Lemon limbs of the cubic connectedness locus Carsten Lunde Petersen and Saeed Zakeri Abstract . We describe a limb structure in the connectedness locus of complex cubic polynomials, where the limbs are indexed by the periodic points of the doubling map t ↦ 2 ​ t ​ ( mod ⁡ ℤ ) t\mapsto 2t\ (\operatorname{mod}{\mathbb{Z}}) . The main renormalization locus in each limb is parametrized by the product of a pair of (punctured) Mandelbrot sets. This parametrization is the inverse of the straightening map and can be thought of as a tuning operation that manufactures a unique cubic of a given combinatorics from a pair of quadratic hybrid classes. Our results build a new understanding of the structure of the cubic connectedness locus and its hyperbolic components. 1. A bird’s-eye view In this paper we define and investigate a limb structure in the connectedness locus of complex cubic polynomials that is inspired by the well-known case of the Mandelbrot set \mathcal{M} described by Douady and Hubbard (see [ DH1 ] and [ M3 ] ). In their description \mathcal{M} is essentially partitioned into a main hyperbolic component—the “main cardioid”—and a countable collection of disjoint limbs attached to it. These limbs are uniquely indexed by the non-trivial rotation cycles of the doubling map \mathbf{m}_{2}:t\mapsto 2t\ (\operatorname{mod}{\mathbb{Z}}) or, equivalently, by their non-zero rotation numbers. A parameter c\in\mathcal{M} belongs to the limb associated with a given rotation cycle precisely when the dynamic rays of the quadratic polynomial Q_{c}:z\mapsto z^{2}+c with angles in that rotation cycle co-land at a fixed point. This description allowed for a divide-and-conquer strategy for understanding the structure of \mathcal{M} . For example, it was the starting point of Yoccoz’s celebrated work on the problem of local connectivity of the Mandelbrot set. For cubic maps the situation is far more complicated. Consider the family \mathcal{P}(3)\cong\mathbb{C}^{2} of complex cubic polynomials in the normal form P_{a,b}:z\mapsto z^{3}+3az^{2}+b , with a,b\in\mathbb{C} , and its connectedness locus \mathcal{C}(3) , the cubic analogue of the Mandelbrot set. Branner and Hubbard [ BH ] showed that \mathcal{C}(3) is compact and cellular, hence connected. But soon after Lavaurs [ La ] proved that \mathcal{C}(3) is not locally connected and therefore its topology must be quite intricate. Up until now, there seems to have been no attempt at understanding \mathcal{C}(3) through a suitable notion of limbs or open wakes that should contain limbs except for their root points (compare the recent paper [ BOTW ] which constructs a locally connected combinatorial model of \mathcal{C}(3) analogous to Thurston’s model of \mathcal{M} ). To illustrate the varied nature of limbs in the cubic case, consider the “unicritical family” \{P_{0,b}:z\mapsto z^{3}+b\}_{b\in\mathbb{C}} where the two critical points coincide, and the “lemon family” \operatorname{Per}_{1}(0)=\{P_{a,0}:z\mapsto z^{3}+3az^{2}\}_{a\in\mathbb{C}} where one critical point is fixed at 0 and the other is free. These families can be identified with complex lines in \mathbb{C}^{2} that meet transversally at the center of the main hyperbolic component \mathcal{H} of \mathcal{C}(3) corresponding to the map z\mapsto z^{3} . Both of these lines intersect \mathcal{C}(3) along a closed topological disk (the closure of their intersection with \mathcal{H} ) decorated with a countable collection of disjoint limbs. But the limbs in these one-dimensional slices of \mathcal{C}(3) have completely different dynamical and topological natures. In the unicritical case, the limbs are naturally indexed by non-zero rational rotation numbers p/q plus an element of \mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z} , where the family has a period- q bifurcation at the root parameter, a situation that bears strong resemblance to the case of the Mandelbrot set (Fig. 1 left). For the lemon family, the limbs are naturally indexed by the periodic points of \mathbf{m}_{2} plus an element of \mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z} and the family has a saddle-node bifurcation at the root parameter (Fig. 1 right). Combinatorially speaking, the unicritical limbs are associated with certain cycles of the tripling map \mathbf{m}_{3}:t\mapsto 3t\ (\operatorname{mod}{\mathbb{Z}}) whose combinatorics have degree 1 , while the limbs in \operatorname{Per}_{1}(0) are associated with pairs of adjacent cycles of \mathbf{m}_{3} that can have any combinatorics of degree 1 or 2 (see § 3.1 for details). [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] Figure 1. Two transversal one-dimensional slices of the cubic connectedness locus \mathcal{C}(3)\subset\mathbb{C}^{2} . Left: The unicritical family \{P_{0,b}:z\mapsto z^{3}+b\}_{b\in\mathbb{C}} , where the limbs attached to the main hyperbolic component are indexed by non-zero rotation numbers. Here b belongs to the limb L(p/q) iff the q dynamic rays of P_{0,b} that co-land at a fixed point are permuted with rotation number p/q and have their angles in the interval ]0,1/2[ . Right: The lemon family \{P_{a,0}:z\mapsto z^{3}+3az^{2}\}_{a\in\mathbb{C}} , where the limbs are indexed by the periodic points of the doubling map \mathbf{m}_{2}:t\mapsto 2t\ (\operatorname{mod}{\mathbb{Z}}) . Here a belongs to the limb \mathcal{L}_{0}(t) iff the dynamic rays of P_{a,0} with the “simulating angles” of t co-land (see § 3.2 ). Both pictures have a 180^{\circ} rotational symmetry since P_{a,b} and P_{-a,-b} are affinely conjugate. This gives rise to a countable collection of rotated limbs designated by asterisks. We use the combinatorial characterization of limbs in \operatorname{Per}_{1}(0) to define the “lemon limb” \mathcal{L}(t)\subset\mathcal{C}(3) for every periodic point t\in\mathbb{Q}/\mathbb{Z} of \mathbf{m}_{2} . The combinatorial pattern of co-landing rays of P=P_{a,b} in \mathcal{L}(t) implies the existence of two quadratic-like restrictions, a “central” P:U\to U^{\prime} about the first critical point 0 and a “peripheral” P^{\circ q}:V\to V^{\prime} about the second critical point -2a , where q\geq 1 is the period of t under \mathbf{m}_{2} . Under favorable conditions these restrictions have connected filled Julia sets and therefore they are hybrid conjugate to unique quadratic polynomials Q_{c} and Q_{\nu} , respectively. This defines a straightening map \bm{\chi}:P\mapsto(c,\nu) from the main renormalization locus \mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t)\subset\mathcal{L}(t) to the product of two copies of \mathcal{M} . We prove that this map is a homeomorphism between \mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t) and the product \check{\mathcal{M}}_{t}\times\check{\mathcal{M}}_{0} . Here \check{\mathcal{M}}_{t}=\mathcal{M}\smallsetminus\{c(t_{1}),\ldots,c(t_{q})\} , where \{t_{1},\ldots,t_{q}\} is the \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbit of t and c(t_{i}) is the parabolic landing point of the external ray of \mathcal{M} at angle t_{i} (in particular, \check{\mathcal{M}}_{0}=\mathcal{M}\smallsetminus\{1/4\} ). Thus, the inverse \bm{\chi}^{-1} gives a parametrization of \mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t) by the product of two finitely punctured Mandelbrot sets. The assignment \bm{\chi}^{-1}:(c,\nu)\mapsto P can be thought of as a “tuning” operation that manufactures a unique cubic P with a peripheral quadratic hybrid class Q_{\nu} having the combinatorics of t , tuned by a central quadratic hybrid class Q_{c} . Our results extend and tie together various pieces of prior knowledge. For example, the one-dimensional limbs \mathcal{L}_{0}(t):=\mathcal{L}(t)\cap\operatorname{Per}_{1}(0) have been studied in the works of Milnor [ M4 ] and Roesch [ R2 ] , and our introduction of the lemon limbs \mathcal{L}(t) can be thought of as a direct generalization from dimension 1 to 2 . Inou and Kiwi [ IK ] have studied properties of the straightening map in the general framework of mapping schemata of postcritically finite polynomials and, among other things, shown its injectivity. For cubic polynomials, they proved the existence of homeomorphic copies of \mathcal{M}\times\mathcal{M} in \mathcal{C}(3) associated with the hyperbolic components of primitive disjoint type. Our work on lemon limbs provides a complementary result for non-primitive disjoint type renormalizations, where one has to deal with the issue of non-compactness of the domain of the straightening map. The paper [ IK ] also showed the existence of injected copies of \mathcal{K}:=\{(c,z):c\in\mathcal{M}\ \text{and}\ z\in K_{c}\} in \mathcal{C}(3) associated with the hyperbolic components of primitive capture type (see also [ BuHe ] ). Such copies of \mathcal{K} can be observed in our full lemon limb \mathcal{L}(t) as the extensions of the capture components in \mathcal{L}_{0}(t) . Another related result is the intertwining surgery studied by Epstein and Yampolsky [ EY ] , and by Haïssinsky [ Ha ] , which can be interpreted as a special case of our construction of P=\bm{\chi}^{-1}(c,\nu) when the combinatorics of t under \mathbf{m}_{2} is of rotation type p/q and the central hybrid class Q_{c} is chosen from the p/q -limb of \mathcal{M} . Finally, lemon limb structures show up in a recent paper of Bonifant, Estabrooks and Sharland [ BES ] which establishes a correspondence between escape loci in \operatorname{Per}_{1}(0) and in the curve \operatorname{Per}_{2}(0)\subset\mathcal{P}(3) consisting of cubics with a critical point of period 2 . The ideas presented in this paper open up several new directions and avenues for further exploration. We refer the reader to a list of problems at the end of our expanded introduction in the next section. 2. Outline of results We now give a more precise account of the main results. We represent cubic polynomials in the normal form P_{a,b}:z\mapsto z^{3}+3az^{2}+b\qquad(a,b\in\mathbb{C}) with marked critical points \omega_{1}=0,\omega_{2}=-2a . The space \mathcal{P}(3) of all such critically marked cubics is isomorphic to \mathbb{C}^{2} with coordinates (a,b) . The space of all affine conjugacy classes of these cubics (the so-called “moduli space”) is also isomorphic to \mathbb{C}^{2} with coordinates (a^{2},b^{2}) . The cubic connectedness locus \mathcal{C}(3) is the set of all cubics in \mathcal{P}(3) with connected Julia set, which is known to be compact and connected (in fact, cellular). Consider the complex line \operatorname{Per}_{1}(0)\subset\mathcal{P}(3) consisting of all cubics P_{a,b} for which \omega_{1} is fixed, with the normal form P_{a}=P_{a,0}:z\mapsto z^{3}+3az^{2}\qquad(a\in\mathbb{C}). The connectedness locus \mathcal{C}_{0}=\mathcal{C}(3)\cap\operatorname{Per}_{1}(0) of this family is shown in Figs. 1 and 7 . The prominent central region \mathcal{H}_{0} in these figures, resembling the shape of a lemon, consists of all a\in\mathbb{C} for which \omega_{2} belongs to the immediate basin of attraction of \omega_{1} (equivalently, the Julia set of P_{a} is a Jordan curve). For this reason, we informally refer to \{P_{a}\}_{a\in\mathbb{C}} as the lemon family of cubics. The limbs of \mathcal{C}_{0} attached to \partial\mathcal{H}_{0} have been the subject of several investigations (see [ F ] , [ M4 ] , and [ R2 ] ). Although structurally different, they are reminiscent of the primary limbs of the Mandelbrot set attached to the boundary of the main cardioid. The “lemon limbs” of the connectedness locus \mathcal{C}(3) that we study in this paper are the natural extensions of the one-dimensional limbs of \mathcal{C}_{0} . Their description depends on a basic combinatorial result on the existence and uniqueness of pairs of periodic orbits of the tripling map \mathbf{m}_{3}:t\mapsto 3t (mod \mathbb{Z} ) that simulate the combinatorics of the periodic points of the doubling map \mathbf{m}_{2} . By the combinatorics of a periodic orbit \{t_{1},\ldots,t_{q}\} under a covering map f:\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z}\to\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} , labeled so that 0\leq t_{1}<\cdots\sigma(i+1) . Here 1\leq i\leq q and we always adopt the convention q+1=1 ). The number of descents of \sigma is called its degree : 2 2 2 In the combinatorics literature this invariant is called the cyclic descent number of \sigma . \deg(\sigma)=\#\{1\leq i\leq q:\sigma\ \text{has a descent at}\ i\}. For example, \sigma=(1243)\in S_{4} , which can be written in the classical notation as \sigma=\begin{pmatrix}1&2&3&4\\ 2&4&1&3\end{pmatrix} , has descents at i=2,4 so \deg(\sigma)=2 . It is easy to see that \deg(\sigma)=1 if and only if \sigma is a rotation cycle , i.e., a cyclic permutation of the form \sigma:i\mapsto i+p\ (\operatorname{mod}q) for some integer 1\leq p\sigma(1),\\ \ \ \displaystyle{\binom{q+k-d-1}{q}}&\qquad\text{otherwise.}\end{cases} The periodic orbits of \mathbf{m}_{k} that realize a given \sigma\in S_{q} are uniquely determined by their “fixed point distribution,” i.e., the knowledge of how the k-1 fixed points of \mathbf{m}_{k} are distributed among the q intervals in between the orbit points, or equivalently, how the orbit points are deployed in the k-1 intervals between the fixed points. The following special case of the above theorem plays a central role in this paper. Suppose a cyclic permutation \sigma\in S_{q} can be realized under the doubling map \mathbf{m}_{2} . Then either \deg(\sigma)=1 so \sigma is a rotation cycle and \sigma(q)<\sigma(1) , or \deg(\sigma)=2 and \sigma(q)>\sigma(1) . Whichever the case, Theorem 3.2 shows that \sigma has a unique realization under \mathbf{m}_{2} and q+1 realizations under \mathbf{m}_{3} . Remark 3.3 . The preceding definitions easily generalize to finite unions of periodic orbits in which case the associated combinatorics are products of cyclic permutations with disjoint supports. The definition of degree remains the same and k\geq\deg(\sigma) is a necessary (but no longer sufficient) condition for \mathbf{m}_{k} having a finite invariant set that realizes \sigma . 3.2. Simulating orbits of \mathbf{m}_{3} Below we describe a process that associates to each periodic point of \mathbf{m}_{2} a canonical pair of periodic orbits of \mathbf{m}_{3} , all with the same combinatorics. First suppose \{t_{1},\ldots,t_{q}\} is a period q orbit of \mathbf{m}_{2} with combinatorics \sigma\in S_{q} . By the above discussion, there are precisely q+1 realizations \mathcal{O}_{0},\ldots,\mathcal{O}_{q} of \sigma under \mathbf{m}_{3} . They are uniquely determined by the condition (3.1) \#(\mathcal{O}_{k}\cap[0,1/2[)=k\qquad\text{for}\ 0\leq k\leq q. The following result is a slight restatement of Theorem A in the introduction and will be proved at the end of this section: Theorem 3.4 . For each 1\leq k\leq q , the neighboring orbits \mathcal{O}_{k-1},\mathcal{O}_{k} interlace. More precisely, if \mathcal{O}_{k}=\{x_{1},\ldots,x_{q}\} and \mathcal{O}_{k-1}=\{y_{1},\ldots,y_{q}\} , then (3.2) 0\leq x_{1}1 . Assuming Theorem 3.4 for a moment, we see that the closed intervals I_{i}:=[x_{i},y_{i}] for 1\leq i\leq q are pairwise disjoint and none of them contains the fixed point 0 . Under \mathbf{m}_{3} each I_{i} maps homeomorphically onto I_{\sigma(i)} except for I_{k} which contains the fixed point 1/2 and maps to the whole circle. More precisely, consider the points x^{\prime}_{k}:=x_{k}+\frac{1}{3}\qquad\text{and}\qquad y^{\prime}_{k}:=y_{k}-\frac{1}{3} which appear in the order x_{k}\sigma(1) in which case \mathbf{m}_{2} maps T_{q} homeomorphically onto T_{\sigma(q)}\cup\cdots\cup T_{\sigma(1)-1} . Now fix 1\leq k\leq q and take the points \alpha_{1},\ldots,\alpha_{q} and \beta_{1},\ldots,\beta_{q} on the circle such that 0<\alpha_{1}<\beta_{1}<\cdots<\alpha_{q}<\beta_{q}<1 . The intervals A_{i}:=[\alpha_{i},\beta_{i}] and B_{i}:=[\beta_{i},\alpha_{i+1}] for 1\leq i\leq q form a partition of the circle modulo their endpoints. We may choose these points so that |A_{\sigma^{i}(k)}|=3^{i-1}/(3^{q}-1) and |B_{i}|=|T_{i}|/2 for all 1\leq i\leq q . This is possible because \sum_{i=1}^{q}\frac{3^{i-1}}{3^{q}-1}=\sum_{i=1}^{q}\frac{|T_{i}|}{2}=\frac{1}{2}. Define a covering map f:\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z}\to\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} which sends the A_{i} and B_{i} affinely to their images as follows: f(A_{i})=\begin{cases}A_{\sigma(i)}&\quad\text{if}\ i\neq k\\ A_{\sigma(i)}\ \text{plus one full turn}&\quad\text{if}\ i=k\end{cases} and f(B_{i})=\begin{cases}\ [\beta_{\sigma(i)},\alpha_{\sigma(i+1)}]&\quad\text{if}\ i\neq q\ \text{or if}\ i=q\ \text{and}\ \sigma(q)>\sigma(1)\\ \ [\beta_{\sigma(i)},\alpha_{\sigma(i+1)}]\ \text{plus one full turn}&\quad\text{if}\ i=q\ \text{and}\ \sigma(q)<\sigma(1).\end{cases} It is easy to see that f is a degree 3 piecewise affine covering map with f^{\prime}|_{A_{i}}=3 for all i . Moreover, f(B_{i}) contains the union B_{\sigma(i)}\cup\cdots\cup B_{\sigma(i+1)-1} , so by ( 3.4 ), f^{\prime}|_{B_{i}}\geq\frac{|B_{\sigma(i)}|+\cdots+|B_{\sigma(i+1)-1}|}{|B_{i}|}=\frac{|T_{\sigma(i)}|+\cdots+|T_{\sigma(i+1)-1}|}{|T_{i}|}=2. Thus, f is uniformly expanding with slope \geq 2 . It is well known that this implies the existence of a unique orientation-preserving homeomorphism \varphi:\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z}\to\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} which fixes 0 and satisfies \varphi\circ f=\mathbf{m}_{3}\circ\varphi (see e.g. [ KH , Theorem 2.4.6] ). Set \hat{x}_{i}:=\varphi(\alpha_{i}),\hat{y}_{i}:=\varphi(\beta_{i}) . Evidently \mathcal{O}:=\{\hat{x}_{1},\ldots,\hat{x}_{q}\} and \mathcal{O}^{\prime}:=\{\hat{y}_{1},\ldots,\hat{y}_{q}\} are periodic orbits of \mathbf{m}_{3} with combinatorics \sigma . As [\hat{x}_{k},\hat{y}_{k}] maps over itself under \mathbf{m}_{3} , it must contain a fixed point of \mathbf{m}_{3} which can only be 1/2 since the other fixed point 0 is in (\hat{y}_{q},\hat{x}_{1}) . This proves the analog of ( 3.2 ) for the \hat{x}_{i},\hat{y}_{i} . It follows in particular that \mathcal{O}\cap[0,1/2]=\{\hat{x}_{1},\ldots,\hat{x}_{k}\}\quad\text{and}\quad\mathcal{O}^{\prime}\cap[0,1/2]=\{\hat{y}_{1},\ldots,\hat{y}_{k-1}\}. We conclude from the characterization ( 3.1 ) that \mathcal{O}=\mathcal{O}_{k},\mathcal{O}^{\prime}=\mathcal{O}_{k-1} , and therefore \hat{x}_{i}=x_{i} and \hat{y}_{i}=y_{i} for all i . ∎ Corollary 3.7 . Let \mathcal{O}_{0},\ldots,\mathcal{O}_{q} be the realizations of \sigma\in S_{q} under \mathbf{m}_{3} as above. Consider the marked interval [x_{k},y_{k}] of the simulating pair \mathcal{O}_{k},\mathcal{O}_{k-1} which contains the fixed point 1/2 . Then \mathcal{O}_{j}\cap\,]x_{k},y_{k}[\,\neq\emptyset whenever j\notin\{k-1,k\} . Proof. In the natural cyclic order of orbits, let u_{i} denote the i -th point of \mathcal{O}_{i} if k\leq i\leq q and the (i+1) -st point of \mathcal{O}_{i} if 0\leq i\leq k-1 . Then Theorem 3.4 and the characterization ( 3.1 ) show that x_{k}=u_{k}G^{\ast}\} and \{z:|z|>\mathrm{e}^{G^{\ast}}\} , where G^{\ast}=\max_{i=1,2}G(\omega_{i}) , and is related to G by \log|\phi(z)|=G(z)\qquad\text{if}\ G(z)>G^{\ast}. In particular, if K is connected, then G^{\ast}=0 and \phi:\mathbb{C}\smallsetminus K\to\mathbb{C}\smallsetminus\overline{\mathbb{D}} is a conformal isomorphism. In this case for each \theta\in\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} the smooth curve R(\theta)=R_{P}(\theta):=\phi^{-1}(\{\mathrm{e}^{s+2\pi\mathrm{i}\theta}:s>0\}) is called the external ray (or the dynamic ray ) of P at angle \theta . The external rays of P can also be defined when K is disconnected. In this case the equipotential curves G=\text{const.}>0 form a singular foliation of the basin of infinity \mathbb{C}\smallsetminus K and the field lines of \nabla G form an orthogonal singular foliation. We denote by R(\theta) the maximally extended smooth field line of \nabla G given by s\mapsto\phi^{-1}(\mathrm{e}^{s+2\pi\mathrm{i}\theta}) for large s . This naturally parametrizes R(\theta) by the potential, so for each \theta there is an s(\theta)\geq 0 such that G(R(\theta,s))=s for all s>s(\theta) . The set N=N_{P}\subset\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} of angles \theta for which s(\theta)>0 is countable, dense and backward-invariant under \mathbf{m}_{3} . For \theta\notin N the field line R(\theta) extends all the way to the Julia set, just like the ordinary external rays in the connected case. For \theta\in N the field line R(\theta) crashes into a singularity of \nabla G at the potential s(\theta)>0 and there is more than one way to extend it to a curve consisting of field lines and singularities on which G defines a homeomorphism onto ]0,+\infty[ . But there are always two special extensions: R^{+}(\theta)=\lim_{\alpha\downarrow\theta}R(\alpha) which turns immediate right and R^{-}(\theta)=\lim_{\alpha\uparrow\theta}R(\alpha) which turns immediate left at each singularity they meet (here the angle \alpha tends to \theta avoiding the exceptional set N ). These are called the broken external rays at angle \theta . We refer to [ PZ2 ] for a comprehensive treatment of the external rays of disconnected Julia sets. As a concrete example of the disconnected case, consider the situation where \omega_{1}\in K but \omega_{2}\notin K . Then there is a unique angle \theta_{0}\in\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} such that the rays R(\theta_{0}\pm 1/3) crash into \omega_{2} (compare Fig. 6 left). In this case, the exceptional set N will consist of all angles \theta for which \mathbf{m}_{3}^{\circ n}(\theta)=\theta_{0}\pm 1/3 for some n\geq 0 . For z_{0}\in J=\partial K we denote by A_{z_{0}} the set of angles \theta\in\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} for which R(\theta) (if \theta\notin N) or one of R^{\pm}(\theta) (if \theta\in N ) lands at z_{0} . Every periodic \theta belongs to A_{z_{0}} for some repelling or parabolic point z_{0} whose period under P divides that of \theta under \mathbf{m}_{3} . Conversely, if z_{0} is a repelling or parabolic point of period k , then A_{z_{0}} is non-empty and \mathbf{m}_{3}^{\circ k}:A_{z_{0}}\to A_{z_{0}} has a well-defined rotation number \rho . Moreover, the following dichotomy holds: Either \rho is rational in which case A_{z_{0}} is a union of finitely many cycles of the same length, or \rho is irrational in which case A_{z_{0}} is a minimal Cantor set. The first alternative always happens when K is connected or more generally when the connected component of K containing z_{0} is not a single point (see [ DH1 ] or [ M1 ] for the connected case and [ LP ] or [ PZ2 ] for the disconnected case). 4.2. The lemon family: dynamical plane Consider the complex line \operatorname{Per}_{1}(0)\subset\mathcal{P}(3) consisting of all cubics P_{a,b} for which the critical point \omega_{1}=0 is fixed, that is, those in the normal form P_{a}:=P_{a,0}:z\mapsto z^{3}+3az^{2}\qquad(a\in\mathbb{C}) (for simplicity we use the subscript a instead of P_{a} for the objects associated with the cubics in \operatorname{Per}_{1}(0) ). The connectedness locus of this family is shown in Fig. 7 . The prominent central region \mathcal{H}_{0} in this figure, resembling the shape of a lemon, consists of all a\in\mathbb{C} for which the critical point \omega_{2}=-2a belongs to the immediate basin of attraction of 0 (equivalently, the Julia set J_{a} is a Jordan curve). We refer to \{P_{a}\}_{a\in\mathbb{C}} as the lemon family of cubics. The study of the slice \operatorname{Per}_{1}(0) appears in the works of several authors including Faught [ F ] , Milnor [ M4 ] , and Roesch [ R1 , R2 ] . Our brief description in the dynamical plane is closest to [ M4 ] but differs in some details in order to incorporate the notion of simulating orbits from § 3.2 into the picture. Fix some a\neq 0 . The immediate basin of attraction of 0 is a Jordan domain B_{a} . There is a canonical Böttcher coordinate \beta_{a} which is defined and holomorphic near 0 and satisfies (4.2) \beta_{a}(P_{a}(z))=(\beta_{a}(z))^{2}. The symmetry P_{-a}(z)=-P_{a}(-z) implies (4.3) \beta_{-a}(z)=\beta_{a}(-z). We distinguish three cases depending on the position of \omega_{2}=-2a : \bullet Case 1 . \omega_{2}\in B_{a} . Then P_{a}:B_{a}\to B_{a} is a degree 3 branched covering and the filled Julia set K_{a}=\overline{B_{a}} is a closed topological disk. There is a largest Jordan domain in B_{a} containing 0 which maps conformally by \beta_{a} to a round disk |z|0 there are at most finitely many limbs L_{a}(t) with Euclidean diameter >\epsilon . This property can be used to show that every non-root point on \partial B_{a} is the landing point of a unique external ray while every root point on \partial B_{a} has at least two external rays landing on it (see [ Z , §5.2] for details of this argument in a very similar case). Below we will show that each root has precisely two external rays landing on it. The external rays landing at a root z_{a}(t) divide the plane into finitely many open sectors. By definition, the (dynamical) wake W_{a}(t) is the complement of the closure of the sector containing B_{a} . Notice that W_{a}(t) contains L_{a}(t)\smallsetminus\{z_{a}(t)\} and distinct roots have disjoint wakes. The wake W_{a}(t) is bounded by two rays R_{a}(x),R_{a}(y) landing at z_{a}(t) which we always label counterclockwise, so R_{a}(\theta)\subset W_{a}(t) if and only if \theta\in\,]x,y[ . We think of the length of the interval [x,y] as the angular size of W_{a}(t) . The critical wake W_{a}(\tau_{a}) can be described as the unique wake whose angular size is \geq 1/3 . The analogue of the property (ii) above holds for wakes: Under P_{a} the wake W_{a}(t) maps conformally to W_{a}(\mathbf{m}_{2}(t)) if t\neq\tau_{a} , and to the entire plane if t=\tau_{a} . Corollary 4.1 . If the critical internal angle \tau_{a} is not periodic under \mathbf{m}_{2} , then z_{a}(\tau_{a})=\omega_{2} and every root is the landing point of precisely two external rays. Proof. The forward \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbit of \mathbf{m}_{2}(\tau_{a}) never hits \tau_{a} , hence z_{a}(\mathbf{m}_{2}(\tau_{a})) is not a root and has a unique ray landing on it. Since there are at least two rays landing at z_{a}(\tau_{a}) , it follows that z_{a}(\tau_{a}) is a critical point. The fact that the local degree of P_{a} at z_{a}(\tau_{a}) is 2 now shows that there are precisely two rays landing there, and therefore two rays landing at all other roots since they are all non-critical. ∎ Every periodic point z_{a}(t)\in\partial B_{a} of period q\geq 1 has combinatorial rotation number zero since the internal ray of angle t landing at z_{a}(t) is invariant under P_{a}^{\circ q} . It follows in particular that only the external rays at angles 0 or 1/2 can land at the fixed point z_{a}(0) . After conjugating P_{a} by z\mapsto-z if necessary (that is, replacing P_{a} with P_{-a} ), we may assume that P_{a} is fixed-ray normalized in the following sense: The external ray R_{a}(0) lands at z_{a}(0) , and if both R_{a}(0),R_{a}(1/2) land at z_{a}(0) , then the wake W_{a}(0) corresponds to the interval ]0,1/2[ (as opposed to ]1/2,1[ ). Let us now discuss the case where the critical internal angle \tau_{a} is periodic of some period q under \mathbf{m}_{2} . If q=1 then \tau_{a}=0 and the critical wake W_{a}(0) is bounded by the rays R_{a}(0),R_{a}(1/2) landing at the fixed point z_{a}(0) . Notice that 0,1/2 are the simulating angles of 0 in the sense of § 3.2 . If q\geq 2 then \tau_{a}\neq 0 and by our normalization R_{a}(0) lands at z_{a}(0) but R_{a}(1/2) does not. Label the \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbit of \tau_{a} in positive cyclic order as 01\})\qquad(\xi\in\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z}). The following appears in [ M4 ] (see also [ BOT ] ): Theorem 4.3 . Let t\in\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} be periodic under \mathbf{m}_{2} with simulating angles x_{k},y_{k} . Then the parameter rays \mathcal{R}(x_{k}-1/3) and \mathcal{R}(y_{k}+1/3) co-land at a(t)\in\partial\mathcal{H}_{0} . If \mathcal{W}_{0}(t) denotes the connected component of \mathbb{C}\smallsetminus(\mathcal{R}(x_{k}-1/3)\cup\mathcal{R}(y_{k}+1/3)\cup\{a(t)\}) not containing \mathcal{H}_{0} , then \displaystyle\overline{\mathcal{W}_{0}(t)} \displaystyle=\{a\in\mathbb{C}:\emph{therays}\ R_{a}(x_{k})\ \emph{and}\ R_{a}(y_{k})\ \emph{co-land}\,\} \displaystyle=\{a\in\mathbb{C}:\tau_{a}=t\}. We call \mathcal{W}_{0}(t) the (parameter) wake in \operatorname{Per}_{1}(0) at internal angle t . Fig. 7 shows a few examples of wakes. The co-landing rays R_{a}(x_{k}),R_{a}(y_{k}) are smooth if a\in\mathcal{W}_{0}(t)\cup\{a(t)\} . However, R_{a}(x_{k}) is infinitely broken if a\in\mathcal{R}(x_{k}-1/3) and R_{a}(y_{k}) is infinitely broken if a\in\mathcal{R}(y_{k}+1/3) (compare Fig. 6 right). The common landing point z_{a}(t) of R_{a}(x_{k}),R_{a}(y_{k}) is periodic under P_{a} of the same period q as that of t under \mathbf{m}_{2} ; it is repelling if a\neq a(t) and parabolic with multiplier 1 if a=a(t) . The orbit of z_{a}(t) moves holomorphically over a\in\mathcal{W}_{0}(t) ; in particular, the multiplier map a\mapsto(P_{a}^{\circ q})^{\prime}(z_{a}(t)) is analytic in \mathcal{W}_{0}(t) . Define the (parameter) limb \mathcal{L}_{0}(t)\subset\operatorname{Per}_{1}(0) by \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{0}(t) \displaystyle:=\overline{\mathcal{W}_{0}(t)}\cap\mathcal{C}_{0}=\{a\in\mathcal{C}_{0}:\text{the rays}\ R_{a}(x_{k}),R_{a}(y_{k})\ \text{co-land}\,\} \displaystyle\,=\{a\in\mathcal{C}_{0}:\tau_{a}=t\}. The limb \mathcal{L}_{0}(t) is a full continuum and meets \partial\mathcal{H}_{0} only at a(t) . The parameter a(t) is the root of the main Mandelbrot copy \mathcal{M}_{0}(t)\subset\mathcal{L}_{0}(t) . If q is the period of t under \mathbf{m}_{2} , the compact set \mathcal{M}_{0}(t) can be described as the set of a\in\mathcal{L}_{0}(t) for which P_{a} is q -renormalizable around the critical point \omega_{2} . More precisely, there is a homeomorphism \chi:\mathcal{M}_{0}(t)\to\mathcal{M} with \chi(a(t))=1/4 having the following property: For every a\in\mathcal{M}_{0}(t) there are Jordan domains U\Subset U^{\prime} containing \omega_{2} such that the restriction P_{a}^{\circ q}:U\to U^{\prime} is quadratic-like hybrid equivalent to Q_{\chi(a)}:z\mapsto z^{2}+\chi(a) . Corollary 4.4 ( [ R2 ] ) . Let 0\leq t<1 have period q under \mathbf{m}_{2} . For every \nu\in\mathcal{M} there exists a unique parameter a\in\mathcal{L}_{0}(t) such that the restriction of P_{a}^{\circ q} to a neighborhood of \omega_{2} is quadratic-like hybrid equivalent to Q_{\nu} . [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] Figure 8. Details of the limb \mathcal{L}_{0}(1/3) , with its main Mandelbrot copy \mathcal{M}_{0}(1/3) (in green) and various capture components (in yellow) attached to its dyadic tips. A parameter a\in\mathcal{M}_{0}(t) is called a dyadic tip if the forward orbit of \omega_{2} under P_{a}^{\circ q} eventually hits the “ \beta -fixed point” of the quadratic-like map P_{a}^{\circ q}:U\to U^{\prime} (this is simply the point z_{a}(t)\in\partial B_{a} ). Under the aforementioned homeomorphism \chi , the dyadic tips of \mathcal{M}_{0}(t) correspond to those of \mathcal{M} , i.e., the landing points of the parameter rays \mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{M}}(p/2^{n}) for n\geq 1 and odd p . Every dyadic tip of \mathcal{M}_{0}(t) is on the boundary of a unique capture component (compare Fig. 8 ). This phenomenon is a special property of the main Mandelbrot copies in \mathcal{C}_{0} . Other maximal copies of the Mandelbrot set have no capture components directly attached to them although they are densely accumulated by capture components. To complete the picture of the limb structure in \mathcal{C}_{0} , we need to also consider the left half of \partial\mathcal{H}_{0} consisting of P_{a} for which the conjugate map P_{-a} via z\mapsto-z is fixed-ray normalized. Notice that the involution z\mapsto-z in the dynamical plane corresponds to the automorphism \theta\mapsto\theta+1/2 of \mathbf{m}_{3} on external angles which exchanges the fixed points 0 and 1/2 . Thus, we also have wakes \mathcal{W}^{\ast}_{0}(t)=-\mathcal{W}_{0}(t) and limbs \mathcal{L}^{\ast}_{0}(t)=-\mathcal{L}_{0}(t) characterized by \displaystyle\overline{\mathcal{W}^{\ast}_{0}(t)} \displaystyle=\{a:\text{the rays}\ R_{a}(x_{k}+1/2)\ \text{and}\ R_{a}(y_{k}+1/2)\ \text{co-land}\} \displaystyle\mathcal{L}^{\ast}_{0}(t) \displaystyle=\overline{\mathcal{W}^{\ast}_{0}(t)}\cap\mathcal{C}_{0}. We can now state the limb structure theorem in \operatorname{Per}_{1}(0) , proved by Roesch in [ R2 ] , as follows: (4.5) \mathcal{C}_{0}=\overline{\mathcal{H}_{0}}\cup\bigcup_{t\ \text{periodic under}\ \mathbf{m}_{2}}\big(\mathcal{L}_{0}(t)\cup\mathcal{L}^{\ast}_{0}(t)\big). 5. Lemon limbs and renormalization Throughout this section t\in\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} is periodic under \mathbf{m}_{2} with period q and simulating angles x_{k},y_{k} . 5.1. Lemon limbs \mathcal{L}(t) The combinatorial characterization of parameter limbs in the one-dimensional slice \operatorname{Per}_{1}(0) motivates the following definition in the full parameter space \mathcal{P}(3) : Definition 5.1 . The lemon limb \mathcal{L}(t) is defined by \mathcal{L}(t):=\{P\in\mathcal{C}(3):\text{the rays}\ R_{P}(x_{k})\ \text{and}\ R_{P}(y_{k})\ \text{co-land}\}. Thus, \mathcal{L}_{0}(t)=\mathcal{L}(t)\cap\operatorname{Per}_{1}(0) . For P\in\mathcal{L}(t) the co-landing point z_{k} of the ray pair R_{P}(x_{k}),R_{P}(y_{k}) is periodic with period dividing q . Moreover, z_{k} is either repelling or parabolic with (P^{\circ q})^{\prime}(z_{k})=1 . Similar to what we saw in the slice \operatorname{Per}_{1}(0) in § 4.3 , we can define the rotated lemon limbs \mathcal{L}^{\ast}(t) as the image of \mathcal{L}(t) under the involution (a,b)\mapsto(-a,-b) of \mathcal{P}(3) . In other words, \mathcal{L}^{\ast}(t):=\{P\in\mathcal{C}(3):\text{the rays}\ R_{P}(x_{k}+1/2)\ \text{and}\ R_{P}(y_{k}+1/2)\ \text{co-land}\}. It can be shown that distinct lemon limbs are disjoint: \mathcal{L}(t)\cap\mathcal{L}(s)=\emptyset whenever t\neq s . However, a limb \mathcal{L}(t) and a rotated limb \mathcal{L}^{\ast}(s) may well intersect. These statements and some related ideas and results are discussed in the Appendix. One subtlety in the definition of lemon limbs (in contrast to the slices \mathcal{L}_{0}(t) or the primary limbs of the Mandelbrot set) is that \mathcal{L}(t) is not compact. Example 5.2 . There is a sequence of cubic maps f_{n}(z):=z^{3}-(\sqrt{2}-\epsilon_{n})z^{2}+\frac{3}{2}z with \epsilon_{n}\to 0 for which the filled Julia set K_{f_{n}} is connected and the rays R_{f_{n}}(0),R_{f_{n}}(1/2) co-land at the repelling fixed point z=0 . This is certainly true if \epsilon_{n}>0 (compare [ PZ3 , Theorem D] ) and it likely holds whenever \operatorname{Re}(\epsilon_{n})>0 and \operatorname{Im}(\epsilon_{n})/\operatorname{Re}(\epsilon_{n})\to 0 sufficiently fast. But for the cubic f=\lim_{n\to\infty}f_{n} the ray R_{f}(0) lands at z=0 while R_{f}(0) lands at the parabolic fixed point z=1/\sqrt{2} (see Fig. 9 ). We refer the reader to Remark 8.6 for a discussion of the characterization of cubics in \overline{\mathcal{L}(t)}\smallsetminus\mathcal{L}(t) . [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] Figure 9. Illustration of non-compactness of lemon limbs: The co-landing condition defining a limb can fail to persist under taking limits (see Example 5.2 ). 5.2. Central and peripheral renormalizaions For the rest of the subsequent sections we will be working under our usual assumptions: 0\leq t_{1}<\cdots0 . For every 1\leq i\leq q there is a univalent pull-back V_{i} of W_{\sigma(i)} outside \bigcup_{i=1}^{q}W_{i} (this is the analog of W_{a}(t_{i}+1/2) in the lemon family). Let U^{\prime}_{0} be the open subset of \mathbb{C}\smallsetminus\bigcup_{i=1}^{q}\overline{W_{i}} consisting of all points at Green’s potential 1/D . Lemma 5.5 . Consider P\in\mathcal{L}(t) with the co-landing orbit \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} . (i) If P\in{\mathcal{L}}_{\operatorname{cen}}(t) and \varphi is any hybrid equivalence between the restriction P:U\to U^{\prime} and Q_{c} , then for 1\leq i\leq q the external ray R_{c}(t_{i}) lands at the point w_{i}:=\varphi(z_{i})\in K_{c} . (ii) If P\in{\mathcal{L}}_{\operatorname{per}}(t) and \psi is any hybrid equivalence between the restriction P^{\circ q}:V\to V^{\prime} and Q_{\nu} , then \psi(z_{k}) and \psi(z^{\prime}_{k}) are the \beta -fixed point of Q_{\nu} and its preimage, respectively. Proof. (i) Let \Pi:I\to\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} be the unique semiconjugacy of Theorem 5.4 associated with the central renormalization which satisfies \Pi(0)=0 . Thus, \theta\in I if and only if R(\theta) accumulates on K_{\operatorname{cen}} . Since K_{\operatorname{cen}}\cap W_{i}=\emptyset for every 1\leq i\leq q , we have \Pi(x_{i})=\Pi(y_{i}) . It suffices to check that \Pi(x_{i})=\Pi(y_{i})=t_{i} , for then another application of Theorem 5.4 will show that R_{c}(t_{i}) lands at w_{i} . Note that the result would be trivial assuming \Pi(x_{1}),\ldots,\Pi(x_{q}) are distinct, for then by monotonicity of \Pi these q points would form an \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbit with combinatorics \sigma and there is only one such orbit namely \{t_{1},\ldots,t_{q}\} . The subtlety here is to rule out any identification among \Pi(x_{1}),\ldots,\Pi(x_{q}) that may change the combinatorics of the projection. Suppose \Pi(x_{i})=\Pi(y_{i}) is not t_{i} for some (hence all) i . Then \Pi(\mathcal{O}_{k})=\Pi(\mathcal{O}_{k-1}) is an \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbit disjoint from \{t_{1},\ldots,t_{q}\} . Choose any u_{1}\in\Pi^{-1}(t_{1}) and consider its \mathbf{m}_{3} -orbit \{u_{1},\ldots,u_{q}\}\subset I , which has the combinatorics \sigma by monotonicity of \Pi , and is disjoint from \mathcal{O}_{k}\cup\mathcal{O}_{k-1} . By Corollary 3.7 , u_{j}\in\,]x_{k},y_{k}[ for some j . Again by monotonicity of \Pi , this implies t_{j}=\Pi(u_{j})=\Pi(x_{k})=\Pi(y_{k}) , contradicting the assumption that \Pi(\mathcal{O}_{k})=\Pi(\mathcal{O}_{k-1}) is disjoint from \{t_{1},\ldots,t_{q}\} . (ii) The argument is similar to but easier than (i). This time let \Pi:I\to\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} be a semiconjugacy (between \mathbf{m}_{3}^{\circ q} and \mathbf{m}_{2} ) given by Theorem 5.4 associated with the peripheral renormalization. Then \Pi(x_{k})=\Pi(y_{k}) since K_{\operatorname{per}}\subset\overline{W_{k}}\smallsetminus W^{\prime}_{k} . Now x_{k},y_{k} are fixed under \mathbf{m}_{3}^{\circ q} , so \Pi(x_{k})=\Pi(y_{k})=0 . Thus, \psi(z_{k}) is the landing point of the fixed ray R_{\nu}(0) of Q_{\nu} and \psi(z^{\prime}_{k}) is its other preimage. ∎ 5.3. Renormalizable cubics and straightening Definition 5.6 . The main renormalization locus \mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t) is the set of all cubics in \mathcal{L}(t) that are both centrally and peripherally renormalizable: \mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t)={\mathcal{L}}_{\operatorname{cen}}(t)\cap{\mathcal{L}}_{\operatorname{per}}(t). Note that for every P\in\mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t) the co-landing orbit \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} is repelling. The following characterization of \mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t) is immediate: Corollary 5.7 . Let P\in\mathcal{L}(t) have a repelling co-landing orbit. Then P\in\mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t) if and only if P^{\circ n}(\omega_{1})\in\mathbb{C}\smallsetminus\bigcup_{i=1}^{q}\overline{W_{i}} and P^{\circ nq}(\omega_{2})\in W_{k}\smallsetminus\overline{W^{\prime}_{k}} for all n\geq 0 . Notice that since \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} is repelling, so is the corresponding orbit \{w_{i}\} of Q_{c} and the \beta -fixed point of Q_{\nu} , where c=\chi_{\operatorname{cen}}(P),\nu=\chi_{\operatorname{per}}(P) . It follows from Lemma 5.5 and the general theory of the Mandelbrot set that \nu\neq 1/4 and c\neq c(t_{i}) for all 1\leq i\leq q , where c(t_{i}) is the landing point of the external ray \mathcal{R}_{\mathcal{M}}(t_{i}) of the Mandelbrot set (see the discussion in § 6.1 ). Set \check{\mathcal{M}}_{t}:=\mathcal{M}\smallsetminus\{c(t_{1}),\ldots,c(t_{q})\}. In particular, \check{\mathcal{M}}_{0}=\mathcal{M}\smallsetminus\{1/4\} . Theorem B in the introduction claims that the straightening map \bm{\chi}:\mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t)\to\check{\mathcal{M}}_{t}\times\check{\mathcal{M}}_{0} defined by \bm{\chi}(P)=(\chi_{\operatorname{cen}}(P),\chi_{\operatorname{per}}(P)) is a homeomorphism. The inverse \bm{\chi}^{-1} provides a homeomorphic embedding of the product \check{\mathcal{M}}_{t}\times\check{\mathcal{M}}_{0} into the lemon limb \mathcal{L}(t) . In the terminology of § 4.3 , the main Mandelbrot copy \mathcal{M}_{0}(t)\subset\mathcal{L}_{0}(t) is the closure of \bm{\chi}^{-1}(\{0\}\times\check{\mathcal{M}}_{0}) . An analogous result holds for the rotated limbs \mathcal{L}^{\ast}(t) since the corresponding straightening map \bm{\chi}^{\ast}:\mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t)\to\check{\mathcal{M}}_{t}\times\check{\mathcal{M}}_{0} satisfies \bm{\chi}^{\ast}(P_{a,b})=\bm{\chi}(P_{-a,-b}) . Example 5.8 . Fig. 11 shows the filled Julia set of the cubic P=\bm{\chi}^{-1}(-2,0) in the limb \mathcal{L}(1/3) which can also be described as the intertwining of the Chebyshev map z\mapsto z^{2}-2 and z\mapsto z^{2}-1 . Here the points of the co-landing orbit of P merge into a repelling fixed point z_{1}=z_{2} (compare Theorem 6.6 ). [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] Figure 11. Filled Julia set of the cubic \bm{\chi}^{-1}(-2,0) in the limb \mathcal{L}(1/3) . Here the critical point \omega_{1}=0 maps to a fixed point after two iterates, while \omega_{2}=-2a is periodic with period 2 . The points of the co-landing orbit have merged into a repelling fixed point z_{1}=z_{2} . Continuity of \bm{\chi} follows from the well-known continuity of the straightening map in degree 2 and the fact that the domains of the quadratic-like restrictions P:U\to U^{\prime} and P^{\circ q}:V\to V^{\prime} can be chosen to depend continuously on P (see [ DH2 ] and [ Mc2 , Proposition 4.7] ). As pointed out in the introduction, the proof of Theorem B will be completed in three stages in § 7 , § 8 , and § 9 . 6. A closer look at the co-landing orbit Suppose P\in{\mathcal{L}}_{\operatorname{cen}}(t) and \chi_{\operatorname{cen}}(P)=c . When c is in the main cardioid of the Mandelbrot set, the co-landing orbit \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} of P has period q and each z_{i} is the landing point of precisely two external rays at angles x_{i},y_{i} . When c is outside the main cardioid, this picture may be violated in two mutually exclusive ways: The orbit \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} may have a third cycle of rays landing on it, or it may coalesce into an orbit of lower period. These cases will be studied in § 6.2 and § 6.3 , respectively. As both situations can be directly translated into the dynamical plane of Q_{c} , we begin by recalling a few relevant facts about periodic orbits of quadratic polynomials and the external rays landing on them. These descriptions have been known for the most part since the seminal work of Douady and Hubbard [ DH1 ] , but our brief presentation is closer to Milnor’s in [ M3 ] to which we refer for further details. 6.1. Quadratic portraits and the Mandelbrot set Let c\in\mathcal{M} and Z be a repelling or parabolic orbit of Q_{c} of period p . For each w\in Z consider the finite set A_{w}\subset\mathbb{Q}/\mathbb{Z} of angles t such that the ray R_{c}(t) lands at w . In the language of [ M3 ] the collection \{A_{w}:w\in Z\} is the portrait associated with Z . Each restriction \mathbf{m}_{2}:A_{w}\to A_{Q_{c}(w)} is an order-preserving bijection, so the first return map \mathbf{m}_{2}^{\circ p}:A_{w}\to A_{w} has a well-defined (combinatorial) rotation number \rho independent of w . It follows that \bigcup_{w\in Z}A_{w} is a disjoint union of N\geq 1 cycles of common period q=rp for some r\geq 1 . Thus, the cardinality of each A_{w} is Nr and the rotation number \rho is a reduced fraction of the form s/r with 0\leq s1 contains at most one pair of \mathcal{M} -partners. In other words, if \hat{t}_{i} denotes the \mathcal{M} -partner of t_{i} , then the relation \hat{t}_{i}=t_{j} can hold for at most one unordered pair i,j . Let c\in\mathcal{M} and consider the set Z of the landing points of R_{c}(t_{1}),\ldots,R_{c}(t_{q}) . If c\in\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{M}}(t_{i},\hat{t}_{i}) for some i , the dynamic rays R_{c}(t_{i}),R_{c}(\hat{t}_{i}) co-land and the portrait of Z is primitive if t_{i},\hat{t}_{i} belong to different \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbits and is satellite if t_{i},\hat{t}_{i} belong to the same \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbit. Conversely, if the portrait of Z is non-trivial, then c\in\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{M}}(t_{i},\hat{t}_{i}) as we pointed out above. We summarize the above observations in the following Corollary 6.1 . Let \{t_{1},\ldots,t_{q}\} be a periodic orbit of \mathbf{m}_{2} with period q>1 and for each 1\leq i\leq q let \hat{t}_{i} be the unique \mathcal{M} -partner of t_{i} . Take c\in\mathcal{M} and consider the set Z of the landing points of the dynamic rays R_{c}(t_{1}),\ldots,R_{c}(t_{q}) . Then the portrait of Z is \bullet primitive if c\in\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{M}}(t_{i},\hat{t}_{i}) for some i and t_{i},\hat{t}_{i} belong to different \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbits; \bullet satellite if c\in\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{M}}(t_{i},\hat{t}_{i}) for some i and t_{i},\hat{t}_{i} belong to the same \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbit; \bullet trivial otherwise. Example 6.2 . The period q=4 orbits of \mathbf{m}_{2} are listed below: orbit combinatorics in S_{4} degree rotation number \{1,2,4,8\}/15 (1234) 1 1/4 \{3,6,9,12\}/15 (1243) 2 - \{7,11,13,14\}/15 (1432) 1 3/4 The \mathcal{M} -partner pairs (in multiples of 1/15 ) are (1,2),\ (3,4),\ (6,9),\ (7,8),\ (11,12),\ (13,14). The degree 2 orbit \{3,6,9,12\}/15=\{1,2,3,4\}/5 is part of a non-trivial portrait in the three limbs \mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{M}}(3/15,4/15) , \mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{M}}(11/15,12/15) and \mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{M}}(6/15,9/15) , and generates a trivial portrait elsewhere. In the first two limbs the portrait is primitive while in the third limb it is satellite and the corresponding landing points form an orbit of lower period p=2 . Example 6.3 . The period q=5 orbits of \mathbf{m}_{2} are listed below: orbit combinatorics in S_{5} degree rotation number \{1,2,4,8,16\}/31 (12345) 1 1/5 \{5,9,10,18,20\}/31 (13524) 1 2/5 \{3,6,12,17,24\}/31 (12354) 2 - \{7,14,19,25,28\}/31 (12543) 2 - \{11,13,21,22,26\}/31 (14253) 1 3/5 \{15,23,27,29,30\}/31 (15432) 1 4/5 The \mathcal{M} -partner pairs (in multiples of 1/31 ) are \displaystyle(1,2),(3,4),(5,6),(7,8),(9,10),(11,12),(13,18),(14,17), \displaystyle(15,16),(19,20),(21,22),(23,24),(25,26),(27,28),(29,30) Observe that the two orbits of degree 2 do not contain any pair of \mathcal{M} -partners, so they can never be part of a satellite portrait. 6.2. External angles of the co-landing orbit For each P\in\mathcal{L}(t) the two cycles of external rays with angles in \mathcal{O}_{k}=\{x_{1},\ldots,x_{q}\} and \mathcal{O}_{k-1}=\{y_{1},\ldots,y_{q}\} co-land on the orbit \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} . It is known that the number of distinct cycles of external rays that land on a periodic orbit of a polynomial of degree D is at most D (in fact, the sharp bound is one plus the number of critical values of the polynomial; see [ M3 ] for the quadratic case already encountered in § 6.1 , and [ K ] for the higher degree case). It follows that in our cubic case there can be at most one additional cycle of rays landing on \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} . The following lemma describes when such third cycle exists for centrally renormalizable cubics: Theorem 6.4 (Third cycle comes from central primitive portraits) . Let P\in{\mathcal{L}}_{\operatorname{cen}}(t) and \chi_{\operatorname{cen}}(P)=c . Take any hybrid equivalence \varphi between P:U\to U^{\prime} and the quadratic Q_{c} . The following conditions are equivalent: (i) There is a third cycle of rays landing on \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} . (ii) The orbit \{\varphi(z_{1}),\ldots,\varphi(z_{q})\} of Q_{c} has a primitive portrait. (iii) c\in\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{M}}(t_{i},\hat{t}_{i}) for some 1\leq i\leq q , where t_{i},\hat{t}_{i} do not belong to the same \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbit. The condition (iii) puts c in the union of either q-1 or q Mandelbrot limbs according as the \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbit \{t_{1},\ldots,t_{q}\} contains a pair of \mathcal{M} -partners or not (see § 6.1 ). Note also that these equivalent conditions imply that \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} has exact period q , so no merging in the co-landing orbit can occur. Proof. As the equivalence (ii) \Leftrightarrow (iii) is part of Corollary 6.1 , it suffices to verify (i) \Leftrightarrow (ii). Consider the semiconjugacy \Pi:I\to\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} of Theorem 5.4 associated with P:U\to U^{\prime} and normalized by \Pi(0)=0 . By (the proof of) Lemma 5.5 , \Pi(x_{i})=\Pi(y_{i})=t_{i} and R_{c}(t_{i}) lands at w_{i}:=\varphi(z_{i}) for every 1\leq i\leq q . Let us first prove (ii) \Rightarrow (i). Suppose the portrait of \{w_{1},\ldots,w_{q}\} is primitive. Then every w_{i} is the landing point of exactly two external rays R_{c}(t_{i}) and R_{c}(s_{i}) , where the \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbits \{t_{1},\ldots,t_{q}\} and \{s_{1},\ldots,s_{q}\} are disjoint (notice that this choice of labeling no longer guarantees that the s_{i} are in positive cyclic order). Choose u_{1}\in\Pi^{-1}(s_{1}) and define u_{\sigma^{i}(1)}:=\mathbf{m}_{3}^{\circ i}(u_{1}) , so \Pi(u_{i})=s_{i} for every 1\leq i\leq q . Then \{u_{1},\ldots,u_{q}\} is an \mathbf{m}_{3} -orbit of period q disjoint from \mathcal{O}_{k}\cup\mathcal{O}_{k-1} . By Theorem 5.4 , for every i the external ray R(u_{i}) lands at z_{i} . Let us now prove (i) \Rightarrow (ii). Suppose there is a third cycle of rays R(u_{1}),\ldots,R(u_{q}) such that R(u_{i}) lands at z_{i} for every i . Setting s_{i}:=\Pi(u_{i}) , it follows from Theorem 5.4 that R_{c}(s_{i}) lands at w_{i} (again, keep in mind that the u_{i} or s_{i} are no longer in positive cyclic order). We need to check that \{s_{1},\ldots,s_{q}\} is an \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbit of period q disjoint from \{t_{1},\ldots,t_{q}\} . Set \mathcal{O}:=\{u_{1},\ldots,u_{q}\} . First we observe that (6.1) \mathcal{O}\cap\bigcup_{i=1}^{q}\,]x_{i},y_{i}[=\emptyset. In fact, if this fails, by taking a suitable iterate under \mathbf{m}_{3} we can find some u\in\mathcal{O}\cap\,]x_{k},y_{k}[ . As \overline{W_{k}}\cap\{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\}=\{z_{k}\} , the ray R(u) must land at z_{k} , so it cannot be contained in the sub-wake W^{\prime}_{k} . Thus u\in\,]x_{k},y^{\prime}_{k}[\,\cup\,]x^{\prime}_{k},y_{k}[ , which implies \mathbf{m}_{3}(u)\in\,]x_{\sigma(k)},y_{\sigma(k)}[ , which in turn shows that every ]x_{i},y_{i}[ contains precisely one element of \mathcal{O} . It follows that \mathcal{O} has the combinatorics \sigma and \#(\mathcal{O}\cap[0,1/2[)=k or k-1 . By the characterization ( 3.1 ), \mathcal{O}=\mathcal{O}_{k} or \mathcal{O}=\mathcal{O}_{k-1} , which is a contradiction. Now suppose the orbit \{s_{1},\ldots,s_{q}\} coincides with \{t_{1},\ldots,t_{q}\} . Then we can re-label the angles in \mathcal{O} as v_{1},\ldots,v_{q} , where \Pi(v_{i})=t_{i} for every i . From monotonicity of \Pi we see that the v_{i} are in positive cyclic order and \mathcal{O} has the combinatorics \sigma . It then follows from ( 6.1 ) and \Pi(v_{k})=t_{k} that v_{k}\in\,]y_{k-1},x_{k}[ or v_{k}\in\,]y_{k},x_{k+1}[ . This implies \#(\mathcal{O}\cap[0,1/2[)=k or k-1 , which as before leads to a contradiction. ∎ Example 6.5 . For t=2/5 the simulating orbits are \mathcal{O}_{2}=\{8,24,56,72\}/80 and \mathcal{O}_{1}=\{17,51,59,73\}/80 with combinatorics \sigma=(1243) (see Example 3.6 ). If P\in{\mathcal{L}}_{\operatorname{cen}}(2/5) and \chi_{\operatorname{cen}}(P)=c\in\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{M}}(3/15,4/15) , Theorem 6.4 shows that there is a third cycle of external rays that lands on the co-landing orbit of P . It is easy to see that the angles of this third cycle form the \mathbf{m}_{3} -orbit \mathcal{O}=\{2,6,18,54\}/80 with combinatorics \tau=(1234) . Under the monotone surjection \Pi the orbits \mathcal{O}_{2}\cup\mathcal{O}_{1} and \mathcal{O} map to the \mathbf{m}_{2} -orbits \{3,6,9,12\}/15 and \{1,2,4,8\}/15 , respectively. 6.3. Merging of the co-landing orbit The co-landing orbit \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} of a cubic P\in\mathcal{L}(t) can merge into an orbit of period 1 and satisfies \bar{\partial}\Phi_{0}=0 a.e. on G^{-1}([s,\infty[)\cup K_{\operatorname{cen}}\cup\bigcup_{i=0}^{q-1}P^{\circ i}(K_{\operatorname{per}}). Since \Phi_{0} conjugates P and \tilde{P} on their respective postcritical sets, we can define \Phi_{n}:\mathbb{C}\to\mathbb{C} inductively by lifting \Phi_{n-1}\circ P under \tilde{P} , so \Phi_{n} is M -quasiconformal, coincides with \Phi_{n-1} on the set G^{-1}([3^{-n}s,\infty[)\cup\bigcup_{\ell=0}^{n-1}P^{-\ell}(K_{\operatorname{cen}}\cup\bigcup_{i=0}^{q-1}P^{\circ i}(K_{\operatorname{per}})), and satisfies \bar{\partial}\Phi_{n}=0 a.e. there. Thus, after passing to a subsequence, \{\Phi_{n}\} converges to an M -quasiconformal homeomorphism \Phi:\mathbb{C}\to\mathbb{C} which conjugates P to \tilde{P} everywhere and satisfies \bar{\partial}\Phi=0 a.e. on the set (\mathbb{C}\smallsetminus K)\cup\bigcup_{\ell=0}^{\infty}P^{-\ell}(K_{\operatorname{cen}}\cup\bigcup_{i=0}^{q-1}P^{\circ i}(K_{\operatorname{per}}))=\mathbb{C}\smallsetminus K_{\infty}. Assuming K_{\infty} has measure zero, it follows that \Phi is conformal a.e. in \mathbb{C} , hence is an affine map. Since \Phi is tangent to the identity at \infty and \Phi(0)=0 , we must have \Phi=\operatorname{id} and P=\tilde{P} . We now address the measure zero statement that was essential in the above argument: Theorem 7.2 . For every P\in\mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t) the residual Julia set K_{\infty} has Lebesgue measure 0 . Compare [ IK , Lemma 6.1] where a similar result is proved in a more general and abstract setting. Below we give a concrete independent proof based on hyperbolic geometry estimates in Lemma 7.5 . See also [ EY , Theorem 6.1] for the special case of intertwining cubics with a restriction on their quadratic renormalizations. Let \Omega_{0} denote the complement of the compact invariant set K_{\operatorname{cen}}\cup\bigcup_{i=0}^{q-1}P^{\circ i}(K_{\operatorname{per}}) . Evidently \Omega_{0} is a backward-invariant domain which avoids the postcritical set of P . For n\geq 1 set \Omega_{n}:=P^{-n}(\Omega_{0}) . Then \Omega_{n}\subsetneq\Omega_{n-1} and each \Omega_{n} is conformally isomorphic to the punctured disk, the puncture being at \infty . For simplicity we will write \lambda_{n} for the hyperbolic metric \lambda_{\Omega_{n}} , B_{n}(w,r) for the hyperbolic ball B_{\Omega_{n}}(w,r) , and \operatorname{area}_{n}(\cdot) for the hyperbolic area in \Omega_{n} . By the Schwarz lemma, \lambda_{n}>\lambda_{n-1} in \Omega_{n} and in particular \lambda_{n}>\lambda_{0} in \Omega_{n} . Since the restriction P^{\circ n}:(\Omega_{n},\lambda_{n})\to(\Omega_{0},\lambda_{0}) is a covering map and therefore a local isometry, it follows that P^{\circ n}:(\Omega_{n},\lambda_{0})\to(\Omega_{0},\lambda_{0}) is expanding (although not uniformly). The residual Julia set K_{\infty} is the set of points in J=\partial K which stay in \Omega_{0} under the iterations of P : K_{\infty}=J\cap\bigcap_{n\geq 0}\Omega_{n}. Recall that for each 1\leq i\leq q , W_{i} is the dynamical wake bounded by the pair R(x_{i}),R(y_{i}) co-landing at z_{i} and W^{\prime}_{k} is the sub-wake of W_{k} bounded by the pair R(y^{\prime}_{k}),R(x^{\prime}_{k}) co-landing at z^{\prime}_{k} . Observe that W^{\prime}_{k}\subset\Omega_{0} . Lemma 7.3 . There are constants 0<\epsilon0 such that B_{\tilde{\Omega}}(u,\epsilon)\cap\tilde{K}=\emptyset for all u\in\tilde{\gamma}_{x}\cup\tilde{\gamma}_{y} . Let \delta>0 be the hyperbolic diameter of \tilde{W} in \tilde{\Omega} and r:=\delta+\epsilon . Then for every w\in\tilde{W} the ball B_{\tilde{\Omega}}(w,r) contains the \epsilon -neighborhood of \tilde{W} , hence it contains the ball B_{\tilde{\Omega}}(u,\epsilon) for every u\in\tilde{\gamma}_{x}\cup\tilde{\gamma}_{y} . ∎ For the proof of Theorem 7.2 we also need a priori estimates on the geometry of the inclusion of one hyperbolic Riemann surface into another, which we formulate in Lemmas 7.4 and 7.5 below. Lemma 7.4 . Let X\subsetneq Y be hyperbolic Riemann surfaces such that the inclusion i:X\hookrightarrow Y induces an injection \pi_{1}(X)\to\pi_{1}(Y) . Then \log\|i^{\prime}\|=\log(\lambda_{Y}/\lambda_{X}):X\to\,]-\infty,0[ is a Lipschitz function (with constant 2 ). Proof. Fix x_{0},x_{1}\in X , take holomorphic universal covering maps p_{X}:(\mathbb{D},0)\to(X,x_{0}) and p_{Y}:(\mathbb{D},0)\to(Y,x_{0}) , and lift i to a holomorphic map f:(\mathbb{D},0)\to(\mathbb{D},0) . By the assumption on the fundamental groups, f is injective. Take a minimal geodesic in X joining x_{0} to x_{1} and lift it under p_{X} to a geodesic in \mathbb{D} joining 0 to some w . Then \operatorname{dist}_{X}(x_{0},x_{1})=\operatorname{dist}_{\mathbb{D}}(0,w)=\log((1+|w|)/(1-|w|)) . Now use Koebe’s distortion theorem to estimate \displaystyle\frac{\|i^{\prime}(x_{0})\|}{\|i^{\prime}(x_{1})\|} \displaystyle=\frac{\|f^{\prime}(0)\|}{\|f^{\prime}(w)\|}=\frac{\lambda_{\mathbb{D}}(w)}{\lambda_{\mathbb{D}}(f(w))}\ \frac{|f^{\prime}(0)|}{|f^{\prime}(w)|}=\frac{1-|f(w)|^{2}}{1-|w|^{2}}\ \frac{|f^{\prime}(0)|}{|f^{\prime}(w)|} \displaystyle\leq\frac{1}{1-|w|^{2}}\ \frac{(1+|w|)^{3}}{1-|w|}=\left(\frac{1+|w|}{1-|w|}\right)^{2}=\exp(2\operatorname{dist}_{\mathbb{D}}(0,w)). Taking logarithms gives \log\|i^{\prime}(x_{0})\|-\log\|i^{\prime}(x_{1})\|\leq 2\operatorname{dist}_{X}(x_{0},x_{1}), and the result follows by symmetry. ∎ Lemma 7.5 . In the situation of Lemma 7.4 , fix x_{0}\in X and let r>0 be smaller than the injectivity radius of X at x_{0} , so the ball B_{X}(x_{0},r) is embedded. (i) For every 0<\epsilon0 such that if B_{X}(x,\epsilon)\subset B_{X}(x_{0},r) , then \frac{\operatorname{area}_{Y}(B_{X}(x,\epsilon))}{\operatorname{area}_{Y}(B_{X}(x_{0},r))}\geq C(r,\epsilon).\vskip 6.0pt (ii) The ball B_{X}(x_{0},r) has bounded geometry in Y in the following sense: \displaystyle r_{\operatorname{\,in}} \displaystyle:=\max\{s:B_{Y}(x_{0},s)\subset B_{X}(x_{0},r)\}\geq\tfrac{1}{2}\,(1-\mathrm{e}^{-2r})\,\|i^{\prime}(x_{0})\|, \displaystyle r_{\operatorname{out}} \displaystyle:=\min\,\{s:B_{Y}(x_{0},s)\supset B_{X}(x_{0},r)\}\leq\tfrac{1}{2}\,(\mathrm{e}^{2r}-1)\ \ \|i^{\prime}(x_{0})\|. In particular, r_{\operatorname{\,in}}/r_{\operatorname{out}}\geq\mathrm{e}^{-2r} . Proof. We will use the following inequalities given by Lemma 7.4 : \mathrm{e}^{-2\operatorname{dist}_{X}(z,x_{0})}\leq\frac{\|i^{\prime}(z)\|}{\|i^{\prime}(x_{0})\|}\leq\mathrm{e}^{2\operatorname{dist}_{X}(z,x_{0})}\qquad\text{for all}\ z\in X. (i) We have \displaystyle\operatorname{area}_{Y}(B_{X}(x,\epsilon)) \displaystyle=\iint_{B_{X}(x,\epsilon)}\lambda_{Y}^{2}(z)\,|dz|^{2}=\iint_{B_{X}(x,\epsilon)}\|i^{\prime}(z)\|^{2}\lambda_{X}^{2}(z)\,|dz|^{2} \displaystyle\geq\mathrm{e}^{-4r}\|i^{\prime}(x_{0})\|^{2}\operatorname{area}_{X}(B_{X}(x,\epsilon)), and \displaystyle\operatorname{area}_{Y}(B_{X}(x_{0},r)) \displaystyle=\iint_{B_{X}(x_{0},r)}\lambda_{Y}^{2}(z)\,|dz|^{2}=\iint_{B_{X}(x_{0},r)}\|i^{\prime}(z)\|^{2}\lambda_{X}^{2}(z)\,|dz|^{2} \displaystyle\leq\mathrm{e}^{4r}\|i^{\prime}(x_{0})\|^{2}\operatorname{area}_{X}(B_{X}(x_{0},r)). Thus, \displaystyle\frac{\operatorname{area}_{Y}(B_{X}(x,\epsilon))}{\operatorname{area}_{Y}(B_{X}(x_{0},r))} \displaystyle\geq\mathrm{e}^{-8r}\ \frac{\operatorname{area}_{X}(B_{X}(x,\epsilon))}{\operatorname{area}_{X}(B_{X}(x_{0},r))}=\mathrm{e}^{-8r}\ \frac{\operatorname{area}_{\mathbb{D}}(B_{\mathbb{D}}(0,\epsilon))}{\operatorname{area}_{\mathbb{D}}(B_{\mathbb{D}}(0,r))} \displaystyle=\mathrm{e}^{-8r}\,\frac{\cosh(\epsilon)-1}{\cosh(r)-1}=:C(r,\epsilon).\vskip 6.0pt (ii) Find p,q\in\partial B_{X}(x_{0},r) such that \operatorname{dist}_{Y}(x_{0},p)=r_{\operatorname{\,in}} and \operatorname{dist}_{Y}(x_{0},q)=r_{\operatorname{out}} . Take the Y -geodesic \gamma:[0,r^{\prime}]\to\overline{B_{Y}(x_{0},r_{\operatorname{\,in}})} with \gamma(0)=x_{0},\gamma(r^{\prime})=p , parametrized so that \|\gamma^{\prime}(t)\|_{X}=\lambda_{X}(\gamma(t))\,|\gamma^{\prime}(t)|=1 for all t . Then \operatorname{dist}_{X}(x_{0},\gamma(t))\leq t , and in particular r\leq r^{\prime} . Hence, \displaystyle r_{\operatorname{\,in}} \displaystyle=\int_{0}^{r^{\prime}}\lambda_{Y}(\gamma(t))\,|\gamma^{\prime}(t)|\ dt=\int_{0}^{r^{\prime}}\|i^{\prime}(\gamma(t))\|\ dt\geq\|i^{\prime}(x_{0})\|\int_{0}^{r^{\prime}}\mathrm{e}^{-2t}\,dt \displaystyle\geq\|i^{\prime}(x_{0})\|\int_{0}^{r}\mathrm{e}^{-2t}\,dt=\frac{1}{2}(1-\mathrm{e}^{-2r})\,\|i^{\prime}(x_{0})\|. Similarly, take the X -geodesic \eta:[0,r]\to\overline{B_{X}(x_{0},r)} with \eta(0)=x_{0},\eta(r)=q , parametrized so that \|\eta^{\prime}(t)\|_{X}=\lambda_{X}(\eta(t))\,|\eta^{\prime}(t)|=1 for all t . Then \operatorname{dist}_{X}(x_{0},\eta(t))=t and \displaystyle r_{\operatorname{out}} \displaystyle\leq\int_{0}^{r}\lambda_{Y}(\eta(t))\,|\eta^{\prime}(t)|\ dt=\int_{0}^{r}\|i^{\prime}(\eta(t))\|\ dt\leq\|i^{\prime}(x_{0})\|\int_{0}^{r}\mathrm{e}^{2t}\,dt \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2}(\mathrm{e}^{2r}-1)\,\|i^{\prime}(x_{0})\|.\hfill\qed Proof of Theorem 7.2 . Assume by way of contradiction that K_{\infty} has positive measure. Since the forward orbit of a.e. point in J converges to the postcritical set of P (see for example [ Mc1 , Theorem 3.9] ), we can find a Lebesgue density point w_{0}\in K_{\infty} whose orbit \{w_{n}:=P^{\circ n}(w_{0})\} converges to the postcritical set. Evidently the orbit \{w_{n}\} must visit the sub-wake W^{\prime}_{k} infinitely often. Since the postcritical set can meet \overline{W^{\prime}_{k}} only at z^{\prime}_{k} , it follows that some subsequence of \{w_{n}\} converges to z^{\prime}_{k} , i.e., there is an increasing sequence S\subset\mathbb{N} such that w_{n}\to z^{\prime}_{k} as n\in S tends to \infty . By Lemma 7.3 there are constants 0<\epsilon1 in which case the period of \zeta_{\infty} must be q . The multiplier (P^{\circ p})^{\prime}(\zeta) is a primitive r th root of unity and the multiplicity of \zeta as a fixed point of P^{\circ q} is r+1 . \bullet Each of the two connected components of B\smallsetminus\gamma contains at least one critical point of P^{\circ q} . In particular, both critical points of P must belong to the disjoint union B\cup P(B)\cup\cdots\cup P^{\circ q-1}(B) . See Theorems A, B, C as well as the Basic Structure Lemma and Lemma 6.2 in [ PZ3 ] . The proof of Theorem 8.1 begins as follows. After passing to a subsequence, we may assume P_{n} converges to some P\in\mathcal{C}(3) and the co-landing orbit \{z_{1,n},\ldots,z_{q,n}\} of P_{n} converges to a periodic orbit \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} of P , where each z_{i} is fixed under P^{\circ q} . The critical points of P are \omega_{1}=\lim_{n\to\infty}\omega_{1,n} and \omega_{2}=\lim_{n\to\infty}\omega_{2,n} . We will show that the rays R(x_{k}),R(y_{k}) of P co-land at z_{k} (so P\in\mathcal{L}(t) ) and that z_{k} is repelling. In particular, the closed rays \overline{R}_{n}(x_{k}),\overline{R}_{n}(y_{k}) of P_{n} converge in the Hausdorff metric to the closed rays \overline{R}(x_{k}),\overline{R}(y_{k}) . Thus, the domains of the quadratic-like restrictions P_{n}:U_{n}\to U^{\prime}_{n} and P_{n}^{\circ q}:V_{n}\to V^{\prime}_{n} can be chosen to converge to those of P:U\to U^{\prime} and P^{\circ q}:V\to V^{\prime} . It follows from Corollary 5.7 that P\in\mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t) . Continuity of \bm{\chi} then shows \bm{\chi}(P)=\bm{\chi}(P_{\infty}) , which implies P=P_{\infty} by injectivity of \bm{\chi} . Lemma 8.4 . At least one of the rays R(x_{k}),R(y_{k}) lands at z_{k} . Proof. Suppose R(x_{k}),R(y_{k}) land at \zeta^{-},\zeta^{+} distinct from z_{k} . By Theorem 8.3 , \zeta^{\pm} are parabolic and the Hausdorff limits of \overline{R}_{n}(x_{k}) and \overline{R}_{n}(y_{k}) are of the form R(x_{k})\cup\{\zeta^{-}\}\cup\gamma^{-}\cup\{z_{k}\} and R(y_{k})\cup\{\zeta^{+}\}\cup\gamma^{+}\cup\{z_{k}\} . Here \gamma^{\pm} are disjoint heteroclinic arcs connecting \zeta^{\pm} to z_{k} and residing in period q parabolic basins B^{\pm} , where B^{-}=B^{+} if and only if \zeta^{-}=\zeta^{+} . Consider the dynamical wakes W_{i,n}\ (1\leq i\leq q) and the sub-wake W^{\prime}_{k,n}\subset W_{k,n} of P_{n} . Define the “wakes” W_{i}\ (1\leq i\leq q) and W^{\prime}_{k} of P as the interior of the Hausdorff limit of the closures \overline{W_{i,n}} and \overline{W^{\prime}_{k,n}} , respectively. It follows from the basic action of P_{n} on its wakes that the W_{i} are pairwise disjoint and we have the following diagram for the action of P : W_{k}\smallsetminus\overline{W^{\prime}_{k}}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle 2:1}}{{\longrightarrow}}W_{\sigma(k)}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle 1:1}}{{\longrightarrow}}\cdots\stackrel{{\scriptstyle 1:1}}{{\longrightarrow}}W_{\sigma^{q-1}(k)}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle 1:1}}{{\longrightarrow}}W_{k}. In particular, P^{\circ q}:W_{k}\smallsetminus\overline{W^{\prime}_{k}}\to W_{k} is a proper map of degree 2 with a single critical point at \omega_{2} . Moreover, the forward orbit of \omega_{1} never enters the union \bigcup_{i=1}^{q}W_{i} . We distinguish three cases: [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] Figure 13. The cases 2 (left) and 3 (right) in the proof of Lemma 8.4 . In either case W_{k} is the region shaded in gray and B is the parabolic basin of \zeta shaded in yellow. Case 1. \zeta^{-}\neq\zeta^{+}\Rightarrow B^{-}\cap B^{+}=\emptyset . This is easily seen to be impossible since by Theorem 8.3 both critical points \omega_{1} and \omega_{2} of P would have to be simultaneously contained in the (disjoint) orbits of B^{\pm} . Case 2. \zeta^{-}=\zeta^{+}=\zeta\Rightarrow B^{-}=B^{+}=B and the domain \Omega bounded by \gamma^{\pm} is disjoint from W_{k} (Fig. 13 left). The complement B\smallsetminus(\gamma^{-}\cup\gamma^{+}) has three connected components, one being \Omega and the other two contained in W_{k} and labeled D^{\pm} having \gamma^{\pm} on their boundary. For integer i modulo q , set B_{i}:=P^{\circ i}(B) and let \Omega_{i}:=P^{\circ i}(\Omega) be the domain in B_{i} bounded by \gamma^{\pm}_{i}:=P^{\circ i}(\gamma^{\pm}) . Let D_{i}^{\pm} denote the remaining components of B_{i}\smallsetminus(\gamma^{-}_{i}\cup\gamma^{+}_{i}) having \gamma^{\pm}_{i} on their boundary. Evidently D^{-}_{i}\cup D^{+}_{i}\subset W_{\sigma^{i}(k)} but \Omega_{i}\cap\bigcup_{j=1}^{q}W_{j}=\emptyset . Since P^{\circ q}:\partial\Omega\to\partial\Omega is a homeomorphism, P^{\circ q}:\Omega\to\Omega must be a conformal isomorphism, so P maps each \Omega_{i} conformally onto \Omega_{i+1} . On the other hand, D^{\pm}_{i} maps conformally onto D^{\pm}_{i+1} if D^{\pm}_{i} does not contain a critical point, and it maps as a degree 2 branched covering onto B_{i+1} otherwise. By Theorem 8.3 , both \omega_{1},\omega_{2} belong to some iterated images of D^{\pm} . Since \omega_{2} is in W_{k} , it must belong to one of D^{\pm} , say \omega_{2}\in D^{-} . In that case \omega_{1}\in D^{+}_{i} for some i . This implies \omega_{1}\in W_{\sigma^{i}(k)} , which is a contradiction. Case 3. \zeta^{-}=\zeta^{+}=\zeta\Rightarrow B^{-}=B^{+}=B and the domain \Omega bounded by \gamma^{\pm} is contained in W_{k} (Fig. 13 right). We can define B_{i},\Omega_{i},D_{i}^{\pm} as in Case 2 except that now \Omega_{i}\subset W_{\sigma^{i}(k)} and (D^{-}_{i}\cup D^{+}_{i})\cap\bigcup_{j=1}^{q}W_{j}=\emptyset . Again by Theorem 8.3 , both \omega_{1},\omega_{2} belong to the iterated images of D^{\pm} . Assuming without loss of generality that \omega_{1}\in D^{-}_{i} for some i , it follows that \omega_{2}\in D^{+}_{j} for some j . This implies D^{+}_{j}\cap W_{k}\neq\emptyset , which is a contradiction. ∎ Lemma 8.5 . Both rays R(x_{k}),R(y_{k}) land at z_{k} , hence P\in\mathcal{L}(t) . Proof. By Lemma 8.4 we may assume without loss of generality that R(y_{k}) lands at z_{k} . Suppose R(x_{k}) lands at a point \zeta\neq z_{k} . Then, by Theorem 8.3 , \zeta is parabolic and the Hausdorff limit of \overline{R}_{n}(x_{k}) is of the form R(x_{k})\cup\{\zeta\}\cup\gamma\cup\{z_{k}\} , where \gamma is a heteroclinic arc connecting \zeta to z_{k} within a period q parabolic basin B . Notice that in this case z_{k} is repelling and the Hausdorff limit of \overline{R}_{n}(y_{k}) is \overline{R}(y_{k}) . Let p=q/r be the period of \zeta under P . Then the multiplier (P^{\circ p})^{\prime}(\zeta) is a primitive r th root of unity and the multiplicity of \zeta as a fixed point of P^{\circ q} is r+1 . Thus, the parabolic point \zeta bifurcates into a nearby fixed point \zeta_{n} and an r -cycle C_{n} of the map P_{n}^{\circ p} . According to [ PZ4 , Theorem 5.1] , for all sufficiently large n the P_{n}^{\circ q} -invariant ray R_{n}(x_{k}) which enters and eventually exists a fixed small disk centered at \zeta must separate the points of C_{n}\cup\{\zeta_{n}\} within that disk. This implies that the ray pair R_{n}(x_{k}),R_{n}(y_{k}) that co-land on z_{k,n} separate these r+1 points. In particular, there is a point \zeta^{\prime}_{n}\in C_{n}\cup\{\zeta_{n}\} that belongs to W_{k,n}\smallsetminus\overline{W^{\prime}}_{k,n} , hence to the peripheral filled Julia set of P_{n} . Under straightening, \zeta^{\prime}_{n} must correspond to the \alpha -fixed point of the peripheral renormalization since z_{k,n} corresponds to its \beta -fixed point. It follows from Lemma 8.2 that \chi_{\operatorname{per}}(P_{\infty})=\lim_{n\to\infty}\chi_{\operatorname{per}}(P_{n})=1/4 . This contradicts the hypothesis \bm{\chi}(P_{\infty})\in\check{\mathcal{M}}_{t}\times\check{\mathcal{M}}_{0} . ∎ Proof of Theorem 8.1 . In view of Lemma 8.5 , it remains to prove that z_{k} is repelling. For simplicity let (c_{n},\nu_{n}):=\bm{\chi}(P_{n})\to(c,\nu):=\bm{\chi}(P_{\infty}) . Assuming z_{k} is parabolic, we reach a contradiction by showing that either c=c(t_{i}) for some 1\leq i\leq q , or \nu=1/4 . First suppose z_{k} is parabolic but the dynamical wake W_{k} of P defined by the co-landing pair R(x_{k}),R(y_{k}) does not contain an immediate attracting basin of z_{k} . Then the thickening procedure gives a central quadratic-like restriction P:U\to U^{\prime} (see § 5.2 ) with connected Julia set which is hybrid equivalent to some quadratic polynomial Q . Under this hybrid conjugacy the co-landing orbit \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} corresponds to an orbit \{w_{1},\ldots,w_{q}\} of Q which is still parabolic. For large n there is a component U_{n} of P_{n}^{-1}(U^{\prime}) containing \omega_{1,n} such that the restriction P_{n}:U_{n}\to U^{\prime} is quadratic-like with connected Julia set, necessarily hybrid equivalent to Q_{c_{n}} . Continuity of the straightening map \chi_{\operatorname{cen}} then shows that Q=Q_{c} . By Lemma 5.5 (i), the rays R_{c}(t_{i}) land at the parabolic point w_{i} for all 1\leq i\leq q . This implies c=c(t_{i}) for some i , a contradiction. Similarly, if z_{k} is parabolic with no immediate attracting basin outside W_{k} , the thickening procedure gives a peripheral quadratic-like restriction P^{\circ q}:V\to V^{\prime} with connected Julia set which is hybrid equivalent to some quadratic polynomial Q . Evidently this quadratic has a parabolic fixed point of multiplier 1 , so Q=Q_{1/4} . For large n there is a component V_{n} of P_{n}^{-q}(V^{\prime}) containing \omega_{2,n} such that the restriction P^{\circ q}_{n}:V_{n}\to V^{\prime} is quadratic-like with connected Julia set, necessarily hybrid equivalent to Q_{\nu_{n}} . By continuity of the straightening map \chi_{\operatorname{per}} we have \nu_{\infty}=\lim_{n\to\infty}\nu_{n}=1/4 , which is again a contradiction. Finally, suppose z_{k} is parabolic with a pair of immediate attracting basins on both sides of the ray pair R(x_{k}),R(y_{k}) : a central basin B^{-} outside W_{k} and a peripheral basin B^{+} inside W_{k} . (Notice that at this point we do not know if the Hausdorff limits of \overline{R}_{n}(x_{k}) and \overline{R}_{n}(y_{k}) are \overline{R}(x_{k}) and \overline{R}(y_{k}) , so a priori B^{\pm} may contain homoclinic arcs in these Hausdorff limits.) Now there are no quadratic-like restrictions near z_{k} in the classical sense, but there is a restriction P^{\circ q}:\Omega\to\Omega^{\prime} between suitable Jordan domains containing z_{k} that is a degree 2 parabolic-like map in the sense of Lomonaco, with the required invariant arcs being the intersections of R(x_{k}),R(y_{k}) with \Omega^{\prime} (see [ Lo ] for details). In fact, we can choose \Omega^{\prime} to be a domain bounded by an equipotential of sufficiently small potential in W_{k} starting on R(x_{k}) and ending on R(y_{k}) , completed with an arc in \mathbb{C}\smallsetminus W_{k} that stays sufficiently close to z_{k} . We can then take \Omega to be the connected component of P^{-q}(\Omega^{\prime}) containing z_{k} . The filled Julia set of the parabolic-like map P^{\circ q}:\Omega\to\Omega^{\prime} is the set of points in K_{P} whose forward P^{\circ q} -orbit remain in \overline{W_{k}}\smallsetminus W^{\prime}_{k} (in particular, it contains the basin B^{+} ). By the straightening theorem for parabolic-like maps, P^{\circ q}|_{\Omega} is hybrid equivalent to a restriction of a unique quadratic rational map of the form g_{A}:z\mapsto z+z^{-1}+A , with z_{k} corresponding to the parabolic fixed point \infty of g_{A} . Since z_{k} is a degenerate parabolic point of P^{\circ q} , the same must be true of \infty for g_{A} , which implies A=0 . It follows that P^{\circ q}|_{\Omega} is hybrid conjugate to the restriction of g_{0}:z\mapsto z+z^{-1} to a neighborhood of the closed left (or right) half-plane and in particular, (\overline{W_{k}}\smallsetminus W^{\prime}_{k})\cap K_{P}\subset\Omega does not contain any fixed point of P^{\circ q} other than z_{k} . Now consider the unique fixed point \zeta_{n} of P_{n}^{\circ q} in W_{k,n}\smallsetminus\overline{W^{\prime}_{k,n}} corresponding to the \alpha -fixed point of the peripheral renormalization. Let \zeta be an accumulation point of \{\zeta_{n}\} . Then \zeta belongs to any Hausdorff limit of \overline{W_{k,n}}\smallsetminus W^{\prime}_{k,n} as n\to\infty . Such a limit is necessarily contained in \overline{W_{k}}\smallsetminus W^{\prime}_{k} union the central basin B^{-} at z_{k} and its partner at the co-landing point z^{\prime}_{k} of the rays R(y^{\prime}_{k}),R(x^{\prime}_{k}) (to account for the possibility of homoclinic arcs in B^{-} ). Since \zeta is a fixed point of P^{\circ q} , we must have \zeta\in\overline{W_{k}}\smallsetminus W^{\prime}_{k} . It follows from what we established above that \zeta=z_{k} . This proves \zeta_{n}\to z_{k} , so (P_{n}^{\circ q})^{\prime}(\zeta_{n})\to 1 and therefore \nu_{\infty}=\lim_{n\to\infty}\nu_{n}=1/4 by Lemma 8.2 , which is a contradiction. ∎ Remark 8.6 . The proof of Lemma 8.4 shows that for every cubic P\in\overline{\mathcal{L}(t)}\smallsetminus\mathcal{L}(t) exactly one of the rays R(x_{k}),R(y_{k}) lands at a parabolic fixed point \zeta of P^{\circ q} of multiplier 1 . The other ray necessarily lands at a repelling fixed point of P^{\circ q} on the boundary of an immediate basin B of \zeta having exact period q . Moreover, the first-return map P^{\circ q}:B\to B is proper of degree 3 or 4 depending on whether both \omega_{1},\omega_{2} belong to B or they belong to different basins in the orbit of B . In Milnor’s terminology [ M4 ] , these cases correspond respectively to P being on the boundary of an “adjacent” or “bi-transitive” hyperbolic component in \mathcal{C}(3) . The failure of co-landing of R(x_{k}),R(y_{k}) is caused by the creation of a heteroclinic arc in the Hausdorff limit of one of these rays. This mechanism can be forced, for example, by taking the limit of suitable sequences P_{n}\in\mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t) with \chi_{\operatorname{cen}}(P_{n})\to c(t_{i}) for some 1\leq i\leq q and \chi_{\operatorname{per}}(P_{n})\to 1/4 . It seems reasonable to speculate that all cubics of the form described above are in fact in \overline{\mathcal{L}(t)}\smallsetminus\mathcal{L}(t) . 9. Surjectivity of straightening The final piece in the proof of Theorem B is the following Theorem 9.1 (Surjectivity of \bm{\chi} ) . For every pair (c,\nu)\in\check{\mathcal{M}}_{t}\times\check{\mathcal{M}}_{0} there is a cubic polynomial P\in\mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t) such that \chi_{\operatorname{cen}}(P)=c and \chi_{\operatorname{per}}(P)=\nu . The proof of this theorem is achieved in three steps that can be loosely described as follows: Step 1. Start from the quadratic polynomial Q_{c} and the unique cubic polynomial P_{a}\in\mathcal{L}_{0}(t) which is peripherally renormalizable around the second critical point \omega_{2} with a quadratic-like restriction hybrid equivalent to Q_{\nu} (Corollary 4.4 ). Construct a new holomorphic map f:\mathbb{C}\smallsetminus\overline{\Lambda}\to\mathbb{C} by changing the external class of Q_{c} (i.e., the map Q_{0}:z\mapsto z^{2} ) to the external class of the quadratic-like map obtained from the central renormalization of P_{a} around its superattracting basin B_{a} . Here \Lambda is the “hole” corresponding to the component B^{\prime}_{a} of P_{a}^{-1}(B_{a}) other than B_{a} . Step 2. Change the conformal structure on \Lambda and all its iterated preimages under f if necessary to create a large enough modulus necessary for quasiconformal interpolation. Step 3. Restrict to a topological disk bounded by a suitable equipotential curve and perform a quasiconformal interpolation on the sub-wake W_{k}^{\prime}\subset W_{k} of f containing \Lambda to obtain a quasiregular polynomial-like map of degree 3 with a central renormalization hybrid equivalent to Q_{c} and a peripheral renormalization hybrid equivalent to Q_{\nu} . This quasiregular map has an invariant conformal structure of bounded dilatation, so we can apply the straightening theorem to obtain the desired cubic polynomial P . The full details of the above steps are given in § 9.2 through § 9.5 . The short section § 9.1 recalls some definitions and relevant known facts on quasiconformal interpolation that are needed in the proof of Theorem 9.1 . 9.1. Dynamical cylinders and interpolation on sectors We begin with some generalities. Let f be a degree d polynomial with connected filled Julia set K . Suppose z_{0} is a repelling point of f of period p and combinatorial rotation number s/r . The external rays landing at z_{0} have a common period q=pr under f and fall into N cycles for some 1\leq N\leq d-1 , forming Nr rays altogether. There are Nr connected components of K\smallsetminus\{z_{0}\} whose intersections with a small neighborhood of z_{0} are permuted around by f^{\circ p} with combinatorial rotation number s/r . We may label these rays and components as R_{1}\ldots,R_{Nr} and K_{1},\ldots,K_{Nr} in positive cyclic order, so K_{j} lies between R_{j} and R_{j+1} (taking indices modulo Nr ). Now take a small Jordan domain D containing z_{0} in which f is linearizable. Then D\Subset D^{\prime}:=f^{\circ q}(D) and the biholomorphism f^{\circ q}:D\to D^{\prime} is conjugate to z\mapsto\lambda z , where \lambda:=(f^{\circ q})^{\prime}(z_{0}) . The quotient T:=(D\smallsetminus\{z_{0}\})/f^{\circ q} is a complex torus conformally isomorphic to (\mathbb{D}\smallsetminus\{0\})/\langle z\mapsto\lambda z\rangle . In particular, the conformal isomorphism class of T is independent of the choice of D . For 1\leq j\leq Nr the ray tails R_{j}\cap D and the intersections K_{j}\cap D project to closed curves \tilde{R}_{j} and compact sets \tilde{K}_{j} in T . The connected component of T\smallsetminus\bigcup_{j=1}^{Nr}\tilde{K}_{j} containing \tilde{R}_{j} is a conformal cylinder C_{j} of modulus \operatorname{mod}(C_{j})=\pi/(q\log d) having \tilde{R}_{j} as its core geodesic. All the C_{j} (hence the \tilde{R}_{j} ) are in the same non-trivial isotopy class in T . [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] quotient by [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] Figure 14. Oblique rays landing at a repelling point and various cylinders in the quotient torus. For the purpose of interpolation, it is often useful to replace the C_{j} by smaller cylinders with smooth (in fact, real analytic) boundary curves as follows. Suppose 0\leq\theta_{j}<1 is the angle of R_{j} , which is an integer multiple of 1/(d^{q}-1) . Let \phi:\mathbb{C}\smallsetminus K\to\mathbb{C}\smallsetminus\overline{\mathbb{D}} be the Böttcher coordinate of f . The map \log\phi:\mathbb{C}\smallsetminus\overline{\mathbb{D}}\to\mathbb{H}^{+}=\{z:\operatorname{Re}(z)>0\} lifts R_{j} to the horizontal ray \eta_{j}(t)=t+2\pi\mathrm{i}\,\theta_{j} for t>0 . The rays \eta_{j}^{\pm}(t)=t+2\pi\mathrm{i}\,(\theta_{j}\pm\varsigma t) map back to the arcs R_{j}^{\pm}=(\phi^{-1}\circ\exp)(\eta_{j}^{\pm}) which we call the oblique rays of slope \pm\varsigma at angle \theta_{j} (see Fig. 14 ). Evidently R_{j}^{\pm} land at z_{0} and R_{j}^{\pm}=f^{\circ q}(R_{j}^{\pm}) . Moreover, the 2Nr tails R_{j}^{\pm}\cap D for 1\leq j\leq Nr are pairwise disjoint. In fact, R_{j}^{\pm}\cap D_{n} are pairwise disjoint for all large n>0 , where D_{n} is the connected component of f^{-nq}(D) containing z_{0} , and f^{\circ nq}:D_{n}\to D is a biholomorphism. The sector in D delimited by R_{j}^{\pm} projects to a cylinder H_{j}\subset C_{j} having \tilde{R}_{j} as its core geodesic. It is easy to see that \operatorname{mod}(H_{j}) tends to 0 as \varsigma\to 0 and it tends to \operatorname{mod}(C_{j})=\pi/(q\log d) as \varsigma\to+\infty . We are also interested in the complementary sectors in D that meet K . Following [ EY ] we consider the invariant \operatorname{mod}_{z_{0}}(K_{j})=\inf\{\operatorname{mod}(C):C\supset\tilde{K}_{j}\}=\sup\{\operatorname{mod}(C):C\subset\tilde{K}_{j}\} where the cylinders C\subset T are taken in the same isotopy class as C_{j} . This invariant is not affected by quasiconformal deformations that keep the conformal structure on K_{j} unchanged. Moreover, \operatorname{mod}_{z_{0}}(K_{j})>0 if and only if z_{0} is on the boundary of a Fatou component of f in K_{j} . The sector in D delimited by R^{+}_{j} and R^{-}_{j+1} projects to a cylinder G_{j}\subset T which contains \tilde{K}_{j} . As \varsigma\to\infty , \operatorname{mod}(G_{j})\to\operatorname{mod}_{z_{0}}(K_{j}) . As \varsigma\to 0 , \operatorname{mod}(G_{j}) tends to the modulus of the cylinder bounded by \tilde{R}_{j} and \tilde{R}_{j+1} , which is at least \frac{\pi}{2q\log d}+\operatorname{mod}_{z_{0}}(K_{j})+\frac{\pi}{2q\log d}=\operatorname{mod}_{z_{0}}(K_{j})+\frac{\pi}{q\log d} by the Grötszch inequality. We note that all the above constructions can be carried out for polynomial-like maps hybrid equivalent to f , or more generally for local holomorphic maps obtained from f by a conjugation near z_{0} . Let us now discuss quasiconformal interpolation on sectors whose idea goes back to the thesis of B. Bielefeld [ B ] . Consider f as above and let \Sigma be a sector in D delimited by two smooth arcs \gamma_{\pm} landing at z_{0} . Thus, \partial\Sigma consists of \gamma_{\pm} and a third arc \gamma_{0}\subset\partial D . We assume \Sigma is invariant in the sense f^{\circ q}(\Sigma)\cap D=\Sigma . Denote by \zeta:(D,z_{0})\to(\mathbb{D},0) the (unique up to a rotation) linearizing map that conjugates f^{\circ q} to z\mapsto\lambda z . There is a univalent branch of z\mapsto\log\zeta(z)/\log\lambda that maps \Sigma to a half-strip S and conjugates f^{\circ q} to the unit translation z\mapsto z+1 . We call S the half-strip model of \Sigma . Note that \partial S consists of two “horizontal” arcs \Gamma_{\pm} that are invariant under z\mapsto z-1 , joined by a “vertical” arc \Gamma_{0} (see Fig. 15 ). [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] [formula] Figure 15. An invariant sector \Sigma and its half-strip model S . Now suppose we have another holomorphic map \hat{f} with a repelling fixed point \hat{z}_{0} and invariant sector \hat{\Sigma}\subset\hat{D} with boundary arcs \hat{\gamma}_{\pm},\hat{\gamma}_{0} and the corresponding half-strip model \hat{S} with boundary arcs \hat{\Gamma}_{\pm},\hat{\Gamma}_{0} . Consider a homeomorphism h:\partial\Sigma\to\partial\hat{\Sigma} , which maps each boundary arc of \Sigma to the corresponding boundary arc of \hat{\Sigma} . We say that the restrictions h:\gamma_{\pm}\to\hat{\gamma}_{\pm} are near-linear if they are smooth and the induced maps H:\Gamma_{\pm}\to\hat{\Gamma}_{\pm} have uniform C^{1} distance from a translation, i.e., there is a constant M>1 such that |H(z(t))-z(t)|0 and C(m) be any cylinder of modulus m . Take a quasiconformal homeomorphism \psi:C_{\Lambda}\to C(m) . Let \mu be the conformal structure on \Delta\cap\Lambda obtained by pulling back the standard conformal structure of C(m) under \psi and then lifting under g . Extend \mu to the union of the iterated f -preimages of \Delta\cap\Lambda and define it to be the standard conformal structure in the rest of the plane. Evidently \mu has bounded dilatation, so there is a quasiconformal homeomorphism \phi:\mathbb{C}\to\mathbb{C} which integrates \mu and is normalized by the conditions \phi(0)=0,\phi(\infty)=\infty and (\phi\circ f\circ\phi^{-1})(z)=\text{const.}+z^{2}+O(z^{3}) near the origin. The map f can now be replaced with \phi\circ f\circ\phi^{-1} which still has the central and peripheral renormalizations hybrid equivalent to Q_{c} and Q_{\nu} , but for which the corresponding cylinder \phi(\Delta\cap\Lambda)/(\phi\circ g\circ\phi^{-1}) has modulus equal to m . Thus, without loss of generality, we may assume that the cylinder C_{\Lambda} (and therefore C^{\prime} ) for our map f has arbitrarily large modulus. 9.4. A quasiregular extension of f The external rays of f landing on the orbit \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} are related to the external rays of Q_{c} landing on the orbit \{w_{i}:=\Phi^{-1}(z_{i})\} . Since f has a central renormalization hybrid equivalent to Q_{c} , the discussion of § 6.1 shows that there are three possibilities according as the portrait of \{w_{1},\ldots,w_{q}\} is trivial, primitive or satellite: (i) \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} has period q and each z_{i} has exactly two rays R_{f}(x_{i}),R_{f}(y_{i}) landing on it; (ii) \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} has period q and each z_{i} has exactly three rays R_{f}(x_{i}),R_{f}(y_{i}),R_{f}(u_{i}) with disjoint orbits landing on it; (iii) \{z_{1},\ldots,z_{q}\} has a smaller period p=q/r and every z_{i} has exactly 2r rays landing on it, r rays in the orbit of R_{f}(x_{i}) and r rays in the orbit of R_{f}(y_{i}) . Whatever the case, the number n of the external rays landing at each z_{i} satisfies 2\leq n\leq 2q . Denote by R_{1},\ldots,R_{n} the rays landing at z_{j}=f(z_{k}) , where the labeling is counterclockwise starting with R_{1}=R_{f}(y_{j}) and ending with R_{n}=R_{f}(x_{j}) . Let K_{i} be the intersection of K_{f} with the sector bounded by the closures of the rays R_{i} and R_{i+1} , taking the index i modulo n . Evidently K_{n}\subset W_{j} . Set m_{i}:=\operatorname{mod}_{z_{j}}(K_{i})\qquad(1\leq i\leq n) as defined in § 9.1 and note that the m_{i} are unaffected by the change of the conformal structure on \Lambda described at the end of the previous section. We shall thus suppose (9.1) m=\operatorname{mod}(C_{\Lambda})\geq\sum_{i=1}^{n-1}m_{i}+(n-1)\ \frac{\pi}{q\log 3}. For each 1\leq i\leq n-1 replace the rays R_{i},R_{i+1} surrounding K_{i} by the oblique rays \Gamma_{2i}:=R^{+}_{i},\Gamma_{2i+1}:=R^{-}_{i+1} of slopes \varsigma_{i},-\varsigma_{i} . Setting \Gamma_{1}:=R_{1},\Gamma_{2n}:=R_{n} , we obtain 2n rays \Gamma_{1},\ldots,\Gamma_{2n} arranged counterclockwise around z_{j} which we may assume do not intersect each other in D . The quotient under f^{\circ q} of the sector in D delimited by \Gamma_{2i},\Gamma_{2i+1} is a sub-cylinder C_{2i} of C=(D\smallsetminus\overline{W_{j}})/f^{\circ q} . By the discussion in § 9.1 , \operatorname{mod}(C_{2i}) tends to m_{i} as \varsigma_{i}\to\infty and it tends to a limit \geq m_{i}+\pi/(q\log 3) as \varsigma_{i}\to 0 . Thus, we can choose \varsigma_{i}>0 such that (9.2) \operatorname{mod}(C_{2i})=m_{i}+\frac{\pi}{2q\log 3}\qquad(1\leq i\leq n-1). For 1\leq i\leq n the quotient under f^{\circ q} of the sector in D delimited by \Gamma_{2i-1},\Gamma_{2i} is a sub-cylinder of C that we denote by C_{2i-1} . Choose a sufficiently small Green’s potential s>0 such that the rays \Gamma_{1},\ldots,\Gamma_{2n} are disjoint up to level s . Let U and U^{\prime} be the topological disks bounded by the equipotentials of f at levels s/3 and s , respectively. We replace each ray \Gamma_{i} with the arc \Gamma_{i}\cap\overline{U^{\prime}} and for simplicity continue to denote the trimmed ray by \Gamma_{i} . For 1\leq i\leq 2n-1 we denote by \Sigma_{i} the sector in U^{\prime} with the vertex at z_{j} that is delimited by \Gamma_{i} and \Gamma_{i+1} . Thus, (\Sigma_{i}\cap D)/f^{\circ q}=C_{i} . Observe that \Sigma_{2i}\cap K_{f}=K_{i} while \Sigma_{2i-1}\cap K_{f}=\emptyset . Let us now carry out a similar construction near z^{\prime}_{k} for the cylinder C^{\prime}=(\Delta\cap W^{\prime}_{k})/g bounded by the Jordan curves \gamma_{1}:=R_{f}(y^{\prime}_{k})/g and \gamma_{2n}:=R_{f}(x^{\prime}_{k})/g . Supplement these curves with 2n-2 additional disjoint smooth Jordan curves \gamma_{2},\ldots\gamma_{2n-1} in C^{\prime} , all in the same isotopy class as \gamma_{1},\gamma_{2n} and labeled consecutively so as to obtain pairwise disjoint cylinders C^{\prime}_{i}\subset C^{\prime} bounded by \gamma_{i} and \gamma_{i+1} for 1\leq i\leq 2n-1 . By the choice ( 9.1 ) we can choose the \gamma_{i} such that (9.3) \operatorname{mod}(C^{\prime}_{2i})=m_{i}+\frac{\pi}{2q\log 3}\qquad(1\leq i\leq n-1)\\ We can lift and extend \gamma_{1},\ldots,\gamma_{2n} to global arcs \Gamma^{\prime}_{1},\ldots,\Gamma^{\prime}_{2n} in \overline{W_{k}} as follows. Set \Gamma^{\prime}_{1}:=R_{f}(y^{\prime}_{k})\cap\overline{U},\Gamma^{\prime}_{2n}:=R_{f}(x^{\prime}_{k})\cap\overline{U} , and for 2\leq i\leq 2n-1 choose a smooth embedded arc \Gamma^{\prime}_{i} connecting z^{\prime}_{k} within W^{\prime}_{k} to \partial U such that (\Gamma^{\prime}_{i}\cap\Delta)/g=\gamma_{i} . We may assume that \Gamma^{\prime}_{1},\ldots,\Gamma^{\prime}_{2n} are pairwise disjoint except that their common extremity at z^{\prime}_{k} . For 1\leq i\leq 2n-1 denote by \Sigma^{\prime}_{i} the sector in U with the vertex at z^{\prime}_{k} that is delimited by \Gamma^{\prime}_{i} and \Gamma^{\prime}_{i+1} , so (\Sigma^{\prime}_{i}\cap\Delta)/g=C^{\prime}_{i} . Let \zeta_{2i}:\Sigma^{\prime}_{2i}\to\Sigma_{2i} be the conformal isomorphism which maps z^{\prime}_{k} to z_{j} , \Gamma^{\prime}_{2i}\cap\partial U to \Gamma_{2i}\cap\partial U^{\prime} and \Gamma^{\prime}_{2i+1}\cap\partial U to \Gamma_{2i+1}\cap\partial U^{\prime} . By ( 9.2 ) and ( 9.3 ), \operatorname{mod}((\Sigma^{\prime}_{2i}\cap\Delta)/g)=\operatorname{mod}(C^{\prime}_{2i})=\operatorname{mod}(C_{2i})=\operatorname{mod}((\Sigma_{2i}\cap D)/f^{\circ q}). It follows from Lemma 9.2 that the boundary maps \zeta_{2i}:\Gamma^{\prime}_{2i}\to\Gamma_{2i} and \zeta_{2i}:\Gamma^{\prime}_{2i+1}\to\Gamma_{2i+1} are near-linear for 1\leq i\leq n-1 . Moreover, the restrictions f:\Gamma^{\prime}_{1}\to\Gamma_{1} and f:\Gamma^{\prime}_{2n}\to\Gamma_{2n} are also near-linear since they conjugate g to f^{\circ q} . Lemma 9.3 now shows that these boundary maps yield quasiconformal extensions \zeta_{2i-1}:\Sigma^{\prime}_{2i-1}\to\Sigma_{2i-1} on the complementary sectors. We may thus define a proper quasiregular map F:U\to U^{\prime} of degree 3 by F(z):=\begin{cases}f(z)&\qquad z\in U\smallsetminus W^{\prime}_{k}\\ \zeta_{i}(z)&\qquad z\in\Sigma^{\prime}_{i}\quad(1\leq i\leq 2n-1).\end{cases} 9.5. Completion of the proof of Theorem 9.1 The set where \bar{\partial}F\neq 0 is contained in the union {E^{\prime}}_{\!\!{\textrm{odd}}}:=\bigcup_{i=1}^{n}\overline{\Sigma^{\prime}_{2i-1}}\subset\overline{U\cap W^{\prime}_{k}} . Each forward orbit of F can meet {E^{\prime}}_{\!\!{\textrm{odd}}} at most once because F({E^{\prime}}_{\!\!{\textrm{odd}}})=E_{\textrm{odd}}:=\bigcup_{i=1}^{n}\overline{\Sigma_{2i-1}} , where E_{\textrm{odd}}\cap{E^{\prime}}_{\!\!{\textrm{odd}}}=\emptyset and all further iterates of E_{\textrm{odd}} under F are disjoint from W_{k} and contained in the escaping set \mathbb{C}\smallsetminus K_{f} . Define a conformal structure \mu on U^{\prime} by taking the standard conformal structure on E_{\textrm{odd}} and extending it to the union \bigcup_{i\geq 0}F^{-i}(E_{\textrm{odd}}) by iterated pull-backs. On the rest of U^{\prime} let \mu be the standard conformal structure. Notice that \mu is well-defined since the branches of F^{-q}=f^{-q} that map E_{\textrm{odd}} to itself are conformal. Moreover, the iterated branches F^{-i} can contain at most one non-conformal branch of F^{-1} by the above observation. Thus, \mu is F -invariant and has bounded dilatation. Let \Psi:U^{\prime}\to\mathbb{D} be a quasiconformal homeomorphism that integrates \mu with say \Psi(0)=0 . Then G:=\Psi\circ F\circ\Psi^{-1}:\Psi(U)\to\mathbb{D} is a polynomial-like map of degree 3 . Moreover, by the construction of F=f in U\smallsetminus W^{\prime}_{k} , the map G has a quadratic-like restriction around the critical point (\Psi\circ\Phi)(\omega_{1})=0 which is hybrid equivalent to Q_{c} and G^{\circ q} has a quadratic-like restriction around the critical point (\Psi\circ\Phi)(\omega_{2}) which is hybrid equivalent to Q_{\nu} . A suitably normalized straightening of G will then be the desired cubic P\in\mathcal{L}_{\operatorname{ren}}(t) with \bm{\chi}(P)=(c,\nu) . \Box Appendix. On the intersection of lemon limbs Although distinct lemon limbs are disjoint, there could be plenty of non-trivial intersections between a limb \mathcal{L}(t) and a rotated limb \mathcal{L}^{\ast}(s) . This appendix provides some relevant results and examples; they will be mostly independent from the rest of this paper. Throughout the following discussion we assume t,s are periodic angles under \mathbf{m}_{2} with periods q,p\geq 2 and combinatorics \sigma\in S_{q},\tau\in S_{p} , respectively. As usual, let \{x_{1},\ldots,x_{q}\} and \{y_{1},\ldots,y_{q}\} be the simulating orbits for t=t_{k} with simulating angles x_{k},y_{k} . Similarly, let \{u_{1},\ldots,u_{p}\} and \{v_{1},\ldots,v_{p}\} be the simulating orbits for s=s_{\ell} with simulating angles u_{\ell},v_{\ell} . Set I_{i}:=[x_{i},y_{i}] for 1\leq i\leq q and J_{j}:=[u_{j},v_{j}] for 1\leq j\leq p . Recall from § 3.2 that I_{\sigma(k)} and J_{\tau(\ell)} are the shortest intervals in their respective collections with |I_{\sigma(k)}|=1/(3^{q}-1) and |J_{\tau(\ell)}|=1/(3^{p}-1) . Similarly, I_{k} and J_{\ell} are the longest intervals in their respective collections with |I_{k}|=3^{q-1}/(3^{q}-1) and |J_{\ell}|=3^{p-1}/(3^{p}-1) . Theorem . \mathcal{L}(t)\cap\mathcal{L}(s)=\emptyset whenever t\neq s . Proof. Assume by way of contradiction that there is a cubic P\in\mathcal{L}(t)\cap\mathcal{L}(s) and t\neq s . For 1\leq i\leq q let z_{i} denote the co-landing point of the rays R(x_{i}),R(y_{i}) and for 1\leq j\leq p let w_{j} denote the co-landing point of R(u_{j}),R(v_{j}) . Setting y^{\prime}_{k}:=y_{k}-1/3<1/21/3>|[y^{\prime}_{k},x^{\prime}_{k}]| then shows that (9.4) u_{\ell}|J_{\ell}| . By ( 9.4 ), x_{k}\leq u_{\ell}