The structural method for Ordinary Differential Equations S. Clain, M.T. Malheiro, G.J. Machado, R. Costa Abstract We design and analyse a new numerical method to solve ODE system based on the structural method. We compute approximations of solutions together with its derivatives up to order K K by solving an entire block corresponding to R R time steps. We build the physical relations that connect the function and derivative approximations at each time step by using the ODE and its derivatives and develop the structural equations that establish linear relations between the function and its derivative over the whole block of R R times steps. The non-linear system is solved and provide very accurate approximations with nice spectral resolution properties. Keywords structural method \cdot very high-order \cdot compact scheme \cdot EDO \cdot spectral resolution \cdot stability 1  Introduction Numerical methods to solve Ordinary Differential Equations has a long history since the papers of Bashforth and Adams (1883) and the paper of Runge (1895). We refer to the extensive review of J.C. Butcher about the Numerical methods for ordinary differential equations in the 20th century [ 1 ] . Multi-step methods use relations between the function and its first-derivative evaluated on several backward points t_{n+r} , with r=-R,\cdots,0 for the explicit methods and r=-R,\cdots,0,1 for the implicit ones. On the other hand, Runge-Kutta methods introduce intermediate sub-steps on [t_{n},t_{n+1}] with implicit or explicit relations between the auxiliary values and the derivative at their intermediate points. Consequently, the user faces a trade-off between the order of accuracy, the spectral resolution, the stability, the computational cost and chooses the formulae’ parameters in function of the objectives. Kastlunger and Wanner (1972) [ 2 ] Hairer and Wanner (1973) [ 3 ] , Enright (1974) [ 4 ] , Cash (1978) [ 5 ] , introduced the idea to use higher-order derivative in the design of the numerical method (Multi-derivative methods). They built relations between the different derivative approximations of the solution and the derivatives of the differential equation (see also [ 6 , 7 ] and the textbook of Butcher [ 8 ] about the contribution of Obrechkoff [ 9 ] ) with a particular interest for the two-derivatives case studied by [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] . In general, the determination of the coefficients to provide the coefficients of the multi-derivative methods in function of the number of derivatives and collocation points is quite cumbersome. For example, the multi-derivative R-K method requires many relations of compatibility to achieve a given order [ 2 , 13 , 14 ] , leading to complex calculations of the coefficients when dealing with third- or fourth- derivatives with s substages. Very recently, a new approach based on the combination of physical and structural equations have been developed for a restricted number of collocation points and derivatives [ 15 ] . The present paper proposes a complete and detailed study about the approximations of ODE system for the general case by using the structural method paradigm. Given the approximations of the function and its K derivative at time t_{n} , \displaystyle\Big(\phi_{n}^{(k)}\Big)_{k=0,\cdots,K} , we aim at computing a block of size R of approximation \displaystyle\left(\phi_{n+r}^{(k)}\right)_{k=0,\cdots,K} , r{\in\llbracket{1,R}\rrbracket} . To this end, we use two kinds of relations: (1) the physical relations that connect the function and derivative approximations at each time step t_{n+r} by using the ODE and its derivatives; (2) the structural equations that establish linear relations between the function and its derivative combining all the times steps t_{n+r} , r{\in\llbracket{0,R}\rrbracket} . The non-linear system is solved and provides very accurate approximations on the whole R -block. The advantage of the method regarding to the traditional ones is the evaluation of the coefficients that does not require analytic expressions, but, on the contrary, derives from the basis of a matrix kernel. In other words, coefficients come from a computational procedure whatever are the configurations (number of derivatives K and size of the block R ), and the technique is still available when one is dealing with non uniform time subdivisions. Additionally, all the intermediate approximations at time t_{n+1},\cdots,t_{n+R-1} are not auxiliary variables as in the multi-derivative RK case but are real approximations with the same global accuracy order of the method. The section 2 is dedicated to the design of the structural method where we detail the construction of the physical and structural equations. We also present an algorithm to solve the non-linear system and prove the convergence of the iterative method under a CFL-like condition. The consistency error and convergence order are established in section 3 where we determine the convergence order in function of K and R . Section 4 is dedicated to the stability where we prove that our method in unconditional stable for a wide set of configuration. We address the spectral resolution issue in section 5 and focus on the ability of our schemes to provide very high-resolution that enable to recover sub-scale information, that is variations occurring between two successive time steps. We produce in section 6 structural post-processing equations that enable to evaluate higher order derivatives than were not produce by the scheme itself. The section 7 concerns the numerical tests and benchmarks to assess the different properties of the structural scheme, namely the accuracy, the stability and the spectral resolution. We also demonstrate the superior quality of the method dealing with stiff and difficult problems, including chaotic system. At last we group in several annexes explicit formula of the structural equations when dealing with uniform grid, avoiding to compute the structural equations via the kernel method for the simplified case wher \Delta t is constant. 2  General design of the structural method Consider the generic first-order scalar Ordinary Differential Equation (ODE) problem \phi^{\prime}(t)=f(\phi(t),t),\ t\in[0,T], (1) together with the initial condition \phi(0)=\phi_{0} , with T>0 the final time and f\equiv f(z,t) a regular function in \mathbb{R}\times[0,T] . Let N\in\mathbb{N} , t_{n}=n\Delta t an uniform grid with n{\in\llbracket{0,N}\rrbracket} with T=N\Delta t and denote by \phi^{(k)} the k -derivative of the solution to equation ( 1 ). The approximations of the solution and the derivatives over the time subdivision is given by \phi^{(k)}_{n}\approx\phi^{(k)}(t_{n}). The core concept of the structural method consists in splitting the scheme into two subsystems of equations: the Physical Equations that only deal with the relation( 1 ) and its derivatives, and the Structural Equations that are linear relations, only depending on the grid, and definitively independent of the underlying problem. 2.1 Physical Equations Relation ( 1 ) involves the first derivative \phi^{(1)}(t) regarding the function \phi^{(0)}(t) and the time and reads \phi^{(1)}(t)={\texttt{df}^{(0)}\big[{t,\phi^{(0)}}\big]}=f\left(\phi^{(0)}(t),t\right). (2) Time derivative of equation ( 2 ) provides the new physical equation \phi^{(2)}(t)={\texttt{df}^{(1)}\big[{t,\phi^{(0)},\phi^{(1)}}\big]}=\partial_{z}f\left(\phi^{(0)}(t),t\right)\phi^{(1)}(t)+\partial_{t}f\left(\phi^{(0)}(t),t\right) (3) where \partial_{z}f and \partial_{t}f denote the derivatives in order to the first and second argument respectively. Once again, time derivative of equation ( 3 ) provides a relation between \phi and all the derivatives up to the third-order one \begin{split}\phi^{(3)}(t)={\texttt{df}^{(2)}\big[{t,\phi^{(0)},\phi^{(1)},\phi^{(2)}}\big]}&=\partial_{z}f\left(\phi^{(0)}(t),t\right)\phi^{(2)}(t)+\partial_{zz}f\left(\phi^{(0)}(t),t\right)\left[\phi^{(1)}(t)\right]^{2}\\ &\qquad+2\partial_{zt}f\left(\phi^{(0)}(t),t\right)\phi^{(1)}(t)+\partial_{tt}f\left(\phi^{(0)}(t),t\right).\end{split} (4) Applying the chain rule several times, provide the relations \phi^{(k+1)}(t)={\texttt{df}^{(k)}\big[{t,\phi^{(0)},\phi^{(1)},\ldots,\phi^{(k)}}\big]}=\frac{d}{dt}{\texttt{df}^{(k-1)}\big[{t,\phi^{(0)},\phi^{(1)},\ldots,\phi^{(k-1)}}\big]},\quad k{\in\llbracket{0,K-1}\rrbracket}. Remark : Note that, by construction, the application (t,z_{0},z_{1},\cdots,z_{k})\to{\texttt{df}^{(k)}\big[{t,z_{0},z_{1},\ldots,z_{k}}\big]} is a polynomial function with respect to z_{1},\cdots,z_{k} with non-linear coefficients solely depending on t and z_{0} corresponding to the partial derivative in time and z . \scriptstyle\blacksquare Physical equation just consists in substituting the exact values by its approximation \phi^{(k)}_{n} . Therefore, the first Physical Equation {{\texttt{PE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{1}}}}}(n) , deriving from relation ( 2 ), simply reads \phi^{(1)}_{n}={\texttt{df}^{(0)}\big[{t_{n},\phi_{n}^{(0)}}\big]}=f(\phi^{(0)}_{n},t_{n}). Similarly, we deduce the second Physical Equation {{\texttt{PE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{2}}}}}(n) from relation ( 3 ) and we have \phi^{(2)}_{n}={\texttt{df}^{(1)}\big[{t,\phi_{n}^{(0)},\phi_{n}^{(1)}}\big]}=\partial_{z}f(\phi^{(0)}_{n},t_{n})\phi^{(1)}_{n}+\partial_{t}f(\phi^{(0)}_{n},t_{n}) while the third Physical Equation {{\texttt{PE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{3}}}}}(n) deriving from relation ( 4 ) gives \displaystyle\ \phi^{(3)}_{n} \displaystyle= \displaystyle{\texttt{df}^{(2)}\big[{t,\phi_{n}^{(0)},\phi_{n}^{(1)},\phi_{n}^{(2)}}\big]} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\partial_{z}f\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n},t_{n}\right)\phi^{(2)}_{n}+\partial_{zz}f\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n},t_{n}\right)\left[\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right]^{2}+2\partial_{zt}f\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n},t_{n}\right)\phi^{(1)}_{n}+\partial_{tt}f\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n},t_{n}\right). Higher derivatives Physical Equations {{\texttt{PE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{4}}}}}(n) , {{\texttt{PE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{5}}}}}(n) are obtained similarly, and we define \phi_{n}^{(4)}={\texttt{df}^{(3)}\big[{t,\phi_{n}^{(0)},\phi_{n}^{(1)},\ldots,\phi_{n}^{(3)}}\big]} and \phi_{n}^{(5)}={\texttt{df}^{(4)}\big[{t,\phi_{n}^{(0)},\ldots,\phi_{n}^{(4)}}\big]} . Remark : It is important to note that the {{\texttt{PE}\raisebox{-3.30003pt}{{\,{k}}}}}(n) equations only involve the approximations (function and derivatives) at the same point t_{n} . The necessary relations between the different quantities around time t_{n} will give rise to the second subset of relations tagged Structural Equations we present hereafter. \scriptstyle\blacksquare 2.2 Structural Equations Given K the maximum derivative order, we provide a set of K Physical Equations, from PE 1 up to PE K , involving the derivatives \phi^{(k)}_{n} , k{\in\llbracket{0,K}\rrbracket} at any time t_{n} . Assuming that we know all the values at the time t_{n} , we want to determine the solutions and its derivatives within a block of size R of time step (labelled R -Block), that is, we want to compute the (K+1)\times R matrix \Phi_{n}=\left(\phi^{(k)}_{n+r}\right)_{k,r},\qquad k{\in\llbracket{0,K}\rrbracket},\ r{\in\llbracket{1,R}\rrbracket}, as depicts in Figure 1 . Figure 1: Grid of points for a structural scheme. We plot in blue the given values at the time t_{n} while the red points denote the unknowns that constitute the R -block The K Physical Equations at time t_{n+r} , r{\in\llbracket{1,R}\rrbracket} , provide R\times K relations, Therefore R additional equations have to be produced, taking into account the underlying structure of the grid that represents the time line discretization, in other words, the numerical schemes. 2.2.1 General design Structural equations are linear relations that involve approximations \phi^{(k)}_{n+r} for successive times t_{n+r} , r{\in\llbracket{0,R}\rrbracket} , and derivative order k{\in\llbracket{0,K}\rrbracket} . More precisely, an R-block structural equation reads \sum_{k=0}^{K}\sum_{r=0}^{R}a_{k,r}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\phi^{(k)}_{n+r}=0, (5) with {\boldsymbol{a}}=\left(a_{k,r}\right)_{k,r} k{\in\llbracket{0,K}\rrbracket} , r{\in\llbracket{0,R}\rrbracket} the (K+1)\times(R+1) matrix that gathers all the components while (\Delta t)^{k} stands for the different powers of the time increment. Remark : Noting by \widetilde{\Phi}_{n}=\left(\phi^{(k)}_{n+r}\right)_{k,r},\hskip 22.00006ptk{\in\llbracket{0,K}\rrbracket},\ r{\in\llbracket{0,R}\rrbracket}, the extension of matrix \Phi_{n} by including the initial stage n , relation 5 has the compact form {\boldsymbol{a}}{\boldsymbol{:}}\widetilde{\Phi}_{n}=0 where the operator {\boldsymbol{:}} stands for the double contraction. \scriptstyle\blacksquare In order to determine the coefficients a_{k,r} of the structural equation, we introduce the functional E({\boldsymbol{a}};\pi)=\sum_{k=0}^{K}\sum_{r=0}^{R}a_{k,r}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\pi^{(k)}(t_{n+r}) for any function \pi=\pi(t) , regular enough. We convert matrix {\boldsymbol{a}} into a one-index entries vector (still denoting {\boldsymbol{a}} for the sake of simplicity) by introducing the one-to one mapping (k,r)\to\ell=\ell(k,r)=1+k(R+1)+r from \llbracket 0,K\rrbracket\times\llbracket 0,R\rrbracket onto \llbracket 1,M\rrbracket , M=(K+1)(R+1) . Then the cost function also reads E({\boldsymbol{a}};\pi)=\sum_{k=0}^{K}\sum_{r=0}^{R}a_{\ell}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\pi^{(k)}(t_{n+r}),\qquad\ell=\ell(k,r). To design high-order of accuracy schemes, we impose the functional to exactly satisfies the relations for polynomial function up to a certain degree. To this end, we consider the list of polynomial functions \pi_{m}(t;t_{n})=\left(\frac{t-t_{n}}{\Delta t}\right)^{m-1},\quad m{\in\llbracket{1,M}\rrbracket}. By setting E({\boldsymbol{a}};\pi_{m})=0 for all m{\in\llbracket{1,M}\rrbracket} , we get the M\times M linear system \mathcal{M}{\boldsymbol{a}}=0 with the entries \mathcal{M}[m,\ell]=\pi^{(k)}_{m}(t_{n+r};t_{n})=C^{m}_{k}r^{m-1-k},\quad\ell=\ell(k,r) with C^{m}_{k}=\begin{cases}\frac{(m-1)!}{(m-1-k)!}&\text{if $m>k$},\\ 0&\text{otherwise}.\end{cases} for k{\in\llbracket{0,K}\rrbracket} and r{\in\llbracket{0,R}\rrbracket} . We highlight the matrix \mathcal{M} does not involve the grid parameter \Delta t and is also independent of the initial time t_{n} due to the choice of a uniform mesh and function \pi_{m}(.;t_{n}) . Remark : Illustrating, for K=2 and R , matrix \mathcal{M} is given by \mathcal{M}=\left(\begin{smallmatrix}1&1&\ldots&1&0&0&\ldots&0&0&0&\ldots&0\\ 0&1&\ldots&R^{1}&1&1&\ldots&1&0&0&\ldots&0\\ 0&1&\ldots&R^{2}&0&2&\ldots&2\times R^{1}&2&2&\ldots&2\\ 0&1&\ldots&R^{3}&0&3&\ldots&3\times R^{2}&0&3\times 2&\ldots&3\times 2\times R^{1}\\ \vdots&\vdots&\ddots&\vdots&\vdots&\vdots&\ddots&\vdots&\vdots&\vdots&\ddots&\vdots\\ 0&1&\ldots&R^{M-1}&0&(M-1)&\ldots&(M-1)\times R^{M-2}&0&(M-1)(M-2)&\ldots&(M-1)(M-2)R^{M-3}\\ \end{smallmatrix}\right). Note that the matrix does not contain the time step \Delta t . \scriptstyle\blacksquare We now analysis the linear system \mathcal{M}{\boldsymbol{a}}=0 and its properties. Definition 2.1 : A set of functions \left(\pi_{m}(t)\right)_{m=1,\ldots,M} is resolvent if, \big[\,\forall m{\in\llbracket{1,M}\rrbracket},\hskip 11.00003ptE({\boldsymbol{a}};\pi_{m})=0\,\big]\implies{\boldsymbol{a}}=0. Proposition 2.1 . The set of M polynomial functions of degree M-1 \tau_{k,r}(t):=\tau_{\ell(k,r)}(t)=\left(\frac{t-t_{n+r}}{\Delta t}\right)^{k}\prod_{s\neq r}\left(\frac{t-t_{n+s}}{\Delta t}\right)^{K+1},\quad k{\in\llbracket{0,K}\rrbracket},\ r{\in\llbracket{0,R}\rrbracket}, is resolvent. Proof. We first remark that the degree of all the polynomial functions is strictly lower than M. Second, all the polynomials are linearly independent hence represent a basis of \mathbb{P}_{M-1} . Noting that any derivative of order k^{\prime}\leqslant K and node r^{\prime}\neq r , we have \tau_{k,r}^{(k^{\prime})}(t_{n+r^{\prime}})=0 hence \displaystyle E({\boldsymbol{a}};\tau_{k,r}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{k^{\prime}=0}^{K}\sum_{r^{\prime}=0}^{R}a_{k^{\prime},r^{\prime}}\,\Delta t^{k^{\prime}}\,\pi_{k,r}^{(k^{\prime})}(t_{n+r^{\prime}}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{k^{\prime}=0}^{K}a_{k^{\prime},r}\,\Delta t^{k^{\prime}}\,\pi_{k,r}^{(k^{\prime})}(t_{n+r}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{k^{\prime}=k}^{K}a_{k^{\prime},r}\,\Delta t^{k^{\prime}}\,\pi_{k,r}^{(k^{\prime})}(t_{n+r})=\sum_{k^{\prime}=k}^{K}a_{k^{\prime},r}\,\Delta t^{k^{\prime}-k}\,b_{k^{\prime}-k,r}, where for k^{\prime}\geq k we have b_{k^{\prime}-k,r}=\left[\prod_{s\neq r}\left(\frac{t-t_{n+s}}{\Delta t}\right)^{K+1}\right]^{(k^{\prime}-k)}_{\boldsymbol{\big|t=t_{n+r}}}. Notice that for k=k^{\prime} , we obtain b_{0,r}=\left[\prod_{s\neq r}\left(\frac{t-t_{n+s}}{\Delta t}\right)^{K+1}\right]_{\boldsymbol{\big|t=t_{n+r}}}=\prod_{s\neq r}\left(r-s\right)^{K+1}\neq 0. The rest of the proof is achieved by induction. Let r\in{\in\llbracket{0,R}\rrbracket} . For k=K , we just have 0=E({\boldsymbol{a}};\tau_{K,r})=a_{K,r}b_{0,r}; hence a_{K,r}=0 . Now, take k=K-1 , then we have 0=E({\boldsymbol{a}};\tau_{{K-1},r})=a_{K,r}\,\Delta t\,b_{1,r}+a_{K-1,r}b_{0,r}=a_{K-1,r}b_{0,r}. Therefore a_{K-1,r}=0 . Similarly, we prove successively that a_{K-2,r}=0 , a_{K-3,r}=0 until a_{0,r}=0 . In conclusion, all the coefficients of {\boldsymbol{a}} are null, so the set of functions is resolvent and the associated matrix \mathcal{M} is non-singular. ∎ In particular, the set of polynomials \pi_{m}(t;t_{n}) is also a basis of \mathbb{P}_{M-1} , therefore, due to the linearity of the functional regarding the functions \pi , it is also resolvent, thus matrix \mathcal{M} is non-singular. Definition 2.2 : Let S be the number of structural equations we intend to produce. We denote by \mathcal{K}^{S}\subset\mathbb{R}^{M} the kernel of the rectangular (M-S)\times M matrix \mathcal{M}[1:M-S,:] , where we eliminated the S last rows. Since \mathcal{M} is non-singular, the matrix \mathcal{M}[1:M-S,:] enjoys the maximum rank property hence, the dimension of \mathcal{K}^{S} is S and contains a basis of S linear independent vectors of \mathbb{R}^{M} we shall denote {\boldsymbol{a}}^{s} , s{\in\llbracket{1,S}\rrbracket} . Definition 2.3 : Given K the number of derivatives, R the size of the block and let S the total number of structural equations, we denote by {{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.30003pt}{{\,{K}\,{R}}}}\raisebox{5.50002pt}{{{\hskip-12.70496pt{S} }}}\hskip 2.19997pt}(s) , s{\in\llbracket{1,S}\rrbracket} the structural equation number s corresponding to the vector {\boldsymbol{a}}^{s}\in\mathcal{K}^{S} . Remark : If we denote by A , the S\times M matrix constituted of the line vectors ({\boldsymbol{a}}^{s})^{\textrm{\rm t}} , s\in{\in\llbracket{1,S}\rrbracket} , we have \mathcal{A}^{\textrm{\rm t}}=0\in\mathbb{R}^{S} . \scriptstyle\blacksquare 2.2.2 Choice of the structural equations A first observation is that we do not have uniqueness of the set of S structural equations. Particularly, the conditioning of the whole system (the coupling of physical and structural equations) may depend on a wise choice of the basis, i.e. the choice of the coefficients of the structural equations. We list several methods to produce the S basis vectors. I. Analytic method. One can derive analytic expression of the coefficients from the system E({\boldsymbol{a}};\pi_{m})=0 , m=1,\ldots,M-S using symbolic computation, assuming a uniform time subdivision. Such relations avoid the computation of matrix \mathcal{M} and are mandatory for the stability analysis. We report in annexe A sets of structural equations {{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{K}\,{R}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{S} }}}\thinspace}(s) for useful values of K and R . Remark : The analytical expressions of vectors ({\boldsymbol{a}}^{s})_{s=1}^{S} given in annexe A do not necessarily correspond to an orthogonal basis of \mathcal{K}^{S} , that is we do not have \langle{\boldsymbol{a}}^{s},{\boldsymbol{a}}^{m}\rangle=\delta_{sm} . \scriptstyle\blacksquare II. Numerical method. For larger value of K and R or when dealing with a non-uniform grid, we compute an orthogonal basis of the kernel \mathcal{K}^{S} using the complete SVD decomposition \mathcal{M}[1:M-S,1:M]=U\Sigma V^{\textrm{\rm t}} with U a rectangular (M-S)\times M matrix, \Sigma the diagonal M\times M matrix and V^{\textrm{\rm t}} the square orthogonal M\times M . Since the S last diagonal entries of \Sigma are null, we deduce that the S last column vectors of V define an orthogonal basis of \mathcal{K}^{S} . III. Hierarchical basis. We want that the first vector {\boldsymbol{a}}^{1} provides the larger order of consistency error. The second vector {\boldsymbol{a}}^{2} reduces the consistency order of one and so forth. To provide such a property, we propose an algorithm to set up a numerical hierarchical basis of kernel \mathcal{K}^{S} . 1. We first compute the sole vector {\boldsymbol{a}}^{1} of the kernel \mathcal{K}^{1} . 2. We then determine a basis of the kernel \mathcal{K}^{2} . Noting that {\boldsymbol{a}}^{1} automatically belongs to \mathcal{K}^{2} , we determine a normalized vector {\boldsymbol{a}}^{2}\in\mathcal{K}^{2} orthogonal to \mathcal{K}^{1} using an orthogonalization procedure. Moreover, the consistency error associated to {\boldsymbol{a}}^{2} of one order lower than {\boldsymbol{a}}^{1} since we reduce the number of constraints E({\boldsymbol{a}},\pi^{m})=0 . 3. For a given stage S^{\prime}0 centred at the origin and assume that the function (z,t)\to f(z,t) is a C^{K+1}(\mathbb{R}\times[0,T]) function. Then, for any k{\in\llbracket{1,K}\rrbracket} , the functions (t,z_{0},\ldots,z_{k-1})\to z_{k}={\texttt{df}^{(k-1)}\big[{t,z_{0},\ldots,z_{k-1}}\big]} are bounded by a constant M_{k} , and they are L_{k} uniformly Lipschitz in time on the compact set B(M_{0})\times\cdots\times B(M_{k-1}) , with |z_{k}-z_{k}^{\prime}|\leqslant L_{k}\left(\sum_{\kappa=0}^{k-1}|z_{\kappa}-z_{\kappa}^{\prime}|\right). (7) Proof. We prove the property by induction. Since (t,z_{0}) belongs to the compact set [0,T]\times B(M_{0}) , continuity of f yields that z_{1}={\texttt{df}^{(0)}\big[{t,z_{0}}\big]} is bounded and belong to a compact set we include inside a closed ball B(M_{1}) centred at the origin for M_{1} large enough. On the other hand, for two values z_{0},z_{0}^{\prime}\in B(M_{0}) , one has {\texttt{df}^{(0)}\big[{t,z_{0}}\big]}-{\texttt{df}^{(0)}\big[{t,z_{0}^{\prime}}\big]}=f(t,z_{0})-f(t,z_{0}^{\prime})=\partial_{z}f\big(t,\theta z_{0}+(1-\theta)z_{0}^{\prime}\big)(z_{0}-z_{0}^{\prime}) with \theta\in[0,1] . Hence, the intermediate point belongs to the ball \overline{B}(M_{0}) . Denoting L_{1}=\max_{\zeta\in B(M_{0})\atop t\in[0,T]}\partial_{z}f(\zeta,t), we provide the uniform in time Lipschitz property |{\texttt{df}^{(0)}\big[{t,z_{0}}\big]}-{\texttt{df}^{(0)}\big[{t,z_{0}^{\prime}}\big]}|\leqslant L_{1}|z_{0}-z_{0}^{\prime}|. Assume that the properties hold for k0 \phi(t_{n}+h)=\pi(h;t_{n})+\frac{h^{K(R+1)+1}}{(K(R+1)+1)!}\phi^{(K(R+1)+1)}(t_{n}+\theta_{0}h),\ \theta_{0}\in[0,1], where \pi(h;t_{n}) is the Taylor polynomial of degree K(R+1) and \theta_{0}\in[0,1] . On the other hand, the Taylor expansion for k -derivatives regarding variable h is \phi^{(k)}(t_{n}+h)=\pi^{(k)}(h;t_{n})+\frac{h^{K(R+1)+1-k}}{(K(R+1)+1-k)!}\phi^{(K(R+1)+1)}(t_{n}+\theta_{k}h). Consistency error corresponds to the error when we substitute the approximation by the exact solution in the structural equation. We have the following proposition. Proposition 3.2 . Let e^{s}_{n} the consistency error for the structural equation SE[s] given by e^{s}_{n}=\sum_{k=0}^{K}\sum_{r=0}^{R}a_{k,r}^{s}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\phi^{(k)}(t_{n}+r\Delta t). (14) Then |e^{s}_{n}|\leqslant C_{K,R}\,\Delta t^{K(R+1)+1} with C_{K,R} a real number independent of \Delta t . Proof. Taking advantage that the relation is exact for polynomial \pi(h;t_{n}) , as a function of h , we deduce with h=\Delta t,2\Delta t,\cdots,R\Delta t \displaystyle e^{s}_{n} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{k=0}^{K}\sum_{r=0}^{R}a_{k,r}^{s}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\frac{(r\Delta t)^{K(R+1)+1-k}}{(K(R+1)+1-k)!}\phi^{(K(R+1)+1)}(t_{n}+\theta_{r,k}r\Delta t), \displaystyle= \displaystyle\Delta t^{K(R+1)+1}\,\sum_{k=0}^{K}\sum_{r=0}^{R}a_{k,r}^{s}\frac{r^{K(R+1)+1-k}}{\big(K(R+1)+1-k\big)!}\phi^{(K(R+1)+1)}(t_{n}+\theta_{r,k}r\Delta t), \displaystyle|e^{s}_{n}| \displaystyle\leqslant \displaystyle\Delta t^{K(R+1)+1}\,L_{K,R}\sum_{k=0}^{K}\sum_{r=0}^{R}|a_{k,r}^{s}|\;\frac{r^{K(R+1)+1-k}}{\big(K(R+1)+1-k\big)!}, with L_{K,R}=\max_{t\in[0,T]}|\phi^{(K(R+1)+1)}(t)|. Setting C^{s}_{K,R}=L_{K,R}\sum_{k=0}^{K}\sum_{r=0}^{R}|a_{k,r}^{s}|\;\frac{r^{K(R+1)+1-k}}{\big(K(R+1)+1-k\big)!}, provides the relation ( 14 ). ∎ If \mathcal{E}_{n}=(e^{s}_{n})_{s=1,\cdots,R} stands for the vector that gathers the truncation errors, therefore we have \displaystyle\|\mathcal{E}_{n}\|_{\infty}=C_{K,R}\,\Delta t^{K(R+1)+1} with C_{K,R}=\max_{s=1,\cdots,R}C^{s}_{K,R} . 3.2 Convergence order of the Skm[K,R] scheme We adapt the Grönwall-type lemma for the R block method. Lemma 3.3 . let (e_{n})_{n=0}^{N} a sequence with N=S\times R and assume that, for \displaystyle\Delta t\leqslant\overline{\Delta}t with \overline{\Delta}t to be fixed further, there exist non negative real numbers B^{0},\cdots,B^{K} , independent of \Delta t such that |e_{(s+1)R}|\leqslant|e_{sR}|\left(1+\sum_{k=1}^{K}\Delta t^{k}\,B^{k}\right)+B^{0}\,\Delta t^{P+1}. Then for any s{\in\llbracket{1,S}\rrbracket} , we have the estimate |e_{sR}|\leqslant\widetilde{C}\,\Delta t^{P}+\widehat{C}|e_{0}|. (15) where \widetilde{C} and \widehat{C} are constants independent of \Delta t . Proof. Letting C=\sum_{k=1}^{K}\overline{\Delta}t^{k-1}\,B^{k}. From the assumption, we obtain the inequality for any s |e_{(s+1)R}|\leqslant|e_{sR}|(1+C\Delta t)+B^{0}\,\Delta t^{P+1}. By induction, we get \displaystyle|e_{(s+1)R}| \displaystyle\leqslant \displaystyle(1+C\Delta t)^{s}|e_{0}|+B^{0}\,\Delta t^{P+1}\sum_{\sigma=0}^{s}(1+C\Delta t)^{\sigma}, \displaystyle\leqslant \displaystyle\exp(Cs\Delta t)|e_{0}|+B^{0}\,\Delta t^{P}\sum_{\sigma=0}^{s}\Delta t\exp(C\sigma\Delta t), \displaystyle\leqslant \displaystyle\exp(CT)|e_{0}|+B^{0}\,\Delta t^{P}\int_{0}^{T}\exp(C\xi)d\xi, \displaystyle\leqslant \displaystyle\exp(CT)|e_{0}|+B^{0}\,\Delta t^{P}\frac{\exp(CT)-1}{C} Therefore, we deduce the inequality ( 15 ) with \widetilde{C}=B^{0}\,\frac{\exp(CT)-1}{C},\qquad\widehat{C}=\exp(CT). ∎ Proposition 3.4 . There exists \overline{\Delta t} such that, for \Delta t\leqslant\overline{\Delta t} , we have the estimates for any sR\leqslant N \big|\phi^{(0)}_{sR}-\overline{\phi}^{(0)}_{sR}\big|\leqslant\overline{C}\,\Delta t^{K(R+1)}, (16) where \overline{C} is a real number independent of \Delta t . Proof. The difference between the consistency error and the approximation gives \sum_{k=0}^{K}\Delta t^{k}\,A^{(k)}\Big(\Phi_{n}^{(k)}-\overline{\Phi}_{n}^{(k)}\Big)+\sum_{k=0}^{K}\widehat{\boldsymbol{a}}_{k}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\big(\phi^{(k)}_{n}-\overline{\phi}^{(k)}_{n})=\mathcal{E}_{n} Using lemma 3.1 , we rewrite the consistency error under the form \displaystyle\big(\Phi_{n}^{(0)}-\overline{\Phi}_{n}^{(0)}\big) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\big(\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\overline{\phi}^{(0)}_{n}\big){\boldsymbol{1}\hskip-5.0pt\boldsymbol{1}}-\sum_{k=1}^{K}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\Big(A^{(0)}\Big)^{-1}A^{(k)}\Big(\Phi_{n}^{(k)}-\overline{\Phi}_{n}^{(k)}\Big) \displaystyle-\sum_{k=1}^{K}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\Big(A^{(0)}\Big)^{-1}\widehat{\boldsymbol{a}}_{k}\big(\phi^{(k)}_{n}-\overline{\phi}^{(k)}_{n})+\Big(A^{(0)}\Big)^{-1}\mathcal{E}_{n} Using the L^{\infty} norm \|.\|_{\infty} , we have \displaystyle{\big\|}\Phi_{n}^{(0)}-\overline{\Phi}_{n}^{(0)}{\big\|}_{\infty} \displaystyle\leqslant \displaystyle{\big|}\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\overline{\phi}^{(0)}_{n}{\big|}+\sum_{k=1}^{K}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\left\|\Big(A^{(0)}\Big)^{-1}A^{(k)}\right\|_{\infty}{\big\|}\Phi_{n}^{(k)}-\overline{\Phi}_{n}^{(k)}{\big\|}_{\infty} \displaystyle\sum_{k=1}^{K}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\left\|\Big(A^{(0)}\Big)^{-1}\widehat{\boldsymbol{a}}_{k}\right\|_{\infty}{\big|}\phi^{(k)}_{n}-\overline{\phi}^{(k)}_{n}{\big|}+\left\|\Big(A^{(0)}\Big)^{-1}\right\|_{\infty}{\big\|}\mathcal{E}_{n}{\big\|}_{\infty} From inequalities ( 9 ), we then deduce {\big\|}\Phi_{n}^{(k)}-\overline{\Phi}_{n}^{(k)}{\big\|}_{\infty}\leqslant\widehat{L}_{k}{\big\|}\Phi_{n}^{(0)}-\overline{\Phi}_{n}^{(0)}{\big\|}_{\infty}. On the other side, we also have \big|\phi^{(k)}_{n}-\overline{\phi}^{(k)}_{n}\big|\leqslant\widehat{L}_{k}\big|\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\overline{\phi}^{(0)}_{n}\big|. We now deduce, using the consistency error estimate C_{f}\,\Delta t\,\big\|\Phi_{n}^{(0)}-\overline{\Phi}_{n}^{(0)}\big\|_{\infty}\leqslant C_{b}\,\Delta t\,\big|\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\overline{\phi}^{(0)}_{n}\big|+\left\|\Big(A^{(0)}\Big)^{-1}\right\|_{\infty}C_{K,R}\,\Delta t^{K(R+1)+1}, (17) where \displaystyle C_{f}\,\Delta t \displaystyle= \displaystyle 1-\sum_{k=1}^{K}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\widehat{L}_{k}\left\|\Big(A^{(0)}\Big)^{-1}A^{(k)}\right\|_{\infty}, \displaystyle C_{b}\,\Delta t \displaystyle= \displaystyle 1+\sum_{k=1}^{K}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\widehat{L}_{k}\left\|\Big(A^{(0)}\Big)^{-1}\widehat{\boldsymbol{a}}_{k}\right\|_{\infty}. Thanks to the inequality {\big|}\phi^{(0)}_{n+R}-\overline{\phi}^{(0)}_{n+R}{\big|}\leqslant{\big\|}\Phi_{n}^{(0)}-\overline{\Phi}_{n}^{(0)}{\big\|}_{\infty}, we deduce \big|\phi^{(0)}_{n+R}-\overline{\phi}^{(0)}_{n+R}\big|\leqslant\frac{C_{b}\,\Delta t}{C_{f}\,\Delta t}\big|\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\overline{\phi}^{(0)}_{n}\big|+\left\|\Big(A^{(0)}\Big)^{-1}\right\|_{\infty}\frac{C_{K,R}}{C_{f}\,\Delta t}\,\Delta t^{K(R+1)+1} We now define \overline{\Delta}t>0 such that C_{f}\,\overline{\Delta}t=1/2 . Consequently, for any \Delta t<\overline{\Delta}t , we have C_{f}\,\Delta t\geq 1/2 and deduce, for \Delta t\leqslant\overline{\Delta}t , the inequality \frac{C_{b}\,\Delta t}{C_{f}\,\Delta t}\leqslant 1+\frac{C_{b}\,\Delta t-C_{f}\,\Delta t}{C_{f}\,\Delta t}\leqslant 1+2\sum_{k=1}^{K}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\widehat{L}_{k}\left(\left\|\Big(A^{(0)}\Big)^{-1}A^{(k)}\right\|_{\infty}+\left\|\Big(A^{(0)}\Big)^{-1}\widehat{\boldsymbol{a}}_{k}\right\|_{\infty}\right) We finally conclude that for \Delta t\leqslant\overline{\Delta}t , we have \big|\phi^{(0)}_{n+R}-\overline{\phi}^{(0)}_{n+R}\big|\leqslant\big|\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\overline{\phi}^{(0)}_{n}\big|\left(1+\sum_{k=1}^{K}\,\Delta t^{k}\,B^{k}\right)+B^{0}\,\Delta t^{K(R+1)+1} where the real number B^{0},\cdots,B^{K} do not depend on \Delta t . Since we treat the differential equation using blocks of size R , we have n=sR and from Lemma 3.3 , relation ( 15 ) holds, that is \big|\phi^{(0)}_{sR}-\overline{\phi}^{(0)}_{sR}\big|\leqslant\widetilde{C}\,\Delta t^{K(R+1)}+\widehat{C}|e_{0}|. If one use the exact solution at time t=0 for the initial condition we deduce that that the error error is of order \Delta t^{K(R+1)} ∎ Theorem 3.5 . Let n=sR . Under the assumption of Proposition 3.4 , there exists a real value C_{K,R} independent of \Delta t , r s and k such that, if \Delta t\leqslant\overline{\Delta t} \big|\phi^{(k)}_{n+r}-\phi^{(k)}(t_{n+r})\big|\leqslant C\,\Delta t^{K(R+1)}. (18) The scheme is of order K(R+1) at any points and for any derivatives. Proof. From relation ( 17 ) and \displaystyle\big|\phi^{(0)}_{n+r}-\phi^{(0)}(t_{n+r})\big|\leqslant\big\|\Phi_{n}^{(0)}-\overline{\Phi}_{n}^{(0)}\big\|_{\infty} we deduce \big|\phi^{(0)}_{n+r}-\phi^{(0)}(t_{n+r})\big|\leqslant\big|\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\overline{\phi}^{(0)}_{n}\big|\left(1+\sum_{k=1}^{K}\Delta t^{k}\,B^{k}\right)+B^{0}\,\Delta t^{K(R+1)+1}, and with the estimate ( 16 ), we deduce the zero-derivative convergence order \displaystyle\big|\phi^{(0)}_{n+r}-\phi^{(0)}(t_{n+r})\big| \displaystyle\leqslant \displaystyle\widetilde{C}\,\Delta t^{K(R+1)}\,\left(1+\sum_{k=1}^{K}\,\Delta t^{k}\,B^{k}\right)+B^{0}\,\Delta t^{K(R+1)+1} \displaystyle\leqslant \displaystyle C^{0}_{K,R}\,\Delta t^{K(R+1)}. where the C^{0}_{K,R} does not depend on \Delta t . On the other hand, using the Lipschitz property of Lemma 2.3 , we get \big|\phi^{(k)}_{n+r}-\phi^{(k)}(t_{n+r})\big|\leqslant\widehat{L}_{k}\big|\phi^{(0)}_{n+r}-\phi^{(0)}(t_{n+r})\big|\leqslant C^{k}_{K,R}\,\Delta t^{K(R+1)}. with C^{k}_{K,R}=\widehat{L}_{k}C^{0}_{K,R} . Let C=\max C^{k}_{K,R} over k{\in\llbracket{0,K}\rrbracket} and we deduce the convergence ( 18 ). ∎ 4  Linear stability 4.1 Linear stability condition To study the linear stability of these schemes we apply the von Neumann stability analysis. This involves assessing the growth factor of Fourier modes and ensuring that the magnitude of this growth factor does not exceed 1 for each time step. The analysis is based on the solution of the simple linear ordinary equation \phi^{(1)}=\lambda\phi^{(0)} with \lambda\in\mathbb{C} . The first physical equation PE 1 then reads \phi_{n+r}^{(1)}=\lambda\phi_{n+r}^{(0)} for all points of the R -block. Generalizing to the k th physical equation PE k given by \phi^{(k)}=\lambda^{k}\phi^{(0)} and then \phi_{n+r}^{(k)}=\lambda^{k}\phi_{n+r}^{(0)} . Substituting \phi^{(k)}_{n+r} with \lambda^{k}\phi^{(0)}_{n+r} , r{\in\llbracket{,R}\rrbracket} in the R structural equations, we obtain the following system \sum_{k=0}^{K}\sum_{r=0}^{R}a_{k,r}^{s}(\lambda\Delta t)^{k}\phi^{(0)}_{n+r}=0,\quad s{\in\llbracket{1,R}\rrbracket}, (19) we rewrite with z=\lambda\Delta t \sum_{r=1}^{R}\left(\sum_{k=0}^{K}a_{k,r}^{s}z^{k}\right)\phi^{(0)}_{n+r}=-\left(\sum_{k=0}^{K}a_{k,0}^{s}z^{k}\right)\phi^{(0)}_{n},\quad s{\in\llbracket{1,R}\rrbracket}. Let g_{sr}(z)=\sum_{k=0}^{K}a_{k,r}^{s}z^{k},\quad G(z)=\Big(g_{sr}(z)\Big)_{s,r=1}^{R},\quad b(z)=\Big(g_{s0}(z)\Big)_{s=1}^{R}, system ( 19 ) takes the matrix form G(z)\Phi_{n}^{(0)}=-b(z)\phi_{n}^{(0)},\implies\Phi_{n}^{(0)}=\chi(z)\phi_{n}^{(0)} (20) where \chi(z)=-G^{-1}(z)b(z)\in\mathbb{R}^{R} is the vector of entries \chi_{r}(z) . Stability of the numerical solution requires that |\chi_{r}(z)|\leqslant 1 for any r{\in\llbracket{1,R}\rrbracket} , but only \chi_{R}(z) is of interest since we use vector \Phi_{n+R} to compute the next R -block. Hence we focus the study on the amplification function \chi_{R}(z) derived from the system ( 20 ) to define the notion of A -Stability. Definition 4.1 : The scheme is A-stable if |\chi_{R}(z)|\leqslant 1 . Since the choice of the set of S structural equations is not unique, we prove that the stability condition is independent of the basis of the kernel. Proposition 4.1 . Let A=[a^{s}]_{R\times M} and \widetilde{A}=[\widetilde{a}^{s}]_{S\times M} be two basis of the Kernel \mathcal{K}^{R} given by ( 6 ). Then we have {G}(z)\Phi_{n}^{(0)}=-{b}(z)\phi_{n}^{(0)},\qquad\widetilde{G}(z)\Phi_{n}^{(0)}=-\widetilde{b}(z)\phi_{n}^{(0)} and the amplification vector \chi(z) is independent of the basis. Proof. Let \widetilde{A} and A be two different kernel bases, as in ( 6 ). We have \widetilde{A}=\Xi A where \Xi is a nonsingular R\times R matrix that changes the basis, that is \widetilde{G}=\Xi G and \widetilde{b}=\Xi b . From the system ( 20 ) we have \Phi_{n}^{(0)}=\chi(z)\phi_{n}^{(0)} . On the other hand, using the alternative basis provides the relation \widetilde{G}(z)\Phi_{n}^{(0)}=-\widetilde{b}(z)\phi_{n}^{(0)} and \widetilde{\chi}(z)=-\widetilde{G}^{-1}(z)\widetilde{b}(z)=-\Big(\Xi G(z)\Big)^{-1}\Xi b(x)=-G^{-1}(z)\big(\Xi^{-1}\Xi\big)b(x)=\chi(z). Hence \chi=\widetilde{\chi} , and the amplification functions \chi_{R} do not depend on the choice of the kernel basis. In particular, the stability condition |\chi_{R}(z)|\leqslant 1 of the approximation at time t_{n+R} is independent of the choice of the structural equations. ∎ In order to study the stability, we determine a new expression of the amplification function. Proposition 4.2 . The amplification coefficient for time t_{n+R} is given by \chi_{R}(z)=\frac{\det(G(z)({\textrm{\rm Id}}-e_{R}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}})-b(z)e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}})}{\det(G(z))} (21) where Id is the identity matrix of order R and e_{R} the last canonic column vector. In particular, \chi_{R}(z) is a rational function. Proof. We apply Cramer’s rule on the system ( 20 ) to obtain the last column of unknowns. Consider the triangular superior matrix {\textrm{\rm Id}}-e_{R}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}}+\Phi_{n}^{(0)}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}} , which is the identity matrix with the column R replaced by the vector \Phi_{n}^{(0)} . Multiplying on the left by G , we have G({\textrm{\rm Id}}-e_{R}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}}+\Phi_{n}^{(0)}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}})=G({\textrm{\rm Id}}-e_{R}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}})-b\phi_{n}^{(0)}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}}. On the one hand, \det\big({\textrm{\rm Id}}-e_{R}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}}+\Phi_{n}^{(0)}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}}\big)=\phi_{n+R}^{(0)} , and we get \det\big(G({\textrm{\rm Id}}-e_{R}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}}+\Phi_{n}^{(0)}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}})\big)=\det(G)\ \phi_{n+R}^{(0)}. Algebraic manipulations provides the expression \det\big(G({\textrm{\rm Id}}-e_{R}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}}+\Phi_{n}^{(0)}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}})\big)=\det\big(G({\textrm{\rm Id}}-e_{R}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}})-b\phi_{n}^{(0)}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}}\big)=\det\big(G({\textrm{\rm Id}}-e_{R}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}})-be_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}}\big)\ \phi_{n}^{(0)}. We then obtain \phi_{n+R}^{(0)}(z)=\frac{\det\big(G(z)({\textrm{\rm Id}}-e_{R}e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}})-b(z)e_{R}^{\textrm{\rm t}}\big)}{\det\big(G(z)\big)}\phi_{n}^{(0)}; thus relation ( 21 ) holds. Since the entries of the matrix G and vector b are polynomials of z of degree K with real coefficients, the amplification function \chi_{R} is a rational function with real coefficients. ∎ 4.2 Criteria for the unconditional stability We develop several tools that enable to analyse the stability of the Skm[K,R] scheme. The methodology lies on the assumption that the transfer function reads as \displaystyle\chi_{R}(z)=\frac{p(z)}{p(-z)} where p(z) is a polynomial function. Then using the Routh-Hurwitz criterion [ 17 ] , we show that roots of polynomial p(z) have a negative real part from which we deduce the A -stability. Lemma 4.3 . Assume that the transfer function associated to scheme Skm[K,R] is given by \displaystyle\chi_{R}(z)=\frac{p(z)}{p(-z)} where p(z) is a polynomial in \mathbb{C} which all roots have a negative real part. Then the scheme Skm[K,R] is A-stable. Proof. If p(z) has all its roots in the left-half complex plane, then p(-z) has all its roots in the right-half complex plane and \chi_{R}(z) is analytic in the left-half complex plane. By the Maximum Modulus Theorem, we have that the maximum value of |\chi_{R}| occurs on the boundary of the semicircular region bounded by the imaginary axis from -\rho to \rho and the semicircle z=\rho e^{$$\theta} , \theta\in[\pi/2,3\pi/2] . Since \displaystyle\chi_{R}(z)=\frac{p(z)}{p(-z)} , then for any \theta\in[\pi/2,3\pi/2] , \displaystyle\lim_{\rho\to+\infty}|\chi_{R}(z)|=1 . On the other hand, for imaginary number z=$$y , y\in\mathbb{R} , we have \displaystyle|\chi_{R}($$y)|=\left|\frac{p($$y)}{p(-$$y)}\right|=1 . We then conclude that \displaystyle|\chi_{R}(z)|\leqslant 1 for \mathop{\rm Re}\nolimits{z}\leqslant 0 . ∎ From lemma ( 4.3 ), the unconditional stability holds if: (1) \displaystyle\chi_{R}(z)=\frac{p(z)}{p(-z)} and, (2) all zeros of p(z) are in the left complex half-plane. For the latter condition, we shall prove that p(z) is a Hurwitz stable polynomial [ 18 ] , we can assess by applying the Routh-Hurwitz stability criterion, [ 18 , 19 ] . Definition 4.2 : Let p(z)=a_{I}z^{I}+a_{I-1}z^{I-1}+\cdots+a_{1}z+a_{0} (22) be a polynomial with real coefficients. The I\times I matrix H=\begin{bmatrix}a_{I-1}&a_{I-3}&a_{I-5}&a_{I-7}&a_{I-9}&\cdots&0\\ a_{I}&a_{I-2}&a_{I-4}&a_{I-6}&a_{I-8}&\cdots&0\\ 0&a_{I-1}&a_{I-3}&a_{I-5}&a_{I-7}&\cdots&0\\ 0&a_{I}&a_{I-2}&a_{I-4}&a_{I-6}&\cdots&0\\ 0&0&a_{I-1}&a_{I-3}&a_{I-5}&\cdots&0\\ 0&0&a_{I}&a_{I-2}&a_{I-4}&\cdots&0\\ \vdots&\vdots&\vdots&\vdots&\vdots&\cdots&a_{0}\end{bmatrix} is called the Hurwitz matrix associated with p(z) . Definition 4.3 : The polynomial p(z) is called Hurwitz polynomial if \mathop{\rm Re}\nolimits{z_{i}}<0 , for i{\in\llbracket{1,I}\rrbracket} , where z_{i} are the roots of p(z) . The Routh-Hurwitz criterion is given in the following theorem (see [ 17 ] ). Theorem 4.4 . The polynomial p(z) given in ( 22 ) is a Hurwitz polynomial if and only if each principal minor of \det H is strictly positive, that is, m_{i}>0, for i{\in\llbracket{1,I}\rrbracket} where m_{i}=\begin{vmatrix}a_{I-1}&a_{I-3}&a_{I-5}&\cdots&0\\ a_{I}&a_{I-2}&a_{I-4}&\cdots&0\\ 0&a_{I-1}&a_{I-3}&\cdots&0\\ 0&a_{I}&a_{I-2}&\cdots&0\\ \vdots&\vdots&\vdots&\cdots&a_{I-i}\end{vmatrix}. From Lemma 4.3 and the definition of a Hurwitz polynomial we deduce the following theorem. Theorem 4.5 . If \displaystyle\chi_{R}(z)=\frac{p(z)}{p(-z)} is the transfer function associated to Skm[K,R] , where p(z) is a Hurwitz polynomial in \mathbb{C} , then the scheme Skm[K,R] is A-stable. We apply the theorem to check the A-stability of several schemes Skm[K,R] using the computation of the \chi_{R}(z) function given in Tables 91 , 92 and 93 in C and the verification of the Routh-Hurwitz criterion given in C . The \chi_{R}(z) expressions of these schemes are of the form \chi_{R}(z)=p(z)/p(-z) , where p(z) is a real polynomial where all their coefficients are positive, see Tables 91 , 92 and 93 in C . Corollary 4.6 . We have that schemes Skm[1,R] , for R=1,2,3,4 , Skm[K,R] , for K=2,3 , R=1,2,3 are A-stable. Proof. We present the methodology to provide the evidences for two typical cases. • Scheme Skm[1,3] . Polynomial p(z) is a third degree polynomial with all coefficients positive given in C . Therefore, the associated Hurwitz matrix is given by H_{13}=\begin{bmatrix}11&12&0\\ 3&18&0\\ 0&11&12\end{bmatrix}. We check that all principal minors m_{i} , for i{\in\llbracket{1,3}\rrbracket} of \det H_{13} are strictly positive. By Theorem 4.5 , we conclude that the scheme Skm[1,3] is A-stable. • Scheme Skm[2,2] . Polynomial p(z) is a fourth degree polynomial with all coefficients positive given in C . The associated Hurwitz matrix reads H_{22}=\begin{bmatrix}9&90&0&0\\ 1&39&90&0\\ 0&9&90&0\\ 0&1&39&90\end{bmatrix}. Simple calculations show that all the principal minors m_{i} , i{\in\llbracket{1,4}\rrbracket} of matrix H_{22} are strictly positive, and conclude that the scheme Skm[2,2] is A-stable. ∎ 5  Spectral resolution Fourier analysis is the standard tool to assess the spectral resolution of a compact method. The pioneer paper of Lele [ 20 ] provides an explicit relation for the first and second derivative approximations with respect to the local wave number \omega=2\pi\kappa\Delta t . The main ingredient is the phase deviation due to the numerical scheme is independent of the position . Indeed, the first derivatives are connected to the zero derivatives thanks to a linear relation \sum_{r=1}^{R}a^{0}_{r}\phi^{(0)}_{r}+\sum_{r=1}^{R}a^{1}_{r}\phi^{(1)}_{r}=0. Thus introducing the local modified wave number \omega^{(1)} for the first derivative, we derive an algebraic expression with respect to \omega . We proceed similarly for the second derivative since the Lele scheme connect \phi^{(2)}_{r} to \phi^{(0)}_{r} with a linear relation of type \sum_{r=1}^{R}b^{0}_{r}\phi^{(0)}_{r}+\sum_{r=1}^{R}b^{2}_{r}\phi^{(2)}_{r}=0 that provides an explicit algebraic relation of \omega^{(2)} in function of \omega . Extension to the k -derivative is based on an implicit coupling of \phi^{(k)}_{r} with \phi^{(0)}_{r} [ 21 ] . Once again the spectral analysis using the von-Neumann analysis is available since we solely connect the function to the k -derivative. The Compact Combined Scheme [ 22 , 23 , 24 ] uses the same approach but with a slightly modification. Indeed CCS scheme combined both the first- and second-derivative at the same time but with two linearly independent equations leading to a small 2\times 2 system that provides the modified wave numbers \omega^{(1)} and \omega^{(2)} for the first- and second-derivative in function of \omega . 5.1 A new notion of spectral resolution Such an approach is inadequate for structural equation. First, we are interested in assessing the impact of the structural scheme for a whole R-block, and in particular to the last time step t_{n+R} regarding to the initial t_{n} . Second, if K\neq R we do not have a square non singular linear system that provides the solution for \omega^{(1)}(\omega) up to \omega^{(K)}(\omega) . At last, Fourier analyse assumes we are dealing with a stationary solution where the phase shift of the first and second derivative is the same whatever the time step t_{n} which is not the case when dealing with an initial condition problem where we prescribe the exact for all the derivatives. We then propose a new approach to assess the spectral resolution that takes into account the specificities of the structural scheme Skm[K,R] that is, the coupling between Structural Equations and Physical Equations. To this end, we substitute the fundamental solution \exp($$2\pi\kappa t) by the equation \phi^{\prime}=$$2\pi\kappa\phi . Then, we connect all the derivatives to the solution thanks to the physical equations \phi^{(k)}=\Big($$2\pi\kappa\Big)^{k}\phi^{(0)},\ k{\in\llbracket{1,K}\rrbracket}. Therefore, the R structural equations provide the linear system of size R already define in the stability section 4 by relation ( 20 ) G(z)\Phi_{n}^{(0)}=-b(z)\phi_{n}^{(0)}, for the particular case z=\lambda\Delta t with \lambda=$$2\pi\kappa . To assess the diffusion and dispersion of schemes Skm[K,R] , we assume that the initial condition at t_{n} is equal to the exact solution \phi^{(0)}_{n}=\exp($$2\pi\kappa t_{n}) The transfer function then reads \chi_{r}($$\omega) providing the diffusion and the dispersion of the solution at time t_{n+r} . Since the exact solution at time t_{n+r} is \phi^{(0)}(t_{n+r})=\exp($$r\omega)\exp($$2\pi\kappa t_{n}) , the deviation regarding the exact solution corresponds to the ratio between the approximation and the exact solution at time t_{n+r} \frac{\phi_{n+r}^{(0)}}{\phi^{(0)}(t_{n+r})}=\frac{\chi_{r}($$\omega)\phi_{n}^{(0)}}{\exp($$r\omega)\exp($$2\pi\kappa t_{n})}=\chi_{r}($$\omega)\exp(-$$r\omega). Definition 5.1 : The scheme diffusion is given by the modulus of \zeta_{r}(\omega)=\chi_{r}($$\omega)\exp(-$$r\omega) (amplification factor) while the dispersion corresponds to its argument (phase deviation). Remark : It is important to note that the \zeta function also depends the parameters R and K thus we employ the notation \zeta_{r}(\omega;K,R) when necessary (see section 5.4 for instance). Noting that the solution at time t_{n+R} will be used for the next block resolution, we focus our study on the case r=R with \chi_{R}($$\omega) . Of course, all the intermediate step can be analysed similarly. Proposition 5.1 . If \chi_{R}(z) is a rational functions of the form p(z)/p(-z) then we have |\chi_{R}($$\omega)|=1 whence |\zeta_{R}(\omega)|=1 for all \omega>0 . The schemes has no diffusion at time t_{n+R} . 5.2 One block phase error Such a property is indeed observed in the numerical simulations when using the physical equation \phi^{\prime}=$$2\pi\kappa\phi (see section 7.2 ). Thanks to the explicit expressions of the structural equations coefficients, we get an analytical expression of the transfer functions \chi_{R}(z) as rational functions for a large set of situations (see Tables 91 , 92 and 93 in C ) from which we produce the polynomial expression in function of \omega in Table 1 we use in the \zeta(\omega) function. Table 1 : Spectral deviation. polynomial expression with respect to the local wavelength \omega in function of K and R scheme Skm[K,R] p($$\omega)=p($$\omega;K,R) Skm[1,1] 2+$$\omega Skm[1,2] -\omega^{2}+3$$\omega+3 Skm[1,3] -3$$\omega^{3}-11\omega^{2}+18$$\omega+12 Skm[2,1] -\omega^{2}+6$$\omega+12 Skm[2,2] \omega^{4}-9$$\omega^{3}-39\omega^{2}+90$$\omega+90 Skm[2,3] -3\omega^{6}+33$$\omega^{5}+193\omega^{4}-720$$\omega^{3}-1740\omega^{2}+2520$$\omega+1680 Skm[3,1] -$$\omega^{3}-12\omega^{2}+60$$\omega+120 Skm[3,2] -\omega^{6}+18$$\omega^{5}+165\omega^{4}-945$$\omega^{3}-3465\omega^{2}+7560$$\omega+7560 Skm[3,3] 9$$\omega^{9}+198\omega^{8}-2355$$\omega^{7}-19075\omega^{6}+112770$$\omega^{5} +\ 494760\omega^{4}-1587600$$\omega^{3}-3553200\omega^{2}+4989600$$\omega+3326400 We plot in Figure 2 the phase deviation (in radiant) in function of the local wavelength \omega for for R=1 with K=1,2,3 (top figure), then R=2 , (middle panel) and R=3 (bottom). As expected the spectral resolution is dramatically improved with K while the impact of R is less obvious. In particular, large deviations occur for \omega\geq\pi when R=3 . Particular attention concerns the case R=2 , K=3 where the phase deviation remains very small until \omega=2\pi . Indeed, we just have three points to approximate a complete revolution with a tiny phase deviation, below to \pi/20 . Figure 2: Dispersion curves \arg(\zeta) in function of \omega . Left panel: for schemes Skm[K,1] , K=1,2,3 . Middle panel: for schemes Skm[K,2] , K=1,2,3 . Right panel: for schemes Skm[K,3] , K=1,2,3 . In each panel, K1 ( ), K2 ( ), K3 ( ). 5.3 Spectral resolution analysis with respect to the time parameter \Delta t and K In this section we address the following question. Given N and \omega , what happen to the phase deviation when duplicating the number of points. Indeed, taking 2N points provide the time parameter \Delta t/2 and then \omega/2 but we duplicate the number of block. Consequently one has to compare the reference phase deviation \zeta(\omega) corresponding to N point with \zeta^{2}(\omega/2) involving 2N points. More generally, if we use \ell\,N point the deviation \zeta(\omega) has to be compared with \zeta^{\ell}(\omega/\ell) since we need \ell blocks to reach the same final time. Table 2: Dispersion curves \arg(\zeta(\omega)) ( ), \arg(\zeta^{2}(\omega/2)) ( ) and \arg(\zeta^{3}(\omega/3)) ( ) in function of \omega for schemes Skm[K,R] , K=1,2,3 , R=1,2,3 . We plot in Figure 2 the phase deviation of \zeta(\omega) , \zeta^{2}(\omega/2) and \zeta^{3}(\omega/3) corresponding to the same time variation \Delta\bar{t}=\frac{T}{N} in function of K (the columns) and R (the rows). First, as expected, a smaller value of the incrementing time \Delta t (black curves), \Delta t/2 (red curve) and \Delta t/3 (green curve) strongly improve the spectral resolutions since we use more discrete points. The trade off \zeta^{\ell}(\omega/\ell) between the argument reduction and the increase of the power is in favour to larger \ell . Second, for fixed \ell , the phase error is dramatically reduced with larger K . For example, with \ell=1 , i.e. \Delta\bar{t}=\Delta t_{n} , the phase error is almost contained to \omega=\pi/4 ( K=1 ), \omega=\pi/2 ( K=2 ), \omega=\pi ( K=3 ). This last case indicates that we manage to recover sub-scales information that is, we reveal the existence of an extremum within the cell. 5.4 Spectral resolution analysis with respect to to K and R Let T=1 and \kappa\in\mathbb{N} , be given. We fix the value of N such that \displaystyle\frac{N}{R}\in\mathbb{N} , with R=1,2,3,4 . We aim at comparing the deviation of the numerical approximation at the final time T for different choices of K and R , while the time step \Delta t is constant, independently of the two parameters. For R=1 , the final deviation is {\tt dev}(\omega;K,1)=\big(\zeta(\omega;K,1)\big)^{N} since we have to solve N blocks of size R=1 . For blocks of size R , the final deviation at the final time is given by {\tt dev}(\omega;K,R)=\big(\zeta(\omega;K,R)\big)^{N/R}. Consequently, numerical simulations are carried out using the same time parameter \Delta t and we numerical assess the phase deviation together with the one provided by the analytic expression. Table 3 : Algebraic error comparison between the analytical version calculated with \arg(\zeta(\omega;K,R)) and the numeric error one obtained when applying scheme Skm[K,R] for N=36 , T=1 and \kappa=1 ( \omega=\frac{2\pi}{36} ). K error R=1 R=2 R=3 R=4 1 analytic -1.59E-02 -1.29E-04 7.07E-05 2.20E-06 numeric -1.59E-02 -1.29E-04 7.07E-05 2.20E-06 2 analytic -8.08E-06 1.87E-08 -5.08E-11 1.61E-13 numeric -8.08E-06 1.87E-08 -5.08E-11 1.61E-13 3 analytic -1.76E-09 6.27E-15 2.61E-18 -5.38E-23 numeric -1.76E-09 6.27E-15 2.61E-18 -5.38E-23 4 analytic -2.13E-13 -8.88E-20 -5.71E-26 -5.46E-32 numeric -2.13E-13 -8.88E-20 -5.71E-26 -5.46E-32 Table 4 : Comparison between analytical error calculated as \arg(\zeta(\omega;K,R)) and the numeric error obtained when applying scheme Skm[K,R] for N=36 , T=1 and \kappa=2 , ( \omega=\frac{2\pi}{18} ). K error R=1 R=2 R=3 R=4 1 analytic -1.25E-01 -4.03E-03 2.05E-03 2.64E-04 numeric -1.25E-01 -4.03E-03 2.05E-03 2.64E-04 2 analytic -2.57E-04 2.34E-06 -2.46E-08 2.94E-10 numeric -2.57E-04 2.34E-06 -2.46E-08 2.94E-10 3 analytic -2.24E-07 1.27E-11 2.00E-14 -6.72E-18 numeric -2.24E-07 1.27E-11 2.00E-14 -6.72E-18 4 analytic -1.09E-10 -7.14E-16 -7.06E-21 -1.01E-25 numeric -1.09E-10 -7.14E-16 -7.06E-21 -1.01E-25 We report in Tables 3 and 4 the algebraic deviation error computed analytically and numerically and observe a perfect matching between theory and simulation. For \kappa=1 , the solution is a full revolution discretized by 36 points. The deviation decreases as K and R increases in accordance to the scheme order. We note that the doubling the frequency \kappa=2 ( i.e. 18 points in a full revolution), strongly impact the accuracy especially, the highest order. For example, we lost one order of magnitude for K=1 , R=1 , while we lost seven orders of magnitude for K=4 , R=4 . Table 5 : Analytical error calculated as \arg(\zeta(\omega;K,R)) for schemes Skm[K,R] for N=36 , T=1 and three values of \kappa . \kappa K R=1 R=2 R=3 R=4 4 1 -9.52E-01 -1.17E-01 4.23E-02 2.54E-02 2 -8.05E-03 2.74E-04 -9.92E-06 3.38E-07 3 -2.83E-05 2.51E-08 1.21E-10 -7.21E-13 4 -5.50E-08 -5.44E-12 -7.19E-16 -1.07E-19 8 1 -1.00E-01 -2.56E-00 -3.75E-01 7.52E-01 2 -2.35E-01 2.41E-02 -1.14E-03 -4.72E-04 3 -3.42E-03 4.39E-05 -5.19E-08 -3.53E-08 4 -2.70E-05 -3.22E-08 -1.12E-11 2.78E-13 12 1 1.66E-00 1.54E-00 -2.61E-01 -2.89E-00 2 -1.52E-00 1.89E-01 6.68E-02 -5.55E-02 3 -5.30E-02 2.90E-03 -1.71E-04 7.06E-06 4 -9.65E-04 -3.10E-06 5.90E-08 1.87E-09 To assess the spectral resolution capacity, we increase the value of \kappa , taking 4,8 and 12 . The last case means that we have 9 collocation points to compute two revolutions. We report in Table 5 the algebraic errors of the phase deviation obtained from the numerical simulations. Clearly, when K=1 , we do not manage to resolve the sub-scaled variations with \kappa=8,12 and the solution is no longer admissible. The case K=2 provides better approximation of the solution but require larger R . From K=3 and higher, we manage to solve the sub-scaled information (at least the one associated to the highest frequency \kappa=12 ). An interesting point to highlight is the total number of unknowns versus the accuracy. With K derivatives, we handle N(K+1) unknowns and the number is invariant regarding the meta-parameter R . For example, with \kappa=2 we have the same error with Skm[2,4] and Skm[4,2] But with the 5N unknowns for the first case and 3N unknowns for the latter. For \kappa=2 , the schemes Skm[1,4] and Skm[2,1] have the same accuracy with 3N and 2N unknowns respectively. Nevertheless, when increasing the frequency, there may have some strong limitations to retrieve sub-scaled information if K is too small, whatever R is. For instance, with \kappa=12 , the schemes Skm[2,4] and Skm[3,1] have the same phase deviation error but larger K (that is an increase of the local data) has to be preferred to provide better insights on the sub-scaled information. 6  Post-processing A simulation based on Skm[K,R] method provide approximations of \phi^{(k)}_{N}\approx\phi^{(k)}(t_{N}) , k{\in\llbracket{0,K}\rrbracket} at the final time, with order d=K(R+1) . Consider p>K , one easily provide approximations of higher derivative \phi_{N}^{(p)} by using additional physical equations {{\texttt{PE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{K+1}}}}},\cdots{{\texttt{PE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{p}}}}} . Nevertheless, such new physical equations may not be available due to the complexity of the partial derivative or some part of the physical equation is driven by tabulated functions. Our goal is to provide an approximation \phi_{N}^{(p)}\approx\phi^{(p)}(t_{N}) with the best precision using a new type of structural equations (the post-processing structural equations) that take the form \phi_{N}^{(p)}=\sum_{i=0}^{I_{p}}\sum_{k=0}^{K}a^{p}_{ik}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\phi_{N-i}^{(k)}, where I_{p} is the number of backward time steps we need to obtain a consistency order of d . To determine the (I_{p}+1)\times(K+1) matrix {\boldsymbol{a}}^{p}=\big(a^{p}_{ik}\big)_{i=0\cdots,I_{p}\atop k=0\cdots,K} , we introduce the functional E_{p}({\boldsymbol{a}}^{p};\pi)=\sum_{i=0}^{I_{p}}\sum_{k=0}^{K}a^{p}_{ik}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\pi^{(k)}(t_{N-i})-\pi^{(p)}(t_{N}), for any function \pi=\pi(t) , regular enough. We reshape matrix {\boldsymbol{a}}^{p} into a one-index entries vector {\boldsymbol{a}}^{p} (we use the same notation for the sake of simplicity) with the one-to one mapping (i,k)\to\ell=\ell(i,k)=1+k(I_{p}+1)+i from {\in\llbracket{0,K}\rrbracket}\times{\in\llbracket{0,I_{p}}\rrbracket} onto {\in\llbracket{1,M}\rrbracket} , with M=(K+1)(I_{p}+1) and the cost function now reads E_{p}({\boldsymbol{a}}^{p};\pi)=\sum_{i=0}^{I_{p}}\sum_{k=0}^{K}a^{p}_{\ell}\,\Delta t^{k}\,\pi^{(k)}(t_{N-i})-\pi^{(p)}(t_{N}),\qquad\ell=\ell(i,k). To provide the accuracy, we impose the functional to exactly satisfies the relation E({\boldsymbol{a}};\pi_{m})=0 for polynomial function up to a certain degree. To this end, we use the list of polynomial functions \pi_{m}(t;t_{N})=\left(\frac{t-t_{N}}{\Delta t}\right)^{m-1},\ m{\in\llbracket{1,\overline{M}}\rrbracket},\ \overline{M}=p+d. Note that the number of coefficients is M and we need to impose the condition \overline{M}\leq M such that the linear system have at least one solution. We then deduce a sufficient condition about the number of backward time steps I_{p} p+K(R+1)-K-1\leqslant I_{p}(K+1)\implies I_{p}\geqslant\frac{KR+p-1}{K+1}. Remark : For K=1 and R=2 , we have I_{p}\geqslant\frac{1+p}{2} while K=3 or R=4 require I_{p}\geqslant\frac{11+p}{4} . \scriptstyle\blacksquare To compute the coefficients of matrix {\boldsymbol{a}}^{p} , one has to find a solution of the linear system \mathcal{M}^{p}{\boldsymbol{a}}^{p}={\boldsymbol{b}}^{p} with \mathcal{M}^{p} an \overline{M}\times M matrix, we seek non-trivial vectors {\boldsymbol{a}}^{p} as a particular solution of the system plus any vector of the kernel of \mathcal{M}^{p} . To compute the entries of matrix \mathcal{M}^{p} , the k -derivative of the polynomial function \pi_{m}(t;t_{N}) , m{\in\llbracket{0,\overline{M}}\rrbracket} reads \pi_{m}^{(k)}(t;t_{N})=\frac{(m-1)\cdots(m-k)}{\Delta t^{k}}\left(\frac{t-t_{N}}{\Delta t}\right)^{m-1-k},\ k\ell$}\\ 0&\text{otherwise}\end{cases},\quad\ell=\ell(i,k), for m{\in\llbracket{1,\overline{M}}\rrbracket} and \ell{\in\llbracket{1,M}\rrbracket} . Several cases of post processing analytical formulas are given in D . Remark : For larger value of K and p , or for non-uniform grid, matrix \mathcal{M}^{p} and right-hand side {\boldsymbol{b}}^{p} are still numerically computed via the condition E_{p}({\boldsymbol{a}}^{p};\pi) , m{\in\llbracket{0,\overline{M}}\rrbracket} . Therefore a solution is available via a least-square method that provide the post-processing structural equation. \scriptstyle\blacksquare To assess the order of the consistency error we consider the function \phi(t)=\exp(t) we compute the difference between \phi^{(p)}(T) and \phi^{(p)}_{N} where the expressions \phi^{(k)}_{N-i} are substituted by the exact values. We report in Tables 6 , 8 , 8 the errors and convergence orders for some examples of p -derivative approximation using post-processing structural equations. Table 6 : Consistency error: K=1 . Ip N \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} \phi^{(4)} E O E O E O 1 60 6.25E -05 --- 2.25E -02 --- 2.72E +00 --- 120 1.57E -05 2.0 1.13E -02 1.0 2.72E +00 0.0 240 3.93E -06 2.0 5.66E -03 1.0 2.72E +00 0.0 2 60 2.30E -09 --- 1.24E -06 --- 3.23E -04 --- 120 1.45E -10 4.0 1.56E -07 3.0 8.13E -05 2.0 240 9.07E -12 4.0 1.96E -08 3.0 2.04E -05 2.0 3 60 1.02E -13 --- 6.72E -11 --- 2.36E -08 --- 120 1.61E -15 6.0 2.12E -12 5.0 1.49E -09 4.0 240 2.53E -17 6.0 6.67E -14 5.0 9.36E -11 4.0 4 60 4.98E -18 --- 3.74E -15 --- 1.56E -12 --- 120 1.98E -20 8.0 2.97E -17 7.0 2.48E -14 6.0 240 7.78E -23 8.0 2.33E -19 7.0 3.90E -16 6.0 5 60 2.60E -22 --- 2.14E -19 --- 1.01E -16 --- 120 2.59E -25 10.0 4.26E -22 9.0 4.01E -19 8.0 240 2.55E -28 10.0 8.40E -25 9.0 1.58E -21 8.0 Table 8 : Consistency error: K=3 . Ip N \phi^{(4)} E O 1 60 1.24E-10 --- 120 7.77E-12 4.0 240 4.87E-13 4.0 2 60 1.28E-20 --- 120 5.03E-23 8.0 240 1.97E-25 8.0 3 60 1.81E-30 --- 120 4.48E-34 12.0 240 1.10E-37 12.0 4 60 3.06E-40 --- 120 4.74E-45 16.0 240 7.28E-50 16.0 5 60 5.73E-50 --- 120 5.57E-56 20.0 240 5.37E-62 20.0 Table 7 : Consistency error: K=2 . Ip N \phi^{(3)} \phi^{(4)} E O E O 1 60 1.04E-07 --- 7.50E-05 --- 120 1.31E-08 3.0 1.88E-05 2.0 240 1.64E-09 3.0 4.71E-06 2.0 2 60 7.59E-15 --- 8.20E-12 --- 120 1.20E-16 6.0 2.58E-13 5.0 240 1.87E-18 6.0 8.10E-15 5.0 3 60 7.13E-22 --- 9.42E-19 --- 120 1.41E-24 9.0 3.72E-21 8.0 240 2.77E-27 9.0 1.46E-23 8.0 4 60 7.68E-29 --- 1.15E-25 --- 120 1.90E-32 12.0 5.71E-29 11.0 240 4.68E-36 12.0 2.81E-32 11.0 5 60 9.00E-36 --- 1.48E-32 --- 120 2.80E-40 15.0 9.21E-37 14.0 240 8.63E-45 15.0 5.68E-41 14.0 We get the expected convergence errors in all the situations, noting that we loose one order of convergence each time the derivative order is increased by one unit. 7  Benchmarking for ordinary differential equations To assess the errors and the convergence rate at the final time, we define E_{N}=\left|\phi^{(k)}_{N}-\phi^{(k)}(T)\right|, where \phi^{(k)}_{N} is the numerical approximation of \phi^{(k)}(T) at time t_{N}=N\Delta t=T . We will also compute the rate of convergence between two numerical solutions \phi^{(k)}_{N_{1}} and \phi^{(k)}_{N_{2}} given by O(N_{1},N_{2})=\frac{\left|\log\left(E_{N_{1}}/E_{N_{2}}\right)\right|}{|\log N_{1}/N_{2}|}. All benchmarks will consider the maximum number of physical equations. 7.1 Benchmark ODE1 We consider the linear equation \phi^{\prime}=-\phi in (0,T] with \phi(0)=1 to assess the numerical diffusion. We perform numerical simulations up to the final time T=1 using schemes and compare them with the exact solution \phi(t)=\exp(-t) . We report in Tables to the errors at the final time together with the convergence orders for K=1 , K=2 , K=3 , and K=4 , respectively, for R=1 to R=5 . In Table 19 we present the number of variables of the numerical discretization system and summarize the obtained orders of convergence. We note that if K is odd and R is even, there is a phenomenon of superconvergence due to ??? symmetry of ???. The data presented in this table will remain valid for all the next benchmarks. Finally, in Tables 20 and 21 we present the errors and the convergence orders for all R steps on the last R block with K=2 , R=2 and K=4 , R=5 , respectively. From these tables, we observe that the intermediate steps also obtained the optimal orders of convergence. Table 9 : Benchmark ODE1: K=1 with I_{p}=I_{p,\min} and \varepsilon=10^{-20} . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} \phi^{(4)} E O E O E O E O E O 1 Ip=1 Ip=2 Ip=2 60 8.52E-06 --- 8.52E-06 --- 3.08E-03 --- 2.33E+00 --- 3.36E+02 --- 120 2.13E-06 2.0 2.13E-06 2.0 1.54E-03 1.0 2.32E+00 0.0 6.67E+02 \uparrow 240 5.32E-07 2.0 5.32E-07 2.0 7.67E-04 1.0 2.31E+00 0.0 1.33E+03 \uparrow 2 Ip=2 Ip=3 Ip=3 60 6.31E-10 --- 6.31E-10 --- 3.46E-05 --- 6.96E-03 --- 3.47E+00 --- 120 3.94E-11 4.0 3.94E-11 4.0 8.59E-06 2.0 3.50E-03 1.0 3.47E+00 \uparrow 240 2.46E-12 4.0 2.46E-12 4.0 2.14E-06 2.0 1.76E-03 1.0 3.47E+00 \uparrow 3 Ip=2 Ip=3 Ip=3 60 3.55E-10 --- 3.55E-10 --- 4.36E-07 --- 9.56E-05 --- 9.33E-03 --- 120 2.22E-11 4.0 2.22E-11 4.0 5.39E-08 3.0 2.37E-05 2.0 4.63E-03 1.0 240 1.39E-12 4.0 1.39E-12 4.0 6.69E-09 3.0 5.88E-06 2.0 2.31E-03 1.0 4 Ip=3 Ip=4 Ip=4 60 1.00E-13 --- 1.00E-13 --- 5.87E-09 --- 1.46E-06 --- 1.83E-04 --- 120 1.56E-15 6.0 1.56E-15 6.0 3.61E-10 4.0 1.80E-07 3.0 4.53E-05 2.0 240 2.44E-17 6.0 2.44E-17 6.0 2.24E-11 4.0 2.23E-08 3.0 1.12E-05 2.0 5 Ip=3 Ip=4 Ip=4 60 3.59E-14 --- 3.59E-14 --- 8.22E-11 --- 2.24E-08 --- 3.31E-06 --- 120 5.60E-16 6.0 5.60E-16 6.0 2.52E-12 5.0 1.38E-09 4.0 4.06E-07 3.0 240 8.75E-18 6.0 8.75E-18 6.0 7.78E-14 5.0 8.52E-11 4.0 5.03E-08 3.0 Table 10 : Benchmark ODE1: K=1 with I_{p}=I_{p,\min}+1 and \varepsilon=10^{-20} . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} \phi^{(4)} E O E O E O E O E O 1 Ip=2 Ip=3 Ip=3 60 8.52E-06 --- 8.52E-06 --- 7.76E-03 --- 8.40E+00 --- 2.11E+03 --- 120 2.13E-06 2.0 2.13E-06 2.0 3.86E-03 1.0 8.31E+00 0.0 4.17E+03 \uparrow 240 5.32E-07 2.0 5.32E-07 2.0 1.92E-03 1.0 8.27E+00 0.0 8.29E+03 \uparrow 2 Ip=3 Ip=4 Ip=4 60 6.31E-10 --- 6.31E-10 --- 1.19E-05 --- 1.25E-02 --- 5.35E+00 --- 120 3.94E-11 4.0 3.94E-11 4.0 2.91E-06 2.0 6.76E-03 0.9 5.74E+00 \uparrow 240 2.46E-12 4.0 2.46E-12 4.0 7.19E-07 2.0 3.51E-03 0.9 5.92E+00 \uparrow 3 Ip=3 Ip=4 Ip=4 60 3.55E-10 --- 3.55E-10 --- 4.36E-07 --- 5.01E-04 --- 1.63E-01 --- 120 2.22E-11 4.0 2.22E-11 4.0 5.39E-08 3.0 1.23E-04 2.0 8.02E-02 1.0 240 1.39E-12 4.0 1.39E-12 4.0 6.69E-09 3.0 3.05E-05 2.0 3.97E-02 1.0 4 Ip=4 Ip=5 Ip=5 60 1.00E-13 --- 1.00E-13 --- 5.87E-09 --- 2.92E-06 --- 1.75E-03 --- 120 1.56E-15 6.0 1.56E-15 6.0 3.61E-10 4.0 3.62E-07 3.0 4.33E-04 2.0 240 2.44E-17 6.0 2.44E-17 6.0 2.24E-11 4.0 4.50E-08 3.0 1.08E-04 2.0 5 Ip=4 Ip=5 Ip=5 60 3.59E-14 --- 3.59E-14 --- 8.22E-11 --- 2.24E-08 --- 3.31E-06 --- 120 5.60E-16 6.0 5.60E-16 6.0 2.52E-12 5.0 1.38E-09 4.0 4.06E-07 3.0 240 8.75E-18 6.0 8.75E-18 6.0 7.78E-14 5.0 8.52E-11 4.0 5.03E-08 3.0 Table 11 : Benchmark ODE1: K=1 with I_{p}=I_{p,\min}+2 and \varepsilon=10^{-20} . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} \phi^{(4)} E O E O E O E O E O 1 Ip=3 Ip=4 Ip=4 60 8.52E-06 --- 8.52E-06 --- 1.82E-02 --- 2.75E+01 --- 9.25E+03 --- 120 2.13E-06 2.0 2.13E-06 2.0 9.03E-03 1.0 2.71E+01 0.0 1.82E+04 \uparrow 240 5.32E-07 2.0 5.32E-07 2.0 4.49E-03 1.0 2.69E+01 0.0 3.62E+04 \uparrow 2 Ip=4 Ip=5 Ip=5 60 6.31E-10 --- 6.31E-10 --- 3.43E-06 --- 2.78E-02 --- 1.22E+01 --- 120 3.94E-11 4.0 3.94E-11 4.0 4.21E-07 3.0 1.17E-02 1.2 1.04E+01 0.2 240 2.46E-12 4.0 2.46E-12 4.0 5.22E-08 3.0 5.32E-03 1.1 9.48E+00 0.1 3 Ip=4 Ip=5 Ip=5 60 3.55E-10 --- 3.55E-10 --- 1.02E-06 --- 3.57E-03 --- 1.50E+00 --- 120 2.22E-11 4.0 2.22E-11 4.0 1.25E-07 3.0 8.73E-04 2.0 7.36E-01 1.0 240 1.39E-12 4.0 1.39E-12 4.0 1.55E-08 3.0 2.16E-04 2.0 3.64E-01 1.0 4 Ip=5 Ip=6 Ip=6 60 1.00E-13 --- 1.00E-13 --- 2.64E-10 --- 3.52E-05 --- 1.74E-02 --- 120 1.56E-15 6.0 1.56E-15 6.0 1.42E-11 4.2 4.41E-06 3.0 4.37E-03 2.0 240 2.44E-17 6.0 2.44E-17 6.0 8.21E-13 4.1 5.51E-07 3.0 1.09E-03 2.0 5 Ip=5 Ip=6 Ip=6 60 3.59E-14 --- 3.59E-14 --- 8.22E-11 --- 1.17E-07 --- 4.99E-05 --- 120 5.60E-16 6.0 5.60E-16 6.0 2.52E-12 5.0 7.15E-09 4.0 6.08E-06 3.0 240 8.75E-18 6.0 8.75E-18 6.0 7.78E-14 5.0 4.41E-10 4.0 7.50E-07 3.0 Table 12 : Benchmark ODE1: K=1 with I_{p}=I_{p,\min}+3 and \varepsilon=10^{-20} . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} \phi^{(4)} E O E O E O E O E O 1 Ip=4 Ip=5 Ip=5 60 8.52E-06 --- 8.52E-06 --- 4.59E-02 --- 8.98E+01 --- 3.64E+04 --- 120 2.13E-06 2.0 2.13E-06 2.0 2.27E-02 1.0 8.81E+01 0.0 7.14E+04 \uparrow 240 5.32E-07 2.0 5.32E-07 2.0 1.13E-02 1.0 8.73E+01 0.0 1.42E+05 \uparrow 2 Ip=5 Ip=6 Ip=6 60 6.31E-10 --- 6.31E-10 --- 5.54E-05 --- 6.09E-02 --- 2.80E+01 --- 120 3.94E-11 4.0 3.94E-11 4.0 1.24E-05 2.2 2.49E-02 1.3 2.29E+01 0.3 240 2.46E-12 4.0 2.46E-12 4.0 2.91E-06 2.1 1.11E-02 1.2 2.04E+01 0.2 3 Ip=5 Ip=6 Ip=6 60 3.55E-10 --- 3.55E-10 --- 4.96E-06 --- 1.58E-02 --- 7.46E+00 --- 120 2.22E-11 4.0 2.22E-11 4.0 6.08E-07 3.0 3.86E-03 2.0 3.64E+00 1.0 240 1.39E-12 4.0 1.39E-12 4.0 7.52E-08 3.0 9.54E-04 2.0 1.80E+00 1.0 4 Ip=6 Ip=7 Ip=7 60 1.00E-13 --- 1.00E-13 --- 3.80E-08 --- 1.16E-04 --- 6.00E-02 --- 120 1.56E-15 6.0 1.56E-15 6.0 2.39E-09 4.0 1.50E-05 2.9 1.56E-02 1.9 240 2.44E-17 6.0 2.44E-17 6.0 1.49E-10 4.0 1.91E-06 3.0 3.96E-03 2.0 5 Ip=6 Ip=7 Ip=7 60 3.59E-14 --- 3.59E-14 --- 1.94E-10 --- 1.69E-06 --- 8.83E-04 --- 120 5.60E-16 6.0 5.60E-16 6.0 5.91E-12 5.0 1.02E-07 4.0 1.07E-04 3.0 240 8.75E-18 6.0 8.75E-18 6.0 1.83E-13 5.0 6.30E-09 4.0 1.32E-05 3.0 Table 13 : Benchmark ODE1: mean number of fixed-point iterations \bar{\kappa} and \bar{\tau}=\bar{\kappa}/R with N=60 for schemes with convergence orders 2, 4, and 6. K 1 2 3 R (order) 1 (2) 2 (4) 3 (4) 4 (6) 5 (6) 1 (4) 2 (6) 1 (6) \bar{\kappa} with \varepsilon=10^{-20} 9.00 5.00 3.33 2.50 2.20 8.00 4.50 7.00 \bar{\tau} with \varepsilon=10^{-20} 9.00 2.50 1.11 0.63 0.44 8.00 2.25 7.00 \bar{\kappa} with \varepsilon=10^{-30} 14.00 7.50 5.00 4.00 3.20 13.00 7.00 12.00 \bar{\tau} with \varepsilon=10^{-30} 14.00 3.75 1.67 1.00 0.64 13.00 3.50 12.00 Table 14 : Benchmark ODE1: mean number of fixed-point iterations \bar{\kappa} and \bar{\tau}=\bar{\kappa}/R with N=60 for schemes with convergence orders 8, 10, and 12. K 2 3 4 R (order) 3 (8) 4 (10) 5 (12) 2 (10) 3 (12) 1 (10) 2 (12) \bar{\kappa} with \varepsilon=10^{-25} 4.17 3.47 3.00 4.97 3.33 8.00 4.50 \bar{\tau} with \varepsilon=10^{-25} 1.39 0.87 0.60 2.49 1.11 8.00 2.25 \bar{\kappa} with \varepsilon=10^{-40} 7.00 5.75 5.00 8.50 6.00 15.00 8.45 \bar{\tau} with \varepsilon=10^{-40} 2.33 1.44 1.00 4.25 2.00 15.00 4.23 Table 15 : Benchmark ODE1: mean number of fixed-point iterations \bar{\kappa} and \bar{\tau}=\bar{\kappa}/R with N=60 for schemes with convergence orders 16, 18, 20 and 24. K 3 4 R (order) 4 (16) 5 (18) 3 (16) 4 (20) 5 (24) \bar{\kappa} with \varepsilon=10^{-40} 4.93 4.40 6.12 5.35 5.40 \bar{\tau} with \varepsilon=10^{-40} 1.24 0.88 2.04 1.34 1.08 \bar{\kappa} with \varepsilon=10^{-60} 7.75 6.83 10.00 8.75 8.98 \bar{\tau} with \varepsilon=10^{-60} 1.94 1.37 3.33 2.19 1.80 Table 16 : Benchmark ODE3b: mean number of fixed-point iterations \bar{\kappa} and \bar{\tau}=\bar{\kappa}/R with N=240 for schemes with convergence orders 2, 4 and 6. K 1 2 3 R (order) 1 (2) 2 (4) 3 (4) 4 (6) 5 (6) 1 (4) 2 (6) 1 (6) \bar{\kappa} with \varepsilon=10^{-20} 9.87 5.24 3.71 2.86 2.36 8.54 4.79 7.52 \bar{\tau} with \varepsilon=10^{-20} 9.87 2.62 1.24 0.72 0.47 8.54 2.40 7.52 \bar{\kappa} with \varepsilon=10^{-30} 15.45 8.18 5.76 4.43 3.68 14.26 7.97 13.17 \bar{\tau} with \varepsilon=10^{-30} 15.45 4.09 1.92 1.11 0.74 14.26 3.99 13.17 Table 17 : Benchmark ODE3b: mean number of fixed-point iterations \bar{\kappa} and \bar{\tau}=\bar{\kappa}/R with N=240 for schemes with convergence orders 8, 10, and 12. K 2 3 R (order) 3 (8) 4 (10) 5 (12) 2 (10) 3 (12) \bar{\kappa} with \varepsilon=10^{-25} 4.70 3.91 3.50 5.90 4.19 \bar{\tau} with \varepsilon=10^{-25} 1.57 0.98 0.70 2.95 1.40 \bar{\kappa} with \varepsilon=10^{-40} 8.15 6.78 6.11 10.21 7.28 \bar{\tau} with \varepsilon=10^{-40} 2.72 1.70 1.22 5.11 2.43 Table 18 : Benchmark ODE3b: mean number of fixed-point iterations \bar{\kappa} and \bar{\tau}=\bar{\kappa}/R with N=240 for schemes with convergence orders 16 and 18. K 3 R (order) 4 (16) 5 (18) \bar{\kappa} with \varepsilon=10^{-40} 5.95 5.45 \bar{\tau} with \varepsilon=10^{-40} 1.49 1.09 \bar{\kappa} with \varepsilon=10^{-60} 4.28 3.90 \bar{\tau} with \varepsilon=10^{-60} 1.07 0.78 Table 19 : Number of variables and convergence orders. K R \# PEs \# SEs I O_{\phi} O_{\phi^{(1)}} O_{\phi^{(2)}} O_{\phi^{(3)}} O_{\phi^{(4)}} 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 4 4 4 3 3 3 6 4 4 4 4 4 8 6 6 5 5 5 10 6 6 2 1 2 1 3 4 4 4 2 4 2 6 6 6 6 3 6 3 9 8 8 8 4 8 4 12 10 10 10 5 10 5 15 12 12 12 3 1 3 1 4 6 6 6 6 2 6 2 8 10 10 10 10 3 9 3 12 12 12 12 12 4 12 4 16 16 16 16 16 5 15 5 20 18 18 18 18 4 1 4 1 5 8 8 8 8 8 2 8 2 10 12 12 12 12 12 3 12 3 15 16 16 16 16 16 4 16 4 20 20 20 20 20 20 5 20 5 25 24 24 24 24 24 Table 20 : Benchmark ODE1: errors and order of convergences for all R steps on the last R-block with R=2 and K=2 . t N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} E O E O E O T-1\Delta t 60 8.34E-16 --- 8.34E-16 --- 8.34E-16 --- 120 1.30E-17 6.0 1.30E-17 6.0 1.30E-17 6.0 240 2.04E-19 6.0 2.04E-19 6.0 2.04E-19 6.0 T-0\Delta t 60 8.34E-16 --- 8.34E-16 --- 8.34E-16 --- 120 1.30E-17 6.0 1.30E-17 6.0 1.30E-17 6.0 240 2.04E-19 6.0 2.04E-19 6.0 2.04E-19 6.0 Table 21 : Benchmark ODE1: errors and orders of convergence for all R steps on the last R-block with R=5 and K=4 . t N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} \phi^{(4)} E O E O E O E O E O T-4\Delta t 60 1.47E-63 --- 1.47E-63 --- 1.47E-63 --- 1.47E-63 --- 1.47E-63 --- 120 8.67E-71 24.0 8.67E-71 24.0 8.67E-71 24.0 8.67E-71 24.0 8.67E-71 24.0 240 5.14E-78 24.0 5.14E-78 24.0 5.14E-78 24.0 5.14E-78 24.0 5.14E-78 24.0 T-3\Delta t 60 1.45E-63 --- 1.45E-63 --- 1.45E-63 --- 1.45E-63 --- 1.45E-63 --- 120 8.60E-71 24.0 8.60E-71 24.0 8.60E-71 24.0 8.60E-71 24.0 8.60E-71 24.0 240 5.12E-78 24.0 5.12E-78 24.0 5.12E-78 24.0 5.12E-78 24.0 5.12E-78 24.0 T-2\Delta t 60 1.42E-63 --- 1.42E-63 --- 1.42E-63 --- 1.42E-63 --- 1.42E-63 --- 120 8.53E-71 24.0 8.53E-71 24.0 8.53E-71 24.0 8.53E-71 24.0 8.53E-71 24.0 240 5.10E-78 24.0 5.10E-78 24.0 5.10E-78 24.0 5.10E-78 24.0 5.10E-78 24.0 T-1\Delta t 60 1.40E-63 --- 1.40E-63 --- 1.40E-63 --- 1.40E-63 --- 1.40E-63 --- 120 8.46E-71 24.0 8.46E-71 24.0 8.46E-71 24.0 8.46E-71 24.0 8.46E-71 24.0 240 5.08E-78 24.0 5.08E-78 24.0 5.08E-78 24.0 5.08E-78 24.0 5.08E-78 24.0 T-0\Delta t 60 1.44E-63 --- 1.44E-63 --- 1.44E-63 --- 1.44E-63 --- 1.44E-63 --- 120 8.57E-71 24.0 8.57E-71 24.0 8.57E-71 24.0 8.57E-71 24.0 8.57E-71 24.0 240 5.11E-78 24.0 5.11E-78 24.0 5.11E-78 24.0 5.11E-78 24.0 5.11E-78 24.0 7.2 Benchmark ODE2 To assess the spectral resolution of the scheme, we consider the linear equation \phi^{\prime}=-$$2\kappa\pi\phi in (0,T] , T=1 with \phi(0)=1 where \kappa\in\mathbb{N} is the wave number and the imaginary unit. We evaluate the dispersion between the numerical approximation and the exact solution \phi(t)=\exp($$2\kappa\pi t) . We consider two benchmarks: • Benchmark ODE2a considers \kappa=1 . Errors and convergence orders are reported in Tables 22 to 24 , for K=1 , K=2 , and K=3 , respectively, for R=1 to R=5 . • Benchmark ODE2b considers \kappa=10 . In Table 25 we indicate the smallest value for N such that the error is less or equal to \epsilon for K=1 , K=2 , K=3 , and K=4 for R=1 to R=5 . These values are plotted in Figures 3 and 4 . Table 22 : Benchmark ODE2a: K=1 . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} E O E O 1 60 5.73E-03 --- 3.60E-02 --- 120 1.43E-03 2.0 9.02E-03 2.0 240 3.59E-04 2.0 2.25E-03 2.0 2 60 1.67E-05 --- 1.05E-04 --- 120 1.05E-06 4.0 6.59E-06 4.0 240 6.56E-08 4.0 4.12E-07 4.0 3 60 9.34E-06 --- 5.87E-05 --- 120 5.89E-07 4.0 3.70E-06 4.0 240 3.69E-08 4.0 2.32E-07 4.0 4 60 1.04E-07 --- 6.56E-07 --- 120 1.64E-09 6.0 1.03E-08 6.0 240 2.57E-11 6.0 1.61E-10 6.0 5 60 3.65E-08 --- 2.29E-07 --- 120 5.84E-10 6.0 3.67E-09 6.0 240 9.18E-12 6.0 5.77E-11 6.0 Table 23 : Benchmark ODE2a: K=2 . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} E O E O E O 1 60 1.05E-06 --- 6.59E-06 --- 4.14E-05 --- 120 6.56E-08 4.0 4.12E-07 4.0 2.59E-06 4.0 240 4.10E-09 4.0 2.58E-08 4.0 1.62E-07 4.0 2 60 8.75E-10 --- 5.50E-09 --- 3.45E-08 --- 120 1.37E-11 6.0 8.60E-11 6.0 5.41E-10 6.0 240 2.14E-13 6.0 1.34E-12 6.0 8.45E-12 6.0 3 60 8.64E-13 --- 5.43E-12 --- 3.41E-11 --- 120 3.39E-15 8.0 2.13E-14 8.0 1.34E-13 8.0 240 1.33E-17 8.0 8.33E-17 8.0 5.23E-16 8.0 4 60 1.00E-15 --- 6.29E-15 --- 3.95E-14 --- 120 9.87E-19 10.0 6.20E-18 10.0 3.90E-17 10.0 240 9.67E-22 10.0 6.07E-21 10.0 3.82E-20 10.0 5 60 1.34E-18 --- 8.41E-18 --- 5.29E-17 --- 120 3.33E-22 12.0 2.09E-21 12.0 1.31E-20 12.0 240 8.16E-26 12.0 5.13E-25 12.0 3.22E-24 12.0 Table 24 : Benchmark ODE2a: K=3 . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 1 60 8.22E-11 --- 5.16E-10 --- 3.24E-09 --- 2.04E-08 --- 120 1.28E-12 6.0 8.07E-12 6.0 5.07E-11 6.0 3.19E-10 6.0 240 2.01E-14 6.0 1.26E-13 6.0 7.92E-13 6.0 4.98E-12 6.0 2 60 3.80E-17 --- 2.39E-16 --- 1.50E-15 --- 9.42E-15 --- 120 3.71E-20 10.0 2.33E-19 10.0 1.47E-18 10.0 9.21E-18 10.0 240 3.63E-23 10.0 2.28E-22 10.0 1.43E-21 10.0 9.00E-21 10.0 3 60 5.77E-21 --- 3.62E-20 --- 2.28E-19 --- 1.43E-18 --- 120 1.42E-24 12.0 8.90E-24 12.0 5.59E-23 12.0 3.51E-22 12.0 240 3.46E-28 12.0 2.18E-27 12.0 1.37E-26 12.0 8.59E-26 12.0 4 60 1.53E-26 --- 9.63E-26 --- 6.05E-25 --- 3.80E-24 --- 120 2.35E-31 16.0 1.48E-30 16.0 9.27E-30 16.0 5.83E-29 16.0 240 3.59E-36 16.0 2.25E-35 16.0 1.42E-34 16.0 8.90E-34 16.0 5 60 1.64E-30 --- 1.03E-29 --- 6.47E-29 --- 4.06E-28 --- 120 6.37E-36 18.0 4.00E-35 18.0 2.52E-34 18.0 1.58E-33 18.0 240 2.44E-41 18.0 1.54E-40 18.0 9.65E-40 18.0 6.06E-39 18.0 Table 25 : Benchmark ODE2b: smallest values for N such that the error is less or equal to \epsilon . \epsilon R K 1 2 3 4 1E-3 1 4144 178 54 28 2 356 80 32 18 3 306 48 27 15 4 176 44 24 16 5 135 40 20 15 1E-5 1 41436 562 117 49 2 1124 172 52 22 3 975 96 36 21 4 384 56 28 20 5 320 55 25 20 Figure 3: Benchmark ODE2b: smallest values for N such that the error is less or equal to \epsilon=1 E -3 . Figure 4: Benchmark ODE2b: smallest values for N such that the error is less or equal to \epsilon=1 E -5 . 7.3 Benchmark ODE3 In this subsection we consider three non-linear ordinary differential equations: • Benchmark ODE3a is given by the non-linear equation \phi^{\prime}=\exp(t)\phi^{2} in (0,1] with \phi(0)=-\frac{1}{2} , whose solution is \displaystyle\phi(t)=-\frac{1}{1+\exp(t)} . We present in Tables to the convergence tables. • Benchmark ODE3b is given by the non-linear equation \phi^{\prime}=\phi(1-\phi) in (-10,0] with \displaystyle\phi(0)=\frac{1}{1+\exp(10)} , whose solution is the sigmoid function \displaystyle\phi(t)=\frac{1}{1+\exp(-t)} . We present in Tables to the convergence tables. • Benchmark ODE3c is given by the non-linear equation \phi^{\prime}=\phi^{2} in (0,0.95] with \phi(0)=20 , whose solution is \phi(t)=\frac{1}{1-t} . We present in Tables to the convergence tables. All benchmarks consider K=1 , K=2 , K=3 for R=1 to R=5 . We also compute the mean number of the Picard fixed-point algorithm at each R-block. This number is given by \bar{\kappa} in the convergence tables. Table 26 : Benchmark ODE3a: K=2 with I_{p}=I_{p,\min} and \varepsilon=10^{-40} . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 1 Ip=2 60 5.23E-12 --- 7.65E-12 --- 9.13E-12 --- 2.05E-06 --- 120 3.27E-13 4.0 4.78E-13 4.0 5.71E-13 4.0 5.14E-07 2.0 240 2.04E-14 4.0 2.99E-14 4.0 3.57E-14 4.0 1.29E-07 2.0 2 Ip=2 60 1.10E-16 --- 1.60E-16 --- 1.91E-16 --- 4.76E-10 --- 120 1.71E-18 6.0 2.50E-18 6.0 2.98E-18 6.0 3.00E-11 4.0 240 2.67E-20 6.0 3.91E-20 6.0 4.66E-20 6.0 1.88E-12 4.0 3 Ip=3 60 2.94E-20 --- 4.30E-20 --- 5.13E-20 --- 1.86E-13 --- 120 1.15E-22 8.0 1.68E-22 8.0 2.01E-22 8.0 2.88E-15 6.0 240 4.49E-25 8.0 6.57E-25 8.0 7.83E-25 8.0 4.48E-17 6.0 4 Ip=4 60 1.86E-23 --- 2.72E-23 --- 3.24E-23 --- 8.55E-17 --- 120 1.81E-26 10.0 2.65E-26 10.0 3.16E-26 10.0 3.19E-19 8.1 240 1.77E-29 10.0 2.59E-29 10.0 3.09E-29 10.0 1.22E-21 8.0 5 Ip=4 60 1.09E-26 --- 1.60E-26 --- 1.91E-26 --- 3.84E-20 --- 120 2.66E-30 12.0 3.89E-30 12.0 4.64E-30 12.0 3.18E-23 10.2 240 6.49E-34 12.0 9.49E-34 12.0 1.13E-33 12.0 2.83E-26 10.1 Table 27 : Benchmark ODE3a: K=1 with I_{p}=I_{p,\min} and \varepsilon=10^{-20} . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 1 Ip=1 Ip=2 60 1.03E-06 --- 1.51E-06 --- 3.00E-04 --- 2.32E-01 --- 120 2.58E-07 2.0 3.77E-07 2.0 1.48E-04 1.0 2.26E-01 0.0 240 6.45E-08 2.0 9.43E-08 2.0 7.39E-05 1.0 2.23E-01 0.0 2 Ip=2 Ip=3 60 1.81E-10 --- 2.65E-10 --- 1.16E-05 --- 2.31E-03 --- 120 1.13E-11 4.0 1.65E-11 4.0 2.87E-06 2.0 1.17E-03 1.0 240 7.07E-13 4.0 1.03E-12 4.0 7.17E-07 2.0 5.88E-04 1.0 3 Ip=2 Ip=3 60 4.71E-11 --- 6.89E-11 --- 5.28E-08 --- 1.17E-05 --- 120 2.94E-12 4.0 4.30E-12 4.0 7.00E-09 2.9 3.09E-06 1.9 240 1.84E-13 4.0 2.69E-13 4.0 8.99E-10 3.0 7.92E-07 2.0 4 Ip=3 Ip=4 60 7.69E-14 --- 1.12E-13 --- 4.65E-09 --- 1.15E-06 --- 120 1.20E-15 6.0 1.76E-15 6.0 2.82E-10 4.0 1.41E-07 3.0 240 1.88E-17 6.0 2.74E-17 6.0 1.74E-11 4.0 1.73E-08 3.0 5 Ip=3 Ip=4 60 4.73E-15 --- 6.92E-15 --- 1.16E-10 --- 3.18E-08 --- 120 7.36E-17 6.0 1.08E-16 6.0 3.71E-12 5.0 2.03E-09 4.0 240 1.15E-18 6.0 1.68E-18 6.0 1.17E-13 5.0 1.28E-10 4.0 Table 28 : Benchmark ODE3a: K=3 with I_{p}=I_{p,\min} and \varepsilon=10^{-60} . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 60 1.03E-17 --- 1.50E-17 --- 1.79E-17 --- 1.25E-17 --- 120 1.60E-19 6.0 2.34E-19 6.0 2.80E-19 6.0 1.95E-19 6.0 240 2.50E-21 6.0 3.66E-21 6.0 4.37E-21 6.0 3.05E-21 6.0 60 4.48E-25 --- 6.55E-25 --- 7.82E-25 --- 5.46E-25 --- 120 4.37E-28 10.0 6.40E-28 10.0 7.63E-28 10.0 5.33E-28 10.0 240 4.27E-31 10.0 6.24E-31 10.0 7.45E-31 10.0 5.21E-31 10.0 60 4.62E-29 --- 6.76E-29 --- 8.07E-29 --- 5.64E-29 --- 120 1.13E-32 12.0 1.65E-32 12.0 1.97E-32 12.0 1.37E-32 12.0 240 2.75E-36 12.0 4.02E-36 12.0 4.80E-36 12.0 3.35E-36 12.0 60 3.06E-36 --- 4.47E-36 --- 5.33E-36 --- 3.72E-36 --- 120 4.66E-41 16.0 6.81E-41 16.0 8.13E-41 16.0 5.68E-41 16.0 240 7.10E-46 16.0 1.04E-45 16.0 1.24E-45 16.0 8.66E-46 16.0 60 5.81E-40 --- 8.49E-40 --- 1.01E-39 --- 7.08E-40 --- 120 2.22E-45 18.0 3.24E-45 18.0 3.87E-45 18.0 2.71E-45 18.0 240 8.47E-51 18.0 1.24E-50 18.0 1.48E-50 18.0 1.03E-50 18.0 Table 29 : Benchmark ODE3b: K=1 with I_{p}=I_{p,\min} and \varepsilon=10^{-20} . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 1 Ip=1 Ip=2 120 1.01E-03 --- 1.03E-06 --- 4.69E-03 --- 7.76E-01 --- 240 2.53E-04 2.0 6.41E-08 4.0 2.48E-03 0.9 7.80E-01 \uparrow 480 6.33E-05 2.0 4.01E-09 4.0 1.27E-03 1.0 7.81E-01 \uparrow 960 1.58E-05 2.0 2.50E-10 4.0 6.43E-04 1.0 7.81E-01 \uparrow 2 Ip=2 Ip=3 120 1.68E-06 --- 2.81E-12 --- 3.68E-05 --- 9.45E-04 --- 240 1.05E-07 4.0 1.10E-14 8.0 4.57E-06 3.0 2.01E-04 2.2 480 6.54E-09 4.0 4.28E-17 8.0 5.68E-07 3.0 4.80E-05 2.1 960 4.09E-10 4.0 1.67E-19 8.0 7.08E-08 3.0 1.19E-05 2.0 3 Ip=2 Ip=3 120 7.59E-07 --- 5.76E-13 --- 3.56E-05 --- 1.56E-03 --- 240 4.72E-08 4.0 2.23E-15 8.0 4.52E-06 3.0 3.96E-04 2.0 480 2.95E-09 4.0 8.68E-18 8.0 5.66E-07 3.0 9.93E-05 2.0 960 1.84E-10 4.0 3.39E-20 8.0 7.07E-08 3.0 2.49E-05 2.0 4 Ip=3 Ip=4 120 4.45E-09 --- 1.98E-17 --- 1.37E-06 --- 6.57E-05 --- 240 6.93E-11 6.0 4.81E-21 12.0 4.41E-08 5.0 4.20E-06 4.0 480 1.08E-12 6.0 1.17E-24 12.0 1.39E-09 5.0 2.64E-07 4.0 960 1.69E-14 6.0 2.86E-28 12.0 4.34E-11 5.0 1.65E-08 4.0 5 Ip=3 Ip=4 120 1.17E-09 --- 1.36E-18 --- 6.24E-07 --- 3.44E-05 --- 240 1.80E-11 6.0 3.23E-22 12.0 2.15E-08 4.9 2.36E-06 3.9 480 2.80E-13 6.0 7.82E-26 12.0 6.89E-10 5.0 1.51E-07 4.0 960 4.37E-15 6.0 1.91E-29 12.0 2.17E-11 5.0 9.50E-09 4.0 Table 30 : Benchmark ODE3b: K=2 with I_{p}=I_{p,\min} and \varepsilon=10^{-40} . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 1 Ip=2 120 8.38E-08 --- 7.02E-15 --- 4.19E-08 --- 2.55E-04 --- 240 5.23E-09 4.0 2.74E-17 8.0 2.62E-09 4.0 6.34E-05 2.0 480 3.27E-10 4.0 1.07E-19 8.0 1.64E-10 4.0 1.58E-05 2.0 960 2.04E-11 4.0 4.18E-22 8.0 1.02E-11 4.0 3.96E-06 2.0 2 Ip=2 120 2.67E-11 --- 7.11E-22 --- 1.33E-11 --- 5.57E-07 --- 240 4.16E-13 6.0 1.73E-25 12.0 2.08E-13 6.0 3.54E-08 4.0 480 6.50E-15 6.0 4.23E-29 12.0 3.25E-15 6.0 2.22E-09 4.0 960 1.02E-16 6.0 1.03E-32 12.0 5.08E-17 6.0 1.39E-10 4.0 3 Ip=3 120 5.71E-15 --- 3.26E-29 --- 2.86E-15 --- 4.30E-09 --- 240 2.23E-17 8.0 4.95E-34 16.0 1.11E-17 8.0 7.11E-11 5.9 480 8.69E-20 8.0 7.54E-39 16.0 4.34E-20 8.0 1.13E-12 6.0 960 3.39E-22 8.0 1.15E-43 16.0 1.70E-22 8.0 1.77E-14 6.0 4 Ip=4 120 3.76E-18 --- 1.42E-35 --- 1.88E-18 --- 5.22E-11 --- 240 3.65E-21 10.0 1.33E-41 20.0 1.82E-21 10.0 2.37E-13 7.8 480 3.56E-24 10.0 1.27E-47 20.0 1.78E-24 10.0 9.61E-16 7.9 960 3.47E-27 10.0 1.21E-53 20.0 1.74E-27 10.0 3.79E-18 8.0 5 Ip=4 120 9.40E-21 --- 8.84E-41 --- 4.70E-21 --- 8.34E-13 --- 240 2.27E-24 12.0 5.15E-48 24.0 1.13E-24 12.0 1.17E-15 9.5 480 5.52E-28 12.0 3.05E-55 24.0 2.76E-28 12.0 1.23E-18 9.9 960 1.35E-31 12.0 1.81E-62 24.0 6.74E-32 12.0 1.23E-21 10.0 Table 31 : Benchmark ODE3b: K=3 with I_{p}=I_{p,\min} and \varepsilon=10^{-60} . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 120 2.50E-12 --- 6.24E-24 --- 1.25E-12 --- 1.25E-23 --- 240 3.90E-14 6.0 1.52E-27 12.0 1.95E-14 6.0 3.04E-27 12.0 480 6.10E-16 6.0 3.72E-31 12.0 3.05E-16 6.0 7.43E-31 12.0 960 9.52E-18 6.0 9.07E-35 12.0 4.76E-18 6.0 1.81E-34 12.0 120 2.18E-20 --- 4.75E-40 --- 1.09E-20 --- 9.51E-40 --- 240 2.13E-23 10.0 4.55E-46 20.0 1.07E-23 10.0 9.10E-46 20.0 480 2.08E-26 10.0 4.34E-52 20.0 1.04E-26 10.0 8.69E-52 20.0 960 2.04E-29 10.0 4.14E-58 20.0 1.02E-29 10.0 8.29E-58 20.0 120 3.94E-23 --- 1.56E-45 --- 1.97E-23 --- 3.11E-45 --- 240 9.59E-27 12.0 9.20E-53 24.0 4.80E-27 12.0 1.84E-52 24.0 480 2.34E-30 12.0 5.47E-60 24.0 1.17E-30 12.0 1.09E-59 24.0 960 5.71E-34 12.0 3.26E-67 24.0 2.86E-34 12.0 6.52E-67 24.0 120 5.08E-29 --- 2.58E-57 --- 2.54E-29 --- 5.16E-57 --- 240 7.72E-34 16.0 5.96E-67 32.0 3.86E-34 16.0 1.19E-66 32.0 480 1.18E-38 16.0 1.39E-76 32.0 5.89E-39 16.0 2.77E-76 32.0 960 1.80E-43 16.0 3.23E-86 32.0 8.98E-44 16.0 6.45E-86 32.0 120 5.54E-31 --- 3.07E-61 --- 2.77E-31 --- 6.14E-61 --- 240 5.70E-38 23.2 3.25E-75 46.4 2.85E-38 23.2 6.50E-75 46.4 480 2.17E-43 18.0 4.72E-86 36.0 1.09E-43 18.0 9.43E-86 36.0 960 8.28E-49 18.0 6.86E-97 36.0 4.14E-49 18.0 1.37E-96 36.0 Table 32 : Benchmark ODE3c: K=1 with I_{p}=I_{p,\min} and \varepsilon=10^{-20} . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 1 Ip=1 Ip=2 120 2.45E-01 --- 9.87E+00 --- 2.56E+03 --- 4.04E+06 --- 240 6.00E-02 2.0 2.40E+00 2.0 1.56E+03 0.7 4.78E+06 \uparrow 480 1.49E-02 2.0 5.97E-01 2.0 8.58E+02 0.9 5.31E+06 \uparrow 960 3.72E-03 2.0 1.49E-01 2.0 4.51E+02 0.9 5.63E+06 \uparrow 2 Ip=2 Ip=3 120 2.75E-03 --- 1.10E-01 --- 9.07E+02 --- 3.64E+05 --- 240 1.74E-04 4.0 6.96E-03 4.0 2.95E+02 1.6 2.76E+05 0.4 480 1.09E-05 4.0 4.36E-04 4.0 8.54E+01 1.8 1.62E+05 0.8 960 6.82E-07 4.0 2.73E-05 4.0 2.31E+01 1.9 8.55E+04 0.9 3 Ip=2 Ip=3 120 6.09E-03 --- 2.43E-01 --- 3.27E+02 --- 1.81E+05 --- 240 3.89E-04 4.0 1.56E-02 4.0 6.71E+01 2.3 6.78E+04 1.4 480 2.45E-05 4.0 9.80E-04 4.0 1.10E+01 2.6 2.14E+04 1.7 960 1.53E-06 4.0 6.13E-05 4.0 1.60E+00 2.8 6.05E+03 1.8 4 Ip=3 Ip=4 120 5.12E-04 --- 2.05E-02 --- 1.51E+02 --- 8.97E+04 --- 240 9.68E-06 5.7 3.87E-04 5.7 1.90E+01 3.0 2.14E+04 2.1 480 1.61E-07 5.9 6.42E-06 5.9 1.79E+00 3.4 3.89E+03 2.5 960 2.55E-09 6.0 1.02E-07 6.0 1.40E-01 3.7 5.98E+02 2.7 5 Ip=3 Ip=4 120 9.94E-04 --- 3.98E-02 --- 7.11E+01 --- 4.75E+04 --- 240 2.00E-05 5.6 8.01E-04 5.6 6.04E+00 3.6 7.47E+03 2.7 480 3.41E-07 5.9 1.37E-05 5.9 3.38E-01 4.2 8.06E+02 3.2 960 5.46E-09 6.0 2.19E-07 6.0 1.45E-02 4.5 6.81E+01 3.6 Table 33 : Benchmark ODE3c: K=2 with I_{p}=I_{p,\min} and \varepsilon=10^{-40} . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 1 Ip=2 120 7.00E-04 --- 2.80E-02 --- 1.68E+00 --- 5.65E+04 --- 240 4.37E-05 4.0 1.75E-03 4.0 1.05E-01 4.0 1.62E+04 1.8 480 2.73E-06 4.0 1.09E-04 4.0 6.55E-03 4.0 4.26E+03 1.9 960 1.70E-07 4.0 6.82E-06 4.0 4.09E-04 4.0 1.08E+03 2.0 2 Ip=2 120 3.15E-05 --- 1.26E-03 --- 7.56E-02 --- 2.09E+03 --- 240 5.16E-07 5.9 2.06E-05 5.9 1.24E-03 5.9 2.08E+02 3.3 480 8.17E-09 6.0 3.27E-07 6.0 1.96E-05 6.0 1.67E+01 3.6 960 1.28E-10 6.0 5.12E-09 6.0 3.07E-07 6.0 1.20E+00 3.8 3 Ip=3 120 2.87E-06 --- 1.15E-04 --- 6.89E-03 --- 2.62E+02 --- 240 1.40E-08 7.7 5.59E-07 7.7 3.35E-05 7.7 9.50E+00 4.8 480 5.84E-11 7.9 2.33E-09 7.9 1.40E-07 7.9 2.38E-01 5.3 960 2.32E-13 8.0 9.28E-12 8.0 5.57E-10 8.0 4.79E-03 5.6 4 Ip=4 120 4.00E-07 --- 1.60E-05 --- 9.61E-04 --- 4.57E+01 --- 240 6.70E-10 9.2 2.68E-08 9.2 1.61E-06 9.2 6.50E-01 6.1 480 7.92E-13 9.7 3.17E-11 9.7 1.90E-09 9.7 5.34E-03 6.9 960 8.17E-16 9.9 3.27E-14 9.9 1.96E-12 9.9 3.12E-05 7.4 5 Ip=4 120 7.48E-08 --- 2.99E-06 --- 1.80E-04 --- 1.00E+01 --- 240 4.87E-11 10.6 1.95E-09 10.6 1.17E-07 10.6 5.99E-02 7.4 480 1.77E-14 11.4 7.09E-13 11.4 4.25E-11 11.4 1.69E-04 8.5 960 4.90E-18 11.8 1.96E-16 11.8 1.18E-14 11.8 2.96E-07 9.2 Table 34 : Benchmark ODE3c: K=3 with I_{p}=I_{p,\min} and \varepsilon=10^{-60} . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 120 3.12E-06 --- 1.25E-04 --- 7.48E-03 --- 5.99E-01 --- 240 4.91E-08 6.0 1.96E-06 6.0 1.18E-04 6.0 9.43E-03 6.0 480 7.69E-10 6.0 3.08E-08 6.0 1.85E-06 6.0 1.48E-04 6.0 960 1.20E-11 6.0 4.81E-10 6.0 2.88E-08 6.0 2.31E-06 6.0 120 2.60E-09 --- 1.04E-07 --- 6.25E-06 --- 5.00E-04 --- 240 3.05E-12 9.7 1.22E-10 9.7 7.32E-09 9.7 5.86E-07 9.7 480 3.14E-15 9.9 1.26E-13 9.9 7.53E-12 9.9 6.03E-10 9.9 960 3.11E-18 10.0 1.24E-16 10.0 7.46E-15 10.0 5.97E-13 10.0 120 7.19E-10 --- 2.88E-08 --- 1.73E-06 --- 1.38E-04 --- 240 2.90E-13 11.3 1.16E-11 11.3 6.95E-10 11.3 5.56E-08 11.3 480 8.37E-17 11.8 3.35E-15 11.8 2.01E-13 11.8 1.61E-11 11.8 960 2.14E-20 11.9 8.57E-19 11.9 5.14E-17 11.9 4.11E-15 11.9 120 8.18E-12 --- 3.27E-10 --- 1.96E-08 --- 1.57E-06 --- 240 4.15E-16 14.3 1.66E-14 14.3 9.95E-13 14.3 7.96E-11 14.3 480 1.03E-20 15.3 4.11E-19 15.3 2.46E-17 15.3 1.97E-15 15.3 960 1.82E-25 15.8 7.29E-24 15.8 4.38E-22 15.8 3.50E-20 15.8 120 3.23E-12 --- 1.29E-10 --- 7.75E-09 --- 6.20E-07 --- 240 7.45E-17 15.4 2.98E-15 15.4 1.79E-13 15.4 1.43E-11 15.4 480 6.41E-22 16.8 2.57E-20 16.8 1.54E-18 16.8 1.23E-16 16.8 960 3.25E-27 17.6 1.30E-25 17.6 7.80E-24 17.6 6.24E-22 17.6 7.4 Benchmark ODE4 We explore the system case and consider the first-order plane waves equation system \left\{\begin{array}[]{l}\phi^{\prime}=\alpha\psi,\\ \psi^{\prime}=-\alpha\phi,\end{array}\right. leading to the second-order linear equation \phi^{\prime\prime}+\alpha^{2}\phi=0 , where \alpha\in\mathbb{R} . Assuming that \phi(0)=1 and \psi(0)=0 , the exact solution reads \phi(t)=\cos(\alpha t) . Tables 35 , 36 , and 37 We consider a low frequency case \alpha=2.1\pi (benchmark ODE4a) and a high frequency case \alpha=10.1\pi (benchmark ODE4b) to check the ability of the schemes to catch the correct solution with low phase deviations. Tables and report the errors and convergence orders at the final time T=1 for the five schemes. Tables 35 , 36 , and 37 Table 35 : Benchmark ODE4: K=1 . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} E O E O 1 60 2.03E-03 --- 4.17E-02 --- 120 5.12E-04 2.0 1.04E-02 2.0 240 1.28E-04 2.0 2.61E-03 2.0 2 60 6.60E-06 --- 1.34E-04 --- 120 4.14E-07 4.0 8.40E-06 4.0 240 2.59E-08 4.0 5.25E-07 4.0 3 60 3.68E-06 --- 7.47E-05 --- 120 2.32E-07 4.0 4.71E-06 4.0 240 1.45E-08 4.0 2.95E-07 4.0 4 60 4.53E-08 --- 9.21E-07 --- 120 7.13E-10 6.0 1.45E-08 6.0 240 1.12E-11 6.0 2.27E-10 6.0 5 60 1.58E-08 --- 3.21E-07 --- 120 2.54E-10 6.0 5.15E-09 6.0 240 3.99E-12 6.0 8.10E-11 6.0 Table 36 : Benchmark ODE4: K=2 . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} E O E O E O 1 60 4.14E-07 --- 8.40E-06 --- 1.80E-05 --- 120 2.59E-08 4.0 5.25E-07 4.0 1.13E-06 4.0 240 1.62E-09 4.0 3.28E-08 4.0 7.04E-08 4.0 2 60 3.80E-10 --- 7.72E-09 --- 1.65E-08 --- 120 5.95E-12 6.0 1.21E-10 6.0 2.59E-10 6.0 240 9.31E-14 6.0 1.89E-12 6.0 4.05E-12 6.0 3 60 4.14E-13 --- 8.40E-12 --- 1.80E-11 --- 120 1.62E-15 8.0 3.30E-14 8.0 7.07E-14 8.0 240 6.36E-18 8.0 1.29E-16 8.0 2.77E-16 8.0 4 60 5.28E-16 --- 1.07E-14 --- 2.30E-14 --- 120 5.22E-19 10.0 1.06E-17 10.0 2.27E-17 10.0 240 5.11E-22 10.0 1.04E-20 10.0 2.22E-20 10.0 5 60 7.78E-19 --- 1.58E-17 --- 3.39E-17 --- 120 1.94E-22 12.0 3.94E-21 12.0 8.44E-21 12.0 240 4.76E-26 12.0 9.66E-25 12.0 2.07E-24 12.0 Table 37 : Benchmark ODE4: K=3 . R N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 1 60 3.57E-11 --- 7.25E-10 --- 1.56E-09 --- 3.16E-08 --- 120 5.58E-13 6.0 1.13E-11 6.0 2.43E-11 6.0 4.94E-10 6.0 240 8.73E-15 6.0 1.77E-13 6.0 3.80E-13 6.0 7.71E-12 6.0 2 60 2.01E-17 --- 4.08E-16 --- 8.74E-16 --- 1.77E-14 --- 120 1.96E-20 10.0 3.99E-19 10.0 8.54E-19 10.0 1.73E-17 10.0 240 1.92E-23 10.0 3.89E-22 10.0 8.34E-22 10.0 1.69E-20 10.0 3 60 3.36E-21 --- 6.82E-20 --- 1.46E-19 --- 2.97E-18 --- 120 8.25E-25 12.0 1.68E-23 12.0 3.59E-23 12.0 7.29E-22 12.0 240 2.02E-28 12.0 4.10E-27 12.0 8.79E-27 12.0 1.78E-25 12.0 4 60 1.09E-26 --- 2.20E-25 --- 4.72E-25 --- 9.59E-24 --- 120 1.66E-31 16.0 3.38E-30 16.0 7.24E-30 16.0 1.47E-28 16.0 240 2.54E-36 16.0 5.16E-35 16.0 1.11E-34 16.0 2.25E-33 16.0 5 60 1.28E-30 --- 2.59E-29 --- 5.55E-29 --- 1.13E-27 --- 120 4.97E-36 18.0 1.01E-34 18.0 2.16E-34 18.0 4.40E-33 18.0 240 1.91E-41 18.0 3.87E-40 18.0 8.30E-40 18.0 1.69E-38 18.0 7.5 Benchmark ODE5 — Van der Pol Table 38 : Benchmark ODE5a (VanDerPol with \mu=1.0 ): K=1 with \varepsilon=10^{-20} for x . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} E O E O 1 480 20.85 2.88E-05 --- 2.57E-04 --- 600 19.79 1.85E-05 2.0 1.64E-04 2.0 720 19.04 1.28E-05 2.0 1.14E-04 2.0 2 480 10.90 3.26E-08 --- 3.56E-08 --- 600 10.33 1.34E-08 4.0 1.46E-08 4.0 720 9.89 6.44E-09 4.0 7.05E-09 4.0 3 480 7.67 2.79E-08 --- 6.42E-09 --- 600 7.25 1.14E-08 4.0 2.59E-09 4.1 720 6.95 5.51E-09 4.0 1.24E-09 4.0 4 480 5.90 5.16E-11 --- 1.48E-10 --- 600 5.59 1.36E-11 6.0 3.89E-11 6.0 720 5.33 4.54E-12 6.0 1.30E-11 6.0 5 480 4.87 3.84E-11 --- 3.23E-12 --- 600 4.59 1.01E-11 6.0 6.49E-13 7.2 720 4.38 3.37E-12 6.0 1.82E-13 7.0 Table 39 : Benchmark ODE5a (VanDerPol with \mu=1.0 ): K=1 with \varepsilon=10^{-20} for y . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} E O E O 1 480 20.85 2.57E-04 --- 8.09E-04 --- 600 19.79 1.64E-04 2.0 5.18E-04 2.0 720 19.04 1.14E-04 2.0 3.59E-04 2.0 2 480 10.90 3.56E-08 --- 1.41E-07 --- 600 10.33 1.46E-08 4.0 5.77E-08 4.0 720 9.89 7.05E-09 4.0 2.78E-08 4.0 3 480 7.67 6.42E-09 --- 8.42E-09 --- 600 7.25 2.59E-09 4.1 3.58E-09 3.8 720 6.95 1.24E-09 4.0 1.76E-09 3.9 4 480 5.90 1.48E-10 --- 5.00E-10 --- 600 5.59 3.89E-11 6.0 1.31E-10 6.0 720 5.33 1.30E-11 6.0 4.41E-11 6.0 5 480 4.87 3.23E-12 --- 2.86E-11 --- 600 4.59 6.49E-13 7.2 8.10E-12 5.7 720 4.38 1.82E-13 7.0 2.82E-12 5.8 Table 40 : Benchmark ODE5a (VanDerPol with \mu=1.0 ): K=2 with \varepsilon=10^{-40} for x . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} E O E O E O 1 480 19.97 3.10E-09 --- 6.84E-10 --- 1.03E-09 --- 600 18.90 1.27E-09 4.0 2.80E-10 4.0 4.21E-10 4.0 720 18.10 6.12E-10 4.0 1.35E-10 4.0 2.03E-10 4.0 2 480 11.00 8.93E-13 --- 3.12E-14 --- 7.99E-13 --- 600 10.38 2.34E-13 6.0 7.75E-15 6.2 2.11E-13 6.0 720 9.92 7.84E-14 6.0 2.51E-15 6.2 7.08E-14 6.0 3 480 8.05 6.39E-16 --- 3.23E-15 --- 9.17E-15 --- 600 7.54 1.07E-16 8.0 5.43E-16 8.0 1.54E-15 8.0 720 7.17 2.49E-17 8.0 1.26E-16 8.0 3.58E-16 8.0 4 480 6.65 1.66E-18 --- 6.14E-18 --- 1.70E-17 --- 600 6.22 1.78E-19 10.0 6.59E-19 10.0 1.82E-18 10.0 720 5.88 2.87E-20 10.0 1.06E-19 10.0 2.94E-19 10.0 5 480 5.99 3.76E-21 --- 7.57E-21 --- 1.92E-20 --- 600 5.52 2.59E-22 12.0 5.19E-22 12.0 1.32E-21 12.0 720 5.19 2.91E-23 12.0 5.82E-23 12.0 1.47E-22 12.0 Table 41 : Benchmark ODE5a (VanDerPol with \mu=1.0 ): K=2 with \varepsilon=10^{-40} for y . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} E O E O E O 1 480 19.97 6.84E-10 --- 1.03E-09 --- 2.88E-08 --- 600 18.90 2.80E-10 4.0 4.21E-10 4.0 1.18E-08 4.0 720 18.10 1.35E-10 4.0 2.03E-10 4.0 5.69E-09 4.0 2 480 11.00 3.12E-14 --- 7.99E-13 --- 9.66E-12 --- 600 10.38 7.75E-15 6.2 2.11E-13 6.0 2.54E-12 6.0 720 9.92 2.51E-15 6.2 7.08E-14 6.0 8.50E-13 6.0 3 480 8.05 3.23E-15 --- 9.17E-15 --- 1.94E-14 --- 600 7.54 5.43E-16 8.0 1.54E-15 8.0 3.26E-15 8.0 720 7.17 1.26E-16 8.0 3.58E-16 8.0 7.59E-16 8.0 4 480 6.65 6.14E-18 --- 1.70E-17 --- 3.19E-17 --- 600 6.22 6.59E-19 10.0 1.82E-18 10.0 3.43E-18 10.0 720 5.88 1.06E-19 10.0 2.94E-19 10.0 5.54E-19 10.0 5 480 5.99 7.57E-21 --- 1.92E-20 --- 2.05E-20 --- 600 5.52 5.19E-22 12.0 1.32E-21 12.0 1.39E-21 12.1 720 5.19 5.82E-23 12.0 1.47E-22 12.0 1.55E-22 12.0 Table 42 : Benchmark ODE5a (VanDerPol with \mu=1.0 ): K=3 with \varepsilon=10^{-60} for x . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 1 480 29.58 8.37E-14 --- 2.58E-15 --- 7.59E-14 --- 9.09E-13 --- 600 28.02 2.20E-14 6.0 6.69E-16 6.1 1.99E-14 6.0 2.38E-13 6.0 720 26.75 7.35E-15 6.0 2.22E-16 6.0 6.68E-15 6.0 7.98E-14 6.0 2 480 15.12 2.35E-20 --- 1.24E-19 --- 3.54E-19 --- 7.61E-19 --- 600 14.24 2.52E-21 10.0 1.34E-20 10.0 3.80E-20 10.0 8.17E-20 10.0 720 13.69 4.07E-22 10.0 2.16E-21 10.0 6.14E-21 10.0 1.32E-20 10.0 3 480 10.60 1.60E-23 --- 3.19E-23 --- 8.09E-23 --- 8.47E-23 --- 600 10.01 1.10E-24 12.0 2.19E-24 12.0 5.56E-24 12.0 5.80E-24 12.0 720 9.54 1.23E-25 12.0 2.46E-25 12.0 6.23E-25 12.0 6.49E-25 12.0 4 480 8.83 1.84E-28 --- 6.39E-28 --- 1.75E-27 --- 3.20E-27 --- 600 8.30 4.91E-30 16.2 1.73E-29 16.2 4.75E-29 16.2 8.72E-29 16.1 720 7.88 2.58E-31 16.2 9.13E-31 16.1 2.51E-30 16.1 4.63E-30 16.1 5 480 8.07 9.41E-31 --- 2.62E-30 --- 7.02E-30 --- 1.11E-29 --- 600 7.48 1.68E-32 18.0 4.70E-32 18.0 1.26E-31 18.0 1.99E-31 18.0 720 7.08 6.30E-34 18.0 1.76E-33 18.0 4.71E-33 18.0 7.44E-33 18.0 Table 43 : Benchmark ODE5a (VanDerPol with \mu=1.0 ): K=3 with \varepsilon=10^{-60} for y . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 1 480 29.58 2.58E-15 --- 7.59E-14 --- 9.09E-13 --- 4.79E-12 --- 600 28.02 6.69E-16 6.1 1.99E-14 6.0 2.38E-13 6.0 1.26E-12 6.0 720 26.75 2.22E-16 6.0 6.68E-15 6.0 7.98E-14 6.0 4.21E-13 6.0 2 480 15.12 1.24E-19 --- 3.54E-19 --- 7.61E-19 --- 1.63E-18 --- 600 14.24 1.34E-20 10.0 3.80E-20 10.0 8.17E-20 10.0 1.75E-19 10.0 720 13.69 2.16E-21 10.0 6.14E-21 10.0 1.32E-20 10.0 2.83E-20 10.0 3 480 10.60 3.19E-23 --- 8.09E-23 --- 8.47E-23 --- 9.88E-22 --- 600 10.01 2.19E-24 12.0 5.56E-24 12.0 5.80E-24 12.0 6.80E-23 12.0 720 9.54 2.46E-25 12.0 6.23E-25 12.0 6.49E-25 12.0 7.63E-24 12.0 4 480 8.83 6.39E-28 --- 1.75E-27 --- 3.20E-27 --- 1.20E-26 --- 600 8.30 1.73E-29 16.2 4.75E-29 16.2 8.72E-29 16.1 3.21E-28 16.2 720 7.88 9.13E-31 16.1 2.51E-30 16.1 4.63E-30 16.1 1.69E-29 16.2 5 480 8.07 2.62E-30 --- 7.02E-30 --- 1.11E-29 --- 5.99E-29 --- 600 7.48 4.70E-32 18.0 1.26E-31 18.0 1.99E-31 18.0 1.07E-30 18.0 720 7.08 1.76E-33 18.0 4.71E-33 18.0 7.44E-33 18.0 4.01E-32 18.0 Table 44: ODE5a — Van der Pol with \mu=1 : K=1 , R=1 , N=480 . Table 45 : Benchmark ODE5b (VanDerPol with \mu=50.0 ): K=1 with \varepsilon=10^{-20} for x . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} E O E O 1 840000 4.47 1.57E-06 --- 2.38E-04 --- 960000 4.17 1.21E-06 2.0 1.82E-04 2.0 1080000 4.09 9.55E-07 2.0 1.43E-04 2.0 2 840000 2.51 3.44E-11 --- 5.32E-09 --- 960000 2.51 2.02E-11 4.0 3.12E-09 4.0 1080000 2.51 1.26E-11 4.0 1.95E-09 4.0 3 840000 1.68 1.94E-11 --- 2.98E-09 --- 960000 1.68 1.14E-11 4.0 1.75E-09 4.0 1080000 1.67 7.10E-12 4.0 1.09E-09 4.0 4 840000 1.26 3.99E-15 --- 5.89E-13 --- 960000 1.26 1.79E-15 6.0 2.64E-13 6.0 1080000 1.26 8.83E-16 6.0 1.30E-13 6.0 5 840000 1.20 1.42E-15 --- 2.11E-13 --- 960000 1.03 6.38E-16 6.0 9.49E-14 6.0 1080000 1.01 3.15E-16 6.0 4.68E-14 6.0 Table 46 : Benchmark ODE5b (VanDerPol with \mu=50.0 ): K=1 with \varepsilon=10^{-20} for y . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} E O E O 1 840000 4.47 2.38E-04 --- 3.58E-02 --- 960000 4.17 1.82E-04 2.0 2.73E-02 2.0 1080000 4.09 1.43E-04 2.0 2.16E-02 2.0 2 840000 2.51 5.32E-09 --- 8.01E-07 --- 960000 2.51 3.12E-09 4.0 4.70E-07 4.0 1080000 2.51 1.95E-09 4.0 2.93E-07 4.0 3 840000 1.68 2.98E-09 --- 4.49E-07 --- 960000 1.68 1.75E-09 4.0 2.63E-07 4.0 1080000 1.67 1.09E-09 4.0 1.64E-07 4.0 4 840000 1.26 5.89E-13 --- 8.87E-11 --- 960000 1.26 2.64E-13 6.0 3.98E-11 6.0 1080000 1.26 1.30E-13 6.0 1.96E-11 6.0 5 840000 1.20 2.11E-13 --- 3.18E-11 --- 960000 1.03 9.49E-14 6.0 1.43E-11 6.0 1080000 1.01 4.68E-14 6.0 7.05E-12 6.0 Table 47 : Benchmark ODE5b (VanDerPol with \mu=50.0 ): K=2 with \varepsilon=10^{-40} for x . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} E O E O E O 1 840000 10.74 2.16E-12 --- 3.31E-10 --- 4.99E-08 --- 960000 10.47 1.26E-12 4.0 1.94E-10 4.0 2.93E-08 4.0 1080000 10.10 7.89E-13 4.0 1.21E-10 4.0 1.83E-08 4.0 2 840000 5.81 3.31E-17 --- 4.93E-15 --- 7.42E-13 --- 960000 5.66 1.49E-17 6.0 2.21E-15 6.0 3.33E-13 6.0 1080000 5.45 7.33E-18 6.0 1.09E-15 6.0 1.64E-13 6.0 3 840000 4.16 1.06E-21 --- 1.59E-19 --- 2.40E-17 --- 960000 4.03 3.64E-22 8.0 5.48E-20 8.0 8.25E-18 8.0 1080000 3.91 1.42E-22 8.0 2.14E-20 8.0 3.22E-18 8.0 4 840000 3.34 6.27E-26 --- 9.46E-24 --- 1.42E-21 --- 960000 3.24 1.65E-26 10.0 2.49E-24 10.0 3.75E-22 10.0 1080000 3.14 5.08E-27 10.0 7.67E-25 10.0 1.15E-22 10.0 5 840000 2.89 6.21E-30 --- 9.32E-28 --- 1.40E-25 --- 960000 2.79 1.25E-30 12.0 1.88E-28 12.0 2.83E-26 12.0 1080000 2.69 3.04E-31 12.0 4.57E-29 12.0 6.89E-27 12.0 Table 48 : Benchmark ODE5b (VanDerPol with \mu=50.0 ): K=2 with \varepsilon=10^{-40} for y . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} E O E O E O 1 840000 10.74 3.31E-10 --- 4.99E-08 --- 7.52E-06 --- 960000 10.47 1.94E-10 4.0 2.93E-08 4.0 4.41E-06 4.0 1080000 10.10 1.21E-10 4.0 1.83E-08 4.0 2.75E-06 4.0 2 840000 5.81 4.93E-15 --- 7.42E-13 --- 1.12E-10 --- 960000 5.66 2.21E-15 6.0 3.33E-13 6.0 5.01E-11 6.0 1080000 5.45 1.09E-15 6.0 1.64E-13 6.0 2.47E-11 6.0 3 840000 4.16 1.59E-19 --- 2.40E-17 --- 3.62E-15 --- 960000 4.03 5.48E-20 8.0 8.25E-18 8.0 1.24E-15 8.0 1080000 3.91 2.14E-20 8.0 3.22E-18 8.0 4.84E-16 8.0 4 840000 3.34 9.46E-24 --- 1.42E-21 --- 2.15E-19 --- 960000 3.24 2.49E-24 10.0 3.75E-22 10.0 5.65E-20 10.0 1080000 3.14 7.67E-25 10.0 1.15E-22 10.0 1.74E-20 10.0 5 840000 2.89 9.32E-28 --- 1.40E-25 --- 2.11E-23 --- 960000 2.79 1.88E-28 12.0 2.83E-26 12.0 4.26E-24 12.0 1080000 2.69 4.57E-29 12.0 6.89E-27 12.0 1.04E-24 12.0 Table 49 : Benchmark ODE5b (VanDerPol with \mu=50.0 ): K=3 with \varepsilon=10^{-60} for x . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 1 840000 16.91 3.10E-18 --- 4.62E-16 --- 6.96E-14 --- 1.05E-11 --- 960000 16.40 1.39E-18 6.0 2.07E-16 6.0 3.12E-14 6.0 4.70E-12 6.0 1080000 16.07 6.87E-19 6.0 1.02E-16 6.0 1.54E-14 6.0 2.32E-12 6.0 2 840000 8.65 2.36E-27 --- 3.55E-25 --- 5.34E-23 --- 8.05E-21 --- 960000 8.44 6.20E-28 10.0 9.34E-26 10.0 1.41E-23 10.0 2.12E-21 10.0 1080000 8.22 1.91E-28 10.0 2.87E-26 10.0 4.33E-24 10.0 6.52E-22 10.0 3 840000 6.01 2.64E-32 --- 3.96E-30 --- 5.96E-28 --- 8.98E-26 --- 960000 5.83 5.31E-33 12.0 7.98E-31 12.0 1.20E-28 12.0 1.81E-26 12.0 1080000 5.68 1.29E-33 12.0 1.94E-31 12.0 2.92E-29 12.0 4.40E-27 12.0 4 840000 4.88 9.02E-40 --- 1.36E-37 --- 2.04E-35 --- 3.08E-33 --- 960000 4.72 1.07E-40 16.0 1.60E-38 16.0 2.41E-36 16.0 3.64E-34 16.0 1080000 4.60 1.62E-41 16.0 2.44E-39 16.0 3.67E-37 16.0 5.52E-35 16.0 5 840000 4.28 1.61E-44 --- 2.42E-42 --- 3.65E-40 --- 5.50E-38 --- 960000 4.13 1.46E-45 18.0 2.19E-43 18.0 3.30E-41 18.0 4.97E-39 18.0 1080000 4.02 1.75E-46 18.0 2.63E-44 18.0 3.97E-42 18.0 5.98E-40 18.0 Table 50 : Benchmark ODE5b (VanDerPol with \mu=50.0 ): K=3 with \varepsilon=10^{-60} for y . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 1 840000 16.91 4.62E-16 --- 6.96E-14 --- 1.05E-11 --- 1.58E-09 --- 960000 16.40 2.07E-16 6.0 3.12E-14 6.0 4.70E-12 6.0 7.08E-10 6.0 1080000 16.07 1.02E-16 6.0 1.54E-14 6.0 2.32E-12 6.0 3.49E-10 6.0 2 840000 8.65 3.55E-25 --- 5.34E-23 --- 8.05E-21 --- 1.21E-18 --- 960000 8.44 9.34E-26 10.0 1.41E-23 10.0 2.12E-21 10.0 3.19E-19 10.0 1080000 8.22 2.87E-26 10.0 4.33E-24 10.0 6.52E-22 10.0 9.82E-20 10.0 3 840000 6.01 3.96E-30 --- 5.96E-28 --- 8.98E-26 --- 1.35E-23 --- 960000 5.83 7.98E-31 12.0 1.20E-28 12.0 1.81E-26 12.0 2.72E-24 12.0 1080000 5.68 1.94E-31 12.0 2.92E-29 12.0 4.40E-27 12.0 6.63E-25 12.0 4 840000 4.88 1.36E-37 --- 2.04E-35 --- 3.08E-33 --- 4.64E-31 --- 960000 4.72 1.60E-38 16.0 2.41E-36 16.0 3.64E-34 16.0 5.47E-32 16.0 1080000 4.60 2.44E-39 16.0 3.67E-37 16.0 5.52E-35 16.0 8.32E-33 16.0 5 840000 4.28 2.42E-42 --- 3.65E-40 --- 5.50E-38 --- 8.27E-36 --- 960000 4.13 2.19E-43 18.0 3.30E-41 18.0 4.97E-39 18.0 7.49E-37 18.0 1080000 4.02 2.63E-44 18.0 3.97E-42 18.0 5.98E-40 18.0 9.00E-38 18.0 Table 51: ODE5b — Van der Pol with \mu=50 : K=1 , R=1 , N=840000 . Table 52 : Benchmark ODE5b-v3 (VanDerPol with \mu=50.0 ): K=1 with \varepsilon=10^{-20} for x . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} E O E O 1 18000 16.92 2.92E+00 --- 8.03E-01 --- 21000 15.28 2.84E+00 0.2 1.79E+00 \uparrow 24000 14.09 2.72E+00 0.3 4.19E+00 \uparrow 300000 6.03 1.16E-05 4.9 1.98E-03 3.0 2 18000 9.61 9.23E-05 --- 5.70E-02 --- 21000 8.61 2.61E-05 8.2 2.12E-02 6.4 24000 7.83 3.13E-05 \uparrow 1.02E-02 5.5 300000 3.01 2.11E-09 3.8 3.27E-07 4.1 3 18000 7.75 9.28E-04 --- 1.33E-02 --- 21000 6.77 9.69E-05 14.7 6.21E-03 4.9 24000 6.12 2.96E-07 43.4 1.55E-03 10.4 300000 2.17 1.19E-09 2.2 1.83E-07 3.6 4 18000 6.33 1.48E-04 --- 1.58E-03 --- 21000 5.49 6.45E-05 5.4 9.40E-03 \uparrow 24000 4.94 9.32E-05 \uparrow 1.22E-02 \uparrow 300000 1.75 1.92E-12 7.0 2.83E-10 7.0 5 18000 5.74 2.21E+00 --- 2.37E+01 --- 21000 4.90 1.74E-04 61.3 1.33E-02 48.5 24000 4.35 3.33E-03 \uparrow 5.07E-01 \uparrow 300000 1.42 6.80E-13 8.8 1.01E-10 8.8 Table 53 : Benchmark ODE5b-v3 (VanDerPol with \mu=50.0 ): K=2 with \varepsilon=10^{-40} for x . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} E O E O E O 1 18000 43.22 9.35E-06 --- 1.62E-03 --- 2.44E-01 --- 21000 38.46 5.24E-06 3.8 8.59E-04 4.1 1.29E-01 4.1 24000 35.16 3.13E-06 3.9 4.99E-04 4.1 7.52E-02 4.1 300000 13.51 1.33E-10 4.0 2.04E-08 4.0 3.07E-06 4.0 2 18000 0.00 0 --- 0 --- 0 --- 21000 0.00 0 !!! 0 !!! 0 !!! 24000 11.47 3.99E+00 \uparrow 2.30E+00 \uparrow 3.44E+02 \uparrow 300000 7.47 1.59E-14 13.1 2.37E-12 10.9 3.57E-10 10.9 3 18000 0.00 0 --- 0 --- 0 --- 21000 0.00 0 !!! 0 !!! 0 !!! 24000 0.00 0 !!! 0 !!! 0 !!! 300000 5.45 4.00E-18 \uparrow 6.01E-16 \uparrow 9.05E-14 \uparrow 4 18000 0.00 0 --- 0 --- 0 --- 21000 0.00 0 !!! 0 !!! 0 !!! 24000 0.00 0 !!! 0 !!! 0 !!! 300000 4.49 1.84E-21 \uparrow 2.78E-19 \uparrow 4.19E-17 \uparrow 5 18000 0.00 0 --- 0 --- 0 --- 21000 0.00 0 !!! 0 !!! 0 !!! 24000 0.00 0 !!! 0 !!! 0 !!! 300000 4.00 1.42E-24 \uparrow 2.13E-22 \uparrow 3.21E-20 \uparrow 7.6 Benchmark ODE7 — Chen “Exact solution” computed with K=4 , R=8 , N=800000 , \epsilon=10^{-60} Table 54 : Benchmark ODE7: K=1 with \varepsilon=10^{-20} for x . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} E O E O 1 7200000 4.00 1.98E+01 --- 3.03E-01 --- 7800000 4.00 1.58E+00 31.5 1.23E+02 \uparrow 8400000 4.00 2.34E+01 \uparrow 1.42E+02 \uparrow 2 7200000 2.01 4.62E-04 --- 2.87E-02 --- 7800000 2.01 3.36E-04 4.0 2.09E-02 4.0 8400000 2.00 2.50E-04 4.0 1.55E-02 4.0 3 3600000 1.52 4.19E-03 --- 2.58E-01 --- 3900000 1.50 3.04E-03 4.0 1.88E-01 4.0 4200000 1.48 2.26E-03 4.0 1.40E-01 4.0 4 200000 1.73 1.28E-02 --- 7.80E-01 --- 240000 1.67 4.25E-03 6.1 2.62E-01 6.0 280000 1.61 1.68E-03 6.0 1.04E-01 6.0 5 200000 1.41 4.49E-03 --- 2.81E-01 --- 220000 1.40 2.54E-03 6.0 1.59E-01 6.0 240000 1.38 1.51E-03 6.0 9.40E-02 6.0 Table 55 : Benchmark ODE7: K=2 with \varepsilon=10^{-20} for x . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} E O E O E O 1 9600000 2.99 9.12E-06 --- 5.67E-04 --- 8.65E-03 --- 10800000 2.98 5.70E-06 4.0 3.54E-04 4.0 5.40E-03 4.0 12000000 2.97 3.74E-06 4.0 2.32E-04 4.0 3.55E-03 4.0 2 280000 2.56 1.39E-05 --- 8.65E-04 --- 1.32E-02 --- 320000 2.52 6.21E-06 6.1 3.86E-04 6.1 5.89E-03 6.1 360000 2.48 3.05E-06 6.0 1.89E-04 6.0 2.89E-03 6.0 3 57000 2.49 8.25E-06 --- 5.12E-04 --- 7.82E-03 --- 60000 2.47 5.47E-06 8.0 3.40E-04 8.0 5.19E-03 8.0 63000 2.44 3.70E-06 8.0 2.30E-04 8.0 3.50E-03 8.0 4 20000 2.62 1.84E-05 --- 1.15E-03 --- 1.75E-02 --- 22000 2.55 7.11E-06 10.0 4.42E-04 10.0 6.74E-03 10.0 24000 2.48 3.01E-06 9.9 1.87E-04 9.9 2.85E-03 9.9 5 11000 2.82 1.78E-05 --- 1.10E-03 --- 1.69E-02 --- 12000 2.73 6.32E-06 11.9 3.93E-04 11.9 5.99E-03 11.9 13000 2.64 2.46E-06 11.8 1.53E-04 11.8 2.34E-03 11.8 Table 56 : Benchmark ODE7: K=3 with \varepsilon=10^{-20} for x . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 1 220000 4.03 5.63E-06 --- 3.50E-04 --- 5.34E-03 --- 6.05E-02 --- 260000 3.91 2.10E-06 5.9 1.31E-04 5.9 2.00E-03 5.9 2.26E-02 5.9 300000 3.80 9.14E-07 5.8 5.68E-05 5.8 8.67E-04 5.8 9.83E-03 5.8 2 12000 4.29 1.15E-04 --- 7.16E-03 --- 1.09E-01 --- 1.24E+00 --- 16000 3.95 6.52E-06 10.0 4.05E-04 10.0 6.18E-03 10.0 7.00E-02 10.0 20000 3.75 6.86E-07 10.1 4.26E-05 10.1 6.51E-04 10.1 7.37E-03 10.1 3 4500 4.19 3.26E-03 --- 2.01E-01 --- 3.08E+00 --- 3.46E+01 --- 6000 3.77 1.08E-04 11.8 6.71E-03 11.8 1.02E-01 11.8 1.16E+00 11.8 7500 3.51 7.58E-06 11.9 4.71E-04 11.9 7.18E-03 11.9 8.14E-02 11.9 4 4600 3.59 1.23E-05 --- 7.62E-04 --- 1.16E-02 --- 1.32E-01 --- 4800 3.53 1.30E-06 52.8 8.06E-05 52.8 1.23E-03 52.8 1.39E-02 52.8 5000 3.47 1.66E-07 50.3 1.03E-05 50.3 1.58E-04 50.3 1.79E-03 50.3 5 3000 4.32 6.34E-02 --- 3.57E+00 --- 5.63E+01 --- 5.49E+02 --- 4000 3.66 1.10E-04 22.1 6.81E-03 21.8 1.04E-01 21.9 1.18E+00 21.4 5000 3.27 1.17E-06 20.3 7.29E-05 20.3 1.11E-03 20.3 1.26E-02 20.3 Table 57 : Benchmark ODE7: K=4 with \varepsilon=10^{-20} for x . R N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} \phi^{(4)} E O E O E O E O E O 1 10000 7.64 3.58E-02 --- 2.37E+00 --- 3.55E+01 --- 4.39E+02 --- 3.63E+04 --- 15000 6.66 1.47E-03 7.9 9.14E-02 8.0 1.39E+00 8.0 1.59E+01 8.2 1.41E+03 8.0 20000 6.03 1.47E-04 8.0 9.15E-03 8.0 1.40E-01 8.0 1.58E+00 8.0 1.41E+02 8.0 25000 5.63 2.47E-05 8.0 1.53E-03 8.0 2.34E-02 8.0 2.65E-01 8.0 2.36E+01 8.0 30000 5.35 5.72E-06 8.0 3.55E-04 8.0 5.43E-03 8.0 6.15E-02 8.0 5.47E+00 8.0 35000 5.09 1.70E-06 7.9 1.06E-04 7.9 1.61E-03 7.9 1.83E-02 7.9 1.63E+00 7.9 2 3000 6.87 1.45E-02 --- 9.22E-01 --- 1.40E+01 --- 1.64E+02 --- 1.41E+04 --- 4000 6.04 4.81E-04 11.8 2.99E-02 11.9 4.56E-01 11.9 5.17E+00 12.0 4.60E+02 11.9 5000 5.51 3.35E-05 11.9 2.08E-03 11.9 3.18E-02 11.9 3.60E-01 11.9 3.20E+01 11.9 6000 5.10 3.80E-06 11.9 2.36E-04 11.9 3.61E-03 11.9 4.09E-02 11.9 3.63E+00 11.9 7000 4.82 6.14E-07 11.8 3.82E-05 11.8 5.83E-04 11.8 6.60E-03 11.8 5.87E-01 11.8 8000 4.56 9.35E-08 14.1 5.81E-06 14.1 8.86E-05 14.1 1.00E-03 14.1 8.93E-02 14.1 3 3300 5.24 1.72E-05 --- 1.07E-03 --- 1.63E-02 --- 1.84E-01 --- 1.64E+01 --- 3600 5.00 2.78E-07 47.4 1.72E-05 47.4 2.63E-04 47.4 2.98E-03 47.4 2.65E-01 47.4 3900 4.81 1.18E-07 10.7 7.35E-06 10.7 1.12E-04 10.7 1.27E-03 10.7 1.13E-01 10.7 4200 4.62 1.91E-08 24.6 1.19E-06 24.6 1.81E-05 24.6 2.05E-04 24.6 1.83E-02 24.6 4500 4.47 1.43E-09 37.6 8.89E-08 37.6 1.36E-06 37.5 1.54E-05 37.6 1.37E-03 37.6 4800 4.34 1.27E-08 \uparrow 7.90E-07 \uparrow 1.21E-05 \uparrow 1.37E-04 \uparrow 1.21E-02 \uparrow 4 2800 5.94 6.48E-05 --- 4.02E-03 --- 6.14E-02 --- 6.96E-01 --- 6.19E+01 --- 3000 5.63 6.71E-06 32.9 4.17E-04 32.9 6.36E-03 32.9 7.21E-02 32.9 6.41E+00 32.9 3200 5.36 2.01E-06 18.7 1.25E-04 18.7 1.90E-03 18.7 2.16E-02 18.7 1.92E+00 18.7 3400 5.13 2.72E-07 33.0 1.69E-05 33.0 2.58E-04 33.0 2.93E-03 33.0 2.60E-01 33.0 3600 4.94 1.06E-07 16.4 6.61E-06 16.4 1.01E-04 16.4 1.14E-03 16.4 1.02E-01 16.4 4000 4.59 6.84E-08 4.2 4.25E-06 4.2 6.49E-05 4.2 7.35E-04 4.2 6.53E-02 4.2 5 2500 0.00 1.13E+01 --- 2.66E+01 --- 5.17E+02 --- 1.46E+04 --- 6.02E+05 --- 2750 0.62 2.33E+01 \uparrow 3.02E+02 \uparrow 3.45E+03 \uparrow 1.51E+04 \uparrow 6.94E+06 \uparrow 3000 9.88 2.02E-07 213.3 1.25E-05 195.3 1.91E-04 192.0 2.17E-03 181.1 1.93E-01 200.0 3250 8.44 1.02E-07 8.6 6.31E-06 8.6 9.64E-05 8.6 1.09E-03 8.6 9.71E-02 8.6 3500 7.48 9.45E-09 32.1 5.87E-07 32.1 8.96E-06 32.1 1.02E-04 32.1 9.03E-03 32.1 3750 6.81 5.30E-08 \uparrow 3.29E-06 \uparrow 5.02E-05 \uparrow 5.69E-04 \uparrow 5.06E-02 \uparrow Table 58: ODE7 (Chen): left — K=1 , R=1 , N=8400000 ; right — K=4 , R=5 , N=5000 . K=2 , R=3 , N=60000 8  Conclusion We designed and analysed the construction of numerical scheme based on the structural method concept. Such schemes enable to provide very high accuracy, spectral resolution involving a compact stencil. Stability and convergence have been established and numerical benchmarks prove the efficiency of the method. Statement on the use of Artificial Intelligence Tools This document was reviewed and refined with the assistance of Large Language Models, such as ChatGPT, or similar tools, which helped check grammar, correct typos, and enhance clarity. Any Artificial Intelligence-generated text or content is clearly indicated within the document and is used only to a limited extent. The overall content and ideas remain solely the responsibility of the authors. Appendix A Analytical expression of some structural equations We recall the notations SE K R S (s) where K is the highest derivative order, R the block size, S the kernel dimension and M=(K+1)(R+1) . The Index s ranges from 1 to S such that the associated vectors ({\boldsymbol{a}}^{s})_{s=1}^{S} define a basis of the kernel. On the other hand, the formula is exact up to a polynomial degree d=M-s , thus we also provide the consistency error when we apply the formula to a smooth function \phi . A.1 Structural equations with K=1 The formulae only handle approximations of kind \phi^{(0)}_{n+r} and \phi^{(1)}_{n+r} with r{\in\llbracket{1,R}\rrbracket} . \bullet Case R=1 , S=1 ( M=4 ). We have a unique structural equation given by \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{1}\,{1}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{1} }}}\thinspace}(1):~\scriptstyle 2\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}-\phi^{(0)}_{n}\right)-\Delta t\left(\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)=0 The formula is exact up to degree d=M-1=3 and the consistency error is {\texttt{err(1)}}=2(\Delta t)^{2}||\phi^{(3)}||. \bullet Case R=2 , S=2 ( M=6 ). We have two structural equations of degree 5 and, 4 respectively: \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{1}\,{2}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{2} }}}\thinspace}(1):~\scriptstyle 3\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}-\phi^{(0)}_{n}\right)-\Delta t\left(\phi^{(1)}_{n+2}+4\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{1}\,{2}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{2} }}}\thinspace}(2):~\scriptstyle 2\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}-2\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}+\phi^{(0)}_{n}\right)-\Delta t\left(\phi^{(1)}_{n+2}-\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)=0 The consistency errors of the formula are given by \displaystyle{\texttt{err(1)}}=\frac{2}{3}(\Delta t)^{4}||\phi^{(6)}||,\qquad{\texttt{err(2)}}=4(\Delta t)^{3}||\phi^{(5)}||. \bullet Case R=3 , S=3 ( M=8 ) \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{1}\,{3}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{3} }}}\thinspace}(1):~\scriptstyle-11\phi^{(0)}_{n+3}-27\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}+27\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}+11\phi^{(0)}_{n}+\Delta t\left(+3\phi^{(1)}_{n+3}+27\phi^{(1)}_{n+2}+27\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+3\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{1}\,{3}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{3} }}}\thinspace}(2):~\scriptstyle 8\phi^{(0)}_{n+3}-27\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}+19\phi^{(0)}_{n}+\Delta t\left(-3\phi^{(1)}_{n+3}+27\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+6\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{1}\,{3}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{3} }}}\thinspace}(3):~\scriptstyle 13\phi^{(0)}_{n+3}-27\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}+27\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}-13\phi^{(0)}_{n}+\Delta t\left(-6\phi^{(1)}_{n+3}-6\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)=0 with errors {\texttt{err(1)}}=108(\Delta t)^{6}||\phi^{(7)}||,\quad{\texttt{err(2)}}=-108(\Delta t)^{5}||\phi^{(6)}||,\quad{\texttt{err(3)}}=-108(\Delta t)^{4}||\phi^{(5)}||. A.2 Structural equations with K=2 The formulae handle approximations of kind \phi^{(0)}_{n+r} , \phi^{(1)}_{n+r} and \phi^{(2)}_{n+r} with r{\in\llbracket{1,R}\rrbracket} . \bullet Case R=1 , S=2 ( M=6 ) \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{2}\,{1}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{2} }}}\thinspace}(1):~\scriptstyle 12\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}-\phi^{(0)}_{n}\right)-6\Delta t\left(\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)+\Delta t^{2}\left(\phi^{(2)}_{n+1}-\phi^{(2)}_{n}\right)=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{2}\,{1}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{2} }}}\thinspace}(2):~\scriptstyle 6\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}-\phi^{(0)}_{n}\right)-2\Delta t\left(2\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)+\Delta t^{2}\phi^{(2)}_{n+1}=0 \bullet Case R=2 , S=4 , ( M=9 ) \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{2}\,{2}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{4} }}}\thinspace}(1):~\scriptstyle 24\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}-2\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}+\phi^{(0)}_{n}\right)-9\Delta t\left(\phi^{(1)}_{n+2}-\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)+\Delta t^{2}\left(\phi^{(2)}_{n+2}-8\phi^{(2)}_{n+1}+\phi^{(2)}_{n}\right)=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{2}\,{2}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{4} }}}\thinspace}(2):~\scriptstyle 15\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}-\phi^{(0)}_{n}\right)-\Delta t\left(7\phi^{(1)}_{n+2}+16\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+7\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)+\Delta t^{2}\left(\phi^{(2)}_{n+2}-\phi^{(2)}_{n}\right)=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{2}\,{2}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{4} }}}\thinspace}(3):~\scriptstyle 23\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}-16\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}-7\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\Delta t\left(12\phi^{(1)}_{n+2}+16\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+2\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)+2\Delta t^{2}\phi^{(2)}_{n+2}=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{2}\,{2}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{4} }}}\thinspace}(4):~\scriptstyle 13\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}+16\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}-29\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\Delta t\left(32\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+10\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)-2\Delta t^{2}\phi^{(2)}_{n+2}=0 \bullet Case R=3 , S=6 ( M=12 ) \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{2}\,{3}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{6} }}}\thinspace}(1):~\scriptstyle 103\phi^{(0)}_{n+3}-729\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}+729\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}-103\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\Delta t\left(33\phi^{(1)}_{n+3}-243\phi^{(1)}_{n+2}-243\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+33\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)+\Delta t^{2}\left(3\phi^{(2)}_{n+3}-81\phi^{(2)}_{n+2}+81\phi^{(2)}_{n+1}-3\phi^{(2)}_{n}\right)=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{2}\,{3}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{6} }}}\thinspace}(2):~\scriptstyle 70\phi^{(0)}_{n+3}+243\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}-486\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}+173\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\Delta t\left(27\phi^{(1)}_{n+3}+162\phi^{(1)}_{n+2}+81\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}-60\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)+\Delta t^{2}\left(3\phi^{(2)}_{n+3}-81\phi^{(2)}_{n+1}+6\phi^{(2)}_{n}\right)=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{2}\,{3}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{6} }}}\thinspace}(3):~\scriptstyle 113\phi^{(0)}_{n+3}+81\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}-81\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}-113\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\Delta t\left(48\phi^{(1)}_{n+3}+162\phi^{(1)}_{n+2}+162\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+48\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)+\Delta t^{2}\left(6\phi^{(2)}_{n+3}-6\phi^{(2)}_{n}\right)=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{2}\,{3}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{6} }}}\thinspace}(4):~\scriptstyle 97\phi^{(0)}_{n+3}-81\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}-16\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\Delta t\left(44\phi^{(1)}_{n+3}+108\phi^{(1)}_{n+2}+54\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+4\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)+6\Delta t^{2}\phi^{(2)}_{n+3}=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{2}\,{3}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{6} }}}\thinspace}(5):~\scriptstyle-193\phi^{(0)}_{n+3}-1188\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}+945\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}+436\phi^{(0)}_{n}+\Delta t\left(864\phi^{(1)}_{n+2}+1026\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+120\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)+18\Delta t^{2}\phi^{(2)}_{n+3}=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{2}\,{3}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{6} }}}\thinspace}(6):~\scriptstyle-97\phi^{(0)}_{n+3}+540\phi^{(0)}_{n+2}+81\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}-524\phi^{(0)}_{n}-\Delta t\left(702\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+168\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)+18\Delta t^{2}\phi^{(2)}_{n+3}=0. A.3 Structural equations with K=3 The formulae handle approximations of kind \phi^{(0)}_{n+r} , \phi^{(1)}_{n+r} , \phi^{(2)}_{n+r} and \phi^{(3)}_{n+r} with r{\in\llbracket{1,R}\rrbracket} . \bullet Case R=1 , S=3 ( M=8 ) \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{3}\,{1}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{3} }}}\thinspace}(1):~\scriptstyle-120\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}-\phi^{(0)}_{n}\right)+60\Delta t\left(\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)-12\Delta t^{2}\left(\phi^{(2)}_{n+1}-\phi^{(2)}_{n}\right)+\Delta t^{3}\left(\phi^{(3)}_{n+1}+\phi^{(3)}_{n}\right)=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{3}\,{1}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{3} }}}\thinspace}(2):~\scriptstyle-60\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}-\phi^{(0)}_{n}\right)+\Delta t\left(36\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+24\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)-\Delta t^{2}\left(9\phi^{(2)}_{n+1}-3\phi^{(2)}_{n}\right)+\Delta t^{3}\phi^{(3)}_{n+1}=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{3}\,{1}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{3} }}}\thinspace}(3):~\scriptstyle 48\left(\phi^{(0)}_{n+1}-\phi^{(0)}_{n}\right)-\Delta t\left(18\phi^{(1)}_{n+1}+30\phi^{(1)}_{n}\right)-6\Delta t^{2}\phi^{(2)}_{n}+\Delta t^{3}\phi^{(3)}_{n+1}=0 \bullet Case R=2 , S=6 ( M=12 ) \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{3}\,{2}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{6} }}}\thinspace}(1):~\scriptstyle 315\left(\phi_{n}^{(0)}-\phi_{n+2}^{(0)}\right)+\Delta t\left(123\phi_{n}^{(1)}+384\phi_{n+1}^{(1)}+123\phi_{n+2}^{(1)}\right)+18\Delta t^{2}\left(\phi_{n}^{(2)}-\phi_{n+2}^{(2)}\right)+\Delta t^{3}\left(\phi_{n}^{(3)}+16\phi_{n+1}^{(3)}+\phi_{n+2}^{(3)}\right)=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{3}\,{2}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{6} }}}\thinspace}(2):~\scriptstyle-192\left(\phi_{n}^{(0)}-2\phi_{n+1}^{(0)}+\phi_{n+2}^{(0)}\right)-87\Delta t\left(\phi_{n}^{(1)}-\phi_{n+2}^{(1)}\right)+\Delta t^{2}\left(-15\phi_{n}^{(2)}+48\phi_{n+1}^{(2)}-15\phi_{n+2}^{(2)}\right)+\Delta t^{3}\left(-\phi_{n}^{(3)}+\phi_{n+2}^{(3)}\right)=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{3}\,{2}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{6} }}}\thinspace}(3):~\scriptstyle-87\phi_{n}^{(0)}+384\phi_{n+1}^{(0)}-297\phi_{n+2}^{(0)}+2\Delta t\left(-15\phi_{n}^{(1)}+48\phi_{n+1}^{(1)}+72\phi_{n+2}^{(1)}\right)+\Delta t^{2}\left(-3\phi_{n}^{(2)}+48\phi_{n+1}^{(2)}-27\phi_{n+2}^{(2)}\right)+2\Delta t^{3}\phi_{n+2}^{(3)}=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{3}\,{2}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{6} }}}\thinspace}(4):~\scriptstyle 561\phi_{n}^{(0)}-912\phi_{n+1}^{(0)}+351\phi_{n+2}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(213\phi_{n}^{(1)}+96\phi_{n+1}^{(1)}-99\phi_{n+2}^{(1)}\right)+2\Delta t^{2}\left(12\phi_{n}^{(2)}-84\phi_{n+1}^{(2)}\right)+2\Delta t^{3}\phi_{n+2}^{(3)}=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{3}\,{2}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{6} }}}\thinspace}(5):~\scriptstyle-129\phi_{n}^{(0)}+48\phi_{n+1}^{(0)}+81\phi_{n+2}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(-123\phi_{n}^{(1)}-240\phi_{n+1}^{(1)}-57\phi_{n+2}^{(1)}\right)-9\Delta t^{2}\phi_{n}^{(2)}+\Delta t^{3}\phi_{n+2}^{(3)}=0 \displaystyle{{\texttt{SE}\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{{\,{3}\,{2}}}}\raisebox{5.0pt}{{{\hskip-11.54994pt{6} }}}\thinspace}(6):\scriptstyle-51\phi_{n}^{(0)}-48\phi_{n+1}^{(0)}+99\phi_{n+2}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(-15\phi_{n}^{(1)}-96\phi_{n+1}^{(1)}-39\phi_{n+2}^{(1)}\right)+2\Delta t^{3}\phi_{n+2}^{(3)}=0 Appendix B Tables and figures Figure 5: The graph of the function \phi(t)=\frac{1}{1+\exp{(-\lambda t)}} for \lambda=1 in the interval [-50,0] . Table 59 : Benchmark ODE1 with IRK order 4 to compare with K1R2. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 30 6.31E -10 --- 6.31E -10 --- 6.31E -10 --- 6.31E -10 --- 60 3.94E -11 4.00 3.94E -11 4.00 3.94E -11 4.00 3.94E -11 4.00 120 2.46E -12 4.00 2.46E -12 4.00 2.46E -12 4.00 2.46E -12 4.00 Table 60 : Benchmark ODE1 with IRK order 4 to compare with K1R3. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 20 3.19E -09 --- 3.19E -09 --- 3.19E -09 --- 3.19E -09 --- 40 2.00E -10 4.00 2.00E -10 4.00 2.00E -10 4.00 2.00E -10 4.00 80 1.25E -11 4.00 1.25E -11 4.00 1.25E -11 4.00 1.25E -11 4.00 Table 61 : Benchmark ODE1 with IRK order 6 to compare with K1R4. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 15 3.20E -13 --- 3.20E -13 --- 3.20E -13 --- 3.20E -13 --- 30 5.01E -15 6.00 5.01E -15 6.00 5.01E -15 6.00 5.01E -15 6.00 60 7.82E -17 6.00 7.82E -17 6.00 7.82E -17 6.00 7.82E -17 6.00 Table 62 : Benchmark ODE1 with IRK order 6 to compare with K1R5. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 12 1.22E -12 --- 1.22E -12 --- 1.22E -12 --- 1.22E -12 --- 24 1.91E -14 6.00 1.91E -14 6.00 1.91E -14 6.00 1.91E -14 6.00 48 2.98E -16 6.00 2.98E -16 6.00 2.98E -16 6.00 2.98E -16 6.00 Table 63 : Benchmark ODE1 with IRK order 4 to compare with K2R1. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 60 3.94E -11 --- 3.94E -11 --- 3.94E -11 --- 3.94E -11 --- 120 2.46E -12 4.00 2.46E -12 4.00 2.46E -12 4.00 2.46E -12 4.00 240 1.54E -13 4.00 1.54E -13 4.00 1.54E -13 4.00 1.54E -13 4.00 Table 64 : Benchmark ODE1 with IRK order 6 to compare with K2R2. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 30 5.01E -15 --- 5.01E -15 --- 5.01E -15 --- 5.01E -15 --- 60 7.82E -17 6.00 7.82E -17 6.00 7.82E -17 6.00 7.82E -17 6.00 120 1.20E -18 6.02 1.20E -18 6.02 1.20E -18 6.02 1.20E -18 6.02 Table 65 : Benchmark ODE1 with IRK order 6 to compare with K3R1. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 60 7.82E -17 --- 7.82E -17 --- 7.82E -17 --- 7.82E -17 --- 120 1.20E -18 6.02 1.20E -18 6.02 1.20E -18 6.02 1.20E -18 6.02 240 8.80E -21 7.09 8.80E -21 7.09 8.80E -21 7.09 8.80E -21 7.09 Table 66 : Benchmark ODE2 with IRK order 4 to compare with K1R2. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 30 1.67E -05 --- 1.05E -04 --- 6.61E -04 --- 4.15E -03 --- 60 1.05E -06 4.00 6.59E -06 4.00 4.14E -05 4.00 2.60E -04 4.00 120 6.56E -08 4.00 4.12E -07 4.00 2.59E -06 4.00 1.63E -05 4.00 Table 67 : Benchmark ODE2 with IRK order 4 to compare with K1R3. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 20 8.45E -05 --- 5.31E -04 --- 3.34E -03 --- 2.10E -02 --- 40 5.31E -06 3.99 3.33E -05 3.99 2.09E -04 3.99 1.32E -03 3.99 80 3.32E -07 4.00 2.09E -06 4.00 1.31E -05 4.00 8.23E -05 4.00 Table 68 : Benchmark ODE2 with IRK order 6 to compare with K1R4. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 15 3.34E -07 --- 2.10E -06 --- 1.32E -05 --- 8.30E -05 --- 30 5.25E -09 5.99 3.30E -08 5.99 2.07E -07 5.99 1.30E -06 5.99 60 8.22E -11 6.00 5.16E -10 6.00 3.24E -09 6.00 2.04E -08 6.00 Table 69 : Benchmark ODE2 with IRK order 6 to compare with K1R5. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 12 1.27E -06 --- 7.98E -06 --- 5.02E -05 --- 3.15E -04 --- 24 2.00E -08 5.99 1.26E -07 5.99 7.90E -07 5.99 4.96E -06 5.99 48 3.13E -10 6.00 1.97E -09 6.00 1.24E -08 6.00 7.77E -08 6.00 Table 70 : Benchmark ODE2 with IRK order 4 to compare with K2R1. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 60 1.05E -06 --- 6.59E -06 --- 4.14E -05 --- 2.60E -04 --- 120 6.56E -08 4.00 4.12E -07 4.00 2.59E -06 4.00 1.63E -05 4.00 240 4.10E -09 4.00 2.58E -08 4.00 1.62E -07 4.00 1.02E -06 4.00 Table 71 : Benchmark ODE2 with IRK order 6 to compare with K2R2. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 30 5.25E -09 --- 3.30E -08 --- 2.07E -07 --- 1.30E -06 --- 60 8.22E -11 6.00 5.16E -10 6.00 3.24E -09 6.00 2.04E -08 6.00 120 1.28E -12 6.00 8.07E -12 6.00 5.07E -11 6.00 3.19E -10 6.00 Table 72 : Benchmark ODE2 with IRK order 6 to compare with K3R1. N \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 60 8.22E -11 --- 5.16E -10 --- 3.24E -09 --- 2.04E -08 --- 120 1.28E -12 6.00 8.07E -12 6.00 5.07E -11 6.00 3.19E -10 6.00 240 2.01E -14 6.00 1.26E -13 6.00 7.92E -13 6.00 4.98E -12 6.00 Table 73 : N^{*} \epsilon R K 1 2 3 4 1 E -3 1 4144 178 54 28 2 356 80 32 18 3 306 48 27 15 4 176 44 24 16 5 135 40 20 15 1 E -5 1 41436 562 117 49 2 1124 172 52 22 3 975 96 36 21 4 384 56 28 20 5 320 55 25 20 Table 74 : N^{*} with IRK \epsilon IRK4 IRK6 1 E -3 177 53 1 E -5 562 116 Table 75 : Error with IRK4 and with IRK6 for N^{*}/R \epsilon R K 1 2 3 1 E -3 1 -- 9.88E -04 -- 2 9.88E -04 5.57E -03 -- 3 9.04E -03 -- 1.15E +00 4 3.19E -03 -- -- 5 5.30E -02 -- -- 1 E -5 1 -- 1.00E -05 -- 2 1.00E -05 6.04E -05 -- 3 8.93E -05 -- 2.89E +00 4 3.13E -05 -- -- 5 3.50E -04 -- -- Table 76 : Benchmark ODE3a with IRK order 4 to compare with K1R3. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 20 58.00 6.94E -10 --- 1.02E -09 --- 1.21E -09 --- 8.46E -10 --- 40 49.73 4.34E -11 4.00 6.34E -11 4.00 7.56E -11 4.00 5.29E -11 4.00 80 43.51 2.71E -12 4.00 3.96E -12 4.00 4.73E -12 4.00 3.30E -12 4.00 160 38.84 1.69E -13 4.00 2.48E -13 4.00 2.95E -13 4.00 2.06E -13 4.00 320 35.06 1.06E -14 4.00 1.55E -14 4.00 1.85E -14 4.00 1.29E -14 4.00 Table 77 : Benchmark ODE3a with IRK order 4 to compare with K2R1. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 60 45.97 8.56E -12 --- 1.25E -11 --- 1.49E -11 --- 1.04E -11 --- 120 40.71 5.35E -13 4.00 7.83E -13 4.00 9.34E -13 4.00 6.52E -13 4.00 240 36.36 3.34E -14 4.00 4.89E -14 4.00 5.84E -14 4.00 4.08E -14 4.00 480 33.18 2.09E -15 4.00 3.06E -15 4.00 3.65E -15 4.00 2.55E -15 4.00 960 30.30 1.31E -16 4.00 1.91E -16 4.00 2.28E -16 4.00 1.59E -16 4.00 Table 78 : Benchmark ODE3a with IRK order 6 to compare with K1R5. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 12 61.58 1.33E -12 --- 1.95E -12 --- 2.32E -12 --- 1.62E -12 --- 24 52.29 2.08E -14 6.00 3.04E -14 6.00 3.63E -14 6.00 2.54E -14 6.00 48 45.60 3.25E -16 6.00 4.75E -16 6.00 5.67E -16 6.00 3.96E -16 6.00 96 40.35 5.09E -18 6.00 7.44E -18 6.00 8.88E -18 6.00 6.20E -18 6.00 192 36.27 8.49E -20 5.91 1.24E -19 5.91 1.48E -19 5.91 1.03E -19 5.91 Table 79 : Benchmark ODE3a with IRK order 6 to compare with K2R2. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 30 49.93 5.45E -15 --- 7.97E -15 --- 9.51E -15 --- 6.65E -15 --- 60 43.73 8.52E -17 6.00 1.25E -16 6.00 1.49E -16 6.00 1.04E -16 6.00 120 38.97 1.34E -18 5.99 1.96E -18 5.99 2.34E -18 5.99 1.63E -18 5.99 240 35.15 2.52E -20 5.73 3.69E -20 5.73 4.40E -20 5.73 3.08E -20 5.73 480 32.04 2.54E -21 3.31 3.72E -21 3.31 4.43E -21 3.31 3.10E -21 3.31 Table 80 : Benchmark ODE3a with IRK order 6 to compare with K3R1. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 60 43.73 8.52E -17 --- 1.25E -16 --- 1.49E -16 --- 1.04E -16 --- 120 38.97 1.34E -18 5.99 1.96E -18 5.99 2.34E -18 5.99 1.63E -18 5.99 240 35.15 2.52E -20 5.73 3.69E -20 5.73 4.40E -20 5.73 3.08E -20 5.73 480 32.04 2.54E -21 3.31 3.72E -21 3.31 4.43E -21 3.31 3.10E -21 3.31 960 29.49 1.11E -21 1.19 1.63E -21 1.19 1.94E -21 1.19 1.36E -21 1.19 Table 81 : Benchmark ODE3b with IRK order 4 to compare with K1R3. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 20 109.35 1.65E -04 --- 2.72E -08 --- 8.25E -05 --- 5.45E -08 --- 40 82.00 1.02E -05 4.01 1.04E -10 8.03 5.10E -06 4.01 2.08E -10 8.03 80 65.86 6.36E -07 4.00 4.05E -13 8.01 3.18E -07 4.00 8.10E -13 8.01 160 55.29 3.97E -08 4.00 1.58E -15 8.00 1.99E -08 4.00 3.16E -15 8.00 320 47.39 2.48E -09 4.00 6.17E -18 8.00 1.24E -09 4.00 1.23E -17 8.00 Table 82 : Benchmark ODE3b with IRK order 6 to compare with K1R5. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 12 122.67 5.53E -06 --- 3.06E -11 --- 2.76E -06 --- 6.11E -11 --- 24 89.42 8.49E -08 6.03 7.20E -15 12.05 4.24E -08 6.03 1.44E -14 12.05 48 70.48 1.32E -09 6.01 1.74E -18 12.01 6.60E -10 6.01 3.49E -18 12.01 96 58.41 2.06E -11 6.00 4.25E -22 12.00 1.03E -11 6.00 8.49E -22 12.00 192 49.96 3.22E -13 6.00 1.04E -25 12.00 1.61E -13 6.00 2.07E -25 12.00 Table 83 : Benchmark ODE3b with IRK order 4 to compare with K2R1. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 60 71.83 2.01E -06 --- 4.05E -12 --- 1.01E -06 --- 8.10E -12 --- 120 59.06 1.26E -07 4.00 1.58E -14 8.00 6.28E -08 4.00 3.16E -14 8.00 240 50.53 7.85E -09 4.00 6.16E -17 8.00 3.93E -09 4.00 1.23E -16 8.00 480 44.09 4.91E -10 4.00 2.41E -19 8.00 2.45E -10 4.00 4.81E -19 8.00 960 39.02 3.07E -11 4.00 9.40E -22 8.00 1.53E -11 4.00 1.88E -21 8.00 Table 84 : Benchmark ODE3b with IRK order 6 to compare with K2R2. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 30 82.27 2.22E -08 --- 4.93E -16 --- 1.11E -08 --- 9.86E -16 --- 60 66.02 3.46E -10 6.00 1.20E -19 12.01 1.73E -10 6.00 2.39E -19 12.01 120 55.43 5.40E -12 6.00 2.92E -23 12.00 2.70E -12 6.00 5.83E -23 12.00 240 47.74 8.44E -14 6.00 7.12E -27 12.00 4.22E -14 6.00 1.42E -26 12.00 480 41.88 1.32E -15 6.00 1.74E -30 12.00 6.59E -16 6.00 3.48E -30 12.00 Table 85 : Benchmark ODE3b with IRK order 6 to compare with K3R1. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 60 66.02 3.46E -10 --- 1.20E -19 --- 1.73E -10 --- 2.39E -19 --- 120 55.43 5.40E -12 6.00 2.92E -23 12.00 2.70E -12 6.00 5.83E -23 12.00 240 47.74 8.44E -14 6.00 7.12E -27 12.00 4.22E -14 6.00 1.42E -26 12.00 480 41.88 1.32E -15 6.00 1.74E -30 12.00 6.59E -16 6.00 3.48E -30 12.00 960 37.54 2.07E -17 5.99 4.30E -34 11.98 1.04E -17 5.99 8.61E -34 11.98 —————————————————————————————————————- Table 86 : Benchmark ODE3c with IRK order 4 to compare with K1R3. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 20 95.75 4.58E -03 --- 1.83E -01 --- 1.10E +01 --- 8.79E +02 --- 40 73.22 9.30E -05 5.62 3.72E -03 5.62 2.23E -01 5.62 1.78E +01 5.62 80 59.94 1.60E -06 5.86 6.40E -05 5.86 3.84E -03 5.86 3.07E -01 5.86 160 50.97 2.57E -08 5.96 1.03E -06 5.96 6.17E -05 5.96 4.94E -03 5.96 320 44.49 4.05E -10 5.99 1.62E -08 5.99 9.71E -07 5.99 7.77E -05 5.99 Table 87 : Benchmark ODE3c with IRK order 6 to compare with K1R5. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 12 105.75 2.82E -03 --- 1.13E -01 --- 6.77E +00 --- 5.42E +02 --- 24 79.17 2.79E -05 6.66 1.12E -03 6.66 6.70E -02 6.66 5.36E +00 6.66 48 63.79 1.71E -07 7.35 6.85E -06 7.35 4.11E -04 7.35 3.29E -02 7.35 96 53.76 7.88E -10 7.76 3.15E -08 7.76 1.89E -06 7.76 1.51E -04 7.76 192 46.56 3.23E -12 7.93 1.29E -10 7.93 7.75E -09 7.93 6.20E -07 7.93 Table 88 : Benchmark ODE3c with IRK order 4 to compare with K2R1. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 60 64.80 8.75E -06 --- 3.50E -04 --- 2.10E -02 --- 1.68E +00 --- 120 54.37 1.43E -07 5.93 5.73E -06 5.93 3.44E -04 5.93 2.75E -02 5.93 240 46.98 2.27E -09 5.98 9.08E -08 5.98 5.45E -06 5.98 4.36E -04 5.98 480 41.41 3.56E -11 6.00 1.42E -09 6.00 8.54E -08 6.00 6.83E -06 6.00 960 37.16 5.56E -13 6.00 2.23E -11 6.00 1.34E -09 6.00 1.07E -07 6.00 Table 89 : Benchmark ODE3c with IRK order 6 to compare with K2R2. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 30 73.43 5.66E -06 --- 2.26E -04 --- 1.36E -02 --- 1.09E +00 --- 60 60.18 3.09E -08 7.52 1.24E -06 7.52 7.42E -05 7.52 5.94E -03 7.52 120 51.20 1.35E -10 7.84 5.41E -09 7.84 3.25E -07 7.84 2.60E -05 7.84 240 44.65 5.45E -13 7.95 2.18E -11 7.95 1.31E -09 7.95 1.05E -07 7.95 480 39.69 2.18E -15 7.97 8.71E -14 7.97 5.23E -12 7.97 4.18E -10 7.97 Table 90 : Benchmark ODE3c with IRK order 6 to compare with K3R1. N \bar{\kappa} \phi \phi^{(1)} \phi^{(2)} \phi^{(3)} E O E O E O E O 60 60.18 3.09E -08 --- 1.24E -06 --- 7.42E -05 --- 5.94E -03 --- 120 51.20 1.35E -10 7.84 5.41E -09 7.84 3.25E -07 7.84 2.60E -05 7.84 240 44.65 5.45E -13 7.95 2.18E -11 7.95 1.31E -09 7.95 1.05E -07 7.95 480 39.69 2.18E -15 7.97 8.71E -14 7.97 5.23E -12 7.97 4.18E -10 7.97 960 35.76 2.41E -17 6.50 9.62E -16 6.50 5.77E -14 6.50 4.62E -12 6.50 Appendix C Scheme stability data For each scheme Skm[K,R] , we verified that the expressions for \chi_{R}(z) , in Tables 91 , 92 , 93 were obtained using the Symbolic Math Toolbox of MATLAB and are of the form p(z)/p(-z) . Table 91: Transfer functions of schemes Skm[1,R] scheme R \chi_{R}(z) Skm[1,1] 1 \frac{2+z}{2-z} Skm[1,2] 2 \frac{z^{2}+3z+3}{z^{2}-3z+3} Skm[1,3] 3 \frac{3z^{3}+11z^{2}+18z+12}{-3z^{3}+11z^{2}-18z+12} Skm[1,4] 4 \frac{12z^{4}+50z^{3}+105z^{2}+120z+60}{12z^{4}-50z^{3}+105z^{2}-120z+60} Table 92: Transfer functions of schemes Skm[2,R] scheme R \chi_{R}(z) Skm[2,1] 1 \frac{z^{2}+6z+12}{z^{2}-6z+12} Skm[2,2] 2 \frac{z^{4}+9z^{3}+39z^{2}+90z+90}{z^{4}-9z^{3}+39z^{2}-90z+90} Skm[2,3] 3 \frac{3z^{6}+33z^{5}+193z^{4}+720z^{3}+1740z^{2}+2520z+1680}{3z^{6}-33z^{5}+193z^{4}-720z^{3}+1740z^{2}-2520z+1680} Table 93: Transfer functions of schemes Skm[3,R] scheme R \chi_{R}(z) Skm[3,1] 1 \frac{z^{3}+12z^{2}+60z+120}{-z^{3}+12z^{2}-60z+120} Skm[3,2] 2 \frac{z^{6}+18z^{5}+165z^{4}+945z^{3}+3465z^{2}+7560z+7560}{z^{6}-18z^{5}+165z^{4}-945z^{3}+3465z^{2}-7560z+7560} Skm[3,3] 3 \frac{9z^{9}+198z^{8}+2355z^{7}+19075z^{6}+112770z^{5}+494760z^{4}+1587600z^{3}+3553200z^{2}+4989600z+3326400}{-9z^{9}+198z^{8}-2355z^{7}+19075z^{6}-112770z^{5}+494760z^{4}-1587600z^{3}+3553200z^{2}-4989600z+3326400} C.1 One physical equation: K=1 • Skm[1,1] : unconditional second order scheme with p(z)=z+2 and its only zero ( z=-2 ) is in the left half-plane. • Skm[1,2] : unconditional fourth order scheme with p(z)=z^{2}+3z+3 and H_{12}=\begin{bmatrix}3&0\\ 1&3\\ \end{bmatrix}. Its determinant is positive. • Skm[1,3] : unconditional fourth order scheme with p(z)=3z^{3}+11z^{2}+18z+12 and H_{13}=\begin{bmatrix}11&12&0\\ 3&18&0\\ 0&11&12\end{bmatrix}. All its principal minors m_{i} , for i=1,2,3 of \det H_{13} are strictly positive. • Skm[1,4] : unconditional sixth order scheme with p(z)=12z^{4}+50z^{3}+105z^{2}+120z+60 and H_{14}=\begin{bmatrix}50&120&0&0\\ 12&105&60&0\\ 0&50&120&0\\ 0&12&105&60\end{bmatrix}. All its principal minors m_{i} , for i=1,2,3,4 of H_{14} are strictly positive. C.2 Two physical equations: K=2 • Skm[2,1] : unconditional fourth order scheme with p(z)=z^{2}+6z+12 and H_{21}=\begin{bmatrix}6&0\\ 1&12\\ \end{bmatrix}. Its determinant is positive. • Skm[2,2] : unconditional sixth order scheme with p(z)=z^{4}+9z^{3}+39z^{2}+90z+90 and H_{22}=\begin{bmatrix}9&90&0&0\\ 1&39&90&0\\ 0&9&90&0\\ 0&1&39&90\end{bmatrix}. All principal minors m_{i} , for i=1,2,3,4 of \det H_{22} are strictly positive. • Skm[2,3] : unconditional eight order scheme with p(z)=3z^{6}+33z^{5}+193z^{4}+720z^{3}+1740z^{2}+2520z+1680 and H_{23}=\begin{bmatrix}33&720&2520&0&0&0\\ 3&193&1740&1680&0&0\\ 0&33&720&2520&0&0\\ 0&3&193&1740&1680&0\\ 0&0&33&720&2520&0\\ 0&0&3&193&1740&1680\\ \end{bmatrix}. All principal minors m_{i} , for i=1,2,3,4,5,6 of H_{23} are strictly positive. C.3 Three physical equations: K=3 • Skm[3,1] : unconditional sixth order scheme with p(z)=z^{3}+12z^{2}+60z+120 and H_{31}=\begin{bmatrix}12&120&0\\ 1&60&0\\ 0&12&120\end{bmatrix}. All principal minors m_{i} , for i=1,2,3 of \det H_{31} are strictly positive. • Skm[3,2] : unconditional tenth order scheme with p(z)=z^{6}+18z^{5}+165z^{4}+945z^{3}+3465z^{2}+7560z+7560 and H_{32}=\begin{bmatrix}18&945&7560&0&0&0\\ 1&165&3465&7560&0&0\\ 0&18&945&7560&0&0\\ 0&1&165&3465&7560&0\\ 0&0&18&945&7560&0\\ 0&0&1&165&3465&7560\\ \end{bmatrix}. All principal minors m_{i} , for i=1,2,3,4,5,6 of \det H_{32} are strictly positive. • Skm[3,3] : unconditional twelfth order scheme with p(z)=9z^{9}+198z^{8}+2355z^{7}+19075z^{6}+112770z^{5}+494760z^{4}+1587600z^{3}+3553200z^{2}+4989600z+3326400 and H_{33}=\begin{bmatrix}198&19075&494760&3553200&3326400&0&0&0&0\\ 9&2355&112770&15876000&4989600&0&0&0&0\\ 0&198&19075&494760&3553200&3326400&0&0&0\\ 0&9&2355&112770&15876000&4989600&0&0&0\\ 0&0&198&19075&494760&3553200&3326400&0&0\\ 0&0&9&2355&112770&15876000&4989600&0&0\\ 0&0&0&198&19075&494760&3553200&3326400&0\\ 0&0&0&9&2355&112770&15876000&4989600&0\\ 0&0&0&0&198&19075&494760&3553200&3326400\\ \end{bmatrix}. All principal minors m_{i} , for i=1,\cdots,9 of \det H_{33} are strictly positive. Hence, all schemes are A-stable. Appendix D Post processing structural equations D.1 One-order derivative case K=1 \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=2,I_{p}=1(O=2):~}\phi_{0}^{(2)}=6\phi_{-1}^{(0)}-6\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(2\phi_{-1}^{(1)}+4\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=2,I_{p}=2(O=4):~}\phi_{0}^{(2)}=\frac{7}{2}\phi_{-2}^{(0)}+8\phi_{-1}^{(0)}-\frac{23}{2}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+8\phi_{-1}^{(1)}+6\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=2,I_{p}=3(O=6):~}\phi_{0}^{(2)}=\frac{8}{3}\phi_{-3}^{(0)}+\frac{27}{2}\phi_{-2}^{(0)}-\frac{97}{6}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(\frac{2}{3}\phi_{-3}^{(1)}+9\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+18\phi_{-1}^{(1)}+\frac{22}{3}\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=3,I_{p}=2(O=3):~}\phi_{0}^{(3)}=\frac{51}{2}\phi_{-2}^{(0)}+24\phi_{-1}^{(0)}-\frac{99}{2}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(\frac{15}{2}\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+48\phi_{-1}^{(1)}+\frac{39}{2}\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=3,I_{p}=3(O=5):~}\phi_{0}^{(3)}=\frac{238}{9}\phi_{-3}^{(0)}+\frac{243}{2}\phi_{-2}^{(0)}-54\phi_{-1}^{(0)}-\frac{1691}{18}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(\frac{20}{3}\phi_{-3}^{(1)}+\frac{171}{2}\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+144\phi_{-1}^{(1)}+\frac{193}{6}\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=3,I_{p}=4(O=7):~}\phi_{0}^{(3)}=\frac{1241}{48}\phi_{-4}^{(0)}+\frac{2176}{9}\phi_{-3}^{(0)}+171\phi_{-2}^{(0)}-\frac{896}{3}\phi_{-1}^{(0)}-\frac{20155}{144}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(\frac{47}{8}\phi_{-4}^{(1)}+\frac{368}{3}\phi_{-3}^{(1)}+396\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+304\phi_{-1}^{(1)}+\frac{1045}{24}\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=4,I_{p}=2(O=2):~}\phi_{0}^{(4)}=78\phi_{-2}^{(0)}+24\phi_{-1}^{(0)}-102\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(24\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+120\phi_{-1}^{(1)}+36\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=4,I_{p}=3(O=4):~}\phi_{0}^{(4)}=\frac{400}{3}\phi_{-3}^{(0)}+540\phi_{-2}^{(0)}-360\phi_{-1}^{(0)}-\frac{940}{3}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(34\phi_{-3}^{(1)}+408\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+582\phi_{-1}^{(1)}+96\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=4,I_{p}=4(O=6):~}\phi_{0}^{(4)}=\frac{11879}{72}\phi_{-4}^{(0)}+\frac{13328}{9}\phi_{-3}^{(0)}+\frac{1659}{2}\phi_{-2}^{(0)}-\frac{16912}{9}\phi_{-1}^{(0)}-\frac{42931}{72}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(\frac{113}{3}\phi_{-4}^{(1)}+\frac{2296}{3}\phi_{-3}^{(1)}+2343\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+\frac{4712}{3}\phi_{-1}^{(1)}+\frac{995}{6}\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right) D.2 Two-order derivative case K=2 \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=3,I_{p}=2(O=6):~}\phi_{0}^{(3)}=87\phi_{-2}^{(0)}-384\phi_{-1}^{(0)}+297\phi_{0}^{(0)}+2\Delta t\left(15\phi_{-2}^{(1)}-48\phi_{-1}^{(1)}-72\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right)+\Delta t^{2}\left(3\phi_{-2}^{(2)}-48\phi_{-1}^{(2)}+27\phi_{0}^{(2)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=3,I_{p}=3(O=9):~}\phi_{0}^{(3)}=-\frac{344}{9}\phi_{-3}^{(0)}+\frac{891}{2}\phi_{-2}^{(0)}-648\phi_{-1}^{(0)}+\frac{4333}{18}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(-\frac{35}{3}\phi_{-3}^{(1)}+162\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+81\phi_{-1}^{(1)}-103\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right)+ \displaystyle\scriptstyle\hskip 65.55579pt\Delta t^{2}\left(-\phi_{-3}^{(2)}+\frac{81}{2}\phi_{-2}^{(2)}-81\phi_{-1}^{(2)}+\frac{33}{2}\phi_{0}^{(2)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=3,I_{p}=4(O=12):~}\phi_{0}^{(3)}=\frac{559}{16}\phi_{-4}^{(0)}-\frac{8768}{9}\phi_{-3}^{(0)}+2592\phi_{-2}^{(0)}-1984\phi_{-1}^{(0)}+\frac{47705}{144}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(\frac{39}{4}\phi_{-4}^{(1)}-\frac{1088}{3}\phi_{-3}^{(1)}+324\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+576\phi_{-1}^{(1)}-130\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right)+ \displaystyle\scriptstyle\hskip 65.55579pt\Delta t^{2}\left(\frac{3}{4}\phi_{-4}^{(2)}-64\phi_{-3}^{(2)}+324\phi_{-2}^{(2)}-192\phi_{-1}^{(2)}+\frac{75}{4}\phi_{0}^{(2)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=4,I_{p}=2(O=5):~}\phi_{0}^{(4)}=\frac{1359}{2}\phi_{-2}^{(0)}-2304\phi_{-1}^{(0)}+\frac{3249}{2}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(237\phi_{-2}^{(1)}-480\phi_{-1}^{(1)}-702\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right)+\Delta t^{2}\left(24\phi_{-2}^{(2)}-336\phi_{-1}^{(2)}+99\phi_{0}^{(2)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=4,I_{p}=3(O=8):~}\phi_{0}^{(4)}=-\frac{7060}{9}\phi_{-3}^{(0)}+\frac{17415}{2}\phi_{-2}^{(0)}-11340\phi_{-1}^{(0)}+\frac{61505}{18}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(-\frac{2162}{9}\phi_{-3}^{(1)}+3159\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+2106\phi_{-1}^{(1)}-\frac{11728}{9}\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right)+ \displaystyle\scriptstyle\hskip 65.55579pt\Delta t^{2}\left(-\frac{62}{3}\phi_{-3}^{(2)}+810\phi_{-2}^{(2)}-1458\phi_{-1}^{(2)}+157\phi_{0}^{(2)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=4,I_{p}=4(O=11):~}\phi_{0}^{(4)}=\frac{26751}{32}\phi_{-4}^{(0)}-\frac{205888}{9}\phi_{-3}^{(0)}+58968\phi_{-2}^{(0)}-42432\phi_{-1}^{(0)}+\frac{1585289}{288}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+ \displaystyle\scriptstyle\hskip 65.55579pt\Delta t\left(\frac{1869}{8}\phi_{-4}^{(1)}-76736\phi_{-3}^{(1)}+6804\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+13632\phi_{-1}^{(1)}-\frac{69295}{36}\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right)+\Delta t^{2}\left(18\phi_{-4}^{(2)}-\frac{4544}{3}\phi_{-3}^{(2)}+7452\phi_{-2}^{(2)}-4032\phi_{-1}^{(2)}+\frac{835}{4}\phi_{0}^{(2)}\right) D.3 Third-order derivative case K=3 \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=4,I_{p}=1(O=4):~}\phi_{0}^{(4)}=840\phi_{-1}^{(0)}-840\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(360\phi_{-1}^{(1)}+480\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right)+\Delta t^{2}\left(60\phi_{-1}^{(2)}-120\phi_{0}^{(2)}\right)+\Delta t^{3}\left(4\phi_{-1}^{(3)}+16\phi_{0}^{(3)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=4,I_{p}=2(O=8):~}\phi_{0}^{(4)}=1545\phi_{-2}^{(0)}+1920\phi_{-1}^{(0)}-\frac{5385}{2}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(285\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+1920\phi_{-1}^{(1)}+1260\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right)+ \displaystyle\scriptstyle\hskip 65.55579pt\Delta t^{2}\left(39\phi_{-2}^{(2)}+192\phi_{-1}^{(2)}-246\phi_{0}^{(2)}\right)+\Delta t^{3}\left(2\phi_{-2}^{(3)}+64\phi_{-1}^{(3)}+24\phi_{0}^{(3)}\right) \displaystyle\scriptstyle{\tt p=4,I_{p}=3(O=12):~}\phi_{0}^{(4)}=\frac{21160}{27}\phi_{-3}^{(0)}+\frac{27945}{2}\phi_{-2}^{(0)}-9720\phi_{-1}^{(0)}-\frac{271955}{54}\phi_{0}^{(0)}+\Delta t\left(\frac{772}{3}\phi_{-3}^{(1)}+7533\phi_{-2}^{(1)}+10692\phi_{-1}^{(1)}+\frac{18844}{9}\phi_{0}^{(1)}\right)+ \displaystyle\scriptstyle\hskip 65.55579pt\Delta t^{2}\left(\frac{92}{3}\phi_{-3}^{(2)}+1215\phi_{-2}^{(2)}-972\phi_{-1}^{(2)}-\frac{1066}{3}\phi_{0}^{(2)}\right)+\Delta t^{3}\left(\frac{4}{3}\phi_{-3}^{(3)}+162\phi_{-2}^{(3)}+324\phi_{-1}^{(3)}+\frac{88}{3}\phi_{0}^{(3)}\right)