Theory of nonlinear magnetoelectric transport effects in normal-metal – magnetic-insulator heterostructures Oliver Franke, Piet W. Brouwer Abstract Heterostructures of normal metals (N) and magnetic insulators (F) show paradigmatic effects, such as spin-Hall magnetoresistance and electric drag currents. These effects are linear in the applied electric field E ⁡ ( ω ) E(\omega) . Normal-metal–magnetic-insulator heterostructures also exhibit a characteristic nonlinear response quadratic in E ⁡ ( ω ) E(\omega) , referred to as unidirectional spin-Hall magnetoresistance or spin-torque diode effect. In this article, we develop a theory of the bilinear response of FN bilayers and NFN trilayers for finite frequencies ω \omega of the driving field and for four contributions that have been previously considered in the literature: Joule heating, phonon-mediated unidirectional magnetoresistance, the spin-torque diode effect, and magnonic unidirectional spin-Hall magnetoresistance. We identify their distinct dependencies on frequency and the magnetization direction of the magnetic insulator and examine their scaling with magnetic field and system geometry, providing a framework for experimental differentiation. I Introduction The combination of non-magnetic metals and magnetically ordered materials is at the heart of spintronics. Their interfaces couple spin, charge, and heat transport and give rise to key spintronic effects driven by spin accumulations, electric fields, and temperature gradients Hirohata et al. 2020 . In this article, we consider bilayer and trilayer systems consisting of normal metals and a magnetic insulator. Such multilayers exhibit a rich set of spintronic phenomena, which arise from the conversion of electronic excitations in the normal metal to magnonic excitations in the ferromagnetic insulator at their interface. Prominent such spintronic effects are current-induced magnetization switching Avci et al. 2017a ; Yang et al. 2024 , spin-Hall magnetoresistance Weiler et al. 2012 ; Huang et al. 2012 ; Nakayama et al. 2013 ; Hahn et al. 2013 ; Vlietstra et al. 2013 ; Althammer et al. 2013 ; Lotze et al. 2014 ; Choi et al. 2017 ; Chen et al. 2013 ; Chen et al. 2016 ; Zhang et al. 2019 , and the spin-Seebeck and spin-Peltier effects Uchida et al. 2010 ; Bauer et al. 2012 ; Flipse et al. 2014 . The spin-Hall magnetoresistance refers to a dependence of the in-plane conductivity of a bilayer consisting of a normal metal (N) and a ferromagnetic insulator (F) on the magnetization direction of F Weiler et al. 2012 ; Huang et al. 2012 ; Nakayama et al. 2013 ; Hahn et al. 2013 ; Vlietstra et al. 2013 ; Althammer et al. 2013 ; Lotze et al. 2014 ; Choi et al. 2017 ; Chen et al. 2013 ; Chen et al. 2016 ; Zhang et al. 2019 . Central to this effect is that the spin-Hall effect (SHE) in N drives a spin current between N and F, which, via the inverse spin-Hall effect (ISHE), has a back action on the in-plane charge current in N. Since the magnitude of the spin current between N and F depends on the magnetization direction in F, the resulting change of the in-plane conductivity of N depends on it, too. Magnetotransport effects have also been observed in N | F | N trilayers, in which application of an electric field in one N layer leads to a current response in the other. This nonlocal response is known as magnon-mediated current drag Zhang and Zhang 2012a ; Zhang and Zhang 2012b ; Kajiwara et al. 2010 ; Cornelissen et al. 2015 ; Goennenwein et al. 2015 ; Schlitz et al. 2021 ; Li et al. 2016 ; Wu et al. 2016 ; Muduli et al. 2020 . Being a linear-response effect, the spin-Hall magnetoresistance is invariant under reversal of either the current direction or the magnetization direction. These symmetries are broken in the current response quadratic in the applied electric field E , which is therefore referred to as unidirectional spin-Hall magnetoresistance (USMR) Avci et al. 2015 ; Avci et al. 2018 ; Zhang and Vignale 2016 . Unidirectional magnetotransport effects have been proposed as a building block for spintronic applications, such as multi-state memory devices Avci et al. 2017b . The USMR effect was originally observed in multilayers involving a metallic ferromagnet, but subsequently predicted Wang et al. 2018 ; Sterk et al. 2019 and measured Liu et al. 2021 in bilayers featuring a ferromagnetic insulator. Figure 1: Schematic illustration of the four sources of unidirectional spin-Hall magnetoresistance in ferromagnetic-insulator–normal-metal multilayers considered here: (i) Joule heating in N drives a spin current from N to F via the spin-Seebeck effect. This spin current affects the in-plane charge current in N via the inverse spin-Hall effect (ISHE). (ii) Via the spin-Peltier effect, the linear-in- E spin current from N to F associated with the spin-Hall magnetoresistance effect changes the temperature in N. The temperature change implies a conductivity change and, hence, a quadratic-in- E contribution to the in-plane current response. (iii) Stimulated magnon excitation from spin-flip scattering at the F | N interface is intrinsically nonlinear. This gives a nonlinear dependence of the spin current through the F | N interface on the applied field E and, via the ISHE, of the charge response in N. (iv) Analogous to the spin-torque diode effect, a strong coherent excitation of magnetization modes in F causes a modulation of all linear response coefficients and, hence, a unidirectional response. The coordinate system of F in panel (iv) is rotated with respect to N and other panels for clarity. Processes linear in the electric field E are colored in blue, while processes quadratic in E are orange. In the literature, different sources of a nonlinear spin-Hall magnetotransport have been proposed for multilayers containing a ferromagnetic insulator, see Fig. 1 : (i) Joule heating in N, in combination with the spin-Seebeck Uchida et al. 2010 ; Bauer et al. 2012 and ISHE effects Cornelissen et al. 2015 , (ii) a linear-in- E conductivity change of N Sullivan et al. 2023 from the heating or cooling of N by the spin-Peltier effect Flipse et al. 2014 , (iii) the intrinsic nonlinearity of stimulated magnon emission from spin-flip scattering at the F | N interface Sterk et al. 2019 , and (iv) a modulation of the linear response from the coherent driving of large-amplitude magnetization modes in F Chiba et al. 2014 ; Liu et al. 2011 ; Kondou et al. 2012 ; Ganguly et al. 2014 ; Schreier et al. 2015 ; Sklenar et al. 2015 , analogous to the spin-torque diode effect Tulapurkar et al. 2005 ; Sankey et al. 2006 . Since the conductivity of N is dominated by electron-phonon scattering, the second mechanism is referred to as “phonon-mediated USMR”. Since these four mechanisms for the USMR effect have almost identical nonlinear signatures in electrical transport, distinguishing them requires an understanding of their dependence of relevant system parameters, such as the full dependence on magnetization direction or the sample geometry. In this article, we calculate the USMR effect for these four sources of the nonlinear response — which for brevity we refer to as “Joule-heating”, “phonon-mediated”, “interfacial”, and “spin-torque” USMR — in a common theoretical framework, so that we can compare their magnitude and characteristic dependence on the magnetization direction. Motivated by recent experiments that address spintronic effects on ultrafast time scales Fülöp et al. 2020 ; Kampfrath et al. 2013 ; Schellekens et al. 2014 ; Kimling et al. 2017 , we calculate these contributions to the USMR effect for driving frequencies \omega up to the THz frequency range. In addition, we consider unidirectional magnon-mediated current drag — the nonlocal counterpart of the USMR effect — in a trilayer geometry Cornelissen et al. 2015 , where the driving field E and the current response are in different layers. The frequency dependence and the comparison between local and nonlocal responses give additional possibilities to distinguish the different mechanisms for USMR. We find that, depending on the driving frequency \omega , of the four mechanisms mentioned above, all but the interfacial USMR mechanism can dominate the quadratic-in- E charge current response. Our work builds on and unifies a large number of previous theoretical works in this field. This includes geometric considerations of the magnetization direction dependence of the USMR effect Liu et al. 2021 ; Avci et al. 2015 , magnetization dynamics in F based on the Landau-Lifshitz-Gilbert equation, which is either solved numerically Liu et al. 2021 ; Wang et al. 2018 or analytically for a uniformly precessing mode Chiba et al. 2014 ; Ganguly et al. 2014 ; Chiba et al. 2015 , diffusion equations for spin and heat transport in N and F Sullivan et al. 2023 ; Sterk et al. 2019 ; Chiba et al. 2015 ; Wang et al. 2018 , and nonperturbative relations between spin accumulations and temperatures across F | N interfaces Sterk et al. 2019 . Our theory of the nonlinear spin-Hall magnetoresistance strongly relies on theories of the linear spin-Hall magnetoresistance effect. For F | N bilayers, such theories were put forward in Refs. Chen et al. 2013 ; Chen et al. 2016 ; Zhang et al. 2019 in the zero-frequency limit and in Ref. Reiss et al. 2021 for finite frequencies. In our companion article Franke et al. 2025 we extend the theory of Ref. Reiss et al. 2021 to nonlocal linear response in an N | F | N trilayer, accounting for the driving of coherent magnetization modes via the spin-Hall effect as well as for diffusive transport of thermal magnons in F Cornelissen et al. 2016 . In the present article, we use the fundamental linear-response relations derived in Ref. Franke et al. 2025 as the starting point for our calculations. One aspect in which the present article goes beyond the existing literature on the USMR effect is that we consider driving frequencies \omega up to the THz regime. In this frequency range, the frequency dependence of nonlinear effects in N | F | N trilayers arises primarily from magnon transport and the coherent excitation of magnetization modes in F. Both effects are fully captured within the linear response theory of the spin-Hall magnetoresistance effect Reiss et al. 2021 ; Franke et al. 2025 . Relevant time scales are the diffusion time for thermal magnons across F Cornelissen et al. 2016 ; Schmidt and Brouwer 2021 and the inverse spectral widths of coherent magnetization modes in F Chiba et al. 2014 ; Ganguly et al. 2014 ; Chiba et al. 2015 . The former time scales correspond to characteristic frequencies in the THz range, making the nonlinear response of such systems highly frequency-dependent in this regime. In contrast, the linear transport and sources of nonlinearity in N and at the F | N interface have only a weak intrinsic frequency dependence for \omega in the THz range and below Schellekens et al. 2014 ; Razdolski et al. 2017 ; Kampfrath et al. 2013 ; Seifert et al. 2018 . The remainder of this article is organized as follows: In Sec. II , we introduce the system of interest and the bilinear conductivity, which describes the quadratic-in- E response to an applied electric field E . In Sec. III , we review the spin-dependent transport equations for the normal-metal layers and briefly discuss the structure of the linear-response theory of Ref. Franke et al. 2025 , as far as necessary for the calculation of the quadratic-in- E response considered here. The theory of the quadratic-in- E current response is developed in Sec. IV . We present our result in terms of four response coefficients, calculated separately for each of the four sources of nonlinear response we consider, which each represent a different characteristic magnetization-direction dependence of the bilinear conductivity. Numerical estimates for material and device parameters of a typical Pt | YIG | Pt trilayer are given in Sec. V . We conclude in Sec. VI . The appendices contain additional details of our calculations and a brief summary of the linear-response results of Ref. Franke et al. 2025 used for our calculations. To facilitate the evaluation of our results for device parameters not considered by us or for other material combinations, an open source code is available to evaluate local and nonlocal, linear and nonlinear response for different materials and system sizes Franke 2025 . II N | F | N Trilayer and Bilinear Response We consider an N | F | N trilayer consisting of two normal metals N1 and N2, separated by a ferromagnetic insulator F, see Fig. 2 . We choose coordinates such that N1 and N2 are located at 0