A strange contribution to the neutron EDM Luca Vecchi Abstract We analyze the contribution of hypothetical quark electric dipoles to the electric dipole moment (EDM) of the neutron. Particular emphasis is devoted to the strange quark contribution. Considerations based on perturbative QCD, the large N expansion, a critic reassessment of the non-relativistic quark model as well as a next to leading order calculation in heavy baryon effective field theory, all consistently indicate that, barring accidental cancellations, the matrix element of the strange quark dipole should be of order a tenth of those of the valence quarks. This implies that the strange EDM provides the dominant contribution to the neutron EDM in many scenarios beyond the Standard Model. 1 Motivation The non-observation of the electric dipole moment (EDM) of the neutron, d_{n} , provides one of the most stringent constraints on physics beyond the Standard Model. Currently the best bound is |d_{n}|\leq 1.8\times 10^{-26}~e\,{\text{cm}} at 90\% CL [ 1 ] , but the experimental sensitivity is expected to improve by one or even two orders of magnitude in the next ten to twenty years [ 2 ] . Given the enormous impact that this measurement has, it is crucial to correctly identify the mapping between the new physics parameters and d_{n} . Among the many contributions to d_{n} , those arising from hypothetical quark EDMs are especially relevant for a vast class of new physics scenarios. Denoting the EDMs of the up, down, and strange quarks renormalized slightly above the GeV as d_{u},d_{d},d_{s} , respectively, and working at leading order in the CP-violating couplings, the neutron EDM takes the form \displaystyle d_{n}=g_{Tn}^{u}d_{u}+g_{Tn}^{d}d_{d}+g_{Tn}^{s}d_{s} (1) for some unknown real numbers g_{Tn}^{u,d,s} known as tensor charges. The tensor charges are intrinsically non-perturbative and cannot be reliably computed analytically. Yet, intuitively one expects sizable g_{Tn}^{u,d} and a moderately smaller g_{Tn}^{s} . The strange quark contributes non-negligibly to the nucleon masses (as confirmed by analyses in chiral perturbation theory [ 3 ] and lattice QCD [ 4 ] ), as well as to the nucleon spin (see [ 5 ] for chiral perturbation theory and again [ 4 ] for lattice QCD measurements). The matrix elements of both the scalar and axial-vector strange operators are roughly a fraction 0.1 of the analogous valence quark operators. One would thus naively anticipate a similar trend in the tensor charges. However, this is not what more concrete approaches find. As we review in the next section, the tensor charges have been estimated via various models of the QCD dynamics as well as via numerical simulations with lattice QCD methods. The former seem to suggest g_{Tn}^{s} is negligible but, admittedly, either completely ignore the effect of the strange EDM or suffer from uncertainties that are impossible to quantify. Lattice QCD simulations instead measure a |g_{Tn}^{s}| smaller by a factor of 100 to 1000 compared to the matrix elements of the valence quarks [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] . At present the origin of such surprising small ratio is unknown. This state of affairs is not fully satisfactory, in our opinion. What must absolutely be avoided is that the actual impact of the strange EDM gets erroneously underestimated, since that would badly misguide us when assessing the phenomenological implications of the experimental efforts. Indeed, in many well-motivated scenarios of new physics the quark dipoles arise at 1-loop and the chirality-flip is controlled by parameters that feature hierarchies similar to those of the quark masses, so that d_{q}\sim m_{q}e/m_{*}^{2} for some heavy mass scale m_{*} . In those scenarios the strange quark dipole would dominate over those of the up or down as soon as |g_{Tn}^{s}/g_{Tn}^{u,d}|\gtrsim m_{u,d}/m_{s}\sim 0.02\div 0.05 . And in the extreme event in which |g_{Tn}^{s}/g_{Tn}^{u,d}|\sim 1 the lower bounds on the new physics scale would be stronger by a factor of 4 to 6 compared to those expected from valence quark dipoles. Evidently, which new physics scenarios are or are not allowed by a measurement of d_{n} critically depends on the value of g_{Tn}^{s} , and qualitatively differ if, say, |g_{Tn}^{s}/g_{Tn}^{u,d}|\sim 0.1 as opposed to |g_{Tn}^{s}/g_{Tn}^{u,d}|\sim 0.01 . The relevance of the sea quarks in nucleon physics has a very long history, and has been and is being investigated by many authors. In the study of the neutron EDM, the impact of the strange chromo-electric dipole was emphasized by several authors in the past (see e.g. [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] ). Surprisingly, though, we have not found a likewise systematic assessment of the strange EDM contribution to d_{n} . The main aim of the present paper is filling this gap. While the last word is clearly left to the lattice QCD community, we believe that the transparency and simplicity of an analytical approach can, despite all its limits, help shed light on this interesting problem. The paper is organized as follows. We begin with a presentation of the setup in Section 2 . The most popular estimates of the tensor charges are summarized in Section 2.1 . A first look at the diagrams contributing to g_{Tn}^{s} is presented in Section 2.2 . In Section 3 we complete our preliminary assessment by showing what large N_{c} QCD has to say about the tensor charges. In Section 4 we start a more quantitative analysis, critically reviewing the predictions of the familiar non-relativistic quark model. In Section 5 we present the result of a chiral expansion at next to leading order. The appendices contain details on the results presented in the bulk of the paper. We summarize our conclusions in Section 6 . 2 Introductory remarks We perturb the QCD Lagrangian introducing electric dipole moments for the light quarks. At a scale \Lambda_{\text{UV}} above the typical hadron mass M_{h}\sim 1 GeV the Lagrangian reads \displaystyle{\cal L}_{\Lambda_{\text{UV}}} \displaystyle=-\frac{1}{4}G_{\mu\nu}^{A}G^{A\,\mu\nu}+\overline{q_{i}}i{\not{D}}q_{i}-(\overline{q_{i}}m_{ij}P_{R}q_{j}+{\text{hc}})-\theta\frac{g^{2}}{64\pi^{2}}G_{\mu\nu}^{A}G_{\alpha\beta}^{A}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta} (2) \displaystyle-\left(\frac{d_{ij}}{2}\overline{q}_{i}i\sigma^{\mu\nu}P_{R}q_{j}\,F_{\mu\nu}+{\text{hc}}\right), where a sum over the flavor indices i,j=u,d,s is understood, P_{R}=\frac{1}{2}(1+\gamma_{5}) is the right-handed chiral projector, and finally \sigma^{\mu\nu}=\frac{i}{2}[\gamma^{\mu},\gamma^{\nu}] . For simplicity, throughout the paper we will work in a fantasy world in which the charm quark is much heavier than M_{h} . Hence, at the scales of interest, the c,b,t quarks are sufficiently heavy to be integrated out and their impact on d_{n} is suppressed by powers of the heavy quark mass. In practice this means that \displaystyle M_{h}<\Lambda_{\text{UV}}M_{h} on the loop virtualities. This can be achieved for example inserting a momentum scale of order \Lambda on the external states. Following this prescription one would find that the two classes of diagrams mentioned above induce corrections to g_{Tn}^{s} that scale with powers of m/\Lambda and M_{h}/\Lambda , as anticipated around ( 12 ). Alternatively, one can approach the problem adopting a Wilsonian effective action defined at scales \Lambda satisfying M_{h}<\Lambda<\Lambda_{\text{UV}} . In that language our diagrams are mapped into operators with arbitrary pairs of quark fields. For example, the diagrams in Fig. 1 are parametrized respectively by operators with two, four, six external quarks plus quark mass insertions. Diagrams of the second class have more fermionic fields and are commonly known as “dangerous irrelevant operators”. Among them we find for example the following \displaystyle{\cal O}_{\Lambda}=[d_{mn}\overline{q}_{m}P_{R}q_{n}][\overline{q}_{j}P_{L}q_{i}][\overline{q}_{i}i\sigma^{\mu\nu}P_{R}q_{j}]\,F_{\mu\nu}+{\text{hc}}, (13) where [\cdots] denotes contraction of the color and spinor indices. This has a coefficient of order 5 5 5 We will see how these expressions scale at large N_{c} in Section 3 . For now we work at finite N_{c} . \displaystyle C(\Lambda)\sim\frac{g^{4}}{\Lambda^{6}}\left(\frac{g^{2}}{16\pi^{2}}\right)^{n}, (14) for some loop order n . The operator ( 13 ) has the correct quantum numbers to mix with ( 6 ) along the Wilsonian RG evolution down to \Lambda , and hence to contribute to the neutron EDM. Obviously, for \Lambda\gg M_{h} its effect is suppressed by a small loop factor and inverse powers of \Lambda . However, as we approach the hadron scale it might become numerically significant. According to NDA the QCD coupling gets maximally strong at that scale, g^{2}\to 16\pi^{2} , and C({M_{h}})\sim(16\pi^{2})^{2}/M_{h}^{6} becomes of natural size. After chiral symmetry breaking, the condensate \langle\overline{q}_{i}q_{j}\rangle\sim\delta_{ij}M_{h}^{3}/(16\pi^{2}) forms, and the effective action at the hadronic scale includes \displaystyle{\cal L}_{M_{h}}\supset C(M_{h}){\cal O}_{M_{h}} \displaystyle\supset{\cal O}(1)[d_{mn}\delta_{mn}]\,[\overline{q}_{i}i\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma_{5}q_{i}]\,F_{\mu\nu}. (15) Interestingly, the latter describes a flavor-diagonal dipole operator proportional to {\text{Tr}}[d] , which of course contains the strange EDM as well. In the Wilson language we thus find a sizable mixing between the valence and the sea tensors. In the alternative prescription with an IR-momentum flowing in the diagrams, these would correspond to sizable finite threshold effects. Diagrams with additional powers of the order parameter are suppressed by further powers of g^{2}/\Lambda^{3} , but when approaching \Lambda\to M_{h} they should all be re-summed as they are expected to contribute comparably to ( 15 ). In our Wilsonian EFT there are also operators with insertions of both the quark condensate and quark masses. For example, we have some analogous to ( 13 ) with the quark bilinears replaced by powers of m , \displaystyle{\cal L}_{\Lambda}\supset\frac{g^{2}}{\Lambda^{4}}\left(\frac{g^{2}}{16\pi^{2}}\right)^{n^{\prime}}[d_{mn}m^{*}_{mn}][\overline{q}_{j}P_{L}q_{i}][\overline{q}_{i}i\sigma^{\mu\nu}P_{R}q_{j}]\,F_{\mu\nu}+{\text{hc}}, (16) and \displaystyle{\cal L}_{\Lambda}\supset\frac{1}{\Lambda^{2}}\left(\frac{g^{2}}{16\pi^{2}}\right)^{n^{\prime\prime}}[d_{mn}m^{*}_{mn}][m_{ij}][\overline{q}_{i}i\sigma^{\mu\nu}P_{R}q_{j}]\,F_{\mu\nu}+{\text{hc}}. (17) As we approach the hadron scale, and again using NDA, these induce corrections to ( 15 ) of order m/M_{h} and m^{2}/M_{h}^{2} , respectively. There are also operators of lower engineering dimension than shown so far. Performing a one-instanton calculation for example we find, up to an order one factor, \displaystyle{\cal L}_{\Lambda}\supset\frac{1}{\Lambda}e^{-{8\pi^{2}}/{g^{2}}-i\theta}\left(\frac{16\pi^{2}}{g^{2}}\right)^{6}\epsilon_{ii^{\prime}i^{\prime\prime}}\epsilon_{jj^{\prime}j^{\prime\prime}}d^{*}_{i^{\prime}j^{\prime}}{m}^{*}_{i^{\prime\prime}j^{\prime\prime}}\,[\overline{q}_{i}i\sigma^{\mu\nu}P_{R}q_{j}]\,F_{\mu\nu}+{\text{hc}}, (18) where \displaystyle\epsilon_{ii^{\prime}i^{\prime\prime}}\epsilon_{jj^{\prime}j^{\prime\prime}}d^{*}_{i^{\prime}j^{\prime}}{m}^{*}_{i^{\prime\prime}j^{\prime\prime}}=\left(\begin{matrix}d_{d}^{*}m_{s}^{*}+d_{s}^{*}m_{d}^{*}&&\\ &d_{u}^{*}m_{s}^{*}+d_{s}^{*}m_{u}^{*}&-d_{sd}^{*}m_{u}^{*}\\ &-d_{ds}^{*}m_{u}^{*}&d_{u}^{*}m_{d}^{*}+d_{d}^{*}m_{u}^{*}\end{matrix}\right). (19) At around the QCD scale instantons become unreliable and the best we can do is, again, to invoke NDA and replace \exp(-{8\pi^{2}}/{g^{2}})/\Lambda with 1/M_{h} . Effects similar to these are at the origin of [m^{\dagger}]^{-1}{\text{Det}}[m] corrections in chiral perturbation theory (related to the so-called Kaplan-Manohar ambiguity [ 20 ] ). In the present case, the main implication of ( 18 ) would be a mixing between g_{Tn}^{u} and g_{Tn}^{d} , potentially of order m_{s}/M_{h}=20\% . On the other hand, g_{Tn}^{s} would only receive negligible corrections proportional to the light quark masses. To summarize, the diagrams contributing to g_{Tn}^{s} are either proportional to powers of m or the condensate \langle\overline{q}q\rangle , or both, divided by some IR scale \Lambda . It is impossible to reliably calculate their impact at the hadronic scale analytically and so we had to resort to NDA, obtaining essentially a refinement of our earlier guess ( 9 ). But we have reasons to expect that our naive estimates should provide a reasonable order one approximation of the actual result. The Wilson operators proportional to powers of m , as in eqs. ( 16 ), ( 17 ), and ( 18 ), are the progenitors of the counterterms encountered in a chiral expansion in m/M_{h} , derived by matching QCD to a theory of baryons and mesons. They are the counterparts of the genuinely IR contributions, non-analytic in m , arising from chiral loops, i.e. from integrating down to \Lambda\ll M_{h} . The latter are evaluated in Section 5 at first non-trivial order in m/M_{h} , and found to be numerically of the order suggested by NDA. Barring unnatural cancellations, then, the same must be true for the local counterterms, namely for the coefficients of operators like ( 16 )( 18 ) evolved down to \Lambda\sim M_{h} and, reasonably, also for {\cal O}(m^{2}) counterterms like ( 17 ) and the parametrically larger contributions like ( 15 ). Our exercise in chiral perturbation theory (see Section 5 ) can therefore be interpreted as an indirect confirmation of the NDA estimates of this section. 3 Large N_{c} counting The large N_{c} expansion is the only systematically improvable approximation of a continuum non-abelian gauge theory at strong coupling. Since in the real world N_{c}=3 , one may suspect that a perturbative expansion in powers of 1/3 cannot converge fast enough to make concrete predictions. Yet, there is plenty of evidence that large N_{c} techniques provide a qualitatively accurate description in many instances. We hope the same applies to our question. The analysis of baryons at large N_{c} was initiated in [ 21 ] and then subsequently developed by various authors, see in particular [ 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 ] . The crucial difference between the large N_{c} counting for mesons and that of baryons is that the latter are composed of N_{c} quarks, and therefore the multiplicity of diagrams plays a crucial role. Another important difference compared to mesons is that with three light flavors there is some ambiguity in the extrapolation of ordinary baryons to large N_{c} . Specifically, the flavor SU(3)_{V} multiplet of spin J=1/2 has components with strangeness S=0,-1,-2,\cdots,-(N_{c}+1)/2+1,-(N_{c}+1)/2 , where we assumed N_{c} is odd. It is therefore not obvious to which representation the strange baryons in the real world should be associate to since, for example, the \Sigma may be identified with either the component with S=-1 or the one with S=-(N_{c}+1)/2+1 . The strangeness is the same at N_{c}=3 but clearly is not at arbitrary N_{c} , and the predictions of a large N_{c} analysis in those two cases can differ qualitatively. Fortunately, this ambiguity has no implications when analyzing the physics of the nucleons at leading 1/N_{c} order. The leading order predictions are in fact the same as long as we interpret the nucleon as an isospin doublet with strangeness |S|\ll{\cal O}(N_{c}) . To appreciate that, consider first g_{Tn}^{u} . Since our neutron is an isospin doublet with “small to vanishing strangeness”, it must be a state composed of {\cal O}(N_{c}) up and down quarks and a number \ll{\cal O}(N_{c}) of strange quarks. The dipole d_{u} can then be attached at tree level on any of the valence up quarks. As a result we have g_{Tn}^{u}={\cal O}(N_{c}) . Loops do not alter this conclusion. Similar considerations show that g_{Tn}^{d}={\cal O}(N_{c}) . For what concerns g_{Tn}^{s} , instead, tree effects are negligible, or absent altogether if S=0 . We should therefore go back to the loops of Fig. 1 and start, say, by estimating the diagram on the left, where a strange loop is attached to the same valence quark via the gluon lines. The fermion loop brings a suppression {\cal O}(1/N_{c}) , but because there is a number {\cal O}(N_{c}) of lines on which to attach the three gluons the overall result is g_{Tn}^{s}={\cal O}(1) . Consistently, the same conclusion extends to the other kinds of diagrams. For example, for diagrams in which two gluon legs are attached to the same valence quark and the third to another one (see the middle diagram in Fig. 1 ), one can verify that the loop is suppressed by {\cal O}(1/N_{c}^{2}) . Yet, there are {\cal O}(N^{2}_{c}) ways to select the two valence lines on which the gluons are attached. Therefore, the net result is again g_{Tn}^{s}={\cal O}(1) . The same conclusion holds for the last diagram in Fig. 1 , whereas one can show that g_{Tn}^{s}\leq{\cal O}(1) from diagrams with more gluon legs. All in all, large N_{c} considerations lead to g_{Tn}^{u,d}={\cal O}(N_{c}) and g_{Tn}^{s}={\cal O}(1) . We can say more if we postulate that flavor SU(3)_{V} is an accurate symmetry of nature. When framed in that context, the statement that fermionic loops are suppressed becomes (see Eq. ( 29 ) and Eq. ( 54 ) below for a discussion of flavor SU(3)_{V} ) 6 6 6 Analogously to ( 20 ), combining large N_{c} and flavor SU(3)_{V} the quark contributions to the proton spin satisfy g_{A}^{u}+g_{A}^{d}+g_{A}^{s}=0 (see the explicit definition in ( 12 )). The latter relation was approximately satisfied in several experimental analyses of inclusive deep inelastic scattering, where SU(3)_{V} was in fact imposed (see, e.g. [ 26 ] ). \displaystyle g_{Tn}^{u}+g_{Tn}^{d}+g_{Tn}^{s}={\cal O}(1). (20) This relation, when combined with the earlier result g_{Tn}^{s}/g_{Tn}^{u,d}={\cal O}(1/N_{c}) gives \displaystyle\frac{g_{Tn}^{d}}{g_{Tn}^{u}}=-1+{\cal O}(1/N_{c}),~~~~~~~\frac{g_{Tn}^{s}}{g_{Tn}^{u}}={\cal O}(1/N_{c})~~~~~~~(SU(3)_{V}{\text{-Large $N_{c}$}}). (21) Eq. ( 21 ) should be added to the list of estimates collected in Section 2.1 . 7 7 7 A discussion of the tensor charges for the proton at large N_{c} is found in [ 27 ] . Famously, the SU(3)_{V} flavor symmetry is explicitly broken by the quark masses and electromagnetism. The dominant effect is by far due to the strange quark mass and is \sim m_{s}/M_{h} , which is numerically comparable to 1/N_{c} . The latter modifies g_{Tn}^{i} via calculable non-analytic corrections (starting at order m_{s}\ln m_{s} ) as well as incalculable power-law contributions. The leading non-analytic corrections in m_{s}/M_{h} will be carefully analyzed in Section 5 . Here we just mention that the leading order counterterms induce corrections of order \displaystyle\frac{\delta g_{Tn}^{s}}{g_{Tn}^{u}}={\cal O}\left(\frac{1}{N_{c}}\frac{m_{s}}{M_{h}}\right). (22) These considerations represent important consistency checks for any quantitative analysis of the tensor charges. For example, they imply that at large N_{c} all contributions discussed in Section 2.2 are at least of order 1/N_{c} (the one in ( 18 ) is actually down by e^{-{\cal O}(N_{c})} in this limit). We will see that the more quantitative results derived below are indeed consistent with large N_{c} expectations. In the following subsection we will confirm the large N_{c} scaling via the more systematic techniques introduced in [ 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 ] . 3.1 A systematic approach By carrying out a diagrammatic expansion on a reference “baryon ground state”, refs. [ 23 , 24 ] argued that the matrix elements of static baryons can be written as matrix elements of “many-body” interactions involving quarks of definite spin and SU(3)_{V} flavor. 8 8 8 As usual, we can write our results in a SU(3)_{L}\times SU(3)_{R} invariant way introducing the Nambu-Goldstone matrix \xi (see Section 4 ) and replacing d with combinations of \frac{1}{2}\xi^{\dagger}d\xi^{\dagger} everywhere in this section. Concretely, the matrix element of the dipole operator with a static baryon state is written, at all orders in QCD and leading order in d , as \displaystyle d_{BB^{\prime}}=(B^{\prime}|{\cal O}_{3}|B). (23) The object |B)={\cal B}^{i_{1}\alpha_{1}\cdots i_{N_{c}}\alpha_{N_{c}}}\alpha_{i_{1}\alpha_{1}}^{\dagger}\cdots\alpha_{i_{N_{c}}\alpha_{N_{c}}}^{\dagger}|0) denotes a properly normalized baryon state of spin and flavor determined by the wavefunction {\cal B} . Since the color Levi-Civita tensor has been absorbed in {\cal B} , \alpha^{i\alpha}/\alpha_{i\alpha}^{\dagger} are commuting annihilation/creation operators for quarks of spin \alpha=+,- and flavor index i . The quantity {\cal O}_{k} in ( 23 ) is a linear combination of the following (hermitian) operators \displaystyle\left\{dJ_{k}\right\},~~~{\text{Tr}}[d]\,\left\{J_{k}\right\},~~~\left\{d\right\}\left\{J_{k}\right\},~~~\left\{dJ_{k^{\prime}}\right\}\left\{J_{k^{\prime}}\right\}\left\{J_{k}\right\}, (24) multiplied by arbitrary powers of \left\{J_{k^{\prime}}\right\}\left\{J_{k^{\prime}}\right\} , where J_{k}=\sigma_{k} is the spin operator [ 23 , 24 ] . We adopt the notation [ 24 , 25 ] \displaystyle\left\{WJ_{k}\right\}=W^{i}_{j}\alpha_{i\alpha}^{\dagger}[J_{k}]^{\alpha}_{\beta}\alpha^{j\beta}. (25) Structures of the form \left\{\cdots\right\} are referred to as 1 -body operators, and consequently \left\{\cdots\right\}^{n} as n -body. Neglecting the SU(3)_{V} breaking due to the quark masses and electromagnetism, the most important contributions to the baryon EDM are given by \displaystyle{\cal O}_{k} \displaystyle=c_{0}\left\{d_{a}\lambda_{a}J_{k}\right\}+\frac{c_{1}}{N_{c}}\,{\text{Tr}}[d]\left\{J_{k}\right\}+\frac{c_{2}}{N_{c}}\left\{d_{a}\lambda_{a}\right\}\left\{J_{k}\right\}+\frac{c_{3}}{N_{c}^{2}}\left\{d_{a}\lambda_{a}J_{k^{\prime}}\right\}\left\{J_{k^{\prime}}\right\}\left\{J_{k}\right\}+\cdots, (26) where we separated the trace from the traceless parts of the dipole as \displaystyle d=\frac{1}{3}{\text{Tr}}[d]+d_{a}\lambda_{a}, (27) with \lambda_{a} the Gell-Mann matrices. The coefficients c_{0,1,2,3} are of order unity plus corrections proportional to increasing powers of 1/N_{c} . To understand the inverse powers of N_{c} in ( 26 ) one observes that r-body operators have matrix elements scaling at most as N_{c}^{r} (for baryons of any spin). Yet, the energy shift due to an {\cal O}(1) external electric field can be at most of order the baryon mass, namely {\cal O}(N_{c}) . The very hypothesis that an expansion exists therefore indicates the coefficients c_{0,1,\cdots} must satisfy upper bounds, which we assume get saturated in the spirit of NDA. This logic readily explains the size of c_{0,2,3} . The power of 1/N_{c} in front of c_{1} is understood noting that the trace of d can only occur because of a fermionic loop, and the latter are 1/N_{c} -suppressed. We now want to evaluate the matrix element ( 23 ) of ( 26 ) for {\cal B} being the appropriate neutron wavefunction. Conservatively assuming the neutron is associated to a state with vanishing strangeness ( S=0 ), it is easy to see that the neutron corresponds to [ 22 , 23 , 25 ] \displaystyle|n)=C_{n}\alpha_{d+}^{\dagger}(\alpha_{u+}^{\dagger}\alpha_{d-}^{\dagger}-\alpha_{u-}^{\dagger}\alpha_{d+}^{\dagger})^{\frac{N_{c}+1}{2}}|0), (28) with C_{n} a normalization chosen so that (n|n)=1 . Using this definition we find that the matrix element of \left\{\lambda_{a}J\right\} can be of order N_{c} (see Appendix A.1 ). On the other hand, all other contributions in ( 26 ) are at most {\cal O}(1) . Hence, the largest contribution to the matrix element ( 23 ) is from the c_{0} term in ( 26 ). We find (see Appendix A.1 ) \displaystyle\left.d_{n}\right|_{\text{LO}} \displaystyle=c_{0}\,(n|\left\{d_{a}\lambda_{a}J_{3}\right\}|n) (29) \displaystyle=c_{0}\left[\left(-\frac{N_{c}+1}{6}\right)d_{u}+\left(\frac{N_{c}+3}{6}\right)d_{d}+\left(-\frac{1}{3}\right)d_{s}\right]. Each of the three coefficients g_{Tn}^{u,d,s} is also affected by independent {\cal O}(1) corrections due to the operators in ( 26 ). The explicit result ( 29 ) satisfies ( 20 ), as anticipated, and reduces to ( 21 ) for N_{c}\gg 1 . Furthermore, when the effect of the strange quark mass is taken into account, the present framework confirms that additional corrections of the parametric form ( 22 ) arise. For example, a matrix element like that shown in ( 29 ) with d replaced by a product of d and m/M_{h} implies a correction of order \delta g_{Tn}^{s}/g_{Tn}^{u}={\cal O}(\frac{1}{N_{c}}m_{s}/M_{h}) , as it should be. In the real world with N_{c}=3 the {\cal O}(1) corrections neglected in ( 29 ) are likely to be too large to be ignored. Yet, one may be tempted to evaluate ( 29 ) at N_{c}=3 . That would give \displaystyle\frac{g_{Tn}^{d}}{g_{Tn}^{u}}=-\frac{3}{2},~~~~~~~\frac{g_{Tn}^{s}}{g_{Tn}^{u}}=\frac{1}{2}. (30) A compatible result is obtained via a soliton model of baryons (see Appendix A.2 ). In either case, the sizable strange contribution found for N_{c}=3 is probably an overestimate; still, without knowing the relative size of the other coefficients in ( 26 ) nobody can tell by how much. It is worth stressing that in the present language the prediction of a naive NRQM corresponds to evaluating at N_{c}=3 a matrix element analogous to ( 29 ), but with the entire d replacing the traceless d_{a}\lambda_{a} : \displaystyle\left.d_{n}\right|_{\text{NRQM}}=\left.c(n|\left\{dJ_{3}\right\}|n)\right|_{N_{c}=3}=c\left[\left(-\frac{N_{c}-1}{6}\right)d_{u}+\left(\frac{N_{c}+5}{6}\right)d_{d}\right]_{N_{c}=3}. (31) Comparing ( 29 ) to ( 31 ) it becomes apparent that the vanishing of g_{Tn}^{s} in a naive NRQM occurs because of an exact cancellation between the traceless and the trace parts of d . However, there is no underlying symmetry that guarantees the stability of such cancellation, and in fact large N_{c} treats the traceless and trace parts independently, with the latter being subleading. Analogously, d_{a}\lambda_{a} and {\text{Tr}}[d] may appear in different combinations in the discussion of Section 2.2 . Consistently, we will show in the next section that “radiative corrections” within the NRQM tend to split the contributions proportional to the traceless and the trace parts, confirming the expected result g_{Tn}^{s}={\cal O}(1/N_{c}) . 4 Constituent quark model In this section we critically review the predictions of the non-relativistic quark model (NRQM) and validate the claims of Sections 2.2 and 3 . In the NRQM nucleons are described by bound states of weakly-interacting constituent quarks \psi of mass m_{\psi} . This picture provided a surprisingly accurate description of hadronic physics, and it was of course the model that people referred to when the first attempts at estimating the quark dipole contribution to the neutron EDM were made. In this language the normalized wavefunction of a neutron with spin up is given by \displaystyle|n;{\text{NR}}\rangle=\frac{1}{3\sqrt{2}} \displaystyle\left[|ddu\rangle\left(2|\!++\,-\rangle-|\!+-\,+\rangle-|\!-+\,+\rangle\right)\right. (32) \displaystyle+\frac{}{} \displaystyle\left.|dud\rangle\left(2|\!+-\,+\rangle-|\!-+\,+\rangle-|\!++\,-\rangle\right)\right. \displaystyle+\frac{}{} \displaystyle\left.|udd\rangle\left(2|\!-+\,+\rangle-|\!++\,-\rangle-|\!+-\,+\rangle\right)\right], where |ddu\rangle indicates the flavor content and |\!++\,\,-\rangle the spin of the corresponding flavor. Denoting by d_{\psi} the EDM matrix of the constituent quarks, the neutron dipole is formally obtained from the tensor product of an operator in flavor space (the constituent quark dipole d_{\psi} ) and in spin space (the third component of spin). The result is well-known: \displaystyle\left.d_{n}\right|_{\text{NRQM}}=\langle n;{\text{NR}}|d_{\psi}\otimes{\sigma_{3}}|n;{\text{NR}}\rangle=-\frac{1}{3}d_{\psi}^{u}+\frac{4}{3}d_{\psi}^{d}. (33) As already anticipated in the introduction and Section 2.1 , there is no contribution from the constituent strange dipole because the strange is a see quark. The constituent dipoles d_{\psi} are conceptually different from the bare ones d defined in ( 2 ). The precise relation between the two should be determined by matching the constituent quark picture to QCD at the scale M_{h} . In order to investigate the relation between d_{\psi} and d we need to define an unambiguous prescription for the NRQM. The prescription we adopt is the following: the chiral quark model [ 28 ] of Georgi and Manohar is postulated to be the effective field theory description of the constituent quarks; from it the neutron properties are extracted by taking matrix elements of constituent quark operators (renormalized at M_{h} ) with the non-relativistic wavefunction ( 32 ), analogously to ( 33 ). Needless to say, this is just one of the many prescriptions that reproduce the same predictions of the non-relativistic quark model at leading order in some approximation. The arbitrariness in the choice of the model represents an intrinsic systematic uncertainty of the constituent quark approach. In the chiral quark model, quarks have a flavor-singlet constituent mass m_{\psi} , interact weakly with gluons and with light mesons compatibly with the full, non-linearly realized, SU(3)_{L}\times SU(3)_{R} chiral symmetry. The EFT is defined below the chiral symmetry breaking scale \displaystyle M_{\chi}\equiv\frac{4\pi f_{\pi}}{\sqrt{N_{c}}}, (34) which is numerically of order M_{h} , and reads [ 28 ] : \displaystyle{\cal L}_{\text{$\chi$QM}} \displaystyle=-\frac{1}{4}G^{A}_{\mu\nu}G^{A\,\mu\nu}+\overline{\psi}i\gamma^{\mu}\nabla_{\mu}\psi-m_{\psi}\overline{\psi}\psi (35) \displaystyle+\frac{f_{\pi}^{2}}{4}{\text{Tr}}[\partial_{\mu}U\partial^{\mu}U^{\dagger}]+bM_{\chi}f_{\pi}^{2}{\text{Tr}}[{m}U^{\dagger}+{\text{hc}}]+g_{A}\overline{\psi}\gamma^{\mu}\gamma_{5}A_{\mu}\psi \displaystyle+\cdots, with constituent quark fields \psi transforming in the fundamental of color as well as flavor SU(3)_{V} , \nabla_{\mu}\psi=(D_{\mu}+V_{\mu})\psi is the color- and flavor-covariant derivative, and \displaystyle V_{\mu} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2}\left(\xi\partial_{\mu}\xi^{\dagger}+\xi^{\dagger}\partial_{\mu}\xi\right) (36) \displaystyle A_{\mu} \displaystyle=\frac{i}{2}\left(\xi\partial_{\mu}\xi^{\dagger}-\xi^{\dagger}\partial_{\mu}\xi\right). The special unitary pion matrix is \xi=e^{i\Pi} , with \Pi=\Pi_{a}T_{a} and T_{a}=\lambda_{a}/2 the flavor SU(3) generators normalized such that {\text{Tr}}[T_{a}T_{b}]=\delta_{ab}/2 , and as usual U=\xi^{2} . The dots in ( 35 ) indicate higher dimensional operators as well as other insertions of m . The parameters of the EFT ( 35 ) are formally found by matching the EFT to QCD at the scale M_{\chi} . In our notation m denotes the quark mass renormalized at \Lambda_{\text{UV}} appearing in ( 2 ) whereas the parameter b in ( 35 ) is a constant of order unity that includes the RG evolution down to the matching scale. Taking m_{\psi}\sim 360 MeV, g_{A}\sim 0.75 , and a rather weak gauge coupling, g^{2}/(4\pi)\sim 0.3 , the Lagrangian ( 35 ) reproduces the predictions of the non-relativistic quark model as well as many other salient features of hadronic physics [ 28 ] . We are thus justified to expect that the same model provides a rough estimate of the neutron EDM as well. Among the higher dimensional operators included in ( 35 ) there are some that are proportional to the UV coupling d defined in ( 2 ). At leading order in d and zeroth order in the electric charge and {m} , the SU(3)_{L}\times SU(3)_{R} -symmetric operators with the smallest number of derivatives are: \displaystyle{\cal L}_{\text{$\chi$QM}}\supset-\frac{i}{2}\,\overline{\psi}\hat{d}_{\psi}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma_{5}\psi\,F_{\mu\nu}-\frac{1}{2}\,\overline{\psi}\hat{d}_{\psi}^{\prime}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\psi\,F_{\mu\nu}, (37) where \displaystyle[\hat{d}_{\psi}]_{ij}=c_{1}[\hat{d}]_{ij}+c_{2}{\text{Tr}}[\hat{d}]\,\delta_{ij},~~~~~~~[\hat{d}^{\prime}_{\psi}]_{ij}=c^{\prime}_{1}[\hat{d}^{\prime}]_{ij}+c^{\prime}_{2}{\text{Tr}}[\hat{d}^{\prime}]\,\delta_{ij} (38) and \displaystyle\hat{d} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2}\left(\xi^{\dagger}d\xi^{\dagger}+\xi d^{\dagger}\xi\right)=d-\Pi d\Pi-\frac{1}{2}\left(\Pi^{2}d+d\Pi^{2}\right)+\cdots (39) \displaystyle\hat{d}^{\prime} \displaystyle=\frac{i}{2}\left(\xi^{\dagger}d\xi^{\dagger}-\xi d^{\dagger}\xi\right)=\Pi d+d\Pi+\cdots. Similarly to b , the RG evolution of d down to \Lambda\sim M_{\chi} and the result of the matching between ( 2 ) and the chiral quark model is encoded in c_{1},c_{2} and c_{1}^{\prime},c_{2}^{\prime} . From ( 37 ), and setting the pion matrix to its vacuum expectation value \langle\xi\rangle=1 , we readily see that the EDMs of the constituent quarks appearing in ( 33 ) are related to the bare EDMs of ( 2 ) via \displaystyle[d_{\psi}]_{ij}=c_{1}d_{ij}+c_{2}{\text{Tr}}[d]\delta_{ij}. (40) The presence of two coefficients stems from the fact that the traceless and trace parts of d transform as two independent representations of the unbroken SU(3)_{V} , and contribute differently to physical observables, as already emphasized in Section 3 . Following our prescription ( 33 ), and employing the definition ( 1 ), we have \displaystyle g_{Tn}^{u}=-\frac{1}{3}c_{1}+c_{2},~~~~~g_{Tn}^{d}=\frac{4}{3}c_{1}+c_{2},~~~~~g_{Tn}^{s}=c_{2}. (41) In terms of fermions \psi^{\prime}_{L}=\xi\psi_{L} , \psi^{\prime}_{R}=\xi^{\dagger}\psi_{R} transforming under SU(3)_{L}\times SU(3)_{R} as q_{L} , q_{R} in ( 2 ), c_{2} in ( 37 ) is the coefficient of an operator with two insertions of U , which is dual to the chiral condensate. That coefficient therefore arises from matching the chiral quark model to the class of operators ( 13 ) discussed in Section 2.2 . Hence, as anticipated in Section 2.2 , at leading order in the bare quark masses g_{Tn}^{s} is entirely induced by dangerous irrelevant operators like ( 13 ). Of course we cannot reliably calculate c_{1,2} because that would require a non-perturbative calculation, but we can estimate them invoking naturalness arguments as done in [ 28 ] : the size of c_{1,2} should be comparable to, and certainly not much smaller than, the typical radiative corrections derived within the EFT. Let us look at the corrections to c_{2} proportional to c_{1} . Corrections proportional to c_{1} that involve only quark-gluon loops are analogous to those that one would find in ordinary QCD. The dominant effect of that type arises at 3 loops from corrections analogous to that shown in the first diagram of Fig. 1 . Yet, in the chiral quark model that kind of diagrams are calculable because the constituent mass m_{\psi} acts as a natural IR regulator and avoids the problem we encountered in perturbative QCD. In fact, the 3-loop contribution is finite [ 29 , 19 ] . Taking a common constituent mass m_{\psi} , using ref. [ 19 ] we find \displaystyle\left.\delta c_{2}\right|_{\text{gluons}}=c_{1}\frac{5(8\zeta(3)-7)}{72}\left(\frac{g^{2}}{4\pi^{2}}\right)^{3}=c_{1}\,0.18\left(\frac{g^{2}}{4\pi^{2}}\right)^{3}\sim c_{1}\,10^{-4}. (42) Note that this result is numerically consistent with a naive large N_{c} estimate, which for N_{c}=3 reads \delta c_{2}\sim\frac{1}{N_{c}}(g^{2}N_{c}/16\pi^{2})^{3}=0.14(g^{2}/4\pi^{2})^{3} . In principle, ( 42 ) could be sizable if the coupling was strong. However, the g indicated by [ 28 ] is quite small, and so such correction turns out to be very tiny, as shown in the numerical estimate of ( 42 ). Figure 2: 1-loop diagram describing the additive renormalization of c_{2} in the chiral quark model (see ( 38 )). There are also corrections to c_{2} that involve virtual mesons, which are characteristic of the chiral quark model. At 1-loop there is a single diagram that can induce a non-vanishing c_{2} from c_{1}\neq 0 . It is shown in Fig. 2 and has a virtual strange of mass m_{\psi_{s}}=m_{\psi}+{\cal O}(m_{s})\approx 540 MeV 9 9 9 Here we included a formally subleading {\cal O}(m) correction to the constituent mass because it is numerically important. Technically, it is parametrized by a -\overline{\psi}\hat{m}\psi term in ( 35 ), where \hat{m} is a CP-even combination of \xi^{\dagger}m\xi^{\dagger} analogous to the one on the left in ( 39 ) with m replacing d . and a virtual Kaon of mass M_{K}\approx 494 MeV. Its flavor structure \displaystyle(T^{a}d_{\psi}T^{a})_{ij}=\frac{1}{2}{\text{Tr}}[d_{\psi}]\delta_{ij}-\frac{1}{6}[d_{\psi}]_{ij} (43) introduces the desired dependence of d_{\psi} on {\text{Tr}}[d_{\psi}] . The diagram is UV-divergent, and the divergence is cancelled by a local counterterm in ( 37 ). If we assume a sharp cutoff at the maximum scale M_{\chi} , taken for simplicity \gg m_{\psi_{s}},M_{K} , the size of c_{2} would be \displaystyle\left.\delta c_{2}\right|_{\text{NDA}}\sim c_{1}g_{A}^{2}\frac{M_{\chi}^{2}}{16\pi^{2}f_{\pi}^{2}}\sim\frac{c_{1}}{N_{c}}. (44) Recalling ( 41 ) and ( 34 ) we see that the resulting form of g_{Tn}^{s}/g_{Tn}^{u,d} is parametrically consistent with the large N_{c} scaling presented in Section 3 . Yet, one might say Eq. ( 44 ) is an overestimate since it is plausible that the meson dynamics in the chiral quark model is in fact softer than in the more familar chiral Lagrangian. This is because if the effective meson coupling p^{2}/f_{\pi}^{2} could grow up to the maximal value \sim 16\pi^{2}/\sqrt{N_{c}} as in the chiral Lagrangian, then radiative corrections would be significant and our predictions would depart significantly from those of a naive NRQM, which are known to be rather accurate. If ( 35 ) combined with ( 32 ) have to reproduce the successful predictions of the non-relativistic quark model, then the pion loops cannot be too significant. After all, QCD should be better and better approximated by a pure quark-gluon Lagrangian as the momentum scale increases. To mimic this feature we may imagine the loop of Fig. 2 gets saturated at 0 , as well as operators proportional to the CP-violating coupling d . At leading order in the chiral expansion, there are two classes of baryon-octet interactions containing a single insertion of d : \displaystyle{\cal L}_{\text{dip}}= \displaystyle-\frac{i}{2}\left\{\kappa_{1}{\rm Tr}[\hat{d}\overline{\Psi}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma_{5}\Psi]+\kappa_{2}{\rm Tr}[\overline{\Psi}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma_{5}\hat{d}\Psi]+\kappa_{3}{\text{Tr}}[\hat{d}]{\rm Tr}[\overline{\Psi}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma_{5}\Psi]\right\}F_{\mu\nu} (51) \displaystyle-\frac{1}{2}\left\{\kappa_{1}^{\prime}{\rm Tr}[\hat{d}^{\prime}\overline{\Psi}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\Psi]+\kappa_{2}^{\prime}{\rm Tr}[\overline{\Psi}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\hat{d}^{\prime}\Psi]+\kappa_{3}^{\prime}{\text{Tr}}[\hat{d}^{\prime}]{\rm Tr}[\overline{\Psi}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\Psi]\right\}F_{\mu\nu}, with \hat{d} and \hat{d}^{\prime} the same quantities defined in ( 39 ). The couplings \kappa_{1},\kappa_{2},\kappa_{3} parametrize the baryonic EDMs at zeroth order in the chiral expansion. We collect the leading order expression of the EDMs in Appendix B . In particular, the EDM of the neutron reads \displaystyle d^{\text{LO}}_{n}=\kappa_{1}d_{s}+\kappa_{2}d_{d}+\kappa_{3}(d_{u}+d_{d}+d_{s}). (52) To make contact with our earlier notation, we observe that the leading order prediction for the tensor charges in ( 1 ) are \displaystyle g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{u} \displaystyle=\kappa_{3} (53) \displaystyle g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{d} \displaystyle=\kappa_{2}+\kappa_{3} \displaystyle g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{s} \displaystyle=\kappa_{1}+\kappa_{3}. The parameters \kappa_{3} , \kappa_{2}+\kappa_{3} , or \kappa_{1}+\kappa_{3} are all expected to be of order unity according to NDA. Yet, the particular combination \displaystyle g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{u}+g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{d}+g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{s}=\kappa_{1}+\kappa_{2}+3\kappa_{3} (54) is somewhat special since, in the absence of SU(3)_{V} breaking, the condition g_{Tn}^{u}+g_{Tn}^{d}+g_{Tn}^{s}=0 is RG-invariant. The reason is that when such relation holds the trace {\text{Tr}}[d] decouples from ( 51 ), and only the traceless part survives. The RG-stability of the condition {\text{Tr}}[d]=0 is of course not a surprise. In fact, in the large N_{c} expansion, terms proportional to {\text{Tr}}[d] arise from closed fermion loops and must be suppressed, so in the exact N_{c}=\infty limit the condition {\text{Tr}}[d]=0 must be stable, which is what we have just observed. What is remarkable is that in this section we are able to identify the special condition \kappa_{1}+\kappa_{2}+3\kappa_{3}=0 (previously shown in ( 20 )) in an EFT without quarks, just based on basic considerations. In the following we will be agnostic about the relative size of \kappa_{1},\kappa_{2},\kappa_{3} and calculate the chiral corrections to ( 53 ). 5.2 NLO corrections The next to leading order corrections in the chiral expansion are induced by the baryon-octet 1-loop diagrams of Fig. 3 , involving one insertion of {\cal L}_{\text{dip}} and the baryon-meson interactions from {\cal L}_{0} , plus corrections due to virtual heavier baryons. A simple power-counting analysis reveals that at NLO the baryonic dipoles acquire the following form \displaystyle d^{\text{NLO}}_{a^{\prime}b^{\prime}}=d^{\text{LO}}_{a^{\prime}b^{\prime}}+A^{\Pi}_{a^{\prime}b^{\prime}}\frac{M_{\Pi}^{2}}{16\pi^{2}f_{\pi}^{2}}\ln\frac{\mu^{2}}{M_{\Pi}^{2}}+B^{\Pi}_{a^{\prime}b^{\prime}}\frac{M_{\Pi}^{2}}{16\pi^{2}f_{\pi}^{2}}, (55) with a^{\prime},b^{\prime} indices labelling the baryons and in our approximation \Pi=K,\eta . The quantities A^{\Pi}_{a^{\prime}b^{\prime}} are calculated from the diagrams of Fig. 3 with virtual baryon octets and meson octets, and are fully determined in terms of the parameters d , \kappa_{1},\kappa_{2},\kappa_{3} and D,F . On the other hand, loops involving heavier baryons introduce calculable functions of \delta M/M_{K} and \delta M/\mu , which however depend on the unknown dipoles of the heavy baryons and light-heavy transition dipoles. The M_{K} -independent part of these contributions can be re-absorbed in the SU(3)_{V} invariant parameters \kappa_{1,2,3} . The reminder is proportional to M_{K} and is included, along with the unknown counterterms of order {\cal O}(dm) , into B^{\Pi}_{a^{\prime}b^{\prime}} . The latter are of course incalculable within our EFT, but NDA suggests B^{\Pi}_{a^{\prime}b^{\prime}} should be numerically of order unity. Since \ln\mu^{2}/M_{K}^{2} and \ln\mu^{2}/M_{\eta}^{2} for the natural choice \mu\sim M_{n} are of order unity, there are no large-log enhancements in ( 55 ); hence, the fully calculable non-analytic corrections proportional to A^{\Pi}_{a^{\prime}b^{\prime}} contribute comparably to the incalculable counterterms B^{\Pi}_{a^{\prime}b^{\prime}} . For this reason, in the absence of additional phenomenological input one cannot make a numerically accurate prediction of d_{n} . Nevertheless, qualitative conclusions can still be drawn, as we will see. Figure 3: Next to leading order contributions to the baryon dipole moments. Double lines indicate baryons, dashed lines refer to the light mesons and the wavy line to the external electric field. We calculated the diagrams of Fig. 3 employing Dimensional Regularization. Details of the computation are presented in Appendix B . Here we quote only the NLO expression for g_{Tn}^{s} evaluated at \mu=M_{n} (see ( 89 )): \displaystyle g_{Tn,\text{NLO}}^{s} \displaystyle=\frac{M^{2}_{K}}{16\pi^{2}f_{\pi}^{2}}\ln\frac{M_{n}^{2}}{M_{K}^{2}}\left(\frac{1}{2}-\frac{13}{18}D^{2}+\frac{15}{9}DF-\frac{1}{2}F^{2}\right)g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{u} (56) \displaystyle+\frac{M^{2}_{K}}{16\pi^{2}f_{\pi}^{2}}\ln\frac{M_{n}^{2}}{M_{K}^{2}}\left(\frac{1}{2}-\frac{1}{18}(D+3F)^{2}\right)g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{d} \displaystyle+\left\{1+\frac{M_{K}^{2}}{16\pi^{2}f_{\pi}^{2}}\ln\frac{M_{n}^{2}}{M_{K}^{2}}\left(1+\frac{22}{9}D^{2}-\frac{10}{3}DF+4F^{2}\right)\right. \displaystyle\left.~~~+\frac{M_{\eta}^{2}}{16\pi^{2}f_{\pi}^{2}}\ln\frac{M_{n}^{2}}{M_{\eta}^{2}}\left(\frac{2}{3}+\frac{1}{6}(D-3F)^{2}\right)\right\}g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{s} \displaystyle+B_{nn,s}^{K}\frac{M_{K}^{2}}{16\pi^{2}f_{\pi}^{2}}. Importantly, we see that g_{Tn}^{s} mixes at order M_{K}^{2}/\Lambda_{\chi}^{2}=0.2 with g_{Tn}^{u,d} because of loops with a virtual \Sigma baryon and a Kaon. 11 11 11 The relevance of the \Sigma,K loops in the study of the strange chromo-electric dipole was emphasized by [ 9 , 10 ] . One finds analogous sizable corrections to the matrix element of axial currents ( 12 ), see for instance [ 5 ] . Quantitatively, evaluating ( 56 ) numerically with M_{K}=494 MeV, f_{\pi}=92 MeV and the values of D,F extracted at tree-level, we find \displaystyle g_{Tn,\text{NLO}}^{s} \displaystyle=0.14\,g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{u}+0.048\,g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{d}+1.7\,g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{s}+0.18\,B_{nn,s}^{K}. (57) (Using the 1-loop values of D,F only the second entry would be appreciably affected, going from 0.048 to 0.081 .) So, even if for some accident the leading order |g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{s}| term is negligible, the strange tensor charge receives corrections proportional to the valence quark tensor charges of the natural size M_{K}^{2}/\Lambda_{\chi}^{2} . Barring unnatural cancellations we thus conclude that \displaystyle\frac{|g_{Tn}^{s}|}{|g_{Tn}^{u,d}|}\gtrsim 0.1. (58) We interpreted this as a lower bound because in reality we saw in Sections 3 and 4 that g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{s} is typically non-vanishing. Note also that the numerical size of the non-analytic m_{s}\ln m_{s} term in Eq. ( 45 ) is consistent with the one presented in ( 56 ). This proves that the naturalness considerations of Section 4 are sensible. Let us finally comment on the impact of higher order corrections on ( 55 ). We have already mentioned that in the real world a chiral expansion may not be fully trustable because M_{K}^{2}/\Lambda_{\chi}^{2}=0.2 is not very small. What this means in practice is that our approach may suffer from large numerical uncertainties due to higher order corrections. What can our analysis teach us, then? Well, for sure g_{Tn}^{s} is a complicated function of M_{K}/\Lambda_{\chi} , of which we have found just the first few terms in a hypothetical M_{K}/\Lambda_{\chi}\ll 1 limit. And the very fact that in such a limit the strange tensor charge does depend on m_{s} allows us to draw an important robust conclusion, which holds irrespectively of whether M_{K}/\Lambda_{\chi} can or cannot be considered a small parameter: a ratio |g_{Tn}^{s}/g_{Tn}^{u,d}| much smaller than shown in ( 58 ) can only be the result of a m_{s} -dependent cancellation among a priori unrelated quantities, namely the leading order m_{s} -independent value g_{Tn,\text{LO}}^{s} and the chiral corrections. The presence of such a cancellation cannot be excluded by our analysis, but it is fair to say that it would be very surprising. 6 Discussion An accurate determination of how the dipole moments of the light quarks affect the neutron EDM d_{n} is essential to the correct interpretation of the experimental measurements of d_{n} within a beyond the Standard Model hypothesis. 12 12 12 In the Standard Model, the dominant contribution to d_{n} arises from a double insertion of the Fermi interactions dressed by long-range effects. According to NDA we expect it to be of order d_{n}/e\sim J({f_{\pi}}/{v})^{4}/M_{n}\sim 10^{-32}{\text{cm}} , where J\sim 3\times 10^{-5} is the Jarlskog invariant and v\sim 246 the electroweak scale. The contribution arising from quark dipoles is instead chirally suppressed and numerically smaller by roughly a factor 10^{-2} [ 31 , 32 ] . Hence, our results do not impact the Standard Model prediction of d_{n} substantially. We thank T. Cohen for asking this important question. In this paper we approached this interesting question, focusing in particular on the strange quark contribution, see ( 1 ). We approached the problem using perturbative QCD and the large N_{c} expansion (combined with NDA arguments), a concrete modelling of the constituent quark dynamics (combined with naturalness considerations), and finally chiral perturbation theory. While none of these tools can on its own determine the tensor charges precisely, the strength of our assessment resides in the fact that all our predictions turn out to be perfectly consistent with each other, both qualitatively as well as quantitatively. Our main results can be summarized as follows. The strange tensor charge g_{Tn}^{s} is controlled by IR-sensitive diagrams of order 1/N_{c} that contain either insertions of the quark masses or insertions of the quark condensate. At around the GeV such diagrams are unsuppressed and induce a g_{Tn}^{s} of order 0.1\div 0.3 of the tensor charges g_{Tn}^{u,d} of the valence quarks. Despite this mild suppression, and the fact that the sign of g_{Tn}^{s} remains unknown, our results demonstrate that g_{Tn}^{s} is absolutely critical to scenarios beyond the Standard Model, a possibility that is overlooked in most phenomenological studies. Indeed, in many extensions — specifically those in which the quark EDMs are proportional to the mass of the corresponding quark — the dominant contribution to d_{n} is due to the strange quark dipole as soon as |g_{Tn}^{s}/g_{Tn}^{u,d}| is larger than about 0.02\div 0.05 , which is what our results actually indicate. At first, the existence of an unsuppressed g_{Tn}^{s} might seem to contradict the non-relativistic quark model, where the strange is naively expected to be irrelevant, being a sea quark. However, this is not the case. Because in such a picture the dynamical degrees of freedom are constituent quarks, before drawing any robust conclusion about g_{Tn}^{i} one should first establish a mapping between the bare quark dipoles and the constituent quark dipoles. The chiral quark model of Georgi and Manohar represents a simple enough framework in which such a matching can be concretely approached. Consistently with our diagrammatic arguments, in that model g^{s}_{Tn} arises from 1/N_{c} -suppressed contributions proportional to the bare quark masses and the vacuum condensate, and its numerical size is naturally of the order mentioned above. Perhaps the most convincing piece of evidence in support of our claims comes from our calculation in heavy baryon EFT. The part of g_{Tn}^{s} that depends non-analytically on the quark masses can be unambiguously extracted from chiral perturbation theory, at least as long as m_{s}/(4\pi f_{\pi}) can be considered a small parameter. A next-to-leading order analysis reveals that those contributions are of the natural size M_{K}^{2}/(4\pi f_{\pi})^{2} , in agreement with the chiral quark model as well as with NDA and large N_{c} expectations. Barring accidental cancellations among a priori unrelated quantities, this implies that |g_{Tn}^{s}/g_{Tn}^{u,d}| cannot be smaller than 0.1 . While our analysis rests on the assumption that m_{s}/(4\pi f_{\pi}) be a small parameter, the conclusion that g_{Tn}^{s} does depend on m_{s} , and that among the m_{s} -dependent contributions there are some of order 0.1 , are of course robust. As a result we can firmly establish that a hypothetical strange tensor charge much smaller than 0.1 can only be the result of a m_{s} -dependent cancellation, irrespective of whether the chiral expansion in m_{s}/(4\pi f_{\pi}) is accurate or not. The pattern that emerges is qualitatively the same observed for the form factors of the axial vector operator ( 12 ). Even in that case |g_{An}^{s}/g_{An}^{u,d}| is in the 10\% ballpark, as indicated by a multitude of independent data. In fact, virtually all of the results we derived here apply to g_{An}^{i} as well. 13 13 13 With the exception of the comment around ( 12 ), which however does not appear relevant at the scales of interest. In other words, we found no reason for |g_{Tn}^{s}/g_{Tn}^{u,d}| to be “special”. Our results are in conflict with the numerical results of the lattice QCD investigations available at present, which find a strikingly small g_{Tn}^{s} , see ( 11 ). The 1/N_{c} suppression cannot justify the discrepancy, as if large N_{c} was the true answer, then one would also anticipate g_{Tn}^{d}/g_{Tn}^{u}\approx-1 , which instead appears to be badly violated by the measurement quoted in the first relation in ( 11 ). At present the disagreement between ( 11 ) and our results still puzzles us, but we feel we should briefly comment about it. First, we have no reason to doubt the validity of the lattice simulations used in [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] , and we will therefore present our considerations under the assumption that the discretized strange tensor charge is actually negligible. Because ( 11 ) is suggestively close to the prediction of a naive NRQM, maybe this is one of those instances in which the NRQM turns out to describe QCD much better than “it should”. Second, and regardless of that, it is well known that even in the presence of precise measurements of the lattice matrix elements, one is still a long way to an evaluation of the parameters g_{Tn}^{i} that appear in the continuum Lagrangian ( 2 ). The calculations of [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] , for example, are performed at finite lattice spacing a , subsequently matched to a continuum RI-MOM scheme at a scale of order \Lambda , then converted into Dimensional Regularization at that scale, and finally ran up to \Lambda_{\text{UV}}=2 GeV. We would expect this matching to be impacted by the finite threshold effects discussed in Section 2.2 . However, we do not see any trace of the associated diagrams in the references used in [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] . More generally, the extraction of a |g_{Tn}^{s}/g_{Tn}^{u,d}| smaller than 1\% , as in ( 11 ), requires understanding the extrapolation to the continuum with a precision that is at least of the same order and, in our opinion, such an effort cannot escape the evaluation of the diagrams of Section 2.2 at a scale \Lambda numerically close to the GeV, since the matching ideally must be performed within a window M_{h}\ll\Lambda\ll 1/a [ 33 ] . Given that the QCD coupling is inevitably largish at that scale, even 3-loop diagrams mixing the strange and valence quark dipoles turn out to be crucial, especially for g_{Tn}^{s} , which we have argued is dominated by such contributions. Finally, our NLO analysis in heavy baryon EFT firmly establishes that a hypothetical suppression of |g_{Tn}^{s}/g_{Tn}^{u,d}| can only be the result of a m_{s} -dependent cancellation. Hence, a careful analysis of the m_{s} dependence of g_{Tn}^{s} represents a precious consistency check for future numerical investigations. Appendix A More on large N_{c} A.1 One-body matrix elements In this appendix we collect results useful for the analysis of Section 3 , and are a straightforward application of [ 25 ] . We consider the matrix element of 1-body operators of the form \left\{WJ_{k}\right\}=W^{i}_{j}\alpha_{i\alpha}^{\dagger}[\sigma_{k}]^{\alpha}_{\beta}\alpha^{j\beta},~~~~~~~\left\{W\right\}=W^{i}_{j}\alpha_{i\alpha}^{\dagger}\alpha^{j\alpha}, with W hermitian in flavor space. We can write \displaystyle W=\frac{1}{3}{\text{Tr}}[W]{\bf 1}+W_{a}\lambda_{a}. (59) In the text we presented some result for W=d . Our normalized neutron of spin +1/2 is described by ( 28 ), where \alpha_{u\pm/d\pm}^{\dagger} are the creation operators for up/down quarks of spin \pm 1/2 , and |0) is an appropriate vacuum state. The normalization immediately follows from the standard definitions [\alpha^{i\alpha},\alpha^{j\beta}]=0 and [\alpha^{i\alpha},\alpha_{j\beta}^{\dagger}]=\delta^{\alpha}_{\beta}\delta^{i}_{j} . We find \displaystyle(n|n) \displaystyle=C_{n}^{2}\frac{1}{8}(N_{c}+3)(N_{c}+1)\,\Gamma^{2}\left(\frac{N_{c}+1}{2}\right)=1. (60) It is straightforward to see see that \displaystyle(n|\left\{J_{3}\right\}|n) \displaystyle=1 (61) \displaystyle(n|\left\{\lambda_{3}J_{3}\right\}|n) \displaystyle=-\frac{N_{c}+2}{3} \displaystyle(n|\left\{\lambda_{8}J_{3}\right\}|n) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}, and \displaystyle(n|\left\{{\bf 1}\right\}|n) \displaystyle=N_{c} (62) \displaystyle(n|\left\{\lambda_{3}\right\}|n) \displaystyle=-1 \displaystyle(n|\left\{\lambda_{8}\right\}|n) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}N_{c}. With these simple formulas one can recover the expressions presented in Section 3 . A.2 The soliton model At large N_{c} baryons can be viewed as topologically stable solitons of a theory of mesons [ 21 , 34 ] , thus justifying the qualitative success of the approach pioneered by Skyrme [ 35 ] . We will now show that, at leading order in 1/N_{c} , the soliton model makes a very sharp prediction regarding the relative size of the g_{Tn}^{i} ’s. 14 14 14 The soliton model was previously employed in refs. [ 36 , 37 ] to estimate the \bar{\theta} -dependence of d_{n} . However, as far as we know, no analysis of the quark EDMs has ever been performed before (see however [ 27 ] ). Imagine we are able to derive an EFT for the light meson octet by integrating out all hadrons of masses M_{\chi}\gtrsim 4\pi f_{\pi}/\sqrt{N_{c}} . The result is a chiral Lagrangian for the pion field U with an infinite number of derivative interactions and a linearly realized SU(3)_{V} flavor symmetry. In that language baryons are described by space-dependent configurations of the pion matrix, of the form \displaystyle U_{0}({\bf r})=e^{iF(|{\bf r}|)\lambda_{k}\hat{\bf r}_{k}}, (63) where \lambda_{k} are the Gell-Mann matrices associated to isospin SU(2)_{V}\subset SU(3)_{V} (with k=1,2,3 ) and F(|{\bf r}|) is a function found by extremizing the equations of motion and minimizing the energy. The typical size of the soliton is set by the dynamical scale, \sim 1/M_{\chi}={\cal O}(N_{c}^{0}) , whereas its energy is of order 4\pi f_{\pi}^{2}/M_{\chi}={\cal O}(N_{c}) . The background solution ( 63 ) breaks translations, rotations and SU(3)_{V} transformations. Yet, hypercharge and the combined action of ordinary rotations and isospin are conserved. We are interested in properties of baryons at rest, so we can ignore the motion of the center of mass. The seven collective coordinates associated to the remaining symmetry breaking pattern, SU(2)_{J}\times SU(3)_{V}\to SU(2)_{J+V}\times U(1)_{Y} , parametrize the coset SU(3)/U(1) and are described by a time-dependent unitary matrix A=A(t) . The relevant fluctuations around the classical solution ( 63 ) are studied defining \displaystyle U=AU_{0}A^{\dagger}. (64) SU(3)_{V} transformations act as A\to VA , with V\in SU(3)_{V} . Because U_{0}(R{\bf r})=V^{\dagger}_{S}(R)U_{0}({\bf r})V_{S}(R) , with V_{S}(R)=e^{i\lambda_{k}\alpha_{k}}\in SU(2)_{J} , ordinary rotations {\bf r}\to R\,{\bf r} can equivalently be realized as U_{0}({\bf r})\to U_{0}({\bf r}) provided A\to AV^{\dagger}_{S}(R) . Therefore, the combined action of SU(2)_{J}\times SU(3)_{V} is \displaystyle A\to VA\,V^{\dagger}_{S}(R). (65) To quantize the collective coordinates one proceeds as explained in [ 38 ] [ 39 ] [ 40 ] , which generalized to three flavors the approach of [ 34 ] [ 41 ] . The idea is to consider the entire SU(3)_{V} manifold and subject the matrix A to an appropriate constraint that takes into account the redundancy A\to Ae^{i\theta\lambda_{8}} , valid for any time-dependent \theta . All the machinery necessary to our analysis has already been developed by those authors and need not be repeated here. We merely complete the picture by writing down the transformation properties of A under the action of P , CP , and T . Analogously to what done for ordinary rotations (see around ( 65 )), we can define the transformation in such a way that U_{0}({\bf r}) in ( 64 ) remains unchanged. The result is \displaystyle A(t)\xrightarrow{P}A(t),~~~~~~A(t)\xrightarrow{CP}A^{*}(t)\,(i\lambda_{2}),~~~~~~A(t)\xrightarrow{T}A^{*}(-t)\,(i\lambda_{2}). (66) For example, under CP the familiar transformation of the NGB matrix is U(x)\to U^{*}({\cal P}x) . Because U_{0}^{*}(-{\bf r})=U_{0}^{t}({\bf r})=(i\lambda_{2})U_{0}({\bf r})(i\lambda_{2})^{\dagger} , CP can be conveniently taken to act non-trivially only on A . Similar considerations can be made for P and T . The effective Lagrangian for A in the absence of d,\theta must be invariant under P , CP , and T separately. It can be organized as an expansion in time derivatives of A , which must be small because our baryons are very heavy and move very little. On dimensional grounds we expect the time derivatives to appear in the combination \partial_{0}/M_{B} , where M_{B} is the baryon mass. Because M_{B}\propto N_{c} , we see that our expansion in 1/N_{c} translates in this language into an expansion in time derivatives of A . The effect of the couplings d,\theta can be easily taken into account applying the usual rules of effective field theories, treating them as spurions transforming appropriately under flavor SU(3)_{V} as well as P,CP,T . Interestingly, neglecting derivatives of A , and compatibly with SU(3)_{V}\times SU(2)_{J} , there is a unique operator that can describe a spin 1/2 baryon EDM: \displaystyle{\bf d}_{B}=c\,{\text{Tr}}[A^{\dagger}dA\lambda_{3}], (67) with c={\cal O}(N_{c}) a numerical factor. The presence of a unique operator is to be compared with considerations based solely on SU(3)_{V} , that allow 3 independent parameters (see Section 5 ). The expression ( 67 ) is completely general and does not rely on any specific form of the meson EFT. Yet, just to be concrete we mention that the mesonic operator with the lowest number of derivatives and the correct quantum numbers to contribute to the P , CP , T -violating hamiltonian {\cal H}_{d}=-{\cal L}_{d} is \displaystyle-\Delta{\cal L}_{d} \displaystyle=c^{\prime}\left({\text{Tr}}[dU^{\dagger}D_{\mu}UD_{\nu}U^{\dagger}]-{\text{Tr}}[d^{\dagger}UD_{\nu}U^{\dagger}D_{\mu}U]\right)i\widetilde{F}^{\mu\nu}, (68) with c^{\prime}\sim f_{\pi}^{2}/M_{\chi} by naive dimensional analysis. Evaluating H_{d}=\int d{\bf r}\,{\cal H}_{d} with U as in ( 64 ) and an electric field E_{\text{el}} along the 3-direction, one finds \Delta H_{d}=-\Delta c\,{\text{Tr}}[A^{\dagger}dA\lambda_{3}]E_{\text{el}} , with \displaystyle\Delta c \displaystyle=c^{\prime}\int{\text{d}}{\bf r}~\frac{4}{3}\sin(F)\left(\frac{2F^{\prime}}{r}+\frac{\sin(F)\cos(F)}{r^{2}}\right). (69) Since the relevant length scale of the soliton is 1/M_{\chi} , a momentum expansion is not meaningful here. Hence ( 68 ) is just one of the many contributions to c . The NDA guess c\sim 4\pi c^{\prime}/M_{\chi}\sim 4\pi f_{\pi}^{2}/M_{\chi}^{2}\sim N_{c}/(4\pi) is nevertheless expected to represent a reasonable estimate. 15 15 15 In a large N_{c} expansion the tree exchange of \eta^{\prime} may result in contributions to the light mesons Lagrangian that at momenta p^{2}