QCD sum rule study of topped mesons within heavy quark effective theory Shu-Wei Zhang 1, Xuan Luo 1, Hui-Min Yang 1,2, Hua-Xing Chen 1 Abstract Motivated by the recent CMS observation of a near-threshold enhancement in top-quark pair production CMS:2025kzt , we investigate a novel class of hadronic systems containing a single top quark: the topped mesons ( t ​ q ¯ t\bar{q} , with q ¯ = u ¯ , d ¯ , s ¯ \bar{q}=\bar{u},\bar{d},\bar{s} ). In contrast to the extensively studied toponium ( t ​ t ¯ t\bar{t} ) system—analyzed primarily within perturbative QCD—topped mesons offer a complementary nonperturbative probe of QCD dynamics in the heavy-quark limit. These states are expected to exhibit longer lifetimes and narrower decay widths than toponium, as only a single top quark undergoes weak decay. We employ QCD sum rules within the framework of heavy quark effective theory to study the structure and mass spectrum of ground-state topped mesons. Our analysis predicts masses near 173.1 GeV, approximately 0.5–0.6 GeV above the top-quark pole mass. Compared to singly topped baryons ( t ​ q ​ q tqq , with q = u , d , s q=u,d,s ) studied in Ref. Zhang:2025xxd , topped mesons feature a simpler quark composition and more favorable decay channels, enhancing their potential for both theoretical analysis and experimental discovery. I Introduction The top quark holds a unique status within the Standard Model due to its remarkably large mass of approximately 172.57 GeV pdg , setting it apart from all other quark flavors. Unlike lighter quarks, it decays before hadronization can occur, owing to its extremely short lifetime of about 5\times 10^{-25} seconds. This exceptional characteristic presents both theoretical challenges and novel opportunities for the study of hadronic physics. Theoretical efforts have traditionally focused on the toponium system—a hypothetical t\bar{t} bound state. Although such a state cannot form a stable resonance due to the rapid decay of the top quark, the dynamics of near-threshold t\bar{t} production are still governed by nonrelativistic QCD. Extensive studies based on perturbative QCD and potential models have predicted distinctive enhancements near the production threshold Fadin:1987wz ; Barger:1987xg ; Kuhn:1987ty ; Fadin:1990wx ; Strassler:1990nw ; Sumino:1997ve ; Hoang:2000yr ; Penin:2005eu ; Hagiwara:2008df ; Kiyo:2008bv ; Sumino:2010bv ; Beneke:2015kwa ; Fuks:2021xje ; Wang:2024hzd ; Jiang:2024fyw ; Akbar:2024brg ; Fuks:2024yjj . Notably, the CMS Collaboration recently reported an excess in the t\bar{t} invariant mass spectrum near threshold CMS:2025kzt , consistent with the expected behavior of a pseudoscalar toponium state. Similar features observed in earlier ATLAS and CMS data further support this interpretation ATLAS:2023fsd ; CMS:2024pts . The observed enhancement appears more consistent with QCD-based toponium predictions than with alternative explanations, potentially marking the first experimental evidence of toponium formation—an important milestone in top-quark physics Aguilar-Saavedra:2024mnm ; Llanes-Estrada:2024phk ; Fu:2025yft ; Fu:2025zxb ; Nason:2025hix ; Ellis:2025nkm ; Jafari:2025rmm ; Bai:2025buy ; Shao:2025dzw ; Xiong:2025iwg ; Thompson:2025cgp . Beyond toponium, a broader class of hadronic systems containing a single top quark—such as topped mesons and singly topped baryons —presents additional theoretical interest. Although these configurations are unlikely to form true bound states due to the top quark’s fleeting lifetime, they provide a valuable framework for probing heavy-quark dynamics. A particularly noteworthy feature lies in their decay properties: since only one top quark decays, their expected lifetimes are approximately twice that of toponium, resulting in narrower decay widths Chen:2021erj ; Maltoni:2024csn . These characteristics may enhance their experimental accessibility and open new avenues for exploring top-related QCD phenomena. The study of topped mesons and singly topped baryons can be systematically performed within the framework of heavy quark effective theory (HQET) Neubert:1993mb ; Manohar:2000dt . In this approach, the top quark is treated as a static color source, allowing for a systematic classification of the light degrees of freedom. This simplification facilitates the construction of interpolating currents suitable for both QCD sum rule analyses and lattice QCD simulations Dai:1993kt ; Dai:1996yw ; Liu:2007fg . Singly topped baryons are thoroughly examined in Ref. Zhang:2025xxd , while the present work focuses on a systematic investigation of topped mesons. In this study we construct and analyze interpolating currents for ground-state topped mesons within the HQET framework. Using QCD sum rules, we explore their properties and find that their predicted masses lie near 173.1 GeV—approximately 0.5–0.6 GeV above the top-quark pole mass. It is worth emphasizing that topped mesons offer several distinct advantages over their baryonic counterparts: • Theoretical simplicity: The internal structure of ground-state topped mesons is conceptually simpler and more transparent. Only two categories are expected: pseudoscalar mesons ( T and T_{s} ) and vector mesons ( T^{*} and T_{s}^{*} ). The states T^{(*)} and T_{s}^{(*)} correspond to the quark configurations t\bar{q} (with \bar{q}=\bar{u}/\bar{d} ) and t\bar{s} , respectively. • Production feasibility: A topped meson involves only a single light antiquark, making it generally easier to produce than a singly topped baryon, which requires two light quarks. • Experimental observability: A topped meson is expected to decay weakly into a \Upsilon meson and a charmed meson. These decay products are typically easier to identify and reconstruct experimentally than those from a singly topped baryon, which decays into a \Upsilon meson and a charmed baryon. This paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II we construct interpolating currents for ground-state topped mesons and perform QCD sum rule analyses at leading order. In Sec. III we incorporate \mathcal{O}(1/m_{Q}) corrections to examine next-to-leading-order effects. Finally, Sec. IV summarizes our findings and discusses their physical implications. II Results at leading order In this section we perform leading-order QCD sum rule analyses to investigate the properties of ground-state topped mesons. Before proceeding with the formalism, we briefly outline the notations and conventions adopted throughout this work. A topped meson is defined as a bound state composed of a heavy top quark and a light antiquark, which may be of up, down, or strange flavor. The lowest-lying topped mesons carry spin-parity quantum numbers J^{P}=0^{-} and 1^{-} , and are organized into a doublet under heavy quark effective theory (HQET). This structure arises in the heavy quark limit, where the spin of the top quark decouples from the system’s dynamics, leaving the light degrees of freedom—characterized by the light quark spin s_{q}=1/2 —to govern the quantum behavior. Coupling the light component with the heavy quark spin s_{Q}=1/2 leads to two degenerate states with total angular momentum J=s_{Q}\otimes s_{q}=0\oplus 1 , forming an HQET doublet. The relevant interpolating currents are constructed as \displaystyle J(x) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\bar{q}^{a}(x)\gamma_{5}h_{v}^{a}(x)\,, (1) \displaystyle J_{\mu}(x) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\bar{q}^{a}(x)\gamma^{t}_{\mu}h_{v}^{a}(x)\,, (2) where a denotes the color index. The field \bar{q}(x) refers to a light antiquark, such as \bar{u}(x) , \bar{d}(x) , or \bar{s}(x) , while h_{v}(x) represents the effective top quark field in HQET. The transverse gamma matrix is defined by \gamma^{t}_{\mu}=\gamma_{\mu}-v\!\!\!/\penalty\,v_{\mu} , where v_{\mu} is the four-velocity of the heavy quark. Since J(x) and J_{\mu}(x) arise from the same HQET doublet, they yield equivalent QCD sum rules Dai:1993kt ; Dai:1996yw ; Liu:2007fg ; Dai:1996qx ; Dai:2003yg ; Yang:2025hzc . Thus, it is sufficient to work with either current. In this analysis, we focus on the vector current J_{\mu}(x) with quark content t\bar{s} to investigate the properties of the vector topped meson T_{s}^{\star} , which carries quantum numbers J^{P}=1^{-} . The corresponding decay constant is defined through the matrix element: \langle 0|J_{\mu}(x)|T_{s}^{\star}\rangle=f\,\epsilon_{\mu}\,, (3) where f denotes the decay constant and \epsilon_{\mu} is the polarization vector. This leads to the following two-point correlation function: \displaystyle\Pi_{\mu\nu}(\omega) \displaystyle= \displaystyle i\int d^{4}x\,e^{ik\cdot x}\langle 0|T[J_{\mu}(x)J_{\nu}^{\dagger}(0)]|0\rangle (4) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(g_{\mu\nu}-\frac{q_{\mu}q_{\nu}}{q^{2}}\right)\times\Pi(\omega)+\cdots\,, where \omega=2v\cdot k is twice the residual off-shell energy. Here, we project out the Lorentz structure associated with the vector meson contribution, while subleading terms are omitted for brevity. At the hadronic level, Eq. ( 4 ) can be rewritten as \Pi(\omega)=\frac{f^{2}}{2\overline{\Lambda}-\omega}+\text{higher states}\,, (5) where \overline{\Lambda}\equiv\lim_{m_{t}\rightarrow\infty}(m_{T_{s}^{\star}}-m_{t})\,, (6) denotes the residual mass of the T_{s}^{\star} meson in the heavy quark limit, with m_{T_{s}^{\star}} representing its physical mass. On the QCD side, Eq. ( 4 ) is evaluated via the operator product expansion (OPE). By substituting the interpolating current defined in Eq. ( 2 ) and performing a Borel transformation, we arrive at \displaystyle\Pi(\omega_{c},T) \displaystyle=f^{2}(\omega_{c},T)\cdot e^{-2\overline{\Lambda}(\omega_{c},T)/T} \displaystyle=\int_{s_{<}}^{\omega_{c}}\left[\frac{3\omega^{2}}{16\pi^{2}}+\frac{3m_{s}\omega}{8\pi^{2}}-\frac{3m_{s}^{2}}{8\pi^{2}}\right]e^{-{\omega/T}}\,d\omega \displaystyle\quad-\frac{\langle\bar{s}s\rangle}{2}+\frac{m_{s}\langle\bar{s}s\rangle}{4T}+\frac{\langle g_{s}\bar{s}\sigma Gs\rangle}{8T^{2}}\,. (7) Here, s_{<}=2m_{s} represents the physical threshold, \omega_{c} is the continuum threshold parameter, and T denotes the Borel mass. The parameter \omega_{c} encodes the quark–hadron duality assumption, wherein contributions from higher excited states and the continuum are modeled by the perturbative portion of the OPE. In practice, \omega_{c}/2 is selected to lie moderately above the residual mass of the meson under study, thereby ensuring ground-state dominance and reliable convergence of the OPE expansion. Figure 1: Dependence of (a) the convergence parameter (CVG), defined in Eq. ( 11 ), and (b) the pole contribution (PC), defined in Eq. ( 5 ), on the Borel mass T for the interpolating current J_{\mu}(x) . Dashed, solid, and dotted curves correspond to \omega_{c}=1.6 , 1.8 , and 2.0~\mathrm{GeV} , respectively. Figure 2: Variations of (a) the residual mass \overline{\Lambda} and (b) the decay constant f with respect to the Borel mass T for the interpolating current J_{\mu}(x) . Dashed, solid, and dotted curves correspond to \omega_{c}=1.6 , 1.8 , and 2.0~\mathrm{GeV} , respectively. To extract physical observables, we differentiate Eq. ( 7 ) with respect to -2/T , yielding \displaystyle\overline{\Lambda}(\omega_{c},T) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{1}{\Pi(\omega_{c},T)}\cdot\frac{\partial\Pi(\omega_{c},T)}{\partial(-2/T)}\,, (8) \displaystyle f^{2}(\omega_{c},T) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\Pi(\omega_{c},T)\cdot e^{2\overline{\Lambda}(\omega_{c},T)/T}\,. (9) These expressions involve two free parameters: the threshold value \omega_{c} and the Borel mass T . To determine their optimal working ranges, we impose three standard QCD sum rule criteria. Throughout our numerical analysis, we adopt the following input parameters pdg ; Yang:1993bp ; Narison:2011xe ; Narison:2018dcr ; Gimenez:2005nt ; Jamin:2002ev ; Ioffe:2002be ; Ovchinnikov:1988gk ; Colangelo:2000dp : \displaystyle\langle\bar{q}q\rangle \displaystyle= \displaystyle-(0.240~\mathrm{GeV})^{3}\,, \displaystyle\langle\bar{s}s\rangle \displaystyle= \displaystyle(0.8\pm 0.1)\times\langle\bar{q}q\rangle\,, \displaystyle\langle g_{s}\bar{q}\sigma Gq\rangle \displaystyle= \displaystyle M_{0}^{2}\cdot\langle\bar{q}q\rangle\,, \displaystyle\langle g_{s}\bar{s}\sigma Gs\rangle \displaystyle= \displaystyle M_{0}^{2}\cdot\langle\bar{s}s\rangle\,, (10) \displaystyle M_{0}^{2} \displaystyle= \displaystyle(0.8\pm 0.2)~\mathrm{GeV}^{2}\,, \displaystyle\langle g_{s}^{2}GG\rangle \displaystyle= \displaystyle(0.48\pm 0.14)~\mathrm{GeV}^{4}\,, \displaystyle m_{s} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 119\pm 1~\mathrm{MeV}\,, \displaystyle m_{q} \displaystyle\approx \displaystyle m_{u}\approx m_{d}\approx 5.3~\mathrm{MeV}\,. In particular, we use the pole mass of the strange quark, m_{s}^{\mathrm{pole}} , evaluated at the renormalization scale \mu=2~\mathrm{GeV} . The first criterion requires that contributions from higher-dimensional condensates be less than 20% of the total correlator: \mathrm{CVG}\equiv\left|\frac{\Pi^{\text{high-order}}(\omega_{c},T)}{\Pi(\infty,T)}\right|\leq 20\%\,. (11) As shown in Fig. 1 (a), this condition sets the lower bound of the Borel mass at T_{\rm min}=0.45~\mathrm{GeV} . The second criterion demands that the pole contribution exceed 40%: \mathrm{PC}\equiv\frac{\Pi(\omega_{c},T)}{\Pi(\infty,T)}\geq 40\%\,. (12) As illustrated in Fig. 1 (b), this requirement establishes an upper limit T_{\rm max}=0.93~\mathrm{GeV} for \omega_{c}=1.8~\mathrm{GeV} . Together, these two conditions define the initial Borel window: 0.45~\mathrm{GeV}