A parametric tensor ROM for the shallow water dam break problem Md Rezwan Bin Mizan, Maxim Olshanskii, Ilya Timofeyev Abstract We develop a variant of a tensor reduced-order model (tROM) for the parameterized shallow-water dam-break problem. This hyperbolic system presents multiple challenges for model reduction, including a slow decay of the Kolmogorov N N -width of the solution manifold, shock formation, and the loss of smooth solution dependence on parameters. These issues limit the performance of traditional Proper Orthogonal Decomposition based ROMs. Our tROM approach, based on a low-rank tensor decomposition, builds a parameter-to-solution map from high-fidelity snapshots and constructs localized reduced bases via a local POD procedure. We apply this method to both dry-bed and wet-bed problem setups, showing that the non-interpolatory variant of the tROM, combined with Chebyshev sampling near critical parameter values, effectively captures parameter-dependent behavior and significantly outperforms standard POD-ROMs. This is especially evident in the wet-bed case, where POD-ROMs exhibit poor resolution of shock waves and spurious oscillations. 1 Introduction The development of accurate and efficient Reduced-Order Models (ROMs) that capture parametric variations in numerical simulations of time-dependent partial differential equations (PDEs) remains a major challenge in scientific computing. This task is typically problem-dependent and often necessitates adaptations of established techniques. The challenge becomes particularly acute when the parameter vector is high-dimensional. Among the most prominent approaches are traditional Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD)-based ROMs, which have seen many successful applications [ 3 ] . However, the efficiency of many traditional ROMs is theoretically constrained by the decay rate of the Kolmogorov N -width of the solution manifold for the parametric problem of interest. The Kolmogorov N -width quantifies how well a manifold can be approximated by an N -dimensional linear subspace. While sharp estimates of the Kolmogorov N -width are rare [ 19 , 14 ] , its equivalence to the best N -term approximation in greedy POD [ 5 ] suggests exponential or algebraic decay for parabolic and elliptic problems with sufficiently smooth parametric dependence; see, e.g., [ 10 , 6 , 9 , 13 , 2 ] . In contrast, hyperbolic problems often exhibit much slower decay rates. For example, for linear problems with discontinuous initial data, the authors in [ 21 , 12 ] observed a decay rate of O(N^{-1/2}) . This slower decay implies that a relatively high-dimensional subspace is required for accurate solution approximation. This partially explains why POD-based ROMs for hyperbolic problems are comparatively less developed; see, however, [ 26 , 11 , 1 , 7 ] . The situation becomes even more complex for nonlinear hyperbolic problems due to the formation of shocks, which require accurate tracking. The Shallow Water Equations (SWE), addressed in this study, provide a classical example of such a problem. To overcome the limitations of linear reduction techniques, machine learning (ML) methods have been employed to construct ROMs for hyperbolic systems; see, e.g., [ 11 , 1 , 7 ] . ML-based reduced models for the SWE include [ 25 , 4 , 24 ] . However, ML approaches have their own limitations, particularly the lack of a mature theoretical foundation. A more mathematically grounded alternative is the tensor ROM (tROM) approach [ 16 , 17 , 22 ] , developed recently to address the limitations of POD-based ROMs for parametric PDEs. This method is especially well-suited to time-dependent PDEs with high-dimensional parameter spaces [ 16 ] . The tROM is a projection-based method that performs high-fidelity simulations across different parameter values to construct an (N+D) -dimensional “snapshot” tensor in a low-rank tensor format, where N is the physical dimension and D is the number of parameters. This tensor represents a discrete approximation of the parameter-to-solution map. By operating directly on these low-rank structures, one can compute a parameter-dependent reduced basis for any new parameter value. Further details are given in Section 2.2.1 . In this work, we employ a Low-Rank Tensor Decomposition (LRTD) in the Tucker format to build a tROM and distinguish between interpolatory and non-interpolatory variants. For interpolatory tROMs, a local reduced basis is computed via low-rank interpolation of the parameter-to-solution map. In the non-interpolatory case, interpolation is replaced by a local POD procedure. As we shall demonstrate, the non-interpolatory tROM performs better. We apply the tensor ROM approach to a hyperbolic problem – specifically, the one-dimensional SWE dam-break problem with both dry-bed and wet-bed initial conditions. The initial conditions are characterized by the parameters (h_{\!L},h_{\!R}) , representing the water heights to the left and right of the dam, respectively. Hence, the parameter space has dimension D=2 . The dry-bed case ( h_{\!R}=0 ) leads to a relatively simple solution involving a rarefaction wave. In contrast, the wet-bed case ( h_{\!R}>0 ) is more challenging due to the formation of a shock wave downstream of the dam. For this case, the shock persists for all times t>0 , and the derivative of the solution with respect to h_{\!R} near the shock becomes unbounded as h_{\!R}\to 0 . This makes the construction of projection-based ROMs particularly difficult, as the quality of approximation hinges on the regularity of the parameter-to-solution map [ 18 ] . Thus, even though the physical and parameter dimensions of the problem are low, the hyperbolic nature of the problem, shock formation and the lack of regularity near h_{\!R}=0 poses a significant challenge for ROM development . We demonstrate that the non-interpolatory tROM, combined with Chebyshev sampling in the wet-bed parameter direction, is an effective strategy. Although the resulting local reduced spaces have higher dimensions than those typically required for parabolic or elliptic problems, this is consistent with the known slow decay of the Kolmogorov N -width in hyperbolic settings. We also show that this method significantly outperforms standard POD-ROMs, especially in the wet-bed case, where POD-ROMs struggle to resolve shock waves and tend to generate spurious high-frequency oscillations. The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we present the governing equations, describe the projection-based ROM approach, and provide an overview of tROM and POD-ROM techniques. For further details on tROMs, we refer the reader to [ 16 , 17 ] . Section 3 presents numerical results for both dry-bed and wet-bed cases, including an analysis of local basis generation thresholds, variation in parameter h_{\!R} , and a performance comparison between interpolatory and non-interpolatory tROMs as well as between POD-ROM and tROM. Finally, in Appendix A , we discuss the solution regularity of the wet-bed dam-break problem near the dry-bed limit. 2 Methods and Setup In this section, we briefly describe the shallow-water equations and the formalism for developing Reduced-Order Models. In particular, we outline the standard POD-ROM approach and discuss a tensor ROM. 2.1 Problem Formulation We consider the one-dimensional (1D) shallow water equations (SWEs) to model the dam-break problem, a classical benchmark for hyperbolic conservation laws. The dam-break scenario involves a sudden release of water, generating shock and rarefaction waves, making it an ideal test case for numerical methods and reduced-order modeling of hyperbolic systems. Governing Equations. In conservative form, without source terms, the 1D SWEs are expressed as: \partial_{t}\mathbf{U}+\partial_{x}\mathbf{F}=\mathbf{0}, (1) with \mathbf{U}=\begin{bmatrix}h\\ q\end{bmatrix},\qquad\mathbf{F}=\begin{bmatrix}q\\[2.0pt] q^{2}/h+\frac{1}{2}\,g\,h^{2}\end{bmatrix}, where h(x,t) is the water depth, q(x,t)=h\,u the discharge, u(x,t) the depth-averaged velocity, and g gravity. Full-order model. Full-order model (FOM) solutions to equation ( 1 ) are computed using a standard finite volume discretization outlined below. In time we apply s second-order accurate explicit Heun (RK-2) scheme, while spatial fluxes use the local Lax–Friedrichs (LLF) formula \mathbf{F}_{i+\frac{1}{2}}=\frac{1}{2}\!\bigl[\mathbf{F}(\mathbf{U}_{i})+\mathbf{F}(\mathbf{U}_{i+1})\bigr]-\frac{\lambda_{i+\frac{1}{2}}}{2}\bigl(\mathbf{U}_{i+1}-\mathbf{U}_{i}\bigr), (2) with maximum wave speed \lambda_{i+\frac{1}{2}}=\max\bigl(|u_{i}|+c_{i},\;|u_{i+1}|+c_{i+1}\bigr),\;c_{i}=\sqrt{g\,h_{i}}. A constant time step \Delta t is chosen such that the CFL condition \max_{i}\lambda_{i+\frac{1}{2}}\,\Delta t/\Delta x<1 holds; simulations advance to a prescribed final time T . The computational domain is [0,L_{x}] , with L_{x}-100 , discretized using a uniform grid with N_{x} interior points plus two ghost points (one at each end). The spatial step size is \Delta x=L_{x}/N_{x} , with interior points at x_{i}=i\Delta x\;(i=1,\dots,N_{x}) , and ghost points at x_{0}=-\Delta x/2,\;x_{N_{x}+1}=L_{x}+\Delta x/2 . Parametrized initial conditions. Placing a depth discontinuity at x_{\text{dam}}=L_{x}/2 gives h(x,0)=\begin{cases}h_{\!L},&xh_{\!R}\geq 0 . These depths form the parameter vector \boldsymbol{\mu}=(h_{\!L},h_{\!R})\in\mathcal{P}\subset\mathbb{R}^{2} . Our parameter domain is a box \mathcal{P}=[h_{\!L}^{\min},h_{\!L}^{\max}]\times[h_{\!R}^{\min},h_{\!R}^{\max}] . The setups with h_{\!R}=0 and h_{\!R}>0 are known as the dry-bed and wet-bed dam break problem, respectively. Boundary conditions. We impose outflow boundary conditions by copying the nearest interior state to each ghost cell, equivalent to \partial_{x}h=\partial_{x}q=0 at x=0,L_{x} . Parameters sampling. Snapshots are collected on a two-parameter grid. The dam depths are sampled uniformly: h_{\!L}^{i}=h_{\!L}^{\min}+\frac{(h_{\!L}^{\max}-h_{\!L}^{\min})(i-1)}{N_{L}-1},\qquad i=1,\dots,N_{L}, (4) while for the downstream bed depths we use N_{R} uniformly distributed or Chebyshev nodes: h_{\!R}^{j}=\frac{1}{2}\!\Bigl[\bigl(h_{\!R}^{\min}+2h_{\!R}^{\max}\bigr)-\bigl(2h_{\!R}^{\max}-h_{\!R}^{\min}\bigr)\cos\!\Bigl(\tfrac{\pi j}{2(N_{R}-1)}\Bigr)\Bigr],\qquad j=1,\dots,N_{R}-1. (5) For every (h_{\!L},h_{\!R}) pair we store snapshots of h and q at all N_{x} interior cells at regular time intervals. We use (h_{\!L}^{\min},h_{\!L}^{\max})=(10,28) and (h_{\!R}^{\min},h_{\!R}^{\max})=(0,8) in this paper, which is significantly larger comparing to other studies of the parametrized dam-break problem known from the literature [ 8 , 15 , 20 , 23 , 26 , 27 ] . 2.2 Reduced-Order Modeling Reduced-order modeling constructs low-dimensional approximations of high-dimensional systems to enable efficient simulations while preserving the dominant dynamics of the full-order model. For the 1D dam-break problem governed by the SWEs, the ROMs facilitate rapid exploration of parametric variations in initial conditions, such as left and right water heights, denoted by the parameter vector \boldsymbol{\mu}=(h_{\!L},h_{\!R}) . This section outlines the principles of ROM, introduces tROM using the LRTD with Tucker format, and details the interpolatory and non-interpolatory tROM approaches employed. Additionally, the POD ROM is discussed for comparison, and implementation details highlight the offline-online strategy that enhances computational efficiency. A projection ROM approximates the discrete solutions h^{n},q^{n}\in\mathbb{R}^{N_{x}} at each time level by h^{n}\;\approx\;V_{h}^{\ell_{h}}(\boldsymbol{\mu})\,\boldsymbol{\alpha}_{h}^{n},\qquad q^{n}\;\approx\;V_{q}^{\ell_{q}}(\boldsymbol{\mu})\,\boldsymbol{\alpha}_{q}^{n}, (6) where V_{h}^{\ell_{h}}(\boldsymbol{\mu})\in\mathbb{R}^{N_{x}\times\ell_{h}},V_{q}^{\ell_{q}}(\boldsymbol{\mu})\in\mathbb{R}^{N_{x}\times\ell_{q}} are orthonormal bases in \ell_{h} -dimensional and \ell_{q} -dimensional ROM spaces, respectively, possibly dependent on \boldsymbol{\mu} where \ell_{h}\ll N_{x} and \ell_{q}\ll N_{x} . The coefficients \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{h}^{n}\in\mathbb{R}^{\ell_{h}} and \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{q}^{n}\in\mathbb{R}^{\ell_{q}} evolve in time. Galerkin projection of the FOM onto these subspaces is given by \displaystyle(V_{h}^{\ell_{h}})^{T}\Bigl(\frac{h^{\,n+1}-h^{\,n}}{\Delta t}+\frac{1}{\Delta x}\bigl(\mathbf{F}_{h,i+\frac{1}{2}}^{\,n}-\mathbf{F}_{h,i-\frac{1}{2}}^{\,n}\bigr)\Bigr) \displaystyle=\mathbf{0}, (7) \displaystyle(V_{q}^{\ell_{q}})^{T}\Bigl(\frac{q^{\,n+1}-q^{\,n}}{\Delta t}+\frac{1}{\Delta x}\bigl(\mathbf{F}_{q,i+\frac{1}{2}}^{\,n}-\mathbf{F}_{q,i-\frac{1}{2}}^{\,n}\bigr)\Bigr) \displaystyle=\mathbf{0}, where \mathbf{F}_{h,i+\frac{1}{2}}^{\,n} and \mathbf{F}_{q,i+\frac{1}{2}}^{\,n} are the interface fluxes evaluated midway through the RK-2 step. Initial conditions are also needs to be projected, \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{h}^{0}=(V_{h}^{\ell_{h}})^{T}h^{0},\;\boldsymbol{\alpha}_{q}^{0}=(V_{q}^{\ell_{q}})^{T}q^{0}. The core challenge lies in constructing parameter-specific subspaces V_{h}^{\ell_{h}}(\boldsymbol{\mu}) and V_{q}^{\ell_{q}}(\boldsymbol{\mu}) . The tROM exploits the space–time–parameter structure of snapshot data, offering superior adaptability compared to the global POD bases. 2.2.1 Tensor ROM Tensor ROM enhances projection-based ROM by organizing snapshot data into a higher-order tensor, preserving the intrinsic structure across spatial, temporal, and parametric dimensions. Unlike classical POD, which flattens snapshots into a matrix, tROM employs LRTD to compress data and generate parameter-adaptive bases, making it well-suited for problems with a parametric variability, such as the dam-break problem with its shock fronts. In tROM, the goal is to approximate solutions in low-dimensional subspaces V_{h}^{\ell_{h}}(\boldsymbol{\mu}),V_{q}^{\ell_{q}}(\boldsymbol{\mu})\subset\mathbb{R}^{N_{x}} , where \ell_{h},\ell_{q}\ll N_{x} , tailored to a parameter \boldsymbol{\mu}\in\mathcal{D} . The snapshot set, comprising FOM solutions \{h(\mathbf{x},t_{n};\boldsymbol{\mu}_{k}),q(\mathbf{x},t_{n};\boldsymbol{\mu}_{k})\}_{n,k} for time steps t_{n} and parameter samples \boldsymbol{\mu}_{k}\in\mathcal{D} , is organized into 4-D tensors \mathcal{Q}_{h},\mathcal{Q}_{q}\in\mathbb{R}^{N_{x}\times N_{\mu_{1}}\times N_{\mu_{2}}\times N_{T}} , where N_{\mu_{1}},N_{\mu_{2}} are the number of samples for h_{\!L} and h_{\!R} , and N_{T} is the number of temporal snapshots. LRTD We adopt the Tucker decomposition, a multilinear LRTD method, to approximate the snapshot tensors. For the water-depth tensor, the approximation is \mathcal{Q}_{h}\approx\widetilde{\mathcal{Q}}_{h}=\mathcal{G}_{h}\times_{1}\mathbf{W}_{h}\times_{2}\boldsymbol{\Sigma}_{h}^{(1)}\times_{3}\boldsymbol{\Sigma}_{h}^{(2)}\times_{4}\mathbf{V}_{h}, (8) where \mathcal{G}_{h}\in\mathbb{R}^{\tilde{N}_{x}\times\tilde{N}_{\mu_{1}}\times\tilde{N}_{\mu_{2}}\times\tilde{N}_{T}} is the core tensor, \mathbf{W}_{h}\in\mathbb{R}^{N_{x}\times\tilde{N}_{x}} , \boldsymbol{\Sigma}_{h}^{(1)}\in\mathbb{R}^{N_{\mu_{1}}\times\tilde{N}_{\mu_{1}}} , \boldsymbol{\Sigma}_{h}^{(2)}\in\mathbb{R}^{N_{\mu_{2}}\times\tilde{N}_{\mu_{2}}} , and \mathbf{V}_{h}\in\mathbb{R}^{N_{T}\times\tilde{N}_{T}} are orthogonal factor matrices; \tilde{N}_{x},\tilde{N}_{\mu_{1}},\tilde{N}_{\mu_{2}},\tilde{N}_{T} are reduced ranks ( \tilde{N}_{x}\ll N_{x} ). The operator \times_{m} denotes mode- m tensor–matrix multiplication. The approximation error is controlled by a tolerance \epsilon_{h} : \|\mathcal{Q}_{h}-\widetilde{\mathcal{Q}}_{h}\|_{F}\leq\epsilon_{h}\,\|\mathcal{Q}_{h}\|_{F}. (9) The columns of the spatial factor matrix \mathbf{W}_{h} spans a universal subspace: V_{\text{univ},h}=\spann\{\,\mathbf{W}_{h}[:,m]\,\}_{m=1}^{\tilde{N}_{x}}\subset\mathbb{R}^{N_{x}}, (10) representing information given be all collected snapshots up to the LRTD error. The parameter factor matrices \boldsymbol{\Sigma}_{h}^{(1)},\boldsymbol{\Sigma}_{h}^{(2)} encode parametric dependencies, enabling the construction of local bases for unseen parameters. 2.2.2 Interpolatory tROM The interpolatory tROM [ 16 , 17 ] generates parameter-specific bases by interpolating the parameter factor matrices. For an parameter \boldsymbol{\mu}^{*}=(h_{\!L}^{*},h_{\!R}^{*}) , not necessarily from a sampling set, the online phase constructs interpolation vectors using Lagrange interpolation of order p : \chi_{p,L}(h_{\!L}^{*})_{k}=\begin{cases}\displaystyle\prod_{\begin{subarray}{c}m=1\\ m\neq k\end{subarray}}^{p}\frac{h_{\!L}^{(i_{m})}-h_{\!L}^{*}}{h_{\!L}^{(i_{m})}-h_{\!L}^{(k)}}&\text{if }k=i_{k}\in\{i_{1},\ldots,i_{p}\},\\[6.0pt] 0&\text{otherwise},\end{cases} (11) and similarly for \chi_{p,R}(h_{\!R}^{*}) , selecting the p closest sampled parameters h_{\!L}^{(i_{m})},h_{\!R}^{(i_{m})} . The local core matrix is formed by contracting the core tensor: \mathcal{C}_{h}(\boldsymbol{\mu}^{*})\;=\;\mathcal{G}_{h}\times_{2}\chi_{p,L}(h_{\!L}^{*})\times_{3}\chi_{p,R}(h_{\!R}^{*})\in\mathbb{R}^{\tilde{N}_{x}\times\tilde{N}_{T}}, (12) followed by an SVD: \mathcal{C}_{h}(\boldsymbol{\mu}^{*})=\widehat{U}_{h}\boldsymbol{\Sigma}_{h}\widehat{V}_{h}^{\!T} . The local basis is then given by V_{h}^{\ell_{h}}(\boldsymbol{\mu}^{*})=\mathbf{W}_{h}\,\widehat{U}_{h}[:,\,1:\ell_{h}]\subset V_{\text{univ},h}, (13) where \ell_{h} is chosen based on a local energy threshold \epsilon_{\text{loc}} . The process is analogous for V_{q}^{\ell_{q}}(\boldsymbol{\mu}^{*}) . 2.2.3 Non-Interpolatory tROM The non-interpolatory tROM [ 22 ] constructs local bases by combining snapshot data from several nearest parameter grid points (four points are taken in our implementation), avoiding interpolation to enhance accuracy for discontinuous solutions. For \boldsymbol{\mu}^{*} , the method identifies bracketing indices such that h_{\!L}^{(k_{\text{low}})}\leq h_{\!L}^{*}x_{r},\end{cases} (19) where \delta=(x-x_{\text{dam}})/t . This solution reflects a rarefaction wave expanding into the dry region, with the water depth decreasing smoothly from h_{\!L} to 0 across the wave. Wet-Bed Case ( h_{\!R}>0 ) For the wet-bed case, where h_{\!R}>0 , the solution involves a rarefaction wave on the left, a constant middle state (h_{m},u_{m}) , and a shock wave on the right. The middle state and shock speed s are determined by solving a system of equations using the Riemann invariant across the left rarefaction wave and the Rankine–Hugoniot conditions. The middle state (h_{m},u_{m}) and shock speed s satisfy the nonlinear equation u_{m}+2\sqrt{gh_{m}}-2\sqrt{gh_{\!L}}=0, (20) where u_{m}=s-\frac{gh_{\!R}}{4s}\left(\sqrt{1+\frac{8s^{2}}{gh_{\!R}}}+1\right),\qquad h_{m}=\frac{h_{\!R}}{2}\left(\sqrt{1+\frac{8s^{2}}{gh_{\!R}}}-1\right). (21) The s solving the above equation can be computed numerically using, for instance, Newton’s method. Newton’s iteration starts with an initial guess s=\sqrt{gh_{\!L}} and iteratively updates s until convergence. Given the middle state, the solution at time t and position x is determined by the positions of the rarefaction on wave and shock. The the gravity wave speed c , \delta , and the tail if the wave x_{1}=x_{\ell} are the same as in the dry case. Let c_{m}=\sqrt{gh_{m}} , x_{2}=x_{\text{dam}}+(u_{m}-c_{m})t , and x_{3}=x_{\text{dam}}+st . The analytical solution for the wet case is then given by \left[u(x,t),\,h(x,t)\right]=\begin{cases}\left[0,\,h_{\!L}\right]&\text{if }x\leq x_{1},\\ \left[\dfrac{2}{3}\left(c+\delta\right),\,\dfrac{4}{9g}\left(c-\dfrac{\delta}{2}\right)^{2}\right]&\text{if }x_{1}x_{3}.\end{cases} (22) This solution captures the rarefaction wave, the constant middle state, and the shock wave propagating to the right. Convergence and regularity for h_{\!R}\to 0 We are now interested in the behavior of the wet-bed solution when h_{\!R}\to 0 . It is easy to see from the second equation in ( 21 ) that h_{m}\sim\sqrt{h_{\!R}}\to 0 . Then from ( 20 ) we obtain u_{m}\to 2\sqrt{gh_{\!L}}=2c also with the speed O(\sqrt{h_{\!R}}) . On the other hand, from the first equation in ( 21 ), u_{m}\to s . Therefore, (h_{m},u_{m},s)\to(0,2c,2c) as h_{\!R}\to 0 . We also have x_{3}\to x_{r} and x_{2}\to x_{r} as h_{\!R}\to 0 . Therefore, the solution of the wet-bed converges in L^{\infty}(0,L) to the solution of the dry-bed as h_{\!R}\to 0 uniformly in time t\in[0,T] if x_{\text{dam}}+2cT0 because the shock appears immediately, since x_{3}-x_{2}>0 for any t>0 . This is evident since s-u_{m}>0 for any h_{\!R}>0 (the first equation in ( 21 )) and c_{m} is also strictly positive for h_{\!R}>0 . Thus, although there is convergence in L^{\infty}(0,L) , the wet-bed solutions fail to converge to the dry-bed solution in H^{1}(0,L) norm for h_{\!R}\to 0 and any fixed t>0 . We are also interested in the regularity of the wet-bed case solution with respect the h_{\!R} parameter in the proximity of h_{\!R}=0 . First note that s\to c>0 as h_{\!R}\to 0 and so the propagation speed of the shock is uniformly bounded away from zero. For x\in(x_{2},x_{3}) the water depth is given by h=h_{m} and from ( 21 ) we obtain \partial h/\partial h_{\!R}\sim O(h_{\!R}^{-\frac{1}{2}}) on (x_{2},x_{3}) for small h_{\!R} . The interval length is x_{3}-x_{2}=(s-u_{m}+c_{m})t\sim O(h_{\!R}^{1/4})t , since s-u_{m}\geq 0 , c_{m}=\sqrt{gh_{m}} and h_{m}\sim O(h_{\!R}^{\frac{1}{2}}) . We conclude that the derivative of \partial h(x,t)/\partial h_{\!R} is unbounded on (0,L) when h_{\!R}\to 0 and for any t>0 . More generally, straightforward calculations show that the L^{p}(0,L) norm of \partial h/\partial h_{\!R} has O(h_{\!R}^{\frac{1}{4p}-\frac{1}{2}}) asymptotic for h_{\!R}\to 0 . Furthermore, similar calculations shows the same asymptotics for \partial u(x,t)/\partial h_{\!R} and for \partial q(x,t)/\partial h_{\!R} in the neighborhood of the dry-bed case.