Ice clouds as nonlinear oscillators Hannah Bergner, Peter Spichtinger Abstract Abstract : Clouds are important features of the atmosphere, determining the energy budget by interacting with incoming solar radiation and outgoing thermal radiation, respectively. For pure ice clouds, the net effect of radiative effect is still unknown. In this study we develop a simple but physically consistent ice cloud model, and analyze it using methods from the theory of dynamical systems. We find that the model constitutes a nonlinear oscillator with two Hopf bifurcations in the relevant parameter regime. In addition to the characterization of the equilibrium states and the occurring limit cycle, we find scaling behaviors of the bifurcations and the limit cycle, reducing the parameter space crucially. Finally, the model shows very good agreement with real measurements, indicating that the main physics is captured and such simple models are helpful tools for investigating ice clouds. 1 Introduction Clouds are frequently found to be distributed over the whole globe. A portion of about 60-70\% of the Earth is permanently covered by clouds ( Stubenrauch et al. 2017 ) , which are also distributed over several vertical levels in the troposphere (i.e. up to 12-15 km altitude). Clouds are composed of myriads of water particles of different phases. For low vertical levels in the atmosphere, i.e. at temperatures above the triple point ( T_{t}=$273.15\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$ ) clouds contain only liquid water droplets. For the temperature range between the triple point and about T\sim$235\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$ liquid water can still exist, however the solid phase, i.e. classical hexagonal ice, is the stable phase. At temperatures around T\sim$235\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$ liquid water freezes spontaneously and below this temperatures, pure liquid water cannot exist anymore ( Gallo et al. 2016 ) , thus clouds at these temperatures (i.e. at high altitudes close to the tropopause) are completely composed by ice crystals. Clouds play a major role for the Earth-Atmosphere system. They determine the hydrological cycle by producing precipitation, but also drive atmospheric flows by the huge amount of energy, which is released at phase transitions ( Gallo et al. 2019 ) . Vigorous systems like thunderstorms are only possible because of this anomaly of water. Finally, clouds also regulate the energy budget of the system itself, controlling the impact of radiation. Clouds interact with incoming solar radiation by scattering and partly reflecting solar radiation; in the presence of clouds less solar energy is transported into the system as compared to the clear sky case, leading to a cooling effect (albedo effect). On the other hand, they partly absorb and re-emit thermal radiation as radiated by the Earth’s surface (as an almost perfect black body), thus keeping more energy in the system as compared to the clear sky case (greenhouse effect). The difference of these two effects leads to the net climate effect of clouds. For low level liquid clouds, the albedo effect is dominant, hence leading to a net cooling of these clouds. For clouds at higher altitudes, i.e. clouds containing ice particles, the net effect is still uncertain; for pure ice clouds we do not even know the sign of the net effect. This results also from the fact that for ice clouds both effects (cooling vs. warming) are of comparable values but with different signs. Thus, small variations in microphysical properties as e.g. size of particles lead to significant changes in the net effect, as demonstrated by Zhang et al. 1999 . For high level ice clouds, often a net warming is assumed (e.g. Chen et al. 2000 ) , but recent estimations indicate different or even inconclusive outcomes (see Figure 5 in Kr\"amer et al. 2020 ) . Since for clouds, thermodynamics decides about the mass concentration in first order, the number concentration of ice particles can be directly translated into the size of particles and thus into the radiation calculations; this is crucial, since smaller particles scatter more efficiently than larger ones (e.g. Fu & Liou 1993 ) . The number concentration of ice particles is determined by the generation mechanisms, i.e. the nucleation pathway. In recent studies ( Kr\"amer et al. 2016 ; Wernli et al. 2016 ) , a distinction between generally different formation pathways was formulated, termed as liquid origin cirrus and in situ cirrus, respectively. The former pathway is characterized by pre-existing liquid cloud droplets at states close to thermodynamic equilibrium (saturation over water), which freeze to ice particles, either triggered by solid aerosols or spontaneously. This pathway is only valid in the temperature range T>$235\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$ , where liquid water can still exist. The latter pathway takes place at low temperature; water vapor is either directly deposited as ice on solid aerosol particles (so-called heterogeneous nucleation), or supercooled aqueous solution droplets freeze spontaneously. The nucleation mechanisms might have a big impact on the resulting number concentration from such a freezing/nucleation event. The resulting number concentration might be limited either by the amount of available ice nucleating particles (particle limited regime) or even by the available water vapor for producing cloud or solution droplets (supersaturation limited regime). The latter one is crucially depending on local dynamics, which leads to a source of supersaturation by adiabatic cooling in upward motions. Beside the details of nucleation processes, which are barely understood on a molecular level, many other processes in clouds are quite uncertain. Very often, we find that the processes might be understood to some extend on a particle level, but the scaling up to the ensemble is not clear. This points to the fact that in contrast to fluid dynamics where a general and well accepted theory is available (i.e. Navier-Stokes equations or approximations of it), this is not the case for clouds. Actually, there is no generally accepted theory of clouds in terms of a closed system of partial differential equations or something similar. Processes are mostly known on particle basis and reaction rates are formulated often in an ad hoc manner in order to take into account the needs for the respective applications. There are only few attempts to formulate a general theory of clouds for some parts of the phase space of clouds, mostly in the field of liquid clouds. For ice clouds, we are aware of some attempts of deriving a Boltzmann-type evolution equation ( Khvorostyanov 1995 ) . However, none of them resulted into an overall and generally accepted cloud formulation. For a review of such formulations see Khain et al. 2015 . In this study we focus on pure ice clouds in a low temperature regime ( T<$240\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$ ), where in situ formation takes place at levels in the upper troposphere. For the formation of ice particles at this regime, environmental conditions far away from thermodynamic equilibrium (i.e saturation with respect to ice) are required; even after the formation process, ice clouds remain in a state out of equilibrium, because relaxation towards equilibrium can be quite slow. Thus, ice clouds form a non-equilibrium multiphase system. Ice clouds are also multiscale phenomena, showing structure formation and emergence of pattern, thus not only relevant in terms of microscale processes but also in the propagation of information through all scales. For investigation of such phenomena simple but consistent models are necessary, which contain the main features of the physics, but are simple enough for coupling to fluid dynamics equations. For instance, if we want to investigate issues such as predictability, we have to make sure that the cloud model as coupled to the equations of motion in terms of reaction rates is well-posed. Otherwise, investigations about representing clouds on different scales in numerical models with changing grid resolutions remain a bit arbitrary. In this study we derive a simple ice cloud model on the basis of a consistent formulation of cloud processes. Here, we include the most important processes, as ice nucleation, growth and evaporation by water vapor diffusion and sedimentation of ice crystals, respectively. After some simplifications, we end up with a three-dimensional (3D) system of nonlinear autonomous ordinary differential equations, which then can be analyzed by the theory of dynamical systems. There were several former studies, investigating cloud models as dynamical systems, e.g. for liquid and mixed-phase clouds ( Hauf 1993 ; Wacker 1992 ; Wacker 1995 ; Wacker 2006 ) , but also for aerosol-cloud-systems ( Koren & Feingold 2011 ; Feingold & Koren 2013 ) . Our investigation is based on the former study by Spreitzer et al. 2017 , which evaluated a small part of the phase space of ice clouds, i.e. so-called subvisible cirrus clouds at low vertical updrafts; they used a slightly different model, which could not be analyzed in details. Our approach extends this former study and aims to derive a much more detailed analysis; since our current model is "much simpler", however still realistic, we can determine several properties in an analytical or semi-analytical way, including also the regime treated by Spreitzer et al. 2017 . We determine equilibrium states and their quality using linearization approaches. In addition, we determine bifurcations and thus periods of limit cycles with numerical evaluations. Finally, the model is compared to real measurements in order to determine its feasibility for the use in extended models. The study is structured as follows. In Section 2, we present the physical variables and processes for modeling ice clouds in the low temperature regime. In Section 3, the model is presented as a 3D nonlinear system of ordinary differential equations. This system is characterized in terms of dynamical systems theory in Section 4, i.e. determining equilibrium states and their quality, and possible limit cycles. In addition, scaling properties of the system are investigated. In Section 5, we compare the model results with real measurements. Finally, we summarize the work, draw some conclusions and present an outlook for future work. 2 Physical variables and processes In this section we will define the general settings for the model. We give a general description of clouds as an ensemble of many particles, embedded into atmospheric flows. Nevertheless, later we will simplify the whole system to a 3D dynamical system, describing Lagrangian air parcels transported by prescribed air motion. 2.1 Thermodynamic environment For modeling ice clouds, we have to set up the thermodynamic environment. We consider air and water vapor in a control volume V (box or parcel) as ideal gases as described by the ideal gas law: p_{k}V=M_{k}R_{k}T\Leftrightarrow p_{k}=\rho_{k}R_{k}T,\penalty\ \penalty\ \text{with}\penalty\ \rho_{k}=\frac{M_{k}}{V} (1) using the partial pressure p_{k} , the specific gas constant R_{k}=\frac{R^{*}}{M_{\text{mol},k}} as derived from the universal gas constant R^{*}=$8.314\,462\text{\,}\mathrm{J}\text{\,}\mathrm{mol}$ , and the temperature T , respectively. The partial masses of the gases are denoted by M_{k} . The index a indicates dry air, the index v denotes water vapor, respectively. The total pressure in the volume is determined by Dalton’s law, i.e. p=p_{a}+p_{v} ; however, a good approximation is given by p\approx p_{a} (since p_{a}\gg p_{v} ). The parcel can be seen as one vertical layer at a certain height within a full atmospheric column. The pressure is determined by the hydrostatic balance, i.e. the air mass in the vertical column \partialderivative{p}{z}=-g\rho. (2) We consider the low temperature regime in the upper troposphere, i.e. temperatures in the range $190\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$\leq T\leq$240\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$ . The corresponding air pressure values are considered to be within the range $200\text{\,}\mathrm{hPa}$\leq p\leq$300\text{\,}\mathrm{hPa}$ . In addition to water vapor, we also consider the mass of the condensed water phase, i.e. the total mass of ice particles M_{i} . At these low temperatures, liquid water does not exist in the atmosphere (e.g. Gallo et al. 2016 ) , thus we can restrict the system to gaseous and solid phases of water. For the further investigations, we use the mass concentration of water vapor q_{v}=\frac{M_{v}}{M_{a}} and the mass concentration of ice q_{i}=\frac{M_{i}}{M_{a}} , respectively. In fact, the total mass M=M_{a}+M_{v}+M_{i} can be approximated by the mass of air, since the relative contribution of water substances is less than 10^{-3} , thus M\approx M_{a} . 2.2 Phase changes and saturation ratio We are only interested in the formation of ice crystals within the respective low temperature region, i.e. the formation of ice “directly” from water vapor without any transition through the liquid phase. Recently, formation pathways of this type were grouped together and named as “ in situ formation” (e.g., Kr\"amer et al. 2016 ; Wernli et al. 2016 ) . From these different pathways we only consider the pathway of homogeneous freezing of aqueous solution droplets (short “homogeneous nucleation”, see, e.g., Koop et al. 2000 ; Spichtinger et al. 2023 ) . At these atmospheric conditions, hexagonal ice ( I_{h} ) is the stable solid phase of water ( Gallo et al. 2016 ) . For assuming water vapor as an ideal gas, the thermodynamic equilibrium of these water phases is approximately determined by the Clausius-Clapeyron equation (e.g. Kondepudi & Prigogine 2014 ) \derivative{p_\text{si}}{T}=\frac{L\,p_{\text{si}}}{R_{v}T^{2}} (3) using the specific latent heat of sublimation L , which is slightly dependent on temperature (see, e.g., Murphy & Koop 2005 ) ; p_{\text{si}} denotes the saturation vapor pressure over hexagonal ice (see also appendix A.3 ). The thermodynamical control variable for determining ice cloud processes is the saturation ratio over ice S_{i}:=\frac{p_{v}}{p_{\text{si}}(T)}=\frac{p\,q_{v}}{\varepsilon p_{\text{si}}(T)} (4) using the water vapor mixing ratio q_{v} , and the ratio of molar masses of water and air \varepsilon=\frac{M_{\text{mol},v}}{M_{\text{mol},a}}\approx 0.622 . We will often consider changes in the saturation ratio, which are governed by changes in temperature, pressure and specific humidity, respectively. For this purpose, we investigate the total derivative of the saturation ratio, as given by: \derivative{S_i}{t}=\partialderivative{S_i}{T}\derivative{T}{t}+\partialderivative{S_i}{p}\derivative{p}{t}+\partialderivative{S_i}{q_v}\derivative{q_v}{t} (5) using the partial derivatives \partialderivative{S_i}{T}=-S_{i}\frac{L}{R_{v}T^{2}},\penalty\ \penalty\ \partialderivative{S_i}{p}=\frac{S_{i}}{p},\penalty\ \penalty\ \partialderivative{S_i}{q_v}=\frac{S_{i}}{q_{v}}=\frac{p}{\varepsilon p_{\text{si}}} (6) where we have used the Clausius-Clapeyron equation ( 3 ). We can split the changes in temperature into adiabatic and diabatic components, i.e. temperature changes driven by adiabatic expansion due to vertical upward motions and temperature changes induced by latent heat release during phase changes. These temperature rates can be represented as follows: \displaystyle\evaluated{\dv{T}{t}}_{\text}{adiabatic} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\derivative{T}{z}\derivative{z}{t}=-\frac{g}{c_{p}}w (7) \displaystyle\evaluated{\dv{T}{t}}_{\text}{diabatic} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-\frac{L}{c_{p}}\derivative{q_v}{t}. (8) Note, that we omit other diabatic processes, as e.g. friction or radiation processes. For our investigation, this restriction is still meaningful. Using these expressions, we can determine the change in S_{i} due to temperature changes: \displaystyle\partialderivative{S_i}{T}\derivative{T}{t} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-S_{i}\frac{L}{R_{v}T^{2}}\left(\evaluated{\dv{T}{t}}_{\text}{adiabatic}+\evaluated{\dv{T}{t}}_{\text}{diabatic}\right) (9) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{L\,g}{c_{p}R_{v}T^{2}}S_{i}w+\frac{L^{2}}{c_{p}R_{v}T^{2}}S_{i}\derivative{q_v}{t} (10) The adiabatic pressure change, assuming hydrostatic balance, \derivative{p}{t}=\derivative{p}{z}\derivative{z}{t}=-g\rho w (11) also influences the saturation ratio, thus \partialderivative{S_i}{p}\derivative{p}{t}=-\frac{S_{i}}{p}g\rho w=-S_{i}\frac{g}{R_{a}T}w (12) and changes in the water vapor concentration q_{v} finally give the rate \partialderivative{S_i}{q_v}\derivative{q_v}{t}=\frac{p}{\varepsilon p_{\text{si}}}\derivative{q_v}{t} (13) Putting all rates together and sorting leads to the final rate for the saturation over ice: \derivative{S_i}{t}=\left[\frac{L}{c_{p}R_{v}T^{2}}-\frac{1}{R_{a}T}\right]gwS_{i}+\left[\frac{L^{2}}{c_{p}R_{v}T^{2}}S_{i}+\frac{p}{\varepsilon p_{\text{si}}}\right]\dot{q}_{v}. (14) In our investigations we are often interested in asymptotic states of the ice cloud model, i.e. the long term evolution. For these investigations, long time evolution (and integration) is necessary. In order to approach these states analytically, we make the following simplification. In Equation ( 14 ) the changes of temperature and pressure are represented by the vertical upward motion w . For the further investigation, we assume that temperature/pressure rates just appear in the evolution equation of S_{i} , but we skip evolution equations for p,T , i.e. we assume that both quantities remain constant. As a consequence to be consistent, we also skip the term in Equation ( 14 ) reflecting the latent heat release due to phase changes, i.e. we use the approximation: \displaystyle\derivative{S_i}{t} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left[\frac{L}{c_{p}R_{v}T^{2}}-\frac{1}{R_{a}T}\right]gwS_{i}+\left[\frac{L^{2}}{c_{p}R_{v}T^{2}}S_{i}+\frac{p}{\varepsilon p_{\text{si}}}\right]\dot{q}_{v} (15) \displaystyle\approx \displaystyle\underbrace{\left[\frac{L}{c_{p}R_{v}T^{2}}-\frac{1}{R_{a}T}\right]gwS_{i}}_{\text{Cool}}+\underbrace{\left[\frac{p}{\varepsilon p_{\text{si}}}\right]\dot{q}_{v}}_{\text{Dep}_{s}} (16) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\underbrace{A_{s}S_{i}}_{\text{Cool}}+\underbrace{B_{s}\dot{q}_{v}}_{\text{Dep}_{s}} (17) introducing two terms Cool and \text{Dep}_{s} , respectively, governing the time evolution of the saturation ratio. These terms will also appear in the complete model. We will later use the notation, setting s\coloneqq S_{i} . Note here that the first term constitutes a source for supersaturation, if the vertical velocity w>0 , i.e. if there is an upward motion. The coefficient A_{s} depends on temperature T , and linearly on vertical velocity w , whereas the coefficient B_{s} depends on temperature and pressure, respectively. This kind of simplification neglecting changes of temperature and pressure was already used in former investigations of subvisible ice clouds ( Spreitzer et al. 2017 ) . 2.3 General assumptions for ice crystals Ice crystals usually have quite irregular shapes with inherent hexagonal structures due to the stable solid phase (hexagonal ice I_{h} ). The exact and detailed shape and its evolution in time depend crucially on the environmental conditions (e.g. Libbrecht 2005 ) . Since there is a huge variety of shapes for ice crystals (see, e.g., Bailey & Hallett 2009 ; Grulich et al. 2021 ) and we cannot represent this variability within a simple model, we have to choose an approximation. There are two different reasons for choosing a spherical shape for ice crystals in our model. First, we are interested in the low temperature regime; thus, the available amount of water vapor is limited, so ice crystals stay quite small and are almost spherical; from measurements we know that the maximum diameter should not exceed values of 200-$300\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro m}$ ( Kr\"amer et al. 2020 ) . The complex shapes of ice crystal usually appear for the warm temperature regime (i.e. T>$240\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$ ) together with much larger sizes. Second, from theoretical and computational investigations (e.g. Baumgartner & Spichtinger 2017 ) we know that in a certain distance to a non-spherical crystal, the resulting water vapor field is almost the same as for a larger spherical ice crystal. Thus, we use a spherical shape for ice crystals, with the common relationship between mass and radius m=\frac{4}{3}\pi\rho_{b}r^{3}\penalty\ \Leftrightarrow\penalty\ r=\sqrt[3]{\frac{3}{4\pi\rho_{b}}}m^{\frac{1}{3}}=c\,m^{\frac{1}{3}},\penalty\ \text{with}\penalty\ \rho_{b}=$810\text{\,}\mathrm{kg}$\text{\penalty\ bulk density of ice}. (18) The radius will appear later in the growth equation, when we specify a spherical shape. 2.4 Relevant processes for ice cloud modeling 1. Particle formation - ice nucleation For ice formation at low temperatures, two nucleation processes might be relevant, i.e. (1) homogeneous freezing of aqueous solution droplets (see, e.g., Koop et al. 2000 ) , and (2) heterogeneous nucleation at solid aerosol particles. In the first case, we assume that supercooled solution droplets (e.g. containing a small amount of sulfuric acid or other inorganic substances) freeze spontaneously (i.e. stochastically) to small ice crystals. The probability of a solution droplet of volume V freezing within a time interval \Delta t can be calculated as P=1-\exp(-JV\Delta t) (19) with the nucleation rate J . For such solution droplets this rate can be formulated in terms of water activity ( Koop et al. 2000 ) , which translates into the form J(T,S_{i})=J_{0}\exp(A(T)(s-S_c(T))) (20) with a steepness A(T) and a threshold S_{c}(T) , respectively. These two functions can be approximated by a recent formulation ( Spichtinger et al. 2023 ) to A(T)\approx p_{1}(T)=a_{w0}+a_{w1}T,\penalty\ \penalty\ S_{c}(T)\approx p_{2}(T)=a_{s0}+a_{s1}T+a_{s2}T^{2} (21) using polynomials p_{n}(x) of degree n\in\mathbb{N} . There is still a debate about the relevance or dominance of these different nucleation pathways. However, for our purposes we can restrict the formulation to homogeneous freezing of solution droplets, since in the cold temperature regime of in situ formed ice clouds (cf. Kr\"amer et al. 2016 ) , homogeneous nucleation produces most of the ice particles. Thus, we include a supersaturation limited pathway of ice nucleation. 2. Particle growth/evaporation by diffusion of water vapor Small water particles (liquid or solid) grow by diffusion of surrounding water vapor. The boundary condition at the surface of the particle (i.e. saturation with respect to the phase of the particle) determines the direction of the water vapor flux, leading either to evaporation or growth of the particle. The mathematical details of the problem and a proof of uniqueness of the solution can be found in Baumgartner & Spichtinger 2018 . The growth equation of a single water particle with mass m can be written as \derivative{m}{t}=4\pi CD_{v}f_{k}G_{v}(s-1)f_{v}. (22) The shape of the particle influences the diffusional growth; using the electrostatic analog (see, e.g., Spichtinger & Gierens 2009 ; Lamb & Verlinde 2011 ; Baumgartner & Spichtinger 2018 ) , a capacity coefficient C representing the shape of a single particle can be introduced to the growth equation. D_{v} denotes the diffusion coefficient of water vapor in air, D_{v}=D_{v0}\quantity(\frac{T}{T_0})^{2}\quantity(\frac{p_0}{p}),\penalty\ D_{v0}=$2.1422\text{\cdot}{10}^{-5}\text{\,}\mathrm{m}$,\penalty\ T_{0}=$273.15\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$,\penalty\ p_{0}=$101\,325\text{\,}\mathrm{Pa}$ (23) with a correction f_{k} of the flux in the kinetic regime; this correction would reduce the uptake of water vapor, since f_{k}\leq 1 . The fit of D_{v} is based on the description by Hall & Pruppacher 1976 . The effect of latent heat release is captured by the Howell factor G_{v}=\left[\left(\frac{L}{R_{v}T}-1\right)\frac{L}{T}\frac{D_{v}}{K_{T}}+\frac{R_{v}T}{p_{si}}\right]^{-1}, (24) with the latent heat of sublimation L , the ideal gas constant of water vapor R_{v} , and the heat conduction of air K_{T} (cf. Dixon 2007 ) , respectively. Note, that in this formulation we already omit possible corrections for small particles for D_{v},K_{T} , respectively (see, e.g., Lamb & Verlinde 2011 ) . For large particles, a correction f_{v} for the ventilation effect (wakes behind falling particles enhance water vapor diffusion) is applied; this correction would enhance the uptake of water vapor, since f_{v}\geq 1 . 3. Sedimentation - a particle falls out due to gravity Water particles in general, and also ice crystals are accelerated by gravity; since the friction of air leads to a drag and thus a balance of forces, ice crystals very quickly reach a so-called terminal velocity without any further acceleration. For low Reynolds numbers using the Stokes law (see Lamb & Verlinde 2011 , pp. 381) and assuming a spherical shape, the terminal velocity is proportional to the squared radius. For irregularly shaped particles as ice crystals, the terminal velocity can be approximated by power laws v_{t}(m)=\alpha_{k}m^{\beta_{k}} with piecewise constant coefficients \alpha_{k},\beta_{k} (see Spichtinger & Gierens 2009 ) . We have to apply a correction factor (see, e.g., Spichtinger & Gierens 2009 ; Pruppacher & Klett 2010 ) , taking into account the friction of the air at different densities, expressed as a function of temperature and pressure: c(p,T)=\left(\frac{p}{p_{c}}\right)^{a_{c}}\left(\frac{T}{T_{c}}\right)^{b_{c}},\penalty\ \penalty\ p_{c}=$30\,000\text{\,}\mathrm{Pa}$,\penalty\ \penalty\ T_{c}=$233\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$,\penalty\ \penalty\ a_{c}=-0.178,\penalty\ \penalty\ b_{c}=-0.394 (25) 4. Collision of particles Collision of particles is usually the major process for growing particles to large sizes. For liquid particles, collision is very efficient, but for ice particles in the cold temperature regime aggregation is not a relevant process ( Kajikawa & Heymsfield 1989 ; Kienast-Sj\"ogren et al. 2013 ) . 2.5 General assumptions for cloud ensembles Clouds are usually composed by myriads of water particles, thus we have to consider a cloud as a statistical ensemble. As described in details by Spreitzer et al. 2017 , a generic way for describing the cloud ensemble would be to use a probability distribution f(m,x,t) for the masses of cloud particles and investigate the evolution of the distribution in time and space. This would lead to a Boltzmann type evolution equation for the distribution, i.e. \partialderivative{(\rho f)}{t}+\nabla_{x}\dotproduct\quantity(\rho f u)+\partialderivative{(\rho f g)}{m}=\rho h (26) with transport with velocity u , growth with a rate function g , and other sources and sinks, described by h . From this equation we can derive (infinitely many) equations for the general moments \mu_{k}[m]\coloneqq\int_{0}^{\infty}m^{k}f(m,x,t)\,\differential m,\penalty\ \penalty\ k\in\mathbb{N}_{0}, (27) of the distribution if the integral converges. The general formulation of moment equations as derived from the Boltzmann approach is presented in Appendix A . Since we can neither solve infinitely many equations, nor do we have a general and consistent description of the sources and sink term h on the right hand side, we make the following assumptions for simplification: • We only use two equations, i.e. for the moments k=0,1 and use a closure condition. Usually, the distribution is normalized by the cloud particle number concentration n , thus we obtain equations for the number concentration \mu_{0}=n and the mass concentration \mu_{1}=q . For ice crystals in the low temperature regime ( T<$240\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$ ) we assume a fixed type of distribution, i.e. a lognormal distribution f(m)=\frac{n}{\sqrt{2\pi}\log(\sigma_m)m}\exp(-\frac{1}{2}\qty(\frac{\log(\frac{m}{m_m})}{\log(\sigma_m)})^2) (28) with the modal mass m_{m} and the geometric standard deviation \sigma_{m} . Thus, the general moments can be calculated analytically as \mu_{k}[m]=nm_{m}^{k}\exp(\frac{1}{2}\qty(k\log\sigma_m)^2). (29) The closure is determined by a fixed ratio of moments r_{0} , i.e. r_{0}=\frac{\mu_{2}\mu_{0}}{\mu_{1}^{2}}=\exp(\qty(\log(\sigma_m))^2) (30) which can be used for calculating the moments \mu_{k}[m]=nm_{m}^{k}r_{0}^{\frac{k^{2}}{2}}=n\bar{m}^{k}r_{0}^{\frac{k(k-1)}{2}} (31) with the mean mass \bar{m}\coloneqq\frac{q}{n} . We set r_{0}= const. and thus the geometric standard deviation \sigma_{m} is constant. Motivated by former investigations ( Spichtinger & Gierens 2009 ) we set r_{0}=3 . • For the right hand side, i.e. the formation and annihilation processes of ice particles, we will use meaningful parameterizations, which are partly derived from the moment approach (see also Appendix A ). Thus, we will formulate our model using the mean variables number concentration of ice particles n=\mu_{0} and mass concentration of ice particles q=\mu_{1} , respectively. 2.6 Basic structure of the model system We now determine the general structure of the resulting model system, which then turns into a system of ordinary differential equations (ODEs). The process of nucleation affects number and mass concentrations as a source of the system, thus we formally introduce the terms \text{Nuc}_{n},\text{Nuc}_{q} for the two variables respectively. Growth and evaporation act in different ways on the variables n and q . For a supersaturated regime ( s>1 ) the ice particles can grow by diffusion, thus we need a deposition term \text{Dep}_{q} ; the number concentration is not affected by growth. For evaporation, both mass and number concentrations are depleted; however, the effect is treated differently. From the general derivation of the growth term for ensembles (see Appendix A.4 ), we see that evaporation of mass is symmetric to growth, thus the term \text{Dep}_{q} already treats the loss of mass correctly. For the effect of evaporation on the number concentration, we introduce the term \text{Evap}_{n} . In fact, it is quite tricky to introduce a meaningful ansatz for this term, since the type of the underlying distribution is changing by evaporation. However, in the following investigations, we will concentrate on the supersaturated regime, thus we do not need to investigate the evaporation term in details for this study. Finally, we have to consider sedimentation of particles and introduce the sedimentation terms \text{Sed}_{n} and \text{Sed}_{q} for the change rates in number and mass concentration due to sedimentation. We will use an approximation in order to avoid a vertical transport equation (i.e. a system of partial differential equations). This approximation will be introduced later based on a vertical discretization. The basic structure of the ice cloud model is then as follows \displaystyle\derivative{n}{t} \displaystyle\ =\ \text{Nuc}_{n}\ +\ \text{Evap}_{n}\ +\ \text{Sed}_{n} (32) \displaystyle\derivative{q}{t} \displaystyle\ =\ \text{Nuc}_{q}\ +\ \text{Dep}_{q}\ \penalty\ \penalty\ +\ \text{Sed}_{q} (33) \displaystyle\derivative{s}{t} \displaystyle\ =\ \text{Cool}\ +\ \text{Dep}_{s}, (34) with total derivatives \derivative{\psi}{t} . We will see in the following section that the system (after some further simplifications) becomes an autonomous nonlinear ODE system. 3 Simple model In this section, we finally derive the model, which will be used for analytical and numerical considerations. 3.1 Simplifications For nucleation of particles, we prescribe a size distribution of solution droplets. Instead of tracking aerosol properties with water uptake controlled by Köhler theory ( K\"ohler 1936 ) , we use a lognormal distribution with fixed modal radius and geometric standard deviation, normalized by the number concentration of aerosols. Details are given in Appendix A.2 . This leads to a nucleation term \text{Nuc}_{n} for the ice crystal number concentration as given below. In addition, we assume a constant nucleation mass m_{\text{nuc}}=${10}^{-16}\text{\,}\mathrm{kg}$ for each newly nucleated ice crystal, which gives the nucleation term \text{Nuc}_{q} for the mass concentration. In summary, we obtain \displaystyle\text{Nuc}_{n}=n_{a}\,V_{sol}\,J_{0}\exp(p_{1e}(s-p_2)) \displaystyle= \displaystyle A_{n}\exp(p_{1e}(s-p_2)) (35) \displaystyle\text{Nuc}_{q}=m_{\text{nuc}}\,n_{a}\,V_{sol}\,J_{0}\exp(p_{1e}(s-p_2)) \displaystyle= \displaystyle A_{q}\exp(p_{1e}(s-p_2)) (36) using two polynomials p_{1e},p_{2} depending on temperature solely (see Section 2.4 and Appendix A.3 ). Note, that the mass of the newly nucleated ice particles is obtained from the surrounding water vapor (since the solution droplets deplete some water vapor), thus we introduce a sink term for the saturation ratio as -B_{s1}\exp(p_{1e}(s-p_2)),\penalty\ \penalty\ \text{with}\penalty\ \penalty\ B_{s1}=A_{q}\frac{p}{\varepsilon p_{\text{si}}}. (37) We use a spherical shape of the ice particles, which in turn affects the description of the growth and sedimentation, respectively. For the representation of the growth term, we apply additional simplifications: • We neglect the kinetic correction, which would apply for very small ice particles, and especially affect nucleation events in clear air at very high velocities and/or low temperature regimes (see discussion in Spichtinger & Gierens 2009 ) . However, since we are interested in the qualitative behavior of the model, and especially in the long term behavior (where cloud particles pre-exist), this correction is not very relevant; thus, we set f_{k}=1 • We neglect the ventilation correction, which is quite important for large particles. However, in our low temperature regime with in situ formation process of homogeneous nucleation, ice crystals do not grow to such large sizes. Thus, we set f_{v}=1 . • For a spherical particle, we obtain the radius as capacity factor C=r , which can be expressed by the cubic root of the mean mass. Thus, we can express the growth term for the mass concentration (see also Appendix A.4 ) as \text{Dep}_{q}=B_{q}n^{\frac{2}{3}}q^{\frac{1}{3}}(s-1). (38) The growth term models the transfer of water vapor to ice particles, thus we have to introduce a sink term for the saturation ratio, i.e. -B_{s2}n^{\frac{2}{3}}q^{\frac{1}{3}}(s-1),\penalty\ \penalty\ \text{with}\penalty\ \penalty\ B_{s2}=B_{q}\frac{p}{\varepsilon p_{\text{si}}}; (39) in combination with the nucleation term above, we can set \text{Dep}_{s}=-B_{s1}\exp(p_{1e}(s-p_2))-B_{s2}n^{\frac{2}{3}}q^{\frac{1}{3}}(s-1). (40) For the evaporation term of the number concentration, we make the ad hoc ansatz \text{Evap}_{n}=\frac{n}{q}\text{Dep}_{q}H(1-s) (41) with the assumption that the number concentration of ice crystals reduces proportionally to the loss of mass concentration. This only happens for subsaturation, thus a Heaviside function H is used for switching off the process at s>1 . The terminal velocity of the ice particles as formulated in Spichtinger & Gierens 2009 by piecewise power laws can be approximated by a simple approach v_{t}(m)\approx v_{\text{final}}\,a_{s}\,m^{b_{s}}\frac{1}{v_{\text{final}}+a_{s}\,m^{b_{s}}}, (42) mimicking the major increase of the velocity. However, even this approach is too sophisticated, since in our regime, we do not find such large particles approaching the final value v_{\text{final}}\approx$2.4641\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\text{\,}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ , thus a simple power law v_{t}(m)\approx\,a_{s}\,m^{b_{s}} (43) works well. Since we consider a spherical shape of ice crystals, we find a meaningful fit v_{t}(m)=a_{s}m^{\frac{2}{3}},a_{s}=$6.0\text{\cdot}{10}^{5}\text{\,}\mathrm{m}$, (44) which is consistent with the expressions for falling spheres (velocity proportional to the squared radius as in Lamb & Verlinde 2011 ) . The sedimentation is a vertical transport in a column. However, in our simple model we concentrate on a single level and restrict ourselves to a box of a certain vertical extension \Delta z . Then we can approximate the change of the flux j_{\psi}=\rho v_{\psi}\psi (for a quantity \psi=n,q ) by the finite difference \partialderivative{j_\psi}{z}\approx\frac{j_{\psi}^{\text{top}}-j_{\psi}^{\text{bottom}}}{\Delta z} (45) with the flux j_{\psi}^{\text{top}} through the top boundary into the box and the flux j_{\psi}^{\text{bottom}} through the bottom out of the box, respectively. Generally, we can only determine the outgoing flux, but we might add constraints for determining the incoming flux; otherwise, the incoming flux can be seen as a variable parameter. Thus, the sedimentation terms can be formulated as \text{Sed}_{n}=F_{n}-\frac{1}{\Delta z}v_{n}n,\penalty\ \penalty\ \text{Sed}_{q}=F_{q}-\frac{1}{\Delta z}v_{q}q (46) with fluxes from above F_{n},F_{q} . Using the approximation of the terminal velocity ( 44 ), and the formulation of general moments of the lognormal distribution ( 31 ) we can derive the averaged terminal velocities \displaystyle v_{n}=\frac{1}{n}\int_{0}^{\infty}f(m)v_{t}(m)\differential m \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{1}{n}\quantity(a_sr_0^{-\frac{1}{9}}n^\frac{1}{3}q^\frac{2}{3}) (47) \displaystyle v_{q}=\frac{1}{q}\int_{0}^{\infty}f(m)mv_{t}(m)\differential m \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{1}{q}\quantity(a_sr_0^{\frac{5}{9}}n^{-\frac{2}{3}}q^\frac{5}{3}) (48) and thus the sedimentation terms \displaystyle\text{Sed}_{n}=F_{n}-\frac{1}{\Delta z}v_{n}n \displaystyle= \displaystyle F_{n}-C_{n}n^{\frac{1}{3}}q^{\frac{2}{3}},\penalty\ \penalty\ C_{n}=\frac{a_{s}r_{0}^{-\frac{1}{9}}}{\Delta z} (49) \displaystyle\text{Sed}_{q}=F_{q}-\frac{1}{\Delta z}v_{q}q \displaystyle= \displaystyle F_{q}-C_{q}n^{-\frac{2}{3}}q^{\frac{5}{3}},\penalty\ \penalty\ C_{q}=\frac{a_{s}r_{0}^{\frac{5}{9}}}{\Delta z} (50) The fluxes from above, F_{n} and F_{q} , appear as additional variables (or parameters). Since we would like to avoid too many parameters for our investigations, we adopt a strategy by Spichtinger & Cziczo 2010 : We assume that the sedimentation flux into the box/layer from above through the top boundary is a fixed fraction f_{\text{sed}} of the sedimentation flux through the bottom out of the box/layer, i.e. we can set j_{\psi}^{\text{top}}=f_{\text{sed}}\cdot j_{\psi}^{\text{bottom}} (51) with a constant 0\leq f_{\text{sed}}\leq 1 . The extreme values indicate either no flux into the box from above ( f_{\text{sed}}=0 ) or no net flux out of the box ( f_{\text{sed}}=1 ), i.e. the flux into the box from above and the flux out of the box are identical in magnitude. Thus, we find F_{n}=f_{\text{sed}}C_{n}n^{\frac{1}{3}}q^{\frac{2}{3}},F_{q}=f_{\text{sed}}C_{q}n^{-\frac{2}{3}}q^{\frac{5}{3}} (52) and set F\coloneqq 1-f_{\text{sed}} for computational convenience later on with 00 ). For the supersaturation regime ( s>1 ) a regularization of the sedimentation term -FC_{q}n^{-\frac{2}{3}}q^{\frac{5}{3}}\approx-FC_{q}\quantity(n+n_{\text{small}})^{-\frac{2}{3}}q^{\frac{5}{3}} (58) might be applied. Nevertheless, even if the singularities are removed, the right hand side is not Lipschitz continuous for initial values n=0 or q=0 because of terms n^{\alpha}q^{\beta} with 0\leq\alpha<1,0\leq\beta<1 . Thus, for initial value problems starting at such states the standard theory (general theorem for existence and uniqueness, see, e.g., Walter 1998 , p.68) cannot be applied. For other starting points, existence and uniqueness of solutions is guaranteed, since the right hand side is smooth; this is also true for the system without a regularization. We want to note here, that even for the initial values n=0 or q=0 , uniqueness might be obtained, following the arguments by Hanke & Porz 2020 to produce a mathematically unique solution with additional physical conditions. However, for our investigations these details might be not relevant, since we are mainly interested in the long time behavior, i.e. the qualitative properties of the system; then we can assume that n,q are positive. 4 Qualitative properties of the model In this section, we investigate the quality of the system in terms of dynamical systems theory. 4.1 Equilibrium states We start with the determination of the equilibrium states of the system. Equilibrium points (stationary points/fixed points) of an ODE system are states for which the right hand side of the ODE system vanishes, i.e. \dot{n}=\dot{q}=\dot{s}=0 , so we have to determine the roots of the 3D vector field V(x) . In order to (approximately) calculate the equilibrium points, we make two more simplifying assumptions. First, since we are interested in the supersaturated regime (i.e. s>1 ), we can omit the evaporation term \text{Evap}_{n}=B_{q}n^{\frac{5}{3}}q^{-\frac{2}{3}}H(1-s)(s-1) (59) from Equation ( 55 ). Since we assume w>0 , this is not an approximation; the supersaturation source A_{s}s will always drive the system into states with s>1 , and thus H(1-s)=0 . Second, we estimate the contribution of the nucleation rate to the mass concentration q . This term is usually very small, thus we can also neglect the term \text{Nuc}_{q}=A_{q}\exp(p_{1e}(s-p_2))\approx 0 (60) in Equation ( 56 ); the same argument holds for the term B_{s1}\exp(p_{1e}(s-p_2))\approx 0. (61) Thus we now have to find roots for the reduced system \displaystyle\derivative{n}{t} \displaystyle= \displaystyle A_{n}\exp(p_{1e}(s-p_2))-FC_{n}n^{\frac{1}{3}}q^{\frac{2}{3}} (62) \displaystyle\ \derivative{q}{t} \displaystyle= \displaystyle B_{q}n^{\frac{2}{3}}q^{\frac{1}{3}}(s-1)-FC_{q}n^{-\frac{2}{3}}q^{\frac{5}{3}} (63) \displaystyle\derivative{s}{t} \displaystyle= \displaystyle A_{s}s-B_{s2}n^{\frac{2}{3}}q^{\frac{1}{3}}(s-1). (64) This slight simplification has the convenient property that finding its roots can be reduced to finding the roots of a scalar function of the saturation ratio s . From this root s_{0} the values of the equilibrium state (i.e. n_{0},q_{0} ) can be calculated recursively. The respective function for the saturation ratio is as follows (see Appendix B ): f(x)=ax-b(x-1)^{\frac{3}{4}}\exp\left(c(x-x_{0})\right), (65) where a=A_{s},\penalty\ \penalty\ b=\frac{B_{s2}A_{n}}{C_{n}}\left(\frac{C_{q}}{B_{q}}\right)^{\frac{1}{4}}\left(\frac{1}{F}\right)^{\frac{3}{4}},\penalty\ \penalty\ c=p_{1e},\penalty\ \penalty\ x_{0}=p_{2}. (66) For a given value of the saturation ratio s we can calculate the respective values for n and q (see Appendix B ) as n=\frac{A_{n}}{FC_{n}}\exp(p_{1e}(s - p_2))\left(\frac{B_{q}}{FC_{q}}(s-1)\right)^{-\frac{1}{2}} (67) and q=\frac{A_{n}}{FC_{n}}\exp(p_{1e}(s - p_2))\left(\frac{B_{q}}{FC_{q}}(s-1)\right)^{\frac{1}{4}}. (68) Now we can show, that the 3D system has exactly one equilibrium point. For the existence of at least one root s>1 , we make the following argument: We investigate the function f from Equation ( 65 ) on the interval [1,\infty) . For s=1 we obtain f(s)=a=A_{s}>0 . Since the coefficients a,b,c>0 , the exponential term is the fastest growing one, such that f(s)<0 for sufficiently large values of s . Then the intermediate value theorem provides the existence of a root s_{0}>1 . In order to see that f has exactly one root, we consider the function g(x)=\frac{f(x)}{x}=a-bx^{-1}(x-1)^{\frac{3}{4}}\exp(c(x-x_0)) (69) and note that any x=s>1 is a root of f if and only if x is a root of g . We calculate the derivative of g as g^{\prime}(x)=-bx^{-1}(x-1)^{\frac{3}{4}}\exp(c(x-x_0))\cdot\left(c-\frac{1}{x}\right)-\frac{3}{4}bx^{-1}(x-1)^{-\frac{1}{4}}\exp(c(x-x_0)). (70) Since c=p_{1e}(T)>1 in the considered temperature range, we can conclude that g^{\prime}(x)<0 for all x>1 , i.e. g is strictly decreasing for x>1 and thus there is at most one root. Altogether, we can conclude that there is exactly one root s_{0} of f and thus exactly one equilibrium point of system ( 62 )-( 64 ). For a meaningful approximation of the equilibrium states, we fix temperature and pressure, and let s_{0} denote the saturation ratio at the fixed point of the system for a given vertical velocity w_{0} . Remember that among the coefficients of the function f , only the coefficient a=A_{s} depends on the vertical velocity w and and moreover this dependence is linear. If we slightly vary the saturation ratio, the main changes in the values of the function f stem from the exponential term \exp(c(x-x_0)) , while changes in the other terms can be considered to be minor. If we slightly vary the vertical velocity w_{0} to a new value w_{1} , we may assume that the corresponding value s_{1} of the saturation ratio at the equilibrium point satisfies a(w_{1})s_{1}=b(s_{1}-1)^{\frac{3}{4}}\exp\left(c(s_{1}-x_{0})\right)\approx b(s_{0}-1)^{\frac{3}{4}}\exp\left(c(s_{1}-x_{0})\right) (71) and also a(w_{1})\cdot s_{1}=\frac{a(w_{0})}{w_{0}}\cdot w_{1}\cdot s_{1}\approx\frac{a(w_{0})}{w_{0}}\cdot w_{1}\cdot s_{0}, (72) where we also used the fact that a depends linearly on w . Combined this leads to the approximation \exp\left(c(s_{1}-x_{0})\right)=\frac{a(w_{0})}{w_{0}}\cdot w_{1}\cdot s_{0}\cdot b^{-1}\cdot(s_{0}-1)^{-\frac{3}{4}} (73) and thus an expression for the saturation ratio s_{1} as follows s_{1}=p_{2}+\frac{1}{p_{1e}}\log( \frac{A_s(w_0)}{w_0}\cdot w_1 \cdot s_0 (s_0-1)^{-\frac 3 4} \cdot\frac{C_n}{ B_{s2} A_n} \left(\frac{B_q}{C_q}\right)^{\frac 1 4} F^{\frac 3 4} ). (74) We introduce two further functions: \displaystyle\sigma(T,p) \displaystyle\coloneqq \displaystyle p_{2}+\frac{1}{p_{1e}}\log( \left(\frac{L}{c_p R_v T^2} - \frac{1}{R_a T} \right) \cdot g \cdot\frac{C_n}{ B_{s2} A_n} \left(\frac{B_q}{C_q}\right)^{\frac 1 4} ) (75) \displaystyle h(x)\coloneqq h(x,F,w,T,p) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sigma+\frac{1}{p_{1e}}\log(w)+\frac{3}{4p_{1e}}\log(F)+\frac{1}{p_{1e}}\log(\frac{x}{(x-1)^{\frac 3 4}}) (76) such that s_{1}=h(s_{0},F,w_{1},T,p) . A direct calculation shows that x^{*} is a fixed point of h (i.e. x^{*}=h\quantity(x^*) ) if and only if x^{*} is a root of f (i.e. f(x^{*})=0 ). Therefore, fixed points x^{*} of h correspond precisely to the values of the saturation ratio at equilibrium points of the ice cloud model. We now show that function h is a contraction on a suitable compact interval (which in turn narrows the range for the equilibrium value s_{0} ) and use this property for a suitable approximation. Estimating the ranges of functions \sigma and p_{1e} (see Appendix C ) we find that h(x)=\kappa_{0}+\frac{1}{p_{1e}}\log(\frac{x}{(x-1)^{\frac{3}{4}}}) (77) for some (variable) \kappa_{0}\in[1.375170,1.585966] . Let us now specify the following interval [s_{\text{min}},s_{\text{max}}]\penalty\ \text{with}\penalty\ s_{\text{min}}=1.37,\penalty\ s_{\text{max}}=1.59. (78) We can show (see Appendix C ) that \displaystyle h\quantity([s_\text{min},s_\text{max}]) \displaystyle\subset \displaystyle[s_{\text{min}},s_{\text{max}}]. (79) In addition, we calculate the derivative of h as h^{\prime}(x)=\frac{1}{4p_{1e}}\frac{x-4}{x(x-1)} (80) and thus \absolutevalue{h'(x)}\leq\frac{\pi_{2}}{4}\frac{4-s_{\text{min}}}{s_{\text{min}}(s_{\text{min}}-1)}\approx 0.004415\ll 1. (81) Therefore, h is a contraction on the compact interval [s_{\text{min}},s_{\text{max}}]\subset\mathbb{R} . Consequently, the Banach Fixed Point Theorem yields the existence of a unique fixed point, and the sequence x_{n} defined by x_{n}=h\quantity(x_{n-1})=\sigma+\frac{1}{p_{1e}}\log(w)+\frac{3}{4p_{1e}}\log(F)+\frac{1}{p_{1e}}\log(\frac{x_{n-1}}{(x_{n-1}-1)^{\frac 3 4}}) (82) converges to this fixed point s_{0} . This implies in particular that the saturation ratio s_{0} at an equilibrium point (which has the value of the unique fixed point of h(x) ) is always contained in the interval [s_{\text{min}},s_{\text{max}}] for any given environmental conditions in the relevant ranges as previously specified and summarized in Table 1 . In practice, we can determine an approximation for the value of s_{0} while approximating the function l(x)=\log(\frac{x}{(x-1)^{\frac{3}{4}}}) on the interval [s_{\text{min}},s_{\text{max}}] by the midpoint of possible values \ell_{m}=\frac{1}{2}\quantity(l(s_\text{min})+l(s_\text{max}))\approx 0.959979 , such that s_{0}\approx\sigma(T,p)+\frac{1}{p_{1e}(T)}\quantity(\ell_m+\log(w)+\frac{3}{4}\log(F)) (83) with an absolute error of approximation smaller than 4\cdot 10^{-4} . Hence, the proof of uniqueness using the fixed point theorem also leads to an approximate description of the equilibrium states as a by-product in our setting here. Note here, that the contraction property assures that the approximation converges towards the equilibrium point, i.e. iteration of the function leads to an improved approximation. Using the Equations ( 67 ) and ( 68 ) for the calculation of the other values of the equilibrium state n_{0},q_{0} from the value s_{0} , we finally get the equations \displaystyle n_{0} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{g}{B_{s2}}\left(\frac{C_{q}}{B_{q}}\right)^{\frac{1}{4}}\left(\frac{L}{c_{p}R_{v}T^{2}}-\frac{1}{R_{a}T}\right)\cdot w\cdot F^{\frac{1}{4}}\cdot s_{0}(s_{0}-1)^{-\frac{5}{4}} (84) \displaystyle q_{0} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{g}{B_{s2}}\left(\frac{B_{q}}{C_{q}}\right)^{\frac{1}{2}}\left(\frac{L}{c_{p}R_{v}T^{2}}-\frac{1}{R_{a}T}\right)\cdot w\cdot F^{-\frac{1}{2}}\cdot s_{0}(s_{0}-1)^{-\frac{1}{2}}. (85) Since the changes in the saturation ratio s_{0} at the equilibrium point for varying w and F within the specified ranges are only very minor compared to the changes in w and F^{\frac{1}{4}} or F^{-\frac{1}{2}} in Equations ( 84 ) and ( 85 ), good approximations for the ice crystal number and mass concentrations n_{0} and q_{0} at the equilibrium point for varying w and F are given by calculating s_{0} for one choice of vertical velocity w and sedimentation parameter F (e.g. for w=$0.1\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\text{\,}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ and F=1.0 ) and then approximating n_{0} and q_{0} by Equations ( 84 ) and ( 85 ) using the fixed s_{0} . In Figure 1 , the equilibrium states for different temperatures are represented. The dependency of all quantities n,q,s on \log(w) is clearly visible, since we use a logarithmic axis for the vertical updrafts. The quasi-linear fits are almost perfect. Figure 1 : Equilibrium states for the ice cloud model at p=$300\text{\,}\mathrm{hPa}$ . Colors indicate different temperatures, i.e. red: 230\text{\,}\mathrm{K} , grey: 210\text{\,}\mathrm{K} , blue: 190\text{\,}\mathrm{K} . Black lines indicate approximations as given in Equations ( 83 )-( 85 ). Left: Number concentration (in 1/kg), middle: mass concentration (in kg/kg), right: saturation ratio. 4.2 Quality of equilibrium states The quality of the equilibrium point of the model depends on the choice of the parameters, and can be deduced from the eigenvalues of the Jacobi matrix of the system at the equilibrium point; this is true at least in case of non-zero eigenvalues, which is the case here, as we show later. The Jacobi matrix of the reduced system ( 62 )-( 64 ) at an arbitrary point (n,q,s) is given by J=\left(\begin{matrix}-\frac{1}{3}FC_{n}\bar{m}^{\frac{2}{3}}&-\frac{2}{3}FC_{n}\bar{m}^{-\frac{1}{3}}&p_{1e}A_{n}\exp(p_{1e}(s - p_2))\\ \frac{2}{3}\left(B_{q}\bar{m}^{\frac{1}{3}}(s-1)+FC_{q}\bar{m}^{\frac{5}{3}}\right)&\frac{1}{3}B_{q}\bar{m}^{-\frac{2}{3}}(s-1)-\frac{5}{3}FC_{q}\bar{m}^{\frac{2}{3}}&B_{q}n^{\frac{2}{3}}q^{\frac{1}{3}}\\ -\frac{2}{3}B_{s2}\bar{m}^{\frac{1}{3}}(s-1)&-\frac{1}{3}B_{s2}\bar{m}^{-\frac{2}{3}}(s-1)&A_{s}-B_{s2}n^{\frac{2}{3}}q^{\frac{1}{3}}\end{matrix}\right). (86) Here, \bar{m}=\frac{q}{n} denotes the mean mass of ice crystals. Since the expressions become too complicated there is no chance to calculate the eigenvalues analytically at the equilibrium points. However, we can partly determine the general quality of the solution, e.g. properties such as the sign of the eigenvalues. For this purpose, we reformulate the Jacobi matrix. Using the conditions for an equilibrium point, i.e. (\dot{n},\dot{q},\dot{s})=(0,0,0) , we obtain the following equations (see Appendix B ) \displaystyle A_{n}\exp(p_{1e} (s - p_2 )) \displaystyle= \displaystyle FC_{n}n^{\frac{1}{3}}q^{\frac{2}{3}} (87) \displaystyle\bar{m} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(\frac{B_{q}}{FC_{q}}(s-1)\right)^{\frac{3}{4}} (88) \displaystyle B_{s2}(s-1) \displaystyle= \displaystyle A_{s}s\bar{m}^{-\frac{1}{3}}n^{-1} (89) These identities can be used for rewriting the Jacobi matrix as J=\left(\begin{matrix}-\frac{1}{3}FC_{n}\bar{m}^{\frac{2}{3}}&-\frac{2}{3}FC_{n}\bar{m}^{-\frac{1}{3}}&p_{1e}FC_{n}\bar{m}^{\frac{2}{3}}n\\ \frac{4}{3}FC_{q}\bar{m}^{\frac{5}{3}}&-\frac{4}{3}FC_{q}\bar{m}^{\frac{2}{3}}&\frac{1}{(s-1)}FC_{q}\bar{m}^{\frac{5}{3}}n\\ -\frac{2}{3}A_{s}sn^{-1}&-\frac{1}{3}A_{s}sq^{-1}&-A_{s}\frac{1}{(s-1)}\end{matrix}\right). (90) It turns out that this matrix J is similar to a slightly simpler matrix J_{1} , which has the same eigenvalues, i.e. J=D^{-1}J_{1}D , and finally J=a\cdot D^{-1}J_{2}D , with a=\frac{1}{3}FC_{n}\bar{m}^{\frac{2}{3}},\penalty\ \penalty\ D=\matrixquantity(\lx@physics@matrix 1 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & \bar m^{-1} & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & n\endlx@physics@matrix),\penalty\ \penalty\ J_{2}=\left(\begin{matrix}-1&-2&3p_{1e}\\ 4r_{0}^{\frac{2}{3}}&-4r_{0}^{\frac{2}{3}}&3r_{0}^{\frac{2}{3}}\frac{1}{(s-1)}\\ -2\gamma\frac{s}{\sqrt{s-1}}&-\gamma\frac{s}{\sqrt{s-1}}&-3\gamma\frac{1}{(s-1)^{\frac{3}{2}}}\end{matrix}\right) (91) using the relations C_{q}=r_{0}^{\frac{2}{3}}C_{n},\penalty\ \penalty\ \gamma=A_{s}F^{-\frac{1}{2}}B_{q}^{-\frac{1}{2}}r_{0}^{\frac{1}{3}}C_{n}^{-\frac{1}{2}} (92) For the calculation of the determinant we use the formulation J=a\cdot D^{-1}J_{2}D , thus we find \det J=\frac{1}{3}F^{2}C_{n}^{2}A_{s}\bar{m}^{\frac{4}{3}}r_{0}^{\frac{2}{3}}\frac{1}{s-1}\cdot\quantity(-4+s-4s(s -1) p_{1e}) (93) Since F,C_{n},A_{s},\bar{m} are all positive and s>1 and p_{1e}>1 in the considered range, we find -4+s-4s(s-1)p_{1e}=-3+(s-1)(-4sp_{1e}+1)<0\penalty\ \Rightarrow\det J<0 (94) Let \lambda_{1},\lambda_{2},\lambda_{3} denote the eigenvalues of J for a given equilibrium state. After rearranging/renumbering we can assume that either all eigenvalues are real or one ( \lambda_{3} ) is real and two are complex conjugates ( \lambda_{1}=\lambda_{2}^{*} ). Since \det J=\lambda_{1}\lambda_{2}\lambda_{3}<0 , we conclude that there has to be at least one negative real eigenvalue \lambda_{i}<0 . In addition, all eigenvalues are non-zero ( \lambda_{i}\neq 0 for all i=1,2,3 ). The eigenvalues are then calculated numerically using routines of the package “linalg” in “numpy” ( Harris et al. 2020 ) . The real negative eigenvalue is denoted by \lambda_{3} . For most parameters, we find two complex conjugate eigenvalues \lambda_{1},\lambda_{2} ; in a small regime (higher temperature and/or high vertical velocities) we obtain two real negative eigenvalues \lambda_{1},\lambda_{2}<0 . We find two supercritical Hopf bifurcations of the system, i.e. the real part of the complex conjugate eigenvalues changes its sign, such that there is a transition from a stable equilibrium point to the case of an unstable equilibrium point and an attracting limit cycle (see, e.g., Kuznetsov 1998 ) . For the local existence of the periodic solutions (i.e. limit cycles), we can apply a theorem based on Lyapunov-Schmidt reduction (Theorem 2.1 in Golubitsky & Schaeffer 1985 , page 341) , since at the bifurcation point we have exactly two conjugate imaginary eigenvalues and no other eigenvalues on the imaginary axis. However, we will investigate the the limit cycles later in Section 4.3 , using numerical investigations. Using the description of the trace of the Jacobi matrix, we can derive additional properties of the eigenvalues of the linearized system. The trace can be calculated as \tr(J)=\tr(aD^{-1}J_2D)=a\tr(J_2)=-a\quantity(1+4r_0^{\frac{2}{3}}+3\gamma\frac{1}{(s -1)^{\frac{3}{2}}})=\lambda_{1}+\lambda_{2}+\lambda_{3} (95) using the description of the matrix J_{2} in Equation ( 91 ). Since the constants a,r_{0},\gamma are all positive and in the considered range we have s>1 , we find a negative trace of the Jacobi matrix \tr(J)=a\tr(J_2)=\lambda_{1}+\lambda_{2}+\lambda_{3}<0. (96) This condition can be reformulated as \lambda_{1}+\lambda_{2}<-\lambda_{3} with the distinct real and negative eigenvalue \lambda_{3}\in\mathbb{R}_{<0} . We can distinguish different cases: 1. For a pair of complex conjugate eigenvalues \lambda_{1}=\lambda_{2}^{\ast}=\alpha+i\beta\in\mathbb{C} ( \alpha,\beta\in\mathbb{R} ) we find \lambda_{1}+\lambda_{2}=2\alpha<-\lambda_{3}\Leftrightarrow\alpha=\real(\lambda_{1,2})<-\frac{\lambda_{3}}{2}\in\mathbb{R}_{>0} (97) For negative real parts \alpha this is not a restriction, since then we find \alpha<0<-\frac{\lambda_{3}}{2} . However, for positive real parts (i.e. in case of an unstable fixed point), we determine the condition 0<\alpha<-\frac{\lambda_{3}}{2} . Thus, the absolute value of the growth rate \real(\lambda_{1,2})=\alpha of the instability close to the equilibrium point is always smaller than the value of the contraction rate \lambda_{3} , i.e. close to the equilibrium state the flow contraction in \lambda_{3}- direction is always faster than the blowup in \lambda_{1,2}- directions. This points to a quasi 2D system for longer time scales. 2. For real eigenvalues \lambda_{1},\lambda_{2}\in\mathbb{R} , we still have the property \lambda_{1}+\lambda_{2}<-\lambda_{3} . In the numerical determination we only find the case of two negative real eigenvalues \lambda_{1},\lambda_{2}<0 ; thus, there is again no restriction for the eigenvalues, since the eigenvalues always fulfill \lambda_{1}+\lambda_{2}<0<-\lambda_{3} . In Figure 2 we show an example of real and imaginary parts of the numerically determined eigenvalues for a fixed parameter set of p=$300\text{\,}\mathrm{hPa}$,T=$230\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$,F=1 and values of vertical updrafts in the interval $0.0005\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\text{\,}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$\leq w\leq$2\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\text{\,}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ . Note, that we show a regime with all possible occurring variants of eigenvalues, i.e. conjugate-complex pair and three real eigenvalues, respectively. For the unstable regime (for positive real part, i.e. in the range between w\sim$0.048\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\text{\,}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ and w\sim$0.77\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\text{\,}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ ) we clearly see, that the relation ( 97 ) is fulfilled, i.e. the positive real part of \lambda_{1,2} is much smaller than the absolute value of \lambda_{3} . Remark: If we could assure that the real part of the complex-conjugate eigenvalues changes with non-zero speed at the bifurcation points, a theorem by Hopf (1942, see Guckenheimer & Holmes 2002 , Theorem 3.4.2, p. 151) would guarantee the existence of a two dimensional centre manifold, on which the limit cycle lies. Figure 2 : Example of real (left) and imaginary (right) parts of numerically determined eigenvalues at the equilibrium state of the system for a fixed set of parameters p=$300\text{\,}\mathrm{hPa}$,T=$230\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$,F=1 We calculate the bifurcation points numerically. For a fixed temperature T we scan through the w -interval, calculate the eigenvalues of the respective Jacobi matrix J , and determine the position where the sign of the real part of \lambda_{1,2} changes. The bifurcation diagram for values p=$300\text{\,}\mathrm{hPa}$ and F=1 is represented in Figure 3 . Blue and red dots mark the numerically determined Hopf bifurcations, grey dots mark the region of three real and negative eigenvalues. Figure 3 : Bifurcation diagram in the parameter space T-w for p=$300\text{\,}\mathrm{hPa}$ and F=1 . The red and blue dots indicate the numerically calculated transition in the real parts of the complex-conjugate eigenvalues \lambda_{1,2} , i.e. the two Hopf bifurcations. The black lines indicate fits to the bifurcations using a quadratic polynomial in T . Above the red points and below the blue points, the unique equilibrium state is stable. Between the two lines, the equilibrium state is unstable and a limit cycle occurs. Grey dots indicate the region with purely real eigenvalues (i.e. three negative real eigenvalues). We find that the two bifurcations for F=1 can be fitted using exponential functions with quadratic polynomials in the argument, i.e. functions of the form w_{a}(T)=\bar{w}\exp(a_2T^2+a_1T+a_0),\penalty\ \penalty\ w_{b}(T)=\bar{w}\exp(b_2T^2+b_1T+b_0) (98) with coefficients a_{i},b_{i} as represented in Table 2 , and the “constant” \bar{w}=$1\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\text{\,}\mathrm{s}$ determining the correct unit of the functions. \begin{array}[]{l||c|c|c}&k=0&k=1&k=2\\ \hline\cr a_{k}&$-38.309\,47\text{\,}$&$0.278\,555\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$&$-0.000\,491\,91\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$\\ \hline\cr b_{k}&$-36.150\,46\text{\,}$&$0.229\,111\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$&$-0.000\,369\,97\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$\end{array} Table 2 : Coefficients for the quadratic fit functions w_{a}(T),w_{b}(T) of the two Hopf bifurcations The fits are shown in Figure 3 as black lines; however, blue dots “belong” to fit w_{a}(T) , whereas red dots “belong” to fit w_{b}(T) . The bifurcation diagram for other values of F will be discussed later in the Section 4.4 , where we investigate the scaling properties of the system. For different values of pressure (i.e. p=$200\text{\,}\mathrm{hPa}$ ) we find qualitatively similar bifurcation diagrams, i.e. the supercritical Hopf bifurcations are still there, however slightly shifted in their position. In fact, the quality of the system stays the same. Remark: For the Jacobi matrix of the equilibrium state at the bifurcation we can use basic relations from linear algebra \lambda_{1,2}=\pm i\beta,\penalty\ \Rightarrow\tr(J)=\lambda_{3},\penalty\ \Rightarrow\det(J-\lambda_3I)=0 (99) to derive a quasi-quadratic equation from the determinant for the bifurcation value w , i.e. a_{2}w^{2}+a_{1}w+a_{0}=0 (100) with coefficients a_{2},a_{1},a_{0} only slightly depending on w . This gives also an analytical hint, that we should find two bifurcations for the system. When calculating the values of w from Equation ( 100 ), we find values very close to the bifurcation points as numerically calculated from the complete system. In Figure 4 , some examples for the three different regimes are represented, i.e. the time evolution of the saturation ratio s is shown for values w=$0.01\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\text{\,}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ (stable equilibrium, lower regime), w=$0.1\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\text{\,}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ (unstable equilibrium, limit cycle), and w=$1\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\text{\,}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ (stable equilibrium, higher regime). Figure 4 : Examples of solutions for different regimes. Left: damped oscillator ( w=$0.01\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\text{\,}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$) , middle: undamped oscillator ( w=$0.1\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\text{\,}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ ), right: damped oscillator ( w=$1\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\text{\,}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ ) In all simulations we see the same general evolution of a first and undisturbed nucleation event followed by a (more or less) strong reduction of the supersaturation, and afterwards subsequent nucleation events, which are less vigorous since pre-existing ice slows down the explosion term. This behavior was observed in former studies (e.g. Spichtinger & Cziczo 2010 ) . All variables of the simulations are shown in Appendix D , i.e. Figures 10 , 11 , and 12 . Qualitatively we can describe the behavior with the three different processes. Nucleation, as driven by the cooling/forcing term of s , acts as a source for ice crystals, whereas sedimentation is the sink for ice crystals. The growth process acts as a mediator in between, shifting mass from the saturation ratio to the mass concentration, which (1) shuts down the nucleation event because of less supersaturation as discussed in Spichtinger & Kr\"amer 2013 , and (2) enhances the sedimentation sink. These feedback can also be seen calculating the divergence of the vector field, i.e. the trace of the general Jacobi matrix. \divergence{V}=\tr(J)=A_{s}+\frac{1}{3}B_{q}m^{-\frac{2}{3}}(s-1)-B_{s2}nm^{\frac{1}{3}}-\frac{1}{3}FC_{n}\quantity(1+5r_0^{\frac{2}{3}})m^{\frac{2}{3}} (101) The first term, i.e. the cooling/forcing of the system is clearly positive, the last term, i.e. sedimentation, is negative, and the growth terms in the middle could change signs. For small particles, the first term of growth dominates (positive), whereas for large (or many) particles the second term of growth dominates (negative). However, the divergence can change sign, thus a clear asymptotic behavior cannot be seen from this analysis. As described in the next section, in the unstable case we observe an undamped oscillation, which indicates an attracting limit cycle. 4.3 Limit cycles There is no method available for calculating the limit cycles, or even their periods analytically for this 3D nonlinear system, at least to our best knowledge. Therefore we use a numerical method to determine the period of the limit cycles. For this purpose we integrate the system again for quite a long time, but with initial conditions close to the unstable equilibrium state. To be precise, for a (numerically determined) equilibrium point x_{0}=(n_{0},q_{0},s_{0})^{T} we determine the initial condition as x_{\text{init}}=x_{0}\cdot(1-\varepsilon) with a small deviation \varepsilon=0.01 . We then run the simulation for a time T_{\text{final}} , which is approximately determined as T_{\text{final}}=300\cdot\tau_{\lambda} with the period at the equilibrium point \tau_{\lambda}=\frac{2\pi}{\imaginary(\lambda_{1})} , using the imaginary part of the two complex-conjugate eigenvalues. The simulations are carried out using a Gaussian grid with a timestep, adaptively but constant determined by the empirical relation \Delta t=\frac{$0.01\text{\,}\mathrm{m}$}{w} , using the prescribed vertical velocity w . Since the variable s is the most “linear” one, we then determine minima and maxima of this variable over time. From the difference between consecutive minima or maxima, respectively, at the end of the simulation we determine two periods \tau_{\text{min}},\tau_{\text{max}} . The mean value \tau=\frac{1}{2}\quantity(\tau_{\text{min}}+\tau_{\text{max}}) is then used as the numerically determined period of the limit cycle, for a given set of parameters (p,T,w,F) , respectively. In Figure 5 (left panel) the periods of the limit cycles are represented. For the domain between the two Hopf bifurcations, the color code indicates the periods of the limit cycles. Note that there is a huge range of periods, ranging from very short periods at high temperatures and high vertical velocities (in the order of few hundreds of seconds) up to large periods at low temperatures and low vertical updrafts (in the order of 10^{4} to 10^{5} seconds). The periods depending on w show a similar shape for a distinct temperature, as will be investigated later in terms of scaling properties in Section 4.4 . In the right panel of Figure 5 an example for periods at a fixed temperature of T=$210\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$ but varying vertical updraft is displayed. The red curve shows the “oscillation period” as derived from the imaginary part of the respective complex-conjugate eigenvalues ( \tau=\frac{2\pi}{\imaginary(\lambda_{k})} ) at the equilibrium point, whereas the black curve shows the period of the limit cycle in the region of the unstable equilibrium point. Both curves touch each other at the bifurcation, as expected. The periods of the limit cycle always have a distinct maximum in the interval between the two bifurcation lines. Note that for the small regime of three real eigenvalues, as indicated in Figure 3 by the grey shading, \tau shows a singularity when approaching an imaginary part \imaginary(\lambda_{k})=0 . Figure 5 : Left: Periods of limit cycles in the bifurcation diagram. Right: Example of section through the parameter space at fixed temperature T=$210\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$ , representing the oscillation period as calculated from the imaginary part of the complex eigenvalues (red line), and the period of the respective limit cycle in the unstable regime (black line). 4.4 Scaling properties Now we investigate some scaling properties of the system. 4.4.1 Scaling property of bifurcations Until now we investigated the bifurcations for variations in p,T,w , but left the sedimentation parameter unchanged, i.e. F=1 (no flux from above). Now we investigate possible changes in the bifurcations due to variation of F in the interval 0.010} . Then we can derive: \displaystyle w_{1}(T)=F^{\alpha}w_{0}(T) \displaystyle= \displaystyle F^{\alpha}\bar{w}\exp(c_0+c_1T+c_2T^2) (105) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\bar{w}\exp(\bar{c}_0+c_1T+c_2T^2) (106) with the expression F^{\alpha}\exp(c_0)=\exp(\bar{c}_0)\Leftrightarrow\log(F^\alpha\exp(c_0))=\bar{c}_{0}\Leftrightarrow\alpha\log(F)+c_{0}=\bar{c}_{0}\Leftrightarrow\alpha=\frac{\bar{c}_{0}-c_{0}}{\log(F)}. (107) We determine fits for sedimentation factors F\in\quantity{0.01,0.02,0.05,0.1,0.2,0.3,0.4,0.5,0.6} for both bifurcations and determine the exponent \alpha (also in terms of a mean value). We find for the upper bifurcation \alpha\approx\frac{1}{2} as from theory, whereas for the lower bifurcation the values changes slightly to \alpha\approx 0.512\approx\frac{1}{2} . Thus, the scaling property of the bifurcation due to F^{\alpha} is a robust feature. In Figure 6 the scaled fits using the respective ansatz w(T)=F^{\alpha}w_{\ast}(T) are shown for F=1,0.1,0.01 ; reddish colors show the upper bifurcations, whereas bluish colors display the lower bifurcation. The fits match the data points quite well, corroborating this type of scaling. Finally, we can state that the change of the sedimentation parameter F does not change the quality of the bifurcation diagram. Actually, the quality of the phase diagram and thus the bifurcations remain the same, only the transition lines/bifurcation curves change their position, but even not their shape. This is a remarkable feature of this nonlinear oscillator. Figure 6 : Scaling of bifurcations for different values of the sedimentation parameter F . Black dots show the numerically derived values, whereas colored lines represent the scaling of the fit curves as derived for the parameter F=1 . Reddish colors show the change in the upper bifurcation, whereas bluish colors show the change in the lower bifurcations; in both cases, sedimentation parameters of F=1,0.1,0.01 are shown. 4.4.2 Scaling property of limit cycle periods In Section 4.3 , we determined the periods of the limit cycles for the regime of unstable equilibrium states. We already noted that the shape of the curves at fixed but different temperatures T is very similar. In the left panel of Figure 7 , the curves for the periods of the limit cycles at different temperatures are displayed. Figure 7 : Scalings of limit cycle’s periods. Left: periods of limit cycles for different temperatures; middle: numerical scaling of the data together with the reference curve for T=$210\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$ ; right: scaled data using the scaling functions from Equations ( 111 ) and ( 112 ). In the double-logarithmic representation the similarity of the curves is very evident. Thus, we make an empirical scaling ansatz, using the temperature value T_{\text{ref}}=$210\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$ as reference temperature. We hypothesize that the curve scale with a non-dimensional temperature. Using the reduced temperature x\coloneqq\frac{T}{T_{\text{ref}}} , we might find scaling functions f(x),g(x) such that the periods \tau(w,T) can be expressed as \tau\quantity(w,T)=f(x)\tau\quantity(g(x)w,T_{\text{ref}}). (108) The scaling function g(x) shifts the w- position of the periods, whereas the function f(x) changes the amplitude of the periods, respectively. This kind of scalings are often found in phase transitions and self-organized criticality (see, e.g., Pruessner 2012 ) , and thus we would expect a function of the form f(x)\sim x^{a} with a so-called critical exponent a\in\mathbb{R} . A similar form is expected for the function g(x) . Comparing the numerically derived periods and calculating shifts for matching the curves, we can map the curves on each other; this is shown in the middle panel of Figure 7 , with the calculated and shifted data as black points and the “reference” period at T_{\text{ref}} as a red curve. We can calculate numerically the apparent shifts in position and amplitude, respectively, for the different reduced temperatures x in the temperature interval $190\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$\leq T\leq$240\text{\,}\mathrm{K}$ , i.e. in the interval 0.9\leq x\leq 1.15 . These values are plotted in Figure 8 as grey dots. Using the expected form for functions f(x),g(x)\sim x^{a} we find the exponents f(x)=x^{15.0617},\penalty\ \penalty\ g(x)=x^{-14.1228}; (109) these fits are shown in Figure 8 as curves in light red or blue. For values 0.95