds a higher number density for young quiescent galaxies at 310^{10.5}M_{\odot}} Quiescence Criterion \mathrm{sSFR_{50th}<10^{-10}\,yr^{-1}} \mathrm{sSFR_{16th}<10^{-10}\,yr^{-1}} \mathrm{sSFR_{50th}<10^{-10}\,yr^{-1}} 24.5 . Taken together with our results, this suggests that the number density of quiescent galaxies likely drops steeply at 43 between RUBIES and the only non-JWST result at these redshifts ( Forrest et al. 2018 ) , potentially due to differences in effective mass limits. We find a relatively consistent number density (within 0.3\,\mathrm{dex} ) with non-JWST literature results with similar minimum mass at 210^{10.8}M_{\odot}} versus \mathrm{M_{*}>10^{10.3}M_{\odot}} for RUBIES). At z\sim 3 , these ground-based samples likely miss both the old and young quiescent galaxies compared to any JWST sample such as RUBIES, due to several factors. The selection of pre-JWST era samples at these epochs, such as the one in Forrest et al. 2018 ( Kriek et al. 2011 , following) , primarily relied on magnitude-limited K-band surveys. At the low-mass or high redshifts, quiescent galaxies will fall below K-band selection limits. This is especially relevant for the oldest galaxies, which have the highest M/L in the K band. This incompleteness at z>3 is further exacerbated by the lack of rest-frame NIR coverage, which requires extrapolation to compute rest-frame V-J colors for common UVJ color selection ( Antwi-Danso et al. 2023 ) . Meanwhile, JWST samples reach deeper magnitude limits, cover longer wavelengths, and have yielded relatively consistent number densities of quiescent galaxies at z>3 . Constraining the number density of the first old quiescent galaxies at cosmic noon provides an opportunity to validate the number density of young quiescent galaxies at earlier epochs. After approximately \mathrm{\sim 0.5-1\,Gyr} , young quiescent galaxies at a given epoch lose the A-type stars that dominate their SEDs and thus become part of the old quiescent population in the next epoch ( Whitaker et al. 2012 ) . Therefore, the old quiescent population should be a cumulative ensemble of all quiescent galaxies quenched \mathrm{\sim 0.5-1\,Gyr} ago, if rejuvenation or major mergers are infrequent among these galaxies. Since the young number density of young quiescent galaxies appears to drop steeply at 410.5 . The simulation values shown in the right panel are computed with random errors in \mathrm{M}_{*} and \mathrm{S}FR while those in the left are computed without considering those errors. At z>3 , all simulations shown here under-predict the population abundance of quiescent galaxies. In Figure 7 , we compare the observed number density of quiescent galaxies derived from this sample to various simulation predictions discussed in Lagos et al. 2025 . Three are semi-analytical models: Shark ( Lagos et al. 2018 ; Lagos et al. 2024 ) , GAEA ( De Lucia et al. 2014 ; Hirschmann et al. 2016 ; De Lucia et al. 2024 ) , and Galform ( Lacey et al. 2016 ) . The other three are cosmological hydrodynamical simulations: Eagle ( Crain et al. 2015 ; Schaye et al. 2015 ) , IllustrisTNG ( Pillepich et al. 2018 ; Springel et al. 2018 ) , and Simba ( Davé et al. 2019 ) . All three semi-analytical models correspond to co-moving volumes of \mathrm{\sim(700\,cMpc)^{3}} , and the three cosmological hydrodynamical simulations have co-moving box sizes of \mathrm{\sim(100\,cMpc)^{3}-(150\,cMpc)^{3}} . All simulation predictions shown here assume a quiescence criterion of \mathrm{sSFR}<10^{-10}\,yr^{-1} and a stellar mass limit of \mathrm{l}og(M_{*}/M_{\odot})>10.5 , regardless of dust attenuation. The simulation number densities shown in the left panel select galaxies by their exact values in stellar mass and SFR, while those in the right panel additionally consider the random errors in these properties, as described in Lagos et al. 2025 or De Lucia et al. 2024 . For the curves shown in the right panel, errors are drawn for stellar mass and SFR from two independent Gaussians, which are centered at 0 and have widths of 0.3\,\mathrm{dex} (except for GAEA , where the errors are drawn from Gaussians with widths of 0.35\,\mathrm{dex} ). These choices of Gaussian widths for error convolution are motivated by the typical uncertainties in stellar mass and SFR inferred from multi-wavelength observations ( Robotham et al. 2020 ; Bellstedt & Robotham 2025 ) . Notably, incorporating scatter to emulate the effects of measurement uncertainties systematically increases the number densities in Eagle and Shark . This is likely because >10^{10.5} M ⊙ falls in the exponential decline of the quiescent galaxy stellar mass functions in these simulations ( Lagos et al. 2025 ) , introducing a net upward Eddington bias and inflating number densities. For the observed quiescent galaxy number density shown in these panels, we take the fiducial sample (Criterion 1) and further enforce a mass cut of \mathrm{\log(M_{*}/M_{\odot})>10.5} , same as the selection in these simulations. Baker et al. 2025a has shown that the observed quiescent galaxy stellar mass function is flat at \mathrm{\log(M_{*}/M_{\odot})\sim 10.5} cutoff at 210.5} at 43 is unlikely to be attributed to the contamination within photometric samples or targeting biases in spectroscopic studies. Although we expect the effect to be small, our measured number densities could be slightly underestimated at the highest redshifts due to the effective magnitude completeness limits within the RUBIES survey. The magnitude limit ( \mathrm{F444W<24} ) of our fiducial parent sample corresponds to stellar mass limits of \mathrm{10^{10.3}M_{\odot}} ( 20.7} quiescent galaxies (see details in Appendix B ). Although most quiescent galaxies at z<2.5 have \mathrm{A_{v}<0.75} ( Suess et al. 2019 ; Siegel et al. 2025 , e.g.,) , rare counter examples with significant dust-reddening in the core ( \mathrm{A_{v}>0.75} , Setton et al. 2024b ; Siegel et al. 2025 ) or the outskirts ( Ji et al. 2024 ) exist. However, these sources of sample incompleteness would only exaggerate the tension between simulation and observation. Among these simulations and models, the wide range of predicted quiescent number densities at a given redshift is mainly due to the different implementations of AGN feedback (see Lagos et al. 2025 for detailed discussion). Further modifications to the AGN feedback implementation could resolve the current tension in quiescent galaxy number densities. Although hard to pinpoint observationally, many lines of evidence point toward the simultaneity of quenching and AGN activity. For example, the AGN incidence rate of massive quiescent galaxies at similar epochs ( \mathrm{\sim 50\%} from a multi-wavelength search by Baker et al. 2025b ; \mathrm{\sim 20\%} from analysis of optical emission lines in Martínez-Marín et al. 2024 or Ito et al. 2025a ) is much higher than that of the youngest quiescent galaxies at low redshifts ( Greene et al. 2020 ) . A number of the quiescent galaxies in this sample exhibit strong nebular emission lines, which hints at the incidence of nuclear activities, although we defer that analysis to a future study. Including re-ionization physics has been shown to significantly boost the number of quiescent galaxies at earlier times ( z\sim 5.5 ; Chittenden et al. 2025 ), which could ultimately become important in resolving tension with future theoretical models. In the future, the lack of massive quiescent galaxies in state-of-the-art galaxy formation simulations needs to be investigated further to separate two compounding issues. One is the potential overall lack of massive galaxies ( Weibel et al. 2024 ; Shuntov et al. 2025 , either star-forming or quenched; e.g.,) , which would point to star formation not being efficient enough or, conversely, feedback being too strong in regulating star formation in the early universe. The second one is AGN feedback itself, and whether the processes it encompasses (e.g., mechanical, radiative, or energetic feedback) are sufficient to quench massive galaxies in the early universe. It is clear that this field is nascent, and further observations of massive quiescent galaxies and their stellar mass distribution over larger samples would provide invaluable constraints for galaxy formation models. A final resolution is empirical: if most apparently quiescent galaxies host heavily dust-obscured star formation, then the apparent tension could disappear. Testing this would require additional observations of apparently quiescent galaxies at 33 . If \sim 90\% of the rest-frame-optically-selected quiescent galaxies at z>4 turned out to host star formation embedded in optically thick dust, the \mathrm{1\,dex} discrepancy would disappear. Stellar population synthesis modeling of a truly panchromatic sample of quiescent galaxies at z>3 could lay this uncertainty to rest; the attenuated radiation from instantaneous star formation would inevitably re-radiate at MIR and FIR, observable by existing Herschel data and/or with facilities such as ALMA. VI Summary In this paper, we presented a sample of 17 (Criterion 1) or 20 (Criterion 2) spectroscopically-confirmed massive ( \mathrm{log(M_{*}/M_{\odot})>10.3} ) quiescent galaxies at 22 , but consistent with other JWST studies. Although only found at cosmic noon, the number density of older quiescent galaxies at 23 are much more common than predictions from six state-of-the-art cosmological galaxy formation simulations. This discrepancy at z>4 is unambiguous even when the cosmic variance is included, as the number density of massive quiescent galaxies estimated with the RUBIES sample is 10 times greater than the simulation prediction at this epoch. Understanding the formation and quenching of the first massive quiescent galaxies, indeed even just matching number densities, will require efforts on the theoretical and observational fronts. For this rare population, beating down the uncertainties due to cosmic variance by increasing surveyed volumes is critical. The co-moving volume probed by RUBIES in each one of the redshift bins is merely \mathrm{\sim 5\cdot 10^{5}\,cMpc^{3}} , compared to simulation volumes that are typically \mathrm{\sim 10^{6}-10^{8}\,cMpc^{3}} . Dramatically increasing the area of the sky probed by JWST imaging would be an obvious first step, although we emphasize the high contamination rates of quiescent samples even with CEERS/PRIMER NIRCam photometric coverage and spectroscopic redshifts. This would be much worse in shallower imaging and/or with sparsely sampled SEDs from e.g., COSMOS-Web. JWST parallel imaging surveys, such as PANORAMIC ( Williams et al. 2025 ) , can provide an opportunity to efficiently cover large areas (with many filters) and provide independent fields that optimally minimize cosmic variance uncertainties ( Jespersen et al. 2025 ) . However, spectroscopic confirmation will always be necessary, ideally leveraging larger imaging surveys for targeting using well-characterized selection functions as in RUBIES. Ideally, these samples will comprise maximal multi-wavelength data, including coverage in the MIR and FIR, to conclusively confirm quiescence. Finally, even at cosmic noon, the number densities and ages of the descendants of these extreme, early quiescent galaxies are poorly constrained. Thus, wide-area large spectroscopic surveys like the Prime Focus Spectrograph Survey ( Greene et al. 2022 ) or MOONS ( Maiolino et al. 2020 ) promise to provide interesting insights into the number densities and star formation histories of old quiescent systems at cosmic noon and indirectly test their earliest histories. VII